council regul ec februari amend anti dump measur impos regul ec import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin croatia ukrain council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun quot basic regul quot articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur previou investig exist measur measur forc import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin croatia ukrain definit anti dump duti impos council regul ec undertak accept export croatia commiss decis ec rate duti applic import croatia duti rate applic import ukrain initi novemb commiss announc notic initi publish offici journal european commun initi interim review anti dump measur applic import seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin croatia ukrain commenc investig investig initi request lodg defenc committe seamless steel tube industri european union behalf produc repres total commun product note date novemb review initi measur forc import product seamless pipe tube iron alloi steel origin poland russia czech republ romania slovak republ measur poland czech republ slovak republ laps result enlarg european union regul ec exist measur import seamless pipe tube origin russia romania temporarili appli juli review measur ongo parti concern proceed commiss offici advis export produc croatia ukrain produc import supplier user commun concern author croatia ukrain open investig interest parti opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi commiss questionnair parti concern compani made deadlin set notic initi repli receiv commun produc import export produc croatia export produc ukrain trader relat ukrainian produc commiss sought verifi inform deem determin dump result injuri carri verif premis compani commun produc dalmin spa itali producto tubular sa spain tubo reunido sa spain vallourec amp mannesmann germani vallourec amp mannesmann franc unrel import commun comerci de tubo sa spain export produc croatia mechel željezara sisak export produc ukrain cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant nikotub nikopol dnipropetrovsk tube work dtw dnipropetrovsk ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp dnipropetrovsk relat trader ukrain time dnipropetrovsk sgip interpip dnipropetrovsk relat trader switzerland sepco lugano investig period investig dump injuri cover period octob septemb investig period ip examin trend relev assess injuri cover period januari end investig period period consid product concern product product concern product review seamless pipe iron alloi steel kind oil ga pipelin extern diamet exceed mm seamless tube circular cross section iron alloi steel cold drawn cold roll precis tube tube circular cross section iron alloi steel thread threadabl extern diamet exceed mm origin croatia ukrain product concern fall cn code investig shown categori suffici similar constitut singl product origin investig purpos present anti dump investig type product concern regard product product previou investig differ found product concern seamless pipe tube produc sold domest market croatia likewis differ found product concern seamless pipe tube produc commun produc sold commun market share physic chemic characterist conform industri standard din api astm consid product mean articl basic regul dump croatia cooper concern croatia export produc mechel željezara account export product concern commun mechel željezara compani cooper origin investig željezara sisak offici chang imposit exist measur due subsequ ownership origin investig undertak accept mechel željezara origin investig initi review level form measur undertak subject review investig recit normal establish mechel željezara total domest sale product repres comparison total export sale commun accord articl basic regul domest sale consid repres total domest sale volum repres total export sale volum commun subsequ defin product type accord cn code product classifi examin domest sale product type repres domest sale product type consid suffici repres total domest sale volum type ip repres total sale volum compar product type export commun found product type sold compani export commun repres domest sale examin made domest sale product type regard made ordinari trade establish proport profit sale independ custom type question case sale volum product type sold net sale price equal unit cost repres total sale volum type weight averag price type equal unit cost normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag price domest sale product type made ip irrespect sale profit case product type case volum profit sale product type repres total sale volum type weight averag price sale unit cost normal base actual domest price calcul weight averag profit sale type case product type fourth product type domest sale volum profit ip consid product type sold insuffici quantiti domest price provid basi establish normal method appli case construct normal accord articl basic regul normal construct ad manufactur cost export type adjust reason percentag sell gener administr expens sg amp reason margin profit basi actual data pertain product sale ordinari trade product export produc investig accord sentenc articl basic regul export price investig show export sale mechel željezara sole made directli unrel custom commun export price establish basi export price paid payabl product concern sold independ custom commun accord articl basic regul comparison normal export price compar work basi purpos ensur fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ affect price compar accord articl basic regul allow claim differ transport cost handl load ancillari cost credit cost commiss grant applic support verifi evid dump margin accord articl basic regul adjust weight averag normal product type compar adjust weight averag export price type product concern comparison show exist dump dump margin express percentag cif commun frontier price duti unpaid mechel željezara dump margin dump margin found origin investig level cooper high export product concern croatia commun residu dump margin set level establish mechel željezara ukrain market economi treatment met pursuant articl basic regul anti dump investig import origin ukrain normal determin accord paragraph articl export produc show meet criteria laid articl regul market economi condit prevail respect manufactur sale product briefli eas refer