commiss decis decemb declar concentr compat common market eea agreement case comp enbw eni gv notifi document number english text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard agreement european econom area articl thereof regard council regul eec decemb control concentr undertak amend regul ec articl thereof regard commiss decis septemb initi proceed case regard opinion advisori committe concentr regard final report hear offic case august commiss receiv notif propos concentr pursuant articl regul eec quot merger regul quot undertak energi baden württemberg ag quot enbw quot germani eni spa quot eni quot itali acquir joint control german undertak gasversorgung süddeutschland gmbh quot gv quot purchas share examin notif commiss conclud notifi oper fall scope merger regul rais doubt compat common market septemb commiss decid initi proceed accord articl merger regul articl eea agreement advisori committe discuss draft decis decemb parti oper enbw activ field electr ga gener transmiss distribut suppli trade district heat suppli busi activ compris telecommun wast recycl prior liberalis german electr market enbw busi activ focus southwest germani state baden württemberg liberalis enbw extend electr activ nationwid quot yello quot electr household custom ga concern enbw distribut ga subsidiari local level final custom secondari distributor enbw jointli control electricité de franc quot edf quot zweckverband oberschwäbisch elektrizitätswerk quot oew quot edf wholli state own compani activ field suppli transport electr franc edf oper nation grid activ sector ga gener suppli edf indirectli hold share enbw oew associ public district southwest germani main purpos hold share compani activ energi sector wholli own subsidiari oew beteiligungsgesellschaft mbh oew hold share enbw eni activ explor product oil natur ga worldwid eni ga produc itali north sea egypt nigeria kazakhstan libya eni purchas ga volum sonatrach gasuni gazprom gazexport nigeria lng norwegian ga produc eni activ suppli transmiss storag distribut trade natur ga eni hold share compani transport capac activ oper transnat pipelin transmiss natur ga germani austria switzerland tunisia sea pipelin mediterranean tunisia itali black sea russia turkei north sea unit kingdom belgium eni control italian ministri financ control particip eni share capit remain share eni float stock exchang gv busi activ region ga distribut transport oper ga transport system network pipelin baden württemberg gv suppli ga local distribut compani addit gv suppli industri plant rodia rhone poulenc ag freiburg badisch stahlwerk ag kehl activ constitut approxim gv turnov present share gv held mvv rhe ag quot mvv quot state baden württemberg individu local author neckarwerk stuttgart ag quot nw quot control enbw mvv state baden württemberg nw individu local author repres share gv decid sell share local author remain sharehold gv account share gv enbw eni wholli own subsidiari società nazional metanodotti quot snam quot intend acquir share gv complet transact notifi parti intend gv main ga distribut channel border state baden württemberg ii concentr result notifi oper enbw eni jointli control gv newco jointli control joint ventur enbw eni wholli own subsidiari snam intend acquir share gv gain control gv newco mere hold compani parti share gv transact indirectli lead joint control gv parti major strateg decis newco gv requir consent enbw snam parent compani equal right appoint joint ventur manag bodi enbw snam jointli control gv newco propos oper constitut concentr mean articl merger regul iii commun dimens edf includ enbw eni gv combin aggreg worldwid turnov eur million eur million edf eur million eni eur million gv aggreg commun wide turnov edf eni gv exce eur million eur million edf eur million eni million gv edf includ enbw gener third commun wide turnov franc gv germani eni itali notifi oper commun dimens mean articl merger regul iv relev market relev product market germani result histor develop level ga wholesal compani wholesal compani purchas ga commun commun ga produc transport ga long distanc high pressur pipelin region suppli compani short distanc medium low pressur transmiss pipelin exxon mobil veba viag commiss conclud germani long distanc short distanc wholesal compani oper wholesal market region wholesal ga relev product market gv busi activ region ga distribut transport oper ga transport system network pipelin baden württemberg gv suppli ga local distribut compani region wholesal ga relev product market gv oper set recit investig carri commiss reveal larg commerci custom municip own util quot stadtwerk quot tend conclud suppli contract ga wholesal activ respect region mean region wholesal decis refer short distanc wholesal transmiss ga distinct product market assess focu market defin relev geograph market exxon mobil veba viag commiss left open ga wholesal market germani region limit demarc region nation scope notifi parti submit ga wholesal market nation scope notifi parti view wholesal transmiss market nation distribut tradition organis larg nation basi nation region oper support possibl