annual report strasbourg februari mr josé maría gil robl gil delgado presid european parliament rue wiertz bruxel mr presid accord articl treati establish european commun articl decis european parliament regul gener condit govern perform ombudsman duti present report year jacob söderman ombudsman european union content gt tabl gt foreword establish offic european ombudsman import achiev maastricht treati relat citizenship union possibl appli ombudsman right european citizenship guarante commun law annual report announc propos reform mandat power procedur european ombudsman offic annual report light experi gain offic began work septemb larg part foreword dedic fulfil undertak purpos ponder need establish fulli ombudsman offic serv european citizen effect firstli inform reader structur annual report previou full year activ signific chang made select case present report previou annual report includ case close inquiri earli year offic order give complet pictur ombudsman work grow number case mean includ longer defens point view citizen case fact repetit earlier signific public interest report adopt normal practic nation ombudsman offic includ select case length report reason limit ensur remain clear readabl case rais signific issu principl includ rais issu compet procedur ombudsman find gener interest studi case close inquiri websit provid inform fresh comprehens form juli publish decis english languag complain paper copi decis obtain ombudsman offic result annual report dealt european parliament critic voic suggest ombudsman success small percentag case view reach basi receiv complaint includ mandat judg result ombudsman activ fair complaint mandat advis complain transfer complaint compet bodi manag case ombudsman offic handl total case complaint receiv initi inquiri launch year inquiri close reason decis case institut settl matter friendli solut found case close critic remark equival figur case maladministr found find maladministr neg citizen process inquiri requir institut explain complain case convinc complain act properli ombudsman offic close watch result point view citizen field forget continu improv outcom case number case dealt main aim time deal case shorten year target month decid admiss year close case inquiri fulli reach realiti year posit result achiev initi inquiri conduct ombudsman dai dai handl complaint citizen bring problem recur issu ombudsman attent case posit initi ombudsman address matter question novemb launch inquiri exist public access commun institut bodi code good administr behaviour offici relat public idea code consist support european parliament mr roi perri mep rapporteur report committe petit activ call code good administr behaviour establish commun institut bodi parliament stress quot import code reason public access understand ident european institut bodi quot detail initi inquiri found chapter section hope announc posit result initi futur annual report freedom movement origin spanish propos establish european ombudsman offic idea ombudsman supervis right european citizen commun law level european union nation region municip level high number complaint mandat complaint receiv european citizen understand mandat european ombudsman limit activ commun institut bodi analysi complaint mandat commun law made josé martínez aragón princip legal advisor secretariat present chapter annual report show complaint concern freedom movement union freedom movement right union citizenship guarante articl treati european ombudsman assist european citizen order benefit fundament confer total proper principl subsidiar consist promot idea nation ombudsmen similar bodi encourag assist deal complaint european citizen commun law relev treati amsterdam enter forc bring question visa asylum foreign right classic complaint issu ombudsmen similar bodi nation level domain commun law petit european parliament made matter principl polit signific cooper nation region bodi develop posit prepar propos chang point mandat european ombudsman laid treati undertak increas effort field citizen remedi commun law mention treati order properli inform european citizen right respect societi govern rule law court constitut main system rule law upheld moment provis inform citizen vital role plai nation court ensur respect commun law complain nation ombudsmen petit parliament case conflict administr involv commun law mention treati member state oblig ensur legal structur includ effect judici bodi citizen appli purpos underlin european citizen complain european commiss breach commun law member state includ treati guarante statu citizen parti process ensur proper transpar deal complaint futur chang ombudsman statut european parliament initi chang financi regul order establish independ budget european ombudsman initi welcom offic time adjust deal complaint hamper independ budget year realist respect timet give time make requir amend ombudsman statut issu statut substanti import concern limit inquiri set articl access file refus quot duli substanti ground secreci quot offici servant commun institut bodi testifi request ombudsman quot speak behalf accord instruct administr continu bound duti profession secreci quot limit unnecessari inappropri idea ombudsman inquiri citizen expect relev fact document ombudsman inform fulli releas public classifi case citizen ombudsman inquiri restrict inspect file need testimoni limit laid hear wit unaccept understood liter oblig wit lie cover fraud case instruct superior administr make reliabl inquiri wit requir speak truth releas relev fact inquiri reason present provis statut fact obstacl deal properli case corrupt fraud european administr aim ombudsman inquiri contribut fight corrupt fraud administr basi complaint initi inappropri limit remov practic ombudsman refus access file convers disput arisen due abovement limit process take testimoni initi avoid doubt treati make clear ombudsman full access purpos inquiri file document held commun institut bodi offici give full truth testimoni ombudsman natur requir articl statut ombudsman staff disclos document reveal inform obtain inquiri remain forc fruit cooper rule european parliament european ombudsman recent renew date insert provis parliament deal annual report special report ombudsman order ensur main respons respect confer respons committe parliament request expert opinion committe depend substanc report draft report readi issu matter settl end legislatur need procedur establish parliament take half discuss rule cooper european parliament respons committe ombudsman goodwil demonstr cooper produc posit result construct flexibl cooper continu produc result posit attitud atmospher successfulli replac detail sophist rule final commun institut bodi cooper construct attitud ombudsman offic mention regard european parliament respons committe committe petit profound effort consist assist establish european ombudsman offic order serv support citizen europ enhanc relat citizen european union administr jacob söderman decemb complaint ombudsman import task european ombudsman deal maladministr activ commun institut bodi except court justic court instanc act judici role instanc maladministr attent ombudsman complaint made european citizen ombudsman possibl conduct inquiri initi european citizen citizen live member state make complaint ombudsman busi associ bodi regist offic union complain complaint made ombudsman directli member european parliament complaint ombudsman dealt public complain request confidenti import ombudsman act open transpar european citizen follow understand work set good ombudsman dealt case complaint receiv directli individu citizen associ compani complaint transmit member european parliament case brought forward year ombudsman began initi inquiri note ombudsman annual report agreement committe ombudsman mutual transfer complaint petit case petit transfer ombudsman consent petition dealt complaint complaint transfer consent complain european parliament dealt petit addition case ombudsman advis complain petit european parliament annex statist legal basi ombudsman work ombudsman work carri accord articl treati establish european commun statut ombudsman implement provis adopt ombudsman articl statut text implement provis offici languag publish ombudsman websit http www euro ombudsman eu int text ombudsman offic implement provis deal intern oper ombudsman offic order form document understand citizen includ materi relat institut bodi contain statut ombudsman articl implement provis rule govern public access document held european ombudsman rule procedur european parliament number provis rule parliament relationship european ombudsman juli parliament adopt rule propos committe rule procedur rapporteur mr brian crowlei draft report propos amend rule consider committe rule procedur rapporteur mr johann voggenhub propos amend make clear ombudsman annual special report dealt respons committe practic committe petit mandat european ombudsman complaint ombudsman regist acknowledg letter acknowledg inform complain procedur complaint includ telephon number legal offic deal step examin complaint mandat ombudsman mandat ombudsman establish articl ec treati empow receiv complaint citizen union natur legal person resid regist offic member state instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi except court justic court instanc act judici role complaint mandat complain person entitl make complaint complaint commun institut bodi court justic court instanc act judici role concern instanc maladministr entitl complain april quot associ person nationalis real properti quot seat romania complain ombudsman complaint concern romanian law dealt restitut real estat nationalis communist regim complain view law legalis nationalis larg extent contravent romanian constitut european convent human right ratifi romania complain ask ombudsman persuad romanian author modifi contest legisl order provid extens restitut properti ombudsman inform complain associ complaint mandat seat member state european union council europ adopt resolut subject matter complaint complain awar inform complain possibl contact european commiss human right note case complaint made authoris complain ombudsman possibl deal matter initi inquiri case question initi inquiri aris subject matter involv instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi case hl complaint commun institut bodi februari mr employe technic centr agricultur rural cooper cta complain ombudsman employ contract centr termin complain observ longer reli staff committe cta want ombudsman form legal redress open ombudsman consid complaint fell mandat concern commun institut bodi articl statut cta set framework acp african caribbean pacif state ec lomé convent intern agreement govern acp ec committe ambassador articl fourth lomé convent ombudsman inform mr case ov court justic court instanc act quot judici role quot articl ec treati european ombudsman empow receiv complaint instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi quot except court justic court instanc act judici role quot februari hartmut nassauer mep forward ombudsman complaint mr alleg maladministr registrar court justic court instanc deal request access file proceed initi court mr claim registrar act administr capac decis decis court act judici role claim citizen access file court fundament enshrin nation constitut european convent human right failur respect infring constitut member state articl german constitut question complaint involv court justic court instanc act judici role question commun law highest author court justic repli ombudsman inquiri case presid court justic court instanc state court act judici role deal request access case file ombudsman continu inquiri instanc maladministr case ombudsman close case case vk quot maladministr quot ombudsman annual report gave exhaust list exampl maladministr respons call european parliament clear definit term ombudsman offer definit annual report maladministr occur public bodi fail act accord rule principl bind deal annual report european parliament consid definit explan provid annual report clear pictur li remit ombudsman mr newman propos behalf committe petit adopt resolut welcom definit appli definit identifi rule principl bind contribut make rule principl concret made code good administr behaviour code good administr behaviour code good administr behaviour help staff commun institut bodi deal request complaint citizen code easili access public instanc form decis publish offici journal european commun provid citizen inform right standard administr expect year gener tendenc set code checklist good administr behaviour member state intern organis ombudsman refer instanc recommend april council oecd improv ethic conduct public servic intern ombudsman institut publish administr fair checklist law member state ombudsman drew attent recent french draft law improv relat administr public administr ethic checklist establish ombudsman ireland administr procedur law belgium denmark finland portug commun institut bodi initi ombudsman awar european commiss decemb secretari gener commiss ombudsman draft code conduct european commiss offici relat public januari ombudsman remark content form draft code provid commiss nation exampl code good administr behaviour basi articl treati european union european citizen entitl expect consist approach matter presuppos arbitrari differ institut bodi exist public access code avoid novemb ombudsman began initi inquiri exist public access commun institut bodi code good administr behaviour offici relat public ask commun institut bodi decentralis agenc inform adopt agre adopt code good administr behaviour offici relat public easili access citizen content code good administr behaviour ombudsman observ includ gener rule substant procedur principl substant principl code includ instanc oblig appli law establish rule procedur principl law avoid discrimin principl equal treatment measur proport aim pursu principl proportion avoid abus power ensur object imparti includ abstent case person interest respect legitim expect principl legal certainti act fairli act consist procedur principl code includ oblig repli correspond languag citizen articl ec treati amend treati amsterdam send acknowledg receipt repli offici charg file telephon number transfer letter file compet servic respect heard make statement decis right defenc repli decis reason time limit includ impli reject decis account relev consider exclud irrelev state reason individu decis neg decis notifi decis person concern possibl remedi appeal neg individu decis maintain adequ record code oblig deal directli citizen duti provid clear understand inform give correct advic deal correctli telephon call act courtesi apologis error promot public access code distribut leaflet citizen initi inquiri address commun institut bodi due repli ombudsman februari freedom movement mandat ombudsman ombudsman receiv increas number complaint obstacl encount citizen exercis move freeli union intern frontier problem frequent rais rang exist border control difficulti encount establish member state exercis econom activ problem deliveri resid permit student retir work person applic discriminatori practic ground nation problem creat confus disappoint citizen exampl complaint made freedom movement entri resid mr german citizen complain obtain assist german administr wish move germani ireland case vk complain state german citizen live franc unabl obtain resid permit french administr claim prove live countri case adb mr live germani husband itali complain time friend rel intend visit husband visit report polic case adb studi employ mr french nation complain discrimin daughter studi netherland foreign offer facil dutch student free public transport separ social insur scheme case adb complain french citizen qualifi primari school teacher belgium move back franc complain allow work year privat school temporari contract renew year order authoris work french teacher complain requir pass examin civil servant attend year case xd complain dutch dietician want practic franc unabl obtain recognit relev diploma french ministri employ ministri educ claim power deal matter case ov mr qualifi experienc physiotherapist offer job unit kingdom provid obtain recognit spanish diploma council profess supplementari medicin unit kingdom refus recognis diploma ground major differ spain unit kingdom profess case xd taxat administr formal mr finnish citizen work sweden complain swedish pension tax sweden finland case bb complain move germani netherland claim order regist car netherland provid relev paper licenc plate car dutch author complain process week car case vk mr portugues nation work franc made redund decid back portug receiv unemploy benefit complain great difficulti obtain relev document franc case adb mr spanish citizen work franc switzerland made redund decid return spain parent obtain social secur benefit spain ask produc document deliv worker activ member state union case adb obstacl exercis free movement person result incorrect implement applic commun law nation region local administr evalu problem unveil complaint potenti solut ombudsman account work undertaken recent year commun institut propos made quot high level panel free movement person quot group expert gather commiss januari report prepar european parliament propos ombudsman experi support conclus akin reach high level panel parliament report european ombudsman open inquiri complaint nation region local administr member state articl statut quot framework treati ombudsman uncov maladministr activ commun institut bodi action author person subject complaint ombudsman quot accord provis ombudsman declar complaint relat free movement person union receiv mandat practic suggest complaint forward institut deal member state failur compli commun law altern complaint directli transfer institut provid previou agreement complain action depend situat stake effect solut ombudsman pass case commun institut commiss guardian treati committe petit european parliament altern similar institut member state nation region ombudsmen type respons satisfactori problem requir speedi concert action commun nation level commun institut gener lack resourc mean tackl case case problem result occasion administr decis recours nation bodi limit difficult commun consider aris desir design mechan cope problem commun nation bodi combin effort rapid solut individu problem respect ombudsman share point view put forward high level panel conclud quot satisfactori applic free movement requir involv concern quot includ report recognis european ombudsman nation ombudsmen closer cooper european ombudsman similar institut member state nation region local level facilit exchang inform specif problem free circul person europ ultim effect pressur respons administr author cooper involv european commiss committe petit european parliament definit exist right commun law scope free movement person mean protect defenc appear desir individu easili mean protect right vest european citizen treati provis ombudsman intend pursu review complaint relat free movement person union monitor develop area view make specif propos futur admiss complaint complaint mandat ombudsman meet criteria admiss ombudsman open inquiri criteria set statut ombudsman author object complaint identifi articl statut ombudsman interven case court question sound court rule articl complaint made year date fact base attent complain articl complaint preced administr approach institut bodi concern articl case complaint work relationship institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint exhaust lodg complaint articl inadmiss complaint court proceed februari mr lawyer wrote ombudsman legal proceed begun client compani po po complain commiss march propos merger compani commiss refus open examin merger po brought proceed court instanc challeng refus mr request ombudsman interven proceed court instanc ii examin commiss act fairli refus investig po complaint relat request articl statut ombudsman quot ombudsman interven case court quot relat request articl ec treati ombudsman conduct inquiri quot alleg fact subject legal proceed quot ombudsman inform mr interven proceed court instanc inquir question commiss act unfairli deal po complaint case ijh ground inquiri ombudsman deal complaint mandat meet criteria admiss articl ec treati quot conduct inquiri find ground quot case suffici ground ombudsman begin inquiri complaint technic admiss complaint dealt petit committe petit european parliament ombudsman consid ground open inquiri evid present complaint provid ground inquiri februari mr offici european commiss complain ombudsman commiss start infring procedur franc complaint alleg french social secur author refus reimburs cost month convalesc father spent belgium complain refus contrari provis regul eec appear document transmit complain commiss decid suspend investig complaint mr wait judgment court justic case question prior authoris foreseen articl regul eec condit issu complaint mr resolv appear complaint commiss start examin complaint ask inform french author inform complain detail manner legal question rais complaint commiss decid suspend investig court judgment ombudsman decid ground inquir complaint mr inform case ov analysi complaint complaint regist begin activ ombudsman origin franc germani spain unit kingdom itali full analysi geograph origin complaint provid annex statist process examin complaint mandat meet criteria admiss provid ground open inquiri complet case complaint examin appear mandat ombudsman met criteria admiss provid ground inquiri inquiri begun case complaint led inquiri european commiss commiss main commun organ make decis direct impact citizen normal princip object citizen complaint complaint european parliament complaint council european union main type maladministr alleg lack transpar case discrimin case unsatisfactori procedur failur respect right defenc case unfair abus power case avoid delai case neglig case failur ensur fulfil oblig failur european commiss carri role quot guardian treati quot vi vi member state case legal error case advic contact agenc transfer complaint mandat inadmiss ombudsman give advic complain agenc deal complaint ombudsman transfer complaint directli compet agenc consent complain provid ground complaint advic case involv issu commun law case complain advis complaint nation region ombudsmen similar bodi addit consent complain complaint transfer directli nation ombudsman complain advis petit european parliament addition complaint transfer european parliament consent complain dealt petit case advic contact european commiss figur includ case complaint commiss declar inadmiss administr approach made commiss case complain advis contact agenc decis inquiri ombudsman ombudsman decid start inquiri complaint step send complaint annex commun institut bodi concern opinion opinion receiv complain observ explain section ombudsman account inform suppli parti parti opportun comment case institut bodi take step settl case satisfact complain opinion observ show case close quot settl institut quot case complain decid drop complaint file close reason complaint settl institut drop complain ombudsman continu inquiri inquiri reveal instanc maladministr complain institut bodi inform case close ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr seek friendli solut elimin satisfi complain meet held strasbourg octob ombudsman secretari gener commiss mr carlo trojan agre inform meet case provid pursu friendli solut case involv commiss meet place lead friendli solut friendli solut search friendli solut unsuccess ombudsman close file critic remark institut bodi concern make formal find maladministr draft recommend critic remark consid case instanc maladministr appear gener implic follow action ombudsman case follow action ombudsman case maladministr case gener implic ombudsman make decis draft recommend institut bodi concern accord articl statut ombudsman institut bodi send detail opinion month detail opinion consist accept ombudsman decis descript measur implement recommend commun institut bodi fail respond satisfactorili draft recommend articl ombudsman send report european parliament institut bodi concern report recommend possibl european ombudsman present special report parliament inestim work nation ombudsmen long struggl obtain compar possibl special report present frequent relat import matter parliament action assist ombudsman accord statut ombudsman ombudsman special report made decemb concern ombudsman initi inquiri public access document report discuss parliament plenari session juli basi report committe petit rapporteur astrid thor ombudsman began inquiri relat complaint initi case settl institut bodi explain section case classifi categori classifi previou year case ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr critic remark address institut case friendli solut reach case draft recommend institut bodi concern made detail appendix statist case involv failur repli correspond common type complaint concern failur repli correspond begin ombudsman activ clear telephon call ombudsman offic respons servic result repli citizen case point pursu inquiri practic ombudsman case intervent succeed obtain repli unansw correspond inform complain longer appear ground conduct inquiri complaint articl ec treati section statist purpos case includ categori quot ground inquiri quot annual report march practic review queri mr edward newman rapporteur committe petit report annual report case classifi quot ground inquiri quot conclud futur case classifi quot settl institut quot decis kind complaint unansw correspond exampl case settl institut march mr complain ombudsman commiss fail repli letter decemb ask inform introduct euro ombudsman contact respons servic commiss request repli complain send inform request intervent commiss repli complain march step appear adequ settl matter ombudsman close case case adb june ms complain behalf counti administr court uusimaa offic offici public european commun opoc fail repli letter court written opoc finnish june inquir receiv special edit offici journal european commun remind letter april english repli receiv letter ombudsman contact opoc telephon request repli counti administr court uusimaa intervent opoc contact court forward miss volum offici journal european commun finnish swedish step appear adequ settl matter ombudsman close case case bb natur complaint unansw correspond resolv satisfactorili telephon enquiri respons servic institut concern identifi correspond accept respons prepar rapid repli ombudsman write presid institut concern request opinion complaint ombudsman follow action reason suspect origin failur repli isol administr oversight substanc complaint alleg unjustifi delai repli correspond issu access document year ombudsman consid number question access document appear relev rule principl fulli understood commun institut bodi section report explain question aris dealt treati statut ombudsman complaint refus access document commun institut bodi rule public access document hold commiss council adopt joint code conduct access document code implement separ decis institut initi inquiri ombudsman commun institut bodi adopt rule public access similar council commiss request access document refus council commiss rule citizen make confirmatori applic citizen confirmatori applic reject possibl complain ombudsman bring proceed court instanc case complaint ombudsman issu refus access constitut maladministr question inquiri institut concern properli appli rule public access act limit legal author exercis discretionari power question aros happen ombudsman consid institut wrongli appli rule action institut concern reconsid matter time appli rule correctli ombudsman order institut annul relev decis explain view critic remark institut possibl action fair procedur ombudsman inquiri question aros concern document institut bodi concern send ombudsman part opinion complaint case institut concern forward document ombudsman inform relev ombudsman decis case ask ombudsman document confidenti vi vi complain case ombudsman explain institut concern basic principl fair procedur ombudsman decis complaint account inform contain document provid parti parti chanc respond ombudsman decis complaint account inform contain document suppli institut bodi concern complain chanc make observ document ombudsman power inspect file issu aros concern ombudsman power inspect file held commun institut bodi relev part articl statut ombudsman quot commun institut bodi oblig suppli ombudsman inform request give access file concern refus duli substanti ground secreci give access document origin member state class secret law regul member state prior agreement give access document origin member state inform member state concern quot normal principl member state nation ombudsman system ombudsman inspect document held administr consid part inquiri includ document citizen access power fundament import guarante citizen ombudsman make independ check accuraci complet answer administr long articl continu restrict ombudsman access document import restrict interpret narrowli burden proof institut bodi seek deni access question restrict european ombudsman access file european union commit democraci transpar effici honest administr consid institut european parliament council commiss involv procedur amend statut ombudsman natur ombudsman power inspect complement duti confidenti articl statut ombudsman make clear ombudsman staff inspect document held administr bound duti confidenti administr inspect document ombudsman result releas document complain mistak suggest rule public access document commun institut bodi adopt restrict ombudsman access document suggest appear base fundament misunderstand natur ombudsman power inspect verifi truth complet administr answer complaint result public access document concern decis inquiri case maladministr found european parliament recoveri medic expens decis complaint kp jma european parliament complaint novemb complain ombudsman refus european parliament reimburs cost cure delic children daughter european parliament reject request ground medic centr concern quot consid compet medic paramed institut quot request reject basi treatment question correspond requir cure delic children decemb complain appeal unsuccessfulli secretari gener parliament secretari gener respons complain recov specif medic expens incur cure complaint ombudsman claim european parliament proper procedur manag committe health insur scheme advic matter ii treatment consid daughter iii request reimburs specif medic expens reject ground stipul price date medic visit qualiti doctor complain ask ombudsman step compel european parliament pai expens cure includ travel cost inquiri parliament opinion complaint forward european parliament parliament opinion state normal procedur case type appeal court instanc substanc complaint opinion includ summari point reach decis appoint author due account opinion manag committe health insur scheme ii treatment select centr children year ag complain daughter start treatment iii request reimburs individu medic expens incur cure conform relev rule gener includ cost reimburs relev rule provid travel cost reimburs complain observ observ state decid appeal court instanc claim bill medic centr correctli fill state price treatment calcul packag basi medic cost separ identifi consid parliament refus reimburs show lack flexibl good comment procedur ombudsman deal complaint consid begin procedur forward complaint institut concern opinion decis power european ombudsman make inquiri case european parliament state normal procedur case type make applic court instanc constitut framework treati court justic highest author interpret applic commun law ombudsman make inquiri uncov instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi admiss complaint ombudsman preced administr approach institut concern similarli complaint concern work relationship commun institut bodi offici servant complaint made ombudsman possibl submiss intern administr request complaint procedur refer articl staff regul exhaust person concern intern procedur exhaust commun offici servant possibl appeal court instanc altern complain ombudsman ombudsman procedur observ complain consid ombudsman begin inquiri forward complaint institut concern opinion articl statut ombudsman requir ombudsman inform institut bodi concern inquiri suspect instanc maladministr submit comment medic consider type cure annex titl xi rule govern reimburs medic expens cure health resort recognis strictli medic offic respons settl claim present case respons medic offic review case conclud cure meet medic requir evid reach decis medic offic properli relev criteria reimburs expens parliament refus reimburs cost cure delic children agre cover specif medic expens parliament reject bill submit complain ground identifi cost separ refer gener sum medic centr daili charg applic rule provid reimburs medic expens parliament act properli requir separ identif medic expens condit reimburs annex titl xi rule govern reimburs medic expens provid reimburs travel cost conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european parliament ombudsman close case rule join european parliament pension scheme decis join complaint pd pd european parliament complaint januari mr mep complain ombudsman european parliament alleg maladministr relat addit pension scheme member parliament januari mr mep inform ombudsman associ mr complaint background complaint decis june bureau parliament set addit voluntari pension scheme member rule govern pension scheme constitut annex ix annex rule govern payment expens allow member autumn time limit month laid join pension scheme mr mr join scheme time claim inform introduct time limit elect european parliament mr allow join period previou period mr longer mep appli join period allow join previou period mr contact instanc parliament view allow join scheme retroact period argu inform time limit introduc parliament appli time limit unfair discriminatori juli chairman pension fund set scheme member colleg quaestor parliament repli letter drew mr attent cut date join scheme inform possibl backdat contribut consid conclud backdat practic legal letter ad quot correct error made colleg quaestor discuss april mr enclos extract minut meet matter concern french italian pension scheme administ european parliament behalf french italian govern refer annex iii rule member expens allow annex annex ix rule mep addit voluntari pension scheme addit request mr receiv pension join pension scheme quot abovement extract minut meet colleg quaestor read quot rule govern pension member french nation assembl appli analog french member european parliament applic receiv pension made write month date member member elig french member unawar provis made applic european parliament month elig discuss colleg authoris except current rule favour mr order enabl receiv pension notwithstand failur appli month time limit instruct administr submit draft amend aim clarifi time limit applic annex iii rule member expens allow quot complaint ombudsman complain alleg substanc time limit join pension scheme properli advertis ii unfair discriminatori complain join scheme retroact effect inquiri european parliament opinion complaint forward european parliament opinion parliament state examin complaint basi opinion legal servic adopt decis reject complain alleg enclos copi opinion legal servic substanc opinion legal servic conclud complain claim properli inform unfound mr written notic parliament home address addit minut decis bureau circul mep month join pension scheme elect mr legal servic evid prove awar time limit join scheme legal servic evid mr ask join scheme prior contest decis colleg quaestor modif regul bureau decis octob fix time limit month legal servic consid colleg bound respect gener rule set infring principl equal treatment membership refus mep appli decemb except except specif base agreement colleg quaestor made question aros limit membership pension scheme middl parliamentari term offic appli present case gener except rule final opinion legal servic put forward addit point basi conclus contest decis arbitrari quot ensur healthi financi manag restor financi balanc pension fund report cooper lybrand august defici moment account carri reliabl actuari calcul framework financi manag budgetari author make detail budgetari forecast discrimin member join scheme begin financi situat fact favour member make back payment quot complain observ observ complain maintain complaint decis alleg deadlin join pension scheme properli advertis appear regulatori rule govern question consid proper advertis mep european parliament rule procedur relev rule relat articl treati articl staff regul commun court rule notif measur occur measur commun addresse knowledg court rule burden proof due notif li administr case law transpos case case law concern individu act advers affect addresse exact definit moment notif utmost import calcul time limit judici proceed brought case concern commun gener inform offer addresse choos make case addresse appli applic refus refus time limit bring judici proceed appli commun institut administr practic appear frequent made gener commun make right servant appli basi conclud question proper commun inform mep question li parliament power intern organis exercis power parliament case law commun court act conform interest good administr question parliament act appear case parliament commun member time limit introduc pension scheme intern distribut system parliament supplementari ensur commun mep parliament ordinari mail mep home address individu member occas knowledg time limit introduc constitut instanc maladministr unfair discriminatori treatment question refus admit complain scheme retroact effect unfair discriminatori appear question cover issu issu unfair regul gener provid join retroact effect issu time limit join pension scheme complain case waiv context common ground complain parliament waiv time limit case entail join retroact effect clear question answer effect gener possibl join retroact effect question made redund concern question common ground complain parliament regul provis effect scheme join retroact question fair parliament introduc provis appear parliament reason sound financi manag scheme notic parliament power set scheme parliament entitl lai limit scheme reason ombudsman found fact parliament provid gener possibl join scheme retroact effect constitut instanc maladministr concern question time limit join scheme complain case waiv examin question fell part firstli examin refus waiv time limit unfair subsequ discriminatori fair firstli observ regul govern pension scheme provis allow waiv time limit ground equiti relev provis regul simpli member quot maximum period month elect elect quot join scheme absenc explicit provis allow waiv time limit question commun law exist gener principl effect time limit waiv ground equiti appear gener principl background take account reason sound financi manag parliament consid unfair time limit appli strictli complain alleg discrimin recal principl equal treatment requir ident situat treat ident situat treat ident put forward mep allow join scheme spite time limit appear parliament opinion member prior introduct time limit receiv assur join scheme situat ident case put forward parliament retir pension scheme scheme annex iii waiv time limit case case mention letter juli quot regard notic demand concern present month expir time limit concern present scheme financi situat demand concern entitl pension member concern contribut appear amend rule administr request submit propos quot minut meet colleg questor demand present time limit retroact effect situat appear case principl equal treatment violat question principl equal treatment violat question law recal court justic highest author question commun law basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european parliament ombudsman close case council european union inspect check reason refus access document decis complaint statewatch uk ijh council complaint complaint concern request document complain address council juli august applic made council decis public access council document quot decis ec quot juli request copi report consid meet quot quot committe held septemb octob novemb juli request document date august letter council request copi singl report produc request copi report consid jha council held luxembourg june produc bore earlier date septemb council gener secretariat repli complain repli state request quot regard repeat applic equal relat larg number document quot gener secretariat found fair solut articl decis eec document produc document request letter date august gener secretariat provid complain document deni access octob complain made confirmatori applic document refus access novemb presid council repli uphold origin decis appli quot fair solut quot document produc relat document council state carefulli balanc complain interest seek access interest council keep deliber confidenti interest outweigh gave detail quot document detail nation posit convent extern frontier recommend illeg employ countri nation convent extradit issu discuss adopt recent document detail nation posit budget europol drug unit europol comput system final document refer opinion council legal servic issu judici interpret europol convent comment made deleg matter quot complaint ombudsman complain claim council treatment request access document unfair possibl unlaw inquiri council opinion complaint forward council complaint made complain march council repli contest compet ombudsman deal complaint april ombudsman wrote council confirm origin decis complaint mandat renew request opinion substanc complaint june council compli ombudsman request applic quot fair solut quot council remark opinion complaint complain statewatch uk ijh appli case complain observ observ complain claim council entitl appli quot fair solut quot request document council entitl refus access document ground recent adopt includ view member state ombudsman inspect document ombudsman consid inspect document council refus access articl decis ec ombudsman inform complain inspect conform articl statut ombudsman involv releas complain document inform contain inspect carri justu lipsiu build council brussel octob provid access document council servic offer suppli copi ombudsman servic requir inspect document ombudsman servic consid unnecessari copi decis jurisdict point council object ombudsman compet appear base proposit compet ombudsman extend action council relat cooper field justic home affair quot pillar quot subject matter complaint concern action council pillar ombudsman decis deal complaint base view proposit mistaken unnecessari posit proposit subject matter complaint concern council respons request access document request made decis ec dealt council decis ec made articl ec treati judgement netherland council court justic confirm decis legal effect vi vi parti matter commun law decis interpret appli court instanc carvel guardian newspap council case involv access pillar document limit jurisdict court justic impos articl treati european union court instanc jurisdict deal aspect carvel case access pillar document pillar matter appear correct interpret applic decis ec public access document matter commun law pillar matter document question concern action pillar ombudsman inform council decis april nb judgment june court instanc reject similar ground council object jurisdict court tidningen journalisten case applic quot fair solut quot complain claim articl decis ec entitl council appli quot fair solut quot applic document council note opinion issu relat aspect complaint ident rais complaint complain statewatch uk ijh ombudsman decis juli case appli present case appli decis mean term quot repeat applic quot quot larg document quot clear council entitl appli quot fair solut quot articl decis ec request document case refus access articl council refus access document articl decis ec read quot access council document refus order protect confidenti council proceed quot establish case law applic provis requir council strike genuin balanc hand interest citizen obtain access document interest maintain confidenti deliber complain claim appli articl council entitl refus access document ground recent adopt includ view member state ombudsman awar legal rule principl requir council balanc interest articl exclud element consider ombudsman inspect document confirm content document question correspond reason council appear maladministr council relat aspect case conclus applic council quot fair solut quot ombudsman critic remark statewatch uk ijh decis juli appli complain request document present case refus access document articl decis ec basi ombudsman inquiri appear maladministr council ombudsman close case european commiss competit repli submiss ombudsman compet decis complaint hkc pd european commiss complaint februari hkc danish law firm complain ombudsman behalf lf danish trade union complaint concern commiss decis grant exempt competit rule allianc agreement airlin employe member lf complain view agreement lead job loss lf member lf commiss oblig effect unemploy account grant competit exempt complaint concern fact lf observ commiss invit lf submit applic exempt