Peters then had supporting roles in the films "An American Crime" (2007), "Gardens of the Night" (2008), "Never Back Down" (2008), and its sequel "" (2011). He has also starred in several theater plays, including playing Fagin in a production of "Oliver Twist" at the Met Theater. In 2008, he had a recurring role as Jack Daniels on The CW teen-drama series "One Tree Hill". In addition, he landed many one episode guest spots in television series such as "The Mentalist", "House", "Monk", "The Office", "In Plain Sight", and "Parenthood".