With the success of the first team, in the summer of 2010 founded by Daniel Jenkins and Ryan "Gammon" Williams the Goytre United Reserve squad was made. The squad entered the Port Talbot Reserve Division and claimed a respectable 8th-place finish in the league as well as a quarter final spot in the Port Talbot knockout cup. Notable acclaims for the season included beating champions Bay View 4–2 at the Glenhafod, Bayviews only defeat of the season. The 2011–12 season started off with big signings for the club in the form of Mikkel Mccalmon, Liam McGinley and Richard Phelps. With the new additions the reserve squad won not only the league but also the Port Talbot knockout cup beating local rivals Tata Steel 3–0 in the final. The 2012–13 season ended on 9 May with Goytre yet again doing the double with the league and cup. Goytre played Cornelly in the final with the scoreline at 5–2 to Goytre.