Top Ten Worst Warrior Cats

Cats I hate and you should hate them too! I mean, they are so bad >:(
The Top Ten

Tigerstar is just plain evil! He had everything that he could've ever wanted yet all of THAT wasn't enough for him!? Sure, his father, Pinestar, abandoned ThunderClan for the Twolegplace, Mistkit and Nightkit, his sisters died shortly after birth, and his mother passed away, but Tigerstar still had Whitestorm, Lionheart, Brindleface, Frostfur's, Goldenflower, Bramblekit, and Tawnykit, and his whole entire Clan that was willing to die for him. He was even one of the most respected cats in the forest but he wanted to take over the Clans!? Wow, Tigerclaw. You are THE most ungrateful brat ever.

Tigerstar is the worst cat the forest has ever known, I'm glad Scourge killed him when he was living. He caused all problems basically for all of the Clans. Hawkfrost may be bad, but he wouldn't be alive if tigerstar didn't live!

He killed Bluestar. He stood and watched when Leapordfur was trying to kill Fireheart! He killed Redtail to be deputy! He is a selfish, rude, horrible cat. He is the most evil of all! Not to be rude but I am glad Scouge Killed him. And I agree he is one of the worst cats in warriors history!

He is evil and kills everyone I mean brings dogs into the forest, maybe set thunderclan's camp on fire, oh and killed redtail, runningwind? , (I think that's his name) gorsepaw, graypool and bunch of other cats.

2 Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet named Rusty. Firestar is killed by fatal wounds by the spirit of Tigerstar and a falling tree more.

I think 'Worst Characters' should be for poorly written characters, and that evil characters should have their own list. Firestar was good in the first series as a proud, mischievous young cat, but when we was a deputy he transitioned into an inner-troubled cat. They tried way too desperately to paint him as the good main character of righteousness, which in my opinion makes for a rather boring and predictable cat.

I'm pretty sure this is for cats who are terrible for their story, not overall character. Even if Firestar doesn't go through great changes or struggles besides Tigerstar, he's the least likely character to be put up here. He was the first prophecised cat, the first cat to save the Clans. Why is he above Thistleclaw, the villain of Bluestar's Prophecy, and Sol, who brought down ShadowClan, and started a fight between WindClan and ThunderClan. Firestar isn't on my favourites list, but he's still a good cat.

He acts more like a kit than a leader, let start when he was a apprentice feeding yellowfang than eat for himself wow. Then he goes and spare a river clan warrior without touching her really can you at least give her a small scratch and let her go. Don't forget the river clan feeding without feeding his clan that mousebrain. Then when he leader he lets all of these fat kittypets like please stop.

Bone-the proud leader of pack of savage souls rouge pack

As a warrior, he was okay. It was when he became a leader he became annoying. Always butting into other clans problems when it was clear they didn't want any. The Erins forgot about making him a nice character and portrayed him as just another ordinary leader, even when everyone thought he was so great. He should have died in the first series!

3 Thistleclaw Thistleclaw is a villain in the Warrior Cats series. Thistleclaw is a gray-and-white tabby tom with spiky fur and amber eyes

Essentially everything bad that happened was because of Thistleclaw. If he had been a nicer cat,
1. Snowfur would not have died, and Whitestorm would have grown up with a mother
2. Tigerclaw would not have attacked Tiny, who would not have grown up a vengeful and mean cat who eventually returned to the forest as Scourge and tried to take over the Clans
3. Tigerclaw wouldn't have learned to be powerhungry and bloodthirsty from Thistleclaw, and subsequently wouldn't have killed all of the cats he did.
4. Without Tigerclaw, Hawkfrost, Thistleclaw and all of the cats who joined the Dark Forest because of Thistleclaw, they wouldn't have been nearly as powerful and probably wouldn't have tried to fight the Clans at the lake.

