commiss decis octob state aid grant itali iveco spa notifi document number italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis procedur letter date june italian author notifi plan grant region aid iveco spa iveco juli commiss request inform italian author provid letter date octob receiv octob decemb commiss decid initi formal enquiri procedur laid articl treati doubt compat measur common market itali submit comment initi proceed letter februari receiv februari april commiss carri visit plant foggia itali april request inform provid itali letter june receiv june commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun invit interest parti submit comment comment receiv ii detail descript measur project notifi project concern product famili diesel engin litr litr version product start engin replac ag model power light commerci vehicl fiat group motor vehicl manufactur project take place exist iveco plant foggia region puglia puglia articl area region ceil period project start august complet decemb italian author state involv instal complet line product engin engin phase gradual time project complet capac plant engin year compris plant produc stand crankshaft sold compet engin produc italian author project mobil site own fiat group bielsko biaa poland chosen project car assembl polish site discontinu free space invest exploit exist infrastructur part workforc product foggia site reduc engin phase end project foggia produc engin year model satisfi demand develop market centr renov engin open foggia italian author state iveco inform decis scale product foggia begin ask iveco reconsid choic offer state aid partial compens extra cost foggia negoti italian author approv region aid map articl region march iveco decid move project foggia work start summer break august formal applic aid made juli approv italian author decemb legal basi amount aid notifi aid grant scheme authoris set act decemb act act decemb act iveco intend invest nomin eur eur current valu base year discount rate eur consid elig italian author plan aid take form outright grant amount nomin eur gross grant equival gge equal eur current valu aid intens notifi italian author gge aid commun financ alloc project ground initi procedur decis initi proceed decemb commiss express doubt mobil project repres quot transform quot need verifi evid show iveco consid bielsko biaa viabl altern locat commiss doubt number element cost benefit analysi inclus inelig invest cost cost benefit analysi justif higher invest cost machineri equip foggia oppos bielsko biaa invest cost vendor tool provid project exact amount invest locat invest name supplier involv exact calcul outward transport cost number worker need product site labour cost foggia iii comment itali februari italian author comment initi proceed addit inform provid visit foggia april letter date june comment italian author reaffirm project mobil provid intern document show final decis carri invest foggia juli bielsko biaa plan abandon time italian author affirm figur eur nomin invest cost benefit analysi repres mobil cost incur iveco project figur eur consid elig act constitut legal basi aid italian author figur gave understand econom choic compani make chosen locat altern site reason refer cost benefit analysi suppli detail inform natur time expens mobil elig invest depreci method elig invest machineri build italian author provid detail inform support evid invest machineri equip made cost foggia higher bielsko biaa work station similar locat signific differ identifi foggia transfer line technic solut select machineri adapt site summer climat condit visit april italian author provid addit evid support claim fourth italian author provid clarif differ vendor tool invest cost supplier teksid cost invest lower poland ow lower price lower degre autom supplier plant italian author repeat engin produc foggia ship destin plant road bielsko biaa ship rail substanti claim provid document show logist facil oper departur destin plant provid detail inform transport rout time sixth italian author provid detail evid number worker emploi engin product number lost product hour suppli materi confirm report labour cost foggia seventh italian author provid detail inform redund cost occur foggia project carri bielsko biaa redund cost occur bielsko biaa consequ choic foggia case foggia italian author estim absenc project take account natur turnov requir residu product engin worker made redund receiv incent leav job remain transfer cost plant oper iveco fiat group compon supplier qualifi special mobil scheme istituto della mobilità worker reach retir ag italian author estim total cost redund foggia eur eur current valu case bielsko biaa italian author confirm redund cost report notif directli unequivoc link decis carri project poland provid evid layoff cost amount eur worker redund connect project final italian author suppli data show european product capac light commerci vehicl segment engin intend remain constant lifetim project fiat group level iv assess aid measur notifi itali favour iveco constitut state aid mean articl treati financ state state resourc constitut signific proport fund project aid liabl distort competit commun give iveco advantag competitor receiv aid extens trade member state automobil market articl ec treati list type aid compat ec treati view natur purpos aid geograph locat firm subparagraph appli plan question articl specifi form aid consid compat common market project locat region puglia qualifi assist articl region ceil larg compani net grant equival nge correspond gge aid grant iveco manufactur assembl engin light commerci vehicl lorri iveco oper motor vehicl industri mean commun framework state aid motor vehicl industri framework framework state aid public author plan grant individu project authoris aid scheme firm oper motor vehicl industri notifi grant accord articl treati threshold reach total cost project eur million total gross aid project state aid aid commun instrument eur million case consider total cost project amount aid exce notif threshold notifi propos aid iveco italian author compli requir articl treati framework commiss ensur aid grant realis project proport graviti problem intend solv test necess proportion satisfi commiss authoris state aid motor vehicl industri paragraph framework state order demonstr necess region aid aid recipi prove econom viabl altern locat project industri site exist capabl receiv invest question group undertak compel carri project sole plant absenc aid region aid authoris project geograph mobil automot expert commiss assess document inform provid itali conclud project mobil italian author shown bielsko biaa viabl altern locat project document provid demonstr bielsko biaa chosen host project april preparatori work start polish site year