regul acknowledg repli inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss claim ombudsman compet stand question effect unemploy account competit exempt grant matter concern alleg failur appli law oppos maladministr commiss contend oblig repli observ invit parti lf submit observ intend assist commiss analysi complain observ observ complain maintain complaint consid ombudsman compet deal aspect decis ombudsman consid compet deal question commiss oblig effect unemploy account grant competit exempt remark issu made letter presid commiss content summaris section remark substant issu ombudsman found basi applic rule case law court justic appear oblig commiss consider account commiss failur acknowledg repli lf observ ombudsman observ applic regul contain oblig invit parti submit observ intend assist analysi commiss situat citizen expect reaction case lf interest decis virtu fact member possibl affect commiss failur give reaction lf instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark letter presid commiss accompani decis ombudsman made summari remark commiss give view admiss complaint whilst acknowledg ombudsman decid question case fundament misunderstand correct servic respons draft commiss repli ombudsman case appear assum quot wrong applic law quot quot maladministr quot fact opposit true good administr fail act accord law essenti task ombudsman conduct inquiri instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi establish institut concern act lawfulli carri task ombudsman mind fact highest author mean interpret commun law court justic case complaint expressli rais question interpret applic law commiss suppli opinion matter forward complain normal commiss respond ombudsman trust continu offic european ombudsman set order enhanc relat commun institut bodi european citizen imposs institut give opinion issu present complain case institut explain act correctli accord rule principl bind citizen satisfi explan understand institut action gener help commiss opinion explain posit legal element case order ensur view account ombudsman inquiri ombudsman conclud request presid commiss ensur respons commiss servic remark account prepar commiss repli ombudsman commission salari request inform decis complaint mca es jma european commiss complaint behalf quot asociación amigo de benalmádena quot mr lodg complaint ombudsman april failur european commiss repli request inform salari emolu member commiss complain state commiss fail repli previou letter madrid offic octob decemb letter request inform incom salari allow earn spanish member commiss time messr marín matut inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss apologis failur answer origin letter salari commission govern case council regul eec euratom juli amend number occas regard mission travel expens state total amount paid commission type expens ecu addit commission entitl reimburs represent expens sum ecu ecu final commiss state sum subject intern financi monitor institut extern control court auditor complain observ observ mr state request unansw view commiss refer regul unknown comment refer total amount ecu paid expens member commiss indic relat commission mention request ombudsman effort achiev friendli solut accord articl statut view seek friendli solut case ombudsman wrote commiss refer fact repli institut unsatisfactori complain suggest commiss answer review light european union commit transpar public access inform view principl propos satisfactori solut found commiss balanc interest stake provid clearer precis inform justifi clear conclus inform made repli commiss strike balanc transpar protect privaci order reach compromis disclos inform salari allow relat commiss specif member commiss state member monthli salari allow establish council decemb explain calcul represent expens reimburs invoic issu reimburs maximum ecu year commission respons foreign affair sum ecu offici travel complianc duti receiv reimburs travel expens daili subsist allow relat countri mission take place repli commiss forward complain invit solut propos commiss repli complain express satisfact effort undertaken european ombudsman find friendli settlement matter believ repli commiss answer question specif view control public expenditur paramount object preced privaci decis commun inform request inform complain commiss letter octob decemb rais question relat commun citizen inform import aspect administr work commiss order weigh legal implic request start european union undertak make work commun institut bodi transpar open public commit spelt final act treati european union includ declar access inform similarli reaffirm number european council birmingham edinburgh present rule foster greater public access inform access document relat commiss institut adopt june commun transpar commun basi guidelin set text februari adopt decis ecsc ec euratom public access commiss document absenc gener rule gener inform exist rule access document provid surrog decid citizen request inform institut conflict transpar privaci right commiss state comment specif inform salari emolu travel allow individu member commiss imping privaci right inform institut made public case refer entir commiss public releas inform conflict import valu privaci context commiss decis public access commiss document protect individu privaci consid mandatori except bar disclosur request document institut interpret provis court instanc state quot commiss oblig refus access document fall except contain categori relev circumst shown exist quot view circumst case european ombudsman commiss violat principl good administr disclos inform relat commiss failur answer correspond commiss acknowledg failur deal promptli request inform complain madrid offic institut offer explan long delai apologis repli ground european ombudsman pursu aspect case control public expenditur complain view failur commiss respond question salari emolu commission made evid lack control type expenditur commun account includ personnel function expenditur period audit court auditor establish articl treati institut quot examin revenu receiv expenditur incur law regular manner financi manag sound quot european ombudsman note indic report court auditor irregular place salari allow receiv period member commiss view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case danish taxat import hand car decis complaint dk pd european commiss complaint mr danish citizen lodg complaint european ombudsman juli commiss deal assess complaint lodg commiss alleg denmark fail fulfil oblig commun law complaint mr state year commiss calcul vat hand car import denmark member state hereinaft import hand car put forward answer receiv commiss untru annex complaint appear correspond relat danish registr fee import hand car ombudsman ask commiss address question give comment complaint complain grievanc vat appear consid danish vat rule import hand car discriminatori danish dealer state danish rule impli privat person resid denmark import hand car germani pai vat denmark vat paid germani profit margin dealer hand danish dealer import car pai danish vat full price car german residu vat reimburs consequ price danish dealer offer privat person car significantli higher price german dealer offer complain consid rule led discriminatori distort competit contrari direct ec vat hand good fundament principl vat paid dealer profit margin mr address commiss question satisfi commiss initi respons lawyer danish member european parliament pursu matter vi vi commiss answer lawyer march answer octob mep commiss maintain danish rule contrari commun direct field letter octob commission respons state quot mep point distort competit exist danish dealer hand car regim applic denmark germani stage harmonis nation law afraid legal term cope inconveni matter fact articl direct ec special arrang applic inter alia hand good expressli denmark derog margin scheme comment inform hesit contact servic dg xxi unit quot complain grievanc registr fee background summari judgment decemb case ecr court justic rule question danish registr fee import hand car amount discriminatori taxat prohibit articl ec treati danish tax system impli import hand car subject motor vehicl registr fee car hand car origin denmark subject registr fee order justifi denmark argu car industri hand car origin denmark moment import car car submit registr fee price includ vat price dkk rest price consider part price hand car origin denmark consist residu registr fee registr fee import hand car fix level account residu registr fee hand car origin denmark court justic accept consider principl found gener danish system led manifestli excess taxat import hand car system contrari articl ec treati court rule danish author establish system principl aim ensur import hand car submit registr fee extent total car equal ident hand car origin denmark system administ import hand car import privat profession obtain provision indic registr fee import author fix final registr fee paid possibl inspect import hand car mr consid system oper continu contrari articl treati final registr fee fix import car high car sold fee fix object consider delai involv procedur context import hand car background mr lodg complaint commiss letter novemb commiss repli complaint term quot refer complaint lodg commiss octob telex februari commiss stanc state danish system vat registr duti make difficult import car member state denmark purpos sell duti import car high compet car origin regist denmark alleg practic conflict articl treati registr duti car import denmark danish rule car amend judgment european court justic decemb case court found duti import car discriminatori conflict articl treati acquaint danish rule registr car point found regul pursuant law august registr duti motor vehicl state basi calcul fee assess assessor appoint minist inland revenu assessor includ technic expert trade expert appoint recommend main organis car owner complaint dutiabl set custom excis author lodg assessor abovement regul detail descript procedur duti import car base real basi inform provid commiss view duti gener higher correspond residu duti involv car type ag regist denmark basi assess vehicl normal price similar vehicl vehicl similar make model normal state repair time registr deduct made extra charg ad mileag state repair improv characterist final price differ trade list depend individu assess estim dutiabl car lead deviat list price offici appli car origin regist denmark prove ident respect find dutiabl final establish high compar residu dutiabl similar vehicl regist time denmark urg contact depart detail assess quot mr satisfi answer commiss lodg complaint ombudsman alleg commiss answer untru contrari commun law inquiri commiss opinion comment commiss put forward dealt appropri mr case maintain analysi case set letter quot state studi mr alleg danish rule complianc articl direct ec contrari articl commiss state argument direct incompat ec treati rais problem analys detail letter june commiss inform ombudsman result analysi state quot find case special tax arrang refer articl sixth vat direct appli notabl denmark pursuant option grant paragraph articl derog normal system tax resal hand good introduc direct ec differ tax charg stem differ exist rate vat forc denmark forc member state state pursuant deduct mechan laid impos articl indent differ tax charg hand vehicl resold denmark vari basi vehicl member state origin direct consequ differ rate vat appli member state note pass differ vat rate result deliber choic commun legisl broadli harmonis system taxat vat system confin lai articl sixth direct minimum rate implicitli leav member state free set vat rate higher floor rate situat consist differ treatment product trader member state differ attribut differ nation law complet harmonis recent dealt court perfili judgment februari state paragraph judgment court consist held prohibit member state appli law differ ground nation field applic treati articl concern dispar treatment result member state differ exist law member state long affect person subject accord object criteria regard nation effect judgment case kenni insur offic ecr paragraph join case wood cowi ecr paragraph join case van dam en zonen ecr paragraph gener interpret principl express court abovement perfili judgment earlier judgment appli adapt circumst case problem question discrimin rule articl broadli similar spirit articl treati explicitli mention court rate vat directli set commun legisl uniform percentag price good suppli commun disadvantag danish dealer automat disappear note present time problem heavier tax charg respect hand vehicl resold denmark purchas member state aris respect vehicl come member state appli rate vat lower danish rate differ taxat affect hand vehicl purchas member state appli rate vat denmark sweden vehicl come member state argument sake set rate vat receiv advantag tax treatment hand vehicl purchas denmark light forego consider opinion differ tax charg denmark stem rate vat dealer deduct input tax output tax liabl pursuant articl sixth direct result word court differ exist law member state input vat deduct accord object criterion rate applic member state place suppli taxabl dealer determin accord articl deem situat criterion regard origin product appli distinct dealer subject danish vat legisl vehicl resold denmark circumst conclud denmark infring articl treati quot complain observ observ mr maintain commiss dealt case grievanc relat registr fee put forward case danish author establish final fee vari consider provision fee staff charg evalu import hand car compet state import hand car requir produc registr paper car order provision fee requir impli practic bui car know amount final fee reason car dealer hand registr paper sold car question state danish rule entail problem leas import hand car import hand taxi put equal foot hand taxi origin denmark state evidenc person resid denmark work german compani germani fulli compani car denmark compani put dispos decis grievanc recal european ombudsman inquir activ nation author ombudsman inquir mr origin alleg commiss dealt properli assess case brought forward grievanc registr fee appear commiss dealt assess outstand question commiss assess system danish author set abovement rule court justic aim ensur registr fee set total import hand car includ registr fee exce hand car origin denmark includ residu registr fee paid car commiss found system compli court rule mr proof contrari commiss invit submit proof element hand assess wrong recal court justic highest author question commun law complain grievanc vat appear commiss dealt assess crucial question equal commiss assess appear establish uncontest mr commiss rule question lead competit disadvantag situat danish dealer german dealer appear agreement mr commiss danish rule allow direct ec question regim allow direct ec contrari treati commiss found disadvantag stem differ rate vat allow commun law stand appear disadvantag fact disappear vat rate applic germani denmark commiss assess appear recal court justic highest author question commun law basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman decid close case tender procedur suppli technic servic commiss decis complaint ka nl en ijh european commiss complaint august dr complain ombudsman call tender organis commiss consult compani submit tender suppli technic assist director public health health safeti work dg commiss inform cancel call tender translat error tender document intend proce limit acceler procedur particip unsuccessfulli procedur claim commiss violat procedur requir servic direct fail suppli document tender rapid mean requir articl direct ii respond fax request clarif dai close date tender requir articl direct iii respond request negoti foreseen articl direct claim iv real reason cancel tender translat error illegitim purpos specif requir qualiti personnel procedur render inop procedur consequ give advantag firm lower qualiti personnel current contractor inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss alleg procedur error commiss opinion includ summari point commiss tender document compani select tender time regist post ii close date receipt tender june commiss repli fax queri complain telephon june half work dai receipt fax commiss acknowledg repli write iii articl servic direct relev contract award negoti procedur case acceler restrict procedur commiss respons point iv complaint summari bid call tender open discov differ tender interpret specif human resourc result translat error french version specif refer quot man month quot german english version refer quot hour month quot bid compar commiss cancel procedur view urgenc commiss organis call tender restrict acceler procedur adapt invit tender procedur correct translat error technic specif invit tender ident unlik open procedur restrict procedur compris distinct stage select particip firm award contract requir qualiti personnel appli select stage procedur properli award report show accus previou contractor prefer unfound lot award compani put lowest bid complain observ observ complain made detail critic commiss opinion gave detail claim observ includ summari addit point negoti procedur direct irregular bid made origin procedur includ differ interpret amount translat work tender ii complain question commiss criteria qualiti personnel contain tender document compar bid receiv commiss demonstr success tender met criteria inquiri view fact complain observ made claim forward commiss request opinion commiss repli commiss repli includ summari point complain reason request negoti procedur irregular error textual interpret translat cost commiss carefulli compar tender relat item order discrimin tender spite differ tender receiv ii select stage restrict acceler procedur commiss check qualiti qualif personnel propos basi detail provid tender tender satisfi select criteria specif enabl submit tender complain complementari observ observ complain made detail critic commiss repli insist commiss violat rule public procur practis maladministr claim commiss prove criteria qualiti personnel appli provid detail inform document success tender bid qualiti personnel decis alleg procedur violat servic direct articl financi regul requir commun institut compli oblig servic direct conclud servic contract amount involv equal greater threshold commiss contest complain assert direct appli tender question complain claim commiss breach articl direct fail suppli tender document rapid mean evid suppli commiss complain contradict document compani select tender time regist post obviou articl direct cite complain intend impos oblig contract author tender complain claim commiss breach articl direct fail suppli addit inform period prescrib commiss acknowledg repli write complain request addit inform common ground commun telephon articl appli addit inform request tender quot good time quot basi factual circumst case appear ombudsman inquiri question breach requir articl occur complain claim commiss negoti procedur choic procedur matter contract author subject requir servic direct claim consid section decis argument present ombudsman requir direct breach acceler restrict procedur negoti procedur ombudsman inquiri reveal maladministr relat aspect case alleg illegitim purpos commiss deni alleg translat error real reason cancel tender procedur comparison languag version offici journal european commun confirm differ identifi commiss exist commiss deni previou contractor prefer assert lot involv tender award compani put lowest bid commiss insist criteria qualiti personnel appli select stage acceler restrict procedur account event coher consist documentari evid commiss suppli complain opportun make observ complain disput accuraci commiss account provid evid substanti alleg ombudsman inquiri reveal maladministr relat aspect case claim inform document complain claim commiss suppli inform document prove appli qualiti criteria articl servic direct make specif provis suppli inform reason unsuccess tender public access commiss document govern commiss decis ecsc ec euratom complain made alleg violat relev provis direct decis view find section decis ombudsman commiss suppli inform document part inquiri case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case alleg infring competit rule decis complaint fdr pd european commiss complaint juli mr petit european parliament commiss handl complaint alleg infring commun competit rule car manufactur car import august mr made complaint ombudsman matter septemb european parliament view mr petit concern alleg instanc maladministr activ commiss transfer ombudsman dealt complaint complain car produc german manufactur expens germani member state denmark netherland finland fact consum live germani address car dealer member state order bui car run problem refus sell consum resid germani excess deliveri time artifici increas price number occas mr live germani address individu car dealer member state view bui car appear met problem kind mention refus reluct sell car consum ground live member state contrari commun competit rule mr address commiss subsequ consider correspond commiss appear commiss principl contest complain percept law report instanc contrari competit rule includ commiss regul ec mr consid commiss step enforc competit rule express discont letter commiss address june letter commiss refer exchang correspond mr commiss sought explain polici matter relev paragraph read quot commiss respons administr author act public interest requir ensur complianc ec competit polici infring occur requisit organis measur determin prioriti make choic commiss preced case signific polit econom legal point view principl appli receipt handl complaint connect point european competit rule enabl commiss privat person enforc subject right basic function nation court unlik commiss determin entitl damag commiss awar individu case difficulti purchas car finland denmark reason explain write relev depart fairli comprehens exchang correspond date aris case show commiss action sphere respons view understand desir million driver european union bui car cheapli view difficulti occur commiss action individu case involv person interest quot complain consid commiss refer case person interest inappropri pursu matter interest gener public background mr put forward grievanc complaint commiss inact pend procedur ii commiss toler illeg practic continu systemat violat regul ec iii commiss fail monitor applic rule iv commiss proven violat law commiss wrongli assess procedur initi car manufactur allegedli violat relev competit rule vi commiss citizen complain complaint effect commiss passiv matter complain action commiss inappropri inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss explain issu concern alleg obstacl parallel export motor vehicl member state impli commiss regul ec dealer reject consum offer bui higher price simpli consum resid member state present complaint commiss submit account correspond mr mr address letter commiss complain conduct main german car manufactur complain conduct import manufactur member state commiss investig mr complaint allegedli unlaw practic time commiss repeatedli explain mr attitud issu consider letter commission competit mr inform case infring commiss hesit organis measur accord prioriti commission inform mr commiss duti privat person enforc subject right call quot partikularinteress quot task nation jurisdict commiss comment state approach chosen commiss correspond principl confirm court instanc commiss explain judgment question confirm commiss duti act public interest impli thing commiss account administr resourc prioritis complaint infring commun law commission emphasis commiss assess evid basi infring competit stipul final commiss observ issu gener natur complaint car distribut european union submit commiss devot consider time resourc follow investig complaint complaint mr light circumst commiss consid mr alleg unfound complain observ observ complain emphasis complain repres person interest commiss repli correspond acknowledg receipt letter infring take place commiss european parliament easili establish investig commiss investig infring displai complet inact free movement good fact protect union final action commiss opinion oblig complain recal alleg commiss inact toler alleg infring competit rule wai institut opinion evad respons extent mean fraud uphold competit rule mr commiss support infring complet bias favour car industri attach materi newspap articl price list compani complain opinion show infring take place mr ask ombudsman investig directli car manufactur car import complain ombudsman regul ec subsequ develop lodg complaint ombudsman mr continu address commiss directli decemb commiss address letter mr articl regul eec inform intend open formal investig regard file complaint matter complain suffici commun interest merit investig mr invit submit observ preliminari conclus commiss time limit week wish letter divid titl call quot submiss quot quot commiss opinion quot read quot pursuant articl regul natur legal person claim legitim interest submit complaint assumpt legitim interest point set born mind open formal investig commiss entail disproportion expenditur relat limit signific case commun author respons implement commun competit polici commiss serv gener interest limit administr resourc dispos carri function deploi case brought notic letter commiss complain alleg gener refus dealer authoris car manufactur commun member state refer sell car purpos export fact prepar allegedli excess price letter claim subject right violat free bring action claim violat right nation court member state nation court appli european competit rule unlik commiss award damag addit sale motor vehicl subject group exempt regul commiss regul eec decemb forc juli june replac juli commiss regul ec june purpos advantag group exempt regul part enabl nation court appli european competit law articl regul ec instanc benefit exempt automat laps freedom final consum authoris intermediari dealer bui motor vehicl undertak belong network choic common market indirectli directli restrict insuffici commun interest warrant commiss open investig quot repli letter mr submit observ commiss effect wrong complaint repres insuffici commun interest submit observ effect ombudsman observ mr repeatedli state letter commiss reject complaint appear letter concern file commiss open pursuant complaint mr observ commiss reach final conclus close file appear commiss investig file open pursuant mr complaint fact recal commiss publish yearli report competit polici report commiss state paragraph car sector receiv numer complaint consum experi major problem bui car member state accord normal practic european parliament adopt resolut commiss report quot deplor lack genuin intern market relat distribut servic motor vehicl numer complaint consum prove call commiss ensur free market consum problem bui car member state obstacl parallel trade exist quot note januari commiss adopt decis establish infring competit rule commit volkswagen impos fine ecu million compani press releas commiss issu adopt decis state quot comment decis mr van miert commiss hesit measur motor manufactur compli regul ec govern motor trade size fine indic commiss toler practic kind act similar determin manufactur set partit market quot decis ombudsman compet observ mr ask ombudsman investig directli car manufactur car import concern scrutinis merit regul ec articl statut ombudsman quot framework treati ombudsman uncov maladministr activ commun institut bodi action author person subject complaint ombudsman quot ombudsman inquir infring allegedli commit car manufactur import commiss investig infring articl statut quot citizen union refer complaint ombudsman respect instanc maladministr quot state european ombudsman report mean task ombudsman examin merit legisl act commun regul direct ombudsman deal mr alleg merit regul ec commiss alleg passiv adopt action firstli recal legal framework mr complaint assess substant law articl treati prohibit anti competit agreement behaviour affect trade member state articl circumst articl declar inapplic council regul eec commiss empow make declar inapplic mean gener regul call exempt regul effect gener regul agreement meet condit laid regul prohibit articl treati contrari agreement meet condit violat principl caught prohibit articl concern motor vehicl sector commiss regul eec adopt regul ec applic articl treati categori motor vehicl distribut servic agreement articl regul ec entail appli manufactur supplier undertak directli indirectli seek restrict freedom final consum obtain motor vehicl whichev authoris dealer choos commun behaviour principl prohibit articl treati procedur law laid make substant law oper recal articl appli commiss nation author includ nation jurisdict contrari articl appli commiss relat commiss nation author object commiss notic cooper nation competit author commiss handl case fall scope articl ec treati publish offici journal european commun oj cooper nation court likewis object commiss notic publish oj commiss procedur main provis found council regul articl regul commiss adopt detail regul regul eec articl regul quot commiss applic initi find infring articl articl treati decis requir undertak associ undertak concern bring infring end entitl make applic member state natur legal person claim legitim interest quot articl regul eec relat provis articl quot commiss receiv applic pursuant articl regul consid basi inform possess insuffici ground grant applic inform applic reason fix time limit submit comment write quot clear person legitim interest lodg complaint commiss suppos infring articl treati bear mind court justic held complain entitl request commiss reach final decis infring procedur complaint roughli sum initi investig commiss find complaint justifi undertak concern dispos resolv matter commiss start formal infring procedur involv strict observ right defenc undertak concern initi investig commiss consid complaint unjustifi complain inform articl regul eec call articl letter submit observ challeng letter commun court commiss observ persist view take definit stand complain challeng note case complain consid commiss fail act complaint case law articl letter bring failur end briefli system complement case law commun court commiss abstain pursu complaint ground lack suffici commun interest reason court commiss respons competit matter form part gener oblig guardian treati monitor applic commun law discharg oblig commiss oblig entitl give degre prioriti matter field competit criterion quot commun interest quot relev law criterion appear gener understand case commiss reject complaint lack commun interest right defenc undertak complain bar commiss take stand infring summari commiss act complaint lodg person legitim interest find complaint dismiss ground lack suffici quot commun interest quot inform complain call articl letter letter put end failur act complaint complain submit observ articl letter maintain complaint commiss persist view complaint lack quot commun interest quot adopt final stand effect assess quot commun interest quot commiss act limit legal author commiss final stand challeng complain mr complaint assess common ground year mr brought suspect infring commiss attent appear commiss consid mr qualifi person legitim interest lodg complaint mean articl regul appear alleg infring resolv pursuant commiss intervent investig investig commiss address abovement letter mr refer case person interest letter appear line commiss gener polici abovement quot annual report competit polici turn rest case law commun court claim constitut maladministr warrant investig initi mr complaint time element hand indic commiss investig complaint due care accord principl good administr file open commiss pursuant mr complaint investig initi led commiss provision conclus complaint repres suffici commun interest inform correspondingli call articl letter decemb state case law court letter put end failur act complaint remain final conclus commiss reach due studi complain extens observ circumst ombudsman enter assess merit letter letter led ombudsman formul remark attent commiss thing stood ombudsman found justifi claim commiss passiv inappropri action mr want commiss deploi resourc matter high concern appear ground claim commiss inact inappropri action basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case remark european ombudsman creat enhanc relat european institut european citizen task impli ombudsman secur posit citizen promot good administr practic encourag administr author seek solut improv relat citizen background european ombudsman make suggest prejudic bind natur call articl letter commiss initi seek give comprehens adequ reason intent close file complaint letter enabl citizen fulli comprehend posit commiss lodg adequ observ accord principl good administr matter gener interest commiss account fact european citizen limit time resourc bring court proceed defenc right proceed brought member state citizen live select candid traineeship decis complaint aisr es jma european commiss complaint august ms made complaint ombudsman alleg failur commiss repli letter select applic ms appli march train period commiss spite high academ profession qualif relat work european union ms applic exclud stage select procedur wrote commiss juli reason exclus stage inform gener criteria select procedur ms receiv repli letter lodg formal complaint ombudsman inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss firstli apologis failur repli ms letter state letter juli receiv train offic commiss applic spanish candid receiv commiss train period begin octob stage procedur includ pre select list quot blue book quot commiss state applic examin basi object criteria laid applic rule commiss agre ms qualif extrem good equival candid select candid obtain traineeship high number applic unavoid good candid chosen commiss state order minimis exclus valuabl candid traineeship recent introduc rigor systemat procedur check applic complain observ observ ms point system adopt commiss select procedur candid unclear complain unsatisfi commiss repli opinion gener inquiri import aspect complaint suffici dealt commiss opinion ombudsman request detail select procedur order review correct select procedur traine ms particip ombudsman request element applic select spanish candid repli commiss explain select procedur involv creation pre select group commiss offici nation group mixtur commiss staff experi personnel recruit matter recent recruit civil servant task screen applic basi criteria laid applic rule prefer candid ombudsman forward document submit commiss relat select process complain invit comment initi institut repli letter commiss repli includ number confidenti document inspect ombudsman applic candid chosen octob train period document commiss basi final select decis basi articl rule govern servic train commiss european commun decis commiss march applic select basi qualif obtain studi provid geograph balanc maintain prioriti select process applic undertaken studi profession knowledg european integr natur select procedur appoint author enjoi margin discret discret commiss merit candid set rule order ensur exercis commiss discret process principl good administr ombudsman inspect applic success spanish candid octob train period view high profession experi good qualif select candid ombudsman consid instanc maladministr gener criteria emploi commiss servic vet candid ombudsman note institut implement procedur ensur effici object select basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case fraud involv european social fund alleg failur act uclaf decis complaint open line gr bb ov european commiss complaint octob mr complain ombudsman commiss anti fraud unit uclaf alleg lack refus inform relat alleg fraud administr european social fund esf programm greec mr complain behalf greek initi group seat athen septemb june complain wrote letter uclaf director alleg irregular manag esf resourc greec ask action commun author repli letter receiv standard repli uclaf director thank interest state gener term investig carri mr wrote letter uclaf provid addit detail inform letter receiv repli mr letter uclaf repeat inform letter ad inform alleg irregular repli letter complain receiv standard letter uclaf director date august state investig case measur complaint ombudsman mr ask ombudsman put end alleg mismanag esf activ greec complain letter receiv adequ respons inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss observ acknowledg receipt complain inform receiv complain immedi examin uclaf director commiss state novemb servic ask greek author inform esf project irregular alleg greek author provid inform march basi inform commiss carri spot investig octob account addit inform forward complain visit organis name complain organis order evalu role bodi manag follow esf project check alleg made complain investig reveal elig expenditur project check nation author agre result investig promis proce correct extend control programm beneficiari concern commiss observ servic carri seri control greec year result reject total certif greek centr profession train kek demand reform greek certif system basi inform commiss conclud inact inform receiv complain mission task uclaf director permit disclosur detail activ complain observ observ complain state commiss account alleg conclus incomplet complain observ audit carri uclaf director fail examin case made alleg enclos memorandum alleg decis request ombudsman put end alleg mismanag esf fund respons counter fraud affect financi interest commun fall primarili member state articl ec treati measur counter fraud affect financi interest commun counter fraud affect financi interest respons member state share commiss framework gener task ensur commun budget properli implement oper financ structur fund respons member state commiss regard financi control set articl council regul eec final financi control oper financ structur fund fall court auditor articl ec treati examin revenu receiv expenditur commun incur law regular manner financi manag sound context articl ec treati empow court auditor carri audit spot member state articl court auditor time submit observ form special report specif question ec treati empow european ombudsman inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi ombudsman mandat inquir instanc maladministr nation author greek public privat bodi involv present case reason request complain put end alleg mismanag esf fund greec ombudsman power inquir instanc maladministr nation level alleg failur adequ respons uclaf director complain letter uclaf septemb june letter acknowledg letter thank complain interest state gener term investig measur complain consid letter receiv adequ respons commiss observ acknowledg receipt letter date septemb acknowledg receipt letter receipt alleg uclaf director immedi start investig inform receiv complain commiss conclud mission task uclaf director permit disclosur inform action undertaken ombudsman note inform commiss obtain context investig fraud regard oper financ structur fund cover profession confidenti refer made articl uclaf regul deal exchang inform member state commiss provis forese member state commiss precaut ensur inform exchang remain confidenti articl stipul inform person member state commun institut duti requir access appear provis uclaf director entitl disclos result investig complain requir mission task appear ombudsman provid inform parti ongo commiss investig alleg fraud member state result thereof jeopardis ongo investig uclaf director reason fact uclaf director respons complain inform gener term ongo investig gave detail inquiri alleg mismanag fund constitut instanc maladministr alleg failur uclaf act complain alleg appear inform present commiss opinion receipt alleg mismanag esf fund contain complain letter uclaf immedi start examin alleg appear uclaf investig matter carri spot investig seri control observ commiss opinion complain claim audit carri uclaf director incomplet fail examin alleg ombudsman servic contact uclaf director inform complain alleg mismanag investig dealt uclaf context ombudsman uclaf director copi memorandum complain attach observ basi inform appear evid instanc maladministr uclaf dealt complain alleg ombudsman wish draw attent complain fact final financi control oper financ structur fund fall compet court auditor articl ec treati court auditor examin revenu receiv expenditur commun incur law regular manner financi manag sound basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case tender procedur decis complaint hydroplan vk european commiss complaint novemb mr made complaint european ombudsman call tender servic contract commiss mr appli particip call servic contract includ studi consult work technic assist carri member countri march mr receiv invit particip restrict tender offer commiss receiv acknowledg mr state elabor offer involv consider cost extens cooper compani member state letter februari mr inform select procedur unfruit standard letter give reason august mr ask dg commiss reason closur procedur repli octob commiss state procedur close bid compli tender requir mr complain ombudsman reason eventu insuffici ii expens reimburs commiss inquiri commiss opinion relat relev point commiss state complain inform februari select board examin offer receiv decid close procedur unsuccess annex ii articl descript servic provis tender public procedur commiss oblig offer contract end tender procedur commiss oblig reimburs unsuccess particip procedur decid offer contract annex iii complain observ summari complain made main point commiss oblig award contract view care public spend sudden interrupt procedur logic bidder enterpris expert involv interrupt assess bid appear avoid econom damag action select board understand commiss decid offer contract direct negoti procedur decis good administr behaviour inform tender procedur time limit februari tender inform select procedur unfruit close mr contact relev commiss servic telephon order receiv inform matter state commiss fail provid repli letter august mr request fulli inform reason closur commiss repli octob procedur close declar fruitless bid compli tender requir letter emphasis written notif bidder appear commiss appropri repli mr written request inform ombudsman commiss compli principl good administr behaviour notifi tender explain reason request write inform ombudsman appear commiss oblig offer contract reimburs unsuccess particip basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman decid close case financi support spanish custom agent entri forc intern market decis complaint fpr es jma european commiss complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman implement commiss council regul eec measur adapt profess custom agent intern market mr firm custom agent suffer larg loss result entri forc intern market januari consequ remov border control submit applic spanish author respons vet select project fund framework regul eec proceed mr correspond member spanish parliament cabinet spanish commission mr matut letter member mr matut cabinet spanish parliamentarian date februari mr project obtain grant ecu complain view inform forward commiss gener unclear insuffici alleg applic regul eec commiss defici constitut instanc maladministr inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion made point whilst recognis neg consequ complet intern market custom commiss agent lost job commiss consid restructur sector respons member state accord principl subsidiar import problem commiss decid support effort member state accompani measur financ european social fund action region develop fund interreg initi contain regul eec budget ecu million ecu alloc spain ii propos assist spanish enterpris servic affect entri forc intern market submit spanish agenc respons implement regul eec intern revenu servic quot agencia tributaria quot iii technic evalu spanish propos committe agencia tributaria project accept evalu carri full independ evalu base object criteria laid regul relev budgetari provis iv fax decemb agencia tributaria request inform complain project inform receiv project select definit vagu imprecis cost amount spanish alloc fund regul eec correspond cabinet commission matut misunderstand letter februari firm ident name quot quot locat spain franc obtain commun fund misunderstand creat fact presid director gener french compani quot quot busi partner complain commiss written mr apologis confus vi commiss deni defici applic regul eec monitor financi servic court auditor complain observ summari mr made observ regul eec publish decemb commiss commun time dai deadlin march present propos ii failur repli request inform decemb complain understand aim request decis februari project exclud iii sum request submit applic inform total amount european commun fund grant spain programm iv commiss disclos custom agent project select decis allegedli defici measur adopt commiss allegedli defici respons commun situat custom commiss agent entri forc intern market subject matter complaint address european ombudsman articl treati requir number action commiss council ensur balanc progress sector affect entri forc intern market commiss consid assist sector primarili respons member state undertook initi contain vade mecum restructur custom sector specif measur assist contain regul eec task