commiss decis april dual exempt unit kingdom plan implement climat chang levi extend exempt compet process notifi document number english text authent text eea relev ec ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard treati establish european coal steel commun articl thereof commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid steel industri quot steel aid code quot regard agreement european econom area articl thereof protocol thereto call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl ec treati pursuant articl steel aid code regard comment dual exempt climat chang levi concern procedur letter date februari unit kingdom notifi commiss climat chang levi quot ccl quot legal basi ccl financ act section schedul letter date april unit kingdom notifi commiss ccl accord steel aid code letter date march sg april sg commiss inform unit kingdom decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati articl steel aid code respect exempt dual fuel ccl commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss call interest parti submit comment commiss receiv comment interest parti relat investig articl ec treati commiss receiv observ british cement associ letter juli british lime associ letter juli addition relat investig articl steel aid code commiss receiv observ uk steel associ letter juli european independ steelwork associ letter august coru letter juli asw letter august commiss forward comment unit kingdom letter august letter august unit kingdom submit respons commiss letter march april letter date septemb unit kingdom submit comment parti observ detail descript climat chang levi ccl packag take forward british govern polici environment taxat central part british govern climat chang programm set govern propos meet unit kingdom legal bind target reduct greenhous ga emiss kyoto protocol move british govern domest goal reduct carbon dioxid emiss ccl design cover domest energi product fuel purpos fuel purpos includ light heat motiv power power applianc energi product fuel purpos subject ccl consum industri includ fuel industri commerc agricultur public administr servic tax levi point sale final consum taxabl commod electr ga coal solid fuel liquefi petroleum ga miner oil scope tax subject excis duti accord council direct eec octob harmonis structur excis duti miner oil quot miner oil direct quot legal basi ccl financ act section schedul receiv royal assent juli decis march april commiss rais object exempt ccl exempt electr ga coal public transport rail freight exempt input fuel electr gener good qualiti combin heat power plant exempt electr gener clean energi sourc reduct facil enter climat chang agreement measur contain element state aid notifi british author period year extent commiss rais object ccl forc april fuel dual exempt ccl energi product fall scope levi exempt purpos fuel ccl appli energi product raw materi fuel exempt addition energi product princip fuel purpos product exempt ccl dual exempt full list process involv dual fuel contain climat chang levi fuel regul commiss initi investig procedur articl ec treati articl steel aid code respect dual exempt reason open procedur open procedur commiss express doubt dual exempt consid gener measur favour undertak product good metal batteri chemic commiss consid steel product sector exempt favour undertak depend product method emploi commiss consid dual exempt justifi basi natur logic tax system consist object ccl reduc emiss carbon dioxid commiss note claim made british author imposit ccl sole energi fuel purpos consist provis miner oil direct propos council direct restructur commun framework taxat energi product quot propos quot commiss note definit scope energi tax energi product tax logic system establish miner oil direct propos commiss consid propos dual exempt definit scope levi reason doubt unit kingdom exempt fuel levi partial energi purpos defin commiss doubt british author establish mechan estim fuel fuel process made levi impos exempt treat compar situat equal dual process exempt levi process consid dual exempt propos forc reli refer point establish logic gener natur tax system provid indic commiss note exempt extend energi metallurg process requir articl propos comment interest parti observ receiv parti summaris british cement associ support principl dual exempt concern practic compar situat treat equal ccl discrimin manufactur cement dual exempt creat distort competit cement concret product steel product manufactur blast furnac british cement associ domin chemic reaction cement chemic decomposit calcium carbon caco calcium oxid cao convers caco cao chemic reaction typic requir kwh energi tonn caco similar figur dolomit limeston cement make process energi suppli fuel drive chemic reaction calcin lime british lime associ support principl unit kingdom dual approach concern practic treat compar situat equal discrimin lime consid dual exempt threaten distort competit unit kingdom list exempt amend includ lime british lime associ energi requir lime manufactur process convert or limeston activ chemic lime chemic reaction defin manufactur high calcium lime caco cao chemic reaction defin manufactur dolomit lime caco mgco energi caomgo commerci product energi requir convert limeston lime thermal energi temperatur excess uk steel associ comment dual exempt gener measur natur logic tax system concern distort competit caus dual exempt consid prefer end distort british govern addition exempt ccl electr electr arc furnac european independ steelwork associ claim fuel coke blast furnac coke input difficult apport fuel fuel consid electr arc furnac exempt metallurg process line propos exempt coke blast furnac similar exempt grant electr arc furnac steelmak aid british blast furnac steel maker contrari ecsc state aid rule asw maintain dual exempt state aid appli coru discrimin electr arc furnac justifi basi logic natur system consid fuel element coke blast furnac repres coke input underlin electr arc furnac environment damag steel product process requir energi produc carbon dioxid consid dual exempt incompat propos extend metallurg process final dual exempt compli commun guidelin state aid environment protect quot environment aid guidelin quot coru consid dual exempt state aid justifi natur gener scheme system consid gener principl establish miner oil direct propos view blast furnac coke raw materi coke charg purpos chemic reduct