According to Jingoro YOKOKURA, however, he survived the battle and returned to Edo, but was injured while he was fighting in the Battle of Koshu-Katsunuma on March 29 of the year and died in Itado, Koshu.
しかし、横倉甚五郎は、存命して江戸に帰還した後、同年三月六日の甲州勝沼の戦いに参戦、手負いの後、甲州板戸で死亡したとしている。