council regul ec termin anti dump anti subsidi proceed import farm atlant salmon origin norwai anti dump proceed import farm atlant salmon origin chile faero island council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun quot basic anti dump regul quot articl articl thereof regard council regul ec octob protect subsidis import countri member european commun quot basic anti subsidi regul quot articl articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur previou investig exist measur norwai septemb council regul ec impos definit anti dump countervail duti import farm atlant salmon origin norwai decis ec commiss accept undertak larg number export produc norwai respect inter alia minimum import price decemb commiss announc notic publish offici journal european commun initi officio investig pursuant articl regul ec articl regul ec order review possibl chang form duti import salmon injuri price prevent subsequ council repeal replac regul ec singl council regul ec parallel abovement anti dump countervail duti undertak agreement quot agreement solut salmon case quot salmon agreement sign commiss norwegian govern provid support measur manag framework regular contact signatori interim expiri review investig norwai basi inform receiv commiss framework salmon agreement inform obtain sourc commiss consid suffici ground warrant initi interim review exist measur appear form measur includ undertak longer remov injuri effect dump subsidis disturb present commun market appear evid provid norwegian author normal inform export price commun dump margin establish chang significantli light inform receiv norwegian author export tax inform receiv commun produc farm atlant salmon consid review parallel effect form level countervail measur final inform develop ownership structur salmon produc compani commun product cost resal price norwegian import volum substanti consid review find relat injuri respect anti dump countervail measur determin consult advisori committe suffici evid exist justifi initi interim review commiss announc notic notic initi publish offici journal european commun initi investig pursuant articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul regard import commun farm atlant salmon origin norwai cover form level anti dump countervail measur articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul interim review measur progress time measur due expir interim review cover aspect circumst dealt scope expiri review open articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul commiss investig expiri measur result continu recurr dump subsidis injuri context commiss inform interest parti extens scope review sought opinion expiri measur lead continu recurr dump injuri continu recurr subsidis injuri initi anti dump proceed chile faero island juli commiss announc notic publish offici journal european commun initi anti dump proceed import farm atlant salmon origin chile faero island proceed initi result complaint lodg june eu salmon produc group complain behalf produc repres major proport commun product farm atlant salmon mean articl basic anti dump regul complaint contain suffici prima faci evid dump materi injuri result therefrom justifi initi anti dump proceed parti concern investig commiss offici advis export produc import trader concern associ author norwai chile home govern faero island user supplier commun produc initi investig interest parti opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi number export produc trader norwai chile faero island produc supplier locat commun repres associ fish import processor consum made view write parti request time limit show reason heard grant opportun heard view appar larg number export produc product concern norwai chile faero island larg number produc product commun applic sampl techniqu investig injuri dump subsidis review injuri dump investig chile faero island envisag notic initi commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos investig regard investig import origin chile faero island includ inform deem relev determin dump injuri commun interest regard investig import origin norwai includ inform deem relev determin dump subsidis injuri determin likelihood continu recurr injuri dump subsidis assess commun interest verif visit carri govern norwai entiti norwai ministri fisheri oslo ministri local govern region develop oslo ministri trade industri oslo norwegian industri region develop fund snd oslo research council norwai oslo commun produc orknei sea farm glasgow unit kingdom muirachmhainní teo galwai ireland ardvar salmon saffron walden unit kingdom hoga salmon wester sound salmon shetland unit kingdom cro lax shetland unit kingdom bressai salmon shetland unit kingdom west minch salmon atlant west salmon sidinish salmon south uist unit kingdom loch duart edinburgh unit kingdom hoov salmon shetland unit kingdom north atlant salmon shetland unit kingdom ayr salmon shetland unit kingdom export produc relat sale compani norwai midt norsk havbruk rørvik lofoten sjøprodukt lekn follalak nordfold terra seafood trondheim marin harvest norwai bergen aqua farm bergen naco trade bergen aalesundfisk aalesund alsak fjordbruk onarheim labeyri norg oslo chile marin harvest chile puerto montt salmon multiexport ltda puerto montt pesca chile santiago invertec pesquera mar de chiloé santiago cultivo yadran yadran quellón quellón chiloé island faero island vestlax vestsalmon kollafjørður east salmon klaksvík faero seafood tórshavn bakkafrost glyvrar relat import commun armor quimper franc vensi españa málaga spain narvik landivisiau franc benfumat st feliu de llobregat spain van wijnen krimpen ijssel netherland fish skagen skagen denmark labeyri saint geour de maremn franc unrel import commun moulin de la march brittani franc supplier landcatch argyl unit kingdom investig dump subsidis review investig norwai cover period januari decemb quot ip quot period exception investig dump anti dump proceed chile faero island order combin analysi injuri causat proceed examin trend context analysi injuri investig cover period januari end ip analysi period accord articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul parti concern inform essenti fact consider basi intend propos termin investig grant period make represent subsequ disclosur commiss continu seek verifi inform deem investig written comment submit parti consid find modifi product concern product product concern product consider farm atlant salmon fillet fresh chill frozen definit exclud similar farm fish product larg salmon trout salmon speci pacif salmon wild salmon process type smoke salmon product classifi cn code present product fresh chill fish fresh chill fillet frozen fish frozen fillet present found suffici similar constitut singl product purpos proceed product consid product produc norwai chile faero island sold export commun ident alik respect farm atlant salmon produc commun sold commun market mean articl basic anti dump anti subsidi regul parti contend fresh frozen salmon distinguish purpos investig basi frozen salmon produc larg quantiti commun distinct custom market fresh salmon note previou commiss investig farm atlant salmon initi subsequ termin imposit measur frozen salmon exclud scope investig similarli attent drawn fact author unit state america usa consist made distinct fresh frozen salmon context anti dump countervail investig relat salmon parti suggest freez salmon ad signific ad final product appreci user process industri frozen salmon argu process product fresh salmon raw materi claim consum commun show clear prefer fresh salmon reflect price premium prepar pai view consider argu frozen atlant salmon consid product produc commun exclud investig assess product concern deem alik farm atlant salmon produc commun initi consid type present farm atlant salmon fillet fish fresh frozen share basic physic technic chemic characterist argument practic usa prior investig termin measur consid relev context recal recent investig led imposit measur import commun farm atlant salmon origin norwai determin product concern includ fish gut fish type portion fillet fresh chill frozen present salmon constitut singl product deem alik respect produc commun sold commun market consid freez salmon suffici alter basic characterist product ad product appreci user consid main reason freez product facilit transport commun refer frozen salmon process product deriv fresh salmon wine produc grape found reason context present investig present investig establish fresh frozen salmon interchang degre increas share total consumpt account frozen salmon ip assum user cooper proceed replac fresh salmon product process frozen salmon time note commun market show clear prefer farm atlant salmon type salmon pacif salmon wild salmon evidenc volum farm atlant salmon consum commun recit speci salmon product concern consid signific influenc market farm atlant salmon sampl dump assess purpos order enabl commiss select sampl pursuant articl basic anti dump regul export produc export produc request make week initi review investig anti dump proceed provid basic inform export domest sale precis activ regard product product concern name activ relat compani product sell farm