understand rule procedur govern settlement disput member agre articl coverag applic rule procedur understand appli disput brought pursuant consult disput settlement provis agreement list appendix understand refer understand cover agreement rule procedur understand appli consult settlement disput member right oblig provis agreement establish world trade organ refer understand wto agreement understand isol combin cover agreement rule procedur understand appli subject special addit rule procedur disput settlement contain cover agreement identifi appendix understand extent differ rule procedur understand special addit rule procedur set appendix special addit rule procedur appendix prevail disput involv rule procedur cover agreement conflict special addit rule procedur agreement review parti disput agre rule procedur dai establish panel chairman disput settlement bodi provid paragraph articl refer understand dsb consult parti disput determin rule procedur dai request member chairman guid principl special addit rule procedur rule procedur set understand extent avoid conflict articl administr disput settlement bodi establish administ rule procedur provid cover agreement consult disput settlement provis cover agreement dsb author establish panel adopt panel appel bodi report maintain surveil implement rule recommend author suspens concess oblig cover agreement respect disput aris cover agreement plurilater trade agreement term member refer member parti relev plurilater trade agreement dsb administ disput settlement provis plurilater trade agreement member parti agreement particip decis action dsb respect disput dsb inform relev wto council committe develop disput relat provis respect cover agreement dsb meet carri function time frame provid understand rule procedur understand provid dsb decis consensu articl gener provis member affirm adher principl manag disput heretofor appli articl xxii xxiii gatt rule procedur elabor modifi disput settlement system wto central element provid secur predict multilater trade system member recogn serv preserv right oblig member cover agreement clarifi exist provis agreement accord customari rule interpret public intern law recommend rule dsb add diminish right oblig provid cover agreement prompt settlement situat member consid benefit accru direcli indirectli cover agreement impair measur member essenti effect function wto mainten proper balanc right oblig member recommend rule made dsb aim achiev satisfactori settlement matter accord right oblig understand cover agreement solut matter formal rais consult disput settlement provis cover agreement includ arbitr award consist agreement nullifi impair benefit accru member agreement imped attain object agreement mutual agre solut matter formal rais consult disput settlement provis cover agreement notifi dsb relev council committe member rais point relat thereto bring case member exercis judgement action procedur fruit aim disput settlement mechan secur posit solut disput solut mutual accept parti disput consist cover agreement prefer absenc mutual agre solut object disput settlement mechan secur withdraw measur concern found inconsist provis cover agreement provis compens resort withdraw measur impractic temporari measur pend withdraw measur inconsist cover agreement resort understand member invok disput settlement procedur possibl suspend applic concess oblig cover agreement discriminatori basi vi vi member subject author dsb measur case infring oblig assum cover agreement action consid prima faci constitut case nullif impair mean presumpt breach rule advers impact member parti cover agreement case member complaint brought rebut charg provis understand prejudic right member seek authorit interpret provis cover agreement decis make wto agreement cover agreement plurilater trade agreement understood request concili disput settlement procedur intend consid contenti act disput aris member engag procedur good faith effort resolv disput understood complaint counter complaint regard distinct matter link understand appli respect request consult consult provis cover agreement made date entri forc wto agreement respect disput request consult made gatt predecessor agreement cover agreement date entri forc wto agreement relev disput settlement rule procedur effect immedi prior date entri forc wto agreement continu appli notwithstand paragraph complaint base cover agreement brought develop countri member develop countri member complain parti invok altern provis contain articl understand provis decis april bisd panel consid time frame provid paragraph decis insuffici provid report agreement complain parti time frame extend extent differ rule procedur articl rule procedur decis prevail articl consult member affirm resolv strengthen improv effect consult procedur emploi member member undertak accord sympathet consider afford adequ opportun consult represent made member measur affect oper cover agreement territori request consult made pursuant cover agreement member request made mutual agre repli request dai date receipt enter consult good faith period dai date receipt request view reach mutual satisfactori solut member respond dai date receipt request enter consult period dai period mutual agre date receipt request member request hold consult proce directli request establish panel request consult notifi dsb relev council committe member request consult request consult submit write give reason request includ identif measur issu indic legal basi complaint consult accord provis cover agreement resort action understand member attempt obtain satisfactori adjust matter consult confidenti prejudic right member proceed consult fail settl disput dai date receipt request consult complain parti request establish panel complain parti request panel dai period consult parti jointli consult fail settl disput case urgenc includ concern perish good member enter consult period dai date