In 2012, Bleu also had a role in and co-produced the indie horror anthology "Scary or Die" (2012), a collection of five short horror films. In 2012, he joined the cast of "Godspell" as Jesus beginning April 17 at the Circle in the Square Theatre. He joined co-stars on the 66th Annual Tony Awards, to performing "Day by Day" and "Light of the World" at Beacon Theatre, with Neil Patrick Harris as the host. During this time, he recorded the duet "If I Never Knew You" (2012), with Anna Maria Perez de Tagle to promote "Pocahontas". He guest starred in one episode of "Blue Bloods" as Officer Blake in 2012. In 2012, he performed the voice Drew in "Twinkle Toes", Bleu starred in the drama film "To Write Love on Her Arms" (originally titled "Renee") in 2012, with Kat Dennings, Chad Michael Murray and Rupert Friend. The film began production in Orlando, Florida, in February 2011.