Mike Schiller of "PopMatters" agreed and gave "Switch" a score of five out of ten. Schiller again criticised the workings of "Rockstar: INXS", noting aspects of favouritism, of the loss of Hutchence being too great, and of the "questionable popularity of INXS." He argued that "Switch" did not resemble an INXS album; rather, he said it sounded like ""Rock Star INXS: The Album"" – "rushed, undercooked, and a bit uncomfortable." Schiller, like Collar, praised "Devil's Party", as well as "Pretty Vegas" – he pointed out that Fortune sounded best on the songs he helped write. Meanwhile, the collaborative songwriting was criticised, with Schiller arguing that Guy Chambers "just doesn't quite know how to fit his songwriting style into the INXS template." He also pointed out that "Rockstar INXS" runner-up Suzie McNeil's performance on closing track "God's Top Ten" showed " a strong performance here that outshines Fortune's." Overall, he argued, "Switch" did not seem like an album by a well versed band, but a solo artist hiring some extra musicians.