The baseball team has enjoyed a long history of success starting in the early 1970s. The team won the Non-Public B state championship in 1973 (defeating Paterson Catholic High School in the tournament final), 1974 (vs. Pope Paul VI Regional High School of Clifton), 1980 (vs. St. Mary High School of Jersey City), 1984 (vs. Bayley-Ellard High School), 1985 (vs. Immaculata High School), 1986 (vs. Phillipsburg Catholic High School), 1993 (vs. Marist High School), 1996 (vs. Pope John XXIII Regional High School), 2001 (vs. St. Mary High School of Rutherford), 2003 (vs. St. Mary of Rutherford), 2007 (vs. Newark Academy), 2010 (vs. Morristown–Beard School), 2011 and 2017 (vs. Newark Academy both years), and won the Non-Public A title in 1999 (vs. Saint Joseph Regional High School of Montvale), 2000 (vs. Seton Hall Preparatory School), 2012 vs. Don Bosco Preparatory High School), 2013 (vs. Seton Hall Prep), 2017 (vs. Newark Academy), 2018 (vs. DePaul Catholic High School) and 2019 (vs. St. Mary of Rutherford). The programs' 20 state titles are the most of any school statewide.