commiss decis april declar concentr compat common market function eea agreement case comp bombardi adtranz notifi document number english text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun regard agreement european econom area hereinaft eea agreement articl thereof regard council regul eec decemb control concentr undertak hereinaft merger regul amend regul ec articl thereof regard commiss decis decemb initi proceed case regard opinion advisori committe concentr octob commiss receiv notif pursuant articl merger regul propos concentr bombardi hereinaft bombardi acquir sole control undertak daimlerchrysl rail system gmbh hereinaft adtranz merg activ world wide decis date decemb commiss found notifi oper rais doubt compat common market commiss initi proceed case pursuant articl merger regul parti bombardi canadian corpor engag design develop manufactur market aircraft rail transport equip recreat product industri addit compani offer servic relat core product core busi subsidiari involv financi servic develop real estat interest bombardi oper plant north america western europ revenu gener canada adtranz wholli own daimlerchrysl ag engag manufactur distribut rail transport vehicl current activ cover manufactur sale roll stock equip fix instal signal equip prior independ present transact compani decid focu roll stock busi adtranz enter bind agreement sell fix instal busi unit kingdom base group balfour beatti subject clearanc offic fair trade adtranz intend sell signal equip oper buyer found ii concentr bombardi intend acquir sole control adtranz purchas transfer adtranz share held daimler chrysler ag notifi oper constitut concentr mean articl merger regul iii commun dimens undertak concern combin aggreg world wide turnov eur billion bombardi eur billion financi year end januari adtranz eur billion financi year end decemb aggreg commun wide turnov excess eur million bombardi eur million financi year end januari adtranz eur million financi year end decemb achiev third aggreg commun wide turnov member state notifi oper commun dimens mean articl merger regul constitut cooper case eea agreement pursuant articl agreement iv competit assess relev product market decis case iv abb daimler benz commiss categoris market railwai transport technolog product group mainlin train region train local train waysid system miscellan product group subdivid inter alia electr diesel locomot electr diesel multipl unit emu dmu passeng coach freight wagon tram underground train compon spare part mainten subdivis constitut relev product market whilst market investig case confirm delin abb daimler benz larg applic shown addit subdivis account relev product market found high speed train propel electr multipl unit emu diesel multipl unit dmu interc transport hereinaft refer interc train mainlin train emu dmu region transport hereinaft refer region train passeng coach tram light rail vehicl refer lrv underground vehicl airport peopl mover apm heavi mainten servic light mainten servic refurbish rail vehicl high speed train french tgv alstom german ic train highli integr propel unit locomot haul train design travel long distanc speed km convent track case dedic track high speed travel km km propel unit interc transport set coach traction compon fulli integr passeng coach locomot merg train set separ coupl order increas capac intend long rang travel urban centr ordinari rail track achiev speed km km tilt technolog basic type propel interc train unit electr multipl unit emu diesel multipl unit dmu type propel unit parti activ overlap combin market share vari significantli left open case separ product market exist interc emu dmu region train propel unit oper lower speed km built singl multipl unit case interc train left open separ product market exist region emu dmu parti suggest separ market segment number seat train seat train seat commut train set seat clear major answer commiss market investig agre market definit custom answer order vehicl segment arbitrari common practic combin train set peak hour order train narrow seat mention custom respons segment singl doubl decker car envisag issu explor impact competit assess concentr suggest parti distinct mainlin region train rigid accept industri definit degre overlap product market product market featur render distinct valid region train top speed overrid issu due frequent stop rout agreement germani region train oper speed km capac import region train comfort product requir reflect technic profil product propuls system design lower oper speed interior layout focus function demand side point view product suppli side note major player market activ market except small player activ region train stadler jenbach capabl switch mainlin train signific adjust cost distinct mainlin region train remain valid purpos decis passeng coach includ propel railwai vehicl mainlin smaller extent region passeng transport haul type locomot coach propuls make adapt nation environ easier requir significantli product technolog roll stock tram light rail vehicl parti suggest distinct low floor high floor tram answer commiss market investig demand side perspect clear trend urban public transport compani low floor tram high floor tram progress replac low floor tram come end life cycl low floor tram involv low floor specif invest infrastructur platform level access car technic imposs switch system fact tram oper system track oper hesit revert high floor tram introduc low floor system reason inter alia cost specif low floor platform frustrat increas comfort level access longer proposit low floor tram instanc solut compli specif legisl local