




 





















Arab Voters Are Abandoning Kamala Harris. Why Doesn’t She Seem to Care? | The Nation



























































 




































































Log In











Email *





Password *










Remember Me





							
								Forgot Your Password?							
							










Log In






New to The Nation? SubscribePrint subscriber? Activate your online access









 







Skip to content
Skip to footer

















                    Arab Voters Are Abandoning Kamala Harris. Why Doesn’t She Seem to Care?
                



Magazine


Newsletters



















 


Subscribe


Log In



















Search


















Subscribe


Donate


Magazine


Latest


Archive


Podcasts


Newsletters





Sections



Politics


World


Economy


Culture


Books & the Arts



The Nation



About


Events


Contact Us


Advertise





Current Issue



















 














 


 








Politics


 / 
October 3, 2024


Arab Voters Are Abandoning Kamala Harris. Why Doesn’t She Seem to Care?
Arab American support for Democrats has plummeted—but Harris is making virtually no effort to win these voters back.



Waleed Shahid 


Share


Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email


 







Ad Policy


Hundreds gather for a rally in support of Lebanon in light of recent Israeli strikes that killed hundreds, on Wednesday, September 25, 2024, in front of the Henry Ford Centennial Library in Dearborn, Michigan.(Katy Kildee / Detroit News via AP)
There’s been a lot of discussion over the past few years about Black men slowly moving away from the Democratic Party or Latino voters in places like South Texas shifting rightward. But a similar exodus has been brewing among Arab American and Muslim voters, especially in states like Michigan, with far less attention. And, as new polling out this week from the Arab American Institute emphasizes, Gaza has accelerated this shift at breakneck speed.

But while Kamala Harris has made aggressive efforts to stabilize her Black and Latino support, she appears uninterested in doing the same for Arab American voters. With the presidential election on a knife edge, the question is not why Harris is losing Arab American voters but why she won’t even try to win them back.
For years, Arab American voters were a reliable part of the Democratic coalition, especially in Michigan. Michigan is home to Arab and Muslim American Democratic elected officials up and down the ballot. But as Israel’s assault on Gaza rages on and expands to Lebanon and the West Bank, these voters are turning their backs on a party that they feel has abandoned them. The latest AAI poll, taken before Israel’s recent bombing of Lebanon and released on Wednesday, shows that Arab Americans are now virtually tied between Harris and Trump. The Biden-Harris administration’s unrestricted weapons transfers for Israel, in the face of a growing humanitarian crisis, has eroded what little trust was left. So why won’t the Harris campaign take this seriously?

“In our thirty years of polling Arab American voters, we have not witnessed anything like the role that the war on Gaza is having on voter behavior,” said James Zogby, president of the Arab American Institute. pic.twitter.com/6qOmafS9Pu— Asma Khalid (@asmamk) October 3, 2024

The refusal to engage Arab American voters is glaring. There’s been talk about outreach to Black men, Latinos, and other key constituencies, but when it comes to Arab Americans, the silence is deafening. Even supporters of Dick and Liz Cheney are getting more attention from the Harris campaign than Arab voters. Abbas Alawieh, my colleague in the Uncommitted campaign, put it bluntly on CNN, asking why Vice President Harris won’t sit down with Lebanese and Palestinian Americans, and why she won’t meet with families directly impacted by the bombs falling in Gaza. The absence of that dialogue is not just political malpractice; it’s a moral failure.

81% of Arab American voters say Gaza is very or somewhat important to their vote[Est. Arab American population vs. 2020 margin]:Michigan — 392,733 vs. 154,188Pennsylvania — 126,553 vs. 80,555Arizona — 77,599 vs. 10,457Georgia — 58,033 vs. 11,779Wisconsin — 31,387 vs. 20,682 pic.twitter.com/S3AcpSye5V— Prem Thakker (@prem_thakker) October 2, 2024

The latest poll numbers tell a stark story. A majority—55 percent—of Arab Americans told the AAIA that they would be more likely to support Harris if the DNC had allowed a Palestinian American to speak at the convention. But Harris and the DNC refused. More than 56 percent of Arab Americans said they would support Harris if she called for an end to arms shipments to Israel. But she hasn’t. Instead, the Harris campaign has offered little more than platitudes, virtual staff meetings, and a refusal to engage with the urgency that this moment demands.

