It was a roaring success, and it catapulted the Marx Brothers to superstardom, accepted by the New York smart set of the Algonquin Round Table. Alexander Woollcott and Robert Benchley were among the theatre critics who made "I'll Say She Is" a smash, and George S. Kaufman would co-write their next two Broadway musicals, "The Cocoanuts" (1925) and "Animal Crackers" (1928). Unlike those shows, however, "I'll Say She Is" was never made into a film. A version of its opening scene, however, was made into a short for Paramount Pictures as part of a feature called "The House That Shadows Built" (1931), made to celebrate Paramount's 20th anniversary of their founding in 1912, and as a promotion for the then-upcoming Marx film "Monkey Business". An animated version of the Napoleon scene (with Groucho voicing himself) was incorporated into an ABC-TV special called "The Mad, Mad, Mad Comedians" (1970).