council regul ec june impos definit countervail duti import ring binder mechan rbm origin indonesia termin anti subsidi proceed respect import rbm origin india council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec octob protect subsidis import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur present investig commiss announc notic hereinaft refer quot notic initi quot publish offici journal european commun initi anti subsidi proceed regard import commun ring binder mechan hereinaft refer quot rbm quot origin india indonesia commenc investig proceed initi result complaint lodg april commun produc koloman handler ag quot koloman quot austria kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh amp kg quot kraus quot germani quot complain quot repres major proport case commun product rbm complaint contain evid subsidis product materi injuri result therefrom consid suffici justifi initi proceed initi parallel anti dump proceed import product origin countri announc notic publish offici journal european commun date prior initi proceed accord articl regul ec hereinaft refer quot basic regul quot commiss notifi govern india indonesia receiv properli document complaint alleg subsidis import rbm origin india indonesia caus materi injuri commun industri govern invit consult aim clarifi situat content complaint arriv mutual agre solut consult govern held commiss brussel due note comment made govern regard alleg contain complaint subsidis import materi injuri suffer commun industri number alleg scheme subsequ includ investig commiss offici advis commun produc export produc import user concern repres export countri complain initi proceed parti concern opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi commiss questionnair parti concern compani made deadlin set notic initi repli receiv govern india commun produc export produc india relat export commun import commun user relat import commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos determin subsidis injuri causat commun interest verif visit carri premis govern india compani commun produc koloman handler ag austria export produc india tocheungle stationeri mfg pvt tiruvallor relat export commun hong kong tocheungle bvi limit world wide stationeri mfg ultim hold compani unrel import benson intern system unit kingdom benson intern system bv netherland user esselt unit kingdom investig subsidis injuri cover period april march quot investig period quot quot ip quot purpos analys trend relev assess injuri commiss examin data relat period januari end ip quot period consid quot provision measur examin aspect injuri causat commun interest view ongo restructur complain provision countervail measur impos rbm origin india indonesia subsequ procedur parti inform decis impos provision measur commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find spot investig carri premis user rbm commun unrel import commun parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit countervail duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit parti consid find modifi product concern product product concern product concern ring binder mechan quot product concern quot classifi cn code lever arch mechan fall cn code includ scope investig rbm consist rectangular steel sheet wire half ring made steel wire fix steel cover open pull half ring small steel made trigger mechan fix rbm ring shape popular round rectangular shape rbm file kind document paper inter alia produc ring binder softwar technic manual photo stamp album catalogu brochur hundr model rbm sold ip commun model vari size shape number ring size base plate system open ring pull open open trigger absenc clear divid line rang rbm basic physic technic characterist model rbm rang replac commiss establish rbm constitut singl product purpos present proceed product commiss found rbm produc sold domest market india export commun india basic physic technic characterist commiss found differ basic physic technic characterist rbm import commun origin india rbm produc commun industri sold commun market view lack cooper indonesian produc commiss reli fact accord articl basic regul regard absenc inform countri commiss consid make inform submit complaint rbm produc sold indonesia export commun rbm produc complain commun produc sold commun market alik conclud rbm produc sold commun industri commun market rbm origin india indonesia export commun rbm produc sold domest market india indonesia product mean articl basic regul ip product concern subject convent custom duti gsp regim product concern import india indonesia benefit reduct amount convent custom duti payabl result duti appli subsidi india introduct basi inform contain complaint repli commiss questionnair commiss investig scheme allegedli involv grant export subsidi export process zone export orient unit epz eou duti entitl passbook scheme depb export promot capit good scheme epcg incom tax exempt scheme it scheme base foreign trade develop regul act effect august foreign trade act authoris govern india issu notif export import polici summaris quot export import polici quot document issu year updat annual document relev investig period case cover polici year scheme incom tax scheme base incom tax act amend yearli financ act compani repli questionnair export produc compani commun relat export produc repli questionnair basi import data report eurostat export produc india account indian export commun export process zone epz export orient unit eou legal basi