consid electr arc furnac carbon addit form coke coal raw materi consid econom disadvantag suffer electr arc produc de minimi final view dual exempt consid state aid compat environment aid guidelin comment unit kingdom apportion unit kingdom posit ccl extend taxabl commod sole fuel purpos view british author taxabl commod fuel purpos fuel purpos raw materi ccl levi part taxabl commod fuel purpos apportion support posit british author highlight fact submiss made interest parti apportion solut dual issu british author draw commiss attent wide varieti figur quot purport defin energi energi proport coke blast furnac make difficult accur identifi fuel fuel energi product british author maintain highli variabl factor qualiti coke or account british author commiss note member state utilis method apportion deal issu dual fuel british author contend support view apportion scientif practic dual natur logic system british author apportion maintain taxabl commod perform dual logic natur system grant full exempt commod primarili raw materi fuel product element heat british author exempt dual logic natur system reason exempt fuel unit kingdom exempt fuel reflect wide accept view manufactur process form energi heat light electron motiv power exclus raw materi ccl line object common energi taxat unit kingdom levi energi fuel raw materi energi fall intend scope energi taxat unit kingdom exempt ccl miner oil excis duti british author underlin exempt fuel approv commiss exempt part natur logic system taxat reason input energi raw materi determin chemistri reaction amount product requir input amount energi product chemic physic relationship alter remov scope produc improv effici oper term amount energi product requir impos ccl energi circumst increas incent energi effici serv purpos steel sector british author accept number option blast furnac auxiliari process energi fuel benefit dual exempt improv effici includ item blower effici temperatur control pipework insul heat recoveri maintain step reduc amount raw materi coke oil inject need produc chemic reduct type raw materi requir sever constrain chemistri reaction reaction requir solid carbon base fuel requir energi suppli raw materi form ga produc switch altern sourc energi renew gener electr impos ccl energi circumst creat incent switch sourc purpos british author fuel dual exempt natur logic energi taxat system differ principl fuel energi dual fuel british author maintain differ approach taxat fuel dual british author maintain fuel dual exempt consist aspect ccl exempt discount ccl demonstr logic packag measur form ccl exempt public transport renew energi good qualiti chp temporarili natur ga northern ireland includ ccl reduct facil enter energi save agreement british author aspect ccl packag target achiev object fit equal natur logic ccl relat observ receiv parti british author major submiss fulli support principl dual exempt main area disput correct process benefit exempt relat observ submit british cement associ british lime associ british author note associ state chemic transform involv cement lime manufactur make mineralog transform process entitl dual exempt british author disput chemic inform provid contend irrelev assess elig dual exempt cement lime manufactur energi reaction pure fuel energi form heat temperatur calcin lime calcium carbon magnesium carbon feedstock react case energi fuel raw materi british author stress dual exempt appli process energi product primari purpos raw materi heat product energi feedstock raw materi cement lime product conflict natur logic ccl includ cement lime product list process elig dual exempt whilst maintain dual exempt natur logic ccl environment tax british author accept situat lead pervers environment effect case process exempt levi dual provis compet process environment damag tax reason british author commit gener remov distort modifi notif british author propos modifi dual exempt cover situat energi intens recycl process liabl higher ccl payment energi intens compet primari process fall exempt fuel dual exempt design appli limit circumst natur logic ccl system energi taxat produc result contrari environment aim levi appli recycl process recycl process energi intens defin energi produc equal quantiti product primari process recycl process liabl higher ccl charg primari process defin ccl payabl tonn product situat aris primari process elig fuel dual exempt ccl process part process directli compet steel manufactur exempt appli energi electr arc furnac process compet primari produc blast furnac appli part steel product process british author undertak publicis term exempt invit busi elig appli support evid applic assess criteria outlin specialist technic input obtain requir valid applic approv recipi entitl submit levi reduct certif energi supplier amend certif submit benefit scope exempt posit british author accur identifi process meet criteria dual exempt list climat chang levi fuel regul british author maintain energi identifi exempt ccl result expert consider hm custom excis supplementari independ scientif advic energi technolog support unit etsu british author undertook technic consult repres industri concern relat observ receiv parti british author make gener point clear differ fuel heat chemic reaction place fuel raw materi case matter fuel heat gener case amount type energi determin precis natur chemic reaction british author electr arc furnac process rais parti cement glass ceram lime fulfil criteria dual exempt fuel raw materi determin immut scientif equat pure heat purpos relat observ receiv parti steel sector british author agre coke blast furnac consid primarili fuel suggest asw european independ steelwork associ british author technic basi claim coke blast furnac base inaccur interpret figur provid intern iron steel institut british author accur interpret figur coke input blast furnac fuel purpos signific variat determin factor qualiti or coke british author accept blast furnac electr arc furnac exempt ccl metallurg process suggest eisa asw uk steel associ british author agre definit metallurg process purpos articl propos view dual exempt encompass process includ metallurg process energi primari purpos raw materi heat product relat observ receiv process fall ec treati british author process refer consid mineralog process qualifi dual exempt cement lime manufactur energi pure fuel provid temperatur calcin