lung cancer is the most commonly diagnosed cancer . it is the leading cause of cancer - related deaths in males and the second cause of cancer - related deaths in females worldwide.1 non - small - cell histology comprises ~85% of lung cancers , and 75% of patients
are diagnosed at stages iii and iv.2,3 at the advanced stages , taxane chemotherapy regimens are commonly used for the treatment of non - small - cell lung cancers ( nsclcs ) as first - line options.4 however , long - term survival in patients with advanced nsclc is < 5% and toxic .
side effects such as febrile neutropenia , neuropathy , and hypersensitivity reactions are particularly high in taxane formulations .
furthermore , the therapeutic results are not satisfactory.4,5 paclitaxel and its semisynthetic form , docetaxel , are isolated from the yew tree and primarily stabilize cytoplasmic microtubules via binding to the -tubulin site , thereby causing cell cycle arrest at the g2/m phase and driving apoptosis.6 several compounds have been tested to determine whether they increase taxane - induced anticancer efficacy .
for example , the therapeutic efficacy of paclitaxel is restricted by the increasing frequency of chemotherapeutic resistance in nsclc . pulsing with both taxanes results in approximately fivefold higher resistant clones in nsclc cells , such as a549 and h1299 cells.7 several compounds , such as l - type calcium channel blockers , reverse docetaxel - induced multidrug resistance independent of abcb1 expression in both cell lines.8 additionally , the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin a increases both cell cycle delay at the g2/m phase and apoptosis in docetaxel - treated a549 cells.9 in hormone - refractory prostate cancer ( hrpc ) models , taxol synergizes with several antioxidants in hrpc cells by inducing cell cycle arrest at the sub g1 phase , apoptosis , and caspase activity and decreasing bcl-2 expression simultaneously.10 by contrast , tp53 mutations are the most frequent gene abnormalities leading to inactivation of p53 , which effects paclitaxel sensitivity in nsclc.11 a trace element , zinc , is essential for the wide range of physiological processes , including growth , development , and immune functions as well as the intracellular activities of ~300 enzymes and 2,000 transcription factors.12 it is also effective in decreasing oxidative stress and the generation of inflammatory cytokines such as tnf- and il-1.13 furthermore , the role of zinc in the development and progression of prostate cancer and its widespread antitumor efficacy have been shown in several malignancies.1417 intracellular zinc status is associated with prostate carcinogenesis .
for example , zinc deficiency contributes to tumor progression and development in cultured hrpc cells,18 whereas increased levels of intracellular zinc decrease cancer cell proliferation and induce apoptosis.14,15 in a large case - control study , a direct association was found between zinc intake and prostate cancer risk.19 the vast majority of epithelial tumors are associated with reduced intratumoral or plasma zinc levels.20 importantly , zinc deficiency reduces paclitaxel efficacy in cultured prostate cancer cells , whereas increased intracellular zinc concentrations sensitize prostate cancer cells to cytotoxic agents , including paclitaxel , via inhibition of nf-b activation.21,22 therefore , zinc supplementation may have growth inhibitory effects against nsclc cells and may increase docetaxel efficacies . in this study , cellular viability ,
apoptosis , and cell cycle alterations as well as oxidative stress activities were tested in the nsclc cell lines , a549 , and h1299 , when zinc was used alone and in combination with docetaxel .
nsclc cells , a549 ( p53 wild - type ) , and h1299 ( lymph node metastasis , p53 null - type ) were obtained from the american type culture collection .
the a549 cells were cultured in dmem / ham s f12k medium that containing 10% fbs , 1% penicillin / streptomycin , 1% l - glutamine , and 1% amphotericin b. the h1299 cells were cultured in rpmi-1640 medium containing 10% fbs , 1% penicillin / streptomycin , 1% l - glutamine , and 1% amphotericin b at 37c in a 5% co2 incubator .
cell viability was determined using the cck-8 ( cell counting kit-8 ; sigma - aldrich , st louis , mo , usa ) assay in accordance with the manufacturer s instructions .
