council regul ec januari protect injuri price vessel council european union regard treati establish european commun articl thereof regard propos commiss regard opinion european parliament multilater negoti conduct auspic organ econom cooper develop led conclus decemb agreement respect normal competit condit commerci shipbuild repair industri hereinaft refer shipbuild agreement recogn framework shipbuild agreement special characterist ship purchas transact made impract appli countervail anti dump duti provid articl vi gener agreement tariff trade gatt agreement subsidi countervail measur agreement implement articl vi gatt annex agreement establish world trade organ provid effect mean protect sale ship normal injuri led conclus shipbuild injuri price code basic principl constitut annex iii shipbuild agreement hereinaft refer ipi code text ipi code base agreement implement articl vi gatt deviat agreement warrant specif natur ship purchas transact transpos languag ipi code commun legisl extent basi text council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun shipbuild agreement legisl provis deriv therefrom signific import commun law maintain balanc right oblig shipbuild agreement establish action commun injuri price vessel sale normal injuri commun industri vi vi shipbuild parti shipbuild agreement sale vessel subject investig commun buyer vessel commun buyer provid ship militari vessel desir lai clear detail rule calcul normal base repres sale vessel ordinari trade export countri expedi defin circumst domest sale consid made loss disregard recours sale vessel countri construct normal desir provid proper alloc cost start situat construct normal methodolog appli determin amount sell gener administr cost profit margin includ order appli correctli instrument combat injuri price commiss step ascertain larg conglomer hold countri valid account charg cost price structur estim determin normal market economi countri appear prudent set rule choos market economi countri purpos find suitabl countri provid normal establish reason basi expedi defin export price enumer adjust made case reconstruct price open market price deem purpos ensur fair comparison export price normal advis list factor includ contractu penalti affect price price compar desir lai clear detail guidanc factor relev determin injuri price sale caus materi injuri threaten injuri demonstr price level sale concern respons injuri sustain commun industri attent effect factor prevail market condit commun advis defin term commun industri refer capabl build vessel provid parti relat export exclud industri defin term relat lai procedur substant condit lodg complaint injuri price includ extent support commun industri inform buyer vessel injuri price injuri causat complaint expedi procedur reject complaint initi proceed buyer injuri price vessel establish territori contract parti shipbuild agreement complaint request investig initi author contract parti request transmit author contract parti warrant investig initi written complaint author contract parti shipbuild agreement accord regul condit shipbuild agreement lai manner interest parti notic inform author requir ampl opportun present relev evid defend interest desir set rule procedur investig rule interest parti make present view submit inform time limit view inform account set condit interest parti access comment inform present interest parti cooper member state commiss collect inform provid termin case irrespect injuri price charg impos place year date initi date deliveri vessel case investig proceed termin margin injuri price de minimi investig termin imposit injuri price charg sale injuri price vessel definit uncondition void altern equival remedi accept avoid jeopard achiev aim pursu regul special consider injuri price charg equal amount injuri price margin impos decis shipbuild injuri price sale vessel caus injuri commun industri condit provid regul fulfil precis detail rule provid implement decis includ measur actual enforc take countermeasur shipbuild pai injuri price charg applic time limit lai precis rule denial load unload commun port vessel built shipbuild subject countermeasur oblig pai injuri price charg expir charg fulli paid end period countermeasur applic action regul contrari commun interest act pursuant regul commun bear mind rapid effect action provid consult advisori committe regular stage investig committe consist repres member state repres commiss chairman expedi provid verif visit check inform submit injuri price injuri visit condit proper repli questionnair receiv provid parti cooper satisfactorili inform establish find inform favour parti cooper provis made treatment confidenti inform busi secret divulg essenti provis made proper disclosur essenti fact consider parti qualifi treatment disclosur made due regard decis make process commun time period permit parti defend interest adopt regul articl principl definit injuri price charg impos builder injuri price vessel sale buyer buyer countri vessel origin injuri vessel consid injuri price export price vessel sold compar price vessel ordinari trade sold buyer export countri purpos regul term vessel propel sea vessel gross tonn transport good person perform special servic ic breaker dredger tug kw term vessel vessel type purpos approxim size vessel consider possess characterist close resembl vessel consider term gener categori vessel vessel type purpos significantli size term sale cover creation transfer ownership interest vessel ownership interest creat acquir sole purpos provid secur normal commerci loan term ownership interest includ contractu proprietari interest beneficiari beneficiari interest advantag oper vessel manner substanti compar owner benefit oper vessel determin substanti compar exist factor consid inter alia term circumst transact ii commerci practic industri iii vessel subject transact integr