


Netanyahu’s defiance of Biden-Harris Rafah invasion threats led to elimination of Sinwar, experts say | Fox News


   Fox News Media Fox News MediaFox BusinessFox NationFox News AudioFox WeatherOutkickFox NoticiasBooks Fox News  
              U.S.
             
                  Crime
                
                  Immigration
                
                  Terror
                
                  True Crime
                
                  Bryan Kohberger
                
              Politics
             
                  Trump's First 100 Days
                
                  Senate
                
                  House
                
                  Judiciary
                
                  Foreign Policy
                
                  Fox News Polls
                
                  Elections
                
              World
             
                  U.N.
                
                  Conflicts
                
                  Terrorism
                
                  Disasters
                
                  Global Economy
                
                  Environment
                
                  Religion
                
                  Scandals
                
              Opinion
             
              Media
             
                  Fox Nation Coverage
                
              Entertainment
             
                  Exclusives
                
                  Country Music
                
                  Royals
                
                  Blake Lively
                
                  Diddy
                
                  Game Shows
                
                  Hot Videos
                
              Sports
             
                  NFL
                
                  College Football
                
                  MLB
                
                  NBA
                
                  NHL
                
                  Golf
                
                  Tennis
                
                  Soccer
                
                  UFC
                
                  WWE
                
              Lifestyle
             
                  MAHA
                
                  Health
                
                  Travel
                
                  Food & Drink
                
                  Games & Quizzes
                
              Health
             
              Video
             
              AI
              More Expand / Collapse search Log In Watch
            TV Menu    
            Games
           Expand/Collapse Menu Daily Crossword PuzzleCrazy Crystals Match 3 GameWord SearchMini Crossword PuzzleStack and Match Block Puzzle5 Across the Letter Word Game
            Deals
            
            FOX Business
           Expand/Collapse Menu Personal FinanceEconomyMarketsWatchlistLifestyleReal EstateTech
            Science & Tech
           Expand/Collapse Menu Air & SpaceSecurityInnovationVideo GamesMilitary TechPlanet EarthWild Nature
            Watch Live 
           Expand/Collapse Menu FOX News ShowsProgramming ScheduleOn Air PersonalitiesFull EpisodesShow ClipsNews Clips
            Apps & Products
           Expand/Collapse Menu FOX News GoFOX WeatherFOX NationFOX NoticiasFOX News ShopFOX News RadioOutkickNewslettersPodcasts 
            Games
           Expand/Collapse Menu Daily Crossword PuzzleCrazy Crystals Match 3 GameWord SearchMini Crossword PuzzleStack and Match Block Puzzle5 Across the Letter Word Game
            Deals
            
