chosen
stringlengths
62
12.6k
rejected
stringlengths
61
12.6k
Human: ChemE graduate taking a manufacturing engineering position traditionally filled by MechE's... What can I do to prepare myself? I'll be starting a job in a month as a manufacturing engineer at a polymer film plant. As part of an overhaul in the polymer process, management recently decided to start filling the position with chemical engineers instead of the traditional mechanical engineers. I'll have most of the same job responsibilities as the mechanical guys. In an attempt to "catch up" on some of the things I missed out on in my ChemE education, I plan to watch an MIT opencourseware class on lean manufacturing / six-sigma to prepare for that aspect of the industry. I also hope to find an online "Intro to Statistics" class that I could watch since I wasn't able to take a statistics course while in school. I also plan to brush up on my excel/VBA skills. These things I'm pretty sure will benefit me based on the job description. Are there any other things I should try to learn/ study / brush up on to prepare for the role? Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance! Assistant: I'm all for learning stuff to broaden your horizons, but you should really talk to your future direct supervisor and tell him/her what you are thinking about studying, and whether it will be of any use. Otherwise you will likely be covering some ground that will not really be of much use.
Human: ChemE graduate taking a manufacturing engineering position traditionally filled by MechE's... What can I do to prepare myself? I'll be starting a job in a month as a manufacturing engineer at a polymer film plant. As part of an overhaul in the polymer process, management recently decided to start filling the position with chemical engineers instead of the traditional mechanical engineers. I'll have most of the same job responsibilities as the mechanical guys. In an attempt to "catch up" on some of the things I missed out on in my ChemE education, I plan to watch an MIT opencourseware class on lean manufacturing / six-sigma to prepare for that aspect of the industry. I also hope to find an online "Intro to Statistics" class that I could watch since I wasn't able to take a statistics course while in school. I also plan to brush up on my excel/VBA skills. These things I'm pretty sure will benefit me based on the job description. Are there any other things I should try to learn/ study / brush up on to prepare for the role? Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance! Assistant: The two most important undergraduate courses you missed are statics and strength of materials. They are both sophomore level classes, do you shouldn't have a hard time teaching yourself. You may be able to move right along without those classes, but I think that would be a bad idea. Remember, an engineer can do for a dollar what any damn fool can do for two. Just because you're OK without those courses doesn't mean you're really doing a good job.
Human: I understand the mathematical explanation but what is the physical explanation behind an isenthalpic temperature rise across a pressure differential (i.e. high pressure hydraulic oil passing through an orifice)? We're having some issues with hydraulics at my company and while I'm not directly involved, it got me reading into some material online. From my research, it seems like situations where hydraulic oil travels across a pressure differential (orifice, relief valve, leak, etc.) without doing any work, there is a temperature rise. My understanding is this is an isenthalpic process and since the volume of the oil is not changing but its pressure is, this change is "made up for" by an increase in temperature. The Joule-Thompson effect in regards to expanding gases makes sense to me. That physical explanation makes sense. Its when the working fluid is a liquid is what I find confusing. Compress a gas, molecules get closer, start smashing into each other more, and you get a temperature increase. Reverse it for an expanding gas. But what about an in-compressible liquid? What is the physical mechanism behind this temperature change? Assistant: I think this correct but you never know with thermo: Your fluid has energy stored in the form of pressure. When you go through an orifice the pressure is lost. Since energy is conserved, where is that energy going to go? In a gas it can go into expansion and velocity. In a fluid it generally results in a temperature rise since it won't expand.
Human: I understand the mathematical explanation but what is the physical explanation behind an isenthalpic temperature rise across a pressure differential (i.e. high pressure hydraulic oil passing through an orifice)? We're having some issues with hydraulics at my company and while I'm not directly involved, it got me reading into some material online. From my research, it seems like situations where hydraulic oil travels across a pressure differential (orifice, relief valve, leak, etc.) without doing any work, there is a temperature rise. My understanding is this is an isenthalpic process and since the volume of the oil is not changing but its pressure is, this change is "made up for" by an increase in temperature. The Joule-Thompson effect in regards to expanding gases makes sense to me. That physical explanation makes sense. Its when the working fluid is a liquid is what I find confusing. Compress a gas, molecules get closer, start smashing into each other more, and you get a temperature increase. Reverse it for an expanding gas. But what about an in-compressible liquid? What is the physical mechanism behind this temperature change? Assistant: the contact between molecules will increase when it's happening. The better way to understand is comparing to polymer extrusion (you can call hydraulic oil as low weigth polymers). When you start the machine you will need to heat to process the material, after some time you can turn off the resistance and let shear do the job.
Human: Do you charge people you know, when they ask you to do anything engineering related? Basically the title. I’ve gotten really tired of taking my time designing boring CAD models every time a family member or old acquaintance wants something 3D printed. Or when they have some failure of a business idea. Literally had an old acquaintance today, send me a picture of a part and he just expected it to magically get 3D printed by sending a picture to the printer. I told him that my hourly rate for design work is $150. It scared him off, so I’m thinking of doing this from now on. Anyone else do this? Assistant: If you want an answer, my hourly rate for consulting is $150/hr. Two hour minimum.
Human: Do you charge people you know, when they ask you to do anything engineering related? Basically the title. I’ve gotten really tired of taking my time designing boring CAD models every time a family member or old acquaintance wants something 3D printed. Or when they have some failure of a business idea. Literally had an old acquaintance today, send me a picture of a part and he just expected it to magically get 3D printed by sending a picture to the printer. I told him that my hourly rate for design work is $150. It scared him off, so I’m thinking of doing this from now on. Anyone else do this? Assistant: If it's relatively simple, I like the person, and am not particularly busy, then I probably wouldn't charge beyond the cost of materials if that. If I'm legitimately interested in it and they're paying for materials, then I'd be more inclined to do something for free. At which point it becomes them effectively paying for a hobby project that they keep. I don't have people asking me to make random stuff though, so the point is kinda moot for me.
Human: How do you think the classified self-guided bullet EXACTO technology work ? www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX8Z2MDYX3g It's basically a .50 cal bullet that can adjust its trajectory 30 times per second to land on a laser-painted target I was wondering issues like a bullet which is spinning (I guess missiles are not ? or is this bullet not spinning, but how do you prevent it from spinning ?) would make it difficult to work with. Maybe some small, gyroscope-thing inside the bullet which adjust its internal balance as it spins ? I doubt the use of fins would be very practical for a bullet. I'm just wondering about the mechanical aspect of it, since it's so small, I can understand how sensors can be attracted to an lazed target. I am not asking for any classified information or specifically encouraging darpa engineers to talk about classified stuff,I'm just asking the opinion of other engineers :) Assistant: Here you go.
Human: How do you think the classified self-guided bullet EXACTO technology work ? www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX8Z2MDYX3g It's basically a .50 cal bullet that can adjust its trajectory 30 times per second to land on a laser-painted target I was wondering issues like a bullet which is spinning (I guess missiles are not ? or is this bullet not spinning, but how do you prevent it from spinning ?) would make it difficult to work with. Maybe some small, gyroscope-thing inside the bullet which adjust its internal balance as it spins ? I doubt the use of fins would be very practical for a bullet. I'm just wondering about the mechanical aspect of it, since it's so small, I can understand how sensors can be attracted to an lazed target. I am not asking for any classified information or specifically encouraging darpa engineers to talk about classified stuff,I'm just asking the opinion of other engineers :) Assistant: If you have fins, you don't need to spin to stabilize the projectile. We've had guided artillery shells fired from rifled guns for a long time. They use, IIRC, a band that can spin around the projectile when it's fired to minimize the spinning when it exits the bore, and the fins engage to cancel out the rest. Getting it down to .50 is essentially an exercise in miniaturization.
Human: Working at Intel soon...stuff to familiarize myself with the way chips are made? Just looking for some videos, books, etc that are helpful to get up to speed quickly @ Intel. Also, if any of you work there, what do you think? Things to do? Cool benefits to take advantage of? Thanks! Assistant: Also in what regard are you working for them? Working on the production floor requires a different skill set than those designing chips, and what specific part are you working on?
Human: Working at Intel soon...stuff to familiarize myself with the way chips are made? Just looking for some videos, books, etc that are helpful to get up to speed quickly @ Intel. Also, if any of you work there, what do you think? Things to do? Cool benefits to take advantage of? Thanks! Assistant: Real basic high level info here: http://newsroom.intel.com/docs/DOC-2476 A couple videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5paWn7bFg4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PecKlm6VutU What's your position? Depending if you're in the fab, tech development, design, validation, reliability, etc. it will impact what you need to know. Intel is a huge company. I bet you'll have a truck load of training once you start.
Human: What is the word for when a 3D surface can be made from 2D materials using just cutting and bending? A naval architect one told me the word that represents this concept, but I can never remember it. My brain wants to say "realizable", but google doesn't turn on up anything on that. I think it came up when we were talking about cold-molded plywood boats. Assistant: Developable is the word you're looking for. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Developable\_surface
Human: What is the word for when a 3D surface can be made from 2D materials using just cutting and bending? A naval architect one told me the word that represents this concept, but I can never remember it. My brain wants to say "realizable", but google doesn't turn on up anything on that. I think it came up when we were talking about cold-molded plywood boats. Assistant: Origami?
Human: Is it possible to make a vacuum pump out of a window air conditioner unit? I want to make a vacuum ping pong ball cannon, but can't get a vacuum pump. Could an AC compressor be repurposed to do it? Assistant: Buy a cheap vacuum pump from aliexpress. <$20
Human: Is it possible to make a vacuum pump out of a window air conditioner unit? I want to make a vacuum ping pong ball cannon, but can't get a vacuum pump. Could an AC compressor be repurposed to do it? Assistant: Why can't you get a vacuum pump?
Human: How did you get your start? How did you guys figure out what specific job you wanted to do. What has brought you to this current point in life? Assistant: I picked engineering because it paid well and has a high employment rate. I picked EE because I did well in the circuit section of my physics class. I picked controls engineering because I enjoyed the work.
Human: How did you get your start? How did you guys figure out what specific job you wanted to do. What has brought you to this current point in life? Assistant: Chemistry, Coffee.
Human: What fuel do military rockets mainly use? solid or liquid? Assistant: “Ignition!” Is a great book that talks in depth about the development of lots of these rocket fuels. Surprisingly easy to read given the chemistry discussed. Highly recommended.
Human: What fuel do military rockets mainly use? solid or liquid? Assistant: Depend on the application. Tomahawk? Liquid fuel, ICBM ? Solid Edit.... appearantly tomahawk also use solid
Human: I have a meeting with the CEO next month. What should I ask him? I’m a recent hire part of a rotational program focused on operations. I got an invite last week to a 30 minute call with the CEO. I want to make a good impression of course so I thought I’d ask you smart creative bunch. Any good questions or talking points I could use to stand out? Thanks for any support or advice! Assistant: Instead of trying to impress the CEO with your questions I’d just be myself and ask questions that I’m curious about. If the CEO deems any of your questions as ‘stupid’ then it’s not a company I’d want to work for.
Human: I have a meeting with the CEO next month. What should I ask him? I’m a recent hire part of a rotational program focused on operations. I got an invite last week to a 30 minute call with the CEO. I want to make a good impression of course so I thought I’d ask you smart creative bunch. Any good questions or talking points I could use to stand out? Thanks for any support or advice! Assistant: Ask him if 2020/COVID has changed his mindset on how your company will conduct business in the future, for both operational and non-operational roles.
Human: What is more dangerous and how? Voltage or current? I often hear people say "current above 1A is deadly" or "high voltage is dangerous". Or are they both equally important (power)? If so, what are the ranges where it is safe? And can you tell me why each of these are dangerous (what will high current or voltage do exactly/separately). Fe high voltage pushes the current quicker to other stuff like a person. Assistant: I=V/R. The human body resistance is relatively constant. Therefore, the current and voltage will be proportional to each other. The higher the voltage, the higher the current. The only caveat is the source of the voltage. If the energy stored is really low, then, during discharge, the voltage and current will rapidly drop off.
Human: What is more dangerous and how? Voltage or current? I often hear people say "current above 1A is deadly" or "high voltage is dangerous". Or are they both equally important (power)? If so, what are the ranges where it is safe? And can you tell me why each of these are dangerous (what will high current or voltage do exactly/separately). Fe high voltage pushes the current quicker to other stuff like a person. Assistant: I used to work with high frequency, high voltage corona. Very low current at 80,000 volts. I could put my finger in the visible streamers with no issue.
Human: I'm a young petroleum engineering student and I want to know which language (other than English) would you recommend for me to learn? I am a petroleum engineering student in Croatia and I want to learn another language that can help me get better job after graduation other than English. I'm considering Norwegian and Russian language. Can you give me some good advices or tips? Assistant: arabic and chineese if you wanna understand your teachers
Human: I'm a young petroleum engineering student and I want to know which language (other than English) would you recommend for me to learn? I am a petroleum engineering student in Croatia and I want to learn another language that can help me get better job after graduation other than English. I'm considering Norwegian and Russian language. Can you give me some good advices or tips? Assistant: Arabic/Russian/Chinese would be helpful if you wanted to work there or worked on Projects with companies from those places. Portuguese/Spanish would be helpful in South America but I wouldn't put those as top priority.
Human: What non-engineering books should engineers and engineering students read? I've just started getting active within this sub, but have seen questions about what to do with spare time, how to better network, how to do better on interviews, etc. A few common themes have emerged, such as developing your social skills, or taking an interest in America's great equalizer... professional sports. I responded to a question by /u/sweat-e-sac with the suggestion of reading different books to round out your knowledge base. I've compiled a list of books I've read and organized them by subject matter. I find that even when I don't wish to participate in a conversation with someone else, having knowledge of the discussion topic gives me an incredible leg up. What are your suggestions for non-technical/non-engineering books that should be read? Oh and before I forget, definitely try to learn a second language if you don't have fluency in one yet, it is a great talking point in your interviews. **World Affairs** *Overview* * World Order by Henry Kissinger *US Foreign Policy* * Rise to Globalism: American Foreign Policy Since 1938 by Stephen E. Ambrose *Middle East* * From Beirut to Jerusalem by Thomas L. Friedman * Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and bin Laden from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001 by Steve Coll * The Wall and the Gate: Israel, Palestine, and the Legal Battle for Human Rights by Michael Sfard *China* * On China by Henry Kissinger * China Goes Global: The Partial Power by David Shambaugh *Economics* * Capital in the Twenty-First Century Paperback by Thomas Piketty * Economic Policy Beyond the Headlines by George P. Shultz, Kenneth W. Dam **United States Domestic Issues** *Civil Rights* * Why We Can't Wait by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. * The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander *Poverty* * Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond * Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis by J. D. Vance *General Politics and Policy* * Free Speech Beyond Words: The Surprising Reach of the First Amendment by Mark V. Tushnet,‎ Alan K. Chen,‎ Joseph Blocher * Decision Points by George W. Bush * The Federalist Papers **Sports** * Eleven Rings: The Soul of Success by Phil Jackson **Science/Medicine** * The Gene: An Intimate History by Siddhartha Mukherjee * The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer by Siddhartha Mukherjee * Permanent Present Tense: The Unforgettable Life of the Amnesic Patient, H. M. by Suzanne Corkin * Bellevue: Three Centuries of Medicine and Mayhem at America's Most Storied Hospital by David Oshinsky **Religion/Spirituality** * Love Does by Bob Goff * Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Album * Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis **Business** * Let My People Go Surfing: The Education of a Reluctant Businessman by Yvon Chouinard * Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike Hardcover by Phil Knight Assistant: Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, Philip K Dick Red Mars, Kim Stanley Robinson. Besides Martian colonization potentially happening in our lifetime, it deals with many ethical side effects of engineering and settling. The Gods Themselves, Isaac Asimov Borges, On Exactitude in Science (preferably find a collection like Ficciones and read a few. Most are pretty short). Library of Babyk is good too
Human: What non-engineering books should engineers and engineering students read? I've just started getting active within this sub, but have seen questions about what to do with spare time, how to better network, how to do better on interviews, etc. A few common themes have emerged, such as developing your social skills, or taking an interest in America's great equalizer... professional sports. I responded to a question by /u/sweat-e-sac with the suggestion of reading different books to round out your knowledge base. I've compiled a list of books I've read and organized them by subject matter. I find that even when I don't wish to participate in a conversation with someone else, having knowledge of the discussion topic gives me an incredible leg up. What are your suggestions for non-technical/non-engineering books that should be read? Oh and before I forget, definitely try to learn a second language if you don't have fluency in one yet, it is a great talking point in your interviews. **World Affairs** *Overview* * World Order by Henry Kissinger *US Foreign Policy* * Rise to Globalism: American Foreign Policy Since 1938 by Stephen E. Ambrose *Middle East* * From Beirut to Jerusalem by Thomas L. Friedman * Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and bin Laden from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001 by Steve Coll * The Wall and the Gate: Israel, Palestine, and the Legal Battle for Human Rights by Michael Sfard *China* * On China by Henry Kissinger * China Goes Global: The Partial Power by David Shambaugh *Economics* * Capital in the Twenty-First Century Paperback by Thomas Piketty * Economic Policy Beyond the Headlines by George P. Shultz, Kenneth W. Dam **United States Domestic Issues** *Civil Rights* * Why We Can't Wait by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. * The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander *Poverty* * Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond * Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis by J. D. Vance *General Politics and Policy* * Free Speech Beyond Words: The Surprising Reach of the First Amendment by Mark V. Tushnet,‎ Alan K. Chen,‎ Joseph Blocher * Decision Points by George W. Bush * The Federalist Papers **Sports** * Eleven Rings: The Soul of Success by Phil Jackson **Science/Medicine** * The Gene: An Intimate History by Siddhartha Mukherjee * The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer by Siddhartha Mukherjee * Permanent Present Tense: The Unforgettable Life of the Amnesic Patient, H. M. by Suzanne Corkin * Bellevue: Three Centuries of Medicine and Mayhem at America's Most Storied Hospital by David Oshinsky **Religion/Spirituality** * Love Does by Bob Goff * Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Album * Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis **Business** * Let My People Go Surfing: The Education of a Reluctant Businessman by Yvon Chouinard * Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike Hardcover by Phil Knight Assistant: I guess everyone should have a copy of *Machinerys Handbook* on their desk
Human: Do any other recent graduates want to do something that isn't engineering? I graduated in the spring and just got an offer from a big aerospace engine mfg company. I'm going to accept to see how I like it since it's going to be a very new experience, but part of me is worried I won't like it. Towards the end of college I really began to find myself. I started playing drums, learning about politics a LOT, learning more about myself and psychology, and I love all of it. All I ever think about are these things and I never think about engineering because its boring. Hopefully my new job will prove me wrong, but a big part of me thinks about how I want a career that helps people or is constantly active and interesting. I think about how motivating it would be to be a therapist, or to do some kind of physical work that helps people like a trade where you can always be active, or honestly I would love to sit at home and cook, clean, read, play video games, etc. Thinking about sitting behind a desk all day seems extremely demotivating, but it's not like I can go just become a therapist or politician, I would need to get an entirely new degree! Does anyone else have these thoughts constantly in their head like me? Assistant: >honestly I would love to sit at home and cook, clean, read, play video games Yeah so would everybody. Get a job that pays enough money for you to do all this on evenings/weekends without having to worry about paying your bills.
