My dad was a Protestant and had to sign one of those forms to agree to raise us Catholic. He stayed home and made us lunch, while mom took us to church every Sunday. When my younger brother was confirmed, he all of a sudden decided to come into the church too. Mostly we missed the lunches! ha ha...but seriously, he only remained Catholic until my mom died, and then he returned to his Protestant faith when he re-married. Life is complicated. I think in the end, we all make our own choices.