On 22 January 2020, Fox Sports released a video which was leaked online showing Reynolds verbally abusing a woman who was at his residence. In the 37 second video, Reynolds can be seen swearing at the woman saying "Give me my phone, where the f*ck is it?, "Get out of my house. I want you out now. I want you out now or I’m going to f*cking flip it. I swear to god I’m going to flip it". Reynolds then called the woman a "C*nt" and a "Dog". The Wests Tigers then released a statement saying "Both Josh and Wests Tigers have previously alerted the NRL Unit as to this matter and will continue to work closely with them as required. As the subject matter is before the courts, Wests Tigers will be making no further comment".