commiss decis procedur relat applic regul eec case vii ama viva air french text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul eec juli access commun air carrier intra commun air rout articl thereof consult advisori committe establish regul background januari viva air head offic call zurbano madrid spain request commiss investig legal decis french author refus viva air licenc oper pari charl de gaull madrid rout issu decis base articl regul eec viva air want oper schedul air servic madrid pari charl de gaull airport januari rate return flight dai telex messag octob appli pari cdg slot airport author grant telex messag date telex messag date novemb spanish civil aviat author inform french counterpart decis author viva air oper servic question request french author repli receiv french autor spanish civil author confirm term commun telex messag decemb letter decemb viva air inform french author intent oper rout concern refer author issu spanish author gave flight number utc schedul airport departur arriv frequenc period oper type aircraft repli receiv french author spite meet french civil aviat author offici decemb viva air repeat applic letter date decemb emphas amount invest order oper servic concern french civil aviat author repli telex messag date state viva air applic examin author ad applic lodg month prior date servic start requir decre septemb forc viva air repli telex messag letter decemb point exercis freedom fourth freedom intra commun traffic right complet liber commun rule member state longer discret matter object applic cumbersom procedur provid decre septemb case appli french carrier viva air ad hand french author inform intent oper servic question long ago octob airlin lodg request air slot viva air unawar rule govern traffic alloc pari airport system viva air emphas loss sustain unabl oper servic plan date view invest made undertak passeng french author repli letter address chairman viva air date decemb refus viva air author oper plan servic madrid pari cdg ad prevent servic oper madrid pari orli refus base fact articl regul eec member state regul distribut traffic airport airport system rule french govern airlin oper servic medium haul intern rout pari orli pari cdg case point french author consid viva air part iberia group oper madrid pari orli rout viva air propos servic madrid pari cdg rout independ oper iberia madrid pari orli rout interpret support fact iberia pari lodg viva air schedul french civil aviat author letter decemb french author reiter posit traffic right refer articl regul eec grant explicitli member state concern safeguard measur provid regul member state retain refus restrict traffic right impos condit subject right exercis french author consid nation provis lodg schedul adopt decre septemb remain forc contrari commun law author ad applic slot viva air lodg coordin pari cdg airport regard compli requir telex messag decemb french civil aviat author inform spanish counterpart posit state compani compani belong group serv european citi airport pari system creat preced undermin present system alloc airport facil subject decis object viva air lodg commiss januari direct french author refus decemb grant author ii object viva air ask commiss examin legal french author refus decis base provis articl regul eec support applic viva air stress aspect procedur impos french author incompat provis regul eec articl regul appli inappropri discriminatori manner author procedur viva air consid articl regul eec leav member state discret refus traffic right except provid principl freedom exercis right embodi regul undermin mean explicit author need formal need enabl member state oper except strict minimum viva air current french rule fulfil condit consid light principl proportion instanc contrari requir commun law french rule discriminatori provis applic french airlin differ appli french commun airlin applic slot lodg airport regard equival give nation author prior inform applic specif refer rout slot alloc equival member state grant author slot alloc instrument implement gener polici share traffic airport final month requir examin applic excess articl council regul eec juli fare rate air servic fare submit hour effect implement articl regul eec viva air consid member state appli provis articl regul eec line object discriminatori criteria view organ airport effici instanc criteria traffic alloc rule quot french author appli intra commun intern rout domest french rout rout member countri rule air franc advantag oper servic pari cdg madrid whilst air inter indirect servic pari orli madrid toulous bordeaux lyon french author refus mean air franc remain monopoli posit pari cdg madrid rout viva air consid french author incorrect conclud iberia viva air part compani viva air spite subsidiari iberia legal person commerci ident commerci polici licenc viva air found regard genuin commun air carrier mean articl regul eec french author interpret lead discrimin french airlin euralair direct servic pari orli madrid fact depend air franc group work iii enabl decis object lodg viva air commiss letter februari request french author repli question fortnight french author intend repeal provis decre septemb schedul intra commun air servic amend futur period french author requir examin applic month letter decemb french civil aviat author viva air dai provid articl decre septemb decre septemb refer foreign compani procedur appli compani includ flag carrier establish franc wish start servic rule govern alloc traffic airport orli pari cdg letter decemb state french govern airlin oper servic medium haul intern rout pari orli pari cdg prohibit appli medium haul intern flight long haul domest flight case instanc prohibit milit expans cdg airport sought french author letter decemb reason refus viva air permiss oper pari cdg iberia viva air part group respect servic independ gener criteria french author decid compani fact member group singl compani purpos appli rule govern alloc traffic orli cdg connect interdepend compani determin commiss receiv repli deadlin french author remind march allow dai author repli letter date march log commiss march french author commiss inform request iv repli french author question commiss put letter februari summar question provis articl regul eec prevent applic procedur establish decre septemb intend amend decre reduc month period requir notif reduc month question entri forc council regul eec french carrier includ flag carrier meet requir obtain oper licenc process involv opinion conseil supérieur de aviat marchand csam lodg programm month prior start question ministeri decis alloc traffic airport pari system issu formal document base principl formul french govern set air transport polici principl analys detail pari cdg airport built recent ministeri decis collat rule alloc traffic pari airport system issu shortli question decis appli principl allow airlin serv pari orli pari cdg medium haul intern flight type market involv long haul servic concern airlin duplic servic oper daili flight afford land dai pari case domest servic view heavi competit surfac transport duplic servic encourag order airlin wish improv servic pari encourag expans pari cdg airport case medium haul intern servic take account low flow intensifi fact carrier competit concentr flight airlin airport ensur servic user optim airport capac avoid discrimin carrier serv rout