These experiences led to Witt's having small parts in Mike Figgis' "Liebestraum" (1991), in which her brother Ian also appears, the Gen-X drama "Bodies, Rest & Motion" (1993), and the TV movie "The Disappearance of Vonnie" (1994). In 1994, Witt landed her first lead role in a film, playing a disturbed, murderous teenager in "Fun" and receiving the "Special Jury Recognition" Award at the Sundance Festival. Witt was then cast in the "desultory" "Four Rooms," as Madonna's lover in the episode, "The Missing Ingredient".