council regul ec novemb impos definit anti dump duti import ring binder mechan origin peopl republ china council european union regard treati establish european commun regard council regul ec decemb protect dump import countri member european commun quot basic regul quot articl thereof regard propos submit commiss consult advisori committe procedur measur forc januari council regul ec impos definit anti dump duti import ring binder mechan quot rbm quot origin inter alia peopl republ china quot prc quot quot countri concern quot rate definit duti applic net free commun frontier price duti world wide stationeri mfg quot ww quot compani grant individu treatment compani prc rate duti applic rbm ring taric code rbm ring taric code subject duti equal differ minimum import price quot mip quot eur piec free commun frontier price duti lower mip septemb request anti absorpt review abovement measur lodg pursuant articl basic regul rate duti applic rbm ring taric code revis upward council regul ec ww compani prc anti dump countervail measur forc june import rbm origin indonesia measur subject current review impos council regul ec council regul ec june investig alleg circumvent anti dump measur impos council regul ec import rbm consign vietnam measur extend import consign vietnam council regul ec investig alleg circumvent anti dump measur impos council regul ec import rbm consign thailand declar origin thailand initi april investig mention previou recit independ result present investig request review public notic impend expiri anti dump measur forc import rbm origin prc commiss receiv octob request review measur pursuant articl basic regul request lodg commun produc koloman handler ag kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh quot applic quot repres major proport total commun product rbm request base ground expiri measur result higher volum injuri dump import origin prc determin consult advisori committe suffici evid exist initi review pursuant articl basic regul commiss initi review investig procedur commiss offici advis export produc import user concern repres export countri applic commun produc commun produc initi expiri review interest parti opportun make view write request hear time limit set notic initi parti request time limit demonstr reason heard grant opportun heard questionnair parti offici advis initi review request questionnair time limit set notic initi addit produc india analogu countri contact receiv questionnair repli questionnair receiv applic commun produc export produc countri concern produc analogu countri unrel import commun parti concern inform essenti fact consider basi intend recommend imposit definit anti dump duti grant period make represent subsequ disclosur comment parti consid find modifi interest parti verif visit inform deem purpos determin likelihood continu recurr dump injuri commun interest sought verifi verif visit carri premis compani applic commun produc kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh espelkamp germani sx bürowaren produkt und handel gmbh novemb rbm manufactur koloman handler ag vienna austria recit ii produc export countri world wide stationeri mfg hong kong prc iii produc analogu countri tocheungle stationeri manufactur chennai india iv unrel import commun benson intern system utrecht netherland investig period investig likelihood continu recurr dump cover period januari decemb quot investig period quot quot ip quot examin trend relev assess likelihood continu recurr injuri cover period januari end ip quot period consid quot product concern product product concern product concern origin investig ring binder mechan made rectangular steel sheet wire half ring made steel wire fix steel cover open pull half ring small steel made trigger mechan fix rbm ring shape common round shape rbm classifi cn code taric code mechan ring taric code mechan ring lever arch mechan quot lam quot classifi cn code includ scope investig rbm make paper cardboard plastic coat offic file present bound file larg number type rbm sold commun ip differ type determin width base type mechan number ring open system nomin paper hold capac ring diamet shape ring length ring space fact type basic physic technic characterist rang interchang establish rbm constitut singl product purpos present proceed product found rbm produc sold domest market analogu countri india export commun prc basic physic technic characterist found differ basic physic technic characterist rbm import commun origin prc rbm produc commun industri sold commun market conclud rbm produc sold domest market analogu countri rbm origin prc export commun rbm produc sold commun industri commun market product mean articl basic regul likelihood continu recurr dump accord articl basic regul examin expiri exist measur lead continu recurr dump preliminari remark chines export produc name complaint ww grant individu treatment origin anti absorpt investig cooper export compani state export product concern commun ip compani appear involv circumvent practic thailand investig european anti fraud offic olaf recit continu dump volum export sale sole cooper compani repres import origin prc ip eurostat