text: You may, as is your wont, throw up a straw man (a non-zero impact is not saying "more harmful," for example).  For my part, I'm merely focusing on inconsistencies in a group's arguments as a scientist, not as a political hack nor a parental-love-starved millennial-seeking-meaning-for-her-life.  I'm also unsure why you see me as a "traditional catholic".  I've certainly never self-identified as such.  I'm simply "Catholic."  Is the "progressive catholic's" view much different, provided he does the hard work of thinking about the issue?