I wonder how many "guitar music, hands clapping" Catholic liturgy fans....AND the Extraordinary Form fans/snobs....would be happy to actually GO TO HIS Passion and to CALVARY.  

Yes...that is, when the Holy Mass started!  That one...the one with the first Pilate (most of us are new Pilates every day in various ways).

I think both sides get wrapped up in their own "experiential preferences".

Would they go?  Or would they say...Can I just have my own liturgy, just like I like it.

Let's just go to Calvary in the Mass, whether there's an Arlo Guthrie pretender singing with guitar, or whether there is lovely, transcendent chant being present with the correct number of candles.  

Let's just go and accompany Jesus mystically on His way to Calvary, which is what the Catholic Mass invites us to do, every day.