In 2000, the band released "White Out". The title refers to a blizzard that happened during the recording sessions, which took place in a rented vacation home on the shores of Lake Michigan. David Suycott (Stabbing Westward, Spies Who Surf) played drums on the album, and bass guitars were played by Rothschild and Lennie Dietsch. Most of the album was produced by Brad Wood, known for his work with Liz Phair. "New History" was remixed by Chris Lord-Alge for a promotional single. A three-song EP for "New History" was also released.