Madonna did not perform the song again until her Sticky & Sweet Tour (2008–2009). She appeared on stage wearing a black Givenchy dress, with pink colored ribbons around her neck and black stockings on her legs and performed an acoustic, guitar-driven version of the song sitting on a stool. She was backed by 4 musicians who were dressed in gypsy clothes. As she performed the song, scenes from "Evita" played on the backdrop screens. The performance received positive feedback from critics with Ricardo Baca, from "The Denver Post", writing that "her courageous, late-set take on 'You Must Love Me' — from the filmed version of the Broadway musical "Evita" — was spot-on and gorgeous with its string accompaniment". On the Buenos Aires stop of the tour, after performing "You Must Love Me", Madonna also sang "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" from the film. The performances of both songs in the city were recorded in the live CD-DVD titled, "Sticky & Sweet Tour" (2010).