Starting in 2000, he was an offensive coordinator at Christian High School San Diego, in El Cajon, California, a suburb of San Diego, under Head Coach Matt Oliver. In 2007, he coached at Desert Hills High School and as the Offensive Coordinator and Quarterbacks Coach. He then became an assistant coach for Oaks Christian High School in California. In December 2010, Jay was hired as the Director of Football Operations at Village Christian School in Sun Valley, California. He also coached Varsity and JV golf at Village Christian.