commiss decis april state aid germani plan grant hamburg ag notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite procedur letter date regist receiv june germani notifi intent grant invest aid multisector framework region aid larg invest project hereinaft call multisector framework hamburg ag propos aid regist number commiss acknowledg receipt inform germani notif consid incomplet ask addit question letter date june germani repli letter date juli regist receiv juli letter date juli regist receiv juli notif consid incomplet question letter date august germani repli letter date august regist receiv august letter date august commiss inform germani notif consid complet final posit adopt month date registr letter complet inform letter date octob commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid letter date decemb regist receiv dai germani respond initi procedur commiss receiv comment interest parti forward germani opportun react germani observ letter date januari regist receiv dai ii detail descript aid recipi recipi aid hamburg ag pitten austria hamburg ag part hamburg group own prinzhorn hold hamburg ag activ industri product paper project invest project locat schwarz pump brandenburg assist area articl ec treati maximum allow aid intens larg undertak gross project compris construct plant product white brown corrug base paper construct plant reportedli start product plan earliest latest plant produc testlin hamburg ag produc brown grade plant austria hungari white grade high qualiti plant rieger bavaria purpos construct plant firstli fill gap brown grade high grade close east european market market poland czech republ baltic countri thought good growth potenti plan product capac plant tonn testlin year begin tonn year tonn year achiev full capac year year plan produc brown grade white grade switch product quickli type recycl fibr base plant equip corrug tonn year capac plant total product tonn corrug base paper tonn obtain sourc undergo process corrug paperboard addit tonn plant product corrug base paper deliv convert plant own hamburg group poland tonn plant total product group product corrug base paper tonn independ corrug convert target market brown testlin consist germani poland czech republ baltic benelux countri target market white testlin extend europ tonn corrug paperboard sold radiu km product plant cost project broken gt tabl gt construct plant increas corrug base paper product capac hamburg group tonn tonn hamburg group share market corrug base paper european econom area notif project lead creation perman job corrug paper produc factori corrug paperboard produc factori transport activ germani notifi creation indirect job assist area field raw materi suppli transport servic aid measur propos aid consist invest aid form reimburs grant amount eur award framework plan joint feder govern länder programm improv region econom structur approv commiss invest premium amount eur grant basi invest premium law approv commiss reason initi formal investig procedur commiss consid relev product market market corrug base paper evid commiss stage consid relev market rel declin averag annual growth appar consumpt market significantli averag annual growth manufactur industri competit factor provision set commiss provision set capit labour factor commiss doubt creation indirect job announc germani doubt total number account creat adjac assist region indirect job claim germani expect locat poland czech republ commiss question job account czech republ poland member state european union czech republ border land brandenburg adjac region germani claim indirect job creat compani make recycl paper hamburg ag establish schwarz pump commiss proceed basi project consid part main project job includ calcul direct job indirect job provision consid project issu lead creation indirect job region impact factor provision set doubt exist job creat transport field account creat adjac assist region lead region impact factor lower decis initi procedur commiss calcul formula project depend region impact factor commiss doubt amount eur million dem million equival aid intens germani intend grant hamburg ag invest schwarz pump brandenburg conform maximum allow aid intens calcul basi multisector framework iii comment interest parti procedur initi commiss receiv comment interest parti comment made competitor associ spanish paper industri associ american forest paper industri french govern comment forward germani letter date decemb januari give opportun react answer germani receiv februari interest parti express concern capac situat relev market sector corrug base paper face structur overcapac competitor overcapac high germani year capac expect increas ow plant extens exist plant market growth slow situat worsen percentag growth eastern europ high increas volum low level paper consumpt modest competitor futur growth rate market present germani overestim american forest paper associ point project capac expans year significantli proport demand project competitor misgiv market characteris medium size compani famili busi project hamburg ag lead signific excess capac detriment effect market lead distort competitor maintain sector highli capit intens ad low plan aid project hamburg ag significantli reduc product cost lower price competitor suppli recycl paper competitor point year shortag recycl paper longish period east european countri poland czech republ hamburg wish obtain raw materi net import recycl paper competitor expect raw materi plant competitor creation direct job exagger competitor point figur job sale job financ manag control opinion high competitor number job relat corrug high competitor address issu indirect job creation opinion number significantli overestim job creat field recycl paper account larg proport total product larg part transport rail road creat fewer job claim german govern event number job creat field transport high competitor point high number job allegedli creat field mainten energi argu job creat adjac assist area iv comment germani comment initi procedur germani explain establish compani make recycl paper independ project carri amp recycl gmbh amp recycl gmbh own hamburg ag strateg reason hamburg ag decid end involv activ relat recycl paper octob sold share amp recycl gmbh rwe umwelt servic deutschland gmbh notif collect wast paper compani estim tonn year lead creation job amount purchas hamburg ag type recycl paper produc plant need compani suppli compani regard part hamburg ag project job creat amp recycl gmbh germani explain expect suppli tonn recycl paper hamburg ag lead creation job confirm letter intent provid compani