council regul ec august impos definit anti dump duti import grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel origin unit state america russia repeal regul ec impos definit anti dump duti import grain orient electr sheet origin russia council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun quot basic regul quot articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur initi commiss announc notic quot notic initi quot publish offici journal european union initi anti dump proceed import commun grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel origin unit state america quot usa quot russia initi interim review anti dump duti import grain orient electr sheet width mm origin russia anti dump proceed initi complaint lodg april european confeder iron steel industri quot eurof quot quot complain quot behalf produc repres major proport case total commun product grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel complaint contain evid dump product materi injuri result consid suffici justifi initi proceed interim review initi commiss initi pursuant articl basic regul order amend repeal definit anti dump measur impos council regul ec import russia grain orient electr sheet width mm amend repeal aris due fact product measur impos regul ec fall scope product subject proceed import commun grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel origin usa russia parti concern proceed commiss offici advis export produc russia usa import trader user concern repres export countri concern complain commun produc initi proceed interest parti opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi export produc russia usa commun produc import trader user made view write parti request time limit reason heard grant opportun heard questionnair commiss questionnair parti concern compani made deadlin set notic initi repli receiv export produc relat subsidiari commun russian export produc relat subsidiari commun repli receiv commun produc user import relat export produc countri concern commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos determin dump result injuri commun interest verif visit carri premis compani commun produc thyssenkrupp electr steel ugo isbergu franc thyssenkrupp electr steel ast terni itali thyssenkrupp electr steel gmbh gelsenkirchen germani orb electr steel limit newport unit kingdom user commun areva pari franc specialacciai srl novi ligur itali export produc russia novolipetski iron amp steel corpor quot nlmk quot lipetsk stal ekaterinburg export produc usa ak steel corpor butler pennsylvania relat import commun ak steel bv oosterhout netherland ak steel gmbh köln germani ak steel baldock unit kingdom ak steel genova itali duferco commercial spa genova itali duferco gmbh mülheim germani relat import commun duferco sa lugano switzerland stinol ag lugano switzerland investig dump injuri cover period april march quot investig period quot quot ip quot examin trend relev assess injuri cover period januari end ip quot period examin quot measur forc council regul ec definit anti dump duti impos import russia grain orient electr sheet width mm quot larg quot investig initi pursuant articl basic regul regul anti dump duti rate set import stal import nlmk rate time residu duti rate import product compani russia commiss regul ec undertak connect anti dump proceed import larg origin russia accept nlmk stal relat sale compani period month novemb undertak intend provid temporari adapt anti dump measur extend import member state enlarg european union purpos avoid sudden excess neg effect import user caus sudden full applic extend measur countri undertak accept period month commiss regul ec condit accept consid exist provision measur examin aspect investig interrel interim review mention recit decid continu investig imposit provision measur interest parti inform preliminari find investig grant period comment find comment submit parti consid relev claim address find modifi product concern product product concern product concern grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel quot quot width declar cn code width mm width mm cn code inform produc hot roll coil silicon alloi steel thick grain structur uniformli direct order magnet conduct high degre effici ineffici regard conduct call quot core loss quot prime indic qualiti product market typic divid quot high permeabl quot high conduct grade regular grade high permeabl grade achiev lower core loss thick sheet grain orient steel sheet need cut width custom specif process call slit product concern manufactur electromagnet applianc transform power gener distributor spite differ permeabl thick width type share basic physic technic characterist essenti basic refer review investig larg mention paragraph note number occas observ anti dump measur forc mention paragraph avoid cut coil grain orient electr steel export commun commun user bought larg slit requir measur imposit measur cut produc export part exceed mm export product fell scope measur export produc claim narrow defin compani mm width distinguish larg width mm larg substitut narrow narrow larg subject competit condit argument competit condit base observ end user order purchas directli width meet exact requir order avoid cost slit oppos purchas coil larger width product process care slit case recours specialis subcontractor argument lack interchang base fact narrow substitut larg subsequ slit revers situat imposs refer made export concern anti dump proceed footwear textil upper china indonesia consid indoor shoe form separ product refer mention anti dump proceed conclud indoor outdoor shoe form separ product indoor shoe basic physic characterist make suitabl outdoor situat present case investig conclud irrespect width made basic materi basic characterist compar end note partial interchang product suffic order singl product purpos anti dump investig case explain recit interchang occur argument rais export produc base observ end user preferenti make width meet technic