Trump Blames Speechwriters for His Comedic Flops at New York Charity Event | Vanity FairSkip to main contentOpen Navigation MenuMenuSearchSearchPoliticsBusinessHollywoodStyleCultureRoyalsCelebrityVideoPodcastsArchiveVF ShopWhat Is Cinema?ArchiveVF ShopMagazineNo jokeTrump Blames Speechwriters for His Comedic Flops at New York Charity EventThe former president called his writers “idiots” while telling a series of humorless jokes, later claiming that “a couple people from Fox” wrote some of them.By Caitlin DeweyOctober 18, 2024Former president Donald Trump speaks during the annual Alfred E. Smith Foundation Dinner on October 17, 2024.Michael M. Santiago/Getty ImagesSave this storySaveSave this storySaveFormer president Donald Trump blamed his speechwriters for the unfunny and mean-spirited jokes he made at a charity event on Thursday, calling them “idiots” and later telling Fox News that he “didn’t like” some of the jokes that were drafted for him.“That’s a nasty one,” Trump said Thursday night, when a joke about Doug Emhoff, vice president Kamala Harris’s husband, elicited groans from the audience. “I told these idiots that gave me this stuff, that’s too tough.”Trump’s joke—and his disavowal of it—both came during the Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation Dinner in New York on Thursday night, a long-running Catholic charity event. It’s traditional for presidential candidates to speak at the dinner during election years, delivering humorous (or would-be humorous) remarks to a crowd of well-heeled guests.During Trump’s 30-minute set, which he delivered in person, he took aim at president Joseph Biden, Minnesota governor Tim Walz and New York mayor Eric Adams, among other Democratic figures. Harris, meanwhile, did not attend in person but submitted a prerecorded sketch with the actress Molly Shannon, to Trump’s apparent consternation.While neither candidate was consistently funny—they are politicians, after all—Trump’s performance in particular sometimes seemed less comedic than spiteful. The former president opened with a meandering diatribe in which he repeatedly criticized Harris for skipping the dinner, complained about the lack of teleprompters and panned his audience as “Manhattan liberals.” Trump first acknowledged the attendees were not his “normal crowd,” to widespread laughter. “Many of you are Manhattan liberals from the media and the Democrat Party,” he then added, to more-or-less complete silence.Trump’s political jokes, meanwhile, often took on a crude and personal edge. He quipped that Harris and Biden both possess the “mental faculties” of children and made an anti-trans gag about Walz having a menstrual period. He dropped his jokey demeanor entirely to attack former New York City mayor Bill de Blasio, who was in the audience.“He was a terrible mayor—I don’t give a shit if this is comedy or not. He was a terrible man,” Trump said.Even Trump seemed to doubt the success of his comedy at points. Appearing to veer off script, he complained that he hadn’t wanted to make any jokes at all—and that he didn’t know if the jokes he’d made were funny. On Fox & Friends the next morning, host Steve Doocy complimented Trump and asked where he got his material, which Trump himself then panned.“I had a lot of people helping, a lot of people,” Trump said. “A couple people from Fox—actually, I shouldn't say that, but they wrote some jokes. For the most part, I didn't like any of them." (Fox News later claimed that “no employee or freelancer wrote the jokes.”)Notably, this is not Trump’s first misfire at an Al Smith dinner. By his own admission, he also “went overboard” in 2016 when roasting Democratic presidential candidate Hilary Clinton. “I knew I was in trouble around midway through, because…even my own side was angry at me,” Trump said Thursday. “They were saying ‘it's too much,’ but I did it anyway.”More Great Stories From Vanity FairSee Our Winner Predictions for the 2025 SAG AwardsHow Patrick Schwarzenegger “Eye-F—ed” His Way Onto The White LotusThe White Lotus Season 3: All the Easter Eggs You May Have MissedThe Education—and Anointment—of Barron TrumpMillie Bobby Brown on Stranger Things, Marriage, and Life on the FarmWhere to Watch Every 2025 Oscar-Nominated MovieA Lovesick Aristocrat and the Royal Family’s Nazi-Connected ShamesChronicling JD Vance’s Circuitous Rise to Power: Listen to the Inside the Hive Podcast with Host Radhika