Neonatal Restriction of Tactile Inputs Leads to Long-Lasting Impairments of Cross-Modal Processing
[['Most environmental events provide inputs to multiple senses that need to be integrated into a unified percept .', 'Multisensory interactions have been observed both in higher-order brain regions and in primary sensory cortices [1–4] .', 'Exposure to cross-modal stimuli has been shown to modulate the neuronal firing of cortical neurons and to shape the power and phase of oscillatory network activity [5–7] .', 'Direct cortico-cortical connectivity [8] and feed-forward projections from thalamic nuclei [9] represent possible anatomical substrates of efficient multisensory processing at the cortical level .', 'Furthermore , this multisensory processing in primary sensory areas supports the decoding of behaviorally relevant information and thereby improves task performance [10] .', 'While the multisensory abilities are indispensable for daily life , their emergence is a progressive and protracted process that continues well after the development of individual senses [11 , 12] .', 'For example , one of the earliest forms of multisensory integration in humans has been described at two months of age , when vowel information in faces and voices are matched [13] .', 'In kittens , the first multisensory neurons were detected in the superior colliculus ( SC ) during the second postnatal week [14] .', 'However , other multisensory processes do not reach adult level until adolescence [15 , 16] .', 'The crucial requirements and processes controlling the development of multisensory interactions at the level of primary sensory cortices remain mechanistically unsolved .', 'This knowledge gap is particularly striking in rodents , which have been shown to express highly multisensory abilities at the level of primary sensory cortices [8] .', 'In contrast to multisensory maturation , the mechanisms underlying the unisensory development are better understood .', 'The processing of unimodal stimuli is considered to rely on a highly precise wiring of the corresponding neuronal networks in the primary sensory cortices .', 'The maturation of the neural circuitry is initiated under the control of molecular cues and subsequently refined by both experience-independent and experience-dependent electrical activity [17–20] .', 'The experience-dependent refinement peaks during defined developmental stages , which have been termed critical or sensitive periods [21 , 22] .', 'Unimodal inputs during these periods are crucial for shaping neuronal networks according to the environment and individual features .', 'Hence , deprivation or reduction of unimodal input during this time results in abnormal patterns of neuronal activity in the corresponding primary sensory cortex and permanent behavioral impairment , whereas manipulation of the input before or after these periods is overall less detrimental [23 , 24] .', 'While the development of multisensory processes in the SC neurons seems to depend on genuine cross-modal experience [25] , it remains unclear which type of inputs controls the development of multisensory processing within neocortical networks .', 'Here , we aimed at elucidating the role of early unisensory experience for the development of multisensory interactions in the primary visual ( V1 ) and somatosensory ( S1 ) cortices as well as of multisensory object recognition in rats .', 'We provide electrophysiological , anatomical , and behavioral evidence that neonatal unimodal inputs prior to the cross-modal experience are necessary for the correct maturation of multisensory processing by contributing to the setting up of structural and functional coupling within cortical networks .'], ['Since previous studies showed that unimodal experience during early development is crucial for the refinement of corresponding cortical networks and topographic maps , we assessed the impact of transient whisker trimming on the anatomy and tactile processing in S1 .', 'We firstly analyzed the structural changes in the barrel field of NWT rats post-mortem ( Fig 2A ) .', 'Similar to previous findings [27] , the overall cytoarchitecture ( i . e . , number and position of barrels ) of the posteromedial barrel subfield corresponding to the major whiskers was not affected by deprivation .', 'The size of individual cytochrome oxidase-stained ( COX ) barrels was slightly increased in the NWT rats ( n = 7 ) when compared to the corresponding barrels in CON