council regul ec januari repeal council regul eec impos definit anti dump duti import ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter origin japan council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss procedur measur forc regul eec hereinaft refer quot definit duti regul quot council impos definit anti dump duti import ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter origin japan peopl republ china republ korea thailand japan duti rate set definit duti regul amend respect china regul ec thailand concern replac regul ec march initi review commiss publish notic impend expiri measur forc japan republ korea public commiss receiv request review pursuant articl regul ec hereinaft refer quot basic regul quot regard import ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter origin japan lodg european feder lighter manufactur behalf bic flamaga subsequ request receiv support swedish match bic flamaga swedish match repres total commun product product concern request contain suffici prima faci evid expiri measur result recurr dump import caus injuri evid presenc utilis capac japan evid import japan depress effect price commun produc support alleg likelihood alleg situat exacerb continu vulner commun industri commiss announc review definit duti regul respect japan review open accord articl basic regul interim review korea measur expir review investig commiss offici advis produc export countri concern tokai corpor relat import commun tokai seiki gmbh repres export countri complain parti directli concern opportun make view write request hear complain request grant hear commiss questionnair parti concern receiv detail inform complain commun produc subsidiari japanes export relat import locat commun commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos investig carri verif premis compani commun produc subsidiari bic bic group clichi franc bic bj redon franc bic deutschland gmbh amp ettlingen germani biro bic london uk laforest bic tarragona spain swedish match lighter assen netherland swedish match lighter includ cricket sa rillieux la pape franc arnold andré gmbh amp kg bünde germani flamaga barcelona llina del vall spain produc countri origin tokai corpor japan tokyo japan purpos dump injuri commun interest determin geograph scope investig commun investig dump cover period januari septemb hereinaft refer quot investig period quot examin injuri cover period end investig period investig exceed normal time period provid articl basic regul due fact commiss consid data gather examin initi suffici basi anti dump duti accur assess likelihood recurr injuri dump verif visit export carri advanc stage investig investig extend consider commiss initi propos maintain anti dump duti give rise lengthi deliber council product concern product product concern product consider ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter hereinaft refer quot dispos flint lighter quot fall cn code request inclus lighter recal respect dispos lighter market call electron piezo lighter subject anti dump measur month open review investig swedish match made request extend scope review investig electron piezo lighter argu ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter ga fuell refil electron lighter hereinaft quot electron lighter quot form singl categori product request recal proceed open april concern ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter assess regul eec confirm provision find laid recit council regul eec oj basic technic characterist electron lighter dispos flint lighter subject anti dump duti request evid show conclus longer show basic technic characterist ignit system type lighter invalid find definit duti regul evid present insuffici justifi inclus electron lighter investig request made belatedli parti support request review reserv request extens scope review investig grant size model final note product consider manufactur size model dispos flint lighter basic technic characterist basic applic perform function previou investig rang model dispos flint lighter consid form singl categori product product dispos flint lighter produc sold domest japan investig show product respect ident close resembl export commun countri question investig establish dispos flint lighter import countri concern hand produc commun industri sold commun market hand possess similar basic technic characterist intend dispos flint lighter produc sold commun industri regard product import countri concern conclud dispos flint lighter produc sold commun produc sold japan regard product mean articl basic regul export commun japan dump normal origin investig tokai corpor sole cooper export japanes produc investig period sold model product concern domest market model export commun found export domest sale product concern investig period repres total volum sale exceed threshold export sale provid articl basic regul domest sale product model export commun repres met criterion accord articl basic regul commiss determin domest sale model made ordinari trade proport profit sale total sale investig show domest sale made investig period profit normal base averag weight sale price domest transact model question export price total export sale made export concern investig period made relat compani commun export price construct accord articl basic regul basi resal price independ buyer adjust account cost incur import resal includ custom anti dump duti profit margin establish basi profit margin consid reason busi sector unrel import cost alloc import gener administr sell expens construct export price made basi turnov comparison dump margin accord articl basic regul weight averag normal model compar weight averag export price model factori level level trade purpos fair comparison adjust grant differ affect price compar satisfactori evid suppli adjust made respect transport insur credit packag comparison normal export price show exist dump dump margin express percentag cif commun frontier import found commun industri present investig tokai seiki gmbh subsidiari tokai corpor produc product concern commun cooper import commun dispos flint lighter origin japan includ definit commun industri accord articl basic regul sole import product consider subsidiari tokai corpor japan disregard tokai seiki gmbh product commun produc cooper present investig includ subsidiari repres total commun product dispos flint lighter cooper commun produc constitut commun industri mean articl basic regul injuri preliminari remark recit definit duti regul conclud quot cumul dump import japan peopl republ china republ korea thailand caus materi injuri commun industri quot measur republ korea laps measur peopl republ china thailand amend interim review state recit regul actual impact import origin japan impact angl recurr examin isol consumpt commun order calcul total appar consumpt dispos flint