In 2014, she portrayed Mel in the independent drama film "Electricity", starring opposite Agyness Deyn and Christian Cooke. In February 2014, it was announced that Crichlow had been cast as Stephie Bennett in the NBC comedy series "A to Z". The series was given a full season order, but was ultimately cancelled. She next appeared in the Kevin Pollak-directed comedy-drama "The Late Bloomer", alongside J. K. Simmons, Brittany Snow, and Johnny Simmons. Crichlow was then cast as Dina Clark in the ABC procedural crime drama series "Deception", alongside Jack Cutmore-Scott and Amaury Nolasco.