eval_output/pwiseg_count_eval_llama3_llava.json

[
    {
        "id": "6075",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer explicitly mentions that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer explicitly mentions that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2473",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that states there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "3070",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists two pairs of scissors and one pair of forceps. However, the Annotated Answer lists different tools and their quantities: 2 instances of scalpel, 1 instance of stripping, 1 instance of tweezers, 1 instance of rongeur_forceps_1, and 1 instance of wire_grabbing_pliers. The tools mentioned in the LLM Answer do not match any of the tools listed in the Annotated Answer, and the quantities are also inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists two pairs of scissors and one pair of forceps. However, the Annotated Answer lists different tools and their quantities: 2 instances of scalpel, 1 instance of stripping, 1 instance of tweezers, 1 instance of rongeur_forceps_1, and 1 instance of wire_grabbing_pliers. The tools mentioned in the LLM Answer do not match any of the tools listed in the Annotated Answer, and the quantities are also inconsistent.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13026",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the stripping tools on the table. It mentions the presence of various medical instruments but does not quantify them, nor does it identify any specific tool as a 'stripping tool.' The Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated information, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the stripping tools on the table. It mentions the presence of various medical instruments but does not quantify them, nor does it identify any specific tool as a 'stripping tool.' The Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated information, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12299",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists 10 different surgical tools, including scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tongs, hemostats, scalpels, tweezers, pliers, and a suction cannula. The Annotated Answer, however, lists only 7 tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, stripping, bending_shear, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, and scalpel. There is a clear discrepancy in both the number and names of the tools between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists 10 different surgical tools, including scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tongs, hemostats, scalpels, tweezers, pliers, and a suction cannula. The Annotated Answer, however, lists only 7 tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, stripping, bending_shear, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, and scalpel. There is a clear discrepancy in both the number and names of the tools between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6945",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no spoons on the table and describes the presence of surgical instruments instead. However, the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no spoons on the table and describes the presence of surgical instruments instead. However, the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there is 1 unique circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10392",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer provides a general description of the surgical tools present on the table and mentions that there are multiple instruments. However, it does not specify the exact number of surgical tools. The Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer provides a general description of the surgical tools present on the table and mentions that there are multiple instruments. However, it does not specify the exact number of surgical tools. The Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6860",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer identifies several types of surgical instruments including scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, and other unidentified instruments, making a rough estimate of the count. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which clearly states there are only 2 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers and circular spoons. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated quantity or types of tools accurately."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer identifies several types of surgical instruments including scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, and other unidentified instruments, making a rough estimate of the count. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which clearly states there are only 2 types of surgical tools on the table: wire grabbing pliers and circular spoons. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated quantity or types of tools accurately.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1880",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are two pairs of scissors on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there are two scalpels on the table. The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not agree on the type of surgical tools that are duplicated, even though they both mention a quantity of two."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are two pairs of scissors on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there are two scalpels on the table. The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not agree on the type of surgical tools that are duplicated, even though they both mention a quantity of two.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8387",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only one bending shear on the table. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only one bending shear on the table. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6698",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The LLM Answer, however, does not provide an exact count and only mentions that there are several rongeur forceps visible in the image. This lack of specificity and numerical inconsistency means that the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The LLM Answer, however, does not provide an exact count and only mentions that there are several rongeur forceps visible in the image. This lack of specificity and numerical inconsistency means that the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12843",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 'two pairs of Artery Forceps,' which implies a total of 4 Artery Forceps. However, the Annotated Answer states there are 2 Artery Forceps. Therefore, the quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 'two pairs of Artery Forceps,' which implies a total of 4 Artery Forceps. However, the Annotated Answer states there are 2 Artery Forceps. Therefore, the quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6832",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the top row of the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3707",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer states that there are three instances of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the annotated answer specifies that there is only one instance. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer states that there are three instances of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the annotated answer specifies that there is only one instance. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10224",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table (two pairs), whereas the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. This discrepancy shows that the LLM's numerical assessment is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table (two pairs), whereas the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. This discrepancy shows that the LLM's numerical assessment is not consistent with the annotated data.\",\n  \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13008",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 'at least three pairs of forceps visible,' whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 artery forceps. The LLM Answer's count does not match the annotated data, which clearly indicates a different quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 'at least three pairs of forceps visible,' whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 artery forceps. The LLM Answer's count does not match the annotated data, which clearly indicates a different quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12828",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The question asked about the number of bending shears on the table. The LLM answer stated there are 12 pairs of scissors, which is inconsistent with the annotated answer that specifies there is 1 bending shear on the table. Therefore, the LLM answer does not match the annotated information in terms of quantities or the specified item."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The question asked about the number of bending shears on the table. The LLM answer stated there are 12 pairs of scissors, which is inconsistent with the annotated answer that specifies there is 1 bending shear on the table. Therefore, the LLM answer does not match the annotated information in terms of quantities or the specified item.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6752",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. The numerical values provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 5 wire grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. The numerical values provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3745",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are three. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are three. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1984",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's prediction lists different surgical tools than the annotated answer. The LLM answer includes scissors, forceps, needle holder, and retractor, whereas the annotated answer lists scalpel, rongeur forceps, stripping, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. The tools named are not consistent between the two answers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The large language model's prediction lists different surgical tools than the annotated answer. The LLM answer includes scissors, forceps, needle holder, and retractor, whereas the annotated answer lists scalpel, rongeur forceps, stripping, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. The tools named are not consistent between the two answers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "624",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three bending shear tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear tool on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three bending shear tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear tool on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8037",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 15 surgical tools. The numerical values do not match, meaning the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 15 surgical tools. The numerical values do not match, meaning the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5952",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities provided do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities provided do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10465",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table. It mentions several instruments but does not quantify them accurately. The Annotated Answer clearly states there are 14 surgical tools on the table, which the LLM Answer fails to match or confirm."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table. It mentions several instruments but does not quantify them accurately. The Annotated Answer clearly states there are 14 surgical tools on the table, which the LLM Answer fails to match or confirm.