Off-Broadway Chenoweth was in "The Box Office of the Damned" (Kristy), "Dames at Sea" (Ruby), "The Fantasticks" (Luisa), "A New Brain" (Nancy D/Waitress), and "Love, Loss, and What I Wore" (Woman). She also played Christine Daae on the German tour of "Phantom". At Encores! she appeared in "Strike Up the Band", "Stairway to Paradise", "Music in the Air", "The Apple Tree", and "On a Clear Day You Can See Forever".