eval_output/pwiseg_count_eval_llama3_llava_finetune.json

[
    {
        "id": "6075",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of circular spoons, thereby confirming numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of circular spoons, thereby confirming numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2473",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are '2 rongeur forceps on the table,' which is consistent with the Annotated Answer stating 'There are two rongeur forceps on the table.' Both answers indicate the same quantity of rongeur forceps, making them consistent with each other."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are '2 rongeur forceps on the table,' which is consistent with the Annotated Answer stating 'There are two rongeur forceps on the table.' Both answers indicate the same quantity of rongeur forceps, making them consistent with each other.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3070",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer provides incorrect quantities for several surgical tools compared to the Annotated Answer. Specifically, the LLM Answer states there are 2 instances of rongeur_forceps_1 and tweezers, while the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 instance of each. Additionally, the LLM Answer mentions 2 instances of tweezers, whereas the Annotated Answer states there is only 1 instance."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer provides incorrect quantities for several surgical tools compared to the Annotated Answer. Specifically, the LLM Answer states there are 2 instances of rongeur_forceps_1 and tweezers, while the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 instance of each. Additionally, the LLM Answer mentions 2 instances of tweezers, whereas the Annotated Answer states there is only 1 instance.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13026",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of stripping tools present."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of stripping tools present.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12299",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer lists six surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, stripping, and artery_forceps. The annotated answer lists seven surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, stripping, bending_shear, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, and scalpel. Additionally, the LLM answer is missing the 'bending_shear' and incorrectly lists 'wire_grabbing_pliers' before 'tweezers' and 'scalpel' in a different order."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer lists six surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, stripping, and artery_forceps. The annotated answer lists seven surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, stripping, bending_shear, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, and scalpel. Additionally, the LLM answer is missing the 'bending_shear' and incorrectly lists 'wire_grabbing_pliers' before 'tweezers' and 'scalpel' in a different order.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6945",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also confirms that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also confirms that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10392",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. The two numbers do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. The two numbers do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6860",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers, Rongeur forceps, and circular spoons. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers and circular spoons. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers, Rongeur forceps, and circular spoons. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers and circular spoons. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1880",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table. The Annotated Answer similarly indicates that there are two scalpel tools on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of the quantity of scalpel tools present."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table. The Annotated Answer similarly indicates that there are two scalpel tools on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of the quantity of scalpel tools present.\",\n  \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8387",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 bending shear on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 bending shear on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6698",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12843",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 Artery Forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 Artery Forceps on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 Artery Forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 Artery Forceps on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6832",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the top row. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the top row. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3707",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10224",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both sources indicate the same quantity of bending shear, demonstrating numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both sources indicate the same quantity of bending shear, demonstrating numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13008",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there are 2 artery forceps. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity for artery forceps."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there are 2 artery forceps. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity for artery forceps.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12828",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6752",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a numerical inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a numerical inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3745",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1984",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the same five surgical tools as the Annotated Answer: rongeur_forceps_1 (rongeur forceps), wire_grabbing_pliers (wire grabbing pliers), tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. While there is a slight variation in naming conventions, the overall content and quantity of the items are consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the same five surgical tools as the Annotated Answer: rongeur_forceps_1 (rongeur forceps), wire_grabbing_pliers (wire grabbing pliers), tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. While there is a slight variation in naming conventions, the overall content and quantity of the items are consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "624",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8037",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. The numerical values do not match, indicating that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. The numerical values do not match, indicating that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5952",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity in the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity in the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10465",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 14 surgical tools. The quantities provided by the LLM do not add up to 14. Specifically, the LLM lists the following counts: 4 tweezers, 2 artery forceps, 1 bending shear, 2 scalpels, 1 stripping instrument, 1 wire grabbing pliers, and 1 rongeur forceps. Adding these up, we get a total of 12 tools, which still does not match the annotated count of 14."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 14 surgical tools. The quantities provided by the LLM do not add up to 14. Specifically, the LLM lists the following counts: 4 tweezers, 2 artery forceps, 1 bending shear, 2 scalpels, 1 stripping instrument, 1 wire grabbing pliers, and 1 rongeur forceps. Adding these up, we get a total of 12 tools, which still does not match the annotated count of 14.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3528",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer specifies that there are 5 different types of surgical tools, but then lists 7 distinct tools: Rongeur Forceps 1, Wire Grabbing Pliers, Stripping, Tweezers, Scalpel, and Artery Forceps. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which correctly lists five types: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, bending_shear, stripping, and tweezers. Furthermore, the lists of tools do not match exactly."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer specifies that there are 5 different types of surgical tools, but then lists 7 distinct tools: Rongeur Forceps 1, Wire Grabbing Pliers, Stripping, Tweezers, Scalpel, and Artery Forceps. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which correctly lists five types: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, bending_shear, stripping, and tweezers. Furthermore, the lists of tools do not match exactly.