commiss decis june grant spain aid coal industri notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european coal steel commun regard commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid coal industri articl articl thereof decis ecsc commiss gave opinion conform phase modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan coal industri notifi spain gener specif object decis ecsc letter octob spain notifi commiss phase modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan coal industri letter decemb februari march spain provid addit inform respons request contain commiss letter novemb decemb letter march pursuant articl decis ecsc spain notifi commiss financi measur intend respect coal industri decis ecsc commiss give opinion conform phase modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan spanish coal industri gener specif object decis rule financi measur relat aid esp million cover oper loss coal undertak aid esp million cover except welfar aid paid worker lose job result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ coal industri aid esp million cover technic cost close mine instal result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ coal industri financi measur propos spain coal industri fall provis articl decis ecsc approv commiss accord articl basi gener criteria object laid articl specif criteria establish articl decis accord articl decis commiss assess measur conform plan notifi ii measur implement phase spain modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan deviat plan notifi approv commiss evalu phase plan commiss found undertak product unit grant oper aid articl made limit progress improv econom viabil rel coal price intern market broadli speak undertak made effort announc modernis rationalis restructur approv aid commiss recognis prioriti attenu social region impact restructur provid coal undertak medium term outlook complet restructur undertak step restructur effort phase undertak product unit receiv aid reduct activ articl adopt seri measur period conflict oblig progress reduc product capac mean total partial closur measur result signific increas aid accord articl decis ecsc commiss request spain explain deviat propos correct measur januari decemb spain gradual brought aid arrang coal industri contract coal electr produc line decis ecsc provid articl respons commiss letter date novemb spain made amend modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan origin notifi letter octob phase definit plan notifi spain letter date march aim step modernis rationalis restructur measur coal undertak implement reduc product cost order receiv oper aid provid articl decis ecsc undertak unabl reduc product cost reduc achiev econom viabil step activ reduct plan provid articl decis ecsc undertak receiv oper aid articl spain set target minimum net reduct product million tonn januari juli time plan complet maximum product level million tonn compar million tonn order confirm trend reduct undertak product cost price spain notifi commiss product septemb latest product cost trend period show undertak product unit fail meet condit laid articl decis ecsc spain submit propos commiss subject closur plan juli progress continu activ reduct plan provid articl decis period spain monitor product cost trend coal undertak prove unabl gener downward trend propos correct measur commiss view difficult geolog condit spain coalfield undertak product unit subject closur plan juli progress continu activ reduct plan order qualifi aid reduct activ articl decis ecsc compani endesa underground product capac million tonn subject closur plan complet juli except social region condit asturia coalfield hunosa mina de figaredo sa mina de la camocha sa subject progress continu activ reduct plan product hunosa mina de figaredo sa fell combin total million tonn million tonn million tonn reduct made product maximum million tonn repres reduct number minework reduc januari decemb januari mine hunosa mina de lier sa close definit decemb hunosa commit make invest prepar reserv mine spain undertak grant aid cover product cost januari closur date mina de la camocha reduc product million tonn million tonn reduct made product maximum million tonn number minework fell januari decemb decemb plan modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct coal industri notifi spain line articl decis ecsc object solv region social problem creat total partial reduct activ product unit view social region aspect plan notifi commiss accompani convers programm mine region entail aid restor industri activ region compat treati plan notifi spain annual reduct aid current product underground mine open cast mine achiev object degress aid aid cover product cost undertak product unit aid articl articl intend cover part differ product cost sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market accord articl decis ecsc aid spain plan grant coal industri decis period enter nation region local public budget part aid hunosa mina de figaredo sa channel sepi sociedad estat de participacion industrial public undertak expenditur revenu estim enter gener state budget view plan submit spain line gener object laid articl specif object establish articl decis ecsc provid condit laid decis compli condit relat discrimin produc purchas user coal commun iii aid esp million spain plan grant coal industri intend compens full part oper loss suffer coal undertak intend cover differ product cost sell price freeli agre contract parti light condit prevail world market sum notifi subdivid oper aid esp million articl decis ecsc aid esp million reduc activ articl decis oper aid esp million intend cover oper loss suffer undertak produc total million tonn spain send notif undertak product cost septemb latest show trend aid esp million reduc activ esp million intend cover oper loss hunosa mina de figaredo sa esp million oper loss mina de la camocha sa esp million oper loss underground work endesa product total million tonn aid esp million hunosa mina de figaredo sa esp million grant sepi amount aid notifi spain lower aid authoris commiss comparison sell price light condit prevail world market spain notif council minist decis compani compani alloc aid aid cover oper loss suffer coal undertak enter gener state budget inclus measur modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan notifi spain degress aid quantiti plan line object indent articl decis object solv social region problem creat develop coal industri view basi inform provid spain aid compat object decis ecsc proper function common market iv aid esp million spain propos grant cover compens worker lose job earli retir modernis rationalis restructur activ reduct plan spanish coal industri part aid amount esp million grant hunosa mina de figaredo sa cover cost worker earli retir januari earli retir part aid grant hunosa mina de figaredo sepi remain esp million aid intend cover compens worker undertak affect modernis rationalis restructur measur lose job aid cover except cost aris restructur enter gener state budget financi measur relat action necessit modernis rationalis restructur spanish coal industri consid relat current product inherit liabil pursuant articl decis ecsc aid mention explicitli annex decis cost pai social welfar benefit result pension worker reach statutori retir ag except expenditur worker lose job result restructur rationalis consid compat common market provid amount paid exce cost view basi inform provid spain aid compat object decis ecsc proper function common market aid esp million spain propos grant intend cover part loss fix asset coal undertak close total partial except cost result progress closur connect restructur coal industri part aid total esp million grant hunosa mina de figaredo sa sepi remain esp million aid intend undertak restructur reduc activ aid cover except cost aris restructur enter gener state budget financi measur relat action made modernis rationalis restructur spanish coal industri consid relat current product inherit liabil pursuant articl decis ecsc aid mention explicitli annex decis except intrins depreci provid result restructur industri take account revalu occur januari exce rate inflat addit work residu cost aris closur instal consid compat common market condit amount paid exce cost spain ensur aid grant undertak cover except cost line categori cost defin annex decis ecsc view basi inform provid spain aid compat object decis ecsc proper function common market vi spain ensur aid current product grant decis rise discrimin produc purchas user commun coal market view basi inform provid spain aid measur plan coal industri compat object decis ecsc proper function common market decis appli prejudic compat treati contract conclud spanish coal electr produc accord indent articl articl decis ecsc commiss verifi aid relat sole purpos set articl decis end inform amount involv distribut payment adopt decis articl spain authoris pai aid respect oper aid esp million articl decis ecsc aid reduct activ esp million articl decis ecsc aid esp million cover except welfar aid paid worker lose job result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ spanish coal industri articl decis ecsc aid esp million cover except technic cost close mine instal result measur modernis rationalis restructur reduc activ spanish coal industri articl decis ecsc articl accord articl ecsc treati spain adopt measur gener ensur fulfil oblig aris decis ensur aid authoris purpos intend unspent overestim incorrectli aid item cover decis repaid articl spain notifi commiss june latest amount aid paid respect articl decis address kingdom spain brussel june commiss christo papoutsi member commiss oj oj