The boys' basketball team was by far the school's most successful athletic program, including state championships in Parochial B in 1960 and Parochial C in 1977. Before relocating to Mt. Ephraim Avenue, the basketball team played and practiced in the upstairs Parish Hall at 10th and Liberty. Football practices were held at a field located near Everett Street and Broadway. The football and baseball teams practiced on city fields at the end of Dayton Street (Dayton Diamond). Home baseball games were played there.