receipt request consult fail settl disput period dai date receipt request complain parti request establish panel case urgenc includ concern perish good parti disput panel appel bodi make effort acceler proceed greatest extent consult member give special attent problem interest develop countri member member consult member consid substanti trade interest consult held pursuant paragraph articl xxii gatt paragraph articl xxii gat provis cover agreement member notifi consult member dsb dai date circul request consultaton articl desir join consult member join consult provid member request consult address agree claim substanti interest found event inform dsb request join consult accept applic member free request consult paragraph articl xxii paragraph articl xxiii gatt paragraph articl xxii paragraph articl xxiii gat provis cover agreement articl good offic concili mediat good offic concili mediat procedur undertaken voluntarili parti disput agre proceed involv good offic concili mediat posit parti disput proceed confidenti prejudic right parti proceed procedur good offic concili mediat request time parti disput begin time termin time procedur good offic concili mediat termin complain parti proce request establish panel good offic concili mediat enter dai date receipt request consult complain parti period dai date receipt request consult request establish panel complain parti request establish panel dai period parti disput jointli good offic concili mediat process fail settl disput parti disput agre procedur good offic concili mediat continu panel process proce director gener act officio capac offer good offic concili mediat view assist member settl disput articl establish panel complain parti request panel establish latest dsb meet request appear item dsb agenda meet dsb decid consensu establish panel request establish panel made write consult held identifi specif measur issu provid summari legal basi complaint suffici present problem case applic request establish panel standard term refer written request includ propos text special term refer articl term refer panel panel term refer parti disput agre dai establish panel examin light relev provis cover agreement cite parti disput matter refer dsb parti document make find assist dsb make recommend give rule provid agreement panel address relev provis cover agreement agreement cite parti disput establish panel dsb author chairman draw term refer panel consult parti disput subject provis paragraph term refer drawn circul member standard term refer agre member rais point relat thereto dsb articl composit panel panel compos qualifi government government individu includ person serv present case panel serv repres member contract parti gatt repres council committe cover agreement predecessor agreement secretariat taught publish intern trade law polici serv senior trade polici offici member panel member select view ensur independ member suffici divers background wide spectrum experi citizen member govern parti disput parti defin paragraph articl serv panel concern disput parti disput agre assist select panelist secretariat maintain indic list government government individu possess qualif outlin paragraph panelist drawn list includ roster government panelist establish novemb bisd roster indic list establish cover agreement retain name person roster indic list time entri forc wto agreement member period suggest name government government individu inclus indic list provid relev inform knowledg intern trade sector subject matter cover agreement name ad list approv dsb individu list list specif area experi expertis individu sector subject matter cover agreement panel compos panelist parti disput agre dai establish panel panel compos panelist member inform promptli composit panel secretariat propos nomin panel parti disput parti disput oppos nomin compel reason agreement panelist dai date establish panel request parti director gener consult chairman dsb chairman relev council committe determin composit panel appoint panelist director gener consid accord relev special addit rule procedur cover agreement cover agreement issu disput consult parti disput chairman dsb inform member composit panel form dai date chairman receiv request member undertak gener rule permit offici serv panelist panelist serv individu capac govern repres repres organ member give instruct seek influenc individu regard matter panel disput develop countri member develop countri member panel develop countri member request includ panelist develop countri member panelist expens includ travel subsist allow met wto budget accord criteria adopt gener council base recommend committe budget financ administr articl procedur multipl complain member request establish panel relat matter singl panel establish examin complaint take account right member concern singl panel establish examin complaint feasibl singl panel organ examin present find dsb manner right parti disput enjoi separ panel examin complaint impair parti disput request panel submit separ report disput concern written submiss complain made complain complain present complain present view panel panel establish examin complaint relat matter greatest extent person serv panelist separ panel timet panel process disput harmon articl parti interest parti disput member cover agreement issu disput fulli account panel process member substanti interest manner panel notifi interest dsb refer understand parti opportun heard panel make written submiss panel submiss parti disput reflect panel report parti receiv submiss parti disput meet panel parti consid measur subject panel proceed nullifi impair benefit accru cover agreement member recours normal disput settlement procedur understand disput refer origin panel articl function panel function panel assist dsb discharg respons understand cover agreement panel make object assess matter includ object assess fact case applic conform relev cover