good point John. How can a dialogue happen if it's "my way or the highway". Tridentius & Co. are good spokesmen for those who do not wish to do any thinking at all, ever again, since it was all done by Aquinas. However, it is not apparent to me how A)those who are not married but having sex can receive communion nor B) how the remarried without annulments can receive it. On B) I am open to seeing how that can be dealt with, but on A) it just seems right out of bounds.