commiss decis octob wast dispos system car wreck implement netherland notifi document number dutch text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis regard comment procedur letter date septemb regist septemb netherland author notifi commiss intend extend wast dispos system car wreck origin system extens approv commiss conclud measur constitut aid mean articl treati letter date octob commiss request inform commiss remind netherland author request letter date decemb netherland author repli letter date decemb regist decemb request inform letter date januari netherland author repli letter date januari regist januari decis februari commiss initi procedur laid articl treati respect wast dispos system letter date march commiss inform netherland decis ask time letter date march regist march grant letter date april netherland react decis letter date june regist june decis publish offici journal european commun interest parti invit submit comment aid commiss receiv comment receiv period month date public expir netherland ask comment letter letter date juli netherland comment comment interest parti letter date june regist june letter date august regist august meet commiss netherland author arn central organis wast manag system place march dutch author view prolong system await commiss final decis declar system gener bind view expiri previou period detail descript measur aim wast dispos system ensur compani manufactur sell car respons high degre recycl reus car wreck signific environment consequ involv european parliament council adopt direct end life vehicl hereinaft car wreck direct direct set object reus recoveri reus recycl end life vehicl figur reach object particip dutch system realis object line principl produc respons quot pollut pai quot principl import respons reach object li car manufactur import earli sector organis combin form profit foundat car amp recycl sticht auto amp recycl hereinaft sar develop nationwid collect recycl system car wreck implement manag recycl system sar set privat limit liabil compani auto recycl nederland bv hereinaft arn own sar arn respons organis logist administr recycl car wreck system oper januari core system voluntari agreement manufactur profession import car netherland combin rai agre pai charg car regist time netherland charg collect arn resourc cost dismantl car wreck recycl collect materi includ transport agreement conclud time period year notifi agreement date juli stipul car manufactur import pai eur nlg car regist netherland brand type period charg eur nlg eur nlg car charg eur nlg car base complex calcul import variabl calcul averag composit car wreck averag cost dismantl recycl car wreck expect number car wreck expect number car regist netherland import variabl extent exist reserv current dismantl premium charg flat rate appli brand type car arn cost dismantl recycl car wreck differenti order ensur car manufactur import pai charg netherland govern declar agreement gener bind manufactur import market period januari januari minist hous plan environ grant exempt request parti ensur dispos car wreck equival dispos system declar gener bind premium paid part car wreck netherland author dismantl collect recycl econom viabl manner present arn grant wast dispos premium dismantl materi gt tabl gt plan add airbag safeti belt fasten air condit plastic fuel tank list onward theoret situat materi dismantl norm total cost amount eur nlg wreck eur nlg cost dismantl eur nlg cost packag collect eur nlg cost recycl due inflat higher recycl percentag includ materi recycl technolog develop respect car cost expect increas time expect total figur eur nlg materi recycl premium neg mean dismantl compani receiv payment recycl compani materi recycl deduct premium receiv arn car dismantl compani affili arn dismantl car wreck netherland arn pai dismantl contribut quantiti raw materi dismantl averag norm quantiti eur nlg arn estim number car wreck arn market share total amount disburs amount eur million nlg million administr cost system budget eur million nlg million expect grow eur million nlg million year dismantl compani arn certifi elig premium provid meet object criteria environment licens regist onlin registr system car dismantl orad work facil machin tool softwar line arn standard certif procedur carri independ certifi bodi société générale de surveil addit arn requir dismantl compani recognis netherland vehicl registr author rdw provid law compani legal establish netherland obtain recognit fact compani obtain wast dispos premium tender procedur award contract collect transport dismantl materi recycl compani interest compani invit prove fulfil minimum technic financi standard environment transport licenc facil experi compani provinc select take account cost price collect technic qualiti organis suitabl collect oil subject system regul law tender procedur award contract recycl materi interest compani fulfil number minimum technic financi requir environment licenc equip bankruptci histori crimin record arn select attract offer materi question take account cost price recycl work method technic qualiti organis suitabl produc import car free pass charg