commiss decis februari state aid implement germani korn fahrzeug und technik gmbh thuringia notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thererof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite procedur letter date octob german author notifi commiss pursuant articl ec treati restructur measur assist korn fahrzeug und technik gmbh gera quot korn quot measur regist aid number inform submit fax date novemb regist receiv novemb commiss request inform novemb german author withdrew notif april commiss meantim approv programm aid measur grant letter date march regist receiv march german author inform commiss measur assist korn measur implement case regist unnotifi aid nn letter date april june commiss request inform receiv march septemb letter date june commiss inform german author decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect measur juli german author request delet text commiss letter prior public offici journal commiss decis initi formal investig procedur publish offici journal european commun august commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid measur commiss receiv comment interest parti partial repli germani receiv juli august case discuss meet german author brussel septemb decemb german author inform commiss insolv proceed initi compani novemb letter date januari regist receiv januari germani author inform commiss current state insolv proceed ii descript aid beneficiari korn emploi peopl turnov dem million asset dem million qualifi sme mean commun guidelin state aid small medium size enterpris korn base gera thuringia german assist area korn landtechnik amp baumaschinen gmbh gera privatis june manag bui mr reinhard korn purchas price dem million privatis treuhandanstalt tha paid debt compani amount dem million remain debt amount dem million gera rural district measur cover tha scheme korn pursu main activ agricultur technolog repair mainten servic distribut tractor agricultur equip includ equip replac part develop wood grind machin purchas sale commerci vehicl truck includ servic sale replac part accessori environment engin metal construct product wast dispos contain restructur compani underw distinct period restructur restructur place mid mid restructur plan period submit german author explan oper measur period provid restructur plan made oper extend period year work consult commiss receiv statement consult develop potenti plan plan main point reorganis compani busi area seat autohau sell car agricultur engin commerci vehicl landtechnik nutzfahrzeug environment engin korn umwelttechnik busi area seat autohau agricultur engin commerci vehicl creat manag bui mbo sold employe total price dem million mr korn retain busi area environment engin korn umwelttechnik main busi area take account depart mbo reorganis busi area compani suppos set central warehous purchas unit save cost busi area environment engin korn umwelttechnik agricultur engin commerci vehicl landtechnik nutzfahrzeug reorganis achiev increas profit save cost product distribut wood grind machin maintain seat autohau compani intend increas stock car flow amount foreign brand offer earlier financi measur financi measur grant korn mid mid context restructur erp loan grant total dem million ekh loan grant total dem million amp subsidi grant total dem million direct invest aid grant basi inform estim dem million invest allow grant basi inform estim dem million consolid loan land thuringia amount dem million grant basi approv aid scheme restructur firm difficulti loan cover gurante deutsch ausgleichsbank amount dem million base approv aid scheme loan grant sparkass gera greiz mid basi inform estim amount dem million grant public advertis grant amount dem million grant particip fair grant amount dem million grant promot employ grant total dem million measur allegedli grant approv aid scheme concern measur commiss initi formal investig procedur programm loan grant thought programm misus loan award aid scheme longer year loan grant year measur grant approv aid scheme german author inform commiss invest grant made amount dem million measur includ insolv tabl addit sparkass gera greiz reclaim loan amount dem million measur bank reclaim consolid loan amount dem million measur recent financi measur march german author inform commiss measur form consolid loan amount dem million grant octob korn context restructur grant thuringia consolid fund firm difficulti scheme meant rescu restructur approv commiss basi articl term scheme requir observ requir aid exce dem million grant purpos restructur aid grant approv aid scheme notifi individu commiss earlier aid measur support korn purpos restructur exce dem million rescu restructur aid exceed dem million grant previous notifi commiss event earlier measur prove fall approv aid programm gener consid rescu restructur aid latest inform german author loan secur person guarante mr korn amount dem million assign right mr korn person insur polici amount dem million