council regul ec februari impos definit anti dump duti import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin croatia ukrain collect definit provision duti impos council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe provision measur regul ec hereinaft refer quot provision regul quot commiss impos provision anti dump duti import commun seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin croatia ukrain subsequ procedur imposit provision anti dump duti interest parti request grant opportun heard parti inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti definit collect level duti amount secur provision duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur oral written comment submit interest parti consid definit find chang product concern product product concern recal recit provision regul product concern seamless pipe iron alloi steel kind oil ga pipelin extern diamet exceed mm seamless tube circular cross section iron alloi steel cold drawn cold roll tube circular cross section iron alloi steel extern diamet exceed mm hereinaft refer quot seamless tube quot claim repeat seamless tube divid separ product concern commerci steel grade tube steel line pipe oil ga applic injuri suffer commun industri analys separ product alleg distinct base ground commerci tube line pipe interchang specif certif requir oil ga applic argu higher cost produc line pipe preclud sale oil ga applic alleg commerci tube build infrastructur applic line pipe oil ga industri product sold sale channel line pipe sold directli end user trader found seamless tube basic physic technic characterist wide rang type vari extern diamet wall thick steel grade technic specif clear divid line found exist investig show type seamless tube sold trader end user clear distinct sale channel se relev establish final seamless tube found essenti industri construct automobil oil petroleum industri power plant boiler construct pneumat hydraul engin accept user type seamless tube consid basic applic type seamless tube intend specif applic oil pipelin pipe specif applic found commerci tube wide rang applic show exist larg degre competit interchang product type conclus provision find seamless tube commerci tube line pipe form singl product confirm product recal recit provision regul commiss found seamless tube import countri concern seamless tube produc sold commun commun industri domest sold croatian market alik basic physic technic characterist found essenti claim commun produc seamless tube import ukrain manufactur standard commun industri specif test requir appli commun produc seamless tube meant product process investig shown commun industri ukrainian export produc similar nation intern standard inform provid ukrainian export show seamless tube export commun commerci tube line pipe conform industri standard din api astm produc commun industri view provision find seamless tube import countri concern seamless tube produc sold commun commun industri domest sold croatian market product mean articl regul ec hereinaft refer quot basic regul quot confirm dump croatia adopt provision measur argument submit calcul normal determin export price comparison normal export price establish dump margin find set recit provision regul confirm dump margin residu margin remain level ukrain normal public provision regul import object select croatia market economi countri purpos establish normal ukrain import argu cost energi input croatia higher ukrain croatian domest market monopolis domin sole produc insuffici evid put forward justifi repres croatian domest sale consid argument higher croatian cost relev ukrain market economi comparison natur unreli relev context ukrainian produc absolut compar advantag compar croatia effici energi case select croatia unreason altern brazil reject ground price brazilian market high due domin produc croatia import product concern export element competit domest market addit domest sale repres amount total ukrainian export commun volum final effort made investig altern brazil unit state america czech republ cooper forthcom countri argument put forward methodolog calcul normal find set recit provision regul confirm export price export produc object fact establish export price commiss account sale relat import commun ground inform submit found unreli evid submit contradict find set recit provision regul confirm comparison export produc reiter claim adjust differ physic characterist lower standard ukrainian tube industri compar commun industri claim reject provision stage insuffici substanti export produc fail back argument absenc inform find set recit provision regul confirm dump margin provision find dump margin confirm ukrain injuri definit commun industri absenc inform provision find definit commun industri recit provision regul confirm import commun countri concern cumul croatian export produc argu import croatia cumul assess origin ukrain respect claim volum import croatia investig period hereinaft refer quot ip quot substanti lower ukrain price import higher claim croatian export price set ukrainian import commun market dump margin found substanti countri volum import countri increas period examin reach signific level case found de minimi level price import found price seamless tube countri significantli undercut price commun industri ip seamless tube countri sold sale channel compar sale condit compet tube sold commun industri provision find appropri cumul assess import croatia ukrain confirm price dump import price undercut margin croatia ukrain recalcul light evid submit interest parti price product categori group seamless tube purpos price comparison croatia revis weight averag price undercut express percentag commun industri price amount ukrain revis weight averag price undercut express percentag commun industri price amount situat commun industri preliminari remark public provision regul commiss decemb found commun produc part commun industri present proceed infring articl ec treati engag anti competit practic conclud dalmin mannesmannröhren werk vallourec particip agreement provid observ respect domest market seamless tube notabl oil countri tubular good line pipe decis examin order determin injuri found suffer commun industri deriv dump import caus conduct commun produc note period find investig base januari octob period anti competit practic found place view fact practic place period prior consid proceed increas volum import croatia ukrain dump price coincid deterior situat commun industri conclud anti competit conduct commun produc contribut injuri suffer commun industri current proceed extent break causal link injuri suffer commun industri import concern mean articl basic regul argument rais interest parti provision find ukrainian export produc argu commun industri suffer materi injuri mean articl basic regul ip indic product capac utilis