(S (S (S (BASENP (NNP Microsoft)) (VP (VBD had) (VP (VP (VBN appealed) (PP (TO to) (NP (BASENP (NNS fines)) (PP (IN by) (BASENP (DT the) (NNP EU)))))) (ADVP (RB before))))) (CONJP (COMMA ,) (CC but)) (S (BASENP (PDT all) (DT the) (NNS charges)) (VP (VBD were) (VP (VBN defeated))))) (PERIOD .))