Distinct Roles for Dectin-1 and TLR4 in the Pathogenesis of Aspergillus fumigatus Keratitis
[['Fungal infections of the cornea ( i . e . fungal keratitis ) account for approximately 1% of corneal ulcers in temperate regions of industrialized nations [1] .', 'However , in tropical regions of developed countries , such as in the southeastern United States , fungal infections of the cornea account for up to 35% of all corneal ulcers resulting in severe visual impairment and blindness [1]–[3] .', 'Globally , the impact of fungal keratitis on visual health is even greater , with reports of up to 60% of corneal ulcers attributable to fungal infection in developing nations including China , Nepal , India , Bangladesh , Ghana and Mexico [4]–[11] .', 'The etiological agents of these corneal infections are most commonly filamentous Fusarium ( F . solani , F . oxysporum ) [1] , [12] , and Aspergillus species ( A . flavus , A . fumigatus , nomius [13] , A . tamarii [14] , A . terreus , and A . tubingensis [15] , [16] ) , which are prevalent in hot , humid climates , and where the predominant risk factor is traumatic injury associated with agricultural work .', 'As Aspergillus is ubiquitous in the environment , the population at large is constantly exposed to this opportunistic pathogen [17]–[19] , and conidia are inhaled at an estimated 200 conidia per day [19]–[21] .', 'In areas of high endemicity , A . fumigatus can also be isolated from the conjunctival sac of healthy individuals [22] .', 'Thus , in the setting of a disrupted corneal epithelium , there is broad opportunity for inoculation of A . fumigatus conidia ( 2–3 µm diameter ) or conidiophores ( >100 individual conidia per hyphal stalk ) from airborne vegetative matter or the conjunctiva into the corneal stroma in association with traumatic injury [8] , [23] .', 'Subsequently , fungal virulence factors that facilitate hyphal invasion of the tissue ( e . g . toxin and protease secretion ) [24]–[29] , together with low efficacy of anti-mycotic therapy [30]–[32] , and the resulting inflammatory response all converge to induce destruction of corneal tissue .', 'Treatment failure also occurs in up to 60% of patients , who may require at least one and sometimes repeated corneal transplantation , and in severe cases results in enucleation of the infected eye [23] , [31] .', 'In contrast to pulmonary aspergillosis , which is associated with immune suppression , fungal keratitis occurs in otherwise healthy , immunocompetent individuals .', 'Despite the impact of filamentous fungal infections on global blindness , and a recent outbreak of contact lens-associated Fusarium keratitis in the USA [12] , the pathogenesis of this disease is not well understood .', 'We therefore developed a murine model of corneal infection using Aspergillus that constitutively express dsRed fluorescent protein at each stage of development , and are therefore readily detected in the transparent cornea .', 'Our findings demonstrate that Dectin-1 mediates the initial wave of pro-inflammatory and chemotactic cytokine production and cellular infiltration into the cornea .', 'We also show that the IL-1R1/MyD88 pathway further propagates cellular recruitment into the cornea during Aspergillus infection , and that in contrast to Dectin 1 , TLR4 does not regulate cellular infiltration , but is essential for anti-fungal activity .'], ['To visualize A . fumigatus during infection of the transparent mammalian cornea , we generated a monomeric dsRED RFP-expressing A . fumigatus strain .', 'Figure S1 illustrates the structure of the plasmid , and shows expression of RFP at each lifecycle stage of Aspergillus .', 'To determine the role of the host response to these organisms in the cornea , C57BL/6 mice were either treated systemically with cyclophosphamide ( cyc ) , or were left untreated prior to injecting 1×105 Af293 . 