commiss decis juli state aid grant franc scott paper sa kimberli clark notifi document number french text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof notic parti concern submit comment accord articl regard comment procedur public french cour de compt court auditor novemb special public report entitl quot local author assist firm quot commiss receiv letter date decemb complaint preferenti term vill orléan quot citi council quot conseil général du loiret quot counti council quot refer quot local author quot sold ha la saussay industri estat unit state compani scott paper manufactur household sanitari paper letter date januari commiss request inform french author letter date februari french author request extens dai commiss grant march letter date march french author suppli inform request inform complet commiss renew request letter date march french author repli part letter date april letter request extens dai commiss grant june commiss receiv supplementari inform request august ask french author clarifi matter remind septemb octob french author provid addit inform novemb commun complain novemb letter date decemb complain provid inform commiss servic repli januari addit inform complain reach commiss januari april commiss decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect measur view doubt circumst french author act regard scott paper compat measur treati letter date juli sg commiss inform french author decis letter date juli french author request extens month commiss grant august letter date septemb request extens dai grant septemb letter date novemb french author repli initi procedur commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment measur question commiss receiv comment subject interest parti comment translat french parti request letter date februari withdraw request confidenti comment french author letter date march french author parti submit comment aspect need clarif case close letter march commiss request detail inform letter date march french author request extens dai commiss grant letter march french author repli part commiss request letter april consider delai repli inadequ french author order commiss juli provid inform decis notifi french author letter date juli sg requir submit observ work dai date notif decis august letter date august french author ask deadlin extend work dai extens commiss grant august octob french author repli part order suppli inform request french author meet commiss servic held decemb meet commiss servic exception allow french author interest proceed provid addit inform end decemb inform final forward januari februari detail descript aid aid beneficiari scott paper compani purchas french firm bouton brochard subsequ found separ compani bouton brochard scott bouton brochard busi bouton brochard scott chang scott sa novemb scott sa share bought kimberli clark corpor kc januari own household sanitari paper product plant orléan sologn industri estat municip saint cyr en val loiret peopl emploi plant kc announc closur januari plant asset site paper mill bought procter amp gambl amp june sale land enabl bouton brochard scott scott build household paper factori french subsidiari scott paper compani counti council citi council commiss société economi mixt pour equip du loiret quot sempel quot septemb carri studi work develop hectar land quot la saussay quot industri estat quot la planch quot sector la saussay industri estat end citi council sold hectar concern sempel symbol franc land agricultur land time bought citi council frf eur total price frf million eur million sempel local semi public compani subject privat law govern law juli compani cover legisl legal person govern privat law link local author region depart municip associ privat person possibl public person order carri develop construct work industri commerci servic activ public interest control public person case local author hold half capit subject ceil govern rule privat law law juli trade compani articl sempel agreement sempel commiss carri work land intend scott propos facil quot survei prepar preliminari plan road miscellan network work suppli water ga electr site subject agreement park space lorri light vehicl rail link site subject agreement light road park space green area format level receiv factori warehous superstructur structur built contract develop scott paper compani tall primari secondari tertiari infrastructur facil situat estat develop directli connect extern network develop work requir make land suitabl alloc quot time scott agreement conclud citi council loiret undertook financ site prepar cost quot maximum frf million quot amount divid quot part frf million orléan citi council frf million loiret loiret quot clear statement final account drawn sempel improv la saussay industri estat date juli sempel statement final account citi council minut total cost develop site consider higher sempel statement final account frf million eur million broken gt tabl gt point citi council minut total cost oper loiret approxim frf million eur million citi council approxim frf million eur million frf million eur million redempt loan frf million eur million grant sempel frf million eur million purchas land frf million eur million land improv oper carri sempel sold ha ha scott price frf eur total price frf million eur million price laid sempel agreement point quot price sell factori warehous support land scott paper compani frf million inclus tax quot remain ha sold back orléan municip author symbol price franc sempel wound la saussay industri estat cover hectar firm establish emploi staff preferenti rate water treatment levi water treatment levi express frf charg quantiti water consum firm orléan citi council calcul base levi accord interministeri circular decemb circular explain calcul base number metr effluent coeffici coeffici degress pollut coeffici user consumpt year amount levi freeli decid citi council delib assembl januari quantiti water exceed threshold articl municip code code de commun stipul quot number cubic metr record serv basi water treatment levi adjust upward reflect special cost impos water board result level type pollut caus firm quot quot coeffici degress quot fix orléan citi council articl scott agreement preferenti rate water treatment levi scott quot orléan citi council undertak chang rate water treatment levi applic industri user except situat lai rate exce favour current rate subject scott complianc current technic standard legisl orléan citi council appli preferenti rate quot januari orléan citi council set amount water treatment levi coeffici degress volum coeffici degress reduc proport volum coeffici increas citi council minut aim encourag larg scale consum water reduc effluent consumpt exceed coeffici reduc reason coeffici degress shown tabl gt tabl gt scott consumpt compani elig coeffici respect substanti part consumpt part exceed french author scott entiti qualifi coeffici hôpital de la sourc water consumpt approxim coeffici appli part excess ground initi procedur commiss publish commun state aid element sale land build public author commun clarifi polici emerg period year describ procedur sale land build automat exclud state aid element sale uncondit bid procedur basi asset valuat independ expert prior negoti order determin market list type sale notifi commiss uncondit bid procedur valuat independ expert place case commiss view decis initi procedur price land sold justifi provid cover land relat cost incur author excess suppli similar site bring price ii correspond market price basi inform time commiss found establish certainti price land sold scott cover cost incur french author ii correspond market price wonder rate water treatment levi element state aid ground order suppli inform french author satisfactori repli question rais decis initi procedur commiss order provid inform request question virtual ident set commiss letter french author date march commiss regard french repli inadequ inform suppli detail descript evid public sale franc europ detail breakdown type work carri sempel land occupi scott level electr infrastructur construct actual cost breakdown fund aris loan contract sempel copi tripartit agreement orléan citi council loiret counti council sempel sale contract conclud includ sale price agre orléan citi council firm bought plot remain ha explan decre march provid legal basi reduct water treatment levi basi quantiti consum stipul levi adjust level pollut caus firm invoic particular firm region qualifi qualifi reduct water treatment levi offer scott paper lastli light comment receiv parti decis initi procedur commiss requir french author provid copi agreement conclud scott paper orléan citi council loiret counti council copi joint guarante agreement orléan citi council loan contract sempel agreement citi council counti council comment parti concern complain beneficiari firm scott capac parti comment