In "Quebec (Attorney General) v. A" (2013) a majority of the Court found that perpetuating prejudice or stereotyping did not form an additional requirement in the second part of the test. The majority itself split on the correct way to apply the second part of the test, leaving the present state of the law on Section 15 unclear until 2015. The current framework for analyzing an alleged violation of s 15(1) of the "Charter" is that set out in "Kahkewistahaw First Nation v. Taypotat" (2015) at paras 19-20.