Enrollment was 400 in 2000, but fell to 281 in the 2010–2011 academic year; in November 2010, Ursuline President Julie Carver sent out an email to all parents announcing that for financial reasons the school would close the following May. Cardinal Newman became coeducational in the following academic year, 2011–2012, and took on all continuing Ursuline students. The campus became the site of Roseland Collegiate Prep, a charter high school, and was badly damaged in the Tubbs Fire in October 2017.