The conversation between human and AI assistant.
Why do Shia’s claim that Imam Ali's father Abu Talib is in Jannah even though the Qur’an and Prophet Muhammad (SAW) say he died in kufr?
Can you tell me why some Shia’s claim that Imam Ali's father Abu Talib is in Jannah even though the Qur’an and Prophet Muhammad (SAW) say he died in kufr?
Shia's believe that Abu Talib was a Muslim in his heart, but he was not able to declare his faith openly due to the circumstances of his time. They believe that he still died in a state of faith and therefore believe he is in Jannah.