Protease-Sensitive Conformers in Broad Spectrum of Distinct PrPSc Structures in Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease Are Indicator of Progression Rate
[['Prions cause a group of fatal and rapidly progressing neurodegenerative diseases , originally described as transmissible spongiform encephalopathies ( TSEs ) [1] , [2] .', 'The most common of these diseases is sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease ( sCJD ) , which accounts for ∼85% of all CJD cases worldwide [3] .', 'Although 40 years ago sCJD was shown to be transmissible to nonhuman primates [4] , its pathogenesis remains enigmatic .', 'Most researchers today believe that all prion diseases are caused by the accumulation of an aberrantly folded isoform , termed PrPSc , of the prion protein PrP [5] .', 'Having a basic amino acid composition and an unstructured N-terminus , PrP can assume at least two conformations: ( 1 ) native , α-helix–rich PrPC and ( 2 ) disease-causing , β-sheet–rich PrPSc [6]–[8] .', 'The latter represents a misfolded isoform of the normal cellular prion protein PrPC , which is host-encoded by the chromosomal gene PRNP and expressed at different levels in mammalian cells [9] .', 'Yet despite the impressive progress that has been made in understanding the molecular basis of prion diseases , the molecular mechanism of initial misfolding and the high-fidelity replication of the pathogenic conformation of PrPSc in vivo both remain elusive [2] , [10]–[12] .', 'Many lines of evidence from experiments with laboratory prion strains support the view that the phenotype of the disease—its distinctive incubation time , clinical features , and brain pathology—is enciphered in the strain-specific conformation of PrPSc [13]–[17] .', 'Although remarkable progress has been made in understanding the structure of laboratory strains of rodent prions [2] , [10] , [18]–[20] , knowledge of the molecular basis of human prion diseases has lagged behind .', 'Researchers generally agree that the genotype at codon 129 of the chromosomal gene PRNP underlies susceptibility to these diseases and , to some degree , their phenotype [21] .', 'However , in contrast to the experiments with laboratory rodent prion strains , in which the digestion of brain PrPSc with proteolytic enzyme proteinase K ( PK ) consistently results in a single protease-resistant domain with mass ∼19 kDa , the outcome in sCJD is more complex .', 'Distinctive glycosylation patterns and up to four PK-resistant fragments of the pathogenic prion protein ( rPrPSc ) found in sCJD brains are easily distinguishable on western blot ( WB ) [14] , [21]–[25] .', 'The WB findings together with PRNP gene polymorphism led Parchi , Gambetti , and colleagues to posit a clinicopathological classification of sCJD into five or six subtypes; notably , the WB characteristics of PrPSc breed true upon transmission to susceptible transgenic mice [14] , [21] , [22] .', 'An alternative classification of the PrPSc types and their pairing with CJD phenotypes has been proposed by Collinge and collaborators [23] , [24] , [26] , [27] .', 'This classification differs from the previous one in two major aspects: First , it recognizes three ( not two ) PrPSc electrophoretic mobilities; and second , it identifies also PrPSc isoforms with different ratios of the three PrP glycoforms [26] .', 'Although the disease phenotypes of patients with sCJD are remarkably heterogeneous , 21 kDa fragments of unglycosylated PrPSc ( Type 1 ) frequently differ from the phenotypes associated with the 19 kDa fragments of unglycosylated PrPSc ( Type 2 ) [14] , [21] , [22] , [28] .', 'Cumulatively these findings argue that the PrPSc type represents yet an additional major modifier in human prion diseases; accordingly , WB-based clinicopathologic classifications became an important tool in studies of prion pathogenesis in human brains and in transgenic mice models [14] , [26] .', 'Now , inasmuch as two distinct PK cleavage sites in PrPSc Types 1 and 2 most likely stem from distinct conformations , some investigators contend that PrPSc Types 1 and 2 code distinct prion strains [14] , [23] , [28] , [29] .', 'However , the heterogeneity of sCJD , along with a growing number of studies including bioassays , all suggest that the range of prions causing sCJD exceeds the number of categories recognized within the current WB-based clinicopathologic schemes [30]–[32] .', 'Additionally , recent findings revealed the co-occurrence of PrPSc Types 1 and 2 in up to 44% of sCJD cases and thus created