(S (S (NP (BASENP (DT The) (JJ first) (NN decision)) (PP (IN in) (BASENP (DT this) (JJ antitrust) (NN case)))) (VP (VBD was) (VP (VP (VBN given) (PP (IN in) (BASENP (NN 2004)))) (S (VP (VBG citing) (SBAR (IN that) (S (S (BASENP (NNP Microsoft)) (VP (VP (VBD withheld) (BASENP (VBN needed) (NN interoperability) (NN information))) (PP (IN from) (BASENP (JJ rival) (NN software) (NNS companies))))) (SBAR (WHNP (WDT which)) (S (VP (VP (VBD prevented) (BASENP (PRP them))) (PP (IN from) (S (VP (VBG making) (NP (BASENP (NN software)) (ADJP (JJ compatible) (PP (IN with) (BASENP (NNP Windows)))))))))))))))))) (PERIOD .))