In the Fall of 2011, PWRFC ran the table in EPRU Division 3, going a perfect 8–0 and won the EPRU D3 crown. PWRFC continued their winning ways that spring running the table to win the MARFU championship, defeating Virginia RFC in the final 37–32. They advanced to the Final Four in Glendale, Colorado after defeating Gainesville and Syracuse in the USA Rugby Round of 16 and 8, respectively. After defeating the South Bay Rhinos (CA) in the National Semifinal 50–26, they fell to New Orleans RFC in the National Championship Game 36–20, finishing the season with a 14–1 record.