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3528",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the different types of surgical tools, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 distinct types of surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, bending_shear, stripping, and tweezers. The LLM Answer lists different types of instruments but does not confirm the count or match the specific types provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the different types of surgical tools, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 5 distinct types of surgical tools: rongeur_forceps_1, artery_forceps, bending_shear, stripping, and tweezers. The LLM Answer lists different types of instruments but does not confirm the count or match the specific types provided in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3455",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer states that it cannot provide an exact count of the surgical tools due to the image being rotated and unclear. However, the annotated answer explicitly states that there are 10 surgical tools on the table. Hence, the LLM answer does not provide the specific numerical count required and is inconsistent with the annotated answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer states that it cannot provide an exact count of the surgical tools due to the image being rotated and unclear. However, the annotated answer explicitly states that there are 10 surgical tools on the table. Hence, the LLM answer does not provide the specific numerical count required and is inconsistent with the annotated answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2884",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four tweezers on the table, which is numerically consistent with the Annotated Answer of '4'. Both answers represent the same quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four tweezers on the table, which is numerically consistent with the Annotated Answer of '4'. Both answers represent the same quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1684",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a clear count of the stripping tools on the table. It mentions several pairs of scissors and some forceps but does not specify the number of stripping tools. The Annotated Answer explicitly states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a clear count of the stripping tools on the table. It mentions several pairs of scissors and some forceps but does not specify the number of stripping tools. The Annotated Answer explicitly states there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8703",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists six different types of surgical tools: scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tissue forceps, and a clamp. However, the Annotated Answer states there are seven types of surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists six different types of surgical tools: scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tissue forceps, and a clamp. However, the Annotated Answer states there are seven types of surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8059",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer does not address the specific term 'bending_shear' and instead talks about scissors and shears, interpreting the term as a potential typo. The annotated answer clearly states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which the LLM answer does not mention or confirm. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer does not address the specific term 'bending_shear' and instead talks about scissors and shears, interpreting the term as a potential typo. The annotated answer clearly states that there is 1 bending_shear on the table, which the LLM answer does not mention or confirm. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9520",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of six artery forceps (3 pairs x 2 forceps per pair). The Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of six artery forceps (3 pairs x 2 forceps per pair). The Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8134",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are at least four pairs of wire grabbing pliers visible in the image, while the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. This discrepancy in quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are at least four pairs of wire grabbing pliers visible in the image, while the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. This discrepancy in quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8171",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire-grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire-grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire_grabbing_pliers on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that it cannot provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table and only mentions that there are several tools. In contrast, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical quantity that can be compared to the annotated number, which is crucial for consistency in this context."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that it cannot provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table and only mentions that there are several tools. In contrast, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are 13 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical quantity that can be compared to the annotated number, which is crucial for consistency in this context.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12023",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six surgical tools on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 surgical tools on the left side of the table. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating that the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six surgical tools on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 surgical tools on the left side of the table. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating that the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8736",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of six individual artery forceps tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps tools on the table. The quantities mentioned in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of six individual artery forceps tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps tools on the table. The quantities mentioned in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4816",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three surgical tools on the table, which matches exactly with the Annotated Answer stating the same quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three surgical tools on the table, which matches exactly with the Annotated Answer stating the same quantity.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10061",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer estimated that there are at least a dozen scalpels visible on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 scalpels. The LLM Answer's estimation is significantly higher than the annotated count, making it inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer estimated that there are at least a dozen scalpels visible on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 scalpels. The LLM Answer's estimation is significantly higher than the annotated count, making it inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12270",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two instances of 'stripping' on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only one instance. This discrepancy shows that the LLM's numerical count is inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two instances of 'stripping' on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only one instance. This discrepancy shows that the LLM's numerical count is inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5061",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the unique surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 4 unique surgical tools. The LLM Answer only mentions that there are several different types of instruments visible but does not quantify them, thus it is inconsistent with the annotated data which precisely enumerates the tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the unique surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 4 unique surgical tools. The LLM Answer only mentions that there are several different types of instruments visible but does not quantify them, thus it is inconsistent with the annotated data which precisely enumerates the tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3463",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists 8 different types of surgical instruments, which include forceps, scissors, needle holders, tissue forceps, hemostats, and artery forceps with details on blade types. The Annotated Answer, however, lists a different set of tools \u2014 artery forceps, bending shear, stripping, scalpel, rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. There are discrepancies in the types of instruments mentioned between the two answers. For instance, the Annotated Answer mentions a scalpel and wire grabbing pliers which are not mentioned in the LLM Answer, and the LLM Answer mentions items like needle holders and hemostats which are not listed in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the answers are not consistent with each other."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists 8 different types of surgical instruments, which include forceps, scissors, needle holders, tissue forceps, hemostats, and artery forceps with details on blade types. The Annotated Answer, however, lists a different set of tools \u2014 artery forceps, bending shear, stripping, scalpel, rongeur forceps, wire grabbing pliers, and tweezers. There are discrepancies in the types of instruments mentioned between the two answers. For instance, the Annotated Answer mentions a scalpel and wire grabbing pliers which are not mentioned in the LLM Answer, and the LLM Answer mentions items like needle holders and hemostats which are not listed in the Annotated Answer. Therefore, the answers are not consistent with each other.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2344",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 5 tweezers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 5 tweezers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7465",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"yes\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12329",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two instances of the same surgical tool (a pair of scissors) on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are three instances of artery_forceps and two instances of scalpel on the table. The LLM Answer does not mention artery_forceps or scalpel, and it incorrectly identifies the quantity and type of surgical tools present. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of numerical accuracy and the specific types of tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two instances of the same surgical tool (a pair of scissors) on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are three instances of artery_forceps and two instances of scalpel on the table. The LLM Answer does not mention artery_forceps or scalpel, and it incorrectly identifies the quantity and type of surgical tools present. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of numerical accuracy and the specific types of tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7588",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 instruments visible but acknowledges the difficulty in providing an accurate count. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 14 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated quantity and thus is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 instruments visible but acknowledges the difficulty in providing an accurate count. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 14 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not match the annotated quantity and thus is not consistent with the annotated data.\",\n  \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11893",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions 'three pairs of scissors' which is unrelated to the question about the number of scalpels on the table. The Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the numerical quantity and the object in question."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions 'three pairs of scissors' which is unrelated to the question about the number of scalpels on the table. The Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the numerical quantity and the object in question.