commiss decis octob state aid measur nn implement germani technisch glaswerk ilmenau gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl ec treati articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati regard comment procedur letter date decemb regist receiv decemb germani notifi restructur measur technisch glaswerk ilmenau gmbh hereinaft refer tgi commiss accord articl ec treati aid disburs measur regist notifi aid number nn letter date decemb march commiss request addit inform germani provid letter date februari regist februari regist june letter septemb regist septemb octob regist octob octob regist novemb germani submit inform letter date april commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect waiver dem purchas price state aid time germani enjoin provid inform data establish invest loan amount dem allegedli grant kreditanstalt für wiederaufbau hereinaft refer kfw aid scheme authoris commiss aid dem grant thuringia consolid fund approv aid scheme compli term relev scheme letter date juli regist juli germani repli decis initi procedur inform order meet repres german author held novemb letter date februari regist march germani submit inform context formal investig proceed case commiss receiv comment interest parti forward germani comment germani comment receiv letter decemb regist decemb februari regist march letter date juli commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid measur letter date octob regist dai germani respond decis initi procedur provid addit inform letter march regist march april regist april letter date june regist june germani submit inform commiss receiv comment interest parti forward germani submit respons letter date februari regist februari letter receiv compani concern march regist march april regist april meet german repres lawyer compani held occas compani hand inform regist waiver subject proceed case assess final neg decis june aid recipi lodg appeal decis august case order april presid court instanc suspend subject condit implement articl commiss decis requir recoveri aid commiss contest order june descript aid recipi tgi locat ilmenau thuringia area elig region aid articl ec treati set privat person mr mr geiß aim take product line ilmenau glaswerk gmbh hereinaft refer igw compani sole owner treuhandanstalt hereinaft refer tha decid wind remain product line shut dismantl tgi activ field technic glasswar laboratori glass glass domest sight glass tube rod employe turnov dem main sharehold share manag director compani mr geiß sole sharehold manag director compani activ market tgi laborbedarf stralsund gmbh ls locat güstrow mecklenburg western pomerania paul schröder amp technisch glaswaren gmbh amp pf locat ellerau hamburg ls employe stop busi activ pf employe turnov dem file bankruptci januari previou financi measur igw product line melt tank sold tgi mean asset deal asset deal contract septemb septemb product line sold tgi negoti potenti investor fail sale approv tha sole sharehold igw decemb purchas price total dem paid instal end payment secur mortgag amount dem bank guarante dem cover turn counterguarante time deposit gt tabl gt addit invest loan kfw amount dem invest grant allow amount dem tgi receiv grant bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben hereinaft refer bv restructur pilot plant amount dem tha bv grant loss compens year amount dem asset deal contract decemb decemb fourth product line sold tgi investor found purchas price dem gt tabl gt addit invest allow amount dem loan thüringer aufbaubank amount dem tgi receiv bv grant restructur fourth product line amount dem bv invest grant amount dem tha bv grant loss compens year amount dem effect asset deal depend provis bank guarante tgi forthcom asset deal provision ineffect februari restructur plan financi measur germani tgi ran difficulti start invest project postpon half year tha approv term asset deal decemb consequ tgi start invest project april plan start quarter delai rest invest project tgi unabl provid time evid guarante precondit implement asset deal bv make grant amount dem restructur fourth product line result invest carri tgi suffer incept continu lack liquid project balanc compani liquid resourc exhaust order restor viabil tgi oblig solv liquid problem build capit reserv end concert action decid bv land thuringia owner compani februari gt tabl gt purchas price product line paid addit dem need restructur fourth product line dem relat invest project improv product gener overhaul product line dem envisag outstand account payabl supplier rent payment origin due amount dem requir gt tabl gt bv agre waiv dem initi purchas price addit bank guarante amount dem asset deal convert mortgag order improv liquid situat compani bv final approv asset deal insist provis bank guarante precondit made contract provision ineffect februari grant restructur fourth product line amount dem final paid compani receiv tha bv grant loss compens total dem invest allow amount dem grant compani context restructur compani receiv dem loan thüringer aufbaubank thuringia consolid fund agre asset deal restructur plan dem restructur cost financ compani resourc form cash flow