The album received mostly negative reviews from critics. "NME" wrote that "the slick, dumbed-down "Dungeons & Dragons" rap-rock schtick [...] is often unbearable". "College Music Journal" writer Matt Ashare described the album as "Cirque de so-lame". "Rolling Stone" writer Barry Walters gave the album two out of five stars, writing that "no musical sleight of hand can disguise the fact that Shaggy and J remain the ultimate wack MCs." In "The Great Rock Discography", Martin Charles Strong gave the album four out of ten stars.