council regul ec novemb impos definit countervail duti import polyest textur filament yarn pty origin india termin proceed import pty origin indonesia council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec octob protect subsidis import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur commiss regul ec hereinaft refer quot provision regul quot provision countervail duti impos import commun polyest textur filament yarn hereinaft refer quot pty quot fall cn code origin india subsidi amount establish indonesia de minimi provision countervail duti impos countri simultan commiss impos regul ec provision anti dump duti import pty origin india recal investig period subsidis injuri cover period octob septemb ip cleric error found provision regul confirm show tabl examin trend relev injuri analysi cover period januari octob state provision regul end ip period consider choic period made view analys evolut econom situat commun industri impact imposit anti dump measur indonesia malaysia taiwan thailand subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision measur interest parti submit comment write accord articl regul ec hereinaft refer quot basic regul quot interest parti request hear grant opportun heard commiss commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit countervail duti definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur addit verif visit carri commiss provision stage compani unifi textur yarn commun produc pty locat ireland visit imposit provision measur oral written argument submit parti consid provision find modifi product consider product indian export produc claim commiss analysi consider exist market segment pty commun allegedli evidenc significantli level averag sale price pty origin india countri pty produc commun industri export produc confirm fact commun industri averag price ip higher indian import price allegedli indic pty produc commun alik respect pty origin india recal provision establish signific differ exist basic physic characterist type qualiti pty circumst type pty consid singl product purpos proceed provision conclud pty produc india export commun share similar basic physic characterist compar manufactur commun produc consid product mean articl basic regul respect differ sale price consid criterion determin product addit concern argument market segment evid brought forward found clear divid line base object criteria support conclus import india product produc commun industri product sale price consid suffici element establish market segment view dump subsidis practic differ product type found involv price element account undercut injuri elimin level calcul explain recit reason argument reject conclus pty consid singl product analysi made level confirm absenc comment definit product consider product set recit provision regul confirm subsidi india sampl investig subsidis india conduct accord articl basic regul imposit provision countervail duti comment sampl indian export produc receiv conclus set recit provision regul confirm duti entitl passbook scheme depb post export basi disclosur provision find export produc associ repres industri india argu compani stop depb licenc ip scheme countervail compani compani challeng find depb scheme post export basi ip scheme india benefit depb scheme calcul basi credit grant licenc utilis transfer sold ip claim compani stop receiv depb licens shift scheme ip chang fact utilis sold depb licenc ip scheme compani conclud compani receiv benefit depb scheme ip reason conclud compani benefit scheme futur export produc claim depb benefit purpos purchas raw materi product product concern regard countervail subsidi note provision find depb scheme permit remiss drawback scheme mean annex ii iii basic regul export oblig consum good import free duti product process amount credit calcul relat actual input good import credit sold domest market addit licens freeli sold investig shown compani sold depb licens ip conclud depb benefit compani countervail subsidi export produc claim benefit confer depb scheme post export basi limit depb amount licenc grant export product concern pty fact licenc kind import transfer alloc full benefit product licenc grant product product concern import input enter directli indirectli product pty alloc benefit depb post export basi total export turnov ip confirm recit provision regul export produc claim number allow relat hypothet cost tax reduct interest exchang loss mean articl basic regul cost necessarili incur order qualifi obtain subsidi deduct total subsidi respect hypothet allow claim export elig deduct amount countervail subsidi establish conclus find set recit provision regul confirm export promot capit good scheme epcg export produc claim epcg benefit alloc total turnov export domest consider capit good obtain scheme domest export product note epcg subsidi scheme conting law export perform mean articl basic regul licenc obtain commit export good find challeng export subsidi duti exempt capit good acquir scheme alloc export turnov export produc claim calcul epcg benefit limit invest product product concern pty epcg licenc obtain export produc produc product concern pty produc product polyest orient yarn poi main input enter product pty poi produc unit sold finish product product product imposs establish account compani capit good proport product pty conclud full benefit epcg licenc compar total export turnov determin subsidi amount find set recit provision regul confirm amount countervail subsidi imposit provision countervail duti cleric error detect total subsidi amount establish cooper compani includ sampl ad valorem subsidi amount establish recit provision regul respect cooper compani includ sampl associ repres industri india claim genuin weight averag subsidi amount investig compani de minimi threshold quot proceed termin accord consist ec case law quot set recit provision regul subsidi amount establish export produc india rang subsidi amount compani found de minimi threshold india countrywid weight averag subsidi amount take account subsidi amount establish recit provision regul de minimi threshold reason termin proceed india subsidi amount establish recit provision regul find confirm gt tabl gt ii indonesia imposit provision measur comment receiv find de minimi subsidi amount respect indonesia find recit provision regul confirm proceed indonesia termin definit commun industri shortli imposit provision measur dupont sa cooper commun produc includ definit commun