LOUISIANA v. MISSISSIPPI et al.
No. 14,
Original.
Argued November 16, 1965.
Decided April 18, 1966.
John L. Madden and Edward M. Carmouche, Assistant Attorneys General of Louisiana, argued on the exceptions to the Report of the Special Master on behalf of the plaintiff. With them on the briefs were Jack P. F. Gremittion, Attorney General, Carroll Buck, First Assistant Attorney General, and John A. Bivins, Special Counsel to the Attorney General.
Marlin R. McLendon, Assistant Attorney General of Mississippi, and Landman Teller, Special Assistant to the Attorney General, argued on the exceptions to the Report of the Special Master on behalf of the defendants. With them on the briefs were Joe T. Patterson, Attorney General, and George W. Rogers, Jr.
M. M. Roberts, Bernard J. Caillouet and E. L. Brunini filed a brief for Humble Oil & Refining Co. in support of its exceptions to the Report of the Special Master.
Per Curiam
and Decree.
Upon consideration of the Report filed June 7, 1965, by Senior Judge Marvin Jones, Special Master, and the exceptions thereto, it is now adjudged, ordered, and decreed as follows:
(1) All exceptions are overruled and the Report is in all things confirmed.
(2) The true boundary between the States of Louisiana and Mississippi in the area of the Mississippi River known as Deadman’s Bend on the several dates mentioned is determined to be as follows:
At all times the live thalweg has been the true boundary.
On October 3, 1952, the live thalweg was a gradually curving line running southward from the foot of Glass-cock Cutoff, and east of the future location of Louisiana State Well No. 1 by 230 feet, to the end of Deadman’s Bend at range 334.5 AHP. This line is described below by latitude and longitude and is drawn on Special Master Exhibit No. 1.
On April 10, 1964, the live thalweg was a gradually curving line running southward from the foot of Glass-cock Cutoff, and west of Louisiana State Well No. 1 by 850 feet, to the end of Deadman’s Bend at range 334.5 AHP. This line is described below by latitude and longitude and is drawn on Special Master Exhibit No. 1.
At all times between October 3, 1952, and April 10, 1964, the live thalweg has moved at a constant rate. The boundary location for any intervening period at any point in Deadman’s Bend (from the foot of Glasscock Cutoff to range 334.5 AHP) is to be determined mathematically by calculating the constant rate of change for that particular place in Deadman’s Bend, using the 1952 and 1964 thalwegs described heretofore and the appropriate time differentials.
At the latitude of Louisiana State Well No. 1 the location of the boundary was as follows from October 3, 1952, to April 10, 1964:
October 3, 1952 ................ 230 feet east of well
April 27, 1954 .................. 80 feet east of well
February 27, 1955.............. Directly above the well
April 10, 1956.................. 102 feet west of well
April 10, 1957.................. 195 feet west of well
April 10, 1958.................. 289 feet west of well
April 10, 1959.................. 382 feet west of well
April 10, 1960.................. 476 feet west of well
April 10, 1961.................. 569 feet west of well
April 10, 1962 .................. 663 feet west of well
April 10, 1963 .................. 756 feet west of well
April 10, 1964.................. 850 feet west of well
The Louisiana State Well No. 1 became located inside the boundary of Mississippi on February 28, 1955.
The description of the October 3, 1952, live thalweg by geodetic positions (North American Datum) is as follows:
Beginning at the foot of Glasscock Cutoff at a point on range 338.3 AHP, which is Lat. 31°19'07.0"— Long. 91°30'33.5".
