As early as 1935, St. Marnocks were unable to field a team against Innisfails, who were back playing again, at Brian Boru Park. St. Marnocks had won the game by 1–1 to 0–1 but Innisfails were objecting to them being awarded the points because the list of players supplied by St. Marnocks contained only 14 names. The game was refixed for the following Sunday in Parnell Park. St. Marnocks were already in danger of breaking up. As things worked out they did not break up and Innisfails went on to reach the final of the Dublin Junior Football Championship only to be beaten by St. Pauls by 1–3 to 0–3. The following September, St. Marnocks beat the reigning Dublin Junior Football Champions, St. Pauls, in the semi-final of the Loving Cup by 1–4 to 0–2.