Identification of Newly Synthesized Proteins by Echinococcus granulosus Protoscoleces upon Induction of Strobilation
[['The parasite Echinococcus granulosus is a cestode tapeworm that acts as the causative agent of cystic echinococcosis ( cystic hydatid disease ) , one of the 17 neglected tropical diseases to be recently prioritized by the World Health Organization [1] .', 'During its life cycle , the E . granulosus adult worm resides in the intestine of the definitive host ( e . g . , dogs ) , releasing their eggs with the host feces .', 'Following ingestion by the intermediate host ( e . g . , domestic ungulates ) , the eggs release oncospheres that penetrate the intestinal wall and then migrate to various organs of the host .', 'At the organ site , the oncosphere develops in the larval stage of the parasite , the hydatid cyst ( metacestode ) .', 'The pre-adult forms ( protoscolex , PSC ) are asexually formed in the cyst germinal cellular layer and liberated into the lumen of hydatid cysts [2–7] .', 'In the cyst cavity , PSCs may remain in an inactive state for years until the structural integrity of the cyst is lost and they exhibit a dual developmental capacity .', 'When ingested by a definitive host , PSCs sexually differentiate into fully developed , segmented adult worms in a process called strobilation .', 'Alternately , upon hydatid cyst rupture and the release of its contents into the peritoneal cavity of an intermediate host , PSCs can dedifferentiate into secondary hydatid cysts [8] .', 'This dual developmental capacity of the parasite and its requirement for more than one host to complete its life cycle are associated with its ability to readily respond to host environmental changes and regulate its gene expression and protein synthesis [9–11] .', 'Transcriptional and proteomic studies have identified differentially expressed genes and proteins between the different life stages and cyst components of E . granulosus [6 , 12–14] .', 'However , the identities of the proteins responsible for key molecular events that lead to structural changes of the parasite and its transition between different developmental stages remain essentially unknown .', 'One possible reason for this is the difficulty of indirectly associating changes in gene expression to the response from a particular stimulus .', 'Consequently , the direct visualization and identification of newly synthesized proteins ( NSPs ) is useful for revealing the spatiotemporal characteristics of proteomes during development [15] .', 'Recently , the application of bioorthogonal non-canonical amino acid tagging ( BONCAT ) and fluorescent non-canonical amino acid tagging ( FUNCAT ) have been described for the non-radioactive labeling , visualization , purification and identification of NSPs [11 , 16 , 17] .', 'In BONCAT , newly synthesized proteins containing non-canonical amino acids containing either azide or alkyne moieties , such as the methionine ( Met ) analogue azidohomoalanine ( AHA ) , are chemically combined with affinity tags .', 'The alkyne or azide functional groups used in BONCAT require further purification steps , whereas FUNCAT uses fluorescent tags for in situ visualization .', 'BONCAT has been used for labeling NSPs in response to different stimulus in mammalian [16 , 17] and bacterial [18] cells .', 'Moreover , BONCAT has been used in combination with FUNCAT to show NSPs in zebrafish [19] .', 'Further adaptations have allowed the application of these methods to identifying NSPs in model organisms such as Caenorhabditis elegans , fruit fly and mouse [20] .', 'Here , we report the application of FUNCAT and BONCAT followed by confocal , SDS-PAGE and MS analyses to study E . granulosus NSPs and to identify 365 AHA-labeled NSPs during the E . granulosus strobilar development in vitro .', 'Some of the identified proteins have important functions in key processes for the survival and development of the parasite , such as metabolic reactions and processes involved in host/parasite relationships .', 'The further applicability of these methods for developmental studies in parasitic flatworms is also discussed .'], ['Hydatid cysts from E . granulosus ( G1 genotype ) were obtained from the naturally infected livers and lungs of cattle routinely slaughtered in a local abattoir ( São Leopoldo , RS , Brazil ) .', 'Finding hydatid cysts during mandatory animal inspection renders contaminated viscera unfit for human consumption , and E . granulosus contaminated livers and lungs were donated by the abattoir for use in this work .', 'PSCs were collected by aspiration , decanted by gravity and washed several times with PBS , pH 7 . 