a conundrum [33]–[38] .', 'Finally , up to 90% of brain PrPSc in sCJD eludes WB analysis because it is destroyed by proteinase-K treatment , which is necessary to eliminate PrPC .', 'Consequently , the conformation or role of this major protease-sensitive', '( s ) fraction of PrPSc in the pathogenesis of the disease is a subject of speculation [30] , [39] , [40] .', 'Aiming to advance our understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of human prion diseases , we used the conformation-dependent immunoassay ( CDI ) [15] , [30] , [41] to determine the conformational range and strain-dependent molecular features of sCJD PrPSc in patients who were homozygous for codon 129 of the PRNP gene .', 'Even relatively minute variations in a soluble protein structure can be determined by measuring conformational stability in a denaturant such as Gdn HCl [42] .', 'Utilizing this concept , we designed a procedure in which PrPSc is first exposed to denaturant Gdn HCl and then exposed to europium-labeled mAb against the epitopes hidden in the native conformation [15] .', 'As the concentration of Gdn HCl increases , PrPSc dissociates and unfolds from native β-sheet-structured aggregates; and more epitopes become available to antibody binding .', 'These experiments involve insoluble oligomeric forms of PrPSc , and denaturation of this protein is irreversible in vitro; consequently the Gibbs free energy change ( ΔG ) of PrPSc cannot be calculated [43] .', 'Therefore we chose instead to use the Gdn HCl value found at the half-maximal denaturation ( [GdnHCl]1/2 ) as a measure of the relative conformational stability of PrPSc .', 'The differences in stability reveal evidence of distinct conformations of PrPSc [15] , [42] , [43] .', 'Because CDI is not dependent on protease treatment , it allowed us to address fundamental questions concerning the concentration and conformation of different isoforms of sCJD PrPSc , including protease-sensitive', '( s ) and protease-resistant', '( r ) PrPSc .', 'We found a broad spectrum of structures that are likely responsible for the phenotypic heterogeneity of sCJD and we identified the structural characteristics of PrPSc that are linked to the duration of the disease .'], ['From 340 patients with an unequivocally definite diagnosis of Type 1 or Type 2 sCJD and who were homozygous for codon 129 polymorphism in the PRNP gene , we selected samples from 46 patients .', 'The descriptive statistics and Kaplan-Meier survival curves indicate that these cases are representative of the whole group collected at NPDPSC and are similar to those previously reported by us and others ( Compare Figure 1 and Figure S1 , Table 1 ) [21] , [38] , [44] .', 'As expected , we did not observe statistically significant differences in sex ratio or age at onset of the disease [21] , [44] .', 'Kaplan-Meier analyses of survival ( Figure 1 ) demonstrated that patients with PrPSc Type 1 had a significantly shorter disease duration than patients with PrPSc Type 2 ( P\u200a=\u200a0 . 002 ) despite identical codon 129 MM polymorphism , age , and sex distribution ( Table 1 ) .', 'Moreover , there is an apparent tendency toward longer survival of patients with Type 2 rPrPSc ( 129 V ) than patients with Type 1 rPrPSc ( 129 M ) ( P\u200a=\u200a0 . 017 ) .', 'The difference in survival between patients with Type 2 rPrPSc ( 129 V ) and Type 2 rPrPSc ( 129 M ) was also significant ( P\u200a=\u200a0 . 008 ) with shorter survival of those homozygous for valine ( Figure 1 ) .', 'To ensure that the brain homogenate analyzed by CDI contained only Type 1 or 2 rPrPSc , each brain homogenate underwent a second WB ( Figure S2 ) .', 'The results confirmed the original diagnostic classification but we found two atypical patterns: Case #833 ( Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) and Case #162 ( Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 V ) revealed , in addition to a band of unglycosylated rPrPSc with apparent molecular mass ∼19 kDa , a second band with electrophoretic mobility corresponding to mass ∼17 kDa .', 'The observation of different glycoform patterns of PrPSc in different sCJD cases before protease K treatment and distinct resistance to proteolytic degradation of different glycoforms of PrPSc is interesting and deserves further investigation .', 'To measure the concentration of different forms of PrPSc in the frontal cortex , we used europium-labeled mAb 3F4 [45] for detection and 8H4 mAb ( epitope residues 175–185 ) [46] to capture human PrPSc in a sandwich CDI format ( Figure S4 ) [30] , [47] .', 'The analytical sensitivity and specificity of the optimized CDI for detection of both protease-sensitive', '( s ) and protease-resistant', '( r ) conformers of PrPSc was previously reported by us and others in numerous publications [15] , [30] , [41] , [48]–[50] and has been shown to be as low as ∼500 fg ( ∼20 attomoles ) of PrPSc .', 'This sensitivity of CDI is similar to the sensitivity of human prion bioassay in Tg ( MHu2M ) 5378/Prnp0/0 mice [30] .', 'First , we determined the concentration of disease-causing PrPSc in subpopulations of sporadic sCJD patients ( Table 1 and Figure 2 ) .', 'We observed wide interindividual variations , and approximately sixfold more accumulated PrPSc in the frontal cortex of patients with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) than those with Type 1 PrPSc ( 129 M ) or Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 V ) .', 'A large portion of PrPSc in all groups is protease-sensitive , constituting a pool of sPrPSc conformers ( Table 1 and Figure 3a ) .', 'The digestion with proteinase K ( PK ) was performed with 3 IU/ml ( 100 µg/ml ) of 10% brain homogenate containing 1% sarkosyl for one hour at 37°C .', 'The protocol for PrPSc digestion , validated in previously published experiments , was selected according to the following criteria: 1 ) complete digestion of PrPC determined with CDI in control samples; 2 ) complete shift of the bands of PrPSc to PrP 27–30 on WBs; 3 ) unequivocal WB differentiation of Type 1 and Type 2 rPrPSc in all tested samples [15] , [30] , [38] , [40] , [47] , [51] .', 'Additionally , the complete digestion of the PrPSc N-terminus with PK was monitored on WBs in all samples ( Figure S2 ) .', 'In patients with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) , significantly higher concentrations of total PrPSc and sPrPSc protein ( Table 1 ) are associated with extended duration of disease .', 'However , the concentration of sPrPSc vary greatly between individual patients , with numerous overlapping values between each classification group ( Figure 3a ) .', 'Thus , when the concentration of sPrPSc is expressed as a percentage of total PrPSc , no significant difference between groups appears , and the proportion of sPrPSc varies from 5% to 90% in individual patients ( Figure 3b ) .', 'We concluded from these observations that a major portion of pathogenic sCJD PrPSc is protease-sensitive and that the highest levels of sPrPSc are present in Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) .', 'The observed large interindividual differences in PK sensitivity likely indicate a broad range of PrPSc conformers within each PRNP genotype and WB pattern [15] , [39] .', 'Since the proteolytic sensitivity of PrPSc is considered a reliable and constant marker of a distinct prion strain , the data support the conclusion that distinct prion structures are present within each classification group .', 'The partial exposure of epitopes 108–112 and 175–185 in native pathogenic PrPSc reflects differences in the conformation of native PrPSc [15] , [52] .', 'When we adopted this approach previously , we found considerable differences among eight laboratory prion strains passaged in Syrian hamsters [15] .', 'The denatured state is a reference corresponding to the concentration of PrPSc; the ratio between the fluorescence signal of europium-labeled mAb 3F4 reacting with PrPSc in the native ( N ) or completely denatured ( D ) state represents a relative measure of the degree of exposure of these epitopes .', 'The highest D/N PrPSc ratio was found in patients with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) ; and despite a large spread of values , the difference is statistically significant ( P\u200a=\u200a0 . 002 ) ( Figure 4 ) .', 'PK treatment eliminated most of the exposed 108–112 and 175–185 epitopes in patients with Type 1 PrPSc ( 129 M ) and in patients with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 V ) , resulting in the increased D/N ratios ( Figure 4 ) .', 'The opposite trend was observed in patients with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) .', 'After PK treatment the PK-induced differences among the three cohorts proved statistically significant to a remarkable degree ( P<0 . 