New Zealand television website, Throng, said that Izzy had "grown to become a fan favourite" in her time with the show. Izzy has been labelled a "super-bitch" by newspaper "Daily Mirror", newspaper "Metro", entertainment website Digital Spy and Australian LGBT website Samesame. Bree Hoskin writing for LGBT website Gaydar, included Izzy on their list of "Top Ten Soap Bitches". She also said the serial was shaken up with her arrival and branded her "Erinsborough’s most memorable bitch and home wrecker". Also opining she met her match in Paul and it subsequently caused "a good vs. evil cul-de-sac showdown the likes of which Ramsay street had never seen before".