commiss decis juli state aid itali plan grant fiat auto spa mirafiori carrozzeria plant notifi document number italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof invit interest parti submit comment accord abovement provis procedur octob decemb itali notifi commiss pursuant articl treati propos grant state aid fiat auto spa regist octob concern invest fiat mirafiori carrozzeria automobil assembl plant mirafiori turin request inform number remind italian author elicit data requir commiss decis april meet held repres italian author clarifi aspect examin case partial repli question rais commiss suppli italian author letter novemb commiss inform itali decis februari initi procedur provid articl treati respect propos aid measur allow itali month suppli document inform data requir assess compat aid common market absenc repli commiss reach decis basi inform possess decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun interest parti invit commiss submit comment comment receiv repres commiss mirafiori februari discuss matter mirafiori carrozzeria plan april italian author request extens deadlin repli april letter commiss inform consid complet examin case examin mirafiori carrozzeria case serv strengthen commiss initi doubt plan aid commiss inform itali decis widen procedur initi februari allow italian author month suppli document inform data requir assess compat aid common market absenc repli commiss reach decis basi inform possess decis widen procedur publish offici journal european commun interest parti invit commiss submit comment comment receiv ii detail descript aid ground initi articl procedur aid notifi grant fiat auto spa subsidiari fiat spa fiat group oper automobil sector compani fiat auto car iveco industri vehicl magneti marelli part fiat plant itali poland turkei south america sold million vehicl alfa romeo ferrari fiat lancia maserati make itali rest europ rest world notifi invest total itl billion eur million mirafiori turin march area mirafiori design assist area articl treati maximum aid intens forc time net grant equival nge larg firm mirafiori carrozzeria produc car start project made uno thema croma panda punto car complet invest produc punto model marea multipla vehicl notifi project origin concern improv manag organis plant produc car marea model multipla urban locat plant impos major product logist constraint invest intend improv work condit save energi improv environment protect lastli invest safeguard number job area suffer industri declin scheme provid law decemb approv region aid grant total itl billion eur million present discount aid intens assess italian author decid alter term notif repli novemb question commiss novemb state intens region aid obviat cost benefit analysi propos aid authoris aid innov invest provid descript innov invest total itl billion nomin present itl billion broken subproject multipla marea letter quantifi innov defin quot complementari margin quot provis made aid total itl billion discount intens gross grant equival scheme provid law decemb approv letter italian author novemb state invest project mobil view financi advantag possibl extens reduc capac mirafiori concentr larg proport invest bielsko biala poland part project relat multipla turin factori rivalta mirafiori equival cost februari commiss decid initi proceed articl ec treati inform possess incomplet number doubt compat aid emerg examin case commiss assess innov natur process notifi question fix refer date examin alleg innov practic consequ fix date ii calcul aid intens subproject regard innov iii aid intens consider exceed maximum rate authoris commiss case invest aid innov purpos fiat auto incur suffici degre risk justifi aid intens emerg mirafiori carrozzeria assist area march project start preced feasibl locat studi carri decis invest mirafiori priori latest plant locat assist area commiss decis widen procedur express doubt investor decid financ project question account prospect obtain region aid aid view need carri invest question mirafiori decis initi proceed supplementari decis commiss formal requir itali suppli month inform requir assess compat measur question commiss adopt decis basi data possess iii comment itali april italian author request extens deadlin order prepar repli decis februari april letter commiss addit inform examin mirafiori carrozzeria case italian govern stress failur studi carri commiss reflect econom realiti decis plant locat mobil perform cost benefit analysi comment made context specif case mirafiori carrozzeria includ fiat case refer assembl plant concern itali note fiat drawn coher invest programm period scenario carri invest concern give prefer italian plant polish plant maximis transfer product tichi bielsko biala diagram attach letter april illustr capac alloc plant scenario consider analys carri fiat show set plant poland produc fiat alfa romeo segment vehicl profit option final chosen fiat limit polish product segment vehicl slightli higher invest higher profit chiefli result reduc labour cost lower transport cost outlet market lower compon cost market local fiat supplier organis expand italian author point fiat achiev workforc reduct reloc product poland staff turnov decid replac worker due retir shape ag pyramid plant belong group hand fall employ area itali industri declin south countri neg consequ fiat region aid initi plan suffici offset addit cost entail decis carri invest itali undoubtedli factor final decis italian govern believ cassino mirafiori carrozzeria pomigliano rivalta project mobil regard mirafiori carrozzeria project mobil evid gener explan italian author ad context strong ti rivalta mirafiori plant creat highli integr complex