commiss decis octob aid scheme implement kingdom spain airlin intermediación aérea sl notifi document number spanish text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl cite regard comment procedur letter april regist nn commiss inform kingdom spain implement aid airlin intermediación aérea sl hereinaft refer interm provis air transport servic gerona madrid gerona rout letter commiss ask spanish author relev inform repli letter juli regist juli letter decemb commiss inform kingdom spain decis initi procedur provid articl ec treati regard aid commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european union commiss call parti concern submit comment aid letter januari perman represent spain european union spanish author ask time repli letter decemb letter tren januari commiss grant addit period work dai spanish author comment letter march refer regist secretariat gener commiss march commiss receiv comment subject parti concern forward kingdom spain letter march april allow opportun comment receiv comment letter ii detail descript aid legal basi aid inform commiss possess measur provid spanish author contract relat air rout serv citi gerona madrid conclud march generalitat de catalunya autonom govern catalonia diputación de girona gerona region council gerona chamber commerc industri repres interm hereinaft refer contract aim aid aid intend promot develop competit high qualiti air transport gerona madrid gerona rout aircraft meet condit comfort reliabl secur proper level profit rout procedur select compani provid servic lack schedul servic citi gerona madrid air carrier offer servic autonom govern catalonia contact nation carrier carrier member state commun aerolínea de balear aebal spanair spanair air europa línea aérea air europ klm uk ld interm air catalunya air catalunya ibertran aérea ibertran navegación servicio canario naysa individu letter period juli novemb inform initi encourag establish air link call submit tender state prepar ensur air link end process author autonom govern catalonia found air carrier shown avail capac ensur regular air servic fulfil public servic oblig inher interm contract conclud carrier gerona madrid gerona air link inform receiv spanish author gerona madrid gerona air link provid firstli mean schedul servic oper interm april seat atr aircraft charter servic oper complain case april sa aircraft gerona airport small airport passeng number develop year number passeng year number passeng content contract contract stipul provis servic question interm turboprop atr aircraft chief characterist seat arrang row inclin maximum load capac kg volum baggag hold maximum altitud feet flight speed kt km initi flight dai mondai fridai timet morn departur gerona departur madrid afternoon departur gerona departur madrid gener term flight timet passeng gerona minimum stai hour madrid time arriv destin fund servic maximum total amount aid period cover contract eur autonom govern catalonia gerona region council undertak bear cost fund air servic gerona madrid annual limit financi year financi year month oper air link generalitat de catalunya autonom govern catalonia diputación de girona gerona region council equal bear maximum amount eur rest financi year autonom govern catalonia gerona region council bear cost provid fund period sum eur autonom govern catalonia eur gerona region council financi year period includ regularis financi year ceil eur eur born autonom govern catalonia eur gerona region council financi year period ceil eur eur gerona region council fund half financi year eur autonom govern catalonia fund half financi year aid paid interm calcul basi averag annual occup rate seat aircraft oper gerona madrid gerona rout appli formula set annex contract inform spanish author cost flight calcul basi averag occup rate person eur broken item eur depreci aircraft insur line cost includ check electr system avion land gear inspect fuel inject system fuel staff cost cabin ground crew includ social secur airport charg land fee handl eurocontrol rout charg passeng servic cater press total advertis measur gerona region council undertak establish financ advertis promot market air link period valid contract maximum eur similarli gerona chamber commerc industri navig undertak prove field compet support ensur smooth function air servic cover contract termin contract provid contract termin event air carrier establish air servic gerona madrid characterist similar air servic cover contract term type aircraft frequenc fare period servic public aid state fund durat aid contract conclud period march decemb servic suspend decemb initi commiss formal investig procedur provis contract question provis occup rate regular punctual groundhandl servic applic fare ground decis initi procedur decis initi formal investig procedur commiss express doubt compat aid question articl ec treati lack complianc procedur establish articl council regul eec juli access commun air carrier intra commun air rout commiss