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8748",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table, stating that the image is slightly blurry and that it cannot provide an exact number. In contrast, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table, stating that the image is slightly blurry and that it cannot provide an exact number. In contrast, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "937",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3988",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1483",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer categorizes surgical instruments into 7 broad types: Cutting instruments, Retracting instruments, Holding instruments, Grasping instruments, Measuring instruments, Suction instruments, and Miscellaneous instruments. This categorization aligns with the Annotated Answer, which states there are 7 types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer categorizes surgical instruments into 7 broad types: Cutting instruments, Retracting instruments, Holding instruments, Grasping instruments, Measuring instruments, Suction instruments, and Miscellaneous instruments. This categorization aligns with the Annotated Answer, which states there are 7 types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9646",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpels on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpels on the table. The two numbers are not consistent with each other, thus the LLM's response does not align with the annotated information in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpels on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpels on the table. The two numbers are not consistent with each other, thus the LLM's response does not align with the annotated information in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4105",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are seven surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the numerical values do not match, and the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are seven surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the numerical values do not match, and the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8956",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists 12 surgical instruments, but there are inconsistencies in the counting and types listed. Specifically, it mentions 'One pair of tissue forceps' multiple times and counts pairs as single instruments. The Annotated Answer states there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM answer does not accurately reflect the annotated count of 15 surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists 12 surgical instruments, but there are inconsistencies in the counting and types listed. Specifically, it mentions 'One pair of tissue forceps' multiple times and counts pairs as single instruments. The Annotated Answer states there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM answer does not accurately reflect the annotated count of 15 surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12627",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's response states that there are six pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of twelve artery forceps. However, the annotated data specifies that there are only four artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match, and the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The large language model's response states that there are six pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of twelve artery forceps. However, the annotated data specifies that there are only four artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match, and the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11243",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions there are two pairs of scissors and two pairs of tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states there are two scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities and the types of tools mentioned do not match between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions there are two pairs of scissors and two pairs of tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states there are two scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities and the types of tools mentioned do not match between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5985",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are six core needles on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 core needle on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are six core needles on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 core needle on the table. The quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10460",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 Wire Grabbing Pliers tool on the table. The quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10109",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, but it does not mention the duplicate instances of artery forceps, bending shear, scalpel, and rongeur forceps as stated in the Annotated Answer. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific types and quantities of duplicate surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, but it does not mention the duplicate instances of artery forceps, bending shear, scalpel, and rongeur forceps as stated in the Annotated Answer. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific types and quantities of duplicate surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12376",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there are 12 pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are only 2 wire grabbing pliers. The quantities do not match, making the LLM's answer inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there are 12 pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are only 2 wire grabbing pliers. The quantities do not match, making the LLM's answer inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1799",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer did not provide a specific numerical count of the surgical tools on the table. It mentioned the difficulty in counting due to the arrangement and angle but did not give a precise number. The Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 14 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer did not provide a specific numerical count of the surgical tools on the table. It mentioned the difficulty in counting due to the arrangement and angle but did not give a precise number. The Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 14 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5725",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four core needles on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 core needle on the table. The quantities do not match, and therefore the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four core needles on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 core needle on the table. The quantities do not match, and therefore the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5340",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table and describes surgical instruments instead. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table and describes surgical instruments instead. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6000",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. This shows a discrepancy in the numerical count of circular spoons between the two answers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. This shows a discrepancy in the numerical count of circular spoons between the two answers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3559",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. The numerical quantities are inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. The numerical quantities are inconsistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "542",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four instances of scalpel on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 instances of scalpel on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four instances of scalpel on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 instances of scalpel on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10740",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four different types of surgical tools on the table: scissors, forceps, tweezers, and scalpel. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six different types of surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. The number of types mentioned in the LLM Answer (4) does not match the number of types mentioned in the Annotated Answer (6). Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four different types of surgical tools on the table: scissors, forceps, tweezers, and scalpel. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six different types of surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, and stripping. The number of types mentioned in the LLM Answer (4) does not match the number of types mentioned in the Annotated Answer (6). Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2127",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9673",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of scissors on the table, which is different from the question asking about the number of scalpels. Additionally, the annotated answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is neither addressing the correct item (scalpel) nor providing the correct quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of scissors on the table, which is different from the question asking about the number of scalpels. Additionally, the annotated answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is neither addressing the correct item (scalpel) nor providing the correct quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9240",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the artery forceps appear only once on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that the artery forceps appear twice. The LLM's response does not match the annotated information in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the artery forceps appear only once on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that the artery forceps appear twice. The LLM's response does not match the annotated information in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9839",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire-grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 wire-grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire-grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 wire-grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7075",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Since the numerical quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Since the numerical quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3643",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating inconsistency."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 rongeur forceps. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating inconsistency.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "538",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the unique surgical tools on the table. It mentions that it is difficult to provide an exact count due to the blurriness of the image, but it does not specify that there are 7 unique surgical tools, which is the information provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the unique surgical tools on the table. It mentions that it is difficult to provide an exact count due to the blurriness of the image, but it does not specify that there are 7 unique surgical tools, which is the information provided in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12612",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are two pairs of scissors on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are two artery forceps on the table. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific surgical tools identified as duplicates."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are two pairs of scissors on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are two artery forceps on the table. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific surgical tools identified as duplicates.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3314",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table is a pair of forceps. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool closest to the left edge is a bending_shear. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the surgical tool closest to the left edge of the table is a pair of forceps. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool closest to the left edge is a bending_shear. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8459",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 stripping instruments on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 stripping instrument on the table. The two answers are not consistent in terms of the numerical quantity of the stripping instruments."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 stripping instruments on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 stripping instrument on the table. The two answers are not consistent in terms of the numerical quantity of the stripping instruments.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12786",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that indicates there are 3 bending_shear on the table. The quantities mentioned in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match, and the type of items (scissors vs. bending_shear) are also different."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that indicates there are 3 bending_shear on the table. The quantities mentioned in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match, and the type of items (scissors vs. bending_shear) are also different.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13202",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 7 different types of surgical tools. The LLM Answer significantly overestimates the number of types in comparison to the annotated information."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 different types of surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 7 different types of surgical tools. The LLM Answer significantly overestimates the number of types in comparison to the annotated information.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8052",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer provides information about various medical instruments visible in an image including scissors and forceps but does not specifically address or mention the quantity of 'stripping.' The annotated answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated answer in terms of the specific quantity requested."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer provides information about various medical instruments visible in an image including scissors and forceps but does not specifically address or mention the quantity of 'stripping.' The annotated answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping. Hence, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated answer in terms of the specific quantity requested.