This issue goes to the heart of the culture of paternalism within the Church. The laity are not children to be cared for but equal members of the Body of Christ. This is an especially pertinent point when it comes to issues of child protection, which require the charism of parenthood more than that of a celibate clergy.

And, yes, survivors must be included. Otherwise, they are twice victimized by being pushed to the margins in a conversation in which they have something vital, and irreplaceable, to offer.