council regul ec januari impos definit anti dump duti import ferro molybdenum origin peopl republ china council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun basic regul articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur regul ec quot provision regul quot commiss impos provision anti dump duti import ferro molybdenum quot femo quot fall cn code origin peopl republ china quot prc quot subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision anti dump measur import femo origin prc interest parti submit comment write parti request grant opportun heard oral commiss continu seek verifi inform deem reach definit find parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti import femo origin prc definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit interest parti consid find modifi product concern product absenc argument product concern product provision find recit provision regul confirm dump gener methodolog number chines export produc argu time sampl decis stipul notic initi creat consider legal uncertainti regard applic deadlin submiss relev questionnair commiss lenient appli statutori deadlin fact standard notic initi appli proceed set applic deadlin time limit submiss requisit inform commiss provid parti concern addit clarif stage proceed address doubt question except flexibl accord export produc experienc difficulti submit requisit inform final fact commiss servic decid sampl mere consequ limit number cooper export produc number consid manag commiss servic base find inform duli provid cooper export produc alleg legal uncertainti case unfound event export produc neg affect decis sampl time decis commiss review treatment accord chines export compli deadlin submiss sampl questionnair appli market economi individu treatment compani treat cooper parti export transact includ cooper export dump calcul assess countrywid dump rate withdraw market economi individu treatment met recal provision stage export grant met export grant signific inform light mean individu duti rate longer justifi definit stage establish china chamber commerc minmet cccmc host meet shortli public provision regul set group chines femo produc call molybdenum molybdenum product coordin group china chamber commerc minmet chemic account china femo output agre appli price quantit restrict export femo commun group bring produc cooper proceed make attempt demonstr oper accord market economi principl state interfer chairman group emploi state own enterpris largest femo produc china cooper anti dump investig vice chairman drawn compani grant met provision stage investig produc concern grant specif export alloc determin take account level provision anti dump duti compani low duti level alloc disproportion high quota compani grant met lowest duti alloc export quota excess product capac entir quantiti group intend export commun group includ state aim avoid anti dump duti parti concern includ cooper compani relev chamber commerc inform commiss concern matter opportun respond find repli subsequ receiv parti except chamber commerc respons confirm establish associ femo produc claim unreason infer state interfer overturn met find base regulatori decis group number parti assert chines trade ministri moftec involv matter resolut group submit moftec approv arrang question incompat criterion free determin export price quantiti satisfi award maintain export constraint adopt auspic chamber commerc agreement state own compani strongli suggest signific state influenc risk circumvent duti pact clear deliber attempt channel export compani compani lower anti dump duti purpos avoid duti note arrang found exist earlier stage investig met grant compani concern whilst inform relat period subsequ ip account except circumst account develop effect render previou conclus manifestli unsound light inform conclud suffici evid exist render provision find invalid grant concern compani provision regul effect withdrawn compani henceforth subject countrywid margin china regard met grant cooper compani recal compani declar questionnair respons decis inter alia price output sale made respons market signal reflect suppli demand signific state interfer stress grant met line applic provis articl basic regul base clear evid produc oper market economi condit case compani align oper busi decis compani fail satisfi met criteria state own firm cooper proceed appear agre export product capac produc minimum price establish group contrari prior declar incompat main criteria grant met inter alia decis price output sale made respons market signal assess compani grant met commiss base conclus situat investig period ip criteria set articl basic regul compli period commiss assum compani oper futur suffici degre independ state market economi standard present case compani appear act market economi standard ip modifi behaviour receiv individu dump margin appar compani longer oper accord market economi principl accord articl basic regul subject extern interfer parti export constraint term price quantiti appear compani oper signific state interfer whilst inform relat period subsequ ip account except circumst account develop effect render previou conclus manifestli unsound light inform conclud met find compani longer stand individu duti longer compani met previous award nanj metalink revok henceforth subject countrywid margin china note event arrang found context investig relat fulli fledg market economi countri institut choic impos countri wide duti accord articl individu duti rate normal analogu countri number export produc alleg inform provid cooper compani provid reliabl basi determin normal question commiss find compani sale ip ordinari trade fact inform provid cooper compani fulli verifi commiss premis compani commiss satisfi accuraci reliabl data provid compani purpos proceed confirm normal continu base determin analogu countri export produc submit inappropri