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5312",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no aspirators or suction devices visible in the image. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is 1 aspirator on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no aspirators or suction devices visible in the image. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is 1 aspirator on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3299",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count of the stripping tools on the table, stating that it is difficult to provide an exact count without a clearer view of each instrument. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count of the stripping tools on the table, stating that it is difficult to provide an exact count without a clearer view of each instrument. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12562",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are four artery forceps. The numerical quantities in the two answers do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are four artery forceps. The numerical quantities in the two answers do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1121",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities provided do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The numerical quantities provided do not match.\",\n  \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8542",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The numerical quantities provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 rongeur forceps on the table. The numerical quantities provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3902",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that it is unable to provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table due to the image being rotated and not fully visible. However, the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not provide the numerical accuracy required and is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that it is unable to provide an exact count of the surgical tools on the table due to the image being rotated and not fully visible. However, the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not provide the numerical accuracy required and is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9517",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "360",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9316",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two artery forceps tools visible on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are three artery forceps tools. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two artery forceps tools visible on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are three artery forceps tools. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11882",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the tool with the smallest area on the table is a pair of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool with the smallest area is tweezers. Since the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer, it is not consistent in terms of identifying the tool with the smallest area."
    },
    "{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the tool with the smallest area on the table is a pair of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that the tool with the smallest area is tweezers. Since the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer, it is not consistent in terms of identifying the tool with the smallest area.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "2470",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are two artery forceps. The numbers do not match, thus the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are two artery forceps. The numbers do not match, thus the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "927",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three bending shear tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 bending shear tool on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three bending shear tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 bending shear tool on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1953",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer are consistent in the fact that they both confirm the presence of duplicate surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer mentions the presence of several pairs of scissors, which implies duplication, aligning with the Annotated Answer that states there are duplicate surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer are consistent in the fact that they both confirm the presence of duplicate surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer mentions the presence of several pairs of scissors, which implies duplication, aligning with the Annotated Answer that states there are duplicate surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9626",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that it is unable to provide an exact count of the surgical tools and does not mention any specific number. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not provide the numerical information required to determine consistency with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that it is unable to provide an exact count of the surgical tools and does not mention any specific number. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not provide the numerical information required to determine consistency with the annotated data.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1226",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 instance of the tweezers tool. The quantities do not match, indicating a clear inconsistency between the two answers."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 instance of the tweezers tool. The quantities do not match, indicating a clear inconsistency between the two answers.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10855",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four stripping tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four stripping tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6946",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 7 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8772",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of 6 artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which implies a total of 6 artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1022",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which implies a total of six wire grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer states that there is only one wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match, and the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which implies a total of six wire grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer states that there is only one wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match, and the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4148",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 12 surgical tools. Both answers provide the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 surgical tools on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that also specifies 12 surgical tools. Both answers provide the same quantity, ensuring numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12722",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors in unique positions on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 unique positions of surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match, and the counts are inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors in unique positions on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 5 unique positions of surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match, and the counts are inconsistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8899",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier. The numbers are not consistent, as the LLM Answer mentions six pliers (three pairs) whereas the Annotated Answer mentions only one."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier. The numbers are not consistent, as the LLM Answer mentions six pliers (three pairs) whereas the Annotated Answer mentions only one.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4441",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools in total, including scissors and forceps, without specifying which are used specifically for cutting or stripping. The Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are two surgical tools used for cutting or stripping, which are scalpel and stripping. The quantities and types of tools do not match between the two answers, indicating a discrepancy in identifying the tools used for cutting or stripping."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools in total, including scissors and forceps, without specifying which are used specifically for cutting or stripping. The Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are two surgical tools used for cutting or stripping, which are scalpel and stripping. The quantities and types of tools do not match between the two answers, indicating a discrepancy in identifying the tools used for cutting or stripping.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2201",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the most frequently appearing surgical tool on the table is the pair of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the most frequently appearing surgical tool is artery forceps, which appear three times. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, particularly in terms of the identified tool and its frequency."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the most frequently appearing surgical tool on the table is the pair of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the most frequently appearing surgical tool is artery forceps, which appear three times. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer, particularly in terms of the identified tool and its frequency.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2619",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are six surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating a discrepancy in the count of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are six surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating a discrepancy in the count of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2407",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are several pairs of scissors placed at the bottom center of the table. However, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are no tools placed at the bottom center of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are several pairs of scissors placed at the bottom center of the table. However, the Annotated Answer explicitly states that there are no tools placed at the bottom center of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1383",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table as the duplicate surgical tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools on the table are tweezers, artery forceps, and rongeur forceps, not scissors. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of identifying the specific types of duplicate surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table as the duplicate surgical tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools on the table are tweezers, artery forceps, and rongeur forceps, not scissors. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of identifying the specific types of duplicate surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1393",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicated that there are four tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there are five tweezers on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicated that there are four tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there are five tweezers on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1433",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the unique surgical tools on the table and instead indicates uncertainty due to the unclear view of each instrument. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 7 unique surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the unique surgical tools on the table and instead indicates uncertainty due to the unclear view of each instrument. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 7 unique surgical tools on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3891",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 instances of artery forceps on the table. These quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 instances of artery forceps on the table. These quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3434",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 bending shear on the table. These two answers differ in the numerical quantity of bending shears, indicating a significant discrepancy in the count."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 bending shear on the table. These two answers differ in the numerical quantity of bending shears, indicating a significant discrepancy in the count.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "902",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 bending shears on the table. The quantities and the types of items mentioned do not match, indicating inconsistency."