In a review for Canadian-based website Jam!, Andrew Carver praised the different sounds on "Supernature", which range from "a blend of future noise" to "crushed velvet corruption"; he described the album as "one sharp recording". Jessica Suarez of "Spin" magazine compared "Ooh La La" to "Black Cherry"'s "Strict Machine", saying that "Ooh La La" sounds "so simplistic that minimalist repetition occasionally teeters over into redundancy". She praised "Ride a White Horse" and "Fly Me Away" for featuring Alison Goldfrapp's "velvet-soft vocals, which stay that way even when heavily processed". A less favourable reception came from "Stylus Magazine" reviewer Edward Oculicz, who stated ""Supernature" is not a great album" and called several of its tracks too "dull".