industri provision stage definit ceas product pty commun allegedli low price import commun market view definit natur event consid longer treat dupont sa part commun industri determin definit find consid commun industri defin consist remain cooper commun produc unifi textur yarn sinterama spa verifi compani account major proport commun product set articl basic regul found cumul product remain cooper commun produc repres total commun product product commun ip threshold set abovement articl compani constitut commun industri full accord articl basic regul indian export produc argu provision injuri analysi base situat minor proport commun produc base alleg fact complain commun produc cooper investig repres major proport commun product argument incorrect reject remain compani repres commun product confirm cooper commun produc constitut commun industri mean articl articl basic regul injuri commun consumpt absenc inform provision find commun consumpt recit provision regul confirm period consider commun consumpt develop gt tabl gt subsidis import india gt tabl gt absolut term indian import volum tripl period consider tonn tonn ip note period ip time commun consumpt decreas indian import volum doubl indian import increas share commun market ip parallel rapid increas import volum ip market share rose commun consumpt decreas averag import price concern increas period subsequ decreas lowest price level reach year absenc comment volum price import india provision find recit provision regul confirm price undercut view mention constitut commun industri calcul revis methodolog calcul undercut margin explain recit provision regul remain unchang recal purpos analys price undercut price type pty origin india compar price similar type produc sold commun industri comparison averag price suggest indian export produc consider exist product type lead mislead result basi revis price undercut margin express percentag commun industri price rang export produc cooper investig view fact subsidi amount establish indian export produc found de minimi threshold commiss analys exclus subsidis import significantli alter conclus basi found level increas subsidis indian import compar absolut volum rel term doubl ip specif drop doubl year end ip averag import price concern trend period consider increas indian import price significantli undercut commun industri price ip conclud import compani de minimi injuri margin establish exclud purpos analysi conclus thereof remain similar situat commun industri abovement exclus cooper commun produc definit commun industri provision establish injuri indic revis data show evolut injuri indic period consider pertain remain cooper commun produc confidenti reason commun industri consist commun produc figur index product product capac capac utilis gt tabl gt commun industri product volum increas period consider note major increas place year product volum unsteadi curv reach ip level compar level reach product capac establish basi theoret maximum hourli output machin instal multipli annual theoret work hour mainten similar product interrupt increas product capac develop step increas place increas note commun industri product volum increas compar extent period result stabl high level capac utilis increas occur end ip product capac rose period product level remain stabl explain decreas capac utilis rate stock gt tabl gt decreas level stock period explain signific increas sale volum compar product volum period level stock increas due signific decreas sale volum product slightli increas sale volum market share growth gt tabl gt commun industri sale volum increas period consider reach peak year increas compar decreas subsequ period period commun industri sale volum increas significantli compar evolut consumpt commun subsequ decreas mark decreas demand pty observ commun ip explain fact market share constantli decreas indian export produc claim commiss account market share evolut commun produc period consider market share evolut commun industri shown increas market share note articl basic regul determin injuri materi injuri commun industri determin injuri limit econom situat cooper commun produc constitut commun industri defin recit tabl recit show market share commun produc decreas signific extent period consider fact role commun produc evalu context question causat argument reject sale price gt tabl gt averag commun industri sale price remain stabl decreas subsequ period recal comparison price compar product type sold commun market ip establish margin undercut profit gt tabl gt commun industri profit express term return net sale commun market fell sharpli period consider posit level signific neg level ip invest abil rais capit gt tabl gt level invest high year relat increas product capac ip invest extrem limit comparison year commun industri abil rais capit extern provid financ parent compani affect begin period consider regard level loss ip abil rais capit jeopardis ip return invest gt tabl gt return net asset express profit percentag total asset commun industri consid case adequ indic evolut return net asset consist profit figur show clear deterior financi situat commun industri subsequ year indian export produc question level return net asset basi respect price develop pty main raw materi produc pty poi argu averag pty sale price increas purchas price poi result posit develop return net asset firstli note period ip averag price pty poi develop similarli consider element cost materi cost manufactur element verifi account establish profit return invest period consider evolut asset consid respect argument reject cash flow gt tabl gt figur cash flow confirm deterior financi situat commun industri remain posit period consider reach peak peak relat cash inflow signific number sale transact record year cash employ wage product gt tabl gt number employe increas period consider employ cost increas period product decreas period consider recoveri past dump period financi result commun industri satisfactori show partial recov impact dump import origin countri anti dump measur impos ip view increas indian subsidis import situat commun industri precari actual margin subsidi definit margin subsidi signific volum price subsidis import impact margin subsidi consid neglig conclus injuri provision conclus commun industri suffer materi injuri ip mean articl basic regul confirm precari situat commun industri appar period subsequ year commun industri product volum increas capac utilis rate high sale volum increas sale