ombudsman examin merit legisl act legisl propos commun type judgment boundari maladministr concern consider polit natur context recal european parliament adopt critic resolut matter septemb novemb jackson report novemb project select complain criticis select project made jointli commiss spanish agencia tributaria exclus project final select view time period submiss propos unduli short request inform late stage select procedur inappropri complain receiv inform possibl commun assist march content programm time schedul set regul eec publish offici journal european commun decemb reason amount time present project appear ground justifi claim unduli short deadlin commiss justifi exclus complain project ground vagu excess financi request complain respond request inform believ decis februari assess relev factor account purpos decid award contract invit parti commun institut enjoi larg degre discret discret justifi misus power manifest error select procedur inform ombudsman appear evid suggest commiss act limit legal author adopt decis applic assist fund regul eec evid maladministr relat aspect case allegedli mislead inform commiss servic appear cabinet commission matut letter complain project receiv commun grant commun mislead complain commiss explain misunderstand firm commiss complain letter apologis commiss recognis mistak apologis potenti misunderstand appear evid maladministr relat aspect case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case german state aid renew energi decis join complaint hk vk js vk fs vk ks vk fp vk sb vk gs vk kp vk hs vk ad vk ms vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk vk european commiss complaint decemb januari ombudsman receiv total complaint german citizen letter commission karel van miert address german minist econom affair mr rexrodt german law favour product renew energi stromeinspeisegesetz order deal complaint effect promptli ombudsman decid treat jointli stromeinspeisegesetz subject petit european parliament ombudsman deal matter pend committe petit european parliament consent petition committe transfer ombudsman dealt complaint case ombudsman receiv complaint citizen address petit parliament stromeinspeisegesetz enter forc januari impos electr suppli compani oblig purchas electr gener renew energi sourc pai guarante minimum price depend natur renew sourc articl law prescrib minimum price electr gener wind power averag revenu kwh electr suppli compani gener sale electr penultim calendar year german author notifi stromeinspeisegesetz commiss state aid accord articl ec teati commiss decid law compat common market articl octob commission van miert wrote minist rexrodt propos reduct minimum price wind power energi kwh kwh take complaint ombudsman substanc alleg commission van miert entitl send letter question stromeinspeisegesetz approv commiss bind decis articl ec treati complain consid content letter amount alter commiss decis made commiss decis ii commission van miert wrongli assess legal econom situat wind energi produc germani commission appar base posit data figur provid german electr supplier verifi figur correct complain effect commission propos disastr wind energi produc reduct remuner level jeopardis wind energi plant current employ situat research field suffer neg impact environment technic develop competit fact distort monopolist structur aris inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion made point juli commiss start receiv complaint german electr supplier support wind energi complain claim guarante price wind energi longer justifi face consider loss guarante price wind energi remain plan german länder extend wind power capac mw year pursu commiss consid reassess situat receiv complaint ii novemb commiss ask german govern comment matter hear german parliament discuss amend law commiss receiv comment particip repres govern german länder energi suppli compani associ favour renew energi addit meet concern parti includ repres wind energi produc place iii appear real legal condit chang time approv stromeinspeisegesetz commiss octob support mechan wind energi stromeinspeisegesetz led consider increas wind energi product coastal region germani enact stromeinspeisegesetz amount plant capac consider increas rais cost energi supplier factor commiss reassess technolog wind power plant improv plant effici product wind power costli iv background commission van miert letter minist rexrodt examin support mechan favour wind energi stromeinspeisegesetz amend hand exist wind energi produc receiv support hand trade distort thing propos reduct remuner wind power kwh kwh simpl quick chang present situat letter question legal consequ german govern bind recommend modifi law consid legal action solut german govern solv problem competit intern letter fulli measur commiss pursuant articl ec treati vi data number wind power station capac product dg iv base inform provid commiss german govern commiss receiv inform hear held german bundestag repres side wind energi produc main energi supplier addit extra meet parti concern held commiss opinion parti account complain observ take observ ombudsman complaint maintain complain express dissatisfact commiss observ decis complain claim complain claim substanc commiss infring treati wrong procedur complain letter german govern amount alter commiss decis made articl ec treati stromeinspeisegesetz compat common market claim alter validli made commiss decis provis ec treati state aid requir member state propos grant aid give prior notif commiss make decis consid aid compat common market stromeinspeisegesetz receiv approv procedur exist system aid articl ec treati procedur commiss seek modif exist scheme aid procedur propos measur member state concern articl propos bind forc procedur address bind decis member state concern requir abolish alter aid procedur articl legal basi articl procedur case commiss previous approv aid articl letter question purport bind member state purport alter commiss decis stromeinspeisegesetz letter element exceed compet commiss articl ombudsman inquiri complain claim reveal maladministr complain claim complain claim substanc commiss wrongli assess legal econom situat wind energi produc reli unverifi data suppli german electr industri articl lai specif requir commiss cooper member state review exist system aid matter good administr practic commiss base technic econom assess accur inform ensur opportun critic apprais relev data opinion heard opinion commiss provid account activ contradict complain commiss inform german govern complaint receiv system aid wind energi ask comment hear german parliament discuss amend law commiss receiv comment particip repres govern german länder energi suppli compani associ favour renew energi addit meet concern parti includ repres wind energi produc place basi appear commiss reason step ensur technic econom assess base accur inform opportun critic apprais relev data opinion heard ombudsman inquiri complain claim reveal maladministr basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case deadlin present propos call tender decis complaint cfui jma european commiss complaint decemb associ cfui complain ombudsman short deadlin submiss propos call tender commiss publish notic octob invit present propos fund european social fund esf innovatori action creation job submiss applic postmark novemb usual delai post cfui receiv offici journal european commun novemb immedi request applic form commiss servic dg document arriv novemb cfui ask commiss send form fax novemb cfui unabl submit applic commiss due time complaint cfui claim time limit short appear potenti tender receiv applic form time inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss explain step involv select procedur call tender timet exchang complain launch initi process requir agreement esf committe step meet committe end septemb commiss conclud intern consult propos offici journal european commun result call tender publish octob set deadlin submiss propos commiss state budgetari reason imper process conclud end evalu propos week commiss servic fix novemb deadlin commiss request applic form receiv complain fax date novemb commiss point servic repli expediti fax ombudsman forward commiss opinion complain invit make observ repli receiv decis accord articl regul implement financi regul deadlin submiss tender quot fix natur contract depend length time prepar repli invit tender quot octob commiss publish deadlin submiss propos novemb opinion commiss gave reason short time limit consult esf committe end septemb length subsequ intern commiss procedur commit expenditur end reason contradict criteria laid regul ombudsman state previou case complaint sf short deadlin establish submiss applic good administr practic postal servic adequ mean commun inform interest parti context case commiss acknowledg futur deadlin longer telefax complementari mean commun procedur present case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case protect forest fire interpret regul eec decis complaint vk european commiss complaint januari mr complain ombudsman commiss fail ensur italian author compli regul protect commun forest fire complaint italian author made contract compani fight forest fire calabria mr consid compani equip insuffici complain italian author success complain commiss claim commiss duti ensur adequaci equip compani commiss repli regul compet adequaci equip commiss question li compet member state background mr complain ombudsman alleg commiss fail ensur applic regul inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion state dealt great length mr complaint protect forest itali decid close file regul eec provid specif equip fire fighter choic equip question fall remit member state complain observ observ mr maintain complaint decis question rais complaint commiss interpret regul eec correct content regul articl regul aim set commun scheme protect forest fire articl scheme concern prevent measur instanc quot provis forest road quot quot organis inform campaign quot articl member state inform commiss programm project increas forest protect articl describ role plai consult committe forest protect articl concern commun financi contribut measur involv scheme articl provid member state design bodi purpos regul adopt measur ensur commun fund correctli appli articl oblig commiss submit annual report articl date entri forc regul appear provis control adequaci equip appear element hand indic commiss interpret regul wrong recal highest author question commun law court justic basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case cancel financi assist project decis complaint jma european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman behalf firm commiss decis cancel financi assist project firm respond commiss call propos project transnat charact decemb order qualifi set transnat partnership includ number firm member state commiss dg xxiii agre bear half total cost project ecu partner firm withdrew project commiss inform mr decid cancel financi assist substanti modif origin propos inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state call propos concern project transnat charact august commiss agre contribut firm project basi balanc particip greek spanish portugues partner octob commiss learnt fundament scope condit origin propos withdraw spanish partner juli made role financi particip remain partner seek inform mr commiss view departur spanish partner reduc transnat charact propos limit scope project region calabria consequ substant origin project failur firm notifi commiss consid basi contract respect firm modifi unilater propos consent commiss decid cancel financi particip project complain observ observ mr claim firm act good faith inform commiss withdraw spanish partner unawar mr claim made origin propos view commiss cancel financi contribut reject project decis case law court instanc oblig compli condit attach decis grant commun financi assist constitut essenti duti beneficiari fulfil condit award commun aid present case call propos state quot action innov transnat natur quot withdraw spanish partner transnat aspect project substanti affect claus declar sign complain establish quot beneficiari undertak notifi project chang object content partner budget fund commiss obtain authoris proce quot contract sign august involv partner particip project place juli commun commiss half month institut request inform implement project failur contractor commun promptli commiss obtain previou authoris correspond oblig laid claus declar beneficiari basi fact ombudsman consid commiss act decid condit govern financi particip complain project compli cancel support project appear maladministr ombudsman close case tariff deer meat decis complaint vk european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman behalf feder european deer farmer associ complaint concern mr correspond commiss custom tariff appli deer meat import european union complaint low rate import duti make import deer meat agricultur product compar cheap competit creat difficulti european deer farmer complain ask commiss recognis deer meat agricultur product domest anim meat impli higher rate import duti complain claim deer meat agricultur product consid meat domest anim deer domest anim food breed treatment meat complain claim line decis court justic held quot express game appear subhead common custom tariff interpret appli anim live wild state hunt quot deer question hunt brought slaughterhous sheep cattl complain consid fair treat custom purpos domest anim exchang correspond complain commiss emerg commiss share complain point view background complain complain ombudsman alleg commiss wrongli interpret current provis custom tariff applic deer meat inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state substanc commiss assess complain grievanc state letter conclus obei instruct common custom tariff state meat anim hunt deer remain classifi meat game anim rais captiv argument line explan commission monti gave complain point judgment court justic cite complain state express quot game quot ordinari mean design categori anim live wild hunt deer undoubtedli includ descript final recal protect grant agricultur product princip decid polit administr action commiss opinion assess complain inform correctli suffici matter complain observ observ complain maintain complaint decis question rais complaint commiss wrongli interpret provis govern tariff applic deer meat relev common custom tariff state deer meat hunt declar quot game quot appear commiss rightli assess relev provis deer meat anim remain captiv import union game recal court justic highest author question commun law basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case commiss decis initi infring proceed articl ec treati decis complaint jma european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman behalf client mr alleg commiss fail ensur correct applic direct eec portug mr work firm quot casino algarv quot administr commiss set portugues author labour relat disput mr brought legal action employ administr agenc charg casino declar court respons firm manag situat appear contraven criteria laid direct eec regul employ oblig inform employe condit applic contract employ relationship mr case portugues court case relat applic commun direct portugues author complaint letter commiss mr complain letter receiv repli commiss inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state letter mr regist secretariat gener basi fact present letter commiss conclud portugues author correctli appli direct eec direct eec safeguard employe right event transfer undertak commiss deem inappropri carri inquiri matter view fact assess case depend interpret portugues law fact disput object legal proceed nation court commiss request inform portugues author commiss made refer discretionari power start infring proceed member state recognis court justic complain observ observ mr state case appeal portugues court settl diverg interpret direct eec judg dealt origin case suprem court portug complain view nation author respect commun law commiss interven power treati commiss fail act guardian treati allow violat european citizen right member state decis decis complaint articl treati commiss duti quot guardian treati quot ensur commun law appli carri duti guardian treati commiss investig infring commun law attent result complaint initi investig lead send letter formal notic member state concern opportun submit observ commiss consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati articl deliv reason opinion matter commiss choos pursu inquiri matter reason support action reason provid basi potenti inquiri ombudsman order ensur maladministr place commiss justifi inact mr case ground assess complaint depend interpret portugues law fact disput object legal proceed nation court nation court handl case involv incorrect applic commun law expediti preliminari refer procedur articl question commun law refer court justic review action chosen commiss ombudsman found institut act limit legal author instanc maladministr establish prompt repli letter complain commiss state opinion mr complaint commiss regist mr inform write registr ombudsman state similar case commiss public administr duti properli repli queri citizen present case commiss abid principl good administr behaviour european ombudsman note commiss recognis failur apologis complain remark ombudsman appear basi inquiri european ombudsman complaint appear commiss chose action member state complaint mr take account assess complaint depend interpret portugues law fact disput object legal proceed nation court review action chosen commiss european ombudsman found institut act limit legal author instanc maladministr establish ombudsman close case refus nation court request preliminari rule commiss decis pursu relat complaint decis complaint jma european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman behalf client mr complaint concern commiss failur repli letter address august decemb letter commiss formal complaint alleg infring commun law portugues author letter commiss complain explain client mr origin nation finland arrest portugues author extradit request finnish author legal process reveal mr nation dominican republ compet portugues judici author consid take nation dominican republ mr lost origin finnish nation appli rule countri nation european union citizen approach confirm portugues suprem court complain consid legal interpret breach articl treati claim portugues suprem court duti refer matter court justic preliminari rule accord articl treati mr ask commiss interven role guardian treati ensur portugues author properli appli commun law letter commiss decemb mr provid addit document complaint inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state evalu document submit complain letter commiss draft repli june commiss recognis long delai apologis repli letter reason time factual situat commiss confirm posit complain consid infring commun law occur document forward complain letter prove mr held finnish nation commiss consid approach portugues suprem court justifi commiss state infring proceed articl treati rule render nation court ombudsman forward commiss comment complain invit make observ observ receiv decis failur answer correspond commiss acknowledg failur deal promptli letter complain offer explan apologis delai view fact appear ground european ombudsman pursu aspect case decis complaint articl treati commiss duti quot guardian treati quot ensur commun law appli carri duti guardian treati commiss investig infring commun law attent result complaint initi investig lead send letter formal notic member state concern opportun submit observ commiss consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati articl deliv reason opinion matter commiss choos pursu inquiri matter reason support action reason provid basi potenti inquiri european ombudsman order ensur maladministr place commiss justifi inact case ground approach portugues suprem court justifi document forward complain prove client held finnish nation commiss point infring proceed articl treati rule render nation court review action chosen commiss ombudsman found institut act limit legal author instanc maladministr establish aspect case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case mutual accept civil aviat licenc decis complaint jma european commiss complaint april mr complain ombudsman alleg failur commiss ensur proper applic british author council direct eec mutual accept civil aviat licenc complain compet british author recognis pilot licenc obtain spain explain refus basi addit requir satisfi mutual recognit grant complain claim practic experi account belief british author breach direct eec mr letter matter commiss represent madrid februari march complaint ombudsman mr claim commiss ensur proper applic direct eec unit kingdom repli letter represent madrid inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss apologis failur represent madrid answer complain letter time fashion commiss explain recent chang staff place quot euroju quot section madrid result dispatch correspond suffer delai commiss state clear instruct represent member state avoid similar delai occur futur applic direct eec unit kingdom commiss state order clarifi situat servic contact unit kingdom civil aviat author complain inform initi ask commiss servic forward detail licenc experi ombudsman forward commiss comment complain invit make observ observ receiv decis failur answer correspond commiss acknowledg failur deal promptli letter complain represent madrid offer explan apologis delai commiss instruct represent member state measur avoid delai occur futur appear repli complain letter measur avoid similar situat ground ombudsman pursu aspect case due dilig ensur complianc commun law ensur member state compli fulli commun law commiss work accord principl good administr act due dilig impli commiss guardian treati activ seek concern member state put end alleg infring duli inform complain action letter complain commiss servic contact respons nation author order ensur proper applic direct eec respons british author commiss request inform complain problem pilot licenc profession experi inform appear commiss act due dilig handl complaint ombudsman found evid maladministr relat aspect case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case price commiss public decis complaint pd european commiss complaint march mr member european parliament complain behalf mr greek scientist mr state european union citizen european commiss public expens opinion citizen exclud access public consid problemat perspect transpar annex mr complaint letter receiv mr letter mr state commiss public unafford greek nation state public page cost equival dai pai greek scientist inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss criteria price document quot price polici offic offici public european commun base principl establish institut institut author decid price public recommend offic take consider polici object product cost minimum price requir sale network small print run languag price cover cost incur principl discrimin price ecu member countri quot commiss point oper network european document centr provid free access public commun institut make consider amount free inform internet observ commiss opinion receiv complain decis exorbit arbitrari price polici inconsist principl transpar prevent european citizen access inform publish commun institut appear current price polici commiss base object criteria legitim aim cover cost product distribut public polici constitut maladministr price polici consid relat principl equal treatment case law court justic principl impli ident situat treat differ situat treat ident crucial question appli principl establish ident situat hand commiss account differ incom distribut commun establish price polici lead situat public appear price member state hand public substanti price offer sale appear commiss consid option appear entitl fact commiss consid public principl price infring principl equal treatment appear instanc maladministr ombudsman close case decis complaint wg vk ov offic offici public european commun commiss fellowship social secur contribut decis complaint jma european commiss complaint march mr complain ombudsman commiss fail repli request inform problem payment unemploy benefit switzerland complain recipi fellowship commun rtd quot human capit mobil quot programm move duebendorf switzerland decemb order complet scientif research month period beneficiari type assist requir ensur social secur scheme complain paid unemploy insur period complet research juli move zurich find employ complain request payment unemploy benefit swiss social secur offic citi obtain posit respons swiss author request octob wrote commiss request inform receiv repli queri complaint mr ask ombudsman make inquiri ensur commiss clarifi situat inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion care investig registr system incom mail trace complain letter date octob file commiss letter commiss point address specif person institut copi quot commiss européenn directorat général quot substanc case commiss explain gener condit govern research train fellowship applic case social secur contribut tax paid research fellowship complain duli inform condit host institut research type grant sole respons ensur complianc nation tax provis commiss explain ec legisl applic case relev rule regul eec extend applic european econom area switzerland part eea order complain commiss state rapidli contact relev nation author seek addit inform resolut case complain inform result addit inform complain ombudsman receiv commiss opinion complain addit inform letter june letter complain explain inform bilater agreement recognit unemploy right franc switzerland basi provis unemploy contribut recognis octob claim social secur payment date back august inform bilater agreement complain lost opportun advantag minimum salari reintegr labour market summari claim failur commiss fulli explain consequ fellowship cost substanti amount monei present origin complaint ombudsman pursu question ombudsman forward commiss opinion complain make observ decis ombudsman state similar case commiss public administr duti properli repli queri citizen case commiss justifi failur repli complain request ground trace letter found registr system institut letter copi commiss address includ conceiv postal servic deliv letter opinion commiss gave repli problem pose complain mean find potenti solut appear repli complain request ground ombudsman pursu case basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case fail recruit expert decis complaint pd european commiss complaint made complaint ombudsman commiss hold respons fact recruit post execut director develop project concern countri commiss fund post question provid financi assist recruit commiss enlist specialist consult recruit procedur consult notifi meet manag bodi project compos repres countri concern subsequ inform select post call brussel juli attend meet futur execut director project commiss offici ambassador countri concern suppos duti execut director novemb novemb contract sign state time contact commiss matter told wait problem signatur fund agreement european union manag bodi decemb receiv draft contract manag bodi inform time draft approv commiss decemb propos number amend draft contract februari receiv letter manag bodi state accept amend want break negoti address commiss issu success complain ombudsman substanc complaint commiss role intermediari respons fact recruit procedur complain demand compens inquiri ec treati empow european ombudsman inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi statut ombudsman specif action author person subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman inquiri complaint direct examin maladministr activ commiss commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state march manag bodi address commiss seek commun financ commiss agre fund select procedur post execut director project fund post commiss submit short list candid manag bodi select manag bodi address commiss view secur approv appoint act intermediari agre remuner term success candid director gener concern approv appoint forward term condit includ contract manag bodi commiss state manag bodi decid break negoti demand excess agre call question term agre final commiss state financi assist european commun project constitut commit part commiss vi vi candid manag bodi contract institut commiss complain observ observ complain claim contractu link commiss aris fact commiss contract select candid european compani candid interview european commun offici fact commiss approv final choic made liabl contest commiss claim term contract agre decis question rais complaint complain recruit post execut director project constitut instanc maladministr attribut commiss appear commiss assist manag bodi find candid post fund recruit procedur commiss conclud contract complain appear procedur set motion initi manag bodi final choic success candid made intervent commiss contract sign conclud complain manag bodi decis sign contract break negoti respons fact manag bodi ask commiss approv appoint commiss immedi alter respons element hand indic commiss unduli measur incit manag bodi break negoti element hand indic commiss moment assum legal respons action manag bodi commiss behav complain legitim contract commiss appear fact complain recruit post execut director project constitut instanc maladministr activ commiss ombudsman close case reserv list recruit decis complaint pd european commiss complaint mr made complaint ombudsman alleg commiss recruit polici constitut instanc maladministr commiss organis gener competit nation member state view establish reserv list administr mr appli competit pass examin successfulli enter reserv list establish autumn june mr invit brussel commiss order undergo medic examin interview commiss servic possibl interest recruit pass medic test interview mr receiv job offer obtain knowledg fact commiss recruit temporari agent person pass gener competit mr consid instanc maladministr person pass competit offer job person pass competit recruit inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss firstli point staff regul case law court justic person pass competit automat offer job commiss notic competit explain situat notic fact state number name reserv list number post commiss explain proceed reserv list transmit reserv list curriculum vita applic commiss servic request recruit applic vacant perman post case specif competit initi commiss staff depart applic invit brussel interview inform meet recruit procedur interview mr staff depart receiv request recruit concern recruit temporari staff commiss observ profil applic reserv list fit servic concern commiss subject budgetari constraint lead situat appropri employ temporari agent extern servic recruit staff perman post thirdli commiss observ assign larg part recruit nation member state decis question complaint rais consid instanc maladministr commiss gener recruit staff perman staff person reserv list offer perman job respect firstli observ commiss legal oblig recruit person reserv list appar explan commiss opinion commiss carri wide varieti function act budgetari constraint budgetari author impos function natur temporari requir specif expertis reserv list possess mere fact commiss proceed recruit staff perman staff time exhaust exist reserv list constitut instanc maladministr basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case alleg discrimin call tender decis complaint pd european commiss complaint june mr made complaint ombudsman commiss handl restrict call tender translat french fr publish commiss februari point tender notic state number applic invit bid cover oper contract author ensur genuin competit point call tender laid condit applic compli point provid contract author select applic invit bid basi inform submit relat point mr appli call tender commiss inform invit bid applic conform tender notic letter june mr ask commiss review decis success background mr complain commiss discrimin compani view support alleg ask ombudsman request commiss repli question criteria commiss order select number candid invit bid point tender notic commiss understand quot genuin competit quot advantag commiss gain exclud candid fulfil condit tender notic point final mr claim fact call tender compani invit bid translat english german inconsist decis call tender translat french inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss explain procedur select applic invit bid commiss call attent fact procedur question call restrict procedur govern provis articl council direct eec procedur contract author oblig select applic fulfil criteria laid tender notic repli question commiss select applic made compar respect merit commiss annex evid opinion appear past qualiti translat provid mr compani consid suffici concern question commiss explain previou tender procedur compani retain translat french receiv work translat page term quot ensur genuin competit quot commiss understood limit number compani ensur real competit concern question commiss explain restrict procedur repres advantag commiss sens compani retain impli commiss servic revis translat receiv background commiss conclud oper properli discrimin mr compani complain observ observ mr maintain complaint refer document show commiss servic charg tender procedur pleas work decis principl discrimin impli ident situat treat differ situat treat ident element hand indic commiss engag discrimin matter distinguish element applic conform tender notic qualiti applic work mr case weak point select committe commiss appear commiss opinion commiss compli properli provis govern procedur fact call tender mr compani success bear find fact occas commiss found complain work good qualiti invalid fact occas commiss found qualiti insuffici ombudsman found ground claim commiss decis invit mr bid constitut instanc maladministr activ commiss basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case articl failur deliv reason opinion exclus complain meet decis complaint ijh european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman behalf compani blc limit import beer produc german breweri unit kingdom market summari fact present complaint april mr complain commiss unit kingdom law quot guest beer provis quot gbp allow tenant larg unit kingdom brewer subject exclus purchas agreement bui cask condit beer choic mr claim gbp discrimin beer produc member state infring articl ec treati june commiss inform mr complaint regist gbp examin commiss staff standpoint free movement good septemb commiss inform mr septemb unit kingdom author letter formal notic accord procedur laid articl ec treati februari commiss inform mr substanc unit kingdom repli letter formal notic invit make observ argument unit kingdom put forward august commiss press releas ip announc commiss decid send reason opinion unit kingdom accord procedur laid articl ec treati august mr learnt press releas issu unit kingdom depart trade industri tripartit meet schedul place octob commiss unit kingdom author trade associ confédérat de brasseur du marché commun cbmc august wrote commiss allow attend meet commiss refus request invit attend separ meet commiss servic dai novemb mr wrote commiss tripartit meet rais question accuraci inform provid cbmc mr subsequ initi numer contact respons commiss servic advis decemb reason opinion readi march unit kingdom govern announc propos amend gbp includ bottl condit ferment beer commiss satisfi term propos amend longer intend issu reason opinion mr consid propos amend adequ bring infring articl end complaint ombudsman mr alleg commiss failur send reason opinion unit kingdom author announc decis august maladministr ii articl procedur improperli conduct august exclus tripartit meet octob unreason mr request ombudsman commiss termin articl procedur inquiri complet inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss made summari point articl commiss power bring member state court justic consid fail fulfil oblig treati commiss discret seiz court member state compli reason opinion individu complain requir commiss adopt specif posit ii commiss encourag individu make complaint servic awar violat commun law commiss consid complain inform outcom action decid iii gbp allow draught cask condit beer bought kind beer correspond typic british tradit product commiss consid de facto discrimin breach articl ec treati commiss consid object gbp guarante choic consum give market opportun tradit beer produc small medium size breweri legitim iv send letter formal notic decid send reason opinion commiss take account open unit kingdom author find solut conform commun law decid discuss altern meet organis includ tripartit meet commiss unit kingdom author beer industri repres cbmc begin march unit kingdom author propos amend gbp allow tenant larg nation breweri bui brand bottl condit beer addit cask condit beer commiss solut satisfactori tradit beer produc member state bottl condit commiss decid suspend procedur send reason opinion amend pass juli unit kingdom parliament vi mr inform stage action commiss press releas august state commiss decid send reason opinion unit kingdom inform telephon stage reach procedur receiv time commiss offic invit tripartit meet held octob receiv dai dg xv inform confidenti element discuss meet april inform letter commiss consid extens gbp tradit bottl condit beer satisfactori complain observ mr observ includ summari point commiss failur send reason opinion unit kingdom author breach legal oblig articl ec treati ii commiss decis support amend gbp fail deal crucial legal issu provis introduc iii commiss decis legal unsustain evid suppli reason quot tradit quot beer excus negoti polit settlement articl procedur decis request commiss termin articl procedur ombudsman inquiri complet treati statut ombudsman complaint ombudsman suspens effect administr procedur normal principl appli nation level complaint ombudsman effect present case appear special factor justifi ombudsman propos commiss termin articl procedur question affect interest parti commiss failur send reason opinion unit kingdom articl ec treati establish role commiss quot guardian treati quot guardian treati duti ensur provis treati measur institut pursuant thereto appli articl treati commiss consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati deliv reason opinion matter give state concern opportun submit observ state concern compli opinion period laid commiss bring matter court justic evid ombudsman unit kingdom opportun submit observ commiss consid guest beer provis infring provis treati free movement good commiss decid send reason opinion immedi unit kingdom author discuss find solut conform commun law case law court justic enforc procedur involv power part commiss mean time limit purpos put end contravent treati evid present ombudsman show power abus present case evid unnecessari delai commiss discuss unit kingdom author august march unit kingdom author propos amend gbp commiss consid satisfactori bring infring end complain claim observ amend gbp satisfactori commiss fail deal gbp introduc articl reason opinion time limit state compli opinion commiss bring matter court justic state compli period laid clear carri function articl relev question commiss unit kingdom propos amend gbp propos satisfactori put end infring commiss procedur treatment complaint carri function guardian treati commiss duti act accord principl good administr behaviour respond ombudsman inquiri quot articl quot case commiss consist acknowledg duti common ground commiss regist complaint gbp inform complain send letter formal notic gave opportun comment substanc repli receiv unit kingdom commiss publicli announc view infring exist basi evid ombudsman appear complain inform commiss subsequ decis engag discuss unit kingdom author altern wai bring infring end commiss inform complain april view extens gbp tradit bottl condit beer satisfactori bring infring end evid suppli parti ombudsman show complain knew commiss reason conclus opportun submit evid counter argument complain appear enjoi procedur possibl accept commiss respons ombudsman initi inquiri commiss administr procedur relat citizen complaint nation author tripartit meet exclus complain meet intend discuss solut complaint prima faci unreason normal administr procedur complain parti choic cours action compat commun law matter member state concern present state commun law appear legal basi claim unreason exclud complain meet organis context provid procedur possibl comment compat commun law action final select accept satisfactori commiss note paragraph appear case ombudsman inquiri reveal evid failur commiss observ principl good administr behaviour relat procedur matter dealt section decis matter rais complain observ observ commiss opinion complain argu commiss decis support amend gbp legal unsustain evid suppli claim commiss reason quot tradit quot beer excus negoti polit settlement articl procedur origin complaint focus procedur question dealt section observ provid ground ombudsman conduct inquiri alleg ombudsman note complain possibl contest compat amend guest beer provis articl ec treati initi proceed unit kingdom court basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case transfer pension right decis complaint pd european commiss complaint august petit committe german bundestag transfer petit lodg mr european ombudsman dealt complaint mr work european commiss resign accord applic provis staff regul paid sever grant decemb april mr ask commiss repai sever grant transfer pension right german pension system complain alleg commiss properli deal request inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state accord applic provis staff regul mr entitl pension sever grant paid opinion state commis repli complain inquiri decemb april june hand reimburs sever grant articl annex viii staff regul possibl person concern resum activ employ commun institut hand transfer pension right consider offici temporari agent activ servic leav servic commun institut prove entitl pension entitl take effect period case complain opinion state payment sever grant commiss fullfil oblig complain claim pension commiss answer complain question measur consid observ receiv complain decis appear repli mr inquiri commiss gave adequ reason meet request ombudsman found justif claim commiss dealt mr request improperli basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case packag holidai direct alleg failur commiss deal properli complaint decis complaint ijh european commiss complaint novemb mr made complaint ombudsman commiss dealt complaint made unit kingdom author august mr complaint commiss concern alleg failur unit kingdom govern properli implement enforc provis relat surcharg contain direct eec nation legisl direct transpos domest law commiss regist complaint februari dg xxiv commiss inform complain direct appear properli transpos domest law commiss request inform unit kingdom author guidanc booklet law publish unit kingdom depart trade industri dti articl infring proceed commenc repli unit kingdom author satisfactori octob dg xxiv inform complain complaint result chang word dti guidanc booklet commiss decid matter letter explain direct question requir injunct power nation author deal infring nation provis transpos commun law propos direct injunct power consid summari mr complaint ombudsman made alleg time deal complaint commiss excess ii commiss letter date octob contain irrelev inform iii commiss fail deal properli issu rais complaint approv revis word dti guidanc booklet commiss collud unit kingdom govern failur implement direct eec properli effect alleg complain refer fact guidanc booklet omit kei word direct regul direct transpos domest law firstli law surcharg impos quot contract state precis revis price calcul quot booklet omit word quot precis quot quot quot complaint packag tour compani practic explain contract method surcharg calcul law surcharg impos respect limit rang item includ quot fee chargeabl servic land tax embark disembark fee port airport quot booklet refer quot fee chargeabl servic quot practic packag tour compani frequent add amount respect administr charg agent commiss entitl charg complain consum protect direct aim provid negat inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss commiss opinion includ summari point complain complain commiss text guidanc booklet absenc enforc mechan case packag travel contract quot state precis revis price calcul quot commiss inform unit kingdom author complaint decemb letter march unit kingdom author view guidanc booklet mislead meet offici dg xxiv juli unit kingdom author show readi modifi text booklet take account text commun octob commiss decid close file march consid unit kingdom breach commun law complain inform decis reason letter octob letter contain clear detail inform question rais complain issu enforc commiss opinion express regret delai close file march inform complain decis octob complain observ observ complain maintain alleg excess delai irrelev inform collus misrepres mean direct repeat view commiss main point import precis word direct respect consid revis word dti guidanc booklet origin decis preliminari remark commiss procedur