commiss decis decemb state aid implement germani favour entstaubungstechnik magdeburg gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof notic parti concern submit comment accord abovement provis procedur march commiss initi formal investig procedur respect state aid sket schwermaschinenbau magdeburg gmbh magdeburg quot sket smm quot plan afoot turn entstaubungstechnik magdeburg gmbh magdeburg quot etm quot subsidiari sket smm procedur extend includ etm procedur number juli procedur extend includ aid paid decis initi procedur cover decis potenti investor oestmann amp borchert industriebeteiligungen gbr abandon restructur plan end plan involv addit aid subsequ notifi june respect aid sket smm commiss adopt final neg decis decis ec decis appli etm procedur etm number januari august germani inform commiss aid etm receiv meet commiss germani announc etm privatis april commiss ask germani detail privatis provid month ask inform furnish germani juli addit question put decemb answer januari august number final question put answer receiv septemb ii detail descript aid etm base magdeburg saxoni anhalt emploi peopl achiev turnov dm million design manufactur advanc air smoke filter system share relev market etm current busi activ date back environment legisl introduc german democrat republ firm retool produc filter system integr air refriger technolog combin result transfer ernst thälmann heavi machineri combin result subsidiari sket ag share transfer treuhandanstalt quot tha quot tha dissolv share pass bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben quot bv quot hand remain privatis sale pka group privatis occur januari etm sold pka umwelttechnik gmbh amp kg member pka group pka group base germani oper worldwid market environment technolog group made small firm activ product market product servic offer includ design construct sale plant treatment process sludg refus wast recoveri reusabl materi energi specialis applic pyrolysi purpos pka group includ etm employe achiev turnov dem million light inform furnish germani entir pka group sme criteria laid commiss recommend ec april definit small medium size enterpris sale etm pka group place basi open uncondit transpar tender procedur west merchant bank task bv find investor june receiv bid respons invit tender total firm worldwid approach procedur negoti enter bidder offer select basi busi plan job mainten guarante kei financi data pka group bidder capabl take firm forese futur take part privatis resourc share commerci risk posit present financ plan bv guarante sale price dem pka inject dem million capit firm undertook invest dem million decemb subject penalti continu emploi peopl year subject penalti dem worker year undertook releas bv guarante current account credit facil dem million counter guarante dem million bv waiv repay etm dem million loan includ interest grant subsidi dem million etm firm difficulti incur annual loss main problem defici oper control equip purchas market sale oper high proport bought part relat servic account contract effici bui cost lower problem unsuccess associ sket smm etm subsidiari sket smm sket smm subsidiari privatis plan fruition relationship troubl conglomer sket smm etm damag reput credibl marketplac etm order book suffer result addit problem aros establish quot technolog quot divis cumbersom ineffici organis framework sket smm etm undergon continu restructur found limit compani firm acquir pka tha bv restructur measur failur privatis sket smm bv strategi prepar etm privatis independ compani step direct etm concentr core busi design manufactur filter system quot special construct quot divis shut firm reduc personnel cost product plant close restructur plan submit investor address oper control problem respect expertis acquir pka group stand etm good stead plan base cooper etm pka group product rang custom base complementari etm pka group busi partner air ga filtrat field aspect restructur expans etm product pka group core product ga convert pipe conduit silo interest pka group product capac elimin risk loss inher parti product enabl etm underutilis capac restructur complet total cost restructur onward administr treuhandanstalt view prepar etm privatis dem million cost broken tabl gt tabl gt restructur plan plan fulli implement return viabil tabl kei data project return viabil figur base forecast made time privatis tabl gt tabl gt project growth turnov reflect etm order book tem benefit order rest pka group worldwid growth demand pka group product level incom order etm averag compar firm activ sector germani interim figur confirm viabil restor plan forecast bear favour trend inclus tabl fact restructur complet packag state financ measur notifi commiss germani worth time privatis dem million measur concern tabl gt tabl gt choic pka group investor result open uncondit invit tender award highest bidder result aid element fall consid context privatis investor contribut amount dem million broken tabl gt tabl gt etm activ market design manufactur industri air smoke filter system relev geograph market worldwid relev product market growth market geograph area growth longer spectacular late earli market outlook remain favour increas import energi save perceiv protect environ worldwid evidenc grow number environment protect provis european union market expect expand spain itali greec data suppli germani addit growth expect countri central eastern europ move closer standard set commun market industri air smoke filter system part broader market environment technolog pka group oper pyrolysi pyrolysi recov solid gase lessen dispos problem compar process reduc volum wast avoid problem inciner process contribut reduct emiss ga result process energi product solid residu pyrolysi char filter purpos gasifi ga energi industri solid