text: Why the heck is it when I say the very same thing here, I don't get stars of approval, but a torrent of invective?
  
  After consideration, it's apparently something very much to do with your keeping your criticism within the progressive Catholic sphere (Jesuit authors and  "our Catholic intellectual heritage").  
  In that way,  you can object to the MSWesque worldview by informing the progressive readers that NCR isn't the only or the best progressive Catholic oracle.   Very nice!