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of scissors on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 bending shears on the table. The quantities and the types of items mentioned do not match, indicating inconsistency.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11629",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicates that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are six surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated information."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicates that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are six surgical tools on the table. The numerical quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated information.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2442",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 stripping tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 stripping tool on the table. The quantities provided in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 stripping tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 stripping tool on the table. The quantities provided in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1602",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are seven surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are seven surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, indicating inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2865",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only two scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only two scalpel tools on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11958",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists three surgical tools: scissors, forceps, and tweezers. However, the Annotated Answer lists six different tools: stripping, scalpel (mentioned twice), wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The only tool that matches between the two lists is tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists three surgical tools: scissors, forceps, and tweezers. However, the Annotated Answer lists six different tools: stripping, scalpel (mentioned twice), wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers. The only tool that matches between the two lists is tweezers. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10520",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 artery forceps. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 artery forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 artery forceps. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "304",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions several pairs of scissors and provides an estimation of at least four pairs of scissors on the table, without addressing the concept of 'stripping.' The Annotated Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table. The LLM's response does not provide the necessary information related to 'stripping,' and therefore it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions several pairs of scissors and provides an estimation of at least four pairs of scissors on the table, without addressing the concept of 'stripping.' The Annotated Answer states that there is 1 stripping on the table. The LLM's response does not provide the necessary information related to 'stripping,' and therefore it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11321",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer provides a list of five tools: scissors, forceps, tweezers, scalpel, and needle. However, the Annotated Answer lists specific names of six tools: rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping. The names and quantities of the tools do not match between the two sets of answers. Additionally, the LLM Answer includes tools like scissors and needle, which are not mentioned in the Annotated Answer, and it does not include wire_grabbing_pliers and stripping, which are mentioned in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer provides a list of five tools: scissors, forceps, tweezers, scalpel, and needle. However, the Annotated Answer lists specific names of six tools: rongeur_forceps_1, scalpel, tweezers, wire_grabbing_pliers, scalpel, and stripping. The names and quantities of the tools do not match between the two sets of answers. Additionally, the LLM Answer includes tools like scissors and needle, which are not mentioned in the Annotated Answer, and it does not include wire_grabbing_pliers and stripping, which are mentioned in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "1010",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three rongeur forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 rongeur forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical quantity shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three rongeur forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 rongeur forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical quantity shows that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1783",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of scissors and two forceps on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is one instance each of stripping, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps, and tweezers. There is no mention of scissors or forceps in the quantities stated by the LLM Answer. Hence, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy and the types of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of scissors and two forceps on the table. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is one instance each of stripping, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps, and tweezers. There is no mention of scissors or forceps in the quantities stated by the LLM Answer. Hence, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy and the types of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "833",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which would imply a total of 8 artery forceps (4 pairs x 2 forceps per pair). However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity of artery forceps."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which would imply a total of 8 artery forceps (4 pairs x 2 forceps per pair). However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of the quantity of artery forceps.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9417",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two Rongeur Forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table. Both responses indicate the same quantity, despite the slight difference in phrasing."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"yes\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two Rongeur Forceps on the table, which is consistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 2 Rongeur Forceps 1 tools on the table. Both responses indicate the same quantity, despite the slight difference in phrasing.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1730",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the instances of the same tool on the table. It mentions that the tools are not clearly visible and therefore does not attempt to count them. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states the exact number of instances for each type of tool: 3 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel. The LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer as it fails to provide numerical quantities."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific count of the instances of the same tool on the table. It mentions that the tools are not clearly visible and therefore does not attempt to count them. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states the exact number of instances for each type of tool: 3 instances of tweezers, 2 instances of artery forceps, and 2 instances of scalpel. The LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer as it fails to provide numerical quantities.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "168",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, which indicates duplicates of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are duplicate artery forceps on the table. The types of surgical tools identified as duplicates are different in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer, so they are not consistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, which indicates duplicates of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are duplicate artery forceps on the table. The types of surgical tools identified as duplicates are different in the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer, so they are not consistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6784",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire-grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are no wire-grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. This discrepancy in the quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire-grabbing pliers on the left side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are no wire-grabbing pliers on the left side of the table. This discrepancy in the quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5803",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists 4 distinct types of surgical instruments (Forceps, Scissors, Needle, and Tweezers) and mentions Gauze as a material, which is generally not classified as a surgical tool. The Annotated Answer states there are 5 different types of surgical tools, which suggests that Gauze is considered a surgical tool in this context. However, the LLM also mentions additional items (green and yellow items) that are not clearly identifiable as surgical instruments, creating ambiguity. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not clearly align with the Annotated Answer's count of 5 distinct surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists 4 distinct types of surgical instruments (Forceps, Scissors, Needle, and Tweezers) and mentions Gauze as a material, which is generally not classified as a surgical tool. The Annotated Answer states there are 5 different types of surgical tools, which suggests that Gauze is considered a surgical tool in this context. However, the LLM also mentions additional items (green and yellow items) that are not clearly identifiable as surgical instruments, creating ambiguity. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not clearly align with the Annotated Answer's count of 5 distinct surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "311",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of scissors and two pairs of forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer mentions that there are two scalpel surgical tools on the table. These answers indicate different types of duplicates and do not match in terms of the specific surgical tools being counted."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of scissors and two pairs of forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer mentions that there are two scalpel surgical tools on the table. These answers indicate different types of duplicates and do not match in terms of the specific surgical tools being counted.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1595",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide different lists of surgical tools. The LLM Answer lists scissors, forceps, needle holder, tissue forceps, and retractor, whereas the Annotated Answer lists scalpel, stripping, scalpel, tweezers, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1. The names and types of tools do not match, indicating inconsistency. Additionally, the Annotated Answer lists six tools, while the LLM Answer lists five tools, which further highlights the discrepancy in quantities."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide different lists of surgical tools. The LLM Answer lists scissors, forceps, needle holder, tissue forceps, and retractor, whereas the Annotated Answer lists scalpel, stripping, scalpel, tweezers, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1. The names and types of tools do not match, indicating inconsistency. Additionally, the Annotated Answer lists six tools, while the LLM Answer lists five tools, which further highlights the discrepancy in quantities.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1078",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer provides an estimate and mentions that there are at least four pairs of pliers visible, which are commonly used for stripping. However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 stripping tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the exact quantity of stripping tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer provides an estimate and mentions that there are at least four pairs of pliers visible, which are commonly used for stripping. However, the Annotated Answer clearly states that there are 2 stripping tools on the table. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the exact quantity of stripping tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2954",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of tweezers on the table, which implies a total of 12 individual tweezers. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which specifies that there are 4 tweezers on the table. The numbers provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six pairs of tweezers on the table, which implies a total of 12 individual tweezers. This is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, which specifies that there are 4 tweezers on the table. The numbers provided by the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5824",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three rongeur forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are two rongeur forceps on the table. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three rongeur forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are two rongeur forceps on the table. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12139",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one wire grabbing pliers on the table. The numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2348",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpels on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpels on the table. The numerical discrepancy between the two answers means that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 scalpels on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are only 2 scalpels on the table. The numerical discrepancy between the two answers means that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2980",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing plier on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7652",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are six surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states there are 11 surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are six surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer states there are 11 surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2766",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpels on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpels on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 2 scalpels on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13304",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only one wire grabbing plier on the table. This discrepancy in quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only one wire grabbing plier on the table. This discrepancy in quantity means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9713",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count of stripping tools on the table. It mentions various surgical instruments but does not specify the number of stripping tools, while the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count of stripping tools on the table. It mentions various surgical instruments but does not specify the number of stripping tools, while the Annotated Answer clearly states that there is 1 stripping tool on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6482",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "While both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer agree that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, they mention different types of tools. The LLM Answer mentions several pairs of scissors, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies duplicate wire grabbing pliers. Consistency requires that both answers identify the same type of duplicate tool."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"While both the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer agree that there are duplicate surgical tools on the table, they mention different types of tools. The LLM Answer mentions several pairs of scissors, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies duplicate wire grabbing pliers. Consistency requires that both answers identify the same type of duplicate tool.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10431",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 instruments visible, which does not match the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The LLM's estimate is lower than the actual count."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are at least 12 instruments visible, which does not match the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 15 surgical tools on the table. The LLM's estimate is lower than the actual count.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12848",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are 'two pairs of bending shears' on the table, which implies a total of 4 bending shears. However, the Annotated Answer indicates there are 2 bending shears on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are 'two pairs of bending shears' on the table, which implies a total of 4 bending shears. However, the Annotated Answer indicates there are 2 bending shears on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8192",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which corresponds to six individual artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of artery forceps on the table, which corresponds to six individual artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer states that there are 2 artery forceps on the table. The quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6259",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicates that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 4 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count means that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicates that there are 12 rongeur forceps on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are 4 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count means that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4238",
        "answer": "yes",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are five different types of surgical tools on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer. Additionally, the LLM Answer lists out five different types of surgical tools, which supports their count."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are five different types of surgical tools on the table, which matches the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer. Additionally, the LLM Answer lists out five different types of surgical tools, which supports their count.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "457",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the forceps appear the least on the table, mentioning that there are several pairs of forceps, but they are not prominently displayed. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the surgical tool appearing the least on the table is stripping, with only 1 occurrence. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tool and its quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the forceps appear the least on the table, mentioning that there are several pairs of forceps, but they are not prominently displayed. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the surgical tool appearing the least on the table is stripping, with only 1 occurrence. Therefore, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tool and its quantity.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5216",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not address the specific count of stripping tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly states there is 1 stripping tool. The LLM Answer instead describes the type of instruments seen and their potential uses, without providing a numerical count. Therefore, it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not address the specific count of stripping tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly states there is 1 stripping tool. The LLM Answer instead describes the type of instruments seen and their potential uses, without providing a numerical count. Therefore, it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8763",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which implies a total of four wire grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, which implies a total of four wire grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13302",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there are six tweezers in the image, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are five tweezers on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there are six tweezers in the image, whereas the annotated answer indicates that there are five tweezers on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11511",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is one instance of the tweezers on the table. These two answers are not consistent with each other in terms of quantity."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is one instance of the tweezers on the table. These two answers are not consistent with each other in terms of quantity.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "181",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one artery forceps tool on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of artery forceps on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one artery forceps tool on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3315",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are at least 8 visible surgical instruments on the right side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 surgical tools. The LLM Answer does not align with the annotated information in terms of the number of surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are at least 8 visible surgical instruments on the right side of the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 7 surgical tools. The LLM Answer does not align with the annotated information in terms of the number of surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7499",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table as duplicates, while the Annotated Answer specifies different tools as duplicates, including scalpel, rongeur forceps 1, and artery forceps. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tools that are duplicates."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table as duplicates, while the Annotated Answer specifies different tools as duplicates, including scalpel, rongeur forceps 1, and artery forceps. The LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tools that are duplicates.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10523",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide different lists of surgical tools. The LLM Answer lists scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tissue forceps, hemostats, and scalpels. In contrast, the Annotated Answer lists wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, scalpel, tweezers, bending shear, artery forceps, and stripping. Only 'scalpel' is common between the two lists, and the quantities of tools do not match exactly between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer provide different lists of surgical tools. The LLM Answer lists scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, tissue forceps, hemostats, and scalpels. In contrast, the Annotated Answer lists wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, scalpel, tweezers, bending shear, artery forceps, and stripping. Only 'scalpel' is common between the two lists, and the quantities of tools do not match exactly between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "978",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are three bending shear instruments on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 bending shear instrument. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are three bending shear instruments on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates there is only 1 bending shear instrument. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8745",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1935",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which means a total of 8 artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which means a total of 8 artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. Therefore, the quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the quantity in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12241",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 artery forceps tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery forceps tools. The quantities do not match, leading to an inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 artery forceps tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 4 artery forceps tools. The quantities do not match, leading to an inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10386",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 5 tweezers on the table. There is a discrepancy in the numerical values provided, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated information."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 tweezers on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are 5 tweezers on the table. There is a discrepancy in the numerical values provided, making the LLM Answer inconsistent with the annotated information.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3404",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are six surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, leading to an inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly indicates that there are six surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, leading to an inconsistency between the LLM Answer and the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "63",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 pair of tweezers on the table. These quantities do not match, indicating numerical inconsistency."
