Everybody has a Metallica shirt, from Kim Kardashian to Justin Bieber to Gigi Hadad, to Michael Jackson’s daughter, Paris. You can get a Metallica shirt basically anywhere, from Urban Outfitters to H&M to Barneys New York (?!).

But some people are pushing back on the trend of wearing metal shirts. A few months ago, Twisted Sister’s Dee Snider called the trend “sickening” saying “Metal is not ironic! Dicks.” It seems like pop rock musician (and all around badass) St. Vincent shares that sentiment. She tweeted earlier today:

I can only imagine how awkward this situation would be on the street. Personally, I am not a fan of gatekeeping. If the kid bought the shirt because it looked cool and never heard of the band, why not just grab them and play Ride The Lightning for them as opposed to quizzing them on it. There are no record stores anymore where kids can just browse vinyl and be inspired by a sick cover to get into a band.

Either way, Metallica caught light of the tweet and responded in jest: