commiss decis novemb aid land baden wuerttemberg feder republ germani provid bug alutechnik gmbh undertak produc semi finish finish aluminium product german text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun subparagraph articl thereof notic accord articl interest parti submit comment regard comment request commiss feder german govern inform commiss verbal note perman represent date june land baden wuerttemberg grant decis april dm million undertak question cancel state guarante dm million award undertak land juli accord direct grant guarante industri land baden wuerttemberg grant dm million provid condit declar guarante land return grant increas capit undertak receivership aim grant make recipi undertak worthwhil acquisit point view purchas compani agre undertak condit share capit rais dm million dm million invest firm asset commiss decid januari initi procedur provid articl eec treati respect notifi aid dm million land baden wuerttemberg provid produc semi finish aluminium product initi scrutini commiss consid grant dm million constitut aid measur mean articl allow undertak carri relat cost liabl distort competit affect trade commun extent contrari common interest regard oblig notif aid measur commiss conclud grant dm million notifi advanc provid articl eec treati govern feder republ germani argu grant dm million notifi fell threshold laid commiss letter sg septemb threshold appli gener aid scheme approv commiss case grant dm million commiss approv gener aid scheme land baden wuerttemberg provid grant favour undertak difficulti compani bankrupt payment grant dm million consid legal point view honour guarante dm million addit compani form viabl part undertak receivership receiv agre invest dm million firm asset commiss strong doubt statement absenc grant compani bankrupt grant dm million provid illicitli prior notif author commiss basi inform stage commiss consid aid question benefit derog provid articl eec treati fact subsector extrud semi finish aluminium product face face overcapac problem commun level undertak consider particip intra commun trade danger aid measur question affect trade condit member state extent contrari common interest appear signific time commiss request addit inform order final decis compat aid measur question articl eec treati letter date februari gave govern feder republ germani notic submit comment conform provis articl eec treati member state parti notic submit comment ii govern feder republ germani submit comment procedur provid articl eec treati letter date april state aid econom justifi request closur procedur aim grant make bug alutechnik gmbh worthwhil acquisit point view interest purchas kaiser aluminium europ larg integr aluminium produc bug alutechnik kaiser europ set motion restructur process involv closur warehous sale offic disband vehicl fleet cut employ result integr aluminium group aid undertak switch product strategi satur build market extrud semi finish product manufactur industri approxim share turnov grant affect intern cost undertak question result lower price competitor market grant stave bankruptci threaten firm medium term loss dm million incur larger group ensu increas capit profit loss transfer group prevent cash run undertak export output commun countri export sale target semi finish aluminium product eec tonn total intra commun trade account tonn take basi actual export semi finish aluminium product undertak account trade eec feder republ share view small actual market share effect trade member state minim detail inform restructur effort invest programm capac provid request commiss letter feder german perman represent april june juli octob invest realiz budget dm aim transform central product build concentr storag facil administr build equip link product mix invest increas manufactur capac bug alutechnik product made bug alutechnik complementari activ kaiser europ compensatori capac reduct expect rest group integr bug alutechnik kaiser europ present capac bug alutechnik transform aluminium chang consist extrus press technic capac tonn util capac transform util reduct capac estim feder german author list organiz bug alutechnik provid closur unit finish product illmense esenhausen april ii reduct product mix window door element decemb iii cessat independ metal construct activ april iv closur warehous wurzach munich april reduct employ april march vi closur warehous velbert darmstadt hannov decemb vii disband vehicl fleet decemb viii closur sale offic berlin decemb commun octob feder german author argu capac bug alutechnik vogt ad occur koblenz extrus plant kaiser aluminium europ undertak purchas bug instal addit extrus capac hard alloi aluminium grow market kaiser chang exist extrus press koblenz transform soft alloi hard alloi aluminium cost dm million market soft alloi satisfi press soft alloi aluminium vogt area soft alloi extrud aluminium product character overcapac problem kaiser reduc number press particip grow