commiss decis june programm land thuringia invest small medium size enterpris implement notifi document number german version authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment regard comment receiv procedur octob commiss decid authoris thuringia programm sme invest kmu investitionsprogramm de land thüringen hereinaft refer quot scheme quot amend version notifi authoris commiss octob notifi scheme cover period provid product invest aid letter date august regist receiv august germani formal rule possibl aid grant firm difficulti rule aid expressli mention commiss decis commiss authoris scheme limit undertak difficulti decis april commiss authoris extens aid scheme period subject amend condit laid time commiss express doubt scheme appli past conform version notifi approv commiss doubt base inform germani annual report inform light inform commiss rule possibl aid grant rescu restructur firm difficulti commiss order germani injunct suppli inform mean judgment court justic quot italgrani quot case provid inform enabl commiss decid aid grant accord approv scheme list case aid grant firm time aid grant regard firm difficulti inform condit aid grant comment august germani acknowledg authoris aid scheme rescu restructur aid grant germani state grant aid automat check carri determin recipi firm good health letter provid inform relev case condit aid grant inform injunct requir commiss unabl determin scheme appli accord notifi approv version letter date decemb commiss inform germani decid initi proceed articl ec treati order examin applic scheme past case appli decis initi proceed commiss note germani provid inform relev individu case requir inform injunct scheme appli improp manner basi abovement court judgment commiss decid assess conform manner scheme appli past aid involv commiss gave germani notic articl procedur submit observ suppli inform consid assess aid applic individu case letter commiss requir germani month receiv letter submit document inform data assess aid individu aid case compat list individu specif item inform submit point receiv inform decis base fact possess absenc inform need reach find compat regard incompat common market individu grant aid made scheme letter commiss ask germani forward copi letter aid recipi commiss decis initi proceed publish offici journal european commun commiss gave interest parti notic submit comment measur comment interest parti receiv commiss letter date march regist receiv march regist receiv germani submit comment proceed letter date septemb regist receiv septemb respons request made commiss germani provid inform number firm exist receiv aid scheme descript aid purpos aid scheme promot modernis develop exist sme face econom difficulti make transit market economi promot sme manufactur industri type invest elig purpos recit origin notif juli product invest exclud acquisit land invest restructur programm letter august germani state restructur measur rescu restructur firm difficulti relat invest econom sound firm purpos set establish extend modernis exist establish introduc product process total amount estim aid programm initi eur million subsequ increas eur million aid initi invest grant form subsidi limit eur million project take account region ceil applic land thuringia maximum ceil case larg firm extra percentag point articl area sme mean definit commun guidelin state aid small medium size enterpris applic time aid scheme approv commiss guidelin total grant made firm aid scheme scheme grant aid conting present long term busi plan ground initi formal investig procedur reason prompt commiss initi formal investig procedur articl ec treati applic aid scheme hitherto individu case applic base find contrari inform provid author germani grant aid firm difficulti aid scheme improperli appli firm difficulti modal reason compat commiss polici aid firm difficulti aid scheme requir individu notif aid firm difficulti firm oper sensit industri make grant aid depend submiss implement restructur plan design ensur restor econom viabil firm period restrict aid amount requir achiev goal letter inform germani initi articl proceed commiss call germani inform case aid scheme grant firm time aid grant regard healthi firm time aid grant regard difficulti desir inform relat detail size firm extent aid amount intens aid relat plan invest total amount public aid grant firm year prior grant aid examin financi situat firm time aid grant abovement letter commiss point germani decid aid scheme individu case applic aid grant firm difficulti comment germani letter date march germani submit tabl show time aid grant firm regard firm difficulti healthi firm healthi firm grant aid number grant aid healthi firm rise assess result examin situat firm time aid approv german author letter date septemb germani correct tabl state firm previous regard difficulti regard healthi firm mean total case aid grant firm difficulti case grant total healthi firm examin individu case applic germani carri case recipi firm oper basi questionnair number employe balanc sheet total equiti return annual deficit turnov ratio capit total capit cash flow capac utilis inform provid germani letter date cover year prior grant aid case newli set compani year grant aid letter march germani instanc posit present data intens aid grant number employe balanc sheet total turnov provid inform offici aid public resourc inform lack regard firm regard healthi list ii regard difficulti list case firm list inform omit ground firm question time firm germani offer explan unabl provid inform request commiss germani put forward argument applic aid scheme letter septemb germani inform commiss firm regard healthi oper market inform firm difficulti recipi firm oper market assess aid law aid decis octob octob commiss