annual report strasbourg april mr josé maría gil robl gil delgado presid european parliament rue wiertz bruxel mr presid accord articl treati establish european commun articl decis european parliament regul gener condit govern perform ombudsman duti present report year jacob söderman ombudsman european union gt tabl gt foreword european ombudsman annual report european ombudsman cover full year activ offic earli stage develop manag begin initi inquiri close case reason decis achiev posit result complain friendli solut successfulli propos special report present european parliament year inaugur main offic strasbourg small celebr open antenna brussel implement provis adopt ombudsman accord articl statut ombudsman network liaison offic set nation ombudsmen offic similar bodi member state inform citizen complain begin work european ombudsman septemb dedic consider part time inform european citizen complain ombudsman situat make complaint promot citizen knowledg engag regular contact cooper offic nation ombudsmen similar bodi european parliament inform offic european commiss represent member state bodi inform materi includ option standard form complaint made shown posit attitud cooper time provid inform citizen quickli effect open websit internet link european parliament give gener inform complain activ releas inform european press decis initi gener interest present ombudsman work number trade journal visit member state order make work ombudsman member state portug visit visit due place april arrang cooper european parliament inform offic lisbon offic portugues nation ombudsman statist show number complaint relat popul member state give rough pictur inform campaign receiv appendix signific differ leav belgium luxembourg finland explan smaller countri ireland inform fewer complaint receiv austria sweden big countri inform campaign success spain franc success germani itali gener level complaint made european ombudsman repres increas total complaint receiv increas number admiss complaint slower lot field inform expect european parliament committe petit problem promot knowledg petit differ limit mandat confin activ commun institut bodi focu reach peopl real reason complain european administr launch gener campaign year ombudsman inform campaign target citizen bodi deal european commun administr effort put possibl internet commun directli citizen furnish european inform offic organis knowledg complain ombudsman import focu region level member state decentralis structur inform activ distribut inform citizen petit european parliament initi transpar articl treati ombudsman possibl carri inquiri initi respons complaint limit mandat initi power promot transpar union begin inquiri subject number complaint suggest gener dissatisfact part citizen initi inquiri procedur european commiss deal complaint citizen infring commun law member state initi close present report chapter initi inquiri welcom parliament resolut fourteenth annual report commiss monitor applic commun law rapporteur astrid thor initi inquiri intend promot greater transpar concern procedur commun institut recruit staff inquiri launch novemb continu final initi inquiri public access document launch june decemb made draft recommend commun institut bodi adopt make easili public rule public access document draft recommend reason fulli explain annual report respons institut bodi concern draft recommend subject special report ombudsman european parliament present presid european parliament mr gil robl decemb special report statut european ombudsman propos dealt procedur similar annual report guarante consist effect respons ombudsman work utmost import committe european parliament respons relat ombudsman deal report ombudsman present parliament accord statut special expertis need relat report obtain opinion committe avoid confus help parliament clarif rule procedur ombudsman annual special report dealt result work year oper ombudsman offic posit result citizen year number case settl institut increas friendli solut reach achiev respect come year result consid satisfactori antenna brussel make easier carri time consum activ inspect document negoti friendli solut adopt public code conduct good administr behaviour sure rais qualiti institut administr practic enhanc relat european citizen offic manag decid rapidli admiss complaint advis complain compet bodi complaint address manag deal admiss case open initi investig small backlog deal admiss complaint develop object carri inquiri complaint inform citizen outcom year special circumst requir longer investig end case goal achiev partli initi phase involv administr work expect object staf staff underlin respons treati amsterdam european ombudsman hope adequ dealt budget procedur year resolut deal ombudsman annual report european parliament express defin term maladministr undertook oblig definit take account experi nation ombudsmen similar bodi member state includ chapter annual report cooper posit atmospher refer earlier annual report continu year hope european citizen benefit open human european administr jacob söderman complaint ombudsman import task european ombudsman deal maladministr activ commun institut bodi instanc maladministr attent ombudsman complaint made european citizen ombudsman conduct inquiri initi european citizen citizen live member state make complaint ombudsman busi associ bodi regist offic union complain complaint made ombudsman directli member european parliament complaint ombudsman dealt public complain request confidenti import ombudsman act open transpar manner european citizen follow understand work set good ombudsman dealt case complaint receiv directli individu citizen associ compani complaint transmit member european parliament case brought forward year ombudsman began initi inquiri note ombudsman annual report agreement committe ombudsman mutual transfer complaint petit case petit transfer ombudsman consent petition dealt complaint complaint transfer consent complain european parliament dealt petit addition case ombudsman advis complain petit european parliament annex statist legal basi ombudsman work ombudsman work carri accord articl treati establish european commun statut ombudsman articl statut ombudsman adopt implement provis view limit experi oper european ombudsman offic implement provis adopt indic provision basi septemb ombudsman inform committe petit committe rule procedur european parliament adopt implement provis provision indic basi formal durabl implement provis adopt octob ombudsman adopt formal durabl implement provis effect januari committe petit committe rule procedur european parliament inform adopt final provis text implement provis offici languag publish ombudsman websit http www euro ombudsman eu int text ombudsman offic notic give detail adopt public implement provis publish offici journal european commun implement provis deal intern oper ombudsman offic order form document understand citizen includ materi relat institut bodi contain statut ombudsman articl implement provis revis consolid rule govern public access document held european ombudsman previous rule access complaint relat document contain provision indic implement provis rule public access document contain separ decis ombudsman march parliament committe rule procedur propos amend rule rapporteur mr brian crowlei ombudsman attend meet committe septemb propos amend discuss report committe rule procedur amend rule parliament rule procedur unanim adopt committe meet novemb plenari session parliament rule procedur european parliament specif provis parliament deal annual report special report european ombudsman felt provis ombudsman make propos purpos foreseen rule rule procedur complaint dealt complaint ombudsman regist acknowledg letter acknowledg inform complain procedur complaint includ telephon number legal offic deal step examin complaint mandat ombudsman mandat european ombudsman mandat ombudsman establish articl treati empow receiv complaint citizen union natur legal person resid regist offic member state instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi except court justic court instanc act judici role complaint mandat complain person entitl make complaint commun institut bodi court justic court instanc act judici role concern instanc maladministr entitl complain turkish citizen resid unit state complain ombudsman handl european commiss turkei applic membership european union complaint individu citizen union resid member state union fell mandat ombudsman ombudsman suggest complain address respons commission matter directli inform address write ov moroccan citizen wrote ombudsman address morocco complain expel franc hear court withdraw resid permit prefect pari complaint individu citizen union resid member state unionarticlet fell mandat ombudsman ombudsman inform complain gener term condit case dealt european commiss human right nb complain physic present franc complaint nonetheless fallen ombudsman mandat commun institut bodi xd exampl complaint commun institut bodi uk citizen appli busi innov centr support project start busi complain ombudsman applic fail irregular dealt centr busi innov centr complaint made part european busi innov network consist busi centr commun commun support creation develop centr financi technic assist centr base public privat partnership bodi local author chamber commerc profession associ trade union financi institut univers research centr firm similar local interest commiss repres govern bodi ombudsman inform complain busi centr european busi innov network commun institut bodi complaint hma employe european molecular biologi laboratori complain ombudsman laboratori complain alleg mistreat subject harass suffer injuri lack safeti measur workplac laboratori set context european molecular biologi confer state member agreement set laboratori origin sign state austria denmark franc germani itali netherland sweden switzerland unit kingdom laboratori establish commun treati act adopt institut commun fund provid commun ombudsman inform complain laboratori commun institut bodi complaint mv uk pd offici european commiss complain ombudsman european school woluw brussel complaint concern decis class council disciplinari council school son complain alleg exist right defenc student parent criticis appeal system european school claim unfair class council hear appeal decis ombudsman decid complaint mandat commun institut bodi commiss gener respons repres board governor school larg part budget held respons matter intern manag complaint ov question compet ombudsman aros complaint council made british journalist mr toni bunyan behalf government organis statewatch novemb decemb complaint concern council respons request made mr bunyan access document relat activ pillar pillar inform term refer cooper field justic home affair titl vi treati european union determin complaint mandat admiss ground inquiri ombudsman forward council januari march council repli contest compet ombudsman deal complaint april ombudsman wrote council confirm origin decis complaint mandat renew request opinion substanc complaint june council compli ombudsman request council argument ombudsman lack compet deal complaint mr bunyan appear base proposit compet ombudsman extend action council pillar subject matter complaint concern action council pillar confirm earlier decis compet deal complaint ombudsman explain proposit wrong unnecessari posit proposit ombudsman recal complaint concern council respons request access document request made council decis public access council document dealt council purport applic decis council decis public access document made articl treati establish european commun court justic confirm judgment netherland council decis legal effect vi vi parti matter commun law decis interpret appli court instanc carvel guardian newspap council case involv access inter alia document relat action council pillar limit jurisdict court justic impos articl treati european union court instanc jurisdict deal aspect carvel case access council document action pillar pillar matter fact court accept jurisdict case correct interpret applic council decis public access document matter commun law matter dealt pillar document question concern action pillar mean maladministr resolut ombudsman annual report european parliament encourag ombudsman make full mandat confer treati deal maladministr activ commun institut bodi resolut refer context clear definit term maladministr treati establish european commun defin maladministr occas adopt parliament resolut ombudsman undertook attempt provid precis definit annual report ombudsman annual report explain term maladministr maladministr commun institut bodi fail act accord treati commun act bind fail observ rule principl law establish court justic court instanc european ombudsman account requir articl treati european union commun institut bodi respect fundament right thing amount maladministr includ administr irregular administr omiss abus power neglig unlaw procedur unfair malfunct incompet discrimin avoid delai lack refus inform list intend exhaust experi nation ombudsmen show attempt rigid definit constitut maladministr open end natur term thing distinguish role ombudsman judg limit count maladministr complaint decis polit administr natur regard inadmiss complaint polit work european parliament organ decis committe petit task ombudsman examin merit legisl act commun regul direct explan maladministr accept european parliament report ombudsman annual report refer approv meet european nation ombudsmen held septemb order supplement explan definit nation ombudsman similar bodi ask inform european ombudsman mean term maladministr member state repli receiv appear fundament notion defin maladministr occur public bodi fail act accord rule principl bind comment definit mandat ombudsmen expressli limit nation law establish offic legisl establish uk parliamentari commission administr investig complaint judici remedi natur ombudsman concern limit inquiri maladministr restrict part normal mean term maladministr unnecessari state expressli instanc offic danish ombudsman serv inspir creation offic european ombudsman restrict council europ definit ombudsman role includ review law administr act specif rule principl bind public bodi vari constitut legal administr framework countri concern rule principl static chang develop result work legisl court ombudsman administr help add remark rule principl bind context european commun rule law start point work institut bodi creat european union treati law court justic emphasis occas european commun commun law european ombudsman investig commun institut bodi act accord rule principl bind essenti task establish act lawfulli carri task ombudsman mind fact state annual report highest author mean interpret commun law court justic accord articl treati ombudsman conduct inquiri alleg fact subject legal proceed complaint european ombudsman rais issu nation law complaint concern exist contractu relationship complain commun institut contract govern provis relev nation law member state ombudsman deal contractu disput gener characterist contract nation law law establish ombudsman mandat expressli exclud contractu matter state annual report part mission european ombudsman reliev burden litig promot friendli solut make recommend avoid proceed court european ombudsman deal complaint maladministr aris contractu relationship seek determin breach contract parti question dealt effect court compet jurisdict possibl hear argument parti relev nation law evalu conflict evid disput issu fact matter good administr public author engag contractu disput privat parti provid ombudsman coher account legal basi action believ view contractu posit justifi rule principl good administr behaviour good bad administr mean practic establish concretis case case basi matter clarifi adopt law code conduct good administr behaviour member state import initi roi perri mep rapporteur report committe petit activ call code good administr behaviour establish commun institut bodi secretari gener european commiss inform ombudsman meet strasbourg octob commiss begun draft code appli offici initi warmli welcom publish code good administr behaviour inform offici servic provid citizen expect enhanc qualiti administr work relat citizen offic european ombudsman assist preparatori work secretari gener commiss provid inform exampl drawn experi member state comment principl appli initi stage draft ombudsman forward secretari gener copi danish law public administr finnish law administr procedur detail provis matter procedur includ give reason decis heard duti give inform remedi ombudsman forward secretari gener copi portugues code administr procedur recent french draft law relat administr public provis acknowledg receipt oblig transmit correspond compet servic deadlin repli present written oral observ decis statement principl unit kingdom citizen charter checklist good administr behaviour establish ombudsmen ireland hong kong relev materi limit maladministr conclud section report help clarifi limit maladministr relat exercis discretionari administr power polit work parliament carri administr task confer treati commun institut bodi legal author choos cours action commiss consid member state fail fulfil oblig ec treati procedur step bring matter court justic articl treati discretionari power commiss requir bring infring court justic ombudsman seek question discretionari administr decis provid institut bodi concern act limit legal author gener limit author establish jurisprud court justic requir administr author act consist good faith avoid discrimin compli principl proportion equal legitim expect respect human right fundament freedom articl treati specif exclud judici work court justic mandat ombudsman silent polit work european parliament classic ombudsman offic nordic countri set supervis public administr behalf parliament supervis polit activ parliament ombudsmen member state supervis polit work respect parliament appli constitut principl common member state european ombudsman establish carri inquiri polit activ european parliament question dealt practic earli ombudsman offic receiv number complaint alleg maladministr committe petit european parliament deal petit committe polit bodi deal petit polit task parliament complaint consid mandat ombudsman admiss complaint complaint mandat ombudsman meet criteria admiss ombudsman open inquiri criteria set statut ombudsman author object complaint identifi articl statut ombudsman interven case court question sound court rule articl complaint made year date fact base attent complain articl complaint preced administr approach institut bodi concern articl case complaint work relationship institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint exhaust lodg complaint articl exampl inadmiss complaint octob greek ph research intern commun law complain ombudsman european commiss complaint base fact exclud basi nation competit organis post univers research law school la sapienza univers rome instituto universitario di lingu modern milan complain commiss letter march june exclus competit infring articl ec treati complaint ombudsman commiss repli letter juli satisfactori step deal discrimin ombudsman decid complaint inadmiss complain contact commiss juli period year complain ombudsman time limit year establish articl consider exceed complaint ov compani complain ombudsman commiss relat tender procedur particip tender restrict procedur provis transport servic diplomat bag post complaint fact commiss invit compani submit tender deadlin septemb septemb septemb compani request inform clarif aspect tender document septemb septemb commiss repli unabl provid inform request complain held previou contract advantag background inform compani complain ombudsman ask clarifi situat complain contact commiss tender procedur indic made commiss awar dissatisfact conduct outcom tender procedur ombudsman decid complaint inadmiss administr approach made requir articl statut complain compani advis contact commiss set concern tender process dissatisfi commiss respons address complaint ombudsman ijh ground inquiri ombudsman deal complaint mandat meet criteria admiss articl ec treati conduct inquiri find ground case suffici ground ombudsman begin inquiri complaint technic admiss complaint dealt petit committe petit european parliament ombudsman consid ground open inquiri evid present complaint alleg letter answer ombudsman offic resolv matter inform telephon inquiri institut bodi concern respond send answer complain promptli ombudsman consid ground make inquiri case close reason exampl complaint provid ground inquiri juli mr complain ombudsman evid committe petit european parliament commiss offici fail satisfactorili explain justifi commiss view breach habitat direct eec case newburi bypass substanc complaint concern matter committe petit deal consider petit relat newburi bypass ombudsman consid ground inquir complaint mr inform ijh februari ms complain ombudsman action commiss relat bse mad cow diseas alleg commiss view british european research juli temporari committe inquiri establish european parliament articl ec treati examin bse affair committe consid respons commiss council uk govern committe report publish februari includ find critic commiss recommend futur view fact commiss respons relat bse examin temporari committe inquiri ombudsman consid ground inquir complaint ms inform complaint jma analysi complaint complaint regist begin activ ombudsman origin franc germani spain uk itali full analysi geograph origin complaint provid annex statist process examin complaint mandat meet criteria admiss provid ground open inquiri complet case complaint examin appear mandat ombudsman met criteria admiss provid ground inquiri inquiri begun case complaint led inquiri european commiss commiss main commun organ make decis direct impact citizen normal princip object citizen complaint complaint european parliament complaint council european union main type maladministr alleg lack transpar case discrimin case unsatisfactori procedur failur respect right defenc case unfair abus power case avoid delai neglig case failur ensur fulfil oblig failur european commiss carri role guardian treati vi vi member state case legal error case advic contact agenc transfer complaint mandat inadmiss ombudsman give advic complain agenc deal complaint ombudsman transfer complaint directli compet agenc consent complain provid ground complaint advic case involv issu commun law case complain advis complaint nation region ombudsman similar bodi addit consent complain complaint transfer directli nation ombudsman petit nation parliament complain advis petit european parliament addition complaint transfer european parliament consent complain dealt petit case advic contact european commiss figur includ case complaint commiss declar inadmiss administr approach made commiss case complain advis contact agenc decis inquiri ombudsman ombudsman decid start inquiri complaint step send complaint annex commun institut bodi concern opinion opinion receiv complain observ case institut bodi take step settl case satisfact complain opinion observ show case close settl institut case complain decid drop complaint file close reason complaint settl institut drop complain ombudsman continu inquiri inquiri reveal instanc maladministr complain institut bodi inform case close ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr seek friendli solut elimin satisfi complain meet held strasbourg octob ombudsman secretari gener commiss mr carlo trojan agre inform meet case provid pursu friendli solut case involv commiss friendli solut search friendli solut unsuccess ombudsman close file critic remark institut bodi concern make formal find maladministr draft recommend critic remark consid case instanc maladministr appear gener implic follow action ombudsman case follow action ombudsman case maladministr case gener implic ombudsman make decis draft recommend institut bodi concern accord articl statut ombudsman institut bodi send detail opinion month detail opinion consist accept ombudsman decis descript measur implement recommend commun institut bodi fail respond satisfactorili draft recommend articl ombudsman send report european parliament institut bodi concern report recommend possibl european ombudsman present special report parliament inestim work nation ombudsmen long struggl obtain compar possibl special report present frequent relat import matter parliament action assist ombudsman accord statut ombudsman ombudsman special report made decemb initi inquiri public access document held commun institut bodi chapter ombudsman began inquiri relat complaint initi case settl institut bodi case drop complain case ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr critic remark address institut case friendli solut reach case draft recommend institut bodi concern made detail appendix statist decis inquiri case maladministr found european parliamenti decis activ statu articl staff regul decis complaint dg kt european parliamenti complaint februari mr complain ombudsman decis european parliament place activ statu articl staff regul complain ombudsman februari subject complaint dg kt deem inadmiss intern administr remedi exhaust articl statut ombudsman earli januari european parliament inform mr decis place activ statu decis date decemb effect decemb mr wrote secretari gener contest fact decis commun week retroact effect point sick leav end februari receiv repli secretari gener complain unsatisfi renew complaint ombudsman inquiri parliament comment complaint forward european parliament summari parliament comment mr offici volunt juli activ statu learn propos reduc post mean articl staff regul subsequ chang intent servic administr reason decis transfer activ statu highli favour decis place mr activ statu end year budgetari author decid remov maximum post programm retroact decis appoint author consult joint committe report committe decid activ statu consult complet novemb januari mr ask date transfer activ statu chang march enjoi full period sick leav grant doctor octob februari parliament learn word establish plan allow outstand unus articl procedur carri personnel servic propos date entri forc decis place mr activ statu chang februari financi control view factor involv warrant chang initi decis comment european parliament forward mr invit make observ wish observ receiv decis articl staff regul appoint author draw list offici assign activ statu offici occupi post affect reduct number post express assign activ statu automat enter list offici list assign activ statu decis appoint author basi inform ombudsman appear mr wish assign activ statu european parliament believ decis highli favour evid present ombudsman breach staff regul european parliament deal case appear parliament respond mr request postpon entri forc decis transfer activ statu financi control view factor involv warrant chang initi decis evid present ombudsman question exercis discret financi control view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case handl complaint decis complaint hma european parliament complaint februari lodg complaint manag committe kindergarten run european parliament period month son bitten time children kindergarten numer contact director kindergarten manag committe attempt solv problem complain manag committe fact director kindergarten protect son bitten view manag committe deal properli complaint complain made alleg manag committe neglig protect children danger abus power form intimid threat claim told circumst futur babi admit kindergarten inequ discrimin children bite treat children bitten alleg told free withdraw son kindergarten satisfi situat manag committe refus disclos name children bitten son explain concret action kindergarten regard children bite prevent incid kind happen accord articl statut complaint classifi confidenti request complain inquiri parliament comment complaint forward european parliament summari parliament comment case neglig complaint dealt relev author detail appear file member manag committe wit similar incid kindergarten handl alleg intimid threat unfound obstacl admit futur babi kindergarten alleg abus power relat partli fact manag committe refus appli transfer son commiss kindergarten strict rule govern transfer applic situat demand ground applic high list prioriti entranc kindergarten place parliament facil abus power director kindergarten gave manag committe detail explan regard event polici staff deal incid basi explan manag committe found evid discrimin parliament forc withdraw son eastman kindergarten failur disclos child bitten son justifi polici order avoid violent scene parent kindergarten neg concern matter dealt kindergarten parent child bitten son parliament state inform procedur decis manag committe director kindergarten invit discuss matter director kindergarten complain observ observ complaint examin manag committe neglig substanc outcom investig oppos fact forbidden direct contact parent children bit son claim director inform intent speak parent concret action solv problem threat maintain posit regard threat admit futur babi kindergarten circumst decis alleg manag committe neglig appear committe examin complaint question director kindergarten matter carri investig appear accord principl good administr alleg abus power parliament opinion state obstacl admit futur child complain kindergarten demand transfer complain child commiss kindergarten inquir justif refus demand time child kindergarten alleg discrimin appear pedagogi kindergarten appli children appear discrimin evid effect complain forc withdraw child kindergarten refus director support manag committe disclos name children bitten son refus base pedagog consider director kindergarten awar parent oppos decis prefer channel parent anger parent children decis pedagog natur infring principl good administr appear file complain inform children bit punish pedagogi kindergarten director talk parent children view solv problem complain invit discuss matter director decis disclos concret action appear relat work ethic decis ethic natur infring principl good administr basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr manag committe kindergarten european parliament ombudsman close case european parliament european commiss court auditor committe region econom social committe actio populari complaint ag limit recruit competit decis complaint sktol fin bb european commiss european parliament court auditor committe region econom social committe complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman behalf feder finnish translat offic suomen käännöstoimistojen liitto ag limit notic competit publish commun institut bodi notic competit eur la eur la complaint translat profess opinion current practic commun institut discrimin peopl basi ag contrari principl equal treatment possibl unit nation charter translat claim disconcert practic exist european union put emphasi free competit citizen europ mr ask ombudsman investig legal ag limit step deal matter inquiri complaint forward institut bodi concern commiss comment commiss comment began refer opinion background note ombudsman octob commiss state applic ag limit competit option provid staff regul flexibl appli depend circumst specif object competit commiss explain applic ag limit tool manag high number potenti applic final commiss note ag limit prevent women appli result competit member state shown ag import factor affect mobil parliament comment parliament state staff regul ag limit set candid open competit organis commun institut appoint author decid basi judgment sound administr principl ag limit justifi parliament stress institut appli ag limit recruit polici institut reason applic ag limit mainten career structur difficulti settl multicultur multilinguist environ home increas ag administr financi problem increas ag limit abolish recruit cumbersom expens concomit increas number post fill court auditor comment court auditor commiss comment transmit march committe region econom social committe committe region econom social committe gave common opinion associ commiss comment transmit march decis ag limit recruit polici commun institut gener rule commun institut appli ag limit admiss candid competit possibl appear annex iii staff regul articl annex iii state notic open competit ag limit extens ag limit case offici servant commun complet year servic appear ag limit rais candid perform compulsori militari servic depend child compulsori school ag suffer sever mental physic handicap candid physic handicap institut ag limit import instrument assur career civil servic respect statutori oblig institut follow principl recruit personnel basic grade principl neg effect motiv good manag commiss research show higher ag limit clearer geograph imbal commiss claim experi shown women particip open competit european ombudsman initi inquiri ag limit recruit commun institut european ombudsman receiv seri complaint alleg instanc maladministr ag limit recruit personnel commun institut inquiri ombudsman complaint complaint ag limit commun institut led ombudsman conclud conduct gener examin ag limit basi complaint ombudsman receiv appear current practic ag limit institut caus consider dissatisfact european citizen citizen member state articl ec treati european ombudsman empow conduct inquiri initi relat maladministr activ commun institut bodi virtu provis ombudsman initi initi inquiri ag limit recruit offici servant european commun juli conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint complaint ag limit appear justifi open gener inquiri ag limit juli ombudsman initi initi inquiri ag limit recruit commun institut issu rais specif complaint account initi inquiri ombudsman close case council european union recruit exclus competit decis complaint gd fr kh council complaint mr complain ombudsman juli exclus gener competit organis council pass written test invit letter post part oral examin held pari june letter post address marseil mr council mr left marseil brussel ask father forward mail occas telephon call made parent june mr heard letter council arriv receipt letter june mr learn invit oral test contact council told select board finish work june letter june mr ask chairman board organis supplementari oral examin reason put forward request ag limit appli candid mr opportun particip competit organis commun institut june chairman board inform mr write select board termin work exclud competit inquiri council comment complaint forward council comment council made point mr contact gener secretariat council earli june board fit oral examin moment reserv list establish principl equal opportun candid prevent council reopen competit procedur organis oral test special mr complain observ observ council comment mr maintain initi complaint decis ombudsman remark council comment respond favour complain request present due time request reach council closur competit procedur accept impli reopen procedur view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case remark ombudsman ombudsman remark larg number complaint receiv ag limit recruit personnel institut decid conduct initi inquiri practic council european union european commiss discrimin open competit decis complaint alc es vk european commiss council european union complaint august mr spain complain ombudsman alleg instanc maladministr commiss council european union aspect recruit system complain put forward claim view gap state commiss booklet publish spanish la carrera en la comisión de la comunidad europea institut real polici recruit offici principl discrimin basi nation breach come forc council regul ec march introduc special temporari measur contradict opinion staff regul council commiss discrimin basi ag appli ag limit recruit offici request ag limit elimin commun open competit respect principl discrimin basi nation ensur inquiri complaint forward commiss council commiss comment previou request ombudsman commiss forward comment gener question applic ag limit point institut appli ag limit recruit offici commun basi provis staff regul annex iii articl ag limit object critic member european parliament commiss undertaken assess implic abolish ag limit commiss view main reason support ag limit assur condit balanc manag human resourc promot geograph balanc institut civil servant support women applic specif mr complaint commiss booklet refer complain legal design inform purpos respect alleg infring principl discrimin basi nation council regul ec introduc special temporari measur aim promot recruit offici member state join union januari commiss stress complain previous address petit subject matter european parliament committe petit examin petit decid close file view commiss repli council comment firstli council underlin implement recruit polici institut account post budgetari restrict council regul ec introduc special temporari measur order promot recruit offici member state breach principl discrimin basi nation complain observ mr claim possibl appli ag limit foreseen articl annex iii staff regul contrari european convent human right spanish constitut argument career prospect newli appoint offici older ag limit irrelev consid promot career prioriti final believ balanc represent nation member state achiev limit access open competit basi nation promot equal access competit union citizen decis appear inquiri made type brochur present content show aim creat legal framework defin access union civil servic provid gener inform open competit institut ombudsman conclud potenti diverg exist situat gener aim brochur consid instanc maladministr part commiss discrimin basi nation complain address petit european parliament matter dealt committe petit petit ombudsman consid ground pursu inquiri matter question ag limit subject initi inquiri ombudsman launch juli ombudsman pursu inquiri complaint complain inform outcom initi inquiri background european ombudsman close case recruit assess work experi failur repli decis complaint sw bb european commiss council european union complaint octob ms complain ombudsman assess work experi competit eur la organis commiss council failur repli ms request transmit copi correct examin script competit council la ms exclud open competit eur la ground lack requir minimum work experi year ms request select board review decis maintain origin decis ms wrote select board claim board assess work experi ms point awar studi period parallel work activ recognis studi merit certif merit certif state final date subject final ms calcul studi merit certif requir year work experi ms ask review select board decis januari board repli review decis board refer point notic vi xi applic form publish offici journal european commun august state except rule allow complaint ombudsman ms claim commiss evalu criteria assess work experi stress order treat applic equal select board provid inform assess method februari ms letter council request copi correct english examin script relat competit council la complaint ombudsman claim receiv repli letter inquiri complaint forward commiss council commiss comment summari commiss made point comment notic competit candid year profession experi obtain univers degre notic competit stipul duli attest period specialist refresh train cours count profession experi case train cours level equival requir admiss competit specialist refresh train cours train cours account calcul profession experi order count experi train fulltim rule appli profession experi word train take place employ count addit period profession experi point xi notic competit photocopi show candid satisfi condit attach applic ms profession experi calcul basi origin