instrument export import polici involv export relat incent export process zone hereinaft quot epz quot export orient unit hereinaft quot eou quot scheme introduc ip scheme regul custom notif detail scheme contain chapter export import polici relev handbook procedur ii elig principl compani undertak export entir product good set epz eou scheme statu grant compani avail benefit identifi epz india eou locat india bond unit surveil custom offici accord section custom act eou epz gener oblig export entir product govern india unit sell part product domest market condit cooper export produc grant statu eou iii practic implement compani request eou statu set epz appli relev author applic includ detail period cover year inter alia plan product quantiti project export import requir indigen requir author accept compani applic term condit attach accept commun compani compani epz eou involv product product agreement valid year period renew period epz eou unit entitl benefit exempt import duti type good includ capit good raw materi consum requir manufactur product process connect therewith provid prohibit item neg list import ii exempt excis duti good procur indigen sourc iii exempt incom incom tax due accord section incom tax act year period iv reimburs central sale tax paid good procur local foreign equiti ownership vi facil sell part product domest market import maintain format proper account import concern consumpt utilis import materi export made submit period requir develop commission import ensur minimum net foreign exchang earn percentag export export perform stipul polici entir oper eou epz custom bond premis iv conclus epz eou present proceed eou scheme import capit good raw materi consum procur good domest market commiss examin countervail concess regard eou epz scheme involv grant subsidi concess grant scheme constitut financi contribut govern india govern revenu due forgon benefit confer recipi suspens collect duti capit good effect exempt long export requir fulfil sole discret compani de bond capit good subsidi conting law export perform mean articl basic regul obtain compani accept export oblig deem specif countervail calcul subsidi amount suspens import duti purchas capit good indian export produc eou scheme order obtain suspens import duti payabl capit good benefit compani calcul basi amount unpaid custom duti due import capit good spread amount period year reflect depreci period capit good import compani consid reflect normal depreci asset industri concern amount calcul attribut investig period adjust ad interest investig period order establish full benefit recipi scheme natur scheme equival time grant commerci interest rate investig period india consid amount alloc total export investig period basi compani receiv benefit scheme rate exempt custom duti due import raw materi consum indian export produc eou scheme order obtain exempt custom duti due import raw materi consum verif visit natur quantiti import materi verifi compani raw materi import ip demonstr clear link quantiti export finish product establish import excess import quantiti input export product place import fall except item illustr list export subsidi contain annex basic regul good import free duti incorpor export product excess remiss import duti occur exempt excis duti good procur indigen sourc indian export produc eou scheme order obtain exempt excis duti good procur indigen sourc excis duti paid purchas eou unit compani oper special statu credit drawback cenvat modvat utilis payment excis duti domest sale exempt excis duti purchas eou unit addit revenu forgon govern india addit benefit accru eou reimburs central sale tax paid good procur local indian export produc eou scheme order obtain reimburs central sale tax paid good procur local reimburs involv grant subsidi govern revenu due forgon benefit confer recipi benefit calcul basi amount central sale tax refund local purchas investig period respect establish indian export produc procur practic local purchas state locat tamil nadu central sale tax appli inter state transact amount central sale tax refund compani limit incom tax exempt scheme it legal basi incom tax exempt scheme base incom tax act set basi collect tax exempt deduct claim exempt claim cover section hhc act provid incom tax exempt profit obtain export sale ii elig exempt section claim firm locat free trade zone exempt section claim export orient unit exempt section hhc claim firm export good iii practic implement claim deduct export profit submit alongsid usual annual incom tax declar iv conclus it it scheme govern india confer financi contribut compani forgo govern revenu form direct tax due financi contribut confer benefit recipi reduc incom tax liabil incom tax exempt scheme conting law export perform mean articl basic regul profit earn export activ deduct taxabl incom deem specif countervail calcul subsidi amount indian export produc eou elig incom tax exempt section incom tax act introduc claim deduct ip benefit calcul appli notion tax rate appli profit deduct made basi compani obtain benefit scheme rate subsidi scheme investig determin export produc investig scheme assess countervail amount countervail subsidi amount countervail subsidi accord provis basic regul express ad valorem investig export rate de minimi level circumst subsidi margin india consid neglig indonesia introduct consult refer recit commiss servic decid limit investig scheme bkpm cakung epz questionnair govern indonesia request relev inform