Ray had a video of another victim, Kelli Garrett (also called Kelli Van Cleave), which dated from 1996. Garrett ultimately was found in Colorado alive, after police identified a tattoo on her ankle. She later testified that she had gotten in a fight with her husband, and decided to spend the night playing pool with friends. On July 24, 1996, Ray's daughter, Jesse, who knew Garrett, took her to the Blu-Water Saloon in Truth Or Consequences, New Mexico, and drugged the beer she was drinking. Garrett had walked to the parking lot when she suffered a blow from behind, which knocked her unconscious.