US warns Elon Musk that his $1m voter giveaway may be illegalSkip to contentBritish Broadcasting CorporationWatch LiveHomeNewsSportBusinessInnovationCultureArtsTravelEarthAudioVideoLiveHomeNewsIsrael-Gaza WarWar in UkraineUS & CanadaUKUK PoliticsEnglandN. IrelandN. Ireland PoliticsScotlandScotland PoliticsWalesWales PoliticsAfricaAsiaChinaIndiaAustraliaEuropeLatin AmericaMiddle EastIn PicturesBBC InDepthBBC VerifySportBusinessExecutive LoungeTechnology of BusinessFuture of BusinessInnovationTechnologyScience & HealthArtificial IntelligenceAI v the MindCultureFilm & TVMusicArt & DesignStyleBooksEntertainment NewsArtsArts in MotionTravelDestinationsAfricaAntarcticaAsiaAustralia and PacificCaribbean & BermudaCentral AmericaEuropeMiddle EastNorth AmericaSouth AmericaWorld’s TableCulture & ExperiencesAdventuresThe SpeciaListEarthNatural WondersWeather & ScienceClimate SolutionsSustainable BusinessGreen LivingAudioPodcastsRadioAudio FAQsVideoLiveLive NewsLive SportHomeNewsSportBusinessInnovationCultureArtsTravelEarthAudioVideoLiveWeatherNewslettersUS warns Musk political group that $1m voter giveaway may be illegal23 October 2024Max MatzaBBC NewsWatch: Elon Musk gives $1m to a rally attendeeA letter sent to Elon Musk's political action committee from the US Department of Justice (DOJ) warned that his lottery-style giveaway of $1m per day to a registered voter may be illegal, according to US media. Mr Musk, who is the world's richest man, actively campaigns for Republican Donald Trump in his presidential bid against Kamala Harris. Over the weekend, the owner of Tesla and X/Twitter began giving away prizes to American voters who signed a petition. It's unclear when the DOJ letter was sent to Mr Musk's organisation, America PAC. DOJ investigators have declined to comment on the case.US outlets, including CBS News, the BBC's US partner, reported on Wednesday that the letter informed Musk's team that the giveaway may violate federal election laws. It was sent by the DOJ's Public Integrity Section following outrage from Democrats over the cash stunt. Election polls - is Harris or Trump ahead?Under US law, it is illegal to pay people to register to vote. But it remains unclear whether the sweepstakes breaks any laws. Mr Musk's contest offers money to signatories of a petition, which the PAC circulated. “We want to try to get over a million, maybe 2 million voters in the battleground states to sign the petition in support of the First and Second Amendment,” Mr Musk said in Pennsylvania on Saturday when he announced the event. The contest rules state that winners must be registered to vote, but no party affiliation is required. “We are going to be awarding $1 million (£770,000) randomly to people who have signed the petition, every day, from now until the election,” he said.The America PAC website states the goal is getting “1 million registered voters in swing states to sign in support of the Constitution, especially freedom of speech and the right to bear arms”.It is open to voters in seven swing states - Pennsylvania, Georgia, Nevada, Arizona, Michigan, Wisconsin and North Carolina. US election day is 5 November.Trump has the world’s richest man on his side. What does Musk want?Musk is giving some US voters $1m. Is it legal?Musk v Ambani: Billionaires battle over India's satellite internetOn Tuesday, a group of Republican ex-prosecutors wrote to the DOJ urging officials to investigate the contest. "We are aware of nothing like this in modern political history," they wrote, pointing to potential federal and state law violations."Law enforcement agencies are appropriately reluctant to take action shortly before elections that could affect how people vote. But serious questions arising under laws that directly regulate the voting process must be an exception."Mr Musk previously dismissed claims that the contest is illegal, saying: "You can be from any or no political party, and you don’t even have to vote."On Sunday, the contest reframed its rules, describing the money as payment for a job, according to CNN.America PAC said the winner will be “selected to earn $1M as a spokesperson for America PAC”. Winners have gone on to film pro-Trump videos. Tim Walz accuses Elon Musk of trying to buy the electionSeveral legal experts have told the BBC that they believe the contest may be illegal."His offer is only open to registered voters, so I think his offer runs afoul of this provision," said Paul Schiff Berman, a law professor at the George Washington University.He pointed to the US Code on electoral law, which states that anyone who "pays or offers to pay or accepts payment either for registration to vote or for voting" faces a potential $10,000 fine or a five-year prison sentence.Adav Noti of the non-partisan Campaign Legal Center said Mr Musk's scheme "violates federal law and is subject to civil or criminal enforcement by the Department of Justice"."It is illegal to give out money on the condition that recipients register as voters," Mr Noti told the BBC.But Jeremy Paul, who teaches law at Northeastern University, said that Mr Musk may have found a legal loophole.He said that, while there is an argument that the offer could be illegal, it is “targeted and designed to get around what’s supposed to be the law" and he believes the case would be difficult to make in court.Do you live outside the US and have a question out the election? Tell us here or use the form below.SIMPLE GUIDE: How you can get most votes but loseEXPLAINER: The seven states that will decide the electionGLOBAL: A third election outcome on minds of MoscowON THE GROUND: Democrats take fight deep into Trump countryWWE: Why Trump is courting old friends from the ringPOLLS: Who is winning the race for the White House?Elon MuskUS election 2024WatchBarron Trump: Then and nowAged just 10 when his father first became president, he's now well over six feet tall, and goes to New York University.20 Jan 2025US & CanadaWatch: Trump's 'golden age' speech in 82 secondsThe US president spoke about his plans for the second Trump administration, as well as criticising the 'corrupt establishment'.20 Jan 2025US & Canada'I Donald John Trump'... 