JonesEvery Steven Spielberg Movie, RankedFrom the Archive: Seduction-to-Spilt Secrets From Ava Gardner’s Three MarriagesCaitlin DeweyContributorCaitlin Dewey is a freelance journalist and the author of the long-running digital culture newsletter “Links I Would Gchat You If We Were Friends.” She has reported on technology, culture, and politics for outlets including The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, Elle, Slate, and Cosmopolitan. She lives in Buffalo, ... Read moreSee More By Caitlin Dewey »Read MoreNewsDonald Trump Kicks Off Second Term With a Litany of Gripes and GrudgesIn rambling remarks after his inaugural address, the 47th president resurfaced baseless claims of election fraud, and aimed invective at Hillary Clinton, Liz Cheney, Adam Kinzinger and Joe Biden.By Eve BateyPoliticsThe Gen Z Influencers Giving MAGA a Youthful Glow: “Our Voices Are Being Heard”On the eve of the inauguration, the hard-charging stars of the movement tell VF that they’re poised to play a powerful role in steering Donald Trump’s agenda.By Olivia EmpsonCultureNo, the Obamas Are Not Divorcing. But MAGA World Infected the Culture With an Absurd RumorAnd nope on the Jennifer Aniston part, too. Did we learn nothing about spreading gossip from the Kate Middleton conspiracy churn? Or Taylor Swift’s “wedding”?By Kase WickmanPoliticsRFK Jr. Proved Himself Out of His Depth—Even Under Friendly Republican QuestioningThe Kennedy scion is already well-known for pushing conspiracy theories and junk science, but Wednesday’s hearing revealed just how little he understands about the monumental job he might take on.By Eric LutzPoliticsThe Democrats’ Fear FactorIt’s the consultants, stupid! Future candidates need to be themselves, take control on social media, and immediately push back on right-wing spin.By Molly Jong-FastHollywoodJesse Eisenberg Unfriended Mark Zuckerberg a Long Time AgoDespite earning an Oscar nomination for his performance in The Social Network, the actor says, “I don’t want to think of myself as associated with somebody like that.”By Savannah WalshPoliticsThe Awful Absurdity of Donald Trump’s First Week Back in PowerA watchdog purge. A proposal to “clean out” Gaza. Immigration raids starring Dr. Phil. It was an appalling return to Trump politics—and, with little real opposition so far, it’s only going to get worse.By Eric LutzPoliticsDemocrats Need More Than a New MessageSaturday’s Democratic National Committee chair election is a chance for the party to stop soul-searching and start rebuilding the brand to take on Trump 2.0. But from my conversations with top contenders, the party still isn’t meeting the moment with a bold vision for the future.By Eric LutzNewsElon Musk Sure Isn’t Denying That His Inaugural Gesture Was a Nazi SaluteThere’s an easy way to say “I wasn't Sieg heiling all my pals” on the world stage. Musk isn’t saying it. Silly libs!By Kase WickmanPoliticsCaroline Kennedy’s Letter Is “Too Late,” Fears Woman Who Accused RFK Jr. of Sexual Assault“This is a McCarthy-era moment,” another Kennedy cousin tells VF, as unlikely allies dig in for a nasty fight over Kennedy Jr.’s nomination.By Joe HaganHollywoodBefore Their New Movie, Reese Witherspoon and Will Ferrell Met on the Post-9/11 Episode of Saturday Night LivePrior to starring as warring love interests in You’re Cordially Invited, the pair delivered comedy during a time of turmoil: “I was scared out of my mind.”By Savannah WalshPoliticsCheryl Hines, Megyn Kelly, and Vani Hari Form RFK Jr.’s MAHA Cheer Squad at First Confirmation HearingPlus, Jessica Reed Kraus, Marla Maples, and Hari's 8-year-old daughter—because what grade schooler doesn’t get psyched about Medicaid?By Kase WickmanFacebookXInstagramPinterestYouTubeMore from Vanity FairNewslettersSubscribeDigital EditionInside the IssueAbout Vanity FairFAQContactContact VFManage AccountAdvertisingCareersUser AgreementPrivacy PolicyYour California Privacy RightsCondé Nast StoreVF Media KitAccessibility Help© 2025 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Vanity Fair may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad ChoicesCN EntertainmentSelect international siteUnited StatesLargeChevronItalySpainFrance
This is completely wrong. I listened to Shmanity for about 15 minutes today where he went into detail explaining why Trumps jokes were funny

Because everyone know that having to explain a joke means it was really hilarious….