inform provid compani oper convert produc whilst request adjust account extraordinari cost relat convers process commiss reconsid appropri data convert calcul normal proceed import ensur data comprehens repres consid context respect conclud inform pertain convert includ relev calcul normal base reliabl repres data order address concern relev chines export produc decid exclud data relat convert question normal determin event effect chang methodolog minim export produc claim adjust account differ cost environment protect molybdenum loss note provision regul commiss servic consid merit claim respect note chines compani subject environment protect law standard whilst extent differ affect price compar clear demonstr matter view conjunct claim molybdenum loss likelihood signific impact price compar reduc claim molybdenum loss potenti higher china impli produc effici chines produc differ environment cost partli offset effici product process event absenc precis quantif alleg differ relat environment cost molybdenum loss commiss conclud effect price compar demonstr adjust warrant respect except exclus data convert explain methodolog determin normal set recit provision regul confirm export price export price calcul accord articl basic regul basi export price paid payabl product concern independ custom comparison methodolog set recit provision regul confirm export produc claim calcul conduct refer grade quot metal bulletin method provision regul refer exact content molybdenum consid accur take account varianc content compar normal analogu countri produc report relev data molybdenum content dump margin view met outlin cooper export produc receiv countrywid dump margin prc methodolog calcul margin set recit provision regul confirm countrywid dump margin prc establish basi commun industri absenc argument commun product definit commun industri provision find recit provision regul confirm injuri commun consumpt argu commun industri compos complain support compani inform commun oper account purpos injuri analysi note sale volum commun oper establish commun consumpt evalu econom indic pertain situat commun industri sale volum commun oper ad appar commun consumpt underestim view provision find commun consumpt recit provision regul confirm import origin prc volum market share import concern absenc argument volum market share import concern provision find recit provision regul confirm price import concern price evolut absenc inform price evolut provision find recit provision regul confirm ii price undercut interest parti question date invoic convert currenc export euro claim month time lag date invoic date import commun currenc convers basi exchang rate month invoic altern claim averag exchang rate entir ip prescrib basic regul context convers currenc calcul dump margin exchang rate date sale date sale invoic date date appropri establish materi term sale context inform provid show date custom clearanc provid term sale export commun industri currenc convers perform level date invoic irrespect date deliveri custom clearanc view consid convers euro provision stage adequ price comparison request reject export produc argu export price adjust differ level trade export produc sell trader commun industri sell end user note commun industri sale found made sale channel trader end user consist signific price differenti found exist sale channel request level trade adjust reject provision stage cif price export produc compar commun industri work level order fair comparison export produc request adjust made commun industri price cost relat rent warehous consid adjust made commun industri price wareh cost price export produc calcul includ cost post import cost ad export price recit provision regul request reject take account treatment addit export produc definit stage cooper parti withdraw met argument mention correct cleric error differ price express percentag commun industri weight averag price countri wide weight averag price undercut margin amount situat commun industri absenc inform affect find abovement factor provision find recit provision regul confirm conclus injuri provision regul conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri ip found ip volum dump import chines femo increas share commun market increas largest increas place ip volum import increas gain percentag point market share situat commun industri show mark period ip product sale market share profit improv commun industri advantag decreas sale volum market share commun oper ip coincid largest penetr chines import commun industri product decreas sale volum market share percentag point profit decreas ip increas commun consumpt volum sale commun industri decreas result loss market share cleric error occur sentenc recit provision regul read quot commun industri increas volum product sale period consid follow growth commun consumpt ip quot argu start point ip end point situat commun industri deterior argu find injuri base deterior situat commun industri part period consid ip purpos anti dump investig evalu effect dump import situat commun industri ip period exist dump examin respect period ip serv indic evolut situat commun industri determin situat ip classifi injuri end point end point analysi examin econom situat commun industri account event period consid provision regul conclud analysi situat commun industri made provision stage satisfi requir basic regul absenc inform situat commun industri account abovement find provision find injuri suffer commun industri recit provision regul confirm causat interest parti argu injuri suffer commun industri caus factor evolut price raw materi interest parti argu price commun industri move alongsid price raw materi evolut attribut chines import price investig show main raw materi product femo moo link moo femo price price movement moo automat correspond movement cost raw materi commun industri femo produc room set price