commiss decis octob research develop aid site zamudio basqu countri spain plan implement compani quot industria de turbo propulsor sa quot itp notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis regard comment procedur letter decemb regist decemb spanish author act accord articl treati notifi plan grant research develop aid site zamudio basqu countri inform letter april regist april letter june commiss inform spain decid initi procedur laid articl treati respect plan aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss call interest parti submit comment aid letter august regist august spanish author submit comment commiss letter octob regist octob feder turbin heavi energi plant manufactur sytemel submit comment plan aid commiss letter octob regist octob pratt amp whitnei compani submit comment commiss letter novemb commiss forward spanish author copi comment submit sytemel pratt amp whitnei letter novemb regist novemb spanish author request commiss provid spanish translat comment commiss satisfi request letter decemb letter januari spanish author commiss respons comment submit sytemel pratt amp whitnei letter decemb commiss ask spanish author inform spanish author provid inform letter januari regist januari januari regist januari februari regist februari letter april commiss inform spain decid extend procedur laid articl treati respect plan aid letter june regist june spanish author submit comment commiss extens procedur commiss decis extend procedur publish offici journal european union commiss call interest parti submit comment letter june regist june spanish author forward commiss comment submit aid recipi descript case concern aid basqu govern plan grant compani industria de turbo propulsor sa itp itp specialis design develop manufactur mainten ga turbin own roll royc consortium turbo own sener sepi number employe compani turnov exce threshold laid annex commiss regul ec januari applic articl ec treati state aid small medium size enterpris compani consid sme aid concern research develop amp project carri site zamudio basqu countri involv develop type low pressur turbin tangibl invest project zamudio site increas itp product capac enabl roll royc main supplier low pressur turbin engin model servic administr grant aid basqu govern region administr amp project amp project concern develop low pressur turbin high low thrust high thrust turbin incorpor roll royc trent engin power airbu aircraft project compris cycl develop turbin involv stage prepar project preliminari design conceptu design realis concept stage divid step detail design compon trial engin trial aerodynam valid trial manufactur prototyp certif post certif activ low thrust turbin incorpor alli signal aero engin engin power bombardi continent bae system rjx region jet project compris main task gener activ design low pressur turbin manufactur support manufactur develop compon manufactur tool compon trial improv aeromechan paramet turbin programm includ addit task integr logist support activ design axial compressor activ link studi extern behaviour engin spanish author activ cover aid constitut quot precompetit develop activ quot mean annex commun framework state aid research develop hereinaft refer amp framework durat project year aid provid basqu govern form interest free loan total esp million eur million total elig cost amount esp million eur million loan paid reimburs arrang set tabl gt tabl gt invest project inform provid spanish author project part current region aid scheme approv commiss ad hoc region aid project zamudio site competit high technolog market indirect cost high itp plan manufactur compon zamudio site engin model ej trent allison atar br tf lm fla mtr attack helicopt trent trent industri trent spanish author project posit effect basqu economi industri diversif econom impetu creation job ad access advanc technolog incorpor technolog industri fabric workforc skill multipli effect industri refer creation indirect job basqu countri subcontract ratio reach durat project year total amount invest esp million eur million broken gt tabl gt refer discount rate total amount invest discount decemb esp million eur million aid form repay grant spanish author aid condit net job creation itp mainten invest minimum period year amount grant esp million eur million paid timet gt tabl gt refer discount rate tax rate total amount discount decemb esp million aid intens gge gross grant equival nge net grant equival background addit repli question commiss spanish author recipi firm januari receiv invest aid form tax credit amount esp eur invest project cover period involv cost build esp million machineri esp million technic instal esp million instal esp million system esp million total esp million aid intens grant vizcaya provinci council provinci law norma foral decemb decis ec juli state aid scheme implement spain firm vizcaya form tax credit amount invest commiss found aid provid provinci law tax credit invest firm vizcaya unlaw incompat common market repaid letter februari regist februari spanish author aid itp repaid descript ground initi procedur decis june commiss rais number doubt aspect aid examin classif amp task precompetit develop activ low pressur high thrust turbin project doubt concern engin test certif post certif activ low pressur low thrust turbin project doubt concern manufactur support tool manufactur