people with intellectual disability ( i d ) experience significant health inequalities compared with the general population.1,2 for example , patients with i d have higher mortality rates , a shorter life expectancy , and higher levels of unmet health needs.1 previous studies have indicated that individuals with i d have higher levels of an overweight status and obesity than those without id,15 and moderate , but not severe , i d has been reported to be associated with being overweight.3,4 it has also been reported that the risk of developing i d is high among patients with epilepsy.69 valproic acid ( vpa ) is one of the most widely prescribed antiepileptic drugs worldwide.10 long - term treatment with vpa has been shown to be associated with metabolic and endocrine disorders , such as weight gain and hyperinsulinemia , which may contribute to the increased cardiovascular risks observed in patients with epilepsy.1113 although the real incidence and magnitude of vpa - induced weight gain is unknown , the reported frequency of weight gain varies between 10% and 70%.11,12 several potential risk factors for vpa - induced weight gain have been identified , including puberty and a pretreatment overweight status.11,12 however , there are presently no data available regarding the relationship between i d and vpa - induced weight gain .
the primary objective of this exploratory study was to retrospectively investigate the influence of moderate i d on an overweight status in vpa - treated patients with epilepsy .
furthermore , we determined potentially specific factors affecting weight gain in vpa - treated patients with moderate i d .
a clinic - based retrospective longitudinal analysis was conducted among 143 japanese patients ( 89 males and 54 females ) with epilepsy treated with vpa at kumamoto saishunso national hospital in kumamoto , japan , between june 1989 and april 2011 .
the study protocol was approved by the ethics committees of kumamoto saishunso national hospital and the faculty of life sciences , kumamoto university ( kumamoto , japan ) .
informed consent , including a statement regarding the privacy policy , was obtained in writing from each patient and his / her parent before entry into the study .
patients were included if they fulfilled all the following conditions : younger than 18 years of age at the start of vpa therapy ( baseline ) ; treatment with sustained - release vpa for 6 months or longer and not taking any drugs that may alter the body weight , except for antiepileptic drugs ; and no history of severe or profound i d , eg , severe motor and intellectual disabilities , as well as other psychiatric disorders .
the type of seizure and epileptic syndrome was classified according to the guidelines of the international league against epilepsy.14 in all patients , vpa therapy was chosen according to the treatment guidelines of the japan epilepsy society .
the dose of vpa was escalated at weekly intervals by 510 mg / kg / day for each step up to the maximum tolerated dose .
the data included the patient s weight , dose , and schedule of vpa and concomitant medications , evaluated at all visits during treatment with vpa .
we used the international classification of diseases , 10th revision ( icd-10 ) to identify individuals with moderate i d ( icd-10 f71 , consistent with an iq score of 3549 ) and defined patients with an iq score of 50 as being without moderate i d .
the height and weight of each subject were measured , and the body mass index ( bmi ) was calculated . since the bmi in childhood changes substantially with age,15 the age- and sex - specific international bmi cutoff value for an overweight status in children , which was established by cole et al15 was used for diagnosis of being overweight when the patient was 17 years of age or under .
when the patient was 18 years of age or older during vpa therapy , an overweight status was diagnosed as a bmi 25 kg / m . we determined the bmi gap in each patient at every follow - up visit using the following equation : bmi gap = patient s bmi value 
, the strength of the association between moderate i d and the risk of being overweight was measured as the odds ratio using a logistic regression analysis in all vpa - treated patients with epilepsy . among the patients who were not overweight at baseline , the cumulative incidence of becoming overweight according to the presence or absence of moderate i d was plotted based on the kaplan  meier method , and the multivariable - adjusted hazard ratio ( hr ) was determined using a cox proportional hazards model .
the odds ratio and hr were adjusted for potentially confounding factors,11,16 ie , the patient age at baseline , sex , dose of vpa , seizure locus , and the co - administration of antiepileptic drugs that may influence the body weight ( ie , carbamazepine , clobazam , gabapentin , zonisamide ) and other antiepileptic drugs . in order to identify specific factors influencing the fluctuation in weight in the patients with moderate i
d , the associations between the patient age at baseline , sex , dose of vpa , seizure locus and co - administration of antiepileptic drugs and the longitudinal changes in the bmi gap were also measured using adjusted partial regression coefficients ( b ) separately in the patients with and without moderate i d .
the b - values were calculated employing a multiple linear regression model based on the generalized estimating equations approach . in the multiple linear regression model , the variance structure model was best described using an autoregressive model . in order to assess the cumulative incidence of an overweight status and
the multivariable - adjusted hr obtained using the cox proportional hazards model , we included all data acquired at every follow - up visit during the vpa therapy period . in order to assess the longitudinal changes in the bmi gap using the generalized estimating equations approach
, we extracted the values for the bmi gap at yearly intervals after starting the vpa therapy . a p - value of < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant .
all statistical analyses were performed using the spss software package for windows ( version 17.0 , ibm japan ltd . , tokyo , japan ) .
the prevalence of moderate i d was 52.4% among all 143 vpa - treated patients with epilepsy .