briefly , when the cells reached 80% confluency , the medium was replaced with fresh medium without zinc or docetaxel .
then , the cells were transferred to 96-well plates at a density of 10,000 cells / well .
docetaxel ( 0.001100 m ) and zinc sulfate ( 101,000 m ) were added to the cell lines at different concentrations in each of the eight wells .
the cck-8 reagents were added to each well at the indicated time after the treatments . at the end of 24 hours and 48 hours , the absorbance was measured at a test wavelength of 450 nm and a reference wavelength of 650 nm using a microplate reader ( thermo electron corporation , multiskan ascent ) .
the average inhibitory concentration 50 values ( ic50 values ) were determined at 24-hour and 48-hour treatment periods .
the 24-hour doses were selected due to the lack of significant differences between the 24-hour and 48-hour doses .
the cells were plated in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and the total volume was brought to 3.2 ml with fresh media .
after the initial 72-hour incubation , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with the previously established ic50 concentrations of docetaxel , zinc and combinations thereof in fresh medium for an additional 24 hours .
the cells were harvested by trypsinization and collected by centrifugation at 1,500 rpm for 5 minutes . following removal of the supernatant
, the cells were resuspended in 400 l binding buffer and stained with 5 l annexin - v and 5 l propidium iodide ( pi , 50 g / ml ) at room temperature for 20 minutes in the dark . after adding 400 l binding buffer to each tube
the percentage apoptosis , necrosis , and viable cells were evaluated by using a flow cytometer .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a becton dickinson ( bd ) facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells . the cycletest plus dna reagent kit ( bd pharmingen )
the cells were seeded in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and their volume was adjusted to 3.2 ml with media . after an initial incubation for 72 hours , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with previously defined ic50 doses of zinc and docetaxel and then incubated for 24 hours .
then , the medium was removed , and 500 l trypsin was added to the cells , which were transferred into a tube .
a volume of 1 ml fresh medium was added to each tube to inactivate the trypsin .
the suspension was transferred to 17100 mm tubes and centrifuged at 1,500 rpm for 5 minutes .
the supernatant was removed , and the cells were resuspended by adding 1 ml buffer solution ( sucrose - citrate buffer containing dimethyl sulfoxide ) to the pellet ( wash procedure ) .
after removal of the buffer , 250 l solution a ( citrate buffer containing trypsin ) was added to the pellet in each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
then , 200 l solution b ( citrate buffer containing trypsin inhibitor and rnase ) was added to each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
finally , 200 l solution c ( pi - staining solution ) at 4c was added to each tube and reincubated on ice for 10 minutes .
three hours later , the cells were analyzed using double laser - flow cytometry devices .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a bd facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells .
the cells in g0/g1 , s ( synthesis ) , and g2/m ( mitosis ) phases were evaluated using the modfitlt3.2 software program .
the cell lysates were prepared and kept at 20c before the antioxidant enzyme and malondialdehyde ( mda ) analyses . for standard preparation , the mda standard ( t-9889 )
a 10 mm stock standard solution was prepared by dissolving the mda in distilled water , and this was then diluted to working concentrations ranging from 1 m to 50 m . for sample preparation
, the protein concentrations were measured using a bca protein assay kit ( pierce bca protein assay kit 23225 ; thermo fisher scientific , waltham , ma , usa ) .
the samples were lyophilized with a flexi - dry up freeze dryer ( fts systems , stone ridge , ny ) because of the low protein concentrations . for mda measurement , 100 l
distilled water was added to a 40 l volume of all cell samples . then , 20 l of 2.8 mmol / l bht , 40 l of 8.1% sds , 600 l of 8 g
/ l tba:200 ml / l acetic acid ( 1:1 ) were added , and the ph was adjusted with 2 m naoh ( ph 3.5 ) .
a volume of 200 l distilled water and 1,000 l butanol : pyridine ( 15:1 ) were added , and all the samples were vortexed for 1 minute .
after 3 minutes , the organic phases were transferred to new eppendorf tubes and centrifuged at 10,000 rpm for 10 minutes .
