council regul ec januari impos definit anti dump duti collect definit provision anti dump duti impos import urea origin belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur commiss regul ec provision regul impos provision anti dump duti import urea fall cn code origin belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain regul decid termin proceed import urea origin egypt poland subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision measur import urea belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain interest parti submit comment write parti request grant opportun heard oral commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find addit verif visit carri premis commun produc fertiberia madrid hydro agri franc pari user commun libera associazion agricoltori cremonesi cremona parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit parti consid provision find modifi product consider product absenc comment definit product consider product recit provision regul confirm dump market economi countri normal applic articl basic regul export produc libya claim recit provision regul accur describ level cooper provid claim commiss awar implicitli accept fact compani account cover activ group submit due confidenti reason claim line libyan account requir public audit account file accord articl basic regul commiss reject compani account ground level cooper concern commiss indic accept compani refus submit essenti account document contrari repeatedli inform export produc applic articl basic regul includ fact due defici level cooper compani maintain posit submit substanti inform reconcil domest sale cost product product concern circumst order determin normal compani concern institut choic make fact inform provid complaint accord articl basic regul view incorrect assum compani absenc publicli audit account reason fact determin normal confirm fact report data verifi reconcil compani intern account establish export price libyan export produc recit provision regul export produc claim normal establish basi actual domest sale price altern construct basi compani account data basi data submit commun industri complaint argu purpos evid inform relat product sale urea libyan domest market provid compani fail consist submit essenti inform repli questionnair satisfactorili explain inconsist contradict reveal verif visit fact expressli point commiss defici letter spot establish complet correct domest sale report cost product submit submiss evid inform relat product sale urea libyan domest market concern find recit provision regul confirm mention recit provision regul absenc reliabl inform normal export produc libya establish basi data submit complaint accord articl basic regul export produc claim case profit margin complaint order construct normal overestim argu support claim profit margin urea busi tradition low basi find cooper export produc proceed commiss consid review level profit margin construct normal export produc libya outlin recit provision regul averag profit margin realis cooper export produc present investig sell product concern domest market accord articl basic regul construct normal export produc profit margin establish accord chapeau articl basic regul subparagraph valid reason identifi justifi appli profit margin libyan export produc absenc inform decid appli definit stage profit margin libyan produc order establish normal normal base domest sale export produc romania submit normal establish monthli basi due inflat romania investig period methodolog provision stage export produc romania imposit provision anti dump duti approach analys investig shown effect inflat justifi calcul monthli normal valu institut consist practic establish averag normal valu investig period situat hyperinfl condit fulfil case romania consid establish normal definit stage export produc romania basi averag price paid domest market investig period construct normal commun industri claim determin profit margin construct normal valu export produc bulgaria estonia lithuania minimum return capit emploi quot sustain viabl urea busi medium long term quot argu profit margin countri gener reliabl due quot overhang quot market economi system account polici compani concern investig reveal evid inform indic account compani concern reliabl determin profit margin institut altern establish normal valu accord articl basic regul profit margin establish accord articl basic regul basi profit realis gener categori product produc sold export produc concern domest market case lithuania case bulgaria estonia reason basi basi weight averag profit margin found cooper export produc proceed level profit margin establish accord articl basic regul basi weight averag profit margin cooper export produc profit domest sale examin termin proceed import urea origin egypt export produc egypt exclud calcul averag profit margin comment estonian export produc profit margin reconstruct normal reassess examin provision find made appar profit margin base sale product compani review product consid part gener categori product concern fertilis absenc suffici sale ordinari trade estonian export produc product concern product gener categori sold estonian compani concern reason method appli definit stage pursuant articl basic regul regard profit margin base weight averag profit margin cooper export produc concern bulgarian export produc recit lithuanian export produc argu sell gener administr cost sg amp profit