commiss decis februari state aid germani plan introduc graphisch maschinenbau gmbh berlin notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis procedur letter date januari germani notifi commiss restructur aid graphisch maschinenbau gmbh berlin gmb letter date march april june provid commiss inform letter date august commiss inform germani decid initi proceed articl ec treati respect aid commiss decis initi proceed publish offici journal european commun commiss call interest parti submit comment aid commiss receiv comment interest parti detail descript measur land berlin offer restructur aid gmb form grant dem million eur million spread period estim total cost restructur process amount dem million eur million includ measur relat skill restructur product layout organis chang product rang increas vertic rang manufactur loss incur expect come year gmb manufactur newspap print machineri part base berlin spandau west area elig region assist articl workforc number gmb subsidiari koenig amp bauer albert ag würzburg kba primarili manufactur print machineri kba larg firm mean commiss recommend april definit small medium size enterpris reason gmb deem larg firm meet independ criterion set articl annex recommend figur continu downward trend turnov oper loss record show firm difficulti restructur programm drawn kba februari complet septemb cover period period propos measur lead optimum oper size improv organis lower cost restructur gmb enabl kba group produc machin part roller bearer previous procur firm gmb develop depart design develop part handl parent compani würzburg grant restructur aid conting gmb maintain workforc employe year kba contribut resourc amount total dem million restructur plan form takeov oper loss incur gmb past expect incur includ social plan expenditur adjust inventori clearanc cost incur partial closur restructur measur expect decreas loss profit dem expect year addit measur result increas annual turnov dem million examin case basi notif commiss doubt compat propos grant derog provid articl ec treati stage investig evid commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti appli gmb ground assumpt long term viabil restor satisfactorili support gmb trial balanc sheet year clear sale prospect relev sector cost estim kba würzburg develop special machineri part high measur gmb expect annual turnov year justifi parent compani kba primarili interest ensur manufactur special machineri part carri group result sell gmb manufactur product license usual group evid produc show develop product absolut restructur gmb contribut kba parent compani consist primarili take loss incur gmb reach break point year kba requir gmb loss exist control profit transfer agreement mean loss incur notif cover kba accept contribut kba gmb restructur addit plan restructur grant dem million proport elig cost benefit firm difficulti mean guidelin rescu restructur aid benefit parent compani comment germani letter date septemb germani submit comment regard ground initi proceed restructur subsidiari compani gmb serv extend workbench kba group product site frankenth radebeul trennfeld kusel product manufactur exclus berlin manufactur place kba product site overlap capac kba group made gmb crisi prone compani onward demand print machineri sector fell drastic overstaf fall demand led rapidli mount loss threaten gmb viabil parent compani kba intend novemb close gmb june eventu decid part product plant berlin continu oper provid state aid made focu restructur plan establish abil kba group produc machineri part roller bearer rollenwechsl cool roller kühlwalzen draw roller einzugswerk machineri part independ modul web offset press repres total price print machineri roller bearer cool roller draw roller direct competit firm product possibl includ distribut kba prerequisit plan success suppli competit econom innov product rapid introduct market due current structur gmb unabl develop product short term basi restructur plan involv recours develop construct capac kba würzburg futur modif adapt carri berlin germani emphasis develop activ undertaken würzburg absenc capac berlin benefit gmb independ profit centr supplier abovement modul gmb manufactur improv product stop manufactur product manufactur restructur compani addit previous present preliminari profit loss account year germani provid part proceed gmb plan balanc sheet figur plan balanc sheet show slight decreas balanc sheet gener sound financ support assumpt germani present market studi kba gmb share world market turnov web offset press newspap commerci web offset press web fed rotogravur press roller bearer web offset press figur reveal steadi increas gmb turnov roller bearer amount dem million dem million dem million dem million year gmb percentag share total product product kba rise sale forecast provid modul draw roller cool roller gmb continu manufactur develop site regard estim dem million develop competit product germani consid commiss doubt ratio cost gmb expect annual turnov dem million year unjustifi experi show lifetim newli develop product year expenditur spread period lead annual burden dem abovement expect turnov year amount year cost analyt revis ad cost estim ratio consid extrem low mechan engin industri notwithstand quot creation product quot previous mention commiss activ carri würzburg meet definit appli research develop basic industri research laid annex commun framework state aid research develop work base technic knowledg kba focus standard size roller paper roll width econom handi compon main point restructur plan futur independ abil gmb kba group produc roller bearer draw roller cool roller expenditur relat