"The Trades" questioned its existence, saying "I am unsure what reason this spinoff was made, but regardless, it was a well done one". It added that "the same team directed and produced the second movie, and unlike many direct to video movies, it is animated as well as the first and uses a healthy portion of CGI, something many movies of that nature tend to lack. Backgrounds have the same detail as the original movie, making this a definite worthwhile watch". "The Dallas Morning News" notes ""Bartok the Magnificent" does even more disservice to Russian history than "Anastasia" did".