The change was well received, as the album stayed on Billboard's Christian albums chart for more than five months and was the third consecutive Petra album to receive a Grammy for Best Rock Gospel Album. The short-lived America's Christian Music Awards named Petra favorite rock group or duo and named "Wake Up Call" favorite rock CD, and the band won a Dove award for Rock Album of the Year. In the 1994 "CCM" Readers Awards, the band continued to clean up, winning Favorite Rock Artist/Band, Favorite Rock Album for "Wake Up Call" and Favorite Song for the radio hit "Just Reach Out".