commiss decis novemb declar concentr compat common market case iv mannesmann hoesch council regul eec german text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul eec decemb control concentr undertak articl thereof regard request german bundeskartellamt june seek referr case accord articl regul regard commiss decis juli initi proceed case undertak concern opportun make view object rais commiss consult advisori committe concentr notifi oper mannesmannroehrenwerk ag mrw hoesch ag hoesch intend bring precis steel tube busi establish joint ventur jv call mhp mannesmann hoesch praezisrohr gmbh mhp mrw contribut work brackwed holzhausen remscheid wicked sharehold robur buizenfabrik helmond netherland addit mannesmannroehrenwerk sachsen gmbh mr work make precis steel tube dedic product facil mhp hoesch contribut work hamm sharehold schult rohrbearbeitung gmbh drensteinfurt regard precis steel tube hoesch turn transfer ownership own subsidiari hoesch tubular product corpor usa htp mrw give mrw sharehold fulli own subsidiari gebr fuch gmbh siegen fuch fuch jv mrw hoesch part hoesch work hamm produc precis steel tube transfer mhp dedic product facil mrw hoesch precis steel activ mrw exist precis tube busi steel tube subsidiari brazil turkei part transact mrw hoesch krupp share small german steel produc nmh stahlwerk gmbh compani tube make subsidiari rohrwerk neue maxhuett gmbh steel tube activ part transact oper carri parti relat sector industri oper repres part agreement parti restructur steel tube activ consid singl concentr mean articl regul eec hereinaft merger regul creation joint ventur mhp fuch acquisit mrw sole control htp repres singl concentr purpos merger regul ii parti mrw activ product finish distribut steel tube subsidiari mannesmann ag diversifi german group activ area mechan engin plant construct inform system electron engin autom part product finish iron steel product provis relat servic mrw own thyssen stahl ag german steel produc parti present oper hoesch german produc metal steel iron product engag wide rang activ connect domain hoesch acquir krupp gmbh project clear ecsc treati fall merger regul ecsc product concern iii concentr joint ventur joint control mrw hoesch hold share mhp fuch equal vote right equal number sharehold repres supervisori board sharehold committe mhp manag jv submit major busi decis supervisori board fuch sharehold committe mhp prior approv busi decis includ busi price distribut polici invest financi personnel plan mhp fuch jointli control mean articl merger regul autonom econom entiti mhp bear respons busi activ parti agre provid mhp financi resourc busi develop proport sharehold met resourc favour financ found fuch present busi perform function autonom econom entiti remain notwithstand chang ownership arrang parti agre fuch continu independ compani market strategi financi resourc suppli develop mhp steel input joint ventur fulli suppli parent steel account materi cost total product cost mhp effect substanti part sale roughli parent trade compani account exist mutual dedic product facil precis tube made mhp behalf mrw mr output precis steel tube produc behalf mhp remain substanti commerci relationship parent jv mhp insuffici rebut conclus mhp fuch oper fulli function jv account steel industri vertic integr normal extent larg european competitor british steel usinor ilva fulli integr group suppli tube subsidiari steel act trader steel product ad jv steel input provid parent substanti mhp fuch provid substanti asset suffici financi resourc commerci relationship parent normal industri practic jv consid fulli function autonom econom entiti mean articl merger regul absenc coordin competit behaviour independ undertak hoesch transfer precis steel tube activ mhp precis steel transfer own subsidiari htp mrw grant stake fuch mrw complet hoesch interest steel tube market sharehold jv hoesch interest suppli jv exist overcapac steel market make commerci sens hoesch seek enter steel tube market mrw remain activ market jv true regard precis steel tube mrw extens interest fuch regard precis tube mrw maintain minor interest mhp product capac mr dedic mhp interest roehrenwerk neue maxhuett small produc major sharehold brazilian turkish steel tube produc neglig sale european commun natur interest hoesch withdraw tube market compar mrw retain substanti interest market reflect busi guidelin geschaeftsordnung sharehold committe mhp partner agreement mrw hoesch regard fuch mannesmann ag futur krupp hoesch group import steel produc note firstli mannesmann absorb product exclus activ product market tube round pre tube mannesmann flat product hot roll wide strip krupp hoesch impact competit free market upstream small size degre vertic integr industri signific upstream product different reflect suppli agreement parent jv mrw suppli tube round pre tube squar whilst krupp hoesch provid hot roll wide strip creation joint ventur give rise coordin competit behaviour independ undertak mean articl merger regul conclus mhp fuch regard concentr jv mean articl iv commun dimens aggreg worldwid turnov parti exceed ecu million mannesmann ecu million hoesch ecu million parti commun wide turnov ecu million parti achiev third commun wide turnov member state oper commun dimens mean articl merger regul compat common market steel tube industri steel tube industri produc wide varieti tube rang applic product procedur tube rang size fine tube diamet mm larg tube diamet weight tube vari correspondingli