commiss decis march state aid implement germani efb verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg lintra beteiligungshold gmbh zeitzer maschinen anlagen gerät gmbh landtechnik schlüter gmbh ilka mafa kältetechnik gmbh skl motoren und systembautechnik gmbh skl spezialapparatebau gmbh magdeburg eisengießerei gmbh saxonia edelmetal gmbh gothaer fahrzeugwerk gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof regard council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite procedur letter date januari germani notifi aid privatis compani zeitzer maschinen anlagen gerät gmbh landtechnik schlüter gmbh ilka mafa kältetechnik gmbh skl motoren und systembautechnik gmbh skl spezialapparatebau gmbh magdeburg eisengießerei gmbh saxonia edelmetal gmbh gothaer fahrzeugwerk gmbh hereinaft call quot lintra subsidiari quot brought singl hold own treuhandanstalt hold compani efb verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg lintra beteiligungshold gmbh lintra group privatis privatis restructur project contain aid measur case regist aid commiss question germani letter date februari juli decemb germani submit respons date april juli august januari letter date april commiss inform germani approv restructur aid context privatis lintra beteiligungshold gmbh hereinaft call quot decis march quot basi inform receiv notif restructur aid subsidiari compani lintra group commiss letter date june germani question germani repli letter date decemb annex thereto submit decemb case discuss meet german author letter date june commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss call interest parti submit comment commiss receiv comment interest parti octob germani submit answer question annex decis initi procedur meet german author commiss place novemb remind commiss date decemb german request extens answer deadlin date februari commiss agre letter date februari germani submit comment initi procedur letter date march august commiss germani request provid relev inform determin hold compani expenditur apport individu subsidiari amount aid remain hold compani suitabl alloc german request extens answer deadlin commiss receiv german repli octob meet commiss octob germani addit inform octob ii background develop lintra group privatis state industri gdr larg complet find investor undertak case number enterpris gear economi comecon need complet chang direct industri investor show interest undertak brought form singl group joint restructur privatis bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv decid sell compani privat partnership aim owner lintra group partli reorganis restructur separ entiti secur develop independ competit compani mean cooper experienc industri partner make attract privatis industri investor public tender procedur organis eman amp partner gbr partnership german law select investor partner dr hartmut eman dr andrea weis dr hellmut kirchner friedrich carl graup jörg gehrhardt privatis contract conclud novemb subsequ lintra beteiligungshold gmbh act financi hold compani essenc carri central cash manag group member partnership manageri respons lintra beteiligungshold gmbh lintra subsidiari time commiss approv lintra group compani consist hold compani lintra beteiligungshold gmbh industri subsidiari gt tabl gt privatis relat sale cluster histor unrel compani employe notifi individu commiss assess project rescu restructur guidelin expect restructur period end end commiss approv measur lintra subsidiari march gt tabl gt commiss approv grant aid extent provid lintra subsidiari equiti capit dem million decemb financi assist compani restructur phase bv allow cover annual deficit compani period maximum amount dem million loss cover amount commiss authoris bv end award dem million form grant ti guarante dem million financ invest restructur lintra subsidiari lintra subsidiari origin expect profit latest outset expect actual perform wide differ present june annual report bv recognis shortli commiss approv aid consider risk failur privatis plan end financi situat lintra group critic due higher loss origin expect group face immin threat insolv process jointli privatis restructur cluster econom unrel compani privat partnership prove unsuccess main reason failur origin plan compani product programm unsuit requir western market tradit central east european ci market weaken rapidli inevit consider cost develop product introduc market compani run financi difficulti find stronger industri partner addit lintra group uncoordin assembl wide diversifi activ suffer lack proper manag capabl financi control lintra beteiligungshold consum larg part resourc begin bv step assum financi respons order prevent entir group insolv agreement reach bv investor januari releas depart investor liabil privatis contract return payment dem million agreement lintra beteiligungshold continu administr manag remain subsidiari bv