Writing for "Metal Hammer", Alec Chillingworth said that "'Lunchbox', 'Get Your Gunn', 'Wrapped In Plastic' and 'Dope Hat' are the catchiest on the album". In a piece they wrote for "Clash", the Astroid Boys deemed "Get Your Gunn" one of their "personal favourites" from Marilyn Manson's catalogue and praised its lyrics for capturing the hypocrisy in Gunn's murder. Jon Wiederhorn of "Loudwire" praised the track for "driving the record" and helping the band to retain the loyal fan-base that it had cultivated prior to the release of "Portrait of an American Family".