commiss decis januari aid measur propos german author rhineland palatin distil wine german text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun subparagraph articl thereof regard council regul eec march common organ market wine amend regul eec articl thereof regard commiss decis eec septemb recogn product qualiti wine produc region qualit featur demand amend decis eec notic pursuant articl parti concern submit comment regard comment letter april regist april german author notifi commiss aid distil wine pursuant articl treati aid paid rate dm litr wine distil aid repres state aid mean articl treati oper aid derog provid articl appli commiss regard measur incompat treati measur found infring common organ market wine embrac instrument commun law admit nation measur seek improv produc incom award oper aid letter sg juli commiss decid initi articl procedur regard aid procedur call german author grant aid commiss remind german author commiss letter member state novemb member state oblig result articl eec treati commun commiss publish offici journal european commun state illeg aid scheme grant await final posit decis connect procedur provid articl commiss requir member state recov aid recipi refus make eaggf advanc payment charg expenditur relat nation measur directli affect commun measur eaggf budget commiss invit german author submit observ week receipt letter publish letter request member state interest parti comment ii articl procedur german author send letter date august request addit time repli commiss letter initi articl procedur contest posit adopt commiss aid grant observ receiv member state interest parti iii measur aid winegrow distil wine earlier year produc area author product author german author aforesaid decis eec germani permit author ha increas area product rhineland palatin wine wine year german author winegrow aggriev produc earlier wine year cover arrang market produc area subsequ author wine earlier year market german author propos aid distil aid rate suffici high ensur produc concern distil aid rate propos pfennig litr wine distil measur subsidi total aid budget amount dm million address list suppli compet author show winegrow receiv author produc previous unauthor area applic suppli data land date receipt author volum unmarket area subsequ author applic suppli assur wine store separ produc area subsequ author wine inspector check data situ examin wine inspector winegrow submit proof distil compet author iv articl council regul eec state articl appli state aid sector measur give german winegrow question special advantag enabl reduc cost effect distort competit winegrow member state statist domest product qualiti wine amount hl financi year domest consumpt total hl basi data degre suffici order differ met import member state hl hl export member state amount hl hl measur affect trade enabl winegrow question reduc distil cost bear entireti recipi undertak room manoeuvr competitor measur question meet criteria laid articl eec treati provis establish principl incompat common market aid meet criteria laid derog incompat set articl applic aid question laid articl stipul object pursu common european interest interest specif sector nation economi derog strictli interpret scrutin region sector aid programm individu case applic gener aid scheme grant commiss establish aid achiev object set provis grant derog aid involv quid pro quo kind tantamount permit advers effect trade member state distort competit justif ground commun interest time give member state unfair advantag case point quid pro quo appear exist aid german author unabl demonstr commiss determin basi suppos aid question satisfi requir applic derog provid articl treati aid promot execut import project common european interest mean articl view effect trade run counter common interest aid remedi disturb economi member state question mean provis derog provid articl aid design promot facilit econom develop area activ mention point note aid bring perman improv circumst experienc econom sector receiv aid aid ceas structur situat remain unchang aid consid oper aid type aid commiss principl withheld approv grant independ condit qualifi derog provid articl addit measur disregard principl intervent member state market mechan specif laid commun liabl interfer organ common market note regul establish common organ state articl plant vine prohibit august provis member state wine year author plant case qualiti wine produc region commiss recogn product qualit featur demand virtu commiss decis eec germani permit author ha area plant rhineland palatin wine wine year german author conced wine produc earlier year cover commiss decis subsequ author plant area earlier wine produc german author recogn wine produc area newli plant earlier legal market wine question market altern outlet grape wine produc area commun law famili consumpt product grape juic distil expens view commiss consid whilst measur repres state laid mean articl regard oper aid derog articl appli measur deem incompat treati grant measur conflict common organ wine market market organ aim guarante produc fair incom leav room individu aid measur member state aim improv produc incom grant oper aid derog term articl treati contempl aid infring common market organ rule debar benefit derog adopt decis articl aid measur propos german author form aid dm litr wine distil incompat common market term articl treati grant articl german author requir inform commiss month receipt decis measur appli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel januari commiss rené steichen member commiss oj oj oj oj oj oj