commiss decis juli aid grant itali sangal manfredonia vetro notifi document number italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof accord abovement articl interest parti notic submit comment regard comment procedur letter februari regist incom mail februari commiss receiv complaint competitor aid italian author allegedli intend grant sangal vetro spa build flat glass factori manfredonia southern itali complain aid form land sale market price provis infrastructur free charg grant invest aid intens higher allow region aid scheme applic grant employ subsidi tax concess reduct social secur contribut complaint aid measur receiv letter septemb flat glass produc letter februari april juli octob commiss ask italian author detail inform measur question italian author repli letter view lack suffici detail inform italian author doubt compat aid measur common market commiss decid decemb initi procedur laid articl treati requir italian govern answer question italian govern inform letter januari sg publish offici journal european commun invit interest parti submit comment aid question commiss receiv comment sangal vetro spa recipi sangal manfredonia vetro srl enisud compani intend move industri site sangal vetro manfredonia forward italian govern observ italian govern repli letter june ii descript aid ii recipi sangal manfredonia vetro srl sangal set januari registr offic foggia apulia itali control sangal vetro spa sangal spa sangal group oper flat glass process industri obtain raw materi major flat glass produc establish countri european econom area sangal medium size firm criteria set commiss recommend definit small medium size enterpris start oper employe asset itl million sangal vetro group medium size firm criteria refer recit emploi person consolid turnov itl billion decemb ii measur issu articl procedur initi respect measur sale land agricoltura spa sangal price appar consist market price commiss specif detail inform ident sell compani price charg current market price subsidi region nation author grant sangal compani construct infrastructur invest area commiss suffici data identifi natur infrastructur check built sole sangal project invest aid build flat glass factori allegedli grant italian govern sangal area concern assist region commiss note italian author fail state exact legal basi measur question forecast market growth complain absorb capac increas grant itl million employe enisud grant sangal commiss unabl satisfi state aid aid form tax concess reduct social secur contribut commiss unabl establish cover approv scheme iii repli italian author initi articl procedur decemb agricoltura spa compani privat law agricoltura sold total land industri site mattinata mote sant angelo hereinaft manfredonia italian author state price paid sangal higher price determin expert report carri independ compani plot adjac plot question accord point ii commiss commun state aid element sale land build public author notifi sale compris state aid mean treati price paid higher paid time investor adjac plot infrastructur provid place invest firm locat manfredonia industri site consist suppli drink water instal centralis water purifi treatment plant network road share park area cost infrastructur exclus sangal site develop connect electr grid born sole sangal italian author state consorzio lo sviluppo industrial asi consorzio manag industri plot infrastructur work determin charg firm site pai common infrastructur italian author state public busi enterpris consorzio oblig appli tariff cover cost tariff set list price adopt intern procedur appli firm manfredonia regard situat flat glass market italian author provid data indic italian commun market flat glass suffer excess capac contrari grow year ow vari flat type glass demonstr fact produc flat glass set joint subsidiari european countri italian author main reason complain appli commiss factori manfredonia built sangal group longer acquir raw materi complain italian author forward list term condit appli competitor sangal group invest aid grant total itl billion respect elig discount cost itl billion italian author argu correspond intens net grant equival gross grant equival permit object invest region calcul accord relev ministeri order italian author state manfredonia sviluppo incorpor partnership establish foggia apulia submit respons ministri applic sangal admiss quot manfredonia area contract quot instrument framework region scheme provid law decemb sangal project approv juli scheme law quot area contract quot system approv commiss decis june letter sg decemb letter sg enisud spa enisud sangal sign agreement provid recruit maximum worker emploi eni compani hive eni worker enisud undertook pai itl million eur agreement notifi commiss annual report enisud activ sangal emploi eni worker take satisfi job requir italian author point commiss acknowledg letter enisud activ similar form subject decis eec french public industri group caught articl italian author state gener reduct social secur contribut grant sangal author compli pagliarini van miert agreement march extend decis march letter sg april iii comment interest parti comment itali commiss comment associazion degli industriali di capitanata associ foggia apulia sangal spa sangal enisud associ emphasis sangal project part manfredonia area contract consider import apulia open plant job direct indirect small medium size firm encourag move region fact sangal produc glass raw materi process strengthen competit common market oligopolist sector sangal describ situat flat glass market europ itali estim product exclud output tonn demand tonn sangal justifi invest produc flat glass depend major european produc detail futur sale strategi respons point rais procedur italian author enisud confirm statement italian author mandatori natur agreement sangal enisud fact eni worker enisud point abovement letter dg iv industri restructur eni group state aid enisud argu confirm assess enisud annual report carri commiss enisud specifi effort promot manfredonia area contract assist firm total itl billion job plan eni worker emploi compani manfredonia repli comment parti part procedur itali state agre observ submit iv assess aid articl treati articl eea agreement provid aid distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good affect trade member state incompat common market procedur articl treati enabl commiss determin measur question compris state aid mean articl treati articl eea agreement initi invest aid compli approv scheme hand tax concess reduct social secur contribut grant recipi compat common