In 2000, work began on Iced Earth's sixth studio album. Entitled "Horror Show", the album contained songs based on horror films and literature, such as "Dracula", "The Phantom of the Opera" and the "Wolf Man". Released on June 26, 2001, the album was the band's first to feature drummer Richard Christy, and the third with guitarist Larry Tarnowski (now a full-time member). Originally Steve di Giorgio played bass on the album, but left the group after the recording process. According to Schaffer, Di Giorgio was required and agreed to go on tour, but left due to "prior commitments." He was replaced by James MacDonough. "Horror Show" was also the first Iced Earth album to be partially recorded at Schaffer's home studio "Schaffer Sound."