In early 1900, the Hickses played in their only Broadway show together, "My Daughter-in-law", at the Frohman brothers' old Lyceum Theatre. They then joined forces with the producer Charles Frohman and, in his company over a period of seven years, they played the leads in a series of musicals written by Hicks, including: "Bluebell in Fairyland" (1901), which was continually revived as a Christmas entertainment for the next four decades; "The Cherry Girl" (1902); "The Beauty of Bath" (1906), which opened the Hicks Theatre (later renamed the Globe) and included additional lyrics by a newcomer, P.G. Wodehouse, and music by Jerome Kern, which became one of Terriss's best-loved roles; and "The Gay Gordons" (1907).