Human: Do any other recent graduates want to do something that isn't engineering? I graduated in the spring and just got an offer from a big aerospace engine mfg company. I'm going to accept to see how I like it since it's going to be a very new experience, but part of me is worried I won't like it. Towards the end of college I really began to find myself. I started playing drums, learning about politics a LOT, learning more about myself and psychology, and I love all of it. All I ever think about are these things and I never think about engineering because its boring. Hopefully my new job will prove me wrong, but a big part of me thinks about how I want a career that helps people or is constantly active and interesting. I think about how motivating it would be to be a therapist, or to do some kind of physical work that helps people like a trade where you can always be active, or honestly I would love to sit at home and cook, clean, read, play video games, etc. Thinking about sitting behind a desk all day seems extremely demotivating, but it's not like I can go just become a therapist or politician, I would need to get an entirely new degree! Does anyone else have these thoughts constantly in their head like me? Assistant: Double majored in EE and Theater. Realized about halfway through that engineering was the fallback, not the other way around. Now I’m trying to track down everyone in the entertainment industry who needs a controls engineer…
Human: What’s the coolest Christmas gift you have received? Doesn’t have to be engineering related necessarily, but all the engineers I know love cool, nerdy, mechanical objects. Figured we’d switch up the regular career advice and see everyone’s cool toys! Assistant: Something called a “Power Meter” for my bike (I’m a cyclist). It measured exactly how many watts you are producing, which allows you to do very accurate training and get a very accurate calorie count post workout :)
Human: What’s the coolest Christmas gift you have received? Doesn’t have to be engineering related necessarily, but all the engineers I know love cool, nerdy, mechanical objects. Figured we’d switch up the regular career advice and see everyone’s cool toys! Assistant: Recently: a fitbit. As a kid: Super Nintendo and big Lego castles.
Human: Trying to learn to use Matlab So as i progress into my career i can't really ignore this any more. My university makes us use Matlab a lot but there's not a specific course to really "learn" to use it, I've learnt a few things as I go but I still feel like I should be more knowledgeable in this, I wanted to know if you guys knew about some tool (a book or a youtube series or whatever) to learn the ins and outs of MatLab in my free time. Thanks Assistant: I'd almost recommend learning Python over matlab. The Syntax is similar and you'll have more job marketability when you graduate.
Human: Trying to learn to use Matlab So as i progress into my career i can't really ignore this any more. My university makes us use Matlab a lot but there's not a specific course to really "learn" to use it, I've learnt a few things as I go but I still feel like I should be more knowledgeable in this, I wanted to know if you guys knew about some tool (a book or a youtube series or whatever) to learn the ins and outs of MatLab in my free time. Thanks Assistant: Ughhhhh I hate matlab so much. Is it really so useful? edit: yay for downloading real questions.
Human: I cannot come close to my microphone without creating a strong buzz. When I Hold my microphone's cable this stops. Why and how to solve it? I have a generic headset I like to use just for its microphone connected to my desktop pc. Now people have been complaining about a buzzing sound in the background but only today ive come close to finding out why. When the headset is sitting on my desk these is no buzz, when I reach out to it with my hand it starts (before i touch it, 10-15 cm away) and increases all to way until i put it on my head. Now these headphones have 2 jacks to plug into the pc, one for mic and one for sound. The sound one is not connected and hanging in the air (since i use my speakers on very low for sound). When I hold this second plug/jack in my hand all the buzzing dissapears instantly. When i plug it in to my pc there is buzzing. Tried connecting it to my phone and even my 100W guitar amp, still buzzing. Seems my body is the magic solution here. I wrapped a thin copper wire around this connection pin for the headphones, and when i connect this wire to my metal watch on my arm the buzzing is gone again (obviously) but when i connect this wire to the ''grounding" metal part in my wall electric plug, the buzzing continues. Is my house (and plugs) not grounded at all? If not what might be causing this? I've gone outside, walked on the ground bare feet and came back 10 seconds later to try and it happens so im going to guess its not my body static. Assistant: http://www.amazon.com/PAC-SNI-1-3-5-3-5-mm-Isolator/dp/B001EAQTRI This may help.
Human: I cannot come close to my microphone without creating a strong buzz. When I Hold my microphone's cable this stops. Why and how to solve it? I have a generic headset I like to use just for its microphone connected to my desktop pc. Now people have been complaining about a buzzing sound in the background but only today ive come close to finding out why. When the headset is sitting on my desk these is no buzz, when I reach out to it with my hand it starts (before i touch it, 10-15 cm away) and increases all to way until i put it on my head. Now these headphones have 2 jacks to plug into the pc, one for mic and one for sound. The sound one is not connected and hanging in the air (since i use my speakers on very low for sound). When I hold this second plug/jack in my hand all the buzzing dissapears instantly. When i plug it in to my pc there is buzzing. Tried connecting it to my phone and even my 100W guitar amp, still buzzing. Seems my body is the magic solution here. I wrapped a thin copper wire around this connection pin for the headphones, and when i connect this wire to my metal watch on my arm the buzzing is gone again (obviously) but when i connect this wire to the ''grounding" metal part in my wall electric plug, the buzzing continues. Is my house (and plugs) not grounded at all? If not what might be causing this? I've gone outside, walked on the ground bare feet and came back 10 seconds later to try and it happens so im going to guess its not my body static. Assistant: Honestly I would wrap an insulated wire around your cable and tape it to your desk or something, experiment with what you touch it off to
Human: What would be a useful gift for a mining engineer starting his first job? My little brother just got his first job as a mining engineer and I want to get him a useful gift as he will be living remotely on site. What is something useful I can give him? Assistant: By order of importance: - Socks and foot powder. Lots of both. - Gentleman's toiletry roll. (small, waterproof, with hanging hook and mirror.) (load it up for him) - A good multitool. (Buy the Swiss one) - Something for entertainment.
Human: What would be a useful gift for a mining engineer starting his first job? My little brother just got his first job as a mining engineer and I want to get him a useful gift as he will be living remotely on site. What is something useful I can give him? Assistant: A good headlamp
Human: Where do I start with the most simple kind of engineering? I have looked around, but I cannot for the life of me find a resource for this. I am sorry if I come off as not knowing anything (because I really don't know.) I own a 3d printer and do woodworking and I am only interested in designing the most simple devices that require no electricity, motors or anything like that, just things that require the use of force from an individual. For example sliding stuff, ways(complicated or not) to make the parts move, gears all that jazz. My question is: What are some resources( books, courses) that teach this bare kind of stuff, principles? Yes, I don't know what I am talking about. This engineering stuff is so vast and overwhelming and I really don't know where to start or even the names of the stuff to even do google searches. (I'm not an english speaking citizen so I am not familiar the naming.) Assistant: Shigleys Mechanical Engineering Design is my favorite textbook
Human: Where do I start with the most simple kind of engineering? I have looked around, but I cannot for the life of me find a resource for this. I am sorry if I come off as not knowing anything (because I really don't know.) I own a 3d printer and do woodworking and I am only interested in designing the most simple devices that require no electricity, motors or anything like that, just things that require the use of force from an individual. For example sliding stuff, ways(complicated or not) to make the parts move, gears all that jazz. My question is: What are some resources( books, courses) that teach this bare kind of stuff, principles? Yes, I don't know what I am talking about. This engineering stuff is so vast and overwhelming and I really don't know where to start or even the names of the stuff to even do google searches. (I'm not an english speaking citizen so I am not familiar the naming.) Assistant: Libgen(dot)is bro. Search for any subject you may find interesting.
Human: Is high speed rail practical? Here in the us there is no high speed rail. I’m a pretty science literate person and it seems to me like a pretty killer way to move goods and people around. Seems like it would be efficient and get semis off the road and planes out of the air. I wanted to “AskEngineers” whether there’s something Im missing? To me it just seems like it’s a big, expensive hurdle to build the infrastructure but once it’s there it seems like it knocks the crap out of driving cars, traditional rail, and planes. What am I missing? Assistant: The addiction to cars is indirect in our lifestyles. We can’t even get people in the engineering industry to break up with the notion that people need to be in the office every day.
Human: Is high speed rail practical? Here in the us there is no high speed rail. I’m a pretty science literate person and it seems to me like a pretty killer way to move goods and people around. Seems like it would be efficient and get semis off the road and planes out of the air. I wanted to “AskEngineers” whether there’s something Im missing? To me it just seems like it’s a big, expensive hurdle to build the infrastructure but once it’s there it seems like it knocks the crap out of driving cars, traditional rail, and planes. What am I missing? Assistant: The main reason why trucks beat trains is because roads are subsidized. Taxes on fuel pay only a small percentage of road building and maintenance costs, the rest comes from the government treasury, i.e. taxes in general. The problem is political, if anybody proposed to raise taxes on fuel to subsidize railroads he would never get elected. People *like* having subsidized roads.
Human: Masters in CS with a Bach in Mechanical Engineering. Hi everyone, so I have a bachelor in mechanical engineering but since the final year of my degree that I've wanted to pursue a career as a software developer. Since I have basic knowledge in Visual Basic, C and Java, I talked to the main professor of the masters degree program in COMP SCI, at my university, and he told me that I could enroll in, as long as I took the 4 main classes from the undergrad curriculum. Those classes are " Software engineering", "Data Bases", "Systems Architecture" and "Intro to programming". So my question is, Do u think I should enroll in the masters program, or do something else ? Extra: In my country the masters program is 2 years long and the tuitions aren´t as crazy as in the US. Sorry if my English is not perfect, it's not my main language. Assistant: I suggest a Mozart in CS instead
Human: Masters in CS with a Bach in Mechanical Engineering. Hi everyone, so I have a bachelor in mechanical engineering but since the final year of my degree that I've wanted to pursue a career as a software developer. Since I have basic knowledge in Visual Basic, C and Java, I talked to the main professor of the masters degree program in COMP SCI, at my university, and he told me that I could enroll in, as long as I took the 4 main classes from the undergrad curriculum. Those classes are " Software engineering", "Data Bases", "Systems Architecture" and "Intro to programming". So my question is, Do u think I should enroll in the masters program, or do something else ? Extra: In my country the masters program is 2 years long and the tuitions aren´t as crazy as in the US. Sorry if my English is not perfect, it's not my main language. Assistant: I'm not sure I agree with needing to take the main courses. If you obtain an MS in CS, then you can be a software developer for a company that does mechanical work. Infact, I feel it would look better having gone to graduate school rather that take more undergraduate school. The difficulty of courses are different by a lot.
Human: Just got fired (today)! What now? Honestly my old job kinda broke my brain a little bit, and I have no idea what I like or am good at anymore. I did engineering change requests and that was torture, especially with undiagnosed/unmedicated ADHD. I did machine retrofits & construction design for an industrial plant and I loved that shit. But from what I remember - since they're continuous process, the WLB isn't ...amazing. Manufacturing engineering intimidates me for that reason. Consulting is absolutely not for me, not even a little bit. Will say, solid PTO & WLB is kinda critical for me - between ongoing chronic illnesses & MH issues I need to be able to work somewhere that doesn't need me to be on 24/7. Which is why I'm looking at government jobs, but I don't think that answers *what kind of engineering* works with who I am. So I guess that's kinda what I'm looking for. There are a ton of jobs around me for manufacturing engineering, test engineering, R&D and some reliability engineering, which I'm looking at but I'm not sure how to gauge how well I can succeed in those areas and jobs. I know I ignored a bunch of red flags at my last job, which is why I am where I am now tbh, but beyond "don't ignore those", idk what else to look for. Ftr, I have 2.5ish years of internship experience in manufacturing and reliability, and 1.5ish years in energy efficiency/commissioning. Commissioning was fun! The controls engineering was pretty cool tbh. Everything about the structure at my old company fucking sucked tho lmao. So I'm really trying to not go back to any kinda consulting for a good long while, if ever. Also, what kind of engineering is available at the govt level? How does that compare to industry? Assistant: As an engineer with ADHD, go get treated for it. Medication does wonders, people like us have different kind of brains and having medication to go forward with your future career stops many issues on such as anxiety about work since we tend to procrastinate.
Human: Just got fired (today)! What now? Honestly my old job kinda broke my brain a little bit, and I have no idea what I like or am good at anymore. I did engineering change requests and that was torture, especially with undiagnosed/unmedicated ADHD. I did machine retrofits & construction design for an industrial plant and I loved that shit. But from what I remember - since they're continuous process, the WLB isn't ...amazing. Manufacturing engineering intimidates me for that reason. Consulting is absolutely not for me, not even a little bit. Will say, solid PTO & WLB is kinda critical for me - between ongoing chronic illnesses & MH issues I need to be able to work somewhere that doesn't need me to be on 24/7. Which is why I'm looking at government jobs, but I don't think that answers *what kind of engineering* works with who I am. So I guess that's kinda what I'm looking for. There are a ton of jobs around me for manufacturing engineering, test engineering, R&D and some reliability engineering, which I'm looking at but I'm not sure how to gauge how well I can succeed in those areas and jobs. I know I ignored a bunch of red flags at my last job, which is why I am where I am now tbh, but beyond "don't ignore those", idk what else to look for. Ftr, I have 2.5ish years of internship experience in manufacturing and reliability, and 1.5ish years in energy efficiency/commissioning. Commissioning was fun! The controls engineering was pretty cool tbh. Everything about the structure at my old company fucking sucked tho lmao. So I'm really trying to not go back to any kinda consulting for a good long while, if ever. Also, what kind of engineering is available at the govt level? How does that compare to industry? Assistant: Fired or laid-off? Quite different process, similar outcome.
Human: Is Lean six sigma worth it? I am a mechanical engineering undergraduate student starting my final year and I am considering doing the green belt lean six sigma certification at my university. It is fairly expensive and I would have to take a week off from work, but I am also thinking of doing an mba or masters in engineering leadership a few years after I graduate. Would this certification help me get a job after graduation or be valuable to me in any way? Assistant: if the company you work for really wants it, they'll pay for it, and give you the time to do it. DON"T spend your own money AND vacation on it. GB is worth having, but it's a sprinkle or two on top of the sunday that is your resume.
Human: Is Lean six sigma worth it? I am a mechanical engineering undergraduate student starting my final year and I am considering doing the green belt lean six sigma certification at my university. It is fairly expensive and I would have to take a week off from work, but I am also thinking of doing an mba or masters in engineering leadership a few years after I graduate. Would this certification help me get a job after graduation or be valuable to me in any way? Assistant: Lean is pretty worthless unless you're trying to optimize just-in-time stuff. Six sigma is just "applied" statistics. Really knowing the statistics is incredibly valuable. Six sigma generally speaking teaches how to do the statistics using software and check P-values but not what it actually means or whether the result is meaningful.
Human: Is there a website where I could find technical drawings of parts with all the rules applied? I’m an aerospace engineering student and I’ve been looking for some technical drawings to get familiarized with but I can’t find any “base” on the Internet to cull from. The drawings would have to be congruent with all the official rules and include things like tolerance, coarseness etc. Assistant: ASME Y14.5 is at its 2018 revision, which is tough to find shared copy of. You’d have better chance to find its 2009, or 1994 copies. Not a lot have changed throughout concept-wise, but as a novice, that’d be the least of your concern. I wish every BSME program at every school would have this important “language”. At least 2 semesters of it, 101, 102.
Human: Is there a website where I could find technical drawings of parts with all the rules applied? I’m an aerospace engineering student and I’ve been looking for some technical drawings to get familiarized with but I can’t find any “base” on the Internet to cull from. The drawings would have to be congruent with all the official rules and include things like tolerance, coarseness etc. Assistant: In the UK most companies abide by standards BS8888 which is pretty standard, if you look it up you can find a lot of technical and assembly drawings conforming to those standards.
Human: What is the day of a mechanical engineer like? And electrical? What kind of work do you do? What did you start out doing? Do you like doing it? Would you like to switch to a different type of engineering? Do you travel a lot? Do you like your pay? All feedback appreciated, thanks! Assistant: I spend half my day fighting off the throngs of hot babes. The other half I do stuff on a computer.
Human: What is the day of a mechanical engineer like? And electrical? What kind of work do you do? What did you start out doing? Do you like doing it? Would you like to switch to a different type of engineering? Do you travel a lot? Do you like your pay? All feedback appreciated, thanks! Assistant: Mechanical and Electrical are such wide fields that you'll likely get a different answer form everyone.
Human: How much detail should I give in an exit interview? I'm currently scheduled for an exit interview next week with my employer. I have many reasons for leaving, and I am wondering just how much detail should I give? I feel like some of these details will throw my immediate managers under the bus with their upper management - which may strain my relationship should I need them for future references. Does it make sense to do a tell-all? Or should I just keep in vague? Assistant: None. Don't do the interview at all, there is no requirement to, and you have the right to decline it. It can only harm you.
Human: How much detail should I give in an exit interview? I'm currently scheduled for an exit interview next week with my employer. I have many reasons for leaving, and I am wondering just how much detail should I give? I feel like some of these details will throw my immediate managers under the bus with their upper management - which may strain my relationship should I need them for future references. Does it make sense to do a tell-all? Or should I just keep in vague? Assistant: You did the job, you got paid. Enough said.
Human: How To Maintain 12V / 30A during a 200ms Outage? I have a battery disconnect switch with 4 positions: Source 1, Source 2, Both, Off. Continuity tester's beep is interrupted when switching from "1" to "Both." I'd like my things to stay running when switching. Max load will be 30A. Is there some sort of beefy capacitor that will do the job? Assistant: Alternatively, there are switches that are “make before break” and “make after break”. You have a make after break (new connection made after old connection is broken). You want a “make before break” (new connection made before old connection is broken). Most of these are used for switching batteries (12v) in automotive and marine applications. You can absolutely find them in 12v 30a. Perko makes them, for example, as do many others if you search “make before break battery switch”.
