Ruth Deller of television website Lowculture gave Lucy a 3.5 out of 5 for her contribution to "Neighbours", in a feature called "A guide to recognising your Ramsays and Robinsons". Deller said "Lucy's dramatic tenure(s) involved being one of the first of many Ramsay Street residents to fall down a drain and to experience temporary blindness (although she combined the two mishaps), getting sent away to boarding school, engaging in a spot of incest, modelling, marrying a rich older man and having a drugs problem".