commiss decis juli aid grant italian govern eni lanerossi italian text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun subparagraph articl thereof notic parti concern submit comment provid articl regard comment lanerossi spa state hold compani ent nazional idrocarburi eni purpos creat vertic fulli integr textil group resolv econom financi problem number privat textil cloth compani purpos turn lanerossi year consider restructur effort return subsidiari viabil transfer privat sector subsidiari remain loss make continu receiv financi assist form loss compens italian govern order remain busi case subsidiari lanerossi spa subsector men outer wear lanerossi confezioni arezzo macerata orvieto intesa maratea nocera gagliano confezioni di filottrano ancona confezioni monti pescara yearli loss firm grew lit billion lit billion commiss receiv offici complaint european associ cloth industri aeih textil industri feder consid continu compens oper loss subsidiari consider distort competit commun basi detail examin situat develop state own manufactur men outer wear take account inform provid italian govern respect commiss view intervent favour enterpris consid aid mean articl eec treati letter june inform italian govern measur grant exempt incompat rule articl provid assist grant limit period condit restructur programm present commiss carri purpos reduc capac compani concern return viabil financi support short term subsequ develop state own manufactur men outer wear close commiss letter italian govern date consid subsidiari lanerossi sector lebol spa financi assist order compens loss match restructur effort implement implement shortli kind exclud simpl rescu oper oper aid commiss conclud financi assist benefit derog articl eec treati regard compat common market basi monitor progress implement restructur programm firm decemb commiss confirm earlier posit close file lebor spa definit abovement subsidiari eni lanerossi econom financi result achiev end show restructur effort past year success evid factori continu suffer structur difficulti spite constant support public fund loss reach lit billion equal restructur programm year made commiss italian govern compani expect continu reli heavili state intervent public fund order compens loss letter refer commiss state busi mark strong competit overcapac commun level depress price heavi intra commun trade artifici mainten public financi assist small amount product export increas difficulti undertak receipt state aid commiss account social region import factori rais object aid grant end express doubt financi assist public fund order cover oper deficit subsidiari futur regard compat orderli function common market commiss inform italian govern futur intervent kind oblig measur remind italian govern articl eec treati exist oblig member state inform commiss suffici time enabl submit comment plan grant alter aid request italian govern week receipt letter intent respect telex june italian govern inform commiss notifi futur intervent favour men outer wear factori pursuant articl eec treati receiv inform factori continu suffer consider loss commiss letter juli remind italian govern letter year repeat aid favour subsidiari eni lanerossi view histori situat market concern regard compat common market letter novemb italian govern confirm state aid envisag favour factori regard eni lanerossi manag unrestructur abovement restructur programm year execut ii subsequ press report suggest italian govern confirm factori remain busi continu suffer loss avoid bankruptci receiv state aid commiss repeatedli request italian govern submit inform real situat respect letter august italian govern transmit commiss summari restructur programm men outer wear factori eni lanerossi document appear manag eni lanerossi continu factori restructur continu stai busi oper deficit oper year reach lit billion reduct subsequ increas capit loss compens public financ summari restructur programm obviou futur year loss compens requir factori expect break quickli appear abovement compens place end fix italian govern definit end restructur effort factori scrutini aid grant form loss compens commiss consid notifi illeg italian govern fail fulfil oblig articl eec treati commiss view intervent favour subsidiari eni lanerossi consid rescu aid view factori financi econom record situat commiss polici rescu aid pend restructur plan grant short period form credit loan market rate member state inform letter januari aid question meet condit set commiss commiss consid aid grant contravent decis assist factori end onward commun italian govern letter juli repeat reconfirm letter decemb commiss view aid grant possibl envisag promot develop commun point view adequ counteract trade distort effect situat sector concern face problem structur overcapac depress price high level intra commun trade consid sensit subsector textil cloth industri commiss consid aid regard compat common market benefit derog provid articl eec treati commiss initi procedur provid subparagraph articl eec treati letter decemb gave italian govern notic submit comment member state inform februari interest parti februari iii receiv remind commiss date februari request obtain deadlin submit comment procedur initi italian govern letter point tendenc reduc loss factori question observ equal workforc reduc fact factori privat sector time practic bankrupt impli restructur effort succe short period realiz factori unrestructur reconvert activ time ensur lanerossi activ endang reach satisfactori result accept longer period time commiss request stop intervent favour compani immedi destroi past effort social consequ letter italian govern view state intervent form gift capit favour eni partial lanerossi constitut state aid altogeth view italian legisl loss compens immedi sharehold order avoid bankruptci notif pursuant articl eec treati imposs final italian govern refer market export share factori aid favour compani effect trade competit bilater meet held june italian govern announc addit inform programm restructur part factori reconvert order enabl commiss examin restructur reconvers programm programm shortli lead definit solut current effort final result examin commiss shortli receiv data