newli design product roller bearer incur exclus benefit gmb purchas kba germani consid irrelev question purchas product manufactur licens basi argu case licenc fee calcul cover cost incur develop construct account realist lifetim product doubt gmb liquid reject ground notifi aid aim remov liquid problem facilit restructur compani kba contribut resourc take loss incur control profit transfer agreement kba gmb requir take gmb loss agreement period notic termin crisi meet held februari kba termin agreement immedi entitl loss aris date present balanc sheet balanc sheet financi year present april establish restructur plan framework quot allianc work quot bündni für arbeit sign februari germani consid import attach question scale compani loss question requir loss gmb close june origin plan result termin control profit transfer agreement kba gmb kba total loss incur cost social measur closur bulk cost due restructur outag period requir convers product layout cost exce significantli incur plan close gmb june assess propos aid dem million gmb proport elig cost account contribut compani resourc specif situat west berlin background decis close gmb view signific restructur cost hand take account specif region situat west berlin situat manufactur industri germani consid contribut kba proport restructur cost propos restructur aid benefit kba promis grant restructur aid gmb close june decis continu busi gmb signific loss kba consider risk cost exceed amount restructur aid kba point view preserv small product site berlin special compet group product site kba group establish abil manufactur product question expenditur significantli restructur cost incur gmb secur grant land charg amount dem million confirm notari record attach german letter evid german commun propos restructur aid affect trade margin distort competit extent contrari common interest gmb smallest supplier roller bearer supplier belong intern financi strong group main competitor roller bearer sector stork contiweb heidelberg druckmaschinen ag subsidiari rwe competitor vit maschinenbau gmbh langenfeld part deutsch babcock ag grant restructur aid gmb oper compet competit supplier market roller bearer draw roller cool roller gmb market posit intensifi competit relev market excess capac notifi restructur aid aim restor viabil gmb creat excess capac gmb kba assess aid restructur aid gmb provid state resourc serv busi firm experienc difficulti advers effect posit competitor member state market print machineri market intern commun manufactur competit custom commun state support distort competit threaten distort affect trade member state plan state support constitut state aid mean articl ec treati enabl recipi compani carri restructur bear cost full firm normal market situat state aid cover approv exist aid scheme notifi individu pursuant articl ec treati germani compli notif requir articl ec treati lai principl aid characterist incompat common market articl ec treati list exempt aid found compat common market exempt provid articl ec treati appli aid aid social charact grant individu consum serv make good damag caus natur disast grant economi area feder republ germani affect divis germani similarli exempt laid articl appli aid promot econom develop area standard live abnorm low underemploy derog provid articl appli aid intend promot import project common european interest remedi disturb economi member state derog laid articl appli aid intend promot cultur heritag conserv restructur aid deem compat common market exempt provid articl aid promot econom activ trade affect run counter common interest provid condit set commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti met context applic exempt examin basi framework guidelin commiss set interpret exempt question commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti lai condit restructur aid consid compat common market applic legal basi present case guidelin restructur place context feasibl coher reach plan restor firm long term viabil reason timescal basi realist assumpt futur oper condit restructur plan account inter alia circumst give rise compani difficulti market suppli demand relev product expect develop specif strength weak compani orderli transit compani structur viabl long term prospect enabl oper strength resourc requir state assist restructur involv reorganis rationalis firm activ effici basi typic involv withdraw activ longer viabl loss make addit exist activ restructur made competit possibl viabl activ develop diversifi financi restructur accompani physic restructur section commun guidelin commiss examin restructur meet requir restor long term viabil compani reason timescal aid result undu distort competit thirdli aid proport restructur cost benefit fourthli restructur plan fulli implement fifthli detail annual report submit commiss order monitor implement progress success restructur plan restor long term viabil letter date januari germani submit restructur plan drawn kba gmb busi letter date march april germani complet notif provid detail preliminari profit loss account balanc sheet financi year proceed germani submit plan balanc sheet year restructur plan take account circumst give rise firm difficulti notabl unfavour oper size cost structur unsound financi posit duplic capac kba group relat rang product manufactur gmb kba product site commiss note outset group commit implement restructur plan order adjust coststructur gmb primarili reduc staff expenditur staff cost turnov result partial closur mid job cut workforc reduc employe provid restructur plan gmb employe agre relinquish contractu wage increas accept wage cut waiv welfar benefit quot allianc