Latest News:  
Beijing   Cloudy/Overcast    7 / 0   City Forecast

People's Daily Online>>Opinion

WTO's raw materials ruling reveals bias

By Xu Li (China Daily)

13:58, March 19, 2012

On March 13, the United States, the European Union and Japan jointly challenged China's restrictions on exports of rare earth materials, a group of 17 key elements used in high-technology products, and requested consultations with China under the World Trade Organization framework. China responded on March 15, by saying it will consult with them following the dispute settlement procedure of the WTO.

China has time and again emphasized that the export restrictions are necessary in order to conserve its exhaustible natural resources and to protect people's health and are thus permitted by the General Exceptions clause in the WTO rules.

The WTO rules, a single set of comprehensive world-wide trade rules, require member countries commit to the fundamental obligations of non-discrimination, lowering trade barriers, non-quantitative restrictions and transparency in the administration of their trade related economic system. But the WTO rules also respect the sovereignty of member states in certain prescribed circumstances.

The WTO rules guarantee member countries a balance between their international obligations and national sovereignty by permitting the adoption or enforcement of measures in certain instances. In particular, Article XX of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade allows measures "necessary to protect human, animal or plant life or health" or "relating to the conservation of exhaustible natural resources".

However, the dispute settlement body of the WTO has denied China use of this clause.

On Jan 30th, the dispute settlement body delivered its decision on a complaint made at the end of 2009 by Mexico, the EU and the US of China's export restrictions on certain raw materials. After examining the case for two years, the dispute settlement body ruled that the restrictions were not consistent with WTO provisions and the commitments of China's WTO accession protocol.

【1】 【2】


Leave your comment3 comments

  1. Name

Todd at 2012-03-20108.32.203.*
Just get out of the WTO.
Harald at 2012-03-19101.5.221.*
The GATT has another biased implication: Almost all developed countries are very poor in natural resources. It"s easy to demand free trade when you don"t have resources to protect in your own country.
wende at 2012-03-1971.255.86.*
China ought to place first emphasis on environmental protection and depletion of natural resources on the second. WTO and other world organizations are set up by the west, and US specially, to gain hegemony in the world. Do not expect too much from these organizations nor should China be naive enough to think that they will be fair. The top echelon of these organizations are staffed with westerners. Unless Chinese can gain a place in these organizations, the west will be able to get what it wants. They might let you win a few small battles but they will triumph in most other important cases just to make you think that they are acting fairly. Don"t be fooled!

Selections for you

  1. Helicopter dispatched to SW China forest fire

  2. Bomb disposal team defuses hoax bomb in Shenzhen

  3. Warplanes conduct confrontation drilling

  4. British shop owner in Beijing’s hutong

Most Popular


  1. Arms race will happen, but who to blame?
  2. Why China can't persuade N.Korea alone
  3. WTO's raw materials ruling reveals bias
  4. 21st Century classrooms needed for the future
  5. West's rare earth claim against China unreasonable
  6. Chinese economy vital for world
  7. How should China provide for seniors?
  8. Obama brings new trade case against China
  9. Giving is an aid to prosperity
  10. Rare earth case reveals US hypocrisy

What's happening in China

Poverty relief campaign offered in 798 Art Zone

  1. Coal-rich city aims to become sunshine state
  2. Firm admits it sold dead ducks
  3. Synthetic drugs pose new challenge
  4. Union chiefs asked to give contact info
  5. Carrefour food scandal shuts down store

PD Online Data

  1. Spring Festival
  2. Chinese ethnic odyssey
  3. Yangge in Shaanxi
  4. Gaoqiao in Northern China
  5. The drum dance in Ansai