Thence running southward through the following points:
Latitude Longitude
91°30'37.0" 31°18'57.5"
91°30'39.0" 31018'47.5"
91°30'40.0" 31°18'37.0"
91°30'39.5" 3V1&'27.W'
91°30'39.0" 31°18'17.0"
91°30'38.0" 31°18'07.0"
91°30'38.0" 31°17'57.5"
91°30'38.0" 31°17/47.0"
91°30'37.0" 31°17/37.0,/
91°30'36.5" 31° 17'27.0"
91°30'36.0" 31°17'17.0"
91°30'35.0" 31°17,07.0"
91°30'33.5" 31016'57.5"
91°30'32.5" 31°16'4:7.0"
91°30'34.0" 31°16'42.5"
91°30'37.0" 31°16'38.0"
91°30'43.0" srie^ob"
91°30'51.0" 31°16,22.5,/
91°31'00.0" 31016'17.0"
9io3i'io.o" 31°16'12.0"
91°31'21.0" 31°16,08.0"
91°31'32.0" 31°16'05.5"
91o31'42.0" 31016'03.5"
The description of the April 10, 1964, live thalweg by geodetic positions (North American Datum) is as follows:
Beginning at the foot of Glasscock Cutoff at a point on range 338.3 AHP, which is Lat. 31°19'07.0"— Long. 91°30'38.5".
Thence running southward through the following points:
Latitude Longitude
91°30'40.5" 31°18'57.5"
91°30'42.5" 3i°i8'48.o"
91°30'44.0" 31°18'38.0"
91°30'46.0" 31°18'28.0"
91°30'47.0" 3i°i8T8.5"
91°30'48.5" 31°18'08.5"
91°30'50.0" 31°17'59.0"
91°30'52.0" 31°17'49.0"
91°30'52.5" 31°17'39.0"
91°30'52.5" 31°17'29.5"
91°30'52.5" 31°17/20.0'/
91°30'52.0" 31°17'10.0"
91°30'52.0" 31°17'00.5"
91°30'52.5" 31°16'51.0"
91°30'53.0" 31°16'41.0"
91°30'55.0" 31°16'36.0"
9i°30'58.0" 31°16'32.0"
91°31'04.5" 31°16'24.0"
91°31'11.5" 31°16'16.0"
91°31'18.5" 3i°i6'09.0"
91°31'28.0" 31°16'03.0"
91°31'38.0" 31°15'59.0"
(3) As it appears that the Special Master has completed his work, he is hereby discharged with the thanks of the Court.
(4) The costs of this suit are to be equally divided between the two States.
What follows is an opinion from the Supreme Court of the United States. Your task is to determine the issue area of the Court's decision. Determine the issue area on the basis of the Court's own statements as to what the case is about. Focus on the subject matter of the controversy rather than its legal basis. In specifying the issue in a legacy case, choose the one that best accords with what today's Court would consider it to be. Choose among the following issue areas: "Criminal Procedure" encompasses the rights of persons accused of crime, except for the due process rights of prisoners. "Civil rights" includes non-First Amendment freedom cases which pertain to classifications based on race (including American Indians), age, indigency, voting, residency, military or handicapped status, gender, and alienage. "First Amendment encompasses the scope of this constitutional provision, but do note that it need not involve the interpretation and application of a provision of the First Amendment. For example, if the case only construe a precedent, or the reviewability of a claim based on the First Amendment, or the scope of an administrative rule or regulation that impacts the exercise of First Amendment freedoms. "Due process" is limited to non-criminal guarantees. "Privacy" concerns libel, comity, abortion, contraceptives, right to die, and Freedom of Information Act and related federal or state statutes or regulations. "Attorneys" includes attorneys' compensation and licenses, along with trhose of governmental officials and employees. "Unions" encompass those issues involving labor union activity. "Economic activity" is largely commercial and business related; it includes tort actions and employee actions vis-a-vis employers. "Judicial power" concerns the exercise of the judiciary's own power. "Federalism" pertains to conflicts and other relationships between the federal government and the states, except for those between the federal and state courts. "Federal taxation" concerns the Internal Revenue Code and related statutes. "Private law" relates to disputes between private persons involving real and personal property, contracts, evidence, civil procedure, torts, wills and trusts, and commercial transactions. Prior to the passage of the Judges' Bill of 1925 much of the Court's cases concerned such issues. Use "Miscellaneous" for legislative veto and executive authority vis-a-vis congress or the states.
Criminal Procedure Civil Rights First Amendment Due Process Privacy Attorneys Unions Economic Activity Judicial Power Federalism Interstate Relations Federal Taxation Miscellaneous Private Action