001 ) .', 'Large variations in D/N values exceed what we expect from our experiments with laboratory prion strains [15] and suggest that a high degree of conformational heterogeneity exists in PrPSc aggregates .', 'Protease treatment change the ratio in all groups and reduced the heterogeneity in MM2 sCJD , and as a result , each group could be reliably differentiated .', 'The increased frequency of exposed epitopes in codon 129 MM samples with Type 2 rPrPSc after PK treatment is unexpected and may indicate one of three possibilities: that the ligand protecting the 3F4 epitope was removed by PK treatment; that epitope 108–112 was protected by the N-terminus of PrPSc; or that conformational transition resulted in more exposed 108–112 epitopes .', 'Whether the epitopes hindrance in undigested PrPSc is the result of lipid , glycosaminoglycan , nucleic acid , or protein binding to the conformers unique to the MM2 sCJDF PrPSc remains to be established .', 'First , we asked whether the PTA precipitation has an impact on the stability of PrPSc .', 'This step in the protocol was important for eliminating high concentrations of PrPC and for concentrating PrPSc in brain samples with relatively low levels of PrPSc .', '( Figure S5 ) .', 'The denaturation curves performed on 5% brain homogenate before PTA precipitation , on PTA pellet and on PTA pellet washed with an excess of H2O , were superimposable , an effect which indicated that PTA quantitatively concentrated all PrPSc conformers and did not influence the stability in CDI .', 'This conclusion accords with numerous previously published data , including bioassays , which indicate that PTA dose not precipitate PrPC and recovers specifically ≥95% of infectious PrPSc in the pellet , regardless of protease sensitivity or prion strain [15] , [30] , [53]–[55] .', 'The error of the method does not exceed 5% in monitoring [Gdn HCl]1/2 values in the same repeatedly measured brain samples ( Figure S5 and Figure S6 ) .', 'Since the dissociation and unfolding of oligomeric PrPSc may be dependent on protein concentration [42] , we first followed the process with CDI at different dilutions of PrPSc ( Figure S5 ) .', 'The resulting overlapping dissociation/unfolding curves of PrPSc with variation in Gdn HCl1/2 values <3% indicate that in the 10–250 ng range , the dissociation/unfolding is independent of concentration and is highly reproducible .', 'Furthermore , to ensure the same conditions in all dissociation/unfolding experiments , the PrPSc content in all samples was maintained at a constant 50 ng/ml concentration .', 'As we observed previously with the western blot technique , the Gdn HCl1/2 values obtained with frontal , temporal , parietal , and occipital cortex , thalamus , and cerebellum in three typical sCJD cases were superimposable , indicating that the same conformers of PrPSc are present in different anatomical areas ( data not shown ) [38] .', 'Next we examined the frontal cortex of individual sCJD patients homozygous for methionine or valine at codon 129 of the PRNP gene .', 'Typical examples of dissociation/unfolding curves are shown in Figures 5a , 5b , and 5c .', 'Comparing all sCJD cases , we found a broad range of Gdn HCl1/2 values ranging from 1 . 3 to 3 . 5 M ( Figure 6a ) .', 'Because of the wide spread of values , the difference between the cases with Type 1 and 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) is only marginally significant ( P\u200a=\u200a0 . 040 ) and there is no statistically significant difference among other groups .', 'The possible cluster of Gdn HCl1/2 values at ∼3 . 0 M is discernible in cases with Type 1 PrPSc ( 129 M ) ( Figure 6a ) .', 'We concluded from these experiments that PrPSc proteins in different brains of sCJD patients display a vast range of unique conformations within each classification group .', 'We next investigated the conformational impact of the proteolytic digestion of sPrPSc conformers and the loss of N-terminal residues in rPrPSc .', 'The proteolysis of PrPSc with PK resulted in increased conformational stability in Type 1 rPrPSc ( 129 M ) and Type 2 rPrPSc ( 129 V ) but did not significantly reduce the range of values ( Figure 6a ) .', 'In contrast , PK treatment uniformly decreased Gdn HCl1/2 values in Type 2 rPrPSc ( 129 M ) ( Figure 6a ) .', "The marked drop in this group's stability is statistically significant to a high degree ( P<0 . 001 ) .", 'Additionally , there is a discernible cluster of Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) cases at ∼2 . 