commiss decis decemb relat proceed articl eec treati iv aluminium import eastern europ dutch english french german italian text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul februari regul implement articl treati amend act access greec articl thereof regard notif pursuant articl regul regard commiss decis august initi proceed case undertak concern opportun make view object rais commiss pursuant articl regul commiss regul eec juli hear provid articl council regul consult advisori committe restrict practic domin posit fact agreement introduct arrang concern proceed confin sale primari eventu aluminium foreign trade organ ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ group western primari aluminium produc return purchas western parti primari aluminium ingot foreign trade organ undertook limit except sell aluminium ingot scrap secondari semi manufactur prospect purchas western world oper agreement involv entir primari aluminium industri eec western europ involv polic export eec efta countri unit state america south america divers tonnag ingot eec turkei japan english compani brandei goldschmidt swiss subsidiari brandei goldschmidt ag enter seri purchas agreement oj oj separ refer need compani hereinaft refer distinct quot brandei goldschmidt quot foreign trade organ raznoimport impexmet metalimpex keramet intrac eisen und metal aktiengesellschaft west german compani enter purchas agreement intrac seri sale agreement conclud brandei compani eisen und metal side primari aluminium produc provid resal quantiti deliv purchas agreement ancillari agreement concert practic parti western parti arrang directli purchas brandei compani eisen und metal indirectli receipt deliveri eastern metal contract nomin buyer set conveni annex produc primari aluminium integr vertic greater lesser extent brandei compani trader ferrou metal brandei goldschmidt full member london metal exchang lme eastern european parti foreign trade organ charg export aluminium legal person separ state domicil european primari aluminium associ epaa legal person law feder republ germani epaa found purpos constitut further common interest primari aluminium industri epaa regist offic aluminium zentral düsseldorf time associ found member list founder member annex purchas aluminium brandei agreement western produc parti brandei agreement member epaa nippon light metal nlm alugasa nlm european compani produc primari aluminium europ alugasa subsidiari exist member pechinei ugin kuhlmann puk inelig membership articl constitut epaa negoti agreement total quantiti novemb februari agre principl baco swiss aluminium montecatini vaw puk desir ascertain term raznoimport prepar sell export quota virgin aluminium exclus western european aluminium produc meet brandei goldschmidt author approach raznoimport summar note brandei goldschmidt meet brandei goldschmidt raznoimport place februari raznoimport interest principl negoti led conclus agreement moscow brandei goldschmidt buyer raznoimport seller baco swiss aluminium puk present exploratori meet brandei goldschmidt quot understood compani repres substanti western produc quot submiss uk registrar restrict trade practic baco brandei goldschmidt emploi sound russian baco swiss aluminium montecatini vaw puk identifi big western produc vsesojuznoj importno exportnoj objedinenij quot raznoimport quot ussr centrala importowo eksportowa quot impexmet quot przedsiebiorstwo panstwow poland metalimpex hungarian trade compani steel metal hungari keramet foreign trade czechoslovakia intrac handelsgesellschaft mbh ddr raznoimport separ ident confirm constitut section principl civil legisl law ussr decemb state liabl oblig state bodi legal person impexmet public corpor przedsiebiorstwo panstwow polish law separ person polish state metalimpex foreign trade compani legal person separ state liabl oblig extent asset articl hungarian civil code keramet regard czechoslovak law entiti separ state section law liabl oblig extent asset state liabl keramet oblig intrac full impli limit liabil genesi arrang reveal commiss januari text verbatim particular suppli baco uk registrar restrict trade practic baco respons put special public section uk regist letter commiss date januari quot willing particip arrang quot alcan uk vmw endasa elkem gränge asv compani bought eastern metal brandei goldschmidt agreement raznoimport renew end end end year gradual foreign trade organ appear seller accommod brandei goldschmidt agreement extend product ingot period period seller contract made conform date termin laid current raznoimport contract foreign trade organ seller potenti seller tonnag metal hope sell increas practic onward preced conclus individu quot brandei contract quot negoti total quantiti price call big western parti quot eastern metal confer quot text brandei agreement standard issu total tonnag price price variat derog exist contract tabl show total tonnag contract ad individu tonnag quot brandei agreement quot quot eastern metal confer quot surplu foreign trade organ tend lessen time difficulti western market place eastern metal confer concern tonnag price adjust eastern metal confer chairmanship share raznoimport swiss aluminium budapest confer attend western side swiss aluminium puk alcan baco brandei goldschmidt undertak eastern metal brandei goldschmidt accept result confer epaa form forum discuss oper brandei agreement resolv issu time time aris agreement occas gener meet epaa ask give full power negoti eastern metal confer agreement reach confer report epaa membership ratif agreement sought swiss aluminium appoint coordin quot spokesman quot western produc chairman epaa negoti team eastern metal confer appear consist epaa execut committe time negoti foreign trade organ joint western european produc shown activ particip support negoti take eastern metal take membership epaa analysi oper agreement brandei agreement reason tonnag origin contract reduc final deliveri shown tabl price dealt section essenc agreement prevent suppli aluminium come western market western european market brandei agreement record meet made brandei goldschmidt state quot russian guarante contractu quantiti export western world russia eastern countri period commenc present russian commit barter deal fulfil understand russian conclud deal moment quot brandei goldschmidt confirm raznoimport meet februari quot brandei goldschmidt explain principl interest bui entir product aluminium produc socialist republ export western market provid guarante quantiti bought sold direct barter deal market quot asv endasa elkem giulini holland aluminium vaw vmw nlm gränge montedison result eastern metal confer venic quantiti ingot brandei goldschmidt reduc suit western produc glut time price tonn remaind increas foreign trade organ forbidden sell result surplu prohibit countri promis sell brandei price agreement made impexmet provis permit export tonn primari aluminium process semi manufactur product quot member buyer group quot western produc begin parti adopt draft devic eastern european seller undertook quot sell countri quot list except countri except limit product primari aluminium ad list sold quot countri quot agreement expressli permit sale semi manufactur raznoimport agreement raznoimport agre restrain export unit kingdom aluminium sheet tabl show schemat product limit introduc includ restrict barter deal mention begin contractu countri includ territori open sale foreign trade organ thought central interest western produc contractu limit design protect western produc tabl contract raznoimport claus quot spirit agreement quot claus introduc quot appar period juli june export aluminium sourc import interfer spirit agreement seller buyer renegoti term quot quot spirit agreement quot defin intend cover consid ground frustrat contract dealt contract quot frustrat quot claus explicitli includ quot prohibit import export quot reli impexmet intrac govern forbad export raznoimport contract quot conting quot interfer spirit agreement quot appear export tonnag foreign trade organ connect agreement raznoimport supplementari letter brandei goldschmidt confirm agreement bulgarian export deduct tonnag due bought russia quot spirit agreement quot formula stop restrict sale aluminium ingot ensur quantiti permit contractu export sold price endang aluminium market agreement onward formula cover conting aluminium sold lme quota aluminium cabl exceed eisen und metal agreement brandei goldschmidt agreement east german foreign trade organ intrac march eisen und metal made agreement intrac import aluminium german democrat republ agreement state framework agreement made brandei goldschmidt intrac contract contractu quantiti increas tonn yearli quota increas correspondingli agre deliveri place framework berlin agreement trade feder republ germani german democrat republ claus intrac undertook export primari aluminium semi manufactur feder republ germani contractu quantiti agreement intrac laps end forc majeur negoti fourth seri intent parti fresh agreement negoti run januari decemb copenhagen confer succeed extend exist contract month order bui negoti time foreign trade organ wish free sell unit state japan send aluminium western europ process permiss western produc wish send aluminium forbidden territori part barter deal propos baco quot ridicul quot telex baco state quot usa cover agreement eas switch merchant back european market quot alcan uk asv suggest usa quot free countri quot export semi manufactur limit tonn baco asv felt quantiti semi manufactur western produc differ western produc foreign trade organ resolv negoti end juli august brandei western produc brandei goldschmidt made sale contract western produc serial number letter prefix repres countri origin summari agreement set annex origin text agreement reproduc materi term agreement made brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ set full restrict impos suppli foreign trade organ primari secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur amend made histori set agreement made brandei goldschmidt seri agreement made conclud brandei goldschmidt ag wholli own swiss subsidiari brandei goldschmidt letter commiss date januari brandei goldschmidt explain quot agreement made brandei goldschmidt ag brandei goldschmidt onward elimin necess regist agreement registrar restrict trade practic quot registrar call detail agreement regist oper agreement epaa membership time epaa found founder member purchas aluminium brandei agreement member join epaa invit swiss aluminium quota aluminium purchas brandei contract invit express term made clear particip brandei arrang duti ow member epaa member allot western produc aluminium purchas brandei agreement distribut particip ratio particip share sale western europ ratio calcul swiss aluminium basi inform sale aluminium particip requir disclos compani includ sale sale primari aluminium parti deliveri primari aluminium subsidiari compani deliveri europ produc swap transact sale inform request relat calendar year request quota assign year quota establish refer sale figur disclos request septemb inform quota establish particip member epaa previous produc primari aluminium estim product year procedur adopt anglesei aluminium kaiser preussag metallgesellschaft alsar procedur oper life agreement swiss aluminium inform compani prescrib quota circular letter circul quot eastern metal distribut quot list list fix quota circul epaa member member made awar amount eastern metal purchas event epaa member disput amount quota member swiss aluminium investig explan epaa member tonnag metal bought brandei goldschmidt shown contract annual basi tabl basic framework arrang agreement made brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ agreement brandei goldschmidt western produc western produc notabl vaw rtz bicc part sign standard form brandei agreement primari aluminium sold brandei agreement swap particip quota reserv japan agreement made brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ purchas nlm agreement ru quota amount total purchas brandei agreement eisen und metal agreement supersed brandei agreement intrac vaw agre entir quota tonn eisen und metal vaw made agreement alusuiss deutschland gmbh kaiser preussag aluminium gmbh metallgesellschaft ag gebrüder giulini gmbh aluminium purchas intrac distribut west german aluminium produc half alusuiss agre share supplementari quota attribut giulini kaiser preussag metallgesellschaft intrac withdrew agreement export primari aluminium prohibit govern german democrat republ restrict resal eastern metal aluminium ingot sold brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal agreement carri cast mark relev produc parti recogn origin aluminium remelt understand western produc eastern metal sold parti remelt origin longer recogn alcan contend hear uneconom remelt ingot sale primari unalloi remelt ingot repli swiss aluminium vaw vmw remelt result increas cost refer remelt specif purpos chang set mark origin evid oral hear commiss ad pot virgin aluminium left product cell eastern metal melt addit cost leav furnac temperatur aluminium aluminium melt western produc deni restrict quot oblig quot alcan admit quot currenc agreement alcan thought understand kind quot swiss aluminium refer letter time quot gentlemen agreement quot quot understand quot quot point understand epaa member eastern metal sold parti remelt origin longer recogn quot telex swiss aluminium novemb contract ru alsar rotterdam port discharg employe swiss aluminium put manuscript note copi receiv quot alsar eastern metal simpli resold remelt work quot remark doubt prompt notorieti rotterdam centr free market aluminium swiss aluminium repli alsar quot metal sold parti remelt free sell directli western produc quot document show commiss find fact understand purpos prevent resal outsid origin form parti alleg remelt technic necess custom remelt facil potenti custom posit user scrap rank integr produc ingot puriti sweeten necess trader remelt epaa member sell eastern metal origin condit understand resel parti remelt gener respect accept onward sale made epaa member subsidiari remelt vmw vaw sold small quantiti parti remelt vmw ask quota aluminium russia suppli mark call quot neutral quot form receiv neg answer raznoimport hear vmw ask made request repli eastern metal bought vmw gener sold countri common market easier vmw remelt show technic necess remelt necess understand polic understand aluminium ingot sold brandei arrang buyer request puriti western parti maintain gener low market commiss accept market limit reason western produc interest remelt upgrad ad metal higher puriti make differ melt temperatur aluminium higher exit temperatur cell extent technic necess remelt parti state remelt arrang enforc brandei arrang ensur brand eastern metal appear western market mean adher foreign trade organ oblig export western countri verifi sale epaa member instanc quota allot western produc includ amount western produc arrang produc concern arrang natur made alcan vaw swiss aluminium rtz bicc vaw compani agre brandei goldschmidt negoti raznoimport record agreement made vaw brandei goldschmidt conclud purchas aluminium impexmet repli statement object vaw state quot particip concert purchas eastern aluminium june quot repli question hear repres vaw declar quot respect particip vaw correct unequivoc join concert action decis discuss enter oblig made agreement quot statement wholli accur account particip vaw brandei agreement evid show vaw compani appoint brandei goldschmidt negoti agreement raznoimport particip agreement incept precis method vaw particip brandei agreement disclos commiss alcan letter januari make clear alcan accept vaw alloc eastern metal arrang raznoimport metalimpex intrac return alcan agreement accept alloc eastern metal behalf vaw agre purchas alcan tonnag aluminium product practic purchas call alcan matter dealt vaw alcan repli vaw unabl particip directli brandei contract import eastern aluminium feder republ germani time prohibit strictli limit quota assign swiss aluminium onward includ amount purchas rtz bicc quota ultim purchas correspond respect share initi estim product subsequ sale anglesei aluminium calcul refer percentag share capit anglesei aluminium held rtz bicc particip rtz bicc appear arrang manner order avoid provis uk restrict trade practic act anglesei aluminium agre decemb accept oblig aluminium brandei agreement result member epaa januari rtz quot legal technic problem quot relat particip consult baco length quot attempt find formula offend uk trade practic court quot ask swiss aluminium prepar make agreement rtz assum commit quot master agreement quot eastern metal distribut list show quota assign alcan canada includ parti share amount eastern metal alcan includ amount proportion sale alcan compani europ amount proportion share kaiser aluminium chemic corpor sale alcan booth industri materi time kaiser held sharehold mosal jointli own subsidiari elkem aluminium compani america alcoa sign purchas agreement brandei goldschmidt similar agreement made elkem quota allot agreement calcul refer mosal quot sale western europ quot sale western europ made alcoa elkem sign brandei agreement quota allot relat sale made alcoa directli mosal long term arrang involv alcan vaw swiss aluminium rtz kaiser bicc elkem alcoa instanc eastern metal pass hand western metal produc addit ad hoc sale swap eastern metal made time time epaa member daili trade enforc agreement introduct object effect seri agreement made brandei goldschmidt western aluminium produc foreign trade organ manner implement enforc act regard infring durat brandei arrang step western produc enforc term restrict foreign trade organ enter enforc agreement agreement