id
string | words
list | boxes
list | question
string | answer
string |
---|---|---|---|---|
478
|
[
"ils",
"INTERNATIONAL",
"LITIGATION",
"SERVICES",
"CERTIFICATION",
"OF",
"TRANSLATION",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"a",
"company",
"specializing",
"in",
"international",
"cases",
"and",
"foreign",
"language",
"document",
"processing,",
"certifies",
"the",
"following:",
".",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services",
"has",
"retained",
"a",
"professional",
"translator",
"for",
"the",
"attached",
"Japanese",
"into",
"English",
"document.",
"The",
"document",
"is",
"referred",
"to",
"as:",
"\"TAK-NISHY-00221506P-0001\"",
"I",
"affirm",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"has",
"been",
"prepared",
"by",
"a",
"duly",
"qualified",
"translator,",
"who",
"has",
"confirmed",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"is,",
"to",
"the",
"best",
"of",
"his/",
"her",
"knowledge",
"and",
"belief,",
"a",
"true",
"and",
"accurate",
"translation",
"in",
"English",
"of",
"the",
"corresponding",
"Japanese",
"document.",
"I",
"declare",
"under",
"the",
"penalty",
"of",
"perjury",
"that",
"the",
"forgoing",
"is",
"true",
"and",
"correct.",
"Notwithstanding",
"the",
"foregoing",
"affirmations,",
"no",
"liability",
"is",
"assumed",
"for",
"errors",
"and",
"omissions",
"in",
"the",
"translation",
"of",
"the",
"attached",
"document.",
"Executed",
"on",
"this",
"19th",
"day",
"of",
"February",
"2014,",
"in",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California.",
"Joeph",
"thorpe",
"Joseph",
"Thorpe",
"Managing",
"Director",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"&",
"Of",
"Enterprise",
".",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California",
"92656",
"Phone:",
"838",
"313.4457",
".",
"Fall",
"2182.",
"213.674.4181",
".",
"[email protected]&WWW.HISTEAM.com",
"NEW",
"YORK",
".",
"LOS",
"ANGELES",
".",
"LAS",
"VEGAS",
"*",
"ORANGE",
"COUNTY",
"Source:",
"https://www.industry-ments.ucsf.edu/docs/tfkf0226"
] |
[
[
447,
108,
550,
187
],
[
418,
206,
561,
218
],
[
440,
218,
538,
230
],
[
450,
233,
531,
245
],
[
306,
263,
484,
280
],
[
494,
263,
527,
280
],
[
533,
263,
691,
280
],
[
117,
308,
211,
323
],
[
214,
309,
285,
324
],
[
289,
309,
352,
324
],
[
356,
309,
365,
324
],
[
369,
309,
435,
324
],
[
438,
309,
521,
324
],
[
524,
309,
540,
324
],
[
544,
309,
637,
324
],
[
640,
309,
678,
324
],
[
681,
309,
710,
324
],
[
713,
308,
764,
324
],
[
767,
308,
831,
324
],
[
120,
340,
190,
356
],
[
194,
340,
275,
355
],
[
279,
340,
337,
355
],
[
340,
340,
365,
355
],
[
368,
340,
443,
355
],
[
147,
370,
159,
384
],
[
174,
371,
270,
385
],
[
272,
370,
343,
385
],
[
347,
370,
405,
386
],
[
409,
370,
434,
386
],
[
438,
370,
498,
386
],
[
501,
370,
510,
386
],
[
512,
370,
603,
386
],
[
606,
370,
675,
386
],
[
679,
370,
702,
386
],
[
705,
370,
730,
386
],
[
733,
370,
794,
386
],
[
798,
370,
865,
386
],
[
175,
401,
205,
416
],
[
209,
401,
267,
417
],
[
271,
402,
347,
417
],
[
351,
402,
382,
417
],
[
386,
402,
455,
417
],
[
459,
402,
472,
417
],
[
476,
402,
535,
417
],
[
538,
402,
554,
416
],
[
558,
402,
579,
416
],
[
370,
431,
610,
446
],
[
175,
465,
184,
478
],
[
186,
465,
228,
479
],
[
235,
465,
266,
479
],
[
269,
465,
303,
480
],
[
306,
465,
383,
480
],
[
386,
465,
412,
480
],
[
415,
464,
451,
480
],
[
454,
464,
520,
480
],
[
523,
464,
542,
480
],
[
546,
464,
557,
480
],
[
561,
464,
590,
480
],
[
592,
464,
656,
480
],
[
659,
464,
734,
480
],
[
737,
464,
769,
480
],
[
771,
464,
798,
480
],
[
801,
464,
877,
479
],
[
175,
497,
205,
510
],
[
208,
496,
242,
510
],
[
246,
496,
322,
511
],
[
326,
496,
343,
511
],
[
347,
496,
362,
511
],
[
366,
496,
390,
511
],
[
394,
496,
424,
511
],
[
428,
496,
444,
511
],
[
447,
496,
474,
511
],
[
477,
496,
502,
511
],
[
505,
496,
585,
511
],
[
589,
496,
615,
511
],
[
618,
496,
665,
511
],
[
668,
496,
677,
511
],
[
680,
496,
710,
511
],
[
714,
496,
741,
511
],
[
744,
496,
805,
511
],
[
175,
528,
252,
541
],
[
255,
528,
271,
541
],
[
275,
528,
330,
542
],
[
334,
528,
352,
542
],
[
354,
528,
379,
542
],
[
382,
528,
487,
542
],
[
490,
528,
555,
542
],
[
560,
529,
637,
542
],
[
175,
558,
186,
573
],
[
190,
558,
238,
573
],
[
241,
559,
285,
573
],
[
288,
559,
311,
574
],
[
315,
559,
369,
574
],
[
372,
560,
388,
574
],
[
392,
560,
444,
574
],
[
447,
560,
478,
574
],
[
481,
560,
505,
574
],
[
509,
560,
571,
574
],
[
574,
560,
588,
574
],
[
591,
560,
620,
574
],
[
624,
560,
651,
574
],
[
655,
559,
715,
574
],
[
719,
559,
842,
573
],
[
845,
558,
871,
572
],
[
175,
591,
247,
605
],
[
250,
591,
341,
605
],
[
345,
590,
364,
605
],
[
368,
590,
422,
605
],
[
425,
590,
439,
605
],
[
442,
590,
505,
605
],
[
508,
590,
531,
605
],
[
535,
590,
578,
605
],
[
582,
590,
610,
605
],
[
614,
590,
684,
605
],
[
688,
590,
704,
605
],
[
707,
590,
731,
605
],
[
735,
590,
812,
605
],
[
815,
590,
833,
604
],
[
836,
590,
860,
604
],
[
175,
622,
237,
635
],
[
243,
622,
317,
635
],
[
117,
652,
187,
666
],
[
190,
652,
210,
667
],
[
212,
652,
242,
667
],
[
245,
652,
278,
667
],
[
284,
652,
307,
667
],
[
310,
652,
328,
667
],
[
331,
652,
397,
667
],
[
400,
652,
440,
667
],
[
442,
652,
459,
667
],
[
462,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
548,
667
],
[
552,
652,
630,
667
],
[
465,
715,
566,
755
],
[
574,
712,
683,
751
],
[
470,
777,
522,
790
],
[
527,
778,
578,
790
],
[
470,
791,
542,
805
],
[
546,
793,
607,
805
],
[
470,
808,
565,
821
],
[
569,
808,
640,
821
],
[
643,
808,
707,
822
],
[
710,
808,
742,
822
],
[
208,
851,
299,
862
],
[
301,
851,
365,
862
],
[
369,
851,
431,
862
],
[
434,
851,
464,
862
],
[
467,
851,
476,
863
],
[
482,
851,
500,
863
],
[
504,
851,
576,
863
],
[
583,
851,
592,
863
],
[
600,
851,
632,
863
],
[
636,
850,
677,
863
],
[
680,
850,
746,
863
],
[
749,
850,
793,
863
],
[
194,
862,
248,
877
],
[
250,
862,
278,
875
],
[
281,
862,
350,
875
],
[
352,
863,
365,
875
],
[
368,
864,
401,
877
],
[
404,
865,
444,
879
],
[
405,
863,
500,
875
],
[
506,
863,
517,
875
],
[
521,
863,
802,
877
],
[
254,
886,
290,
901
],
[
298,
886,
342,
902
],
[
349,
886,
361,
902
],
[
367,
886,
399,
902
],
[
402,
887,
475,
902
],
[
481,
887,
493,
902
],
[
499,
887,
528,
903
],
[
532,
887,
587,
903
],
[
592,
887,
605,
903
],
[
611,
886,
679,
903
],
[
682,
886,
747,
902
],
[
229,
981,
294,
998
],
[
298,
981,
773,
998
]
] |
who retained a professional translator
|
International Litigation Services
|
478
|
[
"ils",
"INTERNATIONAL",
"LITIGATION",
"SERVICES",
"CERTIFICATION",
"OF",
"TRANSLATION",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"a",
"company",
"specializing",
"in",
"international",
"cases",
"and",
"foreign",
"language",
"document",
"processing,",
"certifies",
"the",
"following:",
".",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services",
"has",
"retained",
"a",
"professional",
"translator",
"for",
"the",
"attached",
"Japanese",
"into",
"English",
"document.",
"The",
"document",
"is",
"referred",
"to",
"as:",
"\"TAK-NISHY-00221506P-0001\"",
"I",
"affirm",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"has",
"been",
"prepared",
"by",
"a",
"duly",
"qualified",
"translator,",
"who",
"has",
"confirmed",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"is,",
"to",
"the",
"best",
"of",
"his/",
"her",
"knowledge",
"and",
"belief,",
"a",
"true",
"and",
"accurate",
"translation",
"in",
"English",
"of",
"the",
"corresponding",
"Japanese",
"document.",
"I",
"declare",
"under",
"the",
"penalty",
"of",
"perjury",
"that",
"the",
"forgoing",
"is",
"true",
"and",
"correct.",
"Notwithstanding",
"the",
"foregoing",
"affirmations,",
"no",
"liability",
"is",
"assumed",
"for",
"errors",
"and",
"omissions",
"in",
"the",
"translation",
"of",
"the",
"attached",
"document.",
"Executed",
"on",
"this",
"19th",
"day",
"of",
"February",
"2014,",
"in",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California.",
"Joeph",
"thorpe",
"Joseph",
"Thorpe",
"Managing",
"Director",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"&",
"Of",
"Enterprise",
".",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California",
"92656",
"Phone:",
"838",
"313.4457",
".",
"Fall",
"2182.",
"213.674.4181",
".",
"[email protected]&WWW.HISTEAM.com",
"NEW",
"YORK",
".",
"LOS",
"ANGELES",
".",
"LAS",
"VEGAS",
"*",
"ORANGE",
"COUNTY",
"Source:",
"https://www.industry-ments.ucsf.edu/docs/tfkf0226"
] |
[
[
447,
108,
550,
187
],
[
418,
206,
561,
218
],
[
440,
218,
538,
230
],
[
450,
233,
531,
245
],
[
306,
263,
484,
280
],
[
494,
263,
527,
280
],
[
533,
263,
691,
280
],
[
117,
308,
211,
323
],
[
214,
309,
285,
324
],
[
289,
309,
352,
324
],
[
356,
309,
365,
324
],
[
369,
309,
435,
324
],
[
438,
309,
521,
324
],
[
524,
309,
540,
324
],
[
544,
309,
637,
324
],
[
640,
309,
678,
324
],
[
681,
309,
710,
324
],
[
713,
308,
764,
324
],
[
767,
308,
831,
324
],
[
120,
340,
190,
356
],
[
194,
340,
275,
355
],
[
279,
340,
337,
355
],
[
340,
340,
365,
355
],
[
368,
340,
443,
355
],
[
147,
370,
159,
384
],
[
174,
371,
270,
385
],
[
272,
370,
343,
385
],
[
347,
370,
405,
386
],
[
409,
370,
434,
386
],
[
438,
370,
498,
386
],
[
501,
370,
510,
386
],
[
512,
370,
603,
386
],
[
606,
370,
675,
386
],
[
679,
370,
702,
386
],
[
705,
370,
730,
386
],
[
733,
370,
794,
386
],
[
798,
370,
865,
386
],
[
175,
401,
205,
416
],
[
209,
401,
267,
417
],
[
271,
402,
347,
417
],
[
351,
402,
382,
417
],
[
386,
402,
455,
417
],
[
459,
402,
472,
417
],
[
476,
402,
535,
417
],
[
538,
402,
554,
416
],
[
558,
402,
579,
416
],
[
370,
431,
610,
446
],
[
175,
465,
184,
478
],
[
186,
465,
228,
479
],
[
235,
465,
266,
479
],
[
269,
465,
303,
480
],
[
306,
465,
383,
480
],
[
386,
465,
412,
480
],
[
415,
464,
451,
480
],
[
454,
464,
520,
480
],
[
523,
464,
542,
480
],
[
546,
464,
557,
480
],
[
561,
464,
590,
480
],
[
592,
464,
656,
480
],
[
659,
464,
734,
480
],
[
737,
464,
769,
480
],
[
771,
464,
798,
480
],
[
801,
464,
877,
479
],
[
175,
497,
205,
510
],
[
208,
496,
242,
510
],
[
246,
496,
322,
511
],
[
326,
496,
343,
511
],
[
347,
496,
362,
511
],
[
366,
496,
390,
511
],
[
394,
496,
424,
511
],
[
428,
496,
444,
511
],
[
447,
496,
474,
511
],
[
477,
496,
502,
511
],
[
505,
496,
585,
511
],
[
589,
496,
615,
511
],
[
618,
496,
665,
511
],
[
668,
496,
677,
511
],
[
680,
496,
710,
511
],
[
714,
496,
741,
511
],
[
744,
496,
805,
511
],
[
175,
528,
252,
541
],
[
255,
528,
271,
541
],
[
275,
528,
330,
542
],
[
334,
528,
352,
542
],
[
354,
528,
379,
542
],
[
382,
528,
487,
542
],
[
490,
528,
555,
542
],
[
560,
529,
637,
542
],
[
175,
558,
186,
573
],
[
190,
558,
238,
573
],
[
241,
559,
285,
573
],
[
288,
559,
311,
574
],
[
315,
559,
369,
574
],
[
372,
560,
388,
574
],
[
392,
560,
444,
574
],
[
447,
560,
478,
574
],
[
481,
560,
505,
574
],
[
509,
560,
571,
574
],
[
574,
560,
588,
574
],
[
591,
560,
620,
574
],
[
624,
560,
651,
574
],
[
655,
559,
715,
574
],
[
719,
559,
842,
573
],
[
845,
558,
871,
572
],
[
175,
591,
247,
605
],
[
250,
591,
341,
605
],
[
345,
590,
364,
605
],
[
368,
590,
422,
605
],
[
425,
590,
439,
605
],
[
442,
590,
505,
605
],
[
508,
590,
531,
605
],
[
535,
590,
578,
605
],
[
582,
590,
610,
605
],
[
614,
590,
684,
605
],
[
688,
590,
704,
605
],
[
707,
590,
731,
605
],
[
735,
590,
812,
605
],
[
815,
590,
833,
604
],
[
836,
590,
860,
604
],
[
175,
622,
237,
635
],
[
243,
622,
317,
635
],
[
117,
652,
187,
666
],
[
190,
652,
210,
667
],
[
212,
652,
242,
667
],
[
245,
652,
278,
667
],
[
284,
652,
307,
667
],
[
310,
652,
328,
667
],
[
331,
652,
397,
667
],
[
400,
652,
440,
667
],
[
442,
652,
459,
667
],
[
462,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
548,
667
],
[
552,
652,
630,
667
],
[
465,
715,
566,
755
],
[
574,
712,
683,
751
],
[
470,
777,
522,
790
],
[
527,
778,
578,
790
],
[
470,
791,
542,
805
],
[
546,
793,
607,
805
],
[
470,
808,
565,
821
],
[
569,
808,
640,
821
],
[
643,
808,
707,
822
],
[
710,
808,
742,
822
],
[
208,
851,
299,
862
],
[
301,
851,
365,
862
],
[
369,
851,
431,
862
],
[
434,
851,
464,
862
],
[
467,
851,
476,
863
],
[
482,
851,
500,
863
],
[
504,
851,
576,
863
],
[
583,
851,
592,
863
],
[
600,
851,
632,
863
],
[
636,
850,
677,
863
],
[
680,
850,
746,
863
],
[
749,
850,
793,
863
],
[
194,
862,
248,
877
],
[
250,
862,
278,
875
],
[
281,
862,
350,
875
],
[
352,
863,
365,
875
],
[
368,
864,
401,
877
],
[
404,
865,
444,
879
],
[
405,
863,
500,
875
],
[
506,
863,
517,
875
],
[
521,
863,
802,
877
],
[
254,
886,
290,
901
],
[
298,
886,
342,
902
],
[
349,
886,
361,
902
],
[
367,
886,
399,
902
],
[
402,
887,
475,
902
],
[
481,
887,
493,
902
],
[
499,
887,
528,
903
],
[
532,
887,
587,
903
],
[
592,
887,
605,
903
],
[
611,
886,
679,
903
],
[
682,
886,
747,
902
],
[
229,
981,
294,
998
],
[
298,
981,
773,
998
]
] |
who is the managing director of international litigation services,Inc.
|
Joseph Thorpe
|
478
|
[
"ils",
"INTERNATIONAL",
"LITIGATION",
"SERVICES",
"CERTIFICATION",
"OF",
"TRANSLATION",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"a",
"company",
"specializing",
"in",
"international",
"cases",
"and",
"foreign",
"language",
"document",
"processing,",
"certifies",
"the",
"following:",
".",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services",
"has",
"retained",
"a",
"professional",
"translator",
"for",
"the",
"attached",
"Japanese",
"into",
"English",
"document.",
"The",
"document",
"is",
"referred",
"to",
"as:",
"\"TAK-NISHY-00221506P-0001\"",
"I",
"affirm",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"has",
"been",
"prepared",
"by",
"a",
"duly",
"qualified",
"translator,",
"who",
"has",
"confirmed",
"that",
"such",
"translation",
"is,",
"to",
"the",
"best",
"of",
"his/",
"her",
"knowledge",
"and",
"belief,",
"a",
"true",
"and",
"accurate",
"translation",
"in",
"English",
"of",
"the",
"corresponding",
"Japanese",
"document.",
"I",
"declare",
"under",
"the",
"penalty",
"of",
"perjury",
"that",
"the",
"forgoing",
"is",
"true",
"and",
"correct.",
"Notwithstanding",
"the",
"foregoing",
"affirmations,",
"no",
"liability",
"is",
"assumed",
"for",
"errors",
"and",
"omissions",
"in",
"the",
"translation",
"of",
"the",
"attached",
"document.",
"Executed",
"on",
"this",
"19th",
"day",
"of",
"February",
"2014,",
"in",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California.",
"Joeph",
"thorpe",
"Joseph",
"Thorpe",
"Managing",
"Director",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"International",
"Litigation",
"Services,",
"Inc.",
"&",
"Of",
"Enterprise",
".",
"Aliso",
"Viejo,",
"California",
"92656",
"Phone:",
"838",
"313.4457",
".",
"Fall",
"2182.",
"213.674.4181",
".",
"[email protected]&WWW.HISTEAM.com",
"NEW",
"YORK",
".",
"LOS",
"ANGELES",
".",
"LAS",
"VEGAS",
"*",
"ORANGE",
"COUNTY",
"Source:",
"https://www.industry-ments.ucsf.edu/docs/tfkf0226"
] |
[
[
447,
108,
550,
187
],
[
418,
206,
561,
218
],
[
440,
218,
538,
230
],
[
450,
233,
531,
245
],
[
306,
263,
484,
280
],
[
494,
263,
527,
280
],
[
533,
263,
691,
280
],
[
117,
308,
211,
323
],
[
214,
309,
285,
324
],
[
289,
309,
352,
324
],
[
356,
309,
365,
324
],
[
369,
309,
435,
324
],
[
438,
309,
521,
324
],
[
524,
309,
540,
324
],
[
544,
309,
637,
324
],
[
640,
309,
678,
324
],
[
681,
309,
710,
324
],
[
713,
308,
764,
324
],
[
767,
308,
831,
324
],
[
120,
340,
190,
356
],
[
194,
340,
275,
355
],
[
279,
340,
337,
355
],
[
340,
340,
365,
355
],
[
368,
340,
443,
355
],
[
147,
370,
159,
384
],
[
174,
371,
270,
385
],
[
272,
370,
343,
385
],
[
347,
370,
405,
386
],
[
409,
370,
434,
386
],
[
438,
370,
498,
386
],
[
501,
370,
510,
386
],
[
512,
370,
603,
386
],
[
606,
370,
675,
386
],
[
679,
370,
702,
386
],
[
705,
370,
730,
386
],
[
733,
370,
794,
386
],
[
798,
370,
865,
386
],
[
175,
401,
205,
416
],
[
209,
401,
267,
417
],
[
271,
402,
347,
417
],
[
351,
402,
382,
417
],
[
386,
402,
455,
417
],
[
459,
402,
472,
417
],
[
476,
402,
535,
417
],
[
538,
402,
554,
416
],
[
558,
402,
579,
416
],
[
370,
431,
610,
446
],
[
175,
465,
184,
478
],
[
186,
465,
228,
479
],
[
235,
465,
266,
479
],
[
269,
465,
303,
480
],
[
306,
465,
383,
480
],
[
386,
465,
412,
480
],
[
415,
464,
451,
480
],
[
454,
464,
520,
480
],
[
523,
464,
542,
480
],
[
546,
464,
557,
480
],
[
561,
464,
590,
480
],
[
592,
464,
656,
480
],
[
659,
464,
734,
480
],
[
737,
464,
769,
480
],
[
771,
464,
798,
480
],
[
801,
464,
877,
479
],
[
175,
497,
205,
510
],
[
208,
496,
242,
510
],
[
246,
496,
322,
511
],
[
326,
496,
343,
511
],
[
347,
496,
362,
511
],
[
366,
496,
390,
511
],
[
394,
496,
424,
511
],
[
428,
496,
444,
511
],
[
447,
496,
474,
511
],
[
477,
496,
502,
511
],
[
505,
496,
585,
511
],
[
589,
496,
615,
511
],
[
618,
496,
665,
511
],
[
668,
496,
677,
511
],
[
680,
496,
710,
511
],
[
714,
496,
741,
511
],
[
744,
496,
805,
511
],
[
175,
528,
252,
541
],
[
255,
528,
271,
541
],
[
275,
528,
330,
542
],
[
334,
528,
352,
542
],
[
354,
528,
379,
542
],
[
382,
528,
487,
542
],
[
490,
528,
555,
542
],
[
560,
529,
637,
542
],
[
175,
558,
186,
573
],
[
190,
558,
238,
573
],
[
241,
559,
285,
573
],
[
288,
559,
311,
574
],
[
315,
559,
369,
574
],
[
372,
560,
388,
574
],
[
392,
560,
444,
574
],
[
447,
560,
478,
574
],
[
481,
560,
505,
574
],
[
509,
560,
571,
574
],
[
574,
560,
588,
574
],
[
591,
560,
620,
574
],
[
624,
560,
651,
574
],
[
655,
559,
715,
574
],
[
719,
559,
842,
573
],
[
845,
558,
871,
572
],
[
175,
591,
247,
605
],
[
250,
591,
341,
605
],
[
345,
590,
364,
605
],
[
368,
590,
422,
605
],
[
425,
590,
439,
605
],
[
442,
590,
505,
605
],
[
508,
590,
531,
605
],
[
535,
590,
578,
605
],
[
582,
590,
610,
605
],
[
614,
590,
684,
605
],
[
688,
590,
704,
605
],
[
707,
590,
731,
605
],
[
735,
590,
812,
605
],
[
815,
590,
833,
604
],
[
836,
590,
860,
604
],
[
175,
622,
237,
635
],
[
243,
622,
317,
635
],
[
117,
652,
187,
666
],
[
190,
652,
210,
667
],
[
212,
652,
242,
667
],
[
245,
652,
278,
667
],
[
284,
652,
307,
667
],
[
310,
652,
328,
667
],
[
331,
652,
397,
667
],
[
400,
652,
440,
667
],
[
442,
652,
459,
667
],
[
462,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
548,
667
],
[
552,
652,
630,
667
],
[
465,
715,
566,
755
],
[
574,
712,
683,
751
],
[
470,
777,
522,
790
],
[
527,
778,
578,
790
],
[
470,
791,
542,
805
],
[
546,
793,
607,
805
],
[
470,
808,
565,
821
],
[
569,
808,
640,
821
],
[
643,
808,
707,
822
],
[
710,
808,
742,
822
],
[
208,
851,
299,
862
],
[
301,
851,
365,
862
],
[
369,
851,
431,
862
],
[
434,
851,
464,
862
],
[
467,
851,
476,
863
],
[
482,
851,
500,
863
],
[
504,
851,
576,
863
],
[
583,
851,
592,
863
],
[
600,
851,
632,
863
],
[
636,
850,
677,
863
],
[
680,
850,
746,
863
],
[
749,
850,
793,
863
],
[
194,
862,
248,
877
],
[
250,
862,
278,
875
],
[
281,
862,
350,
875
],
[
352,
863,
365,
875
],
[
368,
864,
401,
877
],
[
404,
865,
444,
879
],
[
405,
863,
500,
875
],
[
506,
863,
517,
875
],
[
521,
863,
802,
877
],
[
254,
886,
290,
901
],
[
298,
886,
342,
902
],
[
349,
886,
361,
902
],
[
367,
886,
399,
902
],
[
402,
887,
475,
902
],
[
481,
887,
493,
902
],
[
499,
887,
528,
903
],
[
532,
887,
587,
903
],
[
592,
887,
605,
903
],
[
611,
886,
679,
903
],
[
682,
886,
747,
902
],
[
229,
981,
294,
998
],
[
298,
981,
773,
998
]
] |
What is the fullform of ILS?
|
INTERNATIONAL LITIGATION SERVICES
|
722
|
[
"American",
"*",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"NW.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20503",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"on",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC",
"or",
"the",
"Council)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
".",
"The",
"Council",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry-",
"ACC",
"and",
"its",
"members",
"make",
"substantial,",
"ongoing",
"investments",
"in",
"research",
"to",
"support",
"product",
"development,",
"health,",
"safety",
"and",
"environmental",
"protection,",
"and",
"to",
"abide",
"by",
"product",
"stewardship",
"and",
"regulatory",
"policies.",
"Chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"science-based",
"industry,",
"and",
"ACC",
"has",
"long",
"sought",
"to",
"improve",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"government",
"science",
"generally",
"and",
"risk",
"assessment",
"in",
"particular.",
"For",
"example,",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"OMB's",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,",
"ACC",
"filed",
"an",
"extensive",
"set",
"of",
"comments",
"(63",
"pages",
"plus",
"five",
"appendices)",
"that",
"primarily",
"focused",
"on",
"EPA's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"practices.\"",
"Appendix",
"5",
"to",
"those",
"comments",
"provided",
"62",
"additional",
"pages",
"of",
"examples",
"of",
"EPA",
"risk",
"assessments",
"that",
"overstated",
"risks.",
"ACC's",
"comments",
"were",
"the",
"principal",
"drivers",
"behind",
"EPA's",
"2004",
"staff",
"paper",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"principles",
"and",
"practices",
"-",
"a",
"document",
"which",
"defended",
"the",
"appropriateness",
"of",
"many",
"of",
"the",
"practices",
"to",
"which",
"ACC",
"objected.*",
"These",
"controversies",
"are",
"still",
"largely",
"unresolved,",
"and",
"thus",
"ACC",
"has",
"a",
"substantial",
"interest",
"in",
"the",
"Bulletin.",
"Notice",
"of",
"availability",
"at",
"71",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2600",
"(Jan.",
"17,",
"2006).",
"Council",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"The",
"Council",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care",
",",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$460",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporter,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"invest",
"more",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development",
"than",
"any",
"other",
"business",
"sector.",
"'ACC,",
"\"Comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"&",
"Budget;",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,\"",
"filed",
"May",
"5,",
"2003.",
"These",
"comments",
"and",
"Appendix",
"5",
"are",
"attached.",
"EPA",
"Office",
"of",
"the",
"Science",
"Advisor",
"Staff",
"Paper,",
"An",
"Examination",
"of",
"EPA",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Principles",
"and",
"Practices",
"(EPA/100/B-04/001)",
"(Feb.",
"2004).",
"Responsible",
"Care",
"1300",
"Wilson",
"Boulevard,",
"Arlington,",
"VA",
"23209",
".",
"Tel",
"703-741-5000",
".",
"Fax",
"703-741-6000",
".",
"hap:/www.americanchemistry.com",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
716,
89,
833,
109
],
[
842,
90,
861,
106
],
[
745,
109,
870,
130
],
[
717,
127,
814,
145
],
[
83,
213,
109,
228
],
[
112,
214,
165,
228
],
[
169,
214,
213,
229
],
[
734,
213,
773,
227
],
[
776,
214,
801,
228
],
[
804,
213,
845,
228
],
[
82,
230,
133,
246
],
[
137,
230,
155,
247
],
[
158,
230,
254,
247
],
[
257,
231,
286,
247
],
[
290,
231,
379,
247
],
[
383,
230,
441,
247
],
[
83,
248,
134,
264
],
[
138,
249,
154,
264
],
[
158,
249,
262,
264
],
[
266,
249,
295,
265
],
[
299,
249,
358,
265
],
[
84,
265,
114,
281
],
[
117,
265,
154,
281
],
[
157,
265,
207,
281
],
[
211,
265,
250,
281
],
[
82,
283,
118,
298
],
[
124,
283,
205,
299
],
[
208,
283,
260,
300
],
[
263,
283,
335,
302
],
[
84,
300,
127,
315
],
[
137,
300,
187,
315
],
[
84,
317,
184,
333
],
[
186,
317,
214,
333
],
[
224,
316,
275,
333
],
[
141,
353,
175,
368
],
[
201,
354,
286,
368
],
[
290,
354,
311,
369
],
[
314,
354,
389,
369
],
[
392,
354,
431,
369
],
[
434,
353,
528,
370
],
[
531,
353,
597,
370
],
[
81,
388,
121,
403
],
[
125,
387,
152,
403
],
[
155,
387,
202,
403
],
[
85,
423,
115,
438
],
[
118,
423,
198,
438
],
[
200,
423,
284,
439
],
[
287,
423,
351,
439
],
[
354,
423,
401,
439
],
[
404,
424,
422,
439
],
[
425,
424,
452,
439
],
[
455,
424,
525,
439
],
[
529,
424,
542,
439
],
[
546,
424,
607,
439
],
[
610,
424,
627,
439
],
[
631,
424,
686,
439
],
[
690,
423,
771,
439
],
[
775,
423,
796,
438
],
[
800,
423,
825,
438
],
[
828,
423,
880,
438
],
[
884,
423,
903,
438
],
[
82,
440,
187,
457
],
[
190,
440,
218,
457
],
[
221,
440,
295,
456
],
[
298,
440,
372,
456
],
[
375,
440,
415,
456
],
[
418,
440,
511,
456
],
[
514,
440,
581,
456
],
[
584,
440,
598,
456
],
[
602,
440,
631,
456
],
[
635,
440,
699,
457
],
[
702,
440,
782,
457
],
[
786,
440,
811,
457
],
[
815,
440,
872,
457
],
[
83,
459,
168,
473
],
[
171,
459,
238,
474
],
[
241,
459,
258,
474
],
[
261,
459,
287,
474
],
[
290,
458,
359,
474
],
[
362,
458,
380,
474
],
[
383,
458,
467,
474
],
[
84,
492,
124,
508
],
[
128,
493,
156,
508
],
[
160,
493,
180,
509
],
[
184,
493,
257,
509
],
[
260,
493,
304,
509
],
[
308,
493,
398,
509
],
[
402,
494,
467,
509
],
[
471,
494,
565,
509
],
[
569,
494,
585,
509
],
[
589,
494,
657,
509
],
[
661,
494,
677,
509
],
[
681,
494,
741,
509
],
[
744,
493,
810,
509
],
[
813,
493,
918,
509
],
[
83,
511,
137,
526
],
[
140,
512,
188,
526
],
[
191,
512,
221,
526
],
[
224,
512,
339,
526
],
[
342,
512,
429,
527
],
[
432,
513,
462,
527
],
[
465,
513,
482,
527
],
[
486,
512,
530,
527
],
[
534,
512,
555,
527
],
[
558,
512,
620,
527
],
[
624,
512,
719,
527
],
[
722,
512,
752,
526
],
[
755,
511,
837,
526
],
[
840,
511,
910,
526
],
[
83,
528,
165,
543
],
[
167,
528,
184,
543
],
[
187,
528,
198,
544
],
[
200,
528,
311,
544
],
[
314,
528,
385,
544
],
[
388,
528,
420,
544
],
[
422,
528,
464,
544
],
[
467,
528,
494,
543
],
[
497,
528,
535,
543
],
[
538,
528,
592,
543
],
[
595,
528,
611,
543
],
[
614,
528,
682,
543
],
[
685,
528,
712,
543
],
[
715,
528,
771,
543
],
[
774,
528,
793,
543
],
[
796,
528,
887,
543
],
[
82,
546,
141,
561
],
[
145,
546,
219,
561
],
[
223,
546,
251,
561
],
[
255,
546,
287,
561
],
[
291,
545,
378,
561
],
[
382,
545,
398,
561
],
[
402,
545,
488,
561
],
[
492,
545,
522,
561
],
[
525,
545,
597,
561
],
[
601,
545,
617,
561
],
[
621,
545,
690,
561
],
[
694,
545,
712,
561
],
[
715,
545,
775,
561
],
[
778,
545,
821,
561
],
[
825,
545,
866,
561
],
[
870,
544,
927,
561
],
[
82,
564,
98,
578
],
[
102,
563,
177,
579
],
[
180,
563,
201,
579
],
[
204,
563,
230,
579
],
[
234,
563,
279,
579
],
[
282,
563,
312,
579
],
[
315,
563,
382,
579
],
[
386,
563,
403,
579
],
[
407,
563,
467,
579
],
[
470,
563,
571,
579
],
[
575,
563,
614,
579
],
[
620,
563,
657,
579
],
[
660,
563,
680,
579
],
[
684,
563,
759,
579
],
[
762,
563,
786,
578
],
[
790,
563,
808,
578
],
[
811,
563,
892,
578
],
[
895,
564,
925,
578
],
[
83,
581,
128,
596
],
[
131,
581,
165,
596
],
[
169,
581,
201,
596
],
[
204,
581,
299,
596
],
[
302,
581,
334,
595
],
[
337,
581,
412,
595
],
[
415,
581,
478,
595
],
[
481,
581,
504,
595
],
[
507,
581,
559,
595
],
[
562,
581,
595,
595
],
[
597,
580,
685,
595
],
[
688,
580,
777,
596
],
[
780,
580,
860,
596
],
[
862,
580,
874,
596
],
[
877,
580,
896,
596
],
[
84,
598,
124,
613
],
[
128,
598,
210,
613
],
[
214,
598,
285,
613
],
[
288,
598,
310,
613
],
[
313,
598,
392,
613
],
[
395,
598,
442,
613
],
[
446,
598,
464,
613
],
[
467,
598,
544,
613
],
[
547,
598,
565,
613
],
[
568,
598,
605,
613
],
[
610,
598,
642,
613
],
[
645,
597,
740,
613
],
[
744,
597,
775,
613
],
[
780,
597,
860,
613
],
[
864,
597,
910,
613
],
[
84,
615,
138,
631
],
[
142,
615,
225,
631
],
[
228,
615,
266,
631
],
[
270,
615,
295,
631
],
[
298,
615,
373,
631
],
[
377,
615,
429,
631
],
[
432,
615,
488,
630
],
[
492,
615,
544,
630
],
[
548,
615,
589,
630
],
[
593,
615,
628,
630
],
[
631,
615,
677,
630
],
[
681,
615,
701,
631
],
[
704,
615,
731,
631
],
[
735,
615,
809,
631
],
[
813,
615,
847,
631
],
[
82,
634,
170,
648
],
[
174,
634,
252,
648
],
[
256,
633,
286,
648
],
[
289,
633,
361,
648
],
[
364,
633,
376,
648
],
[
379,
633,
392,
648
],
[
397,
633,
472,
649
],
[
475,
633,
526,
649
],
[
532,
633,
601,
649
],
[
605,
633,
631,
649
],
[
634,
633,
759,
649
],
[
762,
633,
780,
648
],
[
783,
633,
829,
648
],
[
832,
633,
850,
648
],
[
853,
633,
877,
648
],
[
84,
650,
152,
665
],
[
156,
650,
174,
665
],
[
178,
650,
227,
665
],
[
231,
650,
271,
665
],
[
276,
650,
360,
665
],
[
365,
650,
411,
665
],
[
414,
650,
521,
666
],
[
525,
649,
550,
666
],
[
554,
649,
584,
666
],
[
587,
649,
643,
666
],
[
647,
649,
740,
666
],
[
744,
650,
772,
666
],
[
776,
650,
812,
666
],
[
816,
650,
855,
666
],
[
858,
650,
887,
666
],
[
891,
650,
898,
666
],
[
83,
667,
167,
683
],
[
171,
667,
230,
682
],
[
234,
667,
250,
682
],
[
254,
667,
280,
682
],
[
283,
667,
354,
683
],
[
92,
704,
138,
720
],
[
142,
705,
155,
720
],
[
158,
705,
233,
720
],
[
237,
706,
250,
720
],
[
254,
706,
268,
720
],
[
271,
706,
302,
720
],
[
305,
706,
337,
720
],
[
341,
706,
374,
720
],
[
377,
706,
410,
720
],
[
413,
706,
434,
720
],
[
437,
706,
483,
720
],
[
91,
721,
143,
735
],
[
146,
722,
208,
735
],
[
211,
722,
248,
735
],
[
252,
723,
272,
735
],
[
275,
723,
324,
735
],
[
328,
723,
342,
735
],
[
345,
723,
411,
735
],
[
414,
724,
428,
735
],
[
431,
724,
467,
735
],
[
470,
724,
540,
735
],
[
544,
724,
602,
735
],
[
605,
724,
630,
735
],
[
632,
723,
687,
735
],
[
690,
723,
715,
735
],
[
718,
723,
754,
735
],
[
757,
722,
814,
735
],
[
817,
722,
848,
735
],
[
851,
722,
895,
735
],
[
84,
736,
140,
750
],
[
144,
736,
167,
750
],
[
171,
737,
212,
751
],
[
216,
737,
241,
751
],
[
244,
737,
296,
751
],
[
300,
737,
312,
751
],
[
315,
737,
385,
751
],
[
389,
737,
402,
751
],
[
405,
737,
469,
751
],
[
472,
738,
571,
751
],
[
574,
738,
616,
751
],
[
620,
737,
644,
750
],
[
648,
737,
686,
750
],
[
690,
737,
773,
750
],
[
777,
737,
828,
750
],
[
832,
736,
915,
750
],
[
84,
754,
117,
769
],
[
120,
754,
126,
768
],
[
128,
754,
188,
768
],
[
191,
755,
227,
768
],
[
230,
755,
295,
768
],
[
298,
755,
355,
768
],
[
358,
755,
372,
768
],
[
375,
755,
424,
768
],
[
427,
755,
466,
768
],
[
469,
755,
511,
768
],
[
514,
755,
556,
768
],
[
559,
755,
605,
768
],
[
608,
755,
631,
768
],
[
634,
755,
676,
768
],
[
679,
755,
704,
768
],
[
707,
755,
801,
768
],
[
804,
755,
861,
767
],
[
864,
755,
887,
767
],
[
83,
770,
132,
783
],
[
135,
770,
191,
783
],
[
193,
770,
218,
783
],
[
221,
770,
279,
783
],
[
281,
770,
297,
783
],
[
300,
770,
364,
783
],
[
367,
770,
379,
783
],
[
382,
770,
391,
783
],
[
394,
770,
427,
783
],
[
430,
770,
475,
783
],
[
478,
770,
543,
783
],
[
546,
770,
571,
783
],
[
574,
770,
582,
783
],
[
585,
770,
610,
783
],
[
613,
770,
666,
783
],
[
669,
770,
684,
783
],
[
687,
770,
707,
783
],
[
710,
770,
765,
783
],
[
768,
770,
837,
783
],
[
840,
770,
850,
783
],
[
853,
770,
866,
783
],
[
869,
770,
892,
783
],
[
81,
784,
135,
796
],
[
138,
784,
184,
796
],
[
187,
784,
246,
796
],
[
249,
784,
322,
796
],
[
325,
784,
345,
796
],
[
349,
784,
370,
796
],
[
372,
784,
407,
796
],
[
410,
784,
432,
796
],
[
435,
784,
450,
796
],
[
452,
784,
492,
796
],
[
496,
784,
532,
796
],
[
535,
784,
550,
796
],
[
553,
784,
582,
796
],
[
585,
784,
643,
796
],
[
646,
784,
715,
796
],
[
718,
784,
789,
796
],
[
792,
784,
832,
796
],
[
835,
784,
870,
796
],
[
873,
784,
887,
796
],
[
82,
800,
138,
812
],
[
141,
800,
167,
812
],
[
171,
800,
254,
812
],
[
257,
800,
287,
812
],
[
290,
800,
314,
812
],
[
317,
800,
352,
812
],
[
355,
800,
412,
812
],
[
415,
800,
460,
812
],
[
81,
811,
128,
826
],
[
132,
812,
211,
826
],
[
214,
812,
228,
826
],
[
231,
812,
253,
826
],
[
256,
812,
298,
826
],
[
302,
813,
316,
826
],
[
319,
813,
406,
826
],
[
409,
813,
422,
826
],
[
425,
813,
477,
826
],
[
480,
813,
517,
826
],
[
520,
813,
554,
826
],
[
557,
813,
603,
826
],
[
606,
813,
620,
826
],
[
623,
813,
684,
826
],
[
687,
813,
704,
826
],
[
707,
813,
729,
826
],
[
732,
813,
770,
826
],
[
772,
813,
797,
826
],
[
800,
812,
856,
826
],
[
858,
812,
873,
826
],
[
876,
812,
928,
826
],
[
82,
827,
172,
840
],
[
175,
827,
207,
840
],
[
209,
827,
241,
841
],
[
244,
827,
257,
841
],
[
260,
827,
303,
841
],
[
305,
827,
345,
841
],
[
348,
827,
417,
841
],
[
419,
827,
445,
841
],
[
448,
827,
514,
841
],
[
516,
827,
525,
841
],
[
527,
827,
550,
841
],
[
552,
828,
611,
840
],
[
91,
840,
123,
854
],
[
127,
840,
170,
855
],
[
172,
841,
187,
855
],
[
190,
841,
211,
855
],
[
214,
841,
267,
855
],
[
270,
841,
322,
856
],
[
326,
841,
358,
856
],
[
361,
841,
403,
856
],
[
406,
841,
427,
856
],
[
430,
841,
514,
856
],
[
517,
842,
531,
856
],
[
535,
842,
565,
856
],
[
568,
842,
596,
856
],
[
600,
842,
675,
856
],
[
679,
842,
747,
856
],
[
750,
842,
775,
855
],
[
778,
842,
844,
855
],
[
82,
856,
220,
869
],
[
223,
855,
259,
869
],
[
262,
855,
308,
870
],
[
118,
903,
183,
915
],
[
185,
902,
216,
915
],
[
114,
935,
143,
947
],
[
147,
934,
189,
947
],
[
192,
934,
258,
947
],
[
261,
934,
323,
947
],
[
327,
934,
347,
947
],
[
354,
934,
395,
947
],
[
400,
934,
411,
947
],
[
418,
934,
437,
947
],
[
441,
934,
527,
947
],
[
532,
934,
544,
947
],
[
549,
934,
575,
947
],
[
580,
934,
667,
947
],
[
671,
934,
681,
947
],
[
687,
935,
898,
948
],
[
224,
981,
291,
997
],
[
295,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the issued date of this letter?
|
June 15, 2006
|
722
|
[
"American",
"*",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"NW.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20503",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"on",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC",
"or",
"the",
"Council)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
".",
"The",
"Council",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry-",
"ACC",
"and",
"its",
"members",
"make",
"substantial,",
"ongoing",
"investments",
"in",
"research",
"to",
"support",
"product",
"development,",
"health,",
"safety",
"and",
"environmental",
"protection,",
"and",
"to",
"abide",
"by",
"product",
"stewardship",
"and",
"regulatory",
"policies.",
"Chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"science-based",
"industry,",
"and",
"ACC",
"has",
"long",
"sought",
"to",
"improve",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"government",
"science",
"generally",
"and",
"risk",
"assessment",
"in",
"particular.",
"For",
"example,",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"OMB's",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,",
"ACC",
"filed",
"an",
"extensive",
"set",
"of",
"comments",
"(63",
"pages",
"plus",
"five",
"appendices)",
"that",
"primarily",
"focused",
"on",
"EPA's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"practices.\"",
"Appendix",
"5",
"to",
"those",
"comments",
"provided",
"62",
"additional",
"pages",
"of",
"examples",
"of",
"EPA",
"risk",
"assessments",
"that",
"overstated",
"risks.",
"ACC's",
"comments",
"were",
"the",
"principal",
"drivers",
"behind",
"EPA's",
"2004",
"staff",
"paper",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"principles",
"and",
"practices",
"-",
"a",
"document",
"which",
"defended",
"the",
"appropriateness",
"of",
"many",
"of",
"the",
"practices",
"to",
"which",
"ACC",
"objected.*",
"These",
"controversies",
"are",
"still",
"largely",
"unresolved,",
"and",
"thus",
"ACC",
"has",
"a",
"substantial",
"interest",
"in",
"the",
"Bulletin.",
"Notice",
"of",
"availability",
"at",
"71",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2600",
"(Jan.",
"17,",
"2006).",
"Council",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"The",
"Council",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care",
",",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$460",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporter,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"invest",
"more",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development",
"than",
"any",
"other",
"business",
"sector.",
"'ACC,",
"\"Comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"&",
"Budget;",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,\"",
"filed",
"May",
"5,",
"2003.",
"These",
"comments",
"and",
"Appendix",
"5",
"are",
"attached.",
"EPA",
"Office",
"of",
"the",
"Science",
"Advisor",
"Staff",
"Paper,",
"An",
"Examination",
"of",
"EPA",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Principles",
"and",
"Practices",
"(EPA/100/B-04/001)",
"(Feb.",
"2004).",
"Responsible",
"Care",
"1300",
"Wilson",
"Boulevard,",
"Arlington,",
"VA",
"23209",
".",
"Tel",
"703-741-5000",
".",
"Fax",
"703-741-6000",
".",
"hap:/www.americanchemistry.com",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
716,
89,
833,
109
],
[
842,
90,
861,
106
],
[
745,
109,
870,
130
],
[
717,
127,
814,
145
],
[
83,
213,
109,
228
],
[
112,
214,
165,
228
],
[
169,
214,
213,
229
],
[
734,
213,
773,
227
],
[
776,
214,
801,
228
],
[
804,
213,
845,
228
],
[
82,
230,
133,
246
],
[
137,
230,
155,
247
],
[
158,
230,
254,
247
],
[
257,
231,
286,
247
],
[
290,
231,
379,
247
],
[
383,
230,
441,
247
],
[
83,
248,
134,
264
],
[
138,
249,
154,
264
],
[
158,
249,
262,
264
],
[
266,
249,
295,
265
],
[
299,
249,
358,
265
],
[
84,
265,
114,
281
],
[
117,
265,
154,
281
],
[
157,
265,
207,
281
],
[
211,
265,
250,
281
],
[
82,
283,
118,
298
],
[
124,
283,
205,
299
],
[
208,
283,
260,
300
],
[
263,
283,
335,
302
],
[
84,
300,
127,
315
],
[
137,
300,
187,
315
],
[
84,
317,
184,
333
],
[
186,
317,
214,
333
],
[
224,
316,
275,
333
],
[
141,
353,
175,
368
],
[
201,
354,
286,
368
],
[
290,
354,
311,
369
],
[
314,
354,
389,
369
],
[
392,
354,
431,
369
],
[
434,
353,
528,
370
],
[
531,
353,
597,
370
],
[
81,
388,
121,
403
],
[
125,
387,
152,
403
],
[
155,
387,
202,
403
],
[
85,
423,
115,
438
],
[
118,
423,
198,
438
],
[
200,
423,
284,
439
],
[
287,
423,
351,
439
],
[
354,
423,
401,
439
],
[
404,
424,
422,
439
],
[
425,
424,
452,
439
],
[
455,
424,
525,
439
],
[
529,
424,
542,
439
],
[
546,
424,
607,
439
],
[
610,
424,
627,
439
],
[
631,
424,
686,
439
],
[
690,
423,
771,
439
],
[
775,
423,
796,
438
],
[
800,
423,
825,
438
],
[
828,
423,
880,
438
],
[
884,
423,
903,
438
],
[
82,
440,
187,
457
],
[
190,
440,
218,
457
],
[
221,
440,
295,
456
],
[
298,
440,
372,
456
],
[
375,
440,
415,
456
],
[
418,
440,
511,
456
],
[
514,
440,
581,
456
],
[
584,
440,
598,
456
],
[
602,
440,
631,
456
],
[
635,
440,
699,
457
],
[
702,
440,
782,
457
],
[
786,
440,
811,
457
],
[
815,
440,
872,
457
],
[
83,
459,
168,
473
],
[
171,
459,
238,
474
],
[
241,
459,
258,
474
],
[
261,
459,
287,
474
],
[
290,
458,
359,
474
],
[
362,
458,
380,
474
],
[
383,
458,
467,
474
],
[
84,
492,
124,
508
],
[
128,
493,
156,
508
],
[
160,
493,
180,
509
],
[
184,
493,
257,
509
],
[
260,
493,
304,
509
],
[
308,
493,
398,
509
],
[
402,
494,
467,
509
],
[
471,
494,
565,
509
],
[
569,
494,
585,
509
],
[
589,
494,
657,
509
],
[
661,
494,
677,
509
],
[
681,
494,
741,
509
],
[
744,
493,
810,
509
],
[
813,
493,
918,
509
],
[
83,
511,
137,
526
],
[
140,
512,
188,
526
],
[
191,
512,
221,
526
],
[
224,
512,
339,
526
],
[
342,
512,
429,
527
],
[
432,
513,
462,
527
],
[
465,
513,
482,
527
],
[
486,
512,
530,
527
],
[
534,
512,
555,
527
],
[
558,
512,
620,
527
],
[
624,
512,
719,
527
],
[
722,
512,
752,
526
],
[
755,
511,
837,
526
],
[
840,
511,
910,
526
],
[
83,
528,
165,
543
],
[
167,
528,
184,
543
],
[
187,
528,
198,
544
],
[
200,
528,
311,
544
],
[
314,
528,
385,
544
],
[
388,
528,
420,
544
],
[
422,
528,
464,
544
],
[
467,
528,
494,
543
],
[
497,
528,
535,
543
],
[
538,
528,
592,
543
],
[
595,
528,
611,
543
],
[
614,
528,
682,
543
],
[
685,
528,
712,
543
],
[
715,
528,
771,
543
],
[
774,
528,
793,
543
],
[
796,
528,
887,
543
],
[
82,
546,
141,
561
],
[
145,
546,
219,
561
],
[
223,
546,
251,
561
],
[
255,
546,
287,
561
],
[
291,
545,
378,
561
],
[
382,
545,
398,
561
],
[
402,
545,
488,
561
],
[
492,
545,
522,
561
],
[
525,
545,
597,
561
],
[
601,
545,
617,
561
],
[
621,
545,
690,
561
],
[
694,
545,
712,
561
],
[
715,
545,
775,
561
],
[
778,
545,
821,
561
],
[
825,
545,
866,
561
],
[
870,
544,
927,
561
],
[
82,
564,
98,
578
],
[
102,
563,
177,
579
],
[
180,
563,
201,
579
],
[
204,
563,
230,
579
],
[
234,
563,
279,
579
],
[
282,
563,
312,
579
],
[
315,
563,
382,
579
],
[
386,
563,
403,
579
],
[
407,
563,
467,
579
],
[
470,
563,
571,
579
],
[
575,
563,
614,
579
],
[
620,
563,
657,
579
],
[
660,
563,
680,
579
],
[
684,
563,
759,
579
],
[
762,
563,
786,
578
],
[
790,
563,
808,
578
],
[
811,
563,
892,
578
],
[
895,
564,
925,
578
],
[
83,
581,
128,
596
],
[
131,
581,
165,
596
],
[
169,
581,
201,
596
],
[
204,
581,
299,
596
],
[
302,
581,
334,
595
],
[
337,
581,
412,
595
],
[
415,
581,
478,
595
],
[
481,
581,
504,
595
],
[
507,
581,
559,
595
],
[
562,
581,
595,
595
],
[
597,
580,
685,
595
],
[
688,
580,
777,
596
],
[
780,
580,
860,
596
],
[
862,
580,
874,
596
],
[
877,
580,
896,
596
],
[
84,
598,
124,
613
],
[
128,
598,
210,
613
],
[
214,
598,
285,
613
],
[
288,
598,
310,
613
],
[
313,
598,
392,
613
],
[
395,
598,
442,
613
],
[
446,
598,
464,
613
],
[
467,
598,
544,
613
],
[
547,
598,
565,
613
],
[
568,
598,
605,
613
],
[
610,
598,
642,
613
],
[
645,
597,
740,
613
],
[
744,
597,
775,
613
],
[
780,
597,
860,
613
],
[
864,
597,
910,
613
],
[
84,
615,
138,
631
],
[
142,
615,
225,
631
],
[
228,
615,
266,
631
],
[
270,
615,
295,
631
],
[
298,
615,
373,
631
],
[
377,
615,
429,
631
],
[
432,
615,
488,
630
],
[
492,
615,
544,
630
],
[
548,
615,
589,
630
],
[
593,
615,
628,
630
],
[
631,
615,
677,
630
],
[
681,
615,
701,
631
],
[
704,
615,
731,
631
],
[
735,
615,
809,
631
],
[
813,
615,
847,
631
],
[
82,
634,
170,
648
],
[
174,
634,
252,
648
],
[
256,
633,
286,
648
],
[
289,
633,
361,
648
],
[
364,
633,
376,
648
],
[
379,
633,
392,
648
],
[
397,
633,
472,
649
],
[
475,
633,
526,
649
],
[
532,
633,
601,
649
],
[
605,
633,
631,
649
],
[
634,
633,
759,
649
],
[
762,
633,
780,
648
],
[
783,
633,
829,
648
],
[
832,
633,
850,
648
],
[
853,
633,
877,
648
],
[
84,
650,
152,
665
],
[
156,
650,
174,
665
],
[
178,
650,
227,
665
],
[
231,
650,
271,
665
],
[
276,
650,
360,
665
],
[
365,
650,
411,
665
],
[
414,
650,
521,
666
],
[
525,
649,
550,
666
],
[
554,
649,
584,
666
],
[
587,
649,
643,
666
],
[
647,
649,
740,
666
],
[
744,
650,
772,
666
],
[
776,
650,
812,
666
],
[
816,
650,
855,
666
],
[
858,
650,
887,
666
],
[
891,
650,
898,
666
],
[
83,
667,
167,
683
],
[
171,
667,
230,
682
],
[
234,
667,
250,
682
],
[
254,
667,
280,
682
],
[
283,
667,
354,
683
],
[
92,
704,
138,
720
],
[
142,
705,
155,
720
],
[
158,
705,
233,
720
],
[
237,
706,
250,
720
],
[
254,
706,
268,
720
],
[
271,
706,
302,
720
],
[
305,
706,
337,
720
],
[
341,
706,
374,
720
],
[
377,
706,
410,
720
],
[
413,
706,
434,
720
],
[
437,
706,
483,
720
],
[
91,
721,
143,
735
],
[
146,
722,
208,
735
],
[
211,
722,
248,
735
],
[
252,
723,
272,
735
],
[
275,
723,
324,
735
],
[
328,
723,
342,
735
],
[
345,
723,
411,
735
],
[
414,
724,
428,
735
],
[
431,
724,
467,
735
],
[
470,
724,
540,
735
],
[
544,
724,
602,
735
],
[
605,
724,
630,
735
],
[
632,
723,
687,
735
],
[
690,
723,
715,
735
],
[
718,
723,
754,
735
],
[
757,
722,
814,
735
],
[
817,
722,
848,
735
],
[
851,
722,
895,
735
],
[
84,
736,
140,
750
],
[
144,
736,
167,
750
],
[
171,
737,
212,
751
],
[
216,
737,
241,
751
],
[
244,
737,
296,
751
],
[
300,
737,
312,
751
],
[
315,
737,
385,
751
],
[
389,
737,
402,
751
],
[
405,
737,
469,
751
],
[
472,
738,
571,
751
],
[
574,
738,
616,
751
],
[
620,
737,
644,
750
],
[
648,
737,
686,
750
],
[
690,
737,
773,
750
],
[
777,
737,
828,
750
],
[
832,
736,
915,
750
],
[
84,
754,
117,
769
],
[
120,
754,
126,
768
],
[
128,
754,
188,
768
],
[
191,
755,
227,
768
],
[
230,
755,
295,
768
],
[
298,
755,
355,
768
],
[
358,
755,
372,
768
],
[
375,
755,
424,
768
],
[
427,
755,
466,
768
],
[
469,
755,
511,
768
],
[
514,
755,
556,
768
],
[
559,
755,
605,
768
],
[
608,
755,
631,
768
],
[
634,
755,
676,
768
],
[
679,
755,
704,
768
],
[
707,
755,
801,
768
],
[
804,
755,
861,
767
],
[
864,
755,
887,
767
],
[
83,
770,
132,
783
],
[
135,
770,
191,
783
],
[
193,
770,
218,
783
],
[
221,
770,
279,
783
],
[
281,
770,
297,
783
],
[
300,
770,
364,
783
],
[
367,
770,
379,
783
],
[
382,
770,
391,
783
],
[
394,
770,
427,
783
],
[
430,
770,
475,
783
],
[
478,
770,
543,
783
],
[
546,
770,
571,
783
],
[
574,
770,
582,
783
],
[
585,
770,
610,
783
],
[
613,
770,
666,
783
],
[
669,
770,
684,
783
],
[
687,
770,
707,
783
],
[
710,
770,
765,
783
],
[
768,
770,
837,
783
],
[
840,
770,
850,
783
],
[
853,
770,
866,
783
],
[
869,
770,
892,
783
],
[
81,
784,
135,
796
],
[
138,
784,
184,
796
],
[
187,
784,
246,
796
],
[
249,
784,
322,
796
],
[
325,
784,
345,
796
],
[
349,
784,
370,
796
],
[
372,
784,
407,
796
],
[
410,
784,
432,
796
],
[
435,
784,
450,
796
],
[
452,
784,
492,
796
],
[
496,
784,
532,
796
],
[
535,
784,
550,
796
],
[
553,
784,
582,
796
],
[
585,
784,
643,
796
],
[
646,
784,
715,
796
],
[
718,
784,
789,
796
],
[
792,
784,
832,
796
],
[
835,
784,
870,
796
],
[
873,
784,
887,
796
],
[
82,
800,
138,
812
],
[
141,
800,
167,
812
],
[
171,
800,
254,
812
],
[
257,
800,
287,
812
],
[
290,
800,
314,
812
],
[
317,
800,
352,
812
],
[
355,
800,
412,
812
],
[
415,
800,
460,
812
],
[
81,
811,
128,
826
],
[
132,
812,
211,
826
],
[
214,
812,
228,
826
],
[
231,
812,
253,
826
],
[
256,
812,
298,
826
],
[
302,
813,
316,
826
],
[
319,
813,
406,
826
],
[
409,
813,
422,
826
],
[
425,
813,
477,
826
],
[
480,
813,
517,
826
],
[
520,
813,
554,
826
],
[
557,
813,
603,
826
],
[
606,
813,
620,
826
],
[
623,
813,
684,
826
],
[
687,
813,
704,
826
],
[
707,
813,
729,
826
],
[
732,
813,
770,
826
],
[
772,
813,
797,
826
],
[
800,
812,
856,
826
],
[
858,
812,
873,
826
],
[
876,
812,
928,
826
],
[
82,
827,
172,
840
],
[
175,
827,
207,
840
],
[
209,
827,
241,
841
],
[
244,
827,
257,
841
],
[
260,
827,
303,
841
],
[
305,
827,
345,
841
],
[
348,
827,
417,
841
],
[
419,
827,
445,
841
],
[
448,
827,
514,
841
],
[
516,
827,
525,
841
],
[
527,
827,
550,
841
],
[
552,
828,
611,
840
],
[
91,
840,
123,
854
],
[
127,
840,
170,
855
],
[
172,
841,
187,
855
],
[
190,
841,
211,
855
],
[
214,
841,
267,
855
],
[
270,
841,
322,
856
],
[
326,
841,
358,
856
],
[
361,
841,
403,
856
],
[
406,
841,
427,
856
],
[
430,
841,
514,
856
],
[
517,
842,
531,
856
],
[
535,
842,
565,
856
],
[
568,
842,
596,
856
],
[
600,
842,
675,
856
],
[
679,
842,
747,
856
],
[
750,
842,
775,
855
],
[
778,
842,
844,
855
],
[
82,
856,
220,
869
],
[
223,
855,
259,
869
],
[
262,
855,
308,
870
],
[
118,
903,
183,
915
],
[
185,
902,
216,
915
],
[
114,
935,
143,
947
],
[
147,
934,
189,
947
],
[
192,
934,
258,
947
],
[
261,
934,
323,
947
],
[
327,
934,
347,
947
],
[
354,
934,
395,
947
],
[
400,
934,
411,
947
],
[
418,
934,
437,
947
],
[
441,
934,
527,
947
],
[
532,
934,
544,
947
],
[
549,
934,
575,
947
],
[
580,
934,
667,
947
],
[
671,
934,
681,
947
],
[
687,
935,
898,
948
],
[
224,
981,
291,
997
],
[
295,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the subject of the letter?
|
comments on proposed risk assessment bulletin
|
722
|
[
"American",
"*",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"NW.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20503",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"on",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC",
"or",
"the",
"Council)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
".",
"The",
"Council",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry-",
"ACC",
"and",
"its",
"members",
"make",
"substantial,",
"ongoing",
"investments",
"in",
"research",
"to",
"support",
"product",
"development,",
"health,",
"safety",
"and",
"environmental",
"protection,",
"and",
"to",
"abide",
"by",
"product",
"stewardship",
"and",
"regulatory",
"policies.",
"Chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"science-based",
"industry,",
"and",
"ACC",
"has",
"long",
"sought",
"to",
"improve",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"government",
"science",
"generally",
"and",
"risk",
"assessment",
"in",
"particular.",
"For",
"example,",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"OMB's",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,",
"ACC",
"filed",
"an",
"extensive",
"set",
"of",
"comments",
"(63",
"pages",
"plus",
"five",
"appendices)",
"that",
"primarily",
"focused",
"on",
"EPA's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"practices.\"",
"Appendix",
"5",
"to",
"those",
"comments",
"provided",
"62",
"additional",
"pages",
"of",
"examples",
"of",
"EPA",
"risk",
"assessments",
"that",
"overstated",
"risks.",
"ACC's",
"comments",
"were",
"the",
"principal",
"drivers",
"behind",
"EPA's",
"2004",
"staff",
"paper",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"risk",
"assessment",
"principles",
"and",
"practices",
"-",
"a",
"document",
"which",
"defended",
"the",
"appropriateness",
"of",
"many",
"of",
"the",
"practices",
"to",
"which",
"ACC",
"objected.*",
"These",
"controversies",
"are",
"still",
"largely",
"unresolved,",
"and",
"thus",
"ACC",
"has",
"a",
"substantial",
"interest",
"in",
"the",
"Bulletin.",
"Notice",
"of",
"availability",
"at",
"71",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2600",
"(Jan.",
"17,",
"2006).",
"Council",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"The",
"Council",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care",
",",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$460",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporter,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"invest",
"more",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development",
"than",
"any",
"other",
"business",
"sector.",
"'ACC,",
"\"Comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"&",
"Budget;",
"Draft",
"2003",
"Report",
"to",
"Congress",
"on",
"the",
"Costs",
"and",
"Benefits",
"of",
"Federal",
"Regulations,\"",
"filed",
"May",
"5,",
"2003.",
"These",
"comments",
"and",
"Appendix",
"5",
"are",
"attached.",
"EPA",
"Office",
"of",
"the",
"Science",
"Advisor",
"Staff",
"Paper,",
"An",
"Examination",
"of",
"EPA",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Principles",
"and",
"Practices",
"(EPA/100/B-04/001)",
"(Feb.",
"2004).",
"Responsible",
"Care",
"1300",
"Wilson",
"Boulevard,",
"Arlington,",
"VA",
"23209",
".",
"Tel",
"703-741-5000",
".",
"Fax",
"703-741-6000",
".",
"hap:/www.americanchemistry.com",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
716,
89,
833,
109
],
[
842,
90,
861,
106
],
[
745,
109,
870,
130
],
[
717,
127,
814,
145
],
[
83,
213,
109,
228
],
[
112,
214,
165,
228
],
[
169,
214,
213,
229
],
[
734,
213,
773,
227
],
[
776,
214,
801,
228
],
[
804,
213,
845,
228
],
[
82,
230,
133,
246
],
[
137,
230,
155,
247
],
[
158,
230,
254,
247
],
[
257,
231,
286,
247
],
[
290,
231,
379,
247
],
[
383,
230,
441,
247
],
[
83,
248,
134,
264
],
[
138,
249,
154,
264
],
[
158,
249,
262,
264
],
[
266,
249,
295,
265
],
[
299,
249,
358,
265
],
[
84,
265,
114,
281
],
[
117,
265,
154,
281
],
[
157,
265,
207,
281
],
[
211,
265,
250,
281
],
[
82,
283,
118,
298
],
[
124,
283,
205,
299
],
[
208,
283,
260,
300
],
[
263,
283,
335,
302
],
[
84,
300,
127,
315
],
[
137,
300,
187,
315
],
[
84,
317,
184,
333
],
[
186,
317,
214,
333
],
[
224,
316,
275,
333
],
[
141,
353,
175,
368
],
[
201,
354,
286,
368
],
[
290,
354,
311,
369
],
[
314,
354,
389,
369
],
[
392,
354,
431,
369
],
[
434,
353,
528,
370
],
[
531,
353,
597,
370
],
[
81,
388,
121,
403
],
[
125,
387,
152,
403
],
[
155,
387,
202,
403
],
[
85,
423,
115,
438
],
[
118,
423,
198,
438
],
[
200,
423,
284,
439
],
[
287,
423,
351,
439
],
[
354,
423,
401,
439
],
[
404,
424,
422,
439
],
[
425,
424,
452,
439
],
[
455,
424,
525,
439
],
[
529,
424,
542,
439
],
[
546,
424,
607,
439
],
[
610,
424,
627,
439
],
[
631,
424,
686,
439
],
[
690,
423,
771,
439
],
[
775,
423,
796,
438
],
[
800,
423,
825,
438
],
[
828,
423,
880,
438
],
[
884,
423,
903,
438
],
[
82,
440,
187,
457
],
[
190,
440,
218,
457
],
[
221,
440,
295,
456
],
[
298,
440,
372,
456
],
[
375,
440,
415,
456
],
[
418,
440,
511,
456
],
[
514,
440,
581,
456
],
[
584,
440,
598,
456
],
[
602,
440,
631,
456
],
[
635,
440,
699,
457
],
[
702,
440,
782,
457
],
[
786,
440,
811,
457
],
[
815,
440,
872,
457
],
[
83,
459,
168,
473
],
[
171,
459,
238,
474
],
[
241,
459,
258,
474
],
[
261,
459,
287,
474
],
[
290,
458,
359,
474
],
[
362,
458,
380,
474
],
[
383,
458,
467,
474
],
[
84,
492,
124,
508
],
[
128,
493,
156,
508
],
[
160,
493,
180,
509
],
[
184,
493,
257,
509
],
[
260,
493,
304,
509
],
[
308,
493,
398,
509
],
[
402,
494,
467,
509
],
[
471,
494,
565,
509
],
[
569,
494,
585,
509
],
[
589,
494,
657,
509
],
[
661,
494,
677,
509
],
[
681,
494,
741,
509
],
[
744,
493,
810,
509
],
[
813,
493,
918,
509
],
[
83,
511,
137,
526
],
[
140,
512,
188,
526
],
[
191,
512,
221,
526
],
[
224,
512,
339,
526
],
[
342,
512,
429,
527
],
[
432,
513,
462,
527
],
[
465,
513,
482,
527
],
[
486,
512,
530,
527
],
[
534,
512,
555,
527
],
[
558,
512,
620,
527
],
[
624,
512,
719,
527
],
[
722,
512,
752,
526
],
[
755,
511,
837,
526
],
[
840,
511,
910,
526
],
[
83,
528,
165,
543
],
[
167,
528,
184,
543
],
[
187,
528,
198,
544
],
[
200,
528,
311,
544
],
[
314,
528,
385,
544
],
[
388,
528,
420,
544
],
[
422,
528,
464,
544
],
[
467,
528,
494,
543
],
[
497,
528,
535,
543
],
[
538,
528,
592,
543
],
[
595,
528,
611,
543
],
[
614,
528,
682,
543
],
[
685,
528,
712,
543
],
[
715,
528,
771,
543
],
[
774,
528,
793,
543
],
[
796,
528,
887,
543
],
[
82,
546,
141,
561
],
[
145,
546,
219,
561
],
[
223,
546,
251,
561
],
[
255,
546,
287,
561
],
[
291,
545,
378,
561
],
[
382,
545,
398,
561
],
[
402,
545,
488,
561
],
[
492,
545,
522,
561
],
[
525,
545,
597,
561
],
[
601,
545,
617,
561
],
[
621,
545,
690,
561
],
[
694,
545,
712,
561
],
[
715,
545,
775,
561
],
[
778,
545,
821,
561
],
[
825,
545,
866,
561
],
[
870,
544,
927,
561
],
[
82,
564,
98,
578
],
[
102,
563,
177,
579
],
[
180,
563,
201,
579
],
[
204,
563,
230,
579
],
[
234,
563,
279,
579
],
[
282,
563,
312,
579
],
[
315,
563,
382,
579
],
[
386,
563,
403,
579
],
[
407,
563,
467,
579
],
[
470,
563,
571,
579
],
[
575,
563,
614,
579
],
[
620,
563,
657,
579
],
[
660,
563,
680,
579
],
[
684,
563,
759,
579
],
[
762,
563,
786,
578
],
[
790,
563,
808,
578
],
[
811,
563,
892,
578
],
[
895,
564,
925,
578
],
[
83,
581,
128,
596
],
[
131,
581,
165,
596
],
[
169,
581,
201,
596
],
[
204,
581,
299,
596
],
[
302,
581,
334,
595
],
[
337,
581,
412,
595
],
[
415,
581,
478,
595
],
[
481,
581,
504,
595
],
[
507,
581,
559,
595
],
[
562,
581,
595,
595
],
[
597,
580,
685,
595
],
[
688,
580,
777,
596
],
[
780,
580,
860,
596
],
[
862,
580,
874,
596
],
[
877,
580,
896,
596
],
[
84,
598,
124,
613
],
[
128,
598,
210,
613
],
[
214,
598,
285,
613
],
[
288,
598,
310,
613
],
[
313,
598,
392,
613
],
[
395,
598,
442,
613
],
[
446,
598,
464,
613
],
[
467,
598,
544,
613
],
[
547,
598,
565,
613
],
[
568,
598,
605,
613
],
[
610,
598,
642,
613
],
[
645,
597,
740,
613
],
[
744,
597,
775,
613
],
[
780,
597,
860,
613
],
[
864,
597,
910,
613
],
[
84,
615,
138,
631
],
[
142,
615,
225,
631
],
[
228,
615,
266,
631
],
[
270,
615,
295,
631
],
[
298,
615,
373,
631
],
[
377,
615,
429,
631
],
[
432,
615,
488,
630
],
[
492,
615,
544,
630
],
[
548,
615,
589,
630
],
[
593,
615,
628,
630
],
[
631,
615,
677,
630
],
[
681,
615,
701,
631
],
[
704,
615,
731,
631
],
[
735,
615,
809,
631
],
[
813,
615,
847,
631
],
[
82,
634,
170,
648
],
[
174,
634,
252,
648
],
[
256,
633,
286,
648
],
[
289,
633,
361,
648
],
[
364,
633,
376,
648
],
[
379,
633,
392,
648
],
[
397,
633,
472,
649
],
[
475,
633,
526,
649
],
[
532,
633,
601,
649
],
[
605,
633,
631,
649
],
[
634,
633,
759,
649
],
[
762,
633,
780,
648
],
[
783,
633,
829,
648
],
[
832,
633,
850,
648
],
[
853,
633,
877,
648
],
[
84,
650,
152,
665
],
[
156,
650,
174,
665
],
[
178,
650,
227,
665
],
[
231,
650,
271,
665
],
[
276,
650,
360,
665
],
[
365,
650,
411,
665
],
[
414,
650,
521,
666
],
[
525,
649,
550,
666
],
[
554,
649,
584,
666
],
[
587,
649,
643,
666
],
[
647,
649,
740,
666
],
[
744,
650,
772,
666
],
[
776,
650,
812,
666
],
[
816,
650,
855,
666
],
[
858,
650,
887,
666
],
[
891,
650,
898,
666
],
[
83,
667,
167,
683
],
[
171,
667,
230,
682
],
[
234,
667,
250,
682
],
[
254,
667,
280,
682
],
[
283,
667,
354,
683
],
[
92,
704,
138,
720
],
[
142,
705,
155,
720
],
[
158,
705,
233,
720
],
[
237,
706,
250,
720
],
[
254,
706,
268,
720
],
[
271,
706,
302,
720
],
[
305,
706,
337,
720
],
[
341,
706,
374,
720
],
[
377,
706,
410,
720
],
[
413,
706,
434,
720
],
[
437,
706,
483,
720
],
[
91,
721,
143,
735
],
[
146,
722,
208,
735
],
[
211,
722,
248,
735
],
[
252,
723,
272,
735
],
[
275,
723,
324,
735
],
[
328,
723,
342,
735
],
[
345,
723,
411,
735
],
[
414,
724,
428,
735
],
[
431,
724,
467,
735
],
[
470,
724,
540,
735
],
[
544,
724,
602,
735
],
[
605,
724,
630,
735
],
[
632,
723,
687,
735
],
[
690,
723,
715,
735
],
[
718,
723,
754,
735
],
[
757,
722,
814,
735
],
[
817,
722,
848,
735
],
[
851,
722,
895,
735
],
[
84,
736,
140,
750
],
[
144,
736,
167,
750
],
[
171,
737,
212,
751
],
[
216,
737,
241,
751
],
[
244,
737,
296,
751
],
[
300,
737,
312,
751
],
[
315,
737,
385,
751
],
[
389,
737,
402,
751
],
[
405,
737,
469,
751
],
[
472,
738,
571,
751
],
[
574,
738,
616,
751
],
[
620,
737,
644,
750
],
[
648,
737,
686,
750
],
[
690,
737,
773,
750
],
[
777,
737,
828,
750
],
[
832,
736,
915,
750
],
[
84,
754,
117,
769
],
[
120,
754,
126,
768
],
[
128,
754,
188,
768
],
[
191,
755,
227,
768
],
[
230,
755,
295,
768
],
[
298,
755,
355,
768
],
[
358,
755,
372,
768
],
[
375,
755,
424,
768
],
[
427,
755,
466,
768
],
[
469,
755,
511,
768
],
[
514,
755,
556,
768
],
[
559,
755,
605,
768
],
[
608,
755,
631,
768
],
[
634,
755,
676,
768
],
[
679,
755,
704,
768
],
[
707,
755,
801,
768
],
[
804,
755,
861,
767
],
[
864,
755,
887,
767
],
[
83,
770,
132,
783
],
[
135,
770,
191,
783
],
[
193,
770,
218,
783
],
[
221,
770,
279,
783
],
[
281,
770,
297,
783
],
[
300,
770,
364,
783
],
[
367,
770,
379,
783
],
[
382,
770,
391,
783
],
[
394,
770,
427,
783
],
[
430,
770,
475,
783
],
[
478,
770,
543,
783
],
[
546,
770,
571,
783
],
[
574,
770,
582,
783
],
[
585,
770,
610,
783
],
[
613,
770,
666,
783
],
[
669,
770,
684,
783
],
[
687,
770,
707,
783
],
[
710,
770,
765,
783
],
[
768,
770,
837,
783
],
[
840,
770,
850,
783
],
[
853,
770,
866,
783
],
[
869,
770,
892,
783
],
[
81,
784,
135,
796
],
[
138,
784,
184,
796
],
[
187,
784,
246,
796
],
[
249,
784,
322,
796
],
[
325,
784,
345,
796
],
[
349,
784,
370,
796
],
[
372,
784,
407,
796
],
[
410,
784,
432,
796
],
[
435,
784,
450,
796
],
[
452,
784,
492,
796
],
[
496,
784,
532,
796
],
[
535,
784,
550,
796
],
[
553,
784,
582,
796
],
[
585,
784,
643,
796
],
[
646,
784,
715,
796
],
[
718,
784,
789,
796
],
[
792,
784,
832,
796
],
[
835,
784,
870,
796
],
[
873,
784,
887,
796
],
[
82,
800,
138,
812
],
[
141,
800,
167,
812
],
[
171,
800,
254,
812
],
[
257,
800,
287,
812
],
[
290,
800,
314,
812
],
[
317,
800,
352,
812
],
[
355,
800,
412,
812
],
[
415,
800,
460,
812
],
[
81,
811,
128,
826
],
[
132,
812,
211,
826
],
[
214,
812,
228,
826
],
[
231,
812,
253,
826
],
[
256,
812,
298,
826
],
[
302,
813,
316,
826
],
[
319,
813,
406,
826
],
[
409,
813,
422,
826
],
[
425,
813,
477,
826
],
[
480,
813,
517,
826
],
[
520,
813,
554,
826
],
[
557,
813,
603,
826
],
[
606,
813,
620,
826
],
[
623,
813,
684,
826
],
[
687,
813,
704,
826
],
[
707,
813,
729,
826
],
[
732,
813,
770,
826
],
[
772,
813,
797,
826
],
[
800,
812,
856,
826
],
[
858,
812,
873,
826
],
[
876,
812,
928,
826
],
[
82,
827,
172,
840
],
[
175,
827,
207,
840
],
[
209,
827,
241,
841
],
[
244,
827,
257,
841
],
[
260,
827,
303,
841
],
[
305,
827,
345,
841
],
[
348,
827,
417,
841
],
[
419,
827,
445,
841
],
[
448,
827,
514,
841
],
[
516,
827,
525,
841
],
[
527,
827,
550,
841
],
[
552,
828,
611,
840
],
[
91,
840,
123,
854
],
[
127,
840,
170,
855
],
[
172,
841,
187,
855
],
[
190,
841,
211,
855
],
[
214,
841,
267,
855
],
[
270,
841,
322,
856
],
[
326,
841,
358,
856
],
[
361,
841,
403,
856
],
[
406,
841,
427,
856
],
[
430,
841,
514,
856
],
[
517,
842,
531,
856
],
[
535,
842,
565,
856
],
[
568,
842,
596,
856
],
[
600,
842,
675,
856
],
[
679,
842,
747,
856
],
[
750,
842,
775,
855
],
[
778,
842,
844,
855
],
[
82,
856,
220,
869
],
[
223,
855,
259,
869
],
[
262,
855,
308,
870
],
[
118,
903,
183,
915
],
[
185,
902,
216,
915
],
[
114,
935,
143,
947
],
[
147,
934,
189,
947
],
[
192,
934,
258,
947
],
[
261,
934,
323,
947
],
[
327,
934,
347,
947
],
[
354,
934,
395,
947
],
[
400,
934,
411,
947
],
[
418,
934,
437,
947
],
[
441,
934,
527,
947
],
[
532,
934,
544,
947
],
[
549,
934,
575,
947
],
[
580,
934,
667,
947
],
[
671,
934,
681,
947
],
[
687,
935,
898,
948
],
[
224,
981,
291,
997
],
[
295,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is ACC stands for?
|
American Chemistry council
|
648
|
[
"UTFRG",
"Recall",
"Testing",
"Whitepaper",
"August",
"3,",
"2016",
"Figure",
"2.",
"Images",
"of",
"swollen",
"battery",
"from",
"a",
"Lorex",
"baby",
"monitor",
"that",
"had",
"failed.",
"The",
"purpose",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"work",
"is",
"to",
"investigate",
"the",
"effectiveness",
"of",
"FR",
"on",
"a",
"representative",
"electronic",
"baby",
"accessory.",
"In",
"this",
"study",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"as",
"the",
"representative",
"exemplar.",
"UTFRG",
"proposes",
"that",
"our",
"services",
"be",
"divided",
"into",
"the",
"following",
"tasks:",
"Task",
"A-Fabricate",
"Replica",
"Baby",
"Monitors",
"$10,000.00",
"($15,600",
"w/",
"overhead)",
"The",
"scope",
"of",
"Task",
"A",
"is",
"to",
"design",
"and",
"fabricate",
"three",
"replicas",
"of",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor.",
"It",
"is",
"UTFRG's",
"understanding",
"that",
"one",
"possible",
"model",
"of",
"interest",
"is",
"manufactured",
"by",
"Lorex",
"(Model",
"No.",
"WL3520,",
"WL4320,",
"and",
"WL3401).",
"As",
"discussed",
"above,",
"these",
"models",
"have",
"been",
"recalled",
"and",
"are",
"currently",
"unavailable",
"from",
"United",
"States",
"retailers.",
"However,",
"it",
"may",
"be",
"possible",
"to",
"obtain",
"exemplar",
"units",
"from",
"international",
"retailers",
"or",
"third-party",
"resellers.",
"If",
"available,",
"UTFRG",
"will",
"procure",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitors.",
"If",
"the",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"is",
"commercially",
"unavailable,",
"an",
"alternative",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"may",
"be",
"used.",
"Any",
"alternative",
"model",
"will",
"be",
"agreed",
"upon",
"in",
"discussions",
"with",
"the",
"sponsor",
"prior",
"to",
"procurement.",
"An",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitor",
"housing",
"will",
"be",
"laser",
"scanned",
"and",
"three",
"replicas",
"will",
"be",
"fabricated",
"using",
"a",
"3-D",
"printer.",
"The",
"replica",
"housings",
"will",
"be",
"constructed",
"of",
"material",
"that",
"does",
"not",
"contain",
"fire",
"retardants.",
"One",
"filament",
"system",
"available",
"for",
"testing",
"for",
"the",
"Makerbot",
"systems",
"is",
"PLA",
"3D",
"Printer",
"Filament/",
"MakerBot",
"PLA.",
"Makerbot",
"has",
"information",
"on",
"their",
"website",
"about",
"the",
"flammability",
"concerns",
"of",
"their",
"products",
"Figure",
"3.",
"Makerbot",
"flammability",
"warning",
"video",
"at",
"http://www.makerbot.com/blog/2010/11/29/makerbot-psa-fire-and-abs-pla-dont-mix",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/qrbn0226"
] |
[
[
118,
96,
165,
108
],
[
169,
97,
210,
109
],
[
212,
98,
257,
109
],
[
260,
98,
329,
109
],
[
119,
111,
162,
121
],
[
164,
111,
177,
121
],
[
178,
111,
210,
121
],
[
191,
307,
244,
324
],
[
248,
307,
263,
324
],
[
267,
307,
327,
324
],
[
331,
308,
348,
324
],
[
352,
308,
410,
324
],
[
414,
308,
471,
324
],
[
475,
308,
510,
324
],
[
517,
308,
527,
324
],
[
531,
308,
577,
324
],
[
581,
308,
621,
324
],
[
625,
307,
688,
324
],
[
691,
307,
722,
323
],
[
726,
307,
757,
323
],
[
761,
306,
808,
322
],
[
119,
340,
148,
356
],
[
151,
340,
216,
356
],
[
219,
340,
237,
356
],
[
241,
340,
266,
356
],
[
269,
340,
343,
356
],
[
347,
340,
388,
356
],
[
391,
340,
405,
356
],
[
409,
340,
425,
356
],
[
429,
340,
517,
356
],
[
520,
340,
545,
356
],
[
548,
340,
654,
356
],
[
658,
340,
675,
356
],
[
678,
340,
703,
356
],
[
708,
340,
729,
356
],
[
732,
340,
741,
356
],
[
745,
340,
860,
356
],
[
118,
358,
196,
373
],
[
200,
358,
240,
373
],
[
244,
358,
325,
373
],
[
328,
358,
346,
373
],
[
350,
358,
380,
373
],
[
383,
358,
427,
373
],
[
431,
358,
440,
373
],
[
443,
358,
483,
373
],
[
487,
358,
551,
373
],
[
555,
358,
587,
373
],
[
590,
358,
610,
373
],
[
613,
358,
651,
373
],
[
654,
358,
672,
373
],
[
675,
358,
701,
373
],
[
704,
358,
813,
373
],
[
119,
375,
197,
390
],
[
200,
375,
265,
390
],
[
268,
375,
340,
390
],
[
343,
375,
374,
390
],
[
378,
375,
405,
390
],
[
409,
375,
474,
390
],
[
477,
375,
500,
390
],
[
504,
375,
560,
390
],
[
564,
375,
597,
390
],
[
600,
375,
626,
390
],
[
629,
375,
708,
390
],
[
711,
376,
756,
390
],
[
120,
405,
164,
423
],
[
168,
405,
291,
424
],
[
295,
407,
366,
424
],
[
370,
407,
419,
424
],
[
423,
407,
507,
424
],
[
571,
408,
672,
423
],
[
675,
407,
754,
423
],
[
758,
407,
781,
423
],
[
785,
406,
881,
423
],
[
120,
440,
149,
455
],
[
152,
440,
200,
455
],
[
202,
440,
222,
455
],
[
225,
440,
264,
455
],
[
268,
440,
281,
455
],
[
285,
440,
300,
455
],
[
303,
440,
322,
455
],
[
327,
440,
377,
455
],
[
380,
440,
410,
455
],
[
413,
440,
482,
455
],
[
486,
440,
527,
455
],
[
530,
440,
594,
455
],
[
597,
440,
615,
455
],
[
618,
440,
628,
455
],
[
631,
440,
672,
455
],
[
675,
440,
745,
455
],
[
748,
440,
761,
455
],
[
764,
440,
780,
455
],
[
782,
439,
860,
455
],
[
118,
457,
230,
473
],
[
233,
457,
264,
473
],
[
268,
457,
295,
473
],
[
300,
457,
366,
473
],
[
370,
457,
421,
473
],
[
425,
457,
441,
473
],
[
445,
457,
504,
473
],
[
507,
457,
522,
473
],
[
526,
457,
635,
473
],
[
639,
457,
660,
473
],
[
664,
457,
711,
473
],
[
715,
457,
774,
473
],
[
778,
457,
805,
473
],
[
120,
473,
195,
490
],
[
198,
474,
274,
490
],
[
277,
474,
307,
490
],
[
311,
475,
392,
490
],
[
396,
475,
421,
490
],
[
425,
475,
499,
490
],
[
503,
475,
555,
490
],
[
559,
475,
600,
490
],
[
604,
475,
662,
490
],
[
665,
475,
705,
490
],
[
708,
475,
747,
490
],
[
751,
475,
814,
490
],
[
818,
475,
848,
490
],
[
851,
475,
878,
490
],
[
118,
492,
190,
508
],
[
192,
492,
285,
508
],
[
288,
492,
323,
508
],
[
331,
492,
387,
508
],
[
390,
492,
438,
508
],
[
441,
492,
510,
508
],
[
513,
492,
593,
508
],
[
596,
492,
608,
508
],
[
611,
492,
647,
508
],
[
650,
492,
671,
508
],
[
674,
492,
741,
508
],
[
744,
492,
761,
508
],
[
764,
492,
817,
508
],
[
117,
510,
192,
525
],
[
195,
510,
235,
526
],
[
238,
510,
274,
526
],
[
280,
510,
381,
526
],
[
384,
510,
451,
526
],
[
454,
510,
471,
526
],
[
474,
510,
561,
526
],
[
564,
509,
636,
526
],
[
640,
509,
655,
526
],
[
658,
509,
736,
525
],
[
740,
508,
802,
525
],
[
808,
508,
840,
525
],
[
118,
529,
179,
543
],
[
182,
529,
256,
543
],
[
260,
529,
299,
543
],
[
302,
528,
380,
543
],
[
383,
528,
397,
543
],
[
400,
528,
425,
543
],
[
428,
528,
474,
543
],
[
477,
528,
507,
543
],
[
510,
528,
561,
543
],
[
564,
528,
580,
543
],
[
582,
528,
693,
543
],
[
696,
528,
794,
543
],
[
796,
528,
818,
542
],
[
121,
545,
201,
560
],
[
204,
545,
249,
560
],
[
252,
545,
282,
560
],
[
285,
545,
336,
560
],
[
339,
545,
372,
560
],
[
376,
545,
398,
560
],
[
401,
545,
444,
560
],
[
447,
545,
482,
560
],
[
485,
545,
571,
560
],
[
574,
545,
625,
560
],
[
628,
545,
660,
560
],
[
663,
545,
684,
560
],
[
687,
545,
741,
560
],
[
744,
545,
784,
560
],
[
787,
545,
805,
560
],
[
120,
562,
209,
578
],
[
212,
563,
248,
578
],
[
251,
563,
277,
578
],
[
280,
563,
341,
578
],
[
345,
563,
384,
578
],
[
388,
563,
404,
578
],
[
408,
563,
515,
578
],
[
519,
563,
544,
578
],
[
547,
563,
621,
578
],
[
625,
563,
664,
578
],
[
668,
562,
731,
578
],
[
735,
562,
800,
577
],
[
803,
561,
834,
577
],
[
838,
561,
860,
577
],
[
117,
580,
157,
594
],
[
160,
580,
224,
594
],
[
228,
580,
257,
594
],
[
260,
580,
301,
595
],
[
305,
580,
368,
595
],
[
371,
580,
402,
595
],
[
405,
580,
426,
595
],
[
430,
580,
510,
595
],
[
514,
580,
558,
595
],
[
561,
580,
572,
595
],
[
575,
580,
602,
595
],
[
609,
580,
675,
595
],
[
681,
580,
709,
595
],
[
712,
580,
767,
595
],
[
770,
580,
844,
595
],
[
847,
580,
880,
595
],
[
118,
596,
138,
611
],
[
141,
597,
233,
611
],
[
237,
597,
253,
611
],
[
257,
597,
323,
611
],
[
327,
597,
361,
611
],
[
365,
597,
398,
611
],
[
401,
597,
428,
611
],
[
432,
597,
492,
611
],
[
495,
597,
522,
611
],
[
525,
597,
612,
612
],
[
615,
597,
649,
612
],
[
652,
597,
720,
612
],
[
723,
597,
775,
612
],
[
782,
596,
855,
612
],
[
859,
596,
886,
612
],
[
118,
614,
171,
630
],
[
175,
614,
198,
630
],
[
202,
614,
227,
630
],
[
230,
614,
310,
630
],
[
313,
614,
375,
630
],
[
379,
614,
394,
630
],
[
397,
614,
435,
630
],
[
440,
614,
462,
630
],
[
468,
614,
522,
630
],
[
526,
614,
604,
630
],
[
607,
614,
689,
630
],
[
692,
614,
741,
630
],
[
744,
614,
822,
630
],
[
825,
614,
855,
630
],
[
118,
633,
211,
647
],
[
215,
633,
235,
647
],
[
240,
633,
278,
647
],
[
281,
633,
341,
647
],
[
344,
633,
391,
648
],
[
394,
633,
420,
648
],
[
422,
633,
525,
648
],
[
528,
633,
601,
648
],
[
603,
633,
622,
648
],
[
624,
633,
663,
648
],
[
666,
633,
738,
647
],
[
118,
833,
170,
851
],
[
174,
834,
188,
851
],
[
192,
834,
271,
851
],
[
275,
834,
376,
851
],
[
380,
835,
447,
851
],
[
450,
835,
495,
850
],
[
498,
835,
515,
850
],
[
117,
852,
784,
868
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
What is Task A?
|
Fabricate Replica Baby Monitors
|
648
|
[
"UTFRG",
"Recall",
"Testing",
"Whitepaper",
"August",
"3,",
"2016",
"Figure",
"2.",
"Images",
"of",
"swollen",
"battery",
"from",
"a",
"Lorex",
"baby",
"monitor",
"that",
"had",
"failed.",
"The",
"purpose",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"work",
"is",
"to",
"investigate",
"the",
"effectiveness",
"of",
"FR",
"on",
"a",
"representative",
"electronic",
"baby",
"accessory.",
"In",
"this",
"study",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"as",
"the",
"representative",
"exemplar.",
"UTFRG",
"proposes",
"that",
"our",
"services",
"be",
"divided",
"into",
"the",
"following",
"tasks:",
"Task",
"A-Fabricate",
"Replica",
"Baby",
"Monitors",
"$10,000.00",
"($15,600",
"w/",
"overhead)",
"The",
"scope",
"of",
"Task",
"A",
"is",
"to",
"design",
"and",
"fabricate",
"three",
"replicas",
"of",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor.",
"It",
"is",
"UTFRG's",
"understanding",
"that",
"one",
"possible",
"model",
"of",
"interest",
"is",
"manufactured",
"by",
"Lorex",
"(Model",
"No.",
"WL3520,",
"WL4320,",
"and",
"WL3401).",
"As",
"discussed",
"above,",
"these",
"models",
"have",
"been",
"recalled",
"and",
"are",
"currently",
"unavailable",
"from",
"United",
"States",
"retailers.",
"However,",
"it",
"may",
"be",
"possible",
"to",
"obtain",
"exemplar",
"units",
"from",
"international",
"retailers",
"or",
"third-party",
"resellers.",
"If",
"available,",
"UTFRG",
"will",
"procure",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitors.",
"If",
"the",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"is",
"commercially",
"unavailable,",
"an",
"alternative",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"may",
"be",
"used.",
"Any",
"alternative",
"model",
"will",
"be",
"agreed",
"upon",
"in",
"discussions",
"with",
"the",
"sponsor",
"prior",
"to",
"procurement.",
"An",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitor",
"housing",
"will",
"be",
"laser",
"scanned",
"and",
"three",
"replicas",
"will",
"be",
"fabricated",
"using",
"a",
"3-D",
"printer.",
"The",
"replica",
"housings",
"will",
"be",
"constructed",
"of",
"material",
"that",
"does",
"not",
"contain",
"fire",
"retardants.",
"One",
"filament",
"system",
"available",
"for",
"testing",
"for",
"the",
"Makerbot",
"systems",
"is",
"PLA",
"3D",
"Printer",
"Filament/",
"MakerBot",
"PLA.",
"Makerbot",
"has",
"information",
"on",
"their",
"website",
"about",
"the",
"flammability",
"concerns",
"of",
"their",
"products",
"Figure",
"3.",
"Makerbot",
"flammability",
"warning",
"video",
"at",
"http://www.makerbot.com/blog/2010/11/29/makerbot-psa-fire-and-abs-pla-dont-mix",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/qrbn0226"
] |
[
[
118,
96,
165,
108
],
[
169,
97,
210,
109
],
[
212,
98,
257,
109
],
[
260,
98,
329,
109
],
[
119,
111,
162,
121
],
[
164,
111,
177,
121
],
[
178,
111,
210,
121
],
[
191,
307,
244,
324
],
[
248,
307,
263,
324
],
[
267,
307,
327,
324
],
[
331,
308,
348,
324
],
[
352,
308,
410,
324
],
[
414,
308,
471,
324
],
[
475,
308,
510,
324
],
[
517,
308,
527,
324
],
[
531,
308,
577,
324
],
[
581,
308,
621,
324
],
[
625,
307,
688,
324
],
[
691,
307,
722,
323
],
[
726,
307,
757,
323
],
[
761,
306,
808,
322
],
[
119,
340,
148,
356
],
[
151,
340,
216,
356
],
[
219,
340,
237,
356
],
[
241,
340,
266,
356
],
[
269,
340,
343,
356
],
[
347,
340,
388,
356
],
[
391,
340,
405,
356
],
[
409,
340,
425,
356
],
[
429,
340,
517,
356
],
[
520,
340,
545,
356
],
[
548,
340,
654,
356
],
[
658,
340,
675,
356
],
[
678,
340,
703,
356
],
[
708,
340,
729,
356
],
[
732,
340,
741,
356
],
[
745,
340,
860,
356
],
[
118,
358,
196,
373
],
[
200,
358,
240,
373
],
[
244,
358,
325,
373
],
[
328,
358,
346,
373
],
[
350,
358,
380,
373
],
[
383,
358,
427,
373
],
[
431,
358,
440,
373
],
[
443,
358,
483,
373
],
[
487,
358,
551,
373
],
[
555,
358,
587,
373
],
[
590,
358,
610,
373
],
[
613,
358,
651,
373
],
[
654,
358,
672,
373
],
[
675,
358,
701,
373
],
[
704,
358,
813,
373
],
[
119,
375,
197,
390
],
[
200,
375,
265,
390
],
[
268,
375,
340,
390
],
[
343,
375,
374,
390
],
[
378,
375,
405,
390
],
[
409,
375,
474,
390
],
[
477,
375,
500,
390
],
[
504,
375,
560,
390
],
[
564,
375,
597,
390
],
[
600,
375,
626,
390
],
[
629,
375,
708,
390
],
[
711,
376,
756,
390
],
[
120,
405,
164,
423
],
[
168,
405,
291,
424
],
[
295,
407,
366,
424
],
[
370,
407,
419,
424
],
[
423,
407,
507,
424
],
[
571,
408,
672,
423
],
[
675,
407,
754,
423
],
[
758,
407,
781,
423
],
[
785,
406,
881,
423
],
[
120,
440,
149,
455
],
[
152,
440,
200,
455
],
[
202,
440,
222,
455
],
[
225,
440,
264,
455
],
[
268,
440,
281,
455
],
[
285,
440,
300,
455
],
[
303,
440,
322,
455
],
[
327,
440,
377,
455
],
[
380,
440,
410,
455
],
[
413,
440,
482,
455
],
[
486,
440,
527,
455
],
[
530,
440,
594,
455
],
[
597,
440,
615,
455
],
[
618,
440,
628,
455
],
[
631,
440,
672,
455
],
[
675,
440,
745,
455
],
[
748,
440,
761,
455
],
[
764,
440,
780,
455
],
[
782,
439,
860,
455
],
[
118,
457,
230,
473
],
[
233,
457,
264,
473
],
[
268,
457,
295,
473
],
[
300,
457,
366,
473
],
[
370,
457,
421,
473
],
[
425,
457,
441,
473
],
[
445,
457,
504,
473
],
[
507,
457,
522,
473
],
[
526,
457,
635,
473
],
[
639,
457,
660,
473
],
[
664,
457,
711,
473
],
[
715,
457,
774,
473
],
[
778,
457,
805,
473
],
[
120,
473,
195,
490
],
[
198,
474,
274,
490
],
[
277,
474,
307,
490
],
[
311,
475,
392,
490
],
[
396,
475,
421,
490
],
[
425,
475,
499,
490
],
[
503,
475,
555,
490
],
[
559,
475,
600,
490
],
[
604,
475,
662,
490
],
[
665,
475,
705,
490
],
[
708,
475,
747,
490
],
[
751,
475,
814,
490
],
[
818,
475,
848,
490
],
[
851,
475,
878,
490
],
[
118,
492,
190,
508
],
[
192,
492,
285,
508
],
[
288,
492,
323,
508
],
[
331,
492,
387,
508
],
[
390,
492,
438,
508
],
[
441,
492,
510,
508
],
[
513,
492,
593,
508
],
[
596,
492,
608,
508
],
[
611,
492,
647,
508
],
[
650,
492,
671,
508
],
[
674,
492,
741,
508
],
[
744,
492,
761,
508
],
[
764,
492,
817,
508
],
[
117,
510,
192,
525
],
[
195,
510,
235,
526
],
[
238,
510,
274,
526
],
[
280,
510,
381,
526
],
[
384,
510,
451,
526
],
[
454,
510,
471,
526
],
[
474,
510,
561,
526
],
[
564,
509,
636,
526
],
[
640,
509,
655,
526
],
[
658,
509,
736,
525
],
[
740,
508,
802,
525
],
[
808,
508,
840,
525
],
[
118,
529,
179,
543
],
[
182,
529,
256,
543
],
[
260,
529,
299,
543
],
[
302,
528,
380,
543
],
[
383,
528,
397,
543
],
[
400,
528,
425,
543
],
[
428,
528,
474,
543
],
[
477,
528,
507,
543
],
[
510,
528,
561,
543
],
[
564,
528,
580,
543
],
[
582,
528,
693,
543
],
[
696,
528,
794,
543
],
[
796,
528,
818,
542
],
[
121,
545,
201,
560
],
[
204,
545,
249,
560
],
[
252,
545,
282,
560
],
[
285,
545,
336,
560
],
[
339,
545,
372,
560
],
[
376,
545,
398,
560
],
[
401,
545,
444,
560
],
[
447,
545,
482,
560
],
[
485,
545,
571,
560
],
[
574,
545,
625,
560
],
[
628,
545,
660,
560
],
[
663,
545,
684,
560
],
[
687,
545,
741,
560
],
[
744,
545,
784,
560
],
[
787,
545,
805,
560
],
[
120,
562,
209,
578
],
[
212,
563,
248,
578
],
[
251,
563,
277,
578
],
[
280,
563,
341,
578
],
[
345,
563,
384,
578
],
[
388,
563,
404,
578
],
[
408,
563,
515,
578
],
[
519,
563,
544,
578
],
[
547,
563,
621,
578
],
[
625,
563,
664,
578
],
[
668,
562,
731,
578
],
[
735,
562,
800,
577
],
[
803,
561,
834,
577
],
[
838,
561,
860,
577
],
[
117,
580,
157,
594
],
[
160,
580,
224,
594
],
[
228,
580,
257,
594
],
[
260,
580,
301,
595
],
[
305,
580,
368,
595
],
[
371,
580,
402,
595
],
[
405,
580,
426,
595
],
[
430,
580,
510,
595
],
[
514,
580,
558,
595
],
[
561,
580,
572,
595
],
[
575,
580,
602,
595
],
[
609,
580,
675,
595
],
[
681,
580,
709,
595
],
[
712,
580,
767,
595
],
[
770,
580,
844,
595
],
[
847,
580,
880,
595
],
[
118,
596,
138,
611
],
[
141,
597,
233,
611
],
[
237,
597,
253,
611
],
[
257,
597,
323,
611
],
[
327,
597,
361,
611
],
[
365,
597,
398,
611
],
[
401,
597,
428,
611
],
[
432,
597,
492,
611
],
[
495,
597,
522,
611
],
[
525,
597,
612,
612
],
[
615,
597,
649,
612
],
[
652,
597,
720,
612
],
[
723,
597,
775,
612
],
[
782,
596,
855,
612
],
[
859,
596,
886,
612
],
[
118,
614,
171,
630
],
[
175,
614,
198,
630
],
[
202,
614,
227,
630
],
[
230,
614,
310,
630
],
[
313,
614,
375,
630
],
[
379,
614,
394,
630
],
[
397,
614,
435,
630
],
[
440,
614,
462,
630
],
[
468,
614,
522,
630
],
[
526,
614,
604,
630
],
[
607,
614,
689,
630
],
[
692,
614,
741,
630
],
[
744,
614,
822,
630
],
[
825,
614,
855,
630
],
[
118,
633,
211,
647
],
[
215,
633,
235,
647
],
[
240,
633,
278,
647
],
[
281,
633,
341,
647
],
[
344,
633,
391,
648
],
[
394,
633,
420,
648
],
[
422,
633,
525,
648
],
[
528,
633,
601,
648
],
[
603,
633,
622,
648
],
[
624,
633,
663,
648
],
[
666,
633,
738,
647
],
[
118,
833,
170,
851
],
[
174,
834,
188,
851
],
[
192,
834,
271,
851
],
[
275,
834,
376,
851
],
[
380,
835,
447,
851
],
[
450,
835,
495,
850
],
[
498,
835,
515,
850
],
[
117,
852,
784,
868
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
What does the Figure 3 show?
|
Makerbot Flammability warning video
|
648
|
[
"UTFRG",
"Recall",
"Testing",
"Whitepaper",
"August",
"3,",
"2016",
"Figure",
"2.",
"Images",
"of",
"swollen",
"battery",
"from",
"a",
"Lorex",
"baby",
"monitor",
"that",
"had",
"failed.",
"The",
"purpose",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"work",
"is",
"to",
"investigate",
"the",
"effectiveness",
"of",
"FR",
"on",
"a",
"representative",
"electronic",
"baby",
"accessory.",
"In",
"this",
"study",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"as",
"the",
"representative",
"exemplar.",
"UTFRG",
"proposes",
"that",
"our",
"services",
"be",
"divided",
"into",
"the",
"following",
"tasks:",
"Task",
"A-Fabricate",
"Replica",
"Baby",
"Monitors",
"$10,000.00",
"($15,600",
"w/",
"overhead)",
"The",
"scope",
"of",
"Task",
"A",
"is",
"to",
"design",
"and",
"fabricate",
"three",
"replicas",
"of",
"a",
"baby",
"monitor.",
"It",
"is",
"UTFRG's",
"understanding",
"that",
"one",
"possible",
"model",
"of",
"interest",
"is",
"manufactured",
"by",
"Lorex",
"(Model",
"No.",
"WL3520,",
"WL4320,",
"and",
"WL3401).",
"As",
"discussed",
"above,",
"these",
"models",
"have",
"been",
"recalled",
"and",
"are",
"currently",
"unavailable",
"from",
"United",
"States",
"retailers.",
"However,",
"it",
"may",
"be",
"possible",
"to",
"obtain",
"exemplar",
"units",
"from",
"international",
"retailers",
"or",
"third-party",
"resellers.",
"If",
"available,",
"UTFRG",
"will",
"procure",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitors.",
"If",
"the",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"is",
"commercially",
"unavailable,",
"an",
"alternative",
"make",
"and",
"model",
"may",
"be",
"used.",
"Any",
"alternative",
"model",
"will",
"be",
"agreed",
"upon",
"in",
"discussions",
"with",
"the",
"sponsor",
"prior",
"to",
"procurement.",
"An",
"exemplar",
"baby",
"monitor",
"housing",
"will",
"be",
"laser",
"scanned",
"and",
"three",
"replicas",
"will",
"be",
"fabricated",
"using",
"a",
"3-D",
"printer.",
"The",
"replica",
"housings",
"will",
"be",
"constructed",
"of",
"material",
"that",
"does",
"not",
"contain",
"fire",
"retardants.",
"One",
"filament",
"system",
"available",
"for",
"testing",
"for",
"the",
"Makerbot",
"systems",
"is",
"PLA",
"3D",
"Printer",
"Filament/",
"MakerBot",
"PLA.",
"Makerbot",
"has",
"information",
"on",
"their",
"website",
"about",
"the",
"flammability",
"concerns",
"of",
"their",
"products",
"Figure",
"3.",
"Makerbot",
"flammability",
"warning",
"video",
"at",
"http://www.makerbot.com/blog/2010/11/29/makerbot-psa-fire-and-abs-pla-dont-mix",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/qrbn0226"
] |
[
[
118,
96,
165,
108
],
[
169,
97,
210,
109
],
[
212,
98,
257,
109
],
[
260,
98,
329,
109
],
[
119,
111,
162,
121
],
[
164,
111,
177,
121
],
[
178,
111,
210,
121
],
[
191,
307,
244,
324
],
[
248,
307,
263,
324
],
[
267,
307,
327,
324
],
[
331,
308,
348,
324
],
[
352,
308,
410,
324
],
[
414,
308,
471,
324
],
[
475,
308,
510,
324
],
[
517,
308,
527,
324
],
[
531,
308,
577,
324
],
[
581,
308,
621,
324
],
[
625,
307,
688,
324
],
[
691,
307,
722,
323
],
[
726,
307,
757,
323
],
[
761,
306,
808,
322
],
[
119,
340,
148,
356
],
[
151,
340,
216,
356
],
[
219,
340,
237,
356
],
[
241,
340,
266,
356
],
[
269,
340,
343,
356
],
[
347,
340,
388,
356
],
[
391,
340,
405,
356
],
[
409,
340,
425,
356
],
[
429,
340,
517,
356
],
[
520,
340,
545,
356
],
[
548,
340,
654,
356
],
[
658,
340,
675,
356
],
[
678,
340,
703,
356
],
[
708,
340,
729,
356
],
[
732,
340,
741,
356
],
[
745,
340,
860,
356
],
[
118,
358,
196,
373
],
[
200,
358,
240,
373
],
[
244,
358,
325,
373
],
[
328,
358,
346,
373
],
[
350,
358,
380,
373
],
[
383,
358,
427,
373
],
[
431,
358,
440,
373
],
[
443,
358,
483,
373
],
[
487,
358,
551,
373
],
[
555,
358,
587,
373
],
[
590,
358,
610,
373
],
[
613,
358,
651,
373
],
[
654,
358,
672,
373
],
[
675,
358,
701,
373
],
[
704,
358,
813,
373
],
[
119,
375,
197,
390
],
[
200,
375,
265,
390
],
[
268,
375,
340,
390
],
[
343,
375,
374,
390
],
[
378,
375,
405,
390
],
[
409,
375,
474,
390
],
[
477,
375,
500,
390
],
[
504,
375,
560,
390
],
[
564,
375,
597,
390
],
[
600,
375,
626,
390
],
[
629,
375,
708,
390
],
[
711,
376,
756,
390
],
[
120,
405,
164,
423
],
[
168,
405,
291,
424
],
[
295,
407,
366,
424
],
[
370,
407,
419,
424
],
[
423,
407,
507,
424
],
[
571,
408,
672,
423
],
[
675,
407,
754,
423
],
[
758,
407,
781,
423
],
[
785,
406,
881,
423
],
[
120,
440,
149,
455
],
[
152,
440,
200,
455
],
[
202,
440,
222,
455
],
[
225,
440,
264,
455
],
[
268,
440,
281,
455
],
[
285,
440,
300,
455
],
[
303,
440,
322,
455
],
[
327,
440,
377,
455
],
[
380,
440,
410,
455
],
[
413,
440,
482,
455
],
[
486,
440,
527,
455
],
[
530,
440,
594,
455
],
[
597,
440,
615,
455
],
[
618,
440,
628,
455
],
[
631,
440,
672,
455
],
[
675,
440,
745,
455
],
[
748,
440,
761,
455
],
[
764,
440,
780,
455
],
[
782,
439,
860,
455
],
[
118,
457,
230,
473
],
[
233,
457,
264,
473
],
[
268,
457,
295,
473
],
[
300,
457,
366,
473
],
[
370,
457,
421,
473
],
[
425,
457,
441,
473
],
[
445,
457,
504,
473
],
[
507,
457,
522,
473
],
[
526,
457,
635,
473
],
[
639,
457,
660,
473
],
[
664,
457,
711,
473
],
[
715,
457,
774,
473
],
[
778,
457,
805,
473
],
[
120,
473,
195,
490
],
[
198,
474,
274,
490
],
[
277,
474,
307,
490
],
[
311,
475,
392,
490
],
[
396,
475,
421,
490
],
[
425,
475,
499,
490
],
[
503,
475,
555,
490
],
[
559,
475,
600,
490
],
[
604,
475,
662,
490
],
[
665,
475,
705,
490
],
[
708,
475,
747,
490
],
[
751,
475,
814,
490
],
[
818,
475,
848,
490
],
[
851,
475,
878,
490
],
[
118,
492,
190,
508
],
[
192,
492,
285,
508
],
[
288,
492,
323,
508
],
[
331,
492,
387,
508
],
[
390,
492,
438,
508
],
[
441,
492,
510,
508
],
[
513,
492,
593,
508
],
[
596,
492,
608,
508
],
[
611,
492,
647,
508
],
[
650,
492,
671,
508
],
[
674,
492,
741,
508
],
[
744,
492,
761,
508
],
[
764,
492,
817,
508
],
[
117,
510,
192,
525
],
[
195,
510,
235,
526
],
[
238,
510,
274,
526
],
[
280,
510,
381,
526
],
[
384,
510,
451,
526
],
[
454,
510,
471,
526
],
[
474,
510,
561,
526
],
[
564,
509,
636,
526
],
[
640,
509,
655,
526
],
[
658,
509,
736,
525
],
[
740,
508,
802,
525
],
[
808,
508,
840,
525
],
[
118,
529,
179,
543
],
[
182,
529,
256,
543
],
[
260,
529,
299,
543
],
[
302,
528,
380,
543
],
[
383,
528,
397,
543
],
[
400,
528,
425,
543
],
[
428,
528,
474,
543
],
[
477,
528,
507,
543
],
[
510,
528,
561,
543
],
[
564,
528,
580,
543
],
[
582,
528,
693,
543
],
[
696,
528,
794,
543
],
[
796,
528,
818,
542
],
[
121,
545,
201,
560
],
[
204,
545,
249,
560
],
[
252,
545,
282,
560
],
[
285,
545,
336,
560
],
[
339,
545,
372,
560
],
[
376,
545,
398,
560
],
[
401,
545,
444,
560
],
[
447,
545,
482,
560
],
[
485,
545,
571,
560
],
[
574,
545,
625,
560
],
[
628,
545,
660,
560
],
[
663,
545,
684,
560
],
[
687,
545,
741,
560
],
[
744,
545,
784,
560
],
[
787,
545,
805,
560
],
[
120,
562,
209,
578
],
[
212,
563,
248,
578
],
[
251,
563,
277,
578
],
[
280,
563,
341,
578
],
[
345,
563,
384,
578
],
[
388,
563,
404,
578
],
[
408,
563,
515,
578
],
[
519,
563,
544,
578
],
[
547,
563,
621,
578
],
[
625,
563,
664,
578
],
[
668,
562,
731,
578
],
[
735,
562,
800,
577
],
[
803,
561,
834,
577
],
[
838,
561,
860,
577
],
[
117,
580,
157,
594
],
[
160,
580,
224,
594
],
[
228,
580,
257,
594
],
[
260,
580,
301,
595
],
[
305,
580,
368,
595
],
[
371,
580,
402,
595
],
[
405,
580,
426,
595
],
[
430,
580,
510,
595
],
[
514,
580,
558,
595
],
[
561,
580,
572,
595
],
[
575,
580,
602,
595
],
[
609,
580,
675,
595
],
[
681,
580,
709,
595
],
[
712,
580,
767,
595
],
[
770,
580,
844,
595
],
[
847,
580,
880,
595
],
[
118,
596,
138,
611
],
[
141,
597,
233,
611
],
[
237,
597,
253,
611
],
[
257,
597,
323,
611
],
[
327,
597,
361,
611
],
[
365,
597,
398,
611
],
[
401,
597,
428,
611
],
[
432,
597,
492,
611
],
[
495,
597,
522,
611
],
[
525,
597,
612,
612
],
[
615,
597,
649,
612
],
[
652,
597,
720,
612
],
[
723,
597,
775,
612
],
[
782,
596,
855,
612
],
[
859,
596,
886,
612
],
[
118,
614,
171,
630
],
[
175,
614,
198,
630
],
[
202,
614,
227,
630
],
[
230,
614,
310,
630
],
[
313,
614,
375,
630
],
[
379,
614,
394,
630
],
[
397,
614,
435,
630
],
[
440,
614,
462,
630
],
[
468,
614,
522,
630
],
[
526,
614,
604,
630
],
[
607,
614,
689,
630
],
[
692,
614,
741,
630
],
[
744,
614,
822,
630
],
[
825,
614,
855,
630
],
[
118,
633,
211,
647
],
[
215,
633,
235,
647
],
[
240,
633,
278,
647
],
[
281,
633,
341,
647
],
[
344,
633,
391,
648
],
[
394,
633,
420,
648
],
[
422,
633,
525,
648
],
[
528,
633,
601,
648
],
[
603,
633,
622,
648
],
[
624,
633,
663,
648
],
[
666,
633,
738,
647
],
[
118,
833,
170,
851
],
[
174,
834,
188,
851
],
[
192,
834,
271,
851
],
[
275,
834,
376,
851
],
[
380,
835,
447,
851
],
[
450,
835,
495,
850
],
[
498,
835,
515,
850
],
[
117,
852,
784,
868
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned?
|
August 3, 2016
|
715
|
[
"Risk-Based",
"Prioritization",
"Matrix",
"Iscreasing",
"Exposure",
"Two-Step",
"Prioritization",
"Process",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Rank",
"Ordering",
"within",
"Priority",
"Groups",
"Biomonitoring",
"/",
"Environmental",
"Monitoring",
"*",
"Use",
"in",
"Children's",
"Products",
"Emissions",
"(e.9.",
"TRI)",
"*",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
147,
182,
233,
202
],
[
235,
183,
331,
203
],
[
334,
183,
380,
204
],
[
226,
249,
277,
259
],
[
280,
248,
324,
259
],
[
541,
226,
682,
271
],
[
446,
275,
643,
313
],
[
652,
275,
773,
314
],
[
535,
601,
636,
637
],
[
643,
600,
687,
636
],
[
419,
642,
476,
674
],
[
480,
642,
574,
675
],
[
578,
642,
641,
675
],
[
645,
642,
722,
675
],
[
726,
643,
803,
675
],
[
437,
700,
558,
727
],
[
561,
700,
570,
728
],
[
574,
700,
700,
728
],
[
704,
700,
798,
728
],
[
419,
734,
433,
759
],
[
435,
734,
472,
760
],
[
475,
734,
495,
760
],
[
498,
734,
587,
761
],
[
590,
735,
670,
761
],
[
436,
771,
528,
798
],
[
531,
772,
576,
798
],
[
579,
771,
615,
798
],
[
419,
807,
431,
830
],
[
436,
807,
547,
832
],
[
550,
807,
590,
832
],
[
594,
807,
711,
832
],
[
714,
807,
780,
832
],
[
286,
975,
337,
996
],
[
340,
974,
716,
996
]
] |
How many steps Prioritization Process is shown?
|
Two-step
|
715
|
[
"Risk-Based",
"Prioritization",
"Matrix",
"Iscreasing",
"Exposure",
"Two-Step",
"Prioritization",
"Process",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Rank",
"Ordering",
"within",
"Priority",
"Groups",
"Biomonitoring",
"/",
"Environmental",
"Monitoring",
"*",
"Use",
"in",
"Children's",
"Products",
"Emissions",
"(e.9.",
"TRI)",
"*",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
147,
182,
233,
202
],
[
235,
183,
331,
203
],
[
334,
183,
380,
204
],
[
226,
249,
277,
259
],
[
280,
248,
324,
259
],
[
541,
226,
682,
271
],
[
446,
275,
643,
313
],
[
652,
275,
773,
314
],
[
535,
601,
636,
637
],
[
643,
600,
687,
636
],
[
419,
642,
476,
674
],
[
480,
642,
574,
675
],
[
578,
642,
641,
675
],
[
645,
642,
722,
675
],
[
726,
643,
803,
675
],
[
437,
700,
558,
727
],
[
561,
700,
570,
728
],
[
574,
700,
700,
728
],
[
704,
700,
798,
728
],
[
419,
734,
433,
759
],
[
435,
734,
472,
760
],
[
475,
734,
495,
760
],
[
498,
734,
587,
761
],
[
590,
735,
670,
761
],
[
436,
771,
528,
798
],
[
531,
772,
576,
798
],
[
579,
771,
615,
798
],
[
419,
807,
431,
830
],
[
436,
807,
547,
832
],
[
550,
807,
590,
832
],
[
594,
807,
711,
832
],
[
714,
807,
780,
832
],
[
286,
975,
337,
996
],
[
340,
974,
716,
996
]
] |
In the Second Tier the Ranking Ordering are within which groups?
|
Priority groups
|
715
|
[
"Risk-Based",
"Prioritization",
"Matrix",
"Iscreasing",
"Exposure",
"Two-Step",
"Prioritization",
"Process",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Rank",
"Ordering",
"within",
"Priority",
"Groups",
"Biomonitoring",
"/",
"Environmental",
"Monitoring",
"*",
"Use",
"in",
"Children's",
"Products",
"Emissions",
"(e.9.",
"TRI)",
"*",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
147,
182,
233,
202
],
[
235,
183,
331,
203
],
[
334,
183,
380,
204
],
[
226,
249,
277,
259
],
[
280,
248,
324,
259
],
[
541,
226,
682,
271
],
[
446,
275,
643,
313
],
[
652,
275,
773,
314
],
[
535,
601,
636,
637
],
[
643,
600,
687,
636
],
[
419,
642,
476,
674
],
[
480,
642,
574,
675
],
[
578,
642,
641,
675
],
[
645,
642,
722,
675
],
[
726,
643,
803,
675
],
[
437,
700,
558,
727
],
[
561,
700,
570,
728
],
[
574,
700,
700,
728
],
[
704,
700,
798,
728
],
[
419,
734,
433,
759
],
[
435,
734,
472,
760
],
[
475,
734,
495,
760
],
[
498,
734,
587,
761
],
[
590,
735,
670,
761
],
[
436,
771,
528,
798
],
[
531,
772,
576,
798
],
[
579,
771,
615,
798
],
[
419,
807,
431,
830
],
[
436,
807,
547,
832
],
[
550,
807,
590,
832
],
[
594,
807,
711,
832
],
[
714,
807,
780,
832
],
[
286,
975,
337,
996
],
[
340,
974,
716,
996
]
] |
What is the heading of the picture shown?
|
Risk-Based Prioritization Matrix
|
715
|
[
"Risk-Based",
"Prioritization",
"Matrix",
"Iscreasing",
"Exposure",
"Two-Step",
"Prioritization",
"Process",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Rank",
"Ordering",
"within",
"Priority",
"Groups",
"Biomonitoring",
"/",
"Environmental",
"Monitoring",
"*",
"Use",
"in",
"Children's",
"Products",
"Emissions",
"(e.9.",
"TRI)",
"*",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
147,
182,
233,
202
],
[
235,
183,
331,
203
],
[
334,
183,
380,
204
],
[
226,
249,
277,
259
],
[
280,
248,
324,
259
],
[
541,
226,
682,
271
],
[
446,
275,
643,
313
],
[
652,
275,
773,
314
],
[
535,
601,
636,
637
],
[
643,
600,
687,
636
],
[
419,
642,
476,
674
],
[
480,
642,
574,
675
],
[
578,
642,
641,
675
],
[
645,
642,
722,
675
],
[
726,
643,
803,
675
],
[
437,
700,
558,
727
],
[
561,
700,
570,
728
],
[
574,
700,
700,
728
],
[
704,
700,
798,
728
],
[
419,
734,
433,
759
],
[
435,
734,
472,
760
],
[
475,
734,
495,
760
],
[
498,
734,
587,
761
],
[
590,
735,
670,
761
],
[
436,
771,
528,
798
],
[
531,
772,
576,
798
],
[
579,
771,
615,
798
],
[
419,
807,
431,
830
],
[
436,
807,
547,
832
],
[
550,
807,
590,
832
],
[
594,
807,
711,
832
],
[
714,
807,
780,
832
],
[
286,
975,
337,
996
],
[
340,
974,
716,
996
]
] |
What is the alternative given for Biomonitoring?
|
Environmental Monitoring
|
725
|
[
"American'",
"Council",
"January",
"28,",
"2013",
"John",
"Cowden,",
"Ph.D.",
"Janice",
"Lee,",
"Ph.D.",
"U.S.",
"EPA",
"National",
"Center",
"for",
"Environmental",
"Assessment",
"Mail",
"Code:",
"B243-01",
"109",
"T.W.",
"Alexander",
"Drive,",
"Durham,",
"N.C,",
"27711",
"Submitted",
"via",
"email",
"to:",
"Docket",
"[email protected];",
"cowden.john",
"@epa.gov;",
"lee.janices",
"@epa.gov",
"Regarding:",
"Submission",
"to",
"docket",
"EPA-HQ-ORD-2012-0830;",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic.",
"Dear",
"Drs.",
"Cowden",
"and",
"Lee:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"and",
"its",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"appreciate",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"on",
"the",
"draft",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic",
"(hereinafter",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"draft",
"Scope).",
"We",
"applaud",
"EPA",
"for",
"holding",
"a",
"two-day",
"stakeholder",
"workshop",
"to",
"begin",
"addressing",
"important",
"scientific",
"issues",
"that",
"will",
"inform",
"the",
"toxicological",
"review",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"the",
"National",
"Academies",
"review",
"of",
"inorganic",
"arsenic.",
"ACC",
"participated",
"remotely",
"via",
"webinar",
"and",
"we",
"found",
"the",
"technology",
"to",
"be",
"easily",
"accessible",
"and",
"generally",
"user-friendly.",
"While",
"there",
"were",
"some",
"small",
"glitches,",
"we",
"are",
"confident",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"work",
"to",
"improve",
"them",
"in",
"the",
"future.",
"To",
"further",
"improve",
"transparency,",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"very",
"helpful",
"if",
"EPA",
"could",
"share",
"the",
"presentations",
"with",
"the",
"meeting",
"participants",
"in",
"advance",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"or",
"in",
"real-time",
"via",
"email.",
"While",
"we",
"understand",
"that",
"web",
"posting",
"may",
"take",
"longer,",
"it",
"is",
"unfortunate",
"that",
"this",
"delays",
"active",
"participation",
"from",
"engaged",
"stakeholders.",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$760",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"largest",
"exporting",
"sector",
"in",
"the",
"U.S.,",
"accounting",
"for",
"12",
"percent",
"of",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"threats",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"Within",
"ACC,",
"the",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"is",
"a",
"coalition",
"of",
"independent",
"groups",
"and",
"associations",
"that",
"promotes",
"the",
"development",
"and",
"application",
"of",
"up-to-date,",
"scientifically",
"sound",
"methods",
"for",
"conducting",
"chemical",
"assessments.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ngcn0226"
] |
[
[
468,
55,
587,
75
],
[
469,
95,
558,
117
],
[
530,
165,
593,
180
],
[
596,
165,
622,
180
],
[
625,
165,
667,
180
],
[
117,
217,
157,
232
],
[
161,
218,
232,
232
],
[
235,
217,
280,
232
],
[
118,
235,
168,
250
],
[
172,
235,
207,
250
],
[
210,
235,
253,
250
],
[
117,
251,
155,
266
],
[
158,
252,
194,
267
],
[
117,
270,
186,
284
],
[
190,
270,
244,
284
],
[
247,
270,
271,
285
],
[
274,
270,
394,
285
],
[
397,
271,
491,
286
],
[
118,
287,
156,
302
],
[
160,
287,
208,
302
],
[
212,
287,
278,
302
],
[
119,
304,
150,
319
],
[
154,
305,
194,
319
],
[
197,
305,
280,
320
],
[
283,
305,
338,
321
],
[
117,
322,
188,
338
],
[
191,
322,
230,
338
],
[
234,
321,
283,
337
],
[
118,
340,
200,
355
],
[
204,
340,
228,
355
],
[
231,
340,
277,
355
],
[
280,
340,
302,
356
],
[
305,
340,
369,
356
],
[
372,
340,
498,
357
],
[
501,
340,
601,
357
],
[
605,
340,
684,
357
],
[
688,
340,
772,
357
],
[
775,
340,
854,
357
],
[
117,
374,
210,
390
],
[
214,
375,
306,
390
],
[
310,
375,
330,
390
],
[
334,
375,
384,
390
],
[
388,
375,
607,
390
],
[
611,
375,
692,
391
],
[
697,
375,
717,
391
],
[
721,
375,
745,
391
],
[
749,
375,
820,
391
],
[
824,
375,
855,
391
],
[
118,
392,
184,
408
],
[
187,
392,
265,
408
],
[
268,
392,
292,
409
],
[
295,
393,
322,
409
],
[
326,
393,
434,
409
],
[
438,
393,
497,
409
],
[
503,
393,
521,
409
],
[
525,
393,
601,
409
],
[
605,
393,
672,
409
],
[
117,
426,
157,
442
],
[
161,
427,
195,
443
],
[
199,
427,
265,
443
],
[
269,
428,
298,
443
],
[
302,
428,
338,
443
],
[
120,
463,
151,
477
],
[
154,
462,
232,
478
],
[
235,
462,
320,
478
],
[
322,
462,
386,
478
],
[
389,
462,
451,
478
],
[
454,
462,
484,
478
],
[
487,
462,
509,
478
],
[
512,
462,
565,
478
],
[
569,
462,
593,
478
],
[
597,
462,
684,
478
],
[
687,
462,
725,
477
],
[
730,
462,
824,
477
],
[
827,
462,
890,
477
],
[
117,
480,
147,
495
],
[
150,
480,
202,
495
],
[
205,
480,
290,
495
],
[
294,
480,
374,
495
],
[
378,
480,
404,
495
],
[
408,
480,
501,
495
],
[
504,
480,
520,
495
],
[
524,
480,
587,
495
],
[
591,
480,
671,
495
],
[
674,
480,
692,
495
],
[
695,
480,
721,
495
],
[
724,
480,
845,
495
],
[
117,
497,
200,
513
],
[
203,
497,
265,
514
],
[
268,
497,
321,
514
],
[
324,
497,
344,
514
],
[
347,
497,
377,
514
],
[
380,
497,
416,
514
],
[
419,
497,
491,
514
],
[
494,
497,
525,
514
],
[
528,
497,
594,
514
],
[
597,
497,
674,
514
],
[
677,
497,
701,
514
],
[
704,
497,
734,
514
],
[
737,
496,
847,
514
],
[
118,
515,
176,
530
],
[
182,
515,
200,
530
],
[
204,
515,
281,
530
],
[
284,
516,
345,
530
],
[
349,
516,
442,
531
],
[
445,
516,
510,
531
],
[
513,
516,
530,
531
],
[
533,
516,
552,
531
],
[
556,
515,
594,
531
],
[
597,
515,
654,
530
],
[
118,
550,
146,
565
],
[
149,
550,
214,
565
],
[
217,
550,
254,
565
],
[
258,
550,
282,
565
],
[
285,
550,
347,
565
],
[
351,
550,
361,
565
],
[
365,
550,
431,
566
],
[
434,
550,
527,
566
],
[
530,
550,
607,
566
],
[
611,
550,
628,
566
],
[
631,
550,
678,
566
],
[
681,
550,
765,
566
],
[
768,
550,
850,
565
],
[
117,
568,
190,
582
],
[
194,
569,
242,
583
],
[
246,
569,
278,
583
],
[
281,
569,
312,
583
],
[
315,
569,
365,
583
],
[
374,
569,
400,
583
],
[
403,
569,
506,
583
],
[
510,
569,
562,
583
],
[
569,
569,
587,
583
],
[
590,
568,
625,
583
],
[
628,
568,
646,
583
],
[
650,
568,
674,
583
],
[
678,
568,
750,
583
],
[
752,
567,
840,
582
],
[
842,
567,
894,
582
],
[
118,
585,
135,
600
],
[
138,
585,
215,
600
],
[
218,
585,
284,
600
],
[
288,
585,
328,
600
],
[
332,
585,
427,
600
],
[
430,
585,
502,
600
],
[
507,
585,
531,
600
],
[
535,
585,
600,
600
],
[
603,
585,
632,
600
],
[
635,
585,
661,
600
],
[
664,
585,
711,
600
],
[
714,
585,
740,
600
],
[
742,
585,
831,
600
],
[
834,
585,
851,
600
],
[
854,
585,
879,
600
],
[
120,
602,
164,
618
],
[
168,
602,
248,
618
],
[
252,
602,
282,
618
],
[
287,
602,
359,
618
],
[
363,
602,
472,
618
],
[
476,
602,
524,
618
],
[
527,
602,
570,
618
],
[
573,
602,
612,
618
],
[
615,
602,
658,
618
],
[
661,
602,
707,
618
],
[
710,
602,
777,
618
],
[
781,
602,
804,
618
],
[
807,
603,
832,
618
],
[
117,
620,
192,
635
],
[
196,
620,
227,
635
],
[
230,
620,
268,
635
],
[
274,
620,
306,
635
],
[
309,
620,
349,
635
],
[
352,
620,
370,
635
],
[
373,
620,
440,
635
],
[
443,
620,
480,
635
],
[
488,
620,
504,
635
],
[
507,
620,
534,
635
],
[
537,
620,
597,
635
],
[
601,
620,
622,
635
],
[
625,
620,
680,
635
],
[
683,
620,
750,
635
],
[
754,
620,
861,
635
],
[
864,
620,
878,
635
],
[
118,
637,
168,
651
],
[
171,
637,
192,
652
],
[
195,
637,
230,
652
],
[
234,
637,
291,
652
],
[
294,
637,
309,
652
],
[
312,
637,
348,
652
],
[
354,
637,
399,
652
],
[
402,
637,
444,
652
],
[
448,
637,
474,
652
],
[
477,
637,
583,
652
],
[
587,
637,
622,
652
],
[
626,
637,
651,
652
],
[
654,
637,
719,
652
],
[
722,
637,
816,
652
],
[
819,
637,
837,
652
],
[
840,
637,
907,
652
],
[
118,
655,
134,
670
],
[
138,
655,
163,
670
],
[
167,
655,
231,
670
],
[
235,
654,
253,
670
],
[
257,
654,
272,
670
],
[
276,
654,
350,
670
],
[
354,
654,
378,
670
],
[
382,
654,
438,
670
],
[
441,
654,
490,
670
],
[
493,
654,
517,
670
],
[
520,
654,
608,
670
],
[
612,
654,
643,
670
],
[
647,
654,
680,
670
],
[
682,
654,
742,
670
],
[
746,
654,
781,
670
],
[
785,
654,
819,
671
],
[
822,
654,
878,
671
],
[
881,
655,
894,
671
],
[
118,
672,
132,
686
],
[
135,
672,
228,
687
],
[
231,
673,
261,
687
],
[
264,
673,
298,
687
],
[
302,
673,
350,
687
],
[
354,
673,
402,
688
],
[
405,
673,
507,
688
],
[
510,
673,
545,
688
],
[
552,
673,
620,
688
],
[
622,
672,
730,
688
],
[
127,
720,
152,
734
],
[
156,
720,
221,
735
],
[
224,
721,
292,
735
],
[
296,
722,
349,
735
],
[
352,
722,
397,
735
],
[
400,
722,
467,
735
],
[
471,
723,
491,
735
],
[
495,
723,
544,
735
],
[
547,
723,
618,
735
],
[
621,
723,
675,
735
],
[
679,
722,
694,
735
],
[
697,
722,
717,
735
],
[
721,
722,
777,
735
],
[
781,
722,
795,
735
],
[
798,
721,
868,
735
],
[
871,
720,
905,
734
],
[
117,
736,
178,
750
],
[
181,
736,
218,
750
],
[
221,
736,
243,
750
],
[
247,
736,
295,
750
],
[
298,
736,
312,
750
],
[
315,
736,
381,
750
],
[
384,
736,
397,
750
],
[
400,
736,
437,
750
],
[
440,
736,
509,
750
],
[
512,
736,
571,
750
],
[
575,
736,
599,
749
],
[
602,
736,
655,
749
],
[
658,
736,
684,
749
],
[
687,
736,
722,
749
],
[
726,
736,
780,
749
],
[
784,
736,
814,
749
],
[
818,
736,
864,
749
],
[
117,
751,
175,
764
],
[
178,
751,
203,
764
],
[
206,
751,
243,
764
],
[
246,
751,
280,
764
],
[
283,
751,
295,
764
],
[
298,
751,
370,
764
],
[
373,
752,
386,
764
],
[
389,
752,
452,
764
],
[
455,
751,
555,
764
],
[
558,
751,
600,
764
],
[
603,
751,
628,
764
],
[
631,
751,
670,
764
],
[
672,
751,
757,
764
],
[
760,
751,
812,
764
],
[
814,
750,
895,
764
],
[
120,
765,
166,
779
],
[
169,
765,
227,
779
],
[
230,
766,
267,
779
],
[
270,
766,
334,
779
],
[
337,
766,
394,
780
],
[
397,
766,
411,
780
],
[
414,
766,
464,
780
],
[
467,
766,
506,
780
],
[
509,
766,
551,
780
],
[
554,
766,
596,
780
],
[
599,
766,
644,
779
],
[
647,
766,
671,
779
],
[
674,
766,
715,
779
],
[
719,
765,
742,
779
],
[
746,
765,
841,
779
],
[
844,
765,
901,
779
],
[
118,
780,
141,
793
],
[
144,
780,
196,
793
],
[
199,
780,
249,
793
],
[
251,
780,
277,
793
],
[
280,
780,
337,
793
],
[
340,
780,
355,
793
],
[
357,
780,
422,
793
],
[
424,
780,
438,
793
],
[
441,
780,
450,
793
],
[
452,
780,
487,
793
],
[
489,
780,
534,
793
],
[
536,
780,
603,
793
],
[
605,
780,
630,
793
],
[
632,
780,
641,
793
],
[
643,
780,
669,
793
],
[
671,
780,
725,
793
],
[
727,
780,
741,
793
],
[
744,
780,
766,
793
],
[
768,
780,
820,
793
],
[
822,
780,
887,
793
],
[
890,
780,
905,
793
],
[
117,
795,
130,
808
],
[
132,
795,
153,
808
],
[
156,
795,
201,
808
],
[
203,
795,
268,
808
],
[
271,
795,
310,
808
],
[
312,
795,
327,
808
],
[
330,
795,
352,
808
],
[
355,
795,
389,
808
],
[
391,
795,
465,
808
],
[
467,
795,
489,
808
],
[
492,
795,
508,
808
],
[
511,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
579,
808
],
[
582,
795,
612,
808
],
[
614,
795,
672,
808
],
[
676,
795,
745,
808
],
[
748,
795,
819,
808
],
[
821,
795,
844,
808
],
[
846,
795,
892,
808
],
[
117,
809,
137,
821
],
[
140,
809,
185,
821
],
[
188,
809,
249,
822
],
[
252,
809,
265,
822
],
[
268,
809,
325,
822
],
[
327,
809,
354,
822
],
[
357,
809,
446,
822
],
[
448,
809,
490,
822
],
[
493,
809,
519,
822
],
[
521,
809,
573,
822
],
[
575,
809,
611,
822
],
[
613,
809,
660,
822
],
[
662,
809,
694,
822
],
[
695,
809,
750,
822
],
[
752,
809,
812,
822
],
[
815,
809,
831,
821
],
[
832,
808,
867,
821
],
[
117,
824,
182,
836
],
[
185,
824,
210,
836
],
[
213,
824,
241,
836
],
[
244,
824,
277,
836
],
[
279,
824,
350,
836
],
[
352,
824,
384,
836
],
[
387,
824,
435,
836
],
[
438,
824,
494,
836
],
[
496,
824,
545,
836
],
[
547,
824,
578,
836
],
[
580,
824,
660,
836
],
[
662,
824,
720,
836
],
[
722,
824,
737,
836
],
[
739,
824,
795,
836
],
[
798,
823,
851,
836
],
[
853,
823,
878,
836
],
[
881,
823,
898,
836
],
[
120,
839,
163,
851
],
[
166,
839,
213,
851
],
[
216,
839,
261,
851
],
[
264,
839,
278,
851
],
[
281,
839,
301,
851
],
[
304,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
408,
852
],
[
411,
839,
503,
852
],
[
127,
851,
174,
865
],
[
177,
851,
214,
865
],
[
217,
851,
240,
865
],
[
242,
851,
287,
865
],
[
290,
851,
310,
865
],
[
313,
851,
385,
865
],
[
388,
851,
421,
865
],
[
424,
851,
501,
865
],
[
505,
851,
556,
865
],
[
560,
851,
582,
865
],
[
585,
851,
629,
865
],
[
632,
851,
697,
865
],
[
700,
851,
712,
865
],
[
715,
851,
724,
865
],
[
727,
851,
784,
865
],
[
788,
851,
801,
865
],
[
805,
851,
885,
865
],
[
118,
868,
164,
880
],
[
165,
868,
191,
880
],
[
193,
868,
274,
880
],
[
277,
868,
301,
880
],
[
304,
868,
367,
881
],
[
369,
868,
393,
881
],
[
397,
868,
480,
881
],
[
482,
868,
508,
881
],
[
510,
868,
585,
881
],
[
587,
868,
602,
880
],
[
604,
868,
678,
880
],
[
681,
868,
766,
880
],
[
768,
868,
810,
880
],
[
812,
868,
869,
880
],
[
871,
867,
894,
879
],
[
117,
882,
191,
895
],
[
194,
882,
254,
895
],
[
257,
882,
345,
895
],
[
30,
923,
202,
937
],
[
490,
925,
512,
937
],
[
515,
925,
559,
937
],
[
562,
925,
581,
937
],
[
584,
925,
602,
937
],
[
605,
925,
612,
937
],
[
615,
925,
691,
937
],
[
694,
925,
714,
937
],
[
717,
925,
757,
937
],
[
760,
925,
765,
937
],
[
768,
925,
801,
937
],
[
804,
924,
861,
937
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
290,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the heading of the document?
|
American Chemistry council
|
725
|
[
"American'",
"Council",
"January",
"28,",
"2013",
"John",
"Cowden,",
"Ph.D.",
"Janice",
"Lee,",
"Ph.D.",
"U.S.",
"EPA",
"National",
"Center",
"for",
"Environmental",
"Assessment",
"Mail",
"Code:",
"B243-01",
"109",
"T.W.",
"Alexander",
"Drive,",
"Durham,",
"N.C,",
"27711",
"Submitted",
"via",
"email",
"to:",
"Docket",
"[email protected];",
"cowden.john",
"@epa.gov;",
"lee.janices",
"@epa.gov",
"Regarding:",
"Submission",
"to",
"docket",
"EPA-HQ-ORD-2012-0830;",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic.",
"Dear",
"Drs.",
"Cowden",
"and",
"Lee:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"and",
"its",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"appreciate",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"on",
"the",
"draft",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic",
"(hereinafter",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"draft",
"Scope).",
"We",
"applaud",
"EPA",
"for",
"holding",
"a",
"two-day",
"stakeholder",
"workshop",
"to",
"begin",
"addressing",
"important",
"scientific",
"issues",
"that",
"will",
"inform",
"the",
"toxicological",
"review",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"the",
"National",
"Academies",
"review",
"of",
"inorganic",
"arsenic.",
"ACC",
"participated",
"remotely",
"via",
"webinar",
"and",
"we",
"found",
"the",
"technology",
"to",
"be",
"easily",
"accessible",
"and",
"generally",
"user-friendly.",
"While",
"there",
"were",
"some",
"small",
"glitches,",
"we",
"are",
"confident",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"work",
"to",
"improve",
"them",
"in",
"the",
"future.",
"To",
"further",
"improve",
"transparency,",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"very",
"helpful",
"if",
"EPA",
"could",
"share",
"the",
"presentations",
"with",
"the",
"meeting",
"participants",
"in",
"advance",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"or",
"in",
"real-time",
"via",
"email.",
"While",
"we",
"understand",
"that",
"web",
"posting",
"may",
"take",
"longer,",
"it",
"is",
"unfortunate",
"that",
"this",
"delays",
"active",
"participation",
"from",
"engaged",
"stakeholders.",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$760",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"largest",
"exporting",
"sector",
"in",
"the",
"U.S.,",
"accounting",
"for",
"12",
"percent",
"of",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"threats",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"Within",
"ACC,",
"the",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"is",
"a",
"coalition",
"of",
"independent",
"groups",
"and",
"associations",
"that",
"promotes",
"the",
"development",
"and",
"application",
"of",
"up-to-date,",
"scientifically",
"sound",
"methods",
"for",
"conducting",
"chemical",
"assessments.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ngcn0226"
] |
[
[
468,
55,
587,
75
],
[
469,
95,
558,
117
],
[
530,
165,
593,
180
],
[
596,
165,
622,
180
],
[
625,
165,
667,
180
],
[
117,
217,
157,
232
],
[
161,
218,
232,
232
],
[
235,
217,
280,
232
],
[
118,
235,
168,
250
],
[
172,
235,
207,
250
],
[
210,
235,
253,
250
],
[
117,
251,
155,
266
],
[
158,
252,
194,
267
],
[
117,
270,
186,
284
],
[
190,
270,
244,
284
],
[
247,
270,
271,
285
],
[
274,
270,
394,
285
],
[
397,
271,
491,
286
],
[
118,
287,
156,
302
],
[
160,
287,
208,
302
],
[
212,
287,
278,
302
],
[
119,
304,
150,
319
],
[
154,
305,
194,
319
],
[
197,
305,
280,
320
],
[
283,
305,
338,
321
],
[
117,
322,
188,
338
],
[
191,
322,
230,
338
],
[
234,
321,
283,
337
],
[
118,
340,
200,
355
],
[
204,
340,
228,
355
],
[
231,
340,
277,
355
],
[
280,
340,
302,
356
],
[
305,
340,
369,
356
],
[
372,
340,
498,
357
],
[
501,
340,
601,
357
],
[
605,
340,
684,
357
],
[
688,
340,
772,
357
],
[
775,
340,
854,
357
],
[
117,
374,
210,
390
],
[
214,
375,
306,
390
],
[
310,
375,
330,
390
],
[
334,
375,
384,
390
],
[
388,
375,
607,
390
],
[
611,
375,
692,
391
],
[
697,
375,
717,
391
],
[
721,
375,
745,
391
],
[
749,
375,
820,
391
],
[
824,
375,
855,
391
],
[
118,
392,
184,
408
],
[
187,
392,
265,
408
],
[
268,
392,
292,
409
],
[
295,
393,
322,
409
],
[
326,
393,
434,
409
],
[
438,
393,
497,
409
],
[
503,
393,
521,
409
],
[
525,
393,
601,
409
],
[
605,
393,
672,
409
],
[
117,
426,
157,
442
],
[
161,
427,
195,
443
],
[
199,
427,
265,
443
],
[
269,
428,
298,
443
],
[
302,
428,
338,
443
],
[
120,
463,
151,
477
],
[
154,
462,
232,
478
],
[
235,
462,
320,
478
],
[
322,
462,
386,
478
],
[
389,
462,
451,
478
],
[
454,
462,
484,
478
],
[
487,
462,
509,
478
],
[
512,
462,
565,
478
],
[
569,
462,
593,
478
],
[
597,
462,
684,
478
],
[
687,
462,
725,
477
],
[
730,
462,
824,
477
],
[
827,
462,
890,
477
],
[
117,
480,
147,
495
],
[
150,
480,
202,
495
],
[
205,
480,
290,
495
],
[
294,
480,
374,
495
],
[
378,
480,
404,
495
],
[
408,
480,
501,
495
],
[
504,
480,
520,
495
],
[
524,
480,
587,
495
],
[
591,
480,
671,
495
],
[
674,
480,
692,
495
],
[
695,
480,
721,
495
],
[
724,
480,
845,
495
],
[
117,
497,
200,
513
],
[
203,
497,
265,
514
],
[
268,
497,
321,
514
],
[
324,
497,
344,
514
],
[
347,
497,
377,
514
],
[
380,
497,
416,
514
],
[
419,
497,
491,
514
],
[
494,
497,
525,
514
],
[
528,
497,
594,
514
],
[
597,
497,
674,
514
],
[
677,
497,
701,
514
],
[
704,
497,
734,
514
],
[
737,
496,
847,
514
],
[
118,
515,
176,
530
],
[
182,
515,
200,
530
],
[
204,
515,
281,
530
],
[
284,
516,
345,
530
],
[
349,
516,
442,
531
],
[
445,
516,
510,
531
],
[
513,
516,
530,
531
],
[
533,
516,
552,
531
],
[
556,
515,
594,
531
],
[
597,
515,
654,
530
],
[
118,
550,
146,
565
],
[
149,
550,
214,
565
],
[
217,
550,
254,
565
],
[
258,
550,
282,
565
],
[
285,
550,
347,
565
],
[
351,
550,
361,
565
],
[
365,
550,
431,
566
],
[
434,
550,
527,
566
],
[
530,
550,
607,
566
],
[
611,
550,
628,
566
],
[
631,
550,
678,
566
],
[
681,
550,
765,
566
],
[
768,
550,
850,
565
],
[
117,
568,
190,
582
],
[
194,
569,
242,
583
],
[
246,
569,
278,
583
],
[
281,
569,
312,
583
],
[
315,
569,
365,
583
],
[
374,
569,
400,
583
],
[
403,
569,
506,
583
],
[
510,
569,
562,
583
],
[
569,
569,
587,
583
],
[
590,
568,
625,
583
],
[
628,
568,
646,
583
],
[
650,
568,
674,
583
],
[
678,
568,
750,
583
],
[
752,
567,
840,
582
],
[
842,
567,
894,
582
],
[
118,
585,
135,
600
],
[
138,
585,
215,
600
],
[
218,
585,
284,
600
],
[
288,
585,
328,
600
],
[
332,
585,
427,
600
],
[
430,
585,
502,
600
],
[
507,
585,
531,
600
],
[
535,
585,
600,
600
],
[
603,
585,
632,
600
],
[
635,
585,
661,
600
],
[
664,
585,
711,
600
],
[
714,
585,
740,
600
],
[
742,
585,
831,
600
],
[
834,
585,
851,
600
],
[
854,
585,
879,
600
],
[
120,
602,
164,
618
],
[
168,
602,
248,
618
],
[
252,
602,
282,
618
],
[
287,
602,
359,
618
],
[
363,
602,
472,
618
],
[
476,
602,
524,
618
],
[
527,
602,
570,
618
],
[
573,
602,
612,
618
],
[
615,
602,
658,
618
],
[
661,
602,
707,
618
],
[
710,
602,
777,
618
],
[
781,
602,
804,
618
],
[
807,
603,
832,
618
],
[
117,
620,
192,
635
],
[
196,
620,
227,
635
],
[
230,
620,
268,
635
],
[
274,
620,
306,
635
],
[
309,
620,
349,
635
],
[
352,
620,
370,
635
],
[
373,
620,
440,
635
],
[
443,
620,
480,
635
],
[
488,
620,
504,
635
],
[
507,
620,
534,
635
],
[
537,
620,
597,
635
],
[
601,
620,
622,
635
],
[
625,
620,
680,
635
],
[
683,
620,
750,
635
],
[
754,
620,
861,
635
],
[
864,
620,
878,
635
],
[
118,
637,
168,
651
],
[
171,
637,
192,
652
],
[
195,
637,
230,
652
],
[
234,
637,
291,
652
],
[
294,
637,
309,
652
],
[
312,
637,
348,
652
],
[
354,
637,
399,
652
],
[
402,
637,
444,
652
],
[
448,
637,
474,
652
],
[
477,
637,
583,
652
],
[
587,
637,
622,
652
],
[
626,
637,
651,
652
],
[
654,
637,
719,
652
],
[
722,
637,
816,
652
],
[
819,
637,
837,
652
],
[
840,
637,
907,
652
],
[
118,
655,
134,
670
],
[
138,
655,
163,
670
],
[
167,
655,
231,
670
],
[
235,
654,
253,
670
],
[
257,
654,
272,
670
],
[
276,
654,
350,
670
],
[
354,
654,
378,
670
],
[
382,
654,
438,
670
],
[
441,
654,
490,
670
],
[
493,
654,
517,
670
],
[
520,
654,
608,
670
],
[
612,
654,
643,
670
],
[
647,
654,
680,
670
],
[
682,
654,
742,
670
],
[
746,
654,
781,
670
],
[
785,
654,
819,
671
],
[
822,
654,
878,
671
],
[
881,
655,
894,
671
],
[
118,
672,
132,
686
],
[
135,
672,
228,
687
],
[
231,
673,
261,
687
],
[
264,
673,
298,
687
],
[
302,
673,
350,
687
],
[
354,
673,
402,
688
],
[
405,
673,
507,
688
],
[
510,
673,
545,
688
],
[
552,
673,
620,
688
],
[
622,
672,
730,
688
],
[
127,
720,
152,
734
],
[
156,
720,
221,
735
],
[
224,
721,
292,
735
],
[
296,
722,
349,
735
],
[
352,
722,
397,
735
],
[
400,
722,
467,
735
],
[
471,
723,
491,
735
],
[
495,
723,
544,
735
],
[
547,
723,
618,
735
],
[
621,
723,
675,
735
],
[
679,
722,
694,
735
],
[
697,
722,
717,
735
],
[
721,
722,
777,
735
],
[
781,
722,
795,
735
],
[
798,
721,
868,
735
],
[
871,
720,
905,
734
],
[
117,
736,
178,
750
],
[
181,
736,
218,
750
],
[
221,
736,
243,
750
],
[
247,
736,
295,
750
],
[
298,
736,
312,
750
],
[
315,
736,
381,
750
],
[
384,
736,
397,
750
],
[
400,
736,
437,
750
],
[
440,
736,
509,
750
],
[
512,
736,
571,
750
],
[
575,
736,
599,
749
],
[
602,
736,
655,
749
],
[
658,
736,
684,
749
],
[
687,
736,
722,
749
],
[
726,
736,
780,
749
],
[
784,
736,
814,
749
],
[
818,
736,
864,
749
],
[
117,
751,
175,
764
],
[
178,
751,
203,
764
],
[
206,
751,
243,
764
],
[
246,
751,
280,
764
],
[
283,
751,
295,
764
],
[
298,
751,
370,
764
],
[
373,
752,
386,
764
],
[
389,
752,
452,
764
],
[
455,
751,
555,
764
],
[
558,
751,
600,
764
],
[
603,
751,
628,
764
],
[
631,
751,
670,
764
],
[
672,
751,
757,
764
],
[
760,
751,
812,
764
],
[
814,
750,
895,
764
],
[
120,
765,
166,
779
],
[
169,
765,
227,
779
],
[
230,
766,
267,
779
],
[
270,
766,
334,
779
],
[
337,
766,
394,
780
],
[
397,
766,
411,
780
],
[
414,
766,
464,
780
],
[
467,
766,
506,
780
],
[
509,
766,
551,
780
],
[
554,
766,
596,
780
],
[
599,
766,
644,
779
],
[
647,
766,
671,
779
],
[
674,
766,
715,
779
],
[
719,
765,
742,
779
],
[
746,
765,
841,
779
],
[
844,
765,
901,
779
],
[
118,
780,
141,
793
],
[
144,
780,
196,
793
],
[
199,
780,
249,
793
],
[
251,
780,
277,
793
],
[
280,
780,
337,
793
],
[
340,
780,
355,
793
],
[
357,
780,
422,
793
],
[
424,
780,
438,
793
],
[
441,
780,
450,
793
],
[
452,
780,
487,
793
],
[
489,
780,
534,
793
],
[
536,
780,
603,
793
],
[
605,
780,
630,
793
],
[
632,
780,
641,
793
],
[
643,
780,
669,
793
],
[
671,
780,
725,
793
],
[
727,
780,
741,
793
],
[
744,
780,
766,
793
],
[
768,
780,
820,
793
],
[
822,
780,
887,
793
],
[
890,
780,
905,
793
],
[
117,
795,
130,
808
],
[
132,
795,
153,
808
],
[
156,
795,
201,
808
],
[
203,
795,
268,
808
],
[
271,
795,
310,
808
],
[
312,
795,
327,
808
],
[
330,
795,
352,
808
],
[
355,
795,
389,
808
],
[
391,
795,
465,
808
],
[
467,
795,
489,
808
],
[
492,
795,
508,
808
],
[
511,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
579,
808
],
[
582,
795,
612,
808
],
[
614,
795,
672,
808
],
[
676,
795,
745,
808
],
[
748,
795,
819,
808
],
[
821,
795,
844,
808
],
[
846,
795,
892,
808
],
[
117,
809,
137,
821
],
[
140,
809,
185,
821
],
[
188,
809,
249,
822
],
[
252,
809,
265,
822
],
[
268,
809,
325,
822
],
[
327,
809,
354,
822
],
[
357,
809,
446,
822
],
[
448,
809,
490,
822
],
[
493,
809,
519,
822
],
[
521,
809,
573,
822
],
[
575,
809,
611,
822
],
[
613,
809,
660,
822
],
[
662,
809,
694,
822
],
[
695,
809,
750,
822
],
[
752,
809,
812,
822
],
[
815,
809,
831,
821
],
[
832,
808,
867,
821
],
[
117,
824,
182,
836
],
[
185,
824,
210,
836
],
[
213,
824,
241,
836
],
[
244,
824,
277,
836
],
[
279,
824,
350,
836
],
[
352,
824,
384,
836
],
[
387,
824,
435,
836
],
[
438,
824,
494,
836
],
[
496,
824,
545,
836
],
[
547,
824,
578,
836
],
[
580,
824,
660,
836
],
[
662,
824,
720,
836
],
[
722,
824,
737,
836
],
[
739,
824,
795,
836
],
[
798,
823,
851,
836
],
[
853,
823,
878,
836
],
[
881,
823,
898,
836
],
[
120,
839,
163,
851
],
[
166,
839,
213,
851
],
[
216,
839,
261,
851
],
[
264,
839,
278,
851
],
[
281,
839,
301,
851
],
[
304,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
408,
852
],
[
411,
839,
503,
852
],
[
127,
851,
174,
865
],
[
177,
851,
214,
865
],
[
217,
851,
240,
865
],
[
242,
851,
287,
865
],
[
290,
851,
310,
865
],
[
313,
851,
385,
865
],
[
388,
851,
421,
865
],
[
424,
851,
501,
865
],
[
505,
851,
556,
865
],
[
560,
851,
582,
865
],
[
585,
851,
629,
865
],
[
632,
851,
697,
865
],
[
700,
851,
712,
865
],
[
715,
851,
724,
865
],
[
727,
851,
784,
865
],
[
788,
851,
801,
865
],
[
805,
851,
885,
865
],
[
118,
868,
164,
880
],
[
165,
868,
191,
880
],
[
193,
868,
274,
880
],
[
277,
868,
301,
880
],
[
304,
868,
367,
881
],
[
369,
868,
393,
881
],
[
397,
868,
480,
881
],
[
482,
868,
508,
881
],
[
510,
868,
585,
881
],
[
587,
868,
602,
880
],
[
604,
868,
678,
880
],
[
681,
868,
766,
880
],
[
768,
868,
810,
880
],
[
812,
868,
869,
880
],
[
871,
867,
894,
879
],
[
117,
882,
191,
895
],
[
194,
882,
254,
895
],
[
257,
882,
345,
895
],
[
30,
923,
202,
937
],
[
490,
925,
512,
937
],
[
515,
925,
559,
937
],
[
562,
925,
581,
937
],
[
584,
925,
602,
937
],
[
605,
925,
612,
937
],
[
615,
925,
691,
937
],
[
694,
925,
714,
937
],
[
717,
925,
757,
937
],
[
760,
925,
765,
937
],
[
768,
925,
801,
937
],
[
804,
924,
861,
937
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
290,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned?
|
january 28, 2013
|
725
|
[
"American'",
"Council",
"January",
"28,",
"2013",
"John",
"Cowden,",
"Ph.D.",
"Janice",
"Lee,",
"Ph.D.",
"U.S.",
"EPA",
"National",
"Center",
"for",
"Environmental",
"Assessment",
"Mail",
"Code:",
"B243-01",
"109",
"T.W.",
"Alexander",
"Drive,",
"Durham,",
"N.C,",
"27711",
"Submitted",
"via",
"email",
"to:",
"Docket",
"[email protected];",
"cowden.john",
"@epa.gov;",
"lee.janices",
"@epa.gov",
"Regarding:",
"Submission",
"to",
"docket",
"EPA-HQ-ORD-2012-0830;",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic.",
"Dear",
"Drs.",
"Cowden",
"and",
"Lee:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"and",
"its",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"appreciate",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"on",
"the",
"draft",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic",
"(hereinafter",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"draft",
"Scope).",
"We",
"applaud",
"EPA",
"for",
"holding",
"a",
"two-day",
"stakeholder",
"workshop",
"to",
"begin",
"addressing",
"important",
"scientific",
"issues",
"that",
"will",
"inform",
"the",
"toxicological",
"review",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"the",
"National",
"Academies",
"review",
"of",
"inorganic",
"arsenic.",
"ACC",
"participated",
"remotely",
"via",
"webinar",
"and",
"we",
"found",
"the",
"technology",
"to",
"be",
"easily",
"accessible",
"and",
"generally",
"user-friendly.",
"While",
"there",
"were",
"some",
"small",
"glitches,",
"we",
"are",
"confident",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"work",
"to",
"improve",
"them",
"in",
"the",
"future.",
"To",
"further",
"improve",
"transparency,",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"very",
"helpful",
"if",
"EPA",
"could",
"share",
"the",
"presentations",
"with",
"the",
"meeting",
"participants",
"in",
"advance",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"or",
"in",
"real-time",
"via",
"email.",
"While",
"we",
"understand",
"that",
"web",
"posting",
"may",
"take",
"longer,",
"it",
"is",
"unfortunate",
"that",
"this",
"delays",
"active",
"participation",
"from",
"engaged",
"stakeholders.",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$760",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"largest",
"exporting",
"sector",
"in",
"the",
"U.S.,",
"accounting",
"for",
"12",
"percent",
"of",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"threats",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"Within",
"ACC,",
"the",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"is",
"a",
"coalition",
"of",
"independent",
"groups",
"and",
"associations",
"that",
"promotes",
"the",
"development",
"and",
"application",
"of",
"up-to-date,",
"scientifically",
"sound",
"methods",
"for",
"conducting",
"chemical",
"assessments.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ngcn0226"
] |
[
[
468,
55,
587,
75
],
[
469,
95,
558,
117
],
[
530,
165,
593,
180
],
[
596,
165,
622,
180
],
[
625,
165,
667,
180
],
[
117,
217,
157,
232
],
[
161,
218,
232,
232
],
[
235,
217,
280,
232
],
[
118,
235,
168,
250
],
[
172,
235,
207,
250
],
[
210,
235,
253,
250
],
[
117,
251,
155,
266
],
[
158,
252,
194,
267
],
[
117,
270,
186,
284
],
[
190,
270,
244,
284
],
[
247,
270,
271,
285
],
[
274,
270,
394,
285
],
[
397,
271,
491,
286
],
[
118,
287,
156,
302
],
[
160,
287,
208,
302
],
[
212,
287,
278,
302
],
[
119,
304,
150,
319
],
[
154,
305,
194,
319
],
[
197,
305,
280,
320
],
[
283,
305,
338,
321
],
[
117,
322,
188,
338
],
[
191,
322,
230,
338
],
[
234,
321,
283,
337
],
[
118,
340,
200,
355
],
[
204,
340,
228,
355
],
[
231,
340,
277,
355
],
[
280,
340,
302,
356
],
[
305,
340,
369,
356
],
[
372,
340,
498,
357
],
[
501,
340,
601,
357
],
[
605,
340,
684,
357
],
[
688,
340,
772,
357
],
[
775,
340,
854,
357
],
[
117,
374,
210,
390
],
[
214,
375,
306,
390
],
[
310,
375,
330,
390
],
[
334,
375,
384,
390
],
[
388,
375,
607,
390
],
[
611,
375,
692,
391
],
[
697,
375,
717,
391
],
[
721,
375,
745,
391
],
[
749,
375,
820,
391
],
[
824,
375,
855,
391
],
[
118,
392,
184,
408
],
[
187,
392,
265,
408
],
[
268,
392,
292,
409
],
[
295,
393,
322,
409
],
[
326,
393,
434,
409
],
[
438,
393,
497,
409
],
[
503,
393,
521,
409
],
[
525,
393,
601,
409
],
[
605,
393,
672,
409
],
[
117,
426,
157,
442
],
[
161,
427,
195,
443
],
[
199,
427,
265,
443
],
[
269,
428,
298,
443
],
[
302,
428,
338,
443
],
[
120,
463,
151,
477
],
[
154,
462,
232,
478
],
[
235,
462,
320,
478
],
[
322,
462,
386,
478
],
[
389,
462,
451,
478
],
[
454,
462,
484,
478
],
[
487,
462,
509,
478
],
[
512,
462,
565,
478
],
[
569,
462,
593,
478
],
[
597,
462,
684,
478
],
[
687,
462,
725,
477
],
[
730,
462,
824,
477
],
[
827,
462,
890,
477
],
[
117,
480,
147,
495
],
[
150,
480,
202,
495
],
[
205,
480,
290,
495
],
[
294,
480,
374,
495
],
[
378,
480,
404,
495
],
[
408,
480,
501,
495
],
[
504,
480,
520,
495
],
[
524,
480,
587,
495
],
[
591,
480,
671,
495
],
[
674,
480,
692,
495
],
[
695,
480,
721,
495
],
[
724,
480,
845,
495
],
[
117,
497,
200,
513
],
[
203,
497,
265,
514
],
[
268,
497,
321,
514
],
[
324,
497,
344,
514
],
[
347,
497,
377,
514
],
[
380,
497,
416,
514
],
[
419,
497,
491,
514
],
[
494,
497,
525,
514
],
[
528,
497,
594,
514
],
[
597,
497,
674,
514
],
[
677,
497,
701,
514
],
[
704,
497,
734,
514
],
[
737,
496,
847,
514
],
[
118,
515,
176,
530
],
[
182,
515,
200,
530
],
[
204,
515,
281,
530
],
[
284,
516,
345,
530
],
[
349,
516,
442,
531
],
[
445,
516,
510,
531
],
[
513,
516,
530,
531
],
[
533,
516,
552,
531
],
[
556,
515,
594,
531
],
[
597,
515,
654,
530
],
[
118,
550,
146,
565
],
[
149,
550,
214,
565
],
[
217,
550,
254,
565
],
[
258,
550,
282,
565
],
[
285,
550,
347,
565
],
[
351,
550,
361,
565
],
[
365,
550,
431,
566
],
[
434,
550,
527,
566
],
[
530,
550,
607,
566
],
[
611,
550,
628,
566
],
[
631,
550,
678,
566
],
[
681,
550,
765,
566
],
[
768,
550,
850,
565
],
[
117,
568,
190,
582
],
[
194,
569,
242,
583
],
[
246,
569,
278,
583
],
[
281,
569,
312,
583
],
[
315,
569,
365,
583
],
[
374,
569,
400,
583
],
[
403,
569,
506,
583
],
[
510,
569,
562,
583
],
[
569,
569,
587,
583
],
[
590,
568,
625,
583
],
[
628,
568,
646,
583
],
[
650,
568,
674,
583
],
[
678,
568,
750,
583
],
[
752,
567,
840,
582
],
[
842,
567,
894,
582
],
[
118,
585,
135,
600
],
[
138,
585,
215,
600
],
[
218,
585,
284,
600
],
[
288,
585,
328,
600
],
[
332,
585,
427,
600
],
[
430,
585,
502,
600
],
[
507,
585,
531,
600
],
[
535,
585,
600,
600
],
[
603,
585,
632,
600
],
[
635,
585,
661,
600
],
[
664,
585,
711,
600
],
[
714,
585,
740,
600
],
[
742,
585,
831,
600
],
[
834,
585,
851,
600
],
[
854,
585,
879,
600
],
[
120,
602,
164,
618
],
[
168,
602,
248,
618
],
[
252,
602,
282,
618
],
[
287,
602,
359,
618
],
[
363,
602,
472,
618
],
[
476,
602,
524,
618
],
[
527,
602,
570,
618
],
[
573,
602,
612,
618
],
[
615,
602,
658,
618
],
[
661,
602,
707,
618
],
[
710,
602,
777,
618
],
[
781,
602,
804,
618
],
[
807,
603,
832,
618
],
[
117,
620,
192,
635
],
[
196,
620,
227,
635
],
[
230,
620,
268,
635
],
[
274,
620,
306,
635
],
[
309,
620,
349,
635
],
[
352,
620,
370,
635
],
[
373,
620,
440,
635
],
[
443,
620,
480,
635
],
[
488,
620,
504,
635
],
[
507,
620,
534,
635
],
[
537,
620,
597,
635
],
[
601,
620,
622,
635
],
[
625,
620,
680,
635
],
[
683,
620,
750,
635
],
[
754,
620,
861,
635
],
[
864,
620,
878,
635
],
[
118,
637,
168,
651
],
[
171,
637,
192,
652
],
[
195,
637,
230,
652
],
[
234,
637,
291,
652
],
[
294,
637,
309,
652
],
[
312,
637,
348,
652
],
[
354,
637,
399,
652
],
[
402,
637,
444,
652
],
[
448,
637,
474,
652
],
[
477,
637,
583,
652
],
[
587,
637,
622,
652
],
[
626,
637,
651,
652
],
[
654,
637,
719,
652
],
[
722,
637,
816,
652
],
[
819,
637,
837,
652
],
[
840,
637,
907,
652
],
[
118,
655,
134,
670
],
[
138,
655,
163,
670
],
[
167,
655,
231,
670
],
[
235,
654,
253,
670
],
[
257,
654,
272,
670
],
[
276,
654,
350,
670
],
[
354,
654,
378,
670
],
[
382,
654,
438,
670
],
[
441,
654,
490,
670
],
[
493,
654,
517,
670
],
[
520,
654,
608,
670
],
[
612,
654,
643,
670
],
[
647,
654,
680,
670
],
[
682,
654,
742,
670
],
[
746,
654,
781,
670
],
[
785,
654,
819,
671
],
[
822,
654,
878,
671
],
[
881,
655,
894,
671
],
[
118,
672,
132,
686
],
[
135,
672,
228,
687
],
[
231,
673,
261,
687
],
[
264,
673,
298,
687
],
[
302,
673,
350,
687
],
[
354,
673,
402,
688
],
[
405,
673,
507,
688
],
[
510,
673,
545,
688
],
[
552,
673,
620,
688
],
[
622,
672,
730,
688
],
[
127,
720,
152,
734
],
[
156,
720,
221,
735
],
[
224,
721,
292,
735
],
[
296,
722,
349,
735
],
[
352,
722,
397,
735
],
[
400,
722,
467,
735
],
[
471,
723,
491,
735
],
[
495,
723,
544,
735
],
[
547,
723,
618,
735
],
[
621,
723,
675,
735
],
[
679,
722,
694,
735
],
[
697,
722,
717,
735
],
[
721,
722,
777,
735
],
[
781,
722,
795,
735
],
[
798,
721,
868,
735
],
[
871,
720,
905,
734
],
[
117,
736,
178,
750
],
[
181,
736,
218,
750
],
[
221,
736,
243,
750
],
[
247,
736,
295,
750
],
[
298,
736,
312,
750
],
[
315,
736,
381,
750
],
[
384,
736,
397,
750
],
[
400,
736,
437,
750
],
[
440,
736,
509,
750
],
[
512,
736,
571,
750
],
[
575,
736,
599,
749
],
[
602,
736,
655,
749
],
[
658,
736,
684,
749
],
[
687,
736,
722,
749
],
[
726,
736,
780,
749
],
[
784,
736,
814,
749
],
[
818,
736,
864,
749
],
[
117,
751,
175,
764
],
[
178,
751,
203,
764
],
[
206,
751,
243,
764
],
[
246,
751,
280,
764
],
[
283,
751,
295,
764
],
[
298,
751,
370,
764
],
[
373,
752,
386,
764
],
[
389,
752,
452,
764
],
[
455,
751,
555,
764
],
[
558,
751,
600,
764
],
[
603,
751,
628,
764
],
[
631,
751,
670,
764
],
[
672,
751,
757,
764
],
[
760,
751,
812,
764
],
[
814,
750,
895,
764
],
[
120,
765,
166,
779
],
[
169,
765,
227,
779
],
[
230,
766,
267,
779
],
[
270,
766,
334,
779
],
[
337,
766,
394,
780
],
[
397,
766,
411,
780
],
[
414,
766,
464,
780
],
[
467,
766,
506,
780
],
[
509,
766,
551,
780
],
[
554,
766,
596,
780
],
[
599,
766,
644,
779
],
[
647,
766,
671,
779
],
[
674,
766,
715,
779
],
[
719,
765,
742,
779
],
[
746,
765,
841,
779
],
[
844,
765,
901,
779
],
[
118,
780,
141,
793
],
[
144,
780,
196,
793
],
[
199,
780,
249,
793
],
[
251,
780,
277,
793
],
[
280,
780,
337,
793
],
[
340,
780,
355,
793
],
[
357,
780,
422,
793
],
[
424,
780,
438,
793
],
[
441,
780,
450,
793
],
[
452,
780,
487,
793
],
[
489,
780,
534,
793
],
[
536,
780,
603,
793
],
[
605,
780,
630,
793
],
[
632,
780,
641,
793
],
[
643,
780,
669,
793
],
[
671,
780,
725,
793
],
[
727,
780,
741,
793
],
[
744,
780,
766,
793
],
[
768,
780,
820,
793
],
[
822,
780,
887,
793
],
[
890,
780,
905,
793
],
[
117,
795,
130,
808
],
[
132,
795,
153,
808
],
[
156,
795,
201,
808
],
[
203,
795,
268,
808
],
[
271,
795,
310,
808
],
[
312,
795,
327,
808
],
[
330,
795,
352,
808
],
[
355,
795,
389,
808
],
[
391,
795,
465,
808
],
[
467,
795,
489,
808
],
[
492,
795,
508,
808
],
[
511,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
579,
808
],
[
582,
795,
612,
808
],
[
614,
795,
672,
808
],
[
676,
795,
745,
808
],
[
748,
795,
819,
808
],
[
821,
795,
844,
808
],
[
846,
795,
892,
808
],
[
117,
809,
137,
821
],
[
140,
809,
185,
821
],
[
188,
809,
249,
822
],
[
252,
809,
265,
822
],
[
268,
809,
325,
822
],
[
327,
809,
354,
822
],
[
357,
809,
446,
822
],
[
448,
809,
490,
822
],
[
493,
809,
519,
822
],
[
521,
809,
573,
822
],
[
575,
809,
611,
822
],
[
613,
809,
660,
822
],
[
662,
809,
694,
822
],
[
695,
809,
750,
822
],
[
752,
809,
812,
822
],
[
815,
809,
831,
821
],
[
832,
808,
867,
821
],
[
117,
824,
182,
836
],
[
185,
824,
210,
836
],
[
213,
824,
241,
836
],
[
244,
824,
277,
836
],
[
279,
824,
350,
836
],
[
352,
824,
384,
836
],
[
387,
824,
435,
836
],
[
438,
824,
494,
836
],
[
496,
824,
545,
836
],
[
547,
824,
578,
836
],
[
580,
824,
660,
836
],
[
662,
824,
720,
836
],
[
722,
824,
737,
836
],
[
739,
824,
795,
836
],
[
798,
823,
851,
836
],
[
853,
823,
878,
836
],
[
881,
823,
898,
836
],
[
120,
839,
163,
851
],
[
166,
839,
213,
851
],
[
216,
839,
261,
851
],
[
264,
839,
278,
851
],
[
281,
839,
301,
851
],
[
304,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
408,
852
],
[
411,
839,
503,
852
],
[
127,
851,
174,
865
],
[
177,
851,
214,
865
],
[
217,
851,
240,
865
],
[
242,
851,
287,
865
],
[
290,
851,
310,
865
],
[
313,
851,
385,
865
],
[
388,
851,
421,
865
],
[
424,
851,
501,
865
],
[
505,
851,
556,
865
],
[
560,
851,
582,
865
],
[
585,
851,
629,
865
],
[
632,
851,
697,
865
],
[
700,
851,
712,
865
],
[
715,
851,
724,
865
],
[
727,
851,
784,
865
],
[
788,
851,
801,
865
],
[
805,
851,
885,
865
],
[
118,
868,
164,
880
],
[
165,
868,
191,
880
],
[
193,
868,
274,
880
],
[
277,
868,
301,
880
],
[
304,
868,
367,
881
],
[
369,
868,
393,
881
],
[
397,
868,
480,
881
],
[
482,
868,
508,
881
],
[
510,
868,
585,
881
],
[
587,
868,
602,
880
],
[
604,
868,
678,
880
],
[
681,
868,
766,
880
],
[
768,
868,
810,
880
],
[
812,
868,
869,
880
],
[
871,
867,
894,
879
],
[
117,
882,
191,
895
],
[
194,
882,
254,
895
],
[
257,
882,
345,
895
],
[
30,
923,
202,
937
],
[
490,
925,
512,
937
],
[
515,
925,
559,
937
],
[
562,
925,
581,
937
],
[
584,
925,
602,
937
],
[
605,
925,
612,
937
],
[
615,
925,
691,
937
],
[
694,
925,
714,
937
],
[
717,
925,
757,
937
],
[
760,
925,
765,
937
],
[
768,
925,
801,
937
],
[
804,
924,
861,
937
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
290,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
To whom is this email addressed?
|
Drs. Cowden and Lee
|
725
|
[
"American'",
"Council",
"January",
"28,",
"2013",
"John",
"Cowden,",
"Ph.D.",
"Janice",
"Lee,",
"Ph.D.",
"U.S.",
"EPA",
"National",
"Center",
"for",
"Environmental",
"Assessment",
"Mail",
"Code:",
"B243-01",
"109",
"T.W.",
"Alexander",
"Drive,",
"Durham,",
"N.C,",
"27711",
"Submitted",
"via",
"email",
"to:",
"Docket",
"[email protected];",
"cowden.john",
"@epa.gov;",
"lee.janices",
"@epa.gov",
"Regarding:",
"Submission",
"to",
"docket",
"EPA-HQ-ORD-2012-0830;",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic.",
"Dear",
"Drs.",
"Cowden",
"and",
"Lee:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"and",
"its",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"appreciate",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"on",
"the",
"draft",
"Planning",
"and",
"Scoping",
"Summary",
"for",
"the",
"Toxicological",
"Review",
"of",
"Inorganic",
"Arsenic",
"(hereinafter",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"draft",
"Scope).",
"We",
"applaud",
"EPA",
"for",
"holding",
"a",
"two-day",
"stakeholder",
"workshop",
"to",
"begin",
"addressing",
"important",
"scientific",
"issues",
"that",
"will",
"inform",
"the",
"toxicological",
"review",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"the",
"National",
"Academies",
"review",
"of",
"inorganic",
"arsenic.",
"ACC",
"participated",
"remotely",
"via",
"webinar",
"and",
"we",
"found",
"the",
"technology",
"to",
"be",
"easily",
"accessible",
"and",
"generally",
"user-friendly.",
"While",
"there",
"were",
"some",
"small",
"glitches,",
"we",
"are",
"confident",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"work",
"to",
"improve",
"them",
"in",
"the",
"future.",
"To",
"further",
"improve",
"transparency,",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"very",
"helpful",
"if",
"EPA",
"could",
"share",
"the",
"presentations",
"with",
"the",
"meeting",
"participants",
"in",
"advance",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"or",
"in",
"real-time",
"via",
"email.",
"While",
"we",
"understand",
"that",
"web",
"posting",
"may",
"take",
"longer,",
"it",
"is",
"unfortunate",
"that",
"this",
"delays",
"active",
"participation",
"from",
"engaged",
"stakeholders.",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$760",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"the",
"largest",
"exporting",
"sector",
"in",
"the",
"U.S.,",
"accounting",
"for",
"12",
"percent",
"of",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"threats",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"Within",
"ACC,",
"the",
"Center",
"for",
"Advancing",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Science",
"and",
"Policy",
"(ARASP)",
"is",
"a",
"coalition",
"of",
"independent",
"groups",
"and",
"associations",
"that",
"promotes",
"the",
"development",
"and",
"application",
"of",
"up-to-date,",
"scientifically",
"sound",
"methods",
"for",
"conducting",
"chemical",
"assessments.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ngcn0226"
] |
[
[
468,
55,
587,
75
],
[
469,
95,
558,
117
],
[
530,
165,
593,
180
],
[
596,
165,
622,
180
],
[
625,
165,
667,
180
],
[
117,
217,
157,
232
],
[
161,
218,
232,
232
],
[
235,
217,
280,
232
],
[
118,
235,
168,
250
],
[
172,
235,
207,
250
],
[
210,
235,
253,
250
],
[
117,
251,
155,
266
],
[
158,
252,
194,
267
],
[
117,
270,
186,
284
],
[
190,
270,
244,
284
],
[
247,
270,
271,
285
],
[
274,
270,
394,
285
],
[
397,
271,
491,
286
],
[
118,
287,
156,
302
],
[
160,
287,
208,
302
],
[
212,
287,
278,
302
],
[
119,
304,
150,
319
],
[
154,
305,
194,
319
],
[
197,
305,
280,
320
],
[
283,
305,
338,
321
],
[
117,
322,
188,
338
],
[
191,
322,
230,
338
],
[
234,
321,
283,
337
],
[
118,
340,
200,
355
],
[
204,
340,
228,
355
],
[
231,
340,
277,
355
],
[
280,
340,
302,
356
],
[
305,
340,
369,
356
],
[
372,
340,
498,
357
],
[
501,
340,
601,
357
],
[
605,
340,
684,
357
],
[
688,
340,
772,
357
],
[
775,
340,
854,
357
],
[
117,
374,
210,
390
],
[
214,
375,
306,
390
],
[
310,
375,
330,
390
],
[
334,
375,
384,
390
],
[
388,
375,
607,
390
],
[
611,
375,
692,
391
],
[
697,
375,
717,
391
],
[
721,
375,
745,
391
],
[
749,
375,
820,
391
],
[
824,
375,
855,
391
],
[
118,
392,
184,
408
],
[
187,
392,
265,
408
],
[
268,
392,
292,
409
],
[
295,
393,
322,
409
],
[
326,
393,
434,
409
],
[
438,
393,
497,
409
],
[
503,
393,
521,
409
],
[
525,
393,
601,
409
],
[
605,
393,
672,
409
],
[
117,
426,
157,
442
],
[
161,
427,
195,
443
],
[
199,
427,
265,
443
],
[
269,
428,
298,
443
],
[
302,
428,
338,
443
],
[
120,
463,
151,
477
],
[
154,
462,
232,
478
],
[
235,
462,
320,
478
],
[
322,
462,
386,
478
],
[
389,
462,
451,
478
],
[
454,
462,
484,
478
],
[
487,
462,
509,
478
],
[
512,
462,
565,
478
],
[
569,
462,
593,
478
],
[
597,
462,
684,
478
],
[
687,
462,
725,
477
],
[
730,
462,
824,
477
],
[
827,
462,
890,
477
],
[
117,
480,
147,
495
],
[
150,
480,
202,
495
],
[
205,
480,
290,
495
],
[
294,
480,
374,
495
],
[
378,
480,
404,
495
],
[
408,
480,
501,
495
],
[
504,
480,
520,
495
],
[
524,
480,
587,
495
],
[
591,
480,
671,
495
],
[
674,
480,
692,
495
],
[
695,
480,
721,
495
],
[
724,
480,
845,
495
],
[
117,
497,
200,
513
],
[
203,
497,
265,
514
],
[
268,
497,
321,
514
],
[
324,
497,
344,
514
],
[
347,
497,
377,
514
],
[
380,
497,
416,
514
],
[
419,
497,
491,
514
],
[
494,
497,
525,
514
],
[
528,
497,
594,
514
],
[
597,
497,
674,
514
],
[
677,
497,
701,
514
],
[
704,
497,
734,
514
],
[
737,
496,
847,
514
],
[
118,
515,
176,
530
],
[
182,
515,
200,
530
],
[
204,
515,
281,
530
],
[
284,
516,
345,
530
],
[
349,
516,
442,
531
],
[
445,
516,
510,
531
],
[
513,
516,
530,
531
],
[
533,
516,
552,
531
],
[
556,
515,
594,
531
],
[
597,
515,
654,
530
],
[
118,
550,
146,
565
],
[
149,
550,
214,
565
],
[
217,
550,
254,
565
],
[
258,
550,
282,
565
],
[
285,
550,
347,
565
],
[
351,
550,
361,
565
],
[
365,
550,
431,
566
],
[
434,
550,
527,
566
],
[
530,
550,
607,
566
],
[
611,
550,
628,
566
],
[
631,
550,
678,
566
],
[
681,
550,
765,
566
],
[
768,
550,
850,
565
],
[
117,
568,
190,
582
],
[
194,
569,
242,
583
],
[
246,
569,
278,
583
],
[
281,
569,
312,
583
],
[
315,
569,
365,
583
],
[
374,
569,
400,
583
],
[
403,
569,
506,
583
],
[
510,
569,
562,
583
],
[
569,
569,
587,
583
],
[
590,
568,
625,
583
],
[
628,
568,
646,
583
],
[
650,
568,
674,
583
],
[
678,
568,
750,
583
],
[
752,
567,
840,
582
],
[
842,
567,
894,
582
],
[
118,
585,
135,
600
],
[
138,
585,
215,
600
],
[
218,
585,
284,
600
],
[
288,
585,
328,
600
],
[
332,
585,
427,
600
],
[
430,
585,
502,
600
],
[
507,
585,
531,
600
],
[
535,
585,
600,
600
],
[
603,
585,
632,
600
],
[
635,
585,
661,
600
],
[
664,
585,
711,
600
],
[
714,
585,
740,
600
],
[
742,
585,
831,
600
],
[
834,
585,
851,
600
],
[
854,
585,
879,
600
],
[
120,
602,
164,
618
],
[
168,
602,
248,
618
],
[
252,
602,
282,
618
],
[
287,
602,
359,
618
],
[
363,
602,
472,
618
],
[
476,
602,
524,
618
],
[
527,
602,
570,
618
],
[
573,
602,
612,
618
],
[
615,
602,
658,
618
],
[
661,
602,
707,
618
],
[
710,
602,
777,
618
],
[
781,
602,
804,
618
],
[
807,
603,
832,
618
],
[
117,
620,
192,
635
],
[
196,
620,
227,
635
],
[
230,
620,
268,
635
],
[
274,
620,
306,
635
],
[
309,
620,
349,
635
],
[
352,
620,
370,
635
],
[
373,
620,
440,
635
],
[
443,
620,
480,
635
],
[
488,
620,
504,
635
],
[
507,
620,
534,
635
],
[
537,
620,
597,
635
],
[
601,
620,
622,
635
],
[
625,
620,
680,
635
],
[
683,
620,
750,
635
],
[
754,
620,
861,
635
],
[
864,
620,
878,
635
],
[
118,
637,
168,
651
],
[
171,
637,
192,
652
],
[
195,
637,
230,
652
],
[
234,
637,
291,
652
],
[
294,
637,
309,
652
],
[
312,
637,
348,
652
],
[
354,
637,
399,
652
],
[
402,
637,
444,
652
],
[
448,
637,
474,
652
],
[
477,
637,
583,
652
],
[
587,
637,
622,
652
],
[
626,
637,
651,
652
],
[
654,
637,
719,
652
],
[
722,
637,
816,
652
],
[
819,
637,
837,
652
],
[
840,
637,
907,
652
],
[
118,
655,
134,
670
],
[
138,
655,
163,
670
],
[
167,
655,
231,
670
],
[
235,
654,
253,
670
],
[
257,
654,
272,
670
],
[
276,
654,
350,
670
],
[
354,
654,
378,
670
],
[
382,
654,
438,
670
],
[
441,
654,
490,
670
],
[
493,
654,
517,
670
],
[
520,
654,
608,
670
],
[
612,
654,
643,
670
],
[
647,
654,
680,
670
],
[
682,
654,
742,
670
],
[
746,
654,
781,
670
],
[
785,
654,
819,
671
],
[
822,
654,
878,
671
],
[
881,
655,
894,
671
],
[
118,
672,
132,
686
],
[
135,
672,
228,
687
],
[
231,
673,
261,
687
],
[
264,
673,
298,
687
],
[
302,
673,
350,
687
],
[
354,
673,
402,
688
],
[
405,
673,
507,
688
],
[
510,
673,
545,
688
],
[
552,
673,
620,
688
],
[
622,
672,
730,
688
],
[
127,
720,
152,
734
],
[
156,
720,
221,
735
],
[
224,
721,
292,
735
],
[
296,
722,
349,
735
],
[
352,
722,
397,
735
],
[
400,
722,
467,
735
],
[
471,
723,
491,
735
],
[
495,
723,
544,
735
],
[
547,
723,
618,
735
],
[
621,
723,
675,
735
],
[
679,
722,
694,
735
],
[
697,
722,
717,
735
],
[
721,
722,
777,
735
],
[
781,
722,
795,
735
],
[
798,
721,
868,
735
],
[
871,
720,
905,
734
],
[
117,
736,
178,
750
],
[
181,
736,
218,
750
],
[
221,
736,
243,
750
],
[
247,
736,
295,
750
],
[
298,
736,
312,
750
],
[
315,
736,
381,
750
],
[
384,
736,
397,
750
],
[
400,
736,
437,
750
],
[
440,
736,
509,
750
],
[
512,
736,
571,
750
],
[
575,
736,
599,
749
],
[
602,
736,
655,
749
],
[
658,
736,
684,
749
],
[
687,
736,
722,
749
],
[
726,
736,
780,
749
],
[
784,
736,
814,
749
],
[
818,
736,
864,
749
],
[
117,
751,
175,
764
],
[
178,
751,
203,
764
],
[
206,
751,
243,
764
],
[
246,
751,
280,
764
],
[
283,
751,
295,
764
],
[
298,
751,
370,
764
],
[
373,
752,
386,
764
],
[
389,
752,
452,
764
],
[
455,
751,
555,
764
],
[
558,
751,
600,
764
],
[
603,
751,
628,
764
],
[
631,
751,
670,
764
],
[
672,
751,
757,
764
],
[
760,
751,
812,
764
],
[
814,
750,
895,
764
],
[
120,
765,
166,
779
],
[
169,
765,
227,
779
],
[
230,
766,
267,
779
],
[
270,
766,
334,
779
],
[
337,
766,
394,
780
],
[
397,
766,
411,
780
],
[
414,
766,
464,
780
],
[
467,
766,
506,
780
],
[
509,
766,
551,
780
],
[
554,
766,
596,
780
],
[
599,
766,
644,
779
],
[
647,
766,
671,
779
],
[
674,
766,
715,
779
],
[
719,
765,
742,
779
],
[
746,
765,
841,
779
],
[
844,
765,
901,
779
],
[
118,
780,
141,
793
],
[
144,
780,
196,
793
],
[
199,
780,
249,
793
],
[
251,
780,
277,
793
],
[
280,
780,
337,
793
],
[
340,
780,
355,
793
],
[
357,
780,
422,
793
],
[
424,
780,
438,
793
],
[
441,
780,
450,
793
],
[
452,
780,
487,
793
],
[
489,
780,
534,
793
],
[
536,
780,
603,
793
],
[
605,
780,
630,
793
],
[
632,
780,
641,
793
],
[
643,
780,
669,
793
],
[
671,
780,
725,
793
],
[
727,
780,
741,
793
],
[
744,
780,
766,
793
],
[
768,
780,
820,
793
],
[
822,
780,
887,
793
],
[
890,
780,
905,
793
],
[
117,
795,
130,
808
],
[
132,
795,
153,
808
],
[
156,
795,
201,
808
],
[
203,
795,
268,
808
],
[
271,
795,
310,
808
],
[
312,
795,
327,
808
],
[
330,
795,
352,
808
],
[
355,
795,
389,
808
],
[
391,
795,
465,
808
],
[
467,
795,
489,
808
],
[
492,
795,
508,
808
],
[
511,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
579,
808
],
[
582,
795,
612,
808
],
[
614,
795,
672,
808
],
[
676,
795,
745,
808
],
[
748,
795,
819,
808
],
[
821,
795,
844,
808
],
[
846,
795,
892,
808
],
[
117,
809,
137,
821
],
[
140,
809,
185,
821
],
[
188,
809,
249,
822
],
[
252,
809,
265,
822
],
[
268,
809,
325,
822
],
[
327,
809,
354,
822
],
[
357,
809,
446,
822
],
[
448,
809,
490,
822
],
[
493,
809,
519,
822
],
[
521,
809,
573,
822
],
[
575,
809,
611,
822
],
[
613,
809,
660,
822
],
[
662,
809,
694,
822
],
[
695,
809,
750,
822
],
[
752,
809,
812,
822
],
[
815,
809,
831,
821
],
[
832,
808,
867,
821
],
[
117,
824,
182,
836
],
[
185,
824,
210,
836
],
[
213,
824,
241,
836
],
[
244,
824,
277,
836
],
[
279,
824,
350,
836
],
[
352,
824,
384,
836
],
[
387,
824,
435,
836
],
[
438,
824,
494,
836
],
[
496,
824,
545,
836
],
[
547,
824,
578,
836
],
[
580,
824,
660,
836
],
[
662,
824,
720,
836
],
[
722,
824,
737,
836
],
[
739,
824,
795,
836
],
[
798,
823,
851,
836
],
[
853,
823,
878,
836
],
[
881,
823,
898,
836
],
[
120,
839,
163,
851
],
[
166,
839,
213,
851
],
[
216,
839,
261,
851
],
[
264,
839,
278,
851
],
[
281,
839,
301,
851
],
[
304,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
408,
852
],
[
411,
839,
503,
852
],
[
127,
851,
174,
865
],
[
177,
851,
214,
865
],
[
217,
851,
240,
865
],
[
242,
851,
287,
865
],
[
290,
851,
310,
865
],
[
313,
851,
385,
865
],
[
388,
851,
421,
865
],
[
424,
851,
501,
865
],
[
505,
851,
556,
865
],
[
560,
851,
582,
865
],
[
585,
851,
629,
865
],
[
632,
851,
697,
865
],
[
700,
851,
712,
865
],
[
715,
851,
724,
865
],
[
727,
851,
784,
865
],
[
788,
851,
801,
865
],
[
805,
851,
885,
865
],
[
118,
868,
164,
880
],
[
165,
868,
191,
880
],
[
193,
868,
274,
880
],
[
277,
868,
301,
880
],
[
304,
868,
367,
881
],
[
369,
868,
393,
881
],
[
397,
868,
480,
881
],
[
482,
868,
508,
881
],
[
510,
868,
585,
881
],
[
587,
868,
602,
880
],
[
604,
868,
678,
880
],
[
681,
868,
766,
880
],
[
768,
868,
810,
880
],
[
812,
868,
869,
880
],
[
871,
867,
894,
879
],
[
117,
882,
191,
895
],
[
194,
882,
254,
895
],
[
257,
882,
345,
895
],
[
30,
923,
202,
937
],
[
490,
925,
512,
937
],
[
515,
925,
559,
937
],
[
562,
925,
581,
937
],
[
584,
925,
602,
937
],
[
605,
925,
612,
937
],
[
615,
925,
691,
937
],
[
694,
925,
714,
937
],
[
717,
925,
757,
937
],
[
760,
925,
765,
937
],
[
768,
925,
801,
937
],
[
804,
924,
861,
937
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
290,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the full form ACC?
