commiss decis januari termin examin procedur brazilian export financ programm quot proex quot appli region aircraft sector ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb lai commun procedur field common commerci polici order ensur exercis commun right intern trade rule establish auspic word trade organis articl thereof januari german manufactur region aircraft dornier luftfahrt gmbh refer quot dornier quot lodg complaint commiss pursuant articl trade barrier regul complaint relat brazilian export financ programm quot programa de financiamentò às exportaco quot proex export aircraft oper interest rate equalis system complain alleg applic proex brazilian aircraft industri region jet manufactur embraer allow compet unfairli dornier seat jet market proex allow purchas embraer aircraft reduc financ cost level offer financi market led signific reduct aircraft price complain contend proex constitut prohibit export subsidi articl wto agreement subsidi countervail measur scm agreement dornier claim embraer abus proex programm caus materi injuri commun market advers trade effect ec market notabl switzerland commiss found complaint contain suffici prima faci evid trade barrier announc initi examin procedur notic publish april offici journal commiss main find summaris proex act interest rate equalis system virtu brazilian govern reimburs part interest rate foreign purchas embraer aircraft pai financ purchas reimburs amount percentag point annum period year proex allow airlin acquir aircraft financ condit favour market place result net present benefit rang aircraft purchas price result embraer posit systemat undercut price dornier seat jet gain lion share commun seat jet market fleet deal proex financ term decis factor airlin opt brazilian jet circumst commiss consid complain alleg exist obstacl trade found proex result advers trade effect injuri mean articl tbr tbr examin panel establish canadian request disput settlement bodi dsb world trade organis wto conclud proex payment constitut prohibit export subsidi inconsist articl wto agreement subsidi countervail measur scm agreement conclus recommend panel upheld wto appel bodi report adopt dsb august novemb brazil inform dsb introduc proex proex ii order implement dsb recommend canada consid proex ii continu provid export subsidi contrari scm agreement initi complianc procedur articl disput settlement understand dsu complianc panel appel bodi upheld canada posit found proex ii constitut illeg export subsidi decemb brazil adopt revis version proex proex iii canada initi complianc panel articl dsu examin wto compat time panel report adopt dsb august conclud unlik previou version proex iii violat articl scm agreement requir brazil provid export credit term condit constitut subsidi panel conclus refer proex iii law face independ applic state necessarili follow futur applic proex iii consist scm agreement adopt panel dsb european commun state remain vigil ensur brazil respect wto oblig applic proex iii individu transact year monitor alleg made evid submit brazil respect absenc evid unfair trade practic brazil adopt wto panel report proex iii european commun consid action requir accord articl regul procedur termin advisori committe consult measur provid decis adopt decis sole articl examin procedur brazilian export financ programm quot proex quot appli region aircraft sector initi april termin brussel januari commiss pascal lami member commiss oj amend regul ec oj oj