commiss decis novemb aid region tuscani itali intend grant livestock sector favour chianina cattl breed notifi document number italian text authent ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant aforement provis regard comment procedur letter date decemb italian perman represent european union notifi commiss articl treati aid scheme livestock sector favour chianina cattl breed letter date march receiv march juli receiv juli itali furnish commiss supplementari inform letter august commiss ask italian author view summer break work dai extens term due adopt decis aid concern letter date septemb commiss inform itali decis initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid italian perman represent inform commiss decis initi procedur letter sg date septemb commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment letter date octob decemb italian author submit commiss comment respect open procedur commiss receiv comment interest parti letter date januari forward itali opportun express view comment italian author letter date ii descript scheme implement period descript aid scheme notifi year programm protect improv chianina cattl breed local breed deriv chiana vallei tuscani origin scheme aim counter steadi declin characteris breed preserv possibl improv genet base help stockfarm bear addit cost result rear breed oppos product viabl data submit italian author popul breed decreas itali past year head present tabl show figur herd book develop past year tabl number cow head cattl regist herd book itali gt tabl gt data show doubl number head cow regist decreas annual averag rate origin dramat decreas wit breed primarili due advent mechanis farm practic consequ reduct number chianina draft anim purpos suit ow strength resist difficult work condit current declin essenti due high cost sustain stockfarm rear chianina low incom breed compar profit type cattl hold small locat difficult hilli mountain area mean scope economi scale cost reduct order surviv stockfarm tend slaughter anim femal reach calv approach result reduct genet base genet variabl breed jeopardis select process futur genet improv breed italian author fear long run declin endang breed actual prospect surviv measur plan counter trend measur aid establish artifici insemin programm financ pilot project product embryo high genet potenti take oocyt month heifer fertilis vitro semen breed bull implant fertilis embryo breed cow result femal sourc oocyt breed cow male breed bull genet test beneficiari measur urata union regional dell associazioni toscan allevatori region union associ stockfarm tuscani region carri pilot project measur aid purchas breed bull chianina breed hold list herd book aid form grant cover invest cost aid grant stockfarm rear chianina breed regist herd book locat region bui certifi breed bull measur aid mainten calv adult femal anim chianina breed born hold list herd book list herd book calv time hold list herd book aid form premium itl approxim eur head mean premium italian author hope encourag stockfarm femal breed anim sell fatten slaughter oper proven profit riski limit aid anim meet abovement requir italian author aim increas femal genet base breed aid grant stockfarm regist anim compli requir decis initi proceed articl treati commiss express strong doubt compat measur common market basi inform provid italian author measur oper aid intend reliev stockfarm cost dai dai manag activ proven favour structur effect develop sector respect measur hand commiss state substant point view measur principl elig derog provid articl treati commiss decid initi articl procedur respect measur view suspicion entir aid scheme notifi appli retrospect case invalid posit assess measur concern entir aid scheme fact lack element necess guid commiss assess state aid case oper aid incompat common market implement period aid scheme inform contain origin notif italian author scheme involv year programm run notifi propos decis region council present region execut giunta novemb provid budget alloc itl subsequ year refer made budget alloc itl financ measur scheme impli project carri prior present region council region execut propos decis provid aid scheme relev fund benefit measur word aid case paid retrospect expenditur incur potenti beneficiari legal entitl appli aid circumst aid lost charact necess oper assist carri absenc aid legal undertak public author pai aid aid constitut oper aid structur effect sector incompat common market clarifi point commiss ask italian author letter date januari measur programm implement implement period programm notifi decemb amend time letter date march italian author repli quot aid measur provid programm implement implement period initi laid amend quot commiss understood aid paid aid paid expenditur incur potenti beneficiari legal entitl aid commiss decid initi procedur respect measur scheme notifi view retrospect natur aid iii comment interest parti commiss receiv comment parti urata union regional associazioni toscan allevatori beneficiari measur letter januari copa committe agricultur organis european union letter januari posit parti ident letter parti stress uniqu qualiti chianina cattl breed import breed economi margin area stockfarm face difficult live work condit neglig impact aid competit trade member state parti express full support initi undertaken itali protect breed counter declin light consider call commiss revis posit authoris programm entireti action late chianina breed endang iv comment itali