The boys' basketball team won the Non-Public B state championships in 2013-2015 (defeating St. Anthony High School in the finals each of the three years) and 2018 (vs. Ranney School). The team won their third consecutive Non-Public B title in 2015 with a 56-52 win against St. Anthony in the championship game. The team won the 2018 Non-Public B title with a 63-61 win against Ranney School on a basket scored with just over six seconds remaining in the championship game. The team came into the 2013 Tournament of Champions as the top seed and finished the season 25-5 after winning the program's first ToC title with a 78-54 win against fifth-seeded Newark Tech High School in the semifinals and 65-49 against number-two seed St. Joseph High School of Metuchen in the championship game. The 2015 team won the school's second ToC title with a 103-34 win against Paulsboro High School in the semifinals and 57-45 against Pope John XXIII Regional High School in the finals, behind 27 points by Isaiah Briscoe. The team came into the 2018 ToC as the top seed and won the program's third title with a 75-62 win against Nottingham High School in the semifinals and a 61-54 win against Don Bosco Preparatory High School in the finals at the CURE Insurance Arena in Trenton, despite a career-high 33 points from Don Bosco's Ron Harper Jr..