<!doctypehtml><html class="header-spacing spacing"lang=en-US><meta charset=utf-8><meta content=IE=edge http-equiv=X-UA-Compatible><meta content=telephone=no name=format-detection><meta content=width=device-width,initial-scale=1.0 id=ovp name=viewport><script>if ( document.location.hostname.match(/\.$/) ) {
              document.location.replace(
                  document.location.protocol +
                  '//' +
                  document.location.hostname.replace(/\.+$/, '') +
                  ( undefined !== document.location.pathname ? document.location.pathname : '' ) +
                  ( undefined !== document.location.search ? document.location.search : '' )  +
                  ( undefined !== document.location.hash ? document.location.hash : '' )
              );
          }</script><script>var HDN = HDN || {}; HDN.t_firstbyte = Number(new Date());</script><script id=hnpprivacy src=/hdn/dynamic/hnpprivacy-min.js></script><script>// <![CDATA[

        var HDN = HDN || {};
        HDN.dataLayer = HDN.dataLayer || {};

        // HDN.dataLayer object for content and href data
        HDN.dataLayer.content = HDN.dataLayer.content || {};
        HDN.dataLayer.href = HDN.dataLayer.href || {};

    

        HDN.dataLayer.content.sectionPath = ['page not found'];
        HDN.dataLayer.content.title = "page not found";
        HDN.dataLayer.content.objectId = "404PNF";
        HDN.dataLayer.content.objectType = "page not found";
        HDN.dataLayer.content.pubDate = "2021-10-31  1:07:31";

        HDN.dataLayer.href.pageUrl = window.location.href;
        HDN.dataLayer.href.canonicalUrl = window.location.href;
        HDN.dataLayer.href.pageUrlPath = window.location.pathname;
        HDN.dataLayer.href.pageUrlPathFolders = window.location.pathname.replace(/[A-Za-z0-9-_.]+$/, '');
        HDN.dataLayer.href.pageUrlQueryParams = window.location.search.replace(/^\?/, '');
        HDN.dataLayer.href.pageUrlHash = window.location.hash;
        HDN.dataLayer.site.amazonTag = 'hearstnp-sfg-20';
    HDN.dataLayer.site.skimlinksPublisherId = '131678X1594033';

HDN.abData = {};
    

(function () {
    var findAbNames = function() {
        var cookies=document.cookie.split(';');
        var c,s,t;
        for ( var asdf = 0 ; asdf < cookies.length ; asdf++ ) {
            c = cookies[asdf].trim();
            if ( 0 === c.indexOf('ab_name_') ) {
                s = c.split('=');
                if ( 2 === s.length ) {
                    HDN.abData['_hasData'] = 1;
                    if ( undefined === HDN.abData[s[0].substr(8)] ) {
                        HDN.abData[s[0].substr(8)] = ( 'A' === s[1] ? 'C' : 'V1' );
                    }
                }
            }
        }
    };
    findAbNames();
    if ( HDN.abData['_hasData'] ) {
        delete(HDN.abData['_hasData']);

        HDN.dataLayer.abtest = HDN.dataLayer.abtest || {};
        HDN.dataLayer.abtest.experimentId = HDN.dataLayer.abtest.experimentId || [];
        window.aps = window.aps || {};
        window.aps.abtest = window.aps.abtest || '';

        var abDataTmp = []
        for ( var abDataKey in HDN.abData ) {
            abDataTmp.push(abDataKey + '_' + HDN.abData[abDataKey]);
        }

        HDN.dataLayer.abtest.experimentId = HDN.dataLayer.abtest.experimentId.concat(abDataTmp);
        if ( window.aps.abtest ) {
            window.aps.abtest += ',';
        }
        window.aps.abtest += abDataTmp.join(',');
    }
})();



if ( HDN.activeABTest &&
     HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles ) {
    if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files ) {
         if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.css &&
              HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.css['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_css'] ) {
             (function () {
                 var l = document.createElement('link');
                 l.rel = 'stylesheet';
                 l.type = 'text/css';
                 l.media = 'all';
                 l.href = HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.css['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_css'];
                 document.head.appendChild(l);
             })();
         }
         if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.js &&
              HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.js['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_js'] ) {
             (function () {
                var s = document.createElement('script');
                s.src = HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.files.js['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_js'];
                s.async = false;
                s.defer = true;
                document.head.appendChild(s);
             })();
         }
    }
    if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.items ) {
         if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.items['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_css'] ) {
             (function () {
                 var s = document.createElement('style');
                 s.id = HDN.activeABTest + '_css_style_element';
                 s.type = 'text/css';
                 s.appendChild(document.createTextNode(HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.items['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_css']));
                 document.head.appendChild(s);
             })();
         }
         if ( HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.items['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_js'] ) {
             (function () {
                 var s = document.createElement('script');
                 s.text = HDN.dataLayer.abTestProfiles.items['profiles_' + HDN.activeABTest + '_js'];
                 document.head.appendChild(s);
             })();
         }
    }
}

    // ]]></script><script src=/js/hdn/utils/polyfill.min.js></script><script src=/js/hdn/utils/modernizr-2.6.2.min.js?v12.4.3></script><style>@media only screen and (min-width: 47.5rem) {.bg-ad-on #subHead {transform: unset !important;}}
@media only screen and (min-width: 68.25rem) {.bg-ad-on #siteNav {transform: unset !important;}}</style><script>document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function () { setTimeout(function () { responsiveAds(); }, 14000); }, false);</script><style>.fullwidth > .twitter-tweet {
        width: 100% !important;
    }</style><style>.mostPopular { display: none; }
    .article .mostPopular,
    .slideshow .mostPopular { display: block; }
    @media only screen and (min-width: 81.5rem) { body.search #content { margin: 0 auto; width: 1304px; } }</style><script>window._taboolaNetworkMode = true;</script><meta content=SKYPE_TOOLBAR_PARSER_COMPATIBLE name=SKYPE_TOOLBAR><script>// <![CDATA[
        bizobject_identifier = "";
        var requestTime = new Date(1635703651 * 1000);