initi procedur comment complain letter octob complain confirm support main commiss posit set decis initi procedur complain stress recit clarifi link local author sempel scott paper recit respect contribut author loiret addit complain comment recit term sale saint cyr en val site amp kc locat loiret clarifi link local author sempel scott paper obscur link local author sempel complain request clarif sempel fund aris loan contract draw commiss attent fact sempel dissolv administr order shortli expiri tripartit agreement orléan citi council loiret counti council sempel septemb relat period object quot carri survei work need develop site la saussay industri estat quot respect complain point administr order sempel march orléan commerci court note audit report compani date januari found quot deficit frf million quot complain invit commiss french local author concern submit tripartit agreement sempel loiret counti council orléan citi council work carri sempel benefit scott paper saint cyr en val site complain maintain loan contract sempel realiti explain hidden financ exclus benefit scott paper number work financ undistort competit arrang scott paper complain journal de gien septemb reveal local author polici onward scott paper locat loiret quot orléan put flag reveal factor year negoti made win dai author reveal resourc deploi hook unit state giant frf million quot complain add articl show bulk aid grant local author develop land scott paper site carri infrastructur work exclus benefit scott paper quot case author includ packag public servic need make la saussay estat meet expect scott paper benefit sale free charg sempel ha land quot complain press articl state quot sempel respons work carri provis servic miscellan develop work construct factori warehous total bill frf million share counti council frf million orléan citi council frf million februari author recov stake bouton brochard scott subsidiari scott paper bui build frf million measur constitut instal author make financi contribut quot complain conclud inform confirm view set french court auditor report novemb quot round urban plan rule author hesit hide purpos aid collect alloc case facil loiret elig region plan grant agreement conclud firm stipul aid relat land develop larg case aid greater cost develop land financ illeg build work case aid intens high declar cost real estat invest project quot complain argu propos loiret author financ infrastructur decis scott paper choic locat saint cyr en val accept quot competit quot offer french local author juli quot nouvel républiqu quot note scott paper hesit decid locat franc quot result scott paper dossier make slowli govern doubt open nation market foreign giant municip willing host unit state firm rivalri scott paper obtain locat term quot quot municip orléan elimin rival avail warehous south sen caught scott paper attent quot quot challeng orléan find argument save time commit put build month appar satisfactori time frame enabl scott paper oper end period unit state multin initi aim confin warehous process chain suppli paper belgian italian factori antwerp turin quot respect contribut author loiret contribut author note januari le canard enchaîné mention agreement scott paper local author quot orléan citi council loiret counti council hope recov stake contract sign scott penni back compani fail meet oblig hope brussel quot term sale saint cyr en val site procter amp gambl kimberli clark decis locat loiret earli kc scott paper sold saint cyr en val site amp la républiqu du centr septemb state amp acquir saint cyr en val site belong scott paper advantag term note site question bought quot price frf million worth frf million quot octob bare month announc closur kc factori saint cyr en val daili quot le echo quot report compani set plant loiret final complain stress commiss verifi inform provid french author access quot tripartit agreement conclud sempel local author septemb quot quot agreement conclud initi scott paper local author quot comment presum beneficiari aid letter novemb scott comment initi procedur regard purchas price orléan site recit grant scott concessionari rate water treatment levi recit repay aid scott recit purchas price orléan site price paid scott market price order expand market share franc scott announc june set plant franc medium term expect invest usd million time scott suppli franc plant itali belgium scott compani began site franc meet locat account transport cost size allow futur expans infrastructur skill labour suffici suppli water energi respons announc region firm inform site financi condit locat scott state consult extens market effort budget quot find quot scott quot respond quot scott announc interest set franc succeed month scott carefulli investig larg number site final shortlist site march la saussay scott explain definit decis time understood local author franc offer site compani respect scott stress market price simpli buyer seller mutual agre accept price assess made determin market price privat sector owner develop sologn busi park handl case condit investor sold site scott remark time local author scan market industri investor bui site invest oper number compani limit time market price reflect fact demand firm exceed suppli enhanc negoti power price paid scott frf million eur million price prepar pai site question light extens research carri preced month net cost acquir compet site ii analysi total invest readi make fact easili continu suppli french market commun french plant loss make year scott claim fact compani attract firm busi park purchas price direct receipt gener activ time repaid cost incur local author continu benefit sourc revenu connect scott refer commiss decis daimler benz assert show busi rate form local tax includ local author revenu determin paid proper price price differ site sold scott adjoin site scott point differ size site ha site thousand squar meter reflect sale price obtain point sale adjoin site place year sale site scott price site influenc larg number factor includ increas land area scott arriv site sold extens market campaign scott believ market promot initi undertaken local author behalf recherch développ intern rdi meet requir quot suffici publicis quot understood absenc clarif guidanc commiss scott believ standard commun reli commiss publish receiv aid case retrospect applic principl commun scott accept commun appli sale public land place commiss claim appli polici develop ten year institut state need clarifi public commun ten year number decis adopt sale land public author scott consid legal instrument commun commiss appear reli quot soft law quot bind legal effect legal basi aid grant scott notifi scott franc advis compani aid descript alloc local author grant indirect aid law law commiss scott claim law formal notifi commiss commiss receiv copi oblig act expediti compil file carri preliminari investig fail law implement franc ground exist aid measur accord principl lorenz grant scott preferenti rate water treatment levi lastli alleg preferenti rate water treatment levi scott understand rate appli custom quantiti water firm institut pai rate scott simpli pai rate provid law firm categori repay aid scott scott maintain accord decis court justic beneficiari aid grant unlawfulli invok except circumst result legitim assum aid law reason aid grant unlawfulli repaid case advantag scott oper plant neutralis amp bui site plant combin market scott retain advantag incompat aid book site plant time sale amp total cost asset scott asset sold amp half book transpar manner commiss dealt law notifi franc aid grant french local region author made imposs firm obtain inform statu enact commun law perspect comment french author french author repli commiss decis initi articl procedur request inform letter date novemb april octob januari februari summaris french author scott receiv aid reason market industri site rural area time sale land recit commiss find market land sold market price recit land suffici publicis mean commun recit commiss think sale land constitut aid cost deduct recit preferenti rate water treatment levi recit limit period recit statu kc case recit market industri site rural area time sale land market industri site rural area french author privat develop orléan area carri type work lack market industri land made difficult set market price mean commun french author claim order creat market stimul develop local economi local author prepar land sell firm point firm establish estat scott attract compani conclud size busi park market type land land sold market price commiss conclud market land fact sold market price reason differ price land sold scott remain land due economi scale sempel sold ha scott frf million eur million frf eur remain ha sold back citi council ha sold firm averag price frf eur sell plot size ha scott citi council achiev economi scale frf justifi sell price approxim frf