 





























John Kelly says Donald Trump fits ‘fascist’ definition and prefers ‘dictator approach’ | CNN Politics












































































CNN values your feedback




                                                        1. How relevant is this ad to you?
                                                






























                                                2. Did you encounter any technical issues?
                                        











                                                                        Video player was slow to load content
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad froze or did not finish loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content did not start after ad
                                                                        



                                                                        Audio on ad was too loud
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        





                                                                        Ad never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad prevented/slowed the page from loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Content moved around while ad loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad was repetitive to ads I've seen previously
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        











                                                        Cancel
                                                

                                                        Submit
                                                





Thank You!

                                        Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much
                                        appreciated.
                                

                                        Close
                                











Ad Feedback


















Close icon








Politics






                  
                  SCOTUS
                



                  
                  Congress
                



                  
                  Facts First
                



                  
                  2024 Elections
                




                      More
                    




                      SCOTUS
                    

                      Congress
                    

                      Facts First
                    

                      2024 Elections
                    








            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          




              Subscribe
            










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account


























        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






            Live TV
          

            Listen
          

            Watch
          




                Edition
              


                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                




                Edition





                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                









                  SCOTUS
                



                  Congress
                



                  Facts First
                



                  2024 Elections
                




Follow CNN Politics

























        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        US Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            News
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Football
          



            Tennis
          



            Golf
          



            Motorsport
          



            US Sports
          



            Olympics
          



            Climbing
          



            Esports
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Features
      



            As Equals
          



            Call to Earth
          



            Freedom Project
          



            Impact Your World
          



            Inside Africa
          



            CNN Heroes
          





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Fast
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        About CNN
      



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















 







Ad Feedback





 





      Trump’s former chief of staff says he fits ‘fascist’ definition and prefers ‘dictator approach’
    














			By Eric Bradner and Kate Sullivan, CNN
		



                  7 minute read
                

  Updated
        8:42 PM EDT, Wed October 23, 2024
    





















            Link Copied!
        














 






















Video Ad Feedback



Former defense secretary reacts to NYT audio from ex-chief of staff on Trump and 'fascism'
                


                                02:37
                            
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Former defense secretary reacts to NYT audio from ex-chief of staff on Trump and 'fascism'

02:37     












Politics of the Day
11 videos














Video Ad Feedback



Former defense secretary reacts to NYT audio from ex-chief of staff on Trump and 'fascism'
                




                                02:37
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Former defense secretary reacts to NYT audio from ex-chief of staff on Trump and 'fascism'

02:37     


















Video Ad Feedback



Trump falsely claims Ukraine started war with Russia
                




                                02:08
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Trump falsely claims Ukraine started war with Russia

02:08     


















Video Ad Feedback



Brianna Keilar presses White House adviser on whether Elon Musk is in charge of DOGE
                




                                02:17
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Brianna Keilar presses White House adviser on whether Elon Musk is in charge of DOGE

02:17     


















Video Ad Feedback



Pollster shares what voters are telling him about President Trump
                




                                01:41
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Pollster shares what voters are telling him about President Trump

01:41     


















Video Ad Feedback



Trump administration ‘absolutely committed’ to NATO, Secretary General says
                




                                01:58
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Trump administration ‘absolutely committed’ to NATO, Secretary General says

01:58     


















Video Ad Feedback



Legal experts explain why removing Eric Adams is easier said than done
                




                                03:08
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Legal experts explain why removing Eric Adams is easier said than done

03:08     


















Video Ad Feedback



Axios senior contributor on what we know about controversial quote Trump shared
                




                                04:03
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Axios senior contributor on what we know about controversial quote Trump shared

04:03     


















Video Ad Feedback



Expert has theory on Trump's strategy behind his attendance at big sporting events
                




                                03:12
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Expert has theory on Trump's strategy behind his attendance at big sporting events

03:12     


















Video Ad Feedback



Dana Bash presses Tom Homan on alleged quid pro quo with Eric Adams
                




                                04:02
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Dana Bash presses Tom Homan on alleged quid pro quo with Eric Adams

04:02     


















Video Ad Feedback



Author reacts to RFK Jr. becoming HHS secretary
                




                                03:35
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Author reacts to RFK Jr. becoming HHS secretary

03:35     


















Video Ad Feedback



Honig on ‘incalculable damage on DOJ’
                




                                01:40
                            
Now playing
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Honig on ‘incalculable damage on DOJ’

01:40     









See More Videos



















CNN
         — 
    


            John Kelly, the retired Marine general who was Donald Trump’s White House chief of staff, entered the 2024 fray in stunning fashion in a series of interviews published Tuesday, saying the former president fits “into the general definition of fascist” and that he spoke of the loyalty of Hitler’s Nazi generals.
    