preparatori work suspend march offici contact iveco italian author pend final decis locat march iveco held meet machineri supplier comau altern bielsko biaa foggia consid juli iveco final decid carri invest foggia abandon bielsko biaa plan offici applic aid submit italian author juli aid approv subject commiss authoris decemb visit site april commiss verifi project involv complet dismantl product line instal complet machineri equip product structur previou project qualifi quot transform quot framework commiss conclud project mobil consid elig region aid aid attract invest assist region elig cost paragraph framework state elig defin scheme applic assist region concern elig cost form basi region handicap aid intens calcul compar region aid ceil present case elig cost defin act amount nomin eur eur current valu base year discount rate aid intens notifi italian author gge point framework commiss ensur plan aid proport region problem intend solv method cost benefit analysi cost benefit analysi made compar regard mobil element cost investor bear order carri project region question bear ident project locat make determin specif handicap assist region concern commiss authoris region aid limit region handicap result invest compar plant accord point framework cost benefit analysi assess oper handicap foggia bielsko biaa year project question transform greenfield develop period cover cost benefit analysi submit year begin product complianc section annex framework commiss account addit inform receiv itali initi proceed base inform extern automot expert commiss modifi element cost benefit analysi detail higher invest cost machineri equip foggia inform provid itali evid gather visit site demonstr differ cost foggia nomin eur bielsko biaa nomin eur justifi product process product machin instal transfer line costli foggia ow layout build lack space case overhead trollei instal foggia transfer compon work station addit smaller cost aros foggia result necess upgrad cool system electr electron unit invest cost vendor tool includ nomin eur consid elig italian author reason form part basi handicap aid intens calcul compar region aid ceil outward transport cost commiss verifi inform provid itali conclud iveco logist capabl ship engin rail bielsko biaa destin plant allow substanti save transport cost engin kilometr compar road transport foggia solut greater distanc polish site destin plant outweigh save base inform provid commiss calcul foggia enjoi advantag outward transport cost equal eur current valu period forecast employ level addit iveco intern document provid itali demonstr number worker project report cost benefit analysi document confirm high incid lost hour total hour engin product lost hour due main factor high level absente plant difficult transit product engin model commiss conclud employ level correctli report cost benefit analysi labour cost foggia addit figur provid italian author show wage cost foggia line italian plant fiat group italian author state recent year differenti labour cost northern southern itali decreas ow phase fiscal incent employ south proport specialis highli skill worker higher engin product plant foggia car assembl plant commiss conclud labour cost report cost benefit analysi accept commiss take view potenti redund cost foggia consid cost benefit analysi order assess compar disadvantag foggia respect bielsko biaa commiss verifi figur provid italian author conclud figur natur turnov residu workforc foggia earli retir mobil istituto della mobilità accept commiss find italian author suffici demonstr worker made redund easili transfer plant belong iveco fiat group compon supplier support claim worker transfer iveco plant north itali italian author provid copi agreement compani union number worker foggia transfer iveco plant commiss doubt similar agreement reach connect partial shutdown foggia plant workforc transfer place time iveco invest heavili foggia plant face temporari drop demand engin produc agreement stipul compani provid incent return transfer worker foggia requir product allow doubt worker union agre similar arrang event import perman cut product plant support claim worker transfer plant fiat group italian author provid figur staff recruit fiat auto plant region figur show great major worker hire temporari basi contract design reduc indirect cost emploi young worker contratti di formazion lavoro commiss consid convinc evid provid show plant readi hire worker made redund foggia italian author averag enjoi high wage level clear worker accept transfer place work offer contractu condit good capac compon supplier hire worker made redund foggia italian author provid evid prove claim base inform possess provid itali respons initi inquiri proceed commiss conclud absenc project number worker made redund foggia benefit special mobil scheme worker close retir ag istituto della mobilità remain worker compens leav job basi commiss estim redund cost arisen foggia absenc project period eur potenti redund cost bielsko biaa redund fact place direct consequ iveco decis carri project foggia downsiz polish plant result thousand redund recent year project made maintain commiss conclud redund cost relat job imput decis carri project poland italian author provid suffici document show cost relat redund worker year eur worker made redund short term basi inform possess commiss estim total redund cost bielsko biaa period eur analysi produc cost benefit result initi notifi itali modifi cost benefit analysi net cost handicap foggia eur valu compar eur initi notifi bring handicap ratio project compar initi notifi absolut valu region handicap lower notifi itali ratio increas cost consid elig framework amount eur final commiss consid question quot top quot increas allow aid intens intend incent invest region question document provid show european product capac light commerci vehicl segment engin intend remain constant lifetim project fiat group level region handicap ratio result cost benefit analysi increas percentag point give final ratio conclus aid intens project gge disadvantag identifi cost benefit top analysi region aid ceil net grant equival figur gross grant equival region aid itali plan grant iveco consid compat common market articl treati adopt decis articl state aid itali plan grant iveco spa foggia amount eur gross grant equival nomin valu eur current valu base year discount rate elig invest eur nomin term eur current valu compat common market mean articl treati articl decis address italian republ brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss oj footnot commiss decis march case oj commiss decis juli rais object case oj convert statut amend decre law octob amend act march respect organis special measur south rule measur facilit product activ measur rationalis public financ footnot oj oj