In March 2019, Casey was found responsible for additional Title IX violations in a separate UVA investigation. Among the supported allegations, Casey used the word "cunt" while teaching, called a student a “sexy Irish pirate”, commented regularly on female students’ appearances, and showed up uninvited to a female student's house and “was overly critical and hostile to her when she rebuffed him”. The panel recommended that Casey be permanently banned from UVA property and made ineligible for paid or unpaid UVA employment.