Harley had to audition for the recording of the song at Lloyd Webber's home. Speaking to "Number One" in February 1986, Harley revealed: "I don't mean to boast but after only singing one verse he told me I'd got the job!" He also commented to the "Daily Star" at the time: "A friend said he was going to tell Andrew that my voice was just right for the song. I thought he was joking. But I really enjoyed working with Andrew. I'd love to play the Phantom when he puts the show on stage."