atlant salmon commiss contact associ export produc author norwai chile home govern faero island object sampl rais parti pre select cooper compani chile entiti chile compos individu compani group relat compani compani forward provid request inform time limit set purpos repres total export product concern chile commun produc report export commun ip account select sampl remain fourteen compani trader account select sampl produc export commun ip remain compani transform product product concern faero island compani faero island group thirteen group relat compani forward provid request inform time limit set purpos compani express cooper investig repres total export product concern faero island commun thirteen group product export commun ip group account select sampl norwai compani norwai repli sampl mini questionnair time limit set purpos repres close total norwegian export product concern commun select sampl chile chile gener rule product sale product concern made integr compani carri function case chile sampl integr export produc select articl basic anti dump regul select sampl base largest repres volum export investig time criteria found import select chilean sampl repres domest sale signific product basi export produc chosen constitut sampl consult chilean salmon trout produc associ quot cstpa quot chilean author rais object propos commiss compani select sampl repres repli mini questionnair chilean export sale commun chilean domest sale chilean product product concern cooper export produc final retain sampl inform anti dump duti export calcul accord articl basic anti dump regul compani initi intent claim individu treatment accord articl basic anti dump regul case select sampl substanti claim receiv deadlin notic initi compani submit claim individu treatment subsequ inform commiss wish withdraw request individu treatment submiss questionnair respons error human resourc correct error continu investig compani final constitut sampl fulli cooper investig sole compani claim individu examin attribut dump margin questionnair complet sampl compani compani initi express intent claim individu margin faero island case chile product sale product concern faero island carri integr compani sampl integr export produc select articl basic anti dump regul select sampl base largest repres volum export investig time export produc chosen constitut sampl consult consent faero fish farmer associ home govern faero island compani select sampl repres repli mini questionnair faeroes product export commun product concern remain export produc request individu treatment accord articl basic anti dump regul cooper export produc final retain sampl inform anti dump duti export calcul accord articl basic anti dump regul compani final constitut sampl fulli cooper investig attribut dump margin questionnair complet sampl compani norwai sampl norwai select consult consent norwegian author norwegian feder fish aquacultur industri case time investig led imposit origin measur origin investig found strict distinct function maintain farmer grow salmon trader export sell domest export decid sampl farmer export found imposs impos compani specif duti enforc custom author ident grower check decid purpos sampl establish countri wide duti regul ec establish duti rate norwai present investig envisag review singl duti consequ compani specif request part sampl view individu margin withdrew request compani select basi criteria farmer signific product volum ii locat ensur good geograph spread export trader signific volum export ii involv activ repres role plai norwegian export sampl establish line compris ten compani altogeth sampl questionnair repli compani repres norwegian export sale commun norwegian domest sale norwegian product product concern questionnair complet sampl compani subsequ disclosur parti claim norwegian sampl export unrepres led unreli result includ compani part multin group worldwid interest note select sampl made earli stage review investig interest parti opportun comment appropri time chose importantli reason advanc fact norwegian export belong multin group made data compani unus dump purpos claim parti reject dump chile normal accord articl basic anti dump regul commiss examin domest sale farm atlant salmon independ custom export produc repres total volum sale equal greater total volum export sale commun assess reveal investig export produc repres sale farm salmon domest market ip commiss subsequ consid domest sold export product type similar qualiti form fresh chill frozen present gut fish head gut fish head fillet portion conclud ident directli compar addition product type sold export produc domest market found directli compar type sold export commun establish domest sale suffici repres purpos articl basic anti dump regul domest sale product type consid suffici repres total domest sale volum type ip repres total sale volum compar product type export commun commiss subsequ examin domest sale compani consid made ordinari trade pursuant articl basic anti dump regul establish proport domest sale independ custom export product type sold loss domest market ip product type volum sale domest market unit cost weight averag sale price equal higher weight averag product cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price type question product type volum sale domest market unit cost normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price found equal unit cost type question product type volum sale domest market unit cost consid product type concern sold ordinari trade normal construct type sold export commun domest sale found made ordinari trade case investig compani normal base product type actual price paid payabl independ custom domest market chile ip set articl basic anti dump regul sale product type made ordinari trade product type sold repres quantiti domest market normal construct investig compani sale commun product type construct normal pursuant articl basic anti dump regul sell gener administr sg amp cost incur weight averag profit realis cooper export produc concern domest sale product ordinari trade ip ad averag cost manufactur ip manufactur cost sg amp cost report correct ordinari trade test construct normal valu export price investig show export chilean export produc made unrel relat custom commun compani export unrel trader uruguai usa case establish product consider ship commun export product consider export produc made directli independ custom commun export price establish accord articl basic anti dump regul basi export price paid payabl independ custom commun independ trader locat countri sale made relat import export price construct basi resal price independ custom adjust made cost incur import resal import includ sg amp cost assum reason profit margin accord articl basic anti dump regul comparison comparison normal export price made factori basi purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ affect price compar accord articl basic anti dump regul investig export produc allow differ transport cost ocean freight insur cost handl load ancillari cost import charg credit cost sale cost commiss discount rebat currenc convers claim grant applic justifi dump margin dump margin compani investig establish basi comparison weight averag normal product type weight averag export price product type dump margin establish sampl export produc chile dump margin export produc made accord articl basic anti dump regul examin individu establish pursuant articl basic anti dump regul basi dump margin compani sampl exist dump establish due high cooper level establish consid set residu dump margin cooper compani level dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border duti unpaid gt tabl gt faero island normal accord articl basic anti dump regul commiss examin domest sale product concern independ custom export produc repres total volum sale equal greater total volum export sale commun examin reveal investig export produc repres sale farm atlant salmon domest market ip stipul articl basic anti dump regul normal base cost manufactur compani sampl reason amount sg amp profit basi export price ordinari trade countri provid sale repres respect found export produc repres export sale individu countri commiss option base normal cost manufactur compani sampl reason amount sg amp profit absenc repres domest sale product concern absenc domest sale product fall gener categori product reason method sought calcul amount sg amp cost profit ad cost manufactur sampl export produc decid pursuant articl determin normal valu export produc sampl ad cost manufactur weight averag sg amp cost profit incur sampl chilean export produc domest sale method consid reason situat chile parti proceed faero island product sale structur salmon industri countri similar faero island sens chile faero salmon industri run larg integr compani subsequ disclosur parti contest methodolog claim commiss sg amp cost profit chile construct normal faero chilean market compar faeroes market term size develop claim profit margin commiss consid proper level profit commun industri origin investig norwai address argument note domest market faero island product concern issu compar exist domest market domest market irrelev commiss