Fuld had a "big winter" playing winter ball in Venezuela on the Tigres de Aragua, who he helped lead to a championship. He hit leadoff for Aragua, while batting .322 with 5 triples (leading the league), 36 walks and 43 runs (2nd), 16 doubles (5th), a .425 on-base percentage (7th), and a .938 OPS (8th). For his 2008–09 winter performance, including walking nearly twice as much as he struck out, he was elected to the "Baseball America" All Winter League Team.