The band put out one more record for Matador, "On the Mouth" in 1993. After Matador entered into a distribution agreement with major label Atlantic Records, Superchunk decided to leave the label, even though the Atlantic logo did not have to be displayed on their releases. Instead, the band opted to release their following records through Merge. The next album, "Foolish", brought further critical acclaim for the band in 1994. A second singles compilation (the first was 1992's "Tossing Seeds") came out in the summer of 1995. It was titled "Incidental Music 1991–95" and contained most of their hard-to-find tracks (imports, B-sides, comp. tracks) released between 1991 and 1995.