When asked in a 2001 interview with "Margen Magazine", whether he thinks "Sing to God" is the band's best album due to it being their "more known album", Tim Smith replied "no… I sort of like them all in one way or another." The band followed "Sing to God" with "Guns" (1999), their final album, which shocked fans due to its less restless sound. In an interview with "Prog", Devin Townsend said "Sing to God" is the prog album he plays to "get in a good mood": "It's uplifting and intense. Some of the chord changes are so unconventional and hilarious." In a 2014 list entitled "The Arresting Sound of Cardiacs", written by Ben Saunders for "The Hooded Utilitarian", "Fiery Gun Hand" and "Dirty Boy" from "Sing to God" featured as the seventh and eighth tracks. In a 2015 list for "Team Rock", musician Mike Vennart included "Eat it Up Worms Hero", "Dog Like Sparky" and "Dirty Boy" in his list of "The 10 Best Cardiacs Songs".