council regul ec septemb impos definit anti dump duti import weld tube pipe iron alloi steel origin czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun hereinaft refer basic regul articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur commiss regul ec hereinaft refer provision regul impos provision anti dump duti import weld tube pipe iron alloi steel fall cn code taric code origin czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision anti dump measur interest parti made written submiss make view provision find parti request grant opportun heard commiss servic continu seek verifi inform deem definit find parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti import weld tube pipe iron alloi steel origin czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider oral written comment submit interest parti consid find modifi product concern product absenc comment receiv disclosur provision find product concern product provision find recit provision regul confirm dump poland ukrain absenc argument dump provision find recit poland ukrain provision regul confirm czech republ czech export produc zelezárni veselí react commiss provision find claim allegedli subject higher technic test standard tube type sold domest market czech republ tube type export commun market note claim introduc advanc stage investig check spot verif carri export premis addit czech export produc bring forward evid support claim repli commiss questionnair compani state contrari present claim czech foreign standard product concern compar price comparison requir adjust respect inform obtain investig regard sale product concern czech market suggest justifi differ technic standard exist claim reject provision level dump produc confirm czech export produc jäkl karvina substanti claim differ physic characterist type tube chosen normal type sold export commun made claim consid justifi final dump margin recalcul turkei regard turkei minor correct daili exchang rate interest rate request compani accept justifi receiv definit disclosur calcul compani claim dump margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal valu weight averag export transact commun ground export differ significantli purchas region time period dump quot target dump quot time compani situat creat devalu turkish lira februari middl investig period ip alleg made compani verifi found differ price fact signific basi calcul chang method led reduct dump margin compani concern final dump margin cooper compani includ sampl gt tabl gt exercis led revis weight averag dump margin cooper compani includ sampl boruta boru sanayii ve ticaret adapazari cinar boru profil san tic sti eregli guven boru ve profil sanayi ve ticaret sti istanbul özdemir boru profil san ve ticaret eregli sevil boru profil sanayii ve ticaret istanbul toscelik profil ve sac endüstrisi iskenderun özborsan boru san ve ticaret istanbul level cooper turkei high residu definit dump margin set level highest margin level cooper compani thailand spot investig carri public provision regul premis saha thai steel pipe sole thai cooper export produc thai produc initi repli questionnair posit accept spot verif due time normal normal concern gener methodolog set recit provision regul market economi countri concern appli sole cooper thai produc describ find specif compani normal establish basi domest sale type product concern directli compar type tube export commun case sale compar type tube domest market normal construct accord articl basic regul purpos cooper export produc cost product compani sg amp expens profit export price procedur methodolog assess export price product origin thailand explain recit provision regul export sale made directli independ custom commun establish pursuant articl basic regul comparison accord methodolog recit provision regul adjust made transport ancillari cost bank charg insur credit cost differ physic characterist duti drawback dump margin accord methodolog recit provision regul comparison normal export price weight weight averag basi appli method show exist dump respect sole cooper export produc definit dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border compani gt tabl gt regard determin residu duti level cooper thailand low methodolog recit provision regul confirm residu dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border commun industri absenc argument commun product definit commun industri provision find recit provision regul confirm injuri commun consumpt absenc comment receiv disclosur provision find commun consumpt provision find recit provision regul confirm cumul assess effect import concern argu line previou practic import czech republ cumul import origin countri concern evolut import price czech republ period consid diverg evolut observ countri concern argu czech import undercut commun industri price competit import investig countri unlik destin germani note case refer diverg trend import price decis element consid conclus cumul decumul base number factor import condit list articl basic regul margin dump de minimi volum import neglig condit competit import product condit competit import product commun product firstli note dump margin czech import de minimi import origin czech republ decreas constantli volum import ip neglig note eurostat averag price import origin czech republ increas constantli found substanti undercut commun industri price ip import origin investig countri respect note product concern model price exist calcul carri compar model product concern level trade order fulli reflect price behaviour countri concern thirdli contrari submiss czech export cumul light condit competit respect note import czech republ interchang import sale commun industri market commun