commiss decis septemb state aid germani plan implement kronopli notifi document number german text authent text eea relev ec commiss european commun regard treati establish european commun subparagraph articl thereof regard agreement european econom area articl thereof call interest parti submit comment pursuant provis regard comment procedur letter date decemb germani notifi commiss plan award invest grant kronopli gmbh heiligengrab brandenburg hereinaft quot kronopli quot multisector framework region aid larg invest project quot multisector aid framework quot notifi aid regist letter date februari sg commiss inform germani decis initi procedur laid articl ec treati commiss decis initi procedur publish offici journal european union commiss call interest parti submit comment letter date march germani submit comment letter date luther menold rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbh submit comment behalf kronopli comment forward germani novemb detail descript aid notif present case relat case commiss approv aid kronopli juli sg commiss approv gross aid intens kronopoli multisector aid framework connect construct product plant orient strand board quot osb quot heiligengrab brandenburg assist area mean articl ec treati aid intens set percentag point lower maximum relev market consid declin commiss calcul assess criteria appli determin maximum allow aid intens multisector aid framework order compli criteria maximum allow aid intens calcul competit factor capit labour factor region impact factor amount aid involv million calcul competit factor caus disagr commiss germani side agre relev market consist osb plywood product germani initi provid studi show market declin commiss doubt studi result hing exception strong demand growth compar previou year inform exchang occas germani reduc notifi aid intens letter date decemb germani notifi intent grant aid kronopli multisector aid framework januari commiss request inform meet held januari repres german govern land brandenburg compani involv commiss german govern provid request inform letter date februari februari letter april commiss addit question germani repli letter date june germani reduc notifi aid intens letter date juli sg commiss inform germani object aid letter date januari germani request amend commiss decis provid evid growth demand estim achiev market declin letter date februari commiss refus amend earlier decis aid assess basi correct calcul relev factor specif commiss amend decis reason assess competit factor reli comparison evolut appar consumpt product question growth rate manufactur period forecast time decis correct notif attempt made notif achiev maximum intens reject previous grant addit aid equival germani argu market definit origin notif factual wrong refer articl council regul ec march lai detail rule applic articl ec treati quot regul ec quot revoc decis condit quot commiss revok decis decis base incorrect inform provid procedur determin factor decis quot relev market defin origin notif osb plywood germani claim newli submit studi show relev market correctli defin osb segment plywood market definit relev market declin period concern point multisector aid framework full aid intens approv decis initi procedur commiss compli request germani basi definit substitut product relev market limit osb segment plywood commiss reassess market fundament element miss gave rise doubt aid compat common market lack incent commiss express doubt exist incent effect notifi aid invest made aid provid incent derog laid articl ec treati region develop appli lack necess commiss doubt aid invest made consid facilit develop econom activ econom area mean articl case point aid intens suffici trigger invest comment germani germani insist commiss reassess market accord articl regul ec aid grant joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur commiss approv region aid scheme commiss duti simpli assess measur notifi compli requir set approv aid scheme compat multisector aid framework aid concern notif fulfil requir aid measur invest aid oper aid european court instanc confirm judgment kronopli notifi addit aid chang exist aid commiss classifi aid notif oper aid ground project complet possibl notifi aid measur confirm court meaningless comment interest parti kronopli insist notif invest project support line argument rule court case european court instanc confirm kronopli addit aid chang exist aid quot nation author deni notifi measur aid grant exist aid measur amend quot similar opinion express nuov industri molisan srl quot commiss decis preclud possibl italian author notifi project introduc aid favour applic amend aid grant quot kronopli emphas commiss assess notif merit advanc main argument commiss reli earlier market assess base factual wrong market definit kronopli possibl court review commiss origin decis interest affect kronopli deni lack incent support view main argument point guidelin nation region aid quot region aid guidelin quot test incent read quot addit aid scheme lai applic aid submit work start project quot kronopli fulfil requir appli nation author aid start project aid provid desir incent fulfil criterion necess view promot econom develop mean articl ec treati kronopli consist appli aid intens reduct intens notifi aid aid longer formal procedur eighteen month advantag recipi receiv immedi part aid admiss challeng commiss assess consid comment submit germani kronopli commiss maintain posit decis institut procedur reassess market multisector aid framework fundament element incent necess miss present case elig invest cost mean region aid guidelin commiss take view present notif date decemb regard separ notif aid kronopoli albeit aid give rise invest job addit elig cost mean region aid guidelin justifi grant addit aid commiss approv invest aid kronopli amount million decis sg juli base inform provid