council regul ec march impos definit anti dump duti collect definit provision duti impos import sodium cyclam origin peopl republ china indonesia council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun quot basic regul quot articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur septemb commiss impos regul ec provision anti dump duti import commun sodium cyclam origin peopl republ china quot prc quot indonesia quot provision regul quot recal investig period dump injuri cover period octob septemb quot ip quot examin trend relev injuri analysi cover period januari end ip quot period consid quot subsequ procedur imposit provision anti dump duti import sodium cyclam origin prc indonesia interest parti submit comment write parti request grant opportun heard oral explain recit provision regul dump verif visit prc indonesia place provision find made cancel due introduct travel restrict sar notic consequ sar anti dump anti subsidi investig publish offici journal european union commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find travel restrict relat sar lift verif visit carri premis compani export produc relat compani prc hong kong zhong hua fang da limit hong kong fang da food addit shen zhen limit shenzhen prc shanghai shumi shanghai prc rainbow rich industri hong kong golden time enterpris shenzhen shenzhen prc export produc indonesia pt golden sari chemic industri bandar lampung indonesia expiri deadlin comment provision find verif visit indonesian compani made request export produc questionnair order repli compani inform made request questionnair time initi investig inform advanc stage investig inform consid find base fact opportun comment comment consid chang conclus parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit parti consid account definit find product consider product comment product concern product receiv conclus set recit provision regul confirm dump gener methodolog section explain gener methodolog establish import commun product concern dump specif issu rais investig countri concern recit normal cooper export produc indonesia export produc prc market economi treatment quot met quot grant repres domest sale accord articl basic regul examin domest sale sodium cyclam independ custom export produc repres total volum sale total volum export sale commun product type specif repres subsequ examin domest sale export product type consid repres purpos compar type sold domest market identifi investig consid product type sodium cyclam sold domest ident directli compar type sold export commun form defin recit provision regul domest sale product type consid suffici repres total domest sale volum type sold independ custom ip repres total sale volum compar product type export commun ordinari trade test examin domest sale export produc consid made ordinari trade pursuant articl basic regul establish proport domest sale independ custom export product type sold loss domest market ip product type volum sale domest market unit cost weight averag sale price equal higher weight averag product cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price ip paid payabl independ custom type question irrespect sale profit product type volum sale domest market unit cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price made price equal unit cost type question normal base actual domest price requir set recit met normal base product type actual price paid payabl independ custom domest market export countri ip provid articl basic regul export produc prc met pursuant articl basic regul normal export produc grant met establish basi price construct market economi countri analogu countri product export price articl basic regul export price price paid payabl product sold export export countri commun comparison order ensur fair comparison normal export price account accord articl basic regul differ factor claim demonstr affect price price compar basi allow differ transport cost ocean freight insur cost handl load ancillari cost level trade pack cost credit cost commiss discount bank charg grant applic justifi comparison normal export price made factori basi level trade dump margin cooper export produc indonesia export produc prc grant met articl basic regul adjust weight averag normal product type determin recit compar adjust weight averag export price determin recit cooper compani export produc repli questionnair made dump margin establish basi fact accord articl basic regul approach consid respect cooper export produc order prevent cooper export produc benefit cooper level cooper found low consid set countri wide dump margin cooper compani higher level highest dump margin establish cooper compani reason high level cooper result cooper export produc countri concern gener dump higher level cooper export produc countri specif issu rais investig regard establish dump margin countri concern indonesia total export produc cooper investig normal establish domest sale sodium cyclam sole cooper export produc repres ip recit establish sole product type sodium cyclam sold domest market cooper export produc ident sole type sold export commun product type volum sold loss domest market weight averag sale price higher weight averag product cost normal calcul weight averag price domest sale made ip paid payabl independ custom type question set articl basic regul export price export made unrel custom commun export price establish accord articl basic regul basi export price paid payabl ip comparison order ensur fair comparison allow made differ transport cost ocean freight insur cost handl load ancillari cost level trade pack cost credit cost commiss applic justifi export produc claim adjust normal amount import charg indirect tax incom tax born product materi physic incorpor intend consumpt indonesia collect refund respect product export commun compani concern demonstr tax paid refund