agreement make find assist dsb make recommend give rule provid cover agreement panel consult regularli parti disput give adequ opportun develop mutual satisfactori solut articl panel procedur panel follow work procedur appendix panel decid consult parti disput panel procedur provid suffici flexibl ensur highli qualiti panel report unduli delai panel process consult parti disput panelist practic week composit term refer panel agre fix timet panel process take account provis paragraph articl relev determin timet panel process panel provid suffici time parti disput prepar submiss panel set precis deadlin written submiss parti parti respect deadlin parti disput deposit written submiss secretariat transmiss panel parti parti disput complain parti submit submiss advanc respond parti submiss panel decid fix timet refer paragraph consult parti disput parti submit submiss simultan sequenti arrang deposit submiss panel establish firm time period receipt respond parti submiss subsequ written submiss submit simultan parti disput fail develop mutual satisfactori solut panel submit find form written report dsb case report panel set find fact applic relev provis basic rational find recommend make settlement manner parti disput found report panel confin descript case report solut reach order make procedur effici period panel conduct examin date composit term refer panel agre date final report issu parti disput gener rule exce month case urgenc includ relat perish good panel aim issu report parti disput month panel consid issu report month month case urgenc inform dsb write reason delai estim period issu report case period establish panel circul report member exce month context consult involv measur develop countri member parti agre extend period establish paragraph articl relev period elaps consult parti agre consult conclud chairman dsb decid consult parti extend relev period long addit examin complaint develop countri member panel accord suffici time develop countri member prepar present argument provis paragraph articl paragraph articl affect action pursuant paragraph parti develop countri member panel report explicitli form account relev provis differenti favour treatment develop countri member form part cover agreement rais develop countri member disput settlement procedur panel suspend work time request complain parti period exce month event suspens time frame set paragraph articl paragraph articl paragraph articl extend amount time work suspend work panel suspend month author establish panel laps articl seek inform panel seek inform technic advic individu bodi deem panel seek inform advic individu bodi jurisdict member inform author member member respond promptli fulli request panel inform panel consid confidenti inform provid reveal formal author individu bodi author member provid inform panel seek inform relev sourc consult expert obtain opinion aspect matter respect factual issu scientif technic matter rais parti disput panel request advisori report write expert review group rule establish group procedur set appendix articl confidenti panel deliber confidenti report panel draft presenc parti disput light inform provid statement made opinion express panel report individu panelist anonym articl interim review stage consider rebutt submiss oral argument panel issu descript factual argument section draft report parti disput period time set panel parti submit comment write expir set period time receipt comment parti disput panel issu interim report parti includ descript section panel find conclus period time set panel parti submit written request panel review precis aspect interim report prior circul final report member request parti panel hold meet parti issu identifi written comment comment receiv parti comment period interim report consid final panel report circul promptli member find final panel report includ discuss argument made interim review stage interim review stage conduct time period set paragraph articl articl adopt panel report order provid suffici time member panel report report consid adopt dsb dai date circul member member object panel report give written reason explain object circul dai prior dsb meet panel report consid parti disput particip fulli consider panel report dsb view fulli record dai date circul panel report member report adopt dsb meet parti disput formal notifi dsb decis appeal dsb decid consensu adopt report parti notifi decis appeal report panel consid adopt dsb complet appeal adopt procedur prejudic member express view panel report articl appel review stand appel bodi stand appel bodi establish dsb appel bodi hear appeal panel case compos person serv case person serv appel bodi serv rotat rotat determin work procedur appel bodi dsb appoint person serv appel bodi year term person reappoint term person appoint immedi entri forc wto agreement expir end year determin lot vacanc fill aris person appoint replac person term offic expir hold offic remaind predecessor term appel bodi compris person recogn author demonstr expertis law intern trade subject matter cover agreement gener unaffili govern appel bodi membership broadli repres membership wto person serv appel bodi time short notic stai abreast disput settlement activ relev activ wto particip consider disput creat direct indirect conflict interest parti disput parti appeal panel report parti notifi dsb substanti interest matter pursuant paragraph articl make written submiss opportun heard appel bodi gener rule proceed exce dai date parti disput formal notifi decis appeal date appel bodi circul report fix timet appel bodi account provis paragraph articl relev appel bodi consid provid report dai inform dsb write reason delai estim period submit report case proceed exce dai appeal limit issu law cover panel report legal interpret develop panel appel bodi provid administr legal support requir expens person serv appel bodi includ travel subsist allow met wto budget