I go often to the Cosimo's location in Newburgh, and I was quite impressed after visiting the Middletown location. This restaurant has the same ambiance and high quality food. I have yet to order a dish I am disappointed in. The brick oven pizzas have inventive flavors and pair well with the wine list. Prices are above $10 for a personal pizza, but it is a good value -- this is no Pizza Hut, this is upscale! You get a lot of food for your money at Cosimo's, but you don't feel like you're dining at a chain family restaurant.