"Punk in Drublic" was followed by 1996's "Heavy Petting Zoo", whose LP companion featured different cover art and the name "Eating Lamb". The artwork for the CD featured a man holding a sheep, while the LP depicted the same man in a 69 position with the sheep. The "Eating Lamb" version was banned from sale in Germany due to its obscene cover art. The LP version did not achieve the success of its predecessor, although it was the first NOFX record to achieve a position on the "Billboard" charts, reaching number 63. Fat Mike stated: "Weird record. I thought it was the coolest record when we finished it, but a few months later I wasn't so sure. Some of those songs are kinda weird. I like the cover a lot though. I think it sold well in Belgium."