rats ( n = 7 ) , but none of the differences reached significance level ( Fig 2B , S1B Table ) .', 'Second , we characterized the effects of neonatal tactile restriction on unisensory evoked potentials ( EPs ) elicited by a mechanical deflection of the principal whiskers .', 'Extracellular local field potentials ( LFPs ) were recorded simultaneously in S1 and V1 of lightly urethane-anesthetized NWT ( n = 9 ) and CON ( n = 10 ) rats using electrodes with 16 recording sites that covered the entire cortical depth .', 'All recordings were conducted under urethane anesthesia to avoid the impact of varying alert states on multisensory processing [28] .', 'Whisker deflection elicited in all cortical layers [supragranular ( S ) , granular ( G ) and infragranular ( I ) ] of the contralateral S1 of all investigated rats EPs with a depth profile characterized by layer specific polarity ( Fig 2C ) .', 'EPs consisted of a first prominent peak with positive surface polarity ( P1 ) followed by additional negative and positive peaks ( N1 , P2 ) .', 'The absolute amplitude of tactile EPs in G and I layers was larger in NWT rats when compared to CON rats ( Fig 2C and 2F ) .', 'In contrast , the absolute amplitude of tactile EPs in the S layer was decreased in NWT compared to CON animals .', 'Thus , the neonatal restriction caused specific changes of unimodal processing in the S1 .', 'In line with our previous findings [8] , the S1 responded to visual stimulation via light flashes , yet the evoked responses were significantly smaller when compared to tactile EPs and had the same polarity over all cortical layers , suggesting that they are at least partially volume conducted ( e . g . , non-specifically electrically spread at a distance from their source generator ) .', 'However , these low-amplitude visually evoked responses in the S1 differed between CON and NWT rats ( Fig 2D and 2G ) .', 'Additionally , such plasticity was also induced for a non-deprived modality , since the EPs evoked by light flashes in the contralateral V1 differed between CON and NWT rats ( Fig 2E and 2H ) .', 'The S1 seems to integrate simultaneously presented spatially congruent ( i . e . , in the same hemifield ) whisker deflections and light flashes as reflected by the supra-additive enhancement of the EPs .', 'Their magnitude was larger than the arithmetic sum of responses evoked by unimodal tactile and visual stimulations [8] .', 'To assess the effects of neonatal tactile restriction on these multisensory interactions , we compared the bimodal EPs in NWT and CON rats .', 'In CON rats , a supra-additive enhancement of the P1 peak after congruent visual-tactile stimulation was detected in all cortical layers when compared to unimodal stimulation ( Fig 3A , S1C Table ) .', 'Most prominently , in the G layer the absolute amplitude of multisensory P1 peak ( 581 . 8 ± 6 . 9 μV ) was larger when compared to the unisensory response ( 552 . 9 ± 7 . 1 μV , p = 0 . 003 ) and the arithmetic sum of EPs resulting from tactile and visual stimulation ( 536 . 9 ± 8 . 0 μV , p < 0 . 001 ) .', 'Here , also the amplitude of the N1 peak was significantly augmented by bimodal stimulation ( 133 . 1 ± 2 . 5 μV versus unimodal: 98 . 6 ± 2 . 7 μV , p = 0 . 001 and arithmetic sum: 123 . 5 ± 3 . 8 μV , p = 0 . 016 ) , exceeding the enhancing effect of unimodal visual stimulation on the tactile response .', 'In contrast , this multisensory EP enhancement was significantly reduced in NWT rats .', 'The absolute P1 amplitude in the G layer was similar after uni- and cross-modal stimulation ( tactile , 621 . 6 ± 13 . 5 μV; unimodal arithmetic sum , 641 . 0 ± 14 . 8 μV; bimodal , 644 . 9 ± 13 . 4 μV; p = 0 . 73 , p = 0 . 95 ) .', 'Moreover , the multisensory enhancement of the N1 peak ( 167 . 2 ± 4 . 4 μV ) reached significance level only when compared to tactile stimulation ( 124 . 4 ± 4 . 4 μV , p < 0 . 001 ) , but not when compared to the arithmetic sum of unimodal stimulations ( 166 . 0 ± 7 . 9 μV , p = 0 . 