deal complaint infring commun law member state commiss close file complaint case march april ombudsman began initi inquiri possibl improv qualiti commiss administr procedur deal complaint infring commun law member state initi inquiri commiss adopt intern rule procedur decis close file take action initi offici infring proceed complaint maximum period year date regist special case reason state commiss undertook case complaint foundat case heard complain commiss ensur complain inform intent close case appear case present commiss find infring commun law complain possibl put forward view critic commiss point view commiss commit final conclus infring complaint excess delai present case delai registr complaint commiss decis close file year opinion commiss apologis delai month complain inform decis commiss adopt intern rule refer paragraph commit refer paragraph prevent unnecessari delai deal futur complaint appear commiss act ensur futur case dealt approxim half time deal present case view commit commiss apolog refer paragraph action ombudsman appear alleg commiss letter date octob contain irrelev inform commiss letter complain date octob inform commiss view modifi text dti guidanc booklet met demand clarif commiss decid matter note paragraph complain futur opportun put forward view critic commiss point view decis close case made complain commiss includ irrelev materi letter addit explan absenc requir injunct provis enforc direct eec inform propos direct requir provis complaint commiss date august expressli rais issu absenc mean enforc direct ombudsman consid correct commiss deal matter letter complain inappropri commiss volunt inform legisl propos relat enforc appear maladministr relat aspect complaint alleg commiss fail deal properli issu rais complaint collud failur unit kingdom govern implement direct eec properli effect complain main claim relat aspect case concern fact dti guidanc booklet reproduc word direct transpos regul alleg result packag tour oper regularli includ contract provis void direct transpos regul consum protect direct aim provid negat complain commiss fail deal satisfactorili complaint approv revis word dti guidanc booklet collud failur unit kingdom govern implement direct eec properli effect opinion commiss refer letter complain date januari repli complain letter date novemb complain letter explain consid revis word guidanc booklet unaccept commiss repli state member state oblig transpos implement direct eec oblig publish distribut inform measur compli direct guidanc booklet judg infring direct grave endang aim case commiss repli express view enforc provis packag travel contract fail state precis revis price calcul sanction simpli organis entitl addit payment full complianc articl direct commiss respond argument present complain made clear consid member state legal oblig consid infring commun law member state evid ombudsman suggest maladministr commiss assess matter correspond complain commiss refer paragraph place commiss close file complaint note paragraph futur complain possibl put forward view critic commiss point view commiss commit final conclus infring view appear maladministr relat aspect complaint conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case recruit procedur decis nomin candid decis complaint bb european commiss complaint novemb mr made complaint ombudsman select procedur select board decis nomin applic posit fact complain reserv list complain candid select procedur march commiss inform reserv list valid decemb complaint mr alleg posit fact creat mr complain mr compli requir vacanc notic year work experi field qualifi candid complain claim fax commiss august fill vacanc claim order elimin candid member state finnish citizenship requir notic mr stood real chanc recruit final claim inform nomin made pursuant select procedur inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss commiss opinion summaris select procedur aim constitut reserv list posit head unit joint research centr petten total transpar object fair abovement reserv list establish select board act margin discret basi list appli discretionari power appoint author select applic fulfil requir qualif notic applic present examin file select board establish applic fulfil criteria notic applic invit interview board unanim decid propos put mr mr reserv list april select board met ispra order examin applic board declar applic suitabl posit underlin mr qualifi market administr research project industri qualif figur vacanc notic appoint author margin discret nomin mr posit legitim appli choic applic candid invit interview fulfil formal criteria requir vacanc notic contrari alleg mr fulfil requir year work experi fact finnish nation requir element prove posit creat mr council regul ec establish special measur open competit organis decemb order recruit citizen member state secretariat select board claim knowledg fax complain august commiss regret fact complain notifi nomin candid posit question measur ensur situat occur futur complain observ observ complain maintain complaint select procedur complain state ground claim mr qualifi market administr research project industri formal criteria alleg mr year work experi requir field complain complain contest polici recruit citizen member state alleg knew european citizen qualifi posit select candid complain maintain claim fax commiss receiv inform result select decis select procedur formal criteria articl staff regul procedur competit procedur adopt appoint author recruit post requir special qualif establish case law court justic appoint author assess candid fulfil condit requir vacanc notic assess question event manifest error select procedur formal criteria appli ombudsman inquiri complaint select board act accord vacanc notic ombudsman found instanc maladministr select procedur formal criteria appli select board nation requir select board entitl impos nation requir accord council regul ec appear evid support alleg possibl abus order benefit candid ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr aspect case alleg loss candid fax ombudsman underlin principl good administr conduct demand request inform repli undu delai complain alleg fax european commiss secretariat research select committe august request inform fill posit concern commiss explain opinion found fax date august observ complain maintain alleg ombudsman found appear evid contradict commiss claim receiv fax ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr relat aspect complaint lack inform fill posit ombudsman note principl good administr requir candid select procedur reserv list receiv notif fill posit note fact commiss regret complain notifi nomin candid posit question measur ensur situat occur futur view find take account commiss regret failur notifi complain measur ensur failur occur futur ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case alleg failur prevent discrimin access public employ decis complaint vk european commiss complaint march mr made complaint ombudsman commiss claim commiss fail ensur italian author discrimin italian citizen seek employ teacher south tyrol fail repli matter begin complain austrian citizen ask euro ju offic commiss austrian represent advic matter discrimin access public employ teacher northern italian region south tyrol inform appear german mother tongu requir employ due complex point system italian applic equal chanc post euro ju offic investig matter inform complain request transfer legal servic commiss investig receiv repli commiss servic brussel complain receiv repli complain ombudsman inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state due high number complaint receiv servic issu relat access public servic member state complain letter answer due time delai regret commiss detail letter complain june commiss state fulli awar specif problem access employ provinc bolzano south tyrol commiss offici contact italian author august topic repli itali inform commiss author bolzano undertaken remov obstacl european union nation access public employ addit commiss undertook bring complain specif case attent italian author remind commit decis ec treati empow european ombudsman inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi statut european ombudsman specif action author person subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman inquiri complaint direct examin maladministr activ european commiss failur repli appear commiss detail letter repli complain june commiss admit complain letter answer earlier regret delai aspect complaint appear settl concern requir access public employ provinc bolzano commiss appear awar issu contact relev nation author italian author repli commiss announc formal commit remov obstacl european union nation access public employ commiss undertook bring complain individu case attent appear commiss activ measur improv current situat access public employ gener make complain case directli relev author basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case offic offici public european commun opoc distribut system price polici decis complaint wg vk ov offic offici public european commun complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman distribut system offic offici public european commun opoc complain supplier ec document germani receiv materi opoc central german supplier bundesanzeig main claim compar situat citizen order ec materi directli opoc present distribut system order bundesanzeig function effici alleg document price high criticis access document internet citizen inquiri opoc opinion complain complaint address ombudsman opoc opoc transmit complaint ombudsman opinion complaint opinion opoc state suppli public document network nation distributor opoc possibl deal order system intend closer citizen opoc point larg number public current titl public year imposs titl time nation sale point understand public complain want order opoc underlin constantli promot quick client servic cost document document opoc observ price differ countri countri due cost live member state mean nation offic opoc ad debat sale free distribut document present polici institut member state base sale observ make servic quot document deliveri quot centralis eudor compris offici journal european commun document collect appli charg servic citizen member state access internet opoc state internet access parallel exclus mean access document complain observ observ complain repeat critic difficulti obtain european commun inform fact present suppli system close citizen complain criticis fact inform sold profit european institut act commerci organis sell inform contrari philosophi public institut decis alleg suppli system problem obtain document opoc justifi system distribut nation offic suppli document necess decentralis imposs opoc deal demand equal underlin constantli promot quick client servic admit imposs document time nation offic larg number public appear ombudsman number public opoc constitut valid reason titl temporarili unavail fact public ask complain immedi germani consid instanc maladministr alleg price document practic sale opoc complain criticis price document fact opoc sell document provid free opoc observ current polici institut sell document provid free ombudsman note opoc awar price vari member state member state due cost live make quot document deliveri quot servic guarante charg citizen take account aim cover cost product distribut document opoc price polici base arbitrari unreason criteria consid instanc maladministr view find appear maladministr opoc ombudsman close case decis complaint pd european commiss case close reason european parliament allow system member european parliament decis join complaint uk pd sw pd dk pd pd european parliament complaint octob januari ombudsman receiv complaint allow regim european parliament appli member februari ombudsman inform complain complaint dealt jointli inquiri involv examin matter relat individu member european parliament mandat european ombudsman limit commun institut bodi gener background complaint report media parliament allow system report public fund spent irregularli background complain put forward substanc grievanc close link grievanc effect allow system set parliament illeg principl sound financi manag argu detail system set parliament meant circumv rule govern payment member parliament complain contrario articl protocol privileg immun european commun ensu council regul member parliament paid commun member meant paid member state elect complain remuner system appear unsatisfactori parliament set gener allow system serv hidden form pai rule make payment allow condit present support document grievanc effect exist rule properli enforc member parliament receiv allow request justifi work expens allow meant cover inquiri parliament opinion complaint forward european parliament opinion parliament state juli bureau parliament adopt decis quot set system perman control travel allow product support document cover mean transport member distinct propos modal system establish quaestor submit bureau approv entitl subsist allow brussel provid henceforth sign singl central regist regard subsist allow plenari session strasbourg principl link entitl allow particip roll call vote quaestor submit bureau propos precis modal agre principl review aspect method calcul kilometr allow includ introduct band basi propos submit bureau quaestor quot parliament state septemb bureau adopt implement provis quot case member undertaken part journei public transport support document submit journei plane board card board card issu document submit air ticket copi thereof case journei train document submit rail ticket ticket requir journei copi ticket verifi cash offic case journei undertaken privat car member submit person declar includ registr number car kilometr read begin end journei rout precis locat car park parliament place work quot octob presid parliament address note individu member parliament explain implic provis septemb note state inter alia quot confid member view european parliament interest demonstr citizen european union amount payabl member respect allow subject adequ check transpar line resolut budget adopt parliament decemb june practic term system effect novemb requir member includ presid submit member cash offic proof journei claim undertaken documentari proof cover major part journei made form airlin board pass individu journei air railwai ticket rail travel person declar journei undertaken privat car mean transport person declar journei drawn enabl check rare case normal practic airlin issu board pass copi relev airlin ticket submit quot final decemb bureau parliament establish provis member entitl daili allow quot daili allow member absent half roll call vote tuesdai wednesdai thursdai part session held strasbourg thursdai part session held brussel reduc member entitl signifi present event particip roll call vote quot note mention week dai dai legisl matter discuss addit member present half plenari session lose gener expens parliament result measur european parliament demand parliament european union attend member plenari session complain observ observ lodg effect good parliament adopt rule subject matter concern express effect rule appar sanction impos member compli rule decis appear light public critic complaint lodg european parliament proceed reform relev rule complain lodg observ appear happi reform accord good administr behaviour ombudsman note fact parliament financi control task accord commun financi regul ensur principl sound financi manag observ nation ombudsmen offic provid establish practic ombudsman inquir appear specialis control instanc inquir matter reason instanc gener remit give specialis instanc appear court auditor conduct audit parliament expens allow system worth recal briefli characterist commun institut set treati establish european commun articl treati court auditor respons carri audit commun financ articl quot member court auditor gener interest commun complet independ perform duti perform duti seek instruct govern bodi refrain action incompat duti quot court auditor fulli independ carri task articl treati specifi detail task power inquiri court articl inter alia quot court auditor examin account revenu expenditur commun court auditor examin revenu receiv expenditur incur law regular manner financi manag sound audit base record perform spot institut commun member state quot ombudsman underlin question regular spend public fund principl sound financi manag court auditor consid specialis instanc inform audit court auditor conduct time concentr evalu allow expens system includ examin system conform parliament relev regul commun financi regul principl sound financi manag result audit laid report made public due background european ombudsman inquiri justifi ombudsman close case case settl institut european parliament recruit neg result medic examin decis complaint nlp es jma european parliament complaint novemb ms complain ombudsman decis european parliament appoint vacant post basi neg medic advic complain part inter institut competit eur reserv list septemb european commiss servic respons personnel administr dg ix invit undergo medic examin brussel result medic examin forward complain februari ms interview european parliament view fill vacanc parliament recruit servic made offer employ complain telephon receiv written commun ms contact parliament april inform vacanc offer candid decis basi neg result medic examin ms undergon complaint ombudsman alleg institut concern compli provis articl staff regul right candid post ec institut respect decis parliament appar base result medic test perform valid period month establish parliament recruit polici type procedur inquiri parliament opinion complaint forward parliament opinion parliament point decis select complain vacanc base neg result medic examin carri commiss medic servic parliament express regret result medic examin forward complain result opportun contest neg result requir articl staff regul parliament consid respons failur cover letter opinion presid european parliament vacanc moment complain invit undergo medic examin carri medic servic european parliament complain observ observ ms agre solut propos presid letter undergo medic examin parliament examin carri quot guarante quot complain made request aspect examin decis appear ombudsman inquiri european parliament step settl matter satisfact complain ombudsman close case failur provid contract document languag tender decis complaint vk ov european parliament complaint june mr complain ombudsman behalf dutch carpentri firm mr read offici notic publish dutch newspap call tender provid furnitur european parliament confer room leopold build brussel ask contract document french dutch contact parliament servic confirm contract document exist french complaint ombudsman mr alleg order guarante equal tender receiv contract document languag inquiri parliament opinion complaint forward parliament opinion parliament observ call tender publish offici journal european commun nation newspap includ dutch newspap linguist requir notic call tender parliament refer articl council direct eec june coordin procedur award public suppli contract articl tender notic contract author wish award public suppli contract publish full offici journal european commun origin languag summari import element notic publish offici languag commun text origin languag authent parliament conclud tender notic present case publish offici languag union respect requir contract document parliament observ nation contract author oblig commun law translat public procur commun institut contract document volumin practic parliament institut translat contract document contract document present case french parliament observ awar pragmat approach commun institut respect principl equal treatment commun languag reason advisori committe purchas tender adopt novemb recommend ccam offici languag tender parliament conclud conform recommend measur order ensur futur essenti part contract document offici languag union final observ tender submit tender offici languag choic complain observ written observ receiv complain inform offic ombudsman telephon convers contract document dutch unabl submit tender observ complaint led posit result parliament announc chang practic futur decis failur parliament provid complain contract document dutch languag field tender commun institut gener principl discrimin basi nation set articl ec treati repeat articl financi regul quot respect contract enter commun discrimin nation member state ground nation quot principl discrimin ombudsman note parliament express awar fact practic translat contract document respect principl ombudsman welcom initi parliament led novemb adopt advisori committe purchas tender recommend ccam offici languag tender european citizen valuabl recommend contract document institut person compani subject jurisdict member state principl draft languag state languag request regrett complain part tender contract document languag constitut infring principl discrimin basi nation appear parliament react posit promptli complaint chang practic contract document enabl complain tender particip equal condit futur tender organis parliament appear european parliament opinion complain observ parliament step settl matter satisfi complaint ombudsman close case european commiss state aid enforc commun law commiss decis complaint sjb uk ijh european commiss complaint august firm solicitor made complaint ombudsman commiss behalf client ladbrok complaint concern commiss deal relat alleg state aid grant french author undertak french race bet industri origin ask complaint treat confidenti wrote confirm ladbrok disclos ombudsman decis close case complain ladbrok made number complaint commiss alleg state aid grant french author french race associ pari mutuel urbain pmu ladbrok consid articl ec treati state aid notifi commiss implement lead decis commiss articl compat common market complaint ombudsman refer specif complaint made commiss behalf ladbrok complaint made fax date decemb grant frf million notifi commiss french govern state aid letter date commiss dg iv inform complaint dealt number nn receiv respons commiss year complaint made letter date august frf million aid press report pmu receiv year receiv respons commiss complaint complaint made letter date march grant frf million french race associ pmu report press receiv respons commiss complaint claim commiss fail investig ladbrok complaint enforc oblig impos member state articl ec treati notifi state aid commiss inform ombudsman complaint made commiss incid alleg state aid grant french author french race bet undertak complaint subject judici proceed court instanc nation court made complaint ombudsman respect commiss handl complaint accord articl ec treati articl statut ombudsman form part ombudsman inquiri inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion novemb summari opinion made point subject matter complaint concern french tax legisl relat race bet levi amend decre issu march decemb request inform clarifi matter french author januari novemb ii take formal decis ladbrok complaint review success amend french legisl ensur consist commiss respons state aid case compar natur verifi measur complain fact state aid gener form econom regul taxat complaint requir depth examin commiss staff engag oper iii contrari situat aid notifi commiss oblig respond predetermin time complain redress proce nation court complain observ observ refer press releas ip issu commiss januari mention complaint ladbrok commiss decid seek explan french author natur french horserac bet measur understood press releas commiss decid open formal procedur articl ec treati investig measur constitut unlaw state aid queri commiss procedur account ladbrok complaint date decemb account complaint date august march observ made substanc point treati provis state aid direct effect enforc nation court commiss exclus jurisdict determin aid compat common market ii commiss maintain activ investig ladbrok complaint commun french author novemb year prior decis institut formal proceed inquiri respons request ombudsman clarifi ladbrok complaint cover formal investig commiss forward copi letter french author set decis open procedur articl letter date februari publish offici journal european commun commiss subsequ provid clarif ombudsman effect letter french author mention decre relev ladbrok complaint date decemb relat complaint date august march letter cover aid refer press releas date decemb issu french ministri agricultur appear complain observ inform commiss accept concern maladministr express origin complaint satisfi open formal investig articl express concern progress formal investig allow drift indefinit view absenc bind time limit commiss procedur state complaint ombudsman made case excess delai commiss conclud investig articl decis articl ec treati establish role commiss quot guardian treati quot guardian treati duti ensur provis treati measur institut pursuant thereto appli case state aid notifi accord articl ec treati commiss empow appli procedur articl deal complaint field state aid commiss requir interest sound administr fundament rule treati relat state aid conduct dilig imparti examin complaint februari commiss began formal investig articl ladbrok complaint state aid french race bet industri investig appear cover matter subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman understood complain accept concern maladministr express origin complaint ombudsman satisfi open formal investig articl februari appear european commiss comment complain observ commiss step settl matter satisfi complain ombudsman close case alleg lack inform telephon convers decis complaint mh vk ov european commiss complaint decemb mr journalist complain ombudsman alleg lack inform commiss mr occas obtain commiss inform badg danger substanc tin food import trade consumpt crocodil meat south africa regul kitchen equip restaur complain claim seri telephon convers transfer commiss offici receiv concret inform mr servic commiss contact order obtain inform inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion made point principl journalist address request inform spokesman servic commiss servic respons give inform interview journalist commiss comment verifi step complain order obtain request inform imposs identifi telephon convers complain servic commiss observ prepar provid request inform complain order obtain gener inform complain contact spokesman servic gave telephon number concern access specif document commiss refer rule laid commiss decis ecsc ec euratom februari public access commiss document topic complain request inform name telephon number offici director iii viii xi respons matter commiss opinion provid basic inform badg tin food import crocodil meat south africa regul kitchen equip restaur topic commiss enclos opinion scientif committe food express june telephon convers offici dg iii complain document matter april complain observ observ commiss opinion receiv complain telephon convers complain declar satisfi final respons commiss document decis alleg lack inform initi telephon convers inform contain complaint mr transfer seri telephon convers commiss offici receiv concret inform opinion commiss observ journalist make request inform spokesman servic servic respons give inform interview journalist matter good administr behaviour commiss ensur offici deal properli request inform telephon citizen indic procedur follow respons servic contact commiss avoid citizen remain answer request present case commiss comment possibl complain contact spokesman servic gener inform gave name offici contact director gener specif inform action ombudsman posit respons commiss provid request inform opinion commiss declar prepar provid inform request complain suppli basic inform subject badg tin food import crocodil meat south africa regul kitchen equip restaur commiss suggest complain contact spokesman servic offici gener specif inform appear commiss comment complain observ commiss step settl matter satisfi complain ombudsman close case late payment commiss contribut project decis complaint jma european commiss complaint mr mr complain ombudsman behalf european natur heritag fund enhf complaint alleg unjustifi delai dg vi commiss pai contribut project carri enhf june dg vi grant amount ecu enhf carri aspect project quot articl es quot relat quot proyecto piloto de demostración de aprovechamiento duradero de pastizal arbolado en el oest de españa quot enhf complet project end march submit technic financi report commiss order obtain final payment commiss paid esp june offici dg vi request present project final report forward complain june complain contact commiss occas request final payment made commiss repli februari request modif project financi report consid origin report conform guidelin complet project complain forward financi report commiss april time complaint ombudsman complain receiv payment commiss year project complet state financi situat desper ask ombudsman commiss deadlin late payment request intervent ensur final payment promptli made inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state financ complain project basi articl regul eec payment project made instal august juli final payment delai check financi inform project decis set rule govern project establish final payment made compet commiss servic approv technic financi report submit contractor annex ii decis authoris commiss request relev inform contractor case commiss servic request addit inform complain occas length delai make final payment consequ review carri commiss project financ articl regul eec critic remark made court auditor review entail substant increas workload commiss servic commiss underlin receiv report complain april drawn line guidelin clear final payment month addit inform complain ombudsman receiv commiss opinion complain addit inform letter date june juli letter refer contact servic commiss view find situat final payment project final payment commiss point complain power block payment case doubt view statement complain question letter ombudsman deadlin limit power letter juli complain state receiv final payment state commiss modifi deal government organis unabl particip project complain thank ombudsman effort achiev success solut problem ombudsman forward commiss opinion complain invit make observ receiv decis basi inform provid complain commiss ombudsman conclud case settl commiss ombudsman close case failur complain inform develop complaint decis complaint jma european commiss complaint june mr complain ombudsman behalf environment group cer alleg commiss fail inform cer develop complaint commiss cer complaint commiss concern authoris grant spanish author mine exploit mont obaren toloño la rioja area classifi spanish author special protect area spa protect bird june commiss inform cer complaint regist file number sg subsequ forward inform inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss commiss opinion summari preliminari aspect commiss claim complaint preced administr approach requir articl statut ombudsman commiss consid complain initi contact servic lodg initi complaint substanti aspect case commiss refer gener oblig complain set standard complaint form oblig involv send acknowledg receipt complaint receiv ii inform complain action relat complaint iii decis launch infring proceed respons member state relat case commiss explain complain letter regist complaint complaint file provis council direct eec april protect wild bird council direct eec conserv natur habitat wild fauna flora relev case request comment spanish author juli commiss explain case inform submit complain spars assess case undertaken light inform submit nation author absenc repli spanish author establish month period remind octob februari receiv repli commission bjerregaard wrote ms tocino spanish minist environ march repli spanish author final receiv commiss june basi explan spanish author commiss review case ask complain observ letter juli repli august complain agre assess carri commiss explain project origin complaint suspend consequ commiss intervent complain observ ombudsman forward commiss comment complain invit make observ repli complain project suspend spanish author order environment impact assess project undertaken view complain believ posit correct authoris project illeg complain ask ombudsman close case procedur authoris project complet spanish author full complianc european commun law ensur decis admiss case commiss argument complain previous complain institut stress ombudsman decid complaint admiss commun institut bodi natur make view subject ombudsman order admiss complaint preced administr approach institut bodi concern articl statut view linguist version text take account object provis practic ombudsman evalu suitabl administr approach made depend circumst case view fact case relat failur commiss complain inform year develop relat case reason expect inform forward complain prior request ombudsman consid criteria admiss complaint met administr approach failur commiss complain inform commiss justifi failur forward inform complain juli ground spanish author repli letter remind institut request comment matter context ombudsman initi inquiri pd commiss detail polici inform complain action respons complaint explain quot complaint regist complain inform action respons complaint includ represent made nation author concern quot basi commit proper commiss inform complain numer approach author concern ombudsman note result approach includ person letter commission charg environment portfolio respons nation minist allegedli illeg project cancel problem solv conclud commiss step settl matter complain full satisfact complain request case open ombudsman empow inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi statut ombudsman specif articl action author person subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman inquiri complaint direct examin maladministr activ commiss remit ombudsman assess complianc commun law activ undertaken spanish author conclus basi inform provid complain observ submit commiss ombudsman conclud case settl commiss complain full satisfact ombudsman close case offic harmonis intern market competit temporari agent select candid decis complaint alg pl es jma offic harmonis intern market complaint novemb mr made complaint alleg lack transpar offic harmonis intern market ohim conduct open competit failur provid explan candid select mr initi complain region ombudsman valencia quot sindic de greug de la comunitat valenciana quot transmit complaint european ombudsman mr part competit temporari agent organis ohim novemb preliminari screen applic select board admit oral test inform standard letter april mr wrote ohim underlin complain decis select board request inform select process reason exclus repli ohim consid complain gener lack clear reason inquiri ohim opinion complaint forward ohim opinion ohim point competit gener competit recruit ec offici select temporari agent secretari post grade gener rule govern organis type special competit temporari agent ohim select process carri due respect principl equal treatment transpar geograph balanc stage process ohim applic form express interest particip applic form repli receiv regist applic dossier consid admiss select board carri compar analysi candid merit experi candid includ final list stage consist oral test complain select oral test limit profession experi work spanish local administr complet recruit procedur select board letter candid inform outcom select applic submit formal complaint inform reason exclus offic stress complain contest exclus select board inquir reason decis letter consid complaint ombudsman forward ohim opinion complain make observ decis basi inform provid complain observ submit offic harmonis intern market ombudsman reach conclus give reason letter april complain expressli request offic harmonis intern market inform reason exclus competit ohim repli state stage person file candid compar complain select oral test context competit decis select board reject candid state condit notic competit fulfil larg number candid select board initi confin state reason refus summari manner inform candid criteria result select select board give subsequ individu explan candid expressli repli ohim complain suffici detail enabl complain understand factor select board decis relat base potenti review ground decis repli fail give adequ reason reject applic ohim justifi failur give reason fact mr submit formal appeal decis select board mere request inform addit requir deriv relev case law court justic matter court underlin duti institut give reason trigger candid competit expressli request individu explan substant decis opinion ombudsman ohim select board carri compar analysi candid merit account type task undertaken geograph balanc intern experi prefer candid acquir experi intern environ light criteria complain select profession experi practic knowledg foreign languag appear limit ombudsman consid aspect repli gave explan individu reason select board select complain oral test ohim respond properli request complain appear opinion ohim inform submit complain offic step settl matter satisfi complain ombudsman close case friendli solut achiev ombudsman european parliament travel expens offici visit mep decis complaint jc uk ijh european parliament complaint juli mr mep made complaint ombudsman complaint relev fact mr member committe develop cooper european parliament time event gave rise complaint committe rapporteur lomé convent committe instruct mep travel pari meet french foreign minist januari mr expens mission subsequ paid parliament week mr inform committe advis bureau parliament mission time instruct repai expens mr matter quaestor presid parliament confirm expens repaid complaint ombudsman mr claim unfair mep offici instruct undertak mission expect pai fare expens mistak inquiri parliament opinion complaint annex document forward european parliament parliament opinion includ remark quot keep ombudsman compet respons oblig act ad hoc arbitr appeal author member request turn compet parliamentari bodi bureau quaestor regret ombudsman involv unfound individu grievanc natur trust futur case declar inadmiss quot substanc complaint opinion contain point stipul parliament rule prior authoris requir attend meet mr receiv sought authoris ii mep entitl allow ecu year meet cost travel undertaken perform duti countri elect mr entitl submit request due time basi support document reimburs travel expens visit pari allow complain observ observ mr state deepli resent remark quot ital state interest financi aspect matter wish clear felt quot blacken quot parliament approach matter ombudsman effort achiev friendli solut examin parliament opinion mr observ ombudsman consid prima faci evid maladministr statement parliament opinion request prior authoris made visit pari appear accord documentari evid annex mr complaint accord articl statut ombudsman propos meet servic parliament discuss possibl friendli solut letter date januari current presid european parliament ombudsman letter includ remark quot accord rule parliament rule procedur member request bureau authoris part meet parliament usual place work januari lord plumb presid acp eu joint assembl request authoris mr part mission pari late submiss request meant bureau time mission ahead requir authoris parliament rule procedur clear point establish room doubt request submit advanc provis authoris event circumst parliament pai allow travel expens mr entitl mission authoris bureau call question mr good faith want carri job rapporteur abil quot meet ombudsman servic mr confirm state observ interest financi aspect matter complaint satisfi european parliament place public record act good faith prior authoris mission pari sought decis european parliament public record accept complain act good faith prior authoris mission pari sought complain part made clear seek reclaim expens parliament requir repaid basi rule parliament rule procedur appear ombudsman initi seek friendli solut issu remain disput complain european parliament ombudsman close case remark european parliament formal contest compet ombudsman deal complaint envisag futur case kind declar inadmiss consid ombudsman act quot arbitr appeal author member request turn compet parliamentari bodi quot explain annual report ombudsman supervis polit work european parliament absenc express provis treati statut ombudsman legal basi ombudsman complaint parliament administr work inadmiss similarli european ombudsman seek situat consid mean redress case kind legal basi ombudsman complaint made mep behalf inadmiss provid condit admiss laid statut fulfil articl statut requir complaint preced administr approach case kind includ applic compet author parliament case solv author provid reason complaint accord articl ec treati ombudsman inquiri concern instanc maladministr inquiri ombudsman institut concern opportun demonstr maladministr occur give opinion deal carefulli correctli relev issu secur complaint dealt promptli properli ombudsman european commiss access commiss document decis complaint bh irl jma european commiss complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman refus commiss give access document concern polici poverti european union inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion commiss medium term social action programm announc report relev commun action poverti social exclus prepar commiss start work repres member state context high level group social exclus request commiss member state made group inform nation criteria defin poverti social exclus includ outlin polici organis determin complain request concern compil document member state commiss decid forward copi contribut document question commiss document materi origin produc member state institut put basi commiss decis februari public access commiss document commiss conclud request materi consid commiss document commiss view request made author document member state commiss polici public access commiss document relat document forese commiss give access document produc bodi commiss point make final report complain complet commiss suggest complain liais irish depart social welfar inform seek complain observ observ mr point view confus type document ask request refer commiss document number document produc member state materi partial translat circul commiss cover page document consid commiss document mr ad document circul ireland commiss document summer ask irish depart social welfar copi document request refus ground refer commiss document decis make rest commiss mr disagre point view commiss document compil circul author institut commiss document lastli complain stress commiss reason neg consequ transpar european union document made interest transpar inquiri natur disput order reach satisfactori solut problem ombudsman decid document question inspect offici secretariat inspect aim assess document simpli compil contribut member state exclud public access meet carri inspect place commiss premis brussel octob commiss notic inspect member high level group meet commiss offici present explain document origin conceiv mean improv mutual understand member state nation polici social exclus poverti end high level group set commiss particip nation expert member state context high level group order prepar discuss commiss distribut questionnair member state end respons receiv member state collat commiss servic singl document distribut meet high level group june ombudsman effort achiev friendli solut inspect ombudsman wrote commiss accord articl statut view seek friendli solut complaint ombudsman refer letter role commiss prepar document question fact member state reject complain ground address request commiss regrett complain attempt obtain document met neg respons member state commiss ombudsman consid lack transpar case undermin public confid commun administr frustrat aim declar attach treati european union access inform view consider ombudsman propos friendli solut commiss agre give complain access request document repli februari commiss reaffirm opinion natur document agre ombudsman propos reach ad hoc solut case end request authoris member state contribut releas juli ombudsman receiv inform commiss repli receiv request appear member state agre forward document complain restrict reproduct copyright commiss agre send mr copi note servic meet high level group social exclus june letter ombudsman juli mr document initi request forward propos ombudsman initi friendli solut complain thank ombudsman work undertaken acknowledg signific progress made view ombudsman power author agre close case nonetheless complain express gener concern document receiv gener procedur public access document european union decis ombudsman initi friendli solut agre institut complain ombudsman close case tender exercis post financ manag phare programm decis complaint igl uk ijh european commiss complaint decemb made complaint ombudsman tender exercis post financ manag phare programm carri dg commiss accord articl statut ombudsman request complaint treat confidenti summari relev fact present complaint emploi brussel financ manag phare programm coordin unit august post reloc countri receiv inform assur length prospect period employ move countri famili approxim year post financ manag subject tender exercis