commiss decis decemb relat proceed articl eec treati iv magil tv guid itp bbc rte english text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul februari regul implement articl treati amend act access spain portug articl thereof regard complaint lodg magil tv guid april independ televis public british broadcast corpor radio telefi eireann regard commiss decis decemb initi proceed case undertak concern opportun make view object rais commiss pursuant articl regul read conjunct commiss regul eec juli hear provid articl council regul consult advisori committe restrict practic domin posit fact decis concern practic polici independ televis public british broadcast corpor bbc enterpris radio telefi eireann relat advanc programm list effect practic polici market televis tv programm guid programm receiv ireland northern ireland undertak itp independ televis public london establish order publish nation programm journal independ televis unit kingdom sharehold itp current televis contractor franchis independ broadcast author iba suppli independ televis programm iba public corpor establish order provid independ televis radio broadcast servic public servic unit kingdom isl man channel island addit bbc iba award contract privat undertak suppli programm region countri suppli programm servic contractor provid programm tv channel itv addit channel televis compani subsidiari iba televis programm servic bbc british broadcast corpor incorpor unit kingdom royal charter oper licenc grant secretari state home affair princip object bbc provid public broadcast servic gener recept home oversea object compil print publish issu circul distribut charg print matter conduc object corpor bbc revenu deriv sourc televis licenc incom grant bbc commerci trade activ conduct bbc enterpris bbc wholli own subsidiari includ public total annual turnov bbc enterpris million rte radio telefi eireann author statutori corpor bodi establish ireland provid nation televis sound broadcast servic fulfil public servic condit rte grant author publish charg print matter conduc incident object rte revenu deriv sourc televis licenc incom advertis revenu public magil magil tv guid dublin establish order publish ireland northern ireland weekli magazin inform forthcom televis programm televis viewer area public began initi injunct obtain itp bbc rte restrain magil publish advanc weekli televis list pend full nation proceed publish materi magil present ceas publish activ magil tv guid wholli own subsidiari magil public hold dublin televis market decemb million colour million black white televis licenc issu household ireland central statist offic figur compar figur unit kingdom juli million million northern ireland million household possess televis licenc novemb vast major popul countri access televis ireland rte enjoi statutori monopoli provis nation broadcast servic broadcast channel rte rte unit kingdom duopoli exist bbc iba provis nation televis servic channel bbc bbc itv channel region variat northern ireland region addit programm servic broadcast directli televis viewer ireland northern ireland receiv neighbour televis programm result viewer receiv televis channel rte rte bbc northern ireland bbc itv ulster channel altern addit viewer receiv bbc iba programm broadcast wale januari viewer ireland receiv number satellit channel distribut cabl oper countri addit televis channel envisag countri product product involv case advanc list forthcom televis radio programm advanc weekli list free charg request newspap case magazin form programm inform sheet summari sheet summari includ addit inform content individu programm includ copi refer copyright notic licenc defin limit publish permit reproduc inform viewer listen ireland unit kingdom substanti part thereof receiv list defin present purpos list programm broadcast behalf broadcast organ period time list includ inform titl programm broadcast channel date time transmiss programm list produc determin content programm servic broadcast includ channel time transmiss programm term programm schedul plan procedur iba bbc rte programm schedul start month actual date broadcast initi relat period week weekli daili programm schedul prepar event schedul seri draft increasingli detail precis stage weekli schedul final subject minut week transmiss depend practic broadcast organ compani concern list serv document weekli programm schedul stage market product copyright law programm list unit kingdom expressli confirm televis programm list includ programm summari factual synopsi programm entitl copyright protect literari work copyright act result owner programm list entitl prevent unauthor parti inter alia reproduc publish broadcast substanti part protect work precis definit constitut substanti part programm list establish ireland legal posit regard programm list copyright act date examin judici matter subject legal proceed magil bbc itp rte copyright itp itv channel bbc rte programm list itp itv channel ownership copyright programm list itv televis servic vest initi programm contractor produc programm schedul term contract iba requir assign copyright itp durat contract forbid publish programm journal programm detail return itp agre pai contractor amount equal proport net profit itp attribut sale tv time amount divid programm contractor direct proport net advertis revenu channel assign copyright programm list itp charg consider agreement incur cost expens order publish public channel inform programm purpos present decis list collect term itp list bbc ownership copyright programm list bbc bbc vest initi bbc agreement sign copyright assign bbc enterpris subject bbc exercis right public rte ownership copyright programm list rte rte vest rte programm list tv guid market programm list mean view public obtain advanc inform forthcom programm servic receiv gener list impart directli public extent made receiv intermediari public broadcast servic extent inform public term tv guid distinct drawn daili weekend weekli tv guid comprehens guid oj oj market radio programm consid separ present decis advanc list radio programm servic publish televis programm list limit number viewer unit kingdom receiv addit channel distribut local cabl oper cabl