Interference and Shaping in Sensorimotor Adaptations with Rewards
[['Transformations that map sensory inputs to motor commands are referred to as sensorimotor mappings [1] .', 'While sensorimotor mappings are already formed at early stages of development [2] , they are subject to modifications , since the brain , the body and/or the environment are constantly changing .', 'Plasticity in sensorimotor mappings has been extensively studied in situations where subjects receive sensory feedback during the task , allowing them to correct their motor actions and to adapt to the induced perturbation .', 'These include visuomotor rotation [3] , reaching movements under forcefields [4] , adaptation in a smooth pursuit eye movements [5] , prism adaptation [6] , and pitch perturbation in songbirds [7] and in humans [8] .', 'Although these studies involve different sensory modalities and different effectors , they are similar in the sense that they all have sensory goals ( targets ) and a motor gesture is made to reach the target .', 'They consist of three phases namely a standard phase , in which subjects perform the task under regular conditions followed by an adaptation phase , where subjects perform the same task under the perturbed condition and a washout phase during which the perturbation is removed , and the subject readapts toward baseline .', 'Remarkably , in all these three phases , movements display substantial trial to trial variability .', 'Recent theoretical as well as experimental studies suggested that this variability plays a crucial role in sensorimotor learning and adaptation processes [9]–[11] .', 'Another issue concerns the ability of subjects to generalize the adaptation from one context condition to a different context .', 'This has been investigated by testing how subjects perform upon presentation of sensory stimuli that were not present during the adaptation phase [12] , [13] .', 'Generalization is usually good for sensory stimuli that are similar to the one used during adaptation and degrades as the sensory stimuli become different [3] , [14] .', 'Remarkably , subjects can even perform worse than in baseline ( negative generalization ) for sensory stimuli which are very different from those which was presented to the subject during adaptation .', 'This has been observed , for instance , in motor reaching tasks , when the tested stimulus is presented in a direction which is opposite to the adapted direction [4] , [14] .', 'The above mentioned studies implicitly assumed that the neural mechanisms for adaptation are driven by a sensory feedback , which supplies a continuous error signal to the subject .', 'Yet , recent studies show that adaptation is possible even without any sensory feedback , when only a binary reward that informs on a success or a failure of a trial is provided to the subject [15]–[17] .', 'Moreover , recent experimental works suggest that reward based mechanisms also affect the adaptation dynamics in sensorimotor tasks even when a sensory feedback is available [18] , [19] .', 'However , and not surprisingly , adaptation relying solely on rewards at the end of a trial is more difficult than when a sensory feedback on the performance is provided continuously during the task , as adapting with sensory feedback conveys more information regarding errors .', 'For instance , when visual feedback is available in visuomotor rotation tasks , subjects adapt to large perturbation ( e . g . 30 degrees ) in a few dozen trials [3] , [20] , while in the absence of such feedback , but with binary ( success or a failure ) reward feedback , subjects find it notoriously difficult to adapt .', 'Recent studies , nevertheless , have shown that it is possible to adapt to large perturbations relying solely on rewards if the size of the perturbation is slowly increased between rewarded blocks of trials [17] , [21] .', 'The fact that progressively increasing the amount of perturbation makes it possible to adapt , even when the perturbation is large , is reminiscent of the classical shaping strategy [22] .', 'In shaping , the difficulty of the task is increased gradually in order to accelerate learning , or to even make it possible .', 'Although shaping is routinely used in laboratories when training animals to perform complex sensorimotor and cognitive tasks [23]–[25] , it is only in recent years that it started to be explored in a theoretical framework [26]–[28] .', 'What neural mechanisms could be involved in this reward based learning ?', 'Recent experimental evidence [29]–[31] indicates that rewards modulate local synaptic plasticity via global neuromodulatory signals , e . g . dopamine .', 'When combined with the popular idea that synapses are modified according to Hebbian rules , this leads to the hypothesis that reward signals interact with local neuronal activity to modulate synaptic efficacies [32] , [33] .', 'This theoretical paper aims to provide qualitative as well as quantitative insights into the conditions in which sensorimotor adaptation relying solely on rewards can take place .', 'More specifically , we assume that a local learning rule based on the coactivation of pre and postsynaptic neurons is gated by a binary reward signal is the neural basis for modifications of synaptic efficacies [32] , [34] , [35] .', 'We focus here on adaptation to a rotation during reaching movements where subjects are asked to move a cursor on a screen to bring