














Heed the generals who call Trump unfit to lead - Defense One


















































































































          Continue to the site 








Skip to Content




Notice at Collection



                Your Privacy Choices   




Exercise Your Privacy Rights











China is rehearsing for war, Indo-Pacific commander says







With IVAS takeover, Anduril looks to build out human-machine ‘ecosystem’







America’s ‘Iron Dome’ is going to need a lot more sensors: NORTHCOM







How Trump could productively reshape the transatlantic defense relationship







Return-to-work order created ‘panic’ among military-spouse federal workers 






sponsor content

Adobe JELA Streamlines DoD Software Acquisition, Enables Digital Modernization








China is rehearsing for war, Indo-Pacific commander says







With IVAS takeover, Anduril looks to build out human-machine ‘ecosystem’







America’s ‘Iron Dome’ is going to need a lot more sensors: NORTHCOM







How Trump could productively reshape the transatlantic defense relationship







Return-to-work order created ‘panic’ among military-spouse federal workers 






sponsor content

Adobe JELA Streamlines DoD Software Acquisition, Enables Digital Modernization








































About


Newsletters


Podcast


Insights


Advertise


Forecast International
















































          Threats
        



          Policy
        



          Business
        



          Science & Tech
        



          SYSTEMS
        



          Ideas
        



          Events
        



          Army
        



          Navy
        



          Marine Corps
        



          Air Force
        



          Space Force
        









About


Newsletters


Podcast


Insights


Advertise


DSM












































Notice at Collection



              Your Privacy Choices   




Exercise Your Privacy Rights














                Threats
              



                Policy
              



                Business
              



                Science & Tech
              



              Services
              

Army
Navy
Marine Corps
Air Force
Space Force




                SYSTEMS
              



                Ideas
              



                Events
              













Trending

Army

Ukraine

Middle East

Congress

China

Air Force

NATO














China is rehearsing for war, Indo-Pacific commander says







With IVAS takeover, Anduril looks to build out human-machine ‘ecosystem’









America’s ‘Iron Dome’ is going to need a lot more sensors: NORTHCOM







How Trump could productively reshape the transatlantic defense relationship









Return-to-work order created ‘panic’ among military-spouse federal workers 







[SPONSORED] Adobe JELA Streamlines DoD Software Acquisition, Enables Digital Modernization






















                    On May 29, 2017, then-President Donald Trump stood with then-DHS Secretary John Kelly at the Arlington grave of Kelly's son, a Marine killed in Afghanistan. “I don’t get it,” Trump told the grieving Kelly. “What was in it for them?”
                  
                    Aaron P. Bernstein/Getty Images
                  
        Get all our news and commentary in your inbox at 6 a.m. ET.
      emailRegister for NewsletterStay Connected
      Insights & Reports
    Safeguarding Military Infrastructure and Frameworks: Opportunities and Challenges | West MountainsPresented By Palo Alto Networks 
              Download Now
                The Guide to Secure ChatOpsPresented By Mattermost
              Download Now
                




Ideas


        Heed the generals who call Trump unfit to lead
      
The former commander-in-chief understands nothing of military service, duty, or a cause greater than himself.


James Kitfield

 | 


            October 23, 2024
          








                  Commentary
                









                  White House
                









                  Elections
                
















































By James Kitfield

Author of "In the Company of Heroes"