the samples were then placed in an autosampler vial for high - performance liquid chromatography ( hplc ) analysis .
as previously described,23 the analysis was performed using a hplc set prominence lc 20 ( shimadzu , kyoto , japan ) equipped with sil-20ac autosampler , lc-20ad pump , and rf-10axl fluorescence detector .
phosphate buffer ( 0.01 m in 30% methanol , ph 7.0 ) was used as the mobile phase .
the superoxide dismutase ( sod ) activity of the cells was determined using a ransod kit ( randox labs , crumlin , uk ) .
the absorbance was measured at 505 nm on a microplate reader ( bio - tek instruments , inc .
the glutathione peroxidase ( gpx ) activity of the cells was determined using a ransel kit ( randox labs , crumlin , uk ) and a previously described method.24 briefly , the lyophilized cells and standard solutions were used to assay for gpx .
the absorbance was measured at 340 nm on a microplate reader ( bio - tek instruments , inc . ) . in this method , gpx oxidizes glutathione via cumene hydroperoxidase . in the presence of gr and nadph ,
oxidized glutathione is immediately converted to the reduced form , with concomitant oxidation of nadph to nadp .
a 40-l sample was added to the primary reagent ( 200 l ) and cumene ( 80 l ) into a 96-well plate .
the plate was read after 1 minute , then again after 2 minutes for the final absorbance ( after reaction ) .
the gpx activity of these samples was calculated according to gpx manual included with the ransel kit .
the triplicate data were analyzed using the sigmastat 3.5 ( systat inc . , santa cruz , ca , usa ) software program .
nsclc cells , a549 ( p53 wild - type ) , and h1299 ( lymph node metastasis , p53 null - type ) were obtained from the american type culture collection .
the a549 cells were cultured in dmem / ham s f12k medium that containing 10% fbs , 1% penicillin / streptomycin , 1% l - glutamine , and 1% amphotericin b. the h1299 cells were cultured in rpmi-1640 medium containing 10% fbs , 1% penicillin / streptomycin , 1% l - glutamine , and 1% amphotericin b at 37c in a 5% co2 incubator .
cell viability was determined using the cck-8 ( cell counting kit-8 ; sigma - aldrich , st louis , mo , usa ) assay in accordance with the manufacturer s instructions .
briefly , when the cells reached 80% confluency , the medium was replaced with fresh medium without zinc or docetaxel .
then , the cells were transferred to 96-well plates at a density of 10,000 cells / well .
docetaxel ( 0.001100 m ) and zinc sulfate ( 101,000 m ) were added to the cell lines at different concentrations in each of the eight wells .
the cck-8 reagents were added to each well at the indicated time after the treatments . at the end of 24 hours and 48 hours , the absorbance was measured at a test wavelength of 450 nm and a reference wavelength of 650 nm using a microplate reader ( thermo electron corporation , multiskan ascent ) .
the average inhibitory concentration 50 values ( ic50 values ) were determined at 24-hour and 48-hour treatment periods .
the 24-hour doses were selected due to the lack of significant differences between the 24-hour and 48-hour doses .
the cells were plated in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and the total volume was brought to 3.2 ml with fresh media .
after the initial 72-hour incubation , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with the previously established ic50 concentrations of docetaxel , zinc and combinations thereof in fresh medium for an additional 24 hours .
the cells were harvested by trypsinization and collected by centrifugation at 1,500 rpm for 5 minutes . following removal of the supernatant
, the cells were resuspended in 400 l binding buffer and stained with 5 l annexin - v and 5 l propidium iodide ( pi , 50 g / ml ) at room temperature for 20 minutes in the dark . after adding 400 l binding buffer to each tube
the percentage apoptosis , necrosis , and viable cells were evaluated by using a flow cytometer .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a becton dickinson ( bd ) facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells . the cycletest plus dna reagent kit ( bd pharmingen )
the cells were seeded in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and their volume was adjusted to 3.2 ml with media . after an initial incubation for 72 hours , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with previously defined ic50 doses of zinc and docetaxel and then incubated for 24 hours .
