 

































False claims about the federal response to Helene are an ominous sign for the coming election | CNN Business













































































CNN values your feedback




                                                        1. How relevant is this ad to you?
                                                






























                                                2. Did you encounter any technical issues?
                                        











                                                                        Video player was slow to load content
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad froze or did not finish loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content did not start after ad
                                                                        



                                                                        Audio on ad was too loud
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        





                                                                        Ad never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad prevented/slowed the page from loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Content moved around while ad loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad was repetitive to ads I've seen previously
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        











                                                        Cancel
                                                

                                                        Submit
                                                





Thank You!

                                        Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much
                                        appreciated.
                                

                                        Close
                                











Ad Feedback


















Close icon








Business






                  
                  Markets
                



                  
                  Tech
                



                  
                  Media
                



                  
                  Calculators
                



                  
                  Videos
                




                      More
                    




                      Markets
                    

                      Tech
                    

                      Media
                    

                      Calculators
                    

                      Videos
                    








            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          




              Subscribe
            










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account


























        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






            Live TV
          

            Listen
          

            Watch
          




                Edition
              


                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                




                Edition





                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                









                  Markets
                



                  Tech
                



                  Media
                



                  Calculators
                



                  Videos
                




Follow CNN Business

























        US
      



            Crime + Justice
          





        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Pro Football
          



            College Football
          



            Basketball
          



            Baseball
          



            Soccer
          



            Olympics
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Headlines
          



            CNN Shorts
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          



            FlashDocs
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        CNN Underscored
      



            Electronics
          



            Fashion
          



            Beauty
          



            Health & Fitness
          



            Home
          



            Reviews
          



            Deals
          



            Gifts
          



            Travel
          



            Outdoors
          



            Pets
          





        Games
      



            CNN Crossword
          



            Jumble Crossword
          



            Photo Shuffle
          



            Sudoblock
          



            Sudoku
          



            5 Things Quiz
          





        About CNN
      



            Subscribe
          



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















 




Markets 






DOW





S&P 500





NASDAQ








Hot Stocks 



















Fear & Greed Index 







































----- is driving the US market 
        







            Latest Market News 
















What DOGE could gain by accessing your Social Security data









Trump administration kills New York City’s congestion pricing









It feels like there are suddenly way more plane crashes and incidents. Here’s the truth











            Hot Stocks 






































----- is driving the US market 
        



Something isn't loading properly. Please check back later.








Ad Feedback












 
Business
    /
    Media







      False claims about the federal response to Helene are an ominous sign for the coming election
    











			Analysis by Brian Stelter, CNN
		



                  3 minute read
                

  Published
        4:55 PM EDT, Sat October 5, 2024
    





















            Link Copied!
        










Follow:


Fighting disinformation





See your latest updates










 










Damage from Hurricane Helene is seen on Main Street in Marshall, North Carolina, on October 3, 2024.

Melissa Sue Gerrits/Getty Images







New York
CNN
         — 
    


            False claims about the federal response to the historic devastation left by Hurricane Helene are spreading out of control on social media, hampering recovery efforts in hard-hit areas, according to local officials.
    

            The flood of misinformation targeting the Biden administration’s response to the destructive storm is an ominous sign for the coming election, with the presidential contest between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris sure to trigger further attacks on the truth.
    

            “If you think the lies and distortions and know-nothing takes about FEMA are bad, just wait until this time next month,” Tim Alberta, The Atlantic staff writer and author, wrote on X, one of the primary platforms where falsehoods have spread faster than facts.
    

            Elon Musk, the X owner who has endorsed Trump, has repeatedly posted rumors and innuendo denigrating the federal government’s response to Helene. Most of the misinformation is brazenly political, portraying President Joe Biden and Harris as incompetent in an attempt to help Trump win reelection.
    









Residents and volunteers clean up on October 1, 2024, after flooding in Marshall, North Carolina.

Travis Long/The News & Observer/TNS/Getty Images




Related article
With misinformation swirling in Hurricane Helene’s wake, officials urge residents to ‘stop this conspiracy theory junk’




            Politicians and emergency responders in the disaster zone stretching from Georgia to North Carolina, including many Republican elected officials, have refuted the lies and urged people to stop sharing unsupported rumors on social media.
    

            Kerry Giles, the public information officer for Rutherford County, NC, told CNN on Saturday that debunking the rumors “did consume resources that could have been more effectively utilized in the recovery efforts.”
    

            Giles and her colleagues issued a statement on Friday shutting down several lies swirling online about the devastated towns of Lake Lure and Chimney Rock Village. No, they said, the government is not taking over Chimney Rock; no, there is no discussion about seizing property; no, there are not dead “bodies everywhere” as a result of the storm.
    

            “Snopes.com and regional media outlets have covered much of the debunking, which has helped to reduce some of the misinformation circulating,” Giles told CNN.
    