                var omni_channelPath = "page not found";
        var omni_title = "page not found";
        var omni_bizObjectId = "404PNF";
        var omni_className = "page not found";
        var omni_publicationDate = "2021-10-31  1:07:31";
                // ]]></script><title>
   Article - SFGATE
  </title><link rel="SHORTCUT ICON"href=/favicon.ico><link href=/apple-touch-icon.png rel=apple-touch-icon sizes=60x60><link href=/apple-touch-icon-76x76.png rel=apple-touch-icon sizes=76x76><link href=/apple-touch-icon-120x120.png rel=apple-touch-icon sizes=120x120><link href=/apple-touch-icon-152x152.png rel=apple-touch-icon sizes=152x152><link href=/apple-touch-icon-128x128.png rel=apple-touch-icon-precomposed sizes=128x128><script src=/js/hdn/unification/modules/adTools.js></script><script>function hearstPlaceAd(){}</script><script id=adPositionManagerScriptTag src=https://aps.hearstnp.com/Scripts/loadAds.js></script><link href=/external/css/global.less.allPages.v12.4.3.css media=all rel=stylesheet><link href=/external/css/global.less.miscPages.v12.4.3.css media=all rel=stylesheet><script src=/external/js/global.allPages.v12.4.3.js></script><script async src=https://cdn.blueconic.net/hearst.js></script><script>document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
    var e = function(e) {
        if (window.innerWidth > 768) { return; }
        try {
            for (var t = 0; t < e.length; t++) {
                var n;
                if (document.getElementById(e[t]) !== null) {
                    n = document.getElementById(e[t]);
                } else if (document.getElementsByClassName(e[t])[0] !== undefined) {
                    n = document.getElementsByClassName(e[t])[0];
                }
                n.classList.add('taboolaSave');
            }
        } catch(err) {
            console.warn(err.message);
        }
    };
    var t = ['ctpl-mediumrectangle1', 'ctpl-mediumrectangle2', 'ctpl-mediumrectangle3', 'NTV7'];
    e(t);
    window.addEventListener('resize', function(event) { e(t); });
}, false);</script><script>if ( document.readyState === "complete" || (document.readyState !== "loading" && !document.documentElement.doScroll)) {
    addTaboolaClickClass();
} else {
    document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", function() { addTaboolaClickClass(); });
};
var addTaboolaClickClass = function () {
    var tbfrms = document.getElementsByClassName('taboola-frame');
    for (var i = 0; i < tbfrms.length; i++) {
        tbfrms.item(i).classList.add('.taboola-frame');
    }
};</script><script>// ENG-2780
window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
    // If there's an adhesion/MAD ad, then move the S2N player up by 50px
    if(document.getElementById("MAD") && document.getElementById("MAD").style.display !== "none" || document.getElementById("hst-adhesion") && document.getElementById("hst-adhesion").style.display !== "none") {
        if(document.getElementsByClassName("s2nPlayerFrame")[0]) {
          var bottom = parseInt(document.getElementsByClassName("s2nPlayerFrame")[0].style.bottom);
          document.getElementsByClassName("s2nPlayerFrame")[0].style.bottom = bottom + 50 + "px";
        }
    }
}, false);</script><script>// ENG-2955
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
    var stnplayer = document.getElementsByClassName("s2nPlayer");
    if(!('remove' in Element.prototype)) {
        Element.prototype['remove'] = function() {
            if(this.parentNode) {
                this.parentNode.removeChild(this);
            }
        };
    }
    if(stnplayer.length > 1) {
        for(var i = 1; i < stnplayer.length; i++) {
            if(stnplayer[i].parentNode.parentNode.classList.contains('asset-media')) {
                stnplayer[i].parentNode.parentNode.remove();
            }
            else {
                stnplayer[i].parentElement.remove();
            }
        }
    }
}, false);</script><style>/*ENG-2662*/
/*The flex style that was added to the centerpiece to allow 'real' columns is spilling onto */
/*Nativo ads. This code should fix just that issue and not affect the other tabs.*/
.core-centerpiece ul {
    display: block;
}</style><style>/*ENG-2662*/
/*The first tab in 2-tab centerpieces needs flex, it was */
/*missed or overridden in the original ticket. */
.centerpiece-tabs.total-2 .firstTab-true .list-container {
    display: flex;
}</style><script>(function () {
    try {
        window.HDN.dataLayer.site.galleryRatio = '3:2';
    } catch (e) {}
}());</script><style>.no-touch .hst-resgalleryitem .img-wrap,
.hst-resgalleryitem .img-wrap,
.hst-resgallery-container.in-motion .img-wrap.taboolaloader {
    height: auto !important;
    padding: 66.666667% 0 0 0 !important;
}
.hst-resgalleryitem .img-wrap.open-width {
    background-position: center;
    background-size: cover;
}
.hst-resgalleryitem .img-wrap.open-width img {
    visibility: hidden;
}
.hst-resgalleryitem .img-wrap.open-height img {
    max-height: none;
}
.no-touch .hst-resgallery-container .hst-resgallery-wedge {
    height: auto !important;
}
.no-touch .fullscreen .hst-resgallery-container .hst-resgallery-wedge {
    height: 100% !important;
}</style><style>.alert{background-color:#000;bottom:0;box-sizing:border-box;color:#fff;font-family:Helvetica,sans-serif;font-size:16px;font-weight:600;left:50%;line-height:1.25;overflow:hidden;padding:10px;position:fixed;transform:translateX(-50%);width:100vw;z-index:5000000}.alert .close{border-radius:8px;color:#fff;display:block;position:absolute;right:10px;height:16px;overflow:hidden;top:10px;width:16px}.alert .close::after{background-color:#fff;content:'';display:block;height:2px;left:-6px;position:relative;top:4px;transform:rotate(-45deg);width:30px}.alert .close::before{background-color:#fff;content:'';display:block;height:2px;left:-5px;position:relative;top:9px;transform:rotate(45deg);width:30px}.alert>div{box-sizing:border-box;max-width:1200px;margin:0 auto;position:relative;padding-right:34px}</style><script>document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
    if (/MSIE \d|Trident.*rv:/.test(navigator.userAgent)) {var site=HDN.domain,name=site.charAt(0).toUpperCase()+site.slice(1),section=document.createElement("section"),close=document.createElement("a");close.className="close",close.href="#",close.addEventListener("click",function(e){e.stopPropagation(),e.preventDefault(),e.target.parentElement.style.display="none"});var HTML="<div>Thank you for visiting "+name+". You are using an older browser that may impact your reading experience. For the best experience, we recommend you use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge.</div>";section.className="alert",section.id="warning",section.innerHTML=HTML,section.appendChild(close),document.getElementsByTagName("body")[0].appendChild(section);}
  }, false);</script><style>.article-body { 
    position: relative;
}</style><script>$(document).ready(function () {
		$("#nativo-latest-news").removeAttr("id");
		$(".twelve-2").attr("id", "nativo-latest-news");
	});</script><style>.menu-bar.off-screen {top: 0};
.search .autocomplete-suggestions {top: 170px !important;}