then , the medium was removed , and 500 l trypsin was added to the cells , which were transferred into a tube .
a volume of 1 ml fresh medium was added to each tube to inactivate the trypsin . the suspension
the supernatant was removed , and the cells were resuspended by adding 1 ml buffer solution ( sucrose - citrate buffer containing dimethyl sulfoxide ) to the pellet ( wash procedure ) .
after removal of the buffer , 250 l solution a ( citrate buffer containing trypsin ) was added to the pellet in each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
then , 200 l solution b ( citrate buffer containing trypsin inhibitor and rnase ) was added to each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
finally , 200 l solution c ( pi - staining solution ) at 4c was added to each tube and reincubated on ice for 10 minutes .
three hours later , the cells were analyzed using double laser - flow cytometry devices .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a bd facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells .
the cells in g0/g1 , s ( synthesis ) , and g2/m ( mitosis ) phases were evaluated using the modfitlt3.2 software program .
the cells were plated in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and the total volume was brought to 3.2 ml with fresh media .
after the initial 72-hour incubation , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with the previously established ic50 concentrations of docetaxel , zinc and combinations thereof in fresh medium for an additional 24 hours .
the cells were harvested by trypsinization and collected by centrifugation at 1,500 rpm for 5 minutes . following removal of the supernatant
, the cells were resuspended in 400 l binding buffer and stained with 5 l annexin - v and 5 l propidium iodide ( pi , 50 g / ml ) at room temperature for 20 minutes in the dark . after adding 400 l binding buffer to each tube
the percentage apoptosis , necrosis , and viable cells were evaluated by using a flow cytometer .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a becton dickinson ( bd ) facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells .
the cycletest plus dna reagent kit ( bd pharmingen ) was used to determine the distribution of cells between cell - cycle phases .
the cells were seeded in six - well plates at a density of 5010 cells / well , and their volume was adjusted to 3.2 ml with media . after an initial incubation for 72 hours , at which point the cells were ~80% confluent , the cells were treated with previously defined ic50 doses of zinc and docetaxel and then incubated for 24 hours .
then , the medium was removed , and 500 l trypsin was added to the cells , which were transferred into a tube .
a volume of 1 ml fresh medium was added to each tube to inactivate the trypsin . the suspension
the supernatant was removed , and the cells were resuspended by adding 1 ml buffer solution ( sucrose - citrate buffer containing dimethyl sulfoxide ) to the pellet ( wash procedure ) .
after removal of the buffer , 250 l solution a ( citrate buffer containing trypsin ) was added to the pellet in each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
then , 200 l solution b ( citrate buffer containing trypsin inhibitor and rnase ) was added to each tube and incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes .
finally , 200 l solution c ( pi - staining solution ) at 4c was added to each tube and reincubated on ice for 10 minutes .
three hours later , the cells were analyzed using double laser - flow cytometry devices .
a beckman coulterepicsxl - mcl was used for analysis of the h1299 cells , and a bd facscanto ii cytometer was used for analysis of the a549 cells .
the cells in g0/g1 , s ( synthesis ) , and g2/m ( mitosis ) phases were evaluated using the modfitlt3.2 software program .
the cell lysates were prepared and kept at 20c before the antioxidant enzyme and malondialdehyde ( mda ) analyses . for standard preparation , the mda standard ( t-9889 )
a 10 mm stock standard solution was prepared by dissolving the mda in distilled water , and this was then diluted to working concentrations ranging from 1 m to 50 m . for sample preparation
, the protein concentrations were measured using a bca protein assay kit ( pierce bca protein assay kit 23225 ; thermo fisher scientific , waltham , ma , usa ) .
the samples were lyophilized with a flexi - dry up freeze dryer ( fts systems , stone ridge , ny ) because of the low protein concentrations . for mda measurement , 100 l
then , 20 l of 2.8 mmol / l bht , 40 l of 8.1% sds , 600 l of 8 g
/ l tba:200 ml / l acetic acid ( 1:1 ) were added , and the ph was adjusted with 2 m naoh ( ph 3.5 ) .
