commiss decis juli state aid grant germani gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh subsidiari walzwerk burg gmbh notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun articl thereof regard treati establish european coal steel commun articl thereof regard agreement european econom area protocol thereto regard commiss decis ecsc novemb ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid steel industri notic parti concern submit comment accord abovement provis regard comment procedur letter date june germani notifi commiss articl ec treati financ measur preced accompani privatis gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh gröditzer subsidiari walzwerk burg gmbh burg letter date august commiss inform germani decid initi procedur laid articl decis ecsc respect state aid involv commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european commun commiss gave notic interest parti submit comment measur germani suppli commiss inform paper letter date septemb novemb juli august octob januari februari march meet commiss germani place januari decemb march april commiss receiv observ interest parti forward germani germani comment letter date april detail descript measur notif notif june germani state year gröditzer receiv financ amount dem million made dem million sharehold loan provid success public sharehold compani dem million bank loan guarante treuhandanstalt privatis agenc successor bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv dem million outright grant dem million paid gröditzer separ joint feder govern länder region develop scheme gemeinschaftsaufgab verbesserung der regionalen wirtschaftsstruktur germani inform commiss public sharehold beteiligung manag gesellschaft mbh bmgb sold gröditzer wholli own subsidiari burg georgsmarienhütt gmbh georgsmarienhütt januari sale gröditzer burg cost bmgb total dem million result waiver sharehold loan redempt bank loan germani state georgsmarienhütt submit offer take account commit respect job invest transfer technolog initi procedur commiss decid initi procedur laid decis ecsc sixth steel aid code letter germani august publish offici journal european commun letter initi procedur commiss argu assum stage sharehold loan dem million constitut aid free interest compani provid secur guarante bank loan dem million likewis appear constitut aid premium compat dem million region aid examin turn privatis commiss doubt sale neg price accord privat investor principl figur appear costli wind compani clear privatis procedur open transpar uncondit lastli privatis agreement appear commit bmgb provid invest aid gröditzer total state resourc transfer prior privatis gt tabl gt quot outright grant quot column includ dem million notifi dem million region aid dem million social measur dem million tax incent sum identifi germani procedur figur break invest measur gröditzer receiv total transfer state resourc dem million invest programm cost dem million detail invest programm suppli commiss show take compani busi invest year sum dem million made item dem million form sharehold loan loan free interest schedul drawn repay dem million form loan provid bank guarante success public sharehold gröditzer outright grant amount dem million region aid dem million tax incent invest applic legisl invest allow act investitionszulagengesetz legal basi sharehold loan guarante germani cite gener restructur oblig impos articl german unif treati paragraph treuhand act expenditur invest aid relat germani inform commiss dem million invest steelmak dem million invest product facil fall scope ecsc treati invest detail decis initi procedur social measur social measur total dem million compris dem million paid social plan compris redund earli retir scheme employ pool cost rule born compani view gröditzer financi difficulti cover sharehold loan provid erel verwaltung gmbh amp manag kg erel bmgb paid gröditzer sum dem million cover cost social measur top social plan main measur reduct work hour train redund staff germani public sharehold financ measur east german compani respons dem million financ employ measur paragraph employ promot act arbeitsförderungsgesetz act scheme set emploi redund dismiss staff current treuhand compani environment clean activ rule public author compani concern contribut cost measur figur dem million quot embodi share fall gröditzer ow financi difficulti unabl pai oper measur sharehold loan dem million cover oper measur notif state aid oper measur amount dem million procedur clear figur dem million fact social measur sum refer recit point august germani submit commiss report prepar kpmg report alloc dem million gröditzer product area post basi establish cash flow requir ebdit ergebni year kpmg find base gröditzer intern bookkeep system german govern endors kpmg conclus kpmg divid monei oper measur dem million cover accru oper loss gröditzer divis forg ring roll mill foundri total loss amount dem million partial offset oper profit dem million steelmak plant dem million overhead dem million need compli contractu oblig settl claim aros decis stop invest programm origin gdr period dem million site clean clearanc oper dem million cover miscellan cost sum refer point recit kpmg assign total dem million steelmak plant assign rest ecsc sector financi measur connect privatis gröditzer subsidiari burg sold georgsmarienhütt