commiss decis octob extens authoris germani invest premium invest project länder grant pursuant financ law mitteldeutsch erdöl raffineri gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis background procedur mitteldeutsch erdöl raffineri gmbh hereinaft refer mider subsidiari french compani elf aquitain sa elf form juli view construct refineri leuna saxoni anhalt leuna project decis novemb commiss approv invest premium invest project territori gdr invest premium law investitionszulagengesetz hereinaft refer invzulg articl invzulg state qualifi premium invest project start decemb juli complet januari project fulli complet period applic requir repai sum receiv invest premium decis june commiss declar packag aid construct refineri leuna project compat common market includ aid eur million dem million form invest premium main part decis read quot except addit invest aid dem million aid grant base accord exist aid scheme approv commiss investitionszulagengesetz nn fördergebietsgesetz gemeinschaftsaufgab verbesserung der regionalen wirtschaftsstruktur nn quot quot take consider posit situat prospect refineri industri commun grow demand fuel distil länder benefici impact refineri develop hall region fact plan aid grant pursuant approv aid scheme addit invest aid dem million exce cumul ceil construct aid project consid compat common market articl ec treati quot decis octob commiss authoris grant addit aid leuna project articl invzulg amend articl financ law jahressteuergesetz provis qualifi premium invest project complet januari prolong deadlin elig invest year modifi relev period aid invest start financ law enter forc januari letter decemb germani belatedli notifi commiss amend decis juli notifi germani juli commiss initi procedur articl ec treati respect articl financ law call germani member state interest parti submit comment germani elf submit comment letter septemb octob octob franc respond view express elf decemb juli commiss german author meet discuss matter octob commiss termin procedur adopt final neg decis decis consid extens articl financ law period complet invest qualifi premium constitut addit state aid undertak made invest länder state aid promot addit invest regard oper aid intend increas capit undertak concern rule possibl appli derog articl ec treati ground oper aid benefit exclus economi länder decis oper part read quot articl articl financ law amend articl invest premium law effect invest premium grant invest project begun decemb juli complet januari januari introduc addit state aid undertak made invest länder aid unlaw put effect disregard articl ec treati aid incompat common market contribut achiev object refer articl ec treati articl articl financ law repeal germani recov aid grant pursuant provis aid repaid accord procedur provis german law interest run date grant aid calcul basi rate serv refer interest rate assess region aid programm articl germani inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli herewith articl decis address feder republ germani quot decis commiss state quot comment prejudic individu notif germani measur modifi aid packag mider invest eastern germani amend examin commiss regard special circumst invest posit decis commiss project quot letter march germani inform commiss decis put effect articl law develop germani financi centr gesetz zur weiteren entwicklung de finanzplatz deutschland result financ law repeal measur enter forc march tax author länder sought repay sum paid investor unabl complet project januari land saxoni anhalt demand mider decis decemb repay invest premium grant year amount eur million dem million interest eur million mider appeal deposit amount block account complaint lodg court instanc januari mider legal action commiss decis octob decemb settlement reach elf mider bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben successor treuhand privatis agenc hereinaft refer bv waiv mutual claim result privatis leuna project settlement provid payment eur million dem million bv eur million dem million land saxoni anhalt germani notifi commiss settlement januari march commiss adopt decis find settlement element state aid mean articl ec treati payment eur million bv concern respect payment eur million land saxoni anhalt intend compens part invest premium receiv commiss consid measur constitut state aid declar compat common market germani undertook leav amount eur million block account commiss final decis procedur leuna elf mider judgement court instanc novemb court instanc gave judgement case annul commiss decis octob extens invest premium invest project länder pursuant financ law concern mider main find judgement quot observ final fact formal commiss notifi aid scheme prevent examin applic case make gener abstract examin scheme similarli decis adopt examin commiss specif applic aid scheme notifi constitut aid declar applic incompat common market exercis wide discret differenti beneficiari aid scheme notifi refer characterist condit satisfi quot point judgement quot