integr logist support activ admiss addit overhead oper expens elig amp cost incent effect amp compon aid justif project term region develop view fact ad hoc aid measur justif includ expenditur tool elig cost invest project descript ground extend procedur commiss view circumst refer recit inform decis june fact inform adopt decis commiss deem inform kei import reach decis issu mention accord principl establish court justic european commun judgment case textilwerk deggendorf gmbh commiss feder republ germani fact aid unlaw incompat repaid recipi firm affect compat aid account cumul affect aid measur question spanish author inform commiss recipi aid examin present procedur reimburs aid form tax credit amount esp grant vizcaya provinci council declar unlaw incompat decis ec commiss doubt compat amp invest aid view doubt commiss extend procedur order examin question cover decis june comment spanish author classif amp task precompetit develop activ regard high thrust turbin project commiss rule possibl engin test certif post certif activ relat market product constitut precompetit develop activ spanish author point engin trial project compris test extensometri measur metal temperatur measur air temperatur thermal paint effici test cycl test type test fan blade test certif test spanish author crucial object develop capac itp amp depart design complet model fan blade test carri earlier develop phase view high cost provid opportun risk calibr linear calcul tool develop load case activ form part develop process constitut initi verif calibr design tool develop itp spanish author view compon subject test commerci ag accumul resist test type test destruct natur fan blade test spanish author state aspect check monitor committe provid programm certif post certif activ high thrust turbin project involv analysi data document gener prior test task confus draft activ aim fulfil condit laid certif author spanish author view certif process impos technic constraint case stringent demand custom constraint impos begin design determin spanish author regard mere administr requir innov event spanish author drew commiss attent fact itp involv activ excel learn opportun compani put good view launch competit project futur activ contribut develop busi area firm form creation airworthi depart submiss jaa joint aviat author applic doa design organis approv case low thrust turbin project commiss doubt concern manufactur support tool manufactur integr logist support activ regard tool manufactur spanish author stress object project produc engin significantli cheaper exist option made modifi aerodynam criteria mechan criteria qualif condit activ task constitut engin design manufactur engin depart contribut review design manufactur concept activ involv high degre innov regard design manufactur method high level technic discuss qualiti capac condit process regard tool manufactur activ commiss rule possibl part tool seri product engin spanish author acknowledg usual principl develop programm recov tool product programm present case claim approach project base extrem low purchas price introduc huge risk regard possibl futur manufactur time market reduc order captur custom compet project lastli reduct cost requir outset made introduc concept unusu type small engin reduct number vane verifi earli stage project finalis tool earli concept demonstr spanish author point result region polici commit cast compon produc unit state transfer vizcaya meant itp event bear cost set tool integr logist support activ project commiss view correspond market version contribut featur modif improv form part precompetit develop spanish author explain activ relat aspect illustr technic manual draft technic manual reliabl mainten name activ carri logist support group design develop task carri time develop turbin determin product design constitut precompetit develop activ activ concern spanish author argu commiss view justifi itp habitu engag activ type present case activ compani introduc innov develop method involv develop tool establish depart includ develop system tool produc illustr technic public drawn manner compat aircraft incorpor latest technolog advanc neglig share work consist develop success prototyp final version system produc technic public task spanish author form part precompetit develop admiss addit overhead oper expens elig cost spanish author understood commiss doubt relat cost head quot contribut develop programm quot understand commiss class cost addit overhead view fact direct cost aris research activ spanish author stress itp origin engin manufactur oem wish assum respons engin process incorpor turbin engin task involv incorpor turbin engin test turbin carri respons oem itp particip spanish author stress intens aid elig cost repay advanc request cost account total amount repay advanc request entir project line condit intang technolog transfer cost invest project incent effect amp compon aid spanish author point itp activ area engin mainten develop product engin compon time appli aid compani specialis static compon simpler integr product infrastructur tailor product part type analys posit market itp decid chang strategi order supplier complet modul decis entail obviou risk account scale invest compani penetr sector high low thrust low pressur turbin partner roll royc alli signal spanish author stress contact compani basqu govern date