commiss decis march aid itali plan grant enterpris state insolv result oblig repai state aid pursuant commun decis adopt articl treati italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun articl thereof notic accord subparagraph articl treati interest parti submit comment letter date decemb commiss inform italian govern decis initi articl procedur respect law lai rule applic extraordinari administr procedur provid law firm insolv due oblig repai state aid state public undertak compani pursuant decis commun institut adopt articl treati part procedur commiss gave italian govern notic submit comment inform member state interest parti public notic offici journal european commun comment receiv member state interest parti ii italian govern repli letter date februari detail receiv letter date june januari iii measur question provid applic extraordinari administr procedur law enterpris insolv caus oblig repai state public undertak compani public author major hold paid capit lit billion pursuanc decis commun institut adopt articl treati establish european econom commun italian author point provis appli firm nuova cartiera di arbatax subject commiss decis eec basi inform italian author telex date june repay aid incompat common market enter balanc sheet firm concern indic recognit debt actual repay sum end italian author announc set administr commiss review criteria applic law subsequ amend addit view abrog relev provis law iv law state aid mean articl treati articl agreement european econom area beneficiari enterpris present limit nuova cartiera di arbatax possibl extend enterpris futur continu enjoi advantag confer aid declar incompat commun law advantag deriv state aid firm concern requir repai previou commiss decis judgment commun court state guarante provid articl law reserv enterpris state insolv ow oblig repai aid commiss possibl commun court consid contrari articl treati view combin provis law no take account commun definit small medium size enterpris area state aid polici enterpris benefit measur question larg enterpris activ affect trade member state applic provis beneficiari illeg advantag liabl creat distort competit law refer aid commiss declar incompat common market oper eea agreement appli court justic upheld commiss decis provis compromis effect commun decis requir repay state aid incompat commun law perpetu unlaw advantag decis intend abolish propos measur appli beneficiari identifi law nation territori econom sector sector region purpos lack sector limit mean scope cover firm sensit industri subject strict commun monitor regard grant state aid regard specif case nuova cartiera di arbatax italian author state applic law accompani grant state guarante provid articl law aid measur law fact case point state resourc grant state aid subject commiss decis eec recipi continu enjoi mechan govern law nation law effect prevent repay state aid held incompat common market function eea agreement result avoid return situat prior aid prevent abolit advantag enjoi recipi result aid enabl recipi continu benefit advantag affect intra commun trade liabl creat distort competit aid scheme incompat common market function eea agreement pursuant articl treati articl agreement qualifi exempt articl ec treati articl eea agreement case nuova cartiera di arbatax firm benefit fresh aid retain aid declar incompat commun law subject recoveri order case applic law produc advantag aris public resourc constitut state aid incompat common market function european econom area pursuant articl treati articl eea agreement addit extend scope law enterpris requir repai state aid pursuant decis adopt articl treati law make recipi obtain state guarante provid articl law regard articl treati articl eea agreement principl adopt commiss area state guarante possibl caught articl seq treati articl seq eea agreement guarante subject payment premium recipi difficulti attest state insolv state guarante unabl obtain loan question market fortiori grant reciproc concess case conduct state diverg strongli privat oper similar circumst oper ration manner market applic law entail wai grant aid mean articl treati articl eea agreement measur question constitut illeg aid adopt notifi advanc accord articl treati applic notifi commiss italian author letter formal notic establish aid scheme provis regard exist aid cover procedur relat fundament provis law examin articl treati vi clear forego rule introduc law constitut state aid mean articl treati articl eea agreement incompat common market oper european econom area provis paragraph articl appli rule measur question aim individu design remedi damag caus natur disast extraordinari event region sector cultur purpos aim promot execut import project common european interest provis law incompat common market necessarili involv transfer fresh public resourc beneficiari enabl firm requir repai state aid continu enjoi advantag aid avoid give advantag grant breach commun law whilst possibl benefit addit advantag form state guarante articl law solut repeal provis law requir nuova cartiera di arbatax repai state aid incompat common market pursuant commiss decis eec italian govern formal undertak effect step possibl realiz depend outcom work carri administr commiss entrust task review criteria applic law hold decis make power conclud repeal law absolut prerequisit remov machineri give rise repeat infring articl treati articl eea agreement law appli case repay aid paid nuova cartiera di arbatax proce delai recoveri aid order restor situat prevail grant abolish financi econom advantag enjoi firm aid grant adopt decis articl aid measur provid law illeg notifi advanc commiss accord articl treati measur incompat common market oper agreement european econom area pursuant articl treati articl eea agreement articl itali requir repeal provis law articl itali notifi commiss month date notif decis step compli herewith articl decis address italian republ brussel march commiss karel van miert member commiss oj oj commun guidelin state aid small medium size enterpris oj letter sg april member state commun publish oj paragraph commun oj judgment court justic case tubemeus ecr