Lucy (now played by Bell) returns to Ramsay Street permanently. Upon her return, she is different than she was before she had departed. The high-level intellectual was gone, replaced by a stereotypical 1990s blond bimbo bombshell. Following her expulsion from Alumwood, she re-enrols at Erinsborough High to complete Year Twelve. During this time, she is constantly battling the unrequited affections of Todd's friend Josh Anderson (Jeremy Angerson), but she is more interested in Glen Donnelly (Richard Huggett), despite knowing that he is her half-brother. The pair prepare to have sex, but are caught by Paul. He tells Jim, who is disbelieving at first, accusing Paul of lying, however, Helen confirms this is the truth. After a few arguments, the family agrees to move forward. Lucy then confesses to Glen's ex-girlfriend, Gemma Ramsay (Beth Buchanan) who then slaps her. Scenes showing Lucy and Glen's relationship were edited out and cut by the BBC in their UK airing.