"Moo, You Bloody Choir" saw the band move from receiving only critical acclaim to achieving mainstream success as well. The album spent 21 weeks on the ARIA Albums Chart, peaking at number ten, while lead single "One Crowded Hour" reached number 29 in its 20-week ARIA Singles Chart stint. The album was certified platinum in Australia. Work by Augie March was nominated for six ARIA Awards in 2006, including "One Crowded Hour" for "Single of the Year". Despite the hype, the band did not win any further ARIAs. Augie March were still more successful underground than in the mainstream; "One Crowded Hour" topped Triple J Hottest 100, 2006. The album's popularity also saw it nominated for the 2006 J Award. A 2008 "The Australian" poll ranked "One Crowded Hour" the tenth best Australian song of the past 20 years.