|
American Chemistry council
|
731
|
[
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"My",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"sole",
"proprietor",
"of",
"her",
"law",
"firm,",
"which",
"does",
"business",
"as",
"Martha",
"C.",
"Dourson,",
"LLC.",
"For",
"as",
"long",
"as",
"my",
"spouse",
"continues",
"to",
"have",
"her",
"law",
"practice,",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"that",
"to",
"my",
"knowledge",
"has",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"effect",
"on",
"the",
"financial",
"interests",
"of",
"the",
"firm,",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"obtain",
"a",
"written",
"waiver,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"18",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"208(b)(1).",
"I",
"also",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"a",
"client",
"of",
"my",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"receive",
"royalties",
"from",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"for",
"sales",
"of",
"my",
"three",
"books:",
"Messiah's",
"Star",
"(",
"Evidence",
"for",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"1);",
"The",
"Beginning:",
"Let",
"there",
"be",
"light",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"2);",
"and",
"\"The",
"Linen",
"Cloths:",
"...Jesus",
"left",
"behind",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"3).",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"If",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"managed",
"account",
"or",
"otherwise",
"use",
"the",
"services",
"of",
"an",
"investment",
"professional",
"during",
"my",
"appointment,",
"I",
"will",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"account",
"manager",
"or",
"investment",
"professional",
"obtains",
"my",
"prior",
"approval",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-case",
"basis",
"for",
"the",
"purchase",
"of",
"any",
"assets",
"other",
"than",
"cash,",
"cash",
"equivalents,",
"investment",
"funds",
"that",
"qualify",
"for",
"the",
"exemption",
"at",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2640.201(a),",
"obligations",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States,",
"or",
"municipal",
"bonds.",
"I",
"will",
"meet",
"in",
"person",
"with",
"you",
"during",
"the",
"first",
"week",
"of",
"my",
"service",
"in",
"the",
"position",
"of",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"complete",
"the",
"initial",
"ethics",
"briefing",
"required",
"under",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2638.305.",
"Within",
"90",
"days",
"of",
"my",
"confirmation,",
"I",
"will",
"document",
"my",
"compliance",
"with",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"by",
"notifying",
"you",
"in",
"writing",
"when",
"I",
"have",
"completed",
"the",
"steps",
"described",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"as",
"an",
"appointee",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge",
"(Exec.",
"Order",
"No.",
"13770)",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"bound",
"by",
"the",
"requirements",
"and",
"restrictions",
"therein",
"in",
"addition",
"to",
"the",
"commitments",
"I",
"have",
"made",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"that",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"will",
"be",
"posted",
"publicly,",
"consistent",
"with",
"5",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"552,",
"on",
"the",
"website",
"of",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"with",
"ethics",
"agreements",
"of",
"other",
"Presidential",
"nominees",
"who",
"file",
"public",
"financial",
"disclosure",
"reports.",
"Sincerely",
"yours,",
"Michael",
"L.",
"Dourson",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/llcn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
205,
111
],
[
209,
94,
279,
110
],
[
282,
93,
300,
109
],
[
304,
93,
315,
109
],
[
319,
93,
372,
108
],
[
376,
93,
386,
108
],
[
390,
93,
490,
109
],
[
178,
129,
205,
144
],
[
209,
129,
262,
144
],
[
265,
129,
281,
144
],
[
285,
129,
295,
144
],
[
299,
129,
331,
144
],
[
334,
129,
415,
144
],
[
418,
129,
436,
144
],
[
439,
129,
465,
144
],
[
469,
129,
497,
144
],
[
503,
129,
544,
144
],
[
548,
129,
597,
144
],
[
603,
129,
637,
144
],
[
640,
128,
710,
144
],
[
712,
128,
730,
143
],
[
732,
127,
792,
143
],
[
795,
127,
815,
143
],
[
117,
145,
191,
161
],
[
195,
146,
242,
161
],
[
247,
146,
275,
161
],
[
279,
146,
296,
161
],
[
300,
146,
336,
161
],
[
340,
146,
357,
161
],
[
361,
147,
387,
161
],
[
390,
147,
445,
161
],
[
448,
147,
525,
161
],
[
529,
147,
545,
161
],
[
548,
146,
586,
161
],
[
590,
146,
617,
161
],
[
621,
146,
648,
161
],
[
654,
146,
722,
160
],
[
726,
146,
735,
160
],
[
739,
145,
769,
160
],
[
772,
145,
802,
160
],
[
116,
164,
201,
179
],
[
204,
164,
288,
179
],
[
292,
164,
322,
179
],
[
325,
164,
425,
179
],
[
429,
164,
446,
179
],
[
450,
164,
478,
179
],
[
482,
164,
559,
179
],
[
562,
164,
614,
179
],
[
618,
164,
648,
179
],
[
652,
164,
668,
179
],
[
672,
164,
698,
179
],
[
702,
164,
789,
179
],
[
792,
164,
821,
179
],
[
825,
164,
838,
179
],
[
842,
163,
886,
179
],
[
118,
181,
147,
195
],
[
151,
181,
240,
195
],
[
243,
181,
289,
196
],
[
292,
181,
312,
196
],
[
316,
181,
342,
196
],
[
345,
181,
415,
196
],
[
418,
181,
487,
196
],
[
490,
182,
507,
196
],
[
511,
182,
536,
196
],
[
539,
182,
580,
196
],
[
583,
182,
634,
196
],
[
637,
182,
645,
196
],
[
648,
182,
682,
196
],
[
685,
182,
737,
196
],
[
740,
182,
750,
196
],
[
753,
182,
811,
196
],
[
814,
182,
876,
196
],
[
116,
198,
185,
214
],
[
189,
198,
207,
214
],
[
211,
198,
231,
214
],
[
235,
198,
290,
214
],
[
293,
198,
303,
214
],
[
307,
198,
394,
214
],
[
397,
198,
404,
214
],
[
408,
198,
442,
214
],
[
446,
198,
476,
214
],
[
480,
198,
505,
214
],
[
510,
198,
594,
214
],
[
597,
198,
681,
214
],
[
685,
198,
715,
214
],
[
718,
198,
818,
215
],
[
821,
199,
838,
215
],
[
841,
199,
871,
215
],
[
117,
216,
193,
231
],
[
197,
216,
248,
231
],
[
252,
216,
329,
231
],
[
332,
215,
394,
231
],
[
397,
215,
451,
232
],
[
455,
215,
473,
232
],
[
477,
215,
526,
232
],
[
530,
215,
536,
232
],
[
539,
215,
582,
232
],
[
590,
215,
600,
232
],
[
602,
215,
648,
232
],
[
651,
215,
668,
232
],
[
671,
215,
700,
231
],
[
702,
215,
757,
231
],
[
760,
216,
776,
231
],
[
779,
216,
788,
231
],
[
791,
216,
834,
231
],
[
837,
216,
853,
231
],
[
117,
234,
199,
248
],
[
202,
234,
211,
248
],
[
214,
234,
262,
248
],
[
265,
234,
317,
248
],
[
320,
234,
327,
248
],
[
331,
234,
351,
248
],
[
360,
234,
392,
248
],
[
396,
234,
480,
248
],
[
484,
234,
501,
248
],
[
504,
233,
592,
248
],
[
596,
233,
665,
248
],
[
669,
233,
686,
248
],
[
690,
233,
701,
248
],
[
704,
232,
759,
248
],
[
762,
232,
772,
248
],
[
775,
231,
875,
248
],
[
176,
268,
183,
283
],
[
187,
268,
245,
284
],
[
248,
268,
318,
284
],
[
322,
268,
357,
284
],
[
365,
268,
464,
284
],
[
467,
268,
566,
284
],
[
570,
268,
655,
284
],
[
659,
268,
724,
284
],
[
732,
268,
756,
284
],
[
760,
268,
799,
283
],
[
803,
268,
820,
283
],
[
824,
268,
849,
283
],
[
117,
285,
157,
300
],
[
161,
285,
220,
300
],
[
223,
285,
304,
300
],
[
307,
285,
340,
300
],
[
343,
285,
348,
300
],
[
351,
285,
422,
301
],
[
425,
285,
452,
301
],
[
455,
285,
505,
301
],
[
509,
286,
578,
301
],
[
581,
286,
605,
301
],
[
608,
286,
637,
301
],
[
640,
285,
730,
301
],
[
733,
285,
759,
300
],
[
762,
285,
804,
300
],
[
807,
285,
828,
300
],
[
831,
285,
867,
300
],
[
118,
302,
197,
318
],
[
201,
302,
218,
318
],
[
222,
302,
271,
319
],
[
275,
302,
342,
319
],
[
346,
302,
367,
319
],
[
371,
302,
396,
319
],
[
400,
302,
441,
319
],
[
445,
302,
491,
319
],
[
495,
302,
552,
319
],
[
556,
302,
614,
319
],
[
618,
302,
644,
318
],
[
648,
302,
703,
318
],
[
707,
302,
787,
318
],
[
790,
302,
807,
318
],
[
811,
302,
862,
318
],
[
119,
319,
185,
336
],
[
190,
319,
220,
336
],
[
224,
320,
231,
336
],
[
235,
320,
267,
336
],
[
271,
320,
296,
336
],
[
300,
320,
383,
336
],
[
387,
320,
471,
336
],
[
475,
320,
505,
336
],
[
510,
320,
608,
336
],
[
612,
320,
630,
336
],
[
633,
320,
662,
336
],
[
665,
320,
741,
336
],
[
745,
320,
797,
336
],
[
801,
320,
878,
336
],
[
118,
338,
178,
353
],
[
181,
338,
237,
353
],
[
240,
338,
258,
353
],
[
261,
338,
310,
353
],
[
313,
338,
321,
353
],
[
324,
337,
368,
353
],
[
374,
337,
474,
353
],
[
477,
337,
575,
353
],
[
578,
338,
664,
353
],
[
667,
338,
734,
353
],
[
740,
338,
757,
353
],
[
760,
338,
769,
353
],
[
772,
338,
815,
353
],
[
818,
339,
840,
353
],
[
117,
355,
199,
370
],
[
202,
355,
211,
370
],
[
214,
355,
261,
370
],
[
264,
355,
315,
370
],
[
318,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
352,
370
],
[
359,
355,
392,
370
],
[
396,
355,
479,
370
],
[
482,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
593,
370
],
[
597,
355,
665,
370
],
[
669,
355,
686,
370
],
[
690,
355,
701,
370
],
[
705,
354,
758,
370
],
[
762,
354,
772,
370
],
[
776,
353,
875,
370
],
[
177,
391,
191,
405
],
[
194,
391,
201,
405
],
[
204,
391,
245,
405
],
[
248,
391,
258,
405
],
[
261,
391,
334,
405
],
[
337,
391,
400,
405
],
[
403,
392,
422,
405
],
[
425,
392,
502,
405
],
[
506,
391,
532,
405
],
[
536,
391,
562,
405
],
[
566,
391,
631,
405
],
[
634,
391,
651,
405
],
[
655,
391,
675,
405
],
[
678,
390,
766,
405
],
[
769,
389,
870,
405
],
[
120,
407,
169,
423
],
[
172,
407,
200,
423
],
[
203,
407,
308,
422
],
[
311,
408,
320,
422
],
[
323,
408,
355,
422
],
[
359,
408,
411,
422
],
[
414,
408,
445,
422
],
[
449,
408,
474,
422
],
[
478,
408,
540,
422
],
[
544,
408,
613,
422
],
[
616,
408,
634,
422
],
[
637,
408,
725,
422
],
[
728,
408,
826,
421
],
[
120,
425,
174,
440
],
[
178,
425,
204,
440
],
[
208,
425,
248,
440
],
[
252,
425,
321,
440
],
[
325,
425,
347,
440
],
[
350,
425,
361,
440
],
[
364,
425,
464,
440
],
[
467,
425,
510,
440
],
[
513,
425,
537,
440
],
[
540,
425,
565,
440
],
[
569,
425,
641,
440
],
[
645,
425,
662,
440
],
[
665,
425,
696,
440
],
[
700,
425,
747,
440
],
[
750,
425,
791,
440
],
[
795,
425,
830,
440
],
[
834,
425,
876,
440
],
[
118,
442,
154,
457
],
[
157,
442,
252,
457
],
[
256,
442,
344,
458
],
[
347,
442,
392,
458
],
[
395,
442,
427,
458
],
[
431,
442,
487,
458
],
[
491,
442,
515,
458
],
[
519,
442,
544,
458
],
[
548,
441,
632,
458
],
[
635,
441,
652,
458
],
[
656,
441,
667,
458
],
[
671,
441,
724,
458
],
[
727,
441,
738,
457
],
[
742,
441,
843,
457
],
[
117,
460,
207,
474
],
[
210,
460,
228,
474
],
[
231,
460,
257,
474
],
[
260,
460,
315,
474
],
[
318,
460,
372,
474
],
[
375,
460,
392,
474
],
[
395,
460,
475,
475
],
[
478,
460,
533,
475
],
[
177,
495,
184,
509
],
[
187,
495,
220,
509
],
[
223,
495,
262,
510
],
[
266,
495,
282,
510
],
[
285,
495,
341,
510
],
[
344,
495,
380,
510
],
[
384,
495,
414,
510
],
[
419,
495,
470,
510
],
[
473,
495,
499,
510
],
[
502,
495,
537,
510
],
[
540,
495,
582,
510
],
[
585,
495,
602,
510
],
[
607,
495,
634,
510
],
[
637,
495,
694,
510
],
[
697,
495,
713,
510
],
[
717,
494,
742,
510
],
[
746,
494,
811,
509
],
[
814,
494,
835,
509
],
[
119,
511,
192,
526
],
[
195,
512,
305,
527
],
[
308,
512,
326,
527
],
[
330,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
392,
527
],
[
397,
512,
468,
527
],
[
472,
512,
498,
527
],
[
502,
512,
549,
527
],
[
552,
512,
598,
527
],
[
602,
512,
665,
527
],
[
669,
512,
736,
527
],
[
740,
512,
787,
527
],
[
790,
512,
802,
527
],
[
805,
511,
859,
527
],
[
862,
511,
870,
526
],
[
118,
528,
197,
545
],
[
201,
528,
257,
545
],
[
260,
529,
284,
545
],
[
288,
529,
321,
545
],
[
325,
529,
342,
545
],
[
345,
529,
372,
545
],
[
376,
529,
484,
545
],
[
488,
529,
497,
545
],
[
500,
529,
534,
545
],
[
537,
529,
614,
545
],
[
617,
529,
644,
545
],
[
648,
529,
740,
545
],
[
743,
529,
780,
545
],
[
783,
529,
812,
545
],
[
816,
529,
862,
544
],
[
117,
547,
200,
563
],
[
204,
547,
224,
563
],
[
228,
547,
302,
563
],
[
305,
547,
335,
563
],
[
339,
547,
357,
563
],
[
360,
547,
419,
563
],
[
422,
547,
466,
563
],
[
470,
547,
476,
563
],
[
480,
546,
520,
563
],
[
523,
546,
606,
563
],
[
610,
546,
635,
563
],
[
639,
546,
682,
563
],
[
685,
546,
758,
562
],
[
762,
546,
779,
562
],
[
782,
546,
813,
562
],
[
817,
546,
863,
562
],
[
119,
566,
205,
580
],
[
175,
600,
184,
613
],
[
187,
600,
274,
614
],
[
278,
600,
310,
614
],
[
313,
600,
331,
614
],
[
334,
600,
355,
614
],
[
358,
600,
435,
614
],
[
439,
600,
447,
614
],
[
451,
599,
481,
614
],
[
485,
599,
505,
614
],
[
508,
599,
576,
615
],
[
580,
599,
597,
615
],
[
600,
599,
633,
615
],
[
637,
599,
662,
615
],
[
666,
599,
716,
615
],
[
720,
598,
775,
615
],
[
779,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
881,
614
],
[
116,
616,
150,
631
],
[
153,
616,
208,
631
],
[
211,
616,
241,
631
],
[
244,
617,
276,
631
],
[
280,
617,
287,
631
],
[
291,
617,
321,
632
],
[
325,
617,
345,
632
],
[
350,
617,
399,
632
],
[
402,
617,
424,
632
],
[
428,
617,
452,
632
],
[
455,
618,
561,
632
],
[
564,
618,
594,
632
],
[
597,
618,
687,
632
],
[
690,
617,
745,
632
],
[
748,
617,
767,
631
],
[
770,
617,
835,
631
],
[
838,
617,
855,
631
],
[
858,
617,
887,
631
],
[
121,
634,
226,
649
],
[
230,
634,
236,
648
],
[
239,
634,
279,
648
],
[
282,
634,
327,
648
],
[
330,
634,
347,
648
],
[
351,
634,
380,
649
],
[
384,
634,
432,
649
],
[
435,
634,
526,
650
],
[
175,
668,
182,
684
],
[
186,
668,
225,
684
],
[
228,
669,
268,
684
],
[
271,
669,
332,
684
],
[
336,
669,
367,
684
],
[
370,
669,
401,
684
],
[
404,
669,
451,
684
],
[
455,
669,
539,
684
],
[
543,
669,
573,
684
],
[
577,
669,
595,
684
],
[
600,
669,
652,
684
],
[
656,
669,
727,
684
],
[
731,
668,
811,
684
],
[
815,
668,
851,
684
],
[
855,
668,
867,
683
],
[
118,
685,
172,
701
],
[
176,
685,
187,
701
],
[
191,
685,
225,
701
],
[
230,
685,
250,
701
],
[
254,
685,
279,
701
],
[
283,
685,
344,
701
],
[
347,
685,
364,
701
],
[
367,
685,
394,
701
],
[
398,
685,
433,
701
],
[
437,
685,
488,
701
],
[
492,
685,
510,
701
],
[
513,
685,
613,
701
],
[
616,
685,
668,
702
],
[
671,
685,
707,
702
],
[
710,
685,
758,
702
],
[
761,
686,
851,
702
],
[
855,
686,
875,
702
],
[
118,
704,
158,
719
],
[
162,
703,
255,
719
],
[
259,
703,
337,
719
],
[
341,
703,
375,
719
],
[
379,
703,
405,
719
],
[
409,
703,
461,
719
],
[
464,
703,
537,
719
],
[
540,
703,
619,
719
],
[
622,
703,
683,
719
],
[
472,
738,
547,
754
],
[
550,
739,
600,
754
],
[
471,
806,
535,
822
],
[
539,
807,
558,
821
],
[
562,
807,
633,
822
],
[
227,
981,
293,
997
],
[
297,
980,
775,
997
]
] |
By whom is this ethics agreement written?
|
Michael L. Dourson
|
731
|
[
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"My",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"sole",
"proprietor",
"of",
"her",
"law",
"firm,",
"which",
"does",
"business",
"as",
"Martha",
"C.",
"Dourson,",
"LLC.",
"For",
"as",
"long",
"as",
"my",
"spouse",
"continues",
"to",
"have",
"her",
"law",
"practice,",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"that",
"to",
"my",
"knowledge",
"has",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"effect",
"on",
"the",
"financial",
"interests",
"of",
"the",
"firm,",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"obtain",
"a",
"written",
"waiver,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"18",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"208(b)(1).",
"I",
"also",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"a",
"client",
"of",
"my",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"receive",
"royalties",
"from",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"for",
"sales",
"of",
"my",
"three",
"books:",
"Messiah's",
"Star",
"(",
"Evidence",
"for",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"1);",
"The",
"Beginning:",
"Let",
"there",
"be",
"light",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"2);",
"and",
"\"The",
"Linen",
"Cloths:",
"...Jesus",
"left",
"behind",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"3).",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"If",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"managed",
"account",
"or",
"otherwise",
"use",
"the",
"services",
"of",
"an",
"investment",
"professional",
"during",
"my",
"appointment,",
"I",
"will",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"account",
"manager",
"or",
"investment",
"professional",
"obtains",
"my",
"prior",
"approval",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-case",
"basis",
"for",
"the",
"purchase",
"of",
"any",
"assets",
"other",
"than",
"cash,",
"cash",
"equivalents,",
"investment",
"funds",
"that",
"qualify",
"for",
"the",
"exemption",
"at",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2640.201(a),",
"obligations",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States,",
"or",
"municipal",
"bonds.",
"I",
"will",
"meet",
"in",
"person",
"with",
"you",
"during",
"the",
"first",
"week",
"of",
"my",
"service",
"in",
"the",
"position",
"of",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"complete",
"the",
"initial",
"ethics",
"briefing",
"required",
"under",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2638.305.",
"Within",
"90",
"days",
"of",
"my",
"confirmation,",
"I",
"will",
"document",
"my",
"compliance",
"with",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"by",
"notifying",
"you",
"in",
"writing",
"when",
"I",
"have",
"completed",
"the",
"steps",
"described",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"as",
"an",
"appointee",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge",
"(Exec.",
"Order",
"No.",
"13770)",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"bound",
"by",
"the",
"requirements",
"and",
"restrictions",
"therein",
"in",
"addition",
"to",
"the",
"commitments",
"I",
"have",
"made",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"that",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"will",
"be",
"posted",
"publicly,",
"consistent",
"with",
"5",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"552,",
"on",
"the",
"website",
"of",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"with",
"ethics",
"agreements",
"of",
"other",
"Presidential",
"nominees",
"who",
"file",
"public",
"financial",
"disclosure",
"reports.",
"Sincerely",
"yours,",
"Michael",
"L.",
"Dourson",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/llcn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
205,
111
],
[
209,
94,
279,
110
],
[
282,
93,
300,
109
],
[
304,
93,
315,
109
],
[
319,
93,
372,
108
],
[
376,
93,
386,
108
],
[
390,
93,
490,
109
],
[
178,
129,
205,
144
],
[
209,
129,
262,
144
],
[
265,
129,
281,
144
],
[
285,
129,
295,
144
],
[
299,
129,
331,
144
],
[
334,
129,
415,
144
],
[
418,
129,
436,
144
],
[
439,
129,
465,
144
],
[
469,
129,
497,
144
],
[
503,
129,
544,
144
],
[
548,
129,
597,
144
],
[
603,
129,
637,
144
],
[
640,
128,
710,
144
],
[
712,
128,
730,
143
],
[
732,
127,
792,
143
],
[
795,
127,
815,
143
],
[
117,
145,
191,
161
],
[
195,
146,
242,
161
],
[
247,
146,
275,
161
],
[
279,
146,
296,
161
],
[
300,
146,
336,
161
],
[
340,
146,
357,
161
],
[
361,
147,
387,
161
],
[
390,
147,
445,
161
],
[
448,
147,
525,
161
],
[
529,
147,
545,
161
],
[
548,
146,
586,
161
],
[
590,
146,
617,
161
],
[
621,
146,
648,
161
],
[
654,
146,
722,
160
],
[
726,
146,
735,
160
],
[
739,
145,
769,
160
],
[
772,
145,
802,
160
],
[
116,
164,
201,
179
],
[
204,
164,
288,
179
],
[
292,
164,
322,
179
],
[
325,
164,
425,
179
],
[
429,
164,
446,
179
],
[
450,
164,
478,
179
],
[
482,
164,
559,
179
],
[
562,
164,
614,
179
],
[
618,
164,
648,
179
],
[
652,
164,
668,
179
],
[
672,
164,
698,
179
],
[
702,
164,
789,
179
],
[
792,
164,
821,
179
],
[
825,
164,
838,
179
],
[
842,
163,
886,
179
],
[
118,
181,
147,
195
],
[
151,
181,
240,
195
],
[
243,
181,
289,
196
],
[
292,
181,
312,
196
],
[
316,
181,
342,
196
],
[
345,
181,
415,
196
],
[
418,
181,
487,
196
],
[
490,
182,
507,
196
],
[
511,
182,
536,
196
],
[
539,
182,
580,
196
],
[
583,
182,
634,
196
],
[
637,
182,
645,
196
],
[
648,
182,
682,
196
],
[
685,
182,
737,
196
],
[
740,
182,
750,
196
],
[
753,
182,
811,
196
],
[
814,
182,
876,
196
],
[
116,
198,
185,
214
],
[
189,
198,
207,
214
],
[
211,
198,
231,
214
],
[
235,
198,
290,
214
],
[
293,
198,
303,
214
],
[
307,
198,
394,
214
],
[
397,
198,
404,
214
],
[
408,
198,
442,
214
],
[
446,
198,
476,
214
],
[
480,
198,
505,
214
],
[
510,
198,
594,
214
],
[
597,
198,
681,
214
],
[
685,
198,
715,
214
],
[
718,
198,
818,
215
],
[
821,
199,
838,
215
],
[
841,
199,
871,
215
],
[
117,
216,
193,
231
],
[
197,
216,
248,
231
],
[
252,
216,
329,
231
],
[
332,
215,
394,
231
],
[
397,
215,
451,
232
],
[
455,
215,
473,
232
],
[
477,
215,
526,
232
],
[
530,
215,
536,
232
],
[
539,
215,
582,
232
],
[
590,
215,
600,
232
],
[
602,
215,
648,
232
],
[
651,
215,
668,
232
],
[
671,
215,
700,
231
],
[
702,
215,
757,
231
],
[
760,
216,
776,
231
],
[
779,
216,
788,
231
],
[
791,
216,
834,
231
],
[
837,
216,
853,
231
],
[
117,
234,
199,
248
],
[
202,
234,
211,
248
],
[
214,
234,
262,
248
],
[
265,
234,
317,
248
],
[
320,
234,
327,
248
],
[
331,
234,
351,
248
],
[
360,
234,
392,
248
],
[
396,
234,
480,
248
],
[
484,
234,
501,
248
],
[
504,
233,
592,
248
],
[
596,
233,
665,
248
],
[
669,
233,
686,
248
],
[
690,
233,
701,
248
],
[
704,
232,
759,
248
],
[
762,
232,
772,
248
],
[
775,
231,
875,
248
],
[
176,
268,
183,
283
],
[
187,
268,
245,
284
],
[
248,
268,
318,
284
],
[
322,
268,
357,
284
],
[
365,
268,
464,
284
],
[
467,
268,
566,
284
],
[
570,
268,
655,
284
],
[
659,
268,
724,
284
],
[
732,
268,
756,
284
],
[
760,
268,
799,
283
],
[
803,
268,
820,
283
],
[
824,
268,
849,
283
],
[
117,
285,
157,
300
],
[
161,
285,
220,
300
],
[
223,
285,
304,
300
],
[
307,
285,
340,
300
],
[
343,
285,
348,
300
],
[
351,
285,
422,
301
],
[
425,
285,
452,
301
],
[
455,
285,
505,
301
],
[
509,
286,
578,
301
],
[
581,
286,
605,
301
],
[
608,
286,
637,
301
],
[
640,
285,
730,
301
],
[
733,
285,
759,
300
],
[
762,
285,
804,
300
],
[
807,
285,
828,
300
],
[
831,
285,
867,
300
],
[
118,
302,
197,
318
],
[
201,
302,
218,
318
],
[
222,
302,
271,
319
],
[
275,
302,
342,
319
],
[
346,
302,
367,
319
],
[
371,
302,
396,
319
],
[
400,
302,
441,
319
],
[
445,
302,
491,
319
],
[
495,
302,
552,
319
],
[
556,
302,
614,
319
],
[
618,
302,
644,
318
],
[
648,
302,
703,
318
],
[
707,
302,
787,
318
],
[
790,
302,
807,
318
],
[
811,
302,
862,
318
],
[
119,
319,
185,
336
],
[
190,
319,
220,
336
],
[
224,
320,
231,
336
],
[
235,
320,
267,
336
],
[
271,
320,
296,
336
],
[
300,
320,
383,
336
],
[
387,
320,
471,
336
],
[
475,
320,
505,
336
],
[
510,
320,
608,
336
],
[
612,
320,
630,
336
],
[
633,
320,
662,
336
],
[
665,
320,
741,
336
],
[
745,
320,
797,
336
],
[
801,
320,
878,
336
],
[
118,
338,
178,
353
],
[
181,
338,
237,
353
],
[
240,
338,
258,
353
],
[
261,
338,
310,
353
],
[
313,
338,
321,
353
],
[
324,
337,
368,
353
],
[
374,
337,
474,
353
],
[
477,
337,
575,
353
],
[
578,
338,
664,
353
],
[
667,
338,
734,
353
],
[
740,
338,
757,
353
],
[
760,
338,
769,
353
],
[
772,
338,
815,
353
],
[
818,
339,
840,
353
],
[
117,
355,
199,
370
],
[
202,
355,
211,
370
],
[
214,
355,
261,
370
],
[
264,
355,
315,
370
],
[
318,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
352,
370
],
[
359,
355,
392,
370
],
[
396,
355,
479,
370
],
[
482,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
593,
370
],
[
597,
355,
665,
370
],
[
669,
355,
686,
370
],
[
690,
355,
701,
370
],
[
705,
354,
758,
370
],
[
762,
354,
772,
370
],
[
776,
353,
875,
370
],
[
177,
391,
191,
405
],
[
194,
391,
201,
405
],
[
204,
391,
245,
405
],
[
248,
391,
258,
405
],
[
261,
391,
334,
405
],
[
337,
391,
400,
405
],
[
403,
392,
422,
405
],
[
425,
392,
502,
405
],
[
506,
391,
532,
405
],
[
536,
391,
562,
405
],
[
566,
391,
631,
405
],
[
634,
391,
651,
405
],
[
655,
391,
675,
405
],
[
678,
390,
766,
405
],
[
769,
389,
870,
405
],
[
120,
407,
169,
423
],
[
172,
407,
200,
423
],
[
203,
407,
308,
422
],
[
311,
408,
320,
422
],
[
323,
408,
355,
422
],
[
359,
408,
411,
422
],
[
414,
408,
445,
422
],
[
449,
408,
474,
422
],
[
478,
408,
540,
422
],
[
544,
408,
613,
422
],
[
616,
408,
634,
422
],
[
637,
408,
725,
422
],
[
728,
408,
826,
421
],
[
120,
425,
174,
440
],
[
178,
425,
204,
440
],
[
208,
425,
248,
440
],
[
252,
425,
321,
440
],
[
325,
425,
347,
440
],
[
350,
425,
361,
440
],
[
364,
425,
464,
440
],
[
467,
425,
510,
440
],
[
513,
425,
537,
440
],
[
540,
425,
565,
440
],
[
569,
425,
641,
440
],
[
645,
425,
662,
440
],
[
665,
425,
696,
440
],
[
700,
425,
747,
440
],
[
750,
425,
791,
440
],
[
795,
425,
830,
440
],
[
834,
425,
876,
440
],
[
118,
442,
154,
457
],
[
157,
442,
252,
457
],
[
256,
442,
344,
458
],
[
347,
442,
392,
458
],
[
395,
442,
427,
458
],
[
431,
442,
487,
458
],
[
491,
442,
515,
458
],
[
519,
442,
544,
458
],
[
548,
441,
632,
458
],
[
635,
441,
652,
458
],
[
656,
441,
667,
458
],
[
671,
441,
724,
458
],
[
727,
441,
738,
457
],
[
742,
441,
843,
457
],
[
117,
460,
207,
474
],
[
210,
460,
228,
474
],
[
231,
460,
257,
474
],
[
260,
460,
315,
474
],
[
318,
460,
372,
474
],
[
375,
460,
392,
474
],
[
395,
460,
475,
475
],
[
478,
460,
533,
475
],
[
177,
495,
184,
509
],
[
187,
495,
220,
509
],
[
223,
495,
262,
510
],
[
266,
495,
282,
510
],
[
285,
495,
341,
510
],
[
344,
495,
380,
510
],
[
384,
495,
414,
510
],
[
419,
495,
470,
510
],
[
473,
495,
499,
510
],
[
502,
495,
537,
510
],
[
540,
495,
582,
510
],
[
585,
495,
602,
510
],
[
607,
495,
634,
510
],
[
637,
495,
694,
510
],
[
697,
495,
713,
510
],
[
717,
494,
742,
510
],
[
746,
494,
811,
509
],
[
814,
494,
835,
509
],
[
119,
511,
192,
526
],
[
195,
512,
305,
527
],
[
308,
512,
326,
527
],
[
330,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
392,
527
],
[
397,
512,
468,
527
],
[
472,
512,
498,
527
],
[
502,
512,
549,
527
],
[
552,
512,
598,
527
],
[
602,
512,
665,
527
],
[
669,
512,
736,
527
],
[
740,
512,
787,
527
],
[
790,
512,
802,
527
],
[
805,
511,
859,
527
],
[
862,
511,
870,
526
],
[
118,
528,
197,
545
],
[
201,
528,
257,
545
],
[
260,
529,
284,
545
],
[
288,
529,
321,
545
],
[
325,
529,
342,
545
],
[
345,
529,
372,
545
],
[
376,
529,
484,
545
],
[
488,
529,
497,
545
],
[
500,
529,
534,
545
],
[
537,
529,
614,
545
],
[
617,
529,
644,
545
],
[
648,
529,
740,
545
],
[
743,
529,
780,
545
],
[
783,
529,
812,
545
],
[
816,
529,
862,
544
],
[
117,
547,
200,
563
],
[
204,
547,
224,
563
],
[
228,
547,
302,
563
],
[
305,
547,
335,
563
],
[
339,
547,
357,
563
],
[
360,
547,
419,
563
],
[
422,
547,
466,
563
],
[
470,
547,
476,
563
],
[
480,
546,
520,
563
],
[
523,
546,
606,
563
],
[
610,
546,
635,
563
],
[
639,
546,
682,
563
],
[
685,
546,
758,
562
],
[
762,
546,
779,
562
],
[
782,
546,
813,
562
],
[
817,
546,
863,
562
],
[
119,
566,
205,
580
],
[
175,
600,
184,
613
],
[
187,
600,
274,
614
],
[
278,
600,
310,
614
],
[
313,
600,
331,
614
],
[
334,
600,
355,
614
],
[
358,
600,
435,
614
],
[
439,
600,
447,
614
],
[
451,
599,
481,
614
],
[
485,
599,
505,
614
],
[
508,
599,
576,
615
],
[
580,
599,
597,
615
],
[
600,
599,
633,
615
],
[
637,
599,
662,
615
],
[
666,
599,
716,
615
],
[
720,
598,
775,
615
],
[
779,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
881,
614
],
[
116,
616,
150,
631
],
[
153,
616,
208,
631
],
[
211,
616,
241,
631
],
[
244,
617,
276,
631
],
[
280,
617,
287,
631
],
[
291,
617,
321,
632
],
[
325,
617,
345,
632
],
[
350,
617,
399,
632
],
[
402,
617,
424,
632
],
[
428,
617,
452,
632
],
[
455,
618,
561,
632
],
[
564,
618,
594,
632
],
[
597,
618,
687,
632
],
[
690,
617,
745,
632
],
[
748,
617,
767,
631
],
[
770,
617,
835,
631
],
[
838,
617,
855,
631
],
[
858,
617,
887,
631
],
[
121,
634,
226,
649
],
[
230,
634,
236,
648
],
[
239,
634,
279,
648
],
[
282,
634,
327,
648
],
[
330,
634,
347,
648
],
[
351,
634,
380,
649
],
[
384,
634,
432,
649
],
[
435,
634,
526,
650
],
[
175,
668,
182,
684
],
[
186,
668,
225,
684
],
[
228,
669,
268,
684
],
[
271,
669,
332,
684
],
[
336,
669,
367,
684
],
[
370,
669,
401,
684
],
[
404,
669,
451,
684
],
[
455,
669,
539,
684
],
[
543,
669,
573,
684
],
[
577,
669,
595,
684
],
[
600,
669,
652,
684
],
[
656,
669,
727,
684
],
[
731,
668,
811,
684
],
[
815,
668,
851,
684
],
[
855,
668,
867,
683
],
[
118,
685,
172,
701
],
[
176,
685,
187,
701
],
[
191,
685,
225,
701
],
[
230,
685,
250,
701
],
[
254,
685,
279,
701
],
[
283,
685,
344,
701
],
[
347,
685,
364,
701
],
[
367,
685,
394,
701
],
[
398,
685,
433,
701
],
[
437,
685,
488,
701
],
[
492,
685,
510,
701
],
[
513,
685,
613,
701
],
[
616,
685,
668,
702
],
[
671,
685,
707,
702
],
[
710,
685,
758,
702
],
[
761,
686,
851,
702
],
[
855,
686,
875,
702
],
[
118,
704,
158,
719
],
[
162,
703,
255,
719
],
[
259,
703,
337,
719
],
[
341,
703,
375,
719
],
[
379,
703,
405,
719
],
[
409,
703,
461,
719
],
[
464,
703,
537,
719
],
[
540,
703,
619,
719
],
[
622,
703,
683,
719
],
[
472,
738,
547,
754
],
[
550,
739,
600,
754
],
[
471,
806,
535,
822
],
[
539,
807,
558,
821
],
[
562,
807,
633,
822
],
[
227,
981,
293,
997
],
[
297,
980,
775,
997
]
] |
From which Publishing Platform did the author receive royalties for sales of his three books?
|
CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform
|
731
|
[
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"My",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"sole",
"proprietor",
"of",
"her",
"law",
"firm,",
"which",
"does",
"business",
"as",
"Martha",
"C.",
"Dourson,",
"LLC.",
"For",
"as",
"long",
"as",
"my",
"spouse",
"continues",
"to",
"have",
"her",
"law",
"practice,",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"that",
"to",
"my",
"knowledge",
"has",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"effect",
"on",
"the",
"financial",
"interests",
"of",
"the",
"firm,",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"obtain",
"a",
"written",
"waiver,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"18",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"208(b)(1).",
"I",
"also",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"a",
"client",
"of",
"my",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"receive",
"royalties",
"from",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"for",
"sales",
"of",
"my",
"three",
"books:",
"Messiah's",
"Star",
"(",
"Evidence",
"for",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"1);",
"The",
"Beginning:",
"Let",
"there",
"be",
"light",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"2);",
"and",
"\"The",
"Linen",
"Cloths:",
"...Jesus",
"left",
"behind",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"3).",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"If",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"managed",
"account",
"or",
"otherwise",
"use",
"the",
"services",
"of",
"an",
"investment",
"professional",
"during",
"my",
"appointment,",
"I",
"will",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"account",
"manager",
"or",
"investment",
"professional",
"obtains",
"my",
"prior",
"approval",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-case",
"basis",
"for",
"the",
"purchase",
"of",
"any",
"assets",
"other",
"than",
"cash,",
"cash",
"equivalents,",
"investment",
"funds",
"that",
"qualify",
"for",
"the",
"exemption",
"at",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2640.201(a),",
"obligations",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States,",
"or",
"municipal",
"bonds.",
"I",
"will",
"meet",
"in",
"person",
"with",
"you",
"during",
"the",
"first",
"week",
"of",
"my",
"service",
"in",
"the",
"position",
"of",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"complete",
"the",
"initial",
"ethics",
"briefing",
"required",
"under",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2638.305.",
"Within",
"90",
"days",
"of",
"my",
"confirmation,",
"I",
"will",
"document",
"my",
"compliance",
"with",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"by",
"notifying",
"you",
"in",
"writing",
"when",
"I",
"have",
"completed",
"the",
"steps",
"described",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"as",
"an",
"appointee",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge",
"(Exec.",
"Order",
"No.",
"13770)",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"bound",
"by",
"the",
"requirements",
"and",
"restrictions",
"therein",
"in",
"addition",
"to",
"the",
"commitments",
"I",
"have",
"made",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"that",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"will",
"be",
"posted",
"publicly,",
"consistent",
"with",
"5",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"552,",
"on",
"the",
"website",
"of",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"with",
"ethics",
"agreements",
"of",
"other",
"Presidential",
"nominees",
"who",
"file",
"public",
"financial",
"disclosure",
"reports.",
"Sincerely",
"yours,",
"Michael",
"L.",
"Dourson",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/llcn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
205,
111
],
[
209,
94,
279,
110
],
[
282,
93,
300,
109
],
[
304,
93,
315,
109
],
[
319,
93,
372,
108
],
[
376,
93,
386,
108
],
[
390,
93,
490,
109
],
[
178,
129,
205,
144
],
[
209,
129,
262,
144
],
[
265,
129,
281,
144
],
[
285,
129,
295,
144
],
[
299,
129,
331,
144
],
[
334,
129,
415,
144
],
[
418,
129,
436,
144
],
[
439,
129,
465,
144
],
[
469,
129,
497,
144
],
[
503,
129,
544,
144
],
[
548,
129,
597,
144
],
[
603,
129,
637,
144
],
[
640,
128,
710,
144
],
[
712,
128,
730,
143
],
[
732,
127,
792,
143
],
[
795,
127,
815,
143
],
[
117,
145,
191,
161
],
[
195,
146,
242,
161
],
[
247,
146,
275,
161
],
[
279,
146,
296,
161
],
[
300,
146,
336,
161
],
[
340,
146,
357,
161
],
[
361,
147,
387,
161
],
[
390,
147,
445,
161
],
[
448,
147,
525,
161
],
[
529,
147,
545,
161
],
[
548,
146,
586,
161
],
[
590,
146,
617,
161
],
[
621,
146,
648,
161
],
[
654,
146,
722,
160
],
[
726,
146,
735,
160
],
[
739,
145,
769,
160
],
[
772,
145,
802,
160
],
[
116,
164,
201,
179
],
[
204,
164,
288,
179
],
[
292,
164,
322,
179
],
[
325,
164,
425,
179
],
[
429,
164,
446,
179
],
[
450,
164,
478,
179
],
[
482,
164,
559,
179
],
[
562,
164,
614,
179
],
[
618,
164,
648,
179
],
[
652,
164,
668,
179
],
[
672,
164,
698,
179
],
[
702,
164,
789,
179
],
[
792,
164,
821,
179
],
[
825,
164,
838,
179
],
[
842,
163,
886,
179
],
[
118,
181,
147,
195
],
[
151,
181,
240,
195
],
[
243,
181,
289,
196
],
[
292,
181,
312,
196
],
[
316,
181,
342,
196
],
[
345,
181,
415,
196
],
[
418,
181,
487,
196
],
[
490,
182,
507,
196
],
[
511,
182,
536,
196
],
[
539,
182,
580,
196
],
[
583,
182,
634,
196
],
[
637,
182,
645,
196
],
[
648,
182,
682,
196
],
[
685,
182,
737,
196
],
[
740,
182,
750,
196
],
[
753,
182,
811,
196
],
[
814,
182,
876,
196
],
[
116,
198,
185,
214
],
[
189,
198,
207,
214
],
[
211,
198,
231,
214
],
[
235,
198,
290,
214
],
[
293,
198,
303,
214
],
[
307,
198,
394,
214
],
[
397,
198,
404,
214
],
[
408,
198,
442,
214
],
[
446,
198,
476,
214
],
[
480,
198,
505,
214
],
[
510,
198,
594,
214
],
[
597,
198,
681,
214
],
[
685,
198,
715,
214
],
[
718,
198,
818,
215
],
[
821,
199,
838,
215
],
[
841,
199,
871,
215
],
[
117,
216,
193,
231
],
[
197,
216,
248,
231
],
[
252,
216,
329,
231
],
[
332,
215,
394,
231
],
[
397,
215,
451,
232
],
[
455,
215,
473,
232
],
[
477,
215,
526,
232
],
[
530,
215,
536,
232
],
[
539,
215,
582,
232
],
[
590,
215,
600,
232
],
[
602,
215,
648,
232
],
[
651,
215,
668,
232
],
[
671,
215,
700,
231
],
[
702,
215,
757,
231
],
[
760,
216,
776,
231
],
[
779,
216,
788,
231
],
[
791,
216,
834,
231
],
[
837,
216,
853,
231
],
[
117,
234,
199,
248
],
[
202,
234,
211,
248
],
[
214,
234,
262,
248
],
[
265,
234,
317,
248
],
[
320,
234,
327,
248
],
[
331,
234,
351,
248
],
[
360,
234,
392,
248
],
[
396,
234,
480,
248
],
[
484,
234,
501,
248
],
[
504,
233,
592,
248
],
[
596,
233,
665,
248
],
[
669,
233,
686,
248
],
[
690,
233,
701,
248
],
[
704,
232,
759,
248
],
[
762,
232,
772,
248
],
[
775,
231,
875,
248
],
[
176,
268,
183,
283
],
[
187,
268,
245,
284
],
[
248,
268,
318,
284
],
[
322,
268,
357,
284
],
[
365,
268,
464,
284
],
[
467,
268,
566,
284
],
[
570,
268,
655,
284
],
[
659,
268,
724,
284
],
[
732,
268,
756,
284
],
[
760,
268,
799,
283
],
[
803,
268,
820,
283
],
[
824,
268,
849,
283
],
[
117,
285,
157,
300
],
[
161,
285,
220,
300
],
[
223,
285,
304,
300
],
[
307,
285,
340,
300
],
[
343,
285,
348,
300
],
[
351,
285,
422,
301
],
[
425,
285,
452,
301
],
[
455,
285,
505,
301
],
[
509,
286,
578,
301
],
[
581,
286,
605,
301
],
[
608,
286,
637,
301
],
[
640,
285,
730,
301
],
[
733,
285,
759,
300
],
[
762,
285,
804,
300
],
[
807,
285,
828,
300
],
[
831,
285,
867,
300
],
[
118,
302,
197,
318
],
[
201,
302,
218,
318
],
[
222,
302,
271,
319
],
[
275,
302,
342,
319
],
[
346,
302,
367,
319
],
[
371,
302,
396,
319
],
[
400,
302,
441,
319
],
[
445,
302,
491,
319
],
[
495,
302,
552,
319
],
[
556,
302,
614,
319
],
[
618,
302,
644,
318
],
[
648,
302,
703,
318
],
[
707,
302,
787,
318
],
[
790,
302,
807,
318
],
[
811,
302,
862,
318
],
[
119,
319,
185,
336
],
[
190,
319,
220,
336
],
[
224,
320,
231,
336
],
[
235,
320,
267,
336
],
[
271,
320,
296,
336
],
[
300,
320,
383,
336
],
[
387,
320,
471,
336
],
[
475,
320,
505,
336
],
[
510,
320,
608,
336
],
[
612,
320,
630,
336
],
[
633,
320,
662,
336
],
[
665,
320,
741,
336
],
[
745,
320,
797,
336
],
[
801,
320,
878,
336
],
[
118,
338,
178,
353
],
[
181,
338,
237,
353
],
[
240,
338,
258,
353
],
[
261,
338,
310,
353
],
[
313,
338,
321,
353
],
[
324,
337,
368,
353
],
[
374,
337,
474,
353
],
[
477,
337,
575,
353
],
[
578,
338,
664,
353
],
[
667,
338,
734,
353
],
[
740,
338,
757,
353
],
[
760,
338,
769,
353
],
[
772,
338,
815,
353
],
[
818,
339,
840,
353
],
[
117,
355,
199,
370
],
[
202,
355,
211,
370
],
[
214,
355,
261,
370
],
[
264,
355,
315,
370
],
[
318,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
352,
370
],
[
359,
355,
392,
370
],
[
396,
355,
479,
370
],
[
482,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
593,
370
],
[
597,
355,
665,
370
],
[
669,
355,
686,
370
],
[
690,
355,
701,
370
],
[
705,
354,
758,
370
],
[
762,
354,
772,
370
],
[
776,
353,
875,
370
],
[
177,
391,
191,
405
],
[
194,
391,
201,
405
],
[
204,
391,
245,
405
],
[
248,
391,
258,
405
],
[
261,
391,
334,
405
],
[
337,
391,
400,
405
],
[
403,
392,
422,
405
],
[
425,
392,
502,
405
],
[
506,
391,
532,
405
],
[
536,
391,
562,
405
],
[
566,
391,
631,
405
],
[
634,
391,
651,
405
],
[
655,
391,
675,
405
],
[
678,
390,
766,
405
],
[
769,
389,
870,
405
],
[
120,
407,
169,
423
],
[
172,
407,
200,
423
],
[
203,
407,
308,
422
],
[
311,
408,
320,
422
],
[
323,
408,
355,
422
],
[
359,
408,
411,
422
],
[
414,
408,
445,
422
],
[
449,
408,
474,
422
],
[
478,
408,
540,
422
],
[
544,
408,
613,
422
],
[
616,
408,
634,
422
],
[
637,
408,
725,
422
],
[
728,
408,
826,
421
],
[
120,
425,
174,
440
],
[
178,
425,
204,
440
],
[
208,
425,
248,
440
],
[
252,
425,
321,
440
],
[
325,
425,
347,
440
],
[
350,
425,
361,
440
],
[
364,
425,
464,
440
],
[
467,
425,
510,
440
],
[
513,
425,
537,
440
],
[
540,
425,
565,
440
],
[
569,
425,
641,
440
],
[
645,
425,
662,
440
],
[
665,
425,
696,
440
],
[
700,
425,
747,
440
],
[
750,
425,
791,
440
],
[
795,
425,
830,
440
],
[
834,
425,
876,
440
],
[
118,
442,
154,
457
],
[
157,
442,
252,
457
],
[
256,
442,
344,
458
],
[
347,
442,
392,
458
],
[
395,
442,
427,
458
],
[
431,
442,
487,
458
],
[
491,
442,
515,
458
],
[
519,
442,
544,
458
],
[
548,
441,
632,
458
],
[
635,
441,
652,
458
],
[
656,
441,
667,
458
],
[
671,
441,
724,
458
],
[
727,
441,
738,
457
],
[
742,
441,
843,
457
],
[
117,
460,
207,
474
],
[
210,
460,
228,
474
],
[
231,
460,
257,
474
],
[
260,
460,
315,
474
],
[
318,
460,
372,
474
],
[
375,
460,
392,
474
],
[
395,
460,
475,
475
],
[
478,
460,
533,
475
],
[
177,
495,
184,
509
],
[
187,
495,
220,
509
],
[
223,
495,
262,
510
],
[
266,
495,
282,
510
],
[
285,
495,
341,
510
],
[
344,
495,
380,
510
],
[
384,
495,
414,
510
],
[
419,
495,
470,
510
],
[
473,
495,
499,
510
],
[
502,
495,
537,
510
],
[
540,
495,
582,
510
],
[
585,
495,
602,
510
],
[
607,
495,
634,
510
],
[
637,
495,
694,
510
],
[
697,
495,
713,
510
],
[
717,
494,
742,
510
],
[
746,
494,
811,
509
],
[
814,
494,
835,
509
],
[
119,
511,
192,
526
],
[
195,
512,
305,
527
],
[
308,
512,
326,
527
],
[
330,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
392,
527
],
[
397,
512,
468,
527
],
[
472,
512,
498,
527
],
[
502,
512,
549,
527
],
[
552,
512,
598,
527
],
[
602,
512,
665,
527
],
[
669,
512,
736,
527
],
[
740,
512,
787,
527
],
[
790,
512,
802,
527
],
[
805,
511,
859,
527
],
[
862,
511,
870,
526
],
[
118,
528,
197,
545
],
[
201,
528,
257,
545
],
[
260,
529,
284,
545
],
[
288,
529,
321,
545
],
[
325,
529,
342,
545
],
[
345,
529,
372,
545
],
[
376,
529,
484,
545
],
[
488,
529,
497,
545
],
[
500,
529,
534,
545
],
[
537,
529,
614,
545
],
[
617,
529,
644,
545
],
[
648,
529,
740,
545
],
[
743,
529,
780,
545
],
[
783,
529,
812,
545
],
[
816,
529,
862,
544
],
[
117,
547,
200,
563
],
[
204,
547,
224,
563
],
[
228,
547,
302,
563
],
[
305,
547,
335,
563
],
[
339,
547,
357,
563
],
[
360,
547,
419,
563
],
[
422,
547,
466,
563
],
[
470,
547,
476,
563
],
[
480,
546,
520,
563
],
[
523,
546,
606,
563
],
[
610,
546,
635,
563
],
[
639,
546,
682,
563
],
[
685,
546,
758,
562
],
[
762,
546,
779,
562
],
[
782,
546,
813,
562
],
[
817,
546,
863,
562
],
[
119,
566,
205,
580
],
[
175,
600,
184,
613
],
[
187,
600,
274,
614
],
[
278,
600,
310,
614
],
[
313,
600,
331,
614
],
[
334,
600,
355,
614
],
[
358,
600,
435,
614
],
[
439,
600,
447,
614
],
[
451,
599,
481,
614
],
[
485,
599,
505,
614
],
[
508,
599,
576,
615
],
[
580,
599,
597,
615
],
[
600,
599,
633,
615
],
[
637,
599,
662,
615
],
[
666,
599,
716,
615
],
[
720,
598,
775,
615
],
[
779,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
881,
614
],
[
116,
616,
150,
631
],
[
153,
616,
208,
631
],
[
211,
616,
241,
631
],
[
244,
617,
276,
631
],
[
280,
617,
287,
631
],
[
291,
617,
321,
632
],
[
325,
617,
345,
632
],
[
350,
617,
399,
632
],
[
402,
617,
424,
632
],
[
428,
617,
452,
632
],
[
455,
618,
561,
632
],
[
564,
618,
594,
632
],
[
597,
618,
687,
632
],
[
690,
617,
745,
632
],
[
748,
617,
767,
631
],
[
770,
617,
835,
631
],
[
838,
617,
855,
631
],
[
858,
617,
887,
631
],
[
121,
634,
226,
649
],
[
230,
634,
236,
648
],
[
239,
634,
279,
648
],
[
282,
634,
327,
648
],
[
330,
634,
347,
648
],
[
351,
634,
380,
649
],
[
384,
634,
432,
649
],
[
435,
634,
526,
650
],
[
175,
668,
182,
684
],
[
186,
668,
225,
684
],
[
228,
669,
268,
684
],
[
271,
669,
332,
684
],
[
336,
669,
367,
684
],
[
370,
669,
401,
684
],
[
404,
669,
451,
684
],
[
455,
669,
539,
684
],
[
543,
669,
573,
684
],
[
577,
669,
595,
684
],
[
600,
669,
652,
684
],
[
656,
669,
727,
684
],
[
731,
668,
811,
684
],
[
815,
668,
851,
684
],
[
855,
668,
867,
683
],
[
118,
685,
172,
701
],
[
176,
685,
187,
701
],
[
191,
685,
225,
701
],
[
230,
685,
250,
701
],
[
254,
685,
279,
701
],
[
283,
685,
344,
701
],
[
347,
685,
364,
701
],
[
367,
685,
394,
701
],
[
398,
685,
433,
701
],
[
437,
685,
488,
701
],
[
492,
685,
510,
701
],
[
513,
685,
613,
701
],
[
616,
685,
668,
702
],
[
671,
685,
707,
702
],
[
710,
685,
758,
702
],
[
761,
686,
851,
702
],
[
855,
686,
875,
702
],
[
118,
704,
158,
719
],
[
162,
703,
255,
719
],
[
259,
703,
337,
719
],
[
341,
703,
375,
719
],
[
379,
703,
405,
719
],
[
409,
703,
461,
719
],
[
464,
703,
537,
719
],
[
540,
703,
619,
719
],
[
622,
703,
683,
719
],
[
472,
738,
547,
754
],
[
550,
739,
600,
754
],
[
471,
806,
535,
822
],
[
539,
807,
558,
821
],
[
562,
807,
633,
822
],
[
227,
981,
293,
997
],
[
297,
980,
775,
997
]
] |
The authors wife is a sole proprietor of which firm?
|
her law firm
|
731
|
[
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"My",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"sole",
"proprietor",
"of",
"her",
"law",
"firm,",
"which",
"does",
"business",
"as",
"Martha",
"C.",
"Dourson,",
"LLC.",
"For",
"as",
"long",
"as",
"my",
"spouse",
"continues",
"to",
"have",
"her",
"law",
"practice,",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"that",
"to",
"my",
"knowledge",
"has",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"effect",
"on",
"the",
"financial",
"interests",
"of",
"the",
"firm,",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"obtain",
"a",
"written",
"waiver,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"18",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"208(b)(1).",
"I",
"also",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"a",
"client",
"of",
"my",
"spouse",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"receive",
"royalties",
"from",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"for",
"sales",
"of",
"my",
"three",
"books:",
"Messiah's",
"Star",
"(",
"Evidence",
"for",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"1);",
"The",
"Beginning:",
"Let",
"there",
"be",
"light",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"2);",
"and",
"\"The",
"Linen",
"Cloths:",
"...Jesus",
"left",
"behind",
"(Evidence",
"of",
"Faith)",
"(Volume",
"3).",
"I",
"will",
"not",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"I",
"know",
"CreateSpace",
"Independent",
"Publishing",
"Platform",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party,",
"unless",
"I",
"am",
"first",
"authorized",
"to",
"participate,",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2635.502(d).",
"If",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"managed",
"account",
"or",
"otherwise",
"use",
"the",
"services",
"of",
"an",
"investment",
"professional",
"during",
"my",
"appointment,",
"I",
"will",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"account",
"manager",
"or",
"investment",
"professional",
"obtains",
"my",
"prior",
"approval",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-case",
"basis",
"for",
"the",
"purchase",
"of",
"any",
"assets",
"other",
"than",
"cash,",
"cash",
"equivalents,",
"investment",
"funds",
"that",
"qualify",
"for",
"the",
"exemption",
"at",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2640.201(a),",
"obligations",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States,",
"or",
"municipal",
"bonds.",
"I",
"will",
"meet",
"in",
"person",
"with",
"you",
"during",
"the",
"first",
"week",
"of",
"my",
"service",
"in",
"the",
"position",
"of",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"complete",
"the",
"initial",
"ethics",
"briefing",
"required",
"under",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"$",
"2638.305.",
"Within",
"90",
"days",
"of",
"my",
"confirmation,",
"I",
"will",
"document",
"my",
"compliance",
"with",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"by",
"notifying",
"you",
"in",
"writing",
"when",
"I",
"have",
"completed",
"the",
"steps",
"described",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"as",
"an",
"appointee",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge",
"(Exec.",
"Order",
"No.",
"13770)",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"will",
"be",
"bound",
"by",
"the",
"requirements",
"and",
"restrictions",
"therein",
"in",
"addition",
"to",
"the",
"commitments",
"I",
"have",
"made",
"in",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement.",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"that",
"this",
"ethics",
"agreement",
"will",
"be",
"posted",
"publicly,",
"consistent",
"with",
"5",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"552,",
"on",
"the",
"website",
"of",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"with",
"ethics",
"agreements",
"of",
"other",
"Presidential",
"nominees",
"who",
"file",
"public",
"financial",
"disclosure",
"reports.",
"Sincerely",
"yours,",
"Michael",
"L.",
"Dourson",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/llcn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
205,
111
],
[
209,
94,
279,
110
],
[
282,
93,
300,
109
],
[
304,
93,
315,
109
],
[
319,
93,
372,
108
],
[
376,
93,
386,
108
],
[
390,
93,
490,
109
],
[
178,
129,
205,
144
],
[
209,
129,
262,
144
],
[
265,
129,
281,
144
],
[
285,
129,
295,
144
],
[
299,
129,
331,
144
],
[
334,
129,
415,
144
],
[
418,
129,
436,
144
],
[
439,
129,
465,
144
],
[
469,
129,
497,
144
],
[
503,
129,
544,
144
],
[
548,
129,
597,
144
],
[
603,
129,
637,
144
],
[
640,
128,
710,
144
],
[
712,
128,
730,
143
],
[
732,
127,
792,
143
],
[
795,
127,
815,
143
],
[
117,
145,
191,
161
],
[
195,
146,
242,
161
],
[
247,
146,
275,
161
],
[
279,
146,
296,
161
],
[
300,
146,
336,
161
],
[
340,
146,
357,
161
],
[
361,
147,
387,
161
],
[
390,
147,
445,
161
],
[
448,
147,
525,
161
],
[
529,
147,
545,
161
],
[
548,
146,
586,
161
],
[
590,
146,
617,
161
],
[
621,
146,
648,
161
],
[
654,
146,
722,
160
],
[
726,
146,
735,
160
],
[
739,
145,
769,
160
],
[
772,
145,
802,
160
],
[
116,
164,
201,
179
],
[
204,
164,
288,
179
],
[
292,
164,
322,
179
],
[
325,
164,
425,
179
],
[
429,
164,
446,
179
],
[
450,
164,
478,
179
],
[
482,
164,
559,
179
],
[
562,
164,
614,
179
],
[
618,
164,
648,
179
],
[
652,
164,
668,
179
],
[
672,
164,
698,
179
],
[
702,
164,
789,
179
],
[
792,
164,
821,
179
],
[
825,
164,
838,
179
],
[
842,
163,
886,
179
],
[
118,
181,
147,
195
],
[
151,
181,
240,
195
],
[
243,
181,
289,
196
],
[
292,
181,
312,
196
],
[
316,
181,
342,
196
],
[
345,
181,
415,
196
],
[
418,
181,
487,
196
],
[
490,
182,
507,
196
],
[
511,
182,
536,
196
],
[
539,
182,
580,
196
],
[
583,
182,
634,
196
],
[
637,
182,
645,
196
],
[
648,
182,
682,
196
],
[
685,
182,
737,
196
],
[
740,
182,
750,
196
],
[
753,
182,
811,
196
],
[
814,
182,
876,
196
],
[
116,
198,
185,
214
],
[
189,
198,
207,
214
],
[
211,
198,
231,
214
],
[
235,
198,
290,
214
],
[
293,
198,
303,
214
],
[
307,
198,
394,
214
],
[
397,
198,
404,
214
],
[
408,
198,
442,
214
],
[
446,
198,
476,
214
],
[
480,
198,
505,
214
],
[
510,
198,
594,
214
],
[
597,
198,
681,
214
],
[
685,
198,
715,
214
],
[
718,
198,
818,
215
],
[
821,
199,
838,
215
],
[
841,
199,
871,
215
],
[
117,
216,
193,
231
],
[
197,
216,
248,
231
],
[
252,
216,
329,
231
],
[
332,
215,
394,
231
],
[
397,
215,
451,
232
],
[
455,
215,
473,
232
],
[
477,
215,
526,
232
],
[
530,
215,
536,
232
],
[
539,
215,
582,
232
],
[
590,
215,
600,
232
],
[
602,
215,
648,
232
],
[
651,
215,
668,
232
],
[
671,
215,
700,
231
],
[
702,
215,
757,
231
],
[
760,
216,
776,
231
],
[
779,
216,
788,
231
],
[
791,
216,
834,
231
],
[
837,
216,
853,
231
],
[
117,
234,
199,
248
],
[
202,
234,
211,
248
],
[
214,
234,
262,
248
],
[
265,
234,
317,
248
],
[
320,
234,
327,
248
],
[
331,
234,
351,
248
],
[
360,
234,
392,
248
],
[
396,
234,
480,
248
],
[
484,
234,
501,
248
],
[
504,
233,
592,
248
],
[
596,
233,
665,
248
],
[
669,
233,
686,
248
],
[
690,
233,
701,
248
],
[
704,
232,
759,
248
],
[
762,
232,
772,
248
],
[
775,
231,
875,
248
],
[
176,
268,
183,
283
],
[
187,
268,
245,
284
],
[
248,
268,
318,
284
],
[
322,
268,
357,
284
],
[
365,
268,
464,
284
],
[
467,
268,
566,
284
],
[
570,
268,
655,
284
],
[
659,
268,
724,
284
],
[
732,
268,
756,
284
],
[
760,
268,
799,
283
],
[
803,
268,
820,
283
],
[
824,
268,
849,
283
],
[
117,
285,
157,
300
],
[
161,
285,
220,
300
],
[
223,
285,
304,
300
],
[
307,
285,
340,
300
],
[
343,
285,
348,
300
],
[
351,
285,
422,
301
],
[
425,
285,
452,
301
],
[
455,
285,
505,
301
],
[
509,
286,
578,
301
],
[
581,
286,
605,
301
],
[
608,
286,
637,
301
],
[
640,
285,
730,
301
],
[
733,
285,
759,
300
],
[
762,
285,
804,
300
],
[
807,
285,
828,
300
],
[
831,
285,
867,
300
],
[
118,
302,
197,
318
],
[
201,
302,
218,
318
],
[
222,
302,
271,
319
],
[
275,
302,
342,
319
],
[
346,
302,
367,
319
],
[
371,
302,
396,
319
],
[
400,
302,
441,
319
],
[
445,
302,
491,
319
],
[
495,
302,
552,
319
],
[
556,
302,
614,
319
],
[
618,
302,
644,
318
],
[
648,
302,
703,
318
],
[
707,
302,
787,
318
],
[
790,
302,
807,
318
],
[
811,
302,
862,
318
],
[
119,
319,
185,
336
],
[
190,
319,
220,
336
],
[
224,
320,
231,
336
],
[
235,
320,
267,
336
],
[
271,
320,
296,
336
],
[
300,
320,
383,
336
],
[
387,
320,
471,
336
],
[
475,
320,
505,
336
],
[
510,
320,
608,
336
],
[
612,
320,
630,
336
],
[
633,
320,
662,
336
],
[
665,
320,
741,
336
],
[
745,
320,
797,
336
],
[
801,
320,
878,
336
],
[
118,
338,
178,
353
],
[
181,
338,
237,
353
],
[
240,
338,
258,
353
],
[
261,
338,
310,
353
],
[
313,
338,
321,
353
],
[
324,
337,
368,
353
],
[
374,
337,
474,
353
],
[
477,
337,
575,
353
],
[
578,
338,
664,
353
],
[
667,
338,
734,
353
],
[
740,
338,
757,
353
],
[
760,
338,
769,
353
],
[
772,
338,
815,
353
],
[
818,
339,
840,
353
],
[
117,
355,
199,
370
],
[
202,
355,
211,
370
],
[
214,
355,
261,
370
],
[
264,
355,
315,
370
],
[
318,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
352,
370
],
[
359,
355,
392,
370
],
[
396,
355,
479,
370
],
[
482,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
593,
370
],
[
597,
355,
665,
370
],
[
669,
355,
686,
370
],
[
690,
355,
701,
370
],
[
705,
354,
758,
370
],
[
762,
354,
772,
370
],
[
776,
353,
875,
370
],
[
177,
391,
191,
405
],
[
194,
391,
201,
405
],
[
204,
391,
245,
405
],
[
248,
391,
258,
405
],
[
261,
391,
334,
405
],
[
337,
391,
400,
405
],
[
403,
392,
422,
405
],
[
425,
392,
502,
405
],
[
506,
391,
532,
405
],
[
536,
391,
562,
405
],
[
566,
391,
631,
405
],
[
634,
391,
651,
405
],
[
655,
391,
675,
405
],
[
678,
390,
766,
405
],
[
769,
389,
870,
405
],
[
120,
407,
169,
423
],
[
172,
407,
200,
423
],
[
203,
407,
308,
422
],
[
311,
408,
320,
422
],
[
323,
408,
355,
422
],
[
359,
408,
411,
422
],
[
414,
408,
445,
422
],
[
449,
408,
474,
422
],
[
478,
408,
540,
422
],
[
544,
408,
613,
422
],
[
616,
408,
634,
422
],
[
637,
408,
725,
422
],
[
728,
408,
826,
421
],
[
120,
425,
174,
440
],
[
178,
425,
204,
440
],
[
208,
425,
248,
440
],
[
252,
425,
321,
440
],
[
325,
425,
347,
440
],
[
350,
425,
361,
440
],
[
364,
425,
464,
440
],
[
467,
425,
510,
440
],
[
513,
425,
537,
440
],
[
540,
425,
565,
440
],
[
569,
425,
641,
440
],
[
645,
425,
662,
440
],
[
665,
425,
696,
440
],
[
700,
425,
747,
440
],
[
750,
425,
791,
440
],
[
795,
425,
830,
440
],
[
834,
425,
876,
440
],
[
118,
442,
154,
457
],
[
157,
442,
252,
457
],
[
256,
442,
344,
458
],
[
347,
442,
392,
458
],
[
395,
442,
427,
458
],
[
431,
442,
487,
458
],
[
491,
442,
515,
458
],
[
519,
442,
544,
458
],
[
548,
441,
632,
458
],
[
635,
441,
652,
458
],
[
656,
441,
667,
458
],
[
671,
441,
724,
458
],
[
727,
441,
738,
457
],
[
742,
441,
843,
457
],
[
117,
460,
207,
474
],
[
210,
460,
228,
474
],
[
231,
460,
257,
474
],
[
260,
460,
315,
474
],
[
318,
460,
372,
474
],
[
375,
460,
392,
474
],
[
395,
460,
475,
475
],
[
478,
460,
533,
475
],
[
177,
495,
184,
509
],
[
187,
495,
220,
509
],
[
223,
495,
262,
510
],
[
266,
495,
282,
510
],
[
285,
495,
341,
510
],
[
344,
495,
380,
510
],
[
384,
495,
414,
510
],
[
419,
495,
470,
510
],
[
473,
495,
499,
510
],
[
502,
495,
537,
510
],
[
540,
495,
582,
510
],
[
585,
495,
602,
510
],
[
607,
495,
634,
510
],
[
637,
495,
694,
510
],
[
697,
495,
713,
510
],
[
717,
494,
742,
510
],
[
746,
494,
811,
509
],
[
814,
494,
835,
509
],
[
119,
511,
192,
526
],
[
195,
512,
305,
527
],
[
308,
512,
326,
527
],
[
330,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
392,
527
],
[
397,
512,
468,
527
],
[
472,
512,
498,
527
],
[
502,
512,
549,
527
],
[
552,
512,
598,
527
],
[
602,
512,
665,
527
],
[
669,
512,
736,
527
],
[
740,
512,
787,
527
],
[
790,
512,
802,
527
],
[
805,
511,
859,
527
],
[
862,
511,
870,
526
],
[
118,
528,
197,
545
],
[
201,
528,
257,
545
],
[
260,
529,
284,
545
],
[
288,
529,
321,
545
],
[
325,
529,
342,
545
],
[
345,
529,
372,
545
],
[
376,
529,
484,
545
],
[
488,
529,
497,
545
],
[
500,
529,
534,
545
],
[
537,
529,
614,
545
],
[
617,
529,
644,
545
],
[
648,
529,
740,
545
],
[
743,
529,
780,
545
],
[
783,
529,
812,
545
],
[
816,
529,
862,
544
],
[
117,
547,
200,
563
],
[
204,
547,
224,
563
],
[
228,
547,
302,
563
],
[
305,
547,
335,
563
],
[
339,
547,
357,
563
],
[
360,
547,
419,
563
],
[
422,
547,
466,
563
],
[
470,
547,
476,
563
],
[
480,
546,
520,
563
],
[
523,
546,
606,
563
],
[
610,
546,
635,
563
],
[
639,
546,
682,
563
],
[
685,
546,
758,
562
],
[
762,
546,
779,
562
],
[
782,
546,
813,
562
],
[
817,
546,
863,
562
],
[
119,
566,
205,
580
],
[
175,
600,
184,
613
],
[
187,
600,
274,
614
],
[
278,
600,
310,
614
],
[
313,
600,
331,
614
],
[
334,
600,
355,
614
],
[
358,
600,
435,
614
],
[
439,
600,
447,
614
],
[
451,
599,
481,
614
],
[
485,
599,
505,
614
],
[
508,
599,
576,
615
],
[
580,
599,
597,
615
],
[
600,
599,
633,
615
],
[
637,
599,
662,
615
],
[
666,
599,
716,
615
],
[
720,
598,
775,
615
],
[
779,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
881,
614
],
[
116,
616,
150,
631
],
[
153,
616,
208,
631
],
[
211,
616,
241,
631
],
[
244,
617,
276,
631
],
[
280,
617,
287,
631
],
[
291,
617,
321,
632
],
[
325,
617,
345,
632
],
[
350,
617,
399,
632
],
[
402,
617,
424,
632
],
[
428,
617,
452,
632
],
[
455,
618,
561,
632
],
[
564,
618,
594,
632
],
[
597,
618,
687,
632
],
[
690,
617,
745,
632
],
[
748,
617,
767,
631
],
[
770,
617,
835,
631
],
[
838,
617,
855,
631
],
[
858,
617,
887,
631
],
[
121,
634,
226,
649
],
[
230,
634,
236,
648
],
[
239,
634,
279,
648
],
[
282,
634,
327,
648
],
[
330,
634,
347,
648
],
[
351,
634,
380,
649
],
[
384,
634,
432,
649
],
[
435,
634,
526,
650
],
[
175,
668,
182,
684
],
[
186,
668,
225,
684
],
[
228,
669,
268,
684
],
[
271,
669,
332,
684
],
[
336,
669,
367,
684
],
[
370,
669,
401,
684
],
[
404,
669,
451,
684
],
[
455,
669,
539,
684
],
[
543,
669,
573,
684
],
[
577,
669,
595,
684
],
[
600,
669,
652,
684
],
[
656,
669,
727,
684
],
[
731,
668,
811,
684
],
[
815,
668,
851,
684
],
[
855,
668,
867,
683
],
[
118,
685,
172,
701
],
[
176,
685,
187,
701
],
[
191,
685,
225,
701
],
[
230,
685,
250,
701
],
[
254,
685,
279,
701
],
[
283,
685,
344,
701
],
[
347,
685,
364,
701
],
[
367,
685,
394,
701
],
[
398,
685,
433,
701
],
[
437,
685,
488,
701
],
[
492,
685,
510,
701
],
[
513,
685,
613,
701
],
[
616,
685,
668,
702
],
[
671,
685,
707,
702
],
[
710,
685,
758,
702
],
[
761,
686,
851,
702
],
[
855,
686,
875,
702
],
[
118,
704,
158,
719
],
[
162,
703,
255,
719
],
[
259,
703,
337,
719
],
[
341,
703,
375,
719
],
[
379,
703,
405,
719
],
[
409,
703,
461,
719
],
[
464,
703,
537,
719
],
[
540,
703,
619,
719
],
[
622,
703,
683,
719
],
[
472,
738,
547,
754
],
[
550,
739,
600,
754
],
[
471,
806,
535,
822
],
[
539,
807,
558,
821
],
[
562,
807,
633,
822
],
[
227,
981,
293,
997
],
[
297,
980,
775,
997
]
] |
Name the first book written by the author among the three?
|
Messiah's Star (Evidence for Faith) (Volume 1)
|
723
|
[
"variability,",
"uncertainty,",
"the",
"degree",
"of",
"independent",
"verification",
"and",
"peer",
"review.",
"In",
"proposing",
"this",
"definition,",
"ACC",
"has",
"drawn",
"language",
"directly",
"from",
"the",
"1996",
"SDWA",
"amendments\"and",
"from",
"section",
"26(h)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"EPA",
"has",
"already",
"adopted",
"the",
"language",
"from",
"the",
"SDWA",
"amendments",
"in",
"the",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"concept",
"of",
"evaluating",
"data",
"based",
"on",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"definition",
"provided",
"in",
"the",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record",
"for",
"LCSA.\"",
"To",
"ensure",
"a",
"greater",
"level",
"transparency",
"that",
"forces",
"EPA",
"to",
"\"show",
"its",
"work,\"",
"as",
"was",
"envisioned",
"by",
"the",
"authors",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA,\"",
"this",
"definition",
"covers",
"not",
"only",
"what",
"EPA",
"must",
"consider",
"and",
"evaluate,",
"but",
"also",
"requires",
"that",
"important",
"descriptions",
"and",
"documentation",
"be",
"including",
"in",
"EPA",
"work",
"products",
"developed",
"under",
"Sections",
"4-6",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"ii.",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"Evidence",
"(WoE).",
"ACC",
"suggests",
"the",
"following",
"definition:",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"evidence",
"means",
"a",
"systematic",
"review",
"method",
"that",
"uses",
"a",
"pre-",
"established",
"protocol",
"to",
"comprehensively,",
"objectively,",
"transparently,",
"and",
"consistently,",
"identify",
"and",
"evaluate",
"each",
"stream",
"of",
"evidence,",
"including",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"each",
"study",
"and",
"to",
"integrate",
"evidence",
"as",
"necessary",
"and",
"appropriate",
"based",
"upon",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance.",
"ACC",
"agrees",
"that",
"the",
"term",
"WoE",
"has",
"meant",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"groups.",
"In",
"fact,",
"different",
"NAS",
"studies",
"contradict",
"themselves",
"regarding",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"this",
"term",
"and",
"inconsistently",
"define",
"its",
"meaning.",
"As",
"such,",
"it",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"EPA",
"clearly",
"explain",
"what",
"this",
"term",
"means",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"This",
"term",
"cannot",
"and",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"avoided",
"or",
"discounted",
"as",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"codifies",
"the",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"use",
"a",
"WoE",
"approach.",
"As",
"such,",
"a",
"clear",
"and",
"transparent",
"definition",
"is",
"critical",
"ACC",
"is",
"recommending",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"definition",
"that",
"is",
"in",
"the",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record.",
"This",
"is",
"the",
"definition",
"we",
"have",
"provided",
"above.",
"This",
"definition",
"is",
"also",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"June",
"2015",
"House",
"Report",
"Language.\"",
"While",
"other",
"definitions",
"exist,",
"using",
"the",
"definition",
"associated",
"with",
"LCSA",
"makes",
"the",
"most",
"sense",
"and",
"is",
"a",
"straightforward",
"approach",
"that",
"is",
"clearly",
"linked",
"to",
"the",
"intent",
"of",
"Congress.",
"Without",
"a",
"clear",
"definition,",
"WoE",
"will",
"continue",
"to",
"mean",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"experts",
"and",
"stakeholders.",
"An",
"example",
"illustrates",
"that",
"EPA",
"very",
"recently",
"has",
"not",
"interpreted",
"WoE",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"way",
"Congress",
"now",
"intends.",
"In",
"the",
"draft",
"risk",
"assessment",
"of",
"1-bromopropane",
"(released",
"prior",
"to",
"enactment",
"of",
"LCSA),",
"EPA",
"does",
"not",
"provide",
"information",
"regarding",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"the",
"individual",
"29",
"Id.",
"30",
"See",
"generally,",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"at",
"$3518.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"$3522.",
"33",
"Id",
"at",
"$3518.",
"34",
"See",
"House",
"Report,",
"at",
"33,",
"available",
"at",
"https://www.congress.gov/Ll4/crot/hump:176/CRPT.114hmt176.pdf.",
"15/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
207,
94,
297,
110
],
[
300,
93,
400,
110
],
[
404,
93,
432,
110
],
[
440,
93,
494,
110
],
[
498,
93,
521,
110
],
[
524,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
94,
724,
109
],
[
730,
94,
763,
109
],
[
768,
94,
804,
109
],
[
206,
112,
267,
125
],
[
117,
146,
134,
162
],
[
137,
146,
218,
162
],
[
222,
146,
254,
161
],
[
258,
146,
339,
161
],
[
342,
146,
382,
161
],
[
385,
146,
417,
161
],
[
421,
146,
467,
161
],
[
470,
145,
547,
161
],
[
551,
145,
609,
160
],
[
612,
145,
648,
160
],
[
654,
145,
682,
160
],
[
685,
145,
726,
160
],
[
730,
145,
787,
160
],
[
117,
163,
264,
179
],
[
267,
163,
304,
179
],
[
311,
163,
368,
179
],
[
371,
163,
415,
179
],
[
419,
163,
436,
179
],
[
439,
163,
465,
179
],
[
469,
163,
525,
179
],
[
529,
163,
567,
179
],
[
570,
163,
598,
179
],
[
602,
163,
661,
179
],
[
665,
163,
728,
179
],
[
732,
163,
757,
179
],
[
760,
163,
833,
179
],
[
837,
164,
872,
179
],
[
117,
180,
144,
195
],
[
147,
180,
204,
195
],
[
209,
180,
308,
196
],
[
312,
181,
329,
196
],
[
332,
181,
359,
196
],
[
362,
181,
399,
196
],
[
404,
181,
500,
196
],
[
504,
181,
564,
196
],
[
568,
181,
665,
196
],
[
681,
181,
698,
196
],
[
701,
180,
772,
196
],
[
775,
180,
801,
196
],
[
804,
180,
870,
196
],
[
117,
198,
134,
214
],
[
138,
198,
224,
214
],
[
227,
198,
258,
214
],
[
261,
198,
309,
214
],
[
312,
198,
334,
214
],
[
337,
198,
410,
213
],
[
412,
198,
441,
213
],
[
444,
198,
530,
213
],
[
533,
198,
550,
213
],
[
552,
198,
634,
213
],
[
637,
198,
672,
213
],
[
675,
198,
704,
214
],
[
707,
198,
782,
214
],
[
785,
197,
856,
214
],
[
859,
197,
878,
214
],
[
118,
215,
142,
231
],
[
146,
215,
199,
231
],
[
203,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
378,
231
],
[
381,
215,
406,
231
],
[
410,
215,
480,
231
],
[
490,
215,
512,
231
],
[
515,
215,
568,
231
],
[
571,
215,
582,
231
],
[
585,
215,
640,
231
],
[
644,
215,
684,
231
],
[
687,
215,
788,
231
],
[
791,
215,
823,
231
],
[
826,
216,
881,
231
],
[
117,
232,
155,
247
],
[
159,
233,
177,
248
],
[
180,
233,
228,
248
],
[
234,
233,
255,
248
],
[
258,
233,
313,
248
],
[
317,
233,
335,
248
],
[
338,
233,
370,
248
],
[
374,
233,
459,
248
],
[
462,
233,
484,
248
],
[
488,
233,
514,
248
],
[
517,
233,
577,
248
],
[
580,
233,
597,
248
],
[
601,
233,
626,
248
],
[
630,
233,
698,
248
],
[
703,
232,
737,
248
],
[
740,
232,
815,
248
],
[
819,
232,
873,
248
],
[
116,
250,
144,
265
],
[
147,
250,
184,
265
],
[
187,
250,
227,
265
],
[
230,
250,
268,
265
],
[
271,
250,
312,
265
],
[
315,
250,
383,
265
],
[
387,
250,
415,
265
],
[
420,
250,
491,
265
],
[
494,
250,
521,
265
],
[
525,
250,
558,
265
],
[
562,
250,
625,
265
],
[
629,
250,
660,
266
],
[
664,
250,
745,
266
],
[
750,
250,
843,
266
],
[
846,
250,
878,
266
],
[
120,
268,
234,
283
],
[
238,
268,
258,
283
],
[
262,
268,
337,
284
],
[
340,
268,
358,
284
],
[
362,
268,
399,
284
],
[
403,
267,
444,
284
],
[
448,
267,
522,
284
],
[
525,
267,
604,
284
],
[
607,
267,
655,
284
],
[
657,
267,
727,
284
],
[
729,
266,
757,
284
],
[
760,
266,
780,
284
],
[
782,
266,
837,
284
],
[
147,
300,
164,
315
],
[
206,
301,
265,
317
],
[
269,
303,
286,
317
],
[
290,
303,
315,
318
],
[
319,
302,
394,
318
],
[
397,
301,
455,
318
],
[
120,
337,
158,
352
],
[
162,
337,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
264,
338,
344,
353
],
[
347,
338,
428,
353
],
[
179,
371,
237,
387
],
[
241,
372,
260,
387
],
[
264,
372,
294,
387
],
[
297,
372,
370,
388
],
[
374,
373,
431,
388
],
[
434,
373,
447,
388
],
[
450,
374,
538,
388
],
[
542,
374,
596,
388
],
[
604,
373,
668,
388
],
[
672,
373,
708,
388
],
[
711,
373,
751,
387
],
[
754,
372,
767,
387
],
[
770,
372,
804,
387
],
[
177,
390,
266,
405
],
[
277,
391,
350,
405
],
[
359,
391,
378,
405
],
[
390,
391,
536,
406
],
[
544,
391,
644,
406
],
[
651,
390,
767,
405
],
[
773,
390,
804,
405
],
[
177,
407,
284,
423
],
[
288,
407,
355,
422
],
[
365,
407,
399,
422
],
[
408,
407,
478,
422
],
[
488,
407,
528,
422
],
[
540,
407,
590,
422
],
[
607,
407,
631,
422
],
[
638,
407,
721,
423
],
[
727,
407,
806,
423
],
[
177,
424,
253,
440
],
[
256,
424,
349,
440
],
[
352,
424,
382,
440
],
[
385,
424,
464,
440
],
[
468,
425,
487,
440
],
[
490,
425,
529,
440
],
[
532,
425,
577,
440
],
[
580,
425,
610,
440
],
[
613,
425,
632,
440
],
[
635,
425,
707,
441
],
[
710,
425,
783,
441
],
[
786,
425,
805,
441
],
[
176,
443,
255,
457
],
[
258,
443,
288,
457
],
[
291,
443,
381,
458
],
[
384,
443,
431,
458
],
[
434,
443,
475,
458
],
[
478,
443,
555,
458
],
[
559,
443,
651,
458
],
[
654,
443,
682,
457
],
[
686,
443,
767,
457
],
[
119,
476,
158,
491
],
[
162,
476,
213,
492
],
[
217,
476,
248,
492
],
[
251,
476,
277,
492
],
[
280,
476,
315,
492
],
[
322,
477,
362,
493
],
[
366,
477,
394,
493
],
[
397,
477,
451,
493
],
[
454,
477,
520,
493
],
[
524,
477,
573,
493
],
[
577,
477,
595,
493
],
[
600,
477,
667,
493
],
[
671,
477,
729,
493
],
[
732,
477,
751,
492
],
[
754,
477,
792,
492
],
[
795,
476,
863,
492
],
[
117,
494,
158,
509
],
[
161,
494,
218,
510
],
[
221,
495,
300,
510
],
[
303,
495,
391,
510
],
[
395,
495,
472,
510
],
[
475,
495,
501,
510
],
[
505,
495,
533,
510
],
[
537,
495,
554,
510
],
[
557,
495,
587,
510
],
[
591,
495,
625,
510
],
[
632,
495,
661,
510
],
[
664,
495,
778,
510
],
[
782,
495,
830,
509
],
[
833,
495,
854,
509
],
[
117,
512,
192,
527
],
[
196,
512,
218,
527
],
[
222,
512,
263,
527
],
[
266,
512,
279,
527
],
[
282,
512,
297,
527
],
[
301,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
454,
527
],
[
457,
512,
488,
527
],
[
491,
512,
528,
527
],
[
533,
512,
589,
527
],
[
592,
512,
652,
527
],
[
655,
512,
694,
527
],
[
697,
512,
727,
526
],
[
730,
512,
764,
526
],
[
771,
513,
823,
526
],
[
826,
513,
842,
526
],
[
845,
513,
874,
525
],
[
120,
529,
191,
545
],
[
195,
529,
228,
545
],
[
232,
529,
267,
545
],
[
274,
529,
328,
545
],
[
332,
529,
361,
545
],
[
365,
529,
417,
545
],
[
421,
529,
447,
545
],
[
451,
529,
472,
545
],
[
476,
529,
538,
545
],
[
542,
529,
562,
545
],
[
566,
528,
649,
545
],
[
653,
528,
671,
545
],
[
675,
528,
735,
545
],
[
739,
528,
778,
545
],
[
782,
528,
798,
545
],
[
802,
528,
828,
545
],
[
831,
528,
883,
545
],
[
118,
547,
181,
562
],
[
184,
547,
209,
562
],
[
212,
547,
311,
562
],
[
314,
547,
337,
562
],
[
341,
547,
377,
563
],
[
382,
547,
400,
563
],
[
402,
547,
431,
563
],
[
434,
547,
445,
563
],
[
448,
547,
490,
563
],
[
492,
547,
577,
563
],
[
581,
547,
604,
563
],
[
607,
547,
650,
563
],
[
652,
547,
664,
562
],
[
667,
547,
707,
562
],
[
710,
548,
740,
562
],
[
742,
548,
834,
562
],
[
121,
564,
195,
579
],
[
198,
565,
213,
579
],
[
217,
565,
272,
580
],
[
119,
600,
158,
614
],
[
162,
600,
177,
614
],
[
180,
600,
299,
615
],
[
302,
600,
328,
615
],
[
331,
600,
360,
615
],
[
362,
600,
380,
615
],
[
383,
600,
411,
615
],
[
416,
600,
490,
615
],
[
494,
600,
525,
615
],
[
529,
600,
544,
615
],
[
547,
599,
562,
615
],
[
567,
599,
593,
615
],
[
597,
599,
635,
615
],
[
639,
599,
654,
615
],
[
657,
599,
698,
615
],
[
702,
599,
754,
615
],
[
758,
599,
871,
615
],
[
118,
615,
187,
631
],
[
204,
616,
238,
631
],
[
242,
616,
255,
631
],
[
259,
616,
288,
632
],
[
292,
617,
367,
632
],
[
371,
617,
394,
632
],
[
397,
617,
434,
632
],
[
438,
618,
511,
632
],
[
514,
618,
570,
632
],
[
574,
618,
611,
632
],
[
614,
617,
688,
632
],
[
692,
617,
707,
632
],
[
711,
617,
742,
632
],
[
746,
617,
827,
631
],
[
830,
616,
865,
631
],
[
118,
633,
143,
649
],
[
146,
633,
184,
649
],
[
187,
633,
228,
650
],
[
231,
634,
283,
650
],
[
286,
634,
341,
650
],
[
344,
634,
441,
650
],
[
451,
634,
500,
650
],
[
503,
634,
548,
650
],
[
551,
634,
634,
650
],
[
637,
634,
681,
650
],
[
684,
634,
728,
650
],
[
731,
634,
760,
649
],
[
764,
634,
840,
649
],
[
118,
651,
200,
667
],
[
203,
651,
238,
667
],
[
242,
651,
294,
667
],
[
297,
651,
348,
667
],
[
352,
651,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
421,
667
],
[
425,
652,
468,
667
],
[
472,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
521,
667
],
[
524,
652,
534,
667
],
[
538,
652,
660,
667
],
[
664,
651,
736,
667
],
[
740,
651,
770,
667
],
[
774,
651,
790,
667
],
[
794,
651,
850,
667
],
[
117,
668,
168,
683
],
[
171,
668,
188,
683
],
[
192,
669,
217,
683
],
[
220,
669,
267,
684
],
[
271,
669,
290,
684
],
[
292,
669,
368,
685
],
[
120,
702,
183,
719
],
[
187,
703,
197,
719
],
[
200,
703,
242,
719
],
[
245,
703,
327,
719
],
[
330,
703,
372,
720
],
[
375,
704,
406,
720
],
[
410,
704,
479,
720
],
[
482,
704,
498,
720
],
[
501,
704,
549,
720
],
[
552,
704,
619,
720
],
[
622,
704,
671,
720
],
[
674,
704,
695,
720
],
[
698,
704,
764,
719
],
[
767,
704,
827,
719
],
[
830,
704,
857,
719
],
[
118,
721,
228,
736
],
[
231,
721,
255,
736
],
[
259,
721,
327,
736
],
[
330,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
443,
737
],
[
446,
722,
483,
737
],
[
488,
722,
524,
737
],
[
527,
722,
592,
737
],
[
595,
722,
624,
736
],
[
627,
722,
654,
736
],
[
657,
721,
746,
736
],
[
748,
721,
790,
736
],
[
792,
721,
810,
735
],
[
812,
721,
839,
735
],
[
841,
721,
885,
735
],
[
118,
739,
151,
755
],
[
155,
739,
229,
755
],
[
232,
739,
266,
754
],
[
271,
738,
340,
754
],
[
343,
738,
360,
754
],
[
363,
738,
392,
754
],
[
396,
738,
431,
754
],
[
434,
738,
466,
754
],
[
470,
738,
558,
754
],
[
562,
738,
581,
754
],
[
585,
738,
715,
755
],
[
719,
738,
791,
755
],
[
794,
739,
834,
755
],
[
838,
739,
854,
755
],
[
118,
755,
199,
771
],
[
203,
756,
221,
771
],
[
224,
756,
287,
771
],
[
291,
756,
327,
772
],
[
335,
756,
370,
772
],
[
373,
756,
400,
772
],
[
403,
756,
465,
772
],
[
468,
756,
562,
772
],
[
566,
755,
642,
772
],
[
646,
755,
671,
772
],
[
675,
755,
731,
772
],
[
735,
755,
752,
772
],
[
757,
755,
781,
771
],
[
785,
755,
868,
771
],
[
117,
821,
130,
835
],
[
131,
822,
150,
836
],
[
118,
835,
130,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
161,
836,
225,
851
],
[
228,
838,
260,
852
],
[
264,
838,
343,
852
],
[
346,
839,
397,
852
],
[
400,
838,
478,
852
],
[
132,
850,
176,
865
],
[
180,
851,
273,
866
],
[
277,
853,
330,
866
],
[
333,
853,
364,
866
],
[
367,
853,
380,
866
],
[
384,
853,
417,
866
],
[
420,
852,
434,
866
],
[
437,
852,
484,
866
],
[
117,
864,
128,
878
],
[
131,
864,
151,
879
],
[
154,
865,
167,
879
],
[
170,
866,
220,
880
],
[
118,
879,
129,
893
],
[
132,
879,
148,
893
],
[
151,
880,
164,
894
],
[
167,
880,
216,
894
],
[
118,
895,
129,
908
],
[
132,
895,
156,
908
],
[
160,
895,
202,
909
],
[
205,
895,
255,
910
],
[
258,
896,
271,
910
],
[
275,
896,
295,
910
],
[
299,
896,
358,
910
],
[
362,
896,
374,
911
],
[
377,
895,
818,
911
],
[
821,
940,
884,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
979,
782,
997
]
] |
What two are the degree of independent verification and peer review?
|
variability, uncertainty
|
723
|
[
"variability,",
"uncertainty,",
"the",
"degree",
"of",
"independent",
"verification",
"and",
"peer",
"review.",
"In",
"proposing",
"this",
"definition,",
"ACC",
"has",
"drawn",
"language",
"directly",
"from",
"the",
"1996",
"SDWA",
"amendments\"and",
"from",
"section",
"26(h)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"EPA",
"has",
"already",
"adopted",
"the",
"language",
"from",
"the",
"SDWA",
"amendments",
"in",
"the",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"concept",
"of",
"evaluating",
"data",
"based",
"on",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"definition",
"provided",
"in",
"the",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record",
"for",
"LCSA.\"",
"To",
"ensure",
"a",
"greater",
"level",
"transparency",
"that",
"forces",
"EPA",
"to",
"\"show",
"its",
"work,\"",
"as",
"was",
"envisioned",
"by",
"the",
"authors",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA,\"",
"this",
"definition",
"covers",
"not",
"only",
"what",
"EPA",
"must",
"consider",
"and",
"evaluate,",
"but",
"also",
"requires",
"that",
"important",
"descriptions",
"and",
"documentation",
"be",
"including",
"in",
"EPA",
"work",
"products",
"developed",
"under",
"Sections",
"4-6",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"ii.",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"Evidence",
"(WoE).",
"ACC",
"suggests",
"the",
"following",
"definition:",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"evidence",
"means",
"a",
"systematic",
"review",
"method",
"that",
"uses",
"a",
"pre-",
"established",
"protocol",
"to",
"comprehensively,",
"objectively,",
"transparently,",
"and",
"consistently,",
"identify",
"and",
"evaluate",
"each",
"stream",
"of",
"evidence,",
"including",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"each",
"study",
"and",
"to",
"integrate",
"evidence",
"as",
"necessary",
"and",
"appropriate",
"based",
"upon",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance.",
"ACC",
"agrees",
"that",
"the",
"term",
"WoE",
"has",
"meant",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"groups.",
"In",
"fact,",
"different",
"NAS",
"studies",
"contradict",
"themselves",
"regarding",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"this",
"term",
"and",
"inconsistently",
"define",
"its",
"meaning.",
"As",
"such,",
"it",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"EPA",
"clearly",
"explain",
"what",
"this",
"term",
"means",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"This",
"term",
"cannot",
"and",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"avoided",
"or",
"discounted",
"as",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"codifies",
"the",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"use",
"a",
"WoE",
"approach.",
"As",
"such,",
"a",
"clear",
"and",
"transparent",
"definition",
"is",
"critical",
"ACC",
"is",
"recommending",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"definition",
"that",
"is",
"in",
"the",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record.",
"This",
"is",
"the",
"definition",
"we",
"have",
"provided",
"above.",
"This",
"definition",
"is",
"also",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"June",
"2015",
"House",
"Report",
"Language.\"",
"While",
"other",
"definitions",
"exist,",
"using",
"the",
"definition",
"associated",
"with",
"LCSA",
"makes",
"the",
"most",
"sense",
"and",
"is",
"a",
"straightforward",
"approach",
"that",
"is",
"clearly",
"linked",
"to",
"the",
"intent",
"of",
"Congress.",
"Without",
"a",
"clear",
"definition,",
"WoE",
"will",
"continue",
"to",
"mean",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"experts",
"and",
"stakeholders.",
"An",
"example",
"illustrates",
"that",
"EPA",
"very",
"recently",
"has",
"not",
"interpreted",
"WoE",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"way",
"Congress",
"now",
"intends.",
"In",
"the",
"draft",
"risk",
"assessment",
"of",
"1-bromopropane",
"(released",
"prior",
"to",
"enactment",
"of",
"LCSA),",
"EPA",
"does",
"not",
"provide",
"information",
"regarding",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"the",
"individual",
"29",
"Id.",
"30",
"See",
"generally,",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"at",
"$3518.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"$3522.",
"33",
"Id",
"at",
"$3518.",
"34",
"See",
"House",
"Report,",
"at",
"33,",
"available",
"at",
"https://www.congress.gov/Ll4/crot/hump:176/CRPT.114hmt176.pdf.",
"15/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
207,
94,
297,
110
],
[
300,
93,
400,
110
],
[
404,
93,
432,
110
],
[
440,
93,
494,
110
],
[
498,
93,
521,
110
],
[
524,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
94,
724,
109
],
[
730,
94,
763,
109
],
[
768,
94,
804,
109
],
[
206,
112,
267,
125
],
[
117,
146,
134,
162
],
[
137,
146,
218,
162
],
[
222,
146,
254,
161
],
[
258,
146,
339,
161
],
[
342,
146,
382,
161
],
[
385,
146,
417,
161
],
[
421,
146,
467,
161
],
[
470,
145,
547,
161
],
[
551,
145,
609,
160
],
[
612,
145,
648,
160
],
[
654,
145,
682,
160
],
[
685,
145,
726,
160
],
[
730,
145,
787,
160
],
[
117,
163,
264,
179
],
[
267,
163,
304,
179
],
[
311,
163,
368,
179
],
[
371,
163,
415,
179
],
[
419,
163,
436,
179
],
[
439,
163,
465,
179
],
[
469,
163,
525,
179
],
[
529,
163,
567,
179
],
[
570,
163,
598,
179
],
[
602,
163,
661,
179
],
[
665,
163,
728,
179
],
[
732,
163,
757,
179
],
[
760,
163,
833,
179
],
[
837,
164,
872,
179
],
[
117,
180,
144,
195
],
[
147,
180,
204,
195
],
[
209,
180,
308,
196
],
[
312,
181,
329,
196
],
[
332,
181,
359,
196
],
[
362,
181,
399,
196
],
[
404,
181,
500,
196
],
[
504,
181,
564,
196
],
[
568,
181,
665,
196
],
[
681,
181,
698,
196
],
[
701,
180,
772,
196
],
[
775,
180,
801,
196
],
[
804,
180,
870,
196
],
[
117,
198,
134,
214
],
[
138,
198,
224,
214
],
[
227,
198,
258,
214
],
[
261,
198,
309,
214
],
[
312,
198,
334,
214
],
[
337,
198,
410,
213
],
[
412,
198,
441,
213
],
[
444,
198,
530,
213
],
[
533,
198,
550,
213
],
[
552,
198,
634,
213
],
[
637,
198,
672,
213
],
[
675,
198,
704,
214
],
[
707,
198,
782,
214
],
[
785,
197,
856,
214
],
[
859,
197,
878,
214
],
[
118,
215,
142,
231
],
[
146,
215,
199,
231
],
[
203,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
378,
231
],
[
381,
215,
406,
231
],
[
410,
215,
480,
231
],
[
490,
215,
512,
231
],
[
515,
215,
568,
231
],
[
571,
215,
582,
231
],
[
585,
215,
640,
231
],
[
644,
215,
684,
231
],
[
687,
215,
788,
231
],
[
791,
215,
823,
231
],
[
826,
216,
881,
231
],
[
117,
232,
155,
247
],
[
159,
233,
177,
248
],
[
180,
233,
228,
248
],
[
234,
233,
255,
248
],
[
258,
233,
313,
248
],
[
317,
233,
335,
248
],
[
338,
233,
370,
248
],
[
374,
233,
459,
248
],
[
462,
233,
484,
248
],
[
488,
233,
514,
248
],
[
517,
233,
577,
248
],
[
580,
233,
597,
248
],
[
601,
233,
626,
248
],
[
630,
233,
698,
248
],
[
703,
232,
737,
248
],
[
740,
232,
815,
248
],
[
819,
232,
873,
248
],
[
116,
250,
144,
265
],
[
147,
250,
184,
265
],
[
187,
250,
227,
265
],
[
230,
250,
268,
265
],
[
271,
250,
312,
265
],
[
315,
250,
383,
265
],
[
387,
250,
415,
265
],
[
420,
250,
491,
265
],
[
494,
250,
521,
265
],
[
525,
250,
558,
265
],
[
562,
250,
625,
265
],
[
629,
250,
660,
266
],
[
664,
250,
745,
266
],
[
750,
250,
843,
266
],
[
846,
250,
878,
266
],
[
120,
268,
234,
283
],
[
238,
268,
258,
283
],
[
262,
268,
337,
284
],
[
340,
268,
358,
284
],
[
362,
268,
399,
284
],
[
403,
267,
444,
284
],
[
448,
267,
522,
284
],
[
525,
267,
604,
284
],
[
607,
267,
655,
284
],
[
657,
267,
727,
284
],
[
729,
266,
757,
284
],
[
760,
266,
780,
284
],
[
782,
266,
837,
284
],
[
147,
300,
164,
315
],
[
206,
301,
265,
317
],
[
269,
303,
286,
317
],
[
290,
303,
315,
318
],
[
319,
302,
394,
318
],
[
397,
301,
455,
318
],
[
120,
337,
158,
352
],
[
162,
337,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
264,
338,
344,
353
],
[
347,
338,
428,
353
],
[
179,
371,
237,
387
],
[
241,
372,
260,
387
],
[
264,
372,
294,
387
],
[
297,
372,
370,
388
],
[
374,
373,
431,
388
],
[
434,
373,
447,
388
],
[
450,
374,
538,
388
],
[
542,
374,
596,
388
],
[
604,
373,
668,
388
],
[
672,
373,
708,
388
],
[
711,
373,
751,
387
],
[
754,
372,
767,
387
],
[
770,
372,
804,
387
],
[
177,
390,
266,
405
],
[
277,
391,
350,
405
],
[
359,
391,
378,
405
],
[
390,
391,
536,
406
],
[
544,
391,
644,
406
],
[
651,
390,
767,
405
],
[
773,
390,
804,
405
],
[
177,
407,
284,
423
],
[
288,
407,
355,
422
],
[
365,
407,
399,
422
],
[
408,
407,
478,
422
],
[
488,
407,
528,
422
],
[
540,
407,
590,
422
],
[
607,
407,
631,
422
],
[
638,
407,
721,
423
],
[
727,
407,
806,
423
],
[
177,
424,
253,
440
],
[
256,
424,
349,
440
],
[
352,
424,
382,
440
],
[
385,
424,
464,
440
],
[
468,
425,
487,
440
],
[
490,
425,
529,
440
],
[
532,
425,
577,
440
],
[
580,
425,
610,
440
],
[
613,
425,
632,
440
],
[
635,
425,
707,
441
],
[
710,
425,
783,
441
],
[
786,
425,
805,
441
],
[
176,
443,
255,
457
],
[
258,
443,
288,
457
],
[
291,
443,
381,
458
],
[
384,
443,
431,
458
],
[
434,
443,
475,
458
],
[
478,
443,
555,
458
],
[
559,
443,
651,
458
],
[
654,
443,
682,
457
],
[
686,
443,
767,
457
],
[
119,
476,
158,
491
],
[
162,
476,
213,
492
],
[
217,
476,
248,
492
],
[
251,
476,
277,
492
],
[
280,
476,
315,
492
],
[
322,
477,
362,
493
],
[
366,
477,
394,
493
],
[
397,
477,
451,
493
],
[
454,
477,
520,
493
],
[
524,
477,
573,
493
],
[
577,
477,
595,
493
],
[
600,
477,
667,
493
],
[
671,
477,
729,
493
],
[
732,
477,
751,
492
],
[
754,
477,
792,
492
],
[
795,
476,
863,
492
],
[
117,
494,
158,
509
],
[
161,
494,
218,
510
],
[
221,
495,
300,
510
],
[
303,
495,
391,
510
],
[
395,
495,
472,
510
],
[
475,
495,
501,
510
],
[
505,
495,
533,
510
],
[
537,
495,
554,
510
],
[
557,
495,
587,
510
],
[
591,
495,
625,
510
],
[
632,
495,
661,
510
],
[
664,
495,
778,
510
],
[
782,
495,
830,
509
],
[
833,
495,
854,
509
],
[
117,
512,
192,
527
],
[
196,
512,
218,
527
],
[
222,
512,
263,
527
],
[
266,
512,
279,
527
],
[
282,
512,
297,
527
],
[
301,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
454,
527
],
[
457,
512,
488,
527
],
[
491,
512,
528,
527
],
[
533,
512,
589,
527
],
[
592,
512,
652,
527
],
[
655,
512,
694,
527
],
[
697,
512,
727,
526
],
[
730,
512,
764,
526
],
[
771,
513,
823,
526
],
[
826,
513,
842,
526
],
[
845,
513,
874,
525
],
[
120,
529,
191,
545
],
[
195,
529,
228,
545
],
[
232,
529,
267,
545
],
[
274,
529,
328,
545
],
[
332,
529,
361,
545
],
[
365,
529,
417,
545
],
[
421,
529,
447,
545
],
[
451,
529,
472,
545
],
[
476,
529,
538,
545
],
[
542,
529,
562,
545
],
[
566,
528,
649,
545
],
[
653,
528,
671,
545
],
[
675,
528,
735,
545
],
[
739,
528,
778,
545
],
[
782,
528,
798,
545
],
[
802,
528,
828,
545
],
[
831,
528,
883,
545
],
[
118,
547,
181,
562
],
[
184,
547,
209,
562
],
[
212,
547,
311,
562
],
[
314,
547,
337,
562
],
[
341,
547,
377,
563
],
[
382,
547,
400,
563
],
[
402,
547,
431,
563
],
[
434,
547,
445,
563
],
[
448,
547,
490,
563
],
[
492,
547,
577,
563
],
[
581,
547,
604,
563
],
[
607,
547,
650,
563
],
[
652,
547,
664,
562
],
[
667,
547,
707,
562
],
[
710,
548,
740,
562
],
[
742,
548,
834,
562
],
[
121,
564,
195,
579
],
[
198,
565,
213,
579
],
[
217,
565,
272,
580
],
[
119,
600,
158,
614
],
[
162,
600,
177,
614
],
[
180,
600,
299,
615
],
[
302,
600,
328,
615
],
[
331,
600,
360,
615
],
[
362,
600,
380,
615
],
[
383,
600,
411,
615
],
[
416,
600,
490,
615
],
[
494,
600,
525,
615
],
[
529,
600,
544,
615
],
[
547,
599,
562,
615
],
[
567,
599,
593,
615
],
[
597,
599,
635,
615
],
[
639,
599,
654,
615
],
[
657,
599,
698,
615
],
[
702,
599,
754,
615
],
[
758,
599,
871,
615
],
[
118,
615,
187,
631
],
[
204,
616,
238,
631
],
[
242,
616,
255,
631
],
[
259,
616,
288,
632
],
[
292,
617,
367,
632
],
[
371,
617,
394,
632
],
[
397,
617,
434,
632
],
[
438,
618,
511,
632
],
[
514,
618,
570,
632
],
[
574,
618,
611,
632
],
[
614,
617,
688,
632
],
[
692,
617,
707,
632
],
[
711,
617,
742,
632
],
[
746,
617,
827,
631
],
[
830,
616,
865,
631
],
[
118,
633,
143,
649
],
[
146,
633,
184,
649
],
[
187,
633,
228,
650
],
[
231,
634,
283,
650
],
[
286,
634,
341,
650
],
[
344,
634,
441,
650
],
[
451,
634,
500,
650
],
[
503,
634,
548,
650
],
[
551,
634,
634,
650
],
[
637,
634,
681,
650
],
[
684,
634,
728,
650
],
[
731,
634,
760,
649
],
[
764,
634,
840,
649
],
[
118,
651,
200,
667
],
[
203,
651,
238,
667
],
[
242,
651,
294,
667
],
[
297,
651,
348,
667
],
[
352,
651,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
421,
667
],
[
425,
652,
468,
667
],
[
472,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
521,
667
],
[
524,
652,
534,
667
],
[
538,
652,
660,
667
],
[
664,
651,
736,
667
],
[
740,
651,
770,
667
],
[
774,
651,
790,
667
],
[
794,
651,
850,
667
],
[
117,
668,
168,
683
],
[
171,
668,
188,
683
],
[
192,
669,
217,
683
],
[
220,
669,
267,
684
],
[
271,
669,
290,
684
],
[
292,
669,
368,
685
],
[
120,
702,
183,
719
],
[
187,
703,
197,
719
],
[
200,
703,
242,
719
],
[
245,
703,
327,
719
],
[
330,
703,
372,
720
],
[
375,
704,
406,
720
],
[
410,
704,
479,
720
],
[
482,
704,
498,
720
],
[
501,
704,
549,
720
],
[
552,
704,
619,
720
],
[
622,
704,
671,
720
],
[
674,
704,
695,
720
],
[
698,
704,
764,
719
],
[
767,
704,
827,
719
],
[
830,
704,
857,
719
],
[
118,
721,
228,
736
],
[
231,
721,
255,
736
],
[
259,
721,
327,
736
],
[
330,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
443,
737
],
[
446,
722,
483,
737
],
[
488,
722,
524,
737
],
[
527,
722,
592,
737
],
[
595,
722,
624,
736
],
[
627,
722,
654,
736
],
[
657,
721,
746,
736
],
[
748,
721,
790,
736
],
[
792,
721,
810,
735
],
[
812,
721,
839,
735
],
[
841,
721,
885,
735
],
[
118,
739,
151,
755
],
[
155,
739,
229,
755
],
[
232,
739,
266,
754
],
[
271,
738,
340,
754
],
[
343,
738,
360,
754
],
[
363,
738,
392,
754
],
[
396,
738,
431,
754
],
[
434,
738,
466,
754
],
[
470,
738,
558,
754
],
[
562,
738,
581,
754
],
[
585,
738,
715,
755
],
[
719,
738,
791,
755
],
[
794,
739,
834,
755
],
[
838,
739,
854,
755
],
[
118,
755,
199,
771
],
[
203,
756,
221,
771
],
[
224,
756,
287,
771
],
[
291,
756,
327,
772
],
[
335,
756,
370,
772
],
[
373,
756,
400,
772
],
[
403,
756,
465,
772
],
[
468,
756,
562,
772
],
[
566,
755,
642,
772
],
[
646,
755,
671,
772
],
[
675,
755,
731,
772
],
[
735,
755,
752,
772
],
[
757,
755,
781,
771
],
[
785,
755,
868,
771
],
[
117,
821,
130,
835
],
[
131,
822,
150,
836
],
[
118,
835,
130,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
161,
836,
225,
851
],
[
228,
838,
260,
852
],
[
264,
838,
343,
852
],
[
346,
839,
397,
852
],
[
400,
838,
478,
852
],
[
132,
850,
176,
865
],
[
180,
851,
273,
866
],
[
277,
853,
330,
866
],
[
333,
853,
364,
866
],
[
367,
853,
380,
866
],
[
384,
853,
417,
866
],
[
420,
852,
434,
866
],
[
437,
852,
484,
866
],
[
117,
864,
128,
878
],
[
131,
864,
151,
879
],
[
154,
865,
167,
879
],
[
170,
866,
220,
880
],
[
118,
879,
129,
893
],
[
132,
879,
148,
893
],
[
151,
880,
164,
894
],
[
167,
880,
216,
894
],
[
118,
895,
129,
908
],
[
132,
895,
156,
908
],
[
160,
895,
202,
909
],
[
205,
895,
255,
910
],
[
258,
896,
271,
910
],
[
275,
896,
295,
910
],
[
299,
896,
358,
910
],
[
362,
896,
374,
911
],
[
377,
895,
818,
911
],
[
821,
940,
884,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
979,
782,
997
]
] |
Who agrees that the term WoE has meant different things to different groups?
|
ACC
|
723
|
[
"variability,",
"uncertainty,",
"the",
"degree",
"of",
"independent",
"verification",
"and",
"peer",
"review.",
"In",
"proposing",
"this",
"definition,",
"ACC",
"has",
"drawn",
"language",
"directly",
"from",
"the",
"1996",
"SDWA",
"amendments\"and",
"from",
"section",
"26(h)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"EPA",
"has",
"already",
"adopted",
"the",
"language",
"from",
"the",
"SDWA",
"amendments",
"in",
"the",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"concept",
"of",
"evaluating",
"data",
"based",
"on",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"definition",
"provided",
"in",
"the",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record",
"for",
"LCSA.\"",
"To",
"ensure",
"a",
"greater",
"level",
"transparency",
"that",
"forces",
"EPA",
"to",
"\"show",
"its",
"work,\"",
"as",
"was",
"envisioned",
"by",
"the",
"authors",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA,\"",
"this",
"definition",
"covers",
"not",
"only",
"what",
"EPA",
"must",
"consider",
"and",
"evaluate,",
"but",
"also",
"requires",
"that",
"important",
"descriptions",
"and",
"documentation",
"be",
"including",
"in",
"EPA",
"work",
"products",
"developed",
"under",
"Sections",
"4-6",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"ii.",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"Evidence",
"(WoE).",
"ACC",
"suggests",
"the",
"following",
"definition:",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"evidence",
"means",
"a",
"systematic",
"review",
"method",
"that",
"uses",
"a",
"pre-",
"established",
"protocol",
"to",
"comprehensively,",
"objectively,",
"transparently,",
"and",
"consistently,",
"identify",
"and",
"evaluate",
"each",
"stream",
"of",
"evidence,",
"including",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"each",
"study",
"and",
"to",
"integrate",
"evidence",
"as",
"necessary",
"and",
"appropriate",
"based",
"upon",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance.",
"ACC",
"agrees",
"that",
"the",
"term",
"WoE",
"has",
"meant",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"groups.",
"In",
"fact,",
"different",
"NAS",
"studies",
"contradict",
"themselves",
"regarding",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"this",
"term",
"and",
"inconsistently",
"define",
"its",
"meaning.",
"As",
"such,",
"it",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"EPA",
"clearly",
"explain",
"what",
"this",
"term",
"means",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"This",
"term",
"cannot",
"and",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"avoided",
"or",
"discounted",
"as",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"codifies",
"the",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"use",
"a",
"WoE",
"approach.",
"As",
"such,",
"a",
"clear",
"and",
"transparent",
"definition",
"is",
"critical",
"ACC",
"is",
"recommending",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"definition",
"that",
"is",
"in",
"the",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record.",
"This",
"is",
"the",
"definition",
"we",
"have",
"provided",
"above.",
"This",
"definition",
"is",
"also",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"June",
"2015",
"House",
"Report",
"Language.\"",
"While",
"other",
"definitions",
"exist,",
"using",
"the",
"definition",
"associated",
"with",
"LCSA",
"makes",
"the",
"most",
"sense",
"and",
"is",
"a",
"straightforward",
"approach",
"that",
"is",
"clearly",
"linked",
"to",
"the",
"intent",
"of",
"Congress.",
"Without",
"a",
"clear",
"definition,",
"WoE",
"will",
"continue",
"to",
"mean",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"experts",
"and",
"stakeholders.",
"An",
"example",
"illustrates",
"that",
"EPA",
"very",
"recently",
"has",
"not",
"interpreted",
"WoE",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"way",
"Congress",
"now",
"intends.",
"In",
"the",
"draft",
"risk",
"assessment",
"of",
"1-bromopropane",
"(released",
"prior",
"to",
"enactment",
"of",
"LCSA),",
"EPA",
"does",
"not",
"provide",
"information",
"regarding",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"the",
"individual",
"29",
"Id.",
"30",
"See",
"generally,",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"at",
"$3518.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"$3522.",
"33",
"Id",
"at",
"$3518.",
"34",
"See",
"House",
"Report,",
"at",
"33,",
"available",
"at",
"https://www.congress.gov/Ll4/crot/hump:176/CRPT.114hmt176.pdf.",
"15/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
207,
94,
297,
110
],
[
300,
93,
400,
110
],
[
404,
93,
432,
110
],
[
440,
93,
494,
110
],
[
498,
93,
521,
110
],
[
524,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
94,
724,
109
],
[
730,
94,
763,
109
],
[
768,
94,
804,
109
],
[
206,
112,
267,
125
],
[
117,
146,
134,
162
],
[
137,
146,
218,
162
],
[
222,
146,
254,
161
],
[
258,
146,
339,
161
],
[
342,
146,
382,
161
],
[
385,
146,
417,
161
],
[
421,
146,
467,
161
],
[
470,
145,
547,
161
],
[
551,
145,
609,
160
],
[
612,
145,
648,
160
],
[
654,
145,
682,
160
],
[
685,
145,
726,
160
],
[
730,
145,
787,
160
],
[
117,
163,
264,
179
],
[
267,
163,
304,
179
],
[
311,
163,
368,
179
],
[
371,
163,
415,
179
],
[
419,
163,
436,
179
],
[
439,
163,
465,
179
],
[
469,
163,
525,
179
],
[
529,
163,
567,
179
],
[
570,
163,
598,
179
],
[
602,
163,
661,
179
],
[
665,
163,
728,
179
],
[
732,
163,
757,
179
],
[
760,
163,
833,
179
],
[
837,
164,
872,
179
],
[
117,
180,
144,
195
],
[
147,
180,
204,
195
],
[
209,
180,
308,
196
],
[
312,
181,
329,
196
],
[
332,
181,
359,
196
],
[
362,
181,
399,
196
],
[
404,
181,
500,
196
],
[
504,
181,
564,
196
],
[
568,
181,
665,
196
],
[
681,
181,
698,
196
],
[
701,
180,
772,
196
],
[
775,
180,
801,
196
],
[
804,
180,
870,
196
],
[
117,
198,
134,
214
],
[
138,
198,
224,
214
],
[
227,
198,
258,
214
],
[
261,
198,
309,
214
],
[
312,
198,
334,
214
],
[
337,
198,
410,
213
],
[
412,
198,
441,
213
],
[
444,
198,
530,
213
],
[
533,
198,
550,
213
],
[
552,
198,
634,
213
],
[
637,
198,
672,
213
],
[
675,
198,
704,
214
],
[
707,
198,
782,
214
],
[
785,
197,
856,
214
],
[
859,
197,
878,
214
],
[
118,
215,
142,
231
],
[
146,
215,
199,
231
],
[
203,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
378,
231
],
[
381,
215,
406,
231
],
[
410,
215,
480,
231
],
[
490,
215,
512,
231
],
[
515,
215,
568,
231
],
[
571,
215,
582,
231
],
[
585,
215,
640,
231
],
[
644,
215,
684,
231
],
[
687,
215,
788,
231
],
[
791,
215,
823,
231
],
[
826,
216,
881,
231
],
[
117,
232,
155,
247
],
[
159,
233,
177,
248
],
[
180,
233,
228,
248
],
[
234,
233,
255,
248
],
[
258,
233,
313,
248
],
[
317,
233,
335,
248
],
[
338,
233,
370,
248
],
[
374,
233,
459,
248
],
[
462,
233,
484,
248
],
[
488,
233,
514,
248
],
[
517,
233,
577,
248
],
[
580,
233,
597,
248
],
[
601,
233,
626,
248
],
[
630,
233,
698,
248
],
[
703,
232,
737,
248
],
[
740,
232,
815,
248
],
[
819,
232,
873,
248
],
[
116,
250,
144,
265
],
[
147,
250,
184,
265
],
[
187,
250,
227,
265
],
[
230,
250,
268,
265
],
[
271,
250,
312,
265
],
[
315,
250,
383,
265
],
[
387,
250,
415,
265
],
[
420,
250,
491,
265
],
[
494,
250,
521,
265
],
[
525,
250,
558,
265
],
[
562,
250,
625,
265
],
[
629,
250,
660,
266
],
[
664,
250,
745,
266
],
[
750,
250,
843,
266
],
[
846,
250,
878,
266
],
[
120,
268,
234,
283
],
[
238,
268,
258,
283
],
[
262,
268,
337,
284
],
[
340,
268,
358,
284
],
[
362,
268,
399,
284
],
[
403,
267,
444,
284
],
[
448,
267,
522,
284
],
[
525,
267,
604,
284
],
[
607,
267,
655,
284
],
[
657,
267,
727,
284
],
[
729,
266,
757,
284
],
[
760,
266,
780,
284
],
[
782,
266,
837,
284
],
[
147,
300,
164,
315
],
[
206,
301,
265,
317
],
[
269,
303,
286,
317
],
[
290,
303,
315,
318
],
[
319,
302,
394,
318
],
[
397,
301,
455,
318
],
[
120,
337,
158,
352
],
[
162,
337,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
264,
338,
344,
353
],
[
347,
338,
428,
353
],
[
179,
371,
237,
387
],
[
241,
372,
260,
387
],
[
264,
372,
294,
387
],
[
297,
372,
370,
388
],
[
374,
373,
431,
388
],
[
434,
373,
447,
388
],
[
450,
374,
538,
388
],
[
542,
374,
596,
388
],
[
604,
373,
668,
388
],
[
672,
373,
708,
388
],
[
711,
373,
751,
387
],
[
754,
372,
767,
387
],
[
770,
372,
804,
387
],
[
177,
390,
266,
405
],
[
277,
391,
350,
405
],
[
359,
391,
378,
405
],
[
390,
391,
536,
406
],
[
544,
391,
644,
406
],
[
651,
390,
767,
405
],
[
773,
390,
804,
405
],
[
177,
407,
284,
423
],
[
288,
407,
355,
422
],
[
365,
407,
399,
422
],
[
408,
407,
478,
422
],
[
488,
407,
528,
422
],
[
540,
407,
590,
422
],
[
607,
407,
631,
422
],
[
638,
407,
721,
423
],
[
727,
407,
806,
423
],
[
177,
424,
253,
440
],
[
256,
424,
349,
440
],
[
352,
424,
382,
440
],
[
385,
424,
464,
440
],
[
468,
425,
487,
440
],
[
490,
425,
529,
440
],
[
532,
425,
577,
440
],
[
580,
425,
610,
440
],
[
613,
425,
632,
440
],
[
635,
425,
707,
441
],
[
710,
425,
783,
441
],
[
786,
425,
805,
441
],
[
176,
443,
255,
457
],
[
258,
443,
288,
457
],
[
291,
443,
381,
458
],
[
384,
443,
431,
458
],
[
434,
443,
475,
458
],
[
478,
443,
555,
458
],
[
559,
443,
651,
458
],
[
654,
443,
682,
457
],
[
686,
443,
767,
457
],
[
119,
476,
158,
491
],
[
162,
476,
213,
492
],
[
217,
476,
248,
492
],
[
251,
476,
277,
492
],
[
280,
476,
315,
492
],
[
322,
477,
362,
493
],
[
366,
477,
394,
493
],
[
397,
477,
451,
493
],
[
454,
477,
520,
493
],
[
524,
477,
573,
493
],
[
577,
477,
595,
493
],
[
600,
477,
667,
493
],
[
671,
477,
729,
493
],
[
732,
477,
751,
492
],
[
754,
477,
792,
492
],
[
795,
476,
863,
492
],
[
117,
494,
158,
509
],
[
161,
494,
218,
510
],
[
221,
495,
300,
510
],
[
303,
495,
391,
510
],
[
395,
495,
472,
510
],
[
475,
495,
501,
510
],
[
505,
495,
533,
510
],
[
537,
495,
554,
510
],
[
557,
495,
587,
510
],
[
591,
495,
625,
510
],
[
632,
495,
661,
510
],
[
664,
495,
778,
510
],
[
782,
495,
830,
509
],
[
833,
495,
854,
509
],
[
117,
512,
192,
527
],
[
196,
512,
218,
527
],
[
222,
512,
263,
527
],
[
266,
512,
279,
527
],
[
282,
512,
297,
527
],
[
301,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
454,
527
],
[
457,
512,
488,
527
],
[
491,
512,
528,
527
],
[
533,
512,
589,
527
],
[
592,
512,
652,
527
],
[
655,
512,
694,
527
],
[
697,
512,
727,
526
],
[
730,
512,
764,
526
],
[
771,
513,
823,
526
],
[
826,
513,
842,
526
],
[
845,
513,
874,
525
],
[
120,
529,
191,
545
],
[
195,
529,
228,
545
],
[
232,
529,
267,
545
],
[
274,
529,
328,
545
],
[
332,
529,
361,
545
],
[
365,
529,
417,
545
],
[
421,
529,
447,
545
],
[
451,
529,
472,
545
],
[
476,
529,
538,
545
],
[
542,
529,
562,
545
],
[
566,
528,
649,
545
],
[
653,
528,
671,
545
],
[
675,
528,
735,
545
],
[
739,
528,
778,
545
],
[
782,
528,
798,
545
],
[
802,
528,
828,
545
],
[
831,
528,
883,
545
],
[
118,
547,
181,
562
],
[
184,
547,
209,
562
],
[
212,
547,
311,
562
],
[
314,
547,
337,
562
],
[
341,
547,
377,
563
],
[
382,
547,
400,
563
],
[
402,
547,
431,
563
],
[
434,
547,
445,
563
],
[
448,
547,
490,
563
],
[
492,
547,
577,
563
],
[
581,
547,
604,
563
],
[
607,
547,
650,
563
],
[
652,
547,
664,
562
],
[
667,
547,
707,
562
],
[
710,
548,
740,
562
],
[
742,
548,
834,
562
],
[
121,
564,
195,
579
],
[
198,
565,
213,
579
],
[
217,
565,
272,
580
],
[
119,
600,
158,
614
],
[
162,
600,
177,
614
],
[
180,
600,
299,
615
],
[
302,
600,
328,
615
],
[
331,
600,
360,
615
],
[
362,
600,
380,
615
],
[
383,
600,
411,
615
],
[
416,
600,
490,
615
],
[
494,
600,
525,
615
],
[
529,
600,
544,
615
],
[
547,
599,
562,
615
],
[
567,
599,
593,
615
],
[
597,
599,
635,
615
],
[
639,
599,
654,
615
],
[
657,
599,
698,
615
],
[
702,
599,
754,
615
],
[
758,
599,
871,
615
],
[
118,
615,
187,
631
],
[
204,
616,
238,
631
],
[
242,
616,
255,
631
],
[
259,
616,
288,
632
],
[
292,
617,
367,
632
],
[
371,
617,
394,
632
],
[
397,
617,
434,
632
],
[
438,
618,
511,
632
],
[
514,
618,
570,
632
],
[
574,
618,
611,
632
],
[
614,
617,
688,
632
],
[
692,
617,
707,
632
],
[
711,
617,
742,
632
],
[
746,
617,
827,
631
],
[
830,
616,
865,
631
],
[
118,
633,
143,
649
],
[
146,
633,
184,
649
],
[
187,
633,
228,
650
],
[
231,
634,
283,
650
],
[
286,
634,
341,
650
],
[
344,
634,
441,
650
],
[
451,
634,
500,
650
],
[
503,
634,
548,
650
],
[
551,
634,
634,
650
],
[
637,
634,
681,
650
],
[
684,
634,
728,
650
],
[
731,
634,
760,
649
],
[
764,
634,
840,
649
],
[
118,
651,
200,
667
],
[
203,
651,
238,
667
],
[
242,
651,
294,
667
],
[
297,
651,
348,
667
],
[
352,
651,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
421,
667
],
[
425,
652,
468,
667
],
[
472,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
521,
667
],
[
524,
652,
534,
667
],
[
538,
652,
660,
667
],
[
664,
651,
736,
667
],
[
740,
651,
770,
667
],
[
774,
651,
790,
667
],
[
794,
651,
850,
667
],
[
117,
668,
168,
683
],
[
171,
668,
188,
683
],
[
192,
669,
217,
683
],
[
220,
669,
267,
684
],
[
271,
669,
290,
684
],
[
292,
669,
368,
685
],
[
120,
702,
183,
719
],
[
187,
703,
197,
719
],
[
200,
703,
242,
719
],
[
245,
703,
327,
719
],
[
330,
703,
372,
720
],
[
375,
704,
406,
720
],
[
410,
704,
479,
720
],
[
482,
704,
498,
720
],
[
501,
704,
549,
720
],
[
552,
704,
619,
720
],
[
622,
704,
671,
720
],
[
674,
704,
695,
720
],
[
698,
704,
764,
719
],
[
767,
704,
827,
719
],
[
830,
704,
857,
719
],
[
118,
721,
228,
736
],
[
231,
721,
255,
736
],
[
259,
721,
327,
736
],
[
330,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
443,
737
],
[
446,
722,
483,
737
],
[
488,
722,
524,
737
],
[
527,
722,
592,
737
],
[
595,
722,
624,
736
],
[
627,
722,
654,
736
],
[
657,
721,
746,
736
],
[
748,
721,
790,
736
],
[
792,
721,
810,
735
],
[
812,
721,
839,
735
],
[
841,
721,
885,
735
],
[
118,
739,
151,
755
],
[
155,
739,
229,
755
],
[
232,
739,
266,
754
],
[
271,
738,
340,
754
],
[
343,
738,
360,
754
],
[
363,
738,
392,
754
],
[
396,
738,
431,
754
],
[
434,
738,
466,
754
],
[
470,
738,
558,
754
],
[
562,
738,
581,
754
],
[
585,
738,
715,
755
],
[
719,
738,
791,
755
],
[
794,
739,
834,
755
],
[
838,
739,
854,
755
],
[
118,
755,
199,
771
],
[
203,
756,
221,
771
],
[
224,
756,
287,
771
],
[
291,
756,
327,
772
],
[
335,
756,
370,
772
],
[
373,
756,
400,
772
],
[
403,
756,
465,
772
],
[
468,
756,
562,
772
],
[
566,
755,
642,
772
],
[
646,
755,
671,
772
],
[
675,
755,
731,
772
],
[
735,
755,
752,
772
],
[
757,
755,
781,
771
],
[
785,
755,
868,
771
],
[
117,
821,
130,
835
],
[
131,
822,
150,
836
],
[
118,
835,
130,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
161,
836,
225,
851
],
[
228,
838,
260,
852
],
[
264,
838,
343,
852
],
[
346,
839,
397,
852
],
[
400,
838,
478,
852
],
[
132,
850,
176,
865
],
[
180,
851,
273,
866
],
[
277,
853,
330,
866
],
[
333,
853,
364,
866
],
[
367,
853,
380,
866
],
[
384,
853,
417,
866
],
[
420,
852,
434,
866
],
[
437,
852,
484,
866
],
[
117,
864,
128,
878
],
[
131,
864,
151,
879
],
[
154,
865,
167,
879
],
[
170,
866,
220,
880
],
[
118,
879,
129,
893
],
[
132,
879,
148,
893
],
[
151,
880,
164,
894
],
[
167,
880,
216,
894
],
[
118,
895,
129,
908
],
[
132,
895,
156,
908
],
[
160,
895,
202,
909
],
[
205,
895,
255,
910
],
[
258,
896,
271,
910
],
[
275,
896,
295,
910
],
[
299,
896,
358,
910
],
[
362,
896,
374,
911
],
[
377,
895,
818,
911
],
[
821,
940,
884,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
979,
782,
997
]
] |
Who does not provide information regarding the quality of the individual?
|
EPA
|
723
|
[
"variability,",
"uncertainty,",
"the",
"degree",
"of",
"independent",
"verification",
"and",
"peer",
"review.",
"In",
"proposing",
"this",
"definition,",
"ACC",
"has",
"drawn",
"language",
"directly",
"from",
"the",
"1996",
"SDWA",
"amendments\"and",
"from",
"section",
"26(h)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"EPA",
"has",
"already",
"adopted",
"the",
"language",
"from",
"the",
"SDWA",
"amendments",
"in",
"the",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"concept",
"of",
"evaluating",
"data",
"based",
"on",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"definition",
"provided",
"in",
"the",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record",
"for",
"LCSA.\"",
"To",
"ensure",
"a",
"greater",
"level",
"transparency",
"that",
"forces",
"EPA",
"to",
"\"show",
"its",
"work,\"",
"as",
"was",
"envisioned",
"by",
"the",
"authors",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA,\"",
"this",
"definition",
"covers",
"not",
"only",
"what",
"EPA",
"must",
"consider",
"and",
"evaluate,",
"but",
"also",
"requires",
"that",
"important",
"descriptions",
"and",
"documentation",
"be",
"including",
"in",
"EPA",
"work",
"products",
"developed",
"under",
"Sections",
"4-6",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"ii.",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"Evidence",
"(WoE).",
"ACC",
"suggests",
"the",
"following",
"definition:",
"Weight",
"of",
"the",
"evidence",
"means",
"a",
"systematic",
"review",
"method",
"that",
"uses",
"a",
"pre-",
"established",
"protocol",
"to",
"comprehensively,",
"objectively,",
"transparently,",
"and",
"consistently,",
"identify",
"and",
"evaluate",
"each",
"stream",
"of",
"evidence,",
"including",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"each",
"study",
"and",
"to",
"integrate",
"evidence",
"as",
"necessary",
"and",
"appropriate",
"based",
"upon",
"strengths,",
"limitations,",
"and",
"relevance.",
"ACC",
"agrees",
"that",
"the",
"term",
"WoE",
"has",
"meant",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"groups.",
"In",
"fact,",
"different",
"NAS",
"studies",
"contradict",
"themselves",
"regarding",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"this",
"term",
"and",
"inconsistently",
"define",
"its",
"meaning.",
"As",
"such,",
"it",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"EPA",
"clearly",
"explain",
"what",
"this",
"term",
"means",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"This",
"term",
"cannot",
"and",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"avoided",
"or",
"discounted",
"as",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"codifies",
"the",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"use",
"a",
"WoE",
"approach.",
"As",
"such,",
"a",
"clear",
"and",
"transparent",
"definition",
"is",
"critical",
"ACC",
"is",
"recommending",
"the",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"definition",
"that",
"is",
"in",
"the",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record.",
"This",
"is",
"the",
"definition",
"we",
"have",
"provided",
"above.",
"This",
"definition",
"is",
"also",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"June",
"2015",
"House",
"Report",
"Language.\"",
"While",
"other",
"definitions",
"exist,",
"using",
"the",
"definition",
"associated",
"with",
"LCSA",
"makes",
"the",
"most",
"sense",
"and",
"is",
"a",
"straightforward",
"approach",
"that",
"is",
"clearly",
"linked",
"to",
"the",
"intent",
"of",
"Congress.",
"Without",
"a",
"clear",
"definition,",
"WoE",
"will",
"continue",
"to",
"mean",
"different",
"things",
"to",
"different",
"experts",
"and",
"stakeholders.",
"An",
"example",
"illustrates",
"that",
"EPA",
"very",
"recently",
"has",
"not",
"interpreted",
"WoE",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"way",
"Congress",
"now",
"intends.",
"In",
"the",
"draft",
"risk",
"assessment",
"of",
"1-bromopropane",
"(released",
"prior",
"to",
"enactment",
"of",
"LCSA),",
"EPA",
"does",
"not",
"provide",
"information",
"regarding",
"the",
"quality",
"of",
"the",
"individual",
"29",
"Id.",
"30",
"See",
"generally,",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines.",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016",
"at",
"$3518.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"$3522.",
"33",
"Id",
"at",
"$3518.",
"34",
"See",
"House",
"Report,",
"at",
"33,",
"available",
"at",
"https://www.congress.gov/Ll4/crot/hump:176/CRPT.114hmt176.pdf.",
"15/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
207,
94,
297,
110
],
[
300,
93,
400,
110
],
[
404,
93,
432,
110
],
[
440,
93,
494,
110
],
[
498,
93,
521,
110
],
[
524,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
94,
724,
109
],
[
730,
94,
763,
109
],
[
768,
94,
804,
109
],
[
206,
112,
267,
125
],
[
117,
146,
134,
162
],
[
137,
146,
218,
162
],
[
222,
146,
254,
161
],
[
258,
146,
339,
161
],
[
342,
146,
382,
161
],
[
385,
146,
417,
161
],
[
421,
146,
467,
161
],
[
470,
145,
547,
161
],
[
551,
145,
609,
160
],
[
612,
145,
648,
160
],
[
654,
145,
682,
160
],
[
685,
145,
726,
160
],
[
730,
145,
787,
160
],
[
117,
163,
264,
179
],
[
267,
163,
304,
179
],
[
311,
163,
368,
179
],
[
371,
163,
415,
179
],
[
419,
163,
436,
179
],
[
439,
163,
465,
179
],
[
469,
163,
525,
179
],
[
529,
163,
567,
179
],
[
570,
163,
598,
179
],
[
602,
163,
661,
179
],
[
665,
163,
728,
179
],
[
732,
163,
757,
179
],
[
760,
163,
833,
179
],
[
837,
164,
872,
179
],
[
117,
180,
144,
195
],
[
147,
180,
204,
195
],
[
209,
180,
308,
196
],
[
312,
181,
329,
196
],
[
332,
181,
359,
196
],
[
362,
181,
399,
196
],
[
404,
181,
500,
196
],
[
504,
181,
564,
196
],
[
568,
181,
665,
196
],
[
681,
181,
698,
196
],
[
701,
180,
772,
196
],
[
775,
180,
801,
196
],
[
804,
180,
870,
196
],
[
117,
198,
134,
214
],
[
138,
198,
224,
214
],
[
227,
198,
258,
214
],
[
261,
198,
309,
214
],
[
312,
198,
334,
214
],
[
337,
198,
410,
213
],
[
412,
198,
441,
213
],
[
444,
198,
530,
213
],
[
533,
198,
550,
213
],
[
552,
198,
634,
213
],
[
637,
198,
672,
213
],
[
675,
198,
704,
214
],
[
707,
198,
782,
214
],
[
785,
197,
856,
214
],
[
859,
197,
878,
214
],
[
118,
215,
142,
231
],
[
146,
215,
199,
231
],
[
203,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
378,
231
],
[
381,
215,
406,
231
],
[
410,
215,
480,
231
],
[
490,
215,
512,
231
],
[
515,
215,
568,
231
],
[
571,
215,
582,
231
],
[
585,
215,
640,
231
],
[
644,
215,
684,
231
],
[
687,
215,
788,
231
],
[
791,
215,
823,
231
],
[
826,
216,
881,
231
],
[
117,
232,
155,
247
],
[
159,
233,
177,
248
],
[
180,
233,
228,
248
],
[
234,
233,
255,
248
],
[
258,
233,
313,
248
],
[
317,
233,
335,
248
],
[
338,
233,
370,
248
],
[
374,
233,
459,
248
],
[
462,
233,
484,
248
],
[
488,
233,
514,
248
],
[
517,
233,
577,
248
],
[
580,
233,
597,
248
],
[
601,
233,
626,
248
],
[
630,
233,
698,
248
],
[
703,
232,
737,
248
],
[
740,
232,
815,
248
],
[
819,
232,
873,
248
],
[
116,
250,
144,
265
],
[
147,
250,
184,
265
],
[
187,
250,
227,
265
],
[
230,
250,
268,
265
],
[
271,
250,
312,
265
],
[
315,
250,
383,
265
],
[
387,
250,
415,
265
],
[
420,
250,
491,
265
],
[
494,
250,
521,
265
],
[
525,
250,
558,
265
],
[
562,
250,
625,
265
],
[
629,
250,
660,
266
],
[
664,
250,
745,
266
],
[
750,
250,
843,
266
],
[
846,
250,
878,
266
],
[
120,
268,
234,
283
],
[
238,
268,
258,
283
],
[
262,
268,
337,
284
],
[
340,
268,
358,
284
],
[
362,
268,
399,
284
],
[
403,
267,
444,
284
],
[
448,
267,
522,
284
],
[
525,
267,
604,
284
],
[
607,
267,
655,
284
],
[
657,
267,
727,
284
],
[
729,
266,
757,
284
],
[
760,
266,
780,
284
],
[
782,
266,
837,
284
],
[
147,
300,
164,
315
],
[
206,
301,
265,
317
],
[
269,
303,
286,
317
],
[
290,
303,
315,
318
],
[
319,
302,
394,
318
],
[
397,
301,
455,
318
],
[
120,
337,
158,
352
],
[
162,
337,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
264,
338,
344,
353
],
[
347,
338,
428,
353
],
[
179,
371,
237,
387
],
[
241,
372,
260,
387
],
[
264,
372,
294,
387
],
[
297,
372,
370,
388
],
[
374,
373,
431,
388
],
[
434,
373,
447,
388
],
[
450,
374,
538,
388
],
[
542,
374,
596,
388
],
[
604,
373,
668,
388
],
[
672,
373,
708,
388
],
[
711,
373,
751,
387
],
[
754,
372,
767,
387
],
[
770,
372,
804,
387
],
[
177,
390,
266,
405
],
[
277,
391,
350,
405
],
[
359,
391,
378,
405
],
[
390,
391,
536,
406
],
[
544,
391,
644,
406
],
[
651,
390,
767,
405
],
[
773,
390,
804,
405
],
[
177,
407,
284,
423
],
[
288,
407,
355,
422
],
[
365,
407,
399,
422
],
[
408,
407,
478,
422
],
[
488,
407,
528,
422
],
[
540,
407,
590,
422
],
[
607,
407,
631,
422
],
[
638,
407,
721,
423
],
[
727,
407,
806,
423
],
[
177,
424,
253,
440
],
[
256,
424,
349,
440
],
[
352,
424,
382,
440
],
[
385,
424,
464,
440
],
[
468,
425,
487,
440
],
[
490,
425,
529,
440
],
[
532,
425,
577,
440
],
[
580,
425,
610,
440
],
[
613,
425,
632,
440
],
[
635,
425,
707,
441
],
[
710,
425,
783,
441
],
[
786,
425,
805,
441
],
[
176,
443,
255,
457
],
[
258,
443,
288,
457
],
[
291,
443,
381,
458
],
[
384,
443,
431,
458
],
[
434,
443,
475,
458
],
[
478,
443,
555,
458
],
[
559,
443,
651,
458
],
[
654,
443,
682,
457
],
[
686,
443,
767,
457
],
[
119,
476,
158,
491
],
[
162,
476,
213,
492
],
[
217,
476,
248,
492
],
[
251,
476,
277,
492
],
[
280,
476,
315,
492
],
[
322,
477,
362,
493
],
[
366,
477,
394,
493
],
[
397,
477,
451,
493
],
[
454,
477,
520,
493
],
[
524,
477,
573,
493
],
[
577,
477,
595,
493
],
[
600,
477,
667,
493
],
[
671,
477,
729,
493
],
[
732,
477,
751,
492
],
[
754,
477,
792,
492
],
[
795,
476,
863,
492
],
[
117,
494,
158,
509
],
[
161,
494,
218,
510
],
[
221,
495,
300,
510
],
[
303,
495,
391,
510
],
[
395,
495,
472,
510
],
[
475,
495,
501,
510
],
[
505,
495,
533,
510
],
[
537,
495,
554,
510
],
[
557,
495,
587,
510
],
[
591,
495,
625,
510
],
[
632,
495,
661,
510
],
[
664,
495,
778,
510
],
[
782,
495,
830,
509
],
[
833,
495,
854,
509
],
[
117,
512,
192,
527
],
[
196,
512,
218,
527
],
[
222,
512,
263,
527
],
[
266,
512,
279,
527
],
[
282,
512,
297,
527
],
[
301,
512,
372,
527
],
[
375,
512,
454,
527
],
[
457,
512,
488,
527
],
[
491,
512,
528,
527
],
[
533,
512,
589,
527
],
[
592,
512,
652,
527
],
[
655,
512,
694,
527
],
[
697,
512,
727,
526
],
[
730,
512,
764,
526
],
[
771,
513,
823,
526
],
[
826,
513,
842,
526
],
[
845,
513,
874,
525
],
[
120,
529,
191,
545
],
[
195,
529,
228,
545
],
[
232,
529,
267,
545
],
[
274,
529,
328,
545
],
[
332,
529,
361,
545
],
[
365,
529,
417,
545
],
[
421,
529,
447,
545
],
[
451,
529,
472,
545
],
[
476,
529,
538,
545
],
[
542,
529,
562,
545
],
[
566,
528,
649,
545
],
[
653,
528,
671,
545
],
[
675,
528,
735,
545
],
[
739,
528,
778,
545
],
[
782,
528,
798,
545
],
[
802,
528,
828,
545
],
[
831,
528,
883,
545
],
[
118,
547,
181,
562
],
[
184,
547,
209,
562
],
[
212,
547,
311,
562
],
[
314,
547,
337,
562
],
[
341,
547,
377,
563
],
[
382,
547,
400,
563
],
[
402,
547,
431,
563
],
[
434,
547,
445,
563
],
[
448,
547,
490,
563
],
[
492,
547,
577,
563
],
[
581,
547,
604,
563
],
[
607,
547,
650,
563
],
[
652,
547,
664,
562
],
[
667,
547,
707,
562
],
[
710,
548,
740,
562
],
[
742,
548,
834,
562
],
[
121,
564,
195,
579
],
[
198,
565,
213,
579
],
[
217,
565,
272,
580
],
[
119,
600,
158,
614
],
[
162,
600,
177,
614
],
[
180,
600,
299,
615
],
[
302,
600,
328,
615
],
[
331,
600,
360,
615
],
[
362,
600,
380,
615
],
[
383,
600,
411,
615
],
[
416,
600,
490,
615
],
[
494,
600,
525,
615
],
[
529,
600,
544,
615
],
[
547,
599,
562,
615
],
[
567,
599,
593,
615
],
[
597,
599,
635,
615
],
[
639,
599,
654,
615
],
[
657,
599,
698,
615
],
[
702,
599,
754,
615
],
[
758,
599,
871,
615
],
[
118,
615,
187,
631
],
[
204,
616,
238,
631
],
[
242,
616,
255,
631
],
[
259,
616,
288,
632
],
[
292,
617,
367,
632
],
[
371,
617,
394,
632
],
[
397,
617,
434,
632
],
[
438,
618,
511,
632
],
[
514,
618,
570,
632
],
[
574,
618,
611,
632
],
[
614,
617,
688,
632
],
[
692,
617,
707,
632
],
[
711,
617,
742,
632
],
[
746,
617,
827,
631
],
[
830,
616,
865,
631
],
[
118,
633,
143,
649
],
[
146,
633,
184,
649
],
[
187,
633,
228,
650
],
[
231,
634,
283,
650
],
[
286,
634,
341,
650
],
[
344,
634,
441,
650
],
[
451,
634,
500,
650
],
[
503,
634,
548,
650
],
[
551,
634,
634,
650
],
[
637,
634,
681,
650
],
[
684,
634,
728,
650
],
[
731,
634,
760,
649
],
[
764,
634,
840,
649
],
[
118,
651,
200,
667
],
[
203,
651,
238,
667
],
[
242,
651,
294,
667
],
[
297,
651,
348,
667
],
[
352,
651,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
421,
667
],
[
425,
652,
468,
667
],
[
472,
652,
501,
667
],
[
505,
652,
521,
667
],
[
524,
652,
534,
667
],
[
538,
652,
660,
667
],
[
664,
651,
736,
667
],
[
740,
651,
770,
667
],
[
774,
651,
790,
667
],
[
794,
651,
850,
667
],
[
117,
668,
168,
683
],
[
171,
668,
188,
683
],
[
192,
669,
217,
683
],
[
220,
669,
267,
684
],
[
271,
669,
290,
684
],
[
292,
669,
368,
685
],
[
120,
702,
183,
719
],
[
187,
703,
197,
719
],
[
200,
703,
242,
719
],
[
245,
703,
327,
719
],
[
330,
703,
372,
720
],
[
375,
704,
406,
720
],
[
410,
704,
479,
720
],
[
482,
704,
498,
720
],
[
501,
704,
549,
720
],
[
552,
704,
619,
720
],
[
622,
704,
671,
720
],
[
674,
704,
695,
720
],
[
698,
704,
764,
719
],
[
767,
704,
827,
719
],
[
830,
704,
857,
719
],
[
118,
721,
228,
736
],
[
231,
721,
255,
736
],
[
259,
721,
327,
736
],
[
330,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
443,
737
],
[
446,
722,
483,
737
],
[
488,
722,
524,
737
],
[
527,
722,
592,
737
],
[
595,
722,
624,
736
],
[
627,
722,
654,
736
],
[
657,
721,
746,
736
],
[
748,
721,
790,
736
],
[
792,
721,
810,
735
],
[
812,
721,
839,
735
],
[
841,
721,
885,
735
],
[
118,
739,
151,
755
],
[
155,
739,
229,
755
],
[
232,
739,
266,
754
],
[
271,
738,
340,
754
],
[
343,
738,
360,
754
],
[
363,
738,
392,
754
],
[
396,
738,
431,
754
],
[
434,
738,
466,
754
],
[
470,
738,
558,
754
],
[
562,
738,
581,
754
],
[
585,
738,
715,
755
],
[
719,
738,
791,
755
],
[
794,
739,
834,
755
],
[
838,
739,
854,
755
],
[
118,
755,
199,
771
],
[
203,
756,
221,
771
],
[
224,
756,
287,
771
],
[
291,
756,
327,
772
],
[
335,
756,
370,
772
],
[
373,
756,
400,
772
],
[
403,
756,
465,
772
],
[
468,
756,
562,
772
],
[
566,
755,
642,
772
],
[
646,
755,
671,
772
],
[
675,
755,
731,
772
],
[
735,
755,
752,
772
],
[
757,
755,
781,
771
],
[
785,
755,
868,
771
],
[
117,
821,
130,
835
],
[
131,
822,
150,
836
],
[
118,
835,
130,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
161,
836,
225,
851
],
[
228,
838,
260,
852
],
[
264,
838,
343,
852
],
[
346,
839,
397,
852
],
[
400,
838,
478,
852
],
[
132,
850,
176,
865
],
[
180,
851,
273,
866
],
[
277,
853,
330,
866
],
[
333,
853,
364,
866
],
[
367,
853,
380,
866
],
[
384,
853,
417,
866
],
[
420,
852,
434,
866
],
[
437,
852,
484,
866
],
[
117,
864,
128,
878
],
[
131,
864,
151,
879
],
[
154,
865,
167,
879
],
[
170,
866,
220,
880
],
[
118,
879,
129,
893
],
[
132,
879,
148,
893
],
[
151,
880,
164,
894
],
[
167,
880,
216,
894
],
[
118,
895,
129,
908
],
[
132,
895,
156,
908
],
[
160,
895,
202,
909
],
[
205,
895,
255,
910
],
[
258,
896,
271,
910
],
[
275,
896,
295,
910
],
[
299,
896,
358,
910
],
[
362,
896,
374,
911
],
[
377,
895,
818,
911
],
[
821,
940,
884,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
979,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the name of the second point?
|
Weight of the Evidence (WoE)
|
718
|
[
"screening",
"for",
"potential",
"endocrine",
"activity",
"has",
"not",
"yet",
"been",
"conducted",
"on",
"certain",
"compounds,",
"hazard",
"identification",
"based",
"on",
"observable",
"outcomes",
"from",
"apical",
"toxicity",
"tests",
"(e.g.,",
"outcomes",
"such",
"as",
"pathologic",
"states",
"indicative",
"of",
"disease",
"conditions)",
"covers",
"all",
"modes",
"of",
"action,",
"including",
"endocrine",
"pathways.",
"The",
"toxicity",
"information",
"evaluated",
"(CMR",
"and",
"repeat",
"dose",
"toxicity)",
"is",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to",
"evaluating",
"potential",
"hazards",
"to",
"all",
"individuals,",
"including",
"children.",
"Such",
"data",
"typically",
"includes:",
"1)",
"identification",
"and",
"definition",
"of",
"possible",
"hazards",
"upon",
"all",
"major",
"organ",
"systems",
"from",
"both",
"acute",
"and",
"repeated",
"exposures,",
"including",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"2)",
"detection",
"of",
"potential",
"hazards",
"arising",
"from",
"in",
"utero",
"exposures,",
"including",
"possible",
"effects",
"on",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"3)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"affect",
"reproduction;",
"and",
"4)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"damage",
"DNA.",
"Integration",
"of",
"Hazard",
"Elements:",
"Each",
"of",
"the",
"environmental",
"and",
"human",
"health",
"classifications",
"is",
"assigned",
"a",
"numeric",
"value",
"based",
"upon",
"its",
"ranking,",
"with",
"1",
"being",
"the",
"lowest",
"value",
"and",
"4",
"the",
"highest.",
"The",
"greatest",
"ranking",
"(highest",
"hazard",
"potential",
"score)",
"of",
"either",
"Environmental",
"or",
"Human",
"Health",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"a",
"substance-",
"specific",
"priority",
"ranking.",
"The",
"numeric",
"value",
"does",
"not",
"imply",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"but",
"rather",
"a",
"numerical",
"order",
"of",
"priority.",
"B.",
"Exposure",
"Potential",
"Ranking",
"The",
"screening",
"method",
"allows",
"for",
"an",
"initial",
"indication",
"of",
"the",
"extent",
"of",
"exposure",
"potential",
"by",
"considering:",
"1.",
"The",
"chemical's",
"uses",
"and",
"use",
"pattern(s).",
"2.",
"Production",
"volume",
"as",
"a",
"first",
"pass",
"indicator",
"of",
"relative",
"emission/release",
"potential",
"since",
"magnitude",
"and",
"route",
"(i.e.",
"air,",
"water,",
"soil)",
"of",
"emissions",
"is",
"not",
"available",
"for",
"all",
"substances.",
".",
"Persistence",
"and",
"bioaccumulation",
"characteristics",
"of",
"the",
"substance.",
"Together",
"the",
"3",
"elements",
"are",
"used",
"to",
"rank",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"1.",
"Use",
"Patterns",
"The",
"proposed",
"approach",
"applies",
"the",
"most",
"current",
"2006",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"Update",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(IUR,",
"now",
"called",
"the",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(CDR)",
"data.",
"To",
"keep",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"simple",
"and",
"transparent,",
"the",
"approach",
"\"bins\"",
"different",
"use",
"patterns",
"to",
"align",
"with",
"general",
"exposure",
"potential",
"-",
"intermediates,",
"industrial",
"use,",
"commercial",
"use",
"and",
"consumer",
"use.",
"These",
"patterns",
"are",
"the",
"same",
"as",
"those",
"reported",
"in",
"the",
"TUR",
"and",
"are",
"consistent",
"with",
"REACH",
"exposure",
"categories",
"(intermediates,",
"worker,",
"professional,",
"consumer).",
"Chemicals",
"with",
"consumer",
"product",
"use",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"widespread",
"potential",
"for",
"general",
"population",
"exposures",
"and",
"are",
"given",
"high",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"For",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally",
"(see",
"additional",
"discussion",
"below",
"under",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Considerations).",
"Intermediates",
"will",
"have",
"low",
"general",
"population",
"exposures,",
"since",
"these",
"substances",
"are",
"consumed,",
"by",
"definition,",
"within",
"the",
"workplace.",
"Therefore,",
"they",
"are",
"given",
"the",
"lowest",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"In",
"the",
"context",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"the",
"intermediates",
"category",
"includes",
"both",
"intermediates",
"and",
"non-isolated",
"intermediates.",
"A",
"chemical",
"used",
"in",
"multiple",
"use",
"patterns",
"is",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
206,
89,
282,
104
],
[
285,
89,
310,
104
],
[
313,
89,
383,
104
],
[
386,
89,
467,
104
],
[
470,
89,
529,
104
],
[
532,
89,
560,
104
],
[
563,
89,
591,
104
],
[
594,
89,
619,
104
],
[
622,
89,
661,
104
],
[
664,
89,
748,
104
],
[
751,
89,
772,
104
],
[
775,
89,
831,
103
],
[
207,
106,
302,
122
],
[
305,
106,
358,
121
],
[
362,
106,
469,
121
],
[
472,
106,
519,
121
],
[
522,
106,
544,
121
],
[
547,
106,
634,
121
],
[
637,
106,
714,
122
],
[
717,
105,
754,
122
],
[
761,
105,
809,
122
],
[
812,
105,
875,
123
],
[
208,
125,
241,
139
],
[
244,
125,
287,
139
],
[
290,
124,
367,
139
],
[
370,
124,
407,
139
],
[
411,
124,
429,
139
],
[
432,
124,
517,
139
],
[
520,
124,
565,
139
],
[
568,
124,
648,
139
],
[
651,
124,
672,
139
],
[
675,
124,
730,
139
],
[
734,
124,
824,
138
],
[
827,
124,
881,
138
],
[
205,
141,
226,
155
],
[
229,
141,
283,
155
],
[
286,
141,
304,
156
],
[
307,
141,
361,
156
],
[
365,
141,
442,
156
],
[
445,
141,
524,
156
],
[
527,
141,
608,
156
],
[
207,
160,
235,
175
],
[
238,
160,
294,
175
],
[
298,
160,
384,
175
],
[
387,
161,
457,
175
],
[
460,
161,
507,
175
],
[
511,
161,
538,
175
],
[
541,
161,
590,
175
],
[
594,
161,
624,
175
],
[
628,
161,
688,
175
],
[
692,
161,
709,
175
],
[
712,
161,
765,
175
],
[
768,
160,
828,
175
],
[
831,
160,
849,
175
],
[
208,
177,
281,
191
],
[
285,
177,
349,
191
],
[
352,
177,
408,
191
],
[
411,
177,
427,
191
],
[
431,
177,
449,
191
],
[
452,
177,
538,
191
],
[
542,
177,
611,
191
],
[
614,
176,
680,
191
],
[
683,
176,
721,
191
],
[
725,
176,
753,
191
],
[
757,
176,
821,
191
],
[
824,
176,
892,
191
],
[
895,
176,
911,
191
],
[
207,
192,
303,
207
],
[
307,
192,
337,
207
],
[
340,
192,
408,
207
],
[
411,
193,
427,
207
],
[
430,
193,
490,
207
],
[
493,
193,
550,
207
],
[
553,
193,
591,
207
],
[
594,
193,
613,
207
],
[
616,
193,
660,
207
],
[
663,
193,
705,
207
],
[
709,
193,
766,
207
],
[
770,
193,
803,
207
],
[
809,
192,
844,
207
],
[
847,
192,
885,
206
],
[
889,
192,
918,
206
],
[
205,
208,
267,
223
],
[
271,
208,
348,
223
],
[
351,
208,
420,
224
],
[
423,
208,
447,
224
],
[
450,
208,
510,
224
],
[
513,
208,
568,
224
],
[
571,
208,
591,
224
],
[
595,
208,
658,
224
],
[
661,
208,
677,
223
],
[
680,
208,
745,
223
],
[
748,
208,
804,
223
],
[
807,
208,
857,
223
],
[
861,
208,
894,
223
],
[
207,
224,
221,
239
],
[
224,
224,
262,
239
],
[
266,
224,
342,
240
],
[
346,
224,
415,
240
],
[
418,
224,
479,
240
],
[
482,
224,
532,
240
],
[
535,
224,
553,
240
],
[
557,
224,
580,
240
],
[
584,
224,
643,
240
],
[
647,
224,
702,
240
],
[
705,
224,
721,
240
],
[
725,
223,
800,
240
],
[
804,
223,
820,
239
],
[
824,
223,
888,
239
],
[
891,
223,
911,
238
],
[
207,
240,
215,
254
],
[
218,
240,
288,
255
],
[
292,
240,
308,
255
],
[
311,
240,
353,
255
],
[
357,
240,
454,
255
],
[
458,
240,
485,
255
],
[
489,
240,
505,
255
],
[
508,
240,
585,
255
],
[
588,
240,
603,
255
],
[
607,
240,
630,
255
],
[
633,
240,
698,
255
],
[
701,
240,
717,
255
],
[
721,
240,
730,
255
],
[
734,
240,
804,
255
],
[
807,
240,
825,
255
],
[
829,
240,
881,
255
],
[
207,
255,
254,
270
],
[
182,
285,
272,
299
],
[
275,
286,
293,
299
],
[
296,
286,
357,
300
],
[
360,
286,
438,
300
],
[
181,
315,
222,
330
],
[
225,
315,
243,
330
],
[
246,
315,
273,
330
],
[
276,
315,
391,
330
],
[
394,
315,
423,
330
],
[
426,
315,
482,
330
],
[
484,
315,
536,
330
],
[
539,
315,
651,
330
],
[
654,
315,
671,
330
],
[
674,
315,
742,
330
],
[
745,
315,
755,
330
],
[
758,
315,
827,
330
],
[
829,
315,
873,
330
],
[
147,
333,
192,
348
],
[
195,
333,
236,
348
],
[
240,
333,
260,
348
],
[
263,
333,
331,
348
],
[
335,
333,
371,
348
],
[
375,
333,
384,
348
],
[
387,
333,
432,
348
],
[
436,
333,
461,
348
],
[
465,
333,
519,
348
],
[
522,
333,
567,
349
],
[
570,
333,
599,
349
],
[
603,
333,
613,
349
],
[
617,
333,
642,
349
],
[
645,
333,
712,
349
],
[
715,
333,
745,
348
],
[
750,
333,
810,
348
],
[
813,
333,
876,
348
],
[
146,
350,
210,
365
],
[
214,
350,
268,
365
],
[
272,
350,
342,
366
],
[
345,
350,
394,
366
],
[
398,
350,
415,
366
],
[
420,
350,
466,
366
],
[
470,
351,
587,
366
],
[
591,
351,
608,
366
],
[
612,
350,
672,
365
],
[
675,
350,
728,
365
],
[
732,
350,
747,
365
],
[
751,
350,
787,
365
],
[
790,
350,
808,
365
],
[
811,
350,
822,
365
],
[
826,
350,
909,
365
],
[
149,
368,
208,
384
],
[
211,
368,
271,
384
],
[
275,
368,
344,
384
],
[
347,
367,
377,
384
],
[
380,
367,
448,
384
],
[
452,
367,
498,
384
],
[
502,
367,
535,
384
],
[
539,
367,
565,
384
],
[
570,
367,
615,
384
],
[
620,
367,
680,
384
],
[
684,
367,
768,
384
],
[
771,
368,
798,
384
],
[
802,
368,
850,
384
],
[
853,
368,
865,
384
],
[
146,
385,
227,
400
],
[
231,
385,
274,
400
],
[
277,
385,
294,
401
],
[
297,
385,
360,
402
],
[
147,
420,
167,
436
],
[
170,
420,
243,
436
],
[
247,
420,
317,
437
],
[
321,
420,
391,
439
],
[
187,
468,
214,
483
],
[
218,
467,
294,
483
],
[
298,
467,
358,
483
],
[
361,
467,
414,
483
],
[
418,
467,
442,
483
],
[
446,
467,
464,
483
],
[
468,
467,
515,
483
],
[
519,
467,
600,
483
],
[
604,
467,
620,
484
],
[
624,
467,
650,
484
],
[
653,
467,
704,
484
],
[
707,
467,
724,
484
],
[
728,
467,
798,
485
],
[
802,
467,
873,
485
],
[
876,
468,
898,
485
],
[
147,
486,
242,
501
],
[
177,
519,
198,
534
],
[
207,
519,
235,
534
],
[
238,
520,
317,
534
],
[
320,
521,
354,
534
],
[
357,
521,
382,
534
],
[
385,
521,
410,
534
],
[
413,
521,
485,
534
],
[
177,
535,
198,
550
],
[
205,
535,
287,
550
],
[
290,
536,
345,
550
],
[
348,
537,
363,
550
],
[
367,
537,
375,
550
],
[
378,
537,
409,
550
],
[
412,
537,
444,
550
],
[
447,
537,
514,
550
],
[
518,
538,
533,
550
],
[
536,
538,
592,
550
],
[
595,
537,
715,
550
],
[
718,
537,
784,
550
],
[
787,
536,
824,
550
],
[
827,
535,
906,
550
],
[
206,
553,
232,
566
],
[
235,
553,
274,
566
],
[
277,
553,
307,
566
],
[
310,
554,
336,
566
],
[
339,
554,
384,
566
],
[
387,
554,
420,
566
],
[
424,
554,
440,
566
],
[
443,
554,
515,
567
],
[
518,
554,
532,
567
],
[
535,
554,
560,
567
],
[
563,
553,
629,
566
],
[
632,
553,
654,
566
],
[
657,
553,
677,
566
],
[
680,
552,
758,
566
],
[
184,
568,
197,
582
],
[
204,
568,
288,
582
],
[
291,
569,
318,
582
],
[
321,
569,
442,
583
],
[
445,
570,
551,
583
],
[
554,
570,
570,
583
],
[
573,
570,
595,
583
],
[
598,
569,
677,
583
],
[
184,
596,
253,
612
],
[
257,
596,
282,
612
],
[
287,
596,
298,
612
],
[
301,
597,
372,
612
],
[
376,
597,
401,
613
],
[
404,
597,
441,
613
],
[
445,
597,
461,
613
],
[
464,
597,
503,
613
],
[
506,
597,
578,
613
],
[
581,
597,
658,
614
],
[
178,
632,
198,
647
],
[
206,
633,
234,
647
],
[
238,
633,
304,
648
],
[
184,
663,
213,
679
],
[
217,
663,
290,
679
],
[
294,
663,
368,
679
],
[
371,
663,
428,
678
],
[
432,
663,
457,
678
],
[
461,
663,
501,
678
],
[
504,
663,
561,
678
],
[
564,
663,
607,
678
],
[
611,
662,
660,
678
],
[
663,
662,
741,
679
],
[
745,
662,
802,
679
],
[
805,
662,
887,
680
],
[
147,
679,
178,
695
],
[
182,
679,
228,
695
],
[
232,
680,
266,
695
],
[
271,
680,
318,
696
],
[
322,
680,
348,
696
],
[
352,
680,
428,
696
],
[
432,
680,
470,
696
],
[
474,
680,
553,
696
],
[
557,
680,
589,
696
],
[
593,
680,
651,
696
],
[
655,
680,
692,
695
],
[
695,
680,
715,
695
],
[
719,
680,
758,
695
],
[
761,
680,
787,
695
],
[
790,
680,
838,
695
],
[
148,
698,
251,
713
],
[
254,
698,
308,
713
],
[
312,
698,
341,
713
],
[
345,
698,
438,
713
],
[
442,
698,
467,
713
],
[
471,
698,
543,
713
],
[
547,
698,
601,
713
],
[
604,
698,
671,
713
],
[
675,
698,
702,
713
],
[
705,
698,
770,
713
],
[
773,
697,
791,
713
],
[
794,
697,
835,
713
],
[
839,
697,
876,
712
],
[
148,
715,
205,
731
],
[
210,
715,
281,
731
],
[
285,
715,
355,
730
],
[
359,
715,
368,
730
],
[
372,
715,
485,
730
],
[
489,
715,
564,
730
],
[
568,
715,
600,
730
],
[
604,
715,
698,
730
],
[
702,
715,
730,
730
],
[
734,
715,
763,
730
],
[
767,
715,
844,
730
],
[
848,
715,
878,
730
],
[
149,
732,
194,
747
],
[
198,
732,
262,
748
],
[
266,
732,
290,
748
],
[
293,
732,
321,
748
],
[
324,
733,
365,
748
],
[
369,
733,
386,
748
],
[
390,
733,
431,
748
],
[
434,
733,
502,
748
],
[
505,
733,
522,
748
],
[
526,
733,
552,
748
],
[
555,
732,
590,
748
],
[
594,
732,
624,
748
],
[
628,
732,
652,
748
],
[
656,
732,
737,
748
],
[
740,
731,
777,
748
],
[
780,
731,
846,
747
],
[
148,
750,
219,
765
],
[
222,
750,
304,
765
],
[
307,
750,
426,
765
],
[
430,
750,
490,
765
],
[
493,
750,
598,
765
],
[
601,
750,
690,
765
],
[
692,
750,
778,
765
],
[
781,
750,
818,
765
],
[
821,
750,
902,
765
],
[
148,
767,
208,
782
],
[
211,
767,
238,
783
],
[
242,
767,
267,
783
],
[
271,
767,
317,
783
],
[
321,
767,
337,
783
],
[
340,
767,
381,
783
],
[
384,
767,
472,
783
],
[
475,
767,
548,
783
],
[
551,
767,
576,
783
],
[
579,
767,
638,
783
],
[
641,
767,
728,
783
],
[
730,
767,
811,
783
],
[
813,
768,
845,
783
],
[
847,
768,
874,
783
],
[
147,
785,
191,
800
],
[
194,
785,
230,
800
],
[
233,
785,
295,
801
],
[
298,
785,
361,
801
],
[
364,
785,
414,
801
],
[
418,
785,
444,
801
],
[
447,
785,
526,
801
],
[
530,
785,
557,
800
],
[
560,
785,
587,
800
],
[
590,
785,
636,
800
],
[
640,
784,
745,
800
],
[
749,
784,
825,
800
],
[
830,
784,
870,
799
],
[
150,
802,
208,
818
],
[
211,
802,
281,
818
],
[
285,
802,
311,
818
],
[
314,
802,
382,
817
],
[
386,
802,
432,
817
],
[
436,
802,
495,
817
],
[
498,
802,
576,
817
],
[
580,
802,
648,
817
],
[
652,
802,
683,
817
],
[
687,
802,
707,
817
],
[
711,
802,
788,
818
],
[
791,
802,
861,
818
],
[
864,
803,
890,
818
],
[
148,
819,
220,
835
],
[
223,
819,
282,
835
],
[
285,
819,
319,
835
],
[
322,
819,
406,
835
],
[
409,
819,
488,
835
],
[
491,
819,
541,
835
],
[
545,
819,
592,
835
],
[
595,
819,
657,
834
],
[
660,
819,
692,
834
],
[
695,
819,
824,
834
],
[
147,
836,
255,
852
],
[
259,
836,
289,
852
],
[
293,
836,
331,
852
],
[
335,
837,
365,
852
],
[
371,
837,
428,
852
],
[
431,
837,
518,
852
],
[
522,
837,
607,
852
],
[
611,
837,
651,
852
],
[
655,
837,
697,
852
],
[
701,
837,
786,
852
],
[
790,
837,
814,
852
],
[
818,
837,
904,
852
],
[
147,
854,
170,
869
],
[
175,
854,
255,
869
],
[
258,
855,
308,
869
],
[
311,
855,
338,
869
],
[
342,
855,
432,
870
],
[
435,
855,
517,
870
],
[
520,
855,
556,
870
],
[
559,
855,
585,
870
],
[
588,
855,
633,
870
],
[
637,
855,
661,
870
],
[
664,
855,
717,
870
],
[
720,
855,
781,
870
],
[
784,
855,
847,
870
],
[
850,
854,
904,
870
],
[
146,
871,
172,
886
],
[
175,
871,
253,
887
],
[
257,
871,
274,
887
],
[
278,
871,
304,
887
],
[
307,
871,
367,
887
],
[
370,
872,
387,
887
],
[
391,
872,
415,
887
],
[
420,
872,
494,
887
],
[
498,
872,
575,
887
],
[
579,
872,
604,
887
],
[
607,
872,
715,
887
],
[
718,
871,
787,
887
],
[
790,
871,
857,
887
],
[
860,
871,
899,
887
],
[
147,
889,
254,
904
],
[
257,
889,
287,
904
],
[
291,
888,
388,
905
],
[
392,
888,
506,
905
],
[
510,
888,
521,
905
],
[
527,
888,
600,
905
],
[
602,
889,
640,
905
],
[
644,
889,
661,
905
],
[
664,
889,
731,
905
],
[
734,
889,
761,
905
],
[
764,
889,
830,
905
],
[
832,
890,
850,
905
],
[
168,
924,
227,
939
],
[
231,
924,
258,
938
],
[
261,
924,
307,
939
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
293,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned in the bottom?
|
August 29, 2011
|
718
|
[
"screening",
"for",
"potential",
"endocrine",
"activity",
"has",
"not",
"yet",
"been",
"conducted",
"on",
"certain",
"compounds,",
"hazard",
"identification",
"based",
"on",
"observable",
"outcomes",
"from",
"apical",
"toxicity",
"tests",
"(e.g.,",
"outcomes",
"such",
"as",
"pathologic",
"states",
"indicative",
"of",
"disease",
"conditions)",
"covers",
"all",
"modes",
"of",
"action,",
"including",
"endocrine",
"pathways.",
"The",
"toxicity",
"information",
"evaluated",
"(CMR",
"and",
"repeat",
"dose",
"toxicity)",
"is",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to",
"evaluating",
"potential",
"hazards",
"to",
"all",
"individuals,",
"including",
"children.",
"Such",
"data",
"typically",
"includes:",
"1)",
"identification",
"and",
"definition",
"of",
"possible",
"hazards",
"upon",
"all",
"major",
"organ",
"systems",
"from",
"both",
"acute",
"and",
"repeated",
"exposures,",
"including",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"2)",
"detection",
"of",
"potential",
"hazards",
"arising",
"from",
"in",
"utero",
"exposures,",
"including",
"possible",
"effects",
"on",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"3)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"affect",
"reproduction;",
"and",
"4)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"damage",
"DNA.",
"Integration",
"of",
"Hazard",
"Elements:",
"Each",
"of",
"the",
"environmental",
"and",
"human",
"health",
"classifications",
"is",
"assigned",
"a",
"numeric",
"value",
"based",
"upon",
"its",
"ranking,",
"with",
"1",
"being",
"the",
"lowest",
"value",
"and",
"4",
"the",
"highest.",
"The",
"greatest",
"ranking",
"(highest",
"hazard",
"potential",
"score)",
"of",
"either",
"Environmental",
"or",
"Human",
"Health",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"a",
"substance-",
"specific",
"priority",
"ranking.",
"The",
"numeric",
"value",
"does",
"not",
"imply",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"but",
"rather",
"a",
"numerical",
"order",
"of",
"priority.",
"B.",
"Exposure",
"Potential",
"Ranking",
"The",
"screening",
"method",
"allows",
"for",
"an",
"initial",
"indication",
"of",
"the",
"extent",
"of",
"exposure",
"potential",
"by",
"considering:",
"1.",
"The",
"chemical's",
"uses",
"and",
"use",
"pattern(s).",
"2.",
"Production",
"volume",
"as",
"a",
"first",
"pass",
"indicator",
"of",
"relative",
"emission/release",
"potential",
"since",
"magnitude",
"and",
"route",
"(i.e.",
"air,",
"water,",
"soil)",
"of",
"emissions",
"is",
"not",
"available",
"for",
"all",
"substances.",
".",
"Persistence",
"and",
"bioaccumulation",
"characteristics",
"of",
"the",
"substance.",
"Together",
"the",
"3",
"elements",
"are",
"used",
"to",
"rank",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"1.",
"Use",
"Patterns",
"The",
"proposed",
"approach",
"applies",
"the",
"most",
"current",
"2006",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"Update",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(IUR,",
"now",
"called",
"the",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(CDR)",
"data.",
"To",
"keep",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"simple",
"and",
"transparent,",
"the",
"approach",
"\"bins\"",
"different",
"use",
"patterns",
"to",
"align",
"with",
"general",
"exposure",
"potential",
"-",
"intermediates,",
"industrial",
"use,",
"commercial",
"use",
"and",
"consumer",
"use.",
"These",
"patterns",
"are",
"the",
"same",
"as",
"those",
"reported",
"in",
"the",
"TUR",
"and",
"are",
"consistent",
"with",
"REACH",
"exposure",
"categories",
"(intermediates,",
"worker,",
"professional,",
"consumer).",
"Chemicals",
"with",
"consumer",
"product",
"use",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"widespread",
"potential",
"for",
"general",
"population",
"exposures",
"and",
"are",
"given",
"high",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"For",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally",
"(see",
"additional",
"discussion",
"below",
"under",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Considerations).",
"Intermediates",
"will",
"have",
"low",
"general",
"population",
"exposures,",
"since",
"these",
"substances",
"are",
"consumed,",
"by",
"definition,",
"within",
"the",
"workplace.",
"Therefore,",
"they",
"are",
"given",
"the",
"lowest",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"In",
"the",
"context",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"the",
"intermediates",
"category",
"includes",
"both",
"intermediates",
"and",
"non-isolated",
"intermediates.",
"A",
"chemical",
"used",
"in",
"multiple",
"use",
"patterns",
"is",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
206,
89,
282,
104
],
[
285,
89,
310,
104
],
[
313,
89,
383,
104
],
[
386,
89,
467,
104
],
[
470,
89,
529,
104
],
[
532,
89,
560,
104
],
[
563,
89,
591,
104
],
[
594,
89,
619,
104
],
[
622,
89,
661,
104
],
[
664,
89,
748,
104
],
[
751,
89,
772,
104
],
[
775,
89,
831,
103
],
[
207,
106,
302,
122
],
[
305,
106,
358,
121
],
[
362,
106,
469,
121
],
[
472,
106,
519,
121
],
[
522,
106,
544,
121
],
[
547,
106,
634,
121
],
[
637,
106,
714,
122
],
[
717,
105,
754,
122
],
[
761,
105,
809,
122
],
[
812,
105,
875,
123
],
[
208,
125,
241,
139
],
[
244,
125,
287,
139
],
[
290,
124,
367,
139
],
[
370,
124,
407,
139
],
[
411,
124,
429,
139
],
[
432,
124,
517,
139
],
[
520,
124,
565,
139
],
[
568,
124,
648,
139
],
[
651,
124,
672,
139
],
[
675,
124,
730,
139
],
[
734,
124,
824,
138
],
[
827,
124,
881,
138
],
[
205,
141,
226,
155
],
[
229,
141,
283,
155
],
[
286,
141,
304,
156
],
[
307,
141,
361,
156
],
[
365,
141,
442,
156
],
[
445,
141,
524,
156
],
[
527,
141,
608,
156
],
[
207,
160,
235,
175
],
[
238,
160,
294,
175
],
[
298,
160,
384,
175
],
[
387,
161,
457,
175
],
[
460,
161,
507,
175
],
[
511,
161,
538,
175
],
[
541,
161,
590,
175
],
[
594,
161,
624,
175
],
[
628,
161,
688,
175
],
[
692,
161,
709,
175
],
[
712,
161,
765,
175
],
[
768,
160,
828,
175
],
[
831,
160,
849,
175
],
[
208,
177,
281,
191
],
[
285,
177,
349,
191
],
[
352,
177,
408,
191
],
[
411,
177,
427,
191
],
[
431,
177,
449,
191
],
[
452,
177,
538,
191
],
[
542,
177,
611,
191
],
[
614,
176,
680,
191
],
[
683,
176,
721,
191
],
[
725,
176,
753,
191
],
[
757,
176,
821,
191
],
[
824,
176,
892,
191
],
[
895,
176,
911,
191
],
[
207,
192,
303,
207
],
[
307,
192,
337,
207
],
[
340,
192,
408,
207
],
[
411,
193,
427,
207
],
[
430,
193,
490,
207
],
[
493,
193,
550,
207
],
[
553,
193,
591,
207
],
[
594,
193,
613,
207
],
[
616,
193,
660,
207
],
[
663,
193,
705,
207
],
[
709,
193,
766,
207
],
[
770,
193,
803,
207
],
[
809,
192,
844,
207
],
[
847,
192,
885,
206
],
[
889,
192,
918,
206
],
[
205,
208,
267,
223
],
[
271,
208,
348,
223
],
[
351,
208,
420,
224
],
[
423,
208,
447,
224
],
[
450,
208,
510,
224
],
[
513,
208,
568,
224
],
[
571,
208,
591,
224
],
[
595,
208,
658,
224
],
[
661,
208,
677,
223
],
[
680,
208,
745,
223
],
[
748,
208,
804,
223
],
[
807,
208,
857,
223
],
[
861,
208,
894,
223
],
[
207,
224,
221,
239
],
[
224,
224,
262,
239
],
[
266,
224,
342,
240
],
[
346,
224,
415,
240
],
[
418,
224,
479,
240
],
[
482,
224,
532,
240
],
[
535,
224,
553,
240
],
[
557,
224,
580,
240
],
[
584,
224,
643,
240
],
[
647,
224,
702,
240
],
[
705,
224,
721,
240
],
[
725,
223,
800,
240
],
[
804,
223,
820,
239
],
[
824,
223,
888,
239
],
[
891,
223,
911,
238
],
[
207,
240,
215,
254
],
[
218,
240,
288,
255
],
[
292,
240,
308,
255
],
[
311,
240,
353,
255
],
[
357,
240,
454,
255
],
[
458,
240,
485,
255
],
[
489,
240,
505,
255
],
[
508,
240,
585,
255
],
[
588,
240,
603,
255
],
[
607,
240,
630,
255
],
[
633,
240,
698,
255
],
[
701,
240,
717,
255
],
[
721,
240,
730,
255
],
[
734,
240,
804,
255
],
[
807,
240,
825,
255
],
[
829,
240,
881,
255
],
[
207,
255,
254,
270
],
[
182,
285,
272,
299
],
[
275,
286,
293,
299
],
[
296,
286,
357,
300
],
[
360,
286,
438,
300
],
[
181,
315,
222,
330
],
[
225,
315,
243,
330
],
[
246,
315,
273,
330
],
[
276,
315,
391,
330
],
[
394,
315,
423,
330
],
[
426,
315,
482,
330
],
[
484,
315,
536,
330
],
[
539,
315,
651,
330
],
[
654,
315,
671,
330
],
[
674,
315,
742,
330
],
[
745,
315,
755,
330
],
[
758,
315,
827,
330
],
[
829,
315,
873,
330
],
[
147,
333,
192,
348
],
[
195,
333,
236,
348
],
[
240,
333,
260,
348
],
[
263,
333,
331,
348
],
[
335,
333,
371,
348
],
[
375,
333,
384,
348
],
[
387,
333,
432,
348
],
[
436,
333,
461,
348
],
[
465,
333,
519,
348
],
[
522,
333,
567,
349
],
[
570,
333,
599,
349
],
[
603,
333,
613,
349
],
[
617,
333,
642,
349
],
[
645,
333,
712,
349
],
[
715,
333,
745,
348
],
[
750,
333,
810,
348
],
[
813,
333,
876,
348
],
[
146,
350,
210,
365
],
[
214,
350,
268,
365
],
[
272,
350,
342,
366
],
[
345,
350,
394,
366
],
[
398,
350,
415,
366
],
[
420,
350,
466,
366
],
[
470,
351,
587,
366
],
[
591,
351,
608,
366
],
[
612,
350,
672,
365
],
[
675,
350,
728,
365
],
[
732,
350,
747,
365
],
[
751,
350,
787,
365
],
[
790,
350,
808,
365
],
[
811,
350,
822,
365
],
[
826,
350,
909,
365
],
[
149,
368,
208,
384
],
[
211,
368,
271,
384
],
[
275,
368,
344,
384
],
[
347,
367,
377,
384
],
[
380,
367,
448,
384
],
[
452,
367,
498,
384
],
[
502,
367,
535,
384
],
[
539,
367,
565,
384
],
[
570,
367,
615,
384
],
[
620,
367,
680,
384
],
[
684,
367,
768,
384
],
[
771,
368,
798,
384
],
[
802,
368,
850,
384
],
[
853,
368,
865,
384
],
[
146,
385,
227,
400
],
[
231,
385,
274,
400
],
[
277,
385,
294,
401
],
[
297,
385,
360,
402
],
[
147,
420,
167,
436
],
[
170,
420,
243,
436
],
[
247,
420,
317,
437
],
[
321,
420,
391,
439
],
[
187,
468,
214,
483
],
[
218,
467,
294,
483
],
[
298,
467,
358,
483
],
[
361,
467,
414,
483
],
[
418,
467,
442,
483
],
[
446,
467,
464,
483
],
[
468,
467,
515,
483
],
[
519,
467,
600,
483
],
[
604,
467,
620,
484
],
[
624,
467,
650,
484
],
[
653,
467,
704,
484
],
[
707,
467,
724,
484
],
[
728,
467,
798,
485
],
[
802,
467,
873,
485
],
[
876,
468,
898,
485
],
[
147,
486,
242,
501
],
[
177,
519,
198,
534
],
[
207,
519,
235,
534
],
[
238,
520,
317,
534
],
[
320,
521,
354,
534
],
[
357,
521,
382,
534
],
[
385,
521,
410,
534
],
[
413,
521,
485,
534
],
[
177,
535,
198,
550
],
[
205,
535,
287,
550
],
[
290,
536,
345,
550
],
[
348,
537,
363,
550
],
[
367,
537,
375,
550
],
[
378,
537,
409,
550
],
[
412,
537,
444,
550
],
[
447,
537,
514,
550
],
[
518,
538,
533,
550
],
[
536,
538,
592,
550
],
[
595,
537,
715,
550
],
[
718,
537,
784,
550
],
[
787,
536,
824,
550
],
[
827,
535,
906,
550
],
[
206,
553,
232,
566
],
[
235,
553,
274,
566
],
[
277,
553,
307,
566
],
[
310,
554,
336,
566
],
[
339,
554,
384,
566
],
[
387,
554,
420,
566
],
[
424,
554,
440,
566
],
[
443,
554,
515,
567
],
[
518,
554,
532,
567
],
[
535,
554,
560,
567
],
[
563,
553,
629,
566
],
[
632,
553,
654,
566
],
[
657,
553,
677,
566
],
[
680,
552,
758,
566
],
[
184,
568,
197,
582
],
[
204,
568,
288,
582
],
[
291,
569,
318,
582
],
[
321,
569,
442,
583
],
[
445,
570,
551,
583
],
[
554,
570,
570,
583
],
[
573,
570,
595,
583
],
[
598,
569,
677,
583
],
[
184,
596,
253,
612
],
[
257,
596,
282,
612
],
[
287,
596,
298,
612
],
[
301,
597,
372,
612
],
[
376,
597,
401,
613
],
[
404,
597,
441,
613
],
[
445,
597,
461,
613
],
[
464,
597,
503,
613
],
[
506,
597,
578,
613
],
[
581,
597,
658,
614
],
[
178,
632,
198,
647
],
[
206,
633,
234,
647
],
[
238,
633,
304,
648
],
[
184,
663,
213,
679
],
[
217,
663,
290,
679
],
[
294,
663,
368,
679
],
[
371,
663,
428,
678
],
[
432,
663,
457,
678
],
[
461,
663,
501,
678
],
[
504,
663,
561,
678
],
[
564,
663,
607,
678
],
[
611,
662,
660,
678
],
[
663,
662,
741,
679
],
[
745,
662,
802,
679
],
[
805,
662,
887,
680
],
[
147,
679,
178,
695
],
[
182,
679,
228,
695
],
[
232,
680,
266,
695
],
[
271,
680,
318,
696
],
[
322,
680,
348,
696
],
[
352,
680,
428,
696
],
[
432,
680,
470,
696
],
[
474,
680,
553,
696
],
[
557,
680,
589,
696
],
[
593,
680,
651,
696
],
[
655,
680,
692,
695
],
[
695,
680,
715,
695
],
[
719,
680,
758,
695
],
[
761,
680,
787,
695
],
[
790,
680,
838,
695
],
[
148,
698,
251,
713
],
[
254,
698,
308,
713
],
[
312,
698,
341,
713
],
[
345,
698,
438,
713
],
[
442,
698,
467,
713
],
[
471,
698,
543,
713
],
[
547,
698,
601,
713
],
[
604,
698,
671,
713
],
[
675,
698,
702,
713
],
[
705,
698,
770,
713
],
[
773,
697,
791,
713
],
[
794,
697,
835,
713
],
[
839,
697,
876,
712
],
[
148,
715,
205,
731
],
[
210,
715,
281,
731
],
[
285,
715,
355,
730
],
[
359,
715,
368,
730
],
[
372,
715,
485,
730
],
[
489,
715,
564,
730
],
[
568,
715,
600,
730
],
[
604,
715,
698,
730
],
[
702,
715,
730,
730
],
[
734,
715,
763,
730
],
[
767,
715,
844,
730
],
[
848,
715,
878,
730
],
[
149,
732,
194,
747
],
[
198,
732,
262,
748
],
[
266,
732,
290,
748
],
[
293,
732,
321,
748
],
[
324,
733,
365,
748
],
[
369,
733,
386,
748
],
[
390,
733,
431,
748
],
[
434,
733,
502,
748
],
[
505,
733,
522,
748
],
[
526,
733,
552,
748
],
[
555,
732,
590,
748
],
[
594,
732,
624,
748
],
[
628,
732,
652,
748
],
[
656,
732,
737,
748
],
[
740,
731,
777,
748
],
[
780,
731,
846,
747
],
[
148,
750,
219,
765
],
[
222,
750,
304,
765
],
[
307,
750,
426,
765
],
[
430,
750,
490,
765
],
[
493,
750,
598,
765
],
[
601,
750,
690,
765
],
[
692,
750,
778,
765
],
[
781,
750,
818,
765
],
[
821,
750,
902,
765
],
[
148,
767,
208,
782
],
[
211,
767,
238,
783
],
[
242,
767,
267,
783
],
[
271,
767,
317,
783
],
[
321,
767,
337,
783
],
[
340,
767,
381,
783
],
[
384,
767,
472,
783
],
[
475,
767,
548,
783
],
[
551,
767,
576,
783
],
[
579,
767,
638,
783
],
[
641,
767,
728,
783
],
[
730,
767,
811,
783
],
[
813,
768,
845,
783
],
[
847,
768,
874,
783
],
[
147,
785,
191,
800
],
[
194,
785,
230,
800
],
[
233,
785,
295,
801
],
[
298,
785,
361,
801
],
[
364,
785,
414,
801
],
[
418,
785,
444,
801
],
[
447,
785,
526,
801
],
[
530,
785,
557,
800
],
[
560,
785,
587,
800
],
[
590,
785,
636,
800
],
[
640,
784,
745,
800
],
[
749,
784,
825,
800
],
[
830,
784,
870,
799
],
[
150,
802,
208,
818
],
[
211,
802,
281,
818
],
[
285,
802,
311,
818
],
[
314,
802,
382,
817
],
[
386,
802,
432,
817
],
[
436,
802,
495,
817
],
[
498,
802,
576,
817
],
[
580,
802,
648,
817
],
[
652,
802,
683,
817
],
[
687,
802,
707,
817
],
[
711,
802,
788,
818
],
[
791,
802,
861,
818
],
[
864,
803,
890,
818
],
[
148,
819,
220,
835
],
[
223,
819,
282,
835
],
[
285,
819,
319,
835
],
[
322,
819,
406,
835
],
[
409,
819,
488,
835
],
[
491,
819,
541,
835
],
[
545,
819,
592,
835
],
[
595,
819,
657,
834
],
[
660,
819,
692,
834
],
[
695,
819,
824,
834
],
[
147,
836,
255,
852
],
[
259,
836,
289,
852
],
[
293,
836,
331,
852
],
[
335,
837,
365,
852
],
[
371,
837,
428,
852
],
[
431,
837,
518,
852
],
[
522,
837,
607,
852
],
[
611,
837,
651,
852
],
[
655,
837,
697,
852
],
[
701,
837,
786,
852
],
[
790,
837,
814,
852
],
[
818,
837,
904,
852
],
[
147,
854,
170,
869
],
[
175,
854,
255,
869
],
[
258,
855,
308,
869
],
[
311,
855,
338,
869
],
[
342,
855,
432,
870
],
[
435,
855,
517,
870
],
[
520,
855,
556,
870
],
[
559,
855,
585,
870
],
[
588,
855,
633,
870
],
[
637,
855,
661,
870
],
[
664,
855,
717,
870
],
[
720,
855,
781,
870
],
[
784,
855,
847,
870
],
[
850,
854,
904,
870
],
[
146,
871,
172,
886
],
[
175,
871,
253,
887
],
[
257,
871,
274,
887
],
[
278,
871,
304,
887
],
[
307,
871,
367,
887
],
[
370,
872,
387,
887
],
[
391,
872,
415,
887
],
[
420,
872,
494,
887
],
[
498,
872,
575,
887
],
[
579,
872,
604,
887
],
[
607,
872,
715,
887
],
[
718,
871,
787,
887
],
[
790,
871,
857,
887
],
[
860,
871,
899,
887
],
[
147,
889,
254,
904
],
[
257,
889,
287,
904
],
[
291,
888,
388,
905
],
[
392,
888,
506,
905
],
[
510,
888,
521,
905
],
[
527,
888,
600,
905
],
[
602,
889,
640,
905
],
[
644,
889,
661,
905
],
[
664,
889,
731,
905
],
[
734,
889,
761,
905
],
[
764,
889,
830,
905
],
[
832,
890,
850,
905
],
[
168,
924,
227,
939
],
[
231,
924,
258,
938
],
[
261,
924,
307,
939
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
293,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the heading of the point B?
