Kevin Powers of "Comics Bulletin" gave "Fate of Atlantis", "Thunder in the Orient" and "Arms of Gold" positive reviews. He found "Fate of Atlantis" a "darker, more fast-paced" adaptation of the game, but that it still captured Indiana and Sophia Hapgood's relationship. He also argued "the parallel between the downfall of Atlantis and the downfall of the Nazi searchers is really well done". There was "hell of a lot going on in" "Thunder in the Orient", "but it's fairly easy to follow and the political connotations are very well documented". He compared it and "Arms of Gold" to "Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom" because of its focus on action over characterization, although he deemed the latter "perfect for someone looking for a well-crafted adventure story". He praised its romantic elements, but found the villain an afterthought.