januari notif total cost neg purchas price privatis dem million main cost waiver sharehold loan recoveri subsidi redempt guarante bank loan recit total cost includ fund provid seller publicli own bmgb dem million provid quot equiti assist quot eigenkapitalhilf notif financ dem million invest programm privatis agreement oper purpos dem million paid quot bridg financ quot zuschüssen zur zwischenfinanzierung offset region aid dem million gröditzer dem million burg privatis januari gröditzer receiv region aid amount dem million privatis agreement gröditzer remain entitl remaind dem million dem million burg burg separ compani oper ecsc sector sold gröditzer public sharehold erel time privatis previous gröditzer subsidiari comment interest parti januari februari comment submit commiss interest parti belong group max aicher gmbh amp neue maxhütt stahlwerk gmbh lech stahlwerk gmbh argu sale neg price provid georgsmarienhütt cash inject enabl georgsmarienhütt improv financi posit financ acquisit condit sale gröditzer distort competit comment germani germani comment initi procedur letter septemb provid inform paper refer recit comment account repli comment interest parti germani state sale gröditzer affect georgsmarienhütt cash posit privatis agreement georgsmarienhütt undertaken sell gröditzer asset event sale share suspens pend outcom commiss assess aid grant gröditzer compani price determin arm length basi common cash manag georgsmarienhütt support posit germani assess treati applic burg gröditzer burg state decis initi procedur burg separ ecsc compani sold gröditzer public sharehold time privatis privatis gröditzer subsidiari privatis serv steel servic centr gröditzer burg consid ec treati germani submit burg size financi measur benefit notifi basi arrang govern treuhandanstalt oper approv commiss recent decis aid measur letter refer commiss burg posit respect privatis enter total cost liquid gröditzer ecsc rule steel undertak initi procedur gröditzer undertak engag product liquid steel ingot steel product scope annex ecsc treati fall articl ecsc treati subject levi articl ecsc treati worthwhil recal posit ecsc steel undertak länder address number decis undertak qualifi exempt strict requir decis ecsc steel aid code thing allow receiv region invest aid decis articl ecsc treati unanim assent council approv wide rang aid payment eko stahl sew freital order enabl return viabil vital consider privatis basi reach rescu restructur measur aid measur gröditzer case notifi commiss contrari arrang govern treuhandanstalt aid notifi advanc compani oper sensit industri notif place compani privatis aid form sharehold loan paid gröditzer ecsc undertak aid measur qualifi permit steel aid code forc time aid research develop environment measur closur mean ecsc undertak receiv state aid kind oper aid region invest aid basi articl ecsc treati commiss made clear decid initi procedur principl aid benefit ecsc steel produc undertak assess ecsc treati result uncondition ecsc treati appli ecsc undertak manufactur ecsc product commiss accept except rule aid ecsc undertak assess relev provis ec treati aid activ cover ec treati complet separ activ fall scope ecsc treati initi procedur commiss view condit satisfi gröditzer compani separ account commiss consid danger spillov differenti state aid receiv alloc ecsc ecsc activ german repli respons initi procedur germani contest commiss view gröditzer ecsc undertak engag steel product germani alloc financi measur compani ecsc ecsc activ germani argu yearli averag ecsc steel product manufactur gröditzer sold outsid situat continu todai gröditzer input forg cast ring roll mill facil steel process ecsc steel product aid plant affect competit respect product scope ec treati assess state aid rule ec treati invest measur concern germani contend relev fix asset relat specif product facil invest assess ecsc treati facil manufactur ecsc product amount dem million invest aid assess ec treati turn social plan oper measur germani refer kpmg report mention recit endors conclus alloc aid ecsc ecsc facil germani consid financ respect activ directli relat product ecsc steel product assess state aid rule ec treati letter march germani state aid gröditzer consid state aid rule ec treati commiss view ecsc rule state aid lai rule aid measur distort competit recipi undertak competitor market ecsc product state aid rule ec treati appli aid measur distort competit undertak market ec product rule aid ecsc undertak assess ecsc treati circumst ec treati appli aid ecsc activ carri ecsc undertak provid separ undertak ecsc activ order ascertain activ assist case fact separ form aid grant consid individu invest aid gröditzer singl compani separ account activ make difficult ascrib aid area busi true aid invest relat fix asset product facil gröditzer ecsc product process physic separ steel made steel plant proce facil gröditzer premis forg ring roll mill foundri end product plant end product steelmak plant sold relev market manufactur dedic facil product process integr physic separ make distinguish ecsc ec activ case invest aid oper aid social measur true oper measur social measur direct link loan grant activ financ aid measur assess separ ecsc ec treati distinct drawn aid ecsc activ aid activ gröditzer case separ account bookkeep facilit distinct case real danger spillov activ conclud