commiss decis octob accept undertak connect anti dump proceed import silicon carbid origin peopl republ china norwai poland ussr termin investig import product origin peopl republ china norwai poland czechoslovakia ussr yugoslavia eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul eec juli protect dump subsid import countri member european econom commun articl thereof consult advisori committe provid regul procedur commiss receiv complaint lodg european council chemic manufactur feder cefic behalf commun produc silicon carbid complaint contain evid dump materi injuri result therefrom consid suffici justifi initi proceed commiss announc notic publish offici journal european commun initi anti dump proceed import commun silicon carbid fall common custom tariff subhead nimex code origin peopl republ china czechoslovakia norwai poland ussr spain yugoslavia commenc investig commiss offici advis export import concern repres export countri complain gave parti directli concern opportun make view write request hear produc export import made view write hear grant request submiss made behalf user associ user commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos preliminari determin compani carri investig premis eec produc elektroschmelzwerk kempten gmbh muenchen feder republ germani lonza werk gmbh waldshut tiengen feder republ germani pechinei electrometallurgi sofrem pari franc samim abrasivi spa san michel adig itali eec produc export navarro sa madrid spain arend smelteverk eydehavn norwai norton lillesand norwai orkla exolon amp orkang norwai tovarna dusika ruse yugoslavia represent china nation machineri equip import amp export corpor koeln feder republ germani eec import internat sa lièg belgium sa barascud abrasif chimi castr franc société derognat cie comblanchien franc dfg gremilliet remiremont franc mineralien werk duisburg gmbh duisburg feder republ germani mineralien werk kuppenheim gmbh kuppenheim feder republ germani alfr hempel gmbh amp duesseldorf feder republ germani kerimpex handelsgesellschaft gmbh selb feder republ germani werner kessl giessereibedarf gmbh baernwinkel feder republ germani gesellschaft fuer metallurgi hafner und polt gmbh duesseldorf feder republ germani wilfri post gmbh gut junkerswald feder republ germani thyssen schult metallurgi gmbh dortmund feder republ germani smyri abrasivi srl pero mi itali veneta mineraria spa milano itali carborundum abras gb manchest unit kingdom union carbid uk limit glossop unit kingdom tennant metallurg sheffield unit kingdom investig dump cover period juli june view articl act access spain portug result investig respect import spain dealt separ term council regul eec march protect import subject dump commun ten member state member state period transit measur laid act access spain portug appli normal yugoslavia case yugoslavia sole produc manufactur basic grade black silicon carbid evid present export semi finish state domest sale price base normal decid case case norwai point construct valu full product sell overhead cost product investig period account record cost account produc cost ad reason profit base produc earn domest market sale artifici corundum analog product market economi countri except spain refer point norwai remain export cover investig origin state trade countri order establish import countri dump commiss account fact peopl republ china czechoslovakia poland ussr market economi determin base normal market economi countri connect complain suggest yugoslav market commiss decid accept suggest reason silicon carbid custom head cover wide rang product grade similarli wide rang market price primarili applic abras refractori metallurg field mention point yugoslav produc found manufactur product grade export semi finish state view fact extrem restrict rang product grade incomplet product process state oper manufactur commiss normal valu establish yugoslavia technic satisfactori basi determin normal respect market economi export concern proceed spanish produc found possess complet product process wide rang product grade sold finish product export domest market hwever commiss adopt altern basi normal market economi export countri compar protect natur spanish market fact produc market commiss conclud unreason determin normal market economi export basi construct norwai complet rang product grade sold product process oper norewegian produc import factor conclus fact remark point restrict natur norwegian market render obligatori refer major case construct valu domest price consid disadvantag market economi export view compar advantag enjoi norwegian compani highli energi intens type product export import rais object norwai analogu countri purpos normal refer differ physic characterist product manufactur market economi compar manufactur norwai commiss repli object wide varieti product grade normal valu establish norwai permit comparison product grade sold market economi export differ physic characterist subsist comparison product grade dealt allow explain section comparison export mention make propos altern analogu countri import mention hand critic commiss decis discard choic yugoslavia purpos alleg reason advanc decis point correspond real situat yougoslav produc evid alleg produc find made commiss investig yugoslav produc support alleg norwai seek determin normal norwegian compani commiss account small quantiti product sold domest market found fact refer period investig produc turnov export sale approxim half total export commun gener sale domest market small permit valid comparison export sale product commun case compani product grade sold total consider domest sale found attain threshold volum equival product grade export commun market threshold case establish commiss regul eec anti dump proceed import electron typewrit japan product grade mention compani normal provision determin basi domest price lack adequ quantiti domest sale permit proper comparison case product grade produc norwegian compani determin normal grade basi compani propos export price countri purpos suggest accept commiss posit confirm export price market commun fact dump price addit period cover investig major fluctuat import world currenc ad element uncertainti choic countri export market base normal reason set normal provision determin basi construct