maintain due absenc domest market faero island product concern similar product method determin normal valu territori weight averag sg amp cost profit incur sampl chilean export produc explain recit consid reason method due similar structur salmon industri territori claim level profit note profit margin origin norwegian investig calcul injuri margin confus profit margin construct normal valu dump calcul current investig basi claim made parti justifi amend methodolog commiss export price establish export faeroes export produc made directli independ custom commun consequ accord articl basic anti dump regul export price establish basi export price paid payabl comparison comparison normal export price made factori basi purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ affect price compar accord articl basic anti dump regul investig export produc allow differ transport cost ocean freight insur cost credit cost discount rebat grant applic justifi dump margin dump margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal product type weight averag export price product type basi comparison dump margin found respect compani form sampl due high cooper level achiev export produc faero island consid attribut dump margin faeroes export produc norwai gener origin investig assess dump made export level farmer time sold output norwegian export gener unawar final destin product fundament chang situat origin investig approach present investig note time origin investig consid reason select repres sampl norwegian farmer base quot cost acquisit quot determin export domest sale profit construct normal weight averag domest sell price charg sampl farmer approach investig reason explain recit origin investig investig dump limit specif product type fresh chill salmon gut head superior qualiti fresh chill salmon gut head ordinari qualiti account total export commun export compos sampl approach present investig product type found repres total export commun export compris present sampl view fact present investig envisag establish singl countri wide duti norwai weight averag normal weight averag export price norwai calcul basi inform submit compani includ sampl normal examin domest sale export total product type consid made repres quantiti respect recal origin investig quantiti sold export final destin determin seller disregard specif characterist norwegian domest market percentag volum export product concern commun usual held suffici domest sale repres situat fundament chang respect approach appli present investig parti claim commiss domest sale repres export commun hint sale domest custom redirect commun relat claim note basic anti dump regul possibl domest sale repres percentag lower price charg consid repres market concern accord articl circumst origin current investig domest consumpt norwai fundament chang claim reject claim commiss check domest natur sale consider made final domest custom found case export domest sale total product type consid repres export sale commun sampl export domest sale domest sale account significantli abovement percentag sole export domest sale found repres examin consid made ordinari trade pursuant articl basic anti dump regul respect found product type proport domest sale volum sold unit cost domest market ip view normal product type calcul weight averag domest sale price equal unit cost product type question unit cost determin domest sale made ordinari trade calcul ad unit quot cost acquisit quot unit sg amp cost incur export question domest sale product unit quot cost acquisit quot product type obtain weight averag price made compani includ sampl farmer sell independ domest custom ordinari trade remain export sampl repres sale normal case construct basi quot cost acquisit quot defin reason amount sg amp cost profit accord articl basic anti dump regul amount sg amp cost profit margin base respect amount calcul sole export normal base domest sale parti claim sg amp cost profit export incorrect complain amount disclos opinion amount lower percentag appli origin investig regard claim firstli note parti question suggest altern amount observ investig chile favour result parti reason percentag observ origin investig appli articl refer applic methodolog origin investig circumst chang applic factual data dump calcul claim reject disclosur amount sg amp cost profit relat export disclos reason confidenti final normal valu establish export sampl weight basi quantiti sold respect custom commun arriv averag normal norwai export price case export sale made independ custom commun export price establish accord articl basic anti dump regul basi export price paid payabl case product import commun relat compani transform order process sell smoke marin salmon case reliabl export price obtain deduct cost incur import resal price charg independ custom accord articl basic anti dump regul found sale export relat transform made price fulli line price made sampl export independ custom commun case establish export relat transform oper reason profit transform benefit financi support relat norwegian export consid price paid relat transform reliabl establish export price basi price paid payabl sole export found sell relat transform price line averag price made sampl export independ custom commun export price construct accord articl basic anti dump regul parti claim export price construct export claim reject articl basic anti dump regul appli export price deem unreli case export final export price establish export sampl weight basi quantiti sold respect custom commun arriv averag export price norwai comparison averag normal averag export price obtain compar work basi purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ affect price compar accord articl basic anti dump regul relat export price allow differ discount rebat transport insur handl load ancillari cost credit sale cost export tax applic export norwegian salmon commun grant applic support verifi evid similarli relat normal allow differ transport insur handl load ancillari cost credit cost grant parti queri actual level allow grant disclos actual amount disclos reason confidenti dump margin dump margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal weight averag export price accord articl basic anti dump regul comparison show countri wide dump margin parti claim weight averag normal compar individu export transact opinion shown exist dump sake certainti commiss assess dump margin norwai compar weight averag normal price individu export transact result exercis show de minimi dump margin norwai meant weight averag normal weight export price method reflect full degre dump practis claim reject parti alleg calcul arriv posit determin dump highlight fact import norwegian oper report loss ip parti claim system price undertak circumv larg number norwegian export indic dump note select highlight econom perform individu compani reflect gener situat norwegian salmon industri fact situat norwegian salmon industri ip show mix pictur commonli case industri compani report loss whilst report profit reason compani report loss vari extraordinari restructur cost loss invest product countri fact loss make ip necessarili impli dump product concern regard issu price undertak note parti bring substant evid support claim whilst acknowledg undertak withdrawn violat vast major undertak remain place evid found investig suggest compani involv respect claim reject likelihood recurr dump product capac sampl norwegian farmer work full capac ip product capac norwai depend grant addit licenc norwegian govern feed quota polici establish author norwegian parti state increas number licens grant expans feed quota polici made sustain market growth parti claim norwai shortli increas product capac issu addit product licens norwegian govern novemb fact suffici likelihood injuri dump norwegian export commun consid increas number product licens necessarili lead increas actual product depend level feed quota consid length product cycl product concern year potenti increas felt commun market end onward short term potenti increas product capac effect level sale volum includ export commun event increas product capac impli addit norwegian export direct commun injuri price claim reject ii export sale countri price volum dump analysi trend price volum countri carri basi statist data basi data collect sampl compani analysi basi statist data made difficult fact export salmon record statist code distinguish product type fact price vari significantli depend product type examin export quantiti shown period imposit measur ip export product concern norwai quot emerg market quot russia poland increas significantli export quot tradit market quot japan hong kong taiwan increas compar export commun consid tradit market expect addit export deriv increas capac direct quot emerg market quot constant expans quot tradit quot market commun reach degre stabil period price remain substanti stabl respect quot tradit market quot price export eu countri averag higher commun market price quot emerg market quot decreas expect market strong expans examin data receiv sampl compani confirm export salmon norwai eu countri made price higher averag commun consider fact commun long