buyer refrain part proce charg professionalis pilot project annual budget professionalis amount eur million period onward amount eur million annual budget pilot project relat recycl eur million period eur million year research topic includ method analysi dismantl develop tool equip machineri develop qualiti control system research separ technolog optimis logist system research product market studi develop system reason initi procedur laid articl treati commiss initi procedur laid articl treati doubt aspect system dismantl contribut constitut overcompens dismantl compani potenti spillov spare part market natur professionalis pilot project financ levi unclear commiss express doubt potenti infring articl treati restrict export arn dismantl compani particip system recognis netherland vehicl registr author rdw provid law compani establish netherland obtain recognit practic compani obtain premium commiss express specif doubt potenti aid car manufactur import packag collect recycl compani interest parti opportun comment comment interest parti public notic initi procedur commiss receiv comment parti comment car manufactur associ compani activ wast pur foam market consult work group dutch wast dispos compani unit kingdom author central organis system arn fourth associ compani activ field pur foam subsequ react respons reaction comment car manufactur comment period month public notic offici journal comment car manufactur comment car manufactur focu aspect arn system renault welcom system place respons product stage life consum think requir car dismantl compani establish netherland small concess member state take respons wast stream renault challeng fact charg paid stage life vehicl residu econom car manufactur make effort quot design recycl quot return invest differenti treatment cost product pai averag vehicl car manufactur peugeot argu arn system base incomplet contest approach lead overestim cost treat car wreck arn account differ effici evid european develop restrict car dismantl compani establish netherland justifi european legisl final peugeot regret total absenc transpar arn refus commun result research result uniqu europ share allow analysi car manufactur gener motor europ hereinaft gme find unaccept arn appli averag price effect meant car manufactur involuntarili subsidis ineffici player gme maintain averag price base worst cost base structur alleg dutch dismantl compani excess amount monei arn system bui car wreck germani constitut unfair competit car manufactur involv process normal payer real system tender offer car effici dismantl compani forc dismantl compani make product improv requir gme think lot room product improv gme believ system favour dismantl monei invest energi recoveri good reach recycl quota peugeot gme argu arn suffici transpar provid access result technic studi clear recycl quota achiev recycl materi seat belt final gme consid restrict arn system compani establish netherland fairli complex issu gme believ oper commun home languag countri proper monitor comment associ compani activ wast pur foam market set comment european plastic convert european isocyan produc associ european associ manufactur mould polyurethan part automot industri support european associ flexibl polyurethan foam block manufactur draw attent alleg effect arn system market wast pur foam associ maintain year industri netherland recycl pur foam scrap industri wast voluntari basi subsidi profit arn subsidi kg vehicl detriment impact price level recycl pur final result subsidis pur foam recycl activ squeez market associ point altern provid car wreck direct prevent reus recycl form recoveri end life vehicl compon add system discrimin fill materi car seat car part similar oblig final argu recycl pur foam separ econom solut energet automot shredder residu higher type plastic includ pur foam left comment associ plastic manufactur europ support view plastic recycl develop line prescrib legisl sourc fund arn system repres type framework provid support plastic recycl comment behalf wast dispos compani consult drew set comment submit copi notic object submit wast dispos compani netherland competit author nma notic concern thing distort competit particip particip car dismantl compani respect matter commerci profit part contain car wreck import issu concern distort competit result domin posit arn market dismantl materi fact arn conclud contract wast oil collect compani countri call question document state collect treatment hazard wast wast oil oil filter batteri profit activ comment unit kingdom author unit kingdom author stress transpos car wreck direct member state account system industri structur place econom oper prevent enter commerci negoti contract variabl fix payment basi agre fix price contract unnecessarili complex oblig oper enter variabl contract comment arn arn submit extens inform system studi cost price car dismantl report market structur car dismantl sector netherland author fulli support arn comment larg overlap comment reaction netherland set comment dealt section comment netherland arn gener issu netherland author arn begin remind commiss earlier decis system conclud state aid