letter octob italian author commiss delibera della giunta regional decis region execut octob incorpor comment inform request procedur initi pursuant articl ec treati letter itali ask commiss extens month period submiss comment comment submit letter decemb comment submit italian author letter octob focu point itali rais object procedur argu commiss fail respect month time limit case law court justic make posit aid measur notifi articl ec treati itali maintain commiss express posit month march date itali repli commiss request januari addit inform italian author question valid addit letter commiss april written confirm decis withdraw measur notifi aid scheme argu letter request addit inform reiter request made letter januari italian author repli letter march april letter effect suspend month time limit expir commiss order artifici extend normal deadlin italian author question commiss interpret natur aid measur premium grant heifer list herd book calv time hold list herd book defin commiss aid quot mainten quot anim italian author aid quot incent quot extens femal genet base breed hold list herd book encourag farmer rear quot breed purpos quot femal anim featur genet improv breed thirdli italian author disput commiss view period implement programm possibl aid grant retrospect expenditur incur claim chosen year implement programm fund year refer made region budget budget year programm submit approv region council italian author maintain evid programm implement advis amend stage avoid delai assess procedur commiss intent await complet procedur initi notif commiss commiss reach decis implement programm remaind initi year period extend durat implement period decis region council time reach year initi envisag plan notifi commiss extens accord articl treati final italian author question approach commiss assess measur argu commiss assess aid light articl compar measur exist legisl previou case recal similar measur favour chianina breed approv commiss framework integr mediterranean programm tuscani measur programm provid premium ecu anim born specif stockfarm reach ag chianina breed elig aid measur adopt encourag stockfarm part genet improv project addit letter decemb italian author drew attent commiss specif qualiti chianina cattl econom disadvantag connect rear breed genet declin limit amount aid neglig extent trade breed commun level comment italian author reaction observ parti add observ commiss assess procedur comment made italian author commiss failur compli month time limit unfound letter march italian author state categor prepar withdraw measur notifi aid scheme fact seri telephon contact commiss italian offici telephon convers place normal spirit cooper characteris commiss relationship member state possibl amend programm line suggest commiss discuss possibl withdraw measur left open italian author refer convers made letter commiss italian author april repli italian author juli point commiss letter april telephon convers italian author exclud withdraw measur concern light develop perfectli legitim commiss written confirm itali final posit remain ambival till moment italian author convinc letter commiss april suspens effect inform commiss expiri time limit commiss decis view decis put measur effect provid case law court justic wait commiss final decis aid fact italian author prefer wait till juli repli commiss letter april wait month provid answer made clear letter march commiss authoris aid give ground legitim expect exist system mean articl treati italian perman represent inform commiss decis initi articl procedur letter sg date septemb state point substanc articl ec treati aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market articl council regul eec june common organis market beef veal lai save provid regul articl treati appli product trade product list articl includ product cover measur issu notifi programm grant aid public resourc specif agricultur undertak undeni grant undu econom financi advantag detriment agricultur undertak receiv contribut case law court justic improv competit posit undertak result state financi aid lead distort competit compar compet undertak receiv assist italian author claim amount aid low distort competit born mind low level aid modest size beneficiari undertak rule possibl trade member state distort agricultur sector reflect commiss commun de minimi aid exclud agricultur applic de minimi rule measur affect trade member state fact substanti intra commun trade beef itali import beef eu member state total tonn export eu state total tonn year itali produc cattl ecu output eu ecu specif data commun level trade breed concern aid order demonstr aid influenc trade member state italian author refer chianina beef product tonn mention year figur relat relev market account specif case issu eu beef market includ type beef chianina beef compet compet market substitut product replac chianina beef consum bui pattern court justic held aid undertak affect trade member state distort competit undertak compet product come member state export product member state grant aid undertak domest product reason maintain increas result undertak establish member state chanc export product market member state aid affect trade member state distort competit commiss conclud measur caught prohibit articl ec treati prohibit articl exempt articl exempt list articl manifestli inapplic natur aid measur question object itali submit articl applic articl specifi circumst state aid consid compat common market