1994–95 saw a Kilmore Rec Under-18 team enter the Northern Ireland Youth Cup under the guidance of Billy Sloan. The team became one of few, and the last to date, Amateur league team to win the Cup. They defeated Portadown Boys 2–0 at Dixon Park, Ballyclare on 22 April 1996. The team defeated Irish League teams en route to winning the cup and players who competed in this team are now plying their trade in the Irish league and in the Amateur League.