Really? Are you privy to every Catholic's charital giving or lack of it? I do know of some on the left who refuse to give charitably because they pay taxes and the government then uses that for charity. Really, that's what they've said. So, a Catholic who has donated to Catholic Charities or CRS, while maybe not the best of charities to donate to, is perfectly correct in thinking that they, a Catholic, helped to provide funds to the charity. I myself choose to do most of my charity on a more local and personal level, giving to those in need in my community.