commiss remind italian govern telex august telex date septemb letter decemb italian govern success request obtain addit deadlin letter date februari transmit partial repli progress restructur reconvers programm announc definit solut found futur basi commiss examin case bilater meet held june italian author confirm figur lit billion loss compens figur lit billion lit billion year confirm factori question transfer privat sector reconvert activ underlin definit solut time commiss insist loss compens undertaken prior notif order examin aid case full inform miss partial repli letter date septemb remind septemb commiss bilater meet held novemb clarifi inform data time italian author insist definit solut found commun detail commiss good time bilater meet held septemb appear transfer men outer wear factori privat sector reconvers activ final confirm inform detail transfer execut commun italian govern letter date decemb meet held januari appear march eni lanerossi transfer remain factori privat sector termin state particip sector men outer wear econom result transfer origin employe earli retir transfer privat men outer wear sector civil privat men outer wear sector militari transfer subsector textil cloth industri industri branch shoe product output transfer italian govern argu reconvers reduc pressur men outer wear sector benefit commun textil cloth industri transfer machineri equip stock place market term basi evalu carri intern bank inform confirm telex march letter juli italian govern inform commiss loss compens amount lit billion final lit billion member state parti concern member state comment procedur iv intervent italian state favour eni lanerossi intend cover oper loss suffer men outer wear subsidiari amount lit billion form capit donat explicitli specif intend serv purpos appar public author inject capit compani provid equiti capit normal market economi condit case assess light articl eec treati intervent form loss compens grant men outer wear subsidiari eni lanerossi prevent forc work market economi normal consequ disappear uncompetit factori busi artifici long period time encumb structur commun men outer wear industri face sever adapt difficulti result structur overcapac depress price fierc competit commun loss compens grant circumst accept privat investor oper normal market economi condit present case financi econom posit factori view durat volum loss normal return dividend capit gain expect capit invest italian govern eni lanerossi view factori unrestructur continu suffer oper loss close reconvert note respect court justic clarifi applic articl eec treati respect public hold judgment novemb case intermil judgment juli case meura boch order determin contribut capit state aid court held compani question obtain financ privat capit market evid suggest beneficiari surviv public fund rais capit requir open market privat investor conclud payment constitut state aid posit made clear commiss letter member state septemb case question basi fact outlin factori concern obtain suffici capit ensur surviv privat capit market privat compani investor base decis forese possibl profit disregard social consider consider region sector polici made capit subscript cover oper loss long time consequ intervent lit billion constitut state aid mean articl eec treati aid notifi commiss provid articl eec treati italian govern fail notifi aid question case advanc commiss unabl state view measur implement aid illeg relat commun law time oper situat produc failur fulfil oblig aid paid recipi confirm italian govern larg part total aid grant commiss initi formal examin procedur articl eec treati decemb respect recal view imper charact rule procedur laid articl eec treati import public polici direct effect court justic recogn rule june case illeg aid issu remedi posteriori illeg charact aid issu result failur respect rule procedur laid articl eec treati case aid incompat common market commiss make possibl court justic judgment juli case confirm judgment februari case requir member state recov recipi aid grant illeg vi aid question incompat common market articl eec treati textil cloth industri subsector men outer wear trade member state suffici document statist evid competit keen intra commun trade product group compris multifibr categori woven coat woven coat men categori woven suit men categori woven jacket men repres product italian product categori repres total commun output export italian men outer wear member state increas factori question repres term product output italian industri sector term labour forc share employe subsidiari import men outer wear manufactur commun sector commun small firm typic larg firm rare larg firm modest size plant firm consid industri employe larg number workshop eni lanerossi export amount total men outer wear product group particip activ intra commun trade sector issu closur reconvers subsector textil cloth industri branch industri abovement share reduc site repres approxim workforc sold independ privat compani continu produc men outer wear civil militari reconvers product facil repres workforc product led increas product sector equal character keen competit high constantli increas level trade member state jean women wear pyjama shoe leather aid issu distort competit calcul improv financi posit eni lanerossi subsidiari question give competit advantag manufactur suffer stagnat demand depress price overcapac aid grant cover oper loss factori amount approxim turnov year restor financ firm normal circumst disappear latest financi assist amount lit billion form loss compens state financi aid strengthen posit undertak compar undertak compet intra commun trade regard affect aid case aid enabl subsidiari eni lanerossi surviv facilit reconvers sell product site cost eni lanerossi bear liabl affect trade distort threaten distort competit member state favour group mean articl eec treati articl eec treati lai principl aid featur incompat common market except principl incompat set articl applic case charact aid intend purpos articl set aid consid compat common market compat treati determin context commun singl member state order safeguard proper function common market take account principl articl treati except principl articl