Protein Domain-Level Landscape of Cancer-Type-Specific Somatic Mutations
[['Cancer is caused in large part by the accumulation of mutations in oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes .', 'Previous analyses of well-studied cancers , such as colorectal cancer and retinoblastoma , have suggested that as few as three mutations are sufficient for cancer initiation [1–3] .', 'Thousands of cancer genomes have now been sequenced[4 , 5] , including efforts from The Cancer Genome Atlas ( TCGA ) and the International Cancer Genome Consortium ( ICGC ) [6 , 7] .', 'In recent years , the genetic landscape of mutations has been revealed in several well-studied cancers [8–16] .', 'However , the process of extracting useful knowledge from this vast sequence resource has only begun .', 'The complexity of cancer genomes represents a challenge to therapy and our basic understanding of the disease and therefore also to therapy .', 'Individual cancers can contain thousands of somatic mutations [17 , 18] , only a small fraction of which are likely to be driver mutations contributing to tumor initiation or progression [18–22] .', 'Even genes that are well known to cause cancer contain many effectively-neutral passenger mutations [23] .', 'For example , it was reported that 80% of non-synonymous single-base substitutions observed in genes encoding protein kinases are passenger mutations [24] .', 'Most candidate driver gene identification has been done on the basis of observing mutations in a large fraction of tumor samples .', 'However , the list of putative driver mutations generated includes many that are implausible , with a false positive rate that increases with the number of sequenced tumor samples [25 , 26] .', 'Determining the effect of mutations on the structure and function of proteins remains challenging [27] .', 'Previous gene-based studies have generally focused on the whole gene or whole protein , but mutations in different protein domains , structural units that often have distinct functions , may have different functional consequences .', 'Thus , gene-level analysis can identify genes that contribute to multiple cancers , but does not map mutations to structural elements .', 'Recently , computational structural studies have explored mutational effects on specific regions of a protein ( e . g . , the binding site ) [28–31] .', 'For example , Joerger and Fersht showed that certain mutations in the p53 protein can determine folding state and affinity of p53 for specific target DNA elements .', 'Also , different p53 mutations affect different protein–protein interaction interfaces dictating either tetramerization of p53 or its interaction with a multitude of other regulatory proteins[30] .', 'Similarly , the effects of mutations in different protein kinase sub-domains have been shown to have different functional impacts[28] .', 'Thus , within a multi-functional gene , different mutations can affect different functions .', 'The structural details of individual mutants can provide the basis for the design of cancer therapeutics[30] .', 'Indeed , a given gene may have different functional roles in different cancers , reflected in shifts in the mutational distribution of different cancers .', 'Recently , Nehrt et al . examined 100 colon cancer and 522 breast cancer samples to identify specific domain types with heightened mutation rates , succeeding even within genes that have generally lower mutation rates in colon or breast cancer[32 , 33] .', 'Mutations occurring within a particular domain are more likely to share structural and functional effects [15] .', 'Two mutations within a given gene may be associated with different human diseases , e . g . , potentially by disrupting different protein interactions [34 , 35] .', 'Thus , studies that consider mutational positions ( e . g . , relative to known domains ) could be beneficial in elucidating functional effects of mutations .', 'In this study , a “domain instance” refers to a particular protein domain encoded within a particular gene and a “domain type” refers to a Pfam domain ‘pattern’ that may correspond to different domain instances encoded by different genes .', 'In other words , a domain instance refers to a specific amino acid subsequence within a given single protein that matches to a given domain type .', 'To better distinguish this study from previous related studies , such as the domain landscape in colon and breast cancer by Nehrt et al , we note that we are systematically analyzing multiple ( twenty-one ) cancer types .', 'Like Nehrt et al . , we analyze each Pfam domain type .', 'In addition , however , we specifically analyze each Pfam domain instance .', 'Rather than simply seeking domains with a mutational density that is enriched relative to other genomic regions , we further require that this enrichment is greater in one cancer type than in all other cancer types .', 'This has the advantage of pointing us to interesting differences between cancer types , while also implicitly controlling for region-specific differences in background mutation rate .', 'Thus , we are analyzing the ‘domain-centric mutational landscape’ by examining the domain-level distribution of missense somatic mutations across multiple cancer types .', 'We mapped missense somatic mutations to domain instances ( Fig . 1 . outlines this process ) for 21 cancer types ( Table 1 ) and detected 100 cancer-type-specific significantly-mutated domain instances ( SMDs ) among different cancers .', 'Further examination of these 100 domain instances showed that the proportion of within-domain mutations corresponding to hotspot positions can distinguish oncoproteins from tumor suppressor proteins .', 'We also found that the vast majority of within-domain mutational hotspots shared by multiple cancer types occurred at functional sites .', 'Thus , domain mutational landscape information can be used to prioritize candidate cancer-causing mutations and to elucidate their cancer-type-dependent functional effects .'], ['Protein domains are generally regarded as the conserved structural and functional units of proteins .', 'We therefore focused on the 237 , 716 missense somatic mutations , across 21 different human tissues , that fell within protein domain instances .', 'We further focused on the subset of 76 , 158 mutations that were predicted to compromise the function of the harboring protein , using the IntOGen–mutation platform[36] ( Table 1 , S1 Table ) .', 'To avoid observational biases , the above-mentioned mutations were derived only from genome-scale ( either whole-genome or exome ) sequencing studies ( listed in Table 2 ) .', 'The prevalence of missense somatic mutations can vary from cancer to cancer at the domain level [37 , 38] .', 'We found that most domain instances had a mutational density of only one or two missense somatic mutations per megabase in the corresponding DNA sequence ( Fig . 2 . ) .', 'For example , a mutated domain of length 209 residues ( the average domain instance length ) contains an average of one single-amino acid-changing mutation for every 71 patients .', 'Although domains with high mutation rates can be seen for many cancers ( Fig . 2 . ) , these mutation rates can be misleading .', 'Given heterogeneity of mutation rates across the genome and differences in overall mutation rate for different cancers , domain-instances with the highest mutation density in a given cancer may not be the true drivers of cancer progression[25] .', 'To control for both positional and cancer-type specific differences in mutation rate , we sought domain instances that were highly mutated relative both to the same domain instance in other cancer types and also to other domain instances within the same cancer type ( see Materials and Methods ) .', 'We identified ∼100 cancer-type-specific significantly mutated domain instances ( SMDs ) in 21 cancer types ( S2 Table; P-value = 10–7 , Fisher’s Exact test , False Discovery Rate ( FDR ) <0 . 05 ) .', 'The number of cancer-type-specific SMDs in each of the 21 cancer types is listed in Table 3 , and in S3 Table in greater detail .', 'With only two exceptions , the smallest number of mutations observed for a domain instance that was declared to be significantly mutated was 6 .', 'The exceptions were the Collagen domain instance ( with only 2 mutations ) within the COLEC11 gene product in soft tissue cancers , for which only 14 samples were available; and the CCDC14 domain instances ( with 3 mutations ) encoded by CCDC14 in cancers of the salivary gland , for which only 60 samples were available ( S4 Table ) .', 'We found between 3 and 7 SMDs for each cancer type , except for endometrial cancer ( with 11 SMDs ) as well as hematopoietic and lymphatic cancer ( with 27 SMDs ) .', 'Of the 94 genes encoding at least one SMD , 40 ( 42% ) had already been implicated in cancer according to the Sanger Cancer Gene Census ( ‘Cancer