ammonium nitrat construct normal claim urea ammonium nitrat fertilis sold market competit situat differ manufactur technolog market demand sell price cost produc urea lithuania absenc repres domest sale articl basic regul possibl determin sg amp profit urea nitrogen fertilis differ product technolog exist extent belong gener categori product requir basic regul sake argument market competit situat dissimilar produc import competit view decid maintain provision determin export price absenc comment interest parti find devalu provision find export price export produc concern establish provision confirm comparison handl load cost comment receiv libyan export produc regard calcul load handl cost export product concern commun commiss review calcul found calcul error correct market economi countri export produc belaru contest fact commiss allegedli treat cooper parti proceed compani claim provid commiss inform request consid reason treat cooper depriv right cooper parti opportun offer undertak present investig fact compani provid inform requir establish verifi export price led applic rule set articl basic regul cooper parti partial quot fact quot case export figur provid eurostat note contrari compani alleg partial applic articl depriv right interest parti receiv disclosur heard present written submiss consult confidenti file opportun offer undertak market economi statu quot me quot outlin recit provision regul accord articl basic regul compani ukrain file applic market economi condit prevail respect manufactur sale product concern quot market economi statu quot quot me quot recal ukrainian compani receiv me ukrainian export produc refus me disagre commiss find state interfer commun industri iter claim compani ukrain produc sell nitrogen fertilis includ urea subject signific state interfer gener basi me grant argu ukrainian fertilis market characteris exist toll agreement barter chain arrang state interfer energi electr transport cost factor incompat market economi situat argument export produc commun industri treat recit provision regul ad toll agreement consid se contradict me necessarili consid typic characterist state interfer state interfer transport cost concern account transport rate applic analogu countri energi electr cost evid found cost significantli distort state interfer substanti reflect market compar natur ga cost energi electr major input urea individu treatment commun industri object decis grant individu treatment ukrainian export produc argu sharehold state compani signific state interfer inform evid submit complain commun industri show alleg state interfer permit circumvent measur impos claim reject find provision regul recit confirm sale toll agreement recit provision regul compani ukrain involv toll agreement recal ukrainian law provid raw materi remain owner finish product compani transform acquir properti right good investig reveal compani grant me consid export produc product concern compani establish long term busi relationship compani base countri relationship compani virtual sole supplier toll agreement owner product process main raw materi compani activ involv export sale product concern fact relationship compani usual buyer seller relationship absenc cooper ga supplier full cost manufactur price paid payabl export sale establish verifi note inform export price independ buyer inform verifi establish dump margin cooper supplier legal owner main raw materi finish product normal export price ukrainian compani concern reliabl establish individu dump margin establish compani ukrainian compani grant me individu treatment realis export sale toll agreement absenc cooper ga supplier absenc verifi export price independ buyer price transact establish recit purpos assess countri wide dump margin final compani part domest export sale toll agreement likewis absenc cooper supplier absenc verifi price independ buyer commun institut option disregard sale made toll agreement remain domest sale repres determin recit provision duti regul ukrainian compani sale basi toll ga supplier equal refus cooper argu sale data submit accur reliabl provid suffici evid allow transact account determin normal export price verif visit establish invoic price payment urea includ account record compani absenc cooper supplier ga account data regist evid actual payment transact inform verifi accept normal analogu countri ukrainian export produc argu normal base domest price cost analogu countri normal base domest sale ukrainian export produc grant me commun institut consist practic line articl basic regul determin normal basi paragraph articl basic regul produc show oper line market economi condit produc countri normal determin basi articl basi price construct market economi countri reason basi foreseen articl warrant respect provision find belarussian export produc ukrainian export produc govern belaru ukrain import associ object choic usa analogu countri claim lithuania market economi countri parti alleg usa choic high ga cost lead distort urea price level econom develop compar belaru ukrain differ market size fact produc usa cooper argument usa market economi countri argu lithuania analogu countri claim volum urea produc lithuania repres compar volum export urea ukrain belaru commun ip claim lithuania open competit market import duti exist similar access natur ga similar product process belaru ukrain fact produc urea lithuania consid irrelev parti lithuania countri produc product