commiss decis march aid germani grant develop assist indonesia connect construct dredger volkswerft stralsund sale dredger pengerukan rukindo notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard council direct eec decemb aid shipbuild extend council regul ec articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant articl ec treati cite regard comment receiv procedur european dredg associ inform commiss germani grant aid sale dredger built germani aid appear breach direct eec hereinaft refer quot shipbuild direct quot letter date novemb germani provid commiss inform letter date april commiss inform germani decid initi articl proceed respect aid commiss decis initi proceed publish offici journal european commun commiss invit interest parti submit comment measur commiss receiv comment interest parti forward germani opportun react comment receiv letter date june octob letter date march commiss inform germani decid close part proceed proceed vessel kk aru ii letter date june germani provid commiss addit inform dredger vessel cd batang anai ff bali ii ii detail descript aid commiss approv develop aid grant connect sale dredger volkswerft stralsund indonesian public corpor pengerukan rukindo hereinaft refer quot rukindo quot letter sg commiss inform germani approv develop aid grant form loan kreditanstalt für wiederaufbau loan cover contract period year interest rate oecd aid equival rukindo state limit liabil corpor share own ministri financ borrow loan republ indonesia repres ministri financ notif propos aid march stipul locat indonesia dredger letter approv germani commiss state dredger indonesia european dredg associ inform commiss vessel taiwan thailand appar oper vessel particip intern tender competit compani suppli dredg servic associ aid enabl supplier charg price market price germani confirm dredger indonesian water malaysia mention oper taiwan thailand report european dredg associ germani claim dredger oper optim indonesian water due delai number larg harbour build project dredger origin acquir dredger malaysia form part subcontract order indonesian firm rukindo particip directli intern invit tender addit germani undertook draw indonesian govern attent fact dredger properli purpos origin acquir germani provid inform rukindo financi situat subordin bodi draw certifi inform annual account direct loan relationship exist compani light answer germani commiss view manner dredger compli commiss approv commiss doubt project assum natur develop aid question measur compat condit laid articl shipbuild direct commiss decid initi proceed articl ec treati iii comment interest parti public notic initi proceed denmark european dredg associ submit comment view dredger accord condit laid commiss approv breach shipbuild direct iv comment germani germani made point dredger acquir connect develop main indonesian port tanjung priok batam bojonegra surabaya belawan semarang panjang ujung padang water depth metr due unforese financi difficulti prove imposs make fund requir develop work dredg work carri limit extent port belawan tanjung priok surabaya maritim develop project carri privat firm indonesian govern delai predict delai affect project develop port land reclam locat bojonegra benoa bali maruda jakarta situbondo kuala namu ancol barat ancol timur surabaya kapuk naga pantai mutiara pelabuhan ratu kerawang ring road surabaya betio benoa bali bali benoa marina line avail fund rukindo dredger includ kk aru ii ff bali ii cd batang anai continu complet project rukindo result current indonesian crisi term delai carri project time contract conclud dredger aid grant scope exist deploi vessel indonesia defer plan indonesian project clear dredger deliv point time long aid grant rukindo find wai deploi dredger dredger design special work indonesia requir deeper draught dredger servic time work effect dredger water depth metr deeper draught dredger restrict opportun altern deploy indonesian harbour waterwai order limit period inact recoup portion fix cost personnel cost capit cost rukindo option tender servic dredger dredg firm vessel indonesia abroad occur slack period harbour extens project delai leas dredger abroad effort make effici develop aid gener addit capit project form foreign currenc dredger abroad made acquir develop period dredger indonesia dredger abroad run counter primari object develop indonesian transport infrastructur complet work domest project continu absolut prioriti rukindo dredger project work carri indonesia dredger indonesia except cd batang anai taiwan work dai total dai spent taiwan ff bali ii malaysia dai dai involv econom profit except vessel taiwan malaysia neglig signific compar made vessel indonesia