back august willing support project factor decis itp spanish author point factor made chang strategi riski risk invest larg proport resourc gener fact aid product part trent project locat roll royc exist plant derbi zamudio site fact programm competit rang engin produc roll royc north america allison logic caus sharehold reluct risk compet project spanish author provid indic view demonstr aid incent effect itp enjoi signific growth period time frame strategi involv low pressur turbin growth region similar enjoi firm gener electr itp account turnov engin subsector european aerospac sector particip framework programm region engin subsector aerospac sector time greater expect basi turnov compani amp expenditur increas substanti relat turnov year project onward shown tabl gt tabl gt workforc increas significantli compani emploi technician year activ assess technolog risk inher project account spanish author fact usual oem publish incomplet inform conceal delai develop problem order preserv imag lead commiss project involv risk technolog barrier project overcom spanish author refer inform provid letter april project technolog object underr claim good number achiev trent engin point certifi decemb basic version engin technolog impos heavi load version engin develop improv effici compani work version achiev improv effici certif engin delai year result technic problem lastli spanish author point oem frequent creat major barrier transfer technolog compani subcontract risk introduc programm limit practic number firm receiv subcontract low pressur turbin modul part risk share programm compani spain suffici prior enter sector difficult imagin firm spain europ receiv similar aid spanish author stress usual aircraft industri receiv state aid claim intens aid plan project lower averag level aid europ unit state justif project term region develop spanish author point firstli project form part commiss approv aid scheme system examin analys evalu project natur project class strateg programm evalu basqu govern interinstitut econom develop plan interinstitut agreement introduct plan conclud basqu govern vizcaya guipúzcoa álava provinci council plan provid framework econom develop activ basqu institut spanish author explain decid time notifi commiss plan make individu notif effect project region develop spanish author explain industri region tradition concentr sector mine steelmak shipbuild capit good success crise sector deepli affect region prompt adopt industri polici aim facilit structur chang econom develop plan put forward model competit gear creation busi region higher demand potenti order serv engin develop promot econom activ regard strateg prioriti sector develop innov capac busi facilit internationalis firm region polici base sector approach region develop focu interinstitut agreement provid possibl support specif project pursu object accord number qualit quantit criteria enabl potenti contribut region develop gaug irrespect sector concern spanish author view project present itp fulli line object spanish author view project present itp give major boost develop region mathemat model develop univers deusto faculti econom busi studi basi input output tabl claim project total econom impact esp million level activ esp million term gross ad impact esp million gross ad activ esp million addit activ esp million employ concern total effect job workforc compani lastli project spanish author involv volum invest subcontract region amount esp million level subcontract region amount hope increas number local supplier spanish author state project consolid industri group specialis product high ad substanti technolog content develop competit firm oper subcontractor aircraft industri boost aerospac research basqu countri long stand tradit cooper itp bilbao engin school mondragón polytechn univers view develop skill base capabl meet sector lastli spanish author hope zamudio site centr attract advanc industri justif includ expenditur tool elig cost invest project spanish author explain expenditur head quot tool quot relat product tool manufactur process zamudio site compris mechan apparatu clamp jig templat stiffen compon handl part interact part tool sheetmet work weld tool cut finish tool tool assembl weld compon extrem costli number adjust mechan involv inspect verif tool standard compon templat gaug facilit inspect seri produc compon tool design machineri instal zamudio relat invest relev expenditur broken shown tabl gt tabl gt issu rais decis extend procedur spanish author provid proof aid recit reimburs full recipi decis extend procedur includ compound interest calcul interest rate recommend commiss comment interest parti comment submit sytemel feder turbin heavi energi plant manufactur sytemel french trade associ wish draw commiss attent region issu french depart pyréné atlantiqu home number industri manufactur subcontract centr turbomeca group produc combust turbin aircraft applic naval terrestri distort competit caus support basqu govern aggrav advers effect geograph proxim site mobil research technician publicli assist amp centr combust turbin abnorm affect natur condit competit manufactur unfavour factor tran pyrenean attract proper region plan europ comment submit pratt amp whitnei pratt amp whitnei argu intens aid project consid conjunct state aid previous grant roll royc trent engin relat develop activ roll