38 ) .', 'However , we cannot fully exclude the possibility that this small multisensory effect in NWT rats partially resulted from the volume-conducted visual responses in S1 ( s . above ) .', 'In any case , it can be concluded that neonatal whisker trimming diminished the multisensory enhancement of evoked activity in S1 .', 'Besides affecting the evoked activity , cross-modal stimulation has been reported to influence the cortical networks by modulating the stimulus-induced oscillatory activity ( i . e . , related but not locked to the stimulus ) and the spontaneous ongoing oscillations ( i . e . , not causally related to the stimulus ) [8 , 29] .', 'To get first insights into the ontogeny of these modulatory processes , we quantified the multisensory power change of induced oscillatory activity at different time points after the stimulus onset for both NWT ( n = 9 ) and CON rats ( n = 10 ) .', 'Baseline-normalized wavelet spectra were used to calculate the power of oscillatory activity .', 'For time windows of significant power change between tactile and bimodal stimulation ( 150–230 ms , 440–550 ms , and 850–900 ms post-stimulus ) the differences between the two conditions were calculated and averaged ( S1 Fig ) .', 'As previously reported [8] , the strongest modulatory effect of congruent bimodal stimuli on the power of induced activity of CON rats has been observed for the G layer ( 150–230 ms: 1 . 20 ± 0 . 41 times higher unisensory versus multisensory , p = 0 . 002; 440–550 ms: 0 . 57 ± 0 . 15 times higher multisensory versus unisensory , p = 0 . 002; 850–900 ms: 0 . 47 ± 0 . 15 times higher multisensory versus unisensory , p = 0 . 015 ) .', 'Power modulation after congruent bimodal stimulation was equally detected in NWT rats ( 150–230 ms: 2 . 36 ± 0 . 70 times higher unisensory versus multisensory , p = 0 . 002; 440–550 ms: 0 . 15 ± 0 . 43 times higher multisensory versus unisensory , p = 0 . 6; 850–900 ms: 0 . 11 ± 0 . 13 times higher multisensory versus unisensory , p = 0 . 43 ) ( S1C Table ) .', 'However , its magnitude , especially at later time windows post-stimulus , was lower .', 'These changes were most prominent in the G layer ( 440–550 ms: p = 0 . 006; 850–900 ms: p = 0 . 025 ) ( Fig 3B ) .', 'The modulation of the power of oscillatory activity in CON and NWT rats was not accompanied by changes in population firing of S1 neurons .', 'Analysis of the multi-unit activity ( MUA ) pre- and post-stimulus revealed the absence of multisensory effects in both groups of rats ( n = 10 CON rats , n = 9 NWT rats ) ( S2 Fig ) .', 'Next , we assessed the effects of neonatal tactile restriction on the ongoing spontaneous activity ( i . e . , network activity non-related to the stimulus ) in the S1 .', 'Cross-modal phase reset of network oscillations has been identified as a major cortical mechanism of multisensory interactions [5 , 6] .', 'It has been hypothesized that timing of the neuronal activity by such a phase reset increases the processing efficiency of the stimulus [30] .', 'In CON rats ( n = 9 ) , contralateral visual stimuli induced a prominent phase reset in all S1 layers that was detected as a concentration of a specific oscillatory phase in the histograms of phase resultant vector length ( S3 Fig ) .', 'Among the different frequency bands of oscillatory activity , the strongest phase reset was confined to 8–12 Hz ( Fig 3C ) .', 'For NWT rats ( n = 10 ) , the phase reset persisted , yet switched to a lower frequency ( 4–8 Hz ) ( Fig 3C ) .', 'Thus , neonatal tactile restriction altered multisensory processing in the adult S1 by perturbing the power modulation and the phase reset of network oscillations .', 'To identify the substrate of altered multisensory processing after neonatal tactile restriction , we investigated the structural and functional communication between V1 and S1 of CON and NWT rats .', 'We firstly examined the direct visual-somatosensory intrahemispheric projections in NWT ( n = 5 ) and CON rats ( n = 7 ) by injecting small amounts of the retrograde tracer Fluorogold ( FG ) into their S1 ( Fig 4 ) .', 'Bright fluorescent back-labeled parental cell bodies in V1 feed-forwardly projecting to the ipsilateral barrel field were detected both in NWT and CON rats , indicating that intrahemispheric visual-somatosensory projections emerge even in the absence of unimodal stimuli during neonatal development .', 'However , the maximal density of retrogradely labeled neurons was significantly ( p = 0 . 023 ) lower ( 3–26 cells/0 . 16 mm2; mean: 8 . 6 ± 4 . 5 cells/0 . 16 mm2 ) in the V1 of NWT rats when compared to CON rats ( 11–56 cells/0 . 16 mm2; mean: 28 . 6 ± 6 . 4 cells/0 . 