volum repres total commun consumpt ip current investig compar total commun consumpt ip origin investig octob septemb methodolog compar origin investig choic analogu countri chang methodolog calcul dump margin remain analogu countri prc economi transit normal determin basi inform obtain market economi countri quot analogu countri quot select accord articl basic regul origin investig malaysia chosen analogu countri view fact product malaysia ceas transfer inter alia india repres countri chosen expiri review request india suggest analogu countri purpos establish normal choic contest found reason select india size domest market open market degre access basic materi ensur normal condit competit indian produc contact agre cooper repres domest sale compani relat cooper chines export produc reason found impact determin normal accord articl basic regul india consid analogu countri establish normal normal domest sale product analogu countri found profit repres ip normal base price paid payabl ordinari trade independ custom analogu countri india export price product concern export independ custom commun export price establish accord articl basic regul basi export price paid payabl comparison purpos fair comparison accord articl basic regul due allow form adjust made differ respect inland freight discount defer rebat handl load transport credit cost commiss insur affect price price compar respect note imposit anti dump measur volum varieti type rbm export commun fell sharpli type product sold domest market analogu countri ip compar type directli export prc sole cooper export produc origin investig comparison base total sale volum direct export prc ip current investig cover quot nich segment quot ring mechan subject mip dump margin accord articl basic regul weight averag normal compar weight averag export price level trade comparison show absenc dump conclus dump regard dump practic dump found ww cooper chines export produc volum export sale ww direct commun ip current investig significantli smaller identifi origin investig export direct prc ww centr top end rang rbm ring model subject duti form mip recit mean effect anti dump duti paid import result compar dump margin calcul origin investig calcul dump margin model rbm subject anti dump duti model sold commun market export direct prc ip current investig term sale volum comparison made sale product sold domest market analogu countri model form sale prc commun light consid clear conclus continu dump reach recurr dump absenc clear conclus continu dump question likelihood recurr dump investig respect element analys spare capac invest export chines produc behaviour cooper chines export produc countri market structur volum price export product concern countri cooper compani spare capac invest worth recal absenc cooper export produc ww inform product prc spare product capac sale chines market cooper produc product capac cooper compani remain stabl ip product product concern fell ip cooper export produc signific unus product capac total capac produc quickli increas product direct export market includ commun market measur allow expir note unus product capac sole cooper export produc meet roughli half commun consumpt assum chines produc signific spare capac chines export decreas inform show capac prc declin note cooper compani maintain high level invest machineri equip ip gradual decreas extent behaviour cooper chines export produc countri market export sale countri exclud commun cooper compani decreas volum ip averag export price countri decreas period behaviour cooper chines compani volum price regard compani cooper present investig find base fact accord articl basic regul absenc cooper chines statist consult order establish volum price chines export countri absolut volum chines export differ sourc inform statist confirm signific decreas rbm export china period ip world chines statist volum rbm export world market million piec decreas million piec ip averag export price cover product type wide differ price remain stabl period mention recit absenc inform hypothet decreas product capac cooper chines export produc signific unus capac circumst reason anti dump measur allow expir commun market attract target chines export resum export commun market consider quantiti import note olaf carri investig determin import rbm declar origin thailand origin countri alleg prc origin investig olaf member state concern conclud rbm thai origin investig establish substanti part traffic chines preferenti origin liabl anti dump duti respect note product type export thailand includ model rbm sold commun market ip ring model sold directli prc allow comparison made model sold commun market comparison made rbm export thailand commun number compar product type sold domest market analogu countri result view caution absenc full investig import rbm thailand calcul base fob bangkok price offer provid commun industri product type export thailand commun ip calcul appear show export price rbm export thailand lower price indian domest market exclud rbm sold commun dump price anti absorpt investig addit recal octob origin investig impos duti ww chines compani anti absorpt investig led