detail cash flow gener gener privat investor found contribut dem restructur waiver staff christma bonu amount dem agre releas guarante secur job dem restructur inform guarante gt tabl gt note busi secret actual plan loss actual plan profit latest inform submit germani compani realis turnov dem million dem million made profit dem market analysi product produc tgi fall categori special glass special glass account total eu glass output sector cover wide rang product limit number produc tgi ten compani eu produc light glass inform commiss output growth special glass sector market light glass grew posit trend continu expect consequ asian crisi mid market recov turnov special glass grown germani gener outlook remain posit initi formal investig procedur commiss initi formal investig procedur respect thüringer aufbaubank loan dem million allegedli grant approv aid scheme appear condit approv aid scheme met doubt loan compat guidelin rescu restructur aid instanc restructur plan restor firm viabil submit contribut privat investor commiss doubt aid recipi qualifi small medium size enterpris sme formal investig procedur initi respect deferr payment dem million purchas price convers collater commiss suspect measur constitut state aid doubt compat rescu restructur guidelin comment interest parti commiss receiv comment tgi competitor comment forward germani reaction letter date octob novemb repli comment competitor februari comment open procedur tgi argu commiss violat principl sound administr proceed respect waiver dem purchas price separ respect thüringer aufbaubank loan neg decis case proceed initi measur part restructur plan assess set proceed pick element restructur plan render incoher result neg decis case prejudg outcom proceed respect thüringer aufbaubank loan tgi argu urgent decis waiver compani negoti investor adjust restructur plan commiss violat principl sound administr initi formal investig procedur respect convers collater month inform tgi complain decis initi formal investig procedur commiss account argument put forward germani latest data submit tgi claim loan thüringer aufbaubank constitut state aid compens payment entitl demolit build land thuringia commiss accept reason tgi argu loan cover aid scheme allegedli grant commiss conclud loan cover aid scheme tgi claim authoris basi rescu restructur guidelin tgi main problem applic rescu restructur guidelin absenc contribut privat investor origin restructur plan contribut dem million tgi made point negoti group investor negoti conclud group intend invest dem compani tgi submit letter intent group comment open proceed competitor argu tgi qualifi sme main sharehold mr geiß owner compani compani view singl busi entiti exceed threshold employe laid sme recommend competitor argu convers collater deferr payment constitut state aid convers bank guarante junior mortgag constitut state aid bank guarante involv risk event compani insolv junior mortgag claim creditor prioriti event insolv recov deferr payment constitut state aid competitor compani difficult econom situat creditor enforc claim make bank guarante privat creditor waiv possibl loan thüringer aufbaubank competitor argu constitut state aid cover scheme scheme design sme requir guidelin rescu restructur aid met competitor accus tgi state aid sell product systemat dump price significantli distort competit market share competitor decreas significantli price fallen sharpli compat aid measur rescu restructur guidelin competitor point absenc restructur plan addit guidelin requir abandon structur loss make activ competitor claim tgi abandon product activ coffe pot declin market competitor claim quot time time quot principl restructur aid award observ competitor point structur overcapac product market tgi oper tgi activ light glass market limit comment germani repli decis initi procedur germani claim thüringer aufbaubank loan cover aid scheme allegedli grant condit scheme met argu aid recipi qualifi sme compani own mr geiß longer activ market time aid grant recipi rank sme synergi compani tgi compani own sharehold form busi entiti tgi qualifi sme loan grant thuringia consolid fund case notif requir restructur plan germani point origin amend time compani produc amend plan adapt situat april addit compani negoti privat investor close conclud germani submit final plan date germani view capac reduct requir sme domin posit market suffer overcapac case reduct capac requir germani claim aid limit minimum privat investor contribut argu guarante provid loan main sharehold manag director mr geiß account contribut employe germani reject accus competitor tgi sold product dump price germani argu loan thüringer aufbaubank grant approv aid scheme thuringia consolid fund reason legal certainti commiss assess confin decid condit grant aid assess appropri manifestli incorrect applic scheme commiss respect principl regard doubt sme statu aid recipi commiss note issu inform order obtain inform loan grant thuringia consolid fund basi inform provid conclud condit met oblig initi formal investig procedur commiss accept loan cover aid scheme germani argu altern loan authoris rescu restructur guidelin point commiss restrict