concern previou investig product belong categori commun institut examin argument detail conclus usa market ten produc urea oper compar produc ukrain produc lithuania fact anti dump duti exist usa import urea soviet union countri substanti import million ton urea number countri investig reveal import duti applic lithuania import urea import remain low level usa vast urea market million ton year lithuanian urea market practic exist sale urea investig period quot ip quot lithuanian market minim inform provid lithuanian produc made ordinari trade conclud market urea highli competit contrast lithuanian market final contrari lithuania domest sale usa repres compar belaru ukrainian export commun fact produc cooper investig render conclus invalid fact price produc establish normal subject competit quantiti sold produc repres compar total quantiti export belaru ukrain commun similar access natur ga main raw materi product urea analysi suppli urea produc made confirm american produc natur ga suppli supplier case ukrain lithuanian produc singl supplier altern supplier addit similar ukrain usa produc import natur ga lithuania natur ga resourc commiss compar product process usa belaru ukrain conclud technolog american produc effici belaru ukrainian produc argu lithuania analogu countri subject investig commiss note articl basic regul stipul market economi countri subject investig reason outlin recit lithuania consid analogu countri investig state recit provision regul adjust made high natur ga cost ip usa high natur ga cost result market situat specif usa ip adjust brought ga cost level compar compani cooper proceed commun industri support choic usa analogu countri claim ga price usa experienc mild increas adjust made regard correct sharpest increas ga price place half year ip found half ip unusu specif increas cost natur ga adjust made consid justifi reason conclud usa analogu market economi countri select unreason manner normal base domest sale usa made ordinari trade includ reason excess profit margin fulli line requir articl basic regul ii normal compani grant me ukrainian compani sale made toll agreement argu domest sale basi determin normal altern compani propos commiss normal ukrainian export produc me grant construct normal basi compani data consequ cooper supplier ga conclud ukrainian compani qualifi export produc urea detail recit normal establish announc recit provision duti regul examin adjust cost factor depreci incur ukrainian export produc normal base data comparison depreci cost includ cost product product facil cooper produc analogu countri depreci incur ukrainian produc show differ differ caus numer factor event warrant adjust ukrainian produc cost normal ukrainian produc base domest sale chang cost neglig impact adjust made export price compani ukrain export sale made basi toll agreement exclud dump calcul submit export price construct basi transform fee charg export custom ga cost paid export produc ukrain reason amount profit compani consequ cooper supplier ga price export sale verifi compani qualifi export produc urea detail recit individu dump margin establish compani methodolog propos line articl basic regul purpos articl provid altern method establish export price case cooper account particip export sale import commun relat export produc construct propos ukrainian compani contrari establish articl basic regul base price sale independ parti start point cost manufactur method construct normal valu export price claim reject ukrainian compani export sale made toll agreement argu take lowest export price averag export price ukrainian export produc reason averag export price ukrainian export produc accur commun institut practic case cooper weight averag export price transact lowest export price repres time consider quantiti export quantiti verifi price comparison ukrainian compani belarussian compani claim commiss provid basic inform claim natur compar advantag compani cooper proceed specif evid product sale detail compani disclos breach rule confidenti basic inform geograph locat access raw materi publicli commun institut analys inform made initi adjust call unusu high natur ga cost ip usa identifi adjust made ga cost cooper usa compani brought ga cost level compar compani cooper proceed ukrainian compani belarussian compani disagre fact commiss made adjust inland transport export price base railwai tariff analogu countri argu ukrainian tariff altern lithuanian tariff railwai tariff ukrain belaru countri oper market economi condit set state consid reflect normal market price long establish practic commun institut base adjust type inland transport countri articl basic regul verifi data analogu countri specif mention grant me ukrainian compani involv cost factor correct bring line normal market chang provision find warrant claim lower tariff appli ukrainian export produc railwai wagon larg consign includ return empti wagon inform produc analogu countri reveal adjust wagon warrant calcul revis argu ukranian belarussian compani adjust made physic differ quot granular quot urea sold domest market analogu countri quot prill quot urea export countri base price differ european market aim determin normal prill urea analogu countri market adjust base price differ market adjust made base price differ market commun market price differ market likelihood influenc dump practic claim reject ukrainian compani compani belaru claim adjust level trade allegedli sell trader export