"PC Gamer"s Desslock called it "a game by "D&D" fans and for "D&D" fans, and it provides all RPG fans with the opportunity to experience one of the genre’s classic adventures." "GameSpot"'s Greg Kasavin echoed those sentiments; it gave the game a 7.9 out of 10, calling the game "one of the most authentic PC "Dungeons & Dragons" experiences of the past few years." Jamie Madigan of GameSpy gave the game four out of five stars, but he made note of a lack of multiplayer options. Tal Blevins of "IGN" gave it a 7.5, saying ""ToEE" isn't perfect, but it's certainly not a stinker." GameZone gave an 8.4 out of 10, saying it "is a game that those who are serious about "D&D"-based RPGs should have in their library." John Breeden II of "The Washington Post" complimented the game's graphics, particularly the animated scenery, and also said that "onsters appear suitably gruesome". According to GameSpy, "players who persevered were rewarded with an ultimately fun and satisfying experience – just not the mind-blowing one they had hoped for."