'I don't need to explain why it's a good move, but you need to explain why it's a bad move,' to paraphrase what Northside is saying.

First, it's a double standard.

Second, it assumes that you pronounce on high, as if from the summit of Mount Olympus itself. Well, I've read your posts and, like everyone else on these pages, myself included, you're not batting 1.000 either. If you can't be bothered to explain your reasoning why a 35-year-old Smith is better than, say,  a 32-year-old Elliott given only one season to prove himself, then why waste the skin of your fingertips typing it out.