criteria met set summaris form busi decis cost made respons market signal signific state interfer firm clear set account record independ audit line intern account standard ia appli purpos signific distort carri market economi system legal certainti stabil provid bankruptci properti law currenc exchang carri market rate claim met pursuant articl basic regul receiv group compani produc compani dnipropetrovsk tube work dtw relat trader ukrain time relat produc compani ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot relat trader ukrain sgip interpip claim analys basi criteria set articl basic regul case group account produc compani found unreli due materi inaccuraci misappl account polici refer ia found compani insolv situat belong categori compani bankruptci law provis enjoi special statu deni legal certainti oper compani determin group compani meet fourth criteria articl basic regul case group found produc compani clear set basic account record independ audit line intern account standard appli purpos compani set basic account record purpos addition signific distort carri market economi system form interest free loan pursu state debt forgiv consider amount tax indebted found affect cost structur financi situat group determin group compani meet criteria articl basic regul compani group compani fulfil criteria articl basic regul order market economi treatment grant case group compani refus met group compani argu commiss made determin applic met month period mention articl basic regul determin valid respect note commiss grant extens deadlin ukrainian export produc concern major difficulti fill met claim form deadlin set notic initi note met claim receiv defici requir number substanti clarif addit inform delai investig final complex number issu compani structur sale channel problem regard compani account prolong analysi view make determin met claim receiv month initi respect note respect deadlin entail appar legal consequ compani equal grant opportun comment note abovement group compani claim neg impact due longer period need met determin conclud valid determin regard met made month period claim group compani concern reject commiss find contest group compani argument brought forward alter met determin commun industri opportun comment oppos find individu treatment pursuant articl basic regul countri wide duti establish countri fall articl basic regul case compani demonstr export price quantiti condit term sale freeli determin exchang rate carri market rate state interfer permit circumvent measur export rate duti ukrainian export produc fulfil met criteria altern request individu treatment accord articl basic regul commiss sought verifi inform deem purpos determin group compani qualifi found condit set articl basic regul fulfil group compani consid justifi grant group compani analogu countri pursuant articl basic regul normal export produc grant met establish basi price construct analogu countri product compar export ukrainian export produc commun croatia analogu countri origin investig notic initi croatia envisag analogu countri purpos establish normal ukrain interest parti object choic decid croatia analogu countri framework investig normal pursuant articl basic regul normal ukrain establish basi verifi inform receiv sole produc analogu countri basi price paid payabl domest market croatia compar product type construct croatia compar product type determin normal ukrain methodolog recit appli establish product type cn code cold drawn cold roll tube domest product croatia export account ukrainian export product concern commun case group compani ip export quantiti commun product type repres total export product concern commun basi data conclud product type subject investig compar product type construct normal product type basi normal product type lead reliabl figur appear complex manufactur process normal product type consider higher normal product type export price cold drawn cold roll tube averag higher export price product type inclus product type calcul likelihood lead higher dump margin mention recit injuri margin significantli lower dump margin found includ product type serv basi establish level measur view consid pursu matter product type cn code exclud calcul export price group compani ukrain made export sale commun relat trade compani locat countri export price accord articl basic regul construct basi relat trade compani resal price independ custom commun comparison purpos fair comparison normal export price due allow form adjust made differ claim demonstr affect price compar adjust made accord articl basic regul respect transport insur handl load ancillari cost commiss adjust export price respect inland transport export countri insur load ancillari cost made basi cost establish analogu countri comparison normal export price made work basi dump margin articl basic regul adjust weight averag normal product type analogu countri produc mechel željezara compar compani adjust weight averag export price product type product concern comparison show exist dump dump margin express percentag cif commun frontier price duti unpaid dnipropetrovsk tube work dnipropetrovsk ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant dnipropetrovsk cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot nikopol level cooper high export product concern ukrain commun residu margin set level establish cooper export produc ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot injuri preliminari remark case dump investig sought establish circumst regard situat commun industri chang extent warrant conclus establish origin investig commun product origin investig commun industri compos produc present review investig found seamless pipe tube manufactur complain commun produc fulli cooper commiss investig sixth pietra itali support proceed provid detail questionnair repli produc support commun industri cooper commiss questionnair produc cooper obtain produc product concern made european commiss definit commun industri product commun produc fulli cooper investig tonn investig period repres total commun product compani constitut commun industri mean articl basic regul commun consumpt eurostat inform relat volum valu cn code sourc import data commun industri data obtain verifi questionnair respons cooper commun produc appar commun consumpt sale commun industri