Webcomics reviewer Eric Burns said in 2008 that ""Perry Bible Fellowship" is a comic that works in subversion humor... and Gurewitch is a master at it... The problem is, this is a well that's way too easy to drain dry. Twenty or thirty times, you'll get a horrified laugh. Then, people will expect it. Finally, it will have no impact. It's just what "Perry Bible Fellowship" does." Burns did praise the artistic style, and said that "when he's on his A game, it's hard to think of anyone who's better in webcomics -- particularly in four panel gag-a-day."