"Supernature" received favourable reviews from music critics. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an average score of 79, based on 27 reviews. Dorian Lynskey of "The Guardian" said that the album was "a brash, beautiful celebration of love and dancing". In a review for "PopMatters", Adrien Begrand said that ""Supernature" lacks the imagination of "Felt Mountain" and the saucy brilliance of "Black Cherry", it doesn't pander to the pop crowd." Lauren Gitlin of "Rolling Stone" said the album was "[toxic and delicious" and that ""Supernature" will make you do bad things—and like it." However, "Pitchfork" reviewer Nitsuh Abebe was less impressed, and wrote that the album's songs "keep feeling like exercises: too thick and melodic to work like dance music, but with melodies that refuse to stick as satisfyingly as pop." Michael Hubbard of "musicOMH" wrote a review for every song on "Supernature", and although he felt that it was a "curious, rather than classic, record", he criticised it for "fading out early on, with poor, low quality songs at the end which leave the listener feeling cheated". AllMusic critic Heather Phares called "Supernature" "Goldfrapp's most accessible album" and named "Ooh La La" as its best song.