approv aid scheme compat common market articl ec treati reason land thuringia recognis assist region articl ec treati aid intens provid scheme accept view econom difficulti region promot develop creation job sme lastli firm manufactur industri good surviv prospect elig commiss specif check scheme appli firm difficulti contrari germani state letter august aid grant period firm difficulti meantim declar bankruptci confirm germani proceed comment march septemb germani acknowledg post examin econom situat firm time aid grant futur prospect firm classifi firm difficulti commiss note examin includ assess profit turnov excess capac cash flow debt net asset note germani base examin criteria laid guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti evid data germani grant aid firm difficulti regard larg firm mean commiss definit notif aid scheme initi version amend version germani origin compli oblig articl ec treati improperli appli aid scheme manner cover authoris germani creat de facto seri unnotifi unlaw individu case applic commiss regret germani compli express statement appli aid scheme firm difficulti aid cover commiss authoris regard unlaw germani state instanc inform ensur grant aid region ceil cumul rule correct applic sme bonu compli commiss note germani prove correct applic aid scheme healthi firm incumb member state ensur complianc condit aid scheme authoris provid proof thereof full inform provid commiss conclus aid cover commiss authoris regard unlaw commiss task determin aid grant framework scheme purpos injunct mean quot italgrani quot judgment issu basi inform commiss decid unspecifi number individu grant aid made accord provis scheme initi proceed respect individu case light inform possibl exist individu case aid grant made accord provis scheme absenc final list individu grant aid allegedli made complianc scheme commiss simultan initi proceed aid scheme improp applic commiss aim carri gener abstract examin improperli appli aid scheme basi determin directli compat ec treati proceed germani submit commiss list grant aid allegedli made complianc scheme firm germani case view aid grant firm difficulti acknowledg aid cover scheme germani case view aid grant healthi firm grant aid firm submit albeit incomplet inform case inform present respons inform injunct present initi proceed mean submit late take account circumst case commiss decid initi proceed examin individu case germani fact cover aid scheme inform provid germani relev case aid recipi firm involv firm time aid grant allegedli healthi fefa fenster amp fassaden produkt gmbh zeulenroda thüringer dämmstoffwerk gmbh bad berka marit gmbh vertriebsgesellschaft für gärtnerei und floristik artikel bad salzungen schlacht und verarbeitung gmbh jena topogramm gesellschaft für erderkundung und rauminform mbh altenburg konstrukt holz werk saubert khw gmbh amp kg serba trotz wemag werkzeug maschinen kunststofftechnik gmbh nordhausen wilhelm steinberg pianofortefabrik gmbh eisenberg möbelwerkstätten nützel zeulenroda sapa leichtmetallguss sömmerda gmbh sömmerda wegra anlagenbau gmbh westenfeld metallwerk langensalza gmbh bad langensalza york travelwar gmbh kindelbrück rhönmetal gmbh dermbach nti technolog instrument gmbh kahla stahl und anlagebau grüssing gmbh kambachsmühl metallgestaltung han reich gotha schlossbrauerei schwarzbach gmbh gefo folienbetrieb gmbh gera bike system gmbh amp thüringer radwerk kg nordhausen metzgerei holger bennewitz meder reed gmbh fux hof werlich gbr großbreitenbach fein elast umspinnwerk gmbh zeulenroda bäckerei und konditorei bretschneid sägewerk crawinkel gmbh wiegand gbr hausgerät altenburg gmbh analytik jena gmbh oplibel produkt gmbh appar und industrieanlagenbau grüssing gmbh kunststoffverarbeitung tiefenort gmbh kahla thüringen porzellan gmbh kahla case germani state posit check circumst aid grant firm wound firm longer oper inform case commiss basi inform assess aid cover scheme healthi firm categori germani posit give inform intens aid grant firm inform contain document grant aid marit gmbh vertriebsgesellschaft für gärtnerei und floristik artikel bad salzungen topogramm gesellschaft für erderkundung und rauminform mbh altenburg germani case inform aid intens scheme compli commiss establish relev aid cover scheme case firm germani similarli unabl sme inform contain document grant aid marit gmbh vertriebsgesellschaft für gärtnerei und floristik artikel bad salzungen topogramm gesellschaft für erderkundung und rauminform mbh altenburg kahla porzellan gmbh kahla germani provid inform respect grant aid aid invest aid programm grant invest assist programm land thuringia invest allow scheme commiss specif request inform initi proceed summaris commiss note applic scheme firm marit topogramm kahla unlaw case scheme appli firm time aid grant healthi commiss view cover approv scheme provid amount public aid promot relev invest exce intens gross case larg firm firm statu unknown cf recit gross case aid compli condit unlaw contrast aid compli condit investig view compat common market exist state aid question grant aid firm germani difficulti healthi firm fall scope scheme constitut state aid commiss view present case complianc condit contain aid scheme examin commiss examin relat question compat common market question state aid involv aid scheme instrument member state grant benefit firm fulfil condit laid scheme germani grant ad hoc aid notifi case individu commiss commiss requir natur measur basi power ec treati council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati case law court justic carri gener abstract examin commiss examin individu state aid case fall scope exist scheme germani introduc appli aid scheme order achiev precis defin effect element establish aid scheme state aid contain