1RFP conidia into the corneal stroma ( Preliminary studies revealed that 1×105 conidia was the smallest inoculum in which organisms could be recovered from the cornea after 24h ) .', 'Corneal opacification , fungal growth , survival , and cellular infiltration were assessed at each time point .', 'Figure 1A shows that at 24h post-infection , immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice developed significant corneal opacity , which peaked at 48h , and persisted up to 72h post-infection .', 'However , cyclophosphamide-treated mice had significantly lower corneal opacification scores than immunocompetent mice at 48 and 72h post-infection .', 'To characterize the host response in Aspergillus keratitis , 5µm corneal sections were stained with PASH and examined by brightfield microscopy .', 'As shown in Figure 1B , there was a pronounced cellular infiltration in the corneas of immunocompetent mice between 24 and 72h , with neutrophils also present in the anterior chamber ( for comparison , a PASH stained section of a normal mouse cornea is shown in Supplementary Figure S2A ) .', 'In contrast , there was less cellular infiltration in corneas of cyclophosphamide-treated mice at each time point .', "There was also enhanced fungal penetration though Descemet's membrane and into the anterior chamber at 48 and 72h post-infection , and increased epithelial debridement in cyclophosphamide treated mice compared with immunocompetent mice .", 'Figure 1C shows that cells in the C57BL/6 cornea are NIMP-R14+ neutrophils , and that the numbers increased over time .', 'Neutrophils were not detected in corneas of cyclophosphamide-treated mice at any time post-infection , and in contrast to immunocompetent mice , longer-term infection of treated mice results in corneal perforation ( data not shown ) .', 'To quantify corneal opacification and hypertrophic and filamentous fungal growth during corneal infection , we used image analysis software that provides numerical output for corneal opacification and for fungal dsRed expression for all animals in the experiment rather than representative mice .', 'Figure 1D shows a representative image analysis derivation , which shows color ( pixel ) intensity .', 'Using this method , we found that opacification was significantly lower in cyclophosphamide treated animals ( Figure 1E ) .', 'Conversely , fungal dsRed expression was significantly elevated in corneas of cyclophosphamide-treated mice compared with immunocompetent mice at each time point ( Figure 1F ) .', 'There was no detectable red fluorescence in uninfected mice ( Figure S2 ) .', 'To examine fungal viability , eyes were homogenized , and the number of colony forming units ( CFU ) was determined by standard methods .', 'Figure 1G depicts a 1 log-fold reduction in fungal CFU in immunocompetent mice between 48h and 72h post-infection , whereas CFU were not reduced in cyclophosphamide-treated C57BL/6 corneas over this time period .', 'Together , these findings identify a resistant phenotype in immunocompetent animals , where there is a pronounced neutrophil infiltration to the corneal stroma , resulting in controlled fungal growth .', 'These findings also show a susceptible phenotype illustrated by cyclophosphamide treated mice , where neutrophil recruitment to the corneal stroma is impaired , fungal growth continues unabated , and the cornea eventually perforates .', 'The predominant cells in the corneal stroma are keratocytes , which produce collagen and proteoglycans that comprise the extracellular matrix; however there is also a population of resident macrophages and dendritic cells at this site [33] , [34] .', 'To determine if resident macrophages and dendritic cells mediate the initial recognition of A . fumigatus in the cornea , we utilized Macrophage Fas Induced Apoptosis ( Mafia ) mice , which express eGFP and a membrane bound suicide protein under control of the myeloid-lineage specific c-fms promoter [35] , [36] .', 'In these mice , all macrophages and dendritic cells express eGFP constitutively , and undergo cell-lineage specific apoptosis after cross-linking the FK506 binding domain of the membrane-bound suicide protein using the FK506 dimerizer AP20187 [36] .', 'We showed previously that eGFP+ macrophages/dendritic cells are readily identified in the corneas of naïve untreated Mafia mice , and that eGFP expressing cells are depleted in AP20187-treated Mafia mice [35] .', 'To ascertain the role of macrophages and dendritic cells in Aspergillus keratitis , Mafia mice were treated with AP20187 , and infected with 1×105 Af293 . 1RFP conidia .', 'Corneas of untreated Mafia mice developed opacification at 24 and 48h after infection , consistent with increased eGFP+ cellular infiltration to the corneal stroma and dsRed expressing Aspergillus hyphae ( Figure 2A ) .', 'In contrast , corneas of AP20187-treated Mafia mice had decreased opacification , and significantly increased dsRed expressing Aspergillus hyphae ( Figures 2A ) .', 'Cellular infiltration to the corneal stroma was absent in infected AP20187-treated Mafia mice as shown by the absence of eGFP+ cells ( Figure 2A ) and in histological sections ( Figure 2B ) .', 'To determine if the impaired cellular infiltration is related to pro-inflammatory and chemotactic cytokine production , corneas were dissected from untreated and AP20187-treated Mafia mice at 10h after intrastromal injection of Af293 . 