commiss decis juli state aid itali plan implement ilva lamier tubi srl notifi document number italian text authent text eea relev ec ecsc commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard treati establish european coal steel commun articl thereof regard commiss decis ecsc decemb establish commun rule state aid steel industri articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis cite regard comment procedur letter date novemb march june italian author notifi commiss accord articl commiss decis ecsc hereinaft refer quot steel aid code quot intend grant environment aid steel compani ilva lamier tubi srl hereinaft quot ilt quot aid regist siderumbra spa aid regist notifi articl ec treati aid invest regist ilt tube make facil law decemb italian author subsequ suppli inform commiss request order establish project notifi compli requir state aid steel industri laid steel aid code letter date march commiss inform italian govern decis initi proceed articl steel aid code aid case ilt siderumbra spa invit submit comment decis publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid commiss receiv comment unit kingdom forward itali opportun react comment receiv letter date januari italian author inform commiss withdraw notif relat aid measur ilt siderumbra spa measur implement letter date august commiss inform itali decid initi procedur laid articl ec treati respect aid measur favour ilt decis publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment aid commiss receiv comment german associ steel tube produc wirtschaftsvereinigung stahlrohr unit kingdom steel associ forward itali opportun react comment receiv letter date januari ii detail descript aid ilt base taranto belong riva group main steel produc european union site manufactur steel product cover ecsc treati primarili hot roll plate sheet commun steel product primarili tube ilt hot roll instal tube make instal longitudin weld larg diamet weld tube tul tul instal electr weld small diamet tube erw instal spiral weld larg weld tube tue coat instal tube partial withdraw notif refer recit aid subject assess present decis consist subsidi itl million eur million invest itl million eur million ilt modernis weld tube product facil grant ministri industri law aid depress area aid repres net grant equival nge elig cost invest cover number measur involv tube maker tube coat plant taranto aim improv environment condit product process modernis plant improv product annex detail weld steel tube made steel coil plate ecsc product bent weld intra commun trade steel tube intens decis initi proceed ec treati commiss express doubt effect invest ilt product capac italian author provid detail ilt exist capac detail invest iii comment interest parti letter date decemb unit kingdom steel associ state aid assess rule ecsc treati prohibit permit grant region aid point commiss assess aid term ec treati fact larg weld steel tube sector suffer structur overcapac aid distort competit commun letter date novemb wirtschaftsvereinigung stahlrohr note huge structur overcapac market weld tube gave rise fierc competit capac utilis rate medium small weld steel tube remain period capac utilis rate larg weld tube period circumst aid allow iv comment itali italian author state letter octob risk aid divert ilt ecsc activ exist firstli extrem rigor statutori control check verif aid grant invest programm complet ministri industri check individu invoic account consist programm identif particular plant machineri equip commiss argument base improv ilt financi situat result aid italian author submit independ keep separ account ilt situat respect firm gröditzer stahlwerk recit commit made ilt aid grant alloc capit reserv special capit reserv provis fondo del patrimonio netto entir durat programm mean fund deriv manag compani ecsc activ remain unchang commiss doubt effect invest product capac larg weld steel tube italian author insist remain unchang tonn year tonn tul tube tonn tul tube invest influenc essenti part ilt product process tube form press larg longitudin weld tube bend machin small diamet erw tube italian author provid detail descript invest insist directli link product process primarili concern autom mechanis final italian author recal firm locat region apulia cover articl ec treati maximum nge region aid aid invest bring econom social benefit region preserv job potenti help local economi develop relat activ comment made parti italian author point letter februari market larg weld tube world market link close intern econom develop importantli price oil extrem uncertainti oil market mean time establish product capac insuffici cope demand stem invest project plant ga pipelin time market crisi oil price low type invest drastic reduc result overcapac italian author capac figur provid wirtschaftsvereinigung stahlrohr pure abstract theoret account modif product cycl requir produc tube specif technic qualit characterist final itali submit averag utilis rate german author complet incompat sound financi manag firm western economi assess aid ilt quot undertak quot mean articl ecsc treati manufactur product refer annex treati commiss accept ec treati appli aid ecsc activ carri ecsc undertak provid distinct undertak ecsc activ connect court instanc rule applic ecsc treati aid invest relat ecsc activ ecsc compani justifi absenc suffici guarante ensur aid misappropri benefit product activ cover ecsc treati steel tube product fall scope annex ecsc treati present case commiss note ilt singl compani separ account activ aid invest relat specif instal identifi physic distinct rest instal dedic product ecsc product product manufactur instal downstream ecsc product belong separ product market circumst line decis adopt recit commiss consid risk aid benefit ilt ecsc activ ec treati appli case point repay grant issu constitut state aid mean articl ec treati strengthen ilt posit compar undertak compet intra commun trade compat common market consider appli aid grant scheme approv commiss except feasibl studi reinforc press tul recit compli purpos invest modernis elig cost land build machineri instal aid intens nge part invest relat larg weld steel tube subsector framework sector cover ecsc treati requir prior notif state decis initi proceed ec treati present case commiss assess individu case notifi framework take account market situat subsector undertak activ structur overcapac identifi situat market compani activ commiss assess effect aid invest situat competit commiss note continu product overcapac exist steel tube sector mid acknowledg authoris aid compani oper sector characteris structur overcapac pose risk distort competit aid invest entail expans capac requir reduct intens aid order offset neg effect competit instanc multisector framework region aid larg invest project examin inform provid italian author letter februari commiss note invest benefit aid entail increas capac hand note ilt locat region cover articl treati aid grant approv scheme commiss consid neg effect competit aid question offset benefit region aid itl eur studi reinforc press itali claim feasibl studi consid elig cost circular decemb issu accord law approv commiss recit commiss note circular consid econom feasibl environment impact studi elig extent total elig invest present case reinforc press consid elig feasibl studi consid elig aid cost consid ad hoc aid approv commiss commun region aid system studi constitut invest fix asset mean commun notwithstand recit view small amount aid cover commiss regul ec januari applic articl ec treati de minimi aid constitut state aid mean articl ec treati provid year period total de minimi aid includ aid question grant undertak exce eur vi conclus state aid amount itl itali intend grant ilt law compat common market aid amount itl itali intend grant ilt carri feasibl studi reinforc press consid de minimi aid meet condit laid commiss regul ec adopt decis articl state aid itali plan implement ilva lamier tubi srl amount itl compat common market articl ec treati articl state aid itali plan implement ilva lamier tubi srl feasibl studi reinforc press amount itl constitut state aid mean articl ec treati provid meet condit laid regul ec itali ensur abovement condit met articl proceed initi march articl commiss decis ecsc aid termin articl decis address italian republ brussel juli commiss mario monti member commiss oj oj oj law contain quot organ framework extraordinari aid mezzogiorno standard subsidis product activ quot oj oj commiss decis ec ecsc juli state aid grant germani gröditzer stahlwerk gmbh subsidiari burg gmbh oj recit commiss decis march state aid itali plan implement ferrier nord spa notifi number publish unoffici translat judgment june case esf elb stahlwerk feralpi gmbh commiss point publish ecr footnot letter june ref sg relat state aid modernis defin law initi aim bring innov firm order achiev increas product improv environment condit connect product process oj point oj oj oj annex list invest benefit aid gt tabl gt