Over his 406 game NHL career Sutter exclusively played for the Chicago Blackhawks franchise scoring 161 goals, 118 assists totaling 279 points and 288 penalty minutes, in addition to 24 goals, 19 assists and 26 penalty minutes in 51 Stanley Cup playoff games. Owing to his early retirement and injuries, Sutter's 406 games and 51 playoff games are both the lowest amongst the six Sutter brothers. Despite his low number of games Darryl averaged 0.397 goals per game, the highest amongst the Sutter brothers, slightly ahead of Brian's 0.389.