polici design grant handicap peopl access public transport suppli side perspect answer commiss market investig point substitut high floor low floor tram segment constitut separ product market underground vehicl metro electr vehicl run steel rubber wheel transport peopl citi centr complet segreg track underground metro gener heavier sturdier lrv greater capac accommod high flow passeng car peak travel time built acceler deceler quickli due short distanc station airport peopl mover apm complet autom vehicl form part integr transit system carri passeng plane termin termin airport travel time short passeng carri luggag quick load unload crucial fit larg door seat capac rout gener simpl guidanc system sophist autom guid transport agt mainten refurbish result market investig suggest distinct made light mainten heavi mainten refurbish light mainten includ dai dai repair compon exchang safeti check carri regular basi heavi mainten contrari cover substanti intervent major overhaul railwai vehicl carri central workshop regular infrequ basi durat dai week final refurbish involv modernis adapt roll stock complet concept design case bodi shell railwai vehicl remain unchang type servic requir equip skill technolog regard separ market relev geograph market nation market region train tram light rail vehicl underground train case abb daimler benz relev geograph market rail vehicl found nation member state larg domest rail technolog industri meet custom demand recent case comp alstom fiat ferroviaria comp daimlerchrysl adtranz question left open commiss conduct market investig found market characterist larg unchang abb daimler benz bombardi submit market roll stock regard european rail vehicl industri evolv consider europeanis decis abb daimler benz reason put forward bombardi support submiss includ eu public procur rule appli train tender undermin practic award signific contract nation champion manufactur compet order europ eea increas number eu countri unit kingdom spain portug finland award contract compani countri eu countri germani franc itali contract continu award compani local presenc consortia involv local compani bid contest train manufactur eu member state eu countri european wide bid context increas standardis rail equip infrastructur europ major market player tend offer call product platform object serv custom requir restrict number basic product design produc customis product project bombardi market entri barrier lower european wide bid facilit commiss investig confirm member state strong nation rail industri market consid larg nation take germani order rail vehicl exclus prime contractor main supplier establish germani foreign supplier bid tender spite eu procur rule standardis trend signific foreign entrant german market french compani alstom canadian compani bombardi success depend significantli format consortia german player begin acquisit german compani link hoffmann busch gmbh salzgitt hereinaft lhb case alstom talbot deutsch waggonbau hereinaft dwa case bombardi experi alstom bombardi support definit market nation case germani commiss view support competitor custom parti remain divers infrastructur requir member state cite major obstacl europeanis market eu procur rule implement appear real obstacl european wide bid li nation standard rail infrastructur parti result market investig provid strong evid open nation market accomplish forecast period year commiss appli abb daimler benz case take account peculiar rail technolog sector respect born mind reason put forward exist nation market germani time larg extent ident put forward parti case result market investig proven line abb daimler benz reason assum phenomena entri foreign competitor suffici standardis instanc framework mari industri forum shown signific effect year trigger major chang market condit futur respect import note bombardi reason intern strategi document provid commiss notif past face show local presenc common approach bui local manufactur maintain widespread network local product facil target market bombardi express view europeanis nation market hinder lack harmonis technic standard exist infrastructur progress extrem slowli accomplish commiss conclud market region train tram lrv underground train nation scope open market definit high speed train interc train passeng coach airport peopl mover lack harmonis result enorm cost burden product tendenc market scope wider nation discern high speed train oper tran european network thali ic convert run countri make train expens nation configur definit relev geograph market high speed train left open competit assess chang irrespect definit chosen commiss investig market interc train passeng coach airport peopl mover nation eea wide level case high speed train scope relev geograph market product left open competit assess chang irrespect definit chosen nation market mainten refurbish servic light mainten heavi mainten refurbish servic concern relev geograph market defin nation nation result market investig confirm conclus fact local presenc mainten servic provid essenti econom train oper compani move roll stock region oper distant place mainten purpos loss oper time profit transport cost incur order avoid drawback train oper provid mainten servic quot hous quot depot pictur chang evolv trend train oper quot sourc quot mainten train supplier case local presenc acquisit local depot supplier utmost import conclus light commiss consid relev geograph market product servic nation region train tram lrv underground train mainten refurbish contrast trend european market appar high speed train interc train airport peopl mover