govern indonesia subsequ provid repli questionnair verif visit govern indonesia carri sole export produc indonesia repli questionnair extens deadlin submit repli view cooper compani duli inform definit find base fact pursuant articl basic regul consequ accord articl basic regul result favour cooper accord articl basic regul verif visit carri premis export produc accord articl basic regul subsidis export price determin basi fact commiss consid base find inform submit complaint inform previou anti subsidi proceed indonesia accord articl inform check data independ sourc bkpm scheme appear complaint export produc avail benefit invest coordin board bkpm govern agenc charg plan promot invest previou investig cite shown bkpm approv foreign pma domest pmdn invest compani approv pma pmdn compani grant exempt relief import duti levi import capit good machineri equip spare part auxiliari equip import raw materi bkpm scheme constitut subsidi financi contribut govern indonesia form unpaid duti confer direct benefit recipi scheme qualifi drawback scheme accord provis annex iii basic regul capit good consum product process oblig export finish product raw materi bkpm scheme conting law export perform domest good import good criteria elig set bkpm updat frequent bkpm scheme explicitli limit access subsidi enterpris oper sector grant author exercis discret approv process elig automat bkpm scheme line articl basic regul stipul grant author establish object criteria neutral favour enterpris econom natur horizont applic programm consid specif articl basic regul explicitli limit access subsidi enterpris fact export produc indonesian govern cooper made imposs determin precis extent produc avail scheme indonesian bond zone cakung epz address cooper export produc facil locat cakung export process zone area design quot nusantara bond zone quot compani confirm inform compani locat zone elig benefit compani locat zone notabl exempt import duti good product export finish product export produc choos cooper provid evid benefit zone order reward cooper establish export produc locat epz council entitl assum benefit accord find previou investig duti drawback scheme oper zone constitut financi contribut govern revenu due forgon benefit confer recipi drawback scheme constitut subsidi conting law export perform mean articl basic regul obtain compani accept export oblig deem specif countervail fact export produc cooper made imposs determin import scheme qualifi except annex basic regul establish import good incorpor export product excess remiss occur conclus subsidi basi fact accord articl basic regul evid exist countervail subsidi cooper export produc reason indic subsid purpos measur assum accord previou investig part domest subsidi part constitut export subsidi scheme epz consid export subsidi consid absenc cooper result benefit produc countervail subsidi level de minimi level indonesia order avoid grant bonu cooper view inform contain complaint find previou investig definit subsidi margin express percentag cif import price commun frontier duti unpaid applic indonesian export produc export injuri preliminari remark indian export produc cooper investig commun industri compris compani specif data relat compani index put form rang order preserv confidenti data submit accord articl basic regul commun product establish addit complain commun produc output product take place itali spain italian compani involv suppli complet data commiss inform receiv confirm ip repres share total commun product spanish compani suppli complet data commiss found produc neglig volum product concern import major portion sale countri concern conclud consid import produc found compani locat uk involv product type rbm compani confirm write product product concern ceas year ago produc commun base product complain commun produc locat itali constitut total commun product mean articl basic regul definit commun industri commun industri complain produc repli questionnair kraus consid cooper produc support complaint regard part commun industri produc koloman found compani produc product commun ip produc part hungari addit commun product koloman trade hungarian product commun part produc hungari commun product part product cooper commun produc reloc begin year mean transfer machineri austria hungari forego core activ compani remain commun head offic wareh sale offic product signific amount product rang signific technic market import sale complet product rang product affect koloman statu commun produc product part hungari subsequ incorpor finish product investig establish incorpor part repres minor proport cost product finish product ad statu produc commun produc affect import investig confirm sole cooper commun produc repres commun product rbm fulfil requir articl basic regul deem constitut commun industri mean articl regul hereinaft refer quot commun industri quot event occur investig period novemb end ip cooper commun produc koloman receivership result liquid procedur austrian compani parent compani locat uk acquir hungarian affili koloman acquir confirm commiss support complaint commun consumpt appar commun consumpt establish basi sale volum commun industri commun market sale commun produc commun market report complaint duli adjust concern ip inform provid cooper export produc eurostat import data account fact cn code cover product includ scope proceed regard indonesia lack cooper indonesian export fact eurostat data respect base complaint evid import abovement cn code consid constitut product concern cooper indonesian export claim export commun market lower import volum claim verifi differ explain ratio convert eurostat statist tonn unit basi commun consumpt increas ip detail remain stabl steadili increas end ip found million unit import countri concern recal proceed india termin import indonesia analys import remain countri concern volum subsidis import import volum origin indonesia decreas slightli rose ip note import countri concern start signific level million piec ip market share subsidis import market share held indonesian import found decreas percentag point price subsidis import price evolut weight averag import price import origin indonesia decreas ip ecu thousand unit eur thousand unit decreas mark price fell ip fell ii undercut lack cooper indonesian export price comparison made basi eurostat data duli adjust custom duti post import cost compar level trade commun produc work price basi price undercut review amend basi inform provid addit verif visit import indonesia found undercut commun industri price note price suppress commun industri profit situat commun industri product commun industri product downward trend period decreas ip signific decreas place signific decreas occur subsequ product volum remain stabl end ip capac capac utilis rate product capac trend product decreas ip basi capac utilis rate remain stabl period consid stock commun industri end year stock decreas ip sale commun increas commun consumpt sale volum commun industri fell significantli ip decreas occur pronounc market share market share commun industri decreas percentag point ip trend volum sold price averag net sale price commun industri decreas ip decreas mark import price countri concern significantli decreas explain recit profit weight averag profit commun industri deterior percentag point ip loss result unfavor develop mention recit commun industri receivership cash flow abil rais capit develop cash flow gener commun industri relat sale rbm similar profit signific decreas ip investig establish commun industri abil rais capit difficult time ow financi situat deterior profit employ wage product employ commun industri relat product rbm decreas ip total amount wage similar trend fall period lead increas averag wage ip product commun industri workforc measur product volum person emploi increas ip invest return invest level invest decreas ip decreas mark investig show capit expenditur relat replac maintain exist facil return invest express relat net profit commun industri net book invest close profit trend neg growth commun consumpt increas ip sale volum commun industri decreas volum import concern remain signific commun industri unabl benefit slight increas demand commun market reloc part product order verifi deterior situat commun industri due chang pattern commun product examin reloc part product mention recit mean transfer machineri austria hungari place begin year effect situat commun industri happen decreas trend injuri indic aggrav reloc product product capac sale volum trend capac utilis averag sale price improv lead limit loss instanc assess decreas product link reloc sale volum decreas reloc price decreas time higher profit lost addit percentag point conclud deterior situat commun industri due chang pattern commun product argu core activ commun industri longer commun reloc hungari allegedli entail declin commun product declin commun produc sale explain recit reloc entail decreas commun industri product decreas commun product commun produc sale conclus state recit core activ commun industri confirm conclus injuri deterior situat commun industri account reloc outlin recit found refer period consid anti dump measur import rbm origin peopl republ china quot prc quot malaysia led substanti decreas import origin countri commun industri fulli benefit develop year injuri indic product sale volum price market share profit return invest cash flow employ develop neg decreas sale price commun industri neg effect profit sale commun industri decreas ip import origin indonesia substanti investig shown ip indonesian import made price undercut commun industri addit price suppress situat commun industri found deterior extent conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri recal ip poor financi situat led commun industri receivership causat introduct accord articl basic regul examin import origin indonesia view volum effect price rbm commun market caus injuri commun industri degre enabl classifi materi factor subsidis import time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor attribut subsidis import indonesia effect subsidis import volum subsidis import decreas ip share commun market percentag point period remain signific held market share rang ip import significantli undercut price commun industri market share commun industri decreas percentag point time averag price commun actual declin price fact higher outlin recit period ip situat commun industri deterior illustr decreas sale volum market share price decreas substanti deterior profit turn loss commun industri significantli benefit imposit abovement measur prc malaysia argu indonesian export indonesian export caus injuri decreas held de minimi market share compani alleg import indonesia real impact commun industri commun product time higher volum indonesian import recal indonesian import decreas slightli increas ip reach level addit explain recit ip indonesian import held market share situat substanti de minimi final recal commun industri defin recit level product alleg indonesian compani conclud subsidis import origin indonesia undermin effect anti dump measur adopt prc malaysia amend prc substant neg develop summaris preced paragraph effect factor import countri consider factor subsidis import indonesia led contribut injuri suffer commun industri import countri indonesia contribut situat import volum countri increas ip market share increas percentag point period increas larg extent due increas import origin india hungari thailand meantim import origin prc malaysia significantli decreas ow anti dump measur impos averag unit price import countri decreas ip price countri decreas period price import prc due effect anti dump measur increas significantli reach level hungarian price ip india firstli examin import origin india contribut injuri suffer commun industri import india increas significantli ip found undercut import indonesia price found rang lower price indian import ip addit note indian import start price indian import found higher price indonesian import compar volum rbm indian import price decreas steadili indonesian price found higher indonesian price ip conclud indian import neg impact situat commun industri neg impact subsidis import indonesia isol nonetheless substanti indonesia influenti import player commun volum export commun lower indian export substanti indonesian export undercut commun industri price indian export note aforement analysi imped fact indonesia cooper inform term product type market segment repres export indonesia ii peopl republ china consider absorpt anti dump measur impos import prc led contribut injuri suffer commun industri respect noteworthi absorpt duti import prc undermin effect measur impos regard sale price measur led signific reduct volum import prc addit note import indonesia began reach level import prc import prc dramat decreas indonesian import decreas lesser extent ip import time higher import prc import volum prc import volum indonesia ip conclud import impact commun industri compar effect subsidis import indonesia iii hungari order determin import hungari isol caus injuri commun industri level import price commun market examin analysi hungarian import ip base data provid questionnair repli commun produc plant hungari repres sole hungarian produc period consid import rbm origin hungari increas volum price charg commun industri commun market product import hungari decreas period consid remain highest import price countri undercut import indonesia hungarian product rbm commun industri analys compar austrian product found overlap model produc austria hungari small percentag model manufactur austria hungari conclud hungarian product complet product rang commun industri enabl offer wider choic model custom affect neg situat commun industri basi conclud import hungari materi contribut deterior situat commun industri iv thailand mention regul ec quot good chines origin declar nation custom author thai origin avoid payment anti dump duti due quot consid evalu impact import consign thailand respect import thailand significantli increas period consid start million unit rose million unit ip addit establish basi eurostat data sale price thai import gener price indonesian import thai price found lower price indonesian import recal higher import volum thailand volum import thailand substanti volum import indonesia conclud import signific impact compar effect subsidis import indonesia analysi respect thailand question indonesian export cooper respect argu level import indonesia compar lower price higher compar thai import recal thai price lower price import indonesia volum import indonesia higher import thailand conclus drawn recit confirm factor examin factor abovement contribut injuri suffer commun industri contend cooper import rbm busi extrem price sensit produc sell larg volum competit argu parti commun industri reli commun market world market cost effici matter recal ratio sale commun industri insid commun significantli chang ip commun industri strongli orient commun market export sale permit commun industri profit time import indonesia signific user argu injuri caus strong competit offic suppli industri competit allegedli led user distributor product concern exert price pressur commun industri lead price decreas respect underlin subsidis import significantli worsen price pressur exert user commun caus injuri commun industri examin price depress attribut normal rbm busi price sourc suppli decreas ip respect recal gener price decreas light continu unfair practic firstli prc malaysia indonesia influenc commun market addit mention recit rbm market extrem price sensit price indonesian import found subsidis lower averag unit price import rbm ip conclud import indonesia held commun market ip price depress impact market final analys price behaviour kraus cooper commun produc contribut injuri suffer commun industri addit examin data refer kraus show commun produc suffer deterior situat period consid concern sale price profit appear contribut injuri suffer commun industri equal neg affect import indonesia forc decreas price commun industri reason explain conclud price depress commun market repres normal develop trade consequ unfair commerci practic indonesia contend indonesian author indonesian export limit suppli italian produc ring binder complement product rang assert found contradict statement made cooper indonesian export argu sole market indonesian produc signific market share unit kingdom confirm eurostat produc alleg indonesian export injuri main market uk commun industri signific activ addit fact assumpt contradict alleg made indonesian author recal injuri analysi made commun basi region basi conclus causat view conclud materi injuri suffer commun industri characteris neg develop product sale volum price market share profit return invest cash flow employ duli adjust account reloc hungari caus subsidis import concern combin effect commun industri situat import india thailand prc partial reloc commun product limit contend indonesian export cooper contradict conclus state recit fact suffici evid open expiri review prc respect recal scope expiri review analys situat commun market perspect likelihood continu recurr dump injuri measur forc remov fact deterior commun industri attribut investig period indonesia affect analysi futur behaviour commun market chines export effect situat commun industri recal chines market share low level year period consid analysi properli distinguish separ effect factor situat commun industri injuri effect subsidis import conclud factor revers fact materi injuri found attribut subsidis import commun interest preliminari remark examin compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest adopt measur case purpos accord articl basic regul impact measur parti involv proceed consequ take measur consid basi evid submit order assess impact imposit imposit measur inform request interest parti questionnair complain commun produc compani produc commun unrel import user user associ complain commun produc koloman unrel import user relat import repli questionnair user made submiss repli questionnair repli submiss form basi commun interest analysi interest commun industri preliminari remark produc rbm commun stop manufactur product concern year compani left investig establish mention recit compani locat uk stop product year ago compani locat itali found repres signific proport product rbm commun import signific part sale spanish compani found consid import produc produc neglig volum product concern import sale indonesia conclud complain commun produc rbm signific product left recal complain commun produc heavili injur past import rbm origin prc malaysia regul ec led inter alia decreas workforc octob shown recit reduct commun industri workforc occur ip view materi injuri suffer commun industri conclud commun industri recov unfair subsidis practic product commun ceas complet user significantli depend import financi situat commun industri financi situat commun industri develop neg period consid ip commun industri receivership mention recit note commun industri loss make situat result difficulti compet low price subsidis import fact cooper commun produc show product rbm commun process restructur strong effort made industri viabl render profit effect imposit imposit measur commun industri imposit measur restor fair market condit enabl commun industri recov lost market share increas capac utilis decreas unit product cost increas profit measur expect posit effect level commun industri price conclus expect increas product sale volum hand decreas unit cost hand eventu combin moder price increas commun industri improv financi situat contrari countervail measur impos commun industri lower price continu lose market share scenario financi situat commun industri worsen consequ commun product short period time definit ceas commun industri produc product concern product account turnov closur product line manufactur rbm affect viabil factori lead closur product line consequ wider neg effect employ invest reloc commun industri product examin measur consid interest commun reloc part commun industri product countri possibl reloc examin explain recit recal reloc place permit commun industri limit loss respect strateg decis thwart effect subsidis practic addit reloc improv financi situat commun industri indirect effect make attract investor recent risk addit reloc commiss receiv satisfactori confirm reloc foreseen commun industri addit reason move restructur effort combin imposit countervail duti enabl commun industri enjoi profit situat interest import import purchas rbm indonesia submit switch sourc suppli involv addit cost transit problem import underlin ow anti dump measur impos forc chang sourc suppli recal purpos countervail measur forc import user chang sourc suppli restor fair competit commun market addit import recognis number countri easili produc rbm foresaw difficulti sourc countri cover countervail measur trade commun produc product problem result switch suppli temporari offset posit effect commun industri countervail measur injuri subsidi interest user consum user alleg cooper unrel import user ring binder produc imposit countervail measur advers impact financi situat user respect effect user cost product countervail measur impos indonesia assess respect estim undertaken impact measur propos indonesia user sole sourc suppli import indonesia worst case scenario basi impact measur propos indonesia evalu increas cost product explain hypothet scenario user cooper sourc product concern indonesia view find conclud impact countervail duti user neglig gener term lack cooper user cost impact user similarli neglig cooper user claim happen past year reloc part product commun close plant imposit anti dump measur rbm origin prc malaysia countervail measur import origin indonesia increas price item cost product entail move ring binder product commun closur relev plant risk affect