lime calcium carbon magnesium carbon feedstock react keep logic natur ccl includ cement lime product list process elig dual exempt british author evalu exempt environment damag direct competitor effect limit secondari metal produc ferrou ferrou sector british author awar product product process meet elig criteria recycl process glass rubber plastic cement lime ceram elig assess prejudic applic process consid criteria outlin assess measur dual exempt fall assess articl ec treati articl ecsc treati steel aid code articl eea agreement protocol thereto articl ec treati aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market point articl ecsc treati recognis incompat common market prohibit subsidi aid grant state form whatsoev introduct environment tax consumpt electr coal solid fuel ga liquefi petroleum ga caught articl ec treati articl ecsc treati gener measur favour firm sector industri except gener tax reduc tariff refund tax fall scope articl ec treati articl ecsc treati aim firm sector exempt justifi natur gener scheme system principl set commiss notic applic state aid rule measur relat direct busi taxat point seq commiss consid dual exempt benefit compani advantag financ state resourc assess exempt gener measur british author claim constitut state aid commiss consid assess effect favour undertak product good commiss note dual exempt benefit undertak sector inform provid british author dual exempt extend energi product limit process list climat chang levi fuel regul commiss consid dual exempt select measur commiss note fall consid dual exempt justifi logic natur system taxat commiss note ccl levi energi fuel purpos levi energi fuel purpos commiss accept logic natur environment tax system levi tax energi product fuel exempt energi product pure fuel purpos commiss accept exempt ccl commiss note british author reach conclus process energi product pure fuel purpos basi expert consider hm custom excis supplementari independ scientif advic energi technolog support unit commiss note observ submit parti contend electr electr arc furnac energi product cement lime raw materi reduct commiss accept posit british author energi product process princip fuel purpos decis initi procedur laid articl ec treati articl steel aid code commiss express doubt failur british author relat process energi partli fuel partli fuel purpos apport ccl commiss doubt full exempt dual process commiss note basi inform provid investig procedur consider practic difficulti apport ccl fuel part energi dual purpos commiss note highli variabl factor qualiti raw materi account apport fuel fuel energi commiss note parti submit observ commiss identifi apportion altern dual exempt commiss accept apportion viabl option british author commiss note dual exempt extend situat energi product primarili raw materi element heat product commiss note circumst type amount energi product requir determin natur chemistri reaction commiss note case scope produc chang type amount energi product requir process limit propos direct taxat energi product provid indic dual exempt keep gener logic natur system commiss note articl propos exempt energi product electr princip purpos chemic reduct metallurg electrolyt process commiss consid dual exempt principl line propos energi product electr primarili fuel take element account commiss consid apportion viabl option logic natur environment tax system provid exempt energi product primarili fuel purpos commiss accept basi inform gather investig coke blast furnac primarili purpos chemic reduct commiss express doubt effect dual exempt commiss note applic dual exempt lead distort competit advers environment consequ environment damag process treat unfavour comparison directli compet process fall scope dual exempt british author recognis consequ ccl modifi notif undertak exempt process criteria fulfil commiss note unit kingdom evalu effect modif limit secondari metal produc ferrou ferrou metal sector sector environment damag recycl product process compet primari process fall scope dual exempt commiss note unit kingdom posit modif affect cement lime product recycl process face distort due applic dual exempt compet primari product process fall consid exempt extend compet process justifi natur logic scheme constitut state aid light scope ccl tax fuel energi commiss exempt process classifi energi product pure fuel purpos keep natur logic system commiss consid exempt constitut state aid fall consid exempt consid compat treati commiss note articl ec treati aid facilit develop econom activ consid compat common market aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest commiss note modif notifi british author directli compet primari recycl product process treat manner purpos taxat ccl commiss consid modif significantli reduc distort competit mitig advers environment consequ aris oper dual exempt circumst commiss consid exempt limit neg environment consequ aris dual exempt accept point view commun environment polici commiss exempt advers affect trade condit design ensur mainten equit trade condit commiss find aid consid compat common market initi period year state aid element ccl fall renotifi light posit british author undertak treat directli compet primari recycl product process manner purpos taxat ccl limit disadvantag environment damag process commiss doubt environment consequ distort competit allai conclus view forego commiss consid dual exempt logic natur ccl commiss consid exempt environment damag process recycl product process compet directli primari product process fall scope fuel dual exempt constitut compat state aid commiss approv dual exempt rais object exempt compet process adopt decis articl dual exempt unit kingdom plan implement climat chang levi institut section schedul unit kingdom financ act constitut aid mean articl ec treati point articl ecsc treati articl exempt environment damag process recycl product process compet directli primari product process fall scope fuel dual exempt constitut state aid mean articl treati aid meet condit exempt articl treati compat common market approv initi period year articl decis address unit kingdom great britain northern ireland brussel april commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj footnot oj oj oj energi steel industri committe technolog brussel septemb intern iron steel institut paragraph cj cairn al interpret figur confirm commiss author report oj