a volume of 200 l distilled water and 1,000 l butanol : pyridine ( 15:1 ) were added , and all the samples were vortexed for 1 minute .
after 3 minutes , the organic phases were transferred to new eppendorf tubes and centrifuged at 10,000 rpm for 10 minutes .
the samples were then placed in an autosampler vial for high - performance liquid chromatography ( hplc ) analysis .
as previously described,23 the analysis was performed using a hplc set prominence lc 20 ( shimadzu , kyoto , japan ) equipped with sil-20ac autosampler , lc-20ad pump , and rf-10axl fluorescence detector .
phosphate buffer ( 0.01 m in 30% methanol , ph 7.0 ) was used as the mobile phase .
the superoxide dismutase ( sod ) activity of the cells was determined using a ransod kit ( randox labs , crumlin , uk ) . lyophilized cells and standard solutions
the absorbance was measured at 505 nm on a microplate reader ( bio - tek instruments , inc .
the glutathione peroxidase ( gpx ) activity of the cells was determined using a ransel kit ( randox labs , crumlin , uk ) and a previously described method.24 briefly , the lyophilized cells and standard solutions were used to assay for gpx .
the absorbance was measured at 340 nm on a microplate reader ( bio - tek instruments , inc . ) . in this method , gpx oxidizes glutathione via cumene hydroperoxidase . in the presence of gr and nadph ,
oxidized glutathione is immediately converted to the reduced form , with concomitant oxidation of nadph to nadp .
a 40-l sample was added to the primary reagent ( 200 l ) and cumene ( 80 l ) into a 96-well plate .
the plate was read after 1 minute , then again after 2 minutes for the final absorbance ( after reaction ) .
the gpx activity of these samples was calculated according to gpx manual included with the ransel kit .
the triplicate data were analyzed using the sigmastat 3.5 ( systat inc . , santa cruz , ca , usa ) software program . for comparison of the groups ,
first , we determined the ic50 concentrations for zinc and docetaxel on a549 and h1299 cells using a cc8 kit . to investigate the effects of exogenous zinc on cellular viability , apoptosis , and cell cycle alterations ,
both cell types were treated with various zinc concentrations ( 50 m , 100 m , and ic50 level ) . for the combinations ,
the groups were treated with three different zinc concentrations and the same docetaxel dose ( ic50 ) .
however , to determine the efficacy of zinc pretreatment on ic50 changes caused by docetaxel , nsclc cells were treated with 50 m and 100 m of zinc .
the ic50 values of zinc on a549 and h1299 cells were 287.1 m and 458.2 m , respectively , whereas the docetaxel concentrations were 20.44 m and 33.15 m , respectively ( figure 1 ) .
the docetaxel ic50 values for a549 cells were reduced to 8.16 m and 6.6 m levels after exposure to 50 m and 100 m of zinc , respectively , whereas these values were reduced to 12.16 m and 14.69 m in h1299 cells .
zinc significantly reduced the cellular viability of a549 cells in a dose - dependent fashion when combined with docetaxel and used alone ( p<0.001 ) .
however , zinc supplementation did not modify h1299 cell viability at all concentrations , although significant suppression was observed for the combination groups . for apoptotic induction
, zinc significantly increased the effects of docetaxel on both cell lines ( figure 2 ) .
as shown in figure 3 , the increase of the g0/g1 phase cell population was accompanied by a concomitant s - phase decrease in a549 cells treated with zinc and combinations in a dose - dependent manner .
however , zinc and combinations reduced the g0/g1 population and increased s - phase accumulation in h1299 cells .
as expected , g2/m phase accumulation significantly increased after docetaxel treatment in both cell lines .
h1299 cells showed significantly increased apoptotic / necrotic cell population in the combination groups . to assess the importance of oxidative stress , the sod activity , gpx activity , and mda levels were evaluated in nsclc cells . in both cell lines ,
the sod values significantly increased all treatment groups compared to the control , but the highest values were observed in the cells treated with 100 m zinc .
gpx was not elevated when both the a549 and h1299 cells were treated with 50 m and 100 m doses , but were slightly increased in the docetaxel and combination groups ( table 1 ) .