present case commiss confin carri gener abstract analysi paragraph financ law oblig examin specif case applic examin requir view featur applic invest project commiss fulli awar administr procedur german govern expressli ask quot point judgement quot document case commiss explan hear show reach conclus commiss distinguish categori potenti beneficiari aid measur question quot point judgement categori consist undertak decid carri invest project länder relianc invest premium start project januari june appli good time part payment premium contrari origin expect end unabl complet project januari contest decis commiss state respect quot undertak invest decis invest premium allow time invest relat risk accept invest aid turn potenti lower met requir laid invzulg risk regard invest profit quot quot extens time limit gener extra invest effect termin invest project begun ask court hear explain detail commiss state respect undertak categori paragraph financ law introduc addit state aid elimin risk undertak complet invest project time limit quot point judgement quot commiss place applic categori undertak present case rule correct definit categori parti differ interpret paragraph invzulg quot point judgement quot applic concern paragraph financ law manifestli introduc addit aid oper aid quot point judgement quot document case show applic embark leuna project take risk complet januari date refer paragraph invzulg version fact allow margin time complet project origin finish juli point delai occur result circumst complet control necessarili envisag decis invest presum applic regard invest project quot profit quot premium quot point judgement quot commiss conclud addit state aid favour applic commiss knew outset precis natur extent applic invest project amount intens aid grant project inter alia decis june find factor remain wholli unchang extens year period complet invest qualifi premium quot point judgement quot event suppos paragraph financ law introduc addit state aid applic justif declar aid incompat common market applic case point commiss rais object system invest premium expressli declar grant aid packag leuna project includ dem million invest premium compat common market articl treati mere extens period carri invest project capabl alter natur scope project amount intens aid packag circumst commiss reason suppos extens distort threaten distort competit greater extent leuna project origin notifi make incompat common market quot point judgement quot forego applic concern commiss consid paragraph financ law introduc addit state aid addit aid introduc compat common market quot point judgement recent develop assess measur regard mider annul commiss decis procedur nn relat mider reopen line judgement court instanc order commiss decis individu case germani letter date juli alter origin notif date decemb financ law result alter notif mider receiv invest premium amount eur million dem million interest eur million dem million notif invest premium mider year aid recipi withdrawn interest payment commiss receiv letter elf date august addit comment germani letter date septemb note regard settlement expressli mider repai bv sum paid invest premium enabl dispos amount greater eur million dem million confirm court instanc point judgement commiss take view articl financ law introduc addit state aid mider commiss decis june approv invest grant amount eur million dem million mider fulfil requir articl invzulg provis entitl invest premium amount eur million amend invzulg pursuant financ law introduc aid mider amend mider entitl receiv invest premium aid approv commiss unlaw conclus germani alter notif regard mider letter date juli notifi aid compris invest premium year amount eur million interest eur million basi modifi notif commiss decid compat modifi amount regard mider conform judgement court instanc case earlier decis novemb june commiss confirm mider invest premium year compat common market total aid intens exce region limit cumul aid land saxoni anhalt adopt decis articl articl financ law amend articl invest premium law extent invest premium futur grant invest begun decemb juli complet januari januari creat addit state aid amount eur million interest eur million favour mider aid measur unlaw implement breach articl ec treati articl invest premium mider year amount eur million interest eur million compat common market articl decis address feder republ germani brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss state aid germani verlängerung der investitionszulag der ddr state aid nn germani privatisierung von leuna minol investitionsbeihilf de land sachsen anhalt oj state aid germani erhöhung einer beihilf de land sachsen anhalt die neue raffineriegesellschaft quot mitteldeutsch erdöl raffineri gmbh quot oj oj commiss decis ec octob extens invest premium invest project länder pursuant financ law oj state aid germani case mitteldeutsch erdöl raffineri gmbh commiss ecr ii commiss declar quot aid grant base accord exist aid scheme approv commiss quot