german author time decid rais object approv aid final propos germani decis accept germani kronopli aid subsequ grant german author kronopli complet invest project januari eighteen month commiss final decis year complet invest project germani provid market definit notif decemb explain basi studi relev market correctli defin market osb segment plywood state decis open formal investig procedur commiss circumst reconsid previou decis take view submiss market definit germani subsum articl regul ec line judgment court instanc kronopli commiss consid member state notifi commiss approv addit aid chang approv project tranch state aid project provid incent effect necess aid establish tranch germani notifi addit invest project plan kronopli addit complet project project financ complet year aid project notifi commiss conclus notif design simpli achiev higher aid intens reject previous addit elig cost aid approv incent effect necess court justic european commun rule germani commiss commiss aid oper aid grant impos oblig part recipi intend improv liquid situat undertak incent effect commiss consid forego comment suffici show grant addit aid lead invest incent effect expand concept incent effect respons comment submit germani kronopli invest process busi invest dynam process import differenti ant post stage compani decid ant undertak invest base calcul expect revenu cost project expect return invest project higher requir rate return embark project region aid incent compani chang behaviour invest region invest invest undertaken difficult revers post substanti part specif asset easili redeploi sell asset seller lose invest capit ant assess incent effect region aid guidelin point region aid guidelin appli test determin aid incent effect beneficiari appli aid start project condit fulfil commiss assum incent effect comment germani kronopli claim test point region aid guidelin met kronopli submit aid applic start project test point design check incent effect unduli delai invest full analysi econom circumst recipi invest decis prove difficult time consum hold invest econom develop region assess presenc incent effect addit aid kei question differ chang incent effect influenc kronopli invest decis prior invest kronopli aid eventu receiv assess adjust factor multisector aid framework discret commiss kronopli unsur grant aid intens assum expect intens lie valu depend probabl attach outcom kronopli base invest decis expect amount aid commiss note kronopli decid undertak invest precis amount aid aid intens kronopli complet invest aid intens approv prepar risk attach aid intens fact kronopli met test point region aid guidelin expect extra percentag point provid incent effect post assess incent effect basi fact examin close ant decis kronopli commiss consid reli fact appar kronopli decid invest continu oper grant aid intens invest project complet origin plan kronopli scale invest project respons lower aid intens aid grant kronopli chang behaviour indic aid induc increas product enlarg product facil invest carri reason assum kronopli shut product receiv aid commiss conclus grant aid provid incent effect state decis initi procedur aid measur promot develop econom activ econom area mean articl ec treati act incent case point invest carri aid incent lead invest job creation commiss posit justifi aid increas invest job creation mean articl conclud addit aid constitut oper aid necess statement decis initi procedur commiss consid principl necess deriv directli logic state aid control declar aid compat articl ec treati establish aid contribut attain object normal market condit recipi firm achiev action accord commiss standard practic confirm court justic european commun philip morri explain paragraph plan aid provid incent invest job creation requir recipi quid pro quo contribut object common interest oper aid cover current cost kronopli bear point region aid guidelin prohibit oper aid exception aid grant region elig derog articl provid justifi term contribut region develop natur ii level proport handicap seek allevi germani demonstr exist handicap shown addit aid contribut region develop evid fact aid kronopli decid continu oper lower aid intens approv mean kronopli run viabl econom oper event aid stage aid provid windfal profit kronopli commiss conclud present case aid compat articl ec treati region develop lastli examin derog articl applic derog articl concern aid social charact grant individu consum aid make good damag caus natur disast except occurr aid grant compens econom disadvantag caus divis germani appli case aid consid aid project common european interest remedi disturb german economi provid articl object promot cultur heritag conserv provid articl articl approv aid facilit develop econom activ econom region aid advers affect trade condit extent contrari common interest aid found incompat articl incent effect aid declar compat articl reason conclus commiss conclud notifi aid constitut state aid mean articl ec treati aid incent effect derog articl appli aid constitut incompat oper aid implement adopt decis articl state aid notif germani plan implement kronopli amount incompat common market aid implement articl germani inform commiss month notif decis measur compli articl decis address feder republ germani brussel septemb commiss neeli kroe member commiss oj oj footnot osb wooden panel construct consist layer quot strand quot made primarili pine timber frame construct refurbish restor build prefabr build industri packag industri consist invest aid form repay grant amount million gener plan joint feder govern länder scheme improv region econom structur ii invest allow million invest allow law oj amend act access case kronopli commiss ecr ii footnot paragraph case nuov industri molisan srl commiss ecr ii paragraph footnot paragraph oj case germani commiss ecr paragraph case philip morri commiss ecr