However, according to "Heike Monogatari" (The Tale of the Heike) and the above mentioned "Azuma Kagami," Yoshitsune fought at Hiyodorigoe (eight kilometers to the east from the Ichinotani region), so some historians and experts still strongly support the Hiyodorigoe theory.
しかし、『平家物語』や上記『吾妻鏡』では義経の戦った場所は鵯越（一ノ谷から東方8キロ）となっており鵯越説も根強くある。