            Some of the most-shared lies on social media have involved FEMA’s response. Trump has falsely claimed that relief funds are being withheld from predominantly Republican areas after the agency directed relief money to help migrants.
    

            “A billion dollars was stolen from FEMA to use it for illegal migrants,” Trump falsely claimed Friday in Georgia.
    

            But Trump was actually accusing the Biden administration of an act very similar to something he did as president.
    

            “Republican elected officials keep rebutting the BS, and MAGA does not care,” conservative columnist David French said in a social media post Saturday. “They follow liars, and when the liars lie, they believe them and hate anyone who tells the truth.”
    









In an aerial view, flood damage wrought by Hurricane Helene is seen along the Swannanoa River on October 3, 2024 in Asheville, North Carolina.

Mario Tama/Getty Images




Related article
People desperate for answers as family members remain unaccounted for days after Helene’s devastation




            Veteran users of X say the sheer amount of bogus and baseless information on the platform is getting worse – in part because Musk reversed efforts to reduce viral misinformation and reinstated accounts of conspiracy theorists.
    

            Officials at FEMA have published a rumor control page to push back on bogus claims, including the assertion that it “is confiscating donations for survivors.” Mike Rothschild, a journalist who has written two books about conspiracy theory culture, called FEMA’s effort “noble but doomed.” He wrote on X that “nobody who wants to believe the lies will trust the source, and the denials will just be rolled into the conspiracy theories.”
    

            Or, as the hosts of the progressive podcast Appodlachia commented, more bluntly, “the internet has broken peoples’ brains.”
    

            Misleading AI-generated images purporting to be from the disaster zone have been proliferating on Facebook, leading one local news station to publish a “how to spot AI-generated Helene storm photos” explainer.
    

            As North Carolina columnist Billy Ball wrote on Friday, “We have a lot of crises in the U.S., but few are as significant as the information crisis. People are lying to us to make us hate each other, to get our money, to boost some cause or another.”
    

            And all signs point to an even uglier climate once votes start to be counted next month.
    















Related

























Ad Feedback









Ad Feedback





















Ad Feedback











CNN Business Videos













NBC / Saturday Night Live










Video
Right-leaning media melts down over ‘SNL’ skit not long after saying Americans are too sensitive
2:49


                    Feb 19, 2025
                












Vertical Aerospace










Video
Straight out of ‘The Jetsons’? Meet the flying taxi
3:09


                    Feb 17, 2025
                












NBC










Video
Sabrina Carpenter joins Domingo for ‘SNL’ 50th anniversary special
1:23


                    Feb 17, 2025
                












Clipped From Video










Video
Trump says tariffs could cause short-term price increases
6:51


                    Feb 13, 2025
                














Ad Feedback















Ad Feedback

































        Subscribe
      










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






        Live TV
      

        Listen
      

        Watch
      






        US
      



            Crime + Justice
          





        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            News
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Pro Football
          



            College Football
          



            Basketball
          



            Baseball
          



            Soccer
          



            Olympics
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Headlines
          



            CNN Shorts
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          



            FlashDocs
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        CNN Underscored
      



            Electronics
          



            Fashion
          



            Beauty
          



            Health & Fitness
          



            Home
          



            Reviews
          



            Deals
          



            Gifts
          



            Travel
          



            Outdoors
          



            Pets
          





        Games
      



            CNN Crossword
          



            Jumble Crossword
          



            Photo Shuffle
          



            Sudoblock
          



            Sudoku
          



            5 Things Quiz
          





        About CNN
      



            Subscribe
          



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















Business





            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          


Follow CNN Business
























            Subscribe
          










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account







Most stock quote data provided by BATS. US market indices are shown in real time, except for the S&P 500 which is refreshed every two minutes. All times are ET. Factset: FactSet Research Systems Inc. All rights reserved. Chicago Mercantile: Certain market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Dow Jones: The Dow Jones branded indices are proprietary to and are calculated, distributed and marketed by DJI Opco, a subsidiary of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and have been licensed for use to S&P Opco, LLC and CNN. Standard & Poor’s and S&P are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC and Dow Jones is a registered trademark of Dow Jones Trademark Holdings LLC. All content of the Dow Jones branded indices Copyright S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and/or its affiliates. Fair value provided by IndexArb.com. Market holidays and trading hours provided by Copp Clark Limited.


          Terms of Use
        

          Privacy Policy
        



          Ad Choices
        

          Accessibility & CC
        

          About
        

          Subscribe
        

          Newsletters
        

          Transcripts
        

          Help Center
        

© 2025 Cable News Network. A Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All Rights Reserved.  CNN Sans ™ & © 2016 Cable News Network.










Uhhhh Mayorkas literally said that FEMA funds were used for the emergency at the border and now he says that FEMA doesn’t have enough money for the rest of hurricane season