price remain stabl industri profit term return net turnov return total asset cash flow posit commun industri posit increas invest number employe cash flow remain favour period posit develop explain combin posit effect introduct anti dump measur indonesia thailand taiwan malaysia restor fair trade commun market expans commun consumpt pty situat commun industri start significantli deterior product volum remain stabl product capac utilis decreas percentag point sale volum decreas sale price decreas commun industri start incur signific loss level invest affect indian export produc argu detail injuri indic develop posit period consider point injuri firstli note accord articl basic regul econom factor list articl necessarili give decis guidanc commun industri suffer materi injuri importantli true econom situat commun industri improv period figur conclus show subsequ period strong deterior situat commun industri materi injuri suffer commun industri ip argument reject conclus commun industri suffer materi injuri confirm causat introduct accord articl basic regul examin materi injuri suffer commun industri defin recit caus subsidis import india accord articl basic regul commiss examin factor injur commun industri order ensur injuri caus factor wrongli attribut subsidis import effect subsidis import ip volum import origin india tripl tonn tonn increas step time rais period ip rais tonn tonn increas tonn note increas place commun market expand occur time commun consumpt face signific downturn tonn period ip commun industri sale volum decreas observ rel term indian market share increas ip rais occur phase ip year indian import price reach low level euro tonn averag decreas compar previou year compar mean low price polici posit increas sale volum regain lost market share ip price reach level averag lower level year recal ip signific undercut margin establish rang show strong price pressur exert indian import ip market share ip level price undercut signific neg impact transpar depress commun market product extrem price sensit time commun industri experienc market share decreas percentag point percentag point ip decreas light commun industri price develop lower price year compar order maintain posit market recal year indian import price decreas commun industri price remain stabl level suffici maintain posit financi situat unlik indian commun industri posit improv averag sale price commun period ip period spite increas indian import commun industri develop favour fair trade expand commun market restor imposit anti dump duti import pty origin countri onward financi situat commun industri significantli deterior explain sale volum price start decreas profit return invest cash flow affect coincid period indian price significantli decreas import volum start significantli increas doubl import volum period ip effect factor import origin countri addit inform comment brought forward interest parti conclus drawn recit provision regul import origin indonesia taiwan contribut injuri suffer commun industri ip confirm transpar market signific import low price pty countri origin injuri commun industri degre consid materi impact indian import quantifi compar impact import indonesia taiwan signific increas indian import period ip absolut rel term indian averag import price ip averag lower indonesian taiwanes import price import partli subject anti dump duti circumst conclud impact indian import import impact indonesian taiwanes import genuin substanti link import india precari situat commun industri import remain countri absenc comment provision conclus import consid injuri effect commun industri confirm subsidis import view fact subsidi amount establish indian export produc found de minimi threshold commiss examin import caus injuri commun industri parallel anti dump proceed import pty origin india definit conclud refer definit anti dump regul import specif indian produc dump caus injuri commun industri affect conclus subsidis import india caus injuri commun industri commun produc tabl base inform receiv compani contain complaint show evolut sale volum market share commun produc gt tabl gt data commun produc sale volum pty period ip significantli decreas absolut rel term addit recal signific proport commun produc part origin complain compani posit fulli cooper present investig due lack resourc fulli support proceed total partial cooper similar recent proceed conclud commun produc contribut injuri suffer commun industri ip invest commun industri interest parti argu heavi invest made commun industri period consider caus deterior financi situat explain invest made commun industri relat increas product capac capac increas made time commun consumpt expand commun industri increas product volum posit increas sale volum line expans commun market view posit develop commun industri expand product capac time ip increas amount tonn time commun industri increas product sale volum order fill newli instal capac capac utilis rate significantli decreas pty industri capit intens fix cost signific decreas product sale volum period ip direct neg impact financi situat commun industri note price main raw materi remain stabl period capac increas period ip neg impact financi situat commun industri occur coincid decreas product sale volum commun industri decreas caus pressur commun market indian import pty commun consumpt decreas tonn period ip indian import volum pty increas tonn period aggress price behaviour indian import price pty significantli undercut commun industri price ip relev import volum increas extent commun industri increas limit decreas sale product volum limit neg impact instal capac consid cost relat invest increas instal capac neg impact financi situat commun industri period ip impact exacerb fact commun industri decreas sale product volum sale price turn due pressur low price indian import volum doubl period commun consumpt decreas clear absenc subsidis import india commun industri maintain sale price level increas volum product sale led economi scale fair trade circumst commun industri absorb addit fix cost relat invest contract demand whilst commun consumpt increas period consid decreas period ip decreas trend coincid decreas commun industri sale volum firstli note commun industri sale volum proportion decreas commun consumpt period import origin india doubl exclud contract demand injuri effect situat commun industri consid minor comparison effect subsidis import global econom downturn indian export produc claim