commiss decis state aid grant grupo de empresa álvarez notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl ec treati articl council regul ec regard comment procedur juli commiss adopt decis ec state aid grant grupo de empresa álvarez gea hereinaft decis notifi number authoris restructur aid gea spanish manufactur porcelain china vigo galicia posit assess made basi restructur plan provid drastic capac reduct undertak spanish author refrain grant state aid gea includ wholli own subsidiari vidrio automático del nort vanosa recit decis read quot spanish author inform state aid favour compani consid incompat common market odd undertak repercuss aid approv decis quot articl decis state number measur constitut unlaw state aid measur quot compli commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti compat common market articl treati articl eea agreement condit spanish author refrain undertook letter grant aid compani futur fulli implement agre restructur plan quot decis requir spanish author submit seri report commiss enabl check complianc restructur plan spanish author refrain grant aid firm letter date commiss acknowledg receipt report implement restructur plan inform spain quot basi inform figur justif contain report commiss intend reopen file basic line decis compli quot letter quot take account gea continu loss make remind author commit grant addit state aid firm anymor quot report indic fact shown gea vanosa systemat fail pai tax social secur contribut alleg made competitor hereinaft complain spain waiv claim total amount esp billion view fact spain submit report time commiss inform spain septemb doubt decis juli compli letter octob novemb novemb spain request report inform commiss gea receiv fresh aid certifi spain waiv claim esp billion letter date april commiss receiv complaint hereinaft complain letter date request inform spain letter date june complain submit alleg letter receiv june complain submit evid support alleg gea subsidiari vanosa paid social secur contribut januari letter receiv juli spain partial confirm inform complain septemb commiss decid initi proceed articl treati respect aid spain inform letter dai time repli spain repli letter reach commiss decemb public letter offici journal european commun give rise comment parti ii descript ii complaint complain gea relat compani fail pai tax social secur contribut januari complain rais concern price polici appli firm gea relat compani distort competit relev market sell product price low explain presenc state aid complain submit certif issu tesorería gener de la seguridad social show month gea relat compani paid social secur contribut gea complain state public creditor agre waiv claim vanosa creditor agreement ii aid recipi gea manufactur sell tablewar made porcelain earthenwar glass produc bottl gea past largest spanish tablewar manufactur period gea market share amount averag spanish market eu market time gea workforc person annual turnov esp million novemb gea vanosa file bankruptci total liabil esp million latest report spain workforc reduc oper loss amount esp million group locat vigo provinc pontevedra galicia spanish region ship fish car industri domin ow problem industri face experienc econom crisi high unemploy region classifi object zone elig region aid articl june gea wholli own ini spanish public hold time ini decid privatis enterpris gea sole owner vanosa subsidiari set vanosa present glass packag sector vanosa achiev turnov esp million member state incur loss esp million vanosa emploi worker locat assist area gea ii market brisk trade tablewar spain member state inform provid eurostat januari octob spain export tonn tablewar product worth eur million januari septemb import tonn worth eur million spain share intra commun trade tablewar good stand roughli gea eu major produc tablewar present market consider overcapac porcelain industri product consumpt regist continu growth contract recoveri expect happen trade balanc year posit share import increas markedli household china growth export suffici offset increas competit sector contrari strong competit overcapac reinforc due market entrant south east asia eastern european countri czech republ hungari benefit preferenti trade arrang european union spain import porcelain tablewar member state worth eur eur whilst intra commun sale reach eur eur inform commiss dispos confirm sale spain china porcelain hotel restaur industri import product remain broken gt tabl gt gea product direct competit product spanish eu manufactur vanosa part oper market glass packag market share contain glass industri take place packag sector plastic paperboard period affect fall price rapid downward trend price continu result competit packag product pet cardboard can collaps russian market product contain glass industri europ contain glass industri europ gt tabl gt sourc feve fédération européenn du verr emballag intra commun trade contain glass sector eur final result gt tabl gt sourc eurostat combin nomenclatur cpiv asociación nacion de empresa de fabricación automática de envas de vidrio spanish glass contain associ contain glass import spanish market account product franc absorb export import account total consumpt year portug account import iii spain respons initi proceed letter receiv decemb spain answer commiss letter septemb inform set recit aid grant gea vanosa decis gea vanosa systemat fail compli tax social secur oblig period year adopt decis april tax author grant gea vanosa partial waiver accept payment reschedul waiver subject firm compli reschedul term current tax oblig februari year grant waiver tax author decid cancel waiver payment reschedul ground firm quot fail respect payment oblig quot novemb tax author grant vanosa partial waiver accept payment reschedul waiver subject vanosa compli reschedul term current tax oblig februari year grant waiver tax author decid cancel waiver payment reschedul ground compani quot fail respect payment oblig quot social secur tax administr made effort recov unpaid amount order seizur gea vanosa real estat substanti part properti mortgag privat bank iv assess measur iv exist state aid mean articl articl treati establish principl save provid treati aid distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market recit product market gea trade member state competit manufactur gea spain main manufactur sector concern financi support grant state gea vanosa liabl affect trade distort competit market competitor concern state recit vanosa oper market packag suffer structur problem aid vanosa liabl affect posit market relat competitor eu inform submit spain gea vanosa systemat fail pai social secur contribut adopt decis januari gt tabl gt tax inform submit unpaid tax fact commiss made specif request document provid spanish author gea vanosa systemat fail meet tax oblig amount accumul year substanti social secur contribut appar inform gea vanosa year continu trade meet social secur oblig spanish author state letter juli public creditor behaviour compli nation law forc discrimin favour firm state proceed initi seiz number asset state legal mean spanish law appli stop continu systemat