Thistleclaw is an ugly evil wicked fox hearted fox dung! He ruined Bluestar and ThunderClan by Tigerstar, his strongest weapon. If isn't Firestar, ThunderClan is just a soft, burnt mashed potato!

I don't really see why he is on here. He really was originally a good cat; he was just crazed by grief. He should at LEAST not be in the top 4?!?

Thistleclaw may have made Tigerstar insane but he's not as bad as Tigerstar. Tigerstar caused more damage than he did.

4 Brokenstar Brokenstar is a villain character from the Warrior Cats series. Brokenstar is a matted, dark brown tabby tom with a broad, flat face, a bent tail, and orange eyes. Brokenstar was a former Shadowclan leader and a member of the Dark Forest. His mother is Yellowfang and his father is Raggedstar.

Ok, so don't get me wrong, I hate Brokenstar/tail because, I'm a big yellowfang fan, but still. He wasn't the best villain. Scourge at Tigerstar/claw are better in my opinion, but I hate how he murdered kits, took lives, betrayed his own mother (yellowfang), killed his father, and shot ThunderClan in the back. Well, I'm out.

Terrible cat, he literally killed innocent kits because they LOOKED weak. Well, its actually his fault that they looked weak because he literally starved their mothers. This cat is horrible hands down, thumbs up if you agree.

I swear his middle name is murderer! He made kits with there eyes closed fight, knowing very well that they would all die! How much I dislike tigerstar, well compared to brokenstar, tigerstar is an angel! And that, I thought I'd never, ever say

Brokenstar killed his father, killed innocent kits, and didn't care. that should be enough said.

5 Hawkfrost Hawkfrost is a villain character from the Warriors series. Hawkfrost is a dark brown tabby tom with a snow-white underbelly and ice-blue eyes. Hawkfrost was a former Riverclan warrior and member of the Dark Forest. Hawkfrost tried to kill Firestar with a fox trap but was killed by his brother Brambleclaw more.

My least favorite villain because he really has no backstory or reason to be evil. I usually judge evil cats on what their backstory is, and whether or not it was toxic enough to give a reason for a cat to turn to the dark side. But Hawkfrost had a clan that admired him, a sister that loved him. But he took advantage of all this, even if part of his evil was caused by his father, Tigerstar. He acted shady even before he was training in the Dark Forest.

I hate Hawkfrost he took Tigerstar's side and took one of FireStars lives then he also made his sister become. A medicine cat and Killed Hollyleaf

I hate Hawkfrost! He killed my Hollyleaf! Hollyleaf never did anything, did she? I mean, sure, she killed Ashfur, but still! I love Brambleclaw because he killed Hawkfrost. But I HATE Hawkfrost! Anyone with me?

Who has read Tigerstar & Sasha? Anyone who can believe little Hawk turned into THIS? And, while I'm here, RIP Tadpole!

6 Rainflower

If the dog wouldn't of have killed her first, I would have broken the warrior code and Murdered her myself! She renamed Stormkit Crookedkit, and started liking Oakheart more! She should be dead in the Dark Forest! KILL RAINFLOWER!

I don't get why people compare her with Millie. Millie payed more attention to her injured kit while Rainflower did the opposite. She is a complete idiot.

She rejected her son for his appearance. I wouldn't throw her in the Dark Forest, but I certainly don't deem her a good cat.

Hate her, rejected Crookedstar just because he broke his jaw. Stupid butt!

7 Bluestar Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She was one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She broke the code by being mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and having her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, and Mosskit. Stonefur and Mistyfoot live in RiverClan, while Mosskit died of hypothermia. She has a more.

Oh Bluestar... She was a decent leader in the beginning, nothing really special about her. Then after Tigerclaw attacked her she lost it and went 'insane. Other leaders and cats went through worse and could handle it. She could have stepped down and retired, or taken time to 'recover' but no, she stayed leader and sat in her den while her clan fell apart around her. Most people like her, probably because she has nostalgia on her side, but I really don't see why people won't face it.
She really wasn't that good a leader in the end.