accord criteria adopt gener council base recommend committe budget financ administr procedur appel review work procedur drawn appel bodi consult chairman dsb director gener commun member inform proceed appel bodi confidenti report appel bodi draft presenc parti disput light inform provid statement made opinion express appel bodi report individu serv appel bodi anonym appel bodi address issu rais accord paragraph appel proceed appel bodi uphold modifi revers legal find conclus panel adopt appel bodi report appel bodi report adopt dsb uncondition accept parti disput dsb decid consensu adopt appel bodi report dai circul member adopt procedur prejudic member express view appel bodi report articl commun panel appel bodi part commun panel appel bodi matter consider panel appel bodi written submiss panel appel bodi treat confidenti made parti disput understand preclud parti disput disclos statement posit public member treat confidenti inform submit member panel appel bodi member design confidenti parti disput request member provid confidenti summari inform contain written submiss disclos public articl panel appel bodi recommend panel appel bodi conclud measur inconsist cover agreement recommend member concern bring measur conform agreement addit recommend panel appel bodi suggest wai member concern implement recommend accord paragraph articl find recommend panel appel bodi add diminish right oblig provid cover agreement articl time frame dsb decis agre parti disput period date establish panel dsb date dsb consid panel appel report adopt gener rule exce month panel report appeal month report appeal panel appel bodi act pursuant paragraph articl paragraph articl extend time provid report addit time ad period articl surveil implement recommend rule prompt complianc recommend rule dsb essenti order ensur effect resolut disput benefit member attent paid matter affect interest develop countri member respect measur subject disput settlement dsb meet held dai date adopt panel appel bodi report member concern inform dsb intent respect implement recommend rule dsb impractic compli immedi recommend rule member concern reason period time reason period time period time propos member concern provid period approv dsb absenc approv period time mutual agre parti disput dai date adopt recommend rule absenc agreement period time determin bind arbitr dai date adopt recommend rule arbitr guidelin arbitr reason period time implement panel appel bodi recommend exce month date adopt panel appel bodi report time shorter longer depend circumst panel appel bodi extend pursuant paragraph articl paragraph articl time provid report period date establish panel dsb date determin reason period time exce month parti disput agre panel appel bodi act extend time provid report addit time ad month period provid parti disput agre except circumst total time exce month disagr exist consist cover agreement measur compli recommend rule disput decid recours disput settlement procedur includ resort origin panel panel circul report dai date referr matter panel consid provid report time frame inform dsb write reason delai estim period submit report dsb surveil implement adopt recommend rule issu implement recommend rule rais dsb member time adopt dsb decid issu implement recommend rule agenda dsb meet month date establish reason period time pursuant paragraph remain dsb agenda issu resolv dai prior dsb meet member concern provid dsb statu report write progress implement recommend rule matter rais develop countri member dsb action circumst case brought develop countri member action dsb account trade coverag measur complain impact economi develop countri member concern articl compens suspens concess compens suspens concess oblig temporari measur event recommend rule implement reason period time compens suspens concess oblig prefer full implement recommend bring measur conform cover agreement compens voluntari grant consist cover agreement member concern fail bring measur found inconsist cover agreement complianc therewith compli recommend rule reason period time determin pursuant paragraph articl member request expiri reason period time enter negoti parti invok disput settlement procedur view develop mutual accept compens satisfactori compens agre dai date expiri reason period time parti invok disput settlement procedur request author dsb suspend applic member concern concess oblig cover agreement concess oblig suspend complain parti appli principl procedur gener principl complain parti seek suspend concess oblig respect sector panel appel bodi found violat nullif impair parti consid practic effect suspend concess oblig respect sector seek suspend concess oblig sector agreement parti consid practic effect suspend concess oblig respect sector agreement circumst seek suspend concess oblig cover agreement appli principl parti account trade sector agreement panel appel bodi found violat nullif impair import trade parti ii broader econom element relat nullif impair broader econom consequ suspens concess oblig parti decid request author suspend concess oblig pursuant subparagraph state reason therefor request time request forward dsb forward relev council case request pursuant subparagraph relev sectori bodi purpos paragraph sector mean respect good good ii respect servic princip sector identifi current servic sector classif list identifi sector iii respect trade relat intellectu properti right categori intellectu properti right cover section section section section section section section part ii oblig part iii part iv agreement trip purpos paragraph agreement mean respect good agreement list annex wto agreement plurilater trade agreement relev parti disput parti agreement ii respect servic gat iii respect intellectu properti right agreement trip level suspens concess oblig author dsb equival level nullif impair dsb author suspens concess oblig cover agreement prohibit suspens situat