The four reviewers of "Electronic Gaming Monthly" had similar reactions, while Rich Leadbetter of "Sega Saturn Magazine" argued that even the shorter "Virtua Cop" has far more longevity than it is usually given credit for, as both it and the sequel have numerous modes and approaches that can provide players with new challenges on repeat plays. Tom Ham wrote in "GameSpot": "While the first "Virtua Cop" set a new standard for light gun shooters, Sega and the AM2 team have delivered an incredible sequel that takes the concept to a whole new level".