council regul ec juli impos definit countervail duti collect definit provision countervail duti impos import sulphanil acid origin india council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec octob protect subsidis import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur commiss regul ec quot provision regul quot impos provision countervail duti import sulphanil acid origin india commiss regul ec quot provision anti dump regul quot impos provision anti dump duti import sulphanil acid origin peopl republ china india subsequ procedur subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi decid impos provision countervail duti number interest parti submit comment write interest parti request hear grant opportun heard commiss commiss continu seek verifi inform deem definit find parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit countervail duti definit collect amount secur provision countervail duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written argument submit parti account review provision find basi inform gather main find set provision regul confirm product concern product product concern subsequ public provision regul number interest parti claim definit product concern incorrect argu technic purifi grade sulphanil acid substanti term puriti properti applic claim grade sulphanil acid consid homogen product treat distinct product purpos investig support assert argu insuffici interchang grade sulphanil acid whilst accept purifi grade applic technic grade sulphanil acid level impur contain notabl anilin residu impur made technic grade sulphanil acid unsuit product optic brighten food dye recal purifi grade sulphanil acid result purif technic grade sulphanil acid process remov impur purif process alter molecular properti compound react chemic technic purifi grade share basic chemic characterist fact interchang direct applic concern impur consid suffici justif purifi technic grade constitut product treat separ investig whilst accept purif process add addit cost product process recal account make fair comparison grade produc commun industri import countri concern purpos calcul level price undercut injuri elimin level consid comment made interest parti definit product concern suffici alter find issu reach provision stage definit conclud grade sulphanil acid treat singl product purpos present proceed product element brought attent commiss lead alter conclus reach provision stage sulphanil acid produc sold commun produc produc india export commun product provision find product set recit provision regul confirm subsidi find made provision regul countervail subsidi obtain export produc confirm expressli state bellow export process zone epz export orient unit eou comment receiv head find set recit provision regul confirm duti entitl passbook scheme depb post export govern india quot goi quot claim agreement subsidi countervail measur ascm infring spirit letter commiss investig practic utilis depb case argu commiss assess benefit scheme incorrect excess duti drawback consid subsidi accord articl regul ec quot basic regul quot order establish subsidi exist examin excess exist undertaken commiss approach order establish depb post exportbasi constitut countervail subsidi calcul amount benefit pursuant articl ii basic regul conclud scheme involv financi contribut goi govern revenu import duti import due collect benefit confer mean articl basic regul recipi export produc reliev pai normal import duti depb subsidi conting export perform countervail articl basic regul except provid basic regul appli articl ii except inter alia drawback substitut drawback scheme conform strict rule laid annex item annex ii definit rule drawback annex iii definit rule substitut drawback analysi reveal depb post export basi drawback substitut drawback scheme scheme lack built oblig import good consum product export good annex ii basic regul ensur requir annex item met addition verif system place check import consum product process substitut drawback scheme import good quantiti characterist domest sourc input export product annex iii basic regul lastli export produc elig depb benefit import input order obtain benefit export simpli export good show input materi import export produc procur input local import good input entitl depb benefit depb post export basi conform provis annex iii except subsidi definit appli countervail benefit remiss total import duti due import basic regul excess remiss import duti basi calcul amount benefit case bona fide drawback substitut drawback scheme establish depb post export basi fall categori benefit total remiss import duti suppos excess remiss duti remiss deem excess case reason claim goi accept provision find countervail scheme calcul benefit set recit provision regul confirm incom tax exempt scheme it cooper compani claim calcul benefit scheme actual amount tax paid compani fulli account minimum altern tax mat includ origin calcul prepaid incom tax previou year claim found valid benefit compani recalcul found neglig advanc licenc advanc releas order aro scheme goi submit aro legitim extens legitim substitut drawback scheme advanc licenc goi prove fact unbreak link licenc gain subsequ exchang aro import input manufactur export good system organis administ goi prevent possibl excess drawback occur respect goi argu substitut drawback scheme requir compani obtain duti drawback benefit import input consum exact input product relev export good goi compani consum domest procur input manufactur export product provid consum equival volum input benefit remiss import duti goi argu user aro exchang input product procur indigen advanc licenc advanc licenc obtain refer export product consum match quantiti input address argument recal advanc licenc export manufactur export merchant export enabl import input product export duti free advanc licenc measur unit authoris import term quantiti term case rate determin allow duti free purchas establish product includ product cover investig basi standard input output norm sion input item advanc licenc item product relev export finish product advanc licenc holder intend sourc input indigen sourc lieu direct import option sourc aro case advanc licenc valid aro endors supplier deliveri item accord quot export import polici quot document endors aro entitl supplier benefit deem export deem export drawback refund termin excis duti case cooper compani made limit advanc licenc import duti free input compani convert licenc aro endors local supplier obtain commerci benefit commerci benefit aro correspond amount duti aro enabl supplier forgo deem export drawback facil acknowledg duti drawback system refund drawback import charg input consum product process product export product domest input qualiti characterist substitut import input instanc allow compani case shortag duti free input domest input incorpor export good stage import quantiti duti free input context exist verif system procedur import enabl case goi ensur demonstr quantiti input drawback claim exce quantiti similar product export form drawback import charg excess origin levi import input question state provision regul verif establish system procedur place confirm input sourc aro consum product process export product excess benefit import duti occur mean item annex annex ii iii basic regul export oblig consum input sourc aro product process remiss import duti limit payabl good consum product process export product condit good consum product process export product benefit remiss fulfil conclud aro element advanc licenc scheme permit remiss drawback scheme mean basic regul addit aro consid duti drawback scheme appear requir import input context scheme consid bona fide duti drawback scheme case import element exist link import input export good quantiti import input export good reason claim accept provision find countervail scheme calcul benefit confirm packag scheme incent psi govern maharashtra state provision regul psi scheme compani invest design geograph area jurisdict state maharashtra compani locat area level benefit area concern scheme specif accord articl articl basic regul goi compani concern claim scheme countervail subsidi meet criteria articl basic regul qualifi quot green light quot region subsidi grant state maharashtra articl order subject countervail measur subsidi disadvantag region territori countri origin export compli criteria notabl pursuant gener framework region develop ii region concern design contigu geograph area defin econom administr ident iii regard disadvantag basi neutral object criteria spell law offici document criteria includ measur econom develop base factor incom capita household incom capita gdp capita case averag territori countri origin export concern unemploy rate measur year period averag territori countri origin export concern govern maharashtra letter ministri commerc industri goi state psi appli entir contigu region advanc region compris mumbai thane belt state maharashtra disadvantag region belt characteris capita incom state averag figur provid show capita incom region psi appli figur maharashtra state figur substanti support evid event examin green light claim reveal capita incom state maharashtra measur period year higher nation averag india clear benchmark measur capita incom countri origin export state region basi clear incom capita elig region maharashtra region averag nation averag incom capita region fall green light categori basi criterion unemploy criterion inform provid indian author basi conclud case scheme meet criteria articl basic regul provision find countervail scheme confirm calcul subsidi amount set recit provision regul goi compani concern claim amount benefit obtain tax deferr incent alloc total sale investig period quot ip quot total domest sale ip provision alloc benefit compani reason sole attribut domest sale addit brought attent commiss factor calcul benefit obtain compani concern sale tax exempt incent inflat claim basi alloc benefit obtain tax deferr incent consid valid commiss amend calcul subsidi amount relat sale tax exempt incent take account comment interest parti detail review provision find provision calcul adjust result reduct amount subsidi basi revis calcul amount subsidi compani obtain scheme amount countervail subsidi amount countervail subsidi calcul accord provis basic regul express ad valorem investig export produc level cooper india high view high level cooper decid set residu subsidi margin level subsidi found cooper export produc gt tabl gt commun industri public