Tighe played Fredrik in "Anatomy of Pain" on the Mirror Stage at the Ethnic Cultural Theatre in Seattle in 2012. In Sam Shepard's "Curse of the Starving Class", Tighe played Weston in 2013 at the Long Wharf Theatre in New Haven with Judith Ivey. He had the following thoughts in his approach to doing Shepard's play,"You have to beware of naturalism, which is the place actors tend to go into. You have to leave the ground for awhile and then hope you land." Later in 2013, Tighe played Lyman Wyeth in Other Desert Cities with Pamela Reed at ACT Theatre in Seattle.