text: Mr. DeCuir - this observation, IMO, is correct:
  
  "...collapses any meaningful distinctions of persons & groups within both Evangelicalism & the Catholic right"
  
  Sorry, you mention Trump's evangelical critics - keep in mind that this opinion piece is about the Civilta article .......those same critics were for Trump before they were against Trump.  And, by the way, they are still part of the Evangelical-right wing Catholic union - since Civilta had little to say directly about Trump (you are shifting subjects).
  
  Think Garnett would be much more nuanced than Ross on religious liberty but you are correct - find Garnett to over-react and take positions on same sex marriage, birth control, and gays that fit more into a cultural war attitude.  And the USCCB - still fighting the last century's wars - nothing more needs to be said.