Human: How To Maintain 12V / 30A during a 200ms Outage? I have a battery disconnect switch with 4 positions: Source 1, Source 2, Both, Off. Continuity tester's beep is interrupted when switching from "1" to "Both." I'd like my things to stay running when switching. Max load will be 30A. Is there some sort of beefy capacitor that will do the job? Assistant: Car battery?
Human: What field of engineering did you pick and why? Assistant: Chemical Engineer I used to steal glassware to make bongs in high school chemistry. Took AP because it had better and continued access to glassware. I thought "well wet bench chemistry is boring as fuck and Engineering school is the hardest to get into so why not?" I tell my kids I was good at math and science.
Human: What field of engineering did you pick and why? Assistant: Network Engineering. Was studying Info Sci in Boston as I didn't want to do Computer Science. Cisco Systems comes to campus to hold info sessions for their internships. I was the only one that showed up, sounded interesting, got an interview, got the job. While working there I was like, hey this is cool! So I do that now.
Human: Engineers , How satisfied are with your careers? and would you do anything diff if you could o back to college years?-diff major ?college? etc Assistant: So what I'm getting from this post is that engineering is over-glorified and to live my last days of college to the fullest? Good thing I've decided to do just that for my senior year and I've been incredibly happy.
Human: Engineers , How satisfied are with your careers? and would you do anything diff if you could o back to college years?-diff major ?college? etc Assistant: A++ would career again. In high school, I probably would have taken Mandarin Chinese instead of Spanish. That's specific to my career needs and not necessarily engineering as a whole.
Human: What % of recent mech grads have gotten jobs I am trying to guage roughly what % of recent mech grads who grduated during covid have got jobs. If you have a rough idea between yourself and your friends who graduated and can give an estimate that would be great. Assistant: Even in regular years only about 30% get engineering jobs (in Ontario at elast)
Human: What % of recent mech grads have gotten jobs I am trying to guage roughly what % of recent mech grads who grduated during covid have got jobs. If you have a rough idea between yourself and your friends who graduated and can give an estimate that would be great. Assistant: May 2020 mech e here. Job offer rescinded. No interviews. I don't like ME so I am not going to grad school. I can't join the military and have lots of debt and no connections. Working as a night shift security guard. I'm desperate.
Human: Is Delta-Wye configuration irrelevant when it comes to single-phase transformers? Let's say that our load is a 200 Amp panel feeding from a 50 Amp breaker (480VAC). I would assume, two wires (two hots/phases) from the 50 A breaker would connect to the primary side of a 35 KVA transformer, while the the secondary side will connect 3 wires (two hots and a neutral) to the 200 Amp panel right? Assistant: Yes. Irrelevant. It's not part of the equation because you're only using a single phase setup, so no way to create a Delta or Wye configuration with the coils.
Human: Is Delta-Wye configuration irrelevant when it comes to single-phase transformers? Let's say that our load is a 200 Amp panel feeding from a 50 Amp breaker (480VAC). I would assume, two wires (two hots/phases) from the 50 A breaker would connect to the primary side of a 35 KVA transformer, while the the secondary side will connect 3 wires (two hots and a neutral) to the 200 Amp panel right? Assistant: Not sure what everyone else is commenting, but it sounds like a pretty standard single-phase, split-phase setup. The 480V primary is wired phase-phase, the secondary has a split phase, I'm assuming 240/120V. The secondary has (2) 120V line-neutral legs for single-pole breakers in your panelboard, and 240V line-line for double-pole breakers in the panelboard. But your initial question is correct, you don't have delta or wye with single-phase. Delta and wye describe three-phase connections.
Human: What is the "next big step" in robotics? I am a mechanical engineer and I think I will end up transitioning to something like mechatronics. I hear of companies like Boston Dynamics and Amazon Robotics. However, I am a little confused as to what are the biggest advancements in recent years. What makes a robot today different from one 40 years ago? I work in manufacturing and the tasks these robots do are pretty simple given that they only have to do one or two tasks over and over again. Of course, they are pretty dumb. Can someone from the field elaborate? Assistant: More advanced autonomy. Better sensor perception. Understanding what to do with information. Collaborative robotics. And as a side topic, software safety.
Human: What is the "next big step" in robotics? I am a mechanical engineer and I think I will end up transitioning to something like mechatronics. I hear of companies like Boston Dynamics and Amazon Robotics. However, I am a little confused as to what are the biggest advancements in recent years. What makes a robot today different from one 40 years ago? I work in manufacturing and the tasks these robots do are pretty simple given that they only have to do one or two tasks over and over again. Of course, they are pretty dumb. Can someone from the field elaborate? Assistant: Do you work with robots that Build stuff like cars or just an enthusiast
Human: I’m looking for a light but rigid sheet of plastic. I need something about 30”x48” that won’t bend when lifted from one end. I am building an avalanche simulation board. Basically, I have a scissor lift that is going to lift this sheet up from one side at various angles between 0 and 45 degrees. The load on the sheet will be less than 10lbs spread evenly. Steel is too heavy and flimsy when it is thin. Plastic is the same way. Is there some sort of honeycomb plastic sheet, or some other rigid material that won’t bend? Any other ideas? Assistant: Look for fiber reinforced laminated plates. Depending on the direction of force, it should either be unidirectional (strong in one direction) or quasi-isotropic (fairly strong in all directions) also see here. Examples for pre- laminated sheets: https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/carbon-fiber-laminated-sheet.html In terms of price (from lowest to highest) glassfiber -> carbon -> aramid
Human: I’m looking for a light but rigid sheet of plastic. I need something about 30”x48” that won’t bend when lifted from one end. I am building an avalanche simulation board. Basically, I have a scissor lift that is going to lift this sheet up from one side at various angles between 0 and 45 degrees. The load on the sheet will be less than 10lbs spread evenly. Steel is too heavy and flimsy when it is thin. Plastic is the same way. Is there some sort of honeycomb plastic sheet, or some other rigid material that won’t bend? Any other ideas? Assistant: thicker sheet of plywood with a thin plastic layer on top? should be fairly rigid and cheap. alternatively you can stiffen a thin sheet of plastic by gluing (or otherwise attaching) stiffening members on their side -- think like a plastic beam under the main surface. If you buy the plastic in a 4x8' sheet, you can use strips cut from the excess.
Human: What kind of statistics do engineers use? I am an engineering student, and I am about to finish my semester taking a statistics course. As I prepare for my final exam, I was wondering if there are any particular topics in statistics I should put extra focus on understanding to better prepare myself for an engineering career? What kind of statistics are often used in the engineering field? Assistant: DoE is useful as well.
Human: What kind of statistics do engineers use? I am an engineering student, and I am about to finish my semester taking a statistics course. As I prepare for my final exam, I was wondering if there are any particular topics in statistics I should put extra focus on understanding to better prepare myself for an engineering career? What kind of statistics are often used in the engineering field? Assistant: I have used hypothesis testing a fair bit to determine if design change has a significant effect.
Human: Is anyone else absolutely terrible at mental math? I score very high on standardized tests but I just suck at doing simple calculations in my head. I always make the dumbest mistakes. Assistant: I always say "I'm more worried about someone seeing my calculator history than my browser history"
Human: Is anyone else absolutely terrible at mental math? I score very high on standardized tests but I just suck at doing simple calculations in my head. I always make the dumbest mistakes. Assistant: Same here. Not sure what it is. I feel like my mind goes into overdrive when dealing with complicated problems, otherwise it's in an idle state. Still remember college... Conceptually problem was correct.. arithmetic not so much. 3*3 /= 6
Human: What is the minimum size metal mesh that bluetooth or 2.4GHz can pass through? As the topic says I am trying to find the minimum square hole size for a metal mesh that lets bluetooth signal pass through. I am trying not to make a faraday cage for the signal. The mesh is made from stainless steel wire. Please let me know if it would make a different if the holes are rectangular. And if so what would be the minimum size. Assistant: A very rough rule of thumb is that if the holes are less than 0.1 wavelength (12mm) there will be negligible transmission, and if the holes are bigger than 1 wavelength (122mm) there won’t be much blocking. Waiting for an RF engineer to chime in.
Human: What is the minimum size metal mesh that bluetooth or 2.4GHz can pass through? As the topic says I am trying to find the minimum square hole size for a metal mesh that lets bluetooth signal pass through. I am trying not to make a faraday cage for the signal. The mesh is made from stainless steel wire. Please let me know if it would make a different if the holes are rectangular. And if so what would be the minimum size. Assistant: There’s a formula based on wavelength. I don’t know it off the top of my head.
Human: Automotive question: Why are passenger car tires all roughly 35psi? I've seen lots of answers to adjacent questions that are about overinflation, underinflation and all the stuff a vehicle owner should care about, but this question is not that. I'm wondering why 35psi seems to be the designed pressure for millions of road going vehicles. Several factors at play I know are load bearing both for the rubber and the road, durability and wear, passenger comfort, fuel efficiency and others. Is 35psi the nexus for these factors? I am really asking this as a question for bike tires, which if you're a nerdy cyclist you've seen that all sorts of tire dimensions and treads are a hot topic. 29'er, 650b wheels, 35c slicks, fat bikes etc. One thing that has really come out in recent years is the notion that skinny high pressure tires aren't actually faster - they're just perceptively faster because they transfer more road feel. Fatter tires at an optimal tire pressure seem are actually the faster tire, even in some cases when accounting for added aerodynamic drag, because they seem to push off of bumps on the trailing edge just as much as they asborb impact on the leading edge. That conserves motion and saves the rest of the bike and rider from absorbing energy from road harshness. So thinking back to optimal pressure... We know that for a given load, the tire PSI directly defines the surface contact the tire has. 200lb rider and bike with 100psi tires has a 1 square inch of rubber on the ground for each tire. But lately the trend of non-professional tire choice has been to use a fatter tire on road bikes resulting in 200lb rider and bike to have roughly 40psi in 45c tires leading to larger contact patches. I find that tire pressure to be suspiciously close to what we put in cars... Is this trend working towards some kind of similar nexus that led car tire design to 35psi? If so, should we be thinking of optimal bike tire choice in a similar way where we aim for an ideal tire pressure, say 35 or 40psi and select tires by their width for a given load? I'm sure there are other factors at play, most notably rubber compounds, radial speeds, and acceleration loads. I just didn't find anywhere talking about **why** 35psi is the designed pressure for a passenger car. Assistant: I keep my fat bike tires at 29, recommendation is 27, but it feels too spongy for me. I’m under 200# :)
Human: Automotive question: Why are passenger car tires all roughly 35psi? I've seen lots of answers to adjacent questions that are about overinflation, underinflation and all the stuff a vehicle owner should care about, but this question is not that. I'm wondering why 35psi seems to be the designed pressure for millions of road going vehicles. Several factors at play I know are load bearing both for the rubber and the road, durability and wear, passenger comfort, fuel efficiency and others. Is 35psi the nexus for these factors? I am really asking this as a question for bike tires, which if you're a nerdy cyclist you've seen that all sorts of tire dimensions and treads are a hot topic. 29'er, 650b wheels, 35c slicks, fat bikes etc. One thing that has really come out in recent years is the notion that skinny high pressure tires aren't actually faster - they're just perceptively faster because they transfer more road feel. Fatter tires at an optimal tire pressure seem are actually the faster tire, even in some cases when accounting for added aerodynamic drag, because they seem to push off of bumps on the trailing edge just as much as they asborb impact on the leading edge. That conserves motion and saves the rest of the bike and rider from absorbing energy from road harshness. So thinking back to optimal pressure... We know that for a given load, the tire PSI directly defines the surface contact the tire has. 200lb rider and bike with 100psi tires has a 1 square inch of rubber on the ground for each tire. But lately the trend of non-professional tire choice has been to use a fatter tire on road bikes resulting in 200lb rider and bike to have roughly 40psi in 45c tires leading to larger contact patches. I find that tire pressure to be suspiciously close to what we put in cars... Is this trend working towards some kind of similar nexus that led car tire design to 35psi? If so, should we be thinking of optimal bike tire choice in a similar way where we aim for an ideal tire pressure, say 35 or 40psi and select tires by their width for a given load? I'm sure there are other factors at play, most notably rubber compounds, radial speeds, and acceleration loads. I just didn't find anywhere talking about **why** 35psi is the designed pressure for a passenger car. Assistant: Bike tires are not like vehicle tires.
Human: How to calculate flow rate based on pressure and pipe diameter? How can i calculate the flow rate in cubic meters if i only have the diameter of the pipe (2 inches) and the pressure 2 bar? Assistant: What are you actually doing? Is this a real system? Based on some of your sub-comments, you have some type of pump and some type of tank. How are they arranged? This matters. How much piping do you have? Where are you pumping from and to where are you pumping. If you have a diagram, even better. A problem well-defined is a problem half-solved. Write up the information on your system and edit your initial post with it.
Human: How to calculate flow rate based on pressure and pipe diameter? How can i calculate the flow rate in cubic meters if i only have the diameter of the pipe (2 inches) and the pressure 2 bar? Assistant: Calculate friction factor... Use moody diagram to find Reynolds number. Back calculate flow rate based on fluid conditions.
Human: Is it better to have more internships or a long-term one? I got an internship in my major (EE) field and they informed me that they'll keep me on until I graduate and consider a salaried position after that. But, I've been offered several other internships (all at average companies). Would it be better to have several internships on my resume or one "long-term" internship with the prospect of a job after? Assistant: If they are in different areas of technology, it could be a way to get more exposure and decide what you want to do. Or just to find which company culture you like.
Human: Is it better to have more internships or a long-term one? I got an internship in my major (EE) field and they informed me that they'll keep me on until I graduate and consider a salaried position after that. But, I've been offered several other internships (all at average companies). Would it be better to have several internships on my resume or one "long-term" internship with the prospect of a job after? Assistant: Whichever is most relevant for what you want to do.
Human: Can anyone recommend good books on nuclear power? I’ll take anything - nuclear chemistries, research, reactor design, tales from disasters, history of research programs. Anything interesting. Assistant: I have a reading list for nuclear topics going here: https://whatisnuclear.com/nuclear-reading-list.html And I'm biased since I wrote it but here's a huge writeup on nuclear reactor development history in the USA
Human: Can anyone recommend good books on nuclear power? I’ll take anything - nuclear chemistries, research, reactor design, tales from disasters, history of research programs. Anything interesting. Assistant: Midnight in Chernobyl was absolutely fantastic. I’m a structural engineer and appreciated the technical details they went into.
Human: Question About Engineering Ethics- How to Make an Ethical Choice? I work in a manufacturing facility as a manufacturing engineer. I program parts, load data into an MRP system and calculate labor costs, material costs, and production rates as part of my job. I am the primary manufacturing engineer dedicated to a new product line we launched last year. When the project first kicked off, the actual cost of the product was about 25% over cost. So I was told by management to artificially inflate labor productivity in our MRP system, SAP. (i.e., say we can weld 20 frames per hour when we can only really do 10 per hour). To date, we have been absorbing the variance in the actual cost of the product into other product lines. I have proposed reporting the actual labor rates in the MRP system to decrease our variance. (Variance is how much we actually spent on labor vs. what the MRP says we should have spent). Is being told by your employer to increase labor productivity as a means to decrease the cost of a product unethical? I am essentially under reporting labor. I don’t want to be caught up in a scandal within the company when shit hits the fan. Assistant: This is all internal corporate money math right? Not affecting taxes or spending Client X's money on Client Y's labor?
Human: Question About Engineering Ethics- How to Make an Ethical Choice? I work in a manufacturing facility as a manufacturing engineer. I program parts, load data into an MRP system and calculate labor costs, material costs, and production rates as part of my job. I am the primary manufacturing engineer dedicated to a new product line we launched last year. When the project first kicked off, the actual cost of the product was about 25% over cost. So I was told by management to artificially inflate labor productivity in our MRP system, SAP. (i.e., say we can weld 20 frames per hour when we can only really do 10 per hour). To date, we have been absorbing the variance in the actual cost of the product into other product lines. I have proposed reporting the actual labor rates in the MRP system to decrease our variance. (Variance is how much we actually spent on labor vs. what the MRP says we should have spent). Is being told by your employer to increase labor productivity as a means to decrease the cost of a product unethical? I am essentially under reporting labor. I don’t want to be caught up in a scandal within the company when shit hits the fan. Assistant: Document everything and keep independent records so the company can't delete anything crucial to your defence, should it come to that. However, it is likely that this is just strategic financial management to win contracts or similar. Sometimes it can be favourable to bid under cost to win a contract with a big client to get repeat business etc. There are a number of potential reasons for this and it may not be anything unethical.
Human: Is aerospace engineering a growing or diminishing field? I'm currently studying mechanical engineering and are going to choose a master profile in a year and I'm very intrested in aerospace but I'm a bit concerned that it's a dying field. So my question is is it worth going in to? I know a lot of people are talking about electric airplanes these days but it seems to me that those are quite far in the future. I have also considered the growing use of civilian drones as a possibility. Anyone in the aerospace industry that got any insight for me? Assistant: In 2010 the Bureau of Labor Statistics in the US predicted a -2% growth rate for the next 10 years for aerospace engineers. Not great, but basically steady. Now they predict a +7% growth rate for the next 10 years. While those predictions might not be worth all that much, clearly something is happening to swing that needle wildly upward.
Human: Is aerospace engineering a growing or diminishing field? I'm currently studying mechanical engineering and are going to choose a master profile in a year and I'm very intrested in aerospace but I'm a bit concerned that it's a dying field. So my question is is it worth going in to? I know a lot of people are talking about electric airplanes these days but it seems to me that those are quite far in the future. I have also considered the growing use of civilian drones as a possibility. Anyone in the aerospace industry that got any insight for me? Assistant: It is the number 1 engineering skills demand listed by Engineers Australia.
