Witt appeared as the character Elaine Clayton in "Cowgirls n' Angels" (2012), and in 2013 co-starred in the independent film "Cold Turkey" opposite Peter Bogdanovich and Cheryl Hines; there, she additionally performed an original musical piece over the end credits (see below). Her dramatic performance in this film was critically acclaimed, with "New York Magazine"s David Edelstein proclaiming her turn one of the top performances of 2013. Witt also appeared in four Christmas films in 2013: the feature film "Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas", "A Snow Globe Christmas" for Lifetime Channel, and "A Very Merry Mix-Up" for Hallmark Channel, and in 2014 Hallmark Channel's "Christmas at Cartwright's". She also played the blind girlfriend of a serial killer in The Mentalist.