The return of the black musical to Broadway occurred in 1921 with "Sissle" and Eubie Blake's "Shuffle Along". In 1927, a concert survey of black music was performed at Carnegie Hall including jazz, spirituals and the symphonic music of W. C. Handy's Orchestra and the Jubilee Singers. The first major film musical with a black cast was King Vidor's "Hallelujah" of 1929. African-American performers were featured in the musical "Show Boat" (which had a part written for Paul Robeson and a chorus of Jubilee Singers), and especially all-black operas such as "Porgy and Bess" and Virgil Thomson's "Four Saints in Three Acts" of 1934.