Her 2000 work includes appearances in episodes of "The Beat" and "", as well as a role in The American Collection adaptation of "Cora Unashamed", a short story by Langston Hughes from his 1934 collection "The Ways of White Folks". Muth also had a guest role in "Don't Ask", the original unaired pilot episode of the 2000 Fox show that eventually aired as "Normal, Ohio". The show's revamp eliminated her role. That year, Muth played the lead in the Lifetime Original Movie "The Truth About Jane" about a high school girl's struggle with her sexuality and acceptance.