I like Bluestar, and she surely doesn't deserve to be here, but she's not my favorite at all. She's mopey and annoying in Bluestar's Prophecy, but she grows into a great and wise leader which we know for the first three books. I thought it was contrived when she went crazy, but she came out in the end. She's not the coolest cat of the world (I think that award goes to Ivypool), but I get why people both love her and hate her.

Compared to most other leaders, she was the worst! She was fine at the beginning, but after Tigerclaw attacked her she lost it and let her clan fall apart! People always pity her because her family is dead and stuff, when really, compared to cats like Mapleshade and others, it's nothing! In the end, she just wasn't a good leader at all.

Wait... Bluestar? Bluestar.
Yes, she did go crazy in rising storm and declared war on starclan when a fire hit thunderclan camp, but just because she did that, does that mean she is the worst? No. From what I can tell, blue here was actually a good leader until the fire struck.
So, creator of this top ten list, please remove her or at least out her a bit lower.

8 Ivypool Ivypool is a fictional character created by Erin Hunter for the Book series named Warrior Cats. Ivypool is a common silver-and-white tabby. She spied in the Dark Forest and has dark blue eyes. She is the sister of Dovewing and the kit of Whitewing and Birchfall. Her mate is Fernsong, and she is the more.

Ivypool is annoying she is an overrated selfish mouse brained brat and you pick on dove wing who was being nice. Also spying is not an exscuse for her being good she only helped the dark forest and didn't tell them the information she learned and She was a whimp who couldn't do anything accept sort moss and. She got mad at Dove wing because of her powers to save them also for dove wing be successful in battle moves Ivyppol only new her battle moves because of Hawk frost and helped the dark forest she is such I bad character

She was jealous of her sister, but that's no reason to go train in the Dark Forest which is basically warrior cats hell by the way. AND she didn't tell Dovewing how she felt! If she did then it would be much better.

You guys are so mean! Go ahead, click thumbs down! I don't care! Ivypool is awesome! Dovewing IS a whiny Mary Sue! Like Ivypool is more fun! Dovewing is selfish and is upsest with herself! Dovewing sucks! Ivypool rocks! You guys are so mean!

Oh yeah? What if you had a sister who was better than you at absolutely everything, and that drove you so crazy that you went to the dark forest to train?

9 Ashfur Ashfur is a character created by Erin Hunter for the book series named Warrior Cats. Ashfur is a muscular pale gray tom with darker flecks and dark blue eyes. He has short, thick fur, and a torn ear.

Ashfur is annoying he was good at first but when he got rejected he was so angry that he went mad and tried to kill 4 cats also when I started to forgive him a bit because I thought he was done with rage he posses Bramblestar seriously that is freakin stupid Ashfur Bramblestar did nothing to you. And the clans did nothing to

HOW IS NOT IN THE TOP TEN?! Wow. Just wow. Why I hate him... He is too clingy and obsessed with Squirrelflight, and even when she offered to be friends he said no. And I don't even buy the "He loved too much defense. How on earth did he "love too much"? He HATED Squirrelflight just because she didn't love him back. And there's, of course, the fire scene. He tried to burn Lionblaze, Jayfeather, and Hollyleaf just because she didn't love him. He almost killed 4 cats, Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, Jayfeather, and Firestar. One his former apperntice, another a blind medicine cat, and one his own leader! He also gave Squirrelflight cold looks and tried to kill Lionpaw/blaze while battle training. I don't even know how he when to starclan and Mapleshade and Thistleclaw went to the DF. Ashfur is my least favorite cat in the series. I just hate him and I think he deserves to go to the DF

My argument :
Let's say you break up with you're boyfriend, get married, and have kids. Then your ex-boyfriend comes and tries to kill your father and your children. I can see how Ashfur lovers are sympathetic, but really?

