Tin Star awakes to find his love interest and the mayor's daughter, Maria, informing him Mo has been kidnapped by the Bad Oil Gang, which is also terrorizing the saloon. Tin Star rides back to town disguised in a mask and saves Mo, stops a town shoot-out, finds The Kid and shows the residents he's still alive, successfully finishes off Black Bart in two quick draw encounters, destroys the Black Oil Gang's headquarters, and gets his sheriff position back. What happens with Tin Star and Maria differs depending on the final score. Having below $750,000 results in Maria refusing in marrying Tin Star, $750,000–$999,999 the same with her instead marrying Mo, who inherited a million from his brother's will. If Tin Star has more than a million dollars, Maria is revealed to be Black Bart in disguise; Bart reasons that he wore it to learn Tin Star's secrets.