commiss decis decemb aid grant germani riedel de haën ag notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun paragraph articl regard agreement european econom area articl notic accord articl ec treati interest parti submit comment regard comment procedur letter april privat individu lodg complaint commiss effect riedel de haën ag hereinaft refer quot riedel de haën quot seelz germani receiv state aid amount dem million ecu million invest special wast inciner complain provid commiss particular letter april septemb februari march februari alleg compani intend inciner industri wast premis port author antwerp citi refus permiss environment ground inciner sea inciner ship vesta confirm press report complain compani maintain plant bromin recoveri plant knew plant compani premis previou year letter april june novemb commiss call germani give view suppli inform aid riedel de haën verifi kind grant involv compat common market germani repli letter june septemb januari confirm compani receiv grant amount dem million ecu million germani state aid grant bromin recoveri plant subsequ explain aid fact residu process plant incorpor bromin recoveri plant letter septemb commiss notifi germani decis initi procedur articl grant aid amount dem million ecu million conclud grant made approv economi environ scheme programm quot wirtschaft und umwelt quot grant cover approv rule grant appear compat commun guidelin state aid environment protect notifi germani letter octob letter novemb march germani gave view question reserv respond commiss request inform gener term commiss decis publish offici journal european commun decis gave parti concern notic submit comment deadlin januari receiv comment april solicitor act alliedsign riedel de haën parent compani set compani posit letter june commiss ask germani provid inform decid grant aid compat common market made clear germani chanc provid inform fail decis basi inform commiss dispos meet germani repres riedel de haën held brussel juli germani riedel de haën respond joint letter august letter consid posit adopt riedel de haën letter april posit fulli consider commiss analysi germani posit incorpor commiss analysi riedel de haën posit aid year riedel de haën gener tonn liquid wast halogen hydrocarbon compound wast previous dispos specialis busi special wast inciner compani began construct recycl plant dispos liquid wast site plant oper germani initi assess cost project dem million ecu million adjust dem million ecu million letter august figur incorpor invest develop cost oper cost compani invest cost estim dem million ecu million dem million ecu million invest june tabl breakdown cost develop cost estim dem million ecu million trial oper cost amount dem million ecu million accuraci figur verifi firm account riedel de haën grant invest aid grant dem million ecu million lower saxoni econom assist fund letter april part economi environ scheme approv grant dem million ecu million feder foundat environ letter scheme time approv commiss germani instal amount dem million ecu million paid comment german author letter august germani submit comment set maintain plant exclus environment protect purpos alleg economi environ scheme authoris commiss declar compat common market copi scheme commiss authoris notic authoris publish offici journal european commun append feder foundat environ aid principl compat commun guidelin grant consid aid research develop mean commun framework aid research develop addit germani express view commiss requir aid repaid compani legitim expect met germani present excerpt commerci regist entri riedel de haën ag riedel de haën gmbh annual report list compani fix asset plant produc halogen hydrocarbon plan product site seelz tabl project cost breakdown cost view standpoint present accuraci data verifi firm account data append comparison cost contrast current suppli cost cost suppli plant firm account verifi part cost form basi calcul explan provid germani oper inciner recycl plant differ bromin recoveri plant environment impact assess riedel de haën provid report expert gener contamin plant supplementari materi riedel de haën brochur entitl recycl plant bromin residu verif environment compat lodg copi feder emiss protect order bimschv technic instruct ta quot air quot append forego document addit copi riedel de haën applic aid council regul eec establish life programm copi commiss refus copi compani letter repli present copi riedel de haën applic aid lower saxoni econom assist fund feder foundat environ append result environment impact assess notifi assess recipi aid riedel de haën subsidiari hoechst ag novemb belong american group alliedsign morristown jersei averag employe gener turnov amount dem million ecu million total asset dem million ecu million measur commiss recommend april definit small medium size enterpris riedel de haën larg enterpris compani locat assist area lower saxoni chemic enterpris oper field inorgan chemic laboratori chemic organ chemic technic preserv product