Census’ ) [39 , 40] , including well-established cancer-causing genes such as KRAS , EGFR and TP53 .', 'Enrichment for Cancer Census genes was both strong and significant ( ∼12-fold enrichment; P-value = 5×10–34 , Fisher’s Exact test ) , and suggests the remaining 54 genes that are not already known to be cancer drivers represent good candidates .', 'For example , the Syntaphilin protein , encoded by SNPH harbors the syntaphilin domain instance , which was significantly mutated in lung cancer .', 'Despite reports that it is brain-specific[41] , SNPH is expressed in lung according to microarray[42 , 43] and RNA-seq studies[44] .', 'We compared the resulting novel cancer gene candidates with cancer gene candidates emerging from a large-scale in vivo ( mouse ) screen via mutagenesis with Sleeping Beauty transposons [45] .', 'Of the 94 genes encoding cancer type-specific SMDs , 24 were found in the Sleeping Beauty dataset ( ∼3-fold enrichment; P-value = 7×10–06 , Fisher’s Exact test ) .', 'Of the subset of 54 candidate genes not already known to be cancer genes , 10 were found in the Sleeping Beauty dataset ( ∼2-fold enrichment; P-value = 5×10–3 , Fisher’s Exact test , Table 4 ) .', 'The distribution of cancer-type-specific SMDs varies across cancer types .', 'Among cancer-type-specific SMDs , most ( 95% ) were only significantly mutated in a single cancer type ( Fig . 3 . ) .', 'Five domain instances were found to be significantly mutated in more than one cancer ( Table 4 ) : a Ras domain instance of KRAS , mutated in lung and pancreatic cancer; a PHD finger domain instance ( zf-HC5HC2H ) of MLL3 , mutated in breast and prostate cancer; a MAD homology 2 ( MH2 ) domain instance of SMAD4 , mutated in colon and esophageal cancer; a SNF2 family N-terminal ( SNF2_N ) domain instance of SMARCA4 , mutated in esophageal cancer and cancer of the central nervous system; and the P53 DNA binding domain instance of TP53 , mutated in 8 cancer types .', 'With the exception of KRAS , these genes are usually regarded as tumor suppressors .', 'This suggests that , while tumor suppressors may cause different cancers via a common loss of function mechanism , the gain-of-function mechanism of oncogenes is more likely to be tissue-specific .', 'Domain instances mutated in a specific cancer type can point to functions that are specifically disrupted in that cancer type .', 'Furthermore , the observation that a given gene product has different domain instances mutated in different cancer types may elucidate how a single gene can play different roles in different cancers .', 'To identify candidate genes with this behavior , we first selected all of the multi-domain genes that contained at least one cancer-type-specific SMD , and examined the cancer-type-specificity of these domains ( see Materials and Methods ) .', 'Among the 94 genes identified above to contain cancer-type-specific SMDs , 52 genes had multiple domain instances with differing cancer-type-specificity ( see S2 Table ) .', 'These 52 genes were enriched for evidence of involvement in cancer , with 16 being Cancer Census genes ( enrichment factor ∼ 11 . 9; P-value = 6 . 7 ×10–13 , Fisher’s Exact test ) , and 15 being candidate cancer genes according to the Sleeping Beauty screen ( enrichment factor ∼ 4 . 5; P-value = 1 . 9 ×10–6 , Fisher’s Exact test ) .', 'To illustrate this analysis , we show the distribution of domain mutations in the EGF receptor , encoded by EGFR , across five cancers ( Fig . 4A . ) .', 'The EGF receptor is a flexible protein with four distinct domains , including extracellular and transmembrane regions , the intracellular kinase domains , and a long flexible tail ( Fig . 4B . ) .', 'Our analysis recapitulated domain mutation patterns seen in corresponding to previous findings .', 'The extracellular region consists of the furin-like ( Furin-Like ) domain , the growth factor receptor domain IV ( GF_recep_IV ) and the L domain ( Recep_L_Domain ) .', 'The Furin-Like and the GF_recep_IV domains were both found to be significantly mutated in cancers of the central nervous system .', 'Mutations in the extracellular region of EGF receptor have been associated with ligand-independent dimerization in cancers of the central nervous system[46] , and mutations in the intracellular region of EGF receptor are associated with sensitivity to kinase inhibitors[46] .', 'In lung cancers , mutations were significantly enriched in the tyrosine kinase domain ( Pkinase_Tyr ) .', 'This is a well-known location for oncogenic mutations that hyper-activate downstream pro-survival signaling pathways in lung cancer by causing the auto-phosphorylation of C-terminal residues [51] .', 'The detailed functional consequences of EGFR mutations in prostate and colon cancer are still unclear .', 'Differences in the positions of mutations between the extracellular ( glioblastoma and prostate cancer ) and intracellular regions ( colon , lung and ovarian cancer ) of the EGF receptor in different cancer types suggest different oncogenic mechanisms and possibly different therapeutic avenues .', 'Other interesting examples included that of the histone-lysine N-methyltransferase MLL3 protein , for which the PHD finger domain is mutated in breast cancer and prostate cancer , and for which the SET domain is mutated in glioblastoma and medulloblastoma .', 'MLL3 is reported to possess histone methylation activity and is also involved in transcriptional co-activation .', 'Knockdown or deletion of MLL3 using RNAi or CRISPR is reported to cause acute myeloid leukemia in a mouse model [52] .', 'Domain-associated mutational biases have been reported in several studies focusing on single well-known cancer genes such as the PI3KCA gene in colon and breast cancer[32] , and the NOTCH1 gene in leukemia , breast and ovarian cancer [53] .', 'Here , we analyzed the distribution of somatic missense mutations for 14 , 083 genes across 21 cancer types and identified 52 genes ( 36 of which are not yet known to be cancer genes ) for which different domain instances may contribute to different cancer types .', 'We further analyzed genes with at least one cancer-type-specific SMD .', 'More specifically , we identified a collection of 337 cancer-type-specific mutation hotspots in 68 genes , including some hotspots that appeared in several different types of cancer ( Fig . 5 . , S4 Table ) .', 'For example , in the EGFR protein , residue p . A289 is a mutational hotspot in central nervous system cancer , p . C231 is a mutational hotspot in prostate cancer ( Fig . 5 . ) .', 'Both residues fall in the Furin-like domain of the extra-cellular part of EGFR , but at different domain-domain interaction interfaces .', 'It has been proposed that oncoproteins tend to be recurrently mutated at the same amino acid residues , while tumor suppressor proteins tend to be mutated throughout their length[15] .', 'Therefore we systematically compared the mutation pattern between tumor suppressor proteins and oncoproteins .', 'In both tumor suppressor proteins and oncoproteins , mutations were enriched in the SMDs , as expected ( Fig . 6A . , S5 Table ) .', 'For each cancer-type-specific SMD , to assess whether mutations were recurrent at a few locations as opposed to being evenly spread , we compared the ratio of mutational hotspots to the total number of mutated residues within domains .', 'We found this ratio to be significantly higher for oncoproteins than for tumor suppressor proteins ( Fig . 6B . ; P = 0 . 00026 , Mann-Whitney U-test ) .', 'This is consistent with the known tendency of tumor suppressor proteins to carry loss-of-function mutations that can occur in many places , and that of oncoproteins to harbor more specific gain-of-function mutations[15] .', 'For example , the fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 ( FGFR2 ) is generally regarded as an oncoprotein in breast cancer[15] .', 'Consistent with this view , we found a single hotspot ( p . N549 ) for FGFR2 in breast cancer in the kinase domain , which had not been reported as a hotspot for breast cancer .', 'A previous study of endometrial cancer[54] suggested FGFR2 to be a tumor suppressor protein .', 'Supporting this view , we observed nine evenly-distributed mutated residues in the kinase domain in endometrial cancer , although we also confirm previous observation [54] of the p . N549 hotspot which is more suggestive of an oncoprotein .', 'Four mutational hotspots in the Immunoglobulin I-set domain of FGFR2 were observed in colon cancer , which hints at a tumor suppression role for FGFR2 in colon cancer ( Fig . 