I really don’t understand why the @KamalaHarris campaign won’t even do the bare minimum to persuade Arab American voters. pic.twitter.com/z47GEAbKG9— Waleed Shahid 🪬 (@_waleedshahid) October 2, 2024

This isn’t about misunderstanding the stakes; the stakes are clear. Michigan is a critical battleground state, and Arab American voters have played a decisive role in the past. But the Harris campaign is not making the same effort to persuade them as they are with other disillusioned groups. It’s as if they’ve written off these voters, even as they scramble to address shifts in other demographics. The loss of Arab American voters is seen as collateral damage, rather than an opportunity to build bridges.
Gaza isn’t just a distant foreign policy issue for these voters—it’s personal. The war has torn American families apart, and the Democratic Party’s unwavering insistence on supplying weapons for Israel’s military assault has only deepened the wounds of dehumanization. Yet, instead of addressing these concerns head-on, the Harris campaign continues to ignore them. It’s as if they’re hoping Arab Americans will simply return to the fold because of the fear of Trump without having to put in the work. But that clearly isn’t happening.


                    Current Issue
            





            March 2025 Issue
        


Biden reportedly believes that Netanyahu is extending the war in Gaza to help Trump win the November election, yet his administration’s actions seem to do little to counteract that. Even as pressure mounts within the Democratic Party to distance itself from Netanyahu, Biden’s instinct has been to uphold the US-Israel alliance, despite the obvious political implications. It’s a paradox—recognizing Netanyahu’s motives but still refusing to take the necessary steps to halt the violence or break from unconditional support. It’s not just political negligence; it’s an ideological commitment to the status quo, even if it weakens his own party and jeopardizes Kamala Harris’s chances.
Harris and her team are running out of time. Arab American voters in Michigan, who once turned out in droves for Democrats, are on the verge of walking away from this campaign and party in what would be a historic realignment of an important voting bloc in Michigan. The question that hangs over this election isn’t whether Harris can win back these voters. It’s whether she even wants to.




Keep Reading







                Submit a correction
            



                Send a letter to the editor
            



                Reprints & permissions
            






Waleed Shahid







Waleed Shahid is the director of The Bloc and the former spokesperson for Justice Democrats. He has served as a senior adviser for the Uncommitted Campaign, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and Jamaal Bowman. He is a member of The Nation’s editorial board.















More from The Nation







5 Stages of GOP

                5 Stages of GOP
            

The Republican Party’s fealty to a totalitarian leader.

OppArt

                            /
                        
Peter Kuper 








How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?

                How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?
            


As long as Eric Adams refuses to resign, New Yorkers must contemplate other options, including—but not limited to—intervention by the state’s governor.


Elie Mystal 








How to Organize Our Way Out of the Trump-Musk Putsch

                How to Organize Our Way Out of the Trump-Musk Putsch
            


By firing Gwynne Wilcox, Trump is hoping the Supreme Court will overrule 90 years of legal precedent and give him the authority to fire members of independent boards.


Ezra Levin and Leah Greenberg 








How Donald Trump Dismantled a Worker Protection Agency With One Late-Night E-Mail

                How Donald Trump Dismantled a Worker Protection Agency With One Late-Night E-Mail
            


By firing Gwynne Wilcox, Trump is hoping the Supreme Court will overrule 90 years of legal precedent and give him the authority to fire members of independent boards.


Lynn Rhinehart 








Francesca Albanese Is Not a Diplomat

                Francesca Albanese Is Not a Diplomat
            


A conversation with the UN special rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories on the plain facts of Israel’s war crimes.


Nadine Talaat 








If Trump Crushes Federal Workers, We’re All Next

                If Trump Crushes Federal Workers, We’re All Next
            


Bosses everywhere are itching to wage a DOGE-style war against their workers. That’s why it’s so important that Trump and Musk fail. 


Eric Blanc 




















Sections


Politics


World


Economy


Culture


Books & the Arts


OppArt


Poetry


Letters




Magazine


Current Issue


Masthead


Archive


Subscription Services


Reprints




More


About Us


Contact Us


Advertise


Nation Events


Nation Shop


Nation Travels


Nation Podcasts


Newsletters




Follow


Facebook


Twitter


Instagram


YouTube


RSS





Founded by abolitionists in 1865, The Nation has long believed that independent journalism has the capacity to bring about a more democratic and equitable world.
Donate




Privacy Policy


Terms of Use


Accessibility Statement


Help


Careers


Nation Fund


Privacy Manager












 










x










Latest from the nation


Today 10:52 amArmed Conflicts
What's Next for Syrian Refugees?
Helen Benedict


Today 8:30 am
5 Stages of GOP
Peter Kuper


Today 8:24 am
How Do You Solve a Problem Like Eric Adams?
Elie Mystal


Today 5:30 am
How to Organize Our Way Out of the Trump-Musk Putsch
Ezra Levin and Leah Greenberg


Today 5:30 am
A New International Campaign Rises in Ukraine
Mary Kaldor and Luke Cooper




editor's picks





VIDEO: People in Denmark Are a Lot Happier Than People in the United States. Here’s Why.
The Nation





Historical Amnesia About Slavery Is a Tool of White Supremacy
Mychal Denzel Smith










































He will deport them all.