    },
    "{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is only 1 pair of tweezers on the table. These quantities do not match, indicating numerical inconsistency.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "586",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate tools on the table in the form of several pairs of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools include 2 instances of scalpel, 2 instances of rongeur forceps, and 4 instances of tweezers, and does not mention scissors. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tools and their quantities."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are duplicate tools on the table in the form of several pairs of scissors. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that the duplicate tools include 2 instances of scalpel, 2 instances of rongeur forceps, and 4 instances of tweezers, and does not mention scissors. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of the specific tools and their quantities.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7055",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons visible on the table, which contradicts the Annotated Answer that specifies there is 1 circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the annotated data, particularly in terms of the presence and quantity of circular spoons."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons visible on the table, which contradicts the Annotated Answer that specifies there is 1 circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is therefore inconsistent with the annotated data, particularly in terms of the presence and quantity of circular spoons.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5960",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated information, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no circular spoons on the table, while the Annotated Answer specifies that there is 1 circular spoon on the table. The LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated information, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12138",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are three scalpel tools. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates there are three scalpel tools. Since the quantities do not match, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11616",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three different types of surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning scissors, forceps, and tweezers or tongs. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are five different types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three different types of surgical tools on the table, specifically mentioning scissors, forceps, and tweezers or tongs. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that there are five different types of surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM's response is not consistent with the annotated data in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1217",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there is only 1 wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match, indicating the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9244",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count for the term 'stripping' on the table. Instead, the LLM Answer discusses the instruments on the table and interprets 'stripping' as a process rather than an object. The Annotated Answer clearly states that 'the stripping appears once on the table,' indicating a specific count. Thus, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a numerical count for the term 'stripping' on the table. Instead, the LLM Answer discusses the instruments on the table and interprets 'stripping' as a process rather than an object. The Annotated Answer clearly states that 'the stripping appears once on the table,' indicating a specific count. Thus, the LLM Answer does not align with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3219",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer does not specifically mention the most frequent surgical tools on the table in terms of quantity. It lists a variety of tools such as scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, and tissue forceps but does not quantify them. The annotated answer explicitly states that the most frequent tools are artery forceps and tweezers, with 3 instances each. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated answer regarding the numerical accuracy of the most frequent tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer does not specifically mention the most frequent surgical tools on the table in terms of quantity. It lists a variety of tools such as scissors, forceps, needle holders, retractors, and tissue forceps but does not quantify them. The annotated answer explicitly states that the most frequent tools are artery forceps and tweezers, with 3 instances each. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated answer regarding the numerical accuracy of the most frequent tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10675",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states 'two pairs of artery forceps,' which implies a total of four artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 'two artery forceps' on the table. Thus, the LLM Answer does not match the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states 'two pairs of artery forceps,' which implies a total of four artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 'two artery forceps' on the table. Thus, the LLM Answer does not match the quantity provided in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4889",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The numerical quantities do not match, which means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8382",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM is inconsistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. Therefore, the numerical quantity provided by the LLM is inconsistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9586",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are several surgical tools missing from the table, including scissors, forceps, and a retractor. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that all the surgical tools are present on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of the presence and quantity of the surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are several surgical tools missing from the table, including scissors, forceps, and a retractor. In contrast, the Annotated Answer clearly states that all the surgical tools are present on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer, especially in terms of the presence and quantity of the surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "12111",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer indicates there are four stripping tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there is only one stripping tool on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer indicates there are four stripping tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer states there is only one stripping tool on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5564",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are three wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two wire grabbing pliers on the table, while the Annotated Answer states that there are three wire grabbing pliers on the table. The quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "5418",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are no aspirators visible in the image, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is one aspirator on the table. This discrepancy indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are no aspirators visible in the image, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there is one aspirator on the table. This discrepancy indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the annotated data, particularly in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11919",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists 'Scissors, Forceps, and Tweezers', while the Annotated Answer lists 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers'. The LLM Answer does not match the provided names and quantities of the surgical tools accurately. Specifically, the LLM Answer misses the tools 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1', and only one tool, 'tweezers', matches between the two lists. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer both in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists 'Scissors, Forceps, and Tweezers', while the Annotated Answer lists 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, rongeur forceps 1, and tweezers'. The LLM Answer does not match the provided names and quantities of the surgical tools accurately. Specifically, the LLM Answer misses the tools 'stripping, scalpel, scalpel, wire grabbing pliers, and rongeur forceps 1', and only one tool, 'tweezers', matches between the two lists. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer both in terms of the names and quantities of the surgical tools.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3393",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer lists five surgical tools: scissors, forceps, needle holder, retractor, and clamp. In contrast, the Annotated Answer lists six surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, scalpel, and stripping. Additionally, the names of the tools in the LLM Answer do not match any of the names in the Annotated Answer. Thus, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer lists five surgical tools: scissors, forceps, needle holder, retractor, and clamp. In contrast, the Annotated Answer lists six surgical tools: wire_grabbing_pliers, rongeur_forceps_1, tweezers, scalpel, scalpel, and stripping. Additionally, the names of the tools in the LLM Answer do not match any of the names in the Annotated Answer. Thus, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9552",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions 'three pairs of artery forceps,' which implies a total of six individual forceps if each pair consists of two tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 3 artery forceps tools on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions 'three pairs of artery forceps,' which implies a total of six individual forceps if each pair consists of two tools. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 3 artery forceps tools on the table. Therefore, the quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2628",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four different types of surgical tools on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 6 different types of surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four different types of surgical tools on the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 6 different types of surgical tools on the table. The quantities do not match.