I was really sad to see him change from such an innocent apprentice to a vicious killer. He was sooo loyal as an apprentice, but he changed. I honestly feel sorry for him, even though I know it was his own fault.

10 Darkstripe

A stupid, idiotic cat that just won't let go of the fact that Firestar (or Fireheart) became a loyal cat and was a wussy kittypet before that. Darkstripe is horrible and it would suck so much to be him. Vote for this Tigerstar supporter and treacherous cat so it could be in the top 10.

Darkstripe is my all time least favorite cat. There is NO time he does anything good or nice, even Tigerstar helped save Graystripes kit right after birth.

Darkstripe deserves to be in the top 7!

Yup, totally brainwashed...

The Contenders
11 Sol

Ok were do I begin he lived such a hard life! His mother gave him up and his father abandoned him (well that was his mothers fault he would have brought more food if she was grateful!). Also he wnatd to be a warrior I think leafstar should have tried harder and maybe even let Sol lead some patrols or make himself seem useful!
If I were Leafstar I would have giving him another chance and focus on teaching him about the warrior code then allow him to get more practice on being a warrior or at least give him a mentor that has more time to mentor him. But we all got to admit he did some preety bad stuff but It all could have been avoided.

I have always admired the villains in books that use charisma and manipulative behavior to get e=what they want. So this makes Sol one of my favorite villains, but I still hate him as a character, its hard not to hate him.

Sol made every clan fall apart. I obviously thought he was a dead Dark Forest Warrior.
But to be honest, I wish he could've killed Dovewing somehow.

He is named SOL because he told cats about a SOLar eclipse.

12 Maple Shade

Well... I read Mapleshade's revenge and ended up hating her, blaming others for her own actions, outraged when the oak star was annoyed by birchface's lie, but even she did nothing to stop the rumors. Ravenwing only protected her clan and Frecklewish was understandably upset, darling, not only made a father and a sister believe that the puppies of his "murderer" were birchfall, if not a clan and she suffered the consequences.

It makes me sick to see how they defend her so much.

Okay, Mapleshade haters. Let's do some roleplaying. You are a ThunderClan cat madly in love with a RiverClan cat. You have his kits, then get ratted out by your medicine cat, causing your exile from the Clan. One thing leads to another, and your precious kits, the kits you loved so much, all drown in the river when you try to make it to RiverClan and your mate rejects you when you find out he's been cheating on you with an ugly, annoying cat from his own Clan. The RiverClan leader kicks you out of RiverClan so you have to find shelter, and you realize that you've lost EVERYTHING you love. That's what it was like to be Mapleshade, and all of you say, "Well she didn't have to take it out on everyone! " Well, this is wrong! Wouldn't you want to get revenge on the cats who ruined your life? These cats RUINED her life, I repeat! You Mapleshade haters need to go away, read Mapleshade's Vengeance, and come back! Look up Mapleshade's Vengeance pdf, has a copy of it. Read it and ...more

Yeah. In the books she is a villan who did many things. I thought she was the worst at first.
She was crazy with grief! She was rejected by her Thunder clan, River Clan, mate,and lost her kits! I would have done the same.
After she died, I mean like why did she have to make ither cat's life miserable!?!?!?
feat. Crookedstar, Thistleclaw etc.

Mapleshade belongs in a cat mental asylum.
If she loses everything, it's a big deal. But she shouldn't put an innocent cat in depression just because things didn't go her way.

13 Breezepelt

Breezepelt is the way he is because Nightcloud said horrid things to him about his fathe rand babied him. We all know Spiderleg abandoned Daisy & her kits but they didn't grow up to be pricks.

Breezepelt is such an annoying butt. And the worst thing is... he's not even dead!? Why!?

I hope that in the next book, he dies. Who likes to let an annoying mousebrain live?

He's just misunderstood, his dad doesn't really care for him.

Breezepelt is evil. He joined the Darkforest and tried to kill cats. I rest my case.

14 Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of BloodClan. He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin. One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth. Scourge is a small black tom with one white paw, ice-blue eyes, more.

