Another Suitcase in Another Hall Burpee called it "A sterling, intimate moment from the "Evita" soundtrack. Yes kids, she [Madonna] "can" sing". Writing for the "Los Angeles Times", David Gritten opined Madonna's voice sounded "pitch-perfect and clear as a bell". Greg Morago, from the "Hartford Courant", felt that "By giving her 'Another Suitcase' with its heartbreaking 'Where am I going to?' refrain, Madonna adds a necessary, fragile vulnerability to her ambitious, rags- to-riches Eva Peron". Neil Strauss from "The Herald Journal", said that "Madonna radiates on 'Another Suitcase in Another Hall'". Peter Keough, from the "Boston Phoenix", described the track as "a poignant, winsome exploration
In Another Lifetime released a press release, which spoke of the song, quoting Hillman, who stated ""...but then you take a song like "In Another Lifetime" and you've got John Jorgenson playing guitar like Eric Clapton."" In 2009, a MP3 only karaoke version of the song was created and released by Stingray Music, which included an instrumental version as well as a demonstration version which included lead vocals. This karaoke song featured on an album of three other Desert Rose Band tracks from the "Pages of Life" album; "Story of Love", "Start All Over Again" and "Time Passes Me By". The version was