respect export sale commun tax paid refund includ domest price claim reject disclosur essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti export produc concern claim adjust advertis expens adjust expens repres offic involv domest sale establish export produc includ expens quantif level trade adjust claim earlier level trade adjust grant cover price differ sale channel due function includ advertis sale repres offic order avoid duplic make adjust provid articl basic regul consid grant adjust expens claim reject dump margin definit dump margin express percentag cif commun frontier price duti unpaid pt golden sari chemic industri residu definit dump margin indonesia set higher level dump margin establish cooper compani level cooper indonesia low order establish level cooper volum export commun report cooper export produc compar equival eurostat import statist show level cooper total volum import order calcul residu definit dump margin cooper compani export product type averag import price commun indonesia report eurostat statist adjust ocean freight insur cost compar normal establish cooper export produc adjust freight pack cost residu definit dump margin establish peopl republ china total export produc cooper investig market economi treatment met set recit provision regul met grant export produc prc appli normal export produc grant met verif visit rainbow rich industri mother compani golden time enterpris shenzhen found product sale sodium cyclam ip relat produc compani prc san lian industri situat nanj report questionnair respons subsequ investig met request respect relat compani domest sale inform cost product compani verifi spot verif found report domest sale signific total domest sale relat compani question articl basic regul provision final find made basi fact interest parti refus access provid inform time limit provid basic regul note product cost domest sale inform san lian industri inform order establish normal compar export price establish golden time enterpris shenzhen met grant san lian industri inform domest sale cost product provid verifi investig determin normal golden time enterpris shenzhen base fact parti concern inform consequ partial cooper opportun comment comment confirm san lian industri produc sold domest market ip sodium cyclam behalf mother compani rainbow rich industri detail report conclus establish normal basi fact confirm normal golden time enterpris shenzhen includ domest sale relat compani relat compani consid cooper met grant analogu countri select fact establish normal respect note imposit provision measur comment receiv select indonesia analogu countri set recit provision regul price indonesia consid reason surrog price prc averag domest price cooper indonesian export produc verifi spot verif visit establish normal chines export produc golden time enterpris shenzhen disclosur essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti cooper indonesian export produc indonesian govern argu normal golden time enterpris shenzhen cooper chines export produc recit base data sole cooper indonesian export produc data complaint argu discriminatori data cooper indonesian export produc calcul normal cooper chines export produc dump margin establish chines export produc partial cooper investig found lower cooper indonesian export produc firstli note dump margin result comparison normal export price level dump margin depend paramet normal export price conclus includ abovement discrimin drawn compar paramet normal accord provis articl basic regul determin includ normal base fact fact includ inform suppli complaint check refer offici import statist inform obtain interest parti investig record verifi inform normal obtain sole cooper indonesian export produc consid disregard inform fact inform suppli complaint export produc fang da food addit situat shenzhen yang quan examin domest sale made ordinari trade pursuant articl basic regul sell gener administr expens report fang da food addit relat compani domest sale adjust order account expens record account relat compani zhong hua fang da hong kong verif confirm expens close link oper domest market export activ initi claim compani examin domest sale made ordinari trade carri establish proport domest sale independ custom repres type sold loss domest market ip product type volum sale sold loss domest market weight averag sale price equal higher weight averag product cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price paid payabl independ custom type question product type volum sale domest market unit cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price made price equal unit cost type question export price export produc grant met export sale commun cooper export produc prc made independ custom commun relat compani hong kong investig establish case function relat export sale export produc prc carri relat compani hong kong export price establish pursuant articl basic regul refer price paid payabl relat compani hong kong comparison export produc grant met order ensur fair comparison allow made differ transport insur handl load ancillari cost credit pack discount bank charg applic justifi cooper export produc prc sale commun made relat compani hong kong export price adjust recit order bring factori level prc cooper export produc relat domest sale compani claim adjust domest sale price normal credit cost claim reject compani show written evid agre term payment date sale domest sale invoic correspond dump margin export produc grant met comparison normal export price recit show dump compani fang da food addit situat shenzhen yang quan investig termin compani imposit measur explain recit normal golden time enterpris shenzhen establish price analogu countri indonesia comparison normal export price recit show dump margin dump margin export produc met set recit provision regul signific cooper prc total