The girls basketball team won the Non-Public B state championship in 1996 (defeating DePaul Catholic High School in the tournament final) and 1997 (vs. St. Anthony High School), and won the Non-Public Group A title in 2000 (vs. Immaculate Heart Academy), 2001 (vs. Paramus Catholic High School), 2004 (vs. Immaculate Heart), 2007 (vs. Morris Catholic High School), 2013 (vs. Immaculate Heart) and 2017 (vs. Immaculate Heart); the eight state titles are the fourth-most of any school in the state. The 1996 team won the Non-Public A title with a 60-33 win against DePaul before advancing to the Tournament of Champions as the top seed, winning the semifinals 52-43 against fifth-seeded Rumson-Fair Haven Regional High School and defeating number-two seed Elizabeth High School 39-31 in the finals to finish the season The 2001 girls' basketball team won the Group A state championship with a 56–39 win over Paramus Catholic High School. The girls basketball won the South A state sectional championship in 2007 with a 60–53 win against Camden Catholic High School in the tournament final. The 2007 team moved on to win the Group A state championship with a 43–40 win against Morris Catholic High School.