commiss decis decemb aid scheme implement kingdom netherland manur process compani notifi document number dutch version authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof regard council regul ec march lai dtail rule applic articl ec treati call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite procedur complaint drawn commiss attent case aid grant manur process project netherland quot bijdrageregel proefprojecten mestverwerk quot bpm scheme commiss approv scheme oper complain alleg aid grant date letter date juli sg commiss enjoin dutch author provid work dai receiv injunct relev inform enabl determin aid measur concern cover bpm scheme approv commiss disclos aid grant project letter date octob octob dutch author forward number document answer question rais commiss injunct letter date sg commiss inform dutch author decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect case aid paid scheme expir commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid measur commiss receiv comment interest parti ii detail descript aid commiss approv bpm scheme juli year decis decemb scheme extend end dutch author authoris grant invest aid elig cost larg scale manur process plant scheme design stimul creation outlet manur surplu netherland dutch author focus aid prevent overproduct manur environment friendli wai dispos surplu manur manur process invest aid alloc pilot instal manur process method test test plant compris process phase manur saleabl product pre purif instal pure effluent extract larg scale storag process facil poultri dung pile open emit ammonia bpm scheme expir dutch author grant state aid amount eur manur process compani ferm feed bv fleuren compost bv vloet oploo bv smith markelo arev venhorst memon kpi lastli compani ferm feed benefit state aid evid aid pilot project amount grant expiri bpm scheme gt tabl gt commiss initi procedur laid articl ec treati doubt case cover bpm scheme caught articl except set appear appli regard part derog articl commiss view commun guidelin state aid environment protect hereinaft refer quot environment guidelin quot appli evid produc invest aid made achiev significantli higher level environment protect plan aid intens excess threshold guidelin commun guidelin state aid small medium size enterpris refer hereinaft quot sme guidelin quot appli aid larg enterpris excess aid intens threshold guidelin rule iii comment netherland dutch author quot steunverlen quot grant quot besliss omtrent toeken van een bijdrag quot decis grant contribut legal bind act state aid grant decis govern undertak pai aid applic maximum amount condit recipi compli condit scheme decis decemb recipi inform quot toekenningsbrief quot grant letter stage proceed dutch author argu state aid grant bpm scheme expir form part scheme quot bevestigingsbrief quot confirm letter confirm receipt applic grant issu scheme expir dutch govern held larg scale manur process project requir individu notif notifi project question reason final ferm feed dutch govern point scheme prevent author provid aid project propos compani iv assess aid applic bpm scheme order determin aid compani question classifi exist aid commiss examin extent bpm scheme appli aforement project main legal question case differ interpret constitut legal bind act grant aid dutch govern argu legal bind act compet author undertak grant aid grant letter take view grant grant letter issu decemb cover scheme letter confirm deadlin scrutinis document administr procedur relev case commiss take view legal bind act grant letter letter confirm acknow edgement receipt aid applic prior examin condit aid scheme met grant aid condit evalu advisori committe compris repres ministri committe made assess nation level ministri agricultur natur manag fisheri compet matter issu grant letter indic amount elig cost amount aid condit grant analysi procedur step show aid grant automat applic basi discretionari decis compet author commiss consid date aid grant date grant letter confirm dutch author instanc aid grant manur process compani cover scheme regard unlaw aid implement breach articl aid mean articl ec treati invest aid grant dutch govern design promot invest manur facil favour compani question process anim manur sold primarili dry organ fertilis form manur pellet manur process plant competit manufactur organ chemic fertilis financi incent strengthen plant financi posit threaten distort competit european union farmyard manur fertilis compet organ fertilis studi sale potenti countri dutch process anim manur carri dutch ministri question anim veget fertilis compet local basi french spanish portugues italian greek market dutch share total intra commun trade product amount dutch export process anim manur member state expect increas primarili result aforement project spite inform injunct dutch author fail provid requisit detail market situat individu compani detail made assess compani impact manur process fertilis market reason commiss base assess data market aid affect trade member state sector concern constitut state aid mean articl compat aid articl ec treati aid cover approv applic aid scheme bpm scheme expir contrast argument put forward dutch govern aid grant manur process compani question requir individu notif size dutch author fail meet oblig pursuant articl commiss consid measur aid pursuant articl appli principl set articl propos aid regard compat common market articl articl appli reason derog articl appli present case aid social charact grant individu consum make good damag caus natur disast grant economi area feder republ germani affect divis germani derog articl appli present case aid design promot econom develop area standard live abnorm low underemploy derog articl concern commiss take view aid intend promot import project common european interest remedi disturb economi member state region aspect derog articl appli compani locat assist area aid design promot cultur heritag conserv mean articl dutch author attempt justifi aid ground enumer compat aid articl ec treati part articl aid facilit develop econom activ commiss base assess fact bpm scheme design primarili medium size compani set pilot manur process facil provid environment friendli dispos manur surplus accord dutch legisl restrict manur product council direct