parti access fix nation basi enabl region ga supplier suppli ga custom region respect supplier physic network respect commiss assess exxon mobil veba viag notifi parti view region scope establish decis due regulatori framework place time base quot verbändevereinbarung erdga quot quot vvi quot suffici enabl newcom ga wholesal suppli compet effect respect incumb region quot verbändevereinbarung erdga ii quot quot vvii quot sign relev industri organis enter forc octob valid septemb parti point vvii appli uniform price system region tran region wheel price calcul number characterist transmiss track parti view ga market consid nation scope result pro competit effect vvii investig show market region wholesal ga region scope remain futur present custom suppli ga wholesal activ previou demarc quot bundesländ quot investig carri commiss confirm parti submiss ga market consid nation reveal larg industri custom municip own util quot stadtwerk quot conclud larg extent suppli contract ga wholesal activ respect region level quot bundesland quot state baden württemberg bavaria hess rhineland palatin north rhine westphalia correspond previou demarc ga market subsequ ban due liberalis process ga sector addit custom spot market viabl altern suppli sourc view substanti volum unsuit purchas spot market due typic short term deliveri contract small volum stadtwerk inexperienc manag renew spot purchas deliveri continu basi order perman secur suppli ga spot market deliveri common mean bring ga region direct ec european parliament council june common rule intern market natur ga germani start liberalis ga sector agreement verbändevereinbarung erdga vvi amend verbändevereinbarung erdga ii vvii vvi vvii agreement german busi associ conclud view put practic principl direct ec true current suppli situat base framework defin vvi vvii forc octob framework foreseen vvii significantli defin vvi vvii modifi concept distanc relat tariff establish vvi essenti differ vvi vvii lie point model network access quot punkt zahlen model quot applic region wholesal level network access vvi establish price model base postag stamp tariff access region network price postag stamp defin network oper concern area vvii introduc model region network access transport network access model call quot punktzahlen model quot price transmiss comput base distanc pipelin diamet pressur pipelin model long distanc transmiss basi vvii uniform calcul model foreseen long distanc region wholesal tariff model local suppli network stadtwerk vvi local distribut postag stamp quot endverteilerbriefmark quot oper make public octob appli quot punktzahlen model quot local distribut postag stamp network chose quot punktzahlen model quot publish specif price relat distanc diamet pressur pipelin june publish quot punktzahlen quot octob quot punktzahlen quot calcul basi specif price make comput total price paid base distanc diamet kei issu consid make ga market fulli open newcom address vvi vvii basi vvii appear total price comput transpar potenti competitor oper physic network decid path ga follow network paramet distanc diamet section price base supplier interest transmiss mean control distanc transport relat path paid effect cost model remain distanc relat requir specif parti access agreement tpa agreement network oper involv specif transact mean case greater distanc ga travel network access agreement negoti relat network oper greater addit cost burden incur consequ tpa continu costli complic prevent altern supplier transport ga long distanc network worth note german feder ministri econom technic develop order independ studi made competit assess framework provid vvi network access conclus quot current rule defin network access tariff busi associ develop liquid ga market mass transact essenti issu address case case negoti versu bind standard condit network access tariff network access tariff relat transact mean tariff defin directli indirectli basi specif underli commerci transact system imped competit high transact cost risk discrimin parti network access fact tariff independ specif transact involv stamp tariff quot argument valid vvii address issu fact vvii intermedi step liberalis process ga market critic issu bind standard condit left open address agreement issu septemb respect vvii list improv tackl vviii concern busi associ quot develop improv concept achiev goal competit transpar straightforward servic opportun ga trade floor discriminatori condit suitabl mass market tariff independ specif transact characterist distanc base tariff stamp suitabl form energi balanc group causal principl cost alloc improv concept put forc time begin econom ga year busi associ concern agre continu share experi field develop lead simpl transpar competit network access quot commiss assum requir degre certainti characterist ga market chang short term reli current characterist concern market region scope futur vviii vvii specifi vviii readi ga year indic present busi associ concern address issu outlin recit purpos present assess commiss account impact futur vviii develop ga market germani light conclud relev ga wholesal