On January 20, Kurt Angle was forced to issue an open apology to Joy, but when the Big Show came out, Angle tried to leave the ring only to be get ushered back by The Cabinet. It turned out to be another ploy, as Angle and The Cabinet all attacked Big Show. After Weber's departure from WWE in February 2005, their feud was dropped suddenly and Joy would go on to win the 2005 Rookie Diva of the Year contest at No Way Out after beating out Michelle McCool, Rochelle Loewen, and Lauren Jones. On February 21 at a live event, Joy competed in a bikini contest which was won by Torrie Wilson. After winning the contest, Joy and her fellow "Smackdown" wrestlers would become involved in brief feuds with Dawn Marie and Melina.