In 1986, Jones, by then having become a Christian, starred in "Into the Light", a musical about scientists and the Shroud of Turin, which closed four days after it opened. He had far more success touring in the one-man show "St. John in Exile" as the last surviving Apostle of Jesus Christ, reminiscing about his life while imprisoned on the Greek island of Patmos. A performance was filmed in 1986. He made one more Broadway appearance, in 1993, at the Vivian Beaumont Theater, in a special two-day concert staging of "Company" featuring most of the original Broadway cast.