Jeter received several honors after his senior season. These included an All-State honorable mention, distinguishing him as one of the best high school baseball players in Michigan, the Kalamazoo Area B'nai B'rith Award for Scholar Athlete, the 1992 High School Player of the Year Award from the American Baseball Coaches Association, the 1992 Gatorade High School Player of the year award, and "USA Today"s High School Player of the Year. Jeter earned a baseball scholarship to attend the University of Michigan and play college baseball for the Michigan Wolverines.