Hi, Josh - I took a look at the site. I recognized a rather narrow interpretation of tradition that makes magisterial teaching the criterion of all truth. I found it about as intellectually defensible as the idea of a "spirit of Vatican II" that allegedly supports whatever cause one wishes to espouse.
I think we live in a time when the intellectual presentation of the Catholic faith is at risk, and essays that bait one side or the other are equally vacuous. - Monica.