They are among the most successful USL League Two teams since joining the league in 2003. Since 2003, they have the sixth-best regular season record and the fourth-best home record in the league. They are also one of the best amateur clubs in the country when it comes to the U.S. Open Cup. As a USL League Two team, they have won 11 games (12 of them as a franchise) with six of them coming against professional opponents. Only two Open Division teams Flint City Bucks with 10 and Des Moines Menace with 7) have more pro team upsets in the Modern Era (1995–present).