Larsy,
I would have no problem quizzing a Muslim nominee for a judgeship on their religious beliefs and how that might influence their court decisions, especially if they had written a law review article titled "Muslim Judges in Capital Cases," and made references to "Orthodox Islam."  

Of course, you and other conservatives would go ballistic at the notion of a Muslim judge, just like  in 2011, when Governor Chris Christie nominated Sohail Mohammed for a seat on a New Jersey Superior Court.

"Conservative writer Debbie Schlussel said Christie “rewarded those Muslim mobs who cheered on U.S. soil for the mass murder of 3,000 Americans with a judgeship.” Steve Emerson, who runs the Investigative Project on Terrorism, said Mohammed was “a longtime mouthpiece for radical Islamists.” 

Legislators asked him to define the word “jihad” and to state whether he ever objected to the term “Islamo terrorist."

it was a regular feature of Faux News outrage machine. I'm sure you were lapping it up.