On September 8, 2005, Jennifer was going home from a late-night shift at Wendy's, when she disappeared. Teague had met up with some friends at around 1 am in Mac’s Milk, a local convenience store on Tartan Dr. and Jockvale Rd. after her evening shift. It was when she started walking home alone in the early morning hours that her murderer, Kevin Davis abducted her. An extensive search was conducted by many local residents across much of the Barrhaven area and the disappearance made headlines across Canada. On September 18, her body was discovered by an off-duty police officer, dumped near a secluded parking lot leading to the Lime Kiln Trail off Moodie Drive in the Stony Swamp Conservation Area.