Also in 2014, Witt appeared in a major guest starring role on the DirecTV series "Kingdom", which aired that October. In 2014, in the fifth season of the FX series "Justified" she played Wendy Crowe, the brightest member of a Floridian crime family that gets entangled in the show's events up in Kentucky. In April 2016, Witt appeared in two episodes of the hit series "The Walking Dead"; the same month, it was announced that she would also be reprising her role as Gersten Hayward in the 2017 "Twin Peaks" series. Witt filmed a major guest starring role on Season 12 of "Supernatural" as Lily Sunder, a former enemy of Castiel's. In 2019, she had a recurring role on the seventh season of "Orange Is the New Black" as Zelda.