commiss decis novemb nation provis azody notifi germani articl ec treati notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun articl thereof fact letter perman represent feder republ germani european union german govern refer articl ec treati notifi commiss nation provis azody deem maintain adopt direct ec european parliament council juli amend nineteenth time council direct eec relat restrict market danger substanc prepar azocolour commun legisl articl ec treati articl ec treati quot adopt council commiss harmonis measur member state deem maintain nation provis ground major refer articl relat protect environ work environ notifi commiss provis ground maintain quot articl commiss month notif approv reject nation provis involv verifi mean arbitrari discrimin disguis restrict trade member state constitut obstacl function intern market direct ec council direct eec juli approxim law regul administr provis member state relat restrict market danger substanc prepar amend direct ec european parliament council establish rule restrict market danger substanc prepar articl direct appli danger substanc prepar list annex articl member state measur ensur danger substanc prepar list annex market subject condit direct eec amend occas inter alia add danger substanc prepar annex thereto introduc restrict market protect human health environ case restrict market product treat substanc prepar adopt legal basi articl ec treati direct ec european parliament council insert annex direct eec point azocolour lai rule market substanc recit direct recal background direct state quot textil leather articl azody capac releas arylamin pose cancer risk quot quot limit adopt plan member state azodi textil leather articl concern complet function intern market approxim law member state field amend annex council direct eec quot quot scientif committe toxic ecotox environ sctee consult commiss confirm cancer risk pose textil leather good colour azody give concern quot state recit quot order protect human health danger azody place market articl colour dye prohibit quot point azody reduct cleavag azo group releas aromat amin list appendix detect concentr ppm finish articl dy part thereof test method establish accord articl direct textil leather articl direct prolong contact human skin oral caviti cloth bed towel hairpiec wig hat nappi sanitari item sleep bag footwear glove wristwatch strap handbag purs wallet briefcas chair cover purs worn round neck textil leather toi toi includ textil leather garment yarn fabric intend final consum point state quot textil leather articl refer point market conform requir set point quot provid time limit exempt textil articl made recycl fibr previous dy azody addit point septemb commiss light scientif knowledg review provis azocolour accord recit state quot light scientif knowledg provis azocolour review regard includ materi cover direct aromat amin special attent paid risk children quot articl direct member state adopt publish septemb law regul administr provis compli direct forthwith inform commiss thereof appli provis septemb nation provis notifi nation provis notifi feder govern germani introduc ordin amend consum good ordin bedarfsgegenständeverordnung juli ban harm azody group articl prolong contact bodi introduc protect consum health risk fact dye break substanc potenti carcinogen subsect consum good ordin head quot prohibit substanc quot state quot commerci manufactur treatment materi articl set annex emploi substanc mention quot annex deal substanc manufactur process articl point annex list prohibit substanc quot azody form amin break azo group except pigment amin detect method accord procedur annex quot azody emploi manufactur treatment categori product list annex cloth materi manufactur cloth bed linen blanket pillow sleep bag hand towel beach mat air mattress mask hair piec wig artifici eyelash articl jewelleri worn skin armband monei bag rucksack crawl mat cover seat lounger infant small children nappi sanitari towel panti liner tampon ii procedur letter german perman represent european union inform commiss accord articl ec treati feder republ germani intend maintain nation provis azody deviat provid direct ec amend direct eec market azocolour commiss receiv letter letter june commiss inform german govern receiv notif articl ec treati month period examin articl start dai dai notif receiv letter august commiss inform member state notif receiv feder republ germani commiss publish notic notif offici journal european union order inform interest parti nation provis germani intend maintain ground invok effect iii legal assess consider admiss articl concern case nation provis notifi relat commun harmonis measur provis adopt enter forc adopt mainten incompat german notif receiv commiss intend obtain approv mainten nation provis derog direct ec constitut measur approxim law regul administr provis member state aim establish oper intern market adopt basi articl ec treati addit nation provis adopt enter forc adopt direct harmonis field azocolour aros cancer risk pose textil leather good colour azody give concern confirm sctee opinion januari nation legisl ban carcinogen azocolour introduc notifi member state direct ec introduc restrict azocolour ban azody articl danger substanc shown basi suffici data pose risk articl made textil leather establish case law commun measur interpret light object pursu direct ec base articl treati legal basi adopt harmonis measur object establish function intern market clear recit direct main object remov obstacl complet function intern market result limit adopt plan member state azocolour commiss consid direct ec interpret introduc harmonis current azody prevent member state introduc maintain nation restrict azody laid direct compar provis direct ec nation measur notifi germani emerg nation ban azody consid harm health articl differ requir direct ec german provis subsect annex ban azody group articl limit textil leather requir direct ec articl requir notif nation provis accompani descript ground relat major refer articl protect environ work environ requir articl ec treati germani notifi commiss exact word provis set direct ec includ applic short explan reason relat protect consum health opinion justifi mainten provis light forego commiss consid applic submit germani view obtain authoris maintain nation provis azody admiss articl ec treati assess merit accord articl subparagraph ec treati commiss ascertain condit enabl member state maintain nation provis derog commun harmonis measur provid articl fulfil nation provis justifi major refer articl treati relat protect environ work environ mean arbitrari discrimin disguis restrict trade member state constitut obstacl function intern market point court case law consist requir