




New Report: Populism Wins Pennsylvania







































Jacobin Logo









Jacobin Icon



A/V Icon




Jacobin





Subscribe


Magazine


Donate


Catalyst







Facebook Icon







Twitter Icon







Email Icon










Print Icon








New Report: Populism Wins Pennsylvania













Search Icon









Login Icon




Login
















J







Subscribe


Back Issues


Donate


Store




Magazine


Blog


Catalyst




About


Contact Us


Advertise














Search Icon

















Jacobin relies on your donations to publish. Contribute today.










10.24.2024


United States




Party Politics







Facebook Icon








Twitter Icon







Email Icon










Print Icon









New Report: Populism Wins Pennsylvania


By


                Editors
              



A unique new study by the Center for Working-Class Politics, Jacobin, and YouGov highlights how economic populist messaging resonates with working-class voters in Pennsylvania on the eve of the November elections.






Pennsylvanians vote at a local polling station in Scranton, November 2023. (Aimee Dilger / SOPA Images / LightRocket via Getty Images)








Our new issue, “Bye Bye Bidenism,” is out now. Subscribe to our print edition at a discounted rate today.












            Shawn Fain: Workers Deserve More Time for Themselves
          



              Shawn Fain
            







            Why Bidenism Failed
          



              Brent Cebul
            

              Lily Geismer
            







            Inflation Kills Governments
          



              Isabella Weber
            







            The Working Class Has Left the Building
          



              Jared Abbott
            










In 2020, exit polls and national databases showed Joe Biden neck and neck with Donald Trump among voters without a college degree. This year, however, a range of October surveys have found Trump leading Kamala Harris with the same group by double-digit margins: 11 points, according to a New York Times/Siena poll, or 10 points, according to both Pew and PBS/NPR/Marist.
Among working-class white voters, Harris’s deficits are even larger. A recent Center for Working-Class Politics (CWCP), Jacobin, and YouGov poll in Pennsylvania shows Harris trailing Trump among manual workers by 20 points, and by 15 points among voters who say they have experienced an unfair firing by their employer.
To understand how Harris and Democrats in general can connect more effectively with working-class voters, the CWCP designed a survey testing a range of key messaging approaches among 1,000 registered voters in the critical swing state of Pennsylvania.
The survey, fielded by YouGov between September 24 and October 2, 2024, had two primary goals: first, to test which of Harris’s own actual messaging styles performed best in Pennsylvania, and second, informed by the CWCP’s previous surveys — Commonsense Solidarity (2021),  Trump’s Kryptonite (2023), and Where Are All the Left Populists? (2024) — to test whether Harris’ messages could be improved, either by employing stronger populist rhetoric or placing more emphasis on progressive economic policy.
Here are some of the survey’s key findings:

All populist and economic-centered messaging dramatically outperformed messages around Trump as a threat to democracy. These results held across partisanship and largely across class lines, measured by occupation, education, and income.



Messaging around Trump as a threat to democracy underperformed all other Harris messages among virtually every group. While the strongest message we tested was supported by 58% of respondents, the “threat to democracy” message received just 49% support overall.



Strong economic populist messaging that goes beyond Harris’s current populism-inspired rhetoric outperformed all other messaging among Pennsylvania voters. For instance, while strong populist messaging outperformed average Trump messaging by 3 points among independents, Harris’s current populist messaging underperformed by 2 points, and Trump as a threat to democracy underperformed average Trump messaging by 9 points.

 

Strong populist messaging performed particularly well among working-class and independent voters — 57% of blue-collar workers supported the strong economic populist message, compared to just 45% who supported messaging focused on Trump as a threat to democracy. We see a similarly large gap of 54% to 42% among independents.

Strong populist messaging did not lead to a trade-off between base voters and swing voters. This message received the highest support among African Americans, urban voters, and Democrats as a whole, and trailed no more than 2 points behind the preferred messages of women, higher-income, and highly educated respondents as well as service workers and professionals.

You can read the full report here.
View crosstabs.
Contact:
Authors: [email protected]
Press: [email protected]











Share this article


Facebook


Twitter


Email





Contributors



Filed Under



United States




Party Politics




Donald Trump


Kamala Harris


political polling


Pennsylvania


2024 Election












Remove Icon







Jacobin Logo









Sign up for our mailing list




              {{ message }}
            

Submit




          Thanks for signing up! →

Already on our list? Get our print magazine for just $20 a year.









Remove Icon



        ESC
      


Select a text size





                Small
              


In 2020, exit polls and national databases showed Joe Biden neck and neck with Donald Trump among voters without a college degree. This year, however, a range of October surveys have found Trump leading Kamala Harris with the same group by double-digit margins: 11 points, according to a New York Times/Siena poll, or 10 points, […]





                Medium
              


In 2020, exit polls and national databases showed Joe Biden neck and neck with Donald Trump among voters without a college degree. This year, however, a range of October surveys have found Trump leading Kamala Harris with the same group by double-digit margins: 11 points, according to a New York Times/Siena poll, or 10 points, […]





                Large
              


In 2020, exit polls and national databases showed Joe Biden neck and neck with Donald Trump among voters without a college degree. This year, however, a range of October surveys have found Trump leading Kamala Harris with the same group by double-digit margins: 11 points, according to a New York Times/Siena poll, or 10 points, […]
















Further Reading





                        New Poll: Despite Blue-Collar Troubles, Harris Has Slight Lead Over Trump in Pennsylvania
                      



Editors








                        Class Dealignment Is the Defining Political Challenge of Our Time
                      



Jared Abbott








                        Can Democrats Reverse the Neoliberal Era’s Dealignment?
                      



Jared Abbott


Milan Loewer








                        Trump’s Kryptonite: How Progressives Can Win Back the Working Class
                      



Editors
















Subscribe


Donate



Our new issue, “Bye Bye Bidenism,” is out now. Subscribe to our print edition at a discounted rate today.










Catalyst Logo









A journal of theory and strategy published by Jacobin




































Jacobin Logo
















            Sign up for our mailing list
          


            {{ message }}
          


Submit



        Thanks for signing up!
      







Catalyst


About Us


Contact Us


Advertise


Privacy Policy


© 2024










Yet again, progressive policies are more popular. Why the Harris-Walz campaign has shifted away from that and towards campaigning alongside Republicans is beyond me.