In addition to Rickards, Maguire, and Randolph, the show includes a support cast consisting of Chris Boyer; producer Sara Beebe, who screens listener calls; and Elaina Smith, affectionately dubbed the "Mexican Leprechaun" by other members of the show. While Dunn was in a contract dispute with Clear Channel, Smith substituted for Dunn on air. Former cast members have included Nina Reeba (known as Ruth 66), sports producer David "Bromo" Abromowitz, and Shelly Brown (who was nicknamed "Chucko" to avoid confusion with Shelly Dunn).