valu norwai construct valu establish basi cost present compani investig major product grade produc sold product cost consist actual expens produc grade concern reflect record compani period cover investig cost product incorpor fix cost includ sell administr gener expens percentag factor compani ad account expens percentag factor appear reason light financi data verifi investig reason profit margin ad cost order ensur profit margin reflect compani perform repres period decid purpos audit set account present compani averag oper profit earn recent financi calendar year lead investig period view extrem restrict proport domest sale mention earlier audit account apport profit geograph oper profit specif domest profit constitut reason basi determin profit margin note respect compani produc sold silicon carbid materi inform provid profit norwegian domest sale exist gener higher equal profit extens contact long period time norwegian export form meet exchang correspond provision find stage produc contest commiss find dump injuri analog reason case object normal find group main head place object construct valu bing determin normal discuss point place object construct valu clacul discuss point norwegian produc object construct valu basi normal argument advanc norwegian produc construct valu present case contrari commerci logic entail imput fix equal proport profit product grade deni produc cost advantag opportun compet freeli set sell price profit margin differ product grade competit situat absenc verifi evid permit alloc profit margin differ product grade commiss oblig alloc cost compani investig profit uniform manner basi turnov ensur complet absorb sale period norwegian produc object commiss calcul construct valu norwegian produc inform prior spot investig commiss servic cost extens examin collabor provid extens cost financi account data compani intern record independ audit annual account commerci technic inform compani found oper manag account system account differ variabl cost main product categori sell gener administr overhead gener alloc product grade conform compani practic investig period variabl fix cost concern object rais stage compani form construct cost individu product categori preliminari result investig discuss show dump vari degre compani product grade main object construct valu calcul voic the object put forward slightlti differ formul compani object concern profit margin establish construct valu method calcul point compani claim reason margin profit mean articl ii regul eec determin construct basi object appear size profit margin found larger profit margin attribut norwegian industri construct valu determin anti dump proceed past year proceed involv industri compani experienc loss reduc profit time investig concern accur profit margin basi industri compani recent perform present proceed profit margin audit real profit compani involv case averag year profit calcul order avoid possibl unfair determin base exception profit year compani year includ averag worst year profit histori real profit earn exist accur determin evid constitut reason measur profit purpos unfair discriminatori object concern remain compon construct valu cost gener compani point detail correct find provision present correct justifi basi evid collect investig commiss modifi find time present preliminari find compani rais point method cost product grade emploi hitherto adequ reflect technic commerci realiti argu compani time commiss investig acceler realiz request time opportun present materi commiss basi revis criteria commiss consider doubt correct procedur decid acced request examin carefulli submiss individu merit prejudic question inform validli consider provision find present conclus spot investig materi present differ scope complet compani compani similar purpos case detail point relat evid collect mention norwegian produc claim import cost criteria justifi larg technic ground criteria retroact modifi initi investig find modif propos basi wide rang compani claim complet reorgan cost system result quantit signific result case diminish significantli cost normal valu metallurg wiresaw product grade highest level dump preliminari determin stage proceed compani submit argument revis overhead alloc criteria practic similar result product grade commiss consid extens argument technic explan put forward fact present compani field justifi virtual complet abandon find made investig hand supplementari submiss contain evid point detail bore object verifi relationship data check investig account find appropri correct commiss explain construct valu norwai base exclus inform present compani verifi relat account cost system everydai compani consider time investig period compani investig drew attent fact grade silicon carbid sold refer qualiti specif defin agreement individu custom concern cost system design reflect actual cost term broad product categori distinguish differ chemic composit colour grain size applic basi commiss collect evid conduct investig time compani cost report fulli integr account manag procedur found true remain norwegian compani import account cost system compani time investig li object verifi charact evid provid manag long period lead includ investig system addit record compani result criteria manag time provid framework manag decis includ price decis accept claim commiss adopt product cost estim retroact basi radic revis criteria place cost calcul normal manag account procedur forc compani prior investig period take posit impli case involv construct valu basi normal commiss depart figur compani relev period export price export price determin basi price paid payabl product sold export commun comparison compar normal export price commiss account differ affect price compar claim direct relationship differ sale consider satisfactorili demonstr case differ condit term sale transport credit term ancillari cost pack handl agent commiss applic allow claim interest parti made differ physic characterist comparison made work level commun import product ussr critic make comparison work level base articl regul eec import question bought price includ cost transport long distanc ussr premis cost import case materi low relat weight volum commiss oblig exclud transport cost export price commun frontier cost includ price paid