paragraph occur dsb request grant author suspend concess oblig dai expiri reason period time dsb decid consensu reject request member concern object level suspens propos claim principl procedur set paragraph complain parti request author suspend concess oblig pursuant paragraph matter refer arbitr arbitr carri origin panel member arbitr appoint director gener complet dai date expiri reason period time concess oblig suspend arbitr arbitr act pursuant paragraph examin natur concess oblig suspend determin level suspens equival level nullif impair arbitr determin propos suspens concess oblig allow cover agreement matter refer arbitr includ claim principl procedur set paragraph arbitr examin claim event arbitr determin principl procedur complain parti appli consist paragraph parti accept arbitr decis final parti concern seek arbitr dsb inform promptli decis arbitr request grant author suspend concess oblig request consist decis arbitr dsb decid consensu reject request suspens concess oblig temporari appli time measur found inconsist cover agreement remov member implement recommend rule solut nullif impair benefit mutual satisfactori solut reach accord paragraph articl dsb continu surveil implement adopt recommend rule includ case compens provid concess oblig suspend recommend bring measur conform cover agreement implement disput settlement provis cover agreement invok respect measur affect observ region local govern author territori member dsb rule provis cover agreement observ respons member reason measur ensur observ provis cover agreement understand relat compens suspens concess oblig appli case secur observ articl strengthen multilater system member seek redress violat oblig nullif impair benefit cover agreement impedi attain object cover agreement recours abid rule procedur understand case member make determin effect violat occur benefit nullifi impair attain object cover agreement imped recours disput settlement accord rule procedur understand make determin consist find contain panel appel bodi report adopt dsb arbitr award render understand follow procedur set articl determin reason period time member concern implement recommend rule follow procedur set articl determin level suspens concess oblig obtain dsb author accord procedur suspend concess oblig cover agreement respons failur member concern implement recommend rule reason period time articl special procedur involv develop countri member stage determin disput disput settlement procedur involv develop countri member consider special situat develop countri member regard member exercis due restraint rais matter procedur involv develop countri member nullif impair found result measur develop countri member complain parti exercis due restraint compens seek author suspend applic concess oblig pursuant procedur disput settlement case involv develop countri member satisfactori solut found consult director gener chairman dsb request develop countri member offer good offic concili mediat view assist parti settl disput request panel made director gener chairman dsb provid assist consult sourc deem articl arbitr expediti arbitr wto altern mean disput settlement facilit solut disput concern issu defin parti provid understand resort arbitr subject mutual agreement parti agre procedur agreement resort arbitr notifi member suffici advanc actual commenc arbitr process member parti arbitr proceed agreement parti agre recours arbitr parti proceed agre abid arbitr award arbitr award notifi dsb council committe relev agreement member rais point relat thereto articl understand appli mutati mutandi arbitr award articl violat complaint type paragraph articl xxiii gatt provis paragraph articl xxiii gatt applic cover agreement panel appel bodi make rule recommend parti disput consid benefit accru directli indirectli relev cover agreement nullifi impair attain object agreement imped result applic member measur conflict provis agreement extent parti consid panel appel bodi determin case concern measur conflict provis cover agreement provis paragraph articl xxiii gatt applic procedur understand appli subject complain parti present detail justif support complaint relat measur conflict relev cover agreement measur found nullifi impair benefit imped attain object relev cover agreement violat thereof oblig withdraw measur case panel appel bodi recommend member concern make mutual satisfactori adjust notwithstand provis articl arbitr provid paragraph articl request parti includ determin level benefit nullifi impair suggest wai mean reach mutual satisfactori adjust suggest bind parti disput notwithstand provis paragraph articl compens part mutual satisfactori adjust final settlement disput complaint type paragraph articl xxiii gatt provis paragraph articl xxiii gatt applic cover agreement panel make rule recommend parti consid benefit accru directli indirectli relev cover agreement nullifi impair attain object agreement imped result exist situat provis paragraph articl xxiii gatt applic extent parti consid panel determin matter cover paragraph procedur understand appli includ point proceed panel report circul member disput settlement rule procedur contain decis april bisd appli consider adopt surveil implement recommend rule appli complain parti present detail justif support argument made respect issu cover paragraph case involv matter cover paragraph panel find case involv disput settlement matter cover paragraph panel circul report dsb address matter separ report matter fall paragraph articl respons secretariat secretariat respons assist panel legal histor procedur aspect matter dealt provid secretari technic support secretariat assist member respect disput settlement request provid addit legal advic assist respect disput settlement develop countri member end secretariat make qualifi legal expert wto technic cooper servic develop countri member request expert assist develop countri member manner ensur