One year after the "Puyallup I" decision, Judge Robert C. Belloni issued an order in "Sohappy v. Smith", a treaty fishing case involving the Yakama tribe and the state of Oregon. In this case, Oregon had discriminated against the Indigenous peoples in favor of sports and commercial fishermen, allocating almost nothing to the tribes at the headwaters of the river. Oregon argued that the treaties only gave the Indigenous peoples the same rights as every other citizen, and Belloni noted that "uch a reading would not seem unreasonable if all history, anthropology, biology, prior case law and the intention of the parties to the treaty were to be ignored". Belloni also found that: