The single entered the U.S. "Billboard" Hot 100 at number 68,: peaking at number 34 on the Hot 100, "Leave the Pieces" rose as high as number 1 on "Billboard"'s Hot Country Songs chart, the first track by a first-time charting duo to top the "Billboard" country music chart since 1991, and the first by a female duo since 1953. (The Wreckers had previously appeared on the "Billboard" Hot 100 with "I'm Feeling You" a collaborative single with Santana). Branch said of the song's success, "To see our hard work in getting this project off the ground result in my first number-one as an artist could not be more meaningful", while Jessica Harp said "It's an amazing feeling to have our debut single go number one, especially getting to share it with my dear friend. The fact that we've achieved such success is something I can't even comprehend yet. I just know that the stars have aligned, and it feels good to be a Wrecker." ("Leave the Pieces" was not actually the Wreckers' debut single: apart from their Santana collaboration "I'm Feeling You" in 2005 the Wreckers had that year had a single release with "The Good Kind" which had bubbled under the Hot 100 with a number 115 peak.)