The girls volleyball team won the Group III state championship in 2000 (defeating Paramus Catholic High School in the last match of the tournament), 2001 (vs. Ramapo High School), 2002 (vs. Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan), 2003 (vs. Old Tappan) and 2014 (vs. Old Tappan), and won the Group II title in 2006 (vs. Chatham High School), 2012 (vs. Sterling High School), 2018 (vs. Rutherford High School) and 2019 (vs. Rutherford); the program's 10 group titles are tied for fourth-most of any school in the state. The team won the inaugural Tournament of Champions in 2002 (vs. Cresskill High School) and repeated in 2003 (vs. James Caldwell High School) and 2006 (vs. Hunterdon Central High School). The 2000 team won the Group III championship, topping Paramus Catholic High School, 15-8 and 15–7. The 2001 team repeated, defeating Ramapo High School in the finals. The girls took the title again in 2003, over cross-district rival Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan. The team took the 2006 Group II title over Chatham High School (25-17, 25-15). The 2001 team won the Group III state title over New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association and lost in the Tournament of Champions final match to Immaculate Heart Academy, finishing the season with a 24–4 record. In 2012, the girls volleyball team won the state Group II championship in straight sets over Sterling High School, the program's eighth state group title.