|
Exposure Potential Ranking
|
718
|
[
"screening",
"for",
"potential",
"endocrine",
"activity",
"has",
"not",
"yet",
"been",
"conducted",
"on",
"certain",
"compounds,",
"hazard",
"identification",
"based",
"on",
"observable",
"outcomes",
"from",
"apical",
"toxicity",
"tests",
"(e.g.,",
"outcomes",
"such",
"as",
"pathologic",
"states",
"indicative",
"of",
"disease",
"conditions)",
"covers",
"all",
"modes",
"of",
"action,",
"including",
"endocrine",
"pathways.",
"The",
"toxicity",
"information",
"evaluated",
"(CMR",
"and",
"repeat",
"dose",
"toxicity)",
"is",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to",
"evaluating",
"potential",
"hazards",
"to",
"all",
"individuals,",
"including",
"children.",
"Such",
"data",
"typically",
"includes:",
"1)",
"identification",
"and",
"definition",
"of",
"possible",
"hazards",
"upon",
"all",
"major",
"organ",
"systems",
"from",
"both",
"acute",
"and",
"repeated",
"exposures,",
"including",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"2)",
"detection",
"of",
"potential",
"hazards",
"arising",
"from",
"in",
"utero",
"exposures,",
"including",
"possible",
"effects",
"on",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"3)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"affect",
"reproduction;",
"and",
"4)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"damage",
"DNA.",
"Integration",
"of",
"Hazard",
"Elements:",
"Each",
"of",
"the",
"environmental",
"and",
"human",
"health",
"classifications",
"is",
"assigned",
"a",
"numeric",
"value",
"based",
"upon",
"its",
"ranking,",
"with",
"1",
"being",
"the",
"lowest",
"value",
"and",
"4",
"the",
"highest.",
"The",
"greatest",
"ranking",
"(highest",
"hazard",
"potential",
"score)",
"of",
"either",
"Environmental",
"or",
"Human",
"Health",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"a",
"substance-",
"specific",
"priority",
"ranking.",
"The",
"numeric",
"value",
"does",
"not",
"imply",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"but",
"rather",
"a",
"numerical",
"order",
"of",
"priority.",
"B.",
"Exposure",
"Potential",
"Ranking",
"The",
"screening",
"method",
"allows",
"for",
"an",
"initial",
"indication",
"of",
"the",
"extent",
"of",
"exposure",
"potential",
"by",
"considering:",
"1.",
"The",
"chemical's",
"uses",
"and",
"use",
"pattern(s).",
"2.",
"Production",
"volume",
"as",
"a",
"first",
"pass",
"indicator",
"of",
"relative",
"emission/release",
"potential",
"since",
"magnitude",
"and",
"route",
"(i.e.",
"air,",
"water,",
"soil)",
"of",
"emissions",
"is",
"not",
"available",
"for",
"all",
"substances.",
".",
"Persistence",
"and",
"bioaccumulation",
"characteristics",
"of",
"the",
"substance.",
"Together",
"the",
"3",
"elements",
"are",
"used",
"to",
"rank",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"1.",
"Use",
"Patterns",
"The",
"proposed",
"approach",
"applies",
"the",
"most",
"current",
"2006",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"Update",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(IUR,",
"now",
"called",
"the",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(CDR)",
"data.",
"To",
"keep",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"simple",
"and",
"transparent,",
"the",
"approach",
"\"bins\"",
"different",
"use",
"patterns",
"to",
"align",
"with",
"general",
"exposure",
"potential",
"-",
"intermediates,",
"industrial",
"use,",
"commercial",
"use",
"and",
"consumer",
"use.",
"These",
"patterns",
"are",
"the",
"same",
"as",
"those",
"reported",
"in",
"the",
"TUR",
"and",
"are",
"consistent",
"with",
"REACH",
"exposure",
"categories",
"(intermediates,",
"worker,",
"professional,",
"consumer).",
"Chemicals",
"with",
"consumer",
"product",
"use",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"widespread",
"potential",
"for",
"general",
"population",
"exposures",
"and",
"are",
"given",
"high",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"For",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally",
"(see",
"additional",
"discussion",
"below",
"under",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Considerations).",
"Intermediates",
"will",
"have",
"low",
"general",
"population",
"exposures,",
"since",
"these",
"substances",
"are",
"consumed,",
"by",
"definition,",
"within",
"the",
"workplace.",
"Therefore,",
"they",
"are",
"given",
"the",
"lowest",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"In",
"the",
"context",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"the",
"intermediates",
"category",
"includes",
"both",
"intermediates",
"and",
"non-isolated",
"intermediates.",
"A",
"chemical",
"used",
"in",
"multiple",
"use",
"patterns",
"is",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
206,
89,
282,
104
],
[
285,
89,
310,
104
],
[
313,
89,
383,
104
],
[
386,
89,
467,
104
],
[
470,
89,
529,
104
],
[
532,
89,
560,
104
],
[
563,
89,
591,
104
],
[
594,
89,
619,
104
],
[
622,
89,
661,
104
],
[
664,
89,
748,
104
],
[
751,
89,
772,
104
],
[
775,
89,
831,
103
],
[
207,
106,
302,
122
],
[
305,
106,
358,
121
],
[
362,
106,
469,
121
],
[
472,
106,
519,
121
],
[
522,
106,
544,
121
],
[
547,
106,
634,
121
],
[
637,
106,
714,
122
],
[
717,
105,
754,
122
],
[
761,
105,
809,
122
],
[
812,
105,
875,
123
],
[
208,
125,
241,
139
],
[
244,
125,
287,
139
],
[
290,
124,
367,
139
],
[
370,
124,
407,
139
],
[
411,
124,
429,
139
],
[
432,
124,
517,
139
],
[
520,
124,
565,
139
],
[
568,
124,
648,
139
],
[
651,
124,
672,
139
],
[
675,
124,
730,
139
],
[
734,
124,
824,
138
],
[
827,
124,
881,
138
],
[
205,
141,
226,
155
],
[
229,
141,
283,
155
],
[
286,
141,
304,
156
],
[
307,
141,
361,
156
],
[
365,
141,
442,
156
],
[
445,
141,
524,
156
],
[
527,
141,
608,
156
],
[
207,
160,
235,
175
],
[
238,
160,
294,
175
],
[
298,
160,
384,
175
],
[
387,
161,
457,
175
],
[
460,
161,
507,
175
],
[
511,
161,
538,
175
],
[
541,
161,
590,
175
],
[
594,
161,
624,
175
],
[
628,
161,
688,
175
],
[
692,
161,
709,
175
],
[
712,
161,
765,
175
],
[
768,
160,
828,
175
],
[
831,
160,
849,
175
],
[
208,
177,
281,
191
],
[
285,
177,
349,
191
],
[
352,
177,
408,
191
],
[
411,
177,
427,
191
],
[
431,
177,
449,
191
],
[
452,
177,
538,
191
],
[
542,
177,
611,
191
],
[
614,
176,
680,
191
],
[
683,
176,
721,
191
],
[
725,
176,
753,
191
],
[
757,
176,
821,
191
],
[
824,
176,
892,
191
],
[
895,
176,
911,
191
],
[
207,
192,
303,
207
],
[
307,
192,
337,
207
],
[
340,
192,
408,
207
],
[
411,
193,
427,
207
],
[
430,
193,
490,
207
],
[
493,
193,
550,
207
],
[
553,
193,
591,
207
],
[
594,
193,
613,
207
],
[
616,
193,
660,
207
],
[
663,
193,
705,
207
],
[
709,
193,
766,
207
],
[
770,
193,
803,
207
],
[
809,
192,
844,
207
],
[
847,
192,
885,
206
],
[
889,
192,
918,
206
],
[
205,
208,
267,
223
],
[
271,
208,
348,
223
],
[
351,
208,
420,
224
],
[
423,
208,
447,
224
],
[
450,
208,
510,
224
],
[
513,
208,
568,
224
],
[
571,
208,
591,
224
],
[
595,
208,
658,
224
],
[
661,
208,
677,
223
],
[
680,
208,
745,
223
],
[
748,
208,
804,
223
],
[
807,
208,
857,
223
],
[
861,
208,
894,
223
],
[
207,
224,
221,
239
],
[
224,
224,
262,
239
],
[
266,
224,
342,
240
],
[
346,
224,
415,
240
],
[
418,
224,
479,
240
],
[
482,
224,
532,
240
],
[
535,
224,
553,
240
],
[
557,
224,
580,
240
],
[
584,
224,
643,
240
],
[
647,
224,
702,
240
],
[
705,
224,
721,
240
],
[
725,
223,
800,
240
],
[
804,
223,
820,
239
],
[
824,
223,
888,
239
],
[
891,
223,
911,
238
],
[
207,
240,
215,
254
],
[
218,
240,
288,
255
],
[
292,
240,
308,
255
],
[
311,
240,
353,
255
],
[
357,
240,
454,
255
],
[
458,
240,
485,
255
],
[
489,
240,
505,
255
],
[
508,
240,
585,
255
],
[
588,
240,
603,
255
],
[
607,
240,
630,
255
],
[
633,
240,
698,
255
],
[
701,
240,
717,
255
],
[
721,
240,
730,
255
],
[
734,
240,
804,
255
],
[
807,
240,
825,
255
],
[
829,
240,
881,
255
],
[
207,
255,
254,
270
],
[
182,
285,
272,
299
],
[
275,
286,
293,
299
],
[
296,
286,
357,
300
],
[
360,
286,
438,
300
],
[
181,
315,
222,
330
],
[
225,
315,
243,
330
],
[
246,
315,
273,
330
],
[
276,
315,
391,
330
],
[
394,
315,
423,
330
],
[
426,
315,
482,
330
],
[
484,
315,
536,
330
],
[
539,
315,
651,
330
],
[
654,
315,
671,
330
],
[
674,
315,
742,
330
],
[
745,
315,
755,
330
],
[
758,
315,
827,
330
],
[
829,
315,
873,
330
],
[
147,
333,
192,
348
],
[
195,
333,
236,
348
],
[
240,
333,
260,
348
],
[
263,
333,
331,
348
],
[
335,
333,
371,
348
],
[
375,
333,
384,
348
],
[
387,
333,
432,
348
],
[
436,
333,
461,
348
],
[
465,
333,
519,
348
],
[
522,
333,
567,
349
],
[
570,
333,
599,
349
],
[
603,
333,
613,
349
],
[
617,
333,
642,
349
],
[
645,
333,
712,
349
],
[
715,
333,
745,
348
],
[
750,
333,
810,
348
],
[
813,
333,
876,
348
],
[
146,
350,
210,
365
],
[
214,
350,
268,
365
],
[
272,
350,
342,
366
],
[
345,
350,
394,
366
],
[
398,
350,
415,
366
],
[
420,
350,
466,
366
],
[
470,
351,
587,
366
],
[
591,
351,
608,
366
],
[
612,
350,
672,
365
],
[
675,
350,
728,
365
],
[
732,
350,
747,
365
],
[
751,
350,
787,
365
],
[
790,
350,
808,
365
],
[
811,
350,
822,
365
],
[
826,
350,
909,
365
],
[
149,
368,
208,
384
],
[
211,
368,
271,
384
],
[
275,
368,
344,
384
],
[
347,
367,
377,
384
],
[
380,
367,
448,
384
],
[
452,
367,
498,
384
],
[
502,
367,
535,
384
],
[
539,
367,
565,
384
],
[
570,
367,
615,
384
],
[
620,
367,
680,
384
],
[
684,
367,
768,
384
],
[
771,
368,
798,
384
],
[
802,
368,
850,
384
],
[
853,
368,
865,
384
],
[
146,
385,
227,
400
],
[
231,
385,
274,
400
],
[
277,
385,
294,
401
],
[
297,
385,
360,
402
],
[
147,
420,
167,
436
],
[
170,
420,
243,
436
],
[
247,
420,
317,
437
],
[
321,
420,
391,
439
],
[
187,
468,
214,
483
],
[
218,
467,
294,
483
],
[
298,
467,
358,
483
],
[
361,
467,
414,
483
],
[
418,
467,
442,
483
],
[
446,
467,
464,
483
],
[
468,
467,
515,
483
],
[
519,
467,
600,
483
],
[
604,
467,
620,
484
],
[
624,
467,
650,
484
],
[
653,
467,
704,
484
],
[
707,
467,
724,
484
],
[
728,
467,
798,
485
],
[
802,
467,
873,
485
],
[
876,
468,
898,
485
],
[
147,
486,
242,
501
],
[
177,
519,
198,
534
],
[
207,
519,
235,
534
],
[
238,
520,
317,
534
],
[
320,
521,
354,
534
],
[
357,
521,
382,
534
],
[
385,
521,
410,
534
],
[
413,
521,
485,
534
],
[
177,
535,
198,
550
],
[
205,
535,
287,
550
],
[
290,
536,
345,
550
],
[
348,
537,
363,
550
],
[
367,
537,
375,
550
],
[
378,
537,
409,
550
],
[
412,
537,
444,
550
],
[
447,
537,
514,
550
],
[
518,
538,
533,
550
],
[
536,
538,
592,
550
],
[
595,
537,
715,
550
],
[
718,
537,
784,
550
],
[
787,
536,
824,
550
],
[
827,
535,
906,
550
],
[
206,
553,
232,
566
],
[
235,
553,
274,
566
],
[
277,
553,
307,
566
],
[
310,
554,
336,
566
],
[
339,
554,
384,
566
],
[
387,
554,
420,
566
],
[
424,
554,
440,
566
],
[
443,
554,
515,
567
],
[
518,
554,
532,
567
],
[
535,
554,
560,
567
],
[
563,
553,
629,
566
],
[
632,
553,
654,
566
],
[
657,
553,
677,
566
],
[
680,
552,
758,
566
],
[
184,
568,
197,
582
],
[
204,
568,
288,
582
],
[
291,
569,
318,
582
],
[
321,
569,
442,
583
],
[
445,
570,
551,
583
],
[
554,
570,
570,
583
],
[
573,
570,
595,
583
],
[
598,
569,
677,
583
],
[
184,
596,
253,
612
],
[
257,
596,
282,
612
],
[
287,
596,
298,
612
],
[
301,
597,
372,
612
],
[
376,
597,
401,
613
],
[
404,
597,
441,
613
],
[
445,
597,
461,
613
],
[
464,
597,
503,
613
],
[
506,
597,
578,
613
],
[
581,
597,
658,
614
],
[
178,
632,
198,
647
],
[
206,
633,
234,
647
],
[
238,
633,
304,
648
],
[
184,
663,
213,
679
],
[
217,
663,
290,
679
],
[
294,
663,
368,
679
],
[
371,
663,
428,
678
],
[
432,
663,
457,
678
],
[
461,
663,
501,
678
],
[
504,
663,
561,
678
],
[
564,
663,
607,
678
],
[
611,
662,
660,
678
],
[
663,
662,
741,
679
],
[
745,
662,
802,
679
],
[
805,
662,
887,
680
],
[
147,
679,
178,
695
],
[
182,
679,
228,
695
],
[
232,
680,
266,
695
],
[
271,
680,
318,
696
],
[
322,
680,
348,
696
],
[
352,
680,
428,
696
],
[
432,
680,
470,
696
],
[
474,
680,
553,
696
],
[
557,
680,
589,
696
],
[
593,
680,
651,
696
],
[
655,
680,
692,
695
],
[
695,
680,
715,
695
],
[
719,
680,
758,
695
],
[
761,
680,
787,
695
],
[
790,
680,
838,
695
],
[
148,
698,
251,
713
],
[
254,
698,
308,
713
],
[
312,
698,
341,
713
],
[
345,
698,
438,
713
],
[
442,
698,
467,
713
],
[
471,
698,
543,
713
],
[
547,
698,
601,
713
],
[
604,
698,
671,
713
],
[
675,
698,
702,
713
],
[
705,
698,
770,
713
],
[
773,
697,
791,
713
],
[
794,
697,
835,
713
],
[
839,
697,
876,
712
],
[
148,
715,
205,
731
],
[
210,
715,
281,
731
],
[
285,
715,
355,
730
],
[
359,
715,
368,
730
],
[
372,
715,
485,
730
],
[
489,
715,
564,
730
],
[
568,
715,
600,
730
],
[
604,
715,
698,
730
],
[
702,
715,
730,
730
],
[
734,
715,
763,
730
],
[
767,
715,
844,
730
],
[
848,
715,
878,
730
],
[
149,
732,
194,
747
],
[
198,
732,
262,
748
],
[
266,
732,
290,
748
],
[
293,
732,
321,
748
],
[
324,
733,
365,
748
],
[
369,
733,
386,
748
],
[
390,
733,
431,
748
],
[
434,
733,
502,
748
],
[
505,
733,
522,
748
],
[
526,
733,
552,
748
],
[
555,
732,
590,
748
],
[
594,
732,
624,
748
],
[
628,
732,
652,
748
],
[
656,
732,
737,
748
],
[
740,
731,
777,
748
],
[
780,
731,
846,
747
],
[
148,
750,
219,
765
],
[
222,
750,
304,
765
],
[
307,
750,
426,
765
],
[
430,
750,
490,
765
],
[
493,
750,
598,
765
],
[
601,
750,
690,
765
],
[
692,
750,
778,
765
],
[
781,
750,
818,
765
],
[
821,
750,
902,
765
],
[
148,
767,
208,
782
],
[
211,
767,
238,
783
],
[
242,
767,
267,
783
],
[
271,
767,
317,
783
],
[
321,
767,
337,
783
],
[
340,
767,
381,
783
],
[
384,
767,
472,
783
],
[
475,
767,
548,
783
],
[
551,
767,
576,
783
],
[
579,
767,
638,
783
],
[
641,
767,
728,
783
],
[
730,
767,
811,
783
],
[
813,
768,
845,
783
],
[
847,
768,
874,
783
],
[
147,
785,
191,
800
],
[
194,
785,
230,
800
],
[
233,
785,
295,
801
],
[
298,
785,
361,
801
],
[
364,
785,
414,
801
],
[
418,
785,
444,
801
],
[
447,
785,
526,
801
],
[
530,
785,
557,
800
],
[
560,
785,
587,
800
],
[
590,
785,
636,
800
],
[
640,
784,
745,
800
],
[
749,
784,
825,
800
],
[
830,
784,
870,
799
],
[
150,
802,
208,
818
],
[
211,
802,
281,
818
],
[
285,
802,
311,
818
],
[
314,
802,
382,
817
],
[
386,
802,
432,
817
],
[
436,
802,
495,
817
],
[
498,
802,
576,
817
],
[
580,
802,
648,
817
],
[
652,
802,
683,
817
],
[
687,
802,
707,
817
],
[
711,
802,
788,
818
],
[
791,
802,
861,
818
],
[
864,
803,
890,
818
],
[
148,
819,
220,
835
],
[
223,
819,
282,
835
],
[
285,
819,
319,
835
],
[
322,
819,
406,
835
],
[
409,
819,
488,
835
],
[
491,
819,
541,
835
],
[
545,
819,
592,
835
],
[
595,
819,
657,
834
],
[
660,
819,
692,
834
],
[
695,
819,
824,
834
],
[
147,
836,
255,
852
],
[
259,
836,
289,
852
],
[
293,
836,
331,
852
],
[
335,
837,
365,
852
],
[
371,
837,
428,
852
],
[
431,
837,
518,
852
],
[
522,
837,
607,
852
],
[
611,
837,
651,
852
],
[
655,
837,
697,
852
],
[
701,
837,
786,
852
],
[
790,
837,
814,
852
],
[
818,
837,
904,
852
],
[
147,
854,
170,
869
],
[
175,
854,
255,
869
],
[
258,
855,
308,
869
],
[
311,
855,
338,
869
],
[
342,
855,
432,
870
],
[
435,
855,
517,
870
],
[
520,
855,
556,
870
],
[
559,
855,
585,
870
],
[
588,
855,
633,
870
],
[
637,
855,
661,
870
],
[
664,
855,
717,
870
],
[
720,
855,
781,
870
],
[
784,
855,
847,
870
],
[
850,
854,
904,
870
],
[
146,
871,
172,
886
],
[
175,
871,
253,
887
],
[
257,
871,
274,
887
],
[
278,
871,
304,
887
],
[
307,
871,
367,
887
],
[
370,
872,
387,
887
],
[
391,
872,
415,
887
],
[
420,
872,
494,
887
],
[
498,
872,
575,
887
],
[
579,
872,
604,
887
],
[
607,
872,
715,
887
],
[
718,
871,
787,
887
],
[
790,
871,
857,
887
],
[
860,
871,
899,
887
],
[
147,
889,
254,
904
],
[
257,
889,
287,
904
],
[
291,
888,
388,
905
],
[
392,
888,
506,
905
],
[
510,
888,
521,
905
],
[
527,
888,
600,
905
],
[
602,
889,
640,
905
],
[
644,
889,
661,
905
],
[
664,
889,
731,
905
],
[
734,
889,
761,
905
],
[
764,
889,
830,
905
],
[
832,
890,
850,
905
],
[
168,
924,
227,
939
],
[
231,
924,
258,
938
],
[
261,
924,
307,
939
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
293,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Together how many elements are used to make rank exposure potential?
|
3 elements
|
718
|
[
"screening",
"for",
"potential",
"endocrine",
"activity",
"has",
"not",
"yet",
"been",
"conducted",
"on",
"certain",
"compounds,",
"hazard",
"identification",
"based",
"on",
"observable",
"outcomes",
"from",
"apical",
"toxicity",
"tests",
"(e.g.,",
"outcomes",
"such",
"as",
"pathologic",
"states",
"indicative",
"of",
"disease",
"conditions)",
"covers",
"all",
"modes",
"of",
"action,",
"including",
"endocrine",
"pathways.",
"The",
"toxicity",
"information",
"evaluated",
"(CMR",
"and",
"repeat",
"dose",
"toxicity)",
"is",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to",
"evaluating",
"potential",
"hazards",
"to",
"all",
"individuals,",
"including",
"children.",
"Such",
"data",
"typically",
"includes:",
"1)",
"identification",
"and",
"definition",
"of",
"possible",
"hazards",
"upon",
"all",
"major",
"organ",
"systems",
"from",
"both",
"acute",
"and",
"repeated",
"exposures,",
"including",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"2)",
"detection",
"of",
"potential",
"hazards",
"arising",
"from",
"in",
"utero",
"exposures,",
"including",
"possible",
"effects",
"on",
"the",
"nervous",
"system;",
"3)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"affect",
"reproduction;",
"and",
"4)",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"potential",
"of",
"a",
"substance",
"to",
"damage",
"DNA.",
"Integration",
"of",
"Hazard",
"Elements:",
"Each",
"of",
"the",
"environmental",
"and",
"human",
"health",
"classifications",
"is",
"assigned",
"a",
"numeric",
"value",
"based",
"upon",
"its",
"ranking,",
"with",
"1",
"being",
"the",
"lowest",
"value",
"and",
"4",
"the",
"highest.",
"The",
"greatest",
"ranking",
"(highest",
"hazard",
"potential",
"score)",
"of",
"either",
"Environmental",
"or",
"Human",
"Health",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"a",
"substance-",
"specific",
"priority",
"ranking.",
"The",
"numeric",
"value",
"does",
"not",
"imply",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"but",
"rather",
"a",
"numerical",
"order",
"of",
"priority.",
"B.",
"Exposure",
"Potential",
"Ranking",
"The",
"screening",
"method",
"allows",
"for",
"an",
"initial",
"indication",
"of",
"the",
"extent",
"of",
"exposure",
"potential",
"by",
"considering:",
"1.",
"The",
"chemical's",
"uses",
"and",
"use",
"pattern(s).",
"2.",
"Production",
"volume",
"as",
"a",
"first",
"pass",
"indicator",
"of",
"relative",
"emission/release",
"potential",
"since",
"magnitude",
"and",
"route",
"(i.e.",
"air,",
"water,",
"soil)",
"of",
"emissions",
"is",
"not",
"available",
"for",
"all",
"substances.",
".",
"Persistence",
"and",
"bioaccumulation",
"characteristics",
"of",
"the",
"substance.",
"Together",
"the",
"3",
"elements",
"are",
"used",
"to",
"rank",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"1.",
"Use",
"Patterns",
"The",
"proposed",
"approach",
"applies",
"the",
"most",
"current",
"2006",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"Update",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(IUR,",
"now",
"called",
"the",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"rule",
"(CDR)",
"data.",
"To",
"keep",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"simple",
"and",
"transparent,",
"the",
"approach",
"\"bins\"",
"different",
"use",
"patterns",
"to",
"align",
"with",
"general",
"exposure",
"potential",
"-",
"intermediates,",
"industrial",
"use,",
"commercial",
"use",
"and",
"consumer",
"use.",
"These",
"patterns",
"are",
"the",
"same",
"as",
"those",
"reported",
"in",
"the",
"TUR",
"and",
"are",
"consistent",
"with",
"REACH",
"exposure",
"categories",
"(intermediates,",
"worker,",
"professional,",
"consumer).",
"Chemicals",
"with",
"consumer",
"product",
"use",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"widespread",
"potential",
"for",
"general",
"population",
"exposures",
"and",
"are",
"given",
"high",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"For",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally",
"(see",
"additional",
"discussion",
"below",
"under",
"Second",
"Tier",
"Considerations).",
"Intermediates",
"will",
"have",
"low",
"general",
"population",
"exposures,",
"since",
"these",
"substances",
"are",
"consumed,",
"by",
"definition,",
"within",
"the",
"workplace.",
"Therefore,",
"they",
"are",
"given",
"the",
"lowest",
"priority",
"ranking",
"within",
"the",
"approach.",
"In",
"the",
"context",
"of",
"the",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"the",
"intermediates",
"category",
"includes",
"both",
"intermediates",
"and",
"non-isolated",
"intermediates.",
"A",
"chemical",
"used",
"in",
"multiple",
"use",
"patterns",
"is",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
206,
89,
282,
104
],
[
285,
89,
310,
104
],
[
313,
89,
383,
104
],
[
386,
89,
467,
104
],
[
470,
89,
529,
104
],
[
532,
89,
560,
104
],
[
563,
89,
591,
104
],
[
594,
89,
619,
104
],
[
622,
89,
661,
104
],
[
664,
89,
748,
104
],
[
751,
89,
772,
104
],
[
775,
89,
831,
103
],
[
207,
106,
302,
122
],
[
305,
106,
358,
121
],
[
362,
106,
469,
121
],
[
472,
106,
519,
121
],
[
522,
106,
544,
121
],
[
547,
106,
634,
121
],
[
637,
106,
714,
122
],
[
717,
105,
754,
122
],
[
761,
105,
809,
122
],
[
812,
105,
875,
123
],
[
208,
125,
241,
139
],
[
244,
125,
287,
139
],
[
290,
124,
367,
139
],
[
370,
124,
407,
139
],
[
411,
124,
429,
139
],
[
432,
124,
517,
139
],
[
520,
124,
565,
139
],
[
568,
124,
648,
139
],
[
651,
124,
672,
139
],
[
675,
124,
730,
139
],
[
734,
124,
824,
138
],
[
827,
124,
881,
138
],
[
205,
141,
226,
155
],
[
229,
141,
283,
155
],
[
286,
141,
304,
156
],
[
307,
141,
361,
156
],
[
365,
141,
442,
156
],
[
445,
141,
524,
156
],
[
527,
141,
608,
156
],
[
207,
160,
235,
175
],
[
238,
160,
294,
175
],
[
298,
160,
384,
175
],
[
387,
161,
457,
175
],
[
460,
161,
507,
175
],
[
511,
161,
538,
175
],
[
541,
161,
590,
175
],
[
594,
161,
624,
175
],
[
628,
161,
688,
175
],
[
692,
161,
709,
175
],
[
712,
161,
765,
175
],
[
768,
160,
828,
175
],
[
831,
160,
849,
175
],
[
208,
177,
281,
191
],
[
285,
177,
349,
191
],
[
352,
177,
408,
191
],
[
411,
177,
427,
191
],
[
431,
177,
449,
191
],
[
452,
177,
538,
191
],
[
542,
177,
611,
191
],
[
614,
176,
680,
191
],
[
683,
176,
721,
191
],
[
725,
176,
753,
191
],
[
757,
176,
821,
191
],
[
824,
176,
892,
191
],
[
895,
176,
911,
191
],
[
207,
192,
303,
207
],
[
307,
192,
337,
207
],
[
340,
192,
408,
207
],
[
411,
193,
427,
207
],
[
430,
193,
490,
207
],
[
493,
193,
550,
207
],
[
553,
193,
591,
207
],
[
594,
193,
613,
207
],
[
616,
193,
660,
207
],
[
663,
193,
705,
207
],
[
709,
193,
766,
207
],
[
770,
193,
803,
207
],
[
809,
192,
844,
207
],
[
847,
192,
885,
206
],
[
889,
192,
918,
206
],
[
205,
208,
267,
223
],
[
271,
208,
348,
223
],
[
351,
208,
420,
224
],
[
423,
208,
447,
224
],
[
450,
208,
510,
224
],
[
513,
208,
568,
224
],
[
571,
208,
591,
224
],
[
595,
208,
658,
224
],
[
661,
208,
677,
223
],
[
680,
208,
745,
223
],
[
748,
208,
804,
223
],
[
807,
208,
857,
223
],
[
861,
208,
894,
223
],
[
207,
224,
221,
239
],
[
224,
224,
262,
239
],
[
266,
224,
342,
240
],
[
346,
224,
415,
240
],
[
418,
224,
479,
240
],
[
482,
224,
532,
240
],
[
535,
224,
553,
240
],
[
557,
224,
580,
240
],
[
584,
224,
643,
240
],
[
647,
224,
702,
240
],
[
705,
224,
721,
240
],
[
725,
223,
800,
240
],
[
804,
223,
820,
239
],
[
824,
223,
888,
239
],
[
891,
223,
911,
238
],
[
207,
240,
215,
254
],
[
218,
240,
288,
255
],
[
292,
240,
308,
255
],
[
311,
240,
353,
255
],
[
357,
240,
454,
255
],
[
458,
240,
485,
255
],
[
489,
240,
505,
255
],
[
508,
240,
585,
255
],
[
588,
240,
603,
255
],
[
607,
240,
630,
255
],
[
633,
240,
698,
255
],
[
701,
240,
717,
255
],
[
721,
240,
730,
255
],
[
734,
240,
804,
255
],
[
807,
240,
825,
255
],
[
829,
240,
881,
255
],
[
207,
255,
254,
270
],
[
182,
285,
272,
299
],
[
275,
286,
293,
299
],
[
296,
286,
357,
300
],
[
360,
286,
438,
300
],
[
181,
315,
222,
330
],
[
225,
315,
243,
330
],
[
246,
315,
273,
330
],
[
276,
315,
391,
330
],
[
394,
315,
423,
330
],
[
426,
315,
482,
330
],
[
484,
315,
536,
330
],
[
539,
315,
651,
330
],
[
654,
315,
671,
330
],
[
674,
315,
742,
330
],
[
745,
315,
755,
330
],
[
758,
315,
827,
330
],
[
829,
315,
873,
330
],
[
147,
333,
192,
348
],
[
195,
333,
236,
348
],
[
240,
333,
260,
348
],
[
263,
333,
331,
348
],
[
335,
333,
371,
348
],
[
375,
333,
384,
348
],
[
387,
333,
432,
348
],
[
436,
333,
461,
348
],
[
465,
333,
519,
348
],
[
522,
333,
567,
349
],
[
570,
333,
599,
349
],
[
603,
333,
613,
349
],
[
617,
333,
642,
349
],
[
645,
333,
712,
349
],
[
715,
333,
745,
348
],
[
750,
333,
810,
348
],
[
813,
333,
876,
348
],
[
146,
350,
210,
365
],
[
214,
350,
268,
365
],
[
272,
350,
342,
366
],
[
345,
350,
394,
366
],
[
398,
350,
415,
366
],
[
420,
350,
466,
366
],
[
470,
351,
587,
366
],
[
591,
351,
608,
366
],
[
612,
350,
672,
365
],
[
675,
350,
728,
365
],
[
732,
350,
747,
365
],
[
751,
350,
787,
365
],
[
790,
350,
808,
365
],
[
811,
350,
822,
365
],
[
826,
350,
909,
365
],
[
149,
368,
208,
384
],
[
211,
368,
271,
384
],
[
275,
368,
344,
384
],
[
347,
367,
377,
384
],
[
380,
367,
448,
384
],
[
452,
367,
498,
384
],
[
502,
367,
535,
384
],
[
539,
367,
565,
384
],
[
570,
367,
615,
384
],
[
620,
367,
680,
384
],
[
684,
367,
768,
384
],
[
771,
368,
798,
384
],
[
802,
368,
850,
384
],
[
853,
368,
865,
384
],
[
146,
385,
227,
400
],
[
231,
385,
274,
400
],
[
277,
385,
294,
401
],
[
297,
385,
360,
402
],
[
147,
420,
167,
436
],
[
170,
420,
243,
436
],
[
247,
420,
317,
437
],
[
321,
420,
391,
439
],
[
187,
468,
214,
483
],
[
218,
467,
294,
483
],
[
298,
467,
358,
483
],
[
361,
467,
414,
483
],
[
418,
467,
442,
483
],
[
446,
467,
464,
483
],
[
468,
467,
515,
483
],
[
519,
467,
600,
483
],
[
604,
467,
620,
484
],
[
624,
467,
650,
484
],
[
653,
467,
704,
484
],
[
707,
467,
724,
484
],
[
728,
467,
798,
485
],
[
802,
467,
873,
485
],
[
876,
468,
898,
485
],
[
147,
486,
242,
501
],
[
177,
519,
198,
534
],
[
207,
519,
235,
534
],
[
238,
520,
317,
534
],
[
320,
521,
354,
534
],
[
357,
521,
382,
534
],
[
385,
521,
410,
534
],
[
413,
521,
485,
534
],
[
177,
535,
198,
550
],
[
205,
535,
287,
550
],
[
290,
536,
345,
550
],
[
348,
537,
363,
550
],
[
367,
537,
375,
550
],
[
378,
537,
409,
550
],
[
412,
537,
444,
550
],
[
447,
537,
514,
550
],
[
518,
538,
533,
550
],
[
536,
538,
592,
550
],
[
595,
537,
715,
550
],
[
718,
537,
784,
550
],
[
787,
536,
824,
550
],
[
827,
535,
906,
550
],
[
206,
553,
232,
566
],
[
235,
553,
274,
566
],
[
277,
553,
307,
566
],
[
310,
554,
336,
566
],
[
339,
554,
384,
566
],
[
387,
554,
420,
566
],
[
424,
554,
440,
566
],
[
443,
554,
515,
567
],
[
518,
554,
532,
567
],
[
535,
554,
560,
567
],
[
563,
553,
629,
566
],
[
632,
553,
654,
566
],
[
657,
553,
677,
566
],
[
680,
552,
758,
566
],
[
184,
568,
197,
582
],
[
204,
568,
288,
582
],
[
291,
569,
318,
582
],
[
321,
569,
442,
583
],
[
445,
570,
551,
583
],
[
554,
570,
570,
583
],
[
573,
570,
595,
583
],
[
598,
569,
677,
583
],
[
184,
596,
253,
612
],
[
257,
596,
282,
612
],
[
287,
596,
298,
612
],
[
301,
597,
372,
612
],
[
376,
597,
401,
613
],
[
404,
597,
441,
613
],
[
445,
597,
461,
613
],
[
464,
597,
503,
613
],
[
506,
597,
578,
613
],
[
581,
597,
658,
614
],
[
178,
632,
198,
647
],
[
206,
633,
234,
647
],
[
238,
633,
304,
648
],
[
184,
663,
213,
679
],
[
217,
663,
290,
679
],
[
294,
663,
368,
679
],
[
371,
663,
428,
678
],
[
432,
663,
457,
678
],
[
461,
663,
501,
678
],
[
504,
663,
561,
678
],
[
564,
663,
607,
678
],
[
611,
662,
660,
678
],
[
663,
662,
741,
679
],
[
745,
662,
802,
679
],
[
805,
662,
887,
680
],
[
147,
679,
178,
695
],
[
182,
679,
228,
695
],
[
232,
680,
266,
695
],
[
271,
680,
318,
696
],
[
322,
680,
348,
696
],
[
352,
680,
428,
696
],
[
432,
680,
470,
696
],
[
474,
680,
553,
696
],
[
557,
680,
589,
696
],
[
593,
680,
651,
696
],
[
655,
680,
692,
695
],
[
695,
680,
715,
695
],
[
719,
680,
758,
695
],
[
761,
680,
787,
695
],
[
790,
680,
838,
695
],
[
148,
698,
251,
713
],
[
254,
698,
308,
713
],
[
312,
698,
341,
713
],
[
345,
698,
438,
713
],
[
442,
698,
467,
713
],
[
471,
698,
543,
713
],
[
547,
698,
601,
713
],
[
604,
698,
671,
713
],
[
675,
698,
702,
713
],
[
705,
698,
770,
713
],
[
773,
697,
791,
713
],
[
794,
697,
835,
713
],
[
839,
697,
876,
712
],
[
148,
715,
205,
731
],
[
210,
715,
281,
731
],
[
285,
715,
355,
730
],
[
359,
715,
368,
730
],
[
372,
715,
485,
730
],
[
489,
715,
564,
730
],
[
568,
715,
600,
730
],
[
604,
715,
698,
730
],
[
702,
715,
730,
730
],
[
734,
715,
763,
730
],
[
767,
715,
844,
730
],
[
848,
715,
878,
730
],
[
149,
732,
194,
747
],
[
198,
732,
262,
748
],
[
266,
732,
290,
748
],
[
293,
732,
321,
748
],
[
324,
733,
365,
748
],
[
369,
733,
386,
748
],
[
390,
733,
431,
748
],
[
434,
733,
502,
748
],
[
505,
733,
522,
748
],
[
526,
733,
552,
748
],
[
555,
732,
590,
748
],
[
594,
732,
624,
748
],
[
628,
732,
652,
748
],
[
656,
732,
737,
748
],
[
740,
731,
777,
748
],
[
780,
731,
846,
747
],
[
148,
750,
219,
765
],
[
222,
750,
304,
765
],
[
307,
750,
426,
765
],
[
430,
750,
490,
765
],
[
493,
750,
598,
765
],
[
601,
750,
690,
765
],
[
692,
750,
778,
765
],
[
781,
750,
818,
765
],
[
821,
750,
902,
765
],
[
148,
767,
208,
782
],
[
211,
767,
238,
783
],
[
242,
767,
267,
783
],
[
271,
767,
317,
783
],
[
321,
767,
337,
783
],
[
340,
767,
381,
783
],
[
384,
767,
472,
783
],
[
475,
767,
548,
783
],
[
551,
767,
576,
783
],
[
579,
767,
638,
783
],
[
641,
767,
728,
783
],
[
730,
767,
811,
783
],
[
813,
768,
845,
783
],
[
847,
768,
874,
783
],
[
147,
785,
191,
800
],
[
194,
785,
230,
800
],
[
233,
785,
295,
801
],
[
298,
785,
361,
801
],
[
364,
785,
414,
801
],
[
418,
785,
444,
801
],
[
447,
785,
526,
801
],
[
530,
785,
557,
800
],
[
560,
785,
587,
800
],
[
590,
785,
636,
800
],
[
640,
784,
745,
800
],
[
749,
784,
825,
800
],
[
830,
784,
870,
799
],
[
150,
802,
208,
818
],
[
211,
802,
281,
818
],
[
285,
802,
311,
818
],
[
314,
802,
382,
817
],
[
386,
802,
432,
817
],
[
436,
802,
495,
817
],
[
498,
802,
576,
817
],
[
580,
802,
648,
817
],
[
652,
802,
683,
817
],
[
687,
802,
707,
817
],
[
711,
802,
788,
818
],
[
791,
802,
861,
818
],
[
864,
803,
890,
818
],
[
148,
819,
220,
835
],
[
223,
819,
282,
835
],
[
285,
819,
319,
835
],
[
322,
819,
406,
835
],
[
409,
819,
488,
835
],
[
491,
819,
541,
835
],
[
545,
819,
592,
835
],
[
595,
819,
657,
834
],
[
660,
819,
692,
834
],
[
695,
819,
824,
834
],
[
147,
836,
255,
852
],
[
259,
836,
289,
852
],
[
293,
836,
331,
852
],
[
335,
837,
365,
852
],
[
371,
837,
428,
852
],
[
431,
837,
518,
852
],
[
522,
837,
607,
852
],
[
611,
837,
651,
852
],
[
655,
837,
697,
852
],
[
701,
837,
786,
852
],
[
790,
837,
814,
852
],
[
818,
837,
904,
852
],
[
147,
854,
170,
869
],
[
175,
854,
255,
869
],
[
258,
855,
308,
869
],
[
311,
855,
338,
869
],
[
342,
855,
432,
870
],
[
435,
855,
517,
870
],
[
520,
855,
556,
870
],
[
559,
855,
585,
870
],
[
588,
855,
633,
870
],
[
637,
855,
661,
870
],
[
664,
855,
717,
870
],
[
720,
855,
781,
870
],
[
784,
855,
847,
870
],
[
850,
854,
904,
870
],
[
146,
871,
172,
886
],
[
175,
871,
253,
887
],
[
257,
871,
274,
887
],
[
278,
871,
304,
887
],
[
307,
871,
367,
887
],
[
370,
872,
387,
887
],
[
391,
872,
415,
887
],
[
420,
872,
494,
887
],
[
498,
872,
575,
887
],
[
579,
872,
604,
887
],
[
607,
872,
715,
887
],
[
718,
871,
787,
887
],
[
790,
871,
857,
887
],
[
860,
871,
899,
887
],
[
147,
889,
254,
904
],
[
257,
889,
287,
904
],
[
291,
888,
388,
905
],
[
392,
888,
506,
905
],
[
510,
888,
521,
905
],
[
527,
888,
600,
905
],
[
602,
889,
640,
905
],
[
644,
889,
661,
905
],
[
664,
889,
731,
905
],
[
734,
889,
761,
905
],
[
764,
889,
830,
905
],
[
832,
890,
850,
905
],
[
168,
924,
227,
939
],
[
231,
924,
258,
938
],
[
261,
924,
307,
939
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
293,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
The proposed approach applies the most to which year's TSCA Inventory Update Reporting rule?
|
2006
|
724
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Comments",
"to",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"on",
"Its",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"INTRODUCTION",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"provide",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"these",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"proposed",
"procedures",
"for",
"prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA)",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"ACC",
"strongly",
"supported",
"Congress's",
"efforts",
"to",
"update",
"and",
"reform",
"TSCA.",
"One",
"of",
"ACC's",
"principles",
"for",
"modernizing",
"TSCA",
"called",
"on",
"EPA",
"to",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations.",
"Without",
"a",
"scientifically",
"based",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"EPA",
"would",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"meet",
"efficiently",
"the",
"other",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"achieve",
"the",
"objectives",
"of",
"TSCA",
"reform",
"that",
"Congress",
"intended.",
"As",
"discussed",
"in",
"more",
"detail",
"below,",
"EPA's",
"proposed",
"prioritization",
"process",
"falls",
"short.",
"Congress",
"designed",
"the",
"LCSA",
"to",
"allow",
"chemicals",
"to",
"be",
"systematically",
"prioritized",
"and",
"then",
"to",
"evaluate",
"those",
"substances",
"presenting",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"risk.",
"This",
"design",
"is",
"apparent",
"in",
"every",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"It",
"begins",
"with",
"a",
"reclassification",
"of",
"the",
"full",
"catalog",
"of",
"chemistries",
"in",
"U.S.",
"commerce,",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory.",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"that",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"be",
"sorted,",
"so",
"that",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"currently",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"separated",
"from",
"those",
"no",
"longer",
"manufactured,",
"imported",
"or",
"used;",
"only",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"prioritization",
"and",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"This",
"enables",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"resources",
"for",
"its",
"multi-year,",
"time-and-resource",
"intensive",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"actually",
"in",
"current",
"use.",
"EPA",
"must",
"next",
"undertake",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"sequence",
"of",
"chemicals",
"that",
"will",
"undergo",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"must",
"then",
"undertake",
"a",
"formal",
"scoping",
"process,",
"to",
"define",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"(and",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"sub-populations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"use)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"chemical.",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"various",
"purposes",
"is",
"not",
"new",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"In",
"2011,",
"EPA",
"held",
"a",
"Stakeholder",
"Dialogue",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"and",
"established",
"a",
"Discussion",
"Blog",
"for",
"additional",
"input",
"on",
"the",
"topic.",
"In",
"our",
"comments",
"to",
"that",
"discussion",
"blog,",
"ACC",
"identified",
"several",
"general",
"principles",
"for",
"prioritization",
"(Attachment",
"A).",
"We",
"believe",
"these",
"principles",
"are",
"reflected",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA",
"requirements,",
"in",
"particular",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"recognition",
"that",
"prioritization",
"is",
"a",
"risk",
"based",
"screening",
"process",
"that",
"integrates",
"information",
"on",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"In",
"2011,",
"ACC",
"developed",
"a",
"two-step",
"quantitative",
"and",
"qualitative",
"tool",
"to",
"\"proof",
"test\"",
"our",
"prioritization",
"principles",
"(Attachment",
"B).",
"We",
"presented",
"our",
"principles",
"and",
"our",
"prioritization",
"tool",
"to",
"EPA",
"in",
"2011,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"other",
"industry",
"and",
"NGO",
"stakeholders",
"at",
"the",
"time.",
"In",
"2012,",
"EPA",
"published",
"its",
"methodology",
"to",
"identify",
"chemicals",
"for",
"its",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
368,
64,
451,
80
],
[
457,
64,
548,
80
],
[
551,
62,
616,
80
],
[
277,
84,
366,
100
],
[
370,
84,
389,
100
],
[
392,
85,
428,
100
],
[
432,
85,
560,
100
],
[
564,
85,
651,
100
],
[
656,
85,
718,
100
],
[
722,
85,
745,
100
],
[
260,
103,
283,
119
],
[
287,
103,
366,
119
],
[
370,
104,
467,
120
],
[
470,
105,
497,
120
],
[
501,
105,
615,
120
],
[
619,
105,
638,
120
],
[
642,
104,
728,
120
],
[
731,
103,
761,
119
],
[
253,
124,
294,
139
],
[
297,
124,
389,
139
],
[
392,
125,
445,
139
],
[
449,
125,
478,
139
],
[
481,
125,
528,
139
],
[
531,
125,
627,
139
],
[
631,
125,
696,
139
],
[
700,
125,
727,
139
],
[
454,
159,
597,
173
],
[
198,
193,
230,
208
],
[
233,
194,
312,
209
],
[
315,
194,
399,
210
],
[
402,
193,
465,
210
],
[
468,
193,
523,
210
],
[
526,
193,
542,
210
],
[
545,
193,
606,
210
],
[
609,
193,
625,
210
],
[
628,
193,
691,
210
],
[
694,
192,
721,
209
],
[
723,
192,
756,
209
],
[
140,
213,
256,
229
],
[
260,
214,
342,
230
],
[
346,
214,
408,
230
],
[
411,
214,
464,
230
],
[
467,
214,
508,
230
],
[
512,
214,
595,
230
],
[
598,
214,
619,
230
],
[
622,
214,
648,
230
],
[
651,
214,
728,
230
],
[
731,
214,
804,
230
],
[
137,
234,
225,
250
],
[
230,
234,
252,
250
],
[
256,
234,
361,
250
],
[
365,
234,
382,
249
],
[
387,
234,
465,
249
],
[
470,
234,
492,
249
],
[
496,
234,
528,
249
],
[
532,
233,
614,
249
],
[
617,
233,
664,
249
],
[
667,
233,
694,
249
],
[
698,
233,
744,
249
],
[
748,
233,
838,
249
],
[
139,
253,
201,
269
],
[
205,
253,
233,
269
],
[
236,
253,
301,
270
],
[
304,
254,
322,
270
],
[
325,
254,
397,
270
],
[
400,
254,
422,
270
],
[
425,
254,
451,
270
],
[
454,
254,
547,
270
],
[
550,
253,
627,
270
],
[
630,
253,
682,
270
],
[
685,
253,
715,
270
],
[
718,
253,
790,
269
],
[
793,
253,
820,
269
],
[
138,
272,
190,
289
],
[
193,
273,
257,
289
],
[
261,
273,
300,
290
],
[
304,
273,
321,
290
],
[
324,
273,
398,
290
],
[
402,
274,
422,
290
],
[
427,
274,
464,
290
],
[
468,
274,
477,
290
],
[
480,
274,
563,
290
],
[
567,
274,
642,
290
],
[
646,
274,
707,
290
],
[
711,
274,
727,
290
],
[
731,
274,
792,
290
],
[
796,
274,
834,
289
],
[
140,
294,
167,
309
],
[
171,
294,
201,
310
],
[
205,
294,
267,
310
],
[
270,
295,
355,
310
],
[
359,
295,
383,
310
],
[
387,
295,
417,
310
],
[
421,
294,
512,
310
],
[
516,
294,
561,
310
],
[
565,
294,
590,
309
],
[
594,
294,
647,
309
],
[
198,
326,
240,
343
],
[
243,
326,
308,
343
],
[
312,
326,
391,
343
],
[
395,
327,
482,
343
],
[
487,
327,
538,
343
],
[
542,
327,
558,
343
],
[
562,
326,
615,
343
],
[
620,
326,
649,
342
],
[
653,
326,
705,
342
],
[
712,
326,
768,
342
],
[
772,
326,
805,
342
],
[
809,
326,
830,
342
],
[
140,
346,
192,
363
],
[
197,
346,
276,
363
],
[
281,
346,
303,
362
],
[
307,
346,
410,
362
],
[
414,
346,
464,
362
],
[
467,
346,
516,
362
],
[
520,
346,
540,
362
],
[
544,
347,
581,
362
],
[
585,
347,
602,
362
],
[
606,
347,
718,
362
],
[
722,
347,
797,
362
],
[
139,
366,
218,
382
],
[
222,
366,
244,
382
],
[
248,
366,
320,
382
],
[
324,
366,
341,
382
],
[
345,
367,
376,
382
],
[
380,
367,
477,
382
],
[
481,
367,
545,
382
],
[
550,
367,
558,
382
],
[
562,
367,
664,
382
],
[
668,
367,
714,
382
],
[
717,
366,
825,
382
],
[
138,
387,
204,
402
],
[
207,
387,
244,
402
],
[
249,
387,
299,
402
],
[
302,
387,
328,
402
],
[
332,
387,
352,
402
],
[
356,
387,
390,
402
],
[
394,
387,
410,
402
],
[
414,
387,
453,
402
],
[
457,
387,
539,
402
],
[
542,
387,
568,
402
],
[
572,
387,
612,
402
],
[
616,
386,
721,
402
],
[
725,
386,
741,
402
],
[
745,
386,
771,
401
],
[
774,
386,
826,
401
],
[
831,
385,
860,
401
],
[
140,
406,
198,
423
],
[
202,
407,
229,
423
],
[
232,
407,
314,
423
],
[
317,
407,
336,
423
],
[
340,
407,
388,
423
],
[
392,
407,
444,
423
],
[
451,
407,
482,
423
],
[
485,
407,
560,
423
],
[
564,
407,
639,
423
],
[
642,
407,
667,
422
],
[
671,
407,
744,
422
],
[
748,
407,
764,
422
],
[
768,
407,
812,
422
],
[
817,
406,
855,
422
],
[
138,
426,
192,
443
],
[
197,
426,
248,
443
],
[
252,
427,
324,
443
],
[
328,
427,
432,
443
],
[
435,
428,
497,
443
],
[
500,
428,
536,
442
],
[
539,
427,
584,
442
],
[
199,
459,
274,
475
],
[
277,
460,
346,
475
],
[
350,
460,
374,
475
],
[
377,
460,
430,
475
],
[
433,
460,
450,
475
],
[
454,
460,
498,
475
],
[
503,
460,
582,
475
],
[
585,
460,
602,
475
],
[
605,
460,
625,
475
],
[
629,
459,
742,
475
],
[
745,
459,
830,
475
],
[
833,
459,
864,
475
],
[
138,
479,
172,
495
],
[
176,
480,
193,
495
],
[
197,
480,
264,
495
],
[
268,
480,
310,
495
],
[
314,
480,
399,
495
],
[
402,
480,
485,
495
],
[
489,
480,
515,
495
],
[
519,
480,
581,
495
],
[
585,
480,
654,
495
],
[
658,
480,
696,
495
],
[
700,
480,
738,
495
],
[
742,
479,
790,
495
],
[
794,
479,
806,
495
],
[
140,
500,
207,
515
],
[
210,
500,
228,
515
],
[
231,
500,
276,
515
],
[
279,
500,
312,
515
],
[
315,
500,
332,
515
],
[
335,
500,
361,
515
],
[
364,
500,
422,
515
],
[
424,
500,
438,
515
],
[
441,
500,
495,
515
],
[
498,
500,
535,
515
],
[
538,
500,
548,
515
],
[
551,
500,
672,
515
],
[
675,
500,
692,
515
],
[
695,
500,
722,
515
],
[
725,
500,
755,
515
],
[
757,
499,
817,
515
],
[
820,
499,
841,
515
],
[
140,
520,
228,
535
],
[
232,
520,
250,
536
],
[
254,
520,
290,
536
],
[
294,
520,
380,
536
],
[
384,
520,
411,
536
],
[
415,
520,
464,
536
],
[
468,
520,
552,
536
],
[
556,
520,
586,
536
],
[
590,
520,
642,
535
],
[
645,
520,
710,
535
],
[
713,
520,
744,
535
],
[
748,
520,
775,
535
],
[
780,
519,
828,
535
],
[
139,
540,
215,
555
],
[
218,
540,
240,
555
],
[
243,
540,
297,
555
],
[
301,
540,
319,
555
],
[
322,
540,
354,
555
],
[
358,
540,
437,
555
],
[
440,
541,
471,
555
],
[
475,
541,
501,
555
],
[
505,
541,
577,
555
],
[
581,
541,
628,
555
],
[
631,
541,
649,
555
],
[
652,
540,
736,
555
],
[
740,
540,
765,
555
],
[
768,
540,
845,
555
],
[
138,
560,
174,
575
],
[
181,
560,
223,
575
],
[
227,
560,
248,
575
],
[
252,
560,
304,
575
],
[
307,
560,
420,
576
],
[
424,
560,
497,
576
],
[
501,
560,
518,
576
],
[
522,
560,
565,
576
],
[
568,
560,
605,
575
],
[
609,
560,
687,
575
],
[
690,
561,
724,
575
],
[
727,
561,
751,
575
],
[
754,
561,
802,
575
],
[
806,
561,
823,
574
],
[
141,
581,
222,
595
],
[
225,
581,
250,
595
],
[
254,
581,
311,
595
],
[
314,
581,
330,
595
],
[
334,
581,
359,
595
],
[
362,
581,
467,
595
],
[
471,
581,
501,
595
],
[
504,
581,
535,
595
],
[
539,
581,
629,
595
],
[
632,
581,
666,
595
],
[
670,
581,
731,
595
],
[
734,
581,
770,
595
],
[
776,
581,
792,
595
],
[
795,
580,
840,
595
],
[
137,
600,
213,
616
],
[
217,
601,
241,
616
],
[
244,
601,
264,
616
],
[
268,
601,
356,
616
],
[
360,
601,
504,
616
],
[
507,
601,
580,
616
],
[
584,
601,
615,
616
],
[
619,
601,
709,
616
],
[
712,
601,
734,
616
],
[
737,
600,
817,
615
],
[
820,
600,
850,
615
],
[
140,
621,
164,
635
],
[
167,
621,
230,
635
],
[
234,
621,
251,
635
],
[
254,
621,
311,
635
],
[
315,
621,
349,
635
],
[
352,
621,
387,
635
],
[
392,
621,
432,
636
],
[
435,
621,
472,
636
],
[
475,
621,
554,
636
],
[
558,
621,
567,
636
],
[
571,
621,
674,
636
],
[
677,
621,
743,
635
],
[
746,
621,
764,
635
],
[
767,
620,
817,
635
],
[
825,
620,
850,
635
],
[
139,
641,
212,
655
],
[
215,
641,
233,
655
],
[
237,
641,
316,
656
],
[
320,
641,
352,
656
],
[
355,
641,
386,
656
],
[
390,
640,
455,
656
],
[
458,
640,
490,
656
],
[
492,
640,
582,
656
],
[
585,
640,
621,
656
],
[
627,
640,
667,
656
],
[
670,
640,
705,
655
],
[
708,
640,
787,
655
],
[
790,
640,
802,
655
],
[
804,
640,
860,
655
],
[
139,
662,
200,
675
],
[
203,
661,
270,
676
],
[
272,
661,
290,
676
],
[
297,
661,
344,
676
],
[
347,
661,
373,
676
],
[
376,
661,
460,
676
],
[
463,
661,
482,
676
],
[
485,
661,
513,
676
],
[
516,
661,
552,
676
],
[
555,
661,
641,
676
],
[
644,
661,
710,
676
],
[
714,
661,
835,
676
],
[
138,
681,
202,
695
],
[
205,
681,
222,
695
],
[
225,
681,
252,
695
],
[
255,
681,
289,
695
],
[
292,
681,
326,
695
],
[
329,
681,
359,
695
],
[
362,
681,
382,
695
],
[
385,
681,
455,
696
],
[
458,
681,
475,
696
],
[
478,
681,
505,
696
],
[
508,
681,
555,
696
],
[
558,
680,
576,
696
],
[
579,
680,
604,
696
],
[
607,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
725,
696
],
[
728,
680,
745,
695
],
[
748,
680,
775,
695
],
[
778,
680,
855,
695
],
[
197,
713,
303,
729
],
[
307,
714,
323,
729
],
[
327,
714,
407,
729
],
[
411,
714,
435,
729
],
[
439,
714,
496,
729
],
[
500,
714,
571,
729
],
[
575,
714,
589,
729
],
[
593,
714,
620,
729
],
[
624,
714,
655,
729
],
[
661,
714,
677,
729
],
[
681,
714,
708,
729
],
[
711,
713,
783,
729
],
[
786,
713,
805,
729
],
[
808,
712,
854,
729
],
[
139,
732,
175,
748
],
[
180,
733,
216,
748
],
[
220,
733,
230,
748
],
[
234,
733,
328,
748
],
[
331,
734,
405,
748
],
[
408,
734,
430,
749
],
[
433,
734,
538,
749
],
[
542,
734,
571,
749
],
[
574,
734,
663,
749
],
[
666,
734,
677,
749
],
[
680,
733,
768,
749
],
[
771,
733,
811,
749
],
[
814,
733,
839,
748
],
[
140,
753,
218,
768
],
[
221,
754,
264,
769
],
[
268,
754,
287,
769
],
[
291,
754,
317,
769
],
[
320,
754,
367,
769
],
[
370,
755,
388,
769
],
[
391,
755,
418,
769
],
[
422,
755,
504,
769
],
[
507,
754,
523,
769
],
[
527,
754,
561,
769
],
[
565,
754,
644,
769
],
[
648,
754,
691,
769
],
[
694,
753,
734,
768
],
[
738,
752,
812,
768
],
[
140,
774,
196,
789
],
[
200,
774,
258,
789
],
[
261,
774,
340,
789
],
[
344,
774,
368,
789
],
[
371,
774,
475,
789
],
[
479,
774,
580,
789
],
[
584,
774,
610,
789
],
[
614,
774,
640,
789
],
[
644,
773,
702,
789
],
[
706,
773,
748,
789
],
[
752,
773,
830,
789
],
[
834,
773,
859,
789
],
[
138,
793,
208,
809
],
[
212,
793,
228,
809
],
[
232,
793,
258,
809
],
[
261,
794,
311,
809
],
[
315,
794,
425,
810
],
[
428,
794,
444,
810
],
[
447,
794,
525,
810
],
[
528,
794,
554,
810
],
[
558,
794,
622,
810
],
[
626,
794,
718,
810
],
[
721,
794,
751,
809
],
[
755,
793,
861,
809
],
[
138,
813,
153,
828
],
[
157,
813,
166,
828
],
[
170,
814,
200,
828
],
[
203,
814,
251,
829
],
[
255,
814,
330,
829
],
[
334,
815,
394,
829
],
[
398,
815,
428,
829
],
[
431,
815,
510,
829
],
[
513,
815,
607,
829
],
[
611,
815,
631,
829
],
[
634,
815,
671,
829
],
[
675,
814,
729,
829
],
[
732,
814,
762,
829
],
[
766,
814,
839,
829
],
[
137,
833,
214,
849
],
[
217,
833,
234,
849
],
[
238,
834,
284,
849
],
[
287,
834,
328,
849
],
[
335,
834,
414,
849
],
[
418,
834,
427,
849
],
[
431,
834,
500,
849
],
[
504,
834,
599,
849
],
[
603,
834,
632,
849
],
[
635,
834,
719,
849
],
[
722,
834,
754,
849
],
[
758,
834,
775,
848
],
[
779,
833,
832,
848
],
[
139,
854,
177,
869
],
[
180,
854,
206,
869
],
[
210,
854,
314,
869
],
[
317,
854,
397,
869
],
[
400,
854,
501,
869
],
[
504,
854,
531,
869
],
[
534,
854,
561,
869
],
[
564,
854,
642,
869
],
[
645,
854,
672,
869
],
[
675,
854,
756,
869
],
[
759,
854,
790,
869
],
[
792,
854,
819,
869
],
[
138,
874,
241,
889
],
[
245,
874,
278,
889
],
[
281,
874,
298,
889
],
[
302,
874,
338,
889
],
[
343,
874,
360,
890
],
[
364,
874,
410,
890
],
[
413,
874,
431,
890
],
[
435,
874,
469,
890
],
[
472,
874,
490,
890
],
[
493,
874,
511,
890
],
[
515,
873,
555,
890
],
[
558,
873,
625,
890
],
[
628,
873,
658,
890
],
[
661,
873,
702,
890
],
[
710,
873,
809,
889
],
[
812,
873,
827,
889
],
[
831,
873,
856,
889
],
[
138,
892,
179,
908
],
[
183,
892,
200,
909
],
[
204,
893,
250,
909
],
[
254,
893,
291,
909
],
[
295,
893,
372,
910
],
[
377,
893,
397,
910
],
[
400,
893,
504,
910
],
[
508,
893,
525,
910
],
[
530,
893,
591,
910
],
[
595,
892,
674,
910
],
[
678,
892,
702,
910
],
[
706,
892,
727,
909
],
[
731,
892,
780,
909
],
[
787,
892,
829,
909
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the fullform of ACC?
|
American Chemistry Council
|
720
|
[
"American\"",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Document",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Submitted",
"electronically",
"via",
"www.regulations.gay",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Rule:",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act,",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"7562",
"(January",
"19,",
"2017);",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0654",
"Dear",
"Docket",
"Clerk:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"the",
"attached",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency,",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Proposed",
"Rule,",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act.",
"These",
"comments",
"align",
"with",
"our",
"separately",
"filed",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"proposed",
"rules",
"describing",
"the",
"processes",
"for",
"inventory",
"reset",
"and",
"prioritization",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"and",
"for",
"the",
"development",
"of",
"the",
"scopes",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"first",
"10",
"chemicals",
"selected",
"from",
"the",
"TSCA",
"work",
"plan.",
"All",
"comments",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"together.",
"Please",
"feel",
"free",
"to",
"contact",
"me",
"with",
"any",
"questions",
"at",
"202-249-6130",
"or",
"karynschmidt",
"@americanchemistry.com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Karyn",
"M.",
"Schmidt",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"and",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"CC:",
"Jeffery",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett,",
"OPPT",
"Tala",
"Henry,",
"Director,",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Division,",
"OPPT",
"Susanna",
"Blair,",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"ACC",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"More",
"information",
"about",
"ACC",
"is",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"body",
"of",
"our",
"comments.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
459,
100,
572,
119
],
[
486,
120,
605,
142
],
[
459,
140,
541,
158
],
[
442,
189,
491,
202
],
[
495,
190,
520,
203
],
[
522,
189,
560,
203
],
[
88,
222,
165,
235
],
[
168,
222,
224,
235
],
[
227,
222,
274,
235
],
[
277,
221,
342,
235
],
[
91,
237,
135,
251
],
[
138,
238,
155,
251
],
[
158,
239,
224,
251
],
[
227,
239,
308,
251
],
[
311,
238,
340,
251
],
[
342,
237,
393,
251
],
[
91,
254,
197,
268
],
[
200,
255,
276,
268
],
[
279,
255,
330,
269
],
[
92,
269,
124,
283
],
[
128,
270,
227,
283
],
[
230,
270,
264,
283
],
[
267,
269,
295,
283
],
[
90,
286,
181,
299
],
[
184,
286,
208,
298
],
[
213,
285,
302,
299
],
[
90,
317,
161,
330
],
[
164,
318,
265,
331
],
[
268,
319,
291,
332
],
[
294,
319,
449,
333
],
[
87,
348,
119,
363
],
[
147,
350,
226,
363
],
[
229,
350,
246,
364
],
[
249,
350,
274,
364
],
[
277,
350,
347,
365
],
[
351,
350,
427,
365
],
[
430,
350,
488,
365
],
[
491,
350,
512,
365
],
[
515,
350,
562,
365
],
[
565,
350,
634,
365
],
[
637,
350,
677,
365
],
[
680,
350,
766,
365
],
[
768,
350,
791,
365
],
[
794,
350,
864,
365
],
[
867,
349,
900,
364
],
[
148,
366,
227,
379
],
[
230,
366,
273,
380
],
[
277,
366,
301,
380
],
[
304,
366,
374,
380
],
[
377,
366,
417,
380
],
[
420,
366,
501,
381
],
[
504,
366,
563,
381
],
[
566,
366,
596,
381
],
[
599,
366,
617,
381
],
[
620,
366,
654,
381
],
[
656,
366,
692,
381
],
[
695,
366,
732,
381
],
[
734,
366,
799,
380
],
[
802,
365,
825,
380
],
[
828,
365,
877,
380
],
[
147,
380,
345,
395
],
[
88,
413,
124,
427
],
[
127,
413,
182,
427
],
[
185,
413,
231,
427
],
[
90,
445,
118,
460
],
[
121,
445,
192,
460
],
[
196,
445,
272,
461
],
[
276,
445,
333,
461
],
[
337,
445,
392,
461
],
[
396,
445,
409,
461
],
[
412,
445,
467,
461
],
[
471,
445,
487,
461
],
[
490,
445,
540,
461
],
[
543,
446,
567,
461
],
[
571,
446,
630,
461
],
[
634,
446,
710,
461
],
[
713,
446,
731,
461
],
[
735,
446,
759,
460
],
[
762,
446,
871,
460
],
[
89,
461,
164,
475
],
[
167,
462,
228,
476
],
[
231,
462,
280,
476
],
[
282,
462,
298,
476
],
[
301,
462,
368,
476
],
[
371,
462,
451,
476
],
[
454,
462,
483,
477
],
[
486,
462,
535,
477
],
[
538,
462,
607,
477
],
[
610,
462,
650,
476
],
[
654,
461,
735,
476
],
[
738,
461,
761,
476
],
[
764,
461,
834,
476
],
[
837,
461,
868,
475
],
[
88,
477,
168,
490
],
[
170,
477,
213,
491
],
[
216,
477,
241,
491
],
[
244,
477,
316,
491
],
[
319,
477,
361,
491
],
[
364,
477,
445,
491
],
[
448,
478,
505,
491
],
[
508,
478,
538,
491
],
[
90,
510,
132,
524
],
[
135,
510,
210,
524
],
[
214,
510,
251,
524
],
[
255,
510,
287,
524
],
[
291,
510,
316,
524
],
[
320,
510,
393,
524
],
[
396,
510,
431,
525
],
[
434,
510,
510,
525
],
[
513,
510,
532,
525
],
[
535,
510,
559,
525
],
[
562,
510,
629,
525
],
[
632,
510,
672,
525
],
[
675,
510,
748,
525
],
[
751,
510,
775,
525
],
[
778,
510,
848,
525
],
[
851,
510,
875,
525
],
[
88,
526,
158,
539
],
[
161,
526,
197,
539
],
[
201,
526,
227,
539
],
[
230,
526,
327,
539
],
[
330,
526,
351,
540
],
[
354,
525,
382,
540
],
[
385,
525,
467,
540
],
[
470,
525,
497,
540
],
[
500,
525,
522,
540
],
[
525,
525,
551,
540
],
[
556,
525,
647,
540
],
[
650,
525,
667,
540
],
[
670,
525,
693,
540
],
[
696,
525,
745,
540
],
[
748,
525,
770,
540
],
[
772,
525,
802,
540
],
[
805,
525,
881,
540
],
[
884,
525,
904,
540
],
[
88,
541,
112,
554
],
[
114,
541,
147,
554
],
[
150,
541,
167,
554
],
[
170,
541,
244,
555
],
[
247,
541,
306,
555
],
[
308,
541,
341,
555
],
[
348,
541,
373,
555
],
[
377,
541,
420,
555
],
[
426,
541,
464,
555
],
[
467,
541,
508,
555
],
[
512,
541,
536,
555
],
[
539,
541,
615,
555
],
[
618,
541,
667,
555
],
[
670,
541,
689,
555
],
[
692,
541,
771,
555
],
[
774,
541,
842,
555
],
[
88,
573,
135,
587
],
[
138,
573,
167,
587
],
[
170,
573,
199,
587
],
[
202,
573,
218,
587
],
[
221,
573,
274,
588
],
[
277,
574,
300,
588
],
[
304,
574,
337,
588
],
[
340,
574,
367,
589
],
[
370,
574,
440,
589
],
[
442,
574,
457,
589
],
[
461,
574,
564,
590
],
[
568,
574,
582,
590
],
[
585,
574,
695,
590
],
[
698,
575,
885,
590
],
[
89,
604,
161,
620
],
[
89,
714,
134,
728
],
[
137,
715,
160,
728
],
[
163,
714,
224,
728
],
[
90,
730,
135,
744
],
[
139,
730,
205,
744
],
[
208,
730,
290,
744
],
[
292,
730,
322,
744
],
[
325,
730,
396,
744
],
[
399,
730,
454,
745
],
[
91,
746,
161,
760
],
[
164,
746,
241,
760
],
[
244,
746,
302,
760
],
[
88,
780,
110,
792
],
[
147,
777,
198,
792
],
[
201,
778,
257,
793
],
[
260,
778,
326,
793
],
[
330,
778,
374,
792
],
[
148,
793,
201,
808
],
[
204,
794,
333,
808
],
[
337,
793,
382,
808
],
[
148,
809,
180,
824
],
[
182,
810,
234,
825
],
[
237,
810,
304,
825
],
[
307,
810,
341,
825
],
[
344,
810,
430,
825
],
[
432,
810,
502,
825
],
[
505,
810,
551,
824
],
[
147,
825,
208,
840
],
[
211,
825,
253,
840
],
[
257,
825,
304,
840
],
[
307,
826,
324,
840
],
[
327,
826,
397,
840
],
[
401,
826,
448,
840
],
[
451,
826,
477,
840
],
[
481,
826,
548,
840
],
[
552,
826,
632,
840
],
[
98,
881,
131,
894
],
[
134,
882,
202,
895
],
[
205,
882,
226,
895
],
[
229,
882,
278,
895
],
[
281,
883,
351,
895
],
[
355,
883,
410,
895
],
[
413,
883,
427,
895
],
[
430,
883,
451,
895
],
[
454,
883,
511,
895
],
[
514,
883,
530,
896
],
[
532,
883,
601,
896
],
[
604,
883,
641,
895
],
[
644,
883,
722,
895
],
[
725,
883,
764,
895
],
[
767,
882,
801,
895
],
[
804,
882,
814,
895
],
[
817,
882,
882,
895
],
[
885,
881,
898,
895
],
[
87,
897,
109,
909
],
[
111,
897,
146,
909
],
[
148,
897,
164,
909
],
[
167,
897,
190,
909
],
[
192,
898,
266,
909
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
what does acc stands for?
|
The American Chemistry Council
|
724
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Comments",
"to",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"on",
"Its",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"INTRODUCTION",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"provide",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"these",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"proposed",
"procedures",
"for",
"prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA)",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"ACC",
"strongly",
"supported",
"Congress's",
"efforts",
"to",
"update",
"and",
"reform",
"TSCA.",
"One",
"of",
"ACC's",
"principles",
"for",
"modernizing",
"TSCA",
"called",
"on",
"EPA",
"to",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations.",
"Without",
"a",
"scientifically",
"based",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"EPA",
"would",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"meet",
"efficiently",
"the",
"other",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"achieve",
"the",
"objectives",
"of",
"TSCA",
"reform",
"that",
"Congress",
"intended.",
"As",
"discussed",
"in",
"more",
"detail",
"below,",
"EPA's",
"proposed",
"prioritization",
"process",
"falls",
"short.",
"Congress",
"designed",
"the",
"LCSA",
"to",
"allow",
"chemicals",
"to",
"be",
"systematically",
"prioritized",
"and",
"then",
"to",
"evaluate",
"those",
"substances",
"presenting",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"risk.",
"This",
"design",
"is",
"apparent",
"in",
"every",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"It",
"begins",
"with",
"a",
"reclassification",
"of",
"the",
"full",
"catalog",
"of",
"chemistries",
"in",
"U.S.",
"commerce,",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory.",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"that",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"be",
"sorted,",
"so",
"that",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"currently",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"separated",
"from",
"those",
"no",
"longer",
"manufactured,",
"imported",
"or",
"used;",
"only",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"prioritization",
"and",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"This",
"enables",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"resources",
"for",
"its",
"multi-year,",
"time-and-resource",
"intensive",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"actually",
"in",
"current",
"use.",
"EPA",
"must",
"next",
"undertake",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"sequence",
"of",
"chemicals",
"that",
"will",
"undergo",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"must",
"then",
"undertake",
"a",
"formal",
"scoping",
"process,",
"to",
"define",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"(and",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"sub-populations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"use)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"chemical.",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"various",
"purposes",
"is",
"not",
"new",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"In",
"2011,",
"EPA",
"held",
"a",
"Stakeholder",
"Dialogue",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"and",
"established",
"a",
"Discussion",
"Blog",
"for",
"additional",
"input",
"on",
"the",
"topic.",
"In",
"our",
"comments",
"to",
"that",
"discussion",
"blog,",
"ACC",
"identified",
"several",
"general",
"principles",
"for",
"prioritization",
"(Attachment",
"A).",
"We",
"believe",
"these",
"principles",
"are",
"reflected",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA",
"requirements,",
"in",
"particular",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"recognition",
"that",
"prioritization",
"is",
"a",
"risk",
"based",
"screening",
"process",
"that",
"integrates",
"information",
"on",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"In",
"2011,",
"ACC",
"developed",
"a",
"two-step",
"quantitative",
"and",
"qualitative",
"tool",
"to",
"\"proof",
"test\"",
"our",
"prioritization",
"principles",
"(Attachment",
"B).",
"We",
"presented",
"our",
"principles",
"and",
"our",
"prioritization",
"tool",
"to",
"EPA",
"in",
"2011,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"other",
"industry",
"and",
"NGO",
"stakeholders",
"at",
"the",
"time.",
"In",
"2012,",
"EPA",
"published",
"its",
"methodology",
"to",
"identify",
"chemicals",
"for",
"its",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
368,
64,
451,
80
],
[
457,
64,
548,
80
],
[
551,
62,
616,
80
],
[
277,
84,
366,
100
],
[
370,
84,
389,
100
],
[
392,
85,
428,
100
],
[
432,
85,
560,
100
],
[
564,
85,
651,
100
],
[
656,
85,
718,
100
],
[
722,
85,
745,
100
],
[
260,
103,
283,
119
],
[
287,
103,
366,
119
],
[
370,
104,
467,
120
],
[
470,
105,
497,
120
],
[
501,
105,
615,
120
],
[
619,
105,
638,
120
],
[
642,
104,
728,
120
],
[
731,
103,
761,
119
],
[
253,
124,
294,
139
],
[
297,
124,
389,
139
],
[
392,
125,
445,
139
],
[
449,
125,
478,
139
],
[
481,
125,
528,
139
],
[
531,
125,
627,
139
],
[
631,
125,
696,
139
],
[
700,
125,
727,
139
],
[
454,
159,
597,
173
],
[
198,
193,
230,
208
],
[
233,
194,
312,
209
],
[
315,
194,
399,
210
],
[
402,
193,
465,
210
],
[
468,
193,
523,
210
],
[
526,
193,
542,
210
],
[
545,
193,
606,
210
],
[
609,
193,
625,
210
],
[
628,
193,
691,
210
],
[
694,
192,
721,
209
],
[
723,
192,
756,
209
],
[
140,
213,
256,
229
],
[
260,
214,
342,
230
],
[
346,
214,
408,
230
],
[
411,
214,
464,
230
],
[
467,
214,
508,
230
],
[
512,
214,
595,
230
],
[
598,
214,
619,
230
],
[
622,
214,
648,
230
],
[
651,
214,
728,
230
],
[
731,
214,
804,
230
],
[
137,
234,
225,
250
],
[
230,
234,
252,
250
],
[
256,
234,
361,
250
],
[
365,
234,
382,
249
],
[
387,
234,
465,
249
],
[
470,
234,
492,
249
],
[
496,
234,
528,
249
],
[
532,
233,
614,
249
],
[
617,
233,
664,
249
],
[
667,
233,
694,
249
],
[
698,
233,
744,
249
],
[
748,
233,
838,
249
],
[
139,
253,
201,
269
],
[
205,
253,
233,
269
],
[
236,
253,
301,
270
],
[
304,
254,
322,
270
],
[
325,
254,
397,
270
],
[
400,
254,
422,
270
],
[
425,
254,
451,
270
],
[
454,
254,
547,
270
],
[
550,
253,
627,
270
],
[
630,
253,
682,
270
],
[
685,
253,
715,
270
],
[
718,
253,
790,
269
],
[
793,
253,
820,
269
],
[
138,
272,
190,
289
],
[
193,
273,
257,
289
],
[
261,
273,
300,
290
],
[
304,
273,
321,
290
],
[
324,
273,
398,
290
],
[
402,
274,
422,
290
],
[
427,
274,
464,
290
],
[
468,
274,
477,
290
],
[
480,
274,
563,
290
],
[
567,
274,
642,
290
],
[
646,
274,
707,
290
],
[
711,
274,
727,
290
],
[
731,
274,
792,
290
],
[
796,
274,
834,
289
],
[
140,
294,
167,
309
],
[
171,
294,
201,
310
],
[
205,
294,
267,
310
],
[
270,
295,
355,
310
],
[
359,
295,
383,
310
],
[
387,
295,
417,
310
],
[
421,
294,
512,
310
],
[
516,
294,
561,
310
],
[
565,
294,
590,
309
],
[
594,
294,
647,
309
],
[
198,
326,
240,
343
],
[
243,
326,
308,
343
],
[
312,
326,
391,
343
],
[
395,
327,
482,
343
],
[
487,
327,
538,
343
],
[
542,
327,
558,
343
],
[
562,
326,
615,
343
],
[
620,
326,
649,
342
],
[
653,
326,
705,
342
],
[
712,
326,
768,
342
],
[
772,
326,
805,
342
],
[
809,
326,
830,
342
],
[
140,
346,
192,
363
],
[
197,
346,
276,
363
],
[
281,
346,
303,
362
],
[
307,
346,
410,
362
],
[
414,
346,
464,
362
],
[
467,
346,
516,
362
],
[
520,
346,
540,
362
],
[
544,
347,
581,
362
],
[
585,
347,
602,
362
],
[
606,
347,
718,
362
],
[
722,
347,
797,
362
],
[
139,
366,
218,
382
],
[
222,
366,
244,
382
],
[
248,
366,
320,
382
],
[
324,
366,
341,
382
],
[
345,
367,
376,
382
],
[
380,
367,
477,
382
],
[
481,
367,
545,
382
],
[
550,
367,
558,
382
],
[
562,
367,
664,
382
],
[
668,
367,
714,
382
],
[
717,
366,
825,
382
],
[
138,
387,
204,
402
],
[
207,
387,
244,
402
],
[
249,
387,
299,
402
],
[
302,
387,
328,
402
],
[
332,
387,
352,
402
],
[
356,
387,
390,
402
],
[
394,
387,
410,
402
],
[
414,
387,
453,
402
],
[
457,
387,
539,
402
],
[
542,
387,
568,
402
],
[
572,
387,
612,
402
],
[
616,
386,
721,
402
],
[
725,
386,
741,
402
],
[
745,
386,
771,
401
],
[
774,
386,
826,
401
],
[
831,
385,
860,
401
],
[
140,
406,
198,
423
],
[
202,
407,
229,
423
],
[
232,
407,
314,
423
],
[
317,
407,
336,
423
],
[
340,
407,
388,
423
],
[
392,
407,
444,
423
],
[
451,
407,
482,
423
],
[
485,
407,
560,
423
],
[
564,
407,
639,
423
],
[
642,
407,
667,
422
],
[
671,
407,
744,
422
],
[
748,
407,
764,
422
],
[
768,
407,
812,
422
],
[
817,
406,
855,
422
],
[
138,
426,
192,
443
],
[
197,
426,
248,
443
],
[
252,
427,
324,
443
],
[
328,
427,
432,
443
],
[
435,
428,
497,
443
],
[
500,
428,
536,
442
],
[
539,
427,
584,
442
],
[
199,
459,
274,
475
],
[
277,
460,
346,
475
],
[
350,
460,
374,
475
],
[
377,
460,
430,
475
],
[
433,
460,
450,
475
],
[
454,
460,
498,
475
],
[
503,
460,
582,
475
],
[
585,
460,
602,
475
],
[
605,
460,
625,
475
],
[
629,
459,
742,
475
],
[
745,
459,
830,
475
],
[
833,
459,
864,
475
],
[
138,
479,
172,
495
],
[
176,
480,
193,
495
],
[
197,
480,
264,
495
],
[
268,
480,
310,
495
],
[
314,
480,
399,
495
],
[
402,
480,
485,
495
],
[
489,
480,
515,
495
],
[
519,
480,
581,
495
],
[
585,
480,
654,
495
],
[
658,
480,
696,
495
],
[
700,
480,
738,
495
],
[
742,
479,
790,
495
],
[
794,
479,
806,
495
],
[
140,
500,
207,
515
],
[
210,
500,
228,
515
],
[
231,
500,
276,
515
],
[
279,
500,
312,
515
],
[
315,
500,
332,
515
],
[
335,
500,
361,
515
],
[
364,
500,
422,
515
],
[
424,
500,
438,
515
],
[
441,
500,
495,
515
],
[
498,
500,
535,
515
],
[
538,
500,
548,
515
],
[
551,
500,
672,
515
],
[
675,
500,
692,
515
],
[
695,
500,
722,
515
],
[
725,
500,
755,
515
],
[
757,
499,
817,
515
],
[
820,
499,
841,
515
],
[
140,
520,
228,
535
],
[
232,
520,
250,
536
],
[
254,
520,
290,
536
],
[
294,
520,
380,
536
],
[
384,
520,
411,
536
],
[
415,
520,
464,
536
],
[
468,
520,
552,
536
],
[
556,
520,
586,
536
],
[
590,
520,
642,
535
],
[
645,
520,
710,
535
],
[
713,
520,
744,
535
],
[
748,
520,
775,
535
],
[
780,
519,
828,
535
],
[
139,
540,
215,
555
],
[
218,
540,
240,
555
],
[
243,
540,
297,
555
],
[
301,
540,
319,
555
],
[
322,
540,
354,
555
],
[
358,
540,
437,
555
],
[
440,
541,
471,
555
],
[
475,
541,
501,
555
],
[
505,
541,
577,
555
],
[
581,
541,
628,
555
],
[
631,
541,
649,
555
],
[
652,
540,
736,
555
],
[
740,
540,
765,
555
],
[
768,
540,
845,
555
],
[
138,
560,
174,
575
],
[
181,
560,
223,
575
],
[
227,
560,
248,
575
],
[
252,
560,
304,
575
],
[
307,
560,
420,
576
],
[
424,
560,
497,
576
],
[
501,
560,
518,
576
],
[
522,
560,
565,
576
],
[
568,
560,
605,
575
],
[
609,
560,
687,
575
],
[
690,
561,
724,
575
],
[
727,
561,
751,
575
],
[
754,
561,
802,
575
],
[
806,
561,
823,
574
],
[
141,
581,
222,
595
],
[
225,
581,
250,
595
],
[
254,
581,
311,
595
],
[
314,
581,
330,
595
],
[
334,
581,
359,
595
],
[
362,
581,
467,
595
],
[
471,
581,
501,
595
],
[
504,
581,
535,
595
],
[
539,
581,
629,
595
],
[
632,
581,
666,
595
],
[
670,
581,
731,
595
],
[
734,
581,
770,
595
],
[
776,
581,
792,
595
],
[
795,
580,
840,
595
],
[
137,
600,
213,
616
],
[
217,
601,
241,
616
],
[
244,
601,
264,
616
],
[
268,
601,
356,
616
],
[
360,
601,
504,
616
],
[
507,
601,
580,
616
],
[
584,
601,
615,
616
],
[
619,
601,
709,
616
],
[
712,
601,
734,
616
],
[
737,
600,
817,
615
],
[
820,
600,
850,
615
],
[
140,
621,
164,
635
],
[
167,
621,
230,
635
],
[
234,
621,
251,
635
],
[
254,
621,
311,
635
],
[
315,
621,
349,
635
],
[
352,
621,
387,
635
],
[
392,
621,
432,
636
],
[
435,
621,
472,
636
],
[
475,
621,
554,
636
],
[
558,
621,
567,
636
],
[
571,
621,
674,
636
],
[
677,
621,
743,
635
],
[
746,
621,
764,
635
],
[
767,
620,
817,
635
],
[
825,
620,
850,
635
],
[
139,
641,
212,
655
],
[
215,
641,
233,
655
],
[
237,
641,
316,
656
],
[
320,
641,
352,
656
],
[
355,
641,
386,
656
],
[
390,
640,
455,
656
],
[
458,
640,
490,
656
],
[
492,
640,
582,
656
],
[
585,
640,
621,
656
],
[
627,
640,
667,
656
],
[
670,
640,
705,
655
],
[
708,
640,
787,
655
],
[
790,
640,
802,
655
],
[
804,
640,
860,
655
],
[
139,
662,
200,
675
],
[
203,
661,
270,
676
],
[
272,
661,
290,
676
],
[
297,
661,
344,
676
],
[
347,
661,
373,
676
],
[
376,
661,
460,
676
],
[
463,
661,
482,
676
],
[
485,
661,
513,
676
],
[
516,
661,
552,
676
],
[
555,
661,
641,
676
],
[
644,
661,
710,
676
],
[
714,
661,
835,
676
],
[
138,
681,
202,
695
],
[
205,
681,
222,
695
],
[
225,
681,
252,
695
],
[
255,
681,
289,
695
],
[
292,
681,
326,
695
],
[
329,
681,
359,
695
],
[
362,
681,
382,
695
],
[
385,
681,
455,
696
],
[
458,
681,
475,
696
],
[
478,
681,
505,
696
],
[
508,
681,
555,
696
],
[
558,
680,
576,
696
],
[
579,
680,
604,
696
],
[
607,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
725,
696
],
[
728,
680,
745,
695
],
[
748,
680,
775,
695
],
[
778,
680,
855,
695
],
[
197,
713,
303,
729
],
[
307,
714,
323,
729
],
[
327,
714,
407,
729
],
[
411,
714,
435,
729
],
[
439,
714,
496,
729
],
[
500,
714,
571,
729
],
[
575,
714,
589,
729
],
[
593,
714,
620,
729
],
[
624,
714,
655,
729
],
[
661,
714,
677,
729
],
[
681,
714,
708,
729
],
[
711,
713,
783,
729
],
[
786,
713,
805,
729
],
[
808,
712,
854,
729
],
[
139,
732,
175,
748
],
[
180,
733,
216,
748
],
[
220,
733,
230,
748
],
[
234,
733,
328,
748
],
[
331,
734,
405,
748
],
[
408,
734,
430,
749
],
[
433,
734,
538,
749
],
[
542,
734,
571,
749
],
[
574,
734,
663,
749
],
[
666,
734,
677,
749
],
[
680,
733,
768,
749
],
[
771,
733,
811,
749
],
[
814,
733,
839,
748
],
[
140,
753,
218,
768
],
[
221,
754,
264,
769
],
[
268,
754,
287,
769
],
[
291,
754,
317,
769
],
[
320,
754,
367,
769
],
[
370,
755,
388,
769
],
[
391,
755,
418,
769
],
[
422,
755,
504,
769
],
[
507,
754,
523,
769
],
[
527,
754,
561,
769
],
[
565,
754,
644,
769
],
[
648,
754,
691,
769
],
[
694,
753,
734,
768
],
[
738,
752,
812,
768
],
[
140,
774,
196,
789
],
[
200,
774,
258,
789
],
[
261,
774,
340,
789
],
[
344,
774,
368,
789
],
[
371,
774,
475,
789
],
[
479,
774,
580,
789
],
[
584,
774,
610,
789
],
[
614,
774,
640,
789
],
[
644,
773,
702,
789
],
[
706,
773,
748,
789
],
[
752,
773,
830,
789
],
[
834,
773,
859,
789
],
[
138,
793,
208,
809
],
[
212,
793,
228,
809
],
[
232,
793,
258,
809
],
[
261,
794,
311,
809
],
[
315,
794,
425,
810
],
[
428,
794,
444,
810
],
[
447,
794,
525,
810
],
[
528,
794,
554,
810
],
[
558,
794,
622,
810
],
[
626,
794,
718,
810
],
[
721,
794,
751,
809
],
[
755,
793,
861,
809
],
[
138,
813,
153,
828
],
[
157,
813,
166,
828
],
[
170,
814,
200,
828
],
[
203,
814,
251,
829
],
[
255,
814,
330,
829
],
[
334,
815,
394,
829
],
[
398,
815,
428,
829
],
[
431,
815,
510,
829
],
[
513,
815,
607,
829
],
[
611,
815,
631,
829
],
[
634,
815,
671,
829
],
[
675,
814,
729,
829
],
[
732,
814,
762,
829
],
[
766,
814,
839,
829
],
[
137,
833,
214,
849
],
[
217,
833,
234,
849
],
[
238,
834,
284,
849
],
[
287,
834,
328,
849
],
[
335,
834,
414,
849
],
[
418,
834,
427,
849
],
[
431,
834,
500,
849
],
[
504,
834,
599,
849
],
[
603,
834,
632,
849
],
[
635,
834,
719,
849
],
[
722,
834,
754,
849
],
[
758,
834,
775,
848
],
[
779,
833,
832,
848
],
[
139,
854,
177,
869
],
[
180,
854,
206,
869
],
[
210,
854,
314,
869
],
[
317,
854,
397,
869
],
[
400,
854,
501,
869
],
[
504,
854,
531,
869
],
[
534,
854,
561,
869
],
[
564,
854,
642,
869
],
[
645,
854,
672,
869
],
[
675,
854,
756,
869
],
[
759,
854,
790,
869
],
[
792,
854,
819,
869
],
[
138,
874,
241,
889
],
[
245,
874,
278,
889
],
[
281,
874,
298,
889
],
[
302,
874,
338,
889
],
[
343,
874,
360,
890
],
[
364,
874,
410,
890
],
[
413,
874,
431,
890
],
[
435,
874,
469,
890
],
[
472,
874,
490,
890
],
[
493,
874,
511,
890
],
[
515,
873,
555,
890
],
[
558,
873,
625,
890
],
[
628,
873,
658,
890
],
[
661,
873,
702,
890
],
[
710,
873,
809,
889
],
[
812,
873,
827,
889
],
[
831,
873,
856,
889
],
[
138,
892,
179,
908
],
[
183,
892,
200,
909
],
[
204,
893,
250,
909
],
[
254,
893,
291,
909
],
[
295,
893,
372,
910
],
[
377,
893,
397,
910
],
[
400,
893,
504,
910
],
[
508,
893,
525,
910
],
[
530,
893,
591,
910
],
[
595,
892,
674,
910
],
[
678,
892,
702,
910
],
[
706,
892,
727,
909
],
[
731,
892,
780,
909
],
[
787,
892,
829,
909
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
In which year, EPA held a Stakeholder Dialogue on prioritization?
|
2011
|
751
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"WASHINGTON,",
"D.C.",
"20460",
"June",
"9,",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"CHEMICAL",
"SAFETY",
"AND",
"POLLUTION",
"PREVENTION",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Recusal",
"Statement",
"FROM:",
"Nancy",
"B.",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"TO:",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Because",
"I",
"am",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"position,",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"not",
"subject",
"to",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770",
"and",
"therefore",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge.",
"But",
"as",
"an",
"executive",
"branch",
"employee,",
"I",
"have",
"always",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"statutes",
"codified",
"at",
"Title",
"18",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Code",
"and",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635.",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"the",
"federal",
"impartiality",
"standards,",
"I",
"have",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"\"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"my",
"former",
"employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"and",
"have",
"recused",
"myself",
"from",
"participating",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party.",
"I",
"was",
"advised",
"by",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"my",
"recusal",
"period",
"commenced",
"the",
"day",
"that",
"I",
"left",
"ACC",
"and",
"would",
"remain",
"in",
"effect",
"for",
"one",
"year",
"unless",
"I",
"was",
"authorized",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"to",
"participate",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"have",
"sought",
"and",
"obtained",
"confirmation",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"in",
"particular",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"such",
"as",
"rulemaking,",
"even",
"if",
"my",
"former",
"employer",
"has",
"an",
"interest,",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"discussions",
"or",
"consideration",
"of",
"comments",
"that",
"ACC",
"submitted",
"with",
"regard",
"to",
"rulemaking",
"or",
"other",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability.",
"See",
"attached.",
"I",
"am",
"also",
"now",
"authorized",
"to",
"attend",
"meetings",
"at",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"present",
"or",
"represented,",
"provided",
"that",
"the",
"subject",
"matter",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"is",
"a",
"matter",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"if",
"other",
"interested",
"non-federal",
"parties",
"are",
"present,",
"and",
"other",
"EPA",
"personnel",
"attend.",
"For",
"the",
"remainder",
"of",
"my",
"cooling",
"off",
"period,",
"until",
"April",
"21,",
"2018,",
"however,",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"I",
"cannot",
"otherwise",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"involving",
"ACC",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"seek",
"approval",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/pfcn0226"
] |
[
[
272,
93,
334,
108
],
[
338,
93,
397,
108
],
[
400,
93,
545,
109
],
[
548,
93,
651,
109
],
[
655,
93,
723,
108
],
[
272,
115,
394,
130
],
[
397,
115,
431,
130
],
[
435,
115,
486,
130
],
[
281,
170,
318,
185
],
[
321,
169,
338,
185
],
[
341,
169,
384,
185
],
[
735,
204,
778,
216
],
[
781,
205,
798,
216
],
[
801,
204,
865,
216
],
[
868,
204,
911,
216
],
[
730,
220,
756,
232
],
[
760,
220,
830,
231
],
[
833,
219,
912,
231
],
[
115,
240,
269,
257
],
[
115,
275,
204,
290
],
[
208,
276,
272,
290
],
[
276,
276,
356,
291
],
[
112,
311,
177,
327
],
[
232,
312,
285,
328
],
[
288,
312,
308,
328
],
[
312,
312,
358,
328
],
[
361,
312,
412,
328
],
[
417,
311,
472,
328
],
[
236,
331,
293,
347
],
[
297,
332,
371,
347
],
[
374,
331,
487,
347
],
[
114,
368,
145,
382
],
[
235,
368,
292,
384
],
[
295,
368,
434,
385
],
[
234,
387,
287,
404
],
[
291,
388,
364,
404
],
[
368,
387,
481,
404
],
[
175,
443,
241,
458
],
[
244,
443,
252,
458
],
[
255,
443,
277,
458
],
[
284,
443,
301,
458
],
[
305,
444,
326,
458
],
[
330,
444,
462,
458
],
[
467,
444,
560,
459
],
[
564,
444,
634,
459
],
[
638,
444,
644,
458
],
[
648,
443,
686,
458
],
[
690,
443,
729,
458
],
[
732,
443,
793,
458
],
[
797,
442,
818,
458
],
[
821,
442,
847,
458
],
[
115,
460,
164,
477
],
[
168,
460,
186,
477
],
[
190,
460,
252,
477
],
[
257,
461,
376,
477
],
[
380,
461,
490,
477
],
[
494,
461,
526,
477
],
[
530,
461,
537,
477
],
[
541,
461,
563,
477
],
[
569,
461,
597,
477
],
[
601,
461,
656,
477
],
[
660,
461,
677,
477
],
[
681,
460,
760,
477
],
[
764,
460,
811,
476
],
[
815,
460,
865,
476
],
[
115,
480,
144,
494
],
[
147,
480,
218,
495
],
[
222,
480,
248,
495
],
[
251,
480,
319,
495
],
[
322,
480,
340,
495
],
[
344,
480,
377,
495
],
[
381,
480,
408,
495
],
[
411,
480,
465,
495
],
[
468,
480,
515,
495
],
[
518,
480,
577,
495
],
[
581,
480,
612,
495
],
[
615,
480,
633,
495
],
[
636,
480,
655,
495
],
[
659,
480,
735,
495
],
[
738,
480,
794,
494
],
[
114,
498,
197,
514
],
[
200,
498,
207,
514
],
[
211,
498,
249,
514
],
[
252,
498,
309,
514
],
[
313,
497,
401,
514
],
[
404,
497,
436,
514
],
[
440,
497,
446,
514
],
[
450,
497,
472,
514
],
[
480,
497,
537,
514
],
[
540,
497,
556,
514
],
[
560,
497,
586,
514
],
[
590,
497,
650,
514
],
[
654,
497,
671,
513
],
[
675,
497,
735,
513
],
[
738,
497,
800,
513
],
[
802,
497,
867,
513
],
[
114,
515,
131,
531
],
[
134,
515,
172,
531
],
[
176,
515,
196,
531
],
[
200,
515,
217,
531
],
[
221,
515,
246,
531
],
[
250,
515,
305,
531
],
[
309,
515,
357,
531
],
[
360,
516,
402,
531
],
[
407,
516,
434,
531
],
[
438,
516,
464,
531
],
[
468,
516,
547,
531
],
[
551,
516,
567,
531
],
[
571,
516,
629,
531
],
[
632,
515,
700,
531
],
[
704,
515,
728,
531
],
[
731,
515,
820,
531
],
[
823,
515,
841,
530
],
[
844,
515,
872,
530
],
[
114,
533,
193,
549
],
[
197,
533,
260,
549
],
[
264,
533,
274,
549
],
[
278,
533,
332,
549
],
[
335,
533,
368,
549
],
[
371,
533,
417,
549
],
[
421,
533,
490,
549
],
[
494,
533,
511,
549
],
[
515,
533,
541,
549
],
[
544,
533,
599,
549
],
[
602,
533,
697,
549
],
[
700,
533,
780,
549
],
[
784,
533,
791,
549
],
[
794,
533,
832,
549
],
[
113,
553,
202,
567
],
[
205,
553,
237,
568
],
[
240,
553,
248,
568
],
[
250,
553,
291,
568
],
[
293,
553,
304,
568
],
[
307,
552,
379,
568
],
[
381,
552,
485,
568
],
[
488,
552,
525,
568
],
[
527,
552,
555,
568
],
[
557,
552,
614,
568
],
[
615,
552,
697,
568
],
[
699,
553,
727,
568
],
[
729,
553,
805,
568
],
[
115,
570,
198,
586
],
[
201,
570,
264,
586
],
[
267,
570,
327,
587
],
[
330,
570,
359,
587
],
[
362,
570,
401,
587
],
[
404,
570,
466,
587
],
[
469,
570,
526,
587
],
[
530,
570,
567,
587
],
[
572,
570,
672,
587
],
[
675,
570,
761,
587
],
[
764,
571,
793,
587
],
[
113,
588,
214,
603
],
[
217,
589,
235,
603
],
[
238,
589,
267,
604
],
[
270,
589,
347,
604
],
[
351,
589,
402,
604
],
[
405,
589,
483,
604
],
[
487,
589,
548,
604
],
[
552,
589,
605,
604
],
[
609,
589,
628,
604
],
[
631,
588,
680,
604
],
[
684,
588,
722,
604
],
[
728,
588,
744,
604
],
[
747,
588,
756,
604
],
[
760,
588,
802,
604
],
[
805,
588,
827,
603
],
[
115,
606,
195,
622
],
[
199,
606,
207,
622
],
[
211,
606,
258,
622
],
[
262,
606,
270,
622
],
[
274,
606,
305,
622
],
[
309,
606,
369,
622
],
[
373,
606,
395,
622
],
[
399,
605,
495,
622
],
[
500,
605,
530,
621
],
[
533,
605,
560,
621
],
[
563,
605,
620,
621
],
[
624,
605,
676,
621
],
[
680,
605,
775,
621
],
[
779,
605,
807,
621
],
[
810,
605,
837,
621
],
[
840,
605,
873,
621
],
[
114,
623,
121,
639
],
[
125,
623,
153,
639
],
[
157,
624,
197,
640
],
[
202,
624,
232,
640
],
[
235,
624,
284,
640
],
[
287,
624,
344,
640
],
[
347,
624,
365,
640
],
[
368,
624,
414,
640
],
[
418,
625,
442,
640
],
[
446,
625,
475,
640
],
[
479,
625,
514,
640
],
[
518,
624,
568,
640
],
[
571,
624,
580,
640
],
[
583,
624,
614,
640
],
[
618,
624,
702,
640
],
[
706,
624,
728,
639
],
[
731,
624,
757,
639
],
[
760,
624,
811,
639
],
[
815,
624,
834,
638
],
[
115,
641,
178,
658
],
[
181,
641,
300,
658
],
[
303,
642,
414,
658
],
[
417,
642,
434,
658
],
[
438,
642,
522,
658
],
[
527,
642,
594,
658
],
[
598,
642,
615,
658
],
[
619,
642,
631,
658
],
[
634,
642,
687,
658
],
[
691,
641,
793,
657
],
[
174,
680,
181,
695
],
[
184,
680,
222,
695
],
[
226,
680,
280,
695
],
[
284,
680,
313,
695
],
[
317,
680,
387,
695
],
[
390,
680,
492,
695
],
[
497,
680,
532,
695
],
[
540,
680,
635,
695
],
[
640,
680,
671,
695
],
[
675,
680,
683,
695
],
[
687,
680,
713,
695
],
[
717,
680,
802,
695
],
[
806,
680,
824,
695
],
[
114,
697,
189,
713
],
[
192,
697,
253,
713
],
[
257,
698,
275,
713
],
[
279,
698,
337,
713
],
[
340,
698,
444,
713
],
[
448,
698,
485,
713
],
[
489,
698,
506,
713
],
[
510,
698,
605,
713
],
[
610,
698,
647,
713
],
[
650,
698,
664,
713
],
[
668,
698,
694,
713
],
[
698,
698,
753,
713
],
[
757,
697,
831,
713
],
[
835,
697,
862,
713
],
[
114,
716,
132,
730
],
[
136,
716,
201,
731
],
[
205,
716,
234,
731
],
[
238,
716,
270,
731
],
[
273,
716,
280,
731
],
[
284,
716,
312,
732
],
[
316,
716,
400,
732
],
[
404,
716,
487,
732
],
[
490,
716,
521,
732
],
[
525,
716,
625,
732
],
[
628,
716,
645,
731
],
[
649,
716,
680,
731
],
[
683,
716,
772,
731
],
[
776,
716,
794,
730
],
[
115,
734,
221,
749
],
[
224,
734,
243,
749
],
[
246,
734,
327,
749
],
[
330,
734,
364,
749
],
[
367,
734,
407,
749
],
[
411,
734,
491,
749
],
[
494,
734,
530,
749
],
[
533,
734,
585,
749
],
[
588,
734,
604,
749
],
[
608,
734,
700,
749
],
[
703,
734,
720,
749
],
[
724,
734,
765,
749
],
[
769,
734,
829,
749
],
[
832,
734,
852,
748
],
[
115,
752,
172,
768
],
[
177,
752,
281,
768
],
[
284,
752,
312,
768
],
[
317,
752,
387,
768
],
[
391,
752,
400,
768
],
[
403,
752,
425,
768
],
[
432,
752,
463,
768
],
[
467,
752,
502,
768
],
[
508,
752,
591,
768
],
[
595,
752,
611,
767
],
[
615,
752,
665,
767
],
[
668,
751,
741,
767
],
[
744,
751,
759,
767
],
[
762,
751,
812,
767
],
[
816,
751,
857,
766
],
[
860,
751,
879,
766
],
[
117,
770,
172,
786
],
[
176,
770,
191,
785
],
[
195,
770,
292,
785
],
[
295,
770,
368,
785
],
[
371,
770,
401,
785
],
[
405,
770,
431,
785
],
[
435,
770,
492,
785
],
[
495,
770,
547,
785
],
[
551,
770,
568,
785
],
[
571,
770,
596,
785
],
[
600,
770,
664,
785
],
[
668,
770,
684,
785
],
[
687,
770,
697,
785
],
[
700,
770,
752,
785
],
[
755,
770,
774,
785
],
[
777,
770,
834,
785
],
[
114,
788,
217,
804
],
[
221,
788,
235,
804
],
[
238,
788,
279,
804
],
[
282,
788,
361,
804
],
[
364,
788,
456,
804
],
[
460,
788,
514,
804
],
[
517,
788,
543,
804
],
[
547,
788,
609,
804
],
[
612,
788,
642,
804
],
[
646,
788,
688,
804
],
[
691,
788,
730,
804
],
[
733,
788,
811,
804
],
[
814,
787,
869,
803
],
[
115,
806,
142,
820
],
[
145,
806,
171,
820
],
[
173,
806,
256,
821
],
[
258,
806,
277,
821
],
[
280,
806,
307,
821
],
[
310,
806,
371,
822
],
[
374,
806,
398,
822
],
[
401,
806,
459,
822
],
[
462,
806,
501,
822
],
[
504,
806,
547,
822
],
[
550,
806,
575,
822
],
[
578,
806,
624,
822
],
[
627,
806,
703,
822
],
[
706,
806,
714,
822
],
[
716,
805,
804,
822
],
[
807,
805,
840,
821
],
[
842,
805,
852,
821
],
[
115,
824,
168,
839
],
[
171,
824,
247,
840
],
[
251,
824,
335,
840
],
[
339,
824,
357,
840
],
[
361,
824,
390,
840
],
[
394,
824,
455,
841
],
[
458,
824,
501,
841
],
[
504,
824,
555,
841
],
[
559,
823,
637,
841
],
[
641,
823,
680,
840
],
[
684,
823,
735,
840
],
[
738,
823,
747,
840
],
[
751,
823,
784,
840
],
[
787,
822,
824,
839
],
[
115,
843,
182,
860
],
[
187,
843,
224,
858
],
[
231,
842,
337,
858
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
By whom is this document written?
|
Nancy B. Beck
|
751
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"WASHINGTON,",
"D.C.",
"20460",
"June",
"9,",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"CHEMICAL",
"SAFETY",
"AND",
"POLLUTION",
"PREVENTION",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Recusal",
"Statement",
"FROM:",
"Nancy",
"B.",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"TO:",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Because",
"I",
"am",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"position,",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"not",
"subject",
"to",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770",
"and",
"therefore",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge.",
"But",
"as",
"an",
"executive",
"branch",
"employee,",
"I",
"have",
"always",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"statutes",
"codified",
"at",
"Title",
"18",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Code",
"and",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635.",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"the",
"federal",
"impartiality",
"standards,",
"I",
"have",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"\"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"my",
"former",
"employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"and",
"have",
"recused",
"myself",
"from",
"participating",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party.",
"I",
"was",
"advised",
"by",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"my",
"recusal",
"period",
"commenced",
"the",
"day",
"that",
"I",
"left",
"ACC",
"and",
"would",
"remain",
"in",
"effect",
"for",
"one",
"year",
"unless",
"I",
"was",
"authorized",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"to",
"participate",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"have",
"sought",
"and",
"obtained",
"confirmation",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"in",
"particular",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"such",
"as",
"rulemaking,",
"even",
"if",
"my",
"former",
"employer",
"has",
"an",
"interest,",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"discussions",
"or",
"consideration",
"of",
"comments",
"that",
"ACC",
"submitted",
"with",
"regard",
"to",
"rulemaking",
"or",
"other",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability.",
"See",
"attached.",
"I",
"am",
"also",
"now",
"authorized",
"to",
"attend",
"meetings",
"at",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"present",
"or",
"represented,",
"provided",
"that",
"the",
"subject",
"matter",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"is",
"a",
"matter",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"if",
"other",
"interested",
"non-federal",
"parties",
"are",
"present,",
"and",
"other",
"EPA",
"personnel",
"attend.",
"For",
"the",
"remainder",
"of",
"my",
"cooling",
"off",
"period,",
"until",
"April",
"21,",
"2018,",
"however,",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"I",
"cannot",
"otherwise",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"involving",
"ACC",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"seek",
"approval",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/pfcn0226"
] |
[
[
272,
93,
334,
108
],
[
338,
93,
397,
108
],
[
400,
93,
545,
109
],
[
548,
93,
651,
109
],
[
655,
93,
723,
108
],
[
272,
115,
394,
130
],
[
397,
115,
431,
130
],
[
435,
115,
486,
130
],
[
281,
170,
318,
185
],
[
321,
169,
338,
185
],
[
341,
169,
384,
185
],
[
735,
204,
778,
216
],
[
781,
205,
798,
216
],
[
801,
204,
865,
216
],
[
868,
204,
911,
216
],
[
730,
220,
756,
232
],
[
760,
220,
830,
231
],
[
833,
219,
912,
231
],
[
115,
240,
269,
257
],
[
115,
275,
204,
290
],
[
208,
276,
272,
290
],
[
276,
276,
356,
291
],
[
112,
311,
177,
327
],
[
232,
312,
285,
328
],
[
288,
312,
308,
328
],
[
312,
312,
358,
328
],
[
361,
312,
412,
328
],
[
417,
311,
472,
328
],
[
236,
331,
293,
347
],
[
297,
332,
371,
347
],
[
374,
331,
487,
347
],
[
114,
368,
145,
382
],
[
235,
368,
292,
384
],
[
295,
368,
434,
385
],
[
234,
387,
287,
404
],
[
291,
388,
364,
404
],
[
368,
387,
481,
404
],
[
175,
443,
241,
458
],
[
244,
443,
252,
458
],
[
255,
443,
277,
458
],
[
284,
443,
301,
458
],
[
305,
444,
326,
458
],
[
330,
444,
462,
458
],
[
467,
444,
560,
459
],
[
564,
444,
634,
459
],
[
638,
444,
644,
458
],
[
648,
443,
686,
458
],
[
690,
443,
729,
458
],
[
732,
443,
793,
458
],
[
797,
442,
818,
458
],
[
821,
442,
847,
458
],
[
115,
460,
164,
477
],
[
168,
460,
186,
477
],
[
190,
460,
252,
477
],
[
257,
461,
376,
477
],
[
380,
461,
490,
477
],
[
494,
461,
526,
477
],
[
530,
461,
537,
477
],
[
541,
461,
563,
477
],
[
569,
461,
597,
477
],
[
601,
461,
656,
477
],
[
660,
461,
677,
477
],
[
681,
460,
760,
477
],
[
764,
460,
811,
476
],
[
815,
460,
865,
476
],
[
115,
480,
144,
494
],
[
147,
480,
218,
495
],
[
222,
480,
248,
495
],
[
251,
480,
319,
495
],
[
322,
480,
340,
495
],
[
344,
480,
377,
495
],
[
381,
480,
408,
495
],
[
411,
480,
465,
495
],
[
468,
480,
515,
495
],
[
518,
480,
577,
495
],
[
581,
480,
612,
495
],
[
615,
480,
633,
495
],
[
636,
480,
655,
495
],
[
659,
480,
735,
495
],
[
738,
480,
794,
494
],
[
114,
498,
197,
514
],
[
200,
498,
207,
514
],
[
211,
498,
249,
514
],
[
252,
498,
309,
514
],
[
313,
497,
401,
514
],
[
404,
497,
436,
514
],
[
440,
497,
446,
514
],
[
450,
497,
472,
514
],
[
480,
497,
537,
514
],
[
540,
497,
556,
514
],
[
560,
497,
586,
514
],
[
590,
497,
650,
514
],
[
654,
497,
671,
513
],
[
675,
497,
735,
513
],
[
738,
497,
800,
513
],
[
802,
497,
867,
513
],
[
114,
515,
131,
531
],
[
134,
515,
172,
531
],
[
176,
515,
196,
531
],
[
200,
515,
217,
531
],
[
221,
515,
246,
531
],
[
250,
515,
305,
531
],
[
309,
515,
357,
531
],
[
360,
516,
402,
531
],
[
407,
516,
434,
531
],
[
438,
516,
464,
531
],
[
468,
516,
547,
531
],
[
551,
516,
567,
531
],
[
571,
516,
629,
531
],
[
632,
515,
700,
531
],
[
704,
515,
728,
531
],
[
731,
515,
820,
531
],
[
823,
515,
841,
530
],
[
844,
515,
872,
530
],
[
114,
533,
193,
549
],
[
197,
533,
260,
549
],
[
264,
533,
274,
549
],
[
278,
533,
332,
549
],
[
335,
533,
368,
549
],
[
371,
533,
417,
549
],
[
421,
533,
490,
549
],
[
494,
533,
511,
549
],
[
515,
533,
541,
549
],
[
544,
533,
599,
549
],
[
602,
533,
697,
549
],
[
700,
533,
780,
549
],
[
784,
533,
791,
549
],
[
794,
533,
832,
549
],
[
113,
553,
202,
567
],
[
205,
553,
237,
568
],
[
240,
553,
248,
568
],
[
250,
553,
291,
568
],
[
293,
553,
304,
568
],
[
307,
552,
379,
568
],
[
381,
552,
485,
568
],
[
488,
552,
525,
568
],
[
527,
552,
555,
568
],
[
557,
552,
614,
568
],
[
615,
552,
697,
568
],
[
699,
553,
727,
568
],
[
729,
553,
805,
568
],
[
115,
570,
198,
586
],
[
201,
570,
264,
586
],
[
267,
570,
327,
587
],
[
330,
570,
359,
587
],
[
362,
570,
401,
587
],
[
404,
570,
466,
587
],
[
469,
570,
526,
587
],
[
530,
570,
567,
587
],
[
572,
570,
672,
587
],
[
675,
570,
761,
587
],
[
764,
571,
793,
587
],
[
113,
588,
214,
603
],
[
217,
589,
235,
603
],
[
238,
589,
267,
604
],
[
270,
589,
347,
604
],
[
351,
589,
402,
604
],
[
405,
589,
483,
604
],
[
487,
589,
548,
604
],
[
552,
589,
605,
604
],
[
609,
589,
628,
604
],
[
631,
588,
680,
604
],
[
684,
588,
722,
604
],
[
728,
588,
744,
604
],
[
747,
588,
756,
604
],
[
760,
588,
802,
604
],
[
805,
588,
827,
603
],
[
115,
606,
195,
622
],
[
199,
606,
207,
622
],
[
211,
606,
258,
622
],
[
262,
606,
270,
622
],
[
274,
606,
305,
622
],
[
309,
606,
369,
622
],
[
373,
606,
395,
622
],
[
399,
605,
495,
622
],
[
500,
605,
530,
621
],
[
533,
605,
560,
621
],
[
563,
605,
620,
621
],
[
624,
605,
676,
621
],
[
680,
605,
775,
621
],
[
779,
605,
807,
621
],
[
810,
605,
837,
621
],
[
840,
605,
873,
621
],
[
114,
623,
121,
639
],
[
125,
623,
153,
639
],
[
157,
624,
197,
640
],
[
202,
624,
232,
640
],
[
235,
624,
284,
640
],
[
287,
624,
344,
640
],
[
347,
624,
365,
640
],
[
368,
624,
414,
640
],
[
418,
625,
442,
640
],
[
446,
625,
475,
640
],
[
479,
625,
514,
640
],
[
518,
624,
568,
640
],
[
571,
624,
580,
640
],
[
583,
624,
614,
640
],
[
618,
624,
702,
640
],
[
706,
624,
728,
639
],
[
731,
624,
757,
639
],
[
760,
624,
811,
639
],
[
815,
624,
834,
638
],
[
115,
641,
178,
658
],
[
181,
641,
300,
658
],
[
303,
642,
414,
658
],
[
417,
642,
434,
658
],
[
438,
642,
522,
658
],
[
527,
642,
594,
658
],
[
598,
642,
615,
658
],
[
619,
642,
631,
658
],
[
634,
642,
687,
658
],
[
691,
641,
793,
657
],
[
174,
680,
181,
695
],
[
184,
680,
222,
695
],
[
226,
680,
280,
695
],
[
284,
680,
313,
695
],
[
317,
680,
387,
695
],
[
390,
680,
492,
695
],
[
497,
680,
532,
695
],
[
540,
680,
635,
695
],
[
640,
680,
671,
695
],
[
675,
680,
683,
695
],
[
687,
680,
713,
695
],
[
717,
680,
802,
695
],
[
806,
680,
824,
695
],
[
114,
697,
189,
713
],
[
192,
697,
253,
713
],
[
257,
698,
275,
713
],
[
279,
698,
337,
713
],
[
340,
698,
444,
713
],
[
448,
698,
485,
713
],
[
489,
698,
506,
713
],
[
510,
698,
605,
713
],
[
610,
698,
647,
713
],
[
650,
698,
664,
713
],
[
668,
698,
694,
713
],
[
698,
698,
753,
713
],
[
757,
697,
831,
713
],
[
835,
697,
862,
713
],
[
114,
716,
132,
730
],
[
136,
716,
201,
731
],
[
205,
716,
234,
731
],
[
238,
716,
270,
731
],
[
273,
716,
280,
731
],
[
284,
716,
312,
732
],
[
316,
716,
400,
732
],
[
404,
716,
487,
732
],
[
490,
716,
521,
732
],
[
525,
716,
625,
732
],
[
628,
716,
645,
731
],
[
649,
716,
680,
731
],
[
683,
716,
772,
731
],
[
776,
716,
794,
730
],
[
115,
734,
221,
749
],
[
224,
734,
243,
749
],
[
246,
734,
327,
749
],
[
330,
734,
364,
749
],
[
367,
734,
407,
749
],
[
411,
734,
491,
749
],
[
494,
734,
530,
749
],
[
533,
734,
585,
749
],
[
588,
734,
604,
749
],
[
608,
734,
700,
749
],
[
703,
734,
720,
749
],
[
724,
734,
765,
749
],
[
769,
734,
829,
749
],
[
832,
734,
852,
748
],
[
115,
752,
172,
768
],
[
177,
752,
281,
768
],
[
284,
752,
312,
768
],
[
317,
752,
387,
768
],
[
391,
752,
400,
768
],
[
403,
752,
425,
768
],
[
432,
752,
463,
768
],
[
467,
752,
502,
768
],
[
508,
752,
591,
768
],
[
595,
752,
611,
767
],
[
615,
752,
665,
767
],
[
668,
751,
741,
767
],
[
744,
751,
759,
767
],
[
762,
751,
812,
767
],
[
816,
751,
857,
766
],
[
860,
751,
879,
766
],
[
117,
770,
172,
786
],
[
176,
770,
191,
785
],
[
195,
770,
292,
785
],
[
295,
770,
368,
785
],
[
371,
770,
401,
785
],
[
405,
770,
431,
785
],
[
435,
770,
492,
785
],
[
495,
770,
547,
785
],
[
551,
770,
568,
785
],
[
571,
770,
596,
785
],
[
600,
770,
664,
785
],
[
668,
770,
684,
785
],
[
687,
770,
697,
785
],
[
700,
770,
752,
785
],
[
755,
770,
774,
785
],
[
777,
770,
834,
785
],
[
114,
788,
217,
804
],
[
221,
788,
235,
804
],
[
238,
788,
279,
804
],
[
282,
788,
361,
804
],
[
364,
788,
456,
804
],
[
460,
788,
514,
804
],
[
517,
788,
543,
804
],
[
547,
788,
609,
804
],
[
612,
788,
642,
804
],
[
646,
788,
688,
804
],
[
691,
788,
730,
804
],
[
733,
788,
811,
804
],
[
814,
787,
869,
803
],
[
115,
806,
142,
820
],
[
145,
806,
171,
820
],
[
173,
806,
256,
821
],
[
258,
806,
277,
821
],
[
280,
806,
307,
821
],
[
310,
806,
371,
822
],
[
374,
806,
398,
822
],
[
401,
806,
459,
822
],
[
462,
806,
501,
822
],
[
504,
806,
547,
822
],
[
550,
806,
575,
822
],
[
578,
806,
624,
822
],
[
627,
806,
703,
822
],
[
706,
806,
714,
822
],
[
716,
805,
804,
822
],
[
807,
805,
840,
821
],
[
842,
805,
852,
821
],
[
115,
824,
168,
839
],
[
171,
824,
247,
840
],
[
251,
824,
335,
840
],
[
339,
824,
357,
840
],
[
361,
824,
390,
840
],
[
394,
824,
455,
841
],
[
458,
824,
501,
841
],
[
504,
824,
555,
841
],
[
559,
823,
637,
841
],
[
641,
823,
680,
840
],
[
684,
823,
735,
840
],
[
738,
823,
747,
840
],
[
751,
823,
784,
840
],
[
787,
822,
824,
839
],
[
115,
843,
182,
860
],
[
187,
843,
224,
858
],
[
231,
842,
337,
858
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned?
|
June 9, 2017
|
751
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"WASHINGTON,",
"D.C.",
"20460",
"June",
"9,",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"CHEMICAL",
"SAFETY",
"AND",
"POLLUTION",
"PREVENTION",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Recusal",
"Statement",
"FROM:",
"Nancy",
"B.",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"TO:",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Because",
"I",
"am",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"position,",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"not",
"subject",
"to",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770",
"and",
"therefore",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge.",
"But",
"as",
"an",
"executive",
"branch",
"employee,",
"I",
"have",
"always",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"statutes",
"codified",
"at",
"Title",
"18",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Code",
"and",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635.",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"the",
"federal",
"impartiality",
"standards,",
"I",
"have",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"\"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"my",
"former",
"employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"and",
"have",
"recused",
"myself",
"from",
"participating",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party.",
"I",
"was",
"advised",
"by",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"my",
"recusal",
"period",
"commenced",
"the",
"day",
"that",
"I",
"left",
"ACC",
"and",
"would",
"remain",
"in",
"effect",
"for",
"one",
"year",
"unless",
"I",
"was",
"authorized",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"to",
"participate",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"have",
"sought",
"and",
"obtained",
"confirmation",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"in",
"particular",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"such",
"as",
"rulemaking,",
"even",
"if",
"my",
"former",
"employer",
"has",
"an",
"interest,",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"discussions",
"or",
"consideration",
"of",
"comments",
"that",
"ACC",
"submitted",
"with",
"regard",
"to",
"rulemaking",
"or",
"other",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability.",
"See",
"attached.",
"I",
"am",
"also",
"now",
"authorized",
"to",
"attend",
"meetings",
"at",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"present",
"or",
"represented,",
"provided",
"that",
"the",
"subject",
"matter",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"is",
"a",
"matter",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"if",
"other",
"interested",
"non-federal",
"parties",
"are",
"present,",
"and",
"other",
"EPA",
"personnel",
"attend.",
"For",
"the",
"remainder",
"of",
"my",
"cooling",
"off",
"period,",
"until",
"April",
"21,",
"2018,",
"however,",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"I",
"cannot",
"otherwise",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"involving",
"ACC",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"seek",
"approval",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/pfcn0226"
] |
[
[
272,
93,
334,
108
],
[
338,
93,
397,
108
],
[
400,
93,
545,
109
],
[
548,
93,
651,
109
],
[
655,
93,
723,
108
],
[
272,
115,
394,
130
],
[
397,
115,
431,
130
],
[
435,
115,
486,
130
],
[
281,
170,
318,
185
],
[
321,
169,
338,
185
],
[
341,
169,
384,
185
],
[
735,
204,
778,
216
],
[
781,
205,
798,
216
],
[
801,
204,
865,
216
],
[
868,
204,
911,
216
],
[
730,
220,
756,
232
],
[
760,
220,
830,
231
],
[
833,
219,
912,
231
],
[
115,
240,
269,
257
],
[
115,
275,
204,
290
],
[
208,
276,
272,
290
],
[
276,
276,
356,
291
],
[
112,
311,
177,
327
],
[
232,
312,
285,
328
],
[
288,
312,
308,
328
],
[
312,
312,
358,
328
],
[
361,
312,
412,
328
],
[
417,
311,
472,
328
],
[
236,
331,
293,
347
],
[
297,
332,
371,
347
],
[
374,
331,
487,
347
],
[
114,
368,
145,
382
],
[
235,
368,
292,
384
],
[
295,
368,
434,
385
],
[
234,
387,
287,
404
],
[
291,
388,
364,
404
],
[
368,
387,
481,
404
],
[
175,
443,
241,
458
],
[
244,
443,
252,
458
],
[
255,
443,
277,
458
],
[
284,
443,
301,
458
],
[
305,
444,
326,
458
],
[
330,
444,
462,
458
],
[
467,
444,
560,
459
],
[
564,
444,
634,
459
],
[
638,
444,
644,
458
],
[
648,
443,
686,
458
],
[
690,
443,
729,
458
],
[
732,
443,
793,
458
],
[
797,
442,
818,
458
],
[
821,
442,
847,
458
],
[
115,
460,
164,
477
],
[
168,
460,
186,
477
],
[
190,
460,
252,
477
],
[
257,
461,
376,
477
],
[
380,
461,
490,
477
],
[
494,
461,
526,
477
],
[
530,
461,
537,
477
],
[
541,
461,
563,
477
],
[
569,
461,
597,
477
],
[
601,
461,
656,
477
],
[
660,
461,
677,
477
],
[
681,
460,
760,
477
],
[
764,
460,
811,
476
],
[
815,
460,
865,
476
],
[
115,
480,
144,
494
],
[
147,
480,
218,
495
],
[
222,
480,
248,
495
],
[
251,
480,
319,
495
],
[
322,
480,
340,
495
],
[
344,
480,
377,
495
],
[
381,
480,
408,
495
],
[
411,
480,
465,
495
],
[
468,
480,
515,
495
],
[
518,
480,
577,
495
],
[
581,
480,
612,
495
],
[
615,
480,
633,
495
],
[
636,
480,
655,
495
],
[
659,
480,
735,
495
],
[
738,
480,
794,
494
],
[
114,
498,
197,
514
],
[
200,
498,
207,
514
],
[
211,
498,
249,
514
],
[
252,
498,
309,
514
],
[
313,
497,
401,
514
],
[
404,
497,
436,
514
],
[
440,
497,
446,
514
],
[
450,
497,
472,
514
],
[
480,
497,
537,
514
],
[
540,
497,
556,
514
],
[
560,
497,
586,
514
],
[
590,
497,
650,
514
],
[
654,
497,
671,
513
],
[
675,
497,
735,
513
],
[
738,
497,
800,
513
],
[
802,
497,
867,
513
],
[
114,
515,
131,
531
],
[
134,
515,
172,
531
],
[
176,
515,
196,
531
],
[
200,
515,
217,
531
],
[
221,
515,
246,
531
],
[
250,
515,
305,
531
],
[
309,
515,
357,
531
],
[
360,
516,
402,
531
],
[
407,
516,
434,
531
],
[
438,
516,
464,
531
],
[
468,
516,
547,
531
],
[
551,
516,
567,
531
],
[
571,
516,
629,
531
],
[
632,
515,
700,
531
],
[
704,
515,
728,
531
],
[
731,
515,
820,
531
],
[
823,
515,
841,
530
],
[
844,
515,
872,
530
],
[
114,
533,
193,
549
],
[
197,
533,
260,
549
],
[
264,
533,
274,
549
],
[
278,
533,
332,
549
],
[
335,
533,
368,
549
],
[
371,
533,
417,
549
],
[
421,
533,
490,
549
],
[
494,
533,
511,
549
],
[
515,
533,
541,
549
],
[
544,
533,
599,
549
],
[
602,
533,
697,
549
],
[
700,
533,
780,
549
],
[
784,
533,
791,
549
],
[
794,
533,
832,
549
],
[
113,
553,
202,
567
],
[
205,
553,
237,
568
],
[
240,
553,
248,
568
],
[
250,
553,
291,
568
],
[
293,
553,
304,
568
],
[
307,
552,
379,
568
],
[
381,
552,
485,
568
],
[
488,
552,
525,
568
],
[
527,
552,
555,
568
],
[
557,
552,
614,
568
],
[
615,
552,
697,
568
],
[
699,
553,
727,
568
],
[
729,
553,
805,
568
],
[
115,
570,
198,
586
],
[
201,
570,
264,
586
],
[
267,
570,
327,
587
],
[
330,
570,
359,
587
],
[
362,
570,
401,
587
],
[
404,
570,
466,
587
],
[
469,
570,
526,
587
],
[
530,
570,
567,
587
],
[
572,
570,
672,
587
],
[
675,
570,
761,
587
],
[
764,
571,
793,
587
],
[
113,
588,
214,
603
],
[
217,
589,
235,
603
],
[
238,
589,
267,
604
],
[
270,
589,
347,
604
],
[
351,
589,
402,
604
],
[
405,
589,
483,
604
],
[
487,
589,
548,
604
],
[
552,
589,
605,
604
],
[
609,
589,
628,
604
],
[
631,
588,
680,
604
],
[
684,
588,
722,
604
],
[
728,
588,
744,
604
],
[
747,
588,
756,
604
],
[
760,
588,
802,
604
],
[
805,
588,
827,
603
],
[
115,
606,
195,
622
],
[
199,
606,
207,
622
],
[
211,
606,
258,
622
],
[
262,
606,
270,
622
],
[
274,
606,
305,
622
],
[
309,
606,
369,
622
],
[
373,
606,
395,
622
],
[
399,
605,
495,
622
],
[
500,
605,
530,
621
],
[
533,
605,
560,
621
],
[
563,
605,
620,
621
],
[
624,
605,
676,
621
],
[
680,
605,
775,
621
],
[
779,
605,
807,
621
],
[
810,
605,
837,
621
],
[
840,
605,
873,
621
],
[
114,
623,
121,
639
],
[
125,
623,
153,
639
],
[
157,
624,
197,
640
],
[
202,
624,
232,
640
],
[
235,
624,
284,
640
],
[
287,
624,
344,
640
],
[
347,
624,
365,
640
],
[
368,
624,
414,
640
],
[
418,
625,
442,
640
],
[
446,
625,
475,
640
],
[
479,
625,
514,
640
],
[
518,
624,
568,
640
],
[
571,
624,
580,
640
],
[
583,
624,
614,
640
],
[
618,
624,
702,
640
],
[
706,
624,
728,
639
],
[
731,
624,
757,
639
],
[
760,
624,
811,
639
],
[
815,
624,
834,
638
],
[
115,
641,
178,
658
],
[
181,
641,
300,
658
],
[
303,
642,
414,
658
],
[
417,
642,
434,
658
],
[
438,
642,
522,
658
],
[
527,
642,
594,
658
],
[
598,
642,
615,
658
],
[
619,
642,
631,
658
],
[
634,
642,
687,
658
],
[
691,
641,
793,
657
],
[
174,
680,
181,
695
],
[
184,
680,
222,
695
],
[
226,
680,
280,
695
],
[
284,
680,
313,
695
],
[
317,
680,
387,
695
],
[
390,
680,
492,
695
],
[
497,
680,
532,
695
],
[
540,
680,
635,
695
],
[
640,
680,
671,
695
],
[
675,
680,
683,
695
],
[
687,
680,
713,
695
],
[
717,
680,
802,
695
],
[
806,
680,
824,
695
],
[
114,
697,
189,
713
],
[
192,
697,
253,
713
],
[
257,
698,
275,
713
],
[
279,
698,
337,
713
],
[
340,
698,
444,
713
],
[
448,
698,
485,
713
],
[
489,
698,
506,
713
],
[
510,
698,
605,
713
],
[
610,
698,
647,
713
],
[
650,
698,
664,
713
],
[
668,
698,
694,
713
],
[
698,
698,
753,
713
],
[
757,
697,
831,
713
],
[
835,
697,
862,
713
],
[
114,
716,
132,
730
],
[
136,
716,
201,
731
],
[
205,
716,
234,
731
],
[
238,
716,
270,
731
],
[
273,
716,
280,
731
],
[
284,
716,
312,
732
],
[
316,
716,
400,
732
],
[
404,
716,
487,
732
],
[
490,
716,
521,
732
],
[
525,
716,
625,
732
],
[
628,
716,
645,
731
],
[
649,
716,
680,
731
],
[
683,
716,
772,
731
],
[
776,
716,
794,
730
],
[
115,
734,
221,
749
],
[
224,
734,
243,
749
],
[
246,
734,
327,
749
],
[
330,
734,
364,
749
],
[
367,
734,
407,
749
],
[
411,
734,
491,
749
],
[
494,
734,
530,
749
],
[
533,
734,
585,
749
],
[
588,
734,
604,
749
],
[
608,
734,
700,
749
],
[
703,
734,
720,
749
],
[
724,
734,
765,
749
],
[
769,
734,
829,
749
],
[
832,
734,
852,
748
],
[
115,
752,
172,
768
],
[
177,
752,
281,
768
],
[
284,
752,
312,
768
],
[
317,
752,
387,
768
],
[
391,
752,
400,
768
],
[
403,
752,
425,
768
],
[
432,
752,
463,
768
],
[
467,
752,
502,
768
],
[
508,
752,
591,
768
],
[
595,
752,
611,
767
],
[
615,
752,
665,
767
],
[
668,
751,
741,
767
],
[
744,
751,
759,
767
],
[
762,
751,
812,
767
],
[
816,
751,
857,
766
],
[
860,
751,
879,
766
],
[
117,
770,
172,
786
],
[
176,
770,
191,
785
],
[
195,
770,
292,
785
],
[
295,
770,
368,
785
],
[
371,
770,
401,
785
],
[
405,
770,
431,
785
],
[
435,
770,
492,
785
],
[
495,
770,
547,
785
],
[
551,
770,
568,
785
],
[
571,
770,
596,
785
],
[
600,
770,
664,
785
],
[
668,
770,
684,
785
],
[
687,
770,
697,
785
],
[
700,
770,
752,
785
],
[
755,
770,
774,
785
],
[
777,
770,
834,
785
],
[
114,
788,
217,
804
],
[
221,
788,
235,
804
],
[
238,
788,
279,
804
],
[
282,
788,
361,
804
],
[
364,
788,
456,
804
],
[
460,
788,
514,
804
],
[
517,
788,
543,
804
],
[
547,
788,
609,
804
],
[
612,
788,
642,
804
],
[
646,
788,
688,
804
],
[
691,
788,
730,
804
],
[
733,
788,
811,
804
],
[
814,
787,
869,
803
],
[
115,
806,
142,
820
],
[
145,
806,
171,
820
],
[
173,
806,
256,
821
],
[
258,
806,
277,
821
],
[
280,
806,
307,
821
],
[
310,
806,
371,
822
],
[
374,
806,
398,
822
],
[
401,
806,
459,
822
],
[
462,
806,
501,
822
],
[
504,
806,
547,
822
],
[
550,
806,
575,
822
],
[
578,
806,
624,
822
],
[
627,
806,
703,
822
],
[
706,
806,
714,
822
],
[
716,
805,
804,
822
],
[
807,
805,
840,
821
],
[
842,
805,
852,
821
],
[
115,
824,
168,
839
],
[
171,
824,
247,
840
],
[
251,
824,
335,
840
],
[
339,
824,
357,
840
],
[
361,
824,
390,
840
],
[
394,
824,
455,
841
],
[
458,
824,
501,
841
],
[
504,
824,
555,
841
],
[
559,
823,
637,
841
],
[
641,
823,
680,
840
],
[
684,
823,
735,
840
],
[
738,
823,
747,
840
],
[
751,
823,
784,
840
],
[
787,
822,
824,
839
],
[
115,
843,
182,
860
],
[
187,
843,
224,
858
],
[
231,
842,
337,
858
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
To whom is this document addressed?
|
Wendy Cleland-Hamnett
|
751
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"WASHINGTON,",
"D.C.",
"20460",
"June",
"9,",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"CHEMICAL",
"SAFETY",
"AND",
"POLLUTION",
"PREVENTION",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Recusal",
"Statement",
"FROM:",
"Nancy",
"B.",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"TO:",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Because",
"I",
"am",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"position,",
"I",
"have",
"been",
"advised",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"not",
"subject",
"to",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770",
"and",
"therefore",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge.",
"But",
"as",
"an",
"executive",
"branch",
"employee,",
"I",
"have",
"always",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"am",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"statutes",
"codified",
"at",
"Title",
"18",
"of",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Code",
"and",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635.",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"the",
"federal",
"impartiality",
"standards,",
"I",
"have",
"understood",
"that",
"I",
"have",
"a",
"\"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"my",
"former",
"employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"and",
"have",
"recused",
"myself",
"from",
"participating",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"particular",
"matter",
"involving",
"specific",
"parties",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party.",
"I",
"was",
"advised",
"by",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"my",
"recusal",
"period",
"commenced",
"the",
"day",
"that",
"I",
"left",
"ACC",
"and",
"would",
"remain",
"in",
"effect",
"for",
"one",
"year",
"unless",
"I",
"was",
"authorized",
"by",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"General",
"Counsel/Ethics",
"(OGC/Ethics)",
"to",
"participate",
"pursuant",
"to",
"5",
"C.F.R.",
"2635.502(d).",
"I",
"have",
"sought",
"and",
"obtained",
"confirmation",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"in",
"particular",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"such",
"as",
"rulemaking,",
"even",
"if",
"my",
"former",
"employer",
"has",
"an",
"interest,",
"and",
"that",
"I",
"can",
"participate",
"personally",
"and",
"substantially",
"in",
"any",
"discussions",
"or",
"consideration",
"of",
"comments",
"that",
"ACC",
"submitted",
"with",
"regard",
"to",
"rulemaking",
"or",
"other",
"matters",
"of",
"general",
"applicability.",
"See",
"attached.",
"I",
"am",
"also",
"now",
"authorized",
"to",
"attend",
"meetings",
"at",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"present",
"or",
"represented,",
"provided",
"that",
"the",
"subject",
"matter",
"of",
"the",
"meeting",
"is",
"a",
"matter",
"of",
"general",
"applicability,",
"if",
"other",
"interested",
"non-federal",
"parties",
"are",
"present,",
"and",
"other",
"EPA",
"personnel",
"attend.",
"For",
"the",
"remainder",
"of",
"my",
"cooling",
"off",
"period,",
"until",
"April",
"21,",
"2018,",
"however,",
"I",
"understand",
"that",
"I",
"cannot",
"otherwise",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"involving",
"ACC",
"unless",
"I",
"first",
"seek",
"approval",
"from",
"OGC/Ethics.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/pfcn0226"
] |
[
[
272,
93,
334,
108
],
[
338,
93,
397,
108
],
[
400,
93,
545,
109
],
[
548,
93,
651,
109
],
[
655,
93,
723,
108
],
[
272,
115,
394,
130
],
[
397,
115,
431,
130
],
[
435,
115,
486,
130
],
[
281,
170,
318,
185
],
[
321,
169,
338,
185
],
[
341,
169,
384,
185
],
[
735,
204,
778,
216
],
[
781,
205,
798,
216
],
[
801,
204,
865,
216
],
[
868,
204,
911,
216
],
[
730,
220,
756,
232
],
[
760,
220,
830,
231
],
[
833,
219,
912,
231
],
[
115,
240,
269,
257
],
[
115,
275,
204,
290
],
[
208,
276,
272,
290
],
[
276,
276,
356,
291
],
[
112,
311,
177,
327
],
[
232,
312,
285,
328
],
[
288,
312,
308,
328
],
[
312,
312,
358,
328
],
[
361,
312,
412,
328
],
[
417,
311,
472,
328
],
[
236,
331,
293,
347
],
[
297,
332,
371,
347
],
[
374,
331,
487,
347
],
[
114,
368,
145,
382
],
[
235,
368,
292,
384
],
[
295,
368,
434,
385
],
[
234,
387,
287,
404
],
[
291,
388,
364,
404
],
[
368,
387,
481,
404
],
[
175,
443,
241,
458
],
[
244,
443,
252,
458
],
[
255,
443,
277,
458
],
[
284,
443,
301,
458
],
[
305,
444,
326,
458
],
[
330,
444,
462,
458
],
[
467,
444,
560,
459
],
[
564,
444,
634,
459
],
[
638,
444,
644,
458
],
[
648,
443,
686,
458
],
[
690,
443,
729,
458
],
[
732,
443,
793,
458
],
[
797,
442,
818,
458
],
[
821,
442,
847,
458
],
[
115,
460,
164,
477
],
[
168,
460,
186,
477
],
[
190,
460,
252,
477
],
[
257,
461,
376,
477
],
[
380,
461,
490,
477
],
[
494,
461,
526,
477
],
[
530,
461,
537,
477
],
[
541,
461,
563,
477
],
[
569,
461,
597,
477
],
[
601,
461,
656,
477
],
[
660,
461,
677,
477
],
[
681,
460,
760,
477
],
[
764,
460,
811,
476
],
[
815,
460,
865,
476
],
[
115,
480,
144,
494
],
[
147,
480,
218,
495
],
[
222,
480,
248,
495
],
[
251,
480,
319,
495
],
[
322,
480,
340,
495
],
[
344,
480,
377,
495
],
[
381,
480,
408,
495
],
[
411,
480,
465,
495
],
[
468,
480,
515,
495
],
[
518,
480,
577,
495
],
[
581,
480,
612,
495
],
[
615,
480,
633,
495
],
[
636,
480,
655,
495
],
[
659,
480,
735,
495
],
[
738,
480,
794,
494
],
[
114,
498,
197,
514
],
[
200,
498,
207,
514
],
[
211,
498,
249,
514
],
[
252,
498,
309,
514
],
[
313,
497,
401,
514
],
[
404,
497,
436,
514
],
[
440,
497,
446,
514
],
[
450,
497,
472,
514
],
[
480,
497,
537,
514
],
[
540,
497,
556,
514
],
[
560,
497,
586,
514
],
[
590,
497,
650,
514
],
[
654,
497,
671,
513
],
[
675,
497,
735,
513
],
[
738,
497,
800,
513
],
[
802,
497,
867,
513
],
[
114,
515,
131,
531
],
[
134,
515,
172,
531
],
[
176,
515,
196,
531
],
[
200,
515,
217,
531
],
[
221,
515,
246,
531
],
[
250,
515,
305,
531
],
[
309,
515,
357,
531
],
[
360,
516,
402,
531
],
[
407,
516,
434,
531
],
[
438,
516,
464,
531
],
[
468,
516,
547,
531
],
[
551,
516,
567,
531
],
[
571,
516,
629,
531
],
[
632,
515,
700,
531
],
[
704,
515,
728,
531
],
[
731,
515,
820,
531
],
[
823,
515,
841,
530
],
[
844,
515,
872,
530
],
[
114,
533,
193,
549
],
[
197,
533,
260,
549
],
[
264,
533,
274,
549
],
[
278,
533,
332,
549
],
[
335,
533,
368,
549
],
[
371,
533,
417,
549
],
[
421,
533,
490,
549
],
[
494,
533,
511,
549
],
[
515,
533,
541,
549
],
[
544,
533,
599,
549
],
[
602,
533,
697,
549
],
[
700,
533,
780,
549
],
[
784,
533,
791,
549
],
[
794,
533,
832,
549
],
[
113,
553,
202,
567
],
[
205,
553,
237,
568
],
[
240,
553,
248,
568
],
[
250,
553,
291,
568
],
[
293,
553,
304,
568
],
[
307,
552,
379,
568
],
[
381,
552,
485,
568
],
[
488,
552,
525,
568
],
[
527,
552,
555,
568
],
[
557,
552,
614,
568
],
[
615,
552,
697,
568
],
[
699,
553,
727,
568
],
[
729,
553,
805,
568
],
[
115,
570,
198,
586
],
[
201,
570,
264,
586
],
[
267,
570,
327,
587
],
[
330,
570,
359,
587
],
[
362,
570,
401,
587
],
[
404,
570,
466,
587
],
[
469,
570,
526,
587
],
[
530,
570,
567,
587
],
[
572,
570,
672,
587
],
[
675,
570,
761,
587
],
[
764,
571,
793,
587
],
[
113,
588,
214,
603
],
[
217,
589,
235,
603
],
[
238,
589,
267,
604
],
[
270,
589,
347,
604
],
[
351,
589,
402,
604
],
[
405,
589,
483,
604
],
[
487,
589,
548,
604
],
[
552,
589,
605,
604
],
[
609,
589,
628,
604
],
[
631,
588,
680,
604
],
[
684,
588,
722,
604
],
[
728,
588,
744,
604
],
[
747,
588,
756,
604
],
[
760,
588,
802,
604
],
[
805,
588,
827,
603
],
[
115,
606,
195,
622
],
[
199,
606,
207,
622
],
[
211,
606,
258,
622
],
[
262,
606,
270,
622
],
[
274,
606,
305,
622
],
[
309,
606,
369,
622
],
[
373,
606,
395,
622
],
[
399,
605,
495,
622
],
[
500,
605,
530,
621
],
[
533,
605,
560,
621
],
[
563,
605,
620,
621
],
[
624,
605,
676,
621
],
[
680,
605,
775,
621
],
[
779,
605,
807,
621
],
[
810,
605,
837,
621
],
[
840,
605,
873,
621
],
[
114,
623,
121,
639
],
[
125,
623,
153,
639
],
[
157,
624,
197,
640
],
[
202,
624,
232,
640
],
[
235,
624,
284,
640
],
[
287,
624,
344,
640
],
[
347,
624,
365,
640
],
[
368,
624,
414,
640
],
[
418,
625,
442,
640
],
[
446,
625,
475,
640
],
[
479,
625,
514,
640
],
[
518,
624,
568,
640
],
[
571,
624,
580,
640
],
[
583,
624,
614,
640
],
[
618,
624,
702,
640
],
[
706,
624,
728,
639
],
[
731,
624,
757,
639
],
[
760,
624,
811,
639
],
[
815,
624,
834,
638
],
[
115,
641,
178,
658
],
[
181,
641,
300,
658
],
[
303,
642,
414,
658
],
[
417,
642,
434,
658
],
[
438,
642,
522,
658
],
[
527,
642,
594,
658
],
[
598,
642,
615,
658
],
[
619,
642,
631,
658
],
[
634,
642,
687,
658
],
[
691,
641,
793,
657
],
[
174,
680,
181,
695
],
[
184,
680,
222,
695
],
[
226,
680,
280,
695
],
[
284,
680,
313,
695
],
[
317,
680,
387,
695
],
[
390,
680,
492,
695
],
[
497,
680,
532,
695
],
[
540,
680,
635,
695
],
[
640,
680,
671,
695
],
[
675,
680,
683,
695
],
[
687,
680,
713,
695
],
[
717,
680,
802,
695
],
[
806,
680,
824,
695
],
[
114,
697,
189,
713
],
[
192,
697,
253,
713
],
[
257,
698,
275,
713
],
[
279,
698,
337,
713
],
[
340,
698,
444,
713
],
[
448,
698,
485,
713
],
[
489,
698,
506,
713
],
[
510,
698,
605,
713
],
[
610,
698,
647,
713
],
[
650,
698,
664,
713
],
[
668,
698,
694,
713
],
[
698,
698,
753,
713
],
[
757,
697,
831,
713
],
[
835,
697,
862,
713
],
[
114,
716,
132,
730
],
[
136,
716,
201,
731
],
[
205,
716,
234,
731
],
[
238,
716,
270,
731
],
[
273,
716,
280,
731
],
[
284,
716,
312,
732
],
[
316,
716,
400,
732
],
[
404,
716,
487,
732
],
[
490,
716,
521,
732
],
[
525,
716,
625,
732
],
[
628,
716,
645,
731
],
[
649,
716,
680,
731
],
[
683,
716,
772,
731
],
[
776,
716,
794,
730
],
[
115,
734,
221,
749
],
[
224,
734,
243,
749
],
[
246,
734,
327,
749
],
[
330,
734,
364,
749
],
[
367,
734,
407,
749
],
[
411,
734,
491,
749
],
[
494,
734,
530,
749
],
[
533,
734,
585,
749
],
[
588,
734,
604,
749
],
[
608,
734,
700,
749
],
[
703,
734,
720,
749
],
[
724,
734,
765,
749
],
[
769,
734,
829,
749
],
[
832,
734,
852,
748
],
[
115,
752,
172,
768
],
[
177,
752,
281,
768
],
[
284,
752,
312,
768
],
[
317,
752,
387,
768
],
[
391,
752,
400,
768
],
[
403,
752,
425,
768
],
[
432,
752,
463,
768
],
[
467,
752,
502,
768
],
[
508,
752,
591,
768
],
[
595,
752,
611,
767
],
[
615,
752,
665,
767
],
[
668,
751,
741,
767
],
[
744,
751,
759,
767
],
[
762,
751,
812,
767
],
[
816,
751,
857,
766
],
[
860,
751,
879,
766
],
[
117,
770,
172,
786
],
[
176,
770,
191,
785
],
[
195,
770,
292,
785
],
[
295,
770,
368,
785
],
[
371,
770,
401,
785
],
[
405,
770,
431,
785
],
[
435,
770,
492,
785
],
[
495,
770,
547,
785
],
[
551,
770,
568,
785
],
[
571,
770,
596,
785
],
[
600,
770,
664,
785
],
[
668,
770,
684,
785
],
[
687,
770,
697,
785
],
[
700,
770,
752,
785
],
[
755,
770,
774,
785
],
[
777,
770,
834,
785
],
[
114,
788,
217,
804
],
[
221,
788,
235,
804
],
[
238,
788,
279,
804
],
[
282,
788,
361,
804
],
[
364,
788,
456,
804
],
[
460,
788,
514,
804
],
[
517,
788,
543,
804
],
[
547,
788,
609,
804
],
[
612,
788,
642,
804
],
[
646,
788,
688,
804
],
[
691,
788,
730,
804
],
[
733,
788,
811,
804
],
[
814,
787,
869,
803
],
[
115,
806,
142,
820
],
[
145,
806,
171,
820
],
[
173,
806,
256,
821
],
[
258,
806,
277,
821
],
[
280,
806,
307,
821
],
[
310,
806,
371,
822
],
[
374,
806,
398,
822
],
[
401,
806,
459,
822
],
[
462,
806,
501,
822
],
[
504,
806,
547,
822
],
[
550,
806,
575,
822
],
[
578,
806,
624,
822
],
[
627,
806,
703,
822
],
[
706,
806,
714,
822
],
[
716,
805,
804,
822
],
[
807,
805,
840,
821
],
[
842,
805,
852,
821
],
[
115,
824,
168,
839
],
[
171,
824,
247,
840
],
[
251,
824,
335,
840
],
[
339,
824,
357,
840
],
[
361,
824,
390,
840
],
[
394,
824,
455,
841
],
[
458,
824,
501,
841
],
[
504,
824,
555,
841
],
[
559,
823,
637,
841
],
[
641,
823,
680,
840
],
[
684,
823,
735,
840
],
[
738,
823,
747,
840
],
[
751,
823,
784,
840
],
[
787,
822,
824,
839
],
[
115,
843,
182,
860
],
[
187,
843,
224,
858
],
[
231,
842,
337,
858
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the subject of the memorandum?
|
Recusal Statement
|
724
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Comments",
"to",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"on",
"Its",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"INTRODUCTION",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"provide",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"these",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"proposed",
"procedures",
"for",
"prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA)",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"ACC",
"strongly",
"supported",
"Congress's",
"efforts",
"to",
"update",
"and",
"reform",
"TSCA.",
"One",
"of",
"ACC's",
"principles",
"for",
"modernizing",
"TSCA",
"called",
"on",
"EPA",
"to",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations.",
"Without",
"a",
"scientifically",
"based",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"EPA",
"would",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"meet",
"efficiently",
"the",
"other",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"achieve",
"the",
"objectives",
"of",
"TSCA",
"reform",
"that",
"Congress",
"intended.",
"As",
"discussed",
"in",
"more",
"detail",
"below,",
"EPA's",
"proposed",
"prioritization",
"process",
"falls",
"short.",
"Congress",
"designed",
"the",
"LCSA",
"to",
"allow",
"chemicals",
"to",
"be",
"systematically",
"prioritized",
"and",
"then",
"to",
"evaluate",
"those",
"substances",
"presenting",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"risk.",
"This",
"design",
"is",
"apparent",
"in",
"every",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"It",
"begins",
"with",
"a",
"reclassification",
"of",
"the",
"full",
"catalog",
"of",
"chemistries",
"in",
"U.S.",
"commerce,",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory.",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"that",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"be",
"sorted,",
"so",
"that",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"currently",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"separated",
"from",
"those",
"no",
"longer",
"manufactured,",
"imported",
"or",
"used;",
"only",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"prioritization",
"and",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"This",
"enables",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"resources",
"for",
"its",
"multi-year,",
"time-and-resource",
"intensive",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"actually",
"in",
"current",
"use.",
"EPA",
"must",
"next",
"undertake",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"sequence",
"of",
"chemicals",
"that",
"will",
"undergo",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"must",
"then",
"undertake",
"a",
"formal",
"scoping",
"process,",
"to",
"define",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"(and",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"sub-populations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"use)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"chemical.",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"various",
"purposes",
"is",
"not",
"new",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"In",
"2011,",
"EPA",
"held",
"a",
"Stakeholder",
"Dialogue",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"and",
"established",
"a",
"Discussion",
"Blog",
"for",
"additional",
"input",
"on",
"the",
"topic.",
"In",
"our",
"comments",
"to",
"that",
"discussion",
"blog,",
"ACC",
"identified",
"several",
"general",
"principles",
"for",
"prioritization",
"(Attachment",
"A).",
"We",
"believe",
"these",
"principles",
"are",
"reflected",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA",
"requirements,",
"in",
"particular",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"recognition",
"that",
"prioritization",
"is",
"a",
"risk",
"based",
"screening",
"process",
"that",
"integrates",
"information",
"on",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"In",
"2011,",
"ACC",
"developed",
"a",
"two-step",
"quantitative",
"and",
"qualitative",
"tool",
"to",
"\"proof",
"test\"",
"our",
"prioritization",
"principles",
"(Attachment",
"B).",
"We",
"presented",
"our",
"principles",
"and",
"our",
"prioritization",
"tool",
"to",
"EPA",
"in",
"2011,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"other",
"industry",
"and",
"NGO",
"stakeholders",
"at",
"the",
"time.",
"In",
"2012,",
"EPA",
"published",
"its",
"methodology",
"to",
"identify",
"chemicals",
"for",
"its",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
368,
64,
451,
80
],
[
457,
64,
548,
80
],
[
551,
62,
616,
80
],
[
277,
84,
366,
100
],
[
370,
84,
389,
100
],
[
392,
85,
428,
100
],
[
432,
85,
560,
100
],
[
564,
85,
651,
100
],
[
656,
85,
718,
100
],
[
722,
85,
745,
100
],
[
260,
103,
283,
119
],
[
287,
103,
366,
119
],
[
370,
104,
467,
120
],
[
470,
105,
497,
120
],
[
501,
105,
615,
120
],
[
619,
105,
638,
120
],
[
642,
104,
728,
120
],
[
731,
103,
761,
119
],
[
253,
124,
294,
139
],
[
297,
124,
389,
139
],
[
392,
125,
445,
139
],
[
449,
125,
478,
139
],
[
481,
125,
528,
139
],
[
531,
125,
627,
139
],
[
631,
125,
696,
139
],
[
700,
125,
727,
139
],
[
454,
159,
597,
173
],
[
198,
193,
230,
208
],
[
233,
194,
312,
209
],
[
315,
194,
399,
210
],
[
402,
193,
465,
210
],
[
468,
193,
523,
210
],
[
526,
193,
542,
210
],
[
545,
193,
606,
210
],
[
609,
193,
625,
210
],
[
628,
193,
691,
210
],
[
694,
192,
721,
209
],
[
723,
192,
756,
209
],
[
140,
213,
256,
229
],
[
260,
214,
342,
230
],
[
346,
214,
408,
230
],
[
411,
214,
464,
230
],
[
467,
214,
508,
230
],
[
512,
214,
595,
230
],
[
598,
214,
619,
230
],
[
622,
214,
648,
230
],
[
651,
214,
728,
230
],
[
731,
214,
804,
230
],
[
137,
234,
225,
250
],
[
230,
234,
252,
250
],
[
256,
234,
361,
250
],
[
365,
234,
382,
249
],
[
387,
234,
465,
249
],
[
470,
234,
492,
249
],
[
496,
234,
528,
249
],
[
532,
233,
614,
249
],
[
617,
233,
664,
249
],
[
667,
233,
694,
249
],
[
698,
233,
744,
249
],
[
748,
233,
838,
249
],
[
139,
253,
201,
269
],
[
205,
253,
233,
269
],
[
236,
253,
301,
270
],
[
304,
254,
322,
270
],
[
325,
254,
397,
270
],
[
400,
254,
422,
270
],
[
425,
254,
451,
270
],
[
454,
254,
547,
270
],
[
550,
253,
627,
270
],
[
630,
253,
682,
270
],
[
685,
253,
715,
270
],
[
718,
253,
790,
269
],
[
793,
253,
820,
269
],
[
138,
272,
190,
289
],
[
193,
273,
257,
289
],
[
261,
273,
300,
290
],
[
304,
273,
321,
290
],
[
324,
273,
398,
290
],
[
402,
274,
422,
290
],
[
427,
274,
464,
290
],
[
468,
274,
477,
290
],
[
480,
274,
563,
290
],
[
567,
274,
642,
290
],
[
646,
274,
707,
290
],
[
711,
274,
727,
290
],
[
731,
274,
792,
290
],
[
796,
274,
834,
289
],
[
140,
294,
167,
309
],
[
171,
294,
201,
310
],
[
205,
294,
267,
310
],
[
270,
295,
355,
310
],
[
359,
295,
383,
310
],
[
387,
295,
417,
310
],
[
421,
294,
512,
310
],
[
516,
294,
561,
310
],
[
565,
294,
590,
309
],
[
594,
294,
647,
309
],
[
198,
326,
240,
343
],
[
243,
326,
308,
343
],
[
312,
326,
391,
343
],
[
395,
327,
482,
343
],
[
487,
327,
538,
343
],
[
542,
327,
558,
343
],
[
562,
326,
615,
343
],
[
620,
326,
649,
342
],
[
653,
326,
705,
342
],
[
712,
326,
768,
342
],
[
772,
326,
805,
342
],
[
809,
326,
830,
342
],
[
140,
346,
192,
363
],
[
197,
346,
276,
363
],
[
281,
346,
303,
362
],
[
307,
346,
410,
362
],
[
414,
346,
464,
362
],
[
467,
346,
516,
362
],
[
520,
346,
540,
362
],
[
544,
347,
581,
362
],
[
585,
347,
602,
362
],
[
606,
347,
718,
362
],
[
722,
347,
797,
362
],
[
139,
366,
218,
382
],
[
222,
366,
244,
382
],
[
248,
366,
320,
382
],
[
324,
366,
341,
382
],
[
345,
367,
376,
382
],
[
380,
367,
477,
382
],
[
481,
367,
545,
382
],
[
550,
367,
558,
382
],
[
562,
367,
664,
382
],
[
668,
367,
714,
382
],
[
717,
366,
825,
382
],
[
138,
387,
204,
402
],
[
207,
387,
244,
402
],
[
249,
387,
299,
402
],
[
302,
387,
328,
402
],
[
332,
387,
352,
402
],
[
356,
387,
390,
402
],
[
394,
387,
410,
402
],
[
414,
387,
453,
402
],
[
457,
387,
539,
402
],
[
542,
387,
568,
402
],
[
572,
387,
612,
402
],
[
616,
386,
721,
402
],
[
725,
386,
741,
402
],
[
745,
386,
771,
401
],
[
774,
386,
826,
401
],
[
831,
385,
860,
401
],
[
140,
406,
198,
423
],
[
202,
407,
229,
423
],
[
232,
407,
314,
423
],
[
317,
407,
336,
423
],
[
340,
407,
388,
423
],
[
392,
407,
444,
423
],
[
451,
407,
482,
423
],
[
485,
407,
560,
423
],
[
564,
407,
639,
423
],
[
642,
407,
667,
422
],
[
671,
407,
744,
422
],
[
748,
407,
764,
422
],
[
768,
407,
812,
422
],
[
817,
406,
855,
422
],
[
138,
426,
192,
443
],
[
197,
426,
248,
443
],
[
252,
427,
324,
443
],
[
328,
427,
432,
443
],
[
435,
428,
497,
443
],
[
500,
428,
536,
442
],
[
539,
427,
584,
442
],
[
199,
459,
274,
475
],
[
277,
460,
346,
475
],
[
350,
460,
374,
475
],
[
377,
460,
430,
475
],
[
433,
460,
450,
475
],
[
454,
460,
498,
475
],
[
503,
460,
582,
475
],
[
585,
460,
602,
475
],
[
605,
460,
625,
475
],
[
629,
459,
742,
475
],
[
745,
459,
830,
475
],
[
833,
459,
864,
475
],
[
138,
479,
172,
495
],
[
176,
480,
193,
495
],
[
197,
480,
264,
495
],
[
268,
480,
310,
495
],
[
314,
480,
399,
495
],
[
402,
480,
485,
495
],
[
489,
480,
515,
495
],
[
519,
480,
581,
495
],
[
585,
480,
654,
495
],
[
658,
480,
696,
495
],
[
700,
480,
738,
495
],
[
742,
479,
790,
495
],
[
794,
479,
806,
495
],
[
140,
500,
207,
515
],
[
210,
500,
228,
515
],
[
231,
500,
276,
515
],
[
279,
500,
312,
515
],
[
315,
500,
332,
515
],
[
335,
500,
361,
515
],
[
364,
500,
422,
515
],
[
424,
500,
438,
515
],
[
441,
500,
495,
515
],
[
498,
500,
535,
515
],
[
538,
500,
548,
515
],
[
551,
500,
672,
515
],
[
675,
500,
692,
515
],
[
695,
500,
722,
515
],
[
725,
500,
755,
515
],
[
757,
499,
817,
515
],
[
820,
499,
841,
515
],
[
140,
520,
228,
535
],
[
232,
520,
250,
536
],
[
254,
520,
290,
536
],
[
294,
520,
380,
536
],
[
384,
520,
411,
536
],
[
415,
520,
464,
536
],
[
468,
520,
552,
536
],
[
556,
520,
586,
536
],
[
590,
520,
642,
535
],
[
645,
520,
710,
535
],
[
713,
520,
744,
535
],
[
748,
520,
775,
535
],
[
780,
519,
828,
535
],
[
139,
540,
215,
555
],
[
218,
540,
240,
555
],
[
243,
540,
297,
555
],
[
301,
540,
319,
555
],
[
322,
540,
354,
555
],
[
358,
540,
437,
555
],
[
440,
541,
471,
555
],
[
475,
541,
501,
555
],
[
505,
541,
577,
555
],
[
581,
541,
628,
555
],
[
631,
541,
649,
555
],
[
652,
540,
736,
555
],
[
740,
540,
765,
555
],
[
768,
540,
845,
555
],
[
138,
560,
174,
575
],
[
181,
560,
223,
575
],
[
227,
560,
248,
575
],
[
252,
560,
304,
575
],
[
307,
560,
420,
576
],
[
424,
560,
497,
576
],
[
501,
560,
518,
576
],
[
522,
560,
565,
576
],
[
568,
560,
605,
575
],
[
609,
560,
687,
575
],
[
690,
561,
724,
575
],
[
727,
561,
751,
575
],
[
754,
561,
802,
575
],
[
806,
561,
823,
574
],
[
141,
581,
222,
595
],
[
225,
581,
250,
595
],
[
254,
581,
311,
595
],
[
314,
581,
330,
595
],
[
334,
581,
359,
595
],
[
362,
581,
467,
595
],
[
471,
581,
501,
595
],
[
504,
581,
535,
595
],
[
539,
581,
629,
595
],
[
632,
581,
666,
595
],
[
670,
581,
731,
595
],
[
734,
581,
770,
595
],
[
776,
581,
792,
595
],
[
795,
580,
840,
595
],
[
137,
600,
213,
616
],
[
217,
601,
241,
616
],
[
244,
601,
264,
616
],
[
268,
601,
356,
616
],
[
360,
601,
504,
616
],
[
507,
601,
580,
616
],
[
584,
601,
615,
616
],
[
619,
601,
709,
616
],
[
712,
601,
734,
616
],
[
737,
600,
817,
615
],
[
820,
600,
850,
615
],
[
140,
621,
164,
635
],
[
167,
621,
230,
635
],
[
234,
621,
251,
635
],
[
254,
621,
311,
635
],
[
315,
621,
349,
635
],
[
352,
621,
387,
635
],
[
392,
621,
432,
636
],
[
435,
621,
472,
636
],
[
475,
621,
554,
636
],
[
558,
621,
567,
636
],
[
571,
621,
674,
636
],
[
677,
621,
743,
635
],
[
746,
621,
764,
635
],
[
767,
620,
817,
635
],
[
825,
620,
850,
635
],
[
139,
641,
212,
655
],
[
215,
641,
233,
655
],
[
237,
641,
316,
656
],
[
320,
641,
352,
656
],
[
355,
641,
386,
656
],
[
390,
640,
455,
656
],
[
458,
640,
490,
656
],
[
492,
640,
582,
656
],
[
585,
640,
621,
656
],
[
627,
640,
667,
656
],
[
670,
640,
705,
655
],
[
708,
640,
787,
655
],
[
790,
640,
802,
655
],
[
804,
640,
860,
655
],
[
139,
662,
200,
675
],
[
203,
661,
270,
676
],
[
272,
661,
290,
676
],
[
297,
661,
344,
676
],
[
347,
661,
373,
676
],
[
376,
661,
460,
676
],
[
463,
661,
482,
676
],
[
485,
661,
513,
676
],
[
516,
661,
552,
676
],
[
555,
661,
641,
676
],
[
644,
661,
710,
676
],
[
714,
661,
835,
676
],
[
138,
681,
202,
695
],
[
205,
681,
222,
695
],
[
225,
681,
252,
695
],
[
255,
681,
289,
695
],
[
292,
681,
326,
695
],
[
329,
681,
359,
695
],
[
362,
681,
382,
695
],
[
385,
681,
455,
696
],
[
458,
681,
475,
696
],
[
478,
681,
505,
696
],
[
508,
681,
555,
696
],
[
558,
680,
576,
696
],
[
579,
680,
604,
696
],
[
607,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
725,
696
],
[
728,
680,
745,
695
],
[
748,
680,
775,
695
],
[
778,
680,
855,
695
],
[
197,
713,
303,
729
],
[
307,
714,
323,
729
],
[
327,
714,
407,
729
],
[
411,
714,
435,
729
],
[
439,
714,
496,
729
],
[
500,
714,
571,
729
],
[
575,
714,
589,
729
],
[
593,
714,
620,
729
],
[
624,
714,
655,
729
],
[
661,
714,
677,
729
],
[
681,
714,
708,
729
],
[
711,
713,
783,
729
],
[
786,
713,
805,
729
],
[
808,
712,
854,
729
],
[
139,
732,
175,
748
],
[
180,
733,
216,
748
],
[
220,
733,
230,
748
],
[
234,
733,
328,
748
],
[
331,
734,
405,
748
],
[
408,
734,
430,
749
],
[
433,
734,
538,
749
],
[
542,
734,
571,
749
],
[
574,
734,
663,
749
],
[
666,
734,
677,
749
],
[
680,
733,
768,
749
],
[
771,
733,
811,
749
],
[
814,
733,
839,
748
],
[
140,
753,
218,
768
],
[
221,
754,
264,
769
],
[
268,
754,
287,
769
],
[
291,
754,
317,
769
],
[
320,
754,
367,
769
],
[
370,
755,
388,
769
],
[
391,
755,
418,
769
],
[
422,
755,
504,
769
],
[
507,
754,
523,
769
],
[
527,
754,
561,
769
],
[
565,
754,
644,
769
],
[
648,
754,
691,
769
],
[
694,
753,
734,
768
],
[
738,
752,
812,
768
],
[
140,
774,
196,
789
],
[
200,
774,
258,
789
],
[
261,
774,
340,
789
],
[
344,
774,
368,
789
],
[
371,
774,
475,
789
],
[
479,
774,
580,
789
],
[
584,
774,
610,
789
],
[
614,
774,
640,
789
],
[
644,
773,
702,
789
],
[
706,
773,
748,
789
],
[
752,
773,
830,
789
],
[
834,
773,
859,
789
],
[
138,
793,
208,
809
],
[
212,
793,
228,
809
],
[
232,
793,
258,
809
],
[
261,
794,
311,
809
],
[
315,
794,
425,
810
],
[
428,
794,
444,
810
],
[
447,
794,
525,
810
],
[
528,
794,
554,
810
],
[
558,
794,
622,
810
],
[
626,
794,
718,
810
],
[
721,
794,
751,
809
],
[
755,
793,
861,
809
],
[
138,
813,
153,
828
],
[
157,
813,
166,
828
],
[
170,
814,
200,
828
],
[
203,
814,
251,
829
],
[
255,
814,
330,
829
],
[
334,
815,
394,
829
],
[
398,
815,
428,
829
],
[
431,
815,
510,
829
],
[
513,
815,
607,
829
],
[
611,
815,
631,
829
],
[
634,
815,
671,
829
],
[
675,
814,
729,
829
],
[
732,
814,
762,
829
],
[
766,
814,
839,
829
],
[
137,
833,
214,
849
],
[
217,
833,
234,
849
],
[
238,
834,
284,
849
],
[
287,
834,
328,
849
],
[
335,
834,
414,
849
],
[
418,
834,
427,
849
],
[
431,
834,
500,
849
],
[
504,
834,
599,
849
],
[
603,
834,
632,
849
],
[
635,
834,
719,
849
],
[
722,
834,
754,
849
],
[
758,
834,
775,
848
],
[
779,
833,
832,
848
],
[
139,
854,
177,
869
],
[
180,
854,
206,
869
],
[
210,
854,
314,
869
],
[
317,
854,
397,
869
],
[
400,
854,
501,
869
],
[
504,
854,
531,
869
],
[
534,
854,
561,
869
],
[
564,
854,
642,
869
],
[
645,
854,
672,
869
],
[
675,
854,
756,
869
],
[
759,
854,
790,
869
],
[
792,
854,
819,
869
],
[
138,
874,
241,
889
],
[
245,
874,
278,
889
],
[
281,
874,
298,
889
],
[
302,
874,
338,
889
],
[
343,
874,
360,
890
],
[
364,
874,
410,
890
],
[
413,
874,
431,
890
],
[
435,
874,
469,
890
],
[
472,
874,
490,
890
],
[
493,
874,
511,
890
],
[
515,
873,
555,
890
],
[
558,
873,
625,
890
],
[
628,
873,
658,
890
],
[
661,
873,
702,
890
],
[
710,
873,
809,
889
],
[
812,
873,
827,
889
],
[
831,
873,
856,
889
],
[
138,
892,
179,
908
],
[
183,
892,
200,
909
],
[
204,
893,
250,
909
],
[
254,
893,
291,
909
],
[
295,
893,
372,
910
],
[
377,
893,
397,
910
],
[
400,
893,
504,
910
],
[
508,
893,
525,
910
],
[
530,
893,
591,
910
],
[
595,
892,
674,
910
],
[
678,
892,
702,
910
],
[
706,
892,
727,
909
],
[
731,
892,
780,
909
],
[
787,
892,
829,
909
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Why ACC developed a two-step quantitative and qualitative tool?
|
to "proof test" our prioritization principles
|
733
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Docket",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"(OPPT)",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.,",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Sent",
"electronically",
"to",
"www.regulations.gov_Docket",
"ID#",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0636",
"Re:",
"ACC",
"Comments",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"Dear",
"Sir/Madam:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"appreciates",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"written",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"Agency's",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA),",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"being",
"a",
"constructive",
"stakeholder",
"in",
"the",
"effective",
"implementation",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"we",
"provide",
"these",
"comments",
"to",
"assist",
"the",
"Agency",
"in",
"its",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"evaluation",
"and",
"management",
"program",
"that",
"is",
"efficient,",
"science-based,",
"and",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"legal",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"Prioritization",
"is",
"the",
"first",
"step",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"framework",
"for",
"evaluating",
"active",
"chemicals",
"in",
"commerce",
"and",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"must",
"establish",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"and",
"criteria",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"If",
"you",
"have",
"any",
"questions,",
"please",
"contact",
"me",
"at:",
"202-249-6403",
"or",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"@americanchemistry",
".com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"&",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"Cc:",
"Jeffrey",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland",
"Hamnett,",
"OCSPP",
"Ryan",
"Schmit,",
"OCSPF",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care(@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$797",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"one",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporters,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"any",
"threat",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
502,
112,
618,
135
],
[
531,
135,
655,
156
],
[
503,
155,
588,
174
],
[
711,
212,
761,
225
],
[
764,
212,
787,
225
],
[
790,
211,
827,
225
],
[
118,
227,
170,
242
],
[
174,
228,
231,
243
],
[
234,
229,
280,
243
],
[
283,
228,
351,
243
],
[
119,
243,
165,
258
],
[
168,
244,
184,
259
],
[
187,
244,
255,
259
],
[
258,
245,
337,
259
],
[
340,
245,
369,
259
],
[
372,
244,
421,
259
],
[
425,
243,
482,
259
],
[
118,
259,
150,
275
],
[
154,
259,
262,
275
],
[
266,
260,
341,
275
],
[
344,
261,
395,
276
],
[
118,
276,
154,
290
],
[
157,
276,
256,
291
],
[
259,
276,
298,
291
],
[
301,
276,
328,
291
],
[
337,
276,
429,
291
],
[
432,
276,
458,
291
],
[
462,
275,
548,
291
],
[
120,
308,
151,
323
],
[
154,
308,
252,
324
],
[
255,
308,
271,
324
],
[
275,
308,
495,
324
],
[
499,
308,
529,
323
],
[
532,
306,
734,
323
],
[
118,
340,
144,
354
],
[
147,
340,
185,
354
],
[
188,
340,
268,
355
],
[
271,
340,
290,
355
],
[
294,
340,
341,
355
],
[
344,
340,
412,
355
],
[
416,
340,
498,
355
],
[
501,
340,
522,
355
],
[
526,
340,
622,
355
],
[
626,
340,
641,
355
],
[
645,
340,
721,
355
],
[
725,
339,
746,
354
],
[
750,
339,
785,
354
],
[
788,
339,
869,
354
],
[
117,
356,
160,
370
],
[
163,
356,
188,
370
],
[
191,
356,
234,
370
],
[
237,
356,
317,
370
],
[
320,
355,
378,
371
],
[
381,
355,
407,
371
],
[
411,
355,
427,
371
],
[
430,
355,
496,
371
],
[
500,
355,
518,
371
],
[
521,
355,
545,
371
],
[
548,
355,
632,
371
],
[
635,
355,
705,
371
],
[
708,
355,
757,
371
],
[
760,
355,
787,
370
],
[
118,
387,
154,
402
],
[
157,
388,
245,
402
],
[
148,
416,
177,
430
],
[
180,
416,
252,
431
],
[
255,
416,
332,
432
],
[
334,
416,
392,
432
],
[
395,
416,
457,
432
],
[
460,
416,
541,
433
],
[
544,
416,
568,
433
],
[
571,
417,
656,
433
],
[
659,
417,
675,
432
],
[
678,
417,
734,
432
],
[
738,
417,
790,
432
],
[
793,
417,
868,
431
],
[
871,
417,
889,
430
],
[
119,
432,
141,
447
],
[
144,
432,
192,
447
],
[
195,
432,
211,
447
],
[
214,
432,
285,
447
],
[
288,
432,
334,
447
],
[
338,
432,
364,
447
],
[
368,
432,
434,
447
],
[
438,
432,
518,
447
],
[
521,
432,
536,
447
],
[
540,
432,
587,
447
],
[
592,
432,
618,
447
],
[
621,
433,
693,
447
],
[
697,
433,
788,
447
],
[
792,
433,
808,
447
],
[
811,
433,
818,
447
],
[
118,
449,
211,
464
],
[
215,
449,
270,
464
],
[
274,
449,
303,
464
],
[
307,
449,
348,
464
],
[
352,
449,
376,
464
],
[
380,
448,
421,
464
],
[
425,
448,
507,
464
],
[
511,
448,
567,
463
],
[
571,
448,
596,
464
],
[
600,
448,
664,
464
],
[
667,
448,
684,
464
],
[
688,
448,
752,
464
],
[
756,
448,
775,
464
],
[
778,
448,
801,
464
],
[
805,
448,
891,
464
],
[
118,
464,
187,
480
],
[
191,
464,
238,
480
],
[
242,
464,
267,
480
],
[
271,
464,
335,
480
],
[
339,
464,
375,
480
],
[
379,
464,
392,
480
],
[
397,
464,
474,
480
],
[
478,
464,
492,
480
],
[
497,
464,
537,
480
],
[
541,
465,
550,
480
],
[
554,
465,
642,
479
],
[
646,
465,
728,
479
],
[
732,
465,
747,
479
],
[
751,
465,
775,
479
],
[
779,
465,
840,
479
],
[
117,
480,
231,
495
],
[
235,
480,
251,
495
],
[
254,
480,
277,
495
],
[
280,
480,
327,
495
],
[
331,
480,
359,
495
],
[
363,
480,
382,
495
],
[
386,
480,
443,
495
],
[
447,
480,
484,
495
],
[
488,
480,
563,
495
],
[
567,
480,
582,
495
],
[
586,
480,
625,
495
],
[
628,
480,
652,
495
],
[
656,
480,
711,
495
],
[
715,
480,
730,
495
],
[
733,
480,
754,
495
],
[
758,
480,
850,
495
],
[
853,
480,
868,
495
],
[
872,
480,
883,
495
],
[
120,
496,
184,
511
],
[
187,
497,
263,
511
],
[
267,
497,
292,
511
],
[
297,
497,
388,
512
],
[
392,
497,
452,
512
],
[
457,
497,
485,
512
],
[
489,
497,
502,
512
],
[
506,
497,
572,
512
],
[
576,
497,
681,
512
],
[
685,
497,
711,
512
],
[
714,
496,
788,
512
],
[
792,
496,
824,
511
],
[
827,
496,
850,
511
],
[
853,
496,
894,
511
],
[
117,
513,
213,
528
],
[
216,
513,
232,
526
],
[
235,
513,
257,
526
],
[
261,
513,
312,
527
],
[
156,
541,
248,
555
],
[
251,
541,
265,
555
],
[
268,
541,
292,
555
],
[
295,
541,
326,
555
],
[
330,
541,
358,
555
],
[
361,
541,
377,
555
],
[
380,
541,
402,
555
],
[
406,
541,
468,
556
],
[
471,
541,
550,
556
],
[
554,
541,
576,
556
],
[
580,
541,
655,
556
],
[
658,
541,
702,
556
],
[
705,
541,
780,
556
],
[
782,
541,
797,
556
],
[
800,
541,
876,
556
],
[
118,
557,
144,
571
],
[
148,
557,
170,
571
],
[
174,
558,
270,
571
],
[
272,
558,
328,
571
],
[
331,
558,
360,
571
],
[
364,
558,
400,
571
],
[
403,
558,
468,
572
],
[
471,
558,
479,
572
],
[
482,
558,
558,
572
],
[
561,
557,
632,
572
],
[
635,
557,
691,
572
],
[
694,
557,
721,
572
],
[
724,
557,
777,
572
],
[
780,
557,
795,
572
],
[
798,
557,
855,
572
],
[
857,
557,
892,
572
],
[
118,
574,
144,
587
],
[
147,
574,
174,
587
],
[
179,
573,
234,
587
],
[
238,
573,
315,
588
],
[
319,
573,
340,
588
],
[
344,
573,
373,
588
],
[
377,
573,
459,
588
],
[
462,
573,
504,
588
],
[
507,
573,
531,
588
],
[
534,
573,
587,
588
],
[
590,
573,
602,
588
],
[
605,
573,
633,
589
],
[
636,
573,
672,
589
],
[
675,
573,
703,
589
],
[
706,
573,
780,
589
],
[
783,
574,
831,
589
],
[
834,
574,
886,
589
],
[
117,
590,
141,
603
],
[
144,
590,
164,
603
],
[
167,
589,
270,
605
],
[
273,
589,
290,
605
],
[
293,
589,
335,
605
],
[
342,
589,
403,
605
],
[
406,
590,
552,
606
],
[
555,
590,
595,
606
],
[
118,
620,
194,
636
],
[
118,
675,
160,
690
],
[
163,
675,
223,
690
],
[
118,
691,
165,
706
],
[
169,
692,
234,
706
],
[
237,
692,
320,
706
],
[
324,
692,
337,
706
],
[
342,
691,
413,
706
],
[
417,
691,
471,
706
],
[
119,
723,
142,
739
],
[
147,
723,
196,
739
],
[
200,
723,
255,
738
],
[
259,
723,
325,
738
],
[
328,
723,
374,
737
],
[
154,
739,
202,
754
],
[
206,
739,
262,
754
],
[
266,
739,
335,
754
],
[
338,
739,
395,
754
],
[
152,
755,
188,
770
],
[
192,
755,
249,
770
],
[
253,
755,
304,
769
],
[
139,
798,
161,
811
],
[
163,
798,
214,
812
],
[
216,
799,
271,
812
],
[
274,
800,
316,
813
],
[
318,
800,
354,
813
],
[
357,
800,
411,
813
],
[
413,
801,
430,
814
],
[
432,
801,
471,
814
],
[
474,
801,
531,
814
],
[
534,
801,
578,
814
],
[
580,
801,
592,
814
],
[
595,
801,
610,
814
],
[
613,
801,
659,
814
],
[
662,
801,
673,
813
],
[
676,
800,
732,
813
],
[
735,
800,
761,
813
],
[
764,
800,
814,
813
],
[
127,
814,
156,
825
],
[
158,
814,
176,
825
],
[
178,
814,
218,
826
],
[
220,
814,
232,
826
],
[
234,
814,
285,
826
],
[
288,
814,
300,
826
],
[
302,
814,
331,
826
],
[
334,
814,
390,
826
],
[
392,
814,
438,
826
],
[
441,
814,
461,
826
],
[
464,
814,
506,
826
],
[
508,
814,
529,
826
],
[
531,
814,
560,
826
],
[
562,
814,
605,
826
],
[
608,
814,
634,
826
],
[
636,
814,
670,
826
],
[
672,
814,
720,
826
],
[
722,
814,
742,
826
],
[
745,
814,
774,
826
],
[
777,
814,
804,
826
],
[
807,
814,
818,
826
],
[
127,
825,
184,
837
],
[
186,
825,
197,
837
],
[
200,
825,
250,
837
],
[
252,
825,
331,
837
],
[
334,
826,
368,
837
],
[
370,
826,
390,
837
],
[
392,
826,
424,
837
],
[
426,
826,
493,
837
],
[
496,
826,
538,
837
],
[
540,
826,
605,
837
],
[
608,
826,
646,
837
],
[
648,
826,
696,
837
],
[
698,
826,
727,
837
],
[
730,
826,
780,
837
],
[
128,
837,
174,
848
],
[
177,
837,
188,
848
],
[
191,
837,
230,
848
],
[
232,
837,
263,
849
],
[
266,
837,
300,
849
],
[
302,
837,
335,
849
],
[
337,
837,
374,
849
],
[
376,
837,
395,
849
],
[
397,
837,
431,
849
],
[
434,
837,
454,
849
],
[
456,
837,
531,
849
],
[
534,
837,
580,
849
],
[
582,
837,
601,
849
],
[
603,
837,
644,
849
],
[
646,
837,
687,
848
],
[
690,
837,
709,
848
],
[
711,
837,
757,
848
],
[
759,
837,
772,
848
],
[
127,
848,
178,
860
],
[
181,
848,
191,
860
],
[
194,
848,
201,
860
],
[
203,
848,
229,
860
],
[
231,
849,
267,
860
],
[
270,
849,
322,
860
],
[
324,
849,
344,
860
],
[
347,
849,
353,
860
],
[
355,
849,
375,
860
],
[
378,
849,
420,
860
],
[
422,
849,
434,
860
],
[
437,
849,
452,
860
],
[
455,
849,
497,
860
],
[
500,
849,
551,
860
],
[
554,
849,
562,
860
],
[
565,
849,
575,
860
],
[
577,
849,
597,
860
],
[
600,
849,
611,
860
],
[
614,
849,
630,
860
],
[
632,
849,
675,
860
],
[
678,
849,
714,
860
],
[
717,
849,
772,
860
],
[
127,
860,
185,
871
],
[
187,
860,
204,
871
],
[
206,
860,
222,
871
],
[
225,
860,
253,
871
],
[
255,
860,
272,
872
],
[
275,
860,
287,
872
],
[
290,
860,
321,
872
],
[
324,
860,
352,
872
],
[
355,
860,
367,
872
],
[
370,
860,
393,
872
],
[
395,
860,
438,
872
],
[
441,
860,
496,
872
],
[
498,
860,
555,
872
],
[
557,
860,
575,
872
],
[
577,
860,
614,
872
],
[
616,
860,
632,
872
],
[
635,
860,
670,
872
],
[
672,
860,
721,
872
],
[
723,
860,
734,
872
],
[
736,
860,
782,
871
],
[
784,
860,
805,
871
],
[
130,
873,
199,
883
],
[
201,
872,
235,
884
],
[
237,
872,
258,
884
],
[
260,
872,
301,
884
],
[
304,
872,
331,
884
],
[
332,
872,
369,
884
],
[
371,
872,
397,
884
],
[
400,
872,
442,
884
],
[
444,
872,
492,
884
],
[
494,
872,
507,
884
],
[
510,
872,
535,
884
],
[
539,
872,
591,
884
],
[
593,
872,
614,
884
],
[
615,
872,
638,
884
],
[
640,
872,
666,
884
],
[
668,
872,
727,
884
],
[
729,
873,
753,
883
],
[
755,
873,
798,
883
],
[
128,
885,
172,
895
],
[
174,
885,
212,
895
],
[
215,
885,
238,
895
],
[
241,
885,
304,
896
],
[
306,
885,
352,
896
],
[
354,
885,
365,
896
],
[
368,
885,
413,
896
],
[
415,
885,
457,
896
],
[
460,
885,
479,
896
],
[
481,
885,
493,
896
],
[
497,
885,
532,
896
],
[
534,
885,
572,
896
],
[
575,
885,
594,
896
],
[
596,
885,
627,
896
],
[
629,
885,
640,
896
],
[
642,
885,
659,
896
],
[
661,
885,
705,
896
],
[
707,
885,
744,
895
],
[
747,
885,
826,
895
],
[
30,
911,
202,
926
],
[
519,
913,
542,
925
],
[
545,
913,
589,
925
],
[
591,
913,
611,
925
],
[
614,
913,
632,
925
],
[
635,
913,
642,
925
],
[
644,
913,
720,
925
],
[
722,
913,
743,
925
],
[
747,
913,
785,
925
],
[
788,
913,
794,
925
],
[
797,
912,
830,
925
],
[
833,
912,
890,
925
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the heading of the letter?
|
American Chemistry Council
|
733
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Docket",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"(OPPT)",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.,",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Sent",
"electronically",
"to",
"www.regulations.gov_Docket",
"ID#",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0636",
"Re:",
"ACC",
"Comments",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"Dear",
"Sir/Madam:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"appreciates",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"written",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"Agency's",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA),",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"being",
"a",
"constructive",
"stakeholder",
"in",
"the",
"effective",
"implementation",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"we",
"provide",
"these",
"comments",
"to",
"assist",
"the",
"Agency",
"in",
"its",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"evaluation",
"and",
"management",
"program",
"that",
"is",
"efficient,",
"science-based,",
"and",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"legal",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"Prioritization",
"is",
"the",
"first",
"step",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"framework",
"for",
"evaluating",
"active",
"chemicals",
"in",
"commerce",
"and",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"must",
"establish",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"and",
"criteria",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"If",
"you",
"have",
"any",
"questions,",
"please",
"contact",
"me",
"at:",
"202-249-6403",
"or",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"@americanchemistry",
".com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"&",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"Cc:",
"Jeffrey",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland",
"Hamnett,",
"OCSPP",
"Ryan",
"Schmit,",
"OCSPF",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care(@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$797",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"one",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporters,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"any",
"threat",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
502,
112,
618,
135
],
[
531,
135,
655,
156
],
[
503,
155,
588,
174
],
[
711,
212,
761,
225
],
[
764,
212,
787,
225
],
[
790,
211,
827,
225
],
[
118,
227,
170,
242
],
[
174,
228,
231,
243
],
[
234,
229,
280,
243
],
[
283,
228,
351,
243
],
[
119,
243,
165,
258
],
[
168,
244,
184,
259
],
[
187,
244,
255,
259
],
[
258,
245,
337,
259
],
[
340,
245,
369,
259
],
[
372,
244,
421,
259
],
[
425,
243,
482,
259
],
[
118,
259,
150,
275
],
[
154,
259,
262,
275
],
[
266,
260,
341,
275
],
[
344,
261,
395,
276
],
[
118,
276,
154,
290
],
[
157,
276,
256,
291
],
[
259,
276,
298,
291
],
[
301,
276,
328,
291
],
[
337,
276,
429,
291
],
[
432,
276,
458,
291
],
[
462,
275,
548,
291
],
[
120,
308,
151,
323
],
[
154,
308,
252,
324
],
[
255,
308,
271,
324
],
[
275,
308,
495,
324
],
[
499,
308,
529,
323
],
[
532,
306,
734,
323
],
[
118,
340,
144,
354
],
[
147,
340,
185,
354
],
[
188,
340,
268,
355
],
[
271,
340,
290,
355
],
[
294,
340,
341,
355
],
[
344,
340,
412,
355
],
[
416,
340,
498,
355
],
[
501,
340,
522,
355
],
[
526,
340,
622,
355
],
[
626,
340,
641,
355
],
[
645,
340,
721,
355
],
[
725,
339,
746,
354
],
[
750,
339,
785,
354
],
[
788,
339,
869,
354
],
[
117,
356,
160,
370
],
[
163,
356,
188,
370
],
[
191,
356,
234,
370
],
[
237,
356,
317,
370
],
[
320,
355,
378,
371
],
[
381,
355,
407,
371
],
[
411,
355,
427,
371
],
[
430,
355,
496,
371
],
[
500,
355,
518,
371
],
[
521,
355,
545,
371
],
[
548,
355,
632,
371
],
[
635,
355,
705,
371
],
[
708,
355,
757,
371
],
[
760,
355,
787,
370
],
[
118,
387,
154,
402
],
[
157,
388,
245,
402
],
[
148,
416,
177,
430
],
[
180,
416,
252,
431
],
[
255,
416,
332,
432
],
[
334,
416,
392,
432
],
[
395,
416,
457,
432
],
[
460,
416,
541,
433
],
[
544,
416,
568,
433
],
[
571,
417,
656,
433
],
[
659,
417,
675,
432
],
[
678,
417,
734,
432
],
[
738,
417,
790,
432
],
[
793,
417,
868,
431
],
[
871,
417,
889,
430
],
[
119,
432,
141,
447
],
[
144,
432,
192,
447
],
[
195,
432,
211,
447
],
[
214,
432,
285,
447
],
[
288,
432,
334,
447
],
[
338,
432,
364,
447
],
[
368,
432,
434,
447
],
[
438,
432,
518,
447
],
[
521,
432,
536,
447
],
[
540,
432,
587,
447
],
[
592,
432,
618,
447
],
[
621,
433,
693,
447
],
[
697,
433,
788,
447
],
[
792,
433,
808,
447
],
[
811,
433,
818,
447
],
[
118,
449,
211,
464
],
[
215,
449,
270,
464
],
[
274,
449,
303,
464
],
[
307,
449,
348,
464
],
[
352,
449,
376,
464
],
[
380,
448,
421,
464
],
[
425,
448,
507,
464
],
[
511,
448,
567,
463
],
[
571,
448,
596,
464
],
[
600,
448,
664,
464
],
[
667,
448,
684,
464
],
[
688,
448,
752,
464
],
[
756,
448,
775,
464
],
[
778,
448,
801,
464
],
[
805,
448,
891,
464
],
[
118,
464,
187,
480
],
[
191,
464,
238,
480
],
[
242,
464,
267,
480
],
[
271,
464,
335,
480
],
[
339,
464,
375,
480
],
[
379,
464,
392,
480
],
[
397,
464,
474,
480
],
[
478,
464,
492,
480
],
[
497,
464,
537,
480
],
[
541,
465,
550,
480
],
[
554,
465,
642,
479
],
[
646,
465,
728,
479
],
[
732,
465,
747,
479
],
[
751,
465,
775,
479
],
[
779,
465,
840,
479
],
[
117,
480,
231,
495
],
[
235,
480,
251,
495
],
[
254,
480,
277,
495
],
[
280,
480,
327,
495
],
[
331,
480,
359,
495
],
[
363,
480,
382,
495
],
[
386,
480,
443,
495
],
[
447,
480,
484,
495
],
[
488,
480,
563,
495
],
[
567,
480,
582,
495
],
[
586,
480,
625,
495
],
[
628,
480,
652,
495
],
[
656,
480,
711,
495
],
[
715,
480,
730,
495
],
[
733,
480,
754,
495
],
[
758,
480,
850,
495
],
[
853,
480,
868,
495
],
[
872,
480,
883,
495
],
[
120,
496,
184,
511
],
[
187,
497,
263,
511
],
[
267,
497,
292,
511
],
[
297,
497,
388,
512
],
[
392,
497,
452,
512
],
[
457,
497,
485,
512
],
[
489,
497,
502,
512
],
[
506,
497,
572,
512
],
[
576,
497,
681,
512
],
[
685,
497,
711,
512
],
[
714,
496,
788,
512
],
[
792,
496,
824,
511
],
[
827,
496,
850,
511
],
[
853,
496,
894,
511
],
[
117,
513,
213,
528
],
[
216,
513,
232,
526
],
[
235,
513,
257,
526
],
[
261,
513,
312,
527
],
[
156,
541,
248,
555
],
[
251,
541,
265,
555
],
[
268,
541,
292,
555
],
[
295,
541,
326,
555
],
[
330,
541,
358,
555
],
[
361,
541,
377,
555
],
[
380,
541,
402,
555
],
[
406,
541,
468,
556
],
[
471,
541,
550,
556
],
[
554,
541,
576,
556
],
[
580,
541,
655,
556
],
[
658,
541,
702,
556
],
[
705,
541,
780,
556
],
[
782,
541,
797,
556
],
[
800,
541,
876,
556
],
[
118,
557,
144,
571
],
[
148,
557,
170,
571
],
[
174,
558,
270,
571
],
[
272,
558,
328,
571
],
[
331,
558,
360,
571
],
[
364,
558,
400,
571
],
[
403,
558,
468,
572
],
[
471,
558,
479,
572
],
[
482,
558,
558,
572
],
[
561,
557,
632,
572
],
[
635,
557,
691,
572
],
[
694,
557,
721,
572
],
[
724,
557,
777,
572
],
[
780,
557,
795,
572
],
[
798,
557,
855,
572
],
[
857,
557,
892,
572
],
[
118,
574,
144,
587
],
[
147,
574,
174,
587
],
[
179,
573,
234,
587
],
[
238,
573,
315,
588
],
[
319,
573,
340,
588
],
[
344,
573,
373,
588
],
[
377,
573,
459,
588
],
[
462,
573,
504,
588
],
[
507,
573,
531,
588
],
[
534,
573,
587,
588
],
[
590,
573,
602,
588
],
[
605,
573,
633,
589
],
[
636,
573,
672,
589
],
[
675,
573,
703,
589
],
[
706,
573,
780,
589
],
[
783,
574,
831,
589
],
[
834,
574,
886,
589
],
[
117,
590,
141,
603
],
[
144,
590,
164,
603
],
[
167,
589,
270,
605
],
[
273,
589,
290,
605
],
[
293,
589,
335,
605
],
[
342,
589,
403,
605
],
[
406,
590,
552,
606
],
[
555,
590,
595,
606
],
[
118,
620,
194,
636
],
[
118,
675,
160,
690
],
[
163,
675,
223,
690
],
[
118,
691,
165,
706
],
[
169,
692,
234,
706
],
[
237,
692,
320,
706
],
[
324,
692,
337,
706
],
[
342,
691,
413,
706
],
[
417,
691,
471,
706
],
[
119,
723,
142,
739
],
[
147,
723,
196,
739
],
[
200,
723,
255,
738
],
[
259,
723,
325,
738
],
[
328,
723,
374,
737
],
[
154,
739,
202,
754
],
[
206,
739,
262,
754
],
[
266,
739,
335,
754
],
[
338,
739,
395,
754
],
[
152,
755,
188,
770
],
[
192,
755,
249,
770
],
[
253,
755,
304,
769
],
[
139,
798,
161,
811
],
[
163,
798,
214,
812
],
[
216,
799,
271,
812
],
[
274,
800,
316,
813
],
[
318,
800,
354,
813
],
[
357,
800,
411,
813
],
[
413,
801,
430,
814
],
[
432,
801,
471,
814
],
[
474,
801,
531,
814
],
[
534,
801,
578,
814
],
[
580,
801,
592,
814
],
[
595,
801,
610,
814
],
[
613,
801,
659,
814
],
[
662,
801,
673,
813
],
[
676,
800,
732,
813
],
[
735,
800,
761,
813
],
[
764,
800,
814,
813
],
[
127,
814,
156,
825
],
[
158,
814,
176,
825
],
[
178,
814,
218,
826
],
[
220,
814,
232,
826
],
[
234,
814,
285,
826
],
[
288,
814,
300,
826
],
[
302,
814,
331,
826
],
[
334,
814,
390,
826
],
[
392,
814,
438,
826
],
[
441,
814,
461,
826
],
[
464,
814,
506,
826
],
[
508,
814,
529,
826
],
[
531,
814,
560,
826
],
[
562,
814,
605,
826
],
[
608,
814,
634,
826
],
[
636,
814,
670,
826
],
[
672,
814,
720,
826
],
[
722,
814,
742,
826
],
[
745,
814,
774,
826
],
[
777,
814,
804,
826
],
[
807,
814,
818,
826
],
[
127,
825,
184,
837
],
[
186,
825,
197,
837
],
[
200,
825,
250,
837
],
[
252,
825,
331,
837
],
[
334,
826,
368,
837
],
[
370,
826,
390,
837
],
[
392,
826,
424,
837
],
[
426,
826,
493,
837
],
[
496,
826,
538,
837
],
[
540,
826,
605,
837
],
[
608,
826,
646,
837
],
[
648,
826,
696,
837
],
[
698,
826,
727,
837
],
[
730,
826,
780,
837
],
[
128,
837,
174,
848
],
[
177,
837,
188,
848
],
[
191,
837,
230,
848
],
[
232,
837,
263,
849
],
[
266,
837,
300,
849
],
[
302,
837,
335,
849
],
[
337,
837,
374,
849
],
[
376,
837,
395,
849
],
[
397,
837,
431,
849
],
[
434,
837,
454,
849
],
[
456,
837,
531,
849
],
[
534,
837,
580,
849
],
[
582,
837,
601,
849
],
[
603,
837,
644,
849
],
[
646,
837,
687,
848
],
[
690,
837,
709,
848
],
[
711,
837,
757,
848
],
[
759,
837,
772,
848
],
[
127,
848,
178,
860
],
[
181,
848,
191,
860
],
[
194,
848,
201,
860
],
[
203,
848,
229,
860
],
[
231,
849,
267,
860
],
[
270,
849,
322,
860
],
[
324,
849,
344,
860
],
[
347,
849,
353,
860
],
[
355,
849,
375,
860
],
[
378,
849,
420,
860
],
[
422,
849,
434,
860
],
[
437,
849,
452,
860
],
[
455,
849,
497,
860
],
[
500,
849,
551,
860
],
[
554,
849,
562,
860
],
[
565,
849,
575,
860
],
[
577,
849,
597,
860
],
[
600,
849,
611,
860
],
[
614,
849,
630,
860
],
[
632,
849,
675,
860
],
[
678,
849,
714,
860
],
[
717,
849,
772,
860
],
[
127,
860,
185,
871
],
[
187,
860,
204,
871
],
[
206,
860,
222,
871
],
[
225,
860,
253,
871
],
[
255,
860,
272,
872
],
[
275,
860,
287,
872
],
[
290,
860,
321,
872
],
[
324,
860,
352,
872
],
[
355,
860,
367,
872
],
[
370,
860,
393,
872
],
[
395,
860,
438,
872
],
[
441,
860,
496,
872
],
[
498,
860,
555,
872
],
[
557,
860,
575,
872
],
[
577,
860,
614,
872
],
[
616,
860,
632,
872
],
[
635,
860,
670,
872
],
[
672,
860,
721,
872
],
[
723,
860,
734,
872
],
[
736,
860,
782,
871
],
[
784,
860,
805,
871
],
[
130,
873,
199,
883
],
[
201,
872,
235,
884
],
[
237,
872,
258,
884
],
[
260,
872,
301,
884
],
[
304,
872,
331,
884
],
[
332,
872,
369,
884
],
[
371,
872,
397,
884
],
[
400,
872,
442,
884
],
[
444,
872,
492,
884
],
[
494,
872,
507,
884
],
[
510,
872,
535,
884
],
[
539,
872,
591,
884
],
[
593,
872,
614,
884
],
[
615,
872,
638,
884
],
[
640,
872,
666,
884
],
[
668,
872,
727,
884
],
[
729,
873,
753,
883
],
[
755,
873,
798,
883
],
[
128,
885,
172,
895
],
[
174,
885,
212,
895
],
[
215,
885,
238,
895
],
[
241,
885,
304,
896
],
[
306,
885,
352,
896
],
[
354,
885,
365,
896
],
[
368,
885,
413,
896
],
[
415,
885,
457,
896
],
[
460,
885,
479,
896
],
[
481,
885,
493,
896
],
[
497,
885,
532,
896
],
[
534,
885,
572,
896
],
[
575,
885,
594,
896
],
[
596,
885,
627,
896
],
[
629,
885,
640,
896
],
[
642,
885,
659,
896
],
[
661,
885,
705,
896
],
[
707,
885,
744,
895
],
[
747,
885,
826,
895
],
[
30,
911,
202,
926
],
[
519,
913,
542,
925
],
[
545,
913,
589,
925
],
[
591,
913,
611,
925
],
[
614,
913,
632,
925
],
[
635,
913,
642,
925
],
[
644,
913,
720,
925
],
[
722,
913,
743,
925
],
[
747,
913,
785,
925
],
[
788,
913,
794,
925
],
[
797,
912,
830,
925
],
[
833,
912,
890,
925
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned?