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3455",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM's answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, while the annotated answer states there are 10 surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM's answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, while the annotated answer states there are 10 surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2884",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer of 4."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer of 4.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1684",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity, confirming their consistency."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity, confirming their consistency.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8703",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 types of surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 types of surgical tools. This discrepancy shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 types of surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 types of surgical tools. This discrepancy shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8059",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9520",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the number of artery forceps leads to the conclusion that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the number of artery forceps leads to the conclusion that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8134",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity for the wire grabbing pliers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity for the wire grabbing pliers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8171",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating the same quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating the same quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 13 surgical tools. The numerical discrepancy between these two answers shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 13 surgical tools. The numerical discrepancy between these two answers shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12023",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 surgical tools on the left side of the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 surgical tools on the left side of the table. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated information in terms of the number of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 surgical tools on the left side of the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 surgical tools on the left side of the table. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated information in terms of the number of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8736",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicates that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicates that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4816",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 3 surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 3 surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10061",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there are 2 scalpels on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there are 2 scalpels on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12270",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of 'stripping' on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating the same quantity. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer matches the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of 'stripping' on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating the same quantity. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer matches the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5061",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 unique surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 4 unique surgical tools: stripping, rongeur_forceps_2, wire_grabbing_pliers, and rongeur_forceps_1. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 unique surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 4 unique surgical tools: stripping, rongeur_forceps_2, wire_grabbing_pliers, and rongeur_forceps_1. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3463",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists five types of surgical tools: rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer lists seven types of surgical tools: artery forceps, bending shear, stripping, scalpel, rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. The LLM Answer is missing 'artery forceps' and 'bending shear'. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity and types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists five types of surgical tools: rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer lists seven types of surgical tools: artery forceps, bending shear, stripping, scalpel, rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. The LLM Answer is missing 'artery forceps' and 'bending shear'. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity and types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2344",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity specified in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity specified in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7465",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities provided by the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities provided by the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12329",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 2 instances of the scalpel and 2 instances of the tweezers on the table. The Annotated Answer, however, specifies that there are three instances of artery_forceps and two instances of scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer as it does not mention the artery forceps and incorrectly attributes quantities to the tweezers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 2 instances of the scalpel and 2 instances of the tweezers on the table. The Annotated Answer, however, specifies that there are three instances of artery_forceps and two instances of scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer as it does not mention the artery forceps and incorrectly attributes quantities to the tweezers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7588",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 14 surgical tools on the table. This discrepancy in the quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 14 surgical tools on the table. This discrepancy in the quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11893",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpel on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is numerically accurate and aligns with the annotated information."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpel on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is numerically accurate and aligns with the annotated information.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8748",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, but the Annotated Answer states there are 12 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer also lists individual counts of various types of surgical tools (2 rongeur forceps, 1 wire grabbing pliers, 1 stripping tool, 2 scalpel tools, 4 tweezers tools, 2 artery forceps, and 1 bending shear), which total to 13 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, but the Annotated Answer states there are 12 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer also lists individual counts of various types of surgical tools (2 rongeur forceps, 1 wire grabbing pliers, 1 stripping tool, 2 scalpel tools, 4 tweezers tools, 2 artery forceps, and 1 bending shear), which total to 13 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "937",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the number provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the number provided in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3988",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which matches the quantity given in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which matches the quantity given in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1483",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 types of surgical tools: rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 types of surgical tools: rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9646",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4105",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8956",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a numerical discrepancy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a numerical discrepancy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12627",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery_forceps on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery_forceps on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11243",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer explicitly mention the presence of two scalpel tools, indicating numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer explicitly mention the presence of two scalpel tools, indicating numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5985",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 core_needle on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 core_needle on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM's response matches the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 core_needle on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 core_needle on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM's response matches the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10460",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10109",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning the scalpel and the tweezers. