SC ruled in 2010   they could not order Govmt  request Khadr repatriation,- an  executive prerogative.  The SC ruled in 2008 and 2010  that Khadr's rights had been breached  on 2 occasions in 2003 when interviewed by CSIS and DFAIT, once in 2004 when interviewed by DFAIT ,when he refused to answer questions. US preconditioned Canadians access to Khadr only if interviews were taped, transcripts provided . In 2010  SC said this "may  have provided important evidence relating to his criminal proceedings " to US which might have contributed to continuing detention. See SIRCS 2008 report used by SC  " CSIS’s Role in the Matter of Omar Khadr". CSIS wanted Khadr interview for "compelling operational reasons ...given the threat posed by Sunni Islamic extremism ...following 9/11".  Sum of Canada's  so called egregious offences against  Khadr which Trudeau and terrorist sympathizers say justifies 10.5 million payoff. It would have been outrageous dereliction if CSIS had not interviewed Khadr.