payment social secur contribut separ forc collect procedur adopt regard post suspens debt line decis ec octob aid grant spain firm magefesa group successor upheld court justic rule magfesa persist systemat payment social secur contribut unknown substanti amount tax januari januari constitut transfer public resourc gea vanosa transfer competit advantag unlik competitor oblig defrai cost ordinarili case transfer constitut aid articl treati mere fact nation legisl provis reli spanish govern applic enterpris subject court supervis recoveri scheme contract debt social secur treasuri suffici measur spain avoid categoris aid articl treati advantag result persist systemat failur pai tax persist systemat payment social secur contribut januari januari aris spain fail measur spanish law separ forc collect procedur prevent firm continu oper fulfil tax social secur oblig fact treasuri social secur author formal cancel debt detract fact firm oper meet tax social secur oblig period competitor benefit financi advantag court confirm magefesa state aid element aris circumst result measur state context insolv procedur context suspens payment procedur state act public investor conduct compar conduct privat investor lai capit view realis profit short term commiss examin state act dilig privat creditor maximis chanc recov credit court held tubacex good test compar behaviour state behaviour privat creditor upheld court dmt rule public creditor compar hypothet privat creditor posit vi vi debtor onss public creditor seek recov sum ow question aris public creditor allow persist payment tax social secur contribut behav view maximis chanc recov unpaid tax social secur contribut spanish author state suggest case contrari continu oper firm concern result consider increas tax social secur contribut remain unpaid constitut fundament substanti deviat restructur plan decis base persist payment automat reduc compani asset suspens payment period debt result administr asset tax social secur contribut paid take prioriti debt creditor size public claim declar statutori suspens payment novemb gea novemb vanosa continu oper meet tax social secur oblig damag interest treasuri social secur depart inform submit spain gea statutori suspens payment vanosa suspens payment lift juli debt aris persist payment unpaid juli fact larg amount social secur contribut unknown amount tax remain effect unpaid januari januari show gea vanosa continu oper support econom activ unsustain normal market condit state behaviour suggest act privat creditor recov margin amount unpaid tax social contribut circumst bear mind origin restructur plan compli doubt reason creditor accept high exposur commiss inform total amount tax ow treasuri gea vanosa line decis ec adopt magefesa case spanish govern respons suppli inform conclud persist payment tax social secur contribut gea vanosa declar suspens payment constitut aid articl treati iv compat aid commiss note spain invok except provid treati posit case involv state aid commiss consid measur question qualifi exempt articl aid social charact grant individu consum aid make good damag caus natur disast aid compens econom disadvantag caus divis germani except articl appli aid design promot execut import project common european interest promot cultur heritag conserv except provid articl applic case inform possess commiss conclud measur question constitut oper aid gea vanosa aid incompat common market design reliev gea vanosa cost bear normal condit dai dai oper activ nontheless aid grant exception firm region qualifi exempt articl provid justifi term contribut region develop natur level proport handicap seek allevi commiss note vigo locat articl region commiss consid measur question fulfil condit oper aid laid guidelin nation region aid cf paragraph guidelin commiss note aid question degress commiss conclud aid qualifi exempt articl question aris aid aim restor long term viabil undertak difficulti order assess fund grant firm difficulti commiss issu specif guidelin rescu restructur aid applic measur scrutini commiss note aid grant whilst aid recipi implement restructur plan form basi posit decis accord restructur guidelin restructur plan durat short restor long term viabil firm reason time basi realist assumpt futur oper condit restructur aid link viabl restructur plan monitor member state concern addit compensatori measur commiss impos condit oblig consid order ensur aid distort competit extent contrari common interest requir member state occur present case refrain grant type aid recipi firm restructur period letter date commiss acknowledg receipt report implement restructur plan inform spain quot basi inform figur justif contain report commiss intend reopen file basic line decis compli quot state letter ad quot take account gea continu loss make remind author commit grant addit state aid firm anymor quot report indic fact gea vanosa systemat fail pai tax social secur contribut spain suggest point procedur aid mesur adopt approv restructur plan report implement restructur plan exist aid fortiori measur addit action need implement restructur plan correctli state grant partial waiver gea vanosa provid compli reschedul term current tax oblig februari year grant waiver tax author decid cancel waiver payment reschedul ground compani quot fail meet payment oblig quot persist systemat payment tax social secur contribut eventu led cancel measur waiver crucial proper implement restructur plan systemat failur permit state legal mean stop regard measur adopt framework exist restructur plan order prevent firm unfairli assist restructur aid grant firm concern past receiv restructur aid year elaps restructur period end commiss restructur aid except unforese circumst firm respons unforese circumst anticip restructur plan drawn spain suggest case submit evid support claim circumst commiss conclud aid meet condit authoris set commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti view forego commiss consid aid compat common market conclus aid form persist payment tax social secur contribut grupo de empresa alvarez sa vanosa suspens payment novemb januari incompat common market commiss conclud spain unlawfulli implement aid question breach articl treati articl council regul ec stipul unlaw aid commiss deem incompat common market subject decis requir recov beneficiari order restor econom condit firm contend grant incompat aid spanish author step withdraw benefit deriv aid recov beneficiari accord court justic judgment españa commiss recoveri order address spain includ interest aris date aid grant recov aid recov accord procedur laid nation law adopt decis articl aid form persist payment tax social secur contribut grupo de empresa alvarez sa vanosa date payment suspend novemb gea novemb vanosa januari incompat common market articl spain step recov recipi aid refer articl unlawfulli made recipi recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis articl spain inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli herewith articl decis address kingdom spain brussel commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj oj case spain commiss ecr ecr ecr oj case ecr