Human: Math. After college, what math will I use every day in environmental engineering, and what were your studying techniques during school? I have never been very good at math. Granted, I've never really tried hard to be good at it. I didn't pay much attention to anything in high school except trying to meet girls and getting high with my friends after class. I fucked around my first year of college, trying a few different things and switched majors a few times. I like building things. I love nature and the environment. I did well in biology and decent in chemistry, both without doing much if any studying. I'm interested in electrical systems, and the overall process of designing a structure. This is what led me to environmental engineering. Now it's my second year of college and I'm in the college level algebra class attempting to make my way though algebra and pre-calc before transferring to a 4 year school where I’ll begin calc and physics. I never acquired an interest in math until the summer after my first year of college, where I realized that math is what makes the world orderly and manageable. Math is what people use to create and design buildings, roads, bridges, dams, machines, and really anything in between. And I want to be a part of it. I would rather struggle my way through college level math and get a good job doing something interesting and making a good salary with good job security than coast my way through what I think is easy and land a job sitting in front of a computer typing away at code for years. The subjects I did well in: English, history, Spanish, programming, were really the subjects that I just didn't need to study for to do well in. In short, I’m lazy. I had, and probably still have, a minor case of ADD. I hate it and I’m trying to get myself out of this groove where I put in the minimal amount of effort and get out the grades to match. I'm by no means stupid, I got into some decent schools in my area: U of Delaware, Rowan U, Stockton, Rutgers, I just get bad luck with math teachers. I can’t say I’ve ever had a math teacher that seemed like he was genuinely interested in math and wanted everyone to also feel the same way. My current teacher is Swedish. He has a thick accent and it's very hard to understand him. He doesn't explain things well, expects you to know things and decent bother to explain them if you don’t, and he gets angry at you if you ask a question - which causes no one to ask questions in my class – which is why about 70% of us are failing. I've been trying to remedy this by watching videos on KhanAcademy.com , and I’ve scheduled to meet with a tutor. This is a start, but I want to know what got you through math in college, and what type of math I can expect to be asked to complete on a project by project basis in environmental engineering. tr;dr - I want to know what got you through math in college, and what type of math I can expect to be asked to complete on a project by project basis in environmental engineering. Thanks, and I hope everyone is having a splendid day. Assistant: Start doing the Khan Academy *exercises* from the very beginning (yes, I mean 1+1=2). Continue to do them until you hit a snag on something you don't know. Start watching the videos alongside the exercises at this point. That should take care of you until calculus. For calculus and beyond, use sites like KA, PatrickJMT, Paul's Online Math Notes, BetterExplained, and/or MIT OCW to supplement your lectures and homework. Read this collection of links on efficient study habits.
Human: Math. After college, what math will I use every day in environmental engineering, and what were your studying techniques during school? I have never been very good at math. Granted, I've never really tried hard to be good at it. I didn't pay much attention to anything in high school except trying to meet girls and getting high with my friends after class. I fucked around my first year of college, trying a few different things and switched majors a few times. I like building things. I love nature and the environment. I did well in biology and decent in chemistry, both without doing much if any studying. I'm interested in electrical systems, and the overall process of designing a structure. This is what led me to environmental engineering. Now it's my second year of college and I'm in the college level algebra class attempting to make my way though algebra and pre-calc before transferring to a 4 year school where I’ll begin calc and physics. I never acquired an interest in math until the summer after my first year of college, where I realized that math is what makes the world orderly and manageable. Math is what people use to create and design buildings, roads, bridges, dams, machines, and really anything in between. And I want to be a part of it. I would rather struggle my way through college level math and get a good job doing something interesting and making a good salary with good job security than coast my way through what I think is easy and land a job sitting in front of a computer typing away at code for years. The subjects I did well in: English, history, Spanish, programming, were really the subjects that I just didn't need to study for to do well in. In short, I’m lazy. I had, and probably still have, a minor case of ADD. I hate it and I’m trying to get myself out of this groove where I put in the minimal amount of effort and get out the grades to match. I'm by no means stupid, I got into some decent schools in my area: U of Delaware, Rowan U, Stockton, Rutgers, I just get bad luck with math teachers. I can’t say I’ve ever had a math teacher that seemed like he was genuinely interested in math and wanted everyone to also feel the same way. My current teacher is Swedish. He has a thick accent and it's very hard to understand him. He doesn't explain things well, expects you to know things and decent bother to explain them if you don’t, and he gets angry at you if you ask a question - which causes no one to ask questions in my class – which is why about 70% of us are failing. I've been trying to remedy this by watching videos on KhanAcademy.com , and I’ve scheduled to meet with a tutor. This is a start, but I want to know what got you through math in college, and what type of math I can expect to be asked to complete on a project by project basis in environmental engineering. tr;dr - I want to know what got you through math in college, and what type of math I can expect to be asked to complete on a project by project basis in environmental engineering. Thanks, and I hope everyone is having a splendid day. Assistant: You will need a thorough understanding of calculus and linear algebra for any type of engineering.
Human: Telling interviewer that you already have another job offer when you don't? Let's say you are expecting a job offer but didn't receive it yet, and are still interviewing with other companies. Can you tell tell them that you already have a job offer so they can speed up the interview process? Assistant: Lying, not a good strategy.
Human: Telling interviewer that you already have another job offer when you don't? Let's say you are expecting a job offer but didn't receive it yet, and are still interviewing with other companies. Can you tell tell them that you already have a job offer so they can speed up the interview process? Assistant: There's a thing we as engineers are meant to have, it's called ethics. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
Human: What maths is used in Bridge engineering? Hi all, I hope everyone is doing well. I was just wondering what maths do bridge engineers do? For example, do they use algebra ( quadratic, simultaneous equations etc)? Btw I'm from the UK. Thanks, AspiringEngineer89 Assistant: Not dynamics, hopefully
Human: What maths is used in Bridge engineering? Hi all, I hope everyone is doing well. I was just wondering what maths do bridge engineers do? For example, do they use algebra ( quadratic, simultaneous equations etc)? Btw I'm from the UK. Thanks, AspiringEngineer89 Assistant: Stop wondering bout London bridge falling innit
Human: My guitar (in Texas) started picking up Radio Havana Cuba [Recording]. Why? I was messing around with guitar today and stopped when I heard a voice. Listened for a second and heard someone say "You are listening to Radio Havanah Cuba" and some spanish. It went away so I kept noodling but left a recording going. It eventually came back and I got a recording -> https://clyp.it/ngzheusi. I did some searching and found that this is a shortwave station. Is my guitar acting as an envelope filter and thus demodulating? The signal (at times) was actually quite clear! Thanks! Assistant: Years ago in Toronto, I heard them often on a portable shortwave receiver. I QSL'ed to the address they mentioned on the air, and got a nice card back acknowling my SWL report. Then for years, I kept getting propaganda literature from them in the mail every month or two :-/
Human: My guitar (in Texas) started picking up Radio Havana Cuba [Recording]. Why? I was messing around with guitar today and stopped when I heard a voice. Listened for a second and heard someone say "You are listening to Radio Havanah Cuba" and some spanish. It went away so I kept noodling but left a recording going. It eventually came back and I got a recording -> https://clyp.it/ngzheusi. I did some searching and found that this is a shortwave station. Is my guitar acting as an envelope filter and thus demodulating? The signal (at times) was actually quite clear! Thanks! Assistant: Haha I actually did this while building an audio amp. It was too quiet, so I changed a resistor to up the gain, and the next thing I heard is the closest AM station to come in.
Human: What keeps a passenger jets stable when braking on landing with tricycle type landing gear? One only needs to see Jeremy from Top Gear drive a Robin Reliant, or hear of horror stories about Honda's three-wheel ATC from the 80s, to know how dangerously unstable trike-type vehicles can be. Personally, I can't ever help thinking about above when landing after a flight. To me this seems like an inverted pendulum, assuming the CG of the plane is relatively far behind the front wheel, a classically unstable system. The amount of deceleration that occurs throws you forward, and it feel like the plane could tuck at the slightest misalignment. Yet I've seen videos of similar planes landing at near 45 degree angles during gnarly crosswinds that don't have any oscillations in their track after touching down. What am I missing that makes the planes stability so unintuitive? Is this a controls problems, and the plane takes over to maintain stability? Or is the pilot solely responsible for control? Assistant: Ech, that Top Gear episode. No, Robin Reliants are not that unstable. He had hundreds of pounds of ballast in the roof. You should have worked this out when he got it to wheelie.
Human: What keeps a passenger jets stable when braking on landing with tricycle type landing gear? One only needs to see Jeremy from Top Gear drive a Robin Reliant, or hear of horror stories about Honda's three-wheel ATC from the 80s, to know how dangerously unstable trike-type vehicles can be. Personally, I can't ever help thinking about above when landing after a flight. To me this seems like an inverted pendulum, assuming the CG of the plane is relatively far behind the front wheel, a classically unstable system. The amount of deceleration that occurs throws you forward, and it feel like the plane could tuck at the slightest misalignment. Yet I've seen videos of similar planes landing at near 45 degree angles during gnarly crosswinds that don't have any oscillations in their track after touching down. What am I missing that makes the planes stability so unintuitive? Is this a controls problems, and the plane takes over to maintain stability? Or is the pilot solely responsible for control? Assistant: If I recall, the key detail is that on an airplane there aren’t brakes on the nose gear. Because the only brakes are on the main gear and the CG is forward of those the braking would be stable. Unless of course the brakes fail on one side. Then you’re effed.
Human: Can someone please explain the solution to this pulley problem to me? http://imgur.com/a/aSDyr What's confusing me is why the 1200 N force is not divided equally into it's two cables.. Should it not be two 600 N forces? Assistant: I did the same thing as you before I looked at the solution. The catch is that the left most cable winds around two pulleys, but the way I did the math resulted in parts of that cable having different tension than other parts, which is not correct for frictionless cables.
Human: Can someone please explain the solution to this pulley problem to me? http://imgur.com/a/aSDyr What's confusing me is why the 1200 N force is not divided equally into it's two cables.. Should it not be two 600 N forces? Assistant: Lets call the bottom left cable "BCD" BCD has three vertical sections. Each section has the same tension because of the frictionless pulleys. With me so far? The sum of the 3 sections of BCD must add to 1200N. Therefore the tension of BCD is 400N Therefore the tension of cable C is 1200-400=800
Human: Possibility I'll have access to an electric go kart that's missing a battery pack. What are my options to make this thing insane? I work for a company that uses electric motors for a comparatively boring application. The owner of the company apparently decided a couple years ago to put TWO of these motors on a go kart. Crashed it and it's been sitting in the back of the warehouse ever since( linkage for the break is cashed). We never used lithium batteries for our applications so I'm guessing with two pretty large electric motors and lithium battery back, this think would fucking fly. I was thinking about just buying 50-100 18650 batteries off alibaba and making my own cell. Can you guy think of some other options that I could do that won't break the bank here? Assistant: Find some used Nissan Leaf cells. Quality cells at a terrific price.
Human: Possibility I'll have access to an electric go kart that's missing a battery pack. What are my options to make this thing insane? I work for a company that uses electric motors for a comparatively boring application. The owner of the company apparently decided a couple years ago to put TWO of these motors on a go kart. Crashed it and it's been sitting in the back of the warehouse ever since( linkage for the break is cashed). We never used lithium batteries for our applications so I'm guessing with two pretty large electric motors and lithium battery back, this think would fucking fly. I was thinking about just buying 50-100 18650 batteries off alibaba and making my own cell. Can you guy think of some other options that I could do that won't break the bank here? Assistant: Buy a long cable and run it from mains power. You'll want some kind of strain relief, and a catenary/recoiler. You may need a fair size capacitor bank to get maximum acceleration, unless you have 3 phase power available. I dunno how much power a go kart uses though, if it's only around 2kW you should be fine on single phase. PS. There are many reasons why this is a terrible idea. But it would be cheap...
Human: What is the name of the "mechanism" that allows controlled cable release by wrapping multiple times around a stable anchor? I feel like this has a name but cannot place what it is. Basically, if you need to do a controlled release of a tensioned cable load, you wrap the cable/rope around a non-moving "pulley". You can control very heavy loads without needing much force. Half a loop will get you little force, and if you need more force you can add more wraps. I could control the lowering of a piano without much trouble by just wrapping more turns. (Note: I'm not lowering a piano, just an example). I believe this is what they use for climbing belay systems to let light people belay heavy people. This would be the thing at the top of the climb, not what the person holds on their body. I think they also use this in boating applications but I don't know enough about boats to Google it. Assistant: Bollard, and what you are describing is Bollard Force, at least when discussing ships.
Human: What is the name of the "mechanism" that allows controlled cable release by wrapping multiple times around a stable anchor? I feel like this has a name but cannot place what it is. Basically, if you need to do a controlled release of a tensioned cable load, you wrap the cable/rope around a non-moving "pulley". You can control very heavy loads without needing much force. Half a loop will get you little force, and if you need more force you can add more wraps. I could control the lowering of a piano without much trouble by just wrapping more turns. (Note: I'm not lowering a piano, just an example). I believe this is what they use for climbing belay systems to let light people belay heavy people. This would be the thing at the top of the climb, not what the person holds on their body. I think they also use this in boating applications but I don't know enough about boats to Google it. Assistant: Capstan.
Human: Does anyone know what would do this to a titanium sheet? Shipped from China and was wet upon arrival. Surface is smooth over spots. Would anything reverse what has happened without removing material? https://imgur.com/a/3gSBa1Y Assistant: I'll take oxidized chintanium for 2000 please, Alex.
Human: Does anyone know what would do this to a titanium sheet? Shipped from China and was wet upon arrival. Surface is smooth over spots. Would anything reverse what has happened without removing material? https://imgur.com/a/3gSBa1Y Assistant: What’s the end use of the material? Are there any structural integrity considerations?
Human: Is running an engine at its full load good? I was preparing for my mechanical engineering technical interview and stumbled upon a question: if you have two engines and one is running at full load all day and the other is ramping up and down but only working 4 hours a day which one will fail first? My first intuitive thought was that it was never a good idea to run something at its maximum/limit. Assistant: As an ME that was a heavy diesel mechanic and car nerd before being an ME, that question makes me horny. Those fools would have no idea they activated my trap card. How are they ramped? To idle or engine shutdown? How are they started? Are they totally identical? How are they lubricated? So many fun questions to ask. The answer: it mostly depends. Maintenance intervals are rated based upon hours for most industrial equipment so the short answer is whichever one the hour meter runs faster on.
Human: Is running an engine at its full load good? I was preparing for my mechanical engineering technical interview and stumbled upon a question: if you have two engines and one is running at full load all day and the other is ramping up and down but only working 4 hours a day which one will fail first? My first intuitive thought was that it was never a good idea to run something at its maximum/limit. Assistant: "I would call the engine vendor and ask them"
Human: Can QR codes be stacked on top of each other in different colors? My understanding is that QR codes need at least a 20% difference in color to be readable. I don’t exactly know what “20% difference” means, but it seem like there’s enough room to add more colors that are at least that much different than each other. If that were the case, it seems like you’d be able to print multiple QR codes on top of each other and read each one independently based on color. Is that at all possible? Assistant: Industrial Barcode Readers are normally only using gray scale images because the sensors are only gray scale. Difference in color is only recogniced by changing the Illumination. And there are colored 2D Codes with high data density already: https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/JAB-Code
Human: Can QR codes be stacked on top of each other in different colors? My understanding is that QR codes need at least a 20% difference in color to be readable. I don’t exactly know what “20% difference” means, but it seem like there’s enough room to add more colors that are at least that much different than each other. If that were the case, it seems like you’d be able to print multiple QR codes on top of each other and read each one independently based on color. Is that at all possible? Assistant: Before CAD took over, we used to lay out 2-layer circuit boards using red and blue tape, then the layers were separated using red and blue filters. So I bet it could be done.
Human: How to design an ambient cooling system (closed water circle) Hi, I am looking for some general information on how to design cooling systems. Since I don't have any experience in control engineering a webpage or book teaching the basics would be really appreciated. The task itself is pretty straight forward : - single heat source that produces constant heat (1000W) - closed water circle necessary (stand alone device) - Ambient cooling with radiator - temperature at heat source should be cooled down and hold at 30°C - temperature range at heat source should not exceed +-0.5 degree So, here is the catch: The temperature at the heat source should be the same every day, no matter if its 45°C or 15°C outside. So, how would I start regulating this? Over flow volume or cooling fan speed? Or should I use a cooling compressor (like in a fridge) and try to keep the water-basin at a constant temperature? Anyway, thanks for reading. If you guy can help me that would be great. Or just point me in the general direction where I can learn and understand this issue myself. :) Assistant: I think you're approaching this from the wrong perspective. To hold that tight of a mechanical tolerance (desired temp) with the cooling system would be difficult. Why not design the cooling loop to accommodate the median scenario, and then use an electrical temperature compensation circuit to account for temp changes in your measurement. It would keep the overall system much less expensive and you would have a higher accuracy with temp compensation (assuming you chose components correctly).
Human: How to design an ambient cooling system (closed water circle) Hi, I am looking for some general information on how to design cooling systems. Since I don't have any experience in control engineering a webpage or book teaching the basics would be really appreciated. The task itself is pretty straight forward : - single heat source that produces constant heat (1000W) - closed water circle necessary (stand alone device) - Ambient cooling with radiator - temperature at heat source should be cooled down and hold at 30°C - temperature range at heat source should not exceed +-0.5 degree So, here is the catch: The temperature at the heat source should be the same every day, no matter if its 45°C or 15°C outside. So, how would I start regulating this? Over flow volume or cooling fan speed? Or should I use a cooling compressor (like in a fridge) and try to keep the water-basin at a constant temperature? Anyway, thanks for reading. If you guy can help me that would be great. Or just point me in the general direction where I can learn and understand this issue myself. :) Assistant: Description sounds very much like an internal combustion engine so I'd imagine the most effective method of temp regulation would be water loop through a radiator with a mechanical thermostat to operate a fan.
Human: Is a body of water considered an impervious surface? For stormwater management calculations. Assistant: Usually impervious because the stormwater doesn't infiltrate.
Human: Is a body of water considered an impervious surface? For stormwater management calculations. Assistant: For stromwater runoff calculations it is
Human: How does the mathematical relation of Power = Torque * Angular Velocity and the principle of gear ratios relate in the real world? So I completely understand the mathematics behind gear ratios and the relationship between power, torque and rpm. For a simple 2 gear system, the ratio is equal to the number of teeth of the output over the input or the rpm of the input over the output etc. And from a mathematics stand point, it's easy to see that torque is inversely proportional to rpm. However, I'm trying to wrap my head around how these phenomena work in the real world, in terms of a car pulling away in first gear from a stop, or how initially pedalling a bicycle is easier in first gear as opposed to sixth or seventh gear. However, I want to physically understand what is going on rather than just someone say, it's because of the formula for power showing that torque is inversely proportional to rpm. I want to know how reducing rpm physically increases torque when talking about the gearing system in a car or a bicycle. For this case, I will use the bicycle as the real world example to try get across my guess as to how this happens, and hopefully someone can correct me. The only explanation I can think of is this; Imagine a case where your bicycle is in first gear, and for example, (just plucking random numbers here), the crank gear has 10 teeth, while the first gear on the rear wheel has 100 teeth, and the radius of this 100 tooth gear is 100mm, obviously this gives an extreme ratio of 10:1, so output rpm is greatly reduced, and therefore mathematically, torque output increases too. Now, imagine putting the bike in 6th gear, this gear has 25 teeth with a radius of 25mm, giving a ratio of 2.5:1, increasing rpm but reducing torque. Now, where does this increase in torque from putting the bike in first gear come from? Is it simply from the case that torque is the product of the normal component of a force and the distance it acts on about a point, therefore the torque acting on the rear axle to move that rear wheel which it is connected to is equal to the force from the chain pushing the gear teeth forwards multiplied by the radius of the selected output gear the chain is attached to? And since first gear has a larger radius, it will produce a larger torque that will make it much easier to pedal from a stationary start where a greater force is needed to overcome static friction ie Newton's first law of motion. Is there any sort of accuracy in my assumptions here or am I completely barking up the wrong tree? Assistant: Imagine you replace all of the gears with a ring of levers pushing or getting pushed one at a time. Driving a big gear to spin a shaft is just like trying to lift something with a crowbar. The gears and chains just let you keep going. So yes, larger gear is more torque.