gram tonn metr length gener steel tube divid main group precis precis tube call trade transport tube precis tube distinguish precis tube primarili dimension accuraci toler achiev directli product process altern precis tube pre tube subject product step precis tube subdivid applic line pipe transport gase fluid smooth pipe emploi construct element engin steel construct thread pipe household instal boiler plant pipe found power station chemic petro chemic industri oil drill pipe explor drill oil ga hollow section tube util construct element engin motor vehicl construct structur engin seamless weld tube make tube type weld tube made flat steel product seamless tube made tube round weld tube gener cheaper seamless tube seamless tube replac weld tube applic percentag increas continu due technolog progress improv weld techniqu parti seamless weld tube give rise separ product market extent product method includ cold treatment weld process appli wide rang technic standard satisfi specif field applic precis steel tube relev product market precis steel tube precis steel tube respect product process cold treatment pre tube degre toler characterist field applic price parti estim overlap precis precis steel tube amount volum parti precis steel tube give rise singl relev product market subdivid market precis steel tube seamless weld precis tube special characterist din ii weld precis tube din exist differ precis tube segment deem belong singl relev product market import view custom market segment vehicl construct engin custom determin scope substitut basic precis tube high tube inclus segment singl relev product market justifi move smoothli specif breakpoint precis market definit remain open narrow approach competit impact neighbour market requir assess present case lead materi conclus geograph refer market basi inform assum geograph refer market commun wide view support high level mutual market penetr member state absenc signific price differ observ equal valid member state signific steel industri competit assess combin commun market share undertak concern narrow product market definit adopt precis steel pipe high specif commun market share exce germani undertak combin market share approxim rise precis pipe high specif narrow definit product geograph market adopt concentr expect lead creation strengthen domin posit german market number domest foreign produc signific market share regard present futur competit pressur foreign supplier competit partial substitut precis tube lower specif produc supplier limit scope action mrw hoesch consider extent precis tube exclud line pipe relev product market market precis tube distinguish refer area applic price notif parti initi put forward view trade transport tube divid relev product market line pipe thread pipe smooth pipe siederohr boiler plant pipe oil drill pipe hollow section proceed chang view extent tube transport materi water ga oil air give rise singl transport tube market thread oil drill line pipe smooth boiler plant pipe extent pipe relev product market line pipe consid detail leav market line pipe product market affect requir detail analysi precis product market definit signific effect assess propos concentr valid wider approach hollow section includ construct element made materi narrow approach boiler plant pipe base qualit criteria precis relev product market trade transport tube exclud line pipe left open geograph refer market except line pipe consider definit geograph refer market appli precis tube precis tube germani signific impact propos concentr aris import percentag precis steel tube vari boiler plant pipe hollow section import main steel produc western eastern europ geograph refer market commun wide boiler plant pipe oil drill pipe possibl worldwid competit assess relev product market precis tube exclud line pipe concentr result combin commun market share exceed major addit market share found germani combin market share exce oil drill pipe boiler plant pipe creation strengthen domin posit market except line pipe exclud market oil drill pipe concentr lead fusion german produc import intern natur oil busi remov scope uncontrol action german market respect market boiler plant pipe view special technic safeti standard germani evid separ german market exist hypothesi suffici detriment impact competit mrw market posit improv low end market hoesch present segment guetestuf segment high boiler plant pipe low end market import penetr high improv mrw posit segment increas scope action appreci extent market steel ga line pipe relev product market commiss includ relev product market product regard consum interchang reason characterist price intend commiss consid scope supplier significantli limit market affect action supplier neighbour product market commiss consid relev product market steel ga line pipe exclud larg pipe exist reason set distinct trade transport tube place line pipe distinct call trade transport tube fulfil partli function thread pipe extent flow fluid gaseou materi distinct line pipe regard technic specif din field applic household user method distribut price undertak concern opinion suppli side substitut price interdepend exist singl product market precis tube applic purpos account claim precis tube constitut singl product market fulfil basic function transport materi water ga oil hot air heat air solid leav fact inform submit parti show clear price differ trade transport tube evolut graph submit parti reflect price develop steel tube input