eur frf eur transact summaris tabl gt tabl gt purchas price cover expens sale site scott amp show seller privat own paper sector necessarili cover expens complet basi written cost scott kc sold orléan factori amp transact conclud normal market condit total cost scott kc factori sold written cost net factori factori sold amp belong partli scott partli kc asset scott sold amp land bought sempel build land includ sempel sell price build scott built paid total cost scott sold amp frf million eur million paid sempel paid build time sale written cost asset scott receiv amp asset sold compani scott made loss compar purchas cost slight profit compar written commun decis initi procedur commiss scott receiv aid frf million eur million frf million eur million add sum price scott effect paid asset sold amp cost loss scott made sale amp acquisit cost undepreci basi loss depreci basi loss acquisit cost undepreci basi loss depreci basi loss french author experi scott kc gain orléan site taught expert valuat treat consider caution valuat fulfil market galtier firm consult valu asset belong scott kc sold amp scott kc give total french author conclud expert valuat result figur lower written cost asset compani manag obtain price valuat scott kc found buyer prepar pai accept loss sale asset amp compar galtier expert valuat compar written cost asset function actual market price french author claim market land question frf million eur million reason scott sold amp bought sempel frf million eur million increas time price land scott appli commiss time concept invers land build sold amp order calcul current aid grant past averag interest rate market scott sold amp land build bought sempel land suffici publicis mean commun public franc commun sale french author point scott paper set plant difficult todai produc evid public organis time french author emphasis find potenti investor quot publish quot press notic announc piec land search involv identifi target firm locat europ franc perman substanti scale approach firm directli indirectli consult specialis intermediari present region select initi contact firm react tender discuss final move search conduct basi site case negoti potenti investor conclud quickli rule site propos potenti investor industri estat plan prepar rough draft made local author disinclin invest heavili site prepar search succe present case french author claim counti council citi council made substanti commit year market set agenc econom develop loiret adel inter alia busi invest consult unit state america rdi promot locat busi citi includ orléan sologn site french consult dml associé recruit counti council conduct campaign vi vi european european potenti investor locat pari area french author market activ focus initi state michigan form stand industri exhibit alert unit state compani invest opportun loiret detroit septemb search investor wish loiret orléan meet orléan local develop agenc repres agenc michigan hannov specif invit offici fifteen dai visit unit state organis citi loiret local develop agenc import contact maintain unit state local chamber commerc lawyer offic account french compani bank develop agenc datar director town countri plan rural action activ rdi succeed identifi number unit state compani symplex saturn icb initi interest invest loiret orléan adel produc busi atla entitl quot orléan environ busi peopl quot orléan adel role chamber commerc industri order find buyer special set hire find potenti investor part programm adel contact local chamber commerc industri french author provid letter dml consult scott date decemb describ potenti investor identifi site loiret letter dml specialis assist restructur compani industri group assist local author region develop agenc identifi industri investor letter dml explain work method identifi activ region concern attract compani sector target zone identifi potenti interest consult meet compani determin requir level invest envisag adel examin site region identifi meet potenti investor requir present investor select visit lastli adel present technic econom studi enabl investor decid project viabl region select site propos present case dml write quot work adel began juli initi identifi compani contact south pari region month compani contact result interest want inform loiret want contact month dml contact remain compani determin interest identifi lead follow project identifi quot dml identif potenti investor achiev place advertis press wait compani repli directli contact manag firm dml explain quot dml method oper predic awar potenti investor found substanti preparatori work carri person contact establish assist provid long period persuad potenti investor choos region concern site final decis place establish locat investor job compani hire local develop agenc direct potenti investor region concern site choic site determin technic financi requir investor quot dml conclud state quot lastli confirm dml involv plai part identif locat scott paper invest project orléan quot french author commiss clarifi polici initi regard meet condit commun bid procedur quot suffici publicis quot interpret time repli commiss posit circumst scott sale fall scope commun advertis carri behalf public author suffici specif site french author emphasis commiss appli commun flexibl decis freseniu case french author claim freseniu condit laid commun met count commun authoris land sold valuat price purchas found reason period freseniu case land sold valuat price commun land sold reason period price valu valuat carri order determin realist market valuat freseniu case french author conclud freseniu show commiss appli strictli inflex criterion establish year commun approach adopt scott case event place year freseniu decis adopt result clear procedur local author appli order sell undevelop piec land commiss find sale land constitut aid cost deduct total cost project citi council sum deduct frf million eur million frf million frf million amortis loan frf million eur million nomin loan includ calcul cost frf million eur million repres cost public intercept sewer serv scott commun inhabit firm social overhead capit built wast water treat discharg directli river environment pressur time lead local author facil decis undoubtedli speed scott locat area base frf million eur million refund vat site improv oper gener point note cost relat ha land ha sold scott french author point accord commiss decis daimler benz quot payment local tax purchas site account price paid site quot seventeenth report competit polici specif note expens incur land baden württemberg ratstatt author clear site ii connect public servic water suppli regard constitut aid purchas pai local tax clear report cost specif incur benefit daimler benz meet decemb commiss adopt posit payment local tax account determin price paid purchas site posit practic commiss scott bought site orléan citi council end daimler benz case occur show preferenti rate water treatment levi french author maintain rate water treatment levi appli scott part gener measur constitut select advantag mean articl ec treati hôpital de la sourc subject rate scott french author claim refer citi council minut quot preferenti rate water treatment levi quot link inclus financi statement develop la saussay estat receipt lost result meet decemb degress rate levi base level water consumpt introduc locat scott paper undoubtedli catalyst decis gener measur benefit benefit plant meet requir french author taxpay water consumpt qualifi coeffici degress calcul water treatment levi account consumpt orléan citi council want part encourag larg scale consum limit effluent increas coeffici enter minut reflect water treatment cost rational appli case taxpay consumpt volum water consum make cover relat water treatment cost incent effect rais coeffici degress levi consumpt high reduct enter minut limit period french author draw commiss attent fact scott move loiret back request inform commiss date french author note procedur regul limit period ten year hope case point virtual complet expiri period account commiss time complain acquaint commiss fact show loss suffer competit exist statu kimberli clark case french author kc expect repai aid reason kc receiv aid franc aid grant paid scott year kc acquir interest compani dilig shown kc regard scott time acquisit accord normal commerci legal practic extend back reveal grant aid scott scott account date initi public year kc acquir scott show compani receiv assist whatsoev sourc franc kc discov scott receiv aid franc scan relev local nation press minut meet local author contact compet author author told kc aid paid scott case circumst assess aid measur assess aid measur light order provid inform commiss order french author provid inform inform inadequ inform point detail breakdown work carri sempel land occupi scott type oper level electr infrastructur build actual cost breakdown fund aris loan contract