commiss decis april relat proceed pursuant articl ec treati iv sticht certificati kraanverhuurbedrijf federati van nederlands kraanverhuurbedrijven dutch text authent ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard council regul februari regul implement articl treati amend act access spain portugl articl thereof regard complaint submit januari van marwijk applic interim measur regard statut rule notifi januari sticht certificati kraanverhuurbedrijf februari federati van nederlands kraanverhuurbedrijven undertak concern pursuant articl regul opportun heard matter commiss object fact complaint januari complaint applic interim measur submit van marwijk firm alleg federati van nederlands kraanverhuurbedrijven hereinaft refer fnk sticht certificati kraanverhuurbedrijf hereinaft refer sck infring articl treati exclud member firm mobil crane hire trade impos fix price rate statut rule notifi agreement sck statut rule certif crane hire trade hereinaft refer rule notifi commiss januari fnk statut intern rule similarli notifi februari case applic made neg clearanc altern exempt pursuant articl central notifi agreement call inhuurverbod ban hire extra crane affili firm laid indent articl rule state addit oblig rule certif holder requir crane provid valid certif plate parti complain firm hire mobil crane establish netherland establish belgium member fnk particip sck fnk associ firm hire mobil crane establish march regist offic culemborg decemb member sck regist offic address culemborg establish decemb statut object provid guarante system supervis sion registr firm crane hire busi qualiti compet affili firm staff qualiti machineri decemb firm affili firm member fnk pre oper phase sck receiv subsidi netherland author market relev crane emploi construct petrochem transport industri netherland crane hire busi hire extra crane crane hirer occur larg scale fnk figur crane hire firm netherland total turnov ecu million fnk member account total transport difficulti fnk crane oper radiu km limit market netherland firm member state area belgian german border govern supervis law condit workplac employ ensur tool equip appropri reliabl construct requir equip inspect period safeti decre base law condit workplac rule stipul greater detail mention made decre safeti factori work site decre safeti type workplac provis laid relat safe construct safe crane lift equip provis spelt detail type crane type lift equip ministeri regul due regard requir laid council direct eec relat machineri decre safeti factori work site ministri social affair design keboma bodi offici respons carri inspect crane lift equip shortcom found keboma inform labour inspector structur fnk sck sck recogn certif council certif institut mean thing certif council view meet requir independ fact practic link fnk sck close inconceiv action full knowledg agreement statut sck show half manag committe appoint fnk decis simpl major vote decis approv fnk member manag committe drawn crane hire industri articl includ repres larg firm award contract crane hire firm larg scale regular basi mean sck particip obtain largest contract appar intern oper rule nederlands spoorwegen dutch railwai crane hire firm certifi sck manag committe assist advisori bodi compos member appoint manag committe consult fnk nomin candid advisori bodi consist member includ drawn fnk affili organ associ undertak place contract crane hire firm task advisori bodi includ advis sck manag committe natur content certif system establish requir method inspect underli certif system advic advisori bodi bind natur articl rule advisori bodi fnk claim sck set initi firm award contract impetu fnk firm award contract scarc organ organ address telephon number secretariat statut rule organ notifi repres form behaviour fnk sck statut fnk object promot interest crane hire busi gener member encourag contact cooper broadest sens member object manner achiev set statut intern rule firm establish netherland member fnk statut includ provis requir fnk member need addit crane hire member quot reason hire price provis annul fnk interlocutori judgment utrecht district court februari fnk publish price list independ survei industri found set price rate client member hire extra crane statut sck object promot maintain qualiti crane hire firm object attain establish code conduct certif system monitor arrang ensur complianc code conduct certif involv monitor number aspect crane hire firm complianc legal requir tax social secur payment evid insur cover creditworthi liquid skill condit employ staff involv check firm trade regist chamber commerc exclud imped access firm netherland certif cover technic aspect crane sck inspect crane crane provid certif