commiss decis septemb aid respect export mushroom grant connect market develop fund ireland english text authent ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard council regul eec common organ market fruit veget amend regul ec articl thereof formal notic accord articl treati parti concern submit comment due account commiss inform state aid grant produc mushroom form aid relat quantitii mushroom export aid inform grant market develop fund letter date decemb commiss ask perman repres ireland aid exist inform measur reconcil market develop fund scheme commiss formul object novemb aid market develop fund assist busi produc agricultur product cover common organ market confin aid train market develop advertis aid invest short term oper loan letter date april irish author commiss answer detail april commiss ask addit clarif order avoid misunderstand applic market develop fund mushroom produc telex messag april commiss ask repli telex messag februari repli receiv precis detail condit grant aid question irish author repli request commiss april telex messag addit telex messag irish author answer telex messag februari telex messag led commiss requir detail clarif telex messag irish author answer commiss telex messag telex messag june telex messag justifi doubt continu exist meet irish author commiss staff place june end meet doubt applic market develop fund mushroom sector persist inform reach commiss base document appear circular irish trade board commiss copi recipi aid individu mushroom produc bui compost irish compost sell undertak export fresh mushroom amount aid base quantiti mushroom export fact complain submit commiss aid pound total irl million answer clarif provid irish author includ statement quantiti mushroom export condit elig aid amount aid grant link quantiti mushroom export aid grant mushroom produc market develop fund exclus function produc elig expenditur train market develop promot consist inform contain document refer appear circular irish trade board letter date june irish author confirm exist circular state compost firm aid paid situat rectifi subsequ irish author provid precis evid support statement retif addit meet june evid produc natur elimin doubt aid compat market develop fund ii letter date juli irish govern commiss state decid initi procedur provid articl treati regard aid letter commiss inform irish author consid basi inform contain document refer appear circular irish trade board aid question principl regard proper applic market develop fund mushroom produc fact aid question circular calcul quantiti export amount oper aid direct effect artifici lower cost product benefit produc distort competit affect trade member state met criteria articl treati qualifi exempt provid articl measur infring regul eec provis regul regard complet exhaust system exclud possibl member state complementari market measur addit condit set grant aid case oblig bui compost irish compost sell undertak constitut measur equival effect quantit restrict trade infring articl seq treati commiss consid principl aid incompat mean articl condit grant aid conflict mean articl condit grant aid conflict provis commun law aid consid contrari common interest abovement procedur commiss gave notic irish govern make comment commiss gave notic member state interest parti member state make comment footnot iii member state interest parti commun comment commiss correspond comment pass irish author letter date februari letter date octob irish author announc repli letter juli letter date march undertook give answer week addit letter state irish author review applic market develop fund need slightli time final review small busi letter date april irish author provid repli commiss cencern fundament aspect scheme connedt problem infring articl treati stress initi staff respons pai aid market develop fund consid aid grant firm import compost profit devalu pound sterl represent firm light experi appli fund decid aid paid applic busi import compost support argument irish author provid letter irish mushroom grower associ date april confirm satisfi potenti applic aid inform exist scheme firm import compost elig receiv aid problem oper event payment aid irish author state made inquiri activ main firm assist market develop fund expenditur activ cover scheme approv commiss ad expenditur largest beneficiari undertak account aid mushroom sector market develop fund period octob end respect activ market research sale personnel recruit establish oversea compani offic trade fair travel oversea market oversea custom visit tender cost advertis promot design product develop train exceed aid receiv market develop fund smaller busi account remain market develop fund irish author affirm confid expenditur incur equal amount aid receiv clear evid provid involv post comparison aid grant expenditur record major undertak period determin post commiss felt seek addit clarif meet place april irish author commiss staff result meet irish author undertook provid commiss offici document short time provid document exist show step good time latest payment aid link grant aid recipi elig expenditur accord rule market develop fund irish author provid addit inform grant aid document precis evid regard suppli irish author inform provid letter date april content similar april copi guidelin applic market develop fund complet aid applic form commiss possess document firm request aid letter contain copi certif issu account undertak certifi period septemb decemb firm incur expenditur depend firm market research recruit train sale personnel recruit advertis promot oversea custom visit establish oversea compani trade fair exhibit demonstr travel oversea market tender cost design product devlop product pack hous develop letter date april attach copi letter irish author april chairman irish mushroom grower associ refer condit contain circular novemb point ii aid grant mushroom produc bui compost ireland content letter refer assist provid market develop fund currenc crisi commenc fund oper circular issu fund novemb state assist provid mushroom grower bui compost ireland condit implement accord term approv eu commiss oper fund note regard term letter april purchas irish compost condit elig exist futur scheme state assist remov doubt grower persuad fund letter novemb state assist futur link condit purchas irish compost potenti beneficiari grate circul copi letter member confirm letter date april repeat argument advanc previou letter irish author ad point provis contain circular novemb drawn commiss approv market develop fund scheme commun staff implement scheme payment market develop fund made earli decemb time arrang refer circular novemb supersed appli aid paid author firm export mushroom condit requir distribut mushroom grower ii condit aid made clear beneficiari guidelin applic scheme aid applic form point formal letter approv issu irish trade board firm receiv assist fund letter made refer condit moni receiv pass mushroom produc condit impos formal document transfer fund formal document acknowledg firm complet show oblig pass moni produc ii amount aid link number employe firm calcul refer quantiti mushroom export support argument irish author provid copi guidelin mention copi aid approv letter irish trade board copi administr aid payment document copi acknowledg receipt fill undertak final letter irish author state point constitut suffici evid satisfi commiss market develop fund assist paid firm export mushroom ii amount assist calcul refer quantiti