47th US president sworn inWatch the historic moment when the 45th president is returned to power as he takes the oath of office. 20 Jan 2025US & CanadaTech CEOs, celebs and presidents - who's inside Trump's inaugurationElon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos were among those invited inside the Capitol for Donald Trump's swearing in.20 Jan 2025Thousands protest in Washington DC ahead of Trump inaugurationThousands of people joined in on demonstrations as the United States prepares to inaugurate its new president.18 Jan 2025US & CanadaBiden gives warnings on climate and oligarchy in farewell speechThe outgoing US president warned against power in the hands of the wealthy, the threat of the tech industry and climate change.16 Jan 2025US & CanadaWatch key moments from Rubio and Bondi's confirmation hearingsTrump's pick for US attorney general was pressed on claims of election fraud and pardons for January 6 rioters.15 Jan 2025Watch key moments from Pete Hegseth's confirmation hearingDonald Trump's defence secretary nominee was asked about his stance on women in combat and his alleged excessive drinking.14 Jan 2025US & CanadaWatch moment Kamala Harris certifies US election resultHarris, who Trump defeated in the 2024 election, presided over the event as required by the US Constitution.6 Jan 2025US & CanadaA look at Trump's new top team... in 85 secondsAmong the allies the president-elect has chosen to join his administration are contentious figures, including among fellow Republicans.16 Nov 2024US & CanadaTrump names vaccine sceptic RFK Jr for health secretaryThe president-elect has nominated RFK to lead the Department of Health and Human Services.14 Nov 2024US & CanadaFBI video shows moment man sets ballot box on fireThe suspect used an “improvised incendiary device” to start the fire in Portland, Oregon, ahead of the US election.14 Nov 2024Why is Kamala Harris still asking for campaign donations?A week after losing the election, Kamala Harris's team are still appealing for funds.14 Nov 2024US & CanadaWhat a Republican trifecta means for Trump's second termRepublicans have won control of both chambers of Congress, yielding Trump limited congressional oversight for at least 2 years.
13 Nov 2024US & Canada‘Welcome back’ - Watch moment Biden congratulates TrumpThe president and president-elect shook hands as part of a long-standing tradition signifying the transfer of power.13 Nov 2024US & CanadaWhat we can expect from Trump and Biden's meetingGiven all the things they’ve said about each other, Joe Biden and Donald Trump’s meeting could be really awkward.13 Nov 2024US & Canada'I think Putin believes that he knows how to play Trump' - John Bolton'I think Putin believes that he knows how to play Trump', says Trump's former adviser John Bolton.7 Nov 2024Putin congratulates 'courageous' Trump on election winThe Russian president says he was impressed by Trump's reaction to the first assassination attempt against him.7 Nov 2024WorldWatch: Biden urges Democrats to 'get back up' after Trump winThe president addressed Americans from the White House for the first time since Donald Trump's election victory.7 Nov 2024US & CanadaUS voters on one reason Trump won... and why Harris lostAfter Donald Trump's decisive victory, we asked Americans what they think made the difference for each campaign.6 Nov 2024US & CanadaMore22 hrs agoWhat is Doge and why is Musk cutting so many jobs?US President Donald Trump’s new agency is tasked with slashing costs - but faces opposition.22 hrs agoTechnology6 days agoProject 2025: The right-wing wish list for Trump's second termA conservative think tank set out a sweeping vision for governing that could influence Trump's next term. What influence has it had so far?6 days agoUS & Canada6 days agoJD Vance: The Maga loyalist who became vice-president The conservative from Ohio shot to fame writing about his hard upbringing and is now first in line to the US presidency.6 days agoUS & Canada5 Feb 2025Top Trump nominees advance as Senate confirms attorney generalThe full Senate voted in the evening, approving Bondi as the next attorney general, tasked with running the Department of Justice.  5 Feb 2025US & Canada1 Feb 2025Will Donald Trump’s tariffs hurt US consumers?Trump claims more taxes on trade wouldn't be a cost to the US - but almost all economists dispute this.1 Feb 2025US & CanadaBritish Broadcasting CorporationHomeNewsSportBusinessInnovationCultureArtsTravelEarthAudioVideoLiveWeatherBBC ShopBBC in other languagesFollow BBC on:Terms of UseAbout the BBCPrivacy PolicyCookiesAccessibility HelpContact the BBCAdvertise with usDo not share or sell my infoContact technical supportCopyright 2025 BBC. All rights reserved.  The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking. 
The right-wing interpretation on laws is that they're non-literal and hyperbolic in nature.