improv market share remain stabl question provision find profit commun industri claim support press articl quot improv financi result commun seamless tube produc mention articl basic regul factor list provis give decis guidanc commun industri suffer injuri mean articl basic regul improv situat commun industri ip product capac utilis light anti dump measur impos import seamless tube czech republ hungari poland romania russia slovak republ regul ec intend effect anti dump measur remov injuri found suffer commun industri note ip profit achiev commun industri remain level lower industri expect normal condit competit absenc dump import respect reliabl profit figur note correspond inform provid commun industri investig verifi spot term profit figur submit ukrainian export produc note includ product cover investig relat period period examin present investig market share found commun industri unabl regain previous lost market share commun industri fulli benefit earlier imposit definit measur import origin czech republ hungari poland romania russia slovak republ view provision find materi injuri suffer commun industri confirm causat absenc inform provision find recit provision regul confirm commun interest view find commiss mention paragraph examin imposit anti dump measur rais concern competit market light fact anti competit practic found place period prior consid proceed reason conclud imposit anti dump measur present proceed impact competit market futur absenc inform commun interest provision find recit provision regul confirm anti dump measur injuri elimin level methodolog establish injuri margin recit provision regul confirm injuri margin revis account comment made interest parti recit subsequ disclosur provision find set gt tabl gt form level definit measur conclus reach dump injuri causat commun interest call definit measur view divers product type anti dump duti form ad valorem duti accord articl basic regul export produc level duti base lower injuri dump margin duti express percentag free commun frontier price amount gt tabl gt subsequ imposit provision anti dump measur export produc croatia export produc ukrain conjunct ukrainian author offer price undertak type accept commiss produc central eastern europ regul ec elimin injuri achiev mean price undertak cover import agre volum threshold ad valorem duti levi import threshold ensur quantiti import exempt ad valorem duti exce quantiti price undertak exempt anti dump duti condit present member state custom servic valid product certif identifi produc exact descript good sign declar produc order enabl commiss monitor complianc undertak effect produc agre provid commiss regular detail inform sale export commun copi product certif subsequ verif ukrain undertak offer ukrainian export produc joint reflect ukrain statu market economi countri underpin guarante ukrainian author ensur adequ monitor regard anti dump duti free threshold price undertak volum threshold ad valorem duti remaind import consid adequ mean remov injuri suffer commun industri event breach suspect breach undertak commiss swiftli impos provision definit duti accord articl basic regul commiss accept undertak collect provision duti view magnitud dump margin found export produc light level injuri caus commun industri consid amount secur provision anti dump duti provision regul definit collect rate duti definit impos adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import origin croatia ukrain seamless pipe iron alloi steel kind oil ga pipelin extern diamet exceed mm fall cn code seamless tube circular cross section iron alloi steel cold drawn cold roll fall cn code tube circular cross section iron alloi steel extern diamet exceed mm fall cn code rate duti applic net free commun frontier price import product paragraph gt tabl gt provis forc custom duti appli articl import exempt anti dump duti impos articl provid produc sold export commun compani list paragraph offer undertak accept commiss provid condit paragraph met declar releas free circul present exempt duti condit present compet member state custom servic valid origin product certif issu compani list paragraph product certif conform requir certif set undertak accept commiss essenti element list annex product certif refer paragraph present month date issu quantiti present member state custom servic import commun free anti dump duti exce stipul certif quantiti stipul certif exceed excess subject duti declar relev taric addit code articl import accompani product certif declar taric addit code gt tabl gt articl member state report commiss pursuant articl regul ec releas free circul year month import cn taric taric addit code type measur countri origin quantiti anti dump duti member state import serial number product certif articl amount secur provision anti dump duti impos pursuant regul ec collect rate duti definit impos amount secur excess definit rate anti dump duti releas articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european commun regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel februari council presid gama oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj annex main element product certif refer articl number certif identif show certif origin copi date expiri certif text quot product certif issu compani pursuant articl council regul export european compani taric addit code taric addit code seamless steel pipe tube quot case import ukrain quot product certif authent ministri ukrain monitor pursuant articl council regul export european commun taric addit code taric addit code seamless steel pipe tube quot full address relev export produc includ telephon fax number identif number nation registr number incorpor compani full address custom relev export produc includ telephon fax number product sold invoic export produc number commerci invoic product certif relat exact descript good includ product descript suffici identifi product ident product descript invoic cn code quantiti metric tonn case import croatia offici compani respons issu certif sign declar quot undersign certifi sale export european commun good cover certif made scope term undertak relev export produc permit volum anti dump duti free import european commun set undertak accept commiss pursuant decis ec decis declar inform provid certif complet correct quot case import ukrain sign declar export produc quot undersign certifi sale export european commun good cover certif made scope term undertak relev export produc permit volum anti dump duti free import european commun set undertak accept commiss pursuant decis ec decis declar inform provid certif complet correct quot case import ukrain space stamp signatur authoris person ministri ukrain space compet author commun box certif languag croatia languag countri produc english french german croatia languag ukrain languag countri produc english