"Computer and Video Games" magazine reviewed the game in 1985, stating that the "graphics are perhaps the most unusual of any arcade game around" but is nevertheless "a cubist's delight." In 2001, author John Sellers described "I, Robot" as a "near miss" because of its strong release that didn't gain enough popularity. He further praised the game, calling it enjoyable and influential. Author David Ellis listed it as one of the "notable classics" of its time, calling it "quirky". In 2008, "Guinness World Records Gamer's Edition" listed it as the number ninety arcade game in technical, creative and cultural impact, citing its innovative 3D graphics. Gamasutra placed "I, Robot" on its "20 Atari Games" list, saying that "This is the kind of brilliance Atari could field in its halcyon days". The game has been cited as the first arcade game to use 3D polygon graphics, and holds a Guinness World Record for the milestone. IGN.com's Levi Buchanan and Craig Harris included "I Robot" to their "Dream Arcades" articles.