assign compani claim german author inform commiss loan includ insolv tabl mr korn person guarante addit amount dem million restructur plan includ committ sparkass gera greiz defer interest repay rate loan grant measur thüringer aufbaubank agre grant year deferr repay instal consolid loan grant restructur measur market analysi agricultur machin tractor korn activ repair mainten servic distribut tractor agricultur machineri equip replac part develop wood grind machin situat european agricultur machineri industri substanti improv favour situat mask slow deterior import indic industri sector reduc work popul agricultur increas import eu medium term lead slow eros turnov sector constant price year due sustain product increas fewer person emploi sme constitut bulk thousand compani sector europ specialis product type tool intend specialis specialis make depend fluctuat gener economi vulner local crise motor vehicl korn activ purchas sale commerci vehicl truck includ servic sale replac part accessori demand car determiend number factor led cyclic natur sale past decad econom downturn gener trigger slump car registr truck demand highli correl trend industri output invest plant machineri eu truck fleet expect recov past turndown truck replac pattern domin factor determin level demand truck motor vehicl part accessori busi climat strongli ti cyclic perform motor vehicl sector demand improv durabl life expect vehicl compon signific effect demand replac metal product korn produc metal contain wast dispos environment engin econom recess result weak intra eu demand metal contain time industri experienc increas competit eu countri respons eu manufactur start diversifi relat segment increas effort meet custom requir effici environment friendli product evid demand major downstream industri stagnat german industri perform poorli discoveri metal tank corrod insid stimul plastic iii initi formal investig procedur initi formal investig procedur commiss found measur support korn constitut aid mean articl ec treati view extrem vagu inform provid commiss assess complianc measur scheme basi purportedli grant clear aid measur assess ad hoc aid aid intend restructur aid commiss start assess compat articl ec treati commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti quot guidelin quot commiss doubt compat aid measur common market view repeat grant aid justifi basi reason invok german author doubt express coher restructur plan realism assumpt base commiss concern undu distort competit avoid lack inform korn capac develop lack inform restructur cost doubt substanti privat investor contribut preclud commiss take view proportion initi formal investig procedur commiss inform injunct june pursuant articl council regul march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati detail inform individu measur requir germani provid inform unknown aid grant support compani iv assess injunct commiss requir germani provid commiss month suffici inform assess measur investig request german author deadlin extend octob inform subsequ submit remain incomplet pursuant articl regul ec commiss base assess inform aid mean articl ec treati financi measur support korn constitut aid mean articl ec treati deriv state resourc confer advantag korn compani difficulti receiv privat investor korn competitor relev product market europ trade aid threaten distort competit common market aid measur award restructur aid grant approv region aid scheme ekh loan amount dem million erp loan amount dem million amp subsidi amount dem million regard exist aid compli term approv aid scheme constitut exist aid examin decis includ assess proportion aid fall approv region aid scheme invest grant invest allow exact amount unclear total dem million purportedli grant approv aid scheme insuffici level inform provid inform injunct make imposs commiss conclud compli term scheme fall assess ad hoc aid consolid loan land thuringia total dem million commiss initi proceed programm basi grant misus commiss decid compat programm note loan aid scheme award period longer ten year loan present case award period year compat scheme common market loan fulfil condit laid programm assess ad hoc aid guarante dem million cover consolid loan refer recit award aid scheme approv commiss term scheme requir implement restructur plan lead restor long term viabil guarante fall assess restructur aid loan deem aid amount guarante account avoid doubl count measur grant approv aid scheme assess ad hoc aid loan grant sparkass gera greiz mid basi inform estim total dem million grant public advertis grant amount dem million grant particip fair grant amount dem million grant promot employ grant total dem million accord commiss commun member state applic articl eec treati articl commiss direct eec public undertak manufactur sector loan guarante rescu restructur firm difficulti intens set aid measur commiss assess dem million applic derog provid articl ec treati respect ad hoc aid grant restructur commiss assess individu ad hoc state aid directli provis articl ec treati articl ec treati exempt principl incompat state aid common market exempt articl ec treati serv basi aid compat common market aid social charact grant individu consum make good damag caus natur disast except occurr grant economi area feder republ germani affect divis germani exempt region aid provid articl ec treati korn locat german länder fall provis articl primari purpos aid rescu restructur compani difficulti promot econom develop region successfulli rescu restructur compani contribut develop region commiss gener assess aid articl articl exempt provid articl ec treati project common european interest promot cultur heritag conserv applic leav exempt provid articl ec treati commiss assess aid facilit develop econom activ aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest govern specif commun guidelin germani explicitli classifi aid restructur aid commiss base assess commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti commiss set condit govern applic articl derog restor long term viabil grant restructur aid requir realist coher reach restructur plan capabl restor long term viabil health firm reason timescal inform submit german author includ inform compani develop inform show korn slight posit oper result incur loss result continu neg spite fact compani receiv substanti amount aid inform submit refer vagu previou restructur process inform lack substanti analysi difficulti face firm restructur plan describ oper measur relat cost german author explain aid support sound restructur compani long term viabil restor commiss consid requir fulfil undu distort competit restructur includ measur offset advers effect competitor aid involv contrari common interest elig exempt pursuant articl ec treati compani relev market situat eu object assess demand suppli show structur excess product capac restructur plan make signific contribut restructur industri market irrevers reduc capac reduct proportion cost restructur amount aid receiv spite inform injunct german author provid signific inform korn product capac relev market compani oper inform submit mention measur intend reduc product capac relev product market unproblemat respect capac agricultur machineri sector indic employ import develop unfavour direct motor vehicl sector highli cyclic market metal contain undergo result increas altern materi plastic commiss assess suffici measur offset advers effect competitor distort competit exclud criterion guidelin met proportion restructur cost benefit amount intens aid restrict minimum requir carri restructur proport benefit expect commun point view addit beneficiari make substanti contribut restructur cost absenc restructur plan assess aspect imposs inform contribut investor provid restructur commiss consid substanti aid impact liquid aid provid compani surplu cash aggress market distort activ commiss conclud aid grant context restructur justifi restructur plan meet requir set commun guidelin provid commiss consid aid incompat common market aid grant restructur consolid loan amount dem million grant korn context restructur loan base region aid programm thuringia approv aid scheme restructur firm difficulti requir full implement restructur plan meet requir commun guidelin assess restructur aid latest inform provid german author loan secur person guarante mr korn amount dem million call total collater unclear inform call commiss regard contribut privat investor reduct aid equival calcul dem million abovement loan deem state aid sparkass gera greiz thüringer aufbaubank part current restructur defer year interest repay loan grant deferr relat loan grant restructur aid measur account avoid doubl count applic derog provid articl ec treati aid grant restructur derog gener ban aid laid articl ec treati applic aid measur fall assess articl ec treati commun guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin establish gener rule aid measur grant repeat grant aid base reason extern unforese compani lie respons reason invok german author justifi repeat restructur aid loss due product liabil claim reason put forward relat inabl compani sell product develop commiss consid reason stem directli sphere influenc compani consid quot extern quot condit repeat grant aid met distort effect market serv recipi exclud find suffici commiss conclud aid compli commun guidelin restructur aid incompat common market commiss examin condit point guidelin assess capac plan restor compani long term viabil potenti distort competit proportion aid plan cost benefit full implement restor long term viabil reorganis compani busi area reorganis busi area briefli busi plan plan calcul detail plan cover year financi data year implement plan korn cover loss obtain posit oper result matter fact inform submit show turnov increas amount loan receiv latest case law extraordinari incom form aid account assess return viabil aid simpli cover loss commiss consid