          October 23, 2024
      





































                  Commentary
                









                  White House
                









                  Elections
                













As a coda to two decades covering the post-9/11 conflicts as a correspondent, I wrote a book in 2021 profiling the 25 Medal of Honor recipients from the nation’s longest wars. Theirs are stories of never surrendering despite harrowing odds, of facing death and finding the courage and faith not to be cowed, of wearing their profound scars—both physical as well as mental—like badges of honor. There is wisdom and warrior fierceness in those narratives, but also acts of profound tenderness and love. The common theme running throughout is troops united in a cause greater than themselves, caught in a brush with eternity and choosing to risk and even forfeit their own lives to save their brothers in arms. Their heroism and self-sacrifice is awe-inspiring, and explains why those privileged to lead them in combat consider these uniformed volunteers and their teammates America’s “New Greatest Generation.”Donald Trump cannot fathom any of that.As if we needed reminding, the former and possibly future commander-in-chief continues to prove in the crudest terms imaginable that he views the U.S. military from a deep well of incomprehension, not as a sacred trust to be honored by any leader, but rather as an instrument of self-aggrandizement and brute force. That was the message behind Trump’s recent description of the Presidential Medal of Freedom, which he has bestowed on supporters and major campaign donors, as “much better” than the Medal of Honor, because service members who receive the nation’s highest military honor have either “been hit so many times by bullets, or they’re dead.”Militaries always have an irresistible allure to “wannabe dictators,” to borrow a phrase from Gen. Mark Milley, whom Trump appointed Joint Chiefs chairman. Trump has made no secret of his yearning to deploy the active force onto the streets of America to strike fear into his domestic political opponents, who he chillingly called “the enemy from within” in a recent Fox interview. He has also repeatedly telegraphed his intention to use the military to quell a supposed crime wave in Democratic-led cities, and to conduct the largest deportation in our nation’s history of immigrants and “radical left thugs” that “live like vermin” inside the United States and are “poisoning the blood of our country.”Given Trump's Nazi-esque rhetoric, it’s not surprising—yet still extraordinary—that his former chief of staff, retired Marine Corps Gen. John Kelly, recently confirmed that Trump repeatedly praised Adolf Hitler’s generals for their perceived blind loyalty, and wanted U.S. military leaders more in the mold of the German Wehrmacht under the Nazis. Nor is it surprising that Milley, now retired, has called his former boss the “most dangerous person to this country” and a “fascist to the core.”Decades of covering the U.S. military as a reporter taught me that even retired generals and admirals are instinctively resistant to engaging in partisan politics. They have been inculcated from their first days as cadets or newly minted lieutenants with the principle that the military must stay above the partisan fray in a democracy and submit to civilian authority. Their leaders know that the nonpartisan nature of the U.S. military helps explain why it has long remained the nation’s most respected institution.I also know from talking with many of Milley’s contemporaries, both on-the-record and privately, that they share his dire assessment, and genuinely fear for their country should Trump return to the Oval Office. That’s why so many of the most notable military and national security leaders of the past two decades of war have recently broken with long tradition to publicly warn that he is manifestly unfit to serve again as commander-in-chief. No fewer than 741 former high-ranking national security and military leaders—including 233 general and flag officers, 15 four-star generals, and 10 former service secretaries—recently signed a letter endorsing Kamala Harris for president. They warn that Trump is “too impulsive and ill-informed” to entrust with the world’s most powerful fighting force.Roughly half of my fellow citizens have chosen to ignore those warnings, and that is certainly their right. Before they vote, however, I hope they reconsider why the nation’s guardians have chosen to break with tradition.Consider just one recent, revealing incident that was quickly buried beneath the media coverage of Trump’s non-stop outrages and falsehoods. In August, Trump and the bully boys of his campaign pushed past an Army employee into the highly restricted Section 60 of Arlington National Cemetery, the section largely reserved for the fallen of Afghanistan and Iraq, in order to illegally film a TikTok campaign video and snap a picture of the candidate with Gold Star Family members. Take a close