commiss decis octob aid scheme implement itali firm invest municip affect natur disast notifi document number italian text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite regard comment procedur march commiss receiv complaint prolong law octob municip itali affect natur disast march commiss ask italian author inform extens request deadlin repli extend italian author repli june letter italian author reach commiss juli aid scheme enter forc receiv preliminari approv commiss articl seq treati aid scheme enter regist notifi aid number nn letter septemb commiss inform itali decis initi procedur articl treati respect measur question case regist number commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european union interest parti invit submit comment letter octob italian author ask extens deadlin submit comment letter novemb decemb commiss agre request remind itali comment letter februari receiv februari letter septemb receiv septemb comment receiv interest parti ii detail descript aid scheme legal basi articl decre law decemb convert statut law februari prolong benefit provid articl law octob sole firm invest municip affect natur disast clarifi italian econom financ ministri revenu agenc circular juli municip concern locat area defin prime ministeri decre octob lai provis relat declar state emerg respect effect caus erupt mount etna earthquak provinc catania prime ministeri decre octob lai provis relat declar state emerg respect earthquak octob provinc campobasso prime ministeri decre novemb lai provis relat declar state emerg caus earthquak octob provinc foggia prime ministeri decre novemb provis relat declar state emerg caus except weather flood mudslid liguria lombardi piedmont veneto friuli venezia giulia emilia romagna municip question issu evacu order order ban traffic main access rout municip commiss learnt press articl list municip affect except weather liguria lombardi piedmont veneto friuli venezia giulia emilia romagna drawn prime ministeri order publish italian offici gazett june measur prolong law octob enter forc februari dai public law februari ordinari supplement italian offici gazett februari object scheme design promot invest area affect natur disast list prime ministeri decre refer paragraph recipi firm sector invest municip affect natur disast elig revenu agenc circular juli specifi scheme design promot invest firm difficulti caus natur disast municip locat directli indirectli suffer financi damag state damag deem affect firm municip number build affect evacu order neg effect economi entir municip order ban traffic affect main access rout municip circular question case aid intend firm locat access rout build concern abovement measur form intens aid measur question prolong law octob tax year progress octob confin invest made juli law part invest carri juli invest exceed averag level invest preced year offset taxat incom firm emploi calcul averag level includ invest made year invest highest case real estat invest extens appli invest made tax year take octob juli object scheme scheme design promot invest industri plant build extens renov modernis exist establish complet suspend work purchas equip iii decis initi procedur articl treati decis initi formal investig procedur hereinaft decis initi procedur measur question examin check exempt articl aid intend make good damag caus natur disast except occurr commiss consid measur qualifi derog articl treati pursuant guidelin nation region aid commiss regul ec januari applic articl ec treati state aid small medium size enterpris sme rule laid commun guidelin state aid agricultur sector rule laid guidelin examin state aid fisheri aquacultur analysi measur aid make good damag caus natur disast derog articl treati commiss express doubt initi procedur aid intend sole make good damag caus natur disast question exclus overcompens damag level individu recipi unabl authoris measur aid make good damag caus natur disast except occurr italian author quantifi direct materi damag caus natur disast explain scheme base macroeconom concept damag justifi approach imposs quantifi damag level firm slow procedur make ineffect decis initi procedur commiss consid inform provid italian author suggest measur examin virtu natur oper arrang design make good damag caus natur disast unabl conclud oper arrang aid recipi firm suffer damag damag caus exclus natur disast list prime ministeri decre refer paragraph aid firm confin sole make good damag caus natur disast exclus overcompens damag incur individu recipi exist link aid damag suffer firm demonstr fact view oper arrang scheme question firm suffer damag result natur disast qualifi scheme firm carri invest gear sole make good damag caus natur disast question qualifi aid invest lower averag invest made preced year firm carri invest gear sole make good damag caus natur disast record loss current year qualifi scheme year analysi measur invest aid admiss derog articl treati commiss consid decis initi procedur measur qualifi exempt invest aid derog commiss express doubt aid scheme grant sole area elig region aid italian