In 2012, Sheth continued to choose a variety of challenging roles in independent films. She starred opposite Lynn Chen and Parry Shen in "Yes, We're Open", a sex comedy exploring open relationships. She again paired with Chen in "Nice Girls Crew", which also stars Michelle Krusiec, and starred in "The Wisdom Tree", a film blending science fiction, new age and mysticism. Sheth stepped behind the camera to co-produce "Reign", a short film dramatizing how miscommunication can lead to war. She also starred in the film, which was written and directed by Kimberly Jentzen and shot by Oscar-nominated Cinematographer Jack Green. "Reign" received the Award of Merit from Best Shorts.