"Chase This Light" debuted at number five on the US "Billboard" 200 chart, selling around 62,000 copies in its first week. It appeared on various component charts: number 2 on Alternative Albums and Tastemaker Albums, and number 3 on Top Rock Albums. It reached number 11 in Canada, number 27 in the UK, number 28 in Scotland, number 30 in Australia, number 54 in Germany, number 73 in Austria, and number 94 in Switzerland. "Big Casino" charted at number 3 on Alternative Airplay, and number 22 on Bubbling Under Hot 100. It also reached number 59 on Canadian Hot 100, and number 119 in the UK. "Always Be" charted at number 14 on Alternative Airplay, and also reached number 37 in the UK.