commiss decis grant spain aid undertak hunosa notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european coal steel commun regard commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid coal industri articl articl thereof letter march spain notifi commiss pursuant articl decis ecsc financi support intend grant undertak hullera del nort sa hunosa letter march commiss invit spain pursuant articl ecsc treati submit comment situat instal undertak mina de lier sa oper result instal question cover closur measur financ state aid subsequ reopen hunosa quot pozo siero quot product unit spain repli letter august commiss request inform letter septemb decemb februari spain repli commiss letter januari march decis ecsc decemb grant spain aid coal industri commiss authoris part aid spain plan grant hunosa product unit pozo siero instal mina de lier sa pursuant decis ecsc commiss rule remain measur aid eur esp million cover oper loss hunosa product unit aid eur esp million cover technic cost close mine instal result measur reduc activ coal industri financi measur propos spain hunosa fall provis articl decis ecsc commiss decis measur accord articl decis commiss assess base complianc measur gener criteria object laid articl specif criteria establish articl decis compat proper function common market addition accord articl decis commiss conduct assess check measur conform activ reduct plan commiss approv hunosa decis ecsc ii decis ecsc ecsc commiss gave opinion conform phase activ reduct plan hunosa notifi spain gener specif object decis ecsc commiss found request spain decis ecsc quot mine hunosa mina de lier sa close definit decemb quot compli date set letter date march commiss start pre litig procedur letter formal notic order examin failur compli closur date reason pai aid cover product cost januari closur date decis ecsc commiss announc decid date aid hunosa alloc instal mina de lier sa commiss consid aid total eur esp million reduct activ pursuant articl decis ecsc eur esp million cover technic cost close mine instal pursuant articl decis ecsc hunosa cover closur plan kind provid articl decis ecsc postpon expiri decis justifi except social region ground hunosa receiv aid reduct activ articl decis ecsc subject progress continu reduct activ entail signific reduct capac decis ecsc expir period decis ecsc forc hunosa product capac fell million tonn million tonn workforc shrunk worker end end product cost held steadi eur tonn coal equival tce compar sell price eur tce import coal suppli spanish power station trend set context reduct product capac commun million tonn million tonn number worker emploi industri commun fell end end averag product cost commun stand eur tce context hunosa continu worker close small number product unit time reopen instal mina de lier sa close programm state aid grant commiss consid hunosa appli activ reduct plan kind provid decis ecsc adopt measur render reduct activ period question insignific context restructur effort undertaken commun iii commiss examin hunosa failur compli special condit laid instal mina de lier sa constitut abus aid call question compat aid previous grant decis ecsc letter spain commiss inform situat instal mina de lier sa hunosa letter spain enclos report hunosa state produc tce tce tce instal receiv state aid cover oper loss commiss consid hunosa oper loss period instal mina de lier sa higher notifi hunosa includ cost labour capit servic notif estim oper loss forese add esp million commiss ask spain addit inform letter septemb letter januari spain notifi commiss hunosa product cost instal mina de lier sa pozo siero product unit oper loss pozo siero half stood eur esp million eur esp million eur esp million eur esp million total eur esp million spain state june hunosa ceas product instal mina de lier sa order proce safeti environment protect work prior definit closur mine hunosa failur compli condit laid commiss instal mina de lier sa constitut abus aid call question compat aid grant decis ecsc aid total eur esp million reduct activ grant hunosa spain cover oper loss pozo siero product unit mina de lier sa incompat decis ecsc articl thereof incompat proper function common market aid total eur esp million spain plan grant hunosa cover oper loss pozo siero likewis incompat decis ecsc articl thereof incompat proper function common market aid total eur esp million intend cover oper loss product unit oper hunosa compat articl decis ecsc proper function common market aid paid spain hunosa cover oper loss pozo siero product unit mina de lier sa consid unjustifi cash advanc liabl charg market rate payabl recipi interest calcul date payment aid undertak receiv iv spain grant aid closur instal mina de lier sa reason grant aid purpos letter januari spain notifi commiss half closur instal mina de lier sa gener technic cost total eur esp million hunosa aid cover cost incompat decis ecsc articl thereof letter march repli letter februari commiss spain state except intrins depreci result closur hunosa product unit exclud cost closur instal mina de lier sa gave rise except cost total eur esp million decis ecsc commiss authoris spain pai hunosa eur esp million balanc eur esp million cover cost close product unit instal mina de lier sa compat decis ecsc articl thereof aid compat proper function common market spain ensur aid grant current product decis give rise discrimin coal produc purchas user commun coal market spain ensur framework provis articl ecsc treati aid limit strictli light social region consider characteris declin commun coal industri spain ensur aid grant undertak articl decis ecsc cover technic cost closur exclus purpos list annex decis closur capac aid intend definit carri optimum condit term safeti environment protect accord articl decis ecsc payment made spain hunosa anticip authoris commiss excess aid authoris undertak repaid full undertak receiv month notif decis spain amount liabl charg market rate payabl hunosa accord indent articl articl decis ecsc commiss verifi aid authoris current product respond exclus object state articl decis spain notifi commiss june amount aid paid declar correct made amount origin notifi submit annual statement aid paid spain suppli inform verif criteria set relev articl approv aid commiss recognis soften social region impact restructur coal industri econom social situat surround mine affect basi inform provid spain aid measur justifi coal industri compat object decis ecsc proper function common market adopt decis articl state aid grant spain hullera del nort sa hunosa cover oper loss instal undertak mina de lier sa pozo siero total eur esp million eu esp million eur esp million eur esp million aid cover except cost result closur instal total eur esp million incompat common market articl spain adopt measur recov hunosa aid mention articl total eur esp million hunosa dispos unlawfulli recoveri place delai accord procedur laid nation law provid effect implement decis aid recov liabl interest payabl date dispos recipi date recoveri thereof articl spain authoris pai aid hunosa respect aid reduct activ eur esp million articl decis ecsc aid eur esp million cover except technic cost close mine instal result measur reduc activ spanish coal industri articl accord articl ecsc treati spain measur gener ensur fulfil oblig result decis ensur aid authoris purpos intend unspent overestim incorrectli aid item cover decis repaid articl accord articl decis ecsc payment made spain hunosa anticip authoris commiss excess aid authoris undertak repaid full undertak receiv month notif decis spain amount liabl charg market rate payabl hunosa articl spain notifi commiss june latest amount aid paid hunosa respect articl decis address kingdom spain brussel commiss loyola de palacio vice presid oj oj oj oj