Sarah informs Frankie about her and Craig's engagement and they arrange a party at the Dog. Craig is not happy when he learns about the party and that Sarah has bought her own engagement ring. When John Paul arrives at the party and finds out Craig is engaged to Sarah, he is furious. John Paul demands that Craig makes a choice— it's either him or Sarah. Craig is reluctant to make a choice so John Paul asks him who he cannot live without and Craig says "you" and kisses him. When Craig leaves the room, John Paul texts Sarah on Craig's phone asking her to come upstairs. Sarah comes upstairs and walks in on Craig and John Paul kissing. Craig tells a stunned Sarah it is not what she thinks, but she does not believe him. Sarah outs Craig to everybody by saying she caught him with John Paul. John Paul admits it was him who sent the text to Sarah and tries to get Craig to tell the truth about them, but Craig instead becomes enraged and John Paul is thrown out. Sarah demands to know why Craig would propose to her when he was sleeping with John Paul. When Craig does not answer her, Sarah physically attacks him. Craig tries to explain to his family, but they are all disappointed in him. Frankie even tells Craig he is no different from his father. Craig confronts John Paul over what he did, but John Paul says he has no sympathy for Craig.