set articl constru narrowli aid scheme individu aid award scrutin appli commiss satisfi free plai market forc aid induc prospect aid recipi adopt action contribut attain object appli except case contribut object set articl aid end give unfair advantag industri undertak financi posit bolster trade condit member state affect competit distort justif ground commun interest set articl italian govern unabl give commiss discov justif find aid fall categori except articl vii subsidiari eni lanerossi concern part men outer wear industri subsector textil cloth industri group eni lanerossi import interest branch industri period question financi assist grant eni amount lit billion full subject condit aid textil cloth industri defin commun guidelin aid sector commun member state letter juli februari guidelin number criteria work commiss aid nation expert order guid govern member state intervent possibl make sector guidelin commiss point aid textil cloth sector mark high degre competit commun level involv risk caus distort competit unaccept competitor benefit measur aid gener mark repercuss sector industri guidelin justifi improv structur textil industri structur aid understood guidelin refer aid textil undertak intend inter alia facilit elimin surplu capac branch branch exist encourag convers margin activ activ textil sector aid natur meet condit guidelin subsequ develop aid scheme individu aid award introduc pressur econom situat employ consider found conflict commun interest number respect confirm commiss concern guidelin commun textil cloth industri undergon extrem rapid process chang year product declin pressur competit tradit export market commun market million job repres total employ industri lost sever length crisi forc undertak sector make great effort restructur modern product plant result industri adapt reestablish progress competit profit import role plai commun guidelin aid sector restor balanc maintain reestablish true market economi wide recogn industri remain vulner continu subject extrem strong intern competit commiss take view uncoordin state intervent conflict commun interest put risk past present effort undertaken commun textil cloth produc adapt chang market condit commiss continu attach greatest take account member state abovement guidelin aid issu meet condit set guidelin firstli guidelin provis grant aid purpos maintain compani busi contrari textil rescu ail compani rightli regard bring last improv industri nation commun level affect condit competit common market facilit improv industri competit posit prerequisit recoveri success intern textil market guidelin requir aid textil cloth compani appli short period condit fulfil case issu period commiss approv aid view restructur programm execut order return men outer wear factori viabil financi support prove unsuccess italian govern continu grant financi assist year period thirdli guidelin aim aid provid beneficiari short term level competit suffici ensur success commun textil cloth market men outer wear factori issu receiv substanti aid continu suffer great loss year reach level turnov condit equal fulfil ad respect onward obviou parti involv factori unrestructur object aid intend improv structur industri adapt restructur longer attain fourthli aid grant case earmark specif oper intend gener improv financi situat factori begin highli aid serv purpos artifici maintain product question situat condit set guidelin met direct indirect link aid individu oper apprais impact aid benefit oper final guidelin requir aid affect competit trade absolut respect point men outer wear subsidiari eni lanerossi export product receiv loss compens lit billion situat turnov lit billion subsequ year turnov fell closur sell reconvers site loss remain level close turnov reach lit billion turnov stood lit billion situat commun product product group concern fell share product trade commun increas reach share obviou mainten uncompetit product men outer wear subsidiari eni lanerossi consider part export member state advers affect competit trade condit eni lanerossi men outer wear subsidiari employe import manufactur product commun situat industri concern highli splinter hundr small competitor aid favour largest manufactur sector advers effect trade competit view forego consider conclud aid question grant contravent commun guidelin aid textil cloth industri viii aid question lit billion primarili paid order restor financ men outer wear factori point commiss inform member state letter januari condit rescu aid regard compat common market rescu aid grant firm busi difficulti discov remedi work observ inter alia condit consist cash aid form loan guarante loan bear normal commerci interest rate aid lit billion meet condit paid time need gener exceed month draw feasibl recoveri measur case rescu aid year form success loss compens inject capit grant short period durat sell price fix advanc recov aid grant condit met subsidiari aim ail compani busi aid grant feasibl recoveri measur drawn restructur plan elabor end shortli implement italian govern eni lanerossi acknowledg fact subsidiari unrestructur advers effect industri situat member state case subsidiari question particip activ intra commun trade document earli subsector textil cloth industri consid difficult situat fierc competit commun reduc product depress price uncontest persist overcapac commun level estim repli challeng commun men outer wear industri primarili consist small medium size compani number hundr undertaken extens effort adjust modern plant equip increas effici firm restructur busi document larg number factori closur reduct employ sector take commun observ cloth industri lost compani workforc reduc itali number cloth compani reduc approxim workforc sector fell circumst industri situat member state advers affect aid question term product output subsidiari eni lanerossi repres italian men outer wear industri aid lit billion contain advantag amount approxim factori turnov year save factori bankruptci consider strengthen posit compar competitor intra commun trade industri situat sector member state advers affect notifi commiss advanc signific individu case case question signific view size aid absolut rel size eni lanerossi men outer