continu imparti secretariat secretariat conduct special train cours interest member disput settlement procedur practic enabl member expert inform regard appendix agreement cover understand agreement establish world trade organ multilater trade agreement annex multilater agreement trade good annex gener agreement trade servic annex agreement trade relat aspect intellectu properti right annex understand rule procedur govern settlement disput plurilater trade agreement annex agreement trade civil aircraft agreement govern procur intern dairi agreement intern bovin meat agreement applic understand plurilater trade agreement subject adopt decis parti agreement set term applic understand individu agreement includ special addit rule procedur inclus appendix notifi dsb appendix gt tabl gt appendix work procedur proceed panel follow relev provis understand addit work procedur appli panel meet close session parti disput interest parti present meet invit panel deliber panel document submit confidenti understand preclud parti disput disclos statement posit public member treat confidenti inform submit member panel member design confidenti parti disput submit confidenti version written submiss panel request member provid confidenti summari inform contain submiss disclos public substant meet panel parti parti disput transmit panel written submiss present fact case argument substant meet parti panel parti brought complaint present case subsequ meet parti complaint brought ask present point view parti notifi interest disput dsb invit write present view session substant meet panel set purpos parti present entireti session formal rebutt made substant meet panel parti complain floor complain parti parti submit prior meet written rebutt panel panel time put question parti explan meet parti write parti disput parti invit present view accord articl make panel written version oral statement interest full transpar present rebutt statement refer paragraph made presenc parti parti written submiss includ comment descript part report respons question put panel made parti parti addit procedur specif panel propos timet panel work receipt written submiss parti complain parti week parti complain week date time place substant meet parti parti session week receipt written rebutt parti week date time place substant meet parti week issuanc descript part report parti week receipt comment parti descript part report week issuanc interim report includ find conclus parti week deadlin parti request review part report week period review panel includ addit meet parti week issuanc final report parti disput week circul final report member week calendar chang light unforeseen develop addit meet parti schedul requir appendix expert review group rule procedur appli expert review group establish accord provis paragraph articl expert review group panel author term refer detail work procedur decid panel report panel particip expert review group restrict person profession stand experi field question citizen parti disput serv expert review group joint agreement parti disput except circumst panel consid special scientif expertis fulfil govern offici parti disput serv expert review group member expert review group serv individu capac govern repres repres organ govern organ give instruct regard matter expert review group expert review group consult seek inform technic advic sourc deem expert review group seek inform advic sourc jurisdict member inform govern member member respond promptli fulli request expert review group inform expert review group consid parti disput access relev inform provid expert review group confidenti natur confidenti inform provid expert review group releas formal author govern organ person provid inform inform request expert review group releas inform expert review group author confidenti summari inform provid govern organ person suppli inform expert review group submit draft report parti disput view obtain comment take account final report issu parti disput submit panel final report expert review group advisori dsb deem decid consensu matter submit consider member present meet dsb decis formal object propos decis paragraph appli disput panel report adopt fulli implement provis cover agreement measur region local govern author territori member provis provis paragraph provis cover agreement prevail consult provis cover agreement list hereund agreement agricultur articl agreement applic sanitari phytosanitari measur paragraph articl agreement textil cloth paragraph articl agreement technic barrier trade paragraph articl agreement trade relat invest measur articl agreement implement articl vi gatt paragraph articl agreement implement articl vii gatt paragraph articl agreement preship inspect articl agreement rule origin articl agreement import licens procedur articl agreement subsidi countervail measur articl agreement safeguard articl agreement trade relat aspect intellectu properti right articl consult provis plurilater trade agreement determin compet bodi agreement notifi dsb complain parti request meet dsb conven purpos dai request provid dai advanc notic meet case custom union common market parti disput provis appli citizen member countri custom union common market meet dsb schedul period time enabl requir paragraph articl met meet dsb held purpos meet dsb schedul period meet dsb held purpos member concern parti disput panel appel bodi recommend direct respect recommend case involv violat gatt cover agreement articl parti agre arbitr ten dai refer matter arbitr arbitr appoint director gener ten dai consult parti express arbitr interpret refer individu group list document mtn gn identifi eleven sector express arbitr interpret refer individu group express arbitr interpret refer individu group member origin panel serv capac arbitr provis cover agreement measur region local govern author territori member provis provis paragraph provis cover agreement prevail