Among the hostile critics of the New Journalism were Dwight Macdonald, whose most vocal criticism comprised a chapter in what became known as "the "New Yorker" affair" of 1965. Wolfe had written a two-part semi-fictional parody in "New York" of "The New Yorker" and its editor, William Shawn. Reaction, notably from "New Yorker" writers, was loud and prolonged, but the most significant reaction came from Macdonald, who counterattacked in two articles in the "New York Review of Books". In the first, Macdonald termed Wolfe's approach "parajournalism" and applied it to all similar styles. "Parajournalism," Macdonald wrote,