Before the ensuing election, boundary redistribution led to McKenney running in Pembina (where he was elected), freeing St. Albert up for Boudreau to run again. He was elected this time, defeating Gariépy (who was running as an independent Liberal after refusing to contest the Liberal nomination on the grounds that it was rigged in Boudreau's favour) and Conservative Omer St. Germain (who would leader represent the riding for the United Farmers of Alberta and Liberals). He was re-elected in 1913 and 1917, defeating Conservative candidate Hector Landry both times.