commun market sale commun produc commun import countri show consumpt product concern commun increas tonn peak tonn consumpt decreas tonn ip slightli consumpt ip commun consumpt tonn index import commun countri concern cumul assess effect import concern examin import croatia ukrain assess cumul accord articl basic regul evolut import countri concern volum market share import volum tonn ip ukrain index croatia index countri concern total index market share import ip ukrain croatia countri concern total import countri found dump margin establish recit relat import countri concern de minimi threshold defin articl basic regul addition measur forc volum import countri neglig investig period market share countri croatia ukrain share import rang croatia ukrain ip cumul assess found view condit competit import origin countri import commun product evidenc fact measur forc price countri continu significantli undercut price commun industri ip seamless pipe tube countri sold similar sale channel investig shown import countri concern share physic chemic characterist product final import countri concern product follow price trend recit croatian export claim injuri caus croatian import croatian market share minim cumul assess place state croatian import de minimi neglig ip true consider drop import origin ukrain begin period consid note subsequ import countri broadli similar trend reason conclud criteria set articl basic regul met import origin croatia ukrain assess cumul market share import concern shown introduct measur market share import countri concern decreas significantli start increas continu ip price import undercut comparison sell price commun market ip made price commun industri export produc countri concern comparison made deduct rebat discount price commun industri adjust work price price import cif commun frontier import duti paid anti dump duti unpaid adjust made level trade handl cost base inform collect investig notabl cooper unrel import comparison show ip import product concern sold commun price undercut commun industri price express percentag ukrain croatia anti dump duti account undercut signific import ukrain import croatia note averag price import increas ip shown line price develop eu market shown recit price import countri concern increas price commun industri price import duti unpaid eur tonn ip ukrain index croatia index ukrain croatia averag index situat commun industri accord articl basic regul examin impact dump import commun industri includ evalu econom factor indic bear state industri base year ip commun industri data repres aggreg inform cooper commun produc product product capac capac utilis evolut product product capac capac utilis ip product tonn index product capac tonn index capac utilis index shown tabl product period increas peak decreas significantli ip export sale increas compens extent decreas sale commun reduct product decreas product capac ip avoid stock figur repres volum stock end period ip stock tonn index stock increas period consid note commun industri gener produc product concern order level stock held commun industri found signific indic assess situat commun industri found increas stock consequ decreas sale market share commun industri sale volum market share growth averag unit price commun figur repres commun industri sale independ custom commun ip sale volum tonn index market share index averag sale price eur tonn index commun industri sale volum increas drop significantli ip level develop sale volum light level consumpt period increas decreas ip demand decreas sale volum ip introduct measur commun industri regain lost market share market share commun industri increas commun consumpt period rel strength market share commun industri decreas ip share commun consumpt decreas dump import start penetr commun market face increas import decreas commun sale commun industri increas product product concern forc reduc product capac work forc ip increas export commun industri compens loss sale commun market commun industri averag sale price increas period consid higher price gener suffici profit detail profit profit concept profit tax repres profit gener sale product concern commun market ip profit ec sale imposit anti dump measur import seamless pipe tube origin croatia ukrain commun industri increas price reach break commun industri reach level profit expect achiev absenc dump import set regul impos measur forc level profit decreas ip break reason decreas higher sale price increas raw materi labour cost unit reduct employe time commun industri pass cost custom due competit caus low price dump import slightli posit trend financi situat commun industri start deterior ip coincid increas dump import croatia ukrain profit level reach break level financ suffici reinvest return invest cash flow invest abil rais capit trend return invest cash flow invest shown tabl ip return invest index cash flow index invest index note figur return invest reflect larg extent profit return invest increas decreas ip cash flow show approxim trend profit peak decreas product concern account total turnov commun produc commun produc product line manufactur varieti steel product consid figur meaning illustr cooper commun produc produc product concern higher extent commun produc show trend similar tabl return invest cash flow invest imposit anti dump measur commun industri made invest invest found major aim replac machineri ip invest decreas significantli compar preced year commun industri abil rais capit extern provid financ parent compani affect period consid product concern account total turnov commun produc commun produc product line manufactur varieti steel product employ product wage ip number employe index product tonn employe index wage index commun industri increas product number employe product increas period ip number employe reduc significantli level product decreas substanti decreas product wage stabl period consid move line inflat recoveri past dump introduct measur commun industri regain lost market share reach sustain level averag sale price commun industri financi perform start deterior conclud commun recov past dump magnitud actual margin dump dump margin dump part recit margin establish de minimi volum price dump import impact actual margin dump consid neglig conclus injuri recal imposit anti dump measur import product concern