commiss decis juli aid oper air rout grant law region sardinia januari italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof interest parti notic submit comment accord abovement provis view fact comment submit letter march italian author inform commiss accord articl treati aid scheme oper level air servic introduc law autonom region sardinia januari hereinaft law januari march commiss italian author request inform enabl determin aid scheme compat common market commiss request concern definit rout sardinia receiv futur receiv oper aid definit rout benefit law januari applic italian author provis council regul eec juli access commun air carrier intra commun air rout articl amend act access austria finland sweden restrict market access lastli rule payment calcul subsidi amount concern letter date june italian author commiss memorandum region sardinia partli compli request inform march state region past grant aid airlin list rout receiv aid scheme drawn financi compens concern commun airlin meet requir lastli amount aid limit budget alloc detail inform applic restrict provis regul eec market access articl make provis public servic oblig includ financi compens oper compani respect region rout light traffic remind italian author august point commiss date receiv inform request basi inform possess commiss decid initi articl procedur inform itali decis letter januari letter gave italian govern notic submit comment commiss month inform requir commiss pursu examin matter publish offici journal european commun interest parti invit send comment month date public repli receiv italian author commiss letter give notic comment detail provid aid scheme introduc law januari exist public servic oblig air rout sardinia comment receiv procedur interest parti ii commiss decid examin case articl treati articl agreement european econom area hereinaft eea agreement sole basi inform possess time limit submiss italian govern comment inform request articl procedur expir inform comment submit commiss empow termin procedur make decis basi inform question aid compat common market accord court justic judgment case french republ commiss join case germani pleuger worthington commiss court held prior take decis commiss order member state submit inform inform possess determin aid compat common market commiss consid present case inform possess forward italian author notifi aid scheme respons request inform procedur initi incomplet suffici decis compat common market aid scheme introduc law januari iii law januari intend strengthen air servic sardinia author region execut grant subsidi compani bodi provid schedul level servic transport passeng air level servic mean law air servic provid aeroplan helicopt capac passeng subsidi concern intend compens loss incur carrier result empti seat paid seat offer rout year region execut accord region transport plan sardinia direct air servic main italian citi number european citi rout concern essenti low densiti region rout addit subsidi grant consecut year amount equal fare approv year year year grant subsidi subject administr procedur provid law januari firm wish receiv subsidi submit applic support document annual report technic report financi manag plan forward budget region transport depart octob year preced subsidi request final date submiss file set dai public law question offici gazett autonom region sardinia applic consid admiss includ annual intervent plan adopt region execut take account budgetari resourc lastli grant subsidi airlin subject sign agreement stipul prohibit modifi disrupt oper programm approv region transport depart fare approv appli provis laid law agreement staff compli staf level approv region transport inspector maintain expenditur aris applic subsidi measur estim lit billion year subsidi paid post recipi firm month depart check empti seat aircraft assign rout concern advanc subsidi paid deposit lodg iv articl treati articl eea agreement provid aid grant member state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product good incompat common market case point region sardinia decid mean law januari grant aid firm bodi provid level schedul air servic sardinia state aid mean aid grant central region local author member state public privat bodi establish appoint administ aid court justic held case steinik amp weinlig subsidi question grant direct region sardinia includ budget constitut state aid liabl affect trade member state grant firm engag air transport activ natur directli link trade cover common market european econom area case entri forc council regul eec eec eec air transport packag liber air transport harmon condit grant licenc carrier definit rule applic civil aviat sector principl freedom provid servic commun lastli commiss consid subsidi distort competit favour enterpris aid grant airlin oper rout law januari airlin provid schedul air servic aircraft capac passeng addit compani wish benefit scheme subject procedur amount select procedur requir submit complet file examin region transport depart decid includ number airlin programm accord region transport plan budget avail event grant oper aid condit air carrier order oper rout liabl jeopard competit favour carrier oper rout distort greater law recipi requir appli fare approv depart expressli prohibit charg fare supplement mean unabl adjust fare cost requir maintain minimum price level competitor offer subsidi addit calcul subsidi account revenu gener cost born aid recipi oper rout question guarante carrier realiz excess profit transfer rout competit commun carrier lastli absenc specif inform italian author point probabl freedom access rout question list commun commiss restrict april detriment commun carrier licens member state itali restrict increas risk distort competit result aid scheme introduc law januari commiss consid law januari establish subsidi constitut state aid mean articl treati articl eea agreement aid set law question regard compat common market articl treati articl eea agreement qualifi except provid articl articl appli aid intend make good damag caus natur disast except occurr assist economi area germani point provis relat aid social charact applic subsidi question paid airlin bodi identifi individu consum method calcul subsidi account number passeng carri view probabl access restrict rout question april detriment commun airlin licens itali doubt exist possibl discrimin connect origin servic articl treati articl eea agreement list aid regard compat common market compat examin context commun singl member state except provid relev provis appli commiss establish aid market forc suffici persuad recipi act achiev desir object order safeguard orderli function common market regard principl set articl treati except principl articl defin articl interpret strictli examin aid scheme individu measur articl treati articl eea agreement applic case question subsidi provid law januari aim promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb economi member state except provid articl aid facilit develop econom activ applic hand subsidi question oper aid invest aid hand aim sole increas flight sardinia sector purpos sardinia cover articl treati articl eea agreement exist low densiti air servic sardinia link commun eea region regard promot econom develop island mean provis addit aid question temporari year degress satisfi main condit commiss gener impos accept oper aid articl treati agreement novemb commiss adopt commun state aid civil aviat take account liber measur enter forc januari creat integr singl market air transport introduc cabotag result direct aid oper region air servic principl exempt basi articl treati articl agreement aid result cross subsidi airlin subsid unprofit rout profit rout airlin competit commun airlin distort competit advantag airlin receiv oper aid region present case aggrav factor account calcul subsidi take account revenu cost recipi mean possibl excess profit rule barrier entri rout question due applic restrict claus regul eec strict procedur condit obtain subsidi impos law januari commiss spell commun novemb direct subsidi oper region air rout compat common market specif case exempt articl treati eea agreement demonstr exempt articl regul eec public servic oblig impos member state hypothesi financi compens grant air carrier select transpar tender procedur account expenditur revenu gener servic present case public servic oblig rout sardinia brought attent commiss respons publish notic effect offici journal european commun light forego aid scheme introduc law januari regard incompat common market legisl aid scheme incompat common market commiss entitl order ensur effect incompat decis incompat aid scheme requir member state concern refrain appli legisl step repeal judgment court case commiss italian republ law grant aid expenditur charg end budget italian author refrain appli adopt measur repeal aid scheme incompat common market aid paid pursuant legisl provis establish scheme commiss power pursuant articl treati accord court judgment case commiss germani deufil commiss requir member state concern order aid repaid commiss inform aid payment made pursuant law question italian author recov aid grant firm bodi law aid recov accord provis nation law relat interest arrear amount ow state interest start run date unlaw aid grant adopt decis articl aid scheme establish law region sardinia januari declar incompat common market mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement articl itali forthwith ceas appli law januari month notif decis step repeal law itali order repay month notif decis aid grant law januari aid recov accord provis nation law relat interest arrear payabl amount ow state interest start run date aid grant rate applic refer rate assess region aid scheme articl itali inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address italian republ brussel juli commiss neil kinnock member commiss oj oj ecr ecr ecr oj oj oj ecr ecr ecr