requir product purpos found end user standard work slit materi acquir roughli cut narrow russia free anti dump duti subsequ slit import materi exact specif widespread exist slit compani steel servic centr commun illustr fact leav factori produc dimens specif requir end user claim made export produc reject conclud purpos present anti dump proceed type product concern regard product product product export commun russia usa product produc sold domest russia usa manufactur sold commun commun produc found basic physic technic characterist basic consid product mean articl basic regul dump gener methodolog order determin normal commiss establish export produc total domest sale product concern repres comparison total export sale commun accord articl basic regul domest sale consid repres total domest sale volum export produc total export sale volum commun type sold export produc domest market found directli compar type product concern sold export commun establish domest sale suffici repres purpos articl basic regul domest sale type consid suffici repres total domest sale volum type ip repres total sale volum compar type export commun subsequ examin domest sale type product export produc consid made ordinari trade pursuant articl basic regul establish proport profit sale independ custom type question case sale volum type sold net sale price equal calcul cost product repres total sale volum type weight averag price type equal cost product normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag price domest sale made ip irrespect sale profit case volum profit sale type repres total sale volum type weight averag price type cost product normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag profit sale type provid sale repres total sale volum type case volum profit sale type repres total sale volum type consid type sold insuffici quantiti domest price provid basi establish normal domest price product type sold export produc order establish normal method appli regard commiss construct normal accord articl basic regul normal construct ad export manufactur cost export type adjust reason percentag sell gener administr expens quot sg amp quot reason margin profit unit state america normal cooper export produc found domest sale product concern consid made ordinari trade sale made substanti quantiti unit cost case volum sold domest market establish weight averag sell price domest transact weight averag unit cost product ip consequ domest price product concern sold export produc order establish normal normal construct accord articl basic regul normal construct basi export produc cost manufactur amount sg amp cost profit amount establish sg amp cost profit applic product sale ordinari trade gener categori steel product export produc question domest market accord articl basic regul full cost product determin relev product type steel grade thick fact product concern sold full coil slit coil case slit cost account export price export price determin basi price paid payabl product concern sold consumpt commun accord articl basic regul export produc sell quantiti product concern directli independ custom commun sale made relat subsidiari commun construct export price establish pursuant articl basic regul basi resal price independ custom commun adjust made cost incur import resal relat import includ sg amp expens reason profit margin comparison purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price work level level trade due allow form adjust made differ claim demonstr affect price price compar accord articl basic regul adjust made respect transport cost insur credit cost relat bank charg import charg slit cost applic justifi adjust slit cost order proper comparison import full width coil subsequ sold commun import full width coil sold slit commun import slit materi sold slit commun accord articl basic regul dump margin accord articl basic regul dump margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal weight averag export price product type determin basi dump margin express percentag cif commun frontier price duti unpaid establish ak steel corpor middletown usa evid export deliber cooper investig residu dump margin cooper export produc set level highest margin measur sale repres product type cooper produc commun russia nlmk normal normal establish line gener methodolog explain paragraph sole type domest sale made suffici quantiti ordinari trade normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag price domest sale type made ordinari trade ip remain product type domest sale repres normal construct accord articl basic regul normal construct ad manufactur cost export type adjust reason percentag sell gener administr expens quot sg amp quot reason margin profit basi actual data pertain product sale ordinari trade product export produc investig accord sentenc articl basic regul export price export sale commun made directli independ custom relat compani switzerland export price establish basi resal price independ buyer commun comparison export produc claim product import commun origin russia compar product produc commun qualiti differ export produc claim higher surfac defect higher core loss extent grade export produc request adjust qualiti differ calcul dump margin comparison made level product type steel grade specif rang core loss american russian standard compar european take account relev product characterist comparison made level product sale prime grade materi claim adjust qualiti differ made export produc reject methodolog approach calcul undercut comment recit normal export price compar work basi level trade purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price account accord articl basic regul differ factor claim demonstr affect price price compar basi allow differ freight insur packag credit cost relat bank charg indirect tax grant adjust made export sale made relat compani locat countri commun pursuant articl basic regul export produc claim cleric error occur calcul verif claim accept