applic document altogeth profession experi amount year month text notic competit legal bind select board respect council comment summari council made point comment januari ms inform admit oral competit neg result part written test februari ms request copi correct script written test presid select board gave detail repli request explain procedur refus submit correct script octob ms inform ombudsman council refus transmit correct script dai wrote mr brunmayr deputi director gener request repli octob copi letter februari complain correct script cover secreci select board proceed provid articl annex iii staff regul high number candid particip make difficult accept request copi correct script complain observ observ ms made summari point assess work experi consid notic competit mention train place employ count addit period profession experi notic case ms claim studi merit certif univers stockholm origin applic open competit eur la request review decis exclud mention competit commiss calcul work experi studi merit certif enclos request review ms claim take account studi merit fulfil requir year work experi council letter februari ms state receiv copi letter octob alleg council letter place maintain request copi correct script decis assess work experi case law court justic select board wide discretionari power exercis power select board respect legal framework activ laid notic competit letter decemb comment ombudsman commiss inform ms select board method assess work experi comment complain work experi calcul base ombudsman inquiri complaint appear select board act accord notic failur repli correspond council provid ombudsman copi letter date februari letter council repli rule send copi correct examin script ombudsman found evid support complain alleg council abovement letter copi correct examin script present state commun law legal basi council oblig disclos copi correct examin script applic request ombudsman receiv number complaint field recruit lack transpar procedur thing complain complain refus copi correct examin script request articl treati establish european commun ombudsman empow conduct inquiri initi relat instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi virtu provis initi inquiri open novemb secreci form part commiss recruit procedur part initi ombudsman investig commiss envisag take measur order disclosur copi correct examin script applic concern view find appear maladministr commiss council ombudsman close case remark view consider number complaint ombudsman receiv lack transpar procedur recruit competit organis commun institut open inquiri initi matter novemb european commiss select traine access blue book decis complaint vk european commiss complaint septemb complain european ombudsman traineeship commiss award basi merit connect high rank person support alleg refer unsuccess applic traineeship commiss claim imposs understand enter call blue book commiss time time qualifi accord articl statut complaint classifi confidenti request complain inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss state comment met requir admiss regul traineeship due high number applic receiv year carri preselect test basi actual studi result candid studi undertaken european integr field commun law commiss state ground excel profil curriculum vita enter blue book fail meet requir commiss emphasis principl geograph balanc amount applic year need account complain observ commiss comment complain maintain complaint complain ad recommend high rank person help enter supplementari list blue book time appli inquiri ombudsman request inform commiss relat procedur registr blue book addit ombudsman ask copi applic form candid nation order assess qualif profil commiss submit addit comment copi applic form candid nation commiss point supplementari list assess applic serv correct purpos technic print error decis ombudsman observ criteria appli select traine commun commiss unfound recal administr author enjoi margin appreci determin concret applic fulfil criteria set vacanc ombudsman examin applic candid nation commiss disregard criteria laid contend supplementari list blue book recommend high rank person lack indic ident person person person influenc allegedli exert ground inquiri claim ombudsman close case refus accept eur certif cöte ivoir decis complaint fs ijh european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman octob behalf compani call nv complaint state nv purchas quantiti long grain rice côte ivoir uk trade agent import commun april rice origin cöte ivoir lomé convent countri subject reduc import duti nv submit eur certif belgian custom author proof rice origin custom author suspect rice côte ivoir origin refus accept certif obtain releas rice nv provid custom author guarante addit custom duti payabl rice origin cöte ivoir belgian custom author sampl rice test initi procedur subsequ verif eur certif march nv inform côte ivoir govern confirm valid eur certif nv request releas guarante letter juli belgian custom author inform nv commun anti fraud section refus releas guarante want investig complaint ombudsman mr claim verif procedur complet guarante nv releas claim doubt issu eur certif côte ivoir matter commun author cöte ivoir govern inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss januari comment commiss refer reason belgian custom author commiss servic suspect rice origin côte ivoir summari comment made point repli côte ivoir confirm authent certif origin good previou experi shown verif cöte ivoir author reli question verifi exist certif origin good accord articl protocol lomé convent commiss request côte ivoir author make enquiri rice offer send commun mission assist request made june repeat septemb subsequ correspond bring answer question rais commiss servic brought matter ec acp custom cooper committe evid show nv involv fraud concern remain valid eur certif dialogu enter côte ivoir author request suppli inform comment conclud express hope dialogu lead settlement matter futur complain observ commiss comment forward mr april observ contest evid valid eur certif claim reason doubt justifi subsequ verif precautionari measur lomé convent observ rais issu alleg delai belgian custom author forward eur certif côte ivoir author verif inquiri march european ombudsman wrote commiss enquir dialogu côte ivoir author reach conclus step commiss propos resolv matter repli commiss gave detail attempt resolv issu refer request cooper acp ec custom cooper committe administr oper mission novemb repli disagr commun deleg includ repres commiss belgian custom author côte ivoir author relev fact repli conclud commiss inform belgian author increas deposit paid nv differ preferenti import rate preferenti rate increas belgian author draw conclus matter belgian govern unabl notifi import nv custom debt absenc irrefut proof rice origin côte ivoir commiss emphasis exercis power scrupul protect financi interest union effect resourc loss aspect applic agreement acp countri regret contrari hope engend meet april level cooper shown côte ivoir author inadequ circumst show decis preliminari remark implement commun custom law carri relev administr procedur respons nation custom author implement commun law nation custom author commun institut bodi activ subject inquiri european ombudsman ombudsman compet deal complaint relat administr activ belgian custom author ombudsman inquir alleg made complain observ commiss comment undu delai belgian custom author forward eur certif côte ivoir author verif examin maladministr activ european commiss ombudsman determin substant disput origin rice question determin court compet jurisdict possibl hear testimoni evalu conflict scientif evid role commiss commiss repli appear compet relat case deriv sourc particip custom cooper committe establish articl protocol lomé convent deal disput articl protocol respons execut commun budget ensur proper account custom duti commun resourc payabl commiss côte ivoir author evid ombudsman commiss request côte ivoir author make inquiri accord articl protocol convent request particip administr cooper mission côte ivoir brought matter success meet acp ec custom cooper committe commiss evid failur activ resolv matter result lack cooper côte ivoir author commiss appear fulli possibl action provis lomé convent relat disput commiss belgian custom author comment commiss contradict alleg commiss servic refus releas guarante paid nv basi limit evid appear practic commiss servic plai decis role fulfil respons execut commun budget commiss oblig repeatedli emphasis report court auditor protect financi interest commun commiss repli case appear doubt origin rice base evid constitut reason doubt sens articl protocol lomé convent circumst lack progress resolv disput result commiss continu doubt rice côte ivoir origin constitut maladministr form avoid delai view find appear maladministr ombudsman note complain possibl submit disput origin rice compet judici author proceed nation custom author ombudsman close case recruit oral select procedur decis complaint tmf vk european commiss complaint complaint ombudsman novemb mr alleg impress pass oral select procedur organis dg xii commiss view behaviour select board member select board question futur work congratul shook hand interview alleg commiss disclos name member select board inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss februari comment commiss state question secretari select board indic candid success congratul commiss emphasis member select board brief behav give indic reaction relat candid perform supervis secretari select board observ commiss comment mr maintain complaint decis complain ask question relat post actual work involv content question disput commiss natur futur employ question order assess candid candid react work situat content question constitut indic candid chosen post mr claim congratul member select board factual issu remain disput parti handshak end interview understood gestur polit congratul present state commun law refus disclos name member select board unlaw view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case freedom movement handl complaint lodg commiss decis complaint pl uk pd european commiss complaint novemb mr complain ombudsman behalf brother repres nation council civil liberti liberti complaint alleg maladministr handl complaint lodg european commiss background complaint novemb welsh brother travel train belgium wale plai footbal match brother train belgium luxembourg border belgian polic ident record photograph inform transmit uk nation crimin intellig servic nci record comput list novemb record inform pass belgian polic occas footbal match brother attend brother detain polic station courtrai subject ident check brussel detain polic station brussel hour search photograph deport reason record nci list offici report belgian ministri interior nci state arrest novemb brussel influenc alcohol disturb public order ident check possess ident paper brother nation european parliamentari repres sought obtain nation remedi unsuccess complaint european commiss juli brother repres liberti complain european commiss commiss regist complaint unit kingdom belgium liberti request commiss commun complaint member state concern obtain undertak member state compli requir commun law liberti request remov record relat brother commiss request obtain assur brother free move european union subject restrict justifi ec treati state fail adopt measur satisfactorili commiss request institut infring proceed articl ec treati octob commiss director gener xv respond letter state belgium unit kingdom bound give activ consider brother request remov blacklist written member state effect delet client name blacklist give reason keep list letter octob dg xv commiss report repli receiv unit kingdom substanc uk author subject entri nic record entri made relat detail remain record absenc mention client nci record lead conclud present restrict envisag unit kingdom author free movement consequ consid infring commun law case point intent propos commiss complaint file respons receiv belgian author commiss continu press repli liberti respond letter octob present issu consid unresolv brother told precis list name appear brother inform state organis provid list list question legal name origin list dealt satisfactorili complaint european ombudsman liberti alleg maladministr commiss handl complaint unit kingdom reason delai month respond substant complaint failur requir unit kingdom deal issu rais complaint lodg juli failur institut proceed articl ec treati liberti alleg maladministr commiss handl complaint belgium reason failur commiss obtain belgian author respons complaint lodg juli failur commiss institut proceed articl ec treati absenc respons whatsoev belgian author month complaint lodg commiss inquiri ec treati empow european ombudsman enquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi statut european ombudsman specif action author person subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman inquiri complaint direct examin maladministr activ european commiss commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point comment decid open infring proceed unit kingdom commiss exercis discret fulli recognis court justic court consist held clear scheme articl ec treati commiss oblig commenc proceed articl discretionari power preclud individu requir adopt posit bring action annul refus action proceed complain conform principl good administr behaviour complaint regist repli complain letter forward member state normal time deal complaint alleg infring commiss written member state inform clarif regard issu time delai hand member state concern case unit kingdom letter issu octob remind march repli unit kingdom author receiv repli examin commiss servic complain inform legal repres octob case belgium acknowledg receiv perman repres decemb remind issu februari june belgian author wrote commiss octob confirm request clarif transmit author reaction author complaint belgium examin time period sixteen month respect case commiss complain inform legal repres articl procedur complain possess specif procedur guarante sector competit issu anti dump case time deal matter relev recal complex legal technic consider involv complain observ observ mr made summari point commiss discret issu formal proceed articl send initi letter member state normal time disput commiss comment fail address core complaint maladministr issu octob commiss express view appli court justic rule bouchereau adoui cornuail belgium unit kingdom bound give activ consider brother request remov quot blacklist quot fact commiss accept action member state concern highli pertin assess adequaci subsequ handl matter commiss commiss compli good administr practic propos close file relat unit kingdom repli unit kingdom deal concern rais complaint specif name brother commun countri record propos specif action relat belgium repli whatsoev receiv member state requir good administr requir commiss pursu effect undisput fact brother fundament right ec law respect complain request ombudsman find respons commiss insuffici good administr requir effect follow action commiss inquiri appear commiss inform ombudsman situat complaint ombudsman ask commiss inform repli belgian author complaint commiss repli state commiss receiv short formal respons date june perman repres belgium substanc belgian author gave assur respect right complain free movement territori commiss examin respons commun term complain legal repres letter juli letter view posit put forward belgian author commiss servic propos group examin alleg infring commun law meet case file meet servic propos file case place held octob decis confirm commiss weekli meet octob letter decemb confirm decis file case commun mr repres complain decis alleg failur obtain repli belgian author matter good administr practic commiss persist attempt obtain repli member state administr stage infring procedur articl accord case law court justic member state facilit achiev commiss task guardian treati articl treati member state requir cooper bona fide inquiri undertaken commiss articl suppli commiss inform request purpos refus member state assist commiss investig constitut failur fulfil duti incumb member state articl facilit achiev commiss task case commiss bring matter court justic appear commiss final obtain repli belgian author june remind letter contact ombudsman found evid maladministr relat aspect case delai respond substant complaint unit kingdom alleg delai month respond substant complaint unit kingdom liberti state contest send initi letter member state normal time complaint concern period octob date commiss remind receiv repli letter octob commiss inform complain complaint file appear ombudsman inquiri commiss persist attempt obtain repli unit kingdom matter good administr practic commiss commun decis close file complain promptli ombudsman found evid support alleg undu delai respond substant complaint unit kingdom failur requir unit kingdom deal issu rais complaint alleg commiss fail requir unit kingdom deal issu rais complaint lodg juli unit kingdom author detail brother remain nci record commiss consid infring commun law unit kingdom appear commiss conclud infring present intend pursu issu infring past court justic purpos prelitig procedur provid articl give member state opportun remedi posit matter brought court ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr commiss relat alleg failur request repli issu present complaint failur open infring proceed articl ec treati alleg commiss fail institut formal proceed unit kingdom belgium articl ec treati commiss issu reason opinion consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati articl treati lai procedur criteria commiss period preced issu reason opinion member state jurisprud court justic limit guidanc commiss decid procedur criteria adopt order discharg respons articl process lead issu reason opinion case law court justic role guardian treati commiss compet decid bring proceed member state failur fulfil oblig ombudsman found instanc maladministr commiss conclud inquiri undertaken matter view find take account commiss obtain unit kingdom belgium assur right complain free movement respect appear maladministr ombudsman close case remark inquiri complaint complaint commiss led ombudsman conclud gener examin commiss administr procedur deal complaint citizen member state failur fulfil oblig commun law april ombudsman initi initi inquiri possibl improv qualiti relev administr procedur commiss recruit temporari agent decis complaint vkcg pd uk european commiss complaint mr respond notic invit applic post temporari agent grade consum polici servic commiss august select board inform invit interview complaint ombudsman novemb mr alleg success applic advanc rais number question ask applic interview reason invit interview mr alleg advertis nation press fals mislead advertis job vacanc fact exist question procedur compli equal opportun polici expenditur incur process justifi reason inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss commiss comment includ point commiss temporari staff recruit select procedur announc mean advertis nation press member state temporari post advertis nation press member state applic receiv respons advertis submit select board consist senior offici specialist field cover procedur post question select board compris person establish order examin applic select judg suit post interview select board receiv applic applic select interview basi criteria establish select board qualiti durat applic profession experi invit interview reserv list commiss reject alleg person appoint post determin advanc state select board recognis complain qualiti judg applic qualifi post question equal opportun polici commiss point peopl reserv list women ad select board base decis sole rel merit applic complain observ observ mr rais number question relat procedur reason creation temporari post consum polici servic select procedur ident success applic mr suggest ombudsman interview staff member commiss inquiri commiss comment complain observ appear number aspect complaint remain unansw juli complain observ forward commiss complementari comment european ombudsman ask commiss forward publish notic vacanc applic shortlist applic report select board complementari comment commiss state report select board includ list applic invit interview list applic judg suit post subsequ director gener consum polici examin file shortlist applic select person consid suit post question commiss state expect success applic offer post question greater person commiss complain complementari observ commiss complementari comment forward mr observ maintain origin complaint decis articl condit employ servant european commun temporari staff engag fill post budgetari author classifi temporari engag temporari agent differ recruit offici staff regul specif provis govern recruit procedur temporari agent basi ombudsman inquiri appear evid commiss fail act accord normal procedur recruit temporari agent case basi inform ombudsman appear evid support alleg ident success applic advanc circumst ombudsman consid insuffici ground pursu inquiri aspect complaint view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case termin contract decis complaint dea ef en european commiss complaint complaint european ombudsman novemb mr state emploi contract compani bmb programm ordin eu fund rural develop programm nigeria middl belt programm bmb abruptli termin mr contract novemb subsequ agre pai gbp settlement claim wrong dismiss mr complaint element alleg commiss directli respons termin contract deleg nigeria action offici base brussel alleg lost opportun employ compani mm eu fund programm nigeria commiss deleg nigeria inform advis nomin approv express view blacklist work eu fund project formal advis full reason opportun contest inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss deni termin mr contract bmb result direct intervent offici claim contact offici middl belt programm focus manag monitor report issu highlight critic independ review programm commiss bmb decid respons replac mr programm coordin alleg lost opportun employ commiss deleg nigeria inform advis nomin approv commiss state understand compani concern made assess situat conclus mr candidatur retain final commiss state appreci mr servic exist posit establish deleg nigeria receiv copi complain observ observ commiss comment mr state person inform member bmb manag commiss request dismiss middl belt programm state directli inform mm consortium partner inform commiss support candidatur final state remain unconvinc commiss denial blacklist decis termin middl belt programm contract apprais programm support commun fund normal activ commiss undertak appear probabl critic apprais commiss offici manag procur middl belt programm led termin complain contract appear evid direct intervent commiss offici secur termin contract payment made complain employ settlement claim wrong dismiss impli intervent unnecessari examin circumst direct intervent commiss offici secur termin contract constitut maladministr alleg loss employ opportun complain claim offer employ withdrawn commiss deleg nigeria inform advis support candidatur commiss view compani concern made assess situat complain claim base potenti employ told commiss deleg consortium partner inform lack factual specif prob support alleg maladministr unnecessari examin circumst inform advic candidatur support amount maladministr alleg blacklist complain claim blacklist commiss employ commun fund project formal advis full reason opportun contest commiss disput claim commiss deni blacklist complain appear evid support alleg blacklist view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case interpret commiss regul decis complaint pd european commiss complaint januari mr italian lawyer complain behalf compani alleg knowledg commiss italian author discrimin autumn alleg discrimin concern applic import licenc banana mr compani submitt applic deadlin septemb applic submit septemb approv applic lodg refus inquiri commssion comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state prime respons run import licenc regim li author member state inform commiss compani present applic import licenc deadlin concret case virtu regul eec expir septemb complain observ observ complain state commiss address substanc complaint compani grant import licenc proper read regul eec applic lodg septemb deadlin complain state obviou compani deadlin consid subsequ chang relev provis regul eec time disput fact regul provid applic import licenc lodg week month quarter regul amend regul ec provid applic lodg dai month quarter preced respect licens issu complain week septemb equal dai septemb week expir septemb applic lodg septemb time inquiri ombudsman decid commiss comment complain observ commiss state regul ec modifi time limit lodg applic clarifi legal situat commiss observ inform provid complain italian author applic lodg dai time thirdli italian author commun commiss case similar case applic lodg septemb time observ supplementari comment mr maintain complaint commiss wrong claim regul ec modifi time limit lodg applic decis firstli european ombudsman state sole compet instanc maladministr activ institut bodi commun activ nation author fall remit jurisdict european ombudsman compet alleg italian author issu complaint commiss correctli interpret provis lai time limit lodg applic regulatori background order ensur free movement banana commun council adopt common organis market banana council regul eec februari regul establish basic distinct banana produc commun ii acp countri iii countri categori banana regul creat system tariff quota threshold banana import free custom duti payment modest duti threshold higher duti appli order make system oper import banana commun monitor regim import licens commiss regul eec laid detail rule applic arrang import banana commun banana origin acp state import threshold articl regul eec provid moment fact complaint import licenc applic lodg compet author member state week month quarter complain week refer calendar week commiss week mean dai month support view complain refer subsequ word provis question introduc regul ec articl word import licenc applic lodg compet author member state dai month quarter preced respect licenc issu mr word show previous week meant calendar week commiss word clarifi week mean dai month assess disput complain commiss european ombudsman examin point view support recit regul ec relev recit read detail rule import licenc tradit acp banana reason connect manag period lodg licens applic adjust word adjust suggest time limit substanc modifi languag version point direct instanc german french italian spanish danish version adjust translat angepat adapt adattar adaptar tilpass examin gave support complain view word articl time limit lodg applic question calendar week interpret obviou place mr view week calendar week lead expiri time limit dai month dai fell saturdai sundai impli compani lodg applic earlier benefit dai month reason put forward shorten time limit reason put forward adopt interpret make actual time limit vari month month clear interpret ensur uniform applic commun commiss view week meant dai month found recal court justic highest author question commun law basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman decid close case right free movement person pre retir pension decis complaint mb es kh european commiss complaint decemb mr complain ombudsman failur commiss act alleg infring danish efterløn rule type pre retir benefit commun law brought matter attent dg commiss octob complain ombudsman commiss dealt complaint inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment made point interven danish author alleg discrimin irrespect nation holder benefit legal situat commun law regul receiv social benefit person resid member state council regul eec applic pre retir benefit danish efterløn made clear court justic propos submit commiss council extend scope regul eec adopt propos bring pre retir benefit scope regul submit council januari commiss measur ensur free movement person receipt pre retir benefit decis ec treati empow european ombudsman enquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi statut european ombudsman specif action author person subject complaint ombudsman ombudsman inquiri matter rais complaint direct examin maladministr activ commiss deal complaint treatment complaint letter complain wrote commiss duli answer month recept commiss repli refer regul social secur regul eec regul ensur categori worker appli includ retir peopl resid member state affect pension right repli explicitli state regul cover pre retir benefit refer applic case law court justic complain inform recent propos commiss made council order includ benefit efterløn materi scope regul appear commiss act full conform procedur requir expect deal complaint substant issu complaint complain disput commiss conclus ground treati acknowledg freedom resid union valid peopl benefit efterløn affect benefit consid discriminatori group person benefit efterløn exclud free movement freedom movement assur articl treati articl state council adopt measur field social secur provid freedom movement measur part adopt regul eec establish case law person pre retir exclud materi scope regul measur guarante free movement person pre retir benefit affect social benefit remain conclus commiss freedom movement peopl benefit efterløn scheme assur treati incorrect disput danish state differenti danish danish nation circumst efterløn aris concern conclus drawn commiss discriminatori element danish act incorrect conclus substant issu complaint dealt commiss answer manner answer commiss incorrect submit propos council enlarg materi scope regul commiss show preoccup problem complaint brought forward view ombudsman establish instanc maladministr commiss dealt complaint close case remark articl statut ombudsman advis person lodg complaint address author initi legal proceed involv expens risk proceed unsuccess ombudsman give advic initi legal proceed matter sole judgement complain subject take account complain explicit request inform author deal claim ombudsman made remark complaint contain element brought nation court argu direct effect treati articl free movement make exclus pre retir pension scope regul irrelev support argument found recent decis court justic legal proceed brought nation court result refer articl ec treati court justic highest author commun law recruit level qualif requir part competit decis complaint pd european commiss complaint mr complain januari ombudsman notic competit recruit offici european commun notic graduat finnish univers complet higher univers degre fil kand complain state graduat member state sweden uk possess qualif level finnish lower level degre hum kand complain assum notic competit contain error complain result larg number finn miss opportun appli job inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment made point agre harmonis academ equival univers degre member state commiss determin natur diploma elig admiss competit base inform provid nation author commiss seek ensur approach similar treatment univers graduat whichev member state graduat commiss approach finnish univers degre requir higher univers degre admiss competit commiss conclud comment state light recent develop field higher educ commiss intend review approach diploma give access competit ensur common approach institut complain observ observ mr state commiss comment meant higher level qualif requir finn applic believ wrong request ombudsman continu investig question inquiri commiss comment complain observ appear number aspect complaint remain unansw ombudsman ask commiss inform criteria establish elig requir finnish swedish british candid ombudsman ask detail content commiss review approach diploma give access competit summari repli commiss evalu univers degre commiss base specif inform provid nation ministri educ annual updat report work parti council europ inform compil network nation academ recognit inform centr naric case finland sweden commiss made decis basi inform provid respect nation ministri educ confirm naric decis elig admiss univers degre obtain unit kingdom made time access case final univers degre requir commiss conclud state absenc offici intergovernment agreement recognit academ degre commiss envisag stipul candid holder final univers degre give elig admiss doctor studi decis notic competit origin complaint rais question notic competit contain incorrect mislead inform clear commiss comment notic competit accur state commiss decis requir higher univers degre case graduat finnish univers commiss decis requir higher univers degre case graduat finnish univers articl staff regul european commun recruit direct secur institut servic offici highest standard abil effici integr recruit broadest geograph basi nation member state commun choos criteria vacant post fill appoint author discretionari power exercis discretionari power appoint author respect principl equal discrimin treat candid similar situat differ justifi ground qualif higher educ compet member state commun action respect base principl mutual recognit variat period univers studi graduat member state admit competit suffici demonstr failur respect principl equal discrimin commiss acknowledg principl equal discrimin comment complaint state determin natur diploma elig admiss competit seek ensur approach similar treatment univers graduat whichev member state graduat appear evid commiss exercis improperli discretionari power choos criteria vacant post fill view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case invit tender procedur decis complaint tk vk joint research centr european commiss complaint januari mr german nation petit european parliament joint research centr european commiss committe petit transfer petit ombudsman dealt complaint mr particip restrict tender procedur organis joint research centr ispra alleg procedur properli conduct comparison requir tender german law complain poor commun fact project accept juri properli compens work undertaken inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss made point order renov build research centr ispra call interest prior restrict invit tender publish supplement theoffici journal european commun compani express interest select intern committe compani complain relev document restrict invit tender candid meet held order inform candid complain decid part meet report meet candid includ complain restrict invit tender carri accord relev provis commun law financi regul public procur direct relev document distribut candid correct complet particip person inform result procedur commiss annex document comment provid detail inform select procedur ident juri commiss gener oblig reimburs cost unsuccess tender case research centr undertaken provid maximum compens payment ecu build project submit select depend progress propos basi complain paid ecu compens finalist project ecu project consider complain observ observ commiss comment mr state transpar procedur satisfi inform commiss document annex comment relat level compens mr observ volum preparatori work project unusu high led debat particip result compens subsequ increas term compens payment unclear unusu understand term compens payment publish end competit decis basi evid european ombudsman appear restrict tender procedur carri properli accord relev provis commun law level compens unsuccess project principl good administr requir particip full accur inform procedur invit tender includ compens scheme project submit prepar project involv consider effort cost basi evid european ombudsman appear research centr explain procedur submiss project precis inform condit compens foreseen project submit appear evid research centr fail appli condit laid commun complain particip inform meet organis research centr request inform appear basi claim centr provid addit inform view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case termin phare subcontract respons commiss decis complaint sh rom kt european commiss complaint mr local coordin phare project romania provid servic subcontractor compani call contract european commiss phare programm phare contract februari termin contract mr ground alleg unsatisfactori perform march mr complain european ombudsman summari mr complain termin contract unjustifi project schedul budget project initi commiss deleg romania broke term phare contract decis project commiss deleg requir prior approv write commiss servic respons phare obtain deni access copi phare contract request meet project steer committe discuss matter refus year march mr ombudsman copi materi address court auditor european commiss anti fraud unit uclaf materi concern alleg irregular award contract financ european commun romania includ alleg name individu includ head commiss deleg romania deal alleg maladministr rais question protect financi interest commun ombudsman mind compet court auditor articl treati establish european commun role commiss anti fraud unit uclaf mr alleg appear rais matter appropri consid inquiri court auditor uclaf mr address alleg ombudsman reopen inquiri decis case concern claim made mr origin complaint inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari made comment inform commiss import defici occur prepar seminar import gala event respons mr seminar workshop chang time agreement commiss deleg larg due lack fruit cooper commun mr rest team termin contract mr requir prior approv commiss realloc fund termin contract requir commiss approv commiss gave formal approv amend contract order deal consequ replac mr mr receiv copi contract commiss septemb steer committe project consist contractor commiss deleg romania depart european integr govern romania member committe unanim consid unnecessari call meet discuss termin cooper mr contract complain observ observ commiss comment mr refer specif provis phare contract claim breach observ repeat claim unjustifi dismiss delai give access phare contract absenc steer committe meet discuss dismiss reason decis legal context appear document ombudsman contractu relationship complain mr european commiss commiss enter phare contract consult compani subcontract mr suppli servic agre provid phare contract mr commiss act public author bound commun law includ requir observ gener principl good administr termin mr contract mr contract commiss commun institut bodi european ombudsman compet decid termin mr contract justifi action regard mr subject provis phare contract ombudsman compet inquir maladministr commiss exercis power relat contract ombudsman carefulli examin provis phare contract refer mr fact alleg mr constitut breach provis unnecessari ombudsman failur commiss enforc term contract initi commiss project accord term contract constitut maladministr circumst case avail phare contract mr appear phare contract commiss conclud juli copi made mr meet steer committe septemb materi suppli ombudsman includ document request copi contract complain date request made appear evid gap month sign phare contract commun subcontractor repres maladministr request meet steer committe commiss state member steer committe includ commiss deleg unanim consid call meet steer committe request mr gener principl good administr person interest percept affect decis public author opportun make point view meet steer committe place mr opportun present point view alleg unsatisfactori perform circumst case relev decis termin mr contract made commiss question aros maladministr commiss deleg press meet steer committe discuss decis compet made comment ombudsman appear agre subsequ modif phare