On April 9, playing right field against the Chicago White Sox who had the bases loaded, Fuld made what the "Tampa Tribune" called "one of the best catches in team history". Rays center fielder B.J. Upton said: "Oh my god, oh my. I thought he was going to dive into the ... I was screaming from center field when he caught it. 'Great catch!' Should be play of the year so far." His popularity spread on the internet by late April, with the "Toronto Sun" writing: "Fuld ranks in the Top 10 in batting average, runs, and triples, and also leads the AL in stolen bases and YouTube hits, especially video hits for a catch in Chicago diving towards the right field corner onto the warning track that has been set to a Superman theme."