The pilot received mixed to negative reviews, with most critics acknowledging that younger viewers would probably like the show, but expressing concern regarding the example(s) set for them. "Chicago Tribune" critic Marilynn Preson wrote, "Mostly it will be children and teens and young adults who may come to love this series that's a big part of the problem. [... These cute kids illegally access and search their school's computer, the private files of the county clerk's office and the computer system of a large newspaper in Los Angeles. [...] Instead of appealing, the first episode pilot of "Whiz Kids" is appalling."