ask spain send firstli data show compens net cost public servic question data calcul volum compens reason justifi complianc procedur establish articl regul eec iii comment parti concern compani air catalunya point air rout gerona madrid serv hand beneficiari aid public fund april compani draw attent harm consequ suffer fact obviou distort competit point gerona madrid gerona link subject public servic oblig accord procedur establish articl regul eec aid question compat treati meet requir necess proportion inher public servic role air catalunya suspend servic decemb austrian airlin austrian airlin add rule establish guidelin applic articl ec treati articl eea agreement state aid aviat sector case issu iv comment kingdom spain spanish author point formal investig procedur initi decemb payment aid interm suspend compani forc suspend gerona madrid air servic decemb cover cost involv show air servic question profit compani part fund gerona madrid rout subject time limit rout question consolid profit spanish author procedur led select interm complianc procedur laid articl regul eec impos public servic oblig rout autonom govern catalonia present formal request spanish ministri region develop view impos public servic oblig pso gerona madrid rout conform regul eec request reject ministri question ground suffici reason invok articl regul consider public servic spanish author materi requir demand regul eec servic question consid public gener interest servic fulli met fact airlin oper rout show econom interest rout gener public author intervent made guarante gerona madrid rout assur stabil regular servic regard import point air catalunya start oper gerona madrid rout time interm april date octob date previou compani stop oper rout compani cover gerona madrid rout rout consid essenti oper month justifi intervent public author view import rout citizen spanish author draw attent import establish air link gerona madrid econom develop region consequ infring articl regul eec formal condit impos oblig fulfil call tender open compani commun commiss member state subsidi benefit presumpt state aid mean articl ec treati subject gener rule treati govern matter analysi confirm guidelin evalu state aid air carrier commiss commun applic articl treati articl eea agreement state aid aviat sector paragraph state quot compens loss incur carrier select articl regul eec continu assess gener state aid rule rule appli compens calcul basi criteria articl regul quot spanish author absenc formal declar public servic oblig affect public servic natur rout question compens compat articl ec treati spanish author compens grant interm consid state aid mean articl ec treati unlaw prior notif commiss articl regul eec compli compat common market pursuant articl treati proper framework fund public servic impos air carrier featur case low impact competit commun trade suspens aid immedi initi formal investig procedur consequenti suspens air servic interm low intens aid short durat agreement limit month justifi except applic provis question articl appli compens proport compens requir impos interm agreement regular continu capac fare servic make flight unprofit compani condit impos author give rise addit cost compani oper commerci basi bear proof signific competitor cover gerona madrid rout subject requir frequenc capac continu impos interm compani oper rout past forc ceas uneconom fact airlin ask autonom govern offer servic show interest made clear doubt servic econom viabl air catalunya regard signific competitor fact air catalunya invit part select procedur tender accept compani hold air oper certif aoc licenc oper spain procedur provid articl regul eec imposit public servic oblig air catalunya part tender procedur restrict compani hold licenc oper schedul servic rate term offer flight schedul differ consider frequenc capac impos interm seat occupi aircraft charter air catalunya flight cancel passeng left rapid effici mean transport madrid lastli lack profit rout question underlin fact interm servic withdrawn compani air catalunya provid servic proportion subsidi aid grant interm exce minimum compens requir offset addit cost incur meet requir laid author compens interm amount eur clear annex iii agreement cost flight calcul basi averag occup rate person eur total flight oper interm period valid agreement gener revenu eur shortfal result provid servic eur figur calcul cost flight eur multipli number flight oper word eur revenu receiv eur aid grant public author eur shortfal sustain compani oper gerona madrid rout april decemb court justic european commun consist held quot grant state aid articl treati escap prohibit laid articl treati provid sole purpos aid question offset extra cost incur perform task assign undertak entrust oper servic gener econom interest grant aid order undertak perform public servic oblig condit econom equilibrium quot limit impact competit intra commun trade aid interm low intens eur million ad rel short contract month april decemb