After getting close to forcing a game 5 with the Cubs in 2016, the Giants decided to go after a tier I closer in the off season. I thought Melancon at $62 million might be the difference between an early playoff exit and another World Series appearance. Then the Giants went out and played some terrible baseball in 2017. And Melancon? Not only did he post the 4.50 ERA you mentioned, he was injured and ended up playing only ~30 innings, saving 11 games. $15.5 million for 30 innings. Rockies will be ok without Holland, and I don’t think there are many 30/31 year old relievers worth $15 million a year... just ask the Giants.