text: No, it is not implicit in their question. Were it, you'd quote it. Both are completely Catholic.
  
  I do not know if you even have a son. I took it on your word, and took your description of him respecting the Church's discipline as factual.
  
  If he did not respect the law, he would attend a Catholic parish and present himself for communion without regard to his state.
  
  If you tell me otherwise, I have to accept it on its face since you're the only source.
  
  Unless he was in fear for his life, it would not be like saying that Jews who left Germany in the 1930s "respected" the Nuremberg Laws.