croatia ukrain commun industri immedi gain confid averag price commun sale increas sale volum commun product increas period consequ industri make invest time emploi work forc situat start deterior substanti ip sale commun decreas ip commun industri adjust significantli reduc product product capac employ market share commun industri decreas ip level declin trend ip confirm reduc capac utilis stagnat develop wage increas level stock leav industri situat similar measur impos import countri concern trend shown develop invest return invest cash flow minor improv satisfi return invest reach neg cash flow turn posit deterior ip fact abil compani rais capit affect due compani part larger corpor group consid viabl indic sector product concern regard commun industri financi situat improv loss make situat reach break situat fell back loss make situat ip indic improv initi measur impos except sale price deterior ip show clear injuri pictur continu increas sell price occur period consid lead satisfi profit situat complet absorb rise product cost notabl raw materi cost labour cost unit commun industri pass cost increas custom low price dump import penetr market consequ profit situat commun industri deterior fell break ip view conclud commun industri suffer materi injuri ip mean articl basic regul last natur chang circumst likelihood continu dump injuri origin measur expir februari accord articl basic regul examin expiri exist measur lead continu dump injuri accord articl basic regul analys circumst regard dump injuri chang significantli chang last natur found product concern dump commun market ip recit regard dump margin product concern origin countri subject proceed close dump margin found origin investig huge product capac countri concern ip note signific quantiti import croatia ukrain sold commun market market share continu increas demonstr clear interest croatian ukrainian export eu market consid reason doubt level dump found last natur continu dump highli origin measur allow expir fact commun industri recov extent past dump import origin inter alia croatia ukrain found commun industri suffer materi injuri mean articl basic regul injuri margin found investig increas compar origin investig dump import continu substanti undercut commun industri price fact cost risen worldwid effect dump import profit recit market share commun industri recit decreas ip conclud circumst lead injuri last natur expiri origin measur lead continu injuri causat examin causal link dump import croatia ukrain injuri suffer commun industri establish previou investig present investig factor dump import time injur commun industri examin ensur injuri caus factor attribut dump import measur forc led reduct import export produc croatia ukrain subsequ increas market share commun period consid decreas consumpt ip increas market share time ip commun industri lost market share reduc product substanti ip suffer declin profit increas import countri concern significantli undercut commun industri price deterior situat commun industri coincid time import continu contribut injuri suffer commun industri import origin countri czech republ poland slovak republ investig period member commun import romania russia contribut injuri suffer commun industri note anti dump duti rang undertak forc import abovement countri period consid review ongo measur forc import russia romania recit import russia account market share investig period averag import price import inclus anti dump duti lower price import croatia ukrain level price import russia import contribut injuri regard size market share lower countri concern russian import injuri suffer commun industri import romania account market share ip import price romania inclus anti dump duti higher price import croatia ukrain lower commun industri price conclud contribut injuri suffer commun industri consid effect import russia romania alter find genuin substanti causal link dump import seamless pipe tube croatia ukrain materi injuri suffer commun industri price import access countri poland czech republ slovakia inclus anti dump duti significantli higher level croatia ukrain lower commun industri price market share altogeth ip import contribut injuri conclud price level contribut minor regard fact import croatia ukrain undercut substanti commun industri price indic abovement import major undercut commun price lesser extent break causal link dump import croatia ukrain materi injuri suffer commun industri import countri altogeth account market share ip regard high level price major suffici commun industri price indic import break causal link dump import croatia ukrain materi injuri suffer commun industri commun produc cooper investig face problem increas raw materi cost forc rais price indic found competitor caus injuri suffer commun industri decreas consumpt commun commun sale decreas higher percentag consumpt commun industri lost market share countri concern increas market share commun market period conclud factor break causal link dump import croatia ukrain materi injuri suffer commun industri factor found investig caus injuri base analysi effect factor situat commun industri conclud causal link dump import croatia ukrain materi injuri commun industri establish previou investig broken commun interest gener consider examin compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest maintain anti dump duti import countri concern commiss questionnair import industri user complet questionnair repli receiv import comerci de tubo sa spain user industri questionnair repli receiv supplier made investig basi inform receiv cooper parti conclus reach recal previou investig adopt measur consid interest commun fact present investig review analys situat anti dump measur place assess undu neg impact parti concern current anti dump measur interest commun industri recal commun industri consist produc emploi approxim staff product sale seamless pipe tube recal econom indic commun industri show deterior financi result investig period grow consumpt seamless pipe tube commun declin ip commun industri gain financi stabil industri recov partial prevail financi situat commun industri clear anti dump measur interest commun industri interest unrel import cooper import gener oppos continu imposit anti dump measur comment import import product concern croatia ukrain receiv purpos anti