scheme circumst case examin question aid grant scheme constitut state aid produc result individu aid case healthi firm firm difficulti case firm difficulti aid consid state aid mean articl ec treati member state notifi origin scheme state aid scheme approv commiss member state subsequ grant aid scope applic approv scheme commiss take view check exist state aid unlaw case individu germani request request accompani inform requir enabl commiss assess case individu inform provid commiss part full notif individu grant aid articl ec treati germani awar doubt commiss state regard case consid aid assess individu view specif featur requir provid detail commiss make commiss inform requir individu assess aid scheme aid promot product invest firm oper thuringia aid grant stem resourc land thuringia scheme make improv competit recipi firm viabl measur affect trade member state scheme compris state aid mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement respons inform injunct mean quot italgrani quot case procedur pursuant articl ec treati germani provid inform show aid fall scope applic articl ec treati compat aid common market derog exempt measur fall scope articl treati set articl articl articl applic scheme design promot develop sme thuringia make good damag caus natur disast except occurr compens econom disadvantag caus divis germani germani invok applic exempt provis commiss take view state aid cover derog provid articl ec treati intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb economi member state lastli scheme elig derog provid articl ec treati intend promot cultur heritag conserv scheme intend firm situat assist region articl ec treati except firm sensit industri assist region question commiss confirm maximum intens invest aid gross larg firm gross sme aid grant initi invest assess basi criteria govern region aid aid intend rescu restructur firm difficulti compat common market assess rule govern aid rescu restructur firm difficulti scheme appli period compat rule region aid case firm marit topogramm case scheme appli firm healthi time aid grant cover approv scheme total amount aid relev invest exce intens gross case larg firm firm unknown statu gross case compat aid common market assess provis applic time scheme improperli appli accord commiss notic determin applic rule assess unlaw state aid assess carri basi inform commiss dispos aid aid initi invest assess basi commiss commun method applic articl region aid conjunct point annex commiss commun region aid system annex quot initi invest quot defin invest fix asset creation establish extens exist establish engag activ involv fundament chang product product process exist establish mean rationalis restructur modernis invest fix asset takeov establish close close takeov place deem initi invest period question prejudic specif provis govern invest aid firm sensit industri aid scheme initi invest assist region deem compat common market result intens ceil recit sme larg firm exceed aid combin region aid unlaw case refer recit compat condit met case commiss basi inform dispos establish aid compat common market region aid germani inform intens ceil cumul ceil exceed surplu amount aid incompat common market compat rule restructur aid assess compat aid common market case germani acknowledg grant aid firm difficulti commiss take account fact restructur plan present case inform possess show plan exist aid grant repli request inform decis initi proceed germani confirm contrari previou assur scheme appli firm difficulti regard larg firm commiss examin invest aid grant firm difficulti deem compat common market commiss usual practic region aid promot initi invest firm difficulti grant region scheme prior notif condit aid account assess compat plan aid restructur firm difficulti implement provis aid rescu restructur firm difficulti present case aid firm difficulti grant approv region aid scheme contrari aid explicitli exclud scope applic approv scheme commiss requir check invest aid question regard form part restructur aid larg number case firm difficulti receiv aid unlaw applic scheme commiss consid region purpos aid establish inform provid germani recipi firm difficulti time aid grant graf von henneberg porzellan gmbh weida leder gmbh alpa gmbh textilwerk trieb kmp kunststoff und metallprodukt gmbh hohleborn porzellanambient reichenbach gmbh thüringer kleiderwerk alfr platz gmbh gotha bergwerksmaschinen diella gmbh diella franz götz kg gotha modedruck gera gmbh spezialverpackungen polymen gmbh gera forstbetriebsgemeinschaft katzhütt gmbh barbarossa brauerei gmbh artern zeuro möbelwerk gmbh zeulenroda lmg leichtmetallgiesserei gmbh gera artluminar leuchten gmbh stadlilm radisch textilbetrieb gmbh neustadt orta creaplat gmbh schlotheim thüringer motorenwerk und getriebetechnik gmbh nordhausen hewitt industriekeramik tripli uni push motoren und getriebetechnik gmbh pössneck feuerverzinkerei heldrungen gmbh heldrungen awa antriebstechnik gmbh weimar kyffhäus maschinenfabrik artem gmbh artem alzi metallveredelung gmbh wünschendorf göltzsch mühle spezialpapierfabrik greiz tpm pralinenmanufaktur gmbh issaroda mat maschinen und automatisierungstechnik gmbh großruderstedt stentex gmbh gera gd gotha druck und verpackung gmbh amp kg commiss take view individu aid promot invest firm difficulti deem compat common market compli rule govern aid firm difficulti state paragraph commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti commiss examin compat common market rescu restructur aid grant authoris breach articl treati quot basi guidelin forc time aid grant quot aid examin grant period rule applic aid grant breach articl treati commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti hereinaft refer quot guidelin quot commiss believ guidelin express usual practic restructur aid time aid grant scheme order draw distinct firm difficulti healthi firm commiss defin quot firm difficulti quot point guidelin firm quot unabl recov resourc rais fund sharehold borrow quot typic symptom firm difficulti quot deterior profit increas size loss diminish turnov grow inventori excess capac declin cash flow increas debt rise interest charg low net asset quot definit form basi decis confirm approach adopt hitherto commiss commiss note respect carri post examin recipi firm show firm difficulti time aid grant germani essenti base assess indic commiss note germani appli scheme approv form addit carri examin due time notifi case individu commiss extent aid scheme rescu restructur firm difficulti modal accord abovement guidelin order compat common market case rescu aid aid order deem compat form loan market term guarante enabl firm remain oper market limit period draw restructur plan condit met aid form grant case restructur aid scheme provid realist coher reach restructur plan design restor long term viabil firm take account circumst brought firm difficulti market situat relev sector forese develop guidelin scheme includ measur prevent undu distort competit ensur amount intens aid proport cost benefit restructur commiss note aid scheme provis germani present inform specif case individu grant commiss determin condit met aid scheme prior present quot coher long term busi plan quot requir analysi circumst brought firm declin realist assumpt enabl long term viabil firm restor fact germani acknowledg check recipi firm realist time aid grant expect viabil restor reason period time lack provis requir aid firm difficulti individu notifi restrict amount aid grant strict minimum restructur view lack inform individu grant aid rule applic time aid grant rescu restructur aid firm difficulti compli lastli recipi firm germani subsequ acknowledg difficulti declar bankruptci coher long term busi plan requir guidelin fulli implement commiss point request germani provid document data inform assess aid individu grant made scheme compat common market point inform assess compat individu grant aid deem incompat commiss take view individu grant aid incompat common market case aid scheme allow grant aid rescu restructur firm difficulti conclus except marit topogramm case aid firm healthi time aid grant cover exist scheme provid total amount offici aid grant relev invest exce intens gross case larg firm firm unknown statu recit gross case condit met examin compat common market requir individu case scheme appli includ grant aid firm time aid grant difficulti cover approv scheme aid grant invest small medium size enterpris basi improp applic programm land thuringia constitut state aid mean articl ec treati improp applic aid scheme period individu case result applic unlaw case scheme unlawfulli appli healthi firm improp applic scheme healthi firm incompat common market improp applic scheme allow rescu aid grant firm difficulti relev individu grant aid incompat common market extent improp applic scheme allow restructur aid grant firm difficulti complianc relev criteria individu notif requir prevent undu distort competit restrict strict minimum relev individu grant aid incompat common market accord commiss establish practic aid unlawfulli implement deem incompat common market pursuant articl treati recov recipi practic confirm articl regul ec state member state concern measur recov aid beneficiari inform commiss decis concern aid scheme improperli appli relev individu grant aid implement immedi recoveri individu grant aid grant scheme commiss point decis prejudic decis respect individu case applic subject proceed articl ec treati adopt decis articl programm land thuringia invest sme hereinaft refer quot scheme quot constitut state aid mean articl ec treati applic scheme breach provis unlaw articl firm difficulti aid aid scheme relev individu grant aid incompat common market promot initi invest econom healthi firm aid scheme relev individu grant aid compat common market provid maximum intens articl exceed part aid exce permit maximum intens incompat common market articl combin region aid aid initi invest exce maximum intens gross larg firm gross sme articl germani measur recov beneficiari illeg grant aid refer articl recoveri effect delai accord nation procedur provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date unlaw aid dispos beneficiari date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel june commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj aid sg oj aid sg aid nn sg case italian republ commiss ecr sg loc cit footnot oj letter march germani correct number case state annual report date aid scheme amend version approv number firm receiv aid scheme examin commiss oj aid period letter german author septemb firm oper regard firm difficulti healthi firm receiv aid scheme firm initi list firm difficulti letter septemb germani correct list state kahla regard econom healthi firm time aid grant individu case subject proceed articl ec treati present decis prejudic decis commiss case footnot oj case germani commiss ecr paragraph seq case itali commiss ecr paragraph seq case belgium commiss ecr paragraph join case itali sardinia line commiss ecr paragraph aid sg oj case applic applic rule region aid result favour assess recipi applic rule contain decis oj oj oj commiss chang practic adopt guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti oj propos measur articl ec treati invest aid larg firm difficulti notifi individu page guidelin nation region aid examin relat determin strict minimum viabil firm restor respect invest aid grant restructur project regard form part total aid aid exce strict minimum restor viabil oj declar bankruptci