import report eurostat imposit provision measur comment receiv find prc economi transit price analogu countri establish normal calcul countri wide dump margin reason set recit indonesia analogu countri purpos definit countri wide dump margin applic compani met prc set differ export price calcul basi fact averag import price commun report eurostat statist adjust ocean freight insur cost normal establish indonesia recit definit dump margin prc express percentag cif commun frontier price duti unpaid summaris gt tabl gt commun industri comment receiv imposit provision measur composit commun industri find set recit provision regul confirm injuri imposit provision measur comment receiv analysi commun consumpt find set recit provision regul confirm comment receiv imposit provision measur cumul assess effect import concern definit dump margin affect find set recit provision regul disclosur essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti indonesian govern claim justif cumul export indonesia form prc indonesian export declin substanti ip whilst chines import increas substanti respect investig establish dump import indonesia decreas slightli ip increas period consid fact chines dump import increas faster indonesian dump import period consid justifi cumul assess effect dump import countri investig accord provis articl basic regul comment rais find set recit provision regul claim reject find confirm dump find relat chines export produc recit volum market share dump import reassess dump import deduct import establish recit provision regul evolut volum dump import prc indonesia market share period consid gt tabl gt gt tabl gt dump import increas period consid higher increas notic year ip dump import increas market share dump import increas period consid increas higher year increas notic ip note market share dump import ip substanti reason confidenti precis figur export price report cooper export produc line eurostat import price comment receiv imposit provision measur find set recit provision regul confirm determin price undercut ip methodolog set recit provision regul averag import price cooper indonesian export produc calcul cooper export produc prc indonesia undercut calcul eurostat import price countri price cif level adjust made includ custom duti paid import basi exist price undercut establish dump import prc indonesia level undercut express percentag commun industri averag sell price rang prc found indonesia imposit provision measur written comment receiv situat commun industri conclus injuri chines export produc argu hear commun industri suffer materi injuri period consid product price remain stabl sale commun employ increas note export produc provid evid indic relev find set provision regul accur verifi find product price commun industri decreas period consid put context develop consumpt period consumpt commun increas sale commun industri increas commun industri benefit expand market contrari lost market share employ note increas remain stabl ip increas number employe affect situat commun industri ip employ cost employe increas line inflat period consid conclud argument show commun industri suffer materi injuri ip find set recit provision regul commun industri suffer materi injuri form financi loss confirm causat injuri accord articl basic regul examin dump import sodium cyclam origin prc indonesia caus injuri commun industri degre enabl classifi materi factor dump import time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor attribut dump import written comment causat injuri receiv imposit provision measur chines export produc argu hear import prc injuri commun industri enjoi monopoli situat sodium cyclam export prc indonesia price prc increas period consid sale commun industri decreas period commun industri maintain domin market share argument factual basi investig shown begin period consid import commun held market share commun industri enjoi monopoli situat set recit provision regul price dump import decreas period consid evolut sale commun industri recit explain increas period consumpt increas set recit dump import increas period final market share dump import ip found higher market share commun industri argument accept conclus set recit provision regul confirm export produc argu injuri caus factor commun industri insuffici prepar compet domest foreign market profit affect busi decis invest order maintain state art facil compli legal environ strict environment regul commun industri present high end segment indirectli compet low end segment satisfi import prc chines produc enjoi compar advantag competit commun industri note evid provid support argument commun industri prepar compet domest foreign market investig show reason recit provision regul set reason export perform commun industri contribut significantli injuri suffer contrari signific price undercut dump import recit show import investig main injuri commun industri claim accept invest note commun industri invest profit posit ip realis loss invest fell sharpli time comparison previou profit year recit provision regul indic invest includ environment purpos contribut injuri suffer ip claim reject regard lack direct competit commun industri import prc investig establish form sodium cyclam export prc commun form produc sold commun market commun industri ip direct competit exist exist substitut form indirect competit exist claim accept alleg chines produc enjoi compar advantag competit commun industri note detail alleg advantag provid consid export produc concern benefit compar advantag enjoi long dump product concern mean basic regul investig establish dump import prc undercut price commun industri ip contribut significantli injuri suffer commun industri find conclus set recit provision regul materi injuri suffer commun industri caus dump import confirm commun interest gener remark comment receiv imposit