sempel sale contract conclud includ sell price agre orléan citi council firm bought plot remain ha commiss point respect letter june french author expressli state quot prepar send commiss document request agreement local author sempel sale contract firm document case privat quot invoic detail relat firm region elig quot discount quot water treatment levi grant scott paper rule pleuger quot member state notwithstand commiss order fail provid inform request commiss empow termin procedur make decis basi inform question aid compat common market quot power commiss decis basi inform member state fail compli inform injunct subsequ enshrin articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl articl ec treati procedur regul state aid hereinaft quot procedur regul quot result commiss base assess inform calcul aid measur market price compar plot preferenti rate water treatment levi legal basi preferenti price land scott maintain preferenti price land grant indirect aid law doubt law commiss compani add refer case spain commiss law offici notifi commiss receiv copi oblig act expediti composit file preliminari examin fail law implement franc ground accord principl laid lorenz exist aid posit reject reason firstli french author invok law legal basi measur question comment parti includ scott french author refer law correspond commiss local author cite agreement conclud scott made gener statement quot agreement conclud accord statutori provis rule govern power local author quot refer law citi council minut suppos measur concern grant law case law constitut exist aid mean lorenz judgment scott claim lorenz judgment effect articl treati commiss notifi member state plan grant aid fail initi contenti procedur state expir period month grant propos aid provid prior notic commiss aid system exist aid quot lorenz rule quot case point french author submit commiss law notifi scott claim aid offici notifi maintain quot franc advis scott law commiss quot french author scott provid commiss written evid law fact event contrari scott posit lorenz rule appli measur offici notifi point respect accord practic determin articl procedur regul commiss inform member state concern delai receipt notif receiv inform french author recontact commiss verifi receiv notif quotat cite scott aid measur offici notifi commiss oblig act expediti compil file preliminari investig fail measur govern rule lorenz context firstli quotat opinion advoc gener van gerven court justic judgment statement made footnot comment time limit commiss investig aid discov complaint made interest undertak advoc gener van gerven underlin quot unnotifi aid concern principl case commiss complet investig month period commiss duti act expediti compil file carri preliminari investig quot mean commiss investig case pursuant complaint officio act expediti mean impli fail notif lorenz rule appli case point respect complaint lodg decemb commiss compil present file carri preliminari investig lead decis initi depth investig lastli lorenz rule french author scott claim french author prior notic commiss implement law notic aid measur system appli exist aid pursuant lorenz rule thirdli commiss treat decre base articl law exist aid prior notif articl constitut exist aid time measur grant articl law approv interim plan januari state quot local author associ region purpos action creat expand econom activ grant direct indirect aid firm condit direct aid form region busi start grant region employ grant interest rate subsidi loan advanc favour rate averag yield bond direct aid grant region condit laid decre conseil etat decre determin rule ceil zone essenti implement nation region plan polici compat franc intern commit form direct aid supplement loiret municip associ assist region reach ceil laid decre mention preced paragraph indirect aid grant local author associ region sever jointli local author associ region sell leas build market term discount term grant abat cost renov industri build accord rule ceil zone laid decre mention paragraph indirect aid uncondit local author associ region determin natur amount guarante requir firm receiv aid manag addit agricultur measur industri charact local author associ region agreement conclud central govern lai procedur aid agre law implement nation law quot accord articl law french legal comment french nation law appear distinguish type aid direct aid measur term laid decre conseil etat direct aid assist region elig indirect aid measur relat firm real estat type indirect aid rule ceil zone laid decre assist region appli lastli quot indirect aid quot requir supplementari implement measur quot uncondit quot type ii indirect aid independ region assist decre lai procedur implement direct aid notifi legal basi french scheme region plan grant commiss decis eec octob french region plan grant scheme decre cite articl law legal basi articl law notifi directli commiss decre lai procedur implement type indirect aid real estat aid cite articl law legal basi decre notifi commiss consid scheme constitut exist aid case point measur concern build factori warehous develop site regard indirect aid mean articl law note respect distinct direct indirect aid recognis commun law classif measur concern intend determin measur regard come law measur cost build factori warehous regard constitut type indirect aid purpos french law measur implement procedur laid decre assist area elig irrespect fact commiss time build factori warehous consid decre constitut exist aid measur case decre loiret assist area articl decre quot addit aid grant preced articl zone list annex abovement decre decre order promot creation expans econom activ local author associ region sever jointli grant discount price properti sell leas firm sale build leas market quot annex decre list area qualifi industri project annex ii decre loiret elig grant cost build factori warehous cover decre measur regard aid french author notifi commiss articl ec treati measur site develop regard type ii indirect aid purpos french law measur base directli articl law point respect legal basi requir supplementari implement procedur appli region mention recit articl law notifi infer articl constitut exist aid simpli fact commiss approv french scheme region develop grant base decre refer turn articl notifi claim articl constitut exist aid simpli commiss consid decre base articl exist aid measur regard aid french author notifi commiss pursuant articl preferenti rate water treatment levi basi water treatment levi calcul accord interministeri circular decemb amount water treatment levi freeli decid delib assembl citi council januari coeffici degress base articl municip code code de commun legal base notifi commiss requir articl ec treati aid mean articl preferenti price land question aris price land scott charg preferenti price caught prohibit articl treati articl aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market preferenti price land caught prohibit articl satisfi test grant state state resourc favour undertak product good distort competit undertak favour similar undertak type product product concern trade commun grant state state resourc test grant measur state state resourc concern advantag grant directli public author indirectli bodi strictli speak part structur state scenario concept state understood broadest sens compris organ central author decentralis local author level scenario public privat bodi respons grant state aid import thing aid question chargeabl state criterion chargeabl intend determin bodi question act autonom conduct contrari dictat state supervisori power control influenc regard criterion part make check aid fact financ directli indirectli state resourc case sempel sold land question scott preferenti price question aris preferenti price chargeabl state local author quot state quot broadest sens financ preferenti price regard chargeabl local author reason firstli agreement conclud scott local author clear articl agreement local author sempel carri land improv end citi council sold land develop sempel sum franc sempel undertak control local author govern privat law local author hold half capit limit law juli compani fall legisl legal person privat law link local author region depart municip associ privat person possibl public person order carri develop construct oper provid industri commerci public servic carri activ public interest thirdli lastli price land factori warehous fix local author establish document articl agreement scott local author set price sale scott factori warehous land built frf million point sempel agreement set price preferenti price regard financ local author point sempel agreement project financ local author payment annual instal respect loan contract sempel purpos clear sempel behaviour regard dictat local author control influenc regard compani preferenti price financ local author test articl satisfi favour scott commiss commun state