Human: How does the mathematical relation of Power = Torque * Angular Velocity and the principle of gear ratios relate in the real world? So I completely understand the mathematics behind gear ratios and the relationship between power, torque and rpm. For a simple 2 gear system, the ratio is equal to the number of teeth of the output over the input or the rpm of the input over the output etc. And from a mathematics stand point, it's easy to see that torque is inversely proportional to rpm. However, I'm trying to wrap my head around how these phenomena work in the real world, in terms of a car pulling away in first gear from a stop, or how initially pedalling a bicycle is easier in first gear as opposed to sixth or seventh gear. However, I want to physically understand what is going on rather than just someone say, it's because of the formula for power showing that torque is inversely proportional to rpm. I want to know how reducing rpm physically increases torque when talking about the gearing system in a car or a bicycle. For this case, I will use the bicycle as the real world example to try get across my guess as to how this happens, and hopefully someone can correct me. The only explanation I can think of is this; Imagine a case where your bicycle is in first gear, and for example, (just plucking random numbers here), the crank gear has 10 teeth, while the first gear on the rear wheel has 100 teeth, and the radius of this 100 tooth gear is 100mm, obviously this gives an extreme ratio of 10:1, so output rpm is greatly reduced, and therefore mathematically, torque output increases too. Now, imagine putting the bike in 6th gear, this gear has 25 teeth with a radius of 25mm, giving a ratio of 2.5:1, increasing rpm but reducing torque. Now, where does this increase in torque from putting the bike in first gear come from? Is it simply from the case that torque is the product of the normal component of a force and the distance it acts on about a point, therefore the torque acting on the rear axle to move that rear wheel which it is connected to is equal to the force from the chain pushing the gear teeth forwards multiplied by the radius of the selected output gear the chain is attached to? And since first gear has a larger radius, it will produce a larger torque that will make it much easier to pedal from a stationary start where a greater force is needed to overcome static friction ie Newton's first law of motion. Is there any sort of accuracy in my assumptions here or am I completely barking up the wrong tree? Assistant: The increase in torque simply comes from the increase in radius. T=Fr. The physical benefit of this torque is that it allows higher acceleration (T=Ga) for starting off, but of course that comes at the expense of a lower top speed, hence why you change gears and end up cruising with acceleration = 0 and little torque to overcome resistance.
Human: Why muffin trays aren't made using draw-forming by pressing metal against a die? I'm having a hard time understanding why a manufacturer would choose a complex process for such a simple thing as a muffin baking tray. As the pictures show, each of the cups have been formed separately and then welded on to the tray with holes punched in it. That's a multi-step process as opposed to just pressing the metal sheet against a die, just like aluminum cans are made? muffin tray bottom view muffin tray top view Assistant: I have some that are pressed from one sheet and they fucking suck. Some of the muffins aren’t done and some are burnt I don’t know why. But the ones I have that are made in a multi step process are way better and give an even heating. You don’t even need the paper cups for the ones I have they just pop right out without tearing
Human: Why muffin trays aren't made using draw-forming by pressing metal against a die? I'm having a hard time understanding why a manufacturer would choose a complex process for such a simple thing as a muffin baking tray. As the pictures show, each of the cups have been formed separately and then welded on to the tray with holes punched in it. That's a multi-step process as opposed to just pressing the metal sheet against a die, just like aluminum cans are made? muffin tray bottom view muffin tray top view Assistant: My best guess would be maintain a more uniform material thickness. Not only would the cups be more thinner than the tray, individual cups could have different thicknesses depending on where they're located in the tray. The raw sheet metal stock for the tray might be 20 gauge (0.036") and the the material for the cups 16 gauge (0.060"). When the cup is drawn out (lets assume 2x) it would result in a similar thickness to the tray.
Human: This may not be the place to ask, but can anyone help me with a woodworking project? http://imgur.com/gallery/LfYh7jm I've been trying to figure this project out for a while now but can't seem to make it work, no matter how many trials I do. This started because I just wanted a giant wooden hand to wear, but it's a lot harder than I thought. I've tried attaching a line to each joint, and just to the ends, but neither achieves the results I'm wanting. I tried r/woodworking so I'm trying here on a whim, so if this isnt the right place, I'd appreciate if someone could point me in the right direction. Assistant: Springs my dude! There's nothing to oppose the closing tension on the hands. You might also want to make it so the fingers can't bend backwards by making the joins 90 degree edges on the top part but curved on the bottom so they can still grip.
Human: This may not be the place to ask, but can anyone help me with a woodworking project? http://imgur.com/gallery/LfYh7jm I've been trying to figure this project out for a while now but can't seem to make it work, no matter how many trials I do. This started because I just wanted a giant wooden hand to wear, but it's a lot harder than I thought. I've tried attaching a line to each joint, and just to the ends, but neither achieves the results I'm wanting. I tried r/woodworking so I'm trying here on a whim, so if this isnt the right place, I'd appreciate if someone could point me in the right direction. Assistant: This design for a 3D-printed forearm/elbow supported prosthetic might be relevant for your project
Human: Is it okay to use steel cable instead of a tree branch to support a "porch" swing? Howdy! I want to hang a porch swing at my new place and there are some challenges, position-wise. I'm planning on using steel cable suspended pretty tightly between the trunk of the pine tree and a false-front wall above my garage. I'm going to go around the tree trunk (with some padding/abrasion resistance for both the tree and the cable) and then to a shouldered 1/2" x 10" eye bolt through the cinder block wall. The pull is going to be near horizontal on both ends, naturally. I'll use a giant turnbuckle to keep it mostly tight. Then, a little closer to the tree side on the cable, I'll hang the chair from the provided chains. I'm looking at 3/8" for-lifting braided cable from McMaster. I feel the most uncertain about the cable. Think this is likely to catastrophically fail and kill everyone on the block? Thanks! Assistant: Don't do it. The mechanical advantage pulling perpendicular on a taut steel cable is very high. Let's say your cable is 10 degrees from horizontal on each end, and your swing plus the people on it weigh \~400lb, the tension in the cable will be \~1200 lb. Walls aren't designed for loads like this. The tighter (more horizontal) the cable, the higher the tension. For a perfectly tight rigid cable the tension is infinite.
Human: Is it okay to use steel cable instead of a tree branch to support a "porch" swing? Howdy! I want to hang a porch swing at my new place and there are some challenges, position-wise. I'm planning on using steel cable suspended pretty tightly between the trunk of the pine tree and a false-front wall above my garage. I'm going to go around the tree trunk (with some padding/abrasion resistance for both the tree and the cable) and then to a shouldered 1/2" x 10" eye bolt through the cinder block wall. The pull is going to be near horizontal on both ends, naturally. I'll use a giant turnbuckle to keep it mostly tight. Then, a little closer to the tree side on the cable, I'll hang the chair from the provided chains. I'm looking at 3/8" for-lifting braided cable from McMaster. I feel the most uncertain about the cable. Think this is likely to catastrophically fail and kill everyone on the block? Thanks! Assistant: Keep in mind that the closer the top cable gets to horizontal, the more force it will exert on the anchor points in order to hold up the swing. Depending on how little slack you have in that top cable, it could end up tensioned to several times the weight of the swing and users.
Human: I'm experimenting with steel tumbling media, is there any risk of fire? I'm experimenting with using dry steel media (cheap nails) in a tumbler. My first trial created a significant amount of fine metal powder, which concerns me because (as I understand it): 1) Powders can be an explosion hazard 2) Powdered metal can burn 3) Steel media is considered to be "sparking" media, and shouldn't be used to grind things like gunpowder Is it dangerous to continue these tests? I did some googling and I couldn't find any clear answers. Assistant: Toss some aluminum in the mix and you’ve got yourself a nice thermite generator.
Human: I'm experimenting with steel tumbling media, is there any risk of fire? I'm experimenting with using dry steel media (cheap nails) in a tumbler. My first trial created a significant amount of fine metal powder, which concerns me because (as I understand it): 1) Powders can be an explosion hazard 2) Powdered metal can burn 3) Steel media is considered to be "sparking" media, and shouldn't be used to grind things like gunpowder Is it dangerous to continue these tests? I did some googling and I couldn't find any clear answers. Assistant: We've always used scrap steel plugs from the punch in our big deburring tumbler style machines. I always thought that was common industry practice. Never been a problem.
Human: How to determine a proper torque for a screw? Sorry if this question has been asked before. I'm a young engineer being given a task and just seeking for help. My manager asked me to determine a proper torque for a 1/4" - 20, Grade 8 zinc plated screw. From my research the recommended torque is 108 - 122 in-lb. My question are: - I could reach the recommended torque range if I really try. But I'm questioning if I need that much of torque though? Because I feel like I overtighten the part. - In production, the screw will be installed using a DeWalt 796 screw gun. I looked up the user manual and it doesn't state the specific torque range for each speed settings. Is there a way for me to figure out how much torque is yielded from a setting? Thanks for your help. Assistant: Others have provided good info on determining the torque you need, but I have some comments for your assembly: Those drills are wildly inaccurate for setting a specific torque, even how fast you spin it matters because the chuck has a fair bit of inertia. Better to get it mostly tight with the drill, then use a torque wrench to confirm it’s to spec. There are vendors like Atlas Copco who sell drivers that can hit accurate torque values, up to you to decide if that’s worth it though.
Human: How to determine a proper torque for a screw? Sorry if this question has been asked before. I'm a young engineer being given a task and just seeking for help. My manager asked me to determine a proper torque for a 1/4" - 20, Grade 8 zinc plated screw. From my research the recommended torque is 108 - 122 in-lb. My question are: - I could reach the recommended torque range if I really try. But I'm questioning if I need that much of torque though? Because I feel like I overtighten the part. - In production, the screw will be installed using a DeWalt 796 screw gun. I looked up the user manual and it doesn't state the specific torque range for each speed settings. Is there a way for me to figure out how much torque is yielded from a setting? Thanks for your help. Assistant: You could do a flange design like they probably showed you in machine design. You need to know what the flange is holding (pressure, separating forces , etc) then you get thickness and materials of the different components. Apply all the factors and calculate the torque that way. Another really good source that any mechanical designer should have is the Machinery Handbook. That thing would help you 99% of the time. Buy a paper copy.
Human: So yea, F-1 jobs are super competitive, what about other jobs in motorsports? Anyone work for Sports car manufacturer or any kind of racing team??? Assistant: F1 probably makes up 1% of the motrosports jobs. Every manufacturer has proving grounds, factory teams, etc. There are also hundreds of small racing teams, custom part designers, etc. All I will say is you better be ready to eat, sleep, and breath racing for pretty meh pay and exhausting 80 hour weeks. What have you done to get yourself trained, experienced, and ready for that challenge? If you didnt do FSAE in school, count yourself out already.
Human: So yea, F-1 jobs are super competitive, what about other jobs in motorsports? Anyone work for Sports car manufacturer or any kind of racing team??? Assistant: Thought you meant F-1 Visa.
Human: If you could choose between doing a co-op in china or japan, which would you choose and why? Assistant: Japan. China's full of sketchy, rude people. japanese culture is 10000x better. There's a reason you dont see a lot of Japanese immigrants in America. Everyone comes here to study, and moves back to live.
Human: If you could choose between doing a co-op in china or japan, which would you choose and why? Assistant: Based on news of engineers being held in China without bail for over a year, I'd stay the hell out of that country. http://news.yahoo.com/ap-exclusive-us-scientist-trapped-china-075057518.html
Human: Question regarding the prevalence of coveralls in the industry, and their pain points. Hello everyone! I'm an apparel design student, developing a project that aims to improve workwear - placing specific focus on the coverall (jumpsuit), as it pertains to the Engineering space. I am led to believe that current coverall offerings are archaic in terms of design / construction / fabric and do not completely respond to the ergonomic and performance needs of the wearer. I believe that workwear should serve the wearer, in the way that sportswear serves the athlete. Further developments must be made to optimise the garments in terms of comfortability, functionality, safety and durability. It is my understanding that coveralls are ubiquitous in a vast number of industries and spaces (Automotive, Construction, Oil & Gas, Chemical Engineering, Maintenance etc.). It's hard to believe that the coverall, responsible for equipping workers that are constructing the foundation of our surroundings, has received such little development. I'm familiar with the offerings of industry leaders (Dickies, Duluth, Red Kap, Carhartt, etc.) and feel that there is room for significant innovation. I aim to bring the quality of fabric / construction / durability etc. of an Arc'teryx piece, into the workwear space. I'm in the early stages of the project and am keen to understand more about the coverall, in terms of it's prevalence in the field (I'm aware that prevalence may vary drastically, depending on the specialty) and how adequately it responds to the demands of work. It'd be so helpful to receive insight as to possible pain points of the uniform, in day to day usage (for ex. - ventilation, garment fit, comfort, durability). Any feedback would be very beneficial and greatly appreciated. Writing from Canada, but interested in the US / EU industry. Thank you! R Assistant: Gusset crotch!!
Human: Question regarding the prevalence of coveralls in the industry, and their pain points. Hello everyone! I'm an apparel design student, developing a project that aims to improve workwear - placing specific focus on the coverall (jumpsuit), as it pertains to the Engineering space. I am led to believe that current coverall offerings are archaic in terms of design / construction / fabric and do not completely respond to the ergonomic and performance needs of the wearer. I believe that workwear should serve the wearer, in the way that sportswear serves the athlete. Further developments must be made to optimise the garments in terms of comfortability, functionality, safety and durability. It is my understanding that coveralls are ubiquitous in a vast number of industries and spaces (Automotive, Construction, Oil & Gas, Chemical Engineering, Maintenance etc.). It's hard to believe that the coverall, responsible for equipping workers that are constructing the foundation of our surroundings, has received such little development. I'm familiar with the offerings of industry leaders (Dickies, Duluth, Red Kap, Carhartt, etc.) and feel that there is room for significant innovation. I aim to bring the quality of fabric / construction / durability etc. of an Arc'teryx piece, into the workwear space. I'm in the early stages of the project and am keen to understand more about the coverall, in terms of it's prevalence in the field (I'm aware that prevalence may vary drastically, depending on the specialty) and how adequately it responds to the demands of work. It'd be so helpful to receive insight as to possible pain points of the uniform, in day to day usage (for ex. - ventilation, garment fit, comfort, durability). Any feedback would be very beneficial and greatly appreciated. Writing from Canada, but interested in the US / EU industry. Thank you! R Assistant: I wore them offshore on rigs Just make sure they’re fitted right and you’re good
Human: Calling all engineers: "Sell" me your job! I feel that in this subreddit, we often see people contemplating if a career in engineering is right for them. As a change of pace, I want to try and change that (if only for a few hours). I'd like to request **YOU** to "sell" me your current position. What makes your role the perfect fit for you? Why is the your current area of expertise so interesting? What new technologies and breakthroughs make your future something that all other engineers should envy? Don't skimp on the enthusiasm please! Assistant: I primarily write firmware for a Bluetooth powered bike lock. But our team is highly cross-discipline, and I have a mixed EE/ME background. One four hour period of work could find me coding, soldering, designing a motor test jig in autocad and printing that jig on a makerbot. I fucking love my job.
Human: Calling all engineers: "Sell" me your job! I feel that in this subreddit, we often see people contemplating if a career in engineering is right for them. As a change of pace, I want to try and change that (if only for a few hours). I'd like to request **YOU** to "sell" me your current position. What makes your role the perfect fit for you? Why is the your current area of expertise so interesting? What new technologies and breakthroughs make your future something that all other engineers should envy? Don't skimp on the enthusiasm please! Assistant: Semiconductor manufacturing. Very interesting/complex/diverse manufacturing processes, extremely fast paced, high risk, etc Going to work is exciting - I'm not stuck in a cubicle all day (probably about 60% of my time in the cube - the rest out in the field). Also the pay/benefits are excellent - average engineer will break six figures within a few years.
Human: Why are rockets preferred to giant cannons in sending vehicles into space? Assistant: They are not always preferable. I have a plan to launch all politicians into space using canons.
Human: Why are rockets preferred to giant cannons in sending vehicles into space? Assistant: Gas guns can work, but it's a matter of the delta V. Guns tend to expend MOST of their energy very quickly; the projectile has a VERY high G-force thrust upon it. This can be counteracted, but the barrel length must be VERY long for it to achieve escape velocity before the acceleration stops. Rockets can spread out that acceleration. More likely for the cargo to survive.
Human: How useful is Latex for engineers in industry? How useful is latex for practicing engineers in industry (rather than academia)? I submitted a fairly long report and I needed to format it to follow the formatting guidelines. MS Word was horrible in doing that which ended up in my submitting something not as good as I was hoping for. I heard that Latex, although has a bit of a steep learning curve, is really good at producing PDFs. Do practicing engineers find a problem with MS Word and do you think Latex would be useful even though you might work in teams who have different opinions about the text editor? Assistant: Nobody uses Latex in engineering.
Human: How useful is Latex for engineers in industry? How useful is latex for practicing engineers in industry (rather than academia)? I submitted a fairly long report and I needed to format it to follow the formatting guidelines. MS Word was horrible in doing that which ended up in my submitting something not as good as I was hoping for. I heard that Latex, although has a bit of a steep learning curve, is really good at producing PDFs. Do practicing engineers find a problem with MS Word and do you think Latex would be useful even though you might work in teams who have different opinions about the text editor? Assistant: You should use pandoc, which is easier/simpler with Markdown-based syntax but still lets you generate the final output with LaTeX and include equations. This is also nice for version control with systems like git since it's all text based, unlike MS Word's binary blobs.
