commiss decis juli state aid grant austria lenz lyocel gmbh amp kg notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite regard comment procedur background letter meet austria inform efta surveil author commiss intend grant state aid compani lenz lyocel gmbh amp kg heiligenkreuz llg llg form part austrian lenz group world largest produc viscos fibr begin llg establish product plant busi park heiligenkreuz szentgotthard busi park manufactur lyocel type man made stapl fibr produc natur cellulos wood pulp lenz ag british chemic group courtauld plc patent right produc fibr busi park cross border project austria hungari llg situat provinc burgenland austria articl region invest cost amount eur million austria intend provid invest aid elig cost basi previous approv region aid scheme respons austria written request august commiss inform austria letter octob grant provid approv region scheme individu notif requir commiss remind austria inform commiss due time provid state guarante letter date april austria forward commiss applic form erdf financ larg scale invest project busi park carri compani busi park heiligenkreuz bph wirtschaftspark heiligenkreuz servicegesellschaft mbh wh document austria state interest llg import impact develop activ busi park bph austria state wh invest util centr provid basic process util electr process steam fresh water cool water compress air wast water treatment primarili llg austria provinc burgenland provid grant wh cover expect neg cash flow result suppli infrastructur servic price guarante period year commiss start investig case inform austria letter date decemb transfer case nn regist notifi state aid meet correspond fail clarifi commiss concern austria argu number aid measur cover approv exist aid scheme octob commiss decid initi formal investig procedur articl ec treati measur inform austria letter octob state guarante grant loan total eur million low land price eur hectar industri land price guarante basic process util electr ga water period year letter commiss call austria provid inform enabl assess made number measur austria claim cover exist approv scheme commiss decis publish offici journal european commun commiss receiv set comment interest parti pass austria comment neg submit competitor fibr associ perman represent unit kingdom european union letter march april austria repli commiss letter octob repli clear aid measur cover approv exist scheme commiss assess measur aid directli provis articl ec treati environment aid grant correct applic austria environment aid act preliminari examin led doubt compat aid measur common market commiss decid june extend formal investig procedur measur ad hoc invest aid eur million land purchas ad hoc equiti particip eur million year return compani specif infrastructur connect involv unknown aid amount environment aid eur million possibl grant incorrect applic environment aid act decis extend formal investig procedur publish offici journal european commun interest parti invit comment commiss receiv set comment interest parti industri associ comment favour aid measur unit kingdom perman represent neg view austria repli letter octob meet commiss staff decemb provid inform letter februari april addit aid measur refer point commiss initi formal investig procedur llg grant financi measur concern eur million grant provinc burgenland eur million grant region aid scheme quot burgenland invest allow programm quot approv number eur million grant feder labour act train personnel final grant eur million train consid gener measur constitut aid decis initi extend formal investig procedur commiss note total amount aid measur appear exce region aid ceil net grant equival descript financi measur measur state guarante grant loan eur million decis initi procedur commiss doubt lg paid commerci rate guarante provid approv exist scheme letter march februari april austria report fact commit state guarante grant loan juli stte own wirtschaftsservic burgenland ag hereinaft wibag grant llg basi approv scheme guarante european recoveri programm erp loan eur million guarante run end cover linearli degress amount outstand credit june consortium commerci public bank includ erst bank hypo bank burgenland ag provid guarante erp loan eur million guarante refer run end octob wibag provid guarante eur million loan grant erp fund llg interest subsidi guarante appli event llg fulfil contractu oblig connect subsidi decemb wibag provid guarante feder ministri labour social affair eur million ministri grant llg decemb juli wibag provid guarante feder ministri labour social affair eur million ministri disburs connect eu financ region aid measur low price eur hectar land provinc burgenland made commit contract burgenland vertrag sign march provinc burgenland june llg aid measur contract concern commit offer llg hectar land intend industri llg cost thap eur side letter provinc burgenland undertook provid land condit letter date septemb austria state llg bought hectar land directli privat landown eur document submit april austria state busi park bph plan sell land railwai access eur land railwai access eur commiss doubt land price eur consid market price letter march austria clarifi begin contract negoti llg privat owner land design agricultur land land destin plan flächenwidmungsplan date signatur design chang industri llg bought land complet undevelop arrang onsit infrastructur measur fix price year basic process media point side letter burgenland vertrag provinc burgenland undertook provid llg basic process media electr process steam process water cool pressuris air water treatment wast dispos provinc burgenland guarante fix price servic period year price gear averag electr price eu austria explain price guarante time busi park develop case price repres market price austria view basic process util deliv privat undertak consid market price decis octob initi formal investig procedur commiss request evid