Under new boss Eddie May Barr began playing at right back during the 2009–10 season rather than his more normal centre back role. With his contract due to expire at the end of the season, May confirmed in January that Hibs had made two attempts to sign Barr along with Aberdeen. Barr choose to sign for Hearts on a pre-contract in January rather than leave Falkirk immediately opting to help them escape relegation. Falkirk failed to avoid relegation and Barr left on a low note expressing hope that Falkirk would gain promotion quickly.