contract request commiss satisfi evid support claim unsatisfactori perform mr commiss satisfi decis termin mr contract manifestli wrong appear basi claim principl good administr requir commiss ensur effect ad hoc inform hear contractu disput mr view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case view alleg made mr march ombudsman copi decis inform court auditor uclaf request inform action relat mr alleg ombudsman subsequ inform uclaf begun investig refus access document decis complaint utec kt european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman march commiss refus give copi custom document mr belgian compani import export compani specialis trade african state intern trade oper compani export milk togo dutch compani milk refus import togo conform contract compani immedi brought legal action compani dutch court compani alleg zutphen chamber commerc deliv fals certif origin basi compani receiv payment address belgian dutch author success compani request custom document commiss commiss answer nation author provid document mr address complaint ombudsman obtain custom document commiss inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state interven case question possess administr legal power relat disput privat person commiss question settl nation law commiss advis compani civil court netherland order settl matter commiss state document question commiss document commiss servic access custom document nation servic control import export good access specif provid regul eec order enabl commiss servic carri task control coordin monitor commiss stress articl regul reason profession secreci document obtain power transmit commiss parti civil procedur complain observ observ mr maintain origin complaint protest attitud commiss refus access document ground profession secreci inquiri commiss comment complain observ appear aspect complaint remain unansw ombudsman ask commiss inform legal basi commiss refus give complain copi document light commiss decis februari public access commiss document repli commiss state custom document origin commiss servic servic institut organ commun compani visa dutch custom author commiss state hold document origin form copi decis februari commiss adopt decis public access commiss document decis establish principl wide access public commiss document commiss declar ombudsman author custom document hold document origin form copi circumst commiss give access document question fell scope commiss decis public access commiss document view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case alleg delai payment subvent decis complaint eten es european commiss complaint march mr technic secretari european tourism educ network eten europ wide profit associ complain ombudsman commiss fail pai outstand agre subvent tourism project complain commiss fail repli letter eten commiss give explan delai payment decemb commiss dg xxiii agre financ cost project eten project concern establish intern tourism student associ itsa project public thesauru dictionari tourism terminolog thesauru project framework subsidi commun action plan assist tourism subvent subject contract eten dg xxiii date decemb includ declar recipi financi assist payment subvent stage amount total amount due itsa project complet decemb thesauru project complet june month extens period award eten commiss complain document includ final report statement account deliv time dg xxiii payment ecu ecu itsa thesauru project made august commiss subsequ fail pai outstand amount ecu ecu ecu eten contact commiss numer occas request payment outstand sum explan delai receiv repli dg xxiii claim suffer administr delai letter fax commiss eten june april unansw basi fact eten complain european ombudsman commiss fail meet oblig pai outstand fail provid eten explan delai inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point comment commiss admit failur repli correspond eten apologis procedur dg xxiii respond inquiri outstand payment similar bodi review order ensur inquiri acknowledg delai repli issu delai payment partli due fact case itsa project separ copi contract signatur repres eten return commiss eten locat spain project period complet registr formal luxembourg novemb chang bank account brussel luxembourg project commiss satisfi final statement account reflect real cost project support document claim amount insuffici accord condit contract itsa project carri conform contract condit primari object offer traineeship achiev commiss satisfi inform ask eten state implement project thought carri spot inspect headquart eten april commiss satisfi explan mr support document obtain eten spot inspect examin situat order determin final payment made eten contrari amount need recov eten intent make final decis end juli complain observ summari mr presid eten made observ registr formal administr fact commiss invok fulli justifi delai payment specif administr set procedur date account initi delai delai project complet commiss explan point concern itsa project justifi delai payment thesauru project commiss servic notic spot inspect itsa project manag offer traineeship student continu consolid expans project curb lack financi aid commiss materi request commiss visit servic short time end juli final decis commiss indic approxim date final decis addit letter ombudsman complain observ due delai payment itsa thesauru project undermin develop inquiri commiss inform ombudsman commun eten letter decemb final decis payment itsa thesauru project commiss conclud thesauru project final unpaid amount ecu reduc ecu due inelig expenditur lack support document itsa project commiss conclud full amount payment ecu recov total failur project clear indic effort eten provid reason prospect success commiss net result recoveri order ecu eten complain addit observ complain agre final decis commiss result recoveri order project successfulli complet time term agre regard itsa project complain opinion commiss admit letter decemb agre term project essenti fulfil end decemb commiss respons financi organis problem project final complain ask european ombudsman suspend recoveri order decis complain claim suspend recoveri order ombudsman power suspend oper recoveri order commiss failur repli correspond commiss admit regret failur repli letter eten commiss procedur dg xxiii relat respons inquiri outstand payment review order ensur enquiri acknowledg delai repli issu remark ombudsman commiss failur pai outstand subvent condit payment outstand financi assist laid ident term declar recipi financi assist sign eten decemb relev provis declar foresaw outstand financi assist paid submiss accept commiss document report financi assist account statement financi statement duli certifi support document indic natur amount item expenditur incom declar foresaw statement expenditur fail justifi financi assist eten agre reimburs commiss request amount unduli paid eten entitl receiv payment fulfil condit declar commiss comment delai payment essenti due fact eten fulli compli condit ombudsman determin substant disput commiss eten fulfil condit declar question determin court compet jurisdict possibl hear testimoni evalu conflict evid role ombudsman relat aspect case examin evid commiss fail act accord principl good administr principl requir delai payment eten outstand financi assist genuin doubt eten fulfil condit declar registr formal administr fact commiss invok complain rightli observ fulli justifi delai payment outstand argument commiss put forward appear provid evid commiss genuin doubt eten fulfil condit declar appear comment commiss fulli satisfi final statement account true reflect real cost project appear commiss support document amount claim insuffici accord contract condit fact commiss dissatisfi inform provid eten state implement itsa project decid carri spot control headquart eten consid possibl recov eten amount confirm genuin doubt eten complianc contract condit exist genuin doubt part commiss confirm final decis issu recoveri order inelig expenditur lack support document thesauru project total failur itsa project basi inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss view find ombudsman decid close case remark ombudsman note complain submit disput payment outstand financi assist final decis commiss compet judici author handl request inform commiss represent decis complaint ma dk pd european commiss complaint march mr complain ombudsman alleg commiss represent denmark assist properli give inform right regul eec swedish pension live denmark mr run problem relat social secur denmark written danish represent presid commiss advic inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point mr wrote presid european commiss april letter refer commiss represent copenhagen action commiss copenhagen desk euro ju entrust matter commiss legal consult spoke mr telephon time mr promis technic solv problem provid inform inform request letter april remind remind letter copenhagen represent repeat willing explain inform need order pursu matter final remind legal advis explain inform request imposs investig matter commiss state remain assist mr order investig matter essenti commiss inform refer correspond mr complain observ observ mr maintain complaint confirm wrote presid commiss april state receiv answer mr deni speak time phone legal consult represent mr telephon contact offic april confirm speak euro ju repres februari mr state present relev materi knew commun law stand mr state receiv letter april end fact receiv remind letter letter april annex mr astonish delai receiv letter content letter april concern mr state answer question previou letter februari consid question irrelev aim frustrat mr question answer decis correspond complain commiss servic februari mr wrote commiss represent copenhagen request matter letter gave address fredriksberg februari mr spoke phone euro ju repres ms promis matter april ms repli mr letter februari request inform letter address mention mr letter februari april mr wrote presid european commiss letter gave address humlebæk april presid forward letter commiss represent copenhagen ms repli behalf presid european commiss thank mr letter inform mr mr answer question put forward letter humlebæk mr receiv end commiss represent final remind letter address mr correspond letter request inform repeat base find mr letter commiss represent copenhagen presid european commiss answer april ombudsman found instanc maladministr establish commiss represent repli abovement letter delai receiv letter commiss represent observ mr mention delai receiv letter commiss represent alleg delai appear ow fact mr address correspond commiss represent presid european commiss repli address mr letter mr appear chang address commiss ombudsman inquiri reveal maladministr relat delai receiv correspond assist provid commiss represent correspond commiss represent need inform mr situat order investig matter represent express willing mr consid question put forward irrelev ombudsman found commiss represent assist mr matter order represent inform view find appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case contract technic assist algeria decis complaint st kt european commiss european court auditor complaint april mr lodg complaint ombudsman contract technic assist algeria sign commiss complaint dealt opinion project court auditor commiss mr sign contract commiss cooper algeria context psa programm financ european commun call tender handl commiss deleg algeria complain award project sem task algeria began march difficulti complain manag complet task deadlin set contract march commiss settl acount cover month work acount commiss februari payment made mr request payment acount payment interest delai compens discredit profession imag march commiss agre settl matter mr complain ombudsman alleg maladministr commiss fail provid suffici technic assist abus power oppress contractu claus administr irregular wrong erron inform forward court auditor court auditor mr complain remark includ annual report court auditor psa programm algeria point report court auditor limit report examin document meet commiss offici complain view court arrang meet give opportun justifi action inquiri complaint forward institut concern commiss comment summari commiss made point progress mr compli technic indic contract report incomplet vagu februari mr forward short report work activ period januari report contract complet report insuffici written hast clear evalu progress commiss decid postpon payment acount contract control procedur commiss servic involv finalis june agreement reach complain agre pursu claim exchang payment lump sum court auditor comment summari court auditor made point court auditor audit develop psa programm period april februari carri task court criteria laid ec treati articl audit base record perform spot institut commun member state present case court decid make check spot difficult polit situat algeria court refer psa programm annual report section report draft court basi inform provid commiss accord paragraph articl mr call give evid court oblig hear privat individu bodi hand complain inform court heard report publish offici journal report refer aspect relat complain perform contract specif word point annual report complain refer result concern observ made previou paragraph question technic assist complain observ complain confirm friendli solut reach insist receiv public apolog commiss request court auditor add corrigendum offici journal extent word result point annual report concern technic assist perform complain demand commiss recognis mistak letter order rehabilit profession imag letter declar contractu relationship institut settl decis appear inquiri pursu ombudsman mr commiss state friendli settlement reach merit complaint settlement appar met complain demand express satisfact commiss publicli acknowledg agreement reach mr claim public recognit satisfi assess mean point report court auditor conclud tern result refer technic assist provid complain context appear refer previou section report object court report commiss complain basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss court auditor ombudsman close case recognit countri diploma decis complaint mamg uk ijh european commiss complaint april mr complain ombudsman recognit argentinian qualif clinic psychologist complaint british psycholog societi bp commiss ombudsman inform deal complaint relat commiss bp commun institut bodi complain spanish citizen obtain univers qualif clinic psychologist argentina practis franc qualif recognis decemb move unit kingdom seek work clinic psychologist bp refus recognis qualif requir order obtain statement equival pass uk diploma psycholog result lack recognit inelig appoint clinic psychologist uk nation health servic consid bp recognis qualif council direct eec council recommend eec april citizen europ advisori servic part commiss london offic act behalf mr report situat commiss ask clarif requir bp entir uk diploma order obtain statement equival accord direct eec june commiss dg xv intern market financi servic answer receiv inform relat recognit complain argentinian diploma french author doubt fulfil condit order benefit direct eec commiss observ certif submit british author mr issu spanish embassi pari certifi photocopi origin decis french compet author complain commiss answer made unfair alleg januari member european parliament wrote letter dg xv state commiss answer citizen europ advisori servic extrem neg unhelp complain reason ask review matter carefulli consid opinion mep point french ministri educ recognis complain compet practis septemb complain fulfil requir year profession work franc uk commiss repli februari repeat order benefit direct eec gener system recognit higher educ diploma complain justifi year profession experi certifi member state recognis countri diploma articl direct commiss observ order interven british author appli direct case complain send copi formal decis french author recognis argentinian diploma commiss certif year profession experi basi fact mr complain ombudsman dg xv fail assist obtain recognit qualif made unfair alleg correspond matter adopt obstruct interpret direct eec demand year offici employ recognit fail give effect recommend eec nation member state hold diploma confer member state inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point alleg fail assist complain obtain recognit qualif commiss confirm point made london offic observ proof french author recognis argentinian diploma commiss ad ask complain occas send simpl copi recognit consist fail commiss observ receiv evid complain cover direct eec contact uk author behalf regard alleg made unfair alleg complain commiss observ normal practic deal complaint member state complain suppli copi essenti document order clarifi fact evalu ground complaint contact member state author attitud design cast aspers complain good faith interpret direct eec commiss observ countri diploma obtain commun nation benefit recognit procedur direct condit recognis member state european union holder year profession experi certifi member state recognis diploma alleg failur give effect council recommend eec articl ec treati recommend bind forc complain observ complain repeat prior observ ad document recognit time includ citizen europ advisori servic mep dg xv remov evid prove recognit complain final ask employ restor decis alleg failur commiss assist complain obtain recognit qualif order assist complain obtain recognit qualif verifi uk author act accord direct commiss possess document evalu verifi valid relev legal fact complain profession situat recognit french author argentinian diploma complain constitut document appear commiss comment made request complain obtain copi formal recognit decis french author complain fail send commiss receiv certif issu spanish embassi pari constitut certifi copi recognit decis french author essenti document commiss start investig commiss observ time receiv request copi interven british author appear forego evid commiss fail assist complain obtain recognit qualif alleg unfair alleg complain complain suppli copi formal recognit decis french author refus certif issu spanish embassi proof recognit commiss obtain relev document legal assess profession background complain commiss consid made unfair alleg complain commiss interpret direct eec articl direct countri diploma obtain nation member state benefit recognit system direct holder thereof year profession experi certifi member state recognis countri diploma requir year profession experi recognit countri diploma commiss adopt interpret contrari condit recal court justic highest author interpret commun law alleg failur commiss give effect recommend eec recommend bind forc articl ec treati commiss power requir member state compli recommend commiss consid fail give effect recommend eec basi inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case recognit diploma handl complaint commiss decis complaint mfcl kt european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman complaint portugues author dealt commiss mr inform ombudsman holder french doctor linguist obtain recognit french diploma portug success portugues author consid doctor fall scope direct eec januari mr wrote commiss subject gener secretariat commiss repli inform complaint regist examin complaint mr ask ombudsman investig matter commiss close file open infring procedur portug inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point subject matter complaint involv exercis commiss discret regard proceed articl council direct eec decemb establish gener system recognit higher educ diploma award complet profession educ train year durat basi abovement direct complain obtain recognit order exercis profession activ portug doctor degre gave access franc commiss servic portugues french author complain detail list correspond provid ombudsman base correspond repli french author letter individu similar problem member state commiss decid discuss question meet april nation coordin applic direct eec mr inform telephon meet coordin fact ow meet calendar commiss decis relat open infring proceed earliest octob base argument advanc portugues author discuss meet coordin commiss servic ask mr forward copi correspond portugues author copi diploma commiss mr case concern complic question discuss member state commiss commiss point servic address member state inform calendar treat file depend larg extent final commiss state mr inform time evolut file commiss continu inform action exercis discretionari power complain observ observ mr maintain complaint state experi higher educ diploma academ gave access enseign université profess inform ombudsman commiss request inform june repli request june mr subsequ inform ombudsman novemb receiv letter commiss state send formal notif portugues author januari mr receiv letter inform letter formal notif due materi question mr express dissatisfact delai send formal notif inquiri ombudsman decid request inform commiss initi infring procedur articl ec treati portug transposit direct eec letter complain januari commiss repli commiss repli decid initi infring procedur portug articl ec treati procedur base incomplet transposit direct eec portugues law commiss inform mr letter june develop procedur decis administr stage articl procedur articl ec treati lai procedur criteria commiss period preced issu reason opinion member state jurisprud court justic limit guidanc commiss decid procedur criteria adopt order discharg respons articl process lead issu reason opinion matter good administr practic commiss persist attempt obtain repli member state administr stage infring procedur accord case law court justic articl treati place member state oblig facilit achiev task indent articl assign commiss member state requir cooper bona fide inquiri undertaken commiss articl suppli commiss inform request end mr complaint regist commiss continu send letter member state concern mr inform develop correspond telephon ombudsman found evid maladministr relat aspect case decis open infring proceed articl ec treati articl ec treati commiss issu reason opinion consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati case law court justic role guardian treati commiss compet decid bring proceed member state failur fulfil oblig commiss inform complain letter june formal notif portugues author articl ec treati incomplet transposit direct eec ombudsman found instanc maladministr commiss conduct inquiri undertaken matter view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case financ project med urb programm decis complaint cgw pd xd european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman behalf associ project fund framework med urb programm contract sign commiss citi greec financ med urb project associ benefit project made agreement greek citi locat cultur centr problem aros associ citi locat centr complain argu disagr endang project complain ombudsman commiss respons resolv disagr inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss point contract provid fund project conclud commiss greek citi associ parti contract commiss remark separ agreement locat cultur centr conclud citi complain commiss parti agreement commiss conclud respons citi council act oblig start inquiri complain observ complain argu commiss respons project provid fund made creation cultur centr complain commiss moral oblig support project oblig deriv provis contract intend ensur continu project commiss hand financ project hand project endang citi charg coordin project decis firstli ombudsman note contractu link complain commiss hand contract financ project conclud commiss greek citi hand agreement locat cultur centr sign complain citi ombudsman consid provis contract conclud commiss citi commiss financ project citi respect condit laid contract commiss project financ condit contract fulfil contract provid oblig commiss thirdli ombudsman consid contract global framework decentralis cooper underpin european programm med urb commun financ project respect spirit condit laid programm answer project respons practic problem occur framework project background european ombudsman found instanc maladministr commiss attitud close case treatment commiss represent decis complaint lk fin kt vk european commiss complaint ms complain ombudsman commiss represent finland treat april ms contact commiss represent finland enquir reimburs travel expens commiss competit eur la claim repli offic impolit told contact commiss brussel earlier ms contact represent finland request inform recruit opportun represent similarli repli ms call brussel complaint ms express dissatisfact commiss represent finland respond enquiri inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss inform ombudsman natur advic commiss represent finland state case ms advis telephon brussel commiss week approach relev unit letter complain observ observ ms maintain complaint addit claim entitl compens result late payment travel expens decis advic commiss represent finland commiss state represent regularli gener inform open competit request practic represent refer member public detail question specif recruit matter recruit unit dg ix brussel commiss ms correct assist commiss state person right time respect observ ms contest present evid contrari relat aspect case ombudsman found evid maladministr relat advic commiss represent finland june payment travel expens order commiss juli ms acknowledg receiv payment week earlier ombudsman note complain intend pursu claim compens address directli commiss view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case recruit temporari agent decis complaint kt european commiss complaint june mr complain ombudsman select temporari agent european commiss refer sdt select board notifi complain letter april decis exclud interview mr contest decis letter commiss answer confirm initi decis mr address complaint ombudsman assess qualif competit inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state public notic vacanc commiss forward applic select board member board expert field concern notic check gener condit respect candid articl staff regul compar special compet candid relat requir duti held mr candid shortlist interview contest exclus group select candid mr told write select board reexamin applic board conclud candid qualifi complain maintain initi decis justifi candid depth knowledg comput linguist notic vacanc decis contrast staff regul european commun appli recruit offici regul applic servant european commun appli temporari agent lai specif recruit procedur commiss select procedur sdt aim recruit temporari agent grade la la respons develop automat translat system commiss commiss state select board undertaken compar examin candid qualif relat requir post conclud complain profession qualif limit develop system comput linguist view fact select board gave complain reason decis inquiri carri ombudsman give reason doubt correct reason evid maladministr ombudsman close case radionavig system europ lack implement decis complaint cc vk european commiss complaint june mr complain ombudsman alleg commiss fail implement oblig council decis eec februari function radionavig system europ oper mediterranean loran chain inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point commiss share complain view oper loran chain ensur full coverag western mediterranean loran signal commiss reach agreement spanish author reopen relev station estarit spain implement agreement commiss plan report council implement start radio navig polici result draft report loran chain present council council decis eec requir member state commiss set worldwid radionavig system includ european region loran chain decis leav respons parti region loran agreement sole member state bind commit maintain develop system commiss made consider effort convinc member state set region loran agreement complain observ complain point oblig contract parti intern agreement establish maintain navig aid decis commiss oblig fulfil oblig function radionavig system council decis eec articl decis commiss ensur cooper member state encourag develop receiv pursu work view set radionavig plan propos measur council appear inform ombudsman commiss made arrang agreement member state reach agreement spain spanish author implement relev provis commiss plan report council implement start radionavig polici result draft report loran chain present council appear commiss fulfil oblig council decis complain state contract parti oblig arrang establish mainten aid navig requir base intern convent safeti life sea sola requir council decis commiss parti convent commiss oblig arrang establish mainten aid navig inquiri european ombudsman case reveal instanc maladministr ombudsman close case agricultur tender suppli rye flour decis complaint jew vk european commiss complaint june jew austrian flour mill enterpris complain ombudsman contract suppli rye flour successfulli tender accord commiss regul ec octob commiss impos penalti late deliveri good complain abovement regul state good deliv effect decemb complain commiss wrongli interpret regul request good deliv latest decemb view fact good relev freight carrier dai foreseen regul penalti justifi complain alleg commiss discrimin smaller enterpris inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state period dai meant enabl deliver divid flour suppli deliveri shift exclus meant give transport flexibl plan deliver left time margin entir amount flour readi transport decemb penalti justifi discrimin smaller enterpris commiss state decreas quantiti good order enabl smaller enterpris particip tender complain make observ decis articl commiss regul ec suppli secur success tender lodg favour commun forfeit delai occur deliveri caus produc inform ombudsman appear good deliv time schedul foreseen penalti justifi appear evid discrimin smaller enterpris inquiri ombudsman case reveal instanc maladministr ombudsman close case appeal decis prolong inter univers programm decis complaint dg fk kt european commiss complaint mr vice presid group école supérieur de commerc de renn gsc renn receiv fund erasmu programm inter univers cooper programm icp gsc renn submit reapplic form icp absenc reapplic form erasmu offic decid prolong gsc renn icp year letter mr complain head tao socrat youth decis explain gsc renn receiv reapplic form mr receiv repli letter june complain ombudsman june complaint express concern procedur erasmu offic alleg exist possibl appeal decis offic inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment institutionalis system appeal decis erasmu offic complaint qualit judgment procedur matter examin ad hoc administr error occur procedur commiss technic assist offic tao deal propos commiss power correct error reconsid propos commiss practic case applic make procedur error examin error due circumst control applic institut exampl circumst sudden death ill principl equal treatment plai import role outcom appeal select procedur chang basi complaint applic opportun reappli condit commiss explain decid reject mr appeal ground inform univers necess send reapplic form commiss mr receiv relev letter quot letter appeal commiss state similar case formal procedur requir neglect consid suffici ground reconsid select decis principl equal treatment impli case reconsid commiss comment forward mr invit submit observ wish observ receiv decis appear inform provid european ombudsman commiss ad hoc procedur deal appeal procedur examin correct administr error part commiss technic assist offic part applic commiss evalu argument put forward mr effect receiv reapplic form found unconvinc refus accept reapplic deadlin commiss reason refer principl equal treatment state similar case icp coordin omit formal requir accept commiss provid suffici ground reconsid select decis view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case staff addit salari payment decis complaint vk km vk cs vk european commiss complaint june ms ms mr complain ombudsman refus commiss pai addit salari complain pass open competit enabl obtain higher grade offici appoint higher grade recognit work experi judgment court instanc case brought commiss offici complain benefit regrad addit salari payment backdat date court judgment offici possibl intern complaint provid articl staff regul complaint reject offici complain ombudsman claim receiv addit salari improv step effect date nomin higher grade inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss made summari point judgment court instanc baiwir commiss grade step offici pass open competit higher categori base articl articl staff regul whichev gave favour result offici concern februari commiss publish administr notic invit offici appli grade reconsid light judgment notic stipul effect backdat date judgment septemb public notic complain sought origin grade chang decis effect offici made complaint articl staff regul object fact improv step obtain effect term salari equival date judgment retrospect date appoint categori complaint reject commiss ground benefit judgment obtain parti action base judgment brought person effect futur term commiss administr notic complain bar contest grade decis articl staff regul articl exemplifi applic principl legal certainti provid decis advers affect offici challeng month date notif complain observ complain state commiss breach principl equal complain find comprehens commiss hand provid retroact regrad hand complain situat parti baiwir judgment decis septemb court instanc gave judgment join case baiwir commiss annul decis commiss appli applic case commiss subsequ publish administr notic invit offici parti baiwir case appli grade reconsid light judgment notic stipul effect backdat date judgment question issu complaint commiss entitl impos restrict commiss origin decis step complain grade made june time limit appeal decis staff regul expir year ago timelimit mandatori laid view ensur clariti legal certainti case law court justic emerg fact capabl caus time start run regard court consist held judgment annul administr measur constitut fact person directli affect measur annul relat offici parti baiwir case commiss properli decid chang grade effect term salari date judgment case commiss entitl differ treatment respect applic baiwir case offici justifi violat principl equal recal court justic highest author question commun law inquiri european ombudsman case reveal instanc maladministr close case develop applic fund budget head tropic forest decis complaint aymi nl vk european commiss complaint june ws foundat complain ombudsman particip tender project sustain develop tropic rain forest surinam ws state relev commiss offici dg viii provid suffici inform present project time correct form inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state foundat attempt adapt initi project success version project fulli compli object relev budget head commiss claim attempt explain carefulli success refus provid document complain review design project formul project elig relev budget head commiss admit long time assess project partli due long period silenc part complain inabl design accept sustain develop project complain observ foundat state deleg surinam offic met repres commiss order discuss project complain point discuss posit final decis made brussel date decis inform ombudsman appear unfortun initi delai commiss explain success refus provid document complain review design project complain chanc reappli condit evid delai respons complain failur achiev fund project ombudsman inquiri case reveal instanc maladministr ombudsman close case alleg failur respond complaint decis complaint je uk kt european commiss complaint mr state submit complaint commiss septemb breach habitat direct eec newburi bypass road uk complain european ombudsman june receiv correspond commiss matter inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment complaint address mr ken collin mep septemb forward director gener xi septemb receiv septemb septemb mr spoke telephon offici dg xi respons complaint point octob mr instruct messr solicitor relat complaint correspond messr mr occur octob earli novemb dg xi wrote messr novemb march final decemb decis commiss octob open infring proceed commun correspond messr place date correspond solicitor instruct mr respect matter commission bjerregaard wrote newburi transport forum address correspond juli complaint commiss opinion contain detail schedul abovement correspond comment commiss forward mr invit make observ wish observ receiv decis complain state receiv correspond commiss complaint made septemb appear commiss address correspond matter complain solicitor correspond complaint receiv appear letter commission bjerregaard complain address newburi transport forum correspond complaint appear evid commiss breach principl good administr behaviour fail respond complaint commiss appear act send correspond complain solicitor complain address newburi transport forum view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case staff reimburs administr decis complaint ee vk european commiss complaint juli mr commiss offici lodg complaint ombudsman claim reimburs pair glass comput work medic machin muscl nerv claim reimburs reject inquiri complaint forward commiss comment commiss refer regul reimburs cost spectacl circumst wearer varilux lens year ag claim reimburs present case medic servic decid mr meet requir explain reimburs lens meant comput work distanc cm account medic machin consid function complain point commiss follow protect measur staff glass order carri work properli medic machin save complain visit physiotherapist home work interrupt decis inform ombudsman appear relev regul appli properli evalu procedur carri medic servic appear ground alleg incorrect applic exist rule inquiri reveal instanc maladministr ombudsman close case recruit right person reserv list decis complaint kt european commiss complaint juli complain ombudsman competit accord articl statut complaint classifi confidenti request complain complaint appli januari post secur servic joint research centr ispra itali novemb complain inform reserv list temporari post valid reserv list origin foreseen end june period valid prolong decemb decemb date complaint recruit joint research centr ispra complain found candid left reserv list complaint express disappoint learn intent hold competit fill post appli explain inform secur servic understaf firearm instructor heard rumour reason failur recruit disagr head divis centr head local secur servic italian recruit fellow italian state lodg complaint number ground maladministr servic understaf failur provid accur inform call direct offici knowledg actual matter discrimin ground italian unfair treatment competit held recruit reserv list exhaust avoid delai inform april period valid relev reserv list extend decemb inquiri commiss comment summari commiss made point comment reserv list give candid recruit commiss person inform alleg discrimin inform fals fact italian nation reserv list person recruit centr commiss organis competit temporari agent secur servic joint research centr categori agent categori competit particip commiss consid mr complaint unfound complain made observ comment decis right person reserv list case law court justic fact person reserv list confer person entitl post commun institut complain alleg servic concern understaf alleg remain unsubstanti regard fact element hand indic commiss incorrect procedur ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr relat aspect complaint failur provid accur inform complain alleg failur provid accur inform refer telephon call commiss complaint ombudsman complain regularli telephon written contact offici respons