royc privat industri partner itp account connect fact trent deriv engin incorpor technolog trent trent trent engin meant cost technolog risk involv reduc pratt amp whitnei view cost develop trent cost complet engin fact account determin elig cost trent receiv state aid grant unit kingdom pratt amp whitnei base assumpt roll royc bear develop cost transfer share risk partner itp result effect increas intens aid grant quot doubl dip quot state aid partner obtain state aid quot tripl dip quot aid request addit aid present roll royc trent trent engin includ pratt amp whitnei engin programm technolog assist aid grant pratt amp whitnei point roll royc contribut amp activ fund unusu low compar level compani fund amp pratt amp whitnei competitor pratt amp whitnei consid aid high thrust turbin incent effect request aid retroact precompetit develop cost incur trent programm long past launch phase engin certifi compet author pratt amp whitnei share doubt rais commiss base fact project reach high level matur compani point period aid request postdat formal announc airbu june select trent sole engin engin test certifi decemb order power trent engin total aircraft pratt amp whitnei share doubt rais commiss engin test certif post certif activ class precompetit develop activ mean amp framework compani explain experi larg aero engin develop project distinct phase concept phase market requir busi strategi technolog readi continu evalu conceptu design studi conduct airfram manufactur determin requir thrust perform weight nois emiss instal constraint technolog proven analysi rig engin test order minimis technic risk phase continu long period time regard quot precompetit quot cost low total programm cost launch phase product design specif engin model deriv develop rig compon test carri long lead time tool part order expect product configur end phase engin configur technolog larg fix engin manufactur enter busi agreement custom certif deliveri schedul price perform technic requir engin phase last year account total programm develop cost pratt amp whitnei consid phase regard precompetit develop mean amp framework uncertain end phase engin manufactur sold end launch phase programm proce engin manufactur obtain suffici number order subsequ phase deem constitut precompetit activ engin valid certif phase intend establish product met specif suffici safe reliabl entri servic unproven technolog gener ad engin design phase prove difficult riski costli phase divid part product engin test fett initi prototyp commerci product engin product fett detail design draw engin compon complet fett typic fabric hand product process temporari tool engin valid certif phase prior fett last year end launch phase account total programm cost fett produc successfulli undergo test requir ensur engin met minimum standard safeti perform engin test produc accord design model certifi period last year account total cost larg proport cost incur produc engin test engin certifi deriv engin ten engin engin design engin manufactur commerci product method test extrem condit meant practic imposs refurbish sell airlin gener develop activ post certif engin improv programm pratt amp whitnei share commiss view cost incur certif phase relat product commerci sold commerci end launch phase flight test airfram certif phase final phase engin instal aircraft accord certifi configur aircraft successfulli undergo set flight test certifi engin order demonstr engin airfram combin met prescrib airworthi perform oper requir complet flight test programm flight test engin typic refurbish sold commerci commiss pratt amp whitnei view activ carri phase regard precompetit develop activ mean amp framework lastli regard elig cost pratt amp whitnei share commiss doubt case low thrust turbin project manufactur support tool manufactur integr logist support activ regard precompetit develop activ mean amp framework manufactur support form part firm commerci polici constitut research develop activ tool manufactur aim build machin make prototyp part subsequ manufactur standard engin integr logist support consist produc manufactur instruct manual technic procedur engin mainten relat commerci version engin brought innov modif improv doubt appli high thrust turbin project comment submit recipi aid recipi submit comment decis extend procedur comment concur made connect spanish author demonstr unlaw incompat aid mention recit reimburs full itp decis extend procedur includ compound interest calcul interest rate recommend commiss respons spanish author comment submit interest parti respons comment submit sytemel spanish author contrari claim sytemel project affect network plant subcontractor work turbomeca trigger movement research basqu countri itp supplier subsystem risk partner engin programm competit small medium size workshop contrari creat work manufactur type facil produc compon make turbin itp plan continu subcontract product circumst geograph proxim manufactur repres sytemel constitut advantag comparison potenti supplier locat unit kingdom germani central southern spain argu supplier subsystem creat work take confirm fact itp receiv singl subcontract order industri region increas volum manufactur order south franc itp singl year order turbin disc worth eur million french compani hope grant amount eur million type compon tradition suppli japanes compani unlik sytemel spanish author