calcul duli correct dump margin provid articl basic regul weight averag normal type product concern export commun compar weight averag export price type product concern comparison show exist dump respect cooper export produc dump margin express percentag cif import price commun border duti unpaid nlmk lipetsk stal normal found domest sale product concern repres made ordinari trade sale made substanti quantiti unit cost case volum sold transact consider establish weight averag sell price domest transact weight averag unit cost product ip domest price product concern sold export produc order establish normal normal construct accord articl basic regul normal construct basi export produc full cost product manufactur cost sell gener administr cost quot sg amp quot cost reason margin profit basi actual data pertain product sale export produc investig accord sentenc articl basic regul note ip stal purchas main raw materi hot roll coil hot roll band supplier steel kosic russian compani magnitogorsk investig larg refer recit found relat compani stal close purchas price supplier consid reliabl respect establish cost manufactur specif cost main raw materi exclus base price coil purchas unrel slovak produc supplier steel kosic daf price slovak border ad transport cost ekaterinburg insur cost credit cost base payment condit calcul hot roll coil repres total cost product export produc full cost product determin relev product type steel grade thick fact product concern sold full coil slit coil case slit cost account export price stal sell product concern directli independ custom commun sale made relat subsidiari commun construct export price establish pursuant articl basic regul base resal price independ custom adjust made cost incur import resal relat import includ sell gener administr expens reason profit margin accord articl basic regul comparison purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price work level level trade due allow form adjust made differ claim demonstr affect price price compar accord articl basic regul adjust made respect transport cost insur handl cost bank charg credit cost relat bank charg import cost slit cost applic justifi adjust slit cost order proper comparison import full width coil subsequ sold commun import full width coil sold slit commun import slit materi sold slit commun accord articl basic regul dump margin accord articl basic regul dump margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal weight averag export price product type determin export made export produc commun investig lead find dump conclus dump import commun reach full coil slit coil product type cover larg narrow conclus dump russian import cooper export produc high cover entireti import commun russian export produc dump found ip cooper export produc investig lead find dump import commun residu dump margin set level margin export produc dump found commun industri commun product commun produc manufactur complain commun produc locat germani franc itali note produc belong group produc locat poland czech republ unit kingdom investig conclud produc constitut total commun product mean articl basic regul definit commun industri addit relat complain commun produc commun produc fulli cooper investig total product compani found repres total commun product product concern consid commun produc constitut commun industri mean articl articl basic regul refer quot commun industri quot remain commun produc remain silent support proceed consid part commun industri provid basic inform product sale volum injuri commun consumpt commun consumpt establish basi sale commun market commun industri commun produc provid gener inform import commun market countri report eurostat data submit cooper export produc countri concern basi commun consumpt develop ip commun consumpt metric tonn index commun consumpt firstli increas significantli continu drop period examin decreas consumpt continu drop consumpt explain decreas demand downstream industri transform produc due reduct industri project electr transform need import countri concern cumul assess effect dump import concern commiss consid effect dump import countri concern assess cumul basi criteria set articl basic regul articl import cumul assess margin dump establish relat import countri de minimi defin articl basic regul volum import countri neglig condit competit import product condit competit import product commun product make assess note russian export produc found dump import export produc consider examin cumul assess import found dump margin establish countri concern de minimi addit volum dump import countri neglig repres usa russia commun consumpt ip regard condit competit dump import dump import commun product found sold countri concern sold commun industri alik respect distribut trade channel investig show import price case countri similar decreas trend part period examin price found undercut commun industri price led price depress sold commun industri conclud dump import origin countri concern assess cumul volum market share dump import concern dump import volum ip import volum metric tonn index tabl show import countri concern commun tripl period examin market share dump import ip market share constant increas market share place context decreas commun consumpt case period spite signific declin commun consumpt market share increas signific increas market share place period dump import gain percentag point correspond increas absolut import volum price evolut dump import ip eur metric tonn index price dump import firstli rose due increas demand time price continu decreas eur tonn eur tonn investig period decreas averag price decreas mark period examin decreas averag unit price dump import undercut commiss examin export produc countri concern undercut price commun industri ip purpos analysi cif price export produc adjust commun frontier duti paid level price compar commun industri work price level trade level compar product type russian export produc claim assess