"Push It" remained in the Modern Rock top 10 and hovering around the mid-50s on the Hot 100 until the second week of July. By this time, second single "I Think I'm Paranoid" had debuted on the Modern Rock chart. Almo serviced remixes of "Push It" by New York City producer Victor Calderone to DJs; the song debuted on the Hot Dance Music/Club Play chart in mid-July at number 44. "Push It" rose to number five by the end of August. Capitalizing on the song's gain in popularity in nightclubs, the label commercially issued a double A-side 12-inch vinyl of Calderone remixes of "Push It" backed with mixes of "I Think I'm Paranoid" by The Crystal Method, on October 20. In total, "Push It" spent 18 weeks on the Hot 100 (exiting in early September), 21 weeks on the Modern Rock charts (leaving a week earlier) and 13 weeks on the dance chart (in early October).