made raznoimport brandei goldschmidt expressli permit suppli raznoimport aluminium semi manufactur uk independ dealer ferrou stockhold made contract import tonn aluminium sheet uk govern recent aluminium sheet quot open gener licenc quot list result trade agreement uk govern govern ussr ferrou stockhold sought avail opportun trade present learn ferrou stockhold contract alcan uk baco swiss aluminium jointli prevent perform oblig raznoimport undertak export aluminium sheet unit kingdom alcan uk telex messag date alcan intern explain quot alcan sa telex april baco take view present posit aris metal negoti insist complet cancel sheet contract russian ferrou metal opinion agre tonn year russian sheet influenc stabil uk continent market step prevent baco refus baco signatur metal contract russian undertak write refrain repeat export semi western europ request advis line meet zurich anglesei aluminium origin held rtz bicc rtz bicc bicc ceas sharehold decemb remain sharehold kaiser aluminium chemic corpor major sharehold end share capit mondai understand alcan sa alcan uk repres group quot letter date raznoimport undertook export tonn aluminium sheet unit kingdom period decemb quot spirit agreement quot claus appear metalimpex undertook quot handl sale semi manufactur aluminium product spirit agreement quot parti meant sale semi manufactur held pre exist level baco memorandum date septemb record quot condit contract requir russian limit export aluminium semi unit kingdom tonn period contract tonn addit tonn order deliv hungarian effect agre limit semi sale unit kingdom prevail level tonn annum quot enforc agreement letter date juli swiss aluminium brandei goldschmidt show infring seri place step epaa member remedi infring letter set infring tabular form copi reproduc tabl letter show main remedi epaa member deni advantag foreign trade organ deliveri excess agre quota deduct excess quota year run brandei agreement recurr shortag aluminium scrap eec countri western europ polici western european countri concern restrict import aluminium scrap uk secondari smelter made repeat represent uk board trade allevi shortag scrap associ light alloi refin smelter point russia major supplier scrap uk market import russia amount tonn sourc quot complet dri quot occas primari smelter unit kingdom maintain adequ suppli primari aluminium replac scrap primari aluminium costli scrap secondari smelter complaint breach eastern metal agreement action enforc agreement summar tabl partli overlap tabl action enforc respect deliveri eec restrict contain agreement brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ set detail raznoimport complaint made brandei goldschmidt august deliveri tonn primari ingot rotterdam account metal dealer messr panchaud frère sa raznoimport receiv repli letter matter panchaud frère brandei goldschmidt repli quot note receiv repli messr panchaud frère sa tonn russian aluminium ship rotterdam basl agreement suppli conclus evid materi virgin aluminium ingot russian origin ship russia deduct tonnag fourth quarter alloc quot complaint made endasa suppli spanish cabl maker echevarria hermano sa tonn aluminium ingot ussr origin complaint contain letter date novemb address epaa düsseldorf state quot confirm telex import aluminium ingot ussr spanish import licenc issu spanish cabl manufactur quot echevarria hermano sa quot cover kg aluminium ingot cif spanish port price equival lb countri origin metal shown ussr quot swiss aluminium repli telex date novemb price notic lower price rule brandei agreement tonn quot letter novemb epaa address letter eastern metal zürich quot call endasa provid detail eventu establish swiss aluminium consign question origin destin unit kingdom brandei agreement ship western produc concern impexmet offer made swiss aluminium tonn polish aluminium prompt letter date juli swiss aluminium brandei goldschmidt term quot offer constitut violat agreement order disrupt market swiss aluminium decid purchas metal let offer independ aluminium user quantiti tonn deduct quota suppli impexmet group prove case impexmet warsaw send herewith origin certif analysi issu huta aluminium quot konin quot consequ total quantiti impexmet current year reduc long ton kindli advis impexmet quot swiss aluminium complain activ british metal trader sell polish aluminium argentina telex messag date decemb brandei goldschmidt state quot reliabl inform british metal corpor offer argentina polish metal tonn deliver dai claus price lower request withdraw offer sale made deduct quot decemb swiss aluminium made complaint brandei goldschmidt quot hungarian polish metal subsidiari satral belgium receiv offer landa metal tonn tonn offer habit bad effect price level supplier stop nonsens quot messag convei impexmet metalimpex metalimpex letter date brandei goldschmidt swiss aluminium sought withdraw quotat hungarian aluminium alfa romeo spa letter term quot inform hungarian metalimpex offer suppli alfa romeo tonn aluminium alloi al si suppli tonn action constitut violat present contract deadlin contract octob date quotat year allow good protest withdraw quotat tonn suppli year deduct year quot tonn suppli alfa romeo spa purchas quantiti metalimpex foreign trade organ metalimex keramet januari slovakian compani keramet respons metalimex suppli aluminium brandei agreement clear compani keramet sought releas restrict brandei agreement brandei goldschmidt meet juli remind keramet quot secondari aluminium semi alloi virgin aluminium discuss regret section agreement amend deviat quot intrac earli intrac disclos brandei goldschmidt contract sale tonn aluminium wire tonn primari ingot feder republ germani intrac propos deduct tonn total tonn suppli brandei agreement brandei goldschmidt repli januari quot friend agre sale aluminium wire result deduct aluminium ingot brandei price time tonn cash document refer respect letter date june friend insist cancel contract wire deliv ingot realiz difficulti cancel exist contract conclud order find solut propos deliv tonn ingot year quantiti deduct eventu contract confirm major unpleas aris quot intrac repli understand quot unpleas quot aris intrac deduct amount question quota sell brandei agreement argument brandei goldschmidt repli quot contract brandei goldschmidt basl doubt sale tonn prohibit posit materi sold dia deduct preced sale infring protest deduct confirm letter date june sale made dia word treat transact except circumst give dia make sale deduct equival tonnag contract basl agre give right make nonsens contract basl give option sell semi ingot market favour price agreement price deduct tonnag case deliv tonn ingot call forward chang programm deduct quot brandei goldschmidt suppli swiss aluminium copi telex messag exchang intrac tonn aluminium undertook swiss aluminium inform brandei goldschmidt inform swiss aluminium quot parcel reduc tonn made convers contract direct sale quot activ intrac continu subject complaint swiss aluminium inform brandei goldschmidt quot learnt feder republ germani german democrat republ offer tonn year protest strongli intrac bound agreement action place octob provid agreement reach date quot brandei goldschmidt rais matter intrac explain quot talk quot concern quot inform case agreement quot disclos intrac sold tonn feder republ germani propos deduct quantiti quota quot intrac told sold end year tonn feder republ germani reason gave concern involv financi transact sell materi mention quantiti deduct quot inform produc spirit reaction swiss aluminium letter june swiss aluminium declar quot alarm receiv letter june contact vaw order find metal sold success feel strongli accept statement intrac demand withdraw sale run contract broken intention simultan offer deduct quantiti futur contract purpos spirit contract eastern metal sold western european produc independ aluminium user remain question price quot consequ complaint brandei goldschmidt letter june intrac quot regard tonn sold deliveri end feder republ germani friend perturb new demand withdraw sale contraven basl agreement complet spirit agreement quot matter resolv swiss aluminium made complaint eisen und metal offer aluminium german democrat republ purchas feder republ telex messag june relai term swiss aluminium complaint intrac quot eisen und metal gelsenkirchen offer east german aluminium dm free custom tonn juli tonn septemb tonn octob part free quota vaw quot interzonenabkommen quot import gdr aluminium dm million tonn tonn brandei tonn free quota approxim dm million gdr west german regul export approxim tonn feder republ germani constitut violat present contract intrac withdraw offer immedi quot intrac subsequ deni offer suppli tonnag question eisen und metal enforc agreement enforc effort summar tabl show pattern vigil market place vigor protest alleg infring agreement complaint show western produc prepar resist contract activ foreign trade organ permit forbidden contract swiss aluminium view raznoimport exhibit merchandis exhibit export good ussr held basl repli date raznoimport undertook displai high puriti aluminium roll product state offer sale quantiti aluminium grade fair export raznoimport impexmet aluminium dross aluminium drew protest raznoimport repli export aluminium dross prohibit agreement brandei goldschmidt maintain aluminium content dross deduct primari metal purchas occas notabl intrac wish sell feder republ germani brandei agreement offer deduct amount involv year quota brandei goldschmidt refus period western produc insist prior author convers contract aluminium eastern europ convert semi manufactur export eastern europ knowledg transact order ensur brandei agreement circumv occas western produc complain offer sale eastern foreign trade organ unit state countri market contractu bound eastern european foreign trade organ complaint princip concern local competit author show determin western produc enforc agreement relev eec possibl good find back eec recogn western produc abort negoti agreement raznoimport prepar draft ad countri bound raznoimport japan canada unit state thailand alcan uk stipul thailand quot free quot baco state telex swiss aluminium june quot usa cover agreement eas switch merchant back european market quot complaint made import itali yugoslav aluminium occas metal yugoslav swiss aluminium occas wrote letter januari raznoimport quot metal sell itali bear mark obviou metal intern export export basi import ussr solut curtail export yugoslavia long dump metal manner itali quot meet work group hungarian italian commiss econom cooper joint govern industri bodi held budapest januari februari hungarian interest italian technolog begin product hungari aerosol can italian deleg express interest hungarian aluminium slug semi manufactur payment notic swiss aluminium italian subsidiari swiss aluminium caus brandei goldschmidt interven metalimpex agre slug cover brandei agreement impos annual ceil tonn export semi manufactur metal impex enforc oblig eastern metal membership epaa entail oblig bui prescrib quota eastern metal observ oblig supervis member epaa execut committe alsar inform brandei goldschmidt unabl deliveri tonn balanc quota epaa execut committe compos swiss aluminium puk montedison ardal vaw baco put pressur alsar consign consign assum member epaa alsar quota epaa member swiss aluminium telex alumet septemb request assist compani compel alsar meet contractu commit alsar comment incid statement legal advis hear quot reluct part alsar obviou start plant financ alsar keen assum part quota brandei agreement side imposs system oligopolist system produc sell aluminium friendli relationship produc document show stage alsar member epaa assum quota end convinc fair strong necess sell distribut metal quot price object begin begin object western produc prevent fluctuat price quantiti import tabl show belgium luxemburg quantiti increas significantli previou year respect unit kingdom import peak threshold agre govern govern octob origin group western produc agre novemb februari quot desir ascertain term raznoimport prepar sell export quota virgin aluminium exclus western european aluminium produc disrupt western aluminium market sell dump price merchant consum market quot point put contemporan tactfulli brandei goldschmidt raznoimport passag set brandei goldschmidt quot opinion advantag proposit place receiv return aluminium outlet fix tonnag undoubtedli aluminium offer barter deal depress price undermin world price structur idea arrang distribut serv merchant consum receiv metal past minimum disturb exist price structur quot report western produc meet raznoimport brandei goldschmidt state quot consid negoti intim raznoimport back produc interest explain main reason approach preserv exist price structur interest quot particular suppli baco respons notic issu uk registrar restrict trade practic section restrict trade practic act contract raznoimport permit sell inter alia argentina sweden undertook sell countri quot price lower mention agreement quot intrac made compar agreement respect sweden letter date raznoimport amend agreement substanti free sell billet price quot undermin spirit agreement quot similar price claus appear agreement foreign trade organ possibl export small quantiti semi manufactur eec left open brandei agreement freedom exist case raznoimport metalimpex parti agre quot lower price aluminium product endang aluminium market undermin agreement seller undertak handl sale semi manufactur aluminium product spirit agreement quot commit confin small quota semi manufactur permit sold countri except countri gener commit raznoimport metalimpex export sale complaint made western produc violat agreement show price exacerb factor polish metal argentina decemb swiss aluminium complain offer subsidiari belgium tonn net quot bad effect price level quot complaint small import sheet unit kingdom russia point price import statist list price undercut stockhold price complaint low price made year involv export yugoslavia russian price worri western produc obviou repli commiss statement object alcan quot ussr sell small increas quantiti metal london tonn alcan export price equal discount quot support statement year produc list price discount unit state nation bureau econom research consid time quot larg buyer find aluminium cent list price quot repres discount russian establish market addit discount weak market untoward quantiti trade free market margin mean price tend volatil weak market drop establish supplier knowledg transact price time russian western produc assess low russian price western produc argu russian price unfair prior impli brandei arrang eastern european price continu unfair point unprov argument pre price conclus elkem call quot polit quot price suppli errat eastern organ intend collect western currenc made dear hard currenc object eastern organ continu content rtz argu price unfair eastern european enjoi monopoli posit domest market fear retali impun sell excess quantiti quot price cover margin cost quot true margin cost averag cost eastern produc commiss rtz attract argument unprov assert alcan alleg russian price dump sought prove alcan base calcul domest market price primari aluminium ussr work publish kuznetsov price quot work convert dollar preval offici rate exchang alcan show brandei price dump price sale price tsenoobrazovani tsvetnoi metallurgii price format ferrou metallurgi kuznetsov publish metallurgiya ussr level increas margin dump argument depend rate exchang notion convert currenc convert state alcan expert hear repli question commerci signific offici exchang rate quot domest price system complet disarticul extern price system usual measur purchas power pariti simpli appli quot transcript page kuznetsov work reli alcan contain comparison western market price ussr domest price confirm hear comparison base ussr offici dollar roubl rate exchang method alcan purport show dump rule gatt respect state trade countri partli difficulti reli offici rate exchang public author entrust determin dump method adopt legisl give effect supplementari note articl vi gatt price brandei agreement western produc paid price grade aluminium purchas foreign trade organ brandei eisen agreement addit purchas paid commiss brandei goldschmidt consider servic agent rate commiss charg tonn purchas zurich eastern metal confer june price fix refer quot price canadian uk aluminium deliv work publish current issu quot metal bulletin quot london quot agre discount deduct price publish metal bulletin fact alcan list price hear director alcan explain quot alcan largest produc metal independ compani world largest export metal canada tend compani publish price competit price time quantiti need sell give unit kingdom metal ship unit kingdom sold independ compani complet free bui quot transcript page price juli fix tonn decemb tonn price rais tonn februari zurich eastern metal confer april parti agre price tonn uk list price minu whichev higher brno confer septemb formula adopt price pound sterl convert currenc refer averag rate exchang quot eleven member currenc quot list price formula result pari eastern metal confer held octob formula introduc half averag list price largest produc netherland feder republ germani spain itali franc japan austria switzerland norwai sweden unit kingdom belgium discount dissatisfact raznoimport price receiv part metal bulletin free transact price higher list price led adopt call quot venic formula quot averag nation list price discount metal bulletin price discount quot munich formula quot adopt venic formula discount repli request inform commiss pursuant articl regul brandei goldschmidt list price calcul purchas price brandei agreement quot principl check produc countri concern quot method alcan lead conclus