/* CFREE-7531 */
.hst-articletext img { height: auto;}</style><style>.hst-resgallery-container .control-bar .overlaylink.fullscreen, .hst-resgallery-container .control-bar .overlaylink.thumbs, .hst-lvgallery-container .control-bar .share-toggle, .hst-resgallery-container .control-bar .share-toggle {
    box-sizing: content-box;
}

/* ad hotfix */
iframe[id*='google_ads_iframe_/36117602/hnp-sfgate.com/News_5'][width*='970'][height*='415']{display:none!important;}

/* SUP-764 */
.article-content { float: left !important; }</style><script>document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function(){ 
    var sweeper = function(ele) {
        console.log(ele.length)
    }
    var items = ['taboola-right-rail-thumbnails', 'most-popular'];
    sweeper(items)
}, false);</script><script>/* NPDATA-3254 */

if (HDN.dataLayer.content.objectId == "19773" && document.location.pathname == "/") {
    HDN.dataLayer.content.objectType = "home page";
}</script><script>ga("create", "UA-1616916-22","auto", "stn");
window.addEventListener("message",function(event) {
    if(event.data.type == "s2nEvent" && event.data.s2nEvent == "readyToPlay") {
        console.log("***** readyToPlay @ "  + performance.now()/1000 + " ******");
        ga("stn.send",  {
            hitType: "event",
            eventCategory: "Experimental",
            eventAction: "readyToPlay",
            eventLabel: event.data.playerKey,
            eventValue: Math.round((performance.now()/1000),2),
            nonInteraction: true,
            dimension5: HDN.dataLayer.content.objectType
        });
    }
});</script><script>(function () {
    if (window.HDN && HDN.dataLayer && HDN.dataLayer.content) {
        var _hdn = HDN.dataLayer.content;
        if (_hdn.hasOwnProperty('objectType') && _hdn.objectType === 'slideshow') {
            if (_hdn.hasOwnProperty('galleryListType') && _hdn.galleryListType === 'list') {
                var hfs = document.createElement('style');
                hfs.innerHTML = '#subscription { display: none;'
                document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(hfs);
            }
        }
    }
})();</script><script>document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
    if (HDN.dataLayer.hasOwnProperty('revenueProfiles') && !document.querySelector("[data-type='dtc']")) {
      var a = HDN.dataLayer.revenueProfiles.profiles.nonsub.interstitials.value.split(',');
      if (a.length) {
        setTimeout(function() { window.hearstRefreshInterstitialAds(a); }, 500);
      }
    }
  }, false);</script><meta content=9451CA04ABC9D1D5C6419C73B4C4F7B7 name=msvalidate.01><script src=//treg.hearstnp.com/treg.js></script><script src=https://nexus.ensighten.com/hearst/news/Bootstrap.js></script><body class="sfgate article"location><header><div class=ctpl-fullbanner data-collapse-timer=10 id=ctpl-fullbanner1><div class=ad_deferrable id=A728><script>/*<![CDATA[*/ hearstPlaceAd("A728"); /*]]>*/</script></div></div><div class=subHead id=subHead><div class=innerWrap><div class=weatherWrapper><div class=weather__current-forecast><a href=/weather/> <div class=condition><span class=icon data-class=icon> </span></div> <span data-unit-english="° F"data-unit-metric="° C"class=temp data-key=temp> </span> </a><span class=city data-location=city tabindex=0> </span><p id=weatherChange></div><div class=weatherChange><span class=icon> </span></div></div><form action=/search/? class=searchWrapper id=search_form target=_top><input name=action type=hidden value=search><input name=firstRequest type=hidden value=1><input name=searchindex type=hidden value=solr><input class=textInputNote id=search_query name=query placeholder=Search><input class=submit disabled tabindex=0 type=submit value=Go><button type=reset></button></form><div class=socialWrapper><ul><li class="socialIcon facebook"><a href=https://www.facebook.com/SFGate/ target=_blank> <span class=icon> </span> </a><li class="socialIcon twitter"><a href=https://twitter.com/sfgate/ target=_blank> <span class=icon> </span> </a><li class="socialIcon instagram"><a href=https://instagram.com/sfgate/ target=_blank> <span class=icon> </span> </a><li class="socialIcon pinterest"><a href=https://www.pinterest.com/sfgate/ target=_blank> <span class=icon> </span> </a><li class="socialIcon rss"><a href=/rss/> <span class=icon> </span> </a><li class="treg-is-gigya gigya_menu"><div class="gya-title expandable treg-conditional treg-not-logged-in"><span tabindex=0> Sign In </span></div> <div class="gya-title expandable treg-conditional treg-logged-in"><span tabindex=0> </span></div> <div class="gya-content expandable"><div class=treg-gya-login-widget></div></div> </ul></div></div></div><nav class="site-nav menu-slide"id=siteNav role=navigation><div class=innerWrap><ul class=topnav role=menu><li class="subMenuContainer homeLink home"location=home><a class="subMenuLink homeLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Home|navigation-www|1 href=/ role=menuitem> <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> <span aria-label="Homepage - Site Logo"class=logo role=img> </span> <span class=label> Home </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home hasSubmenu"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=979 href=/aboutsfgate/ role=menuitem> About SFGATE <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <div class=submenu><ul class=submenuUlList><li class=desktop><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE|navigation-www|1"aria-haspopup=true data-naveid=979 href=/aboutsfgate/> About SFGATE </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE-SFGate Newsletters|navigation-www|2"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=979 href=https://link.sfgate.com/join/signup-sfgate> SFGate Newsletters </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE-SFGate Staff|navigation-www|3"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=979 href=/staff/> SFGate Staff </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE-Careers|navigation-www|4"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=979 href=/chronicle/hr/> Careers </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE-Site Index|navigation-www|5"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=979 href=/index/> Site Index </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-About SFGATE-Hearst|navigation-www|6"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=979 href=http://www.hearst.com/> Hearst </a></ul></div><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Contact SFGATE|navigation-www|2"data-naveid=979 href=/chronicle-contacts/ role=menuitem> Contact SFGATE </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Home-Newsletters|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=979 href=https://link.sfgate.com/join/signup-sfgate role=menuitem> Newsletters </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Ethics Policy|navigation-www|4"data-naveid=979 href=https://www.sfgate.com/file/752/8/7528-Hearst_Newspaper_Group_Standards_and_Ethics_Policy.pdf role=menuitem target=_blank> Ethics Policy </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Advertise With Us|navigation-www|5"data-naveid=979 href=https://marketing.sfgate.com/advertise-with-us-today?utm_source=sfgate role=menuitem> Advertise With Us </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Privacy Notice / Notice At Collection|navigation-www|6"data-naveid=979 href=/privacy-policy/ role=menuitem> Privacy