4 [13] .', 'The viability of PSCs was determined using the trypan blue exclusion test [21] and the motility was evaluated visually using an inverted light microscope .', 'Only PSCs with viability greater than 90% were used for further analysis .', 'The PSCs were genotyped by one-step PCR [22] .', 'PSCs were cultured in vitro as previously described [23] , with minor modifications .', 'Briefly , PSCs were incubated at 37°C and 5% CO2 for 15 min with pepsin ( 2 mg/mL , Sigma , St . Louis , MO , USA ) in Hanks’ Balanced Salt Solution ( HBSS ) , pH 2 . 0 .', 'The PSCs were then washed three times with PBS containing antibiotics ( 100 IU/mL penicillin and 100 mg/mL streptomycin , Sigma , St . Louis , MO , USA ) before being incubated with the appropriate medium .', 'To stimulate the PSCs to undergo strobilar development ( SSD ) , the PSC suspension was transferred to a biphasic medium .', 'Approximately 500 PSCs were used per mL of liquid medium over the solid base .', 'The biphasic medium contained coagulated newborn calf serum ( Gibco , Auckland , NZ ) as the solid phase , which was obtained by heating the serum at 76°C in a water bath for 10 to 30 min .', 'Each 100 mL of the liquid phase consisted of 83 . 5 mL RPMI without Met ( Gibco , Grand Island , NY , USA ) , 15 mL fetal bovine serum ( Vitrocell , Campinas , SP , BR ) , 1 . 15 mL glucose ( Merck , Loughborough , UK ) 30% in 18 megaOhm water , 0 . 35 mL taurocholate 0 . 2% ( Sigma , St . Louis , MO , USA ) in HBSS , 100 IU/mL penicillin/streptomycin and AHA ( Invitrogen , Eugene , OR , USA ) in a final concentration of 50 μM .', 'The control without stimuli for strobilar development ( NSD ) consisted of PSCs maintained in a monophasic medium containing RPMI without Met , 15% of fetal bovine serum and AHA ( 50 μM ) .', 'The negative control ( NC ) for AHA incorporation consisted of the NSD condition without AHA .', 'The cultures were maintained at 37°C and 5% CO2 for 24 h for the proteome analysis or 72 h for the other experiments .'], ['The proteins synthesized by E . granulosus PSCs after 72 h of cultivation in the presence of AHA ( SSD ) were labeled with TAMRA and visualized under UV to verify their electrophoretic profiles .', 'The pattern of bands in the total extract of PSCs was assessed by inspection of the gels stained with coomassie blue ( Fig 1A ) .', 'The NSPs of the PSCs could be visualized by UV in the same gel .', 'The analysis of the NSPs revealed a complex but lower number of distinct banding patterns that ranged from 10 to 225 kDa ( Fig 1B ) .', 'In the negative control condition without AHA , the total proteins were visualized with coomassie blue ( Fig 1C ) , but no band corresponding to NSPs was visualized under UV ( Fig 1D ) except for a non-incorporated TAMRA residual band , indicating the high specificity of the reaction .', 'To evaluate whether the AHA-labeling methodology could be applied to identifying NSPs from in toto PSCs and to verify whether the labeled proteins were associated with a particular site or structure in PSCs undergoing strobilation ( SSD ) , Alexa Fluor 488-labeled AHA-containing NSPs were analyzed in whole mount PSCs by confocal microscopy after 72 h of in vitro culture ( Fig 2 ) .', 'The fluorescence signal corresponding to the labeled NSPs was widely distributed and could be detected all over the PSCs ( Fig 2A ) , though there was a possible correlation between the NSPs and the suckers .', 'In contrast , no NSP-associated fluorescence could be detected in the control experiments .', 'The levels of DAPI fluorescence remained stable under the different conditions ( Fig 2B–2D ) .', 'The estimated fluorescence for the NSP-Alexa Fluor and DAPI are shown in Fig 1E .', 'We next explored the identities of the NSPs expressed in PSCs undergoing strobilation over a 24-h time window .', 'As we searched for proteins involved in the strobilation process , we chose a shorter culture time because longer times may dilute the importance of these molecules .', 'Scaffold was used to validate 365 non-redundant proteins in the AHA samples ( Fig 3 ) .', 'In the non-AHA samples , we found 14 proteins that were excluded from subsequent analyzes .', 'The purified NSPs from PSCs either with strobilation stimuli ( SSD ) or without strobilation stimuli ( NSD ) were identified by LC-MS/MS , which allowed for the identification of 248 and 275 proteins , respectively .', 'A list of the newly synthesized proteins identified in both samples is provided in S1 Table .', 'We found 51 proteins ( 23 SSD and 28 NSD ) in only one of the conditions studied in at least two replicates .', 'We normalized the other 233 identified proteins by NSAF and applied Student’s t-test to find the differentially expressed proteins .', '75 proteins were considered to be differentially expressed , with 34 considered to be more highly expressed in SSD and 41 more highly expressed in NSD ( Table 1 ) .', 'In SSD , several proteins are