At the end of the episode, the group takes Katie back to the Empire State Building, and Marshall says that the last trip did not count because they did not get out of the lobby. Lily points out that, by that logic, he is the only one she has had sex with. Later that day, after Katie has left, they go to the bar and beg Barney to tell them the real story of his first time. He reluctantly admits that he was 23 and it was with his mother's 45-year-old friend Rhonda, who called him Barry the whole time. Realizing how much this embarrasses Barney, the group decides to pretend they never heard the real story.