Notice / Notice At Collection </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Terms of Use|navigation-www|7"data-naveid=979 href=/termsandconditions/ role=menuitem> Terms of Use </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Ad Choices|navigation-www|8"data-naveid=979 href=http://www.aboutads.info/choices/ role=menuitem> Ad Choices </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Home-Classifieds|navigation-www|9 data-naveid=979 href=http://sfc.ipublishmarketplace.com/sf-marketplace/ role=menuitem> Classifieds </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics home"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Home-Do Not Sell My Personal Info|navigation-www|10"data-naveid=979 href=/mydata/ role=menuitem> Do Not Sell My Personal Info </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|link-28249|Home-nav-hcat|1 href=http://www.sfgate.com/newsletters role=menuitem> <img alt="Sign up for SFGATE Newsletters - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/05/51/07/18256357/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Sign up for SFGATE Newsletters</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|link-77323|Home-nav-hcat|2 href=https://www.facebook.com/SFGate/ role=menuitem> <img alt="Follow SFGATE on Facebook - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/01/53/17/17216501/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Follow SFGATE on Facebook</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|link-77324|Home-nav-hcat|3 href=https://marketing.sfgate.com/advertise-with-us-today role=menuitem> <img alt="Advertise with SFGATE - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/75/07/22/16020633/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Advertise with SFGATE</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer news"location=news><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|News|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=978 href=/news/ role=menuitem> News <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news hasSubmenu"data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=978 href=/bayarea role=menuitem> Bay Area <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <div class=submenu><ul class=submenuUlList><li class=desktop><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area|navigation-www|1"aria-haspopup=true data-naveid=978 href=/bayarea> Bay Area </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area-Earthquakes|navigation-www|1"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/earthquakes> Earthquakes </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area-Expensive SF|navigation-www|2"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/expensive-san-francisco/> Expensive SF </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area-Arrest Records|navigation-www|3"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/arrestrecords/san_francisco/> Arrest Records </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Bay Area-SF History|navigation-www|4"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/sfhistory/> SF History </a></ul></div><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-California|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=978 href=/california-news/ role=menuitem> California </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Nation|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=978 href=/nation/ role=menuitem> Nation </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-World|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=978 href=/world/ role=menuitem> World </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Crime|navigation-www|5 data-naveid=978 href=/crime/ role=menuitem> Crime </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-California Wildfires|navigation-www|6"data-naveid=978 href=/california-wildfires/ role=menuitem> California Wildfires </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news hasSubmenu"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Business|navigation-www|7 data-naveid=978 href=/business/ role=menuitem> Business <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <div class=submenu><ul class=submenuUlList><li class=desktop><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Business|navigation-www|7 data-naveid=978 href=/business/> Business </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Business-Business Section|navigation-www|1"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/business/> Business Section </a><li><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Business-Technology|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=978 href=/tech/> Technology </a><li><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Business-Jobs|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=978 href=/z-archived-jobs/> Jobs </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Business-Public Notices|navigation-www|4"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=http://www.legalnotice.org/pl/SFGate/landing1.aspx?ipid=publicnoticesnav> Public Notices </a><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Business-MBA by the Bay|navigation-www|5"class=hdn-analytics data-naveid=978 href=/mba/> MBA by the Bay </a><li><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Business-VisionSF|navigation-www|6 data-naveid=978 href=http://www.sfchronicle.com/visionsf> VisionSF </a></ul></div><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Weather|navigation-www|8 data-naveid=978 href=/weather/ role=menuitem> Weather </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Education|navigation-www|9 data-naveid=978 href=/education/ role=menuitem> Education </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics="visit|News-Sponsored Content|navigation-www|10"data-naveid=978 href=/sponsoredarticles/business/ role=menuitem> Sponsored Content </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Health|navigation-www|11 data-naveid=978 href=/health role=menuitem> Health </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics news"data-hdn-analytics=visit|News-Jobs|navigation-www|12 data-naveid=978 href=/jobs/ role=menuitem> Jobs </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16578584|News-nav-hcat|1 href=/news/article/The-Latest-G20-leaders-toss-coins-into-Trevi-16578584.php role=menuitem> <img alt="The Latest: France's Macron praises G-20 progress on climate - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/21/21652557/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>The Latest: France's Macron praises G-20 progress on climate</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16579019|News-nav-hcat|2 href=/news/article/19-Kids-and-Counting-father-running-for-16579019.php role=menuitem> <img alt="'19 Kids and Counting' father running for Arkansas Senate - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/17/21652454/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>'19 Kids and Counting' father running for Arkansas Senate</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16578356|News-nav-hcat|3 href=/news/article/At-Rome-summit-Biden-seeks-fixes-for-supply-16578356.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Biden unveils new steps to strengthen global supply chains - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/20/21652542/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Biden unveils new steps to strengthen global supply chains</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16578829|News-nav-hcat|4 href=/news/article/Plan-to-replace-Minneapolis-PD-worries-many-Black-16578829.