This is a sentiment I hear frequently from folks (mostly seminarians and priests) who have a fondness for the Extraordinary Form.  Then again, I see those same folks adding features of the Extraordinary Form to the Ordinary Form Mass, even though, at least in my reading, the indult Quattuor Abhinc Annos (cf. condition "d."), would seem to prohibit it.

So it would seem "say the black, do the red," only counts if we like the red.