Despite this success it was Trisha Yearwood's version that succeeded the most on country radio. Although Yearwood's version was moving quickly up the pop charts, getting as high as number 23, MCA refused to issue any more copies of the single for fear of cannibalizing album sales. As a result, the limited press run of 300,000 sold out quickly, and the single was off the Hot 100 after 12 weeks. However on country radio it became a much bigger success, climbing all the way to number 2 for one week (held out of the top spot by Kenny Chesney's hit 'She's Got It All,') far outpacing the peak of 43 set by the recording Rimes released.