In July 2011, he moved to Bala Town and helped the side achieve 5th place in the 2011–12 season playing a record number of games and making a clean sweep of end of season awards. In 2012–13, Bala were play-off champions and qualified for the first time in the club's history for a European position in the 2013–14 campaign. Bala qualified again for the Europa Cup in the ensuing seasons, 2014–15, 2015–16, 2016–17. Murtagh has been club captain of Bala Town since 2014.