provision regul number interest parti queri definit commun industri stand term articl basic regul suggest complain produc sorochimi chime fine support commun produc quimig lodg complaint recal whilst quimig parti origin complaint express support proceed initi stage fulli cooper investig respons claim interest parti reiter support proceed investig element brought attent commiss lead alter earlier find provision find definit commun industri stand detail recit provision regul confirm injuri preliminari remark interest parti question commiss establish figur import sulphanil acid commun commun consumpt market share claim insuffici disclosur commiss find import volum term right defenc imped note inform miss public version complaint result complaint meet standard detail articl basic regul note articl basic regul inform submit confid parti investig treat investig author long inform concern warrant treatment recal sulphanil acid manufactur small number produc world reason confidenti disclos precis inform relat import product commun countri export produc purpos disclosur index figur explanatori narr made interest parti relat item interest parti rais issu insuffici disclosur demonstr inform made summaris form enabl defend right argument respect reject import concern interest parti suggest figur increas import note provision regul mislead claim number produc withdrawn market user commun oblig purchas sulphanil acid world market lead sharp rise import volum claim reject number reason instanc addit evid level import submit alter find reach provision stage point similarli whilst acknowledg recit provision regul import india expect continu plai signific role meet demand commun note commun industri subject injuri effect subsidis import put effect expans plan satisfi larger part commun demand light provision find import commun india level price undercut note recit provision regul confirm situat commun industri accord articl basic regul examin impact subsidis import commun industri includ evalu relev econom factor indic bear state subsequ provision disclosur number interest parti question manner commiss reach provision determin injuri indic show posit develop suggest increas commun industri product sale capac utilis analysi period januari june prove suffer injuri interest parti claim commiss fail make proper assess wage cost requir articl basic regul recal articl basic regul econom factor indic list aforement articl necessarili decis determin injuri true indic relat quantiti produc sold commun industri show posit develop light fact commun consumpt sulphanil acid increas analysi period reduct number supplier market due closur commun produc importantli recal commun industri suffer injuri form price depress price suppress averag sell price declin sharpli pressur exert increas volum import market evid subsequ commun industri increas averag sell price demand commun market increas fail achiev level enabl cover full cost product loss continu incur ip regard argument rais wage note number worker emploi sorochimi decreas analysi period averag employ cost employe increas due fact chang mix employe period gener wage inflat regard quimig note base year index compani produc sulphanil acid began product worker engag full time activ extra dai work onward compani note wage emploi sulphanil acid activ effect import concern wage consid indic injuri view provision find commun industri suffer materi injuri mean articl basic regul detail recit provision regul confirm causat gener comment commiss conclus causat injuri interest parti argu commun industri partli respons injuri suffer parti question qualiti sorochimi manag product custom servic highlight fact import sulphanil acid analysi period parti alleg injuri suffer sorochimi attribut busi activ glue experienc signific difficulti ip regard situat quimig compani form part commun industri argu decis enter market low price strategi start phase contribut alleg injuri final claim commun industri meet stringent environment regul higher labour transport cost export produc india implic import origin countri competit advantag made injuri price investig show sorochimi financi difficulti link excess low price prevail market gain custom analysi period adapt product meet compani oblig purchas quantiti product concern analysi period order meet exist custom requir product equip undergo essenti repair consid sorochimi contribut injuri similarli recal except cost relat compani difficulti glue busi exclud current investig link product concern reflect injuri indic provision regul note recit provision regul quimig decis enter market time price sulphanil acid commun market higher quimig establish market time increas demand commun number supplier sulphanil acid commun note compani oblig offer price similar dump subsidis import order establish market gain market share small size meant price taker price setter market share decreas slightli ip import india increas volum indic found deterior situat commun industri due excess intra commun industri competit regard allegedli higher cost commun industri oblig meet term compli environment regul item recal competit advantag import concern account determin normal provision find causat set recit provision regul confirm commun interest public provision