16 mm2 ) ( S1D Table , S4 Fig ) .', 'Thus , unimodal restriction during neonatal development led to a “sparsification” of the direct connectivity between S1 and V1 .', 'To test whether this reduced cortico-cortical connectivity after neonatal tactile restriction is accompanied by an impairment of the functional communication between primary sensory cortices , we assessed the impact of bimodal versus unimodal stimulation on the network synchrony between V1 and S1 of NWT ( n = 9 ) and CON rats ( n = 10 ) ( Fig 5 ) .', 'The mean values of relative coherence were separately calculated for bimodal and unimodal stimulation conditions and their difference was averaged over 12–80 Hz ( S5 Fig ) .', 'In CON rats , bimodal stimulation significantly increased the intrahemispheric coherence between all layers of S1 and V1 by 0 . 058 ± 0 . 033 , p = 0 . 008 ( S ) , 0 . 088 ± 0 . 034 , p = 0 . 017 ( G ) , and 0 . 067 ± 0 . 03 , p = 0 . 03 ( I ) when compared to unimodal stimulation ( Fig 5A ) .', 'The interhemispheric S1-V1 synchrony after bimodal versus unimodal stimulation was similarly affected in NWT rats ( Fig 5B , S1E Table ) , even if their augmented coherence was below the significance threshold ( S: 0 . 043 ± 0 . 040 , p = 0 . 469; G: 0 . 074 ± 0 . 040 , p = 0 . 12; I: 0 . 073 ± 0 . 035 , p = 0 . 095 ) .', 'The symmetric interdependence of coherence precluded reliable insights into the directionality of precisely timed interactions between S1 and V1 .', 'To test for causal information flow between primary sensory cortices in adult rats with and without neonatal tactile restriction , we performed Granger analysis for the V1 and S1 activity and plotted the directionality changes after bimodal versus unimodal stimulation ( blue color in time-frequency plot: weaker directionality; red color in time-frequency plot: stronger directionality ) ( Figs 6 and S6 ) .', 'In CON rats ( n = 10 ) , the bimodal stimulation modulated the directed interactions between the primary sensory cortices by decreasing the drive from V1 to S1 during the first 200 ms post-stimulus and increasing it afterwards ( Fig 6A–6C ) .', 'In these rats , the drive from S1 to V1 was equally modulated by bimodal stimulation , yet the communication increased after stimulus , the strongest effect being detected within the time-window 0–200 ms post-stimulus ( Fig 6D–6F , S1F Table ) .', 'This cross-modal modulation of directed interactions V1 → S1 and S1 → V1 was decreased in NWT rats .', 'The observed changes were particularly strong 200 to 1 , 000 ms after the stimulus in S and G layers ( Fig 6B , 6C , 6E and 6F ) .', 'These results indicate that transient tactile restriction during neonatal development decreased the functional communication between S1 and V1 in line with the sparsification of monosynaptic cortico-cortical projections .', 'To assess the behavioral correlate of impaired multisensory processing at the neural level after transient neonatal tactile restriction , we tested CON ( n = 51 ) and NWT rats ( n = 51 ) in a modified cross-modal novel object recognition task ( NOR ) [31] .', 'This task uses the intrinsic preference of rodents for novel objects [32] .', 'Rats were allowed to explore two identical objects during the sample phase .', 'Subsequently , one of these two identical objects was replaced by a novel object with different features during the choice phase .', 'The paradigm was conducted under four sensory conditions ( S7 Fig ) .', 'We allowed', '( i ) simultaneous visual and tactile exploration ( bimodal condition ) ,', '( ii ) only tactile exploration ( tactile condition , i . e . , the experiment was performed under red light to prevent visual exploration ) or', '( iii ) only visual exploration ( visual condition , i . e . , objects were placed under familiar glass containers to prevent tactile interactions ) .', 'The fourth condition was used to test whether rats could match tactile with visual information ( cross-modal condition ) .', 'For this , the sensory modality used for object exploration differed between the sample and the choice phase .', 'Rats needed to transfer the cross-modal information between modalities to recognize the novel object .', 'These four conditions were tested in two experimental settings .', 'In the first setting , termed as continuous setting , each rat was consecutively assigned to the bimodal , one unimodal and the cross-modal conditions .', 'In contrast , in the second setting , termed as discrete setting , each rat was assigned to only one condition ( S7 Fig , S2 Table ) .', 'The familiarization phase was identical for both settings .', 'Since in an open field pre-test the travelled distance , speed of locomotion , the duration and occurrence of rearing , wall-rearing , and grooming , as well as the time spent in the different areas of the open field was similar for CON and NWT rats , differences in locomotor and anxiety behavior between groups were excluded ( Fig 7 , S1G Table ) .', 'In both settings , CON and NWT rats spent more time with the exploration of the new object compared to the time spent with the exploration of the familiar object when they relied on both senses ( continuous setting , CON: 65 . 