compar year term credit total technic life dredger rukindo request tender document case particip tender rukindo particip directli intern tender enter direct competit foreign firm rukindo direct influenc price servic main tender contractor usual practic main contractor enter negoti dredg compani award contract subcontractor subcontractor rukindo accept price dredger abroad fact result actual loss financi earn incom earn made grant aid unnecessari cd batang anai taiwan repres real loss term total subcontract period loss exceed cost altern idl product time indonesia kreditanstalt für wiederaufbau germani call indonesian ministri financ ensur dredger acquir basi aid sole indonesia germani note loan agreement provis place dredger discuss made clear relev indonesian ministri dredger indonesia abroad domest unwritten commerci basi loan final germani request effect econom financi crisi east asia indonesia account assess aid project approv articl shipbuild direct articl aid grant develop assist develop countri subject ceil set commiss articl deem compat common market compli term laid purpos oecd work parti agreement interpret articl understand export credit ship corrigendum agreement commiss prior notif individu aid propos verifi develop content propos aid satisfi fall scope agreement judgment octob court justic held case quot precis examin content enabl commiss ensur aid base articl intend reduc cost vessel develop countri pursu light specif condit applic genuin develop object fact compli oecd criteria constitut aid favour shipyard member state subject ceil quot commiss letter state basi german notif dredger indonesia germani confirm ff bali ii cd batang anai deploi exclus indonesia mean vessel accord condit attach commiss approv aid misus germani argu deploy dredger forese time vessel order aid grant commiss rule possibl fact case ow delai primari object aid fulli achiev uncertain extent develop aid fact enabl indonesia fulli pursu develop object commiss take note argument put forward germani rukindo influenc tender price abroad deploy abroad profit great extent preclud vessel deploi indonesia competit compani price offer market price result aid fact basi inform made commiss distinguish vessel indonesia indonesia ensur aid benefici indonesia directli benefici countri principl benefit develop aid deploy indonesia problemat case commiss accept germani argument indonesia explicitli run counter initi object aid initi object aid develop insid indonesia dredger indonesia reduct develop contribut indonesia form dredg carri dredger indonesia addit distort creat dredg market countri list countri elig develop aid vessel receiv develop aid deploi indonesia addit deploi pure commerci basi malaysia taiwan list countri elig develop aid develop aid content project put doubt germani argu deploy indonesia neglig compar indonesia tabl provid germani show ff bali ii dai indonesia dai malaysia cd batang anai dai indonesia dai taiwan vessel station approxim dai commiss share view vessel indonesia amount period year approxim consid except neglig view larg number island make indonesia commiss convinc imposs deploi vessel indonesia ensur genuin develop content complianc commiss approv fact condit locat vessel state loan agreement explicitli encourag oper seek option germani inform indonesian parti vessel indonesia realiti indonesian legal oblig compli request condit state loan agreement germani oblig ensur grant loan line condit laid commiss approv fact germani import condit loan agreement fulli compli condit commiss decis serv germani excus misus aid inabl influenc indonesia matter addit omiss condit loan agreement rais doubt develop object main concern project commiss time approv decis letter vessel intend exclus indonesia fact commerci basi malaysia taiwan approv aid commiss consid aid misus genuin develop object pursu vi conclus commiss find aid grant germani connect build dredger ff bali ii cd batang anai misus aid consid genuin develop aid mean articl shipbuild direct aid distort threaten distort competit common market affect trade member state relat shipbuild extent contrari common interest adopt decis articl state aid germani grant form credit facil connect sale dredger ff bali ii cd batang anai pengerukan rukindo indonesia misus incompat common market articl germani recov recipi aid refer articl recoveri effect accord procedur provis german law sum recov bear interest date made recipi actual recoveri interest calcul basi refer rate calcul grant equival region aid articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli brussel march commiss karel van miert member commiss oj oj oj footnot ecr paragraph commiss letter member state sg sg