In early 1900, the Hickses played in their only Broadway show together, "My Daughter-in-law", at the Frohman brothers' old Lyceum Theatre. They then joined forces with producer Charles Frohman and, in his company, over a period of seven years, they played the leads in a series of musicals written by Hicks, including "Bluebell in Fairyland" (1901 with music by Walter Slaughter and lyrics by Charles Taylor – this Christmas show for children was continually revived for the next four decades) and "The Cherry Girl" (1902). Hicks and Terriss also starred in "Quality Street" in 1902. At that time, they moved to a new home, The Old Forge, at Merstham, Surrey. Their cul-de-sac was renamed "Quality Street".