commiss decis decemb aid grant german govern govern land bavaria produc polyamid polypropylen yarn reinhold kg situat selbitz german text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun subparagraph articl thereof notic parti concern submit comment provid articl regard comment novemb perman represent germani notifi project german author grant aid form subvent soft loan invest compani heinrich reinhold kg reinhold carri year inform beneficiari aid suppli request commiss januari februari request inform date payment dm million soft loan commiss novemb german govern inform fail answer request date april assum date element aid soft loan place german author answer request notif concern applic submit reinhold novemb march feder offic trade industri respect extens plant selbitz involv invest volum dm period decemb decemb grant dm invest premium law investitionszulagengesetz approv commiss letter decemb time loan amount dm million grant budget bavaria bavarian region assist programm bayerisch regional foerderprogramm approv commiss letter date decemb loan durat year year grace period interest rate take account total amount invest net grant equival aid worth state aid synthet fibr industri subject constraint introduc renew year recent commun member state juli product reinhold yarn polyamid polypropylen fall scope constraint cover fibr yarn textil juli end juli requir aid propos type favour compani synthet fibr yarn sector notifi commiss suffici time submit comment initi respect propos measur procedur provid articl eec treati constraint limit accept except gener restrict state aid sole incent disinvest sector type product exclud measur effect increas net product capac synthet fibr basi inform suppli german govern commiss view purpos invest propos aid relat reduc compani product capac synthet yarn encourag convers sector mention constraint contrari commisson observ main purpos invest increas product capac final commiss consid commun market yarn polyamid polypropylen highli competit result presenc numer produc oper nation market character stagnant demand capit intens invest reduc margin aid question affect trade member state reason incompat rule laid articl eec treati commiss view aid meet condit fulfil except laid articl appli initi procedur provid subparagraph articl eec treati letter april gave german govern notic submit comment member state interest parti inform mean public commun german govern ii german govern submit comment procedur provid articl letter confirm posit state time notif reinhold product relat coars fibr sector character statement recipi aid time invest high level demand european level high level demand custom undertak german govern conclud aid compat common market german govern point soft loan dm million year includ year grace period bear interest grant reinhold spring prior notif aid commiss hand invest premium dm paid shown pursuant articl invest premium law project econom worthi assist procedur commiss receiv comment feder undertak sector octob observ submit german govern suppli comment iii financi assist grant reinhold invest premium law approv commiss letter decemb bavarian region assist programm approv letter decemb constitut aid mean articl eec treati enabl undertak invest abovement amount bear cost aid notifi commiss pursuant articl aid rule synthet fibr yarn commiss requir prior notif aid propos type case applic approv aid scheme favour compani synthet fibr yarn sector german govern fail notifi soft loan question grant commiss unabl state view measur implement aid contrari commun law time oper situat produc failur aid paid recipi aid rise effect regard incompat common market case aid incompat common market commiss possibl court justic judgment juli case march case septemb case requir member state recov aid grant illeg recipi high volum trade synthet yarn polyamid polypropylen yarn total commun product trade commun reinhold share combin polyamid polypropylen product commun tonn increas product capac yarn polyamid polypropylen tonn tonn export sale account turnov figur plan invest aim increas capac approxim tonn addit process line product capac repres total commun capac substanti overcapac polyamid polypropylen yarn commun geograph shift product continu favour world capac util rate polyamid decreas total estim overcapac tonn capac util rate polypropylen yarn total estim overcapac tonn high level capac util requir commun synthet fibr yarn industri order achiev satisfactori rate profit result sector specif constraint fierc competit downstream market produc custom sensit price factor activ presenc produc low wage countri enjoi competit advantag highli industri countri usa japan capac util close condit public intervent lead reduct cost undoubtedli repres valuabl advantag compani competitor case reinhold aid issu consider reduc cost direct financi invest strengthen financi posit vi vi competitor receiv assist distort competit appreci aid loan grant amount net grant equival state financi aid strengthen posit undertak compar undertak compet intra commun trade regard prejudici affect aid case issu aid reduc invest cost undertak selbitz bear liabl affect trade distort threaten distort competit member state favour undertak mean articl eec treati articl lai principl aid featur incompat common market iv except principl incompat set articl eec treati applic case issu charact aid intend purpos question articl aid grant economi area feder republ germani affect divis germani compat common market commiss consid zonal border area germani automat exempt control state aid favour industri sector subject specif aid code establish order combat crisi letter novemb joint feder govern laender aid plan inform german govern proviso contest polici confirm commiss prohibit grant state aid