It all depends on what you deem the essential issues. I have read people in this very blog say that the refusal to ordain women is on a level with the divinity of Christ. I have come across similar statements with regard to contraception. There is a regular contributor here who has said that anyone who disagrees with the magisterium in any way should leave the Catholic Church.

What annoys me is the remarkably arrogant types who say essentially, "If you disagree with ME, you are not really a Catholic." Archbishop Chaput seems to be one of those.