Milne played in the drawn 2010 AFL Grand Final, in which he kicked two of St Kilda ten goals for the game against Collingwood. He was involved in the game's pivotal moment: St Kilda was trailing by one point with 90 seconds remaining, a 60m running shot by Lenny Hayes () landed 10m in front of the right behind post and in the vicinity of Milne and his opponent; the ball took one bounce 45° left toward the goal, then another bounce 90° right and went through for the tying behind, eluding Milne's efforts to gather the unpredictable ball. Some retrospective views of the match have criticised Milne for allowing the ball to bounce rather than attacking the ball harder, although whether this would even have been possible is debatable. St Kilda ended up losing the grand final replay the following week.