electrochem luminesc pigment photograph dye pharmaceut medicin product aid lower saxoni econom assist fund feder foundat environ public institut financ grant aid includ present grant state resourc letter august germani call question statu foundat state institut respons commiss brought point relev decis foundat set feder law capit amount dem billion ecu billion deriv privatis state enterpris salzgitt ag paragraph law state foundat object provid financi support environment project implement sme paragraph law foundat board member appoint feder govern decid inter alia assist grant grant aid foundat gener applic automat procedur basi object criteria actual fact german author assist board decis discret lastli paragraph law foundat audit feder court auditor regard circumst fact articl appli quot aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev quot commiss conclud foundat assist constitut state aid mean articl fact germani meantim notifi foundat amend rule articl authoris commiss state aid compat common market sector activ riedel de haën compet chemic enterpris member state product featur intra commun trade gener turnov foreign market europ aid lower invest cost consider give advantag competitor member state receiv invest aid liabl prejudic competit posit bromin recoveri riedel de haën competit busi oper kind plant studi present germani estim bromin recoveri plant need western europ grant aid give riedel de haen advantag busi member state kind plant aid liabl affect competit posit advers grant aid liabl distort trade member state constitut state aid mean articl oblig notif aid lower saxoni econom assist fund decemb riedel de haën appli lower saxoni econom assist fund financi support letter april fund made grant economi environ scheme dem million ecu million project cost amount dem million ecu million intend invest complet decemb germani time fund amount dem million ecu million expend project dem million ecu million account invest cost aid contract riedel de haën receiv full amount dem million ecu million decis initi procedur articl commiss express find fund grant made term fix economi environ scheme commiss authoris septemb period scheme fund entitl provid aid invest environment project thrust develop demonstr project involv quot ecolog ad commun quot point scheme quot expenditur basic exce exist legal requir regard elig assist quot spite request commiss germani part invest manifestli exce legal requir unclear part project elig mean scheme part clear fund act accord point scheme meet held brussel held juli german deleg confirm special invest requir order exce exist legal requir comment germani letter august commiss see reason review examin scheme refer germani decis adopt fact review examin confirm decis economi environ scheme lower saxoni provid ground fund grant riedel de haën aid question grant consid individu grant aid notifi germani articl aid grant unlawfulli aid feder foundat environ septemb riedel de haën appli foundat financi support foundat examin proceed basi applic septemb compani alter applic subsequ date letter foundat grant aid amount dem million ecu million commiss found decis initi procedur articl aid authoris scheme germani disput view germani fail compli duti notif articl aid aid grant unlawfulli commiss point foundat made grant aid condit compani provid fund dem million ecu million probabl cost project amount dem million ecu million aid grant fund reduc burden compani condit fulfil exempt aid articl incompat common market articl set condit met aid consid compat common market commiss examin grant aid amount dem million ecu million qualifi provis exempt gener prohibit aid articl appli assist constitut aid social charact grant individu consum aid make good damag caus natur disast aid grant economi area germani affect divis germani articl exempt region articl applic compani locat assist area ground grant exempt articl commiss opinion project meet criteria applic treat import project common european interest aid intend remedi disturb economi member state likewis question exempt articl aid intend promot cultur conserv heritag provis applic part articl aid facilit develop econom activ exempt advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest compat commun guidelin germani maintain aid consid invest made environment protect condit invest consid aid environment protect compat common market laid commun guidelin current commun guidelin publish march grant aid made date april commiss consid light current commun guidelin germani argu plant product purpos exclus intend environment protect compani oblig construct residu process plant conclud permiss grant total project cost invest cost includ develop cost aid environment protect commiss share standpoint view plant involv product process riedel de haën product creat hazard liquid wast oblig dispos dispos consid part product process plant enabl wast dispos site part product process bromin recoveri plant form signific part process plant recov major quantiti