I watched Planet With and liked it and thought about finally reading this since I heard the adaptation was botched.

Is it actually good? I know /a/ has always seemed to like it. Was it like CSM sort of deal where shit was great while chapters were releasing and you just had to be there?

>>251902917 (OP)

I was where when /a/ hyped the manga. Didn't like it, seemed bland. Many years later an anime came out. It was absolute shit. /a/ shit its pants over how shit it was. The shitty end.

The manga is actually great. The anime is actual dogshit.

>>251902917 (OP)

Volume 1 and 2 are a bit slow, it only gets really good when the cast gets fleshed out

Don't expect any shocking twists or anything like that, is just good old character development

>>251902917 (OP)

the start is bad but tolerable

spirit circle is his magnum opus

>>251902917 (OP)

It has a very comfy feel. Reading it with /a/ last year was one of my favorite experiences on the site

>>251902917 (OP)

It's mostly just a well-done shounen.

Its strength, to me, comes from coming back to it every few years. The themes of what it means to be an adult and how each generation sees the other might effect each read a bit different as you get older.

Someone post THAT webm

Please don't post THAT webm.

>>251902917 (OP)

All of Mizukami's main works are great, he is literally my favourite mangaka. I enjoyed the anime because despite being botched it was still adapting a fantastic story.

Sengoku Youko>Spirit Circle>Samidare>World End Solte>Planet With

Sengoku Youko >Biscuit Hammer > Spirit Circle

The worst kind of Mizukami opinion.

what webm?

>>251902917 (OP)

Botched is an understatement. The adaptation is offensively bad. Even though it was a decade late and by NAZ, that wasn't enough to prepare anyone for what we got. The manga is great and had a significant following with /a/ back then and I'm sure the storytime after the godawful adaptation renewed the appreciation for the source.

>>251902917 (OP)

It's liked because the MC changes for the better, the characters are overall likeable, the action is good (I really like the rivalry the MC had going on), and plot had really concise pacing.

Nono, yes?

>>251902917 (OP)

It didn't resonate with me like it did for a bunch of other anons but the manga is alright. I much preferred Spirit Circle and Sengoku Youko.

>>251902917 (OP)

It's a masterpiece in just classic shonen.



Endgame Sengoku Youko > Samidare > Planet With => Spirit Circle > Early Sengoku Youko

>Samidare

>Shonen

I didn't care for the power system but at the same time I admire its simplicity.

No, it's all true.