work quot bündni für arbeit lead cost reduct dem year perman basi compar profit loss account cost reduct staff repres total dem million preliminari account cost decreas dem million compar expect reach level cost reduct approxim achiev field assembl engin optimis product process construct simplif interest miscellan cost expect decreas expenditur materi lower favour purchas price preliminari profit loss account show steadi increas expenditur line expect increas turnov restructur larg extent achiev implement reduct staff cost improv product process restructur focus suppli improv innov product rapid introduct market product exclus manufactur gmb avoid current duplic capac kba group restor compani financi posit primarili financ parent compani take gmb loss incur compani reach break point expect year year profit forecast rise dem commiss examin forecast balanc sheet profit loss account cash flow figur drawn assess restructur measur result restor gmb viabil commiss note forecast present detail statement underli assumpt implement restructur concept requir complet factori layout gear modern product condit aggreg product gain expect subsequ introduct group work commiss consid decis restructur measur gmb concentr manufactur machineri part roller bearer cool roller draw roller introduct revis competit roller bearer web offset press rotogravur press develop undertaken kba commiss note loss make product abandon distribut improv machineri part parent compani coupl capac reduct kba product site part incorpor kba print machineri offer gmb reliabl sale potenti germani indispens rapid market innov product achiev develop construct capac kba würzburg gmb expect increas turnov commiss note signific increas turnov compar due loss incur outag period convers product layout start commiss consid assumpt optimist achiev commiss note kba provid detail geograph breakdown turnov busi area kba gmb commiss note gmb share kba group improv roller bearer rise steadili result turnov increas dem million dem million gmb balanc sheet forecast balanc sheet year reveal posit equiti capit amount dem million exist control profit transfer agreement kba gmb requir parent compani gmb loss allow equiti capit remain posit cost develop improv product manufactur gmb establish manufactur abil part berlin restructur cost restructur programm forecast gmb plan signific invest year gmb achiev sound financi posit year tabl summaris import aspect commiss analysi gt tabl gt gt tabl gt commiss take view forecast show gmb viabl long term prospect oper strength resourc requir state assist avoid undu distort competit aid commiss examin measur offset advers effect restructur aid competitor aid deem elig exempt pursuant articl note gmb base berlin spandau west area elig region assist articl restructur aid form grant berlin author gener distort market effect gmb busi commiss review market data market report provid germani assess structur excess product capac relev market market print machineri close link print publish sector sector grow end reach matur begin product gradual slow tradit form reproduct constitut matur market modest growth potenti sector process constant restructur adapt inform telecommun technolog develop threaten prospect paper base print industri appar consumpt commun product express current price increas growth global consumpt slow drop rose product similar trend recoveri end product stagnat germani demand fell german market print machineri turnov main produc declin period result price decreas substanti job cut employe recent figur show product sector increas compar compar capac utilis ratio sector june kba market forecast year assum steadi growth product relev segment world market germani report overcapac market pursuant point ii commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti restructur plan make contribut proportion amount aid receiv restructur industri serv relev market european commun irrevers reduc close capac reduct closur irrevers relev asset scrap render perman incap produc previou rate perman convert commiss note restructur plan gmb primarili base effici factori layout chang rang product manufactur assembl part exist product reduc loss make abandon part abandon gmb increasingli manufactur parent compani product site würzburg frankenth order increas capac utilis ratio commiss note gmb concentr manufactur machineri part incorpor kba print machineri replac larg extent product suppli manufactur remain competit supplier machineri part question web offset press rotogravur press repres total print machin kba market share print machineri segment amount world market commiss take note structur excess product capac exist relev market commiss note gmb abandon activ reduc product rang addit forecast turnov improv product grow rate world market sale prospect commiss take acccount account gmb smallest supplier roller bearer supplier belong intern financi strong group accord point ii commun guidelin structur excess product capac relev market commun serv recipi commiss requir reduct capac return aid evid excess capac gmb market share small product product redistribut kba group increas capac commiss measur adopt offset advers effect aid competitor aid proport restructur cost benefit commiss examin aid limit minimum need compani restructur commiss take account fact restructur aid dem million accompani signific contribut kba dem million order write gmb oper loss incur gmb reach break point year commiss summaris kba resourc contribut restructur plan cost kba compani resourc contribut restructur plan commiss note loss cost partial closur mid amount dem million incur date notif restructur aid januari commiss