line restructur aid sme germani tgi qualifi sme employe compani own mr geiß irrelev sme statu tgi germani refer expert report date novemb recent data compani develop submit commiss show posit trend germani claim materi account commiss germani argu loan thüringer aufbaubank constitut aid compens demolit batch hous land thuringia build relat oper fourth product line demolit entail addit cost dem million tgi build connect bridg built loan thuringia consolid fund award compani compens germani link provis loan demolit build clear contract loan financ invest relat restor build fourth product line deferr payment remain purchas price germani argu bv act privat creditor deferr claim enabl compani renew product line remain viabl event insolv entir claim unenforc germani deferr constitut state aid mean articl ec treati germani argu altern deferr authoris basi guidelin rescu restructur aid repli comment competitor germani express disappoint proceed split ask commiss revok decis waiver argu commiss revok decis oblig signific mistak made procedur articl regul commiss revok decis base incorrect inform provid procedur determin factor decis case commiss see reason revok decis germani claim neg decis prejudg outcom decis claim possibl comment effect measur part restructur plan defenc violat commiss assess restructur plan germani claim principl sound administr violat germani reiter posit loan effect cover aid scheme allegedli grant altern argu loan constitut aid compens payment argu loan element state aid provid market term support fact mr geiß person guarante repay loan germani point tgi sme time loan grant synergi compani product group busi compani carri arm length basi compani consid entiti actual econom power greater sme germani argu altern loan compat common market basi guidelin rescu restructur aid connect submit latest inform restor firm viabil restructur plan submit tgi latest restructur plan date april contain invest plan overview financ invest germani submit expert report prepar case commiss neg decis waiver show germani sustain improv compani econom perform long term viabil restor letter date march germani claim tgi found investor invest eur compani share investor made contribut condit confirm waiver dem million subject neg decis germani ask commiss revok neg decis waiver case includ waiver current proceed germani argu neg decis case open current proceed base absenc contribut privat investor investor enabl germani present restructur plan met condit viabil proportion aid invest delai carri latest letter date june germani reiter primarili argument present previou letter proceed stress tgi competitor schott gain monopoli market segment tgi forc market fact account decid restructur aid compat common market germani refer guidelin aid rescu restructur firm difficulti state quot state aid warrant instanc desir maintain competit market structur disappear firm lead monopoli tight oligopoli situat quot germani argu commiss view contribut investor account assess compat aid aid approv basi altern plan financ restructur plan commiss germani view financ plan plausibl realist demonstr fact firm carri restructur plan met requir aid proport addit public assist bv land thuringia contain signific privat contribut lastli half restructur cost financ waiver purchas price loan thüringer aufbaubank guarante mr geiß rest financ compani support waiver staff manag salari payment germani argu invest worth eur guarante mr geiß thüringer aufbaubank loan worth dem million eur million defer repay loan privat bank worth eur deferr staff salari christma bonus worth eur waiver christma bonus worth eur view privat investor contribut germani conclud condit met aid approv basi guidelin rescu restructur contribut assess commiss note separ proceed neg decis proceed prejudg outcom set proceed inform decis measur accord principl sound administr conclud formal investig quickli financi assist public resourc grant tgi commiss determin measur constitut state aid mean articl ec treati tgi receiv assist public resourc privat investor grant compani advantag competitor distort competit turn affect trade member state product question activ trade financi measur constitut state aid mean articl ec treati commiss analys compat common market measur support tgi financ public resourc commiss analys constitut state aid compat common market recipi firm germani consid tgi aid recipi consid tgi sme defin commiss recommend april definit small medium size enterpris hereinaft refer sme recommend decis initi formal investig procedur commiss rais question relev undertak larger tgi main sharehold manag director tgi time sole sharehold manag director compani pf ls tgi pf ls exceed threshold employe establish sme recommend question tgi qualifi sme relev assess compat measur concern issu pursu proceed exist aid mean articl ec treati complianc approv aid scheme contribut tha bv context asset deal contract septemb measur grant part asset deal fell tha aid scheme closur compani costli option state decid privatis state support decis impli burden state dem price dem paid compani consid neg price undertak worker financi assist tha bv tgi cover tha scheme constitut exist