 

































US Supreme Court to decide if Mexico may sue gunmakers for border violence | CNN Politics













































































CNN values your feedback




                                                        1. How relevant is this ad to you?
                                                






























                                                2. Did you encounter any technical issues?
                                        











                                                                        Video player was slow to load content
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad froze or did not finish loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Video content did not start after ad
                                                                        



                                                                        Audio on ad was too loud
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        





                                                                        Ad never loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad prevented/slowed the page from loading
                                                                        



                                                                        Content moved around while ad loaded
                                                                        



                                                                        Ad was repetitive to ads I've seen previously
                                                                        



                                                                        Other issues
                                                                        











                                                        Cancel
                                                

                                                        Submit
                                                





Thank You!

                                        Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much
                                        appreciated.
                                

                                        Close
                                











Ad Feedback


















Close icon








Politics






                  
                  SCOTUS
                



                  
                  Congress
                



                  
                  Facts First
                



                  
                  2024 Elections
                




                      More
                    




                      SCOTUS
                    

                      Congress
                    

                      Facts First
                    

                      2024 Elections
                    








            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          




              Subscribe
            










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account


























        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






            Live TV
          

            Listen
          

            Watch
          




                Edition
              


                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                




                Edition





                  US
                



                  International
                



                  Arabic
                



                  Español
                









                  SCOTUS
                



                  Congress
                



                  Facts First
                



                  2024 Elections
                




Follow CNN Politics

























        US
      



            Crime + Justice
          





        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Pro Football
          



            College Football
          



            Basketball
          



            Baseball
          



            Soccer
          



            Olympics
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Headlines
          



            CNN Shorts
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          



            FlashDocs
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        CNN Underscored
      



            Electronics
          



            Fashion
          



            Beauty
          



            Health & Fitness
          



            Home
          



            Reviews
          



            Deals
          



            Gifts
          



            Travel
          



            Outdoors
          



            Pets
          





        Games
      



            CNN Crossword
          



            Jumble Crossword
          



            Photo Shuffle
          



            Sudoblock
          



            Sudoku
          



            5 Things Quiz
          





        About CNN
      



            Subscribe
          



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















 







Ad Feedback





 





      US Supreme Court to decide whether Mexico may sue gunmakers for border violence
    











			By Tierney Sneed and John Fritze, CNN
		



                  5 minute read
                

  Updated
        10:39 AM EDT, Fri October 4, 2024
    





















            Link Copied!
        










Follow:


Supreme Court





See your latest updates










 










A view of the US Supreme Court Building during sunrise on September 5, 2024 in Washington, DC.

Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images








CNN
         — 
    


            The US Supreme Court will decide whether a federal law prevents Mexico from suing gun distributors for allegedly facilitating the flow of firearms to drug cartels.
    

            The high court on Friday granted the request by Smith & Wesson and other gun manufacturers to review a federal appeals court ruling reviving the case, after a trial judge threw it out on the basis of the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act, a law that generally bars civil liability for firearm manufacturers and distributors for the use of their products by third-party criminals.
    

            The Supreme Court granted 13 cases on Friday, filling out the term that will begin on Monday with new disputes dealing with reverse discrimination, the storage of spent nuclear fuel and DNA testing for a death row inmate. The court had already agreed to hear cases on President Joe Biden’s regulation of “ghost guns” and vaping.
    

            The court will reconvene for the first time since its 6-3 conservative majority granted sweeping criminal immunity to former President Donald Trump in July, further limited the power of federal agencies and struck down a ban on bump stocks.
    

        Mexico says gunmakers are reckless


            In its lawsuit, Mexico alleged the manufacturers and distributors were aiding and abetting the purchase of their firearms by dealers known to supply drug cartels. They also claim that firearm makers have resisted making changes to their products – such as making gun serial numbers harder to tamper with or installing certain technological safeguards that would hinder a gun’s unauthorized use – that would make the guns less appealing to criminal gangs.
    

