"NASCAR 98" received mostly positive reviews, with critics praising the authentic handling, multiplayer mode, smooth and detailed graphics, and the comprehensive usage of NASCAR licensing, with real world cars, drivers, tracks, and sponsorships. Glenn Rubenstein of "GameSpot" was particularly pleased at the greater number of cars and relatively small tracks, which together ensure that the player is constantly vying for a place. "IGN" stated that "with a smooth frame rate and very little draw-in, "NASCAR 98" looks and moves almost flawlessly. Even with a crowded track the game moves butter smooth". Some warned that the game would appeal only to hardcore simulation fans, and the average gamer would have more fun with an arcade-style racer. However, Kelly Rickards said in "Electronic Gaming Monthly": "You don't have to be a fan of NASCAR to enjoy this game. I don't follow the sport, but I can appreciate all the good things EA did with this game". "GamePro" gave the PlayStation version a 4.5 out of 5 for graphics and sound and a perfect 5.0 for control and fun factor, commenting: "The popularity of NASCAR racing has mushroomed - it's now only rivaled by the NFL - and this game's powerful combination of sleek graphics, detailed features, and fender-crumpling action will satisfy any serious race fan".