aid element sale land build public author test aid favour undertak product good commiss consid sale land select advantag purpos articl land sold market end commiss publish commun sale land question present case back year commun publish principl appli commun clarifi polici time emerg period ten year born mind time sale case law subject limit commun describ sale procedur automat exclud element state aid sale uncondit bid procedur basi asset valuat independ expert prior sale negoti order establish market transact notifi commiss case point valuat land made time sale scott question aris manner plot sold met criteria sale uncondit bid procedur french author argu commiss clarifi polici appoint consult franc unit state promot region recit regard satisfi criterion bid procedur quot suffici publicis quot mean commun understood time scott take line recit argument accept commun offer quot suffici publicis quot repeatedli advertis long period month nation press estat gazett public intend sale land build high announc public intern circul real estat agent address broad rang potenti buyer notic potenti buyer expect advertis carri time sale compli letter commun basic principl state decid case observ word tender industri site factori warehous wide dissemin nation intern press estat agent commiss emphasis respect mean advertis sale land suffici combin requir potenti buyer inform tender point outset principl deriv freseniu case mention french author applic case land question valu present case commun letter freseniu event place commun publish requir present case basic principl laid commun regard sale uncondit bid procedur observ independ expert carri valuat discrep price consid consist market condit french author gave long descript advertis measur suppos adel rdi recit order provid inform explicitli call detail descript evid advertis sale franc europ french author produc document support argument entitl quot orléan businessman environ quot orléan environn pour homm affair describ loiret head french govern develop free enterpris system ii polit risk union activ loiret iii infrastructur iv industri network orlean econom polici document mention creation la saussay busi park fact site factor warehous sale document regard meet criteria quot suffici publicis quot tender mean intend commiss establish practic consolid commun document letter dml consult scott date decemb letter describ method identifi potenti investor site loiret recit examin method meet criteria quot suffici publicis quot tender mean commun end letter dml explicitli confirm involv scott locat region quot lastli confirm dml involv plai part identif locat scott paper invest project orléan quot descript letter irrelev author compet give opinion land factori warehous sold scott quot suffici publicis quot sold firm descript advertis measur adel rdi recit evid produc commiss point plot land advertis nation intern press requir commun condit express recit condit concern real estat agent address broad rang potenti buyer effort rdi consult direct unit state market state michigan recit content dml associé recruit loiret quot make approach european european potenti investor pari region quot total odd dml statement involv scott locat site question commiss lack inform publicis document entitl quot orléan businessman environ quot market activ local author intend promot loiret gener site factori warehous criteria laid commun met advertis site improv build factori warehous site factori warehous sold accord commiss establish practic consolid commun open uncondit bid procedur compar auction carri definit market state aid case point clear agreement conclud scott local author oper quot made measur quot order meet scott desiderata articl agreement question state improv land carri accord scott specif process plant warehous cover built clear market measur local author regard meet criteria sale uncondit bid procedur mean intend commiss establish practic consolid commun sale procedur appli sale land question rule sale element state aid scott principl privat investor commiss consid sale land constitut select advantag purpos articl privat investor basi forecast potenti profit ignor social region sector polici consider invest land sold plot price ask local author contrast posit defend french author commiss assess design determin case point public author behav lender act normal econom condit account import local author promot develop local economi tax receipt account purpos clear commiss decis ec conclus contradict commiss decis daimler benz contrari french author claim recit clear decis commiss conclud propos price sale site contain aid element daimler benz acquir unsuit agricultur land market price type land region firm bear cost improv land daimler benz decis commiss consid connect cost drain electr water constitut aid firm contribut local tax connect expenditur gener infrastructur fund budget central govern local author gener measur provid infrastructur built sole firm contrari french author maintain decis connect expenditur incur specif benefit daimler benz longer gener natur demolit cost mention daimler benz decis commiss conclud measur constitut aid expenditur landown incur order sell piec land accord reason daimler benz decis commiss exclud cost public interceptor sewer valuat aid case french author shown sewer intend exclus scott serv commun recit argument french author time sale land market industri site rural area reject absolut clear comment submit scott capac parti la saussay industri estat direct competit initi site subsequ shortlist recit point respect project commiss consid object bona fide reason expect adequ rate return moment invest decis treat state aid clear agreement conclud local author scott articl time sale knew land improv oper construct factori warehous cost frf million eur million scott pai frf million eur million plot quot enabl scott set project implement stage local author undertak improv land la saussay la planch industri estat built ceil frf million initi stage improv estim frf million understood scott build condit refer articl factori process plant warehous cover bought sempel frf million quot includ cost land frf million eur million local author knew conclud contract scott loss frf million eur million recit doubt provis public fund explain grant state aid altern local author sell plot lose frf million eur million origin invest rememb connect privat investor aim maximis profit limit loss french author maintain land sold scott market price view differ price scott paid ha frf eur averag price frf eur citi council obtain remain ha justifi economi scale commiss share view firstli order provid inform french author refus account price paid remain land provid copi sale contract contract commiss check correct price claim rememb time sale remain prepar land situat local author time sale scott cost prepar land sunk cost privat investor easili maintain sell ha sell argument appli local author situat decis invest frf million eur million land improv awar price scott pai frf million eur million forget initi cost land frf million eur million french author object recit price cover cost market price point instanc price kc sold la saussay industri estat factori amp enabl meet cost price consid market price add recit market land factori warehous question frf million eur million scott sold amp bought sempel frf million eur million result discount purchas site frf million eur million check correct french author figur cost born kc la saussay estat price obtain amp estat recit reason refut argument market price cover total cost commiss emphasis situat face kc differ significantli face local author kc invest site question cost regard sunk cost amp purchas site kc decid close part world wide restructur suggest oper site question involv heavi loss kc household sanitari paper sector europ suffer overcapac franc boom recit price paid amp site price kc obtain loss make paper mill market suffer overcapac amount invest question kc invest la saussay estat invest made contrast local author found situat invest made initi purchas land question frf million eur million explain recit local author decid prepar land build factori warehous knew invest result loss frf million eur million privat oper ahead invest reason appli french author argument market price scott paid frf million eur million amp paid discount irrespect correct price french author suppli evid establish sum relat land site scott bought price paid site amp commiss refer condit market determin purchas price paid amp compar obtain confirm fact scott readi increas capac franc lastli commiss reject argument simpl discount oper consist reduct market indic market price establish object bona fide reason local author expect invest transform agricultur land industri site build factori warehous sell plot scott give adequ rate return price paid scott site preferenti price local author sold site