            And the complaint says manufacturers market their products in a “inflammatory” and “reckless” way that makes guns more attractive to cartels.
    

            At the heart of the dispute before the Supreme Court is the 2005 federal law passed by a GOP-led Congress. The ruling in Mexico’s favor came after gunmakers had previous success in using the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act to stop similar lawsuits from local and state governments.
    

            The 1st Circuit concluded the Mexico lawsuit could go forward because it fell under an exemption allowing liability when the alleged harm is connected to violations by the gun maker or distributor of state or local law.
    

            In seeking to have that ruling overturn, the manufacturers are contesting Mexico’s allegations that they were aiding and abetting the illegal sales of their arms in violation of federal law. They point to the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling shielding Twitter from a lawsuit alleging it aided and abetted terrorism by hosting tweets created by the terror group ISIS.
    

            Lawyers for Mexico, which asked the court not to disturb the 1st Circuit’s ruling, defended the ruling’s rationale and argued that it was premature for the Supreme Court to take up the case.
    

        Court will hear appeal from straight woman who alleges she was denied promotion by gay boss


            As recent Supreme Court rulings on workplace discrimination continue to ripple through lower courts, the justices also agreed Friday to take up the case of a woman who claims she missed a promotion because she is heterosexual and her boss was gay.
    

            Marlean Ames started working for Ohio’s state government in 2004 and steadily rose through the ranks at the Department of Youth Services. She claims that in 2017 she started reporting to a gay boss and was passed over for a promotion that was offered to another gay woman.
    

            Ames is challenging a requirement applied in five appeals courts across the country that “majority” Americans raising discrimination claims must demonstrate “background circumstances” in order to pursue their lawsuit. A plaintiff might meet that requirement, for instance, by providing statistical evidence documenting a pattern of discrimination against members of a majority group.
    

            Ames lost at the Cincinnati-based 6th US Circuit Court of Appeals. If she wins her case, it could make it easier for American to bring so-called reverse discrimination suits.
    

            Ohio officials counter that the department had “legitimate, nondiscriminatory, reasons for hiring someone” else and that Ames never provided evidence showing that managers were even aware of her sexual orientation.
    

        Spent nuclear fuel and major questions doctrine


            The Supreme Court will also wade into a decades-old battle over how – and where – to store spent nuclear fuel, in a case that could have reverberations for federal agency power.
    

            The Biden administration appealed a decision from the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals that allowed Texas to challenge a Nuclear Regulatory Commission plan to store as much as 40,000 metric tons of nuclear waste on the Permian Basin in Texas.
    

            The case will bring back to the high court a significant issue dealing with how to resolve ambiguities over a doctrine it created that limits the power of federal agencies in situations where Congress has not granted explicit authority for an action, known as the major questions doctrine.
    

            The case will be decided months after the Supreme Court delivered a significant blow to the power of federal agencies in a separate case dealing with when courts may review agency actions.
    

            The Nuclear Regulatory Commission argued that Texas shouldn’t have been permitted to bring the case into federal court at all because the state didn’t formally object to the plan when the agency first awarded the storage license to Interim Storage Partners, a private company. The agency is also fighting the 5th Circuit’s ruling that the agency does not have the authority to issue licenses to store nuclear fuel away from reactors.
    

        Court agrees to decide second death penalty case


            The court agreed Friday to take up an appeal from a death row inmate in Texas who was denied an opportunity to seek post-conviction DNA testing, putting the death penalty on the high court’s docket for a second time this year.
    

            Ruben Gutierrez was convicted of capital murder and related offenses in the killing of Escolastica Harrison more than twenty-five years ago and was sentenced in 1999. He was denied an opportunity to seek additional, post-conviction DNA testing under a Texas law that is at issue in the case.
    

            After a spate of executions across the country in recent weeks – several of which the Supreme Court declined to halt – the justices are set to hear oral arguments Wednesday in a separate death penalty case involving an Oklahoma man who even pro-death penalty state officials believe should be spared.
    

