Sorry sky but it's the same thing. You're still asking Muslim columnists to prove their allegiance or be considered extremists. It's guilt by association and the opposite of "innocent until proven guilty". As I said above, are you going to demand that all Québécois be obliged to disassociate themselves from Bissonette simply because he's Québécois too?

And to use your own example, what did your "non-Muslim male neighbour" say when you specifically asked about his motivation for not killing you?