price coil undertak repres total product cost condit competit appli market affect lack demand side substitut distribut system differ reflect inter alia complet import percentag ga line pipe hand trade transport tube commiss agre parti larg pipe belong relev product market compar line pipe regard size respect field applic long distanc transport siberia germani user condit competit mrw separ busi area jv usinor sacilor call europip gmbh parti includ water pipe relev product market commiss share view water pipe made din permit carri ga addit share water pipe total volum steel line pipe exclud larg pipe share water pipe total turnov steel line pipe mrw hoesch fuch substitut pipe made plastic materi parti relev product market line pipe includ steel pipe pipe made materi plastic cast iron cement stone justifi interchang view real possibl substitut plastic pipe steel enquiri industri associ competitor user gaslin pipe take account expert opinion present parti commiss conclus underli reason substitut steel plastic gaslin pipe determin princip technic possibl substitut nation safeti standard exist ga network util compani buyer prefer theoret degre substitut depend segment gaslin pipe market concern segment correspond usual divis emploi ga industri low pressur pipe amp le bar ga distribut local level medium pressur pipe gt bar amp le bar ga distribut region level high pressur pipe gt bar region network low pressur pipe bar low pressur plastic pipe made polyethylen denot pe pipe approv pressur rang bar technic substitut steel tube subject parti expert ad technic econom plan underli construct distribut network line pipe complex instanc paramet mention current ga demand forecast evolut option rout trench consider impact cost dig surfac work pressur rang pipe materi depend technic restrict distribut network establish extend line pipe renew regard requir pressur rang choic pipe materi object find low cost combin pipe materi line pipe diamet possess flow capac suffici estim reserv capac regard assess substitut relationship steel pe pipe exist restrict dens distribut network technic reason larg juxtaposit materi het network avoid object number joint materi potenti sensit damag usual part pre plan make distribut network region choic materi small extens line pipe renew establish basi technic econom consider practic restrict exist construct distribut network line pipe bar econom combin pipe materi diamet achiev requir flow capac object plan chosen expert opinion submit parti technic restrict choic pipe materi exist dens distribut network pressur rang bar confirm choic made pre plan phase statist bgw feder associ german ga water industri plastic ga pipe pressur rang pressur rang bar expert opinion restrict exist expert opinion confirm larg price differ steel plastic pipe regard pipe materi pipe lai cost price differ depend pipe diamet network bar network bar import point tube produc influenc cost compon simpl pipe cost steel tube produc submit lower offer ga util make cost disadvantag steel pipe higher pipe lai cost steel pipe network bar make cost disadvantag regard low pressur pipe steel plastic pipe relev product market decis process steel pe pipe take place pre competit stage event scope price increas steel tube supplier domin posit limit signific pe pipe supplier medium pressur pipe bar medium pressur pipe limit technic substitut steel pe pipe present pe pipe technic ground maximum pressur bar develop materi suggest pe pipe develop year test purpos includ bar assess possibl substitut term competit technic circumst consid gener legal econom condit time effect substitut establish british ga limit region network oper pressur bar order pe pipe franc belgium part distribut network oper pressur rang hand maximum oper pressur allow germani pe pipe bar pe pipe exclud time region distribut network network typic oper pressur rang bar expect germani approv extens pressur rang pe pipe obtain end suppos scope action steel supplier pressur rang significantli limit pe pipe produc period isol chang nation standard expect harmon phase european level addit attent drawn substanti price disadvantag pe pipe pressur rang document parti expert commiss draw conclus germani definit geograph refer market pe pipe includ relev product market high pressur rang bar present time technic possibl replac steel pipe plastic high pressur rang remain valid forese futur pe steel pipe includ relev product market pressur rang conclus steel pe gaslin pipe consid belong relev product market market steel gaslin pipe discuss show gaslin pipe technic reason chosen light pressur rang exist pressur rang ga network steel gaslin pipe produc germani technic standard din part din part standard cover steel gaslin pipe includ bar technic differ steel gaslin pipe low middl pressur rang cover pressur rang bar high pressur rang account larg number custom bui low medium medium high pressur rang support exist uniform condit competit segment price set segment ignor knock effect segment left open singl market exist market consist market segment base pressur parti estim size steel gaslin pipe market germani ecu million annual sale market size estim commiss amount ecu million ecu million relat pressur rang bar ecu million pressur rang bar suppli side substitut determin relev product market suppli side substitut account manufactur product product question readili quickli switch product submiss parti suppli side substitut achiev cost loss time commiss maintain opinion steel tube