The Man with Pimples On His Chin first appears in "The Carnivorous Carnival" where he mistakes the Hook-Handed Man as a freak to which the Hook-Handed Man states that he isn't one. The Man with Pimples On His Chin apologizes and advises the Hook-Handed Man to get some fake hands. During the show, he joins the Hook-Handed Man into heckling Hugo. Violet and Klaus in the alias of the two-headed person Beverly and Elliot encountered the Man With Pimples On His Chin before the lion-feeding event where he asks them why one of them doesn't wear a bag over their head. Sunny in the alias of Chabo the Wolf Baby grows at them as Violet tells him to leave them alone as Chabo is protective of them. The Man With Pimples On His Chin states that Chabo won't be a match for the lions which his mother agrees on. During the lion-feeding show, The Man with Pimples On His Chin tells Beverly and Elliot to jump into the lion pit. During the commotion where nobody would push Beverly and Elliot into the lion pit, The Man with Pimples On His Chin was accidentally slapped by an audience member as he begins to argue with him and his wife where the worsening commotion caused Madame Lulu and the Bald Man with the Big Nose to be accidentally knocked into the lion pit where they are devoured. When the Caligari Carnival was set on fire, The Man with Pimples On His Chin and his mother aren't seen again after that.