7 ) .', 'We also analyzed the functional properties of the mutational hotspots we observed .', 'Out of the 68 proteins that have at least one mutational hotspot in at least one cancer , we selected 13 proteins for which structures and functional site annotations were available .', 'Of these 13 , seven proteins are encoded by oncogenes ( AKT1 , BRAF , EGFR , HRAS , KRAS , NRAS , and PIK3CA ) and six are encoded by tumor suppressors ( CDKN2A , FBXW7 , PTEN , SMAD4 , TP53 , and VHL ) .', 'We mapped all observed mutations to protein structures .', 'For tumor suppressor proteins , we found that most mutational hotspots fell at the interface of domain-domain interactions .', 'We also found that , of 47 mutational hotspots , only 3 ( 6% ) fell at functional sites of tumor suppressor proteins ( Table 5 ) .', 'For oncoproteins , of 40 mutational hotspots , 15 ( 38% ) fell at functional sites , including GTP/ATP binding sites and other active sites of enzymes .', 'Functional sites were significantly overrepresented among oncogenic mutational hotspots ( Odds ratio = 10 . 0 , P = 0 . 0006 , Fisher’s Exact Test ) .', 'The three mutational hotspots detected at known functional sites of a tumor suppressor protein all fell within the p53 protein .', 'The p . R248 and p . R273 hotspots were within the DNA binding site , and have each been reported as sites of potentially oncogenic mutations in many cancer types , including breast cancer[55] .', 'The hotspot p . R337 , found in liver cancer , fell within p53’s tetramerization domain , a site of post-translational modification targeted by Protein Arginine N-Methyl Transferase 5 ( PRMT5 ) .', 'Methylation of this residue affects the target protein specificity of p53[56 , 57] .', 'As shown in Fig . 8 . , the contact between p . R337 and p . L348 , which is a residue in the P53-Tetramerization domain of another chain , may be necessary for tetramerization of the whole protein .', 'The tetramerization of different domains is reported to be essential for the activity of p53[58] .', 'Disruption of tetramerization could have a dominant-negative loss-of-function effect , or a gain- or change-of-function mutation if the un-tetramerized subunits have additional activities .', 'Thus , our analysis points to residue p . R337 being a novel driver mutation in liver cancer .', 'The different mutational hotspot distribution patterns between oncoproteins and tumor suppressor proteins were generally consistent with the expected gain- and loss-of-function mechanisms of oncogenes and tumor suppressors , respectively[15] .', 'Mutations at functional sites may increase the activation of oncoproteins , while mutations at the inter-chain interfaces may destabilize the protein and lead to loss of function in a tumor suppressor .', 'These distinct mutation patterns can help classify newly identified cancer-associated genes for which oncogene or tumor suppressor roles are unknown .', 'We categorized the ten novel cancer candidate genes that overlap with the Sleeping Beauty dataset based on similarity to the hotspot distribution patterns that are characteristic of oncogenes and tumor suppressors ( Table 4 ) .', 'Among the ten genes , seven ( CNTN4 , CTNNA3 , EPHA6 , FOXO1 , MAGI1 , PTPRD and SMAD4 ) were predicted to be tumor suppressors .', 'Using transposon insertion positions , the Sleeping Beauty study [60] had annotated three of these seven genes as loss of function ( while not suggesting an annotation for the remaining four ) .', 'We also reported two potential oncogenes , USP25 and GNA13 ( Table 4 ) .', 'Finally , we identified one gene , PCDH11X , for which the domain mutation patterns suggest an oncogenic role in lymphoma and leukemia but a tumor suppressive role in glioblastoma and medulloblastoma .', 'At the domain level , we noticed that 10 out of 13 oncogenic mutational hotspots shared by at least three cancer types occurred at functional sites ( Table 6 ) .', 'This is true not only for domains corresponding to a single gene but also for domain types corresponding to different genes .', 'For example , the Ras domain type ( for which instances may be found in multiple genes ) was significantly mutated in different cancers ( Fig . 9A . ) .', 'Enrichment of somatic mutations within Ras domains has been reported for different individual genes[61 , 62] .', 'Here , we collectively analyzed the domain position-based hotspots for K-RAS , H-RAS , and N-RAS , finding that at least one of the GTP binding site residues p . G12 or p . G13 , or the active site residue p . R61 show a relatively high mutation rate in at least five cancer types ( Fig . 