Scourge was. A cool villain but had to much power I would of liked to see something different with Tigerstar's death like he loses his 9 lives not through one wound cause that was boring also Scourge YOU KILLED FIRESTAR

Scourge is followed by dark-obsessed fangirls.
Scourge is not only a kitty-cat psycho, he's got some fangirls too.. Like a kitty Jeff the Killer.
Scourge is known for having 999999 "Ask Scourge" blogs, each one belonging to a different person.
Scourge is known for having girls get a crush on him. HUMAN girls.
(Wow, kitty so seexxy! Me-wow! )
Dark-Obsessed dudes who think Scourge is their Role Model and Hero are everywhere.
I don't really hate him, its just his overrated-ness I hate.

Any people who love Scourge and hate Firestar hate the series. I know people who were bullied in school or by friends/siblings. They DIDN'T, however, go and start murdering cats.

Scourge was the worst cat. But he made the series good by being a good villain.


Millie is underrated. Let's say this.

You are a queen in the forest who has three wonderful kits. But then one of your kits suffers permanent back leg (BOTH LEGS) from a fallen tree. And almost gets killed TWICE. That's three times she almost got killed. Of course you would be mad at what happened to your beautiful kit. Of course you would yell. Millie doesn't mean it whenever she yells at Blossomfall. Kate stated that she loves all three of her kits equally. She's not a bad mother at all, just a traumatized angry mother. If you want to name the worst mother in Warriors, say hello to Rainflower and Cinders.

For all you complaining about how Graystripe x Silverstream is better than Millie x Graystripe, Graystripe only knew Silverstream for a few moons. He knew Millie for WAY longer. Also, so what if Millie didn't take a warrior name? Brook didn't, and everyone loves her! And yes, I don't think she was a good parent, but what would you do if your child's legs were paralyzed? The wiki also states that she wanted to spend time with ALL her kits, so she didn't hate Blossomfall. I agree that she should've been nicer to her 2 other kids, though.

Honestly I love Millie as a character, she was good for Graystripe, because since he was heartbroken and destroyed over Silverstream's death, he found someone who he could love and who could love him. And I see that people are saying that she was a bad mother for disowning 2 of her kits. But she never disowned them, she was just spending time with Briarlight because SHE WAS PARALYZED! If my kids hindquarters where squashed. I WOULD PAY MORE ATTENTION TO THEM TOO! People are comparing her to Rainflower for no reason. I believe that Rainflower disowned her kit because she thought he was going to die. And maybe Millie thought the same thing about Briarlight, or thought that she was ugly, and definitely thought, knew, that she was never going to be a warrior. But instead of disowning her kit, she took this as a chance to grow closer to Briarlight.

And I agree, she could have payed more attention to her other kits, which I think eventually happened later in the books. But as I said, ...more

Everyone who hates Millie is a complete idiot. That person who said Millie is underrated, read his/her comment. S/he covered everything I was going to say.

16 Bloodthirsty

He is a terrible cat. He was a cute kit, but then he saw dogs try to eat his brother so he killed the dog, but he started to like killing. He later escaped his twolegs (Yes he was a kittypet), tried to kill every cat in the neighborhood, then tried to take over the forest, but later got killed by Lavenderpelt from ThunderClan. However, during the battle with the Dark Forest in OOTS, he escaped and tried to plot his revenge on Lavenderpelt and kill everyone in the forest. He almost got killed by Stormtail, but still manged to join ShadowClan, who was completely unaware of him.

If you couldn't tell, I was just kidding. Bloodthirsty isn't even a real character.

A truly terrible cat. His fur is such a dark shade of black that it makes every where he goes dark. He is always covered in layers of fresh blood and eats dogs for his every meal. He's also a hunk and attracts many she-cats and has many kits but he then eats his kits and his mate and gets a new one. Truly evil and broke every warrior code, even the kitty pet one. He even ate his twolegs!

