Accordingly, such "INS"-based decisions as the Notre Dame ring case, the Flint mustard seed case, "Haeger Potteries, Inc. v. Gilner Potteries", in which the court held that copying an ash-tray design "in precise detail as to design, shape and color, and in every other respect than quality, is nothing less than piracy," and "Dior v. Milton", in which the court held that there was no good reason "why the rights of the plaintiff a dress design should receive less protection than those of the sponsor of sporting events and the disseminator of news," can no longer survive: they have been given "the death knell." It is said that—