plate sck show statutori condit compli final certifi firm oblig appli fnk gener condit includ condit price certif carri member advisori bodi certif committe member drawn sector award contract crane hire firm promin repres sck bodi akzo dsm shell repres sck bodi firm place contract encourag award certifi firm system made watertight abovement inhuurverbod enter forc januari certifi firm allow hire extra crane firm affili sck lot work sector carri subcontract basi effect signific decreas turnov affili firm number firm difficulti proceed preliminari examin case commiss issu statement object decemb commiss consid withdraw pursuant articl regul immun fine provid articl regul opinion articl treati infring applic articl justifi princip sck prohibit particip hire crane affili firm exclud affili foreign firm ban hire extra crane affili firm reach consequ view clear involv fnk sck larg firm regularli frequent award contract crane hire firm place sck particip extrem favour posit fact argument adduc fnk sck repli februari statement object provid ground commiss chang view sck certif system ban hire extra crane affili firm letter june commiss inform fnk sck commiss procedur pursuant articl regul termin fnk sck decid withdraw ban respons fnk sck propos letter juli ban hire extra crane affili firm set indent articl rule amend crane emploi provid valid proof certif grant sck certif institut qualifi en certifi crane hire firm appli demonstr equival criteria commiss consid propos meet object establish privat law certif system introduc sck add essenti exist statutori requir appli crane lift equip machin part thereof cover abovement direct eec addit keboma crane inspect bodi recogn dutch govern rank certif institut qualifi en result crane keboma approv satisfi statutori requir caught ban amend propos fnk sck effect practic commiss propos letter date august indent articl rule amend crane shown compli statutori provis forc place user regist offic fnk sck accept propos commiss decid continu proceed pursuant articl proceed nation court interlocutori judgment deliv februari presid utrecht district court proceed brought van marwijk order sck suspend applic ban judgment overturn similarli interlocutori proceed juli amsterdam court appeal court appeal view time evid doubt arrang question chanc exempt commiss view court appeal nation court care deliv judgment matter arrang subject decis commiss issu statement object decemb van marwijk appli presid utrecht district court rule interlocutori judgment deliv juli ban hire crane affili firm suspend circumst prompt court appeal overturn earlier judgment district court longer appli presid district court account fact commiss meantim statement object abovement letter june made point view arrang question clear ban chanc exempt commiss view fact judgment consider extent base interpret amsterdam court appeal earlier judgment juli presid district court postpon entri effect judgment month novemb give parti opportun obtain rule amsterdam court appeal appeal reject judgment amsterdam court appeal octob fnk sck prepar distribut novemb order compli court order statement effect inhuurverbod withdrawn commiss adopt definit posit matter ii articl evid fact fnk rule sck rule form indissolubl assess applic articl treati fnk associ member associ undertak engag crane hire trade clear articl fnk statut explanatori memorandum attach notif fnk associ undertak mean articl intern rule fnk constitut decis associ undertak adopt fnk statut articl thereof sck foundat dutch law set initi fnk purpos certifi crane hire firm payment sck independ legal person articl statut notif sck public law basi sck carri commerci econom activ undertak mean articl fact sck certif institut recogn certif council compli pertin european standard en seri prevent articl applic fact sck rule recogn certif council case sck act breach competit law crane hire firm certifi sck undertak mean articl particip sck system involv accept statut rule constitut agreement decis associ undertak mean articl reason set featur sck system set fnk initi close circuit inhuurverbod articl rule larg ban spelt articl rule prevent affili firm call affili firm subcontractor limit freedom action affili firm restrict competit substanti restrict access firm member state dutch market result certif requir arrang suit situat netherland recit fnk sck arrang tantamount attempt control entir dutch crane hire market circumst conclus competit restrict mean articl treati fnk sck demonstr certif system function inhuurverbod arrang base practic essenti element market share undertak affili fnk sck recit fact largest firm hire crane esso shell dsm dutch railwai make servic firm affili sck signific context