The LP did not debut on on "Billboard" all-genre Top 200 Albums chart until thirteen months after its release, which was credited to its slow-building online buzz and licensing in TV commercials. During its initial release, the album peaked at number 114. It spent 111 weeks altogether on the Independent Albums chart, peaking at number three, and also peaked at number four on its Top Heatseekers chart. "Give Up" spent nineteen non-consecutive weeks at the top of the publication's Top Electronic Albums chart; in total, it logged over 90 weeks on the chart. It was number two album for that chart's year-end ranking for 2004, with "Billboard" Paoletta characterizing it as "the little album that could." Sales of the album and singles on the nascent iTunes Music Store were high, with "Give Up" also routinely topping the platform's Top Electronic Albums chart.