Order your Official Strawberry Days 2017 shirt! Order by June 4th | Free Pick Up from June 8th-9th at Rivals, Inc. | Limited quantities available for purchase at Street Fair | Click to Order
1 How long this takes depends on how thick the steak is and how well you want it to be done. 2  A one-inch (2.5-centimeter) thick steak will take about four minutes for rare steak and about 10 minutes for a well-done steak. 3  Half way through the cooking time, turn the steak over in the pan [source: Delia Smith ].
Answered by The Community. Making the world better, one answer at a time. A 1 inch boneless rib eye, tenderloin, or top loin steak should be cooked for 6-8 minutes on the George Foreman Grill (covered) at 350 degrees F to 375 degrees F for medium rare. If you are cooking uncovered it should be 8-11 minutes.edium steak â¦ is usually 9 minutes and a well done steak would probably be 10-12 minutes. It is also important to marinate the steaks before putting on the grill. You can start to grill after giving 6 hours to marinate but you may experience a change in flavor.