suppli ussr sell price western european price order avoid charg dump produc holland aluminium vaw endasa alumet puk nlm vmw swiss aluminium ardal og sunndal verk gränge aluminium alcan uk alcan end brandei goldschmidt submit list price alcan confirm parti freeli exchang inform price alcan primari sourc inform express uncertainti commiss paid brandei goldschmidt run brandei agreement brandei goldschmidt receiv commiss tonn primari aluminium sold agreement amount commiss receiv set tabl comparison price exact comparison price paid brandei agreement western market price difficult degre vertic integr industri impli intermedi product sold transfer produc group sale ingot minor sale primari aluminium product includ import categori roll slab extrus billet wire bar ingot remelt ingot usabl form unlik billet roll slab market limit purchas remelt facil trader subsequ resal allow made duti differ condit suppli differ puriti differ term payment matter discuss exchang letter metalimpex brandei goldschmidt letter date april metalimpex queri discount canadian uk list price price agre brandei agreement term quot virgin aluminium ingot canadian price metal bulletin allow agre discuss price formula accept told western partner includ compani met loss price contract canadian price sixteen pound sterl sell aluminium bought socialist countri allow grant client exceed price canadian quaotat contract term case cif port destin countri rememb full allow western partner grant client canadian price compos factor duti gener amount cover seller sale effect client premis cover seller dai financ fee reimburs seller buyer highli confirm argument mention accept part allow grant client canadian price experi past year amount club insist price contract envisag year fix quot letter date april brandei goldschmidt repli term quot refer letter date april discount contract aluminium brandei goldschmidt ag basl western produc sell aluminium duti paid deliv work gener dai payment depend duti countri estim case cover abovement negoti discount mention realist figur alcan uk explain reason alcan ask confirm list price quot alcan intern organ wide knowledg domest market list price set local aluminium produc readili verifi correct price calcul brandei quot letter commiss octob repres discount approxim present market condit add contract conclud discount quot duti metalimpex letter refer duti payabl buyer eastern metal purchas level duti amount payabl import eec common extern tariff cet unit kingdom access levi duti import primari aluminium western produc import eastern metal unit kingdom alcan baco lesser extent swiss aluminium puk meet ad cost eastern metal differ condit suppli price paid brandei agreement cif price western european port price contain element meet cost transport port buyer smelter price western produc gener deliv price necessarili cost element provid transport work question natur expect produc deliv price higher produc cif price equival transact involv foreign sale tabl produc swiss aluminium brno eastern metal confer show allow quot handl inland freight quot feder republ germani franc netherland belgium itali unit kingdom austria switzerland allow deduct inter alia swiss aluminium quot free deliv quot price countri order calcul quot net price cif term quot differ puriti grade purchas brandei agreement gener shipment made repli alcan quot gener run product modern smelter metal puriti quot quot compar smelter instal instal date princip improv iv averag qualiti metal produc reduct process improv pure aluminium order pure aluminium quot letter januari refer aluminium compani canada refer ingot quot commerci grade quot price establish metal bulletin quot canadian uk deliv quot ingot show premium payabl ingot higher puriti amount premium ingot price metal bulletin quot transact quot price record premium similar size higher puriti ingot minimum premium charg custom waiv natur depend state market alcan repli refer matter term quot supplier waiv reduc premia form effect price competit quot hear baco quot common practic produc charg premium metal quot quot premium start quot premium puriti fact charg western produc brandei agreement provid premium paid shipment puriti aluminium premium paid shipment hear baco matter quot concess quot made quot part give commerci negoti quot differ payment term repli alcan quot term payment repres import element contract suppli aluminium grant extend payment term effect competit weapon cost supplier supplier occas offer discount prompt payment quot alcan recal discount prompt payment term payment offer western produc custom dai swiss aluminium longer term dai grant alcan state standard term net refer made quot super puriti quot grade understood form market monthli account give averag dai credit alcan term extend meet competit brandei agreement provid payment cash document quot payment effect dai receipt telegraph advic bank supplier countri document receiv seller dispatch buyer quot word credit discount prompt payment term caus surpris rtz bicc join group buyer reaction rtz evidenc exchang correspond compani time sharehold anglesei aluminium bui allot quota eastern metal swiss aluminium bicc state letter rtz aluminium date novemb quot receiv swiss aluminium confirm order tonn russian aluminium made direct comment term absolut deplor intrigu acknowledg state tonn cif weston point expens part negoti whatsoev refer leav situat wide open charg defin annoi term payment hasti accept dai date invoic payment dai date invoic insult buyer profession abil mystifi accept quot rtz aluminium repli june term quot disput swiss aluminium interest charg russian metal shipment take pretti hard line squeal hard final accept act agent matter rightli wrongli feel perform servic industri agre prompt payment term place quot bicc repli june term quot matter thought opinion acced request felt contract gener worst suggest prompt payment aluminium ludicr thing heard long time quot factor set account comparison price paid brandei agreement obtain western produc argu strongli gener intention pai quot premium quot foreign trade organ sens price notic price achiev similar transact price disclos close brandei level produc concern argu brandei price quot line quot quot compar quot price achiev western market hear puk set show brandei price quot arm length quot compar price puk transact price transcript page sale primari ingot integr structur industri major compon total aluminium sale case puk sale ingot independ user amount volum aluminium sale contemporan view buyer western undertak argu price paid time appear discont exchang correspond quot content alcan proceed brandei price dump price statement made western produc run brandei agreement regard aluminium bought agreement cheap western produc remark high price expect pai illustr passag relat period meet held juli board trade alcan baco compani record state quot tonn extra soviet bloc meant tonn western group suppli sourc repres increas quot danegeld quot western group aid maintain stabl market quot similar refer made price paid brandei agreement baco note rome eastern metal confer januari quot ussr romania posit increas quot danegeld quot protect market disrupt exist contract tonn east sell free condit price quot zurich eastern metal confer held septemb consider discuss discount canadian uk deliv work price publish metal bulletin previou eastern metal confer puk argu increas discount brandei price time set metal bulletin publish list price discount tonn zurich confer swiss aluminium puk alcan baco ardal og sunndal verk press discount foreign trade organ grant discount size baco note zurich confer baco thought quot eastern group back counter offer discount small concess payment term quot baco consid discount repres price lower rule west quot event level price eastern metal western fabric plant charg sourc west quot eventu agreement discount price canadian uk aluminium deliv work publish metal bulletin alcan consid price paid agreement burden letter aluminium compani canada date januari alcan uk state quot cent discount extrem low purchas quantiti present agreement cash surrend ship document requir make oner discount credit term provid eastern bloc hot metal return neighbourhood cent lb excess western produc obtain quot letter aluminium compani canada alcan uk date march refer made letter term quot previou letter drew attent fact cent uk list coupl cash document burden push lower price quot document prepar swiss aluminium brno confer septemb puk copenhagen confer decemb show price paid brandei agreement gener market price document design produc eastern foreign trade organ element plead price comparison occas notabl brandei price higher statutorili control list price unit kingdom itali evid norwegian produc sold primari aluminium germani brandei price document suppli bicc hear clear compani resold part quota brandei tax levi england ninth centuri provid protect england dane ethelr redeless quot normal bui dane quot trevelyan shorten histori england assess prob forgotten undertak concern make case uk board trade document undertak exchang intend outsid time eastern metal import unit kingdom incur import duti swiss aluminium document compar brandei price metal bulletin quot transact quot averag price quot dealer small consign reflect margin market reason quot transact quot price challeng subsequ western produc accur represent real market price metal bulletin price regard alcan baco reliabl indic price unit kingdom aluminium eastern europ agreement free market incur substanti loss loss brandei price averag loss strike fact sale eastern metal rtz partner anglesei aluminium take quota eastern metal brandei agreement bicc incur loss brandei price letter date februari depart trade industri alcan declar quot report romanian sale offer aluminium cent lb level ingot tonn metal bulletin publish current index quot transact quot regard report confirm metal bulletin reliabl indic price unit kingdom eastern metal quot alcan list price time cent lb romanian metal sell appar discount aluminium ingot countri eastern europ romania yugoslavia sold free market unit kingdom countri western europ commun probabl expens romanian metal western produc awar foreign trade organ compet price romanian metal meet held septemb alcan repres report board trade quot romanian hide skirt agreement russian object ground free match romanian competit strong argument make agreement quot remov romania eastern european competitor effect brandei agreement baco enabl romanian supplier rais price effect agreement industri background commerci product process primari aluminium pass stage metal bauxit alumina primari aluminium primari aluminium subsequ work wide varieti semi finish ultim finish product scrap aris product process excess contamin clean product scrap product primari metal primari produc case cycl aluminium product scrap produc secondari metal secondari aluminium necessarili lower degre puriti primari aluminium product foundri cast alloi alloi typic aluminium establish integr primari aluminium produc control western world bauxit capac compani own world capac exclud ussr hungari romania peopl republ china primari aluminium produc control western world alumina capac compani western world capac primari aluminium obtain electrolyt reduct alumina electrolyt reduct process prodigi consum electr usa aluminium industri consum suppli electr smelter tonn annual capac consum approxim quantiti electr town inhabit surpris locat primari smelter strongli influenc avail cheap abund suppli electr gener rule hydro electr power cheapest sourc electr oil fire power station expens proportion relianc sourc fuel countri set tabl cost energi aluminium produc vari wide oecd estim rang extend cent cent kwh cost rang estim cent consumpt electr rang kwh tonn produc older smelter kwh modern plant cent differ energi cost equival differ final cost primari aluminium brandei price time tonn discount report prepar lead canadian financi analyst appear alcan energi cost incur canada lowest western world quot alcan canadian power cost rang cent pound worldwid competitor advantag widen come year quot princip reason alcan price leader western produc primari aluminium produc western europ puk swiss aluminium baco vaw began product shortli montedison produc fulli integr entri product bauxit alumina product world war undertak embark product primari aluminium western europ partnership associ establish produc joint ventur arrang natur secur access bauxit alumina number entrant withdrawn partnership enter primari aluminium product leav field integr produc partner rel posit lead produc primari aluminium eec western europ summar tabl produc swiss aluminium puk alcan vaw baco montedison alumet asv account period consider primari aluminium product western europ earli produc countri greec ghana iceland netherland cameroon enter world trade aluminium reduc share world trade usa canada norwai franc practic western export primari aluminium consider proport trade primari aluminium take form deliveri produc integr subsidiari locat countri export greec cameroon made franc puk hold control interest primari smelter countri export ghana kaiser reynold made japan unit state unit kingdom canada norwai ussr world lead export primari aluminium world lead produc primari aluminium usa recent year net import primari aluminium eec long net import primari aluminium commun franc netherland net export virtual primari aluminium produc engag product semi manufactur produc finish product remelt scrap product secondari aluminium scale oper primari aluminium process fabric undertak produc origin primari ingot earli appear member industri degre vertic integr estim estim entir industri individu member industri highli integr addit estim averag group aluminium product group product subject higher degre vertic integr gener speak roll product sector plate sheet strip foil highli integr extrud drawn product sector rod section tube wire turn highli integr cast sector high degre vertic integr produc import econom effect independ produc semi finish product oblig seek suppli produc competitor manufactur product access sourc market intermedi product bauxit alumina primari aluminium exist margin comparison market semi finish good difficult establish market price intermedi product effect transfer highli integr sector cast depend suppli secondari metal scrap ingot sector suppli ingot low puriti need assumpt made made industri integr part secondari semi market total consumpt primari aluminium europ greenshield report februari alcan quot fair substanti accur quot effect market brandei agreement quantit effect provis brandei agreement summar tabl primari aluminium western produc reluct bui fact bui primari ingot foreign trade organ consid offer virtual occas seri brandei agreement negoti primari ingot offer foreign trade organ consider greater amount eventu agre agre amount frequent reduc request western produc eastern metal confer budapest eastern metal confer held octob quot western group quot achiev reduct quantiti deliv brno confer septemb quota half reduc tonn similarli venic eastern metal confer held contractu quota remain deliv allot tonn reduc western produc refus foreign trade organ sell deduct tonnag western market compromis eventu reach foreign trade organ permit sell japan turkei contractu tonnag half reduc munich eastern metal confer held novemb tabl set differ tonnag orgin agre sold brandei agreement tabl set differ offer foreign trade organ amount sold case differ consider doubt open offer foreign trade organ contain element bazaar bargain evid adduc proceed show foreign trade organ suppli quantiti primari aluminium offer case ussr hungari product capac expand consider brandei agreement czechoslovakia german democrat republ product fallen short rate capac refus govern german democrat republ poland permit export aluminium effect contractu quantiti western produc want negoti hard extent pai tonn reduc quantiti ensur surplu reach market rout assumpt integr part secondari semi market total consumpt primari aluminium europ effect integr market tabl alcan baco made applic uk author imposit anti dump duti romanian aluminium time romanian import unit kingdom tonn annum metallgesellschaft statist baco applic support alcan refer fact quot uk market consumpt tonn ti financi link long term contract quot quot romanian import repres substanti tonnag relat limit integr market quot romanian sale repres unti consumpt unit kingdom baco applic state absenc sale quot probabl compani obtain return tonn higher realiz quot time averag price receiv baco sale independ purchas tonn repres discount alcan list price tonn effect romanian sale baco view reduc price time import unit kingdom eastern european primari aluminium brandei agreement tonn annum commiss concern effect price unit kingdom time reason assum eastern metal free brandei constraint parallel effect commun figur analog probabl effect price eec brandei tonnag reach market brandei restrict market secondari aluminium scrap market primari secondari aluminium relat movement price primari aluminium affect price secondari aluminium quantiti primari aluminium product price secondari aluminium affect avail price chief raw materi scrap import type scrap quot quot quot clean product quot scrap sourc larg control establish integr aluminium produc oper materi aris secondari produc larg depend primari produc suppli princip raw materi total annual quota brandei agreement secondari scrap juli june free restrict juli june free restrict januari decemb tonn januari decemb tonn januari june tonn tabl show total consumpt secondari aluminium member state eec import scrap eec countri year end accept materi brandei quota found unit kingdom prior unit kingdom