market cover approv scheme iv sale land agricoltura public enterpris govern privat law decemb sold sangal land locat oper area price itl agricoltura bear cost clear site make good damag caus pollut activ respons work limit time month sale specif proport cost commiss take view price paid sangal correspond market price italian author provid report date carri independ consult firm report price squar metr time itl italian author submit contract sale parcel land area smaller acquir sangal contract recent conclud agricoltura firm itl squar metr condit sangal agricoltura bear cost clearanc clean time limit sell price higher sangal case firm purchas adjac parcel plot larger cost clear turn higher commiss conclud accord point ii commiss commun state aid element sale land build public author sale compris state aid place price establish independ valuer market time sale iv develop infrastructur invest area infrastructur provid consorzio benefit firm locat area inform provid italian author compris suppli purif treatment water construct road link common park area industri site utilis infrastructur italian author state letter june charg cover cost infrastructur provid stipul agreement consorzio sangal charg infrastructur fix intern consorzio rule appli equal firm concern cost infrastructur specif benefit sangal electr suppli connect develop site born sole firm commiss conclud forego infrastructur share firm locat manfredonia industri area made free charg charg calcul cover cost incur charg appli object firm concern cost infrastructur exclus firm includ sangal born sole firm commiss conclud select assist recipi compani construct infrastructur question caught articl treati iv flat glass industri sangal feasibl studi connect initi invest aid italian author forward feasibl studi sangal project sangal produc gross tonn tonn net flat glass vari thick mm mm size output approxim tonn sangal group tonn industri domest market export greec eastern europ state notic initi procedur relev market market flat glass produc float process develop process make produc glass requir polish smooth cut sold directli process industri major produc flat glass produc manufactur pane construct insul reinforc commun flat glass market share small number larg manufactur strong expans eastern europ commun market remain largest outlet major commun flat glass manufactur year crisi upturn demand invest place eastern europ south america addit sourc wit extens intern restructur exercis industri involv loss job order prospect recoveri poor market suffer excess capac commiss note trend intern restructur reloc countri eastern europ due panorama eu industri fact quot glass industri period reorganis firm respond huge variat worldwid labour market make invest lower cost countri benefit cheaper factor product quot prove capac commun flat glass market greater requir studi carri independ organis histor trend glass market fact worldwid growth demand year year figur europ european union specif flat glass sector demand forecast repres averag growth demand period firm predict growth demand period year annual report larg compani refer quot current insuffici capac quot glaverbel state period quot show chang base actual structur quot saint gobain quot total consumpt flat glass eu countri grow rate higher averag gdp quot quot glass consumpt experi similar growth quot optimist view market trend confirm fact state commiss decis august acquisit ppt industri glaverbel quot year guardian built float glass plant germani exist announc project float glass plant itali spain greec unit kingdom exist float glass produc potenti entrant sangal quot recent confirm report forward commiss european flat glass produc group state saint gobain open factori end unit kingdom glaverbel pilkington open spain mid interpan franc sangal itali end product capac tonn dai gross tonn year conclus european flat glass industri crisi explain invest plan major compani sector italian flat glass market strong increas demand ow open fiat plan melfi apulia centralis alfa romeo product napl process glass sector sangal spa oper commiss conclud view market share held sangal medium size firm aid distort competit market basi forego commiss conclud sangal project viabl manfredonia plant output sangal group consumpt flat glass suppli contract conclud sangal group italian author forward commiss show condit price appli group supplier saint gobain pilkington glaverbel competit sangal unabl renegoti factori manfredonia group longer depend supplier achiev higher profit futur output intend market equal demand european level market southern itali experienc strong growth manfredonia close greec balkan region demand expect surg assum product domest european market effect correspond real demand iv region aid basi inform suppli italian author procedur commiss conclud itali grant repay aid amount gross initi invest cost sangal manfredonia compli law grand itl billion paid equal annual instal respect elig cost itl billion correspond maximum intens allow law nge gge medium size firm recipi section ii invest area region qualifi aid articl aid compli instrument implement law area contract area contract intend stimul employ initi creat job industri agricultur servic sector tourism accord region aid scheme public author grant aid invest viabl technic econom financi standpoint benefit account favour term credit institut region aid question reach threshold provid multisector framework region aid larg invest project subject oblig notifi commiss provid framework itali formal grant sangal aid question juli prior entri forc framework basi inform recit abovement feasibl studi present sangal italian author commiss conclud sangal project viabl financ prospect condit applic sangal contribut project amount invest adequ lastli job creation commiss note project creat direct job manag worker indirect job sangal obtain suppli raw materi chiefli glass make sand servic requir land sea transport situ commiss conclud present case region aid grant italian author sangal compli term intens scheme law approv commiss iv employ subsidi grant enisud letter commiss state appli analog decis eec convers activ enisud constitut state aid mean articl treati request letter italian author undertaken send report convers activ enisud year order verifi state aid italian author date regularli present report commiss express concern convers measur enisud state aid enisud belong eni group process privatis decemb treasuri hold minor sharehold eni board member appoint state convers activ supervisori bodi link public author convers activ essenti consist