compani problem insuffici restructur plan plan lai insuffici detail oper measur commiss note consult agre main consult conclus measur restor compani viabil discrep structur compani import market futur earn commiss note agreement futur profit compani final clear link oper measur busi area financi plan calcul underli assumpt made suffici explicit commiss agre german author view restructur plan restor compani viabil undu distort competit aid beneficiari aid increas capac event sector capac capac reduct expect inform injunct explicitli address aspect capac develop compani explain restructur plan includ measur capabl reduc compani product capac regard comment relev product market potenti capac problem sector agricultur machineri motor vehicl metal contain commiss rule undu distort competit proportion aid restructur cost benefit restructur plan cost restructur commiss assess aid receiv proport restructur cost evalu aid limit strict minimum need restructur recent inform provid loan grant restructur secur privat collater investor mr korn amount dem million collater call amount regard contribut privat investor absenc account restructur cost commiss determin investor contribut proport restructur cost case commiss note hypothet sale price plan mbo place accept signific investor contribut mean guidelin extens back comprehens inform realist assumpt underli inform korn mbo plan financi assist state commiss conclud due lack inform unabl assess proportion aid requir commun guidelin met full implement restructur plan novemb compani declar insolv district court gera confirm commiss doubt restor viabil commiss conclud aid grant part restructur justifi unforese extern factor reason compani difficulti restructur plan provid incomplet mean relev requir set commun guidelin met commiss consid aid incompat common market conclus commiss note germani unlawfulli grant aid korn breach articl ec treati basi assess commiss conclud aid incompat common market fulfil condit set commun guidelin aid grant restructur incompat absenc restructur plan grant restructur aid justifi unforese extern factor affect compani restructur plan meet criteria set guidelin adopt decis articl state aid implement germani korn fahrzeug technik gmbh amount eur million dem million incompat common market aid consist measur invest grant basi inform estim amount dem million invest allow grant basi inform estim amount dem million consolid loan thuringia amount dem million grant loan grant sparkass gera greiz mid basi inform estim total dem million grant public amount dem million grant particip fair amount dem million grant promot employ total dem million consolid loan thuringia amount dem million grant articl germani measur recov aid refer articl unlawfulli made restructur aid korn fahrzeug technik gmbh articl due lack inform unclear inform submit german author recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect execut decis aid recov includ interest date dispos beneficiari date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel februari commiss mario monti member commiss oj thuringian loan guarante scheme guarante issu thüringer aufbaubank aid oj oj sg decemb regist nn tha scheme waiv debt stem random alloc cost plan economi aros juli deem state aid answer septemb german author explain busi area agricultur engin amp commerci vehicl difficult sell due unsatisfactori turnov profit sale seat autohau suffer delai rais doubt credibl mbo compani fail introduc product market quot european recoveri programm start scheme quot nn oj oj quot start equiti loan scheme quot nn oj oj quot innov programm quot oj gemeinschaftsaufgab ga mittel thuringia promot region econom structur measur law qualifi region invest aid articl ec treati approv commiss derog provid articl ec treati invest allow act measur act qualifi region invest aid articl ec treati approv commiss derog provid articl ec treati commiss open formal investig procedur scheme quot incorrect applic de minimi rule thuringia sme loan programm quot oj thuringian loan guarante scheme guarante issu thüringer aufbautbank oj recent inform provid germani show loan secur assign compani claim specif risk life assur polici held mr mr korn unknown loan includ insolv tabl collater item utilis aid nn sg februari amount commit panorama eu industri vol nace revis panorama eu industri vol nace revis panorama eu industri vol nace revis panorama eu industri vol nace revis oj oj oj inform loan cover number item collater collater unknown collater appar aid equival amount loan oj commiss commun applic articl ec treati articl eea agreement state aid aviat sector point oj decis commiss aid case nn sg februari reason german author repeat grant aid due loan thuringia consolid fund guarante clear improv turnov profit result compar previou year judgment court instanc septemb case breda fucin ecr ii collater cover loan call commiss note collater right mr korn insur polici assign claim alredai serv secur loan sparkass gera greiz