the patient characteristics at baseline according to the presence or absence of moderate i d are shown in table 1 . the frequency of being overweight at baseline was 18.7% and 14.7% in the patients with and without moderate i d , respectively ( p>0.05 ) .
significant differences were observed between the patients with moderate i d and those without moderate i d in terms of the daily vpa dose ; number of patients receiving vpa only ; number of patients treated with co - administered carbamazepine , clobazam , or phenytoin ; seizure locus ; and seizure type ( table 1 ) . according to the logistic regression analysis in the 143 patients ,
moderate i d was not associated with the incidence of an overweight status at baseline ( odds ratio = 1.18 , 95% confidence intervals = 0.403.53 , p=0.762 ) .
the patient characteristics of the 119 patients who were not overweight at baseline according to the presence or absence of moderate i d are shown in table 1 .
significant differences were also observed between the patients with moderate i d and those without moderate i d in the daily vpa dose ; number of patients receiving vpa only ; number of patients treated with co - administered carbamazepine , clobazam or phenytoin ; seizure locus ; and seizure type ( table 1 ) .
no patients were treated with gabapentin , which may influence the body weight,16 during vpa therapy .
the mean duration of follow - up was 3.62.1 years ( 4.12.1 years for the patients with moderate i d ; 3.11.9 years for those without moderate i d ) .
sixteen ( 13.4% ) patients ( 13 [ 21.3% ] patients with moderate i d , 3 patients [ 5.2% ] without moderate i d ] were newly diagnosed to be overweight during the vpa therapy period .
figure 1 shows the cumulative incidence of becoming overweight in the patients with and without moderate i d .
the presence of moderate i d was significantly associated with a higher incidence of an overweight status in the cox regression model ( hr=6.72 , 95% confidential intervals = 1.6627.15 , p=0.007 ) , which was adjusted for potential confounding factors , ie , the patient age at baseline , sex , dose of vpa , seizure locus , and co - administration of antiepileptic drugs that can influence the body weight ( carbamazepine , clobazam , zonisamide ) and other antiepileptic drugs . in order to identify factors influencing longitudinal changes in body weight during vpa therapy , we investigated the associations between the patient age at baseline , sex , dose of vpa , seizure locus , and co - administration of antiepileptic drugs and the longitudinal changes in the bmi gap separately in the patients with and without moderate i d ( table 2 ) . among the patients with moderate i
d , the co - administration of carbamazepine and clobazam was significantly associated with an increased bmi gap , while a younger age at baseline and the co - administration of zonisamide was associated with a decreased bmi gap ( table 2 ) . among the patients without moderate
i d , a younger age at baseline was associated with a decreased bmi gap , whereas none of the other patient characteristics were associated with the longitudinal changes in the bmi gap ( table 2 ) .
table 3 shows the number of patients treated with carbamazepine , clobazam , or zonisamide at each time point used in the evaluation of the longitudinal changes in the bmi gap during vpa therapy .
the number of patients treated with carbamazepine and clobazam tended to be higher among the subjects with moderate i d than among those without ( table 3 ) .
the daily doses of carbamazepine and clobazam during vpa therapy also tended to be greater in the patients with moderate i d than in those without moderate i d ( figure 2 ) , whereas there were no differences in the dose of zonisamide ( data not shown ) .
the findings of this retrospective longitudinal study showed that moderate i d is associated with weight gain in patients with epilepsy under vpa therapy .
it is known that vpa - induced weight gain may be associated with pathological consequences related to obesity , such as dyslipidemia , diabetes mellitus , and atherosclerosis.11,12,17 therefore , identifying patients at risk for weight gain will help clinicians to select the appropriate treatment and appropriately counsel these patients to avoid weight gain.11 the results of previous clinical studies suggest that various risk factors contribute to vpa - induced weight gain , including a female sex , puberty , a long duration of therapy , generalized seizures , and a pretreatment overweight status.11,12 the findings of the current study suggest that moderate i d may be a potential novel risk factor for weight gain in vpa - treated patients with epilepsy .
the mechanism underlying vpa - induced weight gain is a matter of debate , and various hypotheses have been proposed to explain the effects of vpa on increases in weight .
such mechanisms include dysregulation of the hypothalamic system and the effects of insulin resistance.11,12 it is known that treatment with vpa disrupts the hypothalamo  hypophyseal  gonadal axis in female rats,18 and
it has been reported that vpa - treated patients who report weight gain develop an increased appetite and frequently consume calorie - rich beverages.11,12,19 it has also been demonstrated that people with i d , especially those with moderate i d , have higher levels of being overweight and obese than those without.25 proposed reasons for this observation include high levels of inactivity and comorbid health conditions , physical disabilities , or excessive eating in individuals with id.1,2,5 therefore , we speculate that the more pronounced vpa - induced weight gain observed in patients with moderate i d may be attributed to id - related physical inactivity or excessive eating , although the underlying mechanism remains unknown . in the present study
, the co - administration of carbamazepine and clobazam was significantly associated with an increased bmi gap only in the patients with moderate i d ( table 2 ) .
