


SAVE Plan Blocked; 8M Student-Loan Borrowers Getting Closer to Ruling - Business Insider



























































 















 
































Business Insider








 Subscribe
            

              Newsletters
            



 
 












 















 




 











Search









Business




Strategy




Economy




Finance




Retail




Advertising




Careers




Media




Real Estate




Small Business




The Better Work Project


 





Tech




Science




AI




Enterprise




Transportation




Startups




Innovation


 





Markets




Stocks




Indices




Commodities




Crypto




Currencies




ETFs


 





Lifestyle




Entertainment




Culture




Travel




Food




Health




Parenting







Reviews




Tech




Streaming




Tickets




Home




Kitchen




Style




Beauty




Gifts




Deals


 
 





Politics




Military & Defense




Law




Education


 





Personal Finance







Banking




Savings




Best Savings Accounts




Raisin Review




Checking Accounts




Best Checking Accounts




Chime Checking Account




SoFi Checking and Saving




Best Money Market Accounts




CDs




Best CD Rates




Best Bank Account Bonuses




Cash Back Debit Cards




Best Banks




CIT Bank Review




UFB Direct Bank




Small Business Banking


 





Credit Cards




Credit Scores




Credit Monitoring




Best Credit Cards




Best Cash Back Credit Cards




Best Rewards Credit Cards




Best Travel Credit Cards




Best 0% APR Credit Cards




Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards




Best First Credit Cards




Best Business Credit Cards




Discover it Cash Back Credit Card




Chase Sapphire Preferred Credit Card


 





Investing




Financial Planning




Retirement




Taxes


 





Loans




Best personal loans




Best debt consolidation loans




Best Loans for Bad Credit




Student Loans




Best Student Loans




Best Student Loan Refinance


 





Mortgages




Best mortgage lenders




Best mortgage refinance lenders




Best FHA Lenders




Best HELOC Lenders


 





Insurance




Best Car Insurance




Homeowners Insurance




Best Homeowners Insurance




Best Renters Insurance




Life Insurance




Best Life Insurance




Pet Insurance




Best Pet Insurance




Travel Insurance




Best Travel Insurance




SquareMouth Travel Insurance




Identity Theft Protection


 
 





Video




Big Business




Food Wars




So Expensive




Still Standing




Boot Camp


 
 




        Subscribe
          


My account



Log in


            Newsletters
          



US edition 






Deutschland & Österreich




España




Japan




Netherlands




Polska


 
 







Get the app





 



 



 



 



 













 
                    HOME
                  




    Subscribe
                















                                      Economy
                                    


8 million student-loan borrowers who remain blocked from cheaper payments and debt cancellation are getting a step closer to a final decision on Biden's new repayment plan








Ayelet Sheffey 

                                    2024-10-20T09:22:01Z
                                   







Share icon
An curved arrow pointing right.

 Share







Facebook
 





Email
 





X
 





LinkedIn
 





Copy Link
 





lighning bolt icon
An icon in the shape of a lightning bolt.

 
Impact Link

 
 



Save Article Icon
A bookmark

 Save





 
                        		        Read in app
                        		    

 











 

A Missouri judge will hear oral arguments on President Joe Biden's SAVE student-loan repayment plan, which remains blocked.
 
                            Scott Olson/Getty Images
                          





This story is available exclusively to Business Insider
                      subscribers. Become an Insider
                      and start reading now.
Have an account? Log in.






A Missouri court will hear oral arguments for Biden's SAVE student-loan repayment plan on October 24.The SAVE plan has been blocked for months following challenges from GOP state attorneys general.The case now sits with the 8th Circuit, and the Supreme Court urged for a quick decision.Millions of student-loan borrowers are getting a step closer to a court ruling on cheaper payments and debt relief.

Last summer, Biden and his Education Department introduced the SAVE income-driven repayment plan, intended to make repayment cheaper for borrowers and bring them a shorter timeline for student-loan forgiveness.Shortly after the Education Department began implementing key parts of the plan — like loan forgiveness for borrowers who had original balances of $12,000 or less and made as few as 10 years of qualifying payments — it ran into legal threats from groups of GOP state attorneys general and culminated in two separate lawsuits, one of which blocked any future loan forgiveness through the plan in June.