commun industri suffer injuri due world global econom downturn end consider quantifi purpos causat analysi firstli note analysi show econom situat commun industri start deterior end year global econom downturn expect oper commun similarli affect time market indian export produc manag significantli increas sale volum commun explain commun industri sale volum decreas proportion commun consumpt addit impact global downturn reflect mention contract demand view exclud econom downturn impact situat commun industri conclud comparison price depress impact subsidis import minor import export perform commun industri indian export produc argu loss commun industri market share due fact opt export sale domest sale commun industri increas export volum show competit market fair trade prevail recal export volum quadrupl period consider remain margin compar total sale commun industri final note profit commun industri establish refer sale commun market absenc comment head conclus recit provision regul confirm price raw materi comment receiv respect conclus recit provision regul price raw materi commun industri respons injuri suffer commun industri confirm argument rais interest parti indian export produc argu decreas product volum ip attribut deliber shutdown plant commun produc constitut commun industri investig show closur plant ip produc question confirm plant shutdown place argu reduct product volum ip due effect increas low price pty commun market argument reject conclus causat conclus confirm subsidis import injuri effect commun industri period ip situat characteris decreas sale volum depress sale price loss market share signific deterior financi situat notabl term profit return invest period indian import volum significantli increas absolut rel term price found significantli undercut commun industri price factor examin import origin countri commun produc sale invest commun industri contract demand global econom downturn price raw materi export perform commun industri found factor injuri effect situat commun industri effect factor worsen signific neg effect situat commun industri caus surg import origin india isol caus materi injuri commun industri analysi properli distinguish separ effect factor effect situat commun industri injuri effect subsidis import ensur injuri caus factor attribut subsidis import confirm effect factor alter fact exist genuin substanti relationship effect subsidis import materi injuri suffer commun industri commun interest view event place determin provision find plant shutdown dupont sa examin conclus injuri subsidis compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest impos definit countervail measur commun industri commun produc explain provision regul reason doubt viabil competit commun industri situat normal market condit appli fact show absenc fair trade condit exist commun industri jeopardis unfair trade commun market result shutdown dupont sa surviv current depress situat market measur impos exclud commun produc experi develop recal fact commun produc posit cooper investig proceed fulli support commun produc repres commun product explain commun produc market share sale volum commun market erod provision conclus interest commun industri commun produc impos measur confirm import repli receiv import trader provision stage provision regul conclud imposit measur significantli affect situat absenc comment provid interest parti imposit provision measur conclus confirm supplier raw materi absenc comment provision conclus interest upstream industri impos measur confirm user provision stage user cooper absenc comment reaction subsequ imposit provision measur conclus imposit measur prejudici viabil competit user confirm conclus impos countervail measur endang exist commun industri commun produc reinforc fact unfair trade condit prevail commun market commun produc recent shutdown plant commun contrari definit measur impos continu declin profit commun industri observ period consider jeopardis risk pty plant closur commun view commiss conclud compel reason exist impos definit countervail measur definit action view conclus reach subsidi injuri causat commun interest consid definit countervail measur order prevent injuri caus commun industri subsidis import india injuri elimin level purpos establish level measur definit impos confirm price subsidis import increas injuri level indian export produc claim level profit order calcul injuri price arbitrarili chosen base highest profit margin observ period consider recal level profit consid calcul injuri price correspond level commun industri expect achiev absenc injuri dump year consid reason choic refer deem year import india depress effect commun industri price import countri subject measur level similar prevail ip fact commun produc exclud definit commun industri profit figur establish period consider alter provision find industri fair market condit expect reach level profit absenc dump subsidis import methodolog establish injuri elimin level recit provision regul confirm relat price undercut margin injuri margin likewis review amend form level duti subsidi amount found lower injuri elimin margin definit countervail duti rate impos correspond subsidi amount establish accord articl basic regul gt tabl gt individu compani countervail duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countrywid duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani countervail duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti commiss consult advisori committe amend regul updat list compani benefit individu duti rate collect provision duti view amount countervail subsidi found export produc light serious injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision countervail duti regul ec definit collect extent rate definit duti impos rate provision duti lower adopt regul articl definit countervail duti impos import polyest textur filament yarn pty fall cn code origin india rate definit countervail duti applic net free commun frontier price duti product produc compani gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision countervail duti import pty origin india pursuant regul ec collect rate duti definit impos rate provision duti lower amount secur excess definit rate countervail duti releas articl anti subsidi proceed import pty origin indonesia termin articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel novemb council presid bendtsen oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj european commiss brussel