In 2019, Seton Hall Prep soccer won another Non-Public A state title after beating St. Augustine 1–0. The Pirates also won the sectional title after defeating Pingry School 5–3, and won the Essex County Tournament after besting Montclair High School by a score 1–0. In addition to county and state championships, the boys soccer team won the Super Essex Conference by finishing first in regular season play and thus completed the triple crown. Beyond trophies, the 2019 season was highlighted by program records where the team tied the school record of 22 wins in one season and set a new record with 20 shutout games.