involved in metabolic reactions ( Fig 4 ) and may indicate how the parasite obtains energy during its development into the adult worm .', 'A feasible metabolic pathway for E . granulosus involves phosphoenolpyruvate , which is carboxylated to give oxaloacetate .', 'Oxaloacetate is reduced to malate , which is then either oxidatively decarboxylated to pyruvate or reduced to succinate .', 'Moreover , pyruvate can be converted into acetyl-CoA , which can participate in the tricarboxylic acid cycle or be converted into acetate .', 'A functional annotation of the NSPs is presented in Table 1 ( data summarized in Fig 5A ) .', 'The most representative terms in the SSD were related to post-translational modification , protein turnover , and chaperones ( O , 30% ) , energy production and conversion ( C , 19% ) , cytoskeleton ( Z , 11% ) , intracellular trafficking , secretion , and vesicular transport ( U , 9% ) and transcription ( K , 7% ) .', 'In the NSD condition , the most representative functions were cytoskeleton ( Z , 20% ) , signal transduction mechanisms ( T , 17% ) , post-translational modification , protein turnover , and chaperones ( O , 15% ) and RNA processing and modification ( A , 10% ) .', 'A hierarchical clustering of the up-regulated proteins listed in Table 1 was performed using the Z-score calculation on NSAF , and the results were represented as a heat map ( Fig 5B ) .', 'Two main clusters of the NSPs during the strobilar stimuli showing high ( red ) or low ( green ) expression .'], ['Techniques that allow for the selective labeling of molecular targets are powerful tools for understanding the molecular pathways involved in the strobilation process and the identification of key proteins that are activated in response to specific stimuli .', 'The high specificity of AHA-labeling has been proven to be non-toxic as it does not alter the global protein synthesis rates or cause significant protein misfolding or degradation [16 , 19 , 20 , 31] .', 'Furthermore , AHA is incorporated exclusively into NSPs without interfering with preexisting proteins .', 'Ethical and practical difficulties in undertaking in vivo studies bring up the necessity to develop in vitro systems .', 'Thus , we have successfully obtained an in vitro model of E . granulosus PSCs undergoing strobilar development under low potential sources of Met and conditions that facilitate the efficient incorporation of AHA .', 'The genomic data for E . granulosus were also analyzed and confirm the feasibility of AHA labeling because proteins with non-terminal Met residues are required for this purpose ( S1 Text ) .', 'Another factor contributing to the success of AHA-labeling is that the genome of this parasite showed no machinery for the endogenous synthesis of Met [6] .', 'SDS-PAGE and confocal microscopy were useful in detecting the incorporation of AHA .', 'The confocal microscopy showed a possible correlation between the NSPs and PSCs suckers .', 'In Mesocestoides corti , the apical massif is a polynucleated cell mass that differentiates into several cell types [32] .', 'This structure is a part of the tegmental syncytium and is located at the top of the scolex , next to the suckers .', 'Although studies using DNA labeling in E . granulosus have not demonstrated the existence of a proliferation site in this region [33] , the possible correlation between the NSPs and the suckers may correspond to an increased protein synthesis site .', 'The expression pattern identified by proteomic analysis of NSPs from PSC without stimuli for strobilar development revealed proteins involved in basic cellular functions , such as metabolic processes , regulation of biological processes and cellular component organization .', 'In this sample , we have identified proteins related to transcription , translation and cytoskeletal . In contrast , proteomic analysis of NSPs from SSD samples indicated changes in parasite metabolism and this has been reported with development [34–36] In more advanced stages of worm development , there is a shift from cytosolic to mitochondrial metabolism , which tends to produce more acetate and succinate , two end products with a higher energy yield than lactate [36–38] .', 'Thereby , changes in energy-producing pathways associated with maturation may be essential for both the correct progression of parasite life cycle as well as survival .', 'We found a SNW domain-containing protein that is a member of the SNW gene family .', 'Human SNW encodes a transcription coactivator that can interact with vitamin D receptor ( VDR ) and retinoid X receptor ( RXR ) [39] .', 'It is believed that VDR and RXR may play key roles in stimulating PSCs to develop into adult worms [6 , 40] .', 'The binding and activation of these receptors by bile acid salts regulates the