consid geograph proxim advantag mobil research technician encourag european union sixth framework programm order develop european industri connect itp basqu govern take part interreg initi view develop technolog commerci link basqu countri aquitain region respons comment submit pratt amp whitnei spanish author consid pratt amp whitnei argument aid intens word link aid receiv roll royc trent project base incorrect assumpt roll royc privat sharehold itp remain share belong state region local author itp privat own public sharehold sepi held capit remaind split privat compani sener roll royc privat compani statu state aid receiv itp spain separ aid grant unit kingdom british firm plan amp aid itp correspond invest capit engin actual develop equip state aid receiv condit itp entri project risk partner market condit premium special treatment roll royc duplic work overlap aid grant unit kingdom regard pratt amp whitnei opinion trent deriv engin spanish author point engin base addit knowledg relat previou principl appli manufactur enabl reduc develop cost significantli event aid assess relat actual develop cost cost incur engin complet spanish author stress aid incent aim enabl itp enter area activ itp experi acquir firm level innov incorpor turbin spanish author claim design technolog complet comparison low pressur turbin produc roll royc manufactur repeat aid itp design cover cost compani genuin incur reduc state aid grant unit kingdom lastli view comment account criteria roll royc stress roll royc itp complet compani incent effect aid spanish author consid pratt amp whitnei arriv conclus technic commerci risk ground trent engin certifi decemb amp activ complet certif engin announc spanish author view hand activ overlap account level engin system subsystem announc made artifici order protect custom programm preserv commerci imag project spanish author state turbin standard certifi decemb fulfil requisit condit engin fact certifi basic low pressur turbin standard order avoid delai develop programm aircraft power standard subsequ modif develop test advanc state art modif partli result parallel amp plan show extent technolog risk exist econom impact small firm itp spanish author stress time lag respect establish schedul due design configur caus precompetit develop activ delai project advanc stage notifi commiss deduc therefrom aid lastli argu exist order declar intent purchas engin reliev manufactur risk fail meet technic specif order provid advanc fund includ heavi penalti event complianc precompetit develop activ spanish author view model engin design project put forward pratt amp whitnei necessarili oem perfectli capabl adopt model coincid event spanish author major differ observ method adopt oem pratt amp whitnei firm itp proport precompetit develop task thing larger case supplier subsystem oem involv engin market certif sale technic activ avail exist technolog preced differ firm tradition present market pratt amp whitnei medium size firm market year itp oem regard low pressur turbin product high pressur turbin itp supplier low pressur turbin refer high pressur turbin previou turbin technolog net technolog content activ proportion higher case itp oem lastli spanish author convinc activ respect commiss rais doubt constitut precompetit develop activ itp correspond initi develop methodolog process lastli elig cost concern spanish author view commiss inform need order reach decis issu specif content task inform pratt amp whitnei submit comment certif post certif activ comment groundless assess measur plan spanish author confer advantag recipi firm reliev cost incur invest research activ bear advantag select respect firm carri invest similar research project affect intra commun trade project question aim develop manufactur product suppli roll royc export unit kingdom itp subcontract number european firm lastli interest free loan grant direct basqu govern advantag deem confer mean state resourc measur question constitut state aid mean articl treati state recit decis commiss rais doubt project question aris examin plan aid research develop plan aid invest dealt separ aid research develop classif amp task precompetit develop activ commiss note firstli assess state aid research develop light commun rule base analysi elig cost relat specif invest fact invest link project receiv state aid make project question incompat treati principl appli case invest project commiss dismiss argument put forward pratt amp whitnei aid receiv roll royc context invest link trent project trent trent project decis state aid roll royc develop trent trent engin commiss classifi phase aero engin develop line stage amp defin annex amp framework classif activ prior engin certif constitut amp activ line amp framework situat market precompetit develop activ hand commiss found decis engin certif activ subsequ certif close market constitut amp activ line amp framework commiss consid adopt approach project examin present decis assess abovement unit kingdom project follow approach advoc pratt amp whitnei restrict scope research develop exclus earli work carri initi prototyp albeit commerci unus built approach run counter logic amp framework expressli construct prototyp includ research develop activ account case fact work undertaken itp aim develop engin subassembl entir engin certif activ account order draw line itp work amp mean amp