Beginning on 11 January 2009 Nolan took part in the fourth series of "Dancing on Ice" on ITV. Of her appearance on the show Nolan said, "I've never really skated. When I was 14 I used to go to Disco Beat in Blackpool with my friend. We'd skate round once, hanging on to each other, and spend the rest of the night posing, like 14-year-old girls do. I could only go forwards, I couldn't stop!" She was eliminated in week 10, finishing in fourth place. She went on to co-host the spin-off show "Dancing on Ice Friday" with Ben Shephard in 2010. and on 27 February 2011, she hosted "Dancing on Ice", in place of Holly Willoughby who fell ill.