I would. And I'd bet John would too. And Francis would too. 

Nobody as far as I know is: 

calling them sinners for performing an alleged unnatural, self-indulgent, and intrinsically disordered act.. 
telling them they're going to hell... 
denying them the Eucharist... 
making them appear before a tribunal... 
ordering them to repent... 
questioning their morality... 
demanding they do penance... 
banning funerals... 
branding them un-Catholic... 
shaming them for causing "confusion that's of the devil"...or 
claiming they are instigating public scandal.

Their conscience, rigorously informed and prayerfully shaped,  has primacy and is celebrated, as it should. Always. Me or John or Francis disagreeing with them doesn't change that. 

THAT'S THE POINT!!!  No dubia here. But somehow I can't see Cardinal Burke returning the theology when he thinks HE is right and we are wrong.