commiss decis decemb german aid favour addinol mineralöl gmbh gv newli establish separ hive vehicl addinol lube oil gmbh amp kg notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite regard comment decis novemb june commiss approv rescu aid addinol mineralöl gmbh hereinaft refer addinol letter septemb commiss request detail press articl refer rumour addinol privatis german author repli letter octob visit commiss repres berlin decemb repres german govern bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv answer question aris recent press report talk berlin german author commun addit inform aid measur dem restructur plan letter februari basi inform dispos commiss decid februari open proceed articl ec treati doubt compat common market aid measur decis ground therefor commun germani letter march content publish offici journal european commun commiss chang case number addit interest parti invit submit comment month public letter april regist april letter april regist april germani respond commiss letter march letter april commiss request supplementari inform germani answer letter date regist meet repres commiss feder german govern inform provid german govern addit question german govern june answer german govern june regist dai germani answer juli commiss ask question august question answer letter date august regist august letter date august regist august final commiss put question germani septemb answer septemb regist dai septemb regist octob germani provid addit inform octob regist octob octob regist octob octob regist octob novemb regist dai respons open procedur fina deutschland gmbh fina submit comment juli august commiss put question fina question answer letter august regist dai letter date regist juli germani declar requir translat letter fina letter date august regist august germani gave comment letter fina inform commiss part aid loan dem grant decis commiss compat common market ii addinol set june split state enterpris veb hydrierwerk zeitz privatis place privatis contract sign august enterpris iug innov umwelttechniken gmbh addinol compris addinol mineralöl gmbh subsidiari addinol vertrieb gmbh addinol dienstleistung gmbh octob addinol petit open bankruptci proceed gesamtvollstreckung separ hive vehicl auffanggesellschaft set schmieröl krumpa gmbh amp kg decemb renam addinol lube oil gmbh amp kg hereinaft addinol lube auffanggesellschaft part stock addinol decemb auffanggesellschaft asset premis equip subsidiari addinol dienstleistung gmbh administr gesamtvollstreckung addinol lube own invest compani bvt hold gmbh amp kg share manag share mr wildegg mr streletz dr koehn auffanggesellschaft sme addinol activ lubric sector main product oil kind base oil oil privat car diesel motor hydraul transmiss oil auffanggesellschaft addinol lube blend sell lubric oil refin oil longer addinol turnov respect lubric oil dem turnov achiev germani turnov made estonia addinol employe addinol lube todai employe subsidiari addinol mineralöl market oü estonia forecast turnov dem addinol locat german state sachsen anhalt iii addinol receiv aid measur past framework privatis addinol receiv grant dem bv cover loss period land sachsen anhalt guarante invest loan dem cost remov burden past time juli dem debt incur juli waiv dem debt remain oblig compani decis june commiss found measur cover treuhand regim due difficulti encount addinol bv grant rescu aid dem form loan interest rate term april addinol suffer acut liquid crisi autumn end bv search investor term rescu loan extend rescu aid measur need search investor longer anticip aid measur authoris compris loan total dem interest rate paid back june dem paid context restructur addinol addinol lube receiv aid measur total dem form grant bv provid dem land sachsen anhalt provid dem dem dem provid land sachsen financ fund approv region aid scheme gemeinschaftsaufgab verbesserung der regionalen wirtschaftstruktur ga mittel total amount aid measur auffanglösung notifi authoris commiss amount dem amount includ dem loan financ bv land sachsen anhalt gesamtvollstreckungsverwalt paid decemb mention open procedur dem aid measur spent purpos dem invest financ dem loss compens dem loss blend facil transit period dem work capit dem closur plant dem loss blend facil blend facil construct dem closur plant paid addinol rest dem paid auffanggesellschaft addinol lube letter septemb germani inform commiss aid need order financ loss blend facil leuna werk gmbh own bv waiv dem claim addinol decid leuna werk gmbh compens bv land sachsen anhalt dem part open procedur subject decis letter date novemb notif addit aid withdrawn iv mention comment open procedur receiv commiss fina subsidiari petrofina group base frankfurt main activ market suppli sale market refin fuel market product sale market lubric product includ retail sale servic station sale industri commerci custom germani fina activ market petrochem relat product turnov dem profit dem fina emploi person fina submit