![\\"\\"](\\" news_theme/dist/assets/icons/logo.c2320657.svg\\"/) ## AAP FACTCHECK * TRUSTED![\\"\\"](\\" * ACCURATE![\\"\\"](\\" * IMPARTIAL![\\"\\"](\\" DONATE SUBSCRIBE * * * * * Fact Checks * Check the Facts * Who We Are * AAP FactCheck Team * Neutrality and Code of Practice * Organisational Structure & Funding * How We Work * Our Process * Verdicts * Request a Correction * Contact * Suggest a Fact Check ![\\"A](\\" content/uploads/2023/01/30151335/20220129001618041773-original- scaled.jpg?v=1675052024\\"/) A health worker at a pop-up vaccination clinic. (AAP Images/Con Chronis) # Bivalent booster bluster misinterprets study findings David Williams January 30, 2023 ###### WHAT WAS CLAIMED New studies show bivalent COVID-19 boosters have zero efficacy. ###### OUR VERDICT False. The studies showed the bivalent boosters are effective, just not substantially more so than the original vaccine. A social media post uses two new vaccine studies to claim bivalent COVID-19 boosters have zero efficacy. But this is false. In reality, the studies conclude that bivalent Moderna and Pfizer boosters attack the virus as well as, but no better than, the original vaccines. The boosters are known as bivalent vaccines because they protect against different strains of the COVID virus – the original strain and Omicron subvariants BA.4 and BA.5, which have identical spike proteins. The false claim was made on Twitter on January 13, 2023 by Dr Eli David, who describes himself as a “researcher, lecturer, entrepreneur and investor”. His tweet has since been shared on Instagram and Facebook, such as here, here and here. The original claim reads: “Breaking: New data shows the new bivalent booster had ZERO efficacy. It turns out testing only on 8 mice is not a good drug development strategy”. ![\\"Bivalent](\\" content/uploads/2023/01/30150203/46f45a63-301f-411c-be87-7569253f2796.jpg?v=1675051326\\"/) The two studies concluded boosters work as well as the original vaccine, “which also works well”. Beneath the tweet, Dr David links to an article with the headline: “Bivalent COVID Boosters Offer No Extra Protection, Studies Suggest”. Rather than claiming bivalent boosters aren’t effective at all, the article suggests the “new mRNA bivalent boosters produced by Moderna and Pfizer only attack the COVID-19 virus about as well as the companies’ first-wave vaccines”. Neither the Instagram nor Facebook posts provide a link to the news story. The article references two studies, published in The New England Journal of Medicine on January 11, 2023, that assess the effectiveness of the bivalent Pfizer and Moderna boosters. One of these studies, led by Dr Dan Barouch, director of the Center for Virology and Vaccine Research at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, is titled “Immunogenicity of BA.5 Bivalent mRNA Vaccine Boosters”. Dr Barouch told AAP FactCheck their data showed the bivalent booster worked well. ![\\"A](\\" content/uploads/2023/01/30150213/ab7a19c3-02db-4a8b-9490-11958f69958c.jpg?v=1675051337\\"/) Australia’s vaccination program resulted in tens of millions of people getting their jabs. “It’s just not clear whether it is substantially better than the original vaccine, which also works well,” Dr Barouch said in an email. The other study, led by Professor David Ho of Columbia University’s Department of Microbiology and Immunology, is titled “Antibody Response to Omicron BA.4–BA.5 Bivalent Booster“. Prof Ho debunked Dr David’s tweet to AAP FactCheck, saying the claim had twisted the facts of their study. “Our study showed that the new bivalent vaccine can boost antibodies against Covid but no better than the original monovalent vaccine,” Prof Ho said. Co-author Dr Aubree Gordon also described the claim as misinformation. “Our study looked at neutralizing antibody responses, not efficacy,” Dr Gordon told AAP FactCheck. “While neutralizing antibody responses [has] been correlated with efficacy, they are not the same.” She added: “I would point out that both the bivalent booster and a fourth dose of the monovalent booster generated higher levels of antibodies than having three doses of monovalent. Meaning they both worked, but the bivalent booster did not appear (at least at 30 days when measuring neutralizing antibodies) to give a benefit over the original vaccine.” AAP FactCheck has previously debunked claims that the Pfizer booster was tested only on eight mice. ## The Verdict The claim that new data shows Moderna and Pfizer’s bivalent COVID boosters have zero efficacy is false. The two studies that the claim relies on concluded the boosters were effective, but not substantially more so than the original vaccine. The authors of both studies confirmed to AAP FactCheck that their data had been misinterpreted. False – The claim is inaccurate. * AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network. To keep up with our latest fact checks, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. All information, text and images included on the AAP Websites is for personal use only and may not be re-written, copied, re-sold or re-distributed, framed, linked, shared onto social media or otherwise used whether for compensation of any kind or not, unless you have the prior written permission of AAP. For more information, please