compar sale channel found commun industri export situat investig countri part sell germani eurostat statist show trade flow member state import indic market commun wide indic czech sale product concern competit sale origin investig countri sale commun industri found indic regionalis market czech export argu cumul basi alleg market segment argu alleg segment commun market evidenc infring european competit law compani compos commun industri compani past made illeg agreement market share albeit product product concern mere fact compani infring competit law prior ip product product concern absenc indic behaviour ip product concern consid proof market segment present case present investig evid found show agreement forc product concern compani compos commun industri argument reject export reiter request import origin czech republ decumul caus injuri threat injuri commun industri due volum ceil quota impos council regul eec czech export argu favour decumul point increas commun export czech republ period consid note quota impos regul eec forc end present investig period consid injuri analysi ip level commun export czech republ provid support claim czech export decumul submiss reject argu czech republ subject surveil export doubl check system establish council regul ec exclud present anti dump proceed surveil system place pure order monitor czech import mere fact exist give indic favour cumul support claim decumul argument reject export reiter claim oper condit competit sale commun made relat compani unlik sale export produc oper access raw materi longer deliveri time investig show sale made export commun product concern made sale channel compar export commun industri trader event condit competit mean articl basic regul establish countri wide basi examin individu export submiss reject argu import ukrain cumul import origin countri concern low volum import involv respect stress ukrain market share lower held investig countri consid neglig defin articl basic regul articl agreement implement articl vi gener agreement tariff trade condit cumul set articl basic regul met view fact show condit cumul countri concern met provision find cumul assess effect import concern recit provision regul confirm import origin countri concern volum market share price evolut absenc argument provision find volum market share price evolut import origin countri concern recit provision regul confirm note public provision regul addit turkish compani found dump import export produc exclud increas volum dump import remain signific shown tabl increas market share remain dump import increas percentag point period consid dump import repres commun market ip gt tabl gt ii price undercut import origin turkei confirm level undercut found averag establish import export produc found dump exclud significantli alter level undercut respect import origin czech republ argu comparison czech export price shown eurostat statist individu select case commun industri show undercut request undercut calcul revis normal practic order calcul price undercut verifi averag commun industri averag export price compar ip product type product type basi level trade comparison show undercut argument reject argu eurostat statist lower price germani member state undercut calcul perform compar price export produc price charg commun industri member state respect note commun consid singl market purpos anti dump investig normal practic order fulli reflect undercut level undercut calcul made compar price export produc averag price commun industri addit note sale product concern made trader sell custom locat part commun market eurostat statist confirm show import level intra commun trade thai cooper export claim order compar product concern level trade commun industri adjust made cif import good order reflect import sg amp profit note price import product concern increas eur tonn order reflect cost import incur import commun industri export sell equal type custom import trader sell product user export price increas request effect repres price level trade commun industri addit back evid provid support request request reject absenc element methodolog undercut calcul take account correct cleric error product concern origin countri concern sold commun ip price averag undercut commun industri price express percentag czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain situat commun industri absenc inform affect find situat commun industri provision find recit provision regul confirm conclus injuri absenc inform situat commun industri provision find injuri suffer commun industri recit provision regul confirm except averag level undercut recit revis causat interest parti present argument evid causat effect injuri suffer commun industri impact trade protect measur impos countri import origin countri investig trade protect measur impos countri found level total export commun industri remain stabl level decreas product capac utilis commun industri ip remain substanti due minor part plai export compar total sale whilst export countri impos trade protect measur declin ip total commun sale ip impact trade protect measur impos countri neglig addit stabl export chang decreas trend profit import origin romania hungari dump import origin turkei found term volum cumul decreas ip neg trend similar observ sale commun industri unrel custom decreas opposit increas dump import origin investig countri conclus decreas trend volum import low market share involv confirm import alter find causat light find provision regul recit confirm commun interest imposit provision measur comment receiv commun interest provid commun industri support commiss provision conclus imposit anti dump measur consider increas user cost affect situat note