            The court drew scrutiny from anti-death penalty advocates in late September for declining to intervene in the case of Marcellus Williams, who was convicted in 2001 of killing former newspaper reporter Felicia Gayle.
    

            The court declined to stop the execution, over the objection of the three liberal justices. Williams’ conviction was questioned by the same office that prosecuted him.
    

CNN’s Devan Cole contributed to this report. 


This story has been updated with additional developments.





























Ad Feedback









Ad Feedback





















Ad Feedback












Ad Feedback















Ad Feedback

































        Subscribe
      










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account






        Live TV
      

        Listen
      

        Watch
      






        US
      



            Crime + Justice
          





        World
      



            Africa
          



            Americas
          



            Asia
          



            Australia
          



            China
          



            Europe
          



            India
          



            Middle East
          



            United Kingdom
          





        Politics
      



            SCOTUS
          



            Congress
          



            Facts First
          



            2024 Elections
          





        Business
      



            Tech
          



            Media
          



            Calculators
          



            Videos
          





        Markets
      



            Pre-markets
          



            After-Hours
          



            Fear & Greed
          



            Investing
          



            Markets Now
          



            Nightcap
          





        Health
      



            Life, But Better
          



            Fitness
          



            Food
          



            Sleep
          



            Mindfulness
          



            Relationships
          





        Entertainment
      



            Movies
          



            Television
          



            Celebrity
          





        Tech
      



            Innovate
          



            Foreseeable Future
          



            Mission: Ahead
          



            Work Transformed
          



            Innovative Cities
          





        Style
      



            Arts
          



            Design
          



            Fashion
          



            Architecture
          



            Luxury
          



            Beauty
          



            Video
          





        Travel
      



            Destinations
          



            Food & Drink
          



            Stay
          



            News
          



            Videos
          





        Sports
      



            Pro Football
          



            College Football
          



            Basketball
          



            Baseball
          



            Soccer
          



            Olympics
          



            Hockey
          





        Science
      



            Space
          



            Life
          



            Unearthed
          





        Climate
      



            Solutions
          



            Weather
          





        Weather
      



            Video
          



            Climate
          





        Ukraine-Russia War
      





        Israel-Hamas War
      





        Watch
      



            Live TV
          



            CNN Headlines
          



            CNN Shorts
          



            Shows A-Z
          



            CNN10
          



            CNN Max
          



            CNN TV Schedules
          



            FlashDocs
          





        Listen
      



            CNN 5 Things
          



            Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta
          



            The Assignment with Audie Cornish
          



            One Thing
          



            Tug of War
          



            CNN Political Briefing
          



            The Axe Files
          



            All There Is with Anderson Cooper
          



            All CNN Audio podcasts
          





        CNN Underscored
      



            Electronics
          



            Fashion
          



            Beauty
          



            Health & Fitness
          



            Home
          



            Reviews
          



            Deals
          



            Gifts
          



            Travel
          



            Outdoors
          



            Pets
          





        Games
      



            CNN Crossword
          



            Jumble Crossword
          



            Photo Shuffle
          



            Sudoblock
          



            Sudoku
          



            5 Things Quiz
          





        About CNN
      



            Subscribe
          



            Photos
          



            Investigations
          



            CNN Profiles
          



            CNN Leadership
          



            CNN Newsletters
          



            Work for CNN
          
















Politics





            Watch
          

            Listen
          

            Live TV
          


Follow CNN Politics
























            Subscribe
          










        Sign in
      



      My Account




          Settings
        



          Newsletters
        



          Topics You Follow
          




          Sign Out
        




Your CNN account
Sign in to your CNN account









          Terms of Use
        

          Privacy Policy
        



          Ad Choices
        

          Accessibility & CC
        

          About
        

          Subscribe
        

          Newsletters
        

          Transcripts
        

          Help Center
        

© 2025 Cable News Network. A Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All Rights Reserved.  CNN Sans ™ & © 2016 Cable News Network.










Lawsuits may just be the answer to taming the gun problem here in the U.S.