grant full audit power acquir time lintra subsidiari purchas price dem element agreement januari princip object lintra beteiligungshold gmbh resal lintra subsidiari part thereof investor control bv assess subsidiari chanc viabl continu restructur subsequ decid close entiti econom viabl magdeburg eisengießerei gmbh skl sell profit saxonia edelmetal gmbh directli grant aid continu restructur zemag elka mafa skl lt gothaer fahrzeugwerk cooper lintra view prepar potenti viabl entiti resal industri partner purchas contract conclud bv lintra beteiligungshold gmbh remain investor septemb bv acquir lintra beteiligungshold gmbh dem compani liquid januari letter date june commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati express doubt point provid germani complet correct inform prior decis march extent aid scope decis march aid grant lintra group iii comment interest parti commiss receiv comment interest parti iv comment germani commiss decis initi articl procedur contain annex addit question germani answer letter date octob letter date march germani submit comment point rais commiss decis initi procedur comment germani main element continu restructur lintra group provid inform aid grant bv lintra group present argument doubt rais decis initi procedur repli inform request august germani argu aid lintra beteiligungshold gmbh cover decis march aid approv commiss restructur lintra group amount dem million dem million grant group sole aim hold compani pursu separ busi activ facilit restructur subsidiari hold compani central provid servic exchang fee subsidiari aid subsidiari refin fee spent facilit restructur servic provid lintra hold compani subsidiari contract extern notifi plan restructur lintra subsidiari decis march expressli refer hold structur assess complet correct inform doubt express decis initi procedur germani provid commiss complet correct inform relat aspect privatis lintra subsidiari subject investig german feder court auditor commiss inform time decis investig relev commiss assess compat aid commiss doubt initi procedur provid complet inform prior decis march commiss express doubt decis initi procedur german author commiss assess aid lintra group run difficulti fail provid commiss correct inform question commiss provid complet inform prior decis march commiss note privatis lintra subsidiari fact subject investig german feder court auditor start septemb conclud report septemb initi procedur germani submit complet correspond bv court auditor final report correspond septemb march show period court auditor rais concern contractu provis potenti share bv futur profit subsidiari knowledg correspond court auditor bv march determin factor decis result final report present court auditor septemb month decis march account commiss time judg compat aid respect question commiss suppli correct inform time decis commiss note aid measur notifi januari januari germani provid estim loss dem million bv receiv estim lintra group decemb june account present bv annual account accord oblig privatis contract submit account date reveal dem million loss estim lintra hold compani decemb actual loss fact dem million view high volum aid packag approv commiss amount approv loss cover plausibl commiss decis accept limit viabil compani year restructur decis precis figur actual loss incur commiss partial incorrect inform time decis inform determin factor decis authoris aid aid measur initi articl procedur germani provid overview made grant aid result shown tabl total aid dem million authoris commiss part dem million grant lintra group inform provid germani amount dem million grant lintra group dem million grant subsidiari dem million remain lintra beteiligungshold decemb gt tabl gt respect provis equiti capit commiss decis march approv provis lintra subsidiari equiti capit dem million decemb achiev waiv claim sharehold loan dem million grant dem million bv authoris cover loss maximum dem million award grant total aid approv commiss ensur equiti capit dem million amount dem million commiss conclud provis equiti capit dem million bv lintra group accord decis march take account modif due financi clear lintra group delai provis equiti capit bv total aid requir achiev authoris equiti capit dem million lintra group amount dem million approv dem million respect loss particip commiss decis march approv aid cover annual deficit period dem million form waiver exist claim maximum dem million total assum loss loss cover form waiver exist claim loss incur lintra group fulli cover dem million loss partial offset dem million total dem million absenc sharehold loan origin assum extent bv grant remain dem million loss cover oblig lintra subsidiari order cover annual deficit amount dem million grant failur restructur oper form liquid loan lintra subsidiari prepar restructur attempt restructur lintra group regard fail decemb bv decid time continu