includ period brandei quota repres percentag import gt pic file quot quot gt semi manufactur quota brandei agreement sale eastern trade organ tabl juli june free restrict juli june free restrict januari decemb tonn januari decemb tonn januari june gt pic file quot quot gt primari produc parti brandei eisen und metal agreement produc semi manufactur member vertic integr group compani produc semi manufactur product semi manufactur sheet rod tube wire section import primari aluminium secondari aluminium larg product cast semi manufactur cast account eec consumpt primari secondari aluminium western primari produc parti proceed sale semi manufactur repres largest valuabl market semi manufactur consider valuabl unit weight primari aluminium process aluminium semi manufactur averag doubl infer contain greenshield report cite alcan increas profit sale semi manufactur consider margin year semi manufactur repres vertic integr group larg profit market evid suggest alcan record untyp improb alcan achiev price increas semi manufactur uninfluenc prevail price level market suppli concern western produc protect valuabl profit market reflect provis brandei eisen und metal agreement tabl import semi manufactur eastern europ effect prohibit quota allow raznoimport metalimpex neglig repres product eec tabl signific foreign trade organ permit export semi manufactur countri member state eec undertook expressli quot spirit agreement quot claus undercut price western produc western produc concern enforc provis brandei agreement prohibit export semi manufactur raznoimport request allow export tonn semi annual agreement matter led breakdown negoti semi manufactur produc ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ run brandei agreement semi manufactur export countri export ussr tonn year brandei agreement sale made countri reserv agreement countri eastern europ egypt cuba quota sale aluminium cabl includ design protect gränge scandinavian market entri denmark quota concern commiss date access quota effect eec gränge refus accept propos agreement cabl export denmark limit aluminium content tonn summari histori eastern metal confer show offer primari aluminium foreign trade organ consider higher quota eventu agre foreign trade organ wish free sell semi secondari scrap western market sale fact made small scale breach brandei agreement demonstr product sale london metal exchang quot spirit agreement quot claus onward brandei agreement contain call quot spirit agreement claus quot negoti held june budapest renew agreement foreign trade organ sell output london metal exchang agreement reach result seri agreement quot spirit agreement quot claus explicitli extend manner quot aluminium begin trade london metal exchang appar quot agreement brandei goldschmidt raznoimport februari alcan note eastern metal confer held zurich septemb attend raznoimport metalimpex impexmet intrac metalimex keramet swiss aluminium puk alcan aluminium alcan sa baco av brandei goldschmidt record quot afternoon eastern countri demand tonn hungarian russian assist spokesman state bluntli agreement east maximum damag western compani includ ensur product put london metal exchang threat blatant state forget million pound invest includ larg amount govern monei smelter unit kingdom invest allow put jeopardi quot agreement made brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ agreement style contain provis renegoti termin agreement aluminium trade london metal exchang provis contain implic agreement madi eisen und metal ag intrac claus agreement intrac undertook sell primari aluminium aluminium semi manufactur feder republ germani amount contract parti agre quot provis brandei agreement appli quot provis appear ru seri standard form agreement made western produc situat eec brandei goldschmidt provis term quot seller agre supplier aluminium begin trade london metal exchang seller buyer renegoti term serv month notic parti unabl reach agreement end period notic agreement end date quantiti cancel pro rata basi quot quot short form quot agreement brandei goldschmidt western produc commun claus quot appar export aluminium sourc import interfer oblig deliveri agre tonnag seller buyer renegoti term serv month notic parti unabl reach agreement end period notic agreement end date quot lme committe propos aluminium contract octob london metal exchang committe invit raznoimport impexmet aluminium produc hungari czechoslovakia creation market aluminium london metal exchang benefit interest market februari brandei goldschmidt telex messag raznoimport copi impexmet quot doubt awar statement lme execut committe chairman committe approv gener term lme aluminium contract inform contract base suppli aluminium eastern countri confirm sell parti agreement support lme aluminium contract propos friend cancel recent negoti agreement aluminium trade london metal exchang suggest friend make dear chairman london metal exchang board firstli favour lme trade aluminium aluminium offer lme time forese futur eventu lme contract cover break claus hope materi approach lme committe regard interest aluminium contract year time interest action quot telex messag date februari brandei goldschmidt metalimpex repli quot learnt surpris lme committe accept aluminium contract intent introduc metal market base east european suppli time ago approach question lme inform view exist commit deliv aluminium exchang emphas agreement metalimpex unamendedli firm valid quot repli raznoimport impexmet brandei telex messag februari disclos commiss brandei goldschmidt entir durat agreement subject proceed foreign trade organ offer quantiti aluminium london metal exchang dear offer regard epaa member breach agreement foreign trade organ epaa member puk baco vaw alnor norsk hydro ardal og sunndal verk endasa svenska aluminium gränge aluminium swiss aluminium vmw holland aluminium montecatini edison produc concern directli indirectli proceed alcan alcoa mosal nlm reynold metal kaiser aluminium chemic corpor invit octob letter chairman london metal exchang committe facil london metal exchang aluminium contract trade aluminium exchang recipi gave favour repli letter repli letter lme committe produc concern proceed similar argument baco letter date novemb svenska metallverken gränge aluminium vaw letter date novemb puk letter date novemb mosal aluminium letter date novemb ardal letter date novemb stress desir maintain price stabil aluminium repli alumin holland aluminium swiss aluminium virtual ident textual role epaa committe lme persist effort realiz trade aluminium exchang trade aluminium lme discuss epaa member gener meet epaa held munich octob note date novemb meet made giulini epaa member oppos trade baco appoint observ develop inform member report corrobor minut prepar epaa circul member question discuss gener meet epaa held london septemb attend alcan uk alsar alumet puk ardal og sunndal verk baco elkem endasa giulini gränge aluminium holland aluminium kaiser aluminium europ metallgesellschaft norsk hydro rtz swiss aluminium vaw reynold aluminium deutschland epaa minut circul member report quot chairman baco inform gener meet lme introduc aluminium contract appli uk govern explain aluminium industri oppos past contract moment question discuss chairman epaa member inform develop quot london metal exchang discuss epaa gener meet octob epaa minut report quot london metal exchang lme chairman baco mention recent week report aluminium contract appear newspap magazin report misunderstood explain contract introduc singl broker institut investor specul aluminium contract lme uk govern inform aluminium produc aluminium consum oppos contract baco epaa member inform develop matter quot london metal exchang discuss epaa gener meet held april statement object alleg boycott london metal exchang serv parti proceed septemb import arrang applic member state respect eastern european countri gener western european countri power relev period enabl ban import impos restrict quantiti import impos duti import notabl respect letter term raznoimport impexmet produc hungari czechoslovakia quot dump quot good state member gener agreement tariff trade accept restrict freedom deal import fit eastern european countri poland czechoslovakia hungari member gatt materi time account difficulti ascertain accur fair market price countri origin market economi anti dump legisl inspir gatt provid altern mean establish dump initi involv estim cost product chang introduc expressli account countri central plan economi imposs ascertain fair market price chang enabl import countri check alleg quot dump quot price price import countri export countri gatt case import countri satisfi consequ quot dump quot import quot materi injuri quot industri import countri alcan baco made applic legisl respect aluminium romania applic lead imposit anti dump duti base domest market price romanian produc altern mean permit gatt rule uk legisl period trade western european countri ussr eastern europ progress liber liber extend aluminium product countri notabl unit kingdom formal restrict import primari aluminium product ussr eastern europ countri oper licens system licenc requir import aluminium licenc law confin epaa member evid confin fact sale effect brandei agreement object action epaa member enforc agreement point franc licenc requir import primari aluminium state trade countri import aluminium semi manufactur ussr hungari poland czechoslovakia liber import aluminium semi manufactur german democrat republ liber feder republ germani licenc requir aluminium import state trade countri trade agreement made countri czechoslovakia poland hungari respect german democrat republ trade regul quot interzonenhandelsabkommen quot case agreement made eisen und metal held import primari aluminium half level agre govern feder republ germani german democrat republ netherland quota initi tonn fix import primari aluminium state trade countri quota increas tonn quota restrict impos import scrap semi manufactur belgium luxembourg requir licenc import quota initi tonn increas tonn impos itali licenc requir aluminium import state trade countri grant licenc confin western produc parti brandei agreement evidenc attempt western produc enforc restrict brandei agreement export itali notabl action swiss aluminium frustrat work hungarian italian commiss econom cooper commun level member state adopt common import arrang respect state trade countri council regul eec product state trade countri subject quantit restrict aluminium product fall head no common custom tariff powder extrus roll product construct aluminium contain mesh trelli work subject quantit restrict origin bulgaria hungari poland romania czechoslovakia council decis eec member state adopt common unilater import arrang respect state trade countri decis member state adopt quota oj oj product includ case aluminium product subject quantit restrict subject quota publish council decis member state agre permit import countri concern highest level volum achiev previou year quota amend decis eec brandei quota allot compani countri intern natur industri case allot compani deliv countri establish assumpt brandei quota ship countri establish compani concern quota fell permit maxima case import benelux countri hungari quota allot member state exhaust tonn quota tonn common unilater import arrang decis eec eec relat aluminium product set tabl attitud nation govern brandei agreement western produc alcan baco vaw argu govern state member commun encourag support eastern metal arrang evid produc concern govern unit kingdom feder republ germani uk govern uk govern depart depart industri made alcan baco govern record meet eastern metal arrang discuss record show evid compuls uk govern alcan baco show uk govern encourag support particip alcan baco arrang attitud uk depart industri set note prepar depart knowledg proceed note date march commiss april date novemb alcan baco subsequ form part document submit repli commiss statement object note essenti similar term trace histori brandei agreement accept prior made intervent uk govern uk govern interven russian govern intim inter industri agreement uk govern act quot disrupt british market quot octob note made baco uk board trade advis alcan baco prepar approach uk registrar restrict trade practic eastern metal arrang registrar subsequ issu notic section restrict trade practic act requir inform suppli eastern metal arrang repli baco alcan brandei agreement suppli copi agreement made baco repli section notic issu uk registrar restrict trade practic record quot month novemb februari quot agreement made baco swiss aluminium montecatini vaw aluminium françai approach made raznoimport repli made mention support uk govern section restrict trade practic act registr requir quot agreement expressli author enact scheme order instrument made enact quot section act board trade direct agreement special public section regist agreement particular public quot opinion board contrari public interest quot direct respect baco repli act oj articl quota decis eec increas stage increas made denmark import aluminium cabl agreement amend registrar duti refer restrict practic court amend made ensur british regist compani baco formal parti brandei agreement brandei alcan particip swiss canadian compani amend made brandei goldschmidt quot elimin necess regist agreement registrar restrict trade practic quot agreement baco quot arrang quot substanc unalt formal ident particip chang brandei goldschmidt continu oper agreement alcan uk continu repres alcan group practic correspond attend epaa meet statement made purpos hear commiss manag director alcan uk quot laps year suggest brandei agreement quot quot suggest eman uk govern quot support evid swiss aluminium letter alcan uk address manag director state inter alia quot ey particip feel prevail purpos contract raznoimport serv protect unit kingdom quot passag export sale director alcan uk mark manuscript word quot talk start german swiss quot meet januari alcan uk baco ask uk board trade quot object industri applic gener uk polici soviet bloc import liber import clear understand home market disrupt impos anti dump duti back quota restrict quot alcan baco record repli quot disrupt consid standpoint import ingot britain british produc withdrew quot gentlemen agreement quot probabl agreement abandon unrestrict import eastern metal western european countri consequ fabric product made metal soviet bloc countri flow britain quot addit alcan baco stress quot intern problem satisfactori solut lai intern action reli action individu countri impos anti dump duti quota disrupt occur quot telex messag april baco agreement alcan puk quot accept western produc year commerci deal repres longer term protect govern control quot govern feder republ germani document produc vaw govern feder republ germani consist essenti letter quot bundeswirtschaftsministerium quot argu restrict import eastern europ record made vaw meet offici ministri contemporari document produc govern sourc note made june letter date novemb note made bundeswirtschaftsministerium refer fact hungari romania request german govern increas export quota aluminium aluminium semi manufactur increas quota grant export aluminium aluminium alloi quot sowjetzon quot german democrat republ note state opinion section hungarian romanian request refus concess made german democrat republ note refer possibl permit increas scrap import eastern europ shortag feder republ quot order accommod eastern bloc countri quota aluminium scrap offer case czechoslovakia price undertak definit scrap import probabl longer fulli met north america usa canada quot depart german govern increas scrap import eastern europ possibl exclud altogeth restrict seri agreement forc onward foreign trade organ ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ letter date novemb section iv bundeswirtschaftsministerium gave exampl quot gewiss regelungen hinsichtlich der osteinfuhren quot consid interest vaw letter refer scheme import crude oil ussr coal czechoslovakia evid descript scheme bore similar brandei agreement exclud potenti purchas contain provis restrict sell quantiti agreement vaw suppli record meet held offici bundeswirtschaftsministerium januari april note april vaw state quot emphas prepar work bundeswirtschaftsministerium quot document disclos commiss vaw show inform german govern involv brandei agreement prior januari note januari record vaw inform bundeswirtschaftsministerium immin sign brandei agreement seri vaw effect particip brandei agreement arrang alcan letter januari commiss alcan explain quot vaw support propos arrang principl unabl particip directli import eastern aluminium feder republ germani time prohibit strictli control order obviat difficulti alcan agre vaw alloc soviet metal behalf vaw addit alcan alloc propos arrang quot letter date januari bundeswirtschaftsministerium chairman vaw vaw discuss particip brandei arrang produc draft agreement clear made clear hear form agreement brandei goldschmidt western produc discuss recit restrict enter foreign trade organ mention suppress materi term letter quot exclus contract aluminium state trade countri file appear propos particip vaw exclus contract brandei goldschmidt london aluminium produc state trade countri import primari aluminium agreement western produc brandei take eastern import subject oral written represent vaw feder ministri econom affair draft agreement fact ministri record econom polici object rais ministri particip vaw agreement ministri evid prepar toler particip fact opinion conclus exclus contract jeopard vaw particip appear determin factor danger case restrict west european german aluminium market low price dump import state trade countri evid