Continuing with the trend of producing radio hits, the title track became a major radio hit during 1983 and 1984, with "Grave Robber" being a minor radio hit during that same time. "Lift Him Up" was the featured praise song on this album. The album was massively successful in the still-new world of Christian rock: It became the No. 1 Christian album in the country in February 1984, dislodging Amy Grant's "Age to Age", which had held the top spot for more than a year. More than six months after its release, "Not of This World" remained in the top five, behind two albums by Grant and one by Sandi Patty. "More Power to Ya", in its 86th week on the chart, was still in the top 10.