            FOX Business
           Expand/Collapse Menu Personal FinanceEconomyMarketsWatchlistLifestyleReal EstateTech
            Science & Tech
           Expand/Collapse Menu Air & SpaceSecurityInnovationVideo GamesMilitary TechPlanet EarthWild Nature
            Watch Live 
           Expand/Collapse Menu FOX News ShowsProgramming ScheduleOn Air PersonalitiesFull EpisodesShow ClipsNews Clips
            Apps & Products
           Expand/Collapse Menu FOX News GoFOX WeatherFOX NationFOX NoticiasFOX News ShopFOX News RadioOutkickNewslettersPodcasts Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS Newsletters Fox News Updated Terms of UseNew Privacy PolicyYour Privacy ChoicesClosed Caption PolicyHelpContact UsAccessibility Statement 
        This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. ©2025 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Factset. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Legal Statement. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper.
       Recommended    03:28
       Trump admin designates eight cartels as foreign terrorist organizations  01:26
       South Carolina House Rep. Brandon Guffey offers emotional testimony on the threats facing America’s youth online  12:24
       Trump, Zelenskyy trade jabs as US-Russia peace talks forge ahead  03:19
       Alleged transgender cult members suspected in border agent's murder  02:06
       Trump designates Tren de Aragua a global terrorists organization  02:49
       Anti-Israel protest in NYC devolves into violence and mayhem  03:30
       Transgender vegan 'cult' members arrested  07:21
       Laura: Trump is living up to his promise  01:53
       Blue state sheriff touts crime down in conservative-leaning county while liberal counties pay price  03:58
       US is 'taking the lead' to end Ukraine war, former Trump deputy adviser says  06:18
       US, Russia hold peace talks without Ukraine  04:52
       Rate of descent and gusty conditions created 'recipe for disaster' for flipped Toronto jet, former commercial pilot says  10:54
       New video shows moment Delta plane crash-landed, flipped over in Toronto  04:03
       Former pilot stunned by flipped Toronto jet: It's a 'miracle' anyone walked away from crash  03:17
       Former FAA administrator is 'not concerned at all' about air travel safety after the Trump administration fires hundreds of FAA workers  03:53
       Mike Huckabee: Iran wants a nuclear weapon and the military power that comes with it  04:59
       Expert reveals why Zelenskyy is in a legal conundrum as US, Russia hold peace talks  03:05
       Michigan man drives over 700 miles to set fire to home of man who had communicated with ex  03:29
       Officials give update following Toronto plane crash: 'Grateful there was no loss of life'  03:29
       Peace talks: Trump team works to end Ukraine war as European leaders meet         Israel Netanyahu’s defiance of Biden-Harris Rafah invasion threats led to elimination of Sinwar, experts say Sinwar was eliminated just a short distance from where Hamas executed 6 hostages, including American-Israeli Hersh Goldberg-Polin   
      By
      Benjamin Weinthal  Fox News  
      Published
       October 19, 2024 8:00am EDT  Facebook Twitter Flipboard Comments Print Email   close      Video Kamala Harris opposed Israeli operations before Sinwar's death: Mark Dubowitz Foundation for Defense of Democracies CEO Mark Dubowitz discusses Israel's right to defend itself after the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar on 'America Reports.' Join Fox News for access to this content Plus special access to select articles and other premium content with your account - free of charge. By entering your email and pushing continue, you are agreeing to Fox News' Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which includes our Notice of Financial Incentive.
     Please enter a valid email address.  By entering your email and pushing continue, you are agreeing to Fox News' Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which includes our Notice of Financial Incentive.
        Having trouble? Click here. JERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s decision to ignore dire warnings from President Biden and Vice President Harris not to conquer the last major stronghold of Hamas terrorists in Rafah proved to be correct, according to military and Middle East experts.    Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the country’s Shin Bet intelligence agency announced Wednesday that "soldiers from the Southern Command eliminated Yahya Sinwar, the leader of the Hamas terrorist organization, in an operation in the southern Gaza Strip."Biden and Harris congratulated Israel over the death of the Hamas terror chief, but, earlier this year, both warned Israel about going into Rafah, where Sinwar met his end.     HAMAS ADMITS 'PAINFUL, DISTRESSING' LOSSES AFTER ISRAELI VIDEO SHOWS TERRORIST SINWAR MOMENTS BEFORE HIS DEATH  IDF forces operating in Rafah, a city in the Gaza Strip. (IDF Spokesman's Office)  Sinwar oversaw the massacre of nearly 1,200 people on Oct. 7, 2023, including over 40 American citizens.  In March, Harris declined to rule out "consequences" for Israel if it moved forward with an invasion of Rafah in Gaza."We have been clear in multiple conversations and in every way that any major military operation in Rafah would be a huge mistake," Harris told ABC News at the time."Let me tell you something. I have studied the maps. There's nowhere for those folks to go."  Also in March, Biden National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan echoed Harris’ warning. "Our position is that Hamas should not be allowed a safe haven in Rafah or anywhere else," Sullivan noted during a White House Press briefing. "But a major ground operation there would be a mistake. It would lead to more innocent civilian deaths, worsen the already dire humanitarian crisis, deepen the anarchy in Gaza and further isolate Israel internationally."  