find employ group employe job cover wage guarante fund mobil scheme promot industri initi area eni close plant cost measur born group account fund hous financ commiss conclud grant itl million worker firm emploi eni worker caught articl treati resourc state resourc eni group conduct worker employ polici independ measur question regard state aid initi procedur commiss express doubt fact abovement annual report period octob refer grant sangal italian author eni recipi confirm measur includ annual report recruit sangal place doubt express commiss resolv iv gener reduct statutori contribut repli initi proceed italian author state gener reduct statutori contribut sgravi contributivi di tipo general grant sangal compli pagliarini van miert agreement march extend letter april sg commiss note decis march commun itali letter april refer recit renew measur contain decis ec march arrang reduc social secur contribut paid firm mezzogiorno assign state contribut earlier decis provid dismantl system reduct social secur contribut mezzogiorno decemb addit differenti relat centr north region proport contribut state fiscalizzazion measur phase januari januari januari recent decis march relat part reduct social secur contribut commiss decid aid employ aid connect invest exempt year social secur contribut firm creat job specif region itali compat common market basi guidelin aid employ sangal compani due start oper abovement decis longer applic job creat link invest instanc reduct tax social secur contribut cover scheme approv commiss provid scheme approv commiss reduct constitut individu aid measur compat common market specif assess light characterist aid question compat common market qualifi exempt articl aid social charact grant individu consum intend make good damag caus natur disast except occurr qualifi exempt articl exempt articl aid intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb economi member state facilit develop econom activ promot cultur heritag conserv recipi locat region qualifi assist articl commiss determin compat aid exempt point guidelin aid employ refer recit specifi guidelin cover aid link invest quot invest aid calcul job creat includ premium job creation constitut employ aid directli intend creat maintain job view purpos perman effect industri structur aid treat invest aid subject normal assess criteria quot commiss conclud job creat connect invest account region aid scheme law result sangal receiv addit aid job creat aid top invest aid form subject procedur total exce maximum level assist region question intens invest aid provid law correspond maximum intens assist region question combin aid form reduct tax social secur contribut result maximum level exceed incompat common market reason commiss conclud aid form reduct tax social secur contribut grant sangal constitut incompat aid qualifi relev exempt conclus basi forego commiss consid sale land agricoltura sangal compris state aid sale price consist calcul independ expert price recent paid firm similar transact construct infrastructur invest area regard state aid infrastructur firm locat industri site charg base cost incur appli object firm cost infrastructur sole firm born sole firm invest aid itl billion compli condit intens provid law approv commiss aid compat common market contribut itl million worker enisud grant sangal compris state aid mean articl treati involv public resourc public author involv choic recipi hand tax relief social secur reduct italian author refer letter constitut aid cover decis ec benefit aid combin aid law aid link initi invest benefit firm region provid articl intens aid correspond maximum assist region question combin aid form tax concess social secur reduct result region ceil approv commiss exceed render aid question incompat italian author authoris grant aid sangal basi inform suppli italian author commiss conclud state aid grant firm question advanc commiss final decis adopt decis articl sale land agricoltura spa sangal manfredonia vetro srl construct common infrastructur invest area contribut grant enisud spa sangal manfredonia vetro srl employe eni group recruit sangal manfredonia vetro fall scope articl treati articl aid grant itali sangal manfredonia vetro srl total itl billion compli law decemb establish region aid scheme approv commiss articl itali grant tax concess reduct social secur contribut sangal manfredonia vetro srl measur part scheme approv commiss constitut aid incompat common market articl itali inform commiss month date notif decis step compli herewith articl decis address italian republ brussel juli commiss karel van miert member commiss oj footnot oj oj circolar ministero dell industria novemb amend circolar februari manfredonia contract sign march examin project admiss complet juli project accept includ sangal vetro basi decis state aid notifi itali letter sg june commiss authoris scheme provid law decis decemb state aid notifi itali letter februari commiss approv instrument implement law includ area contract instrument oj oj flat glass produc float process magazin industri miner decemb flat glass market europ share firm pilkington glaverbel saint gobain guardian ppg sisecam eurogla case pilkington plc saint gobain glaverbel websit http www pilkington www saint gobain www glaverbel pilkington annual report websit http www pilkington financ annual report group perform www glaverbel dg iii panorama eu industri vol pp studi publish frost amp sullivan market research statement luc willam ceo glaverbel gener sharehold meet sourc http www glaverbel http www saint gobain glaverbel annual report quot manag report quot section head quot european glass consumpt quot sourc http www glaverbel point decis august declar concentr compat common market case iv glaverbel ppg oj estim assici flat glass produc forecast demand eu million tonn million tonn million tonn elig cost break studi itl billion land itl billion plant itl billion equip itl billion decis state aid list intens allow articl region oj footnot footnot oj footnot inter alia annual report commiss connect supervis convers activ document regist incom mail novemb eni share quot stock exchang http www eni eni estim contain report total convers cost itl billion activ continu end oj oj decis system abruzzi oj grant aid subject condit worker recruit unemploi recruit firm dismiss staff month recruit involv creation job measur number staff emploi firm month preced recruit contract open end suffici length guarante job stabil employ guarante month payment aid event combin aid total amount aid exce higher ceil scheme concern