the maximum mda response was observed when the a549 cells were exposed to 50 m of zinc and combinations , except the ic50 doses , whereas the maximum mda response occurred when the h1299 cells were exposed to 100 m of zinc and docetaxel ( p<0.001 , anova followed by holm 
first , we determined the ic50 concentrations for zinc and docetaxel on a549 and h1299 cells using a cc8 kit . to investigate the effects of exogenous zinc on cellular viability , apoptosis , and cell cycle alterations ,
both cell types were treated with various zinc concentrations ( 50 m , 100 m , and ic50 level ) . for the combinations ,
the groups were treated with three different zinc concentrations and the same docetaxel dose ( ic50 ) .
however , to determine the efficacy of zinc pretreatment on ic50 changes caused by docetaxel , nsclc cells were treated with 50 m and 100 m of zinc .
the ic50 values of zinc on a549 and h1299 cells were 287.1 m and 458.2 m , respectively , whereas the docetaxel concentrations were 20.44 m and 33.15 m , respectively ( figure 1 ) .
the docetaxel ic50 values for a549 cells were reduced to 8.16 m and 6.6 m levels after exposure to 50 m and 100 m of zinc , respectively , whereas these values were reduced to 12.16 m and 14.69 m in h1299 cells .
zinc significantly reduced the cellular viability of a549 cells in a dose - dependent fashion when combined with docetaxel and used alone ( p<0.001 ) .
however , zinc supplementation did not modify h1299 cell viability at all concentrations , although significant suppression was observed for the combination groups . for apoptotic induction
, zinc significantly increased the effects of docetaxel on both cell lines ( figure 2 ) .
as shown in figure 3 , the increase of the g0/g1 phase cell population was accompanied by a concomitant s - phase decrease in a549 cells treated with zinc and combinations in a dose - dependent manner .
however , zinc and combinations reduced the g0/g1 population and increased s - phase accumulation in h1299 cells .
as expected , g2/m phase accumulation significantly increased after docetaxel treatment in both cell lines .
to assess the importance of oxidative stress , the sod activity , gpx activity , and mda levels were evaluated in nsclc cells . in both cell lines , the sod values significantly increased all treatment groups compared to the control , but the highest values were observed in the cells treated with 100 m zinc .
gpx was not elevated when both the a549 and h1299 cells were treated with 50 m and 100 m doses , but were slightly increased in the docetaxel and combination groups ( table 1 ) .
the maximum mda response was observed when the a549 cells were exposed to 50 m of zinc and combinations , except the ic50 doses , whereas the maximum mda response occurred when the h1299 cells were exposed to 100 m of zinc and docetaxel ( p<0.001 , anova followed by holm 
zinc is reported to induce apoptosis and cytotoxicity in different tumor types including prostate , ovarian , hepatoma , pancreatic , and breast cancers,1417,25,26 but it is less studied in lung cancers . here , we found that zinc exhibited growth inhibitory and apoptotic effects in a dose - dependent manner , up to the ic50 concentrations for cultured lung cancer cells .
the exact mechanisms underlying this synergism and zinc - induced apoptosis are unclear , but zinc homeostasis and p53 functions appear to be key factors for subsequent physiological processes including dna repair , cell cycle regulation , and response to oxidative stress.27 both exposures to excessive zinc and zinc depletion activate the apoptosis , and also , the zinc - induced apoptosis are commonly associated with the oxidative stress . for example
, intracellular zinc deficiency can enhance dna damage due to oxidative stress and also blocks critical cellular signals that drive dna repair and apoptosis,27 such that , zinc deficiency results in increased sensitivity to oxidative stress , increased dna damage , and accelerated carcinogenesis.28 the dna repair functions of p53 are commonly lost , and redox sensitive transcription factors , such as ap-1 and nf-b show reduced nuclear binding as a result of low cellular zinc status.27 the zinc exposure causes intracellular acidosis , increased the reactive oxygen species ( ros ) generation in several tumor cells,29,30 and stimulates the caspase - dependent and -independent apoptosis.30,31 moreover , the zinc - induced ros generation has been shown in the presence of functionally active p53 in breast cancer cells.29,30 by contrast , reactivation of mutant p53 increases the sensitivity of chemoresistant cancer cells to antineoplastic agents with zinc supplementation , which was demonstrated for glioblastoma and colorectal cancer cells.32 zinc - related apoptosis is associated with decreased bcl-2 and survivin expression in prostate cancer cells , and other studies found that survivin inhibition with deguelin results in enhanced efficacy of docetaxel in breast cancer cells.15,33 therefore , based on these data , we hypothesize that the addition of zinc into docetaxel regimens is a reasonable option to increase docetaxel - induced apoptosis and cytotoxicity in nsclc cells . in the present study , nsclc - derived h1299 ( p53-null ) and a549 ( p53-wild - type ) cells were used .
