commiss decis decemb pursuant articl council regul eec impos fine undertak suppli incorrect mislead inform notif merger control proceed case comp klm martinair iii notifi document number english text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard agreement european econom area regard council regul eec decemb control concentr undertak articl thereof undertak concern opportun make view object rais commiss regard opinion advisori committe concentr introduct koninklijk luchtvaart maatschappij nv klm lead dutch intern airlin base amsterdam schiphol airport klm oper schedul flight carri passeng cargo serv wide rang european intercontinent destin klm airlin interest includ transavia airlin bv major own subsidiari specialis passeng flight schedul charter netherland mediterranean holidai destin klm sharehold martinair holland nv martinair remain held koninklijk nedlloyd nv nedlloyd commiss consid situat klm nedlloyd exercis quot decis influenc quot mean articl regul eec merger regul martinair jointli control martinair purpos merger regul martinair largest dutch airlin base schiphol oper charter flight amsterdam mediterranean holidai destin regular passeng servic limit rang long haul destin notabl north america septemb klm notifi pursuant articl merger regul propos concentr acquir control martinair notif withdrawn septemb commiss inform klm oral intent declar notif incomplet decemb klm notifi oper februari commiss decid initi proceed applic articl merger regul march commiss issu statement object plan oper klm inform commiss abandon oper ii languag proceed case june commiss statement object klm set preliminari view notif septemb contain incorrect mislead inform save refer decis quot notif quot notif septemb statement object draft english respons klm object english languag request proceed conduct dutch klm refer articl council regul determin languag european econom commun document eu institut send person subject jurisdict member state draft languag state klm argu choic english languag relat notif made english forfeit receiv statement object june languag klm explain opt submit notif english order accommod commiss tight strict deadlin appli merger control procedur state deadlin appli present proceed articl regul document institut commun draft offici languag select sender repli institut draft languag select sender articl commiss regul ec march notif time limit hear provid council regul eec control concentr undertak express gener rule languag chosen parti notif quot languag proceed quot klm argu select english procedur notif present proceed commiss interpret provis refer proceed merger regul relat notifi oper proceed lead substant decis concentr decis articl articl relat notif articl merger regul number proceed proceed lead decis articl articl proceed articl articl proceed lead decis revok decis articl articl proceed issu relat access file proceed relat notif parti choic languag case notif made english commun parti conduct english klm request result represent made klm commiss english discuss dutch procedur articl insepar link notif reason commiss consid english correct languag present proceed iii infring merger regul relev fact notif activ klm group martinair overlap area charter flight mediterranean schedul flight north america transport cargo incorrect mislead inform concern activ klm subsidiari transavia passeng transport mediterranean destin klm submit incorrect inform charter destin transavia withheld relev inform schedul flight transavia inform transavia charter destin inform notif notif page form tabl list transavia martinair charter destin mediterranean summer season tabl form synopsi compar destin countri term quot mediterranean countri quot defin earlier notif compris cypru egypt franc israel malta spain itali portug greec turkei tunisia morocco destin list martinair destin list transavia tabl overlap destin ibiza corfu ko antalya dalaman monastir tabl preced page statement transavia martinair oper larg complementari quot transavia martinair charter servic larg extend complementari martinair oper larg aeroplan md mediterranean destin transavia oper smaller aeroplan destin due size serv martinair plane quot tabl page notif countri martinair transavia spain ibizala palmastenerifemalagapalma de mallorca ibizajerez de la frontalmeriamenorcageronareusarrecifefuerteventura portug faro oporto greec corfukosheraklion corfukosprevenzakefalinazakynthoskalamatachaniasantorinimykonosathenevolosskiathosthessalonikikavalalimnosmytiliniskyroschiossamoskarpatho turkei antalyadalaman antalyadalamanbodrumistambul tunisia monastir monastir morocco agadir egypt luxorhurghada israel tel aviv cypru paphoslarnaca itali romecataniariminimilanoverona franc ajaccio quot incorrect inform transavia charter destin investig appar call mediterranean destin alicant la palma tenerif malaga palma de mallorca faro funchal rhode heraklion djerba serv transavia charter flight mention tabl inform contain transavia timet submit respons request inform except alicant funchal rhode djerba destin serv martinair charter flight martinair destin serv transavia mean realiti complet overlap transavia martinair destin miss destin includ import holidai custom transavia martinair spain signific margin popular countri destin miss destin spain island includ import tourist airport inform schedul servic transavia mediterranean destin inform notif notif klm state transavia substanti schedul oper mediterranean holidai destin sell seat flight packag tour oper section notif entitl quot market definit quot head quot affect market quot question form repeat klm state head quot european inclus charter market quot affect market due small market share parti klm claim market charter flight affect market state describ market affect market quot order provid commiss relev inform describ market affect market quot descript page notif head product market defin quot klm primarili transavia martinair activ product market