Later, she made television appearances as a guest star, in 2005, in two episodes of "Arrested Development" as "Sally Sitwell" and, in 2006, in an episode of NBC's "My Name Is Earl". In July 2006, Taylor's husband Ben Stiller announced plans to direct a CBS sitcom starring Taylor, but the series never aired. She has appeared with Mandy Moore in both "Dedication" and "License to Wed". In 2010, Taylor guest starred in "Hannah Montana Forever". In 2010, she also starred in the Hallmark Channel Christmas movie "Farewell Mr. Kringle". In 2013, Taylor reprised her role as Sally Sitwell in two episodes of the revived "Arrested Development". She also guest starred on "Elementary" in 2017, playing villainess Gail Lundquist.