In 2013 the club decided, due to the cost of travelling to away games, to leave the CMFL, and join the more local Sheffield & Hallamshire County Senior Football League (S&HCSL). Kiveton entered the Second Division of the S&HCSL for the start of the 2013–14 season. After years in Division Two, Park won promotion to Division One of the S&HCSL in 2017; the same year that the club left its Hard Lane home of nearly a century to move to the playing fields of Wales High School.