passeng coach precis definit relev geograph market product left open competit assess present case chang irrespect definit chosen gener market condit main characterist rail technolog market europ privatis increas cost conscious custom ongo consolid process manufactur trend platform base product fact contract gener award bid process trend platform base product past design develop manufactur rail technolog product place close collabor supplier custom custom direct influenc product manufactur select firm produc tailor made product trend supplier offer set product refer platform base product custom choos object serv custom restrict number platform design produc complet vehicl project nation custom specif technic requir differ platform base approach manufactur obtain economi scale scope part train requir customis siemen supplier introduc platform base lrv product potsdam time exist platform base product exert signific price pressur competitor result price decreas present major european manufactur develop platform base product line alstom instanc promot citadi tram metropoli underground train trapoli coradia region train platform adtranz begun offer incentro tram movia underground train itino region train crusari interc train platform ansaldobreda develop platform tram sector call sirio siemen product portfolio includ combino tram momo underground train desiro region train platform bombardi cityrunn tram talent region train product line platform base bombardi manufactur platform base product market segment custom tram sector reluct bui platform product continu demand individu customis solut custom custom rail vehicl nation railwai compani increas number region local transport compani municip grow number privat undertak addit undertak hereinaft refer railwai oper privat custom provid transport servic specialis leas rail vehicl railwai oper privatis fewer public resourc polit pressur develop effici rail transport system result railwai oper sophist cost consciou procur polici purchas power effect purchas pool bui consortia common recent year local train oper custom increasingli concern product perform standard life cycl cost contract manag abil manufactur offer leader consortium complet product assum respons main select criteria roll stock custom manufactur main european manufactur roll stock compani produc mechan part electr propuls element rail vehicl call full line supplier system integr adtranz alstom ansaldobreda siemen addit smaller compani focu suppli mechan electr element railwai vehicl mechan element produc spanish manufactur construccion auxiliar de ferrocarril hereinaft caf patent talgo hereinaft talgo swiss manufactur stadler rail ag hereinaft stadler supplier capabl suppli complet train diesel engin propuls dmu supplier electr propuls technolog german compani kiep elektrik gmbh amp kg düsseldorf hereinaft kiep austrian compani elin ebg traction gmbh vienna hereinaft elin past compani form consortia supplier offer complet packag recent year consortia diminish due consolid integr process rail technolog industri introduct brand platform product consequ supplier electr propuls compon supplier platform product product famili partner consortia bombardi intermedi posit system integr integr manufactur main focu suppli mechan part roll stock bombardi suppli complet train set diesel propuls dmu manag bid prime contractor tram lrv region train electr propuls germani austria due close cooper kiep tram sector elin tram region train sector context cooper kiep elin provid electr propuls bid market data account determin market strength roll stock manufactur account fact contract purchas rail vehicl award result bid process public call tender market share figur account activ winner contract show credibl competitor particip bidder creat competit constraint demand rail technolog vari time order assess parti market strength correctli fairli long period consid gener rule market share analys decis calcul basi undertak averag market volum share year period case market trend chang substanti period shorter period account order ensur market share reflect accur post merger competit situat note case compani submit bid part consortia case consortia decis prime contractor winner contract market share attribut member consortium share consortium note present fulli repres competit strength member consortia member easili replac particip crucial obtain contract final project subsuppli kiep elin particip market share sole attribut respect prime contractor manufactur mechan part train compani oper local subsidiari bid data market share attribut parent compani base contract award shorter period account contrari option exercis custom period consid base contract tender earlier reflect competit environ underli base contract award begin privatis train oper compani transposit german law public procur direct affect market notifi concentr affect market high speed train germani netherland european econom area eea propel unit interc transport germani eea passeng coach eea region train germani tram light rail vehicl austria franc sweden germani underground vehicl austria heavi mainten servic unit kingdom uk busi bombardi adtranz extent complementari predominantli focus manufactur mechan element railwai vehicl electr propuls element market real overlap activ parti part consortium bombardi suppli mechan part whilst adtranz respons electr compon exist signific overlap parti activ market region train tram lrv offer brand product adtranz manufactur mechan part roll stock high speed train germani netherland eea market high speed train bombardi adtranz member ic consortium consortium