council regul ec februari amend regul ec impos definit anti dump duti import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin inter alia romania concern import european commun product manufactur petrotub sa republica sa council european union regard treati establish european commun articl thereof regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun basic regul articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur januari court justic european commun ecj judgment case judgment set previou judgment court instanc european commun decemb join case petrotub republica council judgment ecj effect annul council regul ec novemb impos definit anti dump duti import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin hungari poland russia czech republ romania slovak republ definit anti dump regul contest regul concern import commun manufactur petrotub sa republica sa recognis court case proceed consist administr step annul step annul complet proceed anti dump proceed multi step proceed annul part definit anti dump regul impli annul entir procedur prior adopt regul question hand articl treati commun institut oblig compli judgment court justic commun institut compli judgment possibl remedi aspect contest regul led annul leav unchang uncontest part affect judgment judgment notic publish anti dump measur import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin romania announc petrotub sa republica sa longer subject anti dump measur impos definit anti dump regul regul seek correct respect petrotub sa republica sa aspect contest regul found inconsist commun law judgment led annul contest regul find made contest regul contest time limit challeng consid court lead annul contest regul remain valid product consider categori product consider consid definit anti dump regul seamless pipe iron alloi steel kind oil ga pipelin extern diamet exceed mm seamless tube circular cross section iron alloi steel cold drawn cold roll precis tube tube circular cross section iron alloi steel thread threadabl extern diamet exceed mm manufactur petrotub sa republica sa classifi cn code cn code inform assess find base judgment ecj preliminari remark regul aspect judgment address calcul dump margin petrotub sa determin normal republica sa petrotub dump margin recit definit anti dump regul calcul basi comparison weight averag normal establish petrotub sa price individu export consid order reflect full degre dump practis pattern petrotub export price differ significantli purchas region time period establish judgment method set sentenc articl basic regul addit find export pattern differ significantli purchas region time period explain method sentenc articl call quot symmetr method quot differ pattern export price appropri account reflect full degre dump practis definit anti dump regul council duli mention recit pattern differ significantli purchas region time period conclud symmetr method averag averag method reflect full degre dump practis context address symmetr method transact transact method regul reassess correct result investig lead imposit definit anti dump duti import petrotub sa assess applic symmetr method light requir contain judgment symmetr method forese comparison individu normal valu individu export price commun transact transact basi definit anti dump regul sale made republica sa debt compens consid made ordinari trade paragraph judgment ecj held conclus accompani statement reason mere statement recit definit anti dump regul found quot sale made compens made ordinari trade quot explanatori element kind enlighten parti concern reason led council conclus regul statement reason accord articl treati inform order remedi shortcom found ecj definit anti dump regul led annul commiss time adopt definit anti dump regul investig respect petrotub sa republica sa parti requir motiv base exist inform collect framework investig led imposit definit measur dump margin petrotub sa articl basic regul symmetr method base calcul dump margin comparison individu normal valu type product concern individu export price transact transact basi method appli number condit met transact transact comparison exclud definit averag domest sale side export sale side compar transact made dai domest export side deviat principl price transact made dai arbitrari domest export sale relat compar product type transact transact comparison comparison valid domest sale ordinari trade domest sale made ordinari trade quantiti amount volum export transact accord articl basic regul identif sale made ordinari trade level transact made accord articl basic regul symmetr method export price compar construct normal valu final consid method repres suffici larg volum export transact domest sale transact cover basi examin transact transact calcul appli found volum export transact compar amount volum domest sale made ordinari trade determin normal word overwhelm major domest sale consider dump calcul low transact data suffici repres basi regard determin normal benchmark dump analysi export transact basi transact transact method upheld method calcul dump margin case symmetr method provid repres result method enabl account signific differ pattern export price method comparison weight averag normal valu individu export price asymmetr method appli presenc pattern export price found symmetr method enabl differ account normal republica sa explain recit ecj found council satisfi requir oblig state reason recit paragraph contest regul state sale made compens made ordinari trade reason set investig led imposit definit anti dump duti republica sa claim substanti volum domest sale made basi debt compensatori arrang alleg sale price product concern deliv basi compensatori arrang negoti republica sa forc supplier compensatori circuit