and the production received positive notices. "The Washington Post" reviewer wrote that "The musical adaptation has way more kick than the wispy 1987 film... It's on the technical level that Schaeffer's production still has kinks to work out, for until the actresses are airborne... the mechanics look and feel clunky." BroadwayWorld.com stated that "director Eric Schaeffer certainly pulls "The Witches of Eastwick" all together... does it ever succeed." CultureVulture.net commented that the show is "full of body-shaking thunder, raunchy behavior, and surprises. Gut reaction based on the performance seen June 17 says this show will make it to Broadway and be reasonably successful there." Talkin' Broadway wrote that the "Broadway actors... give memorable and funny performances in the four lead roles... Choreographer Karma Camp gets a chance to show off in this production."