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are duplicates of artery forceps, bending shear, scalpel, and rongeur forceps. The LLM Answer only correctly identifies the scalpel and misses the other duplicates (artery forceps, bending shear, and rongeur forceps) while incorrectly identifying tweezers as a duplicate. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantities and specific items reported."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning the scalpel and the tweezers. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are duplicates of artery forceps, bending shear, scalpel, and rongeur forceps. The LLM Answer only correctly identifies the scalpel and misses the other duplicates (artery forceps, bending shear, and rongeur forceps) while incorrectly identifying tweezers as a duplicate. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantities and specific items reported.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12376",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, thus the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, thus the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1799",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 11 surgical tools on the table, but the list provided actually contains 14 distinct items. The Annotated Answer correctly indicates 14 surgical tools, showing that the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 11 surgical tools on the table, but the list provided actually contains 14 distinct items. The Annotated Answer correctly indicates 14 surgical tools, showing that the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5725",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 core needle on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the annotated answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 core needle on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the annotated answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5340",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there is 1 circular_spoon on the table. This matches the Annotated Answer, which also indicates the presence of 1 circular_spoon. Therefore, the model's response is consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there is 1 circular_spoon on the table. This matches the Annotated Answer, which also indicates the presence of 1 circular_spoon. Therefore, the model's response is consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6000",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3559",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the annotated answer that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the minor difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical quantity is consistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the annotated answer that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the minor difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical quantity is consistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "542",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of scalpel on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer. Both answers are consistent and indicate the same quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of scalpel on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer. Both answers are consistent and indicate the same quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10740",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, but the Annotated Answer lists 6 different types of surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. This discrepancy in the count of surgical tools makes the LLM Answer incorrect."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, but the Annotated Answer lists 6 different types of surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. This discrepancy in the count of surgical tools makes the LLM Answer incorrect.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2127",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. The Annotated Answer also confirms that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the numbers match and the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. The Annotated Answer also confirms that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the numbers match and the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9673",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 scalpel on the table. Both answers match in terms of the numerical quantity provided."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 scalpel on the table. Both answers match in terms of the numerical quantity provided.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9240",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that the artery forceps appear twice on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also mentions the artery forceps appearing twice on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that the artery forceps appear twice on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also mentions the artery forceps appearing twice on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9839",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7075",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3643",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer state that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer state that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "538",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 unique surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 unique surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer lists instances for 7 distinct tools: rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, stripping, artery_forceps, and bending_shear. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data regarding the number of unique surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 unique surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 unique surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer lists instances for 7 distinct tools: rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, stripping, artery_forceps, and bending_shear. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data regarding the number of unique surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12612",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating that there are two artery forceps on the table. Both responses acknowledge the presence of duplicate items, aligning in terms of indicating that there are repeated tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating that there are two artery forceps on the table. Both responses acknowledge the presence of duplicate items, aligning in terms of indicating that there are repeated tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3314",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table is rongeur_forceps_1. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the bending_shear is the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer, and the numerical information regarding the position of the tools is inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table is rongeur_forceps_1. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the bending_shear is the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer, and the numerical information regarding the position of the tools is inconsistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8459",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping instrument on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers indicate the presence of 1 stripping instrument."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping instrument on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers indicate the presence of 1 stripping instrument.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12786",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 bending_shear on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 3 bending_shear. The numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity specified in the Annotated Answer, therefore it is inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 bending_shear on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 3 bending_shear. The numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity specified in the Annotated Answer, therefore it is inconsistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13202",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 different types of surgical tools on the table. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 different types of surgical tools on the table. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8052",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that indicates there is 1 stripping. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that indicates there is 1 stripping. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5312",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 aspirator on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 1 aspirator on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 aspirator on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 1 aspirator on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3299",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer aligns with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer aligns with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12562",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1121",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer. Both answers are consistent in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8542",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3902",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9517",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is correct and the answers align."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is correct and the answers align.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "360",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 scalpel tools on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 scalpel tools on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9316",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery_forceps tools. This discrepancy in the numerical count means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery_forceps tools. This discrepancy in the numerical count means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11882",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the tool with the smallest area on the table is the scalpel, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool with the smallest area on the table is the tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the tool with the smallest area on the table is the scalpel, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool with the smallest area on the table is the tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2470",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which aligns with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are two artery forceps on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of the numerical count of artery forceps."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which aligns with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are two artery forceps on the table. Both answers are consistent in terms of the numerical count of artery forceps.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "927",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there is 1 bending shear tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same quantity, hence the response is accurate."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there is 1 bending shear tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same quantity, hence the response is accurate.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1953",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning two scalpel tools. This aligns with the Annotated Answer, which confirms that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table. Both answers agree on the presence of duplicates, which fulfills the requirement of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning two scalpel tools. This aligns with the Annotated Answer, which confirms that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table. Both answers agree on the presence of duplicates, which fulfills the requirement of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9626",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. This discrepancy shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. This discrepancy shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1226",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 instances of the tweezers tool on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 instance of the tweezers tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 instances of the tweezers tool on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 instance of the tweezers tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10855",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6946",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8772",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1022",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also states there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also states there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4148",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table in total, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table in total, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12722",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 unique positions of surgical tools on the table. However, based on the provided positions: bottom right (wire grabbing pliers), top left and top right (rongeur forceps), middle left and middle right (artery forceps), top center (bending shear), and bottom left (stripping tool), there are actually 5 unique positions (top left, top right, middle left, middle right, top center, bottom left, and bottom right). Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 unique positions of surgical tools on the table. However, based on the provided positions: bottom right (wire grabbing pliers), top left and top right (rongeur forceps), middle left and middle right (artery forceps), top center (bending shear), and bottom left (stripping tool), there are actually 5 unique positions (top left, top right, middle left, middle right, top center, bottom left, and bottom right). Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated answer.\",\n  \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8899",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the annotated answer that indicates there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the slight difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical count is consistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the annotated answer that indicates there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the slight difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical count is consistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4441",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly identifies that there are two surgical tools used for cutting or stripping: the scalpel and the stripping tool. This matches the quantity and tools listed in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly identifies that there are two surgical tools used for cutting or stripping: the scalpel and the stripping tool. This matches the quantity and tools listed in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2201",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the most frequently appearing surgical tool on the table is the scalpel, with 2 instances. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the artery forceps appear three times, which is higher in frequency compared to the scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the most frequently appearing surgical tool on the table is the scalpel, with 2 instances. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the artery forceps appear three times, which is higher in frequency compared to the scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2619",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 6 surgical tools on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 6 surgical tools on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2407",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one tool placed at the bottom center of the table, while the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are no tools placed at the bottom center of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one tool placed at the bottom center of the table, while the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are no tools placed at the bottom center of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1383",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, but it does not specify which tools are duplicated. The Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools are tweezers, artery forceps, and rongeur forceps. The lack of detail in the LLM Answer makes it inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, but it does not specify which tools are duplicated. The Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools are tweezers, artery forceps, and rongeur forceps. The lack of detail in the LLM Answer makes it inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1393",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1433",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 6 unique surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 7 unique surgical tools. Given the detailed breakdown of instances provided in the LLM Answer, it mentioned tools such as rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, wire_grabbing_pliers, stripping, artery_forceps, and bending_shear. These sum up to 7 unique tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 6 unique surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 7 unique surgical tools. Given the detailed breakdown of instances provided in the LLM Answer, it mentioned tools such as rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, wire_grabbing_pliers, stripping, artery_forceps, and bending_shear. These sum up to 7 unique tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3891",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of artery_forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 instances of artery_forceps on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of artery_forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there are 2 instances of artery_forceps on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3434",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer confirming the same quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer confirming the same quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "902",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there are 2 bending shears on the table, which matches the annotated answer. Therefore, the answer is consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there are 2 bending shears on the table, which matches the annotated answer. Therefore, the answer is consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11629",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity, ensuring that the information is aligned and accurate."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity, ensuring that the information is aligned and accurate.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2442",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating there is 1 stripping tool."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer indicating there is 1 stripping tool.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1602",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction is inconsistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction is inconsistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2865",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are two scalpel tools on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy aligns between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are two scalpel tools on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy aligns between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11958",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, scalpel, and tweezers,' which totals five tools. The Annotated Answer lists the surgical tools as 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers,' which totals six tools. Additionally, the name 'stripping' is missing in the LLM Answer, and 'rongeur_forceps_1' appears twice in the LLM Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, scalpel, and tweezers,' which totals five tools. The Annotated Answer lists the surgical tools as 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers,' which totals six tools. Additionally, the name 'stripping' is missing in the LLM Answer, and 'rongeur_forceps_1' appears twice in the LLM Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10520",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is numerically accurate and in alignment with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is numerically accurate and in alignment with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "304",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 stripping on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 stripping on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11321",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools on the table as rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. The Annotated Answer lists them as rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping. Both answers contain the tools rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping, but the Annotated Answer lists 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer lists it only once. Therefore, the quantities of the tools do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools on the table as rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. The Annotated Answer lists them as rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping. Both answers contain the tools rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping, but the Annotated Answer lists 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer lists it only once. Therefore, the quantities of the tools do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1010",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 rongeur forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 rongeur forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1783",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of rongeur_forceps_1, 2 instances of scalpel, 1 instance of wire_grabbing_pliers, and 1 instance of stripping. However, the Annotated Answer indicates there is one instance of each surgical tool: stripping, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The quantities in the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer, which specifies a single instance for each tool."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of rongeur_forceps_1, 2 instances of scalpel, 1 instance of wire_grabbing_pliers, and 1 instance of stripping. However, the Annotated Answer indicates there is one instance of each surgical tool: stripping, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The quantities in the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer, which specifies a single instance for each tool.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "833",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. This is consistent with the provided annotated data where items 13 and 24 are listed as 'Artery forceps'. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. This is consistent with the provided annotated data where items 13 and 24 are listed as 'Artery forceps'. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9417",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1730",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery_forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel. The discrepancy lies in the number of tweezers, where the LLM Answer mentions 2, but the Annotated Answer mentions 3."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery_forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel. The discrepancy lies in the number of tweezers, where the LLM Answer mentions 2, but the Annotated Answer mentions 3.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "168",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM's answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, which aligns with the annotated answer indicating that there are duplicate artery forceps on the table. Both answers confirm the presence of duplicate surgical tools, so the LLM's response is consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM's answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, which aligns with the annotated answer indicating that there are duplicate artery forceps on the table. Both answers confirm the presence of duplicate surgical tools, so the LLM's response is consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6784",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire_grabbing_pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are no wire_grabbing_pliers on the left side of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire_grabbing_pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are no wire_grabbing_pliers on the left side of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5803",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 3 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 different types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data in terms of quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 3 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 different types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data in terms of quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "311",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also confirms the presence of two scalpel surgical tools on the table. Both answers align in terms of the quantity of scalpel tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also confirms the presence of two scalpel surgical tools on the table. Both answers align in terms of the quantity of scalpel tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1595",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping,' whereas the Annotated Answer lists them as 'scalpel, stripping, scalpel, tweezers, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1.' There is a discrepancy in the quantities and names: the Annotated Answer mentions 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer lists 'scalpel' only once. Additionally, the order of the tools is different."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping,' whereas the Annotated Answer lists them as 'scalpel, stripping, scalpel, tweezers, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1.' There is a discrepancy in the quantities and names: the Annotated Answer mentions 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer lists 'scalpel' only once. Additionally, the order of the tools is different.