increas level duti ww compani trade defenc measur appli countri countri appli trade defenc measur import rbm prc conclus investig shown cooper export produc chines export produc consider spare capac view signific decreas export ip unus product capac sole cooper export produc meet roughli half commun consumpt appar commun consumpt ip million piec million piec declar origin prc ip origin investig octob septemb chines export produc export million piec commun view spare capac chines export produc import prc commun market resum signific quantiti anti dump measur allow expir addit pressur chines compani export light huge spare capac export dump price comparison cooper compani show dump base small sampl compar calcul dump origin investig hand chines compani cooper investig export rbm commun market relat compani locat thailand calcul shown possibl sale dump price exclud year anti absorpt investig dump practic continu base find event event resumpt export chines export eu export price normal expect absenc present duti dump china recur definit commun industri ip rbm manufactur commun produc kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh espelkamp germani sx bürowaren produkt und handel gmbh novemb rbm manufactur koloman handler ag vienna austria industria meccanica lombarda srl offanengo itali produc applic cooper investig cooper commun produc repres total commun product rbm ip consid produc repres commun industri mean articl basic regul hereinaft refer quot commun industri quot ip compani part compani group product maintain commun compani group unrel chines export produc situat commun market consumpt commun market questionnair repli cooper commun produc establish commun industri sale rbm commun market inform calcul sale commun produc includ definit commun industri import origin prc import declar origin thailand eurostat figur except figur import declar origin prc ip inform provid cooper chines export produc import origin countri figur import origin india indonesia except relat ip obtain anti dump proceed countri eurostat inform calcul volum import questionnair repli previou proceed import origin hungari questionnair repli cooper commun produc countri hungari countri refer recit eurostat inform note eurostat figur convert tonn piec basi appar commun consumpt decreas period consid million piec figur round million million piec ip figur million piec million piec import countri concern import volum market share import declar origin prc decreas sharpli million piec million piec million piec million piec ip market share import declar origin prc fell year period consid ip price evolut import product concern averag price import declar origin prc increas eur ip eur upward trend price import declar origin prc reflect grow weight expens product type subject mip rbm ring genuin price increas import declar origin thailand mention base find olaf investig substanti part import declar origin thailand fact chines origin import declar origin thailand increas million piec million piec million piec million piec ip market share import declar origin thailand increas year period consid ip averag price import declar origin thailand fell period eur eur detail price inform import declar origin thailand concern resal price european distributor rbm export thailand found resal price averag sale price commun industri econom situat commun industri product product capac capac utilis product commun industri decreas period consid index number ip koloman handler ag decis transfer part product hungari account decreas product year ip koloman handler ag file bankruptci product decreas significantli half product capac commun industri decreas period consid increas index number fell result koloman handler ag decis transfer part product hungari product capac stabilis ip capac utilis fell increas decreas ip stock commun industri close stock fell period consid fallen year period main factor contribut decreas slowdown koloman handler ag product file bankruptci period stock sold reduc dai period consid sale volum market share growth commun industri sale commun market decreas period consid million piec million piec ip sale fallen million piec remain level market share held commun industri grew slightli period consid ip fallen significantli commun consumpt decreas period consid sale volum commun industri decreas hand aggreg volum import declar origin prc thailand fell period consid commun industri slightli increas market share import declar origin prc lost market share import declar origin thailand increas market share sale price cost weight averag sell price rbm sold commun industri commun market unrel custom decreas year period consid eur thousand piec eur eur eur ip period consid anti dump measur import indonesia june exclud dump rbm indonesia impact price develop period consid sell price main raw materi steel strip steel wire follow downward trend hand unit labour cost account fifth total unit cost decreas significantli period consid profit impact item reflect regular perform busi depreci goodwil acquisit signific oper profit margin depreci goodwil consid indic pre tax profit margin assess profit commun industri commun