condit grant derog fundament rule commun law interpret restrict provis question creat except principl uniform applic commun law uniti market articl ec treati measur relat derog interpret scope extend case expressli foreseen articl precis express derog interpret strictli appli strict condit regard justif requir burden proof note light time frame establish articl ec treati commiss examin nation measur notifi articl justifi basi quot ground quot put forward notifi member state mean provis ec treati respons prove nation measur justifi li request member state seek maintain procedur framework establish articl ec treati includ strict deadlin decis adopt commiss limit examin relev element submit request member state seek reason justif notifi member state provid ground fact scientif evid authoris make derog member state interest attach notif substant legal element support applic failur includ notif maintain introduc nation provis element lead commiss notif found letter notif german author invok object safeguard consum health commiss check nation provis commensur aim proportion object pursu harmonis measur adopt direct ec basi high level protect accord articl pursu object proportion justif ground major refer articl relat protect environ work environ german posit feder govern intend retain nation ban azody group articl direct prolong contact bodi consist textil leather restrict contain direct ec limit articl made textil leather justifi mainten nation provis german author submit explanatori statement justif german author point quot ban azody harm health articl prolong contact bodi enact feder republ germani protect consum health quot german author state quot point time azody break carcinogen amin quot quot direct contact bodi azody prevent materi articl consum prolong contact made quot feder govern take view danger health azody break harm amin appli dy object produc textil leather materi scientif data germani simpli mention opinion sctee scientif committe toxic ecotox environ opinion quot risk cancer caus textil leather good colour azody quot januari opinion report final draft quot assess risk human health pose azocolour toi write ink paper product analysi advantag drawback restrict market quot june statement posit german author evalu light criteria establish articl opinion sctee germani base request analys sctee opinion commiss recal effect azody assess studi commiss commiss opinion sctee prepar direct ec januari scientif committe toxic ecotox environ sctee deliv opinion conclud cancer risk azody give concern committe confirm azody cleavag form carcinogen amin classifi carcinogen categori addit amin german mak list special concern sctee consid report commiss commiss adequ review situat risk cancer consum result fabric dy azo compound conclus gener accept committe support report recommend azody restrict distinguish amin classifi eu categori ii carcinogen amin classifi mak commiss consid restrict subject prior develop valid analyt methodolog line recommend direct ec ban danger azocolour place market textil leather articl colour substanc shown basi suffici data pose risk germani reli sctee opinion restrict azody materi textil leather sctee opinion sctee opinion june state product made materi dy azody sourc exposur azody lack quantit data germani reli opinion justifi restrict azody materi textil leather sctee opinion direct ec adopt extend scope ban materi shown suffici data pose risk justifi consider context commiss stress member state base applic maintain exist nation provis assess risk public health accept commun legislatur adopt harmonis measur nation provis derog fall applic member state prove necess proportion nation provis question german author provid element demonstr exist risk human health risk identifi commun legislatur demonstr nation measur concern attain object foreseen demonstr materi data submit german author support request applic articl limit explanatori statement german author justifi mainten nation provis ground consum protect inform data provid substanti argument submit scientif data risk demonstr inadequaci commun harmonis measur evalu risk health estim consum exposur enabl justifi mainten nation provis provid inform azody manufactur product materi textil leather remain argument put forward german author commiss recal ban product constitut restrict trade intern market impedi fundament object free circul good restrict kind base solid ground examin german applic shown ground present document argument submit german author support request derog articl conclud nation measur justifi major refer articl ec treati request germani maintain nation measur fulfil condit set articl ec treati absenc arbitrari discrimin disguis restrict trade member state obstacl function intern market pursuant articl ec treati commiss approv reject nation provis involv verifi mean arbitrari discrimin disguis restrict trade member state constitut obstacl function intern market recal applic articl ec treati assess light condit laid paragraph paragraph articl condit met applic reject examin request made germani fulfil basic condit set articl part iii section decis commiss oblig verifi notifi nation provis mean arbitrari discrimin disguis restrict trade member state constitut obstacl function intern market iv conclus light element assess merit justif put forward nation measur notifi light consider set commiss consid request germani maintain nation provis derog direct ec amend direct eec regard market azody submit admiss fulfil condit set articl ec treati germani justifi mainten nation provis major protect consum health commiss ground nation provis notifi approv accord articl ec treati adopt decis articl nation provis restrict market azody notifi feder republ germani pursuant articl ec treati reject articl decis address feder republ germani brussel novemb commiss erkki liikanen member commiss oj oj oj recit direct ec recit direct ec recit direct ec direct ec introduc appendix direct eec quot point azocolour quot list aromat amin point exhaust list articl point annex includ list amin oj relat articl ec treati european court justic judgment septemb case commiss kingdom denmark paragraph quot commun commiss articl paragraph treati establish european commun quot final paragraph opinion risk cancer caus textil leather good colour azody express seventh sctee plenari meet brussel januari concern point view carcinogen risk aris potenti azody undergo vivo reduct cleavag aromat amin includ amin classifi eu mak commiss proven suspect human carcinogen opinion report final draft quot assess risk human health pose azocolour toi write ink paper product analysi advantag drawback restrict market quot opinion express sctee plenari meet brussel june european court justic judgment march case paragraph