leader prime contractor ic siemen account consortium share adtranz consortium bombardi order eea high speed train year period deutsch bahn ag netherland railwai ns oper order ic adtranz bombardi member consortium suppli ic real overlap parti activ netherland germani relev market eea reason appli competit situat high speed train sector note consortia common industri enorm cost develop true german dutch market examin case geograph market europ countri instanc italian etr suppli consortium ansoldobreda adtranz spanish talgo talgo siemen adtranz talgo manufactur coach european industri leader alstom siemen join forc win contract taiwan bombardi suppli centr coach ic manufactur consortium alstom mechan part compet tgv alstom state repli commiss bombardi particip project merger easili replac bombardi supplier centr coach mechan part caf ansaldobreda demand side highli concentr nation market netherland germani european level buyer nation railwai oper except unit kingdom mean countri buyer railwai oper start form buyer consortia instanc belgian nation train oper compani sncb team french british counterpart order purchas tgv eurostar high speed train similar agreement enter sncb french dutch counterpart acquisit tgv thali high speed train deutsch bahn sncf main custom high speed train europ publicli announc autumn tender jointli fourth gener high speed train oper germani franc countri consortium form suppli fourth gener alstom siemen negoti term condit consortium build train parti state develop fourth gener high speed train conclus competit situat germani netherland eea chang result transact bombardi adtranz part consortium ic bombardi suppli mechan part alstom tgv market investig show easili replac manufactur merg entiti develop high speed train increas competit demand side concentr consider buyer power balanc concentr suppli side buyer countri monopsonist european level larg buyer form buyer consortia propos transact lead creation strengthen domin posit market high speed train germani netherland eea interc mainlin train germani eea interc mainlin train nation market activ parti overlap germani contract award deutsch bahn ag contract tender deutsch bahn ag award adtranz consortium led siemen bombardi supplier mechan compon siemen state repli commiss bombardi particip project merger easili replac bombardi supplier mechan part german market parti compet bombardi submit bid takeov adtranz bombardi number supplier system integr offer interc train chang european level tender relev period repres total volum car total eur billion tender alstom won repres term volum adtranz bombardi remain tender won consortia siemen prime contractor contract alstom caf alstom part consortia led siemen alstom winner part win consortium contract alstom clear market leader case high speed train demand side highli concentr mean countri buyer nation railwai oper enjoi signific countervail power except unit kingdom tender account half european demand interc train place compani invit tender larg power train oper great western group connex activ internation back financ compani subsidiari larg multin bank hsbc conclus german market competit situat chang significantli result merger relev geograph market eea merg entiti distant market leader alstom siemen regard custom credibl integr supplier consider buyer power nation railwai compani train oper case unit kingdom propos transact lead creation strengthen domin posit parti market interc train germani eea passeng coach eea market passeng coach parti activ larg extent complementari bombardi adtranz won contract member state overlap relev geograph market found cover eea area repres affect market adtranz add bombardi european wide market share adtranz won contract austria competitor market includ siemen alstom ansaldobreda caf case high speed interc train demand side highli concentr mean countri buyer nation railwai oper order relev period made nation railwai oper austria belgium finland germani greec itali spain consider buyer power propos transact lead creation strengthen domin posit parti market coach eea region train germani market region train germani parti combin market share amount bombardi adtranz note largest part adtranz market share achiev sale regioshuttl market stadler gelenktriebwagen gtw entrust adtranz end year final year period year examin gtw introduc german market adtranz sold regioshuttl gtw region train germani largest player german market siemen alstom fring compani market swiss manufactur stadler austrian manufactur jenbach transportsystem ag hereinaft jenbach integr compani account market share point time regard independ competitor parti hand market question bid market competit assess notifi concentr exclus base analysi market share parti main competitor german market siemen alstom remain credibl activ bidder hand notifi concentr undoubtedli reduc number independ supplier region train german market bombardi adtranz siemen alstom subsidiari bombardi adtranz siemen alstom subsidiari bombardi adtranz obtain clear market leadership background aspect account tender year period repres total volum car total eur billion bombardi adtranz submit separ bid total contract examin commiss repres eur million volum car market case examin commiss repres eur million volum car market parti particip bidder contract tender deutsch bahn ag repres eur million volum car market award consortium consist bombardi adtranz main competitor siemen case examin commiss parti submit bid parti compet award contract repres market case submit separ bid siemen part br consortium adtranz bombardi won contract train set car db regio ag