aid ecsc undertak assess ecsc rule gt tabl gt show resourc provid gröditzer oper purpos claus mechan alloc ecsc ecsc activ alloc left discret compani ant criteria ration separ product area gröditzer total steel output sold market process end product compani gröditzer intern price bookkeep system steelmak plant transfer product downstream full repay direct indirect cost fact compani sell end product heavi loss appear figur provid procedur initi gröditzer made profit accru loss dem million year year oper cost exceed turnov averag dem million year assign profit loss intern bookkeep system arbitrari account fact product process loss make kpmg report show result gröditzer branch activ year basi intern bookkeep system show gröditzer product steel product oper profit account forg ring roll mill foundri oper loss cost account appli busi gröditzer logic circumst forg foundri ring roll mill continu virtu oper aid receiv mean gröditzer devot resourc place steelmak plant ecsc product area steelmak plant enjoi benefit aid downstream ec activ forego evid provid show separ ecsc ec activ account point view insuffici demonstr oper aid activ consid treati unlik invest aid clear separ vollkommen trennung compani activ conclus oper aid social aid provid germani subject state aid rule ecsc treati overcapac steel industri strict disciplin observ case invest fix asset gröditzer product ec product ec treati aid rule appli recit aid invest fix asset gröditzer product ecsc product subject state aid rule ecsc treati assess financi measur preced privatis gener notif identifi invest aid form guarante bank loan dem million sharehold loan dem million region aid dem million joint feder govern länder scheme paid octob germani inform commiss invest allow investitionszulag grant year cover invest gröditzer firm difficulti accru substanti loss set success public sharehold provid loan oblig respect repay interest clear privat investor advanc loan gröditzer sharehold loan constitut state aid entireti commiss made clear commun member state public undertak manufactur sector state guarante firm difficulti state aid equal entir amount loan guarante procedur germani inform commiss premium equal risk assess place commiss opinion view gröditzer financi difficulti premium extrem low guarante constitut state aid entireti explain recit invest aid assess treati invest aid relat ecsc plant assess articl ecsc treati steel aid code applic time grant invest aid relat ec plant assess rule articl ec treati rule applic invest aid time grant detail assess set assess invest aid ecsc steel plant articl ecsc treati subsidi aid grant state form whatsoev incompat common market prohibit except rule made success steel aid code germani state invest steelmak plant dem million financ invest allow remaind financ sharehold loan guarante bank loan region aid joint feder govern länder scheme cover invest steelmak plant part invest aid grant lifetim steel aid code articl code state aid grant steel undertak invest gener region aid scheme deem compat common market provid undertak locat territori gdr aid notifi june approv paid decemb invest allow invest allow act deadlin payment decemb aid notifi june court instanc confirm preußag stahl commiss notif approv deadlin steel aid code bind commiss commiss prevent aid notifi june assess decemb question element aid elig substant term irrelev invest aid amount dem million assign steel plant incompat ecsc treati steel aid code assess aid invest ecsc product facil invest ecsc facil amount dem million total aid grant invest amount dem million aid includ dem million region aid dem million invest allow remaind financ sharehold loan guarante bank loan sharehold loan bank loan grant gener provis unif treati treuhand act octob germani inform commiss period consider joint feder govern länder region develop scheme appli treuhand compani grant guarante loan treuhandanstalt successor act de facto region aid author loan substitut region invest aid commiss recal period consider ceil region invest aid joint feder govern länder scheme includ aid grant region aid scheme gross germani hand contend success arrang govern activ treuhandanstalt higher amount grant invest aid argument accept gröditzer steel undertak steel aid code allow invest aid steel undertak aid declar exempt gener prohibit limit period time maximum intens confirm eko stahl case reiter commiss report implement steel aid code gröditzer oper sensit sector purpos success treuhandanstalt arrang framework steel sector cover ecsc treati explain concept sensit sector take ecsc steel product preliminari process ecsc steel includ thing forg cast gröditzer oper area sensit sector treuhandanstalt arrang aid firm sensit sector notifi circumst treuhandanstalt arrang make provis except notif requir specif exclud sensit sector state commiss assess aid sector rule forc guidelin state aid rescu restructur firm difficulti guidelin nation region aid explain possibl approv aid ecsc sector limit gröditzer ecsc compani legal basi permit rescu restructur aid treati restructur aid allow ecsc firm decis articl ecsc treati overrid consider return viabil context privatis gröditzer case restructur plan show return viabil submit germani consid invest aid grant region aid substitut region aid commiss take view legal basi invest aid assess provid guidelin nation region aid forc time