"I'm on Fire" was recorded, mixed, and mastered at the Street Rhymes Studios in Port Harcourt. The mixtape includes original tracks—with production handled mostly by Slim Burna and P Jaydino—as well as a few remixes of Burna's favorite reggae-dancehall hits. In an interview with newspaper, Burna said that "I'm on Fire" shows the growth he has achieved so far as an artist. He explained, "I'm on Fire" is the best thing I've done lately. I've grown both lyrically and vocally, my style has improved and I feel like I have more control of my abilities now."