What in the name of StarClan almighty! This guys name is bloodthirsty! I have never seen the suffix thirsty, and how did he get his name! Who would name someone bloodthirsty?!?!?

Who even is this Bloodthirsty character? He's not in the books.

17 Dovewing Dovewing is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. She has pale gray fur with green, pr sky-blue, or pale gold eyes. Her first appearance is in the fourth arc, know as Omen of the Stars, in the book The Fourth Apprentice. She was part of the Power of Three, and her power was to hear and more.

Dovewing is NOT bad cat, she just doesn't give a damn about her sister.
Notorious for being a Mary-Sue like Petalnose, apparently Dovewing is too good for her poor sister Ivypool.
Dovewing also replaced our poor, beloved Hollyleaf.
Really. She's Number.10. that's all I need to say.

Dovewing: Hi Tigerheart. I have dreamed of a twolegplace no cat from clans has ever before seen, is dangerous, and we should totally raise our kits there!

Tigerheart: Good idea, but my clan is in a tough time...


Tigerheart: Uh...

Dovewing: *dramatic gasp* you-you don't care for me enough! I will raise your kits in this dangerous, mysterious place without a father to protect us, leaving me vulnerable near kitting! I am your biggest concern, not your half-gone clan!

I mean, she gets more Mary sue as the series progresses. She dumps her mate into the moonpool, and he gets his lives! That is so mean to brightwhisker, you don't see redscar throwing her onto the moonstone to get resurrected! And she thought she co old just waltz into thunderclan camp anytime if she joined shadowclan! She is my least favorite charcter.

Guys I know that Mary-Sues can be annoying but there are some in real life too. I mean you can't have everyone not be a Mary-Sue in the books. It would get really boring. Like, REALLY boring. You people call cats who are perfect mary-sues and cats that are imperfect mary-sues. Stop the stupid labelling and enjoy your lives! -Tangle

Shes a spoiled, bratty, stuck-up, whiny mary sue who is treated like a queen in thunderclan. Really. REALLY. Worst choice for a main charecter. And she treated her sister like crap and replaced hollyleaf. That's all I'm saying

18 Jayfeather Jayfeather is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He is part of The Three, along with Lionblaze and Dovewing, and has the power to read other cats' minds, emotions, and walk into other cats dreams, He was born blind. according to the Warrior Cats Wiki Jayfeather is a lean, mottled, pale gray tabby more.

I dislike Jayfeather. He's an overrated, whiny little piece of mouse-dung. I'm disappointed he isn't even in the top ten. Let's get him up there.

Just because he was a grump doesn't mean he is bad. If it weren't for him, the Clans wouldn't have existed.

LeafpoolLover, maybe Leafpool should have told Jayfeather about his parentage. But Jayfeather was a little silly about it.

He was alright at first, but during and after Sign of the Moon, he was a grumpybutt.

19 Crookedstar Crookedstar is a huge, light brown tabby tom with green eyes and a twisted jaw. more.

If you put crookedstar on here you must not read warriors you need help. Long live crookedstar

Bone -the proud leader of pack of savage souls

Crookedstar rocks! He smashed his jaw trying to chase out intruders!

What?! Crookedstar shouldn't be on here at all! What's wrong with you!?

Crooked star lived knowing his mother hated him!

20 Onestar Onestar is a fictional character from the book series "Warriors" by Erin Hunter. He is/was a WindClan leader, and is mottled, small, brown tom cat.

*Sigh* Where do I begin? We all loved Onewhisker as a warrior. He was sweet, kind, caring, and he was one of Fireheart/star's best friends! Then...BAM, he became Onestar. Not only is Onestar a stupid name, but he betrayed Firestar and fathered Darktail, a horrible killer! This dude needs to back down and let someone else take over the leadership. I was so glad when he drowned.

