Andrew was a prominent "alternative" comedian, as that term was understood in the U.S. at the turn of the millennium. His long-running "The Second Show" and Eugene Mirman and Bobby Tisdale's "Invite Them Up" were the first comedy shows at Rififi/Cinema Classics, one of alternative or indie comedy's most important New York venues. His one-person shows, "Petula Clark's Greatest Hits", "Bridge-Burner", and "Me and Hitler" were all presented as part of the Edinburgh Festival Fringe In 2003, he made a high-profile return to singing as part of the "Loser's Lounge Tribute to the Bee Gees", which was followed by two New York-area solo shows. In 2007, Andrew was a consultant for a new Fringe venue, The Green Room. His 2006-2008 blog was featured on the UK's Chortle comedy website.