posit air catalunya potenti competitor rout question damag futur payment aid suspend initi procedur autonom govern gerona region council undertaken revok formal contract conclud interm neg impact grant aid interm competit trade member state minimis applic altmark case law spanish author case law emerg altmark case pend ecj date spanish author comment applic case issu case concern applic articl treati impos public servic oblig framework provid applic regul inland transport recoveri aid spanish author procedur initi subsidi grant interm conclud adopt commiss decis declar aid unlaw requir suspend order aid paid recov compat common market pursuant articl assess aid evalu aid accord articl treati articl treati aid grant state state resourc form whatsoev distort threaten distort competit favour undertak product incompat common market affect trade member state financi advantag paragraph commiss commun applic articl ec treati articl eea agreement state aid aviat sector establish presumpt aid involv provid public servic oblig impos relev compens calcul conform procedur provid articl regul eec access commun air carrier intra commun air rout criteria assess aid involv compens public servic subsequ clarifi judgment juli altmark case explain recit decis author autonom govern catalonia select compani fulfil oblig establish articl regul eec essenti guarante principl equal treatment proper function procedur commiss inform imposit public servic oblig gerona madrid gerona rout oblig publish offici journal european union member state consult invit tender publish offici journal european union tender submit air carrier commun member state concern commiss spanish author measur question nonetheless compens public servic oblig impos interm commiss consid establish public servic oblig aviat sector appli articl regul eec regul council establish uniform discriminatori rule grant air traffic right rout public servic oblig impos criteria calcul compens defin absenc inform contrari reimburs calcul accord articl regul made presum financi advantag air carrier concern articl regul eec quot member state reimburs air carrier select subparagraph satisfi standard requir public servic oblig impos paragraph reimburs account cost revenu gener servic quot commiss consid measur envisag spanish author regard compani interm compli provis articl regul presumpt exist aid appli case paragraph guidelin state aid aviat sector state quot compens loss incur carrier select articl regul eec continu assess gener state aid rule rule appli compens calcul basi criteria articl regul quot similarli paragraph establish quot accept reimburs consid light state aid principl interpret court justic case law quot commiss take view specif sector commun regul stipul public servic oblig award tender procedur failur compli regul mean compens grant constitut aid mean articl treati nonetheless commiss assess measur question grant financi advantag interm compens question compli criteria establish court case law judgment juli altmark case judgment confirm amount grant compens public servic oblig state aid provid condit met court judgment quot state measur regard compens servic provid recipi undertak order discharg public servic oblig undertak enjoi real financi advantag measur effect put favour competit posit undertak compet measur caught articl treati compens escap classif state aid case number condit satisfi quot court establish condit condit appli case fourth condit altern order elimin financi advantag whatsoev compens condit establish court recipi undertak requir discharg public servic oblig oblig defin condit paramet basi compens calcul establish object transpar manner case issu recipi undertak requir discharg oblig defin contract oblig paramet calcul compens establish annex iii iv contract result negoti conduct compet region author compani select provid air transport servic fact autonom govern catalonia contact carrier individu letter period juli novemb order inform initi encourag establish air rout invit submit tender state prepar oper air servic process region author invit airlin contact submit tender letter detail oblig impos compani paramet compens rule airlin respond request region author interest conclud contract specif detail oblig paramet calcul compens request region author commiss consid case issu public servic oblig defin clear transpar manner condit laid altmark judgment satisfi contract conclud march autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber trade industri gerona repres intermediación aérea sl interm simpli announc press releas offici publish commiss inform access interest parti addit air transport sector paramet calcul compens advanc object transpar manner establish method laid commun legisl articl regul eec compli addit commiss consid paramet basi compens calcul case hand establish advanc object transpar manner condit altmark judgment satisfi condit laid court compens exce cover part cost incur discharg public servic oblig take account