In other words, since the Knights don't support NCR's PC socialist utopia ideal, they are "divisive."

Look at this this way, NCR.   The Knight's popularity with Catholics is the reason why they are so well funded.    On the other hand,  NCR,  popular support of progressive Catholicism is on a steady decline.   You guys being the flagship of the ProgCath movement, I can see how you're worried about the Knight's success.   Maybe it's time to come up with a more compelling message to the public; you might start with choosing a different chief spokesperson, i.e. one whose main interest in life isn't his pets.