region aid map period doubt concept invest defin scheme provid point guidelin nation region aid articl regul ec aid intens scheme calcul refer item expenditur make standard base defin point guidelin nation region aid articl regul ec compli region ceil italian region aid map period aid intens laid articl regul ec sme rule cumul aid point guidelin nation region aid articl regul ec compli principl necess aid refer point guidelin nation region aid articl regul ec met order ensur product invest aid viabl sound recipi contribut financ provid point guidelin nation region aid articl regul ec rule laid commun guidelin state aid agricultur sector guidelin examin state aid fisheri aquacultur compli iv comment receiv itali repli decis initi procedur itali inform comment main point summaris comment analysi measur aid make good damag caus natur disast italian author point territori concern measur compris municip list prime ministeri decre octob octob novemb articl decre octob aid grant sole municip affect flood evacu order order ban traffic main access rout issu municip list prime ministeri order doubt aid recipi firm suffer damag damag caus exclus natur disast italian author repli damag deem affect taxpay municip number build affect evacu order neg effect economi entir municip order ban traffic affect main access rout municip italian author conclud main aid recipi firm suffer damag place busi locat road build affect abovement evacu order link damag suffer aid grant italian author consid treati rule possibl take account damag area scheme base macroeconom concept damag level demand effici speed damag firm assess individu italian author macroeconom data demonstr budget alloc scheme smaller extent damag italian author point case commiss authoris aid assist recoveri sector offset indirect form damag confirm letter septemb measur base macroeconom approach firm ask present certif statement order verifi actual damag suffer recipi tax author subsequ carri check certif evid firm entitl receiv aid account locat elig area firm certifi aid exce damag suffer overcompens comment measur invest aid analysi compat aid derog articl treati carri manner paragraph decis italian author comment area concern measur identifi directli exclus refer natur disast point compat aid assess light articl treati aid intend make good damag caus natur disast except occurr letter septemb italian author comment aid regard compat common market virtu derog obviat conduct analysi light derog guidelin assess aid element measur order assess measur provid scheme constitut aid mean articl treati determin confer advantag recipi advantag confer state measur question affect competit liabl affect intra commun trade requir applic articl treati possibl scheme confer advantag specif recipi determin recipi enjoi econom advantag obtain normal market condit avoid cost born firm financi resourc advantag confer specif categori firm possibl set part invest tax confer econom advantag recipi taxabl incom amount tax incom reduc compar firm pai addit aid firm oper invest specif area itali favour grant firm area requir applic articl aid grant state state resourc present case state resourc take form revenu forgon public author reduct incom tax reduc tax revenu accru state fourth requir applic articl treati aid distort threaten distort competit liabl affect trade member sate present case measur threaten distort competit strengthen financi posit freedom action recipi firm compar competitor qualifi effect make felt intra commun trade trade member state affect measur distort competit affect trade member state recipi export part product member state analog export domest output favour firm member state chanc export product italian market true member state grant aid firm oper servic distribut industri measur examin principl prohibit articl regard compat common market qualifi derog laid treati commiss consid aid grant scheme constitut state aid condit laid commiss regul ec de minimi rule forc aid grant met unlaw scheme view fact measur enter forc commiss regret italian author fulfil oblig notifi scheme accord articl treati compat measur common market conclud measur question constitut aid mean articl treati commiss aid compat common market mean articl treati applic derog provid treati commiss take view aid qualifi derog articl aid social charact aid cover articl obviou reason derog articl applic applic derog articl commiss refer doubt express connect decis initi procedur take note statement made italian author procedur effect aid question aim object cover provis member state concern provid inform enabl commiss assess compat scheme light derog assess scheme standpoint present decis find prejudic possibl aid grant scheme declar compat individu examin cover exempt regul commiss consid measur qualifi derog articl aid make good damag caus natur disast except occurr note itali procedur stress purpos aid aid make good damag caus natur disast articl treati aid grant make good damag caus natur disast except occurr commiss consist view volcan erupt earthquak flood landslid constitut natur disast