In 2004, Amy was chosen for the lead role of Valentine D'Artagnan in the Hallmark Channel film "La Femme Musketeer", starring alongside Michael York, Gérard Depardieu and Nastassja Kinski. For the role she had to train in martial arts, fencing and horse riding, which she is said to have loved. The same year, she portrayed Beatrice Hastings in "Modigliani", which starred Andy García. In 2005, Amy appeared in films "House of 9", starring Dennis Hopper, and "Dead Fish", and worked on Bill Kenwright's stage production of "Wait Until Dark".