unsuccess complaint ombudsman claim tender exercis conduct accord phare regul ii success tender close compli term refer post iii success tender posit level fee previous receiv financ manag inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss provid inform organis contractu framework phare programm relat specif case opinion made number point state call tender post financ offic compar evalu qualif candid opinion includ annex document select process complain observ observ contest point made commiss refer letter date decemb address offici dg commiss letter copi suppli ombudsman began quot regret inform final choic made evalu committe respons call tender retain offer advantag quot remark commiss respond point ii iii complaint ombudsman effort achiev friendli solut examin commiss opinion complain observ ombudsman consid prima faci evid maladministr discrep commiss opinion state call tender place letter address dg refer outcom tender exercis accord articl statut ombudsman wrote secretariat gener commiss propos inform meet commiss servic ombudsman servic discuss possibl friendli solut complaint meet commiss inform ombudsman discuss commiss servic take place subsequ inform ombudsman fax reach agreement commiss term financi settlement complaint commiss inform ombudsman friendli settlement reach decis ombudsman inquiri case appear reveal prima faci evid maladministr accord articl statut ombudsman propos inform meet commiss servic ombudsman servic initi ombudsman commiss complain reach friendli settlement complaint ombudsman close case renew extern contract alleg failur inform due time decis complaint ov european commiss complaint june mr journalist work correspond european commiss represent hagu complain ombudsman renew contract firstli complain head commiss represent refus sign renew year contract thought function superfici happen april month expir date contract consult audiovisu unit dg inform commun cultur audiovisu media commiss complain work month march inform paid month inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss renew contract commiss observ opinion initi durat contract sign april outgo head commiss represent hagu year renew year head represent duti march decis renew complain contract postpon arriv head represent decid inappropri prolong contract complain oral inform decis meet head represent march april written note date april complain criticis decis head represent inform letter april ground review decis complain final introduc request payment month march amount ecu correspond twelfth payment due initi period request refus commiss final observ confus exact natur complain contractu right commiss declar prepar find friendli solut complain commiss subsequ inform ombudsman friendli solut reach complain paid ecu claim activ month march complain observ written observ receiv complain juli complain inform offic ombudsman telephon satisfi friendli solut thank ombudsman intervent decis alleg failur inform complain due time renew contract complain claim inform due time renew contract alleg inform month expir date contract ombudsman deal complaint maladministr aris contractu relationship seek determin breach contract parti question dealt effect netherland court articl contract compet litig parti possibl hear argument parti relev nation law evalu conflict evid disput issu fact oblig inform due time appear expir date initi contract april march complain appear complain inform renew dai expir date contract month complain oblig inform due time appear instanc maladministr commiss friendli solut regard payment ecu month march complain work month march introduc request payment month amount ecu refus commiss represent comment commiss observ confus exact natur complain contractu right ombudsman request commiss prepar find friendli solut complain agre pai ecu complain activ month march complain inform ombudsman satisfi agreement reach ombudsman note fact agreement elimin instanc maladministr complain express satisfact agreement basi ombudsman inquiri point complaint appear maladministr commiss point complaint friendli solut agre institut complain ombudsman close case case close critic remark european ombudsman european parliament staff recognit occup diseas decis complaint st bb xd adb european parliament complaint complain emploi european parliament framework polici recruit disabl peopl claim suffer occup diseas due hard work carri parliamentari session strasbourg alleg superior gave task compat disabl introduc declar european parliament basi articl rule insur offici european commun risk accid occup diseas complain aim obtain recognit deterior health occup diseas european parliament start inquiri complain ask set medic committe articl rule mention european parliament reject request recognit occup diseas basi report made medic committe consid diseas result evolut complain previou health condit complain appeal decis european parliament reject request decid lodg complaint european ombudsman complain made alleg european parliament make object inquiri collect document relat case ii european parliament fail transmit document medic committe iii procedur characteris avoid delai iv superior misus power give complain task incompat disabl basi item complain want european parliament recognis occup charact diseas claim compens inquiri european parliament opinion european parliament point document forward complain transmit medic committe except document receiv parliament complain parliament recognis delai stage procedur explain delai complex case perman step complain undertook difficulti analys set medic document written german write detail mandat medic committe simultan manag file relat complain parliament enclos chronolog summari procedur opinion complain observ observ complain maintain complaint made comment document european parliament alleg receiv mention conclus medic committe stamp european parliament ii parliament conduct object administr inquiri transmit relev document medic committe complain drew conclus medic committe work proper basi reason vitiat iii inquiri parliament lack transpar conclus complain ask friendli solut decis lack object inquiri articl rule insur offici european commun risk accid occup diseas specifi quot administr hold inquiri order obtain particular determin natur diseas quot ombudsman note european parliament collect larg number document transmit complain permit write detail mandat medic committe consid clear evid inquiri made european parliament lack object aim prejud complain appear maladministr parliament relat aspect complaint failur transmit document medic committe care examin materi dispos ombudsman appear miss document mention parliament fact stamp institut ombudsman point good administr behaviour institut clear registr document receiv consid european parliament fail principl ombudsman examin complain alleg failur european parliament transmit document medic committe obstruct committe clear reason write report note miss document fact transmit medic committe mention committe report note member medic committe appoint complain held european court justic quot interest offici safeguard presenc medic committe member enjoi confid appoint member committe agreement member appoint parti quot basi element reason medic committe vitiat conclus report ombudsman consid ground friendli settlement matter avoid administr delai european parliament ombudsman carefulli analys chronolog summari fact argument put forward european parliament found evid maladministr relat aspect complaint misus power superior ombudsman point basi mandat deal alleg claim made year date fact attent complain conclus basi find ombudsman made critic remark good administr behaviour institut clear registr document receiv european parliament fail principl ombudsman consid ground pursu friendli settlement matter close case competit failur provid accur inform decis complaint af vk european parliament complaint letter date novemb januari mr complain ombudsman alleg european parliament wrongli refus admit written test competit pe organis parliament refus made ground complain submitt document prove good knowledg commun languag requir notic competit public competit offici journal european commun fell part gener provis applic open competit ii guidelin particip open competit organis parliament iii notic specif competit document guidelin provid head quot document quot quot applic provid document request exempt ag limit inform point educ point profession experi applic form quot guidelin document provid prove knowledg commun languag notic competit provid titl iii quot select board examin document establish list applic compli specif condit titl ii select board base decis inform applic form back accompani document quot condit titl ii notic fell part requir applic possess univers diploma equival profession experi requir applic possess good knowledg commun languag applic form contain head document request head quot educ quot quot profession experi quot head entitl quot knowledg languag quot divid categori mother tongu languag indic applic provid document inform head august mr inform admit test quot document submit requir good knowledg addit commun languag laid titl ii point announc select procedur pe quot mr appeal decis claim text offici journal european commun explicitli request document prove knowledg commun languag octob appeal reject ground select board base find applic annex document document submit prove good knowledg commun languag background mr complain ombudsman substanc put forward argument inform applic document confus mislead guidelin request document knowledg languag prevail notic competit select board conclud fulfil languag requir appear applic form work assist member european parliament obviou fulfil languag requir select board infring principl equal treatment applic applic similar situat admit appeal competit inquiri parliament opinion complaint forward european parliament opinion parliament claim decis exclud mr base word notic competit consid preced guidelin complain observ observ mr maintain complaint decis failur provid accur inform good administr behaviour provid accur inform condit elig post enabl applic judg appli support document import proceed enclos applic form guidelin particip document give proof point applic form quot educ quot quot profession experi quot notic competit stipul applic hand copi diploma work refer quot document quot prove inform applic form inform guidelin notic appear contradictori requir document prejudic legal text appear clear text serv function properli inform applic competit differ parliament fail provid complain clear accur inform fact consid knowledg languag support evid ensur applic instruct requir competit work experi proof languag qualif consid multilingu environ place work posit assist european parliament fact work proof suffici knowledg commun languag equal treatment candid select board support alleg mr put forward candid reject reason admit procedur appeal argu strict interpret word notic competit automat lead assumpt document prove knowledg commun languag requir lack indic ident person ombudsman matter conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark good administr behaviour provid accur inform condit elig post enabl applic judg appli support document import proceed enclos applic form guidelin particip document give proof point applic form quot educ quot quot profession experi quot notic competit stipul applic provid copi diploma work refer quot document quot prove inform applic form inform guidelin notic appear contradictori requir document prejudic legal text appear clear text serv function properli inform applic competit differ parliament fail provid complain clear accur inform fact consid knowledg languag support evid ensur applic instruct requir competit aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case council european union council decis ec mean quot repeat applic quot quot larg document quot decis complaint statewatch uk ijh council complaint februari mr wrote council request copi minut meet quot quot committe council justic home affair minist applic made council decis public access council document decis ec april gener secretariat council repli applic repli refer articl decis ec read quot relev depart gener secretariat endeavour find fair solut deal repeat applic relat larg document quot repli state request quot repeat applic relat larg number document quot quot fair solut quot gener secretariat provid document request mr made confirmatori applic document presid council upheld origin decis complaint ombudsman mr claim council entitl reli articl decis ec reason reject part applic document appli document question view term quot repeat applic quot refer situat person appli document ii articl refer quot larg document quot quot larg number document quot mention repli gener secretariat februari council introduc system charg document suppli mr suggest size number document request irrelev inquiri council opinion council opinion includ summari point complain systemat techniqu obtain access council jha document techniqu consist initi request agenda council bodi deal jha matter subsequ request document includ agenda articl interpret practic effect person continu request access document refus circumst motiv refus remain unchang gener secretariat oblig find fair solut adopt ident solut withhold document restrict concept quot repeat applic quot applic refer document divest articl practic effect council view concept quot repeat applic quot includ case person regularli systemat request long period time access larg number document type necessarili ident context number document request criteria consider shown word articl decis ec volum document request separ criterion justifi applic fair solut request repeat french version articl form basi translat languag version refer quot demand répétitiv quot term neg pejor connot council view articl decis ec aim safeguard effici administr except case appli limit extent date charg fee suppli document base articl decis ec affect rule principl provid articl complain observ observ mr criticis council opinion detail maintain view council entitl reli articl decis ec reason reject part applic document decis decis ec decis ec implement principl laid joint code conduct access council commiss document object decis give effect principl largest access citizen inform view strengthen democrat charact institut trust public administr procedur council deal applic access document laid articl decis ec stage procedur foreseen stage applic dealt gener secretariat secretari gener repli applic case neg repli applic opportun initi stage make confirmatori applic confirmatori applic reject repli applic council disput provis articl articl decis ec quot relev depart gener secretariat endeavour find fair solut deal repeat applic relat larg document quot refer gener secretariat possibl fair solut envisag stage initi applic case provis code conduct forese fair solut found quot consult applic quot articl provis code conduct expressli except gener rule public access reason reject part applic access document case council cite articl reason reject complain confirmatori applic document gener secretariat fail provid complain contest council interpret term quot repeat applic quot claim gener secretariat repli initi applic wrong articl appli applic larg number document council opinion ombudsman quot concept repeat applic refer inter alia case person regularli systemat request long period time access larg number document type necessarili ident quot council opinion claim quot volum document request separ criterion justifi applic fair solut request repeat quot appear issu disput complain council interpret term quot repeat applic quot quot larg document quot articl decis ec term defin decis code conduct mean term quot repeat applic quot quot larg document quot extent articl lawfulli council reason reject part applic access document provis oper except gener rule contain decis ec case law court instanc gener principl establish except principl laid except constru appli strictli manner defeat applic gener rule decis ec confer citizen right access document held council person entitl access council document oblig put forward reason request access document legitim block council neg attitud purpos request made person made term quot repeat applic quot appear natur refer applic document interpret practic effect articl includ possibl fair solut council servic deal effici case person make repeat applic document hope claim circumst motiv previou refus chang extend mean quot repeat applic quot includ applic person document defeat applic gener rule decis ec impos limit number document citizen appli absenc limit council interpret infring principl legal certainti advanc document request council applic quot repeat applic quot interpret articl bring applic larg number document scope lead practic result interpret quot repeat applic quot includ applic person document similar argument interpret appli ombudsman consid council wrongli interpret articl decis ec entitl reli articl reason reject part complain applic document case term quot repeat applic quot articl includ applic person document articl interpret bring applic larg number document scope recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark ombudsman consid council wrongli interpret articl decis ec entitl reli articl reason reject part complain applic document case term quot repeat applic quot articl includ applic person document articl interpret bring applic larg number document scope recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic articl council decis ec expressli applic confirmatori applic access document reject inform possibl complaint ombudsman ombudsman critic remark impli council reconsid complain confirmatori applic date april give access document request except contain articl decis ec appli council carri reconsider commun result complain ombudsman close case remark council opinion case refer introduct system charg fee document suppli council decis ec ombudsman agre council view system charg legal irrelev interpret articl decis ec council opinion express legitim concern safeguard effici administr context ombudsman note member state long experi administ public access document reli system charg safeguard deal request document impos heavi administr burden council public access document decis complaint statewatch uk ijh council complaint juli mr wrote gener secretariat council request copi calendar meet council steer group work parti field justic home affair period irish presid juli decemb request made council decis public access council document quot decis ec quot letter date juli gener secretariat council reject request letter refer articl decis ec read quot request document written natur legal person member state commun institut bodi nation intern bodi applic council direct author quot letter state respons calendar meet li presid council gener secretariat mr irish presid directli august wrote irish perman represent european union request calendar meet request refus ground quot propos make publicli inform question quot mr claim gener secretariat wrong refus request refer articl decis ec presid quot commun institut bodi quot function offic council inquiri council opinion complaint forward council council opinion complaint includ quot case gener secretariat consid detail timet inform tool organis council proceed constantli updat presid systemat distribut file secretariat date meet schedul timet provision formalis conven meet offici telex gener secretariat unabl determin precis version timet meet possess final version document ask mr address directli presid provid precis inform current state plan light mr argument secretari gener reconsid practic interpret articl decis ec regard request access document kind quot repli request ombudsman inform council confirm chang practic gener secretariat grant access calendar circul luxembourg presid state intent follow polici similar case futur council made clear calendar offici bind charact subject modif term presid offici convoc meet mean telex set date agenda complain observ observ mr made summari point council respons clarifi council suppli copi timet justic home affair meet held presid element complaint satisfi ii council fail respond claim presid quot commun institut bodi quot mean articl decis ec iii council continu refus access document ground mr refer agenda quot senior level group quot quot eu task forc quot confirmatori applic access document date juli refus council ground agenda question establish jointli presid commiss unit state author articl decis ec appli agenda question prepar sole respons council presid inquiri care consider council opinion complain observ appear inquiri firstli order clarifi council posit statu presid mean articl decis public access document complain observ rais issu refus confirmatori applic juli access agenda quot senior level group quot quot eu task forc quot council respons respons ombudsman request inform matter council state presid quot institut quot separ council mean articl decis ec council state distinct drawn quot document written member state hold presid capac presid council document written member state relat role presid council quot council express view articl decis ec applic categori document agenda quot senior level group quot quot eu task forc quot council state quot neg respons mr request date juli motiv fact presid contribut establish document consid institut mean articl decis ec case agenda question prepar sole respons presid jointli presid commiss unit state author quot complain complementari observ observ council respons mr state pleas council longer consid presid institut separ council made summari point document written member state put formal agenda justic home affair council subsequ agre adopt part justic home affair quot acqui quot open applic decis ec document subsequ agre adopt form part process make implement polici open applic ii council reason refus access agenda senior level group eu task forc unaccept european citizen appli council decis ec access document council presid joint author decis access calendar council meet origin complaint concern refus access calendar council meet plan ireland presid juli decemb ombudsman inquiri establish council chang practic grant access calendar circul luxembourg presid council state intent follow polici similar case futur complain declar satisfi respons council step settl aspect complaint satisfi complain statu presid council refus complain request access calendar council meet refer articl council decis ec public access council document complain claim council reason wrong presid quot institut bodi quot mean articl ombudsman inquiri council expressli state presid quot institut quot mean articl decis ec complain state pleas respons council step settl aspect complaint satisfi complain respons ombudsman request inform council drew distinct document written member state capac presid council document written member state complain made observ statu document written member state formal agenda justic home affair meet council distinct complain observ refer hypothet case document subject complaint ombudsman posit matter decis refus access document council joint author complain applic date juli access agenda senior level group eu task forc reject council ground agenda question establish jointli council presid commiss unit state author articl decis ec appli agenda question prepar sole respons council presid object decis ec give effect principl largest access citizen inform view strengthen democrat charact institut trust public administr articl present form except gener rule public access practic function except consequ incom document complet exclud rang applic gener rule includ document council joint author scope articl consider broaden scope de facto except case law court instanc gener principl establish except principl laid except constru appli strictli manner defeat applic gener rule express word articl abovement case law support council posit document joint author fall scope articl appear council reject complain applic access agenda senior level group eu task forc base misappl decis ec recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic conclus council step settl aspect complaint dealt part decis satisfi complain aspect case dealt part decis appear make critic remark express word articl case law court instanc support council posit document joint author fall scope articl appear council reject complain applic access agenda senior level group eu task forc base misappl decis ec recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic articl council decis ec expressli applic confirmatori applic access document reject inform possibl complaint ombudsman ombudsman critic remark impli council reconsid complain confirmatori applic date juli give access document request except contain articl decis ec appli council carri reconsider commun result thereof complain ombudsman close case refus access document inadequ reason decis complaint statewatch uk ijh council complaint februari mr wrote council request copi report consid meet council justic home affair held march report consid meet committe held march applic made council decis public access council document decis ec gener secretariat council gave access document request refus access complain made confirmatori applic document access refus presid council repli grant access document confirm refus access document complaint ombudsman concern document access refus repli confirmatori applic council explain refus access document quot regard document cor sn consider request involv balanc interest gain access document interest council maintain confidenti deliber council conclud interest outweigh case document question record detail nation posit regard convent recent establish legal instrument discuss recent adopt intern inform procedur recruit staff institut choic consult jha field document work document intern organis purpos protect classifi inform opinion council legal servic exclus council deliber bind regard document relev consider articl council decis ec protect public interest public secur doc sn add protect public interest intern relat doc natur inform contain document regard fight organis crime european union led council conclus access document allow quot complaint ombudsman council reason quot inadequ specif complain mention term quot recent establish quot quot recent adopt quot basi decis ec inquiri council opinion summari council claim opinion respect oblig give reason refus access document question accord principl laid establish case law quot access identifi set document refus protect confidenti council proceed pursuant articl decis ec access identifi set document refus reason public interest public secur intern relat pursuant articl decis ec regard document access refus pursuant articl decis ec letter adduc suffici imper reason justifi applic except ground protect public interest regard document access refus pursuant articl decis ec note council refus access document ground recent establish mr claim complaint justif refus access document resid fact detail nation posit council interest protect confidenti proceed outweigh mr interest obtain access document quot complain observ complain observ council opinion accept access document properli refus maintain complaint relat document sn ask ombudsman examin refus access document justifi decis complain claim complain claim council reason refus access document subject confirmatori applic date april inadequ observ complain accept refus access document maintain claim relat legal principl articl decis ec categori except principl gener access citizen council document articl access council document grant disclosur undermin protect public interest public secur intern relat monetari stabil court proceed inspect investig order demonstr disclosur document undermin protect public interest council oblig respect request document light inform disclosur fact undermin facet public interest protect case council oblig refus access document question articl council refus access order protect confidenti proceed council exercis margin discret enjoi appli articl strike genuin balanc hand interest citizen obtain access document interest maintain confidenti deliber establish case law statement reason decis refus access document categori document concern reason council consid disclosur request document scope except provid decis ec refus access articl access document disput refus articl repli confirmatori applic council explain quot natur inform contain document regard fight organis crime european union led council conclus access document allow quot court instanc concept public secur encompass situat public access document obstruct attempt author prevent crimin activ council refer fight organis crime relev facet public interest protect articl repli complain confirmatori applic council mention quot fight organis crime quot provid explan refer quot natur inform quot contain document ombudsman consid council fail compli requir provid complain reason led disclosur document scope articl refus access articl repli confirmatori applic council refer factor justifi refus access document articl opinion ombudsman council state quot justif refus access document resid fact detail nation posit council interest protect confidenti proceed outweigh mr interest obtain access document quot council justif refus access document articl word quot quot impli access refus document detail nation posit insignific proport document element constitut content document ombudsman reason confirm council compli oblig strike genuin balanc interest involv conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark repli complain confirmatori applic council mention fight organis crime provid explan refer natur inform contain document ombudsman consid council fail compli requir provid complain reason led disclosur request document scope articl council justif refus access document articl word quot quot impli access refus document detail nation posit insignific proport document element constitut content document ombudsman reason confirm council compli oblig strike genuin balanc interest involv relat critic remark recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic articl council decis ec expressli applic confirmatori applic access document reject inform possibl complaint ombudsman ombudsman critic remark impli council reconsid complain confirmatori applic date april give access document request except contain articl decis ec appli council carri reconsider commun result complain ombudsman close case open competit failur provid inform mean appeal decis complaint jma council european union complaint januari mr complain ombudsman decis select board open competit council reject applic select board justifi decis ground complain forward documentari evid knowledg commun languag letter select board notic competit potenti mean appeal board decis complaint ombudsman mr claim citizen contest decis commun public administr claim exercis receiv proper inform council inquiri council opinion complaint forward council council opinion point complain previous complaint institut seek redress ombudsman alleg lack mean contest decis select board council refer number option complain appeal court instanc articl staff regul month notif board decis make previou appeal articl altern submit complaint articl staff regul month notif board decis candid applic reject lodg complaint council secretari gener order ensur proper consider appeal written test competit schedul april month select board decis admiss written test council state relev case law court justic order overburden organis competit high number candid gener secretariat oblig draw attent candid candidatur reject exist mean appeal council ad recent competit order give candid inform mean appeal gener secretariat expressli includ provis notic open competit inform reject applic request examin applic select board period complain observ observ complain inform council right appeal applic court instanc requir previou appeal select board fact candid contest decis select board justifi failur board inform right appeal relev formal complain refer regul similar situat spanish law explain accord spanish law administr procedur public administr concern oblig inform recipi decis mean appeal essenti requir valid administr act decis admiss case scheme establish treati statut ombudsman admiss complaint determin ombudsman accord commun law commun institut bodi natur make view subject ombudsman order admiss complaint preced administr approach institut bodi concern articl statut view linguist version text take account purpos provis ombudsman evalu suitabl administr approach made depend circumst specif case case involv decis select board open competit complain directli appeal court instanc ombudsman consid criteria admiss complaint met requir inform complain view complain contest neg decis select board exercis inform exist mean exercis council argu inform candid mean appeal organis competit larg number candid overburden evalu decis select board due consider ensur orderli develop competit competit larg number candid court justic account factor defin duti select board give reason reject candid establish case law court state accept competit larg number candid select board initi send reject candid inform criteria select result thereof give individu explan organis open competit necessarili disrupt unduli overburden fact select board gener inform mean potenti appeal reject candid standard form adequ inform right vest commun law citizen mean protect basic condit proper exercis right ultim respect order follow principl good administr council ensur deal citizen properli inform right oblig case council take initi invit individu applic open competit aim recruit civil servant european ombudsman note polici adopt council recent competit notic competit publish offici journal european commun includ provis state reject candid request short period time select board examin applic view chang polici council ground ombudsman pursu aspect case failur provid accur inform notic competit select board base reject complain applic ground provid evid knowledg commun languag specif condit admiss competit point notic competit document relat educ point profession experi point type skill point ag point aspect notic competit specif requir type accredit mean certif written evid good administr behaviour provid accur inform condit elig post inform enabl applic judg appli support document import proceed enclos applic form notic competit serv function properli inform applic competit requir condit fulfil present case notic competit explicitli state requir submit document certifi knowledg commun languag circumst complain expect forward document council fail provid complain clear accur inform fact knowledg commun languag support written evid conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark good administr behaviour provid accur inform condit elig post inform enabl applic judg appli support document import proceed enclos applic form notic competit serv function properli inform applic competit requir condit fulfil case notic competit explicitli state requir submit document certifi knowledg commun languag circumst complain expect forward document council fail provid complain clear accur inform fact knowledg commun languag support written evid aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case access document decis complaint pd council complaint juli mr made complaint ombudsman council letter februari council complain request copi agenda council committe document council reject part complain applic reli rule decis ec public access council document agenda council inform complain decid provid copi agenda cover period month half year request complain decis reach basi articl decis ec council find quot fair solut quot deal repeat applic relat larg document complain contest legal decis argu articl appli larg number document applic respect separ document quot larg quot complain separ agenda longer page document council refus access quot schoolchildren quot document compil member state repli questionnair applic joint action quot travel facil eu schoolchildren countri nation quot quot cirea quot draft report detail inform cirea activ quot asylum quot consist document detail answer member state questionnair asylum principl practic quot racism quot note racist crime council work group terror refus access council commun statement reason complain concern quot schoolchildren quot council state quot document note gener secretariat compil repli member state questionnair implement aforement joint action compil examin relev work parti report mention joint action drawn balanc interest gain access document interest council maintain confidenti deliber council conclud interest outweigh case accord articl decis disclosur document stage hamper schedul discuss matter neg effect function exchang inform futur quot quot cirea quot council state quot balanc interest gain access document interest council maintain confidenti proceed council conclud interest outweigh accord articl decis ec document detail inform function cirea examin approv council council consid disclosur document stage hamper plan discuss matter quot asylum racism council state disclosur document undermin protect public interest articl decis ec complaint ombudsman complain claim reason inadequ separ alleg claim repli initi applic document council fail balanc interest citizen open council interest impos confidenti complain submit decis ec balanc requir case law commun court place repli initi applic access document repli confirmatori applic submit initi reject final complain claim council failur set document regist amount maladministr decis ec impos oblig respect lack document regist made complain opinion exception difficult applic intern document exist inquiri council opinion complaint forward council articl decis ec council opinion made remark articl decis ec aim safeguard effici institut administr except case accord gener rule legal interpret articl interpret context practic effect light applic fair solut articl deal repeat applic confin refer ident document concept quot repeat applic quot refer inter alia case person regularli systemat request long period time access larg number document type necessarili ident context number document request criteria account concern document access refus council contest statement reason quot inadequ concern made articl council state note argument put forward complain consid correct appli except articl refus access quot asylum quot quot racism quot alleg failur balanc interest repli complain initi applic council state requir fact observ consid repli complain respect made clear relev except reli ground council conced explicitli state balanc carri futur case make initi statement ground state balanc interest fact place lack central document regist council document council inform ombudsman set regist examin difficulti overcom concern ensur regist reliabl exhaust complain observ complain maintain complaint substanc decis object council decis ec give effect largest access citizen inform view strengthen democrat charact institut trust public administr concern articl issu rais complaint ident complaint statewatch uk ijh council reader refer decis ombudsman date juli relat complaint concern statement reason establish case law statement reason decis refus access document reason council consid disclosur request document scope except provid decis ec concern document quot schoolchildren quot quot cirea quot access refus basi articl council refus access order protect interest confidenti proceed council statement reason base consider document relat subject matter discuss council futur exchang inform council member state harm disclosur ombudsman observ public access regim commonli consid import disclosur document relat ongo discuss hamper discuss council public access regim attain object strengthen democrat charact public trust institut consider appli prudenc statement council refer broad consider relev relat document question council statement reason enabl ombudsman ascertain correctli appli articl ombudsman find complain rightli alleg council reason inadequ concern document quot asylum quot quot racism quot council state opinion relianc articl incorrect articl appli council reconsid refus access articl light ombudsman find concern oblig balanc interest articl repli initi applic document ombudsman note council acknowledg balanc relev interest initi stage public access applic reli articl council recognis duti make clear initi statement reason balanc fact carri ombudsman justifi inquir grievanc concern council regist document appear council set regist document ombudsman justifi inquir grievanc conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark ombudsman consid council wrongli interpret articl decis ec entitl reli articl reason reject part complain applic document case term quot repeat applic quot articl includ applic person document articl interpret bring applic larg number document scope recal highest author mean interpret commun law court justic refus access quot schoolchildren quot quot cirea quot articl decis ec council refer broad consider disclosur document hamper discuss subject matter document broad reason enabl ombudsman ascertain council correctli appli articl ombudsman consid council fail compli requir provid complain reason led disclosur hamper proceed articl council decis ec expressli applic confirmatori applic access document reject inform possibl complaint ombudsman ombudsman critic remark impli council reconsid complain confirmatori applic give access document request except contain articl decis ec appli council carri reconsider commun result complain ombudsman close case european commiss itoiz dam commiss inabl give adequ reason infring decis complaint xp es pd european commiss complaint march greenpeac españa associ cordinadora de itoiz made complaint ombudsman commiss correspond mr design repres complain complaint put forward commiss fail ensur spanish author decis build water reservoir itoiz navarr conform direct eec direct eec complaint concern commiss deal complaint mr made commiss matter commiss assess complaint spanish minist public work approv construct water reservoir itoiz navarr appear project larg inund entail water storag capac hm complain consid procedur led approv construct plan spanish author compli council direct eec june assess effect public privat project environ associ consid project infring council direct eec april protect wild bird relat direct complain consid spanish author made proper environment assess relat direct associ put forward direct eec aim protect wild bird articl member state establish special protect area articl quot respect protect area refer paragraph member state step avoid pollut deterior habitat disturb affect bird signific regard object articl protect area member state strive avoid pollut deterior habitat quot complain associ consid spanish author violat provis interpret case law court justic court judgment februari case commiss germani judgment court rule possibl reduc special protect area articl direct word court quot interpret articl direct born ninth recit preambl underlin special import direct attach special conserv measur habitat bird list annex order ensur surviv reproduct area distribut power reduc extent special protect area justifi except ground ground correspond gener interest superior gener interest repres ecolog object direct context interest refer articl direct econom recreat requir enter consider quot associ reservoir reduc special protect area spanish author build reservoir econom reason consid construct reservoir contrari case law court background associ number municip affect construct reservoir lodg complaint european commiss duti articl ec treati ensur complianc commun law complain produc consider document commiss support view letter decemb commiss inform complain decis complaint letter read quot dear sir inform commiss decid meet novemb close complaint made project reservoir itoiz complaint regist offici complaint regist commiss number enclos spanish version press releas commiss deem publish explain decis close case observ document provid compet author commiss servic establish infring environment commun law prove base exist knowledg project signific impact environ mean direct eec conserv natur habitat wild fauna flora situat commiss decid close case interest bodi repres navarr municip vall de lónguida aoiz vall de artz oroz beztelu junta gener del vall de aezcoa coordinadora de itoiz shown conserv protect environ faithfulli quot press releas refer state concer commiss reason close case quot commiss discontinu procedur infring legisl wild bird navarr region spain commiss interven complaint assert project affect area sierra de artxuba zariquieta mont de areta initi protect council direct eec conserv wild bird part commiss look complaint basi council direct eec conserv natur habitat wild fauna flora effect june replac initi provis direct commiss investig matter spirit dialogu partnership spanish author hand complain ecolog group depart commiss look studi impact project visit area affect interest parti opportun express view hear madrid octob investig enabl effect dam environ ascertain establish effect signific