            Kelly’s comments, two weeks from Election Day, are the latest in a line of warnings from former Trump White House aides about how he views the presidency and would exercise power if returned to office.
    

            In addition to the fascist comments, Kelly — who was Trump’s chief of staff from 2017 to 2019 — told The New York Times that the former president “certainly prefers the dictator approach to government.”
    

            He also confirmed to The Atlantic that Trump had said he wished his military personnel showed him the same deference Adolf Hitler’s Nazi generals showed the German dictator during World War II, and recounted the moment.
    

            “‘Do you mean Bismarck’s generals?’” Kelly told The Atlantic he’d asked Trump. He added, “I mean, I knew he didn’t know who Bismarck was, or about the Franco-Prussian War. I said, ‘Do you mean the kaiser’s generals? Surely you can’t mean Hitler’s generals?’ And he said, ‘Yeah, yeah, Hitler’s generals.’ I explained to him that Rommel had to commit suicide after taking part in a plot against Hitler.”
    

            Trump’s campaign denied the exchange. “This is absolutely false. President Trump never said this,” campaign adviser Alex Pfeiffer said.
    

            But Democrats quickly seized on the comments. Vice President Kamala Harris’ running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, said Tuesday night at a rally in Wisconsin that the reported comments about Hitler’s generals “makes me sick as hell.”
    

            “Folks, the guardrails are gone. Trump is descending into this madness — a former president of the United States and the candidate for president of the United States says he wants generals like Adolf Hitler had,” said Walz, who served in the Army National Guard.
    















Video Ad Feedback



'Significant moment': Haberman reacts to John Kelly's Trump comments
                


                                01:18
                            
 - Source:
            
                CNN











'Significant moment': Haberman reacts to John Kelly's Trump comments

01:18     








        ‘Enemy within’


            Kelly’s comments come in the closing days of Trump’s race against Harris, as he seeks to return to the Oval Office four years after losing an election he has falsely maintained was riddled with fraud.
    

            Trump has mused in recent speeches and interviews about turning the US military on political rivals he has referred to as the “enemy within” — comments that Harris has pointed to as evidence that the former president is “unhinged” and poses a danger to democratic values.
    

            “This is a democracy,” she told Fox News last week. “And in a democracy, the president of the United States – in the United States of America – should be willing to be able to handle criticism without saying he would lock people up for doing it.”
    

            The Times reported Kelly criticized Trump’s “enemy within” comments, saying that “even to say it for political purposes to get elected — I think it’s a very, very bad thing, let alone actually doing it.”
    

            The newspaper reported that in a recorded interview, Kelly was asked whether the former president met the definition of a fascist and responded by reading aloud a definition he’d found online.
    

            “Well, looking at the definition of fascism: It’s a far-right authoritarian, ultranationalist political ideology and movement characterized by a dictatorial leader, centralized autocracy, militarism, forcible suppression of opposition, belief in a natural social hierarchy,” Kelly said. “So certainly, in my experience, those are the kinds of things that he thinks would work better in terms of running America.”
    

            Kelly continued: “Certainly the former president is in the far-right area, he’s certainly an authoritarian, admires people who are dictators — he has said that. So he certainly falls into the general definition of fascist, for sure.”
    

            Kelly told the Times that Trump “never accepted the fact that he wasn’t the most powerful man in the world — and by power, I mean an ability to do anything he wanted, anytime he wanted.”
    

            “I think he’d love to be just like he was in business — he could tell people to do things and they would do it, and not really bother too much about whether what the legalities were and whatnot,” he said.
    

            He also said Trump didn’t understand the Constitution or the values on which the nation was built, and that it “was a new concept for him” that top government officials’ loyalty was to the Constitution, not the president personally.
    

            Trump campaign communications director Steven Cheung said in a statement that Kelly had “totally beclowned himself with these debunked stories he has fabricated because he failed to serve his President well while working as Chief of Staff and currently suffers from a debilitating case of Trump Derangement Syndrome.”
    















Video Ad Feedback



Journalist who spoke to Gen. John Kelly on the record describes interview
                


                                02:41
                            
 - Source:
            
                CNN











Journalist who spoke to Gen. John Kelly on the record describes interview

02:41     








        Praising Hitler’s generals


            Kelly also told The Times that Trump had praised Hitler.
    

