In 2017, the girls' soccer team went 22–1, winning the Central Jersey Group III state sectional championship, the program's first, over Toms River High School East by a score of 2–1. They then went on to win the Group III state title over Middletown High School South in the playoff finals by a score of 2–1. These state titles are the first and only in the girls' soccer program at the high school. The team was also named Area Team of the Year by NJ.com.