The softball team won the Non-Public Group A state championship in 2001 (against runner-up Paramus Catholic High School in the finals of the tournament), 2002 (vs. Immaculate Heart Academy), 2004 (vs. Mount Saint Dominic Academy), 2010 (vs. Paramus Catholic High School), 2011 (vs. Immaculate Heart), 2013 (vs. Immaculate Heart) and 2018 (vs. Mount Saint Dominic). The six state group titles are ranked seventh-most in the state. The 2001 team won the program's first state championship, winning the Parochial A title with a 2-1 defeat of Paramus Catholic. The team won the 2002 Parochial South A sectional championship with a 3-2 win over Red Bank Catholic High School. The 2004 team repeated as sectional champion, with a 5-0 shutout of Red Bank Catholic High School and moved on to win the Group A state championship with a 1-0 win over Mount Saint Dominic Academy, the lone run coming in the bottom of the seventh due to an error on a bunt that allowed a runner to score from second base. The 2004 team finished the season with a perfect 33-0 record, setting the state mark for the number of wins in a season by a girls softball team, and gave the Lady Lancers three state titles in four years, the only exception being an extra innings loss in the 2003 tournament final to Immaculate Heart Academy. The Lady Lancer softball team, led by Coach Kim Lombardi, won the 2010 NJSIAA Non-Public A state title with a 4-1 victory over Paramus Catholic High School, the program's fourth state title and its first since 2004, finishing the season as the #2 ranked team in the state by "The Star-Ledger". NJ.com / "The Star-Ledger" ranked St. John Vianney as their number-one softball team in the state in 2002, 2004, 2011 and 2013.