it within a circular target while the cursor trajectory is rotated ( perturbed ) by some angle with respect to the hand trajectory .', 'These perturbation tasks are classically used in behavioral studies of sensorimotor adaptation [3] .', 'We consider a simplified network model of this task where adaptation relies solely on binary rewards [17] .', 'The simplicity of the model allows us to analytically study several aspects of the adaptation dynamics .', 'Combining these results with numerical simulations enables us to investigate the ways in which the learning dynamics depend on the model parameters .', 'The key question is how the dynamics of adaptation are affected when the task involves multiple targets .', 'Four main findings are reported: interferences can occur when adapting to multiple stimuli , interferences can slow down the adaptation dynamics dramatically , this depends on the ( binary , stochastic ) reward , and the slow down can be overcome by using shaping strategies .'], ['We first consider the case where the network has to adapt to a rotation of the cursor when only one target is presented .', 'Figure 2A ( left ) plots the evolution of the error ( see Eq .', '( 5 ) ) with the number of trials , hereafter referred to as the learning curve , while the network adapts to an imposed rotation with an angle .', 'On the right panel we plotted for the same parameters the learning curve of the directional error , which takes into account only the direction of the movement .', 'The error is large at the beginning of the process and decreases with the number of trials .', 'Importantly , the dynamics strongly depend on the noise .', 'For a low noise level ( Figure 2A , ) , the error remains large for many trials and learning is slow .', 'When the noise level is higher ( Figure 2B , ) the error declines faster .', 'However , this comes at the cost of increasing the error after learning: the median of this error , called hereafter the final error ( see Materials and Methods ) , is larger when the noise level is larger .', 'Similarly , the probability that the network will perform the task successfully , improves more rapidly with the number of trials for than for , but at very long time it is larger in the latter ( ) than in the former ( ) case .', 'The learning curves plotted in Figure 2A–B were obtained for particular realizations of the noise , .', 'To provide a statistical characterization of these dynamics , we estimated the distributions of the logarithm of the learning duration ( ) over many realizations of the noise ( see Materials and Methods ) .', 'As shown in Figure 2D , this distribution shifts toward longer learning duration as the noise level decreases .', 'Figures 2A and 2C plot the learning curves for and for the same noise level .', 'The learning is substantially faster for but the final error is larger in this case .', 'This is because when the target size is large , a reward might also be delivered for less precise movement , i . e . , for large errors .', 'Figure 2E plots the log learning duration and the final error averaged over realizations vs . the target size: when increasing the target size , the learning duration rapidly decreases , whereas the final error increases .', 'When the noise level or the target size are increased , the dynamics are typically faster because the probability of generating rewarded trials at the beginning of the learning is larger .', 'As this probability increases , the time for the network to generate a rewarded trial decreases , leading to more updates in the connectivity matrix ; hence the probability of the following trials to be rewarded increases further .', 'This argument can be made more quantitative if one considers how the time to get the first reward depends on and .', 'It has a geometrical distribution with a parameter ( see Eq .', '( 10 ) ) , which is the probability to get the first reward .', 'Lower values of increase the expectation time to the first reward , and thereby the learning duration .', 'When the noise level is low and the initial error is larger than the target size , the network explores a small region of the two dimensional space and the probability of getting a reward is small .', 'In contrast , for very large noise the target is missed most of the time .', 'The probability therefore varies non-monotonically with the noise level ( Figure 2F ) .', 'The dependency on target size is simpler: increases monotonically with target size , as it is more likely to reach a larger target .', 'What is the learning dynamics when the subject has to perform the task for two targets ?', 'How does learning the task for one of the targets affect learning the other one ?', 'We addressed these questions in numerical simulations , in which two targets were presented at an angular distance , , at consecutive times .', 'Similar results were obtained when the targets were presented in a random order with equal probability .', 'How does the learning duration , i . e . , the time to learn the task for all the presented targets , vary with the number of targets ?', 'We simulated the learning of m targets , whose directions were evenly distributed between and .', 'We took a small target size ( ) , so that up to non-overlapping targets could be considered ( for targets presented on a circle with radius 1 ) .', 'Figure 11A plots the average time to learn the entire task in terms of the total number of target