council regul ec decemb impos definit anti dump duti collect definit provision duti impos import silicon origin russia council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun basic regul articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur provision measur commiss regul ec quot provision regul quot impos provision anti dump measur import silicon origin russia measur express ad valorem duti rang recal investig dump injuri cover period octob septemb quot investig period quot quot ip quot examin trend context investig injuri analysi cover period januari end ip quot period consider quot measur forc anti dump duti ad valorem rate forc import silicon origin peopl republ china quot china quot review measur pursuant articl basic regul ongo subsequ procedur imposit provision anti dump duti parti receiv disclosur fact consider provision regul base parti submit comment write interest parti request grant opportun heard commiss parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti definit collect amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit interest parti consid definit find chang commiss continu seek inform deem purpos definit find addit verif visit undertaken premis compani mention recit provision regul note imposit provision measur spot visit carri premis commun user ge bayer silicon leverkusen germani raffinera metal capra spa brescia itali vedani carlo metal spa milan itali product concern product product concern comment export produc recit provision regul product concern defin silicon classifi cn code export queri silica fume product silica obtain filter process product silicon cover present proceed note silica fume correspond definit product concern provid recit provision regul product product silicon take form powder addit concret confirm product cover cn code scope proceed definit product concern question russian export produc claim fact distinct type silicon cn code type destin metallurg user type chemic user support assert russian produc claim grade significantli chemic composit base trace element content end distinct set user compet signific interchang grade investig show silicon produc grade silicon sold eu market ip produc commun industri import russia contain silicon weight grade silicon determin place percentag silicon place element content iron calcium specialist user chemic user proport trace element determin silicon suitabl intend commonli specialist user silicon manufactur specif requir purchas lengthi verif process individu user whilst level trace element import chemic user suffici conclud separ product silicon consum metallurg user evid provid show high grade materi sold exclus chemic user chemic user purchas quantiti lower grade call metallurg silicon gener accept user lower qualiti requir secondari metallurg user higher grade silicon determin factor price pai premium silicon higher grade requir comment user number user question provision determin product concern submiss made similar receiv export produc metallurg user metallurg user argu distinct product type chemic split standard low grade silicon metallurg user accept grade product process prefer low grade silicon cost ground comment repeat metallurg user organis chemic user comment issu product concern confirm silicon purchas tailor made specif trace element silicon import factor comment commun industri commun industri agre provision determin grade silicon fall definit recit provision regul consid product concern point argument rais context product concern context product determin export produc confus issu conclus product concern silicon product manufactur grade depend firstli iron content calcium content thirdli trace element product process emploi eu russia electr arc furnac larg eu market essenti user group chemic user manufactur silicon metallurg user manufactur aluminium metallurg user subdivid primari aluminium produc secondari recycl aluminium produc silicon silicon weight typic silicon grade silicon identifi high grade standard grade low grade base percentag iron calcium silicon grade found overlap made user group gener accept physic chemic technic characterist prevent secondari aluminium produc grade silicon primari aluminium produc standard high grade silicon degre interchang opposit direct evid submit chemic user prepar standard low grade silicon cost grade determin grade user group investig shown mention type silicon differ term content chemic element basic physic chemic technic characterist whilst silicon end found substitut greater lesser degre grade find recit provision regul definit confirm product analysi found claim product control number pcn address recit provision regul concern price comparison silicon origin russia commun produc silicon correspond injuri elimin level differ price qualiti necessarili lead conclus product alik matter context product type question share basic physic chemic characterist basic aforement differ account comparison export price normal determin price undercut injuri elimin level russian export produc refer anti dump measur impos import silicon china recit refer recit council regul ec state quot qualiti silicon metal russia ukrain compar european chines silicon metal quot respons point point statement made investig date back year base inform submit investig confirm current investig addit recit regul deal issu causal clear word product concern product sourc china russia eu analogu countri norwai silicon silicon form product definit articl basic regul extent qualiti differ found silicon produc countri differ adequ consider mean adjust note qualiti differ type export russia commun base base find investig confirm silicon produc russia sold domest export commun silicon sold domest market analogu countri manufactur sold commun commun industri basic physic chemic characterist conclud type silicon form product famili consid product mean articl basic regul dump normal absenc comment recit market economi treatment provision regul confirm export produc made submiss argu cost electr provision stage amend emphasis main electr supplier major privat own compani low price explain presenc world largest complex hydro electr power station base natur compar advantag matter investig found electr price russia regul price charg electr supplier low compar supplier electr gener hydro electr power station analogu countri norwai canada decid reject claim confirm provision decis electr price charg electr supplier russia price found line lowest price repres electr produc found commun absenc comment recit determin normal provision regul confirm export price export produc argu compani involv sell product concern ec locat russia relat parti compani treat singl econom entiti compani locat russia claim export price price charg relat compani independ custom ec case import locat commun unit kingdom evid present demonstr relat export produc claim reject provision approach establish export price basi sale price import maintain case import switzerland spot verif visit carri imposit provision measur found compani relat export produc sale made import export price base price import unrel custom commun import locat british virgin island note articl basic regul export price quot price paid payabl sold export export countri commun quot word case export transact commun involv intermediari price ultim charg commun custom matter export produc price product quot leav quot export countri price substitut subsequ resal price parti relat rusal submit inform view prove relationship consid relationship demonstr conclus unambigu fact direct sharehold rusal compani british virgin island structur complex transpar compani link result indirect sharehold verifi document effect submit rusal compani british virgin island perform econom activ sale distribut export product letter box compani word sale parti british virgin island compani addresse unclear account purpos verifi true role compani locat british virgin island follow suffici certainti payment flow decid maintain provision approach establish export price basi sale price compani british virgin island comparison export produc claim adjust physic characterist base fact averag grade silicon sold russian market higher qualiti involv higher product cost compani fail present evid demonstr consist differ qualiti product type sold domest market export commun provision approach maintain adjust physic differ made compani repeat claim adjust quantiti level trade request adjust quantiti account compani demonstr discount rebat specif purchas quantiti differ quantiti account level trade adjust type custom grant provision stage respect request addit adjust level trade compani demonstr adjust made provision stage insuffici addit adjust grant dump margin absenc comment determin dump margin recit provision regul confirm definit dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border gt tabl gt injuri commun industri comment receiv definit commun industri content provision conclus recit provision regul confirm consumpt silicon commun absenc inform consumpt provision find recit provision regul confirm import silicon commun volum market share import absenc inform import silicon commun market share provision find recit provision regul confirm price undercut price depress undercut calcul revis reflect adjust level trade qualiti adjust establish basi verifi inform correspond reason estim market differ definit undercut margin show undercut exist level undercut light fact price depress price decreas significantli period consider extent cover commun industri full cost product ip econom situat commun industri russian export produc claim commun industri suffer materi injuri injuri indic show posit develop export produc point improv product capac capac utilis sale volum commun market share stock employ product period consider injuri indic outlin recit provision regul closer examin show main posit develop commun industri place ip indic rose slightli remain stagnant fell period materi injuri suffer commun industri appar note recit provision regul good perform commun industri directli attribut decis commun industri invest addit commun product facil period commun industri product product capac sale volum market share employ product increas profit set net sale subsequ mirror increas presenc low price dump import russia situat commun industri deterior market share cash flow invest return invest import decreas trend injuri indic decreas profit sale price suffer commun industri period consider led conclus commun industri suffer materi injuri conclus injuri reason absenc inform necessit revis find commun industri suffer materi injuri ip price profit argument rais russian export produc reject find conclus set recit provision regul confirm causat russian export produc argu find materi injuri confirm injuri caus russian import silicon number factor alleg true injuri suffer commun industri countri larger share import compar