Prior to that year's All-Ireland semi-final Gill had become a member of the newly established Garda Síochána. He was based in Dublin and, as such, played hurling with the Dublin senior inter-county team as well. He won a Leinster title with the side in the 1924 championship before later finding himself in another All-Ireland final following a win over Antrim. The 1924 All-Ireland final was played on 14 December of that year and Gill's opponents were his own native Galway. ‘The Dubs’ won the game on a score line of 5-3 to 2-6. Three months after winning his first All-Ireland medal Gill won his second and went into the history books as the only player ever to win two senior All-Ireland hurling medals in the same year.