President Biden meets with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office at the White House, July 25, 2024. (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)  In May, Biden went as far as threatening Israel, saying he would not furnish the Jewish state with weapons if it entered Rafah. Biden told CNN "if they go into Rafah, I’m not supplying the weapons that have been used historically to deal with Rafah, to deal with the cities — that deal with that problem."    Amit Segal, chief political analyst of Israel's Channel 12, told Fox News Digital, "The elimination of Sinwar proves that the continuation of the war was not a whim, the entry into Rafah was not a vendetta and the refusal to surrender to Hamas to resolve the northern front was not a rash decision."He continued, "There is a strategy, and it is to ensure, front by front, that the entire Middle East sees what happens to those who attack Israel."BIDEN ADMINISTRATION ISSUES WARNING TO NETANYAHU AS ISRAEL HOLDS EMERGENCY MEETING ON GAZA AID  Yahya Sinwar, center, the late leader of Hamas, during a ceremony for members killed by Israeli air strikes at Yarmouk Stadium May 24, 2021, in Gaza City, Gaza. (Laurent Van der Stockt/Getty Images)    New information emerged about the elimination of Sinwar Friday. An IDF spokesman said "Sinwar’s main goal was to wipe Israel off the map. This operation achievement is one fragment out of a one-year endeavor" in Gaza. He said Sinwar was in the "same tunnel where six hostages were executed" in August.One of the six hostages murdered was Israeli-American Hersh Goldberg-Polin.    "We understand Sinwar was in that area; a few hundred meters from that tunnel is where he was eliminated," the IDF spokesman noted, adding there are "indications of senior Hamas leaders in Rafah area."     There are 14,000 occurrences of Hamas booby-trapped buildings in the Rafah area, the IDF spokesman added.  Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, points at a map of the Gaza Strip during a press conference at the Government Press Office in Jerusalem Sept. 4, 2024.  (Abir Sultan/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)"Had Prime Minister Netanyahu listened to Biden and Harris and not entered Rafah, we may have never reached Sinwar. The people of America and Israel overwhelmingly supported our entry into Rafah and want to see Hamas committed to the annals of history. Now it's time to finish Hamas and bring home the hostages," Israeli Lt. Col (res) Yoni Chetboun, former deputy speaker of the Knesset and a decorated special forces operator, told Fox News Digital.  ELIMINATION OF SINWAR IS ‘SIGNIFICANT AND PRESENTS OPPORTUNITY FOR CEASE-FIRE, STATE DEPARTMENT SAYS Harris’ misjudgment about the ground war in Gaza sparked some intense criticism and ridicule on social media from foreign policy experts. American-Israeli Middle East expert Caroline Glick, wrote on X, "Sinwar was killed in Rafah — a mile from the Egyptian border. Kamala threatened Israel with sanctions if we went in. Oh, and she studied the maps."   The campaign by the U.S. government and the European Union to rope in Israel’s push to eradicate the Iranian regime-backed terrorist movements, Hamas and Hezbollah, has so far not seemed to impact Netanyahu's war plans.  Josep Borrell, the left-wing European Union's foreign policy chief who suggested in February that the United States slash military aid to Israel, said at the time there was no military solution to defeat Hamas.   Protesters rally outside the Defense Ministry against the government and to show support for the hostages kidnapped during the deadly Oct. 7 attack amid the ongoing conflict in Gaza between Israel and Hamas in Tel Aviv, Israel, Sept. 1, 2024. (Reuters/Florion Goga)Max Abrahms, a leading expert on counterterrorism and a tenured professor of political science at Northeastern University, told Fox News Digital, "Biden and Harris have been basing their advice to Netanyahu on American political calculations. The White House is keenly aware that the Democratic Party has a strong anti-Israel constituency. For this reason, the White House has tried to coerce Netanyahu to withdraw Israeli forces from Gaza before the Hamas threat is fully handled and specifically against a Rafah operation.  "Had Netanyahu heeded that advice, Sinwar would be alive. Israel is safer for ignoring this White House, an important lesson as Netanyahu weighs military options against Iran."    CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP Following news of Sinwar's death, a reporter at the State Department briefing on Thursday asked Spokesman Matthew Miller whether the Biden Administration's policy toward Israel invading Rafah was in hindsight preemptive.  In his response, Miller said: "No, I will say that we always made clear that we supported Israel conducting counterterrorism operations to target the leaders of Hamas and to target Hamas militants. And not only did we make clear we supported it, but we provided active intelligence support for those operations. And I think I’ll leave it at that."  Fox News Digital press queries asking President Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris whether they erred in their warnings to Netanyahu over Rafah were not returned.   Fox News Digital’s Anders Hagstrom contributed to this report.  Benjamin Weinthal reports on Israel, Iran, Syria, Turkey and Europe. You can follow Benjamin on Twitter @BenWeinthal, and email him at benjamin.weinthal@fox.com                   Antisemitism Exposed Fox News' Antisemitism Exposed" newsletter brings you stories on the rising anti-Jewish prejudice across the U.S. and the world." Arrives
      Weekly By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and
        agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can
        opt-out at any time. 
      Subscribe
     Subscribed  
      Subscribe
     