9B and C . ) .', 'While each of these three hotspots was known previously for individual genes in individual cancer types , this analysis suggests that an increase in statistical power can be gained in the future by grouping protein domain instances of the same domain type .', 'Beyond the 10 out of 13 oncogenic mutational hotspots occurring at functional sites , there were three oncogenic mutational hotspots shared by at least three cancer types .', 'They are V600 in Serine/threonine-protein kinase B-Raf ( encoded by BRAF ) , and R88 and C420 in the phosphatidylinositol-4 , 5-bisphosphate 3-kinase encoded by PIK3CA .', 'We found both C420 and R88 to be positions of mutational hotspots in endometrium , colon and breast cancer .', 'Although the two residues fall within different domains ( C420 in C2 domain , and R88 in p85α domain ) , they both play important roles in maintaining the p110α/ p85α-iSH2 structure [64] , and both are at the binding interface of the C2 and p85α domains .', 'Although each of these mutations has been previously studied as a potential driver mutation in each of these three cancer types , this analysis objectively confirms the ‘hotspot’ status of these mutations .'], ['Major bottlenecks in the systematic study of cancer genomes exist following identification of somatic tumor mutations , including the identification of driver mutations and their functional impacts .', 'By taking advantage of large-scale whole-genome or whole-exome sequencing data and accumulated information about protein structures , we were able to derive and compare the mutational landscapes for 21 cancer types at the domain level .', 'We used a significance test that not only required a domain to have enriched mutational density in a given tumor type relative to other regions in that tumor type , but further required that an enrichment be significantly greater than that observed for all other cancer types taken together .', 'Because region-dependence of mutation rates is similar across tumor types[25] , this approach not only identifies cancer-type specific mutational positioning but also implicitly controls for regional differences in mutation rate across the genome .', 'We analyzed domain types that are significantly mutated in different cancers , such as the Ras domain type and the Pkinase domain type .', 'We found hotspots that were shared between different domain instances in the same domain type , and which appeared in multiple cancer types .', 'By combining this information with protein structure information , we found that all ( 10 out of 10 ) such identified hotspots , where they fell within known oncoproteins , are ‘functional hotspots’ in the sense that all fell within ligand-binding or active sites .', 'We also found that , in a given cancer type , a functional hotspot corresponding to a given domain type was never mutated in more than one of the domain instances corresponding to that domain type in the same tumor sample .', '( Sample information is shown in S1 Table . )', 'This suggests that functional hotpots falling within different genes corresponding to a given domain type may contribute to cancer development by a similar and parallel mechanism , and further suggests that only one mutated functional site might be able to increase the activity of those proto-oncogenes and ultimately contribute to cancer initiation .', 'Functional hotspots included oncogenic mutations within proteins that are generally considered to be tumor suppressors , for example p . R248 and p . R273 in TP53 .', 'Except for the DNA binding sites p . R248 and p . R273 in the p53 DNA binding domain , we did not find mutational hotspots in known tumor suppressors that appeared in more than five cancer types .', 'Providing greater nuance to previous reports that mutations tend to span the entire tumor suppressor gene[15] , we found that tumor suppressor mutations detected in a given cancer type tended to be distributed throughout the entirety of a significantly mutated domain instance , and many mutations occurred within core regions important for the stabilization of the protein complex .', 'Mutations detected in different cancers tended to be focused within domain instances , but were distributed across different domain instances of the same gene product .', 'Mutational positioning information could assist drug design aimed at precisely targeting the region of the protein involved in a particular cancer .', 'In contrast with gene-level studies of mutational frequency , the domain-level view points to particular functional regions , and identifies tendencies of a gene to be mutated in different regions in different