produc ukrain belaru export product concern trader cooper produc analogu countri sold product trader part domest sale analogu countri produc made blender analys function price reveal claim warrant dump margin compani investig applic articl basic regul subsequ imposit provision duti commiss examin freight cost report lithuanian export produc paid import accur found cost overst compar inform collect import publicli quotat rout amount freight cost revis actual cost comment estonian export produc inappropri adjust cif unreport sale express dump margin sale made provision stage commiss analys issu detail decid revis methodolog adjust made provision stage withdrawn absenc reliabl inform provid compani commiss decid base find inform provid eurostat constitut reliabl data commiss provision made adjust cif belarussian export produc calcul dump margin adjust made erron adjust withdrawn dump margin definit dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border belaru gt tabl gt bulgaria gt tabl gt croatia gt tabl gt estonia gt tabl gt libya gt tabl gt lithuania gt tabl gt romania gt tabl gt ukrain gt tabl gt injuri definit commun industri interest parti repeat claim commun produc purchas import urea countri cover proceed exclud definit commun industri outlin recit provision regul purchas small volum made cover product shortfal due mainten work compani make substanti purchas equal approxim product ip order supplement product rang investig show compani primarili produc urea import good reason exclud definit commun industri case exclus signific impact find case level duti impos find recit provision regul confirm commun consumpt absenc inform find commun consumpt outlin recit provision regul confirm import countri concern cumul assess effect import concern claim import urea origin romania cumul import countri cover proceed claim base ground import volum market share develop differ period consid recit provision regul determin import countri concern substanti level set articl basic regul dump margin found de minimi level export produc undercut sale price commun industri price import commun produc urea fell significantli period consid volum urea import romania trend price urea commun market relationship price volum import romania period consid price lowest import romania evid price transpar commun urea market show romanian export withdraw market price fall partial recoveri price ip recit provision regul romanian import increas substanti held market share ip countri concern romania fourth largest export commun ip import trend specif romania import countri concern remark similar pattern fall import signific return commun market ip background total import volum countri concern rise year year period consid chang share import countri concern line price evid competit import product reason de cumul import romania countri concern reason outlin conclud criteria set articl basic regul met find recit provision regul confirm volum market share price import concern absenc inform volum price import countri concern provision find confirm undercut provision determin undercut calcul compar export commun frontier quai custom duti paid price level deq commun produc verifi work price comparison made prill prill granular granular bulk bulk bag bag level number parti includ export produc claim commun produc price undercut comparison weight averag price commun industri level price individu produc level claim methodolog serv artifici inflat margin zero commun produc level note undercut price comparison exercis injuri indic articl basic regul aim examin quot signific price undercut dump import compar price product commun industri effect import depress price signific degre quot true import countri concern undercut price commun produc signific volum export sale made price commun industri note commun urea market highli transpar sensit price analysi found countri concern proport import compani undercut commun industri price vari averag import level undercut rang high analysi zero due problem cooper export produc belaru recit provision regul estonia recit provision regul carri price comparison compani reason suggest result note commun industri record loss ip recit provision regul price commun industri depress compani undercut undersel found definit determin signific price undercut export produc countri concern depress price commun market ip number claim made injuri elimin calcul address detail recit adjust grant confirm account undercut exercis situat commun industri verif commun produc injuri indic chang absolut term suffici materi affect trend injuri indic period consid alter provision conclus base provision find materi injuri suffer commun industri confirm causat number interest parti iter claim injuri suffer commun industri caus dump import oversuppli urea world market link claim made parti injuri suffer commun industri result fall export sale turn affect sale commun market respect note assess situat commun industri base data relat sale product concern commun market potenti neg effect reduc export sale exclud injuri analysi addit period consid commun industri export sale fell tonn whilst sale commun market increas tonn face difficult export condit commun industri divert half lost export sale commun market time commun consumpt increas million tonn low price dump import increas tonn recit provision regul commun industri lost commun market recit provision regul inabl commun industri advantag expand