The following day, Donna attends Laura's funeral, and witnesses Laura's father Leland throw himself on Laura's casket while sobbing hystericalluy At school, Donna is doing her makeup when Audrey comes in and tells her that she is aware of the secrets surrounding Laura's life, including that she had been seeing Dr. Lawrence Jacoby, something that Donna didn't know. Later, she goes to the woods with James to find the other half of the necklace that they buried as children, but they cannot find it. Donna later goes to the Double R Diner with him, where she meets Laura's cousin, Maddy Ferguson. She asks Maddy to assist them in their investigation into Laura's death. Later that night, Maddy cals Donna and tells her that she found a tape in Laura's hiding place. Donna listens to the tape and realized that it was recorded for Jacoby. She discovers that a tape recorded the night Laura died is missing. James believes that Jacoby must be in possession of the tape and suggests they go to Jacoby's office to find it, and they could lure him out with a "phone call from Laura." Later, she meets Maddy and James in the park, the former wearing a blonde wig to make her look identical to Laura.