Records suggest that Davis and "Virginia" made at least one other Atlantic crossing, from England to the more successful Jamestown Settlement, a project of the Virginia Company of London. "Virginia" was apparently one of the two pinnaces in tow behind one of the larger ships of the Third Supply mission to Jamestown, which left Plymouth in 1609. They encountered a 3-day storm thought to have been a hurricane, resulting in the shipwreck of the flagship of the fleet, the "Sea Venture", on Bermuda.