The conversation between human and AI assistant.
Government of India: Why is it expenses charged on consolidated fund of india is not votable by parliament? Are there any amendments to it or any cases regarding it?
Is there any case law or examples of the rule being challenged?
There have been several cases where the rule has been challenged in court, but the general consensus has been that the rule is constitutional as the mandatory expenses charged to the consolidated fund are necessary for the functioning of the government. One example is the case of Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India, where the Supreme Court of India upheld the constitutionality of the rule.