In 2003–04, former Brackley Town and Abingdon Town manager Bob Rayner returned to the club from Thame United after chairman Richard Woodward persuaded him to return to the club he had last managed during the mid 1990s. Under his guidance the club steadily rebuilt, using players from the successful Rangers junior ranks. They finished runners-up in Division Two in the 2011–12 season. They were also runners-up in the Anagram Trophy that season, losing to Baldock Town 1–0 in the Final at Letchworth. After getting 'Windsors' ground grading up to the required standard the club were finally promoted to Division One at the end of the 2012-13 season. The club also reached the final of the Spartan South Midlands Football League Division Two Cup, losing to Aston Clinton 2–0 at Chesham United. They finished 14th in their first season in Div 1 and reached the final of the Division One Cup, losing 2-0 to 2nd placed Kings Langley in the final at London Colney.