major export market salmon norwai assum measur repeal evolut quantiti export price behaviour similar case quot tradit market quot case market poland russia measur repeal price remain stabl quantiti increas degre period imposit measur note export tradit market japan hong kong taiwan made dump price ip subsequ disclosur number parti claim analysi carri likelihood recurr dump base optimist assumpt place notabl claim poland russia genuin market final destin market quot conveni quot salmon tranship commun examin trade statist show insignific shipment product concern countri commun parti question submit evid support alleg respect claim reject iii conclus light market situat explain consid short run import quantiti flow commun measur repeal exclud situat start chang late due newli grant product licens consid increas norwegian export direct expand quot emerg market quot commun investig shown export product concern tradit market commun made dump level ip price expect remain stabl dump level case increas norwegian product recit conclud measur respect norwai repeal export product concern commun dump price recur subsidi preliminari remark establish origin investig govern norwai grant number subsidi found countervail accord articl basic anti subsidi regul programm found countervail origin investig investig framework review addit investig subsidi scheme confer benefit produc export product concern respect commiss investig govern institut includ public privat entiti control govern norwai provid financi contribut defin articl basic anti subsidi regul salmon grower norwai investig financi contribut found exist confer benefit recipi origin investig limit number repres compani investig agreement norwegian author consid establish singl countri wide subsidi amount investig examin expiri measur lead continu recurr subsidis agreement european econom area eea agreement norwegian govern repeat argument made origin investig applic countervail measur field fisheri consid assess relat oblig protocol eea agreement relat joint declar agre interpret articl protocol norwegian govern made refer articl protocol stipul aid grant state resourc fisheri sector distort competit abolish addit refer made joint declar state quot efta state acqui communautair fisheri polici understood refer made aid grant state resourc distort competit assess contract parti context articl eec treati relat relev provis acqui communautair fisheri polici content joint declar articl agreement quot word norwegian govern argu assess distort competit base comparison aid grant efta eea state concern aid grant commun case distort competit establish state aid abolish origin investig recal articl eea agreement prohibit countervail measur agreement respect articl eea agreement explicitli state provis arrang appli fish set protocol articl protocol expressli permit countervail measur order remedi injuri effect subsidi fisheri sector protocol agreement limit countervail measur area commun acqui fulli integr case fisheri sector programm found countervail origin investig differenti social secur contribut norwai employ social secur contribut vari zone resid employe origin investig prevail system consist geograph zone differenti rate rate vari zone employe gross wage employe resid zone gt tabl gt govern norwai zone revis minor adjust place sector system differenti social secur contribut mine telecommun sector pai irrespect locat employe rate chang origin investig differenti employ social secur contribut constitut subsidi defin articl basic anti subsidi regul conclus scheme origin investig reduct exempt employ social secur contribut constitut financi contribut govern norwai system constitut govern revenu foregon collect exempt reduc employ social secur contribut zone zone govern revenu reduc scheme fall definit financi contribut accord articl ii basic anti subsidi regul scheme confer benefit employ accord articl basic anti subsidi regul emploi employe resid zone employ obtain benefit compar situat exist employe resid zone subject basic rate scheme confer de facto benefit employ basi locat employe live zone employ benefit employ emploi employe zone differ actual amount social secur contribut paid amount contribut paid basic rate appli amount subsidi origin investig measur refer basic rate contribut employ locat zone pai basic rate zone benefit confer limit firm locat zone subsidi specif mean articl basic anti subsidi regul origin investig govern norwai provid global figur social secur contribut salmon farm industri basi calcul benefit social secur contribut investig grower locat zone subsidi calcul compar actual payment social secur contribut amount paid basic rate appli differ obtain consid benefit salmon grower total subsidi express percentag turnov investig grower includ zone amount norwegian industri region develop fund snd snd establish act juli start oper januari snd own ministri trade industri respons carri public polici object snd promot profit busi econom develop norwai contribut develop modernis structur product develop establish norwegian trade industri promot activ provid stabl profit employ opportun area employ problem tradition weak econom basi snd incent firm form grant loan loan guarante grant grant programm salmon grower fund budget ministri trade industri ministri local govern region develop programm fund ministri function programm fund ministri fisheri numario grant develop marin sector introduc salmon fish farm sector consid programm salmon grower develop grant region develop grant programm limit assist area programm geograph limit oper area assist area programm oper origin ip minor place snd oper grant programm salmon fish farm sector establish total amount grant provid salmon grower decreas origin ip exist subsidi grant scheme financi contribut direct transfer fund govern beneficiari mean articl basic anti subsidi regul scheme confer benefit salmon produc invest cost reduc amount grant snd grant constitut subsidi specif snd grant specif establish twofold origin investig region specif lack object criteria automat elig region scheme regard grant nationwid programm grant salmon farm sector ip question specif aris regard programm access subsidi limit enterpris albeit exclus salmon produc region specif exist accord articl basic anti subsidi regul calcul benefit snd grant gener acquisit fix asset recur subsidi obtain beneficiari regular basi addit grant larg concentr amount case origin ip amount grant small grant expens ip benefit grant ip express percentag total sale norwegian salmon grower discuss recit establish certainti amount subsidi confer benefit salmon product ii loan origin investig snd loan programm found countervail financi contribut govern benefit confer provid loan interest rate lower interest rate similar loan commerci market addit snd incur heavi loss loan fish farm sector order establish benefit exist investig grower interest rate snd loan paid ip compar normal commerci interest rate compar commerci loan loan similar amount similar repay period obtain recipi repres privat bank oper domest market analysi reveal snd loan programm includ rate compar privat market benefit investig grower loss incur snd loan due repay found amount loss small interest rate charg includ risk element loan low risk loan subsidi found confer loan programm iii loan guarante origin investig snd loan guarante programm constitut subsidi recal financi contribut snd benefit salmon grower loan guarante extent guarante made commerci basi loss incur snd programm small origin ip nil entir fish farm sector includ salmon ip establish fee set level cover amount default loan circumst subsidi confer programm transport subsidi origin investig transport aid scheme found specif countervail subsidi found scheme present review found counti oper transport aid scheme total grant compani transport fish product salmon nok compar nok previou investig benefit grant calcul percentag total sale salmon ip amount subsidi found neglig scheme consid context review region commiss northern norwai north trondelag investig reveal grant alloc salmon sector scheme consid context review fo rødfisk novemb rødfisk consortium bank set conduct liquid fo export monopoli organis salmon norwai receiv nok million loan govern subsequ written grant origin investig establish benefit written loan pass salmon grower order settl claim fo grant found countervail benefit alloc period time reflect normal depreci period fix asset industri concern period end subsidi confer addit establish aid programm fo rødfisk involv benefit salmon grower grant origin investig scheme consid context review programm programm research council norwai rcn investig object rcn support research develop amp sector norwai purpos support scheme develop knowledg amp elig receiv support univers research institut compani grant open propos particip limit region norwai establish salmon grower receiv amp support programm govern norwai made claim green light treatment aid compani amp support user control project produc product concern basi grant accord criteria set articl basic anti subsidi regul support amp consid specif programm gener sector economi conclud amp aid rcn subject countervail measur specif consid assess