simpli dismiss hand legal question vaw contraven german law particip agreement discuss time question establish principl exclus contract conform german law competit intend horizont understand western produc take aluminium import brandei state trade countri regul import cartel observ vaw recommend submit matter bundeskartellamt refer quot exclus quot contract suggest ministri shown short form agreement long form term quot exclus quot analog languag short form refer quot sole purchas right quot brandei file doubt share compani agreement conform competit law eec advis doubt resolv submit agreement eec commiss quot member state evid member state govern awar brandei agreement notif agreement form agreement made brandei goldschmidt western aluminium produc concern reproduc materi term agreement brandei goldschmidt made foreign trade organ restrict undertaken foreign trade organ set full formula quot seller supplier quot place quot seller quot procedur result achiev letter date novemb legal advis brandei goldschmidt commiss quot brandei goldschmidt instruct swiss aluminium act capac coordin western produc agreement western produc brandei goldschmidt reflect contract brandei goldschmidt raznoimport engross final text agreement western produc brandei goldschmidt check approv swiss aluminium copi agreement brandei goldschmidt western produc signatur essenti procedur brandei goldschmidt agreement seri agreement enter quot letter commiss date januari brandei goldschmidt state usual form produc agreement contract parti aluminium françai aluminium compani canada swiss aluminium baco ardal og sunndal verk montedison vmw mosal aluminium ab svenska aluminiumkompaniet endasa nlm holland aluminium quot alumin quot vaw form agreement vari ident foreign trade organ sold aluminium brandei goldschmidt ru seri agreement set full restrict impos raznoimport seri restrict impos metalimpex seri restrict impos impexmet seri restrict impos intrac seri restrict impos metalimex keramet brandei goldschmidt letter januari quot accord usual procedur long form agreement brandei goldschmidt ag standard cover letter quot long form set annex brandei goldschmidt suppli copi standard cover letter mention aluminium françai puk confirm copi enclos quot repres particip produc subject differ origin tonnag destin quot cover letter aluminium françai date march refer expressli agreement no ru letter inform aluminium françai brandei goldschmidt ag appoint brandei goldschmidt quot handl shipment receipt fund behalf quot letter refer expressli restrict undertaken foreign trade organ quot refer agreement ru understood supplier restrict sale export virgin aluminium claus secondari aluminium scrap claus semi manufactur product aluminium aluminium cabl includ sale export bulgaria understood sale export bulgaria countri mention claus agreement deduct tonnag purchas buyer claus agreement quot quot refer agreement ru agre supplier aluminium cabl market territori disrupt export socialist indic agreement conclud countri draw attent supplier situat situat remedi specif reserv invok paragraph claus agreement quot agreement number consecut begin ru agreement made brandei goldschmidt nlm invoic brandei goldschmidt buyer bore contract number agreement buyer enter number remain unchang brandei invoic agreement eec base produc amend manner list base contract number contain brandei invoic gt pic file quot quot gt agreement abovement long form particip western produc swiss aluminium inform brandei goldschmidt produc base eec call amend made agreement june brandei goldschmidt notifi swiss aluminium final word amend brandei goldschmidt engross amend copi western produc concern check swiss aluminium quot short form quot agreement reproduc annex amend elimin mention restrict foreign trade organ undertaken suppli primari aluminium secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur amend form agreement elimin refer agreement foreign trade organ sell aluminium price lower mention brandei agreement territori remov specif refer london metal exchang quot spirit agreement quot claus restrict convers remov amend intend affect oper brandei agreement gener enforc eec base produc suppress restrict amend agreement produc base eec aluminium françai alumin montedison vaw ident form produc agreement bore number ru seri agreement origin distribut march brandei goldschmidt ru letter code remov replac letter aluminium françai agreement number tabl summar revis nomenclatur agreement gt pic file quot quot gt origin quot short form quot discuss lead amend delet record letter legal advis vaw date march april statement made parti hear letter record outcom discuss march quot péchinei quot aluminium françai vaw refer made amend agreement quot der einzeln vertrag ein westeuropäischen herstel über den einkauf von ostaluminium mit brandei london fällt nicht unter artikel absatz ewg vertrag wenn die vertragsklauseln gestrichen werden die al reexportverbot ander ewg länder verstanden werden können und wenn die ausschließlichkeit der einkäuferstellung gestrichen und nicht von einkaufsquoten gesprochen wird gegen dies streichungen sprechen auch kein wirtschaftlichen bedenken weil da eingekauft ostaluminium von dem westeuropäischen herstel ohnehin entwed seinen verarbeitungsbetrieben verbraucht oder zusammen mit seiner eigenen erzeugung zu deren wettbewerbspreisen und entsprechend den wettbewerbsbedingungen verkauft wird im sinn der ausführungen zu regt der leiter der rechtsabteilung vielmehr auch noch artikel absatz de brandei vertrag zu ändern weil dort vom geist de vertrag und einer pro rata basi die rede ist dies anregung erfolgt im rahmen der überlegung daß der bereinigt deutsch vertrag für brandei da muster für die anderen einkaufsverträg werden könnte ich möchte demnach für artikel absatz folgend fassung vorschlagen quot suggest version fact ultim adopt account event legal advis vaw hear vaw amend claus agreement delet provis quot seller undertak sell suppli virgin aluminium except sale author buyer approv buyer quot replac quot seller herewith grant buyer exclus purchas quantiti feder republ germani countri quot amend concern restrict enter foreign trade organ reproduc usual manner vaw legal advis state hear quot um dies national exklusivität von vaw verständlich zu machen hatt nun vaw einen absatz dem artikel vorausgeschickt und doch die exklusivitätsregelungen de grundliegenden vertrag brandei osten wiederholt quot object amend form claus subsequ vaw amend claus delet altogeth legal advis state march receiv draft agreement refer exclus purchas right virgin aluminium restrict undertaken foreign trade organ recal letter date march record result meet march vaw draft refer quot clean quot german agreement der bereinigt deutsch vertrag serv model purchas agreement brandei goldschmidt vaw draft subsequ discuss meet vaw montedison april letter vaw date april record quot complet agreement quot reach propos set letter march letter evid written receipt vaw draft march meet montedison copi amend brandei agreement vaw quot sie vaw überreichten mailand herrn montedison ein kopi de auf grund meiner beratung geänderten individu vertrag mit brandei dies änderungen sind inzwischen von herrn brandei gebilligt worden ebenso von péchinei der deutsch vertrag hat daher die bedeutung ein mustervertrag zur vermeidung von beanstandungsmöglichkeiten im sinn von ziffer mein schreiben vom märz quot term letter april evid alumin agre amend legal depart refer aluminium françai puk agreement provis contain agreement distribut brandei goldschmidt hear maintain discuss concern delet restrict undertaken foreign trade organ claus appear earlier brandei western produc agreement quot seller undertak sell supplier virgin aluminium except sale author buyer price approv buyer quot view fact draft contract march buyer claus delet explan advanc object discuss incomplet make notif notif submit commiss novemb contain call quot condit public quot provid notif submit condit quot applic publish decid quot notif compos letter form power attornei sign puk giulini montedison vaw holland aluminium question form relat content agreement decis concert practic answer refer accompani letter da begleitschreiben answer question form call address repres subsidiari situat common market case undertak situat list suppli list bore name aluminium compani canada alnor asv baco elkem endasa swiss aluminium ab svenska metallverken gränge aluminium vmw answer form made german origin languag accompani letter materi part letter set quot import eastern bloc countri western european aluminium produc western european produc import sector purchas total import quantiti eastern bloc product compar qualiti offer number eastern bloc countri fabric materi stage product plant remaind sold product framework competit exist western european produc opinion procedur contrari articl eec treati accept import quantiti condit offer entail addit individu purchas intent western european produc exclud competit import dealer tonnag involv exce market possibl disappear possibl purchas parti dealer brought purchas contract conclud eec individu western european produc repres eastern bloc countri except romania yugoslavia consequ accord free market principl fact purchas item merchandis exclud purchas concert action aim restrict purchas possibl western european produc dealer mean articl exist restrict competit exclus dealer irrelev integr eec bring expans sale dealer contrari sale diminish nation framework decreas quantiti custom form raw materi suppli dealer increas degre technic reason materi suppli produc direct custom size alloi advic fabric dealer encount difficulti dispos tonnag purchas romania yugoslavia secondari smelter supplementari purchas western european produc semi fabric plant decreas exclus dealer eastern bloc import purchas western european produc detriment affect trade eec signific degre demonstr fact import purchas western european produc account total western european consumpt tonn risen slowli proport growth foreseen correspond year increas consumpt purchas detriment trade member countri distort exist competit contrari purchas aim prevent distort exist competit price term sale eastern bloc import unlik western european produc determin base product cost product free competit polit consider foreign currenc requir purchas good eastern bloc purchas western european produc approv econom viewpoint nation govern govern counsel industri defens measur eastern bloc dump time pave purchas negoti moscow diplomat channel quot parti contemporan english version text current seri agreement foreign trade organ disclos parti made disclosur text agreement draft agreement foreign trade organ period descript commiss term agreement question contain paragraph cite time notif made particip parti mention aluminio de galicia kaiser preussag metallgesellschaft purchas aluminium agreement subject proceed begin activ notifi commiss februari commiss commenc investig notif state undertak conclud agreement purchas primari aluminium eastern bloc countri quot inzwischen gleichfal kaufverträg über rohaluminium au der produkt von ostblockstaaten abschließen quot particip reynold aluminium deutschland alsar spa rtz bicc notifi commiss reynold alsar conclud agreement brandei goldschmidt rtz bicc purchas eastern metal swiss aluminium term subject condit accept epaa member name brandei goldschmidt raznoimport metalimpex keramet impexmet intrac figur notif investig case reveal descript notif omit import element seri agreement subject proceed omiss appar face document submit director compet director initi refus notif decemb unilater condit public document submit condit decemb regist commiss decemb draft notif discuss approv meet epaa held octob attend alcan uk alnor aluminium norwai holland aluminium aluminium françai ardal og sunndal verk baco elkem empresa nacion del aluminio gebrüder giulini montecatini edison swiss aluminium ab svenska metallverken vaw vmw present anglesei aluminium metallgesellschaft undertak notifi name notif awar inadequaci notif text agreement disclos commiss repli request inform made articl regul novemb time expans commun brought physic jurisdict commiss western produc quot long form quot agreement origin notifi parti quot short form quot agreement februari aluminio de galicia kaiser preussag metallgesellschaft notifi commiss particip brandei agreement notif refer notif involv individu undertak set fact conveni term quot western produc quot quot foreign trade organ quot undertak involv undertak activ brandei arrang begin end western produc divid rough group chief instig organ support swiss aluminium baco puk alcan montedison alumet vaw asv involv ii follow gt pic file quot quot gt iii peripher particip rtz bicc alsar alugasa subsidiari puk nlm own alcan giulini classif roughli repres involv degre interest involv classif repres primari aluminium product western europ purchas aluminium purchas brandei arrang except baco greatest interest quot protect quot origin eec baco larg manufactur enlarg eec classif particip fulli brandei arrang vari period protect home eec market deliber distort commun trade categori cover vital watertight system lesser import unenthusiast nlm trade commun undertak involv arrang ceas exist separ entiti gebrüder giulini liquid acquir alcan giulini ow liquid offer defenc proceed alcan visit consequ giulini conduct kapal kaiser preussag aluminium gmbh enter quot short form quot agreement brandei time own half unit state corpor kaiser aluminium chemic corpor effect decemb sharehold kapal transfer entir share capit kaiser aluminium europ wholli own subsidiari kaiser aluminium chemic corpor kaiser aluminium europ contend held respons action kapal acquir share asset kapal kaiser europ interrupt kapal employe offic close connect kapal involv brandei agreement kaiser aluminium chemic corpor repres govern bodi kapal baco acquir alcan merger baco alcan uk compani compani chang name alsar alumet spa chang alluminio italia spa ii legal assess articl articl eec treati declar incompat common market agreement undertak decis associ undertak concert practic affect trade member state object effect prevent restrict distort competit common market articl list exampl agreement decis concert practic exampl relev proceed agreement decis concert practic quot directli indirectli fix purchas sell price trade condit limit control product market technic develop invest share market sourc suppli quot agreement subject proceed made brandei goldschmidt foreign trade organ raznoimport impexmet metalimpex metalimex keramet intrac western primari aluminium produc quot western produc quot agreement term quot brandei agreement quot concern proceed agreement made implement brandei agreement agreement made eisen und metal aktiengesellschaft western produc particip quot undertak quot mean articl western produc western produc purchas aluminium brandei agreement undertak purpos articl engag busi produc primari aluminium joint ventur relationship establish primari aluminium produc european primari aluminium associ epaa western produc belong associ undertak purpos articl foreign trade organ foreign trade organ raznoimport impexmet metalimpex metalimex keramet intrac undertak purpos articl function organ engag import export rang good matter concern proceed foreign trade organ engag sell aluminium activ specif establish law countri situat entiti engag activ trade regard undertak purpos articl precis statu domest law countri origin separ statu state applic articl relat trade activ defeat claim sovereign immun claim properli confin act govern trade foreign trade organ indistinguish socialist law state sovereign immun attach particip brandei agreement exclus commerci activ domest law member state accord sovereign immun foreign trade organ type concern proceed brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal brandei goldschmidt brandei goldschmidt ag treat purpos decis materi time brandei goldschmidt ag subsidiari brandei goldschmidt proof brandei goldschmidt ag exercis autonomi brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal undertak purpos articl long establish trader ferrou metal continu activ run brandei agreement brandei goldschmidt claim treat undertak purpos articl materi time agent western produc enjoi independ statu correct appli respect eisen und metal brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal act instruct person decid part agreement subject proceed brandei goldschmidt oblig enter agreement assum materi role implement enforc brandei goldschmidt decid independ econom oper part arrang exclud competitor trade aluminium eastern europ brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal withdrawn time agreement line busi compani escap liabil particip restrict agreement alleg independ statu act instruct relationship instruct aros choic enter restrict agreement matter concern proceed quot agreement quot mean articl argu demonstr behalf undertak arrang act govern undertak infring articl commun recours diplomat represent govern concern retali kind govern member state agreement act govern signatori govern oblig undertak enter arrang possibl parti put forward govern concern encourag support arrang oblig undertak enter arrang part extern commerci polici state concern subject scrutini commun institut articl treati possibl examin relat undertak subject materi time jurisdict govern feder republ germani undertak subject materi time jurisdict uk govern intervent govern feder republ germani find fact commiss establish govern feder republ germani particip directli brandei eisen agreement parti german govern lack statutori power time forc parti enter arrang letter written bundeswirtschaftsministerium januari govern prepar toler vaw particip