Human: Need help understanding Tube/pipe scheduling (need thinest wall possible) I am trying to order 0.75in (19mm) OD tube with the thinest wall thickness reasonably available. I found 0.028" on grainger. I would like to know if there are charts available showing OD and WALL. I want the thinest i can find, maybe 0.010"... Thanks for the help. I know what I want, just not how to ask the question. Assistant: There is an app on the appstore/play store by a mob called MRC GLOBAL. I use it every day at work for these exact problems. Has all the relevant standards including pipe schedules and their OD/ID/WT etc. Give it a look! 🙃
Human: Need help understanding Tube/pipe scheduling (need thinest wall possible) I am trying to order 0.75in (19mm) OD tube with the thinest wall thickness reasonably available. I found 0.028" on grainger. I would like to know if there are charts available showing OD and WALL. I want the thinest i can find, maybe 0.010"... Thanks for the help. I know what I want, just not how to ask the question. Assistant: https://www.mcmaster.com/standard-metal-tubing It isn't cheap, but there is a 0.75" OD with a .02" wall thickness there.
Human: Improving Heat Transfer Between Iron and Aluminum (Internal Combustion Engine) Hey Engineers! I've always enjoyed engineering, probably should have went to school for it (Did CS instead). I enjoy working on my vehicles, specifically improving reliability\durability\performance\efficiency. When I take on a project, I tend to over do it, to the point where I re-engineer certain aspects of it. That is where I find myself today. I have a late 80s, air\oil cooled, 4-stroke motorcycle engine that is my current focus. I am increasing the displacement from 600 to about 650cc. The motor has 4 cylinders, 2 valves per cylinder and I am worried about getting rid of the excess heat created from the increased displacement. In increasing the bore, I have determined that it makes the most sense to replace the iron cylinder sleeves as opposed to boring the originals. These new iron sleeves will be interference fit into an aluminum block. I am looking to improve the heat transfer between these iron cylinder sleeves and the aluminum cylinder block. I know thermal compounds like arctic silver improve heat transfer by filling in the microscopic peaks and valleys between the two materials. Arctic silver would not be appropriate in this case due to the interference fit & the temperatures involved. Besides attempting to achieve a mirror finish on both the exterior of the iron cylinder sleeve and the interior of the aluminum bore, is there anything else that can be done to improve the heat transfer? Thanks in advance! Assistant: I would not mess with them at all, most cylinder sleeves are pressed in generally with a temperature difference (cold sleeve and hot block) to get a nice tight fit. If you go in and start screwing around in there like polishing the interfaces you might remove enough material that your nice tight fit is gone. it is only 50cc, so for shits and giggles lets say you make 100 hp at 600cc you are only talking about making 108hp with the extra displacement.
Human: Improving Heat Transfer Between Iron and Aluminum (Internal Combustion Engine) Hey Engineers! I've always enjoyed engineering, probably should have went to school for it (Did CS instead). I enjoy working on my vehicles, specifically improving reliability\durability\performance\efficiency. When I take on a project, I tend to over do it, to the point where I re-engineer certain aspects of it. That is where I find myself today. I have a late 80s, air\oil cooled, 4-stroke motorcycle engine that is my current focus. I am increasing the displacement from 600 to about 650cc. The motor has 4 cylinders, 2 valves per cylinder and I am worried about getting rid of the excess heat created from the increased displacement. In increasing the bore, I have determined that it makes the most sense to replace the iron cylinder sleeves as opposed to boring the originals. These new iron sleeves will be interference fit into an aluminum block. I am looking to improve the heat transfer between these iron cylinder sleeves and the aluminum cylinder block. I know thermal compounds like arctic silver improve heat transfer by filling in the microscopic peaks and valleys between the two materials. Arctic silver would not be appropriate in this case due to the interference fit & the temperatures involved. Besides attempting to achieve a mirror finish on both the exterior of the iron cylinder sleeve and the interior of the aluminum bore, is there anything else that can be done to improve the heat transfer? Thanks in advance! Assistant: There are a whole bunch of different thermal pastes for a variety of applications. Chromerics is one company that makes quite a few. From what I can tell a thermal paste sounds like your best bet.
Human: What is the nature of knowledge that Lockheed (for eg.) has about manufacturing military aircraft (for eg.) that no one else can replicate? As an engineer-by-degree but not-even-close by training (a product India is famous for producing), I was fascinated to learn about how it requires decades of in-house knowledge (and a ton of sustained funding) to make extreme machines like jet engines and military aircraft. This was driven home by this Quora answer : https://www.quora.com/Why-does-India-not-use-reverse-engineering-to-build-weapons-instead-of-buying/answer/Toms-Thomas > Imagine you are the head of the engineering team responsible for getting the Soviet copy of the Nene operational, you report directly to the Beloved, Fearless, Doston ka Dost, Dushmanon ka Dushman, Dear Leader Uncle Stalin— an experience no sane person looks forward to. > > These are the questions your team, meaning you, must answer:- > If a fitting is built with a clearance of 5mm from the surrounding components, why is it 5mm, why not 2mm? or 20mm? What is the rationale here? > >What is this hole for? Its not on any of the other engines. Manufacturing error? Something specific to this engine? Something missed on the other engines? > >Hmm, the guys at the lathe station tell me they cannot grind the axle to the tolerances we need for the primary compressor spool, lazy shirkers! Perhaps a few months in a holiday resort in Siberia will make them more enthusiastic. > >How did the Brits bend these feed pipes to such precision, every time we try it, the pipe cracks, or kinks, or both, it can’t be hot forged, the cross section would distort, it can’t be cold worked, its too brittle for that. How did you do it Mr. Cripps? > >We still can’t get the first stage compressor disk to spool up to XXXX rpm without cracking, we have replicated the British design to the micrometer and still the damn thing keeps flying apart, what kind of heat treatment did they apply during fabrication? So I wanted to ask you experienced engineers : what is the answer like? what form does it take? Is it like a formula that academic literature can never hope to discover? Is it like a specific material ratio that works for no known reason? Is it like a design that is ridiculously complicated that no genius in their spare time could come up with? Or is it something so breathtakingly simple that is nevertheless so counter-inbuitive that no one could derive from public-domain engineering knowledge? The problem is, I have never done any real engineering creation (unless you can count a few thousand lines of trivial code), but I have dabbled in research (masters in computational engineering). So I don't know what very complex and difficult engineering knowledge looks like, other than a hard research paper on, say, numerical solution of stochastic stiff partial differential equations, with hundreds of theorems from topology. That's the scariest thing I can think of. Assistant: Lockheed Martin's big data set is the telephone numbers of senators and generals.
Human: What is the nature of knowledge that Lockheed (for eg.) has about manufacturing military aircraft (for eg.) that no one else can replicate? As an engineer-by-degree but not-even-close by training (a product India is famous for producing), I was fascinated to learn about how it requires decades of in-house knowledge (and a ton of sustained funding) to make extreme machines like jet engines and military aircraft. This was driven home by this Quora answer : https://www.quora.com/Why-does-India-not-use-reverse-engineering-to-build-weapons-instead-of-buying/answer/Toms-Thomas > Imagine you are the head of the engineering team responsible for getting the Soviet copy of the Nene operational, you report directly to the Beloved, Fearless, Doston ka Dost, Dushmanon ka Dushman, Dear Leader Uncle Stalin— an experience no sane person looks forward to. > > These are the questions your team, meaning you, must answer:- > If a fitting is built with a clearance of 5mm from the surrounding components, why is it 5mm, why not 2mm? or 20mm? What is the rationale here? > >What is this hole for? Its not on any of the other engines. Manufacturing error? Something specific to this engine? Something missed on the other engines? > >Hmm, the guys at the lathe station tell me they cannot grind the axle to the tolerances we need for the primary compressor spool, lazy shirkers! Perhaps a few months in a holiday resort in Siberia will make them more enthusiastic. > >How did the Brits bend these feed pipes to such precision, every time we try it, the pipe cracks, or kinks, or both, it can’t be hot forged, the cross section would distort, it can’t be cold worked, its too brittle for that. How did you do it Mr. Cripps? > >We still can’t get the first stage compressor disk to spool up to XXXX rpm without cracking, we have replicated the British design to the micrometer and still the damn thing keeps flying apart, what kind of heat treatment did they apply during fabrication? So I wanted to ask you experienced engineers : what is the answer like? what form does it take? Is it like a formula that academic literature can never hope to discover? Is it like a specific material ratio that works for no known reason? Is it like a design that is ridiculously complicated that no genius in their spare time could come up with? Or is it something so breathtakingly simple that is nevertheless so counter-inbuitive that no one could derive from public-domain engineering knowledge? The problem is, I have never done any real engineering creation (unless you can count a few thousand lines of trivial code), but I have dabbled in research (masters in computational engineering). So I don't know what very complex and difficult engineering knowledge looks like, other than a hard research paper on, say, numerical solution of stochastic stiff partial differential equations, with hundreds of theorems from topology. That's the scariest thing I can think of. Assistant: Imagine entire libraries of books that no one outside of the company has access to.
Human: If I wanted to focus on robotics, would an Electrical Engineering degree be the best path to head down? Assistant: IMO, for undergrad, it depends on what kind of system on a robot you want to work on: To build the chassis and how the mechanical pieces fit together, mechanical engineering. To build the power systems, the control systems, and the sensors systems, electrical engineering. To make the robot smart and do the stuff you want it to do, computer science.engineering. At the graduate level, you can actually specialize in robotics.
Human: If I wanted to focus on robotics, would an Electrical Engineering degree be the best path to head down? Assistant: What school are you looking at? In my school robotics was part of the EE department. But's it's an in-between thing. Look for the professors that specialize in robotics, and see what department they teach in. If you can't find professors specializing in robotics, consider a different school.
Human: When did you start studying for the PE? How rigorous? I recently passed the FE and I'll be graduating soon. Of course I'm not going to start studying now, but just wanted a ballpark figure of when others started, how much they studied, and how much it helped. I passed FE Civil and will most likely be taking the transportation option PE. Assistant: I reviewed for about 3 months, doing 30 minute problems each weeknight and 2 hour sessions on weekends. Mainly you'll be re-acquainting yourself with other engineering disciplines since you'll likely be proficient at whatever your main discipline is.
Human: When did you start studying for the PE? How rigorous? I recently passed the FE and I'll be graduating soon. Of course I'm not going to start studying now, but just wanted a ballpark figure of when others started, how much they studied, and how much it helped. I passed FE Civil and will most likely be taking the transportation option PE. Assistant: My coworkers swear by School of PE.
Human: Circuit Schematics (Software Question) I am studying mechatronics and starting to do my own projects where I am compiling them into a portfolio. One of the things I am doing is drawing up my own circuit schematics, and was wondering what options are out there? There is a popular engineering channel, where they posted this video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHWXZyfhQas At 8:40, there is a clip of a schematic diagram, and was wondering if anyone knew which software this is? I am familiar/comfortable with AutoCAD, Solidworks, and SketchUp, but was still looking into different options. I really appreciate any input. Assistant: It's fusion360, which seems like the worst program to do electrical schematics in: https://help.autodesk.com/view/fusion360/ENU/courses/AP-HOW-TO-CREATE-SCHEMATIC Don't use that if you want to make a schematic. Learn how to use KiCad and never look back.
Human: Circuit Schematics (Software Question) I am studying mechatronics and starting to do my own projects where I am compiling them into a portfolio. One of the things I am doing is drawing up my own circuit schematics, and was wondering what options are out there? There is a popular engineering channel, where they posted this video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHWXZyfhQas At 8:40, there is a clip of a schematic diagram, and was wondering if anyone knew which software this is? I am familiar/comfortable with AutoCAD, Solidworks, and SketchUp, but was still looking into different options. I really appreciate any input. Assistant: Unless you've got a bunch of cash to spend, Kicad is your best bet. In some ways it's actually better than the "professional" options, IMO.
Human: How much would a water tank Increase in temperature if painted black? I work on a site with steel water tanks ranging from 30-60 m^3 (~8,000-16,000 gallons). We want a cheap and easy way to warm up the water, so we want to paint the tanks flat black. I need to show how much that’ll increase the water temperature in the tank. My thermodynamics is a little rusty so any help would be appreciated. I thought what I could do was look at the solar irradiance of the region (5 kWh/m2/Day), which reduces down to about 210 W/m^2 or 210 J/(s*m^2). I have the general dimensions of the tanks, so I take the average between the area of the profile with the area of the top of the tank, and that’s how many Joules/second it receives. The specific heat of water is 4.2J/g/°C, i.e. 4.2 joules of energy are required to raise the temperature of one gram of water by one degree centigrade. Energy required (kJ) = 4.2 x volume (litres) x temperature rise (°C) Assuming 5 good hours of sun a day, knowing the volume of the tanks, **and assuming an efficiency of 10%** I get the Δ°C of about 15. But I know I’m making a lot of assumptions here with the surface area of the tank exposed to the sun at any given time fluctuating, and that along with all the other assumptions led me to my 10% efficiency guesstimate. Please help me understand how to get closer to theoretical reality so I can have a more accurate calculation. This is not homework. This is real life. Assistant: I see a steel tank And I want it painted black No plain tanks any more I want them to turn black
Human: How much would a water tank Increase in temperature if painted black? I work on a site with steel water tanks ranging from 30-60 m^3 (~8,000-16,000 gallons). We want a cheap and easy way to warm up the water, so we want to paint the tanks flat black. I need to show how much that’ll increase the water temperature in the tank. My thermodynamics is a little rusty so any help would be appreciated. I thought what I could do was look at the solar irradiance of the region (5 kWh/m2/Day), which reduces down to about 210 W/m^2 or 210 J/(s*m^2). I have the general dimensions of the tanks, so I take the average between the area of the profile with the area of the top of the tank, and that’s how many Joules/second it receives. The specific heat of water is 4.2J/g/°C, i.e. 4.2 joules of energy are required to raise the temperature of one gram of water by one degree centigrade. Energy required (kJ) = 4.2 x volume (litres) x temperature rise (°C) Assuming 5 good hours of sun a day, knowing the volume of the tanks, **and assuming an efficiency of 10%** I get the Δ°C of about 15. But I know I’m making a lot of assumptions here with the surface area of the tank exposed to the sun at any given time fluctuating, and that along with all the other assumptions led me to my 10% efficiency guesstimate. Please help me understand how to get closer to theoretical reality so I can have a more accurate calculation. This is not homework. This is real life. Assistant: On an tangentially related note, black water tanks can be used as thermal masses to keep greenhouses warm in winter. Perhaps with painting black and a layer of air for thermal insulation you could get compounding heat over multiple days instead of having it cool during the night.
Human: Do the mods/answerers/askers of questions of this subreddit realise how important they are to armchair historians and those who wish to get better at what they "study?" You folks are genuinely amazing; I just want you to know this. In the last three or so years I have learnt a lot in big part due to this subreddit and sometimes it feels like the members here don't know that they enrich the lives of hundreds of thousands Assistant: I am in the STEM field and we have been told so much about how important science communication (making science easily accessible/understandable for the public) is and were even trained on how to use proper techniques for communicating about it. I feel that that's what you guys here essentially did with history, making it accessible for the general public and nonexperts, and I really wish we could replicate that with a science sub.
Human: Do the mods/answerers/askers of questions of this subreddit realise how important they are to armchair historians and those who wish to get better at what they "study?" You folks are genuinely amazing; I just want you to know this. In the last three or so years I have learnt a lot in big part due to this subreddit and sometimes it feels like the members here don't know that they enrich the lives of hundreds of thousands Assistant: This is the best subreddit. I have a huge list of book recommendations I add to when you guys mention them.
Human: Can someone explain why this sub was temporarily banned today? What made some dumbass admin decide to terminate an active sub with 1.3 million users? Assistant: Just commenting so in can tell my grandkids I once commented on /r/AskHistorians and it's wasn't deleted
Human: Can someone explain why this sub was temporarily banned today? What made some dumbass admin decide to terminate an active sub with 1.3 million users? Assistant: This is machine learning in action, the machines are learning. Source: I'm a professor in skynetology.
Human: Can the mods flair posts when the question has an acceptable answer? Don't know if this metapost is allowed. But I think flair would be popular. It's so depressing to click on a great question with a lot of responses to see them all deleted and no answer. Assistant: Honestly what annoys me most about seeing a thread with a bunch of deleted comments is not the fact that they're deleted but the fact that for some reason Reddit still counts deleted comments in the comments count. So I'll see a post with "100 comments" and think "Surely one of those must be an answer" only to find out that not one of those 100 comments actually exists. And unfortunately this is something Reddit itself needs to fix.
Human: Can the mods flair posts when the question has an acceptable answer? Don't know if this metapost is allowed. But I think flair would be popular. It's so depressing to click on a great question with a lot of responses to see them all deleted and no answer. Assistant: It’s really depressing to see a question that’s really intriguing either never get answered or get all responses deleted.
Human: [Meta] Does marketing questions as "GREAT QUESTION" subtlety bias which questions get answered? Does it make people feel uncomfortable because a question not marked can be implied as a average/below average question? I'm curious to see what everyone's thoughts are on this. Assistant: I do not believe the GQ flair generally increases the probability of being answered. Threads marked as "Great Questions" tend to be very complex and difficult to answer, which is by design. It's a rare redditor who has the simultaneous expertise and patience to write an answer to any given Great Question. Great Questions chosen as the monthly "Best Question" are usually unanswered by the time the contest is complete.
Human: [Meta] Does marketing questions as "GREAT QUESTION" subtlety bias which questions get answered? Does it make people feel uncomfortable because a question not marked can be implied as a average/below average question? I'm curious to see what everyone's thoughts are on this. Assistant: What is this question even asking? Can someone explain what this is about?
Human: AMA: I'm Garrett Ryan, author of NAKED STATUES, FAT GLADIATORS, AND WAR ELEPHANTS: FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ANCIENT GREEKS AND ROMANS. Ask me anything about my book! Hi everyone! I'm Dr. Garrett Ryan, AKA u/toldinstone. I'm a Roman historian, and I recently released my first popular book: Naked Statues, Fat Gladiators, and War Elephants: Frequently Asked Questions about the Ancient Greeks and Romans. In a series of short and (hopefully) humorous essays, the book answers 36 questions about the classical world that I've been asked over the years, both in the classroom and - in a few cases - here on AskHistorians. The questions range from practicalities ("Why didn't the Greeks or Romans wear pants?") to beliefs ("Did they believe in ghosts, monsters, and/or aliens?"), from leisure ("Did they jog or lift weights?") to warfare ("How were elephants used in battle?"), and from antiquity ("What happened to Alexander the Great's body?") to the present ("Can any families trace their ancestry back to the Greeks or Romans?"). You'll find the full list of questions in the table of contents on the Amazon preview. (The book sold out on the day of its release at both Amazon and bookstore.org. New shipments, however, are already on the way, and anyone who orders now will receive their book with only a slight delay. In the meantime, *Naked Statues* is available from other retailers (including Barnes & Noble) and as a Kindle e-book. You can also preorder the audiobook, which will be released on October 26.) Today, it will be my pleasure to answer any and every question you might have about the topics discussed in my book, about the process of writing it, or about my YouTube channel toldinstone. Ask me anything! Assistant: Out of the first triumvirate: Shag, Marry, Kill?
