2018 saw Matter star in the Hallmark Channel original movie "Love at First Dance" as former 'Most Eligible Bachelor' Eric alongside dance instructor Hope,(Becca Tobin), which was broadcast as part of the channel's annual 'June Weddings' event. In July of the same year, Matter starred as college professor Nick Miller in the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries franchise the "Aurora Teagarden Mysteries", which star Candace Cameron Bure, in an installment entitled "The Disappearing Game". He went on to reprise the role in five further films in the series, broadcast in 2019 and 2020.