aid reassess part proceed contribut tha bv context asset deal contract decemb measur grant asset deal fell scope tha scheme closur compani costli option state decid privatis state support decis impli burden state dem undertak worker financi assist tha bv tgi cover tha scheme constitut exist aid reassess part proceed invest loan kfw context asset deal loan amount dem grant kfw allegedli aid scheme previous authoris commiss loan dem grant kfw scheme small busi loan dem grant kfw eu job promot scheme small busi inform submit germani loan provid market condit interest rate refer interest rate compani difficulti time loan grant commiss conclud constitut state aid loan dem provid erp reconstruct programm region aid scheme previous authoris commiss compli condit set aid scheme grant effect cover scheme constitut exist aid reassess part proceed invest grant invest allow part asset deal tgi receiv invest grant amount dem outlin plan joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur region aid scheme authoris commiss grant compli term aid scheme approv commiss allegedli grant regard exist aid asset deal invest allow amount dem grant tgi asset deal tgi receiv invest allow amount dem dem payment made invest allow law investitionszulagengesetz region aid scheme authoris commiss basi inform submit commiss conclud invest allow meet condit aid scheme allegedli grant effect cover scheme regard exist aid exist aid reassess part proceed account calcul proportion aid waiver dem purchas price waiver dem purchas price subject investig procedur case neg final decis adopt june waiver assess proceed germani claim waiver price constitut state aid mean articl ec treati correspond behaviour privat creditor argu profit econom point view bv waiv price insist payment full price commiss view waiver constitut state aid incompat common market aid recipi lodg appeal decis court instanc european commun convers secur dem purchas price deferr payment part concert action bv agre convert bank guarante worth dem asset deal junior mortgag payment remain purchas price defer schedul onward commiss initi formal investig procedur suspect measur confer advantag firm privat creditor grant firm difficulti result constitut state aid commiss maintain bv govern bodi task predecessor treuhandanstalt privatis state own firm eastern germani bv part feder govern structur answer measur bv attribut state secur form junior mortgag lower bank guarante bank guarante involv low risk event insolv entir purchas price dem million recov mortgag junior rank compar senior claim bank state germani letter date octob submit case econom mortgag low junior rank bank expect event insolv small percentag claim recov assess confirm letter date octob convers secur confer advantag tgi privat creditor grant constitut state aid assess ad hoc aid deferr payment germani claim correspond behaviour privat creditor constitut state aid establish case law court justic european commun order determin measur public sector bodi constitut state aid determin recipi undertak receiv econom advantag obtain normal market condit remain purchas price amount dem million origin due payment end octob bv agre deferr payment payment schedul onward instal dem end germani argu deferr payment order restor viabil compani compani bankrupt deferr grant purchas price dem million secur junior mortgag point mortgag low econom event insolv small share dem million recov commiss consid deferr consist behaviour privat creditor support fact privat bank agre deferr claim deferr constitut state aid fall scope articl ec treati contradict commiss conclus final decis case effect waiver dem million purchas price constitut state aid waiver deferr payment compar loan dem grant thüringer aufbaubank thuringia consolid fund februari germani loan grant thuringia consolid fund firm difficulti aid scheme authoris commiss commiss doubt loan effect cover aid scheme initi formal investig procedur decis initi procedur commiss question compani rank sme scheme design primarili sme case larg undertak individu notif rest condit scheme set guidelin rescu restructur aid point condit met loan cover aid scheme grant constitut aid assess ad hoc aid commiss accept loan cover aid scheme germani argu constitut aid claim grant market condit inform loan grant interest rate secur mortgag relat real estat fourth product line directli enforc guarante mr geiß owner compani commiss note thüringer aufbaubank develop bank land thuringia public sector bodi control land thuringia guarante activ measur attribut state commiss note loan grant accord approv aid scheme firm difficulti loan grant thüringer aufbaubank decemb compani financi difficulti commiss consid privat investor grant loan term compani loan constitut state aid germani argu altern loan thüringer aufbaubank constitut state aid compens payment land thuringia demolit batch hous build relat oper fourth product line germani claim demolit compani extend build build connect bridg gener cost amount dem million expert report evid provid show compani face addit cost dem million demolit build germani compani claim relationship loan damag caus tgi deduc fact loan contract state loan financ invest relat renov fourth product line prove loan constitut compens payment compani incur addit cost dem million cost compens event receiv grant dem million loan show germani argument unfound commiss conclud dem million loan thüringer aufbaubank constitut state aid assess ad hoc aid exempt articl ec treati thüringer aufbaubank loan dem million convers secur assess ad hoc aid commiss articl ec treati lai exempt gener principl incompat state aid establish articl exempt articl appli case aid measur social charact grant individu consum make good damag caus natur disast except occurr grant economi area feder republ germani affect divis exempt laid articl ec treati primari object aid region develop restor long term viabil undertak difficulti exempt laid articl appli articl authoris state aid grant promot develop econom sector aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest assess rescu restructur aid commiss issu special guidelin consid set commun guidelin relat aid research develop environment protect small medium size enterpris employ train basi compat appli case inform aid grant april commun guidelin aid rescu restructur firm difficulti applic point rescu restructur guidelin financi weak firm receiv restructur gener due poor past perform dim futur prospect typic symptom deterior profit increas size loss diminish turnov grow inventori excess capac declin cash flow increas debt rise interest charg low net asset basi inform provid commiss conclud compani difficulti time aid grant incur continu loss gener insuffici cash flow carri invest equiti capit reduc significantli germani argu aid approv ground tgi competitor schott monopoli posit market segment strengthen domin posit tgi forc market fact disappear firm strengthen competitor market posit domin posit decis criterion approv restructur aid relev condit met restor viabil grant restructur aid requir feasibl coher reach restructur plan capabl restor long term viabil firm reason time span basi realist assumpt germani submit restructur plan cover period submit forecast compani turnov result period compani viabil restor restructur plan reli assumpt investor contribut dem amount cover substanti part invest cost restructur plan privat investor found reason time span financ measur assur absenc contribut restructur plan realist capabl restor long term viabil compani restructur plan viabil suppos restor compani make loss germani argu commiss account expert report novemb contain favour assess compani econom situat report point posit develop compani profit situat year state precondit develop carri invest amount dem million invest amount dem million carri liquid situat compani find resourc invest amount dem million tgi pai back loan dem million estim expert compani carri financ resourc ensur viabil compani state aid waiver exist claim contrari germani claim expert report show compani recov state difficulti long term viabil secur post assess show origin restructur plan implement part end renov product line restor long term viabil compani complet fourth product line renov product line shut temporarili mid expert report prepar case submit investig procedur germani point posit develop compani econom employ term base significantli invest origin invest plan octob compani pai back debt amount dem includ purchas price dem million waiver subject neg decis commiss report state liquid situat difficult germani submit altern plan financ restructur measur date april account fact privat investor found plan postpon renov product line reli deferr staff salari payment medium term deferr loan payment order financ import invest total invest lower origin restructur plan germani argu altern plan capabl restor firm long term viabil latest letter germani explain deferr salari christma bonus deferr repay bank loan waiver christma bonus includ altern financ plan firm surviv contract conclud investor order guarante long term viabil firm waiver dem million purchas price contribut investor give tgi sound financi basi suffici capit commiss conclud altern financ plan manifestli capabl restor firm long term viabil commiss note latest inform submit negoti group investor conclus group investor invest compani letter date march germani claim privat investor found negoti investor conclud bind contract appar sign investor owner compani mr mr geiß investor increas capit compani eur eur hold stake addit investor provid tgi eur capit reserv investor found germani claim argument restructur plan viabl valid anymor germani aid authoris germani claim argu tempor link origin restructur plan germani coher outset carri part absenc investor carri amend form note aid grant februari paid novemb rescu restructur guidelin restructur plan restor long term viabil health firm reason time span restructur aid link viabl restructur programm submit relev detail commiss plan restor firm competit reason period restructur plan establish grant aid origin restructur plan submit realist germani submit adjust restructur plan contribut privat investor constitut restructur plan restructur period link aid measur grant restructur plan investor submit year legal proceed relat decis case tgi assert liquid problem