Yes, the logic of the argument is identical. So, all you have to do is demonstrate that the Apostles ordained women as they ordained gentiles and notify the Holy See.

Over three decades the only reason you have put forth for the proposition that "both arguments are equally bogus" is that you happen to dislike the teaching.

While I can appreciate that, it's hardly the robust fare of a coherent intelligent Catholic discussion, and your gainsaying is really not all that interesting to me.