From 2014-2016, Nitkowski was a studio analyst for Fox Sports 1, where he was a regular on their baseball highlight show "MLB Whip Around", which debuted on March 31, 2013. He also made appearances on FS1's other studio shows as well as Fox's Saturday MLB pre- and post-game coverage. Other analysts he has worked with at FS1 include former MLB players Frank Thomas, Gabe Kapler, Mark Sweeney, Raúl Ibañez, Pete Rose, Alex Rodriguez and Eric Karros. Nitkowski has called nationally televised MLB games for FS1 and Fox from 2014-2019 and has worked with play-by-play men Thom Brennaman, Kenny Albert, Brian Anderson, Len Kasper, Rich Waltz, Justin Kutcher and Tom McCarthy. He started in television on CBS Sports Network, where he served as a color analyst on NCAA baseball games. He has also made appearances on MLB Network and ESPN.