Lawrence enjoyed more success the following season as the Reds found their league form once more, winning the 1965–66 title by 6 clear points over Leeds. Such was Lawrence's form, consistency and durability he missed only a handful of games during eight years as the regular Liverpool goalkeeper. He earned the affectionate nickname "The Flying Pig" because of his ability to dive around the penalty area despite weighing more than 14 stone (89 kg). He is credited with being one of the first sweeper-keepers.