"Masterpiece Theatre", the band's follow-up album, was released as planned on February 24, 2009, as announced on the band's MySpace on January 22, 2009.The album debuted at No. 4 on the Canadian Albums Chart. "Cross My Heart" became the band's second song to peak at No. 1 on both the Much Music Countdown and iTunes Canada Digital Download. "Cross My Heart" was nominated for four MMVAs in 2009 and was certified platinum in Canada. Recently after, Marianas Trench reached the No. 1 spot with the song "All To Myself" on Much Music's MOD. "All To Myself" also made Platinum certification in August 2009 in Canada. The music video for "Beside You" premiered on MuchOnDemand on October 30, 2009.