It isn't that.  If this publication marketed itself as what it truly is--that is--a publication that isn't Catholic, I would still disagree with much of their writings--but I would respect them.  I also would not comment here.

You see, I don't care what Lutherans or Methodists or Presbyterians or Anglicans or Baptists, etc write, nor do I care about their theology.

If this publication was more like the American Catholic Church--that clearly states it has nothing to do with Roman Catholicism, fine.  I would have far more respect for it.

The reason I do not respect this publication is not because I disagree--but because they masquerade as "Catholic" when in  fact, there is little that is "Catholic" about it.

The difference between a dissident Catholic and a Protestant is that the Protestant has integrity.