evolut market assess competit factor germani argu multisector framework period year calcul averag annual growth relev period project issu period averag annual growth amount germani stress invest take place sector wast base paper corrug base paper made recycl fibr recent year averag annual growth higher corrug base paper germani point averag growth rate due evolut market polit intervent polit intervent price recycl paper drop significantli result lower price corrug base paper germani market year recov intervent germani confirm indirect job creat road transport locat assist region indirect job relat rail transport germani admit job locat assist region job question alleg indirect job creation czech republ account assess region impact project germani argu german länder regard singl assist area pursuant articl ec treati common border exist czech republ indirect job creat poland germani point region map nut ii level drawn countri encourag commiss reconsid posit indirect job creat account region impact factor germani indirect job creat assist region adjac assist region count job creat poland czech republ germani submit comment parti observ calcul competit factor point futur develop appar consumpt plai minor role context relev period determin evolut market compris year germani stress appar consumpt grew volum term capac situat market germani explain larg project invest issu year reach product stage calcul submit germani base assumpt averag annual growth rate year overcapac market product plant start hold true year germani recal plant produc white brown testlin depend market condit white testlin produc plant qualiti quickli grow market segment germani draw attent fact competitor complain overcapac plan increas product capac significantli situat market recycl paper germani point net export recycl paper million tonn surplu reduc million tonn demand outstrip suppli proport total sale account recycl paper high germani remain biggest net export recycl paper eu european countri suppli grow faster demand detriment effect market recycl paper price remain stabl find confirm jaakko pöyri direct job creation germani explain higher number job relat total capac project issu compar project competitor due fact instal hamburg ag smaller width capac lower number employe need oper instal reason plant close link parent compani fewer staff need field sale manag control region impact project germani point provid commiss calcul confirm futur partner compani job relat transport germani final product raw materi transport assess aid notif requir total project cost amount eur million cumul aid intens elig invest cost aid job creat eur point multisector framework aid notifi individu assess prior assess propos aid multisector framework requir relev market defin relev market relev product market determin market share compris product envisag invest project substitut present case invest concern product brown white testlin basi recycl paper testlin belong product group corrug base paper corrug base paper classifi categori wast base paper semi chemic kraftlin testlin produc plant question recycl fibr base fall categori wast base paper semi chemic special product kraftlin made cellulos wood share wast base paper total consumpt corrug base paper amount semi chemic share kraftlin share corrug base paper nace code cover rang manufactur paper paperboard corrug base paper intermedi product manufactur corrug paperboard paper white brown corrug paperboard packag materi raw materi packag field testlin produc plant question process site corrug paperboard sold market independ convert corrug main activ plant product testlin light commiss consid market corrug base paper relev product market separ nace classif exist market multisector framework relev geograph market compris eea altern signific part condit competit area suffici distinguish area eea germani consid relev geograph market compris eea view ow locat plant germani eastern border eastern europ consid part relev market reliabl data east european market difficult obtain east european market tini compar eea market commiss base analysi eea market consid eea relev geograph market evolut market germani submit data appar consumpt corrug base paper eea base statist provid european associ maker corrug base paper gt tabl gt germani consumpt corrug base paper expect grow annual averag volum term eea ten year data appar consumpt corrug base paper eastern europ difficult obtain market estim million tonn exclud russia ci averag annual growth rate consumpt volum term expect ten year multisector framework assess multisector framework commiss order determin maximum allow aid intens propos award aid identifi maximum aid intens region aid ceil compani obtain assist area concern context authoris region aid system valid moment notif ow fact hamburg ag consid larg undertak maximum allow aid intens present case gross commiss note propos aid intens gross correspond admiss aid ceil larg undertak region project locat rang adjust factor appli percentag figur accord specif assess factor order calcul maximum allow aid intens project question competit factor capit labour factor region impact factor competit factor commiss note market share hamburg ag exce relev market exce percentag result invest authoris aid compani oper sector structur overcapac pose risk distort competit capac expans offset capac reduct exacerb problem structur overcapac sector subsector establish lowest segment nace classif nace code product corrug base paper compris rang manufactur paper paperboard light consider commiss find relev sector corrug base paper subsector separ nace classif exist sector corrug base paper corrug base paper account small part relev nace code commiss consid capac data nace code repres purpos apprais capac situat corrug base paper pursuant point multisector framework commiss base assess competit factor data appar consumpt consid invest take place declin market purpos commiss compar appar consumpt product question growth rate eea manufactur industri market deem declin year averag annual growth rate appar consumpt product annual averag eea manufactur industri strong upward trend rel growth rate demand product market deem absolut declin averag annual growth rate appar consumpt year neg point germani argu commiss period year assess develop appar consumpt year period multisector framework refer averag annual growth rate year practic commiss appar consumpt period year order calcul growth rate germani provid figur appar consumpt product question eea data averag annual growth rate appar consumpt corrug base paper period period averag annual growth rate eea manufactur