restructur potenti viabl entiti resal industri partner situat liquid loan dem million budget restructur lintra group grant number subsidiari repai overdu bill grant april june subsidiari restructur feasibl aid grant bv failur restructur lintra group prepar restructur regard cover decis march financ restructur lintra subsidiari end commiss decis march approv grant dem million award guarante amount dem million approv grant dem million paid full guarante dem million grant amount dem million supplement invest loan dem million answer question aid measur approv decis march purpos approv restructur plan germani letter octob march submit detail inform restructur measur respect develop individu compani failur origin privatis plan decemb commiss note gothaer fahrzeugwerk gmbh comparison invest carri origin invest plan eman amp partner gbr lead conclus origin plan invest project carri origin plan level capit expenditur achiev time observ invest undertaken plan inform provid germani due technic induc prepar complet time fact final posit compani market fairli long period insuffici clear ilka mafa ilka mafa commiss note origin invest plan eman amp partner gbr detail invest plan dem million involv lowest plan volum invest plan amount year exceed actual level invest dem million low invest due uncertainti outset surround posit compani market landtechnik schönebeck gmbh failur restructur oper implement invest essenti carri framework origin invest plan invest amount origin plan invest volum exceed actual volum invest period disproport plan realis invest reflect problem compani reposit market unabl resolv satisfactorili suffici success develop market product origin plan invest reach final decis stage magdeburg eisengießerei gmbh meg origin invest plan eman amp partner gbr provid total volum invest period dem million compani end carri invest dem million commiss note high invest result form market success major strateg goal reorganis meg achiev depend order skl compani plan reposit market achiev attract custom base loss skl custom due liquid decreas demand skl meg increasingli pressur novemb file insolv inform provid germani meg hive vehicl set continu busi oper eisengießerei magdeburg gmbh egm receiv state aid initi insolv proceed saxonia edelmetal gmbh overview invest carri show origin invest plan implement modifi form plan invest volum period dem million exceed realis invest dem million invest implement result success reorient compani market invest improv product semi finish preciou metal product core invest carri area reinforc wet chemistri product preciou metal product preciou metal recycl consider extens galvanis technolog invest prioriti creat precondit acquisit compani stronger industri partner vereinigt deutsch nickelwerk plan sharehold saxonia inform provid germani invest total dem million end particip bv skl entir period plan invest volum exceed actual invest observ invest magnitud carri reorient compani market requir stronger industri partner decis june liquid skl origin invest plan eman amp partner gbr skl extens invest programm lintra subsidiari total plan volum dem million actual invest period exceed origin expect plan market orient compani achiev satisfactorili extens capit expenditur requir establish engin test stand inform provid germani invest construct univers test stand addit test stand serv research develop purpos singl cylind engin research develop test stand fulli implement commiss consid failur restructur oper origin invest plan implement substanti degre zemag gmbh comparison invest origin plan eman amp partner gbr actual invest carri show plan invest volum exce actual volum invest approxim dem million inform provid germani decreas volum invest due uncertainti surround develop compani crane build divis strategi measur success posit market implement end compani sold investor jacobi amp lobeck stop build crane sold compani divis conclus made aid lintra subsidiari commiss consid failur restructur oper decemb aid essenti accord requir restructur plan approv commiss respect commiss account fact restructur plan decis march base time drawn detail form basi inform submit germani initi procedur consider commiss consid aid amount grant subsidiari context restructur oper grant conform decis march gt tabl gt decis initi procedur commiss express doubt question aid award lintra group commiss note failur origin restructur oper restructur process interrupt begin restructur plan substanti modifi due circumst partli unforese restructur approv date clear origin restructur oper fail germani longer reli commiss origin approv justifi grant aid lintra subsidiari inter alia prepar restructur oper difficulti monitor lintra privatis programm bv delai notif aid lintra subsidiari grant anticip prepar round restructur addit inform receiv germani help remov doubt rais decis initi procedur respect assum award dem million decemb