1RFP conidia or PBS ( trauma control ) , and prior to detectable cellular infiltration .', 'Corneas were homogenized , and CXCL1/KC and IL-1β production were examined by ELISA .', 'Figure 2C shows that both CXCL1/KC and IL-1β were elevated in untreated , but not AP20187-treated corneas from Mafia mice .', 'Figures 2D–F show image analysis based quantification of corneal opacification , eGFP+ cell infiltration , and RFP expression for individual corneas in the experiment and reveal significantly lower corneal opacification ( Figure 2D ) and eGFP+ cell infiltration ( Figure 2E ) in AP20187-treated Mafia mice .', 'Conversely , dsRed hyphae ( Figure 2E ) and CFU ( Figure 2F ) were significantly higher in corneas of AP20187-treated Mafia mice compared with untreated Mafia mice , indicating that cfms+ cells regulate fungal growth and survival ( Figure 2G ) .', 'Taken together , these data show that resident c-fms+ macrophages and dendritic cells in the naïve cornea produce IL-1β and CXCL1/KC , which likely mediate neutrophil recruitment into the cornea , and subsequently limit Aspergillus growth and survival .', 'As resident cfms+ macrophages and dendritic cells are essential for early cytokine production in the cornea after Aspergillus infection , they are likely the first cells to respond to germinating conidia .', 'We therefore examined the pathogen recognition molecules initiating this response , including Dectin-1 , TLR2 and TLR4 .', 'Dectin-1 is a C-type lectin expressed by myeloid-derived cells that recognizes β-glucan when it is exposed on the cell wall , and β-glucan expression in Aspergillus occurs in germinating , but not dormant conidia , and in hyphal stages [37]–[39] .', 'We examined β-glucan and Dectin-1 expression and activation in the cornea after Aspergillus infection .', 'As shown in Figure 3A , PASH stained corneas revealed swollen conidia ( 6h ) and hyphae ( 24h ) ; further , β-glucan expression was apparent in both forms , especially at 24h when hyphal forms predominated , indicating that Aspergillus expresses the ligand for Dectin-1 during corneal infection .', 'To determine the effect of Aspergillus on Dectin-1 protein levels in the cornea , we dissected corneas 10h after infection or after injection with PBS ( trauma controls ) , and processed the corneas for western blot analysis .', 'Dectin-1 was not detected in naïve and PBS-injected corneas; however , as early as 10h after Aspergillus infection , Dectin-1 was clearly expressed in the cornea ( Figure 3B ) Further , phosphorylated Spleen Tyrosine Kinase ( Syk ) was elevated in infected corneas , compared with naïve and trauma controls ( Figure 3C ) .', 'Given that Syk phosphorylation is indicative of Dectin-1 activation [40] , these findings indicate that not only is Dectin-1 expressed in the cornea , but that it is also activated during Aspergillus infection .', 'As we found β-glucan expression in vivo , and increased Dectin-1/pSyk activation in infected corneas , we next examined the role of Dectin-1 during Aspergillus keratitis .', 'Dectin-1−/− and control 129SvEv mice were injected intrastromally with Af293 . 1RFP conidia , and corneal opacification , cellular infiltration , and fungal survival were measured as before .', 'As shown in Figure 4A , corneal opacification was evident in 129SvEv corneas by 24h post-infection , increased at 48h and decreased at 72h , whereas corneal opacification was significantly lower in Dectin-1−/− mice at 24h and 48h .', 'However , there were no significant differences between Dectin-1−/− and control , 129SvEv corneas in fungal dsRed expression ( Figure 4A ) .', 'To determine the role of Dectin-1 in cytokine production and cellular infiltration to the cornea , Dectin-1−/− and 129SvEv mice were infected as before , eyes were processed for histology , and 5µm sections were stained with PASH .', 'As shown in Figure 4B , cellular infiltration in 129SvEv mice was similar to infected C57BL/6 mice , with pronounced cellular infiltration at each time point .', 'In contrast , Dectin-1−/− corneas had impaired cellular infiltration at each time point .', 'To examine if the decreased cellular infiltration in Dectin-1−/− mice was associated with pro-inflammatory and chemotactic cytokine production , corneas were dissected and homogenized at 10h