Onewhisker used to be my favorite character, before he became OneSTAR. He betrayed Firestar, and mated a kittypet, and fathered just about the worst cat in history, Darktail. I mean, seriously! I'm almost positive Tallstar regretted his decision later on. Onestar is truly horrible. Mudclaw is the rightful leader of WindClan.

Onewhisker was fine as a warrior, but now he's a leader (with a very stupid name) and he's acting like Firestar's enemy. Mousebrain.

Sure, Onewhisker was good, but Onestar isn't as friendly as he was back when he was a warrior.

21 Appledusk

This is my least favorite cat in all the warrior series he is a piece of fox dung he betrayed my poor poor maple Shade HE AHOULD BE 1st if it wasn't for this piece of fox dung mapleshade wouldn't have been so evil R.I.P. maple

I absolutely hate him. He literally just rejected Mapleshade! And he didn't even want to know the kits names! Go to the dark forest, jerk Appledusk.

I don't feel too sorry for Mapleshade, But you are a piece of Fox Dung. I'm glad you died.

I hate him. If it wasn't for him, Maple wouldn't be evil. She would've become leader!

22 Heathertail

U people are jerks heathertail did break the warrior code, yes. But Graystripe did, and we all love him! Right?

I hate people who hate kind, innocent cats who don't deserve to be on this list.

Heathertail is STUPID she was mince. At first but then she was just a cocky arrogant selfish brat

I hate her because she was a jerk to Lionblaze...

23 Spottedleaf Spottedleaf was a medicine cat under Bluestar's leadership in the forest territories. She was born as Spottedkit to Adderfang and Swiftbreeze alongside her littermates, Redkit and Willowkit. Initially, Spottedpaw was apprenticed to Thrushpelt; however, she decided to become a medicine cat with Featherwhisker more.

Thank the dark forest she is gone. Clawface and Mapleshade get the award for getting this cat out of existence. Fire (paw) and Spottedleaf have only been in the same Clan for like maybe 2 moons, and they're already in love? Why? She had no character development (Except for her novella, but I'm talking about The Prophecies Begin), nothing to make her actually fall in love with Firestar, and she just warns Firestar with prophecies. (That isn't bad, But nothing extremely special) Sandstorm has a whole page in one of the field guides in how she feels about Firestar, and she had major character development. That is my problem with Spottedleaf.

Well there's one thing I don't know she did not do those things!
P.S. all of those other good cats ( like firestar, cinderpelt, squirrelflight and other onesbut not all of them) didn't do those and who are you guys!

She was a mary-sue who Firestar fell in love with at the drop of a hat she was annoying and I would personally like to give Clawface a bunch of flowers for ridding us of her.

She was a good cat. She might have been a Mary-sue, but Firestar needed someone perfect in his life that he could dream about for generations. Don't vote for her.

24 Nightcloud Nightcloud is a muscular black she-cat with amber eyes. She is a warrior of WindClan who served under Onestar and Harestar's leadership. Nightcloud became mates with Crowfeather after he came back from WindClan after becoming mates with ThunderClan's Medicine Cat, Leafpool. While Nightcloud bore three more.

Worst cat for a mate in existence.

If Nightcloud were a gentle, loving cat like Leafpool, or feisty and warmhearted like Squirrelflight, it would be easier to feel sorry for her. After all, Crowfeather took her as a mate to prove he was loyal to WindClan in spite of everything of trying to run off with the ThunderClan medicine cat. But she's a difficult she-cat to like, with her short temper and her possessiveness over Crowfeather and her son, Breezepaw."

-Warriors Wiki

Enough Said.

All her problems were caused by herself. She knew (it says so in the Ultimate Guide) Crowfeather didn't love her, and yet she became his mate so that she could have kits. She also ENCOURAGED her kit to hate Crowfeather.

She was used by crow feather, how would you feel if the cat you love just used you all long and never love you.

Bone -proud leader of pack of savage souls rouge pack

I hate her...kinda

25 Oakstar
8Load More
PSearch List