question scott regard constitut advantag firm advantag problem present case establish certainti cost sale land question cost cover order provid inform french author suppli commiss request detail breakdown work sempel site level electr infrastructur build real cost work method financ commiss restrict assess inform detail inform commiss unabl determin scott claim part infrastructur count infrastructur provid central govern local author budget constitut aid infrastructur caught articl work carri benefit firm type product case point prepar site regard benefit scott firm owner sole user infrastructur provid factori warehous concern built scott specif clear document entitl quot statement final account la saussay la planch industri estat quot date juli detail document provid french author total cost sempel land improv oper approxim frf million eur million ad cost origin land frf million eur million amount subtract frf million eur million financi cost loan contract sempel frf million eur million refund vat land improv oper frf million eur million cost public intercept sewer french author show intend sole scott serv commun inhabit firm recit cost land sale frf million eur million cost transact relat directli scott frf million eur million frf million eur million figur frf million eur million sempel receiv scott net loss approxim frf million eur million present frf million eur million absenc breakdown work carri sempel land occupi scott level electr infrastructur build indic actual cost inform french author request provid order commiss thought reason fraction take account economi scale present includ applic interest rate date unlaw aid grant date scott agreement sign repay refer rate commiss measur aid element public subsidi franc januari distort competit affect trade member state measur caught articl ec distort competit affect trade member state phillip morri court justic defin criterion quot state financi aid strengthen posit undertak compar undertak compet intra commun trade regard affect aid quot product question trade member state aid strengthen beneficiari posit vi vi competitor present case scott manufactur paper product sanitari appar consumpt toilet hygien articl commun thousand tonn net export thousand tonn commun product thousand tonn relev product trade commun wide basi conclus support fact factori establish la saussay estat loiret scott suppli franc plant itali belgium recit product sanitari paper la saussay factori intend french market export aid distort competit affect trade member state scott compet product come member state situat aris overcapac sector question panorama commun industri sector concern dynam commun industri decad output grew year fact scott bui site preferenti price strengthen posit vi vi competitor aid question intend scott locat loiret increas share french market recit reduc cost invest scott gave compani competit advantag manufactur make plan make similar invest expens french author claim time complain acquaint commiss fact show loss suffer competit exist recit argument reject firstli strengthen scott posit preferenti price grant compani purchas site assess light posit competitor gener complain fact complaint lodg decemb prove loss suffer competit exist commiss point complaint lodg decemb report french court auditor discuss alleg aid measur publish novemb recit clear preferenti price land affect competit commun sum preferenti price land satisfi test articl ec treati grant state state resourc favour scott distort competit scott similar firm type product sanitari household paper trade commun aid caught prohibit articl preferenti rate water treatment levi preferenti price land question aris preferenti rate water treatment levi grant scott constitut preferenti price caught prohibit articl ec treati commiss point articl aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market preferenti rate water treatment levi caught articl satisfi test grant state state resourc favour undertak product good distort competit undertak favour similar undertak type product product concern trade commun grant state state resourc point concept state compris organ central author decentralis local author level recit preferenti rate water treatment levi grant citi council stage stage citi council explicitli undertook articl scott agreement appli preferenti rate water treatment levi scott recit stage citi council pursuant agreement adopt decemb decis levi rate preferenti rate water treatment levi regard grant state test articl satisfi favour scott state charact aid accord articl select favour undertak product good affect balanc exist beneficiari firm competitor select charact distinguish state aid gener econom assist measur applic firm sector member state economi kimberli clark court justic held bodi grant aid enjoi degre latitud enabl adjust financi assist regard number consider choic beneficiari amount financi assist condit provid system liabl place undertak favour situat meet condit classif aid mean articl examin case detail light limit inform provid order suppli inform commiss consid set coeffici degress level consumpt exceed regard constitut select advantag favour scott paper justifi commerci ground gener tax polici consider reason citi council explicitli undertook grant scott preferenti rate water treatment levi articl scott agreement conclud firm local author august lai quot orléan citi council undertak alter rate water treatment levi applic industri user special circumst provid rate exce favour current rate subject scott complianc technic standard legisl forc orléan citi council appli preferenti rate compani quot pursuant agreement citi council adopt decemb decis rate water treatment levi consist amount levi coeffici degress recit coeffici degress reduc volum justifi form quantiti discount citi council minut coeffici increas volum encourag larg scale consum water reduc effluent citi council decis decemb coeffici volum exceed set justif letter januari french author justifi rate quot volum consum make cover cost water treatment quot order suppli inform french author quot justif quot consist simpli sentenc commiss judg claim slightest basi justif french author work event begin directli contradict object reduc effluent reason coeffici applic volum exceed paper industri consum larg quantiti water liquid effluent bleach requir extens process discharg environ logic larg quantiti water gener higher receipt suffici reason reduc rate levi characterist paper industri quantiti creat pollut addit set threshold preferenti rate water intens industri paper firm scott paper qualifi order commiss suppli inter alia water bill particular firm region qualifi quot discount quot levi french author singl bill hôpital de la sourc hospit water consumpt approxim qualifi coeffici respect part consumpt exceed total consumpt year scott water consumpt firm qualifi preferenti rate respect substanti part total consumpt commiss consid fact period preferenti rate forc present dai french author show year hospit qualifi rate respect total consumpt scott paper qualifi respect substanti part light factual inform recit depriv measur select charact set coeffici degress volum exceed de facto basic benefit scott citi council scott favour situat consid constitut select advantag mean articl lastli advantag calcul multipli factor differenti quot reason quot coeffici degress consumpt level exceed preferenti rate scott annual effluent coeffici annual pollut coeffici scott annual offtak calcul year result obtain ad commiss unabl determin advantag order suppli inform french author send inform calcul quot reason quot coeffici degress consumpt exceed french author determin connect proceed recoveri aid show coeffici reason produc evid rate applic firm compar level consumpt effluent establish french depart irrespect outcom coeffici degress preferenti rate quantiti water consum french author determin advantag part recoveri proceed establish court instanc ladbrok held quot case law provis commun law requir commiss determin sum reimburs demand repay aid declar incompat common market quot distort competit affect trade member state commiss point recit advantag distort competit affect trade member state relev product trade member state aid strengthen posit beneficiari vi vi competitor condit relev product trade member state commiss refer assess recit appli preferenti rate water treatment levi condit preferenti rate water treatment levi strengthen scott posit vi vi competitor reduc cost scott bear normal busi clear preferenti rate water treatment levi affect competit commun sum preferenti rate water treatment levi satisfi test articl ec treati grant state state resourc ii favour scott iii distort competit scott similar firm type product sanitari household paper trade commun aid caught prohibit articl compat aid articl treati list type aid consid compat common market compat determin refer commun refer member state