commiss decis april state aid grant feder republ germani ilka mafa kältemaschinenbau gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite procedur letter date march germani inform commiss restructur aid privatis ilka mafa kältemaschinenbau gmbh ilka mafa sale carrier carrier withdrew privatis contract decemb decemb germani notifi restructur aid privatis ilka mafa purchas compani time gea ag letter date april germani provid commiss inform letter date august commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid ilka mafa commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid commiss receiv comment interest parti ilka mafa successor compani ilka mafa kältetechnik gmbh ilka ilka belong group compani gdr privatis efb verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg lintra beteiligungshold gmbh origin privatis concept fail decemb decid januari bundesanstalt für vereingungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv continu restructur potenti viabl lintra subsidiari aim prepar compani resal ilka receiv aid assess context notifi restructur aid case regist notifi aid aid paid ilka lintra beteiligungshold gmbh subject commiss decis ec aid efb verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg lintra beteiligungshold gmbh ii detail descript aid ilka mafa set end ilka prepar privatis evid privatis concept lintra beteiligungshold gmbh fail decemb onward ilka name dipa industri und vermögensverwaltungsgesellschaft dipa insolv proceed start dipa januari privatis contract conclud carrier carrier withdrew interest decemb bv start investor contact ten domest foreign manufactur refriger plant machineri gea ag compani interest take ilka mafa privatis agreement conclud septemb bv dipa gea ag takeov ilka mafa purchas price paid dipa dem ilka mafa locat döllnitz bei hall saxoni anhalt activ product distribut assembl instal mainten refriger system water cool chiller environment compat ammonia base refriger water cool chiller food chemic industri industri product air condit build sport facil investor restructur project gea ag manag hold compani gea group oper compani worldwid group total worker turnov eur billion restructur plan cost save synergi effect belong larg group joint purchas distribut group worldwid sale network save cost administr function sister compani grasso rt berlin compani focu futur core busi product assembl water cool chiller manufactur chiller size perform categori meet individu custom specif replac modernis invest provid joint amp activ step investor emploi averag full time worker year period start novemb activ compani carri decemb explain recit ilka mafa set decemb prepar privatis takeov carrier restructur period decemb decemb explain carrier withdrew interest late restructur period present investor gea ag began octob end decemb period end notifi restructur period ilka restructur process begun withdraw carrier continu privatis gea ag forecast restructur plan compani make slight profit dem turnov dem million profit forecast dem turnov dem million dem million turnov dem million restructur plan assess commiss decis initi procedur financ gt tabl gt addit financ shown tabl germani announc contribut dem million labour cost contribut made workforc ilka mafa waiv annual wage salari restructur decis open procedur commiss note share public financ dem million repres total cost investor contribut dem million repres total cost commiss doubt investor contribut restructur consid signific provid commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin addit commiss note dem million alloc investor restructur plan invest reorganis total dem million set sale offic scandinavia japan expand sale network south america ilka mafa sale oper parent group commiss doubt part aid link invest grant ilka mafa invest essenti restor viabil compani aid limit strictli commiss point result final decis case lintra beteiligungshold gmbh addit claim ilka aris ad cost present restructur plan exact amount establish time decis initi procedur made clear final decis addit liabil account assess proportion aid iii comment germani commiss doubt insuffici investor contribut germani explain calcul account fact restructur period present investor began octob restructur period start decemb total volum fund initi higher amount provid investor cost restructur assess sole basi period octob decemb contribut investor ilka mafa amount regard signific contribut restructur plan commiss doubt necess dem million invest earmark establish sale offic germani explain glare weak compani länder remain inadequ distribut structur globalis sector activ refriger air condit industri develop effici global distribut network cornerston compani long term success germani stress close cooper compani gea refriger divis ilka mafa free access develop distribut network mean expand network low cost amount dem million repres small part gea refriger divis total invest distribut organis ilka mafa contribut establish channel interest market product potenti addit liabil incur ilka framework present procedur germani refer opinion deliv case lintra beteiligungshold gmbh opinion relat lintra claim ilka amount dem claim settl asset remain liquid dipa iv assess aid articl ec treati aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market pursuant establish case law european court criterion trade affect met recipi firm carri econom activ involv trade member state commiss note notifi aid grant state resourc compani benefit reduct cost bear carri notifi restructur project recipi aid ilka mafa develop produc assembl chiller activ involv trade member state aid question fall scope articl ec treati notifi project concern restructur compani accord restructur plan submit investor commiss origin inform restructur march commiss note restructur aid firm difficulti assess pursuant guidelin rescu restructur mean articl treati contribut develop econom activ advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest condit laid guidelin met commiss note present guidelin enter forc octob point guidelin appli aid grant entri forc part aid notifi restructur notif grant date guidelin appli notifi restructur point guidelin typic symptom firm difficulti deterior profit increas size loss diminish turnov declin cash flow low net asset commiss note ilka ilka mafa loss make loss origin notif submit dem million present restructur plan submit dem million compani regard firm difficulti aid restructur assess guidelin guidelin newli creat firm elig rescu restructur aid initi financi posit insecur case firm emerg liquid takeov previou firm footnot guidelin state