5 ± 2 . 8% of the total time , p < 0 . 001; NWT: 61 . 8 ± 4 . 2% , p < 0 . 001; discrete setting , CON: 65 . 1 ± 5 . 7% of the total time , p = 0 . 002; NWT: 63 . 5 ± 4 . 8% , p = 0 . 001 ) ( Fig 8 ) .', 'Similarly , the rats relying on tactile perception explored the novel object longer ( continuous setting , CON: 64 . 8 ± 2 . 8% of the total time , p < 0 . 001; NWT: 71 . 1 ± 7 . 9% , p < 0 . 001; discrete setting , CON: 65 . 7 ± 5 . 2% of the total time , p < 0 . 001; NWT: 67 . 1 ± 5 . 3% , p = 0 . 009 ) .', 'In both groups of rats the visual recognition of the novel object was less precise than the tactile recognition and this was independent of the experimental settings ( continuous setting , CON: 62 . 7 ± 7 . 0% of the total time , p = 0 . 025; NWT: 55 . 6 ± 5 . 6% , p = 0 . 18; discrete setting , CON: 64 . 94 ± 7 . 0% of the total time , p = 0 . 009; NWT: 53 . 39 ± 3 . 84% , p = 0 . 241 ) .', 'For bimodal , tactile and visual conditions , the discrimination ratio did not differ between groups and experimental settings .', 'Under cross-modal conditions , CON rats spent significantly longer time exploring the novel object ( continuous setting , 59 . 7 ± 3 . 3% of the total time , p = 0 . 002; discrete setting , 57 . 4 ± 4 . 3% of the total time , p = 0 . 027 ) , whereas NWT rats failed recognizing the novel object ( continuous setting , 47 . 7 ± 3 . 5% , p = 0 . 37; discrete setting , 44 . 97 ± 5 . 03% of the total time , p = 0 . 179 ) .', 'In only this matching test , the recognition performance of NWT rats was lower when compared to CON rats ( Figs 8 and S1H ) .', 'These results indicate that transient tactile restriction during neonatal development permanently impairs cross-modal matching abilities , while leaving the unimodal object recognition largely unaffected .'], ['Cross-modal modulation of neuronal assemblies in primary sensory cortices is an important mechanism of multisensory processing in adult rodents [8] and across much of the brain in more complex species .', 'To which degree the development of this mechanism depends on uni- or cross-modal experience is still unresolved .', 'The present study provides first insights into the essential requirements of the neural basis of multisensory development .', 'We demonstrate that unimodal experience during neonatal development', '( i ) refines the somatosensory topography and tactile processing in S1 ( Figs 1 and 2 ) ,', '( ii ) shapes visual-tactile interactions in S1 and along the subcortico-cortical sensory tract ( Fig 3 ) ,', '( iii ) ensures the correct maturation of direct cortico-cortical projections ( Fig 4 ) ,', '( iv ) enables multisensory communication by synchrony and modulation of directed interactions within adult cortico-cortical networks ( Figs 5 and 6 ) , and', '( v ) is necessary for the development of cross-modal matching abilities ( Figs 7 and 8 ) .', 'These findings point towards a sensitive/critical period in the multisensory maturation of both neuronal networks and behavior .', 'Unimodal input and thus , experience-driven electrical activity , has been shown to shape and refine the structure and function of cortical circuits [23 , 33] .', 'For example , monocular deprivation during development dramatically alters the V1 topography , visually induced responses , and visual acuity of the deprived eye [34 , 35] .', 'Similarly , tactile deprivation of the vibrissal sensory system by permanent damage of the sensory periphery ( cauterization or lesion of follicle sinuses ) causes extensive structural changes in S1 [36] .', 'Besides this irreversible and complete tactile deprivation , even transient restriction of tactile inputs in neonatal rats by daily whisker trimming seems to affect the morphology of barrels .', 'In line with the increased dendritic span and spine density of spiny stellate neurons in layer IV after transient vibrissal deprivation [27 , 37] , the size of the barrels in NWT rats was slightly , yet not significantly , increased ( Fig 2 ) .', 'During