text: I would agree with that statement, since  you are limiting the observations to Catholics (and once Catholics) who comment at NCR.   Richard Rohr, OFM once said that his experiences in giving retreats to vowed religious, both women and men, made him realize that many, maybe even a majority, do not believe in God.  The surveys indicate that young adult Catholics also don't believe in God, at least not in the way they were taught to believe.  Perhaps because the RCC has neglected the gospels ?