market region scope condit competitor baden württemberg enter area improv gradual come year gv busi activ region ga distribut transport oper ga transport system network pipelin baden württemberg geograph market consid present case state baden württemberg baden württemberg constitut substanti part common market quantiti ga suppli state baden württemberg roughli correspond suppli austria denmark baden württemberg constitut substanti part common market compat common market domin posit gv gv high market share region wholesal ga market main ga supplier baden württemberg gv own oper transport system approxim km baden württemberg includ compressor station smaller storag facil main ga flow direct north south lampertheim amerdingen zoltingen michelbach willstätt import entri point gv pipelin system entri point serv intern transport system megal own ruhrga gaz de franc tenp own ruhrga eni snam midal own winga gv suppli ga winga account gv suppli remaind suppli ruhrga region wholesal ga market baden württemberg compris consumpt billion kwh market level gv ruhrga winga activ gv market share market region wholesal remain suppli ruhrga winga gv conclud long term wholesal suppli contract custom tabl suppli contract end remaind run tabl gv suppli contract baden württemberg gt tabl gt current suppli contract gv custom base standard contract model name lv iii model version march forese contractu durat septemb suppli contract base lv iii model possibl earli termin limit flexibl term adapt volum price conclus basi gv market share assum gv enjoi domin posit futur potenti ga suppli market gv remain domin futur indic gv face degre competit come year indic factor hamper signific competit region wholesal market chang extent forese futur limit degre competit conceiv true complet winga long distanc ga pipelin südal expect decis german feder high court long term exclus ga suppli agreement complet winga long distanc ga pipelin südal wholesal ga import winga own oper system pipelin transport ga long distanc exist pipelin enabl winga directli suppli stadtwerk industri custom locat area path pipelin case winga network competitor gv build dedic connect main transport pipelin custom present section winga pipelin system cover small area north west baden württemberg winga suppli stadtwerk locat area stadtwerk weinheim stadtwerk heidelberg stadtwerk schwäbisch hall recent switch gv winga winga build pipelin call südal complet end pipelin enabl winga transport ga russia suppli citi industri custom area münchen augsburg bavaria stuttgart baden württemberg densiti industri municip custom area pipelin run winga viabl competitor gv substanti part baden württemberg onward judgement long term exclus ga suppli agreement long term exclus suppli claus contain long term ga suppli contract subject court proceed german court appeal düsseldorf german court appeal stuttgart court conclus relev exclus long term contractu claus infring german commun competit law paragraph german law restrict competit articl ec treati deem invalid consequ invalid relev exclus long term contractu claus german court appeal düsseldorf reject possibl resort safeguard claus contain contract order adapt contractu ga volum durat contract german court appeal stuttgart follow german court appeal düsseldorf respect rule possibl safeguard claus form basi adapt reject claim entir contract invalid consequ custom free sourc percentag current suppli supplier judgement german court appeal stuttgart appeal german feder high court accept appeal legal review oral hear foreseen place april depend approach german feder high court custom posit sourc percentag suppli supplier turn make attract competitor winga ga dealer wholesal supplier neighbour area activ baden württemberg true current state market incent competitor activ baden württemberg poorli develop result combin factor firstli transmiss legal technic feasibl difficult current condit transmiss outlin recit importantli custom bound current supplier basi long term contract situat percentag demand open competit competitor chanc step gain custom evid compani winga build dedic connect main transport pipelin order suppli custom gv network competitor ga dealer wholesal supplier neighbour area gv network profit develop extent condit transmiss improv longer term conclus light conclud indic gv face degre competit medium term case due complet südal pipelin end open long term suppli contract basi expect judgement feder high court turn enabl custom sourc percentag suppli supplier strengthen gv domin posit propos concentr strengthen gv domin posit baden württemberg downstream vertic integr foreclos substanti part gv current custom enbw control substanti part downstream market ga distribut baden württemberg enbw activ market local ga distribut downstream market relat region wholesal ga particip stadtwerk volum sold gv undertak control enbw volum sold stadtwerk enbw hold major sharehold correspond region wholesal market shown tabl sharehold enbw consid volum sold gv stadtwerk correspond region wholesal market tabl enbw particip stadtwerk baden württemberg gt tabl gt enbw