region thereof individu ensur common market function principl establish articl treati except list articl interpret strictli examin aid scheme individu aid measur except reli demonstr aid market forc suffici induc beneficiari act enabl object mention except achiev aid measur question qualifi except articl social aid grant consum aid design attract investor citi relat natur disast except occurr divis germani except provid articl aid question intend promot execut import project common european interest fact produc household sanitari paper locat citi common european interest aid intend remedi disturb economi franc characterist project except articl appli measur intend promot cultur heritag conserv articl except articl concern aid facilit develop econom activ clear measur examin meant promot small medium size firm research develop environment protect job creation train accord commun guidelin framework state aid complet assess aid question possibl compat region except provid treati distinct drawn invest aid preferenti price land oper aid preferenti rate water treatment levi preferenti price land preferenti price land regard ad hoc invest aid aim reduc cost scott locat orléan sologn recit aid grant framework approv invest aid scheme recit irrespect ad hoc aid regard contribut develop loiret note orléan sologn situat area recognis fall articl aid regard compat common market region invest aid recit aid grant scott form preferenti land price qualifi except articl declar unlaw incompat common market preferenti rate water treatment levi commiss point recit preferenti rate water treatment levi constitut oper aid intend reduc cost scott bear normal busi absenc compensatori effect oper aid grant except temporari basi offset oper loss articl area justifi contribut region develop natur amount aid proport handicap intend allevi except provid articl appli loiret recognis area abnorm low standard live underemploy aid grant scott form preferenti rate water treatment levi qualifi except articl declar unlaw incompat common market recoveri illeg incompat aid preferenti price land conclud sum frf million eur million present frf million eur million net loss made local author sale la saussay site includ factori warehous scott declar unlaw incompat common market aid grant unlawfulli found incompat common market articl ec treati requir commiss request member state recov beneficiari court justic confirm occas practic establish articl procedur regul commiss decid member state concern measur recov aid beneficiari rational recov unlaw incompat state aid effect competit restor limit period articl procedur regul power commiss recov aid subject limit period ten year begin dai unlaw aid grant beneficiari action commiss regard unlaw aid interrupt limit period case point aid form preferenti price land grant august scott agreement sign scott local author measur commiss complaint decemb date januari form formal request inform made french author limit period interrupt year provid expir commiss power recov aid question scott argu limit period design protect beneficiari aid interrupt beneficiari inform investig commiss conduct scott maintain learn investig conduct public decis initi procedur septemb date year scott conclud agreement local author commiss longer power recov aid argument reject purpos limit period ensur legal certainti addresse commiss decis member state wider commun includ beneficiari aid benefit legal certainti question ultim benefit limit period separ matter period calcul determin articl procedur regul articl refer parti confin relat commiss member state confer specif beneficiari lai oblig commiss regard parti beneficiari aid mention determin date limit period start run quot dai unlaw aid award beneficiari quot articl derog normal procedur conduct exclus member state concern commiss procedur right acknowledg parti procedur right deriv articl ec treati commiss point beneficiari aid check aid grant notifi aid notifi approv legal certainti commiss bound oblig provid inform intend protect beneficiari aid situat subject protect except circumst scott claim beneficiari unlawfulli grant aid reli except circumst led suppos aid law scott reason unlawfulli grant aid repaid case neutralis amp bui site factori combin market advantag scott receiv oper factori competit advantag deriv grant aid longer affect competit distort competit correct repai aid land factori sold amp book total cost scott asset sold amp half book scott retain benefit incompat aid transpar manner commiss dealt law notifi franc aid grant french local region author made imposs firm obtain inform statu enact commun law perspect argument accept argument irrelev commiss point accord establish case law lack residu benefit final purchas year aid grant immateri econom activ origin target firm subsequ absorb case scott continu uninterrupt long unlaw aid recov distort competit continu distort attribut legal entiti remain scott longer oper paper sector respect commiss point unlik acquisit scott kc amp acquir asset la saussay site aid recov scott amp fact ownership scott chang aid grant irrelev agreement commiss refer reason recit french author kc reli legitim expect duti repai aid dilig exercis kc regard scott time acquisit reveal aid grant scott kc discov aid scan local nation press minut local author meet contact compet author recit argument accept commiss consid case point scott beneficiari repai aid receiv commiss point firm receiv aid principl legitim expect aid law grant accord procedur laid articl dilig econom oper ensur procedur kc establish bui share scott check procedur compli stage french author show kc alleg legitim expect attribut act commiss scott receiv aid kc bought scott ask commiss claim ask commiss aid notifi approv fact kc dilig reveal state aid problem compani bought scott legitim reason requir recoveri aid respect commiss stress import firm interest acquir firm show due dilig regard state aid issu kc detect state aid compon preferenti price land commiss point advantag confer local author scott deriv agreement conclud compani recit scott copi agreement commiss conclud argument put forward scott french author give reason proce recoveri incompat aid preferenti rate water treatment levi likewis advantag confer form preferenti rate water treatment levi french author determin recoveri proceed recit declar unlaw incompat common market commiss point recit aid grant unlawfulli found incompat common market articl procedur regul requir institut request member state concern recov aid beneficiari question limit period interrupt aris preferenti rate water treatment levi concern measur appli continu year introduc continu applic preferenti rate water treatment levi argument put forward scott appli scott kc benefit advantag commiss conclud argument put forward scott french author give reason proce recoveri incompat aid conclus view consider object bona fide ground local author expect invest transform agricultur land industri estat build factori warehous sell plot scott give rate return price paid scott site set coeffici degress level consumpt exceed scott de facto princip beneficiari advantag justifi commerci gener tax polici ground commiss find breach articl ec treati franc unlawfulli grant scott aid ad hoc preferenti price frf million eur million present frf million eur million ha industri site la saussay industri estat preferenti rate water treatment levi consumpt water exceed pursuant articl local author code determin french author proceed recoveri aid aid refer regard incompat common market order establish econom condit compani contend grant incompat aid french author step elimin advantag deriv aid recov beneficiari aid recov accord procedur french law includ interest accru date grant date repaid calcul refer rate determin net grant equival region aid franc adopt decis articl state aid form preferenti land price preferenti rate water treatment levi grant franc scott amount case land price frf million eur million present frf million eur million case advantag french author calcul method work commiss incompat common market articl franc measur recov beneficiari aid refer articl made unlawfulli recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date made beneficiari date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl franc inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address french republ brussel juli commiss mario monti member commiss oj quot le intervent de collectivité territorial en faveur de entrepris quot cour de compt pari novemb oj comment scott novemb point comment scott novemb point preambl agreement august conclud bouton brochard scott sa orléan citi council loiret counti council quot scott agreement quot preambl agreement improv la saussay la planch site septemb conclud loiret counti council orléan citi council sempel quot sempel agreement quot extract minut meet orléan citi council fridai quot citi