ispra personnel depart offici respons made note complain interest recruit file ombudsman find evid maladministr relat alleg failur provid accur inform discrimin ground nation alleg discrimin base nation complain claim prefer recruit italian nation opinion commiss state reserv list includ candid italian nation recruit joint research centr basi ombudsman inquiri appear evid maladministr relat aspect complaint organis competit reserv list exhaust previou decis ombudsman view staf requir aris commiss oblig wait reserv list exhaust launch competit commiss state opinion competit organ time order recruit agent categori fact lower categori categori competit complain particip januari ombudsman inquiri reveal instanc maladministr relat organis competit categori exhaust reserv list categori avoid delai recruit alleg delai inform complain april period valid reserv list extend decemb ombudsman accept commiss extend valid specif reserv list valid reserv list competit origin foreseen month ahead novemb june complain inform valid prolong month decemb fact complain inform march valid extend month decemb view find fact decis prolong valid reserv list favour complain ombudsman find instanc maladministr relat aspect complaint view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case failur promot commiss offici decis complaint ls dt european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman failur offic offici public european commun opoc includ promot list select propos candid promot grade mr intern complaint procedur articl staff regul repli articl complaint director gener personnel inform irregular place promot procedur state opoc proceed basi inform report offici includ promot list candid includ list qualifi complaint ombudsman mr alleg subject administr irregular superior opoc legal servic commiss claim discrimin continu promot inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment applic qualifi complain promot ii mr propos promot grade superior suggest includ promot list provid carri task similar standard iii complain includ promot list offici end evalu procedur obtain promot iv promot committe grade inform slow career mr problem dealt primarili servic submit propos promot irregular commit select procedur promot main criteria promot base candid merit complain observ observ commiss comment mr stress slow career path began includ promot list inclus overcom seri irregular due obstruction head opoc legal servic point modif made procedur evalu career promot colleagu qualifi enjoi advantag consequ exclus inquiri commiss opinion irregular select procedur ombudsman consid object element institut letter verifi assert order ensur exercis commiss discret process principl good administr ombudsman request letter juli inspect number confidenti document commiss reach decis includ personnel report compar tabl relat materi emploi appoint author assess merit candid commiss ombudsman confidenti inform appoint author select procedur promot decis respect select procedur promot natur promot procedur set articl staff regul recognis court justic appoint author enjoi larg margin discret discret appoint author merit candid basi object element suscept control recognis court justic order ensur exercis commiss discret process principl good administr ombudsman inspect seri confidenti document appoint author assess merit candid inspect appear commiss reach decis due refer number prima faci object criteria evid commiss discret promot arbitrari discriminatori mr complain alleg unfair treatment commiss select proceed promot contest proceed intern commiss articl statut ombudsman complaint made ombudsman concern work relationship commun institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint procedur refer articl staff regul exhaust person concern condit met relat select proceed promot ombudsman pursu inquiri part complaint view find appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close file staff freedom express decis complaint eaw sw vk european commiss complaint mr swedish nation complain ombudsman juli letter mr erkki liikanen member commiss respons personnel administr mr carl magnu lemmel deputi director gener dg iii commiss appear file complaint swedish newspap dagen politik publish remark attribut mr lemmel remark critic work method commiss complaint concern fact abovement remark publish dagen politik mr liikanen wrote mr lemmel mr lemmel complain ombudsman inform complaint ombudsman inquiri submit view inform ombudsman inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss contain statement public express opinion offici govern articl staff regul offici abstain action public express opinion reflect posit articl staff regul offici exercis greatest discret regard fact inform come knowledg connect perform duti spite provis staff regul commiss decid case question start disciplinari proceed limit send letter remind hand offici recruit duti reserv offici subject hand recal commiss expect offici offici higher grade creativ attent improv made manag implement task entrust institut initi examin mean insid commiss give rise propos translat concret measur complain observ observ commiss comment complain state sweden freedom express constitut enjoi civil servant state consid commiss impos sever restrict freedom express inappropri decis fact ombudsman decis base basi inquiri conduct european ombudsman relev fact appear remark critic commiss work procedur appear swedish newspap attribut mr lemmel disciplinari proceed mr lemmel initi letter address mr lemmel commission liikanen commiss opinion complaint letter remind mr lemmel duti reserv offici subject context commiss refer articl staff regul staff regul paragraph articl staff regul offici abstain action public express opinion reflect posit opinion commiss quot paragraph articl staff regul offici exercis greatest discret regard fact inform come knowledg connect perform duti duti allegi ow commun offici court justic state decis oyow traor commiss staff regul interpret conflict freedom express fundament court ensur respect commun law case law court justic european convent human right mention articl treati european union basi human right gener principl commun law articl european convent human right guarante freedom express includ freedom hold opinion receiv impart inform idea interfer public author articl convent mention exercis freedom carri duti respons envisag condit limit freedom express prescrib law decis european court human right vogt germani legitim impos civil servant account statu duti discret civil servant individu qualifi protect articl convent court mention case ensur fair balanc struck fundament individu freedom express legitim interest democrat state ensur civil servic properli further purpos enumer articl context court remark civil servant freedom express issu duti respons refer articl assum special signific commiss disciplinari proceed mr lemmel confin action send letter remind duti staff regul court justic european commun duti interpret conflict freedom express basi ombudsman inquiri appear evid interfer freedom express case gener intent commiss strike fair balanc fundament individu freedom express duti respons offici view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case remark european ombudsman court justic staff regul interpret conflict freedom express commiss opinion complaint case focus restrict staff regul impos public express opinion offici expressli acknowledg offici fundament freedom express appear articl european convent human right freedom express includ freedom hold opinion receiv impart inform idea interfer public author articl convent envisag condit limit freedom express prescrib law context worth remark commiss opinion ombudsman case quot part paragraph articl staff regul paragraph continu offici manner whatsoev disclos unauthoris person document inform made public continu bound oblig leav servic read liter regard statement court justic staff regul interpret conflict freedom express part articl thought forbid offici put inform whatsoev public domain prevent engag public discuss work interpret incorrect commiss provid guidanc offici consid fair balanc individu freedom express includ freedom impart inform idea duti respons offici articl staff regul issu guidanc ensur fulfil requir articl european convent human right restrict freedom express prescrib law put offici posit forese risk cours action involv public guidanc includ acknowledg fact offici fundament freedom express enhanc relat commiss european citizen avoid confus misunderstand question car import member state handl complaint lodg commiss decis complaint sjh po vk xd european commiss complaint august mr complain ombudsman european commiss addit materi septemb novemb octob mr made complaint commiss alleg portugues author compli commun law matter relat import car portug portugues citizen face difficulti lengthi expens registr procedur vehicl previous regist member state octob commiss decid close file ground detail examin provid suffici evid infring commun law portugues author commiss servic decid undertak initi inquiri matter case examin complain wrote european ombudsman complain alleg commiss take long deal complaint commiss posit action solv alleg infring commun law portugues author inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment made point complaint file detail examin show provid suffici evid infring commun law subsequ initi inquiri commiss intend ensur examin aspect relat free movement good mention complain correspond meet servic commiss portugues author held discuss case commiss contest alleg fail deal complaint reason period time alleg lack posit action resolv alleg infring commun law point servic commiss made analysi alleg problem written detail explanatori letter complain aspect success rais letter commiss complain observ observ commiss comment complain state found difficult insuffici evid start infring proceed mention seri fact claim demonstr clear breach commun law alleg commiss met wrong depart portugues administr inquiri complain state problem urgent recognis receiv lot inform commiss view situat remain unresolv portugues author infring commun law understand commiss fail act year decis regard alleg delai commiss deal complaint commiss intern rule decis close file take action maximum period year date registr special case present case appear complain lodg complaint commiss octob commiss decid close file take action octob year time limit respect appear copi correspond commiss ombudsman complain inform process complaint commiss decid start initi inquiri matter novemb appear commiss letter portugues author decemb met portugues author februari fact launch initi inquiri contact portugues author demonstr willing commiss deal problem mention commiss decid inquiri undertaken form inquiri regard alleg lack posit action commiss case law court justic commiss guardian treati compet decid bring proceed member state failur fulfil oblig mention commiss time carri legal analysi alleg problem take decis start infring proceed member state deal case commiss fail compli principl good administr behaviour conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case recruit exclus open competit decis complaint ys fin ijh european commiss complaint august mr complain european ombudsman exclud open competit organis commiss creat reserv list medic advisor grade austrian finnish swedish nation competit base qualif oral test select board decid invit mr oral examin mr state particip previous open competit recruit head commiss deleg intern organis vienna select board ask send curriculum vita addit applic form mr alleg curriculum vita competit knowingli fix elig criteria competit inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment select board competit ask candid provid curriculum vita addit applic form curriculum vita serv purpos facilit acceler proceed select board candid open competit requir holder higher univers degre medicin certif specialis occup health studi candid requir profession experi thing tropic medicin radiat safeti requir due fact commiss offici work travel tropic region requir staff work nuclear instal nuclear materi mr invit oral examin hold requir qualif reason exclus competit complain observ observ complain maintain origin complaint ombudsman decis annex iii articl staff regul candid complet form prescrib appoint author requir furnish addit document inform legal basi requir candid open competit provid curriculum vita applic form commiss curricula vita open competit serv purpos facilit acceler proceed select board competit ombudsman inquiri reveal evid contradict commiss statement commiss mr exclud open competit hold requir qualif reason ombudsman inquiri reveal evid contradict commiss statement view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case handl complaint lodg commiss decis complaint jc irl bb european commiss complaint octob mr complain ombudsman commiss handl complaint made univers east london uel uk mr state particip year programm uel lead sc degre architectur assur year final year unit diploma basi colleg document state year programm exempt part requir royal institut british architect riba mr pass part sc degre decemb inform fail ms architectur riba part repeat year mr letter mep mr mckenna transmit letter mr cresson member european commiss commission repli complaint concern award diploma architectur conclud matter academ judgment univers case european commiss interven octob mr wrote commission cresson head unit dg xxii explain want complaint uel examin term direct eec complaint ombudsman mr alleg maladministr form lack refus inform commiss handl complaint uel inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point commiss conclus mr complaint sole concern fact fail obtain degre architectur mr inform problem matter univers ground action european commiss repli mr letter dg xxii inform decemb light request mr complaint formal regist januari dg xv wrote reason letter mr explain year programm undertook breach articl direct eec subsequ dg xv decid propos commiss action pursuit mr complaint april dg xv inform mr commiss decid march file complaint univers ground breach commun law complain observ observ mr maintain complaint decis case law court justic commiss compet decid bring proceed member state failur fulfil oblig role guardian treati appear ombudsman inquiri complaint formal regist mr complaint commiss examin light direct eec decis file complaint commiss appear legal reason support conclus found breach direct eec case hand ombudsman inquiri complaint reveal instanc maladministr commiss interpret commun law applic commun law fact nation legal context case view find appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case vat exempt servic provid commiss contractor decis complaint vila pd european commiss complaint mr complain octob ombudsman behalf cooper commiss action relat vat problem encount italian author put forward commiss wrongli assess rule vat exempt appli commiss background grievanc appear file substanc decis februari commiss award cooper grant region fund grant intend financi contribut project improv access small medium size enterpris technolog innov stipul mr run programm includ public campaign check enterpris fund channel provid cooper entitl grant remuner undertak step regard tax exempt servic suppli commiss appear regard provis tax exempt cooper request supplier invoic charg vat legal basi refer relev italian vat statut subsequ compet italian author object proceed implic stand cooper exempt vat circumst mr ask commiss opinion letter juli commiss repli request state place vest author interpret nation legisl place wrote financi contribut commun exempt vat part grant constitut remuner entiti ran commun programm place state entiti acquir servic good perform task oper cover relev rule sixth vat direct vat taxat final commiss observ relev italian statut refer commun fund research project run commun programm satisfi repli mr complain ombudsman vat exempt appli commiss appli equal cooper bought good servic inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state result complaint examin case maintain posit commun letter juli addit sketch solut problem cooper encount italian author commiss comment forward mr invit submit observ wish observ receiv decis commiss author deliv authent interpret provis nation law question issu commiss stand concern commun law found relev provis contain council direct eec sixth vat direct art direct vat exempt intern organis word exempt extend servic deliv subject contractor intern organis understand provis conform case law court justic exempt constru narrowli exempt favour person extend person make contract commiss stand commun cooper undu delai letter juli repli mr letter appear found recal court justic highest author commun law view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case recruit expiri reserv list decis complaint pd european commiss complaint mr itali complain european ombudsman novemb failur commiss offer job background succeed gener competit organis commiss figur reserv list futur perman job commiss valid reserv list origin foreseen end decemb prolong time septemb mr offer auxiliari post declin offer person reason subsequ address commiss occas order seek job offer decemb valid reserv list expir prolong written telephon contact complain relev commiss servic ask job commiss substanc refer fact reserv list expir offer mr perman post complaint ombudsman mr claim letter address commiss remain unansw commiss offer perman post commun offer post inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state record receiv mr letter offer post commiss state legal put name reserv list number post legal oblig proce recruit person list alleg commiss fail commun decis offer mr job commiss state correspond receiv commiss commun prolong valid reserv list receiv commun prolong valid list decemb receiv commun natur mr implicitli inform list expir decemb commiss refer fact subsequ correspond mr made clear list longer constitut base recruit decis commiss declar receiv complain letter ombudsman instanc maladministr letter remain unansw lack job offer case law court justic fact person reserv list confer person entitl post commun institut regard evid procedur irregular part commiss ombudsman conclud appear maladministr relat aspect complaint remain question concern alleg complain inform expiri reserv list fact longer recruit basi list appear file valid list prolong time occas decemb mr inform prolong absenc prolong clear list expir view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case taxat remuner paid expert decis complaint bk dk pd european commiss complaint mr denmark complain ombudsman novemb commiss dealt correctli question liabl pai commun tax earn background complaint mr work china south america framework commun develop assist programm remuner receiv subsequ tax danish author consid taxat unjustifi approach commiss commiss share view essenc complaint commiss ensur danish author compli commun law mr opinion meant pai tax denmark claim commiss answer letter includ complaint lodg danish author februari commiss offic denmark duli forward letter commiss central depart inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state mr engag independ expert cover articl protocol privileg immun european commun offici servant commun exempt nation tax remuner paid commun commiss mr fall categori servant support opinion commiss refer council regul euratom ecsc eec march determin categori offici servant european commun provis articl paragraph articl articl protocol privileg immun commun appli commiss state inform mr opinion exempt nation tax lastli claim represent offic forward letter central depart brussel complain observ observ commiss comment mr maintain commiss interpret articl protocol wrong upheld complaint decis question complaint commiss correctli evalu mr complaint danish author articl paragraph protocol privileg immun european commun offici servant exempt nation tax salari wage emolu paid commun articl protocol council determin categori offici servant provis paragraph articl appli council regul euratom ecsc eec articl provis paragraph articl protocol privileg immun commun appli categori person come staff regul offici condit employ servant commun includ receiv compens provid case retir interest servic except local staff person receiv disabl retir survivor pension paid commun person receiv compens provid articl regul eec euratom ecsc case termin servic clear mr cover clear offici question cover phrase person come condit employ servant commun phrase appli servic commun fact appear relat specif legal document regul eec euratom ecsc lai condit employ servant servant cover condit employ temporari staff auxiliari staff special advis local staff clear time commiss emploi mr temporari staff auxiliari staff special advis local staff cover condit employ servant deem cover tax exempt articl commiss evalu case appear correct mr alleg commiss fail answer letter appear file wrote commiss obtain confirm servic perform china commiss provid confirm letter octob novemb complaint lodg februari danish author file show commiss respond letter date septemb decemb file show commiss represent offic neglig forward mr letter relev central depart brussel view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case select contractor call tender decis complaint jaon uk jma european commiss complaint decemb mr lodg complaint ombudsman behalf firm tasil alleg maladministr call tender organis european commiss select consult carri taci programm invit submit propos project relat develop tourist industri russia tasil act behalf consortium firm european countri lodg express interest commiss propos support russian government agenc tasil exclud tender list prepar commiss complaint contest exclus inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss contract servic kind question award call tender taci programm commiss act contract author servic director dg ia respons launch evalu decid tender case question result commiss evalu tender tasil includ shortlist consortia exclus tasil result standard select procedur commiss includ seri annex gener inform programm complet list express interest receiv tabl compar assess rel merit particip complain observ observ commiss comment mr refer unrival experi tasil consortium renew complaint unfair treatment decis decis ombudsman state commiss enjoi larg degre discret decid award contract invit tender discret justifi manifest error select procedur discret institut base decis object criteria review case commiss base assess number prima faci object criteria reflect tabl compar assess merit particip complain consortium show expertis compet field project evid commiss discret arbitrari discriminatori basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman decid close case contest recruit decis complaint pd european commiss complaint januari mr complain ombudsman vacanc publish june commiss vacanc establish career bracket la denomin post traducteur réviseur jurist head qualif applic complet legal train certifi univers degre depth knowledg dutch languag fair knowledg commun languag knowledg legal terminolog dutch experi translat revis juli mr appli post curriculum vita annex applic appear year mr work dutch translat divis court justic lawyer linguist princip lawyer linguist head servic regularli gave languag revis appoint languag revis la relev servic commiss interview mr eventu fill post applic happen colleagu mr court justic person appoint princip lawyer linguist la court justic complaint mr put forward main argument nomin colleagu contrari draft notic vacanc mr view colleagu consid job princip lawyer linguist experi revis notic request experi translat revis mr found support point view fact subsequ commiss chang notic vacanc kind effect applic experi translat revis state french dictionari le petit robert word experi mean practic habitud routin princip lawyer linguist occasion languag revis experienc colleagu account candid compar examin merit applic led result retain job support alleg mr refer fact colleagu experi lawyer linguist promot post princip lawyer linguist inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point substanc job descript forc court justic mention task revis post princip lawyer linguist post revis state princip lawyer linguist revis job descript mention translat text revis appoint author wide discretionari power fill post respect limit discretionari power fill post question complain observ observ commiss comment mr maintain substanc complaint decis take stand issu complaint place import recal job descript post question court justic commiss appear document submit task princip lawyer linguist court justic gener qualifi offici charg carri translat text revis case revis translat control terminolog document work specialis work linguist field particip profession train translat task languag revis court justic qualifi offici charg carri revis translat case translat text revis control terminolog document work specialis work linguist field particip profession train translat task traducteur réviseur jurist commiss state notic vacanc question check dutch version statutori text draft statutori text commiss legal agreement version text control present statutori text respect gener rule appli field carri research formal legist nation law appear job descript court justic vari consider question commiss background commiss handl matter assess question commiss account applic lodg princip lawyer linguist court justic fact notic vacanc establish applic experi translat revis recruit servic assess degre kind experi interest servic requir appear reason interest servic requir recruit servic gener consider applic formal job descript mention task revis appear document submit practic princip lawyer linguist court justic revis work regular basi formal job descript mention revis task princip lawyer linguist translat revis person appear justifi implic revis final notic career bracket post fill la lawyer linguist appli job appear commiss entitl account applic mr colleagu fact commiss subsequ amend standard notic vacanc sake clariti justifi conclus recal court justic highest author question commun law question commiss rightli assess merit applic appear element hand commiss transgress limit discretionari power hold field request prioriti automat applic senior depriv appoint author power vest case law court justic basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case unsuccess applic copernicu programm decis complaint pd european commiss complaint januari mr complain european ombudsman commiss wrongli reject applic lodg copernicu programm commiss programm cooper scienc technolog complaint forward commiss februari opinion commiss state mr applic qualifi rule forc requir applic concern particip establish member state mr applic involv particip establish itali commiss reject applic observ commiss comment mr maintain origin complaint basi ombudsman inquiri appear commiss decis mr applic made full accord rule applic element file commiss wrongli decid applic view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case commiss inquiri annual tax italian passport decis complaint dt european commiss complaint mr complain commiss fact itali oblig citizen pai special tax year italian passport februari commiss inform mr deal question apologis late answer letter inform receiv letter rais issu examin case carefulli take decis matter februari mr complain ombudsman commiss decis year answer inquiri ombudsman inquiri direct establish instanc maladministr commiss handl mr complaint complaint forward commiss march summari commiss comment basi parliamentari question citizen letter decid examin problem carefulli carri gener survei member state provid inform condit charg issu passport complain inform action commiss receiv answer member state march decis matter wrote mr letter commiss inform mr commun law requir member state issu passport ident card citizen fact itali impos annual tax passport compat commun law cost passport procedur issu fall compet member state commiss system issu passport imped free movement person light commun law commiss comment forward juli mr summari made observ commiss interest question free movement person examin problem proof point year delai decis italian passport base model european passport place foreseen stamp demonstr payment tax meant intent commun law exclud tax interpret justifi intern law consid passport document pass countri view fact member state impos kind tax tendenc ec treati cancel differ member state itali allow impos atyp tax duti commiss guardian treati begun infring proceed itali decis commiss handl complaint appear file complaint question member european parliament commiss conduct inquiri find member state procedur charg issu passport appear commiss examin annual tax passport italian citizen infring commun law commiss reach conclus infring commun law italian state cost passport procedur issu fall sphere commun compet exclus member state articl ec treati empow commiss begin infring proceed consid member state fail fulfil oblig treati basi find appear evid maladministr commiss deal complaint delai respond complain commiss wrote letter complain februari month ask inform justifi delai problem easi resolv examin case carefulli octob commiss letter complain inform inquiri member state letter decis matter complain view complex matter subject written question member european parliament receiv answer survei involv member state ombudsman reach conclus present case delai approxim year commiss reach final decis consid maladministr view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case reject call tender decis complaint pd european commiss complaint march mr complain ombudsman tender procedur commiss compani tender contract commiss provid servic relat drink water direct section tender document head expertis requir contractor state contractor demonstr wide breadth knowledg expertis proven track record field water scienc includ microbiolog toxicolog water sanitari engin essenti contractor possess depth knowledg drink water direct propos revis section head select criteria tender evalu stage tender met select criteria stage continu stage award stage criteria stage tender demonstr experi record water research field demonstr qualif citat previou work composit propos team includ curriculum vita letter januari commiss inform mr tender select januari januari februari mr ask commiss inform reason refus letter march commiss inform mr appli select criteria found compani lack experi water research field understood research develop design water treatment work mr find commiss respons satisfactori address commiss letter april commiss commun detail reason decis letter decis factor select mr tender continu commiss view compani lack experi water sanitari engin design water treatment work mr remain dissatisfi commiss stand complain ombudsman put forward alleg word experi select criteria quot interpret broad mean water research relat drink water direct commiss request experi need field sanitari water engin specif state tender document approach support fact drink water direct primarili dealt aspect drink water qualiti health aspect engin case compani experi water sanitari engin commiss assess wrong commiss act breach articl servic direct eec requir answer dai receipt written request reason reject applic tender inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point requir experi understood light expertis requir wide breadth knowledg expertis proven track record field water scienc includ water sanitari engin tender demonstr experi sanitari water engin relat drink water direct clear potenti contractor event ask commiss clarif commiss continu maintain mr compani requir experi area water sanitari engin qualifi area water research commiss answer mr letter due time reason decis complain observ observ mr maintain complaint state commiss offer compani compens damag lost opportun decis concern mr alleg crucial question select criteria commiss entitl account experi field water sanitari engin true head select criteria state gener term contractor experi water research field criterion read conjunct previou head expertis requir contractor inappropri experi relat requir laid expertis contractor wide breadth knowledg expertis proven track record field water scienc includ microbiolog toxicolog water sanitari engin appear commiss entitl account tender experi water sanitari engin evalu tender commiss assess compani capabl water research field element file assess carri properli mr alleg commiss fail observ time limit dai establish articl servic direct eec direct appli contract exceed relev threshold breach gener principl good administr commiss reason answer mr letter due time basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss basi claim compens award mr compani ombudsman close case procedur adjud call tender pakistan decis complaint jma european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman commiss alleg maladministr adjud call tender complain firm particip call tender publish govern pakistan project ala entitl rural vocat train project financ commiss firm propos relat part project packag demonstr trainer electron electr refriger chosen evalu committe accord technic specif complain ask commiss check irregular tender procedur action undertaken offici pakistan led annul bid result repli commiss wrote packag award compani mr wrote commiss assess decis tender procedur vitiat formal substant irregular complain suggest packag project award divid winner firm commiss reject possibl inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state govern pakistan author respons develop project assist technic group pakistani ministri labour intern labour organis ilo commiss monitor process select complain propos commiss explain offer accord technic specif reason train materi offer design demonstr purpos continu vocat educ environ ii materi accord technic specif iii inform complain compani unclear incomplet iv urgent request evalu committe complain compani request addit inform receiv repli respect complain request divid content packag commiss point submit propos complet packag state govern pakistan commiss line condit call tender underlin firm put forward propos content packag complain observ observ commiss comment mr state repli evalaut committe request inform view decis decis appear complaint support document inquiri conduct final adjud project made govern pakistan capac contract author decis base evalu report offer prepar evalu committe nation train bureau pakistani labour ministri ntb intern train centr intern labour organis itc ilo agre commiss commiss comment evalu report consid complain propos inadequ number ground review defici directli complain firm repli complain contest point ombudsman found select process carri conform rule call tender commiss appear good administr principl surveil process indivis packag advic commiss point compli rule call tender ombudsman conclud commiss breach principl good administr ombudsman close case contest grade offici decis complaint pd european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman grade commiss offici complaint graduat univers start work februari june commiss offici grade step success particip gener competit appoint administr februari grade step senior step februari grade decis object complaint complain ombudsman mr submit appeal commiss grade decis articl staff regul consid commiss wrongli appli decis octob grade complain correct applic decis meant commiss recognis profession experi decemb commiss recognis profession experi decemb reject argument set complaint legal background complaint articl staff regul offici recruit step grade appoint author take account train special experi post person concern addit senior grade exce month grade la la month grade detail rule grade laid mention decis octob articl decis impli offici year previou profession experi moment recruit grade step articl decis annex ii decis concern addit senior impli offici year previou profession experi grant month addit senior offici year previou profession experi grant month addit senior grade step annex decis establish except rule durat univers studi vari member state year lead distort grade measur reduc gap practic year year univers studi short degre studi year durat period profession experi account begin run year graduat univers studi long degre requir studi year durat profession experi account seventh year post secondari studi mr graduat decemb univers studi year durat view fact commiss count profession experi decemb mr consid profession experi count decemb grade step grade step substanc mr put forward rule annex short univers studi discriminatori nation member state univers studi short commiss abid decis octob context mr stress fact durat univers studi year fact year condens studi inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state aim decis octob establish number criteria ensur hand approach grade durat univers studi member state vari consider commiss felt justifi adopt measur reduc effect discrep career offici recruit wide geograph spread ensur treat equal practic commiss contest annex decis discriminatori applic decis commiss state review mr grade maintain decis correctli appli commiss stress aim annex reduc gap durat univers studi year reach aim impli mr case profession experi recognis decemb complain observ observ complain maintain substanc complaint decis concern principl equal treatment impli case law court justic ident situat treat differ situat treat ident crucial question appli principl establish ident situat hand profession experi consid independ consider durat univers studi peopl profession experi difficult justifi experi account simpli durat univers studi preced profession experi hand conced commiss discret decid deal discrep length univers studi commiss consid durat univers studi relev element account take decis grade offici evid reflect career account length univers studi implic offici member state durat univers studi short systemat career prospect offici member state univers studi long commiss appear entitl differ durat univers studi justifi treatment offici short univers studi offici long univers studi evid annex decis octob amount violat principl equal treatment recal court justic highest author question commun law applic annex concret case annex case short univers studi degre year studi profession experi account begin run year graduat mr graduat decemb word annex impli profession experi case count decemb hand annex presuppos shortest univers studi year durat aim reduc gap shortest univers studi longest year underli aim mr profession experi count decemb commiss decid interpret annex conform underli aim commiss appear entitl opt interpret recal court justic highest author question commun law basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr european commiss ombudsman close case admiss competit refus decis complaint pd european commiss complaint march mr complain ombudsman commiss refus admit competit februari commiss publish open competit base diploma oral examin establish reserv list post career bracket condit consider concern work experi applic termin educ entitl particip competit prove year work experi posit educ year field relat natur function competit natur function state notic leader commiss deleg intern organis vienna austria director gener foreign relat europ independ state common foreign secur polici foreign servic leader commiss deleg task repres commiss field compet activ ensur uniform implement commiss measur foreign affair observ deepen enlarg contact intern organis place establish maintain