In 1992, Case scored a radio hit with the song "Dream About You" which peaked at #16 on the U.S. "Billboard" Modern Rock charts. After a third album for Geffen, "Six-Pack of Love," Case recorded a live-in-the-studio album of cover versions of folk, blues, and country songs, "Peter Case Sings Like Hell," which was released on Case's own Travelin' Light label. Case signed a contract with Vanguard Records, and the record was re-released on that label in 1993. His next Vanguard record, "Torn Again," was issued in 1995, and features Case with a band including the rhythm section of Don Heffington and Jerry Scheff, with Greg Leisz on guitar.