commiss decis juli state aid grant germani sket maschinen und anlagenbau gmbh notifi document number german version authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl ec treati articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati sket maschinen und anlagenbau gmbh quot sket mab quot econom successor sket schwermaschinenbau magdeburg gmbh magdeburg quot sket smm quot march commiss decid initi formal investig procedur respect state aid grant sket smm proceed concern sket smm subsidiari entstaubungstechnik magdeburg gmbh magdeburg quot etm quot drahtziehmaschinenwerk grüna gmbh chemnitz quot dzm quot sket smm receiv aid question privatis restructur prior sket smm grant aid commiss object nn nn proceed number juli commiss decid extend proceed includ state aid paid date initi decis cover decis investor oestmann amp borchert industriebeteiligungen gbr withdrawn restructur plan end commiss notifi plan addit aid measur plan envisag inter alia set successor compani oper profit part sket smm salvag bankrupt compani sket mab successor compani octob sket smm forc file gesamtvollstreckungsverfahren proceed insolv proceed länder plan form subject initi decis juli restor sket smm viabil june commiss adopt neg final decis ec regard aid sket smm insolv proceed appli subsidiari etm dzm transfer bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben quot bv quot feder offic special unif relat task decis ec termin case respect part sket smm cover insolv proceed case split separ part sket smm etm dzm reflect realiti sket smm successor compani take independ cours action alloc case number sket mab number nn decis relat sket mab octob commiss decid initi articl procedur respect aid grant sket mab file number letter date novemb sg commiss advis german author decis letter publish offici journal european commun march interest parti invit submit comment receiv letter date april regist receiv commiss date german author advis commiss sket mab privatis provid detail privatis letter date regist receiv commiss date german author repli commiss letter provid addit detail sket mab privatis commiss final question octob inform injunct meet place decemb repres feder govern investor commiss discuss propos answer emerg meet descript restructur plan submit german author talli plan approv investor letter date januari regist receiv commiss januari german govern submit redraft restructur plan german author submit inform februari regist receiv commiss februari april regist receiv commiss april ii sket mab problem deriv natur sket smm emerg sket smm conglomer design oper centralis command economi attempt privatis singl compani econom environ transform competit market hamper cumbersom fragment organis structur restructur conglomer entireti began earli complet commiss reach neg decis aid scheme sket smm notifi measur concern potenti profit compon conglomer includ heavi machineri manufactur oper time sket smm file insolv proceed octob german author modifi origin strategi resolv extract potenti profit activ conglomer continu oper smaller autonom econom unit order achiev bv set commerci inact coordin compani sket manag und vertriebsgesellschaft gmbh quot sket muv quot supervis restructur prepar privatis commerci autonom compani own bv small medium size enterpris sket muv act instruct bv entrust find investor negoti privatis salvag compani compani privatis april process dismantl sket muv gmbh began salvag busi sket mab sket walzwerkstechnik gmbh sket ölsaatentechnik gmbh renam cimbria sket gmbh sket maschinenbau edv gmbh sket verseilmaschinenbau gmbh addit subsidiari etm dzm transfer bv insolv proceed institut sket smm iii sket mab base magdeburg saxoni anhalt germani emploi person turnov dem million balanc sheet total dem million manufactur heavi machineri type order propos restructur plan gain addit downstream oper relat wind turbin product sket mab regist compani magdeburg trade regist novemb share capit dem bv sole sharehold novemb sket mab enter agreement liquid sket smm compani machineri plant privatis contract januari investor enercon group act aloi wobben lmb group act heinz buse acquir share sket mab enercon group busi group compris compani own aloi wobben enercon gmbh compani base lower saxoni germani compani group develop manufactur instal wind turbin worldwid enercon group sme decemb employe turnov amount dem million enercon world market leader wind turbin market largest market share germani lmb group busi group compris compani own heinz buse logauer maschinenbau gmbh compani heinz buse major sharehold logauer maschinenbau gmbh compani base lower saxoni germani produc gener purpos machineri market sket mab suppli enercon group part wind turbin sme turnov dem million iv januari contract conclud sale share sket mab bv vendor aloi wobben heinz buse purchas sale form open invit tender list investor drawn west merchant bank privatis notic publish press document potenti investor appli investor bid submit purchas price dem paid bv investor bank guarante dem million bv contract featur penalti claus number employe sket mab site locat contract contain restrict profit withdraw sket mab buyer enercon group agre includ unit sket mab unit distinct legal statu form integr part sket mab oper problem face unit eventu legal distinct sket mab compani integr larg cumbersom conglomer sket smm design oper central plan economi reflect sket smm intern busi organis physic infrastructur social polici object account sket smm grossli overstaf market economi perspect addit unit eventu sket mab suffer gener neglect underinvest extern sket