respons electr part train siemen brand product market desiro regiosprint regiosprint light weight dmu sold small quantiti germani parti regiosprint accept deutsch bahn ag low buffer load crashworthi contrast desiro newli develop platform product receiv marketplac alstom develop product famili call coradia trapoli modular platform product alstom secur larg contract db regio ag br consortium adtranz suppli electr part won signific number contract coradia lint recent jenbach start develop dmu successor br call integr jenbach award contract suppli bavarian oberlandbahn train deliv earli brought jenbach market share train back depot due sever qualiti problem oper earli jenbach strateg partner jenbach consid strong competitor market stadler market share switzerland small initi exce eu result contract austria greec compani product gelenktriebwagen gtw launch german market consortium adtranz dwa stadler gtw account german market year period stadler initi produc market gtw enter german market give licenc dwa adapt gtw german market built major car stadler initi subsuppli dwa manufactur mechan part adtranz supplier electr part respons market gtw earli stadler acquir major stake adtranz product site berlin pankow stadler plan manufactur gtw german market adtranz hold minor share call stadler pankow gmbh hereinaft stadler pankow joint ventur joint ventur contract adtranz oblig guarante number manufactur hour fill capac higher capit particip oblig end order fulfil oblig adtranz transfer manufactur regioshuttl rs stadler pankow market ownership rs remain adtranz initi market agreement gtw adtranz stadler laps decemb januari stadler market gtw adtranz partner stadler pankow joint ventur influenc decis gtw stadler present consid fulli independ competitor merg entiti long structur link adtranz remain unchang deutsch bahn regio ag biggest custom region train germani countervail buyer power privat own smaller oper region train privatis process continu smaller region train oper compani belong french compani connex vivendi group activ europ major demand side fragment market high speed interc train enjoi degre buyer power risk market domin parti rule conclus reason notifi concentr rais doubt compat common market regard region train germani creat domin posit parti market tram light rail vehicl austria franc sweden germani austria small number contract award austria period contract examin commiss bombardi won repres eur million market volum car market siemen won contract repres eur million market volum car market contract repres eur million volum car award consortium consist bombardi adtranz elin siemen adtranz market share austria exclus base particip consortium overlap parti except result particip consortium compet circumst notifi oper lead creation strengthen domin posit parti austrian market tram light rail vehicl firstli market issu bid market small number contract award competit assess notifi concentr exclus base analysi market share market share reveal credibl competitor particip public tender activ bidder number activ credibl bidder austrian tram lrv market chang result notifi concentr adtranz particip win consortium case compet bombardi major supplier final posit siemen strong competitor austrian market remain unchang franc tram light rail vehicl franc parti combin market share bombardi adtranz alstom market share investig commiss found evid creation duopolist domin bombardi adtranz alstom french market fact addit current market leader alstom bombardi adtranz competitor activ bidder french market siemen ansaldobreda caf total contract tender alstom submit bid bombardi siemen adtranz ansaldobreda caf tender examin parti directli compet bidder strong posit alstom french market presenc activ bidder siemen takeov adtranz bombardi lead creation strengthen domin posit french market tram light rail vehicl sweden swedish market tram light rail vehicl contract sl infrateknik ab stockholm award year period examin commiss contract repres total eur million twelv car bombardi adtranz submit bid contract member singl consortium share consortium bombardi adtranz compet activ swedish market overlap commiss market investig reveal evid creation strengthen domin posit parti sweden germani germani largest market tram light rail vehicl europ parti combin market share amount bombardi adtranz siemen alstom calcul year basi cover year hand market issu bid market competit assess notifi concentr exclus base analysi market share parti main competitor german market siemen alstom remain credibl activ bidder tram light rail vehicl purchas germani examin commiss siemen particip bidder project tender short list case won ten contract success rate alstom compani submit bid period time short list time won contract note alstom recent focuss product site german subsidiari lhb salzgitt manufactur region train tram light rail vehicl german market enhanc compani futur chanc win contract germani increas current market share siemen alstom full product portfolio cover rang applic satisfi custom requir siemen supplier introduc platform base product market combino low floor tram citysprint high floor tram dual voltag gt whilst alstom offer citadi low floor tram wagen high floor tram dual voltag citadi tram train hand notifi concentr undoubtedli reduc number lead activ supplier tram light rail vehicl german market bombardi adtranz siemen alstom subsidiari bombardi adtranz siemen alstom subsidiari bombardi adtranz obtain clear market leadership background aspect account firstli parti product portfolio degre complementari notifi oper entiti bombardi adtranz posit market tram light rail