Justice Scalia believed in a democracy where religious power could be used to define public morality, mostly at the state level. He had a puny view of the 14th Amendment, which protects us from the tyranny of a moral or Catholic majority. Scalia is gone and I doubt Gorsuch will replace him in that view. But even then, Roberts and Alito will not, so the whole strategy of voting Republican for President, no matter how flawed, is a fool's errand and Chuput does not like being called a fool.