import import suggest requir product contain articl regul eec satisfi norwegian construct valu basi normal reason choic explain point grant allow differ physic characterist import product demonstr suffici similar product chosen comparison dump margin preliminari examin fact show exist dump respect peopl republ china norwai poland ussr margin dump equal amount normal establish exce price export commun dump margin express percentag total cif export price commun product investig margin vari import member state product grade silicon carbid concern weight averag margin defin point export countri concern eec margin peopl republ china poland ussr gener produc export product grade black silicon carbid great major quantiti import commun countri concern macro grit lump grit manufactur product abras applianc refractori wiresaw applic import except small quantiti abras grit poland dump case norwai margin vari export grade silicon carbid concern explain norwegian compani manufactur complet rang grade materi larg number grade undump dump margin found commiss grade sold largest quantiti aggreg weight relat total export commun grade investig give credit amount export price exceed normal case undump grade margin dump found compani export eec margin arend smelteverk norton orkla exolon amp margin set illustr commiss consid import featur find concentr signific level dump categori account total quantiti export eec norwai dump margin found metallurg grade minimum sic content fact larger export smallest export significantli concern export product categori investig period wiresaw grain mix rang export arriv dump margin commiss includ calcul product wast materi consid data relat compani normal product sale construct valu provid repres measur level dump export commun norwegian compani state consid export primarili target origin complaint claim larg dispar high level dump alleg complaint modest level found investig strongli contest reason set point demonstr invalid proceed open basi complaint motiv commerci consider back adequ evid argument direct indic dump contain complaint compar domest price norwai high qualiti abras grade export price lower level metallurg materi commiss accept view proceed invalid simpli result show data contain complaint incorrect investig design precis show alleg contain complaint support fact dump level found modest specif level import origin czechoslovakia yugoslavia dump found proceed respect import termin injuri regard injuri caus dump import evid commiss show import commun peopl republ china norwai poland ussr silicon carbid increas tonn tonn tonn repres increas time commun consumpt materi return level tonn tonn fallen back market share held silicon carbid origin countri mention previou point progress period market share commun produc fell percentag commun consumpt impact dump import loss sale commun produc demonstr fact basi consumpt figur commun practic ident increas combin market share countri mention account slightli fall market share commun produc effect lost market share mention previou point complet reflect product figur commun industri approxim tonn silicon carbid product produc commun produc tonn repres depress level comparison tonn commun produc significantli increas product period case smallest produc fell capac util recov level commun averag remain low comparison year satisfactori full capac work commu niti industri produc significantli improv capac util figur produc remain interven period note product fell approxim tonn figur demonstr recoveri product appear basi evid larg relat increas export commun ephemer improv addit export volum attribut temporari exchang rate movement econom indic refer commun produc demonstr pressur larg result dump import period number peopl perman emploi commun industri fell period total consider number involv part time work technic lai employe concern total progress spite ration effort profit sale silicon carbid commun produc diminish sharpli compani make profit break point compani made loss period profit fourth compani descend break end period gener situat silicon carbid grade diminish elimin profit evid detail analysi individu compani cost profit main product grade show metallurg sector silicon carbid product sale underw sever pressur gener figur import sector judg fact metallurg grade account total silicon carbid product volum commun produc sever pressur fact major commun produc account third commun product experienc steadili grow loss area activ end period sale incom metallurg silicon carbid cover total product sell administr cost sector situat refer point commiss examin sale commun silicon carbid export found dump made price price charg equival qualiti product grade commun produc factor price comparison point place commiss found evid level price commun undergon consider depress open investig period year sell price commun produc fallen risen quickli cost demand silicon carbid commun stagnat period reced year market share captur import export concern increas rapidli expens commun produc share point inadequ level commun produc sell price due low price import stagnant demand shown loss previous establish long term custom commun industri export movement market share mention immedi market econom data summar point case market economi export allow grant differ physic characterist point incorpor price comparison injuri assess purpos gross differ price found market natur account allow larger percentag shown compar basi weight averag resal price import investig period equival price commun produc gave result gener import peopl republ china found undercut local produc price averag import poland import ussr case norwai situat complex due partli wider rang product grade import member state involv partli situat import market sector wide rang standard product grade includ wiresaw grain mix exclud metallurg grade rang undercut found vari averag case metallurg grade concern approxim norwegian import silicon carbid commun investig period larger proport import member state undercut found case norwegian produc case comparison commun produc price unaffect price pressur norwegian import case client commun produc maintain purchas agreement price level earlier period undertaken purchas basi standard offer price recal point norwegian produc significantli involv partiular