presentations for a fixed noise level and different values of tuning widths .', 'It shows a non-monotonic dependency with the number of targets .', 'This contrasts the monotonically increasing learning duration when targets are learned independently with the same noise level and target size ( dashed line ) .'], ['Models of sensorimotor control and learning frequently assume minimizing a squared error function .', 'This is convenient because of analytical or computational simplicity [13] , [14] .', 'However , it was shown that although these models can be a good approximation they tend to penalize large errors excessively [41] .', 'In contrast , we chose to explore adaptation with a binary reward function , as used in experiments .', 'Our results and predictions stem from the shape of the reward function .', 'Specifically , they do not depend qualitatively on the specific choice of the distance error used , but are based primarily on the fact that the reward function varies sharply with the distance to the target center .', 'The dynamics of the adaptation to more than one target depend on the overlap between the tuning curves of the input neurons .', 'However , the precise shape of the tuning curves is not crucial and the results are unchanged if one replaces the Von Mises function we used here with any other tuning curve function , such as a cosine tuning curve ( see e . g . Eq . 23 ) .', 'As a matter of fact , the results we describe are the outcome of the following:', '1 ) the same system is used to learn the task for several targets , leading to interference which depends on the way in which the targets differ physically as well as in their neuronal representation and', '2 ) learning the task for one target can deteriorate performance on another target such that the information provided by the reward when attempting to learn the task for it becomes small , thereby delaying the learning .', 'These two properties of the learning process are not specific to the simple model we investigated here .', 'In our model , the latter property stems from the fact that the reward varies sharply with the error .', 'The learning rule we used is part of a general family of gradient-like reinforcement learning rules; i . e . , learning rules that on average form a gradient ascent on the reward function [35]–[37] .', 'In fact , learning with an on-line Gradient Ascent algorithm with a sigmoidal cost function can result in similar effects ( Text S1; Figure S1 ) .', 'It might be claimed that plasticity also occurs when no reward is delivered [42] .', 'Therefore , we also verified that the phenomenology of the model remains qualitatively the same when instead of using a reward function ( unpublished data ) .', 'Note that to avoid a drift of the output vector which occurs when , the synaptic weights must be normalized in this case after each trial .', 'Another extension of our model would be to use a reward prediction error instead of an instantaneous reward; e . g . , by subtracting a running average of the reward from the instantaneous reward .', 'Delayed learning also occurs with this type of learning rule ( results not shown ) .', 'In fact , previous works have argued that this modification does not affect most of the qualitative behavior of the algorithm [32] , [36] .', 'However , it should be noted that in the case of multiple targets , computing the running average of the rewards over all targets is an additional source of interference , as shown recently in [35] .', 'To avoid this , the running average of the reward needs to be monitored for each target separately .', 'We focused on the learning dynamics in a feed-forward network of linear neurons with only two layers .', 'We chose this architecture for the sake of simplicity .', 'However , we verified that similar qualitative behaviors in terms of interference and delayed learning occur in a network model in which an intermediate layer consisting of nonlinear neurons was added , and in which a decoder provides the angle of reach movement instead of a vector ( Text S1 , Figure S2 and unpublished data ) .', 'Note that in the framework of this more complex model , the noise can be unambiguously related to neuronal variability whereas in the simplified two-layer model considered in our paper , the noise is in the decoder .', 'One limitation of our work is that we did not model the trajectory of the movement and/or the muscle activation patterns needed to produce movements [43] .', 'However , we expect that delayed learning and interferences also occur in a more detailed model of movement production , such as the one used in Legenstein et al . [34] .', 'A reward-based component in a sensorimotor task was shown to be involved in adaptation to rotations even when detailed spatial information regarding the error was provided to the subject [18] , [19] .', 'We investigated the ways in which neural possible mechanisms that reinforce successful actions affect adaptation dynamics .', 'This type of reward-based mechanism was also studied in [17] .', 'In this experiment , subjects adapted without visual feedback to a gradually increasing rotation of every 40 trials , up to an rotation .', 'Our modeling results are in line with these experiments ( Figure 4B ) .', 'We thus predict that shaping the reward also accelerates adaptation .', 'Besides demonstrating that adaptation relying on rewards is possible by utilizing a gradual rotation paradigm , the Izawa and Shadmehr [17] results suggested that there is no change in the perceived sensory consequences of the motor commands; i . e . , there should be no change in a “forward model” .', 'Therefore , in [17] adaptation was modeled by an action selection rule .', 'Our model is similar to the latter , as we focused on the reward-based component during adaptation .', 'However , our model differs in that it is value-free , whereas in [17] it involved value-based reinforcement learning .', 'Nevertheless , our model can also account for the experimental results reported in [17] for one target ( see Text S1 , Figure S3 ) .', 'Moreover , it allowed us to investigate the generalization curve and possible interference during adaptation for multiple targets .', 'The key finding of this theoretical work is that if a reward-modulated learning rule underlies adaptation , interferences are likely to be observed when learning multiple targets with a binary reward .', 'It would be valuable to explore whether such effects occur in reward-based sensorimotor adaptation experiments with multiple sensory stimuli .', 'We predict that for a binary reward function , destructive interferences will be observed if the neurons that encode the stimuli have broad tuning curves .', 'These interferences are a dynamical counterpart of the generalization function and might result in a dramatic slowdown because of the abrupt change in the reward from success to failure around target size .', 'We also predict that adding more targets should accelerate adaptation ( Figure 11 ) .', 'From the learning curve of adaptation to one target , the rate and variability in which subjects adapt can be estimated .', 'We predict that at parity of variability , subjects with larger learning rates will tend to display more destructive interferences and therefore slower adaptation to two targets ( see Eq .', '( 23 ) ) .', 'By contrast , if the tuning curves are very narrow , destructive interferences are unlikely to be found .', 'However , even in this case , when the stimuli are sufficiently close , constructive interferences should be observed .', 'In this case as well , adding more targets should accelerate the adaptation .', 'Another prediction is that if adaptation is driven by reward modulated plasticity rules similar to the one we used here , smoothing the reward function should reduce interferences .', 'In our model , this stems from the assumption of a reward modulated learning rule and not from the simplifying assumptions we made in constructing the model .', 'Therefore , we suggest that testing this prediction could shed light on the synaptic mechanisms underlying adaptation tasks .', 'Finally , the location of the reward-based mechanism involved in adaptation could be the cortex-basal-ganglia network .', 'As a matter of fact , there is evidence for the involvement of this network in pitch shift adaptation in songbirds .', 'Although the neural correlates for adaptation in songbirds are unknown , when an auditory feedback is available to songbirds ( by using miniature headphones [7] ) , the anterior frontal pathway , which is the avian homologue of the cortex-basal-ganglia network [50] , is essential for adaptation based solely on binary rewards [15] , [16] .', 'Thus , exploring the behavioral and neural differences in auditory feedback versus binary reward adaptations in pitch shift experiments in songbirds may help reveal the neural mechanisms for reward-based adaptation .'], ['We consider a motor reaching task ( see Figure 1A ) in which a subject manually controls the location of a cursor on a screen to bring it within a circular target of radius [16] .', 'The target location is characterized by a two dimensional vector of norm 1 ( we assume that the target is always at distance 1 from the center of the screen ) and direction .', 'In a standard block of trials , the direction of motion of the cursor and the hand are the same .', 'We assume that the subject is able to perform the task perfectly in this case .', 'In a rotation block of trials a perturbation is introduced: the movement of the cursor on the screen is now rotated by an angle with respect to the hand movement .', 'To overcome this perturbation the subject must move his hand in a direction with respect to the target .', 'Here we focus on the case where there is no visual feedback ( the cursor is not on the screen ) : the only information the subject receives about his performance is provided by a reward signal delivered by the experimentalist [17] .', 'We consider a simplified computational model of a network performing this reaching task , see Figure 1B .', 'The input layer of the network encodes the sensory information regarding the direction of the target , .', 'It is composed of directionally tuned neurons labeled by their preferred direction , .', 'For simplicity , we assume that the shape of the tuning curves is the same for all neurons: upon presentation of a target in direction the activity of neuron is .', 'We take: ( 2 ) where characterizes the width of the tuning curve and is the peak response of a neuron .', 'The width of the tuning curves at half of its maximal activity relative to the baseline ( half bandwidth ) in this case is: ( 3 ) The second layer of the network encodes the location of the endpoint of the hand movement .', 'It consists of two output units whose activities , and , represent the two components of the hand