regular contact organis commiss servic applic profound knowledg commun polici function european union econom commerci polit aspect foreign affair lead team march mr appli post appear curriculum vita hold ph natur scienc year work scientist field usa franc germani work year austrian ministri research technolog current activ involv coordin supervis research field electron data process commun microsystem technic laser technic period undertaken month european commun appear charg ministri relat intern organis question relat inform technic commun select board inform mr decis particip competit form attach letter board consid possess year work experi posit correspond requir laid notic competit mr wrote select board review decis select board inform maintain decis found mr work experi lack relev diplomat experi relat polici area european union mr contest decis select board inform decis final termin work complaint mr claim select board reason admit competit inappropri contrari condit publish notic competit inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss maintain select board posit substanc stress select board decis mr case fulli cover word notic competit underlin select board explain mr reason work experi relev relat post fill complain observ observ complain maintain complaint ad reason select board admit competit draft transpar decis case law court justic select board wide discretionari power exercis power select board respect legal framework activ laid notic competit natur assess applic involv compar element crucial question case select board respect word notic competit appear condit relat work experi order admit competit applic need work relat intern organis possess profound knowledg commun polici select board interpret effect applic diplomat experi relev post fill involv relat polici area european union appear select board act accord notic alleg select board reason lack transpar recal case law court justic reason decis addresse judg proceed brought decis identifi reason decis base court justic state assess adequaci reason bear mind context reason true select board reason letter complain short reason state appear mr judg mr lodg legal proceed decis european ombudsman identifi point board found mr experi insuffici reason appear adequ basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear maladministr commiss ombudsman close case remark consider number complaint ombudsman receiv lack transpar procedur competit organis commun institut open inquiri initi matter novemb includ question commiss commun evalu criteria applic request court justic european commun recruit criteria select candid open competit decis complaint ep dt court justic complaint septemb mr complain european ombudsman exclus competit legal administr organis court justic cj applic august select board inform exclud fail prove good knowledg commun languag appeal select board reconsid decis foreign languag requir inform mr written test stage select select board establish averag univers mark inferior criterion establish competit point complain view criterion select candid unfound appeal select board confirm decis admit written examin basi mr complain long delai select procedur alleg discrimin decis select board establish minimum mark level consider profession experi year compani lawyer half year attornei inquiri comment court justic complaint forward court justic comment court explain select candid admit written test competit cj consist stage stage explain competit guid stage select board establish list candid met requir defin announc competit acquir titl degre profession experi linguist experi ag limit stage select board establish appli criteria evalu degre order decid candid admit examin evalu candid select board decid admit applic mr justif languag skill requir section iii notic competit complain request select board examin matter found document fact annex candidatur justifi knowledg requir languag skill mr applic stage select procedur select board decid exclud degre minimum mark establish criterion select board court comment view case fall mandat ombudsman staff matter concern procedur foreseen articl staff regul ad ombudsman inform mr action appeal court instanc complain observ observ mr argu written guid competit order import relev requir account select board select procedur competit complain insist dissatisfact length time select procedur decis admiss case scheme establish treati statut ombudsman admiss complaint determin ombudsman accord commun law articl statut complaint made ombudsman work relationship commun institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint procedur refer articl staff regul exhaust person concern procedur requir appli offici servant commun candid open competit offici servant commun candid open competit appeal court instanc accord articl staff regul altern candid complain european ombudsman mr chose complain ombudsman provis statut ombudsman impos complain oblig wait timelimit legal proceed exhaust complain began legal proceed ombudsman declar complaint inadmiss averag point criterion section vi notic competit gave select board discret choos select criteria mark obtain univers studi criterion explicitli refer paragraph unreason make choic basi pre establish mark averag criterion perfect time foreseen stage competit time select procedur section xii notic competit present estim fix schedul larg number candid particip type competit make postpon date initi foreseen test view find appear maladministr ombudsman close case case drop complain european commiss delai repli complain decis complaint bawa nl vk european commiss juli dutch law firm complain ombudsman behalf dutch compani commiss alleg failur repli complaint relat infring council direct eec netherland complaint forward commiss comment commiss state due misunderstand commiss servic delai aros measur improv intern procedur infring netherland commiss state legal basi bring formal action netherland commiss comment complain repli wish drop case ombudsman close case recruit wrong inform decis complaint lj pd european commiss octob mr belgian citizen complain ombudsman administr irregular fill post tri nation commiss develop project latin america claim commiss wrong inform qualif need fill post complaint forward commiss comment commiss state candid post receiv inform error prejud candid complain observ state commiss recognis complaint wellfound pursu matter view complain pursu matter ombudsman close case anti dump duti decis complaint pd european commiss april compani complain ombudsman imposit anti dump duti zinc prior notic director made inquiri duti impos spring inform duti impos immin week notic compani director contact commiss inform matter success complaint forward presid commiss commiss repli ombudsman receiv letter complain indic withdraw complaint compani time direct contact commiss ombudsman close case research refus inform decis complaint vk european commiss mr greek student complain ombudsman june request inform address commiss represent athen claim offic staff director document depart rude refus provid inform research student inquiri complain inform ombudsman longer wish pursu complaint director commiss represent appoint situat improv view fact complain longer wish pursu complaint ombudsman close case case close reason european parliament dismiss parliament decis complaint hs kt european parliament februari mr made complaint european ombudsman dismiss european parliament march complaint forward presid european parliament receiv comment parliament observ complain comment ombudsman decid continu inquiri case juli european parliament inform ombudsman complain initi legal proceed court instanc relat subject matter complaint copi plead case forward ombudsman alleg fact subject legal proceed ombudsman termin consider complaint juli accord articl treati establish european commun accord articl statut ombudsman outcom ombudsman inquiri carri point file action european parliament european commiss withhold commun tax european commiss european parliament freelanc interpret decis complaint rk ch pd mac ch pd avl fr jma european commiss european parliament mr ms ms complain separ european ombudsman withhold commun tax european parliament commiss remuner freelanc interpret complaint lodg februari juli novemb complain work number year freelanc interpret parliament commiss institut deduct commun tax remuner parliament adopt practic basi decis bureau parliament decis modifi articl rule applic servant assimil freelanc interpret auxiliari session staff commiss adopt practic mean agreement conclud associ international de interprèt de conférenc aiic complain live switzerland subject doubl taxat remuner paid swiss incom tax commun tax aiic agreement modifi repay nation tax commiss demand detail document nation tax paid complain argu requir violat privaci ombudsman inquiri complain ms mac ch pd ms avl fr jma began proceed commiss court instanc case proceed involv alleg fact complaint ombudsman accord articl statut ombudsman case complaint outcom ombudsman inquiri carri point file action ombudsman consid continu inquiri complaint submit mr rk ch pd take stand issu fact law court instanc case case ombudsman suspend consider complaint pend outcom case european commiss lack recognit medic degre public health spanish author decis complaint lmv es pd european commiss complaint june mr complain ombudsman refus spanish author recognis qualif award franc public health specialist alleg failur commiss ensur correct applic spain council direct eec complet medic degre franc mr sought recognis spanish author applic spanish author refus time relev commun legisl direct eec transpos spanish law direct eec subsequ modifi direct eec relev oblig laid articl remain unchang articl bi spanish implement legisl incorpor provis articl direct partial commiss start infring proceed spain matter reach stage send reason opinion infring procedur begun spain modifi origin implement legisl time complementari letter formal notic forward year procedur exist commiss servic assess spanish legisl contact meet spanish author inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state intent pursu infring proceed spain incorrect transpos direct eec action bring matter european court justic complain invit submit observ commiss comment inform suppli ombudsman appear mr petit subject european parliament committe petit parliament deal matter decis view fact committe petit deal mr petit ground ombudsman conduct inquiri complaint european ombudsman decid close case alleg discrimin intern competit decis complaint jbw bb european commiss mr particip intern competit european commiss pass written examin fail oral examin complaint ombudsman octob alleg unfair discriminatori question ask oral examin complaint forward commiss letter date februari commiss inform ombudsman mr submit appeal novemb decis select board accord articl staff regul appeal dealt articl statut european ombudsman complaint made ombudsman concern work relationship commun institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint procedur refer articl staff regul exhaust person concern time limit repli author petit expir appear procedur refer articl staff regul pend ombudsman close case pursu inquiri staff pension right local agent decis complaint dbr bb european commiss octob mr complain ombudsman problem relat recognit pension right base statu local agent commiss complaint forward commiss inform ombudsman mr submit intern appeal octob articl regim applic local agent servic benin articl statut european ombudsman complaint made ombudsman concern work relationship commun institut bodi offici servant possibl submiss intern administr request complaint procedur refer articl staff regul exhaust person concern time limit repli author petit expir appear condit met ombudsman close case pursu inquiri court auditor admiss time limit exceed decis complaint hdc fr pd ijh xd court auditor juli mr complain ombudsman court auditor event place ombudsman declar complaint inadmiss articl statut ombudsman fact complaint base complain year march mr made complaint court auditor alleg fact comment court auditor complain observ comment ombudsman determin complaint involv fact comparison earlier complaint close case inadmiss articl statut case settl institut european parliament recruit languag discrimin decis complaint ps vk european parliament mr belgian nation complain european ombudsman june call applic publish offici journal european commun vacanc surveil secur servic european parliament brussel call applic requir languag qualif french complain state appear discrimin flemish languag complaint forward european parliament comment parliament repli call applic post secur servic brussel withdrawn januari repli parliament forward complain invit submit observ wish observ receiv basi ombudsman inquiri appear parliament measur prevent languag discrimin call applic post secur servic parliament brussel european parliament appear settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case exclus invit tender decis complaint bb european parliament complaint januari ms de belgian citizen complain ombudsman exclus invit tender publish european parliament parliament publish intern invit tender topic accessibilité de handicapé au parlement européen complain offer due time holidai parliament letter tender explain ow administr problem recept mail parliament unabl open tender offer parliament request tender send copi offer deadlin return holidai ms de found deadlin elaps immedi fax parliament explain situat propos send copi offer mondai parliament repli state ms de authoris particip invit tender complain request invit tender annul ground maladministr relat procedur invit launch inquiri februari european ombudsman forward complaint presid parliament request comment ms de wrote ombudsman februari state parliament inform letter date februari decid annul origin invit tender launch invit futur ms de express satisfact thank ombudsman investig matter parliament comment parliament inform european ombudsman april invit tender annul notic offici journal european commun march invit launch futur parliament explain reason annul tender procedur unfortun cleric error octob open offer parliament mention inform ms de lawyer decis european parliament appear settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case amount paid traine decis complaint jma european parliament ms jointli complain complain januari european ombudsman amount paid traine european parliament correspond figur initi offer traineeship servic european parliament inform complain accept applic traineeship state receiv payment approxim bef month subsequ complain inform monthli payment bef european parliament justifi chang ground commun regul traineeship financi condit approv secretari gener parliament applic condit contest complain respons servic parliament complaint ombudsman result initi parliament reconsid posit decid pai complain amount origin offer ms inform ombudsman complain demand satisfi pursu complaint european parliament appear settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case acknowledg petit european parliament decis complaint ijh european parliament complaint june mr made complaint european ombudsman alleg european parliament fail acknowledg receipt petit address presid parliament april written june acknowledg inquiri parliament opinion juli complaint forward presid european parliament summari parliament made point mr steadi flow letter draft ident word request parliament encourag esperanto letter regist petit time committe petit conclud consider petit inform main decis parliament languag mr wrote time complain decis insist esperanto recent ask petit regist substanc word petit dealt correspond regist parliament petit forward committe petit correspond relat petit chairman committe petit intend consult committe meet june juli follow mr letter committe secretariat time acknowledg correspond steadi stream letter parliament year occas regist petit translat languag examin repli committe petit committe petit time deal matter meet june juli juli chairman committe petit wrote inform mr matter submit committe date inform outcom complain observ parliament opinion forward mr octob observ refer parliament opinion give full explan complaint satisfi committe petit deal matter state european ombudsman close file complaint decis basi opinion european parliament complain observ parliament appear settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case council european union conserv draft agenda council justic home affair minist decis complaint statewatch uk ijh council novemb decemb mr made complaint european ombudsman council ombudsman decis begin inquiri complaint council question compet ombudsman deal april ombudsman wrote council explain decis complaint fell mandat june council opinion merit complaint issu ombudsman compet dealt part summari deal ombudsman decis merit complaint end ombudsman inquiri complaint continu complaint complaint state council appear destroi agenda meet held council justic home affair minist year summari evid present mr wrote council request agenda meet group come committe agenda meet steer group work parti case repli council state agenda exist telex year wrote council similar request relat meet held justic home affair minist juli june repli council state relev document wrote council juli request reconsid polici keep document receiv repli council consid fail address request request made council decis ec decemb public access council document complaint ombudsman mr refer council regul eec euratom open public histor archiv forese transfer histor archiv document record administr histor claim agenda meet relat justic home affair matter essenti inform citizen establish histor record council activ document preserv inquiri council opinion complaint forward council januari ombudsman confirm compet deal matter council opinion merit complaint opinion state complaint refer conserv incorpor histor archiv telex deleg conven meet telex retain exist computeris system despatch telex approxim year period systemat classif document fall intern organis depart council gener secretariat record meet conven drawn sole basi agenda meet adopt begin meet basi draft agenda telex differ draft problem aros result request made mr draft agenda justic home affair jha meet systemat gener secretariat depart concern complain observ council comment forward mr june observ state complaint satisfi decis comment council respond complaint alter practic draft agenda justic home affair meet systemat gener secretariat depart concern complain observ state complaint satisfi appear systemat keep draft agenda justic home affair meet council satisfi complain ombudsman close case european commiss failur repli correspond decis complaint sw irl ijh european commiss complaint mr made complaint european ombudsman alleg commiss fail repli correspond letter european commiss offic dublin refus irish author recognis teach qualif acquir uk juli commiss offic dublin repli state letter forward offici secretariat gener commiss hear futur mr complain receiv commun commiss matter inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state secretariat gener forward mr letter juli director gener intern inquiri reveal letter dealt larg volum correspond depart concern deal matter relat citizen commiss regret inconveni caus ms point clear answer question ask found user guid gener system recognit profession qualif recognit teach qualif ireland commiss opinion state case fell scope council direct eec case substanti differ train acquir migrant requir host state requir adapt period aptitud test whichev person concern prefer opinion conclud state commiss contact nation coordin applic direct eec obtain inform mr case inform result commiss opinion forward mr invit submit observ wish observ receiv inquiri octob ombudsman servic contact mr telephon state receiv commun commiss promis opinion ombudsman servic contact commiss enquir posit novemb commiss ombudsman copi correspond mr case dg xv address irish author octob novemb repli irish author date novemb novemb commiss ombudsman copi letter address mr novemb correspond irish author letter advis contact relev nation author choic aptitud test adapt period letter gave address telephon fax number person contact letter state commun institut power revok administr decis nation author articl direct eec appeal nation court tribun decis opinion commiss state complain letter juli dealt larg volum correspond depart concern express regret inconveni caus unexpectedli larg volum correspond explain delai repli letter constitut accept reason failur repli present case commiss specif inform person concern repli commiss opinion point answer complain question found user guid gener system recognit profession qualif help commiss offic dublin refer complain user guid respons inquiri context ombudsman note august commiss dg provid servic call europ direct intend give quick answer gener request inform address commiss commiss letter complain novemb appear deal question rais letter juli view point commiss act settl complaint satisfactori ombudsman close case failur repli letter decis complaint ej irl kh european commiss juli mr complain ombudsman failur commiss repli letter remind juli address commiss represent offic ireland question insur letter transmit commiss brussel mr hear brussel remind final complain ombudsman complaint forward commiss comment commiss apologis answer mr letter time state failur due malfunct intern mail system commiss measur ensur follow incom mail commiss annex letter octob address mr repli issu put forward initi letter complain make observ commiss comment commiss recognis apologis error occur step put matter settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case handl complaint barrier social secur payment decis complaint pkp european commiss complaint juli ms complain european ombudsman commiss action failur italian author compli regul applic social secur scheme emploi person famili move commun ms arriv itali octob unemploi finland june year regist labour offic padua octob labour offic demand obtain work card local author order receiv unemploy benefit ms resid padua document issu end octob period italian author refus pai unemploy benefit ms complain demand italian author fulfil administr requir order receiv unemploy benefit contrari articl regul eec ms initi complain efta surveil author result finland access european union januari complaint transfer european commiss dg march wrote commiss problem inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment receiv complaint contact italian author inform appear progress made wrote italian ministri labour social affair relev author appli rule laid articl regul eec case subsequ commiss servic contact italian author telephon assur problem resolv immedi commiss view light similar case situat resolv futur action feel contact complain contact matter ombudsman commiss realis insuffici progress made contact italian author confirm matter resolv complain observ commiss comment forward mr subsequ inform ombudsman unemploy benefit claim paid march decis mr receiv unemploy benefit claim matter appear settl satisfactori complain ombudsman close case disclosur document infring procedur decis complaint gm dt european commiss complaint mr complain juli european ombudsman commiss fail make document infring procedur itali articl treati infring procedur concern award public contract build bridg messina strait mr profession interest develop road link messina strait design special bridg inform presid commiss mr delor idea ask support implement scheme commiss thank mr interest inform particip project type request italian govern italian author award contract compani major sharehold italian public hold compani iri award commiss open infring proceed itali mr wrote italian foreign ministri februari request copi relev correspond commiss copi letter forward commiss commiss repli italian author resolv issu italian foreign ministri repli consult commiss reveal document request made public inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment mr ask commiss directli document question commiss copi request address italian foreign ministri consult italian foreign ministri request commiss repli commiss servic concern confidenti appli made clear italian author free decid polici connect request address directli commiss grant document infring procedur except provid commiss decis public access document complain observ observ commiss comment mr state request fund compani origin select carri build work approv project carri complain express satisfact result appear put end problem thank ombudsman involv step decis complain observ matter resolv satisfactori appear unnecessari carri inquiri ombudsman close case failur repli letter decis complaint gl vk european commiss complaint mr work french nation statist institut inse complain ombudsman august commiss fail repli letter standard establish intern standard organis iso inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss commiss comment state mr letter address editori offic bulletin european union letter form note draw attent fact respons letter address secretariat gener requir respons commiss express regret ow problem intern coordin complain letter remain unansw letter repli deal matter substanc iso standard complain complain observ commiss comment forward complain invit submit observ wish repli complain ombudsman copi repli commiss letter repli complain express satisfact issu substanc dealt commiss letter express opinion issu substanc decis commiss acknowledg repli earlier complain letter apologis failur remark ombudsman appear european commiss comment complain observ commiss repli letter respond point substanc complain rais iso standard commiss appear settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case free movement person handl complaint commiss decis complaint fs uk kh european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman decemb commiss properli handl complaint lodg commiss refus denmark issu resid permit wife nation member countri inquiri ombudsman inquiri complaint complain continu correspond directli commiss appear settl matter satisfactori complain receiv commiss comment complain wrote ombudsman state longer wish pursu complaint limit put forward remark thought commiss complaint procedur improv futur decis commiss appear step settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case remark ombudsman complain remark improv administr procedur commiss futur ombudsman inform inquiri complaint led conclud gener examin commiss administr procedur deal complaint citizen member state failur fulfil oblig commun law april ombudsman initi initi inquiri possibl improv qualiti relev administr procedur commiss request inform decis complaint pd european commiss complaint februari mr complain european ombudsman commiss failur answer request inform mr tour guid foreign tourist austria austrian legisl impli tour foreign guid allow give explan background inform point object interest mr wonder compat freedom provid servic enshrin articl ec treati letter august address commiss view clarifi question receiv repli lodg complaint ombudsman inquiri commiss opinion complaint forward commiss opinion commiss state question rais difficult complex discuss year discuss final result adopt commiss work paper pend adopt document respons servic fail repli mr fact commiss apologis commiss state complain quot work paper relev materi complain submit observ decis appear european commiss comment commiss step settl matter satisfi complain ombudsman close case failur repli letter decis complaint pd econom social committe mr complain ombudsman econom social committe repli letter juli problem social secur payment greec ombudsman contact econom social committe repli trace mr letter offici charg answer mr object letter compet econom social committe mr inform euro ju network advis issu commun law relat social secur problem complain satisfi answer receiv ombudsman close case european agenc evalu medicin product emea registr veterinari drug list emea decis complaint vk european agenc evalu medicin product emea compani regist offic germani trade biolog veterinari medicin complain european ombudsman april emea refus evalu complain applic registr veterinari drug ground relev document arriv deadlin compani complain suffici notic deadlin letter complain inform ombudsman meet arrang london repres emea misunderstand parti solv complain express appreci ombudsman intervent thank work inform european ombudsman complain emea appear action settl matter satisfactori complain ombudsman close case friendli solut achiev european ombudsman european commiss recruit public name mark success candid competit decis complaint gs european commiss complaint mr particip competit organis commiss recruit assist administr grade letter date decemb commiss inform success letter inform mark receiv written test subsequ oral test minimum mark requir success candid decemb mr wrote commiss state exist distinct disproport mark obtain oral test compar written test request commiss provid list success candid mark obtain test list member select board conduct oral test vote cast candid examin letter date januari commiss declin provid inform request complaint ombudsman januari mr claim competit financ public monei recruit offici paid public monei commiss provid list success candid mark receiv request ombudsman check regular proceed competit oral test candid examin board led signific differ evalu mark award oral test properli reason light mark written test inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment made point candid admit written test subsequ admit oral test number success candid limit term notic competit mr inform receiv written oral test mark figur requir total point mr request list success candid mark obtain refus ground work select board confidenti involv assess charact person compar natur commun candid concern form mark compli request result obtain success candid receiv total mark mr opportun bring proceed court instanc complain observ mr observ commiss comment repeat claim disproport mark written oral test rais doubt accuraci repeat origin request ombudsman check regular proceed competit claim unaccept result competit financ public monei recruit offici paid public monei remain secret inquiri care consider commiss comment complain observ appear point made complaint answer ombudsman ask commiss inform reason list name success candid competit made public commiss repli includ point reserv list give candid automat entitl obtain job commiss success candid work job commiss harm current career prospect inform made public commiss practic make public reserv list success candid open competit accord staff regul work select board secret practic commiss publish name select board member board report ombudsman attempt achiev friendli solut accord articl statut ombudsman wrote commiss make summari point european union public commit transpar creat gener presumpt favour access inform import interest outweigh principl transpar repli ombudsman inquiri commiss explain refus disclos name success candid ground harm current career prospect appear commiss practic adopt union made commit transpar refer practic council european parliament commiss review commiss practic determin harm term loss transpar outweigh hypothet gain protect success candid current career prospect respons commiss accept complain allow consult list success candid competit commiss state futur notic announc competit intend publish list success candid complain inform commiss propos friendli solut respons state condit accept commiss provid mark obtain success candid competit commiss pai sum il cost pursu complaint issu european ombudsman ask commiss clarifi posit repli commiss reli summari settl case law effect view power select board evalu merit candid commun candid mark obtain satisfi requir select board give reason decis claim cost european ombudsman inform complain power award cost wish pursu matter address commiss directli decis refus suppli name member select board vote articl annex iii staff regul work select board secret secreci introduc view guarante independ select board object proceed protect interfer pressur commiss entitl refus complain request list member select board conduct oral test vote cast candid examin appear maladministr commiss relat aspect complaint public name success candid respons ombudsman suggest review practic order promot friendli solut commiss agre make complain list name success candid competit publish list futur competit commiss appear conclud definit harm caus term loss transpar refus publish name success candid outweigh hypothet gain protect success candid current career prospect agre publish name success candid competit commiss import step improv transpar appear settl aspect complaint satisfact complain public mark obtain success candid appear commiss intend maintain present practic inform candid mark minimum mark requir success candid justif posit commiss reli summari settl case law effect view power select board evalu merit candid commun candid mark obtain satisfi requir select board give reason decis commiss explain reason consid gener principl transpar appli case mark obtain success candid examin question public mark alongsid issu transpar forthcom initi inquiri european ombudsman recruit commun institut bodi circumst appear ground pursu inquiri aspect case regular proceed competit appear commiss comment candid admit written test subsequ admit oral test appear mark oral test express compar judgment candid select board accord case law court justic natur assess process disproport mark complain receiv written oral test disclos ground ombudsman question regular proceed competit complain claim cost european ombudsman power award cost complain conclus commiss entitl refus complain request list member select board conduct oral test vote cast candid examin agre publish name success candid competit commiss import step improv transpar appear settl aspect complaint satisfact complain question public mark success candid examin alongsid issu transpar forthcom initi inquiri european ombudsman recruit commun institut bodi natur assess process disproport mark complain receiv written oral test disclos ground ombudsman question regular proceed competit european ombudsman power award cost complain basi conclus ombudsman decid close case delai payment salari settl travel cost decis complaint lb nl pd european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman servic contract commiss contract termin disput aros pai travel cost background complaint mr start work commiss undisput commiss servic forward written contract mr signatur june mr sign return contract commiss contract sign commiss offici respons june contract stipul take effect period month date signatur termin parti month notic fax june commiss servic termin contract effect juli sign contract forward mr juli octob mr address invoic commiss invoic state pai includ travel cost ecu minu advanc ecu receiv total amount due ecu invoic base assumpt mr perform work dai ecu mr correct work dai perform period juli total amount due ecu contract stipul consider execut contractor task contract commun pai flat rate sum ecu amount calcul basi work dai ecu dai work ecu appear correspond annex complaint commiss posit mr invoic final state accept pai work dai perform june argument financi control commiss agre date approv commit propos june start date work point view commiss lead payment work dai satisfi commiss posit mr point view contract entitl flat rate sum independ question work dai perform ecu travel cost appear individu contract made specif provis gener condit annex contract draft commiss state reimburs travel subsist expens paid product support document includ receipt ticket appear correspond annex complaint commiss place consid travel cost cover contract commiss accept pai travel cost incur june argument choos date mention relat pai complaint mr claim commiss refus pai work travel cost june unground inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state contract sign june administr delai commiss pai commiss maintain unabl pai work dai perform commit propos approv june travel cost commiss state claim accept legal reason relev servic commiss complain observ observ complain maintain complaint ombudsman attempt achiev friendli solut mr complaint commiss comment complain observ ombudsman address commiss accord articl statut ombudsman letter commiss made summari point pai commiss put forward reason pai dai origin invoic argument intern financi control approv relev commit propos ombudsman notic commiss contest mr perform work dai travel cost commiss stand final detail legal reason lead opinion travel cost cover contract background ombudsman found examin file reassur commiss action attain high standard citizen entitl expect commun institut suggest commiss review posit view friendli solut respons commiss inform ombudsman propos mr settl outstand amount origin invoic offer mr accept decis ombudsman initi appear friendli solut complaint agre commiss complain ombudsman decid close case late payment translat servic decis complaint ws uk jma european commiss complaint novemb mr lodg complaint european ombudsman delai commiss settl invoic translat servic mr undertook translat english document guid de artisanat de la petit entrepris dan union européenn work complet end june mr invoic relev commiss servic accord complain contract payment made dai receipt invoic receiv payment deadlin mr remind commiss august octob commiss made payment novemb half month invoic issu complain mr ask ombudsman ensur commiss put end uncertainti surround right contractor oblig institut case late payment secur payment compens financi loss suffer inquiri commiss comment commiss long delai payment respons servic carri detail check qualiti translat long document page vacat period midst administr reorganis commiss note high qualiti translat apologis long delai payment compens state provis framework contract provid compens case late payment compens paid complain observ observ commiss comment mr insist commiss set gener mechan case late payment believ framework contract review provis incorpor order requir payment interest event delai dai limit settlement invoic accord articl statut ombudsman wrote commiss seek friendli solut ombudsman refer fact commiss recommend member state recognis creditor interest arrear nation level commun june late payment interest arrear commiss state creditor obtain interest late payment commiss refus compens mr appear inconsist ombudsman propos commiss appli polici state commun june case pai interest complain repli commiss state measur ensur payment interest late payment commiss readi offer mr gratia payment apologis inconveni caus delai payment ombudsman invit complain solut propos commiss repli complain accept commiss offer apolog mr express satisfact effort undertaken european ombudsman find friendli solut decis ombudsman intervent friendli solut complaint agre institut complain ombudsman close case case close critic remark ombudsman european commiss failur carri suffici check appoint bre repres decis complaint hgf uk european commiss complaint complaint submit european ombudsman octob mr toni cunningham member european parliament behalf constitu mr summari relev fact alleg mr mr design system soil stabilis introduc mr ran compani call cumbria intern trade centr citc mr show mr written agreement european commiss mr understood agreement mr contract repres commiss mr offer submit applic fund european commun invest partnership ecip