aid grant gröditzer ec activ sensit sector framework steel sector cover ecsc treati region aid ceil appli commiss opinion region invest aid ceil exceed commiss conclud aid intens constitut unaccept distort competit invest aid ec activ assess basi ceil region invest aid approv connect joint feder govern länder region scheme total intens aid admiss scheme region aid scheme time question gross commiss find aid paid cover invest gröditzer ecsc activ amount dem million declar compat common market articl ec treati equal dem million remaind amount dem million incompat common market articl ec treati assess social measur social measur total dem million explain recit monei grant employ promot measur paragraph employ promot act dem million constitut state aid commiss accept german argument sum dem million paid social plan constitut gener measur grant specif undertak resourc undertak distinct mean social aid total dem million explain social aid assess ecsc treati articl ecsc treati subsidi aid grant state form whatsoev incompat common market prohibit except rule made success steel aid code aid consider grant lifetim steel aid code sixth steel aid code ident provis order qualifi aid steel aid code social measur paid worker made redund accept earli retir aris total partial closur steel plant regular product time notif aid exce payment level customari member state januari inform provid germani product capac gröditzer fell year year annual steel product fell end employe left compani ow reduct capac fund provid financ redund earli retir scheme short time work train facil benefit gröditzer employe social measur aim staff ultim left compani commiss opinion measur compat common market assess oper measur sum dem million financ sharehold loan paid cover oper cost year breakdown detail recit explain aid assess ecsc treati articl ecsc treati subsidi aid grant state form whatsoev incompat common market prohibit except rule made success steel aid code code permit oper aid recit explain oper aid consid intend purpos earmark ration basi advanc aid incompat ecsc treati steel aid code commiss note privatis sum dem million repai part sharehold loan total amount loan grant oper purpos dem million assess measur connect privatis summari argument put forward germani german view privatis compris state aid rest argument place georgsmarienhütt bid involv cost form neg purchas price outcom advantag public sharehold sell compani cost entail liquid gröditzer higher privat investor sold gröditzer basi place georgsmarienhütt bid emerg uncondit open transpar procedur georgsmarienhütt bidder submit busi plan satisfi seller demand germani refer commiss polici sale privatis process open transpar uncondit constitut aid cost privatis gröditzer argument put forward germani price secur neg privatis advantag liquid cost liquid gröditzer dem million gross dem million net deduct liquid gröditzer asset total cost privatis gröditzer prove dem million germani contend privatis cheapest option price arriv satisfi privat investor test kpmg liquid report germani cost liquid gröditzer dem million break liabil dem million sharehold loan dem million guarante bank loan dem million liabil dem million provis miscellan cost dem million cost liquid dem million oper run cost incur liquid process court justic held hytasa case privat sharehold limit compani liabl debt compani liquid compani asset liquid report liquid asset dem million sum satisfi debt compani order rank applic german insolv law cost liquid limit dem million figur dem million assum full satisfact debt public author necessit fund court held judgment calcul incorrect court found guid prospect viabil long term consider imag reput privat investor contribut capit compani sold inject link sale undertak case hope profit long term oper costlier sell asset reason appli case liquid court held distinct drawn oblig state assum owner share capit compani oblig public author gröditzer case germani cite item total cost liquid seri cost sharehold fact cost state bear capac public author repay dem million guarante bank loan guarante provid treuhandanstalt bv bodi feder institut own directli state time privatis state sharehold place erel bmgb likewis feder institut direct state control guarante claim loan repaid compani asset made sharehold erel treuhandanstalt bv state institut provis dem million exist environment damag altlasten recit sum dem million cost aris social plan requir bind oblig provis dem million cost site clearanc demolish build complet clear site sell site parti fact sell price amount dem million gröditzer financi situat privat investor provid addit fund social plan sale land dem million privat investor decid clear site gröditzer legal oblig clear site sharehold inject addit fund compani liquid cost kind born state germani contend event insolv german law class sharehold loan equiti eigenkapitalersatz equiti substitut mean claim back asset sharehold loan constitut capit sharehold made compani recov liquid commiss remain opinion accord case law court justic cost liquid compris liquid asset dem million sharehold loan includ cost liquid full total dem million asset dem million sharehold loan dem million cost privatis dem million liquid cheaper privat investor wound compani regard dem million environment cost commiss see addit argument fact compar cost liquid cost privatis germani