defin market transport plane request tour oper inclus organis foreign holidai packag includ accommod countri mediterranean quot notif refer market quot charter market quot distinguish market schedul air transport differ charter flight schedul flight set quot charter market market distinguish market schedul air transport destin airlin custom charter market passeng schedul flight market tour oper airlin custom tour oper request airlin fly holidai destin frequenc capac bui minimum amount seat charter plane call allot seat sold part inclus tour passeng tour oper agent account make servic substanti schedul flight quot statement chapter transavia oper schedul flight mediterranean destin sell seat flight tour oper guarante tour oper integr packag tour map transavia destin timet refer paragraph contain notifi document statement effect transavia oper schedul flight made subsequ chapter descript market flight north america quot western europ amsterdam unit state canada market quot footnot relat statement martinair particip klm frequent flyer scheme state quot transavia passeng particip klm frequent flyer program travel transavia schedul flight klm oper destin quot inform includ inform schedul flight inform particip klm frequent flyer scheme head quot ii market relat affect market mean section iii quot print text question form describ relev product geograph market concern notifi oper close relat affect market upstream downstream horizont neighbour market parti concentr activ affect market mean section iii respons klm briefli explain klm martinair control particip tour oper klm share comput reserv system notif continu quot addit martinair charter flight oper destin caribbean klm activ european charter market subsidiari transavia klm martinair schedul flight destin quot statement chapter transavia oper schedul flight mediterranean destin statement chapter transavia quot klm activ european charter market subsidiari transavia quot mislead incorrect charact inform provid schedul servic transavia investig case appar transavia substanti schedul oper mediterranean destin sold seat flight tour oper integr seat packag tour respons request inform klm state letter septemb transavia schedul oper malaga alicant barcelona casablanca djerba faro funchal heraklion lisbon la palma malta nice palma de mallorca tenerif altogeth passeng situat chang substanti transavia continu substanti schedul oper mediterranean destin destin serv transavia charter flight klm letter statement seat schedul flight sold tour oper document submit decemb klm gave inform sale seat schedul flight tour oper state quot guarante seat sold tour oper quot quot tour oper fare schedul flight guarante seat equal guarante seat fare schedul flight quot statement confirm letter klm march shown averag gross price guarante seat sold tour oper ident schedul schedul flight notif decemb klm state quot realiti seldom black white border line schedul charter servic situat grei area guarante seat sold schedul flight tour oper rout popular holidai destin mediterranean close similar servic charter flight quot inform submit calcul passeng transport transavia schedul flight mediterranean destin season summer winter altogeth seat sold tour oper guarante basi seat sold tour oper guarante basi destin major seat passeng transport sold tour oper iv respons statement commiss evalu thereof inform transavia charter destin respond commiss statement object klm describ omiss destin refer paragraph quot administr error quot klm explain provid inform base flight magazin publish transavia flight magazin map transavia destin schedul destin mark yellow dot charter destin mark red dot destin reach charter schedul flight mark yellow dot alicant la palma tenerif malaga palma de mallorca faro funchal rhode heraklion djerba klm state incorrect design destin flight magazin reason mention charter destin klm refer studi sh amp annex notif claim make clear transavia serv charter destin klm state evid examin notif annex differ tabl notif tabl annex previou year due error closer studi notif rightli prompt question part commiss notif annex list klm martinair destin list transavia destin map transavia destin transavia timet refer paragraph part notifi document annex viii notif sh amp studi june quot european charter market analysi relat klm acquisit nedlloyd stake martinair quot studi page text appendix studi schedul passeng belgium germani netherland uk mediterranean destin carrier set tabl year list mediterranean destin serv schedul flight schiphol give destin total number passeng number passeng transport competitor number passeng transport klm martinair transavia tabl conclud transavia serv period airport airport mention year tabl page form notif includ destin refer paragraph introduct form section entitl quot correct complet inform quot state quot inform requir form correct complet inform requir suppli section form annex form supplement inform suppli form quot inform charter destin tabl page form clear ambigu obviou mistak easili detect tabl refer studi cite parti sourc inform instanc chapter refer studi made page context definit geograph scope relev market order support argument geograph market europ wide context klm state quot klm martinair adopt sh amp conclus purpos notif quot sh amp studi refer year inform summer season statist inform appendix studi present comparison tabl notif easili made event airlin chang destin serv time time infer presenc destin refer paragraph sh amp studi year absenc inform provid respect due error klm chang destin serv inform provid appendix sh amp studi serv rectifi incorrect inform section form notif inform transavia schedul flight klm argu transavia sale seat schedul flight part relev product market mention respons oral question transavia schedul flight includ market share data provid notif klm gave written repli quot market share includ sh amp analysi klm notif martinair oper schedul carrier mediterranean destin result