If Catholic practice imitation Evangelicalism, the Evangelicals will always do a better job being Evangelical and people will go for "the real thing" if Evangelicalism is what they want.

Better to be the best Catholics we can be, without watering down or compromises. It's not attractive to others when we try too hard to be something we are not.  Let us offer our own gifts and quit putting our bushel under the basket, running away from our traditions and seeking the lowest common denominator in all things. It usually ends up backfiring on us.