lighter commun commun produc sale commun ad total import origin countri declar cn code adjust made import origin china year recit regul ec basi annual appar consumpt commun increas million unit million unit factor relat import origin japan volum market share investig period import japan plummet low level absolut term index import figur sale import investig period repres market share import japan decreas investig period anti dump measur review effect limit impact dump import dispos flint lighter origin japan context note consider portion import dump import mexico philippin thailand mention regard refer regul ec price undercut commiss calcul extent price charg export commun market undercut price charg commun produc sale made export made relat import comparison made level sale independ custom basi relat import commun produc weight averag sell price free rebat tax price charg relat import adjust anti dump duti paid comparison made level price wholesal exclud sale retail advertis sector price comparison made nake lighter includ lighter export present quot wrap quot export export print sleev lighter investig period origin investig accord articl basic regul price undercut calcul made lighter similar ga content recit regul eec basi found averag price import product undercut weight averag price commun produc investig period compar averag undercut found origin investig conclud export undercut level increas upward effect anti dump duti price charg relat import situat commun industri product product commun industri increas capac utilis capac capac utilis rate increas drop investig period drop coincid increas capac increas capac report increas capac recent capac increas materi rate sale volum sale unit commun market commun industri increas investig period market share grow market market share commun industri drop steadili increas investig period market share lower market share recit regul ec show commun industri begin recov effect dump import price evolut total sale establish weight averag sale price commun industri drop investig period favour develop sale volum fulli reflect term turnov sale commun market increas lighter market price sensit mean face low price dump import commun industri forc lower price order maintain market share product level capac utilis set lose market share maintain price profit year loss commun industri return sale slightli posit deterior recit regul ec present investig basi comparison deterior commun industri financi result steadili improv compar profit rate doubl tripl investig period data suppli commun industri purpos includ complain give admiss repli profit show financi perform continu target set reason profit industri definit duti regul recit regul fact profit small year improv notic profit half injuri level set stock commun industri build signific stock usual practic sector stop product stock big secur risk stock lighter ga long period time rationalis effort made stock end investig period thirti percent smaller end employ investig period employ commun industri stabl increas sign recoveri note employ figur lowest level fallen recit regul ec note consider portion expans pertain sale administr segment product export commun industri perform export market sale unit steadili increas investig period period export sale repres approxim commun industri product increas conclus situat commun industri improv recent year due increas sale commun market countri develop coincid imposit anti dump duti increas sale commun market due growth consumpt lesser extent benefici effect anti dump measur commun downward trend market share commun industri revers market share investig period smaller increas appar consumpt fact anti dump measur impos upward effect price commun market price commun industri found decreas sale commun industri commun market prove profit investig period price charg export commun market undercut commun industri price applic anti dump duti level profit lower injuri level fix definit duti regul light consid commun industri continu suffer injuri notabl term profit growth market share market share import dispos flint lighter origin japan small establish causal link dump japanes import injuri injuri caus import consid neglig case materi likelihood recurr injuri dump introduct commun industri request definit duti regul review argu likelihood recurr injuri dump order make determin point number factor consid export group behaviour avail unus capac export plant japan exist price undertak respect export compani belong export group price export charg duti allow expir addit examin posit commun industri impact resum export japan commun industri exist dump practic evolut share import commun market examin export group behaviour recent year small quantiti dispos flint lighter import japan sold commun market compar import countri primarili china mexico philippin thailand price found dump level low level import origin japan consid light tokai group behaviour sole export investig inter alia import origin mexico definit anti dump measur impos march fulli own control subsidiari tokai group develop imposit anti dump measur dispos flint lighter origin japan recit regul ec import figur show import mexico simpli replac produc export tokai corpor japanes plant imposit measur import quantiti lighter origin mexico similar quantiti tokai corpor deliv commun market japan prior imposit measur recal tokai corpor start downward price trend sell japanes lighter dump price late trend subsequ reinforc dump practic asian produc resumpt dump subsidiari set mexico light low level japanes import investig period lead conclus develop occur imposit measur result normal econom behaviour export produc behaviour independ measur subject review fact result appar strategi tokai group consid account march definit anti dump duti impos import dispos flint lighter origin mexico philippin thailand regul ec mexican export subject anti dump measur subsidiari japanes export examin happen exist measur allow laps japanes product capac investig period export product capac decreas addit decreas product capac utilis rate express percent remain capac decreas investig period investig period unus capac export japanes plant account bigger quantiti million dispos flint lighter tokai corpor export japan investig period origin investig establish investig period unus capac stabl absolut term concomit decreas product capac capac utilis rate price undertak applic group compani imposit measur review export shift product dispos flint lighter destin export commun market mexico subsequ offer price undertak respect import origin countri anti dump measur import warrant march move product line mexico japan export suffici freeli dispos capac japanes plant suppli commun market quantiti higher export export charg lower price commun market permit import product origin mexico continu dump price export charg state