direct pari cdg capac pari cdg mean intern intra commun servic oper airport temporarili carrier establish rout pari iberian peninsula base pari orli transfer pari cdg capac airport develop air franc transfer iberian servic pari cdg iberia choic decid question decis made basi form control iberia exercic viva air relev criteria set commun regul effect control instanc iberia major hold viva air effect control point contest compani ii legal assess case commiss main task decid french author correctli appli provis articl regul eec refus viva air author oper madrid pari rout pari cdg mean examin scope articl regul eec order determin discret member state author refus traffic right formal member state impos connect author procedur vi articl regul eec state subject regul commun air carrier permit member state concern exercis traffic right rout commun commiss consid provis constitut statement gener principl freedom access commun air carrier intra commun rout includ member state freedom access carrier possess oper licenc grant accord provis regul eec provis author commun air carrier exercis traffic right french author maintain author exercis right remain provinc member state concern impos formal author procedur confirm word requir author articl regul eec phrase mean contrari normal circumst restrict constraint provid articl articl articl regul eec capabl appli member state concern requir carrier exercis traffic right author automat member state longer discret matter automat grant right aris gener principl freedom access line recit preambl regul eec refer specif articl treati freedom provid servic intern market intern frontier abolit restrict design traffic right line freedom set fare rate grant regul eec econom point view elimin rigid price elimin rigid quantiti access market unbalanc outcom avoid fact exercis traffic right automat prevent member state exercis appli transit restrict claus provid articl articl articl definit restrict claus articl regul eec member state requir carrier lodg applic provid item inform prior author grant prevent requir undermin freedom access market establish regul eec minimum member state oper abovement restrict claus member state impos formal notif author procedur deadlin repli airlin applic author short reason principl freedom access market establish articl regul eec assum carrier inform quickli decis applic view heavi invest involv start servic small airlin element uncertainti reduc thirdli long examin applic light appli measur restrict access market provid regul view reduc amount uncertainti airlin exercis freedom rule refus except rule repli receiv state deadlin author oper implicit refus hand expressli justifi fact law hand open legal challeng member state includ provis intern regul air slot commiss consid air slot alloc cover council regul eec legal distinct question grant traffic right cover regul eec airlin applic traffic right refus simpl reason airlin air slot provid servic cover applic know know airlin air slot bear matter airlin ask provid inform similarli carrier obtain slot oper servic assum author exercis traffic right respect servic member state concern impos special formal respect obtain right viva air argument applic slot alloc pari cdg equival french author issu author reject final commiss stress contrari french rule forc member state undermin fundament principl discrimin basi nation differenti licens carrier licens member state formal lai regard examin applic traffic right regul eec vii articl regul eec state regul affect member state regul discrimin ground nation ident air carrier distribut traffic airport airport system appli provis restrict gener principl freedom access rout commun airport provid articl regul commiss consid except gener principl restrict interpret strictli interpret base transpar object criteria remain constant period discriminatori respons member state put forward relev ground commiss consid aforement word articl impli rule laid transpar regulatori natur gener individu effect turn mean rule publish publish meet requir transpar reason basi current polici airport clear public enabl airlin work advanc minimum uncertainti airport alloc view intend rout accord freedom commun rule sought confer carrier fact remain french rule traffic alloc pari airport system rule viva air publish commiss conclud rule appli french law unpublish regulatori instrument enforc person purport appli basi individu decis person fact decis refus author decemb entri forc januari regul eec alter forego assess articl council regul eec forc prior regul eec includ similar provis decis decemb continu affect situat decemb inform commiss corrobor repli set french author provid march pursu polici year year promot expans pari cdg airport main continent european gatewai larg hub airport fact compar situat european airport physic potenti expand consider march capac pari cdg increas consider termin oper question alloc traffic airport polici gradual transfer pari cdg airlin oper orli instanc octob cdg termin oper french author decid transfer foreign commun airlin orli west termin cdg refus author viva air oper madrid pari cdg servic run counter polici airport ground refus french govern oper rule airlin run servic medium haul intern rout pari orli pari cdg wonder rule appli medium haul intern traffic domest intern long haul servic french author differenti due type market involv turn long haul servic commiss note french flag carrier oper intern long haul servic departur orli cdg pari york frequenc compar intra commun airlin take medium haul servic commiss accept face explan provid french author oppos situat domest french flight intra commun intern flight oper singl compani serv orli cdg low level competit surfac transport low level traffic flow exist compet compani place gener complet separ nation intern intra commun flight contrari principl singl commun market domest french rout shortest competit surfac transport competit major intra commun intern rout depart pari thirdli differ size traffic flow great justifi treatment point pari london rout busiest intra commun rout lastli domest french flight open competit commun rule establish singl intern market civil aviat forc januari case suppos rule govern traffic alloc regard justifi provis articl regul eec commiss consid purpos appli rule viva air regard separ iberia articl regul simpli defin commun air carrier valid oper licenc issu member state accord regul eec refer question control iberia viva air incontest member group viva air found date contest applic traffic right oper licenc staff commerci imag fleet french author alleg commiss found abus law fraudul action part viva air iberia group view forego commiss consid case french author appli provis articl regul eec incorrectli wrong refus viva air author exercis traffic right madrid pari cdg rout januari accord provis articl regul eec decis french author continu appli measur examin point submit viva air found base discriminatori natur measur shown fact euralair oper direct flight madrid pari orli fact part air franc group oper madrid pari cdg rout adopt decis articl franc continu appli decis decemb refus viva air author exercis traffic right pari cdg madrid rout give reason airlin provid medium haul intern servic pari orli pari cdg articl decis address french republ commun viva air council member state brussel commiss abel matut member commiss oj oj oj oj oj