market hard alloi extrus product transform press koblenz soft alloi destin build construct market hard alloi destin machin construct automobil aviat industri framework consult interest parti provid articl eec treati govern member state nation feder aluminium produc competitor submiss iii financi assist grant undertak vogt ravensburg land baden wuerttemberg aid mean articl eec treati fact grant dm million land prevent econom market forc normal consequ disappear loss make uncompetit undertak undertak busi artifici facilit larg integr aluminium group aid rescu natur favour recipi undertak purchas compar undertak compet sector artifici improv profit grant dm million notifi advanc commiss pursuant articl eec treati provid articl commiss inform suffici time enabl submit comment plant grant alter aid explain occas initi procedur commiss approv gener aid scheme land baden wuerttemberg provid grant favour undertak difficulti fact grant replac state guarante approv direct grant guarante industri land baden wuerttemberg free member state concern oblig prior notif grant concern undertak bankrupt form part strong multin group grant dm milion consid legal point view honour guarante dm million aid illeg relat commun law time oper situat produc failur fulfil oblig notif aid paid recipi gener budget land aid rise effect regard incompat common market case aid incompat common market commiss judgment court justic juli case requir member state recov aid grant illeg recipi iv bug alutechnik oper subsector aluminium industri extrud semi suppli manufactur industri partli pure semi product partli machin finish order standard shape section build industri instal capac aluminium extrus forg european commun estim tonn tonn instal feder republ germani util rate europ estim low rate due lack demand purchas manufactur industri continu show low rate activ bug alutechnik extrus press total capac approxim tonn current util rate capac instal undertak repres feder republ capac eec capac past extrud aluminium produc undertak process aluminium frame wooden aluminium window product edg field minor part product sold extrud semi manufactur industri chang product mix place sale semi finish product manufactur industri risen turnov intra commun trade forg extrud semi finish aluminium product amount tonn germani export tonn extrud semi member state share feder republ total intra commun trade extrud semi correspond undertak export aluminium semi finish product member state export sale target eec tonn undertak account trade eec extrud semi feder republ share inform product capac aluminium standard shape section build industri commun gener present util rate capac instal product low due downturn build industri feder german govern provid inform instal capac undertak question product inform fact util manufactur capac shift basi averag year product vari period tonn trade product commun intra commun trade door window door window frame aluminium amount tonn feder republ germani respons tonn undertak export total product member state feder german govern note eec export target extrud semi tonn major export consist door window shape roof edg rain gutter export standard section shape undertak member state tonn intra commun trade product feder republ share state financi aid strenghten posit undertak compar undertak compet intra commun trade regard affect aid case aid question substanti advantag receiv undertak design bug alutechnik larg integr aluminium group kaiser aluminium europ carri cost aid distort competit artifici improv profit undertak favour enterpris compar competitor constitut aid mean articl articl deal aid mesur compat principl common market applic case aid rescu natur articl eec treati list aid compat common market compat treati determin context commun singl member state order safeguard proper function common market take account principl articl eec treati derog principl articl eec treati set articl constru narrowli aid scheme individu award scrutin appli commiss establish free plai market forc aid induc prospect aid recipi adopt action contribut attain object appli except case contribut object aid end give unfair advantag member state industri undertak financi posit bolster trade condit member state affect competit distort feder german govern unabl give commiss discov justif find aid refer fall categori except articl regard except provid articl aid promot facilit develop area applic aid scheme benefit except provid articl standard live abnorm low underemploy feder republ germani grant incorpor requisit featur aid facilit develop econom area mean articl condit initi invest job creation explain commiss commun principl coordin region aid system undertak situat land baden wuerttemberg locat vogt ravensburg area consid commiss feder govern assist area exempt provid articl evid aid question intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb feder german economi aid favour compani aluminium industri adequ remedi kind situat