In 2011, Teegarden co-starred in the slasher film "Scream 4" as a horror loving high schooler. Also in 2011, Teegarden starred opposite Thomas McDonell in the Disney film "Prom" as Nova Prescott, an overachieving high school senior, bound for Georgetown University after graduation, trying to put together the prom while dealing with love, heartbreak, and pressure from her parents, and falling in love with the school bad boy Jesse Richter (McDonnell). In May 2011, she was named "TV Actress of the Year" by Young Hollywood Awards for her work on "Friday Night Lights". In June 2011, she signed on to co-star in the war drama "Love and Honor", with Liam Hemsworth and Teresa Palmer. Teegarden also played Abby in "Beneath the Darkness".