" JP claimed that islamists worship the same God as Christians" 

Which is true.

. JP denied that that the Old Covenant had been broken.

As did the Apostle Paul.

 JP, by way of approving the Balamand statement, rejected the notion that the Orthodox need to be converted.

Big deal.

 He claimed that non Catholic sects have saints.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a Lutheran, was a martyr, killed by the Nazis for his Christian stance.

Benedict claimed that Jews are not excluded from salvation {barring invincible ignorance, they certainly are, sans conversion}. He further stated that a "Jew, and this is true for believers of other religions, does not need to know or acknowledge Christ...in order to be saved".

That is what Vatican II taught -- do deny it places you in heresy.

Nope, what you demonstrate, McHale, is that you reject authentic Catholicism.