The Islanders would be seeded in the semifinals of the league's Playoffs where they would beat Rochester on an aggregate of 3:2 winning them a spot in the finals against Vancouver. In a controversial decision, the league awarded Vancouver the right to host the finals. After a 3:0 defeat against Santos Laguna in the CCL the club headed to Vancouver where after a hard fought game, the Islanders went down 2:1. The club would also sweep the USL-1 individual awards starting with Coach of the Year Colin Clarke, Defender of the Year (Cristian Arrieta), Goalkeeper of the Year (Bill Gaudette), and USL-1 MVP (Jonny Steele).