(S (S (BASENP (DT The) (NN appeal)) (VP (VBD was) (VP (VP (VBN argued) (PP (IN before) (NP (BASENP (DT the) (JJ 9th) (NNP Circuit)) (PP (IN in) (BASENP (NNP Honolulu)))))) (PP (IN in) (BASENP (NNP November) (NN 2005)))))) (PERIOD .))