bromin directli return product process point commun guidelin aid invest grant invest land build plant equip provis invest cost dem million ecu million possibl consid aid environment protect develop cost cost trial oper point state unequivoc quot elig cost strictli confin extra invest cost meet environment object gener invest cost attribut environment protect exclud quot germani establish part invest cost attribut environment protect proceed principl commiss conclud aid consid aid environment protect invest firm adapt mandatori standard promot quicker complianc standard invest support measur lower emiss significantli exce mandatori standard invest notwithstand absenc mandatori standard adopt basi agreement compani intensifi effort reduc environment pollut notwithstand absenc statutori oblig oblig effect invest aid firm adapt mandatori standard regard categori commun guidelin provid point quot keep pollut pai principl aid cost compli mandatori standard plant quot commiss point residu process plant form invest replac exist plant riedel de haën oper bromin recoveri plant germani inform plant decommiss earli technic standpoint significantli inferior plant integr residu process plant commiss plant replac exist plant entir residu process plant undoubtedli constitut plant purpos commun guidelin imposs authoris aid invest adapt mandatori standard contrari quot pollut pai quot principl invest aid firm significantli mandatori standard germani maintain aid constitut incent improv mandatori standard commiss posit august conclud germani grant aid partli object gener emiss standard project natur laid feder emiss protect order order requir land author adopt decis lai applic environment standard take account characterist individu project present case govern land lower saxoni fix mandatori standard decis march applic riedel de haën site confirm decis august grant authoris requir laid land govern hannov decis requir order decis fix valu emiss term half hourli read emiss valu order fix daili read germani consid compani improv requir laid mandatori standard commiss share view decis requir compani compli valu valu mandatori standard part invest elig aid part relat measur mandatori standard decis commiss request germani state signific reduct emiss prescrib valu link increas cost germani fail part invest serv improv standard fix decis order fact meet brussel juli german deleg confirm special invest need compli valu decis improv valu order commiss authoris assist invest aid encourag firm improv mandatori standard germani fail establish invest cost elig aid aid absenc mandatori environment standard letter august germani maintain aid grant environment protect field mandatori standard claim compani hitherto dispos residu special wast inciner recycl residu inciner gener significantli lower level gaseou solid wast hazard wast order prescrib threshold valu concentr relev quantiti invest result appreci improv environment perform field mandatori standard point commun guidelin field mandatori standard legal oblig firm protect environ firm undertak invest significantli improv environment perform match firm member state mandatori standard appli grant aid subject condit proportion exist standard point guidelin point commun guidelin level aid grant exceed standard proport improv environ achiev invest achiev improv aid grant comparison plant case instal improv environ occur invest made commerci ground order achiev improv environment condit order word essenti purpos part commun guidelin state aid purpos encourag firm carri supplementari invest secur improv environment perform posit financi incent aid disincent tax levi consid commun guidelin point ultim object invest incent sphere facilit gradual improv qualiti environ commun guidelin point commun guidelin intend grant state aid gener invest compani case made busi ground laid point commun guidelin elig cost strictli confin extra invest cost meet environment object basi object fix point commun guidelin commiss conclud case plant firm compar equival activ form basi assess aid environment protect firm process harm environ statutori minimum directli contrari object commun guidelin environment impact plant compar impact similar compar plant firm likelihood contempl econom consider appli principl commiss conclud comparison dispos residu process plant inciner justifi compani made invest environment ground econom consider condit aid form incent environment protect gener incent invest commiss view suffici evid econom object invest mention compani oblig dispos noxiou liquid wast germani liquid wast inciner final dispos imposs inciner carri local special wast inciner high bromin content residu inciner small quantiti supplement wast futur inciner oper possibl refus dispos wast wast high bromin content lead signific deterior plant assum dispos cost wast high bromin content rise appreci futur plant compani depend price polici oper special wast inciner avoid depend compani dispos liquid wast addit recoveri plant enabl riedel de