price undercut injuri elimin margin adjust made respect qualiti differ produc sold export produc produc commun industri claim base fact type qualiti produc export produc consider lower qualiti produc commun industri respect firstli note adjust grant origin investig investig review prolong measur expiri review conclud qualiti adjust longer warrant view improv russian facil user ask comment compar import russia purchas commun industri cooper user mention signific qualiti differ user mention qualiti russian product slightli inferior commun made product user substanti claim user mention product complet substitut switch russian product due signific price differ claim reject basi cooper export produc price undercut margin found countri express percentag commun industri price countri price undercut usa russia russia concern undercut margin establish export produc dump margin found percentag refer cooper export produc situat commun industri pursuant articl basic regul commiss examin econom factor indic bear state commun industri view limit number commun produc belong group export produc concern figur index form rang product product capac capac utilis ip product metric tonn index capac metric tonn index capac utilis period examin commun industri product volum decreas specif product firstli increas continu declin ip decreas report capac figur refer technic capac oppos theoret capac impli adjust consid standard industri normal holidai set time mainten normal stoppag consider increas product capac year design match surg demand capac fell back ip produc slightli modifi product process effect reduc technic capac basi product capac increas period examin show recit increas relat invest made order modernis exist product tool improv effici consist purchas replac equip note increas capac occur time commun industri profit invest respons increas demand light cash flow commun time decreas capac utilis rate result slight increas product capac combin fall product volum decreas percentag point period examin stock ip metric tonn index type product specif produc commun industri order destin stock standardis type produc regular basi sale depend evolut market term demand price clear increas stock period examin commun industri face difficulti sell standardis type product stock increas compar increas compar previou year decreas stock ip explain increas sale period mind ip correspond calendar year affect compar stock level compar year end period examin level stock higher sale volum ip metric tonn index commun industri sale volum commun market decreas period examin tonn tonn ip sale volum increas tonn declin tonn subsequ period end ip increas ip explain fact commun industri decreas sale price order regain market share market share ip commun consumpt period examin commun industri face drop market share percentag point specif spite increas sale volum commun industri bare maintain level market share increas percentag point year period ip commun industri market share drop percentag point loss market share occur time consumpt decreas indic commun industri sale decreas consumpt time market share countri concern continu increas sale price ip eur metric tonn index averag unit sale price increas rose commun industri face signific continu drop price mark ip price fell price decreas order commun industri maintain market share trend emerg tabl show import depress commun industri sale price year coincid period dump import price significantli decreas allow benefit major increas market share pressur commun industri sale price profit ip explain tabl show evolut commun unit sale price compar cost product consist raw materi hot roll coil repres averag total cost product product concern index ip unit price unit full cost product period sale price averag increas cost period price line cost result profit situat shown price significantli drop profit neg spite decreas averag cost year ip slight increas product cost raw materi pass price dramat decreas caus signific loss price depress coupl price suppress incapac commun industri increas price order reflect increas cost profit return invest ip profit net turnov return invest financi result commun produc significantli affect start cost technic problem relat signific invest product tool commun industri profit affect year untyp consid repres start point examin trend commun industri sale commun market profit year view higher demand downstream industri satisfactori price level signific drop price direct neg effect profit sale commun market loss make year loss reach turnov ip purpos investig return invest quot roi quot express profit percent net book invest compani constitut commun industri exclus activ product sale product roi establish respect situat basi roi broadli profit trend period examin decreas continu ip cash flow abil rais capit ip eur index net cash flow oper activ develop xx million eur xx million eur ip peak subsequ drop sharpli reach low ip consequ commun industri averag increasingli resort debt order financ current activ invest investig shown capit requir commun produc advers affect difficult financi situat compani part larg steel compani capit requir met desir level financi resourc gener alloc group profit entiti invest ip eur index commun industri total invest relat product decreas ip investig show vital industri maintain level invest order stai competit invest made modernis purpos increas capac note modernis invest rais slightli technic capac simpli improv equip effici product previou growth ip commun consumpt decreas sale volum commun industri decreas commun industri significantli lost market share market share import concern increas percentag point period employ ip total employe index level employ commun industri remain stabl reduc year result total reduct compar begin period examin wage ip wage eur index avg wage employe eur index period examin averag wage employe remain stabl rate inflat employ reduc period shown previou tabl total cost wage decreas product ip product tonn employ product