I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue the programme but said that there's "got to be an agonising reappraisal" and that Lyttelton was the "very hub of the show". Cryer, Tim Brooke-Taylor and Graeme Garden all ruled themselves out as hosts: Cryer did not think the programme would work if a panellist became chairman and it "would need somebody of stature to be parachuted in". Jeremy Hardy also ruled himself out, saying "Humph had big shoes to fill and I wouldn't do it." In the "Clue" mailout for September 2008 Naismith stated: "Despite the rumours, we've made no decisions about possible replacements for Humph, and are unlikely
I Was Wrong, I'm Sorry & I Love You is far from done, this chapter makes for a grace-filled homecoming." Also, Jesus Freak Hideout's Mark Rice evoked that "Without a doubt, "I Was Wrong…" is Webb's musically most accessible album he's put out as he masters the type of sound that almost everyone can appreciate." At New Release Tuesday, Mary Nikkel highlighted that ""I Was Wrong, I'm Sorry & I Love You" is a culmination, not a contradiction, of Webb's previous body of work, reflecting past themes while recasting them with humility." Scott S. Mertens at The Phantom Tollbooth told that the release was "Somewhat tuned down, both lyrically