market lubric addinol lube oper face signific declin fina market term volum month fina consid addinol lube local player access technolog compet technolog intens intern market problem addinol lube partner industri experi involv restructur plan final addinol lube depend parti raw materi main competitor vertic integr fina price addinol lower deal competitor alleg cost advantag achiev aggress market polici financ aid measur rescu aid measur dem million result aid addinol lube cost advantag enabl compani doubl market share period request proof provid claim fina fina fear restructur measur dem continu market distort strategi addinol lube fina consid market blend addit product overcapac final fina consid subsidi dem million sever distort market total turnov fina lubric market dem million fina state respect investor contribut restructur plan low fina conclud criteria laid commun rescu restructur guidelin fulfil restructur aid addinol lube authoris letter date august germani respond comment made fina addinol lube viabl futur access raw materi base oil refineri koramo kolin ag czech republ germani refut argument compani vertic integr success market addinol lube intern allianc technolog cooper substanti export partner industri experi german author claim investor manag compani custom addinol lube industri partner germani refut fina argument addinol aggress market basi subsidis price true addinol lube futur regard alleg doubl market share germani provid data market share addinol german market declin segment addinol increas market share motor oil segment germani assert price dump practic addinol lost custom period alleg distort competit place state aid measur distort competit market share addinol lube germani internation insignific final germani state aid restrict minimum need restructur germani stress letter investor contribut consid signific open procedur commiss rais doubt approv rescu aid measur aid measur context auffanglösung approv rescu aid measur guidelin rescu restructur oj state rescu aid principl oper addinol receiv rescu aid commiss express doubt rescu aid paid authoris compat common market commiss argu germani breach assur time commiss decis provid firm rescu aid germani fact grant addit aid dem bv land sachsen anhalt gesamtvollstreckungsverwalt addinol decemb aid measur regard aid measur dem commiss express doubt restructur plan enabl firm viabl long term aid provid limit strict minimum need investor contribut consid signific vi time approv novemb aid measur bv land sachsen anhalt believ respect rescu aid measur save compani avoid bankruptci commiss evid forese respect point time addinol initi bankruptci proceed decemb packag rescu aid measur approv commiss germani assur commiss refrain futur grant rescu aid open procedur found assur broken germani addinol receiv loan dem initi bankruptci proceed decemb answer open proceed germani argu dem fact rescu aid pre financ restructur aid continu product blend facil amount dem includ aid amount dem addinol lube argument plausibl restructur plan develop finish octob auffanggesellschaft establish decemb imper creation compani addinol continu product order lose custom decemb restructur concept consult arthur finish restructur plan detail dem reserv continu oper blend facil continu product blend facil blend facil construct end restructur plan dem paid decemb part amount constitut restructur aid commiss open procedur approv rescu aid measur suspect rescu aid analys dem paid decemb constitut pre financ restructur aid germani promis grant rescu aid doubt repetit award rescu aid measur sole reason open procedur rescu aid resolv germani point germani await commiss approv pai dem breach oblig articl ec treati germani claim back paid part rescu aid measur administr bankruptci proceed vii aid measur addinol addinol lube regard aid mean articl ec treati grant state resourc member state distort threaten distort competit favour undertak affect trade member state aid measur provid bv land sachsen anhalt notifi restructur aid commiss consid derog provid articl ec treati quot aid facilit develop econom activ aid affect trade condit extent contrari common interest quot predomin object aid restructur firm difficulti aid consid compat common market criteria commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin met problem appli guidelin appli newli found compani auffanglösung take rent asset compani liquid proceed initi except made favour compani german länder transit plan economi market economi pose special problem low amount equiti capit typic problem compani transit addinol lube problem justifi treat firm compani difficulti special situat special role bv transit process aid compani compani liquid procedur initi case regard restructur aid case privat investor newli found compani contribut substanti restructur commiss approv aid basi restructur guidelin addinol addinol lube restructur plan satisfi condit restructur plan restor viabil restructur plan restor long term