index product commun industri workforc measur output person emploi year increas drop rose ip end period examin product higher observ start period increas product partial explain invest aim improv effici exist equip state recit magnitud dump margin concern impact commun industri magnitud actual margin dump volum price import countri concern impact consid neglig transpar highli price sensit market product concern recoveri effect past dump subsidis previous explain measur import width mm origin russia place period examin recal concern portion product concern current investig present proceed concern width russia origin usa commun industri partial recov subsequ face increas dump import width russia usa develop investig period interest parti claim import develop place investig period develop consider analysi allegedli make imposit measur manifestli inappropri specif claim relat increas commun industri sale price product plant closur complain end investig period firstli note accord articl basic regul inform relat period subsequ investig period account reason relev fact establish verifi limit time period order ensur result investig repres reliabl investig prolong unnecessarili ground fact gather period investig period reflect situat prevail stage word basic regul develop occur investig period consider except natur make imposit measur manifestli inappropri approach confirm european court instanc commun industri price increas argu commun industri announc price increas investig period price increas except natur press unusu larg actual data gather commiss servic evolut averag commun sale price commun market present tabl averag sale price ip apr dec eur metric tonn index tabl price increas investig period price increas unusu larg averag price quarter increas compar ip level price recov compar previou year level addit consid price increas except natur recal case consider evolut investig period price level oper commun market countri concern fluctuat raw materi price order verifi increas price make imposit anti dump duti manifestli inappropri detail analysi respect warrant view partial recoveri price shown unknown price increas last natur importantli recal injuri suffer commun industri exclus base price level characteris deterior combin indic price increas except last natur isol make imposit measur inappropri accompani similar develop injuri indic complet injuri pictur affect reason consid commun industri price increas occur investig period make imposit measur inappropri closur produc commun industri interest parti claim closur produc part commun industri call imposit measur result signific decreas product capac commun possibl gener shortag commun market respect note articl basic regul event occur investig period appli determin commun interest dealt articl basic regul refer made recit issu relat product capac address framework commun interest analysi confirm plant closur produc locat itali announc product continu reduc level june expect complet ceas septemb year envisag closur plant constitut except event last natur consid context analysi reinforc find commun industri suffer injuri investig period precari situat continu investig period conclus injuri spite exist anti dump measur import larg russia econom situat commun industri significantli deterior ip posit impact measur impos larg russia dilut emerg dump import width russia usa import significantli import begin period examin addit refer made recit explain anti dump measur forc larg russia avoid cut coil grain orient electr steel halv exceed mm period examin sale volum decreas product decreas stock significantli increas market share drop percentag point commun produc price commun market undercut dump import increas reflect increas cost product ip result industri made loss ip employ invest decreas period examin specif econom situat commun industri develop year commun market higher demand increas price period commun industri rais sale volum extent increas consumpt sale price result profit situat industri posit invest slightli increas product capac sale volum market share drop commun industri manag maintain price level remain profit albeit level view increas cost product time commun industri longer maintain price significantli drop conjunct strong fall sale volum market share price decreas ip cost remain stabl consequ profit reach dramat low level level loss exist industri risk investig period product plant commun produc close light forego conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri mean articl basic regul causat introduct accord articl basic regul commiss examin dump import product concern origin countri concern caus injuri commun industri degre enabl classifi materi factor dump import time injur commun industri examin order ensur injuri caus factor attribut dump import effect dump import signific increas volum dump import tripl period examin coincid deterior econom situat commun industri materialis drop sale volum period concern larg russia exist measur suffici shield commun industri effect import concern true mention signific increas import width includ origin usa fact measur larg avoid cut sheet explain recit neg effect continu increas volum dump import reinforc year commun consumpt decreas matter fact period dump import gain percentag point market share commun industri share drop point sudden surg dump import explain dramat decreas price period year price decreas eur tonn decreas result import drop commun industri sale volum period commun industri maintain averag price level price decreas eur eur industri choic decreas price order maintain sale volum market share ip direct neg impact profit neg reach turnov ip view establish coincid time hand surg dump import continu decreas price hand commun industri loss sale volum market share price depress result loss make situat conclud dump import plai determin role injuri situat commun industri effect factor exchang rate effect interest parti claim injuri suffer commun industri caus develop usd eur