In partnership with Charles Wyndham in 1900 at the Criterion, Bourchier produced "His Excellency the Governor", "Lady Huntworth’s Experiment", "The Noble Lord", and "Mamma". He became lessee of the Garrick Theatre in September 1900. Over the six years of his management at the Garrick, he produced many plays, often starring himself and Vanbrugh, including "The Bishop's Move", "My Lady Virtue", "Whitewashing Julia", "The Arm of the Law" and W. S. Gilbert's "The Fairy's Dilemma" (1904). Their production of "The Walls of Jericho" by Alfred Sutro, in 1904, ran for a very successful 423 performances.