The softball team won the 2003 North II, Group II state sectional title with a 2–1 win against Pequannock Township High School. The softball team repeated as sectional champs in 2004, shutting out Hoboken High School by a score of 10–0. The team was a sectional winner for the third consecutive time in 2005 with a 2–0 win against Governor Livingston High School in the tournament final. The team went on to win the 2005 Group II state championship with a 3–2 win against Audubon High School that came on a home run in the bottom of the seventh inning by Gina Capardi. The 2005 team finished with a record of 32-1-1, also won the county and conference championships and finished as the second-ranked team in the Star-Ledger's final top 20. Pitcher Kristen Schindler set the state record with 112 wins during her four-year career.