compat common market assess point view commun individu member state interest function common market exempt ban state aid interpret restrict articl manifestli inapplic aid intend promot develop area standard live abnorm low underemploy regard articl aid question intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb itali economi aid intend achiev suitabl achiev object refer articl articl treati aid design facilit develop econom activ econom area consid compat common market provid aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest notifi aid scheme assess framework articl specif provis applic case issu measur aid implement project genet improv breed purchas pure bred male breed stock decis initi procedur articl ec treati commiss stress principl adopt favour approach respect measur judg merit compat common market benefit derog provid articl fact consist commiss practic set letter member state date septemb authoris aid elig expenditur implement artifici insemin programm maximum durat year aid cost anim purchas pure bred male breed anim list herd book measur exce durat aid rate set letter consid principl compat common market commiss decid initi articl procedur respect measur strong doubt retrospect natur entir aid scheme confirm retrospect aspect aid invalid posit assess measur concern aid oper aid aid produc last structur effect develop sector consid compat common market inform provid italian author letter octob dispel commiss doubt retrospect natur notifi aid scheme exclud possibl aid paid expenditur incur prospect beneficiari elig aid author undertaken notifi commiss decis amend implement period measur consid compat common market accord articl ec treati measur aid mainten calv femal breed anim meet specif requir aid cover measur concern premium mainten calv femal anim chianina breed meet specif requir aid form quot quot premium itl livestock unit function unit product principl incompat common market aid base quantiti produc market price product mean product anim feed type aid regard oper aid aid simpli confer short term econom advantag object aid cut beneficiari product cost durat aid reliev busi cost sustain dai dai manag busi aid structur effect develop sector consid facilit econom develop econom activ econom area payment aid interfer oper mechan establish common market organis framework agricultur polici disadvantag produc receipt aid except strict rule prohibit type aid provid commiss letter member state point authoris grant aid rate retent pure bred male breed anim justifi special consider region natur except refer grant aid mainten quot male quot breed anim quot femal quot breed anim measur address cover argu except appli quot analog quot femal anim line commiss practic case fact provis except strict rule prohibit aid base unit product regard oper aid definit mean interpret strictli reason approach male femal breed anim li total natur type aid rear high qualiti male breed anim major factor process genet develop qualit improv livestock sector decis high qualiti male anim regist herd book breed purpos prevent lucr busi meat product decid anim breed meat product stockfarm chosen costli high risk invest pai long term expens maintain breed bull slaughter price extrem low insuffici offset cost mainten stockfarm tend reduc number breed bull long consequ eventu deterior genet heritag provid except case anim commiss consid light consider distort impact aid measur base unit product counterbalanc posit effect measur structur develop livestock sector reason appli femal breed anim stockfarm choos mutual exclus femal anim breed milk meat product reduct case premium livestock unit cover cost mainten constitut aid stockfarm reduc normal oper cost busi premium caught definit oper aid explain point incompat common market benefit except provid articl except refer point relat exclus male breed anim case interpret strictli appli quot analog quot line commiss practic case femal breed anim premium femal breed anim chianina breed caught gener prohibit oper aid reason outlin point incompat definit common market benefit except provid articl italian author contest commiss interpret measur aid mainten anim stress aid quot incent quot design quot orient quot produc rear femal anim breed purpos meat product connect worth recal orient product incom support object task common organis market repeatedli held court justic complet exhaust system exclud power part member state measur derog jeopardis respect aid interf mechan market organis automat exclud applic except provid articl applic regul eec derog prohibit claim italian author aid grant anim belong breed danger extinct accord commun criteria case aid fall scope council regul eec june agricultur product method compat requir protect environ mainten countrysid protect endang breed recognis action contribut achiev purpos regul protect improv genet divers measur type elig part financ state aid mean articl regul authoris member state implement addit aid measur aid grant term laid regul amount exce limit stipul provid aid measur compli object regul articl treati compat object regul assess basi criteria set commun level establish breed danger extinct part financ purpos commiss breed danger extinct purpos regul eec number breed femal anim ceil list tabl breed femal breed gt tabl gt addit total number breed femal regist herd book tabl breed femal regist herd book gt tabl gt data submit italian author report tabl number femal breed anim regist herd book thirteen time