look at that photograph of the former president grinning broadly and giving the thumbs-up over the graves of Marines who lost their lives in the Biden administration’s chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan, and ask yourself: What must he have been thinking?Perhaps his thoughts were similar to the ones he expressed privately during a 2018 trip to France for the centennial anniversary of the end of World War I, when then-President Trump cancelled visits to cemeteries for America’s fallen because he said they were filled with “losers” and “suckers.”Or perhaps his thoughts tracked with those Trump expressed to General Milley, who as JCS chairman had arranged for a severely wounded Army captain to sing at a ceremony for the president. “Why do you bring people like that here?” Trump reportedly asked Milley afterwards, before instructing him not to let the soldier appear in public again. “No one wants to see that, the wounded.”Trump has repeatedly shown that such blasphemy comes from a deep hollowness of character. How else to explain the then-president’s casual cruelty during an earlier visit to Arlington National Cemetery, there supposedly to pay respects at gravesite No. 9480. It held the remains of a young Marine killed in action in Afghanistan: 1st Lt. Robert Michael Kelly, the son of Trump’s soon-to-be chief of staff.“I don’t get it,” Trump told the grieving Kelly. “What was in it for them?”Why young American men and women volunteered after 9/11—knowing they would be subjected to the horrors of war, running to the sound of guns as their fathers and uncles had in Vietnam, and their grandfathers had in Korea and World War II—was not something that could ever be explained to Donald Trump. Yet in his own grief, John Kelly, himself a retired four-star Marine general and decorated combat veteran, understood that his son Robert had already given the answer to the question of whether the cause was worth the sacrifice.“In his mind—and in his heart—he had decided somewhere between the day he was born at 2130, 5 September 1981—and 0719, 9 November 2010—that it was worth it to him to risk everything—even his own life—in the service of his country,” Kelly would later tell other grieving Gold Star families. “So, in spite of the terrible emptiness that is in a corner of my heart and I now know will be there until I see him again, and the corners of the hearts of everyone who ever knew him, we are proud. So very proud. Was it worth his life? It’s not for me to say. He answered the question for me.”Before surrendering the fate of America’s sons and daughters in uniform to the whims of an unstable commander-in-chief who simply cannot grasp the meaning of their devotion and sacrifice, I hope voters will listen to the actual patriots who have devoted their lives to our nation’s defense. They know from experience that Trump will cozy up to autocratic strongmen and once again denigrate democratic allies, eroding the alliances that undergird America’s global strength. They have never forgotten that on January 6, 2021, after inciting a violent mob that ransacked the citadel of our democracy on one of the darkest days in modern U.S. history, the former commander-in-chief was AWOL, watching the desecration on television for hours and breaking the chain of command at the top. They have heard him recently refer to that desecration as a “day of love.”Above all, they know that the hollowness and narcissism at Donald Trump’s core masks a darkness that could eclipse what they and so many others have risked everything to defend.“A person that thinks those who defend their country in uniform, or are shot down or seriously wounded in combat, or spend years being tortured as POWs are all ‘suckers’ because ‘there is nothing in it for them,” John Kelly said of his former boss in a blistering statement to CNN last year confirming many of Trump’s outrageous comments, first reported and recently confirmed in The Atlantic. “A person that did not want to be seen in the presence of military amputees because ‘it doesn’t look good for me.’ A person who demonstrated open contempt…for all Gold Star families…and rants that our most precious heroes who gave their lives in America’s defense are ‘losers,’ and wouldn’t visit their graves in France.”“A person that has no idea what America stands for and has no idea what America is all about,” Kelly continued in what amounted to a scream from the soul of a grieving father, and a dire warning from a renowned military leader afraid for his country. “A person who admires autocrats and murderous dictators. A person that has nothing but contempt for our democratic institutions, our Constitution, and the rule of law.“There is nothing more than can be said,” Kelly concluded. “God help us.”Amen.James Kitfield is the author of “In the Company of Heroes: The Inspiring Stories of Medal of Honor Recipients from America’s Longest Wars in Afghanistan and Iraq,” and a three-time recipient of the Gerald R. Ford Award for Distinguished Reporting on National Defense.








