commiss decis novemb settl disput feder republ germani grand duchi luxembourg author regular coach servic german french text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun regard council regul eec februari introduct common rule regular special regular servic coach bu member state amend regul eec hereinaft refer regul articl thereof compani deutsch tour gmbh frankfurt main hereinaft refer tour oper regular coach servic duesseldorf luxembourg passeng arriv leav luxembourg airport regul enter forc servic author relev author feder republ germani grand duchi luxembourg special coach servic passeng hold luxavia air ticket author expir june servic contract luxembourg firm voyag emil weber canach talk tour fédération luxembourgeois de exploit autobu autocar februari tour appli minist urban develop hous transport north rhine westphalia author expir june renew tour receiv provision author septemb pursuant articl regul august local author author duesseldorf person regierungspraesid reject applic renew author decemb feder minist transport ask luxembourg minist transport accept decis german author author januari luxembourg minist transport reject request letter relev minist north rhine westphalia ask decis author author duesseldorf reconsid letter march feder minist transport luxembourg minist transport confirm posit stress great import continu servic march emil weber appli luxembourg minist transport author servic receiv provision month author march extend expiri septemb relev minist north rhine westphalia inform luxembourg minist transport refus renew author letter view fact govern unabl reach agreement author servic luxembourg govern refer disput commiss june pursuant articl regul request applic made emil weber approv german govern made similar applic commiss juli request commiss settl disput gave posit rule grant author tour tour continu contract servic emil weber past tour confirm willing letter juli feder minist transport member state concern attend meet commiss brussel juli discuss applic ii german author author put forward argument author incompat interest public transport articl regul interpret provis favour railwai form backbon passeng transport european countri railwai need protect competit privat regular servic econom interest firm establish passeng servic subordin case state act interest commun overrid public concern maintain effici transport system regular road servic author request case seemingli servic cost includ price air fare time requir rail journei excess passeng compar travel time rail transport guarante connect flight time rail connect duesseldorf luxembourg train dai direct journei half hour gener provid quantit qualit satisfactori solut transport question luxembourg govern put forward argument regular servic question exist year reason complaint time person servic sole luxavia passeng paid cost connect journei price air ticket transfer servic railwai unaccept passeng ow problem involv chang mean transport vehicl time cumbersom luggag ow fact journei take longer rail road connect flight arriv late pick passeng brussel passeng brussel flight divert iii applic made govern admiss articl accord articl regul examin light articl subparagraph thereof aim provis defin recit regul ensur proper function servic minimum cost commun gener adapt suppli transport demand rout serv coordin passeng transport servic area concern effect manner principl coordin transport servic satisfi specif transport effect minimum cost appli specif case light commun transport polici structur transport market articl regul interpret provis absolut protect railwai uncondit prioriti railwai essenti mean transport passeng commun economi monopoli market level gener princip reason author author duesseldorf decis accept decis individu case contrari made light condit appli public transport interest account weigh specif interest transport user concern transport enterpris examin present forese transport satisfi transport servic question conclud direct coach servic duesseldorf luxembourg eifel offer transport user appreci advantag rail servic trier koblenz coach servic case qualit advantag direct connect luxembourg airport duesseldorf main station chang transfer luggag case rail shorter journei outweigh greater comfort space refresh rail transport coach servic great quantit advantag guarante straightforward connect flight aeroplan divert brussel relev factor account comparison conclud road transport offer servic relev specif case involv special regular servic limit number custom special servic oper year problem hard market situat effect transport industri chang author refus basi factor event major factor milit favour renew author interest compani continu servic offer object made accord author long period invest ti oper interest gener correspond exist undisput demand side transport user light factor conclud coach servic author appli offer servic compet rail servic satisfi specif transport market adopt decis articl compet author feder republ germani author deutsch tour gmbh frankfurt main special regular servic coach duesseldorf luxembourg set oper voyag emil weber canach luxembourg request undertak articl decis address feder republ germani grand duchi luxembourg decis effect dai notif member state concern member state refer matter council expiri time limit brussel novemb commiss stanlei clinton davi member commiss oj oj