commiss decis novemb state aid germani plan implement eko stahl gmbh notifi document number german version authent text eea relev ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european coal steel commun regard agreement european econom area articl thereof read conjunct protocol regard commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid steel industri articl call interest parti submit comment pursuant abovement decis regard comment procedur letter date octob germani notifi commiss intent grant aid eko stahl gmbh hereinaft eko stahl financ amp project letter date march commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl commiss decis ecsc hereinaft steel aid code respect aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid germani present comment commiss decis letter date april commiss receiv comment unit kingdom letter date juli forward germani letter date august germani gave respons letter date august ii detail descript aid aid notifi eko stahl financ compani particip project quot method instrument creat stabilis evalu perman adapt personnel quot joint project carri partner activ field human resourc inform technolog cost eko stahl amount eur notifi aid eur propos aid intens industri research region bonu ten percentag point eko stahl locat articl region cost compris personnel travel administr expens project run juli march project sociolog research project design develop method instrument stabilis long term adapt worker element project quot personnel quot area eko stahl directli involv method instrument develop enabl staff manag achiev level adapt build develop occur german author inform commiss eko stahl project carri stage base timet joint project stage plan stage devis method assess perman adapt stage develop stage instrument adapt develop test stage call control stage dissemin implement find german author inform commiss incent effect aid resid fact eko stahl direct interest project particip aid initi procedur commiss rais doubt notifi particip eko stahl project constitut research mean amp framework doubt eko stahl carri research context project particip correspond sole act quot test ground quot research particip commiss rais doubt compat aid eko stahl project assess amp framework clear definit task perform worker justifi level aid research stage reason put forward incent effect call question commiss origin suspect eko stahl carri research iii comment interest parti unit kingdom comment propos project share view express commiss decis initi procedur project rank amp mean amp framework iv comment germani comment repli comment unit kingdom germani reaffirm initi posit eko stahl particip project constitut research mean amp framework confirm view entir project constitut industri research propos level aid justifi state project meet criteria elig european parliament council decis ec framework programm european commun research technolog develop demonstr activ hereinaft quot commun amp programm quot assess aid eko stahl gmbh undertak mean articl ecsc treati aid subject steel aid code possibl aid steel undertak amp activ aid project notifi individu compat assess amp framework annex amp framework definit amp stage state framework intend cover amp aid link directli subsequ product market product process servic section amp framework set aid intens stage research gener vari industri research pre competit develop activ section requir aid serv incent firm undertak amp activ addit normal dai dai activ state attent exercis case larg firm germani claim eko stahl project meet criteria laid commun amp project project commun amp framework programm similar project eko stahl particip call tender recent launch particip industri compani commun project whilst exclud assess basi merit amp activ carri compani applic institut univers similarli present case aid eko stahl assess basi research contribut compani carri project fact compani state particip research project partner dispens demonstr contribut constitut research germani reiter posit eko stahl project constitut industri research mean amp framework explain research activ claim compani engag signific research activ area methodolog instrument shape stabilis evalu adapt concret inform activ role compani plai research definit descript task perform compani doubt rais commiss initi procedur eko stahl serv quot test ground quot particip project maintain vi conclus commiss conclud eko stahl activ aid notifi constitut research mean amp framework project elig aid framework point rais procedur stage research aid intens incent effect aid examin aid notifi germani eko stahl incompat steel aid code common market function eea agreement adopt decis articl state aid germani plan implement eko stahl gmbh amount eur incompat common market function eea agreement aid implement articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel novemb commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj footnot oj oj