Since then, the plan in its entirety has remained blocked — the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals prohibited the Education Department from implementing any provisions of the SAVE plan until the court issues a final decision on the legality of the plan, leaving 8 million enrolled borrowers in limbo.But some movement could soon be made; on October 24, a Missouri court will hear oral arguments on the SAVE plan, after which the 8th Circuit will issue its final decision. It will consider the key arguments the GOP states have made on why SAVE should be blocked, including the plans' harm to student-loan company Mohela and the states' tax revenues."MOHELA faces the imminent loss of revenue in its role as a servicer of loans owned by the Federal Government," the lawsuit the attorneys general filed said.

It's the same argument GOP attorneys general used to block Biden's first attempt at broad student-loan forgiveness last summer, which the Supreme Court ultimately struck down. They had argued that Mohela, which is an instrumentality of Missouri, would lose revenue on forgiven loans despite the servicer having previously denied involvement in the legal process.David Nahmias, the legal director of the UC Berkeley Center for Consumer Law and Economic Justice, told Business Insider that given the Supreme Court's prior ruling, the arguments the states are making this time around could prevail with the Missouri judges during oral arguments."An appellate court has to apply the law from the US Supreme Court," Nahmias said. "So I think that this particular argument that Missouri and the states are making, even if I believe that it's not substantial, I think that it might hold some water with this panel."

Where borrowers stand under the SAVE blockIt's not surprising that there's confusion surrounding the SAVE litigation — there have been a number of different court rulings over the past few months that impacted different parts of the SAVE plan. For now, borrowers can focus on the 8th Circuit, which placed a preliminary injunction on the plan in its entirety and will determine whether the plan will ultimately be implemented or blocked.



                                         Related stories
                                       



At the end of August, the Supreme Court declined to allow the Education Department to move forward with implementing the SAVE plan while the legal process continued, instead referring the task back to the 8th Circuit. In its one-paragraph ruling, the nation's highest court said that it expects the 8th Circuit "will render its decision with appropriate dispatch," encouraging the court to move quickly with its final decision.It's unclear when exactly a final decision on the SAVE plan will be made, and the 8th Circuit might look at the broader relief the Supreme Court struck down as context to make its decision. However, Nahmias said that the arguments the GOP attorneys general are making — particularly when it comes to Mohela — are highly speculative.

For example, Federal Student Aid announced in April that over 1 million student-loan borrowers were being transferred from Mohela to new servicers upon Mohela request to allow borrowers to receive "the best service and support," and Nahmias said there has not been any evidence of financial harm to the servicer despite it managing fewer accounts."Mohela has been offloading borrowers' accounts, there were accounts of folks who were already having their loans being discharged, and there is no sign of any financial harm to Mohela," Nahmias said.Mohela did not immediately respond to a request for comment from BI on the lawsuit.

While the SAVE plan has been blocked, the Education Department has kept enrolled borrowers on interest-free forbearance and said it will continue to fight for the plan in court. Even so, Nahmias said the legal whiplash borrowers are experiencing is prompting chaos and confusion."People just can't make any independent decisions about how much they're going to pay every month to their student loans," Nahmias said. "This is something that affects millions of people, and they just can't."

 






                                    Read next
                                  







Economy


Politics


Policy
 
More 




Student Debt


Student Loans


student loan forgiveness


Biden
 





 



 






 




 




 


Recommended video








 

 












This story is available exclusively to Business Insider
        subscribers. Become an Insider
        and start reading now.
Have an account? Log in.
















 



 



 



 



 









 






 




Legal & Privacy

Terms of Service
Terms of Sale
Privacy Policy
Accessibility
Code of Ethics Policy
Reprints & Permissions
Disclaimer
Advertising Policies
Conflict of Interest Policy
Commerce Policy
Coupons Privacy Policy
Coupons Terms
 Your Privacy Choices


Company

About Us
Careers
Advertise With Us
Contact Us
Company News
Masthead


Other

Sitemap
Stock quotes by finanzen.net

International Editions

AT
DE
ES
JP
NL
PL



Copyright © 2025 
    Insider Inc. All rights reserved.
    Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our 
    Terms of Service
and
Privacy Policy.








































































Jump to

Main content
Search
Account













To be fair, government subsidization is what led to crazy high loans in the first place because colleges knew that if students loans are guaranteed by the government regardless, why wouldn't they keep pushing prices higher and higher