dump measur restor fair trade prohibit import hamper activ import commun fact measur propos set level enabl continu import futur price dump injuri whichev lower fairli price import allow enter commun market tradit busi import continu anti dump measur dump import impos interest supplier supplier made investig conclud compel reason exist measur impos supplier interest interest user previou investig conclud price effect result anti dump measur signific respect downstream industri user base fact seamless pipe tube repres small element cost user industri includ chemic petrochem industri power station automobil construct industri represent made contradict previou find view lack cooper user present investig expect price effect result anti dump measur neglig respect downstream industri user competit aspect note commiss decis ec found commun produc involv anti competit agreement part product concern origin investig ip novemb octob period consid januari end ip current review investig affect anti competit practic conclus commun interest mainten measur import seamless pipe tube origin countri concern interest commun industri import trader user industri impact price seamless tube expect margin view conclud compel reason impos anti dump duti import seamless pipe tube origin countri concern anti dump measur injuri elimin level view conclus reach regard dump injuri commun interest measur impos order prevent injuri caus commun industri dump import measur impos level suffici elimin injuri caus import exceed dump margin found calcul amount duti remov effect injuri dump consid measur commun industri cover cost product obtain profit tax achiev industri type sector normal condit competit absenc dump import sale product commun pre tax profit margin calcul turnov origin proceed indic found intervent made rate chang basi injuri price calcul commun industri product injuri price obtain ad abovement profit margin cost product price increas determin basi comparison weight averag import price establish undercut calcul averag injuri price differ result comparison express percentag averag import cif amend measur light forego consid anti dump duti forc import product concern origin croatia ukrain amend anti dump duti set level reflect injuri margin found dump margin found compani croatia ukrain higher injuri margin calcul level cooper high export product concern ukrain commun residu margin ukrain set level establish cooper export produc ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot individu compani anti dump duti rate regul establish basi find present investig reflect situat found investig respect compani duti rate oppos countrywid duti applic quot compani quot exclus applic import product origin countri concern produc compani specif legal entiti mention import product produc compani specif mention oper part regul address includ entiti relat specif mention benefit rate subject duti rate applic quot compani quot european commiss director gener trade direct offic brussel forthwith relev inform modif compani activ link product domest export sale chang chang product sale entiti regul amend updat list compani benefit individu duti rate propos anti dump duti countri compani injuri elimin margin dump margin propos anti dump duti croatia compani ukrain dnipropetrovsk tube work dtw dnipropetrovsk ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp dnipropetrovsk cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot nikopol compani basi measur propos year period measur start run measur expir februari state notic impend expiri publish august develop ip croatian export subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi conclud level anti dump measur amend croatian govern inform commiss sole produc croatia mechel željezara liquid ceas product autumn place legal entiti name valjaonic cijevi sisak valjaonic set croatian privatis foundat cpf government institut charg privatis process croatia newli establish compani appear start product process obtain asset mechel željezara inform submit appear product capac valjaonic remain unchang compar mechel željezara clear intent valjaonic continu product product concern basi fact product stop consid last undisput natur affect find investig situat compani justifi review measur review initi undertak commiss decis ec accept price undertak inter alia sole croatian export produc undertak regard mechel željezara subject review undertak mechel željezara undertook sell independ custom quantiti product concern export commun revis price addit mechel željezara undertook price product group fall line price structur commun accord articl basic regul aim undertak elimin injuri effect dump import achiev export rais price ceas export dump level investig shown type undertak origin accept present case fail rais price injuri level restor fair trade commun market case undertak accept mechel željezara consid effect mean elimin injuri effect dump state mechel željezara liquid recent undertak consid longer valid subsequ disclosur essenti fact consider basi conclud level exist anti dump margin amend ukrainian compani ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot relat trader hold compani quot interpip quot offer joint undertak accord articl basic regul ukrainian compani produc type steel product sold product concern rais potenti risk cross compens undertak price formal respect price product concern lower sold product concern addit view volatil price minimum export price compani prepar offer level elimin injuri effect dump offer accept addit ukrainian compani dnipropetrovsk tube work dtw dnipropetrovsk declar offer undertak indic natur minimum price respect offer consider final provis interest parti inform fact consider basi intend propos amend regul forc opportun comment request hear comment receiv consider adopt regul articl regul ec amend tabl articl replac quot countri compani rate duti taric addit code croatia compani ukrain dnipropetrovsk tube work dtw dnipropetrovsk ojsc nizhnedneprovski tube roll plant ntrp dnipropetrovsk cjsc nikopolski seamless tube plant quot nikotub quot nikopol compani quot articl delet articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel februari council presid asselborn oj regul amend regul ec oj oj regul amend regul ec oj oj decis amend decis ec oj oj oj oj notic oj notic oj commiss decis ec oj oj oj