Some reviewers were more critical of the game. The reviewer for "Computer Gaming World" said that "There's nothing really wrong with "Outlaws". There just isn't much right with it." The reviewer noted that the game had excellent music and art, but felt that the game had nothing new or innovative to offer players. "Edge" magazine's reviewer stated that "not for the first time, shown that it's not infallible." Charlie Brooker of "PC Zone (UK)" had to take time to warm up to the game. "when you start playing Outlaws, it feels downright cruddy." Brooker stated that after a lengthy amount of play his opinion changed, and ultimately he gave the game a favorable review.