During the incident involving the "Terror Titans", Zatara became one of the imprisoned heroes forced to fight on the behest of the Clock King, who took over the Dark Side Club Following his escape from the Dark Side Club, Zachary, along with the rest of the former captives, is offered refuge at the Titans Tower. Zachary, however, rejects this, under the misunderstanding that he was being forced to join the team in order to get refuge. He returns to Metropolis with Bunny shortly after.