The game received "mixed or average reviews", according to video game review score aggregator Metacritic. Critics praised "Mischief Makers" inventiveness, personality, and boss fights, but criticized its short length, low difficulty, low replay value, sound, and harsh introductory learning curve. Retrospective reviewers disagreed with the originally poor reception, and multiple reviewers noted Marina's signature "Shake, shake!" sound bite as a highlight. Video game journalists cited "Mischief Makers" as ripe for reissue either through the Nintendo eShop or in a sequel or franchise reboot. In 2009, "GamesRadar" called it "possibly the most underrated and widely ignored game on the N64".