quot except rule case dealt bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben context privatis remit similar case länder involv compani emerg liquid asset occur decemb quot commiss note ilka mafa bv own compani situat länder set view futur privatis relev asset ilka deadlin decemb reason ilka mafa elig rescu restructur aid point guidelin restructur aid grant footnot guidelin state section appli case aid grant enterpris german democrat republ notifi decemb aid ilka mafa notifi deadlin laid guidelin compani grant restructur aid time guidelin aid proport restructur cost benefit section stipul aid limit strict minimum enabl restructur undertaken relat benefit anticip commun point view aid beneficiari make signific contribut restructur plan resourc aid financ invest essenti restor firm viabil decis open procedur commiss doubt investor contribut consid signific mean guidelin addit doubt aid link foreseen dem million invest distribut network essenti restor compani viabil germani commun origin restructur plan letter date juli relat point extens restructur period increas investor contribut delet sale network invest restructur plan period implement gea restructur plan extend germani explain financi result foreseen due book proce financi account subject cost year year consist month financi year need synchronis compani gea group target result turnov achiev virtual order begin year turnov target achiev oper result wors predict reason year delai develop semi hermet compressor propos save materi cost achiev financi situat expect improv oper result ask commiss explain reason delai foreseen origin restructur plan germani explain letter novemb delai occur technic reason foreseen origin plan time take ilka mafa investor gea fulli awar technic detail product rang takeov work group consist employe ilka mafa gea group set analys product manufactur conclud compressor ilka mafa technic outdat need replac order competit product conclud materi cost product high germani view unforeseen adapt reconstruct compressor decid replac product line end due technic problem replac delai year complet end septemb delai plan cost save achiev earlier product lower materi cost mean practic compani bear higher product cost year longer plan reflect financi result compani increas investor contribut germani explain investor make ilka mafa dem million credit line cover potenti liabil guarante claim client invest pc system network dem million higher forecast investor increas contribut invest amount increas investor contribut total dem million commiss note foreseen dm million invest sale network delet invest plan amount test stand chiller dem million expens forecast offic renov construct dem expens product equip dem expens storag logist cost dem revis restructur plan financ period sale gea group decemb septemb remain unchang total cost period dem million born state bv saxoni anhalt restructur aid gea group octob onward remain unchang dem million total amount public financ aid dem million origin plan increas aid revis restructur plan explain recit plan investor contribut increas dem million result higher direct invest contribut dem dem million credit line cover potenti guarante claim client financ revis plan break gt tabl gt workforc restructur contribut dem million commiss note amount includ restructur cost actual contribut cost contribut investor fund investor financi resourc ilka mafa doubt express open procedur amount investor contribut restructur commiss note increas total dm million revis restructur plan amount accord commiss previou practic eastern german restructur aid case consid signific contribut mean guidelin doubt invest sale network commiss note invest replac direct invest product facil ilka mafa reason doubt ilka mafa real beneficiari aid relat invest allai commiss note restructur period extend year germani explain due unforeseen replac addit product facil result technic difficulti essenti element restructur plan commun germani replac modernis product facil develop product decis open procedur commiss state doubt abil restructur plan restor long term viabil compani decis replac addit product facil depth examin ilka mafa product rang line origin restructur plan involv substanc introduct strategi measur provid origin plan carri addit replac product facil plan delai timet achiev oper profit inform provid delai caus technic difficulti affect oper result postpon date achiev profit restructur plan carri plan commiss consid extens restructur period account technic difficulti abil plan restor viabil compani unaffect guidelin restructur plan restor long term viabil compani reason timefram delai defer year moment compani achiev profit origin restructur period present investor year deadlin restor profit year delai reason timefram stipul guidelin accord quot time time quot condit laid point guidelin restructur aid grant restructur aid allow except unforese circumst compani respons extens origin restructur period lead present case increas aid contrari investor contribut increas degre signific mean guidelin commiss monitor implement revis restructur plan germani request provid annual report progress restructur report submit end march year relev inform enabl commiss check implement authoris restructur programm payment aid compani financi posit restructur plan examin accord point guidelin decis open procedur commiss reserv posit addit claim ilka result case lintra beteiligungshold gmbh commiss final decis ec case march letter date septemb germani inform commiss aid dem grant ilka mafa kältetechnik gmbh declar unlaw decis recov interest give total dem evid payment date septemb submit commiss unlaw aid paid back dipa industri und vermögensverwaltung gmbh liquid conclus germani unlawfulli grant aid amount eur million ilka mafa kältemaschinenbau gmbh breach articl treati aid compli commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti compat articl treati adopt decis articl state aid germani implement ilka mafa kältemaschinenbau gmbh amount eur dem compat common market mean articl ec treati articl germani provid annual report commiss progress restructur period report provid end march year relev inform commiss monitor implement authoris restructur plan receipt aid compani financi posit articl decis address feder republ germani brussel april commiss mario monti member commiss oj footnot separ hive vehicl auffanggesellschaft oj oj quot avalrahmen quot commiss decis ec case zemag oj inter alia commiss decis ec case chemienlagenbau stassfurt ag oj decis case nn hydraulik seehausen nn kab kraftwerk footnot ilka mafa kältemaschinenebau gmbh