industri year accord point multisector framework market corrug base paper consid rel declin averag annual growth rate significantli manufactur industri germani argument averag annual growth corrug base paper made recycl fibr averag annual growth corrug base paper note commiss defin relev market corrug base paper pursuant multisector framework evolut market account purpos assess competit factor light consider commiss appli competit factor capit labour factor capit labour factor aim adjust maximum aid intens view favour project effect contribut reduct unemploy creation larg number job germani project lead creation perman job broken gt tabl gt decis initi procedur commiss view project establish compani make recycl paper regard satellit project includ calcul capit labour factor basi inform submit germani respons decis initi procedur commiss consid establish compani make recycl paper regard independ project germani submit data capac number employe compar project justifi number direct job creat project issu commiss consid number reason adjust factor invest eur million result creation job ratio eur job accord point multisector framework capit labour factor adjust maximum aid intens project issu calcul region impact factor region impact factor take account benefici effect aid invest economi assist region commiss consid job creation indic project contribut develop region capit intens invest creat signific number indirect job assist region concern adjac assist region job creation context refer job creat directli project job creat tier supplier custom respons aid invest notif project lead creation indirect job expect creat field gt tabl gt germani import sourc indirect job creation suppli raw materi suppli recycl paper starch total demand recycl paper plant expect amount tonn year germani claim indirect job suppli recycl paper creat compani locat poland czech republ hamburg ag expect obtain tonn recycl paper year sourc locat countri radiu km plant germani base calcul provid recycl compani addit demand tonn recycl paper lead creation job poland czech republ context germani provid list recycl compani locat czech republ recycl compani locat poland alleg job job expect creat supplier locat czech republ third job supplier locat poland addit project issu expect lead creation job custom hamburg ag locat poland produc corrug paper product ow increas secur suppli raw materi reduc freight charg result construct plant compani expect expand product confirm letter intent provid compani approxim job allegedli creat czech republ note czech republ common border land brandenburg adjac assist region mean provis indirect job creat tier supplier countri account calcul region impact factor addit germani point creation indirect job supplier recycl paper custom plant locat poland note poland member state european union articl europ agreement enter forc februari state year entri forc agreement public aid grant poland assess take account fact poland regard area ident area commun articl ec treati provis prolong initi procedur commiss doubt job creat tier supplier custom locat poland account calcul region impact factor notif germani state establish compani make recycl paper schwarz pump suppli tonn recycl paper plant lead creation indirect job latest inform submit state compani suppli tonn recycl paper lead creation indirect job indirect job relat project account twelv job suppos creat compani suppli starch import sourc indirect job creation field transport servic indirect job germani amount tonn raw materi final product wast dispos transport year transport tonn plant transport servic transport tonn expect carri privat haulag compani germani provid letter intent estim compani point transport tonn lead creation job perman full time driver offic worker mechan remain tonn expect transport railwai estim germani confirm privat railwai compani lead creation job germani present estim privat compani creat job shunt activ relat oper plant commiss consid present estim indirect job creat field transport servic reason initi procedur doubt creat adjac assist region germani admit field rail transport job creat adjac assist region field transport indirect job account calcul region impact factor job origin perman mainten facil suppli energi train temporari staff case product standstil servic relat activ plant clean cater offic suppli job creat supplier custom poland suppli recycl paper custom account indirect job creation amount job job account total indirect job creat accord point multisector framework compar direct job creat project figur correspond medium degre indirect job creation job creat aid recipi case region impact factor set maximum allow aid intens view forego maximum allow aid intens calcul gross propos aid eur million equival aid intens gross germani intend grant hamburg ag invest schwarz pump brandenburg conform maximum allow aid intens calcul basi multisector framework post monitor view sensit natur larg mobil invest involv essenti mechan exist help ensur level aid disburs recipi conform commiss decis aid project approv commiss multisector framework commiss requir aid contract relev author member state aid recipi reimburs provis event complianc contract final signific payment aid made aid recipi satisfi member state execut project complianc commiss decis condit commiss basi inform provid member state implement project work dai agreement rais object final payment aid commiss note propos decis grant aid hamburg ag reimburs provis event complianc aid recipi decis grant aid commiss note final signific payment aid made hamburg ag satisfi member state execut project complianc commiss decis commiss note undertak post monitor germani compli oblig laid point multisector framework oblig commun commiss copi decis grant aid annual report project inform document point multisector framework refer vi conclus light consider commiss conclud part notifi aid exceed maximum allow aid intens calcul project accord provis multisector framework fulfil condit consid compat common market adopt decis articl state aid germani plan grant hamburg ag amount eur incompat common market extent exce maximum allow aid intens project issu aid grant intens ceil articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel april commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj footnot busi secret rahmenplan der gemeinschaftsaufgab quot verbesserung der regionalen wirtschaftsstruktur quot investitionszulagengesetz sg sg groupement ondulé statistiqu studi jaakko pöyri consult studi jaakko pöyri consult oj commiss decis wacker chemi commiss decis kronopli commiss decis decis eu poland associ council oj