Critics were generally favorable towards "Broken Boy Soldiers". "Rolling Stone" said of the album "Expectations were sky-high, but the Raconteurs exceed them all." "People" magazine gave the album three-and-a-half stars, making the album the Critic's Choice of the week; they commented "Broken Boy Soldiers incorporates just enough weirdness to show that he (White) hasn't completely changed his stripes." More conservatively, Billboard remarked "No one is breaking any ground here, and White fanatics looking for a new White Stripes record should temper their expectations. But as far as side projects go, this is as good as it gets."