In one of his replies to you Jay Edward spoke of the "NCR agenda" while not responding to my point about all views being allowed on NCR,  contrary to his original statement.   I've just let him keep talking (sans further engagement with him)  because that has revealed his own 'agenda' and that of his supposedly 'real Catholic' cohorts...  which agenda,  unfortunately,  has no desire for discussion and sharing of viewpoints,  but rather to rebuke those whose views differ...  all supposedly "defending the faith".    When he and his friends come here with the attitude that the NCR regulars are the enemy of the faith there is nothing remaining to discuss.   Thereafter I pretty much ignore them rather than read or engage in their argumentative attempts.  It's pointless to do otherwise.