cancers .', 'For most genes , only one domain was found to be significantly mutated in a given cancer type .', 'However , we found five genes that each contain two interaction-mediating domain instances that were significantly mutated in the same cancer type .', 'These five interaction-mediating domain pairs are Bcl-2 and BH4 domains encoded by BCL2 , which play important roles in regulating cell death and survival[65]; DEAD and Helicase_C domains encoded by DDX3X , which play important roles in metabolic processes involving RNAs[66]; and PI3Ka and PI3K_p85B domains encoded by PIK3CA , which interact with each other to initiate a vast array of signaling events[67]; Furin-like and GF_recep_IV domains encoded by EGFR , which are both extracellular domains of receptor tyrosine protein kinases and which interact with each other to regulate the binding of ligands to the receptor[68]; and finally the DNA binding and P53_tetramer ( tetramerization ) domains encoded by TP53 .', 'We also identified 117 domain instance pairs that corresponded to interacting proteins[69] , for which at least one member of the pair was an SMD .', 'For most interaction-mediating pairs , only one domain instance was significantly mutated ( S6 Table ) .', 'There are only ten cases where both domains of a predicted interaction-mediating domain pair were significantly mutated in the same cancer type ( S7 Table ) .', 'This result raises the possibility that mutations in those domain instances act by disrupting domain-domain interactions .', 'Distinctive mutation landscapes in different cancers could indicate that tumor development mechanisms across different cancer types are dissimilar , although it is also possible that differences in the mutational spectrum between different cancer types alter the probability of mutation in one domain relative to another .', 'This domain-level study identified known and novel candidate driver mutations and provided clues to the functional effects of tumor-associated somatic mutations .', 'In total , 41 out of the 100 SMDs we identified are encoded by Cancer Census genes ( S1 Table ) .', 'Among the remaining 59 novel candidate driver genes , many domain instances belong to well-known cancer-associated domain types , such as the Pkinase domain type and the WD40 domain type , supporting the idea that this set contains many cancer driver genes that are not yet annotated as such .', 'By comparing the domain-level mutational landscapes of different cancers generated by our study to previously reported gene-level mutation landscapes in small cell lung cancer , melanoma , colon cancer , and breast cancer[14 , 70–73] , we noticed at least ten cancer-type-specific SMDs that do not correspond to any previously reported highly mutated cancer-associated genes .', 'For each cancer type , we found at least one new potential cancer-associated domain instance , for example , the diacylglycerol kinase domain encoded by DGKZ in chondrosarcoma .', 'The DGKZ protein ( using the diacylglycerol kinase domain ) usually acts as a sentinel and can control p53 function both during normal homeostasis and during stress response [74] .', 'Other examples include the two cadherin domain instances encoded by PCDH11X and PCDH11Y in glioblastoma .', 'These domain instances are thought to play important roles in cell-cell communication and are essential for a normally-functioning central nervous system [75] .', 'Also , all the eight tumor samples that contained mutations in PCDH11Y ( on the Y chromosome ) were also mutated at a corresponding position in the X-chromosome homolog PCDH11X .', 'Another four ( female ) samples had mutations detected on both alleles of PCDH11X [76] .', 'These alleles each contained one of the novel hotspot mutations p . T486 or p . G442 in the cadherin domain , suggesting the potential role for these hotspot mutations as important recessive driver mutations in glioblastoma .', 'Because Nehrt et al . [32] had previously identified significantly mutated domain types for breast and colon cancer , we wished to assess the novelty of the SMDs we found for these cancer types .', 'Of the 23 SMDs we identified for colon cancer , 20 were novel relative to domain types previously identified by Nehrt et al ( we confirmed three domain types: the PI3K_p85B domain encoded by PIK3CA , the MH2 domain encoded by SMAD4 and the P53 DNA binding domain encoded by TP53 ) .', 'Of the 12 SMDs we identified for breast cancer , only