commiss decis april aid grant italian govern forestri pulp paper board industri financ mean levi paper board cellulos italian text authent eec commiss european commun regard treati establish european econom commun subparagraph articl thereof notic accord articl interest parti submit comment regard comment ent nazional la cellulos la carta encc corpor public law consist produc paper cellulos undertak cellulos itali found law june encc statutori task promot develop cellulos product itali facilit product indigen raw materi product cellulos organ product sale paper collect provid inform product cellulos paper encc channel aid link inter alia consumpt newsprint publish notabl press encc activ financ partli mean levi charg home produc cellulos type paper board similar import product partli mean fund provid directli italian govern earmark publish condit aid grant encc repeatedli alter commiss accept alter verifi compat common market novemb commiss close procedur provid articl respect encc activ assur italian govern aid consum italian newsprint newsprint import encc grant publish import newsprint directli member state aid grant public languag italian public export research paper make longer financ levi import member state letter italian govern date novemb commiss state modif aid compat provis treati state aid june commiss adopt decis eec aid scheme press law june requir italian govern publish notic state aid grant distinct paper purchas encc import directli novemb commiss decid close articl procedur open april respect aid scheme favour publish oper encc law august procedur close italian govern statement aid measur newsprint product southern itali includ law aid measur favour cultur public subject restrict prevent alter trade condit commun extent contrari common interest commiss adopt decis eec aid grant italian govern newsprint industri decis commiss demand aid abolish immedi decis commun italian govern letter date june activ encc led legal action allow court justic rule compat common market aspect activ judgment june capolongo judgment june igav judgment march ianelli volpi ii commiss investig misus aid scheme encc led decis eec request inform letter date juli levi cellulos paper cardboard proce levi encc italian govern submit inform commiss letter date novemb inform enabl commiss aid forestri pulp paper board industri measur promot activ timber industri includ research paper make consid elig exempt articl treati levi financ aid appli import member state creat addit unnecessari protect render aid incompat common market commiss note cellulos paper board intend export exempt levi paper product export levi paid paper input refund commiss consid exempt refund constitut product aid export compani incompat common market letter date march commiss propos measur italian govern pursuant articl good import member state longer subject levi oper encc financ aid award italian cellulos paper board industri form exempt levi export member state cellulos paper board refund export member state paper product letter commiss stress posit italian aid levi ident previous respect french aid financ mean parafisc levi paper foundri mechan engin industri italian govern repli commiss propos letter june legal econom observ argument measur propos commiss implement commiss convinc italian govern argument maintain view aid award italian cellulos paper cardboard industri form exempt levi export member state cellulos paper board refund export member state paper product incompat common market commiss maintain view encc aid financ partli mean levi good import member state reason incompat common market commiss decid initi procedur provid articl eec treati italian govern inform decis letter date octob invit submit observ italian govern submit observ telex novemb januari letter date februari april matter discuss bilater meet novemb februari italian govern contest commiss apprais commun intent reform encc phase levi activ financ draft law effect endors italian govern januari present parliament provid transit period end januari abolit aid question respons commiss concern durat transit period italian author propos letter date april reduc month decemb deadlin opinion author transit period adopt law modifi exist scheme observ receiv interest parti public commiss letter italian govern date octob offici journal european commun iii public fund member state financ agenc promot develop cellulos product facilit product indigen materi domest cellulos paper board industri inform advic industri constitut state aid manufactur cellulos paper board member state public fund includ proce levi institut law member state charg levi home produc cellulos type paper board similar import product member state exempt levi cellulos paper board intend export refund levi paper input paper product product export exempt refund constitut state aid export compani cellulos paper board paper product industri italian govern grant aid domest cellulos paper board industri financ activ encc grant aid export compani industri paper product industri grant exempt refund levi cellulos paper board order quantifi aid note inform provid italian govern levi amount lit kg cellulos paper board year commiss annual report encc levi cellulos paper board amount lit billion ecu million sum element levi domest cellulos lit million levi import cellulos lit million levi domest paper board lit million levi import paper board lit million export aid form exempt refund commiss estim letter date march amount lit billion lit billion year italian govern contest estim repli date june observ submit procedur letter italian govern claim commiss recogn aid forestri paper make research fulfil condit set articl treati commiss repli statement letter date octob explain subscrib italian govern interpret commiss point view laid letter italian govern date novemb exclud aid press gener incompat criterion set articl aid grant encc italian govern return subject observ framework articl procedur competit manufactur paper board pulp commun trade product member state commun net import pulp type paper board itali import tonn paper board member state tonn countri figur tonn tonn tonn year total italian import paper board repres domest consumpt product total intra commun trade paper board amount tonn tonn tonn tonn year import countri rose tonn tonn tonn tonn itali export tonn paper board member state tonn countri tonn member state tonn countri member state tonn countri tonn member state tonn countri trade pulp paper board part pulp product take place integr compani product paper board itali import tonn pulp member state tonn countri import tonn member state tonn countri import tonn member state tonn countri import tonn member state tonn countri year total italian import pulp repres domest consumpt pulp paper make total intra commun trade pulp amount tonn tonn tonn tonn year import countri rose tonn tonn tonn tonn itali export tonn pulp member state tonn countri export tonn member state tonn countri export tonn member state tonn countri export tonn member state tonn countri financi assist state strengthen posit enterpris compar competitor commun deem affect enterpris aid italian govern grant domest manufactur export cellulos paper board paper product affect trade member state distort threaten distort competit mean articl treati iv articl principl aid fulfil criteria set incompat common market except principl set articl treati inapplic case view