Thank you for the response.

If I hadn't made it clear, I know that Fr Cole asserted that there is a contradiction. I don't entirely disagree.

He doesn't seem to grasp the meaning of the canon he quotes, and that leads to the more important "contradiction" in his argument. The Canon says we must hold "each and everything" proposed by the Church. 

The canon is trying to exclude the question Fr Cole asks, what are we supposed to hold as true? The canon is clear, we are to hold "each and everything." The two cannot contradict one another and those who reject either "set themselves against the Catholic faith." Based on our faith in the guidance of the Holy Spirit, we may not choose one or the other. Based on logic, we must choose one or the other.

There are a number of ways to approach this. One is to look at how the two positions do not contradict one another. Dismissing the canon's relevance is another. But if you say choose one, you "set yourself against the Catholic faith."