(S (S (PP (IN Despite) (NP (BASENP (NNP Palin) (POS 's)) (NN attack))) (COMMA ,) (S (NP (BASENP (DT the) (JJ original) (NN article)) (PP (IN in) (NP (DT the) (NP (BASENP (NNP October) (NN 3)) (BASENP (NNP New) (NNP York) (NNP Times)))))) (VP (VP (VBD concluded) (SBAR (SBAR (IN that) (S (BASENP (NNP Obama) (CC and) (NNP Ayers)) (VP (VBD were) (ADJP (RB never) (JJ close))))) (CONJP (COMMA ,) (CC and)) (SBAR (IN that) (S (BASENP (DT the) (NN connection)) (VP (VBD was) (PP (IN through) (NP (NP (BASENP (NNP Obama) (POS 's)) (BASENP (JJ initial) (NN run))) (PP (IN for) (NP (BASENP (NN office)) (CC and) (BASENP (DT a) (NNS schools) (NN reform) (NN project))))))))))) (COMMA ,) (QT (DQL ``) (S (VP (VBG saying) (SBAR (IN that) (S (BASENP (PRPD their) (NNS paths)) (VP (VBP have) (VP (VBN crossed) (ADVP (RB sporadically)))))))) (DQR ''))))) (PERIOD .))