regul interest parti question commiss determin light sorochimi administr commun industri viabl competit recal sorochimi oblig seek protect creditor difficulti glue busi pressur sulphanil acid activ commerci court charlevil mézièr appoint administr overse compani trade activ grant compani period time prepar restructur plan period time recent extend januari absenc unforeseen event compani continu exist futur posit benefit imposit definit measur provision find imposit measur interest commun industri note recit provision regul confirm number interest parti claim commiss fail make object assess situat user take account increas commun industri price follow imposit measur claim measur commun interest product capac commun industri insuffici meet commun demand duopolist situat base commun produc result closur market import india prc subject parallel anti dump investig respect claim commiss fail account interest object manner determin imposit measur recal provision stage commiss made detail analysi main user sector optic brighten concret addit dye color produc analysi includ assess impact measur cost basi price import concern increas line propos measur time due allow made calcul maximum increas price sulphanil acid sold commun industri basi price increas level similar import concern imposit measur take account oper fairli high rate capac utilis ip element submit interest parti alter provision find increas manufactur cost user industri suppli competit situat commun market note current product capac commun industri satisfi region commun demand purpos measur event close market import india ensur made subsidis injuri price expect import countri includ india continu enter market time measur ensur continu sulphanil acid product commun result user choic domest foreign supplier competit supplier maintain stress commun industri plan increas output invest facil capit expenditur justifi occur injuri effect subsidis import remov light provision find imposit measur contrari interest commun note recit provision regul confirm anti subsidi measur injuri elimin level absenc submiss point methodolog establish injuri margin set recit provision regul confirm definit measur injuri elimin level higher subsidi margin establish definit measur base duti appli india compani definit collect provision duti view magnitud subsidis found light serious injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision countervail duti definit collect rate duti definit impos amount secur provision duti excess definit duti releas undertak subsequ imposit provision measur sole cooper export produc india offer price undertak accord articl basic regul agre sell product concern price level effect elimin injuri effect subsidis compani provid commiss regular detail inform export commun mean undertak monitor effect commiss sale structur export produc commiss consid risk circumv agre undertak limit view offer undertak accept commiss decis ec order ensur effect respect monitor undertak request releas free circul pursuant undertak present relev custom author exempt duti condit present commerci invoic inform list annex regul invoic present correspond product concern present custom rate countervail duti payabl note event breach withdraw undertak suspect breach countervail duti impos pursuant articl basic regul adopt regul articl definit countervail duti impos import sulphanil acid fall cn code taric code origin india rate definit countervail duti applic net free commun frontier price duti notwithstand paragraph definit duti appli import releas free circul accord articl provis forc custom duti appli articl import taric addit code produc directli export ship invoic compani name compani commun act import exempt countervail duti impos articl provid import conform paragraph gt tabl gt import mention paragraph exempt duti condit commerci invoic element inform list annex present member state custom author present declar releas free circul ii good declar present custom correspond precis descript commerci invoic articl amount secur provision countervail duti impos pursuant regul ec definit collect rate duti definit impos amount secur excess definit rate countervail duti releas articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel juli council presid møller oj oj oj page offici journal annex element commerci invoic refer articl head quot commerci invoic accompani good subject undertak quot compani mention articl issu commerci invoic commerci invoic number date issu commerci invoic taric addit code good invoic custom clear commun frontier exact descript good includ product code number pcn quot pa quot quot ps quot quot ta quot technic physic specif pcn quot pa quot quot ps quot white free flow powder quot ta quot grei free flow powder compani product code number cpc applic cn code quantiti tonn descript term sale includ price tonn applic payment term applic deliveri term total discount rebat compani act import invoic issu directli compani offici compani issu commerci invoic sign declar quot undersign certifi sale direct export european commun good cover invoic made scope term undertak offer kokan synthet amp chemic pvt guruprasad gokhal road dadar mumbai india accept european commiss decis ec declar inform provid invoic complet correct quot