three correspond to a certain highly mutated domain type reported in the study by Nehrt et al ( the PI3K_p85B domain and PI3Ka domain encoded by PI3KCA , and the P53 DNA binding domain encoded by TP53 ) .', 'We note that , even where an SMD corresponds to a domain type previously found to be significantly mutated , our analysis in this case identifies individual domain instances as significantly mutated , as opposed to domain types for which the mutations may be spread across multiple genes .', 'In summary , 20 out of 23 ( 87% ) of the colon-cancer associated SMDs , and 9 out of 12 ( 75% ) of the breast-cancer-associated SMDs found here are novel relative to Nehrt et al . Our study also differs from Nehrt et al . in that we only reported domain instances for which enrichment relative to other regions was significantly greater in one cancer type than in all other cancer types .', 'This procedure controlled both for mutation rates within each cancer type , and for different rates of mutation across cancer types in each domain relative to others .', 'Although a previous study[25] has pointed to the dangers of candidate driver gene identification through mutation frequency analysis , we note that none of the SMDs we identified fell within the 18 genes for which mutational enrichment was reported to be spurious[25] .', 'In addition to correspondence of the discovered SMDs to known cancer-relevant domain families , our set of novel driver gene candidates overlapped s
['Introduction', 'Results', 'Discussion', 'Materials and Methods']
['Identifying driver mutations and their functional consequences is critical to our understanding of cancer .', 'Towards this goal , and because domains are the functional units of a protein , we explored the protein domain-level landscape of cancer-type-specific somatic mutations .', 'Specifically , we systematically examined tumor genomes from 21 cancer types to identify domains with high mutational density in specific tissues , the positions of mutational hotspots within these domains , and the functional and structural context where possible .', 'While hotspots corresponding to specific gain-of-function mutations are expected for oncoproteins , we found that tumor suppressor proteins also exhibit strong biases toward being mutated in particular domains .', 'Within domains , however , we observed the expected patterns of mutation , with recurrently mutated positions for oncogenes and evenly distributed mutations for tumor suppressors .', 'For example , we identified both known and new endometrial cancer hotspots in the tyrosine kinase domain of the FGFR2 protein , one of which is also a hotspot in breast cancer , and found new two hotspots in the Immunoglobulin I-set domain in colon cancer .', 'Thus , to prioritize cancer mutations for further functional studies aimed at more precise cancer treatments , we have systematically correlated mutations and cancer types at the protein domain level .']
['Extensive tumor genome sequencing has provided raw material to understand mutational processes and identify cancer-associated somatic variants .', 'However , fundamental problems remain to:', 'i ) separate ‘driver’ from ‘passenger’ mutations ,', 'ii ) further understand the functional mechanisms and consequences of driver mutations , and', 'iii ) identify the cancer types in which each driver mutation is relevant .', 'Here we analyze whole-genome and exome tumor sequencing data from the perspective of protein domains—the basic structural and functional units of proteins .', 'Exploring the cancer-type-specific landscape of domain mutations across 21 cancer types , we identify both cancer-type-specific mutated domains and mutational hotspots .', 'Frequently-mutated domains were identified for oncoproteins for which the ‘mutational hotspot’ phenomenon owing to the relative rarity of gain-of-function mutations is well known , and also for tumor suppressor proteins , for which more uniformly distributed loss-of-function driver mutations are expected .', 'A given gene product may be perturbed differently in different cancers .', 'Indeed , we observed systematic shifts between cancer types of the positions at which mutations occur within a given protein .', 'Both known and novel candidate driver mutations were retrieved .', 'Novel cancer gene candidates significantly overlapped with orthogonal systematic cancer screen hits , supporting the power of this approach to identify cancer genes .']
[]