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1078",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, but the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 stripping tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, but the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 stripping tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2954",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of tweezers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both indicate the same quantity of tweezers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5824",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12139",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2348",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The question asks about the number of scalpels on the table. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer indicate that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The question asks about the number of scalpels on the table. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer indicate that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2980",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer stating that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the slight difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical quantity is accurate and matches the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer stating that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Despite the slight difference in wording ('pliers' vs. 'plier'), the numerical quantity is accurate and matches the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7652",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 11 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 7 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 11 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2766",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpels on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpels on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13304",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Both answers indicate the quantity as 1, making them consistent with each other in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. Both answers indicate the quantity as 1, making them consistent with each other in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9713",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 stripping tool on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 stripping tool on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6482",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicates that there are multiple instances of several surgical tools on the table, including wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps, scalpel instruments, and artery forceps. This aligns with the Annotated Answer, which confirms the presence of duplicate wire grabbing pliers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of identifying the presence of duplicate surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicates that there are multiple instances of several surgical tools on the table, including wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps, scalpel instruments, and artery forceps. This aligns with the Annotated Answer, which confirms the presence of duplicate wire grabbing pliers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of identifying the presence of duplicate surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10431",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12848",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are 2 bending shears on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction does not match the annotated information in terms of quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are 2 bending shears on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction does not match the annotated information in terms of quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8192",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also mentions 2 artery forceps."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also mentions 2 artery forceps.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6259",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated information in terms of quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the annotated information in terms of quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4238",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both specify the same number of different types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both specify the same number of different types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "457",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool 'stripping' appears the least on the table and specifically mentions that it appears only once. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also states that 'stripping' appears only once. Both answers agree on the tool and its frequency, ensuring numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool 'stripping' appears the least on the table and specifically mentions that it appears only once. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also states that 'stripping' appears only once. Both answers agree on the tool and its frequency, ensuring numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5216",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer which also states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer aligns correctly with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer which also states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer aligns correctly with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8763",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table.\",\n  \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13302",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer states that there are 4 tweezers, while the annotated answer clearly mentions that there are 5 tweezers on the table. The numerical values do not match, indicating inconsistency between the LLM answer and the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM answer states that there are 4 tweezers, while the annotated answer clearly mentions that there are 5 tweezers on the table. The numerical values do not match, indicating inconsistency between the LLM answer and the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11511",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of the tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one instance of the tweezers on the table. The numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 instances of the tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one instance of the tweezers on the table. The numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "181",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 artery forceps tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 artery forceps tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3315",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 surgical tools on the right side of the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 surgical tools on the right side of the table. This discrepancy in the number of surgical tools makes the LLM Answer inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 surgical tools on the right side of the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 surgical tools on the right side of the table. This discrepancy in the number of surgical tools makes the LLM Answer inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7499",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table but does not specify which tools are duplicated. The Annotated Answer provides specific information that there are duplicates of the scalpel, rongeur forceps 1, and artery forceps. The LLM Answer lacks the detail required to be fully consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table but does not specify which tools are duplicated. The Annotated Answer provides specific information that there are duplicates of the scalpel, rongeur forceps 1, and artery forceps. The LLM Answer lacks the detail required to be fully consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10523",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the following surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer lists wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, scalpel, tweezers, bending shear, artery forceps, and stripping. The LLM Answer is missing bending shear and artery forceps, which are present in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the following surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, tweezers, scalpel, and stripping. However, the Annotated Answer lists wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, scalpel, tweezers, bending shear, artery forceps, and stripping. The LLM Answer is missing bending shear and artery forceps, which are present in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "978",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear instrument on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer correctly states that there is 1 bending shear instrument on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8745",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers match in terms of the quantity of wire grabbing pliers on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both answers match in terms of the quantity of wire grabbing pliers on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1935",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer provided. Both answers indicate the presence of 2 artery forceps, so the numerical accuracy is maintained."