investig period import dispos flint lighter origin japan continu dump import product sold price significantli dump origin investig appear dump continu applic anti dump duti undercut averag unit price charg commun produc signific investig period anti dump duti deduct price charg independ custom averag price commun industri undercut impact commun industri price depress effect continu dump investig period minim due applic anti dump duti small quantiti import export suffici unus capac resum export dispos flint lighter origin japan signific level similar quantiti import million quantiti sold commun market price charg german subsidiari export investig period result substanti downward pressur price commun market loss turnov market share quantiti import japan present repres market share approxim market share signific impact situat commun industri establish precis effect remov measur factor market share profit employ commun industri depend uncertain factor growth consumpt commun gener price depress caus resumpt import signific quantiti global analysi specif aspect main region market commun made assess impact import signific quantiti dispos flint lighter origin japan price significantli undercut commun price commun industri establish competit german market fierc major distributor supermarket chain select supplier product offer outlet exercis downward pressur price supplier situat minim price undercut preclud commun industri access distribut network repres larg number consum effect futur price undercut signific term loss market share loss profit extend period time access distribut network grant long contract period establish produc level price unit kingdom low commun produc establish market circumst futur price undercut impair penetr commun produc dispos flint lighter difficult market reduc profit sale competit french market found import due presenc manufactur plant major commun produc price depress appear import germani uk futur increas price undercut bring greater price depress loss market share establish commun produc product plant spain establish market found substanti part spanish market suppli commun produc spain largest import member state price low compar franc germani produc establish spain rationalis cost reduct product plant loss substanti market share price war spanish market result closur plant loss match similar develop nearbi import french market volum price import state japanes export decid suppli commun market product manufactur mexico anti dump measur impos march remedi effect measur impos smaller normal circumst addit import dispos flint lighter increas investig period increas higher increas consumpt period result market share import increas drop shown success anti dump measur impos continu influx low price dump import countri commun market result price commun market continu drop reach low level grow market price commun industri decreas investig period commun interest commun industri commun industri decad suffer low price dump import dispos flint lighter object definit duti review establish fair competit commun market commun produc export counterpart countri fulli met shown subsequ develop tokai set product plant mexico start export european commun dump price countri china philippin thailand resort dump result commun industri recov effort reduc cost benefit economi scale commun industri consist multin group sell product dispos flint lighter small produc combin product dispos flint lighter trade compani commun industri make consider effort improv product recent year attempt obtain lowest cost product enhanc competit price sensit market rationalis effort made produc group rationalis product process adapt structur produc effort primarili base realis economi scale invest made improv product export sale increas faster sale commun export sale repres half commun produc sale invest product capac primarili made purpos suppli market commun market closur product plant occur appear due strateg approach produc concern support exist anti dump measur dispos flint lighter develop export sale regard note produc profit activ sector provid financi resourc maintain product plant dispos flint lighter time rule effect discontinu anti dump measur provok closur product plant view effect commun measur design establish fair open market condit protect commun industri unfair trade practic stake major consider risk commun produc put end product plant anti dump measur allow laps subsequ injuri dump larg quantiti dispos flint lighter origin japan occur import export report direct sale unrel parti european commun reaction receiv import public notic initi unrel import tokai lighter origin japan identifi tokai subsidiari germani sole import dispos flint lighter origin japan note emploi limit number peopl compar commun industri impact import maintain measur review minim consum origin investig import alleg interest consum advers affect anti dump measur dispos flint lighter present investig represent consum associ receiv reason assum chang circumst occur invalid argument previou investig reject alleg repeal anti dump measur basi fact commiss conclud likelihood recurr injuri dump april made propos impos definit anti dump duti import ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter origin japan major council achiev adopt regul basi commiss propos articl basic regul definit anti dump measur expir year imposit determin review expiri lead continu recurr dump injuri expiri review carri anti dump measur remain forc pend outcom review present case result council decid adopt regul basi commiss propos consequ review proceed remain open exist measur remain forc unlimit period time articl basic regul review carri expediti conclud month date initi review circumst commiss consid anti dump duti ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter origin japan repeal order avoid undu durat review remain forc anti dump measur indefinit period time final provis interest parti cooper investig complain export japanes govern receiv disclosur write essenti fact consider basi commiss intend recommend definit measur repeal complain produc object intend action argu circumst chang opinion anti dump duti maintain take account anti dump duti import origin republ korea impos regul definit anti dump duti dispos flint lighter origin japan impos laps provis made remov refer anti dump duti import republ korea regul adopt regul articl regul eec repeal impos definit anti dump duti import ga fuell refil pocket flint lighter fall cn code origin japan regul eec amend articl term quot origin japan peopl republ china republ korea quot replac quot origin peopl republ china quot ii articl replac quot amount duti eur lighter quot articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel januari council presid gama oj regul amend regul ec oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj oj oj oj