Bad Religion slowly reformed in 1986 out of the "Back to the Known" line-up when Graffin called Bentley and asked him to return. Bentley's response was tentative, but after being assured that the setlist consisted mostly of tracks from "How Could Hell Be Any Worse?", he agreed to return for one show, and ended up staying on because he had so much fun. A freshly rehabilitated Gurewitz was eventually convinced to come back aboard, and with Pete Finestone returning on drums and Greg Hetson on second guitar; Bad Religion was back. This lineup recorded the band's third album, "Suffer", which was released in 1988. Punk rock albums did not chart on the "Billboard" 200 in the 1980s, but the album received positive reviews in the independent music press and was voted Best Album of the Year by publications such as "Trust", "Maximum Rocknroll" and "Flipside".