|
March 20, 2017
|
733
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Docket",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"(OPPT)",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.,",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Sent",
"electronically",
"to",
"www.regulations.gov_Docket",
"ID#",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0636",
"Re:",
"ACC",
"Comments",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"Dear",
"Sir/Madam:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"appreciates",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"written",
"comments",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"Agency's",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA),",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"being",
"a",
"constructive",
"stakeholder",
"in",
"the",
"effective",
"implementation",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"we",
"provide",
"these",
"comments",
"to",
"assist",
"the",
"Agency",
"in",
"its",
"development",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"evaluation",
"and",
"management",
"program",
"that",
"is",
"efficient,",
"science-based,",
"and",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"legal",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"Prioritization",
"is",
"the",
"first",
"step",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"framework",
"for",
"evaluating",
"active",
"chemicals",
"in",
"commerce",
"and",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"rule",
"must",
"establish",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"and",
"criteria",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"If",
"you",
"have",
"any",
"questions,",
"please",
"contact",
"me",
"at:",
"202-249-6403",
"or",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"@americanchemistry",
".com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Sarah",
"Brozena",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"&",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"Cc:",
"Jeffrey",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland",
"Hamnett,",
"OCSPP",
"Ryan",
"Schmit,",
"OCSPF",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"ACC",
"members",
"apply",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"chemistry",
"to",
"make",
"innovative",
"products",
"and",
"services",
"that",
"make",
"people's",
"lives",
"better,",
"healthier",
"and",
"safer.",
"ACC",
"is",
"committed",
"to",
"improved",
"environmental,",
"health",
"and",
"safety",
"performance",
"through",
"Responsible",
"Care(@,",
"common",
"sense",
"advocacy",
"designed",
"to",
"address",
"major",
"public",
"policy",
"issues,",
"and",
"health",
"and",
"environmental",
"research",
"and",
"product",
"testing.",
"The",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry",
"is",
"a",
"$797",
"billion",
"enterprise",
"and",
"a",
"key",
"element",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"economy.",
"It",
"is",
"one",
"of",
"the",
"nation's",
"largest",
"exporters,",
"accounting",
"for",
"ten",
"cents",
"out",
"of",
"every",
"dollar",
"in",
"U.S.",
"exports.",
"Chemistry",
"companies",
"are",
"among",
"the",
"largest",
"investors",
"in",
"research",
"and",
"development.",
"Safety",
"and",
"security",
"have",
"always",
"been",
"primary",
"concerns",
"of",
"ACC",
"members,",
"and",
"they",
"have",
"intensified",
"their",
"efforts,",
"working",
"closely",
"with",
"government",
"agencies",
"to",
"improve",
"security",
"and",
"to",
"defend",
"against",
"any",
"threat",
"to",
"the",
"nation's",
"critical",
"infrastructure.",
"americanchemistry.com",
"700",
"Second",
"St.,",
"NE",
"|",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20002",
"|",
"(202)",
"249.7000",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
502,
112,
618,
135
],
[
531,
135,
655,
156
],
[
503,
155,
588,
174
],
[
711,
212,
761,
225
],
[
764,
212,
787,
225
],
[
790,
211,
827,
225
],
[
118,
227,
170,
242
],
[
174,
228,
231,
243
],
[
234,
229,
280,
243
],
[
283,
228,
351,
243
],
[
119,
243,
165,
258
],
[
168,
244,
184,
259
],
[
187,
244,
255,
259
],
[
258,
245,
337,
259
],
[
340,
245,
369,
259
],
[
372,
244,
421,
259
],
[
425,
243,
482,
259
],
[
118,
259,
150,
275
],
[
154,
259,
262,
275
],
[
266,
260,
341,
275
],
[
344,
261,
395,
276
],
[
118,
276,
154,
290
],
[
157,
276,
256,
291
],
[
259,
276,
298,
291
],
[
301,
276,
328,
291
],
[
337,
276,
429,
291
],
[
432,
276,
458,
291
],
[
462,
275,
548,
291
],
[
120,
308,
151,
323
],
[
154,
308,
252,
324
],
[
255,
308,
271,
324
],
[
275,
308,
495,
324
],
[
499,
308,
529,
323
],
[
532,
306,
734,
323
],
[
118,
340,
144,
354
],
[
147,
340,
185,
354
],
[
188,
340,
268,
355
],
[
271,
340,
290,
355
],
[
294,
340,
341,
355
],
[
344,
340,
412,
355
],
[
416,
340,
498,
355
],
[
501,
340,
522,
355
],
[
526,
340,
622,
355
],
[
626,
340,
641,
355
],
[
645,
340,
721,
355
],
[
725,
339,
746,
354
],
[
750,
339,
785,
354
],
[
788,
339,
869,
354
],
[
117,
356,
160,
370
],
[
163,
356,
188,
370
],
[
191,
356,
234,
370
],
[
237,
356,
317,
370
],
[
320,
355,
378,
371
],
[
381,
355,
407,
371
],
[
411,
355,
427,
371
],
[
430,
355,
496,
371
],
[
500,
355,
518,
371
],
[
521,
355,
545,
371
],
[
548,
355,
632,
371
],
[
635,
355,
705,
371
],
[
708,
355,
757,
371
],
[
760,
355,
787,
370
],
[
118,
387,
154,
402
],
[
157,
388,
245,
402
],
[
148,
416,
177,
430
],
[
180,
416,
252,
431
],
[
255,
416,
332,
432
],
[
334,
416,
392,
432
],
[
395,
416,
457,
432
],
[
460,
416,
541,
433
],
[
544,
416,
568,
433
],
[
571,
417,
656,
433
],
[
659,
417,
675,
432
],
[
678,
417,
734,
432
],
[
738,
417,
790,
432
],
[
793,
417,
868,
431
],
[
871,
417,
889,
430
],
[
119,
432,
141,
447
],
[
144,
432,
192,
447
],
[
195,
432,
211,
447
],
[
214,
432,
285,
447
],
[
288,
432,
334,
447
],
[
338,
432,
364,
447
],
[
368,
432,
434,
447
],
[
438,
432,
518,
447
],
[
521,
432,
536,
447
],
[
540,
432,
587,
447
],
[
592,
432,
618,
447
],
[
621,
433,
693,
447
],
[
697,
433,
788,
447
],
[
792,
433,
808,
447
],
[
811,
433,
818,
447
],
[
118,
449,
211,
464
],
[
215,
449,
270,
464
],
[
274,
449,
303,
464
],
[
307,
449,
348,
464
],
[
352,
449,
376,
464
],
[
380,
448,
421,
464
],
[
425,
448,
507,
464
],
[
511,
448,
567,
463
],
[
571,
448,
596,
464
],
[
600,
448,
664,
464
],
[
667,
448,
684,
464
],
[
688,
448,
752,
464
],
[
756,
448,
775,
464
],
[
778,
448,
801,
464
],
[
805,
448,
891,
464
],
[
118,
464,
187,
480
],
[
191,
464,
238,
480
],
[
242,
464,
267,
480
],
[
271,
464,
335,
480
],
[
339,
464,
375,
480
],
[
379,
464,
392,
480
],
[
397,
464,
474,
480
],
[
478,
464,
492,
480
],
[
497,
464,
537,
480
],
[
541,
465,
550,
480
],
[
554,
465,
642,
479
],
[
646,
465,
728,
479
],
[
732,
465,
747,
479
],
[
751,
465,
775,
479
],
[
779,
465,
840,
479
],
[
117,
480,
231,
495
],
[
235,
480,
251,
495
],
[
254,
480,
277,
495
],
[
280,
480,
327,
495
],
[
331,
480,
359,
495
],
[
363,
480,
382,
495
],
[
386,
480,
443,
495
],
[
447,
480,
484,
495
],
[
488,
480,
563,
495
],
[
567,
480,
582,
495
],
[
586,
480,
625,
495
],
[
628,
480,
652,
495
],
[
656,
480,
711,
495
],
[
715,
480,
730,
495
],
[
733,
480,
754,
495
],
[
758,
480,
850,
495
],
[
853,
480,
868,
495
],
[
872,
480,
883,
495
],
[
120,
496,
184,
511
],
[
187,
497,
263,
511
],
[
267,
497,
292,
511
],
[
297,
497,
388,
512
],
[
392,
497,
452,
512
],
[
457,
497,
485,
512
],
[
489,
497,
502,
512
],
[
506,
497,
572,
512
],
[
576,
497,
681,
512
],
[
685,
497,
711,
512
],
[
714,
496,
788,
512
],
[
792,
496,
824,
511
],
[
827,
496,
850,
511
],
[
853,
496,
894,
511
],
[
117,
513,
213,
528
],
[
216,
513,
232,
526
],
[
235,
513,
257,
526
],
[
261,
513,
312,
527
],
[
156,
541,
248,
555
],
[
251,
541,
265,
555
],
[
268,
541,
292,
555
],
[
295,
541,
326,
555
],
[
330,
541,
358,
555
],
[
361,
541,
377,
555
],
[
380,
541,
402,
555
],
[
406,
541,
468,
556
],
[
471,
541,
550,
556
],
[
554,
541,
576,
556
],
[
580,
541,
655,
556
],
[
658,
541,
702,
556
],
[
705,
541,
780,
556
],
[
782,
541,
797,
556
],
[
800,
541,
876,
556
],
[
118,
557,
144,
571
],
[
148,
557,
170,
571
],
[
174,
558,
270,
571
],
[
272,
558,
328,
571
],
[
331,
558,
360,
571
],
[
364,
558,
400,
571
],
[
403,
558,
468,
572
],
[
471,
558,
479,
572
],
[
482,
558,
558,
572
],
[
561,
557,
632,
572
],
[
635,
557,
691,
572
],
[
694,
557,
721,
572
],
[
724,
557,
777,
572
],
[
780,
557,
795,
572
],
[
798,
557,
855,
572
],
[
857,
557,
892,
572
],
[
118,
574,
144,
587
],
[
147,
574,
174,
587
],
[
179,
573,
234,
587
],
[
238,
573,
315,
588
],
[
319,
573,
340,
588
],
[
344,
573,
373,
588
],
[
377,
573,
459,
588
],
[
462,
573,
504,
588
],
[
507,
573,
531,
588
],
[
534,
573,
587,
588
],
[
590,
573,
602,
588
],
[
605,
573,
633,
589
],
[
636,
573,
672,
589
],
[
675,
573,
703,
589
],
[
706,
573,
780,
589
],
[
783,
574,
831,
589
],
[
834,
574,
886,
589
],
[
117,
590,
141,
603
],
[
144,
590,
164,
603
],
[
167,
589,
270,
605
],
[
273,
589,
290,
605
],
[
293,
589,
335,
605
],
[
342,
589,
403,
605
],
[
406,
590,
552,
606
],
[
555,
590,
595,
606
],
[
118,
620,
194,
636
],
[
118,
675,
160,
690
],
[
163,
675,
223,
690
],
[
118,
691,
165,
706
],
[
169,
692,
234,
706
],
[
237,
692,
320,
706
],
[
324,
692,
337,
706
],
[
342,
691,
413,
706
],
[
417,
691,
471,
706
],
[
119,
723,
142,
739
],
[
147,
723,
196,
739
],
[
200,
723,
255,
738
],
[
259,
723,
325,
738
],
[
328,
723,
374,
737
],
[
154,
739,
202,
754
],
[
206,
739,
262,
754
],
[
266,
739,
335,
754
],
[
338,
739,
395,
754
],
[
152,
755,
188,
770
],
[
192,
755,
249,
770
],
[
253,
755,
304,
769
],
[
139,
798,
161,
811
],
[
163,
798,
214,
812
],
[
216,
799,
271,
812
],
[
274,
800,
316,
813
],
[
318,
800,
354,
813
],
[
357,
800,
411,
813
],
[
413,
801,
430,
814
],
[
432,
801,
471,
814
],
[
474,
801,
531,
814
],
[
534,
801,
578,
814
],
[
580,
801,
592,
814
],
[
595,
801,
610,
814
],
[
613,
801,
659,
814
],
[
662,
801,
673,
813
],
[
676,
800,
732,
813
],
[
735,
800,
761,
813
],
[
764,
800,
814,
813
],
[
127,
814,
156,
825
],
[
158,
814,
176,
825
],
[
178,
814,
218,
826
],
[
220,
814,
232,
826
],
[
234,
814,
285,
826
],
[
288,
814,
300,
826
],
[
302,
814,
331,
826
],
[
334,
814,
390,
826
],
[
392,
814,
438,
826
],
[
441,
814,
461,
826
],
[
464,
814,
506,
826
],
[
508,
814,
529,
826
],
[
531,
814,
560,
826
],
[
562,
814,
605,
826
],
[
608,
814,
634,
826
],
[
636,
814,
670,
826
],
[
672,
814,
720,
826
],
[
722,
814,
742,
826
],
[
745,
814,
774,
826
],
[
777,
814,
804,
826
],
[
807,
814,
818,
826
],
[
127,
825,
184,
837
],
[
186,
825,
197,
837
],
[
200,
825,
250,
837
],
[
252,
825,
331,
837
],
[
334,
826,
368,
837
],
[
370,
826,
390,
837
],
[
392,
826,
424,
837
],
[
426,
826,
493,
837
],
[
496,
826,
538,
837
],
[
540,
826,
605,
837
],
[
608,
826,
646,
837
],
[
648,
826,
696,
837
],
[
698,
826,
727,
837
],
[
730,
826,
780,
837
],
[
128,
837,
174,
848
],
[
177,
837,
188,
848
],
[
191,
837,
230,
848
],
[
232,
837,
263,
849
],
[
266,
837,
300,
849
],
[
302,
837,
335,
849
],
[
337,
837,
374,
849
],
[
376,
837,
395,
849
],
[
397,
837,
431,
849
],
[
434,
837,
454,
849
],
[
456,
837,
531,
849
],
[
534,
837,
580,
849
],
[
582,
837,
601,
849
],
[
603,
837,
644,
849
],
[
646,
837,
687,
848
],
[
690,
837,
709,
848
],
[
711,
837,
757,
848
],
[
759,
837,
772,
848
],
[
127,
848,
178,
860
],
[
181,
848,
191,
860
],
[
194,
848,
201,
860
],
[
203,
848,
229,
860
],
[
231,
849,
267,
860
],
[
270,
849,
322,
860
],
[
324,
849,
344,
860
],
[
347,
849,
353,
860
],
[
355,
849,
375,
860
],
[
378,
849,
420,
860
],
[
422,
849,
434,
860
],
[
437,
849,
452,
860
],
[
455,
849,
497,
860
],
[
500,
849,
551,
860
],
[
554,
849,
562,
860
],
[
565,
849,
575,
860
],
[
577,
849,
597,
860
],
[
600,
849,
611,
860
],
[
614,
849,
630,
860
],
[
632,
849,
675,
860
],
[
678,
849,
714,
860
],
[
717,
849,
772,
860
],
[
127,
860,
185,
871
],
[
187,
860,
204,
871
],
[
206,
860,
222,
871
],
[
225,
860,
253,
871
],
[
255,
860,
272,
872
],
[
275,
860,
287,
872
],
[
290,
860,
321,
872
],
[
324,
860,
352,
872
],
[
355,
860,
367,
872
],
[
370,
860,
393,
872
],
[
395,
860,
438,
872
],
[
441,
860,
496,
872
],
[
498,
860,
555,
872
],
[
557,
860,
575,
872
],
[
577,
860,
614,
872
],
[
616,
860,
632,
872
],
[
635,
860,
670,
872
],
[
672,
860,
721,
872
],
[
723,
860,
734,
872
],
[
736,
860,
782,
871
],
[
784,
860,
805,
871
],
[
130,
873,
199,
883
],
[
201,
872,
235,
884
],
[
237,
872,
258,
884
],
[
260,
872,
301,
884
],
[
304,
872,
331,
884
],
[
332,
872,
369,
884
],
[
371,
872,
397,
884
],
[
400,
872,
442,
884
],
[
444,
872,
492,
884
],
[
494,
872,
507,
884
],
[
510,
872,
535,
884
],
[
539,
872,
591,
884
],
[
593,
872,
614,
884
],
[
615,
872,
638,
884
],
[
640,
872,
666,
884
],
[
668,
872,
727,
884
],
[
729,
873,
753,
883
],
[
755,
873,
798,
883
],
[
128,
885,
172,
895
],
[
174,
885,
212,
895
],
[
215,
885,
238,
895
],
[
241,
885,
304,
896
],
[
306,
885,
352,
896
],
[
354,
885,
365,
896
],
[
368,
885,
413,
896
],
[
415,
885,
457,
896
],
[
460,
885,
479,
896
],
[
481,
885,
493,
896
],
[
497,
885,
532,
896
],
[
534,
885,
572,
896
],
[
575,
885,
594,
896
],
[
596,
885,
627,
896
],
[
629,
885,
640,
896
],
[
642,
885,
659,
896
],
[
661,
885,
705,
896
],
[
707,
885,
744,
895
],
[
747,
885,
826,
895
],
[
30,
911,
202,
926
],
[
519,
913,
542,
925
],
[
545,
913,
589,
925
],
[
591,
913,
611,
925
],
[
614,
913,
632,
925
],
[
635,
913,
642,
925
],
[
644,
913,
720,
925
],
[
722,
913,
743,
925
],
[
747,
913,
785,
925
],
[
788,
913,
794,
925
],
[
797,
912,
830,
925
],
[
833,
912,
890,
925
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
By whom is this letter written?
|
Sarah Brozena
|
899
|
[
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"http://www.nap.edu/catalog/11811.html",
"PREPUBLICATION",
"COPY",
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"Committee",
"to",
"Review",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Board",
"on",
"Environmental",
"Studies",
"and",
"Toxicology",
"Division",
"on",
"Earth",
"and",
"Life",
"Studies",
"NATIONAL",
"RESEARCH",
"COUNCIL",
"OF",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"PRESS",
"Washington,",
"D.C.",
"www.nap.edu",
"Source:",
"httpspylighvo/National",
"Atadel,caf",
"screndes.",
"(All",
"fights",
"deserted.s/slcn0226"
] |
[
[
10,
8,
61,
17
],
[
64,
7,
105,
17
],
[
111,
7,
122,
17
],
[
125,
7,
143,
18
],
[
147,
7,
204,
18
],
[
207,
7,
232,
18
],
[
236,
7,
308,
19
],
[
311,
7,
354,
19
],
[
357,
7,
380,
19
],
[
387,
6,
405,
19
],
[
409,
6,
443,
19
],
[
447,
6,
458,
19
],
[
461,
6,
540,
19
],
[
542,
6,
564,
19
],
[
567,
6,
610,
19
],
[
7,
17,
237,
27
],
[
327,
95,
588,
116
],
[
602,
94,
683,
115
],
[
175,
227,
362,
260
],
[
368,
228,
504,
261
],
[
521,
229,
565,
262
],
[
572,
229,
636,
263
],
[
643,
228,
824,
266
],
[
168,
270,
254,
300
],
[
268,
269,
495,
301
],
[
502,
269,
655,
301
],
[
670,
269,
754,
301
],
[
777,
268,
838,
300
],
[
167,
310,
290,
342
],
[
297,
310,
337,
343
],
[
344,
310,
608,
345
],
[
615,
310,
693,
345
],
[
700,
310,
840,
345
],
[
272,
432,
358,
448
],
[
362,
433,
380,
448
],
[
384,
433,
443,
448
],
[
448,
433,
474,
448
],
[
478,
433,
522,
448
],
[
527,
433,
565,
448
],
[
569,
433,
662,
448
],
[
666,
433,
730,
449
],
[
308,
467,
356,
483
],
[
360,
468,
380,
483
],
[
384,
468,
503,
484
],
[
507,
467,
565,
484
],
[
570,
467,
601,
485
],
[
605,
467,
694,
486
],
[
363,
503,
433,
518
],
[
437,
504,
457,
518
],
[
461,
504,
505,
519
],
[
508,
504,
538,
519
],
[
541,
504,
577,
519
],
[
580,
503,
638,
519
],
[
344,
632,
451,
650
],
[
455,
633,
557,
650
],
[
564,
632,
654,
649
],
[
466,
651,
485,
664
],
[
488,
652,
511,
664
],
[
514,
652,
580,
664
],
[
582,
652,
657,
664
],
[
380,
778,
405,
794
],
[
409,
778,
489,
794
],
[
492,
778,
581,
793
],
[
584,
779,
627,
794
],
[
442,
796,
530,
811
],
[
533,
797,
562,
811
],
[
443,
814,
565,
827
],
[
224,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
981,
437,
997
],
[
441,
982,
512,
997
],
[
516,
981,
567,
997
],
[
571,
981,
588,
997
],
[
592,
981,
625,
997
],
[
630,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
What is the main heading of the document?
|
Scientific Review of the Proposed Risk Assessment Bulletin from the Office of Management and Budget
|
724
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Comments",
"to",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"on",
"Its",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"INTRODUCTION",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"provide",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"these",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"proposed",
"procedures",
"for",
"prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA)",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"ACC",
"strongly",
"supported",
"Congress's",
"efforts",
"to",
"update",
"and",
"reform",
"TSCA.",
"One",
"of",
"ACC's",
"principles",
"for",
"modernizing",
"TSCA",
"called",
"on",
"EPA",
"to",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations.",
"Without",
"a",
"scientifically",
"based",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"EPA",
"would",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"meet",
"efficiently",
"the",
"other",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"achieve",
"the",
"objectives",
"of",
"TSCA",
"reform",
"that",
"Congress",
"intended.",
"As",
"discussed",
"in",
"more",
"detail",
"below,",
"EPA's",
"proposed",
"prioritization",
"process",
"falls",
"short.",
"Congress",
"designed",
"the",
"LCSA",
"to",
"allow",
"chemicals",
"to",
"be",
"systematically",
"prioritized",
"and",
"then",
"to",
"evaluate",
"those",
"substances",
"presenting",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"risk.",
"This",
"design",
"is",
"apparent",
"in",
"every",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"It",
"begins",
"with",
"a",
"reclassification",
"of",
"the",
"full",
"catalog",
"of",
"chemistries",
"in",
"U.S.",
"commerce,",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory.",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"that",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"be",
"sorted,",
"so",
"that",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"currently",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"separated",
"from",
"those",
"no",
"longer",
"manufactured,",
"imported",
"or",
"used;",
"only",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"prioritization",
"and",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"This",
"enables",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"resources",
"for",
"its",
"multi-year,",
"time-and-resource",
"intensive",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"actually",
"in",
"current",
"use.",
"EPA",
"must",
"next",
"undertake",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"sequence",
"of",
"chemicals",
"that",
"will",
"undergo",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"must",
"then",
"undertake",
"a",
"formal",
"scoping",
"process,",
"to",
"define",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"(and",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"sub-populations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"use)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"chemical.",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"various",
"purposes",
"is",
"not",
"new",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"In",
"2011,",
"EPA",
"held",
"a",
"Stakeholder",
"Dialogue",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"and",
"established",
"a",
"Discussion",
"Blog",
"for",
"additional",
"input",
"on",
"the",
"topic.",
"In",
"our",
"comments",
"to",
"that",
"discussion",
"blog,",
"ACC",
"identified",
"several",
"general",
"principles",
"for",
"prioritization",
"(Attachment",
"A).",
"We",
"believe",
"these",
"principles",
"are",
"reflected",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA",
"requirements,",
"in",
"particular",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"recognition",
"that",
"prioritization",
"is",
"a",
"risk",
"based",
"screening",
"process",
"that",
"integrates",
"information",
"on",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"In",
"2011,",
"ACC",
"developed",
"a",
"two-step",
"quantitative",
"and",
"qualitative",
"tool",
"to",
"\"proof",
"test\"",
"our",
"prioritization",
"principles",
"(Attachment",
"B).",
"We",
"presented",
"our",
"principles",
"and",
"our",
"prioritization",
"tool",
"to",
"EPA",
"in",
"2011,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"other",
"industry",
"and",
"NGO",
"stakeholders",
"at",
"the",
"time.",
"In",
"2012,",
"EPA",
"published",
"its",
"methodology",
"to",
"identify",
"chemicals",
"for",
"its",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
368,
64,
451,
80
],
[
457,
64,
548,
80
],
[
551,
62,
616,
80
],
[
277,
84,
366,
100
],
[
370,
84,
389,
100
],
[
392,
85,
428,
100
],
[
432,
85,
560,
100
],
[
564,
85,
651,
100
],
[
656,
85,
718,
100
],
[
722,
85,
745,
100
],
[
260,
103,
283,
119
],
[
287,
103,
366,
119
],
[
370,
104,
467,
120
],
[
470,
105,
497,
120
],
[
501,
105,
615,
120
],
[
619,
105,
638,
120
],
[
642,
104,
728,
120
],
[
731,
103,
761,
119
],
[
253,
124,
294,
139
],
[
297,
124,
389,
139
],
[
392,
125,
445,
139
],
[
449,
125,
478,
139
],
[
481,
125,
528,
139
],
[
531,
125,
627,
139
],
[
631,
125,
696,
139
],
[
700,
125,
727,
139
],
[
454,
159,
597,
173
],
[
198,
193,
230,
208
],
[
233,
194,
312,
209
],
[
315,
194,
399,
210
],
[
402,
193,
465,
210
],
[
468,
193,
523,
210
],
[
526,
193,
542,
210
],
[
545,
193,
606,
210
],
[
609,
193,
625,
210
],
[
628,
193,
691,
210
],
[
694,
192,
721,
209
],
[
723,
192,
756,
209
],
[
140,
213,
256,
229
],
[
260,
214,
342,
230
],
[
346,
214,
408,
230
],
[
411,
214,
464,
230
],
[
467,
214,
508,
230
],
[
512,
214,
595,
230
],
[
598,
214,
619,
230
],
[
622,
214,
648,
230
],
[
651,
214,
728,
230
],
[
731,
214,
804,
230
],
[
137,
234,
225,
250
],
[
230,
234,
252,
250
],
[
256,
234,
361,
250
],
[
365,
234,
382,
249
],
[
387,
234,
465,
249
],
[
470,
234,
492,
249
],
[
496,
234,
528,
249
],
[
532,
233,
614,
249
],
[
617,
233,
664,
249
],
[
667,
233,
694,
249
],
[
698,
233,
744,
249
],
[
748,
233,
838,
249
],
[
139,
253,
201,
269
],
[
205,
253,
233,
269
],
[
236,
253,
301,
270
],
[
304,
254,
322,
270
],
[
325,
254,
397,
270
],
[
400,
254,
422,
270
],
[
425,
254,
451,
270
],
[
454,
254,
547,
270
],
[
550,
253,
627,
270
],
[
630,
253,
682,
270
],
[
685,
253,
715,
270
],
[
718,
253,
790,
269
],
[
793,
253,
820,
269
],
[
138,
272,
190,
289
],
[
193,
273,
257,
289
],
[
261,
273,
300,
290
],
[
304,
273,
321,
290
],
[
324,
273,
398,
290
],
[
402,
274,
422,
290
],
[
427,
274,
464,
290
],
[
468,
274,
477,
290
],
[
480,
274,
563,
290
],
[
567,
274,
642,
290
],
[
646,
274,
707,
290
],
[
711,
274,
727,
290
],
[
731,
274,
792,
290
],
[
796,
274,
834,
289
],
[
140,
294,
167,
309
],
[
171,
294,
201,
310
],
[
205,
294,
267,
310
],
[
270,
295,
355,
310
],
[
359,
295,
383,
310
],
[
387,
295,
417,
310
],
[
421,
294,
512,
310
],
[
516,
294,
561,
310
],
[
565,
294,
590,
309
],
[
594,
294,
647,
309
],
[
198,
326,
240,
343
],
[
243,
326,
308,
343
],
[
312,
326,
391,
343
],
[
395,
327,
482,
343
],
[
487,
327,
538,
343
],
[
542,
327,
558,
343
],
[
562,
326,
615,
343
],
[
620,
326,
649,
342
],
[
653,
326,
705,
342
],
[
712,
326,
768,
342
],
[
772,
326,
805,
342
],
[
809,
326,
830,
342
],
[
140,
346,
192,
363
],
[
197,
346,
276,
363
],
[
281,
346,
303,
362
],
[
307,
346,
410,
362
],
[
414,
346,
464,
362
],
[
467,
346,
516,
362
],
[
520,
346,
540,
362
],
[
544,
347,
581,
362
],
[
585,
347,
602,
362
],
[
606,
347,
718,
362
],
[
722,
347,
797,
362
],
[
139,
366,
218,
382
],
[
222,
366,
244,
382
],
[
248,
366,
320,
382
],
[
324,
366,
341,
382
],
[
345,
367,
376,
382
],
[
380,
367,
477,
382
],
[
481,
367,
545,
382
],
[
550,
367,
558,
382
],
[
562,
367,
664,
382
],
[
668,
367,
714,
382
],
[
717,
366,
825,
382
],
[
138,
387,
204,
402
],
[
207,
387,
244,
402
],
[
249,
387,
299,
402
],
[
302,
387,
328,
402
],
[
332,
387,
352,
402
],
[
356,
387,
390,
402
],
[
394,
387,
410,
402
],
[
414,
387,
453,
402
],
[
457,
387,
539,
402
],
[
542,
387,
568,
402
],
[
572,
387,
612,
402
],
[
616,
386,
721,
402
],
[
725,
386,
741,
402
],
[
745,
386,
771,
401
],
[
774,
386,
826,
401
],
[
831,
385,
860,
401
],
[
140,
406,
198,
423
],
[
202,
407,
229,
423
],
[
232,
407,
314,
423
],
[
317,
407,
336,
423
],
[
340,
407,
388,
423
],
[
392,
407,
444,
423
],
[
451,
407,
482,
423
],
[
485,
407,
560,
423
],
[
564,
407,
639,
423
],
[
642,
407,
667,
422
],
[
671,
407,
744,
422
],
[
748,
407,
764,
422
],
[
768,
407,
812,
422
],
[
817,
406,
855,
422
],
[
138,
426,
192,
443
],
[
197,
426,
248,
443
],
[
252,
427,
324,
443
],
[
328,
427,
432,
443
],
[
435,
428,
497,
443
],
[
500,
428,
536,
442
],
[
539,
427,
584,
442
],
[
199,
459,
274,
475
],
[
277,
460,
346,
475
],
[
350,
460,
374,
475
],
[
377,
460,
430,
475
],
[
433,
460,
450,
475
],
[
454,
460,
498,
475
],
[
503,
460,
582,
475
],
[
585,
460,
602,
475
],
[
605,
460,
625,
475
],
[
629,
459,
742,
475
],
[
745,
459,
830,
475
],
[
833,
459,
864,
475
],
[
138,
479,
172,
495
],
[
176,
480,
193,
495
],
[
197,
480,
264,
495
],
[
268,
480,
310,
495
],
[
314,
480,
399,
495
],
[
402,
480,
485,
495
],
[
489,
480,
515,
495
],
[
519,
480,
581,
495
],
[
585,
480,
654,
495
],
[
658,
480,
696,
495
],
[
700,
480,
738,
495
],
[
742,
479,
790,
495
],
[
794,
479,
806,
495
],
[
140,
500,
207,
515
],
[
210,
500,
228,
515
],
[
231,
500,
276,
515
],
[
279,
500,
312,
515
],
[
315,
500,
332,
515
],
[
335,
500,
361,
515
],
[
364,
500,
422,
515
],
[
424,
500,
438,
515
],
[
441,
500,
495,
515
],
[
498,
500,
535,
515
],
[
538,
500,
548,
515
],
[
551,
500,
672,
515
],
[
675,
500,
692,
515
],
[
695,
500,
722,
515
],
[
725,
500,
755,
515
],
[
757,
499,
817,
515
],
[
820,
499,
841,
515
],
[
140,
520,
228,
535
],
[
232,
520,
250,
536
],
[
254,
520,
290,
536
],
[
294,
520,
380,
536
],
[
384,
520,
411,
536
],
[
415,
520,
464,
536
],
[
468,
520,
552,
536
],
[
556,
520,
586,
536
],
[
590,
520,
642,
535
],
[
645,
520,
710,
535
],
[
713,
520,
744,
535
],
[
748,
520,
775,
535
],
[
780,
519,
828,
535
],
[
139,
540,
215,
555
],
[
218,
540,
240,
555
],
[
243,
540,
297,
555
],
[
301,
540,
319,
555
],
[
322,
540,
354,
555
],
[
358,
540,
437,
555
],
[
440,
541,
471,
555
],
[
475,
541,
501,
555
],
[
505,
541,
577,
555
],
[
581,
541,
628,
555
],
[
631,
541,
649,
555
],
[
652,
540,
736,
555
],
[
740,
540,
765,
555
],
[
768,
540,
845,
555
],
[
138,
560,
174,
575
],
[
181,
560,
223,
575
],
[
227,
560,
248,
575
],
[
252,
560,
304,
575
],
[
307,
560,
420,
576
],
[
424,
560,
497,
576
],
[
501,
560,
518,
576
],
[
522,
560,
565,
576
],
[
568,
560,
605,
575
],
[
609,
560,
687,
575
],
[
690,
561,
724,
575
],
[
727,
561,
751,
575
],
[
754,
561,
802,
575
],
[
806,
561,
823,
574
],
[
141,
581,
222,
595
],
[
225,
581,
250,
595
],
[
254,
581,
311,
595
],
[
314,
581,
330,
595
],
[
334,
581,
359,
595
],
[
362,
581,
467,
595
],
[
471,
581,
501,
595
],
[
504,
581,
535,
595
],
[
539,
581,
629,
595
],
[
632,
581,
666,
595
],
[
670,
581,
731,
595
],
[
734,
581,
770,
595
],
[
776,
581,
792,
595
],
[
795,
580,
840,
595
],
[
137,
600,
213,
616
],
[
217,
601,
241,
616
],
[
244,
601,
264,
616
],
[
268,
601,
356,
616
],
[
360,
601,
504,
616
],
[
507,
601,
580,
616
],
[
584,
601,
615,
616
],
[
619,
601,
709,
616
],
[
712,
601,
734,
616
],
[
737,
600,
817,
615
],
[
820,
600,
850,
615
],
[
140,
621,
164,
635
],
[
167,
621,
230,
635
],
[
234,
621,
251,
635
],
[
254,
621,
311,
635
],
[
315,
621,
349,
635
],
[
352,
621,
387,
635
],
[
392,
621,
432,
636
],
[
435,
621,
472,
636
],
[
475,
621,
554,
636
],
[
558,
621,
567,
636
],
[
571,
621,
674,
636
],
[
677,
621,
743,
635
],
[
746,
621,
764,
635
],
[
767,
620,
817,
635
],
[
825,
620,
850,
635
],
[
139,
641,
212,
655
],
[
215,
641,
233,
655
],
[
237,
641,
316,
656
],
[
320,
641,
352,
656
],
[
355,
641,
386,
656
],
[
390,
640,
455,
656
],
[
458,
640,
490,
656
],
[
492,
640,
582,
656
],
[
585,
640,
621,
656
],
[
627,
640,
667,
656
],
[
670,
640,
705,
655
],
[
708,
640,
787,
655
],
[
790,
640,
802,
655
],
[
804,
640,
860,
655
],
[
139,
662,
200,
675
],
[
203,
661,
270,
676
],
[
272,
661,
290,
676
],
[
297,
661,
344,
676
],
[
347,
661,
373,
676
],
[
376,
661,
460,
676
],
[
463,
661,
482,
676
],
[
485,
661,
513,
676
],
[
516,
661,
552,
676
],
[
555,
661,
641,
676
],
[
644,
661,
710,
676
],
[
714,
661,
835,
676
],
[
138,
681,
202,
695
],
[
205,
681,
222,
695
],
[
225,
681,
252,
695
],
[
255,
681,
289,
695
],
[
292,
681,
326,
695
],
[
329,
681,
359,
695
],
[
362,
681,
382,
695
],
[
385,
681,
455,
696
],
[
458,
681,
475,
696
],
[
478,
681,
505,
696
],
[
508,
681,
555,
696
],
[
558,
680,
576,
696
],
[
579,
680,
604,
696
],
[
607,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
725,
696
],
[
728,
680,
745,
695
],
[
748,
680,
775,
695
],
[
778,
680,
855,
695
],
[
197,
713,
303,
729
],
[
307,
714,
323,
729
],
[
327,
714,
407,
729
],
[
411,
714,
435,
729
],
[
439,
714,
496,
729
],
[
500,
714,
571,
729
],
[
575,
714,
589,
729
],
[
593,
714,
620,
729
],
[
624,
714,
655,
729
],
[
661,
714,
677,
729
],
[
681,
714,
708,
729
],
[
711,
713,
783,
729
],
[
786,
713,
805,
729
],
[
808,
712,
854,
729
],
[
139,
732,
175,
748
],
[
180,
733,
216,
748
],
[
220,
733,
230,
748
],
[
234,
733,
328,
748
],
[
331,
734,
405,
748
],
[
408,
734,
430,
749
],
[
433,
734,
538,
749
],
[
542,
734,
571,
749
],
[
574,
734,
663,
749
],
[
666,
734,
677,
749
],
[
680,
733,
768,
749
],
[
771,
733,
811,
749
],
[
814,
733,
839,
748
],
[
140,
753,
218,
768
],
[
221,
754,
264,
769
],
[
268,
754,
287,
769
],
[
291,
754,
317,
769
],
[
320,
754,
367,
769
],
[
370,
755,
388,
769
],
[
391,
755,
418,
769
],
[
422,
755,
504,
769
],
[
507,
754,
523,
769
],
[
527,
754,
561,
769
],
[
565,
754,
644,
769
],
[
648,
754,
691,
769
],
[
694,
753,
734,
768
],
[
738,
752,
812,
768
],
[
140,
774,
196,
789
],
[
200,
774,
258,
789
],
[
261,
774,
340,
789
],
[
344,
774,
368,
789
],
[
371,
774,
475,
789
],
[
479,
774,
580,
789
],
[
584,
774,
610,
789
],
[
614,
774,
640,
789
],
[
644,
773,
702,
789
],
[
706,
773,
748,
789
],
[
752,
773,
830,
789
],
[
834,
773,
859,
789
],
[
138,
793,
208,
809
],
[
212,
793,
228,
809
],
[
232,
793,
258,
809
],
[
261,
794,
311,
809
],
[
315,
794,
425,
810
],
[
428,
794,
444,
810
],
[
447,
794,
525,
810
],
[
528,
794,
554,
810
],
[
558,
794,
622,
810
],
[
626,
794,
718,
810
],
[
721,
794,
751,
809
],
[
755,
793,
861,
809
],
[
138,
813,
153,
828
],
[
157,
813,
166,
828
],
[
170,
814,
200,
828
],
[
203,
814,
251,
829
],
[
255,
814,
330,
829
],
[
334,
815,
394,
829
],
[
398,
815,
428,
829
],
[
431,
815,
510,
829
],
[
513,
815,
607,
829
],
[
611,
815,
631,
829
],
[
634,
815,
671,
829
],
[
675,
814,
729,
829
],
[
732,
814,
762,
829
],
[
766,
814,
839,
829
],
[
137,
833,
214,
849
],
[
217,
833,
234,
849
],
[
238,
834,
284,
849
],
[
287,
834,
328,
849
],
[
335,
834,
414,
849
],
[
418,
834,
427,
849
],
[
431,
834,
500,
849
],
[
504,
834,
599,
849
],
[
603,
834,
632,
849
],
[
635,
834,
719,
849
],
[
722,
834,
754,
849
],
[
758,
834,
775,
848
],
[
779,
833,
832,
848
],
[
139,
854,
177,
869
],
[
180,
854,
206,
869
],
[
210,
854,
314,
869
],
[
317,
854,
397,
869
],
[
400,
854,
501,
869
],
[
504,
854,
531,
869
],
[
534,
854,
561,
869
],
[
564,
854,
642,
869
],
[
645,
854,
672,
869
],
[
675,
854,
756,
869
],
[
759,
854,
790,
869
],
[
792,
854,
819,
869
],
[
138,
874,
241,
889
],
[
245,
874,
278,
889
],
[
281,
874,
298,
889
],
[
302,
874,
338,
889
],
[
343,
874,
360,
890
],
[
364,
874,
410,
890
],
[
413,
874,
431,
890
],
[
435,
874,
469,
890
],
[
472,
874,
490,
890
],
[
493,
874,
511,
890
],
[
515,
873,
555,
890
],
[
558,
873,
625,
890
],
[
628,
873,
658,
890
],
[
661,
873,
702,
890
],
[
710,
873,
809,
889
],
[
812,
873,
827,
889
],
[
831,
873,
856,
889
],
[
138,
892,
179,
908
],
[
183,
892,
200,
909
],
[
204,
893,
250,
909
],
[
254,
893,
291,
909
],
[
295,
893,
372,
910
],
[
377,
893,
397,
910
],
[
400,
893,
504,
910
],
[
508,
893,
525,
910
],
[
530,
893,
591,
910
],
[
595,
892,
674,
910
],
[
678,
892,
702,
910
],
[
706,
892,
727,
909
],
[
731,
892,
780,
909
],
[
787,
892,
829,
909
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the abbreviation of Toxic Substances Control Act?
|
TSCA
|
899
|
[
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"http://www.nap.edu/catalog/11811.html",
"PREPUBLICATION",
"COPY",
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"Committee",
"to",
"Review",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Board",
"on",
"Environmental",
"Studies",
"and",
"Toxicology",
"Division",
"on",
"Earth",
"and",
"Life",
"Studies",
"NATIONAL",
"RESEARCH",
"COUNCIL",
"OF",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"PRESS",
"Washington,",
"D.C.",
"www.nap.edu",
"Source:",
"httpspylighvo/National",
"Atadel,caf",
"screndes.",
"(All",
"fights",
"deserted.s/slcn0226"
] |
[
[
10,
8,
61,
17
],
[
64,
7,
105,
17
],
[
111,
7,
122,
17
],
[
125,
7,
143,
18
],
[
147,
7,
204,
18
],
[
207,
7,
232,
18
],
[
236,
7,
308,
19
],
[
311,
7,
354,
19
],
[
357,
7,
380,
19
],
[
387,
6,
405,
19
],
[
409,
6,
443,
19
],
[
447,
6,
458,
19
],
[
461,
6,
540,
19
],
[
542,
6,
564,
19
],
[
567,
6,
610,
19
],
[
7,
17,
237,
27
],
[
327,
95,
588,
116
],
[
602,
94,
683,
115
],
[
175,
227,
362,
260
],
[
368,
228,
504,
261
],
[
521,
229,
565,
262
],
[
572,
229,
636,
263
],
[
643,
228,
824,
266
],
[
168,
270,
254,
300
],
[
268,
269,
495,
301
],
[
502,
269,
655,
301
],
[
670,
269,
754,
301
],
[
777,
268,
838,
300
],
[
167,
310,
290,
342
],
[
297,
310,
337,
343
],
[
344,
310,
608,
345
],
[
615,
310,
693,
345
],
[
700,
310,
840,
345
],
[
272,
432,
358,
448
],
[
362,
433,
380,
448
],
[
384,
433,
443,
448
],
[
448,
433,
474,
448
],
[
478,
433,
522,
448
],
[
527,
433,
565,
448
],
[
569,
433,
662,
448
],
[
666,
433,
730,
449
],
[
308,
467,
356,
483
],
[
360,
468,
380,
483
],
[
384,
468,
503,
484
],
[
507,
467,
565,
484
],
[
570,
467,
601,
485
],
[
605,
467,
694,
486
],
[
363,
503,
433,
518
],
[
437,
504,
457,
518
],
[
461,
504,
505,
519
],
[
508,
504,
538,
519
],
[
541,
504,
577,
519
],
[
580,
503,
638,
519
],
[
344,
632,
451,
650
],
[
455,
633,
557,
650
],
[
564,
632,
654,
649
],
[
466,
651,
485,
664
],
[
488,
652,
511,
664
],
[
514,
652,
580,
664
],
[
582,
652,
657,
664
],
[
380,
778,
405,
794
],
[
409,
778,
489,
794
],
[
492,
778,
581,
793
],
[
584,
779,
627,
794
],
[
442,
796,
530,
811
],
[
533,
797,
562,
811
],
[
443,
814,
565,
827
],
[
224,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
981,
437,
997
],
[
441,
982,
512,
997
],
[
516,
981,
567,
997
],
[
571,
981,
588,
997
],
[
592,
981,
625,
997
],
[
630,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
Where is The National Academic Press located?
|
Washington, D.C.
|
724
|
[
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"Comments",
"to",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"on",
"Its",
"Proposed",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"Chemicals",
"for",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"INTRODUCTION",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"provide",
"the",
"U.S.",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"these",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Agency's",
"proposed",
"procedures",
"for",
"prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(TSCA)",
"as",
"amended",
"by",
"the",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(LCSA).",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"a",
"risk-based",
"screening",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"high",
"and",
"low",
"priority",
"substances",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"under",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"ACC",
"strongly",
"supported",
"Congress's",
"efforts",
"to",
"update",
"and",
"reform",
"TSCA.",
"One",
"of",
"ACC's",
"principles",
"for",
"modernizing",
"TSCA",
"called",
"on",
"EPA",
"to",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations.",
"Without",
"a",
"scientifically",
"based",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"EPA",
"would",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"meet",
"efficiently",
"the",
"other",
"requirements",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"and",
"achieve",
"the",
"objectives",
"of",
"TSCA",
"reform",
"that",
"Congress",
"intended.",
"As",
"discussed",
"in",
"more",
"detail",
"below,",
"EPA's",
"proposed",
"prioritization",
"process",
"falls",
"short.",
"Congress",
"designed",
"the",
"LCSA",
"to",
"allow",
"chemicals",
"to",
"be",
"systematically",
"prioritized",
"and",
"then",
"to",
"evaluate",
"those",
"substances",
"presenting",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"risk.",
"This",
"design",
"is",
"apparent",
"in",
"every",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"It",
"begins",
"with",
"a",
"reclassification",
"of",
"the",
"full",
"catalog",
"of",
"chemistries",
"in",
"U.S.",
"commerce,",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory.",
"The",
"LCSA",
"requires",
"that",
"the",
"TSCA",
"Inventory",
"be",
"sorted,",
"so",
"that",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"currently",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"separated",
"from",
"those",
"no",
"longer",
"manufactured,",
"imported",
"or",
"used;",
"only",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"active",
"in",
"commerce",
"are",
"subject",
"to",
"the",
"prioritization",
"and",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"This",
"enables",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"resources",
"for",
"its",
"multi-year,",
"time-and-resource",
"intensive",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"are",
"actually",
"in",
"current",
"use.",
"EPA",
"must",
"next",
"undertake",
"a",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"sequence",
"of",
"chemicals",
"that",
"will",
"undergo",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"must",
"then",
"undertake",
"a",
"formal",
"scoping",
"process,",
"to",
"define",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"(and",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"sub-populations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"use)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"chemical.",
"Prioritization",
"of",
"chemicals",
"for",
"various",
"purposes",
"is",
"not",
"new",
"to",
"the",
"Agency.",
"In",
"2011,",
"EPA",
"held",
"a",
"Stakeholder",
"Dialogue",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"and",
"established",
"a",
"Discussion",
"Blog",
"for",
"additional",
"input",
"on",
"the",
"topic.",
"In",
"our",
"comments",
"to",
"that",
"discussion",
"blog,",
"ACC",
"identified",
"several",
"general",
"principles",
"for",
"prioritization",
"(Attachment",
"A).",
"We",
"believe",
"these",
"principles",
"are",
"reflected",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA",
"requirements,",
"in",
"particular",
"the",
"LCSA's",
"recognition",
"that",
"prioritization",
"is",
"a",
"risk",
"based",
"screening",
"process",
"that",
"integrates",
"information",
"on",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"In",
"2011,",
"ACC",
"developed",
"a",
"two-step",
"quantitative",
"and",
"qualitative",
"tool",
"to",
"\"proof",
"test\"",
"our",
"prioritization",
"principles",
"(Attachment",
"B).",
"We",
"presented",
"our",
"principles",
"and",
"our",
"prioritization",
"tool",
"to",
"EPA",
"in",
"2011,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"other",
"industry",
"and",
"NGO",
"stakeholders",
"at",
"the",
"time.",
"In",
"2012,",
"EPA",
"published",
"its",
"methodology",
"to",
"identify",
"chemicals",
"for",
"its",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
368,
64,
451,
80
],
[
457,
64,
548,
80
],
[
551,
62,
616,
80
],
[
277,
84,
366,
100
],
[
370,
84,
389,
100
],
[
392,
85,
428,
100
],
[
432,
85,
560,
100
],
[
564,
85,
651,
100
],
[
656,
85,
718,
100
],
[
722,
85,
745,
100
],
[
260,
103,
283,
119
],
[
287,
103,
366,
119
],
[
370,
104,
467,
120
],
[
470,
105,
497,
120
],
[
501,
105,
615,
120
],
[
619,
105,
638,
120
],
[
642,
104,
728,
120
],
[
731,
103,
761,
119
],
[
253,
124,
294,
139
],
[
297,
124,
389,
139
],
[
392,
125,
445,
139
],
[
449,
125,
478,
139
],
[
481,
125,
528,
139
],
[
531,
125,
627,
139
],
[
631,
125,
696,
139
],
[
700,
125,
727,
139
],
[
454,
159,
597,
173
],
[
198,
193,
230,
208
],
[
233,
194,
312,
209
],
[
315,
194,
399,
210
],
[
402,
193,
465,
210
],
[
468,
193,
523,
210
],
[
526,
193,
542,
210
],
[
545,
193,
606,
210
],
[
609,
193,
625,
210
],
[
628,
193,
691,
210
],
[
694,
192,
721,
209
],
[
723,
192,
756,
209
],
[
140,
213,
256,
229
],
[
260,
214,
342,
230
],
[
346,
214,
408,
230
],
[
411,
214,
464,
230
],
[
467,
214,
508,
230
],
[
512,
214,
595,
230
],
[
598,
214,
619,
230
],
[
622,
214,
648,
230
],
[
651,
214,
728,
230
],
[
731,
214,
804,
230
],
[
137,
234,
225,
250
],
[
230,
234,
252,
250
],
[
256,
234,
361,
250
],
[
365,
234,
382,
249
],
[
387,
234,
465,
249
],
[
470,
234,
492,
249
],
[
496,
234,
528,
249
],
[
532,
233,
614,
249
],
[
617,
233,
664,
249
],
[
667,
233,
694,
249
],
[
698,
233,
744,
249
],
[
748,
233,
838,
249
],
[
139,
253,
201,
269
],
[
205,
253,
233,
269
],
[
236,
253,
301,
270
],
[
304,
254,
322,
270
],
[
325,
254,
397,
270
],
[
400,
254,
422,
270
],
[
425,
254,
451,
270
],
[
454,
254,
547,
270
],
[
550,
253,
627,
270
],
[
630,
253,
682,
270
],
[
685,
253,
715,
270
],
[
718,
253,
790,
269
],
[
793,
253,
820,
269
],
[
138,
272,
190,
289
],
[
193,
273,
257,
289
],
[
261,
273,
300,
290
],
[
304,
273,
321,
290
],
[
324,
273,
398,
290
],
[
402,
274,
422,
290
],
[
427,
274,
464,
290
],
[
468,
274,
477,
290
],
[
480,
274,
563,
290
],
[
567,
274,
642,
290
],
[
646,
274,
707,
290
],
[
711,
274,
727,
290
],
[
731,
274,
792,
290
],
[
796,
274,
834,
289
],
[
140,
294,
167,
309
],
[
171,
294,
201,
310
],
[
205,
294,
267,
310
],
[
270,
295,
355,
310
],
[
359,
295,
383,
310
],
[
387,
295,
417,
310
],
[
421,
294,
512,
310
],
[
516,
294,
561,
310
],
[
565,
294,
590,
309
],
[
594,
294,
647,
309
],
[
198,
326,
240,
343
],
[
243,
326,
308,
343
],
[
312,
326,
391,
343
],
[
395,
327,
482,
343
],
[
487,
327,
538,
343
],
[
542,
327,
558,
343
],
[
562,
326,
615,
343
],
[
620,
326,
649,
342
],
[
653,
326,
705,
342
],
[
712,
326,
768,
342
],
[
772,
326,
805,
342
],
[
809,
326,
830,
342
],
[
140,
346,
192,
363
],
[
197,
346,
276,
363
],
[
281,
346,
303,
362
],
[
307,
346,
410,
362
],
[
414,
346,
464,
362
],
[
467,
346,
516,
362
],
[
520,
346,
540,
362
],
[
544,
347,
581,
362
],
[
585,
347,
602,
362
],
[
606,
347,
718,
362
],
[
722,
347,
797,
362
],
[
139,
366,
218,
382
],
[
222,
366,
244,
382
],
[
248,
366,
320,
382
],
[
324,
366,
341,
382
],
[
345,
367,
376,
382
],
[
380,
367,
477,
382
],
[
481,
367,
545,
382
],
[
550,
367,
558,
382
],
[
562,
367,
664,
382
],
[
668,
367,
714,
382
],
[
717,
366,
825,
382
],
[
138,
387,
204,
402
],
[
207,
387,
244,
402
],
[
249,
387,
299,
402
],
[
302,
387,
328,
402
],
[
332,
387,
352,
402
],
[
356,
387,
390,
402
],
[
394,
387,
410,
402
],
[
414,
387,
453,
402
],
[
457,
387,
539,
402
],
[
542,
387,
568,
402
],
[
572,
387,
612,
402
],
[
616,
386,
721,
402
],
[
725,
386,
741,
402
],
[
745,
386,
771,
401
],
[
774,
386,
826,
401
],
[
831,
385,
860,
401
],
[
140,
406,
198,
423
],
[
202,
407,
229,
423
],
[
232,
407,
314,
423
],
[
317,
407,
336,
423
],
[
340,
407,
388,
423
],
[
392,
407,
444,
423
],
[
451,
407,
482,
423
],
[
485,
407,
560,
423
],
[
564,
407,
639,
423
],
[
642,
407,
667,
422
],
[
671,
407,
744,
422
],
[
748,
407,
764,
422
],
[
768,
407,
812,
422
],
[
817,
406,
855,
422
],
[
138,
426,
192,
443
],
[
197,
426,
248,
443
],
[
252,
427,
324,
443
],
[
328,
427,
432,
443
],
[
435,
428,
497,
443
],
[
500,
428,
536,
442
],
[
539,
427,
584,
442
],
[
199,
459,
274,
475
],
[
277,
460,
346,
475
],
[
350,
460,
374,
475
],
[
377,
460,
430,
475
],
[
433,
460,
450,
475
],
[
454,
460,
498,
475
],
[
503,
460,
582,
475
],
[
585,
460,
602,
475
],
[
605,
460,
625,
475
],
[
629,
459,
742,
475
],
[
745,
459,
830,
475
],
[
833,
459,
864,
475
],
[
138,
479,
172,
495
],
[
176,
480,
193,
495
],
[
197,
480,
264,
495
],
[
268,
480,
310,
495
],
[
314,
480,
399,
495
],
[
402,
480,
485,
495
],
[
489,
480,
515,
495
],
[
519,
480,
581,
495
],
[
585,
480,
654,
495
],
[
658,
480,
696,
495
],
[
700,
480,
738,
495
],
[
742,
479,
790,
495
],
[
794,
479,
806,
495
],
[
140,
500,
207,
515
],
[
210,
500,
228,
515
],
[
231,
500,
276,
515
],
[
279,
500,
312,
515
],
[
315,
500,
332,
515
],
[
335,
500,
361,
515
],
[
364,
500,
422,
515
],
[
424,
500,
438,
515
],
[
441,
500,
495,
515
],
[
498,
500,
535,
515
],
[
538,
500,
548,
515
],
[
551,
500,
672,
515
],
[
675,
500,
692,
515
],
[
695,
500,
722,
515
],
[
725,
500,
755,
515
],
[
757,
499,
817,
515
],
[
820,
499,
841,
515
],
[
140,
520,
228,
535
],
[
232,
520,
250,
536
],
[
254,
520,
290,
536
],
[
294,
520,
380,
536
],
[
384,
520,
411,
536
],
[
415,
520,
464,
536
],
[
468,
520,
552,
536
],
[
556,
520,
586,
536
],
[
590,
520,
642,
535
],
[
645,
520,
710,
535
],
[
713,
520,
744,
535
],
[
748,
520,
775,
535
],
[
780,
519,
828,
535
],
[
139,
540,
215,
555
],
[
218,
540,
240,
555
],
[
243,
540,
297,
555
],
[
301,
540,
319,
555
],
[
322,
540,
354,
555
],
[
358,
540,
437,
555
],
[
440,
541,
471,
555
],
[
475,
541,
501,
555
],
[
505,
541,
577,
555
],
[
581,
541,
628,
555
],
[
631,
541,
649,
555
],
[
652,
540,
736,
555
],
[
740,
540,
765,
555
],
[
768,
540,
845,
555
],
[
138,
560,
174,
575
],
[
181,
560,
223,
575
],
[
227,
560,
248,
575
],
[
252,
560,
304,
575
],
[
307,
560,
420,
576
],
[
424,
560,
497,
576
],
[
501,
560,
518,
576
],
[
522,
560,
565,
576
],
[
568,
560,
605,
575
],
[
609,
560,
687,
575
],
[
690,
561,
724,
575
],
[
727,
561,
751,
575
],
[
754,
561,
802,
575
],
[
806,
561,
823,
574
],
[
141,
581,
222,
595
],
[
225,
581,
250,
595
],
[
254,
581,
311,
595
],
[
314,
581,
330,
595
],
[
334,
581,
359,
595
],
[
362,
581,
467,
595
],
[
471,
581,
501,
595
],
[
504,
581,
535,
595
],
[
539,
581,
629,
595
],
[
632,
581,
666,
595
],
[
670,
581,
731,
595
],
[
734,
581,
770,
595
],
[
776,
581,
792,
595
],
[
795,
580,
840,
595
],
[
137,
600,
213,
616
],
[
217,
601,
241,
616
],
[
244,
601,
264,
616
],
[
268,
601,
356,
616
],
[
360,
601,
504,
616
],
[
507,
601,
580,
616
],
[
584,
601,
615,
616
],
[
619,
601,
709,
616
],
[
712,
601,
734,
616
],
[
737,
600,
817,
615
],
[
820,
600,
850,
615
],
[
140,
621,
164,
635
],
[
167,
621,
230,
635
],
[
234,
621,
251,
635
],
[
254,
621,
311,
635
],
[
315,
621,
349,
635
],
[
352,
621,
387,
635
],
[
392,
621,
432,
636
],
[
435,
621,
472,
636
],
[
475,
621,
554,
636
],
[
558,
621,
567,
636
],
[
571,
621,
674,
636
],
[
677,
621,
743,
635
],
[
746,
621,
764,
635
],
[
767,
620,
817,
635
],
[
825,
620,
850,
635
],
[
139,
641,
212,
655
],
[
215,
641,
233,
655
],
[
237,
641,
316,
656
],
[
320,
641,
352,
656
],
[
355,
641,
386,
656
],
[
390,
640,
455,
656
],
[
458,
640,
490,
656
],
[
492,
640,
582,
656
],
[
585,
640,
621,
656
],
[
627,
640,
667,
656
],
[
670,
640,
705,
655
],
[
708,
640,
787,
655
],
[
790,
640,
802,
655
],
[
804,
640,
860,
655
],
[
139,
662,
200,
675
],
[
203,
661,
270,
676
],
[
272,
661,
290,
676
],
[
297,
661,
344,
676
],
[
347,
661,
373,
676
],
[
376,
661,
460,
676
],
[
463,
661,
482,
676
],
[
485,
661,
513,
676
],
[
516,
661,
552,
676
],
[
555,
661,
641,
676
],
[
644,
661,
710,
676
],
[
714,
661,
835,
676
],
[
138,
681,
202,
695
],
[
205,
681,
222,
695
],
[
225,
681,
252,
695
],
[
255,
681,
289,
695
],
[
292,
681,
326,
695
],
[
329,
681,
359,
695
],
[
362,
681,
382,
695
],
[
385,
681,
455,
696
],
[
458,
681,
475,
696
],
[
478,
681,
505,
696
],
[
508,
681,
555,
696
],
[
558,
680,
576,
696
],
[
579,
680,
604,
696
],
[
607,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
725,
696
],
[
728,
680,
745,
695
],
[
748,
680,
775,
695
],
[
778,
680,
855,
695
],
[
197,
713,
303,
729
],
[
307,
714,
323,
729
],
[
327,
714,
407,
729
],
[
411,
714,
435,
729
],
[
439,
714,
496,
729
],
[
500,
714,
571,
729
],
[
575,
714,
589,
729
],
[
593,
714,
620,
729
],
[
624,
714,
655,
729
],
[
661,
714,
677,
729
],
[
681,
714,
708,
729
],
[
711,
713,
783,
729
],
[
786,
713,
805,
729
],
[
808,
712,
854,
729
],
[
139,
732,
175,
748
],
[
180,
733,
216,
748
],
[
220,
733,
230,
748
],
[
234,
733,
328,
748
],
[
331,
734,
405,
748
],
[
408,
734,
430,
749
],
[
433,
734,
538,
749
],
[
542,
734,
571,
749
],
[
574,
734,
663,
749
],
[
666,
734,
677,
749
],
[
680,
733,
768,
749
],
[
771,
733,
811,
749
],
[
814,
733,
839,
748
],
[
140,
753,
218,
768
],
[
221,
754,
264,
769
],
[
268,
754,
287,
769
],
[
291,
754,
317,
769
],
[
320,
754,
367,
769
],
[
370,
755,
388,
769
],
[
391,
755,
418,
769
],
[
422,
755,
504,
769
],
[
507,
754,
523,
769
],
[
527,
754,
561,
769
],
[
565,
754,
644,
769
],
[
648,
754,
691,
769
],
[
694,
753,
734,
768
],
[
738,
752,
812,
768
],
[
140,
774,
196,
789
],
[
200,
774,
258,
789
],
[
261,
774,
340,
789
],
[
344,
774,
368,
789
],
[
371,
774,
475,
789
],
[
479,
774,
580,
789
],
[
584,
774,
610,
789
],
[
614,
774,
640,
789
],
[
644,
773,
702,
789
],
[
706,
773,
748,
789
],
[
752,
773,
830,
789
],
[
834,
773,
859,
789
],
[
138,
793,
208,
809
],
[
212,
793,
228,
809
],
[
232,
793,
258,
809
],
[
261,
794,
311,
809
],
[
315,
794,
425,
810
],
[
428,
794,
444,
810
],
[
447,
794,
525,
810
],
[
528,
794,
554,
810
],
[
558,
794,
622,
810
],
[
626,
794,
718,
810
],
[
721,
794,
751,
809
],
[
755,
793,
861,
809
],
[
138,
813,
153,
828
],
[
157,
813,
166,
828
],
[
170,
814,
200,
828
],
[
203,
814,
251,
829
],
[
255,
814,
330,
829
],
[
334,
815,
394,
829
],
[
398,
815,
428,
829
],
[
431,
815,
510,
829
],
[
513,
815,
607,
829
],
[
611,
815,
631,
829
],
[
634,
815,
671,
829
],
[
675,
814,
729,
829
],
[
732,
814,
762,
829
],
[
766,
814,
839,
829
],
[
137,
833,
214,
849
],
[
217,
833,
234,
849
],
[
238,
834,
284,
849
],
[
287,
834,
328,
849
],
[
335,
834,
414,
849
],
[
418,
834,
427,
849
],
[
431,
834,
500,
849
],
[
504,
834,
599,
849
],
[
603,
834,
632,
849
],
[
635,
834,
719,
849
],
[
722,
834,
754,
849
],
[
758,
834,
775,
848
],
[
779,
833,
832,
848
],
[
139,
854,
177,
869
],
[
180,
854,
206,
869
],
[
210,
854,
314,
869
],
[
317,
854,
397,
869
],
[
400,
854,
501,
869
],
[
504,
854,
531,
869
],
[
534,
854,
561,
869
],
[
564,
854,
642,
869
],
[
645,
854,
672,
869
],
[
675,
854,
756,
869
],
[
759,
854,
790,
869
],
[
792,
854,
819,
869
],
[
138,
874,
241,
889
],
[
245,
874,
278,
889
],
[
281,
874,
298,
889
],
[
302,
874,
338,
889
],
[
343,
874,
360,
890
],
[
364,
874,
410,
890
],
[
413,
874,
431,
890
],
[
435,
874,
469,
890
],
[
472,
874,
490,
890
],
[
493,
874,
511,
890
],
[
515,
873,
555,
890
],
[
558,
873,
625,
890
],
[
628,
873,
658,
890
],
[
661,
873,
702,
890
],
[
710,
873,
809,
889
],
[
812,
873,
827,
889
],
[
831,
873,
856,
889
],
[
138,
892,
179,
908
],
[
183,
892,
200,
909
],
[
204,
893,
250,
909
],
[
254,
893,
291,
909
],
[
295,
893,
372,
910
],
[
377,
893,
397,
910
],
[
400,
893,
504,
910
],
[
508,
893,
525,
910
],
[
530,
893,
591,
910
],
[
595,
892,
674,
910
],
[
678,
892,
702,
910
],
[
706,
892,
727,
909
],
[
731,
892,
780,
909
],
[
787,
892,
829,
909
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What did ACC strongly supported?
|
supported Congress's efforts to update & reform TSCA
|
720
|
[
"American\"",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Document",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Submitted",
"electronically",
"via",
"www.regulations.gay",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Rule:",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act,",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"7562",
"(January",
"19,",
"2017);",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0654",
"Dear",
"Docket",
"Clerk:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"the",
"attached",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency,",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Proposed",
"Rule,",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act.",
"These",
"comments",
"align",
"with",
"our",
"separately",
"filed",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"proposed",
"rules",
"describing",
"the",
"processes",
"for",
"inventory",
"reset",
"and",
"prioritization",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"and",
"for",
"the",
"development",
"of",
"the",
"scopes",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"first",
"10",
"chemicals",
"selected",
"from",
"the",
"TSCA",
"work",
"plan.",
"All",
"comments",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"together.",
"Please",
"feel",
"free",
"to",
"contact",
"me",
"with",
"any",
"questions",
"at",
"202-249-6130",
"or",
"karynschmidt",
"@americanchemistry.com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Karyn",
"M.",
"Schmidt",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"and",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"CC:",
"Jeffery",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett,",
"OPPT",
"Tala",
"Henry,",
"Director,",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Division,",
"OPPT",
"Susanna",
"Blair,",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"ACC",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"More",
"information",
"about",
"ACC",
"is",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"body",
"of",
"our",
"comments.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
459,
100,
572,
119
],
[
486,
120,
605,
142
],
[
459,
140,
541,
158
],
[
442,
189,
491,
202
],
[
495,
190,
520,
203
],
[
522,
189,
560,
203
],
[
88,
222,
165,
235
],
[
168,
222,
224,
235
],
[
227,
222,
274,
235
],
[
277,
221,
342,
235
],
[
91,
237,
135,
251
],
[
138,
238,
155,
251
],
[
158,
239,
224,
251
],
[
227,
239,
308,
251
],
[
311,
238,
340,
251
],
[
342,
237,
393,
251
],
[
91,
254,
197,
268
],
[
200,
255,
276,
268
],
[
279,
255,
330,
269
],
[
92,
269,
124,
283
],
[
128,
270,
227,
283
],
[
230,
270,
264,
283
],
[
267,
269,
295,
283
],
[
90,
286,
181,
299
],
[
184,
286,
208,
298
],
[
213,
285,
302,
299
],
[
90,
317,
161,
330
],
[
164,
318,
265,
331
],
[
268,
319,
291,
332
],
[
294,
319,
449,
333
],
[
87,
348,
119,
363
],
[
147,
350,
226,
363
],
[
229,
350,
246,
364
],
[
249,
350,
274,
364
],
[
277,
350,
347,
365
],
[
351,
350,
427,
365
],
[
430,
350,
488,
365
],
[
491,
350,
512,
365
],
[
515,
350,
562,
365
],
[
565,
350,
634,
365
],
[
637,
350,
677,
365
],
[
680,
350,
766,
365
],
[
768,
350,
791,
365
],
[
794,
350,
864,
365
],
[
867,
349,
900,
364
],
[
148,
366,
227,
379
],
[
230,
366,
273,
380
],
[
277,
366,
301,
380
],
[
304,
366,
374,
380
],
[
377,
366,
417,
380
],
[
420,
366,
501,
381
],
[
504,
366,
563,
381
],
[
566,
366,
596,
381
],
[
599,
366,
617,
381
],
[
620,
366,
654,
381
],
[
656,
366,
692,
381
],
[
695,
366,
732,
381
],
[
734,
366,
799,
380
],
[
802,
365,
825,
380
],
[
828,
365,
877,
380
],
[
147,
380,
345,
395
],
[
88,
413,
124,
427
],
[
127,
413,
182,
427
],
[
185,
413,
231,
427
],
[
90,
445,
118,
460
],
[
121,
445,
192,
460
],
[
196,
445,
272,
461
],
[
276,
445,
333,
461
],
[
337,
445,
392,
461
],
[
396,
445,
409,
461
],
[
412,
445,
467,
461
],
[
471,
445,
487,
461
],
[
490,
445,
540,
461
],
[
543,
446,
567,
461
],
[
571,
446,
630,
461
],
[
634,
446,
710,
461
],
[
713,
446,
731,
461
],
[
735,
446,
759,
460
],
[
762,
446,
871,
460
],
[
89,
461,
164,
475
],
[
167,
462,
228,
476
],
[
231,
462,
280,
476
],
[
282,
462,
298,
476
],
[
301,
462,
368,
476
],
[
371,
462,
451,
476
],
[
454,
462,
483,
477
],
[
486,
462,
535,
477
],
[
538,
462,
607,
477
],
[
610,
462,
650,
476
],
[
654,
461,
735,
476
],
[
738,
461,
761,
476
],
[
764,
461,
834,
476
],
[
837,
461,
868,
475
],
[
88,
477,
168,
490
],
[
170,
477,
213,
491
],
[
216,
477,
241,
491
],
[
244,
477,
316,
491
],
[
319,
477,
361,
491
],
[
364,
477,
445,
491
],
[
448,
478,
505,
491
],
[
508,
478,
538,
491
],
[
90,
510,
132,
524
],
[
135,
510,
210,
524
],
[
214,
510,
251,
524
],
[
255,
510,
287,
524
],
[
291,
510,
316,
524
],
[
320,
510,
393,
524
],
[
396,
510,
431,
525
],
[
434,
510,
510,
525
],
[
513,
510,
532,
525
],
[
535,
510,
559,
525
],
[
562,
510,
629,
525
],
[
632,
510,
672,
525
],
[
675,
510,
748,
525
],
[
751,
510,
775,
525
],
[
778,
510,
848,
525
],
[
851,
510,
875,
525
],
[
88,
526,
158,
539
],
[
161,
526,
197,
539
],
[
201,
526,
227,
539
],
[
230,
526,
327,
539
],
[
330,
526,
351,
540
],
[
354,
525,
382,
540
],
[
385,
525,
467,
540
],
[
470,
525,
497,
540
],
[
500,
525,
522,
540
],
[
525,
525,
551,
540
],
[
556,
525,
647,
540
],
[
650,
525,
667,
540
],
[
670,
525,
693,
540
],
[
696,
525,
745,
540
],
[
748,
525,
770,
540
],
[
772,
525,
802,
540
],
[
805,
525,
881,
540
],
[
884,
525,
904,
540
],
[
88,
541,
112,
554
],
[
114,
541,
147,
554
],
[
150,
541,
167,
554
],
[
170,
541,
244,
555
],
[
247,
541,
306,
555
],
[
308,
541,
341,
555
],
[
348,
541,
373,
555
],
[
377,
541,
420,
555
],
[
426,
541,
464,
555
],
[
467,
541,
508,
555
],
[
512,
541,
536,
555
],
[
539,
541,
615,
555
],
[
618,
541,
667,
555
],
[
670,
541,
689,
555
],
[
692,
541,
771,
555
],
[
774,
541,
842,
555
],
[
88,
573,
135,
587
],
[
138,
573,
167,
587
],
[
170,
573,
199,
587
],
[
202,
573,
218,
587
],
[
221,
573,
274,
588
],
[
277,
574,
300,
588
],
[
304,
574,
337,
588
],
[
340,
574,
367,
589
],
[
370,
574,
440,
589
],
[
442,
574,
457,
589
],
[
461,
574,
564,
590
],
[
568,
574,
582,
590
],
[
585,
574,
695,
590
],
[
698,
575,
885,
590
],
[
89,
604,
161,
620
],
[
89,
714,
134,
728
],
[
137,
715,
160,
728
],
[
163,
714,
224,
728
],
[
90,
730,
135,
744
],
[
139,
730,
205,
744
],
[
208,
730,
290,
744
],
[
292,
730,
322,
744
],
[
325,
730,
396,
744
],
[
399,
730,
454,
745
],
[
91,
746,
161,
760
],
[
164,
746,
241,
760
],
[
244,
746,
302,
760
],
[
88,
780,
110,
792
],
[
147,
777,
198,
792
],
[
201,
778,
257,
793
],
[
260,
778,
326,
793
],
[
330,
778,
374,
792
],
[
148,
793,
201,
808
],
[
204,
794,
333,
808
],
[
337,
793,
382,
808
],
[
148,
809,
180,
824
],
[
182,
810,
234,
825
],
[
237,
810,
304,
825
],
[
307,
810,
341,
825
],
[
344,
810,
430,
825
],
[
432,
810,
502,
825
],
[
505,
810,
551,
824
],
[
147,
825,
208,
840
],
[
211,
825,
253,
840
],
[
257,
825,
304,
840
],
[
307,
826,
324,
840
],
[
327,
826,
397,
840
],
[
401,
826,
448,
840
],
[
451,
826,
477,
840
],
[
481,
826,
548,
840
],
[
552,
826,
632,
840
],
[
98,
881,
131,
894
],
[
134,
882,
202,
895
],
[
205,
882,
226,
895
],
[
229,
882,
278,
895
],
[
281,
883,
351,
895
],
[
355,
883,
410,
895
],
[
413,
883,
427,
895
],
[
430,
883,
451,
895
],
[
454,
883,
511,
895
],
[
514,
883,
530,
896
],
[
532,
883,
601,
896
],
[
604,
883,
641,
895
],
[
644,
883,
722,
895
],
[
725,
883,
764,
895
],
[
767,
882,
801,
895
],
[
804,
882,
814,
895
],
[
817,
882,
882,
895
],
[
885,
881,
898,
895
],
[
87,
897,
109,
909
],
[
111,
897,
146,
909
],
[
148,
897,
164,
909
],
[
167,
897,
190,
909
],
[
192,
898,
266,
909
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
what is the regulation for amended toxic substances control act?
|
7562
|
899
|
[
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"http://www.nap.edu/catalog/11811.html",
"PREPUBLICATION",
"COPY",
"Scientific",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"from",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"Committee",
"to",
"Review",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Board",
"on",
"Environmental",
"Studies",
"and",
"Toxicology",
"Division",
"on",
"Earth",
"and",
"Life",
"Studies",
"NATIONAL",
"RESEARCH",
"COUNCIL",
"OF",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"THE",
"NATIONAL",
"ACADEMIES",
"PRESS",
"Washington,",
"D.C.",
"www.nap.edu",
"Source:",
"httpspylighvo/National",
"Atadel,caf",
"screndes.",
"(All",
"fights",
"deserted.s/slcn0226"
] |
[
[
10,
8,
61,
17
],
[
64,
7,
105,
17
],
[
111,
7,
122,
17
],
[
125,
7,
143,
18
],
[
147,
7,
204,
18
],
[
207,
7,
232,
18
],
[
236,
7,
308,
19
],
[
311,
7,
354,
19
],
[
357,
7,
380,
19
],
[
387,
6,
405,
19
],
[
409,
6,
443,
19
],
[
447,
6,
458,
19
],
[
461,
6,
540,
19
],
[
542,
6,
564,
19
],
[
567,
6,
610,
19
],
[
7,
17,
237,
27
],
[
327,
95,
588,
116
],
[
602,
94,
683,
115
],
[
175,
227,
362,
260
],
[
368,
228,
504,
261
],
[
521,
229,
565,
262
],
[
572,
229,
636,
263
],
[
643,
228,
824,
266
],
[
168,
270,
254,
300
],
[
268,
269,
495,
301
],
[
502,
269,
655,
301
],
[
670,
269,
754,
301
],
[
777,
268,
838,
300
],
[
167,
310,
290,
342
],
[
297,
310,
337,
343
],
[
344,
310,
608,
345
],
[
615,
310,
693,
345
],
[
700,
310,
840,
345
],
[
272,
432,
358,
448
],
[
362,
433,
380,
448
],
[
384,
433,
443,
448
],
[
448,
433,
474,
448
],
[
478,
433,
522,
448
],
[
527,
433,
565,
448
],
[
569,
433,
662,
448
],
[
666,
433,
730,
449
],
[
308,
467,
356,
483
],
[
360,
468,
380,
483
],
[
384,
468,
503,
484
],
[
507,
467,
565,
484
],
[
570,
467,
601,
485
],
[
605,
467,
694,
486
],
[
363,
503,
433,
518
],
[
437,
504,
457,
518
],
[
461,
504,
505,
519
],
[
508,
504,
538,
519
],
[
541,
504,
577,
519
],
[
580,
503,
638,
519
],
[
344,
632,
451,
650
],
[
455,
633,
557,
650
],
[
564,
632,
654,
649
],
[
466,
651,
485,
664
],
[
488,
652,
511,
664
],
[
514,
652,
580,
664
],
[
582,
652,
657,
664
],
[
380,
778,
405,
794
],
[
409,
778,
489,
794
],
[
492,
778,
581,
793
],
[
584,
779,
627,
794
],
[
442,
796,
530,
811
],
[
533,
797,
562,
811
],
[
443,
814,
565,
827
],
[
224,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
981,
437,
997
],
[
441,
982,
512,
997
],
[
516,
981,
567,
997
],
[
571,
981,
588,
997
],
[
592,
981,
625,
997
],
[
630,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
What is the first heading in the document?
|
Prepublication Copy
|
735
|
[
"potential",
"child",
"exposure",
"is",
"greater",
"than",
"for",
"a",
"non-child",
"specific",
"product.",
"For",
"example,",
"how",
"does",
"child",
"exposure",
"to",
"a",
"general",
"use",
"cleaner",
"compare",
"to",
"exposure",
"from",
"use",
"in",
"a",
"child's",
"raincoat.",
"In",
"the",
"VCCEP",
"assessments,",
"there",
"are",
"examples",
"for",
"inhalation",
"exposures",
"where",
"estimates",
"of",
"passive",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"adult",
"product",
"use",
"exceeded",
"conservative",
"estimates",
"of",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"active",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"child-specific",
"product",
"(such",
"as",
"a",
"hobby",
"product)",
"-",
"differences",
"were",
"related",
"to",
"the",
"amount",
"of",
"product",
"used",
"and",
"substance",
"concentration",
"within",
"the",
"product",
"(MEK",
"VCCEP",
"Submission).",
"the",
"IUR",
"definition",
"targets",
"children",
"age",
"14",
"and",
"younger.",
"Younger",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"non-child",
"specific",
"products",
"that",
"are",
"in",
"general",
"household",
"use.",
"Older",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"additional",
"products.",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"request",
"is",
"targeted",
"to",
"manufacturers,",
"which",
"may",
"not",
"have",
"direct",
"knowledge",
"of",
"all",
"uses,",
"particularly",
"the",
"presence",
"in",
"products",
"for",
"specific",
"subpopulations,",
"such",
"as",
"children.",
"Therefore,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"that",
"the",
"information",
"requested",
"for",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"would",
"be",
"consistently",
"available",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"screened.",
"Ideally,",
"this",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"requested",
"from",
"formulators",
"of",
"child-specific",
"products.",
"Therefore,",
"for",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"which",
"represents",
"a",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"categorization,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally.",
"The",
"IUR",
"information",
"on",
"child",
"specific",
"use",
"would",
"be",
"utilized",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"If",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"is",
"utilized,",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"that",
"the",
"limitations",
"above",
"be",
"considered",
"in",
"its",
"application.",
"Emissions",
"Data:",
"Production",
"volume,",
"which",
"is",
"readily",
"available",
"for",
"substances,",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"this",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"but",
"only",
"serves",
"as",
"a",
"surrogate",
"for",
"environmental",
"emissions.",
"For",
"further",
"prioritization,",
"data",
"or",
"estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"refine",
"prioritization.",
"Estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"will",
"be",
"available",
"for",
"some",
"substances",
"(e.g.,",
"TRI",
"data).",
"When",
"TRI",
"data",
"are",
"utilized",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"recognized",
"that",
"it",
"addresses",
"only",
"emissions",
"that",
"result",
"from",
"industrial",
"and",
"not",
"wide",
"dispersive",
"uses.",
"In",
"other",
"cases,",
"emissions",
"estimates",
"can",
"be",
"developed",
"as",
"a",
"percentage",
"of",
"production",
"volume",
"based",
"upon",
"consideration",
"of",
"use",
"categories.",
"Within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping,",
"available",
"emissions",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"considered",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering,",
"with",
"the",
"understanding",
"that",
"emissions",
"information",
"is",
"not",
"an",
"indicator",
"of",
"actual",
"exposure.",
"Similarly,",
"non-isolated",
"system",
"intermediates,",
"by",
"definition,",
"would",
"have",
"de",
"minimis",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"Therefore,",
"this",
"IUR",
"information",
"could",
"be",
"considered",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions:",
"An",
"initial",
"screening",
"approach",
"for",
"chemical",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"consistent",
"application",
"of",
"specific",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"science",
"elements",
"that",
"define",
"risk",
"potential.",
"The",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"elements",
"should",
"be",
"applicable",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening,",
"existence",
"of",
"international",
"risk",
"management",
"action",
"plans",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"a",
"factor",
"that",
"determines",
"priority",
"grouping.",
"Risk",
"management",
"plans",
"may",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"many",
"factors,",
"including",
"political",
"drivers.",
"It",
"is",
"unclear",
"how",
"factors,",
"their",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"and",
"the",
"rigor",
"of",
"the",
"evaluation",
"may",
"vary",
"across",
"agencies",
"and",
"substances.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
101,
240,
115
],
[
243,
102,
281,
115
],
[
284,
102,
351,
115
],
[
354,
102,
367,
115
],
[
370,
102,
421,
115
],
[
424,
102,
457,
115
],
[
460,
102,
482,
115
],
[
485,
102,
494,
115
],
[
498,
102,
568,
115
],
[
571,
102,
630,
115
],
[
632,
102,
694,
115
],
[
697,
101,
722,
115
],
[
725,
101,
792,
115
],
[
795,
100,
825,
115
],
[
835,
100,
865,
115
],
[
868,
100,
908,
115
],
[
177,
117,
242,
130
],
[
245,
117,
262,
130
],
[
264,
117,
274,
130
],
[
277,
117,
331,
130
],
[
334,
117,
361,
130
],
[
363,
118,
417,
130
],
[
419,
117,
483,
130
],
[
485,
117,
502,
130
],
[
505,
117,
572,
130
],
[
574,
117,
605,
130
],
[
613,
117,
640,
130
],
[
642,
117,
657,
130
],
[
661,
116,
670,
130
],
[
672,
116,
722,
130
],
[
725,
115,
795,
130
],
[
798,
115,
814,
130
],
[
817,
115,
842,
130
],
[
844,
114,
902,
130
],
[
177,
134,
269,
146
],
[
272,
134,
310,
147
],
[
312,
134,
338,
147
],
[
341,
134,
417,
147
],
[
420,
134,
445,
147
],
[
448,
133,
527,
147
],
[
531,
133,
612,
147
],
[
615,
133,
665,
147
],
[
668,
132,
744,
147
],
[
747,
132,
764,
147
],
[
766,
131,
828,
147
],
[
830,
131,
871,
146
],
[
177,
150,
250,
163
],
[
254,
150,
305,
163
],
[
308,
150,
348,
163
],
[
351,
150,
414,
163
],
[
417,
150,
445,
164
],
[
448,
150,
524,
164
],
[
526,
150,
628,
164
],
[
630,
150,
705,
164
],
[
707,
150,
727,
164
],
[
730,
149,
771,
164
],
[
774,
149,
847,
165
],
[
852,
149,
901,
165
],
[
177,
166,
224,
180
],
[
227,
166,
256,
180
],
[
260,
166,
276,
180
],
[
280,
166,
291,
180
],
[
294,
165,
401,
180
],
[
405,
165,
467,
180
],
[
470,
165,
514,
180
],
[
518,
165,
536,
180
],
[
540,
165,
550,
180
],
[
552,
165,
604,
180
],
[
607,
165,
674,
180
],
[
677,
165,
691,
180
],
[
695,
165,
782,
180
],
[
785,
165,
825,
180
],
[
828,
165,
882,
180
],
[
885,
165,
903,
181
],
[
177,
182,
202,
197
],
[
205,
182,
265,
197
],
[
269,
182,
287,
197
],
[
290,
182,
351,
197
],
[
355,
182,
393,
197
],
[
397,
183,
425,
197
],
[
429,
182,
507,
197
],
[
511,
182,
620,
197
],
[
624,
182,
673,
197
],
[
677,
182,
702,
197
],
[
705,
182,
768,
197
],
[
772,
181,
821,
197
],
[
829,
181,
887,
197
],
[
178,
198,
280,
215
],
[
176,
218,
200,
232
],
[
203,
218,
232,
232
],
[
241,
218,
309,
232
],
[
312,
218,
361,
232
],
[
364,
218,
425,
232
],
[
428,
218,
455,
232
],
[
458,
218,
478,
232
],
[
481,
218,
508,
232
],
[
511,
218,
578,
232
],
[
581,
218,
644,
232
],
[
647,
218,
706,
232
],
[
709,
218,
741,
232
],
[
744,
218,
764,
232
],
[
766,
218,
826,
232
],
[
828,
218,
846,
232
],
[
848,
218,
860,
232
],
[
177,
235,
227,
248
],
[
231,
235,
247,
248
],
[
250,
235,
320,
248
],
[
323,
235,
380,
248
],
[
383,
235,
447,
248
],
[
450,
235,
479,
248
],
[
482,
235,
505,
248
],
[
508,
235,
524,
248
],
[
527,
235,
581,
248
],
[
584,
235,
660,
248
],
[
663,
234,
694,
248
],
[
697,
234,
738,
248
],
[
741,
234,
801,
248
],
[
804,
234,
836,
248
],
[
839,
234,
858,
248
],
[
178,
251,
237,
264
],
[
240,
251,
256,
264
],
[
259,
251,
268,
264
],
[
271,
250,
322,
264
],
[
325,
250,
342,
264
],
[
345,
250,
417,
264
],
[
420,
251,
491,
264
],
[
176,
267,
198,
282
],
[
202,
267,
234,
282
],
[
238,
268,
324,
283
],
[
327,
268,
380,
283
],
[
384,
269,
397,
283
],
[
400,
269,
459,
283
],
[
463,
269,
477,
283
],
[
481,
269,
591,
283
],
[
594,
269,
638,
283
],
[
641,
269,
672,
283
],
[
677,
269,
700,
283
],
[
704,
268,
742,
283
],
[
745,
268,
784,
283
],
[
787,
267,
868,
282
],
[
872,
266,
891,
282
],
[
178,
284,
195,
299
],
[
198,
284,
235,
299
],
[
238,
284,
322,
299
],
[
325,
285,
349,
299
],
[
352,
285,
417,
299
],
[
420,
285,
435,
298
],
[
438,
285,
502,
298
],
[
506,
285,
528,
298
],
[
531,
284,
588,
298
],
[
592,
284,
705,
298
],
[
709,
284,
743,
298
],
[
747,
284,
762,
298
],
[
766,
284,
834,
298
],
[
179,
299,
252,
313
],
[
255,
300,
267,
314
],
[
271,
300,
283,
314
],
[
287,
300,
311,
314
],
[
314,
300,
351,
314
],
[
354,
300,
382,
314
],
[
385,
300,
409,
314
],
[
412,
300,
498,
314
],
[
501,
300,
572,
314
],
[
575,
300,
597,
314
],
[
600,
300,
624,
314
],
[
627,
300,
658,
313
],
[
662,
300,
750,
313
],
[
752,
300,
798,
313
],
[
801,
300,
823,
313
],
[
178,
315,
262,
330
],
[
266,
315,
332,
330
],
[
335,
315,
382,
330
],
[
385,
315,
404,
330
],
[
408,
315,
485,
330
],
[
489,
315,
530,
330
],
[
534,
315,
602,
330
],
[
605,
315,
661,
330
],
[
665,
315,
691,
330
],
[
694,
315,
781,
330
],
[
785,
315,
833,
330
],
[
837,
315,
857,
330
],
[
176,
332,
247,
346
],
[
250,
332,
282,
346
],
[
289,
332,
374,
345
],
[
377,
332,
394,
345
],
[
397,
332,
496,
346
],
[
499,
332,
564,
347
],
[
183,
360,
265,
377
],
[
270,
361,
293,
377
],
[
297,
361,
321,
377
],
[
325,
361,
372,
377
],
[
376,
362,
480,
377
],
[
484,
362,
563,
377
],
[
567,
362,
614,
377
],
[
618,
362,
700,
377
],
[
704,
362,
712,
376
],
[
716,
361,
767,
376
],
[
771,
360,
850,
376
],
[
147,
379,
265,
393
],
[
268,
380,
308,
394
],
[
311,
380,
374,
394
],
[
377,
380,
447,
394
],
[
450,
380,
476,
394
],
[
479,
380,
550,
394
],
[
552,
380,
599,
394
],
[
602,
380,
661,
394
],
[
664,
379,
742,
394
],
[
745,
379,
815,
394
],
[
818,
379,
849,
393
],
[
852,
379,
873,
393
],
[
147,
396,
224,
411
],
[
227,
396,
297,
411
],
[
300,
396,
327,
411
],
[
330,
395,
403,
411
],
[
407,
395,
473,
411
],
[
476,
395,
507,
411
],
[
510,
395,
541,
411
],
[
548,
395,
642,
411
],
[
645,
395,
666,
411
],
[
671,
395,
711,
411
],
[
715,
395,
776,
411
],
[
780,
395,
808,
410
],
[
812,
395,
861,
410
],
[
864,
395,
886,
410
],
[
148,
413,
208,
428
],
[
212,
414,
262,
429
],
[
266,
414,
275,
429
],
[
279,
414,
355,
430
],
[
359,
414,
420,
430
],
[
424,
414,
496,
430
],
[
500,
413,
524,
430
],
[
528,
413,
588,
430
],
[
591,
413,
624,
430
],
[
628,
413,
664,
430
],
[
667,
412,
740,
429
],
[
744,
412,
758,
428
],
[
761,
412,
787,
428
],
[
790,
412,
822,
428
],
[
146,
431,
241,
446
],
[
244,
432,
260,
446
],
[
262,
432,
328,
446
],
[
331,
432,
343,
446
],
[
346,
432,
361,
446
],
[
364,
432,
442,
446
],
[
445,
432,
477,
447
],
[
480,
432,
507,
447
],
[
509,
431,
596,
447
],
[
599,
431,
647,
447
],
[
649,
431,
671,
447
],
[
673,
431,
761,
447
],
[
763,
431,
780,
446
],
[
782,
431,
805,
446
],
[
807,
430,
903,
446
],
[
182,
469,
268,
485
],
[
272,
470,
321,
485
],
[
181,
500,
270,
515
],
[
274,
500,
339,
515
],
[
342,
500,
391,
515
],
[
394,
500,
408,
515
],
[
412,
500,
468,
516
],
[
472,
500,
545,
516
],
[
548,
500,
572,
516
],
[
575,
500,
665,
516
],
[
668,
500,
684,
516
],
[
687,
500,
724,
516
],
[
727,
500,
744,
516
],
[
747,
500,
778,
516
],
[
781,
500,
857,
516
],
[
147,
519,
225,
534
],
[
228,
519,
255,
534
],
[
259,
519,
295,
534
],
[
298,
519,
349,
534
],
[
352,
519,
370,
534
],
[
373,
519,
384,
534
],
[
388,
519,
462,
534
],
[
465,
519,
490,
534
],
[
494,
519,
608,
534
],
[
611,
518,
695,
534
],
[
699,
518,
727,
534
],
[
731,
518,
785,
534
],
[
788,
517,
898,
534
],
[
151,
536,
181,
550
],
[
184,
536,
202,
550
],
[
205,
536,
281,
550
],
[
284,
537,
302,
550
],
[
305,
537,
420,
551
],
[
423,
537,
503,
551
],
[
506,
537,
535,
551
],
[
537,
537,
558,
551
],
[
561,
537,
599,
551
],
[
602,
537,
619,
551
],
[
621,
537,
670,
551
],
[
672,
536,
782,
551
],
[
785,
535,
864,
550
],
[
866,
535,
888,
550
],
[
148,
553,
261,
568
],
[
265,
553,
344,
568
],
[
347,
553,
378,
568
],
[
381,
553,
403,
568
],
[
406,
553,
478,
568
],
[
481,
553,
507,
568
],
[
510,
553,
553,
568
],
[
556,
553,
642,
568
],
[
645,
553,
688,
568
],
[
691,
553,
725,
568
],
[
728,
553,
774,
568
],
[
776,
553,
825,
568
],
[
828,
553,
864,
568
],
[
866,
553,
899,
568
],
[
148,
570,
171,
585
],
[
175,
570,
235,
585
],
[
238,
570,
251,
586
],
[
255,
570,
307,
586
],
[
311,
570,
331,
586
],
[
335,
570,
422,
586
],
[
425,
570,
457,
586
],
[
461,
570,
474,
586
],
[
477,
570,
553,
586
],
[
557,
570,
594,
586
],
[
597,
570,
675,
586
],
[
678,
570,
709,
586
],
[
712,
570,
758,
586
],
[
762,
570,
797,
586
],
[
804,
570,
878,
586
],
[
147,
588,
177,
602
],
[
180,
588,
207,
602
],
[
210,
588,
252,
602
],
[
257,
588,
334,
603
],
[
337,
588,
378,
603
],
[
382,
588,
399,
603
],
[
402,
588,
445,
603
],
[
448,
589,
495,
603
],
[
499,
589,
578,
603
],
[
582,
589,
657,
603
],
[
660,
589,
687,
603
],
[
691,
588,
714,
603
],
[
718,
588,
797,
603
],
[
801,
588,
819,
603
],
[
822,
588,
830,
603
],
[
147,
606,
233,
621
],
[
237,
605,
253,
620
],
[
257,
605,
344,
620
],
[
348,
605,
407,
620
],
[
411,
605,
457,
620
],
[
461,
605,
502,
620
],
[
505,
605,
613,
620
],
[
617,
605,
634,
620
],
[
638,
605,
666,
620
],
[
670,
605,
756,
620
],
[
760,
605,
815,
620
],
[
818,
605,
830,
620
],
[
147,
623,
222,
639
],
[
226,
623,
287,
639
],
[
291,
623,
367,
639
],
[
371,
623,
442,
638
],
[
447,
622,
525,
638
],
[
528,
622,
624,
638
],
[
628,
622,
654,
638
],
[
658,
622,
679,
638
],
[
682,
622,
769,
638
],
[
772,
621,
798,
638
],
[
801,
621,
862,
638
],
[
865,
621,
900,
637
],
[
147,
640,
182,
655
],
[
186,
640,
261,
655
],
[
264,
640,
299,
655
],
[
302,
641,
328,
655
],
[
332,
641,
443,
655
],
[
447,
641,
479,
655
],
[
482,
641,
561,
655
],
[
564,
641,
658,
655
],
[
661,
641,
677,
655
],
[
680,
641,
707,
655
],
[
711,
641,
730,
654
],
[
733,
641,
805,
654
],
[
808,
641,
826,
654
],
[
830,
641,
875,
654
],
[
148,
659,
221,
673
],
[
182,
691,
261,
706
],
[
264,
692,
363,
707
],
[
367,
693,
419,
707
],
[
425,
693,
538,
707
],
[
541,
693,
564,
707
],
[
570,
693,
649,
707
],
[
652,
693,
702,
707
],
[
705,
692,
747,
707
],
[
751,
692,
768,
706
],
[
771,
692,
840,
706
],
[
148,
710,
219,
725
],
[
222,
710,
301,
725
],
[
304,
710,
384,
725
],
[
387,
710,
419,
725
],
[
422,
710,
454,
725
],
[
460,
710,
555,
725
],
[
558,
710,
603,
725
],
[
606,
710,
627,
725
],
[
630,
710,
717,
725
],
[
720,
710,
772,
724
],
[
775,
710,
785,
724
],
[
788,
710,
865,
724
],
[
145,
727,
208,
745
],
[
212,
727,
282,
744
],
[
287,
727,
311,
743
],
[
315,
727,
374,
743
],
[
378,
727,
410,
743
],
[
414,
727,
451,
744
],
[
454,
727,
527,
745
],
[
182,
762,
295,
778
],
[
298,
763,
337,
778
],
[
341,
763,
454,
778
],
[
457,
762,
527,
778
],
[
183,
793,
207,
808
],
[
210,
793,
259,
808
],
[
262,
793,
339,
808
],
[
342,
793,
415,
809
],
[
418,
793,
443,
809
],
[
447,
793,
518,
809
],
[
521,
793,
626,
809
],
[
630,
793,
684,
808
],
[
687,
793,
707,
808
],
[
710,
793,
756,
808
],
[
760,
793,
801,
808
],
[
804,
793,
887,
808
],
[
148,
811,
236,
825
],
[
239,
811,
257,
825
],
[
260,
811,
322,
825
],
[
325,
811,
380,
825
],
[
383,
811,
414,
825
],
[
417,
811,
489,
825
],
[
492,
811,
552,
825
],
[
556,
811,
625,
825
],
[
629,
811,
662,
825
],
[
666,
811,
714,
825
],
[
717,
811,
748,
825
],
[
752,
811,
824,
825
],
[
184,
828,
213,
842
],
[
217,
828,
271,
843
],
[
275,
827,
304,
843
],
[
308,
827,
380,
843
],
[
384,
827,
455,
843
],
[
459,
827,
512,
843
],
[
515,
827,
535,
843
],
[
539,
827,
622,
843
],
[
625,
827,
675,
843
],
[
678,
827,
700,
843
],
[
703,
828,
788,
843
],
[
791,
828,
840,
843
],
[
147,
845,
228,
860
],
[
231,
845,
259,
860
],
[
263,
845,
311,
860
],
[
315,
845,
395,
861
],
[
399,
845,
474,
861
],
[
478,
845,
495,
861
],
[
499,
845,
598,
861
],
[
602,
845,
632,
861
],
[
637,
845,
739,
861
],
[
742,
845,
791,
860
],
[
795,
845,
838,
860
],
[
842,
845,
896,
860
],
[
147,
863,
173,
876
],
[
176,
863,
198,
876
],
[
201,
863,
210,
877
],
[
213,
863,
261,
877
],
[
264,
863,
298,
877
],
[
301,
863,
387,
878
],
[
390,
863,
452,
878
],
[
455,
863,
532,
878
],
[
535,
863,
572,
878
],
[
575,
863,
678,
878
],
[
681,
863,
724,
878
],
[
727,
862,
762,
878
],
[
765,
862,
785,
877
],
[
788,
862,
836,
877
],
[
839,
862,
879,
877
],
[
147,
880,
192,
895
],
[
195,
880,
255,
895
],
[
258,
880,
332,
895
],
[
336,
880,
405,
895
],
[
409,
879,
467,
895
],
[
471,
879,
484,
895
],
[
487,
879,
503,
895
],
[
507,
879,
564,
895
],
[
568,
879,
601,
895
],
[
608,
879,
667,
895
],
[
671,
879,
708,
895
],
[
711,
879,
773,
895
],
[
777,
878,
861,
895
],
[
865,
878,
896,
895
],
[
148,
897,
172,
910
],
[
175,
897,
215,
910
],
[
218,
897,
237,
910
],
[
240,
897,
265,
910
],
[
268,
897,
351,
911
],
[
355,
898,
391,
911
],
[
395,
898,
431,
911
],
[
434,
898,
485,
911
],
[
488,
898,
558,
911
],
[
561,
898,
591,
912
],
[
594,
897,
684,
912
],
[
687,
897,
716,
912
],
[
719,
897,
768,
912
],
[
771,
897,
845,
912
],
[
184,
924,
244,
938
],
[
247,
924,
274,
938
],
[
277,
924,
319,
938
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Why is it neccessary to consider IUR information within a particular priority grouping?
|
for second tier rank ordering
|
720
|
[
"American\"",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Document",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Submitted",
"electronically",
"via",
"www.regulations.gay",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Rule:",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act,",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"7562",
"(January",
"19,",
"2017);",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0654",
"Dear",
"Docket",
"Clerk:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"the",
"attached",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency,",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Proposed",
"Rule,",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act.",
"These",
"comments",
"align",
"with",
"our",
"separately",
"filed",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"proposed",
"rules",
"describing",
"the",
"processes",
"for",
"inventory",
"reset",
"and",
"prioritization",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"and",
"for",
"the",
"development",
"of",
"the",
"scopes",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"first",
"10",
"chemicals",
"selected",
"from",
"the",
"TSCA",
"work",
"plan.",
"All",
"comments",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"together.",
"Please",
"feel",
"free",
"to",
"contact",
"me",
"with",
"any",
"questions",
"at",
"202-249-6130",
"or",
"karynschmidt",
"@americanchemistry.com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Karyn",
"M.",
"Schmidt",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"and",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"CC:",
"Jeffery",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett,",
"OPPT",
"Tala",
"Henry,",
"Director,",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Division,",
"OPPT",
"Susanna",
"Blair,",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"ACC",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"More",
"information",
"about",
"ACC",
"is",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"body",
"of",
"our",
"comments.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
459,
100,
572,
119
],
[
486,
120,
605,
142
],
[
459,
140,
541,
158
],
[
442,
189,
491,
202
],
[
495,
190,
520,
203
],
[
522,
189,
560,
203
],
[
88,
222,
165,
235
],
[
168,
222,
224,
235
],
[
227,
222,
274,
235
],
[
277,
221,
342,
235
],
[
91,
237,
135,
251
],
[
138,
238,
155,
251
],
[
158,
239,
224,
251
],
[
227,
239,
308,
251
],
[
311,
238,
340,
251
],
[
342,
237,
393,
251
],
[
91,
254,
197,
268
],
[
200,
255,
276,
268
],
[
279,
255,
330,
269
],
[
92,
269,
124,
283
],
[
128,
270,
227,
283
],
[
230,
270,
264,
283
],
[
267,
269,
295,
283
],
[
90,
286,
181,
299
],
[
184,
286,
208,
298
],
[
213,
285,
302,
299
],
[
90,
317,
161,
330
],
[
164,
318,
265,
331
],
[
268,
319,
291,
332
],
[
294,
319,
449,
333
],
[
87,
348,
119,
363
],
[
147,
350,
226,
363
],
[
229,
350,
246,
364
],
[
249,
350,
274,
364
],
[
277,
350,
347,
365
],
[
351,
350,
427,
365
],
[
430,
350,
488,
365
],
[
491,
350,
512,
365
],
[
515,
350,
562,
365
],
[
565,
350,
634,
365
],
[
637,
350,
677,
365
],
[
680,
350,
766,
365
],
[
768,
350,
791,
365
],
[
794,
350,
864,
365
],
[
867,
349,
900,
364
],
[
148,
366,
227,
379
],
[
230,
366,
273,
380
],
[
277,
366,
301,
380
],
[
304,
366,
374,
380
],
[
377,
366,
417,
380
],
[
420,
366,
501,
381
],
[
504,
366,
563,
381
],
[
566,
366,
596,
381
],
[
599,
366,
617,
381
],
[
620,
366,
654,
381
],
[
656,
366,
692,
381
],
[
695,
366,
732,
381
],
[
734,
366,
799,
380
],
[
802,
365,
825,
380
],
[
828,
365,
877,
380
],
[
147,
380,
345,
395
],
[
88,
413,
124,
427
],
[
127,
413,
182,
427
],
[
185,
413,
231,
427
],
[
90,
445,
118,
460
],
[
121,
445,
192,
460
],
[
196,
445,
272,
461
],
[
276,
445,
333,
461
],
[
337,
445,
392,
461
],
[
396,
445,
409,
461
],
[
412,
445,
467,
461
],
[
471,
445,
487,
461
],
[
490,
445,
540,
461
],
[
543,
446,
567,
461
],
[
571,
446,
630,
461
],
[
634,
446,
710,
461
],
[
713,
446,
731,
461
],
[
735,
446,
759,
460
],
[
762,
446,
871,
460
],
[
89,
461,
164,
475
],
[
167,
462,
228,
476
],
[
231,
462,
280,
476
],
[
282,
462,
298,
476
],
[
301,
462,
368,
476
],
[
371,
462,
451,
476
],
[
454,
462,
483,
477
],
[
486,
462,
535,
477
],
[
538,
462,
607,
477
],
[
610,
462,
650,
476
],
[
654,
461,
735,
476
],
[
738,
461,
761,
476
],
[
764,
461,
834,
476
],
[
837,
461,
868,
475
],
[
88,
477,
168,
490
],
[
170,
477,
213,
491
],
[
216,
477,
241,
491
],
[
244,
477,
316,
491
],
[
319,
477,
361,
491
],
[
364,
477,
445,
491
],
[
448,
478,
505,
491
],
[
508,
478,
538,
491
],
[
90,
510,
132,
524
],
[
135,
510,
210,
524
],
[
214,
510,
251,
524
],
[
255,
510,
287,
524
],
[
291,
510,
316,
524
],
[
320,
510,
393,
524
],
[
396,
510,
431,
525
],
[
434,
510,
510,
525
],
[
513,
510,
532,
525
],
[
535,
510,
559,
525
],
[
562,
510,
629,
525
],
[
632,
510,
672,
525
],
[
675,
510,
748,
525
],
[
751,
510,
775,
525
],
[
778,
510,
848,
525
],
[
851,
510,
875,
525
],
[
88,
526,
158,
539
],
[
161,
526,
197,
539
],
[
201,
526,
227,
539
],
[
230,
526,
327,
539
],
[
330,
526,
351,
540
],
[
354,
525,
382,
540
],
[
385,
525,
467,
540
],
[
470,
525,
497,
540
],
[
500,
525,
522,
540
],
[
525,
525,
551,
540
],
[
556,
525,
647,
540
],
[
650,
525,
667,
540
],
[
670,
525,
693,
540
],
[
696,
525,
745,
540
],
[
748,
525,
770,
540
],
[
772,
525,
802,
540
],
[
805,
525,
881,
540
],
[
884,
525,
904,
540
],
[
88,
541,
112,
554
],
[
114,
541,
147,
554
],
[
150,
541,
167,
554
],
[
170,
541,
244,
555
],
[
247,
541,
306,
555
],
[
308,
541,
341,
555
],
[
348,
541,
373,
555
],
[
377,
541,
420,
555
],
[
426,
541,
464,
555
],
[
467,
541,
508,
555
],
[
512,
541,
536,
555
],
[
539,
541,
615,
555
],
[
618,
541,
667,
555
],
[
670,
541,
689,
555
],
[
692,
541,
771,
555
],
[
774,
541,
842,
555
],
[
88,
573,
135,
587
],
[
138,
573,
167,
587
],
[
170,
573,
199,
587
],
[
202,
573,
218,
587
],
[
221,
573,
274,
588
],
[
277,
574,
300,
588
],
[
304,
574,
337,
588
],
[
340,
574,
367,
589
],
[
370,
574,
440,
589
],
[
442,
574,
457,
589
],
[
461,
574,
564,
590
],
[
568,
574,
582,
590
],
[
585,
574,
695,
590
],
[
698,
575,
885,
590
],
[
89,
604,
161,
620
],
[
89,
714,
134,
728
],
[
137,
715,
160,
728
],
[
163,
714,
224,
728
],
[
90,
730,
135,
744
],
[
139,
730,
205,
744
],
[
208,
730,
290,
744
],
[
292,
730,
322,
744
],
[
325,
730,
396,
744
],
[
399,
730,
454,
745
],
[
91,
746,
161,
760
],
[
164,
746,
241,
760
],
[
244,
746,
302,
760
],
[
88,
780,
110,
792
],
[
147,
777,
198,
792
],
[
201,
778,
257,
793
],
[
260,
778,
326,
793
],
[
330,
778,
374,
792
],
[
148,
793,
201,
808
],
[
204,
794,
333,
808
],
[
337,
793,
382,
808
],
[
148,
809,
180,
824
],
[
182,
810,
234,
825
],
[
237,
810,
304,
825
],
[
307,
810,
341,
825
],
[
344,
810,
430,
825
],
[
432,
810,
502,
825
],
[
505,
810,
551,
824
],
[
147,
825,
208,
840
],
[
211,
825,
253,
840
],
[
257,
825,
304,
840
],
[
307,
826,
324,
840
],
[
327,
826,
397,
840
],
[
401,
826,
448,
840
],
[
451,
826,
477,
840
],
[
481,
826,
548,
840
],
[
552,
826,
632,
840
],
[
98,
881,
131,
894
],
[
134,
882,
202,
895
],
[
205,
882,
226,
895
],
[
229,
882,
278,
895
],
[
281,
883,
351,
895
],
[
355,
883,
410,
895
],
[
413,
883,
427,
895
],
[
430,
883,
451,
895
],
[
454,
883,
511,
895
],
[
514,
883,
530,
896
],
[
532,
883,
601,
896
],
[
604,
883,
641,
895
],
[
644,
883,
722,
895
],
[
725,
883,
764,
895
],
[
767,
882,
801,
895
],
[
804,
882,
814,
895
],
[
817,
882,
882,
895
],
[
885,
881,
898,
895
],
[
87,
897,
109,
909
],
[
111,
897,
146,
909
],
[
148,
897,
164,
909
],
[
167,
897,
190,
909
],
[
192,
898,
266,
909
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
In which number should Karyn M. Schmidt be contacted?
|
202-249-6130
|
735
|
[
"potential",
"child",
"exposure",
"is",
"greater",
"than",
"for",
"a",
"non-child",
"specific",
"product.",
"For",
"example,",
"how",
"does",
"child",
"exposure",
"to",
"a",
"general",
"use",
"cleaner",
"compare",
"to",
"exposure",
"from",
"use",
"in",
"a",
"child's",
"raincoat.",
"In",
"the",
"VCCEP",
"assessments,",
"there",
"are",
"examples",
"for",
"inhalation",
"exposures",
"where",
"estimates",
"of",
"passive",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"adult",
"product",
"use",
"exceeded",
"conservative",
"estimates",
"of",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"active",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"child-specific",
"product",
"(such",
"as",
"a",
"hobby",
"product)",
"-",
"differences",
"were",
"related",
"to",
"the",
"amount",
"of",
"product",
"used",
"and",
"substance",
"concentration",
"within",
"the",
"product",
"(MEK",
"VCCEP",
"Submission).",
"the",
"IUR",
"definition",
"targets",
"children",
"age",
"14",
"and",
"younger.",
"Younger",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"non-child",
"specific",
"products",
"that",
"are",
"in",
"general",
"household",
"use.",
"Older",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"additional",
"products.",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"request",
"is",
"targeted",
"to",
"manufacturers,",
"which",
"may",
"not",
"have",
"direct",
"knowledge",
"of",
"all",
"uses,",
"particularly",
"the",
"presence",
"in",
"products",
"for",
"specific",
"subpopulations,",
"such",
"as",
"children.",
"Therefore,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"that",
"the",
"information",
"requested",
"for",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"would",
"be",
"consistently",
"available",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"screened.",
"Ideally,",
"this",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"requested",
"from",
"formulators",
"of",
"child-specific",
"products.",
"Therefore,",
"for",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"which",
"represents",
"a",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"categorization,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally.",
"The",
"IUR",
"information",
"on",
"child",
"specific",
"use",
"would",
"be",
"utilized",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"If",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"is",
"utilized,",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"that",
"the",
"limitations",
"above",
"be",
"considered",
"in",
"its",
"application.",
"Emissions",
"Data:",
"Production",
"volume,",
"which",
"is",
"readily",
"available",
"for",
"substances,",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"this",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"but",
"only",
"serves",
"as",
"a",
"surrogate",
"for",
"environmental",
"emissions.",
"For",
"further",
"prioritization,",
"data",
"or",
"estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"refine",
"prioritization.",
"Estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"will",
"be",
"available",
"for",
"some",
"substances",
"(e.g.,",
"TRI",
"data).",
"When",
"TRI",
"data",
"are",
"utilized",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"recognized",
"that",
"it",
"addresses",
"only",
"emissions",
"that",
"result",
"from",
"industrial",
"and",
"not",
"wide",
"dispersive",
"uses.",
"In",
"other",
"cases,",
"emissions",
"estimates",
"can",
"be",
"developed",
"as",
"a",
"percentage",
"of",
"production",
"volume",
"based",
"upon",
"consideration",
"of",
"use",
"categories.",
"Within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping,",
"available",
"emissions",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"considered",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering,",
"with",
"the",
"understanding",
"that",
"emissions",
"information",
"is",
"not",
"an",
"indicator",
"of",
"actual",
"exposure.",
"Similarly,",
"non-isolated",
"system",
"intermediates,",
"by",
"definition,",
"would",
"have",
"de",
"minimis",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"Therefore,",
"this",
"IUR",
"information",
"could",
"be",
"considered",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions:",
"An",
"initial",
"screening",
"approach",
"for",
"chemical",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"consistent",
"application",
"of",
"specific",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"science",
"elements",
"that",
"define",
"risk",
"potential.",
"The",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"elements",
"should",
"be",
"applicable",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening,",
"existence",
"of",
"international",
"risk",
"management",
"action",
"plans",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"a",
"factor",
"that",
"determines",
"priority",
"grouping.",
"Risk",
"management",
"plans",
"may",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"many",
"factors,",
"including",
"political",
"drivers.",
"It",
"is",
"unclear",
"how",
"factors,",
"their",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"and",
"the",
"rigor",
"of",
"the",
"evaluation",
"may",
"vary",
"across",
"agencies",
"and",
"substances.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
101,
240,
115
],
[
243,
102,
281,
115
],
[
284,
102,
351,
115
],
[
354,
102,
367,
115
],
[
370,
102,
421,
115
],
[
424,
102,
457,
115
],
[
460,
102,
482,
115
],
[
485,
102,
494,
115
],
[
498,
102,
568,
115
],
[
571,
102,
630,
115
],
[
632,
102,
694,
115
],
[
697,
101,
722,
115
],
[
725,
101,
792,
115
],
[
795,
100,
825,
115
],
[
835,
100,
865,
115
],
[
868,
100,
908,
115
],
[
177,
117,
242,
130
],
[
245,
117,
262,
130
],
[
264,
117,
274,
130
],
[
277,
117,
331,
130
],
[
334,
117,
361,
130
],
[
363,
118,
417,
130
],
[
419,
117,
483,
130
],
[
485,
117,
502,
130
],
[
505,
117,
572,
130
],
[
574,
117,
605,
130
],
[
613,
117,
640,
130
],
[
642,
117,
657,
130
],
[
661,
116,
670,
130
],
[
672,
116,
722,
130
],
[
725,
115,
795,
130
],
[
798,
115,
814,
130
],
[
817,
115,
842,
130
],
[
844,
114,
902,
130
],
[
177,
134,
269,
146
],
[
272,
134,
310,
147
],
[
312,
134,
338,
147
],
[
341,
134,
417,
147
],
[
420,
134,
445,
147
],
[
448,
133,
527,
147
],
[
531,
133,
612,
147
],
[
615,
133,
665,
147
],
[
668,
132,
744,
147
],
[
747,
132,
764,
147
],
[
766,
131,
828,
147
],
[
830,
131,
871,
146
],
[
177,
150,
250,
163
],
[
254,
150,
305,
163
],
[
308,
150,
348,
163
],
[
351,
150,
414,
163
],
[
417,
150,
445,
164
],
[
448,
150,
524,
164
],
[
526,
150,
628,
164
],
[
630,
150,
705,
164
],
[
707,
150,
727,
164
],
[
730,
149,
771,
164
],
[
774,
149,
847,
165
],
[
852,
149,
901,
165
],
[
177,
166,
224,
180
],
[
227,
166,
256,
180
],
[
260,
166,
276,
180
],
[
280,
166,
291,
180
],
[
294,
165,
401,
180
],
[
405,
165,
467,
180
],
[
470,
165,
514,
180
],
[
518,
165,
536,
180
],
[
540,
165,
550,
180
],
[
552,
165,
604,
180
],
[
607,
165,
674,
180
],
[
677,
165,
691,
180
],
[
695,
165,
782,
180
],
[
785,
165,
825,
180
],
[
828,
165,
882,
180
],
[
885,
165,
903,
181
],
[
177,
182,
202,
197
],
[
205,
182,
265,
197
],
[
269,
182,
287,
197
],
[
290,
182,
351,
197
],
[
355,
182,
393,
197
],
[
397,
183,
425,
197
],
[
429,
182,
507,
197
],
[
511,
182,
620,
197
],
[
624,
182,
673,
197
],
[
677,
182,
702,
197
],
[
705,
182,
768,
197
],
[
772,
181,
821,
197
],
[
829,
181,
887,
197
],
[
178,
198,
280,
215
],
[
176,
218,
200,
232
],
[
203,
218,
232,
232
],
[
241,
218,
309,
232
],
[
312,
218,
361,
232
],
[
364,
218,
425,
232
],
[
428,
218,
455,
232
],
[
458,
218,
478,
232
],
[
481,
218,
508,
232
],
[
511,
218,
578,
232
],
[
581,
218,
644,
232
],
[
647,
218,
706,
232
],
[
709,
218,
741,
232
],
[
744,
218,
764,
232
],
[
766,
218,
826,
232
],
[
828,
218,
846,
232
],
[
848,
218,
860,
232
],
[
177,
235,
227,
248
],
[
231,
235,
247,
248
],
[
250,
235,
320,
248
],
[
323,
235,
380,
248
],
[
383,
235,
447,
248
],
[
450,
235,
479,
248
],
[
482,
235,
505,
248
],
[
508,
235,
524,
248
],
[
527,
235,
581,
248
],
[
584,
235,
660,
248
],
[
663,
234,
694,
248
],
[
697,
234,
738,
248
],
[
741,
234,
801,
248
],
[
804,
234,
836,
248
],
[
839,
234,
858,
248
],
[
178,
251,
237,
264
],
[
240,
251,
256,
264
],
[
259,
251,
268,
264
],
[
271,
250,
322,
264
],
[
325,
250,
342,
264
],
[
345,
250,
417,
264
],
[
420,
251,
491,
264
],
[
176,
267,
198,
282
],
[
202,
267,
234,
282
],
[
238,
268,
324,
283
],
[
327,
268,
380,
283
],
[
384,
269,
397,
283
],
[
400,
269,
459,
283
],
[
463,
269,
477,
283
],
[
481,
269,
591,
283
],
[
594,
269,
638,
283
],
[
641,
269,
672,
283
],
[
677,
269,
700,
283
],
[
704,
268,
742,
283
],
[
745,
268,
784,
283
],
[
787,
267,
868,
282
],
[
872,
266,
891,
282
],
[
178,
284,
195,
299
],
[
198,
284,
235,
299
],
[
238,
284,
322,
299
],
[
325,
285,
349,
299
],
[
352,
285,
417,
299
],
[
420,
285,
435,
298
],
[
438,
285,
502,
298
],
[
506,
285,
528,
298
],
[
531,
284,
588,
298
],
[
592,
284,
705,
298
],
[
709,
284,
743,
298
],
[
747,
284,
762,
298
],
[
766,
284,
834,
298
],
[
179,
299,
252,
313
],
[
255,
300,
267,
314
],
[
271,
300,
283,
314
],
[
287,
300,
311,
314
],
[
314,
300,
351,
314
],
[
354,
300,
382,
314
],
[
385,
300,
409,
314
],
[
412,
300,
498,
314
],
[
501,
300,
572,
314
],
[
575,
300,
597,
314
],
[
600,
300,
624,
314
],
[
627,
300,
658,
313
],
[
662,
300,
750,
313
],
[
752,
300,
798,
313
],
[
801,
300,
823,
313
],
[
178,
315,
262,
330
],
[
266,
315,
332,
330
],
[
335,
315,
382,
330
],
[
385,
315,
404,
330
],
[
408,
315,
485,
330
],
[
489,
315,
530,
330
],
[
534,
315,
602,
330
],
[
605,
315,
661,
330
],
[
665,
315,
691,
330
],
[
694,
315,
781,
330
],
[
785,
315,
833,
330
],
[
837,
315,
857,
330
],
[
176,
332,
247,
346
],
[
250,
332,
282,
346
],
[
289,
332,
374,
345
],
[
377,
332,
394,
345
],
[
397,
332,
496,
346
],
[
499,
332,
564,
347
],
[
183,
360,
265,
377
],
[
270,
361,
293,
377
],
[
297,
361,
321,
377
],
[
325,
361,
372,
377
],
[
376,
362,
480,
377
],
[
484,
362,
563,
377
],
[
567,
362,
614,
377
],
[
618,
362,
700,
377
],
[
704,
362,
712,
376
],
[
716,
361,
767,
376
],
[
771,
360,
850,
376
],
[
147,
379,
265,
393
],
[
268,
380,
308,
394
],
[
311,
380,
374,
394
],
[
377,
380,
447,
394
],
[
450,
380,
476,
394
],
[
479,
380,
550,
394
],
[
552,
380,
599,
394
],
[
602,
380,
661,
394
],
[
664,
379,
742,
394
],
[
745,
379,
815,
394
],
[
818,
379,
849,
393
],
[
852,
379,
873,
393
],
[
147,
396,
224,
411
],
[
227,
396,
297,
411
],
[
300,
396,
327,
411
],
[
330,
395,
403,
411
],
[
407,
395,
473,
411
],
[
476,
395,
507,
411
],
[
510,
395,
541,
411
],
[
548,
395,
642,
411
],
[
645,
395,
666,
411
],
[
671,
395,
711,
411
],
[
715,
395,
776,
411
],
[
780,
395,
808,
410
],
[
812,
395,
861,
410
],
[
864,
395,
886,
410
],
[
148,
413,
208,
428
],
[
212,
414,
262,
429
],
[
266,
414,
275,
429
],
[
279,
414,
355,
430
],
[
359,
414,
420,
430
],
[
424,
414,
496,
430
],
[
500,
413,
524,
430
],
[
528,
413,
588,
430
],
[
591,
413,
624,
430
],
[
628,
413,
664,
430
],
[
667,
412,
740,
429
],
[
744,
412,
758,
428
],
[
761,
412,
787,
428
],
[
790,
412,
822,
428
],
[
146,
431,
241,
446
],
[
244,
432,
260,
446
],
[
262,
432,
328,
446
],
[
331,
432,
343,
446
],
[
346,
432,
361,
446
],
[
364,
432,
442,
446
],
[
445,
432,
477,
447
],
[
480,
432,
507,
447
],
[
509,
431,
596,
447
],
[
599,
431,
647,
447
],
[
649,
431,
671,
447
],
[
673,
431,
761,
447
],
[
763,
431,
780,
446
],
[
782,
431,
805,
446
],
[
807,
430,
903,
446
],
[
182,
469,
268,
485
],
[
272,
470,
321,
485
],
[
181,
500,
270,
515
],
[
274,
500,
339,
515
],
[
342,
500,
391,
515
],
[
394,
500,
408,
515
],
[
412,
500,
468,
516
],
[
472,
500,
545,
516
],
[
548,
500,
572,
516
],
[
575,
500,
665,
516
],
[
668,
500,
684,
516
],
[
687,
500,
724,
516
],
[
727,
500,
744,
516
],
[
747,
500,
778,
516
],
[
781,
500,
857,
516
],
[
147,
519,
225,
534
],
[
228,
519,
255,
534
],
[
259,
519,
295,
534
],
[
298,
519,
349,
534
],
[
352,
519,
370,
534
],
[
373,
519,
384,
534
],
[
388,
519,
462,
534
],
[
465,
519,
490,
534
],
[
494,
519,
608,
534
],
[
611,
518,
695,
534
],
[
699,
518,
727,
534
],
[
731,
518,
785,
534
],
[
788,
517,
898,
534
],
[
151,
536,
181,
550
],
[
184,
536,
202,
550
],
[
205,
536,
281,
550
],
[
284,
537,
302,
550
],
[
305,
537,
420,
551
],
[
423,
537,
503,
551
],
[
506,
537,
535,
551
],
[
537,
537,
558,
551
],
[
561,
537,
599,
551
],
[
602,
537,
619,
551
],
[
621,
537,
670,
551
],
[
672,
536,
782,
551
],
[
785,
535,
864,
550
],
[
866,
535,
888,
550
],
[
148,
553,
261,
568
],
[
265,
553,
344,
568
],
[
347,
553,
378,
568
],
[
381,
553,
403,
568
],
[
406,
553,
478,
568
],
[
481,
553,
507,
568
],
[
510,
553,
553,
568
],
[
556,
553,
642,
568
],
[
645,
553,
688,
568
],
[
691,
553,
725,
568
],
[
728,
553,
774,
568
],
[
776,
553,
825,
568
],
[
828,
553,
864,
568
],
[
866,
553,
899,
568
],
[
148,
570,
171,
585
],
[
175,
570,
235,
585
],
[
238,
570,
251,
586
],
[
255,
570,
307,
586
],
[
311,
570,
331,
586
],
[
335,
570,
422,
586
],
[
425,
570,
457,
586
],
[
461,
570,
474,
586
],
[
477,
570,
553,
586
],
[
557,
570,
594,
586
],
[
597,
570,
675,
586
],
[
678,
570,
709,
586
],
[
712,
570,
758,
586
],
[
762,
570,
797,
586
],
[
804,
570,
878,
586
],
[
147,
588,
177,
602
],
[
180,
588,
207,
602
],
[
210,
588,
252,
602
],
[
257,
588,
334,
603
],
[
337,
588,
378,
603
],
[
382,
588,
399,
603
],
[
402,
588,
445,
603
],
[
448,
589,
495,
603
],
[
499,
589,
578,
603
],
[
582,
589,
657,
603
],
[
660,
589,
687,
603
],
[
691,
588,
714,
603
],
[
718,
588,
797,
603
],
[
801,
588,
819,
603
],
[
822,
588,
830,
603
],
[
147,
606,
233,
621
],
[
237,
605,
253,
620
],
[
257,
605,
344,
620
],
[
348,
605,
407,
620
],
[
411,
605,
457,
620
],
[
461,
605,
502,
620
],
[
505,
605,
613,
620
],
[
617,
605,
634,
620
],
[
638,
605,
666,
620
],
[
670,
605,
756,
620
],
[
760,
605,
815,
620
],
[
818,
605,
830,
620
],
[
147,
623,
222,
639
],
[
226,
623,
287,
639
],
[
291,
623,
367,
639
],
[
371,
623,
442,
638
],
[
447,
622,
525,
638
],
[
528,
622,
624,
638
],
[
628,
622,
654,
638
],
[
658,
622,
679,
638
],
[
682,
622,
769,
638
],
[
772,
621,
798,
638
],
[
801,
621,
862,
638
],
[
865,
621,
900,
637
],
[
147,
640,
182,
655
],
[
186,
640,
261,
655
],
[
264,
640,
299,
655
],
[
302,
641,
328,
655
],
[
332,
641,
443,
655
],
[
447,
641,
479,
655
],
[
482,
641,
561,
655
],
[
564,
641,
658,
655
],
[
661,
641,
677,
655
],
[
680,
641,
707,
655
],
[
711,
641,
730,
654
],
[
733,
641,
805,
654
],
[
808,
641,
826,
654
],
[
830,
641,
875,
654
],
[
148,
659,
221,
673
],
[
182,
691,
261,
706
],
[
264,
692,
363,
707
],
[
367,
693,
419,
707
],
[
425,
693,
538,
707
],
[
541,
693,
564,
707
],
[
570,
693,
649,
707
],
[
652,
693,
702,
707
],
[
705,
692,
747,
707
],
[
751,
692,
768,
706
],
[
771,
692,
840,
706
],
[
148,
710,
219,
725
],
[
222,
710,
301,
725
],
[
304,
710,
384,
725
],
[
387,
710,
419,
725
],
[
422,
710,
454,
725
],
[
460,
710,
555,
725
],
[
558,
710,
603,
725
],
[
606,
710,
627,
725
],
[
630,
710,
717,
725
],
[
720,
710,
772,
724
],
[
775,
710,
785,
724
],
[
788,
710,
865,
724
],
[
145,
727,
208,
745
],
[
212,
727,
282,
744
],
[
287,
727,
311,
743
],
[
315,
727,
374,
743
],
[
378,
727,
410,
743
],
[
414,
727,
451,
744
],
[
454,
727,
527,
745
],
[
182,
762,
295,
778
],
[
298,
763,
337,
778
],
[
341,
763,
454,
778
],
[
457,
762,
527,
778
],
[
183,
793,
207,
808
],
[
210,
793,
259,
808
],
[
262,
793,
339,
808
],
[
342,
793,
415,
809
],
[
418,
793,
443,
809
],
[
447,
793,
518,
809
],
[
521,
793,
626,
809
],
[
630,
793,
684,
808
],
[
687,
793,
707,
808
],
[
710,
793,
756,
808
],
[
760,
793,
801,
808
],
[
804,
793,
887,
808
],
[
148,
811,
236,
825
],
[
239,
811,
257,
825
],
[
260,
811,
322,
825
],
[
325,
811,
380,
825
],
[
383,
811,
414,
825
],
[
417,
811,
489,
825
],
[
492,
811,
552,
825
],
[
556,
811,
625,
825
],
[
629,
811,
662,
825
],
[
666,
811,
714,
825
],
[
717,
811,
748,
825
],
[
752,
811,
824,
825
],
[
184,
828,
213,
842
],
[
217,
828,
271,
843
],
[
275,
827,
304,
843
],
[
308,
827,
380,
843
],
[
384,
827,
455,
843
],
[
459,
827,
512,
843
],
[
515,
827,
535,
843
],
[
539,
827,
622,
843
],
[
625,
827,
675,
843
],
[
678,
827,
700,
843
],
[
703,
828,
788,
843
],
[
791,
828,
840,
843
],
[
147,
845,
228,
860
],
[
231,
845,
259,
860
],
[
263,
845,
311,
860
],
[
315,
845,
395,
861
],
[
399,
845,
474,
861
],
[
478,
845,
495,
861
],
[
499,
845,
598,
861
],
[
602,
845,
632,
861
],
[
637,
845,
739,
861
],
[
742,
845,
791,
860
],
[
795,
845,
838,
860
],
[
842,
845,
896,
860
],
[
147,
863,
173,
876
],
[
176,
863,
198,
876
],
[
201,
863,
210,
877
],
[
213,
863,
261,
877
],
[
264,
863,
298,
877
],
[
301,
863,
387,
878
],
[
390,
863,
452,
878
],
[
455,
863,
532,
878
],
[
535,
863,
572,
878
],
[
575,
863,
678,
878
],
[
681,
863,
724,
878
],
[
727,
862,
762,
878
],
[
765,
862,
785,
877
],
[
788,
862,
836,
877
],
[
839,
862,
879,
877
],
[
147,
880,
192,
895
],
[
195,
880,
255,
895
],
[
258,
880,
332,
895
],
[
336,
880,
405,
895
],
[
409,
879,
467,
895
],
[
471,
879,
484,
895
],
[
487,
879,
503,
895
],
[
507,
879,
564,
895
],
[
568,
879,
601,
895
],
[
608,
879,
667,
895
],
[
671,
879,
708,
895
],
[
711,
879,
773,
895
],
[
777,
878,
861,
895
],
[
865,
878,
896,
895
],
[
148,
897,
172,
910
],
[
175,
897,
215,
910
],
[
218,
897,
237,
910
],
[
240,
897,
265,
910
],
[
268,
897,
351,
911
],
[
355,
898,
391,
911
],
[
395,
898,
431,
911
],
[
434,
898,
485,
911
],
[
488,
898,
558,
911
],
[
561,
898,
591,
912
],
[
594,
897,
684,
912
],
[
687,
897,
716,
912
],
[
719,
897,
768,
912
],
[
771,
897,
845,
912
],
[
184,
924,
244,
938
],
[
247,
924,
274,
938
],
[
277,
924,
319,
938
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Which age group foes the IUR definition target?
|
targets children age 14 and younger
|
735
|
[
"potential",
"child",
"exposure",
"is",
"greater",
"than",
"for",
"a",
"non-child",
"specific",
"product.",
"For",
"example,",
"how",
"does",
"child",
"exposure",
"to",
"a",
"general",
"use",
"cleaner",
"compare",
"to",
"exposure",
"from",
"use",
"in",
"a",
"child's",
"raincoat.",
"In",
"the",
"VCCEP",
"assessments,",
"there",
"are",
"examples",
"for",
"inhalation",
"exposures",
"where",
"estimates",
"of",
"passive",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"adult",
"product",
"use",
"exceeded",
"conservative",
"estimates",
"of",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"active",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"child-specific",
"product",
"(such",
"as",
"a",
"hobby",
"product)",
"-",
"differences",
"were",
"related",
"to",
"the",
"amount",
"of",
"product",
"used",
"and",
"substance",
"concentration",
"within",
"the",
"product",
"(MEK",
"VCCEP",
"Submission).",
"the",
"IUR",
"definition",
"targets",
"children",
"age",
"14",
"and",
"younger.",
"Younger",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"non-child",
"specific",
"products",
"that",
"are",
"in",
"general",
"household",
"use.",
"Older",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"additional",
"products.",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"request",
"is",
"targeted",
"to",
"manufacturers,",
"which",
"may",
"not",
"have",
"direct",
"knowledge",
"of",
"all",
"uses,",
"particularly",
"the",
"presence",
"in",
"products",
"for",
"specific",
"subpopulations,",
"such",
"as",
"children.",
"Therefore,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"that",
"the",
"information",
"requested",
"for",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"would",
"be",
"consistently",
"available",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"screened.",
"Ideally,",
"this",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"requested",
"from",
"formulators",
"of",
"child-specific",
"products.",
"Therefore,",
"for",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"which",
"represents",
"a",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"categorization,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally.",
"The",
"IUR",
"information",
"on",
"child",
"specific",
"use",
"would",
"be",
"utilized",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"If",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"is",
"utilized,",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"that",
"the",
"limitations",
"above",
"be",
"considered",
"in",
"its",
"application.",
"Emissions",
"Data:",
"Production",
"volume,",
"which",
"is",
"readily",
"available",
"for",
"substances,",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"this",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"but",
"only",
"serves",
"as",
"a",
"surrogate",
"for",
"environmental",
"emissions.",
"For",
"further",
"prioritization,",
"data",
"or",
"estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"refine",
"prioritization.",
"Estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"will",
"be",
"available",
"for",
"some",
"substances",
"(e.g.,",
"TRI",
"data).",
"When",
"TRI",
"data",
"are",
"utilized",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"recognized",
"that",
"it",
"addresses",
"only",
"emissions",
"that",
"result",
"from",
"industrial",
"and",
"not",
"wide",
"dispersive",
"uses.",
"In",
"other",
"cases,",
"emissions",
"estimates",
"can",
"be",
"developed",
"as",
"a",
"percentage",
"of",
"production",
"volume",
"based",
"upon",
"consideration",
"of",
"use",
"categories.",
"Within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping,",
"available",
"emissions",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"considered",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering,",
"with",
"the",
"understanding",
"that",
"emissions",
"information",
"is",
"not",
"an",
"indicator",
"of",
"actual",
"exposure.",
"Similarly,",
"non-isolated",
"system",
"intermediates,",
"by",
"definition,",
"would",
"have",
"de",
"minimis",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"Therefore,",
"this",
"IUR",
"information",
"could",
"be",
"considered",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions:",
"An",
"initial",
"screening",
"approach",
"for",
"chemical",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"consistent",
"application",
"of",
"specific",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"science",
"elements",
"that",
"define",
"risk",
"potential.",
"The",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"elements",
"should",
"be",
"applicable",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening,",
"existence",
"of",
"international",
"risk",
"management",
"action",
"plans",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"a",
"factor",
"that",
"determines",
"priority",
"grouping.",
"Risk",
"management",
"plans",
"may",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"many",
"factors,",
"including",
"political",
"drivers.",
"It",
"is",
"unclear",
"how",
"factors,",
"their",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"and",
"the",
"rigor",
"of",
"the",
"evaluation",
"may",
"vary",
"across",
"agencies",
"and",
"substances.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
101,
240,
115
],
[
243,
102,
281,
115
],
[
284,
102,
351,
115
],
[
354,
102,
367,
115
],
[
370,
102,
421,
115
],
[
424,
102,
457,
115
],
[
460,
102,
482,
115
],
[
485,
102,
494,
115
],
[
498,
102,
568,
115
],
[
571,
102,
630,
115
],
[
632,
102,
694,
115
],
[
697,
101,
722,
115
],
[
725,
101,
792,
115
],
[
795,
100,
825,
115
],
[
835,
100,
865,
115
],
[
868,
100,
908,
115
],
[
177,
117,
242,
130
],
[
245,
117,
262,
130
],
[
264,
117,
274,
130
],
[
277,
117,
331,
130
],
[
334,
117,
361,
130
],
[
363,
118,
417,
130
],
[
419,
117,
483,
130
],
[
485,
117,
502,
130
],
[
505,
117,
572,
130
],
[
574,
117,
605,
130
],
[
613,
117,
640,
130
],
[
642,
117,
657,
130
],
[
661,
116,
670,
130
],
[
672,
116,
722,
130
],
[
725,
115,
795,
130
],
[
798,
115,
814,
130
],
[
817,
115,
842,
130
],
[
844,
114,
902,
130
],
[
177,
134,
269,
146
],
[
272,
134,
310,
147
],
[
312,
134,
338,
147
],
[
341,
134,
417,
147
],
[
420,
134,
445,
147
],
[
448,
133,
527,
147
],
[
531,
133,
612,
147
],
[
615,
133,
665,
147
],
[
668,
132,
744,
147
],
[
747,
132,
764,
147
],
[
766,
131,
828,
147
],
[
830,
131,
871,
146
],
[
177,
150,
250,
163
],
[
254,
150,
305,
163
],
[
308,
150,
348,
163
],
[
351,
150,
414,
163
],
[
417,
150,
445,
164
],
[
448,
150,
524,
164
],
[
526,
150,
628,
164
],
[
630,
150,
705,
164
],
[
707,
150,
727,
164
],
[
730,
149,
771,
164
],
[
774,
149,
847,
165
],
[
852,
149,
901,
165
],
[
177,
166,
224,
180
],
[
227,
166,
256,
180
],
[
260,
166,
276,
180
],
[
280,
166,
291,
180
],
[
294,
165,
401,
180
],
[
405,
165,
467,
180
],
[
470,
165,
514,
180
],
[
518,
165,
536,
180
],
[
540,
165,
550,
180
],
[
552,
165,
604,
180
],
[
607,
165,
674,
180
],
[
677,
165,
691,
180
],
[
695,
165,
782,
180
],
[
785,
165,
825,
180
],
[
828,
165,
882,
180
],
[
885,
165,
903,
181
],
[
177,
182,
202,
197
],
[
205,
182,
265,
197
],
[
269,
182,
287,
197
],
[
290,
182,
351,
197
],
[
355,
182,
393,
197
],
[
397,
183,
425,
197
],
[
429,
182,
507,
197
],
[
511,
182,
620,
197
],
[
624,
182,
673,
197
],
[
677,
182,
702,
197
],
[
705,
182,
768,
197
],
[
772,
181,
821,
197
],
[
829,
181,
887,
197
],
[
178,
198,
280,
215
],
[
176,
218,
200,
232
],
[
203,
218,
232,
232
],
[
241,
218,
309,
232
],
[
312,
218,
361,
232
],
[
364,
218,
425,
232
],
[
428,
218,
455,
232
],
[
458,
218,
478,
232
],
[
481,
218,
508,
232
],
[
511,
218,
578,
232
],
[
581,
218,
644,
232
],
[
647,
218,
706,
232
],
[
709,
218,
741,
232
],
[
744,
218,
764,
232
],
[
766,
218,
826,
232
],
[
828,
218,
846,
232
],
[
848,
218,
860,
232
],
[
177,
235,
227,
248
],
[
231,
235,
247,
248
],
[
250,
235,
320,
248
],
[
323,
235,
380,
248
],
[
383,
235,
447,
248
],
[
450,
235,
479,
248
],
[
482,
235,
505,
248
],
[
508,
235,
524,
248
],
[
527,
235,
581,
248
],
[
584,
235,
660,
248
],
[
663,
234,
694,
248
],
[
697,
234,
738,
248
],
[
741,
234,
801,
248
],
[
804,
234,
836,
248
],
[
839,
234,
858,
248
],
[
178,
251,
237,
264
],
[
240,
251,
256,
264
],
[
259,
251,
268,
264
],
[
271,
250,
322,
264
],
[
325,
250,
342,
264
],
[
345,
250,
417,
264
],
[
420,
251,
491,
264
],
[
176,
267,
198,
282
],
[
202,
267,
234,
282
],
[
238,
268,
324,
283
],
[
327,
268,
380,
283
],
[
384,
269,
397,
283
],
[
400,
269,
459,
283
],
[
463,
269,
477,
283
],
[
481,
269,
591,
283
],
[
594,
269,
638,
283
],
[
641,
269,
672,
283
],
[
677,
269,
700,
283
],
[
704,
268,
742,
283
],
[
745,
268,
784,
283
],
[
787,
267,
868,
282
],
[
872,
266,
891,
282
],
[
178,
284,
195,
299
],
[
198,
284,
235,
299
],
[
238,
284,
322,
299
],
[
325,
285,
349,
299
],
[
352,
285,
417,
299
],
[
420,
285,
435,
298
],
[
438,
285,
502,
298
],
[
506,
285,
528,
298
],
[
531,
284,
588,
298
],
[
592,
284,
705,
298
],
[
709,
284,
743,
298
],
[
747,
284,
762,
298
],
[
766,
284,
834,
298
],
[
179,
299,
252,
313
],
[
255,
300,
267,
314
],
[
271,
300,
283,
314
],
[
287,
300,
311,
314
],
[
314,
300,
351,
314
],
[
354,
300,
382,
314
],
[
385,
300,
409,
314
],
[
412,
300,
498,
314
],
[
501,
300,
572,
314
],
[
575,
300,
597,
314
],
[
600,
300,
624,
314
],
[
627,
300,
658,
313
],
[
662,
300,
750,
313
],
[
752,
300,
798,
313
],
[
801,
300,
823,
313
],
[
178,
315,
262,
330
],
[
266,
315,
332,
330
],
[
335,
315,
382,
330
],
[
385,
315,
404,
330
],
[
408,
315,
485,
330
],
[
489,
315,
530,
330
],
[
534,
315,
602,
330
],
[
605,
315,
661,
330
],
[
665,
315,
691,
330
],
[
694,
315,
781,
330
],
[
785,
315,
833,
330
],
[
837,
315,
857,
330
],
[
176,
332,
247,
346
],
[
250,
332,
282,
346
],
[
289,
332,
374,
345
],
[
377,
332,
394,
345
],
[
397,
332,
496,
346
],
[
499,
332,
564,
347
],
[
183,
360,
265,
377
],
[
270,
361,
293,
377
],
[
297,
361,
321,
377
],
[
325,
361,
372,
377
],
[
376,
362,
480,
377
],
[
484,
362,
563,
377
],
[
567,
362,
614,
377
],
[
618,
362,
700,
377
],
[
704,
362,
712,
376
],
[
716,
361,
767,
376
],
[
771,
360,
850,
376
],
[
147,
379,
265,
393
],
[
268,
380,
308,
394
],
[
311,
380,
374,
394
],
[
377,
380,
447,
394
],
[
450,
380,
476,
394
],
[
479,
380,
550,
394
],
[
552,
380,
599,
394
],
[
602,
380,
661,
394
],
[
664,
379,
742,
394
],
[
745,
379,
815,
394
],
[
818,
379,
849,
393
],
[
852,
379,
873,
393
],
[
147,
396,
224,
411
],
[
227,
396,
297,
411
],
[
300,
396,
327,
411
],
[
330,
395,
403,
411
],
[
407,
395,
473,
411
],
[
476,
395,
507,
411
],
[
510,
395,
541,
411
],
[
548,
395,
642,
411
],
[
645,
395,
666,
411
],
[
671,
395,
711,
411
],
[
715,
395,
776,
411
],
[
780,
395,
808,
410
],
[
812,
395,
861,
410
],
[
864,
395,
886,
410
],
[
148,
413,
208,
428
],
[
212,
414,
262,
429
],
[
266,
414,
275,
429
],
[
279,
414,
355,
430
],
[
359,
414,
420,
430
],
[
424,
414,
496,
430
],
[
500,
413,
524,
430
],
[
528,
413,
588,
430
],
[
591,
413,
624,
430
],
[
628,
413,
664,
430
],
[
667,
412,
740,
429
],
[
744,
412,
758,
428
],
[
761,
412,
787,
428
],
[
790,
412,
822,
428
],
[
146,
431,
241,
446
],
[
244,
432,
260,
446
],
[
262,
432,
328,
446
],
[
331,
432,
343,
446
],
[
346,
432,
361,
446
],
[
364,
432,
442,
446
],
[
445,
432,
477,
447
],
[
480,
432,
507,
447
],
[
509,
431,
596,
447
],
[
599,
431,
647,
447
],
[
649,
431,
671,
447
],
[
673,
431,
761,
447
],
[
763,
431,
780,
446
],
[
782,
431,
805,
446
],
[
807,
430,
903,
446
],
[
182,
469,
268,
485
],
[
272,
470,
321,
485
],
[
181,
500,
270,
515
],
[
274,
500,
339,
515
],
[
342,
500,
391,
515
],
[
394,
500,
408,
515
],
[
412,
500,
468,
516
],
[
472,
500,
545,
516
],
[
548,
500,
572,
516
],
[
575,
500,
665,
516
],
[
668,
500,
684,
516
],
[
687,
500,
724,
516
],
[
727,
500,
744,
516
],
[
747,
500,
778,
516
],
[
781,
500,
857,
516
],
[
147,
519,
225,
534
],
[
228,
519,
255,
534
],
[
259,
519,
295,
534
],
[
298,
519,
349,
534
],
[
352,
519,
370,
534
],
[
373,
519,
384,
534
],
[
388,
519,
462,
534
],
[
465,
519,
490,
534
],
[
494,
519,
608,
534
],
[
611,
518,
695,
534
],
[
699,
518,
727,
534
],
[
731,
518,
785,
534
],
[
788,
517,
898,
534
],
[
151,
536,
181,
550
],
[
184,
536,
202,
550
],
[
205,
536,
281,
550
],
[
284,
537,
302,
550
],
[
305,
537,
420,
551
],
[
423,
537,
503,
551
],
[
506,
537,
535,
551
],
[
537,
537,
558,
551
],
[
561,
537,
599,
551
],
[
602,
537,
619,
551
],
[
621,
537,
670,
551
],
[
672,
536,
782,
551
],
[
785,
535,
864,
550
],
[
866,
535,
888,
550
],
[
148,
553,
261,
568
],
[
265,
553,
344,
568
],
[
347,
553,
378,
568
],
[
381,
553,
403,
568
],
[
406,
553,
478,
568
],
[
481,
553,
507,
568
],
[
510,
553,
553,
568
],
[
556,
553,
642,
568
],
[
645,
553,
688,
568
],
[
691,
553,
725,
568
],
[
728,
553,
774,
568
],
[
776,
553,
825,
568
],
[
828,
553,
864,
568
],
[
866,
553,
899,
568
],
[
148,
570,
171,
585
],
[
175,
570,
235,
585
],
[
238,
570,
251,
586
],
[
255,
570,
307,
586
],
[
311,
570,
331,
586
],
[
335,
570,
422,
586
],
[
425,
570,
457,
586
],
[
461,
570,
474,
586
],
[
477,
570,
553,
586
],
[
557,
570,
594,
586
],
[
597,
570,
675,
586
],
[
678,
570,
709,
586
],
[
712,
570,
758,
586
],
[
762,
570,
797,
586
],
[
804,
570,
878,
586
],
[
147,
588,
177,
602
],
[
180,
588,
207,
602
],
[
210,
588,
252,
602
],
[
257,
588,
334,
603
],
[
337,
588,
378,
603
],
[
382,
588,
399,
603
],
[
402,
588,
445,
603
],
[
448,
589,
495,
603
],
[
499,
589,
578,
603
],
[
582,
589,
657,
603
],
[
660,
589,
687,
603
],
[
691,
588,
714,
603
],
[
718,
588,
797,
603
],
[
801,
588,
819,
603
],
[
822,
588,
830,
603
],
[
147,
606,
233,
621
],
[
237,
605,
253,
620
],
[
257,
605,
344,
620
],
[
348,
605,
407,
620
],
[
411,
605,
457,
620
],
[
461,
605,
502,
620
],
[
505,
605,
613,
620
],
[
617,
605,
634,
620
],
[
638,
605,
666,
620
],
[
670,
605,
756,
620
],
[
760,
605,
815,
620
],
[
818,
605,
830,
620
],
[
147,
623,
222,
639
],
[
226,
623,
287,
639
],
[
291,
623,
367,
639
],
[
371,
623,
442,
638
],
[
447,
622,
525,
638
],
[
528,
622,
624,
638
],
[
628,
622,
654,
638
],
[
658,
622,
679,
638
],
[
682,
622,
769,
638
],
[
772,
621,
798,
638
],
[
801,
621,
862,
638
],
[
865,
621,
900,
637
],
[
147,
640,
182,
655
],
[
186,
640,
261,
655
],
[
264,
640,
299,
655
],
[
302,
641,
328,
655
],
[
332,
641,
443,
655
],
[
447,
641,
479,
655
],
[
482,
641,
561,
655
],
[
564,
641,
658,
655
],
[
661,
641,
677,
655
],
[
680,
641,
707,
655
],
[
711,
641,
730,
654
],
[
733,
641,
805,
654
],
[
808,
641,
826,
654
],
[
830,
641,
875,
654
],
[
148,
659,
221,
673
],
[
182,
691,
261,
706
],
[
264,
692,
363,
707
],
[
367,
693,
419,
707
],
[
425,
693,
538,
707
],
[
541,
693,
564,
707
],
[
570,
693,
649,
707
],
[
652,
693,
702,
707
],
[
705,
692,
747,
707
],
[
751,
692,
768,
706
],
[
771,
692,
840,
706
],
[
148,
710,
219,
725
],
[
222,
710,
301,
725
],
[
304,
710,
384,
725
],
[
387,
710,
419,
725
],
[
422,
710,
454,
725
],
[
460,
710,
555,
725
],
[
558,
710,
603,
725
],
[
606,
710,
627,
725
],
[
630,
710,
717,
725
],
[
720,
710,
772,
724
],
[
775,
710,
785,
724
],
[
788,
710,
865,
724
],
[
145,
727,
208,
745
],
[
212,
727,
282,
744
],
[
287,
727,
311,
743
],
[
315,
727,
374,
743
],
[
378,
727,
410,
743
],
[
414,
727,
451,
744
],
[
454,
727,
527,
745
],
[
182,
762,
295,
778
],
[
298,
763,
337,
778
],
[
341,
763,
454,
778
],
[
457,
762,
527,
778
],
[
183,
793,
207,
808
],
[
210,
793,
259,
808
],
[
262,
793,
339,
808
],
[
342,
793,
415,
809
],
[
418,
793,
443,
809
],
[
447,
793,
518,
809
],
[
521,
793,
626,
809
],
[
630,
793,
684,
808
],
[
687,
793,
707,
808
],
[
710,
793,
756,
808
],
[
760,
793,
801,
808
],
[
804,
793,
887,
808
],
[
148,
811,
236,
825
],
[
239,
811,
257,
825
],
[
260,
811,
322,
825
],
[
325,
811,
380,
825
],
[
383,
811,
414,
825
],
[
417,
811,
489,
825
],
[
492,
811,
552,
825
],
[
556,
811,
625,
825
],
[
629,
811,
662,
825
],
[
666,
811,
714,
825
],
[
717,
811,
748,
825
],
[
752,
811,
824,
825
],
[
184,
828,
213,
842
],
[
217,
828,
271,
843
],
[
275,
827,
304,
843
],
[
308,
827,
380,
843
],
[
384,
827,
455,
843
],
[
459,
827,
512,
843
],
[
515,
827,
535,
843
],
[
539,
827,
622,
843
],
[
625,
827,
675,
843
],
[
678,
827,
700,
843
],
[
703,
828,
788,
843
],
[
791,
828,
840,
843
],
[
147,
845,
228,
860
],
[
231,
845,
259,
860
],
[
263,
845,
311,
860
],
[
315,
845,
395,
861
],
[
399,
845,
474,
861
],
[
478,
845,
495,
861
],
[
499,
845,
598,
861
],
[
602,
845,
632,
861
],
[
637,
845,
739,
861
],
[
742,
845,
791,
860
],
[
795,
845,
838,
860
],
[
842,
845,
896,
860
],
[
147,
863,
173,
876
],
[
176,
863,
198,
876
],
[
201,
863,
210,
877
],
[
213,
863,
261,
877
],
[
264,
863,
298,
877
],
[
301,
863,
387,
878
],
[
390,
863,
452,
878
],
[
455,
863,
532,
878
],
[
535,
863,
572,
878
],
[
575,
863,
678,
878
],
[
681,
863,
724,
878
],
[
727,
862,
762,
878
],
[
765,
862,
785,
877
],
[
788,
862,
836,
877
],
[
839,
862,
879,
877
],
[
147,
880,
192,
895
],
[
195,
880,
255,
895
],
[
258,
880,
332,
895
],
[
336,
880,
405,
895
],
[
409,
879,
467,
895
],
[
471,
879,
484,
895
],
[
487,
879,
503,
895
],
[
507,
879,
564,
895
],
[
568,
879,
601,
895
],
[
608,
879,
667,
895
],
[
671,
879,
708,
895
],
[
711,
879,
773,
895
],
[
777,
878,
861,
895
],
[
865,
878,
896,
895
],
[
148,
897,
172,
910
],
[
175,
897,
215,
910
],
[
218,
897,
237,
910
],
[
240,
897,
265,
910
],
[
268,
897,
351,
911
],
[
355,
898,
391,
911
],
[
395,
898,
431,
911
],
[
434,
898,
485,
911
],
[
488,
898,
558,
911
],
[
561,
898,
591,
912
],
[
594,
897,
684,
912
],
[
687,
897,
716,
912
],
[
719,
897,
768,
912
],
[
771,
897,
845,
912
],
[
184,
924,
244,
938
],
[
247,
924,
274,
938
],
[
277,
924,
319,
938
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What would have de minimis exposure potential by definition?
|
non-isolated system intermediates
|
735
|
[
"potential",
"child",
"exposure",
"is",
"greater",
"than",
"for",
"a",
"non-child",
"specific",
"product.",
"For",
"example,",
"how",
"does",
"child",
"exposure",
"to",
"a",
"general",
"use",
"cleaner",
"compare",
"to",
"exposure",
"from",
"use",
"in",
"a",
"child's",
"raincoat.",
"In",
"the",
"VCCEP",
"assessments,",
"there",
"are",
"examples",
"for",
"inhalation",
"exposures",
"where",
"estimates",
"of",
"passive",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"adult",
"product",
"use",
"exceeded",
"conservative",
"estimates",
"of",
"child",
"exposure",
"during",
"active",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"child-specific",
"product",
"(such",
"as",
"a",
"hobby",
"product)",
"-",
"differences",
"were",
"related",
"to",
"the",
"amount",
"of",
"product",
"used",
"and",
"substance",
"concentration",
"within",
"the",
"product",
"(MEK",
"VCCEP",
"Submission).",
"the",
"IUR",
"definition",
"targets",
"children",
"age",
"14",
"and",
"younger.",
"Younger",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"non-child",
"specific",
"products",
"that",
"are",
"in",
"general",
"household",
"use.",
"Older",
"children",
"may",
"be",
"exposed",
"to",
"a",
"variety",
"of",
"additional",
"products.",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"request",
"is",
"targeted",
"to",
"manufacturers,",
"which",
"may",
"not",
"have",
"direct",
"knowledge",
"of",
"all",
"uses,",
"particularly",
"the",
"presence",
"in",
"products",
"for",
"specific",
"subpopulations,",
"such",
"as",
"children.",
"Therefore,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"that",
"the",
"information",
"requested",
"for",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"would",
"be",
"consistently",
"available",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"screened.",
"Ideally,",
"this",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"requested",
"from",
"formulators",
"of",
"child-specific",
"products.",
"Therefore,",
"for",
"the",
"initial",
"prioritization",
"approach,",
"which",
"represents",
"a",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"categorization,",
"child",
"specific",
"products",
"are",
"captured",
"under",
"general",
"consumer",
"products",
"and",
"all",
"consumer",
"products",
"are",
"weighted",
"equally.",
"The",
"IUR",
"information",
"on",
"child",
"specific",
"use",
"would",
"be",
"utilized",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"If",
"the",
"IUR",
"information",
"is",
"utilized,",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"that",
"the",
"limitations",
"above",
"be",
"considered",
"in",
"its",
"application.",
"Emissions",
"Data:",
"Production",
"volume,",
"which",
"is",
"readily",
"available",
"for",
"substances,",
"is",
"used",
"in",
"this",
"proposed",
"approach,",
"but",
"only",
"serves",
"as",
"a",
"surrogate",
"for",
"environmental",
"emissions.",
"For",
"further",
"prioritization,",
"data",
"or",
"estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"refine",
"prioritization.",
"Estimates",
"of",
"environmental",
"emissions",
"will",
"be",
"available",
"for",
"some",
"substances",
"(e.g.,",
"TRI",
"data).",
"When",
"TRI",
"data",
"are",
"utilized",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"recognized",
"that",
"it",
"addresses",
"only",
"emissions",
"that",
"result",
"from",
"industrial",
"and",
"not",
"wide",
"dispersive",
"uses.",
"In",
"other",
"cases,",
"emissions",
"estimates",
"can",
"be",
"developed",
"as",
"a",
"percentage",
"of",
"production",
"volume",
"based",
"upon",
"consideration",
"of",
"use",
"categories.",
"Within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping,",
"available",
"emissions",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"considered",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering,",
"with",
"the",
"understanding",
"that",
"emissions",
"information",
"is",
"not",
"an",
"indicator",
"of",
"actual",
"exposure.",
"Similarly,",
"non-isolated",
"system",
"intermediates,",
"by",
"definition,",
"would",
"have",
"de",
"minimis",
"exposure",
"potential.",
"Therefore,",
"this",
"IUR",
"information",
"could",
"be",
"considered",
"within",
"a",
"particular",
"priority",
"grouping",
"for",
"Second",
"Tier",
"rank",
"ordering.",
"International",
"Risk",
"Management",
"Actions:",
"An",
"initial",
"screening",
"approach",
"for",
"chemical",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"consistent",
"application",
"of",
"specific",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"science",
"elements",
"that",
"define",
"risk",
"potential.",
"The",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"elements",
"should",
"be",
"applicable",
"across",
"all",
"substances",
"being",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening,",
"existence",
"of",
"international",
"risk",
"management",
"action",
"plans",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"a",
"factor",
"that",
"determines",
"priority",
"grouping.",
"Risk",
"management",
"plans",
"may",
"be",
"based",
"upon",
"many",
"factors,",
"including",
"political",
"drivers.",
"It",
"is",
"unclear",
"how",
"factors,",
"their",
"relative",
"weighting,",
"and",
"the",
"rigor",
"of",
"the",
"evaluation",
"may",
"vary",
"across",
"agencies",
"and",
"substances.",
"For",
"initial",
"screening",
"August",
"29,",
"2011",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
101,
240,
115
],
[
243,
102,
281,
115
],
[
284,
102,
351,
115
],
[
354,
102,
367,
115
],
[
370,
102,
421,
115
],
[
424,
102,
457,
115
],
[
460,
102,
482,
115
],
[
485,
102,
494,
115
],
[
498,
102,
568,
115
],
[
571,
102,
630,
115
],
[
632,
102,
694,
115
],
[
697,
101,
722,
115
],
[
725,
101,
792,
115
],
[
795,
100,
825,
115
],
[
835,
100,
865,
115
],
[
868,
100,
908,
115
],
[
177,
117,
242,
130
],
[
245,
117,
262,
130
],
[
264,
117,
274,
130
],
[
277,
117,
331,
130
],
[
334,
117,
361,
130
],
[
363,
118,
417,
130
],
[
419,
117,
483,
130
],
[
485,
117,
502,
130
],
[
505,
117,
572,
130
],
[
574,
117,
605,
130
],
[
613,
117,
640,
130
],
[
642,
117,
657,
130
],
[
661,
116,
670,
130
],
[
672,
116,
722,
130
],
[
725,
115,
795,
130
],
[
798,
115,
814,
130
],
[
817,
115,
842,
130
],
[
844,
114,
902,
130
],
[
177,
134,
269,
146
],
[
272,
134,
310,
147
],
[
312,
134,
338,
147
],
[
341,
134,
417,
147
],
[
420,
134,
445,
147
],
[
448,
133,
527,
147
],
[
531,
133,
612,
147
],
[
615,
133,
665,
147
],
[
668,
132,
744,
147
],
[
747,
132,
764,
147
],
[
766,
131,
828,
147
],
[
830,
131,
871,
146
],
[
177,
150,
250,
163
],
[
254,
150,
305,
163
],
[
308,
150,
348,
163
],
[
351,
150,
414,
163
],
[
417,
150,
445,
164
],
[
448,
150,
524,
164
],
[
526,
150,
628,
164
],
[
630,
150,
705,
164
],
[
707,
150,
727,
164
],
[
730,
149,
771,
164
],
[
774,
149,
847,
165
],
[
852,
149,
901,
165
],
[
177,
166,
224,
180
],
[
227,
166,
256,
180
],
[
260,
166,
276,
180
],
[
280,
166,
291,
180
],
[
294,
165,
401,
180
],
[
405,
165,
467,
180
],
[
470,
165,
514,
180
],
[
518,
165,
536,
180
],
[
540,
165,
550,
180
],
[
552,
165,
604,
180
],
[
607,
165,
674,
180
],
[
677,
165,
691,
180
],
[
695,
165,
782,
180
],
[
785,
165,
825,
180
],
[
828,
165,
882,
180
],
[
885,
165,
903,
181
],
[
177,
182,
202,
197
],
[
205,
182,
265,
197
],
[
269,
182,
287,
197
],
[
290,
182,
351,
197
],
[
355,
182,
393,
197
],
[
397,
183,
425,
197
],
[
429,
182,
507,
197
],
[
511,
182,
620,
197
],
[
624,
182,
673,
197
],
[
677,
182,
702,
197
],
[
705,
182,
768,
197
],
[
772,
181,
821,
197
],
[
829,
181,
887,
197
],
[
178,
198,
280,
215
],
[
176,
218,
200,
232
],
[
203,
218,
232,
232
],
[
241,
218,
309,
232
],
[
312,
218,
361,
232
],
[
364,
218,
425,
232
],
[
428,
218,
455,
232
],
[
458,
218,
478,
232
],
[
481,
218,
508,
232
],
[
511,
218,
578,
232
],
[
581,
218,
644,
232
],
[
647,
218,
706,
232
],
[
709,
218,
741,
232
],
[
744,
218,
764,
232
],
[
766,
218,
826,
232
],
[
828,
218,
846,
232
],
[
848,
218,
860,
232
],
[
177,
235,
227,
248
],
[
231,
235,
247,
248
],
[
250,
235,
320,
248
],
[
323,
235,
380,
248
],
[
383,
235,
447,
248
],
[
450,
235,
479,
248
],
[
482,
235,
505,
248
],
[
508,
235,
524,
248
],
[
527,
235,
581,
248
],
[
584,
235,
660,
248
],
[
663,
234,
694,
248
],
[
697,
234,
738,
248
],
[
741,
234,
801,
248
],
[
804,
234,
836,
248
],
[
839,
234,
858,
248
],
[
178,
251,
237,
264
],
[
240,
251,
256,
264
],
[
259,
251,
268,
264
],
[
271,
250,
322,
264
],
[
325,
250,
342,
264
],
[
345,
250,
417,
264
],
[
420,
251,
491,
264
],
[
176,
267,
198,
282
],
[
202,
267,
234,
282
],
[
238,
268,
324,
283
],
[
327,
268,
380,
283
],
[
384,
269,
397,
283
],
[
400,
269,
459,
283
],
[
463,
269,
477,
283
],
[
481,
269,
591,
283
],
[
594,
269,
638,
283
],
[
641,
269,
672,
283
],
[
677,
269,
700,
283
],
[
704,
268,
742,
283
],
[
745,
268,
784,
283
],
[
787,
267,
868,
282
],
[
872,
266,
891,
282
],
[
178,
284,
195,
299
],
[
198,
284,
235,
299
],
[
238,
284,
322,
299
],
[
325,
285,
349,
299
],
[
352,
285,
417,
299
],
[
420,
285,
435,
298
],
[
438,
285,
502,
298
],
[
506,
285,
528,
298
],
[
531,
284,
588,
298
],
[
592,
284,
705,
298
],
[
709,
284,
743,
298
],
[
747,
284,
762,
298
],
[
766,
284,
834,
298
],
[
179,
299,
252,
313
],
[
255,
300,
267,
314
],
[
271,
300,
283,
314
],
[
287,
300,
311,
314
],
[
314,
300,
351,
314
],
[
354,
300,
382,
314
],
[
385,
300,
409,
314
],
[
412,
300,
498,
314
],
[
501,
300,
572,
314
],
[
575,
300,
597,
314
],
[
600,
300,
624,
314
],
[
627,
300,
658,
313
],
[
662,
300,
750,
313
],
[
752,
300,
798,
313
],
[
801,
300,
823,
313
],
[
178,
315,
262,
330
],
[
266,
315,
332,
330
],
[
335,
315,
382,
330
],
[
385,
315,
404,
330
],
[
408,
315,
485,
330
],
[
489,
315,
530,
330
],
[
534,
315,
602,
330
],
[
605,
315,
661,
330
],
[
665,
315,
691,
330
],
[
694,
315,
781,
330
],
[
785,
315,
833,
330
],
[
837,
315,
857,
330
],
[
176,
332,
247,
346
],
[
250,
332,
282,
346
],
[
289,
332,
374,
345
],
[
377,
332,
394,
345
],
[
397,
332,
496,
346
],
[
499,
332,
564,
347
],
[
183,
360,
265,
377
],
[
270,
361,
293,
377
],
[
297,
361,
321,
377
],
[
325,
361,
372,
377
],
[
376,
362,
480,
377
],
[
484,
362,
563,
377
],
[
567,
362,
614,
377
],
[
618,
362,
700,
377
],
[
704,
362,
712,
376
],
[
716,
361,
767,
376
],
[
771,
360,
850,
376
],
[
147,
379,
265,
393
],
[
268,
380,
308,
394
],
[
311,
380,
374,
394
],
[
377,
380,
447,
394
],
[
450,
380,
476,
394
],
[
479,
380,
550,
394
],
[
552,
380,
599,
394
],
[
602,
380,
661,
394
],
[
664,
379,
742,
394
],
[
745,
379,
815,
394
],
[
818,
379,
849,
393
],
[
852,
379,
873,
393
],
[
147,
396,
224,
411
],
[
227,
396,
297,
411
],
[
300,
396,
327,
411
],
[
330,
395,
403,
411
],
[
407,
395,
473,
411
],
[
476,
395,
507,
411
],
[
510,
395,
541,
411
],
[
548,
395,
642,
411
],
[
645,
395,
666,
411
],
[
671,
395,
711,
411
],
[
715,
395,
776,
411
],
[
780,
395,
808,
410
],
[
812,
395,
861,
410
],
[
864,
395,
886,
410
],
[
148,
413,
208,
428
],
[
212,
414,
262,
429
],
[
266,
414,
275,
429
],
[
279,
414,
355,
430
],
[
359,
414,
420,
430
],
[
424,
414,
496,
430
],
[
500,
413,
524,
430
],
[
528,
413,
588,
430
],
[
591,
413,
624,
430
],
[
628,
413,
664,
430
],
[
667,
412,
740,
429
],
[
744,
412,
758,
428
],
[
761,
412,
787,
428
],
[
790,
412,
822,
428
],
[
146,
431,
241,
446
],
[
244,
432,
260,
446
],
[
262,
432,
328,
446
],
[
331,
432,
343,
446
],
[
346,
432,
361,
446
],
[
364,
432,
442,
446
],
[
445,
432,
477,
447
],
[
480,
432,
507,
447
],
[
509,
431,
596,
447
],
[
599,
431,
647,
447
],
[
649,
431,
671,
447
],
[
673,
431,
761,
447
],
[
763,
431,
780,
446
],
[
782,
431,
805,
446
],
[
807,
430,
903,
446
],
[
182,
469,
268,
485
],
[
272,
470,
321,
485
],
[
181,
500,
270,
515
],
[
274,
500,
339,
515
],
[
342,
500,
391,
515
],
[
394,
500,
408,
515
],
[
412,
500,
468,
516
],
[
472,
500,
545,
516
],
[
548,
500,
572,
516
],
[
575,
500,
665,
516
],
[
668,
500,
684,
516
],
[
687,
500,
724,
516
],
[
727,
500,
744,
516
],
[
747,
500,
778,
516
],
[
781,
500,
857,
516
],
[
147,
519,
225,
534
],
[
228,
519,
255,
534
],
[
259,
519,
295,
534
],
[
298,
519,
349,
534
],
[
352,
519,
370,
534
],
[
373,
519,
384,
534
],
[
388,
519,
462,
534
],
[
465,
519,
490,
534
],
[
494,
519,
608,
534
],
[
611,
518,
695,
534
],
[
699,
518,
727,
534
],
[
731,
518,
785,
534
],
[
788,
517,
898,
534
],
[
151,
536,
181,
550
],
[
184,
536,
202,
550
],
[
205,
536,
281,
550
],
[
284,
537,
302,
550
],
[
305,
537,
420,
551
],
[
423,
537,
503,
551
],
[
506,
537,
535,
551
],
[
537,
537,
558,
551
],
[
561,
537,
599,
551
],
[
602,
537,
619,
551
],
[
621,
537,
670,
551
],
[
672,
536,
782,
551
],
[
785,
535,
864,
550
],
[
866,
535,
888,
550
],
[
148,
553,
261,
568
],
[
265,
553,
344,
568
],
[
347,
553,
378,
568
],
[
381,
553,
403,
568
],
[
406,
553,
478,
568
],
[
481,
553,
507,
568
],
[
510,
553,
553,
568
],
[
556,
553,
642,
568
],
[
645,
553,
688,
568
],
[
691,
553,
725,
568
],
[
728,
553,
774,
568
],
[
776,
553,
825,
568
],
[
828,
553,
864,
568
],
[
866,
553,
899,
568
],
[
148,
570,
171,
585
],
[
175,
570,
235,
585
],
[
238,
570,
251,
586
],
[
255,
570,
307,
586
],
[
311,
570,
331,
586
],
[
335,
570,
422,
586
],
[
425,
570,
457,
586
],
[
461,
570,
474,
586
],
[
477,
570,
553,
586
],
[
557,
570,
594,
586
],
[
597,
570,
675,
586
],
[
678,
570,
709,
586
],
[
712,
570,
758,
586
],
[
762,
570,
797,
586
],
[
804,
570,
878,
586
],
[
147,
588,
177,
602
],
[
180,
588,
207,
602
],
[
210,
588,
252,
602
],
[
257,
588,
334,
603
],
[
337,
588,
378,
603
],
[
382,
588,
399,
603
],
[
402,
588,
445,
603
],
[
448,
589,
495,
603
],
[
499,
589,
578,
603
],
[
582,
589,
657,
603
],
[
660,
589,
687,
603
],
[
691,
588,
714,
603
],
[
718,
588,
797,
603
],
[
801,
588,
819,
603
],
[
822,
588,
830,
603
],
[
147,
606,
233,
621
],
[
237,
605,
253,
620
],
[
257,
605,
344,
620
],
[
348,
605,
407,
620
],
[
411,
605,
457,
620
],
[
461,
605,
502,
620
],
[
505,
605,
613,
620
],
[
617,
605,
634,
620
],
[
638,
605,
666,
620
],
[
670,
605,
756,
620
],
[
760,
605,
815,
620
],
[
818,
605,
830,
620
],
[
147,
623,
222,
639
],
[
226,
623,
287,
639
],
[
291,
623,
367,
639
],
[
371,
623,
442,
638
],
[
447,
622,
525,
638
],
[
528,
622,
624,
638
],
[
628,
622,
654,
638
],
[
658,
622,
679,
638
],
[
682,
622,
769,
638
],
[
772,
621,
798,
638
],
[
801,
621,
862,
638
],
[
865,
621,
900,
637
],
[
147,
640,
182,
655
],
[
186,
640,
261,
655
],
[
264,
640,
299,
655
],
[
302,
641,
328,
655
],
[
332,
641,
443,
655
],
[
447,
641,
479,
655
],
[
482,
641,
561,
655
],
[
564,
641,
658,
655
],
[
661,
641,
677,
655
],
[
680,
641,
707,
655
],
[
711,
641,
730,
654
],
[
733,
641,
805,
654
],
[
808,
641,
826,
654
],
[
830,
641,
875,
654
],
[
148,
659,
221,
673
],
[
182,
691,
261,
706
],
[
264,
692,
363,
707
],
[
367,
693,
419,
707
],
[
425,
693,
538,
707
],
[
541,
693,
564,
707
],
[
570,
693,
649,
707
],
[
652,
693,
702,
707
],
[
705,
692,
747,
707
],
[
751,
692,
768,
706
],
[
771,
692,
840,
706
],
[
148,
710,
219,
725
],
[
222,
710,
301,
725
],
[
304,
710,
384,
725
],
[
387,
710,
419,
725
],
[
422,
710,
454,
725
],
[
460,
710,
555,
725
],
[
558,
710,
603,
725
],
[
606,
710,
627,
725
],
[
630,
710,
717,
725
],
[
720,
710,
772,
724
],
[
775,
710,
785,
724
],
[
788,
710,
865,
724
],
[
145,
727,
208,
745
],
[
212,
727,
282,
744
],
[
287,
727,
311,
743
],
[
315,
727,
374,
743
],
[
378,
727,
410,
743
],
[
414,
727,
451,
744
],
[
454,
727,
527,
745
],
[
182,
762,
295,
778
],
[
298,
763,
337,
778
],
[
341,
763,
454,
778
],
[
457,
762,
527,
778
],
[
183,
793,
207,
808
],
[
210,
793,
259,
808
],
[
262,
793,
339,
808
],
[
342,
793,
415,
809
],
[
418,
793,
443,
809
],
[
447,
793,
518,
809
],
[
521,
793,
626,
809
],
[
630,
793,
684,
808
],
[
687,
793,
707,
808
],
[
710,
793,
756,
808
],
[
760,
793,
801,
808
],
[
804,
793,
887,
808
],
[
148,
811,
236,
825
],
[
239,
811,
257,
825
],
[
260,
811,
322,
825
],
[
325,
811,
380,
825
],
[
383,
811,
414,
825
],
[
417,
811,
489,
825
],
[
492,
811,
552,
825
],
[
556,
811,
625,
825
],
[
629,
811,
662,
825
],
[
666,
811,
714,
825
],
[
717,
811,
748,
825
],
[
752,
811,
824,
825
],
[
184,
828,
213,
842
],
[
217,
828,
271,
843
],
[
275,
827,
304,
843
],
[
308,
827,
380,
843
],
[
384,
827,
455,
843
],
[
459,
827,
512,
843
],
[
515,
827,
535,
843
],
[
539,
827,
622,
843
],
[
625,
827,
675,
843
],
[
678,
827,
700,
843
],
[
703,
828,
788,
843
],
[
791,
828,
840,
843
],
[
147,
845,
228,
860
],
[
231,
845,
259,
860
],
[
263,
845,
311,
860
],
[
315,
845,
395,
861
],
[
399,
845,
474,
861
],
[
478,
845,
495,
861
],
[
499,
845,
598,
861
],
[
602,
845,
632,
861
],
[
637,
845,
739,
861
],
[
742,
845,
791,
860
],
[
795,
845,
838,
860
],
[
842,
845,
896,
860
],
[
147,
863,
173,
876
],
[
176,
863,
198,
876
],
[
201,
863,
210,
877
],
[
213,
863,
261,
877
],
[
264,
863,
298,
877
],
[
301,
863,
387,
878
],
[
390,
863,
452,
878
],
[
455,
863,
532,
878
],
[
535,
863,
572,
878
],
[
575,
863,
678,
878
],
[
681,
863,
724,
878
],
[
727,
862,
762,
878
],
[
765,
862,
785,
877
],
[
788,
862,
836,
877
],
[
839,
862,
879,
877
],
[
147,
880,
192,
895
],
[
195,
880,
255,
895
],
[
258,
880,
332,
895
],
[
336,
880,
405,
895
],
[
409,
879,
467,
895
],
[
471,
879,
484,
895
],
[
487,
879,
503,
895
],
[
507,
879,
564,
895
],
[
568,
879,
601,
895
],
[
608,
879,
667,
895
],
[
671,
879,
708,
895
],
[
711,
879,
773,
895
],
[
777,
878,
861,
895
],
[
865,
878,
896,
895
],
[
148,
897,
172,
910
],
[
175,
897,
215,
910
],
[
218,
897,
237,
910
],
[
240,
897,
265,
910
],
[
268,
897,
351,
911
],
[
355,
898,
391,
911
],
[
395,
898,
431,
911
],
[
434,
898,
485,
911
],
[
488,
898,
558,
911
],
[
561,
898,
591,
912
],
[
594,
897,
684,
912
],
[
687,
897,
716,
912
],
[
719,
897,
768,
912
],
[
771,
897,
845,
912
],
[
184,
924,
244,
938
],
[
247,
924,
274,
938
],
[
277,
924,
319,
938
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
On what basis, an initial screening approach for chemical prioritization is done?
|
based upon consistent application of specific hazard and exposure science elements that define risk potential
|
736
|
[
"protects",
"administrative",
"agency",
"authority",
"and",
"promotes",
"judicial",
"efficiency.",
"But",
"here,",
"by",
"requiring",
"inclusion",
"of",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"scopes,",
"the",
"agency",
"impairs",
"the",
"ability",
"of",
"industry",
"to",
"meaningfully",
"comment",
"in",
"the",
"limited",
"time",
"available.",
"EPA",
"seems",
"to",
"be",
"of",
"the",
"view",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"rather",
"include",
"\"too",
"much\"",
"in",
"a",
"scope",
"than",
"inadvertently",
"omit",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"and",
"include",
"\"too",
"little,\"",
"but",
"it",
"is",
"the",
"overly",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"scope",
"that",
"expands",
"the",
"scale",
"and",
"cost",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"and",
"slows",
"them.",
"EPA",
"then",
"ties",
"its",
"own",
"hands",
"by",
"proposing",
"to",
"\"lock",
"down\"",
"overly",
"broad",
"scopes,",
"impeding",
"its",
"ability",
"to",
"update",
"or",
"modify",
"them",
"later",
"in",
"the",
"process.",
"This",
"does",
"not",
"advance",
"efficiency",
"or",
"transparency",
"in",
"the",
"regulatory",
"process.",
"EPA",
"can",
"avoid",
"these",
"inefficiencies",
"by",
"offering",
"a",
"simple",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"those",
"major,",
"important",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"most",
"relevant",
"and",
"meaningful",
"to",
"a",
"high-quality",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"-",
"and",
"to",
"use",
"flexibility",
"in",
"designing",
"the",
"scope",
"accordingly.",
"EPA",
"should",
"offer",
"a",
"rationale",
"of",
"why",
"it",
"selected",
"the",
"uses",
"it",
"did",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"itself.",
"II.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Describe",
"How",
"and",
"When",
"it",
"Will",
"Apply",
"Section",
"26",
"Requirements",
"to",
"Risk",
"Evaluations.",
"Section",
"26(h)",
"sets",
"out",
"scientific",
"standards",
"that",
"apply",
"to",
"every",
"\"decision",
"based",
"on",
"science\"",
"while",
"EPA",
"carries",
"out",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"Section",
"6",
"[emphasis",
"added].",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"'make",
"decisions\"",
"under",
"Section",
"6",
"based",
"on",
"the",
"weight",
"of",
"the",
"scientific",
"evidence",
"[emphasis",
"added].",
"A",
"decision",
"would",
"include",
"any",
"judicially",
"reviewable",
"determination,",
"but",
"also",
"any",
"other",
"decision",
"that",
"requires",
"application",
"of",
"science",
"or",
"scientific",
"judgment",
"by",
"the",
"Agency.",
"EPA",
"should",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"rule,",
"at",
"a",
"minimum,",
"the",
"key",
"decision",
"points",
"that",
"will",
"require",
"compliance",
"with",
"Section",
"26",
"requirements.",
"These",
"should",
"include,",
"but",
"are",
"not",
"limited",
"to:",
"The",
"proposed",
"scope",
"and",
"final",
"scope",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"Hazard",
"assessment,",
"including,",
"where",
"applicable,",
"the",
"likely",
"operable",
"mode",
"of",
"action",
"Exposure",
"assessment",
"Selection",
"and",
"evaluation",
"of",
"technical",
"procedures,",
"measures,",
"methods,",
"protocols,",
"methodologies,",
"and",
"models",
"Basis",
"for",
"scientific",
"assumptions",
"Selection",
"and",
"evaluation",
"of",
"quality",
"assurance",
"procedures",
"Decisions",
"regarding",
"variability",
"and",
"uncertainty",
"Statistical",
"methods",
"The",
"draft",
"and",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"EPA",
"should",
"document",
"how",
"it",
"applied",
"Section",
"26(h)",
"and",
"26(i)",
"requirements",
"for",
"each",
"decision.",
"\"The",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"advance",
"judicial",
"economy",
"either.",
"Determinations",
"of",
"no",
"unreasonable",
"risk,",
"made",
"by",
"the",
"Agency",
"following",
"the",
"completion",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"process,",
"are",
"judicially",
"reviewable",
"-",
"but",
"as",
"a",
"practical",
"matter",
"this",
"means",
"that",
"a",
"judicial",
"challenge",
"to",
"such",
"a",
"determination",
"would",
"be",
"unlikely",
"to",
"occur",
"until",
"years",
"after",
"the",
"scope",
"was",
"published",
"(and",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"completed).",
"Changes",
"to",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"or",
"errors",
"in",
"their",
"identification",
"and",
"inclusion,",
"may",
"not",
"all",
"be",
"evident",
"at",
"the",
"time",
"the",
"scope",
"is",
"originally",
"prepared",
"and",
"published,",
"so",
"applying",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"at",
"this",
"step",
"makes",
"little",
"sense.",
"12/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
181,
110
],
[
184,
94,
298,
110
],
[
301,
94,
358,
110
],
[
362,
93,
434,
110
],
[
437,
93,
465,
110
],
[
470,
93,
545,
110
],
[
549,
93,
610,
110
],
[
614,
92,
705,
110
],
[
720,
92,
748,
110
],
[
752,
92,
791,
110
],
[
795,
92,
820,
110
],
[
117,
110,
189,
127
],
[
193,
111,
267,
127
],
[
271,
111,
287,
127
],
[
291,
111,
322,
127
],
[
326,
111,
408,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
433,
111,
468,
127
],
[
472,
111,
490,
127
],
[
493,
111,
551,
127
],
[
555,
111,
580,
127
],
[
584,
111,
640,
127
],
[
644,
111,
705,
127
],
[
708,
110,
734,
127
],
[
737,
110,
788,
127
],
[
792,
110,
810,
127
],
[
812,
110,
881,
127
],
[
117,
130,
134,
143
],
[
138,
129,
244,
144
],
[
247,
129,
321,
144
],
[
324,
129,
341,
144
],
[
344,
129,
370,
144
],
[
373,
129,
431,
144
],
[
434,
129,
471,
144
],
[
474,
128,
557,
144
],
[
560,
128,
595,
144
],
[
602,
128,
651,
144
],
[
655,
128,
671,
144
],
[
674,
128,
694,
144
],
[
698,
128,
716,
143
],
[
720,
128,
745,
143
],
[
749,
128,
784,
143
],
[
791,
129,
822,
143
],
[
825,
129,
835,
143
],
[
118,
145,
167,
160
],
[
171,
145,
218,
160
],
[
221,
145,
281,
160
],
[
284,
146,
320,
161
],
[
324,
146,
377,
161
],
[
380,
146,
398,
161
],
[
401,
146,
411,
161
],
[
415,
146,
461,
161
],
[
464,
146,
500,
161
],
[
504,
146,
608,
161
],
[
612,
146,
649,
161
],
[
652,
146,
663,
161
],
[
666,
146,
742,
161
],
[
745,
146,
762,
161
],
[
766,
146,
795,
160
],
[
798,
146,
828,
160
],
[
117,
162,
176,
178
],
[
180,
162,
214,
179
],
[
218,
163,
269,
179
],
[
273,
163,
299,
179
],
[
303,
163,
315,
179
],
[
320,
163,
333,
179
],
[
337,
163,
362,
179
],
[
366,
163,
417,
179
],
[
421,
164,
471,
179
],
[
475,
164,
552,
179
],
[
556,
164,
601,
179
],
[
605,
164,
637,
179
],
[
641,
164,
705,
179
],
[
709,
163,
735,
179
],
[
739,
163,
778,
179
],
[
782,
163,
811,
179
],
[
815,
163,
848,
179
],
[
852,
163,
871,
179
],
[
117,
181,
148,
195
],
[
152,
181,
243,
196
],
[
246,
181,
276,
196
],
[
280,
181,
325,
196
],
[
328,
181,
380,
196
],
[
384,
181,
420,
196
],
[
425,
181,
461,
196
],
[
464,
181,
493,
196
],
[
496,
181,
517,
196
],
[
520,
181,
555,
196
],
[
558,
181,
605,
196
],
[
608,
181,
629,
196
],
[
632,
180,
714,
196
],
[
717,
180,
733,
196
],
[
737,
180,
782,
196
],
[
788,
180,
840,
195
],
[
119,
198,
167,
214
],
[
171,
198,
218,
214
],
[
221,
198,
280,
214
],
[
284,
198,
359,
214
],
[
363,
198,
382,
214
],
[
386,
198,
437,
214
],
[
441,
198,
458,
214
],
[
461,
198,
516,
214
],
[
520,
198,
537,
214
],
[
541,
198,
598,
214
],
[
601,
198,
639,
214
],
[
645,
198,
682,
214
],
[
686,
198,
703,
214
],
[
707,
198,
731,
214
],
[
735,
198,
807,
214
],
[
810,
197,
844,
213
],
[
120,
216,
154,
230
],
[
157,
216,
185,
230
],
[
188,
216,
254,
230
],
[
257,
216,
337,
231
],
[
340,
216,
358,
231
],
[
361,
216,
462,
231
],
[
466,
216,
484,
231
],
[
488,
216,
512,
231
],
[
516,
216,
598,
232
],
[
601,
217,
662,
232
],
[
117,
250,
153,
264
],
[
160,
250,
189,
265
],
[
192,
250,
236,
265
],
[
239,
250,
281,
265
],
[
284,
250,
392,
266
],
[
395,
250,
418,
266
],
[
421,
250,
485,
266
],
[
488,
250,
500,
266
],
[
502,
250,
556,
266
],
[
559,
250,
620,
266
],
[
623,
250,
640,
266
],
[
643,
250,
706,
266
],
[
710,
250,
752,
266
],
[
755,
250,
808,
265
],
[
117,
269,
195,
283
],
[
198,
269,
282,
283
],
[
286,
269,
304,
283
],
[
307,
269,
335,
283
],
[
338,
268,
369,
284
],
[
372,
268,
397,
284
],
[
400,
268,
441,
284
],
[
444,
268,
510,
284
],
[
513,
268,
542,
284
],
[
545,
268,
637,
284
],
[
640,
268,
657,
284
],
[
661,
268,
670,
284
],
[
674,
267,
771,
284
],
[
775,
267,
804,
283
],
[
118,
286,
201,
300
],
[
204,
286,
215,
300
],
[
218,
286,
249,
300
],
[
252,
286,
269,
300
],
[
272,
286,
300,
300
],
[
303,
287,
382,
301
],
[
385,
287,
402,
301
],
[
408,
286,
484,
301
],
[
487,
286,
514,
301
],
[
517,
286,
563,
301
],
[
566,
285,
670,
300
],
[
673,
285,
708,
300
],
[
715,
285,
770,
300
],
[
773,
284,
812,
300
],
[
815,
284,
824,
299
],
[
117,
303,
188,
318
],
[
191,
303,
210,
318
],
[
213,
303,
247,
318
],
[
251,
303,
264,
318
],
[
267,
303,
331,
318
],
[
334,
303,
360,
318
],
[
363,
303,
398,
318
],
[
402,
303,
418,
318
],
[
421,
303,
444,
318
],
[
447,
303,
464,
318
],
[
468,
303,
494,
318
],
[
497,
303,
544,
318
],
[
547,
303,
594,
318
],
[
127,
335,
150,
350
],
[
177,
337,
215,
352
],
[
220,
337,
265,
352
],
[
268,
337,
343,
353
],
[
347,
338,
385,
353
],
[
392,
338,
426,
353
],
[
430,
338,
479,
354
],
[
482,
338,
498,
354
],
[
502,
338,
538,
354
],
[
541,
338,
594,
354
],
[
597,
338,
658,
353
],
[
662,
338,
684,
353
],
[
687,
337,
807,
353
],
[
809,
337,
827,
352
],
[
830,
337,
870,
352
],
[
179,
355,
287,
370
],
[
118,
390,
178,
404
],
[
181,
390,
227,
405
],
[
229,
390,
260,
405
],
[
262,
390,
290,
405
],
[
293,
391,
367,
405
],
[
370,
391,
446,
405
],
[
449,
391,
480,
405
],
[
483,
391,
528,
405
],
[
531,
391,
548,
405
],
[
551,
391,
597,
405
],
[
600,
390,
676,
405
],
[
679,
390,
727,
405
],
[
730,
390,
752,
405
],
[
755,
390,
822,
405
],
[
825,
390,
867,
405
],
[
118,
407,
154,
421
],
[
160,
407,
213,
421
],
[
216,
407,
243,
421
],
[
246,
407,
278,
422
],
[
281,
407,
364,
422
],
[
367,
407,
415,
422
],
[
418,
408,
478,
422
],
[
481,
408,
492,
422
],
[
494,
408,
578,
422
],
[
581,
407,
647,
422
],
[
649,
407,
710,
422
],
[
712,
407,
752,
422
],
[
755,
407,
822,
422
],
[
824,
407,
860,
422
],
[
865,
407,
884,
422
],
[
121,
424,
172,
440
],
[
176,
424,
257,
440
],
[
260,
424,
307,
440
],
[
310,
424,
370,
440
],
[
373,
424,
384,
440
],
[
388,
424,
434,
440
],
[
438,
424,
458,
440
],
[
461,
424,
488,
440
],
[
492,
424,
546,
440
],
[
550,
424,
567,
440
],
[
571,
424,
596,
440
],
[
600,
424,
672,
440
],
[
676,
424,
747,
440
],
[
751,
424,
830,
440
],
[
117,
441,
183,
457
],
[
187,
442,
200,
457
],
[
207,
442,
272,
457
],
[
275,
442,
324,
458
],
[
328,
442,
387,
458
],
[
391,
442,
420,
458
],
[
423,
442,
500,
458
],
[
503,
442,
595,
458
],
[
598,
442,
709,
458
],
[
713,
442,
740,
457
],
[
744,
442,
777,
457
],
[
781,
442,
810,
457
],
[
813,
441,
857,
457
],
[
120,
460,
184,
474
],
[
188,
460,
218,
474
],
[
221,
460,
287,
474
],
[
290,
460,
380,
475
],
[
383,
460,
400,
475
],
[
403,
460,
462,
475
],
[
466,
460,
484,
475
],
[
488,
460,
560,
475
],
[
564,
460,
640,
475
],
[
643,
460,
664,
475
],
[
667,
460,
695,
475
],
[
698,
460,
766,
475
],
[
118,
493,
156,
509
],
[
160,
493,
213,
510
],
[
217,
494,
291,
510
],
[
295,
494,
313,
510
],
[
317,
495,
342,
510
],
[
346,
495,
377,
510
],
[
381,
495,
464,
510
],
[
467,
495,
506,
510
],
[
510,
495,
527,
510
],
[
530,
495,
539,
510
],
[
542,
495,
626,
510
],
[
630,
495,
655,
510
],
[
658,
495,
692,
510
],
[
695,
495,
760,
510
],
[
764,
494,
814,
510
],
[
817,
494,
849,
509
],
[
852,
493,
886,
509
],
[
116,
513,
175,
526
],
[
178,
513,
271,
527
],
[
274,
513,
310,
527
],
[
314,
513,
373,
527
],
[
377,
513,
397,
527
],
[
400,
513,
516,
527
],
[
521,
513,
568,
527
],
[
571,
513,
625,
527
],
[
628,
513,
692,
527
],
[
695,
513,
724,
527
],
[
726,
513,
751,
526
],
[
753,
513,
782,
526
],
[
784,
513,
842,
526
],
[
844,
513,
866,
526
],
[
232,
548,
262,
562
],
[
265,
547,
340,
562
],
[
343,
547,
389,
563
],
[
392,
547,
422,
563
],
[
425,
547,
463,
563
],
[
467,
547,
514,
563
],
[
517,
547,
540,
563
],
[
543,
547,
575,
563
],
[
578,
547,
662,
563
],
[
230,
565,
289,
579
],
[
297,
565,
396,
579
],
[
400,
565,
486,
580
],
[
491,
565,
540,
580
],
[
548,
564,
641,
580
],
[
644,
564,
672,
580
],
[
678,
564,
726,
580
],
[
734,
563,
805,
580
],
[
812,
562,
860,
580
],
[
866,
562,
886,
579
],
[
230,
582,
280,
595
],
[
230,
599,
307,
614
],
[
310,
601,
397,
614
],
[
231,
617,
305,
631
],
[
312,
617,
342,
631
],
[
347,
617,
431,
631
],
[
438,
618,
458,
631
],
[
461,
618,
538,
632
],
[
541,
618,
636,
632
],
[
638,
618,
722,
631
],
[
725,
617,
802,
631
],
[
804,
617,
885,
631
],
[
232,
634,
352,
649
],
[
355,
634,
385,
649
],
[
387,
634,
451,
649
],
[
232,
651,
274,
666
],
[
278,
651,
301,
666
],
[
305,
651,
379,
667
],
[
382,
652,
483,
667
],
[
230,
668,
305,
684
],
[
308,
669,
338,
684
],
[
341,
669,
425,
684
],
[
428,
670,
445,
684
],
[
449,
670,
505,
684
],
[
509,
670,
585,
684
],
[
588,
669,
680,
684
],
[
231,
685,
309,
702
],
[
312,
686,
390,
702
],
[
393,
686,
475,
702
],
[
478,
686,
508,
702
],
[
511,
685,
599,
702
],
[
231,
703,
308,
719
],
[
312,
703,
381,
719
],
[
232,
720,
264,
735
],
[
268,
721,
305,
735
],
[
307,
721,
337,
736
],
[
340,
721,
378,
736
],
[
380,
721,
413,
736
],
[
415,
721,
501,
736
],
[
118,
755,
155,
770
],
[
160,
755,
217,
771
],
[
220,
755,
295,
771
],
[
298,
755,
331,
772
],
[
337,
755,
350,
772
],
[
354,
755,
412,
772
],
[
416,
755,
477,
772
],
[
480,
755,
524,
772
],
[
527,
756,
557,
772
],
[
560,
755,
600,
772
],
[
603,
755,
707,
772
],
[
710,
755,
734,
771
],
[
738,
755,
778,
771
],
[
782,
755,
852,
770
],
[
118,
823,
158,
836
],
[
161,
823,
195,
837
],
[
198,
823,
268,
837
],
[
272,
824,
333,
837
],
[
337,
824,
364,
837
],
[
367,
824,
389,
837
],
[
392,
824,
445,
837
],
[
449,
824,
500,
837
],
[
504,
824,
564,
837
],
[
567,
824,
610,
837
],
[
612,
824,
714,
837
],
[
717,
824,
731,
837
],
[
734,
824,
752,
837
],
[
754,
823,
841,
837
],
[
844,
823,
876,
837
],
[
118,
839,
154,
852
],
[
157,
839,
173,
852
],
[
177,
839,
198,
852
],
[
201,
839,
253,
852
],
[
256,
840,
321,
852
],
[
324,
840,
344,
852
],
[
348,
840,
422,
852
],
[
425,
840,
440,
852
],
[
442,
840,
464,
852
],
[
467,
840,
493,
852
],
[
496,
840,
564,
852
],
[
567,
840,
622,
852
],
[
625,
840,
646,
852
],
[
649,
839,
711,
852
],
[
714,
839,
789,
852
],
[
792,
839,
801,
852
],
[
804,
839,
826,
852
],
[
829,
839,
843,
852
],
[
846,
839,
857,
852
],
[
117,
854,
175,
867
],
[
178,
854,
220,
867
],
[
223,
854,
248,
867
],
[
251,
854,
292,
867
],
[
296,
854,
322,
867
],
[
326,
854,
332,
867
],
[
336,
854,
387,
867
],
[
390,
854,
453,
867
],
[
456,
854,
471,
867
],
[
474,
853,
505,
867
],
[
508,
853,
518,
867
],
[
521,
853,
611,
867
],
[
614,
853,
655,
867
],
[
658,
853,
675,
867
],
[
678,
853,
732,
867
],
[
735,
853,
750,
867
],
[
753,
853,
790,
867
],
[
792,
853,
824,
867
],
[
827,
853,
862,
867
],
[
118,
868,
149,
881
],
[
151,
868,
174,
881
],
[
175,
868,
215,
881
],
[
217,
868,
242,
881
],
[
245,
868,
311,
881
],
[
313,
868,
344,
880
],
[
346,
868,
367,
880
],
[
369,
868,
397,
880
],
[
399,
868,
470,
880
],
[
471,
868,
552,
880
],
[
554,
868,
611,
880
],
[
613,
868,
628,
880
],
[
630,
868,
701,
880
],
[
702,
868,
718,
880
],
[
720,
868,
748,
880
],
[
750,
868,
766,
880
],
[
767,
868,
807,
880
],
[
809,
868,
824,
880
],
[
826,
868,
858,
880
],
[
117,
883,
205,
895
],
[
208,
883,
233,
896
],
[
236,
883,
301,
896
],
[
304,
883,
332,
896
],
[
335,
884,
360,
896
],
[
362,
884,
379,
896
],
[
381,
884,
398,
896
],
[
401,
884,
451,
896
],
[
454,
884,
467,
896
],
[
470,
884,
491,
896
],
[
493,
883,
524,
896
],
[
527,
883,
549,
896
],
[
551,
883,
589,
896
],
[
591,
883,
605,
896
],
[
608,
883,
672,
896
],
[
674,
883,
734,
896
],
[
736,
883,
761,
896
],
[
764,
882,
833,
896
],
[
835,
882,
852,
895
],
[
118,
898,
175,
911
],
[
178,
897,
212,
910
],
[
215,
897,
287,
910
],
[
291,
897,
303,
910
],
[
306,
897,
331,
910
],
[
334,
897,
360,
910
],
[
363,
897,
406,
910
],
[
409,
897,
441,
910
],
[
444,
897,
482,
910
],
[
821,
940,
883,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What does Section 26(h) set out?
