There was "no such thing as dogma" back in Jesus' day?  Are you kidding?  The words of Jesus were the dogma of the Church, just as they are today.  That dogma has been bastardized by the left for their own secular purposes.  What "arguments" are there on scripture?  The Church is there for the soul, not the body.  Modernism places the physical needs of man above his spiritual needs and is destroying the Church.  The modernism is the Church is a tenet of socialism and communism - which are inherently evil.  Prelates that buy into the leftist garbage of modernism risk their eternal soul for leading their flock astray.  People don't want "modernism," it is unnatural. Look around, religious orders that push the contemporary garbage are dying; while "traditional orders" are flourishing.