agreement advoc vaw part expressli state made explicit reserv legal brandei arrang german eec competit rule evid commiss conclud encourag support german govern vaw make case fact intervent unit kingdom govern fact show uk govern sens parti brandei agreement british produc agent govern enter brandei agreement support uk govern note depart industri properli ratif act western produc act state content baco act state action reject undertak situat unit kingdom oblig instruct uk govern enter brandei arrang time uk govern statutori power forc undertak enter arrang alcan expressli state uk govern exercis form legal compuls order secur particip arrang parti felt oblig give uk registrar restrict trade practic detail arrang arrang exempt registr virtu section restrict trade practic act time relev ministri argu section direct registrar place registr special section regist section act uk govern uk base western produc act scope legal enact insuffici evid show uk govern induc uk base undertak make agreement western produc appoint brandei goldschmidt negoti raznoimport earli evid produc show uk govern induc alcan baco enter agreement term settl mid compani claim quot doubt uk govern knew approv arrang incept quot evid show initi negoti conclud brandei agreement lai time western produc involv uk govern restrict inform appar onward give approv depart industri note april state agreement made intervent uk govern contemporan report note negoti made brandei goldschmidt correspond relat thereto made refer involv govern note made brandei goldschmidt meet raznoimport moscow februari appear mention made interest govern secur agreement brandei goldschmidt state quot consid negoti intim raznoimport back produc interest quot signific brandei goldschmidt time made mention interest govern strong induc raznoimport enter agreement note letter contemporan contract raznoimport privat initi failur uk base parti uk govern respect brandei arrang exempt possibl uk restrict practic law argument uk parti adduc time carri uk govern polici polici commiss accept fact onward uk govern gave support uk base undertak enter brandei arrang encourag support uk govern reflect sovereign decis commun trade affect fact uk govern pursuit legitim nation interest permit privat restrict competit commun sought desir breach law commun favour breach uk govern intend breach commiss case alter posit undertak commun sought attack brandei arrang concern effect confin territori unit kingdom date unit kingdom member commun uk govern fulli entitl action territori encourag commit act territori effect territori fit commiss duti enforc eec treati accept encourag uk govern defenc act uk base undertak act violat commun law affect trade member state commun unit kingdom subject articl eec treati restrict distort competit parti proceed enter arrang chief purpos effect maintain price aluminium ingot aluminium product eec western market primari mean share sourc suppli ingot remov market semi manufactur scrap control barter convers contract restrict accept western produc conduct knowledg understand parti follow polici restrict agreement resel eastern metal parti remelt aluminium made trade london metal exchang protect price numer statement made parti brandei agreement show purpos arrang protect price western market western produc concern protect price level vigor action prevent sale smallest quantiti aluminium semi manufactur western market clear inter alia western produc foreign trade organ expressli agre brandei agreement price charg territori lower quot agreement foreign trade organ gave contractu undertak maintain price aluminium product reduct price effect ingot price except case sale eastern metal permit western market western produc shield risk price competit express gener term quot spirit agreement quot claus requir abstent price competit western produc foreign trade organ surplu export foreign trade organ promis charg brandei agreement price induc western produc accept sale quot quot territori price paid brandei eastern metal discuss part present purpos decid price brandei paid equal market price circumst industri hard establish puk attempt show brandei price close quot arm length quot price currenc agreement sign western produc thought price high western produc venic metal confer reduc quantiti ingot suit glut ingot time increas price tonn paid price paid assur outlet interest foreign trade organ offset contractu prohibit sale ingot purchas sale scrap semi manufactur product aluminium produc purchas aluminium brandei agreement agre pai price purchas agre pai uniform rate commiss brandei goldschmidt servic similarli purchas alusuiss deutschland vaw kaiser preussag aluminium metallgesellschaft gebrüder giulini parti agreement made eisen und metal ag intrac agre pai price materi purchas price brandei agreement enter arrang purchas includ brandei goldschmidt effect debar offer higher lower price eastern metal fix common agreement purchas foreign trade organ similarli debar sell higher lower price fix common agreement seller absenc agreement purchas contract purchas differ price wish bui brandei price remain irrespect quantiti purchas buyer puk purchas time quantiti purchas giulini parti paid price tonn enter agreement foreign trade organ agre compet price trade condit suppli aluminium eec western market share sourc suppli purchas brandei eisen und metal agreement freedom negoti individu price supplier real discret quantiti purchas western produc purchas free quantiti fix calcul share purchas quot sale western europ quot total year subsequ allot share total eastern metal aluminium bought circul list quot eastern metal distribut quot enabl purchas compar allot made purchas explan swiss aluminium quota purchas distribut eastern metal matter rais epaa meet unwilling alsar prescrib quota discuss epaa execut committe alsar eventu persuad member committe quota system allot adopt brandei agreement administ swiss aluminium epaa execut committe exclud virtu mutual disclosur examin possibl purchas smaller quantiti prescrib formula purchas adopt remov market secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur agreement restrict import eastern europ deriv product prohibit export western countri includ eec secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur poland fix quota product case ussr hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ specif quota fix member state eec quota fix low level effect exclud access independ aluminium user suppli product case semi manufactur quota reduc tonn tonn annum tabl quota repres quarter eec product semi manufactur includ cast similarli quota secondari aluminium scrap reduc total eec consumpt secondari aluminium restrict suppli semi manufactur scrap secondari aluminium subject vigor enforc brandei agreement western produc argu restrict impos prevent evas foreign trade organ oblig primari aluminium shown true provis impos restrict purpos effect aggrav restrict impos primari aluminium note imposit public author anti dump measur line product prevent dump line product permit rule gatt consequ western competitor western produc assess claus western produc protect integr semi manufactur oper prevent semi manufactur eastern european countri establish supplier custom western produc restrict opportun barter convers parti barter transact assum import trade countri currenc freeli convert histori negoti contract show brandei goldschmidt awar aluminium eastern european countri sold barter arrang begin brandei goldschmidt interest bui aluminium raznoimport foreign trade organ provid seller guarante quot quantiti bought brandei goldschmidt sold direct barter deal market quot quot western market quot contractu restrict undertaken foreign trade organ extend includ exchang barter form suppli intervent swiss aluminium prevent barter transact metalimpex impexmet raznoimport show oper restrict claus restrict extend year monitor export foreign trade organ aluminium convers eec western countri import ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ seller prohibit contract person eec convers aluminium consent buyer brandei agreement request seller permiss export purpos convers refer swiss aluminium lead produc countri western produc consult includ vaw feder republ germani holland aluminium netherland vmw austria major case convers carri epaa member subsidiari thereof independ user aluminium deni access suppli eastern metal brandei agreement deni opportun carri convers product aluminium powder flake foil extrus materi agreement made impexmet mention exclud member quot buyer group quot carri work restrict convers decreas rang activ open independ processor fabric prevent convert transform eastern metal result product export ussr eastern europ restrict barter agreement prevent undertak trade ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia german democrat republ bulgaria receiv payment aluminium good servic appli countri restrict resal remelt restrict access parti suppli aluminium eastern europ aros undertak western produc aluminium purchas brandei agreement sold origin condit parti enforc agreement reason impos condit understand restrict purpos effect result practic prevent resal eastern aluminium parti origin form fact agre eastern metal sold epaa member remelt demonstr intent circul eastern metal group epaa member remelt oblig serv ensur eastern metal stock primari ingot reappear market hand merchant take case ingot western produc minim risk eastern metal reappear market number potenti custom materi lower extrus billet roll slab purchas western parti express term brandei agreement requir remelt appreci impedi dispos aluminium purchas brandei agreement form receiv evid vmw request suppli ingot ussr quot neutral quot form cast mark concert action london metal exchang london metal exchang quot spirit agreement quot claus action western produc relat london metal exchang demonstr intent limit market confin sell aluminium western market western aluminium produc enter form brandei agreement forc onward foreign trade organ expressli agre trade aluminium london metal exchang give parti renegoti bring termin agreement western produc argu claus relat london metal exchang clausula rebu sic stantibu provid renegoti brandei agreement event chang natur market assumpt claus restrict competit prevent discourag develop market brandei agreement adopt interest western produc foreign trade organ knew trade lme power encourag bring jeopard interest rebu sic stantibu claus restrict competit parti interest ensur agreement remain forc ensur competit contempl claus occur evid show adopt claus relat london metal exchang introduc meet specif conting declar intent foreign trade organ sell aluminium lme intent made clear eastern metal confer held june budapest zurich septemb seri agreement quot spirit agreement quot claus expressli extend cover possibl aluminium trade london metal exchang continu contract octob london metal exchang committe circular letter invit recipi trade aluminium london metal exchang event set show western produc aluminium trade lme trade view open western market eastern metal affect stabil price evid set show quot spirit agreement quot claus intend appli western eastern parti western produc foreign trade organ reserv trade lme jeopard brandei agreement specif refer lme quot spirit agreement quot claus agreement brandei goldschmidt produc situat eec clear western produc provis explicit agreement brandei goldschmidt trade aluminium lme threaten continu brandei agreement share polici epaa member london metal exchang clear repli circular letter lme committe western produc concern proceed decid sale aluminium london metal exchang inim interest repli show great similar result concert clear minut record epaa meet polici member lme jointli determin confirm meet decis appoint baco behalf member observ report member attempt creat aluminium market lme demonstr member epaa share polici question appoint baco epaa member quot ey tendenc london metal exchang quot necessarili impli epaa member understood epaa member make metal trade exchang action run risk disclosur member gener prohibit contain brandei agreement sell aluminium western market suffici prevent foreign trade organ trade aluminium lme parti acknowledg quot spirit agreement quot claus trade aluminium lme parti undermin basi agreement action mean adopt parti proceed prevent trade aluminium market expect regul parti strove prevent creation market mean distribut aluminium pressur suppli demand sole determin price formul joint polici market suppli market refus suppli western produc foreign trade organ infring articl agre limit market parti gave freedom sell aluminium market knowledg understand parti object effect arrang object effect arrang western produc brandei goldschmidt eisen und metal foreign trade organ enter arrang stabil price share market deni access particip user sourc suppli control western produc arrang anti competit effect inevit effect object foreseen fact show object arrang larg attain appreci effect competit argument parti effect competit argu competit present allegedli quot dump quot eastern metal competit context law free enterpris economi articl appli effect competit appreci sale eastern metal dump price condit requir impos anti dump duti satisfi sale anti dump reaction price eastern metal rise command sale anti dump measur ineffect articl appli competit quot competit quot mean articl argument assum privat parti arrog public function obscur clear differ regul trade public author regul cartel public author account right interest parti gener public interest cartel habitu benefit particip take account concern legisl provis articl peremptori provis contract undercut scope articl protect quot law free enterpris economi quot entrust public author commiss duti pursu gener polici design appli principl laid treati guid conduct undertak light principl join case quot pioneer quot paragraph page find respect competit rule equal applic dump case tonnag deliv eec brandei arrang enter eec legitim concern import quota circumst give rise situat legitim protect quot pioneer quot judgment cite paragraph fundament differ purpos method regul trade adopt govern concern significantli brandei agreement imposit govern quota restrict impos level provid brandei agreement countri concern reserv suppli western produc independ user free bui quantiti concern fact addit independ sourc suppli effect gener price level suppli aluminium western eastern europ brandei agreement made ensur independ aluminium user direct access suppli imposit system import licens exist member state confin suppli aluminium eastern europ western produc user aluminium remain free appli obtain licenc case itali feder republ germani independ user obtain import licenc sale made intend subject intervent western produc brandei agreement equal imposit anti dump duti confin product subject duti circl western produc government measur imposit import quota anti dump duti import licens system effect competit brandei agreement import level decid quota fix brandei agreement government measur depriv independ user access suppli aluminium extent achiev brandei agreement independ user competit western produc sale aluminium product semi manufactur finish form denial access achiev brandei agreement brought appreci restrict competit western produc argument reli presumpt govern eec member state western european countri eec introduc measur restrict effect result brandei eisen und metal agreement parti adduc evid show govern act reach prove govern european state concern measur effect respect brandei eisen und metal agreement aluminium product concern undertak entitl pre empt measur decid competit western europ aluminium circul territori evid government measur adopt restrict brandei eisen und metal agreement brandei agreement impos restrict import aluminium eastern europ fact impos form quota licens requir member state eec western european countri quota permit brandei agreement legal limit impos western european govern brandei arrang effect frustrat act govern polici western govern restrict import scrap eec control export scrap allevi recurr shortag shortag scrap part result remov western market eastern scrap directli due oper brandei agreement restrict scrap import brandei agreement maintain enforc scarciti suppli scrap western europ extent secondari smelter substitut expens primari ingot scrap primari smelter western european countri profit detriment custom secondari smelter fact instanc independ user obtain suppli aluminium brandei agreement demonstr govern countri user resid prepar impos act govern restrict brandei agreement evid absenc agreement measur adopt member state western european countri restrict brandei agreement involv quantit limit minimum price alloc quantiti western produc exclud primari secondari aluminium semi manufactur scrap enabl western produc determin negoti eastern european produc level import permit price period year time regard structur competit interest parti addit gener argument unfair competit western produc argu brandei agreement justifi rule dump contain gatt legisl made thereund give protect consid entitl rule allegedli practic appli sale made foreign trade organ undertak entitl make restrict agreement damag interest competitor consum exist legisl adequ practic purpos clear evid negoti agreement conduct western produc enforc western produc sought achiev greater measur protect competit achiev applic anti dump legisl argument alleg impract anti dump rule light arrang made restrict correct anti dump measur western produc protect govern state commun decid adopt legisl requir procedur criteria fulfil public author interven regul trade decis sens justifi remedi action form restrict agreement industri concern