produc easili quickli switch product gaslin pipe high pressur pipe essenti differ assess li fact commiss estim extens product requir time requir significantli greater suffici long phase allow plan purchas equip construct test plant tuev technisch ueberwachungsverein technic supervisori associ approv procedur produc product train test worker ultim question suffici suppli side substitut exist left open event lack power competitor produc simpl trade transport tube basi assum suppli side substitut quickli enter market restor common condit competit assum combin market simpl trade transport tube gaslin pipe produc gaslin pipe todai produc basic trade transport tube shown clear differ condit competit continu exist gaslin pipe hand trade transport tube accept independ produc simpl tube signific appreci chang structur differ suppli side substitut substanti easier assum commiss regard abil current produc simpl tube gaslin pipe exist capac increas product gaslin pipe note problem relat market definit question potenti capac util exist competitor conclus commiss consid relev product market steel gaslin pipe exclud larg pipe exist product refer hereinaft abbrevi form gaslin pipe exist singl market market consist market segment determin pressur left open account compar market posit undertak concern segment geograph refer market structur aspect gener competit framework set commiss consid condit competit germani curent member state chang dynam develop design bring commun wide market chang progress infer suffici homogen condit competit creat common market futur reason present time relat assess effect propos concentr geograph refer market constitut territori germani current market situat market share differ indic data collect commiss mrw hoesch largest player commun market share commun term ilva group share compani british steel hoogoven group tubo reunido commun share present mutual interpenetr nation market remain limit larg member state steel pipe product nation supplier gaslin pipe largest market share germani import present itali nation produc achiev spain figur franc unit kingdom import significantli higher type characterist product market gaslin pipe chiefli character technic condit harmon european commun appear germani franc unit kingdom prevail nation standard exclus itali spain benelux countri iso din standard german law technic requir low medium pressur gaslin pipe effect deriv law energi sector energiewirtschaftsgesetz high pressur ga pipelin high pressur ga pipelin regul verordnung ueber gashochdruckleitungen text establish specif technic requir refer requir satisfi gener recogn technolog rule legal text requir presum satisfi product satisfi dvgw deutscher verein de ga und wasserfach ev german associ ga water util rule dvgw work paper dvgw arbeitsblaett part low medium pressur high pressur lai specif rule ga pipelin work paper refer din part din set larg number detail standard cover inter alia steel materi aspect product process test procedur plastic coat line pipe undertaken separ produc practic case germani event manufactur meet requir din standard din polyethylen coat produc gaslin pipe gener technic approv tuev mpa materialpruefungsanstalt materi test author approv cover product process equip integr test product qualif employe welder test laid ad arbeitsgemeinschaft druckbehaelt work group pressur vessel notic major west european steel produc partial tuev approv product steel gaslin pipe demand side structur import element assess exist differ condit competit member state demand side structur respect demand side differ markedli germani larger member state high ga consumpt unit kingdom exclud ga pipelin requir shore ga activ british ga monopoli land base requir franc gaz de franc approxim nation local network itali snam own nation nework subsidiari italga local suppli germani exist principl compani long distanc network west germani ruhrga compani east germani vng region ga distributor local ga util size region distributor local ga util vari appreci purchas decis criteria purchas polici german custom nation orient investig carri commiss purchas criteria secur suppli compat pipe exist network long term suppli relationship technic advic support abil satisfi compani specif requir signific influenc purchas decis german ga util criteria determin purchas behaviour tend encourag nation bui commerci easier domest supplier satisfi object requir futur market situat dynam develop harmon technic standard harmon current european standard oper gaslin system materi requir undertaken european committe standard cen aegi cen countri repres recogn industri associ work achiev common standard cen work organ undertaken technic committe tc tc deleg specif task work group prepar european standard gaslin pipe undertaken tc work group tc establish formal work standard commenc tc respons establish function requir distribut transport ga task tc check standard produc tc meet function requir seek reformul case steel line pipe tc draw draft standard prepar tc eciss european committe iron steel standard pr en steel pipe pipelin combust fluid technic deliveri condit part pipe requir class commiss prepar mandat cen context council direct eec construct product direct cpd develop european standard gaslin pipe european standard agre publish offici journal european commun standard support cpd procur rule obligatori european standard exist cen major european standard tc expect steel pipe standard prepar tc enter forc complet coincid din