In 2002, London was selected for the first time to host the Canada Cup, which granted them a wildcard berth. Their opposition in the wildcard match was against Ottawa Wizards, but were defeated 3–0. The 2003 season was a notable one with Harry Gauss once again adding coaching to his list of responsibilities, and appointed Paul Hillman the team captain. Gauss brought in Albanian imports Gentian Buzali, Albi Mile, Isa Bulku, Ervin Ryta, and former veteran Andrew Loague. While the regular season was a disappointment by finishing last in the Western Conference. London on the other hand had a remarkable Open Canada Cup tournament. Though London was eliminated in the quarterfinals of the tournament as the host club they received a wildcard match to the next round. In the wildcard match City faced the Durham Flames, and with goals from Murataj, Loague, and Eris Tafaj the team advanced to the semifinals in a 4–1 victory. In the semifinals London faced amateur club Kanata, and won the match 2–0 with Erik Elmauer and Phil McDonald contributing the goals. Their opponents in the finals were the Metro Lions during the match London took the lead with Eris Tafaj providing the goal, while Lions equalized in the 84' minute to send the game to a penalty shootout with London winning the tournament 4–2 in penalties. The victory was a historic achievement for London as it marked their first piece of silverware and a $10,000 prize.