I disagree that we all have a moral duty to each other. Don't get me wrong, it's a nice sentiment, but to make health care for all work, it involves taking from others. Sure the millionaires of the world can afford to pay extra, and a lot of the upper middle class can too. But what about the plain old basic middle class that isn't too far removed from living paycheck to paycheck? They get shouldered with the burden to pay for this too, but little thought goes into what their financial liabilities are, nobody really seems to care if higher taxes or insurance premiums causes any trouble for this group. Why should these families suffer just so somebody else can get free healthcare? Every debate about this issue boils down to rich vs poor, but what about those caught in the middle? It's not morally wrong to want to keep the little bit of excess income one has left over after paying bills, but it is morally wrong to force someone to give that money to others. In fact it's called theft.