mean direct evid infring commun law commiss close matter quot take account effort made consider document provid commiss associ found decis unsatisfactori consid commiss fail address grievanc concern direct eec eec commiss referr direct eec faulti direct enter forc time project background complain lodg complaint ombudsman attach complaint consider document report establish spanish societi ornithologist conclud itoiz project affect bird life area concern inquiri commiss opinion concern commiss deal complaint commiss state summari complaint lodg juli acknowledg receipt septemb time commiss request inform complain novemb commiss request inform spanish author absenc answer spanish author commiss remind februari spanish author answer request case discuss depth meet held madrid march repres commiss spanish author discuss complementari inform commiss spanish author april case discuss polit level luxembourg june commission mr paleokrassa spanish minist mr borrel spanish secretari state mr narbona presid govern navarr mr alli meet spanish author stress public interest project offer compens articl direct eec conserv natur habitat wild fauna flora site visit itoiz repres servic commiss place june conclus visit commiss repres request inform document spanish local central author specif request justif overrid public interest project analys altern site locat consid decis build itoiz reservoir inform irrig project formal promis project subject full impact assess procedur debat open relev interest parti compens area discuss juli spanish author present set document hydrolog navarr timet submiss rest inform request juli commission mr paleokrassa ask minist mr borrel postpon execut perman work itoiz matter settl request accept minist letter august standstil situat continu file close novemb septemb spanish author submit full set document overrid public interest project altern examin effect project wild bird octob spanish author submit document compens offer direct eec octob commiss initi spanish author organis hear itoiz project madrid relev interest parti allow particip activ defend reason favour project tv press media cover event complain associ quot coordinadora de itoiz quot repres present particip debat hear commiss servic establish final report concern complain alleg infring direct eec commiss state environment impact assess carri spanish author concern alleg relat direct eec commiss state examin complaint point view articl direct oblig impos member state provis replac june provis direct eec articl direct eec member state step avoid special area conserv deterior natur habitat habitat speci disturb speci area design disturb signific articl state assess project directli link manag area signific impact thereon individu combin plan project articl state spite neg assess project carri imper reason overrid public interest includ social econom natur member state concern compensatori measur ensur protect coher ecolog network special area conserv set articl direct call quot natura quot basi provis commiss found inund special area concern itoiz project assess neg technic report made commiss servic hard determin regard quot signific quot mean direct eec commiss decid open infring procedur spain complain observ observ complain put forward commiss provid adequ explan commiss found spain properli compli oblig direct eec eec complain commiss entitl assess project light direct eec direct forc project begun view clear project contrari direct eec establish reduct special protect area occur ground quot correspond gener interest superior gener interest repres ecolog object direct quot court rule abovement leybucht case observ complain annex document show commiss servic moment consid project contrari direct eec inquiri consider commiss opinion complain observ ombudsman address commiss letter ombudsman ask commiss provid detail explan find spanish author compli oblig direct eec eec opinion commiss state substanc concern direct eec spanish ministri public work approv irrig project call quot canal navarr quot decemb project itoiz reservoir approv implement itoiz project approv project modifi date account result public consult assess water circumst difficult justifi direct eec implement juli appli case judgment court justic quot grosskrotzenburg quot case impact assess procedur itoiz project launch finish public consult period final decis implement project preliminari work start commiss view impact assess made evid provid prove impact project environ includ protect bird adequ assess concern direct eec commiss servic consid begin investig effect itoiz project bird habitat signific contrari articl direct conclus chang servic assess inform receiv spanish author addit inform collect hear held madrid case subsequ assess light direct eec provis direct replac articl direct eec june observ commiss opinion complain maintain complaint decis complaint rais question commiss deal complain origin complaint commiss adequ concern commiss examin origin complaint appear basi commiss account document forward complain element effect instruct faulti concern reason commiss conclus appear princip point disput remain commiss complain commiss adequ reason relat complain grievanc itoiz project contrari direct eec infring remedi direct eec forc relev moment principl good administr requir administr adequ reason citizen decis take repli initi inquiri european ombudsman made commiss administr procedur deal complaint member state infring commun law commiss undertook provid complain statement reason conclud infring occur case appear complain persist put forward itoiz project contrari direct eec infring remedi direct eec forc relev moment appear commiss fail address grievanc origin decis insuffici reason decis commiss undertak case pd refer commiss fail properli address grievanc opinion present complaint appear commiss unabl give adequ reason establish instanc maladministr conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir commiss give adequ reason decis take citizen case appear complain persist put forward itoiz project contrari direct eec infring remedi direct eec forc relev moment appear commiss fail address grievanc origin decis insuffici reason decis commiss undertook provid complain statement reason conclud infring occur commiss fail properli address grievanc opinion present complaint appear commiss unabl give adequ reason establish instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case note ombudsman decis report spanish press commiss decid reopen investig itoiz dam disput research contract decis complaint cp uk ijh european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman research contract compani lw limit lwl partner compani portugues greek commiss complaint dg vi commiss deliber set destroi project spread fals inform ii wrongli withheld final payment due contract iii unfair account treatment cost reduc amount final payment due inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state contract commiss pai half elig expenditur maximum ecu lwl respons submiss document commiss behalf contractor opinion continu quot final balanc due paid month date approv consolid cost statement technic report document deliver requir contract articl annex ii contract remain forc submiss inform requir commiss accord contract articl annex ii payment commiss whichev date period year expiri contract commiss entitl audit purpos access relev book keep materi requir submiss documentari evid articl annex ii term articl gener condit set annex ii contract coordin partner discharg oblig commiss made comment draft report month receiv articl annex ii contract oblig commiss make payment deadlin articl part annex ii concern implement work appli contractor oblig respect technic perform work connect commiss staff conclud reason question conform work object project quot commiss opinion includ summari point payment made lwl instruct pass correct amount partner ii basi statement elig expenditur submit remain balanc ecu paid ow lwl iii lwl inform commiss august tenerif author decid project structur illeg iv portugues partner inform commiss august receiv lwl sum ecu respect year work portugues partner mention differ scientif opinion lwl technic alter project consid major commiss organis meet novemb partner confirm lwl continu role scientif coordin project vi commiss independ expert report receiv expert opinion juli commiss accept scientif report submit project vii novemb lwl commiss financi report statement expenditur year project project period commiss made request addit inform correct version consolid expenditur statement mid date consolid report portugues greek partner commiss viii view point iii iv commiss decid project henceforth consid quot doubt quot project warrant closer scrutini commiss prudent stanc decid make payment ix spot audit control place headquart lwl juli lwl unabl produc adequ document wageslip prove expenditur personnel commiss invit portugues partner lwl meet juli clarifi situat portugues partner unabl attend meet commiss repeatedli request lwl suppli miss documentari financi evid lwl posit articl contract meant discharg oblig contract insist commiss make final payment xi commiss anti fraud unit uclaf begun investig lwl suppli bookkeep evid support expenditur claim complain observ observ includ summari point period progress report final report requir contract submit lwl due time commiss submit observ report notifi longer period submit observ accord articl contract commiss deem approv report lwl discharg oblig contract accord articl ii year consolid financi report submit commiss novemb decemb fax letter commiss date april request specif correct made consolid cost statement state commiss examin approv financi report payment follow scientif report approv iii commiss breach contract fail make final payment due articl contract month deem approv iv time commiss sought clarif progress report clarif suppli acknowledg commiss commiss refus explan advic lwl make possibl provid contract transfer cost categori commiss refus accept propos lwl cost origin estim head quot durabl equip quot treat quot consum equip quot reflect true natur cost written project vi end year project clear portugues partner intent carri respons lwl inform commiss oral oral advis primari respons quot deliv result quot accord articl contract contractor quot discharg respons default contractor quot vii meet novemb commiss opinion point agre partner henceforth send report directli commiss remain payment made partner directli commiss pass lwl intermediari viii commiss descript audit juli grossli misrepres event auditor identifi minor item consid inelig case lwl consid item elig sought clarif commiss juli repli receiv item invoic guarante dai deliveri sign contract commiss brussel inelig invoic date dai begin contract ix auditor ask daili time sheet personnel work project sign certifi monthli project manag practic record small team work countri time work diari produc contain daili record individu attend detail meet juli attend commiss offici mr question rais commiss handl contract answer inquiri examin file ombudsman consid conduct inquiri wrote commiss inform reason commiss refus accept propos made lwl cost treat allow contract reason commun lwl legal basi commiss posit progress made financi aspect dossier inform suppli complain contractor connect ombudsman refer commiss letter complain date april inquiri uclaf complet outcom commiss repli repli question commiss refer request document lwl question state reason commun mr audit meet held brussel juli repli question commiss state consolid cost statement portugues partner document requir articl contract receiv novemb basi articl payment made latest januari case request commiss inform made juli outstand commiss ask mr show evid amount alleg transfer partner fail commiss refer quot prudent stanc quot mention point viii opinion repli question commiss state uclaf inquiri continu complain complementari observ summari mr note commiss fail answer question assert answer untru answer question mr claim document deliv separ instruct commiss meet novemb mr enclos copi bank transfer portugues partner copi commiss uclaf mr refer correspond forward ombudsman juli uclaf request suppli copi project financi administr record inform uclaf consid requir copi thousand document unreason lwl paid staff undertak work propos spot audit accord articl contract ombudsman attempt achiev friendli solut septemb ombudsman wrote commiss view seek friendli solut complaint ombudsman point basi evid file complain receiv repli claim uclaf requir suppli copi record unreason propos uclaf perform spot audit altern ombudsman suggest commiss modifi requir give reason insist copi document ombudsman letter drew attent fact commiss suppli ombudsman inform request reason elig cost ombudsman inquiri convinc commiss provid coher account believ view contractu posit justifi suggest depend outcom uclaf inquiri commiss revis stanc relat amount payment final balanc due contract repli novemb commiss inform ombudsman uclaf longer demand lwl suppli copi document spot inspect place mr inform relat contractu disput commiss repli state period payment commiss lwl letter includ financi tabl present expenditur claim elig expenditur explan differ commiss state legal basi paid final balanc commiss approv final cost statement lwl commiss letter forward complain contest point made commiss relat contractu disput insist commiss set destroi project inform interest parti technic econom failur appear friendli solut complaint achiev decis scope ombudsman inquiri decis uclaf investig attempt achiev friendli solut complaint ombudsman point commiss complain receiv repli claim uclaf requir suppli copi record unreason propos uclaf perform spot audit altern repli commiss inform ombudsman uclaf longer insist lwl suppli copi document spot inspect commiss appear dealt satisfactorili specif issu rais ombudsman contractu context complaint articl contract complaint aros contract govern law england wale ombudsmen nation level member state deal contractu disput gener characterist contract nation law law establish ombudsman mandat expressli exclud contractu matter state annual report part mission european ombudsman reliev burden litig promot friendli solut make recommend avoid proceed court european ombudsman deal complaint maladministr aris contractu relationship seek determin breach contract parti question dealt effect court compet jurisdict possibl hear argument parti relev nation law evalu conflict evid disput issu fact matter good administr public author engag contractu disput privat parti provid ombudsman coher account legal basi action believ view contractu posit justifi substant issu alleg dg vi deliber set destroi project complain alleg dg vi deliber set destroi project spread fals inform alleg expressli contradict commiss opinion explan classifi project quot doubt quot deni alleg substanc commiss opinion inform suppli portugues partner sought opinion independ expert receiv expert opinion juli commiss felt accept scientif report submit contract commiss state commiss staff conclud reason question conform work object project basi ombudsman inquiri appear evid subsequ independ expert report remov doubt scientif aspect project commiss offici made statement inconsist report ombudsman found maladministr commiss relat aspect complaint withhold final payment due contract lwl consist made clear commiss view discharg oblig contract commiss made final payment accord articl contract opinion repli ombudsman request inform commiss express view contractu posit respons ombudsman attempt achiev friendli solut commiss explain legal basi paid final balanc commiss approv final cost statement lwl reason withhold approv commiss state complain produc financi inform request juli view present stanc mislead commiss send letter complain date april request specif correct made consolid cost statement state payment follow scientif report approv letter understood impli approv consolid cost statement subject specif correct made account treatment cost reduc final payment due complain claim commiss refus explan advic transfer cost categori accord contract complain observ commiss opinion alleg commiss refus accept propos cost origin estim head quot durabl equip quot treat quot consum equip quot commiss repli ombudsman request inform reason elig cost commun complain audit meet held brussel juli complain specif deni claim observ commiss opinion contain account audit annex minut meet juli document forward commiss suppli evid rebutt attempt achiev friendli solut ombudsman drew attent fact commiss suppli ombudsman inform request reason elig cost respons commiss state period payment commiss lwl letter includ financi tabl present expenditur claim elig expenditur explan differ commiss annex respons copi letter complain commiss date juli march august financi tabl letter refer copi ombudsman effect commiss refus complain request transfer cost categori reduc proport total expenditur elig reduc commiss contribut total circumst commiss complain reason refus reason provid ombudsman request repeat request commiss provid reason ombudsman ombudsman conclud commiss fail suppli complain reason refus propos cost origin estim head quot durabl equip quot treat quot consum equip quot conclus basi ombudsman inquiri appear evid subsequ independ expert report remov doubt scientif aspect project commiss offici made statement inconsist report appear make critic remark view present stanc mislead commiss send letter complain date april request specif correct made consolid cost statement state payment follow scientif report approv letter understood impli approv consolid cost statement subject specif correct made effect commiss refus complain request transfer cost categori reduc proport total expenditur elig reduc commiss contribut total circumst commiss complain reason refus reason provid ombudsman request repeat request commiss provid reason ombudsman ombudsman conclud commiss fail suppli complain reason refus propos cost origin estim head quot durabl equip quot treat quot consum equip quot substant issu disput complain commiss concern contractu oblig ombudsman determin breach contract parti ombudsman make draft recommend case fact effort achiev friendli solut unsuccess ombudsman note contract question govern law england wale court justic sole jurisdict respect disput contract articl annex ii articl open parti bring issu disput commun judicatur ombudsman close case competit law alleg failur action repli correspond decis complaint elr uk ijh ov european commiss complaint mr complain juli european ombudsman alleg failur commiss director gener iv deal properli complaint alleg restrict competit sole agenc agreement german austrian model railwai manufactur complain wrote behalf retail model railwai toi establish north wale specialis suppli manufactur good origin sourc germani austria franc itali august complain wrote mr joe wilson mep forward complaint commiss dg iv alleg restrict competit german austrian model railwai manufactur sole agenc agreement complain german austrian manufactur appoint sole import distributor suppli unit kingdom market trade price unit kingdom dealer consider higher enjoi german counterpart commiss repli januari apolog delai basi content complain letter action competit law satisfi commiss repli complain wrote januari receiv similar repli februari wrote april octob answer novemb repli commiss ask complain provid detail inform alleg violat competit rule indic compani involv alleg improp competit activ complain final letter novemb march receiv repli letter novemb commiss request detail inform complain includ list name address german austrian manufactur practis sole agenc agreement complain receiv repli letter complain juli ombudsman commiss fail action complaint alleg restrict competit german austrian model railwai manufactur fail answer correspond inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss novemb summari commiss made comment alleg failur repli letter complain commiss observ recent repli letter annex observ copi repli date novemb answer complain alleg failur action violat competit rule commiss observ dg iv initi investig duli substanti complaint specif subject involv point commun law lodg commiss maintain circumst complain violat competit rule place identifi compani involv contain statement gener polit natur commiss ad complain submit formal complaint identifi infring competit rule deal accord procedur establish regul commiss observ reason dg iv provid assist complain complain fail provid detail led discov exist restrict agreement commiss state infring competit rule supplier fulli entitl emploi exclus distributor unit kingdom commiss comment absenc detail inform decis carri situ inspect systemat investig formal request inform manufactur wholesal model railwai commun justifi econom impact case complain admit small commiss drew attent fact attach complaint complain copi commiss notic septemb agreement minor import show awar commiss interven case final commiss observ case appear concern trade model railwai retail level effect trade member state event improb complain observ complain reject commiss statement ask full investig matter rais complaint declar fact gener observ observ exist altern sourc suppli monopoli creat repeat unit kingdom retail pai excess price oppos countri comment furnish proof restrict trade arrang break premis supplier manufactur obtain inform decis alleg failur action complaint complain commiss action complaint alleg restrict competit german austrian model railwai manufactur summari commiss observ complain furnish detail inform order enabl initi investig alleg failur commiss action competit law consid frame administr procedur commiss order bring light infring articl ec treati administr procedur regul council regul confer commiss wide power make investig obtain inform case law court justic commiss parti decid purpos investig articl regul inform enabl bring light infring competit rule court justic state evid proof exist infring commiss view request inform enabl defin accur scope infring determin durat identifi circl undertak involv fact commiss request inform complain present case reason excess appear maladministr european commiss decid unabl action basi inform provid complain alleg failur repli letter complain complain alleg commiss fail repli letter novemb march letter novemb complain provid commiss request detail inform list manufactur suppos sole agenc agreement complain receiv answer commiss march wrote letter ask courtesi repli letter date novemb commiss answer repli letter novemb principl good administr behaviour requir letter complain commiss administr receiv repli reason time limit requir letter complain inform compar previou letter correspond commiss action violat competit rule appear inform commiss letter novemb answer novemb year commiss repli correspond complain refer fact complaint point answer letter novemb reason time limit necess repli present case urgent complain commiss request detail inform final provid commiss detail form list german austrian manufactur suppos practic sole agenc agreement inform regard previou correspond complain consid answer commiss request detail addit argument complain entitl receiv reason answer commiss reason time limit fact commiss repli year complain letter novemb contain inform regard origin complaint constitut instanc maladministr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr behaviour requir letter complain commiss administr receiv repli reason time limit fact commiss repli year complain letter novemb contain inform regard origin complaint constitut instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman decid close case recognit certif dentistri member countri decis complaint lbr es kh jma european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman behalf quot colegio de odontólogo estomatólogo quot vizcaya complaint concern alleg failur commiss ensur spanish author correctli appli direct eec mutual recognit certif dentistri complaint mr alleg spain compli direct author recognis odontologist degre obtain latin american countri meet requir set direct receiv complaint situat commiss initi infring procedur articl ec treati letter formal notic spanish author octob reason opinion august spanish author repli reason opinion march mr complain commiss wrote visit servic respons occas order receiv inform develop articl proceed ask commiss speed process access inform relev file obtain copi exchang commiss spanish author commiss reject request file ground proceed confidenti contact letter complain commiss insist procedur commiss servic review document spanish author complain consid repli gener unsatisfactori inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion commiss initi infring procedur articl spain failur follow criteria set council direct eec eec recognit dental degre articl direct eec establish quot prejudic facil grant accord rule member state respect territori authoris holder diploma obtain member state pursu activ dental practition quot member state limit basic criteria laid direct met practition specialis dentistri commiss consid order recognis commun odontologist degre deliv member state guarante minimum criteria spite oblig spain automat recognis dental degre obtain latin american countri meet direct minimum criteria recognit degre base provis bilater intern agreement conclud spain access european commun spanish administr sought compli provis direct decis revers appeal administr court result provis relev direct respect commiss explain view fact spain process renegoti bilater agreement countri decid bring matter european court justic exercis discret recognis case law european court justic length time involv develop infring proceed articl commiss justifi basi complex legal polit point view receiv repli reason opinion commiss ask inform spanish author octob juli spanish author repli request decemb octob date opinion decemb commiss wait repli spanish author request inform alleg failur transpar proceed refus disclos correspond commiss spanish govern commiss insist letter document exchang member state context articl confidenti natur basi oblig share pass inform parti commiss stress handl proceed principl good administr servic repli time properli letter complain meet brussel complain observ observ mr made summari point commiss interpret direct eec eec view adequ made effort guarante proper applic direct spain accept commiss justif lengthi period time handl case consid commiss technic bodi primari task ensur proper applic commun law member state commiss possibl justifi long time elaps action basi polit reason ask ombudsman make inquiri verifi parti involv case act accord commun law april forward ombudsman copi letter receiv commiss letter inform decis adopt commiss decemb refer matter court justic ad case materi lodg commiss adopt decis view unsatisfactori repli spanish author commiss reason opinion inquiri european ombudsman wrote commiss request inform relat complaint ombudsman suggest commiss provid clear precis transpar inform content negoti commiss spanish author develop proceed place repli commiss confirm previou opinion inform ombudsman review inform submit spanish author june februari commiss inform ombudsman decid bring matter court justic commiss view spanish author tackl relev problem accord commun law spanish suprem court chang interpret exist nation rule order make conform requir direct eec eec commiss point fact ombudsman receiv complaint pd pd citizen obtain dental degre latin american countri obtain recognit dental degre spanish author proof chang situat commiss intend close infring proceed spain ceas parti intern agreement contrari commun law decis decis commiss bring case court justic articl treati commiss duti quot guardian treati quot ensur commun law appli role main legal instrument commiss compel complianc member state procedur set articl commiss consid member state fail fulfil commun oblig deliv reason opinion state concern compli opinion commiss bring matter court justic court justic repeatedli state commiss discretionari power appli court justic declar establish failur member state concern exercis discret normal practic public administr explain reason justifi choic action commiss choos pursu infring procedur reason support option reason provid basi potenti inquiri ombudsman order ensur maladministr place basi latest inform submit spanish author commiss decid bring matter european court justic decis prompt fact spanish author denounc intern treati recognit degre sign latin american countri posit spanish suprem court review reason commiss justifi posit ombudsman found institut act limit legal author instanc maladministr establish due dilig ensur complianc commun law context ombudsman initi inquiri commiss administr procedur relat citizen complaint pd commiss commit adopt decis complaint year registr note time observ rule appear adequ mean ensur complaint process undu delai gener aim frustrat complaint result open infring procedur linger year satisfactori solut problem ensur guardian treati member state fulli compli commun law commiss work accord principl good administr act due dilig impli commiss activ seek make member state concern put end infring inform complain action process compel spanish author compli direct eec formal action commiss undertaken octob dispatch letter formal notic decemb institut decid appli court justic suspend decis decemb view posit result negoti spain process review commiss year long period commiss reason opinion spanish author august request addit inform matter march juli octob juli april repli ombudsman commiss claim attitud activ relat complaint year elaps infring proceed begun request ombudsman fail provid clear precis transpar inform support claim demonstr act due dilig long period time request complain access document order clarifi evolut proceed complain request occas inform exchang commiss spanish author commiss repli request refus releas letter basi confidenti infring proceed commiss repli inquiri role guardian treati institut ensur atmospher mutual trust member state aim achiev confidenti charact contact institut member state concern request access document held commiss dealt accord commiss decis ecsc ec euratom effect code conduct adopt council commiss measur place legal oblig commiss give public widest access document held except access document interpret strictli order frustrat specif aim code conduct present case document concern admittedli relat open infring procedur articl present state commun law commiss possibl refus access document relat investig lead infring procedur head protect public interest refus access document ground constitut instanc maladministr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark ensur guardian treati member state fulli compli commun law commiss work accord principl good administr act due dilig impli commiss activ seek make member state concern put end infring inform complain action repli ombudsman case commiss claim attitud activ relat complaint year elaps send reason opinion request ombudsman fail provid clear precis transpar inform support claim demonstr act due dilig long period time aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case confidenti doctor patient relationship decis complaint gv vk european commiss complaint august complain ombudsman behaviour commiss offici traineeship translat servic commiss luxembourg complain award traineeship commiss begin traineeship fell ill forward medic certif commiss januari head servic telephon doctor itali issu certif inquir situat consid head servic behav incorrectli wrote letter complaint commiss receiv repli letter complaint ombudsman claim behaviour head servic concern incorrect substanc alleg head servic warn doctor issu unfound medic certif ii commiss repli letter inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss recognis head servic contact complain doctor januari order quot clarifi situat quot commiss intervent head servic pure limit question purpos attempt influenc doctor judgement remind medic certif requir justifi absenc commiss recognis head servic inform doctor complain accommod situat luxembourg commiss inform relev discuss doctor contain element defam commiss conclud time head servic behav accord normal practic profession ethic concern complain grievanc commiss opinion state repli letter draft due administr oversight complain observ observ complain maintain complaint decis claim head servic contact complain doctor rule govern servic train commiss make provis procedur follow case absenc due sick articl rule appear provid administr adequ safeguard interest traine ill dai prove medic certif incap produc evid administr disregard ill certif leav commiss unansw question specif procedur provid traine requir undergo medic examin recognis court justic confidenti relationship form patient seek treatment doctor import safeguard principl good administr requir commiss respect confidenti doctor patient relationship present case complain head servic contact directli complain permiss doctor issu medic certif complain precis natur inform sought provid complain situat obviou action risk damag confidenti doctor patient relationship commiss consid clarifi situat procedur expressli foreseen articl rule govern servic train failur repli complain letter commiss repli complain letter draft administr oversight commiss express regret oversight conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark recognis court justic confidenti relationship form patient seek treatment doctor import safeguard principl good administr requir commiss respect confidenti doctor patient relationship present case complain head servic contact directli complain permiss doctor issu medic certif complain precis natur inform sought provid complain situat obviou action risk damag confidenti doctor patient relationship commiss consid clarifi situat procedur expressli foreseen articl rule govern servic train commiss repli complain letter draft administr oversight commiss express regret oversight aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case reason reject candid decis complaint sh sw vk european commiss complaint august complain ombudsman exclus commiss open competit candid open competit base qualif oral test constitut reserv list medic advis grade austrian finnish swedish nation request provid commiss curriculum vita gave detail educ experi requir field letter inform candidatur reject select board standard letter reject mention altern lack medic qualif fail provid proof studi field occup medicin ett utbildningsbevi efter specialstudi arbetsmedicin letter june ask select board reconsid applic repli select board state suffici profession experi field tropic medicin radiat safeti complaint ombudsman claim qualif met requir open competit emphasis profession experi field radiat safeti account ii commiss reason reject applic receiv answer request reconsider case iii commiss faulti reason discrimin candid swedish medic qualif inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss summari commiss opinion made point select board examin complain applic form decid admit competit consid possess diploma occup health medicin quot decis notifi letter date board recognis letter absolut clear motiv decis quot ii request slection board examin complain applic conclus suffici experi compar candid tropic medicin radiat safeti quot board assur decis influenc time studi swedish educ system ensur qualifi candid invit interview quot complain observ observ complain claim commiss explan clear point commiss admit reason final express satisfact board assur decis influenc time studi swedish educ system decis select board reason competit organis constitut reserv list grade medic advis occup health commiss medic servic point iii notic competit requir candid holder higher univers degre medicin certif specialis occup health studi candid requir profession experi thing tropic medicin radiat safeti letter complain select board gave reason reject candidatur fact lack medic qualif fail provid proof studi field occup medicin ett utbildningsbevi efter specialstudi arbetsmedicin letter select board gave reason lack suffici experi compar candid tropic medicin radiat safeti field fundament principl good administr behaviour decis reason requir articl ec treati reason enabl affect parti measur comment ombudsman commiss recognis select board letter complain absolut clear motiv decis fact appear reason unclear wrong letter select board consid complain experi insuffici compar candid tropic medicin radiat safeti field articl staff regul european commun recruit direct secur institut servic offici highest standard abil effici appli criteria laid notic competit select board entitl make compar evalu candid order ensur suitabl candid chosen interview reason letter appear adequ enabl candid understand reason reject reason consist proper exercis judgement select board letter acknowledg reason letter wrong letter inadequ explain reason candid reject alleg discrimin candid swedish medic qualif opinion commiss state decis influenc time complain studi swedish educ system ensur qualifi candid invit interview observ complain express satisfact respons ombudsman inquiri reveal evid maladministr relat aspect complaint basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark fundament principl good administr behaviour decis reason requir articl ec treati reason enabl affect parti measur comment ombudsman commiss recognis select board letter complain quot absolut clear motiv decis quot fact appear reason unclear wrong reason letter appear adequ enabl candid understand reason reject reason consist proper exercis judgment select board letter acknowledg reason letter wrong letter inadequ explain reason candid reject aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli solut matter ombudsman close case modif grant research decis complaint tt pd ag pd european commiss complaint septemb grant holder associ complain ombudsman reduct grant member receiv commiss commis made reduct council european parliament adopt decis ec fourth framework programm european commun activ field research technolog develop demonstr euratom treati council adopt parallel decis decis euratom framework commun activ field research train european atom energi commun recit decis commun action framework programm object aim stimul promot train mobil research young research joint research centr commun contribut implement framework programm role joint research centr laid detail council decis ec adopt specif programm research technolog develop includ demonstr carri european commun hand joint research centr hand mean activ framework competit approach intend scientif technic support commun polici council decis euratom adopt specif programm research technolog develop includ demonstr implement joint research centr european atom energi commun appear recit decis joint research centr laboratori instal make effect contribut train mobil research act joint research centr enter contract research member state commun individu contract standard form fill individu element case entitl quot individu fellowship contract european commun quot annex gener condit applic attach contract document draft commiss servic standard form durat fellowship joint research centr year fellowship research receiv monthli grant commun contract concern case articl standard form provid quot commiss pai contractor durat fellowship monthli amount ecu sum modifi approv european commiss gener condit govern research train fellowship modif backdat quot articl standard form establish gener condit attach form integr part contract quot gener condit replac approv gener condit govern research train fellowship replac backdat quot juli commiss adopt decis establish standard contract form amount grant gener condit commiss decid decis appli exist contract quot claus decis effect august establish result decis current grant roughli grant holder suffer reduct letter august individu grant holder inform decis effect august letter draft french attach letter gener condit french unoffici translat english letter end individu grant holder contact commiss servic sign contract septemb summer holidai grant holder undertook consider activ consult lawyer contact commission commiss servic view make commiss refrain reduc current grant order seek clarif claus gener condit aspect contact appar fruitless background research assembl grant holder associ decid lodg complaint ombudsman complaint state decis complet upset basi individu grant holder enter research programm research famili state decis made materi difficult research continu stai joint research centr associ alleg substanc commiss inform grant holder advanc forthcom reduct grant make decis letter august address individu grant holder languag claus contract allow reduct grant illeg unfair ran spirit mobil programm inquiri commiss opinion concern associ grievanc commiss state administr joint research centr grant holder inform directli associ progress discuss grant amount commiss stress meet place juli ispra site joint research centr grant holder inform forthcom commiss decis concern letter august commiss recognis wrong send french version letter grant holder undertook repeat error futur undertook contract translat commun languag concern associ grievanc commiss state amount grant adopt sake coher uniform amount grant ident train research contract programm fourth framework programm establish quot decis commiss state amount determin close consult repres member state calcul ensur grant holder receiv net amount compar research equival level earn host countri decid amount appli current contract contain quot claus order grant holder ispra site grant holder sevil site joint research centr prepar substanti reduct grant commiss decid decemb suspend applic decis march date reduct current grant associ observ concern grievanc associ state local administr ispra site joint research centr power grant holder inform develop associ state local administr face lack inform commiss servic brussel case meet juli grant holder inform forthcom reduct grant concern grievanc associ state accept commiss apolog send french version letter august individu grant holder concern amount grant associ state question commiss entitl establish amount prepar accept consider underli amount aim purport amount amount compar research equival level earn countri associ strongli question amount appli run contract context underlin reduct grant run contract aim compens lower live cost lower tax case reduct grant impli net reduct grant commiss decis adopt refer possibl justifi circumst decis contrari impli net reduct grant run contract case reduct complet frustrat condit underli research take research programm suspens commiss adopt decemb decis associ welcom state research contract termin end suffer sever neg effect decis inquiri due consider commiss opinion associ observ ombudsman address commiss letter ombudsman state gener aim pursu establish grant amount appear understand commiss decis appli current grant ombudsman state research expect commiss make drastic quot contract claus reduct current grant made materi difficult number research continu work case threaten motiv final ombudsman state exclud futur research refrain join research scheme grant drastic reduc contract ombudsman conclud suggest commiss review posit light consider answer letter commiss state criticis ground high amount alloc grant holder fail fulli exist condit countri research carri commiss issu discuss relev programm committe take consider point rais deleg commiss decid amount commiss point amount intend provid coher equiti respect grant specif programm fourth framework programm fact appear complaint lodg ombudsman septemb complaint pd drastic reduct current grant research abandon research programm return home countri famili decis concern grievanc lack inform commun grant holder prior commiss decis firstli observ principl good administr requir administr deal citizen fair impli thing administr intend measur limit identifi number citizen administr establish suitabl contact citizen concern make voic opinion impli citizen inform due notic measur adequ step adapt chang situat case appear contact commiss servic respons grant holder meet juli grant holder simpli inform reduct grant commiss decis effect juli grant holder inform actual reduct decis impli letter august reduct effect proceed appear high hand arrog compli principl good administr concern letter august commiss acknowledg letter individu grant holder languag apologis ombudsman find ground pursu inquiri aspect complaint concern alleg claus allow drastic reduct grant place illeg observ question assess light applic nation law compet nation author ombudsman examin question administr account ombudsman observ principl good administr provid ombudsman coher account action believ justifi principl good administr requir thing commiss deal citizen fair case establish claus commiss insert standard contract allow reduct current grant limit give indic paramet underli reduct claus deem make take research traineeship precari make abus qualifi fair overrid reason resort claus commiss overrid reason background ombudsman found unfair contract claus commiss fail act accord principl good administr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir commiss deal citizen fair fail