As I said your arguments are puerile.
In plucking out one's eyes or cutting off one's limbs Our Lord was obviously comparing the loss of an eye or a hand with losing one's soul. When reading Scripture, especially the words of Our Lord one has to use common sense. 
The Apostles and disciples in the early Church knew how to interpret the sayings of Christ as there are no reports of a plethora of eyeless, handless Christians in the 1st century. If Fr Reese cannot make these intelligent distinctions, it is no wonder he lost his job.
Bearing in mind that the sole authority to interpret Scripture is vested in the Church, when one has difficulty understanding Scripture, one looks to the magisterial interpretation of the Church rather than the views of a dissident Jesuit priest.