articl regard exempt provid articl favour aid facilit develop econom activ observ illicitli provid grant dm million sole rescu aid paid undertak receivership aim make recipi compani worthwhil acquisit point view intern aluminium group aid undertak close purchas group refer made commiss letter member state januari condit rescu aid regard compat common market rescu aid grant firm busi difficulti discov remedi work compli inter alia condit consist cash aid form loan guarante loan bear normal commerci interest rate aid receiv bug alutechnik meet condit paid time need gener exceed month draw feasibl recoveri measur case rescu aid form grant provid short period subject repay aid link adequ recoveri measur aim make bug alutechnik worthwhil acquisit point view purchas compani kaiser aluminium europ advers effect industri situat member state case bug alutechnik particip activ intra commun trade integr kaiser integr multin aluminium group reduc export member state notifi commiss advanc individu signific case case compani recipi undertak purchas call signific feder german govern fulfil oblig articl eec treati notifi aid suffici time enabl commiss submit comment initi respect administr procedur provid articl eec treati undertak oper market capac greatli exce demand competit market extrem acut accept feder german author commun market finish aluminium product destin build sector section frame door window window sill rain gutter roof edg seal show clear capac acut downturn build industri unfair give financi advantag undertak member state oper subsector competit distort market extrud semi finish aluminium product sold manufactur industri face capac estim compani question export extrud product member state danger aid measur affect trade condit member state extent contrari common interest signific hand disappear undertak market decreas overcapac problem market face commun level grant paid bug alutechnik undertak receivership benefit kaiser purchas intern aluminium group annual report parent compani kaiser aluminium chemic corpor acquisit bug alutechnik recent initi group penetr higher margin market practic larg intern aluminium group concentr higher ad product extrud semi sold manufactur industri main target bug alutechnik fact reorient product facil extrud semi account total output integr kaiser group fact nation sale offic distribut point close close share intra commun export total sale decreas futur extrud semi similar ground commiss accept argument effect trade member state minim born mind exist critic market share accept commiss distort effect trade overlook undertak export total output commun countri explain evid reduc futur contrari final restructur process realiz plan futur evalu commun point view sector face capac problem commun level restructur impli reduct instal physic capac real reduct product capac finish aluminium activ place aid grant increas semi finish aluminium activ closur warehous sale offic vehicl fleet effect aid grant impact product capac product figur suggest capac chang substanti util aluminium press higher anod line higher analys invest detail conclud concentr product storag instal product mix absorb largest part capit expenditur link reduct manufactur capac extern sourc report bug alutechnik comput control warehous vogt storag capac tonn capac weld cut drill mill screw transform press kaiser koblenz soft hard alloi aluminium place context purchas bug alutechnik provid complementari justif aid correspond normal diversif strategi integr aluminium group kaiser reduc total number extrus press subsector extrud semi finish product soft hard alloi show overcapac problem commun level past commiss allow aid undertak oper subsector instal capac reduc significantli order contribut solut sector difficulti commun level intern shift soft hard alloi commiss remain coher global sector approach short restructur bug alutechnik vogt chang capac sector extrud semi finish finish aluminium product commun level face capac problem european aluminium group reduc number extrus press eec order meet lower demand organ product mix market realiz bug alutechnik kaiser aluminium koblenz contribut significantli solut surplu capac eec aluminium industri conclud aid grant bug alutechnik benefit exempt provid articl eec treati view forego consider aid question illeg feder german govern fulfil oblig articl eec treati meet condit fulfil order except articl eec treati appli aid withdrawn recoveri adopt decis articl aid dm million form grant land baden wuerttemberg provid april bug alutechnik undertak produc semi finish finish aluminium product govern feder republ germani belatedli inform commiss letter june illeg provid violat provis articl eec treati incompat common market mean articl treati articl aid withdrawn recoveri feder german govern inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli herewith articl decis address feder republ germani brussel novemb commiss peter sutherland member commiss ecr