post-infection ( prior to detectable cellular infiltration ) , and CXCL1/KC and IL-1β were measured by ELISA .', 'Consistent with impaired cellular infiltration , infected Dectin-1−/− corneas had significantly less CXCL1/KC and IL-1β compared with 129SvEv mice ( Figure 4C ) .', 'Quantification by image analysis shows elevated corneal opacification in 129SvEv compared with Dectin-1−/− mice 24h and 48h after infection ( Figures 4D ) , but no difference in fungal RFP expression ( Figures 4E ) .', 'Consistent with the latter observation , there were no differences in fungal CFUs between Dectin-1−/− and 129SvEv mice at any time point examined ( Figure 4F ) .', 'These findings demonstrate that Dectin-1 regulates cytokine production in the cornea , cellular infiltration to the corneal stroma and development of corneal opacification; however , Dectin-1 expression was not required to regulate growth and survival of strain Af293 . 1RFP .', 'Failure to detect increased survival of Af293 . 1RFP in Dectin-1−/− mice , despite decreased cellular infiltration at all stages post-infection , led us to hypothesize that fungal survival in Dectin-1−/− mice is dependent on the virulence of the infecting A . fumigatus strain .', 'We therefore infected Dectin-1−/− and 129SvEv mice with a clinical isolate from a patient with fungal keratitis .', 'Injection of Strain Af-BP into the 129SvEv cornea induced corneal opacification at 24h post-infection , which increased after 48 and 72h ( Figure 5A ) .', 'In contrast to strain Af293 . 1RFP , the Af-BP isolate also caused engorgement of limbal blood vessels after 48h , and hemorrhage after 72h post-infection ( Figure 5A ) , and may be reflective of the characteristic angio-invasiveness of clinical A . fumigatus isolates [41] .', 'Dectin-1−/− mice exhibited impaired cellular infiltration ( Figure 5B ) , and had significantly lower corneal opacification at 24 and 48h post-infection with Strain Af-BP ( Figure 5C ) , which was similar to infection with strain Af293 . 1RFP .', 'However , in contrast to infection with Af293 . 1RFP , fungal CFUs recovered from infected corneas were significantly elevated in Dectin-1−/− compared with 129SvEv mice at 48 and 72h post-infection ( Figure 5D ) .', 'There were no apparent structural differences between naïve Dectin-1−/− and wild type corneas ( data not shown ) .', 'To determine if Dectin-1 regulation of Af-BP but not Af293 . 1RFP survival is related to β-glucan surface expression , we cultured strains Af293 . 1RFP , Af-BP , and the lung isolate B-5233 in SDA media for 6h or 10h , and examined β-glucan expression as described above .', 'β-glucan was not detected on resting conidia of Af293 . 1RFP or the clinical isolates ( data not shown ) .', 'However , at 6 h ( swollen and germinating conidia ) , there was significantly higher surface β-glucan expression in the clinical isolates Af-BP and B-5233 compared with laboratory strain Af293 . 1RFP ( Figure 5E , F ) .', 'β-glucan surface expression on hyphae after 10h growth was also quantified; as shown in Figure 5G , H , there were no significant differences among these strains at this time point .', 'These findings indicate that strains with high surface β-glucan expression on germinating conidia are more likely to be detected by Dectin-1 and to induce a more pronounced cellular infiltrate , resulting in increased fungal killing .', 'Since macrophage depleted Mafia mice and Dectin-1−/− mice exhibited impaired cellular recruitment to the cornea during Aspergillus infection , we next examined the role of Dectin-1 in activation of bone marrow derived macrophages ( BMMs ) by A . fumigatus .', 'Af-BP swollen conidia were isolated after 6h incubation with Sabouraud dextrose media , fixed , and incubated with 129SvEv or Dectin-1−/− BMMs at an MOI\u200a=\u200a100 .', 'After 15 , 30 , and 60 min , cells were lysed , and Syk and Iκb phosphorylation were detected by western blot analysis , and NFκB nuclear translocation was examined after incubation with anti-p65 antibody .', 'Figure 6A shows Syk phosphorylation in 129SvEv BMMs after 15 min incubation , which was sustained for 30 and 60 min .', 'In contrast , p-Syk was not detected in Dectin-1−/− BMMs until 60 min post-exposure .', 'P-Syk was not detected in naïve BMM or after LPS stimulation .', 'Similarly , IκB phosphorylation was elevated in 129SvEv BMMs after 15 min incubation with swollen conidia compared with naïve BMM; however , elevated P-Syk was not detected in Dectin-1−/− BMMs until 60 min incubation ( Figure 6A ) .', 'Additionally , A . fumigatus-induced CXCL1/KC production by BMMs from 129SvEv mice was significantly higher than BMMs from Dectin-1−/− mice ( Figure 6B ) .', 'As shown in Figure 6C , D , NF-κB p65 nuclear translocation was apparent in 129SvEv BMM after 30 min and 60 min , but not in Dectin-1−/− BMMs within this time period .', 'As cell-associated conidia were detected in the p65 translocation experiments , and Dectin-1 – mediated phagocytosis has been shown to inhibit cell signaling [42] , we examined the effect of Dectin-1 on cell associated conidia .', 'BMM were incubated with swollen conidia at 100 MOI as described above , then incubated with Calcofluor white to identify conidia [43] .', 'Cell association was examined by DIC and fluorescence microscopy , and quantified by direct counting .', 'As shown in Figures 6E-G , Dectin-1−/− BMM had significantly less conidia associated with each macrophage than 129SvEv BMMs ( Figure 6F ) .', 'Similarly , the percent of total Dectin-1−/− BMM macrophages with associated conidia was also significantly lower than 129SvEv BMMs ( Figure 6G ) .', 'Together , these data indicate that A . fumigatus conidia bind Dectin-1 on resident corneal macrophages , which then stimulates Syk and NFκB–dependent production of CXCL1/KC that is important for neutrophil recruitment to the cornea .', 'To determine the role of TLR2 and TLR4 in Aspergillus keratitis , C57BL/6 , TLR2−/− and TLR4−/− mice were injected intrastromally with Af293 . 1RFP conidia , and corneal opacification , cellular infiltration , fungal growth and fungal survival were measured as described above .', 'As depicted in Figure 7A–C , there were no significant differences between TLR2−/− and C57BL/6 mice in any of these parameters , indicating that TLR2 has no role in corneal infection with these organisms .', 'Similar results were obtained with clinical isolate Af-BP ( data not shown ) .', 'Figure 7D , E illustrate that as with TLR2−/− mice , there were no significant differences in corneal opacification , cellular infiltration or fungal RFP expression between TLR4−/− and C57BL/6 corneas; however , in marked contrast to TLR2−/− mice , significantly more CFU were recovered from TLR4−/− mice after 48h compared with C57BL/6 mice ( Figure 7F ) , indicating an impaired ability of TLR4−/− mice to clear the infection , and suggesting a role for TLR4 in fungal killing .', 'Increased CFU was also detected in TLR4−/− corneas infected with the Af-BP clinical isolate at 48h and 72h after infection ( Table 1 ) , indicating that the role for TLR4 is consistent among Af strains .', 'Despite the difference in CFU , there was no difference in cellular infiltration between TLR4−/− and C57BL/6 and TLR2−/− corneas ( Figure 7G , H ) , nor any differences in fungal RFP expression ( Figure 7I , J ) .', 'Given the role for TLR4 in fungal viability , we also examined the role of TLR4 co-receptor MD-2 , which binds lipid A of Gram negative bacteria .', 'Corneas of C57BL/6 , TLR4−/− , and MD-2−/−corneas were infected with Af293 . 1RFP , and CFU were quantified after 24 , 48 , and 72h .', 'As before , CFU recovered from corneas of TLR4−/− mice were significantly higher than C57BL/6 at 72h post-infection Figure 7K .', 'However , despite the documented role for MD-2 in responding to LPS , there was no difference in fungal survival in MD-2−/− compared with C57BL/6J mice , indicating that the role of TLR4 fungal killing is MD-2 independent .', 'Given that fungal survival is dependent on TLR4 , and TLR4 signaling involves the adaptor molecules MyD88 , MAL/TIRAP and TRIF ( MyD88: myeloid differentiation primary-response gene 88; TIRAP: toll-interleukin 1 receptor domain containing adaptor protein , which is also called MAL:MyD88-adaptor-like protein; TRIF: TIR-domain-containing adaptor protein inducing IFNβ [44] ) , we next examined the role of these adaptor molecules in cellular infiltration and fungal killing .', 'C57BL/6 , MyD88−/− , TIRAP−/− and TRIF−/− mice were injected intrastromally with Af293 . 