The issue at hand is the kind of dystopian, totalitarian government described by Atwood, and whether it is likely to be imposed here by Christian fundamentalists and Trump (who is not a fundamentalist, anyway).  

The point is that where it HAS already happened and IS happening, right now, is by fundamentalists of another religion. That should tell you something.

Yes, fundamentalists of any religion are bad news, but have you been defending mainstream Christianity against those predicting that totalitarian dystopia here and now the way you are defending Islam? Of course not! If there is any misplaced paranoia, it is as much on the left about Trump as about Islam.