part part extend tuev approv procedur cover import din standard harmon complet current german din standard present formal market entri barrier econom entri barrier product test carri accord german din standard import barrier depend product volum higher order volum achiev signific neg cost effect adapt product process match german din standard conclud hand remain differ standard larg member state chang posit expect hand account fact foreign produc obtain partial tuev approv approv lack requir cover full rang requir din standard easili obtain supplier produc gaslin pipe standard true major west european steel produc commun direct public procur procur pattern ga util differ respect member state subject exist nation public procur rule purchas procedur regul intern rule germani ga util gener publish invit tender confirm util question commiss claim supplier capabl provid technic commerci satisfactori tender applic commun procur rule council direct eec eec forc januari open nation market requir transpar discriminatori procur procedur grant steel tube supplier member state immedi full advantag opportun creat gradual open market import obstacl full effect commun procur rule technic standard harmon tender offer base nation standard full effect commun procur direct achiev import part tc major relev technic standard tc agre commun procur rule forc effect depend proport nation tender achiev minimum purchas volum ecu subject commun wide tender higher proport commerci attract foreign supplier produc din standard technic harmon process complet connect estim signific proport possibl german order gaslin pipe achiev minimum purchas volum direct take account long term commerci strateg interest suppli german market exist overcapac larg absolut size german market exception high level demand year due german reunif certainti forese futur remain technic barrier remov expect immin implement commun public procur direct foreign supplier seek develop suppli relationship german market reli open market regard technic standard conclus commiss take view appreci condit competit exist todai germani member state structur element market gaslin pipe dynam impuls identifi harmon technic standard commun public procur direct open nation market time develop progress proper relat assess effect propos concentr german market account apprais question market domin effect transit period open german market market domin assess market domin commiss take account current market posit undertak concern structur element give rise exist condit competit structur element due chang exist condit competit regard specif circumst individu case consider market share market share character current market posit undertak high market share repres import factor evid domin posit provid reflect current condit reliabl indic futur condit structur factor identifi liabl due chang exist condit competit market share view reliabl indic futur condit commiss obtain turnov figur supplier gaslin pipe europ year basi figur market share germani gaslin pipe market segment low medium pressur hand high pressur hand shown tabl oj concentr mrw hoesch attain market share high pressur segment exce low medium pressur segment amount total market share parti take averag year amount parti contest commiss calcul market share base estim calcul total market share previou year lower borusan rautaruukki recent enter german market british steel purchas mannstaedt kloeckner subsequ enter market acquisit tube work muldenstein east germani element competit product rang undertak concern cover complet product rang gaslin pipe appli pressur rang ga pipe diamet singl ga util order pipe product rang lack complet product rang present decis competit handicap confirm ga util interrog distribut sale gaslin pipe germani take place predominantli project specif call tender parti project past primarili suppli tube produc small repair met trader parti state trader increasingli take part project specif call tender germani german supplier activ direct custom sale except rautaruukki british steel mannstaedt sell gaslin pipe owner kloeckner trader loew amp jaeger belong viag kloeckner group usinor bought german tube produc homburg roehrenwerk compani produc gaslin pipe possess distribut network pipe foreign supplier activ germani arb arfa borusan hoogoven ilva oper market german trader regard distribut undertak concern german manufactur competit advantag compar foreign competitor possess distribut arrang gaslin pipe germani vertic integr undertak concern total vertic integr steel product plastic coat give rise signific advantag product steel input gaslin pipe mean essenti hot roll wide strip notabl competit advantag parti compar german competitor kloeckner steel produc flender extens competit suppli altern advantag domest oppos foreign produc resid intern sourc suppli main foreign produc steel suppli li fact german produc manufactur steel usual german specif hand import commun standard prepar tc govern product steel pipe expect enter forc german produc enjoi competit advantag foreign competitor respect plastic coat german produc british steel mannstaedt nmh coat facil ilva hoogoven vbf british steel possess instal parti contest competit advantag drawn attent number foreign job coater point coat process meet din standard transport cost differ transport cost signific competitor germani supplier countri border germani repres relev market entri barrier foreign competitor declar cost curtail competit german market competitor