1RFP conidia , and markers of infection were examined as before .', 'Figure 8A shows that MyD88−/− mice had less corneal opacification scores at 24h compared with C57BL/6 mice , but not 48h after infection; conversely , MyD88−/− corneas also had increased fungal RFP ( Figure 8A ) .', 'We found impaired cellular infiltration in the corneal stroma of MyD88−/− mice compared with C57BL/6 mice at 24h ( Figure 8B ) ; however , at 48h , there was an intense cellular infiltration into the MyD88−/− corneas .', 'Image analysis shows significantly lower corneal opacification ( Figure 8C ) , but higher fungal RFP expression ( Figure 8D ) in MyD88−/− mice versus C57BL/6 mice .', 'Consistent with the latter observation , Figure 8F shows significantly increased fungal CFU at 48h post-infection in MyD88−/−mice .', 'These data demonstrate that MyD88 regulates early cellular infiltration and fungal survival in Aspergillus keratitis .', 'Further , even though cellular infiltration is detected in MyD88−/−mice after 48h , there was no difference in CFU , indicating a role for MyD88 on the ability of neutrophils and infiltrating macrophages to kill Aspergillus .', 'To determine if MyD88 is due to TLR4 signaling , we infected mice deficient in TIRAP , which is essential for MyD88 signaling by TLR4 .', 'We also infected mice deficient in TRIF , which mediates the TLR4 ( and TLR3 ) , MyD88-independent signaling pathway [45] .', 'Figure 9A shows that TRIF−/− and TIRAP−/− mice develop corneal opacification that is not different from C57BL/6 mice .', 'Similarly , the presence of dsRed Aspergillus in the corneas of TRIF−/− and TIRAP−/− mice was similar to C57BL/6 mice .', 'Image analysis also showed no difference in opacity or dsRed expression , respectively , between C57BL/6 , TRIF−/− , and TIRAP−/− mice ( Figure 9B , C ) .', 'In addition , there was no difference in fungal CFU among the three strains at either 24h or 48h ( Figure 9D ) or in cellular infiltration among these strains ( Figure 9E ) .', 'These findings indicate that although MyD88 has a critical role in Aspergillus keratitis , there is no apparent involvement of TIRAP or TRIF .', 'The role of MyD88 , but not TIRAP in Aspergillus keratitis led us to conjecture that the IL-1 receptor ( IL-1R1 ) , which signals through MyD88 independently of TIRAP , could mediate cellular recruitment during Aspergillus keratitis .', 'To test this hypothesis , we injected 1×105 A . fumigatus conidia into the corneas of C57BL/6 and IL-1R1−/− mice .', 'Figure 10A shows that IL-1R1−/− mice had significantly lower corneal opacification and increased fungal RFP expression and survival at 24 and 48h post-infection .', 'Conversely , there was significantly less cellular infiltration into the corneal stroma of IL-1R1−/−mice compared with C57BL/6 mice ( Figure 10B ) .', 'Image analysis revealed decreased corneal opacity at 24h ( Figure 10C ) and increased fungal dsRed expression at 48h post-infection in IL-1R1−/− mice compared to C57BL/6 mice ( Figure 10D ) .', 'Correspondingly , Figure 10E shows increased fungal CFU 48h post-infection in IL-1R1−/− mice compared to C57BL/6 mice .', 'Taken together , these observations indicate that IL-1R1 mediates early cellular infiltration and fungal survival in Aspergillus keratitis , which is a similar phenotype to MyD88−/− mice .'], ['Aspergillus is a major cause of visual impairment and blindness worldwide; however , the nature of the host response to these organisms in the cornea is not well understood .', 'Our findings show that critical components of the innate immune response in the cornea include c-fms+ macrophages and dendritic cells in addition to Dectin-1 , TLR4 , MyD88 , and IL-1R1 .', 'We also showed that there was no role for MD-2 , TLR2 , TIRAP or TRIF .', 'Taken together , these observations are consistent with a sequence of events that is initiated by expression of β-glucan on germinating conidia in the corneal stroma , and recognition by Dectin-1 expressed on resident corneal macrophages and dendritic cells .', 'Dectin-1 mediated activation of p-Syk , p-IκB , and translocation of NFκB to the nucleus of these cells results in production of CXCL1/KC and IL-1β within 10h of infection , and recruitment of neutrophils to the corneal stroma .', 'Neutrophils kill Aspergillus by attaching to hyphae and releasing cytotoxic proteases , antimicrobial peptides , and reactive oxygen species [46] .', 'Although this inflammatory response causes corneal opacification , the corneas eventually heal , leaving scarified tissue .', 'However , blockade of this response at any of these stages allows the organisms to grow unimpaired , resulting in corneal perforation .', "Germinating Aspergillus conidia encounter a dense , highly organized matrix in the corneal stroma , with anti-parallel layers of collagen separated by keratan sulfate proteoglycans that are essential for corneal transparency; however , the growing hyphae migrate through the stromal matrix and penetrate the basement ( Descemet's ) membrane of the corneal endothelium , which forms the