vehicl hand acknowledg high floor tram low floor tram tram train found belong product market parti activ field extent complementari fact adtranz activ market platform base incentro low floor tram vario tram modular low floor tram whilst bombardi market low floor tram cityrunn ngt high floor tram dual voltag tram train hand notifi oper parti offer complet rang tram lrv product cover high floor low floor market segment enabl gain competit strength accept past bid activ parti degre complementari notifi concentr enhanc entiti possibl particip public tender note parti compet approxim half project tender germani bombardi adtranz submit separ bid total amp lt contract examin commiss repres eur million market volum car whilst amp lt case examin commiss repres eur million volum car parti particip bidder case examin commiss repres eur million volum car bombardi adtranz part consortium compet takeov adtranz necessarili result strengthen bombardi competit posit market fact enlarg entiti product portfolio cover rang product tram lrv sector submit bid public tender publish germani thirdli parti high market share counterbalanc extent increas influenc custom tram market commiss market investig shown buyer power suffici outweigh effect notifi concentr hand custom bargain power increas purchas pool bui consortia common recent year instanc german municip train oper leipzig verkehrsbetrieb gmbh rostock straßenbahn ag recent issu joint call tender tram market mannheim versorgung und verkehrsgesellschaft ag mvv verkehr ag cooper heidelberg straßen und bergbahn ag oberrheinisch eisenbahn ag rhein haardtbahn gmbh verkehrsbetrieb ludwigshafen gmbh market investig shown consortia cooper expect futur hand true vast major custom local train oper compani municip unlik market high speed interc train demand side tram lrv sector remain fragment enjoi suffici degre countervail buyer power rule danger market domin parti result market investig suggest remain barrier entri german tram light rail vehicl market disregard due custom prefer supplier nation local presenc qualiti requir technic specif concentr jeopardis exist electr propuls supplier kiep activ german market tram kiep team mechan supplier past import part turnov railwai busi gener suppli bombardi bombardi integr produc rail vehicl takeov adtranz longer reli electr propuls equip smaller supplier kiep elin import partner bombardi commiss market investig reveal concern supplier lose busi reduc role nich player case longer serv partner integr mechan supplier stadler act gatekeep potenti integr market entrant caf talgo conclus reason notifi concentr rais doubt compat common market regard tram light rail vehicl germani creat domin posit parti market underground vehicl austria underground vehicl commiss market investig shown contract award austria period contract vienna underground quot bahn typ wagen quot bombardi adtranz particip compet bid hand bombardi kiep subsuppli hand siemen adtranz elin subsuppli contract award consortium led siemen contract vienna underground quot bahn typ quot award consortium consist bombardi adtranz siemen kiep elin subsuppli total parti account austrian market adtranz bombardi remain held siemen circumst refer market issu bid market competit assess effect notifi concentr austria base mere analysi market share parti competit overlap regard underground vehicl austria signific vienna underground urban metro system place austria expect tender publish year exist vienna underground system austrian citi market investig commiss found evid creation strengthen domin posit parti austria regard underground vehicl heavi mainten servic unit kingdom heavi mainten sector unit kingdom parti combin market share amount adtranz bombardi railcar alstom local train oper compani account heavi mainten market unit kingdom base figur bombardi adtranz achiev lead posit unit kingdom heavi mainten market concentr give rise competit concern notifi parti submit major part turnov gener bombardi unit kingdom heavi mainten segment achiev result execut contract termin end point time notifi parti order backlog bombardi conclud contract due enter forc heavi mainten sector bombardi signific spare capac offer heavi mainten servic futur conclus light concentr give rise competit concern unit kingdom heavi mainten sector bombardi activ unit kingdom heavi mainten market significantli decreas major overlap parti heavi mainten activ time commiss found evid creation strengthen domin posit parti unit kingdom affect market airport peopl mover apm adtranz world leader market apm global market share main competitor poma oti joint ventur pomagalski franc american compani oti matra siemen mitsubishi adtranz won contract eea period award airport rome bombardi apm product overlap adtranz bombardi bombardi evalu option enter apm market compani form allianc mitsubishi heavi industri hereinaft mhi bombardi market system integr mhi vehicl signal system date mhi bombardi relationship result joint apm bid europ mhi bombardi process prepar bid madrid airport intend particip bid process charl de gaull airport project bombardi mhi agre termin relationship propos transact adtranz consumm bombardi withdrawn madrid airport project transact strengthen domin posit adtranz european apm market put risk entranc supplier apm european market mhi state finalis bid madrid airport sumitomo propos transact lead elimin potenti entrant strengthen adtranz domin posit market europ undertak order address aforement competit concern aris german market region train tram parti submit undertak recit full text undertak set annex form integr part decis undertak aim