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer provided. Both answers indicate the presence of 2 artery forceps, so the numerical accuracy is maintained.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12241",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery_forceps tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery_forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery_forceps tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10386",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 4 tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 tweezers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3404",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both provide the same quantity of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both provide the same quantity of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "63",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one tweezers on the table, and the Annotated Answer confirms that there is 1 pair of tweezers on the table. The numerical quantity is consistent between both answers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one tweezers on the table, and the Annotated Answer confirms that there is 1 pair of tweezers on the table. The numerical quantity is consistent between both answers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "586",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer identifies two instances of scalpel tools but fails to mention the duplicate instances of rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, artery forceps, bending shear, and stripping tools, which are noted in the Annotated Answer. The Annotated Answer specifies two instances of rongeur forceps and four instances of tweezers, which are not mentioned in the LLM Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not fully align with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer identifies two instances of scalpel tools but fails to mention the duplicate instances of rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, artery forceps, bending shear, and stripping tools, which are noted in the Annotated Answer. The Annotated Answer specifies two instances of rongeur forceps and four instances of tweezers, which are not mentioned in the LLM Answer. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not fully align with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7055",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one duplicate circular spoon on the table, indicating the presence of at least two circular spoons (one original and one duplicate). However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is only 1 circular spoon on the table. This discrepancy in the number of circular spoons indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one duplicate circular spoon on the table, indicating the presence of at least two circular spoons (one original and one duplicate). However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is only 1 circular spoon on the table. This discrepancy in the number of circular spoons indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5960",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 circular spoon on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 circular spoon on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is 1 circular spoon on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12138",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are 3 scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, thus the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are 3 scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, thus the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11616",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that confirms there are five different types of surgical tools on the table. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that confirms there are five different types of surgical tools on the table. Both answers match in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1217",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also specifies that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one wire grabbing pliers on the table. This is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which also specifies that there is 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy is maintained.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9244",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the stripping appears once on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both provide the same numerical information."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the stripping appears once on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both provide the same numerical information.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3219",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the most frequent surgical tools on the table are tweezers and scalpel, each with 4 instances. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the most frequent tools are artery forceps and tweezers, each with 3 instances. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the most frequent tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the most frequent surgical tools on the table are tweezers and scalpel, each with 4 instances. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the most frequent tools are artery forceps and tweezers, each with 3 instances. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the most frequent tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10675",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that mentions there are two artery forceps on the table. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity of artery forceps."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that mentions there are two artery forceps on the table. Both answers provide the same numerical quantity of artery forceps.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4889",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 6 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "8382",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which indicates that there is one bending shear on the table. Both answers align in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer, which indicates that there is one bending shear on the table. Both answers align in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9586",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that all the surgical tools are present on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that confirms no surgical tools are missing. Both answers agree on the quantity, indicating that there are no missing surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that all the surgical tools are present on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that confirms no surgical tools are missing. Both answers agree on the quantity, indicating that there are no missing surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12111",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer stated that there is one stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is one stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer matches the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer stated that there is one stripping tool on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there is one stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical accuracy of the LLM Answer matches the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5564",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n  \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5418",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 aspirator on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that states there is one aspirator on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 aspirator on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that states there is one aspirator on the table.