the ic50 doses of docetaxel and zinc were higher for the p53-null h1299 cells than a549 cells ( figure 1 ) .
it is well known that the complete loss of p53 or the expressions of mutant p53 variants are commonly seen in nsclc with 4070% frequencies and are associated with increased resistance to chemotherapy and radiotherapy.11,34,35 functional p53 status may influences docetaxel and zinc - induced cytotoxicity.11 for example , liu et al36 demonstrated that docetaxel induces apoptotic cell death in c4 - 2 and lncap prostate cancer cell express wild - type p53 more than du145 ( mutant p53 ) and pc-3 ( p53-null ) cells .
they also shown knockdown of p53 protein in c4 - 2 cells increases docetaxel resistance .
the role of p53 on zinc - induced apoptosis has been shown in some similar studies.29,37 in our study , zinc showed cytotoxicity in p53-wild lung cancer cells but not in null cells at different supraphysiological concentrations .
these results suggest that zinc - induced cytotoxicity and/or apoptotic induction are associated with the availability of functionally active p53 in nsclc cells . in our study , we observed increased mda levels , which are an indirect indicator of oxidative stress and ros production , using higher zinc concentrations ( 50 m and 100 m but not the ic50 ) in p53-wild - type a549 cells , whereas h1299 cells had higher mda levels at 100 m zinc concentrations . based on our data
, it is suggested that supraphysiological zinc supplementation induces ros generation and apoptosis in nsclc cells through p53 activation . in the presence of altered intracellular zinc concentrations ( low or high )
, ros stimulates p53 activation and/or p53 itself to stimulate ros production , and finally , it may cause cell death .
previous studies demonstrated that when cells are exposed to several zinc chelators , mutant p53 forms start to accumulate , and these forms lose their dna binding capacity .
finally , redox - active compounds cause dna - strand breaks , whereas removal of the zinc chelators from the medium returns to cell  wild - type p53  form.38 in addition , exposure of mcf7 ( p53-wild - type ) cells to 1025 m zinc causes an increase in the expression of bax , proapoptotic bcl-2 and , pig3 ( p53-induced gene product ) and also generation of ros .
the synergistic effects of zinc on docetaxel cytotoxicity may occur by inducing ros generation and increasing oxidative stress .
the combination of zinc and docetaxel induced apoptosis and cytotoxicity as well as mda levels .
interestingly , zinc also reduced the ic50 values of docetaxel and this may related to intracellular action of ros .
similar to other chemotherapeutic agents , taxanes induce ros production , and high levels of ros participate in paclitaxel cytotoxicity.39 for example , exposure of a549 cells to paclitaxel resulted in an intracellular increase of o2 and h2o2 levels .
then , the addition of n - acetylcysteine ( nac ) and glutathione , which are h2o2 scavengers , induced a fourfold increase in the paclitaxel ic50 level.40 we also examined the antioxidant enzymes sod and gpx in cell lysates and found significant increases in all treatment modalities compared to the control , with the highest sod values in the combination group . these results may be related to the higher zinc and docetaxel concentrations .