strengthen independ stadler adtranz oper joint ventur stadler pankow berlin stadler joint ventur parent compani common product site assembl region train adtranz regioshuttl rs stadler gelenktriebwagen gtw adtranz hold share joint ventur whilst stadler hold remain share adtranz appoint member joint ventur supervisori board veto joint ventur budget stadler pankow jointli control parent compani parti offer withdraw joint ventur divest adtranz stake stadler pankow stadler parti offer interim measur ensur stadler pankow continu busi activ includ capac load guarante total work hour year stadler pankow end larg exceed adtranz current oblig joint ventur agreement commit suppli stadler transit period year compon current commerci term subject adjust inflat undertak aim preserv effect competit german market region train tram light rail vehicl parti offer grant exclus licens product market eu product line regioshuttl region train variotram tram stadler regioshuttl repres roughli german market region train period variotram repres approxim german market tram light rail vehicl period product sold custom undertak aim strengthen independ elin bombardi undertak divest minor stake undertak elin elin manufactur propuls technolog rail vehicl region train tram bombardi electr propuls provid talent region train tram cityrunn linz type bombardi undertak addit exist cooper elin develop region train talent type extend cooper elin light rail vehicl cityrunn linz type period year joint develop agreement conclud undertak aim strengthen independ kiep addit bombardi undertak exclus traction equip undertak kiep worldwid sale high floor tram type eu wide sale tram train saarbrücken vehicl type period year propos exclus cooper kiep bind bombardi unilater exclus bombardi offer order instal work kiep valu dem year period year cooper agreement conclud vi assess undertak confirm result market test conduct commiss undertak consid suffici properli remedi competit concern german market region train tram lrv outlin propos undertak ensur independ remain integr player market region train tram lrv increas competit compani hand elin kiep electr propuls provid hand stadler mechan manufactur region train tram light rail vehicl stadler establish import manufactur region train tram german market whilst kiep elin continu plai import role electr propuls supplier integr mechan manufactur stadler undertak submit parti provid compens disappear adtranz manufactur region train tram light rail vehicl situat stadler elin kiep stadler stadler pankow minor stake adtranz joint ventur grant joint control major sharehold stadler instanc joint ventur budget approv unanim sharehold adtranz appoint member joint ventur supervisori board parti access relev busi inform joint ventur concentr clear uncondition sever stadler structur link adtranz stadler pankow turn compani independ manufactur region train acquir regioshuttl variotram licens offer parti stadler establish credibl competitor german market region train tram market stand basi product introduc sold germani guarante transit period provid parti commit offer capac load guarante stadler pankow facil suppli compon stadler current commerci term elin elin minor stake bombardi subsidiari dwa compani grant joint control major sharehold va tech elin ebg gmbh vienna dwa veto strateg busi decis addit bombardi option acquir remain elin major part elin turnov gener project bombardi member elin supervisori board appoint dwa parti access relev busi inform elin concentr clear uncondition sever elin structur link bombardi turn compani independ supplier propuls technolog region train tram light rail vehicl guarante transit period order elin find partner replac bombardi vertic integr acquisit adtranz longer reli elin supplier electr propuls equip joint develop agreement conclud bombardi elin provid cooper compani period year project region train tram sector talent cityrunn linz allow elin continu activ market segment kiep kiep guarante offer bombardi provid suffici time compani find cooper partner replac bombardi vertic integr acquisit adtranz longer reli kiep supplier electr propuls equip cooper agreement conclud bombardi transit period cover high floor tram project light rail vehicl tram train type saarbrücken vehicl provid suffici divers kiep continu activ market segment bombardi commit order dem worth instal work kiep year year period addit econom secur compani find partner cooper stadler elin kiep quot gatekeep quot undertak submit preserv independ propuls supplier elin kiep stadler mechan part train cooper compani medium term compani shown interest cooper stadler cooper compani compet independ supplier german market region train tram light rail vehicl parti siemen alstom elin kiep serv gatekeep german market compani spanish firm caf talgo similar bombardi enter german market cooper kiep fact cooper supplier electr propuls kiep sale tram germani crucial factor allow bombardi rapidli gain consider market share member state year effect market structur region train germani undertak establish stadler signific viabl competitor german market firstli parti divest regioshuttl product line repres approxim market own market adtranz stadler prospect purchas regioshuttl licens withdraw stadler pankow joint ventur adtranz lose influenc stadler gelenktriebwagen gtw busi compani ceas market stadler gtw region train januari adtranz market share decreas stadler gtw introduc germani account german market region train stadler futur market share roughli correspond current share achiev adtranz period period assumpt conform fact recent year adtranz sold regioshuttl gtw