eec decemb protect water pollut caus nitrat agricultur sourc quot nitrat direct quot commiss approv extens bpm scheme except basi dutch govern provid incent introduct innov technolog success outcom project depend willing farmer pai manur produc farm process gave approv commiss point project turn viabl priori neg attitud aid manur process netherland made clear dutch author commiss fundament review approach bpm scheme dutch author expect project base condit bpm scheme regard compat articl commiss assess compat aid light sme guidelin pursuant point guidelin commiss approv aid sme area qualifi domest region aid condit aid intens exce case small enterpris case medium size enterpris mean sme guidelin appli case compani meet criteria set point guidelin aid grant exce authoris ceil case fleuren compost bv aid intens ceil laid sme guidelin spite doubt express commiss size compani concern inform injunct accompani decis initi proceed dutch author fail show compani compli criteria set point guidelin dutch author provid evid compani compli sme criteria laid guidelin justifi aid basi provid evid gener principl enshrin point guidelin respect commiss take view sme guidelin appli commiss assess project light environment guidelin firstli commiss examin measur question compli condit govern grant invest aid set point guidelin commiss take view point applic environment oblig result nitrat direct appli farmer view limit manur product aid recipi parti concern oblig environment guidelin appli aid pursuant point aid encourag firm improv mandatori environment standard authoris invest significantli higher level environment protect attain requir mandatori standard dutch author produc evid case measur question commiss doubt manur process plant attain higher target set direct eec pilot plant receiv aid scheme oper close commiss aid paid scheme expir justifi ground led except extens commiss scrutinis measur aid firm adapt mandatori standard basi inform take view requir set point environment guidelin met guidelin aid authoris level gross elig cost limit period respect plant oper year standard enter forc violat condit aid grant manur process plant aid intens regard grant aid ferm feed bv commiss consid grant aid time varianc principl laid bpm scheme aid grant pilot project aim promot environment friendli process manur base assess fact articl publish agrarisch dagblad novemb ferm feed bv environment permit withdrawn compet dutch author ground compani compli dutch environment legisl aid paid check condit set grant letter met addit relev file grant aid design enabl pilot plant built aid grant renew expand product capac dutch author unabl produc evid project repres innov comparison commiss take view grant aid ferm feed bv compat environment guidelin reason elabor regard case aid paid scheme expir commiss examin point environment guidelin appli condit approv oper aid environment protect compens extra product cost comparison tradit cost addit aid temporari principl degress commiss decid decemb rais object dutch author plan grant invest aid construct larg scale manur process plant end decis base environment object high commerci risk project commerci risk commiss point invest larg scale manur process plant regard pilot project design provid special incent plant built time frame laid demonstr viabil commiss awar fact dutch author import object grant aid manur process plant question relat environment friendli process manur view avoid extern cost form water pollut ga emiss residu heavi metal mere fact project approv life bpm scheme highlight difficulti set viabl manur process plant note manur process profit activ viabil plant depend willing farmer suppli manur pai process uncertainti connect econom viabil larg scale manur process plant confirm complaint written question member european parliament suggest manur process costli perman depend subsidi number plant met financi difficulti overcom addit oper aid line establish neg view oper aid commiss final decis prohibit aid manur process manur process plant subsidis bpm scheme close viabl commiss consid project aid grant scheme expir purpos introduc technolog scheme depend ongo aid order sustain product mean aid temporari degress condit laid point environment guidelin met measur question compli sme guidelin environment guidelin regard contribut develop econom activ affect trade member state extent contrari common interest derog articl relev principl prohibit articl fulli applic dutch author provid evid aid compat ec treati aid deem incompat common market commiss oblig judgment hand court justic case upheld case requir member state recov recipi aid grant unlawfulli repay order revert previou situat withdraw financi benefit firm receiv unlaw aid improperli enjoi date aid paid recoveri incompat unlaw aid oblig impos commiss regul ec aid repaid delai accord procedur laid dutch law effect implement commiss decis amount repay includ interest calcul date aid grant date recov interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid conclus aid paid manur process compani question constitut aid distort competit affect trade mean articl derog articl applic condit laid commun guidelin state aid environment protect commun guidelin state aid small medium size enterpris met aid incompat common market commiss find kingdom netherland unlawfulli implement aid breach articl aid recov adopt decis articl state aid kingdom netherland implement favour manur process compani ferm feed bv fleuren compost bv vloet oploo bv smith markelo arev venhorst memon kpi amount eur incompat common market articl kingdom netherland measur recov recipi aid refer articl unlawfulli made recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date dispos recipi date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl kingdom netherland inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address kingdom netherland brussel decemb commiss mario monti member commiss oj scheme approv juli footnot oj oj booz allen amp hamilton quot afzetmogelijkheden voor verwerkt dierlijk mest quot hagu derog region aid oj aid oj quot sticht natuur en milieu quot foundat natur environ lodg complaint letter date novemb written question nel van dijk oj decis eec oj case commiss germani ecr case deufil commiss ecr case commiss germani ecr