Other than the above, there are descriptions in "Kiyu shoran" written by Kintei KITAMURA saying "in around 1829 in Edo from recently" and in "Shojitome" saying "July 1841, tanabata is celebrated in July annually."
その他、喜多村筠庭の『喜遊笑覧』には「江戸にて近ごろ文政十二年の頃より」、『諸事留』には「天保十二年六月、例年七月七夕祭と唱」とある。