In June 2011, JoJo performed "Too Little Too Late" at the Girls Who Rock benefit concert. JoJo included the song in her set list of her 2015 "I Am JoJo Tour". Mehek Seyid, a writer for Live in Limbo, reviewed the singer's rendition at the Mod Club in Toronto as "performed ... with the same self-affirming attitude and confidence that defined the Billboard hit[ when it] first circulated in the 2000s." In January 2017, JoJo sang verses of "Too Little Too Late" with elementary school choir the PS22 Chorus. Upon being published on the choir's YouTube channel, the video became a viral sensation. JoJo also performed the song throughout her "Mad Love Tour". Reviewing her performance at the O2 Academy Islington, her first performance in the United Kingdom in 10 years, "Attitude" wrote that JoJo's rendition of "Too Little Too Late" is a "reminder of the pipes that made JoJo one of pop's most promising young stars". "The Atlanta Journal-Constitution" Jewel Wicker called her live rendition one of the show's "great moments". Erica Thompson, associate editor for "Columbus Alive", reviewed that the song "held up well over time". Despite sounding "nursery-rhyme catchy, was written for a sophisticated singer, which JoJo proved to be even as a teenager", which Thompson believes her contemporaries would struggle to replicate.