Is she comically over the top, attention-grabbing and at times hysterical (Anthony Tommasini, the New York Times ), or is she simply a captivating comic presence (Charles Isherwood, Variety )? Not everyone loved the  New York 's Peter Davis says, [T]he characters [are] foggily defined and the heart of the opera left unexamined.
Some people liked the New York 's Peter Davis opera and some people didn't.
Nobody like the New York 's Peter Davis opera.