




 





















How Ohio Cities Showed Kamala Harris the Way Forward on Medical Debt | The Nation



























































 




































































Log In











Email *





Password *










Remember Me





							
								Forgot Your Password?							
							










Log In






New to The Nation? SubscribePrint subscriber? Activate your online access









 







Skip to content
Skip to footer

















                    How Ohio Cities Showed Kamala Harris the Way Forward on Medical Debt
                



Magazine


Newsletters



















 


Subscribe


Log In



















Search


















Subscribe


Donate


Magazine


Latest


Archive


Podcasts


Newsletters





Sections



Politics


World


Economy


Culture


Books & the Arts



The Nation



About


Events


Contact Us


Advertise





Current Issue



















 














 


 








Politics


 / 
October 18, 2024


How Ohio Cities Showed Kamala Harris the Way Forward on Medical Debt
The vice president wants a medical debt jubilee. Toledo, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, and Akron demonstrated what that could look like.



Mythili Sampathkumar 


Share


Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email


 







Ad Policy


Vice President Kamala Harris delivers remarks on medical debt relief at an event at the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, next to the White House, in Washington, DC, April 11, 2022.(Stefani Reynolds / AFP via Getty Images)
Cleveland—Medical debt is a national crisis, and Kamala Harris has a plan to deal with it; she just needs to tell people about it. And to do that, she should first talk about Ohio.
About 41 percent of working-age Americans carry medical debt, according to surveys by the Commonwealth Fund and the Kaiser Family Foundation. The figures vary depending on how medical debt is defined—whether a hospital is owed the money or the debt is on a credit card or owed to another lender—but somewhere between 79 to 100 million Americans owe a total of more than $220 billion. Most people with debt have health insurance, and medical debt is one of theleading causes of bankruptcy. Daniel Lempert, the vice president of communications for the nonprofit Undue Medical Debt, pointed out that half of adults in the US don’t even have $500 for an emergency expense. “With all that in mind,” he told me, “it’s unsurprising that almost anyone is one accident or illness away from financial crisis.”

In August, Kamala Harris announced a plan for federal medical debt forgiveness, saying, “No one should go bankrupt just because they had the misfortune of becoming sick or hurt.”
The Harris plan was light on details about how precisely the debt jubilee would be enacted, but Ohio provides a road map on how a Harris administration could work with local governments, hospital systems, and nonprofits to wipe out medical debt for millions of Americans. Ohio is ranked 44th among the 50 states for “health value,” according to the Health Policy Institute of Ohio, meaning residents “live less healthy lives and spend more on health care than people in most other states.”


                    Current Issue
            





            March 2025 Issue
        


Nearly 2 million Ohioans have medical debt, and as the Covid-19 pandemic shut down the economy, local politicians were worried about this debt pushing people deeper in poverty. “This isn’t vanity debt,” Kris Harsh of the Cleveland City Council told me. “For people with insurance, their plans are not covering the entirety of the costs, and for those without insurance, the debt is usually the result of an emergency.”
In late 2022, the city of Toledo set aside a portion of America Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds to forgive medical debt. It used the money to buy up the debt portfolios of two local hospital systems that they had sold to third-party collectors. Once the portfolios were purchased, they were marked as paid. It was Michele Grim, then a city councillor and now a Democratic state representative, who led the initiative
Toledo did not do this on its own, though. It followed Cook County, the area surrounding Chicago, and partnered with the nonprofit Undue Medical Debt. The group began its work in 2014, and Lempert told me that, at first, “the idea that debts are bought and sold for pennies on the dollar, especially medical debt, was foreign and frankly confusing for many people.” He said a 2019 segment on John Oliver’s Last Week Tonight helped; it explained the process, and the show even bought and forgave $15 million of medical debt for 9,000 Texans.
Hospital systems will sell the debt knowing that patients will unlikely be able to cover the costs left over after insurance companies cover their portions of accrued bills. Third-party collections agencies will buy the debt for cheap, but once it has been sitting with them for some time, they often give up attempting on collecting on it, too. That’s when Undue Medical Debt is able to buy the debt portfolios for pennies on the dollar. It gives the third-party collectors some compensation for the portfolio and allows patients much-needed relief. The bills will be marked as paid.


Ad Policy







How much these portfolios cost vary by hospital system, number of patients, and the amount of time the debt has been in collection, Lempert said.
When Harsh learned about this, he jumped on the chance to help Clevelanders, too.
The ARPA funds were meant to provide relief in the wake of the pandemic, but the money wasn’t specifically intended for medical debt forgiveness. As Lempert put it, Ohio cities found ”a creative use for these funds.” Columbus, Cincinnati, and Akron would eventually join Toledo and Cleveland in using federal funds to forgive medical debt.



Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →






Why Democrats Won’t Throw a Real Punch

                Why Democrats Won’t Throw a Real Punch
            


Dave Zirin 







Donald Trump’s Next Diversity Target: People With Disabilities

                Donald Trump’s Next Diversity Target: People With Disabilities
            


Sam Gustin 







How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?

                How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?
            


Elie Mystal 







If Trump Crushes Federal Workers, We’re All Next

                If Trump Crushes Federal Workers, We’re All Next
            


Eric Blanc 






According to the Urban Institute, medical debt both in Ohio and across the country is more common in communities of color. In Cuyahoga County, which includes Cleveland, majority non-white communities have twice the rate of medical debt of white communities. And across the country, more than 20 percent of residents in communities of color have medical debt in collections.
In Cleveland, Harsh and the rest of the city council worked with the Metro Health hospital system, one of the largest in the city, to forgive $200 million in debt for nearly 300,000 patients.
There are some caveats with these kinds of deals. Undue Medical debt can’t select specific people, but it can, Lempert said, “target zip codes for debt forgiveness and basically ensure that we were helping Cleveland residents first and foremost. Of course, some debt was held by people who’ve moved away since the debt was initially incurred. and there was some natural overlap into our surrounding suburbs.”
The group also focuses on patients who are four times or below the federal poverty level and those whose debt is 5 percent or more of their annual income, as Lempert explained. He said the nonprofit’s process is appealing to officials because of the “ROI [return on investment] of medical debt abolishment and the ability to help burdened citizens without any red tape or application process.”
Lempert said that “the main challenge has just been shedding light on this crisis which can be highly stigmatizing and therefore underexplored.” But by sharing personal stories and with more and more municipalities and cities reaching out, there has been increased visibility and more people helped. Undue Medical Debt has forgiven more than $14 billion in debt across the country.
Jenny, whose name has been changed at her request to protect her anonymity, was a patient of Metro Health and said she has had “approximately 14 surgeries since 2015.” She said had employer healthcare until 2015 but was not eligible for Medicare until 2019. In the intervening years, her medical debt piled up. The pandemic and a 2020 breast cancer diagnosis made it impossible for her to work and pay off that debt.
She said that when she was 62, she couldn’t find a job and was forced to take smaller Social Security payments. With her ongoing tests and having to move to be closer to family members, she could barely keep up with the calls and letters coming from the collection agency. Thankfully, Undue Medical Debt bought her debt from the third-party collection agency, and as of early 2024, her bills were considered paid.
Now 71, she still sometimes struggles to make ends meet on her fixed income, but she doesn’t feel forced to go back to work. She told me, “I’d like to see more people get the same kind of help to put their minds at ease. When you have a critical condition, you got enough on your mind without having to worry about getting help.”




The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.




Email






By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.




Sign Up






Samuel Camacho, a disease and intervention specialist, was a patient of Trinity Health System when he was a freelancer and covered by a marketplace insurance plan in Ohio. Camacho said his primary care physician, urgent care, and emergency room as well as his prescriptions “were all in network.” After a diagnosis of kidney stones, he was asked by the hospital to sign a financial document “on admission to the procedure without explaining what [that document] was.”
Camacho later found out he had not met his deductible and so the full bill was his responsibility. He tried to get on a payment plan with Trinity only to be told the hospital no longer provided payment plans; it had sold his debt to a third party. He has said he was “not familiar” with debt relief through deals brokered with Undue Medical Debt but is currently working with an attorney to resolve his issue, since his hospital system was not included in any of the Ohio city-brokered deals.
Harris has been campaigning on her economic plan all over swing states, but she’s been relatively quiet about medical debt forgiveness, which is an extension of the work she did with the Biden administration. Neither Camacho nor Jenny had not heard Harris talk about medical debt forgiveness. “It wouldn’t hurt” to talk about it, Jenny said. “I’m sure I’m not the only one in this situation.”
About 15 million Americans have medical debt on their credit reports, per the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau. That number is down from 46 million in 2020, thanks in part to Harris-led initiatives urging credit bureaus to remove this type of debt from credit reports. Harris has also called on that debt to be eliminated from calculating credit scoress and from evaluations for mortgage. Still, few know about Harris’s plans to forgive the medical debt of millions or her history of making medical debt less of a burden.
One of the lawmakers leading the charge in Congress to remove medical debt from credit reports has been Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio. Brown, whose campaign could not be reached for comment, has a narrow lead in the polls over Republican challenger Bernie Moreno in his reelection bid this year. But he does not appear to be touting medical debt forgiveness on the campaign trail around the state.
Medical debt forgiveness, especially for those with terminal illnesses, is a popular issue with voters—nearly two-thirds of Americans support it. The American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, the Leukemia and Lymphoma Society, and Undue Medical Debt also did a survey and it showed that 84 percent of US adults agree that it is “the responsibility of the government to ensure health care is affordable for all people in the U.S.” and 91 percent agree that “elected officials should pass policies that protect people with serious illnesses like cancer from medical debt and harassment from collection agencies.”
There is an opportunity here for Harris, Brown, and other Democrats. Ohio is controlled at the state level by Republicans, but local Democratic politicians in cities have proved how popular and cost-effective it can be to forgive medical debt. Federal funds helped Ohio residents be free of over $600 million of debt. It’s an accomplishment that Democrats should be boasting about, and Harris has a plan to bring it across the country. She should campaign on it.