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Plan to replace Minneapolis PD worries many Black residents - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/14/21652264/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Plan to replace Minneapolis PD worries many Black residents</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer local"location=local><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|Local|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=5392 href=/local/ role=menuitem> Local <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics local"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Local-SF History|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=5392 href=/sfhistory/ role=menuitem> SF History </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics local"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Local-Businesses|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=5392 href=/sf-businesses/ role=menuitem> Businesses </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics local"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Local-Places|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=5392 href=/places/ role=menuitem> Places </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics local"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Local-Essays|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=5392 href=/essays/ role=menuitem> Essays </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics local"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Local-Sponsored Content|navigation-www|5"data-naveid=5392 href=/sponsoredarticles/lifestyle role=menuitem> Sponsored Content </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16444449|Local-nav-hcat|1 href=/bayarea/article/UC-Berkeley-Forbes-list-top-university-16444449.php role=menuitem> <img alt="UC Berkeley is the first public university to top Forbes best colleges list - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/11/22/62/19213446/5/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>UC Berkeley is the first public university to top Forbes best</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16408845|Local-nav-hcat|2 href=/living/article/Chubby-llama-Muir-Beach-walk-John-Koene-16408845.php role=menuitem> <img alt="A llama named Chubby is the unexpected star of the SF Bay Area's Muir Beach - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/21/45/63/21388505/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>A llama named Chubby is the unexpected star of the SF Bay Area's</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-15752114|Local-nav-hcat|3 href=/local/article/retail-workers-holiday-shopping-covid-Black-Friday-15752114.php role=menuitem> <img alt="What Bay Area retail workers want you to know about holiday shopping this year - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/15/35/43/20306132/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>What Bay Area retail workers want you to know about holiday</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-15734855|Local-nav-hcat|4 href=/sports/article/I-tried-to-ride-an-electric-bike-up-SF-s-steepest-15734855.php role=menuitem> <img alt="I tried to ride an electric bike up SF's steepest street. Here's what happened. - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/15/26/03/20275416/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>I tried to ride an electric bike up SF's steepest street. Here's</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer politics"location=politics><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Politics|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=994 href=/politics/> Politics </a><li class="subMenuContainer sports"location=sports><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports|navigation-www|5 data-naveid=980 href=/sports/ role=menuitem> Sports <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-49ers|navigation-www|1 data-naveid=980 href=/49ers/ role=menuitem> 49ers </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-Giants|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=980 href=/giants/ role=menuitem> Giants </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-A's|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=980 href=/athletics/ role=menuitem> A's </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-Warriors|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=980 href=/warriors/ role=menuitem> Warriors </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-Soccer|navigation-www|5 data-naveid=980 href=/quakes/ role=menuitem> Soccer </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-Sharks|navigation-www|6 data-naveid=980 href=/sharks/ role=menuitem> Sharks </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Sports-TV Listings|navigation-www|7"data-naveid=980 href=/sports/tv/ role=menuitem> TV Listings </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-College|navigation-www|8 data-naveid=980 href=/collegesports/ role=menuitem> College </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics sports"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Sports-Preps|navigation-www|9 data-naveid=980 href=/preps/ role=menuitem> Preps </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16577538|Sports-nav-hcat|1 href=/warriors-column/article/warriors-capitanes-g-league-debut-essay-16577538.php role=menuitem> <img alt="I drove two hours to watch a G League preseason game between the Warriors' affiliate and a Mexico City newcomer. Here's why. - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/45/52/21650083/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>I drove two hours to watch a G League preseason game between the</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16577600|Sports-nav-hcat|2 href=/collegesports/article/Aaron-Rodgers-calls-out-Cal-jeff-tedford-tribute-16577600.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Bay Area legend Aaron Rodgers calls out Cal for last-minute Jeff Tedford tribute - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/45/51/21650001/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Bay Area legend Aaron Rodgers calls out Cal for last-minute Jeff</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16575910|Sports-nav-hcat|3 href=/49ers/article/49ers-2020-first-round-pick-Javon-Kinlaw-injured-16575910.php role=menuitem> <img alt="49ers 2020 first-round pick Javon Kinlaw, who long denied being injured, is out for season after knee surgery - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/70/21646866/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>49ers 2020 first-round pick Javon Kinlaw, who long denied being</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16575380|Sports-nav-hcat|4 href=/warriors/article/Warriors-Moses-Moody-headed-to-g-league-16575380.