claim green light treatment programm found countervail final establish institut grant financi support constitut subsidi mean basic anti subsidi regul conclus subsidi scheme found countervail accord provis basic anti subsidi regul amount subsidi express ad valorem gt tabl gt total ad valorem amount subsidi mere de minimi context born mind ad valorem arriv assum subsidi establish snd grant exclus benefit salmon product explain recit accur reflect real situat continu recurr subsidis accord provis articl basic anti subsidi regul commiss investig expiri measur lead continu recurr subsidis provis requir prospect assess rate subsidis prevail forese futur take account find ip establish total amount government support salmon grower norwai decreas significantli origin investig origin investig total ad valorem amount subsidi programm found countervail origin investig longer applic grant fo rødfisk refer benefit salmon grower establish transport subsidi loan loan guarante snd establish govern norwai introduc programm confer benefit salmon grower programm found countervail origin investig review continu confer benefit context observ born mind firstli level subsidis found differenti social secur contribut benefit establish salmon grower gener region programm destin salmon grower slightli decreas origin investig grant provid salmon grower snd confirm level decreas origin investig respect snd point level grant found inflat govern norwai provid total amount support compani involv activ product sale salmon absenc precis figur amount basi present investig irrespect grant de facto benefit salmon product verif visit premis investig grower confirm grant fact capit invest relat salmon wareh speci pack station sole salmon quantifi level invest product salmon event clear number grant report likelihood directli relat product concern assum grant relat product concern result subsidi found scheme absolut maximum conceiv bear mind realiti actual figur benefit salmon lower actual level subsidis de minimi level amount subsidi snd scheme base amount paid salmon farm sector ip sum grant commit govern norwai salmon grower ip significantli lower amount paid led figur refer total amount grant commit oppos paid salmon grower ip bring level subsidis de minimi reason indic subsidi amount increas continu recurr subsidis level de minimi offici figur amount commit amount paid salmon grower confirm level subsidis de minimi conclus continu recurr subsidis current level subsidi close de minimi rate subsidis prevail forese futur de minimi anti subsidi proceed termin commun industri articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul review investig follow methodolog investig led duti view ownership structur commun salmon farm industri recent year factor note compani consid constitut commun industri purpos present investig mean articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul necessarili consid previou investig norwai led imposit measur review note decid exclud determin commun industri produc relat export norwai chile faero island accord articl articl basic anti dump anti subsidi regul produc locat commun express disappoint interpret note form part multin group salmon farm activ norwai chile countri ultim parent compani group dutch base publicli quot compani consid account part commun industri reason note aforement articl claim accept light determin compani relat export countri investig repres major proport commun product farm atlant salmon constitut quot commun industri quot mean articl articl basic anti dump regul articl articl basic anti subsidi regul injuri preliminari remark view larg number produc farm atlant salmon commun applic sampl techniqu foreseen notic initi assess injuri review investig select sampl commun produc base largest repres volum product sale investig time accord articl basic anti dump regul articl basic anti subsidi regul commun produc farm atlant salmon request notic initi provid inform activ period juli decemb basi inform provid commiss compani list initi select sampl gaelic seafood ireland galwai ireland johnson seawel johnson seafarm shetland unit kingdom orknei sea farm glasgow unit kingdom muirachmhainní teo galwai ireland ardvar salmon saffron walden unit kingdom hoga salmon wester sound salmon shetland unit kingdom cro lax shetland unit kingdom bressai salmon shetland unit kingdom west minch salmon atlant west salmon sidinish salmon south uist unit kingdom loch duart edinburgh unit kingdom hoov salmon shetland unit kingdom north atlant salmon shetland unit kingdom ayr salmon shetland unit kingdom interest parti review import norwai inform sampl chosen opportun make comment gaelic seafood ireland ceas trade march financi difficulti part review johnson seawel johnson seafarm subsequ withdrew cooper part proceed subsequ establish muirachmhainní teoranta enter joint ventur arrang compani relat export norwai consid part commun industri injuri indic discuss establish basi verifi inform provid remain compani list recit view fact period consid assess injuri investig chile faero island review investig interest parti investig inform intent make sampl independ commun produc subject develop note preced recit interest parti opportun comment propos action recal accord articl articl basic anti dump anti subsidi regul inform receiv pursuant regul purpos request result commiss approach sampl produc cooper review written permiss inform submit framework review account purpos investig parti concern gave consent result sampl establish investig chile faero island review commun consumpt larg scale farm atlant salmon commun confin unit kingdom scotland ireland appar consumpt commun farm atlant salmon establish basi product figur produc locat countri obtain fisheri research servic scottish execut irish sea fisheri board import export concern data deriv eurostat case origin investig norwai adjust made convert net weight report eurostat round weight quot fish equival quot common comparison industri made basi import figur fresh chill frozen salmon exclud fillet fresh chill frozen salmon fillet divid convers factor note cn code cover type fish includ scope review pacif salmon danub salmon origin report quantiti consid neglig basi commun consumpt farm atlant salmon ip reach level tonn figur higher record start analysi period gt tabl gt cumul assess effect import concern question cumul aris case import faero island norwai dump case norwai likelihood recurr dump subsidis term quot import concern quot refer import origin chile volum import concern market share volum import origin chile deriv eurostat data methodolog recit increas approxim tonn tonn ip period import concern increas share commun market ip gt tabl gt price import concern evolut price price inform import concern deriv eurostat data base import volum establish methodolog detail recit inform show averag price import concern increas eur kilogram eur kilogram declin ip eur kilogram gt tabl gt price undercut purpos calcul level price undercut ip price sampl commun industri produc compar price import chile price sampl commun industri produc work post process level level trade consid compar import concern sampl commun industri produc sell fish quot bin quot farm gate process upward adjust penc cent kilogram made reflect process pack cost adjust made basi cost incur produc sampl activ investig demonstr import chile ip consist frozen fillet present salmon produc sold sampl commun industri produc adjust made reflect differ present fresh fillet produc sold sampl commun industri produc note present fillet account sale sampl commun industri produc volum ip complain fresh salmon command premium frozen salmon inform collect investig norwegian faeroes cooper export sell fresh frozen salmon present frozen salmon systemat expens equival fresh salmon present weight averag premium frozen salmon calcul basi figur collect norwegian faeroes cooper export appli price chilean import commun frontier custom duti paid basi result comparison show level price undercut rang econom situat commun industri preliminari remark applic sampl techniqu view time limit establish articl articl basic anti dump regul regard conduct investig larg number produc farm atlant salmon commun sampl techniqu appli assess econom situat commun industri injuri indic present establish basi inform obtain repres sampl commun industri produc recit time inform sale commun market cooper commun industri produc includ sampl obtain order calcul sale market share commun industri note sampl compani loch duart began oper purchas salmon farm oper compani includ sampl consid materi effect trend observ analysi period product product capac capac utilis sampl commun industri produc increas product analysi period approxim tonn tonn ip regard product capac recal origin investig led current measur figur capac base environment consent issu scottish environ protect agenc sepa sepa public bodi respons environment protect scotland regul salmon farm scotland grant consent licenc discharg wast tidal water consent set limit cage size biomass level weight live fish site time fish cage harvest extend period time argu total product cage greater biomass limit exceed reason basi capac found appli sampl