downstream market posit stronger subsidiari suppli ga basi long term contract independ stadtwerk stadtwerk enbw particip tabl show stadtwerk suppli ga enbw subsidiari neckarwerk stuttgart ag nw enbw ga gmbh enbw ga ev gasversorgung nord energi gmbh egvn ev gasversorgung süd gmbh egv enbw ostwürttemberg donauri ag odr region distributor tabl custom suppli enbw subsidiari gt tabl gt present oper enbw strong incent profit develop come year complet winga long distanc ga pipelin südal outlin recit winga build südal pipelin complet end pipelin run area baden württemberg densiti industri municip custom high stuttgart area investig carri commiss reveal dedic connect main transport pipelin viabl suppli altern distanc kilometr side pipelin corridor kilometr südal pipelin potenti suppli area ga suppli dedic pipelin respect note enbw subsidiari nw egvn egv stadtwerk enbw sharehold locat area energieversorgung gaildorf ohg stadtwerk esslingen neckar gmbh gasversorgung dornstadt gmbh energieversorgung rottenburg neckar gmbh gasversorgung pforzheim land gmbh stadtwerk sindelfingen gmbh stadtwerk schwäbisch gmünd gmbh fairenergi gmbh reutlingen stadtwerk nürtingen gmbh stadtwerk fellbach gmbh enbw subsidiari nw bigger custom gv account current suppli nw suppli contract end propos transact enbw strong incent explor competit altern nw futur ga suppli suppli südal dedic pipelin market onward sharehold gv enbw interest gv econom perform influenc secur gv current suppli true propos oper enbw interest gv econom perform enbw subsidiari nw sharehold gv stake result propos oper enbw jointli control gv turn doubl interest gv econom perform enbw stronger interest gv econom success sharehold gv enbw subsidiari negoti gv enbw prefer supplier exist suppli contract end respect conclud gv secur suppli contract offer equal accept competitor sharehold subsidiari reason oppos enbw prefer supplier compani direct indirect disadvantag result suppli gv addit enbw decis influenc sharehold gv adapt gv offer affect gv enbw profit enbw high number minor sharehold stadtwerk shown tabl compani enbw control particip concentr compar result term secur futur suppli gv outlin recit extent true compani enbw influenc direct futur ga sourc subsidiari respect stadtwerk enbw minor particip enbw hold seat compani board board director supervisori board enbw repres stadtwerk board amount total repres presenc enabl enbw obtain inform compet suppli offer made ga supplier gv gv posit match condit compet offer compani hold minor sharehold enbw presenc secur gv prefer access client allow secur suppli contract sharehold client perceiv econom disadvantag compar suppli competitor gv result propos oper gv posit secur sale enbw subsidiari current custom base correspond ga volum present sell relev market sharehold enbw consid percentag arguabl higher convers relev part consumpt withdrawn market case enbw subsidiari detriment supplier risk subject degre foreclosur conclus outlin recit competit econom legal feasibl limit extent come year limit competit elimin signific extent vertic downstream integr result propos oper assum enbw subsidiari compani hold share make competit opportun aris complet winga pipelin anticip open suppli contract percentag suppli turn lead signific strengthen gv domin posit futur conclud current state region wholesal ga market propos concentr strengthen gv domin posit baden württemberg due enbw activ downstream market vi undertak decis initi proceed adopt commiss pursuant articl merger regul rais competit concern outlin decis respons notifi parti propos commit aim remedi concern earli stage depth investig undertak offer notifi parti order address issu foreclosur effect propos oper notifi parti undertak grant special local distribut compani custom gv baden württemberg irrespect enbw hold particip termin earli suppli contract conclud gv special earli termin exercis point time long term contract end termin octob octob end termin octob octob custom notifi earli termin month advanc special termin provis extend contract conclud local distribut compani neckarwerk stuttgart ag enbw ga gmbh enbw control sharehold undertak propos provis report oblig notifi parti inform local distribut compani concern special termin right assess undertak propos undertak notifi parti address foreclosur effect provid possibl bring substanti volum ga demand market earlier long term suppli agreement assumpt local distribut compani enbw hold particip remain gv supplier ga potenti volum gv present sale gradual market baden württemberg year expand earli termin right custom nw enbw ga outlin tabl recit custom possibl earli termin suppli contract nw enbw ga disregard custom enbw subsidiari enbw particip addit ga volum gradual market baden württemberg year current suppli contract termin time contract end end respect expect condit region wholesal ga market chang time complet südal pipelin effici tpa rule allow degre competit place current situat custom account gv sale ga contractu bound custom account sale bound result earli termin right undertak propos parti ga volum sold gv open competit futur undertak propos