text: May I add - agree with your comment, Mr. DeCuir.  BUT, yes, there is always a but......your reply to me was fine until the last part when you just had to add an ad hominem which Elagalabus picked up on.
  
  To be fair to Fr Imbelli - in his life work, he has been a significant participant in Pax Christi and in the Bernardin committee years ago.
  That being said, my criticism is limited to and directed at what MSW has posted and also the recent Imbelli writings since his retirement.  
  You may or may not agree but he is no longer being posted at dotCommonweal or Commonweal Magazine (you might want to ask why); and the majority of his latest postings are in more conservative catholic publications, First Things (no indictment - just tracking).
  Personally, would have loved to have been a student in one of Imbelli's classes years ago and understand that his liturgical style is something that others should imitate.  Also, admire that he chose to live in a rectory while teaching.