oper beneficiari beneficiari iv practic likelihood beneficiari beneficiari interest advantag risk oper vessel signific part life time vessel term buyer person compani acquir ownership interest includ leas long term bareboat charter conjunct origin transfer shipbuild directli indirectli includ person compani own control buyer instruct buyer person compani own buyer interest buyer person compani control buyer person compani legal operation posit exercis restraint direct buyer presum interest ownership buyer shown separ control presum exist establish buyer vessel term compani compani firm constitut civil commerci law includ cooper societi legal person govern public privat law includ profitmak term contract parti countri parti shipbuild agreement articl determin injuri price normal normal base price paid payabl ordinari trade vessel independ buyer export countri price parti compensatori arrang consid ordinari trade establish normal determin unaffect relationship sale vessel ordinari trade market situat sale permit proper comparison normal vessel calcul basi export price vessel ordinari trade countri provid price repres sale countri exist permit proper comparison normal vessel calcul basi cost product countri origin reason amount sell gener administr cost profit sale vessel domest market export countri export sale countri price unit product cost fix variabl sell gener administr cost treat ordinari trade reason price disregard determin normal determin sale price provid recoveri cost reason period year cost calcul basi record shipbuild investig provid record accord gener accept account principl countri concern shown record reflect cost product sale vessel consider consider evid submit proper alloc cost provid shown alloc histor util absenc method prefer alloc cost basi turnov reflect cost alloc subparagraph cost adjust appropri recur item cost benefit futur current product circumst cost affect start oper amount sell gener administr cost profit base actual data pertain product sale ordinari trade vessel shipbuild investig amount determin basi amount determin basi weight averag actual amount determin shipbuild countri origin respect product sale vessel countri domest market actual amount applic product sale ordinari trade gener categori vessel shipbuild question domest market countri origin reason method provid amount profit establish exce profit realiz shipbuild sale vessel gener categori domest market countri origin profit ad construct instanc base averag profit realiz reason period time month sale investig reflect reason profit time sale make calcul distort demonstr result profit reason time sale elimin long lead time contract deliveri vessel normal includ actual cost shipbuild demonstr due forc majeur significantli cost increas shipbuild anticip account materi term sale fix case sale market economi countri council regul ec march common rule import countri repeal regul eec eec eec appli normal determin basi price construct market economi countri price countri countri includ commun reason basi includ price paid payabl commun vessel duli adjust includ reason profit margin market economi countri select unreason manner due account reliabl inform made time select account time limit parti investig inform shortli initi market economi countri envisag dai comment export price export price price paid payabl vessel consider case export price appear export price unreli associ compensatori arrang shipbuild buyer parti export price construct basi price vessel resold independ buyer vessel resold independ buyer resold condit origin sold reason basi case adjust cost includ duti tax incur origin sale resal profit accru made establish reliabl export price item adjust made includ born buyer paid parti insid commun appear compensatori arrang shipbuild buyer includ usual transport insur handl load ancillari cost custom duti tax payabl import countri reason purchas vessel reason margin sell gener administr cost profit comparison fair comparison made export price normal comparison made level trade respect sale made time sale month sale investig absenc sale period due allow made case merit differ affect price compar includ differ condit term sale contractu penalti taxat level trade quantiti physic characterist differ demonstr affect price compar case refer paragraph price compar affect normal establish level trade equival level trade construct export price due allow made warrant paragraph duplic make adjust avoid relat discount contractu penalti price comparison requir convers currenc convers made rate exchang date sale sale foreign currenc forward market directli link export sale involv rate exchang forward sale purpos provis date sale date materi term sale establish date contract materi term sale significantli chang date rate exchang date chang appli case adjust made account unreason effect injuri price margin due sole exchang rate fluctuat origin date sale date chang injuri price margin subject relev provis govern fair comparison exist injuri price margin establish basi comparison weight averag normal weight averag price sale comparison individu normal valu individu export price transact transact basi normal establish weight averag basi compar price individu sale pattern export price differ significantli purchas region time period method sentenc paragraph reflect full degre injuri price practis injuri price margin amount normal exce export price injuri price margin vari weight averag injuri price margin establish articl determin injuri pursuant regul term injuri materi injuri commun industri threat materi injuri commun industri materi retard establish industri interpret accord provis articl determin injuri base posit evid involv object examin effect sale normal price commun market vessel consequ impact sale commun industri regard effect sale normal price consider signific price undercut sale normal compar price