Print 71 comment(s) - last by Bad-Karma.. on Jul 11 at 3:41 AM

Microsoft warns that the PATRIOT Act, recent renewed by President Obama, will allow the U.S. to invade EU citizens' private data without notification.  (Source: Paramount Pictures)

The revelation could lead the EU to forcing Facebook, Google, Microsoft, and others to adopt isolated hosting in Europe for European services. Currently much of the hosting for European users is handled in America, exposing their data to invasive U.S. laws.  (Source: Flickr/TJCrowley)

Senators John McCain (R-Ariz.) and John Kerry (D-Mass.) have proposed a privacy bill that may help fix the awkward standoff.  (Source: AP Photo)
Microsoft tipped off the EU about possible data grab

The European Union (EU) is a little bit upset with the United States federal government after it caught wind of a possible plan to swipe EU citizens' private data from cloud service providers, in violation of EU laws.  And the U.S. government can blame software giant Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) for letting the secret out of the bag.

I. PATRIOT Act: Policing the World

People often get caught up in possible domestic spying issues of the "Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001" (USA PATRIOT Act of 2001) as it authorizes the gathering of "foreign intelligence information" from U.S. citizens.

But the bill, which was renewed for four years by President Barack Obama in 2011, is primarily aimed at gathering intelligence from foreign nations.  In that regard, much of its authorizations deal with "spying" on foreign nations -- not solely U.S. citizens.

With citizens in the U.S. and Europe increasingly using "the cloud" -- services from companies like Microsoft, Facebook, Google Inc. (GOOG), and Apple, Inc. (AAPL) -- the question becomes how secure these resources are.

While the U.S. does not guarantee the privacy of its citizens online, the EU has a law titled the Data Protection Directive, which mandates that the EU protect the privacy of its citizens.  The Directive demands that citizens be informed any time private data is obtained.  The problem is that mandate does little to stop the U.S. from secretly seizing cloud data in the name of the PATRIOT Act according to warnings from Microsoft and top lawyers.

II. Our Laws Are Greater Than Yours

Microsoft warns that under the PATRIOT Act, it might not only be forced to hand over EU citizens' data; it might also be forced to do so secretly, without informing the EU.  This would directly violate the privacy protections the EU promises to enforce.


Sophia In't Veld (Netherlands) an EU parliamentarian, voiced outrage at the prospect, stating, "Does the Commission consider that the U.S. PATRIOT Act thus effectively overrules the E.U. Directive on Data Protection? What will the Commission do to remedy this situation, and ensure that E.U. data protection rules can be effectively enforced and that third country legislation does not take precedence over E.U. legislation?"


The EU and the U.S. already have an agreement called Safe Harbor, which allows for the sharing of data under certain restrictions such as the promise of reasonable data security, and clearly defined and effective enforcement.  In these cases the EU is informed of the request, so it can inform the affected citizens about it.

The problem is that the PATRIOT Act offers a far easier secret backdoor to the same information.  And there's little the EU can do to stop it.

Theo Bosboom, IT lawyer with Dirkzager Lawyers comments, "I'm afraid that Safe Harbor has very little value anymore, since it came out that it might be possible that U.S. companies that offer to keep data in a European cloud are still obliged to allow the U.S. government access to these data on basis of the PATRIOT Act. Europeans would be better to keep their data in Europe. If a European contract partner for a European cloud solution, offers the guarantee that data stays within the European Union, that is without a doubt the best choice, legally."

That could spell big trouble for companies like Google, Facebook, Microsoft, and Apple should the EU decide to apply restrictions or mandates to their services in order to protect its citizens' privacy from foreign powers.  Such restrictions could for the companies to switch to local, isolated serving to prevent the U.S. from having access to the data.  However, such schemes would be pricey to implement.

III. Does U.S. Privacy Bill Provide an Answer?

One potential solution may lie with the pending online privacy protection legislation proposed by Senators John Kerry (D-Mass.) and John McCain (R-Ariz.).  

The bill has received much resistance from the online data mining and advertising community, as it suggests the creation of a mandatory opt-out of data gathering.  Such an opt-out could be cost-prohibitive for smaller sites and could seriously undermine online advertising's profitability.

The bill could also make it harder to use the PATRIOT Act to grab information without public notification.

States EU Data Protection Commissioner Viviane Reding, "I welcome a draft Bill of Rights just introduced in the U.S. Congress as a bipartisan initiative of Democrats and Republicans. The Commission also shares the main objective of the Bill: strengthening individuals' trust in new technologies through compatible standards."

A compromise may be reached, but it's doubtful this will be the last we hear of this controversy.

Comments     Threshold


RE: What could happen.
By Noya on 7/6/2011 6:04:14 PM , Rating: 2
Nope, sorry, but Obama could have let the Patriot Act expire but didn't. So it's idiots like YOU that put us on a "slippery slope". Ooooh this is fun, see how that works?

No, it's idiots like you and FIT on the right and the morons on the left that live in some fantasy world and actually believe your little votes mean if corporate money doesn't decide everything that happens in our country. Everything . Just look at the other blog post about ethanol.

Divide and conquer, keep all the common idiots hating each other and nothing ever changes to benefit them. What's happened in the last 40 years? The average person has gotten poorer and no new major infrastructure has taken place. This country peaked in the early 60's.

RE: What could happen.
By Reclaimer77 on 7/6/11, Rating: 0