commiss ceil femal breed anim regist figur repres entir femal breed popul figur set defin endang breed chianina breed danger extinct fall scope regul eec italian author disput breed danger extinct maintain current trend continu unab action counter risk subsequ danger commiss examin scheme light exist legisl preced assess broader view basi articl regard measur facilit develop sector affect trade extent contrari common interest respect fear express italian author extinct breed data submit italian author report tabl show mention point chianina popul decreas yearli averag rate tabl declin year dramat increas breed popul doubl support argument italian author submit project show current downward trend continu pace year number regist femal drop current make calcul italian author account effect aid measur commiss express favour opinion principl mention figur case time commun ceil observ commiss approach assess measur recal articl except gener prohibit state aid laid articl interpret strictli appli commiss fulli satisfi criteria laid articl met measur notifi aid scheme pursu object measur meet requir fact authoris commiss oper aid provid measur meet criteria definit authoris italian author provid sound argument refut commiss assess aid oper aid quantifi quot addit cost quot incom loss incur stockfarm proport relat cost plan premium origin notif italian author simpli defin amount premium quot quot letter decemb make gener refer fact aid cover aforement addit cost detail commiss note premium eur envisag italian author breed danger extinct higher premium provid regul eec eur endang breed econom argument submit explain difficulti face chianina stockfarm justifi grant premium gener natur gener weak livestock sector nation level structur condit stockfarm environment factor lack economi scale lack qualiti assur system strategi commerci promot chianina beef quot discriminatori quot system aid framework cap reform depict situat structur weak livestock sector nation region level invok italian author reason justif grant aid scheme favour impact sector unabl demonstr prove distort effect vi vi stockfarm oblig face difficult live work condit surviv mean skill final justifi grant aid italian author mention similar scheme authoris commiss framework integr mediterranean programm tuscani case contribut ecu livestock unit authoris number local breed includ chianina italian author reason approach adopt case issu rememb aid scheme concern authoris commiss basi specif regul establish specif part financ programm favour specif region framework common agricultur polici basi competit rule laid articl ec treati present case scheme notifi italian author commiss pursuant articl ec treati assess sole basi articl treati authoris consid compat common market articl question basi provis applic specif case issu vi conclus consider lead conclus measur notifi aid scheme consid compat common market articl treati doubt retrospect natur aid scheme induc commiss initi articl procedur measur dispel italian author author notifi commiss decis amend programm implement measur aid scheme incompat common market benefit except articl treati adopt decis articl premium itl approxim eur livestock unit grant mainten calv adult femal anim chianina breed born hold list herd book list herd book calv time hold list herd book incompat common market aid establish artifici insemin programm provid financ pilot project product embryo high genet potenti take oocyt month heifer fertilis vitro semen breed bull implant fertilis embryo breed cow compat common market subject amend period implement refer articl avoid payment retrospect aid aid purchas breed bull chianina breed list herd book form grant cover cost invest compat common market subject amend period implement refer articl avoid payment retrospect aid articl itali implement aid scheme articl articl itali amend period implement aid measur refer articl aid grant expenditur incur date notif aid commiss articl itali inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address republ itali brussel novemb commiss franz fischler member commiss oj sourc chianina associ associazion di razza judgement court justic septemb case philip morri holland commiss ecr judgement court instanc june case siemen sa commiss ecr judgement court justic case lorenz germani ecr case germani commiss ecr decis juli quot procedur provis implement regul eec imp tuscani quot explicitli state letter italian author ask telex januari provid inform letter italian perman represent date march exchang correspond telephon convers place commiss depart compet nation depart possibl amend programm notifi decemb mention posit confirm convers commiss italian offici judgement court justic case lorenz germani ecr case germani commiss ecr articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati oj commiss work dai receipt notic decis oj regul repeal replac council regul ec oj footnot court justic judgement march case belgium commiss ecr septemb join case spain commiss ecr oj includ live cattl includ calv sourc eurostat judgement court justic juli case french republ commiss european commun ecr propos measur relat aid grant member state livestock livestock product sector point footnot aid scheme judgement court justic case offici van justiti beert van den hazel ecr oj commiss document vi quot programm protect genet divers endang breed farm anim plant varieti regul eec quot letter italian author decemb point council regul eec juli integr mediterranean programm oj