When she discovered what Laurie did to his wife Sinead and rival Sienna, she supports them, where she forgives Sienna for everything she had done to her six years ago. Nancy is horrified to find that Finn has been released from prison. However, she decides to forgive him. With her, John-Paul, Sally and Edward help, they wanted him to be a good father to Bella causing Finn to leave the village, but allows him to return to village to visit anytime he wants. However, more tragedy occurs when her boyfriend Kyle commits suicide. Kyle's watch is later stolen, and Nancy discovers that John-Paul hasn stole it causing her angry and refuses to see him even though she drop the charges. However, she later forgives him upon learning that he was used by his cousin Theresa with the help of her boyfriend Seth and learn that Silas has return.