previous studies have reported that patients treated with carbamazepine experience weight gain in the same manner as vpa - treated patients,20,21 and the frequency of weight gain is observed to be as high as 19.1% in patients treated with clobazam.22 patients with epilepsy and i d often receive many antiepileptic drugs at high doses , as i d has been identified to be a potential predictor of intractable epilepsy.2325 in the present study , the number of patients treated with carbamazepine and clobazam tented to be higher among the subjects with moderate i d than those without ( tables 1 and 3 ) , and the doses of these antiepileptic drugs were greater in the patients with moderate i d ( figure 2 ) . when these findings are combined , the high incidence of an overweight status among the vpa - treated patients with moderate i d may also be attributed to the higher frequencies and greater doses of the co - administered carbamazepine and clobazam in these patients , although we adjusted for these potential confounding factors in the cox proportional hazards regression analysis .
the findings of previous clinical studies have demonstrated that a decreased appetite and weight loss are frequently reported in patients treated with zonisamide.26,27 in the present study , the co - administration of zonisamide was associated with a decreased bmi gap only in the patients with moderate i d ( table 2 ) , whereas the number and daily dose of co - administrated zonisamide during vpa therapy did not differ between the patients with moderate i d and those without ( tables 1 and 3 ) .
therefore , the weight loss  inducing effect of zonisamide may be more pronounced in patients with moderate i d than in those without moderate i d .
nevertheless , it remains to be definitively determined why co - administered zonisamide was associated with a decreased bmi gap only in the patients with moderate i d in the current study .
therefore , further investigation with a larger number of patients is required to verify the associations discussed earlier .
puberty has been identified to be a risk factor for weight gain in vpa - treated patients with epilepsy.11 previous studies have suggested that the mature endocrine system in adults may be necessary for the development of vpa - related obesity.11 in this study , a younger age at baseline was found to be associated with a decreased bmi gap in either the patients with or without moderate i d ( table 2 ) . within our study population ,
the findings of the present study suggest that a younger age at baseline may be associated with a low risk of vpa - induced weight gain in children , regardless of the presence of moderate i d .
a major limitation of this study is the study design , which involved a retrospective investigation of a small number of patients .
additionally , since we included only vpa - treated patients , we were unable to determine the relationships between the presence of moderate i d and the weight status in the patients treated with other antiepileptic drugs and nonepileptic subjects . furthermore , several potential covariates associated with being overweight were not included , such as a pretreatment overweight status , dietary habits , physical activity level , presence of sleep apnea , blood concentrations of vpa and other antiepileptic drugs , blood ammonia level , electroencephalogram finding , and type(s ) of disability .
sleep apnea , especially , has been reported to be associated with weight gain as well as cognitive function.28,29 however , since we did not screen sleep apnea in the study subjects , we could not identify the patients with sleep apnea among the subjects included .
finally , since we excluded patients with a history of severe or profound i d in the present study , the association between the severity of i d and vpa - induced weight gain remains unknown .
further investigations are thus needed to confirm and further clarify the association between i d and vpa - induced weight gain .
in conclusion , this is , to the best of our knowledge , the first study to show that patients with moderate i d may have a high risk of becoming overweight during vpa therapy .
additionally , this study demonstrated that the co - administration of carbamazepine and clobazam may be associated with vpa - induced weight gain in patients with moderate i d .
the findings of the present study suggest that the potential for weight gain should be carefully monitored in vpa - treated patients with moderate i d , especially those receiving other co - administered antiepileptic drugs that facilitate weight gain , such as carbamazepine and clobazam .
 backgroundalthough patients with moderate intellectual disability ( i d ) are known to have higher rates of being overweight and obese than those without i d , there are no current data regarding the relationship between i d and weight gain in epilepsy patients treated with valproic acid ( vpa).patients and methodsthe possible association between moderate i d and an overweight status at the time of initiation of vpa therapy ( baseline ) was investigated using a logistic regression analysis in 143 patients with epilepsy . among the 119 nonoverweight patients at baseline , the longitudinal association between moderate i d and the weight status during vpa therapy 
 was retrospectively examined using a cox hazards regression analysis and the generalized estimating equations approach , while also paying careful attention to associations with other patient characteristics.resultsthe proportion of patients with moderate i d was 52.4% among the 143 study subjects . 
 the presence of moderate i d was not associated with an overweight status at baseline ( p=0.762 ) . among the nonoverweight patients at baseline , 
 16 subjects were newly diagnosed as being overweight during treatment with vpa ( 3.62.1 years ) . 
 the presence of moderate i d was significantly associated with the incidence of an overweight status after starting vpa therapy ( adjusted hazard ratio = 6.72 , p=0.007 ) . 
 the patient age at baseline and treatment with co - administered carbamazepine , clobazam , and zonisamide significantly influenced the degree of weight fluctuation during vpa therapy among the patients with moderate i d ( p<0.001 , p<0.001 , p=0.002 , and p=0.028 , respectively ) , whereas only patient age at baseline affected this parameter among the patients without moderate i d ( p=0.022).conclusionthe present findings suggest that the weight status should be carefully monitored in vpa - treated patients with moderate i d , especially those receiving other co - administered antiepileptic drugs that facilitate weight gain , such as carbamazepine . 
Introduction
Materials and methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion