No - ALL "voters" in those cities would be impacted, not just "liberals". Those fat-cat Wall Street-ers in New York, many of whom are undeniably conservative Republicans, would be stuck. The problem with the Left is that they think in terms of everything being black-and-white, this-or-that. If you live in a "red" state that Trump barely won by a few thousand votes, by golly then EVERYBODY in that state must be a backwards-thinking Trump-loving hillbilly. That's how the Left thinks.