cont'd

 . . . who reject Church teaching on, say, contraception, priesthood celibacy, etc., etc.  So your question, "Who are you to judge?," though rhetorically powerful at first glance, is quite easily deflated.  Like everyone else, though, I do judge the mental competence of people who take absurd positions, such as calling themselves Catholic when they reject Catholicism.  They commit no moral wrong, so far as I'm concerned.  But who are you to judge me if I say the world is flat?  I'd say your judging me to be absurd would be perfectly fine.