market sector norwegian produc argu price undercut refer product sector competit action commun produc price cut move initi price adopt commun industri claim difficult verifi conclus data show product sector commun industri frequent match price norwegian import export concern alleg proof extens price cut caus materi injuri commun produc aleadi point price undercut norwegian export found practis sector gener manner case product grade commun produc commit sector fact increasingli adapt price level norwegian import order avoid undercut lose sale injuri inflict sector commun produc evalu basi price undercut observ investig period relat pronounc sector loss commun produc point extent loss contradict alleg norwegian export provid clear measur damag suffer commun industri seek defend market share unfairli price import argument advanc norwegian produc concern profit commun produc claim alleg materi injuri support inconsist financi report compani commun improv perform commun industri mention point offici compani report question commiss examin evid commiss sustain argument report specif comment give quantifi inform silicon carbid activ compani concern fact possess signific activ area addit fact report refer satisfact evolut silicon carbid activ view light loss made activ immedi preced year contradict remark made profit sector profit silicon carbid product grade point similari argument put forward norwegian industri import capit invest undertaken commun produc commiss cast doubt claim injuri suffer produc invest made replac outdat instal effici equip enlarg capac establish impact dump import commun industri commiss consid effect dump import export countri produc concern wide variat market share commun consumpt held export found dump total share mention point held norwai remain countri account export argu impact export commun consid isol judg caus materi injuri view low decreas level share market analys cumul case commiss account compar term physic characterist import product produc commun volum importd level price import product compar compet grade produc commun basi examin conclud dump import export concern consid contribut materi injuri suffer commun industri import made condit commiss treat export isol act discriminatori manner rest decid dump import export cumul establish injuri sustain commiss examin possibl factor import sourc continu downward trend demand caus injuri commun industri regard altern supplementari injuri inform import volum complet add possibl period combin market share export silicon carbid commun origin peopl republ china norwai poland spain ussr progress share export remain practic constant fall share commun consumpt held commun industri directli attribut increas import countri name increas import export regard trend demand mention point commun consumpt fell regain level estblish spite fall back demand import silicon carbid export found dump increas commun produc sale fell tonn export cite failur commiss investig affili commun produc situat countri export signific quantiti silicon carbid commun form procedur discrimin commiss share view export concern name complaint file commun industri oblig relat commun produc introduc affili proceed absenc alleg dump injuri commiss oblig investig compani concern absenc substanti complaint case commiss take consider possibl export includ proceed respons injuri commun industri point examin mention factor injuri caus reason suppos affili bear respons explain point find made regard import commun constitut decemb silicon carbid spain dealt separ regard injuri consider underlin stage effect import exclud injuri commun industri result dump import export mention complaint remain materi basi preced analysi commiss preliminarili determin dump import silicon carbid peopl republ china norwai poland ussr caus materi injuri commun industri concern extent injuri assess primarili term price undercut lost profit sector result price depress investig period point commun interest repres commun process industri individu compani argu introduct protect measur commun interest make competit import final product origin countri argument strongli relat market sector foundri briquett manufactur lower price rang abras grind tool case addition argu protect measur silicon carbid abras grain render grind tool competit countri market compani concern export case raw materi compon price increas expect incid cost process industri extent industri harm depend cost increas transfer custom higher sell price loss sale volum prevent competit pressur import process product reduct consumpt account price elast demand market sector compani provid evid commiss specif effect increas price silicon carbid product cost evid effect increas price processor product total sale circumst evalu impact increas price silicon carbid process industri remain pure specul carefulli weigh argument difficulti commun industri directli attribut dump materi commiss conclud take action dump commun interest undertak repres export peopl republ china norwai poland ussr inform find preliminari investig comment subsequ offer satisfactori undertak effect import price commun silicon carbid origin countri elimin injuri found investig export peopl republ china ussr margin injuri lower dump margin determin elimin dump found respect polish export case norwegian export undertak elimin margin dump injuri whichev lowest respect product grade commiss preliminari find injuri signific dump view circumst present case make applic measur undertak offer export mention consid accept investig termin imposit anti dump duti materi import countri object rais advisori committe accept undertak offer peopl republ china norwai poland ussr decid articl undertak offer represent china nation machineri equip import amp export corpor koeln feder republ germani arend smelteverk eydehavn norwai norton lillesand norwai orkla exolon amp orkang norwai inter vi warsaw poland stankoimport moscow ussr connect anti dump proceed import silicon carbid origin peopl china norwai poland ussr fall subhead common custom tariff nimex code accept articl investig connect anti dump proceed refer articl termin articl investig connect anti dump proceed import silicon carbid origin czechoslavakia yugoslavia termin brussel octob commiss willi de clercq member commiss oj oj oj oj