      You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter!
         
            U.S.
            CrimeImmigrationTerrorTrue CrimeBryan Kohberger
            Politics
            Trump's First 100 DaysSenateHouseJudiciaryForeign PolicyFox News PollsElections
            World
            U.N.ConflictsTerrorismDisastersGlobal EconomyEnvironmentReligionScandals
            Opinion
            
            Media
            FOX Nation Coverage
            Entertainment
            ExclusivesCountry MusicRoyalsBlake LivelyDiddyGame ShowsHot Videos
            Sports
            NFLCollege FootballMLBNBANHLGolfTennisSoccerUFCWWE
            Lifestyle
            MAHAHealthTravelFood & DrinkGames & Quizzes
            Deals
            
            FOX Business
            Personal FinanceEconomyMarketsWatchlistLifestyleReal EstateTech
            Science & Tech
            Air & SpaceSecurityInnovationVideo GamesMilitary TechPlanet EarthWild Nature
            Games
            Daily Crossword PuzzleCrazy Crystals Match 3 GameWord SearchMini Crossword PuzzleStack and Match Block Puzzle5 Across the Letter Word Game
            Watch Live
            FOX News ShowsProgramming ScheduleOn Air PersonalitiesFull EpisodesShow ClipsNews Clips
            About
            Contact UsCareersFox Around the WorldAdvertise With UsMedia RelationsCorporate InformationCompliance
            Apps & Products
            FOX News GoFOX WeatherFOX NationFOX NoticiasFOX News ShopFOX News RadioOutkickNewslettersPodcasts 
            U.S.
            CrimeImmigrationTerrorTrue CrimeBryan Kohberger
            Politics
            Trump's First 100 DaysSenateHouseJudiciaryForeign PolicyFox News PollsElections
            World
            U.N.ConflictsTerrorismDisastersGlobal EconomyEnvironmentReligionScandals
            Opinion
            
            Media
            FOX Nation Coverage
            Entertainment
            ExclusivesCountry MusicRoyalsBlake LivelyDiddyGame ShowsHot Videos
            Sports
            NFLCollege FootballMLBNBANHLGolfTennisSoccerUFCWWE
            Lifestyle
            MAHAHealthTravelFood & DrinkGames & Quizzes
            Deals
            
            FOX Business
            Personal FinanceEconomyMarketsWatchlistLifestyleReal EstateTech
            Science & Tech
            Air & SpaceSecurityInnovationVideo GamesMilitary TechPlanet EarthWild Nature
            Games
            Daily Crossword PuzzleCrazy Crystals Match 3 GameWord SearchMini Crossword PuzzleStack and Match Block Puzzle5 Across the Letter Word Game
            Watch Live
            FOX News ShowsProgramming ScheduleOn Air PersonalitiesFull EpisodesShow ClipsNews Clips
            About
            Contact UsCareersFox Around the WorldAdvertise With UsMedia RelationsCorporate InformationCompliance
            Apps & Products
            FOX News GoFOX WeatherFOX NationFOX NoticiasFOX News ShopFOX News RadioOutkickNewslettersPodcasts Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Flipboard LinkedIn Slack RSS Newsletters Spotify iHeartRadio Fox News Updated Terms of UseNew Privacy PolicyYour Privacy ChoicesClosed Caption PolicyHelpContact UsAccessibility Statement 
        This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. ©2025 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by
        Factset. Powered and implemented by
        FactSet Digital Solutions.
        Legal Statement. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by
        Refinitiv Lipper.
      




If he was caught via Intel, sure. He wasn't it was essentially random. Nothing like Nasrallah or the others. This was grunt work and a lucky discovery. But it does go to show, still fighting in Gaza. What level of destruction is enough for them to lay down their weapons and let the hostages go. You're subjecting your people to what you call "genocide," (Until the ICC or ICJ go there, semantics are just that), that doesn't make you think to stop?