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Warriors' Moses Moody joins Spurs' Josh Primo as only 2021 lottery picks assigned to NBA G League - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/46/21645742/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Warriors' Moses Moody joins Spurs' Josh Primo as only 2021</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer culture"location=culture><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture|navigation-www|6 data-naveid=5388 href=/sf-culture/ role=menuitem> culture <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture-Movies|navigation-www|1 data-naveid=5388 href=/movies/ role=menuitem> Movies </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture-Music|navigation-www|2 data-naveid=5388 href=/music/ role=menuitem> Music </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture-Streaming|navigation-www|3 data-naveid=5388 href=/streaming/ role=menuitem> Streaming </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture-Characters|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=5388 href=/characters/ role=menuitem> Characters </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics="visit|culture-Tech & Social Media|navigation-www|5"data-naveid=5388 href=/tech/ role=menuitem> Tech & Social Media </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics="visit|culture-Things To Do|navigation-www|6"data-naveid=5388 href=/things-to-do/ role=menuitem> Things To Do </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics="visit|culture-Sponsored: SF Culture|navigation-www|7"data-naveid=5388 href=https://blog.sfgate.com/lifestyle/ role=menuitem> Sponsored: SF Culture </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics=visit|culture-Cannabis|navigation-www|8 data-naveid=5388 href=/cannabis role=menuitem> Cannabis </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics culture"data-hdn-analytics="visit|culture-Senior Living|navigation-www|9"data-naveid=5388 href=/senior-living/ role=menuitem> Senior Living </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16579116|culture-nav-hcat|1 href=/culture-events/article/Outside-Lands-headliner-Lizzo-does-Squid-Game-16579116.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Outside Lands headliner Lizzo does 'Squid Game' Halloween montage in San Francisco - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/03/21651681/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Outside Lands headliner Lizzo does 'Squid Game' Halloween montage</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16579083|culture-nav-hcat|2 href=/culture-events/article/outside-lands-2021-reggie-watts-ketamine-16579083.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Marc Rebillet cancels Outside Lands show, Reggie Watts take his place and endorses medicinal ketamine - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/20/21652523/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Marc Rebillet cancels Outside Lands show, Reggie Watts take his</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16578976|culture-nav-hcat|3 href=/sf-culture/article/Outside-Lands-Andrew-McMahon-Cecilia-Satellite-16578976.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Outside Lands artist brings daughter onto stage, crowd swoons - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/17/21652451/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Outside Lands artist brings daughter onto stage, crowd swoons</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|channel-17036|culture-nav-hcat|4 href=/dearabby/ role=menuitem> <img alt="The latest from Dear Abby - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/43/62/37/9381871/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>The latest from Dear Abby</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer food+drink"location=food+drink><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Food + Drink|navigation-www|7"aria-haspopup=true data-naveid=983 href=/food/ role=menuitem> Food + Drink <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics food+drink"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Food + Drink-Restaurants|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=983 href=/restaurants/ role=menuitem> Restaurants </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics food+drink"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Food + Drink-Reservations|navigation-www|2"data-naveid=983 href=http://www.opentable.com/start.aspx?m=4&ref=7801 role=menuitem> Reservations </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics food+drink"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Food + Drink-Beer News|navigation-www|3"data-naveid=983 href=/bars/ role=menuitem> Beer News </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16575017|Food + Drink-nav-hcat|1"class=hdn-analytics href=/food/article/Farleys-coffee-is-potrero-hill-gathering-place-16575017.php role=menuitem> <img alt="How Farley’s Coffee became Potrero Hill’s ‘third place’ - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/56/21646209/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>How Farley’s Coffee became Potrero Hill’s ‘third place’</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16575668|Food + Drink-nav-hcat|2"class=hdn-analytics href=/restaurants/article/San-Francisco-s-historic-North-Beach-16575668.php role=menuitem> <img alt="San Francisco's historic North Beach restaurant, around since the 1890s, has closed - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/55/21646204/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>San Francisco's historic North Beach restaurant, around since the</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16575039|Food + Drink-nav-hcat|3"class=hdn-analytics href=/food/article/Couple-has-wedding-at-Pacifica-Taco-Bell-16575039.php role=menuitem> <img alt="'Totally blown away': This couple's beachside Pacifica Taco Bell wedding reception is what dreams are made of - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/42/21645460/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>'Totally blown away': This couple's beachside Pacifica Taco Bell</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16552337|Food + Drink-nav-hcat|4"class=hdn-analytics href=/restaurants/article/Bay-Area-restaurants-roiled-by-supply-chain-16552337.php role=menuitem> <img alt="'No certainty anymore': Bay Area restaurants roiled by supply chain troubles - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/37/73/21626616/5/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>'No certainty anymore': Bay Area restaurants roiled by supply</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer travel"location=travel><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel|navigation-www|8 data-naveid=985 href=/travel/ role=menuitem> Travel <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Travel-City Guides|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=985 href=/city-guides/ role=menuitem> City Guides </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Travel-Weekend Getaways|navigation-www|2"data-naveid=985 href=/getaways/ role=menuitem> Weekend Getaways </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Travel-Wine Country|navigation-www|3"data-naveid=985 href=/winecountry/ role=menuitem> Wine Country </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel-Napa|navigation-www|4 data-naveid=985 href=/napa/ role=menuitem> Napa </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel-Tahoe|navigation-www|5 data-naveid=985 href=/renotahoe/ role=menuitem> Tahoe </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Travel-California Parks|navigation-www|6"data-naveid=985 href=/california-parks/ role=menuitem> California Parks </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel-Disneyland|navigation-www|7 data-naveid=985 href=/disneyland/ role=menuitem> Disneyland </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel-Hawaii|navigation-www|8 data-naveid=985 href=/hawaii/ role=menuitem> Hawaii </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Travel-SF Insider: Things to do|navigation-www|9"data-naveid=985 href=http://sfinsider.sfgate.com role=menuitem> SF Insider: Things to do </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics travel"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Travel-Monterey-Carmel|navigation-www|10 data-naveid=985 href=/monterey-carmel/ role=menuitem> Monterey-Carmel </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16579092|Travel-nav-hcat|1 href=/travel/article/Southwest-pilot-uses-anti-Biden-insult-16579092.