He served as a jury member for the 62nd Berlin International Film Festival that was held in February 2012. Also in 2012, Gyllenhaal made his Off-Broadway debut in Nick Payne's play "If There Is I Haven't Found It Yet" at the Roundabout Theatre Company's Laura Pels Theatre. 2013 saw Gyllenhaal appear in two films directed by Denis Villeneuve, whom Gyllenhaal describes as "an older brother". The first, the thriller "Prisoners", starred Gyllenhaal as a detective named Loki in search of the abductor of two young girls. "Rolling Stone" critic Peter Travers praised Gyllenhaal's "exceptional" performance in the film. In their second collaboration, Gyllenhaal portrayed the dual role of a history teacher and his doppelgänger in the thriller "Enemy". The following year, he produced and starred in the crime thriller "Nightcrawler", earning Golden Globe Award and Screen Actors Guild Award nominations for his performance. Ben Sachs of the "Chicago Reader" called Gyllenhaal's performance "attention-grabbing" and said that he "creates a memorable screen presence".