wear subsidiari conclud italian govern fulfil oblig notifi aid suffici time enabl commiss submit comment initi respect administr procedur provid articl eec treati recal consider part aid paid open procedur decemb failur notifi italian govern telex june inform commiss notifi futur intervent favour men outer wear factori good time pursuant articl eec treati view confirm italian govern argument advanc procedur letter notifi aid advanc italian legisl reject legisl defend state action incompat treati loss factori accumul oper year priori notif loss compens case exact amount involv final clear judgement court justic case refer rescu aid qualifi derog articl restor firm health firm expect oper viabl basi assist reason time excess product capac industri concern commun case clear onward consider aid grant purpos cover loss period men outer wear subsidiari eni lanerossi continu reli heavili state intervent public fund expect born event march announc state particip sector final termin view argument conclud financi inject form loss compens meet condit link rescu aid set commiss letter member state januari defin court justic abovement judgment ix march eni transfer lanerossi men outer wear factori privat sector employe earli retir rest transfer independ privat compani product site question inform receiv italian govern site sold basi econom financi evalu carri intern bank abovement transfer eni lanerossi termin particip men outer wear sector result transfer origin product capac remain men outer wear civil militari reconvert subsector textil cloth industri branch industri procedur italian govern argu reconvers consider reduc pressur men outer wear sector benefit commun textil cloth industri respect point mean product capac men outer wear sector figur submit italian govern respect calcul basi machineri equip reduct workforc indic view sever overman factori question highli product output maintain time consider reduc personnel case order increas product workforc significantli reduc compar privat italian cloth industri labour product state own compani sector lower document central italian statist institut istat year question reconvers concern involv transfer subsector textil cloth industri jean women outer wear pyjama stock tight subsector equal highli sensit commun level depress price stagnant reduc demand product pressur countri degre overcapac keen grow intra commun competit trade hold true situat nontextil sector leather shoe concern product site reconvert conclud reconvers possibl end reduc pressur men outer wear industri commun capac reduct claim italian govern time increas pressur ad capac subsector textil cloth industri branch industri similar ident structur difficulti exist difficulti increas reconvers conclud facilit develop commun industri sector view consider regard exempt provid subparagraph articl eec treati favour aid facilit develop econom activ observ aid facilit develop eni time sold lanerossi remain interest textil industri facilit develop sector concern commun level time affect trade condit extent contrari common interest artifici men outer wear factori busi sector high constantli increas level trade commun competit keen lower cost eni weaken competit posit produc commun effect increas pressur firm depress price commun market detriment withdraw market produc hitherto surviv ow restructur product qualiti improv capac workforc reduct undertaken resourc aid favour eni artifici reliev cost market posit longer sole determin effici merit power consid contribut develop commun point view adequ counteract trade distort effect aid benefit sector derog articl eec treati regard exempt provid articl relat aid intend promot facilit develop area observ area concern pescara maratea nocera gagliano standard live low suffer consider underemploy area concern ancona orvieto arezzo macerata standard live abnorm low underemploy mean exempt articl concept region develop except articl link base essenti provis aid invest major expans convers undertak involv invest physic natur cost case intervent respect factori fallen financi difficulti consequ success sanit balanc sheet fall prescript derog region question point commiss undertak analysi econom social situat framework commun interest sector men outer wear reduc capac avoid state aid favour mainten uncompetit product control sector effect region aid depress area aid promot region develop commun gudelin textil aid region aspect aid assess light problem region develop effect sector viewpoint competit intra commun trade situat industri concern present remain futur aid make product plant financi econom viabl secur job provid aid site busi compens oper loss time employ reduc aid promot econom develop area concern mean articl bring last increas incom reduct unemploy region derog articl view situat men outer wear industri sector industri site reconvert aid affect trade condit extent contrari common interest view argument aid meet condit fulfil order benefit region derog articl final exempt provid articl result forego aid question intend suit promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb italian economi italian govern invok derog view forego consider aid question lit billion illeg italian govern fulfil oblig articl meet condit fulfil order derog articl appli xi point commiss case requir member state recov aid grant illeg recipi case issu amount aid award larg amount consider exce amount nation aid scheme propos reject commiss ground potenti distort competit french parafisc levi scheme textil cloth industri final neg decis eec textil cloth industri aid scheme put forward uk final neg decis eec belgian textil cloth industri aid scheme final neg decis eec serious scale breach commun legisl case requir measur result total amount aid illeg grant lit billion withdrawn recoveri adopt decis articl aid grant eni lanerossi form capit inject favour group men outer wear subsidiari amount lit billion illeg provid violat provis articl eec treati incompat common market mean articl treati articl aid withdrawn recoveri articl italian govern inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli herewith articl decis address italian republ brussel juli commiss peter sutherland member commiss oj oj oj