text: No. That was and still is not the form of the argument. The ritual are the same and the succession lines are intact. The issue for roman Catholics became "a defect on intention," i.e., Anglican bishops in the eyes of Roman theologians, did not intend to ordain priest for the "Church," i.e., the Roman Catholic Church. Which of course they didn't. So case closed, but there was no argument over ritual liturgy or lineage lines.