Marsh was awarded the title of WAMPAS Baby Stars in August 1931 even before her second movie with Warner Brothers was released. With her ability to project warmth, sincerity and inner strength on the screen along with critical praise and the audience's approval of Svengali, she continued to star in a string of successful films for Warner Bros., including "Five Star Final" (1931) with Edward G. Robinson, "The Mad Genius" (1931) with Barrymore, "The Road to Singapore" (1931) with William Powell, "Under 18" (1932) with Warren William, "Alias the Doctor" (1932) with Richard Barthelmess, and "Beauty and the Boss" (1932) with Warren William.