Sweet About Me Digital Spy positively reviewed "Sweet About Me," giving it four out of five stars. Levine comended Xenomania's production on the track, calling it "authentic" and "fresh". He also praised Gabriella Cilmi's vocals on the song, "Most impressive of all is Cilmi's voice, which manages to be sweet and coarse all at the same time, much like a drizzling of honey on a slice of toast." Jake Taylor of Sputnikmusic deemed "Sweet About Me" as one of the best songs released by an Australian artist on debut. He wrote, "A lot of songs focus on the chorus as the returning point
Fill Me In in the UK top 40 in the week of 15 April 2000. "Fill Me In" topped the charts in an unusual week: all top 6 positions in the top 10 were new entries, including hits by Sweet Female Attitude ("Flowers"), Richard Ashcroft and Steps. After one week at the top, Craig dropped to no.2 for two weeks, replaced at no.1 by "Toca's Miracle" by Fragma. Nevertheless, "Fill Me In" managed to clock an impressive 10 weeks inside the top 40, being the chart's longest-running hit at the time it departed on 24 June. The single had a delayed release in