In 1994 "Electronic Gaming Monthly" complimented the Lynx version's large number of options and password feature, and remarked, ""Lemmings" has always been a good strategy game, and the Lynx version continues the tradition." The following year they reviewed the CD-i version, criticising that it has nothing but the obligatory full-motion video intro to set it apart from the numerous ports of the game that had already been released over the past four years. "GamePro" made the same criticisms, commenting that "this former 16-bit puzzler isn't going anywhere new on the CD-i."