principl system chang meantim arn doubt commiss adopt decis earlier decis assert commiss event procedur rule applic exist aid rule applic aid arn comment descript system issu arn stress system base agreement privat parti enter contract dismantl compani order achiev object definit state aid state resourc refer court case preussenelektra opinion mr advoc gener jacob case arn netherland argu system involv state aid levi collect constitut state resourc state resourc fund state exercis control contrari tax payment made basi voluntarili adopt agreement minist declar agreement gener bind market coverag case arn market voluntarili adopt agreement profession import privat parti oblig submit request declar agreement gener bind fund paid privat undertak privat legal entiti sar found privat parti time fund acquir charg properti state state point exercis form control fund arn public bodi organis design establish state fact request order declar agreement gener bind minist conduct limit review agreement dispos system financ charg agre minist assess organis entrust task oper system suffici independ target recycl set government regul met involv parti mean state influenc actual set oper system final collect charg respons privat parti parti refus abid oblig system interest parti appli court civil law system govern civil law netherland author arn maintain contribut affect trade member state competit netherland foreign dismantl compani market dismantl servic european legisl make imposs event unattract export untreat car wreck reason aid mean articl treati overcompens car dismantl compani netherland author arn opinion contribut car dismantl compani constitut reason payment materi dismantl basi realist estim dismantl cost activ compani receiv remuner carri remuner econom profit car dismantl compani free join system remain system chang competit posit compani market remain open competit respect particip compani contribut car dismantl compani base independ research market cost price car produc import repres sar determin contribut interest keep contribut low arn reduc contribut arn activ commerci feasibl contribut activ cancel time import set contribut level car dismantl compani prepar work actual payment contribut paid materi dismantl theoret total dismantl contribut event materi car part dismantl norm quantiti eur averag contribut car practic amount compani dismantl materi norm establish arn due dismantl commerci profit part due fact car wreck quot complet quot actual amount paid small half particip car dismantl compani receiv contribut eur year period tabl compani payment remain eur period compani remain eur case higher figur reach maximum eur compani receiv eur differ contribut cost small result aid threshold gt tabl gt cost price car dismantl compani commiss base decis initi procedur laid articl treati investig independ expert carri april novemb finalis arn note report draft view determin lowest contribut assess overcompens report compani cost figur eur figur case doubt larg group smaller compani cost higher eur eur report interpret mean cheapest dismantl compani dismantl arn materi cost eur practic compani report incomplet unreli base year incomplet administr inform obtain small compani limit experi account matter estim compani materi ad list arn materi materi complic dismantl gener cost inflat shortag qualifi labour cost cost element deliber account cost equip alloc gener cost cost transport car wreck dismantl compani cost mainten larger effici compani practic higher cost report calcul reason arn submit updat report draft consult report focus compani dismantl wreck year compani account car wreck dismantl averag compani dismantl car wreck year focu larger compani justifi fact smaller compani expect higher cost price fix cost weigh heavili averag compani dismantl wreck refer cost price nlg eur car wreck calcul exclud transport cost figur premium paid averag report calcul cost price basi relev cost item compani analys earlier report rang cost price includ transport cost obtain vari nlg eur nlg eur figur higher report variat limit compani report calcul cost price lower refer cost price transport cost includ case report calcul cost price includ transport cost averag premium paid relev compani differ amount nlg eur mean compani profit margin activ cost figur higher spillov effect commerci spare part market smaller compani activ market compani contribut arn low comparison cost contribut signific impact trade member state competit econom apprais sector tender procedur arn submit studi consult econom apprais car dismantl sector analysi outcom tender procedur arn main argument current system arn conclud contract dismantl compani market term compani overcompens reason expect tender procedur select dismantl compani lead result account effect method arn abil achiev commun recycl target contrari payment dismantl compani higher tender procedur studi note normal market effici compani make higher profit netherland author hold tender procedur select car dismantl compani netherland european object car wreck achiev larg number particip dismantl compani desir tender procedur definit lead limit number select compani arn