circumst regard sepa consent accord articl basic anti dump regul basi calcul capac present investig note correspond sepa confirm unabl provid inform precis tonnag term site central consent express term cage number fish biomass limit born mind inform present capac capac utilis gt tabl gt stock note farm atlant salmon perish product frozen shelf life week sampl commun industri produc stock fresh salmon harvest freez product stock level consid meaning indic injuri investig sale volum market share growth volum commun industri sale commun market increas analysi period approxim tonn tonn ip period progress increas share commun market ip rate increas excess growth appar commun consumpt record period volum sampl commun industri produc sale commun market increas analysi period approxim tonn tonn ip sampl commun industri produc share commun market grew ip gt tabl gt sale price cost sampl commun industri produc averag sale price increas figur eur kilogram reach peak eur dramat fall price observ ip averag price fell back eur kilogram period sampl commun industri produc reduc averag cost product figur eur kilogram gt tabl gt profit imposit measur sampl commun industri produc return net sale commun market tax improv reach level spite continu effort improv effici sampl commun industri produc suffer mark deterior profit ip due low price prevail market note sampl commun industri produc achiev minimum profit level analysi period consid time origin investig recal profit margin origin investig establish level order account high risk natur industri subject uncertain factor weather diseas escap exclud combin factor restructur consolid industri recent year part explain sharp movement profit shown absenc conclus evid suggest circumst interven period chang submiss produc associ commun support level profit margin accord articl basic anti dump regul gt tabl gt invest return invest level invest made sampl commun industri produc increas analysi period approxim eur million eur million ip replac exist asset acquisit addit equip handl increas level product signific item expenditur relat purchas autom feed barg vessel design suppli feed control basi salmon cage sea requir fewer peopl overse feed fish sampl commun industri produc return invest express pre tax result percentag averag open close net book asset emploi salmon farm neg reflect loss make situat return invest posit year consid sampl commun industri produc profit gt tabl gt cash flow abil rais capit sampl commun industri produc record net cash inflow oper activ analysi period express percentag turnov net cash inflow show mark declin percentag term sampl produc experienc difficulti rais capit extern sourc bank case recours sharehold addit fund risk involv industri tradit lender reluct extend financ substanti secur provid pressur financ provid coupl short term cash flow difficulti meant produc adher optimum harvest schedul extend credit term feed produc plai increasingli import role oper financ industri case feed compani provid fund purchas feed barg case addit cost arrang gt tabl gt employ product wage number peopl emploi sampl produc increas analysi period reach figur ip view context substanti increas product occur period note recit estim region peopl emploi commun industri rate employ grew product increas product sampl commun industri produc measur tonn produc annual employe increas approxim tonn tonn ip total wage bill sampl commun industri produc increas absolut term analysi period averag wage level employe increas analysi period gt tabl gt magnitud dump recoveri past dump subsidis view volum price import chile impact commun industri magnitud actual dump margin consid neglig econom situat sampl commun industri produc improv imposit anti dump countervail measur import origin norwai increas product sale market share return profit signific disturb commun market ip reduc return produc econom situat sampl commun industri produc deterior consid sampl produc fulli recov past dump subsidis econom situat continu weak conclus injuri spite commun industri continu effort improv effici evidenc invest feed technolog improv product make level return deem industri natur analysi period return profit onward time build suffici reserv withstand extend period advers price develop occur ip import chile present commun market dump price larg volum result disturb commun market half ip number produc forc market note compani initi select sampl gaelic seafood ireland administr compani remain sampl hoga salmon wester sound salmon norwegian interest ip view financi posit compani reconsid product plan futur year result fewer smolt put sea autumn note commun industri advantag increas consumpt observ analysi period increas product capac sale growth accompani increas level employ invest spite commun industri effort improv product counter sever price depress ip level profit declin dramat return invest conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri characteris price depress fall profit insuffici return invest mean articl basic anti dump regul causat injuri introduct accord articl basic anti dump regul examin dump import origin chile caus injuri commun industri degre enabl classifi materi factor dump import time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor incorrectli attribut dump import effect dump import volum dump import origin chile increas threefold analysi period absolut term increas share commun market period ip rate growth mark ip doubl volum dump import undercut price sampl commun industri produc period commun industri lower price averag profit develop posit break ip rate return invest signific number posit develop commun industri doubl sale expand market share invest increas capac reduc cost product focus analysi develop ip show complex ambigu pictur market share held import chile chilean price drop fairli high level percentag point slightli level time commun industri market share increas price drop percentag point profit rate return invest recal import chilean compani found dump analysi direct causal link limit import found dump volum market share price import basi data eurostat sampl exercis shown note net weight convert fish equival convers factor averag price kg base fish basi situat ip extrapol earlier year analysi period gt tabl gt volum import doubl ip market share increas factor price import commun industri period level undercut ip sampl compani found dump exceed increas volum dump import ip signific level price undercut coincid deterior situat commun industri term averag sale price profit light posit develop situat commun industri note recit factor includ limit competit fresh frozen salmon commun market conclud absolut certainti dump import consid isol respons materi injuri suffer commun industri subsequ disclosur parti argu commiss understand interact fresh frozen salmon market wrong investig confirm import product concern origin chile exclus frozen salmon commun industri sold fresh salmon parti claim processor differ prefer bui frozen salmon price lower fresh salmon claim evidenc fact chilean import market share norwegian scottish produc continu address argument recal establish limit competit fresh frozen salmon market ip competit restrict user type salmon product market continu demonstr mark prefer fresh salmon frozen salmon claim chilean import market share norwegian scottish supplier acknowledg norwegian import lose market share ip product salmon produc scotland reach record level ip period market share produc commun commun industri consid separ increas evid parti mistaken claim declin market share scottish produc futur develop chilean import volum market share recal scope investig articl basic anti dump regul event occur ip argument parti accept effect factor import origin countri norwai import player commun salmon market import origin norwai increas volum term declin ip import grew slower rate appar commun consumpt market share declin approxim ip commun consumpt continu increas whilst volum import norwai declin share commun market fell approxim basi inform obtain eurostat averag price import norwai remain stabl eur kilogram increas reach eur kilogram ip averag price declin eur kilogram close price level commun industri import norwai found undercut price commun industri import origin faero island increas volum fall back record sharp increas volum ip reach level tonn time gain highest market share analysi period basi inform obtain eurostat averag price import faero island increas eur kilogram eur kilogram ip averag price fell eur kilogram recal import origin faero island found dump undercut price commun industri final note market share import faero island held commun industri chile subsequ disclosur parti question commiss consid role plai import norwai faero island assess injuri commun industri parti argu calcul level price undercut import norwai base incorrect commun industri price includ deliveri cost custom parti claim commiss ascrib import faero island import deserv assess injuri view market share level price undercut argument calcul price undercut import norwai reject reason firstli comparison made similar level trade similar present salmon upward adjust eur kg made price commun industri produc sell quot bin