Another response, the "Adventures of the Brown Girl (companion to the Black girl of Mr. Bernard Shaw) in her Search for God" by Mr and Mrs I. I. Kazi was published in 1933 by A. H. Stockwell. This was a liberal Muslim reply which argued that the monotheistic view of the divine existed throughout history, and thus that "every prophet preached Islam in its theistic aspects". Other titles include W. R. Matthews' "The Adventures of Gabriel in his Search for Mr. Shaw" (1933) and "The Adventures of the White Girl in her Search for Knowledge" (1934) by Marcus Hayman. In Matthews' book God sends the Archangel Gabriel to seek out the real Shaw, discovering four "sham" Shaws (his public personas) that hide the real individual. Hayman's book was a left-wing criticism of Shaw's religious ideology. In 1973 Brigid Brophy published "The Adventures of God in his Search for the Black Girl", in which Shaw himself appears.