commiss regul ec januari impos provision anti dump duti import barium carbon origin peopl republ china commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun basic regul articl thereof consult advisori committe procedur initi april commiss announc notic notic initi publish offici journal european union initi anti dump proceed regard import commun barium carbon origin peopl republ china prc countri concern proceed initi result complaint lodg march solvai barium strontium gmbh complain sole produc barium carbon commun repres commun product complaint contain evid dump product materi injuri result therefrom consid suffici justifi initi proceed parti concern proceed commiss offici advis complain export produc import supplier user concern repres prc initi proceed interest parti opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi complain produc export produc import user user associ made view interest parti request show reason heard grant hear order export produc prc submit claim market economi treatment met individu treatment wish commiss met claim form chines compani concern compani request met pursuant articl basic regul investig establish meet condit met notic initi commiss view appar larg number export produc import sampl appli investig lower expect number export produc prc import user commun willing cooper decid sampl commiss questionnair parti concern compani made deadlin set notic initi repli receiv complain commun produc unrel import raw materi supplier user associ user export produc prc commiss sought verifi inform deem provision determin dump result injuri commun interest verif visit carri premis compani commun produc solvai barium strontium gmbh germani export produc prc hubei jingshan chutian barium salt corp zaozhuang yongli chemic guizhou hongkaj chemic relat hengyang hong xiang guizhou red star develop hebei xinji chemic group unrel import kimp sarl franc norkem bv netherland commun user ilpea spa itali view establish normal export produc prc met grant verif visit establish normal basi data analogu countri place premis compani chemic product corpor cpc cartersvil produc unit state america investig period investig dump injuri cover period januari decemb ip examin trend relev assess injuri cover period januari end ip period consid product concern product product concern product concern barium carbon strontium content weight sulphur content weight powder press granular calcin granular form origin prc fall cn code product differ found product concern barium carbon produc sold domest market prc unit state america usa serv analogu countri purpos establish normal respect import prc barium carbon produc sold usa basic physic chemic characterist compar export prc commun likewis differ found product concern barium carbon produc commun industri sold commun market share physic chemic characterist barium carbon produc sold domest market prc barium carbon produc sold domest market analogu countri barium carbon produc sold commun commun industri basic physic chemic characterist conclud type barium carbon consid alik mean articl basic regul dump market economi treatment anti dump investig import origin prc normal determin accord paragraph articl basic regul produc found meet criteria laid articl basic regul briefli eas refer criteria fulfil applic compani demonstr set summaris form busi decis cost made respons market signal signific state interfer account record independ audit line intern account standard appli purpos signific distort carri market economi system legal certainti stabil provid bankruptci properti law currenc exchang carri market rate export produc prc request met pursuant articl basic regul repli met claim form export produc request compani reject basi analysi met claim form fail show criteria met compani fulli predominantli state own board director predominantli consist state nomin director demonstr signific state interfer busi decis remain compani commiss sought verifi premis compani inform submit met applic deem investig show compani fulfil criteria requir grant met export produc prc grant met hubei jingshan chutian barium salt corp zaozhuang yongli chemic tabl summaris determin compani met grant criteria set articl basic regul sourc verifi questionnair repli cooper chines export compani criteria articl indent articl indent articl indent articl indent articl indent met met met met met met met compani concern opportun comment find compani concern sharehold relat compani identifi establish ultim control compani signific state interfer exclud compani contest fact provid inform evid shown control privat entrepreneur free signific state interfer conclud criteria laid articl indent basic regul fulfil compani investig reveal signific defici audit account compani auditor made reserv regard book sale figur asset valuat depreci correct made order rectifi shortcom identifi auditor explan compani account reserv express auditor shortcom make reliabl dump calcul basi compani contest conclus provid reason explan account reliabl defici view element set put question reliabl account problem identifi auditor correct conclud criterion set articl indent basic regul met final acquisit compani asset concern compani explain condit compani asset transfer collect own pre exist compani commiss conclud condit articl indent basic regul met compani disagre conclus provid inform evid regard transfer asset