neonatal development , the transient absence of unimodal inputs may decrease the global level of activation within neonatal S1 , since it diminishes non-whisking related ( so-called spontaneous ) patterns of oscillatory activity and the individual neuronal firing [18 , 38 , 39] .', 'The changed timing of individual spiking , which most likely resulted from the reduced spontaneous activity , perturbed the developmental Hebb-like processes that control the refinement of projections [40] .', 'Thus , the absence of unisensory experience during a defined developmental time window may have long-lasting structural and functional effects on unisensory processing .', 'At adulthood , tactile EPs were enhanced in NWT rats ( Fig 2 ) .', 'This increase in amplitude correlated with the enlarged excitatory receptive fields and augmented cellular responses in layer IV [41] .', 'Since the responses of neurons in layer II/III were normal [42] , this altered evoked activity most likely reflects an impairment of thalamo-cortical responses .', 'Moreover , the neonatal tactile restriction has been reported to cause permanent behavioral deficits in texture discrimination or gap crossing tests [27 , 43] .', 'In contrast , we did not observe significant deficits in tactile object recognition skills ( Fig 8 ) .', 'This discrepancy may be explained by the lower sensorimotor complexity of the present matching task .', 'In addition to the deficits in unisensory processing , the transient tactile restriction during neonatal development caused reduced multisensory processing in S1 ( Fig 3 ) .', 'In contrast to the effects observed in CON rats , neither the EPs were supra-additively enhanced nor the induced activity was modulated by a cross-modal stimulus in NWT rats .', 'It might be argued that the absence of a multisensory enhancement resulted from the effects of neonatal tactile restriction on unisensory processing .', 'As a result , an additional visual stimulus was not able to further augment the enlarged tactile responses in NWT rats .', 'However , a multisensory EP enhancement was not only absent in the G layers but additionally in the S layers , where the unisensory processing was not augmented by neonatal restriction .', 'Thus , we alternatively suggest that the absence of a multisensory enhancement in NWT rats was due to the fact that the transient unisensory deprivation affected not only the cortico-cortical processing , but also the feed-forward thalamo-cortical interactions .', 'We have previously shown that the cross-modal augmentation of early ( ~30 ms ) evoked responses in S1 results from the integration of sensory inputs along the sensory tract preceding primary cortices , most likely within thalamic nuclei [8] .', 'The absence of a cross-modal EP enhancement suggests that unisensory experience controls the emergence of multisensory integration at the subcortical level .', 'The mechanisms by which neonatal unimodal inputs shape the physiology of individual thalamic neurons [44] and the axonal patterning along the feed-forward sensory tract remain to be elucidated .', 'Most research of the past has investigated the emergence of multisensory processing in the SC and association cortices .', 'Multisensory interaction in these areas has been demonstrated to depend on sensory experience [25] .', 'When animals were reared in the dark [45 , 46] or in omnidirectional sound conditions [47] , SC neurons did not integrate any visual-nonvisual or auditory-nonauditory cue pairs , respectively .', 'Critically , these deprivation paradigms precluded not only unisensory but additionally concurrent experience with multiple modalities .', 'In contrast , in the present experimental paradigm we partially deprived the animals of tactile experience during an early neonatal time period when visual inputs activate neither the sensory periphery nor subcortical and cortical circuits ( Fig 1 ) .', 'The pigmented rats opened their eyes at P16–17 and the first visual evoked potentials in V1 emerged 2–3 d before eye opening , reflecting the onset of retinal light sensitivity [48] .', 'By this time , the length and function of neonatally-trimmed whiskers were already fully restored in NWT rats .', 'Thus , the reduction of tactile input during early development caused the multisensory deficits in NWT rats .', 'Though the alternative explanation that impairment of unisensory processing may contribute to multisensory deficits cannot be fully excluded , the intact tactile object recognition of NWT rats is inconsistent with this explanation .', 'Whether distinct intracortical circuits differently involving the S , G , and I layers mechanistically disconnect uni- and multisensory processing remains to be investigated .', 'The present study identified both structural and functional deficits within neocortical networks that might cause abnormal cross-modal processing after neonatal unisensory restriction .', 'Deprivation of a sensory modality has been reported to cause the reorganization of sensory systems for another modality ( cross-modal plasticity ) [49 , 50] .', 'For instance , permanent visual deprivation in neonatal hamsters or mice resulted in reciprocal connections between V1 and other brain regions , such as the major midbrain auditory nucleus , the inferior colliculus and S1 [51 , 52] .', 'Consequently , V1 neurons responded to tactile inputs by increasing their firing rate and synchronizing their depolarization [51 , 53] .', 'It has been hypothesized that these plastic effects are mediated by the stronger reliance on the remaining modality after deprivation [50 , 54] .', 'However , the present findings showed that transient unisensory restriction during neonatal development led to reduced rather than an exuberant V1-S1 connectivity ( Fig 4 ) .', 'In line with these results , visual inputs did not evoke an increased response in S1 in NWT rats .', 'Fewer projections coupling the primary sensory cortices of NWT rats may have caused a phase reset in an atypical , presumably suboptimal frequency band ( Fig 3 ) .', 'Setting of the oscillatory activity to a non-random instantaneous phase has been identified as a ubiquitous mechanism for increasing the processing efficiency of individual stimuli [55 , 56] .', 'A cross-modal phase reset might improve the predictability of the associated stimulus or cause an enhanced salience of the cross-modal stimulus , as proposed for visual-auditory interactions [57] .', 'A phase rest in a different frequency band , as observed in NWT rats , might either has prevented an efficient perceptual encoding or has caused a lower stimulus salience .', 'Consequently , we observed a lower cross-modal transfer during object recognition task in NWT rats .', 'Besides influencing the phase of ongoing oscillations , the fewer cortico-cortical projections seem to decrease the power , synchrony and drive between V1 and S1 in NWT rats ( Figs 5 and 6 ) .', 'The present data provide evidence for the critical role of neonatal unimodal experience for the establishment of multisensory interplay both at the neural and behavioral level .', 'Rats have previously been shown to own excellent skills for cross-modal object recognition [31] .', 'Our data confirmed these findings and identified unimodal inputs during development as a critical factor for the emergence of cross-modal matching abilities of object features ( Fig 8 ) .', 'Rats experiencing neonatal tactile restriction were not able to use previously acquired tactile information for recognizing visually explored objects and vice versa .', 'Remarkably , the behavioral changes were very robust and replicated under different experimental settings .', 'This suggests that learning effects did not influence the behavioral outcome and that the divergent features of objects used for testing did not allow unspecific familiarization .', 'In contrast to the reduced multisensory abilities , the unisensory object recognition was intact after neonatal restriction .', 'In both groups of rats visual discrimination of objects was worse than tactile object discrimination .', 'One explanation for this finding might be the weak saliency or contrast of the used objects or a too small distance to the objects .', 'The abilities for cross-modal object recognition seem to critically depend not only on unimodal sensory inputs during defined developmental stage but also on the integrity of the perirhinal and posterior parietal cortices important for memory retention and retrieval [31] .', 'The precise neural mechanisms integrating sensory and mnemonic aspects of the task remain to be elucidated .', 'In conclusion , the present findings demonstrate that the absence of adequate unisensory experience during a specific developmental period impairs the setting up of cortico-cortical and cortico-subcortical connectivity as well as functional network communication underlying multisensory behavior .'], ['Extracellular recordings were performed under light urethane anesthesia ( 0 . 