|
scientific standards that apply to every "decision based on science"
|
736
|
[
"protects",
"administrative",
"agency",
"authority",
"and",
"promotes",
"judicial",
"efficiency.",
"But",
"here,",
"by",
"requiring",
"inclusion",
"of",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"scopes,",
"the",
"agency",
"impairs",
"the",
"ability",
"of",
"industry",
"to",
"meaningfully",
"comment",
"in",
"the",
"limited",
"time",
"available.",
"EPA",
"seems",
"to",
"be",
"of",
"the",
"view",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"rather",
"include",
"\"too",
"much\"",
"in",
"a",
"scope",
"than",
"inadvertently",
"omit",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"and",
"include",
"\"too",
"little,\"",
"but",
"it",
"is",
"the",
"overly",
"broad,",
"unrefined",
"scope",
"that",
"expands",
"the",
"scale",
"and",
"cost",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"and",
"slows",
"them.",
"EPA",
"then",
"ties",
"its",
"own",
"hands",
"by",
"proposing",
"to",
"\"lock",
"down\"",
"overly",
"broad",
"scopes,",
"impeding",
"its",
"ability",
"to",
"update",
"or",
"modify",
"them",
"later",
"in",
"the",
"process.",
"This",
"does",
"not",
"advance",
"efficiency",
"or",
"transparency",
"in",
"the",
"regulatory",
"process.",
"EPA",
"can",
"avoid",
"these",
"inefficiencies",
"by",
"offering",
"a",
"simple",
"process",
"to",
"identify",
"those",
"major,",
"important",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"most",
"relevant",
"and",
"meaningful",
"to",
"a",
"high-quality",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"-",
"and",
"to",
"use",
"flexibility",
"in",
"designing",
"the",
"scope",
"accordingly.",
"EPA",
"should",
"offer",
"a",
"rationale",
"of",
"why",
"it",
"selected",
"the",
"uses",
"it",
"did",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"itself.",
"II.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Describe",
"How",
"and",
"When",
"it",
"Will",
"Apply",
"Section",
"26",
"Requirements",
"to",
"Risk",
"Evaluations.",
"Section",
"26(h)",
"sets",
"out",
"scientific",
"standards",
"that",
"apply",
"to",
"every",
"\"decision",
"based",
"on",
"science\"",
"while",
"EPA",
"carries",
"out",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"Section",
"6",
"[emphasis",
"added].",
"Section",
"26(i)",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"'make",
"decisions\"",
"under",
"Section",
"6",
"based",
"on",
"the",
"weight",
"of",
"the",
"scientific",
"evidence",
"[emphasis",
"added].",
"A",
"decision",
"would",
"include",
"any",
"judicially",
"reviewable",
"determination,",
"but",
"also",
"any",
"other",
"decision",
"that",
"requires",
"application",
"of",
"science",
"or",
"scientific",
"judgment",
"by",
"the",
"Agency.",
"EPA",
"should",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"rule,",
"at",
"a",
"minimum,",
"the",
"key",
"decision",
"points",
"that",
"will",
"require",
"compliance",
"with",
"Section",
"26",
"requirements.",
"These",
"should",
"include,",
"but",
"are",
"not",
"limited",
"to:",
"The",
"proposed",
"scope",
"and",
"final",
"scope",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"Hazard",
"assessment,",
"including,",
"where",
"applicable,",
"the",
"likely",
"operable",
"mode",
"of",
"action",
"Exposure",
"assessment",
"Selection",
"and",
"evaluation",
"of",
"technical",
"procedures,",
"measures,",
"methods,",
"protocols,",
"methodologies,",
"and",
"models",
"Basis",
"for",
"scientific",
"assumptions",
"Selection",
"and",
"evaluation",
"of",
"quality",
"assurance",
"procedures",
"Decisions",
"regarding",
"variability",
"and",
"uncertainty",
"Statistical",
"methods",
"The",
"draft",
"and",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"EPA",
"should",
"document",
"how",
"it",
"applied",
"Section",
"26(h)",
"and",
"26(i)",
"requirements",
"for",
"each",
"decision.",
"\"The",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"advance",
"judicial",
"economy",
"either.",
"Determinations",
"of",
"no",
"unreasonable",
"risk,",
"made",
"by",
"the",
"Agency",
"following",
"the",
"completion",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"process,",
"are",
"judicially",
"reviewable",
"-",
"but",
"as",
"a",
"practical",
"matter",
"this",
"means",
"that",
"a",
"judicial",
"challenge",
"to",
"such",
"a",
"determination",
"would",
"be",
"unlikely",
"to",
"occur",
"until",
"years",
"after",
"the",
"scope",
"was",
"published",
"(and",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"completed).",
"Changes",
"to",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"or",
"errors",
"in",
"their",
"identification",
"and",
"inclusion,",
"may",
"not",
"all",
"be",
"evident",
"at",
"the",
"time",
"the",
"scope",
"is",
"originally",
"prepared",
"and",
"published,",
"so",
"applying",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"at",
"this",
"step",
"makes",
"little",
"sense.",
"12/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
181,
110
],
[
184,
94,
298,
110
],
[
301,
94,
358,
110
],
[
362,
93,
434,
110
],
[
437,
93,
465,
110
],
[
470,
93,
545,
110
],
[
549,
93,
610,
110
],
[
614,
92,
705,
110
],
[
720,
92,
748,
110
],
[
752,
92,
791,
110
],
[
795,
92,
820,
110
],
[
117,
110,
189,
127
],
[
193,
111,
267,
127
],
[
271,
111,
287,
127
],
[
291,
111,
322,
127
],
[
326,
111,
408,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
433,
111,
468,
127
],
[
472,
111,
490,
127
],
[
493,
111,
551,
127
],
[
555,
111,
580,
127
],
[
584,
111,
640,
127
],
[
644,
111,
705,
127
],
[
708,
110,
734,
127
],
[
737,
110,
788,
127
],
[
792,
110,
810,
127
],
[
812,
110,
881,
127
],
[
117,
130,
134,
143
],
[
138,
129,
244,
144
],
[
247,
129,
321,
144
],
[
324,
129,
341,
144
],
[
344,
129,
370,
144
],
[
373,
129,
431,
144
],
[
434,
129,
471,
144
],
[
474,
128,
557,
144
],
[
560,
128,
595,
144
],
[
602,
128,
651,
144
],
[
655,
128,
671,
144
],
[
674,
128,
694,
144
],
[
698,
128,
716,
143
],
[
720,
128,
745,
143
],
[
749,
128,
784,
143
],
[
791,
129,
822,
143
],
[
825,
129,
835,
143
],
[
118,
145,
167,
160
],
[
171,
145,
218,
160
],
[
221,
145,
281,
160
],
[
284,
146,
320,
161
],
[
324,
146,
377,
161
],
[
380,
146,
398,
161
],
[
401,
146,
411,
161
],
[
415,
146,
461,
161
],
[
464,
146,
500,
161
],
[
504,
146,
608,
161
],
[
612,
146,
649,
161
],
[
652,
146,
663,
161
],
[
666,
146,
742,
161
],
[
745,
146,
762,
161
],
[
766,
146,
795,
160
],
[
798,
146,
828,
160
],
[
117,
162,
176,
178
],
[
180,
162,
214,
179
],
[
218,
163,
269,
179
],
[
273,
163,
299,
179
],
[
303,
163,
315,
179
],
[
320,
163,
333,
179
],
[
337,
163,
362,
179
],
[
366,
163,
417,
179
],
[
421,
164,
471,
179
],
[
475,
164,
552,
179
],
[
556,
164,
601,
179
],
[
605,
164,
637,
179
],
[
641,
164,
705,
179
],
[
709,
163,
735,
179
],
[
739,
163,
778,
179
],
[
782,
163,
811,
179
],
[
815,
163,
848,
179
],
[
852,
163,
871,
179
],
[
117,
181,
148,
195
],
[
152,
181,
243,
196
],
[
246,
181,
276,
196
],
[
280,
181,
325,
196
],
[
328,
181,
380,
196
],
[
384,
181,
420,
196
],
[
425,
181,
461,
196
],
[
464,
181,
493,
196
],
[
496,
181,
517,
196
],
[
520,
181,
555,
196
],
[
558,
181,
605,
196
],
[
608,
181,
629,
196
],
[
632,
180,
714,
196
],
[
717,
180,
733,
196
],
[
737,
180,
782,
196
],
[
788,
180,
840,
195
],
[
119,
198,
167,
214
],
[
171,
198,
218,
214
],
[
221,
198,
280,
214
],
[
284,
198,
359,
214
],
[
363,
198,
382,
214
],
[
386,
198,
437,
214
],
[
441,
198,
458,
214
],
[
461,
198,
516,
214
],
[
520,
198,
537,
214
],
[
541,
198,
598,
214
],
[
601,
198,
639,
214
],
[
645,
198,
682,
214
],
[
686,
198,
703,
214
],
[
707,
198,
731,
214
],
[
735,
198,
807,
214
],
[
810,
197,
844,
213
],
[
120,
216,
154,
230
],
[
157,
216,
185,
230
],
[
188,
216,
254,
230
],
[
257,
216,
337,
231
],
[
340,
216,
358,
231
],
[
361,
216,
462,
231
],
[
466,
216,
484,
231
],
[
488,
216,
512,
231
],
[
516,
216,
598,
232
],
[
601,
217,
662,
232
],
[
117,
250,
153,
264
],
[
160,
250,
189,
265
],
[
192,
250,
236,
265
],
[
239,
250,
281,
265
],
[
284,
250,
392,
266
],
[
395,
250,
418,
266
],
[
421,
250,
485,
266
],
[
488,
250,
500,
266
],
[
502,
250,
556,
266
],
[
559,
250,
620,
266
],
[
623,
250,
640,
266
],
[
643,
250,
706,
266
],
[
710,
250,
752,
266
],
[
755,
250,
808,
265
],
[
117,
269,
195,
283
],
[
198,
269,
282,
283
],
[
286,
269,
304,
283
],
[
307,
269,
335,
283
],
[
338,
268,
369,
284
],
[
372,
268,
397,
284
],
[
400,
268,
441,
284
],
[
444,
268,
510,
284
],
[
513,
268,
542,
284
],
[
545,
268,
637,
284
],
[
640,
268,
657,
284
],
[
661,
268,
670,
284
],
[
674,
267,
771,
284
],
[
775,
267,
804,
283
],
[
118,
286,
201,
300
],
[
204,
286,
215,
300
],
[
218,
286,
249,
300
],
[
252,
286,
269,
300
],
[
272,
286,
300,
300
],
[
303,
287,
382,
301
],
[
385,
287,
402,
301
],
[
408,
286,
484,
301
],
[
487,
286,
514,
301
],
[
517,
286,
563,
301
],
[
566,
285,
670,
300
],
[
673,
285,
708,
300
],
[
715,
285,
770,
300
],
[
773,
284,
812,
300
],
[
815,
284,
824,
299
],
[
117,
303,
188,
318
],
[
191,
303,
210,
318
],
[
213,
303,
247,
318
],
[
251,
303,
264,
318
],
[
267,
303,
331,
318
],
[
334,
303,
360,
318
],
[
363,
303,
398,
318
],
[
402,
303,
418,
318
],
[
421,
303,
444,
318
],
[
447,
303,
464,
318
],
[
468,
303,
494,
318
],
[
497,
303,
544,
318
],
[
547,
303,
594,
318
],
[
127,
335,
150,
350
],
[
177,
337,
215,
352
],
[
220,
337,
265,
352
],
[
268,
337,
343,
353
],
[
347,
338,
385,
353
],
[
392,
338,
426,
353
],
[
430,
338,
479,
354
],
[
482,
338,
498,
354
],
[
502,
338,
538,
354
],
[
541,
338,
594,
354
],
[
597,
338,
658,
353
],
[
662,
338,
684,
353
],
[
687,
337,
807,
353
],
[
809,
337,
827,
352
],
[
830,
337,
870,
352
],
[
179,
355,
287,
370
],
[
118,
390,
178,
404
],
[
181,
390,
227,
405
],
[
229,
390,
260,
405
],
[
262,
390,
290,
405
],
[
293,
391,
367,
405
],
[
370,
391,
446,
405
],
[
449,
391,
480,
405
],
[
483,
391,
528,
405
],
[
531,
391,
548,
405
],
[
551,
391,
597,
405
],
[
600,
390,
676,
405
],
[
679,
390,
727,
405
],
[
730,
390,
752,
405
],
[
755,
390,
822,
405
],
[
825,
390,
867,
405
],
[
118,
407,
154,
421
],
[
160,
407,
213,
421
],
[
216,
407,
243,
421
],
[
246,
407,
278,
422
],
[
281,
407,
364,
422
],
[
367,
407,
415,
422
],
[
418,
408,
478,
422
],
[
481,
408,
492,
422
],
[
494,
408,
578,
422
],
[
581,
407,
647,
422
],
[
649,
407,
710,
422
],
[
712,
407,
752,
422
],
[
755,
407,
822,
422
],
[
824,
407,
860,
422
],
[
865,
407,
884,
422
],
[
121,
424,
172,
440
],
[
176,
424,
257,
440
],
[
260,
424,
307,
440
],
[
310,
424,
370,
440
],
[
373,
424,
384,
440
],
[
388,
424,
434,
440
],
[
438,
424,
458,
440
],
[
461,
424,
488,
440
],
[
492,
424,
546,
440
],
[
550,
424,
567,
440
],
[
571,
424,
596,
440
],
[
600,
424,
672,
440
],
[
676,
424,
747,
440
],
[
751,
424,
830,
440
],
[
117,
441,
183,
457
],
[
187,
442,
200,
457
],
[
207,
442,
272,
457
],
[
275,
442,
324,
458
],
[
328,
442,
387,
458
],
[
391,
442,
420,
458
],
[
423,
442,
500,
458
],
[
503,
442,
595,
458
],
[
598,
442,
709,
458
],
[
713,
442,
740,
457
],
[
744,
442,
777,
457
],
[
781,
442,
810,
457
],
[
813,
441,
857,
457
],
[
120,
460,
184,
474
],
[
188,
460,
218,
474
],
[
221,
460,
287,
474
],
[
290,
460,
380,
475
],
[
383,
460,
400,
475
],
[
403,
460,
462,
475
],
[
466,
460,
484,
475
],
[
488,
460,
560,
475
],
[
564,
460,
640,
475
],
[
643,
460,
664,
475
],
[
667,
460,
695,
475
],
[
698,
460,
766,
475
],
[
118,
493,
156,
509
],
[
160,
493,
213,
510
],
[
217,
494,
291,
510
],
[
295,
494,
313,
510
],
[
317,
495,
342,
510
],
[
346,
495,
377,
510
],
[
381,
495,
464,
510
],
[
467,
495,
506,
510
],
[
510,
495,
527,
510
],
[
530,
495,
539,
510
],
[
542,
495,
626,
510
],
[
630,
495,
655,
510
],
[
658,
495,
692,
510
],
[
695,
495,
760,
510
],
[
764,
494,
814,
510
],
[
817,
494,
849,
509
],
[
852,
493,
886,
509
],
[
116,
513,
175,
526
],
[
178,
513,
271,
527
],
[
274,
513,
310,
527
],
[
314,
513,
373,
527
],
[
377,
513,
397,
527
],
[
400,
513,
516,
527
],
[
521,
513,
568,
527
],
[
571,
513,
625,
527
],
[
628,
513,
692,
527
],
[
695,
513,
724,
527
],
[
726,
513,
751,
526
],
[
753,
513,
782,
526
],
[
784,
513,
842,
526
],
[
844,
513,
866,
526
],
[
232,
548,
262,
562
],
[
265,
547,
340,
562
],
[
343,
547,
389,
563
],
[
392,
547,
422,
563
],
[
425,
547,
463,
563
],
[
467,
547,
514,
563
],
[
517,
547,
540,
563
],
[
543,
547,
575,
563
],
[
578,
547,
662,
563
],
[
230,
565,
289,
579
],
[
297,
565,
396,
579
],
[
400,
565,
486,
580
],
[
491,
565,
540,
580
],
[
548,
564,
641,
580
],
[
644,
564,
672,
580
],
[
678,
564,
726,
580
],
[
734,
563,
805,
580
],
[
812,
562,
860,
580
],
[
866,
562,
886,
579
],
[
230,
582,
280,
595
],
[
230,
599,
307,
614
],
[
310,
601,
397,
614
],
[
231,
617,
305,
631
],
[
312,
617,
342,
631
],
[
347,
617,
431,
631
],
[
438,
618,
458,
631
],
[
461,
618,
538,
632
],
[
541,
618,
636,
632
],
[
638,
618,
722,
631
],
[
725,
617,
802,
631
],
[
804,
617,
885,
631
],
[
232,
634,
352,
649
],
[
355,
634,
385,
649
],
[
387,
634,
451,
649
],
[
232,
651,
274,
666
],
[
278,
651,
301,
666
],
[
305,
651,
379,
667
],
[
382,
652,
483,
667
],
[
230,
668,
305,
684
],
[
308,
669,
338,
684
],
[
341,
669,
425,
684
],
[
428,
670,
445,
684
],
[
449,
670,
505,
684
],
[
509,
670,
585,
684
],
[
588,
669,
680,
684
],
[
231,
685,
309,
702
],
[
312,
686,
390,
702
],
[
393,
686,
475,
702
],
[
478,
686,
508,
702
],
[
511,
685,
599,
702
],
[
231,
703,
308,
719
],
[
312,
703,
381,
719
],
[
232,
720,
264,
735
],
[
268,
721,
305,
735
],
[
307,
721,
337,
736
],
[
340,
721,
378,
736
],
[
380,
721,
413,
736
],
[
415,
721,
501,
736
],
[
118,
755,
155,
770
],
[
160,
755,
217,
771
],
[
220,
755,
295,
771
],
[
298,
755,
331,
772
],
[
337,
755,
350,
772
],
[
354,
755,
412,
772
],
[
416,
755,
477,
772
],
[
480,
755,
524,
772
],
[
527,
756,
557,
772
],
[
560,
755,
600,
772
],
[
603,
755,
707,
772
],
[
710,
755,
734,
771
],
[
738,
755,
778,
771
],
[
782,
755,
852,
770
],
[
118,
823,
158,
836
],
[
161,
823,
195,
837
],
[
198,
823,
268,
837
],
[
272,
824,
333,
837
],
[
337,
824,
364,
837
],
[
367,
824,
389,
837
],
[
392,
824,
445,
837
],
[
449,
824,
500,
837
],
[
504,
824,
564,
837
],
[
567,
824,
610,
837
],
[
612,
824,
714,
837
],
[
717,
824,
731,
837
],
[
734,
824,
752,
837
],
[
754,
823,
841,
837
],
[
844,
823,
876,
837
],
[
118,
839,
154,
852
],
[
157,
839,
173,
852
],
[
177,
839,
198,
852
],
[
201,
839,
253,
852
],
[
256,
840,
321,
852
],
[
324,
840,
344,
852
],
[
348,
840,
422,
852
],
[
425,
840,
440,
852
],
[
442,
840,
464,
852
],
[
467,
840,
493,
852
],
[
496,
840,
564,
852
],
[
567,
840,
622,
852
],
[
625,
840,
646,
852
],
[
649,
839,
711,
852
],
[
714,
839,
789,
852
],
[
792,
839,
801,
852
],
[
804,
839,
826,
852
],
[
829,
839,
843,
852
],
[
846,
839,
857,
852
],
[
117,
854,
175,
867
],
[
178,
854,
220,
867
],
[
223,
854,
248,
867
],
[
251,
854,
292,
867
],
[
296,
854,
322,
867
],
[
326,
854,
332,
867
],
[
336,
854,
387,
867
],
[
390,
854,
453,
867
],
[
456,
854,
471,
867
],
[
474,
853,
505,
867
],
[
508,
853,
518,
867
],
[
521,
853,
611,
867
],
[
614,
853,
655,
867
],
[
658,
853,
675,
867
],
[
678,
853,
732,
867
],
[
735,
853,
750,
867
],
[
753,
853,
790,
867
],
[
792,
853,
824,
867
],
[
827,
853,
862,
867
],
[
118,
868,
149,
881
],
[
151,
868,
174,
881
],
[
175,
868,
215,
881
],
[
217,
868,
242,
881
],
[
245,
868,
311,
881
],
[
313,
868,
344,
880
],
[
346,
868,
367,
880
],
[
369,
868,
397,
880
],
[
399,
868,
470,
880
],
[
471,
868,
552,
880
],
[
554,
868,
611,
880
],
[
613,
868,
628,
880
],
[
630,
868,
701,
880
],
[
702,
868,
718,
880
],
[
720,
868,
748,
880
],
[
750,
868,
766,
880
],
[
767,
868,
807,
880
],
[
809,
868,
824,
880
],
[
826,
868,
858,
880
],
[
117,
883,
205,
895
],
[
208,
883,
233,
896
],
[
236,
883,
301,
896
],
[
304,
883,
332,
896
],
[
335,
884,
360,
896
],
[
362,
884,
379,
896
],
[
381,
884,
398,
896
],
[
401,
884,
451,
896
],
[
454,
884,
467,
896
],
[
470,
884,
491,
896
],
[
493,
883,
524,
896
],
[
527,
883,
549,
896
],
[
551,
883,
589,
896
],
[
591,
883,
605,
896
],
[
608,
883,
672,
896
],
[
674,
883,
734,
896
],
[
736,
883,
761,
896
],
[
764,
882,
833,
896
],
[
835,
882,
852,
895
],
[
118,
898,
175,
911
],
[
178,
897,
212,
910
],
[
215,
897,
287,
910
],
[
291,
897,
303,
910
],
[
306,
897,
331,
910
],
[
334,
897,
360,
910
],
[
363,
897,
406,
910
],
[
409,
897,
441,
910
],
[
444,
897,
482,
910
],
[
821,
940,
883,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
Under which section, EPA carries out risk evaluation?
|
section 6
|
737
|
[
"chemicals",
"under",
"\"a",
"single",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"provided",
"the",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential",
"associated",
"with",
"that",
"single",
"use",
"support",
"such",
"a",
"designation.\"",
"But",
"EPA",
"then",
"creates",
"a",
"\"converse\"",
"construct",
"of",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"designation",
"standard",
"to",
"support",
"its",
"position",
"on",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"since",
"it",
"can",
"designate",
"a",
"chemical",
"as",
"a",
"high",
"priority",
"because",
"of",
"the",
"Section",
"6(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"language,",
"\"a",
"potential",
"hazard",
"and",
"a",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,\"2*",
"that",
"low",
"priorities",
"can",
"be",
"so",
"designated",
"only",
"if",
"they",
"don't",
"meet",
"this",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"This",
"argument",
"in",
"the",
"\"converse\"",
"coupled",
"with",
"EPA's",
"interpretation",
"of",
"\"the\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"to",
"mean",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"is",
"strained",
"and",
"counter",
"to",
"Congressional",
"intent.",
"A",
"better",
"interpretation",
"is",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"could",
"be",
"designated",
"low",
"priority",
"if",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk\"",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"for",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"hazard",
"or",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"a,",
"some,",
"or",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"flexibility",
"here",
"that",
"it",
"needs",
"to",
"apply,",
"given",
"the",
"6(b)(1)",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"designate",
"chemicals",
"as",
"low",
"priority",
"and",
"the",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives",
"for",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA's",
"strained",
"reading",
"of",
"the",
"phrase",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"designating",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"wholly",
"at",
"odds",
"with",
"congressional",
"intent",
"to",
"help",
"the",
"Agency",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"resources",
"on",
"high",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"\"",
"Further,",
"EPA's",
"reference",
"to",
"its",
"Safer",
"Chemicals",
"Ingredients",
"List",
"(SCIL)\"",
"as",
"a",
"starting",
"point",
"for",
"identifying",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"disingenuous",
"since",
"the",
"SCIL",
"list",
"does",
"not",
"represent",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"those",
"chemicals.",
"A",
"chemical",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"while",
"that",
"same",
"chemical",
"under",
"other",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"not",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"all.",
"EPA",
"should",
"not",
"have",
"to",
"scope",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"or",
"conduct",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"most",
"chemicals",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"before",
"it",
"can",
"conclude",
"that",
"a",
"certain",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"likely",
"to",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk.",
"EPA",
"should",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"set",
"aside",
"chemicals",
"for",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"through",
"low",
"priority",
"designations",
"where",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"the",
"chemical",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may\"",
"present",
"standard",
"for",
"those",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"Designating",
"low",
"priorities",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"based",
"on",
"less",
"than",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"will",
"help",
"EPA",
"meet",
"its",
"deadlines",
"for",
"scoping",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"will",
"conserve",
"resources,",
"and",
"will",
"enable",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"efforts",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"meet",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"criteria",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"to",
"determine",
"that",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"low",
"potential",
"for",
"risk",
"and",
"can",
"be",
"designated",
"as",
"\"low",
"priority\"",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"should",
"use",
"this",
"authority",
"to",
"help",
"it",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"designated",
"as",
"high",
"priority",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"B.",
"EPA's",
"Abuse",
"of",
"Discretion",
"Argument",
"EPA",
"provides",
"as",
"its",
"rationale",
"for",
"addressing",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"low",
"priority",
"designation",
"process",
"that",
"EPA",
"\"considers",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"an",
"abuse",
"of",
"that",
"discretion",
"to",
"simply",
"disregard",
"known,",
"25",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.at",
"4830.",
"#",
"15",
"U.S.C.",
"2605(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"(emphasis",
"added).",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4829,",
"Section",
"IIIA",
"notes",
"\"conserving",
"resources\"",
"and",
"giving",
"\"the",
"public",
"notice",
"of",
"chemical",
"substances",
"for",
"which",
"potential",
"risks",
"are",
"likely",
"low",
"or",
"nonexistent,\"",
"as",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives.",
"See",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016,",
"at",
"page",
"3519,",
"in",
"which",
"Senator",
"Vitter",
"states:",
"\"The",
"language",
"of",
"the",
"compromise",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"EPA",
"has",
"to",
"make",
"a",
"determination",
"on",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"considered",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"but",
"the",
"Agency",
"is",
"given",
"the",
"discretion",
"to",
"determine",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"will",
"address",
"in",
"its",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"priority",
"chemical.",
"This",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency's",
"focus",
"on",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"he",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"This",
"also",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"can",
"effectively",
"assess",
"and",
"control",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"meet",
"the",
"new",
"law's",
"deadlines.",
"Without",
"this",
"discretion",
"to",
"focus",
"chemical",
"risk",
"assessments",
"on",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"the",
"Agency's",
"job",
"would",
"be",
"more",
"difficult.\"",
"pups:/www.congress.gov/crec/2016/06/07/CREC:2016-06-07-pul-Pes3511.pdf",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4830.",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
140,
64,
217,
80
],
[
221,
65,
268,
80
],
[
271,
65,
290,
80
],
[
294,
65,
342,
80
],
[
346,
65,
421,
80
],
[
424,
65,
442,
80
],
[
445,
65,
477,
80
],
[
480,
65,
552,
80
],
[
556,
65,
581,
80
],
[
585,
65,
639,
80
],
[
642,
65,
672,
80
],
[
676,
65,
747,
80
],
[
750,
64,
821,
80
],
[
825,
64,
908,
80
],
[
139,
82,
175,
97
],
[
178,
82,
210,
97
],
[
212,
82,
261,
97
],
[
264,
82,
292,
97
],
[
295,
82,
355,
97
],
[
359,
82,
397,
97
],
[
401,
82,
414,
97
],
[
417,
82,
522,
97
],
[
537,
82,
566,
97
],
[
570,
82,
607,
97
],
[
612,
82,
647,
97
],
[
650,
82,
706,
97
],
[
710,
82,
719,
97
],
[
722,
82,
812,
97
],
[
815,
82,
888,
97
],
[
891,
82,
912,
97
],
[
138,
99,
163,
115
],
[
167,
99,
202,
115
],
[
206,
99,
270,
115
],
[
274,
100,
363,
115
],
[
367,
100,
434,
115
],
[
437,
100,
454,
115
],
[
458,
100,
517,
115
],
[
521,
101,
540,
115
],
[
544,
100,
611,
115
],
[
614,
100,
634,
115
],
[
637,
100,
667,
115
],
[
671,
100,
735,
115
],
[
739,
99,
840,
115
],
[
844,
99,
880,
114
],
[
140,
118,
218,
132
],
[
222,
117,
252,
132
],
[
256,
117,
298,
132
],
[
301,
117,
314,
132
],
[
317,
117,
346,
132
],
[
353,
117,
425,
132
],
[
428,
117,
438,
132
],
[
441,
117,
515,
132
],
[
518,
117,
536,
132
],
[
540,
117,
549,
132
],
[
552,
117,
590,
132
],
[
592,
117,
652,
132
],
[
655,
117,
721,
132
],
[
724,
117,
742,
131
],
[
745,
117,
771,
131
],
[
774,
117,
830,
131
],
[
141,
133,
239,
150
],
[
244,
134,
318,
150
],
[
323,
134,
342,
150
],
[
346,
134,
415,
150
],
[
420,
134,
474,
150
],
[
478,
134,
508,
150
],
[
512,
134,
521,
150
],
[
525,
134,
595,
150
],
[
599,
134,
642,
150
],
[
646,
134,
662,
150
],
[
667,
134,
738,
150
],
[
741,
134,
788,
150
],
[
791,
134,
818,
150
],
[
822,
134,
905,
150
],
[
908,
134,
927,
150
],
[
138,
151,
192,
167
],
[
196,
151,
227,
167
],
[
231,
151,
261,
167
],
[
264,
151,
337,
168
],
[
341,
151,
369,
168
],
[
372,
151,
393,
168
],
[
397,
151,
417,
168
],
[
422,
151,
504,
168
],
[
508,
151,
544,
168
],
[
548,
151,
561,
168
],
[
564,
151,
603,
168
],
[
607,
151,
646,
168
],
[
649,
151,
689,
168
],
[
692,
151,
721,
168
],
[
724,
151,
761,
168
],
[
764,
151,
827,
168
],
[
830,
151,
900,
167
],
[
138,
170,
185,
184
],
[
188,
170,
210,
184
],
[
213,
169,
298,
184
],
[
300,
169,
319,
185
],
[
322,
169,
357,
185
],
[
360,
169,
394,
185
],
[
397,
169,
472,
185
],
[
475,
169,
494,
185
],
[
497,
169,
522,
185
],
[
525,
169,
614,
185
],
[
617,
169,
681,
185
],
[
685,
169,
722,
185
],
[
725,
169,
777,
185
],
[
781,
168,
887,
184
],
[
891,
168,
912,
184
],
[
141,
185,
181,
201
],
[
185,
185,
268,
201
],
[
271,
185,
289,
201
],
[
292,
185,
320,
201
],
[
323,
185,
340,
201
],
[
343,
185,
388,
202
],
[
391,
185,
430,
202
],
[
434,
185,
517,
202
],
[
520,
186,
538,
202
],
[
541,
186,
568,
202
],
[
572,
186,
587,
202
],
[
590,
186,
655,
202
],
[
658,
186,
688,
202
],
[
691,
186,
751,
202
],
[
754,
186,
772,
202
],
[
775,
186,
888,
202
],
[
138,
203,
189,
218
],
[
175,
234,
188,
249
],
[
192,
234,
238,
249
],
[
242,
234,
349,
249
],
[
352,
234,
368,
249
],
[
371,
234,
402,
249
],
[
405,
234,
415,
249
],
[
419,
234,
492,
250
],
[
495,
234,
540,
250
],
[
543,
234,
565,
250
],
[
570,
234,
652,
250
],
[
655,
234,
684,
250
],
[
690,
234,
750,
250
],
[
754,
234,
767,
250
],
[
771,
234,
788,
250
],
[
792,
234,
825,
250
],
[
829,
234,
858,
249
],
[
862,
234,
901,
249
],
[
905,
233,
932,
249
],
[
138,
252,
181,
266
],
[
185,
252,
244,
267
],
[
247,
252,
268,
267
],
[
271,
251,
375,
267
],
[
379,
251,
419,
268
],
[
422,
251,
458,
268
],
[
461,
251,
523,
268
],
[
526,
251,
595,
268
],
[
598,
251,
622,
268
],
[
625,
251,
654,
268
],
[
656,
251,
727,
268
],
[
730,
251,
785,
268
],
[
788,
251,
805,
267
],
[
808,
251,
837,
267
],
[
840,
251,
908,
267
],
[
138,
270,
181,
284
],
[
184,
270,
202,
284
],
[
205,
270,
278,
284
],
[
281,
270,
331,
284
],
[
334,
270,
351,
284
],
[
354,
270,
402,
285
],
[
405,
270,
424,
285
],
[
427,
270,
451,
285
],
[
454,
269,
538,
285
],
[
542,
269,
560,
285
],
[
562,
269,
598,
285
],
[
601,
269,
635,
285
],
[
642,
269,
671,
285
],
[
674,
269,
752,
284
],
[
755,
269,
790,
284
],
[
794,
269,
824,
284
],
[
828,
269,
841,
284
],
[
844,
268,
891,
284
],
[
894,
268,
908,
283
],
[
138,
287,
189,
303
],
[
192,
286,
236,
303
],
[
240,
286,
266,
302
],
[
270,
286,
325,
302
],
[
330,
286,
425,
302
],
[
430,
286,
452,
301
],
[
457,
286,
495,
301
],
[
498,
286,
519,
301
],
[
522,
286,
595,
301
],
[
598,
286,
679,
301
],
[
682,
286,
700,
301
],
[
702,
286,
733,
301
],
[
736,
286,
798,
301
],
[
801,
286,
831,
302
],
[
833,
287,
861,
302
],
[
139,
304,
217,
320
],
[
220,
304,
271,
320
],
[
274,
304,
355,
320
],
[
358,
304,
381,
320
],
[
384,
304,
415,
320
],
[
420,
303,
484,
320
],
[
487,
303,
597,
320
],
[
612,
303,
664,
320
],
[
667,
303,
730,
320
],
[
734,
303,
795,
320
],
[
798,
303,
815,
320
],
[
820,
303,
844,
320
],
[
848,
303,
902,
320
],
[
139,
321,
231,
336
],
[
235,
321,
256,
336
],
[
260,
321,
295,
336
],
[
299,
322,
318,
337
],
[
322,
322,
412,
337
],
[
415,
322,
443,
337
],
[
449,
322,
510,
337
],
[
513,
322,
593,
337
],
[
596,
322,
613,
337
],
[
616,
322,
671,
337
],
[
674,
322,
691,
337
],
[
694,
322,
733,
336
],
[
736,
321,
772,
336
],
[
776,
321,
887,
336
],
[
138,
338,
184,
353
],
[
187,
339,
204,
353
],
[
207,
339,
244,
353
],
[
247,
339,
273,
353
],
[
276,
339,
339,
354
],
[
342,
339,
386,
354
],
[
389,
339,
408,
354
],
[
412,
339,
444,
354
],
[
447,
340,
530,
354
],
[
534,
339,
610,
354
],
[
614,
339,
633,
354
],
[
637,
339,
672,
353
],
[
676,
339,
738,
353
],
[
742,
339,
821,
353
],
[
824,
338,
855,
353
],
[
138,
356,
222,
371
],
[
226,
356,
244,
371
],
[
247,
356,
273,
371
],
[
277,
356,
308,
371
],
[
311,
355,
350,
371
],
[
353,
355,
380,
371
],
[
384,
355,
444,
371
],
[
448,
355,
520,
371
],
[
523,
355,
547,
371
],
[
550,
355,
586,
371
],
[
590,
355,
602,
371
],
[
619,
355,
685,
371
],
[
688,
355,
740,
371
],
[
744,
355,
820,
371
],
[
824,
355,
840,
370
],
[
844,
355,
866,
370
],
[
870,
355,
912,
370
],
[
139,
372,
224,
389
],
[
228,
373,
319,
390
],
[
323,
373,
355,
390
],
[
359,
374,
430,
390
],
[
434,
374,
452,
390
],
[
457,
374,
467,
390
],
[
471,
374,
531,
390
],
[
534,
374,
578,
390
],
[
582,
374,
605,
390
],
[
610,
374,
699,
390
],
[
703,
374,
732,
390
],
[
738,
374,
799,
390
],
[
803,
374,
883,
389
],
[
887,
374,
902,
389
],
[
142,
390,
245,
406
],
[
249,
391,
291,
406
],
[
294,
391,
321,
406
],
[
325,
391,
368,
406
],
[
372,
391,
401,
406
],
[
405,
391,
439,
406
],
[
443,
391,
471,
406
],
[
475,
391,
550,
406
],
[
554,
391,
575,
406
],
[
579,
391,
664,
406
],
[
667,
391,
685,
406
],
[
688,
391,
718,
406
],
[
721,
391,
739,
406
],
[
742,
391,
786,
406
],
[
789,
391,
880,
406
],
[
177,
421,
189,
436
],
[
192,
421,
265,
436
],
[
268,
422,
314,
437
],
[
318,
422,
374,
437
],
[
377,
422,
460,
437
],
[
463,
422,
481,
437
],
[
485,
422,
511,
437
],
[
515,
422,
552,
437
],
[
555,
422,
617,
437
],
[
620,
422,
629,
437
],
[
632,
422,
664,
437
],
[
668,
422,
751,
436
],
[
754,
422,
798,
436
],
[
802,
421,
834,
436
],
[
837,
421,
881,
436
],
[
139,
439,
211,
454
],
[
214,
440,
260,
454
],
[
263,
440,
306,
454
],
[
309,
440,
392,
454
],
[
396,
441,
413,
454
],
[
417,
441,
444,
454
],
[
448,
441,
482,
454
],
[
485,
441,
515,
454
],
[
518,
440,
578,
454
],
[
582,
440,
592,
454
],
[
595,
440,
627,
454
],
[
630,
440,
714,
454
],
[
717,
440,
733,
454
],
[
737,
440,
762,
454
],
[
765,
439,
802,
453
],
[
808,
439,
860,
453
],
[
863,
438,
891,
453
],
[
137,
456,
177,
471
],
[
180,
456,
198,
471
],
[
201,
456,
247,
471
],
[
250,
456,
260,
471
],
[
262,
456,
295,
471
],
[
298,
456,
382,
470
],
[
385,
456,
404,
470
],
[
407,
456,
469,
470
],
[
472,
456,
504,
470
],
[
507,
456,
600,
470
],
[
602,
456,
623,
470
],
[
627,
456,
667,
470
],
[
670,
456,
750,
470
],
[
753,
456,
800,
470
],
[
803,
456,
824,
470
],
[
827,
455,
912,
470
],
[
140,
473,
156,
489
],
[
160,
473,
186,
489
],
[
190,
473,
241,
489
],
[
245,
473,
257,
489
],
[
261,
473,
290,
489
],
[
294,
474,
365,
490
],
[
370,
474,
400,
490
],
[
404,
474,
413,
490
],
[
417,
474,
472,
490
],
[
476,
474,
502,
490
],
[
506,
474,
520,
490
],
[
524,
474,
550,
490
],
[
554,
474,
600,
490
],
[
603,
474,
620,
490
],
[
624,
474,
682,
490
],
[
687,
474,
706,
490
],
[
710,
474,
814,
490
],
[
818,
473,
854,
489
],
[
858,
473,
895,
489
],
[
139,
490,
191,
506
],
[
194,
490,
215,
506
],
[
219,
490,
253,
506
],
[
257,
491,
273,
506
],
[
277,
491,
300,
506
],
[
304,
491,
345,
506
],
[
348,
491,
429,
506
],
[
432,
491,
456,
506
],
[
460,
492,
515,
506
],
[
519,
492,
602,
507
],
[
605,
492,
622,
506
],
[
625,
492,
654,
506
],
[
657,
492,
720,
506
],
[
723,
491,
754,
506
],
[
757,
491,
821,
506
],
[
824,
491,
924,
506
],
[
140,
508,
189,
523
],
[
192,
508,
228,
523
],
[
232,
508,
312,
523
],
[
315,
508,
348,
524
],
[
352,
508,
377,
524
],
[
380,
508,
456,
524
],
[
460,
508,
493,
524
],
[
497,
508,
522,
524
],
[
526,
508,
566,
524
],
[
570,
508,
595,
524
],
[
600,
508,
650,
524
],
[
654,
508,
713,
524
],
[
717,
508,
785,
524
],
[
788,
508,
812,
524
],
[
815,
508,
861,
523
],
[
138,
525,
221,
542
],
[
225,
526,
242,
542
],
[
245,
526,
278,
542
],
[
282,
526,
377,
542
],
[
381,
526,
411,
542
],
[
415,
526,
488,
542
],
[
492,
526,
516,
542
],
[
520,
526,
551,
542
],
[
554,
525,
644,
542
],
[
648,
525,
694,
542
],
[
698,
525,
718,
541
],
[
721,
525,
752,
541
],
[
756,
525,
791,
541
],
[
795,
525,
834,
541
],
[
838,
525,
922,
541
],
[
139,
543,
155,
558
],
[
159,
543,
188,
558
],
[
192,
544,
222,
559
],
[
226,
544,
262,
559
],
[
265,
544,
301,
559
],
[
306,
544,
345,
559
],
[
349,
544,
373,
559
],
[
377,
544,
449,
559
],
[
452,
545,
477,
559
],
[
480,
545,
541,
559
],
[
545,
545,
577,
559
],
[
580,
545,
677,
559
],
[
680,
545,
712,
559
],
[
716,
545,
784,
559
],
[
788,
545,
870,
558
],
[
872,
544,
906,
558
],
[
139,
560,
170,
575
],
[
174,
560,
227,
575
],
[
230,
560,
267,
575
],
[
272,
560,
289,
575
],
[
292,
560,
335,
575
],
[
338,
560,
358,
575
],
[
362,
560,
395,
575
],
[
398,
560,
481,
575
],
[
484,
560,
537,
575
],
[
540,
560,
562,
575
],
[
565,
560,
645,
575
],
[
648,
560,
678,
575
],
[
681,
560,
722,
575
],
[
725,
560,
751,
575
],
[
754,
560,
791,
576
],
[
794,
560,
855,
576
],
[
858,
560,
917,
576
],
[
140,
579,
185,
593
],
[
188,
578,
242,
593
],
[
246,
578,
329,
594
],
[
332,
578,
350,
594
],
[
354,
578,
387,
594
],
[
390,
578,
427,
594
],
[
431,
578,
460,
594
],
[
463,
578,
535,
594
],
[
538,
578,
557,
594
],
[
562,
578,
639,
594
],
[
642,
578,
674,
594
],
[
677,
578,
733,
594
],
[
736,
578,
820,
594
],
[
822,
578,
841,
594
],
[
844,
578,
872,
594
],
[
875,
578,
894,
594
],
[
896,
578,
907,
594
],
[
140,
595,
211,
610
],
[
214,
596,
239,
610
],
[
242,
596,
290,
610
],
[
293,
596,
309,
611
],
[
312,
596,
351,
611
],
[
354,
596,
382,
611
],
[
388,
596,
460,
611
],
[
464,
596,
485,
611
],
[
489,
596,
521,
611
],
[
525,
596,
554,
611
],
[
558,
596,
587,
611
],
[
590,
596,
612,
611
],
[
617,
595,
700,
611
],
[
702,
595,
720,
611
],
[
724,
595,
761,
611
],
[
767,
595,
837,
611
],
[
840,
595,
862,
611
],
[
866,
595,
898,
610
],
[
138,
612,
227,
627
],
[
230,
613,
268,
628
],
[
272,
613,
326,
628
],
[
329,
613,
357,
628
],
[
360,
613,
391,
628
],
[
394,
613,
466,
628
],
[
469,
613,
485,
628
],
[
489,
613,
525,
628
],
[
528,
613,
541,
628
],
[
545,
613,
588,
628
],
[
592,
613,
611,
628
],
[
614,
613,
647,
628
],
[
650,
613,
741,
628
],
[
744,
613,
766,
628
],
[
769,
613,
850,
628
],
[
142,
630,
223,
646
],
[
227,
630,
244,
646
],
[
247,
630,
283,
646
],
[
287,
630,
348,
646
],
[
352,
630,
398,
646
],
[
402,
630,
456,
646
],
[
460,
630,
544,
646
],
[
548,
630,
565,
646
],
[
568,
630,
599,
646
],
[
145,
665,
170,
679
],
[
174,
665,
230,
680
],
[
232,
665,
286,
680
],
[
289,
665,
307,
680
],
[
310,
665,
398,
681
],
[
401,
665,
491,
681
],
[
174,
695,
210,
710
],
[
215,
695,
285,
710
],
[
288,
695,
305,
710
],
[
309,
695,
329,
710
],
[
332,
695,
402,
711
],
[
406,
696,
432,
711
],
[
435,
696,
520,
711
],
[
524,
696,
544,
711
],
[
548,
696,
632,
711
],
[
635,
696,
652,
711
],
[
655,
696,
684,
711
],
[
687,
696,
702,
711
],
[
706,
695,
732,
711
],
[
735,
695,
765,
711
],
[
770,
695,
833,
711
],
[
838,
695,
927,
711
],
[
140,
714,
199,
728
],
[
202,
713,
234,
728
],
[
237,
713,
273,
728
],
[
278,
713,
363,
728
],
[
366,
713,
398,
728
],
[
401,
713,
414,
729
],
[
417,
713,
467,
729
],
[
470,
713,
492,
729
],
[
495,
713,
514,
729
],
[
517,
713,
564,
729
],
[
567,
713,
585,
729
],
[
588,
713,
624,
729
],
[
627,
713,
702,
729
],
[
705,
713,
722,
729
],
[
725,
713,
782,
729
],
[
786,
713,
858,
729
],
[
861,
714,
924,
729
],
[
110,
770,
120,
783
],
[
124,
770,
136,
783
],
[
139,
771,
163,
784
],
[
166,
771,
201,
784
],
[
204,
771,
235,
784
],
[
115,
784,
122,
796
],
[
125,
784,
137,
797
],
[
140,
785,
176,
798
],
[
179,
786,
265,
799
],
[
268,
788,
321,
799
],
[
324,
788,
362,
799
],
[
124,
800,
137,
812
],
[
140,
800,
163,
812
],
[
166,
800,
190,
813
],
[
193,
800,
203,
813
],
[
206,
800,
235,
813
],
[
239,
801,
278,
814
],
[
281,
801,
303,
814
],
[
306,
801,
334,
814
],
[
338,
802,
401,
814
],
[
404,
802,
460,
815
],
[
462,
802,
483,
815
],
[
487,
803,
518,
815
],
[
521,
803,
543,
815
],
[
546,
803,
579,
815
],
[
582,
803,
616,
815
],
[
619,
803,
630,
815
],
[
633,
803,
680,
815
],
[
683,
802,
740,
815
],
[
743,
802,
758,
815
],
[
761,
802,
793,
814
],
[
796,
802,
842,
814
],
[
845,
801,
870,
814
],
[
873,
801,
888,
814
],
[
891,
801,
922,
814
],
[
110,
814,
128,
826
],
[
131,
814,
142,
826
],
[
145,
814,
217,
826
],
[
219,
815,
230,
826
],
[
233,
815,
284,
826
],
[
287,
815,
320,
826
],
[
323,
815,
385,
826
],
[
124,
828,
143,
839
],
[
145,
828,
182,
839
],
[
184,
828,
259,
839
],
[
261,
828,
304,
839
],
[
307,
829,
332,
839
],
[
335,
829,
344,
839
],
[
347,
829,
377,
840
],
[
380,
829,
388,
840
],
[
391,
829,
417,
840
],
[
420,
829,
450,
840
],
[
452,
829,
464,
840
],
[
466,
829,
499,
840
],
[
502,
829,
543,
840
],
[
546,
829,
577,
840
],
[
579,
829,
611,
840
],
[
614,
829,
641,
840
],
[
643,
829,
692,
840
],
[
694,
829,
706,
840
],
[
708,
829,
725,
840
],
[
727,
828,
793,
840
],
[
795,
828,
831,
840
],
[
833,
828,
859,
840
],
[
861,
828,
882,
840
],
[
884,
828,
909,
840
],
[
911,
828,
932,
840
],
[
111,
840,
120,
850
],
[
122,
840,
151,
850
],
[
154,
840,
162,
851
],
[
165,
840,
236,
851
],
[
239,
840,
253,
851
],
[
256,
840,
270,
851
],
[
272,
840,
327,
851
],
[
330,
840,
341,
851
],
[
344,
840,
362,
851
],
[
364,
840,
422,
851
],
[
424,
840,
435,
851
],
[
438,
840,
454,
851
],
[
457,
840,
487,
851
],
[
490,
840,
508,
851
],
[
510,
840,
528,
851
],
[
530,
840,
571,
851
],
[
573,
840,
583,
851
],
[
585,
840,
615,
851
],
[
618,
840,
636,
851
],
[
638,
840,
689,
851
],
[
691,
840,
705,
851
],
[
707,
840,
758,
851
],
[
760,
840,
778,
851
],
[
781,
840,
837,
851
],
[
839,
840,
850,
851
],
[
852,
840,
871,
851
],
[
873,
840,
894,
851
],
[
896,
840,
915,
851
],
[
110,
853,
151,
863
],
[
153,
853,
174,
863
],
[
177,
853,
216,
863
],
[
218,
853,
230,
863
],
[
232,
853,
245,
863
],
[
248,
853,
304,
863
],
[
307,
853,
317,
863
],
[
320,
853,
336,
863
],
[
338,
853,
378,
863
],
[
381,
853,
438,
864
],
[
440,
853,
462,
864
],
[
465,
853,
503,
864
],
[
505,
853,
527,
864
],
[
529,
853,
547,
864
],
[
549,
853,
599,
864
],
[
601,
853,
631,
864
],
[
634,
853,
647,
864
],
[
650,
853,
690,
864
],
[
693,
853,
745,
864
],
[
748,
853,
758,
863
],
[
761,
853,
774,
863
],
[
777,
853,
831,
863
],
[
834,
853,
845,
863
],
[
848,
853,
866,
863
],
[
868,
853,
888,
863
],
[
891,
852,
919,
863
],
[
112,
864,
126,
874
],
[
128,
864,
170,
875
],
[
172,
864,
219,
875
],
[
221,
864,
237,
875
],
[
239,
864,
268,
875
],
[
271,
864,
293,
875
],
[
295,
864,
317,
875
],
[
320,
864,
358,
875
],
[
361,
864,
381,
875
],
[
384,
864,
402,
875
],
[
404,
864,
444,
875
],
[
447,
864,
465,
875
],
[
468,
864,
525,
875
],
[
528,
864,
561,
875
],
[
563,
864,
583,
875
],
[
585,
864,
623,
875
],
[
625,
864,
665,
875
],
[
668,
864,
721,
875
],
[
723,
864,
744,
875
],
[
746,
864,
772,
875
],
[
775,
864,
791,
875
],
[
794,
864,
816,
875
],
[
818,
864,
851,
875
],
[
854,
864,
908,
875
],
[
112,
875,
152,
886
],
[
155,
875,
176,
886
],
[
178,
875,
230,
887
],
[
232,
875,
242,
887
],
[
245,
875,
275,
887
],
[
278,
876,
324,
887
],
[
327,
876,
348,
887
],
[
351,
876,
415,
887
],
[
418,
876,
431,
887
],
[
434,
876,
470,
887
],
[
473,
876,
528,
887
],
[
531,
876,
541,
887
],
[
544,
876,
565,
887
],
[
568,
876,
585,
887
],
[
588,
875,
638,
887
],
[
640,
875,
658,
887
],
[
661,
875,
694,
887
],
[
697,
875,
709,
887
],
[
712,
875,
741,
887
],
[
744,
875,
797,
887
],
[
108,
887,
532,
900
],
[
124,
900,
138,
911
],
[
140,
900,
164,
911
],
[
166,
901,
192,
911
],
[
194,
901,
205,
911
],
[
207,
901,
235,
911
],
[
511,
914,
530,
927
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
What is the fullform of SCIL?
|
Safer Chemicals Ingredients List
|
737
|
[
"chemicals",
"under",
"\"a",
"single",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"provided",
"the",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential",
"associated",
"with",
"that",
"single",
"use",
"support",
"such",
"a",
"designation.\"",
"But",
"EPA",
"then",
"creates",
"a",
"\"converse\"",
"construct",
"of",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"designation",
"standard",
"to",
"support",
"its",
"position",
"on",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"since",
"it",
"can",
"designate",
"a",
"chemical",
"as",
"a",
"high",
"priority",
"because",
"of",
"the",
"Section",
"6(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"language,",
"\"a",
"potential",
"hazard",
"and",
"a",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,\"2*",
"that",
"low",
"priorities",
"can",
"be",
"so",
"designated",
"only",
"if",
"they",
"don't",
"meet",
"this",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"This",
"argument",
"in",
"the",
"\"converse\"",
"coupled",
"with",
"EPA's",
"interpretation",
"of",
"\"the\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"to",
"mean",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"is",
"strained",
"and",
"counter",
"to",
"Congressional",
"intent.",
"A",
"better",
"interpretation",
"is",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"could",
"be",
"designated",
"low",
"priority",
"if",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk\"",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"for",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"hazard",
"or",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"a,",
"some,",
"or",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"flexibility",
"here",
"that",
"it",
"needs",
"to",
"apply,",
"given",
"the",
"6(b)(1)",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"designate",
"chemicals",
"as",
"low",
"priority",
"and",
"the",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives",
"for",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA's",
"strained",
"reading",
"of",
"the",
"phrase",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"designating",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"wholly",
"at",
"odds",
"with",
"congressional",
"intent",
"to",
"help",
"the",
"Agency",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"resources",
"on",
"high",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"\"",
"Further,",
"EPA's",
"reference",
"to",
"its",
"Safer",
"Chemicals",
"Ingredients",
"List",
"(SCIL)\"",
"as",
"a",
"starting",
"point",
"for",
"identifying",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"disingenuous",
"since",
"the",
"SCIL",
"list",
"does",
"not",
"represent",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"those",
"chemicals.",
"A",
"chemical",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"while",
"that",
"same",
"chemical",
"under",
"other",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"not",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"all.",
"EPA",
"should",
"not",
"have",
"to",
"scope",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"or",
"conduct",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"most",
"chemicals",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"before",
"it",
"can",
"conclude",
"that",
"a",
"certain",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"likely",
"to",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk.",
"EPA",
"should",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"set",
"aside",
"chemicals",
"for",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"through",
"low",
"priority",
"designations",
"where",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"the",
"chemical",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may\"",
"present",
"standard",
"for",
"those",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"Designating",
"low",
"priorities",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"based",
"on",
"less",
"than",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"will",
"help",
"EPA",
"meet",
"its",
"deadlines",
"for",
"scoping",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"will",
"conserve",
"resources,",
"and",
"will",
"enable",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"efforts",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"meet",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"criteria",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"to",
"determine",
"that",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"low",
"potential",
"for",
"risk",
"and",
"can",
"be",
"designated",
"as",
"\"low",
"priority\"",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"should",
"use",
"this",
"authority",
"to",
"help",
"it",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"designated",
"as",
"high",
"priority",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"B.",
"EPA's",
"Abuse",
"of",
"Discretion",
"Argument",
"EPA",
"provides",
"as",
"its",
"rationale",
"for",
"addressing",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"low",
"priority",
"designation",
"process",
"that",
"EPA",
"\"considers",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"an",
"abuse",
"of",
"that",
"discretion",
"to",
"simply",
"disregard",
"known,",
"25",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.at",
"4830.",
"#",
"15",
"U.S.C.",
"2605(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"(emphasis",
"added).",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4829,",
"Section",
"IIIA",
"notes",
"\"conserving",
"resources\"",
"and",
"giving",
"\"the",
"public",
"notice",
"of",
"chemical",
"substances",
"for",
"which",
"potential",
"risks",
"are",
"likely",
"low",
"or",
"nonexistent,\"",
"as",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives.",
"See",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016,",
"at",
"page",
"3519,",
"in",
"which",
"Senator",
"Vitter",
"states:",
"\"The",
"language",
"of",
"the",
"compromise",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"EPA",
"has",
"to",
"make",
"a",
"determination",
"on",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"considered",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"but",
"the",
"Agency",
"is",
"given",
"the",
"discretion",
"to",
"determine",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"will",
"address",
"in",
"its",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"priority",
"chemical.",
"This",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency's",
"focus",
"on",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"he",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"This",
"also",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"can",
"effectively",
"assess",
"and",
"control",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"meet",
"the",
"new",
"law's",
"deadlines.",
"Without",
"this",
"discretion",
"to",
"focus",
"chemical",
"risk",
"assessments",
"on",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"the",
"Agency's",
"job",
"would",
"be",
"more",
"difficult.\"",
"pups:/www.congress.gov/crec/2016/06/07/CREC:2016-06-07-pul-Pes3511.pdf",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4830.",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
140,
64,
217,
80
],
[
221,
65,
268,
80
],
[
271,
65,
290,
80
],
[
294,
65,
342,
80
],
[
346,
65,
421,
80
],
[
424,
65,
442,
80
],
[
445,
65,
477,
80
],
[
480,
65,
552,
80
],
[
556,
65,
581,
80
],
[
585,
65,
639,
80
],
[
642,
65,
672,
80
],
[
676,
65,
747,
80
],
[
750,
64,
821,
80
],
[
825,
64,
908,
80
],
[
139,
82,
175,
97
],
[
178,
82,
210,
97
],
[
212,
82,
261,
97
],
[
264,
82,
292,
97
],
[
295,
82,
355,
97
],
[
359,
82,
397,
97
],
[
401,
82,
414,
97
],
[
417,
82,
522,
97
],
[
537,
82,
566,
97
],
[
570,
82,
607,
97
],
[
612,
82,
647,
97
],
[
650,
82,
706,
97
],
[
710,
82,
719,
97
],
[
722,
82,
812,
97
],
[
815,
82,
888,
97
],
[
891,
82,
912,
97
],
[
138,
99,
163,
115
],
[
167,
99,
202,
115
],
[
206,
99,
270,
115
],
[
274,
100,
363,
115
],
[
367,
100,
434,
115
],
[
437,
100,
454,
115
],
[
458,
100,
517,
115
],
[
521,
101,
540,
115
],
[
544,
100,
611,
115
],
[
614,
100,
634,
115
],
[
637,
100,
667,
115
],
[
671,
100,
735,
115
],
[
739,
99,
840,
115
],
[
844,
99,
880,
114
],
[
140,
118,
218,
132
],
[
222,
117,
252,
132
],
[
256,
117,
298,
132
],
[
301,
117,
314,
132
],
[
317,
117,
346,
132
],
[
353,
117,
425,
132
],
[
428,
117,
438,
132
],
[
441,
117,
515,
132
],
[
518,
117,
536,
132
],
[
540,
117,
549,
132
],
[
552,
117,
590,
132
],
[
592,
117,
652,
132
],
[
655,
117,
721,
132
],
[
724,
117,
742,
131
],
[
745,
117,
771,
131
],
[
774,
117,
830,
131
],
[
141,
133,
239,
150
],
[
244,
134,
318,
150
],
[
323,
134,
342,
150
],
[
346,
134,
415,
150
],
[
420,
134,
474,
150
],
[
478,
134,
508,
150
],
[
512,
134,
521,
150
],
[
525,
134,
595,
150
],
[
599,
134,
642,
150
],
[
646,
134,
662,
150
],
[
667,
134,
738,
150
],
[
741,
134,
788,
150
],
[
791,
134,
818,
150
],
[
822,
134,
905,
150
],
[
908,
134,
927,
150
],
[
138,
151,
192,
167
],
[
196,
151,
227,
167
],
[
231,
151,
261,
167
],
[
264,
151,
337,
168
],
[
341,
151,
369,
168
],
[
372,
151,
393,
168
],
[
397,
151,
417,
168
],
[
422,
151,
504,
168
],
[
508,
151,
544,
168
],
[
548,
151,
561,
168
],
[
564,
151,
603,
168
],
[
607,
151,
646,
168
],
[
649,
151,
689,
168
],
[
692,
151,
721,
168
],
[
724,
151,
761,
168
],
[
764,
151,
827,
168
],
[
830,
151,
900,
167
],
[
138,
170,
185,
184
],
[
188,
170,
210,
184
],
[
213,
169,
298,
184
],
[
300,
169,
319,
185
],
[
322,
169,
357,
185
],
[
360,
169,
394,
185
],
[
397,
169,
472,
185
],
[
475,
169,
494,
185
],
[
497,
169,
522,
185
],
[
525,
169,
614,
185
],
[
617,
169,
681,
185
],
[
685,
169,
722,
185
],
[
725,
169,
777,
185
],
[
781,
168,
887,
184
],
[
891,
168,
912,
184
],
[
141,
185,
181,
201
],
[
185,
185,
268,
201
],
[
271,
185,
289,
201
],
[
292,
185,
320,
201
],
[
323,
185,
340,
201
],
[
343,
185,
388,
202
],
[
391,
185,
430,
202
],
[
434,
185,
517,
202
],
[
520,
186,
538,
202
],
[
541,
186,
568,
202
],
[
572,
186,
587,
202
],
[
590,
186,
655,
202
],
[
658,
186,
688,
202
],
[
691,
186,
751,
202
],
[
754,
186,
772,
202
],
[
775,
186,
888,
202
],
[
138,
203,
189,
218
],
[
175,
234,
188,
249
],
[
192,
234,
238,
249
],
[
242,
234,
349,
249
],
[
352,
234,
368,
249
],
[
371,
234,
402,
249
],
[
405,
234,
415,
249
],
[
419,
234,
492,
250
],
[
495,
234,
540,
250
],
[
543,
234,
565,
250
],
[
570,
234,
652,
250
],
[
655,
234,
684,
250
],
[
690,
234,
750,
250
],
[
754,
234,
767,
250
],
[
771,
234,
788,
250
],
[
792,
234,
825,
250
],
[
829,
234,
858,
249
],
[
862,
234,
901,
249
],
[
905,
233,
932,
249
],
[
138,
252,
181,
266
],
[
185,
252,
244,
267
],
[
247,
252,
268,
267
],
[
271,
251,
375,
267
],
[
379,
251,
419,
268
],
[
422,
251,
458,
268
],
[
461,
251,
523,
268
],
[
526,
251,
595,
268
],
[
598,
251,
622,
268
],
[
625,
251,
654,
268
],
[
656,
251,
727,
268
],
[
730,
251,
785,
268
],
[
788,
251,
805,
267
],
[
808,
251,
837,
267
],
[
840,
251,
908,
267
],
[
138,
270,
181,
284
],
[
184,
270,
202,
284
],
[
205,
270,
278,
284
],
[
281,
270,
331,
284
],
[
334,
270,
351,
284
],
[
354,
270,
402,
285
],
[
405,
270,
424,
285
],
[
427,
270,
451,
285
],
[
454,
269,
538,
285
],
[
542,
269,
560,
285
],
[
562,
269,
598,
285
],
[
601,
269,
635,
285
],
[
642,
269,
671,
285
],
[
674,
269,
752,
284
],
[
755,
269,
790,
284
],
[
794,
269,
824,
284
],
[
828,
269,
841,
284
],
[
844,
268,
891,
284
],
[
894,
268,
908,
283
],
[
138,
287,
189,
303
],
[
192,
286,
236,
303
],
[
240,
286,
266,
302
],
[
270,
286,
325,
302
],
[
330,
286,
425,
302
],
[
430,
286,
452,
301
],
[
457,
286,
495,
301
],
[
498,
286,
519,
301
],
[
522,
286,
595,
301
],
[
598,
286,
679,
301
],
[
682,
286,
700,
301
],
[
702,
286,
733,
301
],
[
736,
286,
798,
301
],
[
801,
286,
831,
302
],
[
833,
287,
861,
302
],
[
139,
304,
217,
320
],
[
220,
304,
271,
320
],
[
274,
304,
355,
320
],
[
358,
304,
381,
320
],
[
384,
304,
415,
320
],
[
420,
303,
484,
320
],
[
487,
303,
597,
320
],
[
612,
303,
664,
320
],
[
667,
303,
730,
320
],
[
734,
303,
795,
320
],
[
798,
303,
815,
320
],
[
820,
303,
844,
320
],
[
848,
303,
902,
320
],
[
139,
321,
231,
336
],
[
235,
321,
256,
336
],
[
260,
321,
295,
336
],
[
299,
322,
318,
337
],
[
322,
322,
412,
337
],
[
415,
322,
443,
337
],
[
449,
322,
510,
337
],
[
513,
322,
593,
337
],
[
596,
322,
613,
337
],
[
616,
322,
671,
337
],
[
674,
322,
691,
337
],
[
694,
322,
733,
336
],
[
736,
321,
772,
336
],
[
776,
321,
887,
336
],
[
138,
338,
184,
353
],
[
187,
339,
204,
353
],
[
207,
339,
244,
353
],
[
247,
339,
273,
353
],
[
276,
339,
339,
354
],
[
342,
339,
386,
354
],
[
389,
339,
408,
354
],
[
412,
339,
444,
354
],
[
447,
340,
530,
354
],
[
534,
339,
610,
354
],
[
614,
339,
633,
354
],
[
637,
339,
672,
353
],
[
676,
339,
738,
353
],
[
742,
339,
821,
353
],
[
824,
338,
855,
353
],
[
138,
356,
222,
371
],
[
226,
356,
244,
371
],
[
247,
356,
273,
371
],
[
277,
356,
308,
371
],
[
311,
355,
350,
371
],
[
353,
355,
380,
371
],
[
384,
355,
444,
371
],
[
448,
355,
520,
371
],
[
523,
355,
547,
371
],
[
550,
355,
586,
371
],
[
590,
355,
602,
371
],
[
619,
355,
685,
371
],
[
688,
355,
740,
371
],
[
744,
355,
820,
371
],
[
824,
355,
840,
370
],
[
844,
355,
866,
370
],
[
870,
355,
912,
370
],
[
139,
372,
224,
389
],
[
228,
373,
319,
390
],
[
323,
373,
355,
390
],
[
359,
374,
430,
390
],
[
434,
374,
452,
390
],
[
457,
374,
467,
390
],
[
471,
374,
531,
390
],
[
534,
374,
578,
390
],
[
582,
374,
605,
390
],
[
610,
374,
699,
390
],
[
703,
374,
732,
390
],
[
738,
374,
799,
390
],
[
803,
374,
883,
389
],
[
887,
374,
902,
389
],
[
142,
390,
245,
406
],
[
249,
391,
291,
406
],
[
294,
391,
321,
406
],
[
325,
391,
368,
406
],
[
372,
391,
401,
406
],
[
405,
391,
439,
406
],
[
443,
391,
471,
406
],
[
475,
391,
550,
406
],
[
554,
391,
575,
406
],
[
579,
391,
664,
406
],
[
667,
391,
685,
406
],
[
688,
391,
718,
406
],
[
721,
391,
739,
406
],
[
742,
391,
786,
406
],
[
789,
391,
880,
406
],
[
177,
421,
189,
436
],
[
192,
421,
265,
436
],
[
268,
422,
314,
437
],
[
318,
422,
374,
437
],
[
377,
422,
460,
437
],
[
463,
422,
481,
437
],
[
485,
422,
511,
437
],
[
515,
422,
552,
437
],
[
555,
422,
617,
437
],
[
620,
422,
629,
437
],
[
632,
422,
664,
437
],
[
668,
422,
751,
436
],
[
754,
422,
798,
436
],
[
802,
421,
834,
436
],
[
837,
421,
881,
436
],
[
139,
439,
211,
454
],
[
214,
440,
260,
454
],
[
263,
440,
306,
454
],
[
309,
440,
392,
454
],
[
396,
441,
413,
454
],
[
417,
441,
444,
454
],
[
448,
441,
482,
454
],
[
485,
441,
515,
454
],
[
518,
440,
578,
454
],
[
582,
440,
592,
454
],
[
595,
440,
627,
454
],
[
630,
440,
714,
454
],
[
717,
440,
733,
454
],
[
737,
440,
762,
454
],
[
765,
439,
802,
453
],
[
808,
439,
860,
453
],
[
863,
438,
891,
453
],
[
137,
456,
177,
471
],
[
180,
456,
198,
471
],
[
201,
456,
247,
471
],
[
250,
456,
260,
471
],
[
262,
456,
295,
471
],
[
298,
456,
382,
470
],
[
385,
456,
404,
470
],
[
407,
456,
469,
470
],
[
472,
456,
504,
470
],
[
507,
456,
600,
470
],
[
602,
456,
623,
470
],
[
627,
456,
667,
470
],
[
670,
456,
750,
470
],
[
753,
456,
800,
470
],
[
803,
456,
824,
470
],
[
827,
455,
912,
470
],
[
140,
473,
156,
489
],
[
160,
473,
186,
489
],
[
190,
473,
241,
489
],
[
245,
473,
257,
489
],
[
261,
473,
290,
489
],
[
294,
474,
365,
490
],
[
370,
474,
400,
490
],
[
404,
474,
413,
490
],
[
417,
474,
472,
490
],
[
476,
474,
502,
490
],
[
506,
474,
520,
490
],
[
524,
474,
550,
490
],
[
554,
474,
600,
490
],
[
603,
474,
620,
490
],
[
624,
474,
682,
490
],
[
687,
474,
706,
490
],
[
710,
474,
814,
490
],
[
818,
473,
854,
489
],
[
858,
473,
895,
489
],
[
139,
490,
191,
506
],
[
194,
490,
215,
506
],
[
219,
490,
253,
506
],
[
257,
491,
273,
506
],
[
277,
491,
300,
506
],
[
304,
491,
345,
506
],
[
348,
491,
429,
506
],
[
432,
491,
456,
506
],
[
460,
492,
515,
506
],
[
519,
492,
602,
507
],
[
605,
492,
622,
506
],
[
625,
492,
654,
506
],
[
657,
492,
720,
506
],
[
723,
491,
754,
506
],
[
757,
491,
821,
506
],
[
824,
491,
924,
506
],
[
140,
508,
189,
523
],
[
192,
508,
228,
523
],
[
232,
508,
312,
523
],
[
315,
508,
348,
524
],
[
352,
508,
377,
524
],
[
380,
508,
456,
524
],
[
460,
508,
493,
524
],
[
497,
508,
522,
524
],
[
526,
508,
566,
524
],
[
570,
508,
595,
524
],
[
600,
508,
650,
524
],
[
654,
508,
713,
524
],
[
717,
508,
785,
524
],
[
788,
508,
812,
524
],
[
815,
508,
861,
523
],
[
138,
525,
221,
542
],
[
225,
526,
242,
542
],
[
245,
526,
278,
542
],
[
282,
526,
377,
542
],
[
381,
526,
411,
542
],
[
415,
526,
488,
542
],
[
492,
526,
516,
542
],
[
520,
526,
551,
542
],
[
554,
525,
644,
542
],
[
648,
525,
694,
542
],
[
698,
525,
718,
541
],
[
721,
525,
752,
541
],
[
756,
525,
791,
541
],
[
795,
525,
834,
541
],
[
838,
525,
922,
541
],
[
139,
543,
155,
558
],
[
159,
543,
188,
558
],
[
192,
544,
222,
559
],
[
226,
544,
262,
559
],
[
265,
544,
301,
559
],
[
306,
544,
345,
559
],
[
349,
544,
373,
559
],
[
377,
544,
449,
559
],
[
452,
545,
477,
559
],
[
480,
545,
541,
559
],
[
545,
545,
577,
559
],
[
580,
545,
677,
559
],
[
680,
545,
712,
559
],
[
716,
545,
784,
559
],
[
788,
545,
870,
558
],
[
872,
544,
906,
558
],
[
139,
560,
170,
575
],
[
174,
560,
227,
575
],
[
230,
560,
267,
575
],
[
272,
560,
289,
575
],
[
292,
560,
335,
575
],
[
338,
560,
358,
575
],
[
362,
560,
395,
575
],
[
398,
560,
481,
575
],
[
484,
560,
537,
575
],
[
540,
560,
562,
575
],
[
565,
560,
645,
575
],
[
648,
560,
678,
575
],
[
681,
560,
722,
575
],
[
725,
560,
751,
575
],
[
754,
560,
791,
576
],
[
794,
560,
855,
576
],
[
858,
560,
917,
576
],
[
140,
579,
185,
593
],
[
188,
578,
242,
593
],
[
246,
578,
329,
594
],
[
332,
578,
350,
594
],
[
354,
578,
387,
594
],
[
390,
578,
427,
594
],
[
431,
578,
460,
594
],
[
463,
578,
535,
594
],
[
538,
578,
557,
594
],
[
562,
578,
639,
594
],
[
642,
578,
674,
594
],
[
677,
578,
733,
594
],
[
736,
578,
820,
594
],
[
822,
578,
841,
594
],
[
844,
578,
872,
594
],
[
875,
578,
894,
594
],
[
896,
578,
907,
594
],
[
140,
595,
211,
610
],
[
214,
596,
239,
610
],
[
242,
596,
290,
610
],
[
293,
596,
309,
611
],
[
312,
596,
351,
611
],
[
354,
596,
382,
611
],
[
388,
596,
460,
611
],
[
464,
596,
485,
611
],
[
489,
596,
521,
611
],
[
525,
596,
554,
611
],
[
558,
596,
587,
611
],
[
590,
596,
612,
611
],
[
617,
595,
700,
611
],
[
702,
595,
720,
611
],
[
724,
595,
761,
611
],
[
767,
595,
837,
611
],
[
840,
595,
862,
611
],
[
866,
595,
898,
610
],
[
138,
612,
227,
627
],
[
230,
613,
268,
628
],
[
272,
613,
326,
628
],
[
329,
613,
357,
628
],
[
360,
613,
391,
628
],
[
394,
613,
466,
628
],
[
469,
613,
485,
628
],
[
489,
613,
525,
628
],
[
528,
613,
541,
628
],
[
545,
613,
588,
628
],
[
592,
613,
611,
628
],
[
614,
613,
647,
628
],
[
650,
613,
741,
628
],
[
744,
613,
766,
628
],
[
769,
613,
850,
628
],
[
142,
630,
223,
646
],
[
227,
630,
244,
646
],
[
247,
630,
283,
646
],
[
287,
630,
348,
646
],
[
352,
630,
398,
646
],
[
402,
630,
456,
646
],
[
460,
630,
544,
646
],
[
548,
630,
565,
646
],
[
568,
630,
599,
646
],
[
145,
665,
170,
679
],
[
174,
665,
230,
680
],
[
232,
665,
286,
680
],
[
289,
665,
307,
680
],
[
310,
665,
398,
681
],
[
401,
665,
491,
681
],
[
174,
695,
210,
710
],
[
215,
695,
285,
710
],
[
288,
695,
305,
710
],
[
309,
695,
329,
710
],
[
332,
695,
402,
711
],
[
406,
696,
432,
711
],
[
435,
696,
520,
711
],
[
524,
696,
544,
711
],
[
548,
696,
632,
711
],
[
635,
696,
652,
711
],
[
655,
696,
684,
711
],
[
687,
696,
702,
711
],
[
706,
695,
732,
711
],
[
735,
695,
765,
711
],
[
770,
695,
833,
711
],
[
838,
695,
927,
711
],
[
140,
714,
199,
728
],
[
202,
713,
234,
728
],
[
237,
713,
273,
728
],
[
278,
713,
363,
728
],
[
366,
713,
398,
728
],
[
401,
713,
414,
729
],
[
417,
713,
467,
729
],
[
470,
713,
492,
729
],
[
495,
713,
514,
729
],
[
517,
713,
564,
729
],
[
567,
713,
585,
729
],
[
588,
713,
624,
729
],
[
627,
713,
702,
729
],
[
705,
713,
722,
729
],
[
725,
713,
782,
729
],
[
786,
713,
858,
729
],
[
861,
714,
924,
729
],
[
110,
770,
120,
783
],
[
124,
770,
136,
783
],
[
139,
771,
163,
784
],
[
166,
771,
201,
784
],
[
204,
771,
235,
784
],
[
115,
784,
122,
796
],
[
125,
784,
137,
797
],
[
140,
785,
176,
798
],
[
179,
786,
265,
799
],
[
268,
788,
321,
799
],
[
324,
788,
362,
799
],
[
124,
800,
137,
812
],
[
140,
800,
163,
812
],
[
166,
800,
190,
813
],
[
193,
800,
203,
813
],
[
206,
800,
235,
813
],
[
239,
801,
278,
814
],
[
281,
801,
303,
814
],
[
306,
801,
334,
814
],
[
338,
802,
401,
814
],
[
404,
802,
460,
815
],
[
462,
802,
483,
815
],
[
487,
803,
518,
815
],
[
521,
803,
543,
815
],
[
546,
803,
579,
815
],
[
582,
803,
616,
815
],
[
619,
803,
630,
815
],
[
633,
803,
680,
815
],
[
683,
802,
740,
815
],
[
743,
802,
758,
815
],
[
761,
802,
793,
814
],
[
796,
802,
842,
814
],
[
845,
801,
870,
814
],
[
873,
801,
888,
814
],
[
891,
801,
922,
814
],
[
110,
814,
128,
826
],
[
131,
814,
142,
826
],
[
145,
814,
217,
826
],
[
219,
815,
230,
826
],
[
233,
815,
284,
826
],
[
287,
815,
320,
826
],
[
323,
815,
385,
826
],
[
124,
828,
143,
839
],
[
145,
828,
182,
839
],
[
184,
828,
259,
839
],
[
261,
828,
304,
839
],
[
307,
829,
332,
839
],
[
335,
829,
344,
839
],
[
347,
829,
377,
840
],
[
380,
829,
388,
840
],
[
391,
829,
417,
840
],
[
420,
829,
450,
840
],
[
452,
829,
464,
840
],
[
466,
829,
499,
840
],
[
502,
829,
543,
840
],
[
546,
829,
577,
840
],
[
579,
829,
611,
840
],
[
614,
829,
641,
840
],
[
643,
829,
692,
840
],
[
694,
829,
706,
840
],
[
708,
829,
725,
840
],
[
727,
828,
793,
840
],
[
795,
828,
831,
840
],
[
833,
828,
859,
840
],
[
861,
828,
882,
840
],
[
884,
828,
909,
840
],
[
911,
828,
932,
840
],
[
111,
840,
120,
850
],
[
122,
840,
151,
850
],
[
154,
840,
162,
851
],
[
165,
840,
236,
851
],
[
239,
840,
253,
851
],
[
256,
840,
270,
851
],
[
272,
840,
327,
851
],
[
330,
840,
341,
851
],
[
344,
840,
362,
851
],
[
364,
840,
422,
851
],
[
424,
840,
435,
851
],
[
438,
840,
454,
851
],
[
457,
840,
487,
851
],
[
490,
840,
508,
851
],
[
510,
840,
528,
851
],
[
530,
840,
571,
851
],
[
573,
840,
583,
851
],
[
585,
840,
615,
851
],
[
618,
840,
636,
851
],
[
638,
840,
689,
851
],
[
691,
840,
705,
851
],
[
707,
840,
758,
851
],
[
760,
840,
778,
851
],
[
781,
840,
837,
851
],
[
839,
840,
850,
851
],
[
852,
840,
871,
851
],
[
873,
840,
894,
851
],
[
896,
840,
915,
851
],
[
110,
853,
151,
863
],
[
153,
853,
174,
863
],
[
177,
853,
216,
863
],
[
218,
853,
230,
863
],
[
232,
853,
245,
863
],
[
248,
853,
304,
863
],
[
307,
853,
317,
863
],
[
320,
853,
336,
863
],
[
338,
853,
378,
863
],
[
381,
853,
438,
864
],
[
440,
853,
462,
864
],
[
465,
853,
503,
864
],
[
505,
853,
527,
864
],
[
529,
853,
547,
864
],
[
549,
853,
599,
864
],
[
601,
853,
631,
864
],
[
634,
853,
647,
864
],
[
650,
853,
690,
864
],
[
693,
853,
745,
864
],
[
748,
853,
758,
863
],
[
761,
853,
774,
863
],
[
777,
853,
831,
863
],
[
834,
853,
845,
863
],
[
848,
853,
866,
863
],
[
868,
853,
888,
863
],
[
891,
852,
919,
863
],
[
112,
864,
126,
874
],
[
128,
864,
170,
875
],
[
172,
864,
219,
875
],
[
221,
864,
237,
875
],
[
239,
864,
268,
875
],
[
271,
864,
293,
875
],
[
295,
864,
317,
875
],
[
320,
864,
358,
875
],
[
361,
864,
381,
875
],
[
384,
864,
402,
875
],
[
404,
864,
444,
875
],
[
447,
864,
465,
875
],
[
468,
864,
525,
875
],
[
528,
864,
561,
875
],
[
563,
864,
583,
875
],
[
585,
864,
623,
875
],
[
625,
864,
665,
875
],
[
668,
864,
721,
875
],
[
723,
864,
744,
875
],
[
746,
864,
772,
875
],
[
775,
864,
791,
875
],
[
794,
864,
816,
875
],
[
818,
864,
851,
875
],
[
854,
864,
908,
875
],
[
112,
875,
152,
886
],
[
155,
875,
176,
886
],
[
178,
875,
230,
887
],
[
232,
875,
242,
887
],
[
245,
875,
275,
887
],
[
278,
876,
324,
887
],
[
327,
876,
348,
887
],
[
351,
876,
415,
887
],
[
418,
876,
431,
887
],
[
434,
876,
470,
887
],
[
473,
876,
528,
887
],
[
531,
876,
541,
887
],
[
544,
876,
565,
887
],
[
568,
876,
585,
887
],
[
588,
875,
638,
887
],
[
640,
875,
658,
887
],
[
661,
875,
694,
887
],
[
697,
875,
709,
887
],
[
712,
875,
741,
887
],
[
744,
875,
797,
887
],
[
108,
887,
532,
900
],
[
124,
900,
138,
911
],
[
140,
900,
164,
911
],
[
166,
901,
192,
911
],
[
194,
901,
205,
911
],
[
207,
901,
235,
911
],
[
511,
914,
530,
927
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
What is the page no mentioned in this document?
|
16
|
737
|
[
"chemicals",
"under",
"\"a",
"single",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"provided",
"the",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential",
"associated",
"with",
"that",
"single",
"use",
"support",
"such",
"a",
"designation.\"",
"But",
"EPA",
"then",
"creates",
"a",
"\"converse\"",
"construct",
"of",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"designation",
"standard",
"to",
"support",
"its",
"position",
"on",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"since",
"it",
"can",
"designate",
"a",
"chemical",
"as",
"a",
"high",
"priority",
"because",
"of",
"the",
"Section",
"6(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"language,",
"\"a",
"potential",
"hazard",
"and",
"a",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,\"2*",
"that",
"low",
"priorities",
"can",
"be",
"so",
"designated",
"only",
"if",
"they",
"don't",
"meet",
"this",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"This",
"argument",
"in",
"the",
"\"converse\"",
"coupled",
"with",
"EPA's",
"interpretation",
"of",
"\"the\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"to",
"mean",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"is",
"strained",
"and",
"counter",
"to",
"Congressional",
"intent.",
"A",
"better",
"interpretation",
"is",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"could",
"be",
"designated",
"low",
"priority",
"if",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk\"",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"for",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"hazard",
"or",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"a,",
"some,",
"or",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"flexibility",
"here",
"that",
"it",
"needs",
"to",
"apply,",
"given",
"the",
"6(b)(1)",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"designate",
"chemicals",
"as",
"low",
"priority",
"and",
"the",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives",
"for",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA's",
"strained",
"reading",
"of",
"the",
"phrase",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"designating",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"wholly",
"at",
"odds",
"with",
"congressional",
"intent",
"to",
"help",
"the",
"Agency",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"resources",
"on",
"high",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"\"",
"Further,",
"EPA's",
"reference",
"to",
"its",
"Safer",
"Chemicals",
"Ingredients",
"List",
"(SCIL)\"",
"as",
"a",
"starting",
"point",
"for",
"identifying",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"disingenuous",
"since",
"the",
"SCIL",
"list",
"does",
"not",
"represent",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"those",
"chemicals.",
"A",
"chemical",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"while",
"that",
"same",
"chemical",
"under",
"other",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"not",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"all.",
"EPA",
"should",
"not",
"have",
"to",
"scope",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"or",
"conduct",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"most",
"chemicals",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"before",
"it",
"can",
"conclude",
"that",
"a",
"certain",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"likely",
"to",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk.",
"EPA",
"should",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"set",
"aside",
"chemicals",
"for",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"through",
"low",
"priority",
"designations",
"where",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"the",
"chemical",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may\"",
"present",
"standard",
"for",
"those",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"Designating",
"low",
"priorities",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"based",
"on",
"less",
"than",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"will",
"help",
"EPA",
"meet",
"its",
"deadlines",
"for",
"scoping",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"will",
"conserve",
"resources,",
"and",
"will",
"enable",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"efforts",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"meet",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"criteria",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"to",
"determine",
"that",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"low",
"potential",
"for",
"risk",
"and",
"can",
"be",
"designated",
"as",
"\"low",
"priority\"",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"should",
"use",
"this",
"authority",
"to",
"help",
"it",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"designated",
"as",
"high",
"priority",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"B.",
"EPA's",
"Abuse",
"of",
"Discretion",
"Argument",
"EPA",
"provides",
"as",
"its",
"rationale",
"for",
"addressing",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"low",
"priority",
"designation",
"process",
"that",
"EPA",
"\"considers",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"an",
"abuse",
"of",
"that",
"discretion",
"to",
"simply",
"disregard",
"known,",
"25",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.at",
"4830.",
"#",
"15",
"U.S.C.",
"2605(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"(emphasis",
"added).",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4829,",
"Section",
"IIIA",
"notes",
"\"conserving",
"resources\"",
"and",
"giving",
"\"the",
"public",
"notice",
"of",
"chemical",
"substances",
"for",
"which",
"potential",
"risks",
"are",
"likely",
"low",
"or",
"nonexistent,\"",
"as",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives.",
"See",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016,",
"at",
"page",
"3519,",
"in",
"which",
"Senator",
"Vitter",
"states:",
"\"The",
"language",
"of",
"the",
"compromise",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"EPA",
"has",
"to",
"make",
"a",
"determination",
"on",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"considered",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"but",
"the",
"Agency",
"is",
"given",
"the",
"discretion",
"to",
"determine",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"will",
"address",
"in",
"its",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"priority",
"chemical.",
"This",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency's",
"focus",
"on",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"he",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"This",
"also",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"can",
"effectively",
"assess",
"and",
"control",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"meet",
"the",
"new",
"law's",
"deadlines.",
"Without",
"this",
"discretion",
"to",
"focus",
"chemical",
"risk",
"assessments",
"on",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"the",
"Agency's",
"job",
"would",
"be",
"more",
"difficult.\"",
"pups:/www.congress.gov/crec/2016/06/07/CREC:2016-06-07-pul-Pes3511.pdf",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4830.",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
140,
64,
217,
80
],
[
221,
65,
268,
80
],
[
271,
65,
290,
80
],
[
294,
65,
342,
80
],
[
346,
65,
421,
80
],
[
424,
65,
442,
80
],
[
445,
65,
477,
80
],
[
480,
65,
552,
80
],
[
556,
65,
581,
80
],
[
585,
65,
639,
80
],
[
642,
65,
672,
80
],
[
676,
65,
747,
80
],
[
750,
64,
821,
80
],
[
825,
64,
908,
80
],
[
139,
82,
175,
97
],
[
178,
82,
210,
97
],
[
212,
82,
261,
97
],
[
264,
82,
292,
97
],
[
295,
82,
355,
97
],
[
359,
82,
397,
97
],
[
401,
82,
414,
97
],
[
417,
82,
522,
97
],
[
537,
82,
566,
97
],
[
570,
82,
607,
97
],
[
612,
82,
647,
97
],
[
650,
82,
706,
97
],
[
710,
82,
719,
97
],
[
722,
82,
812,
97
],
[
815,
82,
888,
97
],
[
891,
82,
912,
97
],
[
138,
99,
163,
115
],
[
167,
99,
202,
115
],
[
206,
99,
270,
115
],
[
274,
100,
363,
115
],
[
367,
100,
434,
115
],
[
437,
100,
454,
115
],
[
458,
100,
517,
115
],
[
521,
101,
540,
115
],
[
544,
100,
611,
115
],
[
614,
100,
634,
115
],
[
637,
100,
667,
115
],
[
671,
100,
735,
115
],
[
739,
99,
840,
115
],
[
844,
99,
880,
114
],
[
140,
118,
218,
132
],
[
222,
117,
252,
132
],
[
256,
117,
298,
132
],
[
301,
117,
314,
132
],
[
317,
117,
346,
132
],
[
353,
117,
425,
132
],
[
428,
117,
438,
132
],
[
441,
117,
515,
132
],
[
518,
117,
536,
132
],
[
540,
117,
549,
132
],
[
552,
117,
590,
132
],
[
592,
117,
652,
132
],
[
655,
117,
721,
132
],
[
724,
117,
742,
131
],
[
745,
117,
771,
131
],
[
774,
117,
830,
131
],
[
141,
133,
239,
150
],
[
244,
134,
318,
150
],
[
323,
134,
342,
150
],
[
346,
134,
415,
150
],
[
420,
134,
474,
150
],
[
478,
134,
508,
150
],
[
512,
134,
521,
150
],
[
525,
134,
595,
150
],
[
599,
134,
642,
150
],
[
646,
134,
662,
150
],
[
667,
134,
738,
150
],
[
741,
134,
788,
150
],
[
791,
134,
818,
150
],
[
822,
134,
905,
150
],
[
908,
134,
927,
150
],
[
138,
151,
192,
167
],
[
196,
151,
227,
167
],
[
231,
151,
261,
167
],
[
264,
151,
337,
168
],
[
341,
151,
369,
168
],
[
372,
151,
393,
168
],
[
397,
151,
417,
168
],
[
422,
151,
504,
168
],
[
508,
151,
544,
168
],
[
548,
151,
561,
168
],
[
564,
151,
603,
168
],
[
607,
151,
646,
168
],
[
649,
151,
689,
168
],
[
692,
151,
721,
168
],
[
724,
151,
761,
168
],
[
764,
151,
827,
168
],
[
830,
151,
900,
167
],
[
138,
170,
185,
184
],
[
188,
170,
210,
184
],
[
213,
169,
298,
184
],
[
300,
169,
319,
185
],
[
322,
169,
357,
185
],
[
360,
169,
394,
185
],
[
397,
169,
472,
185
],
[
475,
169,
494,
185
],
[
497,
169,
522,
185
],
[
525,
169,
614,
185
],
[
617,
169,
681,
185
],
[
685,
169,
722,
185
],
[
725,
169,
777,
185
],
[
781,
168,
887,
184
],
[
891,
168,
912,
184
],
[
141,
185,
181,
201
],
[
185,
185,
268,
201
],
[
271,
185,
289,
201
],
[
292,
185,
320,
201
],
[
323,
185,
340,
201
],
[
343,
185,
388,
202
],
[
391,
185,
430,
202
],
[
434,
185,
517,
202
],
[
520,
186,
538,
202
],
[
541,
186,
568,
202
],
[
572,
186,
587,
202
],
[
590,
186,
655,
202
],
[
658,
186,
688,
202
],
[
691,
186,
751,
202
],
[
754,
186,
772,
202
],
[
775,
186,
888,
202
],
[
138,
203,
189,
218
],
[
175,
234,
188,
249
],
[
192,
234,
238,
249
],
[
242,
234,
349,
249
],
[
352,
234,
368,
249
],
[
371,
234,
402,
249
],
[
405,
234,
415,
249
],
[
419,
234,
492,
250
],
[
495,
234,
540,
250
],
[
543,
234,
565,
250
],
[
570,
234,
652,
250
],
[
655,
234,
684,
250
],
[
690,
234,
750,
250
],
[
754,
234,
767,
250
],
[
771,
234,
788,
250
],
[
792,
234,
825,
250
],
[
829,
234,
858,
249
],
[
862,
234,
901,
249
],
[
905,
233,
932,
249
],
[
138,
252,
181,
266
],
[
185,
252,
244,
267
],
[
247,
252,
268,
267
],
[
271,
251,
375,
267
],
[
379,
251,
419,
268
],
[
422,
251,
458,
268
],
[
461,
251,
523,
268
],
[
526,
251,
595,
268
],
[
598,
251,
622,
268
],
[
625,
251,
654,
268
],
[
656,
251,
727,
268
],
[
730,
251,
785,
268
],
[
788,
251,
805,
267
],
[
808,
251,
837,
267
],
[
840,
251,
908,
267
],
[
138,
270,
181,
284
],
[
184,
270,
202,
284
],
[
205,
270,
278,
284
],
[
281,
270,
331,
284
],
[
334,
270,
351,
284
],
[
354,
270,
402,
285
],
[
405,
270,
424,
285
],
[
427,
270,
451,
285
],
[
454,
269,
538,
285
],
[
542,
269,
560,
285
],
[
562,
269,
598,
285
],
[
601,
269,
635,
285
],
[
642,
269,
671,
285
],
[
674,
269,
752,
284
],
[
755,
269,
790,
284
],
[
794,
269,
824,
284
],
[
828,
269,
841,
284
],
[
844,
268,
891,
284
],
[
894,
268,
908,
283
],
[
138,
287,
189,
303
],
[
192,
286,
236,
303
],
[
240,
286,
266,
302
],
[
270,
286,
325,
302
],
[
330,
286,
425,
302
],
[
430,
286,
452,
301
],
[
457,
286,
495,
301
],
[
498,
286,
519,
301
],
[
522,
286,
595,
301
],
[
598,
286,
679,
301
],
[
682,
286,
700,
301
],
[
702,
286,
733,
301
],
[
736,
286,
798,
301
],
[
801,
286,
831,
302
],
[
833,
287,
861,
302
],
[
139,
304,
217,
320
],
[
220,
304,
271,
320
],
[
274,
304,
355,
320
],
[
358,
304,
381,
320
],
[
384,
304,
415,
320
],
[
420,
303,
484,
320
],
[
487,
303,
597,
320
],
[
612,
303,
664,
320
],
[
667,
303,
730,
320
],
[
734,
303,
795,
320
],
[
798,
303,
815,
320
],
[
820,
303,
844,
320
],
[
848,
303,
902,
320
],
[
139,
321,
231,
336
],
[
235,
321,
256,
336
],
[
260,
321,
295,
336
],
[
299,
322,
318,
337
],
[
322,
322,
412,
337
],
[
415,
322,
443,
337
],
[
449,
322,
510,
337
],
[
513,
322,
593,
337
],
[
596,
322,
613,
337
],
[
616,
322,
671,
337
],
[
674,
322,
691,
337
],
[
694,
322,
733,
336
],
[
736,
321,
772,
336
],
[
776,
321,
887,
336
],
[
138,
338,
184,
353
],
[
187,
339,
204,
353
],
[
207,
339,
244,
353
],
[
247,
339,
273,
353
],
[
276,
339,
339,
354
],
[
342,
339,
386,
354
],
[
389,
339,
408,
354
],
[
412,
339,
444,
354
],
[
447,
340,
530,
354
],
[
534,
339,
610,
354
],
[
614,
339,
633,
354
],
[
637,
339,
672,
353
],
[
676,
339,
738,
353
],
[
742,
339,
821,
353
],
[
824,
338,
855,
353
],
[
138,
356,
222,
371
],
[
226,
356,
244,
371
],
[
247,
356,
273,
371
],
[
277,
356,
308,
371
],
[
311,
355,
350,
371
],
[
353,
355,
380,
371
],
[
384,
355,
444,
371
],
[
448,
355,
520,
371
],
[
523,
355,
547,
371
],
[
550,
355,
586,
371
],
[
590,
355,
602,
371
],
[
619,
355,
685,
371
],
[
688,
355,
740,
371
],
[
744,
355,
820,
371
],
[
824,
355,
840,
370
],
[
844,
355,
866,
370
],
[
870,
355,
912,
370
],
[
139,
372,
224,
389
],
[
228,
373,
319,
390
],
[
323,
373,
355,
390
],
[
359,
374,
430,
390
],
[
434,
374,
452,
390
],
[
457,
374,
467,
390
],
[
471,
374,
531,
390
],
[
534,
374,
578,
390
],
[
582,
374,
605,
390
],
[
610,
374,
699,
390
],
[
703,
374,
732,
390
],
[
738,
374,
799,
390
],
[
803,
374,
883,
389
],
[
887,
374,
902,
389
],
[
142,
390,
245,
406
],
[
249,
391,
291,
406
],
[
294,
391,
321,
406
],
[
325,
391,
368,
406
],
[
372,
391,
401,
406
],
[
405,
391,
439,
406
],
[
443,
391,
471,
406
],
[
475,
391,
550,
406
],
[
554,
391,
575,
406
],
[
579,
391,
664,
406
],
[
667,
391,
685,
406
],
[
688,
391,
718,
406
],
[
721,
391,
739,
406
],
[
742,
391,
786,
406
],
[
789,
391,
880,
406
],
[
177,
421,
189,
436
],
[
192,
421,
265,
436
],
[
268,
422,
314,
437
],
[
318,
422,
374,
437
],
[
377,
422,
460,
437
],
[
463,
422,
481,
437
],
[
485,
422,
511,
437
],
[
515,
422,
552,
437
],
[
555,
422,
617,
437
],
[
620,
422,
629,
437
],
[
632,
422,
664,
437
],
[
668,
422,
751,
436
],
[
754,
422,
798,
436
],
[
802,
421,
834,
436
],
[
837,
421,
881,
436
],
[
139,
439,
211,
454
],
[
214,
440,
260,
454
],
[
263,
440,
306,
454
],
[
309,
440,
392,
454
],
[
396,
441,
413,
454
],
[
417,
441,
444,
454
],
[
448,
441,
482,
454
],
[
485,
441,
515,
454
],
[
518,
440,
578,
454
],
[
582,
440,
592,
454
],
[
595,
440,
627,
454
],
[
630,
440,
714,
454
],
[
717,
440,
733,
454
],
[
737,
440,
762,
454
],
[
765,
439,
802,
453
],
[
808,
439,
860,
453
],
[
863,
438,
891,
453
],
[
137,
456,
177,
471
],
[
180,
456,
198,
471
],
[
201,
456,
247,
471
],
[
250,
456,
260,
471
],
[
262,
456,
295,
471
],
[
298,
456,
382,
470
],
[
385,
456,
404,
470
],
[
407,
456,
469,
470
],
[
472,
456,
504,
470
],
[
507,
456,
600,
470
],
[
602,
456,
623,
470
],
[
627,
456,
667,
470
],
[
670,
456,
750,
470
],
[
753,
456,
800,
470
],
[
803,
456,
824,
470
],
[
827,
455,
912,
470
],
[
140,
473,
156,
489
],
[
160,
473,
186,
489
],
[
190,
473,
241,
489
],
[
245,
473,
257,
489
],
[
261,
473,
290,
489
],
[
294,
474,
365,
490
],
[
370,
474,
400,
490
],
[
404,
474,
413,
490
],
[
417,
474,
472,
490
],
[
476,
474,
502,
490
],
[
506,
474,
520,
490
],
[
524,
474,
550,
490
],
[
554,
474,
600,
490
],
[
603,
474,
620,
490
],
[
624,
474,
682,
490
],
[
687,
474,
706,
490
],
[
710,
474,
814,
490
],
[
818,
473,
854,
489
],
[
858,
473,
895,
489
],
[
139,
490,
191,
506
],
[
194,
490,
215,
506
],
[
219,
490,
253,
506
],
[
257,
491,
273,
506
],
[
277,
491,
300,
506
],
[
304,
491,
345,
506
],
[
348,
491,
429,
506
],
[
432,
491,
456,
506
],
[
460,
492,
515,
506
],
[
519,
492,
602,
507
],
[
605,
492,
622,
506
],
[
625,
492,
654,
506
],
[
657,
492,
720,
506
],
[
723,
491,
754,
506
],
[
757,
491,
821,
506
],
[
824,
491,
924,
506
],
[
140,
508,
189,
523
],
[
192,
508,
228,
523
],
[
232,
508,
312,
523
],
[
315,
508,
348,
524
],
[
352,
508,
377,
524
],
[
380,
508,
456,
524
],
[
460,
508,
493,
524
],
[
497,
508,
522,
524
],
[
526,
508,
566,
524
],
[
570,
508,
595,
524
],
[
600,
508,
650,
524
],
[
654,
508,
713,
524
],
[
717,
508,
785,
524
],
[
788,
508,
812,
524
],
[
815,
508,
861,
523
],
[
138,
525,
221,
542
],
[
225,
526,
242,
542
],
[
245,
526,
278,
542
],
[
282,
526,
377,
542
],
[
381,
526,
411,
542
],
[
415,
526,
488,
542
],
[
492,
526,
516,
542
],
[
520,
526,
551,
542
],
[
554,
525,
644,
542
],
[
648,
525,
694,
542
],
[
698,
525,
718,
541
],
[
721,
525,
752,
541
],
[
756,
525,
791,
541
],
[
795,
525,
834,
541
],
[
838,
525,
922,
541
],
[
139,
543,
155,
558
],
[
159,
543,
188,
558
],
[
192,
544,
222,
559
],
[
226,
544,
262,
559
],
[
265,
544,
301,
559
],
[
306,
544,
345,
559
],
[
349,
544,
373,
559
],
[
377,
544,
449,
559
],
[
452,
545,
477,
559
],
[
480,
545,
541,
559
],
[
545,
545,
577,
559
],
[
580,
545,
677,
559
],
[
680,
545,
712,
559
],
[
716,
545,
784,
559
],
[
788,
545,
870,
558
],
[
872,
544,
906,
558
],
[
139,
560,
170,
575
],
[
174,
560,
227,
575
],
[
230,
560,
267,
575
],
[
272,
560,
289,
575
],
[
292,
560,
335,
575
],
[
338,
560,
358,
575
],
[
362,
560,
395,
575
],
[
398,
560,
481,
575
],
[
484,
560,
537,
575
],
[
540,
560,
562,
575
],
[
565,
560,
645,
575
],
[
648,
560,
678,
575
],
[
681,
560,
722,
575
],
[
725,
560,
751,
575
],
[
754,
560,
791,
576
],
[
794,
560,
855,
576
],
[
858,
560,
917,
576
],
[
140,
579,
185,
593
],
[
188,
578,
242,
593
],
[
246,
578,
329,
594
],
[
332,
578,
350,
594
],
[
354,
578,
387,
594
],
[
390,
578,
427,
594
],
[
431,
578,
460,
594
],
[
463,
578,
535,
594
],
[
538,
578,
557,
594
],
[
562,
578,
639,
594
],
[
642,
578,
674,
594
],
[
677,
578,
733,
594
],
[
736,
578,
820,
594
],
[
822,
578,
841,
594
],
[
844,
578,
872,
594
],
[
875,
578,
894,
594
],
[
896,
578,
907,
594
],
[
140,
595,
211,
610
],
[
214,
596,
239,
610
],
[
242,
596,
290,
610
],
[
293,
596,
309,
611
],
[
312,
596,
351,
611
],
[
354,
596,
382,
611
],
[
388,
596,
460,
611
],
[
464,
596,
485,
611
],
[
489,
596,
521,
611
],
[
525,
596,
554,
611
],
[
558,
596,
587,
611
],
[
590,
596,
612,
611
],
[
617,
595,
700,
611
],
[
702,
595,
720,
611
],
[
724,
595,
761,
611
],
[
767,
595,
837,
611
],
[
840,
595,
862,
611
],
[
866,
595,
898,
610
],
[
138,
612,
227,
627
],
[
230,
613,
268,
628
],
[
272,
613,
326,
628
],
[
329,
613,
357,
628
],
[
360,
613,
391,
628
],
[
394,
613,
466,
628
],
[
469,
613,
485,
628
],
[
489,
613,
525,
628
],
[
528,
613,
541,
628
],
[
545,
613,
588,
628
],
[
592,
613,
611,
628
],
[
614,
613,
647,
628
],
[
650,
613,
741,
628
],
[
744,
613,
766,
628
],
[
769,
613,
850,
628
],
[
142,
630,
223,
646
],
[
227,
630,
244,
646
],
[
247,
630,
283,
646
],
[
287,
630,
348,
646
],
[
352,
630,
398,
646
],
[
402,
630,
456,
646
],
[
460,
630,
544,
646
],
[
548,
630,
565,
646
],
[
568,
630,
599,
646
],
[
145,
665,
170,
679
],
[
174,
665,
230,
680
],
[
232,
665,
286,
680
],
[
289,
665,
307,
680
],
[
310,
665,
398,
681
],
[
401,
665,
491,
681
],
[
174,
695,
210,
710
],
[
215,
695,
285,
710
],
[
288,
695,
305,
710
],
[
309,
695,
329,
710
],
[
332,
695,
402,
711
],
[
406,
696,
432,
711
],
[
435,
696,
520,
711
],
[
524,
696,
544,
711
],
[
548,
696,
632,
711
],
[
635,
696,
652,
711
],
[
655,
696,
684,
711
],
[
687,
696,
702,
711
],
[
706,
695,
732,
711
],
[
735,
695,
765,
711
],
[
770,
695,
833,
711
],
[
838,
695,
927,
711
],
[
140,
714,
199,
728
],
[
202,
713,
234,
728
],
[
237,
713,
273,
728
],
[
278,
713,
363,
728
],
[
366,
713,
398,
728
],
[
401,
713,
414,
729
],
[
417,
713,
467,
729
],
[
470,
713,
492,
729
],
[
495,
713,
514,
729
],
[
517,
713,
564,
729
],
[
567,
713,
585,
729
],
[
588,
713,
624,
729
],
[
627,
713,
702,
729
],
[
705,
713,
722,
729
],
[
725,
713,
782,
729
],
[
786,
713,
858,
729
],
[
861,
714,
924,
729
],
[
110,
770,
120,
783
],
[
124,
770,
136,
783
],
[
139,
771,
163,
784
],
[
166,
771,
201,
784
],
[
204,
771,
235,
784
],
[
115,
784,
122,
796
],
[
125,
784,
137,
797
],
[
140,
785,
176,
798
],
[
179,
786,
265,
799
],
[
268,
788,
321,
799
],
[
324,
788,
362,
799
],
[
124,
800,
137,
812
],
[
140,
800,
163,
812
],
[
166,
800,
190,
813
],
[
193,
800,
203,
813
],
[
206,
800,
235,
813
],
[
239,
801,
278,
814
],
[
281,
801,
303,
814
],
[
306,
801,
334,
814
],
[
338,
802,
401,
814
],
[
404,
802,
460,
815
],
[
462,
802,
483,
815
],
[
487,
803,
518,
815
],
[
521,
803,
543,
815
],
[
546,
803,
579,
815
],
[
582,
803,
616,
815
],
[
619,
803,
630,
815
],
[
633,
803,
680,
815
],
[
683,
802,
740,
815
],
[
743,
802,
758,
815
],
[
761,
802,
793,
814
],
[
796,
802,
842,
814
],
[
845,
801,
870,
814
],
[
873,
801,
888,
814
],
[
891,
801,
922,
814
],
[
110,
814,
128,
826
],
[
131,
814,
142,
826
],
[
145,
814,
217,
826
],
[
219,
815,
230,
826
],
[
233,
815,
284,
826
],
[
287,
815,
320,
826
],
[
323,
815,
385,
826
],
[
124,
828,
143,
839
],
[
145,
828,
182,
839
],
[
184,
828,
259,
839
],
[
261,
828,
304,
839
],
[
307,
829,
332,
839
],
[
335,
829,
344,
839
],
[
347,
829,
377,
840
],
[
380,
829,
388,
840
],
[
391,
829,
417,
840
],
[
420,
829,
450,
840
],
[
452,
829,
464,
840
],
[
466,
829,
499,
840
],
[
502,
829,
543,
840
],
[
546,
829,
577,
840
],
[
579,
829,
611,
840
],
[
614,
829,
641,
840
],
[
643,
829,
692,
840
],
[
694,
829,
706,
840
],
[
708,
829,
725,
840
],
[
727,
828,
793,
840
],
[
795,
828,
831,
840
],
[
833,
828,
859,
840
],
[
861,
828,
882,
840
],
[
884,
828,
909,
840
],
[
911,
828,
932,
840
],
[
111,
840,
120,
850
],
[
122,
840,
151,
850
],
[
154,
840,
162,
851
],
[
165,
840,
236,
851
],
[
239,
840,
253,
851
],
[
256,
840,
270,
851
],
[
272,
840,
327,
851
],
[
330,
840,
341,
851
],
[
344,
840,
362,
851
],
[
364,
840,
422,
851
],
[
424,
840,
435,
851
],
[
438,
840,
454,
851
],
[
457,
840,
487,
851
],
[
490,
840,
508,
851
],
[
510,
840,
528,
851
],
[
530,
840,
571,
851
],
[
573,
840,
583,
851
],
[
585,
840,
615,
851
],
[
618,
840,
636,
851
],
[
638,
840,
689,
851
],
[
691,
840,
705,
851
],
[
707,
840,
758,
851
],
[
760,
840,
778,
851
],
[
781,
840,
837,
851
],
[
839,
840,
850,
851
],
[
852,
840,
871,
851
],
[
873,
840,
894,
851
],
[
896,
840,
915,
851
],
[
110,
853,
151,
863
],
[
153,
853,
174,
863
],
[
177,
853,
216,
863
],
[
218,
853,
230,
863
],
[
232,
853,
245,
863
],
[
248,
853,
304,
863
],
[
307,
853,
317,
863
],
[
320,
853,
336,
863
],
[
338,
853,
378,
863
],
[
381,
853,
438,
864
],
[
440,
853,
462,
864
],
[
465,
853,
503,
864
],
[
505,
853,
527,
864
],
[
529,
853,
547,
864
],
[
549,
853,
599,
864
],
[
601,
853,
631,
864
],
[
634,
853,
647,
864
],
[
650,
853,
690,
864
],
[
693,
853,
745,
864
],
[
748,
853,
758,
863
],
[
761,
853,
774,
863
],
[
777,
853,
831,
863
],
[
834,
853,
845,
863
],
[
848,
853,
866,
863
],
[
868,
853,
888,
863
],
[
891,
852,
919,
863
],
[
112,
864,
126,
874
],
[
128,
864,
170,
875
],
[
172,
864,
219,
875
],
[
221,
864,
237,
875
],
[
239,
864,
268,
875
],
[
271,
864,
293,
875
],
[
295,
864,
317,
875
],
[
320,
864,
358,
875
],
[
361,
864,
381,
875
],
[
384,
864,
402,
875
],
[
404,
864,
444,
875
],
[
447,
864,
465,
875
],
[
468,
864,
525,
875
],
[
528,
864,
561,
875
],
[
563,
864,
583,
875
],
[
585,
864,
623,
875
],
[
625,
864,
665,
875
],
[
668,
864,
721,
875
],
[
723,
864,
744,
875
],
[
746,
864,
772,
875
],
[
775,
864,
791,
875
],
[
794,
864,
816,
875
],
[
818,
864,
851,
875
],
[
854,
864,
908,
875
],
[
112,
875,
152,
886
],
[
155,
875,
176,
886
],
[
178,
875,
230,
887
],
[
232,
875,
242,
887
],
[
245,
875,
275,
887
],
[
278,
876,
324,
887
],
[
327,
876,
348,
887
],
[
351,
876,
415,
887
],
[
418,
876,
431,
887
],
[
434,
876,
470,
887
],
[
473,
876,
528,
887
],
[
531,
876,
541,
887
],
[
544,
876,
565,
887
],
[
568,
876,
585,
887
],
[
588,
875,
638,
887
],
[
640,
875,
658,
887
],
[
661,
875,
694,
887
],
[
697,
875,
709,
887
],
[
712,
875,
741,
887
],
[
744,
875,
797,
887
],
[
108,
887,
532,
900
],
[
124,
900,
138,
911
],
[
140,
900,
164,
911
],
[
166,
901,
192,
911
],
[
194,
901,
205,
911
],
[
207,
901,
235,
911
],
[
511,
914,
530,
927
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
What is the subheading given in this document?
|
EPA's Abuse of Discretion Argument
|
737
|
[
"chemicals",
"under",
"\"a",
"single",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"provided",
"the",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"potential",
"associated",
"with",
"that",
"single",
"use",
"support",
"such",
"a",
"designation.\"",
"But",
"EPA",
"then",
"creates",
"a",
"\"converse\"",
"construct",
"of",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"designation",
"standard",
"to",
"support",
"its",
"position",
"on",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"since",
"it",
"can",
"designate",
"a",
"chemical",
"as",
"a",
"high",
"priority",
"because",
"of",
"the",
"Section",
"6(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"language,",
"\"a",
"potential",
"hazard",
"and",
"a",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,\"2*",
"that",
"low",
"priorities",
"can",
"be",
"so",
"designated",
"only",
"if",
"they",
"don't",
"meet",
"this",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"This",
"argument",
"in",
"the",
"\"converse\"",
"coupled",
"with",
"EPA's",
"interpretation",
"of",
"\"the\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"to",
"mean",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"is",
"strained",
"and",
"counter",
"to",
"Congressional",
"intent.",
"A",
"better",
"interpretation",
"is",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"could",
"be",
"designated",
"low",
"priority",
"if",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk\"",
"high",
"priority",
"standard",
"for",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"hazard",
"or",
"\"a\"",
"potential",
"route",
"of",
"exposure",
"under",
"a,",
"some,",
"or",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"flexibility",
"here",
"that",
"it",
"needs",
"to",
"apply,",
"given",
"the",
"6(b)(1)",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"designate",
"chemicals",
"as",
"low",
"priority",
"and",
"the",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives",
"for",
"low",
"priority",
"designations.",
"EPA's",
"strained",
"reading",
"of",
"the",
"phrase",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"designating",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"wholly",
"at",
"odds",
"with",
"congressional",
"intent",
"to",
"help",
"the",
"Agency",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"resources",
"on",
"high",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"the",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"\"",
"Further,",
"EPA's",
"reference",
"to",
"its",
"Safer",
"Chemicals",
"Ingredients",
"List",
"(SCIL)\"",
"as",
"a",
"starting",
"point",
"for",
"identifying",
"low",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"disingenuous",
"since",
"the",
"SCIL",
"list",
"does",
"not",
"represent",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"those",
"chemicals.",
"A",
"chemical",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"while",
"that",
"same",
"chemical",
"under",
"other",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"may",
"not",
"warrant",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"all.",
"EPA",
"should",
"not",
"have",
"to",
"scope",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"or",
"conduct",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"most",
"chemicals",
"under",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"before",
"it",
"can",
"conclude",
"that",
"a",
"certain",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"likely",
"to",
"present",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk.",
"EPA",
"should",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"set",
"aside",
"chemicals",
"for",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"through",
"low",
"priority",
"designations",
"where",
"EPA",
"concludes",
"that",
"the",
"chemical",
"does",
"not",
"meet",
"the",
"\"may\"",
"present",
"standard",
"for",
"those",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"Designating",
"low",
"priorities",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"based",
"on",
"less",
"than",
"\"all\"",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"will",
"help",
"EPA",
"meet",
"its",
"deadlines",
"for",
"scoping",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"will",
"conserve",
"resources,",
"and",
"will",
"enable",
"EPA",
"to",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"efforts",
"on",
"chemicals",
"that",
"meet",
"the",
"high",
"priority",
"criteria",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"to",
"determine",
"that",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"are",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"low",
"potential",
"for",
"risk",
"and",
"can",
"be",
"designated",
"as",
"\"low",
"priority\"",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"EPA",
"should",
"use",
"this",
"authority",
"to",
"help",
"it",
"focus",
"its",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"chemicals",
"designated",
"as",
"high",
"priority",
"under",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use.",
"B.",
"EPA's",
"Abuse",
"of",
"Discretion",
"Argument",
"EPA",
"provides",
"as",
"its",
"rationale",
"for",
"addressing",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"low",
"priority",
"designation",
"process",
"that",
"EPA",
"\"considers",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"an",
"abuse",
"of",
"that",
"discretion",
"to",
"simply",
"disregard",
"known,",
"25",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.at",
"4830.",
"#",
"15",
"U.S.C.",
"2605(b)(1)(B)(i)",
"(emphasis",
"added).",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4829,",
"Section",
"IIIA",
"notes",
"\"conserving",
"resources\"",
"and",
"giving",
"\"the",
"public",
"notice",
"of",
"chemical",
"substances",
"for",
"which",
"potential",
"risks",
"are",
"likely",
"low",
"or",
"nonexistent,\"",
"as",
"important",
"policy",
"objectives.",
"See",
"Senate",
"Congressional",
"Record,",
"June",
"7,",
"2016,",
"at",
"page",
"3519,",
"in",
"which",
"Senator",
"Vitter",
"states:",
"\"The",
"language",
"of",
"the",
"compromise",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"EPA",
"has",
"to",
"make",
"a",
"determination",
"on",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"considered",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"but",
"the",
"Agency",
"is",
"given",
"the",
"discretion",
"to",
"determine",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"will",
"address",
"in",
"its",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"priority",
"chemical.",
"This",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency's",
"focus",
"on",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"is",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"raise",
"he",
"greatest",
"potential",
"for",
"risk.",
"This",
"also",
"assures",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"can",
"effectively",
"assess",
"and",
"control",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"and",
"meet",
"the",
"new",
"law's",
"deadlines.",
"Without",
"this",
"discretion",
"to",
"focus",
"chemical",
"risk",
"assessments",
"on",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use,",
"the",
"Agency's",
"job",
"would",
"be",
"more",
"difficult.\"",
"pups:/www.congress.gov/crec/2016/06/07/CREC:2016-06-07-pul-Pes3511.pdf",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"4830.",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
140,
64,
217,
80
],
[
221,
65,
268,
80
],
[
271,
65,
290,
80
],
[
294,
65,
342,
80
],
[
346,
65,
421,
80
],
[
424,
65,
442,
80
],
[
445,
65,
477,
80
],
[
480,
65,
552,
80
],
[
556,
65,
581,
80
],
[
585,
65,
639,
80
],
[
642,
65,
672,
80
],
[
676,
65,
747,
80
],
[
750,
64,
821,
80
],
[
825,
64,
908,
80
],
[
139,
82,
175,
97
],
[
178,
82,
210,
97
],
[
212,
82,
261,
97
],
[
264,
82,
292,
97
],
[
295,
82,
355,
97
],
[
359,
82,
397,
97
],
[
401,
82,
414,
97
],
[
417,
82,
522,
97
],
[
537,
82,
566,
97
],
[
570,
82,
607,
97
],
[
612,
82,
647,
97
],
[
650,
82,
706,
97
],
[
710,
82,
719,
97
],
[
722,
82,
812,
97
],
[
815,
82,
888,
97
],
[
891,
82,
912,
97
],
[
138,
99,
163,
115
],
[
167,
99,
202,
115
],
[
206,
99,
270,
115
],
[
274,
100,
363,
115
],
[
367,
100,
434,
115
],
[
437,
100,
454,
115
],
[
458,
100,
517,
115
],
[
521,
101,
540,
115
],
[
544,
100,
611,
115
],
[
614,
100,
634,
115
],
[
637,
100,
667,
115
],
[
671,
100,
735,
115
],
[
739,
99,
840,
115
],
[
844,
99,
880,
114
],
[
140,
118,
218,
132
],
[
222,
117,
252,
132
],
[
256,
117,
298,
132
],
[
301,
117,
314,
132
],
[
317,
117,
346,
132
],
[
353,
117,
425,
132
],
[
428,
117,
438,
132
],
[
441,
117,
515,
132
],
[
518,
117,
536,
132
],
[
540,
117,
549,
132
],
[
552,
117,
590,
132
],
[
592,
117,
652,
132
],
[
655,
117,
721,
132
],
[
724,
117,
742,
131
],
[
745,
117,
771,
131
],
[
774,
117,
830,
131
],
[
141,
133,
239,
150
],
[
244,
134,
318,
150
],
[
323,
134,
342,
150
],
[
346,
134,
415,
150
],
[
420,
134,
474,
150
],
[
478,
134,
508,
150
],
[
512,
134,
521,
150
],
[
525,
134,
595,
150
],
[
599,
134,
642,
150
],
[
646,
134,
662,
150
],
[
667,
134,
738,
150
],
[
741,
134,
788,
150
],
[
791,
134,
818,
150
],
[
822,
134,
905,
150
],
[
908,
134,
927,
150
],
[
138,
151,
192,
167
],
[
196,
151,
227,
167
],
[
231,
151,
261,
167
],
[
264,
151,
337,
168
],
[
341,
151,
369,
168
],
[
372,
151,
393,
168
],
[
397,
151,
417,
168
],
[
422,
151,
504,
168
],
[
508,
151,
544,
168
],
[
548,
151,
561,
168
],
[
564,
151,
603,
168
],
[
607,
151,
646,
168
],
[
649,
151,
689,
168
],
[
692,
151,
721,
168
],
[
724,
151,
761,
168
],
[
764,
151,
827,
168
],
[
830,
151,
900,
167
],
[
138,
170,
185,
184
],
[
188,
170,
210,
184
],
[
213,
169,
298,
184
],
[
300,
169,
319,
185
],
[
322,
169,
357,
185
],
[
360,
169,
394,
185
],
[
397,
169,
472,
185
],
[
475,
169,
494,
185
],
[
497,
169,
522,
185
],
[
525,
169,
614,
185
],
[
617,
169,
681,
185
],
[
685,
169,
722,
185
],
[
725,
169,
777,
185
],
[
781,
168,
887,
184
],
[
891,
168,
912,
184
],
[
141,
185,
181,
201
],
[
185,
185,
268,
201
],
[
271,
185,
289,
201
],
[
292,
185,
320,
201
],
[
323,
185,
340,
201
],
[
343,
185,
388,
202
],
[
391,
185,
430,
202
],
[
434,
185,
517,
202
],
[
520,
186,
538,
202
],
[
541,
186,
568,
202
],
[
572,
186,
587,
202
],
[
590,
186,
655,
202
],
[
658,
186,
688,
202
],
[
691,
186,
751,
202
],
[
754,
186,
772,
202
],
[
775,
186,
888,
202
],
[
138,
203,
189,
218
],
[
175,
234,
188,
249
],
[
192,
234,
238,
249
],
[
242,
234,
349,
249
],
[
352,
234,
368,
249
],
[
371,
234,
402,
249
],
[
405,
234,
415,
249
],
[
419,
234,
492,
250
],
[
495,
234,
540,
250
],
[
543,
234,
565,
250
],
[
570,
234,
652,
250
],
[
655,
234,
684,
250
],
[
690,
234,
750,
250
],
[
754,
234,
767,
250
],
[
771,
234,
788,
250
],
[
792,
234,
825,
250
],
[
829,
234,
858,
249
],
[
862,
234,
901,
249
],
[
905,
233,
932,
249
],
[
138,
252,
181,
266
],
[
185,
252,
244,
267
],
[
247,
252,
268,
267
],
[
271,
251,
375,
267
],
[
379,
251,
419,
268
],
[
422,
251,
458,
268
],
[
461,
251,
523,
268
],
[
526,
251,
595,
268
],
[
598,
251,
622,
268
],
[
625,
251,
654,
268
],
[
656,
251,
727,
268
],
[
730,
251,
785,
268
],
[
788,
251,
805,
267
],
[
808,
251,
837,
267
],
[
840,
251,
908,
267
],
[
138,
270,
181,
284
],
[
184,
270,
202,
284
],
[
205,
270,
278,
284
],
[
281,
270,
331,
284
],
[
334,
270,
351,
284
],
[
354,
270,
402,
285
],
[
405,
270,
424,
285
],
[
427,
270,
451,
285
],
[
454,
269,
538,
285
],
[
542,
269,
560,
285
],
[
562,
269,
598,
285
],
[
601,
269,
635,
285
],
[
642,
269,
671,
285
],
[
674,
269,
752,
284
],
[
755,
269,
790,
284
],
[
794,
269,
824,
284
],
[
828,
269,
841,
284
],
[
844,
268,
891,
284
],
[
894,
268,
908,
283
],
[
138,
287,
189,
303
],
[
192,
286,
236,
303
],
[
240,
286,
266,
302
],
[
270,
286,
325,
302
],
[
330,
286,
425,
302
],
[
430,
286,
452,
301
],
[
457,
286,
495,
301
],
[
498,
286,
519,
301
],
[
522,
286,
595,
301
],
[
598,
286,
679,
301
],
[
682,
286,
700,
301
],
[
702,
286,
733,
301
],
[
736,
286,
798,
301
],
[
801,
286,
831,
302
],
[
833,
287,
861,
302
],
[
139,
304,
217,
320
],
[
220,
304,
271,
320
],
[
274,
304,
355,
320
],
[
358,
304,
381,
320
],
[
384,
304,
415,
320
],
[
420,
303,
484,
320
],
[
487,
303,
597,
320
],
[
612,
303,
664,
320
],
[
667,
303,
730,
320
],
[
734,
303,
795,
320
],
[
798,
303,
815,
320
],
[
820,
303,
844,
320
],
[
848,
303,
902,
320
],
[
139,
321,
231,
336
],
[
235,
321,
256,
336
],
[
260,
321,
295,
336
],
[
299,
322,
318,
337
],
[
322,
322,
412,
337
],
[
415,
322,
443,
337
],
[
449,
322,
510,
337
],
[
513,
322,
593,
337
],
[
596,
322,
613,
337
],
[
616,
322,
671,
337
],
[
674,
322,
691,
337
],
[
694,
322,
733,
336
],
[
736,
321,
772,
336
],
[
776,
321,
887,
336
],
[
138,
338,
184,
353
],
[
187,
339,
204,
353
],
[
207,
339,
244,
353
],
[
247,
339,
273,
353
],
[
276,
339,
339,
354
],
[
342,
339,
386,
354
],
[
389,
339,
408,
354
],
[
412,
339,
444,
354
],
[
447,
340,
530,
354
],
[
534,
339,
610,
354
],
[
614,
339,
633,
354
],
[
637,
339,
672,
353
],
[
676,
339,
738,
353
],
[
742,
339,
821,
353
],
[
824,
338,
855,
353
],
[
138,
356,
222,
371
],
[
226,
356,
244,
371
],
[
247,
356,
273,
371
],
[
277,
356,
308,
371
],
[
311,
355,
350,
371
],
[
353,
355,
380,
371
],
[
384,
355,
444,
371
],
[
448,
355,
520,
371
],
[
523,
355,
547,
371
],
[
550,
355,
586,
371
],
[
590,
355,
602,
371
],
[
619,
355,
685,
371
],
[
688,
355,
740,
371
],
[
744,
355,
820,
371
],
[
824,
355,
840,
370
],
[
844,
355,
866,
370
],
[
870,
355,
912,
370
],
[
139,
372,
224,
389
],
[
228,
373,
319,
390
],
[
323,
373,
355,
390
],
[
359,
374,
430,
390
],
[
434,
374,
452,
390
],
[
457,
374,
467,
390
],
[
471,
374,
531,
390
],
[
534,
374,
578,
390
],
[
582,
374,
605,
390
],
[
610,
374,
699,
390
],
[
703,
374,
732,
390
],
[
738,
374,
799,
390
],
[
803,
374,
883,
389
],
[
887,
374,
902,
389
],
[
142,
390,
245,
406
],
[
249,
391,
291,
406
],
[
294,
391,
321,
406
],
[
325,
391,
368,
406
],
[
372,
391,
401,
406
],
[
405,
391,
439,
406
],
[
443,
391,
471,
406
],
[
475,
391,
550,
406
],
[
554,
391,
575,
406
],
[
579,
391,
664,
406
],
[
667,
391,
685,
406
],
[
688,
391,
718,
406
],
[
721,
391,
739,
406
],
[
742,
391,
786,
406
],
[
789,
391,
880,
406
],
[
177,
421,
189,
436
],
[
192,
421,
265,
436
],
[
268,
422,
314,
437
],
[
318,
422,
374,
437
],
[
377,
422,
460,
437
],
[
463,
422,
481,
437
],
[
485,
422,
511,
437
],
[
515,
422,
552,
437
],
[
555,
422,
617,
437
],
[
620,
422,
629,
437
],
[
632,
422,
664,
437
],
[
668,
422,
751,
436
],
[
754,
422,
798,
436
],
[
802,
421,
834,
436
],
[
837,
421,
881,
436
],
[
139,
439,
211,
454
],
[
214,
440,
260,
454
],
[
263,
440,
306,
454
],
[
309,
440,
392,
454
],
[
396,
441,
413,
454
],
[
417,
441,
444,
454
],
[
448,
441,
482,
454
],
[
485,
441,
515,
454
],
[
518,
440,
578,
454
],
[
582,
440,
592,
454
],
[
595,
440,
627,
454
],
[
630,
440,
714,
454
],
[
717,
440,
733,
454
],
[
737,
440,
762,
454
],
[
765,
439,
802,
453
],
[
808,
439,
860,
453
],
[
863,
438,
891,
453
],
[
137,
456,
177,
471
],
[
180,
456,
198,
471
],
[
201,
456,
247,
471
],
[
250,
456,
260,
471
],
[
262,
456,
295,
471
],
[
298,
456,
382,
470
],
[
385,
456,
404,
470
],
[
407,
456,
469,
470
],
[
472,
456,
504,
470
],
[
507,
456,
600,
470
],
[
602,
456,
623,
470
],
[
627,
456,
667,
470
],
[
670,
456,
750,
470
],
[
753,
456,
800,
470
],
[
803,
456,
824,
470
],
[
827,
455,
912,
470
],
[
140,
473,
156,
489
],
[
160,
473,
186,
489
],
[
190,
473,
241,
489
],
[
245,
473,
257,
489
],
[
261,
473,
290,
489
],
[
294,
474,
365,
490
],
[
370,
474,
400,
490
],
[
404,
474,
413,
490
],
[
417,
474,
472,
490
],
[
476,
474,
502,
490
],
[
506,
474,
520,
490
],
[
524,
474,
550,
490
],
[
554,
474,
600,
490
],
[
603,
474,
620,
490
],
[
624,
474,
682,
490
],
[
687,
474,
706,
490
],
[
710,
474,
814,
490
],
[
818,
473,
854,
489
],
[
858,
473,
895,
489
],
[
139,
490,
191,
506
],
[
194,
490,
215,
506
],
[
219,
490,
253,
506
],
[
257,
491,
273,
506
],
[
277,
491,
300,
506
],
[
304,
491,
345,
506
],
[
348,
491,
429,
506
],
[
432,
491,
456,
506
],
[
460,
492,
515,
506
],
[
519,
492,
602,
507
],
[
605,
492,
622,
506
],
[
625,
492,
654,
506
],
[
657,
492,
720,
506
],
[
723,
491,
754,
506
],
[
757,
491,
821,
506
],
[
824,
491,
924,
506
],
[
140,
508,
189,
523
],
[
192,
508,
228,
523
],
[
232,
508,
312,
523
],
[
315,
508,
348,
524
],
[
352,
508,
377,
524
],
[
380,
508,
456,
524
],
[
460,
508,
493,
524
],
[
497,
508,
522,
524
],
[
526,
508,
566,
524
],
[
570,
508,
595,
524
],
[
600,
508,
650,
524
],
[
654,
508,
713,
524
],
[
717,
508,
785,
524
],
[
788,
508,
812,
524
],
[
815,
508,
861,
523
],
[
138,
525,
221,
542
],
[
225,
526,
242,
542
],
[
245,
526,
278,
542
],
[
282,
526,
377,
542
],
[
381,
526,
411,
542
],
[
415,
526,
488,
542
],
[
492,
526,
516,
542
],
[
520,
526,
551,
542
],
[
554,
525,
644,
542
],
[
648,
525,
694,
542
],
[
698,
525,
718,
541
],
[
721,
525,
752,
541
],
[
756,
525,
791,
541
],
[
795,
525,
834,
541
],
[
838,
525,
922,
541
],
[
139,
543,
155,
558
],
[
159,
543,
188,
558
],
[
192,
544,
222,
559
],
[
226,
544,
262,
559
],
[
265,
544,
301,
559
],
[
306,
544,
345,
559
],
[
349,
544,
373,
559
],
[
377,
544,
449,
559
],
[
452,
545,
477,
559
],
[
480,
545,
541,
559
],
[
545,
545,
577,
559
],
[
580,
545,
677,
559
],
[
680,
545,
712,
559
],
[
716,
545,
784,
559
],
[
788,
545,
870,
558
],
[
872,
544,
906,
558
],
[
139,
560,
170,
575
],
[
174,
560,
227,
575
],
[
230,
560,
267,
575
],
[
272,
560,
289,
575
],
[
292,
560,
335,
575
],
[
338,
560,
358,
575
],
[
362,
560,
395,
575
],
[
398,
560,
481,
575
],
[
484,
560,
537,
575
],
[
540,
560,
562,
575
],
[
565,
560,
645,
575
],
[
648,
560,
678,
575
],
[
681,
560,
722,
575
],
[
725,
560,
751,
575
],
[
754,
560,
791,
576
],
[
794,
560,
855,
576
],
[
858,
560,
917,
576
],
[
140,
579,
185,
593
],
[
188,
578,
242,
593
],
[
246,
578,
329,
594
],
[
332,
578,
350,
594
],
[
354,
578,
387,
594
],
[
390,
578,
427,
594
],
[
431,
578,
460,
594
],
[
463,
578,
535,
594
],
[
538,
578,
557,
594
],
[
562,
578,
639,
594
],
[
642,
578,
674,
594
],
[
677,
578,
733,
594
],
[
736,
578,
820,
594
],
[
822,
578,
841,
594
],
[
844,
578,
872,
594
],
[
875,
578,
894,
594
],
[
896,
578,
907,
594
],
[
140,
595,
211,
610
],
[
214,
596,
239,
610
],
[
242,
596,
290,
610
],
[
293,
596,
309,
611
],
[
312,
596,
351,
611
],
[
354,
596,
382,
611
],
[
388,
596,
460,
611
],
[
464,
596,
485,
611
],
[
489,
596,
521,
611
],
[
525,
596,
554,
611
],
[
558,
596,
587,
611
],
[
590,
596,
612,
611
],
[
617,
595,
700,
611
],
[
702,
595,
720,
611
],
[
724,
595,
761,
611
],
[
767,
595,
837,
611
],
[
840,
595,
862,
611
],
[
866,
595,
898,
610
],
[
138,
612,
227,
627
],
[
230,
613,
268,
628
],
[
272,
613,
326,
628
],
[
329,
613,
357,
628
],
[
360,
613,
391,
628
],
[
394,
613,
466,
628
],
[
469,
613,
485,
628
],
[
489,
613,
525,
628
],
[
528,
613,
541,
628
],
[
545,
613,
588,
628
],
[
592,
613,
611,
628
],
[
614,
613,
647,
628
],
[
650,
613,
741,
628
],
[
744,
613,
766,
628
],
[
769,
613,
850,
628
],
[
142,
630,
223,
646
],
[
227,
630,
244,
646
],
[
247,
630,
283,
646
],
[
287,
630,
348,
646
],
[
352,
630,
398,
646
],
[
402,
630,
456,
646
],
[
460,
630,
544,
646
],
[
548,
630,
565,
646
],
[
568,
630,
599,
646
],
[
145,
665,
170,
679
],
[
174,
665,
230,
680
],
[
232,
665,
286,
680
],
[
289,
665,
307,
680
],
[
310,
665,
398,
681
],
[
401,
665,
491,
681
],
[
174,
695,
210,
710
],
[
215,
695,
285,
710
],
[
288,
695,
305,
710
],
[
309,
695,
329,
710
],
[
332,
695,
402,
711
],
[
406,
696,
432,
711
],
[
435,
696,
520,
711
],
[
524,
696,
544,
711
],
[
548,
696,
632,
711
],
[
635,
696,
652,
711
],
[
655,
696,
684,
711
],
[
687,
696,
702,
711
],
[
706,
695,
732,
711
],
[
735,
695,
765,
711
],
[
770,
695,
833,
711
],
[
838,
695,
927,
711
],
[
140,
714,
199,
728
],
[
202,
713,
234,
728
],
[
237,
713,
273,
728
],
[
278,
713,
363,
728
],
[
366,
713,
398,
728
],
[
401,
713,
414,
729
],
[
417,
713,
467,
729
],
[
470,
713,
492,
729
],
[
495,
713,
514,
729
],
[
517,
713,
564,
729
],
[
567,
713,
585,
729
],
[
588,
713,
624,
729
],
[
627,
713,
702,
729
],
[
705,
713,
722,
729
],
[
725,
713,
782,
729
],
[
786,
713,
858,
729
],
[
861,
714,
924,
729
],
[
110,
770,
120,
783
],
[
124,
770,
136,
783
],
[
139,
771,
163,
784
],
[
166,
771,
201,
784
],
[
204,
771,
235,
784
],
[
115,
784,
122,
796
],
[
125,
784,
137,
797
],
[
140,
785,
176,
798
],
[
179,
786,
265,
799
],
[
268,
788,
321,
799
],
[
324,
788,
362,
799
],
[
124,
800,
137,
812
],
[
140,
800,
163,
812
],
[
166,
800,
190,
813
],
[
193,
800,
203,
813
],
[
206,
800,
235,
813
],
[
239,
801,
278,
814
],
[
281,
801,
303,
814
],
[
306,
801,
334,
814
],
[
338,
802,
401,
814
],
[
404,
802,
460,
815
],
[
462,
802,
483,
815
],
[
487,
803,
518,
815
],
[
521,
803,
543,
815
],
[
546,
803,
579,
815
],
[
582,
803,
616,
815
],
[
619,
803,
630,
815
],
[
633,
803,
680,
815
],
[
683,
802,
740,
815
],
[
743,
802,
758,
815
],
[
761,
802,
793,
814
],
[
796,
802,
842,
814
],
[
845,
801,
870,
814
],
[
873,
801,
888,
814
],
[
891,
801,
922,
814
],
[
110,
814,
128,
826
],
[
131,
814,
142,
826
],
[
145,
814,
217,
826
],
[
219,
815,
230,
826
],
[
233,
815,
284,
826
],
[
287,
815,
320,
826
],
[
323,
815,
385,
826
],
[
124,
828,
143,
839
],
[
145,
828,
182,
839
],
[
184,
828,
259,
839
],
[
261,
828,
304,
839
],
[
307,
829,
332,
839
],
[
335,
829,
344,
839
],
[
347,
829,
377,
840
],
[
380,
829,
388,
840
],
[
391,
829,
417,
840
],
[
420,
829,
450,
840
],
[
452,
829,
464,
840
],
[
466,
829,
499,
840
],
[
502,
829,
543,
840
],
[
546,
829,
577,
840
],
[
579,
829,
611,
840
],
[
614,
829,
641,
840
],
[
643,
829,
692,
840
],
[
694,
829,
706,
840
],
[
708,
829,
725,
840
],
[
727,
828,
793,
840
],
[
795,
828,
831,
840
],
[
833,
828,
859,
840
],
[
861,
828,
882,
840
],
[
884,
828,
909,
840
],
[
911,
828,
932,
840
],
[
111,
840,
120,
850
],
[
122,
840,
151,
850
],
[
154,
840,
162,
851
],
[
165,
840,
236,
851
],
[
239,
840,
253,
851
],
[
256,
840,
270,
851
],
[
272,
840,
327,
851
],
[
330,
840,
341,
851
],
[
344,
840,
362,
851
],
[
364,
840,
422,
851
],
[
424,
840,
435,
851
],
[
438,
840,
454,
851
],
[
457,
840,
487,
851
],
[
490,
840,
508,
851
],
[
510,
840,
528,
851
],
[
530,
840,
571,
851
],
[
573,
840,
583,
851
],
[
585,
840,
615,
851
],
[
618,
840,
636,
851
],
[
638,
840,
689,
851
],
[
691,
840,
705,
851
],
[
707,
840,
758,
851
],
[
760,
840,
778,
851
],
[
781,
840,
837,
851
],
[
839,
840,
850,
851
],
[
852,
840,
871,
851
],
[
873,
840,
894,
851
],
[
896,
840,
915,
851
],
[
110,
853,
151,
863
],
[
153,
853,
174,
863
],
[
177,
853,
216,
863
],
[
218,
853,
230,
863
],
[
232,
853,
245,
863
],
[
248,
853,
304,
863
],
[
307,
853,
317,
863
],
[
320,
853,
336,
863
],
[
338,
853,
378,
863
],
[
381,
853,
438,
864
],
[
440,
853,
462,
864
],
[
465,
853,
503,
864
],
[
505,
853,
527,
864
],
[
529,
853,
547,
864
],
[
549,
853,
599,
864
],
[
601,
853,
631,
864
],
[
634,
853,
647,
864
],
[
650,
853,
690,
864
],
[
693,
853,
745,
864
],
[
748,
853,
758,
863
],
[
761,
853,
774,
863
],
[
777,
853,
831,
863
],
[
834,
853,
845,
863
],
[
848,
853,
866,
863
],
[
868,
853,
888,
863
],
[
891,
852,
919,
863
],
[
112,
864,
126,
874
],
[
128,
864,
170,
875
],
[
172,
864,
219,
875
],
[
221,
864,
237,
875
],
[
239,
864,
268,
875
],
[
271,
864,
293,
875
],
[
295,
864,
317,
875
],
[
320,
864,
358,
875
],
[
361,
864,
381,
875
],
[
384,
864,
402,
875
],
[
404,
864,
444,
875
],
[
447,
864,
465,
875
],
[
468,
864,
525,
875
],
[
528,
864,
561,
875
],
[
563,
864,
583,
875
],
[
585,
864,
623,
875
],
[
625,
864,
665,
875
],
[
668,
864,
721,
875
],
[
723,
864,
744,
875
],
[
746,
864,
772,
875
],
[
775,
864,
791,
875
],
[
794,
864,
816,
875
],
[
818,
864,
851,
875
],
[
854,
864,
908,
875
],
[
112,
875,
152,
886
],
[
155,
875,
176,
886
],
[
178,
875,
230,
887
],
[
232,
875,
242,
887
],
[
245,
875,
275,
887
],
[
278,
876,
324,
887
],
[
327,
876,
348,
887
],
[
351,
876,
415,
887
],
[
418,
876,
431,
887
],
[
434,
876,
470,
887
],
[
473,
876,
528,
887
],
[
531,
876,
541,
887
],
[
544,
876,
565,
887
],
[
568,
876,
585,
887
],
[
588,
875,
638,
887
],
[
640,
875,
658,
887
],
[
661,
875,
694,
887
],
[
697,
875,
709,
887
],
[
712,
875,
741,
887
],
[
744,
875,
797,
887
],
[
108,
887,
532,
900
],
[
124,
900,
138,
911
],
[
140,
900,
164,
911
],
[
166,
901,
192,
911
],
[
194,
901,
205,
911
],
[
207,
901,
235,
911
],
[
511,
914,
530,
927
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
Which agency can designate a chemical as a high priority?
|
EPA
|
738
|
[
"4.",
"Please",
"provide",
"the",
"public",
"with",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"additionalcosts",
"each",
"agency",
"will",
"inc",
"ur",
"annually",
"to",
"produce",
"risk",
"assessments",
"under",
"the",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"and",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"comesponding",
"benefits",
"in",
"terms",
"of",
"improved",
"risk",
"a",
"na",
"lysis.",
"Comments",
"prepared",
"by:",
"Jennifer",
"Sass,",
"Ph.D.",
"Senior",
"sc",
"ie",
"ntist,",
"Health",
"and",
"Environment",
"Natural",
"Reso",
"urc",
"es",
"Defense",
"Council",
"1200",
"New",
"York",
"Avenue",
",",
"NW,",
"Suite",
"400,",
"Washington,",
"DC,",
"20005",
"te",
"1:",
"202-289-2362,",
"email:",
"jsass@",
"nidc.org",
"NRDC",
"on",
"OMBRA",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"June",
"2006",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
148,
94,
167,
107
],
[
205,
93,
264,
109
],
[
267,
93,
335,
110
],
[
339,
94,
368,
110
],
[
372,
94,
428,
110
],
[
432,
94,
470,
110
],
[
473,
94,
498,
110
],
[
501,
94,
578,
110
],
[
582,
94,
600,
110
],
[
604,
94,
634,
110
],
[
638,
94,
777,
110
],
[
780,
94,
827,
109
],
[
148,
120,
217,
135
],
[
221,
120,
247,
135
],
[
251,
120,
274,
135
],
[
278,
120,
296,
135
],
[
300,
120,
375,
135
],
[
378,
120,
396,
135
],
[
401,
120,
477,
135
],
[
481,
120,
510,
135
],
[
514,
120,
618,
135
],
[
621,
120,
675,
135
],
[
678,
120,
708,
135
],
[
712,
120,
745,
135
],
[
748,
119,
850,
135
],
[
147,
145,
184,
159
],
[
187,
145,
208,
159
],
[
214,
145,
248,
159
],
[
253,
145,
276,
159
],
[
281,
145,
357,
160
],
[
361,
145,
381,
160
],
[
384,
145,
412,
160
],
[
418,
145,
544,
160
],
[
550,
145,
621,
160
],
[
624,
145,
639,
160
],
[
643,
145,
692,
160
],
[
696,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
803,
160
],
[
806,
145,
833,
160
],
[
147,
172,
156,
185
],
[
158,
171,
180,
185
],
[
182,
170,
220,
185
],
[
148,
221,
244,
237
],
[
248,
222,
331,
237
],
[
335,
222,
365,
237
],
[
207,
246,
276,
262
],
[
280,
246,
320,
262
],
[
324,
246,
368,
262
],
[
207,
272,
261,
287
],
[
264,
272,
278,
287
],
[
281,
272,
294,
287
],
[
297,
272,
337,
287
],
[
341,
272,
399,
287
],
[
402,
272,
441,
287
],
[
444,
272,
555,
287
],
[
205,
297,
271,
313
],
[
274,
298,
314,
313
],
[
317,
299,
341,
313
],
[
344,
299,
365,
313
],
[
368,
298,
442,
313
],
[
447,
297,
518,
313
],
[
207,
323,
247,
338
],
[
251,
323,
288,
338
],
[
298,
323,
334,
339
],
[
338,
323,
403,
339
],
[
407,
323,
413,
339
],
[
416,
323,
454,
339
],
[
457,
323,
499,
340
],
[
503,
322,
541,
340
],
[
207,
349,
316,
364
],
[
319,
350,
354,
364
],
[
357,
349,
407,
364
],
[
205,
375,
220,
388
],
[
223,
375,
235,
388
],
[
238,
375,
356,
389
],
[
360,
375,
412,
390
],
[
415,
375,
466,
390
],
[
470,
375,
543,
390
],
[
148,
925,
189,
938
],
[
194,
925,
213,
938
],
[
217,
925,
275,
937
],
[
279,
925,
308,
937
],
[
312,
925,
331,
937
],
[
336,
925,
368,
937
],
[
372,
925,
407,
938
],
[
835,
924,
856,
939
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the page no mentioned in this document?
|
16
|
738
|
[
"4.",
"Please",
"provide",
"the",
"public",
"with",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"additionalcosts",
"each",
"agency",
"will",
"inc",
"ur",
"annually",
"to",
"produce",
"risk",
"assessments",
"under",
"the",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"and",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"comesponding",
"benefits",
"in",
"terms",
"of",
"improved",
"risk",
"a",
"na",
"lysis.",
"Comments",
"prepared",
"by:",
"Jennifer",
"Sass,",
"Ph.D.",
"Senior",
"sc",
"ie",
"ntist,",
"Health",
"and",
"Environment",
"Natural",
"Reso",
"urc",
"es",
"Defense",
"Council",
"1200",
"New",
"York",
"Avenue",
",",
"NW,",
"Suite",
"400,",
"Washington,",
"DC,",
"20005",
"te",
"1:",
"202-289-2362,",
"email:",
"jsass@",
"nidc.org",
"NRDC",
"on",
"OMBRA",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"June",
"2006",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
148,
94,
167,
107
],
[
205,
93,
264,
109
],
[
267,
93,
335,
110
],
[
339,
94,
368,
110
],
[
372,
94,
428,
110
],
[
432,
94,
470,
110
],
[
473,
94,
498,
110
],
[
501,
94,
578,
110
],
[
582,
94,
600,
110
],
[
604,
94,
634,
110
],
[
638,
94,
777,
110
],
[
780,
94,
827,
109
],
[
148,
120,
217,
135
],
[
221,
120,
247,
135
],
[
251,
120,
274,
135
],
[
278,
120,
296,
135
],
[
300,
120,
375,
135
],
[
378,
120,
396,
135
],
[
401,
120,
477,
135
],
[
481,
120,
510,
135
],
[
514,
120,
618,
135
],
[
621,
120,
675,
135
],
[
678,
120,
708,
135
],
[
712,
120,
745,
135
],
[
748,
119,
850,
135
],
[
147,
145,
184,
159
],
[
187,
145,
208,
159
],
[
214,
145,
248,
159
],
[
253,
145,
276,
159
],
[
281,
145,
357,
160
],
[
361,
145,
381,
160
],
[
384,
145,
412,
160
],
[
418,
145,
544,
160
],
[
550,
145,
621,
160
],
[
624,
145,
639,
160
],
[
643,
145,
692,
160
],
[
696,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
803,
160
],
[
806,
145,
833,
160
],
[
147,
172,
156,
185
],
[
158,
171,
180,
185
],
[
182,
170,
220,
185
],
[
148,
221,
244,
237
],
[
248,
222,
331,
237
],
[
335,
222,
365,
237
],
[
207,
246,
276,
262
],
[
280,
246,
320,
262
],
[
324,
246,
368,
262
],
[
207,
272,
261,
287
],
[
264,
272,
278,
287
],
[
281,
272,
294,
287
],
[
297,
272,
337,
287
],
[
341,
272,
399,
287
],
[
402,
272,
441,
287
],
[
444,
272,
555,
287
],
[
205,
297,
271,
313
],
[
274,
298,
314,
313
],
[
317,
299,
341,
313
],
[
344,
299,
365,
313
],
[
368,
298,
442,
313
],
[
447,
297,
518,
313
],
[
207,
323,
247,
338
],
[
251,
323,
288,
338
],
[
298,
323,
334,
339
],
[
338,
323,
403,
339
],
[
407,
323,
413,
339
],
[
416,
323,
454,
339
],
[
457,
323,
499,
340
],
[
503,
322,
541,
340
],
[
207,
349,
316,
364
],
[
319,
350,
354,
364
],
[
357,
349,
407,
364
],
[
205,
375,
220,
388
],
[
223,
375,
235,
388
],
[
238,
375,
356,
389
],
[
360,
375,
412,
390
],
[
415,
375,
466,
390
],
[
470,
375,
543,
390
],
[
148,
925,
189,
938
],
[
194,
925,
213,
938
],
[
217,
925,
275,
937
],
[
279,
925,
308,
937
],
[
312,
925,
331,
937
],
[
336,
925,
368,
937
],
[
372,
925,
407,
938
],
[
835,
924,
856,
939
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the date mentioned in this document?
|
June 2006
|
738
|
[
"4.",
"Please",
"provide",
"the",
"public",
"with",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"additionalcosts",
"each",
"agency",
"will",
"inc",
"ur",
"annually",
"to",
"produce",
"risk",
"assessments",
"under",
"the",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"and",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"comesponding",
"benefits",
"in",
"terms",
"of",
"improved",
"risk",
"a",
"na",
"lysis.",
"Comments",
"prepared",
"by:",
"Jennifer",
"Sass,",
"Ph.D.",
"Senior",
"sc",
"ie",
"ntist,",
"Health",
"and",
"Environment",
"Natural",
"Reso",
"urc",
"es",
"Defense",
"Council",
"1200",
"New",
"York",
"Avenue",
",",
"NW,",
"Suite",
"400,",
"Washington,",
"DC,",
"20005",
"te",
"1:",
"202-289-2362,",
"email:",
"jsass@",
"nidc.org",
"NRDC",
"on",
"OMBRA",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"June",
"2006",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
148,
94,
167,
107
],
[
205,
93,
264,
109
],
[
267,
93,
335,
110
],
[
339,
94,
368,
110
],
[
372,
94,
428,
110
],
[
432,
94,
470,
110
],
[
473,
94,
498,
110
],
[
501,
94,
578,
110
],
[
582,
94,
600,
110
],
[
604,
94,
634,
110
],
[
638,
94,
777,
110
],
[
780,
94,
827,
109
],
[
148,
120,
217,
135
],
[
221,
120,
247,
135
],
[
251,
120,
274,
135
],
[
278,
120,
296,
135
],
[
300,
120,
375,
135
],
[
378,
120,
396,
135
],
[
401,
120,
477,
135
],
[
481,
120,
510,
135
],
[
514,
120,
618,
135
],
[
621,
120,
675,
135
],
[
678,
120,
708,
135
],
[
712,
120,
745,
135
],
[
748,
119,
850,
135
],
[
147,
145,
184,
159
],
[
187,
145,
208,
159
],
[
214,
145,
248,
159
],
[
253,
145,
276,
159
],
[
281,
145,
357,
160
],
[
361,
145,
381,
160
],
[
384,
145,
412,
160
],
[
418,
145,
544,
160
],
[
550,
145,
621,
160
],
[
624,
145,
639,
160
],
[
643,
145,
692,
160
],
[
696,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
803,
160
],
[
806,
145,
833,
160
],
[
147,
172,
156,
185
],
[
158,
171,
180,
185
],
[
182,
170,
220,
185
],
[
148,
221,
244,
237
],
[
248,
222,
331,
237
],
[
335,
222,
365,
237
],
[
207,
246,
276,
262
],
[
280,
246,
320,
262
],
[
324,
246,
368,
262
],
[
207,
272,
261,
287
],
[
264,
272,
278,
287
],
[
281,
272,
294,
287
],
[
297,
272,
337,
287
],
[
341,
272,
399,
287
],
[
402,
272,
441,
287
],
[
444,
272,
555,
287
],
[
205,
297,
271,
313
],
[
274,
298,
314,
313
],
[
317,
299,
341,
313
],
[
344,
299,
365,
313
],
[
368,
298,
442,
313
],
[
447,
297,
518,
313
],
[
207,
323,
247,
338
],
[
251,
323,
288,
338
],
[
298,
323,
334,
339
],
[
338,
323,
403,
339
],
[
407,
323,
413,
339
],
[
416,
323,
454,
339
],
[
457,
323,
499,
340
],
[
503,
322,
541,
340
],
[
207,
349,
316,
364
],
[
319,
350,
354,
364
],
[
357,
349,
407,
364
],
[
205,
375,
220,
388
],
[
223,
375,
235,
388
],
[
238,
375,
356,
389
],
[
360,
375,
412,
390
],
[
415,
375,
466,
390
],
[
470,
375,
543,
390
],
[
148,
925,
189,
938
],
[
194,
925,
213,
938
],
[
217,
925,
275,
937
],
[
279,
925,
308,
937
],
[
312,
925,
331,
937
],
[
336,
925,
368,
937
],
[
372,
925,
407,
938
],
[
835,
924,
856,
939
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Who prepared the comments for this document?
|
Jennifer Sass , Je nnife r Sa ss
|
738
|
[
"4.",
"Please",
"provide",
"the",
"public",
"with",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"additionalcosts",
"each",
"agency",
"will",
"inc",
"ur",
"annually",
"to",
"produce",
"risk",
"assessments",
"under",
"the",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"and",
"an",
"estimate",
"of",
"the",
"comesponding",
"benefits",
"in",
"terms",
"of",
"improved",
"risk",
"a",
"na",
"lysis.",
"Comments",
"prepared",
"by:",
"Jennifer",
"Sass,",
"Ph.D.",
"Senior",
"sc",
"ie",
"ntist,",
"Health",
"and",
"Environment",
"Natural",
"Reso",
"urc",
"es",
"Defense",
"Council",
"1200",
"New",
"York",
"Avenue",
",",
"NW,",
"Suite",
"400,",
"Washington,",
"DC,",
"20005",
"te",
"1:",
"202-289-2362,",
"email:",
"jsass@",
"nidc.org",
"NRDC",
"on",
"OMBRA",
"Bulle",
"tin",
"June",
"2006",
"16",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
148,
94,
167,
107
],
[
205,
93,
264,
109
],
[
267,
93,
335,
110
],
[
339,
94,
368,
110
],
[
372,
94,
428,
110
],
[
432,
94,
470,
110
],
[
473,
94,
498,
110
],
[
501,
94,
578,
110
],
[
582,
94,
600,
110
],
[
604,
94,
634,
110
],
[
638,
94,
777,
110
],
[
780,
94,
827,
109
],
[
148,
120,
217,
135
],
[
221,
120,
247,
135
],
[
251,
120,
274,
135
],
[
278,
120,
296,
135
],
[
300,
120,
375,
135
],
[
378,
120,
396,
135
],
[
401,
120,
477,
135
],
[
481,
120,
510,
135
],
[
514,
120,
618,
135
],
[
621,
120,
675,
135
],
[
678,
120,
708,
135
],
[
712,
120,
745,
135
],
[
748,
119,
850,
135
],
[
147,
145,
184,
159
],
[
187,
145,
208,
159
],
[
214,
145,
248,
159
],
[
253,
145,
276,
159
],
[
281,
145,
357,
160
],
[
361,
145,
381,
160
],
[
384,
145,
412,
160
],
[
418,
145,
544,
160
],
[
550,
145,
621,
160
],
[
624,
145,
639,
160
],
[
643,
145,
692,
160
],
[
696,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
803,
160
],
[
806,
145,
833,
160
],
[
147,
172,
156,
185
],
[
158,
171,
180,
185
],
[
182,
170,
220,
185
],
[
148,
221,
244,
237
],
[
248,
222,
331,
237
],
[
335,
222,
365,
237
],
[
207,
246,
276,
262
],
[
280,
246,
320,
262
],
[
324,
246,
368,
262
],
[
207,
272,
261,
287
],
[
264,
272,
278,
287
],
[
281,
272,
294,
287
],
[
297,
272,
337,
287
],
[
341,
272,
399,
287
],
[
402,
272,
441,
287
],
[
444,
272,
555,
287
],
[
205,
297,
271,
313
],
[
274,
298,
314,
313
],
[
317,
299,
341,
313
],
[
344,
299,
365,
313
],
[
368,
298,
442,
313
],
[
447,
297,
518,
313
],
[
207,
323,
247,
338
],
[
251,
323,
288,
338
],
[
298,
323,
334,
339
],
[
338,
323,
403,
339
],
[
407,
323,
413,
339
],
[
416,
323,
454,
339
],
[
457,
323,
499,
340
],
[
503,
322,
541,
340
],
[
207,
349,
316,
364
],
[
319,
350,
354,
364
],
[
357,
349,
407,
364
],
[
205,
375,
220,
388
],
[
223,
375,
235,
388
],
[
238,
375,
356,
389
],
[
360,
375,
412,
390
],
[
415,
375,
466,
390
],
[
470,
375,
543,
390
],
[
148,
925,
189,
938
],
[
194,
925,
213,
938
],
[
217,
925,
275,
937
],
[
279,
925,
308,
937
],
[
312,
925,
331,
937
],
[
336,
925,
368,
937
],
[
372,
925,
407,
938
],
[
835,
924,
856,
939
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the name of the council?
|
Natural Resources Defense Council
|
739
|
[
"NRDC",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"FILED",
"ELECTRONIC",
"ALLY",
"OMB",
"[email protected]",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"N.W.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building,",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"D,",
"20503",
"Re:",
"NRDC",
"Comments",
"on",
"the",
"OMB",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"Natural",
"Resources",
"Defense",
"Council",
"(NRDC),",
"a",
"national",
"non-profit",
"public",
"interest",
"organization,",
"offers",
"these",
"comments",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"(OMB)",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulletin,",
"release",
"on",
"January",
"9,",
"2006,'",
"which",
"will",
"be",
"peer-reviewed",
"by",
"the",
"NationalAcademies",
"of",
"Science",
".",
"2",
"The",
"views",
"expressed",
"here",
"in",
"are",
"presented",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"NRDC'sover1",
"milion",
"members",
"and",
"activists,",
"who",
"help",
"us",
"protect",
"ournation's",
"public",
"health,",
"safety,",
"and",
"environmental",
"safeguards.",
"Such",
"safeguards",
"were",
"bom",
"from",
"a",
"de",
"lib",
"era",
"tive",
"public",
"process,",
"and",
"although",
"these",
"protections",
"may",
"come",
"at",
"some",
"cost,",
"they",
"deliver",
"tremendous",
"benefits",
"from",
"decreased",
"risks",
"of",
"cancer,",
"to",
"safer",
"auto",
"mobiles,",
"and",
"increased",
"energy",
"savings.",
"Thus,",
"we",
"believe",
"those",
"who",
"wish",
"to",
"change",
"these",
"safeguards",
"should",
"engage",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"de",
"liberative",
"process",
"used",
"to",
"create",
"them.",
"Office",
"of",
"Info.",
"&",
"Reg",
"Affs.,",
"OMB,",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(Jan.",
"2006),",
"available",
"atwww.white",
"house",
".gov/omb/infores/proposed",
"risk",
"assessment",
"bulletin",
"010906.pdf",
"2",
"National",
"Academies.",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulle",
"tin.",
"BEST-K-06-02-A",
"(E",
"Mantus)",
"www8.nationalacademies.or/cp/pmjectview",
"aspx?",
"key=",
"34282",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
276,
119,
352,
140
],
[
148,
190,
190,
203
],
[
195,
190,
222,
203
],
[
224,
190,
267,
203
],
[
147,
241,
192,
255
],
[
197,
241,
302,
255
],
[
305,
241,
348,
255
],
[
148,
258,
192,
272
],
[
198,
258,
426,
275
],
[
147,
291,
172,
307
],
[
175,
292,
235,
307
],
[
238,
292,
281,
307
],
[
148,
309,
202,
324
],
[
205,
309,
224,
324
],
[
228,
310,
330,
325
],
[
333,
310,
370,
325
],
[
374,
310,
470,
325
],
[
473,
309,
530,
325
],
[
147,
326,
203,
341
],
[
206,
326,
224,
342
],
[
228,
327,
352,
342
],
[
356,
327,
392,
342
],
[
395,
326,
464,
342
],
[
150,
342,
179,
359
],
[
183,
342,
214,
358
],
[
218,
342,
273,
358
],
[
276,
343,
321,
358
],
[
147,
359,
186,
376
],
[
191,
359,
277,
376
],
[
281,
360,
335,
376
],
[
339,
360,
412,
376
],
[
416,
360,
465,
376
],
[
474,
360,
525,
375
],
[
148,
377,
256,
393
],
[
260,
377,
280,
393
],
[
283,
377,
333,
393
],
[
148,
419,
182,
435
],
[
205,
419,
257,
435
],
[
262,
419,
358,
436
],
[
362,
420,
385,
436
],
[
390,
420,
418,
436
],
[
422,
420,
464,
436
],
[
468,
420,
552,
436
],
[
556,
420,
590,
436
],
[
594,
420,
696,
436
],
[
700,
420,
765,
436
],
[
148,
471,
192,
485
],
[
195,
471,
221,
485
],
[
224,
471,
272,
485
],
[
207,
496,
237,
512
],
[
240,
496,
307,
512
],
[
310,
496,
400,
513
],
[
402,
496,
478,
513
],
[
481,
496,
549,
513
],
[
552,
497,
626,
513
],
[
629,
497,
642,
513
],
[
645,
497,
718,
513
],
[
721,
497,
808,
512
],
[
146,
514,
203,
529
],
[
205,
514,
271,
529
],
[
274,
515,
388,
530
],
[
391,
515,
441,
530
],
[
444,
515,
493,
530
],
[
496,
515,
591,
530
],
[
594,
515,
610,
530
],
[
614,
514,
693,
530
],
[
697,
514,
716,
530
],
[
720,
513,
751,
530
],
[
754,
513,
809,
530
],
[
812,
513,
837,
529
],
[
147,
531,
271,
546
],
[
274,
531,
310,
546
],
[
314,
531,
392,
546
],
[
396,
531,
453,
547
],
[
457,
531,
541,
547
],
[
544,
531,
577,
547
],
[
580,
531,
616,
547
],
[
619,
531,
680,
547
],
[
683,
531,
750,
546
],
[
753,
531,
818,
546
],
[
822,
531,
847,
546
],
[
149,
547,
218,
563
],
[
222,
548,
238,
563
],
[
242,
548,
297,
563
],
[
301,
548,
354,
564
],
[
358,
548,
384,
564
],
[
387,
549,
412,
564
],
[
417,
549,
546,
564
],
[
550,
549,
574,
564
],
[
577,
549,
607,
564
],
[
610,
548,
792,
564
],
[
795,
548,
814,
563
],
[
147,
564,
214,
580
],
[
218,
564,
219,
579
],
[
222,
564,
230,
579
],
[
210,
601,
235,
613
],
[
241,
601,
290,
614
],
[
293,
601,
382,
614
],
[
385,
602,
423,
614
],
[
426,
602,
441,
614
],
[
446,
602,
475,
614
],
[
480,
601,
569,
615
],
[
574,
601,
597,
615
],
[
601,
600,
661,
615
],
[
663,
600,
683,
615
],
[
685,
599,
810,
614
],
[
146,
618,
202,
632
],
[
205,
618,
290,
632
],
[
293,
618,
329,
631
],
[
333,
618,
407,
631
],
[
410,
618,
449,
631
],
[
453,
618,
491,
631
],
[
497,
618,
516,
631
],
[
519,
618,
586,
631
],
[
589,
618,
693,
631
],
[
696,
618,
752,
631
],
[
755,
618,
818,
631
],
[
147,
634,
206,
649
],
[
210,
634,
245,
649
],
[
250,
634,
377,
649
],
[
381,
634,
490,
649
],
[
493,
634,
537,
649
],
[
540,
634,
638,
649
],
[
642,
634,
686,
649
],
[
690,
634,
727,
649
],
[
735,
634,
771,
649
],
[
781,
634,
788,
648
],
[
150,
650,
166,
666
],
[
169,
650,
187,
666
],
[
190,
650,
217,
666
],
[
220,
650,
252,
666
],
[
255,
650,
311,
667
],
[
314,
650,
388,
667
],
[
391,
651,
430,
667
],
[
433,
651,
512,
667
],
[
515,
651,
564,
667
],
[
567,
651,
668,
667
],
[
671,
651,
712,
667
],
[
715,
651,
770,
667
],
[
772,
651,
792,
666
],
[
795,
651,
841,
666
],
[
147,
668,
190,
683
],
[
194,
668,
234,
683
],
[
238,
668,
296,
683
],
[
300,
667,
406,
684
],
[
409,
667,
480,
684
],
[
483,
667,
519,
684
],
[
532,
667,
626,
684
],
[
629,
667,
664,
684
],
[
667,
667,
686,
684
],
[
688,
667,
760,
683
],
[
763,
668,
782,
683
],
[
785,
668,
833,
683
],
[
147,
685,
185,
700
],
[
187,
685,
261,
700
],
[
264,
685,
301,
700
],
[
304,
685,
393,
700
],
[
397,
685,
460,
700
],
[
463,
685,
540,
700
],
[
544,
685,
584,
700
],
[
588,
685,
615,
700
],
[
619,
684,
686,
700
],
[
690,
684,
738,
700
],
[
742,
684,
780,
700
],
[
784,
684,
822,
700
],
[
825,
684,
844,
700
],
[
147,
702,
217,
717
],
[
221,
701,
270,
717
],
[
275,
701,
372,
718
],
[
375,
701,
433,
718
],
[
437,
701,
509,
718
],
[
512,
701,
529,
718
],
[
532,
701,
563,
718
],
[
566,
701,
615,
718
],
[
621,
701,
639,
718
],
[
642,
701,
724,
718
],
[
727,
701,
796,
718
],
[
799,
701,
844,
718
],
[
147,
719,
165,
734
],
[
170,
719,
230,
733
],
[
234,
719,
287,
734
],
[
157,
814,
207,
828
],
[
211,
814,
228,
829
],
[
231,
814,
267,
829
],
[
271,
814,
283,
829
],
[
287,
814,
320,
829
],
[
324,
814,
362,
829
],
[
365,
814,
410,
829
],
[
414,
814,
489,
829
],
[
492,
814,
522,
829
],
[
525,
814,
615,
829
],
[
619,
814,
675,
829
],
[
678,
814,
720,
829
],
[
724,
814,
772,
829
],
[
775,
814,
847,
828
],
[
147,
830,
254,
844
],
[
257,
830,
301,
844
],
[
304,
830,
532,
845
],
[
539,
830,
564,
845
],
[
571,
830,
664,
845
],
[
667,
830,
725,
844
],
[
732,
830,
821,
844
],
[
147,
863,
153,
877
],
[
157,
863,
226,
877
],
[
229,
863,
326,
877
],
[
329,
863,
385,
877
],
[
391,
863,
408,
878
],
[
411,
863,
439,
878
],
[
442,
863,
483,
878
],
[
485,
863,
515,
878
],
[
518,
863,
551,
878
],
[
554,
863,
610,
878
],
[
612,
863,
647,
878
],
[
649,
863,
679,
878
],
[
681,
862,
794,
877
],
[
798,
862,
817,
877
],
[
147,
879,
212,
893
],
[
216,
879,
585,
895
],
[
590,
879,
633,
895
],
[
636,
879,
672,
895
],
[
675,
879,
719,
895
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the issued date of this document?
|
June 15, 2006
|
739
|
[
"NRDC",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"FILED",
"ELECTRONIC",
"ALLY",
"OMB",
"[email protected]",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"N.W.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building,",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"D,",
"20503",
"Re:",
"NRDC",
"Comments",
"on",
"the",
"OMB",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"Natural",
"Resources",
"Defense",
"Council",
"(NRDC),",
"a",
"national",
"non-profit",
"public",
"interest",
"organization,",
"offers",
"these",
"comments",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"(OMB)",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulletin,",
"release",
"on",
"January",
"9,",
"2006,'",
"which",
"will",
"be",
"peer-reviewed",
"by",
"the",
"NationalAcademies",
"of",
"Science",
".",
"2",
"The",
"views",
"expressed",
"here",
"in",
"are",
"presented",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"NRDC'sover1",
"milion",
"members",
"and",
"activists,",
"who",
"help",
"us",
"protect",
"ournation's",
"public",
"health,",
"safety,",
"and",
"environmental",
"safeguards.",
"Such",
"safeguards",
"were",
"bom",
"from",
"a",
"de",
"lib",
"era",
"tive",
"public",
"process,",
"and",
"although",
"these",
"protections",
"may",
"come",
"at",
"some",
"cost,",
"they",
"deliver",
"tremendous",
"benefits",
"from",
"decreased",
"risks",
"of",
"cancer,",
"to",
"safer",
"auto",
"mobiles,",
"and",
"increased",
"energy",
"savings.",
"Thus,",
"we",
"believe",
"those",
"who",
"wish",
"to",
"change",
"these",
"safeguards",
"should",
"engage",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"de",
"liberative",
"process",
"used",
"to",
"create",
"them.",
"Office",
"of",
"Info.",
"&",
"Reg",
"Affs.,",
"OMB,",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(Jan.",
"2006),",
"available",
"atwww.white",
"house",
".gov/omb/infores/proposed",
"risk",
"assessment",
"bulletin",
"010906.pdf",
"2",
"National",
"Academies.",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulle",
"tin.",
"BEST-K-06-02-A",
"(E",
"Mantus)",
"www8.nationalacademies.or/cp/pmjectview",
"aspx?",
"key=",
"34282",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
276,
119,
352,
140
],
[
148,
190,
190,
203
],
[
195,
190,
222,
203
],
[
224,
190,
267,
203
],
[
147,
241,
192,
255
],
[
197,
241,
302,
255
],
[
305,
241,
348,
255
],
[
148,
258,
192,
272
],
[
198,
258,
426,
275
],
[
147,
291,
172,
307
],
[
175,
292,
235,
307
],
[
238,
292,
281,
307
],
[
148,
309,
202,
324
],
[
205,
309,
224,
324
],
[
228,
310,
330,
325
],
[
333,
310,
370,
325
],
[
374,
310,
470,
325
],
[
473,
309,
530,
325
],
[
147,
326,
203,
341
],
[
206,
326,
224,
342
],
[
228,
327,
352,
342
],
[
356,
327,
392,
342
],
[
395,
326,
464,
342
],
[
150,
342,
179,
359
],
[
183,
342,
214,
358
],
[
218,
342,
273,
358
],
[
276,
343,
321,
358
],
[
147,
359,
186,
376
],
[
191,
359,
277,
376
],
[
281,
360,
335,
376
],
[
339,
360,
412,
376
],
[
416,
360,
465,
376
],
[
474,
360,
525,
375
],
[
148,
377,
256,
393
],
[
260,
377,
280,
393
],
[
283,
377,
333,
393
],
[
148,
419,
182,
435
],
[
205,
419,
257,
435
],
[
262,
419,
358,
436
],
[
362,
420,
385,
436
],
[
390,
420,
418,
436
],
[
422,
420,
464,
436
],
[
468,
420,
552,
436
],
[
556,
420,
590,
436
],
[
594,
420,
696,
436
],
[
700,
420,
765,
436
],
[
148,
471,
192,
485
],
[
195,
471,
221,
485
],
[
224,
471,
272,
485
],
[
207,
496,
237,
512
],
[
240,
496,
307,
512
],
[
310,
496,
400,
513
],
[
402,
496,
478,
513
],
[
481,
496,
549,
513
],
[
552,
497,
626,
513
],
[
629,
497,
642,
513
],
[
645,
497,
718,
513
],
[
721,
497,
808,
512
],
[
146,
514,
203,
529
],
[
205,
514,
271,
529
],
[
274,
515,
388,
530
],
[
391,
515,
441,
530
],
[
444,
515,
493,
530
],
[
496,
515,
591,
530
],
[
594,
515,
610,
530
],
[
614,
514,
693,
530
],
[
697,
514,
716,
530
],
[
720,
513,
751,
530
],
[
754,
513,
809,
530
],
[
812,
513,
837,
529
],
[
147,
531,
271,
546
],
[
274,
531,
310,
546
],
[
314,
531,
392,
546
],
[
396,
531,
453,
547
],
[
457,
531,
541,
547
],
[
544,
531,
577,
547
],
[
580,
531,
616,
547
],
[
619,
531,
680,
547
],
[
683,
531,
750,
546
],
[
753,
531,
818,
546
],
[
822,
531,
847,
546
],
[
149,
547,
218,
563
],
[
222,
548,
238,
563
],
[
242,
548,
297,
563
],
[
301,
548,
354,
564
],
[
358,
548,
384,
564
],
[
387,
549,
412,
564
],
[
417,
549,
546,
564
],
[
550,
549,
574,
564
],
[
577,
549,
607,
564
],
[
610,
548,
792,
564
],
[
795,
548,
814,
563
],
[
147,
564,
214,
580
],
[
218,
564,
219,
579
],
[
222,
564,
230,
579
],
[
210,
601,
235,
613
],
[
241,
601,
290,
614
],
[
293,
601,
382,
614
],
[
385,
602,
423,
614
],
[
426,
602,
441,
614
],
[
446,
602,
475,
614
],
[
480,
601,
569,
615
],
[
574,
601,
597,
615
],
[
601,
600,
661,
615
],
[
663,
600,
683,
615
],
[
685,
599,
810,
614
],
[
146,
618,
202,
632
],
[
205,
618,
290,
632
],
[
293,
618,
329,
631
],
[
333,
618,
407,
631
],
[
410,
618,
449,
631
],
[
453,
618,
491,
631
],
[
497,
618,
516,
631
],
[
519,
618,
586,
631
],
[
589,
618,
693,
631
],
[
696,
618,
752,
631
],
[
755,
618,
818,
631
],
[
147,
634,
206,
649
],
[
210,
634,
245,
649
],
[
250,
634,
377,
649
],
[
381,
634,
490,
649
],
[
493,
634,
537,
649
],
[
540,
634,
638,
649
],
[
642,
634,
686,
649
],
[
690,
634,
727,
649
],
[
735,
634,
771,
649
],
[
781,
634,
788,
648
],
[
150,
650,
166,
666
],
[
169,
650,
187,
666
],
[
190,
650,
217,
666
],
[
220,
650,
252,
666
],
[
255,
650,
311,
667
],
[
314,
650,
388,
667
],
[
391,
651,
430,
667
],
[
433,
651,
512,
667
],
[
515,
651,
564,
667
],
[
567,
651,
668,
667
],
[
671,
651,
712,
667
],
[
715,
651,
770,
667
],
[
772,
651,
792,
666
],
[
795,
651,
841,
666
],
[
147,
668,
190,
683
],
[
194,
668,
234,
683
],
[
238,
668,
296,
683
],
[
300,
667,
406,
684
],
[
409,
667,
480,
684
],
[
483,
667,
519,
684
],
[
532,
667,
626,
684
],
[
629,
667,
664,
684
],
[
667,
667,
686,
684
],
[
688,
667,
760,
683
],
[
763,
668,
782,
683
],
[
785,
668,
833,
683
],
[
147,
685,
185,
700
],
[
187,
685,
261,
700
],
[
264,
685,
301,
700
],
[
304,
685,
393,
700
],
[
397,
685,
460,
700
],
[
463,
685,
540,
700
],
[
544,
685,
584,
700
],
[
588,
685,
615,
700
],
[
619,
684,
686,
700
],
[
690,
684,
738,
700
],
[
742,
684,
780,
700
],
[
784,
684,
822,
700
],
[
825,
684,
844,
700
],
[
147,
702,
217,
717
],
[
221,
701,
270,
717
],
[
275,
701,
372,
718
],
[
375,
701,
433,
718
],
[
437,
701,
509,
718
],
[
512,
701,
529,
718
],
[
532,
701,
563,
718
],
[
566,
701,
615,
718
],
[
621,
701,
639,
718
],
[
642,
701,
724,
718
],
[
727,
701,
796,
718
],
[
799,
701,
844,
718
],
[
147,
719,
165,
734
],
[
170,
719,
230,
733
],
[
234,
719,
287,
734
],
[
157,
814,
207,
828
],
[
211,
814,
228,
829
],
[
231,
814,
267,
829
],
[
271,
814,
283,
829
],
[
287,
814,
320,
829
],
[
324,
814,
362,
829
],
[
365,
814,
410,
829
],
[
414,
814,
489,
829
],
[
492,
814,
522,
829
],
[
525,
814,
615,
829
],
[
619,
814,
675,
829
],
[
678,
814,
720,
829
],
[
724,
814,
772,
829
],
[
775,
814,
847,
828
],
[
147,
830,
254,
844
],
[
257,
830,
301,
844
],
[
304,
830,
532,
845
],
[
539,
830,
564,
845
],
[
571,
830,
664,
845
],
[
667,
830,
725,
844
],
[
732,
830,
821,
844
],
[
147,
863,
153,
877
],
[
157,
863,
226,
877
],
[
229,
863,
326,
877
],
[
329,
863,
385,
877
],
[
391,
863,
408,
878
],
[
411,
863,
439,
878
],
[
442,
863,
483,
878
],
[
485,
863,
515,
878
],
[
518,
863,
551,
878
],
[
554,
863,
610,
878
],
[
612,
863,
647,
878
],
[
649,
863,
679,
878
],
[
681,
862,
794,
877
],
[
798,
862,
817,
877
],
[
147,
879,
212,
893
],
[
216,
879,
585,
895
],
[
590,
879,
633,
895
],
[
636,
879,
672,
895
],
[
675,
879,
719,
895
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
Who is the addressee of this letter?
|
Dr. Nancy Beck
|
739
|
[
"NRDC",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"FILED",
"ELECTRONIC",
"ALLY",
"OMB",
"[email protected]",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"N.W.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building,",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"D,",
"20503",
"Re:",
"NRDC",
"Comments",
"on",
"the",
"OMB",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"Natural",
"Resources",
"Defense",
"Council",
"(NRDC),",
"a",
"national",
"non-profit",
"public",
"interest",
"organization,",
"offers",
"these",
"comments",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"(OMB)",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulletin,",
"release",
"on",
"January",
"9,",
"2006,'",
"which",
"will",
"be",
"peer-reviewed",
"by",
"the",
"NationalAcademies",
"of",
"Science",
".",
"2",
"The",
"views",
"expressed",
"here",
"in",
"are",
"presented",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"NRDC'sover1",
"milion",
"members",
"and",
"activists,",
"who",
"help",
"us",
"protect",
"ournation's",
"public",
"health,",
"safety,",
"and",
"environmental",
"safeguards.",
"Such",
"safeguards",
"were",
"bom",
"from",
"a",
"de",
"lib",
"era",
"tive",
"public",
"process,",
"and",
"although",
"these",
"protections",
"may",
"come",
"at",
"some",
"cost,",
"they",
"deliver",
"tremendous",
"benefits",
"from",
"decreased",
"risks",
"of",
"cancer,",
"to",
"safer",
"auto",
"mobiles,",
"and",
"increased",
"energy",
"savings.",
"Thus,",
"we",
"believe",
"those",
"who",
"wish",
"to",
"change",
"these",
"safeguards",
"should",
"engage",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"de",
"liberative",
"process",
"used",
"to",
"create",
"them.",
"Office",
"of",
"Info.",
"&",
"Reg",
"Affs.,",
"OMB,",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(Jan.",
"2006),",
"available",
"atwww.white",
"house",
".gov/omb/infores/proposed",
"risk",
"assessment",
"bulletin",
"010906.pdf",
"2",
"National",
"Academies.",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulle",
"tin.",
"BEST-K-06-02-A",
"(E",
"Mantus)",
"www8.nationalacademies.or/cp/pmjectview",
"aspx?",
"key=",
"34282",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
276,
119,
352,
140
],
[
148,
190,
190,
203
],
[
195,
190,
222,
203
],
[
224,
190,
267,
203
],
[
147,
241,
192,
255
],
[
197,
241,
302,
255
],
[
305,
241,
348,
255
],
[
148,
258,
192,
272
],
[
198,
258,
426,
275
],
[
147,
291,
172,
307
],
[
175,
292,
235,
307
],
[
238,
292,
281,
307
],
[
148,
309,
202,
324
],
[
205,
309,
224,
324
],
[
228,
310,
330,
325
],
[
333,
310,
370,
325
],
[
374,
310,
470,
325
],
[
473,
309,
530,
325
],
[
147,
326,
203,
341
],
[
206,
326,
224,
342
],
[
228,
327,
352,
342
],
[
356,
327,
392,
342
],
[
395,
326,
464,
342
],
[
150,
342,
179,
359
],
[
183,
342,
214,
358
],
[
218,
342,
273,
358
],
[
276,
343,
321,
358
],
[
147,
359,
186,
376
],
[
191,
359,
277,
376
],
[
281,
360,
335,
376
],
[
339,
360,
412,
376
],
[
416,
360,
465,
376
],
[
474,
360,
525,
375
],
[
148,
377,
256,
393
],
[
260,
377,
280,
393
],
[
283,
377,
333,
393
],
[
148,
419,
182,
435
],
[
205,
419,
257,
435
],
[
262,
419,
358,
436
],
[
362,
420,
385,
436
],
[
390,
420,
418,
436
],
[
422,
420,
464,
436
],
[
468,
420,
552,
436
],
[
556,
420,
590,
436
],
[
594,
420,
696,
436
],
[
700,
420,
765,
436
],
[
148,
471,
192,
485
],
[
195,
471,
221,
485
],
[
224,
471,
272,
485
],
[
207,
496,
237,
512
],
[
240,
496,
307,
512
],
[
310,
496,
400,
513
],
[
402,
496,
478,
513
],
[
481,
496,
549,
513
],
[
552,
497,
626,
513
],
[
629,
497,
642,
513
],
[
645,
497,
718,
513
],
[
721,
497,
808,
512
],
[
146,
514,
203,
529
],
[
205,
514,
271,
529
],
[
274,
515,
388,
530
],
[
391,
515,
441,
530
],
[
444,
515,
493,
530
],
[
496,
515,
591,
530
],
[
594,
515,
610,
530
],
[
614,
514,
693,
530
],
[
697,
514,
716,
530
],
[
720,
513,
751,
530
],
[
754,
513,
809,
530
],
[
812,
513,
837,
529
],
[
147,
531,
271,
546
],
[
274,
531,
310,
546
],
[
314,
531,
392,
546
],
[
396,
531,
453,
547
],
[
457,
531,
541,
547
],
[
544,
531,
577,
547
],
[
580,
531,
616,
547
],
[
619,
531,
680,
547
],
[
683,
531,
750,
546
],
[
753,
531,
818,
546
],
[
822,
531,
847,
546
],
[
149,
547,
218,
563
],
[
222,
548,
238,
563
],
[
242,
548,
297,
563
],
[
301,
548,
354,
564
],
[
358,
548,
384,
564
],
[
387,
549,
412,
564
],
[
417,
549,
546,
564
],
[
550,
549,
574,
564
],
[
577,
549,
607,
564
],
[
610,
548,
792,
564
],
[
795,
548,
814,
563
],
[
147,
564,
214,
580
],
[
218,
564,
219,
579
],
[
222,
564,
230,
579
],
[
210,
601,
235,
613
],
[
241,
601,
290,
614
],
[
293,
601,
382,
614
],
[
385,
602,
423,
614
],
[
426,
602,
441,
614
],
[
446,
602,
475,
614
],
[
480,
601,
569,
615
],
[
574,
601,
597,
615
],
[
601,
600,
661,
615
],
[
663,
600,
683,
615
],
[
685,
599,
810,
614
],
[
146,
618,
202,
632
],
[
205,
618,
290,
632
],
[
293,
618,
329,
631
],
[
333,
618,
407,
631
],
[
410,
618,
449,
631
],
[
453,
618,
491,
631
],
[
497,
618,
516,
631
],
[
519,
618,
586,
631
],
[
589,
618,
693,
631
],
[
696,
618,
752,
631
],
[
755,
618,
818,
631
],
[
147,
634,
206,
649
],
[
210,
634,
245,
649
],
[
250,
634,
377,
649
],
[
381,
634,
490,
649
],
[
493,
634,
537,
649
],
[
540,
634,
638,
649
],
[
642,
634,
686,
649
],
[
690,
634,
727,
649
],
[
735,
634,
771,
649
],
[
781,
634,
788,
648
],
[
150,
650,
166,
666
],
[
169,
650,
187,
666
],
[
190,
650,
217,
666
],
[
220,
650,
252,
666
],
[
255,
650,
311,
667
],
[
314,
650,
388,
667
],
[
391,
651,
430,
667
],
[
433,
651,
512,
667
],
[
515,
651,
564,
667
],
[
567,
651,
668,
667
],
[
671,
651,
712,
667
],
[
715,
651,
770,
667
],
[
772,
651,
792,
666
],
[
795,
651,
841,
666
],
[
147,
668,
190,
683
],
[
194,
668,
234,
683
],
[
238,
668,
296,
683
],
[
300,
667,
406,
684
],
[
409,
667,
480,
684
],
[
483,
667,
519,
684
],
[
532,
667,
626,
684
],
[
629,
667,
664,
684
],
[
667,
667,
686,
684
],
[
688,
667,
760,
683
],
[
763,
668,
782,
683
],
[
785,
668,
833,
683
],
[
147,
685,
185,
700
],
[
187,
685,
261,
700
],
[
264,
685,
301,
700
],
[
304,
685,
393,
700
],
[
397,
685,
460,
700
],
[
463,
685,
540,
700
],
[
544,
685,
584,
700
],
[
588,
685,
615,
700
],
[
619,
684,
686,
700
],
[
690,
684,
738,
700
],
[
742,
684,
780,
700
],
[
784,
684,
822,
700
],
[
825,
684,
844,
700
],
[
147,
702,
217,
717
],
[
221,
701,
270,
717
],
[
275,
701,
372,
718
],
[
375,
701,
433,
718
],
[
437,
701,
509,
718
],
[
512,
701,
529,
718
],
[
532,
701,
563,
718
],
[
566,
701,
615,
718
],
[
621,
701,
639,
718
],
[
642,
701,
724,
718
],
[
727,
701,
796,
718
],
[
799,
701,
844,
718
],
[
147,
719,
165,
734
],
[
170,
719,
230,
733
],
[
234,
719,
287,
734
],
[
157,
814,
207,
828
],
[
211,
814,
228,
829
],
[
231,
814,
267,
829
],
[
271,
814,
283,
829
],
[
287,
814,
320,
829
],
[
324,
814,
362,
829
],
[
365,
814,
410,
829
],
[
414,
814,
489,
829
],
[
492,
814,
522,
829
],
[
525,
814,
615,
829
],
[
619,
814,
675,
829
],
[
678,
814,
720,
829
],
[
724,
814,
772,
829
],
[
775,
814,
847,
828
],
[
147,
830,
254,
844
],
[
257,
830,
301,
844
],
[
304,
830,
532,
845
],
[
539,
830,
564,
845
],
[
571,
830,
664,
845
],
[
667,
830,
725,
844
],
[
732,
830,
821,
844
],
[
147,
863,
153,
877
],
[
157,
863,
226,
877
],
[
229,
863,
326,
877
],
[
329,
863,
385,
877
],
[
391,
863,
408,
878
],
[
411,
863,
439,
878
],
[
442,
863,
483,
878
],
[
485,
863,
515,
878
],
[
518,
863,
551,
878
],
[
554,
863,
610,
878
],
[
612,
863,
647,
878
],
[
649,
863,
679,
878
],
[
681,
862,
794,
877
],
[
798,
862,
817,
877
],
[
147,
879,
212,
893
],
[
216,
879,
585,
895
],
[
590,
879,
633,
895
],
[
636,
879,
672,
895
],
[
675,
879,
719,
895
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the fullform of NRDC?
|
Natural Resources Defense Council
|
739
|
[
"NRDC",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"FILED",
"ELECTRONIC",
"ALLY",
"OMB",
"[email protected]",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"N.W.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building,",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"D,",
"20503",
"Re:",
"NRDC",
"Comments",
"on",
"the",
"OMB",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"Natural",
"Resources",
"Defense",
"Council",
"(NRDC),",
"a",
"national",
"non-profit",
"public",
"interest",
"organization,",
"offers",
"these",
"comments",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"(OMB)",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulletin,",
"release",
"on",
"January",
"9,",
"2006,'",
"which",
"will",
"be",
"peer-reviewed",
"by",
"the",
"NationalAcademies",
"of",
"Science",
".",
"2",
"The",
"views",
"expressed",
"here",
"in",
"are",
"presented",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"NRDC'sover1",
"milion",
"members",
"and",
"activists,",
"who",
"help",
"us",
"protect",
"ournation's",
"public",
"health,",
"safety,",
"and",
"environmental",
"safeguards.",
"Such",
"safeguards",
"were",
"bom",
"from",
"a",
"de",
"lib",
"era",
"tive",
"public",
"process,",
"and",
"although",
"these",
"protections",
"may",
"come",
"at",
"some",
"cost,",
"they",
"deliver",
"tremendous",
"benefits",
"from",
"decreased",
"risks",
"of",
"cancer,",
"to",
"safer",
"auto",
"mobiles,",
"and",
"increased",
"energy",
"savings.",
"Thus,",
"we",
"believe",
"those",
"who",
"wish",
"to",
"change",
"these",
"safeguards",
"should",
"engage",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"de",
"liberative",
"process",
"used",
"to",
"create",
"them.",
"Office",
"of",
"Info.",
"&",
"Reg",
"Affs.,",
"OMB,",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(Jan.",
"2006),",
"available",
"atwww.white",
"house",
".gov/omb/infores/proposed",
"risk",
"assessment",
"bulletin",
"010906.pdf",
"2",
"National",
"Academies.",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulle",
"tin.",
"BEST-K-06-02-A",
"(E",
"Mantus)",
"www8.nationalacademies.or/cp/pmjectview",
"aspx?",
"key=",
"34282",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
276,
119,
352,
140
],
[
148,
190,
190,
203
],
[
195,
190,
222,
203
],
[
224,
190,
267,
203
],
[
147,
241,
192,
255
],
[
197,
241,
302,
255
],
[
305,
241,
348,
255
],
[
148,
258,
192,
272
],
[
198,
258,
426,
275
],
[
147,
291,
172,
307
],
[
175,
292,
235,
307
],
[
238,
292,
281,
307
],
[
148,
309,
202,
324
],
[
205,
309,
224,
324
],
[
228,
310,
330,
325
],
[
333,
310,
370,
325
],
[
374,
310,
470,
325
],
[
473,
309,
530,
325
],
[
147,
326,
203,
341
],
[
206,
326,
224,
342
],
[
228,
327,
352,
342
],
[
356,
327,
392,
342
],
[
395,
326,
464,
342
],
[
150,
342,
179,
359
],
[
183,
342,
214,
358
],
[
218,
342,
273,
358
],
[
276,
343,
321,
358
],
[
147,
359,
186,
376
],
[
191,
359,
277,
376
],
[
281,
360,
335,
376
],
[
339,
360,
412,
376
],
[
416,
360,
465,
376
],
[
474,
360,
525,
375
],
[
148,
377,
256,
393
],
[
260,
377,
280,
393
],
[
283,
377,
333,
393
],
[
148,
419,
182,
435
],
[
205,
419,
257,
435
],
[
262,
419,
358,
436
],
[
362,
420,
385,
436
],
[
390,
420,
418,
436
],
[
422,
420,
464,
436
],
[
468,
420,
552,
436
],
[
556,
420,
590,
436
],
[
594,
420,
696,
436
],
[
700,
420,
765,
436
],
[
148,
471,
192,
485
],
[
195,
471,
221,
485
],
[
224,
471,
272,
485
],
[
207,
496,
237,
512
],
[
240,
496,
307,
512
],
[
310,
496,
400,
513
],
[
402,
496,
478,
513
],
[
481,
496,
549,
513
],
[
552,
497,
626,
513
],
[
629,
497,
642,
513
],
[
645,
497,
718,
513
],
[
721,
497,
808,
512
],
[
146,
514,
203,
529
],
[
205,
514,
271,
529
],
[
274,
515,
388,
530
],
[
391,
515,
441,
530
],
[
444,
515,
493,
530
],
[
496,
515,
591,
530
],
[
594,
515,
610,
530
],
[
614,
514,
693,
530
],
[
697,
514,
716,
530
],
[
720,
513,
751,
530
],
[
754,
513,
809,
530
],
[
812,
513,
837,
529
],
[
147,
531,
271,
546
],
[
274,
531,
310,
546
],
[
314,
531,
392,
546
],
[
396,
531,
453,
547
],
[
457,
531,
541,
547
],
[
544,
531,
577,
547
],
[
580,
531,
616,
547
],
[
619,
531,
680,
547
],
[
683,
531,
750,
546
],
[
753,
531,
818,
546
],
[
822,
531,
847,
546
],
[
149,
547,
218,
563
],
[
222,
548,
238,
563
],
[
242,
548,
297,
563
],
[
301,
548,
354,
564
],
[
358,
548,
384,
564
],
[
387,
549,
412,
564
],
[
417,
549,
546,
564
],
[
550,
549,
574,
564
],
[
577,
549,
607,
564
],
[
610,
548,
792,
564
],
[
795,
548,
814,
563
],
[
147,
564,
214,
580
],
[
218,
564,
219,
579
],
[
222,
564,
230,
579
],
[
210,
601,
235,
613
],
[
241,
601,
290,
614
],
[
293,
601,
382,
614
],
[
385,
602,
423,
614
],
[
426,
602,
441,
614
],
[
446,
602,
475,
614
],
[
480,
601,
569,
615
],
[
574,
601,
597,
615
],
[
601,
600,
661,
615
],
[
663,
600,
683,
615
],
[
685,
599,
810,
614
],
[
146,
618,
202,
632
],
[
205,
618,
290,
632
],
[
293,
618,
329,
631
],
[
333,
618,
407,
631
],
[
410,
618,
449,
631
],
[
453,
618,
491,
631
],
[
497,
618,
516,
631
],
[
519,
618,
586,
631
],
[
589,
618,
693,
631
],
[
696,
618,
752,
631
],
[
755,
618,
818,
631
],
[
147,
634,
206,
649
],
[
210,
634,
245,
649
],
[
250,
634,
377,
649
],
[
381,
634,
490,
649
],
[
493,
634,
537,
649
],
[
540,
634,
638,
649
],
[
642,
634,
686,
649
],
[
690,
634,
727,
649
],
[
735,
634,
771,
649
],
[
781,
634,
788,
648
],
[
150,
650,
166,
666
],
[
169,
650,
187,
666
],
[
190,
650,
217,
666
],
[
220,
650,
252,
666
],
[
255,
650,
311,
667
],
[
314,
650,
388,
667
],
[
391,
651,
430,
667
],
[
433,
651,
512,
667
],
[
515,
651,
564,
667
],
[
567,
651,
668,
667
],
[
671,
651,
712,
667
],
[
715,
651,
770,
667
],
[
772,
651,
792,
666
],
[
795,
651,
841,
666
],
[
147,
668,
190,
683
],
[
194,
668,
234,
683
],
[
238,
668,
296,
683
],
[
300,
667,
406,
684
],
[
409,
667,
480,
684
],
[
483,
667,
519,
684
],
[
532,
667,
626,
684
],
[
629,
667,
664,
684
],
[
667,
667,
686,
684
],
[
688,
667,
760,
683
],
[
763,
668,
782,
683
],
[
785,
668,
833,
683
],
[
147,
685,
185,
700
],
[
187,
685,
261,
700
],
[
264,
685,
301,
700
],
[
304,
685,
393,
700
],
[
397,
685,
460,
700
],
[
463,
685,
540,
700
],
[
544,
685,
584,
700
],
[
588,
685,
615,
700
],
[
619,
684,
686,
700
],
[
690,
684,
738,
700
],
[
742,
684,
780,
700
],
[
784,
684,
822,
700
],
[
825,
684,
844,
700
],
[
147,
702,
217,
717
],
[
221,
701,
270,
717
],
[
275,
701,
372,
718
],
[
375,
701,
433,
718
],
[
437,
701,
509,
718
],
[
512,
701,
529,
718
],
[
532,
701,
563,
718
],
[
566,
701,
615,
718
],
[
621,
701,
639,
718
],
[
642,
701,
724,
718
],
[
727,
701,
796,
718
],
[
799,
701,
844,
718
],
[
147,
719,
165,
734
],
[
170,
719,
230,
733
],
[
234,
719,
287,
734
],
[
157,
814,
207,
828
],
[
211,
814,
228,
829
],
[
231,
814,
267,
829
],
[
271,
814,
283,
829
],
[
287,
814,
320,
829
],
[
324,
814,
362,
829
],
[
365,
814,
410,
829
],
[
414,
814,
489,
829
],
[
492,
814,
522,
829
],
[
525,
814,
615,
829
],
[
619,
814,
675,
829
],
[
678,
814,
720,
829
],
[
724,
814,
772,
829
],
[
775,
814,
847,
828
],
[
147,
830,
254,
844
],
[
257,
830,
301,
844
],
[
304,
830,
532,
845
],
[
539,
830,
564,
845
],
[
571,
830,
664,
845
],
[
667,
830,
725,
844
],
[
732,
830,
821,
844
],
[
147,
863,
153,
877
],
[
157,
863,
226,
877
],
[
229,
863,
326,
877
],
[
329,
863,
385,
877
],
[
391,
863,
408,
878
],
[
411,
863,
439,
878
],
[
442,
863,
483,
878
],
[
485,
863,
515,
878
],
[
518,
863,
551,
878
],
[
554,
863,
610,
878
],
[
612,
863,
647,
878
],
[
649,
863,
679,
878
],
[
681,
862,
794,
877
],
[
798,
862,
817,
877
],
[
147,
879,
212,
893
],
[
216,
879,
585,
895
],
[
590,
879,
633,
895
],
[
636,
879,
672,
895
],
[
675,
879,
719,
895
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What kind of organization is NRDC?