relev receipt reason profit discharg oblig complianc condit essenti ensur recipi undertak advantag distort threaten distort competit strengthen undertak competit posit purpos condit avoid overcompens paid undertak avoid situat type amount compens grant mean undertak surplu cash devot activ distort competit aviat sector method legisl avoid overcompens minimis harm effect limit market access strict complianc tender procedur laid articl regul eec commiss consid tender procedur prior purchas member state regard suffici rule possibl member state concern seek grant advantag undertak court instanc confirm approach absenc invit tender believ difficult determin precis amount receiv interm correspond cost aris discharg public servic oblig repres overcompens advantag favour spanish author amount subsidi grant deficit run month servic oper overcompens commiss consid absenc object mean establish level compens pursuant compulsori rule laid council rule compani offer servic question lower level subsidi commiss consid condit altmark judgment satisfi case issu fourth condit altern quot undertak discharg public servic oblig specif case chosen pursuant public procur procedur select tender capabl provid servic cost commun quot quot level compens need determin basi analysi cost typic undertak run adequ provid mean transport meet public servic requir incur discharg oblig take account relev receipt reason profit discharg oblig quot altern fourth condit satisfi case issu select procedur spanish author compli criteria transpar object essenti public tender procedur point recit decis regard genuin competit regard suffici transpar ensur quot cost commun quot altern fourth condit refer recit appli principl oblig issu invit tender oblig exist compli nonetheless assum altern fourth condit appli case issu commiss conclud compli compens calcul basi quot analysi cost typic undertak run adequ provid mean transport meet public servic requir incur discharg requir take account relev receipt reason profit discharg oblig quot explain analysi condit author carri advanc analysi cost compat standard confin provid compens actual cost incur oper question spanish author provid data enabl commiss carri check circumst obviou fourth condit laid altmark judgment satisfi commiss find condit altmark judgment satisfi case issu light forego measur involv advantag beneficiari transfer state resourc concept state aid term treati interpret court justic refer advantag grant directli indirectli state resourc constitut addit burden state bodi appoint set purpos case issu contract beneficiari compani receiv maximum eur durat contract fund autonom govern catalonia gerona region council confirm spanish author amount aid paid amount eur fact amount directli grant spanish author confirm presenc state resourc select natur measur measur question concern transport sector air transport provis singl air rout gerona madrid gerona contract conclud singl airlin inform receiv spanish author deduc measur appli compani decid provid schedul air transport servic madrid gerona measur question consid select impact competit intra commun trade order make find distort competit suffici state intervent artifici modifi element undertak product cost strengthen undertak posit vi vi undertak compet intra commun trade court consid imposs public subsidi grant undertak local region transport servic provid transport servic state origin nonetheless effect trade member state court stress aid capabl affect trade member state distort condit competit competit undertak member state undertak receiv aid particip cross border activ member state grant aid undertak intern suppli maintain increas consequ opportun undertak establish member state offer servic market member state reduc accord recit thereto articl thereof commiss regul ec januari applic articl ec treati de minimi aid appli transport sector court case law threshold percentag consid trade member state affect small amount aid small size undertak receiv exclud possibl trade member state affect case issu air link gerona madrid serv oper receiv public fund receiv public fund true contract termin claus appli event air carrier establish air servic gerona madrid characterist similar air servic cover contract concern term type aircraft frequenc fare period servic public aid state fund compet oper servic compli abovement characterist smaller aircraft select natur confirm oper oper rout receiv aid fact complain case oper gerona madrid gerona air link receiv public aid inform receiv spanish author complain establish charter flight oper gerona madrid gerona rout aircraft seat meet requir contract measur question affect trade member state concern compani transport activ natur directli affect trade cover part common market addit distort competit market aim singl undertak competit commun airlin entri forc air transport liberalis packag packag januari circumst grant advantag interm spanish author aid mean articl ec treati advertis promot market measur agre gerona