residu construct industri plant design pka group etm filter commiss evid overcapac market type plant market environment technolog gener formal investig procedur provid articl ec treati initi respect aid sket smm subsidiari etm includ procedur ow intent transfer share etm sket smm transfer place legal point view etm main problem relat initi procedur lack inform restructur etm privatis januari problem identifi restructur plan submit investor contribut small side total amount aid unclear matter resolv inform subsequ receiv iii assess measur measur identifi tabl fall scope articl ec treati reason etm activ product market extend member state trade member state affect state financ measur made firm difficulti gener constitut aid firm probabl receiv financi assist privat sourc aid threaten se distort competit measur identifi award etm aid mean articl ec treati except provid treati appli incompat common market measur identifi item tabl amount dem million award meet condit relev treuhand aid scheme subsequ waiver repay loan constitut addit aid loan guarante grant treuhand scheme benefit firm difficulti expect time award firm repai assum aid intens case high measur identifi item tabl aid measur identifi item tabl aid state resourc dem invest allow item base region aid scheme previous authoris commiss reassess dem million fall consid decis articl ec treati possibl exempt aid fall scope articl basi exempt restructur aid etm firm difficulti articl order meet requir derog head aid satisfi criteria set guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin guidelin appli version aid measur question aid grant guidelin publish commiss consid rescu restructur aid facilit develop econom activ advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest condit set section guidelin met authoris aid condit firm rescu restructur locat assist area commiss take region consider articl account paragraph guidelin satisfi criteria set guidelin restructur plan restor long term viabil firm difficulti reason timescal basi realist assumpt note etm firm difficulti elig restructur aid problem face etm measur requir address outlin measur undertaken privatis address part measur undertaken privatis address remaind problem includ integr parent compani etm econom perform meet target set time privatis investor commit impact etm order inflow order worth dem million book end januari industri averag etm receiv order pyrolysi plant chile addit order worth dem million restor viabil reason period realist firm satisfi criterion condit restructur aid satisfi guidelin distort competit result aid undu guidelin aid recipi structur overcapac relev market perman reduc product capac increas restructur period allow commiss evid relev market market environment technolog includ product air smoke filter system structur overcapac fact market appear enjoi steadi growth perman capac reduct etm requir etm decommiss part product capac note major part aid grant past privatis etm carri predatori price futur similarli risk misus aid grant context privatis dem million low earmark specif item individu expenditur list tabl mean guidelin undu distort competit commiss indic overcapac specif market etm aid beneficiari oper market rest pka group oper forego take account etm statu sme small market share commiss conclud aid measur favour etm result undu distort competit condit guidelin restructur aid accept amount intens aid limit strict minimum need enabl restructur undertaken relat benefit anticip commun point view investor expect make signific contribut restructur plan resourc total cost restructur amount dem million sum restrict minimum requir carri restructur dem million cover treuhand scheme consid purpos assess proportion balanc dem million investor contribut dem million signific contribut view forego commiss conclud concern express open proceed address criterion proportion aid satisfi condit guidelin restructur plan submit accept commiss fulli implement oblig laid commiss decis observ origin decis amend notif member state commiss step requir recoveri aid restructur etm practic complet germani provid assur measur ensur plan carri commiss conclud head guidelin satisfi iv conclus commiss find germani unlawfulli implement aid measur identifi contrari articl ec treati view forego commiss conclud fulfil restructur aid guidelin compat common market commiss account fact etm locat assist area mean articl ec treati adopt decis articl measur germani implement favour entstaubungstechnik magdeburg gmbh quot etm quot fall consid decis amount dem million compat common market mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement aid concern compris grant bundesanstalt vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv time privatis dem million loan bv dem million amp grant bv dem invest grant dem articl germani submit report year implement restructur plan articl decis address feder republ germani brussel decemb commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj oj pyrolysi inciner process organ matter decompos action intens heat absenc oxygen typic occur pressur temperatur recov solid materi construct industri recov gase power gener made loss dem million normal commerci activ lose dem million head tabl select kei data individu column complet account point view market recycl environment technolog gener panorama eu industri section potenti declin market treatment chemic solvent recit aid grant decemb commiss decis activ treuhandanstalt case nn aid grant commiss decis case state aid case nn financi assist environment protect measur intend time measur job creation consid commiss aid mean articl ec treati invest allow act measur act qualifi region invest aid articl ec treati authoris commiss derog articl authoris aid scheme oj section guidelin oj recit recit recit recit