6 M ( Figure 6a ) .', 'We interpret the data as providing evidence of a wide range of unique conformations in each subgroup .', 'Proteolytic treatment selects the conformers having a more stable core in Type 1 rPrPSc ( 129 M ) and Type 2PrPSc ( 129 V ) .', 'The opposite effect of PK , as well as decreased stability , was observed in samples with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) .', 'These data suggest that PK treatment generates a unique set of conformers in Type 2PrPSc ( 129 M ) , characterized by increased exposure of 108–112 and 175–185 epitopes ( Figure 5 ) and , upon PK treatment , decreased stability of the core rPrPSc ( 129 M ) .', 'To investigate the conformational stability of sPrPSc separately from rPrPSc , we subtracted the relative fractional change in stability of rPrPSc after PK treatment from the PrPSc values obtained before PK ( Figures 5a , 5b , and 5c ) .', 'The resulting differential curves exhibit Gaussian distribution with the peak at the median stability of sPrPSc; the height and integrated peak area is proportional to the relative fraction of PK-digested conformers .', 'Overall stability of Type 1 sPrPSc is , as expected , lower than that of rPrPSc and we estimate , from these data alone , that sPrPSc conformers constitute 13–72% of the PrPSc ( Figure 6a ) .', 'A larger spread of positive values obtained with Type 2 sPrPSc ( 129 V ) coincides with a generally larger spread of Gdn HCl1/2 values in this group .', 'In contrast , the negative differential curves for Type 2 sPrPSc ( 129 M ) indicate that sPrPSc is more stable than rPrPSc in this patient group ( Figure 6b ) .', 'Notably , the only positive value in this group came from a sample having an atypical 19 and 17 kDa doublet of unglycosylated rPrPSc on WBs ( Figure 6b and Figure S2 ) .', 'Since the stability of sPrPSc and of rPrPSc reflect different initial conformation , the observed spread of values suggests a broad range of unique PrPSc conformers within each PRNP genotype and WB pattern [15] , [39] , [56] .', 'To determine whether unifying trends exist , we examined which PrPSc characteristics have an impact on duration of the disease in individual patients in all groups using regression analysis .', 'In contrast to analysis of variance ( Anova ) used to compare MM1 , MM2 , and VV2 groups ( Table 1 ) , the regression analysis is testing the relationship between a dependent variable ( duration of the disease ) and independent variables ( e . g . , sPrPSc levels ) in individual patients .', 'From concentrations of PrPSc , sPrPSc , and rPrPSc , only the levels of sPrPSc ( Figure S7a ) correlated significantly with longer duration of the disease .', 'The overall dependency is driven mainly by the higher levels of sPrPSc in Type 2 sPrPSc ( 129 M ) and longer duration of the disease in this subgroup ( Table 1 ) .', 'Additionally , the measurement of absolute concentration of sPrPSc is clearly a better indicator of this relationship than the estimate of the relative fraction ( percentage ) of sPrPSc ( Figure 3b ) .', 'Despite a wide spread of values , this observation corroborates the conclusion , drawn from previous experiments with eight laboratory strains of prion , that incubation time , and by extension duration of the disease , is linked to the higher levels of sPrPSc [15] .', 'We then analyzed the conformational characteristics of PrPSc .', 'The stability of rPrPSc clearly did not correlate with duration of the disease in individual cases ( Figure 7a ) .', 'In contrast , the change in the stability of PrPSc upon PK treatment ( Figure S7b ) or relative levels of sPrPSc conformers eliminated by PK ( Figure 7b ) expressed as a fraction of all conformers , both demonstrated better correlation with duration of the disease than did any other parameter in both Type 1 and Type 2 cases .', 'In contrast to simple measurement of sPrPSc concentration , the stability assay performed before and after PK treatment cumulatively determines the shift in the stability of PrPSc , change in the slope of the denaturation curve ( dissociation/unfolding rate ) , and relative levels of the sPrPSc conformers in the total PrPSc pool .', 'This effect leads to the clear separation of Type 1 from Type 2 sPrPSc ( 129 M ) cases ( Figure 7b ) .', 'We interpret these findings as evidence of the differential impact of protease treatment on different conformers , resulting in either increased or decreased stability of the remaining rPrPSc core ( PrP 27–30 ) .', 'Taken together , higher levels of more stable sPrPSc conformers are associated with extended duration of the disease .', 'Conversely , lower concentrations of unstable sPrPSc correlate with faster progression of the disease .'], ['The sixfold difference in concentrations of PrPSc between Type 1 and Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) ( Figure', '2 ) revealed in the frontal cortex by means of CDI was surprising , even though some variability was to be expected due to differences in the predominantly affected areas in distinct sCJD phenotypes [30] .', 'The average levels of PrPSc are up to 100-fold lower than those in standard laboratory prion models such as Syrian hamsters infected with Sc237 prions [15]; and together with the up to 100-fold variability within each phenotypic group , these lower levels of PrPSc may partially explain why some sCJD cases are difficult to transmit , and why lower endpoint titers are obtained with human prions in transgenic mice expressing human PrPC [14] , [26] , [30] , [64] .', 'As we observed previously , up to 90% of the pathogenic prion protein was protease-sensitive [30] .', 'In this study , we found the highest concentrations in Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) .', 'The broad range of absolute and relative levels of rPrPSc and sPrPSc offers evidence of a broad spectrum of PrPSc molecules differing in protease sensitivity in each group with an identical polymorphism at codon 129 of the PRNP gene and an identical WB pattern ( Figure 3 ) .', 'Moreover , these findings signal the existence of a variety of sCJD PrPSc conformers; and since protease sensitivity is one of the characteristics of prion strains , they also suggest that distinct sCJD prion strains exist [15] , [30] , [31] , [58] , [62] , [65] .', 'The CJD cases studied in this paper represent 75–90% of all clinical and pathologic diagnostic categories of sCJD [21] .', 'In order to allow unequivocal interpretation of the CDI data , we had to exclude sCJD patients heterozygous for codon 129 polymorphism in the PRNP gene , even though they represent ∼15–20% of sCJD cases .', 'The CDI cannot differentiate PrPSc with codon 129 M from V in a mixture which is present in sCJD heterozygots , and therefore we were unable to differentiate the conformational impact of codon 129 polymorphism .', 'We also excluded the VV1 type of sCJD because of its rarity .', 'This rare form of sCJD constitutes ∼1% of all sCJD cases and we did not collect enough cases to allow statistical comparison with the other groups [21] .', 'The heterogeneity of PrPSc conformations found with CDI within sCJD patients homozygous for codon 129 plymorphism of the PRNP gene is remarkable ( Table 1 and Figure 6 ) , with a range corresponding to that of stabilities found in more than ∼30 distinct strains of de-novo and natural laboratory rodent prions studied up to now [15] , [16] , [66] .', 'The high sensitivity and reproducibility of CDI , together with broad inter-individual variability detected with techniques based on three different principles—PK sensitivity , epitope exposure , and conformational stability—all indicate that the intragroup variations did not originate in the CDI technique but rather reflect differences in the structure of PrPSc in different patients .', 'The intriguing effect of PK treatment on the stability of Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) suggests that the protease-resistant core of Type 2 was profoundly destabilized .', 'Since sCJD cases with Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) have remarkably extended disease durations , the molecular mechanism underlying this effect calls for detailed investigation .', 'Several theories have been proposed to explain the origin of sCJD .', 'One argues for spontaneous somatic mutations in PRNP; another , for rare stochastic conformational changes in PrPC [26] , [67] .', 'Yet a third hypothesis holds that low levels of PrPSc are normally present and cleared , but rise to pathogenic levels when the clearance mechanism fails [40] .', 'Cumulatively , our findings indicate that sCJD PrPSc exhibit extensive conformational heterogeneity .', 'Whether this heterogeneity originates in a stochastic misfolding process that generates many distinct self-replicating conformations [26] , [67] or in a complex process of evolutionary selection during development of the disease [17] remains to be established .', 'We discovered this fraction of PrPSc while developing a conformation-dependent immunoassay ( CDI ) , which does not require proteolytic degradation of ubiquitous PrPC [15] .', 'Although the original definition of sPrPSc was only operational , considerable additional data demonstrate that ( 1 ) sPrPSc replicates in vivo and in vitro as an invariant and major fraction of PrPSc; ( 2 ) sPrPSc separates from rPrPSc in high speed centrifugation; and ( 3 ) the proteolytic sensitivity of PrPSc can reliably differentiate various prion strains [15] , [30] , [31] , [58] , [62] , [65] .', 'Accumulation of sPrPSc precedes protease-resistant product ( rPrPSc ) in prion infection [40] , [68]; and up to 90% of PrPSc accumulating in CJD brains consists of sPrPSc [30] .', 'Thus , the detection by CDI of sPrPSc as a disease-specific marker is widely regarded as a more reliable basis for diagnosing prion diseases .', 'This improved detection led to the discovery of a new human prion disorder , variably protease-sensitive prionopathy ( VPSPr ) [15] , [30] , [39] , [69] , [70] .', 'It is noteworthy that protease-sensitive synthetic prions generated in vitro during polymerization of recombinant mouse PrP into amyloid fibers produced upon inoculation into wild mice prions composed exclusively of sPrPSc [66] .', 'In laboratory rodent prion models , we found that levels of sPrPSc varied with the incubation time of the disease [15] but the molecular mechanism of this link was unknown [15] , [30] , [40] .', 'Subsequent experiments with yeast prions indicated that replication rate may be an inverse function of the stability of misfolded protein [71] .', 'The hypothesis based on these experiments posits that the less stable prions replicate faster by exposing more available sites for growth of the aggregates .', 'Additionally , experiments with laboratory and synthetic prions in mouse suggested that the yeast prion principle may apply to mammalian prions as well .', 'However , these experiments were based entirely on the correlation of the shorter incubation time of mouse inoculated with PrPSc that on WBs converted to protease-sensitive isoforms at a lower denaturant concentration , whereas the replication rates of mammalian prions were never determined [72] .', 'In this paper we determined the conformational features and stability of human sPrPSc in sCJD .', 'The data indicate that the levels as well as stability are linked to the progression rate of the disease .', 'Despite the inevitable influence of variable genetic background and the potential difficulties in evaluating initial symptoms , the disease progression rate and incubation time jointly represent an important parameter , which is influenced by replication rate , propagation , and clearance of prions from the brain [2] , [40] .', 'The correlations among the levels of sPrPSc , the stability of sPrPSc , and the duration of the disease found in this study all indicate that sPrPSc conformers play an important role in the pathogenesis .', 'When sPrPSc is less stable than rPrPSc , the difference in stability correlates with less accumulated sPrPSc and shorter duration of the disease .', 'Conversely , when sPrP conformers are more stable than rPrPSc , we observe the opposite effect—more accumulated sPrPSc and extended disease duration .', 'It remains to be determined if these effects represent an outcome of different replication rates and clearance , or whether they stem from as yet unknown aspects of the pathogenesis of sCJD .'], ['All procedures were performed under protocols approved by the Institutional Review Board at Case Western Reserve University .', 'In all cases , written informed consent for research was obtained from patient or legal guardian and the material used had appropriate ethical approval for use in this project .', "All patient's data and samples were coded and handled according to NIH guidelines to protect patients' identities .", 'We selected 46 representative subjects from a group of 340 patients with definitive diagnosis of sCJD .', 'The criteria for inclusion were ( 1 ) availability of clinical diagnosis of CJD according to WHO criteria [73]–[75] and clearly determined and dated initial symptoms upon neurological examination to ascertain the disease duration; ( 2 ) methionine or valine homozygous at codon 129 of the human prion protein ( PrP ) gene ( PRNP ) ; ( 3 ) unequivocal classification as pure Type 1 or Type 2 sCJD according to WB pattern; ( 4 ) unequivocal classification of pathology as definite Type 1 or 2 at the National Prion Disease Pathology Surveillance Center ( NPDPSC ) in Cleveland , OH; ( 5 ) demographic data distribution within 95% confidence interval of the whole group resulting in no difference between selected cases and the whole group in any of the statistically followed parameters .', 'Retrospective charts review was carried out for all subjects , with particular attention to the documented initial cardinal clinical signs of sCJD such as