I have lived in Quebec for over 25 years and can tell everyone that logical arguments and good common sense have no place in this province for any argument related to values and culture. The whole cultural / rights debate is simply off limits if you are not a white, Catholic, pur laine quebecois whose Quebec family heritage dates back to at least before the mid 1800's. Those of us who are English speakers have learned to just shut up, ignore it and not try to provoke. Debate is impossible to win. They tell us we are lucky to be allowed to have health services in English. Occasionally even that is called into question. As much as you try to talk sensibly about individual rights in Quebec, you will not get anywhere.