Peters has co-starred in a number of television movies, including "The Last Best Year" (1990) with Mary Tyler Moore, "Cinderella" (1997) with Brandy (receiving a nomination for the "Golden Satellite Award" for her role), and "Prince Charming" (2003) with Martin Short. She co-starred in her own television series, "All's Fair", with Richard Crenna in 1976–77. She played a young, liberal photographer, who becomes romantically involved with an older, conservative columnist. Although Peters was praised for her charismatic performance, the show ran for only one season. Peters was nominated for a Golden Globe award as Best TV Actress – Musical/Comedy. In March 2005, she made a pilot for an ABC situation comedy series titled "Adopted", co-starring with Christine Baranski, but it was not picked up. Peters appeared in the Lifetime television movie "Living Proof", which was first broadcast on October 18, 2008. She played the role of Barbara, an art teacher with breast cancer, who is initially reluctant to participate in the study for the cancer drug Herceptin. Andrew Gans of "Playbill" wrote, "Peters is able to choose from an expansive emotional palette to color the character, and her performance... is moving, humorous and ultimately spirit-raising".