"Big Cheese" ranked "Mutiny!" at number 24 on their list of top 50 albums of 2006. It later featured on three best-of pop punk album lists: number 31 on BuzzFeed's 36 Pop Punk Albums You Need To Hear Before You F——ing Die; number 46 on "Rock Sound"s The 51 Most Essential Pop Punk Albums of All Time; and number 49 on "Kerrang!" The 51 Greatest Pop-Punk Albums of All Time. Similarly, "NME" listed the title track as part of their Essential Pop Punk Playlist.