The girls volleyball team won the Group IV state championship in 1986 (against runner-up Paramus High School in the final match of the playoffs), 1987 (vs. Paramus Catholic High School) and 1996 (vs. Immaculate Heart Academy). The 1986 team finished the season with a 23-1 record after winning the Group IV title in three games (13-15, 15-12 and 15-8) against a Paramus team that had come into the finals undefeated and was four points away from winning in the second game.