scheme behalf mr compani applic soil stabilis system involv research partnership work pakistan india afghanistan mr told mr applic success obtain ecip monei respect pai mr receiv monei mr form view mr obtain divert ecip fund respect project soil stabilis system contact commiss telephon told offici ecip desk fund similar project malaya drawn question matter address mr mr subsequ told mr partner ecip offic assist obtain ecip fund divert mr claim ecip author check mr appoint repres fail properli appear document annex complaint written agreement mr commiss agreement appoint mr behalf citc bre bureau de rapproch de entrepris correspond inquiri complaint forward commiss summari made comment commiss awar mr alleg march step investig commiss anti fraud unit uclaf undertaken investig satisfi specif case rais mr commiss fund improperli request approv disburs court auditor made inquiri told commiss satisfi mr compani disburs fraudul ecip fund identifi commiss receiv request fund ecip scheme mr compani involv commiss receiv ecip applic involv mr applic identif invest project partner argentina chile approv financ mr misunderstood telephon convers commiss offici told fund project drawn deal mr commiss total reject alleg mr partner ecip offic uclaf undertaken doubl check confirm commiss reject statement ecip disburs mechan applic mr bre correspond accept view registr legitim compani factual inform provid capac dissemin bre cooper opportun enterpris area locat cumbria intern trade centr northern england area poorli cover bre correspond addit argument favour applic mr declar mr obtain commiss fund bre misrepres bre exclus scheme partner identif grant fund whatsoev commiss comment content bre agreement commiss bre correspond commiss comment forward mr cunningham mr solicitor observ receiv mr solicitor substanc observ maintain origin complaint decis introductori remark role european ombudsman treati empow european ombudsman inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi ombudsman inquiri complaint direct examin maladministr activ european commiss deal alleg maladministr rais question protect financi interest commun ombudsman mind role court auditor commiss anti fraud unit uclaf ombudsman seek duplic investig court auditor uclaf carri relat subject matter case ombudsman inquiri direct determin truth alleg fraud made case disburs procedur ecip fund complaint rais question prima faci case maladministr ecip fund intend applic submit behalf mr compani disburs procedur allow fund misappropri appear commiss comment commiss uclaf court auditor satisfi applic made gener appear commiss comment alleg fraud relat ecip fund disburs procedur cooper fulli investig uclaf court auditor ombudsman found evid maladministr relat aspect complaint inform suppli telephon mr commiss ecip desk origin complaint observ commiss comment mr state told telephon commiss offici question ecip fund address mr origin complaint state commiss offici monei soil stabilis project drawn evid telephon convers limit misunderstand appear explan differ account parti evid intent mislead neglig suppli incorrect inform ombudsman found evid maladministr relat aspect complaint commiss fail make suffici check bona fide bre correspond clear bre correspond author virtu bre agreement hold repres commiss relat applic ecip commun fund agreement bre correspond european commiss state bre instrument set oper commiss oper instrument local level reli network correspond correspond defin agreement person bodi approv commiss act local exclus entitl repres network bre correspond person approv commiss repres local level bre network oper commiss matter good administr practic commiss satisfi propos correspond fit person repres purpos bre network commiss comment complaint appear independ inquiri made appoint mr bre correspond behalf citc check citc regist compani normal administr practic deal previous unknown compani involv check seek refer import contract commiss compani individu involv act repres capac albeit limit purpos fact northern england area poorli cover bre correspond justifi commiss fail make inquiri bona fide person appoint repres purpos bre network appear commiss fail make suffici enquiri appoint mr bre repres conclus basi inquiri conduct ombudsman appear make critic remark bre correspond person approv commiss repres local level bre network oper commiss matter good administr practic commiss satisfi propos correspond fit person repres purpos bre network european commiss fail make suffici enquiri seek refer approv mr behalf cumbria intern trade centr bre correspond repres local level bre network oper commiss aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case measur commiss assist portugues custom agent entri forc intern market decis complaint apf po ef po european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman novemb allegedli ineffici action commiss protect interest portugues custom agent complain entri forc intern market decemb neg effect portugues custom agent due specif factor relat sector portug privat natur sector heavili regul govern complain view measur adopt commun tackl problem inadequ scope limit amount fund involv complaint state measur cover area portugues custom agent carri work porto lisbon part commun extern border complianc specif requir initi relev portugues legisl mr petit european parliament subject petit take consider amount aid european commiss foreseen sector committe petit decid close case complaint ombudsman mr argu act requir commun incur extra contractu liabil mr complain report matter commission pinheiro juli receiv repli inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment acknowledg serious problem custom agent entri forc intern market restructur sector primarili respons member state import problem led commiss support nation effort accompani measur consist group action individu action european social fund ii action region develop fund interreg initi iii action intend specif sector council regul eec initi budget ecu million ecu million intend portug respons portugues author chose aid system implement regul mean assist system geograph area exclud interreg region porto lisbon receiv fund commiss state complain fulli inform initi publish offici journal portugues republ group concern support type fund chosen fund alloc initi commiss argu amount agre initi respons ec budgetari author enjoi complet discret matter complain written commission pinheiro respons commiss servic dg inform unabl repli letter complain observ observ commiss comment complain insist commiss realis lack effect type aid chosen portugues author regul eec portugues commiss agent benefit assist situat contrast countri belgium franc netherland hand portugues govern initi improv situat mean earli retir scheme portugues author claim assist success respons portugues agenc conclud portugues offici commiss agent benefit interreg scheme receiv assist regul eec conclus mr consid commiss principl subsidiar elud respons european ombudsman grant compens damag suffer decis exercis commiss respons matter commiss respons articl ec treati account extent effort economi show differ develop sustain period establish intern market ii propos provis commiss consid assist custom sector primarili respons member state appear consid undertak commun support measur inquir instanc maladministr european ombudsman seek determin disput effect adequaci commun polici issu polit judgment necessarili involv commiss action discharg respons appear evid maladministr relat aspect case ombudsman note european parliament posit matter adopt critic resolut septemb novemb jackson report novemb claim compens complain ask ombudsman recognis obtain compens commun damag suffer portugues offici commiss agent view paragraph inappropri examin claim ombudsman note articl ec treati court justic compet award damag contractu liabil court instanc possibl area custom agent failur answer complain letter complain report situat commission pinheiro answer comment commiss justifi lack answer fact compet servic dg receiv report treati commiss singl legal entiti depart commiss consid independ bodi part singl administr structur commiss power regul intern organis think fulfil task intern organis justifi failur repli correspond receiv citizen accord principl good administr present case complain expect correspond address portugues commission direct compet servic repli aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss power regul intern organis think fulfil task intern organis justifi failur repli correspond receiv citizen accord principl good administr present case complain expect correspond address commission direct compet servic repli aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case recruit unreason disproportion measur candid decis complaint ms pd fr european commiss complaint mr french portugues nation complain ombudsman januari alleg european commiss wrongli withdrawn job offer temporari employ agenc put blacklist agenc put forward futur temporari employ commiss appear file decemb temporari employ agenc mr contract work commiss dai grade assist director gener mr present commiss staff depart decemb ask sign curriculum vita write undersign certifi honour inform true complet curriculum vita establish form purpos inform file requir effect offici deal file disappear return state mr curriculum vita correct reason declar year univers translat diploma appear commiss file year master degre appli languag fact commiss staff depart decid complain envisag dai contact temporari employ agenc order annul contract instruct put forward job commiss notic inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state year diploma qualifi applic grade job question year diploma disqualifi put forward mr manifestli deliber conceal fact full univers degre year diploma meant curriculum vita faulti omiss sign document faulti omiss impli breach principl loyalti inher relat public author agent reason deliber omiss commiss suppos partli basi complain statement due exclus competit commiss organis job categori commiss exclud competit accord practic ground full year univers diploma commiss recognis practic held illeg court instanc mr exclus competit ground illeg chang commiss view infring principl loyalti legal basi principl commiss put forward principl expressli state staff regul impli relat public servant context refer decis court instanc case william court auditor articl condit employ servant underlin import fals inform commun legisl complain legal right job offer commiss state legal relat agenc put forward temporari job public privat bodi commiss breach contract mr contract commiss final observ commiss state instruct temporari employ agenc put mr forward job commiss longer exist complain observ observ commiss comment complain maintain substanc commiss dealt case wrongli unfairli insist fact commiss entitl compar inform submit applic curriculum vita document submit person previou occas claim exist instruct temporari employ agenc put forward job commiss mr obtain written confirm agenc effect complain agenc reluct give write fear commiss decis ombudsman firstli note awar rule prevent commiss check correct inform suppli curriculum vita measur commiss mr case remark uncontest mention year univers diploma curriculum vita submit equal uncontest diploma relev whatsoev job contract establish commiss servic qualifi failur mention year diploma fault omiss result job envisag agenc told put forward job commiss question complaint rais reaction commiss reason proportion materi assess question mr failur mention year diploma intent justif measur adopt commiss invok principl loyalti appli relat institut public servant refer case william court auditor state commun legisl attent fals inform suppli context recruit refer articl condit employ servant ombudsman comment case william court auditor concern offici spread slander declar compli oblig articl staff regul articl condit employ servant concern temporari staff clear element law appli directli mr case engag agenc dai work articl appli case note articl concern fals inform mr curriculum vita inform contrari truth profession life give rise curricula vita elabor extens entail qualif short version fals curriculum vita submit incomplet place fals inform entail sanction articl establish fals inform furnish determin factor agent engag commiss bear whatsoev decis engag year diploma appear mention year diploma irrelev conclus background appear make critic remark measur commiss appli complain unreason disproportion commiss withdrawn job offer mr ground submit fals curriculum vita mention year univers diploma issu instruct employ agenc put forward job commiss fact secretariat gener commiss assur instruct withdrawn ombudsman found ground investig close case failur adequ step inform extern staff posit decis complaint kt european commiss complaint mr work systran machin translat project complain march ombudsman commiss summari relev fact complaint mr offer year contract linguist programm compani contract european commiss develop systran machin translat system mr work project systran develop work carri luxembourg seri consecut contract award success separ compani period develop team mr part work continu project employe compani contract develop work commiss contract award compani compani employ develop team bodi claus commiss contract requir systran develop staff left free move contractor commiss decid emploi fix vacat salari staff commiss plan reduc involv systran develop project result develop staff face redund basi fact mr complain european commiss moral respons legal liabl develop team luxembourg order work institut trust face redund claim commiss envisag institut framework develop team servic translat centr bodi european union inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point commiss dg xiii investig domain machin translat earli activ specul carri rule appli develop project seri contract suppli servic financ multilingu action plan year highli specialis personnel need proceed call tender chang contractor personnel remain unchang year avail fund depend polit decis commun budgetari author award fund contractor subject complianc procedur laid financi regul relev rule contract conclud limit period exceed year view factor involv project depend financ commun budget expect fund continu indefinit systran project spent unusu long period develop phase project unusu commiss plai promin role user finish product work project warn chang word employ contract includ claus time contractor result perform task contract pretend obtain moral engag appoint staff member commiss servic conclus expert panel present futur machin translat commiss project staff place recommend diversifi field languag engin reli exclus commun fund commiss explain opportun diversif contractor staff number occas complain observ observ commiss comment mr restat origin claim detail observ contain number addit point includ summari commiss guidelin rule conduct relat extern contractor supplier servic prevent abus nepot limit length contract year commiss deliber temporari systran contractor circumv time limit servic systran staff contractu claus quot commiss comment refer contractor develop staff develop staff consid commiss de facto employ develop staff deem actual contractor commiss incur legal oblig develop staff luxembourg law decis claim commiss envisag institut framework develop team recruit offici servant european commun carri accord procedur purpos laid staff regul recruit staff extern contractor servic longer requir commiss accord procedur purpos laid staff regul claim commiss oblig provid institut framework systran develop team servic translat centr bodi european union sustain unusu long develop period systran project rule exist restrict length time staff compani provid servic specif programm extern staff work commiss premis rule specif intend prevent establish de facto employ relationship framework staff regul breach rule constitut instanc maladministr appear inquiri conduct european commiss work develop staff systran translat system separ compani year commiss accept comment period question unusu long basi evid ombudsman breach rule matter good administr commiss ensur extern staff made awar employ statu rule govern extern staff case extern staff emploi unusu long period develop import product commiss end user commiss respons posit step avoid forese danger extern staff misl futur prospect materi ombudsman appear commiss fail adequ step ensur systran develop staff made awar career plan reli continu systran programm ombudsman inquiri complaint reveal evid career systran develop staff suffer result unusu long period systran develop ombudsman find relat specif period end ombudsman pursu friendli settlement aspect case claim commiss oblig develop staff luxembourg law claim commiss oblig develop staff luxembourg law rais question nation law involv disput fact interpret matter dealt effect court compet jurisdict possibl hear testimoni evalu conflict evid issu fact relev nation law circumst inquiri claim european ombudsman justifi conclus basi find appear make critic remark matter good administr commiss ensur extern staff made awar employ statu rule govern extern staff case extern staff emploi unusu long period develop import product commiss end user commiss respons posit step avoid forese danger extern staff misl futur prospect materi ombudsman appear commiss fail adequ step ensur systran develop staff made awar career plan reli continu systran programm ombudsman inquiri complaint reveal evid career systran develop staff suffer result unusu long period systran develop ombudsman find relat specif period end ombudsman pursu friendli settlement aspect case ombudsman close case respons commun financ project life programm decis complaint aldm es pd european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman april behalf citi council isaba vallei navarra spain dg xi commiss factual situat underli complaint result commiss action protect brown bear live pyreneean region financi aid life programm local region organis recipi commun aid discuss establish cooper agreement council vallei roncal agre measur set agreement effect limit council control manag natur resourc area result citi council isaba vallei part vallei roncal decid part action financ life programm posit citi council criticis dr publish statement presum reflect concern commiss servic complain wrote occas dg xi request inter alia citi council isaba vallei consid part commun initi relat protect brown bear council manag initi place boundari ii dg xi forward citi council decis report prepar commiss servic inform publish dr made critic remark posit citi council complain alleg commiss properli respond request inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari comment commiss repli issu rais mr letter mr commiss inform issu rais concern member state exclus order implement commun natur protect polici commiss cooper author design member state applic subsidiar principl author respons nation bodi issu relationship commiss servic dr scientif reput held high esteem commiss comment forward mr invit submit observ wish observ receiv decis basi inform european ombudsman reach conclus potenti particip citi council isaba vallei select manag life project regul eec life programm place member state intermediari role commun parti main respons establish prioriti potenti project follow larg entrust member state special posit member state coordin role nation author affect implement manag commun financ project role limit commiss respons entiti individu affect commun financ project properli inform natur financi role channel nation level deal observ ombudsman consid repli european commiss request complain convei power institut implement life programm nation channel complain address solut problem parti public statement citi council isaba vallei comment commiss state servic relationship dr ombudsman inquiri reveal evid contradict commiss statement conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss respons entiti individu affect commun financ project properli inform natur financi role channel nation level deal observ ombudsman consid repli european commiss request complain convei power institut implement life programm nation channel complain address solut problem aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case late payment fee expens failur answer correspond decis complaint ah uk ijh european commiss complaint mr complain ombudsman excess delai payment fee expens work undertaken safeti health committe mine extract industri date complaint mr receiv payment invoic submit decemb contract stipul final payment dai mr complain fax matter answer inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss comment invoic issu complain septemb compli budgetari rule complain submit revis invoic begin financi year chang depart concern recomm financi procedur commit stage appropri requir laps end year payment contract delai administr reason final made half commiss state regard dialogu offici complain inform suppli depart deal matter late provid detail explan complain observ commiss comment forward mr summari observ made point comment dealt question fee due contract delai pai expens commiss detail explan delai pai fee revis invoic submit post fax decemb begin fee final receiv octob month submiss invoic commiss offer recompens delai pai fee expens inquiri commiss comment complain observ appear number aspect complaint remain unansw ombudsman wrote commiss enclos observ commiss propos offer financi compens repli commiss apologis delai final payment expens ii undertook make effort ensur delai occur futur iii state offer ecu compens delai mr confirm ombudsman accept satisfi compens payment state commiss offer compens made april accept april assur payment made maximum dai payment fact made june mr express complaint lead improv effici commiss benefici posit decis late payment expens commiss acknowledg apologis unjustifi delai payment expens complain paid compens delai aspect complaint appear settl commiss satisfact complain late payment balanc fee time origin complaint balanc fee due contract paid basi fact present complain commiss confirm contradict balanc final paid month submiss relev invoic contract payment made dai commiss offer satisfactori explan delai apologis aspect complaint upheld commiss fell standard good administr make payment month term contract complain failur answer correspond commiss appear acknowledg failur deal satisfactorili correspond complain commiss offer satisfactori explan failur occur apologis aspect complaint upheld commiss fell standard good administr fail repli correspond complain conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss fell standard good administr make payment month term contract complain fail repli correspond aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark european ombudsman european ombudsman note commun commission gradin liikanen agreement presid time limit payment commiss interest delai payment sec june appear commun commiss seek reduc delai make payment propos pai interest delai occur ombudsman review situat complaint commiss late payment fee expens order envisag initi inquiri subject alleg infring direct handl complaint lodg commiss decis complaint dh dk pd european commiss complaint mr denmark complain ombudsman june commiss properli dealt complaint lodg danish author complaint commiss alleg danish author infring direct eec fail transpos articl regul eec fisheri sector answer mr commiss state examin complaint led establish infring commun law inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari comment commiss object complaint involv decis commiss articl ec treati establish case law commiss discret respect preclud possibl privat person requir bring case court justic decid engag procedur case commiss act power conform case law court object provis direct complain alleg denmark infring lai detail condit grant financi aid case member state decid establish scheme financi aid denmark establish scheme financi aid infring concern articl regul eec establish case law member state entitl transpos provis regul regul directli applic law member state complain observ observ complain maintain complaint ask ombudsman initi judici proceed denmark decis assess complaint ombudsman firstli recal ec treati empow inquir instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi ombudsman entitl inquir activ nation author bring judici proceed member state commiss refer comment discretionari power articl ec treati irrelev commiss comment consid infring denmark case question aris discret bring proceed articl commiss assess complaint ombudsman recal highest author interpret commun law court justic element hand case made appar commiss assess wrong commiss handl complaint appear commiss dealt provid mr answer alleg commiss provid mr reason conclus denmark infring provis question complain ombudsman provid reason earlier complaint ombudsman arisen ombudsman made critic remark commiss effect made reason complain answer complaint commiss eventu provid complain reason investig justifi ombudsman close case commiss respons intermediari organis decis complaint cj uk ijh european commiss complaint mr chairman committe organis world disabl sail championship uk august novemb appli organis base netherland fipa foundat intern cooper project activ humanitarian affair grant support event march fipa offer financi aid european commiss equal total allow expenditur maximum ecu offer subject condit includ public acknowledg commiss support submiss audit account novemb payment made commiss receiv approv account mr ask fipa payment advanc order avoid interest charg loan request refus arrang loan novemb mr submit audit account fipa spite repeat telephon call payment made payment smaller sum maximum origin offer view delai organis committe final decid make arrang settl outstand loan inform fipa need grant aid mr dr carolin jackson member european parliament behalf complain retrospect payment grant aid lead unnecessari extra cost unfair commiss demand public acknowledg give definit promis provid fund payment full amount due wrongli refus unnecessari delai make payment inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss commiss began comment point frequent intermediari organis fipa manag aid programm summari commiss comment aspect complaint mr inform fipa interest loan includ deficit side organis account happi sign contract ahead appli financi assist claus requir public recognit commun aid standard practic definit promis provid fund organis concern respect term contract basi account submit fipa payment sum initi grant mr ecu result profit defin surplu incom expenditur forbidden articl fipa convent commiss claus mr contract fipa reserv waiv financi aid statement incom expenditur justifi utilis financi aid avoid make profit previous made clear oral mr fipa fipa paid mr advanc sum initi grant ecu mr offer final payment ecu balanc amount grant aid offer minu appar profit shown account advanc receiv mr refus accept final payment offer contract commiss fipa financi statement submit decemb fact receiv septemb delai knock effect organis await payment fipa respons delai lai primarili fipa late commiss decid appli exist arrang payment financi assist strictli individu organis submit financi statement fipa readi fipa pass dg commiss satisfi account correct commiss pai sum fipa turn pai organis arrang heavi administr burden commiss servic financi servic dg decid implement method financi year case longer dealt individu basi fipa receiv advanc contribut receiv balanc submit account fipa forward mr financi statement commiss arrang appli arrang appli dg scrutinis financi statement instruct commenc scrutini exercis fipa activ report detail account submit mr repeat telephon enquiri made fipa commiss commiss express regret delai state problem case rare commiss state fipa commiss learnt case explicit commun potenti problem aris complain observ mr observ includ summari point duti charit organis run affair cost effect includ take increas cost bill paid organis taxpay accept commiss attitud point result delai fipa commiss final payment offer month organis close complet work possibl accept commiss apologis delai occur decis retrospect payment contract complain fipa provid retrospect payment grant aid appear fipa entitl refus make advanc payment maladministr relat aspect complaint complain observ rais gener issu retrospect payment result increas cost commun taxpay financi condit commun grant aid commiss compli financi regul includ requir sound financi manag commiss activ subject supervis regard court auditor european parliament appear ground ombudsman inquir gener issu requir acknowledg commun grant aid appear standard practic requir public recognit commun grant aid commun grant aid paid accord term contract promis fund condit definit appear commiss comment consid fulfil condit control recipi unfair commiss requir public recognit condit commun grant aid fulfil condit control recipi appear maladministr relat aspect complaint amount grant paid letter date june mr thank fipa payment advanc state organis committe decid close account made altern arrang settl outstand loan longer requir balanc grant fipa appear exist contractu disput mr fipa commiss ombudsman examin deal complain amount grant aid payabl commiss act accord normal standard good administr behaviour includ clear legal basi action comment commiss explain basi final payment offer calcul amount origin grant reduc amount equal amount mr account show incom exceed expenditur profit justifi reduct commiss refer articl fipa convent commiss claus complain contract fipa state fipa made clear mr oral avoid make profit provis contract fipa commiss provid legal basi reduc payment due contract fipa mr claus mr contract fipa requir waiv financi aid statement incom expenditur justifi utilis financi aid note paragraph appear commiss comment consid fulfil condit grant aid contract control recipi inconsist approach interpret claus contract confer fipa power reduc grant refer condit made clear recipi advanc commiss claim avoid make profit made clear fipa oral contradict mr normal principl good administr behaviour requir condit impos offer grant aid mention write author concern satisfi condit commun recipi grant appear commiss fell normal standard good administr behaviour case reli exclus oral commun condit obviou oral commun provid legal basi contractu valid condit commiss succeed demonstr action relat aspect case clear legal basi administr delai make payment comment commiss acknowledg organis await payment affect fact fipa account submit decemb submit septemb commiss respons delai lai primarili fipa appear commiss repli specif case complain delai occur arrang introduc commiss approv account commiss fipa forward mr financi statement commiss arrang appli arrang dg scrutinis financi statement arriv instruct wait fipa submit account commiss mr repeat telephon enquiri matter made fipa commiss comment commiss express regret delai occur remark ombudsman appear conclus commiss state comment fipa commiss learnt case explicit commun potenti problem aris basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark normal principl good administr behaviour requir condit impos offer grant aid mention write author concern satisfi condit commun recipi grant appear commiss fell normal standard good administr behaviour case reli exclus oral commun condit obviou oral commun provid legal basi contractu valid condit commiss succeed demonstr action relat aspect case clear legal basi aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark commiss comment case point frequent intermediari organis manag aid programm number point commiss comment interpret impli intermediari organis fail act accord normal standard good administr behaviour commiss respons failur cooper ombudsman inquiri essenti commiss failur compli normal standard good administr behaviour occur includ make clear failur occur intermediari organis commiss servic commiss remain respons qualiti administr carri intermediari organis recruit criteria evalu disclosur name corrector decis complaint aeka fin ijh european commiss european parliament complaint june central union special branch akava central trade union academ profess finland complain ombudsman recruit finnish translat assist translat central union state altogeth translat work commiss represent helsinki particip open competit organis jointli european commiss european parliament reject central union complain candid unabl obtain inform criteria evalu requir select corrector name made public inform receiv translat finnish french treat sever translat select oral examin increas transpar order protect candid legal right ensur equal treatment central union note purpos economi reason examin reject candid script organis competit inquiri complaint forward commiss parliament commiss comment summari commiss made point translat commiss represent helsinki recruit basi written translat test interview open competit basic principl underli open competit equal treatment candid competit select board appoint work independ confidenti select board compos repres administr staff committe order protect independ select board avoid extern pressur ident member select board disclos select board appoint corrector written test order assur high qualiti assess select board appoint compet experienc linguist corrector examin paper assess independ corrector anonym candid assur mark written test parliament comment parliament made summari point select board correct candid script imparti corrector evalu script basi criteria evalu establish select board commun result obtain suffici reason reject candid competit question reason candid complain alleg degre difficulti languag correspond fact languag treat equal alleg number success translat finnish french correct number consider higher disclosur ident member select board corrector candid consist confidenti work select board staff regul establish case law provid confidenti enabl select board work independ imparti parliament rule select corrector parliament accept central union suggest upgrad mark award competit case reject candid possibl particip competit organis end complain observ observ central union maintain complaint parliament comment union state request upgrad mark examin decis criteria evalu appli competit select board accord case law court justic principl good administr behaviour provid applic reason element understand decis ombudsman consid insuffici central union request commiss parliament gave detail inform criteria evalu select board ombudsman receiv number complaint field recruit commun institut complaint concern lack transpar procedur thing complain complain obtain inform criteria evalu request articl treati establish european commun european ombudsman empow conduct inquiri initi relat instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi virtu provis open initi inquiri novemb procedur commiss recruit personnel inquiri ombudsman draw commiss attent fact commun inform criteria evalu applic commiss consider increas transpar recruit allevi work select board deal queri complaint applic disclosur name criteria select corrector present state commun law legal basi commiss parliament oblig disclos name criteria select corrector candid request part initi inquiri ombudsman investig commiss envisag take measur order disclosur name corrector candid concern choic languag equal treatment candid ombudsman inquiri reveal suffici evid instanc maladministr commiss parliament treatment candid base choic languag conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark select board accord case law court justic principl good administr behaviour provid applic reason element understand decis aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark ombudsman inquiri complaint complaint recruit personnel initi gener investig matter novemb ombudsman open inquiri initi procedur commiss recruit personnel recruit procedur open competit decis complaint al fin kt european commiss complaint june ms complain ombudsman procedur commiss recruit competit particip open competit candid invit oral examin reserv list juli commiss inform ms result mark obtain august ms wrote chairman select board request mark examin copi correct examin paper ms complain ombudsman receiv repli letter august select board refus provid copi correct examin paper inform criteria evalu grade scale appli select board inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point notic competit foresaw maximum applic reserv list candid invit oral examin success written test mark award select board meant ms candid letter date june ms state letter commiss august examin file request examin paper return commiss recruit unit examin ms file find letter august ms wrote chairman select board enclos copi letter august commiss repli letter septemb letter commiss apologis delai repli ms letter complain observ ms maintain complaint annex certifi copi receipt regist mail date august letter address chairman competit european commiss dg ix ms point ask examinaton paper return mention commiss opinion copi correct examin paper evalu order enabl familiaris analys futur decis loss candid letter complain provid ombudsman certifi copi receipt regist mail letter august commiss state opinion found complain letter august principl good administr requir letter arriv commiss answer fact commiss lost complain letter august constitut instanc maladministr ombudsman drew commiss attent fact make instanc occur futur copi examin paper staff regul provid competit select board appoint work independ confidenti present state commun law legal basi commiss oblig disclos copi correct examin script candid european ombudsman receiv number complaint field recruit commun institut complaint concern lack transpar procedur thing complain complain obtain copi correct examin script request articl ec treati ombudsman empow conduct inquiri initi relat instanc maladministr activ commun institut bodi virtu provis open initi inquiri novemb procedur commiss recruit personnel part initi ombudsman investig commiss envisag take measur order disclosur copi correct examin script candid concern criteria evalu appli select board select board accord case law court justic principl good administr behaviour provid applic reason element understand decis ombudsman consid insuffici commiss complain request provid detail inform criteria evalu select board ombudsman drew commiss attent fact commun inform criteria evalu candid commiss increas transpar recruit procedur consider allevi work select board deal queri complaint candid conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr requir letter arriv commiss answer fact commiss lost complain letter august constitut instanc maladministr ombudsman drew commiss attent fact make instanc occur futur select board accord case law court principl good administr conduct provid applic reason element understand decis ombudsman consid insuffici commiss complain request provid detail inform criteria evalu select board aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark ombudsman inquiri complaint complaint recruit personnel initi gener investig matter novemb european ombudsman open inquiri initi procedur commiss recruit personnel recruit inform applic decis complaint gr vk european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman lack inform consider delai competit procedur commiss complain particip competit post field biotechnolog receiv acknowledg receipt month person document period year receiv inform commiss regular request inform recruit procedur result send receipt form complain stress select