expression of genes involved in differentiation , development , homeostasis and metabolism .', 'Therefore , finding an SNW protein may indicate the presence of an active state of VDR/RXR in SSD , which is plausible given these findings .', 'We also found three charged multivesicular body proteins that are components of the endosomal sorting complex required for transport III ( ESCRT-III ) [41–43] .', 'ESCRT-III participates in the degradation of the surface receptor proteins , the formation of endocytic multivesicular bodies and the down-regulation of several signaling pathways .', 'We also identified a clathrin light chain , a subunit of clathrin that participates in several membrane traffic pathways [44–46] .', 'Extracellular vesicles are derived from the multivesicular body and act in host/parasite relationships and cell–cell signaling [47 , 48] .', 'Although this is a preliminary result for E . granulosus , it is encouraging to find proteins related to these functions .', 'This cell-cell communication via exosome-like vesicles has been related to sexual differentiation , survival and population density [49] .', 'Interestingly , a comparison of the SSD up-regulated proteins showed no apparent correlation with the previously published RNAseq data [6] .', 'However , RNAseq data includes only expression profiles from either pepsin-activated PSCs or adult worms collected from dogs , with no data available for the transition between these two stages .', 'Therefore , we believe that this only reinforces the importance of our experimental approach in the attempt to identify early molecular events that are triggered by a developmental stimulus .', 'This is the first report of an efficient labeling and identification of NSPs with AHA in flatworms , which provides an interesting tool for use in the search for regulatory molecules in E . granulosus and other parasitic organisms .', 'The temporally controlled and context-dependent labelling of synthesized proteins allow the association between molecular changes and the processes occurring during induction of strobilation .', 'Whereas the steps of induction between different stages play a central role to the correct development of the parasite , the knowledge of such processes can have great value to the improvement of new disease control strategies .', 'Although there is vaccine for the intermediate host [50] , the WHO recommends that other stages should also be targeted for intervention [1] , which would make more efficient control .', 'Still , considering that regulatory processes may be conserved among different helminths , the results obtained here can serve as a starting point for control studies of other parasites .']]
['Introduction', 'Methods', 'Results', 'Discussion']
['The proteins responsible for the key molecular events leading to the structural changes between the developmental stages of Echinococcus granulosus remain unknown .', 'In this work , azidohomoalanine ( AHA ) -specific labeling was used to identify proteins expressed by E . granulosus protoscoleces ( PSCs ) upon the induction of strobilar development .', 'The in vitro incorporation of AHA with different tags into newly synthesized proteins ( NSPs ) by PSCs was analyzed using SDS-PAGE and confocal microscopy .', 'The LC-MS/MS analysis of AHA-labeled NSPs by PSCs undergoing strobilation allowed for the identification of 365 proteins , of which 75 were differentially expressed in comparison between the presence or absence of strobilation stimuli and 51 were expressed exclusively in either condition .', 'These proteins were mainly involved in metabolic , regulatory and signaling processes .', 'After the controlled-labeling of proteins during the induction of strobilar development , we identified modifications in protein expression .', 'The changes in the metabolism and the activation of control and signaling pathways may be important for the correct parasite development and be target for further studies .']
['In the life cycle of the parasite Echinococcus granulosus , hydatid cysts produce the pre-adult form , which has the ability to either differentiate into an adult worm ( strobilation ) or dedifferentiate into a secondary hydatid cyst .', 'We used different protein tags that allowed for the visualization and purification of proteins produced specifically after the induction of strobilar development to identify proteins that might be involved in this process ( temporally controlled and context-dependent ) .', 'As a result , we found proteins that are involved in important processes during development , such as energy metabolism , control pathways and cellular communication .', 'We believe that these results will be useful for the development of scientific approaches to controlling and preventing cystic hydatid disease .']
[]