In the 2015 season, Catchings was voted as a WNBA all-star for the 10th time in her career while averaging 13.1 ppg, passing Tina Thompson for most all-star appearances. With a new all-star sidekick Marissa Coleman joining her in the frontcourt, the Fever finished third in the Eastern Conference with a 20–14 record and made it back to the finals for the first time in 3 years for a rematch with the Minnesota Lynx, this time with Minnesota winning the series 3–2.