In 1991, he starred opposite Cherry Jones in "Our Country's Good", which resulted in a second Tony nomination for best actor. The same year he co-starred in "Absent Friends" as grief-stricken Colin. In 1992, he appeared in Bob Merrill's last Broadway musical (and cast recording) of "Hannah...1939" and Larry Kramer's autobiographical "The Destiny of Me". He also appeared on Broadway in the original productions of "Any Given Day" (1993) and "The Play's the Thing" (1995), as well as the 2005 revival of "The Odd Couple" as Roy (and understudy for Matthew Broderick's Felix Unger).