smm integr depend central plan economi meant sket smm sket mab sale disrupt economi subsequ transform market economi turnov suffer result view kei step restructur involv identifi core profit activ heavi machineri manufactur sket smm extract oper relev asset establish concern entail creat legal entiti sket mab elimin depend sket oper futur relat sket smm successor compani base market principl meant creat separ physic infrastructur sket mab concentr activ smallest site requir workforc need reduc addit measur undertaken remedi underinvest order preserv goodwil sket tradit sale area heavi machineri contract award previous sket smm honour time custom base develop sket mab privatis enercon lmb group final phase restructur sket mab establish commerci joint ventur parent compani sket econom integr enercon group involv set oper rotorblattfertigung gmbh quot roma quot make wind turbin rotor generatorenfertigung und assembl gmbh quot gema quot produc assembl gener enhanc sket mab tradit oper provid downstream capabl relat wind turbin market capabl involv expans sket mab capac form integr part sket mab econom term oper distinct legal person reason product liabil protect industri oper physic integr sket mab product process difficult sourc parti enercon group provid train order familiaris sket mab personnel oper econom integr lmb group benefit sket mab provid access manageri heinz buse person involv sket mab dai dai oper addit reorganis arrang provis made sket mab capit financ requir time extract sket smm privatis restructur plan implement german author complet time total cost restructur sket mab dem million broken dem million machin product oper run part fail sket smm financ work capit capit asset sket mab dem million pre financ complet contract dem million financ sket mab post privatis restructur dem million financ set roma gema downstream oper dem million train sket mab employe dem million restructur plan firm restor profit kei data tabl figur base project made time privatis gt tabl gt note project growth turnov reflect sket mab order book base investor involv proport turnov wind turbin product amount addit sket mab order book show econom futur longer depend contract sket smm successor compani higher personnel cost reflect increas activ acquisit roma gema downstream oper downturn materi cost reflect sket mab abil negoti suppli contract favour term parent compani enercon lmb oper market profit expand concern cooper twelv year vi aid packag notifi german author privatis amount dem million commiss establish investor grant dem million period approv aid scheme outlin programm joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur commiss reassess measur includ amount evalu proportion gt tabl gt addit contract pre financ grant dem million repaid investor part privatis origin aid packag notifi juli amount dem million addit aid compon account enercon lmb group select investor sket mab open uncondit invit tender bid chosen gt tabl gt vii tradit relev market sket mab oper manufactur made order heavi machineri signific part order wind turbin market result compani integr enercon roma gema oper restructur sket mab activ market rotor turbin assembl gener activ concern sket mab custom firm technic oper branch industri requir manufactur compon complet plant basi plan design specif present firm activ german market face stiff competit low wage countri poland czech republ grow demand qualiti time product complex plant site market segment grow import sket mab focus segment qualiti servic logist work deadlin kei factor condit market sket mab oper determin demand downstream market basi inform commiss ground chang view held initi formal investig procedur market sket mab oper affect structur overcapac downstream market wind turbin market sket mab includ roma gema produc wind power europ began mid wake oil crisi industri slump mid low energi price prompt intensifi effort reduc cost improv oper effici recent year wind power market record signific growth larg market develop denmark recent germani largest market eu world outlook market posit electr gener wind power expect grow rapidli technolog advanc lower cost make increasingli competit mainstream power gener technolog commiss found evid structur overcapac market regard activ develop gema roma structur overcapac wind turbin market upstream market product part wind turbin market suffer overcapac viii formal investig procedur initi respect origin aid packag sket mab commiss doubt compat aid restructur aid common market basi inform provid commiss held restructur plan vagu restructur measur cost financi data provid insuffici clear compani turn profit busi reason period time lack inform develop sket mab capac meant hard identifi impact aid competitor lack inform restructur measur cost meant difficult determin aid limit minimum restructur lack privat investor interest take sket mab formal investig procedur initi increas commiss doubt ix aid measur caught articl ec treati reason sket mab compani oper relev market extend member state trade member state affect aid natur distort competit aid award sket mab german author caught articl ec treati articl treati provid possibl exempt aid caught articl reason set sole basi exempt restructur aid sket mab firm difficulti articl aid grant compani bv found insolv proceed initi econom entiti oper legal person sket smm gmbh entiti realiti cluster divers econom oper undergo restructur year sket mab compani continu part sket smm heavi machineri oper bv strategi modifi provid compani capit resourc order privatis stand basi distinguish featur arrang