shown signific distort market economi regim claim made compani unfound reject advisori committe consult parti directli concern inform commun industri opportun comment oppos met determin individu treatment articl basic regul countri wide duti establish countri fall articl basic regul case compani demonstr accord articl basic regul free repatri capit profit export price quantiti condit term sale freeli determin major share belong privat person state offici board director hold kei manag posit minor demonstr compani nonetheless suffici independ state interfer exchang rate convers carri market rate state interfer permit circumvent measur export rate duti export produc met grant claim individu treatment commiss examin export produc demonstr compli criteria set articl basic regul compani compani found fulli predomin state own board director consist fulli state nomin director compani demonstr suffici independ state interfer meet condit set articl basic regul export produc compani partli privat own demonstr ultim control signific state interfer exclud consequ compani demonstr met criterion basic regul compani found risk circumvent measur export individu duti rate risk result partli mention state influenc oper compani fact export demonstr absenc signific state influenc commod natur product concern identifi produc produc risk circumvent measur export compani lower duti deem signific compani meet condit set articl basic regul export produc met condit set articl basic regul conclud grant export produc met grant normal determin normal export produc grant met analogu countri pursuant articl basic regul normal export produc grant met establish basi price construct market economi countri analogu countri notic initi usa envisag market economi countri purpos establish normal prc interest parti invit comment choic export produc contest choic claim level econom develop manufactur process access raw materi usa prc argu level competit usa low barium carbon produc domest market protect anti dump duti south korea russia india propos altern analogu countri commiss sought cooper potenti analogu countri india japan brazil produc countri cooper case commiss conclud south korea analogu countri domest sourc barit import raw materi insignific product barium carbon commiss reject russia analogu countri barium carbon produc russia significantli lower qualiti compar product produc prc commun investig reveal domest market brazil small level protect higher usa brazil consid analogu countri evid indic countri propos altern analogu countri suitabl usa regard usa found product volum substanti repres regard chines export barium carbon level econom develop product process concern consid differ usa highli industrialis economi produc usa emploi advanc effici product method prc note differ affect normal result lower normal usa advantag chines export produc recal adjust made case local variat product process exclud demonstr countri usa product process compar prc competit domest market usa usa produc subject competit import prc germani mexico import countri repres approxim market consid substanti conclud fair level competit usa access raw materi concern found usa prc largest barit produc substanti barit reserv conclud access raw materi term avail compar usa prc view provision conclud unit state constitut analogu countri accord articl basic regul determin normal analogu countri pursuant articl basic regul normal export produc grant met establish basi verifi inform receiv produc analogu countri regard domest cost sale product usa market compar product type normal establish methodolog outlin recit domest sale usa repres albeit product type sold ordinari trade sold loss product type normal construct accord articl basic regul ad reason amount sell gener administr sg amp expens profit margin cost manufactur domest sale product concern repres compani sg amp consid reliabl profit margin concern compani profit margin realis domest sale product concern sale made loss produc cooper commiss profit margin applic product sale gener categori product accord articl basic regul product type normal establish weight averag domest sale price unrel custom cooper produc usa adjust determin normal export produc grant met determin normal concern commiss establish cooper export produc total domest sale barium carbon repres comparison total export sale commun accord articl basic regul domest sale consid repres total volum sale repres total export sale volum produc commun basi export produc domest sale product concern ip made repres quantiti commiss subsequ identifi type product concern sold domest ident directli compar type sold export commun type sold export produc domest market found directli compar type barium carbon sold export commun establish domest sale suffici repres purpos articl basic regul domest sale type barium carbon consid suffici repres total domest sale volum type ip repres total sale volum compar type barium carbon export commun result analysi product type sold repres quantiti commiss subsequ examin domest sale type barium carbon sold domest repres quantiti regard made ordinari trade accord articl basic regul establish proport profit sale independ custom barium carbon type question domest sale transact consid profit unit price specif product type equal cost product cost product product type sold domest market ip determin export produc claim adjust