larg firm heavili repres sck bodi fnk repres block major bodi procedur result market reserv ban hire crane affili firm ensur extra hire crane firm affili sck provid arrang made watertight mean monitor system set sck articl rule provid suspens decertif affili firm fail compli requir includ ban hire extra crane affili firm appeal decis heard panel appoint indirectli hand fnk articl rule suspens decertif affili firm announc mean advertis special press pose threat decertif affili firm continu busi firm question creat suggest avoid busi firm question advertis extrem damag firm concern fnk sck system requir member particip establish netherland articl fnk statut sck certif requir exclus base gear situat netherland exclud undertak member state belgium germani recit germani belgium compar system netherland statutori inspect crane abovement arrang significantli restrict competit view total turnov crane hire busi market share particip involv sck firm award contract notifi statu intern rule fnk initi conced system effect restrict trade common market subsequ revers posit claim effect claim base limit extent cross frontier trade branch industri mobil crane natur meant transport evid fnk handbook krupp crane travel maximum speed kph handbook page advertis page fnk handbook offer hire crane lift capac tonn set rapidli mean word mobil impli fact move mobil crane system constitut potenti restrict intra commun trade remain true particip present engag intra commun trade court held case aeg commiss fact complain belgium show intra commun trade fact trade member state advers affect competit rule cover netherland reason set recit potenti effect trade appreci iii articl statut intern rule fnk statut rule sck notifi commiss view obtain neg clearanc altern exempt pursuant articl state recit fnk sck arrang examin jointli order qualifi exempt fnk sck inter alia show agreement decis associ undertak contribut improv crane hire busi allow consum fair share result benefit improv entail object appreci advantag compens disadvantag field competit requir impos member affili firm virtual ident statutori requir applic tax social secur provis hand complianc safeti rule recit respons author ensur complianc statutori provis undertak particip system hard measur benefit result system conclus restrict impos affili firm result disadvantag affili firm design coerc crane hire firm join cartel disadvantag outweigh benefit claim fnk sck restrict impos fnk sck indispens attain object set statut duplic monitor complianc dutch statutori provis safeti requir sck impos certifi crane hire firm impos safeti decre base law condit workplac ministeri regul offici supervis complianc provis carri keboma similarli safeti relat requir sck impos relat payment tax social secur contribut registr chamber commerc parti insur creditworthi applic collect labour agreement cover statutori provis sck statutori requir impos requir manner conduct busi insuffici reason regard restrict competit impos indispens restrict impos fnk sck aim exclud undertak share market netherland elimin competit respect substanti part crane hire market competit firm member state effect elimin recit fact commiss polici certif scope privat law certif system design provid supplementari monitor complianc statutori provis prejudic detail system accord competit rule laid treati restrict competit caught articl justifi sole ground introduct certif system fit commiss certif polici reason set grant exempt pursuant articl ec treati iv articl regul articl regul stipul fine impos respect activ relat decis notif commiss decis articl immun fine withdrawn commiss preliminari examin opinion articl treati appli applic articl justifi recit commiss opinion decis fall scope articl decis constitut clear infring articl view ban hire extra crane affili firm recit applic articl sight justifi point anti competit natur arrang examin detail proceed utrecht district court find point contradict appeal commiss inform undertak pursuant articl regul decis immun imposit fine result notif agreement withdrawn respect ban hire extra crane notifi fnk sck laid indent articl rule spelt greater detail articl rule adopt decis articl preliminari examin pursuant articl regul commiss opinion arrang notifi fnk sck respect certif crane hire busi meet condit articl ec treati applic articl justifi articl decis address sticht certif kraanverhuurbedrijf postbu nl ah culemborg federati van nederlands kraanverhuurbedrijven postbu nl ah culemborg brussel april commiss karel van miert member commiss oj oj direct amend direct eec oj earlier amend direct eec oj crane includ scope direct ecr paragraph join case consten grundig commiss ecr case hilti commiss ecr ii paragraph