In March 2004, the band released their fourth studio album "Guilt Show", produced by Ed Rose. Sonically, the album combined the more measured, sophisticated sound of "On a Wire" with the frenetic style of their earlier work. "Guilt Show", which was titled after a misreading of a flier saying "Quilt show", was very well received both critically and commercially. The more pop-driven tone of the album reunited the band with many fans who were disenchanted after "On a Wire", while also staying close enough to the evolution of the last album to interest newer fans and critics. However, their return was overshadowed by the booming popularity of other contemporary emo bands such as Dashboard Confessional, who invited the band to open for them on the 2004 Honda Civic Tour.