|
a national non-profit public interest organization
|
739
|
[
"NRDC",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"FILED",
"ELECTRONIC",
"ALLY",
"OMB",
"[email protected]",
"Dr.",
"Nancy",
"Beck",
"Office",
"of",
"Information",
"and",
"Regulatory",
"Affairs",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget",
"725",
"17th",
"Street,",
"N.W.",
"New",
"Executive",
"Office",
"Building,",
"Room",
"10201",
"Washington,",
"D,",
"20503",
"Re:",
"NRDC",
"Comments",
"on",
"the",
"OMB",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"Dear",
"Dr.",
"Beck:",
"The",
"Natural",
"Resources",
"Defense",
"Council",
"(NRDC),",
"a",
"national",
"non-profit",
"public",
"interest",
"organization,",
"offers",
"these",
"comments",
"in",
"response",
"to",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Management",
"and",
"Budget's",
"(OMB)",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulletin,",
"release",
"on",
"January",
"9,",
"2006,'",
"which",
"will",
"be",
"peer-reviewed",
"by",
"the",
"NationalAcademies",
"of",
"Science",
".",
"2",
"The",
"views",
"expressed",
"here",
"in",
"are",
"presented",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"NRDC'sover1",
"milion",
"members",
"and",
"activists,",
"who",
"help",
"us",
"protect",
"ournation's",
"public",
"health,",
"safety,",
"and",
"environmental",
"safeguards.",
"Such",
"safeguards",
"were",
"bom",
"from",
"a",
"de",
"lib",
"era",
"tive",
"public",
"process,",
"and",
"although",
"these",
"protections",
"may",
"come",
"at",
"some",
"cost,",
"they",
"deliver",
"tremendous",
"benefits",
"from",
"decreased",
"risks",
"of",
"cancer,",
"to",
"safer",
"auto",
"mobiles,",
"and",
"increased",
"energy",
"savings.",
"Thus,",
"we",
"believe",
"those",
"who",
"wish",
"to",
"change",
"these",
"safeguards",
"should",
"engage",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"de",
"liberative",
"process",
"used",
"to",
"create",
"them.",
"Office",
"of",
"Info.",
"&",
"Reg",
"Affs.,",
"OMB,",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(Jan.",
"2006),",
"available",
"atwww.white",
"house",
".gov/omb/infores/proposed",
"risk",
"assessment",
"bulletin",
"010906.pdf",
"2",
"National",
"Academies.",
"Review",
"of",
"the",
"OMB",
"Risk",
"Asse",
"ssment",
"Bulle",
"tin.",
"BEST-K-06-02-A",
"(E",
"Mantus)",
"www8.nationalacademies.or/cp/pmjectview",
"aspx?",
"key=",
"34282",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/nicn0226"
] |
[
[
276,
119,
352,
140
],
[
148,
190,
190,
203
],
[
195,
190,
222,
203
],
[
224,
190,
267,
203
],
[
147,
241,
192,
255
],
[
197,
241,
302,
255
],
[
305,
241,
348,
255
],
[
148,
258,
192,
272
],
[
198,
258,
426,
275
],
[
147,
291,
172,
307
],
[
175,
292,
235,
307
],
[
238,
292,
281,
307
],
[
148,
309,
202,
324
],
[
205,
309,
224,
324
],
[
228,
310,
330,
325
],
[
333,
310,
370,
325
],
[
374,
310,
470,
325
],
[
473,
309,
530,
325
],
[
147,
326,
203,
341
],
[
206,
326,
224,
342
],
[
228,
327,
352,
342
],
[
356,
327,
392,
342
],
[
395,
326,
464,
342
],
[
150,
342,
179,
359
],
[
183,
342,
214,
358
],
[
218,
342,
273,
358
],
[
276,
343,
321,
358
],
[
147,
359,
186,
376
],
[
191,
359,
277,
376
],
[
281,
360,
335,
376
],
[
339,
360,
412,
376
],
[
416,
360,
465,
376
],
[
474,
360,
525,
375
],
[
148,
377,
256,
393
],
[
260,
377,
280,
393
],
[
283,
377,
333,
393
],
[
148,
419,
182,
435
],
[
205,
419,
257,
435
],
[
262,
419,
358,
436
],
[
362,
420,
385,
436
],
[
390,
420,
418,
436
],
[
422,
420,
464,
436
],
[
468,
420,
552,
436
],
[
556,
420,
590,
436
],
[
594,
420,
696,
436
],
[
700,
420,
765,
436
],
[
148,
471,
192,
485
],
[
195,
471,
221,
485
],
[
224,
471,
272,
485
],
[
207,
496,
237,
512
],
[
240,
496,
307,
512
],
[
310,
496,
400,
513
],
[
402,
496,
478,
513
],
[
481,
496,
549,
513
],
[
552,
497,
626,
513
],
[
629,
497,
642,
513
],
[
645,
497,
718,
513
],
[
721,
497,
808,
512
],
[
146,
514,
203,
529
],
[
205,
514,
271,
529
],
[
274,
515,
388,
530
],
[
391,
515,
441,
530
],
[
444,
515,
493,
530
],
[
496,
515,
591,
530
],
[
594,
515,
610,
530
],
[
614,
514,
693,
530
],
[
697,
514,
716,
530
],
[
720,
513,
751,
530
],
[
754,
513,
809,
530
],
[
812,
513,
837,
529
],
[
147,
531,
271,
546
],
[
274,
531,
310,
546
],
[
314,
531,
392,
546
],
[
396,
531,
453,
547
],
[
457,
531,
541,
547
],
[
544,
531,
577,
547
],
[
580,
531,
616,
547
],
[
619,
531,
680,
547
],
[
683,
531,
750,
546
],
[
753,
531,
818,
546
],
[
822,
531,
847,
546
],
[
149,
547,
218,
563
],
[
222,
548,
238,
563
],
[
242,
548,
297,
563
],
[
301,
548,
354,
564
],
[
358,
548,
384,
564
],
[
387,
549,
412,
564
],
[
417,
549,
546,
564
],
[
550,
549,
574,
564
],
[
577,
549,
607,
564
],
[
610,
548,
792,
564
],
[
795,
548,
814,
563
],
[
147,
564,
214,
580
],
[
218,
564,
219,
579
],
[
222,
564,
230,
579
],
[
210,
601,
235,
613
],
[
241,
601,
290,
614
],
[
293,
601,
382,
614
],
[
385,
602,
423,
614
],
[
426,
602,
441,
614
],
[
446,
602,
475,
614
],
[
480,
601,
569,
615
],
[
574,
601,
597,
615
],
[
601,
600,
661,
615
],
[
663,
600,
683,
615
],
[
685,
599,
810,
614
],
[
146,
618,
202,
632
],
[
205,
618,
290,
632
],
[
293,
618,
329,
631
],
[
333,
618,
407,
631
],
[
410,
618,
449,
631
],
[
453,
618,
491,
631
],
[
497,
618,
516,
631
],
[
519,
618,
586,
631
],
[
589,
618,
693,
631
],
[
696,
618,
752,
631
],
[
755,
618,
818,
631
],
[
147,
634,
206,
649
],
[
210,
634,
245,
649
],
[
250,
634,
377,
649
],
[
381,
634,
490,
649
],
[
493,
634,
537,
649
],
[
540,
634,
638,
649
],
[
642,
634,
686,
649
],
[
690,
634,
727,
649
],
[
735,
634,
771,
649
],
[
781,
634,
788,
648
],
[
150,
650,
166,
666
],
[
169,
650,
187,
666
],
[
190,
650,
217,
666
],
[
220,
650,
252,
666
],
[
255,
650,
311,
667
],
[
314,
650,
388,
667
],
[
391,
651,
430,
667
],
[
433,
651,
512,
667
],
[
515,
651,
564,
667
],
[
567,
651,
668,
667
],
[
671,
651,
712,
667
],
[
715,
651,
770,
667
],
[
772,
651,
792,
666
],
[
795,
651,
841,
666
],
[
147,
668,
190,
683
],
[
194,
668,
234,
683
],
[
238,
668,
296,
683
],
[
300,
667,
406,
684
],
[
409,
667,
480,
684
],
[
483,
667,
519,
684
],
[
532,
667,
626,
684
],
[
629,
667,
664,
684
],
[
667,
667,
686,
684
],
[
688,
667,
760,
683
],
[
763,
668,
782,
683
],
[
785,
668,
833,
683
],
[
147,
685,
185,
700
],
[
187,
685,
261,
700
],
[
264,
685,
301,
700
],
[
304,
685,
393,
700
],
[
397,
685,
460,
700
],
[
463,
685,
540,
700
],
[
544,
685,
584,
700
],
[
588,
685,
615,
700
],
[
619,
684,
686,
700
],
[
690,
684,
738,
700
],
[
742,
684,
780,
700
],
[
784,
684,
822,
700
],
[
825,
684,
844,
700
],
[
147,
702,
217,
717
],
[
221,
701,
270,
717
],
[
275,
701,
372,
718
],
[
375,
701,
433,
718
],
[
437,
701,
509,
718
],
[
512,
701,
529,
718
],
[
532,
701,
563,
718
],
[
566,
701,
615,
718
],
[
621,
701,
639,
718
],
[
642,
701,
724,
718
],
[
727,
701,
796,
718
],
[
799,
701,
844,
718
],
[
147,
719,
165,
734
],
[
170,
719,
230,
733
],
[
234,
719,
287,
734
],
[
157,
814,
207,
828
],
[
211,
814,
228,
829
],
[
231,
814,
267,
829
],
[
271,
814,
283,
829
],
[
287,
814,
320,
829
],
[
324,
814,
362,
829
],
[
365,
814,
410,
829
],
[
414,
814,
489,
829
],
[
492,
814,
522,
829
],
[
525,
814,
615,
829
],
[
619,
814,
675,
829
],
[
678,
814,
720,
829
],
[
724,
814,
772,
829
],
[
775,
814,
847,
828
],
[
147,
830,
254,
844
],
[
257,
830,
301,
844
],
[
304,
830,
532,
845
],
[
539,
830,
564,
845
],
[
571,
830,
664,
845
],
[
667,
830,
725,
844
],
[
732,
830,
821,
844
],
[
147,
863,
153,
877
],
[
157,
863,
226,
877
],
[
229,
863,
326,
877
],
[
329,
863,
385,
877
],
[
391,
863,
408,
878
],
[
411,
863,
439,
878
],
[
442,
863,
483,
878
],
[
485,
863,
515,
878
],
[
518,
863,
551,
878
],
[
554,
863,
610,
878
],
[
612,
863,
647,
878
],
[
649,
863,
679,
878
],
[
681,
862,
794,
877
],
[
798,
862,
817,
877
],
[
147,
879,
212,
893
],
[
216,
879,
585,
895
],
[
590,
879,
633,
895
],
[
636,
879,
672,
895
],
[
675,
879,
719,
895
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
What is the subject line of this letter?
|
Re: NRDC Comments on the OMB Proposed Risk Assessment Bulletin
|
720
|
[
"American\"",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Document",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Submitted",
"electronically",
"via",
"www.regulations.gay",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Rule:",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act,",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"7562",
"(January",
"19,",
"2017);",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0654",
"Dear",
"Docket",
"Clerk:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"the",
"attached",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency,",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Proposed",
"Rule,",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act.",
"These",
"comments",
"align",
"with",
"our",
"separately",
"filed",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"proposed",
"rules",
"describing",
"the",
"processes",
"for",
"inventory",
"reset",
"and",
"prioritization",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"and",
"for",
"the",
"development",
"of",
"the",
"scopes",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"first",
"10",
"chemicals",
"selected",
"from",
"the",
"TSCA",
"work",
"plan.",
"All",
"comments",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"together.",
"Please",
"feel",
"free",
"to",
"contact",
"me",
"with",
"any",
"questions",
"at",
"202-249-6130",
"or",
"karynschmidt",
"@americanchemistry.com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Karyn",
"M.",
"Schmidt",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"and",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"CC:",
"Jeffery",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett,",
"OPPT",
"Tala",
"Henry,",
"Director,",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Division,",
"OPPT",
"Susanna",
"Blair,",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"ACC",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"More",
"information",
"about",
"ACC",
"is",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"body",
"of",
"our",
"comments.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
459,
100,
572,
119
],
[
486,
120,
605,
142
],
[
459,
140,
541,
158
],
[
442,
189,
491,
202
],
[
495,
190,
520,
203
],
[
522,
189,
560,
203
],
[
88,
222,
165,
235
],
[
168,
222,
224,
235
],
[
227,
222,
274,
235
],
[
277,
221,
342,
235
],
[
91,
237,
135,
251
],
[
138,
238,
155,
251
],
[
158,
239,
224,
251
],
[
227,
239,
308,
251
],
[
311,
238,
340,
251
],
[
342,
237,
393,
251
],
[
91,
254,
197,
268
],
[
200,
255,
276,
268
],
[
279,
255,
330,
269
],
[
92,
269,
124,
283
],
[
128,
270,
227,
283
],
[
230,
270,
264,
283
],
[
267,
269,
295,
283
],
[
90,
286,
181,
299
],
[
184,
286,
208,
298
],
[
213,
285,
302,
299
],
[
90,
317,
161,
330
],
[
164,
318,
265,
331
],
[
268,
319,
291,
332
],
[
294,
319,
449,
333
],
[
87,
348,
119,
363
],
[
147,
350,
226,
363
],
[
229,
350,
246,
364
],
[
249,
350,
274,
364
],
[
277,
350,
347,
365
],
[
351,
350,
427,
365
],
[
430,
350,
488,
365
],
[
491,
350,
512,
365
],
[
515,
350,
562,
365
],
[
565,
350,
634,
365
],
[
637,
350,
677,
365
],
[
680,
350,
766,
365
],
[
768,
350,
791,
365
],
[
794,
350,
864,
365
],
[
867,
349,
900,
364
],
[
148,
366,
227,
379
],
[
230,
366,
273,
380
],
[
277,
366,
301,
380
],
[
304,
366,
374,
380
],
[
377,
366,
417,
380
],
[
420,
366,
501,
381
],
[
504,
366,
563,
381
],
[
566,
366,
596,
381
],
[
599,
366,
617,
381
],
[
620,
366,
654,
381
],
[
656,
366,
692,
381
],
[
695,
366,
732,
381
],
[
734,
366,
799,
380
],
[
802,
365,
825,
380
],
[
828,
365,
877,
380
],
[
147,
380,
345,
395
],
[
88,
413,
124,
427
],
[
127,
413,
182,
427
],
[
185,
413,
231,
427
],
[
90,
445,
118,
460
],
[
121,
445,
192,
460
],
[
196,
445,
272,
461
],
[
276,
445,
333,
461
],
[
337,
445,
392,
461
],
[
396,
445,
409,
461
],
[
412,
445,
467,
461
],
[
471,
445,
487,
461
],
[
490,
445,
540,
461
],
[
543,
446,
567,
461
],
[
571,
446,
630,
461
],
[
634,
446,
710,
461
],
[
713,
446,
731,
461
],
[
735,
446,
759,
460
],
[
762,
446,
871,
460
],
[
89,
461,
164,
475
],
[
167,
462,
228,
476
],
[
231,
462,
280,
476
],
[
282,
462,
298,
476
],
[
301,
462,
368,
476
],
[
371,
462,
451,
476
],
[
454,
462,
483,
477
],
[
486,
462,
535,
477
],
[
538,
462,
607,
477
],
[
610,
462,
650,
476
],
[
654,
461,
735,
476
],
[
738,
461,
761,
476
],
[
764,
461,
834,
476
],
[
837,
461,
868,
475
],
[
88,
477,
168,
490
],
[
170,
477,
213,
491
],
[
216,
477,
241,
491
],
[
244,
477,
316,
491
],
[
319,
477,
361,
491
],
[
364,
477,
445,
491
],
[
448,
478,
505,
491
],
[
508,
478,
538,
491
],
[
90,
510,
132,
524
],
[
135,
510,
210,
524
],
[
214,
510,
251,
524
],
[
255,
510,
287,
524
],
[
291,
510,
316,
524
],
[
320,
510,
393,
524
],
[
396,
510,
431,
525
],
[
434,
510,
510,
525
],
[
513,
510,
532,
525
],
[
535,
510,
559,
525
],
[
562,
510,
629,
525
],
[
632,
510,
672,
525
],
[
675,
510,
748,
525
],
[
751,
510,
775,
525
],
[
778,
510,
848,
525
],
[
851,
510,
875,
525
],
[
88,
526,
158,
539
],
[
161,
526,
197,
539
],
[
201,
526,
227,
539
],
[
230,
526,
327,
539
],
[
330,
526,
351,
540
],
[
354,
525,
382,
540
],
[
385,
525,
467,
540
],
[
470,
525,
497,
540
],
[
500,
525,
522,
540
],
[
525,
525,
551,
540
],
[
556,
525,
647,
540
],
[
650,
525,
667,
540
],
[
670,
525,
693,
540
],
[
696,
525,
745,
540
],
[
748,
525,
770,
540
],
[
772,
525,
802,
540
],
[
805,
525,
881,
540
],
[
884,
525,
904,
540
],
[
88,
541,
112,
554
],
[
114,
541,
147,
554
],
[
150,
541,
167,
554
],
[
170,
541,
244,
555
],
[
247,
541,
306,
555
],
[
308,
541,
341,
555
],
[
348,
541,
373,
555
],
[
377,
541,
420,
555
],
[
426,
541,
464,
555
],
[
467,
541,
508,
555
],
[
512,
541,
536,
555
],
[
539,
541,
615,
555
],
[
618,
541,
667,
555
],
[
670,
541,
689,
555
],
[
692,
541,
771,
555
],
[
774,
541,
842,
555
],
[
88,
573,
135,
587
],
[
138,
573,
167,
587
],
[
170,
573,
199,
587
],
[
202,
573,
218,
587
],
[
221,
573,
274,
588
],
[
277,
574,
300,
588
],
[
304,
574,
337,
588
],
[
340,
574,
367,
589
],
[
370,
574,
440,
589
],
[
442,
574,
457,
589
],
[
461,
574,
564,
590
],
[
568,
574,
582,
590
],
[
585,
574,
695,
590
],
[
698,
575,
885,
590
],
[
89,
604,
161,
620
],
[
89,
714,
134,
728
],
[
137,
715,
160,
728
],
[
163,
714,
224,
728
],
[
90,
730,
135,
744
],
[
139,
730,
205,
744
],
[
208,
730,
290,
744
],
[
292,
730,
322,
744
],
[
325,
730,
396,
744
],
[
399,
730,
454,
745
],
[
91,
746,
161,
760
],
[
164,
746,
241,
760
],
[
244,
746,
302,
760
],
[
88,
780,
110,
792
],
[
147,
777,
198,
792
],
[
201,
778,
257,
793
],
[
260,
778,
326,
793
],
[
330,
778,
374,
792
],
[
148,
793,
201,
808
],
[
204,
794,
333,
808
],
[
337,
793,
382,
808
],
[
148,
809,
180,
824
],
[
182,
810,
234,
825
],
[
237,
810,
304,
825
],
[
307,
810,
341,
825
],
[
344,
810,
430,
825
],
[
432,
810,
502,
825
],
[
505,
810,
551,
824
],
[
147,
825,
208,
840
],
[
211,
825,
253,
840
],
[
257,
825,
304,
840
],
[
307,
826,
324,
840
],
[
327,
826,
397,
840
],
[
401,
826,
448,
840
],
[
451,
826,
477,
840
],
[
481,
826,
548,
840
],
[
552,
826,
632,
840
],
[
98,
881,
131,
894
],
[
134,
882,
202,
895
],
[
205,
882,
226,
895
],
[
229,
882,
278,
895
],
[
281,
883,
351,
895
],
[
355,
883,
410,
895
],
[
413,
883,
427,
895
],
[
430,
883,
451,
895
],
[
454,
883,
511,
895
],
[
514,
883,
530,
896
],
[
532,
883,
601,
896
],
[
604,
883,
641,
895
],
[
644,
883,
722,
895
],
[
725,
883,
764,
895
],
[
767,
882,
801,
895
],
[
804,
882,
814,
895
],
[
817,
882,
882,
895
],
[
885,
881,
898,
895
],
[
87,
897,
109,
909
],
[
111,
897,
146,
909
],
[
148,
897,
164,
909
],
[
167,
897,
190,
909
],
[
192,
898,
266,
909
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
which contact number is provided in this letter?
|
202-249-6130
|
720
|
[
"American\"",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"March",
"20,",
"2017",
"Document",
"Control",
"Office",
"(7407M)",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"1200",
"Pennsylvania",
"Ave.",
"NW",
"Washington,",
"DC",
"20460-0001",
"Submitted",
"electronically",
"via",
"www.regulations.gay",
"Re:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"EPA's",
"Proposed",
"Rule:",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act,",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"7562",
"(January",
"19,",
"2017);",
"EPA-HQ-OPPT-2016-0654",
"Dear",
"Docket",
"Clerk:",
"The",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC)'",
"is",
"pleased",
"to",
"submit",
"the",
"attached",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency,",
"Office",
"of",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"and",
"Toxics",
"Proposed",
"Rule,",
"Procedures",
"for",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Evaluation",
"under",
"the",
"Amended",
"Toxic",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act.",
"These",
"comments",
"align",
"with",
"our",
"separately",
"filed",
"comments",
"on",
"the",
"proposed",
"rules",
"describing",
"the",
"processes",
"for",
"inventory",
"reset",
"and",
"prioritization",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"and",
"for",
"the",
"development",
"of",
"the",
"scopes",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"the",
"first",
"10",
"chemicals",
"selected",
"from",
"the",
"TSCA",
"work",
"plan.",
"All",
"comments",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"together.",
"Please",
"feel",
"free",
"to",
"contact",
"me",
"with",
"any",
"questions",
"at",
"202-249-6130",
"or",
"karynschmidt",
"@americanchemistry.com.",
"Sincerely,",
"Karyn",
"M.",
"Schmidt",
"Senior",
"Director,",
"Regulatory",
"and",
"Technical",
"Affairs",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"CC:",
"Jeffery",
"Morris,",
"Director,",
"OPPT",
"Wendy",
"Cleland-Hamnett,",
"OPPT",
"Tala",
"Henry,",
"Director,",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Division,",
"OPPT",
"Susanna",
"Blair,",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"ACC",
"represents",
"the",
"leading",
"companies",
"engaged",
"in",
"the",
"business",
"of",
"chemistry.",
"More",
"information",
"about",
"ACC",
"is",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"body",
"of",
"our",
"comments.",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
459,
100,
572,
119
],
[
486,
120,
605,
142
],
[
459,
140,
541,
158
],
[
442,
189,
491,
202
],
[
495,
190,
520,
203
],
[
522,
189,
560,
203
],
[
88,
222,
165,
235
],
[
168,
222,
224,
235
],
[
227,
222,
274,
235
],
[
277,
221,
342,
235
],
[
91,
237,
135,
251
],
[
138,
238,
155,
251
],
[
158,
239,
224,
251
],
[
227,
239,
308,
251
],
[
311,
238,
340,
251
],
[
342,
237,
393,
251
],
[
91,
254,
197,
268
],
[
200,
255,
276,
268
],
[
279,
255,
330,
269
],
[
92,
269,
124,
283
],
[
128,
270,
227,
283
],
[
230,
270,
264,
283
],
[
267,
269,
295,
283
],
[
90,
286,
181,
299
],
[
184,
286,
208,
298
],
[
213,
285,
302,
299
],
[
90,
317,
161,
330
],
[
164,
318,
265,
331
],
[
268,
319,
291,
332
],
[
294,
319,
449,
333
],
[
87,
348,
119,
363
],
[
147,
350,
226,
363
],
[
229,
350,
246,
364
],
[
249,
350,
274,
364
],
[
277,
350,
347,
365
],
[
351,
350,
427,
365
],
[
430,
350,
488,
365
],
[
491,
350,
512,
365
],
[
515,
350,
562,
365
],
[
565,
350,
634,
365
],
[
637,
350,
677,
365
],
[
680,
350,
766,
365
],
[
768,
350,
791,
365
],
[
794,
350,
864,
365
],
[
867,
349,
900,
364
],
[
148,
366,
227,
379
],
[
230,
366,
273,
380
],
[
277,
366,
301,
380
],
[
304,
366,
374,
380
],
[
377,
366,
417,
380
],
[
420,
366,
501,
381
],
[
504,
366,
563,
381
],
[
566,
366,
596,
381
],
[
599,
366,
617,
381
],
[
620,
366,
654,
381
],
[
656,
366,
692,
381
],
[
695,
366,
732,
381
],
[
734,
366,
799,
380
],
[
802,
365,
825,
380
],
[
828,
365,
877,
380
],
[
147,
380,
345,
395
],
[
88,
413,
124,
427
],
[
127,
413,
182,
427
],
[
185,
413,
231,
427
],
[
90,
445,
118,
460
],
[
121,
445,
192,
460
],
[
196,
445,
272,
461
],
[
276,
445,
333,
461
],
[
337,
445,
392,
461
],
[
396,
445,
409,
461
],
[
412,
445,
467,
461
],
[
471,
445,
487,
461
],
[
490,
445,
540,
461
],
[
543,
446,
567,
461
],
[
571,
446,
630,
461
],
[
634,
446,
710,
461
],
[
713,
446,
731,
461
],
[
735,
446,
759,
460
],
[
762,
446,
871,
460
],
[
89,
461,
164,
475
],
[
167,
462,
228,
476
],
[
231,
462,
280,
476
],
[
282,
462,
298,
476
],
[
301,
462,
368,
476
],
[
371,
462,
451,
476
],
[
454,
462,
483,
477
],
[
486,
462,
535,
477
],
[
538,
462,
607,
477
],
[
610,
462,
650,
476
],
[
654,
461,
735,
476
],
[
738,
461,
761,
476
],
[
764,
461,
834,
476
],
[
837,
461,
868,
475
],
[
88,
477,
168,
490
],
[
170,
477,
213,
491
],
[
216,
477,
241,
491
],
[
244,
477,
316,
491
],
[
319,
477,
361,
491
],
[
364,
477,
445,
491
],
[
448,
478,
505,
491
],
[
508,
478,
538,
491
],
[
90,
510,
132,
524
],
[
135,
510,
210,
524
],
[
214,
510,
251,
524
],
[
255,
510,
287,
524
],
[
291,
510,
316,
524
],
[
320,
510,
393,
524
],
[
396,
510,
431,
525
],
[
434,
510,
510,
525
],
[
513,
510,
532,
525
],
[
535,
510,
559,
525
],
[
562,
510,
629,
525
],
[
632,
510,
672,
525
],
[
675,
510,
748,
525
],
[
751,
510,
775,
525
],
[
778,
510,
848,
525
],
[
851,
510,
875,
525
],
[
88,
526,
158,
539
],
[
161,
526,
197,
539
],
[
201,
526,
227,
539
],
[
230,
526,
327,
539
],
[
330,
526,
351,
540
],
[
354,
525,
382,
540
],
[
385,
525,
467,
540
],
[
470,
525,
497,
540
],
[
500,
525,
522,
540
],
[
525,
525,
551,
540
],
[
556,
525,
647,
540
],
[
650,
525,
667,
540
],
[
670,
525,
693,
540
],
[
696,
525,
745,
540
],
[
748,
525,
770,
540
],
[
772,
525,
802,
540
],
[
805,
525,
881,
540
],
[
884,
525,
904,
540
],
[
88,
541,
112,
554
],
[
114,
541,
147,
554
],
[
150,
541,
167,
554
],
[
170,
541,
244,
555
],
[
247,
541,
306,
555
],
[
308,
541,
341,
555
],
[
348,
541,
373,
555
],
[
377,
541,
420,
555
],
[
426,
541,
464,
555
],
[
467,
541,
508,
555
],
[
512,
541,
536,
555
],
[
539,
541,
615,
555
],
[
618,
541,
667,
555
],
[
670,
541,
689,
555
],
[
692,
541,
771,
555
],
[
774,
541,
842,
555
],
[
88,
573,
135,
587
],
[
138,
573,
167,
587
],
[
170,
573,
199,
587
],
[
202,
573,
218,
587
],
[
221,
573,
274,
588
],
[
277,
574,
300,
588
],
[
304,
574,
337,
588
],
[
340,
574,
367,
589
],
[
370,
574,
440,
589
],
[
442,
574,
457,
589
],
[
461,
574,
564,
590
],
[
568,
574,
582,
590
],
[
585,
574,
695,
590
],
[
698,
575,
885,
590
],
[
89,
604,
161,
620
],
[
89,
714,
134,
728
],
[
137,
715,
160,
728
],
[
163,
714,
224,
728
],
[
90,
730,
135,
744
],
[
139,
730,
205,
744
],
[
208,
730,
290,
744
],
[
292,
730,
322,
744
],
[
325,
730,
396,
744
],
[
399,
730,
454,
745
],
[
91,
746,
161,
760
],
[
164,
746,
241,
760
],
[
244,
746,
302,
760
],
[
88,
780,
110,
792
],
[
147,
777,
198,
792
],
[
201,
778,
257,
793
],
[
260,
778,
326,
793
],
[
330,
778,
374,
792
],
[
148,
793,
201,
808
],
[
204,
794,
333,
808
],
[
337,
793,
382,
808
],
[
148,
809,
180,
824
],
[
182,
810,
234,
825
],
[
237,
810,
304,
825
],
[
307,
810,
341,
825
],
[
344,
810,
430,
825
],
[
432,
810,
502,
825
],
[
505,
810,
551,
824
],
[
147,
825,
208,
840
],
[
211,
825,
253,
840
],
[
257,
825,
304,
840
],
[
307,
826,
324,
840
],
[
327,
826,
397,
840
],
[
401,
826,
448,
840
],
[
451,
826,
477,
840
],
[
481,
826,
548,
840
],
[
552,
826,
632,
840
],
[
98,
881,
131,
894
],
[
134,
882,
202,
895
],
[
205,
882,
226,
895
],
[
229,
882,
278,
895
],
[
281,
883,
351,
895
],
[
355,
883,
410,
895
],
[
413,
883,
427,
895
],
[
430,
883,
451,
895
],
[
454,
883,
511,
895
],
[
514,
883,
530,
896
],
[
532,
883,
601,
896
],
[
604,
883,
641,
895
],
[
644,
883,
722,
895
],
[
725,
883,
764,
895
],
[
767,
882,
801,
895
],
[
804,
882,
814,
895
],
[
817,
882,
882,
895
],
[
885,
881,
898,
895
],
[
87,
897,
109,
909
],
[
111,
897,
146,
909
],
[
148,
897,
164,
909
],
[
167,
897,
190,
909
],
[
192,
898,
266,
909
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
who is senior director for regulatory and technical affairs american chemistry council?
|
Karyn M. Schmidt
|
740
|
[
"Perhaps",
"for",
"simplification",
"purposes,",
"EPA",
"has",
"provided",
"a",
"succinct",
"definition.",
"However,",
"as",
"noted",
"above,",
"this",
"definition",
"does",
"not",
"appropriately",
"capture",
"how",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"approach",
"is",
"currently",
"used.",
"Relying",
"on",
"the",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"does",
"not",
"mean",
"that",
"the",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"is",
"used.",
"Reasonable",
"values",
"from",
"that",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"should",
"be",
"used",
"instead.",
"A",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"should",
"not",
"use",
"a",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"value",
"as",
"these",
"values",
"are",
"typically",
"unstable.",
"More",
"appropriate",
"language",
"would",
"include",
"the",
"term",
"\"plausible",
"exposure\"",
"or",
"\"plausible",
"upper",
"bound",
"exposure.\"",
"In",
"the",
"environmental",
"toxicology",
"field,",
"it",
"is",
"common",
"to",
"use",
"the",
"95\"",
"percentile",
"under",
"average",
"exposure",
"conditions.",
"The",
"\"plausible",
"maximum",
"exposure\"",
"is",
"not",
"used.",
"Significant",
"revisions",
"are",
"needed",
"to",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"to",
"capture",
"the",
"appropriate",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"concept.",
"E.",
"Uncertainty",
"EPA",
"provides",
"a",
"definition",
"for",
"uncertainty",
"and",
"cites",
"EPA's",
"2014",
"Human",
"Health",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Framework",
"as",
"the",
"source.",
"However,",
"as",
"written,",
"the",
"definition",
"EPA",
"provides",
"is",
"actually",
"not",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"source.",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"should",
"conforms",
"to",
"the",
"edits",
"below",
"to",
"ensure",
"the",
"definition",
"is",
"fully",
"consistent.",
"Uncertainty",
"means",
"the",
"imperfect",
"knowledge",
"or",
"lack",
"of",
"precise",
"knowledge",
"of",
"the",
"real",
"world,",
"either",
"for",
"specific",
"values",
"of",
"interest",
"or",
"in",
"the",
"description",
"of",
"a",
"the",
"system.",
"VIII.",
"The",
"Process",
"for",
"Manufacturer",
"Requested",
"Evaluations",
"A.",
"EPA-Initiated",
"and",
"Manufacturer-Requested",
"Evaluations",
"Should",
"Follow",
"the",
"Same",
"Review",
"Process.",
"LCSA",
"allows",
"chemical",
"manufacturers",
"to",
"request",
"EPA",
"to",
"conduct",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(C)(ii).",
"By",
"law,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"only",
"request",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"it",
"manufacturers",
"(not",
"of",
"a",
"competitor).",
"By",
"rule,",
"EPA",
"is",
"to",
"specify",
"the",
"\"form",
"and",
"manner\"",
"for",
"manufacturer",
"requests,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"prescribe",
"the",
"criteria",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"In",
"our",
"view,",
"EPA",
"should",
"largely",
"follow",
"the",
"same",
"process",
"-",
"and",
"apply",
"the",
"same",
"criteria",
"-",
"to",
"manufacturer",
"requested",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"as",
"it",
"does",
"to",
"EPA-initiated",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"arising",
"out",
"of",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process.",
"There",
"is",
"one",
"notable",
"difference:",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"under",
"LCSA",
"to",
"flexibly",
"scope",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"for",
"chemicals",
"with",
"high",
"priority",
"designations",
"to",
"focus",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"most",
"relevant",
"and",
"meaningful",
"to",
"risk,",
"and",
"it",
"should",
"do",
"so",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-",
"case",
"basis.",
"The",
"result",
"of",
"this",
"process",
"might",
"be",
"that",
"some",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"cover",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use;",
"others",
"a",
"few;",
"others",
"only",
"one.",
"In",
"the",
"case",
"of",
"manufacturer-requested",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"support",
"only",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"-",
"in",
"other",
"words,",
"it",
"may",
"sell",
"the",
"chemical",
"only",
"for",
"use",
"in",
"certain",
"kinds",
"of",
"products",
"or",
"processes.",
"A",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"strongly",
"support",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"it",
"supports,",
"but",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"willing",
"to",
"fund",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"for",
"uses",
"supported",
"by",
"its",
"competitors.",
"While",
"we",
"believe",
"EPA",
"can",
"expand",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"beyond",
"that",
"requested",
"by",
"a",
"manufacturer,",
"the",
"agency",
"should",
"not",
"impose",
"fees",
"on",
"a",
"90",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7568.",
"37/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
93,
180,
110
],
[
184,
93,
208,
110
],
[
212,
93,
321,
110
],
[
324,
93,
402,
110
],
[
405,
93,
442,
109
],
[
445,
93,
474,
109
],
[
477,
93,
551,
109
],
[
554,
93,
564,
109
],
[
567,
93,
635,
109
],
[
638,
93,
718,
109
],
[
721,
93,
801,
109
],
[
804,
93,
822,
109
],
[
824,
93,
871,
109
],
[
118,
111,
170,
126
],
[
174,
111,
207,
126
],
[
210,
111,
287,
126
],
[
292,
111,
325,
126
],
[
328,
111,
356,
126
],
[
360,
111,
465,
126
],
[
469,
112,
527,
126
],
[
531,
112,
565,
126
],
[
570,
112,
596,
126
],
[
600,
112,
662,
126
],
[
666,
111,
738,
126
],
[
742,
111,
814,
126
],
[
818,
111,
829,
126
],
[
117,
128,
189,
143
],
[
193,
129,
235,
144
],
[
238,
129,
302,
144
],
[
307,
130,
327,
144
],
[
331,
130,
355,
144
],
[
358,
130,
417,
144
],
[
421,
130,
493,
144
],
[
497,
130,
566,
144
],
[
571,
129,
604,
144
],
[
607,
129,
634,
143
],
[
637,
129,
682,
143
],
[
685,
128,
716,
143
],
[
720,
128,
745,
143
],
[
748,
127,
837,
143
],
[
118,
146,
189,
161
],
[
192,
146,
207,
161
],
[
211,
146,
252,
160
],
[
257,
146,
350,
160
],
[
353,
146,
404,
160
],
[
408,
146,
442,
160
],
[
450,
146,
481,
160
],
[
484,
146,
543,
160
],
[
547,
146,
620,
160
],
[
623,
146,
690,
160
],
[
693,
145,
745,
160
],
[
749,
145,
770,
160
],
[
773,
145,
811,
161
],
[
814,
145,
878,
161
],
[
118,
163,
132,
179
],
[
135,
163,
167,
179
],
[
171,
163,
253,
179
],
[
257,
164,
310,
179
],
[
314,
164,
341,
179
],
[
344,
164,
372,
179
],
[
376,
164,
385,
179
],
[
389,
164,
477,
179
],
[
480,
164,
553,
179
],
[
557,
164,
601,
179
],
[
604,
164,
621,
179
],
[
624,
164,
667,
179
],
[
671,
164,
721,
179
],
[
725,
164,
750,
179
],
[
754,
164,
822,
179
],
[
118,
181,
189,
196
],
[
192,
181,
237,
196
],
[
240,
181,
330,
196
],
[
333,
181,
407,
196
],
[
410,
182,
460,
196
],
[
463,
181,
522,
196
],
[
526,
181,
552,
196
],
[
555,
181,
588,
196
],
[
595,
181,
678,
196
],
[
681,
181,
762,
196
],
[
765,
180,
782,
196
],
[
786,
180,
870,
196
],
[
119,
198,
162,
213
],
[
166,
198,
217,
214
],
[
221,
198,
310,
214
],
[
315,
198,
333,
214
],
[
337,
198,
362,
214
],
[
366,
198,
480,
214
],
[
483,
198,
570,
214
],
[
574,
197,
615,
213
],
[
618,
197,
631,
213
],
[
635,
197,
649,
213
],
[
652,
197,
723,
213
],
[
727,
197,
744,
213
],
[
747,
197,
774,
212
],
[
777,
197,
803,
212
],
[
807,
197,
835,
212
],
[
118,
216,
196,
231
],
[
200,
216,
247,
231
],
[
250,
216,
312,
231
],
[
315,
216,
387,
231
],
[
391,
216,
481,
232
],
[
485,
216,
514,
232
],
[
517,
215,
598,
232
],
[
601,
215,
680,
232
],
[
687,
215,
768,
232
],
[
771,
215,
785,
231
],
[
789,
215,
815,
231
],
[
819,
215,
862,
231
],
[
118,
233,
205,
247
],
[
208,
233,
281,
248
],
[
284,
233,
308,
248
],
[
312,
234,
370,
248
],
[
372,
234,
390,
248
],
[
394,
234,
449,
248
],
[
452,
234,
528,
249
],
[
531,
234,
548,
249
],
[
551,
234,
611,
249
],
[
614,
234,
640,
249
],
[
644,
233,
734,
248
],
[
737,
233,
765,
248
],
[
768,
233,
786,
248
],
[
790,
233,
815,
248
],
[
819,
233,
881,
248
],
[
118,
251,
190,
266
],
[
193,
251,
260,
265
],
[
177,
283,
199,
299
],
[
237,
285,
335,
300
],
[
118,
320,
155,
336
],
[
158,
320,
229,
336
],
[
232,
320,
245,
336
],
[
248,
320,
323,
336
],
[
327,
320,
351,
336
],
[
354,
320,
445,
336
],
[
448,
320,
478,
336
],
[
481,
320,
519,
335
],
[
522,
320,
575,
335
],
[
579,
320,
619,
335
],
[
622,
320,
682,
335
],
[
685,
320,
738,
335
],
[
742,
320,
781,
335
],
[
784,
320,
882,
335
],
[
117,
338,
210,
352
],
[
213,
338,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
262,
338,
326,
352
],
[
338,
338,
416,
353
],
[
420,
338,
438,
353
],
[
441,
338,
502,
353
],
[
506,
338,
532,
353
],
[
538,
338,
612,
353
],
[
617,
338,
652,
352
],
[
658,
338,
728,
352
],
[
731,
338,
746,
352
],
[
749,
338,
812,
352
],
[
815,
338,
840,
352
],
[
117,
355,
198,
370
],
[
201,
355,
237,
370
],
[
240,
355,
266,
370
],
[
270,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
386,
370
],
[
390,
355,
465,
370
],
[
468,
355,
522,
370
],
[
525,
355,
601,
370
],
[
604,
355,
621,
370
],
[
624,
355,
650,
370
],
[
653,
355,
691,
370
],
[
694,
355,
742,
370
],
[
748,
355,
765,
369
],
[
768,
355,
821,
369
],
[
824,
355,
850,
369
],
[
121,
371,
195,
388
],
[
198,
371,
214,
387
],
[
217,
371,
255,
387
],
[
258,
372,
347,
389
],
[
177,
407,
272,
421
],
[
274,
408,
325,
421
],
[
328,
408,
355,
421
],
[
358,
408,
435,
422
],
[
438,
408,
528,
422
],
[
531,
408,
548,
422
],
[
551,
408,
586,
422
],
[
589,
408,
607,
422
],
[
610,
407,
666,
422
],
[
670,
407,
758,
422
],
[
761,
407,
780,
423
],
[
783,
407,
808,
423
],
[
812,
407,
844,
423
],
[
178,
424,
228,
440
],
[
231,
424,
277,
440
],
[
281,
424,
305,
440
],
[
309,
424,
371,
440
],
[
375,
424,
427,
440
],
[
431,
425,
448,
440
],
[
451,
425,
511,
440
],
[
515,
425,
532,
440
],
[
536,
425,
551,
440
],
[
555,
425,
585,
440
],
[
588,
425,
673,
440
],
[
677,
425,
694,
440
],
[
698,
425,
708,
440
],
[
711,
425,
738,
441
],
[
742,
425,
802,
441
],
[
121,
458,
170,
474
],
[
192,
459,
225,
475
],
[
228,
459,
292,
475
],
[
296,
459,
322,
475
],
[
325,
460,
446,
475
],
[
450,
460,
540,
475
],
[
543,
460,
642,
475
],
[
176,
491,
197,
510
],
[
235,
493,
354,
510
],
[
358,
494,
390,
510
],
[
394,
495,
609,
510
],
[
612,
495,
714,
510
],
[
717,
494,
777,
510
],
[
781,
493,
837,
509
],
[
842,
493,
868,
509
],
[
236,
512,
282,
526
],
[
285,
512,
345,
527
],
[
352,
513,
422,
528
],
[
117,
546,
168,
562
],
[
172,
546,
225,
562
],
[
228,
547,
300,
562
],
[
303,
548,
417,
562
],
[
421,
548,
437,
562
],
[
440,
548,
500,
562
],
[
504,
548,
541,
562
],
[
544,
548,
562,
562
],
[
565,
548,
629,
562
],
[
632,
548,
642,
562
],
[
645,
548,
677,
562
],
[
680,
547,
764,
562
],
[
767,
547,
783,
562
],
[
787,
546,
848,
561
],
[
117,
564,
235,
580
],
[
238,
565,
261,
579
],
[
265,
565,
300,
579
],
[
304,
565,
312,
579
],
[
315,
565,
422,
579
],
[
425,
565,
461,
579
],
[
465,
565,
500,
579
],
[
504,
565,
563,
579
],
[
567,
565,
575,
579
],
[
578,
565,
611,
579
],
[
615,
565,
697,
579
],
[
701,
565,
719,
579
],
[
722,
565,
732,
579
],
[
735,
564,
807,
579
],
[
811,
564,
824,
579
],
[
117,
582,
231,
597
],
[
235,
582,
268,
597
],
[
271,
582,
290,
597
],
[
293,
582,
303,
597
],
[
306,
581,
408,
597
],
[
411,
581,
436,
597
],
[
440,
581,
477,
597
],
[
481,
581,
517,
597
],
[
522,
581,
537,
597
],
[
541,
581,
558,
597
],
[
561,
581,
618,
597
],
[
622,
581,
648,
597
],
[
651,
581,
695,
597
],
[
703,
581,
732,
597
],
[
735,
581,
805,
597
],
[
808,
581,
835,
597
],
[
117,
600,
224,
615
],
[
227,
600,
298,
615
],
[
301,
600,
320,
615
],
[
323,
600,
358,
615
],
[
361,
600,
379,
615
],
[
382,
600,
399,
615
],
[
402,
600,
476,
615
],
[
479,
600,
505,
615
],
[
508,
600,
567,
615
],
[
570,
600,
594,
615
],
[
597,
600,
622,
615
],
[
625,
600,
656,
615
],
[
660,
600,
751,
615
],
[
117,
633,
134,
649
],
[
137,
633,
166,
649
],
[
170,
633,
213,
649
],
[
217,
633,
256,
649
],
[
260,
633,
313,
649
],
[
317,
634,
372,
649
],
[
376,
634,
428,
650
],
[
431,
634,
457,
650
],
[
461,
634,
503,
650
],
[
507,
634,
567,
650
],
[
570,
634,
582,
650
],
[
585,
634,
615,
650
],
[
619,
634,
662,
650
],
[
666,
634,
693,
650
],
[
697,
634,
737,
650
],
[
741,
634,
798,
650
],
[
802,
634,
812,
650
],
[
815,
634,
834,
650
],
[
117,
652,
224,
667
],
[
227,
651,
304,
667
],
[
307,
651,
338,
667
],
[
341,
651,
432,
667
],
[
435,
651,
452,
667
],
[
455,
651,
473,
667
],
[
476,
651,
510,
667
],
[
513,
651,
531,
667
],
[
534,
651,
642,
667
],
[
645,
651,
678,
667
],
[
681,
651,
772,
667
],
[
775,
651,
830,
667
],
[
832,
651,
861,
667
],
[
864,
651,
886,
667
],
[
117,
669,
142,
684
],
[
146,
669,
249,
684
],
[
253,
669,
324,
684
],
[
329,
669,
374,
684
],
[
377,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
425,
684
],
[
429,
669,
491,
684
],
[
495,
669,
579,
684
],
[
582,
669,
618,
684
],
[
623,
669,
652,
684
],
[
655,
668,
727,
684
],
[
730,
668,
776,
684
],
[
780,
668,
829,
684
],
[
835,
668,
854,
684
],
[
117,
686,
180,
702
],
[
182,
686,
228,
702
],
[
231,
686,
264,
702
],
[
267,
686,
358,
702
],
[
361,
686,
386,
702
],
[
389,
686,
469,
702
],
[
472,
686,
508,
702
],
[
511,
686,
548,
702
],
[
551,
686,
616,
702
],
[
619,
686,
715,
702
],
[
718,
686,
735,
702
],
[
738,
686,
783,
702
],
[
786,
686,
806,
702
],
[
117,
704,
201,
719
],
[
205,
704,
222,
719
],
[
225,
704,
252,
719
],
[
255,
704,
287,
719
],
[
291,
704,
315,
719
],
[
318,
704,
359,
720
],
[
362,
704,
428,
720
],
[
431,
704,
460,
720
],
[
462,
704,
554,
720
],
[
557,
703,
574,
720
],
[
578,
703,
614,
720
],
[
618,
703,
647,
720
],
[
651,
703,
664,
720
],
[
668,
703,
724,
720
],
[
728,
703,
745,
720
],
[
749,
703,
768,
720
],
[
772,
703,
792,
719
],
[
796,
703,
806,
719
],
[
810,
703,
875,
719
],
[
117,
721,
151,
736
],
[
155,
721,
208,
736
],
[
211,
721,
241,
736
],
[
245,
722,
290,
737
],
[
294,
722,
311,
737
],
[
315,
722,
344,
737
],
[
348,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
459,
737
],
[
462,
722,
481,
737
],
[
485,
722,
518,
737
],
[
521,
722,
563,
737
],
[
566,
722,
598,
737
],
[
601,
721,
692,
736
],
[
695,
721,
741,
736
],
[
744,
721,
765,
736
],
[
768,
721,
852,
736
],
[
855,
721,
875,
735
],
[
120,
739,
151,
754
],
[
154,
739,
203,
754
],
[
207,
739,
217,
754
],
[
220,
739,
257,
754
],
[
261,
739,
310,
754
],
[
314,
739,
350,
754
],
[
354,
740,
385,
754
],
[
118,
774,
134,
789
],
[
138,
774,
164,
789
],
[
168,
774,
202,
789
],
[
206,
774,
223,
789
],
[
227,
775,
414,
789
],
[
418,
775,
449,
789
],
[
452,
775,
549,
789
],
[
552,
775,
561,
789
],
[
565,
775,
671,
789
],
[
674,
775,
710,
789
],
[
714,
774,
774,
789
],
[
778,
774,
814,
789
],
[
818,
774,
874,
789
],
[
118,
790,
201,
805
],
[
205,
791,
222,
805
],
[
225,
791,
252,
805
],
[
255,
791,
267,
805
],
[
270,
791,
288,
805
],
[
292,
791,
333,
805
],
[
337,
791,
390,
805
],
[
394,
791,
406,
805
],
[
410,
791,
446,
805
],
[
450,
791,
477,
805
],
[
481,
791,
507,
805
],
[
510,
791,
582,
805
],
[
586,
790,
622,
805
],
[
626,
790,
651,
805
],
[
654,
790,
681,
805
],
[
684,
790,
701,
805
],
[
705,
790,
758,
805
],
[
762,
790,
807,
805
],
[
810,
790,
830,
805
],
[
117,
810,
187,
824
],
[
190,
810,
207,
824
],
[
211,
810,
298,
824
],
[
301,
810,
314,
824
],
[
320,
810,
426,
824
],
[
430,
810,
464,
824
],
[
468,
809,
534,
824
],
[
537,
809,
597,
824
],
[
601,
809,
632,
824
],
[
635,
809,
719,
824
],
[
722,
809,
740,
824
],
[
743,
808,
765,
824
],
[
768,
808,
841,
824
],
[
117,
827,
164,
840
],
[
167,
827,
192,
840
],
[
195,
827,
279,
841
],
[
282,
827,
301,
841
],
[
304,
827,
331,
841
],
[
334,
827,
347,
841
],
[
350,
827,
424,
841
],
[
427,
827,
454,
841
],
[
456,
827,
492,
841
],
[
495,
827,
523,
841
],
[
525,
827,
547,
841
],
[
550,
827,
606,
841
],
[
609,
827,
628,
841
],
[
630,
827,
668,
841
],
[
671,
826,
754,
841
],
[
758,
826,
775,
841
],
[
778,
826,
800,
841
],
[
802,
825,
877,
841
],
[
118,
843,
142,
859
],
[
144,
843,
180,
859
],
[
183,
843,
262,
859
],
[
265,
843,
287,
859
],
[
289,
843,
311,
859
],
[
314,
843,
420,
859
],
[
422,
843,
472,
859
],
[
475,
843,
498,
859
],
[
501,
843,
560,
859
],
[
563,
843,
601,
859
],
[
605,
843,
635,
859
],
[
638,
843,
696,
859
],
[
699,
843,
725,
859
],
[
728,
843,
774,
859
],
[
777,
843,
796,
858
],
[
799,
843,
808,
858
],
[
812,
843,
844,
858
],
[
118,
860,
199,
875
],
[
202,
860,
262,
876
],
[
266,
860,
296,
876
],
[
300,
860,
377,
876
],
[
381,
860,
402,
876
],
[
406,
860,
414,
876
],
[
418,
860,
530,
877
],
[
533,
860,
559,
877
],
[
562,
860,
619,
877
],
[
622,
860,
677,
877
],
[
680,
860,
707,
876
],
[
710,
860,
768,
876
],
[
772,
860,
804,
876
],
[
808,
860,
830,
876
],
[
833,
860,
844,
876
],
[
117,
893,
129,
908
],
[
132,
894,
157,
909
],
[
161,
895,
177,
909
],
[
180,
895,
208,
910
],
[
212,
895,
244,
910
],
[
247,
896,
261,
910
],
[
265,
895,
302,
910
],
[
820,
940,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
What is commonly used in the environmental toxicology field?
|
it is common to use the 95th percentile under average exposure conditions.
|
740
|
[
"Perhaps",
"for",
"simplification",
"purposes,",
"EPA",
"has",
"provided",
"a",
"succinct",
"definition.",
"However,",
"as",
"noted",
"above,",
"this",
"definition",
"does",
"not",
"appropriately",
"capture",
"how",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"approach",
"is",
"currently",
"used.",
"Relying",
"on",
"the",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"does",
"not",
"mean",
"that",
"the",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"is",
"used.",
"Reasonable",
"values",
"from",
"that",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"should",
"be",
"used",
"instead.",
"A",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"should",
"not",
"use",
"a",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"value",
"as",
"these",
"values",
"are",
"typically",
"unstable.",
"More",
"appropriate",
"language",
"would",
"include",
"the",
"term",
"\"plausible",
"exposure\"",
"or",
"\"plausible",
"upper",
"bound",
"exposure.\"",
"In",
"the",
"environmental",
"toxicology",
"field,",
"it",
"is",
"common",
"to",
"use",
"the",
"95\"",
"percentile",
"under",
"average",
"exposure",
"conditions.",
"The",
"\"plausible",
"maximum",
"exposure\"",
"is",
"not",
"used.",
"Significant",
"revisions",
"are",
"needed",
"to",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"to",
"capture",
"the",
"appropriate",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"concept.",
"E.",
"Uncertainty",
"EPA",
"provides",
"a",
"definition",
"for",
"uncertainty",
"and",
"cites",
"EPA's",
"2014",
"Human",
"Health",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Framework",
"as",
"the",
"source.",
"However,",
"as",
"written,",
"the",
"definition",
"EPA",
"provides",
"is",
"actually",
"not",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"source.",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"should",
"conforms",
"to",
"the",
"edits",
"below",
"to",
"ensure",
"the",
"definition",
"is",
"fully",
"consistent.",
"Uncertainty",
"means",
"the",
"imperfect",
"knowledge",
"or",
"lack",
"of",
"precise",
"knowledge",
"of",
"the",
"real",
"world,",
"either",
"for",
"specific",
"values",
"of",
"interest",
"or",
"in",
"the",
"description",
"of",
"a",
"the",
"system.",
"VIII.",
"The",
"Process",
"for",
"Manufacturer",
"Requested",
"Evaluations",
"A.",
"EPA-Initiated",
"and",
"Manufacturer-Requested",
"Evaluations",
"Should",
"Follow",
"the",
"Same",
"Review",
"Process.",
"LCSA",
"allows",
"chemical",
"manufacturers",
"to",
"request",
"EPA",
"to",
"conduct",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(C)(ii).",
"By",
"law,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"only",
"request",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"it",
"manufacturers",
"(not",
"of",
"a",
"competitor).",
"By",
"rule,",
"EPA",
"is",
"to",
"specify",
"the",
"\"form",
"and",
"manner\"",
"for",
"manufacturer",
"requests,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"prescribe",
"the",
"criteria",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"In",
"our",
"view,",
"EPA",
"should",
"largely",
"follow",
"the",
"same",
"process",
"-",
"and",
"apply",
"the",
"same",
"criteria",
"-",
"to",
"manufacturer",
"requested",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"as",
"it",
"does",
"to",
"EPA-initiated",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"arising",
"out",
"of",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process.",
"There",
"is",
"one",
"notable",
"difference:",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"under",
"LCSA",
"to",
"flexibly",
"scope",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"for",
"chemicals",
"with",
"high",
"priority",
"designations",
"to",
"focus",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"most",
"relevant",
"and",
"meaningful",
"to",
"risk,",
"and",
"it",
"should",
"do",
"so",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-",
"case",
"basis.",
"The",
"result",
"of",
"this",
"process",
"might",
"be",
"that",
"some",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"cover",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use;",
"others",
"a",
"few;",
"others",
"only",
"one.",
"In",
"the",
"case",
"of",
"manufacturer-requested",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"support",
"only",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"-",
"in",
"other",
"words,",
"it",
"may",
"sell",
"the",
"chemical",
"only",
"for",
"use",
"in",
"certain",
"kinds",
"of",
"products",
"or",
"processes.",
"A",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"strongly",
"support",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"it",
"supports,",
"but",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"willing",
"to",
"fund",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"for",
"uses",
"supported",
"by",
"its",
"competitors.",
"While",
"we",
"believe",
"EPA",
"can",
"expand",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"beyond",
"that",
"requested",
"by",
"a",
"manufacturer,",
"the",
"agency",
"should",
"not",
"impose",
"fees",
"on",
"a",
"90",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7568.",
"37/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
93,
180,
110
],
[
184,
93,
208,
110
],
[
212,
93,
321,
110
],
[
324,
93,
402,
110
],
[
405,
93,
442,
109
],
[
445,
93,
474,
109
],
[
477,
93,
551,
109
],
[
554,
93,
564,
109
],
[
567,
93,
635,
109
],
[
638,
93,
718,
109
],
[
721,
93,
801,
109
],
[
804,
93,
822,
109
],
[
824,
93,
871,
109
],
[
118,
111,
170,
126
],
[
174,
111,
207,
126
],
[
210,
111,
287,
126
],
[
292,
111,
325,
126
],
[
328,
111,
356,
126
],
[
360,
111,
465,
126
],
[
469,
112,
527,
126
],
[
531,
112,
565,
126
],
[
570,
112,
596,
126
],
[
600,
112,
662,
126
],
[
666,
111,
738,
126
],
[
742,
111,
814,
126
],
[
818,
111,
829,
126
],
[
117,
128,
189,
143
],
[
193,
129,
235,
144
],
[
238,
129,
302,
144
],
[
307,
130,
327,
144
],
[
331,
130,
355,
144
],
[
358,
130,
417,
144
],
[
421,
130,
493,
144
],
[
497,
130,
566,
144
],
[
571,
129,
604,
144
],
[
607,
129,
634,
143
],
[
637,
129,
682,
143
],
[
685,
128,
716,
143
],
[
720,
128,
745,
143
],
[
748,
127,
837,
143
],
[
118,
146,
189,
161
],
[
192,
146,
207,
161
],
[
211,
146,
252,
160
],
[
257,
146,
350,
160
],
[
353,
146,
404,
160
],
[
408,
146,
442,
160
],
[
450,
146,
481,
160
],
[
484,
146,
543,
160
],
[
547,
146,
620,
160
],
[
623,
146,
690,
160
],
[
693,
145,
745,
160
],
[
749,
145,
770,
160
],
[
773,
145,
811,
161
],
[
814,
145,
878,
161
],
[
118,
163,
132,
179
],
[
135,
163,
167,
179
],
[
171,
163,
253,
179
],
[
257,
164,
310,
179
],
[
314,
164,
341,
179
],
[
344,
164,
372,
179
],
[
376,
164,
385,
179
],
[
389,
164,
477,
179
],
[
480,
164,
553,
179
],
[
557,
164,
601,
179
],
[
604,
164,
621,
179
],
[
624,
164,
667,
179
],
[
671,
164,
721,
179
],
[
725,
164,
750,
179
],
[
754,
164,
822,
179
],
[
118,
181,
189,
196
],
[
192,
181,
237,
196
],
[
240,
181,
330,
196
],
[
333,
181,
407,
196
],
[
410,
182,
460,
196
],
[
463,
181,
522,
196
],
[
526,
181,
552,
196
],
[
555,
181,
588,
196
],
[
595,
181,
678,
196
],
[
681,
181,
762,
196
],
[
765,
180,
782,
196
],
[
786,
180,
870,
196
],
[
119,
198,
162,
213
],
[
166,
198,
217,
214
],
[
221,
198,
310,
214
],
[
315,
198,
333,
214
],
[
337,
198,
362,
214
],
[
366,
198,
480,
214
],
[
483,
198,
570,
214
],
[
574,
197,
615,
213
],
[
618,
197,
631,
213
],
[
635,
197,
649,
213
],
[
652,
197,
723,
213
],
[
727,
197,
744,
213
],
[
747,
197,
774,
212
],
[
777,
197,
803,
212
],
[
807,
197,
835,
212
],
[
118,
216,
196,
231
],
[
200,
216,
247,
231
],
[
250,
216,
312,
231
],
[
315,
216,
387,
231
],
[
391,
216,
481,
232
],
[
485,
216,
514,
232
],
[
517,
215,
598,
232
],
[
601,
215,
680,
232
],
[
687,
215,
768,
232
],
[
771,
215,
785,
231
],
[
789,
215,
815,
231
],
[
819,
215,
862,
231
],
[
118,
233,
205,
247
],
[
208,
233,
281,
248
],
[
284,
233,
308,
248
],
[
312,
234,
370,
248
],
[
372,
234,
390,
248
],
[
394,
234,
449,
248
],
[
452,
234,
528,
249
],
[
531,
234,
548,
249
],
[
551,
234,
611,
249
],
[
614,
234,
640,
249
],
[
644,
233,
734,
248
],
[
737,
233,
765,
248
],
[
768,
233,
786,
248
],
[
790,
233,
815,
248
],
[
819,
233,
881,
248
],
[
118,
251,
190,
266
],
[
193,
251,
260,
265
],
[
177,
283,
199,
299
],
[
237,
285,
335,
300
],
[
118,
320,
155,
336
],
[
158,
320,
229,
336
],
[
232,
320,
245,
336
],
[
248,
320,
323,
336
],
[
327,
320,
351,
336
],
[
354,
320,
445,
336
],
[
448,
320,
478,
336
],
[
481,
320,
519,
335
],
[
522,
320,
575,
335
],
[
579,
320,
619,
335
],
[
622,
320,
682,
335
],
[
685,
320,
738,
335
],
[
742,
320,
781,
335
],
[
784,
320,
882,
335
],
[
117,
338,
210,
352
],
[
213,
338,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
262,
338,
326,
352
],
[
338,
338,
416,
353
],
[
420,
338,
438,
353
],
[
441,
338,
502,
353
],
[
506,
338,
532,
353
],
[
538,
338,
612,
353
],
[
617,
338,
652,
352
],
[
658,
338,
728,
352
],
[
731,
338,
746,
352
],
[
749,
338,
812,
352
],
[
815,
338,
840,
352
],
[
117,
355,
198,
370
],
[
201,
355,
237,
370
],
[
240,
355,
266,
370
],
[
270,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
386,
370
],
[
390,
355,
465,
370
],
[
468,
355,
522,
370
],
[
525,
355,
601,
370
],
[
604,
355,
621,
370
],
[
624,
355,
650,
370
],
[
653,
355,
691,
370
],
[
694,
355,
742,
370
],
[
748,
355,
765,
369
],
[
768,
355,
821,
369
],
[
824,
355,
850,
369
],
[
121,
371,
195,
388
],
[
198,
371,
214,
387
],
[
217,
371,
255,
387
],
[
258,
372,
347,
389
],
[
177,
407,
272,
421
],
[
274,
408,
325,
421
],
[
328,
408,
355,
421
],
[
358,
408,
435,
422
],
[
438,
408,
528,
422
],
[
531,
408,
548,
422
],
[
551,
408,
586,
422
],
[
589,
408,
607,
422
],
[
610,
407,
666,
422
],
[
670,
407,
758,
422
],
[
761,
407,
780,
423
],
[
783,
407,
808,
423
],
[
812,
407,
844,
423
],
[
178,
424,
228,
440
],
[
231,
424,
277,
440
],
[
281,
424,
305,
440
],
[
309,
424,
371,
440
],
[
375,
424,
427,
440
],
[
431,
425,
448,
440
],
[
451,
425,
511,
440
],
[
515,
425,
532,
440
],
[
536,
425,
551,
440
],
[
555,
425,
585,
440
],
[
588,
425,
673,
440
],
[
677,
425,
694,
440
],
[
698,
425,
708,
440
],
[
711,
425,
738,
441
],
[
742,
425,
802,
441
],
[
121,
458,
170,
474
],
[
192,
459,
225,
475
],
[
228,
459,
292,
475
],
[
296,
459,
322,
475
],
[
325,
460,
446,
475
],
[
450,
460,
540,
475
],
[
543,
460,
642,
475
],
[
176,
491,
197,
510
],
[
235,
493,
354,
510
],
[
358,
494,
390,
510
],
[
394,
495,
609,
510
],
[
612,
495,
714,
510
],
[
717,
494,
777,
510
],
[
781,
493,
837,
509
],
[
842,
493,
868,
509
],
[
236,
512,
282,
526
],
[
285,
512,
345,
527
],
[
352,
513,
422,
528
],
[
117,
546,
168,
562
],
[
172,
546,
225,
562
],
[
228,
547,
300,
562
],
[
303,
548,
417,
562
],
[
421,
548,
437,
562
],
[
440,
548,
500,
562
],
[
504,
548,
541,
562
],
[
544,
548,
562,
562
],
[
565,
548,
629,
562
],
[
632,
548,
642,
562
],
[
645,
548,
677,
562
],
[
680,
547,
764,
562
],
[
767,
547,
783,
562
],
[
787,
546,
848,
561
],
[
117,
564,
235,
580
],
[
238,
565,
261,
579
],
[
265,
565,
300,
579
],
[
304,
565,
312,
579
],
[
315,
565,
422,
579
],
[
425,
565,
461,
579
],
[
465,
565,
500,
579
],
[
504,
565,
563,
579
],
[
567,
565,
575,
579
],
[
578,
565,
611,
579
],
[
615,
565,
697,
579
],
[
701,
565,
719,
579
],
[
722,
565,
732,
579
],
[
735,
564,
807,
579
],
[
811,
564,
824,
579
],
[
117,
582,
231,
597
],
[
235,
582,
268,
597
],
[
271,
582,
290,
597
],
[
293,
582,
303,
597
],
[
306,
581,
408,
597
],
[
411,
581,
436,
597
],
[
440,
581,
477,
597
],
[
481,
581,
517,
597
],
[
522,
581,
537,
597
],
[
541,
581,
558,
597
],
[
561,
581,
618,
597
],
[
622,
581,
648,
597
],
[
651,
581,
695,
597
],
[
703,
581,
732,
597
],
[
735,
581,
805,
597
],
[
808,
581,
835,
597
],
[
117,
600,
224,
615
],
[
227,
600,
298,
615
],
[
301,
600,
320,
615
],
[
323,
600,
358,
615
],
[
361,
600,
379,
615
],
[
382,
600,
399,
615
],
[
402,
600,
476,
615
],
[
479,
600,
505,
615
],
[
508,
600,
567,
615
],
[
570,
600,
594,
615
],
[
597,
600,
622,
615
],
[
625,
600,
656,
615
],
[
660,
600,
751,
615
],
[
117,
633,
134,
649
],
[
137,
633,
166,
649
],
[
170,
633,
213,
649
],
[
217,
633,
256,
649
],
[
260,
633,
313,
649
],
[
317,
634,
372,
649
],
[
376,
634,
428,
650
],
[
431,
634,
457,
650
],
[
461,
634,
503,
650
],
[
507,
634,
567,
650
],
[
570,
634,
582,
650
],
[
585,
634,
615,
650
],
[
619,
634,
662,
650
],
[
666,
634,
693,
650
],
[
697,
634,
737,
650
],
[
741,
634,
798,
650
],
[
802,
634,
812,
650
],
[
815,
634,
834,
650
],
[
117,
652,
224,
667
],
[
227,
651,
304,
667
],
[
307,
651,
338,
667
],
[
341,
651,
432,
667
],
[
435,
651,
452,
667
],
[
455,
651,
473,
667
],
[
476,
651,
510,
667
],
[
513,
651,
531,
667
],
[
534,
651,
642,
667
],
[
645,
651,
678,
667
],
[
681,
651,
772,
667
],
[
775,
651,
830,
667
],
[
832,
651,
861,
667
],
[
864,
651,
886,
667
],
[
117,
669,
142,
684
],
[
146,
669,
249,
684
],
[
253,
669,
324,
684
],
[
329,
669,
374,
684
],
[
377,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
425,
684
],
[
429,
669,
491,
684
],
[
495,
669,
579,
684
],
[
582,
669,
618,
684
],
[
623,
669,
652,
684
],
[
655,
668,
727,
684
],
[
730,
668,
776,
684
],
[
780,
668,
829,
684
],
[
835,
668,
854,
684
],
[
117,
686,
180,
702
],
[
182,
686,
228,
702
],
[
231,
686,
264,
702
],
[
267,
686,
358,
702
],
[
361,
686,
386,
702
],
[
389,
686,
469,
702
],
[
472,
686,
508,
702
],
[
511,
686,
548,
702
],
[
551,
686,
616,
702
],
[
619,
686,
715,
702
],
[
718,
686,
735,
702
],
[
738,
686,
783,
702
],
[
786,
686,
806,
702
],
[
117,
704,
201,
719
],
[
205,
704,
222,
719
],
[
225,
704,
252,
719
],
[
255,
704,
287,
719
],
[
291,
704,
315,
719
],
[
318,
704,
359,
720
],
[
362,
704,
428,
720
],
[
431,
704,
460,
720
],
[
462,
704,
554,
720
],
[
557,
703,
574,
720
],
[
578,
703,
614,
720
],
[
618,
703,
647,
720
],
[
651,
703,
664,
720
],
[
668,
703,
724,
720
],
[
728,
703,
745,
720
],
[
749,
703,
768,
720
],
[
772,
703,
792,
719
],
[
796,
703,
806,
719
],
[
810,
703,
875,
719
],
[
117,
721,
151,
736
],
[
155,
721,
208,
736
],
[
211,
721,
241,
736
],
[
245,
722,
290,
737
],
[
294,
722,
311,
737
],
[
315,
722,
344,
737
],
[
348,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
459,
737
],
[
462,
722,
481,
737
],
[
485,
722,
518,
737
],
[
521,
722,
563,
737
],
[
566,
722,
598,
737
],
[
601,
721,
692,
736
],
[
695,
721,
741,
736
],
[
744,
721,
765,
736
],
[
768,
721,
852,
736
],
[
855,
721,
875,
735
],
[
120,
739,
151,
754
],
[
154,
739,
203,
754
],
[
207,
739,
217,
754
],
[
220,
739,
257,
754
],
[
261,
739,
310,
754
],
[
314,
739,
350,
754
],
[
354,
740,
385,
754
],
[
118,
774,
134,
789
],
[
138,
774,
164,
789
],
[
168,
774,
202,
789
],
[
206,
774,
223,
789
],
[
227,
775,
414,
789
],
[
418,
775,
449,
789
],
[
452,
775,
549,
789
],
[
552,
775,
561,
789
],
[
565,
775,
671,
789
],
[
674,
775,
710,
789
],
[
714,
774,
774,
789
],
[
778,
774,
814,
789
],
[
818,
774,
874,
789
],
[
118,
790,
201,
805
],
[
205,
791,
222,
805
],
[
225,
791,
252,
805
],
[
255,
791,
267,
805
],
[
270,
791,
288,
805
],
[
292,
791,
333,
805
],
[
337,
791,
390,
805
],
[
394,
791,
406,
805
],
[
410,
791,
446,
805
],
[
450,
791,
477,
805
],
[
481,
791,
507,
805
],
[
510,
791,
582,
805
],
[
586,
790,
622,
805
],
[
626,
790,
651,
805
],
[
654,
790,
681,
805
],
[
684,
790,
701,
805
],
[
705,
790,
758,
805
],
[
762,
790,
807,
805
],
[
810,
790,
830,
805
],
[
117,
810,
187,
824
],
[
190,
810,
207,
824
],
[
211,
810,
298,
824
],
[
301,
810,
314,
824
],
[
320,
810,
426,
824
],
[
430,
810,
464,
824
],
[
468,
809,
534,
824
],
[
537,
809,
597,
824
],
[
601,
809,
632,
824
],
[
635,
809,
719,
824
],
[
722,
809,
740,
824
],
[
743,
808,
765,
824
],
[
768,
808,
841,
824
],
[
117,
827,
164,
840
],
[
167,
827,
192,
840
],
[
195,
827,
279,
841
],
[
282,
827,
301,
841
],
[
304,
827,
331,
841
],
[
334,
827,
347,
841
],
[
350,
827,
424,
841
],
[
427,
827,
454,
841
],
[
456,
827,
492,
841
],
[
495,
827,
523,
841
],
[
525,
827,
547,
841
],
[
550,
827,
606,
841
],
[
609,
827,
628,
841
],
[
630,
827,
668,
841
],
[
671,
826,
754,
841
],
[
758,
826,
775,
841
],
[
778,
826,
800,
841
],
[
802,
825,
877,
841
],
[
118,
843,
142,
859
],
[
144,
843,
180,
859
],
[
183,
843,
262,
859
],
[
265,
843,
287,
859
],
[
289,
843,
311,
859
],
[
314,
843,
420,
859
],
[
422,
843,
472,
859
],
[
475,
843,
498,
859
],
[
501,
843,
560,
859
],
[
563,
843,
601,
859
],
[
605,
843,
635,
859
],
[
638,
843,
696,
859
],
[
699,
843,
725,
859
],
[
728,
843,
774,
859
],
[
777,
843,
796,
858
],
[
799,
843,
808,
858
],
[
812,
843,
844,
858
],
[
118,
860,
199,
875
],
[
202,
860,
262,
876
],
[
266,
860,
296,
876
],
[
300,
860,
377,
876
],
[
381,
860,
402,
876
],
[
406,
860,
414,
876
],
[
418,
860,
530,
877
],
[
533,
860,
559,
877
],
[
562,
860,
619,
877
],
[
622,
860,
677,
877
],
[
680,
860,
707,
876
],
[
710,
860,
768,
876
],
[
772,
860,
804,
876
],
[
808,
860,
830,
876
],
[
833,
860,
844,
876
],
[
117,
893,
129,
908
],
[
132,
894,
157,
909
],
[
161,
895,
177,
909
],
[
180,
895,
208,
910
],
[
212,
895,
244,
910
],
[
247,
896,
261,
910
],
[
265,
895,
302,
910
],
[
820,
940,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
Which field does not use the "plausible maximum exposure" ?
|
environmental toxicology field
|
740
|
[
"Perhaps",
"for",
"simplification",
"purposes,",
"EPA",
"has",
"provided",
"a",
"succinct",
"definition.",
"However,",
"as",
"noted",
"above,",
"this",
"definition",
"does",
"not",
"appropriately",
"capture",
"how",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"approach",
"is",
"currently",
"used.",
"Relying",
"on",
"the",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"does",
"not",
"mean",
"that",
"the",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"is",
"used.",
"Reasonable",
"values",
"from",
"that",
"highest",
"exposure",
"scenario",
"should",
"be",
"used",
"instead.",
"A",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"should",
"not",
"use",
"a",
"\"maximal\"",
"exposure",
"value",
"as",
"these",
"values",
"are",
"typically",
"unstable.",
"More",
"appropriate",
"language",
"would",
"include",
"the",
"term",
"\"plausible",
"exposure\"",
"or",
"\"plausible",
"upper",
"bound",
"exposure.\"",
"In",
"the",
"environmental",
"toxicology",
"field,",
"it",
"is",
"common",
"to",
"use",
"the",
"95\"",
"percentile",
"under",
"average",
"exposure",
"conditions.",
"The",
"\"plausible",
"maximum",
"exposure\"",
"is",
"not",
"used.",
"Significant",
"revisions",
"are",
"needed",
"to",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"to",
"capture",
"the",
"appropriate",
"use",
"of",
"the",
"sentinel",
"exposure",
"concept.",
"E.",
"Uncertainty",
"EPA",
"provides",
"a",
"definition",
"for",
"uncertainty",
"and",
"cites",
"EPA's",
"2014",
"Human",
"Health",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Framework",
"as",
"the",
"source.",
"However,",
"as",
"written,",
"the",
"definition",
"EPA",
"provides",
"is",
"actually",
"not",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"source.",
"EPA's",
"definition",
"should",
"conforms",
"to",
"the",
"edits",
"below",
"to",
"ensure",
"the",
"definition",
"is",
"fully",
"consistent.",
"Uncertainty",
"means",
"the",
"imperfect",
"knowledge",
"or",
"lack",
"of",
"precise",
"knowledge",
"of",
"the",
"real",
"world,",
"either",
"for",
"specific",
"values",
"of",
"interest",
"or",
"in",
"the",
"description",
"of",
"a",
"the",
"system.",
"VIII.",
"The",
"Process",
"for",
"Manufacturer",
"Requested",
"Evaluations",
"A.",
"EPA-Initiated",
"and",
"Manufacturer-Requested",
"Evaluations",
"Should",
"Follow",
"the",
"Same",
"Review",
"Process.",
"LCSA",
"allows",
"chemical",
"manufacturers",
"to",
"request",
"EPA",
"to",
"conduct",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"at",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(C)(ii).",
"By",
"law,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"only",
"request",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"it",
"manufacturers",
"(not",
"of",
"a",
"competitor).",
"By",
"rule,",
"EPA",
"is",
"to",
"specify",
"the",
"\"form",
"and",
"manner\"",
"for",
"manufacturer",
"requests,",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"to",
"prescribe",
"the",
"criteria",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"In",
"our",
"view,",
"EPA",
"should",
"largely",
"follow",
"the",
"same",
"process",
"-",
"and",
"apply",
"the",
"same",
"criteria",
"-",
"to",
"manufacturer",
"requested",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"as",
"it",
"does",
"to",
"EPA-initiated",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"arising",
"out",
"of",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process.",
"There",
"is",
"one",
"notable",
"difference:",
"EPA",
"has",
"authority",
"under",
"LCSA",
"to",
"flexibly",
"scope",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"for",
"chemicals",
"with",
"high",
"priority",
"designations",
"to",
"focus",
"on",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"most",
"relevant",
"and",
"meaningful",
"to",
"risk,",
"and",
"it",
"should",
"do",
"so",
"on",
"a",
"case-by-",
"case",
"basis.",
"The",
"result",
"of",
"this",
"process",
"might",
"be",
"that",
"some",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"cover",
"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use;",
"others",
"a",
"few;",
"others",
"only",
"one.",
"In",
"the",
"case",
"of",
"manufacturer-requested",
"risk",
"evaluations,",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"support",
"only",
"certain",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"-",
"in",
"other",
"words,",
"it",
"may",
"sell",
"the",
"chemical",
"only",
"for",
"use",
"in",
"certain",
"kinds",
"of",
"products",
"or",
"processes.",
"A",
"manufacturer",
"may",
"strongly",
"support",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"under",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"it",
"supports,",
"but",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"willing",
"to",
"fund",
"evaluation",
"of",
"its",
"chemical",
"for",
"uses",
"supported",
"by",
"its",
"competitors.",
"While",
"we",
"believe",
"EPA",
"can",
"expand",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"beyond",
"that",
"requested",
"by",
"a",
"manufacturer,",
"the",
"agency",
"should",
"not",
"impose",
"fees",
"on",
"a",
"90",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7568.",
"37/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
93,
180,
110
],
[
184,
93,
208,
110
],
[
212,
93,
321,
110
],
[
324,
93,
402,
110
],
[
405,
93,
442,
109
],
[
445,
93,
474,
109
],
[
477,
93,
551,
109
],
[
554,
93,
564,
109
],
[
567,
93,
635,
109
],
[
638,
93,
718,
109
],
[
721,
93,
801,
109
],
[
804,
93,
822,
109
],
[
824,
93,
871,
109
],
[
118,
111,
170,
126
],
[
174,
111,
207,
126
],
[
210,
111,
287,
126
],
[
292,
111,
325,
126
],
[
328,
111,
356,
126
],
[
360,
111,
465,
126
],
[
469,
112,
527,
126
],
[
531,
112,
565,
126
],
[
570,
112,
596,
126
],
[
600,
112,
662,
126
],
[
666,
111,
738,
126
],
[
742,
111,
814,
126
],
[
818,
111,
829,
126
],
[
117,
128,
189,
143
],
[
193,
129,
235,
144
],
[
238,
129,
302,
144
],
[
307,
130,
327,
144
],
[
331,
130,
355,
144
],
[
358,
130,
417,
144
],
[
421,
130,
493,
144
],
[
497,
130,
566,
144
],
[
571,
129,
604,
144
],
[
607,
129,
634,
143
],
[
637,
129,
682,
143
],
[
685,
128,
716,
143
],
[
720,
128,
745,
143
],
[
748,
127,
837,
143
],
[
118,
146,
189,
161
],
[
192,
146,
207,
161
],
[
211,
146,
252,
160
],
[
257,
146,
350,
160
],
[
353,
146,
404,
160
],
[
408,
146,
442,
160
],
[
450,
146,
481,
160
],
[
484,
146,
543,
160
],
[
547,
146,
620,
160
],
[
623,
146,
690,
160
],
[
693,
145,
745,
160
],
[
749,
145,
770,
160
],
[
773,
145,
811,
161
],
[
814,
145,
878,
161
],
[
118,
163,
132,
179
],
[
135,
163,
167,
179
],
[
171,
163,
253,
179
],
[
257,
164,
310,
179
],
[
314,
164,
341,
179
],
[
344,
164,
372,
179
],
[
376,
164,
385,
179
],
[
389,
164,
477,
179
],
[
480,
164,
553,
179
],
[
557,
164,
601,
179
],
[
604,
164,
621,
179
],
[
624,
164,
667,
179
],
[
671,
164,
721,
179
],
[
725,
164,
750,
179
],
[
754,
164,
822,
179
],
[
118,
181,
189,
196
],
[
192,
181,
237,
196
],
[
240,
181,
330,
196
],
[
333,
181,
407,
196
],
[
410,
182,
460,
196
],
[
463,
181,
522,
196
],
[
526,
181,
552,
196
],
[
555,
181,
588,
196
],
[
595,
181,
678,
196
],
[
681,
181,
762,
196
],
[
765,
180,
782,
196
],
[
786,
180,
870,
196
],
[
119,
198,
162,
213
],
[
166,
198,
217,
214
],
[
221,
198,
310,
214
],
[
315,
198,
333,
214
],
[
337,
198,
362,
214
],
[
366,
198,
480,
214
],
[
483,
198,
570,
214
],
[
574,
197,
615,
213
],
[
618,
197,
631,
213
],
[
635,
197,
649,
213
],
[
652,
197,
723,
213
],
[
727,
197,
744,
213
],
[
747,
197,
774,
212
],
[
777,
197,
803,
212
],
[
807,
197,
835,
212
],
[
118,
216,
196,
231
],
[
200,
216,
247,
231
],
[
250,
216,
312,
231
],
[
315,
216,
387,
231
],
[
391,
216,
481,
232
],
[
485,
216,
514,
232
],
[
517,
215,
598,
232
],
[
601,
215,
680,
232
],
[
687,
215,
768,
232
],
[
771,
215,
785,
231
],
[
789,
215,
815,
231
],
[
819,
215,
862,
231
],
[
118,
233,
205,
247
],
[
208,
233,
281,
248
],
[
284,
233,
308,
248
],
[
312,
234,
370,
248
],
[
372,
234,
390,
248
],
[
394,
234,
449,
248
],
[
452,
234,
528,
249
],
[
531,
234,
548,
249
],
[
551,
234,
611,
249
],
[
614,
234,
640,
249
],
[
644,
233,
734,
248
],
[
737,
233,
765,
248
],
[
768,
233,
786,
248
],
[
790,
233,
815,
248
],
[
819,
233,
881,
248
],
[
118,
251,
190,
266
],
[
193,
251,
260,
265
],
[
177,
283,
199,
299
],
[
237,
285,
335,
300
],
[
118,
320,
155,
336
],
[
158,
320,
229,
336
],
[
232,
320,
245,
336
],
[
248,
320,
323,
336
],
[
327,
320,
351,
336
],
[
354,
320,
445,
336
],
[
448,
320,
478,
336
],
[
481,
320,
519,
335
],
[
522,
320,
575,
335
],
[
579,
320,
619,
335
],
[
622,
320,
682,
335
],
[
685,
320,
738,
335
],
[
742,
320,
781,
335
],
[
784,
320,
882,
335
],
[
117,
338,
210,
352
],
[
213,
338,
231,
352
],
[
234,
338,
260,
352
],
[
262,
338,
326,
352
],
[
338,
338,
416,
353
],
[
420,
338,
438,
353
],
[
441,
338,
502,
353
],
[
506,
338,
532,
353
],
[
538,
338,
612,
353
],
[
617,
338,
652,
352
],
[
658,
338,
728,
352
],
[
731,
338,
746,
352
],
[
749,
338,
812,
352
],
[
815,
338,
840,
352
],
[
117,
355,
198,
370
],
[
201,
355,
237,
370
],
[
240,
355,
266,
370
],
[
270,
355,
327,
370
],
[
330,
355,
386,
370
],
[
390,
355,
465,
370
],
[
468,
355,
522,
370
],
[
525,
355,
601,
370
],
[
604,
355,
621,
370
],
[
624,
355,
650,
370
],
[
653,
355,
691,
370
],
[
694,
355,
742,
370
],
[
748,
355,
765,
369
],
[
768,
355,
821,
369
],
[
824,
355,
850,
369
],
[
121,
371,
195,
388
],
[
198,
371,
214,
387
],
[
217,
371,
255,
387
],
[
258,
372,
347,
389
],
[
177,
407,
272,
421
],
[
274,
408,
325,
421
],
[
328,
408,
355,
421
],
[
358,
408,
435,
422
],
[
438,
408,
528,
422
],
[
531,
408,
548,
422
],
[
551,
408,
586,
422
],
[
589,
408,
607,
422
],
[
610,
407,
666,
422
],
[
670,
407,
758,
422
],
[
761,
407,
780,
423
],
[
783,
407,
808,
423
],
[
812,
407,
844,
423
],
[
178,
424,
228,
440
],
[
231,
424,
277,
440
],
[
281,
424,
305,
440
],
[
309,
424,
371,
440
],
[
375,
424,
427,
440
],
[
431,
425,
448,
440
],
[
451,
425,
511,
440
],
[
515,
425,
532,
440
],
[
536,
425,
551,
440
],
[
555,
425,
585,
440
],
[
588,
425,
673,
440
],
[
677,
425,
694,
440
],
[
698,
425,
708,
440
],
[
711,
425,
738,
441
],
[
742,
425,
802,
441
],
[
121,
458,
170,
474
],
[
192,
459,
225,
475
],
[
228,
459,
292,
475
],
[
296,
459,
322,
475
],
[
325,
460,
446,
475
],
[
450,
460,
540,
475
],
[
543,
460,
642,
475
],
[
176,
491,
197,
510
],
[
235,
493,
354,
510
],
[
358,
494,
390,
510
],
[
394,
495,
609,
510
],
[
612,
495,
714,
510
],
[
717,
494,
777,
510
],
[
781,
493,
837,
509
],
[
842,
493,
868,
509
],
[
236,
512,
282,
526
],
[
285,
512,
345,
527
],
[
352,
513,
422,
528
],
[
117,
546,
168,
562
],
[
172,
546,
225,
562
],
[
228,
547,
300,
562
],
[
303,
548,
417,
562
],
[
421,
548,
437,
562
],
[
440,
548,
500,
562
],
[
504,
548,
541,
562
],
[
544,
548,
562,
562
],
[
565,
548,
629,
562
],
[
632,
548,
642,
562
],
[
645,
548,
677,
562
],
[
680,
547,
764,
562
],
[
767,
547,
783,
562
],
[
787,
546,
848,
561
],
[
117,
564,
235,
580
],
[
238,
565,
261,
579
],
[
265,
565,
300,
579
],
[
304,
565,
312,
579
],
[
315,
565,
422,
579
],
[
425,
565,
461,
579
],
[
465,
565,
500,
579
],
[
504,
565,
563,
579
],
[
567,
565,
575,
579
],
[
578,
565,
611,
579
],
[
615,
565,
697,
579
],
[
701,
565,
719,
579
],
[
722,
565,
732,
579
],
[
735,
564,
807,
579
],
[
811,
564,
824,
579
],
[
117,
582,
231,
597
],
[
235,
582,
268,
597
],
[
271,
582,
290,
597
],
[
293,
582,
303,
597
],
[
306,
581,
408,
597
],
[
411,
581,
436,
597
],
[
440,
581,
477,
597
],
[
481,
581,
517,
597
],
[
522,
581,
537,
597
],
[
541,
581,
558,
597
],
[
561,
581,
618,
597
],
[
622,
581,
648,
597
],
[
651,
581,
695,
597
],
[
703,
581,
732,
597
],
[
735,
581,
805,
597
],
[
808,
581,
835,
597
],
[
117,
600,
224,
615
],
[
227,
600,
298,
615
],
[
301,
600,
320,
615
],
[
323,
600,
358,
615
],
[
361,
600,
379,
615
],
[
382,
600,
399,
615
],
[
402,
600,
476,
615
],
[
479,
600,
505,
615
],
[
508,
600,
567,
615
],
[
570,
600,
594,
615
],
[
597,
600,
622,
615
],
[
625,
600,
656,
615
],
[
660,
600,
751,
615
],
[
117,
633,
134,
649
],
[
137,
633,
166,
649
],
[
170,
633,
213,
649
],
[
217,
633,
256,
649
],
[
260,
633,
313,
649
],
[
317,
634,
372,
649
],
[
376,
634,
428,
650
],
[
431,
634,
457,
650
],
[
461,
634,
503,
650
],
[
507,
634,
567,
650
],
[
570,
634,
582,
650
],
[
585,
634,
615,
650
],
[
619,
634,
662,
650
],
[
666,
634,
693,
650
],
[
697,
634,
737,
650
],
[
741,
634,
798,
650
],
[
802,
634,
812,
650
],
[
815,
634,
834,
650
],
[
117,
652,
224,
667
],
[
227,
651,
304,
667
],
[
307,
651,
338,
667
],
[
341,
651,
432,
667
],
[
435,
651,
452,
667
],
[
455,
651,
473,
667
],
[
476,
651,
510,
667
],
[
513,
651,
531,
667
],
[
534,
651,
642,
667
],
[
645,
651,
678,
667
],
[
681,
651,
772,
667
],
[
775,
651,
830,
667
],
[
832,
651,
861,
667
],
[
864,
651,
886,
667
],
[
117,
669,
142,
684
],
[
146,
669,
249,
684
],
[
253,
669,
324,
684
],
[
329,
669,
374,
684
],
[
377,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
425,
684
],
[
429,
669,
491,
684
],
[
495,
669,
579,
684
],
[
582,
669,
618,
684
],
[
623,
669,
652,
684
],
[
655,
668,
727,
684
],
[
730,
668,
776,
684
],
[
780,
668,
829,
684
],
[
835,
668,
854,
684
],
[
117,
686,
180,
702
],
[
182,
686,
228,
702
],
[
231,
686,
264,
702
],
[
267,
686,
358,
702
],
[
361,
686,
386,
702
],
[
389,
686,
469,
702
],
[
472,
686,
508,
702
],
[
511,
686,
548,
702
],
[
551,
686,
616,
702
],
[
619,
686,
715,
702
],
[
718,
686,
735,
702
],
[
738,
686,
783,
702
],
[
786,
686,
806,
702
],
[
117,
704,
201,
719
],
[
205,
704,
222,
719
],
[
225,
704,
252,
719
],
[
255,
704,
287,
719
],
[
291,
704,
315,
719
],
[
318,
704,
359,
720
],
[
362,
704,
428,
720
],
[
431,
704,
460,
720
],
[
462,
704,
554,
720
],
[
557,
703,
574,
720
],
[
578,
703,
614,
720
],
[
618,
703,
647,
720
],
[
651,
703,
664,
720
],
[
668,
703,
724,
720
],
[
728,
703,
745,
720
],
[
749,
703,
768,
720
],
[
772,
703,
792,
719
],
[
796,
703,
806,
719
],
[
810,
703,
875,
719
],
[
117,
721,
151,
736
],
[
155,
721,
208,
736
],
[
211,
721,
241,
736
],
[
245,
722,
290,
737
],
[
294,
722,
311,
737
],
[
315,
722,
344,
737
],
[
348,
722,
408,
737
],
[
411,
722,
459,
737
],
[
462,
722,
481,
737
],
[
485,
722,
518,
737
],
[
521,
722,
563,
737
],
[
566,
722,
598,
737
],
[
601,
721,
692,
736
],
[
695,
721,
741,
736
],
[
744,
721,
765,
736
],
[
768,
721,
852,
736
],
[
855,
721,
875,
735
],
[
120,
739,
151,
754
],
[
154,
739,
203,
754
],
[
207,
739,
217,
754
],
[
220,
739,
257,
754
],
[
261,
739,
310,
754
],
[
314,
739,
350,
754
],
[
354,
740,
385,
754
],
[
118,
774,
134,
789
],
[
138,
774,
164,
789
],
[
168,
774,
202,
789
],
[
206,
774,
223,
789
],
[
227,
775,
414,
789
],
[
418,
775,
449,
789
],
[
452,
775,
549,
789
],
[
552,
775,
561,
789
],
[
565,
775,
671,
789
],
[
674,
775,
710,
789
],
[
714,
774,
774,
789
],
[
778,
774,
814,
789
],
[
818,
774,
874,
789
],
[
118,
790,
201,
805
],
[
205,
791,
222,
805
],
[
225,
791,
252,
805
],
[
255,
791,
267,
805
],
[
270,
791,
288,
805
],
[
292,
791,
333,
805
],
[
337,
791,
390,
805
],
[
394,
791,
406,
805
],
[
410,
791,
446,
805
],
[
450,
791,
477,
805
],
[
481,
791,
507,
805
],
[
510,
791,
582,
805
],
[
586,
790,
622,
805
],
[
626,
790,
651,
805
],
[
654,
790,
681,
805
],
[
684,
790,
701,
805
],
[
705,
790,
758,
805
],
[
762,
790,
807,
805
],
[
810,
790,
830,
805
],
[
117,
810,
187,
824
],
[
190,
810,
207,
824
],
[
211,
810,
298,
824
],
[
301,
810,
314,
824
],
[
320,
810,
426,
824
],
[
430,
810,
464,
824
],
[
468,
809,
534,
824
],
[
537,
809,
597,
824
],
[
601,
809,
632,
824
],
[
635,
809,
719,
824
],
[
722,
809,
740,
824
],
[
743,
808,
765,
824
],
[
768,
808,
841,
824
],
[
117,
827,
164,
840
],
[
167,
827,
192,
840
],
[
195,
827,
279,
841
],
[
282,
827,
301,
841
],
[
304,
827,
331,
841
],
[
334,
827,
347,
841
],
[
350,
827,
424,
841
],
[
427,
827,
454,
841
],
[
456,
827,
492,
841
],
[
495,
827,
523,
841
],
[
525,
827,
547,
841
],
[
550,
827,
606,
841
],
[
609,
827,
628,
841
],
[
630,
827,
668,
841
],
[
671,
826,
754,
841
],
[
758,
826,
775,
841
],
[
778,
826,
800,
841
],
[
802,
825,
877,
841
],
[
118,
843,
142,
859
],
[
144,
843,
180,
859
],
[
183,
843,
262,
859
],
[
265,
843,
287,
859
],
[
289,
843,
311,
859
],
[
314,
843,
420,
859
],
[
422,
843,
472,
859
],
[
475,
843,
498,
859
],
[
501,
843,
560,
859
],
[
563,
843,
601,
859
],
[
605,
843,
635,
859
],
[
638,
843,
696,
859
],
[
699,
843,
725,
859
],
[
728,
843,
774,
859
],
[
777,
843,
796,
858
],
[
799,
843,
808,
858
],
[
812,
843,
844,
858
],
[
118,
860,
199,
875
],
[
202,
860,
262,
876
],
[
266,
860,
296,
876
],
[
300,
860,
377,
876
],
[
381,
860,
402,
876
],
[
406,
860,
414,
876
],
[
418,
860,
530,
877
],
[
533,
860,
559,
877
],
[
562,
860,
619,
877
],
[
622,
860,
677,
877
],
[
680,
860,
707,
876
],
[
710,
860,
768,
876
],
[
772,
860,
804,
876
],
[
808,
860,
830,
876
],
[
833,
860,
844,
876
],
[
117,
893,
129,
908
],
[
132,
894,
157,
909
],
[
161,
895,
177,
909
],
[
180,
895,
208,
910
],
[
212,
895,
244,
910
],
[
247,
896,
261,
910
],
[
265,
895,
302,
910
],
[
820,
940,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
292,
980,
781,
997
]
] |
What does EPA cites as the source?
|
cites EPA's 2014 Human Health Risk Assessment Framework as the source.
|
743
|
[
"make",
"little",
"sense",
"to",
"continue",
"evaluating",
"that",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"Otherwise,",
"EPA's",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"would",
"be",
"of",
"suspect",
"quality,",
"integrity,",
"and",
"reliability.",
"A",
"better",
"approach",
"would",
"be",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"that",
"after",
"a",
"scope",
"is",
"published,",
"EPA",
"retains",
"discretion",
"to",
"modify",
"it",
"upon",
"a",
"showing",
"of",
"substantial",
"need",
"or",
"changed",
"circumstances,",
"or",
"is",
"otherwise",
"warranted",
"because",
"the",
"addition",
"or",
"removal",
"of",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"properly",
"substantiated,",
"will",
"significantly",
"affect",
"the",
"conduct",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"J.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Remove",
"the",
"Comment-or-Waive",
"(Issue",
"Exhaustion)",
"Proposal.",
"EPA",
"further",
"proposes",
"that",
"it",
"can",
"keep",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"schedule,",
"notwithstanding",
"its",
"proposal",
"to",
"include",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"every",
"scope,",
"by",
"\"providing",
"opportunity",
"for",
"comment",
"on",
"the",
"scoping",
"document",
"and",
"specifying",
"that",
"any",
"objections",
"to",
"the",
"draft",
"scope",
"document",
"are",
"waived",
"if",
"not",
"raised",
"during",
"this",
"process.\"",
"We",
"urge",
"the",
"Agency",
"to",
"remove",
"this",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"(waiver)",
"requirement",
"for",
"several",
"reasons.",
"First,",
"it",
"places",
"an",
"unfair",
"burden",
"on",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"A",
"particular",
"company",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"aware,",
"or",
"otherwise",
"in",
"a",
"position",
"to",
"verify,",
"particular",
"end",
"uses",
"that",
"the",
"company",
"does",
"not",
"support",
"(i.e.,",
"a",
"downstream",
"value",
"chain",
"to",
"which",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"sell).",
"A",
"company",
"likewise",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"verify",
"occurrences",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"from",
"natural",
"sources",
"or",
"the",
"actions",
"of",
"third",
"parties",
"through",
"combustion,",
"spills",
"and",
"discharges,",
"disposal,",
"manufacturing",
"practices",
"or",
"incidents,",
"and",
"the",
"like.",
"When",
"EPA",
"insists",
"on",
"including",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"it",
"moves",
"well",
"past",
"the",
"\"major\"",
"uses",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"and",
"\"major\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"to",
"include",
"fleeting,",
"incidental,",
"minor,",
"isolated,",
"or",
"exceptional",
"cases.",
"Information",
"about",
"these",
"\"minor\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"may",
"be",
"well",
"outside",
"the",
"first-hand",
"knowledge",
"of",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor,",
"making",
"it",
"difficult",
"or",
"impossible",
"to",
"offer",
"meaningful",
"comment",
"during",
"the",
"scoping",
"period.",
"Second,",
"participation",
"in",
"notice",
"and",
"comment",
"rulemaking",
"is",
"governed",
"by",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act",
"(APA)",
"and",
"the",
"judicial",
"review",
"provisions",
"of",
"Section",
"19",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"Issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"can",
"be",
"imposed",
"by",
"statute.",
"Notably,",
"there",
"are",
"only",
"a",
"few",
"statutory",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"provisions",
"in",
"environmental",
"statutes,",
"the",
"most",
"notable",
"of",
"which",
"is",
"in",
"Section",
"307(d)(7)(b)",
"of",
"the",
"Clean",
"Air",
"Act.",
"There",
"are",
"none",
"in",
"TSCA.",
"Congress",
"had",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"for",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"in",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"-",
"and",
"declined",
"to",
"do",
"so.",
"EPA",
"cannot,",
"by",
"regulation,",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"that",
"trumps",
"the",
"statutory",
"rights",
"and",
"obligations",
"of",
"stakeholders",
"under",
"the",
"APA",
"and",
"TSCA",
"Section",
"19.",
"Indeed,",
"ACC",
"believes",
"a",
"waiver",
"provision",
"such",
"as",
"that",
"proposed",
"by",
"EPA",
"may",
"not",
"meet",
"Constitutional",
"muster.",
"Third,",
"the",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"rationally",
"advance",
"its",
"claimed",
"purpose",
"-",
"to",
"meet",
"statutory",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"deadlines.",
"An",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"is",
"supposed",
"to",
"serve",
"two",
"purposes:",
"it",
"19",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7566.",
"Administrative",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"are",
"largely",
"creatures",
"of",
"statute,",
"and",
"here",
"we",
"have",
"no",
"such",
"statutory",
"construct.",
"While",
"some",
"agency",
"regulations",
"set",
"out",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"without",
"a",
"statutory",
"mandate,",
"these",
"tend",
"to",
"be",
"in",
"administrative",
"appeal",
"situations",
"or",
"proceedings",
"that",
"are",
"analogs",
"to",
"adversarial",
"litigation.",
"Notably,",
"the",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"removed",
"a",
"procedure",
"for",
"formal",
"TSCA",
"hearings.",
"11/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
161,
109
],
[
164,
94,
202,
109
],
[
205,
94,
250,
109
],
[
253,
94,
270,
110
],
[
273,
93,
343,
110
],
[
346,
93,
429,
110
],
[
432,
93,
462,
110
],
[
466,
93,
542,
110
],
[
545,
93,
564,
110
],
[
567,
93,
595,
110
],
[
598,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
643,
110
],
[
647,
93,
678,
110
],
[
681,
93,
775,
110
],
[
778,
93,
865,
110
],
[
120,
110,
170,
126
],
[
174,
110,
211,
126
],
[
214,
110,
245,
126
],
[
250,
111,
332,
127
],
[
336,
111,
386,
127
],
[
390,
111,
409,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
434,
111,
492,
127
],
[
497,
111,
557,
127
],
[
561,
111,
634,
128
],
[
638,
111,
667,
128
],
[
670,
111,
756,
128
],
[
119,
146,
132,
161
],
[
136,
146,
182,
161
],
[
185,
146,
260,
161
],
[
264,
146,
312,
161
],
[
316,
146,
337,
161
],
[
341,
146,
364,
161
],
[
368,
146,
405,
161
],
[
410,
146,
427,
161
],
[
430,
145,
504,
161
],
[
507,
145,
525,
161
],
[
528,
145,
554,
161
],
[
557,
145,
589,
161
],
[
592,
145,
624,
161
],
[
627,
145,
664,
161
],
[
667,
145,
678,
161
],
[
680,
145,
727,
161
],
[
730,
145,
745,
161
],
[
748,
145,
831,
161
],
[
834,
145,
873,
161
],
[
117,
164,
173,
178
],
[
176,
164,
253,
179
],
[
256,
164,
273,
179
],
[
276,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
164,
395,
179
],
[
398,
164,
408,
179
],
[
412,
164,
480,
179
],
[
484,
164,
501,
179
],
[
504,
164,
590,
179
],
[
593,
164,
632,
179
],
[
635,
164,
654,
179
],
[
658,
164,
724,
179
],
[
728,
163,
844,
179
],
[
847,
163,
865,
178
],
[
868,
163,
885,
178
],
[
117,
181,
196,
196
],
[
199,
181,
279,
196
],
[
282,
182,
345,
196
],
[
348,
182,
375,
196
],
[
378,
182,
443,
196
],
[
446,
182,
464,
196
],
[
467,
182,
535,
196
],
[
538,
182,
556,
196
],
[
559,
182,
570,
196
],
[
572,
182,
648,
196
],
[
650,
182,
670,
196
],
[
672,
181,
704,
196
],
[
707,
181,
777,
197
],
[
118,
198,
226,
214
],
[
230,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
198,
365,
214
],
[
368,
198,
412,
213
],
[
417,
198,
442,
213
],
[
445,
198,
510,
213
],
[
514,
198,
531,
213
],
[
535,
198,
559,
213
],
[
562,
198,
595,
213
],
[
599,
198,
683,
213
],
[
177,
243,
196,
260
],
[
236,
246,
272,
260
],
[
278,
246,
325,
260
],
[
328,
246,
397,
260
],
[
400,
246,
429,
260
],
[
431,
246,
601,
261
],
[
604,
246,
656,
261
],
[
659,
246,
762,
261
],
[
765,
246,
846,
261
],
[
118,
280,
154,
295
],
[
159,
280,
213,
296
],
[
217,
280,
287,
296
],
[
291,
280,
322,
296
],
[
326,
280,
340,
296
],
[
343,
280,
370,
296
],
[
373,
280,
411,
296
],
[
415,
280,
447,
296
],
[
450,
280,
542,
296
],
[
545,
280,
567,
296
],
[
570,
280,
644,
296
],
[
647,
280,
775,
296
],
[
778,
280,
798,
296
],
[
801,
280,
872,
296
],
[
117,
296,
134,
312
],
[
137,
297,
195,
313
],
[
200,
297,
231,
313
],
[
234,
297,
317,
314
],
[
320,
298,
337,
314
],
[
341,
298,
377,
314
],
[
381,
298,
398,
314
],
[
401,
298,
447,
314
],
[
451,
298,
501,
314
],
[
504,
298,
524,
314
],
[
528,
298,
616,
314
],
[
619,
298,
712,
314
],
[
716,
298,
741,
314
],
[
744,
297,
818,
313
],
[
821,
297,
843,
313
],
[
846,
297,
872,
312
],
[
118,
315,
182,
331
],
[
187,
315,
262,
331
],
[
265,
315,
295,
331
],
[
298,
315,
381,
331
],
[
384,
315,
417,
331
],
[
420,
315,
450,
331
],
[
452,
315,
535,
331
],
[
538,
315,
555,
331
],
[
558,
315,
587,
331
],
[
590,
315,
627,
331
],
[
629,
315,
680,
331
],
[
682,
315,
759,
331
],
[
761,
315,
788,
331
],
[
790,
315,
849,
331
],
[
850,
315,
867,
330
],
[
117,
332,
143,
348
],
[
146,
332,
200,
348
],
[
202,
332,
252,
348
],
[
255,
332,
284,
348
],
[
287,
332,
365,
348
],
[
385,
332,
412,
348
],
[
416,
332,
452,
348
],
[
455,
332,
483,
348
],
[
487,
332,
547,
348
],
[
551,
332,
567,
348
],
[
570,
332,
631,
348
],
[
634,
332,
664,
348
],
[
668,
332,
710,
348
],
[
712,
332,
799,
348
],
[
802,
333,
870,
348
],
[
117,
351,
213,
366
],
[
217,
351,
242,
365
],
[
245,
351,
301,
365
],
[
304,
351,
366,
366
],
[
117,
385,
159,
400
],
[
162,
385,
174,
400
],
[
178,
385,
230,
400
],
[
233,
385,
252,
400
],
[
255,
385,
304,
400
],
[
307,
385,
364,
400
],
[
368,
385,
388,
400
],
[
391,
385,
417,
400
],
[
420,
385,
495,
401
],
[
498,
385,
601,
401
],
[
604,
385,
618,
401
],
[
621,
385,
700,
401
],
[
702,
386,
777,
400
],
[
779,
386,
814,
400
],
[
817,
386,
844,
400
],
[
847,
386,
871,
400
],
[
118,
404,
171,
417
],
[
174,
404,
192,
417
],
[
195,
404,
272,
417
],
[
275,
404,
294,
417
],
[
296,
404,
307,
417
],
[
310,
404,
375,
417
],
[
378,
404,
396,
417
],
[
400,
404,
451,
417
],
[
454,
404,
533,
417
],
[
536,
404,
566,
417
],
[
569,
404,
604,
417
],
[
607,
404,
639,
417
],
[
642,
404,
668,
417
],
[
671,
403,
745,
417
],
[
750,
403,
785,
417
],
[
788,
403,
816,
417
],
[
818,
403,
882,
417
],
[
118,
420,
154,
435
],
[
158,
420,
170,
435
],
[
175,
420,
264,
435
],
[
272,
420,
317,
435
],
[
320,
420,
362,
435
],
[
366,
420,
384,
435
],
[
387,
420,
437,
435
],
[
440,
420,
457,
435
],
[
460,
420,
492,
435
],
[
496,
420,
524,
435
],
[
527,
420,
574,
435
],
[
577,
420,
590,
435
],
[
594,
420,
668,
435
],
[
671,
420,
739,
435
],
[
741,
420,
777,
435
],
[
780,
420,
807,
435
],
[
810,
420,
831,
435
],
[
834,
420,
871,
435
],
[
118,
438,
135,
453
],
[
138,
438,
186,
453
],
[
190,
438,
284,
453
],
[
287,
438,
305,
453
],
[
309,
438,
319,
453
],
[
323,
438,
395,
453
],
[
398,
438,
434,
453
],
[
441,
438,
497,
453
],
[
501,
438,
561,
453
],
[
565,
438,
581,
453
],
[
585,
438,
611,
453
],
[
614,
438,
672,
453
],
[
676,
438,
692,
453
],
[
697,
438,
735,
453
],
[
738,
437,
791,
453
],
[
795,
437,
858,
453
],
[
118,
455,
216,
470
],
[
219,
456,
262,
470
],
[
265,
456,
298,
470
],
[
302,
456,
390,
471
],
[
392,
456,
461,
471
],
[
464,
456,
581,
471
],
[
584,
456,
657,
471
],
[
660,
456,
677,
470
],
[
680,
455,
759,
470
],
[
762,
455,
791,
470
],
[
794,
455,
820,
470
],
[
823,
455,
855,
470
],
[
118,
472,
166,
487
],
[
169,
472,
207,
487
],
[
210,
472,
262,
487
],
[
265,
472,
287,
487
],
[
290,
472,
365,
488
],
[
368,
472,
399,
488
],
[
402,
472,
485,
488
],
[
488,
472,
507,
488
],
[
510,
472,
545,
488
],
[
549,
472,
567,
488
],
[
571,
472,
595,
488
],
[
599,
472,
645,
488
],
[
649,
472,
666,
488
],
[
670,
472,
679,
488
],
[
682,
472,
715,
488
],
[
718,
472,
805,
488
],
[
808,
472,
822,
488
],
[
825,
472,
881,
487
],
[
118,
490,
152,
506
],
[
155,
489,
189,
506
],
[
193,
489,
217,
506
],
[
220,
489,
285,
506
],
[
290,
489,
324,
506
],
[
328,
489,
346,
506
],
[
350,
489,
358,
506
],
[
362,
489,
436,
506
],
[
440,
489,
468,
506
],
[
471,
489,
537,
506
],
[
541,
489,
600,
506
],
[
604,
489,
622,
506
],
[
626,
490,
697,
506
],
[
701,
490,
717,
506
],
[
721,
490,
781,
506
],
[
785,
490,
850,
506
],
[
118,
507,
201,
522
],
[
204,
507,
257,
522
],
[
261,
507,
328,
522
],
[
332,
508,
350,
523
],
[
353,
508,
445,
523
],
[
449,
508,
501,
523
],
[
504,
507,
601,
523
],
[
604,
507,
649,
523
],
[
652,
507,
693,
523
],
[
697,
507,
764,
523
],
[
767,
507,
827,
522
],
[
830,
506,
852,
522
],
[
118,
525,
188,
540
],
[
192,
525,
228,
540
],
[
231,
525,
252,
540
],
[
255,
525,
291,
540
],
[
294,
524,
352,
540
],
[
355,
524,
381,
540
],
[
384,
524,
461,
540
],
[
465,
524,
554,
540
],
[
557,
524,
575,
540
],
[
578,
524,
588,
540
],
[
591,
524,
698,
540
],
[
701,
525,
718,
540
],
[
722,
525,
804,
541
],
[
807,
525,
867,
541
],
[
870,
525,
885,
541
],
[
120,
542,
182,
557
],
[
186,
542,
202,
557
],
[
206,
542,
292,
557
],
[
296,
542,
314,
557
],
[
317,
542,
355,
557
],
[
359,
542,
451,
557
],
[
454,
542,
532,
558
],
[
535,
542,
585,
558
],
[
588,
542,
614,
558
],
[
617,
542,
679,
558
],
[
682,
542,
739,
558
],
[
119,
576,
180,
592
],
[
184,
576,
284,
592
],
[
288,
577,
305,
592
],
[
309,
577,
358,
592
],
[
362,
577,
391,
593
],
[
395,
577,
469,
593
],
[
472,
577,
562,
592
],
[
567,
577,
582,
592
],
[
586,
577,
659,
592
],
[
662,
576,
684,
592
],
[
688,
576,
714,
592
],
[
718,
576,
834,
592
],
[
119,
593,
199,
610
],
[
202,
594,
230,
610
],
[
234,
594,
289,
610
],
[
293,
594,
321,
610
],
[
324,
594,
350,
610
],
[
353,
594,
414,
610
],
[
418,
594,
471,
610
],
[
475,
594,
559,
610
],
[
563,
594,
581,
610
],
[
585,
594,
645,
610
],
[
650,
594,
669,
609
],
[
672,
594,
692,
609
],
[
696,
593,
755,
609
],
[
759,
593,
799,
609
],
[
117,
613,
203,
626
],
[
207,
613,
312,
627
],
[
314,
613,
342,
627
],
[
346,
613,
367,
627
],
[
369,
612,
438,
627
],
[
441,
612,
462,
627
],
[
467,
612,
529,
627
],
[
532,
612,
603,
627
],
[
606,
612,
647,
627
],
[
650,
612,
675,
627
],
[
679,
612,
715,
627
],
[
718,
612,
728,
627
],
[
732,
612,
758,
627
],
[
767,
612,
836,
627
],
[
839,
612,
880,
627
],
[
117,
629,
204,
643
],
[
207,
630,
290,
643
],
[
294,
630,
310,
643
],
[
313,
630,
430,
644
],
[
432,
630,
497,
644
],
[
500,
630,
527,
644
],
[
530,
630,
570,
644
],
[
573,
630,
632,
644
],
[
636,
630,
654,
644
],
[
657,
629,
706,
644
],
[
710,
629,
724,
644
],
[
727,
629,
745,
644
],
[
750,
629,
809,
644
],
[
117,
645,
217,
662
],
[
220,
646,
237,
661
],
[
240,
646,
267,
661
],
[
271,
646,
318,
661
],
[
322,
646,
350,
661
],
[
354,
646,
394,
661
],
[
398,
646,
442,
661
],
[
446,
646,
471,
661
],
[
475,
646,
514,
661
],
[
518,
646,
537,
661
],
[
540,
646,
595,
661
],
[
118,
681,
191,
697
],
[
194,
682,
224,
696
],
[
228,
682,
254,
696
],
[
258,
682,
350,
696
],
[
353,
682,
370,
696
],
[
374,
682,
432,
696
],
[
436,
682,
454,
696
],
[
458,
682,
501,
696
],
[
504,
682,
590,
696
],
[
593,
682,
690,
696
],
[
692,
682,
718,
696
],
[
721,
682,
747,
696
],
[
750,
681,
795,
696
],
[
798,
681,
817,
696
],
[
820,
681,
830,
696
],
[
833,
681,
864,
696
],
[
120,
698,
199,
714
],
[
203,
698,
220,
714
],
[
224,
698,
275,
714
],
[
278,
698,
372,
714
],
[
375,
698,
387,
714
],
[
390,
698,
424,
714
],
[
427,
698,
491,
714
],
[
495,
698,
514,
714
],
[
519,
698,
537,
714
],
[
540,
698,
568,
714
],
[
572,
698,
610,
714
],
[
614,
698,
672,
714
],
[
675,
699,
696,
714
],
[
700,
699,
786,
714
],
[
790,
699,
849,
715
],
[
852,
699,
872,
715
],
[
117,
716,
158,
731
],
[
162,
716,
247,
731
],
[
251,
717,
347,
732
],
[
351,
717,
382,
732
],
[
386,
717,
441,
732
],
[
445,
717,
470,
732
],
[
474,
717,
544,
732
],
[
547,
717,
594,
732
],
[
598,
716,
627,
732
],
[
630,
716,
720,
732
],
[
722,
716,
741,
731
],
[
744,
715,
845,
731
],
[
117,
734,
164,
748
],
[
167,
734,
194,
748
],
[
196,
733,
234,
749
],
[
240,
733,
271,
749
],
[
275,
733,
323,
749
],
[
329,
733,
390,
749
],
[
394,
733,
425,
749
],
[
439,
733,
501,
749
],
[
504,
733,
544,
749
],
[
548,
733,
615,
749
],
[
618,
733,
630,
749
],
[
632,
733,
687,
749
],
[
690,
734,
767,
749
],
[
770,
734,
808,
748
],
[
810,
734,
828,
748
],
[
831,
735,
864,
748
],
[
116,
751,
190,
768
],
[
194,
751,
216,
767
],
[
219,
751,
256,
767
],
[
260,
751,
295,
767
],
[
298,
751,
325,
767
],
[
329,
751,
370,
767
],
[
373,
751,
485,
767
],
[
488,
751,
551,
767
],
[
119,
786,
167,
801
],
[
170,
786,
195,
801
],
[
198,
786,
272,
801
],
[
275,
786,
309,
801
],
[
312,
786,
340,
801
],
[
342,
786,
420,
801
],
[
423,
786,
489,
801
],
[
492,
786,
514,
801
],
[
517,
786,
579,
801
],
[
582,
786,
647,
801
],
[
650,
786,
661,
801
],
[
665,
786,
681,
801
],
[
684,
786,
724,
801
],
[
728,
786,
797,
800
],
[
801,
786,
830,
800
],
[
118,
803,
201,
817
],
[
208,
804,
290,
818
],
[
294,
804,
318,
818
],
[
321,
804,
363,
818
],
[
367,
804,
451,
819
],
[
455,
804,
552,
819
],
[
555,
804,
571,
819
],
[
575,
804,
648,
819
],
[
652,
804,
669,
819
],
[
672,
804,
715,
819
],
[
718,
804,
748,
819
],
[
752,
804,
829,
819
],
[
832,
803,
845,
818
],
[
118,
834,
129,
850
],
[
132,
835,
148,
850
],
[
151,
836,
181,
851
],
[
185,
838,
217,
852
],
[
221,
839,
234,
852
],
[
238,
839,
274,
852
],
[
132,
852,
231,
865
],
[
234,
853,
268,
865
],
[
271,
853,
342,
866
],
[
345,
854,
432,
866
],
[
435,
854,
455,
866
],
[
458,
854,
507,
866
],
[
510,
854,
569,
866
],
[
572,
854,
587,
866
],
[
590,
854,
638,
866
],
[
641,
854,
665,
866
],
[
668,
854,
699,
866
],
[
702,
854,
721,
866
],
[
724,
854,
756,
866
],
[
759,
854,
777,
866
],
[
780,
853,
811,
866
],
[
814,
853,
871,
866
],
[
118,
868,
184,
880
],
[
186,
868,
227,
880
],
[
228,
868,
266,
880
],
[
268,
868,
315,
880
],
[
317,
868,
392,
881
],
[
395,
868,
415,
881
],
[
417,
868,
439,
881
],
[
441,
868,
477,
881
],
[
479,
868,
551,
881
],
[
553,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
695,
880
],
[
697,
868,
707,
880
],
[
709,
868,
767,
880
],
[
770,
868,
831,
880
],
[
833,
868,
868,
880
],
[
119,
883,
146,
895
],
[
148,
883,
164,
895
],
[
166,
883,
183,
895
],
[
185,
883,
200,
895
],
[
203,
883,
298,
896
],
[
300,
884,
345,
896
],
[
347,
884,
411,
896
],
[
414,
884,
428,
896
],
[
430,
884,
512,
896
],
[
514,
884,
541,
896
],
[
543,
884,
564,
896
],
[
567,
884,
618,
896
],
[
621,
883,
636,
896
],
[
638,
883,
711,
896
],
[
714,
883,
778,
895
],
[
780,
882,
840,
895
],
[
842,
882,
865,
895
],
[
117,
897,
159,
910
],
[
163,
897,
240,
910
],
[
242,
897,
302,
910
],
[
305,
897,
312,
910
],
[
315,
897,
383,
910
],
[
386,
897,
407,
910
],
[
410,
897,
455,
910
],
[
458,
897,
499,
910
],
[
502,
897,
568,
910
],
[
821,
941,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
what would be the EPA's final risk evaluation?
|
suspect quality, integrity, and reliability
|
745
|
[
"Search",
"1/19/17",
"snapshot",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"TSCA",
"Contact",
"Us",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"The",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"TSCA",
"Home",
"How",
"EPA",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"the",
"Assesses",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"Assessments",
"for",
"ISCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"Chemicals",
"On",
"June",
"22,",
"2016,",
"President",
"Obama",
"signed",
"into",
"law",
"the",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"Sign",
"up",
"for",
"Current",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Reduction",
"the",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"which",
"amends",
"the",
"Toxic",
"TSCA",
"and",
"Activities",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(ISCA),",
"the",
"Nation's",
"Other",
"ChemView",
"primary",
"chemicals",
"management",
"law.",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"News",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"The",
"new",
"law,",
"which",
"received",
"bipartisan",
"support",
"in",
"both",
"the",
"U.S.",
"House",
"of",
"Representatives",
"and",
"Get",
"email",
"the",
"Senate,",
"includes",
"much",
"needed",
"alerts",
"improvements",
"such",
"as:",
"Enter",
"email",
"address",
".",
"Mandatory",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"evaluate",
"existing",
"chemicals",
"with",
"clear",
"and",
"enforceable",
"deadlines;",
".",
"New",
"risk-based",
"safety",
"standard;",
".",
"Increased",
"public",
"transparency",
"for",
"chemical",
"information;",
"and",
".",
"Consistent",
"source",
"of",
"funding",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"carry",
"Recent",
"out",
"the",
"responsibilities",
"under",
"the",
"new",
"law.",
"Additions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ylcn0226"
] |
[
[
43,
105,
105,
121
],
[
112,
106,
175,
120
],
[
179,
106,
260,
121
],
[
39,
194,
219,
222
],
[
225,
193,
298,
223
],
[
304,
193,
490,
223
],
[
498,
192,
691,
222
],
[
698,
192,
814,
220
],
[
822,
193,
917,
219
],
[
791,
242,
846,
256
],
[
849,
243,
870,
256
],
[
60,
325,
152,
339
],
[
158,
324,
191,
340
],
[
58,
340,
146,
355
],
[
59,
355,
155,
370
],
[
158,
355,
213,
371
],
[
297,
331,
388,
367
],
[
397,
332,
542,
368
],
[
554,
333,
608,
368
],
[
618,
333,
893,
371
],
[
61,
371,
111,
385
],
[
118,
371,
172,
386
],
[
69,
405,
104,
419
],
[
111,
406,
147,
420
],
[
294,
379,
522,
417
],
[
531,
380,
681,
418
],
[
690,
381,
766,
418
],
[
774,
381,
842,
418
],
[
71,
420,
148,
433
],
[
152,
419,
229,
433
],
[
70,
433,
120,
448
],
[
294,
429,
394,
462
],
[
401,
429,
594,
464
],
[
608,
429,
684,
464
],
[
73,
466,
178,
479
],
[
182,
465,
203,
480
],
[
73,
480,
117,
491
],
[
123,
480,
166,
493
],
[
170,
481,
205,
494
],
[
71,
493,
157,
506
],
[
294,
488,
322,
506
],
[
327,
489,
371,
506
],
[
375,
489,
405,
506
],
[
409,
489,
461,
506
],
[
465,
490,
554,
507
],
[
558,
490,
625,
507
],
[
630,
490,
690,
507
],
[
694,
489,
730,
506
],
[
291,
511,
322,
529
],
[
328,
512,
358,
529
],
[
361,
512,
417,
530
],
[
420,
512,
441,
530
],
[
445,
512,
551,
530
],
[
555,
512,
642,
530
],
[
646,
511,
704,
530
],
[
708,
511,
734,
530
],
[
817,
503,
855,
522
],
[
860,
504,
884,
522
],
[
888,
503,
909,
522
],
[
71,
525,
132,
539
],
[
135,
525,
212,
539
],
[
72,
541,
107,
553
],
[
110,
541,
192,
553
],
[
291,
535,
323,
552
],
[
327,
535,
363,
552
],
[
367,
535,
440,
553
],
[
444,
535,
474,
553
],
[
478,
535,
532,
553
],
[
536,
535,
609,
553
],
[
613,
536,
648,
554
],
[
651,
536,
700,
554
],
[
818,
527,
872,
545
],
[
877,
527,
908,
545
],
[
70,
554,
142,
566
],
[
294,
559,
401,
577
],
[
405,
560,
472,
577
],
[
477,
560,
508,
577
],
[
512,
560,
585,
577
],
[
590,
559,
620,
576
],
[
624,
558,
699,
576
],
[
838,
550,
886,
566
],
[
72,
585,
157,
600
],
[
291,
582,
362,
599
],
[
366,
583,
458,
599
],
[
462,
583,
582,
599
],
[
585,
583,
623,
599
],
[
822,
572,
907,
592
],
[
807,
596,
865,
614
],
[
870,
596,
923,
615
],
[
74,
617,
147,
632
],
[
150,
618,
188,
632
],
[
71,
633,
147,
647
],
[
294,
628,
329,
644
],
[
332,
628,
368,
644
],
[
375,
628,
413,
644
],
[
417,
628,
471,
645
],
[
475,
628,
554,
645
],
[
558,
629,
649,
645
],
[
652,
628,
724,
645
],
[
291,
650,
309,
667
],
[
312,
650,
355,
667
],
[
358,
651,
390,
668
],
[
393,
651,
435,
668
],
[
438,
651,
499,
668
],
[
502,
651,
522,
668
],
[
526,
651,
675,
668
],
[
678,
651,
717,
667
],
[
837,
656,
864,
670
],
[
868,
657,
913,
670
],
[
291,
673,
322,
690
],
[
327,
674,
397,
691
],
[
401,
674,
478,
692
],
[
482,
675,
534,
692
],
[
538,
675,
605,
691
],
[
837,
670,
877,
680
],
[
292,
698,
422,
715
],
[
426,
698,
470,
714
],
[
474,
698,
502,
715
],
[
808,
694,
837,
705
],
[
840,
695,
868,
705
],
[
871,
695,
917,
705
],
[
295,
743,
310,
760
],
[
316,
743,
413,
760
],
[
417,
744,
529,
760
],
[
532,
744,
558,
760
],
[
561,
744,
604,
760
],
[
608,
744,
627,
760
],
[
631,
743,
708,
760
],
[
317,
767,
386,
784
],
[
390,
767,
482,
784
],
[
487,
767,
524,
784
],
[
528,
767,
574,
784
],
[
578,
767,
615,
784
],
[
619,
766,
724,
784
],
[
321,
790,
409,
807
],
[
295,
812,
311,
828
],
[
315,
812,
357,
829
],
[
361,
813,
460,
830
],
[
462,
814,
520,
830
],
[
523,
813,
608,
830
],
[
295,
835,
310,
851
],
[
315,
836,
407,
853
],
[
410,
837,
466,
853
],
[
470,
836,
590,
853
],
[
594,
836,
620,
853
],
[
624,
835,
705,
853
],
[
315,
858,
425,
875
],
[
429,
859,
467,
875
],
[
295,
882,
310,
899
],
[
317,
882,
414,
899
],
[
419,
882,
481,
899
],
[
485,
882,
503,
900
],
[
507,
882,
576,
900
],
[
580,
882,
606,
900
],
[
610,
882,
651,
900
],
[
655,
882,
675,
900
],
[
678,
882,
724,
900
],
[
827,
872,
897,
889
],
[
316,
906,
347,
922
],
[
350,
906,
381,
922
],
[
384,
906,
520,
922
],
[
522,
906,
577,
922
],
[
581,
906,
611,
922
],
[
614,
906,
653,
922
],
[
657,
906,
698,
922
],
[
812,
891,
911,
909
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
Which law is signed by President Obama?
|
the Frank R. Launtenberg Chemical Safety for 21st Century Act
|
745
|
[
"Search",
"1/19/17",
"snapshot",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"TSCA",
"Contact",
"Us",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"The",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"TSCA",
"Home",
"How",
"EPA",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"the",
"Assesses",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"Assessments",
"for",
"ISCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"Chemicals",
"On",
"June",
"22,",
"2016,",
"President",
"Obama",
"signed",
"into",
"law",
"the",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"Sign",
"up",
"for",
"Current",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Reduction",
"the",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"which",
"amends",
"the",
"Toxic",
"TSCA",
"and",
"Activities",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(ISCA),",
"the",
"Nation's",
"Other",
"ChemView",
"primary",
"chemicals",
"management",
"law.",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"News",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"The",
"new",
"law,",
"which",
"received",
"bipartisan",
"support",
"in",
"both",
"the",
"U.S.",
"House",
"of",
"Representatives",
"and",
"Get",
"email",
"the",
"Senate,",
"includes",
"much",
"needed",
"alerts",
"improvements",
"such",
"as:",
"Enter",
"email",
"address",
".",
"Mandatory",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"evaluate",
"existing",
"chemicals",
"with",
"clear",
"and",
"enforceable",
"deadlines;",
".",
"New",
"risk-based",
"safety",
"standard;",
".",
"Increased",
"public",
"transparency",
"for",
"chemical",
"information;",
"and",
".",
"Consistent",
"source",
"of",
"funding",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"carry",
"Recent",
"out",
"the",
"responsibilities",
"under",
"the",
"new",
"law.",
"Additions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ylcn0226"
] |
[
[
43,
105,
105,
121
],
[
112,
106,
175,
120
],
[
179,
106,
260,
121
],
[
39,
194,
219,
222
],
[
225,
193,
298,
223
],
[
304,
193,
490,
223
],
[
498,
192,
691,
222
],
[
698,
192,
814,
220
],
[
822,
193,
917,
219
],
[
791,
242,
846,
256
],
[
849,
243,
870,
256
],
[
60,
325,
152,
339
],
[
158,
324,
191,
340
],
[
58,
340,
146,
355
],
[
59,
355,
155,
370
],
[
158,
355,
213,
371
],
[
297,
331,
388,
367
],
[
397,
332,
542,
368
],
[
554,
333,
608,
368
],
[
618,
333,
893,
371
],
[
61,
371,
111,
385
],
[
118,
371,
172,
386
],
[
69,
405,
104,
419
],
[
111,
406,
147,
420
],
[
294,
379,
522,
417
],
[
531,
380,
681,
418
],
[
690,
381,
766,
418
],
[
774,
381,
842,
418
],
[
71,
420,
148,
433
],
[
152,
419,
229,
433
],
[
70,
433,
120,
448
],
[
294,
429,
394,
462
],
[
401,
429,
594,
464
],
[
608,
429,
684,
464
],
[
73,
466,
178,
479
],
[
182,
465,
203,
480
],
[
73,
480,
117,
491
],
[
123,
480,
166,
493
],
[
170,
481,
205,
494
],
[
71,
493,
157,
506
],
[
294,
488,
322,
506
],
[
327,
489,
371,
506
],
[
375,
489,
405,
506
],
[
409,
489,
461,
506
],
[
465,
490,
554,
507
],
[
558,
490,
625,
507
],
[
630,
490,
690,
507
],
[
694,
489,
730,
506
],
[
291,
511,
322,
529
],
[
328,
512,
358,
529
],
[
361,
512,
417,
530
],
[
420,
512,
441,
530
],
[
445,
512,
551,
530
],
[
555,
512,
642,
530
],
[
646,
511,
704,
530
],
[
708,
511,
734,
530
],
[
817,
503,
855,
522
],
[
860,
504,
884,
522
],
[
888,
503,
909,
522
],
[
71,
525,
132,
539
],
[
135,
525,
212,
539
],
[
72,
541,
107,
553
],
[
110,
541,
192,
553
],
[
291,
535,
323,
552
],
[
327,
535,
363,
552
],
[
367,
535,
440,
553
],
[
444,
535,
474,
553
],
[
478,
535,
532,
553
],
[
536,
535,
609,
553
],
[
613,
536,
648,
554
],
[
651,
536,
700,
554
],
[
818,
527,
872,
545
],
[
877,
527,
908,
545
],
[
70,
554,
142,
566
],
[
294,
559,
401,
577
],
[
405,
560,
472,
577
],
[
477,
560,
508,
577
],
[
512,
560,
585,
577
],
[
590,
559,
620,
576
],
[
624,
558,
699,
576
],
[
838,
550,
886,
566
],
[
72,
585,
157,
600
],
[
291,
582,
362,
599
],
[
366,
583,
458,
599
],
[
462,
583,
582,
599
],
[
585,
583,
623,
599
],
[
822,
572,
907,
592
],
[
807,
596,
865,
614
],
[
870,
596,
923,
615
],
[
74,
617,
147,
632
],
[
150,
618,
188,
632
],
[
71,
633,
147,
647
],
[
294,
628,
329,
644
],
[
332,
628,
368,
644
],
[
375,
628,
413,
644
],
[
417,
628,
471,
645
],
[
475,
628,
554,
645
],
[
558,
629,
649,
645
],
[
652,
628,
724,
645
],
[
291,
650,
309,
667
],
[
312,
650,
355,
667
],
[
358,
651,
390,
668
],
[
393,
651,
435,
668
],
[
438,
651,
499,
668
],
[
502,
651,
522,
668
],
[
526,
651,
675,
668
],
[
678,
651,
717,
667
],
[
837,
656,
864,
670
],
[
868,
657,
913,
670
],
[
291,
673,
322,
690
],
[
327,
674,
397,
691
],
[
401,
674,
478,
692
],
[
482,
675,
534,
692
],
[
538,
675,
605,
691
],
[
837,
670,
877,
680
],
[
292,
698,
422,
715
],
[
426,
698,
470,
714
],
[
474,
698,
502,
715
],
[
808,
694,
837,
705
],
[
840,
695,
868,
705
],
[
871,
695,
917,
705
],
[
295,
743,
310,
760
],
[
316,
743,
413,
760
],
[
417,
744,
529,
760
],
[
532,
744,
558,
760
],
[
561,
744,
604,
760
],
[
608,
744,
627,
760
],
[
631,
743,
708,
760
],
[
317,
767,
386,
784
],
[
390,
767,
482,
784
],
[
487,
767,
524,
784
],
[
528,
767,
574,
784
],
[
578,
767,
615,
784
],
[
619,
766,
724,
784
],
[
321,
790,
409,
807
],
[
295,
812,
311,
828
],
[
315,
812,
357,
829
],
[
361,
813,
460,
830
],
[
462,
814,
520,
830
],
[
523,
813,
608,
830
],
[
295,
835,
310,
851
],
[
315,
836,
407,
853
],
[
410,
837,
466,
853
],
[
470,
836,
590,
853
],
[
594,
836,
620,
853
],
[
624,
835,
705,
853
],
[
315,
858,
425,
875
],
[
429,
859,
467,
875
],
[
295,
882,
310,
899
],
[
317,
882,
414,
899
],
[
419,
882,
481,
899
],
[
485,
882,
503,
900
],
[
507,
882,
576,
900
],
[
580,
882,
606,
900
],
[
610,
882,
651,
900
],
[
655,
882,
675,
900
],
[
678,
882,
724,
900
],
[
827,
872,
897,
889
],
[
316,
906,
347,
922
],
[
350,
906,
381,
922
],
[
384,
906,
520,
922
],
[
522,
906,
577,
922
],
[
581,
906,
611,
922
],
[
614,
906,
653,
922
],
[
657,
906,
698,
922
],
[
812,
891,
911,
909
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
What is the fullform of TSCA?
|
Toxic Substances Control Act
|
745
|
[
"Search",
"1/19/17",
"snapshot",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"TSCA",
"Contact",
"Us",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"The",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"TSCA",
"Home",
"How",
"EPA",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"the",
"Assesses",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"Assessments",
"for",
"ISCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"Chemicals",
"On",
"June",
"22,",
"2016,",
"President",
"Obama",
"signed",
"into",
"law",
"the",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"Sign",
"up",
"for",
"Current",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Reduction",
"the",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"which",
"amends",
"the",
"Toxic",
"TSCA",
"and",
"Activities",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(ISCA),",
"the",
"Nation's",
"Other",
"ChemView",
"primary",
"chemicals",
"management",
"law.",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"News",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"The",
"new",
"law,",
"which",
"received",
"bipartisan",
"support",
"in",
"both",
"the",
"U.S.",
"House",
"of",
"Representatives",
"and",
"Get",
"email",
"the",
"Senate,",
"includes",
"much",
"needed",
"alerts",
"improvements",
"such",
"as:",
"Enter",
"email",
"address",
".",
"Mandatory",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"evaluate",
"existing",
"chemicals",
"with",
"clear",
"and",
"enforceable",
"deadlines;",
".",
"New",
"risk-based",
"safety",
"standard;",
".",
"Increased",
"public",
"transparency",
"for",
"chemical",
"information;",
"and",
".",
"Consistent",
"source",
"of",
"funding",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"carry",
"Recent",
"out",
"the",
"responsibilities",
"under",
"the",
"new",
"law.",
"Additions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ylcn0226"
] |
[
[
43,
105,
105,
121
],
[
112,
106,
175,
120
],
[
179,
106,
260,
121
],
[
39,
194,
219,
222
],
[
225,
193,
298,
223
],
[
304,
193,
490,
223
],
[
498,
192,
691,
222
],
[
698,
192,
814,
220
],
[
822,
193,
917,
219
],
[
791,
242,
846,
256
],
[
849,
243,
870,
256
],
[
60,
325,
152,
339
],
[
158,
324,
191,
340
],
[
58,
340,
146,
355
],
[
59,
355,
155,
370
],
[
158,
355,
213,
371
],
[
297,
331,
388,
367
],
[
397,
332,
542,
368
],
[
554,
333,
608,
368
],
[
618,
333,
893,
371
],
[
61,
371,
111,
385
],
[
118,
371,
172,
386
],
[
69,
405,
104,
419
],
[
111,
406,
147,
420
],
[
294,
379,
522,
417
],
[
531,
380,
681,
418
],
[
690,
381,
766,
418
],
[
774,
381,
842,
418
],
[
71,
420,
148,
433
],
[
152,
419,
229,
433
],
[
70,
433,
120,
448
],
[
294,
429,
394,
462
],
[
401,
429,
594,
464
],
[
608,
429,
684,
464
],
[
73,
466,
178,
479
],
[
182,
465,
203,
480
],
[
73,
480,
117,
491
],
[
123,
480,
166,
493
],
[
170,
481,
205,
494
],
[
71,
493,
157,
506
],
[
294,
488,
322,
506
],
[
327,
489,
371,
506
],
[
375,
489,
405,
506
],
[
409,
489,
461,
506
],
[
465,
490,
554,
507
],
[
558,
490,
625,
507
],
[
630,
490,
690,
507
],
[
694,
489,
730,
506
],
[
291,
511,
322,
529
],
[
328,
512,
358,
529
],
[
361,
512,
417,
530
],
[
420,
512,
441,
530
],
[
445,
512,
551,
530
],
[
555,
512,
642,
530
],
[
646,
511,
704,
530
],
[
708,
511,
734,
530
],
[
817,
503,
855,
522
],
[
860,
504,
884,
522
],
[
888,
503,
909,
522
],
[
71,
525,
132,
539
],
[
135,
525,
212,
539
],
[
72,
541,
107,
553
],
[
110,
541,
192,
553
],
[
291,
535,
323,
552
],
[
327,
535,
363,
552
],
[
367,
535,
440,
553
],
[
444,
535,
474,
553
],
[
478,
535,
532,
553
],
[
536,
535,
609,
553
],
[
613,
536,
648,
554
],
[
651,
536,
700,
554
],
[
818,
527,
872,
545
],
[
877,
527,
908,
545
],
[
70,
554,
142,
566
],
[
294,
559,
401,
577
],
[
405,
560,
472,
577
],
[
477,
560,
508,
577
],
[
512,
560,
585,
577
],
[
590,
559,
620,
576
],
[
624,
558,
699,
576
],
[
838,
550,
886,
566
],
[
72,
585,
157,
600
],
[
291,
582,
362,
599
],
[
366,
583,
458,
599
],
[
462,
583,
582,
599
],
[
585,
583,
623,
599
],
[
822,
572,
907,
592
],
[
807,
596,
865,
614
],
[
870,
596,
923,
615
],
[
74,
617,
147,
632
],
[
150,
618,
188,
632
],
[
71,
633,
147,
647
],
[
294,
628,
329,
644
],
[
332,
628,
368,
644
],
[
375,
628,
413,
644
],
[
417,
628,
471,
645
],
[
475,
628,
554,
645
],
[
558,
629,
649,
645
],
[
652,
628,
724,
645
],
[
291,
650,
309,
667
],
[
312,
650,
355,
667
],
[
358,
651,
390,
668
],
[
393,
651,
435,
668
],
[
438,
651,
499,
668
],
[
502,
651,
522,
668
],
[
526,
651,
675,
668
],
[
678,
651,
717,
667
],
[
837,
656,
864,
670
],
[
868,
657,
913,
670
],
[
291,
673,
322,
690
],
[
327,
674,
397,
691
],
[
401,
674,
478,
692
],
[
482,
675,
534,
692
],
[
538,
675,
605,
691
],
[
837,
670,
877,
680
],
[
292,
698,
422,
715
],
[
426,
698,
470,
714
],
[
474,
698,
502,
715
],
[
808,
694,
837,
705
],
[
840,
695,
868,
705
],
[
871,
695,
917,
705
],
[
295,
743,
310,
760
],
[
316,
743,
413,
760
],
[
417,
744,
529,
760
],
[
532,
744,
558,
760
],
[
561,
744,
604,
760
],
[
608,
744,
627,
760
],
[
631,
743,
708,
760
],
[
317,
767,
386,
784
],
[
390,
767,
482,
784
],
[
487,
767,
524,
784
],
[
528,
767,
574,
784
],
[
578,
767,
615,
784
],
[
619,
766,
724,
784
],
[
321,
790,
409,
807
],
[
295,
812,
311,
828
],
[
315,
812,
357,
829
],
[
361,
813,
460,
830
],
[
462,
814,
520,
830
],
[
523,
813,
608,
830
],
[
295,
835,
310,
851
],
[
315,
836,
407,
853
],
[
410,
837,
466,
853
],
[
470,
836,
590,
853
],
[
594,
836,
620,
853
],
[
624,
835,
705,
853
],
[
315,
858,
425,
875
],
[
429,
859,
467,
875
],
[
295,
882,
310,
899
],
[
317,
882,
414,
899
],
[
419,
882,
481,
899
],
[
485,
882,
503,
900
],
[
507,
882,
576,
900
],
[
580,
882,
606,
900
],
[
610,
882,
651,
900
],
[
655,
882,
675,
900
],
[
678,
882,
724,
900
],
[
827,
872,
897,
889
],
[
316,
906,
347,
922
],
[
350,
906,
381,
922
],
[
384,
906,
520,
922
],
[
522,
906,
577,
922
],
[
581,
906,
611,
922
],
[
614,
906,
653,
922
],
[
657,
906,
698,
922
],
[
812,
891,
911,
909
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
When did president Obama amends the TSCA?
|
On June 22, 2016
|
745
|
[
"Search",
"1/19/17",
"snapshot",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"TSCA",
"Contact",
"Us",
"Assessing",
"and",
"Managing",
"Chemicals",
"under",
"The",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"TSCA",
"Home",
"How",
"EPA",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"the",
"Assesses",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"Assessments",
"for",
"ISCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"Chemicals",
"On",
"June",
"22,",
"2016,",
"President",
"Obama",
"signed",
"into",
"law",
"the",
"Frank",
"R.",
"Lautenberg",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"for",
"Sign",
"up",
"for",
"Current",
"Chemical",
"Risk",
"Reduction",
"the",
"21st",
"Century",
"Act",
"which",
"amends",
"the",
"Toxic",
"TSCA",
"and",
"Activities",
"Substances",
"Control",
"Act",
"(ISCA),",
"the",
"Nation's",
"Other",
"ChemView",
"primary",
"chemicals",
"management",
"law.",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"News",
"Chemical",
"Data",
"Reporting",
"The",
"new",
"law,",
"which",
"received",
"bipartisan",
"support",
"in",
"both",
"the",
"U.S.",
"House",
"of",
"Representatives",
"and",
"Get",
"email",
"the",
"Senate,",
"includes",
"much",
"needed",
"alerts",
"improvements",
"such",
"as:",
"Enter",
"email",
"address",
".",
"Mandatory",
"requirement",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"evaluate",
"existing",
"chemicals",
"with",
"clear",
"and",
"enforceable",
"deadlines;",
".",
"New",
"risk-based",
"safety",
"standard;",
".",
"Increased",
"public",
"transparency",
"for",
"chemical",
"information;",
"and",
".",
"Consistent",
"source",
"of",
"funding",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"carry",
"Recent",
"out",
"the",
"responsibilities",
"under",
"the",
"new",
"law.",
"Additions",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ylcn0226"
] |
[
[
43,
105,
105,
121
],
[
112,
106,
175,
120
],
[
179,
106,
260,
121
],
[
39,
194,
219,
222
],
[
225,
193,
298,
223
],
[
304,
193,
490,
223
],
[
498,
192,
691,
222
],
[
698,
192,
814,
220
],
[
822,
193,
917,
219
],
[
791,
242,
846,
256
],
[
849,
243,
870,
256
],
[
60,
325,
152,
339
],
[
158,
324,
191,
340
],
[
58,
340,
146,
355
],
[
59,
355,
155,
370
],
[
158,
355,
213,
371
],
[
297,
331,
388,
367
],
[
397,
332,
542,
368
],
[
554,
333,
608,
368
],
[
618,
333,
893,
371
],
[
61,
371,
111,
385
],
[
118,
371,
172,
386
],
[
69,
405,
104,
419
],
[
111,
406,
147,
420
],
[
294,
379,
522,
417
],
[
531,
380,
681,
418
],
[
690,
381,
766,
418
],
[
774,
381,
842,
418
],
[
71,
420,
148,
433
],
[
152,
419,
229,
433
],
[
70,
433,
120,
448
],
[
294,
429,
394,
462
],
[
401,
429,
594,
464
],
[
608,
429,
684,
464
],
[
73,
466,
178,
479
],
[
182,
465,
203,
480
],
[
73,
480,
117,
491
],
[
123,
480,
166,
493
],
[
170,
481,
205,
494
],
[
71,
493,
157,
506
],
[
294,
488,
322,
506
],
[
327,
489,
371,
506
],
[
375,
489,
405,
506
],
[
409,
489,
461,
506
],
[
465,
490,
554,
507
],
[
558,
490,
625,
507
],
[
630,
490,
690,
507
],
[
694,
489,
730,
506
],
[
291,
511,
322,
529
],
[
328,
512,
358,
529
],
[
361,
512,
417,
530
],
[
420,
512,
441,
530
],
[
445,
512,
551,
530
],
[
555,
512,
642,
530
],
[
646,
511,
704,
530
],
[
708,
511,
734,
530
],
[
817,
503,
855,
522
],
[
860,
504,
884,
522
],
[
888,
503,
909,
522
],
[
71,
525,
132,
539
],
[
135,
525,
212,
539
],
[
72,
541,
107,
553
],
[
110,
541,
192,
553
],
[
291,
535,
323,
552
],
[
327,
535,
363,
552
],
[
367,
535,
440,
553
],
[
444,
535,
474,
553
],
[
478,
535,
532,
553
],
[
536,
535,
609,
553
],
[
613,
536,
648,
554
],
[
651,
536,
700,
554
],
[
818,
527,
872,
545
],
[
877,
527,
908,
545
],
[
70,
554,
142,
566
],
[
294,
559,
401,
577
],
[
405,
560,
472,
577
],
[
477,
560,
508,
577
],
[
512,
560,
585,
577
],
[
590,
559,
620,
576
],
[
624,
558,
699,
576
],
[
838,
550,
886,
566
],
[
72,
585,
157,
600
],
[
291,
582,
362,
599
],
[
366,
583,
458,
599
],
[
462,
583,
582,
599
],
[
585,
583,
623,
599
],
[
822,
572,
907,
592
],
[
807,
596,
865,
614
],
[
870,
596,
923,
615
],
[
74,
617,
147,
632
],
[
150,
618,
188,
632
],
[
71,
633,
147,
647
],
[
294,
628,
329,
644
],
[
332,
628,
368,
644
],
[
375,
628,
413,
644
],
[
417,
628,
471,
645
],
[
475,
628,
554,
645
],
[
558,
629,
649,
645
],
[
652,
628,
724,
645
],
[
291,
650,
309,
667
],
[
312,
650,
355,
667
],
[
358,
651,
390,
668
],
[
393,
651,
435,
668
],
[
438,
651,
499,
668
],
[
502,
651,
522,
668
],
[
526,
651,
675,
668
],
[
678,
651,
717,
667
],
[
837,
656,
864,
670
],
[
868,
657,
913,
670
],
[
291,
673,
322,
690
],
[
327,
674,
397,
691
],
[
401,
674,
478,
692
],
[
482,
675,
534,
692
],
[
538,
675,
605,
691
],
[
837,
670,
877,
680
],
[
292,
698,
422,
715
],
[
426,
698,
470,
714
],
[
474,
698,
502,
715
],
[
808,
694,
837,
705
],
[
840,
695,
868,
705
],
[
871,
695,
917,
705
],
[
295,
743,
310,
760
],
[
316,
743,
413,
760
],
[
417,
744,
529,
760
],
[
532,
744,
558,
760
],
[
561,
744,
604,
760
],
[
608,
744,
627,
760
],
[
631,
743,
708,
760
],
[
317,
767,
386,
784
],
[
390,
767,
482,
784
],
[
487,
767,
524,
784
],
[
528,
767,
574,
784
],
[
578,
767,
615,
784
],
[
619,
766,
724,
784
],
[
321,
790,
409,
807
],
[
295,
812,
311,
828
],
[
315,
812,
357,
829
],
[
361,
813,
460,
830
],
[
462,
814,
520,
830
],
[
523,
813,
608,
830
],
[
295,
835,
310,
851
],
[
315,
836,
407,
853
],
[
410,
837,
466,
853
],
[
470,
836,
590,
853
],
[
594,
836,
620,
853
],
[
624,
835,
705,
853
],
[
315,
858,
425,
875
],
[
429,
859,
467,
875
],
[
295,
882,
310,
899
],
[
317,
882,
414,
899
],
[
419,
882,
481,
899
],
[
485,
882,
503,
900
],
[
507,
882,
576,
900
],
[
580,
882,
606,
900
],
[
610,
882,
651,
900
],
[
655,
882,
675,
900
],
[
678,
882,
724,
900
],
[
827,
872,
897,
889
],
[
316,
906,
347,
922
],
[
350,
906,
381,
922
],
[
384,
906,
520,
922
],
[
522,
906,
577,
922
],
[
581,
906,
611,
922
],
[
614,
906,
653,
922
],
[
657,
906,
698,
922
],
[
812,
891,
911,
909
],
[
223,
981,
291,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
What was the Mandatory requirement for EPA?
|
to evaluate existing chemicals with clear and enforceable deadlines
|
746
|
[
"judiciously",
"use",
"this",
"information",
"and",
"must",
"be",
"extremely",
"transparent",
"regarding",
"all",
"assumptions",
"and",
"uncertainties",
"when",
"incident",
"data",
"are",
"used.",
"Similarly,",
"EPA",
"states",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"may",
"also",
"consider",
"ecological",
"field",
"data.\"",
"ACC",
"appreciates",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"consider",
"using",
"these",
"data",
"over",
"modeling",
"data",
"as",
"this",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"EPA's",
"data",
"preference",
"hierarchy.",
"\"",
"Consistent",
"with",
"this",
"hierarchy,",
"EPA",
"must",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"data",
"are",
"valid,",
"reliable",
"and",
"relevant",
"for",
"the",
"decision",
"being",
"made.",
"ii.",
"Exposure",
"Assessment",
"For",
"refined",
"exposure",
"assessment,",
"above",
"all",
"else,",
"EPA",
"must",
"ensure",
"that",
"it",
"is",
"using",
"high",
"quality",
"representative",
"data",
"that",
"are",
"reflective",
"of",
"current",
"uses",
"for",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"of",
"concern.",
"Similar",
"to",
"the",
"necessity",
"to",
"clarify",
"how",
"the",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"of",
"hazard",
"information",
"will",
"be",
"evaluated,",
"EPA",
"should",
"also",
"clearly",
"present",
"the",
"approach",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"evaluation",
"exposure",
"information.",
"As",
"data",
"and",
"models",
"permit,",
"EPA",
"must",
"strive",
"to",
"use",
"probabilistic",
"exposure",
"analyses.\"",
"iii.",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"To",
"ensure",
"that",
"risk",
"characterization",
"is",
"robust",
"and",
"consistent",
"with",
"not",
"only",
"EPA's",
"2000",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"Handbook\"",
"and",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines,",
"we",
"recommend",
"that",
"EPA",
"include",
"the",
"following",
"description",
"in",
"the",
"regulatory",
"text,",
"which",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"those",
"documents:",
"In",
"the",
"risk",
"characterization,",
"particularly",
"when",
"there",
"are",
"findings",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"presents",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk,",
"for",
"each",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"evaluated,",
"EPA",
"will",
"present",
"(i)",
"each",
"population",
"addressed",
"by",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"applicable",
"human",
"health",
"risk",
"or",
"each",
"risk",
"assessment",
"endpoint,",
"including",
"populations",
"if",
"applicable,",
"addressed",
"by",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"applicable",
"ecological",
"risk;",
"(1i)",
"the",
"expected",
"risk",
"or",
"central",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk",
"of",
"the",
"human",
"health",
"risk",
"for",
"the",
"specific",
"populations",
"affected",
"or",
"the",
"ecological",
"assessment",
"endpoints,",
"including",
"populations",
"if",
"applicable;",
"(iii)",
"each",
"appropriate",
"upper-bound",
"or",
"lower-bound",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk;",
"(iv)",
"each",
"significant",
"uncertainty",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"process",
"of",
"the",
"assessment",
"of",
"risk",
"and",
"the",
"studies",
"that",
"would",
"assist",
"in",
"resolving",
"the",
"uncertainty;",
"and",
"(v)",
"peer-",
"reviewed",
"studies",
"known",
"to",
"the",
"Agency",
"that",
"support,",
"are",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to,",
"or",
"fail",
"to",
"support",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk",
"and",
"the",
"methodology",
"used",
"to",
"reconcile",
"inconsistencies",
"in",
"the",
"scientific",
"data.",
"75",
"Id.",
"at",
"7571.",
"See",
"humps://www.epa.govitsca-screening-tools/non-cancer",
"screening:approaches-health",
"effects.",
"\"",
"This",
"recommendation",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"comments",
"from",
"the",
"CSAC",
"on",
"the",
"1-bromopropane",
"review,",
"see",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Advisory",
"Committee",
"Minutes",
"No.",
"2016-02,",
"at",
"13.",
"See",
"EPA",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"Handbook,",
"available",
"at",
"burps://www.epa.gov.sites/production/files/2015-",
"10/documents/osp.",
"fisk",
"characterization",
"handbook",
"2000.pdf.",
"31/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
220,
92,
307,
110
],
[
311,
93,
340,
110
],
[
343,
93,
372,
110
],
[
377,
93,
471,
110
],
[
475,
93,
504,
110
],
[
507,
94,
547,
110
],
[
551,
94,
570,
110
],
[
574,
94,
654,
110
],
[
658,
94,
746,
110
],
[
750,
93,
827,
110
],
[
831,
93,
852,
109
],
[
221,
112,
320,
126
],
[
323,
112,
351,
126
],
[
355,
111,
459,
127
],
[
462,
111,
504,
127
],
[
508,
111,
576,
127
],
[
580,
111,
611,
127
],
[
614,
111,
640,
127
],
[
643,
111,
687,
127
],
[
221,
144,
298,
160
],
[
302,
145,
340,
160
],
[
345,
146,
389,
161
],
[
393,
146,
424,
161
],
[
428,
146,
454,
161
],
[
458,
146,
519,
161
],
[
522,
146,
558,
161
],
[
562,
146,
595,
161
],
[
598,
146,
667,
161
],
[
670,
145,
752,
161
],
[
755,
144,
795,
160
],
[
798,
143,
847,
160
],
[
222,
162,
262,
178
],
[
266,
163,
354,
179
],
[
358,
163,
389,
179
],
[
392,
163,
431,
179
],
[
435,
163,
467,
179
],
[
470,
163,
538,
179
],
[
542,
163,
585,
179
],
[
588,
163,
635,
179
],
[
638,
163,
669,
179
],
[
672,
163,
708,
179
],
[
711,
163,
791,
179
],
[
794,
163,
825,
179
],
[
828,
163,
845,
179
],
[
848,
163,
881,
179
],
[
220,
181,
235,
195
],
[
238,
181,
320,
195
],
[
322,
180,
358,
195
],
[
362,
180,
418,
196
],
[
421,
180,
451,
196
],
[
454,
180,
540,
196
],
[
543,
180,
621,
196
],
[
624,
180,
637,
196
],
[
641,
180,
726,
196
],
[
730,
180,
765,
196
],
[
768,
180,
798,
196
],
[
802,
180,
881,
196
],
[
220,
198,
258,
213
],
[
262,
198,
302,
213
],
[
305,
198,
357,
213
],
[
360,
198,
392,
213
],
[
396,
198,
424,
213
],
[
428,
198,
458,
213
],
[
462,
198,
488,
213
],
[
491,
198,
536,
213
],
[
540,
198,
601,
213
],
[
605,
198,
633,
214
],
[
637,
198,
702,
214
],
[
705,
198,
730,
214
],
[
734,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
828,
214
],
[
831,
198,
881,
215
],
[
220,
215,
269,
230
],
[
262,
248,
288,
265
],
[
294,
249,
370,
265
],
[
374,
250,
467,
265
],
[
220,
285,
248,
300
],
[
252,
285,
310,
300
],
[
313,
285,
385,
300
],
[
388,
286,
482,
300
],
[
486,
286,
534,
300
],
[
537,
286,
560,
300
],
[
562,
286,
600,
300
],
[
602,
286,
638,
300
],
[
644,
286,
685,
300
],
[
688,
286,
740,
300
],
[
742,
286,
775,
300
],
[
778,
286,
791,
300
],
[
794,
286,
809,
300
],
[
812,
286,
855,
300
],
[
220,
302,
257,
318
],
[
260,
302,
315,
318
],
[
319,
303,
433,
318
],
[
437,
303,
468,
318
],
[
471,
303,
502,
318
],
[
506,
303,
531,
318
],
[
534,
303,
611,
317
],
[
614,
303,
632,
317
],
[
636,
303,
692,
317
],
[
696,
303,
731,
317
],
[
735,
303,
759,
317
],
[
763,
303,
788,
317
],
[
792,
303,
880,
317
],
[
221,
320,
238,
335
],
[
241,
320,
268,
335
],
[
272,
320,
303,
335
],
[
307,
320,
332,
335
],
[
336,
320,
354,
335
],
[
357,
320,
426,
335
],
[
429,
320,
487,
336
],
[
491,
320,
509,
336
],
[
512,
320,
537,
336
],
[
540,
320,
614,
336
],
[
617,
320,
635,
336
],
[
639,
320,
691,
336
],
[
694,
320,
728,
336
],
[
732,
320,
758,
336
],
[
761,
320,
835,
336
],
[
838,
320,
867,
336
],
[
220,
338,
307,
352
],
[
310,
338,
327,
352
],
[
330,
338,
384,
352
],
[
387,
338,
482,
352
],
[
486,
338,
518,
352
],
[
521,
338,
541,
352
],
[
544,
338,
626,
353
],
[
629,
338,
665,
353
],
[
672,
338,
725,
353
],
[
729,
337,
762,
353
],
[
765,
337,
820,
352
],
[
823,
336,
885,
352
],
[
220,
355,
245,
370
],
[
248,
355,
322,
370
],
[
325,
355,
357,
370
],
[
361,
355,
392,
370
],
[
395,
355,
415,
370
],
[
419,
355,
456,
370
],
[
460,
355,
477,
370
],
[
480,
355,
563,
370
],
[
567,
355,
638,
370
],
[
642,
355,
748,
370
],
[
751,
355,
777,
370
],
[
780,
355,
812,
370
],
[
815,
355,
842,
370
],
[
220,
371,
277,
387
],
[
281,
372,
340,
388
],
[
344,
372,
380,
388
],
[
384,
372,
425,
388
],
[
428,
373,
472,
389
],
[
475,
373,
493,
389
],
[
497,
373,
523,
389
],
[
527,
373,
627,
389
],
[
631,
372,
703,
388
],
[
707,
372,
788,
388
],
[
258,
406,
288,
421
],
[
294,
406,
332,
421
],
[
336,
407,
468,
422
],
[
223,
442,
244,
456
],
[
247,
442,
299,
457
],
[
302,
442,
332,
457
],
[
336,
443,
368,
457
],
[
372,
443,
498,
457
],
[
502,
443,
516,
457
],
[
520,
443,
571,
457
],
[
575,
443,
604,
457
],
[
608,
443,
688,
457
],
[
691,
443,
728,
457
],
[
731,
443,
758,
457
],
[
762,
442,
798,
457
],
[
801,
442,
852,
457
],
[
221,
460,
261,
473
],
[
264,
460,
302,
474
],
[
306,
459,
435,
474
],
[
440,
459,
535,
475
],
[
540,
459,
571,
475
],
[
574,
459,
609,
475
],
[
615,
459,
710,
475
],
[
714,
459,
774,
475
],
[
778,
459,
870,
475
],
[
221,
477,
244,
491
],
[
247,
477,
342,
491
],
[
345,
476,
377,
491
],
[
380,
476,
415,
492
],
[
422,
476,
481,
492
],
[
484,
476,
511,
492
],
[
515,
476,
593,
492
],
[
599,
476,
684,
493
],
[
688,
476,
704,
493
],
[
707,
476,
732,
493
],
[
735,
476,
817,
493
],
[
821,
477,
854,
494
],
[
221,
495,
270,
509
],
[
273,
495,
288,
509
],
[
291,
495,
372,
509
],
[
375,
495,
411,
509
],
[
414,
495,
460,
510
],
[
464,
495,
554,
510
],
[
294,
528,
314,
544
],
[
318,
528,
348,
545
],
[
351,
529,
385,
545
],
[
390,
529,
525,
545
],
[
529,
529,
625,
545
],
[
630,
529,
675,
545
],
[
680,
529,
725,
545
],
[
729,
529,
758,
545
],
[
762,
529,
830,
545
],
[
834,
529,
869,
545
],
[
873,
529,
883,
545
],
[
295,
548,
371,
562
],
[
377,
548,
447,
562
],
[
457,
548,
477,
562
],
[
488,
547,
595,
562
],
[
605,
547,
648,
562
],
[
654,
547,
681,
562
],
[
690,
547,
727,
562
],
[
739,
547,
815,
562
],
[
827,
547,
850,
562
],
[
856,
547,
886,
562
],
[
294,
564,
377,
579
],
[
379,
564,
417,
579
],
[
421,
565,
453,
579
],
[
455,
565,
521,
580
],
[
524,
565,
545,
580
],
[
547,
565,
584,
580
],
[
587,
565,
674,
580
],
[
677,
565,
756,
580
],
[
759,
565,
781,
579
],
[
784,
565,
814,
579
],
[
817,
565,
887,
579
],
[
293,
581,
317,
596
],
[
322,
581,
409,
596
],
[
416,
581,
474,
596
],
[
482,
581,
535,
596
],
[
544,
581,
577,
596
],
[
587,
581,
610,
596
],
[
616,
582,
655,
596
],
[
665,
582,
698,
596
],
[
708,
582,
804,
597
],
[
808,
582,
885,
597
],
[
293,
599,
372,
615
],
[
382,
600,
479,
615
],
[
488,
600,
508,
615
],
[
516,
600,
610,
615
],
[
615,
600,
697,
615
],
[
707,
600,
732,
615
],
[
743,
600,
774,
615
],
[
785,
600,
855,
615
],
[
865,
600,
885,
614
],
[
296,
618,
377,
632
],
[
380,
618,
463,
632
],
[
466,
618,
504,
632
],
[
507,
618,
534,
632
],
[
537,
618,
564,
632
],
[
567,
618,
640,
632
],
[
642,
618,
675,
632
],
[
678,
618,
698,
632
],
[
701,
617,
757,
632
],
[
760,
617,
828,
632
],
[
831,
617,
850,
631
],
[
852,
617,
882,
631
],
[
296,
633,
317,
648
],
[
320,
633,
348,
649
],
[
354,
633,
411,
649
],
[
418,
634,
469,
650
],
[
477,
634,
510,
650
],
[
517,
634,
547,
650
],
[
550,
634,
578,
650
],
[
585,
634,
651,
650
],
[
655,
634,
754,
650
],
[
758,
634,
827,
649
],
[
832,
634,
854,
649
],
[
859,
633,
881,
649
],
[
294,
652,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
471,
667
],
[
474,
652,
558,
667
],
[
562,
652,
640,
668
],
[
643,
651,
737,
668
],
[
741,
651,
757,
668
],
[
760,
651,
850,
668
],
[
852,
650,
881,
667
],
[
294,
670,
332,
685
],
[
337,
670,
430,
685
],
[
434,
670,
538,
685
],
[
542,
670,
561,
684
],
[
564,
669,
670,
684
],
[
672,
669,
743,
684
],
[
746,
669,
766,
684
],
[
769,
668,
808,
684
],
[
811,
668,
844,
684
],
[
847,
668,
885,
684
],
[
295,
686,
379,
702
],
[
382,
686,
474,
702
],
[
478,
686,
557,
702
],
[
561,
686,
579,
702
],
[
582,
686,
610,
702
],
[
614,
686,
677,
702
],
[
680,
686,
700,
702
],
[
704,
686,
731,
702
],
[
735,
686,
826,
702
],
[
830,
686,
850,
701
],
[
853,
686,
881,
701
],
[
295,
704,
324,
719
],
[
327,
704,
352,
719
],
[
356,
704,
412,
719
],
[
417,
704,
448,
720
],
[
451,
704,
503,
720
],
[
507,
704,
550,
720
],
[
553,
704,
571,
720
],
[
574,
704,
648,
720
],
[
652,
704,
678,
720
],
[
682,
704,
777,
720
],
[
781,
704,
811,
719
],
[
815,
704,
839,
719
],
[
842,
704,
884,
719
],
[
293,
722,
367,
736
],
[
372,
722,
430,
736
],
[
433,
722,
489,
737
],
[
494,
722,
512,
737
],
[
517,
722,
545,
737
],
[
548,
721,
611,
737
],
[
615,
721,
649,
737
],
[
652,
721,
720,
737
],
[
722,
721,
750,
736
],
[
756,
720,
815,
736
],
[
818,
720,
884,
736
],
[
294,
738,
318,
754
],
[
322,
738,
342,
754
],
[
347,
738,
377,
754
],
[
380,
738,
400,
754
],
[
404,
738,
467,
754
],
[
471,
738,
504,
754
],
[
507,
738,
578,
755
],
[
581,
738,
601,
755
],
[
604,
738,
638,
755
],
[
644,
738,
675,
755
],
[
678,
738,
708,
755
],
[
711,
738,
820,
755
],
[
823,
738,
863,
754
],
[
866,
738,
885,
754
],
[
292,
756,
367,
771
],
[
370,
756,
491,
771
],
[
495,
756,
511,
771
],
[
514,
756,
540,
771
],
[
544,
756,
621,
771
],
[
625,
756,
662,
771
],
[
118,
822,
128,
835
],
[
131,
822,
151,
835
],
[
154,
822,
168,
836
],
[
171,
823,
208,
836
],
[
132,
837,
156,
851
],
[
159,
837,
511,
854
],
[
514,
839,
704,
854
],
[
707,
838,
755,
853
],
[
120,
852,
130,
865
],
[
133,
852,
162,
865
],
[
165,
853,
275,
866
],
[
278,
853,
291,
866
],
[
294,
853,
361,
866
],
[
364,
854,
392,
866
],
[
395,
854,
417,
866
],
[
420,
854,
488,
866
],
[
492,
854,
522,
867
],
[
528,
854,
550,
867
],
[
552,
854,
594,
867
],
[
598,
854,
615,
866
],
[
619,
854,
641,
866
],
[
644,
853,
753,
866
],
[
757,
853,
807,
866
],
[
810,
853,
832,
866
],
[
119,
868,
181,
881
],
[
185,
868,
227,
881
],
[
231,
868,
292,
881
],
[
295,
868,
368,
880
],
[
371,
868,
427,
880
],
[
430,
868,
454,
881
],
[
457,
868,
518,
881
],
[
521,
868,
536,
881
],
[
538,
868,
561,
881
],
[
132,
880,
157,
894
],
[
160,
880,
191,
895
],
[
194,
880,
225,
895
],
[
229,
881,
337,
896
],
[
340,
882,
414,
896
],
[
418,
883,
477,
896
],
[
481,
883,
492,
896
],
[
496,
882,
816,
896
],
[
120,
897,
241,
911
],
[
244,
898,
271,
911
],
[
276,
897,
384,
911
],
[
388,
897,
457,
911
],
[
462,
897,
524,
911
],
[
820,
940,
882,
955
],
[
221,
981,
287,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the page no mentioned in this document?
|
31
|
746
|
[
"judiciously",
"use",
"this",
"information",
"and",
"must",
"be",
"extremely",
"transparent",
"regarding",
"all",
"assumptions",
"and",
"uncertainties",
"when",
"incident",
"data",
"are",
"used.",
"Similarly,",
"EPA",
"states",
"that",
"the",
"Agency",
"may",
"also",
"consider",
"ecological",
"field",
"data.\"",
"ACC",
"appreciates",
"that",
"EPA",
"will",
"consider",
"using",
"these",
"data",
"over",
"modeling",
"data",
"as",
"this",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"EPA's",
"data",
"preference",
"hierarchy.",
"\"",
"Consistent",
"with",
"this",
"hierarchy,",
"EPA",
"must",
"ensure",
"that",
"the",
"data",
"are",
"valid,",
"reliable",
"and",
"relevant",
"for",
"the",
"decision",
"being",
"made.",
"ii.",
"Exposure",
"Assessment",
"For",
"refined",
"exposure",
"assessment,",
"above",
"all",
"else,",
"EPA",
"must",
"ensure",
"that",
"it",
"is",
"using",
"high",
"quality",
"representative",
"data",
"that",
"are",
"reflective",
"of",
"current",
"uses",
"for",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"are",
"of",
"concern.",
"Similar",
"to",
"the",
"necessity",
"to",
"clarify",
"how",
"the",
"strengths",
"and",
"limitations",
"of",
"hazard",
"information",
"will",
"be",
"evaluated,",
"EPA",
"should",
"also",
"clearly",
"present",
"the",
"approach",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"evaluation",
"exposure",
"information.",
"As",
"data",
"and",
"models",
"permit,",
"EPA",
"must",
"strive",
"to",
"use",
"probabilistic",
"exposure",
"analyses.\"",
"iii.",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"To",
"ensure",
"that",
"risk",
"characterization",
"is",
"robust",
"and",
"consistent",
"with",
"not",
"only",
"EPA's",
"2000",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"Handbook\"",
"and",
"EPA",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Guidelines,",
"we",
"recommend",
"that",
"EPA",
"include",
"the",
"following",
"description",
"in",
"the",
"regulatory",
"text,",
"which",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"those",
"documents:",
"In",
"the",
"risk",
"characterization,",
"particularly",
"when",
"there",
"are",
"findings",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"presents",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk,",
"for",
"each",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"evaluated,",
"EPA",
"will",
"present",
"(i)",
"each",
"population",
"addressed",
"by",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"applicable",
"human",
"health",
"risk",
"or",
"each",
"risk",
"assessment",
"endpoint,",
"including",
"populations",
"if",
"applicable,",
"addressed",
"by",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"applicable",
"ecological",
"risk;",
"(1i)",
"the",
"expected",
"risk",
"or",
"central",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk",
"of",
"the",
"human",
"health",
"risk",
"for",
"the",
"specific",
"populations",
"affected",
"or",
"the",
"ecological",
"assessment",
"endpoints,",
"including",
"populations",
"if",
"applicable;",
"(iii)",
"each",
"appropriate",
"upper-bound",
"or",
"lower-bound",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk;",
"(iv)",
"each",
"significant",
"uncertainty",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"process",
"of",
"the",
"assessment",
"of",
"risk",
"and",
"the",
"studies",
"that",
"would",
"assist",
"in",
"resolving",
"the",
"uncertainty;",
"and",
"(v)",
"peer-",
"reviewed",
"studies",
"known",
"to",
"the",
"Agency",
"that",
"support,",
"are",
"directly",
"relevant",
"to,",
"or",
"fail",
"to",
"support",
"any",
"estimate",
"of",
"risk",
"and",
"the",
"methodology",
"used",
"to",
"reconcile",
"inconsistencies",
"in",
"the",
"scientific",
"data.",
"75",
"Id.",
"at",
"7571.",
"See",
"humps://www.epa.govitsca-screening-tools/non-cancer",
"screening:approaches-health",
"effects.",
"\"",
"This",
"recommendation",
"is",
"consistent",
"with",
"the",
"comments",
"from",
"the",
"CSAC",
"on",
"the",
"1-bromopropane",
"review,",
"see",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Advisory",
"Committee",
"Minutes",
"No.",
"2016-02,",
"at",
"13.",
"See",
"EPA",
"Risk",
"Characterization",
"Handbook,",
"available",
"at",
"burps://www.epa.gov.sites/production/files/2015-",
"10/documents/osp.",
"fisk",
"characterization",
"handbook",
"2000.pdf.",
"31/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
220,
92,
307,
110
],
[
311,
93,
340,
110
],
[
343,
93,
372,
110
],
[
377,
93,
471,
110
],
[
475,
93,
504,
110
],
[
507,
94,
547,
110
],
[
551,
94,
570,
110
],
[
574,
94,
654,
110
],
[
658,
94,
746,
110
],
[
750,
93,
827,
110
],
[
831,
93,
852,
109
],
[
221,
112,
320,
126
],
[
323,
112,
351,
126
],
[
355,
111,
459,
127
],
[
462,
111,
504,
127
],
[
508,
111,
576,
127
],
[
580,
111,
611,
127
],
[
614,
111,
640,
127
],
[
643,
111,
687,
127
],
[
221,
144,
298,
160
],
[
302,
145,
340,
160
],
[
345,
146,
389,
161
],
[
393,
146,
424,
161
],
[
428,
146,
454,
161
],
[
458,
146,
519,
161
],
[
522,
146,
558,
161
],
[
562,
146,
595,
161
],
[
598,
146,
667,
161
],
[
670,
145,
752,
161
],
[
755,
144,
795,
160
],
[
798,
143,
847,
160
],
[
222,
162,
262,
178
],
[
266,
163,
354,
179
],
[
358,
163,
389,
179
],
[
392,
163,
431,
179
],
[
435,
163,
467,
179
],
[
470,
163,
538,
179
],
[
542,
163,
585,
179
],
[
588,
163,
635,
179
],
[
638,
163,
669,
179
],
[
672,
163,
708,
179
],
[
711,
163,
791,
179
],
[
794,
163,
825,
179
],
[
828,
163,
845,
179
],
[
848,
163,
881,
179
],
[
220,
181,
235,
195
],
[
238,
181,
320,
195
],
[
322,
180,
358,
195
],
[
362,
180,
418,
196
],
[
421,
180,
451,
196
],
[
454,
180,
540,
196
],
[
543,
180,
621,
196
],
[
624,
180,
637,
196
],
[
641,
180,
726,
196
],
[
730,
180,
765,
196
],
[
768,
180,
798,
196
],
[
802,
180,
881,
196
],
[
220,
198,
258,
213
],
[
262,
198,
302,
213
],
[
305,
198,
357,
213
],
[
360,
198,
392,
213
],
[
396,
198,
424,
213
],
[
428,
198,
458,
213
],
[
462,
198,
488,
213
],
[
491,
198,
536,
213
],
[
540,
198,
601,
213
],
[
605,
198,
633,
214
],
[
637,
198,
702,
214
],
[
705,
198,
730,
214
],
[
734,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
828,
214
],
[
831,
198,
881,
215
],
[
220,
215,
269,
230
],
[
262,
248,
288,
265
],
[
294,
249,
370,
265
],
[
374,
250,
467,
265
],
[
220,
285,
248,
300
],
[
252,
285,
310,
300
],
[
313,
285,
385,
300
],
[
388,
286,
482,
300
],
[
486,
286,
534,
300
],
[
537,
286,
560,
300
],
[
562,
286,
600,
300
],
[
602,
286,
638,
300
],
[
644,
286,
685,
300
],
[
688,
286,
740,
300
],
[
742,
286,
775,
300
],
[
778,
286,
791,
300
],
[
794,
286,
809,
300
],
[
812,
286,
855,
300
],
[
220,
302,
257,
318
],
[
260,
302,
315,
318
],
[
319,
303,
433,
318
],
[
437,
303,
468,
318
],
[
471,
303,
502,
318
],
[
506,
303,
531,
318
],
[
534,
303,
611,
317
],
[
614,
303,
632,
317
],
[
636,
303,
692,
317
],
[
696,
303,
731,
317
],
[
735,
303,
759,
317
],
[
763,
303,
788,
317
],
[
792,
303,
880,
317
],
[
221,
320,
238,
335
],
[
241,
320,
268,
335
],
[
272,
320,
303,
335
],
[
307,
320,
332,
335
],
[
336,
320,
354,
335
],
[
357,
320,
426,
335
],
[
429,
320,
487,
336
],
[
491,
320,
509,
336
],
[
512,
320,
537,
336
],
[
540,
320,
614,
336
],
[
617,
320,
635,
336
],
[
639,
320,
691,
336
],
[
694,
320,
728,
336
],
[
732,
320,
758,
336
],
[
761,
320,
835,
336
],
[
838,
320,
867,
336
],
[
220,
338,
307,
352
],
[
310,
338,
327,
352
],
[
330,
338,
384,
352
],
[
387,
338,
482,
352
],
[
486,
338,
518,
352
],
[
521,
338,
541,
352
],
[
544,
338,
626,
353
],
[
629,
338,
665,
353
],
[
672,
338,
725,
353
],
[
729,
337,
762,
353
],
[
765,
337,
820,
352
],
[
823,
336,
885,
352
],
[
220,
355,
245,
370
],
[
248,
355,
322,
370
],
[
325,
355,
357,
370
],
[
361,
355,
392,
370
],
[
395,
355,
415,
370
],
[
419,
355,
456,
370
],
[
460,
355,
477,
370
],
[
480,
355,
563,
370
],
[
567,
355,
638,
370
],
[
642,
355,
748,
370
],
[
751,
355,
777,
370
],
[
780,
355,
812,
370
],
[
815,
355,
842,
370
],
[
220,
371,
277,
387
],
[
281,
372,
340,
388
],
[
344,
372,
380,
388
],
[
384,
372,
425,
388
],
[
428,
373,
472,
389
],
[
475,
373,
493,
389
],
[
497,
373,
523,
389
],
[
527,
373,
627,
389
],
[
631,
372,
703,
388
],
[
707,
372,
788,
388
],
[
258,
406,
288,
421
],
[
294,
406,
332,
421
],
[
336,
407,
468,
422
],
[
223,
442,
244,
456
],
[
247,
442,
299,
457
],
[
302,
442,
332,
457
],
[
336,
443,
368,
457
],
[
372,
443,
498,
457
],
[
502,
443,
516,
457
],
[
520,
443,
571,
457
],
[
575,
443,
604,
457
],
[
608,
443,
688,
457
],
[
691,
443,
728,
457
],
[
731,
443,
758,
457
],
[
762,
442,
798,
457
],
[
801,
442,
852,
457
],
[
221,
460,
261,
473
],
[
264,
460,
302,
474
],
[
306,
459,
435,
474
],
[
440,
459,
535,
475
],
[
540,
459,
571,
475
],
[
574,
459,
609,
475
],
[
615,
459,
710,
475
],
[
714,
459,
774,
475
],
[
778,
459,
870,
475
],
[
221,
477,
244,
491
],
[
247,
477,
342,
491
],
[
345,
476,
377,
491
],
[
380,
476,
415,
492
],
[
422,
476,
481,
492
],
[
484,
476,
511,
492
],
[
515,
476,
593,
492
],
[
599,
476,
684,
493
],
[
688,
476,
704,
493
],
[
707,
476,
732,
493
],
[
735,
476,
817,
493
],
[
821,
477,
854,
494
],
[
221,
495,
270,
509
],
[
273,
495,
288,
509
],
[
291,
495,
372,
509
],
[
375,
495,
411,
509
],
[
414,
495,
460,
510
],
[
464,
495,
554,
510
],
[
294,
528,
314,
544
],
[
318,
528,
348,
545
],
[
351,
529,
385,
545
],
[
390,
529,
525,
545
],
[
529,
529,
625,
545
],
[
630,
529,
675,
545
],
[
680,
529,
725,
545
],
[
729,
529,
758,
545
],
[
762,
529,
830,
545
],
[
834,
529,
869,
545
],
[
873,
529,
883,
545
],
[
295,
548,
371,
562
],
[
377,
548,
447,
562
],
[
457,
548,
477,
562
],
[
488,
547,
595,
562
],
[
605,
547,
648,
562
],
[
654,
547,
681,
562
],
[
690,
547,
727,
562
],
[
739,
547,
815,
562
],
[
827,
547,
850,
562
],
[
856,
547,
886,
562
],
[
294,
564,
377,
579
],
[
379,
564,
417,
579
],
[
421,
565,
453,
579
],
[
455,
565,
521,
580
],
[
524,
565,
545,
580
],
[
547,
565,
584,
580
],
[
587,
565,
674,
580
],
[
677,
565,
756,
580
],
[
759,
565,
781,
579
],
[
784,
565,
814,
579
],
[
817,
565,
887,
579
],
[
293,
581,
317,
596
],
[
322,
581,
409,
596
],
[
416,
581,
474,
596
],
[
482,
581,
535,
596
],
[
544,
581,
577,
596
],
[
587,
581,
610,
596
],
[
616,
582,
655,
596
],
[
665,
582,
698,
596
],
[
708,
582,
804,
597
],
[
808,
582,
885,
597
],
[
293,
599,
372,
615
],
[
382,
600,
479,
615
],
[
488,
600,
508,
615
],
[
516,
600,
610,
615
],
[
615,
600,
697,
615
],
[
707,
600,
732,
615
],
[
743,
600,
774,
615
],
[
785,
600,
855,
615
],
[
865,
600,
885,
614
],
[
296,
618,
377,
632
],
[
380,
618,
463,
632
],
[
466,
618,
504,
632
],
[
507,
618,
534,
632
],
[
537,
618,
564,
632
],
[
567,
618,
640,
632
],
[
642,
618,
675,
632
],
[
678,
618,
698,
632
],
[
701,
617,
757,
632
],
[
760,
617,
828,
632
],
[
831,
617,
850,
631
],
[
852,
617,
882,
631
],
[
296,
633,
317,
648
],
[
320,
633,
348,
649
],
[
354,
633,
411,
649
],
[
418,
634,
469,
650
],
[
477,
634,
510,
650
],
[
517,
634,
547,
650
],
[
550,
634,
578,
650
],
[
585,
634,
651,
650
],
[
655,
634,
754,
650
],
[
758,
634,
827,
649
],
[
832,
634,
854,
649
],
[
859,
633,
881,
649
],
[
294,
652,
377,
667
],
[
381,
652,
471,
667
],
[
474,
652,
558,
667
],
[
562,
652,
640,
668
],
[
643,
651,
737,
668
],
[
741,
651,
757,
668
],
[
760,
651,
850,
668
],
[
852,
650,
881,
667
],
[
294,
670,
332,
685
],
[
337,
670,
430,
685
],
[
434,
670,
538,
685
],
[
542,
670,
561,
684
],
[
564,
669,
670,
684
],
[
672,
669,
743,
684
],
[
746,
669,
766,
684
],
[
769,
668,
808,
684
],
[
811,
668,
844,
684
],
[
847,
668,
885,
684
],
[
295,
686,
379,
702
],
[
382,
686,
474,
702
],
[
478,
686,
557,
702
],
[
561,
686,
579,
702
],
[
582,
686,
610,
702
],
[
614,
686,
677,
702
],
[
680,
686,
700,
702
],
[
704,
686,
731,
702
],
[
735,
686,
826,
702
],
[
830,
686,
850,
701
],
[
853,
686,
881,
701
],
[
295,
704,
324,
719
],
[
327,
704,
352,
719
],
[
356,
704,
412,
719
],
[
417,
704,
448,
720
],
[
451,
704,
503,
720
],
[
507,
704,
550,
720
],
[
553,
704,
571,
720
],
[
574,
704,
648,
720
],
[
652,
704,
678,
720
],
[
682,
704,
777,
720
],
[
781,
704,
811,
719
],
[
815,
704,
839,
719
],
[
842,
704,
884,
719
],
[
293,
722,
367,
736
],
[
372,
722,
430,
736
],
[
433,
722,
489,
737
],
[
494,
722,
512,
737
],
[
517,
722,
545,
737
],
[
548,
721,
611,
737
],
[
615,
721,
649,
737
],
[
652,
721,
720,
737
],
[
722,
721,
750,
736
],
[
756,
720,
815,
736
],
[
818,
720,
884,
736
],
[
294,
738,
318,
754
],
[
322,
738,
342,
754
],
[
347,
738,
377,
754
],
[
380,
738,
400,
754
],
[
404,
738,
467,
754
],
[
471,
738,
504,
754
],
[
507,
738,
578,
755
],
[
581,
738,
601,
755
],
[
604,
738,
638,
755
],
[
644,
738,
675,
755
],
[
678,
738,
708,
755
],
[
711,
738,
820,
755
],
[
823,
738,
863,
754
],
[
866,
738,
885,
754
],
[
292,
756,
367,
771
],
[
370,
756,
491,
771
],
[
495,
756,
511,
771
],
[
514,
756,
540,
771
],
[
544,
756,
621,
771
],
[
625,
756,
662,
771
],
[
118,
822,
128,
835
],
[
131,
822,
151,
835
],
[
154,
822,
168,
836
],
[
171,
823,
208,
836
],
[
132,
837,
156,
851
],
[
159,
837,
511,
854
],
[
514,
839,
704,
854
],
[
707,
838,
755,
853
],
[
120,
852,
130,
865
],
[
133,
852,
162,
865
],
[
165,
853,
275,
866
],
[
278,
853,
291,
866
],
[
294,
853,
361,
866
],
[
364,
854,
392,
866
],
[
395,
854,
417,
866
],
[
420,
854,
488,
866
],
[
492,
854,
522,
867
],
[
528,
854,
550,
867
],
[
552,
854,
594,
867
],
[
598,
854,
615,
866
],
[
619,
854,
641,
866
],
[
644,
853,
753,
866
],
[
757,
853,
807,
866
],
[
810,
853,
832,
866
],
[
119,
868,
181,
881
],
[
185,
868,
227,
881
],
[
231,
868,
292,
881
],
[
295,
868,
368,
880
],
[
371,
868,
427,
880
],
[
430,
868,
454,
881
],
[
457,
868,
518,
881
],
[
521,
868,
536,
881
],
[
538,
868,
561,
881
],
[
132,
880,
157,
894
],
[
160,
880,
191,
895
],
[
194,
880,
225,
895
],
[
229,
881,
337,
896
],
[
340,
882,
414,
896
],
[
418,
883,
477,
896
],
[
481,
883,
492,
896
],
[
496,
882,
816,
896
],
[
120,
897,
241,
911
],
[
244,
898,
271,
911
],
[
276,
897,
384,
911
],
[
388,
897,
457,
911
],
[
462,
897,
524,
911
],
[
820,
940,
882,
955
],
[
221,
981,
287,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What is the abbreviation for Chemical Safety Advisory Committee?