owner car wreck posit determin dismantl compani receiv car wreck tender procedur lead lower dismantl cost compani offer dismantl servic lower price compani suffici capac dismantl wreck compani concentr wreck result accid commerci attract spare part refus dismantl older econom unattract car wreck netherland author specif criteria tender procedur minimum number dismantl compani region effect solv problem approach lead select larg number car dismantl compani cost contrari low cost object commiss main reason favour tender procedur arn perform guid role market present fact select conclud contract car dismantl compani effect tender procedur real tender procedur establish market price lower current contribut lower dismantl compani dismantl car wreck lower amount netherland author arn conclud overcompens car dismantl compani arn research develop activ arn budget research develop cover arn intern cost feasibl studi carri univers research institut recycl materi recycl method research studi effici arn system pilot project carri compani recycl process dismantl materi arn provid detail breakdown expenditur period quarter activ involv state aid perform benefit compani pai dispos fee assign parti market condit case amount payment low aid event de minimi threshold categori pilot project concern quot recycl quot materi resourc develop technolog exist separ technolog mine industri recycl materi investig view potenti applic car materi applic technolog reach object set car wreck direct arn bear full cost project result publicli reason arn publish inform detail harm arn compani competit interest oblig result car wreck direct netherland author maintain implement car wreck direct legal oblig produc import bear financi respons collect process car wreck agreement wast dispos levi voluntarili addit financi respons direct implement maintain collect process car wreck constitut cost includ budget compani agreement lead exempt cost constitut elabor underli principl particip foreign car dismantl compani netherland author arn perceiv infring articl treati firstli articl target measur privat parti requir recognis orad recognit provid rdw consequ govern measur impos arn public bodi car dismantl compani set establish netherland order obtain orad recognit thirdli measur make distinct basi nation fall applic articl requir recognis orad applic distinct compani domest foreign origin car irrespect produc fourthli export car wreck car dismantl compani abroad imposs restrict orad recognit system fifthli free movement good import export car wreck harmonis council regul eec februari supervis control shipment wast ec altern dutch author hold opinion object justif arn requir orad recognit link registr system ensur contribut paid car produc import netherland dutch author distinguish situat implement car wreck direct concern situat implement car wreck direct rdw provid orad recognit compani establish control monitor compani polici context annual car test apk netherland author reason judgment van schaik applic rdw provid orad recognit compani abroad arn theori compani particip system concern situat implement car wreck direct basi articl member state mutual recognis accept certif destruct issu compet author member state achiev rdw accept certif deregist car wreck concern give foreign compani power deregist car line sentenc articl specifi issu certif destruct entitl compani claim financi reimburs car dismantl basic local oper activ reason relat arn system export car wreck limit netherland author reason expect futur firstli car wreck liquid export conform quot red list procedur quot regul eec part procedur request permiss export import countri payment deposit enabl parti object intend export make export time consum expens riski activ car wreck liquid export conform quot green list procedur quot regul eec remov liquid export make financi organisation unattract export netherland car wreck car dismantl compani abroad number car dismantl compani abroad particip arn system introduc separ collect recycl measur materi dismantl compani lead problem context regul eec arn materi green list particip foreign car dismantl compani make system expens potenti aid packag collect recycl compani netherland author arn contract arn packag collect recycl compani normal contract reason doubt transpar discrimin guarante minimum suppli materi recycl compani constitut monetari transfer provid normal market condit comment parti comment netherland author note parti arn provid evid support remark note comment support system point parti contradict netherland author stress resourc recycl pur foam contribut concern dismantl foam car wreck contribut take account proce dismantl compani obtain materi distort competit arn system lead dismantl tonn pur foam year compar total annual product million tonn pur foam product wast amount tonn tonn export unit state qualiti foam car wreck lower foam product wast extens qualiti report requir netherland author lower proce pur foam foam car wreck due factor notabl poor market situat unit state increas suppli product wast foam diminish demand main underlai carpet arn start recycl pur foam price product wast foam export