refer to our standard terms and conditions. CHECK THE FACTS Media Literacy Campaign ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21144045/output2.jpg\\") ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21143934/output.jpg\\") Stay in Touch ### Latest Fact Checks ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/02143208/79774b13-e3f7-48bf- bc2d-f7d9eedc02b9.png?v=1727843532\\") ## Song claimed to celebrate pager explosions is from the 1990s ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/06/05160011/0b73b70c7273385e710b6a5648b3c80aa3c0dd4adb9a3c977d97f53423095f7f.jpg?v=1717567213\\") ## Word game and brainteaser scams sweeping Facebook ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/01084202/9109c656-1ecc-4b80-a687-e1b46ec57f2d.jpg?v=1727736124\\") ## Claim about Maori\'s customary marine title powers misleads ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/09/30151206/682e9750-1224-49eb- afd9-76f5b65b4c0d.jpg?v=1727673128\\") ## No, nations aren\'t ceding sovereignty by signing UN\'s Pact for the Future ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/09/30101006/66a7ed2c-136c-4ece-b69b-d7c6905843d1.jpg?v=1727655008\\") ## Claim drugs with zero toxicity wouldn\'t become medication misses the mark ### Latest News ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/02121203/f7f3c25c-1d9e-4e3f-a48d-cfbf3a97eee7.jpg?v=1727835126\\") ## Swans veteran Parker requests trade to North Melbourne ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/02153602/d4c261a2-d936-4c26-8d44-440a126ecb20.jpg?v=1727847364\\") ## Expert rejects supermarket land banking concerns ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/02104002/4cd8e2cd-d2ef-4156-826f-2aa133b42a3c.jpg?v=1727829605\\") ## Australians departing Lebanon as conflict escalates ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/02070202/cbc87961-d233-4e86-80de-555808eeb5a9.jpg?v=1727816525\\") ## Kennedy backs \'legend\' Sermanni as Matildas interim ![](\\" content/uploads/2024/10/01163002/3a5fe816-7215-49dd- ba2e-5623ccfbe8ab.jpg?v=1727764205\\") ## Treated as \'animals\': Lebanese anger as Israel invades ## AAP FactCheck ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21151443/carousel-factcheck.jpg\\"/) * Information you can trust * Written by trained, experienced journalists using authoritative sources * Accredited by the International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN) Get the Facts AAP FactCheck provides factual, authoritative information Australians can rely on. Accredited with the Poynter Institute\'s International Fact-Checking Network and adhering to the highest industry standards, our experienced team works to minimise the impact of misinformation. ## AAP Photos ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21151549/carousel-aapphotos.jpg\\"/) * Award-winning Australian Photography * Editorial or Commercial use * Subscriptions or one-off licences Browse Photos Image buyers from all industries rely on AAP Photos. A digital treasure trove of content depicting Australian life, our fully-searchable database contains millions of images from around the country and around the world. ## AAPNews ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21151210/carousel-aapnews3.jpg\\"/) * News delivered to your inbox * Trusted, reliable and accurate * Corporate and individual packages available Subscribe AAPNews delivers newswire content direct to the public. Choose from a number of subscription models to not only gain access to high-quality fact-based news on your desktop or mobile device, but also to show your support for Australia\'s only not-for-profit newswire. ## Newsroom ![](\\" content/uploads/2021/10/21150935/carousel-newsroom2.jpg\\"/) * The wire – up to the minute news at your fingertips * Feeds delivered to your CMS * Agenda – AAP’s planning and events tool Log In Get the news feed your organisation needs, with AAP offering extensive coverage of news, courts, politics, sports, finance and the arts. Take advantage of AAP’s partner content to get the international news that matters to your business, with news feeds delivered via multiple channels including API and FTP. prev next ##### Donate Now ###### WHY AAP is Australia\'s only independent newswire service, delivering stories and images around the country and around the world every day. By supporting AAP with your contribution you are backing a team of dedicated, objective journalists to continue this work. Thank you. Donations over $2 are tax deductible. * $10 * $100 * $500 $ * Once * Monthly * Annually DONATE ![](\\" news_theme/dist/assets/images/donatehero.2754b93d.jpg\\"/) * * * * * Legal and Privacy * Terms of Use CONTACT US AAP * Our Company * Our Board * Our Team * Corporate Governance Acknowledgement of Country In the spirit of reconciliation Australian Associated Press acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today. ![](\\" news_theme/dist/assets/images/aap-factcheck-ifcn-256.30cd597a.png\\"/) © 2024 Australian Associated Press. All rights reserved. ![\\"Close\\"](\\"/wp-content/themes/aap-theme/src/assets/icons/x-mark-black- icon.svg\\") ![\\"Close\\"](\\"/wp-content/themes/aap-theme/src/assets/icons/x-mark-black- icon.svg\\")
New studies show bivalent COVID19 boosters have zero efficacy