Lohan returned to Disney in 2005, starring in the comedy ', the fifth film in the series with the anthropomorphic car Herbie. "Fully Loaded" earned $144 million worldwide, but it received mixed reviews. Stephen Holden of "The New York Times" called Lohan "a genuine star who ... seems completely at home on the screen," while James Berardinelli wrote that "as bright a starlet as she may be, Lohan ends up playing second fiddle to the car." In 2005, Lohan became the first person to have a My Scene celebrity doll released by Mattel. She also voiced herself in the animated direct-to-DVD film ', based on the series of dolls.