The band released their next album "Strength to Survive" on January 31, 2012, their first album on ATO Records. It sold over 50,000 copies, and topped the "Billboard" Reggae Album Chart in both 2012 and 2013. It was also No. 9 for the year end Reggae Albums chart on "Billboard", and reached no. 36 on the "Billboard" 200, as well as no. 2 on the Independent Albums chart. It received 3.5/5 stars from Allmusic, with the website praising the band's growth as songwriters and Hemphill's vocal developments. While Allmusic criticized the non-reggae acoustic tracks at the end of the album, it stated that overall "you've got one of the best American reggae albums of the year."