Taste in art and architecture is as varied as people. I prefer the "traditional" churches more than the modern ones, which I don't care for at all. I should also mention that I also like houses to be Victorian, Colonial or Tudor. Many people prefer the more modern splits or contemporary houses.
My 18 year old child is even more traditional when it comes to churches than I am, she likes the ones that are over 100 years old. So do I but not exclusively.
My current parish church, built around 2001, It is more modern but has some traditional elements I like it - its okay. I would not say its gorgeous. Don't like the reredo but- whatever.
Looking at the example of St Michael's in Wheaton (it looks pretty traditional to me!!!) It has a raised altar area, straight pews, high vaults, nice stained glass and a really big crucifix!
My  jury is out on the Cathedral of Christ the light - looks like an overturned boat but maybe that is the look they were going for (meh).