council regul ec septemb impos definit countervail duti collect definit provision duti impos import graphit electrod system origin india council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec octob protect subsidis import countri member european commun basic regul articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur commiss regul ec provision regul impos provision countervail duti import commun graphit electrod system origin india subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision countervail measur interest parti made written submiss make view provision find parti request grant opportun heard commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit countervail duti import graphit electrod system origin india definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider oral written comment submit interest parti consid find modifi product concern product comment receiv product concern product recit provision regul confirm subsidis duti entitl passbook scheme depb disclosur imposit provision measur subsequ final disclosur number comment receiv govern india goi export produc firstli claim depb post export basi drawback scheme consequ benefit scheme restrict excess remiss import duti claim quantif benefit base date receipt depb licenc date utilis sale commiss final claim amount benefit reduc alleg depb rate product concern reduc februari ip respons claim note recit provision regul basic regul except inter alia drawback substitut drawback scheme conform strict rule laid annex item annex ii definit rule drawback annex iii definit rule substitut drawback context note goi appli effect verif system procedur confirm amount input consum product export product annex ii ii basic regul case substitut drawback scheme annex iii ii basic regul addition goi carri post export examin base actual input involv determin excess payment occur requir absenc effect appli verif system annex ii ii annex iii ii basic regul recit provision regul consid depb post export basi consid permit drawback substitut drawback scheme annex iii articl ii basic regul reason conclus recit provision regul countervail benefit remiss total import duti due import confirm elig benefit scheme compani export good point time export transact declar made export author india indic export take place depb scheme order good export indian custom author issu advanc good export export ship bill show inter alia amount depb credit grant export transact point time export compani benefit receiv custom author issu export ship bill goi discret grant depb credit verifi chang depb rate actual export issuanc depb licenc affect level benefit grant relev depb rate appli time export declar made possibl retroact amend level benefit moment export transact made goi liabl forego custom duti constitut financi contribut mean articl basic regul articl basic regul countervail duti impos purpos offset subsidi grant releas free circul commun injuri rational impos duti price import good lower result receiv subsidi lower price injuri case export graphit electrod system negoti price export sale awar sale benefit subsidi depb scheme virtu fact export awar receiv subsidi benefit scheme compani competit advantag posit point time negoti price reflect subsidi offer lower price indian account standard provid book credit receiv depb scheme accrual basi incom benefit earn ii ultim collect proce export transact made relev point benefit earn state recit custom author issu export ship bill show inter alia amount depb credit grant export transact goi discret grant subsidi discret amount subsidi state recit chang depb rate actual export issuanc depb licenc retroact effect level benefit grant final state recit price export transact consid reflect subsidi lower price benefit circumst consid benefit earn export transact made basi compani line indian account standard book depb credit incom stage export transact accord articl basic regul amount countervail subsidi calcul term benefit confer recipi found exist investig period light consid assess benefit scheme sum credit earn export transact made scheme investig period differ approach provision regul sum credit utilis assess accord articl basic regul fee necessarili incur obtain subsidi deduct respect final argument relat alleg reduct depb rate accept prima faci evid submit show depb rate product concern reduc effect februari amount benefit assess basi amount benefit earn export transact made ip reduct depb rate period effect level subsidi determin basi benefit scheme cooper compani revis export promot capit good scheme epcg absenc comment interest parti conclus outlin recit provision regul confirm advanc licenc scheme al provision stage export produc india deem receiv countervail benefit scheme repres export claim scheme countervail ii case benefit receiv grant busi unit compani manufactur product concern sold compani subsequ ip claim benefit al attribut export respect claim evid provid show al countervail export subsidi context recal goi appli effect verif system procedur confirm amount input consum product export product annex ii ii basic regul case substitut drawback scheme annex iii ii basic regul addition goi carri post export examin base actual input involv determin excess payment occur requir absenc effect appli verif system annex ii ii annex iii ii basic regul reason conclus recit provision regul confirm respect claim found ip export concern benefit scheme result receiv countervail benefit fact busi unit produc product sold subsequ ip relev determin compani benefit subsidi ip addit consid relev assess level subsidis compani subsidi scheme target unit compani produc product concern compani examin benefit unit consid repres benefit compani end confirm ip busi unit benefit al scheme busi unit manufactur product concern form legal econom entiti conclus outlin recit provision regul confirm export process zone epz export orient unit eou absenc comment interest parti conclus outlin recit provision regul confirm incom tax exempt it absenc comment interest parti conclus outlin recit provision