We are the same person?  My name is Mike Eberl.  I live in NY.  If you would like my personal email I will provide it to you. Why would we post under different names?  It seems very clear that the three of us have no issues speaking our minds.  I think Dennis and Marty are much more learned in the Catholic Faith than me, so their posts would clearly show that fact if you actually spent the time to read them.     How about you provide your actual name and  confirm you are in fact a practicing Catholic Priest and where you are currently assigned?