main user product concern construct industri user cost lai instal maintain conduit link cost manpow import cost tube addit cost instal pipe small part total hous construct cost note product concern sold market trader price end user charg depend trader price polici view absenc inform analysi commun interest aspect case absenc cooper reaction user provision find recit provision regul confirm argu present anti dump proceed termin order avoid higher level protect deem product concern includ scope safeguard investig initi march product concern cover scope safeguard investig note subject provision safeguard measur commiss propos adopt definit safeguard measur respect product combin type measur give rise higher level protect anti dump duti amend interest parti opportun comment issu definit anti dump measur injuri elimin level export argu methodolog provision stage establish injuri price lead artifici inflat price request methodolog review methodolog provision stage establish injuri price model level trade involv establish break point weight averag actual sale price charg commun industri compani adjust upward downward actual loss profit break point profit margin ad definit stage methodolog review injuri price model level trade calcul establish break point weight averag actual sale price charg commun industri compani adjust downward commun industri averag actual profit break point profit margin ad note profit commun industri weight averag basi definit stage situat commun industri term price profit quantiti involv fulli reflect argu review methodolog led model discrep cost product injuri price respect note injuri price base actual price commun industri reflect market situat model methodolog fair comparison price correct cleric error made context price undercut calcul appli injuri margin calcul cooper thai compani definit stage low level cooper thailand order give bonu cooper articl basic regul residu injuri margin thailand establish basi eurostat inform revis injuri elimin margin found gt tabl gt definit anti dump measur argu measur exce differ target profit margin profit obtain commun industri ip target profit margin turnov commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump establish recit provision regul note duti impos cooper compani investig countri lesser duti rule note methodolog order determin injuri price commun industri reflect found target profit differ actual level price charg export injuri price commun industri determin level injuri found request reject light forego consid accord articl basic regul definit anti dump duti impos respect import origin czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain level dump margin found level injuri margin found lower basi propos definit duti rate express percentag cif commun border price duti gt tabl gt individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countri wide duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti commiss consult advisori committe amend regul updat list compani benefit individu duti rate undertak provision measur impos number export produc jäkl karvina zelezárni veselí czech republ saha thai thailand borusan birlesik boru fabrikalari mannesmann boru endustrisi turkei offer price undertak accord articl basic regul respect commiss note product concern commod product consider volatil price short term suitabl fix price undertak volatil due variat price raw materi hot roll coil zinc constitut major variabl compon cost product link currenc exchang rate stabl commun unit kingdom sweden denmark fast chang regard usd currenc transact made thailand turkei monthli revis price mip minimum import price index price hot roll coil zinc index formula establish product group energi manpow tonn vari size reason review formula system implement establish formula categori product size rang produc offer price undertak export varieti steel product weld tube structur pipe carbon steel tube squar tube rectangular tube partial subject anti dump investig risk compens price product export custom high gener basi commun industri claim undertak minimum price measur regard product concern reason light offer price undertak reject definit collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found light level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision anti dump duti impos provision regul definit collect rate duti definit impos adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import weld tube pipe iron alloi steel circular cross section extern diamet exceed mm exclud tube pipe kind oil ga pipelin kind drill oil ga attach fit civil aircraft precis tube fall cn code taric code origin czech republ poland thailand turkei ukrain rate definit anti dump duti applic net commun frontier price duti product paragraph produc compani gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision anti dump duti impos pursuant provision regul definit collect rate duti set articl rate provision duti lower amount secur excess definit rate anti dump duti releas articl turkish parti suffici evid commiss export good articl ip relat export produc subject measur impos regul export good concern ip enter irrevoc contractu oblig export signific quantiti commun council act simpl major propos submit commiss consult advisori committe amend articl order attribut parti duti applic cooper produc export sampl articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel septemb council presid fischer boel oj regul amend regul ec oj oj council regul ec urea ammonium nitrat solut origin bulgaria poland oj council regul ec ammonium nitrat origin russia oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj regul amend council regul ec oj oj european commiss director gener trade director brussel