A lot of generalities in your response, sir, nothing specific.

Let's take 1 pt, that Boyle's arrival has helped Matthews by allowing him to play against weaker opposition.  The columnist cited no proof this has happened.  But even if that were true, which it is not, but even if it were, and Matthews was playing vs weaker players, how come he's not scoring?  

He got 9 mins ice time last game, that's how poorly he's playing.

Go ahead, your turn.