Next, Barrington created the role of Sir Despard Murgatroyd in "Ruddigore" and then reprised his original roles in revivals of "Pinafore", "Pirates" and "The Mikado" in (1887–88). During rehearsals for "Ruddigore", and after discussions with other cast members on the subject, Barrington complained to Gilbert about the guests that Gilbert frequently invited to rehearsals, saying that he didn't wish to be taught the stage business "before a row of ...strangers." Gilbert forgave Barrington for the outburst and even discontinued the invitations. However, if anyone sat in the stalls during later rehearsals awaiting their cue, Gilbert would expostulate, "You mustn't sit here; Barrington won't like it."