As the war broadened, many settlers fled the region. Anna Stina and Peter returned to the area 3 years later, though settlement didn't fully rebound until the 1890s. The victims were reburied in New London, Minnesota, in 1891 and marked with a state-funded monument. Anna Stina had married another West Lake Settlement refugee in 1864 and they moved to Pennington County in northwestern Minnesota in 1880. She died in 1933 at the age of 87. Peter Broberg placed a memorial marker at the cabin site in a 1917 ceremony, and died in New London in 1925.