Unterberger commented, however, that the song does not rely on gimmicks and has other aspects that make it compelling. He added that the vocal parts by lead singer Keith Relf, backed by atmospheric harmonies, provide contrasting melancholic and upbeat sections. According to French, "the new single's melancholy, hard-bitten lyrics were a perfect match to Keith's voice". The song is partly propelled by a strummed acoustic guitar by Relf, giving it an element of contemporary folk music or folk rock. McCarty and session bassist Ron Prentice (who also played bass on "For Your Love") comprise the rhythm section. Yardbirds' bassist Paul Samwell-Smith, who assumed the role of producer for "For Your Love", is listed as "Musical Director" on the Columbia 45rpm single. Gomelsky received the credit as the song's producer.