On 28 August 2013, however, Tiendalli re-joined Swansea City on a three-year contract lasting until June 2016. His first game after signing for the club in his second spell came on 19 September 2013 against Valencia in the UEFA Europa League, a 3–0 victory. However, his first-team opportunities at Swansea City were limited once again, due to competition with other defenders. He made six starts in league matches during December in the absence of Rangel. Tiendalli set up Swansea City’s goal in a 2–1 defeat to Everton on 22 December 2013. However, once again he was placed down the pecking order, as well as facing injury concerns. After three months away from the first team, he started a match and played 77 minutes before being substituted in a 1–0 defeat to Southampton on 3 May 2014. By the end of the 2013–14 season, Tiendalli had appeared nineteen times in all competitions.