commiss decis march initi investig provid articl council regul eec access commun air carrier intra commun air rout notifi document number text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard council regul eec juli articl thereof fact decemb pursuant articl regul eec italian republ ask commiss publish notic offici journal european union impos public servic oblig pso rout sardinian airport main nation airport main point notic concern rout alghero rome rome alghero alghero milan milan alghero alghero bologna bologna alghero alghero turin turin alghero alghero pisa pisa alghero cagliari rome rome cagliari cagliari milan milan cagliari cagliari bologna bologna cagliari cagliari turin turin cagliari cagliari pisa pisa cagliari cagliari verona verona cagliari cagliari napl napl cagliari cagliari palermo palermo cagliari olbia rome rome olbia olbia milan milan olbia olbia bologna bologna olbia olbia turin turin olbia olbia verona verona olbia rout public servic oblig impos constitut singl packag accept complet interest carrier compens natur origin singl carrier lead carrier accept public servic oblig provid perform secur purpos guarante correct execut continu servic secur amount eur million guarante bank sureti activ request eur million insur sureti remain amount minimum frequenc timet capac offer rout point quot public servic oblig quot notic publish offici journal european union decemb expressli refer purpos decis minimum capac aircraft point quot aircraft quot notic publish offici journal european union decemb expressli refer purpos decis fare structur rout concern point quot fare quot notic publish offici journal european union decemb expressli refer purpos decis reduc fare point notic state carrier oper affect rout legal bound appli reduc fare quot fare quot group passeng peopl born sardinia live sardinia spous children peopl born sardinia public servic oblig valid januari decemb carrier intend accept public servic oblig present formal accept compet italian author dai public notic offici journal european union note prior impos public servic oblig refer decis italian republ impos public servic oblig publish offici journal european union octob rout sardinian airport rome milan accord articl regul eec put tender select carrier authoris oper rout exclus basi financi compens carrier authoris oper rout accord public servic oblig impos alitalia cagliari rome air cagliari milan alghero milan alghero rome merdiana olbia rome olbia milan arrang replac public servic oblig subject decis ii essenti element rule public servic oblig rule public servic oblig laid regul eec defin condit appli principl freedom provid servic air transport sector public servic oblig defin except principl regul quot subject regul commun air carrier permit member state concern exercis traffic right rout commun quot condit impos defin articl interpret strictli accord principl discrimin proportion adequ justifi basi criteria laid articl precis rule govern public servic oblig provid impos member state respect schedul air servic airport serv peripher develop region territori thin rout region airport provid rout consid vital econom develop region airport locat extent ensur rout adequ provis schedul air servic satisfi fix standard continu regular capac price standard air carrier meet sole commerci interest adequaci schedul air servic assess member state regard public interest possibl recours form transport abil form meet transport consider combin effect air carrier oper intend oper rout articl phase mechan phase articl member state concern impos public servic oblig rout open commun carrier provid meet oblig carrier appli oper rout public servic oblig impos member state move phase articl limit access rout carrier renew period year carrier select commun tender procedur select carrier receiv financi compens oper rout accord public servic oblig virtu articl commiss decid investig carri request member state initi public servic oblig publish continu appli commiss commun decis council member state member state refer matter council act qualifi major decis iii element rais doubt conform public servic oblig impos rout sardinian airport main nation airport articl regul eec articl regul list number cumul criteria impos public servic oblig type rout elig rout airport serv peripher develop region territori member state concern thin rout region airport territori recognis rout vital econom develop region airport serv locat principl adequaci assess regard exist mean transport altern rout observ addit public servic oblig compli basic principl proportion discrimin court justic decis februari case asociación profesion de empresa naviera de línea regular analir administración gener del estado ecr case point notic impos public servic oblig publish offici journal request italian republ provis rais doubt conform articl regul restrict unduli develop rout concern detail explan base econom analysi air transport market sardinia rest itali provid justifi public servic oblig appropri proportion object rout cover previou notic includ assess evid rout public servic oblig impos januari vital econom develop region sardinia airport concern locat natur rout concern shown rout vital econom develop region sardinia airport concern locat exist altern air rout adequ continu servic provid airport concern main italian hub link satisfactori manner sardinia requir interest carrier oper rout public servic oblig appli singl packag signific restrict principl freedom provid servic breach principl proportion discrimin shown group rout vital econom develop region sardinia airport concern locat risk unjustifi discrimin carrier largest mean oper condit addit requir contrari member state impos public servic oblig account assess combin effect air carrier oper intend oper rout fact italian author want impos requir eighteen rout oper singl packag order financ oper loss thin rout expect proce oper import rout cross subsidis alien articl regul eec requir provid secur high amount creat unjustifi discrimin interest carrier largest mean offer guarante short time dai public notic offici journal interest carrier accept public servic oblig twenti dai begin oper januari creat unjustifi discrimin realiti imposs carrier oper rout sardinia complet legal administr formal time allow mobilis resourc need set oper requir point notic reduc fare appli passeng sole place birth case sardinia sole reason famili link person fact unlaw discrimin base nation case commiss itali ecr iv procedur repeat call commiss draw attent italian author problem express doubt conform notic impos public servic oblig regul eec italian republ decid publish publish interest parti contact commiss inform express concern disproportion discriminatori natur public servic oblig commiss receiv complaint contest legal oblig author wish remain anonym light virtu articl regul eec juli commiss carri investig determin develop rout unduli restrict imposit public servic oblig order decid oblig continu impos rout question adopt decis articl commiss carri investig provid articl regul eec order determin public servic oblig impos rout sardinian airport main nation airport publish request italian republ offici journal european union decemb continu appli rout articl italian republ transmit commiss month notif decis inform examin conform public servic oblig refer articl articl regul eec transmit legal analysi impact exercis european air carrier traffic right respect rout public servic oblig publish offici journal european union decemb appli event oblig effect compli state italian author intend creat exclus oper rout carrier carrier formal accept oblig legal analysi regard commun law justifi condit contain notic impos public servic oblig publish offici journal european union decemb reason impos reduc fare quot peopl born sardinia live sardinia spous children peopl born sardinia quot detail assess implement public servic oblig publish offici journal european union octob detail analysi econom relat region sardinia region itali airport concern public servic oblig publish offici journal european union decemb locat detail analysi current suppli air transport sardinian airport italian airport concern public servic oblig publish offici journal european union decemb includ suppli indirect flight detail analysi avail mean transport capac meet transport consider analysi current demand air transport rout concern oblig precis descript journei time frequenc requir connect road sardinian airport concern oblig descript situat dai notif decis oper servic accord oblig ident carrier carrier oper servic oper forecast passeng traffic freight financi forecast commun carrier carrier claim exist nation court dai notif decis legal situat notic impos public servic oblig articl decis address italian republ decis publish offici journal european union brussel march commiss jacqu barrot vice presid oj regul amend european parliament council regul ec oj oj oj amend oj corrigendum oj oj articl regul eec articl iv regul eec