exchang rate decreas impact price import usa situat favour usa import increas market share tabl compar develop usd eur exchang rate averag import price product concern origin ip usd eur exchang rate index import price eur index appear data clear correl develop usd eur exchang rate averag import price product concern origin usa period import price decreas exchang rate remain stabl data period examin decreas relev averag import price stronger neg develop exchang rate case period unit averag import price show strongest decreas conclud effect exchang rate consid substanti injuri situat commun industri perform commun produc ip sale volum metric tonn market share tabl show sale commun produc commun market decreas period examin market share decreas investig period base inform conclud commun produc situat similar commun industri injuri commun industri export perform commun industri ip sale volum export tonn index interest parti claim part injuri suffer commun industri attribut export perform commun industri argu commun industri deliber decreas domest sale favour profit export eu countri tabl show commun industri increas export period examin onward increas light surg dump import commun market time consumpt decreas commun price depress signific extent circumst commun industri react order limit damag attempt increas export recal commun market remain commun industri natur market fact year situat commun market favour commun industri increas domest sale volum export sale reduc addit note injuri suffer commun industri consist loss sale volum market share commun market characteris strong price depress caus dump import signific undercut commun industri price result consider financi loss neg effect price attribut increas export sale product concern contrari consid increas export sale volum allow commun industri benefit economi scale leverag cost product absenc increas export expect loss signific conclud injuri suffer commun industri attribut increas export dump import countri concern ip import volum metric tonn index market share dump import russia increas period examin market share gain percentag point respect firstli note increas import mark dump import state recit establish price level dump import higher dump import whilst undercut margin establish case dump import undercut margin dump import rang reason conclud impact dump import situat commun industri limit consid determin reason injuri situat commun industri import countri ip import volum metric tonn market share averag unit price tabl import countri decreas absolut rel term time averag sale price increas conclud import countri contribut injuri suffer commun industri declin demand market demand decreas expect oper face diminut sale case commun industri sale decreas consumpt period examin whilst commun industri commun produc countri lost sale volum market share period examin volum dump import tripl gain signific market share period shown injuri analysi demand declin tonn period examin commun industri sale drop tonn import countri concern increas tonn context declin demand contribut sale decreas commun industri conclud injuri consist loss market share price depress loss make situat attribut minor extent factor conclus causat conclus confirm materi injuri suffer commun industri characteris declin sale volum market share unit sale price result deterior profit indic caus dump import concern clear coincid time surg dump import drop commun industri sale volum market share price depress caus dump import remark commun industri maintain level price choic follow price level set dump import order maintain level sale result loss make situat identifi factor found break causal link establish combin effect decreas consumpt contribut decreas commun industri sale volum state absenc surg low price dump import situat commun industri affect extent decreas market share consid dump import russia limit neg impact final develop usd eur exchang rate explain high level dump establish usa injuri suffer commun industri conclud dump import origin countri concern caus materi injuri commun industri mean articl basic regul commun interest examin conclus dump injuri causat compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest adopt measur case purpos pursuant articl basic regul impact imposit imposit measur parti concern investig consid interest commun industri injuri analysi demonstr fair trade circumst commun industri viabl profit industri invest order stai competit case year commun industri benefit anti dump measur forc larg russia level dump import concern signific ip recal industri undergon major restructur programm commun merg complain time intend creat larger entiti compet effect increas invest year continu increas low price dump import caus gener price depress commun market face declin consumpt commun industri loss make extrem vulner loss heavi italian produc announc phase closur factori market develop itali show extent dump import neg affect econom situat commun industri import price restor dump injuri level order produc oper commun market normal fair trade circumst commun industri regain satisfactorili volum profit absenc imposit measur exclud commun industri face plant closur conclus imposit anti dump measur commun industri recov effect injuri dump found interest user commun manufactur power distribut transform transform manufactur constitut long establish industri tradition suppli larg energi produc transform industri gener belong larg industri group worldwid presenc smaller independ compani oper market product concern consid signific cost item user repres averag total cost product transform substanti questionnair repli includ request financi inform receiv user user submit comment write provid detail inform financi inform submit cooper user repres commun consumpt user gener express opposit imposit measur firstli claim imposit anti dump measur result cessat import countri concern make depend commun industri arguabl find monopolist situat claim imposit measur result signific