In 2005, Butler starred in the film "Bloodlines". For distribution purposes, it was later retitled "Striking Range". In 2006, she starred in the film "Striking Range". In 2007, she appeared in 13 episodes of the television soap opera "As the World Turns", as Ava Jenkins. She was confirmed to appear in "Tales of an Ancient Empire", the follow-up to "The Sword and the Sorcerer". On January 24, 2012, "Tales of an Ancient Empire" was released on DVD. Butler, however, did not appear in the film. She appeared in a small role in another comic-book adaptation, the film version of "Kick-Ass".