region council view establish financ advertis promot market air rout period valid contract maximum eur regard state aid measur financ public fund intend make creation air servic gener public conclus condit articl treati met commiss conclud measur state aid measur examin order ascertain compat treati legal aid commiss deplor fact spain implement aid contravent articl ec treati compat aid applic articl determin measur consider natur state aid fall scope articl treati assess confirm spanish author commiss examin measur consid compat common market mean articl articl treati commiss assess compat aid pursuant articl treati aid social charact grant individu consum compat common market provid aid grant discrimin relat origin product concern commiss commun state aid aviat sector aid social charact principl cover specif categori passeng travel rout children handicap peopl low incom peopl case rout concern link underprivileg region island aid cover entir popul region commun aid grant discrimin origin servic eea air carrier oper servic impli absenc barrier entri rout concern commun air carrier case issu aid paid sole airlin oper link question exclus compet oper legal basi aid airlin access aid scheme aid satisfi condit requir discrimin oper derog provid articl appli case issu aid intend make good damag caus natur disast except occurr articl list aid consid compat common market order safeguard proper function common market regard principl set articl treati derog articl defin articl strictli interpret examin aid scheme individu measur view increas competit liberalis air transport commiss abid rigor polici monitor state aid make secondari effect contrari common interest paragraph derog aid promot facilit develop area commiss note gerona region area cover articl derog applic commiss note gerona region elig benefit derog articl treati district situat pyrene relev case paragraph applic aid intend promot import project common interest remedi disturb economi member state promot cultur heritag conserv case spanish author invok derog derog provid paragraph concern aid facilit develop econom activ commiss consid oper aid intend encourag invest authoris except circumst end note aid environment train purpos commiss derog appli restructur undertak case interm aid compar start aid analysi made recit applic articl treati justif invok spanish author concern applic articl treati respect commiss consid aid declar compat basi provis treati condit satisfi necess proportion aid commiss point spanish author contest provis articl regul eec compli suggest spanish author impos public servic oblig air link question confirm administr procedur initi commiss request catalan region author june compet spanish author refus initi procedur impos public servic oblig ground suffici reason invok articl regul circumst contradictori maintain hand servic framework articl treati servic question order appli normal legal framework applic public servic oblig aviat sector absenc complianc procedur establish articl regul eec proportion aid confirm spanish author amount subsidi grant deficit run month servic oper overcompens commiss disput amount aid deficit servic absenc object mean establish level compens pursuant mandatori rule laid council rule compani offer servic question lower level subsidi clear court case law joint assess compat carri arrang aid contraven specif provis ec treati articl inextric link object aid manner imposs evalu separ situat condit provis ad compat requir aris articl ec treati addit clear state aid procedur lead result contrari specif provis treati commun regul adopt basi provis case issu procedur articl regul eec inextric link aid accord case law declar aid compat arrang grant compli articl regul eec sentenc articl treati addit requir quot develop trade affect extent contrari interest commun quot commiss consid case contrari commun interest authoris aid grant breach regul eec aid question declar compat articl treati start aid recit commiss decis ec februari advantag grant walloon region brussel south charleroi airport airlin ryanair connect establish charleroi commiss consid aid measur develop oper region airport infrastructur repres cost local commun interest european commun level form part object common transport polici decis commiss consid oper aid intend launch airlin strengthen frequenc tool develop small region airport measur persuad interest compani risk invest rout order declar aid compat basi articl treati determin aid proport object sought affect trade extent contrari common interest oper aid rare declar compat common market distort condit competit area grant capabl natur achiev aim laid exempt provis treati fact involv technic structur alter busi favour commerci develop busi offer artifici favour condit client increas profit margin justif number except principl commiss past declar type aid compat provid condit met order declar aid compat basi articl determin aid paid case issu proportion object sought affect trade degre