synthet yarn produc situat neumuenst deggendorf zonal border area conclud aid grant grant reinhold benefit exempt provid articl eec treati articl set aid consid compat common market compat eec treati determin context commun singl member state order safeguard proper function common market take account principl articl eec treati except principl articl set articl constru narrowli aid scheme individu award scrutin except appli commiss satisfi free plai market forc aid induc prospect aid recipi adopt action contribut attain object appli except case aid achiev object give unfair advantag member state industri undertak financi posit bolster prejudic trade condit member state distort competit justif ground commun interest set articl german govern unabl give commiss discov justif find aid fall categori except articl except provid articl applic aid promot econom develop area standard live abnorm low underemploy method applic articl region aid express refer made commiss stipul region capita gdp pp commun averag elig exempt arrang articl clear list elig region commiss consid econom social situat feder republ germani border prior octob justifi applic articl countri individu region except provid articl evid aid question intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb german economi aid favour compani synthet yarn industri adequ remedi kind situat articl regard exempt provid articl favour aid facilit develop econom activ observ synthet fibr yarn gener polyamid polypropylen yarn high level trade member state competit keen persist uncontest overcapac state reason synthet fibr yarn includ polyamid polypropylen subject aid rule synthet fibr yarn letter juli juli extend system control aid year period end juli cover period relev aid case commiss point member state priori express unfavour opinion regard propos aid sector region gener effect increas net product capac compani sector remind member state continu give sympathet consider propos grant aid purpos speed facilit process convers synthet fibr activ restructur lead reduct capac letter commiss remind member state requir prior notif aid propos type favour compani synthet fibr yarn sector main purpos invest case expand product capac compani ad process line instal reach total output polyamid polypropylen yarn tonn limit increas workforc peopl need oper line result signific increas product competit compani view main purpos reinhold invest plan aid issu contrari synthet fibr yarn aid code time invest featur justifi commiss exempt aid concern rule set aid code public support avoid increas capac contrari commun interest seek reduct capac aggrav situat compet undertak suffer oversuppli market comment procedur german govern claim type yarn produc reinhold special featur coars filament undergo special dye treatment make appreci custom special requir give reinhold competit advantag respect point polyamid polypropylen yarn surplu commun kind filament produc reinhold special innov featur produc high quantiti larg number undertak point beneficiari constantli record posit econom result market forc suffici secur normal develop compani implement invest question state intervent recent year commiss prohibit member state grant financi assist sythet fibr yarn produc similar ident situat compani question wish increas modern product effect requir aid rule synthet fibr view forego consider regard exempt provid articl eec treati favour aid facilit develop econom activ observ aid issu artifici lower cost undertak question weaken competit posit produc commun effect reduc capac util detriment produc effort hitherto surviv virtu restructur oper improv product qualiti forc market aid grant undertak question market posit longer sole determin profit effici financi posit consid contribut develop commun point view adequ counteract distort trade caus aid except provid articl applic aid facilit develop econom area advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest weak condit man made fibr industri sector effect region aid check underdevelop area selbitz belong commiss carri analysi econom social situat context commun interest sector reduc capac limit impact reinhold invest labour market involv creation job insuffici persuad commiss set essenti neg attitud aid man made fibr sector set aid code abovement reason except provid articl appli case view forego consider element aid contain dm million soft loan paid spring bavarian region assist programm illeg german govern fulfil oblig notifi pursuant articl eec treati explain aid unlawfulli enjoi reinhold meet condit fulfil order except articl appli aid recov quantifi aid commiss calcul differ refer market rate time loan grant assumpt april interest rate attach loan percentag point time adopt decis interest subsidi loan result gain dm grant dm paid invest premium law meet condit except provid articl paid month delai compli oblig german govern requir reinhold repai monthli interest subsidi dm adopt decis articl aid grant feder german republ reinhold kg april form interest subsidi loan dm million valu dm date adopt decis illeg grant breach provis articl eec treati aid incompat common market mean articl eec treati aid grant firm form grant dm incompat common market mean articl implement articl german govern requir reinhold kg refund delai interest subsidi dm refer articl german govern delai cancel aid aris loan dm million refer articl requir loan refund make liabl market interest rate rate correspond charg loan grant kreditanstalt fuer wiederaufbau programm month delai compli oblig german govern requir reinhold kg repai monthli interest subsidi dm articl german govern inform commiss measur compli decis month notif articl decis address feder republ germani brussel decemb commiss leon brittan vice presid oj ecr ecr publish oj oj oj oj