Human: AMA: I'm Garrett Ryan, author of NAKED STATUES, FAT GLADIATORS, AND WAR ELEPHANTS: FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ANCIENT GREEKS AND ROMANS. Ask me anything about my book! Hi everyone! I'm Dr. Garrett Ryan, AKA u/toldinstone. I'm a Roman historian, and I recently released my first popular book: Naked Statues, Fat Gladiators, and War Elephants: Frequently Asked Questions about the Ancient Greeks and Romans. In a series of short and (hopefully) humorous essays, the book answers 36 questions about the classical world that I've been asked over the years, both in the classroom and - in a few cases - here on AskHistorians. The questions range from practicalities ("Why didn't the Greeks or Romans wear pants?") to beliefs ("Did they believe in ghosts, monsters, and/or aliens?"), from leisure ("Did they jog or lift weights?") to warfare ("How were elephants used in battle?"), and from antiquity ("What happened to Alexander the Great's body?") to the present ("Can any families trace their ancestry back to the Greeks or Romans?"). You'll find the full list of questions in the table of contents on the Amazon preview. (The book sold out on the day of its release at both Amazon and bookstore.org. New shipments, however, are already on the way, and anyone who orders now will receive their book with only a slight delay. In the meantime, *Naked Statues* is available from other retailers (including Barnes & Noble) and as a Kindle e-book. You can also preorder the audiobook, which will be released on October 26.) Today, it will be my pleasure to answer any and every question you might have about the topics discussed in my book, about the process of writing it, or about my YouTube channel toldinstone. Ask me anything! Assistant: How do you deal with a major lack of primary literary sources during a lot of the time period/places? How much do you rely on writers from the period vs archeological data?
Human: Congratulations to the Winners of the /r/AskHistorians 'Best of 2016'! With the polls now closed, I am pleased to announce the winners of our 'Best of 2016' Contest here on /r/AskHistorians. Taking First Place is /u/sunagainstgold, who answered /u/LukeInTheSkyWith's question "Would a crew of a ship departing from Venice in the 14th century towards Middle East have any plans ready in case they encounter a leviathan on their route?". In Second Place is /u/robbyslaughter, for their response to /u/Skippy_McFitz's "Why is Liechtenstein?". Rounding out Third is /u/commiespaceinvader 's answer for /u/kenrot, to "Why is historical revisionism a crime in certain countries?". I'd like to be the first to congratulate the winners, the nominees, and extend a hearty thank you to everyone who contributed to /r/AskHistorians this past year! For previous 'Best Ofs', please check out our Wiki. Assistant: Aw sheesh. You people. Thank you. I am so glad you liked it, and I can't believe I have the privilege and honor to write for a forum *on reddit* that supports the amazing company of nominees from the individual months and from the year-end. me_irl
Human: Congratulations to the Winners of the /r/AskHistorians 'Best of 2016'! With the polls now closed, I am pleased to announce the winners of our 'Best of 2016' Contest here on /r/AskHistorians. Taking First Place is /u/sunagainstgold, who answered /u/LukeInTheSkyWith's question "Would a crew of a ship departing from Venice in the 14th century towards Middle East have any plans ready in case they encounter a leviathan on their route?". In Second Place is /u/robbyslaughter, for their response to /u/Skippy_McFitz's "Why is Liechtenstein?". Rounding out Third is /u/commiespaceinvader 's answer for /u/kenrot, to "Why is historical revisionism a crime in certain countries?". I'd like to be the first to congratulate the winners, the nominees, and extend a hearty thank you to everyone who contributed to /r/AskHistorians this past year! For previous 'Best Ofs', please check out our Wiki. Assistant: Congratulations to all the winners and nominees for being awesome and mega congrats to /u/sunagainstgold for consistently providing excellent answers to questions which seem on surface almost impossible to tackle. Like a question of someone who is super afraid od the ocean and wonders how the hell did people hundreds of years ago get on wooden ships and sailed away when there are totally monsters out there. If there is one place I can say this, it's here: 2016 was a great year! You're all AH-mazing.
Human: When was the last 'successful' annexation? Am I right in thinking it was India annexing Goa in 1961? By successful I mean UN recognized, and that it still lasts today Assistant: Would the Chinese annexation of Tibet count?
Human: When was the last 'successful' annexation? Am I right in thinking it was India annexing Goa in 1961? By successful I mean UN recognized, and that it still lasts today Assistant: Annexation of West Papua by Indonesia?
Human: Meta]100k users, Eternal September, Rules, Moderators, and a million other things. We are quickly approaching 100k users. This will make us one of the 125 largest subreddits on this site. This is going to present a few new challenges for us. Here they are with their answer. **1) Default status.** Askhistorians WILL NEVER BECOME A DEFAULT SUB IF WE HAVE ANY SAY SO. I believe the way we put it in moderator discussion was, "I would rather burn this sub to the ground than let it become a default sub." That was me, I said that, and everyone agreed. We have already set the system to not allow this sub to become part of the default set. **2) More posters** We recognize that there are more people posting here. Therefore we have a few things in place. Firstly, we will be contacting users we have singled out for their quality posting to become moderators. This will bring the team up to about 17 moderators. This will allow moderators to participate as well as moderate as it will take some of the stress off of them. Additionally we would like to direct you to [the Panel thread and the Quality Contributor thread. If you feel that you would like to receive flair or nominate someone for flair, feel free to use these links to nominate yourself or others. Additionally, more posters means more users unfamiliar with this subreddits rules and culture. So let me direct you again to OUR RULES as well as our GUIDELINES FOR RULES. Think of them like this, the Rules = Constitution, Clarification = The Laws. Both are enforceable, and will be. We also request that you view the POPULAR QUESTIONS thread before you ask. **3)Now we need to also make a few of our rules clear to you guys, again. These are the important rules** 1) 20 year rule. If it has occurred in the past twenty years, it is off limits pending moderator review. 2) NO RACISM, SEXISM, HOMOPHOBIA, OR OTHER BIGOTED BEHAVIOR I am so not kidding. Do not think you are being clever, we have many historians in this sub who actually specialize in racial, sexual, or gender history INCLUDING A MOD. We have had more than enough experience in recognizing the behavior. Yes, if you come here and post something racist and you are from one of the several racist or other biggoted subreddits, we will not only thoroughly thrash your propaganda, but we will also ban you. Yes, we will read through your posting history to see if you have a history of bigotry. 3) No soapboxing or speechifying. You hate America? Fine, go somewhere else. You a die hard college communist? Great. Go somewhere else. This is not the place to recruit, to rabble rouse, to instigate. At this point we have plenty of experience spotting that too. You will have your post removed. 4) Copy Pasting **ANY SOURCE** as your only way of posting, is VERBOTEN. People come here to receive quality, in depth analysis from historians, history students, and history buffs. Please assume the OP of the question isn't a complete moron and has googled for the answer. Additionally, this is /r/askhistorians, not /r/askgoogle. Yes, you can copy and paste a source and give a summary of that link and source, but simply throwing up a link or a wall of copied text is intellectually lazy and will result in the post being removed. 5) On topic, relevant humor only. No memes, advice animals, reaction gifs, or funny videos are allowed. The humor cannot be top tiered comments. Humor is allowed to stray more off topic in *meta threads only*. Jokes otherwise must be relevant, on topic, and hopefully funny. I personally hate puns. 6) Topic drift. The original Godwins Law stated that the longer a UseNet conversation went the more likely Hitler was to be brought up. It meant the thread was dead. Here we also avoid topic drift. A logical progression of topics being brought up is allowed, but please, don't let a thread on 19th Century agriculture end up about cow tipping. 7) Anecdotes are frowned upon. Unless you were there yourself at the event, its probably not a strong enough source. 8) If you are guessing, or you heard from something somewhere some time ago, don't bother. We will delete with extreme prejudice. 9) Wikipedia is the worst possible source you can use. Its acceptable at times, and in a pinch, but it really isn't a good source. If you couldn't use it in a paper, it probably wont work here. **4) Eternal~~kerri~~ September In light of the ever expanding number of users, of course there will be cries of Eternal September. The moderation team can only do so much. We need the user base to assist us by flagging violating posts as spam. We also want you to understand **we enforce rules here**. If you have a problem with the rules, address them to the moderation team, but Braveheart style speeches do not endear us to your plight (neither does calling us faggots after we ban you). The level of our enforcement and strictness of enforcement, as well as our patience is directly inverse to the level of chicanery in the sub. The more the rules are violated, the more people flagrantly violate them, the more people thumb their noses at the mods, the more likely we are to increase the intensity and harshness of our moderation. This is your sub, we just enforce the rules. If your fellow users cannot police themselves and you are not willing to assist in helping them understand they are violating the rules, then we will have to enforce the rules more and more strictly until we suck every bit of fun out of the sub. Assistant: Just wanted to chime in that I wholly support the benevolent rule of the mod despots. Some of the wilder places on reddit are filled to bursting with incorrigible fellows who refuse to have a civil discussion and prefer to have shouting matches than trade points. Just glad to have a place to be settled where I can read quality posts &and answer interesting questions.
Human: Meta]100k users, Eternal September, Rules, Moderators, and a million other things. We are quickly approaching 100k users. This will make us one of the 125 largest subreddits on this site. This is going to present a few new challenges for us. Here they are with their answer. **1) Default status.** Askhistorians WILL NEVER BECOME A DEFAULT SUB IF WE HAVE ANY SAY SO. I believe the way we put it in moderator discussion was, "I would rather burn this sub to the ground than let it become a default sub." That was me, I said that, and everyone agreed. We have already set the system to not allow this sub to become part of the default set. **2) More posters** We recognize that there are more people posting here. Therefore we have a few things in place. Firstly, we will be contacting users we have singled out for their quality posting to become moderators. This will bring the team up to about 17 moderators. This will allow moderators to participate as well as moderate as it will take some of the stress off of them. Additionally we would like to direct you to [the Panel thread and the Quality Contributor thread. If you feel that you would like to receive flair or nominate someone for flair, feel free to use these links to nominate yourself or others. Additionally, more posters means more users unfamiliar with this subreddits rules and culture. So let me direct you again to OUR RULES as well as our GUIDELINES FOR RULES. Think of them like this, the Rules = Constitution, Clarification = The Laws. Both are enforceable, and will be. We also request that you view the POPULAR QUESTIONS thread before you ask. **3)Now we need to also make a few of our rules clear to you guys, again. These are the important rules** 1) 20 year rule. If it has occurred in the past twenty years, it is off limits pending moderator review. 2) NO RACISM, SEXISM, HOMOPHOBIA, OR OTHER BIGOTED BEHAVIOR I am so not kidding. Do not think you are being clever, we have many historians in this sub who actually specialize in racial, sexual, or gender history INCLUDING A MOD. We have had more than enough experience in recognizing the behavior. Yes, if you come here and post something racist and you are from one of the several racist or other biggoted subreddits, we will not only thoroughly thrash your propaganda, but we will also ban you. Yes, we will read through your posting history to see if you have a history of bigotry. 3) No soapboxing or speechifying. You hate America? Fine, go somewhere else. You a die hard college communist? Great. Go somewhere else. This is not the place to recruit, to rabble rouse, to instigate. At this point we have plenty of experience spotting that too. You will have your post removed. 4) Copy Pasting **ANY SOURCE** as your only way of posting, is VERBOTEN. People come here to receive quality, in depth analysis from historians, history students, and history buffs. Please assume the OP of the question isn't a complete moron and has googled for the answer. Additionally, this is /r/askhistorians, not /r/askgoogle. Yes, you can copy and paste a source and give a summary of that link and source, but simply throwing up a link or a wall of copied text is intellectually lazy and will result in the post being removed. 5) On topic, relevant humor only. No memes, advice animals, reaction gifs, or funny videos are allowed. The humor cannot be top tiered comments. Humor is allowed to stray more off topic in *meta threads only*. Jokes otherwise must be relevant, on topic, and hopefully funny. I personally hate puns. 6) Topic drift. The original Godwins Law stated that the longer a UseNet conversation went the more likely Hitler was to be brought up. It meant the thread was dead. Here we also avoid topic drift. A logical progression of topics being brought up is allowed, but please, don't let a thread on 19th Century agriculture end up about cow tipping. 7) Anecdotes are frowned upon. Unless you were there yourself at the event, its probably not a strong enough source. 8) If you are guessing, or you heard from something somewhere some time ago, don't bother. We will delete with extreme prejudice. 9) Wikipedia is the worst possible source you can use. Its acceptable at times, and in a pinch, but it really isn't a good source. If you couldn't use it in a paper, it probably wont work here. **4) Eternal~~kerri~~ September In light of the ever expanding number of users, of course there will be cries of Eternal September. The moderation team can only do so much. We need the user base to assist us by flagging violating posts as spam. We also want you to understand **we enforce rules here**. If you have a problem with the rules, address them to the moderation team, but Braveheart style speeches do not endear us to your plight (neither does calling us faggots after we ban you). The level of our enforcement and strictness of enforcement, as well as our patience is directly inverse to the level of chicanery in the sub. The more the rules are violated, the more people flagrantly violate them, the more people thumb their noses at the mods, the more likely we are to increase the intensity and harshness of our moderation. This is your sub, we just enforce the rules. If your fellow users cannot police themselves and you are not willing to assist in helping them understand they are violating the rules, then we will have to enforce the rules more and more strictly until we suck every bit of fun out of the sub. Assistant: Hey, just out of curiosity, when the mods delete a thread, could they quote the offending chunk of the original top level comment? I admit, it's mostly out of a sense of morbid voyeurism, but still.
Human: What's the history of askhistorians - who founded it, who grew it, what were the key decisions that made this sub far different than all others and what were the major challenges overcome in growing to 500k users? Assistant: AskHistorians was the "subreddit of the day" 5 years ago. Here's an brief interview with the sub's founder, /r/Artrw * November 19, 2011. r/AskHistorians. For all the times you can't remember how history last repeated itself.
Human: What's the history of askhistorians - who founded it, who grew it, what were the key decisions that made this sub far different than all others and what were the major challenges overcome in growing to 500k users? Assistant: Hi folks, Please stop reporting this as a thread that breaks our "20 Year Rule." Yes, you're very clever. But the moderator team has decided that this is an acceptable question on a META level and we've approved it. Thanks! Edit: I don't know what I expected.
Human: How did people with terrible vision live their lives before the invention of prescription glasses? Assistant: Many consider the Medieval Islamic Empire to be one of the first societies to make serious inroads into opthamology. *The Alteration of the Eye* by Yuhanna ibn Masawaiyh (777-857) is the earliest text on opthamology. An Iraqi named Ammar bin Ali Al Mawsili in Egypt developed a method for extracting soft cataracts, suctioning them using a hollow metal syringe in 900AD.
Human: How did people with terrible vision live their lives before the invention of prescription glasses? Assistant: In lieu of other input, I'll link to times this question has been asked previously: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/health#wiki_eyesight.2C_glasses.2C_and_contact_lenses
Human: How did people cope with sunburn before the time of sunscreen? I can't imagine having to work day after day outside without the aid of a full tube of sunscreen, how did (or didn't) they handle it before such a thing existed? Were there natural alternatives (e.g. fruit extracts), or was it just really popular to wear hats? On a related note, how did this affect ancients conflicts in arid landscapes, such as the Persian Empire? Assistant: In addition to other comments, sunburn has also become a much worse problem due to holes in the ozone layer. The ozone layer protects the earth from UV radiation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunburn#Ozone_depletion has multiple references.
Human: How did people cope with sunburn before the time of sunscreen? I can't imagine having to work day after day outside without the aid of a full tube of sunscreen, how did (or didn't) they handle it before such a thing existed? Were there natural alternatives (e.g. fruit extracts), or was it just really popular to wear hats? On a related note, how did this affect ancients conflicts in arid landscapes, such as the Persian Empire? Assistant: Egyptians used oils on their bodies to help with the sun.
Human: Christopher Columbus' real name was Cristobal Colon. What other famous historical figures names have been anglicized or changed and what are their real names? Assistant: That's the spanish version of his name, and what his spanish patrons called him. As Columbus was from Genoa (north Italy), he would have been known as *Cristoforo Colombo* as a young man.
Human: Christopher Columbus' real name was Cristobal Colon. What other famous historical figures names have been anglicized or changed and what are their real names? Assistant: Every German who is called "Charles" in English is "Karl" in German. "Charlemagne" is "Karl der Große" (*Karl the Great*) in German and "Carolus Magnus" (*Carolus (the) Great*) in Latin, for example. I'd be interested in how he called himself in the language of the Frankish.
Human: I am Marcus Tullius Cicero, Father of the Roman Republic. Honored as father by Caesar the Younger, and adversary to Mark Antony, some have named me 'Rome's Greatest Statesman.' AMA! Assistant: Could you please give us a few phrases in Etruscan?. A few linguists REALLY need them
Human: I am Marcus Tullius Cicero, Father of the Roman Republic. Honored as father by Caesar the Younger, and adversary to Mark Antony, some have named me 'Rome's Greatest Statesman.' AMA! Assistant: What did you think of your portrayal in HBO's Rome?
Human: I've often heard it said that for most of history, China lead the world in science and development. How true is this? I always thought of the Roman Empire and Greece as being the most advanced, culturally, scientifically, and militarily, in the world at their peaks, but I've heard people say that China was in fact more advanced, and indeed stayed more advanced than the Europeans until the 17th century or so. I'm curious just how true that is. And if so, in what regards were they more advanced, and in what ways were they less? When and why did this change? Assistant: China's been wealthier and more advanced than most anywhere else for the last four thousand years, excepting the last few hundred.
Human: I've often heard it said that for most of history, China lead the world in science and development. How true is this? I always thought of the Roman Empire and Greece as being the most advanced, culturally, scientifically, and militarily, in the world at their peaks, but I've heard people say that China was in fact more advanced, and indeed stayed more advanced than the Europeans until the 17th century or so. I'm curious just how true that is. And if so, in what regards were they more advanced, and in what ways were they less? When and why did this change? Assistant: A really fantastic comparitive view of civilizations can be had in Why The West Rules .. For Now. The author takes a broad historical view, basically since the invention of fire, and has attempted to create an 'algorithm' that measures the technological advancement of civilizations. Lots of fantastic insights, deep historical coverage and really great reasoning. I highly recommend it if you are curious of a comparative view of civilizations.