compar figur germani state event liquid environment cost born sharehold case privatis cost aris exist environment damag cover except arrang laid land saxoni privatis cost list germani includ provis exist environment liabil object comparison dem million site clearanc exclud cost liquid includ cost privatis cost privatis includ dem million made rise dem million privatis procedur turn argument germani inform commiss june public sharehold instruct invest bank warburg amp freyberg hambro search candid septemb bank issu memorandum inform gröditzer subsidiari burg basi bid made total potenti interest investor ask supplementari inform georgsmarienhütt industri technolog jp select technic financi background bilater negoti enter germani submit synopsi state negoti parti view takeov place januari angebotssynops für gsw vor endverhandlungen mit gmh inform suppli germani georgsmarienhütt award contract compani provid busi plan request offer financi conceptu term german author forward georgsmarienhütt busi plan unternehmenskonzept gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh commiss consid procedur uncondit memoranda issu invest bank call bind bid potenti interest parti ask submit busi plan put forward detail commit job creat save futur invest financ select invit bilater negoti commit enter decis influenc purchas price memoranda expressli mention possibl state aid grant concret bid sought paramet ceil laid assess bid commiss consid procedur open transpar negoti enter parti basi document compris open call bid meet clear requir invit open individu negoti commit enter seller buyer finalis negoti process defin commit ultim enter influenc purchas price negoti differ posit final negoti necessarili due method chosen commiss consid georgsmarienhütt offer busi plan constitut bind bid circumst differ offer inher procedur chosen georgsmarienhütt candid final opportun close negoti adapt final posit seller requir commiss opinion privatis place basi open transpar uncondit procedur german argument tender open transpar uncondit accept amount aid gröditzer consider line establish practic commiss consid sale made term unaccept privat investor neg sale price constitut aid bulk neg sale price consist waiver redempt partial takeov loan recoveri subsidi measur assess order calcul state aid compon privatis account financi measur refer recit commit enter seller bmgb agreement privatis gröditzer amount dem million subsidi invest oper purpos dem million form loan paid back receipt region aid joint feder govern länder region scheme stage date dem million paid measur pursuant privatis agreement enter forc januari total dem million figur dem million paid dem million aid commit residu loan privatis agreement paid alloc sum germani total dem million invest gröditzer figur dem million steel product dem million plant cover ec treati remain dem million oper purpos assess aid gröditzer consider set recit lead conclus dem million invest steel product oper aid dem million assess steel aid code invest aid ecsc product plant includ region aid joint feder govern länder region develop scheme assess light ceil region aid sixth steel aid code gener invest aid oper aid ecsc steel industri amount concern dem million dem million dem million incompat articl ecsc treati sixth steel aid code germani suppli data alloc sum dem million remain paid privatis agreement conclud aid cover invest ecsc sector aid incompat common market coal steel articl ecsc treati sixth steel aid code invest aid ecsc product plant assess relev provis ec treati applic rule region aid total admiss intens aid combin region aid measur gross relev invest amount dem million dem million declar compat common market remaind amount dem million constitut state aid incompat common market aid burg addit aid burg connect privatis amount dem million advanc payment futur region aid explain recit commiss confirm aid burg remain limit set success arrang govern treuhand aid compat common market transfer fix asset order properli implement commiss decis requir recoveri state aid member state behav privat creditor care member state exercis collect thing tax social secur debt domest law appli appli claim made pure domest law collect render imposs extrem difficult gener principl mean member state seek collect debt mean take measur enforc claim asset debtor seek liquid debtor undertak undertak unabl repai debt liquid result insolv proceed undertak remain asset sold rais problem sale take place supervis liquid requir seek result interest creditor proce sale asset satisfi claim proce sale asset suffici pai undertak debt ensur full repay liquid import term competit compet undertak suffer injuri result incompat state aid opportun fill gap market left liquid undertak bui asset sold view effici initi procedur case shortli adopt final decis commiss learnt gröditzer asset transfer undertak control bv current gröditzer asset market price attempt sell open market object effect proceed asset reach commiss decis continu weakest part busi contradict duti member state ensur oblig impos commiss decis compli collect debt member state act ordinari creditor seek ensur danger collect debt contest annul make mean domest law provis govern fraud expens creditor suspect agreement prior insolv proceed order prevent evas decis ensur distort competit elimin commiss duti requir recoveri proceed confin initi recipi extend includ undertak continu busi initi undertak transfer product plant aspect transfer side busi fact continu exampl consider kind commiss investig transfer asset liabil staff consolid asset purchas price ident sharehold owner initi undertak buyer time transfer take place investig begun initi formal investig procedur adopt final decis commerci charact transfer germani inform deni agreement kind refer put effect commiss consid make clear decis term quot recipi quot includ gröditzer undertak asset transfer order evad effect decis conclus measur paragraph employ promot act cover dem million employ promot cost constitut state aid subsidi dem million cover financ social plan addit measur compat articl ecsc treati applic steel aid code commiss conclud invest aid amount dem million made gröditzer head period compat common market articl ec treati commiss conclud gröditzer privatis germani number measur respect compani unlaw amount state aid involv total dem million figur break sum dem million assess ecsc treati made dem million invest aid steel product year ii dem million invest aid steel product year iii dem million oper aid year iv dem million oper aid year aid incompat articl ecsc treati applic steel aid code germani recov invest aid excess ceil region aid amount dem million dem million privatis dem million privatis assess ec treati incompat common market articl treati germani recov aid sum dem million germani plan grant gröditzer assess ecsc treati incompat articl treati sixth steel aid code grant adopt decis articl payment dem million germani gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh gröditzer order cover cost measur paragraph employ promot act constitut state aid mean articl ecsc treati articl measur germani respect gröditzer order financ social plan addit measur benefit redund gröditzer employe compat common market coal steel financ form loan grant gröditzer success public sharehold treuhandanstalt erel bmgb amount dem million sum dem million paid bmgb articl invest aid grant gröditzer total dem million constitut state aid compat articl ec treati aid break dem million joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur gemeinschaftsaufgab verbesserung der regionalen wirtschaftsstruktur dem million invest aid form tax concess invest allow act investitionszulagengesetz year dem million bank loan carri guarante treuhandanstalt bundesanstalt für vereinigungsbedingt sonderaufgaben bv sharehold loan grant gröditzer success public sharehold year region aid paid joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur year articl invest aid gröditzer amount dem million consist bank loan carri guarante treuhandanstalt bv sharehold loan grant gröditzer success public sharehold year region aid joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur paid year incompat common market articl ec treati articl measur germani respect gröditzer total dem million compris invest aid dem million oper aid dem million payment dem million privatis agreement fund dem million financ mean bank loan carri guarante treuhandanstalt bv mean sharehold loan grant gröditzer success public sharehold constitut state aid incompat common market coal steel articl aid germani plan grant gröditzer articl agreement februari govern sale share gröditzer georgsmarienhütt gmbh amount dem million form loan advanc payment region aid receiv incompat common market coal steel articl germani measur recov recipi aid refer articl grant unlawfulli recoveri effect accord procedur nation law nation law render imposs unduli difficult sum recov bear interest date made recipi actual recoveri refer rate calcul grant equival region aid purpos articl term quot recipi quot compris gröditzer undertak asset transfer depriv paragraph effect articl walzwerk burg gmbh benefit exist aid arrang procedur step envisag articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel juli commiss monika wulf mathi member commiss oj oj oj footnot quot stellungnahm zur finanzmittelverwendung für die jahr bi der gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh gröditz quot arrang govern treuhandanstalt aid treuhandanstalt compani sensit sector notifi period compani emploi peopl net aid amount dem million threshold chang employe dem million burg averag workforc total aid paid dem million judgment court instanc european commun join case neue maxhütt commiss januari report main product ring roll mill coil flang tyre foundri machin part forg bar forg hollow forg crankshaft oj case ecr ii commiss letter sg commiss letter sg commun aid measur commiss letter sg notic case oj sec final oj recent oj recent oj commiss letter sg kpmg liquid report describ situat june privatis place februari small differ figur figur privatis public seller consid report erel succeed meantim bmgb join case spain commiss ecr judgment paragraph divis result decis dissolv treuhand activ share separ organis guarante transfer bv manag sharehold transfer erel bmgb exact valuat sharehold loan requir analysi undertak prospect cost privatis gröditzer amount dem million includ dem million agreement ahead privatis provid waiver sharehold loan dem million redempt continu guarante loan dem million grant social measur dem million recoveri subsidi paragraph employ promot act dem million item compris balanc total made figur aid dem million dem million