|
CSAC
|
743
|
[
"make",
"little",
"sense",
"to",
"continue",
"evaluating",
"that",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"Otherwise,",
"EPA's",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"would",
"be",
"of",
"suspect",
"quality,",
"integrity,",
"and",
"reliability.",
"A",
"better",
"approach",
"would",
"be",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"that",
"after",
"a",
"scope",
"is",
"published,",
"EPA",
"retains",
"discretion",
"to",
"modify",
"it",
"upon",
"a",
"showing",
"of",
"substantial",
"need",
"or",
"changed",
"circumstances,",
"or",
"is",
"otherwise",
"warranted",
"because",
"the",
"addition",
"or",
"removal",
"of",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"properly",
"substantiated,",
"will",
"significantly",
"affect",
"the",
"conduct",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"J.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Remove",
"the",
"Comment-or-Waive",
"(Issue",
"Exhaustion)",
"Proposal.",
"EPA",
"further",
"proposes",
"that",
"it",
"can",
"keep",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"schedule,",
"notwithstanding",
"its",
"proposal",
"to",
"include",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"every",
"scope,",
"by",
"\"providing",
"opportunity",
"for",
"comment",
"on",
"the",
"scoping",
"document",
"and",
"specifying",
"that",
"any",
"objections",
"to",
"the",
"draft",
"scope",
"document",
"are",
"waived",
"if",
"not",
"raised",
"during",
"this",
"process.\"",
"We",
"urge",
"the",
"Agency",
"to",
"remove",
"this",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"(waiver)",
"requirement",
"for",
"several",
"reasons.",
"First,",
"it",
"places",
"an",
"unfair",
"burden",
"on",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"A",
"particular",
"company",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"aware,",
"or",
"otherwise",
"in",
"a",
"position",
"to",
"verify,",
"particular",
"end",
"uses",
"that",
"the",
"company",
"does",
"not",
"support",
"(i.e.,",
"a",
"downstream",
"value",
"chain",
"to",
"which",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"sell).",
"A",
"company",
"likewise",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"verify",
"occurrences",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"from",
"natural",
"sources",
"or",
"the",
"actions",
"of",
"third",
"parties",
"through",
"combustion,",
"spills",
"and",
"discharges,",
"disposal,",
"manufacturing",
"practices",
"or",
"incidents,",
"and",
"the",
"like.",
"When",
"EPA",
"insists",
"on",
"including",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"it",
"moves",
"well",
"past",
"the",
"\"major\"",
"uses",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"and",
"\"major\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"to",
"include",
"fleeting,",
"incidental,",
"minor,",
"isolated,",
"or",
"exceptional",
"cases.",
"Information",
"about",
"these",
"\"minor\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"may",
"be",
"well",
"outside",
"the",
"first-hand",
"knowledge",
"of",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor,",
"making",
"it",
"difficult",
"or",
"impossible",
"to",
"offer",
"meaningful",
"comment",
"during",
"the",
"scoping",
"period.",
"Second,",
"participation",
"in",
"notice",
"and",
"comment",
"rulemaking",
"is",
"governed",
"by",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act",
"(APA)",
"and",
"the",
"judicial",
"review",
"provisions",
"of",
"Section",
"19",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"Issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"can",
"be",
"imposed",
"by",
"statute.",
"Notably,",
"there",
"are",
"only",
"a",
"few",
"statutory",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"provisions",
"in",
"environmental",
"statutes,",
"the",
"most",
"notable",
"of",
"which",
"is",
"in",
"Section",
"307(d)(7)(b)",
"of",
"the",
"Clean",
"Air",
"Act.",
"There",
"are",
"none",
"in",
"TSCA.",
"Congress",
"had",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"for",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"in",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"-",
"and",
"declined",
"to",
"do",
"so.",
"EPA",
"cannot,",
"by",
"regulation,",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"that",
"trumps",
"the",
"statutory",
"rights",
"and",
"obligations",
"of",
"stakeholders",
"under",
"the",
"APA",
"and",
"TSCA",
"Section",
"19.",
"Indeed,",
"ACC",
"believes",
"a",
"waiver",
"provision",
"such",
"as",
"that",
"proposed",
"by",
"EPA",
"may",
"not",
"meet",
"Constitutional",
"muster.",
"Third,",
"the",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"rationally",
"advance",
"its",
"claimed",
"purpose",
"-",
"to",
"meet",
"statutory",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"deadlines.",
"An",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"is",
"supposed",
"to",
"serve",
"two",
"purposes:",
"it",
"19",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7566.",
"Administrative",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"are",
"largely",
"creatures",
"of",
"statute,",
"and",
"here",
"we",
"have",
"no",
"such",
"statutory",
"construct.",
"While",
"some",
"agency",
"regulations",
"set",
"out",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"without",
"a",
"statutory",
"mandate,",
"these",
"tend",
"to",
"be",
"in",
"administrative",
"appeal",
"situations",
"or",
"proceedings",
"that",
"are",
"analogs",
"to",
"adversarial",
"litigation.",
"Notably,",
"the",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"removed",
"a",
"procedure",
"for",
"formal",
"TSCA",
"hearings.",
"11/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
161,
109
],
[
164,
94,
202,
109
],
[
205,
94,
250,
109
],
[
253,
94,
270,
110
],
[
273,
93,
343,
110
],
[
346,
93,
429,
110
],
[
432,
93,
462,
110
],
[
466,
93,
542,
110
],
[
545,
93,
564,
110
],
[
567,
93,
595,
110
],
[
598,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
643,
110
],
[
647,
93,
678,
110
],
[
681,
93,
775,
110
],
[
778,
93,
865,
110
],
[
120,
110,
170,
126
],
[
174,
110,
211,
126
],
[
214,
110,
245,
126
],
[
250,
111,
332,
127
],
[
336,
111,
386,
127
],
[
390,
111,
409,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
434,
111,
492,
127
],
[
497,
111,
557,
127
],
[
561,
111,
634,
128
],
[
638,
111,
667,
128
],
[
670,
111,
756,
128
],
[
119,
146,
132,
161
],
[
136,
146,
182,
161
],
[
185,
146,
260,
161
],
[
264,
146,
312,
161
],
[
316,
146,
337,
161
],
[
341,
146,
364,
161
],
[
368,
146,
405,
161
],
[
410,
146,
427,
161
],
[
430,
145,
504,
161
],
[
507,
145,
525,
161
],
[
528,
145,
554,
161
],
[
557,
145,
589,
161
],
[
592,
145,
624,
161
],
[
627,
145,
664,
161
],
[
667,
145,
678,
161
],
[
680,
145,
727,
161
],
[
730,
145,
745,
161
],
[
748,
145,
831,
161
],
[
834,
145,
873,
161
],
[
117,
164,
173,
178
],
[
176,
164,
253,
179
],
[
256,
164,
273,
179
],
[
276,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
164,
395,
179
],
[
398,
164,
408,
179
],
[
412,
164,
480,
179
],
[
484,
164,
501,
179
],
[
504,
164,
590,
179
],
[
593,
164,
632,
179
],
[
635,
164,
654,
179
],
[
658,
164,
724,
179
],
[
728,
163,
844,
179
],
[
847,
163,
865,
178
],
[
868,
163,
885,
178
],
[
117,
181,
196,
196
],
[
199,
181,
279,
196
],
[
282,
182,
345,
196
],
[
348,
182,
375,
196
],
[
378,
182,
443,
196
],
[
446,
182,
464,
196
],
[
467,
182,
535,
196
],
[
538,
182,
556,
196
],
[
559,
182,
570,
196
],
[
572,
182,
648,
196
],
[
650,
182,
670,
196
],
[
672,
181,
704,
196
],
[
707,
181,
777,
197
],
[
118,
198,
226,
214
],
[
230,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
198,
365,
214
],
[
368,
198,
412,
213
],
[
417,
198,
442,
213
],
[
445,
198,
510,
213
],
[
514,
198,
531,
213
],
[
535,
198,
559,
213
],
[
562,
198,
595,
213
],
[
599,
198,
683,
213
],
[
177,
243,
196,
260
],
[
236,
246,
272,
260
],
[
278,
246,
325,
260
],
[
328,
246,
397,
260
],
[
400,
246,
429,
260
],
[
431,
246,
601,
261
],
[
604,
246,
656,
261
],
[
659,
246,
762,
261
],
[
765,
246,
846,
261
],
[
118,
280,
154,
295
],
[
159,
280,
213,
296
],
[
217,
280,
287,
296
],
[
291,
280,
322,
296
],
[
326,
280,
340,
296
],
[
343,
280,
370,
296
],
[
373,
280,
411,
296
],
[
415,
280,
447,
296
],
[
450,
280,
542,
296
],
[
545,
280,
567,
296
],
[
570,
280,
644,
296
],
[
647,
280,
775,
296
],
[
778,
280,
798,
296
],
[
801,
280,
872,
296
],
[
117,
296,
134,
312
],
[
137,
297,
195,
313
],
[
200,
297,
231,
313
],
[
234,
297,
317,
314
],
[
320,
298,
337,
314
],
[
341,
298,
377,
314
],
[
381,
298,
398,
314
],
[
401,
298,
447,
314
],
[
451,
298,
501,
314
],
[
504,
298,
524,
314
],
[
528,
298,
616,
314
],
[
619,
298,
712,
314
],
[
716,
298,
741,
314
],
[
744,
297,
818,
313
],
[
821,
297,
843,
313
],
[
846,
297,
872,
312
],
[
118,
315,
182,
331
],
[
187,
315,
262,
331
],
[
265,
315,
295,
331
],
[
298,
315,
381,
331
],
[
384,
315,
417,
331
],
[
420,
315,
450,
331
],
[
452,
315,
535,
331
],
[
538,
315,
555,
331
],
[
558,
315,
587,
331
],
[
590,
315,
627,
331
],
[
629,
315,
680,
331
],
[
682,
315,
759,
331
],
[
761,
315,
788,
331
],
[
790,
315,
849,
331
],
[
850,
315,
867,
330
],
[
117,
332,
143,
348
],
[
146,
332,
200,
348
],
[
202,
332,
252,
348
],
[
255,
332,
284,
348
],
[
287,
332,
365,
348
],
[
385,
332,
412,
348
],
[
416,
332,
452,
348
],
[
455,
332,
483,
348
],
[
487,
332,
547,
348
],
[
551,
332,
567,
348
],
[
570,
332,
631,
348
],
[
634,
332,
664,
348
],
[
668,
332,
710,
348
],
[
712,
332,
799,
348
],
[
802,
333,
870,
348
],
[
117,
351,
213,
366
],
[
217,
351,
242,
365
],
[
245,
351,
301,
365
],
[
304,
351,
366,
366
],
[
117,
385,
159,
400
],
[
162,
385,
174,
400
],
[
178,
385,
230,
400
],
[
233,
385,
252,
400
],
[
255,
385,
304,
400
],
[
307,
385,
364,
400
],
[
368,
385,
388,
400
],
[
391,
385,
417,
400
],
[
420,
385,
495,
401
],
[
498,
385,
601,
401
],
[
604,
385,
618,
401
],
[
621,
385,
700,
401
],
[
702,
386,
777,
400
],
[
779,
386,
814,
400
],
[
817,
386,
844,
400
],
[
847,
386,
871,
400
],
[
118,
404,
171,
417
],
[
174,
404,
192,
417
],
[
195,
404,
272,
417
],
[
275,
404,
294,
417
],
[
296,
404,
307,
417
],
[
310,
404,
375,
417
],
[
378,
404,
396,
417
],
[
400,
404,
451,
417
],
[
454,
404,
533,
417
],
[
536,
404,
566,
417
],
[
569,
404,
604,
417
],
[
607,
404,
639,
417
],
[
642,
404,
668,
417
],
[
671,
403,
745,
417
],
[
750,
403,
785,
417
],
[
788,
403,
816,
417
],
[
818,
403,
882,
417
],
[
118,
420,
154,
435
],
[
158,
420,
170,
435
],
[
175,
420,
264,
435
],
[
272,
420,
317,
435
],
[
320,
420,
362,
435
],
[
366,
420,
384,
435
],
[
387,
420,
437,
435
],
[
440,
420,
457,
435
],
[
460,
420,
492,
435
],
[
496,
420,
524,
435
],
[
527,
420,
574,
435
],
[
577,
420,
590,
435
],
[
594,
420,
668,
435
],
[
671,
420,
739,
435
],
[
741,
420,
777,
435
],
[
780,
420,
807,
435
],
[
810,
420,
831,
435
],
[
834,
420,
871,
435
],
[
118,
438,
135,
453
],
[
138,
438,
186,
453
],
[
190,
438,
284,
453
],
[
287,
438,
305,
453
],
[
309,
438,
319,
453
],
[
323,
438,
395,
453
],
[
398,
438,
434,
453
],
[
441,
438,
497,
453
],
[
501,
438,
561,
453
],
[
565,
438,
581,
453
],
[
585,
438,
611,
453
],
[
614,
438,
672,
453
],
[
676,
438,
692,
453
],
[
697,
438,
735,
453
],
[
738,
437,
791,
453
],
[
795,
437,
858,
453
],
[
118,
455,
216,
470
],
[
219,
456,
262,
470
],
[
265,
456,
298,
470
],
[
302,
456,
390,
471
],
[
392,
456,
461,
471
],
[
464,
456,
581,
471
],
[
584,
456,
657,
471
],
[
660,
456,
677,
470
],
[
680,
455,
759,
470
],
[
762,
455,
791,
470
],
[
794,
455,
820,
470
],
[
823,
455,
855,
470
],
[
118,
472,
166,
487
],
[
169,
472,
207,
487
],
[
210,
472,
262,
487
],
[
265,
472,
287,
487
],
[
290,
472,
365,
488
],
[
368,
472,
399,
488
],
[
402,
472,
485,
488
],
[
488,
472,
507,
488
],
[
510,
472,
545,
488
],
[
549,
472,
567,
488
],
[
571,
472,
595,
488
],
[
599,
472,
645,
488
],
[
649,
472,
666,
488
],
[
670,
472,
679,
488
],
[
682,
472,
715,
488
],
[
718,
472,
805,
488
],
[
808,
472,
822,
488
],
[
825,
472,
881,
487
],
[
118,
490,
152,
506
],
[
155,
489,
189,
506
],
[
193,
489,
217,
506
],
[
220,
489,
285,
506
],
[
290,
489,
324,
506
],
[
328,
489,
346,
506
],
[
350,
489,
358,
506
],
[
362,
489,
436,
506
],
[
440,
489,
468,
506
],
[
471,
489,
537,
506
],
[
541,
489,
600,
506
],
[
604,
489,
622,
506
],
[
626,
490,
697,
506
],
[
701,
490,
717,
506
],
[
721,
490,
781,
506
],
[
785,
490,
850,
506
],
[
118,
507,
201,
522
],
[
204,
507,
257,
522
],
[
261,
507,
328,
522
],
[
332,
508,
350,
523
],
[
353,
508,
445,
523
],
[
449,
508,
501,
523
],
[
504,
507,
601,
523
],
[
604,
507,
649,
523
],
[
652,
507,
693,
523
],
[
697,
507,
764,
523
],
[
767,
507,
827,
522
],
[
830,
506,
852,
522
],
[
118,
525,
188,
540
],
[
192,
525,
228,
540
],
[
231,
525,
252,
540
],
[
255,
525,
291,
540
],
[
294,
524,
352,
540
],
[
355,
524,
381,
540
],
[
384,
524,
461,
540
],
[
465,
524,
554,
540
],
[
557,
524,
575,
540
],
[
578,
524,
588,
540
],
[
591,
524,
698,
540
],
[
701,
525,
718,
540
],
[
722,
525,
804,
541
],
[
807,
525,
867,
541
],
[
870,
525,
885,
541
],
[
120,
542,
182,
557
],
[
186,
542,
202,
557
],
[
206,
542,
292,
557
],
[
296,
542,
314,
557
],
[
317,
542,
355,
557
],
[
359,
542,
451,
557
],
[
454,
542,
532,
558
],
[
535,
542,
585,
558
],
[
588,
542,
614,
558
],
[
617,
542,
679,
558
],
[
682,
542,
739,
558
],
[
119,
576,
180,
592
],
[
184,
576,
284,
592
],
[
288,
577,
305,
592
],
[
309,
577,
358,
592
],
[
362,
577,
391,
593
],
[
395,
577,
469,
593
],
[
472,
577,
562,
592
],
[
567,
577,
582,
592
],
[
586,
577,
659,
592
],
[
662,
576,
684,
592
],
[
688,
576,
714,
592
],
[
718,
576,
834,
592
],
[
119,
593,
199,
610
],
[
202,
594,
230,
610
],
[
234,
594,
289,
610
],
[
293,
594,
321,
610
],
[
324,
594,
350,
610
],
[
353,
594,
414,
610
],
[
418,
594,
471,
610
],
[
475,
594,
559,
610
],
[
563,
594,
581,
610
],
[
585,
594,
645,
610
],
[
650,
594,
669,
609
],
[
672,
594,
692,
609
],
[
696,
593,
755,
609
],
[
759,
593,
799,
609
],
[
117,
613,
203,
626
],
[
207,
613,
312,
627
],
[
314,
613,
342,
627
],
[
346,
613,
367,
627
],
[
369,
612,
438,
627
],
[
441,
612,
462,
627
],
[
467,
612,
529,
627
],
[
532,
612,
603,
627
],
[
606,
612,
647,
627
],
[
650,
612,
675,
627
],
[
679,
612,
715,
627
],
[
718,
612,
728,
627
],
[
732,
612,
758,
627
],
[
767,
612,
836,
627
],
[
839,
612,
880,
627
],
[
117,
629,
204,
643
],
[
207,
630,
290,
643
],
[
294,
630,
310,
643
],
[
313,
630,
430,
644
],
[
432,
630,
497,
644
],
[
500,
630,
527,
644
],
[
530,
630,
570,
644
],
[
573,
630,
632,
644
],
[
636,
630,
654,
644
],
[
657,
629,
706,
644
],
[
710,
629,
724,
644
],
[
727,
629,
745,
644
],
[
750,
629,
809,
644
],
[
117,
645,
217,
662
],
[
220,
646,
237,
661
],
[
240,
646,
267,
661
],
[
271,
646,
318,
661
],
[
322,
646,
350,
661
],
[
354,
646,
394,
661
],
[
398,
646,
442,
661
],
[
446,
646,
471,
661
],
[
475,
646,
514,
661
],
[
518,
646,
537,
661
],
[
540,
646,
595,
661
],
[
118,
681,
191,
697
],
[
194,
682,
224,
696
],
[
228,
682,
254,
696
],
[
258,
682,
350,
696
],
[
353,
682,
370,
696
],
[
374,
682,
432,
696
],
[
436,
682,
454,
696
],
[
458,
682,
501,
696
],
[
504,
682,
590,
696
],
[
593,
682,
690,
696
],
[
692,
682,
718,
696
],
[
721,
682,
747,
696
],
[
750,
681,
795,
696
],
[
798,
681,
817,
696
],
[
820,
681,
830,
696
],
[
833,
681,
864,
696
],
[
120,
698,
199,
714
],
[
203,
698,
220,
714
],
[
224,
698,
275,
714
],
[
278,
698,
372,
714
],
[
375,
698,
387,
714
],
[
390,
698,
424,
714
],
[
427,
698,
491,
714
],
[
495,
698,
514,
714
],
[
519,
698,
537,
714
],
[
540,
698,
568,
714
],
[
572,
698,
610,
714
],
[
614,
698,
672,
714
],
[
675,
699,
696,
714
],
[
700,
699,
786,
714
],
[
790,
699,
849,
715
],
[
852,
699,
872,
715
],
[
117,
716,
158,
731
],
[
162,
716,
247,
731
],
[
251,
717,
347,
732
],
[
351,
717,
382,
732
],
[
386,
717,
441,
732
],
[
445,
717,
470,
732
],
[
474,
717,
544,
732
],
[
547,
717,
594,
732
],
[
598,
716,
627,
732
],
[
630,
716,
720,
732
],
[
722,
716,
741,
731
],
[
744,
715,
845,
731
],
[
117,
734,
164,
748
],
[
167,
734,
194,
748
],
[
196,
733,
234,
749
],
[
240,
733,
271,
749
],
[
275,
733,
323,
749
],
[
329,
733,
390,
749
],
[
394,
733,
425,
749
],
[
439,
733,
501,
749
],
[
504,
733,
544,
749
],
[
548,
733,
615,
749
],
[
618,
733,
630,
749
],
[
632,
733,
687,
749
],
[
690,
734,
767,
749
],
[
770,
734,
808,
748
],
[
810,
734,
828,
748
],
[
831,
735,
864,
748
],
[
116,
751,
190,
768
],
[
194,
751,
216,
767
],
[
219,
751,
256,
767
],
[
260,
751,
295,
767
],
[
298,
751,
325,
767
],
[
329,
751,
370,
767
],
[
373,
751,
485,
767
],
[
488,
751,
551,
767
],
[
119,
786,
167,
801
],
[
170,
786,
195,
801
],
[
198,
786,
272,
801
],
[
275,
786,
309,
801
],
[
312,
786,
340,
801
],
[
342,
786,
420,
801
],
[
423,
786,
489,
801
],
[
492,
786,
514,
801
],
[
517,
786,
579,
801
],
[
582,
786,
647,
801
],
[
650,
786,
661,
801
],
[
665,
786,
681,
801
],
[
684,
786,
724,
801
],
[
728,
786,
797,
800
],
[
801,
786,
830,
800
],
[
118,
803,
201,
817
],
[
208,
804,
290,
818
],
[
294,
804,
318,
818
],
[
321,
804,
363,
818
],
[
367,
804,
451,
819
],
[
455,
804,
552,
819
],
[
555,
804,
571,
819
],
[
575,
804,
648,
819
],
[
652,
804,
669,
819
],
[
672,
804,
715,
819
],
[
718,
804,
748,
819
],
[
752,
804,
829,
819
],
[
832,
803,
845,
818
],
[
118,
834,
129,
850
],
[
132,
835,
148,
850
],
[
151,
836,
181,
851
],
[
185,
838,
217,
852
],
[
221,
839,
234,
852
],
[
238,
839,
274,
852
],
[
132,
852,
231,
865
],
[
234,
853,
268,
865
],
[
271,
853,
342,
866
],
[
345,
854,
432,
866
],
[
435,
854,
455,
866
],
[
458,
854,
507,
866
],
[
510,
854,
569,
866
],
[
572,
854,
587,
866
],
[
590,
854,
638,
866
],
[
641,
854,
665,
866
],
[
668,
854,
699,
866
],
[
702,
854,
721,
866
],
[
724,
854,
756,
866
],
[
759,
854,
777,
866
],
[
780,
853,
811,
866
],
[
814,
853,
871,
866
],
[
118,
868,
184,
880
],
[
186,
868,
227,
880
],
[
228,
868,
266,
880
],
[
268,
868,
315,
880
],
[
317,
868,
392,
881
],
[
395,
868,
415,
881
],
[
417,
868,
439,
881
],
[
441,
868,
477,
881
],
[
479,
868,
551,
881
],
[
553,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
695,
880
],
[
697,
868,
707,
880
],
[
709,
868,
767,
880
],
[
770,
868,
831,
880
],
[
833,
868,
868,
880
],
[
119,
883,
146,
895
],
[
148,
883,
164,
895
],
[
166,
883,
183,
895
],
[
185,
883,
200,
895
],
[
203,
883,
298,
896
],
[
300,
884,
345,
896
],
[
347,
884,
411,
896
],
[
414,
884,
428,
896
],
[
430,
884,
512,
896
],
[
514,
884,
541,
896
],
[
543,
884,
564,
896
],
[
567,
884,
618,
896
],
[
621,
883,
636,
896
],
[
638,
883,
711,
896
],
[
714,
883,
778,
895
],
[
780,
882,
840,
895
],
[
842,
882,
865,
895
],
[
117,
897,
159,
910
],
[
163,
897,
240,
910
],
[
242,
897,
302,
910
],
[
305,
897,
312,
910
],
[
315,
897,
383,
910
],
[
386,
897,
407,
910
],
[
410,
897,
455,
910
],
[
458,
897,
499,
910
],
[
502,
897,
568,
910
],
[
821,
941,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
what does APA stands for?
|
Administrative Procedure Act
|
747
|
[
"review",
"reliability",
"is",
"reduced",
"and",
"it",
"cannot",
"be",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"systematic....It",
"is",
"unhelpful",
"to",
"classify",
"\"narrative",
"reviews\"",
"as",
"systematic",
"reviews...",
"EPA",
"states",
"that",
"it",
"has",
"included",
"systematic",
"reviews",
"in",
"the",
"past;",
"however,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"what",
"exactly",
"it",
"has",
"done",
"and",
"where",
"these",
"reviews",
"can",
"be",
"found.\"",
"The",
"last",
"completed",
"draft",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"was",
"for",
"1-bromopropane.",
"The",
"executive",
"summary",
"of",
"the",
"peer",
"review",
"report",
"of",
"this",
"draft",
"evaluation,",
"dated",
"August",
"22,",
"2016,",
"states:",
"Committee",
"members",
"agreed",
"that",
"the",
"1-BP",
"risk",
"assessment",
"(and",
"other",
"TSCA",
"chemical",
"assessments",
"to",
"be",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"future)",
"would",
"benefit",
"by",
"adoption",
"of",
"systematic",
"review",
"practices",
"to",
"increase",
"the",
"transparency",
"of",
"how",
"studies",
"were",
"selected",
"and",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"example,",
"the",
"Committee",
"recommended",
"that",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"explicitly",
"stated",
"what",
"criteria",
"were",
"used",
"to",
"determine",
"\"the",
"monitoring",
"was",
"adequate",
"and",
"of",
"acceptable",
"quality\"",
"(risk",
"assessment",
"document,",
"page",
"44).",
"The",
"Committee",
"also",
"noted",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"useful",
"to",
"reference",
"studies",
"that",
"were",
"evaluated",
"but",
"did",
"not",
"meet",
"baseline",
"criteria",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"exposure",
"estimates.",
"30",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"peer",
"review",
"committee",
"could",
"not",
"determine",
"\"what",
"exact",
"methodology",
"was",
"used",
"to",
"systematically",
"rate,",
"rank,",
"and",
"select",
"studies",
"to",
"inform",
"sections",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"assessment.\"",
"Peer",
"reviewers",
"also",
"could",
"not",
"find",
"any",
"ranking",
"system",
"developed",
"for",
"study",
"quality.",
"It",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"systematic",
"review",
"mean",
"the",
"same",
"thing",
"to",
"all",
"engaged",
"stakeholders,",
"including",
"Agency",
"staff",
"and",
"peer",
"reviewers.",
"ACC",
"cannot",
"envision",
"any",
"situation",
"where",
"a",
"definition",
"of",
"systematic",
"review",
"would",
"unduly",
"restrict",
"the",
"specific",
"science",
"that",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"conduct",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"A",
"systematic",
"review",
"process",
"will",
"allow",
"EPA",
"to",
"be",
"flexible",
"and",
"to",
"adapt",
"with",
"changing",
"science,",
"assuming",
"that",
"the",
"new",
"science",
"meets",
"the",
"necessary",
"high",
"quality",
"standards",
"that",
"are",
"required",
"by",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"Including",
"a",
"regulatory",
"definition",
"for",
"systematic",
"review",
"is",
"fully",
"consistent",
"with",
"EPA's",
"policy",
"objectives.\"As",
"such,",
"ACC",
"recommends",
"the",
"following",
"definition",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"final",
"rule:",
"Systematic",
"review",
"means",
"that",
"the",
"evidence",
"has",
"been",
"evaluated",
"using",
"a",
"predefined,",
"transparent,",
"and",
"reproducible",
"process",
"to",
"identify,",
"appraise,",
"and",
"synthesize",
"the",
"available",
"body",
"of",
"evidence",
"to",
"answer",
"a",
"specific",
"question.",
"To",
"ensure",
"transparency,",
"systematic",
"reviews",
"should",
"include",
"a",
"Protocol",
"that",
"describes",
"the",
"specific",
"question(s)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"answered,",
"the",
"literature",
"search",
"strategy",
"and",
"plans",
"for",
"data",
"collection,",
"the",
"methods",
"for",
"evaluating",
"the",
"quality",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"the",
"data",
"48",
"Id.",
"at",
"4.",
"19",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7572.",
"50",
"See",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Advisory",
"Committee",
"Minutes",
"No.",
"2016-02,",
"at",
"1.",
"See",
"id.",
"at",
"41.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"42.",
"3",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7567",
"(\"Due",
"to",
"the",
"rapid",
"advancement",
"of",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"and",
"the",
"science",
"and",
"technology",
"that",
"inform",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"this",
"proposed",
"rule",
"seeks",
"to",
"balance",
"the",
"need",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"procedures",
"to",
"be",
"transparent,",
"without",
"unduly",
"restricting",
"the",
"specific",
"science",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"conduct",
"the",
"evaluations,",
"allowing",
"the",
"Agency",
"flexibility",
"to",
"adapt",
"and",
"keep",
"current",
"with",
"changing",
"science",
"as",
"it",
"conducts",
"TSCA",
"evaluations",
"into",
"the",
"future.\")",
"20/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
176,
93,
230,
109
],
[
233,
93,
311,
110
],
[
314,
93,
330,
110
],
[
333,
93,
398,
110
],
[
401,
93,
430,
110
],
[
433,
93,
445,
110
],
[
449,
93,
502,
110
],
[
507,
93,
527,
110
],
[
530,
93,
593,
110
],
[
597,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
635,
110
],
[
640,
93,
760,
110
],
[
764,
93,
777,
109
],
[
781,
93,
858,
109
],
[
862,
93,
881,
108
],
[
177,
110,
237,
127
],
[
240,
111,
321,
127
],
[
324,
111,
395,
127
],
[
399,
111,
417,
127
],
[
421,
111,
505,
127
],
[
508,
110,
594,
126
],
[
117,
145,
154,
160
],
[
159,
145,
204,
160
],
[
207,
145,
238,
160
],
[
241,
145,
254,
160
],
[
257,
145,
285,
160
],
[
288,
145,
358,
161
],
[
362,
146,
445,
161
],
[
449,
146,
511,
161
],
[
515,
146,
531,
161
],
[
535,
146,
561,
161
],
[
564,
146,
602,
161
],
[
605,
146,
680,
161
],
[
683,
145,
695,
160
],
[
699,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
745,
160
],
[
748,
145,
788,
160
],
[
791,
145,
830,
160
],
[
117,
164,
175,
179
],
[
178,
164,
191,
179
],
[
194,
164,
226,
179
],
[
229,
164,
265,
179
],
[
268,
164,
299,
179
],
[
302,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
163,
395,
179
],
[
399,
163,
462,
179
],
[
466,
163,
493,
179
],
[
497,
163,
518,
179
],
[
522,
163,
585,
179
],
[
597,
163,
627,
178
],
[
631,
162,
660,
178
],
[
663,
162,
749,
178
],
[
752,
162,
790,
178
],
[
793,
162,
842,
178
],
[
119,
180,
163,
195
],
[
167,
180,
203,
196
],
[
207,
181,
238,
196
],
[
241,
181,
324,
196
],
[
328,
182,
360,
196
],
[
363,
182,
389,
196
],
[
392,
182,
531,
196
],
[
535,
182,
563,
196
],
[
567,
182,
644,
196
],
[
648,
181,
722,
196
],
[
726,
181,
742,
196
],
[
747,
181,
771,
196
],
[
775,
181,
810,
196
],
[
814,
180,
868,
196
],
[
118,
198,
165,
214
],
[
170,
198,
185,
214
],
[
190,
198,
222,
214
],
[
226,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
197,
357,
213
],
[
361,
197,
402,
213
],
[
406,
197,
462,
213
],
[
467,
198,
492,
214
],
[
495,
198,
542,
214
],
[
545,
198,
600,
214
],
[
179,
234,
265,
247
],
[
268,
234,
342,
248
],
[
345,
234,
400,
248
],
[
402,
234,
434,
248
],
[
437,
234,
464,
248
],
[
468,
234,
507,
248
],
[
511,
234,
542,
248
],
[
546,
233,
635,
248
],
[
638,
233,
674,
248
],
[
677,
233,
722,
248
],
[
725,
233,
771,
248
],
[
778,
232,
853,
247
],
[
177,
251,
272,
265
],
[
275,
251,
292,
265
],
[
295,
251,
315,
265
],
[
318,
250,
397,
265
],
[
400,
250,
416,
265
],
[
419,
250,
445,
265
],
[
448,
250,
505,
265
],
[
508,
250,
558,
265
],
[
561,
250,
617,
265
],
[
620,
250,
642,
265
],
[
645,
250,
715,
265
],
[
718,
250,
737,
265
],
[
740,
250,
824,
265
],
[
827,
250,
878,
265
],
[
175,
269,
247,
284
],
[
250,
269,
267,
284
],
[
270,
269,
336,
284
],
[
339,
269,
365,
284
],
[
369,
269,
471,
284
],
[
474,
268,
492,
284
],
[
495,
268,
529,
284
],
[
535,
268,
591,
284
],
[
594,
268,
633,
284
],
[
637,
267,
701,
284
],
[
705,
267,
734,
283
],
[
738,
267,
820,
283
],
[
824,
266,
852,
283
],
[
177,
286,
249,
300
],
[
252,
286,
278,
300
],
[
281,
286,
369,
300
],
[
372,
286,
485,
300
],
[
488,
286,
520,
300
],
[
524,
286,
537,
300
],
[
540,
286,
594,
300
],
[
597,
285,
617,
300
],
[
620,
285,
695,
300
],
[
698,
285,
747,
300
],
[
750,
285,
789,
300
],
[
792,
285,
845,
300
],
[
177,
302,
214,
318
],
[
218,
302,
256,
318
],
[
260,
302,
280,
318
],
[
283,
302,
360,
318
],
[
364,
303,
398,
318
],
[
401,
302,
490,
318
],
[
494,
302,
527,
318
],
[
530,
302,
601,
318
],
[
604,
302,
634,
318
],
[
638,
302,
655,
318
],
[
659,
302,
742,
318
],
[
745,
301,
811,
318
],
[
814,
301,
852,
318
],
[
177,
320,
268,
335
],
[
271,
320,
352,
336
],
[
355,
320,
395,
336
],
[
398,
320,
431,
336
],
[
434,
320,
466,
336
],
[
469,
320,
558,
336
],
[
561,
320,
593,
336
],
[
597,
319,
642,
336
],
[
645,
319,
677,
336
],
[
680,
319,
693,
336
],
[
696,
319,
745,
336
],
[
748,
319,
771,
336
],
[
774,
319,
823,
336
],
[
826,
319,
843,
335
],
[
175,
338,
251,
352
],
[
254,
338,
309,
353
],
[
312,
338,
345,
353
],
[
348,
339,
387,
353
],
[
390,
339,
465,
353
],
[
468,
339,
497,
353
],
[
500,
339,
521,
353
],
[
524,
339,
551,
353
],
[
554,
339,
592,
353
],
[
595,
339,
659,
353
],
[
662,
338,
716,
353
],
[
719,
338,
735,
353
],
[
738,
338,
787,
353
],
[
795,
338,
819,
352
],
[
176,
355,
246,
369
],
[
249,
353,
324,
369
],
[
327,
352,
344,
366
],
[
117,
391,
135,
405
],
[
138,
391,
210,
405
],
[
212,
391,
238,
405
],
[
241,
391,
277,
405
],
[
280,
391,
332,
405
],
[
338,
391,
423,
405
],
[
427,
391,
471,
405
],
[
475,
391,
504,
405
],
[
508,
391,
584,
405
],
[
587,
391,
637,
405
],
[
640,
391,
683,
405
],
[
686,
390,
792,
405
],
[
795,
390,
826,
405
],
[
830,
390,
866,
405
],
[
117,
407,
135,
422
],
[
138,
407,
250,
422
],
[
254,
408,
289,
422
],
[
293,
408,
336,
422
],
[
340,
408,
369,
422
],
[
372,
408,
418,
422
],
[
422,
408,
477,
422
],
[
481,
408,
498,
422
],
[
501,
408,
552,
422
],
[
559,
407,
625,
422
],
[
628,
407,
645,
422
],
[
649,
407,
674,
422
],
[
677,
407,
710,
422
],
[
712,
406,
816,
422
],
[
831,
406,
869,
421
],
[
117,
424,
195,
440
],
[
199,
425,
231,
440
],
[
234,
425,
279,
440
],
[
282,
425,
311,
440
],
[
314,
425,
347,
440
],
[
351,
425,
379,
440
],
[
382,
425,
444,
440
],
[
448,
425,
500,
440
],
[
511,
425,
590,
440
],
[
593,
424,
617,
440
],
[
621,
424,
665,
440
],
[
668,
424,
736,
440
],
[
118,
460,
130,
474
],
[
134,
460,
148,
474
],
[
152,
460,
222,
474
],
[
226,
460,
304,
474
],
[
308,
460,
340,
474
],
[
343,
460,
426,
474
],
[
430,
460,
482,
475
],
[
488,
460,
532,
475
],
[
535,
460,
562,
475
],
[
565,
460,
606,
475
],
[
610,
460,
651,
475
],
[
655,
460,
672,
475
],
[
677,
460,
697,
475
],
[
700,
460,
767,
475
],
[
771,
460,
877,
475
],
[
118,
476,
194,
492
],
[
197,
476,
259,
493
],
[
262,
477,
298,
493
],
[
302,
477,
331,
493
],
[
335,
477,
370,
493
],
[
373,
477,
457,
493
],
[
461,
477,
502,
493
],
[
505,
477,
559,
492
],
[
563,
477,
631,
492
],
[
635,
477,
664,
492
],
[
668,
477,
737,
492
],
[
740,
477,
790,
492
],
[
794,
477,
805,
492
],
[
808,
476,
885,
491
],
[
118,
495,
136,
509
],
[
139,
495,
222,
510
],
[
225,
495,
278,
510
],
[
284,
495,
336,
510
],
[
339,
495,
395,
510
],
[
398,
495,
454,
510
],
[
457,
495,
484,
510
],
[
487,
495,
550,
510
],
[
553,
495,
611,
510
],
[
614,
495,
648,
510
],
[
650,
495,
678,
510
],
[
681,
495,
702,
510
],
[
705,
495,
743,
510
],
[
745,
495,
763,
510
],
[
766,
495,
831,
510
],
[
834,
495,
843,
509
],
[
845,
495,
874,
509
],
[
117,
512,
206,
527
],
[
209,
512,
222,
527
],
[
228,
512,
311,
527
],
[
315,
512,
367,
527
],
[
373,
512,
434,
527
],
[
438,
512,
469,
527
],
[
473,
512,
517,
527
],
[
522,
512,
558,
527
],
[
564,
512,
580,
527
],
[
583,
512,
604,
527
],
[
607,
512,
670,
527
],
[
672,
512,
702,
526
],
[
705,
512,
723,
526
],
[
726,
512,
770,
526
],
[
773,
512,
808,
526
],
[
119,
529,
190,
545
],
[
194,
529,
258,
545
],
[
262,
530,
336,
545
],
[
340,
530,
370,
545
],
[
374,
530,
398,
545
],
[
402,
530,
437,
545
],
[
442,
530,
500,
545
],
[
503,
530,
551,
545
],
[
555,
530,
580,
545
],
[
583,
529,
660,
545
],
[
664,
529,
701,
545
],
[
704,
529,
761,
545
],
[
764,
528,
840,
545
],
[
843,
528,
878,
545
],
[
118,
547,
141,
562
],
[
144,
547,
212,
562
],
[
215,
547,
237,
562
],
[
241,
547,
265,
562
],
[
269,
547,
327,
562
],
[
330,
547,
407,
563
],
[
411,
547,
420,
563
],
[
424,
547,
508,
563
],
[
513,
547,
588,
563
],
[
592,
547,
615,
563
],
[
619,
547,
702,
563
],
[
706,
547,
758,
562
],
[
765,
547,
780,
562
],
[
783,
547,
824,
562
],
[
117,
565,
198,
579
],
[
201,
565,
238,
579
],
[
241,
565,
293,
580
],
[
297,
564,
347,
580
],
[
351,
564,
477,
580
],
[
480,
564,
524,
580
],
[
527,
564,
566,
580
],
[
571,
564,
673,
580
],
[
677,
564,
703,
580
],
[
706,
564,
785,
580
],
[
791,
564,
865,
580
],
[
116,
580,
137,
595
],
[
141,
580,
208,
595
],
[
212,
581,
229,
595
],
[
233,
581,
259,
595
],
[
262,
581,
298,
595
],
[
302,
581,
341,
595
],
[
178,
617,
262,
631
],
[
264,
617,
317,
631
],
[
322,
618,
375,
631
],
[
378,
618,
411,
631
],
[
414,
618,
440,
631
],
[
443,
618,
515,
632
],
[
518,
618,
547,
632
],
[
550,
618,
590,
632
],
[
592,
617,
670,
632
],
[
673,
617,
718,
632
],
[
721,
617,
731,
632
],
[
734,
616,
824,
632
],
[
178,
634,
274,
649
],
[
277,
634,
310,
649
],
[
314,
634,
418,
650
],
[
422,
634,
487,
650
],
[
491,
634,
510,
650
],
[
515,
634,
588,
650
],
[
591,
634,
668,
650
],
[
672,
634,
704,
650
],
[
708,
634,
795,
650
],
[
799,
634,
824,
649
],
[
177,
651,
248,
666
],
[
252,
651,
294,
667
],
[
298,
651,
316,
667
],
[
320,
652,
391,
667
],
[
395,
652,
412,
667
],
[
415,
652,
473,
667
],
[
477,
652,
488,
667
],
[
492,
652,
555,
667
],
[
558,
652,
633,
667
],
[
637,
652,
658,
667
],
[
662,
652,
714,
667
],
[
718,
652,
827,
667
],
[
177,
670,
263,
684
],
[
272,
669,
339,
684
],
[
349,
669,
406,
684
],
[
415,
669,
477,
684
],
[
488,
669,
501,
684
],
[
512,
669,
585,
684
],
[
592,
669,
628,
684
],
[
640,
669,
714,
685
],
[
724,
669,
751,
685
],
[
762,
669,
828,
685
],
[
176,
686,
265,
701
],
[
268,
686,
302,
701
],
[
305,
686,
337,
701
],
[
340,
686,
362,
701
],
[
366,
686,
445,
702
],
[
449,
686,
475,
702
],
[
478,
686,
553,
702
],
[
557,
686,
610,
702
],
[
613,
686,
677,
702
],
[
681,
686,
711,
702
],
[
714,
686,
760,
702
],
[
762,
686,
791,
702
],
[
795,
686,
825,
702
],
[
177,
703,
265,
719
],
[
268,
703,
296,
719
],
[
302,
703,
374,
719
],
[
380,
703,
409,
720
],
[
414,
703,
498,
720
],
[
505,
703,
534,
720
],
[
541,
703,
599,
720
],
[
606,
703,
638,
720
],
[
644,
703,
723,
720
],
[
730,
703,
752,
720
],
[
757,
702,
785,
720
],
[
795,
702,
828,
719
],
[
117,
763,
129,
778
],
[
132,
764,
151,
778
],
[
154,
765,
168,
778
],
[
171,
765,
182,
778
],
[
118,
777,
128,
792
],
[
132,
777,
157,
792
],
[
161,
778,
177,
793
],
[
180,
779,
210,
793
],
[
213,
780,
244,
794
],
[
248,
780,
262,
794
],
[
265,
780,
302,
794
],
[
117,
793,
128,
807
],
[
132,
793,
157,
807
],
[
160,
794,
224,
808
],
[
228,
795,
270,
808
],
[
273,
795,
334,
808
],
[
337,
795,
410,
808
],
[
413,
795,
468,
808
],
[
471,
795,
498,
808
],
[
501,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
577,
808
],
[
580,
794,
591,
808
],
[
133,
807,
155,
821
],
[
159,
808,
178,
822
],
[
181,
809,
194,
822
],
[
197,
809,
218,
822
],
[
117,
823,
128,
836
],
[
131,
823,
151,
836
],
[
155,
824,
167,
836
],
[
170,
823,
190,
836
],
[
122,
836,
129,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
160,
837,
177,
851
],
[
180,
837,
208,
851
],
[
212,
838,
244,
851
],
[
247,
838,
261,
852
],
[
264,
838,
296,
852
],
[
300,
839,
340,
852
],
[
344,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
381,
852
],
[
385,
840,
420,
853
],
[
423,
840,
510,
853
],
[
513,
840,
527,
853
],
[
531,
840,
552,
853
],
[
555,
840,
604,
853
],
[
608,
840,
621,
853
],
[
624,
840,
651,
853
],
[
654,
839,
723,
853
],
[
726,
839,
750,
852
],
[
753,
839,
775,
852
],
[
778,
838,
826,
852
],
[
829,
838,
855,
851
],
[
119,
854,
191,
866
],
[
194,
854,
220,
866
],
[
222,
854,
265,
866
],
[
271,
854,
297,
866
],
[
300,
854,
373,
867
],
[
376,
854,
401,
867
],
[
404,
854,
464,
867
],
[
467,
854,
494,
867
],
[
498,
854,
534,
867
],
[
537,
854,
550,
867
],
[
554,
854,
604,
867
],
[
607,
854,
628,
867
],
[
631,
853,
664,
867
],
[
667,
853,
686,
867
],
[
690,
853,
711,
867
],
[
714,
853,
740,
866
],
[
743,
853,
813,
866
],
[
117,
868,
190,
881
],
[
193,
868,
207,
881
],
[
210,
868,
227,
881
],
[
229,
868,
308,
881
],
[
310,
868,
361,
880
],
[
363,
868,
410,
880
],
[
412,
868,
481,
880
],
[
484,
868,
505,
880
],
[
508,
868,
561,
880
],
[
562,
868,
612,
880
],
[
614,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
670,
880
],
[
672,
868,
690,
880
],
[
691,
868,
725,
881
],
[
727,
868,
741,
881
],
[
743,
868,
797,
881
],
[
798,
868,
824,
881
],
[
117,
883,
197,
896
],
[
200,
883,
258,
896
],
[
261,
883,
283,
896
],
[
285,
883,
338,
896
],
[
340,
883,
406,
896
],
[
408,
884,
422,
896
],
[
425,
883,
462,
896
],
[
465,
883,
489,
896
],
[
491,
883,
525,
896
],
[
528,
883,
576,
896
],
[
578,
883,
608,
896
],
[
611,
883,
672,
896
],
[
675,
883,
725,
896
],
[
727,
883,
742,
895
],
[
744,
883,
755,
895
],
[
758,
882,
820,
895
],
[
821,
882,
862,
895
],
[
118,
897,
193,
911
],
[
196,
897,
222,
909
],
[
225,
897,
247,
909
],
[
250,
897,
307,
910
],
[
820,
940,
883,
955
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
Which component is used for the last completed draft TSCA Workplan RIsk Evaluation?
|
1-bromopropane
|
743
|
[
"make",
"little",
"sense",
"to",
"continue",
"evaluating",
"that",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"Otherwise,",
"EPA's",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"would",
"be",
"of",
"suspect",
"quality,",
"integrity,",
"and",
"reliability.",
"A",
"better",
"approach",
"would",
"be",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"that",
"after",
"a",
"scope",
"is",
"published,",
"EPA",
"retains",
"discretion",
"to",
"modify",
"it",
"upon",
"a",
"showing",
"of",
"substantial",
"need",
"or",
"changed",
"circumstances,",
"or",
"is",
"otherwise",
"warranted",
"because",
"the",
"addition",
"or",
"removal",
"of",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"properly",
"substantiated,",
"will",
"significantly",
"affect",
"the",
"conduct",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"J.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Remove",
"the",
"Comment-or-Waive",
"(Issue",
"Exhaustion)",
"Proposal.",
"EPA",
"further",
"proposes",
"that",
"it",
"can",
"keep",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"schedule,",
"notwithstanding",
"its",
"proposal",
"to",
"include",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"every",
"scope,",
"by",
"\"providing",
"opportunity",
"for",
"comment",
"on",
"the",
"scoping",
"document",
"and",
"specifying",
"that",
"any",
"objections",
"to",
"the",
"draft",
"scope",
"document",
"are",
"waived",
"if",
"not",
"raised",
"during",
"this",
"process.\"",
"We",
"urge",
"the",
"Agency",
"to",
"remove",
"this",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"(waiver)",
"requirement",
"for",
"several",
"reasons.",
"First,",
"it",
"places",
"an",
"unfair",
"burden",
"on",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"A",
"particular",
"company",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"aware,",
"or",
"otherwise",
"in",
"a",
"position",
"to",
"verify,",
"particular",
"end",
"uses",
"that",
"the",
"company",
"does",
"not",
"support",
"(i.e.,",
"a",
"downstream",
"value",
"chain",
"to",
"which",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"sell).",
"A",
"company",
"likewise",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"verify",
"occurrences",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"from",
"natural",
"sources",
"or",
"the",
"actions",
"of",
"third",
"parties",
"through",
"combustion,",
"spills",
"and",
"discharges,",
"disposal,",
"manufacturing",
"practices",
"or",
"incidents,",
"and",
"the",
"like.",
"When",
"EPA",
"insists",
"on",
"including",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"it",
"moves",
"well",
"past",
"the",
"\"major\"",
"uses",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"and",
"\"major\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"to",
"include",
"fleeting,",
"incidental,",
"minor,",
"isolated,",
"or",
"exceptional",
"cases.",
"Information",
"about",
"these",
"\"minor\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"may",
"be",
"well",
"outside",
"the",
"first-hand",
"knowledge",
"of",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor,",
"making",
"it",
"difficult",
"or",
"impossible",
"to",
"offer",
"meaningful",
"comment",
"during",
"the",
"scoping",
"period.",
"Second,",
"participation",
"in",
"notice",
"and",
"comment",
"rulemaking",
"is",
"governed",
"by",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act",
"(APA)",
"and",
"the",
"judicial",
"review",
"provisions",
"of",
"Section",
"19",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"Issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"can",
"be",
"imposed",
"by",
"statute.",
"Notably,",
"there",
"are",
"only",
"a",
"few",
"statutory",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"provisions",
"in",
"environmental",
"statutes,",
"the",
"most",
"notable",
"of",
"which",
"is",
"in",
"Section",
"307(d)(7)(b)",
"of",
"the",
"Clean",
"Air",
"Act.",
"There",
"are",
"none",
"in",
"TSCA.",
"Congress",
"had",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"for",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"in",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"-",
"and",
"declined",
"to",
"do",
"so.",
"EPA",
"cannot,",
"by",
"regulation,",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"that",
"trumps",
"the",
"statutory",
"rights",
"and",
"obligations",
"of",
"stakeholders",
"under",
"the",
"APA",
"and",
"TSCA",
"Section",
"19.",
"Indeed,",
"ACC",
"believes",
"a",
"waiver",
"provision",
"such",
"as",
"that",
"proposed",
"by",
"EPA",
"may",
"not",
"meet",
"Constitutional",
"muster.",
"Third,",
"the",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"rationally",
"advance",
"its",
"claimed",
"purpose",
"-",
"to",
"meet",
"statutory",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"deadlines.",
"An",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"is",
"supposed",
"to",
"serve",
"two",
"purposes:",
"it",
"19",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7566.",
"Administrative",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"are",
"largely",
"creatures",
"of",
"statute,",
"and",
"here",
"we",
"have",
"no",
"such",
"statutory",
"construct.",
"While",
"some",
"agency",
"regulations",
"set",
"out",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"without",
"a",
"statutory",
"mandate,",
"these",
"tend",
"to",
"be",
"in",
"administrative",
"appeal",
"situations",
"or",
"proceedings",
"that",
"are",
"analogs",
"to",
"adversarial",
"litigation.",
"Notably,",
"the",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"removed",
"a",
"procedure",
"for",
"formal",
"TSCA",
"hearings.",
"11/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
161,
109
],
[
164,
94,
202,
109
],
[
205,
94,
250,
109
],
[
253,
94,
270,
110
],
[
273,
93,
343,
110
],
[
346,
93,
429,
110
],
[
432,
93,
462,
110
],
[
466,
93,
542,
110
],
[
545,
93,
564,
110
],
[
567,
93,
595,
110
],
[
598,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
643,
110
],
[
647,
93,
678,
110
],
[
681,
93,
775,
110
],
[
778,
93,
865,
110
],
[
120,
110,
170,
126
],
[
174,
110,
211,
126
],
[
214,
110,
245,
126
],
[
250,
111,
332,
127
],
[
336,
111,
386,
127
],
[
390,
111,
409,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
434,
111,
492,
127
],
[
497,
111,
557,
127
],
[
561,
111,
634,
128
],
[
638,
111,
667,
128
],
[
670,
111,
756,
128
],
[
119,
146,
132,
161
],
[
136,
146,
182,
161
],
[
185,
146,
260,
161
],
[
264,
146,
312,
161
],
[
316,
146,
337,
161
],
[
341,
146,
364,
161
],
[
368,
146,
405,
161
],
[
410,
146,
427,
161
],
[
430,
145,
504,
161
],
[
507,
145,
525,
161
],
[
528,
145,
554,
161
],
[
557,
145,
589,
161
],
[
592,
145,
624,
161
],
[
627,
145,
664,
161
],
[
667,
145,
678,
161
],
[
680,
145,
727,
161
],
[
730,
145,
745,
161
],
[
748,
145,
831,
161
],
[
834,
145,
873,
161
],
[
117,
164,
173,
178
],
[
176,
164,
253,
179
],
[
256,
164,
273,
179
],
[
276,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
164,
395,
179
],
[
398,
164,
408,
179
],
[
412,
164,
480,
179
],
[
484,
164,
501,
179
],
[
504,
164,
590,
179
],
[
593,
164,
632,
179
],
[
635,
164,
654,
179
],
[
658,
164,
724,
179
],
[
728,
163,
844,
179
],
[
847,
163,
865,
178
],
[
868,
163,
885,
178
],
[
117,
181,
196,
196
],
[
199,
181,
279,
196
],
[
282,
182,
345,
196
],
[
348,
182,
375,
196
],
[
378,
182,
443,
196
],
[
446,
182,
464,
196
],
[
467,
182,
535,
196
],
[
538,
182,
556,
196
],
[
559,
182,
570,
196
],
[
572,
182,
648,
196
],
[
650,
182,
670,
196
],
[
672,
181,
704,
196
],
[
707,
181,
777,
197
],
[
118,
198,
226,
214
],
[
230,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
198,
365,
214
],
[
368,
198,
412,
213
],
[
417,
198,
442,
213
],
[
445,
198,
510,
213
],
[
514,
198,
531,
213
],
[
535,
198,
559,
213
],
[
562,
198,
595,
213
],
[
599,
198,
683,
213
],
[
177,
243,
196,
260
],
[
236,
246,
272,
260
],
[
278,
246,
325,
260
],
[
328,
246,
397,
260
],
[
400,
246,
429,
260
],
[
431,
246,
601,
261
],
[
604,
246,
656,
261
],
[
659,
246,
762,
261
],
[
765,
246,
846,
261
],
[
118,
280,
154,
295
],
[
159,
280,
213,
296
],
[
217,
280,
287,
296
],
[
291,
280,
322,
296
],
[
326,
280,
340,
296
],
[
343,
280,
370,
296
],
[
373,
280,
411,
296
],
[
415,
280,
447,
296
],
[
450,
280,
542,
296
],
[
545,
280,
567,
296
],
[
570,
280,
644,
296
],
[
647,
280,
775,
296
],
[
778,
280,
798,
296
],
[
801,
280,
872,
296
],
[
117,
296,
134,
312
],
[
137,
297,
195,
313
],
[
200,
297,
231,
313
],
[
234,
297,
317,
314
],
[
320,
298,
337,
314
],
[
341,
298,
377,
314
],
[
381,
298,
398,
314
],
[
401,
298,
447,
314
],
[
451,
298,
501,
314
],
[
504,
298,
524,
314
],
[
528,
298,
616,
314
],
[
619,
298,
712,
314
],
[
716,
298,
741,
314
],
[
744,
297,
818,
313
],
[
821,
297,
843,
313
],
[
846,
297,
872,
312
],
[
118,
315,
182,
331
],
[
187,
315,
262,
331
],
[
265,
315,
295,
331
],
[
298,
315,
381,
331
],
[
384,
315,
417,
331
],
[
420,
315,
450,
331
],
[
452,
315,
535,
331
],
[
538,
315,
555,
331
],
[
558,
315,
587,
331
],
[
590,
315,
627,
331
],
[
629,
315,
680,
331
],
[
682,
315,
759,
331
],
[
761,
315,
788,
331
],
[
790,
315,
849,
331
],
[
850,
315,
867,
330
],
[
117,
332,
143,
348
],
[
146,
332,
200,
348
],
[
202,
332,
252,
348
],
[
255,
332,
284,
348
],
[
287,
332,
365,
348
],
[
385,
332,
412,
348
],
[
416,
332,
452,
348
],
[
455,
332,
483,
348
],
[
487,
332,
547,
348
],
[
551,
332,
567,
348
],
[
570,
332,
631,
348
],
[
634,
332,
664,
348
],
[
668,
332,
710,
348
],
[
712,
332,
799,
348
],
[
802,
333,
870,
348
],
[
117,
351,
213,
366
],
[
217,
351,
242,
365
],
[
245,
351,
301,
365
],
[
304,
351,
366,
366
],
[
117,
385,
159,
400
],
[
162,
385,
174,
400
],
[
178,
385,
230,
400
],
[
233,
385,
252,
400
],
[
255,
385,
304,
400
],
[
307,
385,
364,
400
],
[
368,
385,
388,
400
],
[
391,
385,
417,
400
],
[
420,
385,
495,
401
],
[
498,
385,
601,
401
],
[
604,
385,
618,
401
],
[
621,
385,
700,
401
],
[
702,
386,
777,
400
],
[
779,
386,
814,
400
],
[
817,
386,
844,
400
],
[
847,
386,
871,
400
],
[
118,
404,
171,
417
],
[
174,
404,
192,
417
],
[
195,
404,
272,
417
],
[
275,
404,
294,
417
],
[
296,
404,
307,
417
],
[
310,
404,
375,
417
],
[
378,
404,
396,
417
],
[
400,
404,
451,
417
],
[
454,
404,
533,
417
],
[
536,
404,
566,
417
],
[
569,
404,
604,
417
],
[
607,
404,
639,
417
],
[
642,
404,
668,
417
],
[
671,
403,
745,
417
],
[
750,
403,
785,
417
],
[
788,
403,
816,
417
],
[
818,
403,
882,
417
],
[
118,
420,
154,
435
],
[
158,
420,
170,
435
],
[
175,
420,
264,
435
],
[
272,
420,
317,
435
],
[
320,
420,
362,
435
],
[
366,
420,
384,
435
],
[
387,
420,
437,
435
],
[
440,
420,
457,
435
],
[
460,
420,
492,
435
],
[
496,
420,
524,
435
],
[
527,
420,
574,
435
],
[
577,
420,
590,
435
],
[
594,
420,
668,
435
],
[
671,
420,
739,
435
],
[
741,
420,
777,
435
],
[
780,
420,
807,
435
],
[
810,
420,
831,
435
],
[
834,
420,
871,
435
],
[
118,
438,
135,
453
],
[
138,
438,
186,
453
],
[
190,
438,
284,
453
],
[
287,
438,
305,
453
],
[
309,
438,
319,
453
],
[
323,
438,
395,
453
],
[
398,
438,
434,
453
],
[
441,
438,
497,
453
],
[
501,
438,
561,
453
],
[
565,
438,
581,
453
],
[
585,
438,
611,
453
],
[
614,
438,
672,
453
],
[
676,
438,
692,
453
],
[
697,
438,
735,
453
],
[
738,
437,
791,
453
],
[
795,
437,
858,
453
],
[
118,
455,
216,
470
],
[
219,
456,
262,
470
],
[
265,
456,
298,
470
],
[
302,
456,
390,
471
],
[
392,
456,
461,
471
],
[
464,
456,
581,
471
],
[
584,
456,
657,
471
],
[
660,
456,
677,
470
],
[
680,
455,
759,
470
],
[
762,
455,
791,
470
],
[
794,
455,
820,
470
],
[
823,
455,
855,
470
],
[
118,
472,
166,
487
],
[
169,
472,
207,
487
],
[
210,
472,
262,
487
],
[
265,
472,
287,
487
],
[
290,
472,
365,
488
],
[
368,
472,
399,
488
],
[
402,
472,
485,
488
],
[
488,
472,
507,
488
],
[
510,
472,
545,
488
],
[
549,
472,
567,
488
],
[
571,
472,
595,
488
],
[
599,
472,
645,
488
],
[
649,
472,
666,
488
],
[
670,
472,
679,
488
],
[
682,
472,
715,
488
],
[
718,
472,
805,
488
],
[
808,
472,
822,
488
],
[
825,
472,
881,
487
],
[
118,
490,
152,
506
],
[
155,
489,
189,
506
],
[
193,
489,
217,
506
],
[
220,
489,
285,
506
],
[
290,
489,
324,
506
],
[
328,
489,
346,
506
],
[
350,
489,
358,
506
],
[
362,
489,
436,
506
],
[
440,
489,
468,
506
],
[
471,
489,
537,
506
],
[
541,
489,
600,
506
],
[
604,
489,
622,
506
],
[
626,
490,
697,
506
],
[
701,
490,
717,
506
],
[
721,
490,
781,
506
],
[
785,
490,
850,
506
],
[
118,
507,
201,
522
],
[
204,
507,
257,
522
],
[
261,
507,
328,
522
],
[
332,
508,
350,
523
],
[
353,
508,
445,
523
],
[
449,
508,
501,
523
],
[
504,
507,
601,
523
],
[
604,
507,
649,
523
],
[
652,
507,
693,
523
],
[
697,
507,
764,
523
],
[
767,
507,
827,
522
],
[
830,
506,
852,
522
],
[
118,
525,
188,
540
],
[
192,
525,
228,
540
],
[
231,
525,
252,
540
],
[
255,
525,
291,
540
],
[
294,
524,
352,
540
],
[
355,
524,
381,
540
],
[
384,
524,
461,
540
],
[
465,
524,
554,
540
],
[
557,
524,
575,
540
],
[
578,
524,
588,
540
],
[
591,
524,
698,
540
],
[
701,
525,
718,
540
],
[
722,
525,
804,
541
],
[
807,
525,
867,
541
],
[
870,
525,
885,
541
],
[
120,
542,
182,
557
],
[
186,
542,
202,
557
],
[
206,
542,
292,
557
],
[
296,
542,
314,
557
],
[
317,
542,
355,
557
],
[
359,
542,
451,
557
],
[
454,
542,
532,
558
],
[
535,
542,
585,
558
],
[
588,
542,
614,
558
],
[
617,
542,
679,
558
],
[
682,
542,
739,
558
],
[
119,
576,
180,
592
],
[
184,
576,
284,
592
],
[
288,
577,
305,
592
],
[
309,
577,
358,
592
],
[
362,
577,
391,
593
],
[
395,
577,
469,
593
],
[
472,
577,
562,
592
],
[
567,
577,
582,
592
],
[
586,
577,
659,
592
],
[
662,
576,
684,
592
],
[
688,
576,
714,
592
],
[
718,
576,
834,
592
],
[
119,
593,
199,
610
],
[
202,
594,
230,
610
],
[
234,
594,
289,
610
],
[
293,
594,
321,
610
],
[
324,
594,
350,
610
],
[
353,
594,
414,
610
],
[
418,
594,
471,
610
],
[
475,
594,
559,
610
],
[
563,
594,
581,
610
],
[
585,
594,
645,
610
],
[
650,
594,
669,
609
],
[
672,
594,
692,
609
],
[
696,
593,
755,
609
],
[
759,
593,
799,
609
],
[
117,
613,
203,
626
],
[
207,
613,
312,
627
],
[
314,
613,
342,
627
],
[
346,
613,
367,
627
],
[
369,
612,
438,
627
],
[
441,
612,
462,
627
],
[
467,
612,
529,
627
],
[
532,
612,
603,
627
],
[
606,
612,
647,
627
],
[
650,
612,
675,
627
],
[
679,
612,
715,
627
],
[
718,
612,
728,
627
],
[
732,
612,
758,
627
],
[
767,
612,
836,
627
],
[
839,
612,
880,
627
],
[
117,
629,
204,
643
],
[
207,
630,
290,
643
],
[
294,
630,
310,
643
],
[
313,
630,
430,
644
],
[
432,
630,
497,
644
],
[
500,
630,
527,
644
],
[
530,
630,
570,
644
],
[
573,
630,
632,
644
],
[
636,
630,
654,
644
],
[
657,
629,
706,
644
],
[
710,
629,
724,
644
],
[
727,
629,
745,
644
],
[
750,
629,
809,
644
],
[
117,
645,
217,
662
],
[
220,
646,
237,
661
],
[
240,
646,
267,
661
],
[
271,
646,
318,
661
],
[
322,
646,
350,
661
],
[
354,
646,
394,
661
],
[
398,
646,
442,
661
],
[
446,
646,
471,
661
],
[
475,
646,
514,
661
],
[
518,
646,
537,
661
],
[
540,
646,
595,
661
],
[
118,
681,
191,
697
],
[
194,
682,
224,
696
],
[
228,
682,
254,
696
],
[
258,
682,
350,
696
],
[
353,
682,
370,
696
],
[
374,
682,
432,
696
],
[
436,
682,
454,
696
],
[
458,
682,
501,
696
],
[
504,
682,
590,
696
],
[
593,
682,
690,
696
],
[
692,
682,
718,
696
],
[
721,
682,
747,
696
],
[
750,
681,
795,
696
],
[
798,
681,
817,
696
],
[
820,
681,
830,
696
],
[
833,
681,
864,
696
],
[
120,
698,
199,
714
],
[
203,
698,
220,
714
],
[
224,
698,
275,
714
],
[
278,
698,
372,
714
],
[
375,
698,
387,
714
],
[
390,
698,
424,
714
],
[
427,
698,
491,
714
],
[
495,
698,
514,
714
],
[
519,
698,
537,
714
],
[
540,
698,
568,
714
],
[
572,
698,
610,
714
],
[
614,
698,
672,
714
],
[
675,
699,
696,
714
],
[
700,
699,
786,
714
],
[
790,
699,
849,
715
],
[
852,
699,
872,
715
],
[
117,
716,
158,
731
],
[
162,
716,
247,
731
],
[
251,
717,
347,
732
],
[
351,
717,
382,
732
],
[
386,
717,
441,
732
],
[
445,
717,
470,
732
],
[
474,
717,
544,
732
],
[
547,
717,
594,
732
],
[
598,
716,
627,
732
],
[
630,
716,
720,
732
],
[
722,
716,
741,
731
],
[
744,
715,
845,
731
],
[
117,
734,
164,
748
],
[
167,
734,
194,
748
],
[
196,
733,
234,
749
],
[
240,
733,
271,
749
],
[
275,
733,
323,
749
],
[
329,
733,
390,
749
],
[
394,
733,
425,
749
],
[
439,
733,
501,
749
],
[
504,
733,
544,
749
],
[
548,
733,
615,
749
],
[
618,
733,
630,
749
],
[
632,
733,
687,
749
],
[
690,
734,
767,
749
],
[
770,
734,
808,
748
],
[
810,
734,
828,
748
],
[
831,
735,
864,
748
],
[
116,
751,
190,
768
],
[
194,
751,
216,
767
],
[
219,
751,
256,
767
],
[
260,
751,
295,
767
],
[
298,
751,
325,
767
],
[
329,
751,
370,
767
],
[
373,
751,
485,
767
],
[
488,
751,
551,
767
],
[
119,
786,
167,
801
],
[
170,
786,
195,
801
],
[
198,
786,
272,
801
],
[
275,
786,
309,
801
],
[
312,
786,
340,
801
],
[
342,
786,
420,
801
],
[
423,
786,
489,
801
],
[
492,
786,
514,
801
],
[
517,
786,
579,
801
],
[
582,
786,
647,
801
],
[
650,
786,
661,
801
],
[
665,
786,
681,
801
],
[
684,
786,
724,
801
],
[
728,
786,
797,
800
],
[
801,
786,
830,
800
],
[
118,
803,
201,
817
],
[
208,
804,
290,
818
],
[
294,
804,
318,
818
],
[
321,
804,
363,
818
],
[
367,
804,
451,
819
],
[
455,
804,
552,
819
],
[
555,
804,
571,
819
],
[
575,
804,
648,
819
],
[
652,
804,
669,
819
],
[
672,
804,
715,
819
],
[
718,
804,
748,
819
],
[
752,
804,
829,
819
],
[
832,
803,
845,
818
],
[
118,
834,
129,
850
],
[
132,
835,
148,
850
],
[
151,
836,
181,
851
],
[
185,
838,
217,
852
],
[
221,
839,
234,
852
],
[
238,
839,
274,
852
],
[
132,
852,
231,
865
],
[
234,
853,
268,
865
],
[
271,
853,
342,
866
],
[
345,
854,
432,
866
],
[
435,
854,
455,
866
],
[
458,
854,
507,
866
],
[
510,
854,
569,
866
],
[
572,
854,
587,
866
],
[
590,
854,
638,
866
],
[
641,
854,
665,
866
],
[
668,
854,
699,
866
],
[
702,
854,
721,
866
],
[
724,
854,
756,
866
],
[
759,
854,
777,
866
],
[
780,
853,
811,
866
],
[
814,
853,
871,
866
],
[
118,
868,
184,
880
],
[
186,
868,
227,
880
],
[
228,
868,
266,
880
],
[
268,
868,
315,
880
],
[
317,
868,
392,
881
],
[
395,
868,
415,
881
],
[
417,
868,
439,
881
],
[
441,
868,
477,
881
],
[
479,
868,
551,
881
],
[
553,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
695,
880
],
[
697,
868,
707,
880
],
[
709,
868,
767,
880
],
[
770,
868,
831,
880
],
[
833,
868,
868,
880
],
[
119,
883,
146,
895
],
[
148,
883,
164,
895
],
[
166,
883,
183,
895
],
[
185,
883,
200,
895
],
[
203,
883,
298,
896
],
[
300,
884,
345,
896
],
[
347,
884,
411,
896
],
[
414,
884,
428,
896
],
[
430,
884,
512,
896
],
[
514,
884,
541,
896
],
[
543,
884,
564,
896
],
[
567,
884,
618,
896
],
[
621,
883,
636,
896
],
[
638,
883,
711,
896
],
[
714,
883,
778,
895
],
[
780,
882,
840,
895
],
[
842,
882,
865,
895
],
[
117,
897,
159,
910
],
[
163,
897,
240,
910
],
[
242,
897,
302,
910
],
[
305,
897,
312,
910
],
[
315,
897,
383,
910
],
[
386,
897,
407,
910
],
[
410,
897,
455,
910
],
[
458,
897,
499,
910
],
[
502,
897,
568,
910
],
[
821,
941,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
which section is for judicial review provisions of TSCA?
|
Section 19
|
747
|
[
"review",
"reliability",
"is",
"reduced",
"and",
"it",
"cannot",
"be",
"referred",
"to",
"as",
"systematic....It",
"is",
"unhelpful",
"to",
"classify",
"\"narrative",
"reviews\"",
"as",
"systematic",
"reviews...",
"EPA",
"states",
"that",
"it",
"has",
"included",
"systematic",
"reviews",
"in",
"the",
"past;",
"however,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"clear",
"what",
"exactly",
"it",
"has",
"done",
"and",
"where",
"these",
"reviews",
"can",
"be",
"found.\"",
"The",
"last",
"completed",
"draft",
"TSCA",
"Work",
"Plan",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"was",
"for",
"1-bromopropane.",
"The",
"executive",
"summary",
"of",
"the",
"peer",
"review",
"report",
"of",
"this",
"draft",
"evaluation,",
"dated",
"August",
"22,",
"2016,",
"states:",
"Committee",
"members",
"agreed",
"that",
"the",
"1-BP",
"risk",
"assessment",
"(and",
"other",
"TSCA",
"chemical",
"assessments",
"to",
"be",
"presented",
"in",
"the",
"future)",
"would",
"benefit",
"by",
"adoption",
"of",
"systematic",
"review",
"practices",
"to",
"increase",
"the",
"transparency",
"of",
"how",
"studies",
"were",
"selected",
"and",
"evaluated.",
"For",
"example,",
"the",
"Committee",
"recommended",
"that",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"explicitly",
"stated",
"what",
"criteria",
"were",
"used",
"to",
"determine",
"\"the",
"monitoring",
"was",
"adequate",
"and",
"of",
"acceptable",
"quality\"",
"(risk",
"assessment",
"document,",
"page",
"44).",
"The",
"Committee",
"also",
"noted",
"that",
"it",
"would",
"be",
"useful",
"to",
"reference",
"studies",
"that",
"were",
"evaluated",
"but",
"did",
"not",
"meet",
"baseline",
"criteria",
"to",
"inform",
"the",
"exposure",
"estimates.",
"30",
"In",
"addition,",
"the",
"peer",
"review",
"committee",
"could",
"not",
"determine",
"\"what",
"exact",
"methodology",
"was",
"used",
"to",
"systematically",
"rate,",
"rank,",
"and",
"select",
"studies",
"to",
"inform",
"sections",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"assessment.\"",
"Peer",
"reviewers",
"also",
"could",
"not",
"find",
"any",
"ranking",
"system",
"developed",
"for",
"study",
"quality.",
"It",
"is",
"critically",
"important",
"that",
"systematic",
"review",
"mean",
"the",
"same",
"thing",
"to",
"all",
"engaged",
"stakeholders,",
"including",
"Agency",
"staff",
"and",
"peer",
"reviewers.",
"ACC",
"cannot",
"envision",
"any",
"situation",
"where",
"a",
"definition",
"of",
"systematic",
"review",
"would",
"unduly",
"restrict",
"the",
"specific",
"science",
"that",
"can",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"conduct",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"A",
"systematic",
"review",
"process",
"will",
"allow",
"EPA",
"to",
"be",
"flexible",
"and",
"to",
"adapt",
"with",
"changing",
"science,",
"assuming",
"that",
"the",
"new",
"science",
"meets",
"the",
"necessary",
"high",
"quality",
"standards",
"that",
"are",
"required",
"by",
"the",
"LCSA.",
"Including",
"a",
"regulatory",
"definition",
"for",
"systematic",
"review",
"is",
"fully",
"consistent",
"with",
"EPA's",
"policy",
"objectives.\"As",
"such,",
"ACC",
"recommends",
"the",
"following",
"definition",
"be",
"included",
"in",
"the",
"final",
"rule:",
"Systematic",
"review",
"means",
"that",
"the",
"evidence",
"has",
"been",
"evaluated",
"using",
"a",
"predefined,",
"transparent,",
"and",
"reproducible",
"process",
"to",
"identify,",
"appraise,",
"and",
"synthesize",
"the",
"available",
"body",
"of",
"evidence",
"to",
"answer",
"a",
"specific",
"question.",
"To",
"ensure",
"transparency,",
"systematic",
"reviews",
"should",
"include",
"a",
"Protocol",
"that",
"describes",
"the",
"specific",
"question(s)",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"answered,",
"the",
"literature",
"search",
"strategy",
"and",
"plans",
"for",
"data",
"collection,",
"the",
"methods",
"for",
"evaluating",
"the",
"quality",
"and",
"relevance",
"of",
"the",
"data",
"48",
"Id.",
"at",
"4.",
"19",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7572.",
"50",
"See",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"Advisory",
"Committee",
"Minutes",
"No.",
"2016-02,",
"at",
"1.",
"See",
"id.",
"at",
"41.",
"32",
"Id.",
"at",
"42.",
"3",
"See",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7567",
"(\"Due",
"to",
"the",
"rapid",
"advancement",
"of",
"the",
"science",
"of",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"and",
"the",
"science",
"and",
"technology",
"that",
"inform",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"this",
"proposed",
"rule",
"seeks",
"to",
"balance",
"the",
"need",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"procedures",
"to",
"be",
"transparent,",
"without",
"unduly",
"restricting",
"the",
"specific",
"science",
"that",
"will",
"be",
"used",
"to",
"conduct",
"the",
"evaluations,",
"allowing",
"the",
"Agency",
"flexibility",
"to",
"adapt",
"and",
"keep",
"current",
"with",
"changing",
"science",
"as",
"it",
"conducts",
"TSCA",
"evaluations",
"into",
"the",
"future.\")",
"20/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
176,
93,
230,
109
],
[
233,
93,
311,
110
],
[
314,
93,
330,
110
],
[
333,
93,
398,
110
],
[
401,
93,
430,
110
],
[
433,
93,
445,
110
],
[
449,
93,
502,
110
],
[
507,
93,
527,
110
],
[
530,
93,
593,
110
],
[
597,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
635,
110
],
[
640,
93,
760,
110
],
[
764,
93,
777,
109
],
[
781,
93,
858,
109
],
[
862,
93,
881,
108
],
[
177,
110,
237,
127
],
[
240,
111,
321,
127
],
[
324,
111,
395,
127
],
[
399,
111,
417,
127
],
[
421,
111,
505,
127
],
[
508,
110,
594,
126
],
[
117,
145,
154,
160
],
[
159,
145,
204,
160
],
[
207,
145,
238,
160
],
[
241,
145,
254,
160
],
[
257,
145,
285,
160
],
[
288,
145,
358,
161
],
[
362,
146,
445,
161
],
[
449,
146,
511,
161
],
[
515,
146,
531,
161
],
[
535,
146,
561,
161
],
[
564,
146,
602,
161
],
[
605,
146,
680,
161
],
[
683,
145,
695,
160
],
[
699,
145,
714,
160
],
[
717,
145,
745,
160
],
[
748,
145,
788,
160
],
[
791,
145,
830,
160
],
[
117,
164,
175,
179
],
[
178,
164,
191,
179
],
[
194,
164,
226,
179
],
[
229,
164,
265,
179
],
[
268,
164,
299,
179
],
[
302,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
163,
395,
179
],
[
399,
163,
462,
179
],
[
466,
163,
493,
179
],
[
497,
163,
518,
179
],
[
522,
163,
585,
179
],
[
597,
163,
627,
178
],
[
631,
162,
660,
178
],
[
663,
162,
749,
178
],
[
752,
162,
790,
178
],
[
793,
162,
842,
178
],
[
119,
180,
163,
195
],
[
167,
180,
203,
196
],
[
207,
181,
238,
196
],
[
241,
181,
324,
196
],
[
328,
182,
360,
196
],
[
363,
182,
389,
196
],
[
392,
182,
531,
196
],
[
535,
182,
563,
196
],
[
567,
182,
644,
196
],
[
648,
181,
722,
196
],
[
726,
181,
742,
196
],
[
747,
181,
771,
196
],
[
775,
181,
810,
196
],
[
814,
180,
868,
196
],
[
118,
198,
165,
214
],
[
170,
198,
185,
214
],
[
190,
198,
222,
214
],
[
226,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
197,
357,
213
],
[
361,
197,
402,
213
],
[
406,
197,
462,
213
],
[
467,
198,
492,
214
],
[
495,
198,
542,
214
],
[
545,
198,
600,
214
],
[
179,
234,
265,
247
],
[
268,
234,
342,
248
],
[
345,
234,
400,
248
],
[
402,
234,
434,
248
],
[
437,
234,
464,
248
],
[
468,
234,
507,
248
],
[
511,
234,
542,
248
],
[
546,
233,
635,
248
],
[
638,
233,
674,
248
],
[
677,
233,
722,
248
],
[
725,
233,
771,
248
],
[
778,
232,
853,
247
],
[
177,
251,
272,
265
],
[
275,
251,
292,
265
],
[
295,
251,
315,
265
],
[
318,
250,
397,
265
],
[
400,
250,
416,
265
],
[
419,
250,
445,
265
],
[
448,
250,
505,
265
],
[
508,
250,
558,
265
],
[
561,
250,
617,
265
],
[
620,
250,
642,
265
],
[
645,
250,
715,
265
],
[
718,
250,
737,
265
],
[
740,
250,
824,
265
],
[
827,
250,
878,
265
],
[
175,
269,
247,
284
],
[
250,
269,
267,
284
],
[
270,
269,
336,
284
],
[
339,
269,
365,
284
],
[
369,
269,
471,
284
],
[
474,
268,
492,
284
],
[
495,
268,
529,
284
],
[
535,
268,
591,
284
],
[
594,
268,
633,
284
],
[
637,
267,
701,
284
],
[
705,
267,
734,
283
],
[
738,
267,
820,
283
],
[
824,
266,
852,
283
],
[
177,
286,
249,
300
],
[
252,
286,
278,
300
],
[
281,
286,
369,
300
],
[
372,
286,
485,
300
],
[
488,
286,
520,
300
],
[
524,
286,
537,
300
],
[
540,
286,
594,
300
],
[
597,
285,
617,
300
],
[
620,
285,
695,
300
],
[
698,
285,
747,
300
],
[
750,
285,
789,
300
],
[
792,
285,
845,
300
],
[
177,
302,
214,
318
],
[
218,
302,
256,
318
],
[
260,
302,
280,
318
],
[
283,
302,
360,
318
],
[
364,
303,
398,
318
],
[
401,
302,
490,
318
],
[
494,
302,
527,
318
],
[
530,
302,
601,
318
],
[
604,
302,
634,
318
],
[
638,
302,
655,
318
],
[
659,
302,
742,
318
],
[
745,
301,
811,
318
],
[
814,
301,
852,
318
],
[
177,
320,
268,
335
],
[
271,
320,
352,
336
],
[
355,
320,
395,
336
],
[
398,
320,
431,
336
],
[
434,
320,
466,
336
],
[
469,
320,
558,
336
],
[
561,
320,
593,
336
],
[
597,
319,
642,
336
],
[
645,
319,
677,
336
],
[
680,
319,
693,
336
],
[
696,
319,
745,
336
],
[
748,
319,
771,
336
],
[
774,
319,
823,
336
],
[
826,
319,
843,
335
],
[
175,
338,
251,
352
],
[
254,
338,
309,
353
],
[
312,
338,
345,
353
],
[
348,
339,
387,
353
],
[
390,
339,
465,
353
],
[
468,
339,
497,
353
],
[
500,
339,
521,
353
],
[
524,
339,
551,
353
],
[
554,
339,
592,
353
],
[
595,
339,
659,
353
],
[
662,
338,
716,
353
],
[
719,
338,
735,
353
],
[
738,
338,
787,
353
],
[
795,
338,
819,
352
],
[
176,
355,
246,
369
],
[
249,
353,
324,
369
],
[
327,
352,
344,
366
],
[
117,
391,
135,
405
],
[
138,
391,
210,
405
],
[
212,
391,
238,
405
],
[
241,
391,
277,
405
],
[
280,
391,
332,
405
],
[
338,
391,
423,
405
],
[
427,
391,
471,
405
],
[
475,
391,
504,
405
],
[
508,
391,
584,
405
],
[
587,
391,
637,
405
],
[
640,
391,
683,
405
],
[
686,
390,
792,
405
],
[
795,
390,
826,
405
],
[
830,
390,
866,
405
],
[
117,
407,
135,
422
],
[
138,
407,
250,
422
],
[
254,
408,
289,
422
],
[
293,
408,
336,
422
],
[
340,
408,
369,
422
],
[
372,
408,
418,
422
],
[
422,
408,
477,
422
],
[
481,
408,
498,
422
],
[
501,
408,
552,
422
],
[
559,
407,
625,
422
],
[
628,
407,
645,
422
],
[
649,
407,
674,
422
],
[
677,
407,
710,
422
],
[
712,
406,
816,
422
],
[
831,
406,
869,
421
],
[
117,
424,
195,
440
],
[
199,
425,
231,
440
],
[
234,
425,
279,
440
],
[
282,
425,
311,
440
],
[
314,
425,
347,
440
],
[
351,
425,
379,
440
],
[
382,
425,
444,
440
],
[
448,
425,
500,
440
],
[
511,
425,
590,
440
],
[
593,
424,
617,
440
],
[
621,
424,
665,
440
],
[
668,
424,
736,
440
],
[
118,
460,
130,
474
],
[
134,
460,
148,
474
],
[
152,
460,
222,
474
],
[
226,
460,
304,
474
],
[
308,
460,
340,
474
],
[
343,
460,
426,
474
],
[
430,
460,
482,
475
],
[
488,
460,
532,
475
],
[
535,
460,
562,
475
],
[
565,
460,
606,
475
],
[
610,
460,
651,
475
],
[
655,
460,
672,
475
],
[
677,
460,
697,
475
],
[
700,
460,
767,
475
],
[
771,
460,
877,
475
],
[
118,
476,
194,
492
],
[
197,
476,
259,
493
],
[
262,
477,
298,
493
],
[
302,
477,
331,
493
],
[
335,
477,
370,
493
],
[
373,
477,
457,
493
],
[
461,
477,
502,
493
],
[
505,
477,
559,
492
],
[
563,
477,
631,
492
],
[
635,
477,
664,
492
],
[
668,
477,
737,
492
],
[
740,
477,
790,
492
],
[
794,
477,
805,
492
],
[
808,
476,
885,
491
],
[
118,
495,
136,
509
],
[
139,
495,
222,
510
],
[
225,
495,
278,
510
],
[
284,
495,
336,
510
],
[
339,
495,
395,
510
],
[
398,
495,
454,
510
],
[
457,
495,
484,
510
],
[
487,
495,
550,
510
],
[
553,
495,
611,
510
],
[
614,
495,
648,
510
],
[
650,
495,
678,
510
],
[
681,
495,
702,
510
],
[
705,
495,
743,
510
],
[
745,
495,
763,
510
],
[
766,
495,
831,
510
],
[
834,
495,
843,
509
],
[
845,
495,
874,
509
],
[
117,
512,
206,
527
],
[
209,
512,
222,
527
],
[
228,
512,
311,
527
],
[
315,
512,
367,
527
],
[
373,
512,
434,
527
],
[
438,
512,
469,
527
],
[
473,
512,
517,
527
],
[
522,
512,
558,
527
],
[
564,
512,
580,
527
],
[
583,
512,
604,
527
],
[
607,
512,
670,
527
],
[
672,
512,
702,
526
],
[
705,
512,
723,
526
],
[
726,
512,
770,
526
],
[
773,
512,
808,
526
],
[
119,
529,
190,
545
],
[
194,
529,
258,
545
],
[
262,
530,
336,
545
],
[
340,
530,
370,
545
],
[
374,
530,
398,
545
],
[
402,
530,
437,
545
],
[
442,
530,
500,
545
],
[
503,
530,
551,
545
],
[
555,
530,
580,
545
],
[
583,
529,
660,
545
],
[
664,
529,
701,
545
],
[
704,
529,
761,
545
],
[
764,
528,
840,
545
],
[
843,
528,
878,
545
],
[
118,
547,
141,
562
],
[
144,
547,
212,
562
],
[
215,
547,
237,
562
],
[
241,
547,
265,
562
],
[
269,
547,
327,
562
],
[
330,
547,
407,
563
],
[
411,
547,
420,
563
],
[
424,
547,
508,
563
],
[
513,
547,
588,
563
],
[
592,
547,
615,
563
],
[
619,
547,
702,
563
],
[
706,
547,
758,
562
],
[
765,
547,
780,
562
],
[
783,
547,
824,
562
],
[
117,
565,
198,
579
],
[
201,
565,
238,
579
],
[
241,
565,
293,
580
],
[
297,
564,
347,
580
],
[
351,
564,
477,
580
],
[
480,
564,
524,
580
],
[
527,
564,
566,
580
],
[
571,
564,
673,
580
],
[
677,
564,
703,
580
],
[
706,
564,
785,
580
],
[
791,
564,
865,
580
],
[
116,
580,
137,
595
],
[
141,
580,
208,
595
],
[
212,
581,
229,
595
],
[
233,
581,
259,
595
],
[
262,
581,
298,
595
],
[
302,
581,
341,
595
],
[
178,
617,
262,
631
],
[
264,
617,
317,
631
],
[
322,
618,
375,
631
],
[
378,
618,
411,
631
],
[
414,
618,
440,
631
],
[
443,
618,
515,
632
],
[
518,
618,
547,
632
],
[
550,
618,
590,
632
],
[
592,
617,
670,
632
],
[
673,
617,
718,
632
],
[
721,
617,
731,
632
],
[
734,
616,
824,
632
],
[
178,
634,
274,
649
],
[
277,
634,
310,
649
],
[
314,
634,
418,
650
],
[
422,
634,
487,
650
],
[
491,
634,
510,
650
],
[
515,
634,
588,
650
],
[
591,
634,
668,
650
],
[
672,
634,
704,
650
],
[
708,
634,
795,
650
],
[
799,
634,
824,
649
],
[
177,
651,
248,
666
],
[
252,
651,
294,
667
],
[
298,
651,
316,
667
],
[
320,
652,
391,
667
],
[
395,
652,
412,
667
],
[
415,
652,
473,
667
],
[
477,
652,
488,
667
],
[
492,
652,
555,
667
],
[
558,
652,
633,
667
],
[
637,
652,
658,
667
],
[
662,
652,
714,
667
],
[
718,
652,
827,
667
],
[
177,
670,
263,
684
],
[
272,
669,
339,
684
],
[
349,
669,
406,
684
],
[
415,
669,
477,
684
],
[
488,
669,
501,
684
],
[
512,
669,
585,
684
],
[
592,
669,
628,
684
],
[
640,
669,
714,
685
],
[
724,
669,
751,
685
],
[
762,
669,
828,
685
],
[
176,
686,
265,
701
],
[
268,
686,
302,
701
],
[
305,
686,
337,
701
],
[
340,
686,
362,
701
],
[
366,
686,
445,
702
],
[
449,
686,
475,
702
],
[
478,
686,
553,
702
],
[
557,
686,
610,
702
],
[
613,
686,
677,
702
],
[
681,
686,
711,
702
],
[
714,
686,
760,
702
],
[
762,
686,
791,
702
],
[
795,
686,
825,
702
],
[
177,
703,
265,
719
],
[
268,
703,
296,
719
],
[
302,
703,
374,
719
],
[
380,
703,
409,
720
],
[
414,
703,
498,
720
],
[
505,
703,
534,
720
],
[
541,
703,
599,
720
],
[
606,
703,
638,
720
],
[
644,
703,
723,
720
],
[
730,
703,
752,
720
],
[
757,
702,
785,
720
],
[
795,
702,
828,
719
],
[
117,
763,
129,
778
],
[
132,
764,
151,
778
],
[
154,
765,
168,
778
],
[
171,
765,
182,
778
],
[
118,
777,
128,
792
],
[
132,
777,
157,
792
],
[
161,
778,
177,
793
],
[
180,
779,
210,
793
],
[
213,
780,
244,
794
],
[
248,
780,
262,
794
],
[
265,
780,
302,
794
],
[
117,
793,
128,
807
],
[
132,
793,
157,
807
],
[
160,
794,
224,
808
],
[
228,
795,
270,
808
],
[
273,
795,
334,
808
],
[
337,
795,
410,
808
],
[
413,
795,
468,
808
],
[
471,
795,
498,
808
],
[
501,
795,
561,
808
],
[
564,
795,
577,
808
],
[
580,
794,
591,
808
],
[
133,
807,
155,
821
],
[
159,
808,
178,
822
],
[
181,
809,
194,
822
],
[
197,
809,
218,
822
],
[
117,
823,
128,
836
],
[
131,
823,
151,
836
],
[
155,
824,
167,
836
],
[
170,
823,
190,
836
],
[
122,
836,
129,
850
],
[
132,
836,
157,
850
],
[
160,
837,
177,
851
],
[
180,
837,
208,
851
],
[
212,
838,
244,
851
],
[
247,
838,
261,
852
],
[
264,
838,
296,
852
],
[
300,
839,
340,
852
],
[
344,
839,
358,
852
],
[
361,
839,
381,
852
],
[
385,
840,
420,
853
],
[
423,
840,
510,
853
],
[
513,
840,
527,
853
],
[
531,
840,
552,
853
],
[
555,
840,
604,
853
],
[
608,
840,
621,
853
],
[
624,
840,
651,
853
],
[
654,
839,
723,
853
],
[
726,
839,
750,
852
],
[
753,
839,
775,
852
],
[
778,
838,
826,
852
],
[
829,
838,
855,
851
],
[
119,
854,
191,
866
],
[
194,
854,
220,
866
],
[
222,
854,
265,
866
],
[
271,
854,
297,
866
],
[
300,
854,
373,
867
],
[
376,
854,
401,
867
],
[
404,
854,
464,
867
],
[
467,
854,
494,
867
],
[
498,
854,
534,
867
],
[
537,
854,
550,
867
],
[
554,
854,
604,
867
],
[
607,
854,
628,
867
],
[
631,
853,
664,
867
],
[
667,
853,
686,
867
],
[
690,
853,
711,
867
],
[
714,
853,
740,
866
],
[
743,
853,
813,
866
],
[
117,
868,
190,
881
],
[
193,
868,
207,
881
],
[
210,
868,
227,
881
],
[
229,
868,
308,
881
],
[
310,
868,
361,
880
],
[
363,
868,
410,
880
],
[
412,
868,
481,
880
],
[
484,
868,
505,
880
],
[
508,
868,
561,
880
],
[
562,
868,
612,
880
],
[
614,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
670,
880
],
[
672,
868,
690,
880
],
[
691,
868,
725,
881
],
[
727,
868,
741,
881
],
[
743,
868,
797,
881
],
[
798,
868,
824,
881
],
[
117,
883,
197,
896
],
[
200,
883,
258,
896
],
[
261,
883,
283,
896
],
[
285,
883,
338,
896
],
[
340,
883,
406,
896
],
[
408,
884,
422,
896
],
[
425,
883,
462,
896
],
[
465,
883,
489,
896
],
[
491,
883,
525,
896
],
[
528,
883,
576,
896
],
[
578,
883,
608,
896
],
[
611,
883,
672,
896
],
[
675,
883,
725,
896
],
[
727,
883,
742,
895
],
[
744,
883,
755,
895
],
[
758,
882,
820,
895
],
[
821,
882,
862,
895
],
[
118,
897,
193,
911
],
[
196,
897,
222,
909
],
[
225,
897,
247,
909
],
[
250,
897,
307,
910
],
[
820,
940,
883,
955
],
[
220,
981,
287,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
When was the peer review report of this draft evaluation dated?
|
August 22, 2016
|
743
|
[
"make",
"little",
"sense",
"to",
"continue",
"evaluating",
"that",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"Otherwise,",
"EPA's",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"would",
"be",
"of",
"suspect",
"quality,",
"integrity,",
"and",
"reliability.",
"A",
"better",
"approach",
"would",
"be",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"that",
"after",
"a",
"scope",
"is",
"published,",
"EPA",
"retains",
"discretion",
"to",
"modify",
"it",
"upon",
"a",
"showing",
"of",
"substantial",
"need",
"or",
"changed",
"circumstances,",
"or",
"is",
"otherwise",
"warranted",
"because",
"the",
"addition",
"or",
"removal",
"of",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"properly",
"substantiated,",
"will",
"significantly",
"affect",
"the",
"conduct",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"J.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Remove",
"the",
"Comment-or-Waive",
"(Issue",
"Exhaustion)",
"Proposal.",
"EPA",
"further",
"proposes",
"that",
"it",
"can",
"keep",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"schedule,",
"notwithstanding",
"its",
"proposal",
"to",
"include",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"every",
"scope,",
"by",
"\"providing",
"opportunity",
"for",
"comment",
"on",
"the",
"scoping",
"document",
"and",
"specifying",
"that",
"any",
"objections",
"to",
"the",
"draft",
"scope",
"document",
"are",
"waived",
"if",
"not",
"raised",
"during",
"this",
"process.\"",
"We",
"urge",
"the",
"Agency",
"to",
"remove",
"this",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"(waiver)",
"requirement",
"for",
"several",
"reasons.",
"First,",
"it",
"places",
"an",
"unfair",
"burden",
"on",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"A",
"particular",
"company",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"aware,",
"or",
"otherwise",
"in",
"a",
"position",
"to",
"verify,",
"particular",
"end",
"uses",
"that",
"the",
"company",
"does",
"not",
"support",
"(i.e.,",
"a",
"downstream",
"value",
"chain",
"to",
"which",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"sell).",
"A",
"company",
"likewise",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"verify",
"occurrences",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"from",
"natural",
"sources",
"or",
"the",
"actions",
"of",
"third",
"parties",
"through",
"combustion,",
"spills",
"and",
"discharges,",
"disposal,",
"manufacturing",
"practices",
"or",
"incidents,",
"and",
"the",
"like.",
"When",
"EPA",
"insists",
"on",
"including",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"it",
"moves",
"well",
"past",
"the",
"\"major\"",
"uses",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"and",
"\"major\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"to",
"include",
"fleeting,",
"incidental,",
"minor,",
"isolated,",
"or",
"exceptional",
"cases.",
"Information",
"about",
"these",
"\"minor\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"may",
"be",
"well",
"outside",
"the",
"first-hand",
"knowledge",
"of",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor,",
"making",
"it",
"difficult",
"or",
"impossible",
"to",
"offer",
"meaningful",
"comment",
"during",
"the",
"scoping",
"period.",
"Second,",
"participation",
"in",
"notice",
"and",
"comment",
"rulemaking",
"is",
"governed",
"by",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act",
"(APA)",
"and",
"the",
"judicial",
"review",
"provisions",
"of",
"Section",
"19",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"Issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"can",
"be",
"imposed",
"by",
"statute.",
"Notably,",
"there",
"are",
"only",
"a",
"few",
"statutory",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"provisions",
"in",
"environmental",
"statutes,",
"the",
"most",
"notable",
"of",
"which",
"is",
"in",
"Section",
"307(d)(7)(b)",
"of",
"the",
"Clean",
"Air",
"Act.",
"There",
"are",
"none",
"in",
"TSCA.",
"Congress",
"had",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"for",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"in",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"-",
"and",
"declined",
"to",
"do",
"so.",
"EPA",
"cannot,",
"by",
"regulation,",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"that",
"trumps",
"the",
"statutory",
"rights",
"and",
"obligations",
"of",
"stakeholders",
"under",
"the",
"APA",
"and",
"TSCA",
"Section",
"19.",
"Indeed,",
"ACC",
"believes",
"a",
"waiver",
"provision",
"such",
"as",
"that",
"proposed",
"by",
"EPA",
"may",
"not",
"meet",
"Constitutional",
"muster.",
"Third,",
"the",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"rationally",
"advance",
"its",
"claimed",
"purpose",
"-",
"to",
"meet",
"statutory",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"deadlines.",
"An",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"is",
"supposed",
"to",
"serve",
"two",
"purposes:",
"it",
"19",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7566.",
"Administrative",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"are",
"largely",
"creatures",
"of",
"statute,",
"and",
"here",
"we",
"have",
"no",
"such",
"statutory",
"construct.",
"While",
"some",
"agency",
"regulations",
"set",
"out",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"without",
"a",
"statutory",
"mandate,",
"these",
"tend",
"to",
"be",
"in",
"administrative",
"appeal",
"situations",
"or",
"proceedings",
"that",
"are",
"analogs",
"to",
"adversarial",
"litigation.",
"Notably,",
"the",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"removed",
"a",
"procedure",
"for",
"formal",
"TSCA",
"hearings.",
"11/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
161,
109
],
[
164,
94,
202,
109
],
[
205,
94,
250,
109
],
[
253,
94,
270,
110
],
[
273,
93,
343,
110
],
[
346,
93,
429,
110
],
[
432,
93,
462,
110
],
[
466,
93,
542,
110
],
[
545,
93,
564,
110
],
[
567,
93,
595,
110
],
[
598,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
643,
110
],
[
647,
93,
678,
110
],
[
681,
93,
775,
110
],
[
778,
93,
865,
110
],
[
120,
110,
170,
126
],
[
174,
110,
211,
126
],
[
214,
110,
245,
126
],
[
250,
111,
332,
127
],
[
336,
111,
386,
127
],
[
390,
111,
409,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
434,
111,
492,
127
],
[
497,
111,
557,
127
],
[
561,
111,
634,
128
],
[
638,
111,
667,
128
],
[
670,
111,
756,
128
],
[
119,
146,
132,
161
],
[
136,
146,
182,
161
],
[
185,
146,
260,
161
],
[
264,
146,
312,
161
],
[
316,
146,
337,
161
],
[
341,
146,
364,
161
],
[
368,
146,
405,
161
],
[
410,
146,
427,
161
],
[
430,
145,
504,
161
],
[
507,
145,
525,
161
],
[
528,
145,
554,
161
],
[
557,
145,
589,
161
],
[
592,
145,
624,
161
],
[
627,
145,
664,
161
],
[
667,
145,
678,
161
],
[
680,
145,
727,
161
],
[
730,
145,
745,
161
],
[
748,
145,
831,
161
],
[
834,
145,
873,
161
],
[
117,
164,
173,
178
],
[
176,
164,
253,
179
],
[
256,
164,
273,
179
],
[
276,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
164,
395,
179
],
[
398,
164,
408,
179
],
[
412,
164,
480,
179
],
[
484,
164,
501,
179
],
[
504,
164,
590,
179
],
[
593,
164,
632,
179
],
[
635,
164,
654,
179
],
[
658,
164,
724,
179
],
[
728,
163,
844,
179
],
[
847,
163,
865,
178
],
[
868,
163,
885,
178
],
[
117,
181,
196,
196
],
[
199,
181,
279,
196
],
[
282,
182,
345,
196
],
[
348,
182,
375,
196
],
[
378,
182,
443,
196
],
[
446,
182,
464,
196
],
[
467,
182,
535,
196
],
[
538,
182,
556,
196
],
[
559,
182,
570,
196
],
[
572,
182,
648,
196
],
[
650,
182,
670,
196
],
[
672,
181,
704,
196
],
[
707,
181,
777,
197
],
[
118,
198,
226,
214
],
[
230,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
198,
365,
214
],
[
368,
198,
412,
213
],
[
417,
198,
442,
213
],
[
445,
198,
510,
213
],
[
514,
198,
531,
213
],
[
535,
198,
559,
213
],
[
562,
198,
595,
213
],
[
599,
198,
683,
213
],
[
177,
243,
196,
260
],
[
236,
246,
272,
260
],
[
278,
246,
325,
260
],
[
328,
246,
397,
260
],
[
400,
246,
429,
260
],
[
431,
246,
601,
261
],
[
604,
246,
656,
261
],
[
659,
246,
762,
261
],
[
765,
246,
846,
261
],
[
118,
280,
154,
295
],
[
159,
280,
213,
296
],
[
217,
280,
287,
296
],
[
291,
280,
322,
296
],
[
326,
280,
340,
296
],
[
343,
280,
370,
296
],
[
373,
280,
411,
296
],
[
415,
280,
447,
296
],
[
450,
280,
542,
296
],
[
545,
280,
567,
296
],
[
570,
280,
644,
296
],
[
647,
280,
775,
296
],
[
778,
280,
798,
296
],
[
801,
280,
872,
296
],
[
117,
296,
134,
312
],
[
137,
297,
195,
313
],
[
200,
297,
231,
313
],
[
234,
297,
317,
314
],
[
320,
298,
337,
314
],
[
341,
298,
377,
314
],
[
381,
298,
398,
314
],
[
401,
298,
447,
314
],
[
451,
298,
501,
314
],
[
504,
298,
524,
314
],
[
528,
298,
616,
314
],
[
619,
298,
712,
314
],
[
716,
298,
741,
314
],
[
744,
297,
818,
313
],
[
821,
297,
843,
313
],
[
846,
297,
872,
312
],
[
118,
315,
182,
331
],
[
187,
315,
262,
331
],
[
265,
315,
295,
331
],
[
298,
315,
381,
331
],
[
384,
315,
417,
331
],
[
420,
315,
450,
331
],
[
452,
315,
535,
331
],
[
538,
315,
555,
331
],
[
558,
315,
587,
331
],
[
590,
315,
627,
331
],
[
629,
315,
680,
331
],
[
682,
315,
759,
331
],
[
761,
315,
788,
331
],
[
790,
315,
849,
331
],
[
850,
315,
867,
330
],
[
117,
332,
143,
348
],
[
146,
332,
200,
348
],
[
202,
332,
252,
348
],
[
255,
332,
284,
348
],
[
287,
332,
365,
348
],
[
385,
332,
412,
348
],
[
416,
332,
452,
348
],
[
455,
332,
483,
348
],
[
487,
332,
547,
348
],
[
551,
332,
567,
348
],
[
570,
332,
631,
348
],
[
634,
332,
664,
348
],
[
668,
332,
710,
348
],
[
712,
332,
799,
348
],
[
802,
333,
870,
348
],
[
117,
351,
213,
366
],
[
217,
351,
242,
365
],
[
245,
351,
301,
365
],
[
304,
351,
366,
366
],
[
117,
385,
159,
400
],
[
162,
385,
174,
400
],
[
178,
385,
230,
400
],
[
233,
385,
252,
400
],
[
255,
385,
304,
400
],
[
307,
385,
364,
400
],
[
368,
385,
388,
400
],
[
391,
385,
417,
400
],
[
420,
385,
495,
401
],
[
498,
385,
601,
401
],
[
604,
385,
618,
401
],
[
621,
385,
700,
401
],
[
702,
386,
777,
400
],
[
779,
386,
814,
400
],
[
817,
386,
844,
400
],
[
847,
386,
871,
400
],
[
118,
404,
171,
417
],
[
174,
404,
192,
417
],
[
195,
404,
272,
417
],
[
275,
404,
294,
417
],
[
296,
404,
307,
417
],
[
310,
404,
375,
417
],
[
378,
404,
396,
417
],
[
400,
404,
451,
417
],
[
454,
404,
533,
417
],
[
536,
404,
566,
417
],
[
569,
404,
604,
417
],
[
607,
404,
639,
417
],
[
642,
404,
668,
417
],
[
671,
403,
745,
417
],
[
750,
403,
785,
417
],
[
788,
403,
816,
417
],
[
818,
403,
882,
417
],
[
118,
420,
154,
435
],
[
158,
420,
170,
435
],
[
175,
420,
264,
435
],
[
272,
420,
317,
435
],
[
320,
420,
362,
435
],
[
366,
420,
384,
435
],
[
387,
420,
437,
435
],
[
440,
420,
457,
435
],
[
460,
420,
492,
435
],
[
496,
420,
524,
435
],
[
527,
420,
574,
435
],
[
577,
420,
590,
435
],
[
594,
420,
668,
435
],
[
671,
420,
739,
435
],
[
741,
420,
777,
435
],
[
780,
420,
807,
435
],
[
810,
420,
831,
435
],
[
834,
420,
871,
435
],
[
118,
438,
135,
453
],
[
138,
438,
186,
453
],
[
190,
438,
284,
453
],
[
287,
438,
305,
453
],
[
309,
438,
319,
453
],
[
323,
438,
395,
453
],
[
398,
438,
434,
453
],
[
441,
438,
497,
453
],
[
501,
438,
561,
453
],
[
565,
438,
581,
453
],
[
585,
438,
611,
453
],
[
614,
438,
672,
453
],
[
676,
438,
692,
453
],
[
697,
438,
735,
453
],
[
738,
437,
791,
453
],
[
795,
437,
858,
453
],
[
118,
455,
216,
470
],
[
219,
456,
262,
470
],
[
265,
456,
298,
470
],
[
302,
456,
390,
471
],
[
392,
456,
461,
471
],
[
464,
456,
581,
471
],
[
584,
456,
657,
471
],
[
660,
456,
677,
470
],
[
680,
455,
759,
470
],
[
762,
455,
791,
470
],
[
794,
455,
820,
470
],
[
823,
455,
855,
470
],
[
118,
472,
166,
487
],
[
169,
472,
207,
487
],
[
210,
472,
262,
487
],
[
265,
472,
287,
487
],
[
290,
472,
365,
488
],
[
368,
472,
399,
488
],
[
402,
472,
485,
488
],
[
488,
472,
507,
488
],
[
510,
472,
545,
488
],
[
549,
472,
567,
488
],
[
571,
472,
595,
488
],
[
599,
472,
645,
488
],
[
649,
472,
666,
488
],
[
670,
472,
679,
488
],
[
682,
472,
715,
488
],
[
718,
472,
805,
488
],
[
808,
472,
822,
488
],
[
825,
472,
881,
487
],
[
118,
490,
152,
506
],
[
155,
489,
189,
506
],
[
193,
489,
217,
506
],
[
220,
489,
285,
506
],
[
290,
489,
324,
506
],
[
328,
489,
346,
506
],
[
350,
489,
358,
506
],
[
362,
489,
436,
506
],
[
440,
489,
468,
506
],
[
471,
489,
537,
506
],
[
541,
489,
600,
506
],
[
604,
489,
622,
506
],
[
626,
490,
697,
506
],
[
701,
490,
717,
506
],
[
721,
490,
781,
506
],
[
785,
490,
850,
506
],
[
118,
507,
201,
522
],
[
204,
507,
257,
522
],
[
261,
507,
328,
522
],
[
332,
508,
350,
523
],
[
353,
508,
445,
523
],
[
449,
508,
501,
523
],
[
504,
507,
601,
523
],
[
604,
507,
649,
523
],
[
652,
507,
693,
523
],
[
697,
507,
764,
523
],
[
767,
507,
827,
522
],
[
830,
506,
852,
522
],
[
118,
525,
188,
540
],
[
192,
525,
228,
540
],
[
231,
525,
252,
540
],
[
255,
525,
291,
540
],
[
294,
524,
352,
540
],
[
355,
524,
381,
540
],
[
384,
524,
461,
540
],
[
465,
524,
554,
540
],
[
557,
524,
575,
540
],
[
578,
524,
588,
540
],
[
591,
524,
698,
540
],
[
701,
525,
718,
540
],
[
722,
525,
804,
541
],
[
807,
525,
867,
541
],
[
870,
525,
885,
541
],
[
120,
542,
182,
557
],
[
186,
542,
202,
557
],
[
206,
542,
292,
557
],
[
296,
542,
314,
557
],
[
317,
542,
355,
557
],
[
359,
542,
451,
557
],
[
454,
542,
532,
558
],
[
535,
542,
585,
558
],
[
588,
542,
614,
558
],
[
617,
542,
679,
558
],
[
682,
542,
739,
558
],
[
119,
576,
180,
592
],
[
184,
576,
284,
592
],
[
288,
577,
305,
592
],
[
309,
577,
358,
592
],
[
362,
577,
391,
593
],
[
395,
577,
469,
593
],
[
472,
577,
562,
592
],
[
567,
577,
582,
592
],
[
586,
577,
659,
592
],
[
662,
576,
684,
592
],
[
688,
576,
714,
592
],
[
718,
576,
834,
592
],
[
119,
593,
199,
610
],
[
202,
594,
230,
610
],
[
234,
594,
289,
610
],
[
293,
594,
321,
610
],
[
324,
594,
350,
610
],
[
353,
594,
414,
610
],
[
418,
594,
471,
610
],
[
475,
594,
559,
610
],
[
563,
594,
581,
610
],
[
585,
594,
645,
610
],
[
650,
594,
669,
609
],
[
672,
594,
692,
609
],
[
696,
593,
755,
609
],
[
759,
593,
799,
609
],
[
117,
613,
203,
626
],
[
207,
613,
312,
627
],
[
314,
613,
342,
627
],
[
346,
613,
367,
627
],
[
369,
612,
438,
627
],
[
441,
612,
462,
627
],
[
467,
612,
529,
627
],
[
532,
612,
603,
627
],
[
606,
612,
647,
627
],
[
650,
612,
675,
627
],
[
679,
612,
715,
627
],
[
718,
612,
728,
627
],
[
732,
612,
758,
627
],
[
767,
612,
836,
627
],
[
839,
612,
880,
627
],
[
117,
629,
204,
643
],
[
207,
630,
290,
643
],
[
294,
630,
310,
643
],
[
313,
630,
430,
644
],
[
432,
630,
497,
644
],
[
500,
630,
527,
644
],
[
530,
630,
570,
644
],
[
573,
630,
632,
644
],
[
636,
630,
654,
644
],
[
657,
629,
706,
644
],
[
710,
629,
724,
644
],
[
727,
629,
745,
644
],
[
750,
629,
809,
644
],
[
117,
645,
217,
662
],
[
220,
646,
237,
661
],
[
240,
646,
267,
661
],
[
271,
646,
318,
661
],
[
322,
646,
350,
661
],
[
354,
646,
394,
661
],
[
398,
646,
442,
661
],
[
446,
646,
471,
661
],
[
475,
646,
514,
661
],
[
518,
646,
537,
661
],
[
540,
646,
595,
661
],
[
118,
681,
191,
697
],
[
194,
682,
224,
696
],
[
228,
682,
254,
696
],
[
258,
682,
350,
696
],
[
353,
682,
370,
696
],
[
374,
682,
432,
696
],
[
436,
682,
454,
696
],
[
458,
682,
501,
696
],
[
504,
682,
590,
696
],
[
593,
682,
690,
696
],
[
692,
682,
718,
696
],
[
721,
682,
747,
696
],
[
750,
681,
795,
696
],
[
798,
681,
817,
696
],
[
820,
681,
830,
696
],
[
833,
681,
864,
696
],
[
120,
698,
199,
714
],
[
203,
698,
220,
714
],
[
224,
698,
275,
714
],
[
278,
698,
372,
714
],
[
375,
698,
387,
714
],
[
390,
698,
424,
714
],
[
427,
698,
491,
714
],
[
495,
698,
514,
714
],
[
519,
698,
537,
714
],
[
540,
698,
568,
714
],
[
572,
698,
610,
714
],
[
614,
698,
672,
714
],
[
675,
699,
696,
714
],
[
700,
699,
786,
714
],
[
790,
699,
849,
715
],
[
852,
699,
872,
715
],
[
117,
716,
158,
731
],
[
162,
716,
247,
731
],
[
251,
717,
347,
732
],
[
351,
717,
382,
732
],
[
386,
717,
441,
732
],
[
445,
717,
470,
732
],
[
474,
717,
544,
732
],
[
547,
717,
594,
732
],
[
598,
716,
627,
732
],
[
630,
716,
720,
732
],
[
722,
716,
741,
731
],
[
744,
715,
845,
731
],
[
117,
734,
164,
748
],
[
167,
734,
194,
748
],
[
196,
733,
234,
749
],
[
240,
733,
271,
749
],
[
275,
733,
323,
749
],
[
329,
733,
390,
749
],
[
394,
733,
425,
749
],
[
439,
733,
501,
749
],
[
504,
733,
544,
749
],
[
548,
733,
615,
749
],
[
618,
733,
630,
749
],
[
632,
733,
687,
749
],
[
690,
734,
767,
749
],
[
770,
734,
808,
748
],
[
810,
734,
828,
748
],
[
831,
735,
864,
748
],
[
116,
751,
190,
768
],
[
194,
751,
216,
767
],
[
219,
751,
256,
767
],
[
260,
751,
295,
767
],
[
298,
751,
325,
767
],
[
329,
751,
370,
767
],
[
373,
751,
485,
767
],
[
488,
751,
551,
767
],
[
119,
786,
167,
801
],
[
170,
786,
195,
801
],
[
198,
786,
272,
801
],
[
275,
786,
309,
801
],
[
312,
786,
340,
801
],
[
342,
786,
420,
801
],
[
423,
786,
489,
801
],
[
492,
786,
514,
801
],
[
517,
786,
579,
801
],
[
582,
786,
647,
801
],
[
650,
786,
661,
801
],
[
665,
786,
681,
801
],
[
684,
786,
724,
801
],
[
728,
786,
797,
800
],
[
801,
786,
830,
800
],
[
118,
803,
201,
817
],
[
208,
804,
290,
818
],
[
294,
804,
318,
818
],
[
321,
804,
363,
818
],
[
367,
804,
451,
819
],
[
455,
804,
552,
819
],
[
555,
804,
571,
819
],
[
575,
804,
648,
819
],
[
652,
804,
669,
819
],
[
672,
804,
715,
819
],
[
718,
804,
748,
819
],
[
752,
804,
829,
819
],
[
832,
803,
845,
818
],
[
118,
834,
129,
850
],
[
132,
835,
148,
850
],
[
151,
836,
181,
851
],
[
185,
838,
217,
852
],
[
221,
839,
234,
852
],
[
238,
839,
274,
852
],
[
132,
852,
231,
865
],
[
234,
853,
268,
865
],
[
271,
853,
342,
866
],
[
345,
854,
432,
866
],
[
435,
854,
455,
866
],
[
458,
854,
507,
866
],
[
510,
854,
569,
866
],
[
572,
854,
587,
866
],
[
590,
854,
638,
866
],
[
641,
854,
665,
866
],
[
668,
854,
699,
866
],
[
702,
854,
721,
866
],
[
724,
854,
756,
866
],
[
759,
854,
777,
866
],
[
780,
853,
811,
866
],
[
814,
853,
871,
866
],
[
118,
868,
184,
880
],
[
186,
868,
227,
880
],
[
228,
868,
266,
880
],
[
268,
868,
315,
880
],
[
317,
868,
392,
881
],
[
395,
868,
415,
881
],
[
417,
868,
439,
881
],
[
441,
868,
477,
881
],
[
479,
868,
551,
881
],
[
553,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
695,
880
],
[
697,
868,
707,
880
],
[
709,
868,
767,
880
],
[
770,
868,
831,
880
],
[
833,
868,
868,
880
],
[
119,
883,
146,
895
],
[
148,
883,
164,
895
],
[
166,
883,
183,
895
],
[
185,
883,
200,
895
],
[
203,
883,
298,
896
],
[
300,
884,
345,
896
],
[
347,
884,
411,
896
],
[
414,
884,
428,
896
],
[
430,
884,
512,
896
],
[
514,
884,
541,
896
],
[
543,
884,
564,
896
],
[
567,
884,
618,
896
],
[
621,
883,
636,
896
],
[
638,
883,
711,
896
],
[
714,
883,
778,
895
],
[
780,
882,
840,
895
],
[
842,
882,
865,
895
],
[
117,
897,
159,
910
],
[
163,
897,
240,
910
],
[
242,
897,
302,
910
],
[
305,
897,
312,
910
],
[
315,
897,
383,
910
],
[
386,
897,
407,
910
],
[
410,
897,
455,
910
],
[
458,
897,
499,
910
],
[
502,
897,
568,
910
],
[
821,
941,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
Which section is for issue exhaustion provisions in environmentional statues?
|
Section 307(d)(7)(b) of the Clean Air Act
|
748
|
[
"F.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Generally",
"Exclude",
"Low",
"Exposure",
"Conditions",
"of",
"Use",
"from",
"the",
"Scopes",
"of",
"TSCA",
"Risk",
"Evaluations.",
"In",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"certain",
"scenarios",
"may",
"emerge",
"that",
"are",
"low-",
"to",
"no-exposure.",
"An",
"example",
"is",
"a",
"closed",
"system,",
"intermediate",
"chemical",
"manufacture",
"or",
"processing",
"at",
"an",
"industrial",
"site,",
"where",
"worker",
"exposure",
"is",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"controlled,",
"and",
"does",
"not",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"A",
"second",
"example",
"would",
"be",
"de",
"minimis",
"levels",
"of",
"an",
"impurity",
"in",
"a",
"consumer",
"product,",
"where",
"the",
"levels",
"and",
"variability",
"are",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"well",
"understood,",
"and",
"exposures",
"are",
"so",
"low",
"as",
"not",
"to",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"In",
"such",
"cases,",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"apparent",
"in",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"or",
"before",
"scoping",
"that",
"these",
"use",
"scenarios",
"can",
"readily",
"be",
"excluded",
"from",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"G.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Apply",
"the",
"\"Reasonably",
"Foreseen\"",
"Provision",
"as",
"a",
"Focusing",
"Tool",
"to",
"Help",
"Tailor",
"the",
"Scope",
"of",
"Risk",
"Evaluations",
"-",
"Not",
"to",
"Expand",
"Them.",
"The",
"statutory",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"is",
"\"the",
"circumstances,",
"as",
"determined",
"by",
"the",
"Administrator,",
"under",
"which",
"a",
"chemical",
"substances",
"is",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen",
"to",
"be",
"manufactured,",
"processed,",
"distributed",
"in",
"commerce,",
"used",
"or",
"disposed",
"of.\"10",
"The",
"phrase",
"\"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen\"",
"limits",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"may",
"be",
"identified",
"and",
"included",
"in",
"a",
"scope.",
"Clearly,",
"if",
"a",
"particular",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"a",
"statutory",
"\"condition",
"of",
"use\"",
"and",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"included",
"within",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"The",
"term",
"\"intended\"",
"is",
"generally",
"well",
"understood",
"to",
"mean",
"intended",
"by",
"the",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor.",
"Intention",
"can",
"be",
"demonstrated",
"through",
"express",
"(e.g.,",
"a",
"statement",
"to",
"that",
"effect",
"in",
"a",
"premanufacture",
"notice)",
"or",
"implied",
"evidence",
"(e.g.,",
"marketing",
"materials",
"that",
"imply",
"a",
"potential",
"application",
"for",
"the",
"chemical).",
"The",
"term",
"\"known\"",
"is",
"often",
"considered",
"a",
"backstop",
"for",
"the",
"term",
"\"intended,\"",
"in",
"that",
"manufacturers",
"or",
"processors",
"may",
"not",
"\"intend\"",
"or",
"support",
"a",
"particular",
"downstream",
"use",
"for",
"a",
"chemical",
"but",
"may",
"have",
"actual",
"or",
"imputed",
"knowledge",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"is",
"being",
"used",
"in",
"that",
"application.",
"The",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"also",
"includes",
"the",
"term",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"The",
"concept",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"is",
"well",
"understood",
"in",
"American",
"and",
"western\"",
"tort",
"law.",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"\"the",
"determinant",
"for",
"the",
"limits",
"of",
"duty",
"under",
"a",
"conventional",
"risk",
"analysis\"",
"[emphasis",
"added].\"",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"modified",
"by",
"\"reasonably,\"",
"which",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"not",
"every",
"conceivable",
"or",
"speculative",
"use",
"is",
"included.",
"Product",
"misuses",
"and",
"illegal",
"uses,",
"and",
"manufacturing",
"that",
"disregards",
"legal",
"and",
"industrial",
"hygiene",
"requirements,",
"are",
"not",
"\"reasonable\"",
"and",
"thus",
"not",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"10",
"TSCA",
"$3(4).",
"\"",
"See,",
"e.g.,",
"ANNEXURE",
"T,",
"The",
"Concept",
"of",
"Limited",
"Liability,",
"Existing",
"Law",
"and",
"Rationale",
"(Australia),",
"referring",
"to",
"the",
"limiting",
"tests",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"and",
"proximity,",
"available",
"at",
"MP:/www.ope.new",
"gov.an/.data/assets/pdf",
"me/0012/11406/T.pdf",
"Tyrus",
"V.",
"Dahl",
"Jr.,",
"Strict",
"Products",
"Liability:",
"The",
"Irrelevance",
"of",
"Foreseeability",
"and",
"Related",
"Negligence",
"Concepts,",
"14",
"Tulsa",
"L.",
"J.",
"338,",
"343",
"(1978).",
"8/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
91,
195,
106
],
[
237,
92,
273,
108
],
[
280,
92,
340,
109
],
[
344,
92,
428,
109
],
[
431,
93,
501,
110
],
[
504,
93,
540,
110
],
[
546,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
93,
724,
110
],
[
727,
93,
746,
109
],
[
749,
93,
780,
109
],
[
783,
93,
821,
109
],
[
829,
93,
860,
108
],
[
237,
111,
294,
126
],
[
296,
110,
317,
126
],
[
320,
110,
370,
126
],
[
375,
110,
415,
126
],
[
419,
110,
522,
127
],
[
117,
145,
134,
161
],
[
137,
145,
164,
161
],
[
167,
146,
270,
161
],
[
274,
147,
340,
161
],
[
344,
147,
398,
161
],
[
401,
147,
476,
161
],
[
480,
147,
515,
161
],
[
519,
147,
577,
161
],
[
581,
147,
612,
161
],
[
616,
147,
640,
161
],
[
644,
147,
682,
161
],
[
686,
147,
702,
161
],
[
706,
146,
815,
161
],
[
819,
146,
842,
161
],
[
117,
163,
185,
179
],
[
188,
164,
204,
179
],
[
207,
164,
217,
179
],
[
221,
164,
272,
179
],
[
275,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
439,
179
],
[
442,
164,
515,
179
],
[
518,
164,
618,
179
],
[
622,
164,
639,
179
],
[
643,
164,
728,
179
],
[
732,
164,
747,
179
],
[
751,
164,
770,
178
],
[
774,
163,
850,
178
],
[
118,
182,
152,
195
],
[
154,
182,
205,
196
],
[
207,
182,
265,
196
],
[
268,
182,
341,
196
],
[
343,
182,
360,
196
],
[
362,
182,
401,
196
],
[
403,
182,
499,
196
],
[
501,
182,
532,
196
],
[
534,
182,
621,
196
],
[
624,
182,
657,
196
],
[
661,
182,
694,
196
],
[
697,
182,
725,
196
],
[
728,
182,
787,
196
],
[
791,
182,
798,
195
],
[
118,
198,
200,
214
],
[
204,
198,
246,
213
],
[
250,
198,
263,
213
],
[
268,
198,
324,
213
],
[
328,
198,
395,
213
],
[
399,
198,
449,
213
],
[
452,
198,
477,
213
],
[
480,
198,
496,
213
],
[
500,
198,
563,
213
],
[
567,
198,
614,
213
],
[
618,
198,
637,
213
],
[
640,
198,
659,
213
],
[
662,
198,
731,
214
],
[
734,
199,
752,
214
],
[
755,
199,
766,
214
],
[
770,
199,
850,
214
],
[
116,
215,
184,
231
],
[
187,
215,
235,
231
],
[
239,
215,
265,
231
],
[
268,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
350,
231
],
[
353,
215,
435,
232
],
[
439,
215,
464,
232
],
[
468,
215,
506,
232
],
[
510,
215,
604,
232
],
[
607,
215,
638,
231
],
[
641,
215,
676,
231
],
[
680,
215,
772,
231
],
[
775,
216,
802,
231
],
[
117,
234,
198,
248
],
[
200,
234,
227,
248
],
[
230,
234,
249,
248
],
[
251,
234,
279,
248
],
[
286,
234,
304,
248
],
[
307,
234,
334,
248
],
[
337,
234,
354,
248
],
[
357,
234,
417,
248
],
[
420,
234,
430,
248
],
[
432,
233,
518,
248
],
[
520,
233,
562,
248
],
[
565,
233,
582,
248
],
[
587,
233,
623,
248
],
[
627,
233,
675,
248
],
[
678,
233,
691,
248
],
[
694,
233,
748,
248
],
[
751,
233,
772,
248
],
[
775,
233,
844,
248
],
[
847,
233,
864,
248
],
[
117,
250,
142,
265
],
[
146,
250,
248,
265
],
[
252,
250,
314,
265
],
[
317,
250,
334,
265
],
[
338,
250,
390,
265
],
[
394,
250,
455,
265
],
[
459,
251,
489,
265
],
[
492,
250,
534,
265
],
[
538,
250,
567,
265
],
[
571,
250,
645,
265
],
[
648,
250,
676,
265
],
[
680,
250,
734,
265
],
[
738,
250,
759,
265
],
[
763,
250,
834,
265
],
[
838,
250,
875,
265
],
[
117,
268,
143,
283
],
[
147,
267,
193,
283
],
[
197,
267,
213,
283
],
[
217,
267,
241,
283
],
[
245,
267,
277,
283
],
[
281,
268,
366,
283
],
[
176,
299,
201,
317
],
[
236,
302,
274,
317
],
[
280,
302,
341,
318
],
[
344,
302,
396,
318
],
[
400,
302,
427,
318
],
[
430,
302,
540,
318
],
[
543,
302,
628,
318
],
[
632,
302,
713,
318
],
[
717,
302,
735,
318
],
[
738,
302,
750,
318
],
[
754,
302,
832,
318
],
[
836,
302,
878,
318
],
[
235,
320,
253,
335
],
[
257,
320,
299,
335
],
[
304,
320,
356,
335
],
[
360,
320,
387,
335
],
[
390,
320,
440,
335
],
[
443,
320,
461,
335
],
[
465,
320,
505,
335
],
[
510,
320,
609,
335
],
[
612,
320,
623,
336
],
[
627,
320,
658,
336
],
[
662,
320,
681,
336
],
[
685,
320,
752,
336
],
[
756,
320,
806,
336
],
[
120,
355,
150,
370
],
[
152,
355,
224,
370
],
[
229,
355,
304,
370
],
[
307,
355,
325,
370
],
[
328,
355,
422,
370
],
[
425,
355,
442,
370
],
[
445,
355,
482,
370
],
[
485,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
538,
370
],
[
541,
355,
660,
370
],
[
662,
355,
684,
370
],
[
687,
355,
774,
370
],
[
777,
355,
798,
370
],
[
801,
355,
829,
370
],
[
120,
372,
233,
388
],
[
237,
372,
283,
388
],
[
287,
372,
336,
388
],
[
340,
372,
350,
388
],
[
354,
372,
425,
388
],
[
430,
372,
514,
388
],
[
518,
372,
531,
388
],
[
535,
372,
608,
388
],
[
612,
372,
672,
388
],
[
676,
372,
693,
388
],
[
697,
372,
784,
388
],
[
788,
372,
855,
388
],
[
858,
372,
875,
388
],
[
117,
389,
137,
404
],
[
140,
390,
254,
405
],
[
258,
391,
345,
405
],
[
348,
391,
430,
405
],
[
434,
391,
451,
405
],
[
454,
390,
542,
405
],
[
546,
390,
584,
405
],
[
587,
390,
608,
405
],
[
611,
389,
679,
404
],
[
682,
388,
728,
403
],
[
120,
424,
148,
440
],
[
151,
424,
204,
440
],
[
208,
424,
290,
440
],
[
294,
424,
354,
440
],
[
358,
424,
375,
440
],
[
379,
424,
465,
440
],
[
469,
424,
545,
440
],
[
550,
424,
596,
440
],
[
600,
424,
624,
440
],
[
628,
424,
711,
440
],
[
715,
425,
732,
440
],
[
736,
425,
763,
440
],
[
767,
425,
798,
440
],
[
802,
425,
836,
440
],
[
840,
425,
860,
440
],
[
117,
442,
194,
457
],
[
198,
442,
227,
457
],
[
230,
442,
300,
458
],
[
303,
442,
321,
458
],
[
324,
442,
334,
458
],
[
338,
442,
394,
458
],
[
397,
442,
460,
458
],
[
464,
442,
478,
458
],
[
481,
442,
490,
458
],
[
494,
442,
571,
458
],
[
575,
442,
602,
458
],
[
606,
442,
620,
458
],
[
624,
442,
651,
458
],
[
654,
442,
727,
458
],
[
731,
442,
792,
457
],
[
795,
443,
817,
457
],
[
117,
460,
205,
475
],
[
208,
460,
280,
475
],
[
283,
460,
295,
475
],
[
299,
460,
313,
475
],
[
316,
460,
344,
475
],
[
347,
460,
357,
475
],
[
361,
460,
431,
475
],
[
434,
460,
520,
475
],
[
523,
460,
540,
475
],
[
544,
460,
580,
475
],
[
583,
460,
612,
475
],
[
616,
460,
651,
475
],
[
654,
460,
682,
475
],
[
685,
460,
705,
475
],
[
708,
459,
778,
475
],
[
781,
459,
833,
474
],
[
836,
459,
864,
474
],
[
118,
477,
164,
492
],
[
168,
477,
184,
492
],
[
188,
477,
198,
491
],
[
202,
477,
232,
491
],
[
237,
476,
328,
492
],
[
118,
512,
150,
527
],
[
152,
512,
187,
527
],
[
193,
512,
280,
527
],
[
282,
512,
298,
527
],
[
301,
512,
377,
527
],
[
380,
512,
415,
527
],
[
418,
512,
507,
527
],
[
510,
512,
527,
527
],
[
530,
512,
574,
527
],
[
577,
512,
646,
527
],
[
650,
512,
671,
527
],
[
674,
512,
700,
526
],
[
703,
513,
810,
526
],
[
814,
513,
835,
526
],
[
120,
530,
204,
545
],
[
207,
530,
280,
545
],
[
284,
530,
311,
545
],
[
315,
530,
338,
545
],
[
341,
530,
445,
545
],
[
449,
530,
512,
545
],
[
515,
530,
576,
545
],
[
580,
530,
621,
545
],
[
625,
530,
634,
545
],
[
637,
530,
714,
545
],
[
718,
530,
734,
545
],
[
738,
530,
769,
545
],
[
773,
530,
818,
545
],
[
822,
530,
840,
545
],
[
843,
530,
852,
545
],
[
117,
548,
241,
562
],
[
245,
548,
301,
562
],
[
305,
548,
322,
562
],
[
325,
548,
388,
563
],
[
391,
548,
462,
563
],
[
465,
548,
507,
563
],
[
510,
548,
591,
563
],
[
593,
548,
668,
563
],
[
671,
548,
702,
562
],
[
705,
548,
754,
562
],
[
757,
548,
767,
562
],
[
770,
547,
841,
562
],
[
117,
565,
207,
579
],
[
210,
565,
234,
579
],
[
237,
565,
263,
579
],
[
266,
565,
355,
579
],
[
360,
565,
391,
579
],
[
394,
565,
427,
579
],
[
434,
565,
507,
579
],
[
511,
565,
525,
579
],
[
529,
565,
571,
579
],
[
574,
565,
660,
579
],
[
664,
565,
674,
579
],
[
677,
565,
749,
579
],
[
752,
565,
776,
579
],
[
780,
565,
805,
579
],
[
808,
565,
842,
579
],
[
120,
580,
208,
596
],
[
211,
581,
228,
596
],
[
232,
582,
262,
597
],
[
265,
582,
381,
597
],
[
384,
582,
400,
597
],
[
404,
582,
488,
597
],
[
492,
582,
527,
597
],
[
530,
582,
558,
597
],
[
561,
582,
630,
597
],
[
632,
582,
651,
597
],
[
654,
582,
715,
597
],
[
718,
582,
728,
597
],
[
731,
581,
811,
597
],
[
121,
600,
210,
615
],
[
218,
600,
246,
615
],
[
249,
600,
274,
615
],
[
277,
600,
287,
615
],
[
290,
600,
362,
615
],
[
365,
600,
392,
615
],
[
396,
600,
430,
615
],
[
434,
600,
474,
615
],
[
477,
600,
526,
615
],
[
530,
600,
547,
615
],
[
550,
600,
616,
615
],
[
620,
599,
707,
615
],
[
710,
599,
742,
615
],
[
745,
599,
755,
615
],
[
759,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
849,
614
],
[
117,
616,
162,
632
],
[
165,
617,
203,
632
],
[
207,
617,
224,
632
],
[
227,
617,
258,
632
],
[
261,
617,
354,
632
],
[
119,
650,
152,
667
],
[
156,
650,
230,
667
],
[
234,
651,
251,
667
],
[
255,
651,
347,
667
],
[
351,
651,
368,
667
],
[
371,
651,
409,
667
],
[
412,
651,
444,
668
],
[
448,
651,
514,
668
],
[
518,
651,
543,
668
],
[
547,
651,
583,
668
],
[
588,
651,
684,
667
],
[
688,
651,
772,
667
],
[
779,
651,
810,
667
],
[
813,
650,
878,
667
],
[
118,
668,
134,
683
],
[
138,
668,
224,
684
],
[
228,
669,
335,
684
],
[
338,
669,
354,
684
],
[
357,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
484,
684
],
[
487,
669,
505,
684
],
[
509,
669,
588,
684
],
[
591,
669,
621,
684
],
[
624,
669,
700,
684
],
[
703,
669,
731,
684
],
[
734,
669,
772,
684
],
[
116,
685,
229,
702
],
[
232,
686,
247,
702
],
[
251,
686,
288,
702
],
[
292,
686,
384,
702
],
[
388,
686,
411,
703
],
[
415,
686,
440,
703
],
[
443,
686,
491,
703
],
[
495,
686,
516,
703
],
[
520,
686,
552,
702
],
[
555,
686,
602,
702
],
[
606,
686,
615,
702
],
[
619,
686,
721,
702
],
[
724,
686,
756,
701
],
[
760,
685,
831,
701
],
[
118,
703,
198,
719
],
[
202,
703,
275,
720
],
[
282,
703,
395,
720
],
[
400,
703,
413,
720
],
[
417,
703,
490,
720
],
[
493,
703,
514,
720
],
[
518,
703,
627,
720
],
[
630,
703,
679,
720
],
[
682,
703,
735,
719
],
[
739,
703,
777,
719
],
[
781,
703,
812,
719
],
[
815,
703,
841,
718
],
[
118,
721,
162,
737
],
[
167,
721,
261,
737
],
[
265,
721,
282,
737
],
[
285,
721,
375,
737
],
[
379,
721,
406,
737
],
[
410,
721,
424,
737
],
[
428,
721,
507,
737
],
[
511,
721,
572,
736
],
[
576,
721,
640,
736
],
[
644,
721,
673,
736
],
[
677,
721,
727,
736
],
[
731,
721,
771,
736
],
[
774,
721,
801,
735
],
[
119,
738,
232,
755
],
[
236,
738,
270,
755
],
[
274,
738,
352,
755
],
[
356,
738,
395,
755
],
[
399,
738,
428,
755
],
[
431,
738,
507,
755
],
[
511,
738,
574,
755
],
[
578,
738,
687,
755
],
[
691,
738,
715,
754
],
[
719,
738,
746,
754
],
[
750,
737,
855,
754
],
[
118,
755,
147,
771
],
[
150,
755,
185,
772
],
[
188,
755,
214,
772
],
[
218,
755,
314,
772
],
[
318,
755,
397,
771
],
[
117,
820,
130,
835
],
[
133,
821,
177,
836
],
[
179,
823,
218,
837
],
[
117,
835,
128,
850
],
[
132,
836,
160,
850
],
[
164,
836,
192,
851
],
[
196,
837,
286,
852
],
[
290,
838,
305,
852
],
[
308,
838,
334,
852
],
[
338,
838,
392,
852
],
[
395,
839,
410,
852
],
[
413,
839,
465,
853
],
[
468,
839,
530,
853
],
[
534,
839,
588,
853
],
[
592,
840,
621,
853
],
[
625,
840,
648,
853
],
[
652,
839,
715,
852
],
[
718,
839,
794,
852
],
[
797,
839,
855,
852
],
[
859,
839,
874,
851
],
[
119,
853,
137,
866
],
[
141,
853,
194,
866
],
[
197,
853,
227,
866
],
[
231,
853,
244,
866
],
[
247,
853,
320,
867
],
[
322,
853,
412,
867
],
[
415,
854,
439,
867
],
[
442,
854,
513,
866
],
[
516,
854,
576,
866
],
[
579,
854,
594,
866
],
[
120,
868,
251,
882
],
[
254,
868,
420,
882
],
[
423,
867,
568,
882
],
[
137,
881,
175,
895
],
[
179,
881,
194,
895
],
[
198,
882,
231,
895
],
[
234,
882,
255,
895
],
[
258,
882,
294,
895
],
[
297,
882,
355,
895
],
[
359,
882,
422,
895
],
[
425,
883,
450,
895
],
[
453,
883,
528,
895
],
[
531,
883,
546,
896
],
[
549,
883,
642,
896
],
[
646,
883,
670,
896
],
[
672,
883,
724,
896
],
[
728,
882,
804,
896
],
[
807,
882,
875,
896
],
[
118,
896,
136,
909
],
[
138,
896,
175,
909
],
[
178,
896,
194,
909
],
[
196,
896,
208,
909
],
[
211,
896,
241,
910
],
[
244,
896,
269,
910
],
[
272,
896,
321,
910
],
[
830,
940,
882,
955
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
Define Foreseeability.
|
is "the determinant for the limits of duty under a conventional risk analysis"
|
743
|
[
"make",
"little",
"sense",
"to",
"continue",
"evaluating",
"that",
"condition",
"of",
"use",
"in",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"Otherwise,",
"EPA's",
"final",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"would",
"be",
"of",
"suspect",
"quality,",
"integrity,",
"and",
"reliability.",
"A",
"better",
"approach",
"would",
"be",
"for",
"EPA",
"to",
"articulate",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"that",
"after",
"a",
"scope",
"is",
"published,",
"EPA",
"retains",
"discretion",
"to",
"modify",
"it",
"upon",
"a",
"showing",
"of",
"substantial",
"need",
"or",
"changed",
"circumstances,",
"or",
"is",
"otherwise",
"warranted",
"because",
"the",
"addition",
"or",
"removal",
"of",
"a",
"condition",
"of",
"use,",
"properly",
"substantiated,",
"will",
"significantly",
"affect",
"the",
"conduct",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"J.",
"EPA",
"Must",
"Remove",
"the",
"Comment-or-Waive",
"(Issue",
"Exhaustion)",
"Proposal.",
"EPA",
"further",
"proposes",
"that",
"it",
"can",
"keep",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"on",
"schedule,",
"notwithstanding",
"its",
"proposal",
"to",
"include",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"every",
"scope,",
"by",
"\"providing",
"opportunity",
"for",
"comment",
"on",
"the",
"scoping",
"document",
"and",
"specifying",
"that",
"any",
"objections",
"to",
"the",
"draft",
"scope",
"document",
"are",
"waived",
"if",
"not",
"raised",
"during",
"this",
"process.\"",
"We",
"urge",
"the",
"Agency",
"to",
"remove",
"this",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"(waiver)",
"requirement",
"for",
"several",
"reasons.",
"First,",
"it",
"places",
"an",
"unfair",
"burden",
"on",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"A",
"particular",
"company",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"aware,",
"or",
"otherwise",
"in",
"a",
"position",
"to",
"verify,",
"particular",
"end",
"uses",
"that",
"the",
"company",
"does",
"not",
"support",
"(i.e.,",
"a",
"downstream",
"value",
"chain",
"to",
"which",
"it",
"does",
"not",
"sell).",
"A",
"company",
"likewise",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"able",
"to",
"verify",
"occurrences",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"from",
"natural",
"sources",
"or",
"the",
"actions",
"of",
"third",
"parties",
"through",
"combustion,",
"spills",
"and",
"discharges,",
"disposal,",
"manufacturing",
"practices",
"or",
"incidents,",
"and",
"the",
"like.",
"When",
"EPA",
"insists",
"on",
"including",
"\"all",
"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"in",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"it",
"moves",
"well",
"past",
"the",
"\"major\"",
"uses",
"of",
"a",
"chemical",
"and",
"\"major\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"to",
"include",
"fleeting,",
"incidental,",
"minor,",
"isolated,",
"or",
"exceptional",
"cases.",
"Information",
"about",
"these",
"\"minor\"",
"sources",
"of",
"exposure",
"may",
"be",
"well",
"outside",
"the",
"first-hand",
"knowledge",
"of",
"a",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor,",
"making",
"it",
"difficult",
"or",
"impossible",
"to",
"offer",
"meaningful",
"comment",
"during",
"the",
"scoping",
"period.",
"Second,",
"participation",
"in",
"notice",
"and",
"comment",
"rulemaking",
"is",
"governed",
"by",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act",
"(APA)",
"and",
"the",
"judicial",
"review",
"provisions",
"of",
"Section",
"19",
"of",
"TSCA.",
"Issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"can",
"be",
"imposed",
"by",
"statute.",
"Notably,",
"there",
"are",
"only",
"a",
"few",
"statutory",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"provisions",
"in",
"environmental",
"statutes,",
"the",
"most",
"notable",
"of",
"which",
"is",
"in",
"Section",
"307(d)(7)(b)",
"of",
"the",
"Clean",
"Air",
"Act.",
"There",
"are",
"none",
"in",
"TSCA.",
"Congress",
"had",
"the",
"opportunity",
"to",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"for",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"in",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"-",
"and",
"declined",
"to",
"do",
"so.",
"EPA",
"cannot,",
"by",
"regulation,",
"impose",
"an",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"that",
"trumps",
"the",
"statutory",
"rights",
"and",
"obligations",
"of",
"stakeholders",
"under",
"the",
"APA",
"and",
"TSCA",
"Section",
"19.",
"Indeed,",
"ACC",
"believes",
"a",
"waiver",
"provision",
"such",
"as",
"that",
"proposed",
"by",
"EPA",
"may",
"not",
"meet",
"Constitutional",
"muster.",
"Third,",
"the",
"proposal",
"does",
"not",
"rationally",
"advance",
"its",
"claimed",
"purpose",
"-",
"to",
"meet",
"statutory",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"deadlines.",
"An",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirement",
"is",
"supposed",
"to",
"serve",
"two",
"purposes:",
"it",
"19",
"82",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"at",
"7566.",
"Administrative",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"are",
"largely",
"creatures",
"of",
"statute,",
"and",
"here",
"we",
"have",
"no",
"such",
"statutory",
"construct.",
"While",
"some",
"agency",
"regulations",
"set",
"out",
"issue",
"exhaustion",
"requirements",
"without",
"a",
"statutory",
"mandate,",
"these",
"tend",
"to",
"be",
"in",
"administrative",
"appeal",
"situations",
"or",
"proceedings",
"that",
"are",
"analogs",
"to",
"adversarial",
"litigation.",
"Notably,",
"the",
"LCSA",
"amendment",
"removed",
"a",
"procedure",
"for",
"formal",
"TSCA",
"hearings.",
"11/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
117,
94,
161,
109
],
[
164,
94,
202,
109
],
[
205,
94,
250,
109
],
[
253,
94,
270,
110
],
[
273,
93,
343,
110
],
[
346,
93,
429,
110
],
[
432,
93,
462,
110
],
[
466,
93,
542,
110
],
[
545,
93,
564,
110
],
[
567,
93,
595,
110
],
[
598,
93,
614,
110
],
[
618,
93,
643,
110
],
[
647,
93,
678,
110
],
[
681,
93,
775,
110
],
[
778,
93,
865,
110
],
[
120,
110,
170,
126
],
[
174,
110,
211,
126
],
[
214,
110,
245,
126
],
[
250,
111,
332,
127
],
[
336,
111,
386,
127
],
[
390,
111,
409,
127
],
[
412,
111,
430,
127
],
[
434,
111,
492,
127
],
[
497,
111,
557,
127
],
[
561,
111,
634,
128
],
[
638,
111,
667,
128
],
[
670,
111,
756,
128
],
[
119,
146,
132,
161
],
[
136,
146,
182,
161
],
[
185,
146,
260,
161
],
[
264,
146,
312,
161
],
[
316,
146,
337,
161
],
[
341,
146,
364,
161
],
[
368,
146,
405,
161
],
[
410,
146,
427,
161
],
[
430,
145,
504,
161
],
[
507,
145,
525,
161
],
[
528,
145,
554,
161
],
[
557,
145,
589,
161
],
[
592,
145,
624,
161
],
[
627,
145,
664,
161
],
[
667,
145,
678,
161
],
[
680,
145,
727,
161
],
[
730,
145,
745,
161
],
[
748,
145,
831,
161
],
[
834,
145,
873,
161
],
[
117,
164,
173,
178
],
[
176,
164,
253,
179
],
[
256,
164,
273,
179
],
[
276,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
351,
179
],
[
354,
164,
395,
179
],
[
398,
164,
408,
179
],
[
412,
164,
480,
179
],
[
484,
164,
501,
179
],
[
504,
164,
590,
179
],
[
593,
164,
632,
179
],
[
635,
164,
654,
179
],
[
658,
164,
724,
179
],
[
728,
163,
844,
179
],
[
847,
163,
865,
178
],
[
868,
163,
885,
178
],
[
117,
181,
196,
196
],
[
199,
181,
279,
196
],
[
282,
182,
345,
196
],
[
348,
182,
375,
196
],
[
378,
182,
443,
196
],
[
446,
182,
464,
196
],
[
467,
182,
535,
196
],
[
538,
182,
556,
196
],
[
559,
182,
570,
196
],
[
572,
182,
648,
196
],
[
650,
182,
670,
196
],
[
672,
181,
704,
196
],
[
707,
181,
777,
197
],
[
118,
198,
226,
214
],
[
230,
198,
262,
214
],
[
266,
198,
365,
214
],
[
368,
198,
412,
213
],
[
417,
198,
442,
213
],
[
445,
198,
510,
213
],
[
514,
198,
531,
213
],
[
535,
198,
559,
213
],
[
562,
198,
595,
213
],
[
599,
198,
683,
213
],
[
177,
243,
196,
260
],
[
236,
246,
272,
260
],
[
278,
246,
325,
260
],
[
328,
246,
397,
260
],
[
400,
246,
429,
260
],
[
431,
246,
601,
261
],
[
604,
246,
656,
261
],
[
659,
246,
762,
261
],
[
765,
246,
846,
261
],
[
118,
280,
154,
295
],
[
159,
280,
213,
296
],
[
217,
280,
287,
296
],
[
291,
280,
322,
296
],
[
326,
280,
340,
296
],
[
343,
280,
370,
296
],
[
373,
280,
411,
296
],
[
415,
280,
447,
296
],
[
450,
280,
542,
296
],
[
545,
280,
567,
296
],
[
570,
280,
644,
296
],
[
647,
280,
775,
296
],
[
778,
280,
798,
296
],
[
801,
280,
872,
296
],
[
117,
296,
134,
312
],
[
137,
297,
195,
313
],
[
200,
297,
231,
313
],
[
234,
297,
317,
314
],
[
320,
298,
337,
314
],
[
341,
298,
377,
314
],
[
381,
298,
398,
314
],
[
401,
298,
447,
314
],
[
451,
298,
501,
314
],
[
504,
298,
524,
314
],
[
528,
298,
616,
314
],
[
619,
298,
712,
314
],
[
716,
298,
741,
314
],
[
744,
297,
818,
313
],
[
821,
297,
843,
313
],
[
846,
297,
872,
312
],
[
118,
315,
182,
331
],
[
187,
315,
262,
331
],
[
265,
315,
295,
331
],
[
298,
315,
381,
331
],
[
384,
315,
417,
331
],
[
420,
315,
450,
331
],
[
452,
315,
535,
331
],
[
538,
315,
555,
331
],
[
558,
315,
587,
331
],
[
590,
315,
627,
331
],
[
629,
315,
680,
331
],
[
682,
315,
759,
331
],
[
761,
315,
788,
331
],
[
790,
315,
849,
331
],
[
850,
315,
867,
330
],
[
117,
332,
143,
348
],
[
146,
332,
200,
348
],
[
202,
332,
252,
348
],
[
255,
332,
284,
348
],
[
287,
332,
365,
348
],
[
385,
332,
412,
348
],
[
416,
332,
452,
348
],
[
455,
332,
483,
348
],
[
487,
332,
547,
348
],
[
551,
332,
567,
348
],
[
570,
332,
631,
348
],
[
634,
332,
664,
348
],
[
668,
332,
710,
348
],
[
712,
332,
799,
348
],
[
802,
333,
870,
348
],
[
117,
351,
213,
366
],
[
217,
351,
242,
365
],
[
245,
351,
301,
365
],
[
304,
351,
366,
366
],
[
117,
385,
159,
400
],
[
162,
385,
174,
400
],
[
178,
385,
230,
400
],
[
233,
385,
252,
400
],
[
255,
385,
304,
400
],
[
307,
385,
364,
400
],
[
368,
385,
388,
400
],
[
391,
385,
417,
400
],
[
420,
385,
495,
401
],
[
498,
385,
601,
401
],
[
604,
385,
618,
401
],
[
621,
385,
700,
401
],
[
702,
386,
777,
400
],
[
779,
386,
814,
400
],
[
817,
386,
844,
400
],
[
847,
386,
871,
400
],
[
118,
404,
171,
417
],
[
174,
404,
192,
417
],
[
195,
404,
272,
417
],
[
275,
404,
294,
417
],
[
296,
404,
307,
417
],
[
310,
404,
375,
417
],
[
378,
404,
396,
417
],
[
400,
404,
451,
417
],
[
454,
404,
533,
417
],
[
536,
404,
566,
417
],
[
569,
404,
604,
417
],
[
607,
404,
639,
417
],
[
642,
404,
668,
417
],
[
671,
403,
745,
417
],
[
750,
403,
785,
417
],
[
788,
403,
816,
417
],
[
818,
403,
882,
417
],
[
118,
420,
154,
435
],
[
158,
420,
170,
435
],
[
175,
420,
264,
435
],
[
272,
420,
317,
435
],
[
320,
420,
362,
435
],
[
366,
420,
384,
435
],
[
387,
420,
437,
435
],
[
440,
420,
457,
435
],
[
460,
420,
492,
435
],
[
496,
420,
524,
435
],
[
527,
420,
574,
435
],
[
577,
420,
590,
435
],
[
594,
420,
668,
435
],
[
671,
420,
739,
435
],
[
741,
420,
777,
435
],
[
780,
420,
807,
435
],
[
810,
420,
831,
435
],
[
834,
420,
871,
435
],
[
118,
438,
135,
453
],
[
138,
438,
186,
453
],
[
190,
438,
284,
453
],
[
287,
438,
305,
453
],
[
309,
438,
319,
453
],
[
323,
438,
395,
453
],
[
398,
438,
434,
453
],
[
441,
438,
497,
453
],
[
501,
438,
561,
453
],
[
565,
438,
581,
453
],
[
585,
438,
611,
453
],
[
614,
438,
672,
453
],
[
676,
438,
692,
453
],
[
697,
438,
735,
453
],
[
738,
437,
791,
453
],
[
795,
437,
858,
453
],
[
118,
455,
216,
470
],
[
219,
456,
262,
470
],
[
265,
456,
298,
470
],
[
302,
456,
390,
471
],
[
392,
456,
461,
471
],
[
464,
456,
581,
471
],
[
584,
456,
657,
471
],
[
660,
456,
677,
470
],
[
680,
455,
759,
470
],
[
762,
455,
791,
470
],
[
794,
455,
820,
470
],
[
823,
455,
855,
470
],
[
118,
472,
166,
487
],
[
169,
472,
207,
487
],
[
210,
472,
262,
487
],
[
265,
472,
287,
487
],
[
290,
472,
365,
488
],
[
368,
472,
399,
488
],
[
402,
472,
485,
488
],
[
488,
472,
507,
488
],
[
510,
472,
545,
488
],
[
549,
472,
567,
488
],
[
571,
472,
595,
488
],
[
599,
472,
645,
488
],
[
649,
472,
666,
488
],
[
670,
472,
679,
488
],
[
682,
472,
715,
488
],
[
718,
472,
805,
488
],
[
808,
472,
822,
488
],
[
825,
472,
881,
487
],
[
118,
490,
152,
506
],
[
155,
489,
189,
506
],
[
193,
489,
217,
506
],
[
220,
489,
285,
506
],
[
290,
489,
324,
506
],
[
328,
489,
346,
506
],
[
350,
489,
358,
506
],
[
362,
489,
436,
506
],
[
440,
489,
468,
506
],
[
471,
489,
537,
506
],
[
541,
489,
600,
506
],
[
604,
489,
622,
506
],
[
626,
490,
697,
506
],
[
701,
490,
717,
506
],
[
721,
490,
781,
506
],
[
785,
490,
850,
506
],
[
118,
507,
201,
522
],
[
204,
507,
257,
522
],
[
261,
507,
328,
522
],
[
332,
508,
350,
523
],
[
353,
508,
445,
523
],
[
449,
508,
501,
523
],
[
504,
507,
601,
523
],
[
604,
507,
649,
523
],
[
652,
507,
693,
523
],
[
697,
507,
764,
523
],
[
767,
507,
827,
522
],
[
830,
506,
852,
522
],
[
118,
525,
188,
540
],
[
192,
525,
228,
540
],
[
231,
525,
252,
540
],
[
255,
525,
291,
540
],
[
294,
524,
352,
540
],
[
355,
524,
381,
540
],
[
384,
524,
461,
540
],
[
465,
524,
554,
540
],
[
557,
524,
575,
540
],
[
578,
524,
588,
540
],
[
591,
524,
698,
540
],
[
701,
525,
718,
540
],
[
722,
525,
804,
541
],
[
807,
525,
867,
541
],
[
870,
525,
885,
541
],
[
120,
542,
182,
557
],
[
186,
542,
202,
557
],
[
206,
542,
292,
557
],
[
296,
542,
314,
557
],
[
317,
542,
355,
557
],
[
359,
542,
451,
557
],
[
454,
542,
532,
558
],
[
535,
542,
585,
558
],
[
588,
542,
614,
558
],
[
617,
542,
679,
558
],
[
682,
542,
739,
558
],
[
119,
576,
180,
592
],
[
184,
576,
284,
592
],
[
288,
577,
305,
592
],
[
309,
577,
358,
592
],
[
362,
577,
391,
593
],
[
395,
577,
469,
593
],
[
472,
577,
562,
592
],
[
567,
577,
582,
592
],
[
586,
577,
659,
592
],
[
662,
576,
684,
592
],
[
688,
576,
714,
592
],
[
718,
576,
834,
592
],
[
119,
593,
199,
610
],
[
202,
594,
230,
610
],
[
234,
594,
289,
610
],
[
293,
594,
321,
610
],
[
324,
594,
350,
610
],
[
353,
594,
414,
610
],
[
418,
594,
471,
610
],
[
475,
594,
559,
610
],
[
563,
594,
581,
610
],
[
585,
594,
645,
610
],
[
650,
594,
669,
609
],
[
672,
594,
692,
609
],
[
696,
593,
755,
609
],
[
759,
593,
799,
609
],
[
117,
613,
203,
626
],
[
207,
613,
312,
627
],
[
314,
613,
342,
627
],
[
346,
613,
367,
627
],
[
369,
612,
438,
627
],
[
441,
612,
462,
627
],
[
467,
612,
529,
627
],
[
532,
612,
603,
627
],
[
606,
612,
647,
627
],
[
650,
612,
675,
627
],
[
679,
612,
715,
627
],
[
718,
612,
728,
627
],
[
732,
612,
758,
627
],
[
767,
612,
836,
627
],
[
839,
612,
880,
627
],
[
117,
629,
204,
643
],
[
207,
630,
290,
643
],
[
294,
630,
310,
643
],
[
313,
630,
430,
644
],
[
432,
630,
497,
644
],
[
500,
630,
527,
644
],
[
530,
630,
570,
644
],
[
573,
630,
632,
644
],
[
636,
630,
654,
644
],
[
657,
629,
706,
644
],
[
710,
629,
724,
644
],
[
727,
629,
745,
644
],
[
750,
629,
809,
644
],
[
117,
645,
217,
662
],
[
220,
646,
237,
661
],
[
240,
646,
267,
661
],
[
271,
646,
318,
661
],
[
322,
646,
350,
661
],
[
354,
646,
394,
661
],
[
398,
646,
442,
661
],
[
446,
646,
471,
661
],
[
475,
646,
514,
661
],
[
518,
646,
537,
661
],
[
540,
646,
595,
661
],
[
118,
681,
191,
697
],
[
194,
682,
224,
696
],
[
228,
682,
254,
696
],
[
258,
682,
350,
696
],
[
353,
682,
370,
696
],
[
374,
682,
432,
696
],
[
436,
682,
454,
696
],
[
458,
682,
501,
696
],
[
504,
682,
590,
696
],
[
593,
682,
690,
696
],
[
692,
682,
718,
696
],
[
721,
682,
747,
696
],
[
750,
681,
795,
696
],
[
798,
681,
817,
696
],
[
820,
681,
830,
696
],
[
833,
681,
864,
696
],
[
120,
698,
199,
714
],
[
203,
698,
220,
714
],
[
224,
698,
275,
714
],
[
278,
698,
372,
714
],
[
375,
698,
387,
714
],
[
390,
698,
424,
714
],
[
427,
698,
491,
714
],
[
495,
698,
514,
714
],
[
519,
698,
537,
714
],
[
540,
698,
568,
714
],
[
572,
698,
610,
714
],
[
614,
698,
672,
714
],
[
675,
699,
696,
714
],
[
700,
699,
786,
714
],
[
790,
699,
849,
715
],
[
852,
699,
872,
715
],
[
117,
716,
158,
731
],
[
162,
716,
247,
731
],
[
251,
717,
347,
732
],
[
351,
717,
382,
732
],
[
386,
717,
441,
732
],
[
445,
717,
470,
732
],
[
474,
717,
544,
732
],
[
547,
717,
594,
732
],
[
598,
716,
627,
732
],
[
630,
716,
720,
732
],
[
722,
716,
741,
731
],
[
744,
715,
845,
731
],
[
117,
734,
164,
748
],
[
167,
734,
194,
748
],
[
196,
733,
234,
749
],
[
240,
733,
271,
749
],
[
275,
733,
323,
749
],
[
329,
733,
390,
749
],
[
394,
733,
425,
749
],
[
439,
733,
501,
749
],
[
504,
733,
544,
749
],
[
548,
733,
615,
749
],
[
618,
733,
630,
749
],
[
632,
733,
687,
749
],
[
690,
734,
767,
749
],
[
770,
734,
808,
748
],
[
810,
734,
828,
748
],
[
831,
735,
864,
748
],
[
116,
751,
190,
768
],
[
194,
751,
216,
767
],
[
219,
751,
256,
767
],
[
260,
751,
295,
767
],
[
298,
751,
325,
767
],
[
329,
751,
370,
767
],
[
373,
751,
485,
767
],
[
488,
751,
551,
767
],
[
119,
786,
167,
801
],
[
170,
786,
195,
801
],
[
198,
786,
272,
801
],
[
275,
786,
309,
801
],
[
312,
786,
340,
801
],
[
342,
786,
420,
801
],
[
423,
786,
489,
801
],
[
492,
786,
514,
801
],
[
517,
786,
579,
801
],
[
582,
786,
647,
801
],
[
650,
786,
661,
801
],
[
665,
786,
681,
801
],
[
684,
786,
724,
801
],
[
728,
786,
797,
800
],
[
801,
786,
830,
800
],
[
118,
803,
201,
817
],
[
208,
804,
290,
818
],
[
294,
804,
318,
818
],
[
321,
804,
363,
818
],
[
367,
804,
451,
819
],
[
455,
804,
552,
819
],
[
555,
804,
571,
819
],
[
575,
804,
648,
819
],
[
652,
804,
669,
819
],
[
672,
804,
715,
819
],
[
718,
804,
748,
819
],
[
752,
804,
829,
819
],
[
832,
803,
845,
818
],
[
118,
834,
129,
850
],
[
132,
835,
148,
850
],
[
151,
836,
181,
851
],
[
185,
838,
217,
852
],
[
221,
839,
234,
852
],
[
238,
839,
274,
852
],
[
132,
852,
231,
865
],
[
234,
853,
268,
865
],
[
271,
853,
342,
866
],
[
345,
854,
432,
866
],
[
435,
854,
455,
866
],
[
458,
854,
507,
866
],
[
510,
854,
569,
866
],
[
572,
854,
587,
866
],
[
590,
854,
638,
866
],
[
641,
854,
665,
866
],
[
668,
854,
699,
866
],
[
702,
854,
721,
866
],
[
724,
854,
756,
866
],
[
759,
854,
777,
866
],
[
780,
853,
811,
866
],
[
814,
853,
871,
866
],
[
118,
868,
184,
880
],
[
186,
868,
227,
880
],
[
228,
868,
266,
880
],
[
268,
868,
315,
880
],
[
317,
868,
392,
881
],
[
395,
868,
415,
881
],
[
417,
868,
439,
881
],
[
441,
868,
477,
881
],
[
479,
868,
551,
881
],
[
553,
868,
642,
880
],
[
644,
868,
695,
880
],
[
697,
868,
707,
880
],
[
709,
868,
767,
880
],
[
770,
868,
831,
880
],
[
833,
868,
868,
880
],
[
119,
883,
146,
895
],
[
148,
883,
164,
895
],
[
166,
883,
183,
895
],
[
185,
883,
200,
895
],
[
203,
883,
298,
896
],
[
300,
884,
345,
896
],
[
347,
884,
411,
896
],
[
414,
884,
428,
896
],
[
430,
884,
512,
896
],
[
514,
884,
541,
896
],
[
543,
884,
564,
896
],
[
567,
884,
618,
896
],
[
621,
883,
636,
896
],
[
638,
883,
711,
896
],
[
714,
883,
778,
895
],
[
780,
882,
840,
895
],
[
842,
882,
865,
895
],
[
117,
897,
159,
910
],
[
163,
897,
240,
910
],
[
242,
897,
302,
910
],
[
305,
897,
312,
910
],
[
315,
897,
383,
910
],
[
386,
897,
407,
910
],
[
410,
897,
455,
910
],
[
458,
897,
499,
910
],
[
502,
897,
568,
910
],
[
821,
941,
882,
955
],
[
220,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
which act is for section 307(d)(7)(b)?
|
Clean Air Act
|
748
|
[
"F.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Generally",
"Exclude",
"Low",
"Exposure",
"Conditions",
"of",
"Use",
"from",
"the",
"Scopes",
"of",
"TSCA",
"Risk",
"Evaluations.",
"In",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"certain",
"scenarios",
"may",
"emerge",
"that",
"are",
"low-",
"to",
"no-exposure.",
"An",
"example",
"is",
"a",
"closed",
"system,",
"intermediate",
"chemical",
"manufacture",
"or",
"processing",
"at",
"an",
"industrial",
"site,",
"where",
"worker",
"exposure",
"is",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"controlled,",
"and",
"does",
"not",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"A",
"second",
"example",
"would",
"be",
"de",
"minimis",
"levels",
"of",
"an",
"impurity",
"in",
"a",
"consumer",
"product,",
"where",
"the",
"levels",
"and",
"variability",
"are",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"well",
"understood,",
"and",
"exposures",
"are",
"so",
"low",
"as",
"not",
"to",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"In",
"such",
"cases,",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"apparent",
"in",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"or",
"before",
"scoping",
"that",
"these",
"use",
"scenarios",
"can",
"readily",
"be",
"excluded",
"from",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"G.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Apply",
"the",
"\"Reasonably",
"Foreseen\"",
"Provision",
"as",
"a",
"Focusing",
"Tool",
"to",
"Help",
"Tailor",
"the",
"Scope",
"of",
"Risk",
"Evaluations",
"-",
"Not",
"to",
"Expand",
"Them.",
"The",
"statutory",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"is",
"\"the",
"circumstances,",
"as",
"determined",
"by",
"the",
"Administrator,",
"under",
"which",
"a",
"chemical",
"substances",
"is",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen",
"to",
"be",
"manufactured,",
"processed,",
"distributed",
"in",
"commerce,",
"used",
"or",
"disposed",
"of.\"10",
"The",
"phrase",
"\"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen\"",
"limits",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"may",
"be",
"identified",
"and",
"included",
"in",
"a",
"scope.",
"Clearly,",
"if",
"a",
"particular",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"a",
"statutory",
"\"condition",
"of",
"use\"",
"and",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"included",
"within",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"The",
"term",
"\"intended\"",
"is",
"generally",
"well",
"understood",
"to",
"mean",
"intended",
"by",
"the",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor.",
"Intention",
"can",
"be",
"demonstrated",
"through",
"express",
"(e.g.,",
"a",
"statement",
"to",
"that",
"effect",
"in",
"a",
"premanufacture",
"notice)",
"or",
"implied",
"evidence",
"(e.g.,",
"marketing",
"materials",
"that",
"imply",
"a",
"potential",
"application",
"for",
"the",
"chemical).",
"The",
"term",
"\"known\"",
"is",
"often",
"considered",
"a",
"backstop",
"for",
"the",
"term",
"\"intended,\"",
"in",
"that",
"manufacturers",
"or",
"processors",
"may",
"not",
"\"intend\"",
"or",
"support",
"a",
"particular",
"downstream",
"use",
"for",
"a",
"chemical",
"but",
"may",
"have",
"actual",
"or",
"imputed",
"knowledge",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"is",
"being",
"used",
"in",
"that",
"application.",
"The",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"also",
"includes",
"the",
"term",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"The",
"concept",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"is",
"well",
"understood",
"in",
"American",
"and",
"western\"",
"tort",
"law.",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"\"the",
"determinant",
"for",
"the",
"limits",
"of",
"duty",
"under",
"a",
"conventional",
"risk",
"analysis\"",
"[emphasis",
"added].\"",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"modified",
"by",
"\"reasonably,\"",
"which",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"not",
"every",
"conceivable",
"or",
"speculative",
"use",
"is",
"included.",
"Product",
"misuses",
"and",
"illegal",
"uses,",
"and",
"manufacturing",
"that",
"disregards",
"legal",
"and",
"industrial",
"hygiene",
"requirements,",
"are",
"not",
"\"reasonable\"",
"and",
"thus",
"not",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"10",
"TSCA",
"$3(4).",
"\"",
"See,",
"e.g.,",
"ANNEXURE",
"T,",
"The",
"Concept",
"of",
"Limited",
"Liability,",
"Existing",
"Law",
"and",
"Rationale",
"(Australia),",
"referring",
"to",
"the",
"limiting",
"tests",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"and",
"proximity,",
"available",
"at",
"MP:/www.ope.new",
"gov.an/.data/assets/pdf",
"me/0012/11406/T.pdf",
"Tyrus",
"V.",
"Dahl",
"Jr.,",
"Strict",
"Products",
"Liability:",
"The",
"Irrelevance",
"of",
"Foreseeability",
"and",
"Related",
"Negligence",
"Concepts,",
"14",
"Tulsa",
"L.",
"J.",
"338,",
"343",
"(1978).",
"8/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
91,
195,
106
],
[
237,
92,
273,
108
],
[
280,
92,
340,
109
],
[
344,
92,
428,
109
],
[
431,
93,
501,
110
],
[
504,
93,
540,
110
],
[
546,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
93,
724,
110
],
[
727,
93,
746,
109
],
[
749,
93,
780,
109
],
[
783,
93,
821,
109
],
[
829,
93,
860,
108
],
[
237,
111,
294,
126
],
[
296,
110,
317,
126
],
[
320,
110,
370,
126
],
[
375,
110,
415,
126
],
[
419,
110,
522,
127
],
[
117,
145,
134,
161
],
[
137,
145,
164,
161
],
[
167,
146,
270,
161
],
[
274,
147,
340,
161
],
[
344,
147,
398,
161
],
[
401,
147,
476,
161
],
[
480,
147,
515,
161
],
[
519,
147,
577,
161
],
[
581,
147,
612,
161
],
[
616,
147,
640,
161
],
[
644,
147,
682,
161
],
[
686,
147,
702,
161
],
[
706,
146,
815,
161
],
[
819,
146,
842,
161
],
[
117,
163,
185,
179
],
[
188,
164,
204,
179
],
[
207,
164,
217,
179
],
[
221,
164,
272,
179
],
[
275,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
439,
179
],
[
442,
164,
515,
179
],
[
518,
164,
618,
179
],
[
622,
164,
639,
179
],
[
643,
164,
728,
179
],
[
732,
164,
747,
179
],
[
751,
164,
770,
178
],
[
774,
163,
850,
178
],
[
118,
182,
152,
195
],
[
154,
182,
205,
196
],
[
207,
182,
265,
196
],
[
268,
182,
341,
196
],
[
343,
182,
360,
196
],
[
362,
182,
401,
196
],
[
403,
182,
499,
196
],
[
501,
182,
532,
196
],
[
534,
182,
621,
196
],
[
624,
182,
657,
196
],
[
661,
182,
694,
196
],
[
697,
182,
725,
196
],
[
728,
182,
787,
196
],
[
791,
182,
798,
195
],
[
118,
198,
200,
214
],
[
204,
198,
246,
213
],
[
250,
198,
263,
213
],
[
268,
198,
324,
213
],
[
328,
198,
395,
213
],
[
399,
198,
449,
213
],
[
452,
198,
477,
213
],
[
480,
198,
496,
213
],
[
500,
198,
563,
213
],
[
567,
198,
614,
213
],
[
618,
198,
637,
213
],
[
640,
198,
659,
213
],
[
662,
198,
731,
214
],
[
734,
199,
752,
214
],
[
755,
199,
766,
214
],
[
770,
199,
850,
214
],
[
116,
215,
184,
231
],
[
187,
215,
235,
231
],
[
239,
215,
265,
231
],
[
268,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
350,
231
],
[
353,
215,
435,
232
],
[
439,
215,
464,
232
],
[
468,
215,
506,
232
],
[
510,
215,
604,
232
],
[
607,
215,
638,
231
],
[
641,
215,
676,
231
],
[
680,
215,
772,
231
],
[
775,
216,
802,
231
],
[
117,
234,
198,
248
],
[
200,
234,
227,
248
],
[
230,
234,
249,
248
],
[
251,
234,
279,
248
],
[
286,
234,
304,
248
],
[
307,
234,
334,
248
],
[
337,
234,
354,
248
],
[
357,
234,
417,
248
],
[
420,
234,
430,
248
],
[
432,
233,
518,
248
],
[
520,
233,
562,
248
],
[
565,
233,
582,
248
],
[
587,
233,
623,
248
],
[
627,
233,
675,
248
],
[
678,
233,
691,
248
],
[
694,
233,
748,
248
],
[
751,
233,
772,
248
],
[
775,
233,
844,
248
],
[
847,
233,
864,
248
],
[
117,
250,
142,
265
],
[
146,
250,
248,
265
],
[
252,
250,
314,
265
],
[
317,
250,
334,
265
],
[
338,
250,
390,
265
],
[
394,
250,
455,
265
],
[
459,
251,
489,
265
],
[
492,
250,
534,
265
],
[
538,
250,
567,
265
],
[
571,
250,
645,
265
],
[
648,
250,
676,
265
],
[
680,
250,
734,
265
],
[
738,
250,
759,
265
],
[
763,
250,
834,
265
],
[
838,
250,
875,
265
],
[
117,
268,
143,
283
],
[
147,
267,
193,
283
],
[
197,
267,
213,
283
],
[
217,
267,
241,
283
],
[
245,
267,
277,
283
],
[
281,
268,
366,
283
],
[
176,
299,
201,
317
],
[
236,
302,
274,
317
],
[
280,
302,
341,
318
],
[
344,
302,
396,
318
],
[
400,
302,
427,
318
],
[
430,
302,
540,
318
],
[
543,
302,
628,
318
],
[
632,
302,
713,
318
],
[
717,
302,
735,
318
],
[
738,
302,
750,
318
],
[
754,
302,
832,
318
],
[
836,
302,
878,
318
],
[
235,
320,
253,
335
],
[
257,
320,
299,
335
],
[
304,
320,
356,
335
],
[
360,
320,
387,
335
],
[
390,
320,
440,
335
],
[
443,
320,
461,
335
],
[
465,
320,
505,
335
],
[
510,
320,
609,
335
],
[
612,
320,
623,
336
],
[
627,
320,
658,
336
],
[
662,
320,
681,
336
],
[
685,
320,
752,
336
],
[
756,
320,
806,
336
],
[
120,
355,
150,
370
],
[
152,
355,
224,
370
],
[
229,
355,
304,
370
],
[
307,
355,
325,
370
],
[
328,
355,
422,
370
],
[
425,
355,
442,
370
],
[
445,
355,
482,
370
],
[
485,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
538,
370
],
[
541,
355,
660,
370
],
[
662,
355,
684,
370
],
[
687,
355,
774,
370
],
[
777,
355,
798,
370
],
[
801,
355,
829,
370
],
[
120,
372,
233,
388
],
[
237,
372,
283,
388
],
[
287,
372,
336,
388
],
[
340,
372,
350,
388
],
[
354,
372,
425,
388
],
[
430,
372,
514,
388
],
[
518,
372,
531,
388
],
[
535,
372,
608,
388
],
[
612,
372,
672,
388
],
[
676,
372,
693,
388
],
[
697,
372,
784,
388
],
[
788,
372,
855,
388
],
[
858,
372,
875,
388
],
[
117,
389,
137,
404
],
[
140,
390,
254,
405
],
[
258,
391,
345,
405
],
[
348,
391,
430,
405
],
[
434,
391,
451,
405
],
[
454,
390,
542,
405
],
[
546,
390,
584,
405
],
[
587,
390,
608,
405
],
[
611,
389,
679,
404
],
[
682,
388,
728,
403
],
[
120,
424,
148,
440
],
[
151,
424,
204,
440
],
[
208,
424,
290,
440
],
[
294,
424,
354,
440
],
[
358,
424,
375,
440
],
[
379,
424,
465,
440
],
[
469,
424,
545,
440
],
[
550,
424,
596,
440
],
[
600,
424,
624,
440
],
[
628,
424,
711,
440
],
[
715,
425,
732,
440
],
[
736,
425,
763,
440
],
[
767,
425,
798,
440
],
[
802,
425,
836,
440
],
[
840,
425,
860,
440
],
[
117,
442,
194,
457
],
[
198,
442,
227,
457
],
[
230,
442,
300,
458
],
[
303,
442,
321,
458
],
[
324,
442,
334,
458
],
[
338,
442,
394,
458
],
[
397,
442,
460,
458
],
[
464,
442,
478,
458
],
[
481,
442,
490,
458
],
[
494,
442,
571,
458
],
[
575,
442,
602,
458
],
[
606,
442,
620,
458
],
[
624,
442,
651,
458
],
[
654,
442,
727,
458
],
[
731,
442,
792,
457
],
[
795,
443,
817,
457
],
[
117,
460,
205,
475
],
[
208,
460,
280,
475
],
[
283,
460,
295,
475
],
[
299,
460,
313,
475
],
[
316,
460,
344,
475
],
[
347,
460,
357,
475
],
[
361,
460,
431,
475
],
[
434,
460,
520,
475
],
[
523,
460,
540,
475
],
[
544,
460,
580,
475
],
[
583,
460,
612,
475
],
[
616,
460,
651,
475
],
[
654,
460,
682,
475
],
[
685,
460,
705,
475
],
[
708,
459,
778,
475
],
[
781,
459,
833,
474
],
[
836,
459,
864,
474
],
[
118,
477,
164,
492
],
[
168,
477,
184,
492
],
[
188,
477,
198,
491
],
[
202,
477,
232,
491
],
[
237,
476,
328,
492
],
[
118,
512,
150,
527
],
[
152,
512,
187,
527
],
[
193,
512,
280,
527
],
[
282,
512,
298,
527
],
[
301,
512,
377,
527
],
[
380,
512,
415,
527
],
[
418,
512,
507,
527
],
[
510,
512,
527,
527
],
[
530,
512,
574,
527
],
[
577,
512,
646,
527
],
[
650,
512,
671,
527
],
[
674,
512,
700,
526
],
[
703,
513,
810,
526
],
[
814,
513,
835,
526
],
[
120,
530,
204,
545
],
[
207,
530,
280,
545
],
[
284,
530,
311,
545
],
[
315,
530,
338,
545
],
[
341,
530,
445,
545
],
[
449,
530,
512,
545
],
[
515,
530,
576,
545
],
[
580,
530,
621,
545
],
[
625,
530,
634,
545
],
[
637,
530,
714,
545
],
[
718,
530,
734,
545
],
[
738,
530,
769,
545
],
[
773,
530,
818,
545
],
[
822,
530,
840,
545
],
[
843,
530,
852,
545
],
[
117,
548,
241,
562
],
[
245,
548,
301,
562
],
[
305,
548,
322,
562
],
[
325,
548,
388,
563
],
[
391,
548,
462,
563
],
[
465,
548,
507,
563
],
[
510,
548,
591,
563
],
[
593,
548,
668,
563
],
[
671,
548,
702,
562
],
[
705,
548,
754,
562
],
[
757,
548,
767,
562
],
[
770,
547,
841,
562
],
[
117,
565,
207,
579
],
[
210,
565,
234,
579
],
[
237,
565,
263,
579
],
[
266,
565,
355,
579
],
[
360,
565,
391,
579
],
[
394,
565,
427,
579
],
[
434,
565,
507,
579
],
[
511,
565,
525,
579
],
[
529,
565,
571,
579
],
[
574,
565,
660,
579
],
[
664,
565,
674,
579
],
[
677,
565,
749,
579
],
[
752,
565,
776,
579
],
[
780,
565,
805,
579
],
[
808,
565,
842,
579
],
[
120,
580,
208,
596
],
[
211,
581,
228,
596
],
[
232,
582,
262,
597
],
[
265,
582,
381,
597
],
[
384,
582,
400,
597
],
[
404,
582,
488,
597
],
[
492,
582,
527,
597
],
[
530,
582,
558,
597
],
[
561,
582,
630,
597
],
[
632,
582,
651,
597
],
[
654,
582,
715,
597
],
[
718,
582,
728,
597
],
[
731,
581,
811,
597
],
[
121,
600,
210,
615
],
[
218,
600,
246,
615
],
[
249,
600,
274,
615
],
[
277,
600,
287,
615
],
[
290,
600,
362,
615
],
[
365,
600,
392,
615
],
[
396,
600,
430,
615
],
[
434,
600,
474,
615
],
[
477,
600,
526,
615
],
[
530,
600,
547,
615
],
[
550,
600,
616,
615
],
[
620,
599,
707,
615
],
[
710,
599,
742,
615
],
[
745,
599,
755,
615
],
[
759,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
849,
614
],
[
117,
616,
162,
632
],
[
165,
617,
203,
632
],
[
207,
617,
224,
632
],
[
227,
617,
258,
632
],
[
261,
617,
354,
632
],
[
119,
650,
152,
667
],
[
156,
650,
230,
667
],
[
234,
651,
251,
667
],
[
255,
651,
347,
667
],
[
351,
651,
368,
667
],
[
371,
651,
409,
667
],
[
412,
651,
444,
668
],
[
448,
651,
514,
668
],
[
518,
651,
543,
668
],
[
547,
651,
583,
668
],
[
588,
651,
684,
667
],
[
688,
651,
772,
667
],
[
779,
651,
810,
667
],
[
813,
650,
878,
667
],
[
118,
668,
134,
683
],
[
138,
668,
224,
684
],
[
228,
669,
335,
684
],
[
338,
669,
354,
684
],
[
357,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
484,
684
],
[
487,
669,
505,
684
],
[
509,
669,
588,
684
],
[
591,
669,
621,
684
],
[
624,
669,
700,
684
],
[
703,
669,
731,
684
],
[
734,
669,
772,
684
],
[
116,
685,
229,
702
],
[
232,
686,
247,
702
],
[
251,
686,
288,
702
],
[
292,
686,
384,
702
],
[
388,
686,
411,
703
],
[
415,
686,
440,
703
],
[
443,
686,
491,
703
],
[
495,
686,
516,
703
],
[
520,
686,
552,
702
],
[
555,
686,
602,
702
],
[
606,
686,
615,
702
],
[
619,
686,
721,
702
],
[
724,
686,
756,
701
],
[
760,
685,
831,
701
],
[
118,
703,
198,
719
],
[
202,
703,
275,
720
],
[
282,
703,
395,
720
],
[
400,
703,
413,
720
],
[
417,
703,
490,
720
],
[
493,
703,
514,
720
],
[
518,
703,
627,
720
],
[
630,
703,
679,
720
],
[
682,
703,
735,
719
],
[
739,
703,
777,
719
],
[
781,
703,
812,
719
],
[
815,
703,
841,
718
],
[
118,
721,
162,
737
],
[
167,
721,
261,
737
],
[
265,
721,
282,
737
],
[
285,
721,
375,
737
],
[
379,
721,
406,
737
],
[
410,
721,
424,
737
],
[
428,
721,
507,
737
],
[
511,
721,
572,
736
],
[
576,
721,
640,
736
],
[
644,
721,
673,
736
],
[
677,
721,
727,
736
],
[
731,
721,
771,
736
],
[
774,
721,
801,
735
],
[
119,
738,
232,
755
],
[
236,
738,
270,
755
],
[
274,
738,
352,
755
],
[
356,
738,
395,
755
],
[
399,
738,
428,
755
],
[
431,
738,
507,
755
],
[
511,
738,
574,
755
],
[
578,
738,
687,
755
],
[
691,
738,
715,
754
],
[
719,
738,
746,
754
],
[
750,
737,
855,
754
],
[
118,
755,
147,
771
],
[
150,
755,
185,
772
],
[
188,
755,
214,
772
],
[
218,
755,
314,
772
],
[
318,
755,
397,
771
],
[
117,
820,
130,
835
],
[
133,
821,
177,
836
],
[
179,
823,
218,
837
],
[
117,
835,
128,
850
],
[
132,
836,
160,
850
],
[
164,
836,
192,
851
],
[
196,
837,
286,
852
],
[
290,
838,
305,
852
],
[
308,
838,
334,
852
],
[
338,
838,
392,
852
],
[
395,
839,
410,
852
],
[
413,
839,
465,
853
],
[
468,
839,
530,
853
],
[
534,
839,
588,
853
],
[
592,
840,
621,
853
],
[
625,
840,
648,
853
],
[
652,
839,
715,
852
],
[
718,
839,
794,
852
],
[
797,
839,
855,
852
],
[
859,
839,
874,
851
],
[
119,
853,
137,
866
],
[
141,
853,
194,
866
],
[
197,
853,
227,
866
],
[
231,
853,
244,
866
],
[
247,
853,
320,
867
],
[
322,
853,
412,
867
],
[
415,
854,
439,
867
],
[
442,
854,
513,
866
],
[
516,
854,
576,
866
],
[
579,
854,
594,
866
],
[
120,
868,
251,
882
],
[
254,
868,
420,
882
],
[
423,
867,
568,
882
],
[
137,
881,
175,
895
],
[
179,
881,
194,
895
],
[
198,
882,
231,
895
],
[
234,
882,
255,
895
],
[
258,
882,
294,
895
],
[
297,
882,
355,
895
],
[
359,
882,
422,
895
],
[
425,
883,
450,
895
],
[
453,
883,
528,
895
],
[
531,
883,
546,
896
],
[
549,
883,
642,
896
],
[
646,
883,
670,
896
],
[
672,
883,
724,
896
],
[
728,
882,
804,
896
],
[
807,
882,
875,
896
],
[
118,
896,
136,
909
],
[
138,
896,
175,
909
],
[
178,
896,
194,
909
],
[
196,
896,
208,
909
],
[
211,
896,
241,
910
],
[
244,
896,
269,
910
],
[
272,
896,
321,
910
],
[
830,
940,
882,
955
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
What should EPA exclude from the Scopes of TSCA Risk Evaluations?
|
Exclude Low Exposure Conditions of Use
|
748
|
[
"F.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Generally",
"Exclude",
"Low",
"Exposure",
"Conditions",
"of",
"Use",
"from",
"the",
"Scopes",
"of",
"TSCA",
"Risk",
"Evaluations.",
"In",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process,",
"certain",
"scenarios",
"may",
"emerge",
"that",
"are",
"low-",
"to",
"no-exposure.",
"An",
"example",
"is",
"a",
"closed",
"system,",
"intermediate",
"chemical",
"manufacture",
"or",
"processing",
"at",
"an",
"industrial",
"site,",
"where",
"worker",
"exposure",
"is",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"controlled,",
"and",
"does",
"not",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"A",
"second",
"example",
"would",
"be",
"de",
"minimis",
"levels",
"of",
"an",
"impurity",
"in",
"a",
"consumer",
"product,",
"where",
"the",
"levels",
"and",
"variability",
"are",
"well",
"documented",
"and",
"well",
"understood,",
"and",
"exposures",
"are",
"so",
"low",
"as",
"not",
"to",
"present",
"a",
"significant",
"risk.",
"In",
"such",
"cases,",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"apparent",
"in",
"the",
"prioritization",
"process",
"or",
"before",
"scoping",
"that",
"these",
"use",
"scenarios",
"can",
"readily",
"be",
"excluded",
"from",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"G.",
"EPA",
"Should",
"Apply",
"the",
"\"Reasonably",
"Foreseen\"",
"Provision",
"as",
"a",
"Focusing",
"Tool",
"to",
"Help",
"Tailor",
"the",
"Scope",
"of",
"Risk",
"Evaluations",
"-",
"Not",
"to",
"Expand",
"Them.",
"The",
"statutory",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"is",
"\"the",
"circumstances,",
"as",
"determined",
"by",
"the",
"Administrator,",
"under",
"which",
"a",
"chemical",
"substances",
"is",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen",
"to",
"be",
"manufactured,",
"processed,",
"distributed",
"in",
"commerce,",
"used",
"or",
"disposed",
"of.\"10",
"The",
"phrase",
"\"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen\"",
"limits",
"the",
"conditions",
"of",
"use",
"that",
"may",
"be",
"identified",
"and",
"included",
"in",
"a",
"scope.",
"Clearly,",
"if",
"a",
"particular",
"use",
"is",
"not",
"intended,",
"known,",
"or",
"reasonably",
"foreseen,",
"it",
"is",
"not",
"a",
"statutory",
"\"condition",
"of",
"use\"",
"and",
"may",
"not",
"be",
"included",
"within",
"the",
"scope",
"of",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation.",
"The",
"term",
"\"intended\"",
"is",
"generally",
"well",
"understood",
"to",
"mean",
"intended",
"by",
"the",
"manufacturer",
"or",
"processor.",
"Intention",
"can",
"be",
"demonstrated",
"through",
"express",
"(e.g.,",
"a",
"statement",
"to",
"that",
"effect",
"in",
"a",
"premanufacture",
"notice)",
"or",
"implied",
"evidence",
"(e.g.,",
"marketing",
"materials",
"that",
"imply",
"a",
"potential",
"application",
"for",
"the",
"chemical).",
"The",
"term",
"\"known\"",
"is",
"often",
"considered",
"a",
"backstop",
"for",
"the",
"term",
"\"intended,\"",
"in",
"that",
"manufacturers",
"or",
"processors",
"may",
"not",
"\"intend\"",
"or",
"support",
"a",
"particular",
"downstream",
"use",
"for",
"a",
"chemical",
"but",
"may",
"have",
"actual",
"or",
"imputed",
"knowledge",
"that",
"a",
"chemical",
"is",
"being",
"used",
"in",
"that",
"application.",
"The",
"definition",
"of",
"\"conditions",
"of",
"use\"",
"also",
"includes",
"the",
"term",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"The",
"concept",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"is",
"well",
"understood",
"in",
"American",
"and",
"western\"",
"tort",
"law.",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"\"the",
"determinant",
"for",
"the",
"limits",
"of",
"duty",
"under",
"a",
"conventional",
"risk",
"analysis\"",
"[emphasis",
"added].\"",
"Foreseeability",
"is",
"modified",
"by",
"\"reasonably,\"",
"which",
"makes",
"clear",
"that",
"not",
"every",
"conceivable",
"or",
"speculative",
"use",
"is",
"included.",
"Product",
"misuses",
"and",
"illegal",
"uses,",
"and",
"manufacturing",
"that",
"disregards",
"legal",
"and",
"industrial",
"hygiene",
"requirements,",
"are",
"not",
"\"reasonable\"",
"and",
"thus",
"not",
"\"reasonably",
"foreseen.\"",
"10",
"TSCA",
"$3(4).",
"\"",
"See,",
"e.g.,",
"ANNEXURE",
"T,",
"The",
"Concept",
"of",
"Limited",
"Liability,",
"Existing",
"Law",
"and",
"Rationale",
"(Australia),",
"referring",
"to",
"the",
"limiting",
"tests",
"of",
"reasonable",
"foreseeability",
"and",
"proximity,",
"available",
"at",
"MP:/www.ope.new",
"gov.an/.data/assets/pdf",
"me/0012/11406/T.pdf",
"Tyrus",
"V.",
"Dahl",
"Jr.,",
"Strict",
"Products",
"Liability:",
"The",
"Irrelevance",
"of",
"Foreseeability",
"and",
"Related",
"Negligence",
"Concepts,",
"14",
"Tulsa",
"L.",
"J.",
"338,",
"343",
"(1978).",
"8/Page",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/kzbn0226"
] |
[
[
177,
91,
195,
106
],
[
237,
92,
273,
108
],
[
280,
92,
340,
109
],
[
344,
92,
428,
109
],
[
431,
93,
501,
110
],
[
504,
93,
540,
110
],
[
546,
93,
628,
110
],
[
631,
93,
724,
110
],
[
727,
93,
746,
109
],
[
749,
93,
780,
109
],
[
783,
93,
821,
109
],
[
829,
93,
860,
108
],
[
237,
111,
294,
126
],
[
296,
110,
317,
126
],
[
320,
110,
370,
126
],
[
375,
110,
415,
126
],
[
419,
110,
522,
127
],
[
117,
145,
134,
161
],
[
137,
145,
164,
161
],
[
167,
146,
270,
161
],
[
274,
147,
340,
161
],
[
344,
147,
398,
161
],
[
401,
147,
476,
161
],
[
480,
147,
515,
161
],
[
519,
147,
577,
161
],
[
581,
147,
612,
161
],
[
616,
147,
640,
161
],
[
644,
147,
682,
161
],
[
686,
147,
702,
161
],
[
706,
146,
815,
161
],
[
819,
146,
842,
161
],
[
117,
163,
185,
179
],
[
188,
164,
204,
179
],
[
207,
164,
217,
179
],
[
221,
164,
272,
179
],
[
275,
164,
335,
179
],
[
338,
164,
439,
179
],
[
442,
164,
515,
179
],
[
518,
164,
618,
179
],
[
622,
164,
639,
179
],
[
643,
164,
728,
179
],
[
732,
164,
747,
179
],
[
751,
164,
770,
178
],
[
774,
163,
850,
178
],
[
118,
182,
152,
195
],
[
154,
182,
205,
196
],
[
207,
182,
265,
196
],
[
268,
182,
341,
196
],
[
343,
182,
360,
196
],
[
362,
182,
401,
196
],
[
403,
182,
499,
196
],
[
501,
182,
532,
196
],
[
534,
182,
621,
196
],
[
624,
182,
657,
196
],
[
661,
182,
694,
196
],
[
697,
182,
725,
196
],
[
728,
182,
787,
196
],
[
791,
182,
798,
195
],
[
118,
198,
200,
214
],
[
204,
198,
246,
213
],
[
250,
198,
263,
213
],
[
268,
198,
324,
213
],
[
328,
198,
395,
213
],
[
399,
198,
449,
213
],
[
452,
198,
477,
213
],
[
480,
198,
496,
213
],
[
500,
198,
563,
213
],
[
567,
198,
614,
213
],
[
618,
198,
637,
213
],
[
640,
198,
659,
213
],
[
662,
198,
731,
214
],
[
734,
199,
752,
214
],
[
755,
199,
766,
214
],
[
770,
199,
850,
214
],
[
116,
215,
184,
231
],
[
187,
215,
235,
231
],
[
239,
215,
265,
231
],
[
268,
215,
317,
231
],
[
320,
215,
350,
231
],
[
353,
215,
435,
232
],
[
439,
215,
464,
232
],
[
468,
215,
506,
232
],
[
510,
215,
604,
232
],
[
607,
215,
638,
231
],
[
641,
215,
676,
231
],
[
680,
215,
772,
231
],
[
775,
216,
802,
231
],
[
117,
234,
198,
248
],
[
200,
234,
227,
248
],
[
230,
234,
249,
248
],
[
251,
234,
279,
248
],
[
286,
234,
304,
248
],
[
307,
234,
334,
248
],
[
337,
234,
354,
248
],
[
357,
234,
417,
248
],
[
420,
234,
430,
248
],
[
432,
233,
518,
248
],
[
520,
233,
562,
248
],
[
565,
233,
582,
248
],
[
587,
233,
623,
248
],
[
627,
233,
675,
248
],
[
678,
233,
691,
248
],
[
694,
233,
748,
248
],
[
751,
233,
772,
248
],
[
775,
233,
844,
248
],
[
847,
233,
864,
248
],
[
117,
250,
142,
265
],
[
146,
250,
248,
265
],
[
252,
250,
314,
265
],
[
317,
250,
334,
265
],
[
338,
250,
390,
265
],
[
394,
250,
455,
265
],
[
459,
251,
489,
265
],
[
492,
250,
534,
265
],
[
538,
250,
567,
265
],
[
571,
250,
645,
265
],
[
648,
250,
676,
265
],
[
680,
250,
734,
265
],
[
738,
250,
759,
265
],
[
763,
250,
834,
265
],
[
838,
250,
875,
265
],
[
117,
268,
143,
283
],
[
147,
267,
193,
283
],
[
197,
267,
213,
283
],
[
217,
267,
241,
283
],
[
245,
267,
277,
283
],
[
281,
268,
366,
283
],
[
176,
299,
201,
317
],
[
236,
302,
274,
317
],
[
280,
302,
341,
318
],
[
344,
302,
396,
318
],
[
400,
302,
427,
318
],
[
430,
302,
540,
318
],
[
543,
302,
628,
318
],
[
632,
302,
713,
318
],
[
717,
302,
735,
318
],
[
738,
302,
750,
318
],
[
754,
302,
832,
318
],
[
836,
302,
878,
318
],
[
235,
320,
253,
335
],
[
257,
320,
299,
335
],
[
304,
320,
356,
335
],
[
360,
320,
387,
335
],
[
390,
320,
440,
335
],
[
443,
320,
461,
335
],
[
465,
320,
505,
335
],
[
510,
320,
609,
335
],
[
612,
320,
623,
336
],
[
627,
320,
658,
336
],
[
662,
320,
681,
336
],
[
685,
320,
752,
336
],
[
756,
320,
806,
336
],
[
120,
355,
150,
370
],
[
152,
355,
224,
370
],
[
229,
355,
304,
370
],
[
307,
355,
325,
370
],
[
328,
355,
422,
370
],
[
425,
355,
442,
370
],
[
445,
355,
482,
370
],
[
485,
355,
500,
370
],
[
503,
355,
538,
370
],
[
541,
355,
660,
370
],
[
662,
355,
684,
370
],
[
687,
355,
774,
370
],
[
777,
355,
798,
370
],
[
801,
355,
829,
370
],
[
120,
372,
233,
388
],
[
237,
372,
283,
388
],
[
287,
372,
336,
388
],
[
340,
372,
350,
388
],
[
354,
372,
425,
388
],
[
430,
372,
514,
388
],
[
518,
372,
531,
388
],
[
535,
372,
608,
388
],
[
612,
372,
672,
388
],
[
676,
372,
693,
388
],
[
697,
372,
784,
388
],
[
788,
372,
855,
388
],
[
858,
372,
875,
388
],
[
117,
389,
137,
404
],
[
140,
390,
254,
405
],
[
258,
391,
345,
405
],
[
348,
391,
430,
405
],
[
434,
391,
451,
405
],
[
454,
390,
542,
405
],
[
546,
390,
584,
405
],
[
587,
390,
608,
405
],
[
611,
389,
679,
404
],
[
682,
388,
728,
403
],
[
120,
424,
148,
440
],
[
151,
424,
204,
440
],
[
208,
424,
290,
440
],
[
294,
424,
354,
440
],
[
358,
424,
375,
440
],
[
379,
424,
465,
440
],
[
469,
424,
545,
440
],
[
550,
424,
596,
440
],
[
600,
424,
624,
440
],
[
628,
424,
711,
440
],
[
715,
425,
732,
440
],
[
736,
425,
763,
440
],
[
767,
425,
798,
440
],
[
802,
425,
836,
440
],
[
840,
425,
860,
440
],
[
117,
442,
194,
457
],
[
198,
442,
227,
457
],
[
230,
442,
300,
458
],
[
303,
442,
321,
458
],
[
324,
442,
334,
458
],
[
338,
442,
394,
458
],
[
397,
442,
460,
458
],
[
464,
442,
478,
458
],
[
481,
442,
490,
458
],
[
494,
442,
571,
458
],
[
575,
442,
602,
458
],
[
606,
442,
620,
458
],
[
624,
442,
651,
458
],
[
654,
442,
727,
458
],
[
731,
442,
792,
457
],
[
795,
443,
817,
457
],
[
117,
460,
205,
475
],
[
208,
460,
280,
475
],
[
283,
460,
295,
475
],
[
299,
460,
313,
475
],
[
316,
460,
344,
475
],
[
347,
460,
357,
475
],
[
361,
460,
431,
475
],
[
434,
460,
520,
475
],
[
523,
460,
540,
475
],
[
544,
460,
580,
475
],
[
583,
460,
612,
475
],
[
616,
460,
651,
475
],
[
654,
460,
682,
475
],
[
685,
460,
705,
475
],
[
708,
459,
778,
475
],
[
781,
459,
833,
474
],
[
836,
459,
864,
474
],
[
118,
477,
164,
492
],
[
168,
477,
184,
492
],
[
188,
477,
198,
491
],
[
202,
477,
232,
491
],
[
237,
476,
328,
492
],
[
118,
512,
150,
527
],
[
152,
512,
187,
527
],
[
193,
512,
280,
527
],
[
282,
512,
298,
527
],
[
301,
512,
377,
527
],
[
380,
512,
415,
527
],
[
418,
512,
507,
527
],
[
510,
512,
527,
527
],
[
530,
512,
574,
527
],
[
577,
512,
646,
527
],
[
650,
512,
671,
527
],
[
674,
512,
700,
526
],
[
703,
513,
810,
526
],
[
814,
513,
835,
526
],
[
120,
530,
204,
545
],
[
207,
530,
280,
545
],
[
284,
530,
311,
545
],
[
315,
530,
338,
545
],
[
341,
530,
445,
545
],
[
449,
530,
512,
545
],
[
515,
530,
576,
545
],
[
580,
530,
621,
545
],
[
625,
530,
634,
545
],
[
637,
530,
714,
545
],
[
718,
530,
734,
545
],
[
738,
530,
769,
545
],
[
773,
530,
818,
545
],
[
822,
530,
840,
545
],
[
843,
530,
852,
545
],
[
117,
548,
241,
562
],
[
245,
548,
301,
562
],
[
305,
548,
322,
562
],
[
325,
548,
388,
563
],
[
391,
548,
462,
563
],
[
465,
548,
507,
563
],
[
510,
548,
591,
563
],
[
593,
548,
668,
563
],
[
671,
548,
702,
562
],
[
705,
548,
754,
562
],
[
757,
548,
767,
562
],
[
770,
547,
841,
562
],
[
117,
565,
207,
579
],
[
210,
565,
234,
579
],
[
237,
565,
263,
579
],
[
266,
565,
355,
579
],
[
360,
565,
391,
579
],
[
394,
565,
427,
579
],
[
434,
565,
507,
579
],
[
511,
565,
525,
579
],
[
529,
565,
571,
579
],
[
574,
565,
660,
579
],
[
664,
565,
674,
579
],
[
677,
565,
749,
579
],
[
752,
565,
776,
579
],
[
780,
565,
805,
579
],
[
808,
565,
842,
579
],
[
120,
580,
208,
596
],
[
211,
581,
228,
596
],
[
232,
582,
262,
597
],
[
265,
582,
381,
597
],
[
384,
582,
400,
597
],
[
404,
582,
488,
597
],
[
492,
582,
527,
597
],
[
530,
582,
558,
597
],
[
561,
582,
630,
597
],
[
632,
582,
651,
597
],
[
654,
582,
715,
597
],
[
718,
582,
728,
597
],
[
731,
581,
811,
597
],
[
121,
600,
210,
615
],
[
218,
600,
246,
615
],
[
249,
600,
274,
615
],
[
277,
600,
287,
615
],
[
290,
600,
362,
615
],
[
365,
600,
392,
615
],
[
396,
600,
430,
615
],
[
434,
600,
474,
615
],
[
477,
600,
526,
615
],
[
530,
600,
547,
615
],
[
550,
600,
616,
615
],
[
620,
599,
707,
615
],
[
710,
599,
742,
615
],
[
745,
599,
755,
615
],
[
759,
598,
831,
615
],
[
834,
598,
849,
614
],
[
117,
616,
162,
632
],
[
165,
617,
203,
632
],
[
207,
617,
224,
632
],
[
227,
617,
258,
632
],
[
261,
617,
354,
632
],
[
119,
650,
152,
667
],
[
156,
650,
230,
667
],
[
234,
651,
251,
667
],
[
255,
651,
347,
667
],
[
351,
651,
368,
667
],
[
371,
651,
409,
667
],
[
412,
651,
444,
668
],
[
448,
651,
514,
668
],
[
518,
651,
543,
668
],
[
547,
651,
583,
668
],
[
588,
651,
684,
667
],
[
688,
651,
772,
667
],
[
779,
651,
810,
667
],
[
813,
650,
878,
667
],
[
118,
668,
134,
683
],
[
138,
668,
224,
684
],
[
228,
669,
335,
684
],
[
338,
669,
354,
684
],
[
357,
669,
392,
684
],
[
395,
669,
484,
684
],
[
487,
669,
505,
684
],
[
509,
669,
588,
684
],
[
591,
669,
621,
684
],
[
624,
669,
700,
684
],
[
703,
669,
731,
684
],
[
734,
669,
772,
684
],
[
116,
685,
229,
702
],
[
232,
686,
247,
702
],
[
251,
686,
288,
702
],
[
292,
686,
384,
702
],
[
388,
686,
411,
703
],
[
415,
686,
440,
703
],
[
443,
686,
491,
703
],
[
495,
686,
516,
703
],
[
520,
686,
552,
702
],
[
555,
686,
602,
702
],
[
606,
686,
615,
702
],
[
619,
686,
721,
702
],
[
724,
686,
756,
701
],
[
760,
685,
831,
701
],
[
118,
703,
198,
719
],
[
202,
703,
275,
720
],
[
282,
703,
395,
720
],
[
400,
703,
413,
720
],
[
417,
703,
490,
720
],
[
493,
703,
514,
720
],
[
518,
703,
627,
720
],
[
630,
703,
679,
720
],
[
682,
703,
735,
719
],
[
739,
703,
777,
719
],
[
781,
703,
812,
719
],
[
815,
703,
841,
718
],
[
118,
721,
162,
737
],
[
167,
721,
261,
737
],
[
265,
721,
282,
737
],
[
285,
721,
375,
737
],
[
379,
721,
406,
737
],
[
410,
721,
424,
737
],
[
428,
721,
507,
737
],
[
511,
721,
572,
736
],
[
576,
721,
640,
736
],
[
644,
721,
673,
736
],
[
677,
721,
727,
736
],
[
731,
721,
771,
736
],
[
774,
721,
801,
735
],
[
119,
738,
232,
755
],
[
236,
738,
270,
755
],
[
274,
738,
352,
755
],
[
356,
738,
395,
755
],
[
399,
738,
428,
755
],
[
431,
738,
507,
755
],
[
511,
738,
574,
755
],
[
578,
738,
687,
755
],
[
691,
738,
715,
754
],
[
719,
738,
746,
754
],
[
750,
737,
855,
754
],
[
118,
755,
147,
771
],
[
150,
755,
185,
772
],
[
188,
755,
214,
772
],
[
218,
755,
314,
772
],
[
318,
755,
397,
771
],
[
117,
820,
130,
835
],
[
133,
821,
177,
836
],
[
179,
823,
218,
837
],
[
117,
835,
128,
850
],
[
132,
836,
160,
850
],
[
164,
836,
192,
851
],
[
196,
837,
286,
852
],
[
290,
838,
305,
852
],
[
308,
838,
334,
852
],
[
338,
838,
392,
852
],
[
395,
839,
410,
852
],
[
413,
839,
465,
853
],
[
468,
839,
530,
853
],
[
534,
839,
588,
853
],
[
592,
840,
621,
853
],
[
625,
840,
648,
853
],
[
652,
839,
715,
852
],
[
718,
839,
794,
852
],
[
797,
839,
855,
852
],
[
859,
839,
874,
851
],
[
119,
853,
137,
866
],
[
141,
853,
194,
866
],
[
197,
853,
227,
866
],
[
231,
853,
244,
866
],
[
247,
853,
320,
867
],
[
322,
853,
412,
867
],
[
415,
854,
439,
867
],
[
442,
854,
513,
866
],
[
516,
854,
576,
866
],
[
579,
854,
594,
866
],
[
120,
868,
251,
882
],
[
254,
868,
420,
882
],
[
423,
867,
568,
882
],
[
137,
881,
175,
895
],
[
179,
881,
194,
895
],
[
198,
882,
231,
895
],
[
234,
882,
255,
895
],
[
258,
882,
294,
895
],
[
297,
882,
355,
895
],
[
359,
882,
422,
895
],
[
425,
883,
450,
895
],
[
453,
883,
528,
895
],
[
531,
883,
546,
896
],
[
549,
883,
642,
896
],
[
646,
883,
670,
896
],
[
672,
883,
724,
896
],
[
728,
882,
804,
896
],
[
807,
882,
875,
896
],
[
118,
896,
136,
909
],
[
138,
896,
175,
909
],
[
178,
896,
194,
909
],
[
196,
896,
208,
909
],
[
211,
896,
241,
910
],
[
244,
896,
269,
910
],
[
272,
896,
321,
910
],
[
830,
940,
882,
955
],
[
221,
981,
288,
997
],
[
291,
980,
782,
997
]
] |
Which Provision should be applied as a focusing tool by EPA?