council minut quot articl sempel agreement citi council minut letter date march french author inform commiss land bought citi council frf point citi council minut initi land frf million frf letter french author april articl scott agreement point citi council minut sempel statement final account prepar loiret counti council orléan citi council la saussay la planch industri estat juli point citi council minut letter french author june letter novemb section scott claim purchas orléan site march point citi council minut letter french author april letter french author novemb letter french author octob idem extract minut orléan citi council meet decemb quot citi council minut quot decre march citi council minut state quot ensur initi budget water treatment balanc increas current rate rais frf frf quot citi council minut citi council minut state quot encourag water intens busi reduc effluent decid citi council decemb increas coeffici degress proport excess quot busi secret kimberli clark water treatment bill busi secret hospit water treatment bill oj detail oj commiss point respect letter june french author expressli state quot quot prepar send commiss document request agreement local author sempel sale contract firm case privat scott paper local author overwhelmingli favour scott paper job wrap la nouvel républiqu juli le canard enchaîné januari toilet paper absorb frf subsidi employe quot procter amp gambl scott paper cloud saint cyr site quot le echo kimberli clark locat loiret octob seventeenth report competit polici point case spain commiss ecr case lorenz ecr letter french author novemb pp letter french author april letter french author octob pp letter french author novemb letter french author april letter french author februari pp letter april french author give explan differ price paid scott paid investor estat quot size plot sale larg plot reduc landown financi carri cost compar hypothet situat involv sale smaller plot cost servic site consider case sempel develop ha appreci estat scott move land sold scott sale place quot letter french author februari pp letter french author februari letter octob letter januari letter januari letter french author novemb letter french author octob letter januari letter french author novemb letter french author octob letter french author januari idem letter french author februari annex letter french author novemb letter french author april letter french author octob letter french author januari letter french author januari pp notic nn term land purchas agreement citi council friedberg hessen freseniu ag oj letter french author januari letter french author novemb letter french author april letter french author octob letter french author januari footnot letter french author novemb letter french author april letter french author octob letter french author januari letter french author octob letter french author januari letter french author octob letter french author januari join case pleuger ecr point oj footnot footnot articl scott agreement footnot letter scott novemb case spain commiss ecr decre septemb aid purchas leas build grant local author associ region offici journal french republ septemb decre articl law repeal law februari case piaggio ecr point offici journal french republ januari action économiqu de collectivité local ministri interior local author depart pari report ministri interior droit administratif encadr juridiqu de aid de collectivité territorial aux entrepris supplement la semain juridiqu januari articl la semain juridiqu le intervent de collectivité territorial en faveur de entrepris special public report french court auditor pari novemb report french court auditor decre land plan grant hereinaft decre offici journal french republ report french court auditor report ministri interior report french court auditor articl la semain juridiqu report ministri interior report french court auditor articl la semain juridiqu report ministri interior state quot indirect aid aid industri build uncondit subject specif rule fall scope scheme notifi notifi commiss make gener action affect econom environ region concern caught articl quot oj contrari state commiss decis eec decemb aid grant creation industri enterpris modan savoi oj quot local author provid assist modan articl order septemb approv commiss time pat region develop premium quot decre notifi commiss letter french author octob citi council minut decre march case intermil ecr case germani commiss ecr case commiss franc ecr join case van der kooi case itali commiss ecr case van tiggel ecr join case sloman neptun ecr articl state quot local author specialist compani sempel société economi mixt pour equip du loiret local author major sharehold carri improv defin park space road miscellan network site develop accord scott specif process plant warehous site ha quot point agreement develop la saussay la planch site state quot citi council undertak sell sempel site develop accord attach plan refer sum frf franc quot letter french author april articl agreement state quot initi develop work estim frf million understood scott build condit refer articl factori process plant warehous bought sempel frf million quot point agreement state quot price sale factori warehous site stand scott paper compani frf million inclus tax quot point agreement quot local author undertak give financi assist sempel form amount frf million inclus tax case loiret counti council frf million case orléan citi council quot sum paid annual amount local author sempel ensur payment annual instal loan requir perform oper contract sempel ceil frf million accord respect liabil footnot commun ii principl sale uncondit bid procedur point definit term quot suffici publicis quot letter french author januari annex articl agreement scott local author state quot local author specialist compani sempel société economi mixt pour équipement du loiret local author major sharehold carri improv defin park space road miscellan network site improv accord scott specif process plant warehous site ha quot principl establish court justic case belgium commiss boch ecr commiss decis juli state aid citi mainz grant grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft fort malakoff mainz mbh amp kg oj point iv quot assess present case state act line normal market investor behaviour futur possibl tax receipt account case state sell properti term condit line normal behaviour privat investor posit state respons public interest collect tax quot footnot seventeenth report competit polici state quot contrari initi plan daimler benz ag acquir agricultur land unsuit industri compani bear site prepar cost estim dm million ecu million quot decis state section assess firm bear site prepar cost decis state section assess owner site land local author bear normal cost demolit accord usual practic land sold commiss commun member state oj point extract tribun desfossé januari quot kimberli close door quot quot factori occupi worker dai liber end yesterdai overproduct household paper franc huge loss accumul factori open frf million made decis appar inevit quot extract le mond januari quot part worldwid restructur kimberli clark close orléan factori quot quot market grow slowli year excess capac increas stand tonn europ quot extract le figaro januari quot part worldwid restructur kimberli clark close orléan factori quot quot closur site part global restructur household paper giant handkerchief toilet paper kitchen towel franc kimberlei victim stagnant household paper market year excess capac tonn year cumul loss frf billion ten year quot extract courrier val de loir sologn januari quot chairman loiret counti council eric doligé react announc propos closur kimberli clark site saint cyr en val quot quot develop justifi group ground excess product capac franc quot footnot pleuger paragraph rule consolid articl procedur regul commiss decis nn state aid develop site occupi kimberli clark industri toul villei saint etienn meurth mosel commun publish oj point sempel agreement refer quot format level receiv factori warehous superstructur structur built contract develop scott paper compani quot present calcul take year websit http europa eu int comm dg aid tauxref htm case philip morri commiss ecr point scott paper compani annual report panorama commun industri section case franc commiss ecr point idem footnot footnot case franc commiss kimberli clark ecr point footnot rule consolid articl procedur regul case ladbrok race commiss ecr ii point footnot case commiss germani ecr case deufil commiss ecr case commiss germani bug alutechnik ecr procedur regul recit procedur regul recit case commiss germani bug alutechnik ecr point case land rheinland pfalz alcan ecr point case itali commiss alfa romeo finmeccanica ecr case commiss germani bug alutechnik ecr point commiss letter member state sg march case belgium commiss ecr rule consolid articl procedur regul