You Don't Have to Say You Love Me entitled "Jo no puc viure sense tu" was a 1965 single release for Renata. Pino Donaggio himself recorded a Spanish version of the song entitled "Yo que no vivo sin ti", which was remade in 1971 by Angélica María for her self-titled album and in 1987 by Luis Miguel on his album "Soy Como Quiero Ser", Miguel's version ranking at No.26 on the Hot Latin Tracks in "Billboard". Most international versions of the song were subsequent to Dusty Springfield's 1966 success with "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me" and reference that version's lyrics rather than the Italian original.
You Love Me? Michielvmusic of A Bit of Pop Music described the song as, "an insanely catchy and infectious pop track with some hints of R&B and hiphop" and noted that "the sample with the cute vocals that say ‘You love, you love me, you know that you love me’ will stay in your head forever", further commending her "sweet and soaring vocals that reach high heights". Stagedoor FM called the song "a strong anthem for hazy summer days", while InspireLS described the production of the record as "slick" and Steel's vocals as "alluringly sweet". You Love Me? "You Love Me?" is a