Following the success of "American Pie 2", Reid starred in a number of commercial and critical misfires, including "Josie and the Pussycats" and "Van Wilder". She also starred as the youngest daughter of a Texas gynecologist in Robert Altman's "Dr. T & the Women", alongside Richard Gere. She returned to the small screen as a recurring character on the NBC sitcom, "Scrubs", appearing in 11 episodes of season three. Shortly thereafter, Reid appeared alongside Ashton Kutcher in "My Boss's Daughter", for which she was nominated for both Worst Supporting Actress and Worst Screen Couple at the 2004 Golden Raspberry Awards.