industri consist regist poor oper profit margin sale unrel custom commun profit improv fell abruptli lower ip neg perform contribut fact compani concern bankruptci koloman handler ag juli kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh april end ip invest abil rais capit analysi invest focuss invest plant machineri repres total invest ip invest goodwil consider reflect regular perform commun industri year invest result acquisit event invest plant machineri decreas period consid fell index number ip abil commun industri rais capit dent consist poor profit return invest equiti neg commun produc subsequ file bankruptci return total asset quot rota quot measur return invest rota stabl fell abruptli lower ip cash flow analysi simplifi net oper cash flow oper profit depreci exclud depreci goodwil show trend similar oper profit margin cash flow increas index number decreas sharpli ip employ product wage employ full time unit fell year period consid index number ip product measur thousand piec employe improv period consid labour cost unit output measur eur kg decreas period magnitud actual margin dump find actual dump ip import declar origin prc find import relat small repres rang rbm full determin dump import declar origin thailand made due lack investig dump olaf investig concern determin origin relat issu dump conclus reach magnitud actual margin dump conclus commun industri continu precari situat period consid illustr declin profit word grow loss lower sale volum decreas unit price precari situat commun industri ip result past event dump import origin prc imposit measur januari ii absorpt measur determin octob iii dump import origin indonesia imposit anti dump measur june iv circumvent thailand olaf investig addit investig circumvent anti dump measur impos council regul ec extend import consign vietnam recit show period consid commun industri suffer dump opportun recov decreas consumpt commun market limit explain precari situat commun industri likelihood recurr injuri impact project increas dump import commun industri ip origin investig period octob septemb chines export produc sold million piec commun market ww sale account fifth volum ip current investig sold million piec declar origin prc fact signific spare capac prc chines export countri decreas volum behaviour chines export produc consist shown sell dump injuri price gain market share likelihood recurr injuri dump import origin prc anti dump measur expir commun market chines export produc increas market share market suppli chines produc produc countri control chines produc commun industri presenc signific import market commun rbm sold manufactur prc compani control chines export produc price pressur exert import concern significantli increas suggest analysi anti absorpt investig exist measur allow expir ww absorb signific part anti dump duti chines compani duti absenc anti dump measur posit increas strong downward pressur price rbm sold commun recal averag price rbm declar origin thailand fell period consid comparison averag sell price european distributor rbm declar origin thailand commun industri weight averag sell price show lower import countri hungari part commun onward concern india indonesia export produc countri control chines export produc measur import origin prc expir incent export rbm india indonesia commun reduc case sharp increas dump import come directli prc precari situat commun industri aforement substanti increas import prc dump price combin substanti price undercut undoubtedli consequ commun industri view experi past anti dump anti subsidi investig regard rbm expiri measur rbm import origin prc likelihood lead materi deterior situat commun industri conclus likelihood recurr injuri basi expiri anti dump measur import rbm origin prc result sharp increas volum import commun combin signific declin sell price note bulk product rbm market highli standardis competit take place great extent term price context find situat commun market increas volum import low dump price depress price commun industri turn lead deterior financi situat commun industri consequ commun industri bankruptci closur remain plant expiri measur remov import barrier imped chines export produc sell injuri dump price commun market conclud likelihood recurr injuri caus dump import origin prc commun interest introduct examin compel reason exist lead conclus commun interest renew anti dump measur forc purpos accord articl basic regul impact renew measur parti involv proceed consequ expiri measur consid basi evid submit order assess impact mainten measur interest parti opportun make view pursuant articl basic regul cooper commun produc unrel import repli questionnair user made comment repli questionnair provid evid substanti comment articl basic regul establish inform account support actual evid substanti valid context conclus drawn comment made user suggest commun interest maintain anti dump measur substanti effect anti dump measur previous impos sharp declin import declar origin prc increas measur find absorpt combin sharp increas import origin declar origin countri interest commun industri compani group applic belong commun produc rbm signific