zinc is an essential component of cuznsod , which is the first - line defense enzyme to avoid the harmful effects of ros.27,41 in our study , we selected three different zinc concentrations , and zinc concentration was slightly supraphysiological ( 50 m ) along with higher concentrations ( 100 m and ic50 ) . because , the zinc treatment at ~15 m concentration is accepted as physiological level.42 previous studies showed that zinc - induced apoptosis occurs from 50 m and higher , but zinc - induced ros generation is observed at 100 m doses.14,17,25,43,44 although , we have not counted intracellular free zinc concentrations after the drug and zinc exposures , in a published study , maximum intracellular zinc concentrations have been obtained at 50 m znso4 treatment , and finally decreased to initial level when the concentration of znso4 exceeded 100 m.17 in addition , the cell growth inhibition and apoptosis were evaluated 24 hours after the treatment .
apoptotic changes due to zinc treatments ( 100 ng / ml and 1,000 ng / ml ) were remarkably seen in prostate cancer cells in an in vitro study.45 it has also been shown that , the zinc ions translocated into mitochondria 24 hours after the 150 m zinc sulfate treatment and at the beginning of the 18 hours of treatment , cytochrome c started to be seen in the cytoplasm and reached to the peak level in approximately 36 hours of treatment.44 the cell cycle analysis revealed g0/g1 accumulation in a549 cell after zinc treatment in a dose - dependent manner . this results confirmed p53 activation in a549 cells .
it is well known that activated p53 causes g1 arrest by inducing p21 , followed by cyclin inhibition to induce dna repair before cellular division,46 and the cell cycle analysis showed increased s phase and significantly higher apoptotic / necrotic cell death ( ~50% ) in p53-deficient nsclc cells .
the zinc induced - apoptosis and the synergism with docetaxel were speculated through ros generation and p53 activation here .
however , one of the major limitations of the present study was the lack of tests that showed the p53 functions or the p53-related protein alterations , as well as the apoptotic protein expressions after the docetaxel and the zinc applications
. another important limitation of this study was the absence of the counting of intracellular zinc and ros content after the compound exposures .
in conclusion , the exposure to exogenous zinc results in remarkable growth inhibition , increased apoptosis in the nsclc cells at 50 m and 100 m concentrations and zinc supplementation potentially sensitizes the nsclc cells to the docetaxel treatment .
 backgroundexposure to exogenous zinc results in increased apoptosis , growth inhibition , and altered oxidative stress in cancer cells . 
 previous studies also suggested that zinc sensitizes some cancer cells to cytotoxic agents depending on the p53 status . 
 therefore , zinc supplementation may show anticancer efficacy solely and may increase docetaxel - induced cytotoxicity in non - small - cell lung cancer cells.methodshere , we report the effects of several concentrations of zinc combined with docetaxel on p53-wild - type ( a549 ) and p53-null ( h1299 ) cells . 
 we evaluated cellular viability , apoptosis , and cell cycle progression as well as oxidative stress parameters , including superoxide dismutase , glutathione peroxidase , and malondialdehyde levels.resultszinc reduced the viability of a549 cells and increased the apoptotic response in both cell lines in a dose - dependent manner . 
 zinc also amplified the docetaxel effects and reduced its inhibitory concentration 50 ( ic50 ) values . 
 the superoxide dismutase levels increased in all treatment groups ; however , glutathione peroxidase was slightly increased in the combination treatments . 
 zinc also caused malondialdehyde elevations at 50 m and 100 m.conclusionzinc has anticancer efficacy against non - small - cell lung cancer cells in the presence of functionally active p53 and enhances docetaxel efficacy in both p53-wild - type and p53-deficient cancer cells . 
Introduction
Materials and methods
Cells
Docetaxel/zinc therapy, cell viability analysis
Flow cytometry analyses
Apoptosis analysis
Cell cycle analysis
High-performance liquid chromatography analysis of free malondialdehyde in the cells
Superoxide dismutase and glutathione peroxidase activities of the cells
Statistics
Results
Growth inhibitory effects of zinc and docetaxel on NSCLC cells
Cell cycle analysis
Antioxidant enzyme status and MDA alterations
Discussion
Conclusion