He's appeared at the Roundabout Theatre in three productions: "The Play's the Thing" (1995), "Hurrah at Last" (1999) and "The Dazzle" (2002). For "The Dazzle", he and Reg Rogers were both nominated for Drama League Award for Distinguished Performance and Lucille Lortel Award for Best Actor (Rogers won); the two shared the Obie Award for best actor for their performances as the co-dependent Collier Brothers. They originated the show in 2000 at the New York Stage and Film at Vassar College's Powerhouse Theater.