Responding the Minister for Fisheries, Fionán Lynch TD said that he did not agree that the people had left the island because of illegal fishing and was making enquiries as to their current circumstances. The Minister said that he "would like to feel that everything was being done to keep them from being a permanent charge on home assistance." The Minister later sent a Principal Officer from his Department to report on their circumstances. The Minister then reported in the Dáil that "four of the Inistrahull families derived their livelihood from the Irish Lights boat service to the island, in which they are still able to engage" and that there was no case state intervention. He also said that his Officer's report indicated that the resettled Islanders were not in "poor circumstances."