locat afield spain greec turkei transport cost disadvantag pipe diamet dn estim impact transport cost decis low order volum distant competitor repres specif handicap potenti competit commiss consid prevail condit competit german market gaslin pipe led market posit parti hold high combin market share chang significantli due result potenti competit brought dynam impuls identifi german market gaslin pipe main kind potenti competit consid extens product rang current competitor market entri signific increas exist market particip west european supplier market entri east european competitor probabl increas competit pressur ow extens product rang current competitor consid low kloeckner recent invest gaslin busi acquisit east german plant muldenstein competitor consid extens product rang term pipe diamet expens exist overcapac improb commerci reason incent market entri increas market particip western european supplier consid signific larg degre overcapac steel kind steel tube europ strong competit pressur steel tube market simpl trade transport tube german market largest european market gaslin pipe result german unif high level demand foundat intern market creat practic step forc public procur direct januari continu progress technic harmon process specif circumst present case period time deem assess impact potenti competit parti scope action requir special detail consider term assess time potenti competit date import relat exist legal technic barrier implement public procur direct expect standard steel pipe product major steel gaslin pipe standard enter forc dismantl barrier signific impact market entri major commun competitor anticip progress structur market except circumst case identifi reason account progress natur futur develop longer period circumst respect exist legal technic barrier note preced analysi public procur direct enter forc month fulli effect complet harmon technic standard attain object creat singl european market place progress realiz year present case harmon standard steel gaslin pipe year advent state signific incent market entri major west european supplier major west european supplier britisch steel usinor ilva share german market gaslin pipe establish distribut system made extens independ trader certainti attach framework futur competit immin implement public procur direct major produc anticip full harmon standard seek advantag opportun progress aris specif circumst case commiss consid strong evid percept impact german market full harmon complet reason view firstli potenti competitor ilva british steel usinor sacilor largest steel produc good potenti avail albeit imperfect opportun creat public procur direct true activ germani neighbour tube market substanti sunk cost market entri hold tuev approv part product rang regard time requir expect cost obtain easili part strong incent market entri thirdli notwithstand fragment demand structur germani signific part german market gaslin pipe fall public procur direct lastli reason suppos german ga util larger custom seek involv major west european supplier competit process german market hand high combin market share mannesmann hoesch ration incent seek altern sourc suppli legal oblig compli requir public procur direct major west european supplier enjoi legal remedi event complianc parti point rapid growth import east european produc semi finish steel product simpl transport tube refer low labour cost comparison commun produc point produc hold tuev approv east european supplier restrict scope action mrw hoesch remain sourc competit addit expect activ competit west european supplier conclus high combin market share mrw hoesch german market gaslin pipe competit advantag relat remain german foreign competitor strong evid parti concern achiev complet concentr liberti action immedi fulli control exist competitor assess market posit mrw hoesch significantli imped competit common market mean articl merger regul born mind larg west european competitor ilva british steel usinor sacilor minim activ german market incent opportun market entri high west european competitor east european produc steel tube public procur direct effect month time produc structur chang scope german compani entri market effect public procur direct progress increas attain full matur complet technic harmon process consid absenc signific entri barrier domin posit creat outset propos concentr subsist limit period time high probabl competit quickli erod posit mrw hoesch german market gaslin pipe vi assess commiss conclus propos concentr give rise domin posit product geograph tube market result effect competit significantli imped substanti part common market adopt decis articl propos oper mannesmannroehren werk ag hoesch ag declar compat common market articl decis address mannesmannroehren werk ag bruckhau westrick stegemann freiligrathstrass duesseldorf attent herr rechtsanwalt mooseck fax hoesch ag bruckhau westrick stegemann freiligrathstrass duesseldorf attent herr rechtsanwalt mooseck fax brussel novemb commiss leon brittan vice presid oj republish oj oj publish version decis inform omit pursuant provis articl regul eec disclosur busi secret understand text gener inform footnot case violat disclosur requir busi secret commiss decis unpublish interest busi secreci figur origin text replac publish version interest busi secreci figur origin text omit publish version case share minor oj oj oj publish version decis inform omit pursuant provis articl regul eec disclosur busi secret