natur object propos aid articl treati list aid consid compat common market compat treati view context commun singl member state order ensur proper function common market take account principl laid articl treati except principl articl set paragraph articl interpret strictli aid scheme individu aid award examin appli commiss establish aid market forc insuffici induc potenti recipi act manner contribut attain object sought appli except case contribut attain object aid essenti end tantamount grant undu advantag industri firm member state financi posit bolster affect trade member state distort competit justifi common interest mean articl eec treati regard except provid articl aid promot facilit develop area italian govern unabl give commiss discov region consider award aid italian cellulos paper board industri aid export compani industri paper product industri except provid articl aid italian cellulos paper board paper product industri intend promot execut import project common european interest remedi disturb italian economi italian govern advanc argument favour applic except except provid articl aid facilit develop econom activ aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest distinct made encc expenditur afforest collect activ domest cellulos paper board industri hand exempt refund export levi commiss consid type aid facilit develop cellulos paper board paper product industri advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest export member state concern commiss establish polici aid export member state natur inelig exempt articl aid abolish delai compat type aid common market appli export countri commiss inform italian govern letter date octob examin aid scheme member state support export countri result work discuss due member state order assess compat scheme articl contrast aid afforest collect activ cellulos paper board industri facilit develop industri connect commiss consid aid activ market advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest aid consid compat common market view isol financ judgment court justic june case govern french republ commiss fact aid financ mean obligatori levi constitut essenti element aid compat aid assess aid financ examin respect commun law aid afforest collect activ cellulos paper board industri compat form object fact financ partli levi product import member state addit unnecessari protect effect exce aid commiss consid take account rule court case commun undertak succe increas sale cellulos paper board itali market effort price cut contribut system levi encc aid essenti intend italian competitor made effort context commiss note intra commun trade paper board increas year statist publish european confeder pulp paper board industri cepac intra commun import repres appar consumpt paper board commun percentag gradual increas itali import member state repres appar consumpt paper board rose intra commun trade pulp increas account access portug spain intra commun import pulp repres appar consumpt commun percentag increas itali import member state repres appar domest consumpt pulp percentag increas commiss consid aid cellulos paper board industri partli financ levi import member state consid compat common market commiss explain letter date march point ii apprais alter italian govern commit proce levi import member state assist research paper industri reason firstli activ timber industri encc statut link separ artifici encc easili switch fund activ commit real signific repli letter observ framework procedur laid articl treati italian govern contest reason letter date june point iii italian govern claim encc activ interest pulp paper manufactur member state claim bulk levi realiti pass consum final claim abolish levi import member state creat disproportion damag compar object pursu repli date octob commiss reject claim notabl point judgment case court justic discard argument access aid activ foreign undertak access thing effect particip aid activ base nation target special commiss note italian govern view levi realiti pass consum put french govern case avail commiss final disagre effect propos creat disproportion damag compar object pursu pain adjust encc activ outweigh elimin aid incompat common market commun point view italian author final agre assess framework procedur inform commiss draft law present parliament view transform encc ent nazional la forestazion ed il recupero della carta enfor articl draft law phase januari levi activ encc enfor financ letter date april deadlin brought forward decemb order exist scheme amend legisl aid abolish includ exempt refund levi export pulp paper board virtu power confer subparagraph articl commiss consid deadlin decemb long justifi consid distinct made aid incompat case law result judgment case refer aid export product member state basi criteria hitherto appli applic articl commiss consid aid categori transit period month date adopt decis envisag hand export aid direct impact trade member state condit competit abolish delai month member state compli decis state aid arrang give italian author reason time compli commiss decis instruct compet depart circular form intern memo refrain grant aid question date stipul decis born mind measur propos commiss march forc recommend italian author month bring legisl line measur stress commiss decis pursuant articl directli applic implement necessit legisl measur part member state decis preced nation provis conflict oblig aris decis oblig abolish aid refer decis period stipul clear uncondit decis full effect italian legal system modifi scheme legisl channel judgment court administr author includ municip region author oblig nation court appli commun provis place conflict nation provis italian republ expedi modifi aid scheme question legisl channel incompat aid sole order satisfi addit legal certainti bear mind rule member state reli procedur practic provis nation legal system purpos justifi failur compli commun oblig result decis state aid pursuant articl treati sentenc articl treati commiss find aid grant state state resourc compat common market regard articl decid state concern abolish alter aid period time determin commiss present case consid aid grant export member state abolish delai aid encc financ levi import member state commiss consid period year reason suffici italian govern modifi system levi adopt decis articl aid grant itali italian cellulos paper board paper product industri form exempt refund levi impos export member state financ activ encc incompat common market aid abolish shortest time month date notif decis articl aid itali grant italian cellulos paper board industri financ activ encc incompat common market activ financ partli proce levi cellulos paper board import member state levi import product abolish april latest articl itali inform commiss month date notif decis step compli herewith articl decis address italian republ brussel april commiss leon brittan vice presid oj oj ecr ecr ecr procedur concern except assist grant encc nuova cartiera di arbatax subject separ investig oj ecr judgment june case capolongo ecr inter alia judgment februari case van gend en loo ecr judgment march case simmenth ecr judgment june case costanzo ecr inter alia judgment april case commiss italian republ ecr judgment februari case commiss kingdom belgium ecr judgment februari case commiss kingdom belgium ecr commiss adopt approach decis februari german aid scheme motor vehicl industri oj