mushroom export firm iii condit requir firm pass moni receiv produc iv irish compost condit elig discard decis question firm elig beneficiari left unaid result initi adopt condit vi influenc initi condit firm decis sourc compost neutral iv accord articl regul eec articl treati applic product concern aid question principl regard applic market develop fund beneficiari receiv term laid fund fact market develop fund commiss formul object novemb temporari scheme expir latest end march design small medium size busi cope financi difficulti devalu pound sterl firm product includ agricultur product cover common organ market case mushroom unlik aid firm product involv agricultur product aid limit elig expenditur activ train market develop advertis invest short term oper loan condit elig scheme depend uk market case question quantiti mushroom export condit elig irish author state appear circular commiss possess exist confirm irish author amount aid grant produc calcul basi quantiti mushroom export elig expenditur irish author document subsequ correct payment aid carri document precis evid correct suppli commiss bilater meet june letter date octob march april open procedur articl meet april letter date april repli irish author march april provid detail oper event payment aid post check carri irish author show aid grant accord rule market develop fund refer repli march april april commiss chang assess conform aid irish author made posteriori examin expenditur demonstr aid grant expenditur demonstr aid grant expenditur allow market develop fund oper produc trade product cover annex ii treati elig expenditur determin latest aid initi grant addit check made irish author suppos made recipi aid fact involv undertak circular novemb requir pass aid directli deduct mushroom grower administr document irish author undertook meet april suppli short time commiss provid document exist commiss satisfi step good time link grant aid recipi elig expenditur accord rule market develop fund document kind receiv irish author letter refer earlier april irish mushroom grower associ mention compost mushroom produc letter date april attach document provid evid grant aid end step link grant aid type expenditur refer commiss letter novemb point state letter provis circular novemb replac appli document precis evid provid repeal replac circular absenc indic copi administr letter irish trade board approv aid firm letter date decemb oblig firm pass aid mushroom grower prove oblig appli requir circular novemb conclus appli administr document transfer aid moni firm fact point irish trade board letter quot recal aid grant compost bought irish undertak domest sourc strengthen idea circular novemb contain condit fact replac clear oblig recipi firm pai aid produc aid regard oper aid incompat common market detail case aid payment link type expenditur commiss letter novemb fact alleg irish author letter april aid grant base number employe recipi firm quantiti mushroom export chang charact aid oper aid mushroom export undertak aid effect put recipi favour situat compar oper sector member state result distort competit irish oper receiv aid produc export oper member state addit ireland increas presenc mushroom market largest export fresh mushroom remaind commun exclus unit kingdom absolut term ireland produc tonn mushroom compar tonn tonn ireland export tonn commun countri includ unit kingdom total intra commun trade amount tonn aid question affect trade member state half irish product export commun countri measur fall term articl treati articl state aid scheme fulfil term set principl incompat common market exempt provid articl applic aid scheme concern exempt invok irish author except provid articl list object pursu interest commun sole interest individu sector nation economi exempt interpret strictli examin programm region sector aid individu case applic gener aid scheme exempt grant commiss establish aid carri object pursu grant benefit exempt aid scheme involv counterpart amount allow damag trade member state distort competit justifi commun interest time permit undu advantag accru oper member state case issu aid involv counterpart irish govern provid commiss discov evid aid question meet term exempt provid articl scheme intend promot carri import project common european interest mean articl effect trade aid run counter common interest measur design remedi disturb economi member state concern mean provis regard exempt provid articl aid scheme intend encourag facilit econom develop region activ refer articl note measur issu oper aid natur improv durabl situat recipi produc ceas paid situat exist state aid provid rememb aid concern product cover common organ market limit power member state interven autonom oper common organ compris common support system fall exclus compet commun payment aid issu mushroom sector counter principl member state longer power unilater decis farmer incom framework common organ market grant aid type exempt articl produc agricultur product question aid scheme infring common organ market exclud exempt judgment court justic june case pig bacon commiss mc carren compani aid regard aid elig exempt provid articl addit circular novemb aid restrict produc bui compost undertak sell irish compost regard measur effect equival quantit restrict mean articl treati scheme encourag mushroom produc purchas suppli compost nation produc constitut measur effect equival quantit restrict justifi articl involv pure econom measur irish author repli june april state circular refer firm concern irish author happen payment aid made situat rectifi subsequ commiss consid aid scheme principl incompat common market mean articl treati condit grant aid infring provis commun law irish author declar letter date april circular novemb repeal replac payment made letter copi letter irish trade board decemb recipi aid approv grant aid recal grant condit compost bought irish compani inform contain letter date april irish author mushroom grower associ request circul member remind associ condit requir purchas compost appli recogn provis contrari commun law circumst commiss consid date effect provis circular novemb correct aid question consid incompat common market mean articl treati aid grant notifi draft measur commiss consid illeg articl treati case incompat aid scheme common market commiss entitl accord case law court justic judgment deliv juli case confirm judgment februari septemb case requir member state recov recipi aid grant improperli light consider aid paid exact amount commiss inform reach commiss amount irl million ecu million refund refund collect accord procedur provis irish legisl provis interest overdu sum ow state calcul date aid question grant measur order restor previou situat cancel financi advantag recipi improperli grant aid enjoi unduli date payment aid decis anticip consequ commiss draw connect financ common agricultur polici european agricultur guidanc guarante fund eaggf adopt decis articl aid produc export mushroom grant market develop fund bord tráchtála irish trade board illeg aid incompat common market mean articl ec treati articl ireland requir cancel aid refer articl recov sum paid month notif decis recoveri carri accord procedur provis nation legisl accord interest payabl overdu sum ow state amount recov bear interest date aid question grant articl ireland inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl articl decis address ireland brussel septemb commiss rené steichen member commiss oj oj oj ecr ecr ecr ecr