In the December 1988 edition of "Dragon" (Issue 140), Ken Rolston reviewed two supplements published by Pacesetter just before it went out of business, "Vampires" and "Creature Feature". Rolston had a more favourable opinion of "Vampires", calling it an "excellent book... The graphic presentation is top-notch." Rolston was particularly enthusiastic about the writing, which he called, "exceptional" and concluded, "I highly recommend this supplement." He was less enthusiastic about "Creature Feature", saying, "This supplement lacks the graphic quality or refined presentation of the finer "Chill" supplements." Rolston thought the concept of allowing players to become monsters and prey on humans did have "an oddly redeeming appeal", but felt that "the replay value negligible." He gave this supplement a thumbs down, saying, ""Creature Feature" will not be of use to most GMs, but students of the hobby may find it interesting for a brief diversion or as a curiosity."