cognitive impairment , ataxia , and myoclonus [73]–[75] .', 'We also reviewed the findings on electroencephalography , brain magnetic resonance imaging , and CSF markers when available .', 'All Type 1–2 patients or uncertain cases were excluded from this study .', 'DNA was extracted from frozen brain tissues in all cases , and genotypic analysis of the PRNP coding region was performed as described [29] , [30] , [76] .', 'On the basis of diagnostic pathology , immunohistochemisty , and western blot ( WB ) examination of 2 or 3 brain regions ( including frontal , occipital and cerebellum cortices ) with mAb 3F4 , the pathogenic PrPSc was classified as ( 1 ) Type 1 PrPSc ( 129 M ) ( n\u200a=\u200a16 ) ; ( 2 ) Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M , n\u200a=\u200a16 ) ; or ( 3 ) Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 V , n\u200a=\u200a14 ) .', 'Patients lacked pathogenic mutations in the PRNP and had no history of familial diseases or known exposure to prion agents .', 'These cases underwent additional detailed WB analyses of the PrPSc so that we could ascertain the accuracy of their original classification and confirm that the same brain homogenate analyzed by CDI contained pure Type 1 PrPSc ( 129 M ) , Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 M ) , and Type 2 PrPSc ( 129 V ) .', 'Coronal sections of human brain tissues were obtained at autopsy and stored at 80°C .', 'Three 200–350 mg cuts of frontal ( superior and more posterior middle gyri ) cortex were taken from each brain and used for molecular analyses .', 'The other symmetric cerebral hemisphere was fixed in f
['Introduction', 'Results', 'Discussion', 'Materials and Methods']
['The origin , range , and structure of prions causing the most common human prion disease , sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease ( sCJD ) , are largely unknown .', 'To investigate the molecular mechanism responsible for the broad phenotypic variability of sCJD , we analyzed the conformational characteristics of protease-sensitive and protease-resistant fractions of the pathogenic prion protein ( PrPSc ) using novel conformational methods derived from a conformation-dependent immunoassay ( CDI ) .', 'In 46 brains of patients homozygous for polymorphisms in the PRNP gene and exhibiting either Type 1 or Type 2 western blot pattern of the PrPSc , we identified an extensive array of PrPSc structures that differ in protease sensitivity , display of critical domains , and conformational stability .', 'Surprisingly , in sCJD cases homozygous for methionine or valine at codon 129 of the PRNP gene , the concentration and stability of protease-sensitive conformers of PrPSc correlated with progression rate of the disease .', 'These data indicate that sCJD brains exhibit a wide spectrum of PrPSc structural states , and accordingly argue for a broad spectrum of prion strains coding for different phenotypes .', 'The link between disease duration , levels , and stability of protease-sensitive conformers of PrPSc suggests that these conformers play an important role in the pathogenesis of sCJD .']
['Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease ( sCJD ) is the most common human prion disease worldwide .', 'This neurodegenerative disease , which is transmissible and invariably fatal , is characterized by the accumulation of an abnormally folded isoform ( PrPSc ) of a host-encoded protein ( PrPC ) , predominantly in the brain .', 'Most researchers believe that PrPSc is the infectious agent and five or six subtypes of sCJD have been identified .', 'Whether or not these subtypes represent distinct strains of sCJD prions is debated in the context of the extraordinary variability of sCJD phenotypes , frequent co-occurrence of different PrPSc fragments in the same brain , and the fact that up to 90% of protease-sensitive PrPSc eludes the conventional analysis because it is destroyed by protease treatment .', 'Using novel conformational methods , we identified within each clinical and pathological category an array of PrPSc structures that differ in protease-sensitivity , display of critical domains , and conformational stability .', 'Each of these features offers evidence of a distinct conformation .', 'The link between the rate at which the disease progresses , on the one hand , and the concentration and stability of protease-sensitive conformers of PrPSc on the other , suggests that these conformers play an important role in how the disease originates and progresses .']
['medicine', 'chemistry', 'biology']