domest market export sale fell evid exist injuri caus dump import oversuppli loss export sale fact effect commun industri term limit loss economi scale dump import prevent take full advantag expand commun market conclud effect fall export sale commun industri alleg oversuppli examin separ suffici break causal link effect dump import materi injuri suffer commun industri conclus recit provision regul confirm commun interest import trader public provision regul comment receiv cooper import associ import maintain imposit anti dump measur interest import urea flourish agricultur sector import state recit provision regul continu import duti pass full result increas farmer cost worst whilst rise result farmer sourc urea evid call question conclus set recit provision regul user farmer public provision regul comment receiv farmer organis austria itali spain uk parti challeng provision conclus duti lead worst case scenario increas farmer cost object imposit measur conclus prise increas pass full verif premis farmer cooper conclus cost implic propos measur confirm impact measur pass full base experi anti dump proceed evid suggest case proceed whilst difficult situat face farmer affirm conclud impact duti make imposit measur interest commun industri user written comment receiv direct cooper industri user urea suggest measur import impact user urea industri user import sell urea submit comment import associ compani suggest imposit measur forc close plant loss job claim made directli compani support evid claim reject conclus commun interest absenc inform commun interest aspect conclus recit provision regul confirm definit anti dump measur injuri elimin level provision determin undersel calcul compar export commun frontier quai custom duti paid price level deq commun produc verifi work target price comparison made compani prill prill granular granular bulk bulk bag bag level export produc claim adjust made unload cost arriv deq price insuffici claim import trader margin includ line recent fertilis case evid actual unload cost incur obtain sourc includ export produc commun industri independ import basi inform allow unload cost adjust question grant adjust import margin consid merit investig found export produc sold urea commun market number channel includ directli end user evid provid price vari channel found gener sell price depend type custom signific differ found sale channel commun industri export produc request adjust import margin reject number parti includ major export produc claim commun produc price undersel calcul weight averag price commun industri level price individu produc level claim methodolog serv artifici inflat margin elimin neg undersel commun produc level addit claim base anti dump duti calcul methodolog result zero contraven recent wto rule note undersel calcul aim examin actual extent injuri suffer commun industri caus dump import show true pictur price comparison reflect econom realiti investig show competit commun market take place individu export produc individu produc form part commun industri respect note inter alia signific price spread import differ locat commun produc extent injuri dump caus export produc commun industri assess actual market situat basi specif data verifi compani compar price compani compani result precis evalu full impact injuri dump suffer commun industri artifici inflat level undersel current case claim reject commun industri claim urea import commun fact quot fat quot prill treat separ type urea claim undersel calcul type compar price commun produc quot fat quot prill found larg diamet quot fat quot prill produc commun industri export commun countri concern differ standard prill larger diamet evid suggest cost product higher quot fat quot prill sold premium ip conclud reason quot fat quot prill consid separ product type export produc repeat claim adjust qualiti product support evid provid market percept qualiti problem romanian urea found claim reject note calcul injuri price provision stage profit margin cost turnov state recit provision regul cooper parti argu profit margin limit case previou anti dump proceed nitrat fertilis proceed urea russia part commun industri state claim profit margin return capit emploi roce confirm determin relev profit margin proceed base assess profit margin commun industri count normal condit competit absenc dump import base assess fact case assess fact proceed product investig period reason state recit provision regul claim profit base roce reject absenc evid determin profit margin incorrect conclus recit provision regul confirm final inform receiv data verifi public provision regul includ verifi inform commun produc incorpor calcul level form duti light forego consid accord articl basic regul definit anti dump duti impos level injuri margin dump margin found import urea origin belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain whichev lower residu duti appli cooper export produc residu duti fix basi highest duti rate establish cooper export countri export produc claim order consist previou proceed duti form minimum import price case urea russia state recit provision regul order ensur effici measur discourag price manipul observ previou proceed involv gener categori product fertilis definit duti form specif amount tonn claim reject basi definit duti amount gt tabl gt individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countri wide duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti commiss consult advisori committe amend regul updat list compani benefit individu duti rate collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found light injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision anti dump duti impos provision regul definit collect rate duti definit impos definit duti higher provision duti amount secur level provision duti definit collect undertak subsequ imposit provision measur export produc belaru croatia libya romania ukrain offer price undertak accord articl basic regul export produc estonia lithuania renew undertak offer made provision stage reject reason set recit provision regul recal commiss accept undertak bulgarian export produc provision stage proceed recit provision regul mention recit incorpor data definit injuri margin calcul impact injuri elimin level found minimum price undertak adapt subsequ disclosur provision find complain commun industri object commiss decis accept undertak bulgarian export produc respect argu compani concern relat close technic industri relat export produc nitrogen fertilis includ urea locat bulgaria belaru ukrain constitut strong potenti compensatori arrang commun industri rais concern abil export produc fulfil oblig undertak gener basi commun industri claim undertak minimum price inappropri measur regard nitrogen fertilis includ urea note commun industri support alleg made regard export produc bulgaria suffici evid investig commiss confirm alleg reject appropri undertak concern note assess primarili focu compani specif situat found compani concern produc export urea effect monitor undertak case case event suspect breach breach withdraw undertak anti dump duti impos pursuant articl basic regul undertak offer receiv analys detail main obstacl accept undertak offer result examin export produc concern lithuania romania croatia ukrain libya produc type fertilis chemic product consist past export product common custom trader commun practic rais risk cross compens undertak price formal respect price product concern lower render commit respect minimum price urea easi circumv extrem difficult monitor effect produc vg estonia ukrain belaru claim control knowledg destin sale condit export urea clear offici statist product export commun larg quantiti investig period recal compani provid suffici inform respect commiss option make fact accord articl basic regul establish export price addit export libya estonia provid defici level cooper investig consid fact render risk accept undertak unreason high guarante assur proper monitor unsatisfactori reason set conclud undertak offer subsequ disclosur definit find accept interest parti inform reason undertak offer accept disclos detail export concern advisori committe consult adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import urea aqueou solut fall cn code origin belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain rate definit anti dump duti applic duti net free commun frontier price product paragraph gt tabl gt case good damag entri free circul price paid payabl apport determin custom pursuant articl commiss regul eec juli lai provis implement council regul eec establish commun custom code amount anti dump duti calcul basi paragraph reduc percentag correspond apport price paid payabl provis forc custom duti appli articl import exempt anti dump duti impos articl provid produc directli export ship invoic independ custom commun act import compani name offer undertak accept commiss import conform paragraph gt tabl gt declar releas free circul pursuant undertak present exempt duti condit present valid commerci invoic issu compani list paragraph member state custom author undertak invoic conform requir invoic set undertak accept commiss essenti element list annex exempt duti condit good present custom precis descript commerci invoic import accompani undertak invoic declar taric addit code provid paragraph articl amount secur provision anti dump duti impos pursuant regul ec definit collect rate duti definit impos import urea aqueou solut fall cn code origin belaru bulgaria croatia estonia libya lithuania romania ukrain amount secur excess definit rate anti dump duti releas articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel januari council presid piqué camp oj regul amend regul ec oj oj european commun anti dump duti import cotton type bed linen india ab report appel bodi council regul ec impos definit anti dump duti import urea origin russia oj commiss european commun director gener trade terv rue de la loi wetstraat brussel oj regul amend commiss regul ec oj annex element commerci invoic accompani compani sale urea commun subject undertak head quot commerci invoic accompani good subject undertak quot compani mention articl issu commerci invoic commerci invoic number date issu commerci invoic taric addit code good invoic custom clear commun frontier exact descript good includ product code number pcn descript good pcn quot pcn urea bulk quot quot pcn urea bag quot compani product code number cpc applic cn code quantiti tonn descript term sale includ price tonn applic payment term applic deliveri term total discount rebat compani act import invoic issu directli compani offici compani issu undertak invoic sign declar quot undersign certifi sale direct export compani european commun good cover invoic made scope term undertak offer compani accept commiss european commun regul ec declar inform provid invoic complet correct quot