Not quite correct, I'm afraid.  The research from the 1930's to the late 50's that you cite were the old studies of psychoanalysts that were entirely pathology-centered, and did not use the scientific method in their studies.  All the so-called research was skewed according to the "ideology" of the author.  And BTW - you are pulling the discussion off of where it was placed, it seems to me - and that is within the context of our current sociocultural situation.  We are, of course, the National Catholic Reporter (meaning the US) so there is a built-in predisposition to thinking and talking in view of that.  While I am well aware of the differing views of other countries and cultures, forgive my cultural bias.  The view you express would make for a wonderful other discussion.  I hope it happens!