unit state fell dm dm kg final netherland author note wai wast pur foam cement oven gasif instal pur foam obtain shredder wast car wreck direct explicitli express prefer materi reus recoveri respect comment car manufactur netherland author principl favour differenti premium arn investig conclud respect cost level doubt car manufactur account ambiti object high qualiti requir state arn calcul recycl dismantl cost high quot excess amount quot enabl car dismantl compani bui car wreck germani case contribut paid dismantl netherland car respect comment submit behalf wast dispos compani netherland author hold comment accept consult proven interest case mention netherland competit author nma revis posit decis receipt document submit netherland author background comment regul introduc competit oil collect sector enabl arn conclud contract compani significantli advantag term assess state resourc effect trade preussenelektra court justic rule oblig impos privat electr suppli undertak purchas electr produc renew energi sourc fix minimum price involv direct indirect transfer state resourc undertak produc type electr arn system differ system intermediari organis respons manag resourc fund charg paid proce charg collect recycl materi distribut profit particip compani prohibit characterist charg compar parafisc charg occas court justic rule parafisc charg favour undertak constitut state aid present case manufactur import obtain exempt ensur dispos car wreck equival dispos system financ proce charg recit manufactur import free process car wreck resourc set system affili system option real rate car manufactur larg import commiss netherland author decis declar charg gener bind impos oblig produc result oblig contribut arn system commiss consid charg voluntari option charact proce charg constitut state resourc absenc state resourc mean state aid mean articl treati paragraph made clear proce charg constitut state resourc commiss conclud system involv state aid favour undertak product good effect trade member state concern commiss accept netherland author arn argument trade car wreck limit exist substanti number compani particip system activ spare part market spare part internation trade increasingli aid dismantl activ expect affect trade member state exist system possibl effect trade car car manufactur import articl car wreck direct stipul member state measur ensur produc profession import meet signific part cost implement measur line principl produc respons quot pollut pai quot principl fact netherland system base principl netherland system cost dismantl recycl car wreck financ proce charg declar gener bind govern view isol favour car manufactur import commiss make allow contribut arrang primarili car manufactur import financ recycl system reliev normal compani cost area recycl charg specif uniqu purpos direct compel link charg payment relat precis good moment econom lifetim circumst effect arrang oblig undertak sell car internalis true environment cost activ financi intervent member state car manufactur comment return invest quot design recycl quot form differenti treatment cost product deduc system aid element car manufactur invest similar amount quot design recycl quot notif arn explain choos determin levi type car calcul difficult base poor inform consequ quot design recycl quot impact car wreck system year commiss expect system car manufactur import pai signific part cost refer articl car wreck direct conclud state aid car manufactur import state resourc involv undertak involv packag collect recycl initi articl procedur comment receiv open tender procedur arn commiss assum procedur ensur remuner reduc minimum netherland author interven inflat payment overcompens undertak concern term tender transpar discriminatori condit impos object justifi give rise de facto discrimin public tender suffici transpar discriminatori insuffici conclus drawn state aid involv premium effect fill gap cost dismantl price obtain recycl materi market respons car manufactur import accord quot pollut pai quot principl agre confirm order declar agreement gener bind car wreck direct ensur activ remuner paid carri effect arrang undertak involv packag collect recycl effect perform servic primarili car manufactur import oppos member state consum commiss conclud state aid undertak proce charg deem state resourc comment associ involv pur foam recycl point effect contribut dismantl pur eur kg fact present netherland author effect small addit suppli inferior wast pur foam limit gener effect system remain typic result regul requir environment cost relat sell car internalis car industri dismantl compani commiss assess report submit arn present calcul cost car dismantl compani agre gener pictur shown actual cost price dismantl car wreck significantli higher report quot refer cost price quot dismantl averag car wreck averag contribut paid cost differ smaller conclud report case cost price averag contribut paid relev compani gap small commiss make allow suffici number particip dismantl compani final arn netherland author shown differ car wreck dismantl compani present difficulti tender procedur commiss rule appli procedur agre