supplementari invest loan dem million assum award dem million decemb germani confirm aid fulli declar notif lintra subsidiari aid context continu restructur subsidiari assess separ context assess restructur lintra subsidiari aid grant lintra group purpos envisag approv restructur plan fall scope decis march decis aid directli purpos restructur lintra subsidiari notifi restructur plan decis explicitli aid lintra beteiligungshold gmbh elig restructur aid compani difficulti aid subsidiari purpos purchas servic lintra beteiligungshold gmbh expressli provid restructur plan decis march germani confirm rule aid fact subsidiari pai servic provid compani addit repli inform request germani provid rough set figur expens lintra beteiligungshold gmbh personnel cost legal cost offic rent demonstr servic compani provid time subsidiari return payment germani unabl provid evid respect commiss amount dem million remain lintra beteiligungshold cover decis march part grant aid remain lintra beteiligungshold dem million accord provis approv restructur plan recipi contravent decis march constitut misus aid mean articl ec treati read conjunct articl regul ec commiss conclud amount dem million remain lintra beteiligungshold misus germani recov misus aid amount dem million lintra beteiligungshold gmbh subsidiari amount broken amount dem million liquid loan transfer earli subsidiari residu amount dem million germani unabl answer request inform give detail account reason recit amount dem million dem million fall scope decis march aid origin grant lintra group group longer exist commiss requir examin extent individu compani group benefit aid repay oblig impos compani belong group time aid grant basi inform provid germani lintra beteiligungshold gmbh undoubtedli receiv aid amount dem million germani prove amount pass subsidiari circumst amount recov lintra beteiligungshold subsidiari germani enabl commiss establish detail part aid consid limit repay oblig incumb separ subsidiari amount share total volum aid compat common market subsidiari receiv amount dem million link subsidiari grant failur attempt restructur lintra group light basi inform germani suppli dem million recov individu subsidiari gt tabl gt inform amount dem million apport subsidiari commiss decid germani provid relev inform basi inform receiv germani respons inform request commiss consid amount dem million apport subsidiari proport aid receiv restructur period gt tabl gt misus aid amount dem million recov jointli sever lintra beteiligungshold gmbh liabl amount lintra subsidiari share aid receiv basi proport misus aid recov subsidiari amount gt tabl gt amount recov lintra beteiligungshold reduc liabil individu lintra subsidiari proport sale lintra subsidiari investor failur restructur oper stand full applic commun law effect oblig recov aid question vi conclus basi inform provid germani initi articl procedur commiss conclud germani fail provid commiss complet correct inform prior decis inform determin factor decis condit set articl regul ec revoc decis march met commiss note total amount aid authoris dem million lintra group receiv dem million respect question extent grant aid accord term decis march commiss conclud amount dem million accord decis compat common market hand amount dem million remain lintra beteiligungshold accord decis march amount misus aid total dem million recov lintra beteiligungshold gmbh lintra subsidiari amount dem million recov lintra subsidiari laid recit amount dem million recov jointli sever lintra beteiligungshold lintra subsidiari laid recit adopt decis articl aid amount dem million authoris commiss privatis restructur compani zeitzer maschinen anlagen gerät gmbh landtechnik schlüter gmbh ilka mafa kältetechnik gmbh skl motoren und systembautechnik gmbh skl spezialapparatebau gmbh magdeburg eisengießerei gmbh saxonia edelmetal gmbh gothaer fahrzeugwerk gmbh hereinaft call lintra subsidiari hold compani efb verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg lintra beteiligungshold gmbh grant conform decis march articl amount dem million authoris commiss restructur lintra subsidiari misus mean articl ec treati articl germani measur recov misus aid refer articl total dem million lintra beteiligungshold gmbh lintra subsidiari amount dem million recov subsidiari gt tabl gt remain amount dem million recov jointli sever lintra beteiligungshold gmbh liabl amount lintra subsidiari amount gt tabl gt amount recov lintra beteiligungshold gmbh reduc liabil individu lintra subsidiari proport recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date dispos recipi date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli therewith articl decis address feder republ germani brussel march commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj letter germani date april sg summari publish oj footnot judgment court justic case itali commiss ecr paragraph