result sale price supplier consider lower normal price compar normal market price republica sa argu sale basi compensatori arrang disregard domest sale calcul normal consid made ordinari busi underlin payment compensatori agreement recit regul distinguish exist compensatori arrang sens articl basic regul payment compensatori arrang republica sa submiss recit regul found effect settlement bill receiv payabl compens affect price condit good deliv compensatori arrang mean articl basic regul refer agreement good servic swap supplier client invoic price base differ good servic reflect real good deliv site investig republica premis found domest sale wrongli report made subject standard cash payment term found fact settl mean compens compensatori agreement form compens place made net receiv payabl amount republica sa client act case time supplier good servic parti involv case republica sa sell client receiv parti settl debt republica sa type settlement transact compensatori agreement common economi low liquid investig show influenc origin price set transact found republica sa insist cash payment client need cash order pai personnel sale price set lower case payment compensatori agreement order reward client cash payment conclud republica payment compens fall concept compensatori agreement articl basic regul found compensatori agreement republica sa parti influenc sale price quot conclud argument rais republica sa respect sale settl mean compens influenc domest sale price reflect realiti sale made republica sa compensatori arrang made ordinari trade conclus symmetr method determin dump margin petrotub sa warrant volum domest sale determin normal suffici repres make comparison method method account signific differ pattern export price reflect full degre dump symmetr method albeit reason reflect full degre dump practis method provid articl basic regul appli applic result applic detail recit contest regul confirm reason outlin recit sale made republica sa debt compens found made ordinari trade consequ dump margin determin framework regul ec confirm disclosur parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written argument submit parti consid account undertak romanian export produc offer price undertak accord articl basic regul price undertak offer stipul ceas valid januari consequ ecj judgment commiss consid undertak offer accept suffici shield commun industri injuri effect dump compani provid commiss regular detail inform export commun mean undertak monitor effect commiss order ensur effect respect monitor undertak request releas free circul pursuant undertak present relev custom author exempt duti condit present valid origin product certif inform list annex regul product certif present month date issu quantiti present custom import commun free anti dump duti exce stipul certif product certif present correspond product concern quantiti stipul certif exceed amount anti dump duti payabl event suspect breach actual breach withdraw undertak parti anti dump duti impos pursuant articl basic regul adopt regul articl conclus regul ec regard romanian export produc petrotub sa republica sa confirm definit anti dump duti impos import origin romania manufactur petrotub sa republica sa seamless pipe iron alloi steel kind oil ga pipelin extern diamet exceed mm fall cn code taric code seamless tube circular cross section iron alloi steel cold drawn cold roll precis tube fall cn code tube circular cross section iron alloi steel thread threadabl extern diamet exceed mm fall cn code rate definit anti dump duti applic net free commun frontier price duti gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl import exempt anti dump duti impos articl provid produc sold export commun compani list paragraph offer undertak accept commiss provid condit paragraph met declar releas free circul present exempt duti condit present compet member state custom servic valid origin product certif issu compani list paragraph product certif conform requir certif set undertak accept commiss main element list annex product certif refer paragraph present month date issu quantiti present member state custom servic import commun free anti dump duti exce stipul certif quantiti stipul certif exceed excess subject duti declar relev taric addit code articl import accompani product certif declar taric addit code gt tabl gt articl member state report commiss pursuant articl regul ec releas free circul year month import cn taric taric addit code type measur countri origin quantiti anti dump duti member state import serial number product certif articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel februari council presid mccreevi oj regul amend regul ec oj ecr ii oj regul amend regul ec oj ip council ecr ii case ip council ecr oj annex main element product certif refer articl number certif identif show certif origin date expiri certif text quot product certif issu compani pursuant articl council regul ec export european commun taric addit code seamless steel pipe tube quot full address compani identif number nation registr number incorpor compani full address custom compani commun import good full address unrel trader commun export good number compani invoic product certif relat exact descript good includ product descript suffici identifi product ident product descript invoic cn code quantiti metric tonn offici compani respons issu certif sign declar quot undersign certifi sale export european commun good cover certif made scope term undertak compani permit volum anti dump duti free import commun set undertak accept commiss pursuant decis ec declar inform provid certif complet correct quot space compet author commun undertak offer accept commiss box certif languag languag countri produc english french german