procedur inconveni protect insuffici privat interest western produc argu proceed anti dump rule gatt legisl made thereund practic invok prevent dump aluminium produc eastern europ difficulti establish domest market price produc determin margin dump correct western produc argu anti dump measur similar effect impos absenc brandei agreement alleg impract legisl matter legisl correct justifi make restrict agreement undertak argument anti dump legisl difficulti establish domest market price base incorrect interpret legisl question explain effect competit appreci assess effect brandei arrang made percentag integr market compris likeliest clientel eastern ingot vari estim consumpt signific part market undertak contend circumst appreci true western produc particip year incur expenditur consid oner agreement continu year renew year activ sought suggest content unfound believ western produc run agreement contradict argument reject anti dump legisl ineffect western produc argu foreign trade organ dump aluminium western europ brandei agreement made attract anti dump duti western produc conclud brandei agreement appreci effect competit effect occur event occur argument variat argument dealt reason reject repeat conclud brandei arrang caus restrict distort competit appreci substanti effect trade commun particip brandei agreement import product sale interest member state enlarg arrang alloc eastern metal incumb particip proport product necess affect trade member state unfett access commun caus trade flow brandei arrang prevent parti effect parallel import commun remelt oblig prevent inter state trade particip potenti seller unalt eastern metal prevent sell restrict impos brandei agreement affect suppli primari secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur eec product greater lesser degre raw materi process fabric finish product agreement affect trade raw materi necessarili affect trade product made materi remov market eastern scrap time commun scrap short suppli forc fabric semi manufactur higher cost ingot western produc advers result price possibl intra commun trade inevit result structur competit eec alter remov import altern sourc aluminium independ fabric processor compet fabric process oper vertic integr primari aluminium produc particip parti arrang result affect trade member state brandei agreement design curtail activ trader includ base eec commerc eastern european countri concern western europ instanc reason restrict brandei agreement extend usa negoti agreement run baco state quot usa cover agreement eas switch merchant back european market quot merchant quot switch quot quot eas quot usa europ transact place eec fact trader independ user deni access aluminium ussr poland hungari czechoslovakia bulgaria german democrat republ necessarili meant trade aluminium sourc member state eec opportun trade aluminium eec curtail action western produc prevent foreign trade organ offer sell london metal exchang contract made lme trade concern parti member state seller member state purchas metal warehous hold contract quantiti prevent lme trade fail affect trade member state affect price aluminium europ major particip situat eec alcan swiss aluminium ardal og sunndal verk elkem norsk hydro vmw import export market eec run agreement subsidiari compani eec produc primari secondari aluminium semi manufactur time brandei agreement enter produc protect market situat canada switzerland norwai austria eec market interest activ produc eec swiss aluminium action brandei agreement interrupt suppli aluminium eastern europ purchas eec evid provid histori enforc agreement show western produc consid market countri western europ eec separ eec knew occur market effect eec market vice versa aluminium eastern european sourc free circul countri western europ difficult imposs control ultim destin western produc argu context restrict sale remelt alcan uk baco rtz particip agreement prevent aluminium eastern europ arriv eec western market unit kingdom unit kingdom eec market view structur industri regard commerci isol understood western produc alcan argu effect price unit kingdom felt quot mainland europ quot quot british supplier oblig seek busi europ replac sale lost eastern european supplier quot conduct baco alcan consist view scheme brandei agreement requir particip parti situat eec make arrang effect articl refer agreement affect trade member state effect produc individu particip agreement prove individu particip undertak appreci effect trade eec particip infring articl arrang part affect trade member state fact quantiti primari ingot sold brandei agreement pass eec territori brandei agreement produc effect eec incid arrang arrang design produc effect eec particip text agreement enter purpos effect restrict suppli aluminium form western countri includ eec particip knew basi particip enter agreement particip parti restrict arrang articl appli defenc individu parti stress small scale particip scale particip repres amount purchas fix common agreement reflect market share greater lesser willing particip restrict arrang criterion determin quota western produc quot sale western europ quot system western produc share amount primari ingot purchas ratio quot sale western europ quot express quot sale western europ quot includ suppli primari aluminium eec produc eec sale ingot deliveri subsidiari compani deliveri quot swap quot transact implement agreement involv close connect trade particip aluminium eec brandei arrang affect quantiti metal trade commun arrang neutral import competit pressur price aluminium product eec effect price necessarili affect trade member state agreement made price aluminium circul eec greater jurisdict appli articl undertak argu commiss exercis jurisdict undertak situat commun act commit commun affect trade commun act affect trade member state commun main object brandei arrang limit tonnag ingot cabl offer amput suppli aluminium product reduc suppli direct eec particip brandei arrang market share protect protect effect substanti eec part common market isol member countri substanti restrict effect competit felt territori common market western produc commun common interest effici function brandei arrang part essenti fashion fact show particip awar brandei arrang collaps comprehens princip effect felt common market commiss compet ensur competit common market distort duti treati particip establish territori common market question commiss jurisdict undertak particip commun control subsidiari common market commiss jurisdict formal separ parent subsidiari compani eec parent act common market subsidiari escap uniti conduct market order circumv rule competit parent compani exercis power control subsidiari appli restrict agreement impos abus conduct judgment court case quot ici commiss quot page case quot commerci solvent quot page particip common market trade territori judgment novemb court justic held quot fact undertak parti agreement situat countri prevent applic articl agreement oper territori common market quot case quot béguelin quot paragraph page béguelin case concern vertic exclus distribut agreement commun manufactur commun distributor reason equal applic horizont agreement competitor commun reason distinguish horizont agreement restrict accept common market restrict accept wholli subject requir substanti effect trade member state prohibit rule intern law prevent applic commun law particip brandei arrang reason comiti milit favour restraint exercis jurisdict commiss exercis jurisdict commiss requir undertak concern act contrari requir domest law applic commun law advers affect import interest member state interest import prevail fundament interest commun competit common market distort articl eec treati essenti mean treati achiev object commun undertak unit kingdom prior access undertak concern alcan uk rtz bicc baco access unit kingdom extent brandei arrang serv protect uk market competit eastern metal prior access commiss sought jurisdict undertak claim exercis jurisdict respect effect brandei arrang trade commun respect undertak indistinguish undertak materi time common market undoubt interest uk govern dai protect uk market competit balanc interest commun appli articl eec treati interest incompat particip free act respect interest access undertak commun undertak action support brandei arrang protect uk market consid treat indistinguish similar action protect quot quot commun undertak situat time quot quot commun regul eec keramet metalimpex argu agreement brandei fell term commiss regul eec argument made seller serv equal consid relat suppli aluminium brandei goldschmidt incident restrict agre competitor main object brandei agreement benefit regul eec exempt regul eec appli quot good quot good exclus accord articl context aluminium ingot agreement foreign trade organ brandei includ prohibit sale secondari semi total prohibit sale scrap good subject exclus sale regul appli agreement articl regul eec remov group exempt arrang contract parti made difficult obtain good contract relat dealer common market contract parti quot measur prevent dealer consum obtain good contract relat sell product territori cover contract quot clear fact action brandei goldschmidt put foreign trade organ acced request prevent import commun western state brandei goldschmidt fulfil test regul reason suffici remov benefit regul eec brandei arrang foreign trade organ articl introduct provis articl declar inapplic case agreement contribut improv product distribut good promot technic econom progress allow consum fair share result benefit impos undertak concern restrict indispens attain object afford undertak possibl elimin competit respect substanti part product question accord articl regul agreement restrict prevent distort competit mean articl respect parti thereto seek exempt notifi commiss exempt grant notif made articl notif articl commiss regul requir notif made articl regul oj oj submit form articl commiss regul requir notif inform ask form requir regul notif mere formal absenc notif accord requir regul restrict exempt articl case quot dcl commiss quot point page notif make elig exempt conduct suffici notif notif made form decemb brandei arrang oper year event imposs grant exempt arrang prior date virtu articl regul notif defici respect parti agreement content agreement mean achiev aim agreement notif defici substanti degre relat mean achiev aim agreement relev question section iii form requir parti disclos notifi agreement relat adher bui sell price discount trade condit share market sourc suppli restrict freedom resel parti correct respons question disclos aluminium bought brandei arrang allot fix quota uniform price notif refer purchas quot vorgang quot quot procédé quot french version quot procedur quot parti english version give impress purchas conduct busi combin combin refer produc purchas quot quot quot individu purchas intent quot produc quot purchas contract conclud eec quot individu western european produc impress sale made ad hoc basi produc free negoti price quantiti provid offer notif contain incorrect statement obscur aim content agreement statement purchas possibl dealer restrict statement western produc bought account swiss aluminium alcan bought behalf produc notif background factor contact bundeswirtschaftsministerium parti put express notic brandei arrang question commun law process agreement made brandei goldschmidt eec base produc form suppress mention restrict undertaken foreign trade organ complet june letter legal advis vaw april meet april vaw montedison show process undertaken contempl approach made commiss establish legal brandei agreement articl preambl regul state quot undertak transmit commiss inform fact circumst support notif articl regul quot articl regul make form obligatori statutori form requir repres notifi parti attest content form annex accur case quot vbbb al eldi quot paragraph page court justic held quot mean notif commiss suppli inform enabl decis provid regul agreement reduc write copi entir text attach form inform form intend sole facilit verif inform correct relat fairli provis time consid import object notif obtain quot case form refer articl agreement thought relev full text agreement attach full agreement notifi notif proper present case parti deliber omit annex agreement contrari express term question ii form parti choos annex text agreement special duti state fulli correctli fairli appar text agreement omit form relev defenc parti notif argu brandei agreement necessarili impli joint purchas uniform price allot prescrib quota understood notif western produc bui manner constru notif establish mean commiss oblig reli statement made notif case detail brandei agreement implement lai exclus knowledg parti make notif opportun fairli accur answer specif question form opportun notif notifi term agreement leav commiss guess exist undertak advantag notif ambigu notif interpret favour ambigu obtain protect fine commiss misl opportun continu practis unlaw behaviour instanc parti set file defici notif heard commiss fault succeed commiss find notif serv basi exempt parti notif februari defici predecessor serv basi exempt estoppel western produc argu principl estoppel oper prevent commiss deni valid notif alleg suffici inform impart enabl commiss notif submit contain number omiss alleg brandei arrang notori press director gener commiss awar brandei agreement commiss institut term gener trend alleg notif accept valid laps time preclud commiss reopen question accuraci notif argument withstand examin jurisprud court justic show text notif includ text annex materi stand constru strictli notifi fairli preliminari meet commiss offici absolv parti duti make fair accur disclosur notif arrang made duti parti fail perform offici commiss fact detail broad outlin arrang power commit commiss suspens mandatori requir notif regul exist statutori method notif commiss treat glean newspap servic notifi newspap cut suffic similar consider appli gener assert commiss deni fair accur natur notif argument assum commiss time accept notif fair accur fulli set natur arrang made commiss offici conclus knowledg relev fact appear notif made form answer question form found quot begleitschreiben quot form part notif notif evid error omiss parti claim registr notif demonstr accept valid circular letter concern date decemb state difficulti arisen quot condit public quot quot legalis purchas put question quot express quot purchas quot describ brandei agreement noteworthi confirm period notif restrict undertaken foreign trade organ disclos mere registr notif physic receipt commiss offici amount accept valid complet accuraci notif regist articl regul fine notif discov inaccur articl extend protect matter fall limit notif case examin place fact registr notifi parti time knew restrict featur agreement made eec base produc step suppress mention restrict agreement made brandei goldschmidt approv quot begleitschreiben quot brandei agreement defici manner ill argu commiss misl notif parti protect principl estoppel conduct statement reli secur misrepresent articl inapplic commiss refus exempt notif properli made condit laid articl met improv product distribut good agreement restrict access actual potenti competitor sourc suppli contribut improv product distribut good promot technic econom progress restrict freedom competitor obtain suppli altern sourc restrict impos seek revers benefit contempl articl agreement brought object advantag parti public shown advantag charact compens disadvantag field competit case benefit western produc alleg brought respect primari aluminium justifi restrict impos deriv product secondari aluminium semi manufactur scrap restrict impos suppli base materi affect price contribut improv product deriv good bear burden increas cost promot technic econom progress western produc argu agreement market aluminium liabl disturb uncontrol import east jeopard viabil western supplier protect risk alcan describ quot gross violent unforese fluctuat depress price kind arrang design guard quot technic econom progress suffer western produc argu fact price fact contain show consum enjoi benefit agreement restrict parti claim indispens elimin competit respect risk likelihood quot gross violent unforeseen fluctuat depress price quot matter public author account assess measur regul trade public author countri question commun fact possess power restrict import impos duti author question power power thought inadequ unus matter legisl justifi agreement undertak seek adopt divert exist rule meet privat purpos consum fair share benefit effect brandei arrang price actual potenti reserv consum fair share benefit result improv distribut parti depriv access sourc raw materi trade opportun defend interest system ensur fair share benefit restrict indispens protect western aluminium market competit perturb accept improv product distribut contribut econom progress brandei arrang indispens achiev purpos eec produc aluminium need protect competit offer aluminium produc eastern europ proper make applic public author entrust law regul trade elimin competit part agreement object effect confin suppli eastern aluminium western produc mainten price territori eec reason qualifi exempt articl agreement enabl western produc account entir primari aluminium product eec regul aluminium import eec signific sourc directli control possibl elimin competit respect substanti part product question consider suffic exclud applic articl agreement concert practic concern proceed articl regul defici notif consid prescript period council regul eec expir fine defici notif time bar commiss decis impos fine undertak virtu articl intention neglig infring articl treati special circumst case commiss decid impos fine articl regul commiss