On February 22, 2013, Daffney announced that Love would be making her debut in the all-female promotion Shine Wrestling, at the event "Shine 8". At "Shine 8" on March 23, Love teamed up with Mia Yim, Amazing Kong and Christina Von Eerie in a losing effort to the team of Valkyrie (Allysin Kay, Ivelisse, Rain and Taylor Made). On April 19, at the "Shine 9" event, Love competed in the Shine Championship qualifying tournament, losing to Rain. On May 24 at the "Shine 10" event, Love was unsuccessful in winning the Shine Championship from the reigning champion Rain. Love returned on January 24 at the "Shine 14" event, where she defeated Leah von Dutch.