            “He commented more than once that, ‘You know, Hitler did some good things, too,’” Kelly said.
    

            Kelly’s comments to the newspaper were published the same day The Atlantic reported that Trump had praised Hitler’s generals for their loyalty.
    

            “I need the kind of generals that Hitler had,” Trump said during a private conversation at the White House when he was president, The Atlantic reported. “People who were totally loyal to him, that follow orders.”
    

            Jeffrey Goldberg, the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, told CNN’s Kaitlan Collins on Tuesday night that Trump’s admiration of Hitler was perhaps the “most shocking” thing Kelly heard in the White House.
    

            “Remember, Donald Trump, throughout his presidency, was frustrated by the generals — or ‘my generals,’ as he called them … because they wouldn’t sort of mindlessly listen to him or follow his orders,” Goldberg said.
    

            American military officers, such as generals, swear an oath to the Constitution and not the commander in chief.
    

            Trump has reportedly made similar comments about Hitler and his generals.
    

            CNN’s Jim Sciutto previously reported in his book “The Return of Great Powers” that Trump allegedly praised Hitler saying, “Hitler did some good things,” according to Kelly.
    

            “He said, ‘Well, but Hitler did some good things.’ I said, ‘Well, what?’ And he said, ‘Well, [Hitler] rebuilt the economy.’ But what did he do with that rebuilt economy? He turned it against his own people and against the world. And I said, ‘Sir, you can never say anything good about the guy. Nothing,’” Kelly recounted to Sciutto. “I mean, Mussolini was a great guy in comparison.”
    

            “It’s pretty hard to believe he missed the Holocaust, though, and pretty hard to understand how he missed the 400,000 American GIs that were killed in the European theater,” Kelly told Sciutto. “But I think it’s more, again, the tough guy thing.”
    

            A book published in 2022 also reported Trump told Kelly, “Why can’t you be like the German generals?” The comments by Trump when he was president were reported in “The Divider: Trump in the White House,” by reporters Peter Baker and Susan Glasser.
    

            Kelly confirmed the exchange with Trump to The Atlantic.
    

            The article lays out a series of stories that The Atlantic uses to illustrate Trump’s views on the military and his desires for how it should perform under his command. In addition to recounting the former president’s musings on the loyalty of Nazi generals, The Atlantic also reported Trump was furious when told how much the funeral for a fallen servicemember cost after he had volunteered to pay for it.
    

            The Atlantic reported that that Trump told the family of Fort Hood Pfc. Vanessa Guillen, who was bludgeoned to death with a hammer in the armory room where she worked, that he would pay for the funeral costs but never did.
    

            When he received the $60,000 bill, the Atlantic reported – citing two people present at the meeting and the notes of someone at the meeting – Trump said, “It doesn’t cost 60,000 bucks to bury a f–king Mexican!”
    

            Trump told his then-chief of staff Mark Meadows and directed him not to pay the funeral bill. Later in the day, Trump reportedly said, “F–king people, trying to rip me off.”
    

            “President Donald Trump never said that. This is an outrageous lie from the Atlantic two weeks before the election,” Pfeiffer said.
    

CLARIFICATION: This story has been updated to more accurately reflect what Kelly told The New York Times.


CNN’s Alayna Treene contributed to this report.
























Ad Feedback









Ad Feedback










Ad Feedback









Ad Feedback





















Ad Feedback












Ad Feedback











Ad Feedback











Ad Feedback






















        Subscribe
      










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






        Live TV
      

        Listen
      

        Watch
      






        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        US Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            News
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Football
          



            Tennis
          



            Golf
          



            Motorsport
          



            US Sports
          



            Olympics
          



            Climbing
          



            Esports
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Features
      



            As Equals
          



            Call to Earth
          



            Freedom Project
          



            Impact Your World
          



            Inside Africa
          



            CNN Heroes
          





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Fast
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        About CNN
      



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















Politics





            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          


Follow CNN Politics
























            Subscribe
          










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account









          Terms of Use
        

          Privacy Policy
        



          Ad Choices
        

          Accessibility & CC
        

          About
        

          Newsletters
        

          Transcripts
        

© 2025 Cable News Network. A Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All Rights Reserved.  CNN Sans ™ & © 2016 Cable News Network.











He absolutely fits the traits of a Fascist. This website has a good explanation & details Project 2025... wearenotspecial.org