According to Barnes, he created the original version of "The Sugar Shack" after reflecting upon his childhood, during which he was not "able to go to a dance." In a 2008 interview, Barnes said, ""The Sugar Shack" is a recall of a childhood experience. It was the first time my innocence met with the sins of dance. The painting transmits rhythm so the experience is re-created in the person viewing it. To show that African-Americans utilize rhythm as a way of resolving physical tension."