Re: appealing, what would be the point if the judge in this case applied the law correctly? Appealing all the way to the Supreme Court would cost Saskatchewan many millions in a losing battle. On the other hand, accepting the ruling could cost tens or even hundreds of millions in new education costs. 

The Saskatchewan government's policy of funding non-Catholic students at Catholic schools is reasonable. Nevertheless it falls afoul of the Constitution according to Justice Layh. Premier Wall is saving everyone a lot of time and money by invoking the NWC, and doing so harms no one.