Shortly after Andy arrives, Tyler is asked to deliver a package to his room. Tyler realizes that the package contains a Good Guys doll and, excited, takes it to the cellar to open it, only to have Chucky burst free from the package, intending to possess his now teenaged nemesis. When Chucky sees that Andy is not there, he is furious that Tyler took the package. Remembering the rule from his late voodoo instructor John Bishop that he can possess the first person who learns his true nature and that he has a new body, Chucky tells Tyler his secret, and decides to make Tyler his new target. Just as Chucky is about to possess him, Cochrane interrupts them and confiscates the doll, later throwing it into a garbage truck. However, Chucky escapes by luring the driver into the truck's compactor and crushing him. That night, Chucky attacks Andy and tells him his plans for taking over Tyler's body instead of Andy’s and tells Andy to stay out of his way. Before Andy can attack Chucky, Shelton comes in and takes the doll from him. Andy tries to reclaim by sneaking into Shelton's room (where Chucky steals a dagger from a wooden wall mounted plaque containing blades), but Shelton catches him in the act. Upon realizing the doll has vanished, Shelton suspects it stolen and forces all the cadets to do exercises in the courtyard as punishment.