As his evening unfolds, the listener hears "excerpts" from fictional movies in Tirebiter's past. "High School Madness" stars 'Dave Casman' as Peorgie Tirebiter and 'Joe Bertman' as his sidekick, Mudhead—although an earlier portion of the recording intentionally blurs the distinction between fantasy and reality by identifying Tirebiter (not 'Casman') as having been the star of the "Peorgie and Mudhead" films, rather than a character in those films. "High School Madness" is a parody of the Aldrich Family radio show, the "Archie" comic book and of 1950s youth culture in general. In the movie, Peorgie and Mudhead investigate the theft of their high school, Morse Science High, by their rivals, Communist Martyrs High School, on graduation day.