In 2016, Miranda Devine of "The Daily Telegraph" criticised the selection process, with the national selection panel having to choose from the eight candidates appointed by variously structured, state-based selection panels. Devine also said, "the award, which ought to reflect and unite this great nation, has evolved into a mere plaything of social engineers", noting also that three of the eight finalists were jointly involved in the same events. Concern has also been raised as to how a person who has not lived in a state "for 40-something years" (Cate McGregor) could be nominated as that state's representative. Following criticism of both the award process and the priorities of the 2016 recipient David Morrison, an editorial in "The Sydney Morning Herald" said, "The Herald knows the selection board will look closely at the 2016 process and work to improve public confidence in the awards in time for a better Australia Day in 2017".