Can't argue with you Bill.

To be consistent, let's all be guided by specific metrics-based categories from US News & World Report or some other widely accepted ratings system so that we have a common base of criteria for assessments on quality for any kind of college and university. 

I'll open with Notre Dame, Georgetown, and Boston College as baselines. Who is at least in their "academic league" for being BOTH great Catholic/Catholic great? And why?

And I'm open for ideas on how we should rate "great Catholicity," or is that too subjective?