start cost basi product normal capac utilis rate start begin ip compani start produc barium carbon shortli begin ip compani argu bought product line invest substanti amount repair test product final normal product start claim averag start phase product line month normal product start month begin ip contrast claim export produc found monthli product sale volum level entir ip case exceed monthli volum produc sold period allegedli normal capac utilis rate reach substanti sale volum entir ip point sale mere test product conclud compani produc normal capac utilis rate entir ip compani show alleg start phase unit product cost higher period allegedli normal capac utilis rate reach case cost higher consequ lower product volum evidenc conclud claim adjust regard start cost contradictori confirm evid reject produc claim depreci method compani quot invest fix asset quot reflect cost product sale product concern invest made correspond initi repair cost product line acquisit account financi year compani consid life repair asset year compani expect make invest period repair need product line actual lifetim invest longer origin expect compani claim depreci period adapt accord econom realiti cost book account adjust pursuant articl basic regul regard claim consid higher normal repair expens year ownership equip unusu book higher cost year correspond normal account practic methodolog chosen compani unreason correspond normal practic fact repair cost incur justifi depart normal account practic compani claim adjust cost regard warrant reject export produc claim product sulphur deduct cost product product concern sulphur process ga set free automat produc barium carbon compani technic mean measur quantiti ga product sulphur quantifi claim compani account system sulphur product concern treat separ product cost produc barium carbon establish take account sulphur basi claim provision reject mention recit proport profit sale independ custom domest market product type question establish case sale volum barium carbon type sold net sale price equal calcul cost product repres total sale volum type weight averag price type equal cost product normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag price domest sale type made ip irrespect sale profit case volum profit sale barium carbon type repres total sale volum type weight averag price type cost product normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag profit sale type provid sale repres total sale volum type case volum profit sale product type repres total sale volum type consid type sold insuffici quantiti domest price provid basi establish normal result analysi found product type sold ordinari trade reason price product type sold repres quantiti sold ordinari trade reason price domest price export produc question order establish normal method appli regard commiss construct normal accord articl basic regul accord articl basic regul normal construct basi export produc cost manufactur reason amount sell gener administr sg amp expens profit sg amp profit realis export produc concern domest market constitut reliabl data mean articl basic regul export produc sg amp profit case normal construct export price cooper chines export produc grant met export sale determin individu compani basi export sale commun export produc concern made directli independ custom commun export price establish accord articl basic regul basi price paid payabl comparison normal export price compar work basi level trade purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ affect price price compar accord articl basic regul adjust grant case found reason accur support verifi evid basi allow differ pack cost credit cost discount rebat commiss inland freight insur handl sale servic level trade made bank charg concern adjust articl basic regul made level trade concern found major domest sale usa made end user export sale product concern prc made exclus distributor adjust calcul basi averag price differ sale end user sale distributor usa domest market accord articl basic regul found prc larg quantiti main raw materi barit access specif mine process usa barit mine surfac underground addit raw materi china transport factori involv practic transport cost usa cost transport barit mine factori substanti consid adjust normal usa warrant order bring condit product barium carbon usa compar level prc normal adjust take account major differ product condit differ cost product transport main raw materi barit final found usa substanti environment cost incur prc cost exist normal adjust dump margin cooper export produc grant met articl basic regul dump margin export produc establish basi comparison weight averag normal weight averag export price product type determin provision dump margin cooper export produc met grant express percentag cif net free commun frontier price duti hubei jingshan chutian barium salt corp zaozhuang yongli chemic export produc order calcul countri wide dump margin applic export prc commiss establish level cooper comparison made total import product concern origin prc calcul basi eurostat actual questionnair repli receiv export prc met grant basi establish level cooper close dump margin remain cooper export grant met calcul compar weight averag normal establish analogu countri weight averag export price report cooper export arriv weight averag dump margin remain cooper export