vessel commun industri effect sale depress price signific degre prevent price increas occur signific degre factor necessarili give decis guidanc sale vessel countri simultan subject injuri price investig effect sale cumul assess determin margin injuri price establish relat purchas countri de minimi defin articl cumul assess effect sale light condit competit vessel sold commun shipbuild buyer condit competit vessel commun vessel examin impact sale normal commun industri concern includ evalu relev econom factor indic bear state industri includ fact industri process recov effect past dump injuri price subsid magnitud actual margin injuri price actual potenti declin sale profit output market share product return invest util capac factor affect commun price actual potenti neg effect cash flow inventori employ wage growth abil rais capit invest list exhaust factor necessarili give decis guidanc demonstr relev evid present relat paragraph sale normal caus caus injuri mean regul specif entail demonstr price level identifi pursuant paragraph respons impact commun industri provid paragraph impact exist degre enabl classifi materi factor sale normal time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor attribut sale normal paragraph factor consid respect includ volum price sale shipbuild countri export countri realiz normal contract demand pattern consumpt restrict trade practic competit countri commun produc develop technolog export perform product commun industri effect sale normal assess relat product commun industri vessel data permit separ identif product basi criteria product process produc sale profit separ identif product effect sale normal assess examin product narrowest group rang vessel includ vessel inform provid determin threat materi injuri base fact alleg conjectur remot possibl chang circumst creat situat sale normal injuri foreseen immin make determin exist threat materi injuri consider inter alia factor suffici freeli dispos capac shipbuild immin substanti increas capac indic likelihood substanti increas sale normal account avail export market absorb addit export vessel export price signific degre depress price prevent price increas occur increas demand purchas countri factor list necessarili give decis guidanc total factor consid lead conclus sale normal immin protect action materi injuri occur articl definit commun industri purpos regul term commun industri interpret refer commun produc capabl produc vessel present facil facil adapt time manner produc vessel collect capabl produc vessel constitut major proport defin articl total commun capabl produc vessel produc relat shipbuild export buyer buyer allegedli injuri price vessel term commun industri interpret refer rest produc purpos paragraph produc consid relat shipbuild export buyer directli indirectli control directli indirectli control person directli indirectli control person provid ground believ suspect effect relationship produc concern behav differ relat produc purpos paragraph deem control legal operation posit exercis restraint direct provis articl applic articl articl initi proceed provid paragraph investig determin exist degre effect alleg injuri price initi written complaint natur legal person associ legal person act behalf commun industri complaint submit commiss member state forward commiss commiss send member state copi complaint receiv complaint deem lodg work dai deliveri commiss regist mail issu acknowledg receipt commiss absenc complaint member state possess suffici evid injuri price result injuri commun industri immedi commun evid commiss complaint paragraph file month time complain knew sale vessel complain invit tender bid contract issu broad multipl bid bid process complain tender bid bid complain substanti met bid specif month time complain knew sale vessel absenc invit tender provid notic intent appli includ inform complain identifi transact concern submit month time commiss member state event complaint file month date deliveri vessel complain consid sale vessel time public fact conclus contract gener inform vessel intern trade press purpos articl broad multipl bid interpret bid propos buyer extend invit bid shipbuild buyer capabl build vessel question complaint paragraph includ evid injuri price injuri causal link injuri price sale alleg injuri vessel sold broad multipl bid complain invit tender bid contract issu bid complain substanti met bid specif deliveri date technic requir ii vessel sold bid process complain invit tender bid contract issu bid complain substanti met bid specif iii absenc invit tender bid broad multipl bid complain capabl build vessel concern complain knew propos purchas made demonstr effort conclud sale buyer consist bid specif question complain consid propos purchas demonstr major relev industri made effort buyer conclud sale vessel question demonstr gener inform propos purchas broker financi classif societi charter trade associ entiti involv shipbuild transact complain regular contact deal complaint inform complain ident complain descript volum commun product vessel complain written complaint made behalf commun industri complaint identifi industri behalf complaint made list commun produc capabl build vessel extent descript volum commun product vessel account produc complet descript allegedli injuri price vessel name countri countri origin export question ident export foreign produc ident buyer vessel question price vessel sold domest market countri countri origin export inform price vessel sold countri countri origin export countri countri construct vessel inform export price price vessel resold independ buyer effect injuri price sale price vessel commun market consequ impact sale commun industri demonstr relev factor indic bear state commun industri list articl commiss examin accuraci adequaci evid provid complaint determin suffici evid justifi initi investig