While still a One Tree Hill cast member, Burton-Morgan made her feature film debut opposite Allison Janney and Cheryl Hines in the 2005 well-reviewed drama "Our Very Own" which centered on five small-town teenagers who dream of a better life. Burton-Morgan and her co-stars received the "Outstanding Ensemble Acting" award at the prestigious Sarasota Film Festival. Burton-Morgan appeared in the 2007 Lifetime drama "Normal Adolescent Behavior" which followed a group of friends who are in a six-way polyfidelitous relationship. That same year, Burton-Morgan co-starred in the supernatural horror film "Solstice" opposite Amanda Seyfried and Elisabeth Harnois. Burton-Morgan also created her own production company, Southern Gothic Production (SoGoPro) in 2007, along with Nick Gray, Kelly Tenney, James Burton, and Meg Mortimer.