From the 1990s into the 21st century, McGovern continued her careers in musical theatre, performing in concerts, and recording albums, and she occasionally made guest appearances on television. Other recordings include "Baby I'm Yours" (1992), a collection of her favorite songs from 1955 to 1970, and "Out of This World" (1996), a collection of songs by Harold Arlen. She was nominated twice for a Grammy, for her albums "The Music Never Ends" (1997), a collection of songs by Alan & Marilyn Bergman, and "The Pleasure of His Company" (1998), another voice/piano album.