italian refer quot rivalta mirafiori area quot real choic face fiat marea alloc car dai mirafiori car dai rivalta alloc car dai mirafiori equival car dai bielsko biala detail suppli mobil punto model multipla law aid grant case concern singl horizont aid programm requir grant applic separ invit tender determin project elig aid concern separ locat fiat submit separ applic aid case notifi commiss separ difficulti examin case due fact project notifi separ occas octob decemb commiss appli set guidelin aid motor vehicl industri set requir compar site cost benefit analysi locat assist region commun refer site locat eea countri central eastern europ artifici distinct reflect econom realiti invest overlook interdepend product plant result synergi italian author consid extrem difficult appli cost benefit analysi method separ requir commiss consist integr natur invest programm result financi calcul cost benefit analys examin commiss letter april provid detail data basi cost benefit analys carri mirafiori carrozzeria rivalta cassino pomigliano plant comparison bielsko biala context optimum alloc product itali poland specif cost mirafiori carrozzeria poland project compar basi mobil hypothesi explain invest worth total itl billion carri timet gt tabl gt thirdli italian author state invest question subdivid categori innov invest amount nomin itl billion ii technolog invest elig region aid amount nomin itl billion innov invest compris subcategori aid intens vari degre innov gt tabl gt italian govern note refer date assess innov natur quot variabl section quot quot multipla quot project invest question began time project carri europ car manufactur assist compon supplier emarc regard technolog invest itali point propos region aid intens addit innov invest aid region ceil unnecessari draw cost benefit analysi notifi aid gt tabl gt fourthli itali gener point specif term implement law retroact condit elig invest repli commiss decis extend investig juli itali letter give detail inform main aspect event lead adopt aid scheme link implement aid question complianc formal criteria applic aid iv assess aid measur notifi italian author fiat auto constitut state aid mean articl treati financ state state resourc constitut signific proport financ project aid liabl distort competit commun give fiat auto edg competitor receiv aid lastli extens trade member state motor vehicl market aid question grant approv scheme provid law intend compani engag manufactur assembl motor vehicl aid propos examin relev commun framework state aid motor vehicl industri italian govern notifi case octob notif regist commiss octob relev framework publish offici journal european commun confirm framework enter forc januari state case notifi novemb declar compat commiss subject proceed articl treati initi date examin basi preced framework enter forc januari year itali challeng assess procedur commiss note aid grant approv scheme cost project exce eur million italian author compli notif requir commiss deplor consider delai sign novemb ministeri decre provid aid question date offici notifi end octob articl treati specifi type aid compat treati view natur purpos aid geograph locat invest articl applic articl specifi form aid regard compat common market compat treati assess standpoint commun pure domest context order maintain proper function common market regard principl articl treati except articl constru narrowli regard except articl clear aid question intend project common european interest remedi disturb italian economi promot cultur heritag conserv except articl subparagraph relev mirafiori locat area assist articl articl determin propos region aid measur compat common market exempt provid articl treati commiss check complianc condit commun framework state aid motor vehicl industri commiss check aid grant proport graviti problem design resolv execut project complianc proportion necess criteria essenti commiss authoris state aid motor vehicl sector gener context analys region aid project innov invest aid region aid proportion region aid assess mean cost benefit analysi present case commiss limit assess necess test initi procedur commiss note event led authoris italian scheme law keep decis novemb septemb april commiss acknowledg circumst surround adopt law explain long delai launch project start mass product vehicl concern applic aid notif octob examin necess aid site project mirafiori restrict consider factor commiss check region aid account financi analys locat studi view select fiat mirafiori site commiss check evid suppli itali support claim suffici context narrow interpret exempt provid articl due regard formal requir suppli inform februari letter april italian author state programm marea multipla punto start inform commiss possess spend global programm start pre product marea vehicl affect alleg mobil vehicl region aid authoris began august letter italian author juli state machineri order march april deliveri begin half confirm locat studi allegedli led fiat choos mirafiori carri commiss note mirafiori locat assist area march mirafiori municip assist area articl confirm letter juli itali submit initi propos area class assist area articl septemb commiss conclud decis invest marea multipla punto programm time mirafiori plant locat assist area assess affect mirafiori locat object area alleg possibl transfer machineri site initi phase project start pre product marea inform suppli italian author place confirm signific part invest need produc marea carri period decis assist area statu commiss receiv breakdown invest type vehicl extrem fiat account possibl obtain region aid view financ mirafiori project italian author suppli evid allai doubt fiat includ possibl