product face difficult environ low price dump subsidis injuri import countri remain threat restructur oper file bankruptci avoid bankruptci procedur quarter commun industri make effort build sound busi compet chines export produc world wide basi expiri anti dump measur import origin prc undermin strategi chines export produc shown past push price dump level order gain market share bear mind effect measur place partial undermin absorpt practic dump subsidis rbm import indonesia expiri measur make current restructur effort commun industri imposs commun industri long tradit ceas exist current restructur effort fail robert kraus gmbh amp kg file bankruptci januari successor kraus ringbuchtechnik gmbh own wilhelm vom hoff drahtwerk gmbh june file bankruptci april acquir asset personnel ringbuchtechnik produktionsgesellschaft gmbh resum product applic open bankruptci procedur sx bürowaren produkt und handel gmbh continu tradit koloman handler ag bankruptci end commun industri commun industri stop manufactur rbm skill accumul centuri job left lost renew measur enabl commun industri increas market share decreas unit manufactur cost increas profit price chang significantli sale volum grow substanti restructur commun industri intend boost competit posit allow plan rbm type produc increas negoti power vi vi supplier streamlin sale oper measur contribut reduct cost commun industri viabl bankruptci posit suppli import part commun market conjunct product site locat hungari part commun product sx bürowaren produkt und handel gmbh acquisit benson long time trader rbm compani locat netherland singapor unit kingdom usa show commun industri enhanc access market world wide basi serious restructur effort main issu rais disclosur firstli abus domin posit commun industri respect commiss awar anti trust procedur compani concern alleg commun industri relat chines export benson import part commun industri group exclus distributor product sold ww chines export control product india found suppli agreement benson ww initi foresaw transfer intellectu properti right ww benson transfer benson share ww transfer place suppli agreement forese exclus benson ww stipul benson prioriti exclus distributor supplier ceas activ alleg relationship confirm interest import cooper unrel import acquir sx bürowaren produkt und handel gmbh august relat commun industri ip event ip account acquisit signific last event case account interest import commun industri relat compani unrel import cooper investig suggest measur place unrel import significantli affect measur interest user user cooper investig suggest measur place user significantli affect measur situat user deterior result mainten anti dump measur period consid binder manufactur reduc product close plant commun case move expand product capac commun eastern european countri reason decis user motiv lower labour cost proxim countri commun market combin perspect countri member european union price rbm sold commun industri downward trend import low price rbm ship india indonesia thailand subject anti dump duti period consid stress commun industri ceas exist user total depend import origin prc import chines subsidiari countri moment chines export produc incent substanti increas price market prc endang competit user industri commun industri interest price polici contribut closur commun binder manufactur weaker posit compet commun chines export produc subsidiari measur renew altern sourc suppli worth note current anti dump measur import origin prc entail shortag import rbm commun market interest upstream industri supplier steel wire steel strip sell neglig percentag product commun industri affect outcom proceed made interest parti competit trade distort effect respect effect expiri measur competit commun note produc rbm world wide chines control chines export produc disappear remain produc control chines compani neg effect competit commun conclus commun interest take account factor consider conclud compel reason mainten current anti dump measur anti dump measur light forego consid provid articl basic regul anti dump measur import rbm origin prc impos council regul ec amend council regul ec maintain long durat investig consid measur limit year adopt regul articl definit anti dump duti impos import ring binder mechan classifi cn code origin peopl republ china purpos regul ring binder mechan consist rectangular steel sheet wire half ring made steel wire fix steel cover open pull half ring small steel made trigger mechan fix ring binder mechan rate definit anti dump duti applic net free commun frontier price duti mechan ring taric code amount duti equal differ minimum import price eur piec net free commun frontier price duti mechan ring taric code rate duti taric addit code peopl republ china world wide stationeri mfg hong kong peopl republ china compani provis forc custom duti appli articl anti dump duti impos period year date entri forc regul articl regul enter forc dai public offici journal european union regul bind entireti directli applic member state brussel novemb council presid brinkhorst oj regul amend regul ec oj oj oj oj oj oj oj oj data index number rang preserv confidenti