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "9983",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 bending shears on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one bending shear on the table. The quantities do not match, so the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "4344",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of scissors on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly mentions that there are 2 bending shear on the table. The numerical quantities and the items being described are different."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 12 pairs of scissors on the table, while the Annotated Answer clearly mentions that there are 2 bending shear on the table. The numerical quantities and the items being described are different.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "1006",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The large language model's answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the annotated answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The quantity provided by the model does not match the annotated data, making the answer inconsistent."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The large language model's answer states that there are four surgical tools on the table, while the annotated answer indicates that there are six surgical tools. The quantity provided by the model does not match the annotated data, making the answer inconsistent.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10854",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 scalpel tools. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four scalpel tools on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 3 scalpel tools. Therefore, the numerical quantities do not match.\",\n    \"answer\": \"no\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "10148",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of bending shears on the table, which implies a total of six bending shears. However, the Annotated Answer states that there is only one bending shear on the table. Therefore, the quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three pairs of bending shears on the table, which implies a total of six bending shears. However, the Annotated Answer states that there is only one bending shear on the table. Therefore, the quantity provided by the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6252",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire-grabbing pliers on the right side of the table, which implies a total of 4 wire-grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer specifies there are 5 wire-grabbing pliers on the right side of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are two pairs of wire-grabbing pliers on the right side of the table, which implies a total of 4 wire-grabbing pliers. However, the Annotated Answer specifies there are 5 wire-grabbing pliers on the right side of the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "608",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states there are six pairs of scissors at the top of the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that states there is one bending_shear at the top of the table. The LLM Answer does not match the quantity or the specific item mentioned in the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states there are six pairs of scissors at the top of the table, which is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer that states there is one bending_shear at the top of the table. The LLM Answer does not match the quantity or the specific item mentioned in the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "11877",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM answer states that there are three stripping tools on the table, while the annotated answer specifies that there is only 1 stripping tool on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM answer states that there are three stripping tools on the table, while the annotated answer specifies that there is only 1 stripping tool on the table. The quantities do not match, therefore the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3128",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The annotated answer specifies that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The LLM answer states that there are 'several scalpel tools' and does not provide an exact count, citing visibility issues with the image. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated answer's specific count of 2 scalpels."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The annotated answer specifies that there are 2 scalpel tools on the table. The LLM answer states that there are 'several scalpel tools' and does not provide an exact count, citing visibility issues with the image. Therefore, the LLM answer is not consistent with the annotated answer's specific count of 2 scalpels.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "977",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are six scalpels on the table, which does not match the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 2 scalpels on the table. The numerical discrepancy between the two answers indicates inconsistency."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are six scalpels on the table, which does not match the Annotated Answer that specifies there are 2 scalpels on the table. The numerical discrepancy between the two answers indicates inconsistency.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "8814",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that the name 'artery_forceps' is mentioned once in the list. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that it is mentioned 2 times. Since the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of times 'artery_forceps' is mentioned, the LLM Answer is incorrect."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that the name 'artery_forceps' is mentioned once in the list. However, the Annotated Answer indicates that it is mentioned 2 times. Since the LLM Answer does not match the Annotated Answer in terms of the number of times 'artery_forceps' is mentioned, the LLM Answer is incorrect.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2864",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are three instances of stripping on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 instance. The numerical count in the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are three instances of stripping on the table, while the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only 1 instance. The numerical count in the LLM Answer does not match the annotated data.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3120",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four rongeurs (forceps) on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. The quantities provided in the two answers do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four rongeurs (forceps) on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there are 2 rongeur_forceps_1 on the table. The quantities provided in the two answers do not match, indicating a discrepancy in numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "13201",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, specifically noting at least four pairs of scissors as duplicates. However, the Annotated Answer specifies different duplicates: 2 scalpel tools, 2 rongeur forceps, and 4 tweezers. The LLM Answer does not mention these items or their quantities, thus it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer mentions that there are several pairs of scissors on the table, specifically noting at least four pairs of scissors as duplicates. However, the Annotated Answer specifies different duplicates: 2 scalpel tools, 2 rongeur forceps, and 4 tweezers. The LLM Answer does not mention these items or their quantities, thus it is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "7654",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which would amount to eight individual artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are four pairs of artery forceps on the table, which would amount to eight individual artery forceps. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are only 2 artery forceps on the table. This discrepancy in the numerical count indicates that the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "6836",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are 'at least a dozen instruments visible,' which implies a minimum of 12 instruments. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 9 surgical tools on the table in total. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer states that there are 'at least a dozen instruments visible,' which implies a minimum of 12 instruments. However, the Annotated Answer specifies that there are 9 surgical tools on the table in total. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "3873",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the surgical tools on the table and mentions that it is difficult to give an exact count due to the angle and arrangement of the instruments. The Annotated Answer, however, clearly states that there are 15 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not provide a specific numerical count of the surgical tools on the table and mentions that it is difficult to give an exact count due to the angle and arrangement of the instruments. The Annotated Answer, however, clearly states that there are 15 surgical tools. Therefore, the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}",
    {
        "id": "1372",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer does not specify the number of stripping on the table and instead discusses various medical instruments without giving a clear count. The Annotated Answer explicitly states that there is 1 stripping on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy."
    },
    "```json\n{\n    \"answer\": \"no\",\n    \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer does not specify the number of stripping on the table and instead discusses various medical instruments without giving a clear count. The Annotated Answer explicitly states that there is 1 stripping on the table. Therefore, the LLM Answer is inconsistent with the Annotated Answer in terms of numerical accuracy.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "518",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer identifies the surgical tools on the table as a pair of scissors and a forceps, whereas the Annotated Answer lists the tools as a scalpel, stripping, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, and rongeur forceps. The types and quantities of tools mentioned in the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer."
    },
    "```json\n{\n  \"answer\": \"no\",\n  \"reason\": \"The LLM Answer identifies the surgical tools on the table as a pair of scissors and a forceps, whereas the Annotated Answer lists the tools as a scalpel, stripping, wire grabbing pliers, tweezers, and rongeur forceps. The types and quantities of tools mentioned in the LLM Answer do not match the Annotated Answer.\"\n}\n```",
    {
        "id": "2290",
        "answer": "no",
        "reason": "The LLM Answer states that there are four tweezers on the table, whereas the Annotated Answer indicates that there is only one tweezers tool on the table. This discrepancy in the count of tweezers tools means the LLM Answer is not consistent with the Annotated Answer."
    }
]