price increas neg affect competit vi vi commun transform industri final claim measur impos commun industri suffici capac suppli user industri specif address issu rais user industri background inform mention stage order properli assess situat commun market note number produc product concern worldwid limit produc worldwid oper busi produc japan usa russia south korea china brazil european commun relat european commun market highest number produc distribut network japanes produc organis commun market servic centr relat import eu appear produc worldwid suppli high permeabl laser treat type product concern produc locat eu usa japan recal commun produc merg activ hold compani thyssenkrupp order creat larger entiti compet effect produc world market time merger analys detail european commiss approv final investig reveal cooper user purchas ip russian american produc dump establish word cooper user reli sourc suppli purchas dump sourc purchas commun industri user exclus purchas dump sourc recent switch commun industri suppli background claim made user depend exclus commun industri suppli firstli recal object anti dump duti close commun market import restor situat fair trade remov effect injuri dump import countri concern expect end continu albeit dump injuri price level case russia dump margin establish major russian export produc repres russian import ip limit margin dump establish export produc refer made head suggest measur base find present investig replac place larg russia rang word case russia weight anti dump measur establish present investig significantli import measur forc case usa import expect continu view continu demand commun market specif type product concern produc limit number supplier worldwid refer made recit price undertak offer export produc concern undertak export produc undertak sell product commun market price level remov injuri effect dump expect import countri concern ceas import countri concern expect continu altern sourc suppli exist claim imposit anti dump duti result commun industri monopolist situat unfound import countri concern expect continu countri addit commun industri consist produc commun produc part commun industri activ market parti claim monopolist situat commun industri specif aris respect specif type product concern high permeabl type produc limit number produc worldwid respect firstli note investig conclud purpos present anti dump proceed type product concern regard singl product investig includ commun interest analysi carri respect product concern individu specif type notwithstand true high permeabl type product concern produc limit number produc worldwid produc japan commun respect recal sourc suppli expect remain imposit measur includ import usa albeit dump injuri price suffici level competit expect remain regard specif product type addit claim commun interest impos measur compani produc specif type consid valid reason accept produc case produc sell product dump injuri price commun market recal substanti margin dump establish respect compani investig reveal user purchas signific portion product includ high permeabl type commun industri continu price pressur caus dump import lead plant closur commun absenc anti dump measur remov neg impact injuri dump exclud user exclus depend import detriment competit user industri concern claim price product concern increas commun market anti dump measur impos acknowledg object measur remov injuri dump expect imposit measur increas effect price effect expect remain moder remain sourc suppli hit measur ensur competit mention russia concern view level measur establish present investig measur replac exist measur larg recit anti dump measur base current find lesser impact measur forc ip appli level measur establish present investig russian import product concern commun ip anti dump duti time actual duti paid import usa applic lesser duti rule injuri part dump margin remov averag bring back price import level level alleg imposit anti dump measur result shortag refut set import event expect continu anti dump measur impos commun industri product capac larger commun consumpt ip addit commun price restor fair level expect commun industri shift back sale domest market decreas export sale interest parti claim closur italian plant decreas commun industri product capac product concern possibl result shortag commun market argument ambigu call protect commun industri dump import order prevent plant closur maintain product capac note announc plant closur commun industri product capac larger commun demand ip intent remain produc invest product capac order guarante suffici suppli commun market situat fair competit price level restor commun market ensur satisfactori return commun industri favour invest shift back sale commun market final note claim made user framework previou investig led imposit anti dump measur larg russia spite claim time reject consid unfound found interest commun user provid evid framework current investig measur neg impact claim time indic measur base current find expect signific neg impact user industri reason conclud case imposit measur user product concern exclus depend commun industri circumst purchas price user directli affect imposit measur moder shortag suppli futur commun market interest unrel import unrel import cooper investig oppos imposit measur ground measur allegedli make end trade oper respect product concern compani exclus import countri concern expect directli affect imposit measur import possibl import supplier subject measur appear import turnov relat product concern element consid neg impact imposit measur expect remain limit view fact import claim advers effect result imposit measur conclud import significantli affect note low level cooper import explain fact user import refer made conclus conclus commun interest effect imposit measur expect give commun industri opportun regain profit sale volum commun market higher market share establish dump import highli contribut phase plant closur compani part commun