investig initi pursuant paragraph determin basi examin degre support opposit complaint express commun produc capabl build vessel complaint made behalf commun industri complaint consid made behalf commun industri support commun produc collect capac produc vessel constitut total capac portion commun industri express support opposit complaint investig initi commun produc expressli support complaint account total capac commun produc capabl produc vessel author avoid decis made initi investig public complaint seek initi investig proceed initi investig govern export countri concern notifi special circumst decid initi investig receiv written complaint behalf commun industri initi investig basi suffici evid injuri price injuri causal link member allegedli injur commun industri met criteria paragraph articl justifi initi investig initi written complaint author contract parti complaint support suffici evid show vessel injuri price alleg sale commun buyer normal caus caus injuri domest industri contract parti concern evid injuri price injuri consid simultan decis initi investig complaint reject insuffici evid injuri price injuri justifi proceed case complaint withdrawn prior initi case consid lodg prejudic articl consult appar suffici evid justifi initi proceed commiss dai lodg complaint case initi pursuant paragraph month time sale vessel publish notic offici journal european commun insuffici evid present complain consult inform dai date complaint lodg commiss notic initi proceed announc initi investig countri shipbuild buyer descript vessel concern give summari inform receiv provid relev inform commun commiss state period interest parti make present view write submit inform view inform account investig state period interest parti appli heard commiss accord articl commiss advis export buyer vessel repres associ produc export buyer vessel concern repres countri vessel subject investig complain initi proceed due regard protect confidenti inform provid full text written complaint receiv pursuant paragraph export author export countri make request interest parti involv articl investig initi proceed commiss act cooper member state author countri commenc investig commun level investig cover injuri price injuri investig simultan parti receiv questionnair injuri price investig dai repli time limit export count date receipt questionnair purpos deem receiv week dai export transmit diplomat repres export countri extens dai period grant due account time limit investig provid parti show due extens term circumst commiss request author countri member state suppli inform member state step order give effect request send commiss inform request result inspect check investig carri inform gener interest transmiss request member state commiss forward member state provid confidenti case confidenti summari forward commiss request author countri member state carri check inspect commun produc carri investig countri provid firm concern give consent govern countri question offici notifi rais object member state step order give effect request commiss offici commiss author commiss member state request assist offici member state carri duti likewis offici commiss assist offici author countri carri duti agreement commiss author interest parti made accord articl heard period prescrib notic publish offici journal european commun made written request hear show interest parti affect result proceed reason heard opportun request provid shipbuild buyer repres govern export countri complain interest parti made accord articl meet parti advers interest oppos view present rebutt argument offer provis opportun account preserv confidenti conveni parti oblig parti attend meet failur prejudici parti case oral inform provid paragraph account subsequ confirm write complain shipbuild buyer interest parti made accord articl repres export countri written request inspect inform made parti investig distinct intern document prepar author commun member state relev present case confidenti mean articl investig parti respond inform comment consider suffici substanti respons circumst provid articl inform suppli interest parti find base examin accuraci proceed involv price price comparison vessel deliv investig conclud year date initi proceed vessel construct investig conclud year date deliveri vessel investig involv construct conclud year initi year deliveri vessel whichev time limit suspend extent articl appli articl termin measur imposit collect injuri price charg complaint withdrawn proceed termin consult measur unnecessari object rais advisori committe investig proceed termin case commiss submit council forthwith report result consult propos proceed termin proceed deem termin month council act qualifi major decid termin determin margin injuri price express percentag export price fact final establish show injuri price injuri caus injuri price charg impos shipbuild council act simpl major propos submit commiss consult advisori committe amount injuri price charg equal margin injuri price establish council decis work dai receiv propos commiss measur implement council decis collect injuri price charg shipbuild pai injuri price charg dai notif imposit charg purpos deem receiv week dai shipbuild commiss give shipbuild extend period time pai shipbuild demonstr payment dai render insolv incompat judici supervis reorgan case interest accru unpaid portion charg rate equal secondari market yield medium term ecu bond luxembourg stock exchang basi point articl altern remedi consult advisori committe investig termin imposit injuri price charg shipbuild definit uncondition void sale injuri price vessel compli altern equival remedi accept commiss sale consid void contractu relationship parti concern sale question termin consider paid connect sale reimburs right vessel concern part thereof return shipbuild articl countermeasur denial load unload right shipbuild concern