establish suitabl contact grant holder concern substanti reduct commiss envisag make grant fail inform due notic reduct commiss fail meet requir commiss fail meet requir unfair contract claus aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past grant holder concern end fellowship joint research centr pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case subsidi film festiv inadequ reason decis complaint kh european commiss complaint letter date decemb januari mr complain behalf sticht nederland film festiv nff commiss alleg incomprehens treatment commiss director gener xiii bad function shortag inform background complaint summaris nff organis dai scientif film receiv subsidi commiss appar nff commiss servic involv consid event success nff decis organis dai scientif film appli commiss subsidi subsidi obtain nff made applic subsidi dai scientif film commiss repli letter june june letter complain project natur receiv subsidi complain rearrang budget bring ecu limit rule relev commiss programm exceed applic form enclos letter letter contain addit applic form state document attach inform complain applic juli nff repli state quot receiv budget dai scientif film masterclass seminar kindli request ec financi support ecu particip ec repres event dg xiii quot letter septemb commiss repli state quot regret inform applic subsidi reject apologis troubl decis final report event present commiss form request contract violat contractu oblig quot meet place respons commiss servic nff septemb meet nff address letter commiss novemb letter nff inform commiss film festiv great success letter state quot mr visit offic telephon call promis contact festiv procedur ecu subsidi dai scientif film touch phone hold grate contact project mention quot letter nff inform commiss servic novemb decid continu subsidi procedur quickli diplomat channel januari commiss address letter nff quot happi inform payment financi contribut nff final approv financi author subsidi ecu credit bank account dai carefulli examin possibl grant financi aid edit dutch film festiv regret inform applic accept financi author moment report previou event satisfactorili occas quot inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state respect subsidi nff fail fulfil basic oblig submit report assist late payment approv commiss refer complain correspond project refer letter june commiss state nff duli inform ecu limit subsidi nff ask submit applic subsequ applic nff commiss state search document registr system relev director gener show entri refer applic correspond respect nff inquir subsidi commiss conced repli inform nff applic formal reject mistaken subsequ telephon convers commiss inform nff applic receiv late make applic septemb nff enquir anew subsidi project inform possibl fund event complain observ observ nff maintain complaint due commiss letter januari mention nff failur account adequ spend subsidi nff extens document account spend subsidi inquiri view reason commiss grant subsidi ombudsman ask commiss inform opinion commiss state question grant subsidi consid duli complet applic form commiss commiss ad nff complaint servic respons review intern procedur order make formal commun applic subsidi observ commiss opinion nff maintain complaint decis commiss opinion maintain subsidi event refus nff failur account properli spend subsidi ombudsman inquir correct commiss view nff account faulti commiss maintain nff receiv subsidi event formal applic receiv conclus evid produc effect commiss receiv formal applic ombudsman inquir question commiss dealt improperli nff applic case law court justic principl good administr requir administr adequ coher reason measur take citizen case appear commiss gave reason reject complain applic subsidi motiv reject refer complain alleg failur compli account requir spend previou subsidi final commiss receiv applic commiss fail meet requir adequ coher reason ombudsman welcom commiss initi review procedur conclus basi inquiri complaint appear make critic remark case law court justic principl good administr requir administr adequ coher reason measur take citizen case appear commiss gave reason reject complain applic subsidi motiv reject refer complain alleg failur compli account requir spend previou subsidi final commiss receiv applic commiss fail meet requir adequ coher reason aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case mutual recognit helicopt licenc decis complaint vk european commiss complaint februari mr made complaint ombudsman commiss alleg commiss fail ensur german author compli direct mutual accept personnel licenc exercis function civil aviat alleg commiss fail act accord oblig direct mr ask german author recognit austrian profession helicopt licenc german author consid licenc equival german grant recognit mr compli addit condit mr consid discriminatori complain commiss exchang correspond mr dissatisfi commiss stand complain ombudsman alleg commiss fail make comparison requir appli member state issu helicopt licenc foreseen articl direct ensur german author impos discriminatori condit recognit austrian helicopt licenc establish propos council act full mutual recognit licenc foreseen recit direct repli letter mr address mr probst commiss director gener vii septemb inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss substanc state concern grievanc true commiss made comparison requir helicopt licenc appli member state articl direct made januari failur provid comparison bear mr individu situat commiss duli inform german author addit condit establish recognit austrian helicopt licenc due consider commiss accept mr inform concern grievanc commiss reli propos technic work carri joint aviat author bodi european civil aviat confer time ombudsman inquiri author finish work helicopt licenc commiss examin due view establish propos council act concern mr letter septemb commiss consid fax bonn represent novemb made repli superflu complain observ observ mr maintain complaint decis concern grievanc articl direct state commiss quot make forward member state januari comparison requir appli member state issu licenc function quot commiss admit made comparison helicopt licenc li commiss power propos amend direct meet deadlin laid direct principl good administr requir commiss compli rule principl bind commiss compli articl direct concern helicopt licenc commiss compli requir commiss assess addit condit establish german author recognit austrian helicopt licenc element hand assess wrong concern grievanc recit direct state view full mutual recognit licenc commiss submit propos council juli commiss acknowledg provid propos li commiss power propos amend direct meet deadlin direct principl good administr requir commiss compli clear unambigu publicli made statement submit legisl propos commiss act conform recit commiss met requir concern fourth grievanc note fax bonn represent novemb commiss consid repli mr letter septemb refer letter content fax answer import question rais mr letter contrari fax end state represent contact commiss servic brussel address mr principl good administr requir commiss repli letter address commiss repli mr letter septemb commiss met requir conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir commiss compli rule principl bind concern helicopt licenc commiss compli oblig laid articl direct eec commiss fail meet requir ii principl good administr requir commiss compli clear unambigu publicli made statement submit legisl propos commiss made propos foreseen recit direct eec juli commiss fail meet requir iii principl good administr requir commiss repli letter address commiss repli mr letter septemb fail meet requir aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case failur inform outcom complaint decis complaint ov european commiss complaint march mr complain ombudsman behalf associ alleg lack refus inform commiss dg xvi made claim associ learnt decis commiss financ project quot drain biolog clean system quot preveza greec cohes fund ask dg xvi region polici cohes telephon copi decis request refus ii decis financ project appropri publish offici journal european commun iii januari commiss standard complaint form oj associ made commun mytika complaint alleg complianc commun law greek ministri environ region plan public work complaint concern ministri joint decis juli discharg process sewag ionian sea kalamitsi complain decis contrari commun nation environment law associ ask commiss suspend fund project mention associ commiss letter februari march juli januari provid inform origin complaint dg xvi answer letter inform associ progress complaint inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss june alleg commiss opinion state compet servic inform complain articl commiss decis februari public access commiss document applic made write commiss observ receipt written demand obstacl send decis complain request receiv alleg commiss observ articl council regul ec kei detail commiss decis publish offici journal european commun present project kei detail publish offici journal european commun april commiss explain delai adopt decis public offici journal european commun refer size natur public group project adopt dai adopt decis notifi member state kei detail publish transpar reason commiss prefer group inform relat project publish separ part offici journal european commun regard alleg commiss observ servic conclud project violat commun law complaint regist violat council direct eec enter forc project start preliminari decis greek council state environment impact assess decid minist environ commiss decid novemb financ project decis conform decis greek council state commiss observ complaint date januari acknowledg receipt complain januari februari region fund cohes fund divis answer letter associ commiss juli cohes fund divis letter complain answer previou letter complain observ complain maintain alleg public decis month adopt constitut irregular associ receiv inform complain observ commiss assert violat commun law wrong commiss inform associ fact complaint reject complain conclud year receiv repli letter commiss decis alleg failur send copi decis grant financi support ombudsman note request copi commiss decis financ project articl commiss decis februari public access commiss document applic access document made write relev commiss depart complain inform compet commiss servic formal order obtain request document appear complain produc written demand dg xvi circumst fact commiss send copi decis constitut instanc maladministr alleg failur public decis offici journal european commun complain alleg decis financ project appropri publish offici journal european commun month pass adopt decis public commiss repli kei detail present decis publish offici journal european commun april articl council regul ec kei detail decis commiss approv project grant financi support cohes fund publish offici journal european commun regul forese time limit public present case decis novemb kei detail publish april commiss explain month delai refer size natur public group project adopt dai point servic prefer group inform offici journal publish separ explan delai adopt public decis appear reason fact decis publish april constitut instanc maladministr alleg failur inform complain outcom complaint complianc commun law articl procedur part complaint concern alleg maladministr administr procedur deal complaint infring commun law member state administr procedur commiss comment framework ombudsman initi inquiri pd observ complaint reach commiss regist except made rule acknowledg receipt complaint complain inform action commiss respons complaint action commiss observ decis close file take action complaint maximum period year date regist present case appear acknowledg receipt complain januari februari commiss decid regist complaint conclud violat commun law commiss inform complain fact reason complaint regist commiss left complain written inform outcom complaint juli month acknowledg receipt period month complain letter inform progress complaint commiss inform found infring commun law ombudsman note commiss observ framework initi inquiri except made rule complaint receiv commiss regist decis close file take action maximum period year date complaint regist commit commiss undertook framework initi inquiri date lodg present complaint principl good administr behaviour requir commiss inform complain adequ outcom complaint fact present case commiss inform complain fact reason regist complaint left complain month written inform outcom complaint constitut instanc maladministr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri part complaint appear maladministr commiss basi ombudsman inquiri part complaint appear make critic remark commiss observ framework ombudsman initi inquiri pd except made rule complaint receiv commiss regist decis close file take action maximum period year date complaint regist commit commiss undertook framework initi inquiri date lodg present complaint principl good administr behaviour requir commiss inform complain adequ outcom complaint fact present case commiss inform complain fact reason regist complaint left complain month written inform outcom complaint constitut instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case chang recruit polici decis complaint pd european commiss complaint april mr complain ombudsman commiss dealt recruit constitut maladministr june mr pass select procedur organis commiss establish reserv list recruit temporari post grade xxiii septemb work peru mr call commiss offici dg ib want interest post latin america mr confirm interest novemb mr receiv letter director gener ix invit interview brussel medic examin case offer post interview medic examin place month decemb mr inform oral dg ib offer post question note decemb dg ib ask dg ix put recruit procedur motion januari mr contact dg ix told recruit receiv fax effect week januari dg ix inform mr recruit procedur block decis close relev reserv list recruit mr inform write reserv list close letter march mr inform commiss find proceed complaint ombudsman mr claim commiss proceed constitut maladministr view show faulti procedur lack profession conscienc commiss servic disrespect citizen bad financi manag mr return ticket lima brussel paid commiss inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state novemb adopt decis polici temporari agent govern articl rule applic agent hereinaft quot decis quot detail consult servic staff represent preced adopt decis enter forc decemb rule stricter limit recruit temporari agent grade applic reserv list establish extern competit applic pass select procedur specif profess fact decis recruit temporari agent place grade enabl institut dispos specialis knowledg commiss administr decid reserv list establish select procedur temporari post close decemb relaunch polici temporari agent basi decis gener director head servic inform decis decemb commiss state true process lead adopt decis dg ib contact mr interview post dg ib dg ib request recruit mr made decemb dg ix appli rule reject request commiss state found regrett mr receiv contradictori inform job offer consid underlin point mr ask brussel decis adopt dg ix refus dg ib request invit mr interview fact reserv list confer post person concern fact director gener dg ix authoris decid recruit temporari agent servic dg ix empow address job offer commiss establish mr receiv letter mr letter march receiv repli commiss complain observ observ mr maintain complaint emphasis consid commiss proceed contrari principl legitim expect consid fact commiss servic decemb januari confirm oral job offer decis forc confirm view commiss procedur faulti inquiri due consider commiss opinion complain observ ombudsman ask commiss forward copi decis novemb inform point abovement decis provid transit measur ongo recruit procedur decis provid measur reason intens consult servic involv dg ib work decis finalis procedur submit decis commiss approv set motion commiss servic inform decis adopt repli commiss forward decis novemb note dg ix address director gener head servic commiss date decemb decis commiss forward copi mr curriculum vita commiss decis contain transit measur abovement note decemb state exist reserv list open order recruit conform decis commiss state mr educ polit scienc specif profess decis final commiss state procedur lead adopt decis place transpar commiss servic regularli inform ongo work weekli meet assist note decemb observ opinion commiss mr maintain complaint decis principl good administr requir administr deal citizen fair fall commiss organis procedur compli requir case establish decis recruit temporari agent forc decemb decis laid requir applic specialis profess establish mr fulfil requir recruit establish rule mr undergon interview medic examin successfulli retain servic respons appear rule continu forc novemb mr recruit question fair appli mr case requir forc moment success recruit procedur commiss overrid interest ombudsman found consid fair appli mr requir forc moment success recruit procedur appear commiss met requir organis procedur deal citizen fair conclus basi inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir administr deal citizen fair case appear applic successfulli undergon interview job medic examin retain servic respons recruit reason commiss subject recruit requir forc moment applic success proceed commiss commit instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman decid close case recruit procedur decis complaint pd european commiss complaint june mr made complaint ombudsman commiss failur offer post succeed gener competit administr organis commiss subsequ mr appli job commiss occas interview head servic spite fact qualif gener recognis offer job told commiss reason firstli vacant post fill candid member state austria finland sweden join european union januari offici belgian nation complain consid reason learn oral contact commiss contrari fundament right establish european convent human right articl staff regul establish post reserv nation complain consid paradox task commiss kind temporari staff provid servic auxiliari temporari agent recruit applic pass competit mr ask ombudsman interven applic job duli examin inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state valid reserv list question prolong final expir june longer recruit mr reserv list longer valid commiss recal case law court justic fact person reserv list entail entitl job commun institut complain alleg violat fundament right discrimin ground nation commiss firstli state gener rule establish articl staff regul post reserv nation basi reserv list commiss servic select applic profession profil appear match servic make propos recruit relev director gener dg ix commiss stress dg ix receiv propos mr commiss refer fact belgian reserv list question recruit commiss state context access mention member state council adopt regul ec effect post reserv holder nation concern regul constitut law derogatori measur gener rule post reserv nation temporari staff commiss state budgetari author alloc perman temporari post commiss appropri emploi auxiliari agent servic provid kind staff affect possibl recruit civil servant perman post complain observ observ commiss comment mr substanc maintain complaint rais number question averag period valid reserv list reason commiss decid prolong valid reserv list cost involv organis competit reason commiss decid publish post consid qualifi expir reserv list letter mr ask inform action undertaken ombudsman view find friendli solut complaint facilit due employ commiss decis firstli note ombudsman find justifi start inquiri question rais complain observ scope origin complaint remark question find friendli solut complaint aris ombudsman establish instanc maladministr note commiss entitl offer complain perman post valid reserv list expir fact reserv list give candid employ commun institut mr complaint rais substanc question expos unlaw discrimin ground nation commiss extern temporari staff relev assess question examin question fell part firstli discrimin post gener rule articl staff regul appli discrimin post gener rule appli virtu regul ec concern part word articl recal recruit direct secur institut servic offici highest standard abil effici integr recruit broadest geograph basi nation member state commun offici select refer race creed sex post reserv nation specif member state provis seek strike balanc recruit qualifi staff intern organis ensur staff state found organis case law court justic provis impli quot commun institut recruit promot assign offici post guid hand interest servic regard nation hand ensur recruit widest geograph basi nation member state commun institut reconcil requir court declar judgment case reinarz ecr case qualif candid substanti make nation overrid criterion order maintain establish geograph balanc staff quot appear commiss director gener respons recruit receiv propos complain recruit propos turn ground belgian nation fact belgian reserv list receiv employ commiss appear difficult give credit claim gener bar recruit belgian establish commiss engag unlaw discrimin belgian applic concern oral declar commiss offici mr refer commiss contest true declar give impress offici concern awar oblig articl staff regul principl good administr requir administr deal citizen compli rule bind declar mr refer easili misunderstood effect offici concern respect oblig articl staff regul ombudsman address critic remark commiss effect ensur deal applic staff respect articl staff regul concern post reserv nation austria finland sweden articl regul ec quot notwithstand paragraph articl staff regul offici european commun provis made decemb vacant post fill austrian finnish swedish nation limit set context budgetari discuss institut respons quot appear regul establish derog gener rule paragraph articl staff regul regul contest commiss bound appli appear commiss fulli entitl reserv post fill nation countri concern complain grievanc appear commiss engag unlaw discrimin provis european convent human right bear result basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss ensur deal applic staff awar oblig articl staff regul aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case undu delai repli correspond decis complaint ov european commiss complaint novemb mr director government organis offer medic care injur children war crisi area complain ombudsman reject applic fund dg viii develop commiss project concern intend integr homeless children select famili orphanag give famili structur emot develop project conceiv aad angolan action develop luanda approv relev angolan ministri absenc adequ financi resourc august complain made applic dg viii fund project budget head promot human right democraci develop countri decemb complain inform applic reject limit resourc budget line project fit criteria budget line dg viii equal inform complain doubt famili face enorm daili problem ideal home vulner children find reject decis unclear suffici motiv complain wrote time decemb septemb commiss explan reject applic order eventu reformul concept project receiv repli novemb telephon request ombudsman offic commiss answer correspond complain unsatisfi reason reject decis consid contradictori object clear complain ombudsman alleg commiss fail give adequ reason reject decis ii repli month correspond inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss reason reject decis commiss observ limit financi resourc ecu million countri strict select procedur project select maximum impact strengthen democraci rule law respect human right countri commiss state present project dealt procedur object manner commiss consid reason reject decis contradictori inform complain project fulfil select criteria budget head inform main obstacl project contribut democrat develop countri fund regard failur repli complain correspond explan commiss state period answer complain week letter april week letter novemb reason workload human resourc complain observ complain observ commiss approv project angolan govern reason reject decis complain state commiss inform exact select criteria project fulfil criteria complain ask ombudsman continu investig failur repli complain observ commiss repli april fact answer letter march remind letter decemb observ commiss repli week correct inquiri care consider commiss opinion complain observ appear inquiri order determin select criteria fund budget head fulfil complain commiss observ complain inform select criteria impact strengthen democraci rule law respect human right countri receiv gener condit govern budget head complet standard form attach commiss state view larg number fund applic receiv year met difficult give detail explan refus present case commiss state project primarili social medic orient psycholog care children cover direct prioriti budget line reject decis base natur project complain admit receiv gener condit govern budget head observ condit extens subject interpret state miss clear argument project fit select criteria decis alleg failur state reason reject decis complain alleg decis decemb commiss reject fund applic unclear fail state suffici reason commiss observ inform complain select criteria project contribut democrat develop countri fund addit comment commiss state view larg number applic difficult give detail explan refus case law court justic reason author adopt measur disclos clear unequivoc fashion hand make person concern awar reason measur enabl defend right enabl court exercis supervisori jurisdict letter decemb commiss reject applic term quot examin abovement propos deleg angola geograph servic respons angola regret inform commiss project consider fact limit resourc budget line relat numer countri field activ cover impos set prioriti order ensur geograph themat balanc alloc subvent project centr opportun import problem fit criteria budget line content project concern doubt famili face enorm daili problem ideal home vulner children quot letter novemb commiss repli term quot mention regret confirm commiss fund project consider inform number project propos receiv strict select oper order ensur geograph themat balanc alloc limit financi resourc ecu million year countri project propos receiv examin geograph servic brussel luanda global framework prioriti address ec present angolan condit fulfil criteria budget line project foster democrat develop countri select quot ombudsman note addit observ complain admit inform select criteria project maximum impact strengthen democraci rule law respect human right countri regard appear correspond commiss provid suffici reason reject complain applic inform project fulfil select criteria project promot democrat develop countri select complain project concern social medic aid commiss explan appear reason alleg undu delai repli correspond complain alleg commiss fail repli letter date decemb march april septemb ask explan reject applic commiss observ repli letter week fax april week repli novemb consid reason period workload human resourc principl good administr behaviour requir letter complain commiss receiv repli reason time ombudsman note fax dg viii april repli complain letter name commiss repres angola provid addit inform reason reject decis novemb telephon request ombudsman offic dg viii repli complain request addit inform consid reason time period repli correspond fact commiss repli novemb complain correspond start decemb constitut instanc maladministr conclus basi ombudsman inquiri aspect complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr behaviour requir letter complain commiss administr receiv repli reason time fact commiss repli novemb complain correspond start decemb constitut instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case court auditor reimburs cost applic competit decis complaint ll jp fin pd court auditor complaint octob mr mr complain ombudsman alleg court auditor treat unjust discriminatori offer limit reimburs travel expens incur particip competit organis court auditor complain forward copi complaint directli court auditor competit question intern interinstitut civil servant agent servic commun institut appli complain appli competit time agent commiss represent finland letter august court auditor complain inform admit written test letter place octob brussel complain ask present annex letter sheet set applic rule reimburs travel expens articl rule reimburs distanc applic resid place competit inferior equal km articl provid distanc superior km applic entitl sum calcul basi kilometr quot maximum sum ecu distanc superior km inferior km maximum sum ecu distanc superior equal km inferior km maximum sum ecu distanc superior equal km quot complain consid level reimburs rule impli insuffici order attend test place thursdai ordinari return air ticket helsinki brussel cost approxim ecu accommod expens night brussel approxim ecu bring cost complain particip written test ecu entitl reimburs ecu amount cost bear amount month net salari complain refrain take part competit complaint ombudsman complain claim rule reimburs travel cost case privileg agent work luxemburg brussel contrari principl equal treatment complain consid effect rule contrari principl enshrin articl staff regul quot recruit direct secur institut servic offici highest standard abil effici integr recruit broadest geograph basi nation member state commun quot inquiri opinion court auditor complaint forward court auditor opinion court state limit appli rule laid conclus adopt colleg head administr word conclus applic gener competit organis institut intern decis court auditor rule made applic competit question inquiri ombudsman request court auditor submit document underli adopt conclus appear document receiv conclus aim reduc cost incur institut reimburs travel expens simplifi reimburs system appear fear voic effect conclus account heavi financi burden put applic come doubt relat principl applic equal opportun particip competit fear dealt statement effect number place competit increas decentralis background ombudsman address letter court auditor letter ombudsman note test question organis weekdai saturdai enabl applic benefit cheaper air fare ombudsman note place competit instanc brussel averag cost born applic deduct travel reimburs travel train class come luxemburg ecu strasbourg ecu athen ecu note appear applic distant locat bear disproportion cost ombudsman ask court auditor envisag take measur similar situat aris submit question committe prepar statutori question bodi depend colleg head administr court auditor inform ombudsman institut committe point reimburs travel expens financi benefit applic provid staff regul institut adopt conclus agre multipli place competit order shorten distanc applic aspect court auditor ad decis organis written test luxemburg brussel reason circumst interest servic court organis written test place place commun represent involv disproportion cost decis ombudsman notic fact institut assembl committe prepar statutori question state reimburs travel cost financi contribut provid staff regul ombudsman observ case administr take action foreseen staff regul administr compli rule principl bind ombudsman notic fact committe state adopt rule institut agre multipli place competit order shorten travel distanc applic ombudsman observ court auditor act conform agreement court auditor sought justifi departur agreement refer disproportion cost hold test finland ombudsman observ organis competit lai court auditor exercis power reduc cost applic evid effect competit organis weekdai effect provid place competit instanc commiss parliament represent assist entail disproportion cost uncontest applic rule case result excess cost limit number potenti particip written test competit question principl good administr requir administr proce fair applic competit organis competit entail excess cost limit number applic deem meet requir conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir administr proce fair applic competit case appear court auditor organis competit entail excess cost applic member state return air ticket approxim ecu organis competit court auditor commit instanc maladministr fell court auditor organis competit meet requir instanc organis place competit order shorten travel distanc aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case draft recommend ombudsman council european union date list measur adopt field justic home affair draft recommend complaint statewatch uk ijh council complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman council maintain make public date list measur adopt field justic home affair complain claim interest inform citizen conform democrat standard council maintain list make request inquiri council opinion complaint forward council opinion council refer consider effort made improv transpar proceed context summari council decis titl vi treati european union produc year publish annex annual review council work edit onward decis council titl vi area announc press releas issu gener secretariat includ principl act adopt written procedur decis formal composit council correspond subject matter concern separ head easili identifi press releas comput search content council press releas made quot rapid quot base access internet quot europa quot server gener secretariat council work set databas access internet thing present council decis area justic home affair common foreign secur polici complain observ observ complain acknowledg council effort provid inform consid sign ineffici council date list measur adopt area repeat claim unaccept citizen obtain request date list measur adopt ombudsman attempt achiev friendli solut care consider complaint opinion observ ombudsman wrote council decemb order seek friendli solut complaint accord articl statut ombudsman inform council consid failur maintain date list measur adopt council constitut instanc maladministr basic principl good administr behaviour public author maintain adequ record record ensur consist continu activ mention articl treati european union inadequ record make difficult locat relev document accur quickli ii council publish summari decis titl vi treati european union year council secretariat produc list end year lead error omiss effect administr techniqu secretariat maintain date list year iii appear legal reason present posit council maintain list virtu power intern organis authoris measur order ensur intern oper conform interest good administr ombudsman suggest council respond agre maintain date list measur adopt field justic home affair ombudsman state make list public enhanc transpar strengthen democrat natur council public confid administr foreseen declar attach treati european union council respons letter date februari council repli ombudsman quot letter decemb complaint mr council maintain date list measur agre field justic home affair make list access public pleas confirm gener secretariat maintain list measur question form inform made public consid justic home affair council march issu transpar pillar quot letter date juli council provid addit inform includ point gener secretariat make databas council activ jha field access internet provid thing list instrument adopt date subject possibl access full text offici languag ii public list measur council jha field addit facil offer databas inform contain annual review council work council letter contain conclus adopt jha council meet march transpar jha field inform follow conclus complain respons council letter februari juli forward complain repli letter date march septemb complain welcom initi transpar jha field mention council letter juli maintain complaint point list instrument mention council list measur complaint relat complain state public list measur council annual review suffici meet democrat standard requir citizen obtain request date list measur point year light appear ombudsman search friendli solut complaint unsuccess draft recommend council respons point made letter decemb ombudsman reach conclus council state gener secretariat maintain list measur approv field justic home affair ii articl council decis ec decemb public access council document defin quot council document quot quot written text medium exist data held council quot iii list measur approv field justic home affair council state maintain gener secretariat appear quot council document quot mean articl decis ec accord articl statut ombudsman ombudsman make draft recommend council council make public request accord provis council decis ec list measur approv field justic home affair maintain gener secretariat council complain inform draft recommend accord articl statut ombudsman council send detail opinion januari detail opinion consist accept ombudsman draft recommend descript implement initi inquiri ombudsman european commiss ag limit recruit decis initi inquiri bb issu juli ombudsman began initi inquiri ag limit recruit commun institut signific number complaint relat exclus candid specif competit organis commun institut substanc claim put forward complaint includ ag limit fundament right citizen discriminatori sktol fin bb mchp es kt jia fr kt alc es pd bb bb ip breach principl equal candid xd concern emploi institut year ml pd xd ag limit appli candid polit post mchp es kt legal basi set current ag limit candid clear rw uk kt date birth object criterion laid competit notic contradict object criteria profession experi medic examin xd complain refer fact member state ag limit prohibit constitut legisl provis research note applic ag limit member state european commun ombudsman consid research need order fulli evalu current situat member state purpos ombudsman contact court justic agre measur cooper research document divis prepar research note ombudsman research note common constitut legal principl member state allow prohibit ag limit ag limit impos public sector half member state ag limit gener higher year reason differ member state note tendenc member state treat ag limit unjustifi discrimin abandon inquiri commiss opinion opinion commiss summaris commiss decid matter polici abandon ag limit notic competit commiss recognis implement principl common agreement institut reason decid temporari measur rais ag limit year forthcom competit start grade line decis european parliament octob commiss state delai obtain common agreement institut appreci measur consider administr career council opinion opinion council summaris institut enjoi discret choic mean meet personnel requir broad discret draw requir competit ag criteria basi distinct made time recruit prohibit staff regul articl annex iii staff regul condit legitim determin appoint author ag limit remain staff regul compli respect gener principl commun law respect fundament right guarante european convent protect human right fundament freedom sign rome novemb result constitut tradit common member state gener principl commun law council note treati amsterdam enter forc begin question ag plai part select criterion examin note undesir consequ institut abolish ag limit success candid reach retir ag ag limit set seri competit arrang joint organis competit made harmonis condit access thereto includ set ag limit candid post start grade take account problem unemploy young peopl live european union recent competit member state ag limit set account experi requir post recent launch notic competit provid possibl extend ag limit maximum year case rule govern ag limit laid automat vari natur depart accord requir articl staff regul distinct made candid account respect situat gener secretariat council consid applic ag limit basi post fill success candid competit provid staff regul articl annex iii possibl extens account specif situat quot discriminatori quot measur sens concept european court human right court justic inform gener secretariat ad process discuss propos amend staff regul respect equal treatment complain observ ombudsman commiss opinion complain council opinion complain observ receiv observ complain claim commiss acknowledg ag limit wrong made polici decis principl abolish ag limit intermedi solut rais ag limit year contradict principl unaccept complain state satisfi posit council complain articl staff regul fact legitim basi ag discrimin complain claim council impos ag limit arbitrarili stop hope ombudsman close investig institut chang polici relat matter ag limit abolish decis ag limit human right articl treati european union quot union respect fundament right guarante european convent protect human right fundament freedom sign rome novemb result constitut tradit common member state gener principl commun law quot human right provis discrimin articl european convent human right quot enjoy right freedom set convent secur discrimin ground sex race colour languag religion polit opinion nation social origin associ nation minor properti birth statu quot articl complement substant provis convent protocol independ exist effect sole relat quot enjoy right freedom quot safeguard provis case law european court human right articl convent differ treatment discriminatori quot object reason justif quot pursu quot legitim aim quot quot reason relationship proportion mean emploi aim sought realis quot prohibit discrimin unit nation intern coven civil polit right state articl coven quot state parti present coven undertak respect ensur individu territori subject jurisdict right recognis present coven distinct kind race colour sex languag religion polit opinion nation social origin properti birth statu quot articl european convent human right articl coven civil polit right explicitli prohibit discrimin ground ag scope applic abovement discrimin claus extrem broad exclud scope applic cover discrimin ground ag case exist object reason justif discrimin juli european union step combat ag discrimin treati amsterdam introduc articl ec treati ag mention form discrimin articl read quot prejudic provis treati limit power confer commun council act unanim propos commiss consult european parliament action combat discrimin base sex racial ethnic origin religion belief disabl ag sexual orient quot treati amsterdam enter forc plan introduct articl european union recognis ag unjustifi discrimin articl discrimin affirm commun institut hesit activ enhanc respect human right provis initi court justic european commun recognis commun recruit respect principl equal discrimin treat candid similar situat differ justifi ground court consist case law gener principl equal fundament principl law commun civil servic principl requir compar situat treat differ differenti object justifi applic ag limit member state ombudsman inquiri reveal common constitut legal principl member state allow prohibit ag limit ag limit impos public sector half member state ag limit gener higher year tendenc abandon ag limit discriminatori appar member state applic ag limit commun institut commun institut appli ag limit admiss candid competit possibl mention articl annex iii staff regul notic competit quot ag limit extens ag limit case servant commun complet year servic quot articl staff regul quot offici select refer race creed sex quot ombudsman understood base articl annex iii staff regul appoint author ag limit notic competit ombudsman found take account principl decis reason provis laid articl staff regul word articl annex iii staff regul phrase quot quot court consist case law gener principl equal suggest ag limit impos arbitrarili reason support specif ag limit consid competit develop practic appoint author appli ag limit differ institut articl staff regul lai principl candid recruit basic grade gener ag limit year set ground basic grade suitabl young graduat time establish career european civil servant commiss ag limit set head unit ag limit year princip translat limit year translat limit year possibl rais case council set ag limit possibl rais maximum year ground set ag limit commun institut ground set ag limit vari commun institut institut present ombudsman number ground connect individu complaint ag limit ground put forward summaris balanc manag human resourc career structur system suit recruit older person wealth experi gain long career problem offici adapt multicultur multilingu environ increas ag institut bound requir recruit broadest geograph basi recours nation quota possibl mobil decreas ag relat candid place work place resid recruit younger candid make easier achiev reason geograph balanc ratio male femal employe set ag limit candid post start grade take account problem unemploy young peopl live european union experi show femal particip higher competit level level ag limit enhanc gender balanc abolish ag limit counter product increas number applic men remov obstacl women ensur condit balanc administr career highli experienc peopl recruit lower career bracket disrupt staff structur hypothet institut abandon gener principl recruit personnel basic grade recruit grade justifi creat distort personnel neg effect motiv good manag envisag older offici rapidli request promot order obtain grade suit experi rule govern ag limit laid mechan vari natur depart distinct made candid account respect situat unoffici mention ag limit mean limit number candid practic ag limit enabl organis quot manag quot competit ombudsman concern ground set ag limit put forward commun institut appear object justifi order elimin possibl arbitrari suffici justif set ag limit constitut discrimin union citizen possibl seek employ european union administr ombudsman view union