price market price indic contrari privat util enter contract provid basic process util fix price year time llg option termin contract year erdf cofinanc applic austria provinc burgenland provid grant util oper wh cover expect neg cash flow provis basic process util llg commiss ask austria provid proof llg pai commerci price wh includ depreci fix capit cost util centr similar evid request wast water treatment plant oper abwasserverband bezirk jennersdorf letter februari austria submit declar llg waiv price guarante basic process media measur ad hoc invest aid eur million land purchas articl point burgenland vertrag provinc burgenland grant eur million aid acquisit land sum transfer llg octob letter march austria state grant aid ad hoc aid approv exist aid scheme austria declar aid invest aid justifi region object burgenland vertrag decis june extend formal investig procedur commiss request justif region signific invest aid llg receiv acquisit land measur ad hoc equiti particip eur million year annual return june juli wibag llg sign contract dormant equiti particip echt stifl beteiligung wibag provid capit eur million particip procur wibag annual return invest capit recent side contract wibag market orient return expiri year dormant partnership capit resembl soft loan year matur austria state due abnorm low return invest clear wibag act market economi investor letter march austria state particip grant exist approv aid scheme explain decis june commiss examin aid ad hoc aid provis articl ec treati clear equiti particip contract capit provid invest purpos commiss note invest cost invest timet fix precondit capit inject final commiss consid region justif aid insuffici measur compani specif infrastructur connect unknown aid amount articl quot burgenland vertrag quot provinc burgenland undertook build infrastructur suppli llg electr process water telecommun water treatment wast dispos provid access site road railwai facil provinc burgenland pai infrastructur develop bph develop paid infrastructur busi park provid access llg site road railwai water suppli sewag treatment electr natur ga telecommun compani austria requir pai fee state provid infrastructur develop austria consist argu infrastructur invest constitut state aid llg compani busi park advantag infrastructur commiss held evid austria letter date april develop busi park account specif requir llg railwai access llg site llg commiss held llg benefit compani specif infrastructur connect austria argu bph privat investor commiss request evid final austria claim llg simpli benefit geograph proxim place infrastructur case develop busi park decis june commiss point descript provid connect take account current inform establish compani basi conclud measur gener measur busi park measur environment aid eur million letter date januari state own österreichisch kommunalkredit ag ökk state provid behalf feder state environ relat invest grant eur million environment relat invest eur million aid provid articl environment aid act umweltförderungsgesetz scheme förderungsrichtlinien act scheme notifi efta surveil author exist aid regist forc time grant provid aid provid instal instal amount eur million includ cofinanc erdf research develop activ instal amount million austria provid list elig cost item invest machineri process unit aid intens amount pilot project decis june commiss endors classif pilot project decis june commiss express doubt correct applic exist aid scheme environment scheme stipul elig project relat product method reduct pollut commiss ask austria provid evid pollut reduct potenti invest environment benefit attribut provid evid environment benefit llg product process compar tradit viscos product process austria demonstr specif item consid elig environment aid elig cost assess aid measur measur state guarante grant loan eur million austria state eur million guarante wibag grant llg grant basi approv guarante scheme main condit scheme requir innov charact invest austria demonstr invest concern innov product innov product process commiss consid condit condit scheme fulfil measur exist aid order determin region aid ceil compli commiss calcul aid equival guarante commiss base calcul price creditor pai normal market condit similar guarante mean declar privat bank oberbank austria provid evid annual fee market price guarante llg view view decreas amount cover commiss calcul aid equival amount eur million guarante loan eur million grant consortium commerci public bank austria made clear llg pai commerci rate annual state paragraph commiss consid state aid involv guarante wibag grant erp cover grant eur million letter march austria explain guarante concern cession erp wibag case llg fulfil import contractu oblig austria made clear standard claus grant contract austria explain guarante provid wibag pre condit erp grant commiss take view involv simpli cession right reclaim subsidi state institut guarante commit state resourc confer benefit llg commiss consid guarante constitut state aid mean articl ec treati guarante wibag provid feder ministri labour social affair cover eur million eur million concern cession right state institut reason set measur commiss state aid measur low price eur hectar land present contract statement main seller austria provid conclus evid compani acquir land directli privat individu price level compar farmland individu receiv benefit state resourc llg owner refus sell commiss note chang land destin plan agricultur industri austria declar chang design place llg privat seller sign purchas contract austria point llg plot legal speak part busi park part busi park concept bph time paid price land busi park element commiss conclud llg benefit compani specif state measur receiv transfer state resourc state aid element hidden land price eur paid llg draw conclus commiss regard assess fact futur compani busi park acquir develop land price time high paid llg austria respond emphasis