commiss decis decemb grant spain aid coal industri notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european coal steel commun regard commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid coal industri articl articl thereof letter novemb march letter march fax date septemb spain notifi commiss pursuant articl decis ecsc financi support intend grant coal industri commiss request letter date novemb april juli spain addit inform letter date june august march commiss spain letter letter formal notic request inform situat instal undertak mina de lier sa oper result spain repli letter august commiss request inform septemb spain notifi commiss letter octob product cost undertak letter date march spain notifi commiss pursuant articl decis ecsc amount aid paid coal product year pursuant decis ecsc commiss rule financi measur relat aid esp million eur cover oper loss coal undertak aid esp million eur cover except welfar aid paid worker lose job result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ coal industri aid esp million eur cover technic cost close mine instal result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ coal industri financi measur propos spain coal industri fall provis articl decis ecsc commiss decis measur accord articl decis commiss assess depend complianc measur gener criteria object laid articl specif criteria establish articl decis compat proper function common market addition accord articl decis commiss conduct assess check measur conform modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan commiss approv decis ecsc ii decis ecsc commiss gave opinion conform phase plan notifi spain modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct coal industri gener specif object decis ecsc commiss find request spain decis ecsc quot mine hunosa mina de lier sa close definit decemb quot compli date letter date march commiss start pre litig procedur letter formal notic order examin failur compli closur date reason pai aid cover product cost januari closur date commiss analys measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ spanish coal undertak notifi found analysi made measur refer recit correspond plan approv decis ecsc tonn tonn coal equival tce spain coal product receipt aid lower product figur tonn tce lower number worker undertak fell end end reduct worker forecast instal total product capac million tonn year state process close reduc activ phase spain modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan reduct larger initi envisag due inclus activ reduct plan conform articl decis ecsc undertak unabl meet condit entitl oper aid articl decis letter octob request commiss decis ecsc spain notifi commiss undertak product cost commiss analysi trend product cost undertak product unit receipt oper aid articl decis ecsc reveal reduct cost product price ecu tce eur tce reduct break reduct product product product product ut terral ubeda sa undertak product unit maría group minero siderúrgica de ponferrada sa escand group coto minero del sil sa picardín pontedo arba group uminsa tre amigo mine hunosa close antracita de gillón sa coto minero jove sa jovesa industri comerci minera sa incomisa mina de la camocha sa hullera del nort sa mina de escucha sa promotora de mina de carbón sa mina escob sl mina de valdeloso sl virgilio rieso sa undertak underground product unit endesa encasur includ closur activ reduct plan closur latest undertak product unit equival tonn year total capac tonn year commiss check condit laid articl decis ecsc achiev undertak product unit qualifi activ reduct aid accord articl decis period spain continu monitor product cost trend coal undertak receipt oper aid prove unabl achiev downward trend product cost stipul articl decis ecsc spain propos requisit correct measur commiss aid notifi spain cover oper loss reduct product aid compar current currenc valu reduct achiev object digress aid aid articl decis ecsc intend cover part differ product cost sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market accord decis ecsc aid spain plan grant coal industri decis enter nation region local public budget part aid hunosa channel sepi sociedad estat de participacion industrial undertak part view commiss examin hunosa failur compli special condit laid instal mina de lier sa constitut abus aid call question compat aid previous grant decis ecsc measur notifi spain deem line gener object modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan approv commiss decis ecsc iii aid esp million eur spain plan grant coal industri intend compens full part oper loss sustain coal undertak intend cover differ product cost sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market sum notifi subdivid oper aid esp million eur articl decis ecsc activ reduct aid esp million eur oper aid esp million eur intend cover oper loss undertak combin envisag product tonn commiss note verifi product cost undertak downward trend product cost price observ period continu reduct envisag compar price product cost price undertak receiv aid articl decis ecsc eur tce broken product cost eur tce product cost eur tce product cost eur tce product cost eur tce sell price thermal power station tonn tce product envisag undertak receipt oper aid articl decis ecsc esp tce eur tce light envisag cost product esp tce eur tce commiss note aid notifi correspond differ cost product sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market notif spain aid paid gonzalez díez sa undertak receiv aid esp esp cover except cost result reduct activ accord articl decis ecsc acquisit undertak mina de la camocha sa commiss analys manag report undertak found aid purpos authoris oper aid type provid articl decis ecsc commiss find aid enter undertak account quot oper revenu quot identif cost intend cover letter octob decemb april juli commiss ask spain inform justifi activ reduct cost gonzalez díez sa undertak justifi cost letter receiv spain date decemb june context commiss reserv opinion decis amount oper aid equival amount aid examin commiss cover undertak except cost aid reduc activ total esp million eur intend cover oper loss undertak includ closur action reduct plan conform articl decis ecsc hunosa esp million eur mina de la camocha sa esp million eur endesa esp million eur underground work encasur esp million eur antracita de guillón esp million eur coto minero jove sa esp million eur industri comerci minera sa incomisa esp million eur mina escob sl esp million eur mina de escucha sa esp million eur mina de valdeloso sl esp million eur promotora de mina de carbón sa esp million eur virgilio riesco sa esp million eur remain sum esp million eur intend undertak reduc product capac total product cover aid reduc activ tonn annual capac aid esp million eur hunosa esp million eur grant sepi consolid balanc sheet undertak form part sepi hunosa compens group tax credit receiv result lower compani tax case aid authoris hunosa decis reduc compens receiv tax credit compani tax consolid balanc sheet undertak part sepi letter spain commiss inform mina de lier sa undertak hunosa letter spain enclos report hunosa