result lower dismantl contribut case effici dismantl compani circumst commiss regard dismantl contribut reflect market price servic car dismantl compani overcompens compani absenc overcompens view isol suffici conclus drawn state aid involv premium effect fill gap cost dismantl price obtain recycl materi market recit respons car manufactur import accord quot pollut pai quot principl agre confirm order declar agreement gener bind car wreck direct ensur activ remuner paid carri effect arrang dismantl compani effect perform servic primarili car manufactur import oppos member state consum commiss conclud state aid undertak proce charg deem state resourc wast dispos system car wreck necessarili involv choic technolog view reus recov recycl specif materi arn netherland author object favour select dismantl combin shredder separ technolog involv larg workload dismantl compani fact alter natur contribut market reward servic render reason state constitut state aid expens professionalis pilot project relat recycl research studi effici arn system effici dismantl primarili import arn function system directli benefit dismantl recycl compani car manufactur commiss agre netherland author budgetari resourc deem state resourc studi constitut state aid favour specif compani specif activ mean articl treati conclus hold arn intern cost budget line relat activ connect effici system descript clear feasibl studi pilot project dismantl recycl materi car part primarili serv interest system confer specif benefit particip system compani carri research technolog test work sole concern investig potenti applic exist technolog specif materi car part dissemin result restrict interest arn parti particip research requir arn award research contract firm market condit specif advantag particip firm rule expens constitut state aid mean articl treati budgetari resourc deem state resourc infring treati provis commiss take view system result state aid entitl decid articl procedur provis commun law infring conclus commiss conclud wast dispos system car wreck involv state aid state resourc involv oblig impos law environment manag declar system gener bind regard oblig produc result decis pai charg voluntari option measur constitut state aid proce charg deem state resourc favour specif compani car manufactur pai signific part cost system contribut car dismantl compani view market remuner servic provid diverg observ cost price evid manag system arn provid specif advantag particip system final commiss found budget professionalis pilot project interest system confer specif advantag compani involv research commiss conclud system involv state aid entitl framework articl procedur decid infring treati provis adopt decis articl wast dispos system car wreck declar gener bind netherland author notifi commiss constitut aid mean articl treati articl decis address kingdom netherland brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss oj letter decemb state aid nn letter august state aid paragraph guid procedur state aid case commiss wrote notif requir suffici likelihood light case law court justic commiss practic measur involv state aid competit law european commun volum iia rule applic state aid european commiss footnot paragraph add commiss give inform advic notif requir footnot direct ec european parliament council septemb end life vehicl oj lower target laid vehicl produc januari rai behalf car produc import bovag behalf garag industri focwa car manufactur stiba car dismantl industri svn mrf shredder industri sar manag director industri organis bovag focwa rai stiba appoint director sar advis advisori committe member repres interest govern bodi environment consum organis appoint board sar case charg paid privat person articl law environment manag minist hous plan environ power declar agreement gener bind articl law environment manag footnot remark negat pollut pai principl form basi arn system case preussenelektra ag schleswag ag judgment court march opinion mr advoc gener jacob deliv octob ecr arn cost account establish premium tender procedur compani cost consider order constant flow car wreck avoid idl capac compani transport cost vari nlg eur nlg eur refer cost price base assumpt optim manag account heavi work increas complex dismantl recent car wreck base assumpt larg part cost born activ difficult metal shredder price decreas significantli oj case van schaik ecr footnot paragraph judgment case steinik amp weinlig germani ecr judgment court held quot prohibit contain articl cover aid grant member state state resourc make distinct aid grant directli state public privat bodi establish appoint administ aid appli articl regard primarili effect aid undertak produc favour statu institut entrust distribut administr aid measur adopt public author favour undertak product lose charact gratuit advantag fact wholli partial financ contribut impos public author levi undertak concern quot quot measur quot refer subparagraph articl deliveri vehicl authoris treatment facil cost holder owner result vehicl neg market failur impli commerci deficit result dismantl recycl pass owner holder car subparagraph articl relat cost commerci deficit