receiv region aid reason implicitli accept risk aid withheld commiss prior authoris requir accord commun framework state aid motor vehicl industri time fiat decid carri invest account possibl obtain state aid financ project mirafiori commiss polici requir cost benefit analysi cba base comparison plant question altern site assist region commun fiat locat invest italian author fiat familiar methodolog time handl fiat mezzogiorno case commiss inform choic compar plant altern plant locat central northern itali commiss experi show cba drawn basi assumpt made difficult imposs identifi handicap mirafiori justifi authoris region aid italian author suppli proof fiat effect region aid account decis carri invest mirafiori commiss point incident refer altern plant poland bielsko biala call itali case point entri forc framework state aid motor vehicl industri januari year invest decis lastli commiss consid member state undertak legitim reli region class elig assist articl commiss decis end reason commiss find italian govern demonstr fiat grant region aid consider calcul criterion select mirafiori site notifi region aid order achiev object articl case aim facilit develop econom area order demonstr necess region aid commiss practic framework forc check aid recipi econom viabl altern locat project part project industri site exist capabl receiv invest question group firm compel carri project sole plant absenc aid inform suppli itali subject request detail inadequ commiss explan state fiat choic polish plant rivalta mirafiori complex claim polish altern signific advantag itali term labour cost commiss take view time invest decis real advantag locat project poland obviou italian author maintain industri risk neglig time fiat auto poland undergo intens reorganis network local part supplier develop todai supplier establish analysi mobil project italian author pass import advantag term flexibl fiat strateg object gain establish maintain rivaltalmirafiori complex italian author provid commiss fragmentari inform real prospect produc marea optimum condit altern car dai mirafiori car dai rivalta car dai mirafiori equival car dai bielsko biala satisfactori reason product rate chosen plant virtual inform fiat actual plan move invest question poland commiss consid itali demonstr theoret project mobil notifi region aid attain object articl facilit develop econom area thirdli commiss note incident difficulti aris proportion region aid itali consid hand invest regard elig total itl billion cost benefit analysi present case intens region aid envisag region ceil nomin aid itl billion authoris commiss polici relev framework assist region suffer minimum structur handicap aid intens region ceil regard minimum compens handicap face investor assist area cost benefit analysi need assess net handicap project region question commiss note aid intens definit calcul regard amount elig invest motor vehicl industri mobil invest regard elig itali acknowledg itl billion constitut mobil invest regard propos aid itl billion intens commiss consid itali provid clarif support claim mobil invest rule actual amount lower amount propos result aid intens higher inform italian govern suffici exact cost benefit analysi made invest poland explain suffici detail reason necess aid demonstr view offici request inform case question commiss check region aid question compli proportion criterion conclus region aid italian author plan grant fiat mirafiori carrozzeria total itl billion order achiev object refer articl facilit develop econom activ area evid proportion region aid question incompat common market innov invest aid fact region aid need order locat project assist area aid requir order facilit introduct industri innov motor vehicl sector basi relev framework commiss take firm posit regard aid modernis innov propos grant aid innov examin determin effect concern introduct commun level substanti innov product process commiss ask expert analys technic content project regard innov italian author compar state art european motor vehicl industri time invest decis machineri manufactur expert conclud product variabl section underfram multipla process innov chiefli aluminium compon invest continu present time highli innov consid project involv element industri risk justifi gross aid intens hand depth examin invest present itali defin innov mean relev framework involv minor degre risk result tabl gt tabl gt aid itali propos grant product variabl section underfram multipla process contribut fiat decis invest innov gross intens proport object pursu conclus aid innov gross intens invest exceed itl billion nomin relat product variabl section underfram multipla process compat common market aid aid object mention point italian govern environment protect explain detail formal request provid inform issu commiss commiss unabl examin presenc aid environment protect measur adopt decis articl aid innov invest worth nomin itl billion italian govern plan grant fiat mirafiori carrozzeria compat common market mean articl maximum gross intens implement aid authoris articl addit state aid italian republ plan grant fiat invest project mirafiori carrozzeria incompat common market articl italian republ inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli articl decis address italian republ brussel juli commiss philipp busquin member commiss oj oj letter march refer number sg oj letter june oj sourc fiat fact figur replac punto cassino mirafiori carrozzeria pomigliano rivalta purpos decis market central europ belgium franc germani netherland eastern europ car dai poland work dai itali amend oj oj connect paragraph court judgment case philip morri ecr oj oj oj oj oj ford bridgend case oj