overlap activ martinair transavia schedul mediterranean market european schedul mediterranean market substanti schedul market reason schedul charter traffic sold virtual end rout passeng schedul charter flight bui seat tour oper passeng schedul flight bui predominantli travel agent directli airlin involv seat schedul charter flight sold tour oper contrari seat schedul flight sold tour oper small allot schedul charter flight oper commerci risk tour oper commerci risk schedul flight air carrier penalti cancel schedul flight exist liber schedul charter market player inform provid respons commiss request inform ad klm group market share provid notif includ transavia schedul flight market base necessarili lead substanti increas total market base schedul flight carrier includ quot inform requir form relat market definit section section definit relev product market quot relev product market compris product servic regard interchang substitut consum reason product characterist price intend relev product market case compos number individu product servic present larg ident physic technic characterist interchang quot view fact seat transavia schedul flight sold packag tour oper price econom condit guarante seat charter flight sale consid commiss form part product market fact market definit seat sold schedul flight perform airlin includ relev product market serv klm omit inform commiss note klm believ seat sold tour oper schedul transavia flight form part market seat sold charter flight assumpt activ mention respons question form activ quot market close relat affect market quot call neighbour market purpos question neighbour market precis obtain inform case parti market definit narrow retain commiss klm gave detail explan view schedul flight form part relev product market awar market close relat respons question neighbour market klm leav respect chapter blank klm refer martinair sharehold tour oper particip comput reserv system state martinair charter flight oper destin caribbean klm martinair schedul flight destin statement charter schedul flight show klm understood question neighbour market klm made mention transavia schedul flight context detail descript klm neighbour activ reinforc impress inform complet make omiss mislead legal assess inform transavia charter destin inform tabl page form transavia charter destin incorrect destin import mention incorrect inform reinforc statement preced tabl quot transavia martinair charter servic larg extent complementari quot omit import spanish portugues greek destin tabl incorrect impress overlap oper transavia martinair limit refer page servic complementari understood relat size plane context statement made immedi tabl statement transavia oper destin quot quot martinair support fals impress reader gain tabl suppli incorrect inform grossli neglig parti explan transavia flight magazin accept high degre neglig involv flight magazin market promot brochur accuraci necessarili guarante parti reliabl sourc inform intern statist transavia transavia timet commiss transavia fulli control subsidiari inform readili klm klm failur suppli correct inform point constitut infring fine impos articl merger regul inform transavia schedul flight omiss inform indic transavia schedul flight mediterranean destin transavia sell seat flight tour oper make inform provid transavia mislead incorrect mean articl merger regul refer transavia schedul mediterranean flight context rest inform provid form matter simpl omiss explain section iii iv substant mislead reader distort pictur true fact inform incorrect mislead mean articl merger regul commiss exclud possibl klm intention withheld inform transavia schedul flight high degre neglig involv inform relev requir provid form klm klm failur includ inform infring respect fine impos vi imposit fine articl merger regul commiss impos undertak fine eur eur intention neglig suppli incorrect mislead inform notif pursuant articl merger regul articl set amount fine commiss account natur graviti infring commiss take account aggrav mitig circumst natur infring infring commit klm form suppli incorrect mislead inform mean articl merger regul suppli incorrect mislead inform grossli neglig graviti infring infring merger regul klm regard infring reason set relev incorrect mislead inform inform overlap parti individu destin relev competit assess oper question relev market consist individu rout mediterranean destin transavia destin mention import spanish portugues greek holidai destin attract high volum passeng inform transavia oper relev martinair destin relev assess amount actual competit martinair transavia context parti repeat statement martinair transavia oper complementari inform transavia oper major holidai destin schedul charter servic parallel import order assess transavia market posit seat sold schedul flight form part relev product market inform transavia substanti schedul oper charter destin relev assess market strength transavia rout mitig factor invok klm klm emphasis meet commiss order prepar notif discuss draft notif meet compli good faith suggest remark made commiss point notif matter complex lack readili data klm state proven provid quot incorrect mislead quot inform rate view circumst case provis ground imposit fine commiss share view reason set transavia charter destin comment statement object klm explain omiss transavia charter destin result administr error klm argu mistak evid examin notif klm argu tabl question includ text form request commiss ongo summer season detail market share data tabl page notif present addendum updat inform contain sh amp studi refer paragraph decis illustr klm statement transavia martinair activ quot larg extent complementari quot klm claim tabl read conjunct studi unfound refer studi klm claim incorrect tabl obviou unfound omiss charter destin question detect klm knowledg activ obviou mistak detect care reader klm emphasis intent withhold inform commiss serious administr error