The Kingsway softball team won back-to-back Group II state championships, in 1998 (with a tournament final win vs. Mahwah High School) and 1999 (against Jefferson Township High School), becoming the first female team in school history to win state titles, and won the Group III title in 2008 (vs. John F. Kennedy Memorial High School). The 1998 team won the Group II title with a 4-0 win against Mahwah in the championship game. The team won the Group II title in 1999 against Jefferson Township with a 1-0 no-hitter in the championship game. In 2012 the softball team won the South Jersey Group III state sectional championship with a 2-0 win against Central Regional High School.