basi countri wide level dump provision establish cif commun frontier price injuri definit commun industri sole cooper commun produc account commun product barium carbon ip deem constitut commun industri mean articl articl basic regul commun industri constitut produc figur relat index reason confidenti commun consumpt commun consumpt establish basi sale volum commun industri commun market import prc countri base eurostat commun consumpt barium carbon decreas due difficult econom situat gener recov level import prc increas shown tabl ip commun consumpt tonn import countri concern volum market share import volum barium carbon prc commun increas tonn tonn ip period consid note import decreas tonn quickli recov ip market share increas period consid due substanti increas import prc price averag price import prc decreas constantli eur tonn eur tonn ip price undercut purpos analys price undercut weight averag sale price product type commun industri unrel custom commun market adjust work basi compar weight averag export price import concern establish cif basi adjust custom duti post import cost comparison made deduct rebat discount unlik import prc commun industri guarante stabl product custom specif impur offer custom servic laboratori analys market servic account price comparison make adjust price commun industri base inform receiv commun industri submit import user commun industri charg higher price due higher reactiv product argument reject prc export suppli equival product grade produc commun industri due technic progress made recent year addit reactiv grade barium carbon account sale commun industri consid adjust differ reactiv comparison show ip product concern origin prc sold commun price undercut commun industri price express percentag situat commun industri accord articl basic regul commiss examin relev econom factor indic bear state commun industri analys commun industri process recov effect past subsidis dump evid found case product commun industri product decreas period consid remain stabl diminish subsequ capac capac utilis capac utilis decreas period consid explain small increas total product capac commun industri period consid sale price market share sale volum unrel parti commun decreas ip sale relat custom consist total sale volum reduc market share rang rang averag price tonn fell turnov inventori stock finish product tripl reduc consider year amount doubl ip employ product wage employ commun industri decreas period consid wage increas gradual time calcul basi tonn produc employe increas subsequ growth commun consumpt remain basic stabl ip sale volum commun industri decreas hand volum import concern trend pronounc ip commun consumpt commun industri sale volum fall import prc rise sale commun industri grow demand period ip market share commun industri fell percentag point due import prc contrast chines market share increas percentag point ip invest invest doubl remain stabl return level invest made environment protect mainten profit return invest cash flow abil rais capit sale commun industri product profit period consid commun industri break level situat deterior sale highli unprofit ip return invest express profit loss relat net book asset neg period consid deterior year year ip return invest rang cash flow gener product produc sold commun decreas sharpli ip highli posit neg declin year amount eur ip invest low commun industri found experienc difficulti abil rais capit form loan bank equiti parent compani magnitud dump margin volum price dump import countri concern impact actual margin dump consid neglig conclus injuri examin abovement factor show ip situat commun industri deterior consider sale volum fell period consid result signific loss market share averag price fell turnov diminish significantli product volum capac utilis trend due neg develop profit return invest cash flow deterior consider period consid situat commun industri found deterior extent provision conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri mean articl basic regul causal introduct accord articl basic regul commiss examin dump import barium carbon origin countri concern caus injuri commun industri degre enabl classifi materi accord articl basic regul factor dump import time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor attribut dump import effect dump import period consid dump import countri concern increas significantli term volum tonn tonn market share percentag point import increas import volum occur ip increas compar import price decreas period consid coincid decreas sale result loss market share commun industri percentag point drop averag sale price commun industri lower sale price significantli undercut ip dump import prc due low sale price commun industri cover cost product unprofit effect factor import countri period consid import volum barium carbon countri increas tonn tonn repres market share ip main countri export barium carbon commun brazil russia ip averag price import russia amount eur tonn mean russian product consider expens import prc slightli cheaper product sold commun industri import user qualiti barium carbon import russia lower qualiti product concern import prc product sold commun industri due fact barium carbon russia lower qualiti expens import prc competit commun market compar product sold commun industri qualiti barium carbon russia significantli lower compens small