citizen possibl seek employ european union administr consid limit possibl carri suffici justif avoid recruit procedur element consid discriminatori arbitrari ombudsman initi inquiri ag limit individu complaint commun institut appli ag limit common justif practic provis staff regul govern set ag limit correct applic ag limit ombudsman note articl treati european union set duti commun institut respect human right provis guarante european convent human right result constitut tradit member state pertin commun institut appli provis initi enhanc respect human right fundament freedom introduct articl ec treati ombudsman found ag regard discrimin european union clarifi treati amsterdam combat ag discrimin culmin entri forc ombudsman view current practic commun institut set ag limit differ ground suffici justif consid correct applic ag limit ombudsman inquiri appear commun institut envisag set common ag limit reason suffici justif commun institut abandon ag limit prefer clarifi relev provis staff regul order guarante ag limit appli discriminatori arbitrari manner action commun institut ag limit european parliament decid octob rais ag limit year upcom competit start grade review year basi report submit personnel servic secretari gener parliament commiss decid januari polici principl abandon ag limit recruit polici comment commiss consid put decis practic common agreement institut meantim commiss appli ag limit view develop ombudsman recognis common interinstitut agreement conclus basi ombudsman initi inquiri take account commiss announc polici principl abandon ag limit interinstitut agreement ombudsman found ground pursu initi inquiri ag limit decid close inquiri ombudsman kindli request commiss inform action undertaken order obtain common interinstitut agreement abolish ag limit pension right local agent commiss initi inquiri oi jma complaint novemb european parliament transfer ombudsman petit address mr chilean citizen petit refer refus commiss recognis retir right period work local agent latin american deleg commiss petit regist complaint declar inadmiss complain citizen union resid member state meet criteria set articl ec treati articl statu ombudsman view circumst case ombudsman decid open initi inquiri matter basi articl ec treati regist file number oi jma inquiri commiss opinion decemb ombudsman inform presid committe petit european parliament presid european commiss initi inquiri request opinion commiss end march repli commiss inform ombudsman intervent servic respons pension start evalu situat pension right local staff commiss subsequ explain mr work latin american deleg januari septemb basi articl condit employ servant european commun commiss cover social secur charg local agent line local regul high rate inflat prevail chile commiss arrang local agent emploi santiago join special social secur scheme quot offic de sécurité social outr mer quot ossom brussel chang econom condit chile commiss local agent progress incorpor nation chilean social secur system pension right mr commiss contact ossom inform regist period work latin american deleg social secur contribut paid period account calcul pension right ag commiss inform ombudsman inform complain refer intervent ombudsman forward letter commiss mr june observ receiv decis light inform contain commiss opinion suppli complain ombudsman conclud problem settl commiss close case relat institut european union european parliament committe petit januari mr söderman present special report initi inquiri public access document committe petit januari mr söderman mr ian harden head secretariat meet luxembourg jurisconsult mr garzón clariana member parliament legal servic april mr söderman present annual report committe petit european parliament presid mr edward newman mr söderman speech live discuss press confer meet attend larg number journalist june mr söderman gave speech committe institut affair brussel framework hear open rapporteur mep maj li lööw speaker includ professor deirdr curtin univers utrecht ms kristina rennerstedt state secretari swedish depart justic mr han brunmayr council june mr söderman met presid european parliament mr gil robl secretari gener mr julian priestlei discuss open issu relat establish ombudsman offic draft budget juli mr söderman mr ian harden met mr garzón clariana jurisconsult luxembourg discuss legal issu relat budget novemb mr söderman exchang view committe petit brussel european commiss februari ian harden peter dyrberg meet commiss servic view find friendli solut case april mr söderman mr dyrberg met mr jean claud eeckhout director secretariat gener commiss mr philipp godt discuss possibl organis joint seminar liaison offic euro ju repres member state place brussel novemb april mr söderman met mr santiago gómez reino lecoq deputi director gener director gener extern relat southern mediterranean middl east latin america south south east asia north south cooper discuss possibl union assist cooper nation ombudsmen central america mr söderman meet mr alfonso mattera recigliano director director xv free movement good public procur discuss articl procedur juli mr söderman met ambassador christoffersen perman represent denmark brussel afternoon met commission anita gradin exchang view septemb mr söderman met mr mattera recigliano director dg xv european commiss number collabor gener ombudsman procedur deal complaint relat commiss articl procedur septemb mr söderman gave speech quot custom quot european commiss premis brussel confer attend larg number staff commun institut bodi meet chair director gener dg ix mr steffen smidt relat nation ombudsmen similar bodi safeguard right european citizen flexibl system cooper develop european ombudsman ombudsmen similar bodi member state implement aspect commun law respons nation region local administr member state complaint citizen author infring right commun law mandat european ombudsman union citizenship involv freedom movement guarante articl ec treati case complaint dealt effect nation ombudsmen similar bodi petit committe increasingli involv matter concern implement commun law nation administr liaison network cooper nation ombudsmen similar bodi european ombudsman continu liaison letter publish produc late autumn seminar held liaison offic nation ombudsman offic euro ju offic novemb brussel deal field commun law standard good administr behaviour work nation ombudsmen similar bodi relat judici review concret case relat commun law speaker includ mr söderman mr anita gradin commission mr edward newman vice presid petit committe european parliament mr leif sevón judg court justic european commun mr david keeff professor law univers colleg london mr de brouwer european commiss mr brophi irish ombudsman offic mr ebermann european commiss mr palacio gonzález administr court instanc mr philipp bardiaux french ombudsman offic mr ribeiro portugues ombudsman offic mr gerstberg secretariat petit committe german bundestag mr andersen danish ombudsman offic mr tate uk ombudsman offic mr gasparinetti european commiss mr stoodlei european commiss session chair mr söderman mr bermejo spanish ombudsman offic mr riitta länsisyrjä finnish ombudsman offic mr bardiaux french ombudsman offic cooper deal complaint seminar held strasbourg septemb nation ombudsmen similar bodi european ombudsman agre european ombudsman receiv queri nation ombudsmen similar bodi commun law provid repli directli channel queri union institut bodi respons year queri dealt cooper region ombudsmen similar bodi european ombudsman receiv inquiri andalusian region ombudsman mr chamizo de la rubia complain allegedli passiv attitud french author attack suffer spanish truck driver franc destruct agricultur good view attitud contrari basic principl european commun free circul good contraven articl ec treati mr chamizo stress neg consequ action agricultur spanish export farmer andalusia complaint jma call european ombudsman launch initi inquiri matter order make commiss guardian treati action french govern examin argument put forward complaint ombudsman conclud declar admiss prior administr approach respons ec institut undertaken requir articl statut european ombudsman decid transfer complaint european commiss letter mr chamizo june ombudsman explain transfer commiss measur commiss inform andalusian ombudsman letter regist complaint august dgvi director gener mr legra updat mr chamizo latest develop situat commiss explain monitor situat consid contrari articl treati start infring proceed commiss brought matter court justic case latest event commiss letter french author addit letter mr legra mr chamizo march inform rule court justic franc mr legra explain amsterdam summit june commiss work draft regul submit council regul enabl commiss action member state adopt measur avoid attack free circul good view explan mr chamizo wrote ombudsman express satisfact action undertaken commiss thank ombudsman cooper seek solut problem juli mr romano fantappi region ombudsman tuscani accompani collabor paid visit european ombudsman offic invit ombudsman visit tuscani octob mr söderman met petit committe sächsischer landtag head mr thoma mädler presid committe speech mr söderman gave work european ombudsman exchang view futur cooper bodi public relat highlight year fide congress european ombudsman gener rapporteur theme quot citizen administr commun law quot xviii fide congress held stockholm sweden june accompani ian harden peter dyrberg josé martínez aragón work session theme chair ms elisabeth palm presid administr court appeal gothenburg dr han ragnemalm judg court justic european commun fide congress attend deleg european institut member state union cypru malta norwai switzerland open plenari session congress swedish minist justic ms laila freivald gave speech quot rule law enlarg european union quot presid court justic dr gil carlo rodríguez iglesia gave open lectur quot la cour de justic de communauté européenn interact entr le droit européen le droit nation quot ombudsman gener report theme quot citizen administr commun law quot final report plenari session websit english french annual report european ombudsman present annual report european parliament plenari session strasbourg juli report behalf committe petit parliament mr edward newman mep welcom ombudsman definit quot maladministr quot previou year european parliament encourag ombudsman make full mandat deal maladministr activ commun institut bodi note import clear definit term quot maladministr quot base inform suppli nation ombudsmen similar bodi european ombudsman offer definit annual report quot maladministr occur public bodi fail act accord rule principl bind quot parliament consid definit exampl mention annual report clear pictur li remit ombudsman mr newman propos behalf committe petit adopt resolut welcom definit special report european ombudsman special report ombudsman ombudsman initi public access document present presid european parliament decemb discuss parliament plenari session juli basi report committe petit rapporteur astrid thor resolut special report parliament welcom action ombudsman transpar union note increas transpar improv public access document close link code good administr behaviour suggest ombudsman annual report european human right agenda year octob mr jacob söderman accompani mr peter dyrberg particip confer vienna theme quot eu human right agenda year quot confer organis european univers institut cooper austrian ministri foreign affair mr söderman gave speech european ombudsman human right includ suggest improv protect human right union confer meet germani mr söderman invit mep karl von wogau speak quot right european citizen quot framework quot european dai quot celebr bad krozingen peopl surround area franc switzerland part festiv visit stand brochur european ombudsman displai distribut eu stand mr söderman opportun meet mr gerdi staiblin minist agricultur baden württemberg mayor bad krozingen mr ekkehart meroth june mr söderman invit particip panel theme quot europ todai institut peopl quot organis professor dr hönnighausen univers bonn framework transatlant summer academi tasa panel chair mr matt marshal journalist wall street journal europ speaker includ dr eckhard lübkemeier head foreign polici studi friedrich ebert foundat professor hella mandt professor polit scienc univers trier audienc consist student univers unit state canada russia itali netherland yugoslav republ macedonia great britain ukrain yugoslavia ireland lithuania estonia octob ms vicki kloppenburg mr martínez aragón part seminar quot cooper field justic home affair schengen amsterdam quot organis academi european law trier sought evalu introduc treati amsterdam judici polic cooper european union consequ commun provis common rule asylum immigr border control power treati ombudsman order monitor applic provis discuss take account limit commun institut court justic impact citizen right gener agre implement provis rais import legal problem requir cooper effort nation commun institut novemb peter dyrberg met mr knöfler chairman petit committe parliament german land saxoni anhalt mr schäfer administr committe novemb peter dyrberg gave speech quot european ombudsman transpar democraci quot confer entitl quot transpar democraci quot organis magdeburg associ quot europa forum magdeburg börde quot invit professor dr jürgen schwarz mr söderman gave lectur decemb univers freiburg spain occas anniversari declar human right catalonian institut human right invit mr söderman particip mr cañella region ombudsman catalonia mr álvarez de miranda torr spanish ombudsman confer barcelona march round tabl revolv role human right work ombudsmen speech attend divers audienc lawyer law student mr söderman accompani mr josé martínez aragón part initi ibero american feder ombudsmen fio univers alcalá de henar madrid organis quot strengthen institut ombudsman latin america quot march decemb aim give practic train offici ombudsmen offic latin america mr söderman invit speak open ceremoni march review evolut union citizenship past year drew conclus interest latin american audienc particip event includ mr gala provost univers mr pimentel portugues ombudsman mr álvarez de miranda torr spanish ombudsman mr cañella region ombudsman catalonia mr chamizo region ombudsman andalusia univers complutens organis quot jornada sobr derecho interno derecho comunitario europeo quot theme quot armonización integración de lo ordenamiento jurídico de lo estado miembro en el derecho de la unión europea quot madrid april mr söderman invit speak close ceremoni april gave talk entitl quot la figura del defensor del pueblo europeo funcion perspectiva de actuación quot mr söderman visit european parliament offic madrid occas human right declar mr söderman invit give speech eu human right universidad complutens madrid decemb decemb mr söderman accompani mr martínez aragón particip seminar quot jornada sobr educación en derecho humano quot organis sevil andalusian ombudsman mr söderman gave open lectur franc februari mr söderman invit particip colloquium organis french ombudsman mr jacqu pelleti occas anniversari french institut particip mr jacqu chirac presid franc gave open speech mr lionel jospin prime minist particip close ceremoni mr söderman spoke origin develop ombudsman institut world accompani mr olivi verheeck legal offic benita brom particip colloqui quot hand effect human right protect year univers declar quot colloqui organis strasbourg septemb council europ contribut commemor anniversari univers declar human right review implement vienna declar action programm open statement made ms mari robinson unit nation high commission human right theme discuss includ prevent respons structur larg scale human right violat rapporteur mr vojin dimitrijev social right challeng indivis interdepend rapporteur mr aalt willem heringa effect implement women right rapporteur ms katarina tomasevski protect effect action nation level rapporteur mr régi de goutt protect effect action intern level rapporteur mr jeremi mcbride promot human right inform educ train rapporteur ms kaija gertner parallel discuss group theme chair promin person field human right mr peter dyrberg particip intern congress administr scienc organis intern institut administr scienc pari septemb octob mr bernard stasi médiateur de la républiqu paid visit european ombudsman mr vincent bouvier délégué général mr philipp bardiaux conseil pour le relat extérieur mme ann morrier chargé de mission pour la commun mr jean françoi leroi chargé de mission pour le délégué départementaux discuss seminar agre organis septemb pari meet mr stasi mr söderman gave joint press confer ireland novemb mr ian harden present work european ombudsman seminar transpar democraci europ dungarvan counti waterford killarnei counti kerri organis south east european centr south west ireland rural carrefour south kerri develop partnership speaker includ michael brophi irish ombudsman offic siobhan duffi euro ju repres ireland paul gormlei commiss represent jim brien european parliament represent itali mr söderman paid offici visit itali septemb visit florenc meet region ombudsman tuscani mr romano fantappi staff mr söderman inform project conceiv offic region ombudsman creation electron network link ombudsmen tuscani organis intern meet region ombudsmen eu meet meet professor angelo passaleva presid region council tuscani presid express happi mr söderman tuscani region itali region ombudsman professor passaleva mr söderman exchang view work european ombudsman import relat ombudsmen local region nation level work professor passaleva itali question relat public health constitut major part region ombudsmen work issu concern professor passaleva mr söderman agre forthcom vote bill organis ombudsmanship itali import issu european citizenship mr söderman emphasis itali activ local region ombudsmen respons region bigger member state european union remain countri union nation ombudsman european ombudsman met mr paolo giannarelli minist region govern tuscani charg commun polit mr giannarelli mention import european ombudsman activ view essenti make italian citizen awar european citizenship mr söderman express creat strong relat italian ombudsmen level project present region ombudsman tuscani excel achiev cooper meet european ombudsman present specif case oppos european commiss tuscani case relat wine product livestock farm mr fantappi invit local ombudsmen tuscani meet european ombudsman offer opportun discuss problem rais heterogen organis italian ombudsmanship unifi rule domain promot cooper ombudsmen appear extrem mr söderman paid visit european univers institut fiesol meet professor masterson presid institut professor meni director institut professor dehouss professor ziller mr söderman spoke work notion maladministr exchang view relat european ombudsman commun institut nation court ombudsmen final mr söderman underlin import creat network european ombudsman nation region local ombudsmen perspect treati amsterdam septemb confer organis verona local ombudsman mr giovanni fraizzoli mr söderman invit deliv speech quot cooper nation region local ombudsmen protect promot european citizenship quot mr anton cañella region ombudsman catalonia present region ombudsmanship spanish point view highlight experi mr paolo cavaleri professor public law verona professor lucio strumendo region ombudsman veneto invit present italian issu relat ombudsmanship perspect forthcom vote italian parliament confer debat involv region local ombudsmen part itali citizen verona netherland mr olivi verheeck mr ben hagard attend congress europ held hagu build europ st centuri area solidar freedom occas anniversari congress europ congress organis intern european movement presid mr mario soar gave welcom speech congress solemnli open majesti queen netherland intervent mr josé maria gil robl presid european parliament mr peter mandelson minist portfolio unit kingdom mr jacqu santer presid european commiss mr gil carlo rodriguez iglesia presid court justic european commun mr leni fischer presid parliamentari assembl council europ congress mr verheeck mr hagard manag stand european ombudsman quot expo europ quot inform particip congress role activ european ombudsman congress particip visit ombudsman stand question materi mr verheeck attend workshop quot democraci citizenship human right quot chair mr kapteyn judg court justic european commun speaker workshop mr jean victor loui professor european studi institut brussel presid initi committe intern european movement mr pier virgilio dastoli gener secretari intern european movement mr andrea gross member parliamentari assembl council europ debat base introductori text quot democraci citizenship europ quot present mr jo leinen presid union european federalist uef main subject debat concern draw european constitut workshop quot econom social dimens europ quot quot multicultur dimens europ quot quot europ world quot portug mr jacob söderman made offici visit portug april visit organis mr josé mener pimentel portugues nation ombudsman mr nuno anta de campo head european parliament inform offic lisbon european ombudsman paid visit portugues nation ombudsman offic visit european parliament inform offic european commiss represent lisbon meet high portugues offici part programm includ mr seixa da costa secretari gener european affair foreign ministri mr cardoso da costa presid constitut court mr santo presid portugues parliament mr martin presid commiss portugues parliament deal constitut affair right freedom guarante citizen mr söderman opportun meet mr soar presid portugues republ current presid european movement mr söderman met mr freita amar professor administr law univers lisbon presid portugues branch european movement finland march mr söderman gave lectur entitl quot citizen europ quot tamper finland meet attend juror court instanc mr söderman particip seminar ethic organis archbishop turku gave speech quot european valu quot mr söderman accompani mr benita brom legal offic attend quot nordic confer commun law quot novemb helsinki mr söderman gave speech european citizen commun institut mr söderman present work kajaani seinäjoki imatra novemb sweden occas fide congress june european ombudsman visit swedish parliament present work committe european affair june octob mr söderman visit göteborg sweden gave lectur seminar quot demokrati och transparen vårt europa quot seminar part carrefour west europ sponsor commiss mr linda steneberg head commiss represent sweden made speech access eu relat inform mr ivar virgin mr ann hulthén mep work european parliament unit kingdom januari mr söderman made offici visit scotland visit commission local administr mr frederick mark paid visit commiss represent edinburgh invit give lectur role european ombudsman univers edinburgh professor john usher mr söderman accompani internet commun offic ben hagard visit unit kingdom mr söderman gave seminar role european ombudsman univers read centr ombudsman studi meet mr söderman met professor roi gregori director centr chair seminar live discuss speech mr söderman particip includ professor roi gregori dr philip gid centr ombudsman studi professor peter woodward dr alex warleigh univers read depart polit head depart polit professor richard bellami dean univers faculti letter professor toni down professor gavin drewri royal hollowai colleg univers london articl visit mr söderman appear read even post read chronicl univers read bulletin seminar vice chancellor univers read professor roger william host dinner honour mr söderman mr söderman address quot focu europ quot brief civil servic colleg london mr michael duggett princip lectur polici govern europ colleg chair brief question answer session speech mr söderman particip includ mr michael duggett mr john tate offic uk parliamentari commission uk pension ombudsman mr julian parri mr margaret batti civil servic colleg mr nick brien offic uk legal servic ombudsman mr keith finch ministri agricultur novemb mr ian harden present work european ombudsman confer organis commun council lancashir speaker includ mr toni cunningham mep mr alan watson offic parliamentari commission administr ms alison hook commiss represent confer chair mr patricia thoma commission local administr england event februari mr söderman gave lectur role european ombudsman approxim student université robert schuman strasbourg event organis european parliament framework quot european week quot place hemicycl strasbourg februari mr sandra piszk ombudsman costa rica paid visit european ombudsman strasbourg peruvian ombudsman mr jorg santistevan de noriega visit brussel antenna european ombudsman offic met mr peter dyrberg senior legal offic februari februari mr söderman mr harden met mr gérard beliard head intern relat depart citi strasbourg mr söderman gave lectur role european ombudsman member eu committe american chamber commerc belgium meet place strasbourg march australian ambassador franc mr john michael spender visit european ombudsman strasbourg march mr söderman met mr jan grevstad counsellor mission norwai european union march strasbourg march ian harden gave talk centr european polici studi brussel entitl quot work european ombudsman offic quot march mr peter dyrberg gave talk role european ombudsman student saxoni anhalt march mr fahri ozturk presid conseil de supervis état la présidenc turkei mr nuri tortop member council paid visit european ombudsman visit organis french ministri foreign affair part offici trip franc dr gökhan çapoglu chairman parti chang turkei member turkish parliament visit european ombudsman april april mr olivi verheeck receiv group student professor scuola media statal belluno itali gave present work european ombudsman april mr söderman gave lectur student polit scienc strasbourg centr syracus univers york usa april mr peter dyrberg gave talk work european ombudsman teacher saxoni anhalt receiv group danish journalist spoke ombudsman latest achiev april mr söderman made present work european ombudsman group member associ quot international kolpingwerk quot audienc includ german swiss austrian hungarian czech polish slovak nation meet place framework annual visit european parliament strasbourg april mr söderman gave lectur group student univers bayreuth germani mr peter dyrberg gave talk quot open govern transpar quot seminar quot parliament net quot organis european centr parliamentari research document brussel mr söderman present work group student univers jyväskylä finland visit brussel context european dai european parliament organis open dai brussel strasbourg estim visitor brussel strasbourg larg number visit ombudsman stand leopold build brussel ip strasbourg gener inform provid ombudsman staff present stand inform materi distribut member european inform associ unit kingdom estonia austria itali report mr söderman work ombudsman futur ombudsman websit mr söderman gave insight work member eu committe finnish parliament mr söderman invit give lectur finnish high offici particip train session centr de étude européenn strasbourg secretari gener chilean communist parti ms gladi marin visit european parliament paid visit mr söderman ian harden gave lectur role european ombudsman member finnish associ auditor state administr strasbourg peter dyrberg gave talk member danish union hk handel århu brussel ms vicki kloppenburg gave present work european ombudsman group journalist finland visit european parliament brussel invit mep astrid thor mr jukka pasanen vice chancellor justic finland mr jukka okko referendari counsellor offic chancellor justic paid visit ombudsman peter dyrberg attend confer organis european univers institut florenc theme quot eu human right agenda year quot ian harden gave lectur role european ombudsman group student leiden law faculti led professor dr schermer june june mr söderman present work group member nation centr cultur lisbon invit visit european parliament mep vaz da silva ian harden gave lectur role european ombudsman group stagiair centr de étude supérieur de la fonction publiqu territorial june june catalonian ombudsman mr anton cañella balcel visit brussel antenna ombudsman offic accompani mr jan goorden ombudsman flemish commun belgium exchang view peter dyrberg request montgela societi promot franco bavarian cooper group high offici bavaria lectur mr söderman juli juli mr söderman receiv group student quot gymnasium geretsri quot germani visit european parliament gave lectur role activ professor roi gregori centr ombudsman studi univers read visit ombudsman offic juli exchang view mr söderman mr harden mr ian harden gave lectur role european ombudsman group journalist pakistan bangladesh visit european journal centr septemb septemb mr peter dyrberg gave speech finnish group univers student work ombudsman citizen access inform octob mr söderman met group leiden student associ give review european ombudsman role duti mr ian harden gave present complain european ombudsman seminar organis institut de haut étude européenn novemb strasbourg novemb mr söderman receiv danish group student handelssolen ballerup strasbourg novemb mr benita brom gave overview role european ombudsman group finnish judg lawyer visit strasbourg mr söderman lectur quot le médiateur dan le systèm communautair rôle de la commiss de affair juridiqu quot union de avocat européen novemb strasbourg lectur role european ombudsman mr olivi verheeck decemb wageningen netherland mr xavier denoël decemb midi pyréné franc confer organis quot carrefour quot network rural inform centr media relat januari mr söderman interview anna paljakka journalist finnish newspap helsingin sanomat ms franc horsburgh glasgow herald interview mr söderman januari occas visit edinburgh scotland januari ian harden gave interview mr claud keiflin behalf la croix work european ombudsman mr eva spira interview mr söderman swedish paper statstjänstemannen journalist swedish newspap dagen industri finnish kauppalehti interview ombudsman strasbourg februari februari mr söderman gave brief deleg danish journalist attend seminar strasbourg ms zornitza venkova bulgarian journalist work bulgarian nation televis interview mr söderman quarterli public entitl europ magazin februari march mr päivi palm interview mr söderman newspap turun sanomat mr terttu levonen interview mr söderman march newspap aamulehti european ombudsman visit portug april receiv broad media coverag televis sic portugues newspap diário de notícia press confer organis brussel april present annual report committe petit mr edward newman vice chairman committe petit particip press confer april mr söderman gave telephon interview mr seznec french public jour europ april mr söderman interview ms berna harbour journalist nation newspap el paí visit inform offic european parliament madrid pedro danish journalist interview mr söderman danish paper ekstra bladet strasbourg mr gill bessec interview mr ian harden radio franc international programm quot accent europ quot journalist ms jill morrel present quot focu europ quot hear civil servic colleg london interview mr söderman british satellit new interview film footag brief circul world uk foreign commonwealth offic june mr söderman interview newspap dagen nyhet new agenc tt stockholm june german journalist mr michal kalz interview mr söderman mr söderman gave interview role activ mr dian klein radio televis luxembourg juli juli mr söderman gave telephon interview mr jouni tanninen finnish yle radio juli mr söderman attend press lunch ep inform offic london juli press confer arrang strasbourg present annual report ombudsman european parliament dai mr söderman gave interview mr björn månsson finnish swedish paper hufvudstadsbladet juli mr söderman interview mr roland krimm le temp suiss radio suiss romand mr jesper vind jensen danish paper søndagsavisen interview mr söderman juli dai mr söderman interview ms tiziana di simon rai radio roma juli mr christin holzbauer madison interview ombudsman french yearli magazin anné européenn juli mr söderman gave interview mr alfredo sotillo abc españa lar ströman journalist danish paper europ posten interview mr söderman august mr söderman gave interview mr markku möttönen journalist finnish radio yle octob octob mr bernard stasi médiateur de la républiqu mr söderman gave joint press confer occas visit strasbourg french ombudsman octob mr olivi verheeck gave interview belgian radio rtbf programm quot radio quot octob mr söderman gave interview greek tv programm quot european parliament citizen quot dai interview mr muller german radio iad mr mauro bellabarba italian rai radio interview mr söderman daili programm european institut octob mr söderman gave interview finnish swedish paper hufvudstadsbladet octob la télévision suiss romand made programm work european ombudsman interview mr söderman novemb strasbourg novemb mr söderman gave interview finnish tv yle quot citizen europ quot novemb mr söderman interview french investir magazin mr jakob vind larsen interview mr söderman commiss monthli paper europa novemb novemb mr söderman gave interview mr brandon mitchen wall street journal european parliament decis ecsc ec euratom march regul gener condit govern perform ombudsman duti oj oj oj projet de loi relatif aux droit de citoyen dan leur relat avec le administr assemblé national report high level panel free movement person chair mr simon veil submit commiss march report mr schaffner report high level panel free movement person chair mr simon veil committe civil liberti intern affair report high level panel free movement person page oj code conduct oj council decis ec decemb public access council document oj commiss decis ecsc ec euratom februari public access commiss document oj articl statut european ombudsman judgment june case commiss ecr staff law ii judgment march case casariego commiss ecr ii judgment juli case olbrecht commiss ecr judgment join case maurissen union syndical court auditor ecr establish case law commun court individu measur affect financi situat individu member subject legal review judgment march case weber parliament ecr instanc commiss comment ombudsman join complaint vk km vk cs vk report ombudsman annual report commiss plead case canter commiss judgment septemb ecr judgment april case netherland support parliament council support commiss franc ecr paragraph council decis ec oj case ecr case ecr ii svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june paragraph judgment oj oj case wwf uk commiss ecr ii paragraph oj oj case crimin proceed gianfranco perfili ecr council direct eec june relat coordin procedur award public servic contract oj amend council regul ec euratom ecsc oj commiss decis ecsc ec euratom februari public access commiss document oj commiss regul ec june applic articl treati categori motor vehicl distribut servic agreement oj replac earlier regul matter commiss regul eec oj oj oj judgment court justic march case guerin automobil ecr judgment court justic octob case gema commiss ecr judgment court instanc septemb case automec ii ecr ii council regul eec oj commiss regul ec oj oj complaint sp gr kt apf po ef po case adia interim sa commiss ecr ii paragraph case agenc européenn interim commiss ecr paragraph oj commiss regul euratom ecsc ec decemb lai detail rule implement provis financi regul decemb oj council regul eec oj case ipk münchen gmbh commiss paragraph join case industria pesquera campo commiss ecr ii paragraph judgment decemb case otto witt kg hauptzollamt hamburg ericu ecr oj commiss manual oper procedur section council direct eec decemb mutual accept personnel licenc exercis function civil aviat oj oj commiss franc case ecr pd decis octob council direct eec june packag travel packag holidai packag tour oj packag travel packag holidai packag tour regul si pd report european ombudsman annual report pp commiss annual report monitor applic commun law introduct pp iii iv final quot appoint success candid medic examin institut medic offic neg medic opinion result medic examin candid dai notifi opinion institut request case submit opinion medic committe quot oj case itali commiss ecr case commiss chambr syndical national de entrepris de transport de fond valeur sytrav brink franc sarl judgment april paragraph oj commiss decis oj oj oj state ombudsman previou decis complaint jpb pd dk quot slight discrep languag version provis danish version rightli term fornødn impress administr approach hand instanc english french german spanish swedish version term approprié geeigneten adecuada lämpliga impli suitabl administr approach made quot european ombudsman annual report page initi inquiri commiss administr procedur relat citizen complaint nation author european ombudsman annual report statut european ombudsman articl quot framework aforement treati ombudsman uncov maladministr activ commun institut bodi action author person subject complaint ombudsman quot join case salerno commiss ecr case verzyck commiss ecr case olivi fascilla parliament ecr ii paragraph rule quot bureau author respons authoris meet committe usual place work hear studi fact find journei rapporteur quot rule quot committe agreement bureau parliament instruct member undertak studi fact find mission quot decis ecsc ec euratom european parliament march regul gener condit govern perform ombudsman duti oj quot ombudsman seek solut institut bodi concern elimin instanc maladministr satisfi complaint quot octob european ombudsman secretari gener commiss agre inform meet case provid pursu friendli solut complaint accord articl statut case biedermann court auditor ecr case judgment novemb van hecken econom social committe ecr ii case judgment novemb van hecken econom social committe ecr ii council decis ec decemb oj oj case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june paragraph quot consult applic institut concern find fair solut compli repeat applic relat larg document quot case john carvel guardian newspap council ecr ii world wide fund natur wwf commiss ecr ii case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june paragraph council decis ec decemb oj case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june paragraph case john carvel guardian newspap council ecr ii world wide fund natur wwf commiss ecr ii note council decis ec decemb oj case interporc commiss judgment februari paragraph case gerard van der wal commiss judgment march paragraph case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june case john carvel guardian newspap council ecr ii paragraph case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june state ombudsman previou decis complaint jpb pd dk quot slight discrep languag version provis danish version rightli term fornødn impress administr approach hand instanc english french german spanish swedish version term approprié geeigneten adecuada lämpliga impli suitabl administr approach made quot european ombudsman annual report page case verzyck commiss ecr paragraph case van hecken esc ecr ii council decis ec decemb oj cirea stand quot centr inform discuss exchang asylum quot case svenska journalistförbundet tidningen journalisten council judgment june paragraph oj oj ecr leybucht case subsequ complain refer judgment august case commiss spain ecr santoña case judgment august case ecr case pd report annual report section council regul februari regul implement articl treati oj english special edit seri case amp commiss ecr case orkem commiss ecr council direct eec juli mutual recognit diploma certif evid formal qualif practition dentistri includ measur facilit effect exercic establish freedom provid servic oj council direct eec juli coordin provis laid law regul administr action respect activ dental practition oj recent case order court instanc chamber februari smanor sa hubert ségaud moniqu ségaud commiss european commun ect ii case judgment februari interporc im und export gmbh commiss ecr ii paragraph case wwf uk commiss ecr ii paragraph quot case sick traine notifi advis immedi absent dai produc medic certif indic probabl length absenc advis forward train divis requir undergo medic examin interest servic quot case commiss ecr oj oj oj oj innov activ fourth framework programm research technolog develop dissemin optimis result judgment novemb case azienda agricola quot le cann quot commiss ecr ii paragraph administr liabil explain usher quot good administr commun law quot current legal problem council direct eec decemb oj council regul ec establish cohes fund oj council direct eec june assess effect public privat project environ oj pd report european ombudsman annual report pp commiss annual report monitor applic commun law introduct pp iii iv final judgment june case schloh council ecr paragraph case koyo seiko council ecr ii paragraph titl vi treati european union quot pillar quot titl treati european union quot pillar quot case netherland council ecr oj amend propos council regul euratom ecsc ec amend staff regul offici condit employ servant european commun respect equal treatment final march case gaygusuz austria judgment septemb intern coven civil polit right adopt decemb judgment juli join case ferrario commiss european commun ecr candid perform compulsori militari servic form compulsori servic candid time paid employ year interrupt order depend child compulsori school ag certifi suffer sever mental physic handicap candid physic handicap ag limit rais ag limit appli candid close date submiss applic serv continu offici servant european commun year ag limit rais candid paid employ year order child year ag live case ag limit rais period paid employ allow year child maximum year candid compulsori militari servic form compulsori servic requir countri origin ag limit rais durat servic period voluntari servic period compulsori servic account candid physic handicap compat duti perform duli recognis compet nation author ag limit rais year oj oj annex annex statist work european ombudsman cover period januari decemb gt tabl gt annex ombudsman budget articl financi regul european commun ombudsman transmit european parliament year estim revenu expenditur year statut european ombudsman ombudsman budget annex section european parliament gener budget european commun publish offici journal european commun salari allow cost relat employ contain titl budget titl includ cost mission titl budget cover build equip miscellan oper expenditur titl singl chapter ecu subscript intern ombudsman organis paid avoid unnecessari duplic administr technic staff servic need ombudsman provid european parliament term framework agreement cooper european parliament european ombudsman date octob framework agreement complet agreement administr cooper budgetari financi cooper sign octob servic provid ombudsman involv addit direct expenditur parliament charg made payment effect liaison account rental offic translat servic largest item expenditur dealt begin establish plan ombudsman consist post end post temporari total amount appropri ombudsman budget ecu titl salari allow cost relat employ amount ecu titl build equip miscellan oper expenditur amount ecu addit appropri ecu transfer year conting reserv european parliament final figur appropri ecu gt tabl gt revenu consist deduct remuner ombudsman staff amount budget receipt ecu budget budget prepar establish plan repres increas establish plan appropri post enter reserv total appropri ecu titl salari allow cost relat employ amount ecu titl build equip miscellan oper expenditur ecu titl ecu budget total revenu deduct remuner ombudsman staff ecu agreement compet servic parliament budget estim prepar assumpt exist agreement cooper continu oper budget includ quot manag fee quot ecu cover cost european parliament provid servic consist sole staff time administr contract salari allow rang comput servic inclus manag fee improv transpar budget repres addit cost compar budget previou year prepar form annex budget european parliament accord legal provis forc budget separ conting reserv basi ombudsman request transfer parliament conting reserv annex personnel european ombudsman jacob söderman secretariat european ombudsman ian harden head secretariat tel peter dyrberg princip legal advis brussel antenna ea tel josé martínez aragón princip legal advis tel olivi verheeck legal offic tel vicki kloppenburg legal offic brussel antenna ea tel benita brom legal offic tel xavier denoël traine auxiliari legal offic tel ida palumbo traine auxiliari legal offic temporari agent tel alessandro del bon traine auxiliari legal offic tel ilta helkama press offic tel ben hagard internet commun offic tel panayoti thanou financ offic alexandro kamani financ offic tel daniela tirelli assist nathali christmann administr offic tel ursula garderet secretari brussel antenna ea tel anna ruscitti secretari brussel antenna ea tel muriel richardson secretari european ombudsman leav tel isabel foucaud secretari tel stephani kunz secretari act secretari european ombudsman tel isabel lecestr auxiliari secretari tel mari andré schwoob auxiliari secretari tel patrick schmitt usher leav charl meb usher tel hanna mari anttilainen traine henrik leffler traine maria engleson traine tel peter bonnor traine brussel antenna ea tel contact european ombudsman strasbourg post european ombudsman av du président robert schuman bp strasbourg cedex telephon fax mail euro ombudsman europarl eu int websit http www euro ombudsman eu int brussel telephon fax