provision measur find commun interest shortli imposit provision measur raw materi supplier import letter claim commun interest impos measur cooper indonesian export produc commiss examin final conclus exist injuri dump compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest adopt measur case purpos accord articl basic regul impact measur parti involv proceed consequ take measur consid basi evid submit interest commun supplier supplier made shortli imposit provision measur supplier mention recit provision regul alleg sell cyclohexylamin basic raw materi produc sodium cyclam east indonesia claim sole cooper indonesian export produc main client risk lose signific sale volum anti dump duti impos knock effect parti downstream suppli chain note short letter submit time limit set purpos notic initi supplier question provid actual evid substanti claim provid articl basic regul comment submit imposit provision measur disclosur essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti found supplier provid cyclohexylamin commun industri conclud imposit definit measur significantli neg effect busi comment interest supplier receiv conclus set recit provision regul confirm interest import import made shortli imposit provision measur alleg imposit anti dump duti indonesia justifi supplier sole cooper indonesian export produc shown strong commit quot hold price level econom justifi quot claim quot price indonesian produc higher chines result reason market price end user quot import made provid inform time limit set purpos notic initi claim support actual evid substanti relev inform support alleg exist record contrari investig establish price indonesian export produc question lower chines price recit submiss support actual evid account accord articl basic regul substanti comment interest import receiv conclus set recit provision regul confirm interest user comment interest user receiv imposit provision measur conclus set recit provision regul confirm interest commun industri comment interest commun industri receiv imposit provision measur conclus set recit provision regul confirm competit trade distort effect written comment competit trade distort effect receiv imposit provision measur accord articl basic regul export produc consid interest parti framework commun interest analysi chines export produc argu hear commun interest warrant measur imposit provision measur restrict number player export commun market reduc suppli countri concern commun industri satisfi market demand imposit definit measur reinforc domin posit commun industri note aim anti dump measur elimin export commun market restor fair trade condit fact commun industri product meet present commun demand reason unfair trade practis continu note commun industri hold domin posit market share ip true countri produc sodium cyclam commun indonesia prc import prc produc found dump suppli commun market argument accept conclus set recit provision regul confirm conclus commun interest basi conclud imposit definit anti dump measur commun interest definit anti dump measur injuri elimin level base methodolog explain recit provision regul injuri elimin level calcul purpos establish level measur definit impos comment methodolog establish injuri elimin level receiv methodolog confirm averag import price revis final undercut calcul recit definit measur injuri elimin level higher dump margin establish parti concern definit measur base note inform record cooper export produc intend lower price order absorb duti attent drawn articl basic regul stipul investig reopen dump margin recalcul case suffici evid measur led suffici movement price commun intent investig author swiftli proce reinvestig case suffici inform duti absorpt submit addition order ensur effici measur discourag price manipul impos duti form specif amount kilo note eurostat import statist import product concern countri hong kong product sodium cyclam inform record product sodium cyclam exist spain indonesia prc suffici inform circumvent measur submit investig author prepar swiftli initi investig accord articl basic regul basi rate duti equal fix amount kilo sodium cyclam shown tabl gt tabl gt individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countrywid duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti regul amend updat list compani benefit individu duti rate collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found light level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision duti impos regul ec definit collect extent amount duti definit impos present regul amount equal lower amount provision duti amount provision duti definit collect amount secur excess amount definit anti dump duti releas adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import sodium cyclam classifi cn code taric code origin peopl republ china indonesia rate definit anti dump duti applic net free commun frontier price duti gt tabl gt case good damag entri free circul price paid payabl apport determin custom pursuant articl commiss regul eec juli lai provis implement council regul eec establish common custom code amount anti dump duti calcul basi paragraph reduc percentag correspond apport price paid payabl provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision anti dump duti pursuant regul ec import sodium cyclam classifi cn code taric code origin peopl republ china indonesia definit collect accord rule set amount secur excess amount definit anti dump duti releas amount definit anti dump duti higher provision anti dump duti amount secur level provision duti definit collect articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel march council presid ahern oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj octob compani call jintian enterpris nanj european commiss director gener trade director rue de la loi wetstraat brussel oj regul amend commiss regul ec oj