"Softline" stated that the Apple version of "Hard Hat Mack" "bears a certain similarity to "Miner 2049er", but it's a good game in its own right and the animation is a little better". "Video" also reviewed the Apple version in its "Arcade Alley" column where it was described as "a 'must' buy for Apple arcaders" and "indisputably one of the finest programs ever made for the Apple". Reviewers noted that the game's "look and play" were inferior to the Atari version, but this was attributed to the Apple II's systemic limitations and designers Abbot and Alexander were recommended for a "round of applause" from readers.