barrier to the anterior chamber .", 'Unless killed by neutrophils entering the anterior chamber from iris vessels ( seen as a hypopyon in infected individuals ) , hyphae can penetrate the posterior eye and cause endophthalmitis , at which point enucleation of the infected eye is often indicated .', 'Although the cornea was long considered to be an immune privileged tissue , it has been well established that macrophages and dendritic cells are resident in the corneal stroma and epithelium [47]–[52] .', 'Recently , a role for macrophages in mediating Fusarium and Candida keratitis was identified [53] .', 'Similarly , in the present study we identified c-fms+ resident macrophages and dendritic cells as essential mediators of cellular recruitment and fungal survival into the cornea during A . fumigatus infection , implicating bone marrow derived cells rather than corneal epithelial cells or fibroblasts as the cellular mediators of innate immune recognition [53] .', 'In the current study , we found that β-glucan is not only expressed on Aspergillus germinating conidia and hyphae in vitro as shown previously [37]–[39] , but is also expressed during corneal infection .', 'Furthermore , Syk phosphorylation was detected in infected corneas , and Syk and IκB were phosphorylated in bone marrow macrophages in a Dectin-1 dependent manner .', 'Correspondingly , both NFκB translocation to the nucleus , and CXCL1/KC and IL-1β production were significantly lower in Dectin-1 deficient compared with control macrophages .', 'Similarly , Dectin-1−/− corneas had impaired pro-inflammatory cytokine production and cellular infiltration compared with control corneas .', 'These findings indicate that expression of Dectin-1 on resident corneal macrophages is essential for the initial innate immune recognition of A . fumigatus , for the subsequent pro-inflammatory cytokine response , and ultimately for cellular recruitment into the cornea .', 'We also found that the physical association of swollen conidia with bone marrow macrophages , which includes attachment and phagocytosis , is dependent on Dectin-1 expression .', 'This observation is consistent with reports showing Dectin-1 dependent phagocytosis of β-glucan coated particles [42] , [54] , and that phagocytosis inhibits Dectin-1 signaling [42] , indicating that macrophage interactions with hyphae that are too big to be ingested may have enhanced signaling compared with conidial forms .', 'Our findings also indicate a possible role for Dectin 1 in early killing of swollen conidia and germ tubes rather than hyphae , where we found no differences in β-glucan staining among the A . fumigatus strains .', 'Taken together , it is likely that during corneal infection , macrophages and neutrophils utilize Dectin-1 to bind conidia and germ tube developmental stages of A . fumigatus , which can be phagocytosed and presumably killed .', 'Results from the current study are consistent with reports on pulmonary aspergillosis in which germinating Aspergillus conidia in the lungs express β-glucan , and Dectin-1 mediates cellular infiltration and fungal killing [38] , [39] .', 'Our data are also in agreement with a recent study showing that Dectin-1−/− mice have lower cytokine and chemokine production in the lungs after intratracheal infection , resulting in impaired neutrophil recruitment and increased susceptibility to Aspergillus [56] .', 'The role of Dectin-1 in responding to Aspergillus therefore appears to be conserved in the cornea and lungs .', 'Although studies with fungal cell wall components indicate that Dectin-1 and TLR2 collaborate in recognizing β-glucan [57]–[59] , we found no role for TLR2 in Aspergillus keratitis , indicating that Dectin-1 mediates cellular recruitment independently of TLR2 .', 'Additionally , TLR2-independent receptor collaboration occurs in a sequential manner during non-opsonic phagocytosis of C . albicans by macrophages , where Dectin-1 , CR3 , and mannose receptors collaborate in recognition and phagocytosis [60] .', 'In the current study , phagocytosis of swollen A . fumigatus conidia was impaired in Dectin-1−/− bone marrow macrophages , raising the possibility that a similar collaboration occurs during macrophage phagocytosis of this pathogen .', 'In support of this notion , the mannose receptor was one of the few genes found to be upregulated in a microarray analysis of Aspergillus –infected corneas [61] .', 'Future studies will determine if a similar mechanism occurs for macrophage phagocytosis of Aspergillus conidia .', 'In pulmonary aspergillosis , TLR2 and TLR4 have no role in otherwise immunocompetent animals , although Aspergillus CFU were elevated in vinblastin- or cyclophosphamide-treated TLR2−/−and TLR4−/− mice [62] , [63] .', 'In contrast , we showed increased Aspergillus CFU in TLR4−/− , but not TLR2−/− mice .', 'Although this is consistent with our earlier observation that TLR4−/− mice have impaired clearance of Fusarium in the cornea [64] , the mechanism of TLR4 regulation of Aspergillus survival has yet to be determined .', 'Given that TLR4−/− mice exhibit defects in fungal killing but not cellular recruitment , we predict that the primary role for TLR4 is on infiltrating neutrophils and macrophages that mediate fungal killing rather than on resident macrophages , which regulate cell recruitment to the cornea .', 'Further , as fungal clearance is unimpaired in MD-2−/− corneas , and MD-2 is the binding site for the lipid A moeity of LPS [65] , [66] , TLR4 likely recognizes Aspergillus hyphae at
['Introduction', 'Results', 'Discussion', 'Materials and Methods']
['Aspergillus species are a major worldwide cause of corneal ulcers , resulting in visual impairment and blindness in immunocompetent individuals .', 'To enhance our understanding of the pathogenesis of Aspergillus keratitis , we developed a murine model in which red fluorescent protein ( RFP ) -expressing A . fumigatus ( Af293 . 1RFP ) conidia are injected into the corneal stroma , and disease progression and fungal survival are tracked over time .', 'Using Mafia mice in which c-fms expressing macrophages and dendritic cells can be induced to undergo apoptosis , we demonstrated that the presence of resident corneal macrophages is essential for production of IL-1β and CXCL1/KC , and for recruitment of neutrophils and mononuclear cells into the corneal stroma .', 'We found that β-glucan was highly expressed on germinating conidia and hyphae in the cornea stroma , and that both Dectin-1 and phospho-Syk were up-regulated in infected corneas .', 'Additionally , we show that infected Dectin-1−/− corneas have impaired IL-1β and CXCL1/KC production , resulting in diminished cellular infiltration and fungal clearance compared with control mice , especially during infection with clinical isolates expressing high β-glucan .', 'In contrast to Dectin 1−/− mice , cellular infiltration into infected TLR2−/− , TLR4−/− , and MD-2−/− mice corneas was unimpaired , indicating no role for these receptors in cell recruitment; however , fungal killing was significantly reduced in TLR4−/− mice , but not TLR2−/− or MD-2−/− mice .', 'We also found that TRIF−/− and TIRAP−/− mice exhibited no fungal-killing defects , but that MyD88−/− and IL-1R1−/− mice were unable to regulate fungal growth .', 'In conclusion , these data are consistent with a model in which β-glucan on A . fumigatus germinating conidia activates Dectin-1 on corneal macrophages to produce IL-1β , and CXCL1 , which together with IL-1R1/MyD88-dependent activation , results in recruitment of neutrophils to the corneal stroma and TLR4-dependent fungal killing .']
['Corneal infection with filamentous fungi , including Aspergillus species , is a common cause of visual impairment and blindness in the southern USA and worldwide .', 'The incidence in India and China greatly increases during harvest season when infection occurs after traumatic injury with fungal spores ( conidia ) .', 'In contrast to pulmonary aspergillosis , keratitis occurs in immunocompetent individuals .', 'To characterize the host response , we injected Aspergillus fumigatus conidia expressing red fluorescence into the transparent mouse cornea , and showed that cytokine production , neutrophil and monocyte recruitment to the corneal stroma and fungal killing is dependent on the presence of macrophages and dendritic cells , and on expression of the β-glucan receptor Dectin-1 .', 'We also found that fungal killing , but not cellular infiltration , is dependent on expression of the LPS receptor TLR4 .', 'In addition , we demonstrate that IL-1R1 and MyD88 regulate neutrophil recruitment and fungal killing in Aspergillus keratitis , whereas TLR4 associated adaptor molecules TRIF and TIRAP have no role .', 'Together , these findings identify specific mediators of the innate immune response to these organisms that regulate disease severity and survival of Aspergillus that may have potential application as targets for therapeutic intervention .']
['infectious diseases/fungal infections', 'immunology/leukocyte activation']