The show's only regular panelists were the co-hosts; Bauman sat on the panel during "Match Game" and the Super Match, while Rayburn took his place during "Hollywood Squares". The most frequent semi-regular panelist was actress Nedra Volz, who appeared for nine weeks, followed closely by "Mr. Smith" star Leonard Frey and returning "Match Game" regular Charles Nelson Reilly, who each appeared for seven weeks. Several of the panelists were previously regulars or semi-regulars on "Match Game", including Fannie Flagg (who appeared four weeks), McLean Stevenson, Marcia Wallace, Fred Travalena and Bill Daily; Bauman himself, as Bowzer, had also previously appeared on "Match Game". George Gobel, who appeared one week, and Abby Dalton, who appeared two weeks, were the only "Hollywood Squares" regulars to ever appear on the program.