Glen Rovers lost the next two championship deciders before facing St. Finbarr's in the 1958 county final. Lyons was appointed captain for the second time in his career and lead the charge from the full-back line. The Glen were lining out without Christy Ring and Joe Twomey as they had been sent to the line in the semi-final victory. In one of the great championship deciders in Cork, Glen Rovers won by 4-6 to 3-5. It was an eighth championship medal for Lyons who, once again, had the honour of receiving the cup.