pai injuri price charg impos articl countermeasur form denial load unload right impos commiss consult advisori committe vessel built shipbuild question decis impos countermeasur enter forc dai public offici journal european commun repeal full payment injuri price charg shipbuild countermeasur cover vessel contract period year date entri forc decis vessel subject countermeasur period year deliveri period reduc accord outcom intern disput settlement procedur countermeasur impos vessel subject denial load unload right decis adopt commiss publish offici journal european commun member state custom author grant permiss load unload vessel subject denial load unload right articl consult consult provid regul place advisori committe consist repres member state repres commiss chairman consult held immedi request member state initi commiss event period time time limit set regul adher committe meet conven chairman provid member state promptli relev inform consult write event commiss notifi member state period entitl express opinion request oral consult chairman arrang provid oral consult held period time time limit set regul adher consult cover exist injuri price method establish injuri price margin exist extent injuri causal link injuri price sale injuri measur circumst remedi injuri price wai mean put measur effect articl verif visit commiss consid carri visit examin record export shipbuild trader agent produc trade associ organ verifi inform provid injuri price injuri absenc proper time repli verif visit carri commiss carri investig countri requir provid obtain agreement firm concern notifi repres govern countri question object investig agreement firm concern obtain commiss notifi author export countri name address firm visit date agre firm concern advis natur inform verifi verif visit inform provid visit preclud request made verif detail provid light inform obtain investig carri paragraph commiss assist offici member state request articl cooper case interest parti refus access provid inform time limit provid regul significantli imped investig provision final find affirm neg made basi fact found interest parti suppli fals mislead inform inform disregard made fact interest parti made awar consequ cooper failur give computer respons deem constitut cooper provid interest parti show present respons request result unreason extra burden unreason addit cost inform submit interest parti ideal respect disregard provid defici undu difficulti arriv accur find inform appropri submit good time verifi parti act abil evid inform accept suppli parti inform forthwith reason grant opportun provid explan time limit explan consid unsatisfactori reason reject evid inform disclos publish find determin includ normal base provis paragraph includ inform suppli complaint practic due regard time limit investig check refer inform independ sourc publish price list offici statist sale custom return inform obtain interest parti investig interest parti cooper cooper partial relev inform withheld result favour parti cooper articl confidenti inform natur confidenti disclosur signific competit advantag competitor significantli advers effect person suppli inform person acquir inform provid confidenti basi parti investig good shown treat author interest parti provid confidenti inform requir furnish nonconfidenti summari thereof summari suffici detail permit reason understand substanc inform submit confid except circumst parti inform suscept summari except circumst statement reason summar provid consid request confidenti warrant supplier inform unwil make inform author disclosur gener summari form inform disregard satisfactorili demonstr sourc inform correct request confidenti arbitrarili reject articl preclud disclosur gener inform commun author reason decis pursuant regul base disclosur evid reli commun author explain reason court proceed disclosur account legitim interest parti concern busi secret divulg council commiss member state offici reveal inform receiv pursuant regul confidenti treatment ga request supplier specif permiss supplier exchang inform commiss member state inform relat consult made pursuant articl intern document prepar author commun member state divulg specif provid regul inform receiv pursuant regul purpos request articl disclosur complain shipbuild export buyer vessel repres associ repres export countri request disclosur detail underli essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit injuri price charg termin investig proceed imposit charg request final disclosur defin paragraph address commiss write receiv time limit set commiss disclosur effect write effect due regard protect confidenti inform month definit decis commiss submiss propos definit decis articl commiss posit disclos fact consider time disclos disclosur prejudic subsequ decis commiss council decis base fact consider disclos represent made disclosur consider receiv period set commiss case dai due consider urgenc matter articl final provis regul preclud applic special rule laid agreement conclud commun countri special measur provid action run counter oblig pursuant shipbuild agreement investig pursuant regul carri measur impos maintain measur contrari commun oblig eman shipbuild agreement relev intern agreement regul prevent commun fulfil oblig provis shipbuild agreement disput settlement articl entri forc regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun appli date entri forc shipbuild agreement appli vessel contract date entri forc shipbuild agreement vessel contract decemb deliveri year date contract vessel subject regul shipbuild demonstr extend deliveri date normal commerci reason avoid applic regul regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel januari council presid agnelli oj oj page offici journal oj regul amend regul ec oj date entri forc shipbuild agreement publish offici journal european commun seri