In 1925 Gill won a second Leinster medal with Dublin, however, the team was later stripped of the title. In 1926 he still played hurling with Dublin but the side made an early exit from the championship. In 1927 Gill was appointed captain of Dublin and the team was back on form. Gill captured a third Leinster title before later lining out in the championship decider against Cork who were aiming to capture a second consecutive All-Ireland title. Gill was assisted on the team by eight colleagues from the Gardaí. Dublin won the game by 4-8 to 1-3 and Gill captured his third All-Ireland title. In doing so he became the first native of Galway to win three senior All-Ireland hurling medals as well as becoming the second Galway native to lift the Liam MacCarthy Cup. In 1928 Gill played hurling in the Tailteann Games, the Irish answer to the Olympic Games, before later collecting another Leinster title. Two years later in 1930 Gill captured his fourth Leinster medal before lining out in the championship decider. Tipperary, however, were too powerful for ‘the Dubs’ who lost the game by 2-7 to 1-3. Gill retired from inter-county hurling shortly after.