parti improv condit competit region wholesal market come year extent outweigh competit disadvantag propos oper result propos oper compani account consider part recit region wholesal market prevent make upcom competit opportun commit propos parti gv total suppli direct custom indirect custom suppli nw enbw ga legal chang supplier respect suppli extens market open take place come year gv market posit subject competit market benefit legal liberalis gradual expect evolv commit stadtwerk repres gv entir suppli bound contractu gv circumst expect gv retain domin posit baden württemberg year case volum long term exclus contract releas come year due applic nation commun competit law basi commit competitor winga chanc win custom signific extent come year chanc gradual expand posit baden württemberg proce consider basi relev market contract forc expir background reason commit outbal effect propos concentr effect divestitur quot stadtwerk quot entiti solut involv consider extent activ unrel competit problem identifi electr water district heat insepar outlin propos undertak present wide rang parti includ competitor local distribut compani baden württemberg compani locat neighbour region bavaria hess potenti competit expect parti comment consid propos mean free ga volum long term suppli agreement consequ resolv competit concern rais propos concentr undertak propos parti accept commiss case prejudic legal assess long term exclus suppli claus suppli contract german commun law vii condit oblig pursuant sentenc subparagraph articl merger regul commiss attach decis condit oblig intend ensur undertak concern compli commit enter vi vi commiss view render concentr compat common market achiev measur rise structur chang market condit implement step achiev result gener oblig parti condit fulfil commiss decis declar concentr compat common market longer stand undertak concern commit breach oblig commiss revok clearanc decis act pursuant articl merger regul parti subject fine period penalti payment accord articl merger regul view decis condit grant special earli termin suppli contract set section ii undertak result structur chang market section iii iv undertak refer procedur oblig parti aim implement structur chang market viii conclus conclud forego undertak propos notifi parti remov competit concern implement render propos oper compat common market oper declar compat common market pursuant articl merger regul eea agreement pursuant articl thereof adopt decis articl notifi oper energi baden württemberg ag eni spa acquir joint control undertak gasversorgung süddeutschland gmbh mean articl regul eec declar compat common market eea agreement articl articl subject full complianc condit set section ii annex articl articl subject full complianc oblig set section iii annex articl decis address notifi parti brussel decemb commiss mario monti member commiss oj correct version oj oj oj oj commiss decis ec case comp edf enbw oj commiss decis case iv exxon mobil recit seq commiss decis ec case comp veba viag oj recit footnot reason terminolog clariti express present decis activ stake sale transport activ recit recit vvi sign juli oj bundesverband der deutschen industri verband der industriellen energi und kraftwirtschaft bundesverband der deutschen ga und wasserwirtschaft verband kommunal unternehmen principl includ free choic supplier network access unbundl postag stamp tariff tariff unrel distanc characterist singl transact ewi bet quot analys und wettberwerblich beurteilung der verbändevereinbarung ga zum netzzugang quot gutachten im auftrag de bundesministerium für wirtschaft und technologi endbericht paragraph quot zusammenfassung quot vvii paragraph quot bi zum werden die unterzeichnerverbänd ein verbessert konzept entwickeln welch die folgenden ziel erreicht mehr wettbewerb und transparenz al bisher einfacher bedienung und nutzung börsenfähigkeit diskriminierungsfreiheit eignung für massengeschäft transaktionsunabhängigkeit bilanzkreisfähigkeit kostenzuordnung nach verursacherprinzip da verbessert konzept wird rechtzeitig vor beginn de gaswirtschaftsjahr kraft gesetzt die unterzeichnerverbänd sind sich darin einig dass ein stetig erfahrung und meinungsaustausch zu diesem thema den einfachen transparenten und wettbewerbsfähigen netzzugang begleiten und fördern soll quot part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos squar bracket mark asterisk olg düsseldorf judgement aktenzeichnen kart quot thyssenga stadtwerk aachen ag quot olg stuttgart judgement aktenzeichnen quot gasversorgung süddeutschland gmbh stadtwerk schwäbisch hall gmbh quot gesetz gegen wettbewerbsbeschränkungen gwb prejudic consequ framework implement commun legisl octob typic month year determin begin year period ga suppli agreement suppli contract end relev custom exercis earli termin octob octob nw account gv total ga sale nw turn achiev respect turnov ga remain achiev activ electr import account cf commiss notic remedi accept council regul eec commiss regul ec oj annex full origin text condit oblig refer articl consult commiss websit http europa eu int comm competit index en html