Love made her debut for Family Wrestling Entertainment (FWE) on October 4, 2012 at the "Back 2 Brooklyn" internet pay-per-view, where she teamed up with Velvet Sky to defeat the FWE Women's Champion Maria Kanellis and Katrina Lea a in a tag team match, with Love pinning Kanellis. Because of the win, Williams was named number one contender, and faced Kanellis for the FWE Women's Championship on February 16, 2013, but was unsuccessful in winning the championship after Mike Bennett helped Maria take advantage. On November 10, Love made her debut for in Sudbury, Suffolk, England, defeating Carmel Jacob by disqualification, following interference from Sara-Marie Taylor. Love then teamed with Erin Angel in a tag team match, where they were defeated by Jacob and Taylor. On February 16, 2013, at "FWE No Limits", Love was defeated by the FWE Women's Champion Maria Kanellis in a title match. Love returned to FWE at their "Openweight Grand Prix" on October 12, defeating Cheerleader Melissa and Serena Deeb in a three-way match, when she pinned Deeb.