regul confirm amount countervail subsidi light conclus outlin amount countervail subsidi definit confirm gt tabl gt commun industri absenc substanti inform argument respect recit provision regul confirm injuri provision disclosur indian export point diverg undercut margin type product concern compar undercut margin similar type claim properli examin found discrep due mistak report number credit note discount commun produc claim accept undercut margin type applic type correct found number sale transact commun industri undercut calcul doubl count view doubl count transact elimin undercut calcul modifi doubl count place establish figur assess injuri indic modifi injuri indic result comparison show ip price product concern origin india sold commun undercut commun industri price absenc substanti inform argument respect recit provision regul confirm except recit recit causat return normal competit condit dismantl cartel indian export reiter argument establish causal link subsidis import injuri suffer commun industri base data unreli exist cartel begin indian export provid inform deadlin set submit comment respect absenc substanti inform argument recit provision regul confirm commun interest associ repres user user compani reiter main concern exclud indian supplier commun market imposit measur reduc competit commun market product inevit lead increas price assess recit provision regul impact increas price product final custom minim recal purpos countervail measur mean stop access commun product india restor level plai field distort unfair trade practic final consid level measur exclud indian produc commun market absenc substanti inform argument respect recit provision regul confirm injuri elimin level disclosur provision find interest parti claim profit level deem repres financi situat commun industri absenc injuri subsidis india high alleg normal practic set profit ratio commod good sector steel textil base chemic parti claim methodolog arriv figur fulli disclos explain recit provision regul profit result reason assess establish basi number element profit achiev commun industri market share dump import lowest ii market condit time iii output drawn databas compani account databas consist compani account data collect nation central bank largest industrialis countri member state european union unit state america japan aggreg sector european committe central balanc sheet data offic european commiss databas updat provision definit determin analysi updat data refer eu member state unit state america japan show averag profit extraordinari item compani belong nearest busi sector year databas consid set profit achiev absenc subsidis due consider paid qualit quantit element relev purpos recit provision regul proper examin made commun industri profit level market share subsidis import lowest circumst affect repres period final note product concern demand applic strictli match paramet notabl term electr resist entail highli capit intens manufactur process neglig amount research develop cost fact limit number produc world master technolog indic product consid basic commod take circumst element account definit conclud profit margin deem repres financi situat commun industri absenc injuri subsidis india set purpos calcul injuri margin consequ find undercut recit injuri margin revis gt tabl gt definit measur view conclus reach regard subsidis injuri causat commun interest consid definit countervail duti impos order prevent injuri caus commun industri subsidis import definit measur impos level subsidi margin found higher injuri margin calcul accord articl basic regul level cooper india high residu subsidi margin compani set level compani highest individu margin definit collect provision duti view magnitud subsidi margin found export produc india level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision countervail duti impos provision regul definit collect extent amount definit duti impos definit countervail duti graphit india limit gil higher provision countervail duti amount secur provision countervail duti impos provision regul definit collect convers definit countervail duti hindustan electro graphit heg limit lower provision countervail duti amount provision secur excess definit rate countervail duti releas individu countervail duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countri wide duti applic exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic claim request applic individu countervail duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest sale export sale chang chang product sale entiti regul amend updat list compani benefit individu duti undertak investig export produc india graphit india limit hindustan electro graphit limit offer price undertak accord articl basic regul signific differ observ investig period present time raw materi cost due gener volatil market undertak accept case basi minimum import price establish sole data collect relat investig period offer neg consequ effect undertak remov injuri subsidis addit export produc concern subsequ undertak offer acquir graphit electrod product compani situat commun rais risk circumvent undertak offer view develop finalis workabl accept undertak time limit present investig adopt regul articl definit countervail duti impos import graphit electrod kind electr furnac appar densiti cm electr resist fall cn code taric code nippl electrod fall cn code taric code import separ origin india rate definit countervail duti applic net free commun frontier price duti product produc compani list gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision countervail duti pursuant provision regul import graphit electrod kind electr furnac appar densiti cm electr resist fall cn code taric code nippl electrod fall cn code taric code import separ origin india definit collect amount secur excess definit rate countervail duti releas definit duti higher provision duti amount secur level provision duti definit collect articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel septemb council presid bot oj regul amend regul ec oj oj