quot farm reflect ancillari transport process pack cost custom methodolog consist origin investig level price undercut import faero island calcul manner import norwai recal import faero island found made dump price level price undercut deriv dump commiss acknowledg impact import situat commun industri ascrib import injuri assess import faero island weaken causal link import chile injuri suffer commun industri import origin remain countri exclud norwai chile faero island increas volum analysi period approxim tonn tonn ip period market share increas ip import weight fish equival basi frozen fillet cn code signific origin peopl republ china quot china quot usa averag price type product concern remain countri increas eur kilogram eur ip price import price sampl commun industri produc import norwai chile faero island analysi period natur qualiti import current investig found evid farm atlant salmon produc china case salmon declar cn code subject investig speci salmon pacif danub process atlant salmon origin farm countri gt tabl gt show commun industri import chile peripher player commun market exclud import countri recit partli respons decreas price injuri suffer commun industri pattern consumpt consumpt farm atlant salmon commun increas analysi period reach level tonn ip commun industri benefit growth consumpt increas product sale commun industri increas market share ip import norwai declin volum develop consumpt consid contribut injuri suffer commun industri natur salmon market consid factor bear salmon market commun contribut injuri suffer commun industri faero fish farm associ argu exist number factor demonstr causal link import farm atlant salmon faero island alleg injuri suffer commun industri suggest short term price govern factor weather diseas smolt suppli long term price trend depend product cost argu view length product cycl farm atlant salmon year price examin similar period month year argu type salmon wild salmon farm pacif salmon account investig suppli impact price farm atlant salmon commun short term factor diseas impact suppli salmon market outbreak diseas infecti salmon anaemia isa commun requir remov fish affect area enforc fallow period month isa detect number farm scotland record norwai canada recent faero island remov fish infect site mean harvest ahead expect weight meet requir custom addit enforc harvest reduc total biomass fish harvest period small number compani form part commun industri affect suspect isa outbreak reduc number fish harvest subsequ year consid situat explain deterior situat commun industri observ ip regard parti point accept incorrect examin price restrict period ip whilst acknowledg life cycl farm atlant salmon year product cycl excus engag dump regard final argument rais interest parti influenc type salmon commun market farm atlant salmon note evid provid support argument argument suggest farm pacif salmon wild salmon homogen natur farm atlant salmon substitut claim evid found investig event take account volum farm salmon sold commun believ quantiti type salmon sold commun market significantli affect commun market price farm atlant salmon structur salmon farm industri commun faero fish farm associ drew attent effect commun industri increas product record analysi period produc commun form part commun industri suggest process consolid produc commun meant commun industri reduc size face increas competit larger numer produc commun part commun industri defin pursuant articl basic anti dump regul investig confirm categori produc refer faero fish farm associ account major farm atlant salmon produc commun analysi period compani gener larger size compani deem constitut commun industri present investig show greater degre vertic integr interest smolt rear freshwat stage salmon life cycl feed product control process facil market share region part larg multin group quot stock exchang benefit access capit market financi support suit plan product meet specif requir major custom supermarket chain dai harvest program negoti short medium term contract major custom provid degre protect extrem price fluctuat uncontract spot market oper expos inform gather transform smoker product concern framework review investig import norwai demonstr produc commun influenc process industri oper price process compani purchas product concern ip price sold salmon transform examin establish compani purchas commun produc salmon ip price similar salmon origin norwai transform smoke salmon sold product deriv salmon produc commun sold higher price product deriv salmon origin norwai premium product deriv salmon produc commun found region similar product deriv norwegian produc salmon transform smoker obtain premium product pass supplier consid injuri suffer commun industri due lack leverag vi vi larger custom conclus causat light conclud causal link import origin chile materi injuri commun industri establish degre certainti concurr increas import chile price undercut hand neg develop commun industri term sale price financi perform suffici establish causal link case number factor impact commun industri compar impact import chile greater import import countri concern made price case norwai level commun industri regard countri level price produc commun level import chile sale repres commun market sale produc commun import faero island made price level unsatisfactori commun industri circumst difficult import chile isol materi impact commun industri subsequ disclosur parti criticis manner issu causat examin parti argu commiss made cumul assess effect import chile norwai faero island accord articl basic anti dump regul articl specifi number criteria satisfi effect import origin assess cumul present investig dump found import norwai faero island legal basi assess combin effect import origin dump import chile claim reject ground incorrect interpret provis articl concern view fact causal link exclud absolut certainti consid prudent examin question imposit measur import chile commun interest decid causal link exist evid contrari commun interest preliminari remark examin find injuri dump compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest impos measur import origin chile purpos accord articl basic anti dump regul impact measur parti involv investig consequ parti take measur consid basi evid submit order commun interest inform request interest parti concern made time limit set notic initi addit repli receiv sampl commun industri produc questionnair repli receiv compani produc farm atlant salmon commun marin harvest scotland marin harvest ireland supplier input commun salmon farm industri includ feed compani trouw uk trouw aquacultur ewo biomar supplier smolt landcatch framework review norwai import user framework review norwai unrel export norwai moulin de la march le borvo sa unrel import user framework investig chile faero island coges miko royal greenland seafood comment receiv organis bodi scottish salmon produc organis shetland salmon farmer associ irish salmon grower associ beuc european consum organis aipc cep feder nation organis import export fish danish associ fish process industri export french syndicat nation de industri du saumon fumé nutreco aquacultur sa direct ocean inform receiv feed supplier locat commun havsbrun pf faero island consid inform account assess commun interest current investig complain investig chile faero island submit view nutreco group syndicat nation de industri du saumon fumé discount argu interest nutreco group predominantli eu membership syndicat nation de industri du saumon fumé includ number compani relat norwegian concern recal assess commun interest accord provis articl basic anti dump regul base appreci interest parti includ inter alia domest industri user submiss interest parti account interest commun industri main area product salmon commun locat scotland ireland suitabl condit exist signific structur salmon farm industri commun origin investig trend fewer larger compani number smaller produc busi sold oper larg multin group salmon farm interest world compani constitut commun industri step improv effici reduc cost face increas competit enter collabor arrang feed bui enabl compani increas bui power vi vi supplier time number compani constitut commun industri enter arrang joint market sale product hope product differenti market recal inform gather review investig norwai recit show commun salmon produc deriv full benefit premium consum paid finish product recal chilean export frozen salmon compet commun industri fresh salmon limit extent commun industri market share ip import origin countri chile norwai faero island account commun consumpt imposit measur import origin chile lead posit effect situat commun industri necessit price import product concern sourc increas produc commun part commun industri consequ small market share commun industri vi vi supplier commun market imposit measur chile lead substanti net transfer wealth commun market adjust higher price higher price born consum share intermediari sale chain transfer wealth countri supplier greatli exce benefit measur commun industri deriv highli doubt anti dump measur import chile lead price increas salmon sourc commun industri benefit small market share chilean salmon