text: Clearly you and I read different articles over on his site. 
  He'd been slandered by the sad ersatz catholic writer here on this dismal journal of miserable immanent humanism and he robustly defended himself. Correctly, as it stands.
  The article and the comments are hatchet-jobs driven by ideology.
  Whatever it is you think you're defending - it aint the Catholic Faith. 
  And whatever future you think it might have - it won't. It's dead already. Like the Anglican Communion. You just don't realise it.