In June 2009, Keaggy and Randy Stonehill released a new studio album titled "Mystery Highway". In support of the album, the two musicians, along with guitarist Mike Pachelli and Glass Harp's Daniel Pecchio and John Sferra, played several concerts as "The Keaggy-Stonehill Band". The year also saw Keaggy contribute a soaring re-recorded version of "Passport" on the album "CPR 3"; a compilation of musicians from the Christian Progressive Rock (CPR) scene. The original version of "Passport" appeared on Keaggy's 1985 album "Getting Closer". In October Keaggy released an instrumental album with pianist Jeff Johnson titled "Frio Suite". After meeting each other for the first time at the beginning of the year, the two musicians stayed in touch and created the album via email, with Johnson recording in Seattle while Keaggy recorded in Nashville. December saw the release of the guitarist's third Christmas album, "Welcome Inn". Featuring mostly original compositions such as the title track, "Welcome Inn" also includes the classic "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" and an acoustic instrumental version of "In the Bleak Midwinter". The project also includes a new recording of "On that Day", a song co-written with Glass Harp drummer John Sferra for Keaggy's "True Believer" album in 1995.