Historians have shown little interest in the agreement, either mentioning it in passing or ignoring it altogether. Stubbs does not mention it in his "Constitutional History of England", nor does Hume in his "History of England". Skene's "Celtic Scotland" refers to it as an agreement in his background discussion for the reign of Alexander II's successor, Alexander III, while Burton's "History of Scotland" mentions that claims of land were discussed in 1237 and briefly describes some of them, but makes no reference to an agreement or treaty. James Hill Ramsay's "Dawn of the Constitution" gives a fuller discussion of the agreement, but does not give it any particular prominence.