russia commun industri inflict injuri export perform commun industri import silicon commun industri differ market chemic metallurg silicon cite explan injuri suffer commun industri russian produc alleg differ price commun industri russian price ip larg differ show price competit silicon sourc commun market import countri outlin recit provision regul import number countri made higher volum russia except china import countri fell volum ip commun industri downturn econom situat price import case higher russian import undercut commun industri price price differenti limit russian export produc claim inform eurostat reli account differ product mix point import price differ predominantli lower qualiti silicon export russia higher qualiti silicon countri claim price paid user silicon sourc compar price produc adduc evid support claim due lack substanti data user price paid silicon countri price comparison made inform eurostat repres circumst sourc establish price silicon countri relat inform parallel expiri review china emerg averag undercut margin found price compar grade grade basi line margin found eurostat averag import price compar commun industri averag price note fair comparison import price eurostat data case russia verifi inform ip true price import slightli lower record eurostat inflict injuri claim injuri suffer commun industri primarili due increas cost incur product capac effort increas market share end claim commun industri highest averag cost product cop world claim base comparison verifi cost product commun industri russian produc proceed publish cost countri cost element includ publish figur identifi evid cop compar cop verifi investig typic appear publish figur base manufactur cost includ essenti cost element sg amp addit interest note russian produc provid publish data commun produc basi consid claim address argument rais russian export reject support approach found verifi cop analogu countri norwai higher provid russian produc adjust full cost verifi cop norwai found consist commun industri cost commun industri compar higher fact break link low price dump import injuri suffer commun industri outlin recit provision regul price fallen year ip commun industri made profit oppos actual loss export commun industri claim reduct export sale commun industri impact profit eu sale evid support claim submit total fall export sale ip repres commun industri sale ip impact price profit commun industri eu market minor natur assum reduct export partli due demand commun produc silicon ip import silicon commun industri russian produc queri conclus recit provision regul compani relat commun industri purchas silicon decis behalf influenc commun industri support point claim relat compani allow express opinion proceed prove compani control commun industri fact compani relat commun industri make comment oppos anti dump measur proceed free sourc raw materi base financi consider compani bui silicon commun industri russia sourc wish conclus recit provision regul confirm differ market chemic metallurg silicon alleg problem face commun industri onward due downturn demand chemic grade silicon caus downturn demand product user industri claim commun industri sell higher proport silicon chemic user metallurg user whilst opposit true russian export produc russian silicon compet commun produc silicon chemic market problem face commun industri attribut russian import tabl outlin trend price volum commun industri sale silicon chemic custom commun industri sale chemic custom gt tabl gt sourc commun industri tabl period consider sale silicon sold chemic user increas volum fell term averag price compar increas volum fall price sale silicon period consider tabl provision regul period ip injuri trend show downturn respect price profit sale chemic user fell thousand tonn averag price increas eur tonn sale compar figur show increas thousand tonn whilst averag price fell eur tonn reason injuri suffer commun industri caus downturn sale chemic custom fact natur injuri suffer revers true argument trend sale commun industri chemic custom real injuri suffer ip reject price competit price differ silicon produc commun silicon import russia confirm differ claim russian export averag ip recit provision regul differ exist commun industri price fall ip clear indic effect russian price commun industri claim price undercut larg injuri commun industri counter intuit investig show larg quantiti silicon sold commun industri russian export produc custom custom oper sector clear low level russian price lever user negoti price commun industri conclus causat light argument rais russian export produc reject find conclus set recit provision regul confirm commun interest provision determin imposit measur commun interest interest parti invit forward cooper proceed comment receiv user user associ cooper provision stage proceed addit user user associ cooper provision stage proceed made comment provision find import silicon made comment commun supplier raw materi russian produc submit comment provision stage comment made public provision regul concern differenti chemic metallurg silicon issu product concern product user submit comment impact measur cost profit provid inform assess made spot visit user found whilst user oppos measur increas cost gener agreement method emploi analysi measur impact user inform duti increas cost metallurg user order eur tonn finish product commun supplier raw materi accept imposit measur neg consequ turnov profit evid submit lead conclus impact outweigh expect benefit commun industri inform provid lead find imposit definit measur commun interest conclus reach recit provision regul definit confirm definit measur view conclus reach dump injuri causat commun interest consid definit anti dump measur impos order prevent injuri caus commun industri dump import russia injuri elimin level number claim made methodolog calcul injuri elimin level provision stage pcn tabl state recit provision regul claim product control number pcn tabl identifi type silicon includ suffici detail chemic composit type silicon make proper comparison grade silicon propos amend pcn tabl identifi type import russia compar sold commun industri compani claim extra grade includ cover silicon iron content whilst silicon high level iron command lower price market evid submit show clear market differ silicon iron price differ result iron content case address price adjust claim reject russian export produc request pcn tabl firstli request grade defin trace element main determin factor claim adjust silicon sold metallurg user unfairli compar silicon sold chemic user request silicon iron classifi low qualiti standard qualiti current pcn tabl accept request led accur pcn tabl result poorli defin criteria risk interest parti degre freedom alloc sale pcn freedom undermin reliabl inform provid pcn reliabl injuri elimin level evid indic maintain current pcn structur lead erron accur find undersel calcul base standard low qualiti silicon result margin chang reason claim reject claim evid support chang provid indic silicon iron standard grade user chang pcn tabl consid profit margin provision found profit margin total turnov regard minimum commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump claim margin high margin request margin born fact profit line profit achiev commun industri fair market condit prevail commun market level dump margin found volum import russia commun industri achiev profit level ip qualiti adjust russian produc claim silicon produc plant lower qualiti produc plant due differ product process claim lower qualiti silicon adjust fair comparison price commun industri adjust claim differ averag cost product plant accept qualiti differ plant adjust merit demonstr differ impact price achiev market case eu comparison made grade grade basi consist differ sale price achiev plant high qualiti silicon sale made silicon lower qualiti plant adjust standard grade clear price differ observ adjust made sale qualiti relev plant low qualiti silicon price differ found adjust warrant russian produc claim silicon low qualiti directli compar price low qualiti silicon produc commun industri accept iron level higher silicon produc produc compar produc commun industri russian produc order calcul qualiti effect price achiev produc eu market comparison made averag price achiev russian produc grade grade basi result comparison show adjust price low qualiti silicon russian produc grant compar price low qualiti silicon produc commun industri level trade adjust russian produc claim price adjust level trade eu sale found russian produc sold silicon trader british virgin island produc sold relat trader switzerland unrel trader eu directli end user commun industri sold silicon directli end user order determin level trade adjust warrant sale grade produc sale channel analys consist price differenti result analysi level trade adjust grant sale unrel trader form level definit duti accord articl basic regul definit anti dump measur impos level dump injuri margin found whichev lower measur provision measur form ad valorem duti definit collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found export produc russia light level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision anti dump duti impos provision regul commiss regul ec definit collect extent amount definit duti impos definit duti higher provision duti amount secur level provision duti definit collect claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest sale export sale chang chang product sale entiti regul amend updat list compani benefit individu duti undertak subsequ imposit provision measur disclosur definit find export produc russia offer price undertak accord articl basic regul export produc concern produc type product sold rais potenti risk cross compens undertak price formal respect price product concern lower sold product concern render commit respect minimum price silicon easi circumv difficult monitor effect reason set conclud undertak offer subsequ disclosur definit find accept current form interest parti inform defici undertak offer disclos detail export concern adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import silicon silicon content weight fall cn code origin russia rate definit anti dump duti applic product produc compani name origin russia gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl amount secur provision anti dump duti pursuant commiss regul ec import silicon silicon content weight fall cn code origin russia definit collect accord rule set amount secur excess definit rate anti dump duti releas definit duti higher provision duti amount secur level provision duti definit collect articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel decemb council presid matteoli oj regul amend council regul ec oj oj council regul ec decemb impos definit anti dump duti import metal origin peopl republ china oj oj