In 2013, the team finished the season with a record of 24–2, making it to the semifinals in the North Coast Section playoffs. The team featured San Francisco Giants draftee Ryan Kirby and current Miami Marlins minor leaguer Casey Soltis. The Matadors began the season with 20 consecutive victories, outscoring their opponents 190-39 over the course of the 26-game season. The team had a 13–1 record in their league games, as they won the East Bay Athletic league for the first time since the 1980s. The team was ranked as high as second in the nation by MaxPreps during the course of the season.