price differ russian product competit market share diminish period consid provision conclud import russia break causal link dump materi injuri caus chines import averag price import brazil eur tonn ip period consid market share import brazil rose percentag point take account small increas sale market share provision conclud import break causal link dump materi injuri caus chines import view find provision conclud import countri break causal link dump materi injuri caus chines import commun industri develop demand develop demand appar consumpt barium carbon decreas commun industri market share subsequ sale market share commun industri consumpt increas consider ip time chines import gain market share increas percent point period concern materi injuri suffer commun industri attribut contract demand commun market currenc fluctuat interest parti claim depreci usd euro favour import barium carbon european commun vast major import transact countri concern european commun invoic usd euro appreci usd mid significantli ip favour export euro area base exchang rate prevail begin import prc undercut price commun industri addit favour exchang rate situat impact import countri invoic usd fact currenc fluctuat major effect import countri consid main causal factor import surg dump import countri concern provision conclud appreci euro respect usd favour import barium carbon european commun suffici break causal link dump import materi injuri suffer commun industri import commun industri submit commun industri import barium carbon prc contribut injuri suffer commun industri purchas product prc import year neglig quantiti product provision conclud import commun industri product concern prc determin reason materi injuri suffer commun industri factor user import argu commun suffer injuri due competit water suspend slurri barium carbon elimin toxic dust gener barium carbon powder form slurri produc import commun powder import prc ad water specif addit import argument reject commun industri produc slurri promot consid econom transport water develop cooper european compani equip specif brick tile industri enabl user barium carbon mix powder water point product elimin gener toxic dust commun industri offer competit product slurri slurri produc barium carbon import china dump price sold price price powder suppli commun industri consid factor caus injuri impact slurri result dump import product concern import dump price product offer commun industri competit slurri compet fair term slurri conclus causat analysi demonstr substanti increas volum market share import origin countri concern ip consider decreas sale price high level price undercut ip increas market share low price chines import coincid signific drop market share commun industri downward pressur price result inter alia substanti loss commun industri ip hand examin factor injur commun industri reveal signific neg impact break causal link dump import prc materi injuri suffer commun industri base analysi properli distinguish separ effect factor situat commun industri injuri effect dump import provision conclud import prc caus materi injuri commun mean articl basic regul commun interest preliminari remark accord articl basic regul commiss examin conclus injuri dump compel reason exist conclud commun interest adopt measur case determin commun interest base appreci interest involv commun industri import user product concern investig order assess impact imposit imposit measur commiss request inform interest parti commiss questionnair commun industri supplier raw materi import user product concern commun produc supplier raw materi import user associ user repli commun industri commun industri fulli autom product line oper cost effici spec materi number employe tonn produc made replac invest continu export consid imposit measur restor fair competit market measur commun industri regain part lost market share consequ posit impact profit mention commun industri suffer materi injuri caus dump import origin countri concern measur impos deterior situat commun industri probabl entail loss employ price depress effect dump import continu foil effort commun industri regain profit level take measur jeopardis long term presenc industri exclud sole commun produc shut result competit dump import measur impos supplier raw materi questionnair repli receiv supplier raw materi suppli natur barium sulphat commun industri sole supplier main raw materi product barium carbon locat commun measur impos commun industri regain lost market share supplier raw materi sell product raw materi concern constitut major part turnov compani improv financi situat raw materi supplier measur impos sale commun industri continu demand raw materi neg affect profit raw materi supplier import questionnair repli receiv import imposit measur product concern import powder form prc subsequ transform import slurri ad water special addit profit margin import sale product concern slurri weight averag basi import bear part price increas pass part custom view low duti impos compani oper market economi condit altern sourc duti price increas limit take account fact sale product concern slurri account averag import total turnov financi situat import affect imposit duti basi provision conclud effect anti dump measur materi impact import user questionnair repli user submiss associ user receiv verif visit carri compani purchas