clear loan thüringer aufbaubank germani argument accept commiss note commit privat investor uncondit depend confirm waiver purchas price subject neg decis commiss explicitli state inform submit germani germani write investor made commit condit commiss approv waiver bv confirm waiver basi invest waiver consid commiss decis june constitut unlaw incompat aid commiss decis law see reason revok fact implement articl recoveri suspend order presid court instanc april depriv decis presumpt legal enjoi commun legal instrument plan contribut privat investor account commiss conclud restructur plan exist capabl restor long term viabil health firm reason timescal basi realist assumpt viabil criterion met undu distort competit restructur plan measur offset advers effect competitor aid involv contrari common interest elig exempt pursuant articl ec treati object assess demand suppli situat structur excess product capac relev market commun serv aid recipi restructur plan make contribut proportion amount aid receiv restructur relev sector irrevers reduc close capac germani state tgi expect increas decreas product capac futur comment decis initi procedur competitor tgi argu structur overcapac product market tgi oper shown recit inform commiss market overcapac tgi igw twelv product line result reduct capac place proportion restructur cost benefit amount intens aid limit strict minimum need enabl restructur undertaken relat benefit anticip commun viewpoint investor expect make signific contribut restructur plan resourc extern financ aid grant avoid provid compani surplu cash aggress market distort activ link restructur process germani argu waiv staff christma bonu constitut part investor contribut signific commit part staff restructur compani account investor contribut investor bear risk respect appli deferr salari christma bonus germani identifi latest letter contribut privat investor payment defer repres temporari reduct cost firm germani consid salari reduct manag director main sharehold compani worth dem form part investor contribut measur constitut cost reduct firm view contribut owner financ restructur support fact measur includ restructur plan manag director owner control firm decid level salari amount reduct result reduct kind correspond verifi contribut reduct manag director salari regard part investor contribut germani argu deferr payment loan privat bank commerzbank rank contribut investor deferr reduc cost firm temporarili view part investor contribut germani consid cash flow amount dem investor contribut commiss accept intern financi measur form part investor contribut larg made directli indirectli aid measur cash flow reduc financ restructur compani commiss account element investor contribut germani provid inform cash flow gener gener futur germani claim directli enforc guarante mr geiß owner compani provid thüringer aufbaubank loan dem million part privat investor contribut loan grant public resourc consid privat investor contribut secur mortgag dem million plot fourth product line mr geiß assum entir risk guarante consid lower state germani commiss recognis mr geiß guarante part investor contribut contribut restructur cost accord commiss customari practic suffici reason announc contribut privat investor uncondit account commiss conclud signific privat investor contribut mean rescu restructur guidelin condit proportion aid met full implement restructur plan compani fulli implement restructur plan restructur plan submit commiss show gap financ investor found contribut investor essenti implement restructur plan carri indispens invest restructur plan implement part conclus commiss note convers secur constitut state aid find loan provid thüringer aufbaubank thuringia consolid fund cover scheme allegedli grant constitut state aid find germani unlawfulli implement aid measur breach articl ec treati measur meet criteria laid guidelin aid rescu restructur firm difficulti consid compat common market pursuant articl ec treati restructur plan submit realist restor viabil compani privat investor contribut commiss ask germani recov aid recipi adopt decis articl state aid implement germani technisch glaswerk ilmenau gmbh form convers secur dem eur purchas price loan thüringer aufbaubank worth dem eur incompat common market articl germani measur recov recipi aid refer articl unlawfulli made recipi recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date dispos recipi date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj oj oj repres busi secret panorama eu industri vol ch report stand committe ec glass industri cpiv annual report bundesverband glasindustri und mineralfaserindustri oj oj tha scheme sg tha scheme sg sg outlin plan joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur measur scheme qualifi region invest aid articl ec treati approv commiss exempt laid articl ec treati sg investitionszulagengesetz invest allow law sg measur law qualifi region invest aid articl ec treati approv commiss exempt laid articl ec treati oj case spain commiss ecr nn sg oj point guidelin state quot commiss examin compat common market rescu restructur aid grant authoris basi guidelin forc time aid grant quot oj