Haha - yes not too far from my experience growing up. I had former Lutherans on one side of my family, and then Pentecostal ministers on the other - and a mix in between in a lot of cases. 

Did you know there are like 36,000 denominations of Christianity (consider how many different brands of Baptist there are)? The thing that led me away from it was reading The Bible - I read it and re-read it and then I started to realize that most of the things my pastors would say were cherry-picked and contorted to mean things that it wasn't saying. I started doubting certain things like the concept of the trinity, hell, the fall, etc. Eventually I just scrapped the whole thing and became an agnostic. I don't claim to know anything but I sure doubt people who are certain they do.

I think there are some really interesting concepts in The Bible and the apocrypha. But I pretty much view it like any other mythology at this point.