Says Joe Biden 'has advocated cutting Social Security for 40 years'
Leading up to the primary in Florida, with its many retirees, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., is pressing Joe Biden hard on his past stands on Social Security. Sanders' current ad in heavy rotation in Florida has a picture of Biden under the words 'Biden has advocated cutting Social Security for 40 years.' The ad plays audio of Biden from 1995 saying, 'When I argued that we should freeze federal spending, I meant Social Security as well. I meant Medicare and Medicaid. I meant veterans benefits. I meant every single solitary thing in the government. And I not only tried it once, I tried it twice, I tried it a third time, and I tried it a fourth time.' We've reviewed Biden's past statements on Social Security before. Our focus here is on the specific claim that he has pushed for cuts for 40 years. A plain reading of that would be that Biden consistently sought to reduce benefit payments for most of his career. The reality is that Biden's position has changed over time. In roughly 10-year hops, starting in the 1970s, he went from calling for a 7% increase, then for a one-year freeze, then floated raising the retirement age, then backed a change in how benefits would increase, and has ended up today calling for higher benefits. 1970 to 2000 In 1973, as a first-term senator, Biden co-sponsored a bill to increase monthly benefits by 7%. During the 1980s and 1990s, Biden spoke in favor of freezes to Social Security as part of an effort to rein in all spending to reduce the deficit. 'The only way that Congress will ever be able to come to grips with deficits is by dealing with all federal programs as a package,' Biden said in 1984. In 1984, Biden co-sponsored a proposal with two GOP senators to broadly freeze federal spending. The proposal would have meant no Social Security cost-of-living adjustments for one year, but it was defeated. In 1995, Biden voted in favor of an amendment to exclude reducing Social Security benefits in any legislation to implement a balanced-budget amendment. But Biden ultimately supported the balanced-budget amendment when its final form didn't include the exemption. In 1996, Biden suggested cutting the cost-of-living adjustment by one percentage point. He also supported a balanced-budget amendment that many saw as a backdoor to cuts in Social Security. A shift in the 2000s In 2003, Biden sponsored a Senate resolution opposing cuts in the cost-of-living increases for Social Security benefits. When he ran for president in 2007, in an interview with NBC, Biden said the retirement age and cost-of-living adjustments had to 'be on the table' in negotiations on stabilizing Social Security. But a few months later during a Democratic presidential debate, Biden backed away from changing the retirement age. He said he would support raising the income cap for the Social Security tax, which was then $97,500; that would be enough to avert other changes, he argued. 'The truth is, you're either going to cut benefits or you're going to go ahead and raise taxes above the first $97,000,' Biden said Sept. 26, 2007. 2008-2016: The Obama years As vice president, Biden was drawn back into fights over the future of Social Security amid efforts to reduce federal deficits. A 2010 presidential commission on the deficit had proposed Social Security cuts that President Barack Obama rejected. The 2011 Budget Control Act set deficit reduction targets. If they were not met, automatic cuts, called sequestration, kicked in. In hammering out that bill, the Obama White House and Democrats ensured that sequestration would not touch Social Security. In 2012, Biden promised voters in Virginia: 'I guarantee you, flat guarantee you: There will be no changes in Social Security. I flat guarantee you.' But during the Obama years, Biden did have a hand in a proposal that would have reduced Social Security benefits over time. It involved a different way of calculating inflation, using something called chained CPI. According to a recent report from the Urban Institute, a Washington think tank, such a change today would reduce the mean Social Security benefit by about 4.5% over a span of 45 years. In deficit reduction negotiations with a Republican-controlled Congress, the Obama White House said it was ready to accept a shift to the chained CPI as part of a larger budget deal. Opposition from Democratic lawmakers killed the proposal in 2011 and 2014, and it never went forward. 2020 In this election, Biden has called for 'urgently needed action to make the program solvent and prevent cuts to American retirees.' Biden would increase the minimum benefit for lifelong workers and make payments for the oldest people more generous. To shore up Social Security's finances, he would raise taxes on upper-income households, although his plan doesn't say by how much. 'We should be increasing, not decreasing, Social Security,' Biden said at an AARP Iowa forum in July. The meaning of 'adjustments' Recently, the Sanders campaign argued that in 2018, Biden had endorsed proposals by former Republican House Speaker Paul Ryan to cut Social Security benefits. We rated that False, but in his complete remarks at the time, Biden did say Social Security 'still needs adjustments.' The Sanders ad drew on an article that said the word 'adjustments' is 'a Washington euphemism for cuts.' If that's the case, the same could be said of Sanders. The Associated Press found that in 1996, Sanders said the aging of America's population would require changes in Social Security. 'It is clear that we will have to make incremental adjustments in Social Security taxes and benefits - as Congress has done in the past,' Sanders wrote in an op-ed.
Our ruling Sanders said that Biden advocated for Social Security cuts for 40 years. The record is much more nuanced than that. Over his decades in the Senate, Biden generally pushed to protect Social Security, but he also supported ideas that would reduce Social Security benefits over time. The audio in the Sanders ad of Biden calling for a total freeze on government spending dates back 25 years. About 13 years ago, Biden said he was open to benefit reductions, and then a few months later, said increasing taxes was better than reducing benefits. During the Obama administration, he was on board with a proposal that would have reduced benefits about four percentage points over four decades. That was in the context of a sweeping budget deal, and ultimately, it went nowhere. But also during those years, Biden was part of efforts to protect Social Security from automatic cuts under sequestration. Biden's current policy is to increase Social Security benefits. The claim contains elements of truth, but leaves out important facts that would give a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.
119916-proof-45-21af79b49031f7b4d372bbce7a92e58f.jpg