5 g/kg ,', 'i . p .', ', Sigma-Aldrich , St . Louis , MO ) as previously described [8] .', 'One-shank 16-channel electrodes with 100 μm spacing between recording sites ( 0 . 5–3 MΩ , Silicon Michigan probes , NeuroNexus Technologies , Ann Arbor , MI ) were perpendicularly inserted into S1 ( 2 . 4–2 . 6 mm posterior and 5 . 5–5 . 8 mm lateral to bregma ) and V1 ( 6 . 9–7 . 1 mm posterior and 3 . 4–3 . 7 mm lateral to bregma ) bilaterally to a depth of 1 . 6 mm .', 'Electrodes were labeled with DiI ( 1 , 1′-dioctadecyl-3 , 3 , 3′ , 3′-tetramethyl indocarbocyanine , Invitrogen , Carlsbad , CA ) to enable the post-mortem reconstruction of electrode tracks in histological sections .', 'A custom-built stimulation device placed in front of the animal was used to achieve unimodal ( light-flash , whisker deflection ) or bimodal stimulation [8] .', 'During bimodal stimulation , whisker deflection and light-flashes ( 50 ms , 300 lx , full eye field stimulation ) were presented simultaneously in the same ( congruent ) hemifields with respect to the tactile stimulus .', 'During tactile stimulation , all whiskers were displaced by an upward moving stick activated through compressed air-controlled roundline cylinders gated via solenoid valves .', 'The stimulation device produced almost silent , nonelectrical stimulation with precise timing ( 0 . 013 ± 0 . 810 ms ) that was constant over all trials/ conditio
['Introduction', 'Results', 'Discussion', 'Materials and Methods']
['Optimal behavior relies on the combination of inputs from multiple senses through complex interactions within neocortical networks .', 'The ontogeny of this multisensory interplay is still unknown .', 'Here , we identify critical factors that control the development of visual-tactile processing by combining in vivo electrophysiology with anatomical/functional assessment of cortico-cortical communication and behavioral investigation of pigmented rats .', 'We demonstrate that the transient reduction of unimodal ( tactile ) inputs during a short period of neonatal development prior to the first cross-modal experience affects feed-forward subcortico-cortical interactions by attenuating the cross-modal enhancement of evoked responses in the adult primary somatosensory cortex .', 'Moreover , the neonatal manipulation alters cortico-cortical interactions by decreasing the cross-modal synchrony and directionality in line with the sparsification of direct projections between primary somatosensory and visual cortices .', 'At the behavioral level , these functional and structural deficits resulted in lower cross-modal matching abilities .', 'Thus , neonatal unimodal experience during defined developmental stages is necessary for setting up the neuronal networks of multisensory processing .']
['Our senses , working together , enable us to interact with the environment .', 'To obtain a unified percept of the world , diverse sensory inputs need to be bound together within distributed but strongly interconnected neuronal networks .', 'Many multisensory abilities emerge or mature late in life , long after the maturation of the individual senses , yet the factors and mechanisms controlling their development are largely unknown .', 'Here , we provide evidence for the critical role of unisensory experience during early postnatal life for the development of multisensory integration .', 'Focusing on visual-tactile interactions in pigmented rats with good visual acuity , we show that a transient reduction of tactile inputs during neonatal development leads to sparser direct connections between adult primary visual and somatosensory cortices .', 'As a result , these animals showed reduced neuronal activation following co-occurring tactile and visual stimuli , as well as impaired communication within visual-somatosensory networks .', 'The structural and functional deficits resulting from an early manipulation of tactile experience had major behavioral consequences , impairing the rats’ ability to transfer information about encountered objects between senses .', 'Thus , unisensory experience during early development shapes the neuronal networks of multisensory processing and the ability to transfer cross-modal information .']
[]
Reducing unisensory experience during neonatal development causes permanent disruption of connectivity between primary sensory cortices, resulting in impaired multisensory abilities.