Share This:



NEXT STORY:

              What would Harris, Trump do about Russia's invasion of Ukraine?
            













Middle East news







Ukraine news







China news







Technology news







Defense One eBook: Space Trends








Middle East news







Ukraine news







China news







Technology news







Defense One eBook: Space Trends


































About


Contact


Advertise


Privacy Policy


Terms & Conditions




Nextgov/FCW


Government Executive


Route Fifty


Washington Technology


More




            © 2025 by Government Media Executive Group LLC. All rights reserved.
          






Back to top




×



    Please read our Privacy Policy as it has recently been updated. Defense One uses cookies for analytics and personalization. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.
  








Almost There!
Help us tailor content specifically for you:








          Full Name *





          I Work For... *


— select —
Department of Defense (Civilian)
Department of Defense (Military)
Federal Government
State/Local Government
Government Contractor
Private Sector
Retired








          Agency/Department *


— select —
Department of the Air Force
Department of the Army
Department of the Navy
Joint Chiefs of Staff
National Intelligence Agency
Office of the Secretary of Defense
Other Defense Agency








          Agency/Department *


— select —
Air Force
Army
Coast Guard
Navy
Marines








          Agency/Department *


— select —
Department of Agriculture
Department of Commerce
Department of Education
Department of Energy
Department of HHS
Department of Homeland Security
Department of HUD
Department of Interior
Department of Justice
Department of Labor
Department of State
Department of Transportation
Department of Treasury
Department of Veterans Affairs
EPA
Executive Office of the President/Vice President
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Federal Communications Commission
Federal Trade Commission
GSA
Judiciary Branch
Legislative Branch
NASA
National Institute of Health
OMB
OPM
SSA
USPS
Other Agency








          Agency/Department *


— select —
Government Association
County
Municipal
Special District
State








          Agency/Department *


— select —








          Organization Function *


— select —
Elected Official/Legislative/Executive Office
Environment/Energy
Finance/Budget
Health & Human Services
Public Safety/Emergency Services/Law Enforcement
Technology
Transportation/Utilities/Infrastructure
Other








          Please Provide Your Org.'s Name *






          Industry *


— select —








          Job Title *






          Job Function *


— select —
Agency Leadership
Business & Operations
Communications & Marketing
Financial/Contract Management
Human Resource Management
Technology Management








          Country *


United States
EEA (European Economic Area)
Canada
Other







          Country Name *






          Postal code *






          Phone Number
        







              Yes, I want to receive occasional updates from partners
            






                I agree to the use of my personal data by Government Executive 
                Media Group and its partners to serve me targeted ads.
                Learn more.
            













×







          News, analysis, and ideas driving the future of U.S. defense: straight to your inbox.
        

          Sign up for Defense One Today
        





    My email is ...
  




    I work for ...
  

--select--
Department of Defense (Civilian)
Department of Defense (Military)
Federal Government
State/Local Government
Government Contractor
Private Sector
Retired






Also get The D Brief, your daily source for insights and analysis of the latest in defense news







          Sign up
        



Privacy Policy







          Almost There!
        

          Help us tailor content specifically for you:
        






    Full Name
  




    Agency/Department
  

--select--
Department of the Air Force
Department of the Army
Department of the Navy
Joint Chiefs of Staff
National Intelligence Agency
Office of the Secretary of Defense
Other Defense Agency
Air Force
Army
Coast Guard
Navy
Marines
Department of Agriculture
Department of Commerce
Department of Education
Department of Energy
Department of HHS
Department of Homeland Security
Department of HUD
Department of Interior
Department of Justice
Department of Labor
Department of State
Department of Transportation
Department of Treasury
Department of Veterans Affairs
EPA
Executive Office of the President/Vice President
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Federal Communications Commission
Federal Trade Commission
GSA
Judiciary Branch
Legislative Branch
NASA
National Institute of Health
OMB
OPM
SSA
USPS
Other Agency
Government Association
County
Municipal
Special District
State




    Organization Function
  

--select--
Elected Official/Legislative/Executive Office
Environment/Energy
Finance/Budget
Health & Human Services
Public Safety/Emergency Services/Law Enforcement
Technology
Transportation/Utilities/Infrastructure
Other




    Organization Name
  




    Job Function
  

--select--
Agency Leadership
Business & Operations
Communications & Marketing
Financial/Contract Management
Human Resource Management
Technology Management




    Phone number
  




    Zip code
  




    Country
  

United States
EEA (European Economic Area)
Canada
Other




    Country Name
  






Yes, Defense One can email me on behalf of carefully selected companies and organizations.








            I agree to the use of my personal data by Government Executive Media Group and its partners to serve me targeted ads. Learn more.
        







          Submit
        



More from Defense One
Privacy Policy



















If this happened to Democrats, there would be coverage of it non-stop, every fucking day.