mean articl scheme question aid grant make good damag suffer firm result natur disast affect area itali disast area concern defin administr instrument italian author confirm letter septemb measur base macroeconom approach treati line commiss standard practic clear direct link event caus damag state aid intend remedi link establish level firm macroeconom level indirect form damag commiss commun european parliament council european commun respons flood austria germani applic countri state quot compens indirect form damag caus flood product delai electr cut difficulti deliv product due blockag transport rout clear causal link damag flood establish full compens quot view macroeconom approach measur implement italian author identifi clear causal link damag compens natur disast indirect damag link establish level firm macroeconom level present case scheme benefit firm carri invest excess threshold establish averag preced year municip identifi italian author larg heavili popul characteris signific level econom activ milan turin genoa clear aid recipi suffer direct damag definit proof indirect damag evid damag caus sole natur disast refer italian author aid mechan amount grant recipi bear relat damag suffer depend volum invest carri period volum invest preced year exist taxabl incom condit recipi suffer damag caus natur disast issu amount aid exce amount damag conclud formal investig procedur allai commiss doubt scheme question constitut aid incompat common market letter septemb italian author state firm certif statement ascertain actual damag suffer firm subsequ carri check rule specif case aid grant scheme satisfi condit regard compat common market italian author check recipi firm order verifi exist clear direct link natur disast question state aid intend make good damag make rule certainti overcompens damag suffer individu firm order rule overcompens italian author requir insur payment recipi deduct aid grant ensur cumul aid scheme question aid measur order avoid overcompens damag decis concern scheme enforc forthwith recoveri aid grant unlawfulli declar incompat common market commiss note neg decis aid scheme prejudg possibl aid grant scheme regard state aid consid compat common market ow characterist individu grant cover de minimi rule aid grant decis declar aid compat exempt regul vi conclus commiss find itali unlawfulli implement aid question breach articl treati basi assess commiss find scheme question incompat common market satisfi condit exempt aid make good damag caus natur disast except occurr articl derog claim itali articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati neg decis case unlaw aid commiss decid member state concern measur recov aid beneficiari commiss requir recoveri aid contrari gener principl commun law recoveri present case contrari principl commiss note italian author recipi invok principl itali measur recov aid recipi except individu case accord paragraph decis satisfi condit compat common market derog articl treati end itali requir aid recipi repai aid month notif decis aid recov includ interest calcul accord commiss regul ec april implement council regul ec lai detail rule applic articl ec treati itali send commiss form report progress recov aid draw list recipi concern recoveri actual measur effect effect recoveri aid addit month notif decis send document prove recoveri unlaw incompat aid recipi circular recoveri order issu adopt decis articl scheme grant state aid firm carri invest municip affect natur disast list articl decre law decemb convert law februari prolong firm benefit provid articl law octob unlawfulli implement itali breach articl treati incompat common market prejudic articl articl itali withdraw aid scheme refer articl continu produc effect articl individu aid grant scheme refer articl compat common market mean articl treati extent exce net damag suffer recipi result natur disast refer articl decre law decemb account insur payment amount receiv measur articl individu aid grant scheme refer articl meet condit set articl incompat common market articl itali measur recov recipi aid refer articl itali suspend aid payment date notif decis recoveri effect delai accord procedur nation law provid effect enforc decis aid recov includ interest date dispos recipi date recoveri interest calcul basi provis chapter regul ec itali order recipi aid refer articl repai month date notif decis aid unlawfulli grant interest articl month date notif decis itali inform commiss measur compli herewith complet questionnair attach decis deadlin send commiss document demonstr initi procedur recov unlaw aid recipi articl decis address italian republ brussel octob commiss mario monti member commiss oj footnot oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj judgment european court justic juli case french republ commiss european commun seb ecr paragraph judgment european court justic march case italian republ commiss european commun ecr paragraph oj state aid case nn nn case refer italian author case commiss identifi link level econom oper document final oj regul amend act access oj