sket smm gmbh continu state ownership privatis singl group econom unit circumst distinguish present case rescu compani auffanggesellschaften creat wake wind compani privatis acquir legal person sket mab heavi machineri manufactur oper viabl independ firm note sket smm heavi machineri oper found oper distinct busi design function command economi result problem led eventu collaps sket smm potenti viabl oper extract sket smm restructur independ concern successor oper continu face problem aid grant sket mab part asset resourc bankrupt compani treat restructur aid justifi view histor econom circumst compani oblig readjust rapidli centralis econom system market system view role plai bv successor organis treuhandanstalt adjust light commiss take view exempt provid articl ec treati relev order meet requir exempt articl aid satisfi criteria set guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti commiss consid rescu restructur aid contribut develop econom activ advers affect trade commun interest condit set section guidelin met authoris aid condit firm rescu restructur locat assist area commiss region consider articl account paragraph guidelin measur consid notifi german author amount dem million loan pre financ contract amount dem million interest repaid investor privatis intend restructur aid meet criteria guidelin restructur plan restor compani difficulti long term viabil reason time scale basi realist assumpt problem face oper eventu sket mab measur requir address outlin pre privatis measur address problem post privatis measur tackl remaind includ integr parent compani depend sket smm successor compani end sket mab gain access geograph product market investor group success oper good record work sket mab econom perform line project made time privatis invest compani made impact sket mab order book restor liabil reason timescal realist commiss conclud criterion guidelin met xi condit guidelin restructur aid accept aid give rise undu distort competit case structur excess product capac relev market guidelin requir aid recipi reduc capac perman basi structur excess product capac reduct requir capac increas allow note commiss evid relev sector heavi machineri manufactur oper wind turbin market form part suffer structur excess product capac sket mab requir reduc capac perman basi downsiz premis workforc part restructur arrang addit sket mab exist machin product capac expand gema roma set oper downstream activ compon success integr enercon crucial sket mab return viabil notic publish offici journal european commun set letter german author call interest parti competitor submit comment repli receiv sket mab run joint ventur enercon lmb group group activ market agreement german author distort competit common market commiss conclud aid sket mab result undu distort competit xii condit guidelin restructur aid accept amount intens aid limit strict minimum need restructur relat benefit anticip commun point view investor expect make signific contribut restructur plan resourc case total aid packag bv amount dem million amount compris loan dem million bv purchas work invest capit build stock compon acquir equip sket smm element packag consist loan dem million grant bv administr sket mab receiv loan dem million continu restructur dem million grant joint feder govern länder scheme ad total amount aid purpos assess aid proport restructur cost benefit purchas price dem investor commit provid dem million restructur sket mab financ train sket mab employe tune dem million agre repai loan dem million grant sket mab interest dem restructur plan involv expand sket mab ad roma gema oper investor commit oper account investor put dem million roma gema financ start cost dem million investor contribut restructur dem million dem million take account dem million joint feder govern länder fund grant investor total restructur cost amount dem million privat investor contribut investor contribut regard reason view commiss conclud concern express initi proceed address criterion proportion aid compli xiii condit guidelin restructur plan submit accept commiss fulli implement oblig laid commiss decis discharg origin decis amend notif member state commiss step requir recoveri aid import part restructur plan set roma gema implement investor undertaken implement remain compon year state investor group long histori cooper reason assum dissolv joint ventur addit german govern provid assur measur ensur plan carri commiss conclud part guidelin compli xiv commiss find germani unlawfulli implement aid measur detail violat articl ec treati view commiss conclud measur compli guidelin restructur aid compat common market adopt decis articl measur germani implement sket mab magdeburg heavi machineri manufactur oper sket smm amount dem million compat common market mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement relev aid compris grant bv financ work capit capit asset dem million grant bv build stock dem million loan heavi machineri manufactur oper sket smm waiver repay dem million grant final phase restructur approxim dem million articl loan dem million germani grant sket mab repaid investor sket mab compat common market mean articl ec treati articl eea agreement articl germani submit detail annual report implement restructur plan articl decis address feder republ germani brussel juli commiss karel van miert member commiss oj oj oj oj oj oj oj state aid nn state aid aid firm approv commiss april case nn aid firm approv commiss case nn aid firm approv commiss novemb case state aid aid firm approv commiss case panorama eu industri oj