After the release of "Simple Science," the band decided to combine the remaining tracks—along with three more newly recorded songs—into a new full-length album, "There Are Rules". They also confirmed that the album would not be released on Vagrant Records, who had released their previous three albums, but on their own Quality Hill Records. The album was produced by Ed Rose and mixed by Bob Weston, who produced the band's debut album. "There Are Rules" was released on January 25, 2011, and was supported by a co-headlining tour with Saves The Day.