The soccer team won the 2005 North A state sectional championship with a 50 win over Don Bosco Preparatory High School. In 2007 the team achieved a number one statewide ranking from "The Star-Ledger" and a number five ranking in a national coaches' poll. The 2007 team won the North A state sectional championship with consecutive 3-2 wins over No. 1 ranked Don Bosco, and then the new No. 1 team and rival Delbarton in the North Jersey Final. The team moved on to win the Non-Public A state championship with a 2–0 win over Christian Brothers Academy. They finished the season at 22–1, with several school records: 16 shutouts, 22 wins, 95 goals.