First of all, Kiszla has never liked Siemian.

Secondly, let the cold hard facts of John Elway's stats as a QB speak for themselves.

In his first two seasons - the first just 10 games - Elway completed 337 0f 639 passes for a completion percentage FIFTY THREE PERCENT while throwing 25 TDs and 29 INTs and a 6.5Y/A. 

He was less mediocre in season 2, yet the Broncos went 12-2 despite only minimal improvement from Elway from year 1 to year 2.

For his entire career, Elway's stats are:56.9% completions, 7.1Y/A, 300 TDs, 226 INTs, 148-82 won/lost =.643.

Despite a less than mediocre completion % and a plain bad TD/INT ratio - worse, 1.33/1 than Jay Cutler's, 1.43/1 - he is reckoned by many so-called experts to be among the top 5 or 6 QBs of all time.

Why? Because he is a 5 time Super Bowl QB even tho he lost his first 3 and was quite mediocre in his first win. 

So just WTF does Siemien's 59%, 7.0Y/A, 18TDs, 10 Ints, while playing with a bad shoulder much of the time get so dissed?