In May 1902 Mrs. Fiske put on a revival of "Tess of the D'Urbervilles" at the Manhattan Theatre. Stevens was among the players in a recreation of this production of Mrs. Fiske first staged in 1897. She became a permanent member of the company of Mrs. Fiske in 1904, following three seasons on stage. She acted the role of "Miriam" in "Mary of Magdala" in 1904. The Manhattan Theatre presented "Becky Sharp" in September 1904. Based on "Vanity Fair" by William Makepeace Thackery, the comedy in four acts was written by Langdon Mitchell. Mrs. Fiske and the Manhattan Company brought it before audiences with Stevens and George Arliss as cast principals. A revival of "Hedda Gabler" was staged in November 1904 with Mrs. Fiske in the title role and Stevens as "Berta". The Henrik Ibsen work played for one week in 1903 with near capacity attendance for each performance. "Leah Kleschna" was written especially for Mrs. Fiske by C.M.S. McLellan (Hugh Morton). The Manhattan Theatre presented the play about the daughter of a thief in December 1904. The production marked the first original role Fiske had acted in two years. Stevens, Arliss, John B. Mason, and Marie Fedor were among the players.