Under player/manager Simon Spooner New Bradwell St Peter were Senior Division champions in the league's inaugural season, earning promotion to the Premier Division. In 1999–2000 they won the Berks and Bucks Senior Trophy under the management of Andy Milne and Paul Bevis, beating Milton Keynes City 3–1 on penalties after a 1–1 draw. However, the club finished bottom of the Premier Division in 2001–02 and were relegated to Division One. In 2012–13 they finished bottom of Division One and were relegated to Division Two.