biggest quantiti barium carbon ip cooper user repres total commun consumpt barium carbon ip number staff compani directli relat product barium carbon peopl cooper user purchas commun industri posit imposit anti dump duti fear lose cheap sourc suppli harm competit downstream market vi vi competitor countri user barium carbon concentr tv glass product brick tile industri ceram sector product ferrit base questionnair repli inform submit hear share barium carbon total cost product user establish averag duti result signific reduct competit shortag suppli foreseen import china remain competit price individu duti propos chines export produc level undercut found addit altern sourc suppli countri duti basi conclud user continu bui barium carbon competit price expect impact duti competit user vi vi competitor countri limit submit commun industri posit satisfi demand barium carbon commun respect recal measur intend prevent import commun ensur made injuri dump price import origin continu satisfi signific part commun demand shortag suppli expect basi provision conclud effect anti dump measur materi impact user competit trade distort effect respect effect measur competit commun cooper export produc concern strong market posit continu sell product albeit dump price low duti rate chines export produc oper market economi condit oper fair market condit commun rang duti impos suffici number major competitor commun market includ produc countri concern brazil russia india user continu choic supplier barium carbon hand measur impos futur sole commun produc stake disappear effect reduc competit commun market conclus commun interest reason provision conclud compel reason imposit anti dump duti present case propos provision anti dump measur injuri elimin level view conclus reach regard dump injuri causat commun interest provision anti dump measur impos order prevent injuri caus commun industri dump import order establish level duti account level dump margin found amount duti elimin injuri suffer commun industri commun industri suffer dump import profit achiev absenc dump import base weight averag profit margin product year basi found profit margin turnov regard minimum commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump price increas determin basi comparison weight averag import price establish price undercut calcul injuri price product sold commun industri commun market injuri price obtain adjust sale price commun industri actual loss made ip ad abovement profit margin differ result comparison express percentag total cif import injuri elimin level higher dump margin establish provision measur base provision measur light forego consid accord articl basic regul provision anti dump duti impos respect import origin prc level lower dump injuri margin accord lesser duti rule case individu duti rate countri wide duti set level dump margin found product fungibl price differ product type substanti found duti impos form specif amount tonn order ensur effici measur discourag absorpt anti dump measur decreas export price amount result applic dump margin export price calcul dump ip individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countri wide duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti commiss consult advisori committe amend regul updat list compani benefit individu duti rate product concern fungibl explain brand varianc individu duti rate signific number export produc element facilit attempt channel export flow tradit export benefit lowest duti rate export compani benefit lower individu duti rate increas volum individu measur concern consid insuffici counteract injuri dump found provid requisit element met investig initi order correct appropri measur form level final provis interest sound administr period fix interest parti made time limit notic initi make view write request hear state find imposit duti made purpos regul provision reconsid purpos definit measur adopt regul articl provision anti dump duti impos import barium carbon strontium content weight sulphur content weight powder press granular calcin granular form fall cn code taric code origin peopl republ china amount provision anti dump duti equal fix amount product produc manufactur countri manufactur rate duti eur taric addit code peopl republ china hubei jingshan chutian barium salt corp qinglong road songh town jingshan counti hubei provinc prc zaozhuang yongli chemic south zhuzibukuang qichun zaozhuang citi center district shangdong provinc prc compani releas free circul commun product refer paragraph subject provis secur equival amount provision duti case good damag entri free circul price paid payabl apport determin custom pursuant articl commiss regul eec amount anti dump duti calcul basi fix amount set reduc percentag correspond apport price paid payabl provis forc custom duti appli articl prejudic articl council regul ec interest parti request disclosur essenti fact consider basi regul adopt make view write appli heard oral commiss month date entri forc regul pursuant articl council regul ec parti concern comment applic regul month date entri forc articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union articl regul appli period month regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel januari commiss peter mandelson member commiss oj regul amend regul ec oj oj european commiss director gener trade direct brussel oj