region train germani product line adtranz market segment transfer stadler adtranz remain product line itino secur singl order date competit close bombardi talent region train parti stop manufactur market product concentr view conclud overlap parti activ region train germani elimin market situat tram light rail vehicl germani similarli adtranz share market tram light rail vehicl germani decreas significantli base year period decreas due divestitur parti variotram product line repres roughli german market own market adtranz market share attribut stadler prospect purchas variotram licens licens variotram stadler remov half parti overlap german market tram light rail vehicl due oper ensur stadler viabl competitor market potenti replac competit posit adtranz previou oper variotram adtranz tram product sold adtranz germani relev period compar ngt tram variotram modern technic advanc stadler suit produc variotram requir product techniqu stadler pankow regioshuttl acquir variotram licens stadler diversifi product portfolio establish german tram market electr propuls supplier kiep elin activ tram lrv sector suitabl partner stadler conclus commit submit parti enabl establish independ supplier region train tram light rail vehicl stadler larg extent current market posit adtranz undertak ensur independ supplier electr propuls kiep elin remain activ market futur consortia stadler integr mechan supplier commiss reach conclus basi undertak submit parti notifi concentr lead domin posit parti german market region train tram light rail vehicl vii condit oblig pursuant sentenc subparagraph articl merger regul commiss attach decis condit oblig intend ensur undertak concern compli commit enter vi vi commiss view render concentr compat common market distinct made condit oblig requir achiev measur rise structur chang market condit implement step achiev result gener oblig parti condit fulfil commiss decis declar concentr compat common market longer stand undertak concern commit breach oblig commiss revok clearanc decis act pursuant articl merger regul parti subject fine period penalti payment provid articl merger regul view forego commiss decis present case condit full complianc undertak involv divestitur minor particip compani product line includ licens product line bring structur chang market appli cooper suppli requir vi vi parti parti commit aim ensur success divestitur hand part undertak refer truste appoint parti oblig aim implement structur chang market viii conclus reason set subject full complianc undertak parti assum propos concentr creat strengthen domin posit result effect competit significantli imped common market substanti part concentr declar compat common market function eea agreement pursuant articl articl merger regul articl eea agreement subject full complianc undertak set annex adopt decis articl notifi oper bombardi acquir mean articl merger regul sole control undertak daimlerchrysl rail system gmbh declar compat common market function eea agreement articl articl subject full complianc condit set paragraph subparagraph fourth subparagraph annex articl articl subject full complianc oblig set paragraph subparagraph subparagraph paragraph annex articl decis address bombardi rené lévesqu blvd west montréal québec canada brussel april commiss mario monti member commiss oj corrigendum oj oj corrigendum oj oj turnov calcul accord articl merger regul commiss notic calcul turnov oj part text edit ensur confidenti inform disclos part enclos squar bracket mark asterisk commiss decis ec octob oj point quot train grand vitess quot high speed train quot interc express quot recit decis ec octob recit decis septemb recit decis march oj recit commiss decis januari case iv bombardi dwa oj decis ec octob recit mari mass transit rail initi europ voluntari initi railwai suppli industri urban transport oper auspic european commiss aim improv competit urban rail system accomplish singl market mean standardis area work design harmonis financi engin life cycl cost contractu term condit gener ic train custom refer quot roll stock leas compani quot rosco kiep independ manufactur electr propuls system tram trolleybus compani sold daimler benz condit clearanc case abb daimler benz iv order ensur independ supplier electr compon remain present market alstom present germani subsidiari lhb bombardi parent compani german base dwa recit recit recit recit directli subsidiari singl bidder part consortia directli subsidiari singl bidder part compet consortia dwa subsidiari bombardi recit stadler adtranz joint control stadler pankow joint ventur recit recit tram lrv contract tender franc won alstom recit directli subsidiari singl bidder part consortia recit directli subsidiari singl bidder part compet consortia enlarg entiti product portfolio preced paragraph contract award contract award recit recit paragraph undertak set annex stadler adtranz joint control stadler pankow joint ventur recit paragraph undertak set annex paragraph undertak set annex bombardi elin major sharehold va tech elin ebg gmbh joint control elin recit paragraph undertak set annex recit detail recit fourth subparagraph paragraph undertak set annex recit long adtranz particip stadler pankow joint ventur gtw project regard consortium stadler prime contractor adtranz provid propuls stadler pankow common product site market share split stadler adtranz adtranz withdrawn stadler pankow joint ventur provid undertak submit gtw market share attribut stadler annex case comp bombardi adtranz undertak full english text undertak refer articl consult commiss web site http europa eu int comm competit index en html