transpar market femo user carefulli follow moo price order good posit negoti femo price note trend commun industri price period consid trend cost raw materi time import prc price commun industri period consid except commun industri price prevent increas rate increas total cost product ip respect note ip coincid signific penetr chines import commun market product capac utilis commun industri decreas consequ increas cost increas cost ip fulli reflect sale price led deterior profit level insuffici ensur long term viabil commun industri conclud evolut price raw materi materi contribut deterior situat commun industri contrari reason assum absenc dump chines export commun industri price level market share significantli higher view absenc inform provision find recit provision regul confirm ii lack access mo natur resourc commun industri argu injuri suffer commun industri attribut lack access mo natur resourc significantli hamper effici hand access chines femo produc mo resourc result alleg competit firstli note produc constitut commun industri upstream integr produc moo evid provid show alleg posit effect commun industri effici vertic integr note prc mo natur resourc output reduc inform provid interest parti prc import substanti volum molybdenum product mo concentr present situat contradict alleg chines competit advantag final ip import chines femo found made dump price signific quantiti coincid loss market share previous held commun industri view argu injuri suffer commun industri caus lack access mo natur resourc iii alleg problem commun industri intrins mo market argu examin causat provision regul flaw address impact busi cycl upstream industri copper industri downstream industri steel industri injuri suffer commun industri alleg injuri suffer commun industri intrins mo market evid provid support claim firstli note provision regul commiss examin impact evolut price raw materi product femo moo situat commun industri found contribut injuri suffer commun industri moo obtain mo concentr turn obtain product copper mine mine crude or thirdli downstream industri provision regul commiss examin evolut consumpt relat develop steel industri femo main user recal commun industri benefit growth market ip consumpt increas coincid upturn steel industri sale volum commun industri decreas view argu injuri suffer commun industri caus problem intrins mo market iv behaviour commun produc femo interest parti alleg injuri suffer commun industri due behaviour produc make commun industri commun oper alleg hold collect domin posit commun market combin market share inform provid behaviour produc commun market combin market share firstli note mere fact compani produc femo commun hold market share presum injuri suffer commun industri incident compos compani absenc indic prove injuri due collect posit econom strength enabl compani behav appreci extent independ competitor custom ultim consum compani produc femo commun posit market compani make commun industri primarili produc femo account sold user compani convert moo femo account parti import trader payment fee final commun industri evid found show injuri suffer ip attribut anti competit practic side conclud injuri suffer commun industri caus anti competit behaviour import countri argu injuri suffer commun industri caus import armenia iran note import countri reach ip market share armenia iran price level prc note contribut injuri suffer commun industri market share compar chines contribut remain margin break causal link import prc materi injuri suffer commun industri view absenc inform import countri provision find recit provision regul confirm vi conclus view confirm import concern isol caus materi injuri commun industri mean articl basic regul recit provision regul commun interest interest parti made alleg impact anti dump measur steel industri provid relev support evid absenc inform analysi commun interest aspect case provision find recit provision regul confirm definit anti dump measur injuri elimin level interest parti argu profit margin regard minimum industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump level profit obtain commun industri compar sector higher note calcul amount duti remov effect injuri dump consid measur commun industri cover cost obtain profit tax achiev commun industri normal condit competit absenc dump import case take account level profit obtain sale product type produc commun industri found profit margin turnov regard minimum commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump note argument find adjust claim context price undercut correct cleric error account injuri margin calcul absenc inform comment methodolog establish injuri elimin level recit provision regul confirm definit anti dump measur light forego consid definit anti dump duti impos level injuri margin found lower level dump margin found accord articl basic regul basi propos definit duti rate express percentag cif commun border price custom duti unpaid undertak disclosur provision find export produc express interest offer price undertak individu determin dump establish definit stage commiss servic accept individu undertak collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found light level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision anti dump duti impos provision regul definit collect rate duti definit impos adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import ferro molybdenum fall cn code origin peopl republ china rate definit anti dump duti applic net free commun frontier price duti product paragraph provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision anti dump duti impos provision commiss regul definit collect rate duti set articl rate provision duti lower amount secur excess definit rate anti dump duti releas articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel januari council presid piqué camp oj regul amend regul ec oj oj