activ manufactur product plant delocalis signific job loss commun gener remark note risk reloc downstream industri ow countervail measur temper fact part binder market busi busi orient fundament user close custom flexibl product readi meet demand sound knowledg market investig show fact main criteria custom ring binder produc account choic price qualiti servic speedi deliveri addit explain recit financi impact countervail measur downstream industri found neglig final fact binder produc fulli cooper investig confirm conclus countervail measur decis impact user addit interest parti point reloc user occur past year due high cost product commun confirm reloc wider context cost structur explain countervail measur repres neglig portion specif situat cooper user investig show user reloc part product commun ip imposit anti dump measur prc malaysia user fact chang sourc suppli imposit anti dump measur prc malaysia purchas rbm cooper import turn start import india detriment prc difficult establish link move ring binder product user commun imposit anti dump duti import prc malaysia shown recit countervail duti neglig impact user cost product found reloc consequ extern orient strategi user acquir number compani year strategi eventu led consolid restructur entiti group close reloc plant commun part strategi aim strengthen posit user commun market develop presenc eastern europ background view neglig impact level duti impos user concern appear countervail measur indonesia entail move ring binder product commun closur plant risk closur link imposit countervail measur indonesia found cooper user close plant past year measur prc malaysia forc view neglig impact measur cost product financi situat user question explain recit measur prc malaysia led closur plant countervail measur import indonesia closur plant consum mention product concern sold retail level consum associ made particip investig cooper user argu countervail measur increas price paid final custom ring binder consum view explan impact ring binder produc increas final sale price consum ring binder signific addit investig show cooper user sell product distributor worst scenario cost increas user suffer pass full final consum entail price increas maximum final consum occur gener experi show step distribut chain support part cost increas order stai competit market basi impact user rbm consum ring binder consid constitut compel reason imposit countervail measur neg effect offset posit effect commun industri countervail measur injuri subsidi impact competit examin imposit countervail measur import indonesia lead situat commun industri benefit domin posit commun market view anti dump measur impos import prc malaysia view restructur commun industri recal commun industri held ip market share rang complain commun produc held ip market share rang event includ koloman import market share held complain market share rang commun market ip addit recal commiss initi review measur prc review concern import malaysia rbm import india consid imposit countervail measur indonesia lead neg effect competit commun industri commun market final recal imposit anti dump measur import prc malaysia likewis lead kind domin commun industri sourc suppli countri exist time hand explain recit measur correct effect subsidis import commun product short period time longer viabl ceas interest user commun industri ceas product product concern hand sole user cooper purchas rbm commun industri ip hand commun industri ceas product rbm user significantli depend import measur impos altern sourc suppli exist rbm purchas commun industri commun produc india hong kong addit import malaysia recomm measur countri recent expir investig shown imposit anti dump measur import prc malaysia entail shortag product concern final recal impact measur user found neglig product concern import indonesia conclus commun interest reason conclud compel reason imposit countervail duti definit measur injuri elimin level view conclus reach regard subsidis injuri causat commun interest definit countervail measur impos level suffici elimin injuri caus commun industri subsidis import accord articl basic regul commiss examin level duti adequ remov injuri commun industri caus subsidis purpos consid price level base commun produc cost product reason profit margin calcul found profit margin turnov regard reason minimum take account long term invest amount commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri subsidis lack cooper consid injuri elimin level cover differ calcul price cif price adjust explain recit injuri elimin level found import indonesia definit countervail measur light forego accord articl basic regul countervail duti rate correspond subsidi margin lower injuri margin rate duti appli indonesia compani order meet deadlin set articl basic regul present regul enter forc dai public adopt regul articl definit countervail duti impos import ring binder mechan fall cn code taric code origin indonesia purpos regul ring binder mechan consist rectangular steel sheet wire half ring made steel wire fix steel cover open pull half ring small steel made trigger mechan fix ring binder mechan rate definit countervail duti applic net free commun frontier price duti product origin gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli proceed import ring binder mechan origin india termin articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state luxembourg june council presid de rato figaredo oj oj oj council regul ec oj oj oj