Thank you for answering my question. 

I think your intentions are well meaning but I see that as a dangerous worldview, and one that is unfair. Yes, I do see that as a bit bigoted. You're associating a negative behavior with a VERY broad religion and group of people. 

I don't think I can convince you to be more skeptical and open to the idea that Muslims should not be treated with suspicion by default. 

I, like you, am an agnostic. So I'm not here to defend religion. But where I would challenge you, referring back to the Mike Pence comment, is to at least be logically consistent. 

If you can accept open devotion to God over country from the Vice President, then surely you can understand why some of the statistics and opinions about Sharia law (again NOT defending the likes of Iran and Saudi Arabia) as non threatening. Muslims have varying opinions about what Islam, Jihad, and Sharia law mean to them. Extremists tend to be a minority, just as with any other religion.