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Bay Area locals react to Southwest pilot making anti-Biden statement over cabin intercom - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/20/24/36/21055400/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Bay Area locals react to Southwest pilot making anti-Biden</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|link-38465|Travel-nav-hcat|2 href=http://thepress.sfchronicle.com/review/livermore-wineries/ role=menuitem> <img alt="The ultimate guide to Livermore's top wineries (The Press) - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/75/46/05/16146770/4/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>The ultimate guide to Livermore's top wineries (The Press)</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16575113|Travel-nav-hcat|3 href=/travel/article/Routes-United-London-SFO-Hawaiian-Airlines-flights-16575113.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Routes: United expands SFO service, Hawaiian adds California flights, US sets new entry rules - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/00/62/44/16984366/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Routes: United expands SFO service, Hawaiian adds California</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16576071|Travel-nav-hcat|4 href=/travel/article/Bay-Area-man-accused-assault-on-flight-16576071.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Bay Area man accused of sexually assaulting passenger on flight to Denver - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/45/00/21647381/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Bay Area man accused of sexually assaulting passenger on flight</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer realestate"location=realestate><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate|navigation-www|9"aria-haspopup=true data-naveid=989 href=/realestate/ role=menuitem> Real Estate <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-New Homes|navigation-www|1"data-naveid=989 href=/newhomes/ role=menuitem> New Homes </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-(Virtual) Open Homes|navigation-www|2"data-naveid=989 href=/openhomes/ role=menuitem> (Virtual) Open Homes </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Luxury|navigation-www|3"data-naveid=989 href=/luxuryhomes/ role=menuitem> Luxury </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Rentals|navigation-www|4"data-naveid=989 href=/rentals/ role=menuitem> Rentals </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Mortgage Rates|navigation-www|5"data-naveid=989 href=/mortgagerates/ role=menuitem> Mortgage Rates </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Place a Real Estate Ad|navigation-www|6"data-naveid=989 href=https://ezads.sfchron.com/sf-adportal/realestate/index.html?utm_campaign=subnav role=menuitem> Place a Real Estate Ad </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Neighborhood Guides|navigation-www|7"data-naveid=989 href=/neighborhoods/ role=menuitem> Neighborhood Guides </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics realestate"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Real Estate-Home & Garden|navigation-www|8"data-naveid=989 href=/homeandgarden/ role=menuitem> Home & Garden </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|link-95747|Real Estate-nav-hcat|1"class=hdn-analytics href=https://www.sfgate.com/openhomes/ role=menuitem> <img alt="Stuck house hunting at home? Tour Virtual Open Homes - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/11/23/60/19217469/6/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Stuck house hunting at home? Tour Virtual Open Homes</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16576072|Real Estate-nav-hcat|2"class=hdn-analytics href=/realestate/article/Coterie-luxury-senior-living-building-to-open-16576072.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Coterie luxury apartment building offers meals from Michelin-trained chef. But there’s a catch. - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/45/03/21647554/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Coterie luxury apartment building offers meals from</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16568866|Real Estate-nav-hcat|3"class=hdn-analytics href=/realestate/article/n3-ranch-state-park-livermore-bill-brown-16568866.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Newly sold ranch in East Bay could have been new state park - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/40/21645325/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Newly sold ranch in East Bay could have been new state park</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|article-16551735|Real Estate-nav-hcat|4"class=hdn-analytics href=/realestate/article/what-are-luxury-apartment-rental-amenities-in-sf-16551735.php role=menuitem> <img alt="What are the best luxury apartment rental amenities in San Francisco? - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/34/20/21611547/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>What are the best luxury apartment rental amenities in San</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer obits"location=obits><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"aria-haspopup=true data-hdn-analytics=visit|Obits|navigation-www|10 data-naveid=4351 href=https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/sfgate?ipid=desktopnav9-12 role=menuitem> Obits <span class=icon onclick=siteHeader.openSubMenu(event)> </span> </a> <ul class=subnav role=menu><div class=shadow></div><div class=subnavLeft><ul class=subnavlinks><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics obits"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Obits-Obituaries|navigation-www|1 data-naveid=4351 href=https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/sfgate?ipid=desktopnav9-12 role=menuitem> Obituaries </a><li class=subMenuItem><a class="subMenuItemLink hdn-analytics obits"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Obits-Place an Obituary|navigation-www|2"data-naveid=4351 href=http://ezads.sfchron.com/sf-adportal/obits/index.html?ipid=desktopnav9-12 role=menuitem> Place an Obituary </a></ul></div><div class=subnavRight><div class=subnavPreview><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16579149|Obits-nav-hcat|1 href=/news/article/Jerry-Remy-Boston-Red-Sox-player-and-16579149.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Jerry Remy, Boston Red Sox player and broadcaster, dies - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/21/21652596/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Jerry Remy, Boston Red Sox player and broadcaster, dies</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16571145|Obits-nav-hcat|2 href=/news/article/Father-Fitzpatrick-celebrates-50-years-serving-16571145.