servic wide unit kingdom servic northern ireland includ sky channel super channel art channel children channel cork multichannel lifestyl screensport bbc itp time fsr agreement subject present proceed programm contractor interest profit itp capac sharehold compani term tv guid consid includ radio programm list daili weekend guid daili newspap publish ireland northern ireland itp bbc rte televis radio programm list dai unit kingdom newspap sold ireland includ itp bbc televis radio programm list weekli newspap list dai public dai newspap dai list number irish newspap publish list cabl satellit channel ireland local area result number comprehens daili tv guid exist market ireland unit kingdom includ northern ireland addit daili case dai list bbc itp ceefax oracl televis teletext inform servic provid bbc itv channel household televis set receiv servic newpap daili weekli receiv advanc weekli list free request itp bbc rte programm summari addit factual inform programm concern accompani case copyright notic licenc set term inform reproduc practic polici itp bbc rte respect minor variat individu polici newspap reproduc daili circumst dai list subject condit format public rte permit magazin publish inform basi weekli newspap licens polici itp bbc rte strict enforc parti take legal action public exceed term permit cabl satellit compani contrast impos limit public programm list distribut free charg request weekli guid comprehens weekli tv guid exist market ireland unit kingdom period june magil tv guid publish guid ireland injunct obtain itp bbc rte nation legal proceed magil ceas public guid undertak seek publish comprehens weekli tv guid ireland unit kingdom restrain licens polici itp bbc rte limit paragraph undertak consid exceed limit licenc legal proced threaten initi undertak concern infring copyright unit kindgom irish law proced initi magil basi itp bbc rte contrast itp bbc sought prevent public programm list weekli tv guid publish ireland unit kingdom declar reason interest pursu foreign languag public suspect public includ materi depend local law infring copyright itp bbc rte publish weekli tv guid individu weekli programm list itp itp weekli tv guid tv time publish region edit price irl northern ireland wale edit sold unit kingdom ireland averag weekli circul figur tv time northern ireland ireland itp total averag weekli circul figur tv time million guid purchas household unit kingdom possess televis set bbc tv guid tv time biggest sell weekli journal unit kingdom result attract advertis tv time purchas household ireland total trade result tv time year juli year juli turnov profit tax profit tax percentag turnov copyright fee sourc itp divid sale advertis ii bbc bbc weekli tv guid publish bbc wholli own subsidiari radio time publish region edit price irl irl northern ireland wale edit sold unit kingdom ireland averag weekli circul figur radio time northern ireland ireland total averag weekli circul figur exce million guid purchas approxim household unit kingdom possess televis set precis statist point consum purchas radio time purchas tv time report monopoli merger commiss british broadcast corpor independ televis public cmnd radio time attract advertis total trade result radio time year year march million turnov net profit tax net profit tax percentag turnov net sale advertis revenu sourc bbc iii rte rte weekli guid rte guid publish price irl sold ireland northern ireland averag weekli circul rte guid ireland northern ireland total trade result rte guid year septemb year septemb irl turnov sale advertis ii legal assess articl undertak publish tv guid return commerci gain includ sale advertis space itp bbc bbc enterpris rte engag econom activ undertak mean articl applic competit rule circumst public broadcast organ confirm court case sacchi bbc tv guid publish activ organ transfer bbc enterpris wholli own subsidiari organ subject control bbc retain right relat copyright bbc programm list determin polici licens list bbc bbc entrepris consid singl econom unit fot purpos articl present case fact list receiv contractor channel number highlight refer limit number programm broadcast week deem parti infring copyright separ figur maintain northern ireland case sacchi ecr domin relev product market product account advanc weekli list itp bbc region programm servic rte tv guid list publish broadcast publish wish produc weekli comprehens tv guid distribut geograph area programm list relat receiv list constitut essenti raw materi guid addit list individu list interchang complementari concern programm case comprehens guid list element comprehens equal consum wish obtain advanc weekli inform list essenti practic made consum public broadcast tv guid advanc weekli list broadcast organ contain guid interchang consum concern reason publish state weekli list distinguish daili list daili list limit extent substitut advanc weekli list term inform provid consum fact consum prepar purchas weekli tv guid publish itp bbc rte inform daili basi newspap demonstr demand advanc inform addit demand inform contain singl period comprehens guid experi magil publish sought publish advanc weekli list situat member state comprehens weekli tv guid context import comprehens tv guid advertis underlin view potenti demand guid tv guid market refer separ market broadcast servic deriv exist consid ancillari relev geograph market geograph market present case determin common programm weekli list relat receiv tv guid list distribut rte programm servic receiv ireland northern ireland bbc itv channel programm servic region version servic receiv area comprehens weekli tv guid weekli list region servic purpos present case relev geograph market ireland northern ireland constitut substanti part common market purpos articl domin irrespect intellectu properti right claim entitl broadcast organ factual monopoli product public weekli list programm list product programm schedul process carri programm planner list market product schedul finalis subject minut short time transmiss result parti produc reliabl list public tv guid obtain list broadcast organ undertak right list grant case itp bbc rte parti posit econom depend characterist exist domin posit addit