interest commun produc produc commun cooper proceed emploi peopl salmon relat activ ip combin turnov excess eur million compani suffer mark deterior econom situat ip result mark disturb commun market highlight import role plai salmon farm outli disadvantag area commun note problem market arisen imbal suppli demand suggest good year price combin effect number factor includ diseas problem scotland restrict suppli suppli produc countri includ scotland led sharp fall price claim commun produc salmon supplier serv proper balanc establish suppli demand argu achiev stimul demand manag suppli line demand invest fund commun produc address competit regulatori differ vi vi produc countri nutreco aquacultur divis nutreco group marin harvest compani belong measur optim solut salmon industri produc commun countri export commun note measur inter alia address oversuppli salmon promot effici competit eu produc interest import user consum import cooper framework investig chile faero opinion commun interest aspect investig sale farm atlant salmon repres insignific part turnov represent receiv behalf sa direct ocean compani note import frozen salmon chile product readi meal aim low middl incom consum suggest product competit fresh salmon scotland claim measur chile benefit commun scottish salmon farmer suppli frozen salmon claim thousand job food process industri put risk measur import chile impos feder nation organis import export fish aipc cep express opposit system impact suppli demand result increas price made obtain suppli difficult consid price rise natur level market neg term competit eu industri consum feder provid data show member process excess tonn salmon year produc tonn smoke salmon estim number peopl directli emploi sector exce danish associ fish process industri export made clear opposit regul market disturb price normal rule competit suggest exist measur distort market salmon commun led excess profit made norwai high profit claim turn encourag invest salmon farm industri creat imbal suppli demand world wide associ highlight import process industri commun term employ ad creat syndicat nation de industri du saumon fumé repres compani franc involv product smoke salmon compani emploi peopl process approxim tonn fresh salmon ip associ consid anti dump regul mechan regul trade agricultur product subject signific price movement salmon farm industri manag growth global basi european consum organis beuc note market salmon commun increas markedli larg opinion result increas competit produc norwai recent chile faero island suggest competit led declin price allow european consum increas intak salmon fact welcom perceiv nutrit benefit salmon time argu econom interest import processor retail salmon commun outweigh potenti short term benefit measur bring small number independ produc remain commun result beuc express opposit measur kind import commun farm atlant salmon light comment receiv repres associ consid imposit measur lead user reloc product facil countri commun context note convent tariff applic import fresh frozen atlant salmon commun ip import smoke salmon eurostat data analysi period shown tabl half import declar ip head cn pacif atlant danub salmon smoke includ fillet origin poland import origin norwai faero island import origin signific data suggest measur place norwai appreci impact trade flow smoke salmon recal measur norwai impos import smoke salmon year consid order meaning pictur figur show lower level import origin poland tonn record tonn figur import origin norwai year tonn faero island tonn appar imposit measur led signific increas volum import smoke salmon poland replac product origin denmark volum countri rest commun declin approxim tonn tonn gt tabl gt note european commun member state recent conclud free trade agreement chile agreement convent duti import product concern elimin date agreement enter forc trade salmon relat product smoke salmon note agreement forese gradual elimin exist tariff year period tandem system aggreg quota tonn product classifi head smoke salt brine view quantiti involv quota system futur access poland european union propos discontinu measur norwai consid imposit measur chile lead delocalis salmon process industri countri impact measur final consum inform submit norwegian seafood feder retail price supermarket franc atlant salmon fillet account demonstr averag price fluctuat narrow band shown tabl argu eu consum benefit reduct product cost achiev produc fact echo eu salmon produc group made point salmon agreement exist measur recognis effect consum price primari beneficiari fall produc price appear retail wholesal submiss consum farm atlant salmon extent insul extrem price volatil market unclear precis extent consum impact imposit measur chile depend partli price polici retail cooper proceed gt tabl gt conclus whilst recognis import salmon process sector term employ creation consid basi evid impact measur lead delocalis process activ locat commun consid import user disadvantag measur pai addit duti import salmon chile interest supplier cooper supplier made review norwai comment detail impact potenti measur chilean import activ supplier express opinion measur mean address situat commun salmon produc conclus commun interest acknowledg exist measur import norwai initi enabl commun industri improv econom situat regard level product sale profit market share absenc likelihood continu recurr dump subsidis import countri measur import norwai continu measur limit chilean export assum consid injuri probabl ineffici due limit price competit fresh frozen salmon recit difficulti commun industri experi reap benefit price increas measur chilean export trigger price increas price fresh salmon commun market suppos benefit commun industri result transfer wealth produc export countri subject measur outweigh benefit accru commun industri interest parti time recal increas price detriment import user consum subsequ disclosur parti criticis manner commiss made assess commun interest parti interest commun industri properli account argu commun industri small argument protect measur approach contradict stanc adopt similar situat past notabl time measur origin impos import norwai parti argu appreci view parti investig mistaken suggest opinion express produc commun cooper investig part complain consid repres view produc commun made claim norwegian own salmon produc locat commun instruct cooper commiss claim job immin risk disappear measur impos matter urgenc express view situat commun market expect deterior trade defenc measur usa expect lead increas trade divers chilean export market commun note assess commun interest made basi inform submit view interest parti address includ drew experi exist measur applic norwegian import accept situat present case similar prevail time previou investig norwai time market share commun industri determin norwegian import imposit measur time cover major import product concern commun afford protect commun industri signific share market present case assess commun interest limit consider measur dump import chile import account market share ip total import addit market share commun industri significantli reduc process restructur consolid market continu issu rais parti question commun interest acknowledg nutreco group compani produc commun industri cooper investig whilst intent portrai view nutreco repres salmon produc commun note group largest produc salmon commun assess commun interest call appreci interest inappropri due consider view express nutreco recognis salmon farm industri employ remot area commun employ opportun limit figur job support evid provid overst figur publish scottish execut show peopl directli emploi full time part time salmon product scotland view significantli lower product volum farm atlant salmon ireland figur direct employ countri expect lower underlin primari purpos anti dump instrument counter unfair trade practic specif purpos commun interest test determin overrid interest imposit measur exist injuri dump call appreci econom interest involv commun parti final point relat trade defenc measur place usa repercuss commun salmon market note measur impos author suggest measur impos import fresh salmon usa mean frozen salmon account export chile commun unaffect administr review process undertaken author usa subsequ imposit origin measur result lower level duti chilean export consid trade defenc measur usa constitut suffici justif imposit measur commun import chile light forego claim made parti detail recit reject basi inform submit conclud commun interest appli measur termin proceed view find conclud proceed import origin norwai termin anti dump countervail measur initi adopt regul ec ec allow expir conclud basi find anti dump proceed import origin chile faero island termin adopt regul articl anti dump anti subsidi proceed import farm atlant salmon fall cn code origin norwai termin articl anti dump proceed import farm atlant salmon fall cn code origin chile faero island termin articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel council presid dry oj regul amend regul ec oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj oj decis amend decis ec oj oj oj regul amend council regul ec oj oj oj