|
EPA Should Apply the "Reasonably Foreseen" Provision.
|
749
|
[
"Attachment",
"A",
"ACC's",
"General",
"Principles",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"(Developed",
"for",
"EPA",
"Dialogue",
"7-2011)",
"EPA",
"should",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"safe",
"use",
"determinations.",
".",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"existing",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"data",
"and",
"information",
"(including",
"models,",
"read",
"across,",
"QSAR,",
"etc.)",
"and",
"industry",
"should",
"be",
"responsible",
"for",
"providing",
"EPA",
"with",
"this",
"data",
"and",
"information.",
"Chemicals",
"lacking",
"adequate",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"a",
"higher",
"priority",
"(until",
"relevant",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"that",
"suggests",
"otherwise).",
"Industry",
"should",
"be",
"provided",
"an",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"EPA",
"additional",
"data/information.",
"Timing",
"is",
"an",
"issue,",
"however.",
"And",
"the",
"format",
"in",
"which",
"the",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"to",
"EPA",
"must",
"be",
"useable/digestible",
"by",
"EPA,",
"e.g.",
"robust",
"summaries.)",
"Hazard,",
"use",
"and",
"exposure",
"based",
"criteria",
"should",
"be",
"integrated",
"to",
"form",
"the",
"basis",
"for",
"EPA's",
"prioritization",
"decisions.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"either",
"hazard-only",
"or",
"exposure-",
"only",
"information.",
"The",
"prioritization",
"process",
"and",
"science",
"based",
"criteria",
"that",
"EPA",
"uses",
"to",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"transparent.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"a",
"dynamic,",
"iterative",
"process.",
"Re-examination",
"of",
"priorities",
"should",
"occur",
"as",
"new",
"information",
"becomes",
"available",
"and",
"as",
"new",
"chemicals",
"are",
"approved",
"for",
"manufacturing.",
"For",
"prioritization",
"to",
"be",
"successful,",
"it",
"must",
"include",
"three",
"critical",
"elements:",
"reliable",
"and",
"up-",
"to-",
"date",
"chemical",
"data",
"and",
"information;",
"evaluation",
"criteria",
"that",
"consider",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"together;",
"and",
"established",
"cutoffs",
"to",
"make",
"priority",
"decisions.",
"EPA's",
"communication",
"about",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"clear",
"about",
"what",
"the",
"list",
"is",
"and",
"what",
"it",
"is",
"not,",
"to",
"avoid",
"unintended",
"consequences",
"of",
"product",
"de-selection",
"purely",
"on",
"the",
"basis",
"of",
"listing.",
"Transparency;",
"consistent,",
"scientific",
"criteria;",
"intersection",
"of",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information;",
"dynamic",
"process",
"so",
"new",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"incorporated",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"made",
"available",
"and",
"so",
"if",
"priorities",
"are",
"initially",
"\"wrong\"",
"they",
"can",
"be",
"corrected.",
"25",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
825,
65,
917,
78
],
[
920,
65,
931,
78
],
[
348,
164,
406,
179
],
[
410,
164,
477,
180
],
[
481,
164,
567,
180
],
[
570,
164,
593,
180
],
[
596,
164,
712,
180
],
[
400,
214,
492,
230
],
[
497,
214,
520,
230
],
[
524,
214,
561,
230
],
[
566,
214,
640,
230
],
[
644,
213,
707,
231
],
[
176,
250,
211,
264
],
[
215,
250,
264,
264
],
[
268,
250,
376,
265
],
[
380,
250,
452,
265
],
[
455,
250,
530,
265
],
[
533,
250,
555,
265
],
[
558,
250,
624,
265
],
[
627,
250,
642,
265
],
[
646,
250,
677,
265
],
[
680,
250,
706,
265
],
[
709,
250,
822,
265
],
[
147,
279,
159,
292
],
[
177,
280,
198,
295
],
[
201,
280,
211,
295
],
[
214,
280,
267,
295
],
[
270,
280,
321,
295
],
[
324,
280,
421,
294
],
[
424,
280,
472,
294
],
[
475,
280,
494,
294
],
[
497,
280,
540,
294
],
[
543,
280,
563,
294
],
[
566,
280,
626,
295
],
[
629,
280,
685,
295
],
[
688,
280,
718,
295
],
[
721,
280,
795,
295
],
[
798,
280,
832,
295
],
[
177,
295,
206,
310
],
[
209,
295,
303,
310
],
[
306,
295,
384,
310
],
[
387,
295,
448,
310
],
[
451,
295,
489,
310
],
[
491,
295,
547,
310
],
[
549,
295,
604,
310
],
[
607,
295,
642,
310
],
[
645,
295,
672,
310
],
[
675,
295,
742,
310
],
[
745,
295,
796,
310
],
[
799,
295,
824,
310
],
[
176,
311,
265,
326
],
[
268,
311,
290,
326
],
[
293,
311,
364,
326
],
[
368,
311,
401,
326
],
[
407,
311,
439,
326
],
[
442,
311,
472,
326
],
[
475,
311,
504,
326
],
[
507,
311,
533,
326
],
[
536,
311,
627,
326
],
[
177,
346,
252,
360
],
[
255,
347,
315,
361
],
[
318,
347,
387,
361
],
[
390,
347,
447,
361
],
[
450,
348,
480,
361
],
[
483,
348,
554,
361
],
[
557,
347,
644,
361
],
[
647,
347,
696,
360
],
[
699,
347,
717,
360
],
[
720,
346,
801,
360
],
[
803,
346,
816,
360
],
[
177,
363,
227,
376
],
[
230,
363,
291,
377
],
[
294,
363,
334,
377
],
[
338,
363,
397,
377
],
[
400,
364,
487,
377
],
[
490,
364,
502,
377
],
[
506,
364,
572,
377
],
[
575,
364,
604,
377
],
[
607,
364,
667,
377
],
[
671,
364,
753,
377
],
[
175,
397,
238,
411
],
[
241,
397,
289,
412
],
[
292,
397,
310,
412
],
[
314,
397,
380,
412
],
[
384,
397,
401,
412
],
[
404,
397,
498,
412
],
[
502,
397,
517,
412
],
[
520,
397,
582,
412
],
[
585,
397,
621,
412
],
[
625,
397,
707,
412
],
[
711,
395,
847,
411
],
[
184,
414,
236,
428
],
[
239,
414,
253,
428
],
[
256,
414,
274,
428
],
[
277,
414,
318,
428
],
[
321,
414,
391,
428
],
[
394,
414,
425,
428
],
[
429,
414,
452,
428
],
[
455,
414,
504,
428
],
[
508,
414,
523,
428
],
[
527,
414,
571,
428
],
[
574,
414,
597,
428
],
[
601,
414,
687,
428
],
[
690,
414,
704,
427
],
[
707,
414,
772,
427
],
[
775,
413,
792,
427
],
[
795,
413,
828,
427
],
[
175,
430,
212,
443
],
[
215,
430,
234,
443
],
[
237,
429,
367,
443
],
[
370,
429,
391,
443
],
[
394,
429,
433,
443
],
[
436,
430,
462,
444
],
[
465,
430,
513,
444
],
[
516,
430,
605,
444
],
[
176,
464,
241,
477
],
[
244,
464,
270,
477
],
[
272,
464,
304,
478
],
[
306,
464,
376,
478
],
[
379,
464,
425,
478
],
[
428,
465,
487,
478
],
[
490,
465,
542,
478
],
[
545,
465,
564,
478
],
[
568,
464,
648,
478
],
[
651,
464,
667,
478
],
[
670,
464,
702,
478
],
[
708,
464,
732,
477
],
[
735,
464,
773,
477
],
[
776,
464,
800,
477
],
[
178,
480,
224,
493
],
[
227,
480,
324,
493
],
[
330,
480,
399,
494
],
[
402,
481,
498,
494
],
[
502,
481,
551,
494
],
[
554,
481,
578,
494
],
[
581,
481,
600,
494
],
[
602,
481,
646,
494
],
[
648,
481,
668,
493
],
[
670,
481,
714,
493
],
[
716,
480,
805,
493
],
[
806,
480,
827,
492
],
[
177,
497,
249,
509
],
[
251,
497,
285,
509
],
[
288,
497,
381,
510
],
[
178,
525,
205,
539
],
[
208,
525,
303,
539
],
[
307,
525,
363,
540
],
[
366,
525,
392,
540
],
[
396,
525,
450,
540
],
[
453,
525,
495,
540
],
[
499,
525,
552,
540
],
[
555,
525,
584,
540
],
[
587,
525,
619,
540
],
[
625,
525,
656,
540
],
[
659,
525,
675,
540
],
[
678,
524,
746,
540
],
[
750,
524,
823,
539
],
[
177,
542,
212,
554
],
[
215,
542,
234,
554
],
[
237,
542,
333,
555
],
[
175,
570,
272,
585
],
[
275,
570,
324,
585
],
[
328,
571,
347,
585
],
[
350,
571,
361,
586
],
[
365,
571,
432,
586
],
[
436,
571,
502,
586
],
[
505,
571,
567,
586
],
[
571,
570,
688,
586
],
[
692,
570,
707,
585
],
[
711,
570,
776,
585
],
[
780,
570,
829,
585
],
[
177,
588,
218,
601
],
[
221,
588,
237,
601
],
[
240,
588,
268,
601
],
[
273,
588,
360,
601
],
[
363,
588,
428,
601
],
[
431,
588,
497,
601
],
[
500,
588,
527,
601
],
[
530,
588,
545,
601
],
[
548,
588,
577,
601
],
[
584,
588,
657,
601
],
[
660,
587,
683,
601
],
[
686,
587,
754,
601
],
[
757,
587,
780,
601
],
[
175,
604,
284,
619
],
[
176,
633,
202,
646
],
[
205,
633,
301,
646
],
[
304,
634,
320,
646
],
[
322,
634,
341,
646
],
[
344,
634,
423,
646
],
[
426,
634,
438,
647
],
[
441,
634,
477,
647
],
[
480,
634,
535,
647
],
[
538,
634,
575,
647
],
[
578,
634,
630,
647
],
[
632,
634,
704,
647
],
[
706,
633,
767,
647
],
[
770,
633,
800,
646
],
[
802,
633,
829,
646
],
[
177,
649,
202,
662
],
[
205,
649,
236,
662
],
[
239,
649,
312,
663
],
[
315,
650,
348,
663
],
[
350,
650,
380,
663
],
[
382,
650,
484,
664
],
[
486,
650,
567,
664
],
[
571,
650,
628,
664
],
[
631,
650,
665,
663
],
[
668,
650,
734,
663
],
[
737,
650,
773,
663
],
[
776,
649,
830,
663
],
[
178,
666,
207,
679
],
[
210,
666,
280,
679
],
[
283,
666,
376,
680
],
[
379,
666,
451,
680
],
[
454,
666,
484,
680
],
[
487,
666,
574,
680
],
[
577,
666,
631,
680
],
[
634,
666,
650,
680
],
[
653,
666,
697,
680
],
[
700,
666,
762,
680
],
[
765,
665,
840,
680
],
[
177,
693,
232,
708
],
[
235,
694,
365,
709
],
[
370,
694,
418,
709
],
[
421,
694,
489,
709
],
[
492,
694,
575,
709
],
[
578,
694,
621,
709
],
[
624,
694,
646,
709
],
[
650,
694,
693,
709
],
[
697,
694,
747,
709
],
[
750,
694,
792,
709
],
[
795,
694,
822,
709
],
[
825,
694,
855,
708
],
[
177,
711,
191,
726
],
[
194,
711,
228,
726
],
[
231,
711,
273,
726
],
[
277,
711,
290,
726
],
[
293,
711,
308,
726
],
[
312,
711,
347,
726
],
[
350,
711,
367,
727
],
[
370,
711,
417,
727
],
[
421,
711,
518,
727
],
[
522,
711,
634,
727
],
[
638,
711,
654,
727
],
[
658,
710,
730,
727
],
[
734,
710,
830,
727
],
[
175,
730,
228,
745
],
[
231,
730,
252,
744
],
[
255,
730,
281,
744
],
[
285,
730,
323,
744
],
[
326,
730,
344,
744
],
[
347,
730,
402,
745
],
[
177,
759,
291,
775
],
[
294,
759,
376,
774
],
[
380,
759,
448,
773
],
[
452,
759,
515,
773
],
[
518,
759,
611,
773
],
[
615,
758,
629,
773
],
[
632,
758,
668,
773
],
[
672,
758,
728,
774
],
[
732,
758,
761,
774
],
[
765,
758,
839,
774
],
[
177,
774,
277,
790
],
[
281,
775,
345,
790
],
[
349,
775,
407,
790
],
[
411,
775,
427,
790
],
[
431,
775,
461,
790
],
[
465,
775,
551,
790
],
[
555,
775,
580,
790
],
[
584,
775,
602,
790
],
[
607,
775,
698,
790
],
[
702,
775,
717,
790
],
[
720,
775,
732,
790
],
[
736,
775,
748,
790
],
[
752,
775,
788,
790
],
[
177,
791,
242,
805
],
[
246,
791,
274,
805
],
[
277,
790,
294,
805
],
[
297,
790,
309,
806
],
[
312,
790,
378,
806
],
[
381,
790,
405,
806
],
[
408,
790,
465,
806
],
[
468,
790,
532,
806
],
[
535,
790,
567,
806
],
[
570,
791,
596,
806
],
[
600,
791,
617,
806
],
[
620,
791,
697,
806
],
[
510,
911,
531,
927
],
[
222,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
why industry should be provided an opportunity ?
|
to provide EPA additional data/information
|
752
|
[
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(B)",
"of",
"the",
"statute",
"requires",
"EPA",
"to",
"establish,",
"by",
"rule,",
"\"a",
"process",
"to",
"conduct",
"risk",
"evaluations.\"",
"This",
"process",
"is",
"itself",
"required",
"to",
"meet",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"substantive",
"elements",
"described",
"in",
"the",
"LCSA;",
"a",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"must:",
"Be",
"conducted",
"in",
"a",
"manner",
"designed",
"to",
"help",
"the",
"agency",
"determine",
"\"whether",
"a",
"chemical",
"substance",
"presents",
"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk",
"of",
"injury",
"to",
"health",
"or",
"the",
"environment;\"",
"as",
"set",
"out",
"in",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(A).",
"Include",
"consideration",
"of",
"\"an",
"unreasonable",
"risk",
"to",
"a",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"or",
"susceptible",
"subpopulation.\"",
"EPA",
"must",
"identify",
"relevant",
"potentially",
"exposed",
"or",
"susceptible",
"subpopulations",
"relevant",
"to",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"under",
"conditions",
"of",
"use;",
"Address",
"the",
"specific",
"elements",
"set",
"out",
"in",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(F);",
"and",
"Comply",
"with",
"the",
"specific",
"requirements",
"of",
"Section",
"26,",
"including",
"the",
"best",
"available",
"science,",
"weight",
"of",
"the",
"evidence,",
"and",
"transparency",
"requirements.",
"The",
"very",
"purpose",
"of",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"is",
"to",
"develop",
"the",
"evidentiary",
"and",
"scientific",
"basis",
"to",
"enable",
"EPA",
"to",
"complete",
"the",
"risk",
"determination",
"required",
"by",
"statute.",
"That",
"risk",
"determination",
"has",
"substantive",
"impact",
"-",
"it",
"significantly",
"affects",
"conduct,",
"activity",
"or",
"a",
"substantive",
"interest",
"that",
"is",
"the",
"subject",
"of",
"agency",
"regulation.",
"The",
"basis",
"for",
"the",
"risk",
"determination",
"thus",
"should",
"be",
"adequately",
"described",
"in",
"the",
"rule",
"itself",
"to",
"offer",
"sufficient",
"notice",
"to",
"the",
"regulated",
"community.",
"This",
"is",
"particularly",
"important",
"for",
"decisions",
"that",
"inform",
"safety",
"and",
"safety",
"determinations.'",
"Likewise,",
"decisions",
"that",
"have",
"broad",
"reaching",
"impact",
"should",
"be",
"supported",
"in",
"regulations,",
"not",
"merely",
"through",
"guidance",
"or",
"agency",
"policy.\"",
"While",
"EPA",
"cannot",
"substitute",
"policy",
"or",
"guidance",
"for",
"a",
"regulatory",
"description",
"of",
"what",
"will",
"constitute",
"a",
"complete",
"and",
"robust",
"risk",
"evaluation,",
"we",
"believe",
"the",
"necessary",
"elements",
"can",
"be",
"developed",
"in",
"this",
"rulemaking",
"in",
"a",
"timely",
"manner.",
"VI.",
"The",
"Proposed",
"Rule",
"Should",
"Ensure",
"Consistency",
"with",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(F)",
"As",
"discussed",
"below,",
"Section",
"6(b)(4)(F)",
"of",
"the",
"LCSA",
"describes",
"five",
"requirements",
"for",
"risk",
"evaluations",
"that",
"shall",
"be",
"considered",
"by",
"the",
"Administrator",
"and",
"must",
"be",
"incorporated",
"into",
"the",
"risk",
"evaluation",
"rulemaking.",
"See,",
"e.g.,",
"MST",
"Express",
"v.",
"U.S.",
"Department",
"of",
"Transportation,",
"108",
"F.3d",
"401",
"(D.C.",
"Cir.",
"1997).",
"DOT",
"was",
"directed",
"under",
"the",
"Motor",
"Carrier",
"Safety",
"Act",
"(MCSA)",
"to",
"\"prescribe",
"regulations",
"establishing",
"a",
"procedure",
"to",
"decide",
"on",
"the",
"safety",
"fitness",
"of",
"owners",
"and",
"operators",
"of",
"commercial",
"motor",
"vehicles.\"",
"[Emphasis",
"added].",
"The",
"MCSA",
"stated",
"that",
"implementing",
"regulations",
"would",
"include",
"\"a",
"means",
"of",
"deciding",
"whether",
"the",
"owners,",
"operators,",
"and",
"persons",
"meet",
"the",
"safety",
"fitness",
"requirements.\"",
"DOT",
"promulgated",
"regulations",
"that",
"set",
"out",
"a",
"process",
"for",
"decision",
"making",
"but",
"used",
"guidance",
"to",
"articulate",
"the",
"tests",
"by",
"which",
"the",
"agency",
"would",
"determine",
"whether",
"vehicles",
"met",
"the",
"safety",
"fitness",
"requirements.",
"The",
"court",
"rejected",
"DOT's",
"reliance",
"on",
"guidance",
"because",
"it",
"\"failed",
"to",
"carry",
"out",
"its",
"statutory",
"obligation",
"to",
"establish",
"by",
"regulation",
"a",
"means",
"of",
"determining",
"whether",
"a",
"carrier",
"has",
"complied",
"with",
"the",
"safety",
"fitness",
"requirements.\"",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"\"...it",
"seems",
"to",
"be",
"established",
"that",
"'regulations,'",
"'substantive",
"rules'",
"or",
"'legislative",
"rules'",
"are",
"those",
"which",
"create",
"law,",
"usually",
"implementary",
"to",
"an",
"existing",
"law.\"",
"Gibson",
"Wine",
"Co.",
"v.",
"Snyder,",
"194",
"F.2d",
"329,",
"331",
"(D.C.",
"Cir.",
"1952),",
"cited",
"by",
"Brown",
"Express,",
"Inc.",
"v.",
"U.S.,",
"607",
"F.2d",
"695,",
"700",
"(5th",
"Cir.",
"1979).",
"A",
"\"rule\"",
"is",
"defined",
"under",
"Section",
"2",
"of",
"the",
"Administrative",
"Procedure",
"Act,",
"in",
"relevant",
"part,",
"as:",
"\"the",
"whole",
"or",
"part",
"of",
"an",
"agency",
"statement",
"of",
"general",
"or",
"particular",
"applicability",
"and",
"future",
"effect",
"designed",
"to",
"implement,",
"interpret,",
"or",
"prescribe",
"law",
"or",
"policy",
"or",
"describing",
"the",
"organization,",
"procedure,",
"or",
"practice",
"requirements",
"of",
"an",
"agency.\"",
"5",
"U.S.C.",
"$",
"551(4).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/ylcn0226"
] |
[
[
90,
84,
149,
99
],
[
152,
85,
235,
100
],
[
238,
85,
257,
100
],
[
260,
85,
285,
100
],
[
288,
85,
341,
100
],
[
344,
85,
410,
100
],
[
413,
85,
450,
100
],
[
454,
85,
471,
100
],
[
475,
85,
550,
100
],
[
552,
85,
574,
100
],
[
577,
85,
614,
100
],
[
617,
85,
636,
100
],
[
640,
85,
700,
100
],
[
704,
85,
721,
99
],
[
725,
85,
787,
99
],
[
790,
85,
822,
99
],
[
826,
85,
928,
99
],
[
90,
101,
124,
116
],
[
127,
101,
187,
117
],
[
190,
101,
205,
117
],
[
208,
101,
250,
117
],
[
254,
102,
320,
117
],
[
323,
102,
341,
117
],
[
344,
102,
384,
117
],
[
387,
102,
397,
117
],
[
400,
102,
462,
117
],
[
465,
102,
483,
117
],
[
487,
102,
578,
117
],
[
581,
101,
655,
117
],
[
658,
101,
731,
116
],
[
735,
101,
751,
116
],
[
754,
101,
781,
116
],
[
784,
101,
841,
116
],
[
845,
101,
854,
116
],
[
858,
101,
887,
115
],
[
90,
120,
171,
134
],
[
174,
120,
217,
135
],
[
176,
154,
200,
168
],
[
203,
154,
285,
169
],
[
288,
154,
305,
169
],
[
309,
154,
318,
169
],
[
322,
154,
386,
170
],
[
389,
154,
457,
170
],
[
460,
154,
477,
170
],
[
480,
154,
516,
170
],
[
520,
154,
545,
170
],
[
549,
154,
607,
170
],
[
613,
154,
688,
170
],
[
692,
153,
767,
170
],
[
770,
153,
780,
169
],
[
782,
153,
858,
169
],
[
178,
173,
253,
186
],
[
256,
172,
324,
186
],
[
327,
172,
345,
186
],
[
350,
172,
455,
187
],
[
458,
172,
490,
187
],
[
493,
172,
511,
187
],
[
514,
172,
564,
187
],
[
566,
172,
583,
187
],
[
585,
172,
635,
187
],
[
639,
172,
658,
187
],
[
661,
172,
687,
187
],
[
690,
171,
805,
187
],
[
808,
171,
827,
186
],
[
829,
171,
854,
186
],
[
856,
171,
882,
186
],
[
885,
171,
901,
186
],
[
177,
189,
237,
204
],
[
240,
189,
328,
204
],
[
176,
206,
237,
221
],
[
240,
206,
347,
221
],
[
350,
206,
368,
221
],
[
371,
206,
400,
221
],
[
402,
206,
508,
222
],
[
511,
206,
543,
222
],
[
546,
206,
564,
222
],
[
567,
206,
577,
222
],
[
580,
206,
666,
222
],
[
669,
206,
735,
222
],
[
738,
206,
757,
222
],
[
761,
206,
847,
222
],
[
177,
224,
305,
239
],
[
311,
224,
348,
239
],
[
352,
224,
392,
239
],
[
395,
224,
457,
239
],
[
460,
224,
525,
239
],
[
529,
224,
615,
239
],
[
619,
224,
684,
239
],
[
688,
224,
706,
239
],
[
710,
224,
797,
239
],
[
801,
223,
922,
239
],
[
177,
241,
241,
255
],
[
244,
242,
261,
255
],
[
264,
242,
289,
256
],
[
292,
242,
324,
256
],
[
328,
242,
411,
256
],
[
414,
242,
460,
256
],
[
464,
242,
548,
256
],
[
551,
242,
569,
256
],
[
572,
242,
605,
256
],
[
177,
258,
242,
274
],
[
244,
259,
272,
273
],
[
274,
259,
337,
273
],
[
340,
259,
411,
273
],
[
414,
259,
438,
273
],
[
441,
258,
468,
273
],
[
471,
258,
489,
273
],
[
492,
258,
552,
273
],
[
556,
257,
642,
274
],
[
646,
257,
676,
274
],
[
177,
275,
240,
291
],
[
244,
276,
280,
291
],
[
284,
276,
310,
291
],
[
314,
276,
373,
292
],
[
377,
276,
482,
292
],
[
486,
276,
504,
292
],
[
507,
276,
567,
292
],
[
571,
276,
596,
292
],
[
600,
276,
675,
292
],
[
678,
276,
704,
292
],
[
708,
276,
741,
292
],
[
745,
275,
817,
292
],
[
821,
275,
885,
292
],
[
176,
294,
231,
308
],
[
234,
294,
252,
309
],
[
255,
294,
281,
309
],
[
284,
294,
361,
309
],
[
364,
295,
394,
309
],
[
397,
295,
500,
309
],
[
502,
295,
611,
309
],
[
90,
328,
121,
344
],
[
124,
328,
159,
344
],
[
162,
328,
226,
344
],
[
230,
328,
247,
344
],
[
251,
328,
276,
344
],
[
280,
328,
311,
344
],
[
315,
328,
397,
344
],
[
401,
328,
415,
344
],
[
419,
328,
438,
344
],
[
443,
328,
502,
344
],
[
506,
328,
531,
344
],
[
535,
328,
624,
344
],
[
628,
328,
657,
344
],
[
661,
328,
734,
344
],
[
738,
328,
778,
344
],
[
782,
328,
800,
344
],
[
803,
328,
856,
344
],
[
860,
328,
897,
344
],
[
902,
328,
921,
344
],
[
90,
345,
160,
360
],
[
164,
346,
190,
361
],
[
193,
346,
225,
361
],
[
231,
346,
337,
361
],
[
340,
346,
408,
361
],
[
411,
346,
434,
361
],
[
437,
346,
501,
361
],
[
504,
346,
539,
361
],
[
542,
346,
576,
361
],
[
579,
346,
688,
361
],
[
691,
346,
720,
361
],
[
723,
346,
812,
361
],
[
815,
346,
871,
361
],
[
874,
346,
885,
361
],
[
888,
346,
900,
361
],
[
90,
363,
187,
379
],
[
190,
363,
245,
378
],
[
248,
363,
316,
378
],
[
320,
363,
380,
378
],
[
383,
363,
401,
378
],
[
404,
363,
415,
378
],
[
419,
363,
508,
378
],
[
511,
363,
570,
378
],
[
574,
363,
604,
378
],
[
608,
363,
622,
378
],
[
627,
363,
652,
378
],
[
655,
363,
712,
378
],
[
716,
363,
734,
378
],
[
737,
363,
793,
378
],
[
797,
363,
890,
379
],
[
893,
362,
924,
379
],
[
87,
380,
128,
396
],
[
132,
380,
155,
396
],
[
159,
380,
184,
396
],
[
188,
380,
221,
396
],
[
227,
380,
332,
396
],
[
337,
380,
371,
396
],
[
375,
380,
427,
396
],
[
431,
380,
452,
396
],
[
455,
380,
545,
396
],
[
548,
380,
622,
396
],
[
625,
380,
641,
396
],
[
645,
380,
670,
396
],
[
673,
380,
705,
396
],
[
709,
380,
750,
396
],
[
754,
380,
770,
396
],
[
774,
380,
814,
396
],
[
818,
380,
895,
396
],
[
89,
399,
137,
413
],
[
140,
399,
158,
413
],
[
161,
400,
186,
414
],
[
190,
400,
265,
414
],
[
268,
400,
368,
414
],
[
374,
400,
407,
414
],
[
411,
400,
425,
414
],
[
428,
400,
522,
414
],
[
525,
399,
603,
414
],
[
607,
399,
635,
414
],
[
638,
399,
709,
414
],
[
712,
399,
743,
413
],
[
747,
398,
797,
413
],
[
805,
398,
854,
413
],
[
857,
398,
887,
412
],
[
90,
415,
139,
430
],
[
142,
415,
274,
430
],
[
277,
415,
359,
430
],
[
362,
415,
432,
430
],
[
436,
415,
467,
430
],
[
471,
415,
509,
430
],
[
512,
415,
558,
430
],
[
562,
415,
631,
430
],
[
634,
415,
691,
430
],
[
694,
415,
747,
430
],
[
750,
415,
772,
430
],
[
775,
415,
854,
430
],
[
857,
416,
871,
430
],
[
89,
433,
180,
449
],
[
184,
433,
211,
449
],
[
215,
433,
270,
449
],
[
274,
433,
337,
449
],
[
341,
433,
412,
449
],
[
415,
433,
433,
449
],
[
437,
433,
494,
449
],
[
497,
433,
566,
449
],
[
570,
433,
618,
449
],
[
622,
432,
660,
449
],
[
663,
432,
717,
449
],
[
721,
432,
796,
449
],
[
800,
433,
851,
448
],
[
854,
433,
874,
448
],
[
89,
451,
160,
465
],
[
163,
451,
188,
465
],
[
192,
451,
201,
465
],
[
204,
451,
289,
466
],
[
294,
451,
380,
466
],
[
383,
451,
401,
466
],
[
404,
451,
444,
466
],
[
448,
451,
479,
466
],
[
482,
451,
561,
466
],
[
564,
451,
574,
465
],
[
578,
451,
651,
465
],
[
655,
451,
684,
465
],
[
687,
450,
737,
465
],
[
741,
450,
773,
465
],
[
777,
450,
865,
465
],
[
868,
450,
894,
465
],
[
87,
467,
145,
482
],
[
148,
468,
174,
482
],
[
177,
468,
255,
483
],
[
259,
468,
331,
483
],
[
334,
468,
362,
483
],
[
365,
468,
390,
483
],
[
392,
468,
471,
483
],
[
474,
468,
492,
483
],
[
495,
468,
525,
483
],
[
528,
468,
620,
483
],
[
623,
468,
640,
483
],
[
643,
468,
654,
483
],
[
657,
468,
707,
483
],
[
711,
468,
781,
483
],
[
88,
514,
128,
533
],
[
148,
515,
186,
533
],
[
191,
515,
284,
534
],
[
288,
515,
335,
534
],
[
340,
515,
411,
534
],
[
415,
515,
488,
534
],
[
492,
515,
608,
535
],
[
613,
515,
659,
535
],
[
663,
515,
734,
535
],
[
738,
515,
837,
535
],
[
90,
556,
114,
571
],
[
118,
556,
191,
571
],
[
194,
556,
250,
571
],
[
254,
556,
312,
572
],
[
315,
556,
398,
572
],
[
401,
556,
418,
572
],
[
421,
556,
447,
572
],
[
450,
556,
501,
572
],
[
510,
556,
581,
572
],
[
584,
556,
615,
572
],
[
618,
556,
723,
572
],
[
726,
556,
750,
571
],
[
754,
556,
785,
571
],
[
788,
556,
880,
571
],
[
882,
556,
916,
571
],
[
91,
573,
125,
590
],
[
129,
573,
150,
590
],
[
154,
573,
239,
590
],
[
243,
574,
264,
590
],
[
268,
574,
294,
590
],
[
298,
574,
408,
590
],
[
412,
574,
441,
590
],
[
445,
574,
483,
590
],
[
487,
574,
507,
590
],
[
511,
574,
611,
590
],
[
615,
574,
647,
590
],
[
651,
574,
675,
590
],
[
680,
574,
711,
590
],
[
715,
574,
797,
590
],
[
800,
573,
900,
591
],
[
97,
698,
125,
712
],
[
128,
698,
156,
712
],
[
160,
698,
194,
712
],
[
198,
698,
251,
713
],
[
254,
699,
267,
713
],
[
271,
699,
300,
713
],
[
303,
699,
381,
713
],
[
384,
699,
401,
713
],
[
404,
699,
505,
713
],
[
508,
699,
532,
713
],
[
536,
699,
567,
713
],
[
570,
699,
595,
713
],
[
598,
699,
637,
713
],
[
640,
699,
665,
713
],
[
668,
699,
715,
713
],
[
718,
699,
754,
713
],
[
757,
699,
785,
712
],
[
788,
699,
838,
712
],
[
841,
698,
880,
712
],
[
883,
698,
907,
712
],
[
89,
714,
130,
727
],
[
133,
714,
181,
727
],
[
184,
715,
226,
727
],
[
229,
715,
253,
727
],
[
256,
715,
314,
727
],
[
317,
715,
331,
727
],
[
334,
715,
402,
727
],
[
405,
715,
479,
727
],
[
482,
715,
561,
728
],
[
564,
715,
572,
728
],
[
575,
715,
642,
728
],
[
645,
715,
663,
727
],
[
666,
715,
707,
727
],
[
710,
715,
726,
727
],
[
729,
715,
751,
727
],
[
754,
715,
794,
727
],
[
797,
715,
841,
727
],
[
844,
715,
858,
727
],
[
861,
715,
912,
727
],
[
88,
729,
112,
743
],
[
116,
729,
177,
743
],
[
180,
729,
195,
743
],
[
198,
729,
276,
742
],
[
280,
729,
319,
742
],
[
322,
729,
392,
742
],
[
395,
729,
465,
742
],
[
469,
729,
524,
742
],
[
528,
729,
551,
742
],
[
555,
729,
603,
742
],
[
606,
729,
645,
742
],
[
648,
729,
673,
742
],
[
677,
729,
768,
742
],
[
771,
729,
846,
742
],
[
850,
729,
892,
742
],
[
88,
743,
137,
756
],
[
140,
743,
155,
756
],
[
158,
743,
202,
756
],
[
205,
743,
222,
756
],
[
225,
743,
279,
756
],
[
282,
743,
337,
756
],
[
340,
743,
361,
756
],
[
364,
743,
416,
756
],
[
418,
743,
484,
756
],
[
487,
743,
512,
756
],
[
514,
743,
566,
756
],
[
568,
743,
602,
756
],
[
605,
743,
627,
756
],
[
629,
743,
670,
756
],
[
672,
743,
715,
756
],
[
718,
743,
820,
755
],
[
823,
743,
855,
755
],
[
90,
758,
170,
771
],
[
174,
758,
248,
771
],
[
251,
758,
276,
771
],
[
279,
758,
299,
771
],
[
302,
758,
324,
771
],
[
327,
758,
334,
771
],
[
337,
758,
388,
771
],
[
391,
758,
414,
771
],
[
417,
758,
469,
771
],
[
472,
758,
522,
771
],
[
525,
758,
547,
771
],
[
551,
758,
582,
771
],
[
586,
758,
645,
771
],
[
648,
758,
662,
771
],
[
665,
758,
727,
771
],
[
730,
758,
751,
771
],
[
754,
758,
785,
771
],
[
788,
758,
807,
771
],
[
810,
758,
850,
771
],
[
852,
758,
873,
771
],
[
877,
758,
924,
771
],
[
88,
771,
131,
785
],
[
135,
771,
198,
785
],
[
202,
771,
255,
785
],
[
258,
772,
312,
785
],
[
315,
772,
341,
785
],
[
344,
772,
365,
785
],
[
369,
772,
410,
786
],
[
413,
772,
455,
786
],
[
458,
772,
554,
786
],
[
558,
772,
583,
786
],
[
587,
772,
620,
786
],
[
624,
772,
676,
785
],
[
680,
772,
725,
785
],
[
728,
772,
781,
785
],
[
785,
772,
802,
785
],
[
806,
772,
864,
785
],
[
867,
772,
923,
785
],
[
90,
787,
98,
800
],
[
100,
787,
147,
800
],
[
149,
787,
163,
800
],
[
165,
787,
201,
800
],
[
204,
788,
225,
800
],
[
228,
788,
247,
800
],
[
249,
788,
308,
800
],
[
310,
788,
378,
800
],
[
380,
788,
394,
800
],
[
397,
788,
455,
800
],
[
458,
788,
475,
800
],
[
478,
788,
546,
800
],
[
548,
788,
558,
800
],
[
560,
788,
604,
800
],
[
607,
788,
623,
800
],
[
625,
787,
705,
800
],
[
708,
787,
762,
800
],
[
765,
787,
774,
800
],
[
776,
787,
820,
800
],
[
821,
787,
847,
800
],
[
849,
787,
914,
799
],
[
90,
801,
118,
815
],
[
121,
801,
142,
815
],
[
146,
801,
185,
815
],
[
188,
801,
232,
815
],
[
235,
801,
334,
815
],
[
98,
815,
117,
828
],
[
120,
815,
128,
828
],
[
131,
815,
179,
828
],
[
182,
815,
230,
828
],
[
232,
815,
267,
829
],
[
270,
815,
310,
829
],
[
313,
815,
327,
829
],
[
330,
815,
347,
829
],
[
350,
815,
424,
829
],
[
427,
815,
453,
829
],
[
455,
815,
545,
829
],
[
547,
815,
627,
830
],
[
629,
815,
670,
830
],
[
671,
815,
688,
830
],
[
689,
815,
764,
830
],
[
765,
815,
806,
829
],
[
807,
815,
829,
829
],
[
831,
815,
868,
829
],
[
870,
815,
912,
829
],
[
91,
830,
127,
844
],
[
131,
830,
160,
844
],
[
162,
830,
210,
844
],
[
214,
830,
305,
844
],
[
308,
830,
323,
843
],
[
326,
830,
342,
843
],
[
345,
830,
397,
843
],
[
400,
830,
440,
843
],
[
444,
830,
494,
843
],
[
497,
829,
533,
843
],
[
536,
829,
561,
843
],
[
564,
829,
576,
843
],
[
579,
829,
631,
844
],
[
634,
829,
659,
844
],
[
662,
829,
693,
844
],
[
696,
829,
726,
844
],
[
730,
829,
754,
844
],
[
757,
829,
795,
844
],
[
798,
829,
824,
844
],
[
828,
829,
870,
844
],
[
873,
829,
905,
844
],
[
908,
829,
928,
844
],
[
91,
844,
132,
858
],
[
135,
844,
192,
858
],
[
195,
844,
223,
858
],
[
225,
844,
238,
858
],
[
241,
844,
276,
858
],
[
279,
844,
304,
858
],
[
307,
844,
338,
858
],
[
341,
843,
372,
858
],
[
374,
843,
399,
858
],
[
401,
843,
430,
858
],
[
432,
843,
460,
858
],
[
462,
843,
511,
858
],
[
513,
843,
525,
858
],
[
528,
843,
570,
858
],
[
572,
843,
587,
858
],
[
589,
843,
637,
858
],
[
640,
843,
680,
858
],
[
682,
843,
732,
858
],
[
734,
844,
744,
858
],
[
747,
844,
762,
858
],
[
765,
844,
787,
858
],
[
790,
844,
888,
858
],
[
92,
860,
155,
872
],
[
158,
860,
186,
873
],
[
189,
860,
203,
873
],
[
206,
860,
260,
873
],
[
263,
860,
294,
873
],
[
297,
860,
316,
873
],
[
319,
860,
347,
873
],
[
351,
860,
392,
873
],
[
395,
860,
408,
873
],
[
412,
860,
439,
873
],
[
442,
860,
456,
873
],
[
460,
860,
476,
873
],
[
480,
860,
527,
873
],
[
530,
860,
594,
873
],
[
597,
860,
611,
873
],
[
614,
860,
663,
873
],
[
666,
860,
681,
873
],
[
684,
860,
748,
873
],
[
751,
860,
833,
873
],
[
836,
860,
861,
872
],
[
864,
860,
907,
872
],
[
89,
874,
129,
887
],
[
132,
874,
188,
888
],
[
191,
874,
204,
888
],
[
208,
874,
281,
888
],
[
285,
874,
346,
888
],
[
349,
874,
363,
888
],
[
366,
874,
427,
888
],
[
431,
874,
454,
888
],
[
459,
874,
472,
888
],
[
476,
874,
519,
888
],
[
522,
874,
538,
888
],
[
541,
874,
607,
888
],
[
611,
874,
632,
888
],
[
635,
874,
721,
888
],
[
725,
874,
795,
888
],
[
798,
874,
812,
888
],
[
815,
874,
865,
888
],
[
87,
888,
174,
902
],
[
177,
888,
191,
902
],
[
195,
888,
211,
902
],
[
215,
888,
276,
902
],
[
281,
888,
290,
902
],
[
292,
888,
338,
902
],
[
342,
888,
350,
902
],
[
353,
888,
405,
902
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
What is the fullform of MCSA?
|
Motor Carrier Safety Act
|
749
|
[
"Attachment",
"A",
"ACC's",
"General",
"Principles",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"(Developed",
"for",
"EPA",
"Dialogue",
"7-2011)",
"EPA",
"should",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"safe",
"use",
"determinations.",
".",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"existing",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"data",
"and",
"information",
"(including",
"models,",
"read",
"across,",
"QSAR,",
"etc.)",
"and",
"industry",
"should",
"be",
"responsible",
"for",
"providing",
"EPA",
"with",
"this",
"data",
"and",
"information.",
"Chemicals",
"lacking",
"adequate",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"a",
"higher",
"priority",
"(until",
"relevant",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"that",
"suggests",
"otherwise).",
"Industry",
"should",
"be",
"provided",
"an",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"EPA",
"additional",
"data/information.",
"Timing",
"is",
"an",
"issue,",
"however.",
"And",
"the",
"format",
"in",
"which",
"the",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"to",
"EPA",
"must",
"be",
"useable/digestible",
"by",
"EPA,",
"e.g.",
"robust",
"summaries.)",
"Hazard,",
"use",
"and",
"exposure",
"based",
"criteria",
"should",
"be",
"integrated",
"to",
"form",
"the",
"basis",
"for",
"EPA's",
"prioritization",
"decisions.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"either",
"hazard-only",
"or",
"exposure-",
"only",
"information.",
"The",
"prioritization",
"process",
"and",
"science",
"based",
"criteria",
"that",
"EPA",
"uses",
"to",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"transparent.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"a",
"dynamic,",
"iterative",
"process.",
"Re-examination",
"of",
"priorities",
"should",
"occur",
"as",
"new",
"information",
"becomes",
"available",
"and",
"as",
"new",
"chemicals",
"are",
"approved",
"for",
"manufacturing.",
"For",
"prioritization",
"to",
"be",
"successful,",
"it",
"must",
"include",
"three",
"critical",
"elements:",
"reliable",
"and",
"up-",
"to-",
"date",
"chemical",
"data",
"and",
"information;",
"evaluation",
"criteria",
"that",
"consider",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"together;",
"and",
"established",
"cutoffs",
"to",
"make",
"priority",
"decisions.",
"EPA's",
"communication",
"about",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"clear",
"about",
"what",
"the",
"list",
"is",
"and",
"what",
"it",
"is",
"not,",
"to",
"avoid",
"unintended",
"consequences",
"of",
"product",
"de-selection",
"purely",
"on",
"the",
"basis",
"of",
"listing.",
"Transparency;",
"consistent,",
"scientific",
"criteria;",
"intersection",
"of",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information;",
"dynamic",
"process",
"so",
"new",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"incorporated",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"made",
"available",
"and",
"so",
"if",
"priorities",
"are",
"initially",
"\"wrong\"",
"they",
"can",
"be",
"corrected.",
"25",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
825,
65,
917,
78
],
[
920,
65,
931,
78
],
[
348,
164,
406,
179
],
[
410,
164,
477,
180
],
[
481,
164,
567,
180
],
[
570,
164,
593,
180
],
[
596,
164,
712,
180
],
[
400,
214,
492,
230
],
[
497,
214,
520,
230
],
[
524,
214,
561,
230
],
[
566,
214,
640,
230
],
[
644,
213,
707,
231
],
[
176,
250,
211,
264
],
[
215,
250,
264,
264
],
[
268,
250,
376,
265
],
[
380,
250,
452,
265
],
[
455,
250,
530,
265
],
[
533,
250,
555,
265
],
[
558,
250,
624,
265
],
[
627,
250,
642,
265
],
[
646,
250,
677,
265
],
[
680,
250,
706,
265
],
[
709,
250,
822,
265
],
[
147,
279,
159,
292
],
[
177,
280,
198,
295
],
[
201,
280,
211,
295
],
[
214,
280,
267,
295
],
[
270,
280,
321,
295
],
[
324,
280,
421,
294
],
[
424,
280,
472,
294
],
[
475,
280,
494,
294
],
[
497,
280,
540,
294
],
[
543,
280,
563,
294
],
[
566,
280,
626,
295
],
[
629,
280,
685,
295
],
[
688,
280,
718,
295
],
[
721,
280,
795,
295
],
[
798,
280,
832,
295
],
[
177,
295,
206,
310
],
[
209,
295,
303,
310
],
[
306,
295,
384,
310
],
[
387,
295,
448,
310
],
[
451,
295,
489,
310
],
[
491,
295,
547,
310
],
[
549,
295,
604,
310
],
[
607,
295,
642,
310
],
[
645,
295,
672,
310
],
[
675,
295,
742,
310
],
[
745,
295,
796,
310
],
[
799,
295,
824,
310
],
[
176,
311,
265,
326
],
[
268,
311,
290,
326
],
[
293,
311,
364,
326
],
[
368,
311,
401,
326
],
[
407,
311,
439,
326
],
[
442,
311,
472,
326
],
[
475,
311,
504,
326
],
[
507,
311,
533,
326
],
[
536,
311,
627,
326
],
[
177,
346,
252,
360
],
[
255,
347,
315,
361
],
[
318,
347,
387,
361
],
[
390,
347,
447,
361
],
[
450,
348,
480,
361
],
[
483,
348,
554,
361
],
[
557,
347,
644,
361
],
[
647,
347,
696,
360
],
[
699,
347,
717,
360
],
[
720,
346,
801,
360
],
[
803,
346,
816,
360
],
[
177,
363,
227,
376
],
[
230,
363,
291,
377
],
[
294,
363,
334,
377
],
[
338,
363,
397,
377
],
[
400,
364,
487,
377
],
[
490,
364,
502,
377
],
[
506,
364,
572,
377
],
[
575,
364,
604,
377
],
[
607,
364,
667,
377
],
[
671,
364,
753,
377
],
[
175,
397,
238,
411
],
[
241,
397,
289,
412
],
[
292,
397,
310,
412
],
[
314,
397,
380,
412
],
[
384,
397,
401,
412
],
[
404,
397,
498,
412
],
[
502,
397,
517,
412
],
[
520,
397,
582,
412
],
[
585,
397,
621,
412
],
[
625,
397,
707,
412
],
[
711,
395,
847,
411
],
[
184,
414,
236,
428
],
[
239,
414,
253,
428
],
[
256,
414,
274,
428
],
[
277,
414,
318,
428
],
[
321,
414,
391,
428
],
[
394,
414,
425,
428
],
[
429,
414,
452,
428
],
[
455,
414,
504,
428
],
[
508,
414,
523,
428
],
[
527,
414,
571,
428
],
[
574,
414,
597,
428
],
[
601,
414,
687,
428
],
[
690,
414,
704,
427
],
[
707,
414,
772,
427
],
[
775,
413,
792,
427
],
[
795,
413,
828,
427
],
[
175,
430,
212,
443
],
[
215,
430,
234,
443
],
[
237,
429,
367,
443
],
[
370,
429,
391,
443
],
[
394,
429,
433,
443
],
[
436,
430,
462,
444
],
[
465,
430,
513,
444
],
[
516,
430,
605,
444
],
[
176,
464,
241,
477
],
[
244,
464,
270,
477
],
[
272,
464,
304,
478
],
[
306,
464,
376,
478
],
[
379,
464,
425,
478
],
[
428,
465,
487,
478
],
[
490,
465,
542,
478
],
[
545,
465,
564,
478
],
[
568,
464,
648,
478
],
[
651,
464,
667,
478
],
[
670,
464,
702,
478
],
[
708,
464,
732,
477
],
[
735,
464,
773,
477
],
[
776,
464,
800,
477
],
[
178,
480,
224,
493
],
[
227,
480,
324,
493
],
[
330,
480,
399,
494
],
[
402,
481,
498,
494
],
[
502,
481,
551,
494
],
[
554,
481,
578,
494
],
[
581,
481,
600,
494
],
[
602,
481,
646,
494
],
[
648,
481,
668,
493
],
[
670,
481,
714,
493
],
[
716,
480,
805,
493
],
[
806,
480,
827,
492
],
[
177,
497,
249,
509
],
[
251,
497,
285,
509
],
[
288,
497,
381,
510
],
[
178,
525,
205,
539
],
[
208,
525,
303,
539
],
[
307,
525,
363,
540
],
[
366,
525,
392,
540
],
[
396,
525,
450,
540
],
[
453,
525,
495,
540
],
[
499,
525,
552,
540
],
[
555,
525,
584,
540
],
[
587,
525,
619,
540
],
[
625,
525,
656,
540
],
[
659,
525,
675,
540
],
[
678,
524,
746,
540
],
[
750,
524,
823,
539
],
[
177,
542,
212,
554
],
[
215,
542,
234,
554
],
[
237,
542,
333,
555
],
[
175,
570,
272,
585
],
[
275,
570,
324,
585
],
[
328,
571,
347,
585
],
[
350,
571,
361,
586
],
[
365,
571,
432,
586
],
[
436,
571,
502,
586
],
[
505,
571,
567,
586
],
[
571,
570,
688,
586
],
[
692,
570,
707,
585
],
[
711,
570,
776,
585
],
[
780,
570,
829,
585
],
[
177,
588,
218,
601
],
[
221,
588,
237,
601
],
[
240,
588,
268,
601
],
[
273,
588,
360,
601
],
[
363,
588,
428,
601
],
[
431,
588,
497,
601
],
[
500,
588,
527,
601
],
[
530,
588,
545,
601
],
[
548,
588,
577,
601
],
[
584,
588,
657,
601
],
[
660,
587,
683,
601
],
[
686,
587,
754,
601
],
[
757,
587,
780,
601
],
[
175,
604,
284,
619
],
[
176,
633,
202,
646
],
[
205,
633,
301,
646
],
[
304,
634,
320,
646
],
[
322,
634,
341,
646
],
[
344,
634,
423,
646
],
[
426,
634,
438,
647
],
[
441,
634,
477,
647
],
[
480,
634,
535,
647
],
[
538,
634,
575,
647
],
[
578,
634,
630,
647
],
[
632,
634,
704,
647
],
[
706,
633,
767,
647
],
[
770,
633,
800,
646
],
[
802,
633,
829,
646
],
[
177,
649,
202,
662
],
[
205,
649,
236,
662
],
[
239,
649,
312,
663
],
[
315,
650,
348,
663
],
[
350,
650,
380,
663
],
[
382,
650,
484,
664
],
[
486,
650,
567,
664
],
[
571,
650,
628,
664
],
[
631,
650,
665,
663
],
[
668,
650,
734,
663
],
[
737,
650,
773,
663
],
[
776,
649,
830,
663
],
[
178,
666,
207,
679
],
[
210,
666,
280,
679
],
[
283,
666,
376,
680
],
[
379,
666,
451,
680
],
[
454,
666,
484,
680
],
[
487,
666,
574,
680
],
[
577,
666,
631,
680
],
[
634,
666,
650,
680
],
[
653,
666,
697,
680
],
[
700,
666,
762,
680
],
[
765,
665,
840,
680
],
[
177,
693,
232,
708
],
[
235,
694,
365,
709
],
[
370,
694,
418,
709
],
[
421,
694,
489,
709
],
[
492,
694,
575,
709
],
[
578,
694,
621,
709
],
[
624,
694,
646,
709
],
[
650,
694,
693,
709
],
[
697,
694,
747,
709
],
[
750,
694,
792,
709
],
[
795,
694,
822,
709
],
[
825,
694,
855,
708
],
[
177,
711,
191,
726
],
[
194,
711,
228,
726
],
[
231,
711,
273,
726
],
[
277,
711,
290,
726
],
[
293,
711,
308,
726
],
[
312,
711,
347,
726
],
[
350,
711,
367,
727
],
[
370,
711,
417,
727
],
[
421,
711,
518,
727
],
[
522,
711,
634,
727
],
[
638,
711,
654,
727
],
[
658,
710,
730,
727
],
[
734,
710,
830,
727
],
[
175,
730,
228,
745
],
[
231,
730,
252,
744
],
[
255,
730,
281,
744
],
[
285,
730,
323,
744
],
[
326,
730,
344,
744
],
[
347,
730,
402,
745
],
[
177,
759,
291,
775
],
[
294,
759,
376,
774
],
[
380,
759,
448,
773
],
[
452,
759,
515,
773
],
[
518,
759,
611,
773
],
[
615,
758,
629,
773
],
[
632,
758,
668,
773
],
[
672,
758,
728,
774
],
[
732,
758,
761,
774
],
[
765,
758,
839,
774
],
[
177,
774,
277,
790
],
[
281,
775,
345,
790
],
[
349,
775,
407,
790
],
[
411,
775,
427,
790
],
[
431,
775,
461,
790
],
[
465,
775,
551,
790
],
[
555,
775,
580,
790
],
[
584,
775,
602,
790
],
[
607,
775,
698,
790
],
[
702,
775,
717,
790
],
[
720,
775,
732,
790
],
[
736,
775,
748,
790
],
[
752,
775,
788,
790
],
[
177,
791,
242,
805
],
[
246,
791,
274,
805
],
[
277,
790,
294,
805
],
[
297,
790,
309,
806
],
[
312,
790,
378,
806
],
[
381,
790,
405,
806
],
[
408,
790,
465,
806
],
[
468,
790,
532,
806
],
[
535,
790,
567,
806
],
[
570,
791,
596,
806
],
[
600,
791,
617,
806
],
[
620,
791,
697,
806
],
[
510,
911,
531,
927
],
[
222,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
how should be prioritization process ?
|
dynamic, iterative process
|
749
|
[
"Attachment",
"A",
"ACC's",
"General",
"Principles",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"(Developed",
"for",
"EPA",
"Dialogue",
"7-2011)",
"EPA",
"should",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"safe",
"use",
"determinations.",
".",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"existing",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"data",
"and",
"information",
"(including",
"models,",
"read",
"across,",
"QSAR,",
"etc.)",
"and",
"industry",
"should",
"be",
"responsible",
"for",
"providing",
"EPA",
"with",
"this",
"data",
"and",
"information.",
"Chemicals",
"lacking",
"adequate",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"a",
"higher",
"priority",
"(until",
"relevant",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"that",
"suggests",
"otherwise).",
"Industry",
"should",
"be",
"provided",
"an",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"EPA",
"additional",
"data/information.",
"Timing",
"is",
"an",
"issue,",
"however.",
"And",
"the",
"format",
"in",
"which",
"the",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"to",
"EPA",
"must",
"be",
"useable/digestible",
"by",
"EPA,",
"e.g.",
"robust",
"summaries.)",
"Hazard,",
"use",
"and",
"exposure",
"based",
"criteria",
"should",
"be",
"integrated",
"to",
"form",
"the",
"basis",
"for",
"EPA's",
"prioritization",
"decisions.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"either",
"hazard-only",
"or",
"exposure-",
"only",
"information.",
"The",
"prioritization",
"process",
"and",
"science",
"based",
"criteria",
"that",
"EPA",
"uses",
"to",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"transparent.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"a",
"dynamic,",
"iterative",
"process.",
"Re-examination",
"of",
"priorities",
"should",
"occur",
"as",
"new",
"information",
"becomes",
"available",
"and",
"as",
"new",
"chemicals",
"are",
"approved",
"for",
"manufacturing.",
"For",
"prioritization",
"to",
"be",
"successful,",
"it",
"must",
"include",
"three",
"critical",
"elements:",
"reliable",
"and",
"up-",
"to-",
"date",
"chemical",
"data",
"and",
"information;",
"evaluation",
"criteria",
"that",
"consider",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"together;",
"and",
"established",
"cutoffs",
"to",
"make",
"priority",
"decisions.",
"EPA's",
"communication",
"about",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"clear",
"about",
"what",
"the",
"list",
"is",
"and",
"what",
"it",
"is",
"not,",
"to",
"avoid",
"unintended",
"consequences",
"of",
"product",
"de-selection",
"purely",
"on",
"the",
"basis",
"of",
"listing.",
"Transparency;",
"consistent,",
"scientific",
"criteria;",
"intersection",
"of",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information;",
"dynamic",
"process",
"so",
"new",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"incorporated",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"made",
"available",
"and",
"so",
"if",
"priorities",
"are",
"initially",
"\"wrong\"",
"they",
"can",
"be",
"corrected.",
"25",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
825,
65,
917,
78
],
[
920,
65,
931,
78
],
[
348,
164,
406,
179
],
[
410,
164,
477,
180
],
[
481,
164,
567,
180
],
[
570,
164,
593,
180
],
[
596,
164,
712,
180
],
[
400,
214,
492,
230
],
[
497,
214,
520,
230
],
[
524,
214,
561,
230
],
[
566,
214,
640,
230
],
[
644,
213,
707,
231
],
[
176,
250,
211,
264
],
[
215,
250,
264,
264
],
[
268,
250,
376,
265
],
[
380,
250,
452,
265
],
[
455,
250,
530,
265
],
[
533,
250,
555,
265
],
[
558,
250,
624,
265
],
[
627,
250,
642,
265
],
[
646,
250,
677,
265
],
[
680,
250,
706,
265
],
[
709,
250,
822,
265
],
[
147,
279,
159,
292
],
[
177,
280,
198,
295
],
[
201,
280,
211,
295
],
[
214,
280,
267,
295
],
[
270,
280,
321,
295
],
[
324,
280,
421,
294
],
[
424,
280,
472,
294
],
[
475,
280,
494,
294
],
[
497,
280,
540,
294
],
[
543,
280,
563,
294
],
[
566,
280,
626,
295
],
[
629,
280,
685,
295
],
[
688,
280,
718,
295
],
[
721,
280,
795,
295
],
[
798,
280,
832,
295
],
[
177,
295,
206,
310
],
[
209,
295,
303,
310
],
[
306,
295,
384,
310
],
[
387,
295,
448,
310
],
[
451,
295,
489,
310
],
[
491,
295,
547,
310
],
[
549,
295,
604,
310
],
[
607,
295,
642,
310
],
[
645,
295,
672,
310
],
[
675,
295,
742,
310
],
[
745,
295,
796,
310
],
[
799,
295,
824,
310
],
[
176,
311,
265,
326
],
[
268,
311,
290,
326
],
[
293,
311,
364,
326
],
[
368,
311,
401,
326
],
[
407,
311,
439,
326
],
[
442,
311,
472,
326
],
[
475,
311,
504,
326
],
[
507,
311,
533,
326
],
[
536,
311,
627,
326
],
[
177,
346,
252,
360
],
[
255,
347,
315,
361
],
[
318,
347,
387,
361
],
[
390,
347,
447,
361
],
[
450,
348,
480,
361
],
[
483,
348,
554,
361
],
[
557,
347,
644,
361
],
[
647,
347,
696,
360
],
[
699,
347,
717,
360
],
[
720,
346,
801,
360
],
[
803,
346,
816,
360
],
[
177,
363,
227,
376
],
[
230,
363,
291,
377
],
[
294,
363,
334,
377
],
[
338,
363,
397,
377
],
[
400,
364,
487,
377
],
[
490,
364,
502,
377
],
[
506,
364,
572,
377
],
[
575,
364,
604,
377
],
[
607,
364,
667,
377
],
[
671,
364,
753,
377
],
[
175,
397,
238,
411
],
[
241,
397,
289,
412
],
[
292,
397,
310,
412
],
[
314,
397,
380,
412
],
[
384,
397,
401,
412
],
[
404,
397,
498,
412
],
[
502,
397,
517,
412
],
[
520,
397,
582,
412
],
[
585,
397,
621,
412
],
[
625,
397,
707,
412
],
[
711,
395,
847,
411
],
[
184,
414,
236,
428
],
[
239,
414,
253,
428
],
[
256,
414,
274,
428
],
[
277,
414,
318,
428
],
[
321,
414,
391,
428
],
[
394,
414,
425,
428
],
[
429,
414,
452,
428
],
[
455,
414,
504,
428
],
[
508,
414,
523,
428
],
[
527,
414,
571,
428
],
[
574,
414,
597,
428
],
[
601,
414,
687,
428
],
[
690,
414,
704,
427
],
[
707,
414,
772,
427
],
[
775,
413,
792,
427
],
[
795,
413,
828,
427
],
[
175,
430,
212,
443
],
[
215,
430,
234,
443
],
[
237,
429,
367,
443
],
[
370,
429,
391,
443
],
[
394,
429,
433,
443
],
[
436,
430,
462,
444
],
[
465,
430,
513,
444
],
[
516,
430,
605,
444
],
[
176,
464,
241,
477
],
[
244,
464,
270,
477
],
[
272,
464,
304,
478
],
[
306,
464,
376,
478
],
[
379,
464,
425,
478
],
[
428,
465,
487,
478
],
[
490,
465,
542,
478
],
[
545,
465,
564,
478
],
[
568,
464,
648,
478
],
[
651,
464,
667,
478
],
[
670,
464,
702,
478
],
[
708,
464,
732,
477
],
[
735,
464,
773,
477
],
[
776,
464,
800,
477
],
[
178,
480,
224,
493
],
[
227,
480,
324,
493
],
[
330,
480,
399,
494
],
[
402,
481,
498,
494
],
[
502,
481,
551,
494
],
[
554,
481,
578,
494
],
[
581,
481,
600,
494
],
[
602,
481,
646,
494
],
[
648,
481,
668,
493
],
[
670,
481,
714,
493
],
[
716,
480,
805,
493
],
[
806,
480,
827,
492
],
[
177,
497,
249,
509
],
[
251,
497,
285,
509
],
[
288,
497,
381,
510
],
[
178,
525,
205,
539
],
[
208,
525,
303,
539
],
[
307,
525,
363,
540
],
[
366,
525,
392,
540
],
[
396,
525,
450,
540
],
[
453,
525,
495,
540
],
[
499,
525,
552,
540
],
[
555,
525,
584,
540
],
[
587,
525,
619,
540
],
[
625,
525,
656,
540
],
[
659,
525,
675,
540
],
[
678,
524,
746,
540
],
[
750,
524,
823,
539
],
[
177,
542,
212,
554
],
[
215,
542,
234,
554
],
[
237,
542,
333,
555
],
[
175,
570,
272,
585
],
[
275,
570,
324,
585
],
[
328,
571,
347,
585
],
[
350,
571,
361,
586
],
[
365,
571,
432,
586
],
[
436,
571,
502,
586
],
[
505,
571,
567,
586
],
[
571,
570,
688,
586
],
[
692,
570,
707,
585
],
[
711,
570,
776,
585
],
[
780,
570,
829,
585
],
[
177,
588,
218,
601
],
[
221,
588,
237,
601
],
[
240,
588,
268,
601
],
[
273,
588,
360,
601
],
[
363,
588,
428,
601
],
[
431,
588,
497,
601
],
[
500,
588,
527,
601
],
[
530,
588,
545,
601
],
[
548,
588,
577,
601
],
[
584,
588,
657,
601
],
[
660,
587,
683,
601
],
[
686,
587,
754,
601
],
[
757,
587,
780,
601
],
[
175,
604,
284,
619
],
[
176,
633,
202,
646
],
[
205,
633,
301,
646
],
[
304,
634,
320,
646
],
[
322,
634,
341,
646
],
[
344,
634,
423,
646
],
[
426,
634,
438,
647
],
[
441,
634,
477,
647
],
[
480,
634,
535,
647
],
[
538,
634,
575,
647
],
[
578,
634,
630,
647
],
[
632,
634,
704,
647
],
[
706,
633,
767,
647
],
[
770,
633,
800,
646
],
[
802,
633,
829,
646
],
[
177,
649,
202,
662
],
[
205,
649,
236,
662
],
[
239,
649,
312,
663
],
[
315,
650,
348,
663
],
[
350,
650,
380,
663
],
[
382,
650,
484,
664
],
[
486,
650,
567,
664
],
[
571,
650,
628,
664
],
[
631,
650,
665,
663
],
[
668,
650,
734,
663
],
[
737,
650,
773,
663
],
[
776,
649,
830,
663
],
[
178,
666,
207,
679
],
[
210,
666,
280,
679
],
[
283,
666,
376,
680
],
[
379,
666,
451,
680
],
[
454,
666,
484,
680
],
[
487,
666,
574,
680
],
[
577,
666,
631,
680
],
[
634,
666,
650,
680
],
[
653,
666,
697,
680
],
[
700,
666,
762,
680
],
[
765,
665,
840,
680
],
[
177,
693,
232,
708
],
[
235,
694,
365,
709
],
[
370,
694,
418,
709
],
[
421,
694,
489,
709
],
[
492,
694,
575,
709
],
[
578,
694,
621,
709
],
[
624,
694,
646,
709
],
[
650,
694,
693,
709
],
[
697,
694,
747,
709
],
[
750,
694,
792,
709
],
[
795,
694,
822,
709
],
[
825,
694,
855,
708
],
[
177,
711,
191,
726
],
[
194,
711,
228,
726
],
[
231,
711,
273,
726
],
[
277,
711,
290,
726
],
[
293,
711,
308,
726
],
[
312,
711,
347,
726
],
[
350,
711,
367,
727
],
[
370,
711,
417,
727
],
[
421,
711,
518,
727
],
[
522,
711,
634,
727
],
[
638,
711,
654,
727
],
[
658,
710,
730,
727
],
[
734,
710,
830,
727
],
[
175,
730,
228,
745
],
[
231,
730,
252,
744
],
[
255,
730,
281,
744
],
[
285,
730,
323,
744
],
[
326,
730,
344,
744
],
[
347,
730,
402,
745
],
[
177,
759,
291,
775
],
[
294,
759,
376,
774
],
[
380,
759,
448,
773
],
[
452,
759,
515,
773
],
[
518,
759,
611,
773
],
[
615,
758,
629,
773
],
[
632,
758,
668,
773
],
[
672,
758,
728,
774
],
[
732,
758,
761,
774
],
[
765,
758,
839,
774
],
[
177,
774,
277,
790
],
[
281,
775,
345,
790
],
[
349,
775,
407,
790
],
[
411,
775,
427,
790
],
[
431,
775,
461,
790
],
[
465,
775,
551,
790
],
[
555,
775,
580,
790
],
[
584,
775,
602,
790
],
[
607,
775,
698,
790
],
[
702,
775,
717,
790
],
[
720,
775,
732,
790
],
[
736,
775,
748,
790
],
[
752,
775,
788,
790
],
[
177,
791,
242,
805
],
[
246,
791,
274,
805
],
[
277,
790,
294,
805
],
[
297,
790,
309,
806
],
[
312,
790,
378,
806
],
[
381,
790,
405,
806
],
[
408,
790,
465,
806
],
[
468,
790,
532,
806
],
[
535,
790,
567,
806
],
[
570,
791,
596,
806
],
[
600,
791,
617,
806
],
[
620,
791,
697,
806
],
[
510,
911,
531,
927
],
[
222,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
how many critical elements are included for prioritization to be successful ?
|
three
|
749
|
[
"Attachment",
"A",
"ACC's",
"General",
"Principles",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"(Developed",
"for",
"EPA",
"Dialogue",
"7-2011)",
"EPA",
"should",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"safe",
"use",
"determinations.",
".",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"existing",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"data",
"and",
"information",
"(including",
"models,",
"read",
"across,",
"QSAR,",
"etc.)",
"and",
"industry",
"should",
"be",
"responsible",
"for",
"providing",
"EPA",
"with",
"this",
"data",
"and",
"information.",
"Chemicals",
"lacking",
"adequate",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"a",
"higher",
"priority",
"(until",
"relevant",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"that",
"suggests",
"otherwise).",
"Industry",
"should",
"be",
"provided",
"an",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"EPA",
"additional",
"data/information.",
"Timing",
"is",
"an",
"issue,",
"however.",
"And",
"the",
"format",
"in",
"which",
"the",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"to",
"EPA",
"must",
"be",
"useable/digestible",
"by",
"EPA,",
"e.g.",
"robust",
"summaries.)",
"Hazard,",
"use",
"and",
"exposure",
"based",
"criteria",
"should",
"be",
"integrated",
"to",
"form",
"the",
"basis",
"for",
"EPA's",
"prioritization",
"decisions.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"either",
"hazard-only",
"or",
"exposure-",
"only",
"information.",
"The",
"prioritization",
"process",
"and",
"science",
"based",
"criteria",
"that",
"EPA",
"uses",
"to",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"transparent.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"a",
"dynamic,",
"iterative",
"process.",
"Re-examination",
"of",
"priorities",
"should",
"occur",
"as",
"new",
"information",
"becomes",
"available",
"and",
"as",
"new",
"chemicals",
"are",
"approved",
"for",
"manufacturing.",
"For",
"prioritization",
"to",
"be",
"successful,",
"it",
"must",
"include",
"three",
"critical",
"elements:",
"reliable",
"and",
"up-",
"to-",
"date",
"chemical",
"data",
"and",
"information;",
"evaluation",
"criteria",
"that",
"consider",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"together;",
"and",
"established",
"cutoffs",
"to",
"make",
"priority",
"decisions.",
"EPA's",
"communication",
"about",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"clear",
"about",
"what",
"the",
"list",
"is",
"and",
"what",
"it",
"is",
"not,",
"to",
"avoid",
"unintended",
"consequences",
"of",
"product",
"de-selection",
"purely",
"on",
"the",
"basis",
"of",
"listing.",
"Transparency;",
"consistent,",
"scientific",
"criteria;",
"intersection",
"of",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information;",
"dynamic",
"process",
"so",
"new",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"incorporated",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"made",
"available",
"and",
"so",
"if",
"priorities",
"are",
"initially",
"\"wrong\"",
"they",
"can",
"be",
"corrected.",
"25",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
825,
65,
917,
78
],
[
920,
65,
931,
78
],
[
348,
164,
406,
179
],
[
410,
164,
477,
180
],
[
481,
164,
567,
180
],
[
570,
164,
593,
180
],
[
596,
164,
712,
180
],
[
400,
214,
492,
230
],
[
497,
214,
520,
230
],
[
524,
214,
561,
230
],
[
566,
214,
640,
230
],
[
644,
213,
707,
231
],
[
176,
250,
211,
264
],
[
215,
250,
264,
264
],
[
268,
250,
376,
265
],
[
380,
250,
452,
265
],
[
455,
250,
530,
265
],
[
533,
250,
555,
265
],
[
558,
250,
624,
265
],
[
627,
250,
642,
265
],
[
646,
250,
677,
265
],
[
680,
250,
706,
265
],
[
709,
250,
822,
265
],
[
147,
279,
159,
292
],
[
177,
280,
198,
295
],
[
201,
280,
211,
295
],
[
214,
280,
267,
295
],
[
270,
280,
321,
295
],
[
324,
280,
421,
294
],
[
424,
280,
472,
294
],
[
475,
280,
494,
294
],
[
497,
280,
540,
294
],
[
543,
280,
563,
294
],
[
566,
280,
626,
295
],
[
629,
280,
685,
295
],
[
688,
280,
718,
295
],
[
721,
280,
795,
295
],
[
798,
280,
832,
295
],
[
177,
295,
206,
310
],
[
209,
295,
303,
310
],
[
306,
295,
384,
310
],
[
387,
295,
448,
310
],
[
451,
295,
489,
310
],
[
491,
295,
547,
310
],
[
549,
295,
604,
310
],
[
607,
295,
642,
310
],
[
645,
295,
672,
310
],
[
675,
295,
742,
310
],
[
745,
295,
796,
310
],
[
799,
295,
824,
310
],
[
176,
311,
265,
326
],
[
268,
311,
290,
326
],
[
293,
311,
364,
326
],
[
368,
311,
401,
326
],
[
407,
311,
439,
326
],
[
442,
311,
472,
326
],
[
475,
311,
504,
326
],
[
507,
311,
533,
326
],
[
536,
311,
627,
326
],
[
177,
346,
252,
360
],
[
255,
347,
315,
361
],
[
318,
347,
387,
361
],
[
390,
347,
447,
361
],
[
450,
348,
480,
361
],
[
483,
348,
554,
361
],
[
557,
347,
644,
361
],
[
647,
347,
696,
360
],
[
699,
347,
717,
360
],
[
720,
346,
801,
360
],
[
803,
346,
816,
360
],
[
177,
363,
227,
376
],
[
230,
363,
291,
377
],
[
294,
363,
334,
377
],
[
338,
363,
397,
377
],
[
400,
364,
487,
377
],
[
490,
364,
502,
377
],
[
506,
364,
572,
377
],
[
575,
364,
604,
377
],
[
607,
364,
667,
377
],
[
671,
364,
753,
377
],
[
175,
397,
238,
411
],
[
241,
397,
289,
412
],
[
292,
397,
310,
412
],
[
314,
397,
380,
412
],
[
384,
397,
401,
412
],
[
404,
397,
498,
412
],
[
502,
397,
517,
412
],
[
520,
397,
582,
412
],
[
585,
397,
621,
412
],
[
625,
397,
707,
412
],
[
711,
395,
847,
411
],
[
184,
414,
236,
428
],
[
239,
414,
253,
428
],
[
256,
414,
274,
428
],
[
277,
414,
318,
428
],
[
321,
414,
391,
428
],
[
394,
414,
425,
428
],
[
429,
414,
452,
428
],
[
455,
414,
504,
428
],
[
508,
414,
523,
428
],
[
527,
414,
571,
428
],
[
574,
414,
597,
428
],
[
601,
414,
687,
428
],
[
690,
414,
704,
427
],
[
707,
414,
772,
427
],
[
775,
413,
792,
427
],
[
795,
413,
828,
427
],
[
175,
430,
212,
443
],
[
215,
430,
234,
443
],
[
237,
429,
367,
443
],
[
370,
429,
391,
443
],
[
394,
429,
433,
443
],
[
436,
430,
462,
444
],
[
465,
430,
513,
444
],
[
516,
430,
605,
444
],
[
176,
464,
241,
477
],
[
244,
464,
270,
477
],
[
272,
464,
304,
478
],
[
306,
464,
376,
478
],
[
379,
464,
425,
478
],
[
428,
465,
487,
478
],
[
490,
465,
542,
478
],
[
545,
465,
564,
478
],
[
568,
464,
648,
478
],
[
651,
464,
667,
478
],
[
670,
464,
702,
478
],
[
708,
464,
732,
477
],
[
735,
464,
773,
477
],
[
776,
464,
800,
477
],
[
178,
480,
224,
493
],
[
227,
480,
324,
493
],
[
330,
480,
399,
494
],
[
402,
481,
498,
494
],
[
502,
481,
551,
494
],
[
554,
481,
578,
494
],
[
581,
481,
600,
494
],
[
602,
481,
646,
494
],
[
648,
481,
668,
493
],
[
670,
481,
714,
493
],
[
716,
480,
805,
493
],
[
806,
480,
827,
492
],
[
177,
497,
249,
509
],
[
251,
497,
285,
509
],
[
288,
497,
381,
510
],
[
178,
525,
205,
539
],
[
208,
525,
303,
539
],
[
307,
525,
363,
540
],
[
366,
525,
392,
540
],
[
396,
525,
450,
540
],
[
453,
525,
495,
540
],
[
499,
525,
552,
540
],
[
555,
525,
584,
540
],
[
587,
525,
619,
540
],
[
625,
525,
656,
540
],
[
659,
525,
675,
540
],
[
678,
524,
746,
540
],
[
750,
524,
823,
539
],
[
177,
542,
212,
554
],
[
215,
542,
234,
554
],
[
237,
542,
333,
555
],
[
175,
570,
272,
585
],
[
275,
570,
324,
585
],
[
328,
571,
347,
585
],
[
350,
571,
361,
586
],
[
365,
571,
432,
586
],
[
436,
571,
502,
586
],
[
505,
571,
567,
586
],
[
571,
570,
688,
586
],
[
692,
570,
707,
585
],
[
711,
570,
776,
585
],
[
780,
570,
829,
585
],
[
177,
588,
218,
601
],
[
221,
588,
237,
601
],
[
240,
588,
268,
601
],
[
273,
588,
360,
601
],
[
363,
588,
428,
601
],
[
431,
588,
497,
601
],
[
500,
588,
527,
601
],
[
530,
588,
545,
601
],
[
548,
588,
577,
601
],
[
584,
588,
657,
601
],
[
660,
587,
683,
601
],
[
686,
587,
754,
601
],
[
757,
587,
780,
601
],
[
175,
604,
284,
619
],
[
176,
633,
202,
646
],
[
205,
633,
301,
646
],
[
304,
634,
320,
646
],
[
322,
634,
341,
646
],
[
344,
634,
423,
646
],
[
426,
634,
438,
647
],
[
441,
634,
477,
647
],
[
480,
634,
535,
647
],
[
538,
634,
575,
647
],
[
578,
634,
630,
647
],
[
632,
634,
704,
647
],
[
706,
633,
767,
647
],
[
770,
633,
800,
646
],
[
802,
633,
829,
646
],
[
177,
649,
202,
662
],
[
205,
649,
236,
662
],
[
239,
649,
312,
663
],
[
315,
650,
348,
663
],
[
350,
650,
380,
663
],
[
382,
650,
484,
664
],
[
486,
650,
567,
664
],
[
571,
650,
628,
664
],
[
631,
650,
665,
663
],
[
668,
650,
734,
663
],
[
737,
650,
773,
663
],
[
776,
649,
830,
663
],
[
178,
666,
207,
679
],
[
210,
666,
280,
679
],
[
283,
666,
376,
680
],
[
379,
666,
451,
680
],
[
454,
666,
484,
680
],
[
487,
666,
574,
680
],
[
577,
666,
631,
680
],
[
634,
666,
650,
680
],
[
653,
666,
697,
680
],
[
700,
666,
762,
680
],
[
765,
665,
840,
680
],
[
177,
693,
232,
708
],
[
235,
694,
365,
709
],
[
370,
694,
418,
709
],
[
421,
694,
489,
709
],
[
492,
694,
575,
709
],
[
578,
694,
621,
709
],
[
624,
694,
646,
709
],
[
650,
694,
693,
709
],
[
697,
694,
747,
709
],
[
750,
694,
792,
709
],
[
795,
694,
822,
709
],
[
825,
694,
855,
708
],
[
177,
711,
191,
726
],
[
194,
711,
228,
726
],
[
231,
711,
273,
726
],
[
277,
711,
290,
726
],
[
293,
711,
308,
726
],
[
312,
711,
347,
726
],
[
350,
711,
367,
727
],
[
370,
711,
417,
727
],
[
421,
711,
518,
727
],
[
522,
711,
634,
727
],
[
638,
711,
654,
727
],
[
658,
710,
730,
727
],
[
734,
710,
830,
727
],
[
175,
730,
228,
745
],
[
231,
730,
252,
744
],
[
255,
730,
281,
744
],
[
285,
730,
323,
744
],
[
326,
730,
344,
744
],
[
347,
730,
402,
745
],
[
177,
759,
291,
775
],
[
294,
759,
376,
774
],
[
380,
759,
448,
773
],
[
452,
759,
515,
773
],
[
518,
759,
611,
773
],
[
615,
758,
629,
773
],
[
632,
758,
668,
773
],
[
672,
758,
728,
774
],
[
732,
758,
761,
774
],
[
765,
758,
839,
774
],
[
177,
774,
277,
790
],
[
281,
775,
345,
790
],
[
349,
775,
407,
790
],
[
411,
775,
427,
790
],
[
431,
775,
461,
790
],
[
465,
775,
551,
790
],
[
555,
775,
580,
790
],
[
584,
775,
602,
790
],
[
607,
775,
698,
790
],
[
702,
775,
717,
790
],
[
720,
775,
732,
790
],
[
736,
775,
748,
790
],
[
752,
775,
788,
790
],
[
177,
791,
242,
805
],
[
246,
791,
274,
805
],
[
277,
790,
294,
805
],
[
297,
790,
309,
806
],
[
312,
790,
378,
806
],
[
381,
790,
405,
806
],
[
408,
790,
465,
806
],
[
468,
790,
532,
806
],
[
535,
790,
567,
806
],
[
570,
791,
596,
806
],
[
600,
791,
617,
806
],
[
620,
791,
697,
806
],
[
510,
911,
531,
927
],
[
222,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
mention the first point of critical elements under prioritization to be successful
|
reliable and up-to-date chemical data and information
|
749
|
[
"Attachment",
"A",
"ACC's",
"General",
"Principles",
"on",
"Prioritization",
"(Developed",
"for",
"EPA",
"Dialogue",
"7-2011)",
"EPA",
"should",
"systematically",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"for",
"purposes",
"of",
"safe",
"use",
"determinations.",
".",
"As",
"a",
"general",
"matter,",
"prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"existing",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"data",
"and",
"information",
"(including",
"models,",
"read",
"across,",
"QSAR,",
"etc.)",
"and",
"industry",
"should",
"be",
"responsible",
"for",
"providing",
"EPA",
"with",
"this",
"data",
"and",
"information.",
"Chemicals",
"lacking",
"adequate",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"should",
"be",
"considered",
"a",
"higher",
"priority",
"(until",
"relevant",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"that",
"suggests",
"otherwise).",
"Industry",
"should",
"be",
"provided",
"an",
"opportunity",
"to",
"provide",
"EPA",
"additional",
"data/information.",
"Timing",
"is",
"an",
"issue,",
"however.",
"And",
"the",
"format",
"in",
"which",
"the",
"information",
"is",
"provided",
"to",
"EPA",
"must",
"be",
"useable/digestible",
"by",
"EPA,",
"e.g.",
"robust",
"summaries.)",
"Hazard,",
"use",
"and",
"exposure",
"based",
"criteria",
"should",
"be",
"integrated",
"to",
"form",
"the",
"basis",
"for",
"EPA's",
"prioritization",
"decisions.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"not",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"either",
"hazard-only",
"or",
"exposure-",
"only",
"information.",
"The",
"prioritization",
"process",
"and",
"science",
"based",
"criteria",
"that",
"EPA",
"uses",
"to",
"prioritize",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"transparent.",
"Prioritization",
"should",
"be",
"a",
"dynamic,",
"iterative",
"process.",
"Re-examination",
"of",
"priorities",
"should",
"occur",
"as",
"new",
"information",
"becomes",
"available",
"and",
"as",
"new",
"chemicals",
"are",
"approved",
"for",
"manufacturing.",
"For",
"prioritization",
"to",
"be",
"successful,",
"it",
"must",
"include",
"three",
"critical",
"elements:",
"reliable",
"and",
"up-",
"to-",
"date",
"chemical",
"data",
"and",
"information;",
"evaluation",
"criteria",
"that",
"consider",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information",
"together;",
"and",
"established",
"cutoffs",
"to",
"make",
"priority",
"decisions.",
"EPA's",
"communication",
"about",
"priority",
"chemicals",
"must",
"be",
"clear",
"about",
"what",
"the",
"list",
"is",
"and",
"what",
"it",
"is",
"not,",
"to",
"avoid",
"unintended",
"consequences",
"of",
"product",
"de-selection",
"purely",
"on",
"the",
"basis",
"of",
"listing.",
"Transparency;",
"consistent,",
"scientific",
"criteria;",
"intersection",
"of",
"both",
"hazard",
"and",
"exposure",
"information;",
"dynamic",
"process",
"so",
"new",
"information",
"can",
"be",
"incorporated",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"made",
"available",
"and",
"so",
"if",
"priorities",
"are",
"initially",
"\"wrong\"",
"they",
"can",
"be",
"corrected.",
"25",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/jzbn0226"
] |
[
[
825,
65,
917,
78
],
[
920,
65,
931,
78
],
[
348,
164,
406,
179
],
[
410,
164,
477,
180
],
[
481,
164,
567,
180
],
[
570,
164,
593,
180
],
[
596,
164,
712,
180
],
[
400,
214,
492,
230
],
[
497,
214,
520,
230
],
[
524,
214,
561,
230
],
[
566,
214,
640,
230
],
[
644,
213,
707,
231
],
[
176,
250,
211,
264
],
[
215,
250,
264,
264
],
[
268,
250,
376,
265
],
[
380,
250,
452,
265
],
[
455,
250,
530,
265
],
[
533,
250,
555,
265
],
[
558,
250,
624,
265
],
[
627,
250,
642,
265
],
[
646,
250,
677,
265
],
[
680,
250,
706,
265
],
[
709,
250,
822,
265
],
[
147,
279,
159,
292
],
[
177,
280,
198,
295
],
[
201,
280,
211,
295
],
[
214,
280,
267,
295
],
[
270,
280,
321,
295
],
[
324,
280,
421,
294
],
[
424,
280,
472,
294
],
[
475,
280,
494,
294
],
[
497,
280,
540,
294
],
[
543,
280,
563,
294
],
[
566,
280,
626,
295
],
[
629,
280,
685,
295
],
[
688,
280,
718,
295
],
[
721,
280,
795,
295
],
[
798,
280,
832,
295
],
[
177,
295,
206,
310
],
[
209,
295,
303,
310
],
[
306,
295,
384,
310
],
[
387,
295,
448,
310
],
[
451,
295,
489,
310
],
[
491,
295,
547,
310
],
[
549,
295,
604,
310
],
[
607,
295,
642,
310
],
[
645,
295,
672,
310
],
[
675,
295,
742,
310
],
[
745,
295,
796,
310
],
[
799,
295,
824,
310
],
[
176,
311,
265,
326
],
[
268,
311,
290,
326
],
[
293,
311,
364,
326
],
[
368,
311,
401,
326
],
[
407,
311,
439,
326
],
[
442,
311,
472,
326
],
[
475,
311,
504,
326
],
[
507,
311,
533,
326
],
[
536,
311,
627,
326
],
[
177,
346,
252,
360
],
[
255,
347,
315,
361
],
[
318,
347,
387,
361
],
[
390,
347,
447,
361
],
[
450,
348,
480,
361
],
[
483,
348,
554,
361
],
[
557,
347,
644,
361
],
[
647,
347,
696,
360
],
[
699,
347,
717,
360
],
[
720,
346,
801,
360
],
[
803,
346,
816,
360
],
[
177,
363,
227,
376
],
[
230,
363,
291,
377
],
[
294,
363,
334,
377
],
[
338,
363,
397,
377
],
[
400,
364,
487,
377
],
[
490,
364,
502,
377
],
[
506,
364,
572,
377
],
[
575,
364,
604,
377
],
[
607,
364,
667,
377
],
[
671,
364,
753,
377
],
[
175,
397,
238,
411
],
[
241,
397,
289,
412
],
[
292,
397,
310,
412
],
[
314,
397,
380,
412
],
[
384,
397,
401,
412
],
[
404,
397,
498,
412
],
[
502,
397,
517,
412
],
[
520,
397,
582,
412
],
[
585,
397,
621,
412
],
[
625,
397,
707,
412
],
[
711,
395,
847,
411
],
[
184,
414,
236,
428
],
[
239,
414,
253,
428
],
[
256,
414,
274,
428
],
[
277,
414,
318,
428
],
[
321,
414,
391,
428
],
[
394,
414,
425,
428
],
[
429,
414,
452,
428
],
[
455,
414,
504,
428
],
[
508,
414,
523,
428
],
[
527,
414,
571,
428
],
[
574,
414,
597,
428
],
[
601,
414,
687,
428
],
[
690,
414,
704,
427
],
[
707,
414,
772,
427
],
[
775,
413,
792,
427
],
[
795,
413,
828,
427
],
[
175,
430,
212,
443
],
[
215,
430,
234,
443
],
[
237,
429,
367,
443
],
[
370,
429,
391,
443
],
[
394,
429,
433,
443
],
[
436,
430,
462,
444
],
[
465,
430,
513,
444
],
[
516,
430,
605,
444
],
[
176,
464,
241,
477
],
[
244,
464,
270,
477
],
[
272,
464,
304,
478
],
[
306,
464,
376,
478
],
[
379,
464,
425,
478
],
[
428,
465,
487,
478
],
[
490,
465,
542,
478
],
[
545,
465,
564,
478
],
[
568,
464,
648,
478
],
[
651,
464,
667,
478
],
[
670,
464,
702,
478
],
[
708,
464,
732,
477
],
[
735,
464,
773,
477
],
[
776,
464,
800,
477
],
[
178,
480,
224,
493
],
[
227,
480,
324,
493
],
[
330,
480,
399,
494
],
[
402,
481,
498,
494
],
[
502,
481,
551,
494
],
[
554,
481,
578,
494
],
[
581,
481,
600,
494
],
[
602,
481,
646,
494
],
[
648,
481,
668,
493
],
[
670,
481,
714,
493
],
[
716,
480,
805,
493
],
[
806,
480,
827,
492
],
[
177,
497,
249,
509
],
[
251,
497,
285,
509
],
[
288,
497,
381,
510
],
[
178,
525,
205,
539
],
[
208,
525,
303,
539
],
[
307,
525,
363,
540
],
[
366,
525,
392,
540
],
[
396,
525,
450,
540
],
[
453,
525,
495,
540
],
[
499,
525,
552,
540
],
[
555,
525,
584,
540
],
[
587,
525,
619,
540
],
[
625,
525,
656,
540
],
[
659,
525,
675,
540
],
[
678,
524,
746,
540
],
[
750,
524,
823,
539
],
[
177,
542,
212,
554
],
[
215,
542,
234,
554
],
[
237,
542,
333,
555
],
[
175,
570,
272,
585
],
[
275,
570,
324,
585
],
[
328,
571,
347,
585
],
[
350,
571,
361,
586
],
[
365,
571,
432,
586
],
[
436,
571,
502,
586
],
[
505,
571,
567,
586
],
[
571,
570,
688,
586
],
[
692,
570,
707,
585
],
[
711,
570,
776,
585
],
[
780,
570,
829,
585
],
[
177,
588,
218,
601
],
[
221,
588,
237,
601
],
[
240,
588,
268,
601
],
[
273,
588,
360,
601
],
[
363,
588,
428,
601
],
[
431,
588,
497,
601
],
[
500,
588,
527,
601
],
[
530,
588,
545,
601
],
[
548,
588,
577,
601
],
[
584,
588,
657,
601
],
[
660,
587,
683,
601
],
[
686,
587,
754,
601
],
[
757,
587,
780,
601
],
[
175,
604,
284,
619
],
[
176,
633,
202,
646
],
[
205,
633,
301,
646
],
[
304,
634,
320,
646
],
[
322,
634,
341,
646
],
[
344,
634,
423,
646
],
[
426,
634,
438,
647
],
[
441,
634,
477,
647
],
[
480,
634,
535,
647
],
[
538,
634,
575,
647
],
[
578,
634,
630,
647
],
[
632,
634,
704,
647
],
[
706,
633,
767,
647
],
[
770,
633,
800,
646
],
[
802,
633,
829,
646
],
[
177,
649,
202,
662
],
[
205,
649,
236,
662
],
[
239,
649,
312,
663
],
[
315,
650,
348,
663
],
[
350,
650,
380,
663
],
[
382,
650,
484,
664
],
[
486,
650,
567,
664
],
[
571,
650,
628,
664
],
[
631,
650,
665,
663
],
[
668,
650,
734,
663
],
[
737,
650,
773,
663
],
[
776,
649,
830,
663
],
[
178,
666,
207,
679
],
[
210,
666,
280,
679
],
[
283,
666,
376,
680
],
[
379,
666,
451,
680
],
[
454,
666,
484,
680
],
[
487,
666,
574,
680
],
[
577,
666,
631,
680
],
[
634,
666,
650,
680
],
[
653,
666,
697,
680
],
[
700,
666,
762,
680
],
[
765,
665,
840,
680
],
[
177,
693,
232,
708
],
[
235,
694,
365,
709
],
[
370,
694,
418,
709
],
[
421,
694,
489,
709
],
[
492,
694,
575,
709
],
[
578,
694,
621,
709
],
[
624,
694,
646,
709
],
[
650,
694,
693,
709
],
[
697,
694,
747,
709
],
[
750,
694,
792,
709
],
[
795,
694,
822,
709
],
[
825,
694,
855,
708
],
[
177,
711,
191,
726
],
[
194,
711,
228,
726
],
[
231,
711,
273,
726
],
[
277,
711,
290,
726
],
[
293,
711,
308,
726
],
[
312,
711,
347,
726
],
[
350,
711,
367,
727
],
[
370,
711,
417,
727
],
[
421,
711,
518,
727
],
[
522,
711,
634,
727
],
[
638,
711,
654,
727
],
[
658,
710,
730,
727
],
[
734,
710,
830,
727
],
[
175,
730,
228,
745
],
[
231,
730,
252,
744
],
[
255,
730,
281,
744
],
[
285,
730,
323,
744
],
[
326,
730,
344,
744
],
[
347,
730,
402,
745
],
[
177,
759,
291,
775
],
[
294,
759,
376,
774
],
[
380,
759,
448,
773
],
[
452,
759,
515,
773
],
[
518,
759,
611,
773
],
[
615,
758,
629,
773
],
[
632,
758,
668,
773
],
[
672,
758,
728,
774
],
[
732,
758,
761,
774
],
[
765,
758,
839,
774
],
[
177,
774,
277,
790
],
[
281,
775,
345,
790
],
[
349,
775,
407,
790
],
[
411,
775,
427,
790
],
[
431,
775,
461,
790
],
[
465,
775,
551,
790
],
[
555,
775,
580,
790
],
[
584,
775,
602,
790
],
[
607,
775,
698,
790
],
[
702,
775,
717,
790
],
[
720,
775,
732,
790
],
[
736,
775,
748,
790
],
[
752,
775,
788,
790
],
[
177,
791,
242,
805
],
[
246,
791,
274,
805
],
[
277,
790,
294,
805
],
[
297,
790,
309,
806
],
[
312,
790,
378,
806
],
[
381,
790,
405,
806
],
[
408,
790,
465,
806
],
[
468,
790,
532,
806
],
[
535,
790,
567,
806
],
[
570,
791,
596,
806
],
[
600,
791,
617,
806
],
[
620,
791,
697,
806
],
[
510,
911,
531,
927
],
[
222,
980,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
780,
997
]
] |
what is the title of this document?
|
ACC's General Principles on Prioritization
|
767
|
[
"Dr.",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Page",
"2",
"ACC",
"has",
"strongly",
"supported",
"OMB's",
"efforts",
"-",
"through",
"its",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Act",
"(IQA)",
"Guidelines,",
"the",
"Peer",
"Review",
"Bulletin,",
"Circular",
"A-4,",
"and",
"otherwise",
"-",
"to",
"assure",
"that",
"the",
"highest",
"quality",
"scientific",
"work",
"products",
"are",
"consistently",
"and",
"assiduously",
"applied",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"regulatory",
"policy.",
"The",
"proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"continues",
"those",
"efforts,",
"and",
"ACC",
"applauds",
"OMB",
"for",
"issuing",
"it.",
"We",
"believe",
"the",
"Bulletin,",
"once",
"finalized,",
"will",
"improve",
"the",
"uneven",
"performance",
"of",
"risk",
"assessments",
"at",
"EPA",
"and",
"other",
"federal",
"agencies",
"by",
"setting",
"a",
"unified,",
"upgraded",
"standard.",
"The",
"attached",
"comments",
"highlight",
"the",
"strengths",
"that",
"we",
"have",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"document,",
"and",
"recommend",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"improvements",
"that",
"we",
"believe",
"are",
"vital",
"to",
"its",
"success.",
"We",
"understand",
"that",
"many",
"important",
"issues",
"associated",
"with",
"the",
"Bulletin",
"will",
"only",
"become",
"clear",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"implemented,",
"and",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"a",
"continuing",
"dialogue",
"with",
"OMB",
"before",
"and",
"after",
"its",
"final",
"publication.",
"Should",
"you",
"or",
"other",
"OMB",
"staff",
"have",
"any",
"questions",
"on,",
"or",
"need",
"clarification",
"of,",
"ACC",
"comments,",
"please",
"don't",
"hesitate",
"to",
"contact",
"either",
"of",
"us",
"at",
"703-741-5000.",
"Sincerely,",
"James",
"W.",
"Conrad,",
"Jr.",
"Richard",
"A.",
"Becker,",
"Ph.D.",
"DABT",
"Assistant",
"General",
"Counsel",
"Senior",
"Toxicologist/Senior",
"Director",
"Attachment:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(released",
"for",
"public",
"review",
"and",
"comment",
"in",
"January,",
"2006)",
"OMB,",
"Guidelines",
"for",
"Ensuring",
"and",
"Maximizing",
"the",
"Quality,",
"Objectivity,",
"Utility,",
"and",
"Integrity",
"of",
"Information",
"Disseminated",
"by",
"Federal",
"Agencies,",
"67",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"8452",
"(Feb.",
"22,",
"2002).",
"OMB,",
"Final",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Bulletin",
"for",
"Peer",
"Review,",
"70",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2664",
"(Jan.",
"14,",
"2005).",
"OMB,",
"Circular",
"A-4",
"(Sept.",
"2003).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
82,
46,
105,
59
],
[
108,
47,
140,
60
],
[
82,
62,
114,
74
],
[
117,
62,
139,
74
],
[
141,
61,
176,
74
],
[
81,
76,
115,
88
],
[
118,
77,
129,
88
],
[
83,
163,
124,
179
],
[
127,
163,
155,
179
],
[
159,
164,
225,
180
],
[
228,
164,
307,
180
],
[
311,
164,
370,
180
],
[
373,
164,
427,
180
],
[
430,
164,
440,
180
],
[
444,
163,
507,
180
],
[
510,
163,
530,
180
],
[
534,
163,
629,
180
],
[
632,
163,
694,
180
],
[
698,
163,
726,
180
],
[
730,
163,
779,
180
],
[
783,
162,
881,
180
],
[
887,
162,
912,
179
],
[
84,
180,
118,
196
],
[
122,
180,
181,
196
],
[
186,
181,
264,
197
],
[
271,
181,
335,
197
],
[
339,
181,
382,
197
],
[
386,
181,
415,
197
],
[
418,
181,
497,
197
],
[
500,
181,
511,
197
],
[
515,
181,
532,
197
],
[
535,
181,
585,
197
],
[
589,
182,
621,
197
],
[
624,
182,
649,
197
],
[
652,
182,
711,
196
],
[
714,
182,
771,
196
],
[
774,
182,
848,
196
],
[
851,
182,
895,
196
],
[
83,
199,
151,
214
],
[
154,
199,
181,
214
],
[
184,
199,
279,
214
],
[
282,
199,
312,
215
],
[
315,
199,
410,
215
],
[
412,
198,
471,
215
],
[
474,
198,
492,
215
],
[
495,
198,
557,
215
],
[
560,
198,
577,
215
],
[
580,
198,
662,
215
],
[
665,
198,
728,
214
],
[
731,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
839,
214
],
[
842,
198,
878,
213
],
[
84,
215,
175,
231
],
[
179,
215,
244,
231
],
[
247,
215,
324,
232
],
[
327,
215,
370,
232
],
[
374,
215,
431,
232
],
[
435,
215,
465,
232
],
[
468,
215,
509,
232
],
[
514,
215,
585,
232
],
[
588,
215,
633,
232
],
[
638,
215,
661,
231
],
[
665,
215,
723,
231
],
[
726,
215,
750,
231
],
[
757,
215,
785,
231
],
[
788,
215,
847,
231
],
[
850,
215,
877,
230
],
[
84,
233,
152,
248
],
[
155,
233,
194,
248
],
[
197,
233,
272,
249
],
[
276,
234,
306,
249
],
[
310,
234,
377,
249
],
[
381,
234,
406,
249
],
[
410,
234,
468,
249
],
[
471,
234,
572,
249
],
[
576,
234,
593,
249
],
[
597,
234,
627,
249
],
[
631,
233,
728,
249
],
[
732,
233,
747,
249
],
[
750,
233,
787,
248
],
[
792,
233,
822,
248
],
[
826,
232,
867,
248
],
[
871,
232,
928,
248
],
[
83,
251,
151,
266
],
[
154,
251,
176,
266
],
[
180,
250,
233,
266
],
[
237,
250,
246,
266
],
[
250,
250,
312,
266
],
[
315,
250,
390,
266
],
[
393,
250,
463,
265
],
[
85,
286,
115,
300
],
[
118,
286,
185,
300
],
[
188,
286,
270,
301
],
[
273,
286,
345,
301
],
[
348,
286,
375,
301
],
[
378,
286,
450,
301
],
[
452,
286,
486,
301
],
[
489,
286,
512,
301
],
[
515,
286,
555,
301
],
[
558,
286,
635,
301
],
[
637,
286,
655,
301
],
[
658,
286,
686,
301
],
[
690,
286,
771,
301
],
[
774,
286,
804,
301
],
[
807,
286,
903,
300
],
[
906,
286,
917,
300
],
[
84,
303,
143,
318
],
[
146,
303,
165,
318
],
[
168,
303,
282,
318
],
[
285,
303,
317,
318
],
[
320,
303,
344,
318
],
[
347,
303,
407,
318
],
[
410,
303,
435,
318
],
[
439,
303,
475,
317
],
[
478,
303,
495,
317
],
[
498,
303,
519,
317
],
[
522,
303,
593,
317
],
[
596,
303,
623,
317
],
[
627,
303,
714,
318
],
[
717,
303,
749,
318
],
[
752,
303,
797,
318
],
[
801,
304,
878,
318
],
[
881,
304,
930,
318
],
[
84,
320,
164,
335
],
[
168,
320,
204,
335
],
[
207,
320,
233,
335
],
[
237,
320,
302,
335
],
[
305,
320,
336,
335
],
[
340,
320,
375,
336
],
[
379,
320,
442,
336
],
[
445,
320,
485,
336
],
[
488,
320,
507,
336
],
[
510,
320,
522,
336
],
[
525,
320,
540,
336
],
[
543,
320,
653,
336
],
[
657,
320,
686,
336
],
[
690,
320,
713,
336
],
[
716,
320,
754,
336
],
[
757,
320,
820,
336
],
[
823,
320,
842,
335
],
[
845,
320,
854,
335
],
[
84,
339,
168,
352
],
[
174,
339,
241,
353
],
[
244,
339,
280,
353
],
[
284,
339,
326,
353
],
[
332,
338,
385,
353
],
[
388,
338,
418,
353
],
[
421,
338,
458,
353
],
[
461,
338,
482,
353
],
[
485,
338,
523,
353
],
[
527,
338,
626,
353
],
[
631,
338,
687,
353
],
[
690,
338,
721,
353
],
[
724,
338,
742,
353
],
[
745,
338,
787,
353
],
[
791,
337,
834,
353
],
[
840,
337,
875,
353
],
[
879,
337,
919,
353
],
[
82,
356,
112,
370
],
[
115,
355,
191,
370
],
[
195,
355,
221,
370
],
[
224,
355,
241,
370
],
[
244,
355,
285,
370
],
[
288,
355,
382,
370
],
[
387,
355,
411,
370
],
[
413,
355,
452,
370
],
[
458,
355,
545,
370
],
[
548,
355,
600,
370
],
[
606,
355,
645,
370
],
[
647,
355,
710,
370
],
[
712,
355,
732,
370
],
[
734,
355,
794,
370
],
[
795,
355,
843,
370
],
[
845,
355,
863,
370
],
[
865,
355,
887,
370
],
[
888,
355,
906,
370
],
[
83,
371,
200,
386
],
[
467,
423,
547,
441
],
[
200,
494,
251,
509
],
[
254,
494,
278,
509
],
[
281,
494,
345,
509
],
[
348,
495,
367,
509
],
[
611,
493,
676,
509
],
[
680,
494,
699,
509
],
[
702,
494,
765,
509
],
[
768,
494,
814,
509
],
[
818,
494,
872,
509
],
[
202,
512,
274,
526
],
[
278,
512,
341,
526
],
[
344,
511,
411,
525
],
[
612,
512,
666,
526
],
[
670,
512,
825,
527
],
[
829,
512,
898,
527
],
[
84,
763,
185,
780
],
[
189,
763,
275,
780
],
[
278,
763,
296,
780
],
[
300,
763,
326,
780
],
[
330,
763,
408,
780
],
[
411,
763,
495,
780
],
[
498,
763,
562,
780
],
[
565,
763,
585,
780
],
[
590,
763,
615,
780
],
[
618,
763,
692,
780
],
[
696,
763,
736,
780
],
[
740,
763,
832,
780
],
[
835,
763,
902,
779
],
[
84,
780,
154,
796
],
[
158,
781,
181,
796
],
[
185,
781,
235,
796
],
[
239,
781,
292,
796
],
[
298,
781,
328,
796
],
[
331,
781,
404,
796
],
[
408,
781,
426,
796
],
[
430,
781,
497,
797
],
[
501,
781,
550,
797
],
[
91,
851,
134,
865
],
[
137,
852,
207,
866
],
[
211,
852,
232,
866
],
[
235,
852,
295,
866
],
[
298,
853,
324,
866
],
[
327,
853,
405,
867
],
[
409,
853,
430,
867
],
[
434,
853,
487,
867
],
[
491,
853,
567,
867
],
[
571,
853,
617,
867
],
[
620,
853,
645,
867
],
[
649,
853,
705,
867
],
[
709,
853,
723,
867
],
[
727,
853,
805,
867
],
[
808,
852,
898,
867
],
[
901,
852,
917,
866
],
[
85,
868,
135,
880
],
[
138,
868,
202,
881
],
[
205,
868,
222,
881
],
[
225,
868,
255,
881
],
[
258,
868,
290,
881
],
[
292,
868,
327,
881
],
[
329,
868,
365,
881
],
[
367,
868,
390,
881
],
[
392,
868,
436,
881
],
[
91,
882,
134,
896
],
[
138,
882,
172,
896
],
[
176,
882,
255,
896
],
[
259,
882,
309,
896
],
[
312,
882,
364,
896
],
[
367,
882,
388,
896
],
[
391,
882,
423,
896
],
[
426,
882,
478,
896
],
[
482,
882,
498,
896
],
[
502,
881,
531,
896
],
[
534,
881,
566,
896
],
[
569,
881,
602,
896
],
[
605,
881,
639,
896
],
[
642,
881,
662,
896
],
[
665,
880,
709,
896
],
[
92,
895,
135,
909
],
[
138,
895,
195,
909
],
[
198,
896,
222,
910
],
[
225,
896,
265,
910
],
[
268,
896,
314,
910
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
mention the date which is on right side top of the letter
|
JUNE 15, 2006
|
767
|
[
"Dr.",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Page",
"2",
"ACC",
"has",
"strongly",
"supported",
"OMB's",
"efforts",
"-",
"through",
"its",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Act",
"(IQA)",
"Guidelines,",
"the",
"Peer",
"Review",
"Bulletin,",
"Circular",
"A-4,",
"and",
"otherwise",
"-",
"to",
"assure",
"that",
"the",
"highest",
"quality",
"scientific",
"work",
"products",
"are",
"consistently",
"and",
"assiduously",
"applied",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"regulatory",
"policy.",
"The",
"proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"continues",
"those",
"efforts,",
"and",
"ACC",
"applauds",
"OMB",
"for",
"issuing",
"it.",
"We",
"believe",
"the",
"Bulletin,",
"once",
"finalized,",
"will",
"improve",
"the",
"uneven",
"performance",
"of",
"risk",
"assessments",
"at",
"EPA",
"and",
"other",
"federal",
"agencies",
"by",
"setting",
"a",
"unified,",
"upgraded",
"standard.",
"The",
"attached",
"comments",
"highlight",
"the",
"strengths",
"that",
"we",
"have",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"document,",
"and",
"recommend",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"improvements",
"that",
"we",
"believe",
"are",
"vital",
"to",
"its",
"success.",
"We",
"understand",
"that",
"many",
"important",
"issues",
"associated",
"with",
"the",
"Bulletin",
"will",
"only",
"become",
"clear",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"implemented,",
"and",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"a",
"continuing",
"dialogue",
"with",
"OMB",
"before",
"and",
"after",
"its",
"final",
"publication.",
"Should",
"you",
"or",
"other",
"OMB",
"staff",
"have",
"any",
"questions",
"on,",
"or",
"need",
"clarification",
"of,",
"ACC",
"comments,",
"please",
"don't",
"hesitate",
"to",
"contact",
"either",
"of",
"us",
"at",
"703-741-5000.",
"Sincerely,",
"James",
"W.",
"Conrad,",
"Jr.",
"Richard",
"A.",
"Becker,",
"Ph.D.",
"DABT",
"Assistant",
"General",
"Counsel",
"Senior",
"Toxicologist/Senior",
"Director",
"Attachment:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(released",
"for",
"public",
"review",
"and",
"comment",
"in",
"January,",
"2006)",
"OMB,",
"Guidelines",
"for",
"Ensuring",
"and",
"Maximizing",
"the",
"Quality,",
"Objectivity,",
"Utility,",
"and",
"Integrity",
"of",
"Information",
"Disseminated",
"by",
"Federal",
"Agencies,",
"67",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"8452",
"(Feb.",
"22,",
"2002).",
"OMB,",
"Final",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Bulletin",
"for",
"Peer",
"Review,",
"70",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2664",
"(Jan.",
"14,",
"2005).",
"OMB,",
"Circular",
"A-4",
"(Sept.",
"2003).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
82,
46,
105,
59
],
[
108,
47,
140,
60
],
[
82,
62,
114,
74
],
[
117,
62,
139,
74
],
[
141,
61,
176,
74
],
[
81,
76,
115,
88
],
[
118,
77,
129,
88
],
[
83,
163,
124,
179
],
[
127,
163,
155,
179
],
[
159,
164,
225,
180
],
[
228,
164,
307,
180
],
[
311,
164,
370,
180
],
[
373,
164,
427,
180
],
[
430,
164,
440,
180
],
[
444,
163,
507,
180
],
[
510,
163,
530,
180
],
[
534,
163,
629,
180
],
[
632,
163,
694,
180
],
[
698,
163,
726,
180
],
[
730,
163,
779,
180
],
[
783,
162,
881,
180
],
[
887,
162,
912,
179
],
[
84,
180,
118,
196
],
[
122,
180,
181,
196
],
[
186,
181,
264,
197
],
[
271,
181,
335,
197
],
[
339,
181,
382,
197
],
[
386,
181,
415,
197
],
[
418,
181,
497,
197
],
[
500,
181,
511,
197
],
[
515,
181,
532,
197
],
[
535,
181,
585,
197
],
[
589,
182,
621,
197
],
[
624,
182,
649,
197
],
[
652,
182,
711,
196
],
[
714,
182,
771,
196
],
[
774,
182,
848,
196
],
[
851,
182,
895,
196
],
[
83,
199,
151,
214
],
[
154,
199,
181,
214
],
[
184,
199,
279,
214
],
[
282,
199,
312,
215
],
[
315,
199,
410,
215
],
[
412,
198,
471,
215
],
[
474,
198,
492,
215
],
[
495,
198,
557,
215
],
[
560,
198,
577,
215
],
[
580,
198,
662,
215
],
[
665,
198,
728,
214
],
[
731,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
839,
214
],
[
842,
198,
878,
213
],
[
84,
215,
175,
231
],
[
179,
215,
244,
231
],
[
247,
215,
324,
232
],
[
327,
215,
370,
232
],
[
374,
215,
431,
232
],
[
435,
215,
465,
232
],
[
468,
215,
509,
232
],
[
514,
215,
585,
232
],
[
588,
215,
633,
232
],
[
638,
215,
661,
231
],
[
665,
215,
723,
231
],
[
726,
215,
750,
231
],
[
757,
215,
785,
231
],
[
788,
215,
847,
231
],
[
850,
215,
877,
230
],
[
84,
233,
152,
248
],
[
155,
233,
194,
248
],
[
197,
233,
272,
249
],
[
276,
234,
306,
249
],
[
310,
234,
377,
249
],
[
381,
234,
406,
249
],
[
410,
234,
468,
249
],
[
471,
234,
572,
249
],
[
576,
234,
593,
249
],
[
597,
234,
627,
249
],
[
631,
233,
728,
249
],
[
732,
233,
747,
249
],
[
750,
233,
787,
248
],
[
792,
233,
822,
248
],
[
826,
232,
867,
248
],
[
871,
232,
928,
248
],
[
83,
251,
151,
266
],
[
154,
251,
176,
266
],
[
180,
250,
233,
266
],
[
237,
250,
246,
266
],
[
250,
250,
312,
266
],
[
315,
250,
390,
266
],
[
393,
250,
463,
265
],
[
85,
286,
115,
300
],
[
118,
286,
185,
300
],
[
188,
286,
270,
301
],
[
273,
286,
345,
301
],
[
348,
286,
375,
301
],
[
378,
286,
450,
301
],
[
452,
286,
486,
301
],
[
489,
286,
512,
301
],
[
515,
286,
555,
301
],
[
558,
286,
635,
301
],
[
637,
286,
655,
301
],
[
658,
286,
686,
301
],
[
690,
286,
771,
301
],
[
774,
286,
804,
301
],
[
807,
286,
903,
300
],
[
906,
286,
917,
300
],
[
84,
303,
143,
318
],
[
146,
303,
165,
318
],
[
168,
303,
282,
318
],
[
285,
303,
317,
318
],
[
320,
303,
344,
318
],
[
347,
303,
407,
318
],
[
410,
303,
435,
318
],
[
439,
303,
475,
317
],
[
478,
303,
495,
317
],
[
498,
303,
519,
317
],
[
522,
303,
593,
317
],
[
596,
303,
623,
317
],
[
627,
303,
714,
318
],
[
717,
303,
749,
318
],
[
752,
303,
797,
318
],
[
801,
304,
878,
318
],
[
881,
304,
930,
318
],
[
84,
320,
164,
335
],
[
168,
320,
204,
335
],
[
207,
320,
233,
335
],
[
237,
320,
302,
335
],
[
305,
320,
336,
335
],
[
340,
320,
375,
336
],
[
379,
320,
442,
336
],
[
445,
320,
485,
336
],
[
488,
320,
507,
336
],
[
510,
320,
522,
336
],
[
525,
320,
540,
336
],
[
543,
320,
653,
336
],
[
657,
320,
686,
336
],
[
690,
320,
713,
336
],
[
716,
320,
754,
336
],
[
757,
320,
820,
336
],
[
823,
320,
842,
335
],
[
845,
320,
854,
335
],
[
84,
339,
168,
352
],
[
174,
339,
241,
353
],
[
244,
339,
280,
353
],
[
284,
339,
326,
353
],
[
332,
338,
385,
353
],
[
388,
338,
418,
353
],
[
421,
338,
458,
353
],
[
461,
338,
482,
353
],
[
485,
338,
523,
353
],
[
527,
338,
626,
353
],
[
631,
338,
687,
353
],
[
690,
338,
721,
353
],
[
724,
338,
742,
353
],
[
745,
338,
787,
353
],
[
791,
337,
834,
353
],
[
840,
337,
875,
353
],
[
879,
337,
919,
353
],
[
82,
356,
112,
370
],
[
115,
355,
191,
370
],
[
195,
355,
221,
370
],
[
224,
355,
241,
370
],
[
244,
355,
285,
370
],
[
288,
355,
382,
370
],
[
387,
355,
411,
370
],
[
413,
355,
452,
370
],
[
458,
355,
545,
370
],
[
548,
355,
600,
370
],
[
606,
355,
645,
370
],
[
647,
355,
710,
370
],
[
712,
355,
732,
370
],
[
734,
355,
794,
370
],
[
795,
355,
843,
370
],
[
845,
355,
863,
370
],
[
865,
355,
887,
370
],
[
888,
355,
906,
370
],
[
83,
371,
200,
386
],
[
467,
423,
547,
441
],
[
200,
494,
251,
509
],
[
254,
494,
278,
509
],
[
281,
494,
345,
509
],
[
348,
495,
367,
509
],
[
611,
493,
676,
509
],
[
680,
494,
699,
509
],
[
702,
494,
765,
509
],
[
768,
494,
814,
509
],
[
818,
494,
872,
509
],
[
202,
512,
274,
526
],
[
278,
512,
341,
526
],
[
344,
511,
411,
525
],
[
612,
512,
666,
526
],
[
670,
512,
825,
527
],
[
829,
512,
898,
527
],
[
84,
763,
185,
780
],
[
189,
763,
275,
780
],
[
278,
763,
296,
780
],
[
300,
763,
326,
780
],
[
330,
763,
408,
780
],
[
411,
763,
495,
780
],
[
498,
763,
562,
780
],
[
565,
763,
585,
780
],
[
590,
763,
615,
780
],
[
618,
763,
692,
780
],
[
696,
763,
736,
780
],
[
740,
763,
832,
780
],
[
835,
763,
902,
779
],
[
84,
780,
154,
796
],
[
158,
781,
181,
796
],
[
185,
781,
235,
796
],
[
239,
781,
292,
796
],
[
298,
781,
328,
796
],
[
331,
781,
404,
796
],
[
408,
781,
426,
796
],
[
430,
781,
497,
797
],
[
501,
781,
550,
797
],
[
91,
851,
134,
865
],
[
137,
852,
207,
866
],
[
211,
852,
232,
866
],
[
235,
852,
295,
866
],
[
298,
853,
324,
866
],
[
327,
853,
405,
867
],
[
409,
853,
430,
867
],
[
434,
853,
487,
867
],
[
491,
853,
567,
867
],
[
571,
853,
617,
867
],
[
620,
853,
645,
867
],
[
649,
853,
705,
867
],
[
709,
853,
723,
867
],
[
727,
853,
805,
867
],
[
808,
852,
898,
867
],
[
901,
852,
917,
866
],
[
85,
868,
135,
880
],
[
138,
868,
202,
881
],
[
205,
868,
222,
881
],
[
225,
868,
255,
881
],
[
258,
868,
290,
881
],
[
292,
868,
327,
881
],
[
329,
868,
365,
881
],
[
367,
868,
390,
881
],
[
392,
868,
436,
881
],
[
91,
882,
134,
896
],
[
138,
882,
172,
896
],
[
176,
882,
255,
896
],
[
259,
882,
309,
896
],
[
312,
882,
364,
896
],
[
367,
882,
388,
896
],
[
391,
882,
423,
896
],
[
426,
882,
478,
896
],
[
482,
882,
498,
896
],
[
502,
881,
531,
896
],
[
534,
881,
566,
896
],
[
569,
881,
602,
896
],
[
605,
881,
639,
896
],
[
642,
881,
662,
896
],
[
665,
880,
709,
896
],
[
92,
895,
135,
909
],
[
138,
895,
195,
909
],
[
198,
896,
222,
910
],
[
225,
896,
265,
910
],
[
268,
896,
314,
910
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
what does IQA stands for?
|
INFORMATION QUALITY ACT
|
767
|
[
"Dr.",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Page",
"2",
"ACC",
"has",
"strongly",
"supported",
"OMB's",
"efforts",
"-",
"through",
"its",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Act",
"(IQA)",
"Guidelines,",
"the",
"Peer",
"Review",
"Bulletin,",
"Circular",
"A-4,",
"and",
"otherwise",
"-",
"to",
"assure",
"that",
"the",
"highest",
"quality",
"scientific",
"work",
"products",
"are",
"consistently",
"and",
"assiduously",
"applied",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"regulatory",
"policy.",
"The",
"proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"continues",
"those",
"efforts,",
"and",
"ACC",
"applauds",
"OMB",
"for",
"issuing",
"it.",
"We",
"believe",
"the",
"Bulletin,",
"once",
"finalized,",
"will",
"improve",
"the",
"uneven",
"performance",
"of",
"risk",
"assessments",
"at",
"EPA",
"and",
"other",
"federal",
"agencies",
"by",
"setting",
"a",
"unified,",
"upgraded",
"standard.",
"The",
"attached",
"comments",
"highlight",
"the",
"strengths",
"that",
"we",
"have",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"document,",
"and",
"recommend",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"improvements",
"that",
"we",
"believe",
"are",
"vital",
"to",
"its",
"success.",
"We",
"understand",
"that",
"many",
"important",
"issues",
"associated",
"with",
"the",
"Bulletin",
"will",
"only",
"become",
"clear",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"implemented,",
"and",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"a",
"continuing",
"dialogue",
"with",
"OMB",
"before",
"and",
"after",
"its",
"final",
"publication.",
"Should",
"you",
"or",
"other",
"OMB",
"staff",
"have",
"any",
"questions",
"on,",
"or",
"need",
"clarification",
"of,",
"ACC",
"comments,",
"please",
"don't",
"hesitate",
"to",
"contact",
"either",
"of",
"us",
"at",
"703-741-5000.",
"Sincerely,",
"James",
"W.",
"Conrad,",
"Jr.",
"Richard",
"A.",
"Becker,",
"Ph.D.",
"DABT",
"Assistant",
"General",
"Counsel",
"Senior",
"Toxicologist/Senior",
"Director",
"Attachment:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(released",
"for",
"public",
"review",
"and",
"comment",
"in",
"January,",
"2006)",
"OMB,",
"Guidelines",
"for",
"Ensuring",
"and",
"Maximizing",
"the",
"Quality,",
"Objectivity,",
"Utility,",
"and",
"Integrity",
"of",
"Information",
"Disseminated",
"by",
"Federal",
"Agencies,",
"67",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"8452",
"(Feb.",
"22,",
"2002).",
"OMB,",
"Final",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Bulletin",
"for",
"Peer",
"Review,",
"70",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2664",
"(Jan.",
"14,",
"2005).",
"OMB,",
"Circular",
"A-4",
"(Sept.",
"2003).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
82,
46,
105,
59
],
[
108,
47,
140,
60
],
[
82,
62,
114,
74
],
[
117,
62,
139,
74
],
[
141,
61,
176,
74
],
[
81,
76,
115,
88
],
[
118,
77,
129,
88
],
[
83,
163,
124,
179
],
[
127,
163,
155,
179
],
[
159,
164,
225,
180
],
[
228,
164,
307,
180
],
[
311,
164,
370,
180
],
[
373,
164,
427,
180
],
[
430,
164,
440,
180
],
[
444,
163,
507,
180
],
[
510,
163,
530,
180
],
[
534,
163,
629,
180
],
[
632,
163,
694,
180
],
[
698,
163,
726,
180
],
[
730,
163,
779,
180
],
[
783,
162,
881,
180
],
[
887,
162,
912,
179
],
[
84,
180,
118,
196
],
[
122,
180,
181,
196
],
[
186,
181,
264,
197
],
[
271,
181,
335,
197
],
[
339,
181,
382,
197
],
[
386,
181,
415,
197
],
[
418,
181,
497,
197
],
[
500,
181,
511,
197
],
[
515,
181,
532,
197
],
[
535,
181,
585,
197
],
[
589,
182,
621,
197
],
[
624,
182,
649,
197
],
[
652,
182,
711,
196
],
[
714,
182,
771,
196
],
[
774,
182,
848,
196
],
[
851,
182,
895,
196
],
[
83,
199,
151,
214
],
[
154,
199,
181,
214
],
[
184,
199,
279,
214
],
[
282,
199,
312,
215
],
[
315,
199,
410,
215
],
[
412,
198,
471,
215
],
[
474,
198,
492,
215
],
[
495,
198,
557,
215
],
[
560,
198,
577,
215
],
[
580,
198,
662,
215
],
[
665,
198,
728,
214
],
[
731,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
839,
214
],
[
842,
198,
878,
213
],
[
84,
215,
175,
231
],
[
179,
215,
244,
231
],
[
247,
215,
324,
232
],
[
327,
215,
370,
232
],
[
374,
215,
431,
232
],
[
435,
215,
465,
232
],
[
468,
215,
509,
232
],
[
514,
215,
585,
232
],
[
588,
215,
633,
232
],
[
638,
215,
661,
231
],
[
665,
215,
723,
231
],
[
726,
215,
750,
231
],
[
757,
215,
785,
231
],
[
788,
215,
847,
231
],
[
850,
215,
877,
230
],
[
84,
233,
152,
248
],
[
155,
233,
194,
248
],
[
197,
233,
272,
249
],
[
276,
234,
306,
249
],
[
310,
234,
377,
249
],
[
381,
234,
406,
249
],
[
410,
234,
468,
249
],
[
471,
234,
572,
249
],
[
576,
234,
593,
249
],
[
597,
234,
627,
249
],
[
631,
233,
728,
249
],
[
732,
233,
747,
249
],
[
750,
233,
787,
248
],
[
792,
233,
822,
248
],
[
826,
232,
867,
248
],
[
871,
232,
928,
248
],
[
83,
251,
151,
266
],
[
154,
251,
176,
266
],
[
180,
250,
233,
266
],
[
237,
250,
246,
266
],
[
250,
250,
312,
266
],
[
315,
250,
390,
266
],
[
393,
250,
463,
265
],
[
85,
286,
115,
300
],
[
118,
286,
185,
300
],
[
188,
286,
270,
301
],
[
273,
286,
345,
301
],
[
348,
286,
375,
301
],
[
378,
286,
450,
301
],
[
452,
286,
486,
301
],
[
489,
286,
512,
301
],
[
515,
286,
555,
301
],
[
558,
286,
635,
301
],
[
637,
286,
655,
301
],
[
658,
286,
686,
301
],
[
690,
286,
771,
301
],
[
774,
286,
804,
301
],
[
807,
286,
903,
300
],
[
906,
286,
917,
300
],
[
84,
303,
143,
318
],
[
146,
303,
165,
318
],
[
168,
303,
282,
318
],
[
285,
303,
317,
318
],
[
320,
303,
344,
318
],
[
347,
303,
407,
318
],
[
410,
303,
435,
318
],
[
439,
303,
475,
317
],
[
478,
303,
495,
317
],
[
498,
303,
519,
317
],
[
522,
303,
593,
317
],
[
596,
303,
623,
317
],
[
627,
303,
714,
318
],
[
717,
303,
749,
318
],
[
752,
303,
797,
318
],
[
801,
304,
878,
318
],
[
881,
304,
930,
318
],
[
84,
320,
164,
335
],
[
168,
320,
204,
335
],
[
207,
320,
233,
335
],
[
237,
320,
302,
335
],
[
305,
320,
336,
335
],
[
340,
320,
375,
336
],
[
379,
320,
442,
336
],
[
445,
320,
485,
336
],
[
488,
320,
507,
336
],
[
510,
320,
522,
336
],
[
525,
320,
540,
336
],
[
543,
320,
653,
336
],
[
657,
320,
686,
336
],
[
690,
320,
713,
336
],
[
716,
320,
754,
336
],
[
757,
320,
820,
336
],
[
823,
320,
842,
335
],
[
845,
320,
854,
335
],
[
84,
339,
168,
352
],
[
174,
339,
241,
353
],
[
244,
339,
280,
353
],
[
284,
339,
326,
353
],
[
332,
338,
385,
353
],
[
388,
338,
418,
353
],
[
421,
338,
458,
353
],
[
461,
338,
482,
353
],
[
485,
338,
523,
353
],
[
527,
338,
626,
353
],
[
631,
338,
687,
353
],
[
690,
338,
721,
353
],
[
724,
338,
742,
353
],
[
745,
338,
787,
353
],
[
791,
337,
834,
353
],
[
840,
337,
875,
353
],
[
879,
337,
919,
353
],
[
82,
356,
112,
370
],
[
115,
355,
191,
370
],
[
195,
355,
221,
370
],
[
224,
355,
241,
370
],
[
244,
355,
285,
370
],
[
288,
355,
382,
370
],
[
387,
355,
411,
370
],
[
413,
355,
452,
370
],
[
458,
355,
545,
370
],
[
548,
355,
600,
370
],
[
606,
355,
645,
370
],
[
647,
355,
710,
370
],
[
712,
355,
732,
370
],
[
734,
355,
794,
370
],
[
795,
355,
843,
370
],
[
845,
355,
863,
370
],
[
865,
355,
887,
370
],
[
888,
355,
906,
370
],
[
83,
371,
200,
386
],
[
467,
423,
547,
441
],
[
200,
494,
251,
509
],
[
254,
494,
278,
509
],
[
281,
494,
345,
509
],
[
348,
495,
367,
509
],
[
611,
493,
676,
509
],
[
680,
494,
699,
509
],
[
702,
494,
765,
509
],
[
768,
494,
814,
509
],
[
818,
494,
872,
509
],
[
202,
512,
274,
526
],
[
278,
512,
341,
526
],
[
344,
511,
411,
525
],
[
612,
512,
666,
526
],
[
670,
512,
825,
527
],
[
829,
512,
898,
527
],
[
84,
763,
185,
780
],
[
189,
763,
275,
780
],
[
278,
763,
296,
780
],
[
300,
763,
326,
780
],
[
330,
763,
408,
780
],
[
411,
763,
495,
780
],
[
498,
763,
562,
780
],
[
565,
763,
585,
780
],
[
590,
763,
615,
780
],
[
618,
763,
692,
780
],
[
696,
763,
736,
780
],
[
740,
763,
832,
780
],
[
835,
763,
902,
779
],
[
84,
780,
154,
796
],
[
158,
781,
181,
796
],
[
185,
781,
235,
796
],
[
239,
781,
292,
796
],
[
298,
781,
328,
796
],
[
331,
781,
404,
796
],
[
408,
781,
426,
796
],
[
430,
781,
497,
797
],
[
501,
781,
550,
797
],
[
91,
851,
134,
865
],
[
137,
852,
207,
866
],
[
211,
852,
232,
866
],
[
235,
852,
295,
866
],
[
298,
853,
324,
866
],
[
327,
853,
405,
867
],
[
409,
853,
430,
867
],
[
434,
853,
487,
867
],
[
491,
853,
567,
867
],
[
571,
853,
617,
867
],
[
620,
853,
645,
867
],
[
649,
853,
705,
867
],
[
709,
853,
723,
867
],
[
727,
853,
805,
867
],
[
808,
852,
898,
867
],
[
901,
852,
917,
866
],
[
85,
868,
135,
880
],
[
138,
868,
202,
881
],
[
205,
868,
222,
881
],
[
225,
868,
255,
881
],
[
258,
868,
290,
881
],
[
292,
868,
327,
881
],
[
329,
868,
365,
881
],
[
367,
868,
390,
881
],
[
392,
868,
436,
881
],
[
91,
882,
134,
896
],
[
138,
882,
172,
896
],
[
176,
882,
255,
896
],
[
259,
882,
309,
896
],
[
312,
882,
364,
896
],
[
367,
882,
388,
896
],
[
391,
882,
423,
896
],
[
426,
882,
478,
896
],
[
482,
882,
498,
896
],
[
502,
881,
531,
896
],
[
534,
881,
566,
896
],
[
569,
881,
602,
896
],
[
605,
881,
639,
896
],
[
642,
881,
662,
896
],
[
665,
880,
709,
896
],
[
92,
895,
135,
909
],
[
138,
895,
195,
909
],
[
198,
896,
222,
910
],
[
225,
896,
265,
910
],
[
268,
896,
314,
910
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
who is assistant general counsel?
|
JAMES W. CONRAD,JR.
|
767
|
[
"Dr.",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Page",
"2",
"ACC",
"has",
"strongly",
"supported",
"OMB's",
"efforts",
"-",
"through",
"its",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Act",
"(IQA)",
"Guidelines,",
"the",
"Peer",
"Review",
"Bulletin,",
"Circular",
"A-4,",
"and",
"otherwise",
"-",
"to",
"assure",
"that",
"the",
"highest",
"quality",
"scientific",
"work",
"products",
"are",
"consistently",
"and",
"assiduously",
"applied",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"regulatory",
"policy.",
"The",
"proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"continues",
"those",
"efforts,",
"and",
"ACC",
"applauds",
"OMB",
"for",
"issuing",
"it.",
"We",
"believe",
"the",
"Bulletin,",
"once",
"finalized,",
"will",
"improve",
"the",
"uneven",
"performance",
"of",
"risk",
"assessments",
"at",
"EPA",
"and",
"other",
"federal",
"agencies",
"by",
"setting",
"a",
"unified,",
"upgraded",
"standard.",
"The",
"attached",
"comments",
"highlight",
"the",
"strengths",
"that",
"we",
"have",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"document,",
"and",
"recommend",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"improvements",
"that",
"we",
"believe",
"are",
"vital",
"to",
"its",
"success.",
"We",
"understand",
"that",
"many",
"important",
"issues",
"associated",
"with",
"the",
"Bulletin",
"will",
"only",
"become",
"clear",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"implemented,",
"and",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"a",
"continuing",
"dialogue",
"with",
"OMB",
"before",
"and",
"after",
"its",
"final",
"publication.",
"Should",
"you",
"or",
"other",
"OMB",
"staff",
"have",
"any",
"questions",
"on,",
"or",
"need",
"clarification",
"of,",
"ACC",
"comments,",
"please",
"don't",
"hesitate",
"to",
"contact",
"either",
"of",
"us",
"at",
"703-741-5000.",
"Sincerely,",
"James",
"W.",
"Conrad,",
"Jr.",
"Richard",
"A.",
"Becker,",
"Ph.D.",
"DABT",
"Assistant",
"General",
"Counsel",
"Senior",
"Toxicologist/Senior",
"Director",
"Attachment:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(released",
"for",
"public",
"review",
"and",
"comment",
"in",
"January,",
"2006)",
"OMB,",
"Guidelines",
"for",
"Ensuring",
"and",
"Maximizing",
"the",
"Quality,",
"Objectivity,",
"Utility,",
"and",
"Integrity",
"of",
"Information",
"Disseminated",
"by",
"Federal",
"Agencies,",
"67",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"8452",
"(Feb.",
"22,",
"2002).",
"OMB,",
"Final",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Bulletin",
"for",
"Peer",
"Review,",
"70",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2664",
"(Jan.",
"14,",
"2005).",
"OMB,",
"Circular",
"A-4",
"(Sept.",
"2003).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
82,
46,
105,
59
],
[
108,
47,
140,
60
],
[
82,
62,
114,
74
],
[
117,
62,
139,
74
],
[
141,
61,
176,
74
],
[
81,
76,
115,
88
],
[
118,
77,
129,
88
],
[
83,
163,
124,
179
],
[
127,
163,
155,
179
],
[
159,
164,
225,
180
],
[
228,
164,
307,
180
],
[
311,
164,
370,
180
],
[
373,
164,
427,
180
],
[
430,
164,
440,
180
],
[
444,
163,
507,
180
],
[
510,
163,
530,
180
],
[
534,
163,
629,
180
],
[
632,
163,
694,
180
],
[
698,
163,
726,
180
],
[
730,
163,
779,
180
],
[
783,
162,
881,
180
],
[
887,
162,
912,
179
],
[
84,
180,
118,
196
],
[
122,
180,
181,
196
],
[
186,
181,
264,
197
],
[
271,
181,
335,
197
],
[
339,
181,
382,
197
],
[
386,
181,
415,
197
],
[
418,
181,
497,
197
],
[
500,
181,
511,
197
],
[
515,
181,
532,
197
],
[
535,
181,
585,
197
],
[
589,
182,
621,
197
],
[
624,
182,
649,
197
],
[
652,
182,
711,
196
],
[
714,
182,
771,
196
],
[
774,
182,
848,
196
],
[
851,
182,
895,
196
],
[
83,
199,
151,
214
],
[
154,
199,
181,
214
],
[
184,
199,
279,
214
],
[
282,
199,
312,
215
],
[
315,
199,
410,
215
],
[
412,
198,
471,
215
],
[
474,
198,
492,
215
],
[
495,
198,
557,
215
],
[
560,
198,
577,
215
],
[
580,
198,
662,
215
],
[
665,
198,
728,
214
],
[
731,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
839,
214
],
[
842,
198,
878,
213
],
[
84,
215,
175,
231
],
[
179,
215,
244,
231
],
[
247,
215,
324,
232
],
[
327,
215,
370,
232
],
[
374,
215,
431,
232
],
[
435,
215,
465,
232
],
[
468,
215,
509,
232
],
[
514,
215,
585,
232
],
[
588,
215,
633,
232
],
[
638,
215,
661,
231
],
[
665,
215,
723,
231
],
[
726,
215,
750,
231
],
[
757,
215,
785,
231
],
[
788,
215,
847,
231
],
[
850,
215,
877,
230
],
[
84,
233,
152,
248
],
[
155,
233,
194,
248
],
[
197,
233,
272,
249
],
[
276,
234,
306,
249
],
[
310,
234,
377,
249
],
[
381,
234,
406,
249
],
[
410,
234,
468,
249
],
[
471,
234,
572,
249
],
[
576,
234,
593,
249
],
[
597,
234,
627,
249
],
[
631,
233,
728,
249
],
[
732,
233,
747,
249
],
[
750,
233,
787,
248
],
[
792,
233,
822,
248
],
[
826,
232,
867,
248
],
[
871,
232,
928,
248
],
[
83,
251,
151,
266
],
[
154,
251,
176,
266
],
[
180,
250,
233,
266
],
[
237,
250,
246,
266
],
[
250,
250,
312,
266
],
[
315,
250,
390,
266
],
[
393,
250,
463,
265
],
[
85,
286,
115,
300
],
[
118,
286,
185,
300
],
[
188,
286,
270,
301
],
[
273,
286,
345,
301
],
[
348,
286,
375,
301
],
[
378,
286,
450,
301
],
[
452,
286,
486,
301
],
[
489,
286,
512,
301
],
[
515,
286,
555,
301
],
[
558,
286,
635,
301
],
[
637,
286,
655,
301
],
[
658,
286,
686,
301
],
[
690,
286,
771,
301
],
[
774,
286,
804,
301
],
[
807,
286,
903,
300
],
[
906,
286,
917,
300
],
[
84,
303,
143,
318
],
[
146,
303,
165,
318
],
[
168,
303,
282,
318
],
[
285,
303,
317,
318
],
[
320,
303,
344,
318
],
[
347,
303,
407,
318
],
[
410,
303,
435,
318
],
[
439,
303,
475,
317
],
[
478,
303,
495,
317
],
[
498,
303,
519,
317
],
[
522,
303,
593,
317
],
[
596,
303,
623,
317
],
[
627,
303,
714,
318
],
[
717,
303,
749,
318
],
[
752,
303,
797,
318
],
[
801,
304,
878,
318
],
[
881,
304,
930,
318
],
[
84,
320,
164,
335
],
[
168,
320,
204,
335
],
[
207,
320,
233,
335
],
[
237,
320,
302,
335
],
[
305,
320,
336,
335
],
[
340,
320,
375,
336
],
[
379,
320,
442,
336
],
[
445,
320,
485,
336
],
[
488,
320,
507,
336
],
[
510,
320,
522,
336
],
[
525,
320,
540,
336
],
[
543,
320,
653,
336
],
[
657,
320,
686,
336
],
[
690,
320,
713,
336
],
[
716,
320,
754,
336
],
[
757,
320,
820,
336
],
[
823,
320,
842,
335
],
[
845,
320,
854,
335
],
[
84,
339,
168,
352
],
[
174,
339,
241,
353
],
[
244,
339,
280,
353
],
[
284,
339,
326,
353
],
[
332,
338,
385,
353
],
[
388,
338,
418,
353
],
[
421,
338,
458,
353
],
[
461,
338,
482,
353
],
[
485,
338,
523,
353
],
[
527,
338,
626,
353
],
[
631,
338,
687,
353
],
[
690,
338,
721,
353
],
[
724,
338,
742,
353
],
[
745,
338,
787,
353
],
[
791,
337,
834,
353
],
[
840,
337,
875,
353
],
[
879,
337,
919,
353
],
[
82,
356,
112,
370
],
[
115,
355,
191,
370
],
[
195,
355,
221,
370
],
[
224,
355,
241,
370
],
[
244,
355,
285,
370
],
[
288,
355,
382,
370
],
[
387,
355,
411,
370
],
[
413,
355,
452,
370
],
[
458,
355,
545,
370
],
[
548,
355,
600,
370
],
[
606,
355,
645,
370
],
[
647,
355,
710,
370
],
[
712,
355,
732,
370
],
[
734,
355,
794,
370
],
[
795,
355,
843,
370
],
[
845,
355,
863,
370
],
[
865,
355,
887,
370
],
[
888,
355,
906,
370
],
[
83,
371,
200,
386
],
[
467,
423,
547,
441
],
[
200,
494,
251,
509
],
[
254,
494,
278,
509
],
[
281,
494,
345,
509
],
[
348,
495,
367,
509
],
[
611,
493,
676,
509
],
[
680,
494,
699,
509
],
[
702,
494,
765,
509
],
[
768,
494,
814,
509
],
[
818,
494,
872,
509
],
[
202,
512,
274,
526
],
[
278,
512,
341,
526
],
[
344,
511,
411,
525
],
[
612,
512,
666,
526
],
[
670,
512,
825,
527
],
[
829,
512,
898,
527
],
[
84,
763,
185,
780
],
[
189,
763,
275,
780
],
[
278,
763,
296,
780
],
[
300,
763,
326,
780
],
[
330,
763,
408,
780
],
[
411,
763,
495,
780
],
[
498,
763,
562,
780
],
[
565,
763,
585,
780
],
[
590,
763,
615,
780
],
[
618,
763,
692,
780
],
[
696,
763,
736,
780
],
[
740,
763,
832,
780
],
[
835,
763,
902,
779
],
[
84,
780,
154,
796
],
[
158,
781,
181,
796
],
[
185,
781,
235,
796
],
[
239,
781,
292,
796
],
[
298,
781,
328,
796
],
[
331,
781,
404,
796
],
[
408,
781,
426,
796
],
[
430,
781,
497,
797
],
[
501,
781,
550,
797
],
[
91,
851,
134,
865
],
[
137,
852,
207,
866
],
[
211,
852,
232,
866
],
[
235,
852,
295,
866
],
[
298,
853,
324,
866
],
[
327,
853,
405,
867
],
[
409,
853,
430,
867
],
[
434,
853,
487,
867
],
[
491,
853,
567,
867
],
[
571,
853,
617,
867
],
[
620,
853,
645,
867
],
[
649,
853,
705,
867
],
[
709,
853,
723,
867
],
[
727,
853,
805,
867
],
[
808,
852,
898,
867
],
[
901,
852,
917,
866
],
[
85,
868,
135,
880
],
[
138,
868,
202,
881
],
[
205,
868,
222,
881
],
[
225,
868,
255,
881
],
[
258,
868,
290,
881
],
[
292,
868,
327,
881
],
[
329,
868,
365,
881
],
[
367,
868,
390,
881
],
[
392,
868,
436,
881
],
[
91,
882,
134,
896
],
[
138,
882,
172,
896
],
[
176,
882,
255,
896
],
[
259,
882,
309,
896
],
[
312,
882,
364,
896
],
[
367,
882,
388,
896
],
[
391,
882,
423,
896
],
[
426,
882,
478,
896
],
[
482,
882,
498,
896
],
[
502,
881,
531,
896
],
[
534,
881,
566,
896
],
[
569,
881,
602,
896
],
[
605,
881,
639,
896
],
[
642,
881,
662,
896
],
[
665,
880,
709,
896
],
[
92,
895,
135,
909
],
[
138,
895,
195,
909
],
[
198,
896,
222,
910
],
[
225,
896,
265,
910
],
[
268,
896,
314,
910
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
who is the senior toxicologist/senior director?
|
RICHARD A. BECKER
|
767
|
[
"Dr.",
"Beck",
"June",
"15,",
"2006",
"Page",
"2",
"ACC",
"has",
"strongly",
"supported",
"OMB's",
"efforts",
"-",
"through",
"its",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Act",
"(IQA)",
"Guidelines,",
"the",
"Peer",
"Review",
"Bulletin,",
"Circular",
"A-4,",
"and",
"otherwise",
"-",
"to",
"assure",
"that",
"the",
"highest",
"quality",
"scientific",
"work",
"products",
"are",
"consistently",
"and",
"assiduously",
"applied",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"regulatory",
"policy.",
"The",
"proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"continues",
"those",
"efforts,",
"and",
"ACC",
"applauds",
"OMB",
"for",
"issuing",
"it.",
"We",
"believe",
"the",
"Bulletin,",
"once",
"finalized,",
"will",
"improve",
"the",
"uneven",
"performance",
"of",
"risk",
"assessments",
"at",
"EPA",
"and",
"other",
"federal",
"agencies",
"by",
"setting",
"a",
"unified,",
"upgraded",
"standard.",
"The",
"attached",
"comments",
"highlight",
"the",
"strengths",
"that",
"we",
"have",
"identified",
"in",
"the",
"document,",
"and",
"recommend",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"improvements",
"that",
"we",
"believe",
"are",
"vital",
"to",
"its",
"success.",
"We",
"understand",
"that",
"many",
"important",
"issues",
"associated",
"with",
"the",
"Bulletin",
"will",
"only",
"become",
"clear",
"as",
"it",
"is",
"implemented,",
"and",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"a",
"continuing",
"dialogue",
"with",
"OMB",
"before",
"and",
"after",
"its",
"final",
"publication.",
"Should",
"you",
"or",
"other",
"OMB",
"staff",
"have",
"any",
"questions",
"on,",
"or",
"need",
"clarification",
"of,",
"ACC",
"comments,",
"please",
"don't",
"hesitate",
"to",
"contact",
"either",
"of",
"us",
"at",
"703-741-5000.",
"Sincerely,",
"James",
"W.",
"Conrad,",
"Jr.",
"Richard",
"A.",
"Becker,",
"Ph.D.",
"DABT",
"Assistant",
"General",
"Counsel",
"Senior",
"Toxicologist/Senior",
"Director",
"Attachment:",
"Comments",
"of",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"on",
"the",
"Proposed",
"Risk",
"Assessment",
"Bulletin",
"(released",
"for",
"public",
"review",
"and",
"comment",
"in",
"January,",
"2006)",
"OMB,",
"Guidelines",
"for",
"Ensuring",
"and",
"Maximizing",
"the",
"Quality,",
"Objectivity,",
"Utility,",
"and",
"Integrity",
"of",
"Information",
"Disseminated",
"by",
"Federal",
"Agencies,",
"67",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"8452",
"(Feb.",
"22,",
"2002).",
"OMB,",
"Final",
"Information",
"Quality",
"Bulletin",
"for",
"Peer",
"Review,",
"70",
"Fed.",
"Reg.",
"2664",
"(Jan.",
"14,",
"2005).",
"OMB,",
"Circular",
"A-4",
"(Sept.",
"2003).",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/klcn0226"
] |
[
[
82,
46,
105,
59
],
[
108,
47,
140,
60
],
[
82,
62,
114,
74
],
[
117,
62,
139,
74
],
[
141,
61,
176,
74
],
[
81,
76,
115,
88
],
[
118,
77,
129,
88
],
[
83,
163,
124,
179
],
[
127,
163,
155,
179
],
[
159,
164,
225,
180
],
[
228,
164,
307,
180
],
[
311,
164,
370,
180
],
[
373,
164,
427,
180
],
[
430,
164,
440,
180
],
[
444,
163,
507,
180
],
[
510,
163,
530,
180
],
[
534,
163,
629,
180
],
[
632,
163,
694,
180
],
[
698,
163,
726,
180
],
[
730,
163,
779,
180
],
[
783,
162,
881,
180
],
[
887,
162,
912,
179
],
[
84,
180,
118,
196
],
[
122,
180,
181,
196
],
[
186,
181,
264,
197
],
[
271,
181,
335,
197
],
[
339,
181,
382,
197
],
[
386,
181,
415,
197
],
[
418,
181,
497,
197
],
[
500,
181,
511,
197
],
[
515,
181,
532,
197
],
[
535,
181,
585,
197
],
[
589,
182,
621,
197
],
[
624,
182,
649,
197
],
[
652,
182,
711,
196
],
[
714,
182,
771,
196
],
[
774,
182,
848,
196
],
[
851,
182,
895,
196
],
[
83,
199,
151,
214
],
[
154,
199,
181,
214
],
[
184,
199,
279,
214
],
[
282,
199,
312,
215
],
[
315,
199,
410,
215
],
[
412,
198,
471,
215
],
[
474,
198,
492,
215
],
[
495,
198,
557,
215
],
[
560,
198,
577,
215
],
[
580,
198,
662,
215
],
[
665,
198,
728,
214
],
[
731,
198,
762,
214
],
[
765,
198,
839,
214
],
[
842,
198,
878,
213
],
[
84,
215,
175,
231
],
[
179,
215,
244,
231
],
[
247,
215,
324,
232
],
[
327,
215,
370,
232
],
[
374,
215,
431,
232
],
[
435,
215,
465,
232
],
[
468,
215,
509,
232
],
[
514,
215,
585,
232
],
[
588,
215,
633,
232
],
[
638,
215,
661,
231
],
[
665,
215,
723,
231
],
[
726,
215,
750,
231
],
[
757,
215,
785,
231
],
[
788,
215,
847,
231
],
[
850,
215,
877,
230
],
[
84,
233,
152,
248
],
[
155,
233,
194,
248
],
[
197,
233,
272,
249
],
[
276,
234,
306,
249
],
[
310,
234,
377,
249
],
[
381,
234,
406,
249
],
[
410,
234,
468,
249
],
[
471,
234,
572,
249
],
[
576,
234,
593,
249
],
[
597,
234,
627,
249
],
[
631,
233,
728,
249
],
[
732,
233,
747,
249
],
[
750,
233,
787,
248
],
[
792,
233,
822,
248
],
[
826,
232,
867,
248
],
[
871,
232,
928,
248
],
[
83,
251,
151,
266
],
[
154,
251,
176,
266
],
[
180,
250,
233,
266
],
[
237,
250,
246,
266
],
[
250,
250,
312,
266
],
[
315,
250,
390,
266
],
[
393,
250,
463,
265
],
[
85,
286,
115,
300
],
[
118,
286,
185,
300
],
[
188,
286,
270,
301
],
[
273,
286,
345,
301
],
[
348,
286,
375,
301
],
[
378,
286,
450,
301
],
[
452,
286,
486,
301
],
[
489,
286,
512,
301
],
[
515,
286,
555,
301
],
[
558,
286,
635,
301
],
[
637,
286,
655,
301
],
[
658,
286,
686,
301
],
[
690,
286,
771,
301
],
[
774,
286,
804,
301
],
[
807,
286,
903,
300
],
[
906,
286,
917,
300
],
[
84,
303,
143,
318
],
[
146,
303,
165,
318
],
[
168,
303,
282,
318
],
[
285,
303,
317,
318
],
[
320,
303,
344,
318
],
[
347,
303,
407,
318
],
[
410,
303,
435,
318
],
[
439,
303,
475,
317
],
[
478,
303,
495,
317
],
[
498,
303,
519,
317
],
[
522,
303,
593,
317
],
[
596,
303,
623,
317
],
[
627,
303,
714,
318
],
[
717,
303,
749,
318
],
[
752,
303,
797,
318
],
[
801,
304,
878,
318
],
[
881,
304,
930,
318
],
[
84,
320,
164,
335
],
[
168,
320,
204,
335
],
[
207,
320,
233,
335
],
[
237,
320,
302,
335
],
[
305,
320,
336,
335
],
[
340,
320,
375,
336
],
[
379,
320,
442,
336
],
[
445,
320,
485,
336
],
[
488,
320,
507,
336
],
[
510,
320,
522,
336
],
[
525,
320,
540,
336
],
[
543,
320,
653,
336
],
[
657,
320,
686,
336
],
[
690,
320,
713,
336
],
[
716,
320,
754,
336
],
[
757,
320,
820,
336
],
[
823,
320,
842,
335
],
[
845,
320,
854,
335
],
[
84,
339,
168,
352
],
[
174,
339,
241,
353
],
[
244,
339,
280,
353
],
[
284,
339,
326,
353
],
[
332,
338,
385,
353
],
[
388,
338,
418,
353
],
[
421,
338,
458,
353
],
[
461,
338,
482,
353
],
[
485,
338,
523,
353
],
[
527,
338,
626,
353
],
[
631,
338,
687,
353
],
[
690,
338,
721,
353
],
[
724,
338,
742,
353
],
[
745,
338,
787,
353
],
[
791,
337,
834,
353
],
[
840,
337,
875,
353
],
[
879,
337,
919,
353
],
[
82,
356,
112,
370
],
[
115,
355,
191,
370
],
[
195,
355,
221,
370
],
[
224,
355,
241,
370
],
[
244,
355,
285,
370
],
[
288,
355,
382,
370
],
[
387,
355,
411,
370
],
[
413,
355,
452,
370
],
[
458,
355,
545,
370
],
[
548,
355,
600,
370
],
[
606,
355,
645,
370
],
[
647,
355,
710,
370
],
[
712,
355,
732,
370
],
[
734,
355,
794,
370
],
[
795,
355,
843,
370
],
[
845,
355,
863,
370
],
[
865,
355,
887,
370
],
[
888,
355,
906,
370
],
[
83,
371,
200,
386
],
[
467,
423,
547,
441
],
[
200,
494,
251,
509
],
[
254,
494,
278,
509
],
[
281,
494,
345,
509
],
[
348,
495,
367,
509
],
[
611,
493,
676,
509
],
[
680,
494,
699,
509
],
[
702,
494,
765,
509
],
[
768,
494,
814,
509
],
[
818,
494,
872,
509
],
[
202,
512,
274,
526
],
[
278,
512,
341,
526
],
[
344,
511,
411,
525
],
[
612,
512,
666,
526
],
[
670,
512,
825,
527
],
[
829,
512,
898,
527
],
[
84,
763,
185,
780
],
[
189,
763,
275,
780
],
[
278,
763,
296,
780
],
[
300,
763,
326,
780
],
[
330,
763,
408,
780
],
[
411,
763,
495,
780
],
[
498,
763,
562,
780
],
[
565,
763,
585,
780
],
[
590,
763,
615,
780
],
[
618,
763,
692,
780
],
[
696,
763,
736,
780
],
[
740,
763,
832,
780
],
[
835,
763,
902,
779
],
[
84,
780,
154,
796
],
[
158,
781,
181,
796
],
[
185,
781,
235,
796
],
[
239,
781,
292,
796
],
[
298,
781,
328,
796
],
[
331,
781,
404,
796
],
[
408,
781,
426,
796
],
[
430,
781,
497,
797
],
[
501,
781,
550,
797
],
[
91,
851,
134,
865
],
[
137,
852,
207,
866
],
[
211,
852,
232,
866
],
[
235,
852,
295,
866
],
[
298,
853,
324,
866
],
[
327,
853,
405,
867
],
[
409,
853,
430,
867
],
[
434,
853,
487,
867
],
[
491,
853,
567,
867
],
[
571,
853,
617,
867
],
[
620,
853,
645,
867
],
[
649,
853,
705,
867
],
[
709,
853,
723,
867
],
[
727,
853,
805,
867
],
[
808,
852,
898,
867
],
[
901,
852,
917,
866
],
[
85,
868,
135,
880
],
[
138,
868,
202,
881
],
[
205,
868,
222,
881
],
[
225,
868,
255,
881
],
[
258,
868,
290,
881
],
[
292,
868,
327,
881
],
[
329,
868,
365,
881
],
[
367,
868,
390,
881
],
[
392,
868,
436,
881
],
[
91,
882,
134,
896
],
[
138,
882,
172,
896
],
[
176,
882,
255,
896
],
[
259,
882,
309,
896
],
[
312,
882,
364,
896
],
[
367,
882,
388,
896
],
[
391,
882,
423,
896
],
[
426,
882,
478,
896
],
[
482,
882,
498,
896
],
[
502,
881,
531,
896
],
[
534,
881,
566,
896
],
[
569,
881,
602,
896
],
[
605,
881,
639,
896
],
[
642,
881,
662,
896
],
[
665,
880,
709,
896
],
[
92,
895,
135,
909
],
[
138,
895,
195,
909
],
[
198,
896,
222,
910
],
[
225,
896,
265,
910
],
[
268,
896,
314,
910
],
[
223,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
778,
997
]
] |
which has strongly supported OMB's efforts through its information quality act IQA guidelines?
|
ACC
|
771
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"Washington,",
"D.C",
"20460",
"JUN",
"-",
"8",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"GENERAL",
"COUNSEL",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Participation",
"in",
"Specific",
"Party",
"Matters",
"Involving",
"Your",
"Former",
"Employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"FROM:",
"Kevin",
"S.",
"Minoli",
"Designated",
"Agency",
"Ethics",
"Official",
"and",
"Acting",
"General",
"Counsel",
"TO:",
"Nancy",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"Effective",
"April",
"30,",
"2017,",
"you",
"joined",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"(AD)",
"position",
"as",
"the",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"for",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"(OCSPP).",
"In",
"this",
"position,",
"you",
"are",
"responsible",
"for",
"advising",
"the",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"matters",
"pertaining",
"to",
"chemical",
"safety,",
"pollution",
"prevention,",
"pesticides",
"and",
"toxic",
"substances,",
"including",
"implementation",
"of",
"rulemaking",
"under",
"applicable",
"federal",
"statutes.",
"Previous",
"to",
"your",
"selection,",
"you",
"served",
"as",
"the",
"Senior",
"Director",
"of",
"Regulatory",
"Science",
"Policy",
"at",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"which",
"represents",
"companies",
"that",
"are",
"directly",
"regulated",
"by",
"EPA.",
"You",
"seek",
"permission",
"to",
"participate",
"in",
"specific",
"party",
"matters",
"involving",
"your",
"former",
"employer.",
"In",
"providing",
"my",
"advice,",
"I",
"have",
"taken",
"into",
"consideration",
"the",
"fact",
"that,",
"as",
"an",
"AD",
"appointment,",
"you",
"are",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge",
"because",
"this",
"type",
"of",
"appointment",
"falls",
"outside",
"the",
"definition",
"of",
"\"appointee\"",
"set",
"forth",
"at",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13,770",
"at",
"Section",
"2(b).'",
"You",
"do",
"not",
"have",
"any",
"financial",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"with",
"your",
"former",
"employer,",
"so",
"the",
"ethics",
"rules",
"to",
"be",
"applied",
"to",
"you",
"are",
"set",
"forth",
"in",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"$",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635,",
"specifically",
"Subpart",
"E,",
"\"Impartiality",
"in",
"Performing",
"Official",
"Duty,",
"\"",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"$",
"C.FR.",
"$",
"2635",
"502(b)(1)(iv),",
"you",
"have",
"a",
"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"ACC",
"as",
"your",
"former",
"employer.",
"For",
"one",
"year",
"from",
"the",
"time",
"you",
"resigned",
"from",
"ACC,",
"absent",
"an",
"impartiality",
"determination",
"from",
"me,",
"you",
"cannot",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party",
"if",
"that",
"matter",
"is",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"financial",
"effect",
"upon",
"the",
"ACC",
"or",
"if",
"the",
"circumstances",
"would",
"cause",
"a",
"reasonable",
"See",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"advisories",
"entitled",
"\"Guidance",
"on",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770.",
"\"",
"LA-17-03",
"(3/2027)",
"and",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770,",
"\"LA-17-02",
"(2/6/17),",
"which",
"apply",
"the",
"following",
"QUE",
"advisories",
"from",
"the",
"last",
"administration",
"in",
"full:",
"\"Who",
"Must",
"Sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge?\"",
"DO.09",
"010",
"(3/16",
"09):",
"and",
"\"Signing",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge.\"",
"DO-09-00$",
"(2/10/09);",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/lpbn0226"
] |
[
[
246,
113,
318,
129
],
[
326,
113,
403,
129
],
[
407,
113,
577,
129
],
[
582,
112,
708,
129
],
[
716,
112,
800,
129
],
[
413,
130,
504,
145
],
[
507,
130,
536,
144
],
[
545,
129,
590,
144
],
[
425,
172,
462,
192
],
[
466,
172,
481,
192
],
[
486,
172,
503,
192
],
[
509,
173,
544,
193
],
[
709,
179,
760,
192
],
[
763,
178,
784,
192
],
[
674,
195,
737,
208
],
[
741,
195,
807,
208
],
[
123,
229,
275,
247
],
[
123,
263,
220,
280
],
[
241,
264,
342,
280
],
[
346,
264,
363,
280
],
[
367,
264,
431,
280
],
[
435,
264,
477,
280
],
[
481,
264,
541,
280
],
[
545,
263,
625,
280
],
[
628,
263,
666,
280
],
[
669,
262,
729,
280
],
[
732,
261,
816,
280
],
[
819,
261,
845,
279
],
[
243,
282,
321,
297
],
[
324,
281,
407,
296
],
[
410,
281,
475,
297
],
[
123,
314,
186,
331
],
[
240,
315,
292,
331
],
[
295,
315,
311,
331
],
[
314,
315,
367,
331
],
[
242,
334,
331,
349
],
[
335,
334,
397,
349
],
[
400,
333,
451,
349
],
[
454,
333,
516,
349
],
[
519,
333,
544,
349
],
[
252,
351,
307,
367
],
[
310,
351,
372,
366
],
[
375,
351,
440,
366
],
[
125,
385,
156,
400
],
[
240,
385,
293,
402
],
[
296,
385,
343,
402
],
[
346,
385,
398,
402
],
[
401,
385,
457,
402
],
[
241,
402,
302,
419
],
[
306,
403,
377,
420
],
[
381,
403,
491,
420
],
[
240,
420,
291,
437
],
[
295,
420,
313,
437
],
[
316,
420,
393,
438
],
[
397,
420,
447,
438
],
[
451,
421,
480,
438
],
[
485,
421,
556,
438
],
[
560,
421,
646,
438
],
[
181,
472,
255,
490
],
[
259,
472,
302,
490
],
[
305,
473,
330,
490
],
[
334,
473,
380,
490
],
[
383,
473,
412,
491
],
[
416,
473,
466,
491
],
[
469,
473,
496,
491
],
[
500,
473,
554,
491
],
[
557,
473,
604,
491
],
[
608,
473,
725,
491
],
[
729,
473,
812,
490
],
[
815,
472,
876,
490
],
[
123,
490,
174,
506
],
[
178,
490,
194,
507
],
[
198,
491,
219,
507
],
[
224,
491,
356,
507
],
[
360,
491,
451,
507
],
[
455,
491,
497,
507
],
[
502,
491,
565,
507
],
[
569,
491,
587,
507
],
[
590,
491,
615,
507
],
[
619,
491,
678,
507
],
[
682,
491,
754,
507
],
[
758,
490,
871,
507
],
[
124,
508,
146,
524
],
[
149,
508,
175,
524
],
[
178,
508,
231,
524
],
[
234,
508,
252,
525
],
[
255,
508,
333,
525
],
[
336,
508,
387,
525
],
[
390,
508,
420,
525
],
[
423,
508,
497,
525
],
[
500,
508,
585,
525
],
[
588,
508,
667,
525
],
[
670,
508,
688,
525
],
[
691,
508,
721,
525
],
[
724,
508,
794,
525
],
[
797,
508,
828,
525
],
[
831,
508,
860,
525
],
[
123,
525,
214,
542
],
[
218,
526,
241,
542
],
[
245,
526,
312,
542
],
[
316,
526,
343,
543
],
[
346,
526,
400,
543
],
[
404,
526,
476,
543
],
[
480,
526,
590,
543
],
[
593,
526,
609,
542
],
[
613,
526,
672,
542
],
[
675,
525,
756,
542
],
[
759,
525,
775,
541
],
[
778,
524,
855,
541
],
[
123,
543,
175,
559
],
[
179,
543,
252,
560
],
[
256,
544,
345,
560
],
[
349,
544,
427,
560
],
[
431,
544,
459,
560
],
[
463,
544,
504,
560
],
[
508,
544,
596,
560
],
[
600,
543,
675,
559
],
[
678,
543,
802,
559
],
[
805,
542,
822,
558
],
[
123,
561,
213,
578
],
[
217,
561,
262,
578
],
[
266,
561,
348,
578
],
[
352,
561,
408,
578
],
[
411,
561,
480,
578
],
[
484,
561,
553,
578
],
[
557,
561,
573,
577
],
[
577,
561,
612,
577
],
[
617,
561,
692,
577
],
[
696,
561,
727,
576
],
[
731,
561,
782,
576
],
[
786,
561,
802,
576
],
[
807,
561,
829,
576
],
[
124,
577,
175,
594
],
[
179,
577,
244,
594
],
[
248,
577,
266,
595
],
[
270,
577,
358,
595
],
[
363,
578,
424,
595
],
[
428,
578,
478,
595
],
[
482,
578,
496,
595
],
[
500,
578,
527,
595
],
[
531,
577,
606,
595
],
[
610,
577,
693,
595
],
[
697,
576,
758,
594
],
[
762,
576,
824,
594
],
[
827,
575,
874,
594
],
[
123,
596,
203,
611
],
[
207,
596,
293,
612
],
[
296,
596,
327,
612
],
[
330,
596,
358,
612
],
[
362,
596,
420,
612
],
[
424,
596,
497,
612
],
[
500,
596,
522,
612
],
[
526,
596,
575,
612
],
[
578,
596,
611,
612
],
[
615,
595,
651,
612
],
[
653,
595,
741,
612
],
[
744,
595,
761,
611
],
[
764,
595,
849,
611
],
[
852,
595,
869,
611
],
[
124,
613,
185,
629
],
[
189,
613,
229,
629
],
[
233,
613,
293,
629
],
[
296,
613,
374,
629
],
[
378,
613,
414,
629
],
[
418,
613,
472,
629
],
[
475,
614,
558,
630
],
[
181,
646,
198,
662
],
[
202,
646,
280,
663
],
[
284,
646,
310,
663
],
[
313,
647,
371,
663
],
[
374,
647,
382,
663
],
[
385,
647,
424,
663
],
[
427,
647,
470,
663
],
[
475,
647,
506,
663
],
[
509,
646,
615,
663
],
[
619,
646,
644,
662
],
[
648,
646,
678,
662
],
[
681,
646,
717,
662
],
[
720,
645,
737,
662
],
[
741,
645,
763,
662
],
[
766,
645,
794,
661
],
[
124,
664,
228,
679
],
[
232,
664,
261,
679
],
[
265,
664,
289,
679
],
[
293,
664,
320,
679
],
[
323,
664,
390,
680
],
[
394,
664,
410,
680
],
[
414,
664,
447,
680
],
[
451,
664,
478,
680
],
[
482,
663,
534,
680
],
[
537,
663,
584,
679
],
[
587,
663,
640,
679
],
[
643,
663,
706,
679
],
[
710,
663,
739,
679
],
[
743,
662,
777,
679
],
[
781,
662,
803,
679
],
[
123,
680,
222,
696
],
[
226,
680,
260,
696
],
[
264,
680,
323,
697
],
[
326,
680,
353,
697
],
[
357,
680,
431,
697
],
[
435,
680,
453,
697
],
[
456,
680,
550,
697
],
[
554,
680,
577,
697
],
[
580,
680,
619,
697
],
[
622,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
721,
696
],
[
724,
679,
774,
696
],
[
777,
679,
829,
695
],
[
832,
679,
852,
695
],
[
124,
696,
183,
714
],
[
187,
697,
240,
714
],
[
244,
697,
278,
714
],
[
282,
697,
299,
714
],
[
303,
697,
329,
714
],
[
333,
697,
371,
714
],
[
375,
697,
404,
714
],
[
408,
697,
477,
714
],
[
481,
698,
541,
714
],
[
545,
698,
563,
714
],
[
567,
698,
625,
714
],
[
629,
698,
665,
714
],
[
669,
698,
706,
714
],
[
710,
698,
763,
714
],
[
767,
698,
847,
714
],
[
851,
698,
868,
713
],
[
123,
714,
148,
732
],
[
152,
714,
198,
732
],
[
202,
715,
241,
732
],
[
245,
715,
260,
732
],
[
265,
715,
285,
733
],
[
289,
715,
348,
733
],
[
352,
715,
368,
733
],
[
372,
715,
401,
733
],
[
405,
715,
431,
733
],
[
435,
715,
456,
733
],
[
460,
715,
499,
733
],
[
503,
715,
520,
733
],
[
523,
715,
548,
733
],
[
552,
715,
629,
733
],
[
633,
715,
651,
733
],
[
655,
714,
711,
733
],
[
714,
714,
782,
732
],
[
786,
714,
811,
732
],
[
123,
732,
211,
749
],
[
215,
733,
232,
749
],
[
235,
733,
261,
749
],
[
265,
733,
344,
750
],
[
348,
733,
411,
750
],
[
414,
733,
425,
750
],
[
428,
733,
481,
750
],
[
485,
733,
517,
750
],
[
521,
733,
566,
750
],
[
570,
733,
660,
750
],
[
664,
732,
727,
750
],
[
731,
732,
747,
749
],
[
751,
731,
854,
749
],
[
858,
731,
873,
748
],
[
123,
750,
213,
767
],
[
217,
750,
278,
767
],
[
282,
750,
323,
768
],
[
326,
750,
342,
768
],
[
345,
750,
414,
768
],
[
418,
750,
436,
768
],
[
439,
750,
449,
768
],
[
452,
750,
507,
768
],
[
510,
750,
521,
768
],
[
524,
750,
564,
768
],
[
568,
750,
676,
768
],
[
679,
750,
709,
768
],
[
713,
750,
751,
767
],
[
754,
750,
770,
767
],
[
776,
750,
841,
767
],
[
121,
768,
226,
784
],
[
231,
768,
267,
785
],
[
270,
768,
310,
785
],
[
314,
769,
331,
785
],
[
335,
769,
371,
785
],
[
375,
769,
430,
785
],
[
434,
769,
518,
785
],
[
522,
769,
550,
785
],
[
554,
769,
582,
785
],
[
586,
769,
621,
785
],
[
625,
769,
662,
785
],
[
667,
768,
692,
785
],
[
696,
768,
733,
784
],
[
737,
768,
766,
784
],
[
770,
767,
839,
784
],
[
843,
767,
879,
783
],
[
124,
785,
170,
801
],
[
173,
786,
224,
802
],
[
228,
786,
248,
802
],
[
251,
786,
347,
802
],
[
352,
786,
457,
802
],
[
461,
786,
497,
802
],
[
503,
786,
533,
802
],
[
537,
786,
567,
802
],
[
571,
786,
624,
802
],
[
628,
786,
710,
802
],
[
714,
786,
731,
802
],
[
736,
786,
763,
802
],
[
767,
786,
829,
802
],
[
834,
785,
871,
801
],
[
124,
803,
174,
819
],
[
177,
803,
194,
819
],
[
198,
803,
248,
819
],
[
252,
803,
291,
819
],
[
296,
803,
311,
819
],
[
314,
803,
324,
819
],
[
327,
803,
368,
819
],
[
372,
803,
390,
819
],
[
393,
803,
473,
819
],
[
477,
803,
486,
819
],
[
490,
803,
531,
819
],
[
534,
803,
548,
819
],
[
551,
803,
582,
819
],
[
585,
803,
637,
819
],
[
641,
803,
654,
819
],
[
658,
802,
704,
819
],
[
707,
802,
723,
819
],
[
727,
802,
765,
819
],
[
768,
802,
781,
819
],
[
784,
802,
829,
818
],
[
833,
802,
865,
818
],
[
122,
820,
211,
836
],
[
215,
820,
285,
836
],
[
288,
820,
334,
836
],
[
339,
820,
377,
836
],
[
381,
820,
407,
836
],
[
411,
820,
451,
836
],
[
456,
820,
472,
836
],
[
476,
820,
488,
836
],
[
492,
820,
518,
836
],
[
522,
820,
632,
836
],
[
636,
820,
686,
836
],
[
690,
820,
734,
836
],
[
738,
820,
747,
835
],
[
751,
819,
839,
835
],
[
133,
854,
156,
869
],
[
159,
855,
201,
869
],
[
205,
855,
219,
870
],
[
223,
855,
305,
870
],
[
309,
856,
349,
870
],
[
353,
856,
419,
871
],
[
422,
856,
470,
871
],
[
474,
856,
545,
871
],
[
548,
856,
566,
871
],
[
570,
855,
635,
871
],
[
638,
855,
678,
870
],
[
681,
855,
720,
870
],
[
724,
855,
731,
870
],
[
734,
854,
800,
870
],
[
803,
853,
869,
870
],
[
124,
870,
147,
884
],
[
150,
870,
217,
884
],
[
219,
870,
260,
885
],
[
263,
870,
304,
885
],
[
307,
870,
383,
886
],
[
387,
870,
446,
886
],
[
449,
870,
489,
886
],
[
492,
870,
528,
886
],
[
531,
870,
552,
886
],
[
556,
870,
619,
886
],
[
622,
870,
656,
886
],
[
659,
871,
727,
885
],
[
730,
871,
760,
885
],
[
766,
871,
786,
885
],
[
789,
871,
816,
884
],
[
123,
885,
219,
899
],
[
222,
885,
235,
899
],
[
238,
885,
265,
899
],
[
269,
885,
310,
899
],
[
313,
885,
348,
899
],
[
351,
884,
380,
900
],
[
383,
884,
405,
900
],
[
408,
884,
449,
900
],
[
452,
884,
512,
900
],
[
514,
884,
562,
900
],
[
565,
884,
590,
900
],
[
592,
884,
630,
900
],
[
633,
884,
660,
900
],
[
663,
884,
686,
900
],
[
690,
884,
748,
900
],
[
751,
884,
774,
899
],
[
777,
884,
818,
899
],
[
821,
884,
877,
899
],
[
124,
900,
199,
913
],
[
202,
900,
271,
915
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
What is the location of united states environmental protection agency ?
|
Washington, D.C. 20460
|
771
|
[
"UNITED",
"STATES",
"ENVIRONMENTAL",
"PROTECTION",
"AGENCY",
"Washington,",
"D.C",
"20460",
"JUN",
"-",
"8",
"2017",
"OFFICE",
"OF",
"GENERAL",
"COUNSEL",
"MEMORANDUM",
"SUBJECT:",
"Participation",
"in",
"Specific",
"Party",
"Matters",
"Involving",
"Your",
"Former",
"Employer,",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"FROM:",
"Kevin",
"S.",
"Minoli",
"Designated",
"Agency",
"Ethics",
"Official",
"and",
"Acting",
"General",
"Counsel",
"TO:",
"Nancy",
"Beck,",
"Ph.D.,",
"DABT",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"Effective",
"April",
"30,",
"2017,",
"you",
"joined",
"the",
"United",
"States",
"Environmental",
"Protection",
"Agency",
"(EPA)",
"in",
"an",
"Administratively",
"Determined",
"(AD)",
"position",
"as",
"the",
"Deputy",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"for",
"the",
"Office",
"of",
"Chemical",
"Safety",
"and",
"Pollution",
"Prevention",
"(OCSPP).",
"In",
"this",
"position,",
"you",
"are",
"responsible",
"for",
"advising",
"the",
"Acting",
"Assistant",
"Administrator",
"in",
"matters",
"pertaining",
"to",
"chemical",
"safety,",
"pollution",
"prevention,",
"pesticides",
"and",
"toxic",
"substances,",
"including",
"implementation",
"of",
"rulemaking",
"under",
"applicable",
"federal",
"statutes.",
"Previous",
"to",
"your",
"selection,",
"you",
"served",
"as",
"the",
"Senior",
"Director",
"of",
"Regulatory",
"Science",
"Policy",
"at",
"the",
"American",
"Chemistry",
"Council",
"(ACC),",
"which",
"represents",
"companies",
"that",
"are",
"directly",
"regulated",
"by",
"EPA.",
"You",
"seek",
"permission",
"to",
"participate",
"in",
"specific",
"party",
"matters",
"involving",
"your",
"former",
"employer.",
"In",
"providing",
"my",
"advice,",
"I",
"have",
"taken",
"into",
"consideration",
"the",
"fact",
"that,",
"as",
"an",
"AD",
"appointment,",
"you",
"are",
"not",
"required",
"to",
"sign",
"the",
"Trump",
"ethics",
"pledge",
"because",
"this",
"type",
"of",
"appointment",
"falls",
"outside",
"the",
"definition",
"of",
"\"appointee\"",
"set",
"forth",
"at",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13,770",
"at",
"Section",
"2(b).'",
"You",
"do",
"not",
"have",
"any",
"financial",
"conflict",
"of",
"interest",
"with",
"your",
"former",
"employer,",
"so",
"the",
"ethics",
"rules",
"to",
"be",
"applied",
"to",
"you",
"are",
"set",
"forth",
"in",
"the",
"Standards",
"of",
"Ethical",
"Conduct",
"for",
"Employees",
"of",
"the",
"Executive",
"Branch,",
"$",
"C.F.R.",
"Part",
"2635,",
"specifically",
"Subpart",
"E,",
"\"Impartiality",
"in",
"Performing",
"Official",
"Duty,",
"\"",
"Pursuant",
"to",
"$",
"C.FR.",
"$",
"2635",
"502(b)(1)(iv),",
"you",
"have",
"a",
"covered",
"relationship\"",
"with",
"ACC",
"as",
"your",
"former",
"employer.",
"For",
"one",
"year",
"from",
"the",
"time",
"you",
"resigned",
"from",
"ACC,",
"absent",
"an",
"impartiality",
"determination",
"from",
"me,",
"you",
"cannot",
"participate",
"in",
"any",
"specific",
"party",
"matter",
"in",
"which",
"ACC",
"is",
"a",
"party",
"or",
"represents",
"a",
"party",
"if",
"that",
"matter",
"is",
"likely",
"to",
"have",
"a",
"direct",
"and",
"predictable",
"financial",
"effect",
"upon",
"the",
"ACC",
"or",
"if",
"the",
"circumstances",
"would",
"cause",
"a",
"reasonable",
"See",
"Office",
"of",
"Government",
"Ethics",
"advisories",
"entitled",
"\"Guidance",
"on",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770.",
"\"",
"LA-17-03",
"(3/2027)",
"and",
"Executive",
"Order",
"13770,",
"\"LA-17-02",
"(2/6/17),",
"which",
"apply",
"the",
"following",
"QUE",
"advisories",
"from",
"the",
"last",
"administration",
"in",
"full:",
"\"Who",
"Must",
"Sign",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge?\"",
"DO.09",
"010",
"(3/16",
"09):",
"and",
"\"Signing",
"the",
"Ethics",
"Pledge.\"",
"DO-09-00$",
"(2/10/09);",
"Source:",
"https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/docs/lpbn0226"
] |
[
[
246,
113,
318,
129
],
[
326,
113,
403,
129
],
[
407,
113,
577,
129
],
[
582,
112,
708,
129
],
[
716,
112,
800,
129
],
[
413,
130,
504,
145
],
[
507,
130,
536,
144
],
[
545,
129,
590,
144
],
[
425,
172,
462,
192
],
[
466,
172,
481,
192
],
[
486,
172,
503,
192
],
[
509,
173,
544,
193
],
[
709,
179,
760,
192
],
[
763,
178,
784,
192
],
[
674,
195,
737,
208
],
[
741,
195,
807,
208
],
[
123,
229,
275,
247
],
[
123,
263,
220,
280
],
[
241,
264,
342,
280
],
[
346,
264,
363,
280
],
[
367,
264,
431,
280
],
[
435,
264,
477,
280
],
[
481,
264,
541,
280
],
[
545,
263,
625,
280
],
[
628,
263,
666,
280
],
[
669,
262,
729,
280
],
[
732,
261,
816,
280
],
[
819,
261,
845,
279
],
[
243,
282,
321,
297
],
[
324,
281,
407,
296
],
[
410,
281,
475,
297
],
[
123,
314,
186,
331
],
[
240,
315,
292,
331
],
[
295,
315,
311,
331
],
[
314,
315,
367,
331
],
[
242,
334,
331,
349
],
[
335,
334,
397,
349
],
[
400,
333,
451,
349
],
[
454,
333,
516,
349
],
[
519,
333,
544,
349
],
[
252,
351,
307,
367
],
[
310,
351,
372,
366
],
[
375,
351,
440,
366
],
[
125,
385,
156,
400
],
[
240,
385,
293,
402
],
[
296,
385,
343,
402
],
[
346,
385,
398,
402
],
[
401,
385,
457,
402
],
[
241,
402,
302,
419
],
[
306,
403,
377,
420
],
[
381,
403,
491,
420
],
[
240,
420,
291,
437
],
[
295,
420,
313,
437
],
[
316,
420,
393,
438
],
[
397,
420,
447,
438
],
[
451,
421,
480,
438
],
[
485,
421,
556,
438
],
[
560,
421,
646,
438
],
[
181,
472,
255,
490
],
[
259,
472,
302,
490
],
[
305,
473,
330,
490
],
[
334,
473,
380,
490
],
[
383,
473,
412,
491
],
[
416,
473,
466,
491
],
[
469,
473,
496,
491
],
[
500,
473,
554,
491
],
[
557,
473,
604,
491
],
[
608,
473,
725,
491
],
[
729,
473,
812,
490
],
[
815,
472,
876,
490
],
[
123,
490,
174,
506
],
[
178,
490,
194,
507
],
[
198,
491,
219,
507
],
[
224,
491,
356,
507
],
[
360,
491,
451,
507
],
[
455,
491,
497,
507
],
[
502,
491,
565,
507
],
[
569,
491,
587,
507
],
[
590,
491,
615,
507
],
[
619,
491,
678,
507
],
[
682,
491,
754,
507
],
[
758,
490,
871,
507
],
[
124,
508,
146,
524
],
[
149,
508,
175,
524
],
[
178,
508,
231,
524
],
[
234,
508,
252,
525
],
[
255,
508,
333,
525
],
[
336,
508,
387,
525
],
[
390,
508,
420,
525
],
[
423,
508,
497,
525
],
[
500,
508,
585,
525
],
[
588,
508,
667,
525
],
[
670,
508,
688,
525
],
[
691,
508,
721,
525
],
[
724,
508,
794,
525
],
[
797,
508,
828,
525
],
[
831,
508,
860,
525
],
[
123,
525,
214,
542
],
[
218,
526,
241,
542
],
[
245,
526,
312,
542
],
[
316,
526,
343,
543
],
[
346,
526,
400,
543
],
[
404,
526,
476,
543
],
[
480,
526,
590,
543
],
[
593,
526,
609,
542
],
[
613,
526,
672,
542
],
[
675,
525,
756,
542
],
[
759,
525,
775,
541
],
[
778,
524,
855,
541
],
[
123,
543,
175,
559
],
[
179,
543,
252,
560
],
[
256,
544,
345,
560
],
[
349,
544,
427,
560
],
[
431,
544,
459,
560
],
[
463,
544,
504,
560
],
[
508,
544,
596,
560
],
[
600,
543,
675,
559
],
[
678,
543,
802,
559
],
[
805,
542,
822,
558
],
[
123,
561,
213,
578
],
[
217,
561,
262,
578
],
[
266,
561,
348,
578
],
[
352,
561,
408,
578
],
[
411,
561,
480,
578
],
[
484,
561,
553,
578
],
[
557,
561,
573,
577
],
[
577,
561,
612,
577
],
[
617,
561,
692,
577
],
[
696,
561,
727,
576
],
[
731,
561,
782,
576
],
[
786,
561,
802,
576
],
[
807,
561,
829,
576
],
[
124,
577,
175,
594
],
[
179,
577,
244,
594
],
[
248,
577,
266,
595
],
[
270,
577,
358,
595
],
[
363,
578,
424,
595
],
[
428,
578,
478,
595
],
[
482,
578,
496,
595
],
[
500,
578,
527,
595
],
[
531,
577,
606,
595
],
[
610,
577,
693,
595
],
[
697,
576,
758,
594
],
[
762,
576,
824,
594
],
[
827,
575,
874,
594
],
[
123,
596,
203,
611
],
[
207,
596,
293,
612
],
[
296,
596,
327,
612
],
[
330,
596,
358,
612
],
[
362,
596,
420,
612
],
[
424,
596,
497,
612
],
[
500,
596,
522,
612
],
[
526,
596,
575,
612
],
[
578,
596,
611,
612
],
[
615,
595,
651,
612
],
[
653,
595,
741,
612
],
[
744,
595,
761,
611
],
[
764,
595,
849,
611
],
[
852,
595,
869,
611
],
[
124,
613,
185,
629
],
[
189,
613,
229,
629
],
[
233,
613,
293,
629
],
[
296,
613,
374,
629
],
[
378,
613,
414,
629
],
[
418,
613,
472,
629
],
[
475,
614,
558,
630
],
[
181,
646,
198,
662
],
[
202,
646,
280,
663
],
[
284,
646,
310,
663
],
[
313,
647,
371,
663
],
[
374,
647,
382,
663
],
[
385,
647,
424,
663
],
[
427,
647,
470,
663
],
[
475,
647,
506,
663
],
[
509,
646,
615,
663
],
[
619,
646,
644,
662
],
[
648,
646,
678,
662
],
[
681,
646,
717,
662
],
[
720,
645,
737,
662
],
[
741,
645,
763,
662
],
[
766,
645,
794,
661
],
[
124,
664,
228,
679
],
[
232,
664,
261,
679
],
[
265,
664,
289,
679
],
[
293,
664,
320,
679
],
[
323,
664,
390,
680
],
[
394,
664,
410,
680
],
[
414,
664,
447,
680
],
[
451,
664,
478,
680
],
[
482,
663,
534,
680
],
[
537,
663,
584,
679
],
[
587,
663,
640,
679
],
[
643,
663,
706,
679
],
[
710,
663,
739,
679
],
[
743,
662,
777,
679
],
[
781,
662,
803,
679
],
[
123,
680,
222,
696
],
[
226,
680,
260,
696
],
[
264,
680,
323,
697
],
[
326,
680,
353,
697
],
[
357,
680,
431,
697
],
[
435,
680,
453,
697
],
[
456,
680,
550,
697
],
[
554,
680,
577,
697
],
[
580,
680,
619,
697
],
[
622,
680,
639,
696
],
[
642,
680,
721,
696
],
[
724,
679,
774,
696
],
[
777,
679,
829,
695
],
[
832,
679,
852,
695
],
[
124,
696,
183,
714
],
[
187,
697,
240,
714
],
[
244,
697,
278,
714
],
[
282,
697,
299,
714
],
[
303,
697,
329,
714
],
[
333,
697,
371,
714
],
[
375,
697,
404,
714
],
[
408,
697,
477,
714
],
[
481,
698,
541,
714
],
[
545,
698,
563,
714
],
[
567,
698,
625,
714
],
[
629,
698,
665,
714
],
[
669,
698,
706,
714
],
[
710,
698,
763,
714
],
[
767,
698,
847,
714
],
[
851,
698,
868,
713
],
[
123,
714,
148,
732
],
[
152,
714,
198,
732
],
[
202,
715,
241,
732
],
[
245,
715,
260,
732
],
[
265,
715,
285,
733
],
[
289,
715,
348,
733
],
[
352,
715,
368,
733
],
[
372,
715,
401,
733
],
[
405,
715,
431,
733
],
[
435,
715,
456,
733
],
[
460,
715,
499,
733
],
[
503,
715,
520,
733
],
[
523,
715,
548,
733
],
[
552,
715,
629,
733
],
[
633,
715,
651,
733
],
[
655,
714,
711,
733
],
[
714,
714,
782,
732
],
[
786,
714,
811,
732
],
[
123,
732,
211,
749
],
[
215,
733,
232,
749
],
[
235,
733,
261,
749
],
[
265,
733,
344,
750
],
[
348,
733,
411,
750
],
[
414,
733,
425,
750
],
[
428,
733,
481,
750
],
[
485,
733,
517,
750
],
[
521,
733,
566,
750
],
[
570,
733,
660,
750
],
[
664,
732,
727,
750
],
[
731,
732,
747,
749
],
[
751,
731,
854,
749
],
[
858,
731,
873,
748
],
[
123,
750,
213,
767
],
[
217,
750,
278,
767
],
[
282,
750,
323,
768
],
[
326,
750,
342,
768
],
[
345,
750,
414,
768
],
[
418,
750,
436,
768
],
[
439,
750,
449,
768
],
[
452,
750,
507,
768
],
[
510,
750,
521,
768
],
[
524,
750,
564,
768
],
[
568,
750,
676,
768
],
[
679,
750,
709,
768
],
[
713,
750,
751,
767
],
[
754,
750,
770,
767
],
[
776,
750,
841,
767
],
[
121,
768,
226,
784
],
[
231,
768,
267,
785
],
[
270,
768,
310,
785
],
[
314,
769,
331,
785
],
[
335,
769,
371,
785
],
[
375,
769,
430,
785
],
[
434,
769,
518,
785
],
[
522,
769,
550,
785
],
[
554,
769,
582,
785
],
[
586,
769,
621,
785
],
[
625,
769,
662,
785
],
[
667,
768,
692,
785
],
[
696,
768,
733,
784
],
[
737,
768,
766,
784
],
[
770,
767,
839,
784
],
[
843,
767,
879,
783
],
[
124,
785,
170,
801
],
[
173,
786,
224,
802
],
[
228,
786,
248,
802
],
[
251,
786,
347,
802
],
[
352,
786,
457,
802
],
[
461,
786,
497,
802
],
[
503,
786,
533,
802
],
[
537,
786,
567,
802
],
[
571,
786,
624,
802
],
[
628,
786,
710,
802
],
[
714,
786,
731,
802
],
[
736,
786,
763,
802
],
[
767,
786,
829,
802
],
[
834,
785,
871,
801
],
[
124,
803,
174,
819
],
[
177,
803,
194,
819
],
[
198,
803,
248,
819
],
[
252,
803,
291,
819
],
[
296,
803,
311,
819
],
[
314,
803,
324,
819
],
[
327,
803,
368,
819
],
[
372,
803,
390,
819
],
[
393,
803,
473,
819
],
[
477,
803,
486,
819
],
[
490,
803,
531,
819
],
[
534,
803,
548,
819
],
[
551,
803,
582,
819
],
[
585,
803,
637,
819
],
[
641,
803,
654,
819
],
[
658,
802,
704,
819
],
[
707,
802,
723,
819
],
[
727,
802,
765,
819
],
[
768,
802,
781,
819
],
[
784,
802,
829,
818
],
[
833,
802,
865,
818
],
[
122,
820,
211,
836
],
[
215,
820,
285,
836
],
[
288,
820,
334,
836
],
[
339,
820,
377,
836
],
[
381,
820,
407,
836
],
[
411,
820,
451,
836
],
[
456,
820,
472,
836
],
[
476,
820,
488,
836
],
[
492,
820,
518,
836
],
[
522,
820,
632,
836
],
[
636,
820,
686,
836
],
[
690,
820,
734,
836
],
[
738,
820,
747,
835
],
[
751,
819,
839,
835
],
[
133,
854,
156,
869
],
[
159,
855,
201,
869
],
[
205,
855,
219,
870
],
[
223,
855,
305,
870
],
[
309,
856,
349,
870
],
[
353,
856,
419,
871
],
[
422,
856,
470,
871
],
[
474,
856,
545,
871
],
[
548,
856,
566,
871
],
[
570,
855,
635,
871
],
[
638,
855,
678,
870
],
[
681,
855,
720,
870
],
[
724,
855,
731,
870
],
[
734,
854,
800,
870
],
[
803,
853,
869,
870
],
[
124,
870,
147,
884
],
[
150,
870,
217,
884
],
[
219,
870,
260,
885
],
[
263,
870,
304,
885
],
[
307,
870,
383,
886
],
[
387,
870,
446,
886
],
[
449,
870,
489,
886
],
[
492,
870,
528,
886
],
[
531,
870,
552,
886
],
[
556,
870,
619,
886
],
[
622,
870,
656,
886
],
[
659,
871,
727,
885
],
[
730,
871,
760,
885
],
[
766,
871,
786,
885
],
[
789,
871,
816,
884
],
[
123,
885,
219,
899
],
[
222,
885,
235,
899
],
[
238,
885,
265,
899
],
[
269,
885,
310,
899
],
[
313,
885,
348,
899
],
[
351,
884,
380,
900
],
[
383,
884,
405,
900
],
[
408,
884,
449,
900
],
[
452,
884,
512,
900
],
[
514,
884,
562,
900
],
[
565,
884,
590,
900
],
[
592,
884,
630,
900
],
[
633,
884,
660,
900
],
[
663,
884,
686,
900
],
[
690,
884,
748,
900
],
[
751,
884,
774,
899
],
[
777,
884,
818,
899
],
[
821,
884,
877,
899
],
[
124,
900,
199,
913
],
[
202,
900,
271,
915
],
[
224,
981,
290,
997
],
[
294,
980,
779,
997
]
] |
Who is designated as agency ethics official and acting general counsel ?
|
Kevin S. Minoli
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.