framework work fall definit activ aim certifi engin turbin develop itp part present project previou certif engin turbin distinct import case trent engin ow schedul impos aircraft manufactur subject initi certif roll royc complet decemb turbin displai set characterist develop itp present project initi certif project draw conclus put forward pratt amp whitnei activ carri present project decemb constitut amp mean amp framework view forego commiss take view cost link certif post certif activ high thrust turbin regard amp mean amp framework amount cost esp eur deduct total elig cost notifi spanish author regard engin test cost link high thrust turbin commiss take note spanish author statement test fan blade test type test form part certif process reason mention certif test constitut amp activ mean amp framework hand commiss take view test activ regard preced engin certif itp turbin place engin certifi decemb power turbin name activ includ precompetit develop phase spanish author point mention certif test account total engin test cost link high thrust turbin commiss consid total cost task deduct amount cost elig aid amount esp eur deduct total elig cost notifi spanish author case low thrust turbin project commiss rais doubt inclus elig cost cost relat manufactur support tool manufactur integr logist support consid activ aim manufactur maintain engin final market state manufactur support spanish author claim activ involv high degre innov term design manufactur import technic discuss qualiti capac requir product process commiss call consider question take view enabl withdraw reserv activ qualifi amp fact activ involv high degre innov suffici classifi amp activ mean amp framework point framework make clear activ regard innov fall scope framework exist import technic discuss part task alter fact task correspond product process commerci engin demonstr precis fact qualiti aspect process account definit precompetit develop activ indent annex amp framework explicitli exclud activ result convert industri applic commerci exploit commiss take view manufactur support activ relat low thrust turbin constitut research develop activ mean amp framework cost activ includ cost elig aid line framework amount cost esp eur deduct total elig cost notifi spanish author regard tool manufactur activ commiss take note spanish author statement unlik usual practic project type tool develop activ industrialis final product convert purpos cost final product process low preclud type tool research develop context commiss conclud tool manufactur activ low thrust turbin regard precompetit develop activ mean amp framework cost includ elig cost project head integr logist support activ spanish author state draft technic manual activ compani requir engag substanti process innov method tool develop claim activ task relat engin reliabl mainten constitut design develop activ carri time engin design work commiss take view fact compani draw technic manual type time develop set tool purpos make conclud draft manual constitut amp activ mean amp framework purpos technic manual describ final version engin degre refin innov incorpor manual direct commerci applic buyer engin activ relat engin reliabl mainten commiss consid fact carri partli parallel engin develop result develop input data make conclud relat engin form part research process event commiss point activ definit case mainten consider extent case reliabl direct final stage product market integr logist support activ consider extent direct final product market commiss take view cost activ includ cost elig aid line amp framework amount cost esp eur deduct total elig cost notifi spanish author view forego total amount elig cost reduc esp eur admiss addit overhead oper expens elig cost commiss note cost notif quot contribut develop programm quot includ addit overhead oper expens line fourth indent annex ii amp framework cost fact correspond itp particip subcontractor integr compon manufactur complet engin common practic subcontractor contribut cost integr compon system research develop phase contribut take form cooper risk partnership subcontractor addit pai entri fee join programm respons part develop industrialis engin subassembl integr subassembl system case point itp particip includ cost assist provid compani test integr subassembl complet engin commiss deem elig line annex ii amp framework relat activ carri directli aid recipi subcontractor commiss take view fact aircraft industri adopt specif method cooper compani risk partnership bear natur elig cost line annex ii amp framework commiss find doubt admiss addit overhead oper expens elig cost withdrawn incent effect amp compon aid commiss note firstli technolog risk project limit comparison high averag level technolog risk aircraft industri examin inform suppli spanish author reveal itp engin receiv substanti technic assist unit kingdom compani roll royc industri leader europ involv high technolog engin develop project spanish author provid data demonstr aid signific quantit effect compani amp activ project began peak implement firm amp spend grew eur million eur million rel term proport total turnov alloc amp rose period compani hire engin technician commiss account analysi data suppli pratt amp whitnei topic relat roll royc compani receiv aid figur trent engin sale order submit pratt amp whitnei consider assess incent effect distinguish