position , .', 'Upon presentation of a target in direction : ( 4 ) where is the connectivity matrix between the two layers , denotes the N dimensional vector of the input layer with components , and is a Gaussian noise .', 'The location of the cursor at the end of the movement is related to by a rotation matrix , , of angle .', 'Therefore , the squared distance between the endpoint location of the cursor and the center of the target is: ( 5 ) where .', 'This quantity will be used to measure the error with which the network performs the reaching task .', 'It is also useful to define the noiseless error: ( 6 ) where .', 'This quantity measures the error if the noise is suppressed .', 'Upon presentation of a target in a direction θ at trial t , the network performs the task and a reward R is delivered according to the outcome: ( 7 ) The matrix is then modified according to a reward-modulated learning rule: ( 8 ) where is the learning rate .', 'This learning rule can be derived in a REINFORCE framework [36] .', 'We assume that at the beginning of learning , when there is no rotation , the network is able to perform the reaching task with zero noiseless error for all targets .', 'When all the Fourier components of are non-zero , this constraint fully determines : ( 9 ) where is the first Fourier component of the tuning curves .', 'To get Eq .', '10 , one needs to calculate the Fourier expansion of by using the constraint:for each of the possible target directions , .', 'When some of the Fourier coefficients of the tuning curve function are zero , e . g . when using a cosine tuning curves , is determined up to the Fourier coefficient that are irrelevant to the above constraint .', 'This does not affect the learning dynamics .', 'In the numerical simulations described in this paper , the input layer consists of neurons .', 'We normalized the tuning curves ( parameter in Eq .', '( 2 ) ) such that remains constant ( ) when changing .', 'This was done to guarantee that the time to learn one target does not depend on the tuning width .']]
['Introduction', 'Results', 'Discussion', 'Materials and Methods']
['When a perturbation is applied in a sensorimotor transformation task , subjects can adapt and maintain performance by either relying on sensory feedback , or , in the absence of such feedback , on information provided by rewards .', 'For example , in a classical rotation task where movement endpoints must be rotated to reach a fixed target , human subjects can successfully adapt their reaching movements solely on the basis of binary rewards , although this proves much more difficult than with visual feedback .', 'Here , we investigate such a reward-driven sensorimotor adaptation process in a minimal computational model of the task .', 'The key assumption of the model is that synaptic plasticity is gated by the reward .', 'We study how the learning dynamics depend on the target size , the movement variability , the rotation angle and the number of targets .', 'We show that when the movement is perturbed for multiple targets , the adaptation process for the different targets can interfere destructively or constructively depending on the similarities between the sensory stimuli ( the targets ) and the overlap in their neuronal representations .', 'Destructive interferences can result in a drastic slowdown of the adaptation .', 'As a result of interference , the time to adapt varies non-linearly with the number of targets .', "Our analysis shows that these interferences are weaker if the reward varies smoothly with the subject's performance instead of being binary .", 'We demonstrate how shaping the reward or shaping the task can accelerate the adaptation dramatically by reducing the destructive interferences .', 'We argue that experimentally investigating the dynamics of reward-driven sensorimotor adaptation for more than one sensory stimulus can shed light on the underlying learning rules .']
['The brain has a robust ability to adapt to external perturbations imposed on acquired sensorimotor transformations .', 'Here , we used a mathematical model to investigate the reward-based component in sensorimotor adaptations .', 'We show that the shape of the delivered reward signal , which in experiments is usually binary to indicate success or failure , affects the adaptation dynamics .', 'We demonstrate how the ability to adapt to perturbations by relying solely on binary rewards depends on motor variability , size of perturbation and the threshold for delivering the reward .', 'When adapting motor responses to multiple sensory stimuli simultaneously , on-line interferences between the motor performance in response to the different stimuli occur as a result of the overlap in the neural representation of the sensory stimuli , as well as the physical distance between them .', 'Adaptation may be extremely slow when perturbations are induced to a few stimuli that are physically different from each other because of destructive interferences .', 'When intermediate stimuli are introduced , the physical distance between neighbor stimuli is reduced , and constructive interferences can emerge , resulting in faster adaptation .', 'Remarkably , adaptation to a widespread sensorimotor perturbation is accelerated by increasing the number of sensory stimuli during training , i . e . learning is faster if one learns more .']
['neuroscience', 'motor systems', 'biology', 'computational neuroscience']