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Father Fitzpatrick celebrates 50 years serving God, others - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/42/72/21638839/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Father Fitzpatrick celebrates 50 years serving God, others</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16578347|Obits-nav-hcat|3 href=/news/article/African-American-museum-in-Georgia-honors-16578347.php role=menuitem> <img alt="African American museum in Georgia honors forgotten history - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/46/02/21651621/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>African American museum in Georgia honors forgotten history</h4> </a></div><div class=nav-hcat><a class=hdn-analytics data-hdn-analytics=visit|article-16573628|Obits-nav-hcat|4 href=/news/article/Biden-pope-to-talk-virus-climate-poverty-at-16573628.php role=menuitem> <img alt="Biden: Pope told me that I should 'keep receiving Communion' - Photo"data-src=https://s.hdnux.com/photos/01/22/44/33/21645020/3/landscape_32.jpg> <h4 class=headline>Biden: Pope told me that I should 'keep receiving Communion'</h4> </a></div></div></div></ul><li class="subMenuContainer coupons"location=coupons><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics=visit|Coupons|navigation-www|11 data-naveid=5565 href=/coupons> Coupons </a><li class="subMenuContainer buyarea"location=buyarea><a class="subMenuLink hdn-analytics"data-hdn-analytics="visit|Buy Area|navigation-www|12"data-naveid=5610 href=/shopping/> Buy Area </a></ul></div></nav><div class=menu-bar id=menuBar><a class=homeLink href=/> <span class=icon> </span> </a><a class=nav-btn id=menu-open onclick=siteHeader.openMenu()> <span class=icon> Menu </span> <span class=label> Sections </span> </a><div class=title><span class=icon> </span></div></div><span id=subHead-spacer> </span><span id=ctpl-fullbanner-spacer> </span><span id=site-nav-spacer> </span></header><div class=ctpl-billboard><div class=ad_deferrable id=A951><script>/*<![CDATA[*/ hearstPlaceAd("A951"); /*]]>*/</script></div></div><div id=content><div class=error-404><div class=page-content><div class=error-content><div class=error-header><h2>Page Not Found</h2><p><a href=javascript:history.go(-1)> Return to the previous page </a></div><div class=error-body><p>The item that you have requested was not found.</p><span> Possible causes: </span><ul><li>The address was entered incorrectly<li>The item no longer exists<li>There has been an error on the site</ul><p>If you feel the address you entered is correct you can contact us, mentioning the error message received and the item you were trying to reach.</p><span> We apologize for any inconvenience. From here, you can: </span><ul><li><a href=javascript:history.go(-1)> Return to the previous page </a><li>Use the menu bar above<li>Select an item from our site index below</ul></div></div></div></div></div><footer><div class="hdnce-e hdnce-item-4249"><div class=header><span aria-label="SFGate Logo"class=logo role=img> Logo </span><span class=top> <a href=#> Return to Top </a> </span></div><div class=body><div class=about><h3 id=about-footer-free>About</h3><ul aria-labelledby=about-footer-free role=list><li><a href=/privacy-policy/ role=listitem> Privacy Notice /Notice At Collection </a><li><a href=/privacy-policy/#caprivacyrights role=listitem> Your California Privacy Rights </a><li><a href=/privacy-policy/#interestbasedads role=listitem> Interest Based Ads </a><li><a href=/termsandconditions/ role=listitem> Terms of Use </a><li><a href=/aboutsfgate/ role=listitem> Our Company </a><li><a href=http://thepress.sfchronicle.com/ role=listitem target=_blank> The Press: Guide to Wine Country </a><li><a href=http://www.greenstate.com/ role=listitem target=_blank> Green State: Cannabis Culture </a><li><a href=https://eevd.fa.us6.oraclecloud.com/hcmUI/CandidateExperience/en/sites/CX_15/pages/29004 role=listitem> Careers </a><li><a href=https://marketing.sfgate.com/advertise-with-us-today/ role=listitem> Advertising </a></ul></div><div class=contact><h3 id=contact-footer-free>Contact</h3><ul aria-labelledby=contact-footer-free role=list><li><a href=/feedback/ role=listitem> Customer Service </a><li><a href=/chronicle-contacts/ role=listitem> Newsroom Contacts </a></ul></div><div class=connect><h3 id=connect-footer-free>Connect</h3><ul aria-labelledby=connect-footer-free role=list><li><a class=email href=http://www.sfgate.com/profile/ role=listitem> Sign up for Email Alerts </a><li><a class=facebook href=https://www.facebook.com/SFGate/ role=listitem> Facebook </a><li><a class=twitter href=https://twitter.com/sfgate/ role=listitem> Twitter </a><li><a class=pinterest href=http://www.pinterest.com/sfgate/ role=listitem> Pinterest </a><li><a class=instagram href=https://instagram.com/sfgate/ role=listitem> Instagram </a></ul></div><div class=connect><h3 style="font-size: 13px !important;"id=connect-footer-free>CCPA</h3><ul style="font-size: 13px !important;"aria-labelledby=connect-footer-free role=list><li><a data-hdn-analytics="visit|Do Not Sell My Personal Info|navigation-footer|1"style="font-size: 14px;"class=hdn-analytics href=/mydata/ role=listitem target=_blank> Do Not Sell My Personal Info </a></ul></div><div class=QuickLinks><h3 id=sub-footer-free>QuickLinks</h3><ul aria-labelledby=sub-footer-free role=list><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/realestate/ role=listitem> Real Estate </a><li><a href=https://cars.sfgate.com/ role=listitem> Cars </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/jobs/ role=listitem> Jobs </a><li><a href=http://sfc.ipublishmarketplace.com/sf-marketplace/ role=listitem> SF Marketplace </a><li><a href=https://marketing.sfgate.com/marketplaces/recruitment role=listitem> Recruitment </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/home-services-directory/ role=listitem> Home Services </a><li><a href=https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/sfgate/ role=listitem> Obituaries </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/horoscope/ role=listitem> Horoscopes </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/comics/ck/ role=listitem> Comics </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/dearabby/ role=listitem> Dear Abby </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/weather/ role=listitem> Weather </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/living/ role=listitem> Home </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/movies/ role=listitem> Movies </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/tv/ role=listitem> TV </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/earthquakes/ role=listitem> Earthquakes </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/california-wildfires/ role=listitem> Wildfires </a><li><a href=https://www.legalnotice.org/pl/SFGate/landing1.aspx role=listitem> Public Notice </a><li><a href=https://www.sfgate.com/mba/ role=listitem> MBA by the Bay </a></ul></div></div><div class=footer><span aria-label="Hearst Logo"class=logo role=img> Hearst Newspapers </span><span class=copyright> <a href=/copyright-notice/> © Copyright <script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> Hearst Communications, Inc. </a> </span></div></div></footer><script src=/external/js/global.bottom.v12.4.3.js></script>