Concierge.com's insider take:
The secret is out: Hotel Gutkowski is the best bargain in ancient, seaside Siracusa. You'll need to book way ahead for one of the 26 rooms at this pale-blue villa, on the city's island of Ortygia. All are decorated with rustic simplicity: plain white walls, white linens and drapes, basic wood furniture, and tiled or hardwood floors. But all come with satellite TVs and fridges, and seven have Mediterranean views. Your room rate includes one of the best continental breakfasts in Siracusa, with fresh-squeezed juices, homemade jams and pastries, and organic fruit.