point pursuant exist control profit transfer agreement kba gmb kba requir loss incur gmb commiss note agreement cancel kba crisi meet februari provid period notic termin commiss note novemb kba propos close gmb june case agreement termin closur gmb entitl oper loss incur cost aris closur commiss take note quot allianc work quot bündni für arbeit sign februari basi restructur plan final commiss consider cost incur caus restructur outag period due convers product layout rang product view fact actual oblig kba oper loss incur take account fact restructur cost exce cost incur plan close gmb commiss consid kba contribut dem million restructur gmb tabl summaris total amount contribut restructur gt tabl gt commiss compar compani contribut resourc estim restructur cost summaris tabl gt tabl gt commiss note total cost restructur compani amount dem million eur million includ dem million cover oper loss social plan cost adjust cost kba dem million introduct improv product factori layout commiss take note cost design develop product analyt improv exist product incur würzburg berlin final commiss note parent compani sell innov product design develop würzburg exclus manufactur berlin gmb context commiss take consider fact definit appli research develop basic industri research laid annex commun framework state aid research develop applic activ carri würzburg commiss take note detail cost breakdown detail technic descript data relat activ carri würzburg attach german comment commiss note expenditur develop product spread lifetim year usual mechan engin manufactur give annual burden dem measur expect turnov dem million share year commiss take account germani assur parent compani activ amount man hour dem dem million develop dem product prototyp roller bearer web offset press man hour dem dem million revis standardis roller bearer rotogravur press benefit gmb germani provid exact timet show develop cost occur notif restructur aid commiss note improv roller bearer type quot pastomat rc quot mass produc gmb end result commerci success restructur plan conclud signific part develop expenditur place januari approxim cost design develop product incur parent compani develop construct facil wurzburg frankenth commun septemb note würzburg frankenth locat area elig region assist pursuant articl commiss note gmb capac allow develop short term basi requisit competit innov product gmb recours kba capac commiss consid parent compani case interest suppli improv machineri part incorpor print machineri develop cost dem million incur würzburg frankenth larg extent disburs notif assum benefit kba group improv machineri manufactur gmb provid gmb area compet kba group final commiss point purchas price paid gmb product germani quot calcul order cover cost incur develop construct quot extent offset kba develop cost tabl summaris total elig cost amount contribut compani resourc compar cost elig restructur aid amount state aid gt tabl gt take account calcul gmb evid receiv amount dem million includ dem million resourc dem million public resourc order contribut minimum need compani restructur propos state aid dem million reduc develop cost amount dem million amount elig restructur cost dem million exceed viabil gmb affect reduct cost larg extent incur kba firm difficulti main beneficiari activ carri product site measur provid addit incent abovement cost independ restructur gmb measur serv restructur kba group commiss consid amount dem million minimum need proport elig restructur cost dem million contribut resourc dem million full implement restructur plan observ condit point iv commun guidelin restructur plan submit commiss fulli implement aid recipi discharg oblig laid commiss decis commiss note restructur aid grant period year payment spread period commiss note propos grant reimburs event restructur measur fulli implement commiss note gmb bound collater secur amount dem million notari act referenc novemb monitor annual report commiss note germani provid commiss annual report conclus germani notifi propos state aid articl ec treati compli oblig notifi individu absenc approv aid scheme commiss note time gmb compani difficulti appli restructur aid commiss take account state aid form grant partli meet condit laid commun guidelin firm difficulti notabl restructur aid restor long term viabil compani reason timescal avoid undu distort competit aid minimum need compani restructur propos grant exce elig cost dem million commiss consid grant amount dem million dem million compli requir laid point iii commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti commiss conclud state aid measur contribut develop activ advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest aid compat common market extent amount germani authoris provid aid amount dem million eur million gmb adopt decis articl state aid germani plan grant graphisch maschinenbau gmbh berlin form grant amount dem million compat common market mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement extent dem million amount plan aid excess dem million grant articl germani provid commiss detail annual report order demonstr due implement restructur plan articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel februari commiss karel van miert member commiss oj oj oj kba figur http kba print de oj cost incur partial closur amount dem million social cost dem million balanc sheet panorama eu industri european commiss volum vdma verband deutscher maschinen und anlagenbau part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos squar bracket mark asterisk balanc sheet usual present april conclus quot allianc work quot februari basi restructur plan