No, he deliberately made a logical blunder for rhetorical purposes and I caught him. If it wasn't deliberate, it was because he can't think logically.

Case closed.

Any response on your part now will only look bad and make you look illogical and overly concerned about mere rhetoric.

Give up now. Really, give up now. Unless you want to admit it's all just fact-free, logic-free rhetoric.

Logic? Rhetoric? What's your decision? Choose freely. Choose well. Or, not so well.

Hmmm?