show produc tce tce tce receiv state aid cover oper loss commiss ask decis ecsc june commiss believ mina de lier oper loss period higher notifi hunosa includ cost labour capit servic notif commiss opinion oper loss forese amount esp million ask spain addit inform commiss analys hunosa failur compli condit basi decis mina de lier constitut abus aid call question compat aid previous grant decis ecsc letter august spain inform commiss mina de la camocha sa repaid esp million total esp million commiss authoris undertak decis ecsc june paid anticip authoris commiss letter date august spain inform commiss take action obtain repay aid accord articl decis ecsc payment consid unjustifi cash advanc liabl charg market rate payabl recipi commiss consid amount reimburs interest rate esp million amount repaid mina de la camocha sa commiss reserv decis amount activ reduct aid undertak esp million sell price thermal power station tonn tce product envisag undertak receipt aid reduc activ esp tce eur tce light envisag cost product esp tce eur tce commiss note aid notifi correspond differ cost product sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market aid cover oper loss sustain coal undertak enter gener state budget lower aid authoris commiss spain notif spanish council minist resolut compani compani alloc aid resolut publish spain boletín ofici del estado español inclus measur modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan notifi spain reduct aid quantiti envisag line object indent articl decis ecsc object solv social region problem creat develop coal industri aid esp million mina de la camocha sa esp million gonzález díez sa esp million hunosa basi inform provid spain aid propos compat articl decis ecsc proper function common market commiss decid date balanc esp million analys inform receiv spain repli question iv aid esp million eur spain propos grant intend cover except cost payment social welfar benefit born state special contribut pursuant articl treati compens paid worker spanish coal undertak lost job earli retir modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan spanish coal industri part aid total esp million eur grant hunosa cover cost worker earli retir januari worker retir part aid grant hunosa sepi remain esp million eur intend cover compens worker undertak earli retir end result modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct measur aid design cover except cost arisen due aris restructur enter gener state budget financi measur relat action made modernis rationalis restructur spanish coal industri consid relat current product inherit liabil pursuant articl decis ecsc aid mention explicitli annex decis cost pai social welfar benefit result pension worker reach statutori retir ag except expenditur worker lose job result restructur rationalis consid compat common market provid amount paid exce cost view basi inform provid spain aid compat articl decis ecsc proper function common market aid esp million eur spain propos grant intend cover loss fix asset coal undertak close total partial except cost enabl undertak cover cost arisen due aris progress closur connect restructur coal industri part aid total esp million eur grant hunosa sepi remain sum total esp million eur grant undertak restructur reduc activ aid cover except cost aris due aris restructur enter gener state budget financi measur relat action made modernis rationalis restructur spanish coal industri consid relat current product inherit liabil pursuant articl decis ecsc aid mention explicitli annex decis except intrins depreci provid result restructur industri take account revalu occur januari exce rate inflat addit work residu cost aris closur instal consid compat common market provid amount paid exce cost spain ensur aid grant undertak cover except cost line categori cost annex decis ecsc commiss ask spain inform part esp million plan grant hunosa intend cover cost close instal mina de lier sa undertak spain grant aid closur instal grant aid purpos commiss decid date amount esp million eur consid amount propos spain cover cost close mina de lier sa spain inform commiss intent grant esp eur gonzález díez sa cover cost reduc annual product capac tonn gonzález díez sa show aid grant purpos compli articl decis ecsc commiss ask spain inform intend purpos aid plan grant sum esp million hunosa esp million gonzález díez sa basi inform provid spain aid compat articl decis ecsc proper function common market commiss decid balanc esp million date analys inform receiv spain repli question vi aid grant spain coal industri restrict coal product destin electr product spain undertak ensur coal sold industri domest sector sold price exempt compens cover cost product spain ensur aid grant current product decis give rise discrimin coal produc purchas user commun coal market spain ensur accord indent articl decis ecsc aid cover differ cost product sell price tonn sell price commun coal lower coal similar qualiti member countri spain ensur framework provis articl treati aid limit strictli light social region consider characteris declin commun coal industri aid give econom advantag directli indirectli product aid authoris activ distinct coal product spain ensur aid grant undertak articl decis ecsc cover technic cost closur undertak aid current product articl decis closur capac aid intend definit carri optimum condit safeti environment protect accord indent articl articl decis ecsc commiss verifi aid authoris current product respond exclus object state articl decis spain notifi commiss june amount aid paid declar correct made amount origin notifi submit annual statement aid paid spain suppli commiss inform verif criteria set articl question approv aid commiss recognis soften social region impact restructur coal industri econom social situat surround mine affect view basi inform provid spain aid measur propos coal industri compat object decis ecsc proper function common market adopt decis articl spain authoris pai aid respect oper aid esp eur articl decis ecsc commiss decid date outstand amount esp eur paid gonzález díez sa aid reduct activ esp eur articl decis ecsc commiss decid date outstand sum esp million eur hullera del nort sa hunosa esp million eur mina de la camocha sa authoris aid esp deduct compens hunosa receiv tax credit compani tax consolid balanc sheet undertak incorpor sepi aid esp million eur articl decis essc cover except welfar aid worker lose job result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ spanish coal industri aid esp million eur articl decis essc cover technic cost close mine instal result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ spanish coal industri commiss decid date outstand amount esp million paid hunosa esp million paid gonzález díez sa articl accord articl ecsc treati spain adopt measur gener ensur fulfil oblig result decis ensur aid authoris purpos intend unspent overestim incorrectli aid item cover decis repaid articl spain notifi commiss june latest amount aid paid respect articl decis address kingdom spain brussel decemb commiss loyola de palacio vice presid oj oj oj oj boe