engin incorpor type low thrust turbin sale incorpor high thrust turbin develop itp project cover decis commiss note mention earlier aid enabl signific cross border cooper place recipi unit kingdom compani roll royc special refer trent engin develop itp part risk partner commiss note final compani submit applic aid region author launch programm view forego commiss find case view sector concern aid deem incent effect line section amp framework conclus amp compon aid view forego commiss find activ notifi spanish author receiv aid compat amp framework activ give rise elig cost amount esp eur precompetit develop activ line annex framework maximum allow intens aid pursuant point amp framework extra percentag point ad pursuant paragraph point framework zamudio site locat area elig region aid articl treati commiss consid amp compon aid authoris amp framework provid gross grant equival exce eur eur spanish author express agreement point commiss note gross grant equival aid calcul refer discount rate publish premium basi point loan grant state back secur calcul gross grant equival aid spanish author refer annex guidelin nation region aid lastli claim made sytemel distort competit caus support basqu govern aggrav advers effect geograph proxim site mobil research technician commiss consid increas mobil research contrari posit develop encourag commun aid invest justif project term region develop commiss note decis initi formal investig procedur plan invest aid form part approv aid scheme regard ad hoc aid spanish author disput conclus commiss verifi accord paragraph section guidelin nation region aid benefit region outweigh distort competit result ad hoc aid commiss note basqu countri elig region aid articl treati accord spain region aid map ceil region aid basqu countri nge commiss take note fact aid grant commiss approv aid scheme line interinstitut econom develop plan interinstitut agreement introduct plan conclud basqu govern vizcaya guipúzcoa álava provinci council explain spanish author framework econom develop activ basqu institut plan compris programm basi project question select commiss establish aid grant programm subject annual competit tender procedur grant public call applic select accord object criteria invest aid regard individu aid measur benefit specif compani grant legisl context region develop commiss take view invest aid effect contribut econom develop region data suppli spanish author project signific effect term gross ad job creation involv high level subcontract region commiss consid aid regard proportion intens relev region aid ceil note aid recipi contribut financ project applic aid submit work start project aid condit mainten invest minimum period year condit laid paragraph point point region aid guidelin met aid condit net job creation itp lastli comment submit sytemel procedur commiss take view aim region aid precis offset handicap develop lag region concern suffer take account scale handicap draw nation region aid map case project consider account fact aid intens lower ceil allow spain region aid map fear express sytemel effect project oper compani locat franc unfound point spanish author itp increas order french firm commiss find invest aid itp affect trade condit extent contrari common interest commiss conclud doubt rais decis initi formal investig procedur justif project term region develop withdrawn justif includ expenditur tool elig cost invest project commiss note light explan provid spanish author expenditur tool project relat ancillari item product process design machineri instal zamudio site spanish author point item form part compani fix asset enter balanc sheet item regard belong categori quot plant machineri quot refer point region aid guidelin commiss conclud doubt rais decis initi formal investig procedur justif includ expenditur tool elig cost invest project withdrawn conclus invest compon aid view forego commiss find invest project compli guidelin nation region aid issu rais decis extend procedur commiss note spanish author provid proof unlaw incompat aid refer decis extend procedur reimburs full decis amount repaid includ compound interest calcul interest rate recommend commiss accord commiss commun interest rate appli aid grant unlawfulli recov commiss find extens procedur longer serv purpos conclus view forego commiss conclud invest aid plan basqu govern grant uncondition aid research develop plan basqu govern grant provid condit fulfil adopt decis articl state aid spain plan implement compani industria de turbo propulsor sa itp form grant eur compat common market mean articl ec treati implement aid authoris articl state aid spain plan implement itp form interest free loan total eur compat common market mean articl treati subject condit set articl articl gross grant equival aid calcul refer discount rate publish commiss basi point exce eur articl spain inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl articl decis address kingdom spain brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj footnot footnot oj compani recent merg honeywel group oj itp plan creat job oj ecr resourc gener prior project esp million esp million invest amount esp million esp million esp million year project durat commiss decis octob state aid case oj connect commiss notic method set refer discount rate oj indent sixth paragraph thereof oj itp plan creat job decis june oj