factual monopoli held broadcast organ relat individu programm list strengthen legal monopoli claim protect copayright law unit kingdom ireland parti transfer claim legal right seek protect present case itp independ televis compani unit kingdom assign right bbc rte aqch sought protect copyright law question result competit parti permit exist market basi conclud itp bbc rte hold domin posit mean articl abus articl expressli abus commit undertak domin posit limit product market prejudic consum present publish mean produc comprehens tv guid consum ireland norhern ireland consum wish obtain advanc weekli programm inform requir purchas separ guid tv time radio time rte guid publish itp bbc rte total weekli cost irl irl annual consum ireland fulli inform programm servic area number cabl satellit channel distribut part countri publish entitl publish inform free charg commerci viabl form weekli public includ itp bbc rte weekli list imposs publish produc publish comprehens tv guid result refus itp bbc rte permit public advanc weekli list legal proceed itp bbc rte institut publish respect term licenc grant grant licenc confirm experi magil declar polici practic parti regard itp bbc rte prevent meet substanti potenti demand exist market comprehens tv guid demand result advantag offer comprenhens tv guid mark advanceweekli list great number programm consum practic pai consider amount monei price situat member state experi magil comprehens guid reason price consum concern respect import commerci potenti comprehens tv guid advertis account attract increas fact bbc estim tv guid radio time fact read number personswho purchas potenti market confirm situat member state comprehens weekli tv guid purchas larg proport nation popul fact comprehens daili tv guid exist newspap form ireland unit kingdom public magil tv guid albeit limit print run demonstr consum demand comprehens weekli tv guid area concern itp bbc rte individu collect claim current polici practic regard advanc weekli list motiv ensur comprehens high qualiti coverag programm includ minor region appeal cultur histor educ signific commiss opinion polici practic achiev aim achiev restrict mean impos term effect publish grant licenc publish programm list commiss note parti consid impos limit public parti daili dai list order achiev purpos regard actual polici practic itp bbc rte suppli publish advanc weekli list limit mean term licenc grant reproduct list dai list time rtefus licenc altogeth commiss take view polici practic unduli restrict light commiss conclud current polici practic itp bbc rte relat respect advanc weekli list intend protect effect protect posit individu tv guid compet guid connect commiss consid undertak perfectli capabl regard present posit experi market plai major role market comprehens weekli tv guid altern continu publisdh individu tv guid market comprehens tv guid consum serv guid state limit scope licenc polici prevent product sale coamprehens tv guid restrict competit prejudic consum commiss take view circumst undertak domin posit case itp bbc rte posit prevent introduct market product comprehens weekli tv guid abus domin posit manner prohibit articl argument put forward parti relat copyright affect conclus contrari commiss consid practic polici itp bbc rte present case fact copyright instrument abus manner fall scope specif subject matter intellectu properti element abus virtu opf current polici practic itp bbc rte domin market list retain deriv market weekli tv guid market competit place relat weekli comprehens guid effect trade member state abovement abus effect trade member state comprehens tv guid advanc weekli list itp bbc region programm rte market ireland northern ireland includ cross border trade guid guid addit trade advanc weekli list includ cross frontier natur articl itp bbc rte public statutori duti produc publish individu programm list form tv guid applic competit rule case obstruct perform task mean articl articl applic present case articl regul articl commiss find infring articl treati decis requir undertak associ undertak concern bring infring end abus present case limit parti market weekli tv guid ireland northern ireland limit scope licenc polici practic prevent entri market comprehens tv guid guid commiss intervent remedi current situat provid possibl public comprehens weekli tv guid achiev end region itp bbc weekli programm list rte made parti parti public comprehens guid confin order suppli list itp bbc rte inter se discrimin parti wish produc comprehens weekli guid manner compat articl remedi present case requir itp bbc rte suppli parti request discriminatori basi individu advanc weekli programm list permit reproduct list parti requir extend inform addit list defin decis choos suppli permit reproduct list mean licenc royalit request itp bbc rte reason itp bbc rte includ licenc grant parti term consid ensur comprehens high qualiti coverag programm includ minor region appeal cultur histor educ signific parti requir month date notif decis submit propos approv commiss term parti permit publish advanc weekli programm list subject decis adopt decis articl polici practic itp bbc rte relat individu advanc weekli programm list programm receiv ireland northern ireland constitut infring articl prevent public saql comprehens weekli tv guid ireland northern ireland articl itp bbc rte bring infring mention articl end forthwith suppli parti request nondiscriminatori basi individu advanc weekli programm list permit reproduct list parti requir extend inform addit list defin decis choos suppli permit reproduct list mean licenc royalti request itp bbc rte reason itp bbc rte includ licenc grate parti term consid ensur comprehens high qualiti coverag programm inlcud minor region apeal cultur histor educ signific parti requir month date notif decis submit propos approv commiss term parti permit publish advanc weekli programm list subject decis articl decis address independ televis public tottenham court road london au unit kingdom british broadcast corpor bbc broadcast hous london aa unit kingdom bbc enterpris woodland wood lane london tf unit kingdom radio telefi eireann dublin ireland brussel decemb commiss peter sutherland member commiss