Jarosław Jerry Szprot of Metal Storm, in comparing the album to their previous release, said ""Mythmaker" is basically more of the same". He stated that while the band was doing a lot of experimenting, something was still missing, but continued that newcomers would probably find the album quite interesting and original. Trey Spencer of Sputnikmusic described the album as a blend of elements from many of their previous albums, and also said it would be a good first album for new listeners to buy.