procedur appear lengthi doubt procedur carri correctli file properli examin inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state select procedur meant establish reserv list temporari agent list enabl servic commiss choos candid candid legal claim invit interview success particip claim emploi delai due larg number particip problem origin composit select board mr alleg file properli examin unfound select board inspect applic file separ complain observ complain made point commiss act period year research sector constantli progress applic post field date qualif consider delai select procedur incomprehens complain point view current employ situat gener notif vacanc vagu job descript initi flood applic commiss expect high number applic measur deal decis inform ombudsman appear februari onward complain receiv inform applic particip natur interest develop select procedur case delai part good administr behaviour inform candid current state procedur reason amount time candid specif request inform repeat send acknowledg receipt letter meet inform commiss acknowledg delai occur state complain inform person result select committe basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark good administr behaviour repli request due time present case complain receiv inform period half year complain inform commiss current situat select procedur inquir commiss awar fact applic repli notif vacanc dealt matter appropri applic inform situat reason time aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case refus public access document decis complaint tc irl kt european commiss complaint mr ireland complain ombudsman juli refus european commiss grant access exchang letter commiss offic consum affair ireland mr written commiss alleg consum affair offic ireland breach commun law oblig result complaint commiss exchang correspond consum affair offic ireland occas complain ask commiss copi correspond deni access summari commiss put forward reason refus access decis public access commiss document expressli envisag document origin commiss consum affair offic letter commiss applic refer author consum affair offic request confidenti commiss letter consum affair offic commiss maintain disclosur harm commiss interest confidenti proceed ground commiss refus access decis public access commiss document inquiri ombudsman determin issu rais mandat concern request access document possess european commiss commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss maintain reason origin advanc refus access letter consum affair offic commiss commiss letter consum affair offic commiss review origin decis light year experi appli polici access document consid acced mr request access letter enclos commiss comment complain observ observ commiss comment complain ask consum affair offic copi letter commiss deni access question polici public access document differ countri decis assess complaint ombudsman recal ec treati provis transpar gener rule applic commun institut bodi grant gener public access document recal jurisdict commun institut bodi nation polici public access document mandat commiss council agre code conduct public access document establish hereinaft code commiss concern implement commiss decis februari ombudsman inquiri matter rais complain direct question commiss act conform rule refus access correspond question relev provis code read document held institut written natur legal person member state commun institut bodi nation intern bodi applic direct author institut refus access order protect institut interest confidenti proceed letter consum affair offic commiss appear quot provis incom letter commiss scope applic commiss decis public access document commiss decis mr request appear conform applic rule commiss letter consum affair offic ombudsman remark rule court instanc case carvel guardian newspap council institut invok confidenti proceed balanc interest citizen gain access document interest maintain confidenti deliber commiss decis refus access letter undertaken balanc ombudsman inquiri commiss step correct error releas document concern ombudsman limit make critic remark commiss effect futur compli requir balanc background ombudsman close case recruit appeal decis select board decis complaint ss fin pd european commiss complaint juli mr complain ombudsman behalf experienc translat applic complaint concern gener competit organis commiss swedish speak translat eur la fail written examin complain ask select board review mark forward copi correct examin script complaint ombudsman mr alleg repli select board constitut instanc maladministr letter select board state review mark mark correct complain request access correct examin script board state grant access take consider proceed board confidenti applic principl equal treatment applic complaint mr request bodi select board review mark written examin inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state gener mark written test competit compar exercis cover statutori oblig secreci proceed select board commun court recognis board signific margin appreci written test applic mr case commiss state select board appoint corrector compet experienc linguist examin script assess independ corrector board subsequ decid mark award candid case law commun court question bodi board purport determin mark applic decis take stand complain alleg commiss letter date ombudsman firstli remark commiss refer principl equal treatment applic justifi refus mr access correct examin script principl impli ident situat treat equal situat treat ident decis disclos copi correct examin script applic decis legal framework laid staff regul case law commun court principl refer bear decis ombudsman note commiss reiter argument comment ombudsman found commiss refer principl answer complain mislead made critic remark effect present state commun law legal basi commiss oblig disclos copi correct examin script applic regard wide discret select board recognis commun court import select board compli legal guarante laid commun court principl good administr conduct repli mr request review decis select board state establish mark examin made correct provid complain indic element procedur appli led result ombudsman found unsatisfactori made critic remark commiss effect select board due consider commun court case law principl good administr conduct provid applic reason element understand decis complain request review examin script bodi select board ombudsman remark applic rule forc provid appeal bodi framework competit review select board mark exam basi find ombudsman close case recognit diploma complaint properli consid decis complaint rm pd european commiss complaint octob mr act belgian lawyer made complaint ombudsman commiss mr dutch citizen live belgium hold dutch nurs diploma diploma verpleegkundig obtain februari inform belgian author diploma recognis april mr lodg complaint commiss refus consid contrari commun law consid recognit grant council direct eec june mutual recognit diploma certif evid formal qualif nurs respons gener care includ measur facilit effect exercis establish freedom provid servic mr complain ombudsman found commiss assess deal case unsatisfactori inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state mr diploma deliv direct eec applic mutual recognit diploma eec depend diploma conform requir laid direct council june coordin provis laid law regul administr action respect activ nurs respons gener care mr diploma concern educ conform minimum criteria laid direct commiss state mr benefit provis articl direct eec diploma fulfil requir laid council direct eec provid work certif requir articl basi case law court justic commiss consid belgian author facilit mr access profess spite inapplic direct case nation author compar diploma question requir set direct eec citizen qualif miss suppli inform author enabl citizen decid acquir qualif consid miss deal case commiss state submit case similar committe senior offici public health set direct order examin difficulti applic thereof enumer numer contact belgian dutch author case commiss autumn committe senior offici reach conclus conform commiss legal assess set final commiss state inform mr legal assess letter novemb decis commiss assess origin complaint lodg commiss appear commiss share belgian author opinion diploma question compli minimum requir laid direct eec case articl direct eec diploma recognis accompani certif certif effect holder engag activ nurs respons gener care year year prior date issu certif access profess mutual recognit diploma subject regul commun legisl freedom movement exercis directli basi relev treati provis case articl ec treati provis direct effect appli nation court court justic detail oblig treati provis impos nation author situat court held compet author member state receiv request admit person profess access nation law depend possess diploma profession qualif consider diploma certif evid qualif person concern acquir order exercis profess member state make comparison specialis knowledg abil certifi diploma knowledg qualif requir nation rule rule aran paragraph commiss posit appear ground recal court justic highest author question commun law ombudsman inquiri complaint reveal instanc maladministr commiss interpret direct commiss deal complaint appear enumer commiss opinion contact nation author case similar commiss activ process complaint appear complaint commiss opinion year complain inform commiss deal basi ombudsman inquiri aspect complaint appear make critic remark principl good administr commiss commit requir complain regularli inform ongo process complaint commiss complain regularli inform deal complaint leav complain inform year conform principl aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case select consult carri taci project decis complaint sn uk jma european commiss complaint novemb mr stan newen member european parliament transmit complaint ombudsman behalf mr allegedli ineffici uneth practic repres commiss charg project fund taci programm complain put forward claim view eu institut fail establish realist deadlin project project condit unsatisfactori time alloc activ inadequ fee payabl consult low methodolog develop project preparatori work hand inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss project price statist construct part programm technic assist statist taci countri programm work carri nation statist institut member state msnsi call interest fund programm assess answer advisori steer group chair commiss particip taci countri nation statist offic msnsi privat compani invit particip msnsi carri work project price statist construct result request central asian countri octob msnsi readi carri work repres uk central statist offic cso uk initi approach mr consult firm dlc explor interest project dlc identifi potenti partner file wait suffici budgetari resourc resourc march dlc ask make specif propos submit consid expens negoti dlc accept financi condit taci offer condit line commiss effici guidelin taci statist programm commiss involv msnsi framework steer group septemb german feder statist offic accept respons project dlc immedi inform situat propos submit dlc hand competitor discuss project text natur attent interest parti implement project base text german feder statist offic approach statist field question observ receiv complain decis length negoti basi ombudsman inquiri appear dlc contact project price statist construct novemb budgetari reason commiss made final commit fund project march dlc invit submit specif propos receiv final decis project carri german feder statist offic made octob appear main reason delai suffici budgetari resourc project result evid unnecessari administr delai commiss agent project condit comment commiss state project condit line commiss effici guidelin taci statist programm evid present ombudsman contradict statement content effici guidelin matter commiss subject supervis court auditor european parliament issu sound financi manag agre contact made dlc behalf commiss ensur consult inform condit futur contract avoid possibl dlc misl scope negoti condit deal directli commiss hand complain propos evid provid commiss appear relev taci programm primarili intend financ work nation statist offic member state privat firm invit part nation statist offic unabl unwil carri work similarli appear nation statist offic involv steer group consid fund propos receiv text propos made privat compani dlc invit submit propos commiss expressli inform consult propos transmit nation statist offic nation statist offic express carri work prefer avoid possibl consult misl think deal commiss matter govern normal principl fair deal tender contract commiss state implement project feder statist offic germani base text dlc propos evid provid ombudsman contradict claim conclus view find ombudsman consid make critic remark agre contact made complain firm behalf commiss ensur consult inform condit futur contract avoid possibl consult misl deal directli commiss scope negoti condit complain firm invit submit propos commiss expressli inform consult propos transmit nation statist offic nation statist offic express carri work prefer avoid possibl consult misl think deal commiss matter govern normal principl fair deal tender contract aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case staff incorrect classif expert decis complaint ms pd european commiss complaint mr itali complain ombudsman novemb fact commiss act note address commiss background mr address note commiss summari octob sign contract european associ develop contract sign offici commiss behalf associ contract stipul mr accomplish expert train stai year commiss deleg bueno air argentina sole recit contract provid stai permit acquir work experi practic knowledg cooper european commun develop countri document establish dai sign mr commiss call mandat ef mr undertook particip gener activ deleg accomplish level train task alloc head deleg deleg approxim month mr wrote abovement note commiss offici brussel sign contract letter put forward work assign level expect natur mr relat fact deleg expect economist person train agricultur matter conclud note declar open suggest make profession capabl bueno air brussel deleg note intern staff charact transmit addresse head deleg june transmiss note head deleg substanc disagre content mr note head deleg put forward work carri deleg relat rural agricultur develop concern develop work assign mr expect profession capabl head deleg finish transmiss note suggest end mr contractu period assign deleg work rural agricultur charact mr receiv copi note contact mr commiss servic brussel appar suggest mr stai bueno air await arriv head deleg octob mr sign renew contract period year letter date octob mr state chang deleg error compens damag suffer opportun year period deleg complaint ombudsman mr emphasis offer post bueno air commiss servic mistaken economist appar paper expert agricultur matter substanti alleg inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state firstli object pursu train contract necessarili impli person question receiv supplementari train specialis field content train programm orient administr manag programm conven countri assign concern bilater multilater agreement formal classif train contract specialis field disciplin person question commiss state consid transmiss note head deleg date june mr receiv copi constitut repli note commiss state gener servic avoid embark formal direct discuss agenc deleg ignor overrul mandat head deleg commiss repres respons implement train programm thirdli commiss state mr inform systemat administr posit note novemb address head deleg mr receiv copi note state assign task interest servic commiss comment question servic classifi mr wrongli economist complain observ observ complain maintain complaint request commiss grant year train period compens damag suffer decis assess complain substanti alleg wrongli classifi economist ombudsman firstli remark contract sign mr associ develop commiss field work object train programm necessarili give person question supplementari train specialis field commiss contradict claim correct classif mr rural expert relev decis duti station contradict claim servic classifi mr wrongli background ombudsman address critic remark commiss effect classifi mr properli appear mr receiv offici explicit written repli point note transmiss note head deleg mr receiv copi consid full repli head deleg empow act point put forward mr note contract assign mr deleg bueno air renew mutual agreement year octob note novemb headquart brussel head deleg mr receiv copi made clear commiss stand assign task interest servic propos renew contract year bueno air constitut implicit repli mr wish assign deleg note dealt grievanc assign task background ombudsman found commiss act mr note ground suggest commiss award year train period conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss proceed proper classif mr expert agricultur matter aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case failur respect medic secreci decis complaint bb european commiss complaint decemb complain ombudsman alleg violat medic secreci medic servic commiss ii unjustifi delai send document accord articl statut complaint classifi confidenti request complain work commiss freelanc basi european institut conclud agreement insur compani order cover relev categori freelanc worker loss incom fall ill contract complain undergo urgent medic treatment work commiss requir certif hand administr immedi includ medic indic respons doctor document seal envelop address head commiss medic servic mark medic secret complain subsequ inform commiss claim accept file forward insur compani alleg delai week insur compani receiv file decemb realis employe insur compani commiss servic contract awar confidenti medic inform inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss summari commiss made point accord insur polici submit medic document commiss includ certif treatment undergon transmiss insur compani articl insur polici form time document indic natur oper insur compani seal envelop result complaint offici concern remind correct procedur futur case commiss point offici dealt complaint bound secreci staff regul commiss receiv applic octob insur compani octob commiss medic servic examin commiss ask acknowledg receipt insur compani provid commiss accept alleg delai transmiss document insur compani repli decemb confidenti natur medic inform commiss claim respons action insur compani commiss remind insur compani oblig confidenti meet complain gener principl confidenti medic document commiss state transmiss medic document seal envelop exclus insur compani doctor commiss doctor insur parti option term insur polici document treat insur parti applic form compens member relev categori freelanc worker request coverag sick insur polici abid provis procedur complain observ complain maintain complaint acknowledg commiss note octob complain stress insur compani receiv document novemb decis alleg violat medic secreci matter good administr commiss ensur document cover medic secreci treat care appear ombudsman inquiri commiss acknowledg document indic natur complain medic treatment insur compani seal envelop ombudsman consid commiss failur treat complain medic document care regrett constitut instanc maladministr ombudsman drew commiss attent fact make critic decis brought attent offici deal document cover medic secreci order guarante mistak compar case made futur alleg delai forward document insur compani commiss receiv complain applic octob examin medic servic commiss letter insur compani octob commiss provid ombudsman copi abovement letter letter commiss ask acknowledg receipt insur compani provid assess delai commiss need account insur compani repli complain decemb month letter commiss date appear ombudsman inquiri suffici foundat alleg commiss delai transmiss complain document insur compani conclus view find appear make critic remark european ombudsman found principl good administr requir commiss ensur document cover medic secreci treat care appear ombudsman inquiri commiss acknowledg document indic natur complain medic treatment insur compani seal envelop ombudsman found commiss failur treat complain medic document care regrett constitut instanc maladministr aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case lack transpar run competit decis complaint pd european commiss complaint januari mr complain ombudsman commiss run interinstiut recruit competit eur la participt letter novemb select board inform mr mark obtain preselect written test insuffici remaind written test correct mr ask select board review mark test question made request prejudic review procedur grate addit correct test enabl make observ fit substanti case answer mr main request select board inform detail assess criteria test question state reconsid test paper point result notifi correspond mark award select board purpos test notic attend compil short list candid score highest mark case competit case competit examin experienc translat work union institut observ rigor assess criteria instanc test design assess profici sourc languag profici spanish abil solv translat problem inform factor account determin total mark includ sourc languag gross minor error comprehens inaccuraci target languag assess relat spell gross slight mistak morpholog syntax agreement preposit govern incorrect syntact construct vocabulari omiss word omiss sentenc incorrect term barbar stylist fault incorrect punctuat likewis consider hand good style correct translat difficult passag brilliant translat difficult passag count candid favour test paper mark separ examin candid anonym preserv paper mark examin select board deem paper mark care regret inform decis select board test final mr request knowledg correct test select board state lastli inform send copi test paper matter principl requir treat candid equal proceed select board remain confidenti complaint ombudsman mr state contest select board evalu test knowledg correct test select board appli evalu criteria properli case claim select board reason permit knowledg correct test question inadequ lack transpar inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state select board act conform notic competit select board open mr commun evalu criteria test question reason select board gave permit mr knowledg correct test commiss state substanc common practic commun institut commun correct test applic case law court justic select board wide discretionari power commiss oblig impos select board field commun mark obtain applic concern transpar commiss state transpar rule overrid articl annex iii staff regul proceed select board secret commiss secreci permit select board perform work independ submit kind pressur complain observ observ mr maintain complaint substanc stress commun correct test knowledg correct test leav select board find obtain knowledg mr state fulli accept sign permit identifi corrector delet correct test long mr knowledg correct made transpar mr state object pursu provis articl annex iii staff regul ensur independ work select board justifi refus inform correct test version permit identifi corrector decis question rais mr complaint select board entitl refus inform correct test question assess question note unjustifi select board interpret mr demand knowledg correct test demand commun test question select board justifi refus demand refer principl equal treatment applic confidenti proceed select board principl equal treatment applic impli ident situat treat differ situat treat ident decis commun correct test basi staff regul case law court justic principl bear decis note commiss refer principl comment mr complaint ombudsman refer select board principl confus principl good administr requir adequ reason applic decis select board refer principl equal treatment adequ principl bear decis access grant correct test background ombudsman address critic remark commiss select board refer confidenti proceed reason commun correct test present state commun law oblig commiss commun correct test applic request appear select board entitl refus commun test refer principl confidenti proceed select board conclus basi ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss justifi refus commun correct test question refer principl equal treatment applic principl bear decis correct test commun aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman decid close case remark ombudsman consider number complaint ombudsman receiv lack transpar recruit procedur organis commun institut ombudsman open inquiri initi matter novemb includ question commiss envisag allow applic examin question examin room disclos correct copi examin applic concern letter ombudsman state discretionari power select board confidenti proceed hinder complianc principl good administr critic run competit decis complaint pd european commiss complaint februari mr complain ombudsman commiss run interinstiut recruit competit eur la participt letter novemb select board inform mr mark obtain preselect test test insuffici remaind test correct letter novemb mr ask select board review mark test commun correct test state doubt correct imparti correct made found difficult understand low mark obtain state test applic ask question basi notic competit test accord provis notic test question notic state test compris paper question princip stage european unif commun polici translat spanish dictionari gener text line activ european union languag chosen candid section point exclud languag select test test mr consid number question ask relat princip stage european unif commun polici mr case question question gener secretariat european parliament question compet court instanc question econom social committe question organis member european parliament question length mandat european commiss question exact number commission member state question commun legisl includ applic commun regul complain view obviou question cover draft notic consider notic concern oral test provid interview select board enabl complet assess candid suitabl perform duti section profici languag knowledg union institut polici test interview mr claim read applic question institut ask written test test mr claim set text consist line provid notic line letter decemb januari select board repli complain letter request review board inform test review mark correct board regret inform mr disclos correct test principl equal treatment applic principl confidenti proceed alleg relat test board state question ask relat directli indirectli provis notic test test board ad case law court justic complet autonom independ larg discretionari power long respect provis notic satisfi answer mr complain ombudsman claim answer select board lack transpar normal applic opportun correct test knowledg correct made view select board gave principl confidenti proceed scope unjustifi maintain content test justifi inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state select board act accord notic competit reason select board gave permit mr knowledg correct test commiss state substanc common practic commun institut commun correct test applic case law court justic select board wide discretionari power commiss oblig impos select board field commun mark obtain applic mr alleg relat test commiss state good mark obtain test alleg unfound interest test concern commiss state select board decis give applic text line fell discretionari power select board vest observ commiss comment receiv complain decis select board refus disclos correct test mr board justifi decis refer principl equal treatment applic confidenti proceed principl equal treatment applic impli ident situat treat differ situat treat ident decis commun correct test basi staff regul case law court justic principl bear decis note commiss refer principl comment mr complaint ombudsman refer select board principl confus principl good administr requir adequ reason applic decis select board refer principl equal treatment adequ principl bear decis access grant correct test background ombudsman address critic remark commiss select board refer confidenti proceed reason commun correct test present state commun law oblig commiss commun correct test applic request appear select board entitl refus commun test refer principl confidenti proceed select board concern mr alleg relat test notic test focu stage european union commun polici notic oral test subject includ institut european union notic appear leav impress question limit institut ask test appear test question fact ask concern institut appar relat stage european union commiss put forward argument context place mr lack interest contest appropri question case pass test good result place question relat direct indirect topic notic argument recal articl ec treati citizen appli european ombudsman submit exercis condit relat person interest citizen problem submit european ombudsman commiss argument principl good administr requir citizen reli accuraci public statement commiss make appear unjustifi make specif word led citizen topic test narrowli defin fact case background ombudsman address critic remark commiss mr alleg relat test case law court justic select board vest wide discretionari power provid respect notic competit notic competit text translat test approxim line actual text set line longer excess consid respect word notic competit european ombudsman address critic remark commiss conclus basi european ombudsman inquiri complaint appear make critic remark commiss justifi refus commun correct test question refer principl equal treatment applic principl bear decis correct test commun commiss draft notic competit mislead citizen content test respect word notic competit aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement matter ombudsman close case remark ombudsman consider number complaint ombudsman receiv lack transpar recruit procedur organis commun institut ombudsman open inquiri initi matter novemb includ question commiss envisag allow applic examin question examin room disclos correct copi examin applic concern letter ombudsman state discretionari power select board confidenti proceed hinder complianc principl good administr reimburs medic cost decis complaint pd european commiss complaint april mr complain ombudsman failur commiss reimburs medic cost incur commiss request complain successfulli pass competit organis commiss view recruit commiss ask undergo medic examin novemb examin ask undergo special examin doctor choic expens relat reimburs commiss januari forward doctor bill commiss june commiss offer mr job delai reimburs medic expens neg experi commiss competit made mr declin offer octob wrote commiss remind reimburs receiv april wrote commiss order claim reimburs complaint mr claim unaccept commiss reimburs medic cost answer remind inquiri commiss comment complaint forward commiss comment commiss state mr medic cost paid time origin invoic evid lost time made payment due regret inexplic delai pai cost explain chang procedur settl claim undu delai occur futur commiss comment mr alleg failur repli letter complain observ observ mr express satisfact fact applic ombudsman prompt commiss reimburs medic cost question dissatisfi fact appli ombudsman order make commiss compli reimburs commit commiss comment failur repli letter decis appear commiss opinion complain observ commiss settl claim reimburs appear commiss time chang procedur pai claim futur paid undu delai ombudsman pursu aspect complaint remind commiss deni fail repli ombudsman address critic remark commiss effect repli mr letter promptli aspect case concern procedur relat specif event past pursu friendli settlement aspect case ombudsman close case initi inquiri ombudsman run competit decis initi inquiri la pd juli ombudsman began initi inquiri prompt complaint run competit eur la organis european commiss inquiri ombudsman ask commiss provid inform point relat competit qualif german person charg correct candid examin script written german swedish translat test candid entitl correct made test reason commiss comment commiss repli ombudsman letter octob opinion commiss made point corrector competit eur la experienc translat foreign languag german commiss state script correct independ corrector select board consid correct made profession translat commiss commun institut practic return examin script candid staff regul stipul work select board secret select board oper independ manner sole compet judg perform candid administr burdensom competit total candid result unequ treatment candid paper return request decis concern question qualif german person charg correct candid examin script competit eur la ombudsman found inquiri reveal instanc maladministr applic access correct examin script ombudsman remark start inquiri receiv consider number complaint lack access correct examin script appar lack transpar recruit procedur organis commun institut ombudsman decid open initi inquiri transpar recruit procedur inquiri question access correct examin script address background ombudsman found ground inquiri close case commiss administr procedur deal complaint member state infring commun law decis initi inquiri pd april ombudsman began initi inquiri articl treati establish european commun inquiri concern possibl improv qualiti commiss administr procedur deal complaint member state infring commun law period judici proceed begin background inquiri gener background inquiri substanc essenti part ombudsman mission consist enhanc relat commun institut bodi european citizen import relat concern commiss prime task act guardian treati accord articl treati rome commiss consist recognis reli consider extent privat citizen firm detect member state infring commun law citizen confid commiss deal alleg infring crucial specif background ombudsman receiv complaint administr procedur commiss deal complaint lodg privat citizen member state failur fulfil commun law oblig object complaint discretionari power commiss bring legal proceed member state articl treati administr process take place judici proceed begin alleg complaint submit ombudsman concern excess time process complaint lack inform treatment complaint receiv reason commiss reach conclus infring member state inquiri background ombudsman concern administr procedur commiss deal complaint prejudic question principl commun law requir develop procedur right citizen lodg complaint commiss appear ombudsman commiss decid creat develop procedur right citizen matter good administr behaviour consist case law court justic individu challeng court justic commiss decis bring proceed articl ombudsman suggest commiss commun regist complain provision conclus breach commun law find support conclus invit submit observ defin period make final decis point advantag procedur firstli contribut effect administr give complain opportun criticis commiss view give commiss opportun respond critic enhanc citizen trust commiss allow particip fulli articl procedur make activ transpar commiss comment comment commiss state complaint individu remain import sourc commiss base task monitor applic commun law reason commiss acknowledg complain place infring proceed period judici proceed begin enjoi procedur safeguard commiss constantli develop improv commiss declar readi continu line commiss state complaint reach commiss regist except made rule commiss receiv complaint acknowledg receipt letter complain annex attach explain detail infring proceed complaint regist complain inform action respons complaint includ represent made nation author concern complain inform outcom investig complaint action infring proceed institut complain notifi proceed issu deadlin process complaint commiss state intern rule procedur decis close file take action decis initi offici infring proceed complaint maximum period year date regist special case reason state commiss point delai process complaint relat fact discuss exchang nation author consider time commiss consid prioriti object reduc delai inform complain draft decis reject complaint commiss state case complain inform complaint reject statement reason propos reject commiss declar prepar extend practic leav case complaint foundat case heard complain decis commiss construct servic mind approach inquiri ombudsman pleas commiss appear commit constant develop improv posit citizen articl procedur period judici proceed begin process complaint time involv appear commiss comment receipt complaint acknowledg complain inform action commiss commiss intern rule decis close file take action decis initi offici infring proceed maximum period year date complaint regist special case reason state reason relat time discuss nation author concern await repli commiss request inform author observ rule appear adequ mean ensur citizen inform process complaint complaint process undu delai maximum period year special reason ombudsman found inquiri reveal instanc maladministr respect commiss note suggest made regard improv citizen procedur right articl procedur period judici proceed begin appear futur commiss case inform complain intent close file reason commiss find infring commun law complaint manifestli unfound complain appear lost interest complaint valuabl step process commiss commit constant develop improv procedur posit complain articl procedur period judici proceed begin citizen opportunii put forward view critic commiss point view commit final conclus infring commun law view find appear maladministr ombudsman close inquiri remark european ombudsman commiss state acknowledg receipt complaint forward annex complain set purpos give detail infring proceed annex commiss inform role plai nation court ensur proper applic commun law context commiss equal stress crucial role nation court respect member state exist import extra judici mechan nation ombudsmen similar bodi creat view provid remedi redress citizen expos improp applic law ombudsman suggest commiss possibl provid inform bodi relat european parliament european commiss council european union mission european ombudsman protect promot limit mandat right european citizen commun law ombudsman share mission organ commun effect action secur right citizen requir cooper good work relat mutual trust regular contact ombudsman commun organ european parliament european commiss deal citizen complaint european parliament committe petit citizen european union petit european parliament complain european ombudsman articl treati establish european commun ombudsman committe petit parliament intend complementari institut cooper bodi special import begin offic european ombudsman close cooper establish committe petit regular contact secretariat respect function work method bodi clarifi agreement mutual transfer complaint petit case consent complain petition standard form complaint ombudsman made wide distribut form complain opportun state consent complaint transfer compet bodi case ombudsman deal case complaint mandat ombudsman dealt petit european parliament ombudsman transfer complaint directli parliament dealt petit provid consent case complaint form ombudsman write complain propos transfer complaint european parliament dealt petit case complaint deal matter potenti subject petit formul suffici document ombudsman inform complain possibl submit petit european parliament enclos copi leaflet petit petit transfer ombudsman dealt complaint complaint transfer european parliament dealt petit complain advis petit european parliament committe petit examin annual report ombudsman make report parliament ombudsman present annual report year committe petit brussel april juli mr söderman present annual report plenari session european parliament strasbourg discuss parliament annual report committe petit report ombudsman accept