consist practic issu decis establish infring case parti appar brought infring end decis clarifi point law express statement part iv commiss decis eec practic make legal certainti endors court justic case quot gvl commiss quot paragraph page consider bodi jurisprud competit matter form cohes guidanc nation court articl quot creat direct right respect individu concern nation court safeguard quot case quot brt sabam quot paragraph page right appar real case involv horizont cartel spread nation jurisdict difficulti privat litig obtain proof commiss polici encourag action nation court enforc prohibit contain articl point paragraph thirteenth report competit polici public interest produc declaratori infring decis corpor successor addresse decis kaiser contend respons action predecessor kapal oj oj acquir kapal concern baco merg british subsidiari alcan canada concern kaiser reli exist jurisprud parent compani kaiser europ directli involv earlier action kapal judgment court justic case quot ici commiss quot paragraph page distinct made action parent subsidiari subsidiari shown real independ continu employ senior offic kapal kapal kaiser europ indic continu polici acquisit respect kaiser alcan commiss believ succeed oblig kapal baco competit law acquisit compani right action corpor bodi extinguish acquisit share bodi public polici make except right competit law commiss decis case adopt view decis eec amend decis eec decis eec adopt decis articl element arrang made brandei goldschmidt subsidiari compani brandei goldschmidt ag foreign trade organ aluminium produc name articl constitut infring articl eec treati oblig undertaken foreign trade organ sell exchang barter suppli primari secondari aluminium scrap semi manufactur purchas aluminium produc name articl oblig undertaken foreign trade organ sell aluminium territori price lower purchas brandei agreement ii exce agre quota export aluminium cabl concern denmark access denmark commun restrict import aluminium eec purpos convers product semi manufactur quot spirit agreement quot claus relat export aluminium sourc yugoslavia romania ii price aluminium semi manufactur iii aluminium cabl market arrang make quantiti aluminium trade london metal exchang made foreign trade organ aluminium produc name articl brandei goldschmidt aluminium produc articl element arrang made eisen und metal intrac march constitut infring articl eec treati oblig export primari aluminium semi manufactur feder republ germani eisen und metal agreement arrang oper framework agreement brandei goldschmidt intrac articl action decis epaa support infring refer articl constitut infring articl eec treati articl applic exempt articl eec treati refus articl decis address undertak alcan aluminium place vill mari boît postal cnd montreal oj oj oj alluminio italia spa alsar alumet piazza marconi roma ardal og sunndal verk sørkedalsveien po box oslo bicc po box bloomsburi street uk london wc qn brandei goldschmidt forestreet uk london ec nh eisen und metal ag postfach gelsenkirchen elkem spigerverket middelthun gate po box oslo gränge aluminium lux backen lilla essingen stockholm holland aluminium bv kantoorflat damsigt oosteind nl ax voorburg kaiser aluminium europ rheinpark hau postfach cecillienalle düsseldorf metallgesellschaft ag reuterweg frankfurt main montedison foro buonapart milano norsk hydro bygdøi all oslo péchinei ugin kuhlmann rue balzac boît postal pari reynold aluminium deutschland finkenwerderstraß postfach hamburg rio tinto zinc corpor st jame squar uk london sw ld alusuiss deutschland gmbh seestraß konstanz vereinigt aluminium werk ag georg von boeselag straße postfach bonn vereinigt metallwerk ranshofen berndorf ag braunau ranshofen raznoimport smolenskaja sennaja su moscou intrac handelsgesellschaft mbh schönholzer straße ddr berlin pankow centrala importowo eksportowa quot impexmet quot przedsiebiorstwo panstwow boît postal wilcza pl warszawa keramet foreign trade jasikova cs bratislava metalimpex hungarian foreign trade compani steel metal boît postal budapest associ undertak epaa königsalle postfach düsseldorf brussel decemb commiss fran andriessen member commiss tabl brandei agreement comparison tonnag agre tonnag sold offer gt pic file quot quot gt tabl introduct product limit gt pic file quot quot gt tabl contractu limit gt pic file quot quot gt tabl tonnag bought brandei goldschmidt gt pic file quot quot gt tabl eastern metal contract infring gt pic file quot quot gt tabl enforc agreement gt pic file quot quot gt tabl enforc agreement gt pic file quot quot gt gt pic file quot quot gt tabl aluminium import ussr gt pic file quot quot gt tabl brandei commiss gt pic file quot quot gt tabl relianc energi sourc gt pic file quot quot gt tabl concentr capac ownership gt pic file quot quot gt tabl quantit effect brandei agreement gt pic file quot quot gt tabl brandei agreement tonnag agre sold offer proport european consumpt gt pic file quot quot gt tabl gt pic file quot quot gt tabl commun product semi cast gt pic file quot quot gt tabl eec common unilater import arrang gt pic file quot quot gt gt pic file quot quot gt annex western produc gt pic file quot quot gt gt pic file quot quot gt annex contract brandei western parti gt pic file quot quot gt annex agreement ru brandei goldschmidt ag hirzbodenweg ch basl hereinaft refer quot seller quot part aluminium suiss po box ch zurich hereinaft refer quot buyer quot conclud agreement buyer undertak bui seller period januari decemb cif liner term hamburg rotterdam antwerp le havr genoa venic london liverpool hull swansea newport stockholm ellesmer copenhagen oslo hoyang heroya mosjoen norrkoep kristiansand piraeu kobe osaka yokohama montreal kuibikenborg tyssed eydehaven destin mention parti endeavour reach mutual agreement order achiev smooth run agreement port destin buyer option regard canadian port buyer seller pai half extra freight insur uk port london canadian port nomin buyer quantiti virgin aluminium ingot puriti ton tonnag exact quantiti mutual agre buyer seller septemb preced calendar year contractu deliveri weight ingot kg aluminium deliv pack buyer purchas higher puriti aluminium ingot aluminium roll slab wire bar subject seller supplier confirm aluminium minimum ingot case parti agre rate premium price slab wire bar agre virgin aluminium mention claus agreement buyer notifi seller dai month shipment seller supplier undertak deliv abovement quantiti ingot minimum puriti maximum silicon content balanc maximum silicon content individu shipment consist qualiti physic buyer option balanc high silicon content aluminium minimum puriti maximum silicon premium ton buyer option aluminium roll slab wire bar billet includ alloi billet premium shape mutual agre seller buyer seller supplier undertak sell exchang barter suppli virgin aluminium shape form countri except albania bulgaria hungari cuba german democrat republ romania poland czechoslovakia north korea china vietnam yugoslavia mongolia finland brazil argentina india unit arab republ sweden burma seller supplier undertak materi sold abovement countri unload countri destin seller supplier undertak sell aluminium ingot price lower mention agreement argentina sweden seller supplier convert aluminium countri mention claus prior approv buyer requir price aluminium ingot puriti fix long ton price canadian uk aluminium deliv work publish current issu metal bulletin london present long ton date shipment respect bill lade long ton lb price understood cif liner term port claus agreement agre buyer pai seller minimum price long ton abovement quotat metal bulletin fall long ton case buyer purchas ingot puriti buyer pai seller premium long ton discount long ton mention paragraph claus minimum price mention paragraph claus premium mention paragraph claus base present pariti exchang seller supplier undertak export ton secondari aluminium scrap calendar year agreement countri mention claus agreement except japan seller supplier sell quantiti mention trade agreement countri japan seller supplier undertak materi sold japan unload japan seller supplier undertak sell semi manufactur product aluminium countri except hungari albania bulgaria cuba german democrat republ romania poland czechoslovakia north korea china vietnam yugoslavia mongolia burma indonesia iraq iceland ceylon ghana india unit arab republ cambodia finland nepal morocco pakistan thailand japan saudi arabia syria sudan ethiopia kenya guinea kuwait mali algeria sweden lao libya seller supplier undertak materi sold countri mention unload countri claus appli maximum ton semi manufactur product virgin aluminium seller supplier export countri mention calendar year agreement understood maximum export tonnag franc ton calendar year agreement seller supplier note buyer opinion spirit agreement lower price aluminium semi endang aluminium market undermin agreement seller supplier undertak handl sale semi manufactur product aluminium spirit agreement good ship approxim equal monthli lot commenc januari port amount buyer claus date bill lade consid date shipment seller undertak inform buyer quantiti aluminium deliv dai respect quarter shipment buyer advis seller port destin quantiti dai date receipt notif case aluminium shipment norwegian swedish port swansea lot ton newport ton regard shipment genoa venic stockholm piraeu kobe osaka yokohama buyer give month notic shipment enabl seller supplier bring good port load buyer unabl give long notic seller supplier meet requir buyer buyer compens seller loss seller supplier suffer port load due receipt notif buyer period stipul claus seller supplier undertak insur good full good usual marin risk includ act element accord paragraph claus transport insur rule publish foreign insur depart ussr quot ingosstrakh quot moscow addit cover averag irrespect percentag includ damag caus hook oil freshwat exclud sweat cargo includ theft pilferag deliveri irrespect percentag claim payabl sterl london black sea baltic gener insur subrog lloyd insur cover port load port discharg extend cover warehous port discharg subrog cost lloyd quot polici buyer quot account payment due seller payment made supplier payment effect seller agent messr brandei goldschmidt account warburg gresham street london ec confirm warburg seller agent notifi supplier bank document receiv supplier dispatch seller agent supplier bank correspond london third origin clean negoti ship board steamship compani ocean bill lade issu order blank endors mark quot freight paid quot claus quot liner term quot ship master steamship compani receipt confirm origin bill lade ship bag notifi parti nomin buyer invoic triplic insur polici certif supplier certif qualiti letter guarante triplic certif weight supplier agent port load triplic delai payment seller charg interest buyer rate uk bank rate buyer delai payment week bank charg remitt seller supplier buyer account seller agre supplier circumst aris prevent parti wholli partial carri oblig agreement fire act element war militari oper natur blockad prohibit export import time stipul perform agreement extend proportion long circumst obtain event circumst continu month parti refus continu perform oblig agreement case parti entitl indemnif parti loss sustain certif issu chamber commerc supplier buyer countri case suffici proof oper durat circumst parti unabl carri oblig agreement immedi advis parti commenc termin circumst prevent perform agreement buyer agre event forc majeur declar agreement seller supplier right oblig seller supplier appli seller buyer right oblig buyer seller agre supplier disput differ aris connect contract settl arbitr arbitr compos parti wish appli arbitr notifi thereof parti regist letter state arbitr address subject disput parti nomin arbitr dai receipt letter advis parti regist letter address arbitr parti call arbitr fail nomin arbitr period arbitr parti appoint chamber commerc stockholm sweden case arbitr appoint dai receipt statement parti advis submit disput arbitr arbitr choos umpir dai arbitr fail agre umpir period request parti interest umpir appoint chamber commerc stockholm sweden arbitr held stockholm award arbitr made major vote accord term condit present contract rule law appli principl conflict law arbitr addition appli common intern commerci usag award arbitr motiv composit arbitr place date award indic parti state contempl distribut arbitr expens parti award arbitr made month date appoint umpir final bind parti parti recours legal proceed buyer agre event arbitr seller supplier right oblig seller supplier appli seller buyer right oblig buyer procedur arbitr outlin appli buyer seller buyer seller intend prolong valid agreement enter negoti effect half agre negoti conclud octob latest date parti agreement matter agreement valid decemb seller agre supplier aluminium begin trade london metal exchang appar export aluminium sourc import interfer spirit agreement seller buyer renegoti term serv month notic parti unabl reach agreement end period notic agreement end date quantiti cancel pro rata basi parti entitl transfer right oblig agreement parti written consent parti obtain thereto tax due custom fee connect execut present agreement levi territori seller supplier paid seller supplier levi territori seller supplier paid buyer amend supplement agreement valid made write sign duli author repres parti event claus agreement null void parti agre remain claus remain forc parti agre reinstat amic substitut claus claus declar null void amic agreement reach substitut claus contract submit arbitr accord claus agreement agreement made english sign origin equal forc legal address parti seller brandei goldschmidt ag hirzbodenweg ch basl buyer aluminium suiss po box ch zurich basl march annex agreement brandei goldschmidt hirzbodenweg ch basl hereinaft refer quot seller quot part aluminium françai rue balzac pari hereinaft refer quot buyer quot conclud agreement seller enter arrang raznoimport moscow impexmet warsaw metalimpex budapest intrac berlin metalimex pragu pursuant commit bui amount primari aluminium ingot total long ton period januari decemb understand seller sole purchas right primari aluminium export ussr poland hungari east germani czechoslovakia countri franc except aluminium sold govern trade agreement buyer undertak bui seller period januari decemb quantiti deliveri term cif liner term destin marseil le havr antwerp destin mention parti endeavour reach mutual agreement order achiev smooth run agreement minimum quantiti agreement regard canadian port buyer seller supplier pai half extra freight insur uk port london canadian port nomin buyer port destin buyer option quantiti virgin aluminium ingot puriti long ton tonnag quantiti mutual agre seller buyer septemb preced calendar year weight ingot kg aluminium deliv bundl price aluminium ingot puriti fix long ton present pariti exchang price canadian uk aluminium deliv work publish current issu metal bulletin london present long ton date shipment dispatch seller supplier countri date steamer bill lade railwai bill lade date shipment dispatch seller supplier countri price understood cif liner term destin port destin mention claus agreement agre buyer pai seller minimum price long ton abovement quotat metal bulletin fall long ton present pariti exchang notwithstand buyer seller mutual consent except seller grant buyer favour nation treatment primari metal sold seller common market seller commit refer paragraph claus good ship dispatch approxim equal monthli lot port destin amount buyer claus seller undertak inform buyer quantiti aluminium deliv dai respect quarter shipment dispatch buyer advis seller port destin quantiti dai date receipt notif buyer compens seller loss seller supplier suffer port load due receipt notif buyer period stipul claus seller supplier undertak suffici insur good subrog cost lloyd polici buyer account payment due seller payment made supplier file document delai payment seller charg interest buyer rate uk bank rate buyer delai payment week bank charg remitt seller supplier buyer account seller agre supplier circumst aris prevent parti wholli partial carri oblig agreement fire act element war militari oper natur blockad prohibit export import time stipul perform agreement extend proportion long circumst obtain event circumst continu month parti refus continu perform oblig agreement case parti entitl indemnif parti loss sustain certif issu chamber commerc supplier buyer countri case suffici proof oper durat circumst parti unabl carri oblig agreement immedi advis parti commenc termin circumst prevent perform agreement buyer agre event forc majeur declar agreement seller supplier right oblig seller supplier appli seller buyer right oblig buyer seller agre supplier disput differ aris connect contract settl arbitr buyer agre event arbitr seller supplier right oblig seller supplier appli seller buyer right oblig buyer procedur arbitr settl disput differ seller supplier appli buyer seller buyer seller intend prolong valid agreement enter negoti effect half agre negoti conclud octob latest date parti agreement matter agreement valid decemb appar export aluminium sourc import interfer oblig deliveri agre tonnag seller buyer renegoti term serv month notic parti unabl reach agreement end period notic agreement end date parti entitl transfer right oblig agreement parti written consent parti obtain thereto tax due custom fee connect execut present agreement levi territori seller supplier paid buyer amend supplement agreement valid made write sign duli author repres parti event claus agreement null void parti agre remain claus remain forc parti agre reinstat amic substitut claus claus declar null void amic agreement reach substitut claus contract submit arbitr accord claus agreement basl juli