industri view deterior situat commun industri risk absenc measur commun produc close product line product facil lai part workforc whilst neg effect result form price increas user consid effect remain limit consid interest user viabl competit commun produc remain activ market longer distort unfair trade practic view limit sourc suppli worldwid interest commun user sourc suppli commun weaken dump import result decreas commun industri activ make user progress depend import materi definit anti dump measur view conclus reach regard dump result injuri commun interest measur import product concern usa russia impos injuri elimin level level definit anti dump measur suffici elimin injuri commun industri caus dump import exceed dump margin found calcul amount duti remov effect injuri dump consid measur commun industri cover cost obtain profit tax achiev normal condit competit absenc dump import basi inform preliminarili found profit margin turnov commun industri achiev regard level commun industri expect obtain absenc injuri dump note level profit determin injuri margin framework investig led imposit measur place width mm price increas determin basi comparison level trade weight averag import price establish price undercut calcul injuri price product sold commun industri commun market injuri price obtain adjust sale price compani compos commun industri break point ad mention profit margin differ result comparison express percentag total cif import definit duti light forego accord articl basic regul consid definit anti dump measur impos respect import origin russia usa level lowest dump injuri margin accord lesser duti rule basi propos definit duti countri compani anti dump duti unit state america ak steel corpor compani russia novolipetsk iron amp steel corpor nlmk stal compani individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countri wide duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention oper part regul import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot claim request applic individu compani anti dump duti rate chang entiti set product sale entiti address commiss forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti regul amend updat list compani benefit individu duti rate undertak export produc usa russia offer price undertak accord articl basic regul commiss consid undertak offer ak steel corpor nmlk accept elimin injuri effect dump regular detail report compani undertook provid commiss effect monitor structur compani commiss consid risk circumvent undertak minimis order ensur effect respect monitor undertak request releas free circul pursuant undertak present exempt duti condit present commerci invoic inform list annex custom ascertain shipment correspond commerci document requir level detail invoic present correspond product present custom rate anti dump duti payabl event suspect breach breach withdraw undertak anti dump duti impos pursuant articl basic regul conclus respect interim review investig russia recal mention recit regul interim review initi order amend repeal definit anti dump measur impos import russia larg due fact product fall scope product subject proceed import commun grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel origin usa russia basi find conclus investig establish measur impos width recit origin inter alia russia consid measur cover larg continu imposit measur impos council regul ec longer repeal adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import grain orient flat roll product silicon electr steel origin unit state america russia fall cn code product width mm product width mm rate definit anti dump duti applic duti net free commun frontier price product paragraph manufactur compani countri compani anti dump duti taric addit code unit state america ak steel corpor curti street middletown ohio compani russia novolipetsk iron amp steel corpor nlmk metallurgov sq lipetsk stal kirov street ekaterinburg compani provis forc custom duti appli articl import declar releas free circul exempt anti dump duti impos articl provid manufactur ship invoic compani undertak accept commiss name list relev commiss decis time time amend import conform provis commiss decis regul import mention paragraph exempt anti dump duti condit good declar present custom correspond precis product articl commerci invoic element list annex present member state custom author present declar releas free circul good declar present custom correspond precis descript commerci invoic articl council regul ec repeal articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel august council presid straw oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj council regul ec oj sourc verifi questionnair repli inform provid commun produc inform contain complaint eurostat sourc eurostat cooper export produc sourc eurostat cooper export produc sourc eurostat cooper export produc oj recit sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli eurostat sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc verifi questionnair repli sinochem case sourc questionnair repli complaint eurostat sourc verifi questionnair repli sourc eurostat annex element commerci invoic accompani compani sale commun good subject undertak head quot commerci invoic accompani good subject undertak quot compani issu commerci invoic commerci invoic number date issu commerci invoic taric addit code good invoic custom clear commun frontier regul impos definit anti dump duti exact plain languag descript good product code number pcn technic specif pcn annex compani product code number cpc cn code quantiti kg ton descript term sale includ price unit kg ton applic payment term applic deliveri term total discount rebat compani act import invoic issu directli compani offici compani issu commerci invoic sign declar quot undersign certifi sale direct export european commun good cover invoic made scope term undertak offer compani accept european commiss decis ec declar inform provid invoic complet correct quot