He served in the NZEF in the Second World War, in North Africa. He then played in the first two Test matches in New Zealand after the War. In the Test against Australia at Wellington in 1945–46, New Zealand were bowled out for 42 and then 54, Tindill making 1 and 13. He also played in the only Test against the touring English side at Lancaster Park, Christchurch, in 1946–47. His Test batting average of 9.12 did not reflect his talent.