Not wrong at all. 
The NCReporter is not part of the Catholic press. No one is saying there shouldn't be a free Catholic press, the objection is that its title can give the impression that it is an official Catholic publication.
I know of no other publication with Catholic in its title which openly crusades against the organisation it is named after.
What it's got to do with Watergate I don't know unless you mentioned it to give you the opportunity have a dig at your President.
When you come to think of it the Reporter seems to concentrate more on politics these days than Catholic issues.