Keep Reading







                Submit a correction
            



                Send a letter to the editor
            



                Reprints & permissions
            






Mythili Sampathkumar







Mythili Sampathkumar is a freelance journalist and artist. She runs the Export Quality newsletter.















More from The Nation







Javier Milei’s Crypto Scandal Is Part of a Larger Network of Grift and Graft

                Javier Milei’s Crypto Scandal Is Part of a Larger Network of Grift and Graft
            

The Argentinian president faces impeachment charges for endorsing a crypto rug pull, via the same network that apparently launched Melania Trump’s memecoin.

Jacob Silverman 








The “Teenage Dream” in an Era of Isolation

                The “Teenage Dream” in an Era of Isolation
            


Curfew restrictions and the policing of public spaces prevent teens from “getting into trouble.” But to some, it feels like it’s preventing them from getting anywhere at all.


StudentNation

                            /
                        
Aina Marzia 








Donald Trump’s Next Diversity Target: People With Disabilities

                Donald Trump’s Next Diversity Target: People With Disabilities
            


The president’s disdain for disabled people—and obsession with genetic superiority—harks back to a grim past.


Sam Gustin 








Trump’s Guantánamo Plan Will Be a Costly, Morally Bankrupt Fiasco

                Trump’s Guantánamo Plan Will Be a Costly, Morally Bankrupt Fiasco
            


The US government has begun to shuttle immigrants from the United States to Gitmo, post photos of them in shackles, and lock them away.


Jeffrey S. Kahn 








Will Academia Survive the Criminalization of Dissent?

                Will Academia Survive the Criminalization of Dissent?
            


Professors are experiencing an overwhelming sense of fear and disillusionment amid the crackdown of pro-Palestine protests. “I don’t know anybody who’s not scared right now.”


StudentNation

                            /
                        
Lucy Tobier 








What Harm Reduction Really Looks Like

                What Harm Reduction Really Looks Like
            


Harm reduction advocates are implementing solidarity-based strategies for curbing drug overdoses in Minneapolis.


Photo Essay

                            /
                        
Tim Evans 




















Sections


Politics


World


Economy


Culture


Books & the Arts


OppArt


Poetry


Letters




Magazine


Current Issue


Masthead


Archive


Subscription Services


Reprints




More


About Us


Contact Us


Advertise


Nation Events


Nation Shop


Nation Travels


Nation Podcasts


Newsletters




Follow


Facebook


Twitter


Instagram


YouTube


RSS





Founded by abolitionists in 1865, The Nation has long believed that independent journalism has the capacity to bring about a more democratic and equitable world.
Donate




Privacy Policy


Terms of Use


Accessibility Statement


Help


Careers


Nation Fund


Privacy Manager












 










x










Latest from the nation


Today 10:52 amArmed Conflicts
What’s Next for Syrian Refugees?
Helen Benedict


Today 8:30 am
5 Stages of GOP
Peter Kuper


Today 8:24 am
How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?
Elie Mystal


Today 5:30 am
How to Organize Our Way Out of the Trump-Musk Putsch
Ezra Levin and Leah Greenberg


Today 5:30 am
A New International Campaign Rises in Ukraine
Mary Kaldor and Luke Cooper




editor's picks





VIDEO: People in Denmark Are a Lot Happier Than People in the United States. Here’s Why.
The Nation





Historical Amnesia About Slavery Is a Tool of White Supremacy
Mychal Denzel Smith










































She needs to introduce what they have in the UK - free healthcare for everyone.

It's not a perfect system and has many critics, but it still does a pretty impresssive job.

It allows everyone to have free medical appointments, free medical investigations and free treatments. The only thing they pay for is medication.

It's been going for over 75 years so the vast majority of British people have never known any other form of healthcare.