Producer Kenneth Ehrlich requested Celine Dion perform the song as part of a 2008 Grammy Nominations TV special. For her rendition, Dion sang it with only her band on stage. She included it on her Las Vegas residency show "Céline", and recorded a Babyface-produced cover for her eleventh English-language studio album "Loved Me Back to Life" (2013). According to Steve Morse of the "Boston Globe", the album version contains "a light Brazilian feel". Some critics praised Dion's performance, with "Slant Magazine"'s Eric Henderson writing it perfectly represents the singer as a "manic, Hallmark card-brandishing guru of schmaltz". On the other hand, Stephen Erlewine of AllMusic called the cover "thoroughly colorless adult contemporary." Dion also performed "At Seventeen" as part of a medley with her singles "A New Day Has Come" (2002) and "Unison" (1990) for her tour Celine Dion Live 2018.