llg acquir land undevelop paid develop cost austria present calcul invest plan balanc sheet park develop bph calcul show price differ fulli explain develop cost bph incur plot remain price differ explain cost infrastructur connect individu plot busi park futur purchas land pai connect llg pai connect infrastructur commiss queri point measur recit austria agre make llg pai major share infrastructur connect cost busi park remain unexplain cost differ land purchas price llg consider higher price bph plan charg develop plot land measur fix price year basic process media decis octob commiss request evid price servic market price price cover cost depreci invest fix capit incur wh set util centr abwasserverband bezirk jennersdorf abj construct wast water treatment plant austria provid evid detail model calcul carri renown energi provid show price basic process media agre wh higher llg energi provid built util centr calcul wh charg llg price higher cost provis wh oper date energi effici combin heat power plant cost gener compar favour energi process media provid plant media simultan gener easili compar price individu media provid price compar compar media centr lenz ag parent compani llg intern calcul show mix media consider lower cost main locat lenz burgenland comparison wast water treatment plant show wast water treatment price eur repres normal market price austria demonstr full cost treatment plant includ full depreci invest eur price structur regard normal wast water sector addit cost cover price remov remain doubt state aid austria confirm write llg prepar pai eur million connect cost surfac water drainag februari llg declar write waiv price guarante basic process media remov aid element inher year price guarante stipul quot burgenland vertrag quot llg paid market price refer date waiver austria demonstr llg paid pai price basic process media higher cost provis price higher compani locat price cover full cost provis includ depreci invest commiss accept austria argument price guarante time llg decid invest infrastructur place price guarante waiv commiss consid contract wh llg abj llg element state aid final view evid provid commiss see assess austria argument media provid privat compani act measur ad hoc invest aid eur million land purchas letter march austria state aid grant ad hoc region invest aid aid notifi pursuant articl ec treati austria fail fulfil treati oblig grant aid prior approv commiss individu aid grant commiss assess compat common market directli light articl ec treati articl stipul save provid ec treati aid grant member state state resourc distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market ad hoc grant invest aid benefit llg help significantli reduc invest cost aid signific sustain posit impact llg financi posit area lyocel product akzo nobel intern pharmaceut coat chemic fibr compani base netherland llg main competitor addit llg competit number fibr produc situat member state fibr market suffer capac state measur liabl affect econom posit competitor member state measur constitutet aid mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement distort threaten distort competit affect trade member state articl ec treati exempt principl incompat state aid common market articl ec treati type aid compat common market aid question social charact grant individu consum make good damag caus natur disast except occurr aid grant economi area feder republ germani exempt provid articl ec treati project common european interest appli articl ec treati exempt aid favour develop econom activ aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest aid govern specif commun guidelin commiss consid commun guidelin rescu restructur research develop environ small medium size enterpris employ train appli austria state letter march aid region object provinc burgenland ec treati establish exempt region aid articl state aid consid compat common market promot econom develop area standard live abnorm low underemploy initi invest aid point relev commun guidelin nation region aid set condit exempt court justic establish hytasa case commiss assess aid fulfil requir region aid articl prohibit aid consid incompat common market letter octob austria provid evid region signific aid made clear aid grant part packag quot burgenland vertrag quot clear link purpos region invest aid elig cost envisag invest timet provid earlier quot burgenland vertrag quot describ region signific aid letter octob austria provid inform region signific aid proportion aid packag anticip distort european competit austria emphasis difficult econom situat provinc burgenland süd burgenland project lead creation perman highli skill job invest expect gener catalyt effect region attract compani settl region indirect employ creat region supplier custom austria believ competit impact limit view unnecessari product capac creat llg product lyocel sold product market outlook favour reason capac europ market lyocel fibr region signific aid commiss suffici inform assess region import llg project provinc burgenland link invest cost region object clarifi austria competit impact commiss case lyocel viscos fibr belong distinct product market product market develop trend market product lyocel gener downward trend viscos fibr market regard separ market commiss conclud competit impact llg invest small commiss note decis june austria consid product market lyocel fibr distinct gener viscos fibr market apprais confirm comment receiv interest parti addit commiss refer abovement decis similar conclus decis june merger case iv akzo nobel courtauld take account fact product qualiti lyocel view custom significantli higher price high lyocel tencel fibr compar normal viscos fibr commiss consid purpos case product market suffici distinct regard competit impact limit view assess land elig guidelin nation region aid point commiss approv ad hoc region invest aid provid level aid stai region aid ceil provinc burgenland net grant equival assess recit measur provis equiti capit eur million letter march austria confirm capit particip grant approv aid scheme decis june commiss determin aid charact measur regard soft loan austria written declar market rate charg year time period soft loan year matur confer return capit wibag regard measur austria provid letter octob evid region import aid made clear aid grant part packag burgenland vertrag purpos region invest aid link elig cost envisag invest timet provid earlier regard measur commiss endors region justif equiti capit provis commiss satisfi measur permiss elig cost guidelin nation region aid burgenland vertrag capit invest plant machineri commiss region natur aid justifi austria claim aid equival equiti capit eur million calcul appli market interest rate commiss publish refer interest rate calcul ant grant equival interest subsidi scheme loan refer rate suppos reflect averag level interest rate charg member state medium long term loan year back normal secur equiti measur cover year period commiss consid reason basi experi current interest rate remain year order make relev period short past year refer rate forc date aid grant grant equival aid eur million measur compani specif infrastructur connect unknown aid amount letter april austria present agreement llg bph llg wh llg particip infrastructur cost incur provid connect agreement llg pai total eur million road wast water treatment facil electr ga pipe util centr water provis fire protect facil austria repres cost infrastructur facil busi park addit cost llg futur bear cost eur million develop infrastructur connect plot final llg pai railwai link fee eur million year assess contract complet inform provid partli form independ report financ develop wh bph commiss conclud pai connect llg benefit specif infrastructur develop busi park assess commiss consid austria argument llg site lead investor grant favour condit compani commerci interest bph wh claim substanti financi data origin argument document time set park commiss conclud element state aid involv provis infrastructur wh bph llg measur assess environment aid eur million order approv environment aid act correctli appli commiss check invest aid quot product method reduct pollut quot herstellungsmaßnahmen zur verringerung von umweltbelastung stipul articl conjunct articl aid guidelin austria reiter repli octob environment benefit equip demonstr comparison viscos product process austria argu lyocel process product innov measur comparison closest predecessor process regular viscos product process austria hold assess environment aid act base comparison final product relev market focus product process closest altern support argument austria provid evid applic scheme letter februari austria provid support document underpin decis ökk commiss request inform elig cost clear attribut equip part environment potenti equip avoid doubl count elig cost includ question simultan research develop financ letter octob austria clarifi exact cost elig item rule possibl doubl count relat research develop aid provid eu cofinanc attribut elig cost item finalis invest demonstr environment potenti invest austria provid clarif letter octob includ statement elig equip part llg minimum specif pursuit addit environment benefit letter februari austria provid expert opinion detail environment potenti relev equip item quantit term commiss expert opinion evid high addit environment contribut invest commiss conclud austria establish instanc viscos product process constitut altern environment benefit comparison purpos inform elig cost environment potenti cost item commiss conclud austria correctli appli approv environment aid scheme commiss calcul aid intens elig cost pilot project consid aid exist aid calcul aid intens commiss verifi amount region invest aid grant llg exce maximum allow aid ceil region aid provinc burgenland ceil time aid grant net grant equival purpos assess commiss account measur assist compani detail paragraph discount time commiss determin invest aid eur million gross tax repres net grant equival eur million rel elig cost eur million aid repres aid intens region aid ceil case environment aid eur million elig cost eur million maximum aid intens admiss pilot project environment aid scheme compli conclus measur consid state aid mean articl ec treati measur ad hoc region invest aid measur exist aid repres correct applic approv aid programm commiss consid propos invest aid eur million eur million net elig cost eur million environment aid eur million compat ec treati adopt decis articl aid austria grant lenz lyocel gmbh amp kg llg heiligenkreuz provis guarante amount eur million guarante consortium commerci public sector bank amount eur million guarante wirtschaftspark heiligenkreuz servicegesellschaft mbh wh amount eur million eur million eur million land price eur acquisit hectar industri land fix price guarante provinc burgenland provis process util provis aid unknown amount form creation compani specif infrastructur constitut aid mean articl ec treati articl aid austria grant llg provis guarante amount eur million wibag compli guarante guidelin approv commiss number environment aid amount eur million compli environment aid guidelin approv commiss number articl individu aid austria grant form aid amount eur million land acquisit form equiti capit amount eur million compat common market articl decis address republ austria brussel juli commiss philipp busquin member commiss oj juli courtauld plc part akzo nobel intern pharmaceut coat chemic fibr compani base netherland footnot bundesgesetzblatt oj notifi richtlini betreffend die ubernahm von burgschaften fair kredit darlehen gemäß dem gesetz vom märz landesgesetzblatt über maßnahmen zur gewährleistung der wirtschaftlichen entwicklung im burgenland land wirtschaftsförderungsgesetz wifög footnot oj oj commiss notic method set refer discount rate oj