invit attend press confer arrang committe petit juli mr alessandro fontana chairman committe petit mr nicolao papakyriazi rapporteur committe report accord articl statut european ombudsman opportun present special report european parliament case parliament action assist ombudsman accord statut decemb ombudsman present special report presid european parliament mr josé maría gil robl special report initi inquiri public access document held commun institut bodi inquiri launch june conclud decis ombudsman date decemb draft recommend address commun institut bodi institut bodi detail opinion ombudsman requir articl statut special report analys detail opinion drew attent matter european parliament pursu contain formal recommend addit contact committe petit mr söderman attend meet committe rule procedur septemb brussel propos amend parliament rule procedur discuss propos amend rule present draft report rapporteur mr brian crowlei committe petit gave opinion novemb visit belgium novemb european ombudsman attend meet committe legal affair citizen right european parliament exchang view context committe report fourteenth annual report commiss monitor applic commun law rapporteur astrid thor mr söderman address committe inform initi inquiri commiss administr procedur deal complaint infring commun law member state note januari european parliament adopt committe report resolut welcom ombudsman initi european commiss european institut ombudsman maintain regular dialogu cooper european commiss complaint lead inquiri ombudsman concern alleg instanc maladministr activ commiss normal commiss main commun organ make administr decis direct impact citizen articl treati establish european commun commiss respons ensur commun law observ member state bring proceed court justic purpos articl treati guardian treati commiss import respons ensur legal right citizen european union respect citizen complain commiss feel right infring member state facilit complaint commiss publish standard complaint form offici journal fo european commun year ombudsman launch conclud initi inquiri commiss administr procedur deal complaint infring commun law member state ombudsman decis conclud inquiri summaris chapter european ombudsman meet commission chair presid santer april present annual report commission mr söderman exchang view matter common interest juli mr söderman accompani princip offic ian harden meet director gener commiss octob mr josé martinez aragon senior legal offic mr ursula garderet administr assist ombudsman met offici director employ industri relat social affair dg carri inspect document relat complaint mr söderman princip offic ian harden met secretari gener commiss mr carlo trojan mr jean claud eeckhout director director gener secretariat strasbourg octob ombudsman secretari gener agre case inform meet provid pursu friendli solut accord articl statut discuss possibl commiss adopt code good administr behaviour offici agre cooper organis seminar liaison offic nation ombudsmen similar bodi final ombudsman inform secretari gener consid work euro ju network part time legal advis work commiss represent member state great provid effect advic european citizen right commun law council european union mr söderman met mr piri director gener legal servic council april brussel met mr boixareu director gener council secretariat budget administr relat commun institut secretari gener council mr jürgen trumpf inform ombudsman june council adopt procedur treatment complaint alleg maladministr gener secretariat council act appoint author staff regul henceforth gener secretariat council compet deal complaint provid relev inform directli european ombudsman mr söderman invit lunch corep brussel juli gave overview work european ombudsman answer question relat nation ombudsmen similar bodi safeguard right european citizen flexibl system cooper develop european ombudsman ombudsmen similar bodi member state implement aspect commun law respons nation region local administr member state complaint citizen author infring right commun law mandat european ombudsman union citizenship involv freedom movement guarante articl ec treati case complaint dealt effect nation ombudsmen similar bodi petit committe increasingli involv matter concern implement commun law nation administr liaison network seminar held strasbourg septemb nation ombudsmen similar bodi european ombudsman agre establish network liaison offic network intend promot free flow inform commun law implement make transfer complaint bodi deal european ombudsman organis seminar liaison offic brussel june deal supervis applic commun law nation level speaker includ mr jacob söderman mr alessandro fontana chairman committe petit european parliament mr lar clevesköld swedish ombudsman offic mr axel voss euro ju repres commiss inform offic germani mr peter dyrberg european ombudsman offic mr van nuffel legal servic european commiss mr saverio baviera committe petit european parliament particip seminar attend part meet committe petit final session seminar chair michael brophi irish ombudsman offic particip formul propos practic possibl futur cooper includ product regular liaison letter european ombudsman organis seminar liaison letter distribut end octob intend liaison letter eventu publish electron form facilit develop possibl internet user group network european ombudsman offic undertook survei mail internet usag nation ombudsmen similar bodi mr claud desjean secretari gener french ombudsman visit offic european ombudsman june inform ian harden manag budgetari question relat provis administr servic european ombudsman cooper deal complaint strasbourg seminar agre european ombudsman receiv queri nation ombudsmen commun law provid repli directli channel queri union institut bodi respons queri european ombudsman dealt irish ombudsman concern complaint deal queri march concern interpret commun law provis payment extensif premium june concern compens repay milk super levi council regul eec queri forward commiss request repli month repli receiv transmit irish ombudsman european ombudsman transfer complaint nation author mandat dealt relev nation ombudsman bb confidenti case bb transfer finnish parliamentari ombudsman pd transfer nation ombudsman netherland complaint vk similarli transfer luxembourg parliament dealt petit case ijh member european parliament complain secretariat committe petit dealt petit constitu european ombudsman decid ground open inquiri request inform portugues ombudsman provedor de justiça mr josé menér pimentel underli issu involv confisc portugues author vehicl belong mep constitu mr pimentel inform european ombudsman matter subject decis portugues court forward copi relev court order european ombudsman transmit inform mep cooper region ombudsmen similar bodi order promot effect cooper european ombudsman colleagu region level ombudsman catalonia el síndic de greug de catalunya mr anton cañella organis dai seminar octob barcelona european ombudsman attend meet accompani mr peter dyrberg mr josé martinez aragon secretariat particip meet repres region ombudsmen region committe petit member state chairman committe petit european parliament mr alessandro fontana head committe secretariat mr saverio baviera mr söderman gave speech deal object cooper european institut region ombudsmen similar bodi supervis implement commun law el papel del defensor del pueblo mr dyrberg gave speech analys recent case law court justic number area includ free movement principl discrimin mr martinez aragon made speech role local entiti region european union work respons correct applic commun law final declar seminar stress closer cooper agre region ombudsmen similar bodi appoint liaison offic coordin cooper european ombudsman field commun law follow seminar foreseen place organis ombudsman flemish region belgium mr jan goorden meet european nation ombudsmen septemb mr söderman attend sixth annual meet european nation ombudsmen held jerusalem israel accompani princip offic ian harden press offic ms ilta helkama meet host judg mr miriam ben porat public complaint commission state comptrol particip countri mr ben porat gave open speech topic ombudsman defend democraci human right speech announc role public complaint commission henceforth ombudsman cite approv explan term maladministr annual report european ombudsman mr söderman gave speech role european ombudsman session chair mr clae eklundh chief parliamentari ombudsman sweden chefjustitieombudsman speech deal content impact ombudsman annual report made mr marten oost parliamentari ombudsman netherland de national ombudsman mr jacqu pelleti french ombudsman médiateur de la républiqu chairman session final session chair sir william reid unit kingdom parliamentari commission administr katalin gönczöl hungari dealt issu asylum refuge immigr debat agre provis treati amsterdam asylum immigr made envisag closer cooper issu european nation ombudsmen european ombudsman invit organis cooper public relat inform strategi european ombudsman object inform peopl real reason complain maladministr activ commun institut bodi complain european ombudsman object improv relat union citizen inform broader public ombudsman role help realis union commit open democrat account form administr time essenti creat fals expect simpli result increas number complaint european ombudsman mandat inform strategi focus target accur inform group potenti complain time convent public ombudsman websit intend interest live educ purpos young peopl learn europ progress made achiev object total number complaint number admiss complaint increas clear relat member state itali germani ensur real reason complain ombudsman highlight year offici inaugur offic strasbourg offici inaugur european ombudsman offic strasbourg place april presenc presid european parliament mr josé maría gil robl french minist european affair délégué aux affair européenn mr michel barnier french nation ombudsman médiateur de la républiqu mr jacqu pelleti joint press confer mark occas mr barnier mr pelleti mr söderman chadwyck healei award european inform associ present eia chadwyck healei award mr jacob söderman april achiev european inform chadwyck healei award annual person achiev promot advanc access inform european union wider europ award mr söderman recognit contribut promot european citizen access offici document held commun institut includ call access document guarante revis treati european union amount award donat amnesti intern oecd seminar ethic public sector mr söderman attend symposium ethic public sector challeng opportun oecd countri held novemb pari symposium attend govern offici academ expert dealt topic ethic greater transpar govern ethic valu public manag interpenetr public privat sector mr söderman chair work session ethic challeng time chang present annual report european parliament annual report european ombudsman year present european parliament plenari session strasbourg juli present special report ombudsman ombudsman present special report presid european parliament mr josé maría gil robl decemb report made accord articl statut deal outcom ombudsman initi inquiri public access document held commun institut bodi confer meet inform campaign rais level awar european citizen exist european ombudsman began signific contribut campaign made ombudsman programm offici visit member state began public lectur particip confer meet mr söderman continu programm bring european ombudsman european citizen media member state ombudsman staff continu give lectur make speech role function european ombudsman european intern congress seminar meet addit mr söderman meet numer research group visitor specif visit detail regular visit made brussel luxembourg meet commun institut part belgium march european ombudsman met newli elect belgian feder ombudsmen mr pierr yve monett mr herman wuyt brussel exchang work experi mr söderman accompani peter dyrberg peter dyrberg particip confer eu citizenship current state futur perspect brussel arrang european citizen action servic mr söderman made offici visit belgium novemb stai visit belgian feder ombudsman offic met feder ombudsmen mr wuyt mr monett gave talk legal staff offic experi european ombudsman finnish ombudsman inform offic european parliament mr söderman welcom mr thoma director offic mr bouman deputi director exchang view dealt work ombudsman mission inform offic possibl promot citizen awar european ombudsman europ dai held mr söderman visit belgian chamber repres welcom vice presid parliament mr van der mael member belgian parliament made speech committe petit belgian parliament parliamentari committe respons european issu dai visit devot meet repres belgian civil societi held european parliament build widespread particip meet numer question address european ombudsman press confer attend journalist import belgian newspap de morgen le soir la libr belgiqu het laatst nieuw de financieel economisch tijd gave good coverag european ombudsman visit belgium visit belgium mr söderman visit commiss represent belgium met mr vandebon director represent mr moë deputi director mr vand casteel euro ju network talk experi euro ju advis denmark march european ombudsman visit denmark accompani peter dyrberg met exchang view mr ov fich chairman danish parliament committe eu matter mr bjørn elmquist chairman committe legal affair member committe committe eu matter subsequ made report annual report european ombudsman publish octob mr söderman meet danish ombudsman folketinget ombudsmand mr han gammeltoft hansen staff mr söderman meet mr thoma christensen director commiss represent copenhagen staff organis visit gave press confer meet mr mikael bramsen head parliament inform offic parliament inform offic met lunch inter alia mr ol due presid european court justic germani mr söderman paid visit germani march accompani ms vicki kloppenburg mainz met ombudsman rheinland pfalz mr ullrich gall compar mandat function discuss concret case commun law mr söderman met vice presid rheinland pfalz parliament mr han günter heinz chairman committe petit mr klau hammer press confer mr söderman gave overview work discuss case dealt bonn mr söderman attend confer petit put feet organis mr christa nickel presid committe petit german parliament deutsch bundestag connect initi introduc nation ombudsman system germani mr söderman opportun exchang view offici administr committe petit german parliament includ dr friederik freifrau von welck mr franz kremser liaison offic mr ing gerstberg mr söderman met minist state foreign offic german repres intergovernment confer dr werner hoyer exchang view inform mr söderman invit give speech work mandat dinner organis offic european parliament bonn repres eu relat associ organis high civil servant journalist bonn addit round tabl discuss held offic repres associ deal consum interest environment matter agricultur trade industri mr söderman met head european commiss offic bonn mr axel bunz citizen advis mr axel voss exchang view press club bonn meet journalist peter dyrberg gave speech european ombudsman compon union commit transpar democraci confer entitl civil societi europ held april lochum germani organis german foundat mitarbeit mr gall ombudsman rheinland pfalz paid offici visit european ombudsman octob discuss mr gall mr söderman stress import good cooper european ombudsman nation region ombudsmen member state discuss possibl meet ombudsmen länder level germani mr gall opportun meet chairman committe petit mr sandro fontana vice chairman mr ullmann mr schmidbauer member committe petit met mr willi rothlei vice chairman legal affair committe spain mr söderman attend meet vi jornada europea en el parlament de catalunya organis catalan council european movement barcelona spain ombudsman gave speech el papel del defensor del pueblo europeo la ciudadanía europea januari speaker presid catalan parliament mr joan reventó presid catalan council european movement mr eduard sagarra presid feder council european movement spain mr carlo ma bru meet good press coverag mr söderman gave radio interview januari mr josé martinez aragon repres ombudsman confer icg inform role citizen arrang universidad alcalá de henar madrid spain speaker spanish secretari state european affair mr de miguel mr moran chairman institut affair committe mr medina mr verd aldea mr robl piquer vice presid european parliament spanish ombudsman mr fernando ávarez de miranda torr academ journalist mr martinez aragon gave speech work ombudsman relat transpar event receiv good press coverag annual congress latin american ombudsman place toledo spain april invit spanish ombudsman defensor del pueblo mr fernando álvarez de miranda torr mr söderman deliv open address citizen right process econom integr derecho ciudadano proceso de integración económica reflexion crítica desd la perspectiva de la unión europea particip congress includ nation ombudsmen latin america presid human right commiss region ombudsmen spain portug spanish region ombudsmen work congress focus human right indigen peopl role ombudsman supervis judiciari invit professor carlo moreiro centr european legal studi mr söderman gave lectur role european ombudsman el papel del defensor del pueblo europeo april univers carlo iii madrid student mean european citizen protect right experi european ombudsman octob invit mr lizón ombudsman valencia region mr söderman visit valencia lectur role european ombudsman el papel del defensor del pueblo europeo confer organis club de encuentro manuel broseta member administr businessmen professor student press confer arrang club mr söderman gave interview number newspap includ el paí ef el periodico avui european congress gipsi youth held novemb barcelona event initi european year racism gather young gypsi europ view seek wai defend promot romani cultur open ceremoni chair hm felip de borbón mr söderman invit particip congress chair close session presid catalonian region govern mr pujol present mr söderman emphasis import develop free societi fight form discrimin congress wide review press includ la vanguardia el paí abc el periodico avui el punt franc mr ian harden repres european ombudsman colloquium theme european citizenship held februari corsica invit region institut administr bastia colloquium organis framework french govern nation dialogu europ colloquium open mr claud erignac prefect corsica mr jean baggioni mep presid execut council corsica mr harden deliv paper entitl la fonction du médiateur européen depui sa création dan le traité de maastricht offic european ombudsman creation treati maastricht paper mr pierr chaubon mr philipp bardiaux offic french nation ombudsman dr alberto olivo difensor civico di trento mr yve saless conseil etat mr harden repres european ombudsman member panel region forum europ la vie quotidienn held versail march forum organis framework french govern nation dialogu europ theme train europ work europ european citizen french minist european affair mr michel barnier presid forum panel guest includ french secretari state health mr gaymard vice presid european parliament mr nicol fontain french member european court auditor mr bernicot mr jacob söderman invit french nation ombudsman mr jacqu pelleti visit offic pari octob visit ombudsman assist mr olivi verheeck mr daniela tirelli main topic discuss mr pelleti extern relat advis mr bardiaux experi french ombudsman negoti friendli solut applic principl equiti overview work structur french ombudsman system head unit lunch mr söderman opportun meet mr denoix de saint marc vice presid conseil etat lill octob mr söderman paid visit délégation départemental du médiateur nord pa de calai region centr interministériel de renseign administratif cira met mr fiem délégué département director cira explain role délégué département french ombudsman system meet prefect mr alain ohrel mr söderman gave press confer local journalist accept invit mr rougeri délégué la citoyenneté la médiation visit town hall lill mr rougeri explain initi municip lill set mediat servic municip level press confer mr pelleti mr söderman lill report union nord éclair la voix du jeudi pari octob mr söderman met presid bar council pari confer barrist franc visit law court inform offic european parliament represent european commiss pari met mr bernard chevalli mr jean loui giraudi director offic gave joint press confer mr pelleti mr söderman visit conseil constitutionnel receiv presid mr roland duma conclud visit mr söderman deliv speech role european ombudsman meet nation ombudsmen involv creation associ french speak ombudsmen ian harden deliv speech topic accè aux document de institut de organ de union européenn inform dai europ sourc inform organis centr inform sur le institut européenn strasbourg octob itali peter dyrberg attend confer organis european univers institut februari march florenc decentralis agenc commun mr dyrberg gave outlin work european ombudsman ombudsman initi inquiri public access document ms vicki kloppenburg attend seminar right citizen european union organis divis european affair govern autonom provinc südtirol novemb bolzano itali gave speech mandat role european ombudsman compar committe petit european parliament speaker professor fausto capelli director european colleg parma dr walter oberwex univers innsbruck ian harden particip forum wai european inform organis european inform servic novemb florenc itali gave speech subject european ombudsman public access document held commun institut bodi speaker includ mr andrea pierucci cabinet commission oreja mr peter doyl behalf dg commiss luxembourg mr söderman particip euro ju meet luxembourg accompani peter dyrberg gave speech role european ombudsman work netherland mr peter dyrberg gave speech european ombudsman transpar confer oncom amsterdam treati organis amsterdam dutch member socialist group european parliament septemb mr söderman attend seminar transpar open organis european institut public administr eipa maastricht gave speech role impact european ombudsman access document transpar decis make ian harden attend colloquium manag treati european union cope flexibl legitimaci held european institut public administr maastricht novemb discuss impact treati amsterdam compet european ombudsman austria mr söderman paid visit austria june meet mr benita ferrero waldner secretari state ministri foreign affair ambassador gregor woschnagg head european affair depart repres ministri met mr peter wittmann secretari state feder chancelleri visit austrian parliament nationalrat attend dinner mr heinrich neisser presid austrian parliament austrian journalist occas anniversari establish austrian nation ombudsman institut österreichisch volksanwaltschaft mr söderman gave speech topic classic parliamentari ombudsman mr söderman visit feder academi public administr gave lectur role task european ombudsman visit met head academi mr walter dohr held discuss graduat academi specialis eu affair stai vienna mr söderman opportun visit austrian trade union headquart ögb meet mr karl heinz nachnebel head intern ögb secretariat visit feder chamber agricultur meet presid rudolf schwarzböck repres austrian chamber labour meet presid herbert tumpel austrian chamber commerc work lunch met mr wolfgang streitenberg head european commiss represent vienna mr michael reinprecht head european parliament inform offic finland mr söderman gave speech meet nordiska administrativa förbundet held august helsinki meet attend member associ lawyer work judiciari public administr univers nordic countri sweden januari mr söderman attend seminar univers gothenburg gave speech entitl european ombudsman real power democrat cosmet press confer organis represent european commiss mr söderman particip seminar nya dimension till välfärden mr pádraig flynn member european commiss mr paulin green member european parliament attend pressträff open hous citizen discuss european question central station gothenburg decemb mr söderman gave lectur function european ombudsman occas arrang el organis student commun law univers gothenburg sweden assist inform offic european parliament lectur attend peopl includ invit solicitor senior lawyer region unit kingdom visit uk march mr söderman gave annual guest lectur institut european public law univers hull lectur thousand complaint european ombudsman en rout publish journal european public law edit director institut professor patrick birkinshaw stai london april mr söderman meet mr geoffrei martin head represent european commiss mr martyn bond chief inform offic european parliament london mr söderman accompani legal offic benita brom visit london juli juli mr söderman gave oral evid hous lord select committe european commun chair lord tordoff meet record futur transmiss report publish select committe report session hl mr söderman meet mr michael bucklei parliamentari commission administr mr söderman interview mr norman smith bbc westminst studio radio programm europ juli juli ombudsman gave interview london english spanish bloomberg televis mr geraldin rij programm financi market commod new juli ombudsman met mr geoffrei martin head represent european commiss london work lunch host mr martyn bond chief inform offic european parliament london british section european associ journalist even meet solicitor european group mr söderman gave lectur role european ombudsman attend dinner group vice chairman mr simon holm member group ian harden repres ombudsman workshop transpar access document european agenc evalu medicin product emea organis emea octob london particip includ mr josé lui valverd lópez mep repres industri consum press food drug administr mr harden address workshop ombudsman initi inquiri public access document event press offic finnish embassi member state european union met european ombudsman januari strasbourg repres nordic trade union brussel mr sven svensson mr john svenningsen mr knut arn sanden mr heikki pohja held meet european ombudsman januari strasbourg ms benita brom ms ilta helkama attend ninth stammtisch pierr pflimlin theme de finlandai strasbourg januari strasbourg gave overview role function european ombudsman februari mr söderman receiv group student univers lièg gave present role respons european ombudsman group intern european law student faculti law erasmu univers rotterdam visit european ombudsman februari minist justic finland mr kari häkämi accompani mr jan törnqvist director legisl mr raija toiviainen senior ministeri secretari ministri justic visit european ombudsman april professor roi gregori centr ombudsman studi univers read discuss mr söderman strasbourg april relat research project fund leverhulm trust european ombudsman mr söderman gave speech ombudsman role work dinner nordic women network april brussel member petit committe parliament german land rheinland pfalz receiv april brussel mr peter dyrberg gave present work european ombudsman group student danish busi school niel brock receiv april brussel mr peter dyrberg gave talk work european ombudsman mr söderman met group finnish civil servant attend la franc union européenn organis centr de étude européenn de strasbourg group student tornio polytechn unit busi data process visit european ombudsman group swedish pension entrepreneur aktiva senior visit european ombudsman strasbourg mr söderman met prime minist sahravoui republ mr mahfoud ali beiba strasbourg ms benita brom legal offic particip colloquium entitl social charter st centuri organis gener secretariat council europ strasbourg septemb ms vicki kloppenburg gave outlin work european ombudsman group visitor lower saxoni germani invit ms brigitt langenhagen mep european parliament organis open hous strasbourg context european dai event success high number visitor ombudsman stand visitor invit particip quiz role function european ombudsman success particip receiv small prize mr söderman visit oslo norwai attend european region meet lex mundi global associ independ law firm gave speech work european ombudsman relat transpar open transpar european administr mr paulina oro deputi director hungarian ministri justic staff visit brussel offic ombudsman june mr peter dyrberg gave overview role european ombudsman june mr peter dyrberg gave present work european ombudsman group doctor student institut intern econom law univers helsinki visit brussel mr claud desjean secretari gener french ombudsman visit offic european ombudsman june inform ian harden manag budgetari question relat provis administr servic european ombudsman ms jennif long assist clerk treasuri committe uk hous common visit offic european ombudsman june inform work ombudsman mr harden june mr peter dyrberg receiv group teacher german land saxoni anhalt brussel gave present work european ombudsman mr giusepp guarneri head human right divis council europ address staff ombudsman work juli inform lunch behalf german govern juli german product offic imag made video portrait european ombudsman target young peopl group judg lawyer finland met european ombudsman studi visit strasbourg septemb deputi parliamentari ombudsman finland mr riitta leena paunio deleg offic helsinki paid visit european ombudsman septemb octob ombudsman meet mr ulf öberg referendair court justic european commun prepar doctor thesi transpar group student municip vihti finland visit european ombudsman octob group visitor finland receiv octob ms linda reif professor univers alberta edmonton canada editor intern ombudsman institut paid visit ombudsman offic strasbourg octob conduct research work european ombudsman octob decemb ms vicki kloppenburg invit mr gerhard schmid mep speak repres local region administr bavaria relev work european ombudsman german citizen novemb strasbourg mr söderman receiv group student programm intern legal cooper faculti law vrije universiteit brussel gave overview role european ombudsman mr söderman lunch mr olof salmen presid nordic council occas visit strasbourg novemb mr salmen accompani mr berglind ausgeirsdottir director gener secretariat nordic council mr susann eriksson senior advis åland landst mr gui lindström secretari gener finnish deleg nordic council mr söderman receiv group teacher handelsskolen ballerup denmark novemb gave overview work european ombudsman mr peter gjerloeff bonnor doctor research law depart european univers institut visit european ombudsman offic novemb conduct interview mr söderman mr harden mr leif sévon judg court justic european commun mr virpi tiili judg court instanc visit european ombudsman offic strasbourg decemb mr söderman gave overview work mr sévon mr tiili gave lectur jurispud court legal offic ombudsman offic mr pallic local ombudsman resid tourist citi calvià majorca visit offic ombudsman decemb mr pallic mr söderman inform respect role function exchang view professor moreiro centr european legal studi univers carlo iii madrid accompani student paid visit european ombudsman decemb decemb ombudsman invit speaker lunch kangaroo group occas attend member european parliament support kangaroo group guest mr söderman gave speech explain kind problem submit european citizen european ombudsman public european ombudsman question answer brochur intend potenti complain inform broader public work ombudsman brochur wide distribut inform offic european parliament european commiss member state offic nation ombudsmen similar bodi relai network info centr europ euro info point european document centr euro librari number specif target consum organis chamber commerc profession organis demand brochur high origin print run copi exhaust reprint european ombudsman figur gener eu public inform programm citizen joint initi european parliament european commiss part inform programm european citizen ombudsman intend make full opportun inform interact provid internet ombudsman establish separ address websit http www euro ombudsman eu int basic inform ombudsman annual report import speech decis ombudsman brochur complaint form site easili access european parliament websit vice versa link europa server begin wider rang materi press releas summari ombudsman decis includ updat regular basi inform internet addit substitut convent form public continu access greater proport popul access internet annual report ombudsman present european parliament juli distribut european institut intern ombudsman institut ombudsmen member state univers librari european document centr media print offici journal european commun made ombudsman websit media relat effect mass media import object inform strategi mass media reach peopl real reason complain maladministr activ commun institut bodi inform european citizen gener exist function ombudsman press confer arrang regularli member state mr söderman visit special occas inaugur european ombudsman offic strasbourg april inaugur cover journalist occas present ombudsman annual report european parliament strasbourg juli mr söderman dinner group journalist member state attend press confer arrang committe petit juli mr nikolao papakyriazi chairman committe petit februari mr söderman invit tradit thursdai lunch strasbourg press club gave speech role duti european ombudsman member club addit mr söderman met group journalist visit member state visit brussel strasbourg includ british section european associ journalist london juli group nordic journalist member nordisk journalistcent april brussel group radio journalist daili new denmark radio septemb strasbourg attend meet brussel nation union journalist septemb receiv group journalist member state strasbourg mr söderman gave interview roman school children april italian televis programm deal children idea european union programm produc cooper dg commiss mr bordri interview european ombudsman lettr de européen novemb strasbourg addit interview media visit member state mention mr söderman gave interview journalist newspap magazin radio televis member state inter alia european voic european insid dutch algemen dagblad nrc handelsblad belgian de morgen german badisch zeitung swedisn dagen nyhet finanstidningen finnish turun sanomat keskisuomalainen ilkka nykypäivä time german wirtschaftswoch eu magazin dutch bbc radio franc inter radio franc international deutsch well radio nederland radio portuguesa italian rai swedish sverig radio sverig radio gotland finnish radio yle televis española danmark televis swedish stv finnish televis yle mtv mr söderman gave interview media european union chilean newspap el mercurio hungarian newspap magyar hirlap japanes televis station japan broadcast compani european parliament decis ecsc ec euratom march regul gener condit govern perform ombudsman duti oj complaint mr bunyan close settl institut summari chapter point entitl conserv draft agenda council justic home affair minist end ombudsman inquiri complaint continu decis ec oj case judgment april case judgment octob parliamentari commission act section administr handbook relev context council europ recommend state administr author exercis discretionari power pursu purpos power confer observ object imparti take account factor relev case observ principl equal law avoid unfair discrimin maintain proper balanc advers effect decis right liberti interest person purpos pursu take decis time reason regard matter stake appli gener administr guidelin consist manner time take account circumst case administr handbook pe fin oj council regul eec eec march applic decis acp eec council minist transit measur appli march oj case star fruit commiss ecr case sonito commiss ecr sonito commiss case ecr case ecr commiss ensur provis treati measur institut pursuant thereto appli case commiss european commun hellen republ ecr paragraph case commiss european commun hellen republ ecr paragraph case commiss european commun ireland ecr paragraph case commiss european commun feder republ germani ecr paragraph oj oj oj case valentini ecr propos june oj council regul june applic social secur scheme emploi person emploi person member famili move commun oj case vougiouka ika ecr state paragraph articl regul eec exclud scope regul special scheme civil servant person treat entail request aggreg refus satisfi direct applic articl treati recours coordin rule adopt council case bakk aloya council ecr case prai council ecr case council direct eec oj case transocean marin paint associ commiss ecr paragraph oj oj council decis eec juli commun action plan assist tourism oj commun action plan assist tourism timet prioriti invit tender call propos oj oj oj oj oj case commiss hellen republ ecr paragraph case commiss feder republ germani ecr paragraph oj oj join case ecr ii case barcella commiss ecr case esli commiss ecr case mller council eu eaec ecsc ecr case lesli brown court justic ecr case michael becker court auditor ecr ii case ecr paragraph judgment septemb seri case commiss feder republ germani ecr paragraph oj case commiss germani ecr paragraph oj case commiss germani ecr case adia interim sa commiss ecr ii pargraph case agenc européenn interim commiss ecr pargraph case koyo seiko council ecr ii paragraph oj oj oj oj oj council regul eec june oj commiss decis ecsc ec euratom februari public access commiss document oj ombudsman seek solut institut bodi concern elimin instanc maladministr satisfi complaint declar attach final act treati european union interinstitut declar democraci transpar subsidiar octob oj case european parliament angelo innamorati ecr ibid commiss recommend ec payment period commerci transact oj sec case oj case noonan commiss ecr ii ecr ii oj oj ecr ii oj oj case aran ecr case aguirr borrel ecr case vlassopoul ecr annual report oj pp oj annex statist work european ombudsman gt tabl gt annex ombudsman budget articl financi regul european commun ombudsman transmit european parliament year estim revenu expenditur year statut european ombudsman ombudsman budget annex section european parliament gener budget european commun publish offici journal european commun salari allow cost relat employ contain titl budget titl includ cost mission titl budget cover build equip miscellan oper expenditur avoid unnecessari duplic administr technic staff servic need ombudsman provid european parliament servic involv addit direct expenditur parliament charg made payment effect liaison account rental offic translat servic largest item expenditur dealt begin establish plan ombudsman consist post end post temporari total amount appropri ombudsman budget ecu titl salari allow cost relat employ amount ecu titl build equip miscellan oper expenditur amount ecu tabl actual expenditur term appropri commit gt tabl gt revenu consist deduct remuner ombudsman staff term payment receiv total revenu ecu budget prepar establish plan repres increas establish plan total appropri ecu titl salari allow cost relat employ amount ecu titl build equip miscellan oper expenditur ecu budget total revenu deduct remuner ombudsman staff ecu annex personnel ombudsman european ombudsman jacob söderman secretariat european ombudsman main offic av du président robert schuman strasbourg cedex tel fax ian harden princip offic tel josé martinez aragon senior legal offic tel olivi verheeck legal offic tel vicki kloppenburg legal offic tel benita brom legal offic tel ms katja heed legal offic ilta helkama press offic tel francesca mancini assist tel daniela tirelli assist tel panayoti thanou assist tel nathali christmann secretari european ombudsman administr offic tel muriel richardson secretari secretari european ombudsman tel isabel foucaud secretari tel stephani kunz secretari tel patrick schmitt usher tel traine xavier denoël ida palumbo brussel antenna rue wiertz brussel tel fax peter dyrberg senior legal offic tel ursula garderet secretari tel anna ruscitti secretari strasbourg tel traine hanna mari anttilainen