exagger commiss explan klm collect inform transavia charter destin show larg degre careless base inform flight magazin reliabl sourc show grave neglect duti select carefulli inform view fact transavia fulli control subsidiari ii transavia schedul oper klm argu made secret contact commiss fact klm group includ subsidiari transavia oper schedul flight europ gener mediterranean state provid inform transavia schedul flight commiss request pre notif talk klm refer sh amp studi claim make clear dutch holidai maker vacat schedul flight klm state inconceiv larg proport passeng attribut klm group discuss prenotif meet princip concern clarifi market definit commiss accept klm explain transavia substanti sale seat schedul flight packag tour oper commiss initi contempl take activ account market definit purpos remov oblig klm includ full inform activ respons question form inform sh amp studi relat dutch holidai maker custom bui packag tour tour oper deduc inform transavia sold seat schedul flight packag tour oper inform transavia present draft submit prompt question part commiss transavia present quot charter oper quot inform transavia oper schedul flight final version notif footnot page concern particip transavia klm frequent flyer scheme inform contain earlier draft argument commiss ask inform unfound klm claim inform schedul flight chang klm market share omiss inform irrelev actual market share compani element measur market strength oper transavia schedul servic destin serv charter basi factor contribut strength rout relev commiss assess competit connect merger commiss substant assess case natur scope remedi requir affect knowledg lack knowledg exist oper natur extent case transavia schedul oper destin argu easi schedul airlin commenc oper sell seat individu tour oper consequ merger allow similarli domin posit found exist rout concern remedi focus exclus martinair oper transavia charter oper insuffici affect account substanti sale tour oper transavia make schedul flight rout amount fine proceed initi merger regul import parti merger suppli full inform submit notif constraint firm care submit detail merger present case klm suppli inform incorrect mislead klm grossli neglig inform relev competit assess oper klm provid correct inform initi result commiss investig complet inform addit transavia charter destin deriv inform provid respons request inform final confirm oral inform transavia oper schedul flight mediterranean destin result request inform fact klm sell seat schedul flight tour oper econom condit charter flight import activ fulli confirm notif decemb commiss subsequ investig inform contain notif assess conduct klm born mind klm larg european compani signific busi europ klm prior experi notif merger regul mitig klm claim summari fulli paragraph alleg infring deliber commiss identifi miss inform request prenotif period instanc extens miss inform decis outcom case commiss view limit weight attach claim impact graviti infring amount fine impos evid infring intent klm particip prenotif contact commiss desir ensur notif accept respons ensur relev inform provid klm fail exercis due care carri task degre neglig infring substanti instanc klm reli flight magazin crucial inform transavia charter destin provid inform transavia schedul flight appreci import absenc specif request remind commiss commiss fail identifi element miss inform continu absenc affect substant decis merger wai benefit klm basi take account circumst case commiss consid impos fine eur klm pursuant articl merger regul adopt decis articl fine eur impos koninklijk luchtvaart maatschappij nv klm pursuant articl regul eec suppli incorrect mislead inform notif submit commiss regul septemb articl fine refer articl paid month date notif decis bank account european commiss banqu bruxel lambert agenc européenn rond point schuman brussel expiri period interest automat payabl rate appli european central bank repo oper work dai month decis adopt percentag point make articl decis address koninklijk luchtvaart maatschappij nv amsterdamseweg nl gp amstelveen brussel decemb commiss mario monti member commiss oj regul amend regul ec oj case iv klm martinair oj oj case iv klm martinair oj oj oj regul amend act access oj regul amend act access page notif timet quot charter flight summer quot provid annex iii respons septemb request inform septemb timet mention destin malta croatia annex respons list number stretch transavia schedul flight mediterranian destin netherland destin number stretch rest europ mediterranian destin destin list addit destin destin israel morocco tunisia page notif part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos squar bracket mark asterisk order determin market share market charter flight mediterranean klm wide geograph market definit klm state plane parti charter compani oper airport benelux unit kingdom germani basi market share calcul page flight netherland account market share parti page notif page notif statement impli klm small extent activ market inform klm except statist inform appendix sh amp studi section form klm state quot transavia airlin activ european inclus tour charter market view parti concentr affect market sole commiss inform transavia mention quot page notif page notif footnot page notif klm cover letter notif septemb page notif page notif commiss request septemb notif decemb notif decemb footnot notif decemb footnot notif decemb summer winter addit klm sell guarante seat flight tour oper malaga alicant barcelona djerba faro funchal heraklion lisbon la palma malta nice mallorca tenerif page notif decemb annex xxix summer xxx winter summer winter page notif decemb annex xxix summer xxx winter summer winter summer season djerba faro funchal heraklion lisbon la palma malta mallorca tenerif refer sh amp studi made chapter inform affect market notif page notif letter klm septemb page notif page notif page page notif page letter septemb paragraph decis inform notif decemb