viabil health firm reason timescal basi realist assumpt futur oper condit principl repetit aid germani provid detail restructur plan prepar consult arthur addinol lube core plan addinol lube ceas refin oil focus blend high qualiti lubric motor oil purpos complet oil blend plant built invest cost dem order lose custom addinol lube blend facil addinol construct blend plant complet product facil addinol complet dismantl irrevers close oper addinol lube differ substanti addinol addinol lube refin oil project profit loss account year forecast profit year onward oil need input deliv refineri koramo kolin ag koramo kolin ag develop high qualiti base oil basi addinol lube specialti oil focus blend close refineri compani focu core compet reduc high cost caus unprofit refin activ main assumpt restructur plan addinol lube increas turnov roughli turnov increas central point restructur plan develop arthur essenti condit addinol lube reach long term viabil germani argu increas feasibl reason addinol lube oper profit nich lubric market addinol lube high qualiti product reliabl strong expertis develop produc sell high qualiti lubric aid compani approv uncertainti supplier custom diminish addinol lube acquir custom lot contract past conclud due uncertain futur compani custom fear lose supplier strong growth turnov addinol product estonia compani promis export potenti restructur guidelin improv viabil result intern measur contain restructur plan base extern factor price demand increas compani substanti influenc market assumpt made gener acknowledg germani confirm market lubric oil germani declin month compar pessimist prospect plan turnov increas market confirm evalu industri expert commiss describ motor oil market matur market low profit margin inform wood mackenzi european downstream oil servic februari lubric market shrink oecd countri restructur plan base extern factor extern factor gener acknowledg disregard fact formal explain return viabil extern factor chanc addinol lube increas turnov plan low market motor oil account turnov addinol lube shrank germani april april restructur plan explicitli forese turnov increas addinol lube achiev increas motor oil market problem market time span oil chang car longer longer due improv qualiti oil neg growth rate reflect season phenomenon structur problem market germani argu nich motor oil segment addinol lube oper declin unabl demonstr addinol lube oper high growth segment motor oil market lubric market plan futur implicit argument germani addinol oper profit market nich convinc compani good qualiti product strong expertis research develop addinol lube compet major industri group shell exxon mobil capabl produc high qualiti product qualiti attribut addinol lube consid condit sine qua compet market addinol lube receiv order legal uncertainti compani futur resolv legal certainti respect compani prerequisit compet market support assumpt turnov increas matur declin market export potenti compani germani argu current turnov addinol lube achiev export subsidiari addinol mineralöl market oü estonia germani countri doubl digit growth rate market segment growth rate achiev possibl achiev substanti increas market share eastern europ doubt commiss expert major intern local competitor market addinol lube point product repres russia lukeoil ga station due crisi russia compani acknowledg increas turnov russian market half current perspect econom situat russia make substanti turnov increas futur market pessimist consider appli addinol lube effort enter market asia expect sale increas account export activ indic long term viabil question shown detail investor contribut dem restructur cost dem aid restrict minimum need commiss assum addinol lube undertaken effort increas contribut restructur plan addit financi resourc privat bank privat investor fact addinol lube debt compani receiv dem state aid difficult compani rais privat capit dem gener reluct privat bank eastern germani give loan explain unwilling grant financi support profit orient investor bank financ invest promis outlook compar case german ländershow bank give credit compani compani difficulti appar unwilling privat bank financi institut provid monei consid sign doubt futur prospect compani restructur plan highli leverag state aid mean unforeseen difficulti aris likelihood aid high take account previou histori firm commiss doubt principl time time assur updat assess restructur plan arthur octob chang pictur uncertainti turnov increas confirm studi arthur argu addinol lube focus motor oil busi market prospect bad turnov increas realis partli due special circumst repeat addinol lube sold remain oil refineri special turnov effect result unforeseen effect addinol sold base oil koramo kolin ag parti special effect account dem turnov dem sell base oil koramo kolin ag arthur assess special effect basi year updat financi data origin foreseen restructur concept basic assumpt valid turnov increas achiev full extent addinol lube studi