Human: Before the holocaust was well known, how were the Allies planning to deal with the Nazi leadership after WW2? Many of them were executed for their actions, but these trials usually related to holocaust related activities (at least that I am familiar with). Assistant: The primary charges at Nuremberg were "crime against peace", waging "war of aggression", and war crimes. The Holocaust related activities came under the fourth charge, "crimes against humanity", so it seems that even after the end of the war, the violations of the laws of civilized warfare were considered the most worthy of prosecution.
Human: Before the holocaust was well known, how were the Allies planning to deal with the Nazi leadership after WW2? Many of them were executed for their actions, but these trials usually related to holocaust related activities (at least that I am familiar with). Assistant: I have often wondered what the plans were in the event that Hitler was captured. The allies clearly made contingency plans for his capture after the war because they made doctored photo's of purposed disguises Hitler might use to conceal himself to evade capture made by the Western Allies, like this one. However, a lot of personality profiles done by the west, like the one done by Henry Murray, concluded that Hitler's egomania would drive him to commit suicide and maybe that was part of the plan.
Human: Announcing the Best of November Award Winners The votes are in! Winning the top spot for this month with the unianimous acclaim of both the Flair and User votes is the always deserving /u/itsallfolklore for their response to the question "Were brothels and prostitution as ubiquitous in the American West as is portrayed in film and fiction?". Following by a mere hair in a field of standouts is /u/thefourthmaninaboat, who takes the second award for "Did the Kriegsmarine ever stand a chance of winning the Battle of the Atlantic?". The non-flair taking the Dark Horse Award is /u/eminenssi, in recognition of their answer to "Why were such awful colors popular in the U.S. in the 1970s?" . Finally, the "Excellence in Flairdom" award, which recognizes the contributions of a user in the past month that went beyond a single, standout answer, goes to the millennia-spanning prowess of /u/CptBuck. You know him from his amazing answers in Near Eastern and Islamic history from the origins to today, including taking on the big, controversial questions about the rise of fundamentalist Islam. In November, however, /u/CptBuck ALSO, and repeatedly, stepped up to answer the awkward questions, the methodology or historian questions that don't really aim at a particular field. This month's award may be a quiet one, but in some ways that's the most important work of all. Let no more the hero be unsung! Thank you and congratulations, /u/CptBuck! So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest! For a list of past winners, check out this Wiki page!. Assistant: I'm honored and humbled. Thanks to all!
Human: Announcing the Best of November Award Winners The votes are in! Winning the top spot for this month with the unianimous acclaim of both the Flair and User votes is the always deserving /u/itsallfolklore for their response to the question "Were brothels and prostitution as ubiquitous in the American West as is portrayed in film and fiction?". Following by a mere hair in a field of standouts is /u/thefourthmaninaboat, who takes the second award for "Did the Kriegsmarine ever stand a chance of winning the Battle of the Atlantic?". The non-flair taking the Dark Horse Award is /u/eminenssi, in recognition of their answer to "Why were such awful colors popular in the U.S. in the 1970s?" . Finally, the "Excellence in Flairdom" award, which recognizes the contributions of a user in the past month that went beyond a single, standout answer, goes to the millennia-spanning prowess of /u/CptBuck. You know him from his amazing answers in Near Eastern and Islamic history from the origins to today, including taking on the big, controversial questions about the rise of fundamentalist Islam. In November, however, /u/CptBuck ALSO, and repeatedly, stepped up to answer the awkward questions, the methodology or historian questions that don't really aim at a particular field. This month's award may be a quiet one, but in some ways that's the most important work of all. Let no more the hero be unsung! Thank you and congratulations, /u/CptBuck! So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest! For a list of past winners, check out this Wiki page!. Assistant: Congratulations to all the winners, and a special congratulations to u/eminenssi!
Human: Hwæt! We have new Moderators! Hearken to me readers and contributors of AskHistorians for I bring you tidings! Today we, the AskHistorians moderators, your ~~benevolent dictators~~ friends, accept new members into our exalted ranks of comment removers and behind the scenes drudgers! In the high hallowed halls of our secret cabal, filled with smoke, mirrors, and ban-hammers we the AskHistorians mods have passed a new doom upon the land, and decreed that more ~~lackeys~~ valued contributors should rise to a new station and be given the keys to the kingdom. ___ Our decree thus follows: In the interest of further preserving the ~~strict no fun allowed policy~~ high standards of our subreddit, we have deemed several new mods to be established herein who shall reign over the lands of our demesne, given in our grace, to our valued vassals. May we all join together in fealty and gratitude to welcome: /u/historiagrephour our Scottish historian extraordinaire, who shall sound off in the threads with raucous pipes and critical examination of early modern gender roles! /u/DGBD who brings their musical talent to add to our own concerto and be heard across the subreddit! /u/hellcatfighter adds their own knowledge of China and Japan to weave into our expertise! and /u/Steelcan909! (What do you mean I'm announcing myself and speaking in the third person? I don't think our new mod would appreciate that kind of talk!) Should any infringe upon this, our generous gift, may they be bound by the inextricable bonds of being hit with the banhammer and cast out, or the more greater, make amends through excessive begging and supplication! Assistant: The year is 405 BCE : I'm a Moderator in Ancient Sparta. What does my life look like ? How do I deal with the envy and jealousy this prestigious position attracts ? Is my banhammer made of bronze or iron ? And more importantly, how does all this influence my sex life ?
Human: Hwæt! We have new Moderators! Hearken to me readers and contributors of AskHistorians for I bring you tidings! Today we, the AskHistorians moderators, your ~~benevolent dictators~~ friends, accept new members into our exalted ranks of comment removers and behind the scenes drudgers! In the high hallowed halls of our secret cabal, filled with smoke, mirrors, and ban-hammers we the AskHistorians mods have passed a new doom upon the land, and decreed that more ~~lackeys~~ valued contributors should rise to a new station and be given the keys to the kingdom. ___ Our decree thus follows: In the interest of further preserving the ~~strict no fun allowed policy~~ high standards of our subreddit, we have deemed several new mods to be established herein who shall reign over the lands of our demesne, given in our grace, to our valued vassals. May we all join together in fealty and gratitude to welcome: /u/historiagrephour our Scottish historian extraordinaire, who shall sound off in the threads with raucous pipes and critical examination of early modern gender roles! /u/DGBD who brings their musical talent to add to our own concerto and be heard across the subreddit! /u/hellcatfighter adds their own knowledge of China and Japan to weave into our expertise! and /u/Steelcan909! (What do you mean I'm announcing myself and speaking in the third person? I don't think our new mod would appreciate that kind of talk!) Should any infringe upon this, our generous gift, may they be bound by the inextricable bonds of being hit with the banhammer and cast out, or the more greater, make amends through excessive begging and supplication! Assistant: _Fly, you fools!_
Human: We are AskHistorians flairs of the Viking Age! Ask us anything about Assassin's Creed: Valhalla! Hwæt, /r/AskHistorians we are a team of flaired users who all specialize in different aspects of the Viking Age! With the recent release of the latest Assassin's Creed game, set in the period of Viking raids on England in the 9th century, we decided to come together and answer any questions you may have on the time period in question! If you want to know why the Viking Age started, the intricacies of Norse religious traditions, the arms and armor of the Anglo-Saxons and Norse, or any other topic that tickles your fancy sound off with a question! (Note, if you have a very specific question about a certain aspect of the game it might help to include a screenshot or relevant video for context, we don't all have the game nor have we all finished playing it!) Today, joining us we have /u/bristoneman A doctor of archaeology and medieval history, and who wrote their thesis on English defensive infrastructure during the Danish invasions, and its role in the unification of England /u/kelpie-cat A PhD student in Celtic and Scottish Studies with a degree in medieval history, wit a focus on Christian conversion and early Christianity in the Insular world; Insular art; women in England, Scotland and Ireland; and the Picts. /u/textandtrowel A PhD in history with a focus on the Viking slave trade. /u/mediaevumed Is game (pun intended) to talk to the Norse Diaspora more broadly, questions of gender, religion, raiding etc. They are also keen to discuss the topic of medievalisms: how Vikings get reinterpreted and used in media (esp. Video Games) and how and why AC flirts with (or diverges from) reality. /u/goiyon Can answer any questions you have about the cultural cousins of the Anglo-Saxons in Frisia! /u/thefeckamidoing Mainly focused upon the Viking impact on Ireland and the Kingdom of Mann and the Isles. /u/eyestache Who focuses on Anglo-Saxon and Norse material culture and weaponry. /u/sagathain Their focus is on the imagined Vikings, both in medieval texts and in modern medievalisms, including games. Finally, myself /u/Steelcan909 I'm a moderator here on AskHistorians and I usually answer questions on Norse and Anglo-Saxon society/culture generally, though my actual focus academically is on Anglo-Saxon legal history. Assistant: It seems like everything Norse themed is either called Valhalla or Ragnarok. What are some other nouns that you think would make good names for Viking media? More broadly, what parts of Viking Age culture do you think are underappreciated or underrepresented in media, especially in the rush to make the Vikings a bunch of badass long beards?
Human: We are AskHistorians flairs of the Viking Age! Ask us anything about Assassin's Creed: Valhalla! Hwæt, /r/AskHistorians we are a team of flaired users who all specialize in different aspects of the Viking Age! With the recent release of the latest Assassin's Creed game, set in the period of Viking raids on England in the 9th century, we decided to come together and answer any questions you may have on the time period in question! If you want to know why the Viking Age started, the intricacies of Norse religious traditions, the arms and armor of the Anglo-Saxons and Norse, or any other topic that tickles your fancy sound off with a question! (Note, if you have a very specific question about a certain aspect of the game it might help to include a screenshot or relevant video for context, we don't all have the game nor have we all finished playing it!) Today, joining us we have /u/bristoneman A doctor of archaeology and medieval history, and who wrote their thesis on English defensive infrastructure during the Danish invasions, and its role in the unification of England /u/kelpie-cat A PhD student in Celtic and Scottish Studies with a degree in medieval history, wit a focus on Christian conversion and early Christianity in the Insular world; Insular art; women in England, Scotland and Ireland; and the Picts. /u/textandtrowel A PhD in history with a focus on the Viking slave trade. /u/mediaevumed Is game (pun intended) to talk to the Norse Diaspora more broadly, questions of gender, religion, raiding etc. They are also keen to discuss the topic of medievalisms: how Vikings get reinterpreted and used in media (esp. Video Games) and how and why AC flirts with (or diverges from) reality. /u/goiyon Can answer any questions you have about the cultural cousins of the Anglo-Saxons in Frisia! /u/thefeckamidoing Mainly focused upon the Viking impact on Ireland and the Kingdom of Mann and the Isles. /u/eyestache Who focuses on Anglo-Saxon and Norse material culture and weaponry. /u/sagathain Their focus is on the imagined Vikings, both in medieval texts and in modern medievalisms, including games. Finally, myself /u/Steelcan909 I'm a moderator here on AskHistorians and I usually answer questions on Norse and Anglo-Saxon society/culture generally, though my actual focus academically is on Anglo-Saxon legal history. Assistant: u/sagathain, /u/eyestache i'm curious with the viking longships. The common picture is that of a longboat with just a unroofed deck(?) where the vikings row their oars and where the mast is. Are these really the ships vikings used to cross seas and oceans? For long trips such as from Scandinavia to England, even to North America, how can the vikings sail in such boats without the cabin part to rest. Wouldn't they have died of exposure?
Human: Let us flip the script, what work has helped your field or you admire because of how historically accurate it is? As someone who has both studied and loved post World War II German history I think the film *The Baader Meinhof Complex* is an excellent piece of cinema that shows how history should be told in a film. In this case the truth was just as engrossing and captivating than fiction could ever hope to portray. So historians, which works do you drool over because of their authenticity? Assistant: Grave of the Fireflies. A more tragically accurate portrayal of war than most live-action movies dare to be.
Human: Let us flip the script, what work has helped your field or you admire because of how historically accurate it is? As someone who has both studied and loved post World War II German history I think the film *The Baader Meinhof Complex* is an excellent piece of cinema that shows how history should be told in a film. In this case the truth was just as engrossing and captivating than fiction could ever hope to portray. So historians, which works do you drool over because of their authenticity? Assistant: *Feud: Hatfields, McCoys, and Social Change in Appalachia, 1860-1900* by Altina Waller, published in 1988. * Helped move Appalachian Historiography out of the culture of poverty thesis * Showed that old, passe topics can be reanalyzed amazingly well * Showed that you can use a very small area to tell the story of a whole region * Helped reconnect Appalachia regional studies to the history field as a whole * Helped move studies of Appalachia beyond the study of economics
Human: So we've heard the question asked many times about English. But what about other languages? How far back could you go and still be able to communicate in, say, French? Or any other language. I realize that no one's going to be able to give an answer for every language spoken ever, but I'd be really interested to see how other languages have endured compared to English. So, pick a language and tell me a tale, Reddit. Assistant: A question about language? r/Linguistics!
Human: So we've heard the question asked many times about English. But what about other languages? How far back could you go and still be able to communicate in, say, French? Or any other language. I realize that no one's going to be able to give an answer for every language spoken ever, but I'd be really interested to see how other languages have endured compared to English. So, pick a language and tell me a tale, Reddit. Assistant: If you can read classical Chinese, well, there are changes and classical/ancient Chinese are certainly different, but reliably you can understand (if not pronounce) things back to around the Han Dynasty - 200BC or so, or perhaps even earlier. Most college educated Chinese folks can at least read some classical Chinese today.
Human: Through various history classes, I have learned a good deal about the history of all the major civilizations - But I have a hard time of figuring out where all the events and historical people are in relation to one another: What is a good timeline resource? Assistant: I cannot be the only one who is mildly curious about the comprehensive list of the all the "major" civilizations.
Human: Through various history classes, I have learned a good deal about the history of all the major civilizations - But I have a hard time of figuring out where all the events and historical people are in relation to one another: What is a good timeline resource? Assistant: European History Interactive Map http://www.worldology.com/Europe/europe_history_lg.htm
Human: It is widely thought that the West Germans had it much better than their easterly counterparts. Was there any upside to living in East Germany? Did they have anything the West Germans did not? Assistant: Pensions, especially for ladies. (West) Germany's minimum guaranteed pension is one of the lowest in the EU, at 42% of average salary. Eastern Germans got relatively more, although on *absolute* terms I'm not sure it *was* more.
Human: It is widely thought that the West Germans had it much better than their easterly counterparts. Was there any upside to living in East Germany? Did they have anything the West Germans did not? Assistant: Related to this question - was there less income inequality in East Germany than West Germany (either by Gini or some other measurement)?
Human: Did pre-modern societies (so, let's say before 1400) have any speculative fiction? It seems such hallmark of modern literature to write about time travel, future dys/utopias, parallel universes, etc. Is there any kind of equivalent prior to the modern era? Assistant: Here's one great example from 10th century Japan: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tale_of_the_Bamboo_Cutter
Human: Did pre-modern societies (so, let's say before 1400) have any speculative fiction? It seems such hallmark of modern literature to write about time travel, future dys/utopias, parallel universes, etc. Is there any kind of equivalent prior to the modern era? Assistant: My training is in Philosophy, and not history, but wouldn't Plato's account of Atlantis in the Timeaus and Critias count as speculative fiction? Also, perhaps even the Republic could count as speculative fiction.
Human: How common was it for battles/sieges to be determined by single combat between two opposing champions? Assistant: Reverse question: How common was it for battles/sieges to not be determined in this fashion? By which I mean how often was single combat fought in this fashion, only for the losing side to decide "nah, that didn't count, we're just going to continue what we were doing?" And how often did the winner have to run for his life?
Human: How common was it for battles/sieges to be determined by single combat between two opposing champions? Assistant: This question has come up before. Not discouraging discussion, but the answers are worth reading. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1f46ls/at_the_beginning_of_the_film_troy_a_battle_wasnt/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/183dk7/are_there_any_cases_where_two_leading_individuals/
Human: Floating Feature: What is your favorite *accuracy-be-damned* work of historical fiction? *Now and then, we like to host 'Floating Features', periodic threads intended to allow for more open discussion that allows a multitude of possible answers from people of all sorts of backgrounds and levels of expertise.* The question of the most accurate historical fiction comes up quite often on AskHistorians. This is not that thread. **Tell me, AskHistorians, what are your (not at all) guilty pleasures: your favorite books, TV shows, movies, webcomics about the past that clearly have *all the cares in the world* for maintaining historical accuracy?** Does your love of history or a particular topic spring from one of these works? Do you find yourself recommending it to non-historians? Why or why not? Tell us what is so wonderfully inaccurate about it! Dish! Assistant: The Borgias... in fact, I think they should elect Jeremy Irons as the next pope, and I don't even know if he's catholic. Also, this is today's: http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/history-books
Human: Floating Feature: What is your favorite *accuracy-be-damned* work of historical fiction? *Now and then, we like to host 'Floating Features', periodic threads intended to allow for more open discussion that allows a multitude of possible answers from people of all sorts of backgrounds and levels of expertise.* The question of the most accurate historical fiction comes up quite often on AskHistorians. This is not that thread. **Tell me, AskHistorians, what are your (not at all) guilty pleasures: your favorite books, TV shows, movies, webcomics about the past that clearly have *all the cares in the world* for maintaining historical accuracy?** Does your love of history or a particular topic spring from one of these works? Do you find yourself recommending it to non-historians? Why or why not? Tell us what is so wonderfully inaccurate about it! Dish! Assistant: Braveheart. The speeches. The costumes. And Stephen. Oh Stephen.
Human: Why did the United States become a superpower in the new world, and so many other states did not? It sounds like a simple question, but when you consider that the US started off as a tiny east coast sliver of land (like Chile is now) that expanded across the continent, while countries such as Argentina and Brazil had much higher population and natural resources, it's not obvious why it came to be that the US became first an economic and later a political/military superpower and other American countries did not. Assistant: Here is an interesting article on the topic: The Geopolitics of the United States, Part 1: The Inevitable Empire.
Human: Why did the United States become a superpower in the new world, and so many other states did not? It sounds like a simple question, but when you consider that the US started off as a tiny east coast sliver of land (like Chile is now) that expanded across the continent, while countries such as Argentina and Brazil had much higher population and natural resources, it's not obvious why it came to be that the US became first an economic and later a political/military superpower and other American countries did not. Assistant: The US became a "super power" only recently. After WWII, there were only two major countries that hadn't been bombed to hell and had their infrastructure destroyed: The US and the Soviet Union. The two stayed in constant struggle to see which was on top until 1991 when the Soviet Union fell.