\",\n  \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11919",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, scalpel, and tweezers. The Annotated Answer lists the tools as stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The LLM Answer is missing 'stripping' and has the tools in a different order than the Annotated Answer. Additionally, the total number of tools is different: the Annotated Answer lists six tools, while the LLM Answer lists five tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, scalpel, and tweezers. The Annotated Answer lists the tools as stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The LLM Answer is missing 'stripping' and has the tools in a different order than the Annotated Answer. Additionally, the total number of tools is different: the Annotated Answer lists six tools, while the LLM Answer lists five tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3393",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping,' which differs from the Annotated Answer that lists the tools as 'wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, scalpel, and stripping.' Notably, the Annotated Answer mentions 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer mentions it only once. This discrepancy in the quantity of scalpels means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists the surgical tools as 'rongeur_forceps_1, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping,' which differs from the Annotated Answer that lists the tools as 'wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, scalpel, and stripping.' Notably, the Annotated Answer mentions 'scalpel' twice, while the LLM Answer mentions it only once. This discrepancy in the quantity of scalpels means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9552",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery forceps tools on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count means the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 3 artery forceps tools on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count means the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2628",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 6 different types of surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 5 different types of surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 6 different types of surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9983",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there is one bending shear on the table. The numerical accuracy and the object in question both match perfectly."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there is one bending shear on the table. The numerical accuracy and the object in question both match perfectly.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4344",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 bending shear on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 bending shear on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1006",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer provided. Both sources indicate the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 6 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer provided. Both sources indicate the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10854",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer states there are 3 scalpel tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer states there are 3 scalpel tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10148",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 bending shear on the table. The numerical accuracy is maintained."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 bending shear on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 bending shear on the table. The numerical accuracy is maintained.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6252",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire_grabbing_pliers on the right side of the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 5 wire_grabbing_pliers on the right side of the table. The numbers do not match, indicating a numerical inaccuracy in the LLM Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 wire_grabbing_pliers on the right side of the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 5 wire_grabbing_pliers on the right side of the table. The numbers do not match, indicating a numerical inaccuracy in the LLM Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "608",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 bending_shear at the top of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending_shear at the top of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 bending_shear at the top of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending_shear at the top of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11877",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is one stripping tool on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is one stripping tool on the table, which matches the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3128",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpel tools on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 scalpel tools on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "977",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide the same numerical information regarding the number of scalpels."
    },
    "{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 scalpels on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer. Both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide the same numerical information regarding the number of scalpels.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "8814",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer both state that the name 'artery_forceps' is mentioned 2 times in the list. However, upon closer inspection of the provided list, 'artery_forceps' is actually mentioned 3 times (items 8, 15, and 22). Thus, both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer are incorrect, and the correct answer should be 3 times."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer both state that the name 'artery_forceps' is mentioned 2 times in the list. However, upon closer inspection of the provided list, 'artery_forceps' is actually mentioned 3 times (items 8, 15, and 22). Thus, both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer are incorrect, and the correct answer should be 3 times.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2864",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 1 instance of stripping on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction aligns with the annotated information in terms of quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 instance of stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 1 instance of stripping on the table. Therefore, the LLM's prediction aligns with the annotated information in terms of quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3120",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also indicates there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13201",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate tools on the table, specifically mentioning only two scalpel tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are also other duplicate tools, including 2 rongeur forceps and 4 tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is incomplete and does not fully align with the Annotated Answer regarding the quantities of all duplicate tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate tools on the table, specifically mentioning only two scalpel tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are also other duplicate tools, including 2 rongeur forceps and 4 tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is incomplete and does not fully align with the Annotated Answer regarding the quantities of all duplicate tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7654",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also states there are 2 artery forceps on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table, which is consistent with the annotated answer that also states there are 2 artery forceps on the table.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6836",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table in total, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 9 surgical tools on the table in total. These quantities are not consistent with each other."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table in total, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 9 surgical tools on the table in total. These quantities are not consistent with each other.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3873",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. The numbers provided do not match, thus the LLM's prediction is inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 11 surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 15 surgical tools. The numbers provided do not match, thus the LLM's prediction is inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1372",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping on the table."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also states there is 1 stripping on the table.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "518",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, and stripping as the surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer includes an additional tool: a scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is missing one item, making it inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity and types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, and stripping as the surgical tools on the table. However, the Annotated Answer includes an additional tool: a scalpel. Therefore, the LLM Answer is missing one item, making it inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity and types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2290",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's prediction states that there are 4 tweezers tools on the table, whereas the annotated answer specifies that there is only one tweezers tool on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    }
]