"Beautiful Eyes" peaked at number nine on the US "Billboard" 200 and topped "Billboard"'s Top Country Albums chart, succeeding her self-titled debut album. "I Heart ?" was released as a promotional single in June 2008. Though the EP was not heavily promoted, Swift performed the title track at a few venues. While "Beautiful Eyes" and "I Heart ?" exist on Spotify as unplayable individual tracks on an alternate version of "Fearless", the EP as a whole is Swift's only project to remain unavailable on streaming services.