Everything--as in all--I read in the Reporter is about Catholicism and news/issues attendant to the faith. There are opinion pieces, blogs, news stories, features, and even sports stories that are about Catholics and Catholicism.  Baptized laity, theologians, priests, sisters, public officials, and many others are regular contributors, making it certainly "Catholic."  

To imply (as you do above) that the Reporter is not a "Catholic media outfit" is to outright deny the facts----a very anti-intellectual, scary, and harmful way to consume journalism as you search for truth and for Truth. 

My concurrence or dissent does not make or break a medium's--Right or Left--status as "Catholic." Neither does yours or the KofC's. 

You have a right to say the KofC seems to support only media outfits with which it always agrees. But you cannot say their support reflects or creates authenticity of a medium as a "Catholic media outfit." 

Now if you are judging a house organ, the criteria differ.