contrari common interest aim measur presenc commun interest condit grant start aid form part coher airport develop project reflect willing develop profit infrastructur profit promot region develop tourism local economi region imag spin coher polici intend foremost develop airport activ long term basi region airport provid solut problem transport polici capac satur major airport case inform suggest compani wish start rout gerona destin access similar aid commiss inform exist project develop airport activ spanish author state gerona airport schedul flight establish servic gerona madrid aid commiss defin criterion aid ryanair decis respect start aid essenti develop airport condit met firstli aid grant airlin appli open rout frequenc gener increas net volum passeng depart region airport part risk born compani aid paid rout oper risk run compani aid justifi compani oper rout airport benefit public aid thirdli aid paid airlin rout start oper substitut abandon rout previous benefit start aid thing equal airport net posit effect term number passeng arriv site aid grant rout provid compani replac rout previous serv airport locat econom catchment area popul centr commiss fact consid essenti start aid creat spiral subsidi reloc rout maximum aid grant practic fact run contrari object start aid develop airport concern keep common interest fourthli aid intend assist entrant open link open enter direct competit exist oper work rout airport arriv reli strength public aid compet exist oper regard fourth condit point gerona madrid gerona rout oper compani octob compani abandon servic unprofit rout oper carrier time conclus contract public author concern interm march oper air catalunya start oper link dai april interm start oper april fact compani start oper gerona madrid gerona rout dai make imposs determin definit servic provid interm consid rout condit met case issu madrid gerona madrid rout oper interm start expenditur market advertis make rout consid view aim inform gener public exist air rout incent natur aid aid incent effect busi develop activ embark public support activ prove profit aid long term reason aid intend launch connect increas frequenc limit time aid launch rout maintain rout artifici rout eventu econom viabl commiss consid framework start aid aviat sector maximum period year open connect reason intra european point point link case issu part fund gerona madrid rout public measur limit time contract valid year rout question consolid achiev profit air oper public aid state fund establish air servic gerona madrid characterist servic cover contract concern type aircraft frequenc fare servic period proportion aid proportion establish form link aid context firstli strict link aim airport develop net growth passeng traffic level aid paid airlin total aid calcul passeng airlin deliv airport volum passeng develop unduli favour convers compani meet target make develop airport reap benefit link assess regard proportion aid cost incur beneficiari commiss point aid intens commiss limit case start aid appli oper cost net receipt airlin concern cost elig start aid addit start cost air oper bear quot cruis speed quot reach requir public contribut order share risk viabil link start period case interm concern market advertis cost incur outset make link start cost born interm gerona site convers aid grant relat interm standard oper cost hire depreci aircraft fuel crew salari cater servic cost transpar equal treatment oper discrimin grant aid amount aid grant airlin develop air servic transpar calcul embark passeng order easili identifi identifi fact airport readi grant aid return econom servic launch rout publicis order make interest airlin present stake claim rule principl relat procur contract concess observ applic object criteria develop airport wish encourag develop air servic term maximum total period aid order ensur equal treatment airlin appeal procedur provid member state level order ensur discrimin exercis grant aid airlin favour unfairli airport penalti repay mechan penalti mechan implement carrier fail undertak made relat airport aid paid system recov aid airport ensur airlin honour commit contract case issu fact mechan recov aid interm honour commit overlap aid aid grant principl combin subsidi receiv air carrier aid social natur compens public servic defin aid accord rule proportion combin aid cost includ aid paid state sum total aid rout benefit exce start cost destin question order preserv incent charact start aid air link time develop tool region airport commiss believ ensur aid give indirect advantag larg airport larg open intern traffic competit specif attent paid limit elig cost airlin link gerona case major airport madrid addit aid grant access rout reserv carrier articl regul eec paragraph articl case issu interm receiv rout gerona subsidi social aid compens public servic refer access rout oper interm gerona reserv carrier tender procedur provid articl regul eec descript measur requir undertaken member state