arthur chanc addinol lube achiev turnov increas fact addinol lube loss due fact benefit special effect sell remain oil reserv leuna refineri proof addinol lube profit updat assess includ inform addinol lube achiev cost reduct purchas materi basi argu turnov increas anymor part cost reduct oil input remain reserv leuna refineri temporari background confus arthur state end assess blend concept plausibl sound strategi develop addinol lube dispel concern commiss turnov increas studi inform provid germani provid convinc argument strong indic addinol lube realist achiev increas argument indic plan develop contrari current market assumpt basi inform modifi assess arthur commiss consid return long term viabil secur commiss conclud condit guidelin satisfi aid proport restructur cost benefit amount intens aid limit strict minimum need enabl restructur undertaken relat benefit anticip commun point view aid beneficiari expect make signific contribut restructur plan resourc extern commerci financ tabl sum financ grant addinol lube addinol framework restructur plan equal sum need restructur gt tabl gt restructur cost amount dem dem reserv auffanggesellschaft addinol lube dem reserv addinol amount dem spent closur dismantl refineri blend facil germani argu due environment regul dismantl facil product facil refineri blend facil addinol irrevers close dem auffanggesellschaft includ dem paid addinol amount reserv continu blend facil blend facil construct complet oper end attribut addinol lube investor contribut dem auffanggesellschaft investor contribut amount investor commit oblig job decemb penalti complianc dem month job compani oper decemb penalti complianc amount receiv state oblig pai state profit made sell compani decemb germani argu job addinol lube secur grant state aid job region region merseburg addinol lube locat suffer high unemploy compar region german länder region sangershausen locat region merseburg suffer highest unemploy rate german länder germani argu state aid addinol lube creat high job allevi structur problem region extent investor contribut extrem low consid compani receiv aid measur past take account investor hold major share privat person investor contribut consid signific addinol lube auffanggesellschaft bear debt loss addinol compani state financ complet dem product facil addinol lube attract capit bank financi institut letter novemb germani announc investor plan increas contribut dem aid germani reduc amount contribut financ guarante philip industri electron build blend facil philip decid intern contribut definit commit made amount includ investor contribut kind minut action credibl addinol lube plenti time past increas contribut germani inform commiss addinol lube receiv loan dem purchas input period commiss approv aid approv commiss amount increas contribut consid contribut restructur plan constitut short term financ includ financi restructur plan state aid measur reduc return letter octob germani includ report consult arthur modifi assess restructur plan addinol lube report addinol loss compens dem significantli germani reduc aid measur restructur plan maximum amount loss compens fix adapt actual loss incur commiss assum higher loss compens paid germani need aid restrict minimum need commiss conclud condit guidelin satisfi condit guidelin fulfil derog articl ec treati appli aid measur dem addinol addinol lube germani await commiss approv pai part aid fail compli oblig articl ec treati appli abovement dem addinol dem addinol paid april form interest bear loan adopt decis articl rescu aid germani favour addinol mineralöl gmbh gv dem notifi octob april compat common market restructur aid plan germani favour addinol mineralöl gmbh gv addinol lube oil gmbh amp kg dem notifi octob februari incompat common market restructur aid germani favour addinol mineralöl gmbh gv addinol lube oil gmbh amp kg dem notifi octob februari incompat common market articl germani measur recov respect real final recipi aid refer articl unlawfulli made recoveri effect accord procedur provis german law sum recov bear interest date made recipi interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel decemb commiss karel van miert member commiss state aid measur letter decemb state aid measur nn letter june oj decis commiss regard aid regim treuhandanstalt nn part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos bracket mark asterisk refer time span addinol restructur plan stop refin sell base oil case blema kirchei nn notif open procedur restructur concept envisag dem state aid measur amount dem investor contribut dem investor decid contribut dem contract sanierungsvereinbarung conclud bv addinol addinol lube deal modal aid payment oblig investor framework contract gesamtvollstreckungsverwalt addinol contribut dem dismantl product facil part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos bracket mark asterisk part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos bracket mark asterisk