haën recycl signific quantiti substanc year includ tonn bromin tonn potassium chlorid tonn potassium fluorid directli manufactur process compani reduc product cost appreci lastli compani save cost transport liquid wast site special wast inciner germani consider cost involv commiss agre germani view advantag environ provid plant dispos residu special wast inciner cheaper process special plant germani provid commiss imprecis calcul effect addit cost year incur conclus natur calcul accuraci establish confirm firm account verif state accuraci cost dispos residu duli establish riedel de haën german compani bromin recoveri plant report lodg germani compani dispos bromin residu small medium size enterpris view report quot project carri highli interest busi quot plant design process tonn residu year germani establish tonn liquid wast dispos compani acquir busi addit incom economi scale consider establish riedel de haën invest recycl plant motiv econom environment consider comparison quantiti harm residu plant inciner inappropri proceed basi abovement consider commiss verifi riedel de haën intend environment ground make invest residu process plant increas invest cost assum view plant environment impact compani event instal pure econom ground expert report submit germani gaseou solid wast reduc inciner process volum oxygen concentr dry wast gase occur residu process plant oxygen concentr volum riedel de haën plant oper oxygen concentr volum amount wast gase gener plant fact oper characterist produc improv plant kind commiss point germani argu cost appreci improv environment term field mandatori standard fail prove opt invest residu process plant invest made exclus purpos environment protect commiss unabl regard support invest aid environment protect field mandatori standard germani fail prove exist elig invest cost oper aid point commun guidelin accord long stand polici commiss approv oper aid reliev firm cost result pollut nuisanc commiss make except principl defin circumst field wast manag public financ addit cost select collect recoveri treatment wast benefit busi consum involv state aid point commun guidelin plant oper semi public bodi servic cost met consum take account circumst case basi exist inform view natur procedur basi preced analysi commiss consid aid issu procedur grant basi point commun guidelin consider letter march riedel de haën ask commiss aid life programm germani programm fact financ commiss fund lack compani assum commiss recognis project innovatori characterist commiss recognis innovatori project letter juli refus applic fact ad plan amend prospect commun assist succeed year germani view aid amp exempt commiss consid justif aid refer brochur produc riedel de haën recycl plant bromin residu verif environment compat technolog question develop earli engin firm state aid grant april germani fail demonstr cost consid elig research develop aid commun guidelin conclus clear grant aid odd applic commun guidelin state aid environment protect relat environment protect criterion compat common market project consid gener invest project riedel de haën larg enterpris locat assist area invest aid firm exempt articl grant aid cover exempt provis advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest give riedel de haën unjustifi advantag competitor receiv assist aid compat common market unlawfulli grant purpos articl fulfil condit exempt provis articl grant aid termin repaid accord term set european court justic judgment case repay effect make good distort competit result grant aid notwithstand formal restructur carri group reason repay made riedel de haën ag successor aid recov group subsidiari continu busi exploit product asset acquir riedel de haën aid riedel de haën gmbh repay made accord procedur rule german law interest state outstand claim effect interest payabl time unlaw aid grant measur order restor origin situat make good financi advantag receiv assist enterpris point aid unlawfulli paid adopt decis articl aid dem million lower saxoni econom assist fund aid dem million feder foundat environ grant unlawfulli riedel de haën ag seelz compat common market articl germani measur recov aid paid riedel de haën ag successor prove imposs germani measur recov aid articl riedel de haën gmbh aid recov accord procedur rule german law interest payabl sum recov time grant actual repay made rate commiss period question calcul net grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel decemb commiss karel van miert member commiss context quot riedel de haën quot understood refer riedel de haën gmbh quot wast dispos problem riedel quot landkrei zeitung west octob oj oj part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos squar bracket mark asterisk oj order implement feder law emiss protect inciner wast similar combust materi oj oj law juli establish feder foundat environ bgbi quot studi transfer plant develop riedel de haën ag seelz recoveri residu quot professor hess hanov septemb connexion part decis ecr paragraph