ith e Sahiha, the first man who was the founder of KAWAREJ was Dhul-Khwaisrah Tamimi who raised an objection on RASOOL (SWS), although he was a firm believer of Tauheed and Aakhirat and also his prayers and quranic recitations were apparently beutiful and better than SAHABA (R.A.), but was declared out of Islam. He and his followers will continue to exit untill their last group will come out along with Dajjal before the day of Qiyamat. He and his followers will blame the vast majority of Muslims as Mushrik but they themselves will be the real unbelievers!!! Can any scholar deny these ahadith which have been found not in a few but more than one hundred Ahadith?
These people will claim to be perfect Muslims in their own false belief, and will declare the killing of other Muslims as HALAL but they will be punished by ALLAH (SWT) to the HELL fire. They are declared as the dogs of JAHANNAM and the worst creature of ALLAH (SWT) on earth. The Muslim governments are ordered to crush these groups with force, but it is also told that they will continue till the last day even in minority.
5. If you agree that all Muslims have to follow the advise of our beloved PROPHET, then please again and again read the repeatedly quoted AHADITH about KHAWAREJ and think sincerely and deeply. Then I am sure you and vast majority of Muslim youth will realize, the severity of big damage to Islam’s image, which is being caused by wrong interpretations and wrong actions by the said group of KHAWAREJ in the present era.
6. Again instead of giving any logic against the contents of the Fatwa and all references, you are simply trying to deviate from the subject.
7. again instead of giving any argument or reference, you are simply instructing to do the research. It seems there are really no arguments!
8. Yes, now you came to the topic that some scholars may allow suicide bombing in some specific reasons or specific circumstances!
a. Suicide bombing in Pakistan or any other Muslim country- certainly there are absolutely no arguments in support of such bombings, where killed people are Muslims.
b. Suicide bombing against the Invading forces like USA/ etc: In my opinion this also has two dimensions. If you read the Islamic literature and deeply think in Quran & Sunnah of the beloved holy PROPHET (SWS), you will reach the following conclusion: 1. Suicide is not the right way to fight for freedom movement 2. There must be one leader (Imam-ul-Muslimeen) who should lead such movement. 3. There must be some piece of land for the Mujahideen as a base comp from where they should coordinate all the activities. 4. Even during the war, killing of common people even non-muslims who are not participating directly in the war, killing of woman, children, old people, elimination or causing damage to trees, cultivation and other natural resources which are all a gift from ALLAH (SWT) for all the humans, is strictly prohibited.
So the real question is what is the strategy which can be adopted in order to get rid of the occupying forces and prevent the killing of Muslims as a result of their attacks? All Muslim Ummah is responsible to sincerely think over it and try to find the right way. This to be debated among the scholars of Islam around the globe. But for this purpose everyone must come out of his sectarian identification like DEOBANDI, BARELVI, SHIA, SALAFI etc. as a first step.
To achieve this goal, all the common people must create a pressure on scholars of all sects to give preference to ISLAMIC IDENTITY instead of their sectarian identity. It should be very clear that ALLAH may not forgive us all if we still insist on sectarian identities!
Then as a next step they should try to establish a separate MUSLIM COMMON WEALTH in order to make a realistic strategy. OIC can be activated for this purpose, which should be managed by Muslim Governments and guided by Islamic scholars around the globe.
But the world is a global village now a days. Muslims cannot live in absolute isolation from Non-Muslims. So every one must follow the golden rules which Islam gives us in dealing with them.
For eduction of masses over this issue everyone should participate as much as he can.
Excuse me Engr!
You need to go and take some training on comprehension.
You need to brush up your reading skills.
Plus, you need to learn how to frame questions, you asked “Is suicide bombing illegal?”. One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter. You did not mention Pakistan in the first question, therefore I answered accordingly….For Pakistan I separately wrote in the footnote so people do not get confused, but you got so confused that you tried to defeat Mr. Qadri’s 600 page fatwa on changing up pakistan!
I told you I dont believe Mr. Qadri for personal reasons. I do not follow Barelwism. I do not want to explain the specific issues I have because they are personal and I believe despite our differences Pakistanis should be united on a common platform. Therefore, I do not want to explain things related to me. Thus, I told you to do research on Mr. Qadri and come back. I also mentioned he is a great humanitarian, so I feel he is got his positive side too.
I gave my opinion and I still stand firm on it and all my answers were logical because I will follow the one who is trustworthy. More, we Muslims should be following the Quran and the Sunnah. Therefore, I do not like to follow blindly(taqlid) behind any one sect. Allah gives his human being the knowledge to distinguish between right and wrong.
And yea, no offence, brother you better start taking reading lessons…and follow the idea instead of a person!
International media coverage of this Fatwa is also available on the above link.
Excellent post. I was particularly intrigued by the notion that the message needed to spread to a wider audience (presumably through more recognizable media outlets). While I don’t disagree, this would require distilling the ideas into a smaller, more digestible format. I’d be curious if this is possible.
Although there is no shortage of fatwa’s in our country but still a fatwa declaring terrorism as irrelevant to religion from a internationally acclaimed scholar is step in right direction. I hope somehow this message gets in the head of the demented people who kill innocent people claiming to be holy warriors.
I want to say that Tahir Ul Qadiri is well known figure in Pakistan as an Islamic Intellectual with very balance approach. Lot of people know him and also believed on his statements / fatwa. While on the other hand especially in Middle East Dr. Fadal (Ammam Us Sharif) has also done a great job by showing the people that these Al-Qaida have wrong concept of Jihad. Such Muslim intellect can change / clear the mindset of fundamentalist.
While in my opinion, it is clearly mentioned in Quran that injustice murder of any person is equal to kill the whole humanity.
Moreover, when Our Holy Prophet (PBUH) went for “Fathe e Makka”, He (PBUH) clearly told his companion (razi allah taala ) that do not harm the children, women, old man, and those who close the door of their home and those who enter in the Mosque. He (PBUH) also informed them that do not damage the fields, woods and animals.
In such beautiful and peaceful religion, how suicide bombing against innocent Muslims can be justified????
Assalam-o-alaikum wa rahmatullah e wa barakatuhu!
I think you are becoming personal now, but I don’t mind. Here no personality is under discussion, this must be clear.
As believers of one ALLAH (JJ), one PROPHET (SWS) and one religion, we Muslims around the globe are all brothers, and if we think on the broader perspective, all humans are also brothers and should respect one another. This is the great true message of Islam. The word “Islam” means peace.
We are here for a positive & healthy discussion in order to find the right answers to the critical questions (in the light of QURAN & SUNNAH), which are continuously damaging Islam and Muslims, and the ways which should be adopted for solution of the problems.
1.	You are not in favor of “suicide bombing” in Pakistan and so killing the innocent people.
—OK but you have no where mentioned if these suicide bombers (killing innocent people in Pakistan) are out of Islam? yes or no? please answer categorically!!!
—Good! Are you ready to play your role also, for reducing such attacks in Pakistan? You can play your role for this great cause, as much as you can, according to your capabilities! ALLAH alone is sufficient to give the reward! What should be done in this regard? and how you can play your role?
a)	We all should think first as a “Muslim” instead of our sectarian identities like “Brelvi, Deobandi, Shia, Salafi etc. etc.” Wallah sectarianism has damaged Islam a lot! It has created hatreds in our society up to the extent that no one is ready to just listen the others having differnces.
So, are you ready to play your role for spreading this message of Islam, which is really the need of