concern order make aid compat commiss note aid paid autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber commerc industri gerona interm fulfil condit applic start aid intend promot air servic oper region airport fulfil condit impos case ensur compat amount paid autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber commerc industri gerona fund air servic gerona madrid consid compat common market start aid rout subject condit contribut form part programm develop gerona airport contribut subject time limit period exce maximum year open rout question contribut paid aid intend entrant open link open enter direct competit exist oper oper rout similar condit depart gerona airport contribut justifi mean develop plan establish interm valid compet author rout concern plan cost incur elig directli concern promot rout order make viabl aid termin contract elig cost directli relat start recit decis compet author assist independ auditor task sum total aid rout benefit exce start advertis cost destin question similarli contribut paid exce actual cost connect destin contribut paid autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber commerc industri gerona end start period provid contract prove exceed criteria laid reimburs interm spain establish discriminatori transpar aid scheme ensur equal treatment airlin wish develop air servic depart gerona airport accord object criteria establish decis condit met spain recov aid refer recit vi conclus adopt decis articl state aid implement kingdom spain airlin intermediación aérea sl amount eur hand eur declar compat common market basi articl start aid rout subject condit articl contribut form part programm develop gerona airport contribut subject time limit period exce maximum year open rout question contribut paid aid intend entrant open link open enter direct competit exist oper oper rout similar condit depart gerona airport contribut justifi mean develop plan establish interm valid compet author rout concern plan cost incur elig directli concern promot rout order make viabl aid contract interm autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber commerc industri gerona expir elig cost directli relat start meet condit cover addit start cost airlin bear fulli oper requir public contribut order share risk viabil link start period convers cover standard oper cost hire depreci aircraft fuel crew salari cater servic cost compet author assist independ auditor task total sum aid rout benefit exce start advertis cost destin question similarli contribut paid exce actual cost connect destin contribut paid autonom govern catalonia gerona region council chamber commerc industri gerona end start period provid contract prove exceed criteria laid reimburs interm spain establish discriminatori transpar aid scheme ensur equal treatment airlin wish develop air servic depart gerona airport accord object criteria laid decis articl kingdom spain measur recov beneficiari aid incompat common market refer articl unlawfulli made recoveri place immedi accord procedur nation law provid permit effect implement decis aid recov includ interest compound date aid made beneficiari date recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival framework region aid articl kingdom spain inform commiss month date notif decis measur compli articl decis address kingdom spain brussel octob commiss loyola de palacio vice presid oj note websit www aena es aeropuerto español navegación aérea septemb oj regul amend regul ec european parliament council oj oj initi month air catalunya oper charter flight permit issu director gener civil aviat danish compani north fly licenc held compani oestavi case la post ecr case altmark ecr judgment court instanc august join case amp european ferri ecr state quot accord commiss settl practic fact tender procedur conduct member state make purchas consid suffici possibl member state seek grant advantag undertak rule inform commiss commun framework state aid research develop oj paragraph effect commun guidelin state aid maritim transport oj chapter quot judgment februari adbhu case ecr paragraph sentenc judgment novemb fer case ecr paragraph paragraph altmark judgment court judgment august join case amp european ferri ecr footnot court judgment juli itali commiss case ecr septemb philip morri case ecr paragraph altmark judgment court judgment march itali commiss case ecr paragraph judgment juli franc commiss case ecr paragraph judgment march itali commiss case ecr paragraph oj altmark judgment paragraph judgment march belgium commiss quot tubemeus quot case ecr paragraph judgment septemb spain commiss case ecr paragraph commiss commun guidelin region state aid oj refer region aid made paragraph guidelin state aid aviat sector footnot comment spanish author letter march regist secretariat gener commiss march judgment march case iannelli ecr judgment june case matra commiss ecr oj ryanair decis recit ryanair decis recit ryanair decis recit ryanair decis recit